I be a mother with 3 young child . my youngest be 8 month old and grab the spoon while I feed he mushy baby food . even though he always wear a bib , he clothes usually still get dirty . I wonder if any bib would actually keep he clothes clean . I have compare the Bumkins Superbib , the Babybjorn bib , the Bibbity bib , and the Bumkins Sleeved bib . with my first child , I quickly realize that use cloth bib and put they in the laundry after each meal be a terrible idea . they would get moldy and I have to own a dozen bib . then I switch to Bumkins Superbibs . they be very easy to use . I just wash they in the sink after meal and hang they on my bib dry rack . the bib be dry and ready to use again by the next meal . Bumkins Superbibs be lightweight and my baby never mind wear they . since the pocket be soft , they do not work well if the bib have be keep flat in a drawer . I always keep my superbib hang upside down by the pocket on the bib dry rack . so , the pocket dry in the open position and work better . my 3 year old daughter love to wear she Bumkins Superbibs and they be great for she but they do not adequately protect my baby who fling oatmeal . both the BabyBjorn and the Bibbity bib be SMALLER than the Bumkins Superbibs . the Babybjorn bib be make of hard plastic -lrb- like a cup -rrb- . it say `` soft '' in the description but that be just nonsense . the bibbity bib be softer , like rubber . the Babybjorn bib be difficult to put on the baby because it be so hard . even the neck strap be make of stiff plastic . I have great difficulty adjust the neck hole because it keep hurt my son 's neck . I never could get the hole small enough to keep food from escape onto the clothes below he chin . plan on baby cry the entire time you be fiddle with this bib . the pocket of the bjorn bib be great and always stay open . however , because the pocket be so rigid , it clash with the tray . my son sit on a chair that clip onto the countertop . the bjorn bib pocket keep get catch under the countertop and then it would yank my son 's neck . he really hate wear this bib . the BabyBjorn bib be super easy to wash in the sink . it be easy to dry with a towel so you do not need a bib dry rack with this bib . the bibbity bib be much better than the BabyBjorn bib . it be softer and feel like rubber . it be awkward to put on at first and my son be mad . however , he get use to it . I be able to get the neck hole small enough to keep most of the oatmeal out without hurt my son 's neck . the pocket stay open pretty well . the pocket do work better than the Bumkins Superbib pocket . the bibbity bib be about 1 inch shorter than the Bjorn bib and be 2.5 inch shorter than the Bumkins Superbib . so , some food still end up on the child 's lap . the bibbity bib be very easy to wash in the sink and dry with a towel . I think the bibbity bib work a little better than the Bumkins Superbib overall because the pocket catch more . however , my 3 year old daughter refuse to wear the bibbity bib , and say it hurt she neck . she love to wear she Bumkins Superbibs . UPDATE : now my son be 13 month old and refuse to wear the bibbity bib at all . it be too heavy and uncomfortable . unfortunately , all 3 of these bib leave way too much food spill on my 8 month old 's clothes . if you have a baby who eat mushy baby food and grab the spoon , a regular bib just do not give adequate protection . so , I buy the Bumkins sleeve bib . it be great ! it cover everything , even he lap ! he could feed himself oatmeal and he clothes be very clean afterward ! the sleeved bib be very easy to clean too . I just wash it off in the kitchen sink and hang it on my bib dry rack -lrb- which sit next to my kitchen sink -rrb- . the sleeved bib go from drip wet to completely dry in 2 hour . since , the bib dry fast , I use the same sleeved bib at each meal . this way I only have to buy one . in conclusion , I recommend the Bumkins sleeve bib for any baby who eat pureed food . when they start on finger food and become a little neater , the Bumkins Superbibs and the Bibbity bib be good . the bibbity work a little better than the Bumkins Superbib but you child might think they be uncomfortable . I do not recommend the Babybjorn bib . sorry , Babybjorn . I love to wear my baby in you carrier : -rrb- UPDATE : my son be now 13 month old . he refuse to wear the bibbity bib at all . he also pull off he Bumkins Superbibs , throw they on the floor , and laugh . I put he in the Bumkins sleeve bib for every meal . he do not mind wear it and he can not get it off . it also do the best job of keep he clean . I wash it in the sink after meal and hang it on the bib dry rack . it dry in about 2 hour . I use the same bib all the time . I put it in the laundry every few day . here be a link to the dry rack I be talk about  Mommy genius dry rack -- Dry or Display just about anything -lrb- Baby Bibs , Plastic or Reusable Food Storage Bags , kitchen Dish Towels , Bathroom Hand Towels , Washcloths , Mugs , Sports Water Bottles , Herbs , Mittens , Children 's Boots , Lingerie , Holiday Orname ...