Dwight: So you wanna sell me magic beans. Holly: Um, ok. Did you connect with Michael? I am not going to be proposed to in the break room. Jim: Congratulations! Jim: I was in Jamaica, and I got lost, and it was getting dark this one night and then out of nowhere with a cart and he's selling these. Michael: Heres the ring. Oscar: No. Pam: No she's going to love it so I think you can keep the proposal simple. Ryan: Will you marry me Holly? [SCENE_BREAK]
Pam: Dunder Mifflin is having our first own garage sale.
Plan: A: his expensive diamond ring; Q: What does Michael propose to Holly with? A: outrageous ideas; Q: What does Michael think about when he decides to propose to Holly? A: advice; Q: What does Pam make Michael consult Oscar, Ryan, Jim, and herself for? A: Dunder Mifflin Scranton's warehouse and crew hosts; Q: Who hosts a public garage sale? A: Dwight; Q: Who does Jim dupe into buying "magic beans"? Summary: Michael decides to propose to Holly with his expensive diamond ring, thinking about outrageous ideas to carry out the proposal. When Pam notices, she makes him consult Oscar, Ryan, Jim, and herself for advice, and their opinions on his ideas. Meanwhile, Dunder Mifflin Scranton's warehouse and crew hosts a public garage sale. Jim dupes Dwight by selling him "magic beans". The episode ends with Michael and Holly getting engaged.