I have see and use many tub toy holder over the year as a nanny , prior to become a mother . I know come into this mommy-gig that I would be hard press to find a holder I would like . most use suction of some kind and the suction , I have find , hardly ever stay put . I suppose folk like have the toy up and off to the side somewhere to save space , but if the tub you be use this in be primarily the kid ' , then that be not much of a concern . even if someone want to take shower , just move the basket to the other end . I like that thing have more space to air out and it act a little bit as a block device to keep baby hand from the shampoo and bubble bath . it be as sturdy as any of its counterpart , but I would not suggest a baby hold him\/herself up with it . overall , would buy again and recommend .