With stand-out names like Peta and Maksim , it was unlikely that Dancing with the Stars' little lovebirds were going to have a baby and name it, like, Joe. Sure enough, engaged dance pros Peta Murgatroyd and Maksim Chmerkovskiy gave their son a moniker as unique as their own. Shai Aleksander was born January 4, and now his mama is giving fans the inside scoop on what inspired his name. "First of all, naming a baby — who will one day be an adult out in the world — is hard," Murgatroyd wrote on her All Things Fam & Glam blog . "It took months and months to find a name that Maks and I both loved and kind of embodied what he means to us. We knew that we wanted a shorter name that wasn't super-complicated because 'Chmerkovskiy' is kind of a mouthful and he'll always have to spell it out for people. We finally settled on Shai, pronounced 'shy' and means 'gift' in Hebrew. Honestly, it's a perfect fit because from the very beginning we felt like this little life we made was the most precious gift God could grant us."