I be go on my third kid with these bib and I still think they be great . the original one that I buy with my first son be a bit worn , but they still work perfectly . they be as waterproof as the name promise . Food and drink never seep through to they clothes . the pocket at the bottom catch most of they crumb and milk that they inevitably spill . after each meal , I wipe or rinse the bib off , lay they on they highchair and they be dry by the next snack or meal . I usually use one bib for several day before I put it in the wash machine . when my baby become toddler I switch they to the Bumkins Junior Bib . that one go around they arm so they can not take it off themselves -lrb- at least not easily -rrb- . I never have a serious problem with my baby yank off the bib . I give it four star instead of five because the neck be a bit big . not sure why they do not fix that . so many reviewer complain about that design flaw . sometimes food sneak under the bib because it sit too low below they chin . I also think the fastener could be stronger . as I say , I never have a problem with my kid yank apart the velcro , but a snap closure -lrb- or some other stronger closure -rrb- would be a big improvement . overall , I love these bib and the few problem I have have with they be overshadow by how easy they be to use and reuse between machine washing .