my 3 month old daughter love both she sophie and she Pie toy . both be a soft rubber that smell good - somewhat vanilla - and both be squeaky , which delight she . the Pie toy be a early favorite and Sophie have more recently become a favorite as she learn how to stick the foot in she mouth . the one concern in we house be that the dog think these be he toy because they be squeeky , so we do have to be vigilant about keep they off the floor . we recently receive a second Sophie as a gift and now keep one at home and one in the diaper bag so she be never without it .