(Chris points to Mr. (Paige and Vincent walk into another room.) (Paige orbs in with Piper.) (to Mr. Chris: Jail. Chris: So is one who can orb and wants to save innocents. Demonatrix #3: But I thought you said that...
Vincent: That's for after, when she's by my side, when I can give her what she wants. Demonatrix. Go to the spa, have a pedicure, get a massage. He's appealing to that, to what she secretly wants. It hurts her, Phoebe. It's why Phoebe lost her powers. Just him. Leo: And then once you're in, we'll bring you the potion that makes the demon real. Mr. Mr. One of the demonatrix follows him and strokes his body.) Paige, Mr. Paige: Phoebe, I thought about it and I just wanted to say that you're right and...
Phoebe: Stop. Paige: Why Vincent? Phoebe is there making a potion. Phoebe plucks the throwing stars out of the air and throws them at the two on the right, vanquishing them.) Phoebe: I'm making a vanquishing potion for your evil twin. Phoebe: Leo and I are gonna go to magic school and check on Piper. Piper: As long as one of her sisters doesn't try to kill her again, she'll be fine. Right: Then why not make him real? Right: To be free, independent, to be able to use her magic without fear of consequence. So Darryl's gonna cover? They are after all, still her sisters. Turn around. Vincent and the car orb out. Vincent is there. Vincent speeds out of the car yard. Vincent: Not a demon, a porsche. You just have to figure out a way to honour them without using magic. [Cut to Paige's room.
Plan: A: Piper; Q: Who is the sister who is away at Magic School? A: Phoebe; Q: Who goes undercover as a Demonatrix assassin to prevent Paige from executing her plan? A: her powers; Q: What does Phoebe lose when she is tricked into a plot to kill her sisters? A: Paige; Q: Who kidnaps Piper? A: Mr. Right; Q: What does Phoebe conjure to test a potion that will make Vincent real? A: stress relief; Q: Why does Paige conjure Mr. Right? A: a demon; Q: What is Vincent? A: a plot; Q: What does Vincent hatch to separate the sisters? A: witches; Q: What does Vincent want to kill? A: Paige's dark side; Q: What does Vincent appeal to? A: Wrong / Vincent; Q: Who is the evil twin of Mr. Right? A: his pheromones; Q: What does Vincent use to trick Paige? A: consequence; Q: What does Vincent want Paige to use her magic without fear of? A: Chris; Q: Who gets arrested for stealing a car to chase Vincent? A: Darryl; Q: Who will not cover for Chris when he gets arrested? A: Mr. Wrong's Demonatrix assassins; Q: What does Phoebe go undercover as to prevent Paige from executing her plan? A: the situation; Q: What does Paige and Phoebe try to keep Piper out of? A: Vincent's control; Q: What is Paige under? A: a confused Piper; Q: Who is about to be killed by the Demonatrixes? A: Leo; Q: Who erases the memory of the car dealership manager to save Chris from going to jail? Summary: With Piper away at Magic School and Phoebe without her powers, an overworked Paige re-conjures "Mr. Right" for stress relief, but unknowingly releases his evil twin, a demon called Vincent who immediately hatches a plot to separate the sisters while sending assassins after witches. Appealing to Paige's dark side, Mr. Wrong / Vincent uses his pheromones to trick her into realizing that the only way to achieve her secret desire is to be free and use her magic without fear of consequence, eventually killing her sisters. Chris accidentally gets arrested for stealing a car to chase Vincent and Darryl will not cover. To prevent Paige from executing his plan, Phoebe goes undercover as one of Mr. Wrong's Demonatrix assassins. Paige and Phoebe try to keep Piper out of the situation, but that backfires when Paige, under Vincent's control, kidnaps her so that the Demonatrix assassins can kill her. Phoebe regains confidence in herself when she makes Mr. Right real to test a potion that will make Vincent real so he can be vanquished and infiltrates the Demonatrixes. As the Demonatrixes are about to kill a confused Piper, Phoebe saves her and together they vanquish them. They go after Vincent who is confident they cannot harm him as they do not have the potion to make him real, but Phoebe takes the chance that making Mr. Right real will turn him real too. She proves to be right and Vincent is easily vanquished which breaks his hold over Paige. Later, Leo erases the memory of the car dealership manager to save Chris from having to go to jail.