id
stringlengths 3
7
| context
stringlengths 8
967
| statement
stringlengths 10
276
| entailment
listlengths 0
4
| neutral
listlengths 0
4
| contradiction
listlengths 0
4
| idk
sequencelengths 0
3
| label_count_round_1
dict | label_count_round_2
dict | label_set_round_1
sequencelengths 1
3
| label_set_round_2
sequencelengths 0
3
| error_labels
sequencelengths 0
2
| has_ambiguity
bool 2
classes | chaosnli_labels
dict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
23751e | Part of the reason for the difference in pieces per possible delivery may be due to the fact that five percent of possible residential deliveries are businesses, and it is thought, but not known, that a lesser percentage of possible deliveries on rural routes are businesses. | It is thought, but not known, that a lesser percentage of possible deliveries on rural routes are businesses, and part of the reason for the difference in pieces per possible delivery, may be due to the fact that five percent of possible residential deliveries are businesses. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "664-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Statement just changed the order of two hypothesis in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "664-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The reason for the diffenrence in pieces per possible delivery mentioned in the context is that the difference percentage of businesses deliveries on residential and rural routes. But the reason in the statement only include the percentage of residential deliveries, not the diffenrence of deliveries.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
1,
3
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 85,
"n": 13,
"c": 2
} |
61429c | In this enclosed but airy building, you'll find ladies with large machetes expertly chopping off hunks of kingfish, tuna, or shark for eager buyers. | You'll find small lepers chopping of chunks of tuna, its the only place they can work. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1265-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention whether the ladies are small lepers and whether its the only place they can work.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1265-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not say anything about lepers or where they could work.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1265-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Small lepers\" don't have to be \"ladies\"; we don't know whether \"small lepers\" can find other jobs.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1265-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Lepers and the only place to work at are not mentioned",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 2,
"n": 41,
"c": 57
} |
54811c | The park on the hill of Monte makes a good playground, while the ride down in a wicker toboggan is straight out of an Old World theme park (though surely tame for older kids). | the park on the Hill of Monte is only for children. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1552-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention whether the park is only for children.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1552-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Only because the park makes a good playground it doesn't necessarily have to be only for kids.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1552-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No proof that the park can not be for adults.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1552-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not mentioned that it's only for children",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1552-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The phrase \"makes a good playground\" suggests that the park is not a designated playground and thus is open for all age groups. Also, even if the park would be a designated playground, these can typically be also used by adults (at least the parents).",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 17,
"n": 61,
"c": 22
} |
12601n | I touched my palm to his mutilated cheek, and tried to stem my instinctive revulsion. | You could see where the bear had scratched across his cheek. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "285-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context contains no information about him being scratched on the cheek by a bear.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "285-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not say anything about how his cheek was mutilated, i.e. that it was a bear is not entailed.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "285-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know who/what makes his cheek mutilated.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "285-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know if it's a bear that scratched him",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 14,
"n": 80,
"c": 6
} |
38477c | She wears either revealing clothes or professional clothes (or perhaps both). | She only wears short skirts. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "515-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "She doesn't only wear short skirts. She wears revealing clothes or professional clothes, the former don't have to be just short skirts, the latter are most likely not short skirts.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "515-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Usually, \"professinal clothes\" are not \"short skirts\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "515-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "She could also wear professional clothes",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 1,
"n": 37,
"c": 62
} |
1735n | that doesn't seem fair does it | That might possibly be fair. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1474-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context can be interpreted as saying that it seems unfair but that this maybe wouldn't hold under closer inspection. In that case it doesn't really say something about the actual fairness.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1474-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context suggests that this may not be fair, while the statement suggests that it may be fair.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1474-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context can be interpreted as saying that it's really not fair, so it cannot be possibly fair.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1474-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context suggests a higher possibility of unfairness in this matter, which the statement does not reflect.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1474-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's a rhetorical question. The speaker means it's not fair",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 21,
"n": 31,
"c": 48
} |
7449e | In 1982, Wallace won his last race for governor with a quarter of the black votes cast in the Democratic primary, a fact alluded to in a written epilogue at the end of the film. | Wallace was reelected as governor. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1436-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentioned that Wallance won his last race for gevernor, we don't know if this was his first win or if he won again.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1436-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not say anything about whether Wallace was governer before his 1982 win.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1436-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Wallace was elected as governor, but we don't know whether he was \"reelected\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1436-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know if he was governor before",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 68,
"n": 28,
"c": 4
} |
24385e | farmworkers conducted by the U.S. | Some farm laborers were sampled. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1338-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context contains no information about whether the conduction sampled the farmworkers.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1338-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether it is a census or a sampling survey.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
