He always wears black, we never see him in the daylight, only after dark. (Lily and Marshall get up and run over to Ted's bedroom door, Ted limps behind them, Lily opens door and she and Marshall peek in room to see girl lying on bed, Lily closes the door)
Lily: There's a girl in there. Marshall: And a pineapple. Lily: Wait, were you here when I went to the bathroom in the middle of the night? And who's the girl in my bed? Trudy: Or the one after that. Come hang out! You turn off your brain for a night, and all you're left with is a bad hangover, a sprained ankle.
Plan: A: Ted; Q: Who passes out after a wild night in town? A: the next morning; Q: When does Ted wake up after a wild night? A: a sprained ankle; Q: What is the first thing Ted wakes up with after a wild night? A: a pineapple; Q: What is in Ted's room when he wakes up? A: the evening; Q: What time period does Ted not remember? A: Trudy; Q: Who is the girl in Ted's bed? A: the night's misadventures; Q: What does Trudy tell Ted about? Summary: After Ted passes out after an especially wild night in town, he wakes up the next morning with a sprained ankle, a burnt jacket, a girl in his bed, and a pineapple in his room. Unable to recall everything that transpired over the course of the evening, he asks his friends and the girl in his bed, Trudy, to fill him in on the night's misadventures.