Andy: Dwight. Christmas!!!! Darryl: Oh yeah, and um there's a Christmas party upstairs tonight, wanted to tell you about. Erin: Too late! He's trying to entrap me. Hi, I'm Andy Bernard and I am the first office Santa ever to make holiday wishes come true. Jim: Yeah. Jiminy Christmas! Robert: The fifth one is for you, Erin. Stay home. They totally do. What's everyone staring at?
Plan: A: Andy; Q: Who tries to make everyone's Christmas wishes come true? A: the Christmas party; Q: What event does Erin drink too much at? A: California; Q: Who escorts Erin home? A: Dwight; Q: Who is ordered to stop pranking Jim? A: their Christmas bonuses; Q: What do Dwight and Jim risk losing if they continue to prank each other? Summary: Andy attempts to make everyone's Christmas wishes come true. Erin, upset about her unrequited feelings for Andy, drinks too much at the Christmas party and is escorted home by California. Meanwhile, Dwight and Jim are ordered to stop pranking one another, lest they forfeit their Christmas bonuses. Thus, they try to frame each other.