1,
3
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 28,
"n": 67,
"c": 5
} |
49807n | The next year, he built himself a palace, Iolani, which can still be toured in Honolulu. | Lolani was built in only 1 year. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "362-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"The next year\" can be interpreted as indicating that the building of Lolani was concluded in the same year.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "362-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It was built \"the next year\".",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "362-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context makes no mention of how long it took to build lolani.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "362-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"The next year\" can be interpreted as indicating that the building of Lolani was started in the next year.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "362-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know when did Lolani start to be built.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 28,
"n": 67,
"c": 5
} |
138448c | Indeed, recent economic research suggests that investment in information technology explains most of the acceleration in labor productivity growth-a major component of overall economic growth-since 1995. | Investment in the financial sector explains most of the acceleration in labor productivity. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "753-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Some research only suggests that most of the acceleration comes from investments in information technology. The research can be wrong and it could still be true that most of the acceleration comes from the financial sector.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "753-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether investment in information technology is a subsector of investment in financial sector, or reverse.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "753-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The reason of the acceleration in labor productivity is the investment in information technology, not in the financial sector.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "753-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The the \"suggestion\" of the cited research is strong, then it is likely that most of the acceleration comes from investments in information technologies. This precludes most of the acceleration coming from investments in the financial sector.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "753-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Investment in information technology explains most of the acceleration in labor productivity, not investment in financial sector.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "753-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It should be information technology that is invested in",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 35,
"n": 5,
"c": 60
} |
48454c | These revelations were embarrassing to Clinton's opponents, wrote the Washington Post . The Sun-Times quoted Rahm Emanuel, Stephanopoulos' successor, on the From Day One I always thought this was politically motivated and had politics written all over it; after five years, it is nice to have the truth catch up with the president's political opponents. | Clinton's supporters were pleased with how the hearings went. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "110-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions clinton's opponents, not clinton's supporters.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "110-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context is about a single supporter [probably?] of Clinton so we cannot deduce that all or most of the supporters were pleased with the hearing.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "110-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "These revelations were embarrassing to Clinton's opponents, but Clinton's supporters can also be unsatisfied with process for some reasons.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "110-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know there are hearings",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "110-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "It was embarrassing to them",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 40,
"n": 43,
"c": 17
} |
73260n | The disputes among nobles were not the first concern of ordinary French citizens. | Ordinary French citizens were not concerned with the disputes among nobles. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1456-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In the context, \"The first concern\" can be read as a pars pro toto which would mean that it was really no concern at all.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1456-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"not the first concern\" doesn't mean not the concern. The statement can be true or false.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1456-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It might not be the most important concern to the French citizens, but maybe an important concern after all.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1456-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The disputes among nobles could be second concern of ordinary French citizens.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1456-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They could be concerned. But it is not their first concern",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"entailment"
] | true | {
"e": 72,
"n": 18,
"c": 10
} |
76219n | and i and i may have been the only one that did both because the mentality in Dallas was that you couldn't like both you had to like one and hate the other | I did not follow the mentality in Dallas, of liking only one team. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "248-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In the context is stated that the author likes both, but the mentality in Dallas was that you couldn't like both. So the statement is true.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "248-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context clearly states that the mentality in Dallas was to like only one team and \"may have been the only one\" strongly suggests that the author did not adhere to this mentality.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "248-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I did both instead of only liking one.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "248-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, because I like both",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "248-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know what does \"did both\" mean. It could refer to liking both teams, but also could be others, for example likes both McDonalds and Burger King.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 70,
"n": 25,
"c": 5
} |
10229n | The governing statute provides that a committee consisting of the Comptroller General, the Speaker of the House and President Pro Tempore of the Senate, the Majority and Minority leaders, and the Chairmen and Ranking Minority Members of the Senate Governmental Affairs and House Government Reform Committees recommend an individual to the President for appointment. | The process is long and will be reformed in the coming years. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "531-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context makes no mention about how long the process takes and whether it will be reformed.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "531-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "While the context could suggest that the process takes long because so many individuals are involved, it does not say anything about reform.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "531-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Reform\" is not mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "531-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The time duration of the process is not mentioned",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 3,
