Angel: It-it's a legend... (Giles looks at the box) way before my time... of a demon brought forth to rid the Earth of the plague of humanity... separate the righteous from the wicked... and to burn the righteous down. Behind her Drusilla stalks her. Buffy and Angel are brought before Spike, Drusilla and the Judge. Buffy turns and reaches for the door handle. Buffy ventures in. Buffy: Good call. Buffy: Rough night. Giles: Buffy's surprise party will go ahead as we planned. I like seeing you first thing in the morning. They all go back to their tasks. Without an army?
Plan: A: Buffy; Q: Who turns 17? A: the Scoobies; Q: Who plans a surprise party for Buffy? A: her own celebration; Q: What does Drusilla plan for Buffy's birthday? A: her presents; Q: What does Spike collect for Drusilla? A: The Judge; Q: What ancient demon is Drusilla given? A: humanity; Q: What is The Judge supposed to cleanse the world of? A: every turn; Q: How many times are Buffy and Angel stymied? A: Angel; Q: Who wakes up in the middle of the night calling Buffy's name in anguish? A: their deepest feelings; Q: What do Buffy and Angel confess to each other? A: love; Q: What do Buffy and Angel make for the first time? Summary: Buffy turns 17 and the Scoobies plan a surprise party. Meanwhile Drusilla plans her own celebration as Spike collects her presents: the disassembled pieces of The Judge, an ancient demon called to cleanse the world of humanity. Stymied at every turn, Buffy and Angel go back to his place to regroup, where they confess their deepest feelings and make love for the first time. Afterwards, Angel wakes in the middle of the night calling Buffy's name in anguish...