Look, you can make your own decisions about which of these rumors seems most likely, but I’m calling this one. The original story came from Reality Steve as of March 5: Madison leaves the show before the final rose ceremony and goes back to the U.S. Peter is in love with both Madison and Hannah Ann and doesn’t want to make a decision before he can talk to Madison again. So, with Hannah Ann not technically eliminated, everyone goes back to the States, and Peter ends up reconciling with Madison. He breaks things off with Hannah Ann, and is currently dating, but not engaged to Madison, leaving the possibility that he’ll propose on After the Final Rose.