"n": 79,
"c": 18
} |
99791n | Even analysts who had argued for loosening the old standards, by which the market was clearly overvalued, now think it has maxed out for a while. | Some analysts wanted to make the old standards less restrictive for investors. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "209-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"... analysts ... had argued for loosening the old standards\"",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "209-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions that there are analysts who had wanted to make the old standards less restrictive, but doesn't mention for whom should old standards be loosened.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "209-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the context whether the standards should have been loosened specifically for investors.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "209-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not known if the loosening was thought for investors",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 56,
"n": 31,
"c": 13
} |
13964e | uh plastic is just too easy i mean that's the that's the whole problem with it um have | I find plastic to be too easy to use. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "975-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context refers to the problem of plastic is that it it too easy. So the statement could be true, because too tasy to use is indeed a problem of plastic.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "975-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context clearly states that the speaker finds plastic too easy.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "975-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement could be undetermined because in the context it doesn't explicitly state to what is plastic too easy, could be too easy to use or maybe to produce.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "975-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Plastics can be just too easy to \"use\", to \"produce\", to \"dump\"...",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
3
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 72,
"n": 28,
"c": null
} |
66185c | The political cleansing that did not happen through the impeachment process leaves Clinton with a great and serious burden. | There was no such instance of political cleansing. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "645-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context states that a specific instance of political cleansing did not happen and we can assume that the statement refers to that instance.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "645-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, because the political cleansing did not happen",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "645-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "“The political cleansing that did not happen through the impeachment process”, but it could happen anywhere else.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "645-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The political cleansing did exist, as mentioned in the context. It just didn't happen throught the impeachment process.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 75,
"n": 16,
"c": 9
} |
65066n | Larger ski resorts are 90 minutes away. | The largest resort is actually 100 minutes away. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1592-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions the larger ski resorts not the largest resort.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1592-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The largest resort can be among the larger resorts 90 minutes away or it could be even further away.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1592-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Larger one and the largest one can be different.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1592-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about the largest ski resort",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 2,
"n": 69,
"c": 29
} |
76020e | The city was founded in the third millennium b.c. on the north shore of the bay, and reached a peak during the tenth century b.c. , when it was one of the most important cities in the Ionian Federation the poet Homer was born in S myrna during this period. | The city was founded in the third millennium | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "561-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context states that the city was founded in the third millenium b.c. and we can assume that the third millenium mentioned in the statement is also b.c.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "561-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The city was founded in the third millennium b.c., not in the third millennium.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "561-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "“the third millennium” is different from “the third millennium b.c.”",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "561-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It should be third millennium bc.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 86,
"n": 2,
"c": 12
} |
83248c | Her state is probably to be attributed to the mental shock consequent on recovering her memory." | It is too bad that she never regained her memory. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1010-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "It is not known if she will regain the memory in the future",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1010-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "According to the context, she regained her memory. it is incorrect to say that she never regained her memory.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1010-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context states that something probably happened because she regained her memory. Thus, she has regained her memory at some point.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1010-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "She must regain her memory first to get any consequence on that.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 11,
"n": 29,
"c": 60
} |
79141n | Isn't a woman's body her most personal property? | Women's bodies belong to themselves, they should decide what to do with it. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "10-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context states that women's bodies are her their personal property. Personal property of women does belong to themselves. So the statement is true.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "10-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context can be interpreted as a rhetorical question. In that case, it reasonably entails the statement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "10-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If a woman's body is her personal property, then the body belongs to her and she has right to dominate it.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "10-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context can be interpreted as a honest question. In that case, it's not affirmative and thus neutral to the statement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "10-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "context and statement do not contradicting each other, or one entail the other",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 76,
"n": 24,
"c": null
} |
