"Allison and I knew that if we played the movie right that would be a huge moment and it would be the moment where we meet the real Rose for the first time," Peele told EW. "And I think that’s what’s so chilling about her performance is that the real Rose in the matter of a line communicates that she has no remorse, has no love for this person, and even with the way she sort of waves at him and says, ‘babe,’ that there is a disdain for this character she’s been sleeping with and pretending to be in love with."