Amenadiel: Lucifer, I'm not angry with you that you somehow got your wings back, or even that you cut them off again, as foul as that may be. Amenadiel: The Sinnerman? And that is your connection to the case. Chloe: But there's got to be something. Chloe: Lucifer, whatever it is that you want to show me or that you want to tell me, it's okay. Did her massage make anything pop out? Ella: Found Lucifer's phone... God never gets His own hands dirty, does He? He wants to get in but he is stopped by his wings. He was trying to steal it. Huge crime boss. I'd like a ride to Los Angeles, please. I... Get whacked over the head and hauled out to the desert. Josh Hamid: They were supposed to nab Steve for 48 hours, tie him up in a warehouse, stick him in the desert, and then drop him back at the hotel. Killers often return to the scene of the crime. Lucifer is waiting for the kidnapers in a warehouse. Lucifer shows Linda his wings. Lucifer shows his brother his wings. Lucifer: New who? Marcus Pierce comes for the first time at the station. Sam is packing his clothes. Second victim? So you just got to believe that when He crushes your nuts, He does it for a reason. There has to be a way to find them. They find a dead body. They get paid to abduct people. To pull pranks.
Plan: A: Lucifer; Q: Whose wings grew back after he cut them off again? A: a fleeing criminal; Q: Who does Lucifer encounter? A: his clothes; Q: What does Lucifer steal from a criminal? A: the police; Q: Who does Lucifer get to return the criminal to Los Angeles? A: Linda; Q: Who refuses to remove Lucifer's wings? A: a dehydrated corpse; Q: What is the new case that Chloe brings Lucifer to? A: the desert; Q: Where was the corpse found that Lucifer woke up in? A: Marcus Pierce; Q: Who is Chloe's new lieutenant? A: Pierce; Q: Who instructs Dan to get himself kidnapped? A: a wealthy man; Q: Who was the body of the man Lucifer found in the desert? A: "kidnappers; Q: Who did the wealthy man's friend pay to prank him? A: his own wings; Q: What does Lucifer try to restore, but Amenadiel discovers he has already cut off? A: Lucifer's self-severed pair; Q: What does Amenadiel discover while trying to restore Lucifer's wings? A: the last moment; Q: When does Lucifer make himself the target of the kidnappers? A: his own abduction; Q: What does Lucifer suspect the kidnappers are behind? A: the dead man; Q: Who was turned over to another kidnapper? A: another kidnapper; Q: Who did the dead man's friend turn him over to? A: The man; Q: Who reveals that he was hired by the Sinnerman to abduct Lucifer? A: the Sinnerman; Q: Who hired the kidnapper to abduct Lucifer? A: a mysterious crime boss; Q: Who is the Sinnerman? A: punishment; Q: Why does Lucifer believe God restored his wings? A: a void; Q: Where did God send Charlotte to? Summary: Lucifer encounters a fleeing criminal and steals his clothes before getting the police to return him to Los Angeles. He asks Linda to remove his restored wings, but she refuses. Chloe brings him onto a new case, a dehydrated corpse found in the desert where Lucifer woke up, while overseen by her new lieutenant, Marcus Pierce. The body turns out to be that of a wealthy man and his close friend reveals that he paid "kidnappers" to prank the victim. While attempting to restore his own wings, Amenadiel discovers Lucifer's self-severed pair. Lucifer tries to show Chloe his true "devilface," but is unable. To lure out the "kidnappers," Pierce instructs Dan to get himself kidnapped, which Lucifer arranges. However, he makes himself the target at the last moment, suspecting the kidnappers to be behind his own abduction. He interrogates them and learns that the dead man was turned over to another kidnapper. The man reveals that he was hired by the Sinnerman, a mysterious crime boss, to abduct Lucifer. Lucifer, whose wings grew back after he cut them off again, initially suspects that God restored his wings as punishment for sending Charlotte to a void, but eventually comes to believe that it is "something darker" connected to Sinnerman.