97926n | General Motors, for instance, lost $460 million to strikes in 1997, but investors treated the costs as a kind of extraordinary charge and valued the company as if the losses had never happened. | GM lost a lot of money in labor disputes but was victorious in the end. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1457-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context says that investors held up a high evaluation of GM even after the strikes cost the company a lot of money. This can be interpreted as a win for the company.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1457-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The loss of money was treated by investor as a extraordinary charge and as if it had never happend, so this was a trick of treating the loss, but we can't conclude that it was victorious.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1457-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is conceivable that GM was valued highly by the investors even after losing a lot of money to the strike and additionally losing the subsequent negotiations.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1457-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether GM was \"victorious\" in the end.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1457-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not known if in the end it was victorious",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 67,
"n": 30,
"c": 3
} |
45957e | Bauerstein had been at Styles on the fatal night, and added: "He said twice: 'That alters everything.' And I've been thinking. | The fact that Styles was at Bauerstein changes everything. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1384-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention what changed everything.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1384-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement indicates that Bauerstein is a person and Styles is a location. The statement has it the other way around, so it is a likely contradiction.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1384-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is Bauerstein at Styles, not Styles at Bauerstein.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1384-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It should be Bauerstein had been at Styles",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 43,
"n": 32,
"c": 25
} |
24126n | The door did not budge. | The door was stuck, so it did not move. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "595-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "budge entails that the door wouldn't move",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "595-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions the state of the door, has no information about what caused the state.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "595-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There could have been other reasons that the door didn't moove. For example, that it was locked.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "595-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know the reason why the door did not budge, maybe it worked well.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 77,
"n": 23,
"c": null
} |
135251n | it's like but the time we went to Florida and needed to rent a car you know he believed in it | We rented a car while we were in Florida. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1549-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context says that they needed to rent a car, so it's likely that they also did rent a car.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1549-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context is unclear because it only mentions that they needed to rent a car, doesn't explain whether they did or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1549-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe back then they are so poor that they “Needed to rent”, but could not afford it.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1549-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not known if they rented the car in the end. It's only known that they needed to rent a car",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 72,
"n": 26,
"c": 2
} |
48223n | yeah although i do worry that how easy this one was might be a bad lesson uh to the to the younger people um you know than there is the other generation | I do worry that it might be a bad lesson for the kids. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "76-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context refers to the worry about giving a bad lesson to the younger people, which matches the statement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "76-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker in the context explicitly says that they worry about it being a bad lesson for younger people which includes kids.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "76-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "younger people can be kids, adolescents or young adults",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "76-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "true, if the younger people are considered as kids",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "76-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "younger people are not kids",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 83,
"n": 13,
"c": 4
} |
73518n | no North Carolina State | North Carolina is a county | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "64-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only doesn't state that whether North Carolina is a county or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "64-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is no North Carolina State, North Carolina could be a city or an area.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "64-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "context and statement are irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "64-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context says that North Carolina is a state. So it's not a county.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "64-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is a state but not North Carolina, so North Carolina is a state instead of a country.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 2,
"n": 28,
"c": 70
} |
16996e | In the short term, U.S. consumers will benefit from cheap imports (as will U.S. multinationals that use parts made in East Asian factories). | U.S. consumers and factories in East Asia benefit from imports. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1031-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions that the U.S. consumers and multinationals willl benefit from cheap imports, has no information about the benifits to factories in East Asia.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1031-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not say anything whether the factories in East Asia also benefit from the imports",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1031-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether \"factories in East Asia benefit from imports\".",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1031-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "It should be U.S. cunsumers in U.S.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 63,
"n": 32,
"c": 5
} |
69815n | yeah it's a U S territory and it's just we own it or | I used to be great at remembering this type of thing, but now I don't. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "494-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is irrelevant to what is discussed in the context. I think the topics are different.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "494-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statements seem to be completely unrelated.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "494-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We can not judge “my memory” based on the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "494-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Not relevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 1,
"n": 65,
"c": 34
} |
35809n | Evaluating the intent of the six principles, we observed that they naturally fell into three distinct sets, which we refer to as critical success factors. | All three distinct sets need to be filled in order to be considered successful. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "398-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The critical success factors are three distinct sets, which indicate that they should be filled to get success. This is consistent with the statement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "398-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The three sets are critical success factors. A success means three sets filled.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "398-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether all three sets are required to be filled, or maybe only one or two are enough.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 48,
