Barney: What's wrong with her? Barney: Wow, Lily, that sucked! Got to moisturize! He said it was really romantic. It all comes down to you. It's genius how bad it is. Lily: You know if you did a play, I would sit through the whole thing and I would compliment you on it afterwards. Might be time to send them to the farm. Obviously, he's got to get rid of it. Play's not over. Robin has one of her dog in her knees but Ted sees a man instead. Robin walks into the apartment and Ted brought back all his ex-girlfriends stuff. Robin: All that stuff was from old girlfriends? Well, sit.
Plan: A: Robin; Q: Who gives Ted grief for keeping gifts from ex-girlfriends? A: Ted grief; Q: What does Robin give Ted for keeping all of his gifts from ex-girlfriends? A: Ted; Q: Who decides it's time to give away all of his gifts from ex-girlfriends? A: the tides; Q: What changes when Ted finds out that Robin has been holding on to items as well? A: the whole group; Q: Who does Lily tell to come to her play? A: Barney; Q: Who tells Lily that her play sucked? Summary: After Robin gives Ted grief over keeping all of his gifts from ex-girlfriends, Ted decides it's time to give them all away. However, the tides change when he finds that Robin has been holding on to items as well. Lily tells the whole group to come to her play. After Barney tells her it sucked, she tells him she would compliment a play he performed in regardless of how bad it was - Barney decides to prove her wrong.