While celebrities and bloggers make red eye makeup look easy, there's always the fear that it can turn out more Halloween that hot. But we're here to say that doesn't have to be the case. As with any bold look, it's important to swatch products in-store until you find one that works with your unique complexion. What's more, it's important to always start with an eye primer for true color payoff, then ease in with a light wash of color or smudge into your lashline to start. And when all else fails, wash it off and try again.