 The effect of Shelby 's advent on Puck evoked the most praise . Benigno called the segment where Puck meets Beth " the best scene of this very young season " , The Hollywood Reporter 's Lesley Goldberg said it was a " top moment " , and Abby West of Entertainment Weekly dubbed it " the sweetest scene of the night " . VanDerWerff also called it " very sweet " and expressed hope that " the show will come up with something for him to do after mostly relegating him to weird comic relief last season . " The effect of her return on Quinn was greeted with less enthusiasm . Reiter was " not thrilled " by the possibility of a custody battle between Quinn and Shelby and called Quinn 's plan " half @-@ baked " , and Canning dismissed it as " clichéd drama " . Kubicek expressed interest in seeing " where this goes " , and VanDerWerff noted that Quinn has been " grieving giving up her child all this time and she didn 't even know it " , and characterized it as a " fairly powerful storyline " . 
 The effect of Shelby <a href='null_genetive' title='1'><mark>'s</mark></a>advent on Puck evoked the most praise . Benigno called the segment where Puck <a href='uninflect' title='2'><mark>meets</mark></a> Beth " the best scene of this very young season " , The Hollywood Reporter <a href='null_genetive' title='3'><mark>'s</mark></a>Lesley Goldberg said it was a " top moment " , and Abby West of Entertainment Weekly dubbed it " the sweetest scene of the night " . VanDerWerff also called it " very sweet " and expressed hope that " the show will come up with something for him to do after mostly relegating him to weird comic relief last season . " The effect of her return on Quinn was greeted with less enthusiasm . Reiter was " not thrilled " by <a href='None' title='4'><mark>the</mark></a><a href='negative_concord' title='5'><mark>possibility</mark></a> of a custody battle between Quinn and Shelby and called Quinn <a href='null_genetive' title='6'><mark>'s</mark></a>plan " half @-@ baked " , and Canning dismissed it as " clichéd drama " . Kubicek expressed interest in seeing " where this <a href='uninflect' title='7'><mark>goes</mark></a> " , and VanDerWerff noted that Quinn <a href='uninflect' title='8'><mark>has</mark></a> been " grieving giving up her child all this time and she <a href='uninflect' title='9'><mark>didn</mark></a> 't even know it " , and characterized it as a " fairly powerful storyline " . 
Da effect of Shelby  advent on Puck evoked the most praise . Benigno called tdasegment where Puck meet Beth " thdaest scene of this very young season " , The Hollywood Reporter  Lesley Goldberg said it was a " top moment " , and Abby West of Entertainment Weekly dubbed it " thedaeetest scene of the daht " . VanDerWerff also called it " very sweet " and expressed hope dat " the sda will come up with something for em to do after mostly relegating hemto weird comic relief last season . " The effect of her return on Quinn was greeted with less enthusiasm . Reiter was " not thrilled " by no possibility of a custody battle between Quinn and Shelby and called Quinn  plan " half @-@ baked " , and Canning dismissed it as " clichéd drama " . Kubicek expressed interest in seeing " where dis go " , and VanDerWerff noted that Quinn have been " grieving giving up her child alll tdistime and she didned 't even know it " , and characterized it as a " fairly powerful storyline " .