"n": 49,
"c": 3
} |
30282n | wow who can afford that my God i can't afford to miss a day let alone six | It's amazing that some people can afford to miss days from work, whereas I can't even afford to miss one. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "428-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The \"wow\" in the context indicates amazement at the fact that some people can afford to miss six days from work.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "428-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions that the author can't afford to miss one day, doesn't contain any information that others can afford to miss days.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "428-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is cleat that \"I can't afford to miss a day\", but we don't know whether some people can afford to miss days from work.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "428-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not known if some people can afford it or not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 88,
"n": 12,
"c": null
} |
142430c | Flying at a discount should be more dangerous. | It's totally safe to take advantage of discounted flying. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "608-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The stance given in the context that discounted flying should be more dangerous, can mean that it should be even more dangerous. Thus, it does not really say something about the safety of discounted flying.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "608-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context states that it's dangerous to fly at a discount, whereas the statement states that dictount flying is safe.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "608-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not totally safe, it is more dangerous to choose discounted flying.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "608-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "context says more danguerous flying at discount, whereas statement says total safe.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 14,
"n": 40,
"c": 46
} |
127290n | The logic of analysis in case studies is the same | The logic for the case studies is the same thing as in the data collection. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "973-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The same logic of analysis in case studies doesn't mean the same logic of case studies and data collection. The context doesn't mention the data collection.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "973-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not specify where else the logic is the same. No mention about data collection.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "973-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In context, the subject is the logic of analysis in different case studies; in statement, the subject is the logic in case studies and the logic in data collection.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "973-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not known if the logic for case studies is same as in data collection from context. It could be same as in other fields.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 23,
"n": 70,
"c": 7
} |
100792c | yeah but uh do you have small kids | It matters not if children are involved. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1472-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "The speaker in the context asks about small kids, so at least it matters to them whether kids are involved.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1472-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Based on the context, we don't know if it matters to have kids.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1472-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The question indicates that kids matter, otherwise there should be no \"but uh\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1472-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Context entails the importance of kids, which contradicts the statement.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"entailment",
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 3,
"n": 59,
"c": 38
} |
75572n | Marriage is an important institution. | Marriage is crucial to society. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "879-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "That something is an important institution can be interpreted as being important for society.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "879-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Insitution is a part of society. Marriage being an import institution entails marriage being important to the society",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "879-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Based on the context, we only knowthe attributes of marriage as an important institution,not whether it is inportant to society.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "879-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "marriage could be crucial to other objects, like \"longevity\", \"personal health\", etc.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 49,
"n": 43,
"c": 8
} |
22235n | yeah really no kidding | It's crazy! | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "836-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "People might say \"no kidding\" when they realize what they're talking about is crazy.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "836-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Something sounds so crazy that people would think it is a joke. \"No kidding\" means it's as crazy as it sounds.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "836-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "it can be not crazy but serious.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 28,
"n": 67,
"c": 5
} |
40486n | The Women's Haven, which provides shelter and outreach to domestic-violence victims, already has a full-time attorney. | The Haven is a useful resource in the community. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1568-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Providing shelter and outreach to domestic-violence victims sounds like being useful for the community.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1568-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Haven provides shelter to victims, making it a useful resource in the society",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1568-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context contains no information onthe importance of the Haven.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1568-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Women's Haven is not the Haven.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 52,
"n": 47,
"c": 1
} |
13133n | The newspaper publishes just one letter a week from a reader, always with an editorial riposte at the bottom. | There are many letters submitted each week, but only one is chosen. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "451-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The newspaper publishes only one letter a week, either because they receive only one per week or because they receive many but choose only one. We don't know which is true.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "451-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not say anything about how many letters are submitted.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "451-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether there are many letters submitted.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "451-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not known if many letters are submitted, but only known that only one is published.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 50,
"n": 47,
"c": 3
} |
