But while the Oklahoma native has held on to her small-town charm, the same can't be said of her beauty look, which has changed countless times. She's more confident in her hair and makeup choices now — is always down to throw in come color. "I'm southern, so I love fun eyeliners and makeup that has a little bit of shimmer to it," she says. (Her favorite? The navy blue Pen Eyeliner from Almay, which just hit stores this month.)