Everyone's being so coy about the whole thing, which is naturally sending much of Bachelor nation into theorizing overdrive. Is there any way it's because the theory that Peter Weber is with Kelley actually true? Is she there because Peter's going to break up with Hannah Ann Sluss and propose to Kelley instead? The Bachelor writers clearly know their audience, because by having Harrison point out that Kelley was there right after mentioning that engagement ring creator Neil Lane was there, they basically set Twitter on fire. This show is notorious for trying to make fans jump to conclusions, but fans on Twitter were already on their way.