Flashback Marshall, Lily, Ted and Karen eat in the room of Ted and Marshall. Lily: And you give him? Lily: They hated it! Look who's here! Marshall: Get off me! Marshall: What has happened to Karen? Robin: They are. Ted: It was not that bad. Ted: So, Karen in New York.
Plan: A: wind; Q: What do Lily and Marshall get when they learn that Ted's college girlfriend has moved to New York? A: Laura Prepon; Q: Who played Karen? Summary: When Lily and Marshall get wind of the fact that Ted's college girlfriend Karen ( Laura Prepon ), who they always hated, has moved to New York, they try to persuade him not to contact her.