94674c | Meanwhile, a site established for the WorldAid '96 Global Expo and Conference on Emergency Relief, which took place last fall, gives you a firsthand glimpse of the frequently crass world of the relief business (note the long list of commercial exhibitors in attendance). | WorldAid had a GLobal expo in 2002. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1595-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions that WordAid had Global Expo last fall, we don't know whether last year was 2002 or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1595-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context talks only about a Global expo in 1996, not in 2002.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1595-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know how often is a Global expo hold.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1595-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Context and statement irrelevant to each other",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 2,
"n": 63,
"c": 35
} |
101525c | Monday's Question (No. | There was a question on Tuesday. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "474-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions the question on Monday, we don't know ifthere was a question on Tuesday as well.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "474-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context talks only about a question on Monday, not Tuesday.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "474-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The question can on Wednesday, Thursday ...",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "474-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 72,
"c": 28
} |
145495c | The students' reaction was swift and contentious, as if their feelings had been hurt. | The students reacted with horror. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "163-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't mention what kind of reaction the students had.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "163-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions that the students' feelings might have been hurt but it doesn't specify whether they also experienced horror.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "163-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The students could reacted with anger or disappointment.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "163-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not known what emotion was reacted with, could also be sadness or anger",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 12,
"n": 36,
"c": 52
} |
93357c | So is the salt, drying in the huge, square pans at Las Salinas in the south. | Pepper is made wet in Las Salinas. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1401-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions the salt, not the pepper.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1401-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context talks about salt. Pepper is not mentioned at all.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1401-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Pepper is not mentioned in context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1401-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about where the pepper is made wet",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 47,
"c": 53
} |
42388e | Daniel took it upon himself to explain a few things. | Daniel explained what was happening. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1362-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "This statement could be true, because Daniel explained a few things, which could include what was happening.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1362-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Daniel explained actively.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1362-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1362-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement could be undetermined because the context does not make it clear what things Daniel explained.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1362-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not specify what Daniel explained. It could also be other things than what was happening.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1362-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Daniel felt responsible to explain, but maybe fail to explain in the end.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 81,
"n": 19,
"c": null
} |
22587e | Classic Castilian restaurant. | The restaurant is based off a classic Castilian style. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "291-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"classic castilian restaurant\" means that the style of the restaurant is classic Castilian, so the statement is true.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "291-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both context and statement clearly mention that the restaurant is classic Castilian.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "291-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Usually it is true.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "291-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is a castilian restaurant, so it has castilian style.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 90,
"n": 9,
"c": 1
} |
131261n | But I'll take up my stand somewhere near, and when he comes out of the building I'll drop a handkerchief or something, and off you go!" | I want you to follow him, so watch for the signal that I give. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "9-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker wants the other one watch for the signal, i.e., the handkerchief dropping, so this part is correct, but we don't know if the intention is for the other person to follow the person he/she is observing.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "9-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It's not clear from the context, whether the speaker really wants the person they're talking to to follow someone. It could also be that they want the person to leave.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "9-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe “off you go” means something else, like detonating the rubbish bin etc.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "9-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not known if \"I\" want \"you\" to follow him from the context",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 55,
"n": 40,
"c": 5
} |
51353c | It is not a surprise, either, that Al Pacino chews the scenery in Devil's Advocate . And the idea that if the devil showed up on Earth he'd be running a New York corporate-law firm is also, to say the least, pre-chewed. | Nobody expects that the devil would take the form of a lawyer. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "688-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"pre-chewed\" implies that the idea of the devil running a law firm has been explored, so \"nobody expects\" in the statement is incorrect.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "688-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context says that the idea of the devil being a lawyer is \"pre-chewed\" meaning that other movies already used this idea. So at least some people would expect the devil to take this form.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "688-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "“pre-chewed” means not fresh, so many people should have expected devil would take the form of a lawyer.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "688-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "From the context we know that it is not a surprise, meaning people had expected that.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 15,
"n": 29,
"c": 56
} |
10547c | He jumped up, planting one hand on the charging horse, and came at the brute with the axe. | He swung at the brute with his sword. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "578-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "He came at the brute with the axe, not the sword.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "578-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement says that the person has one hand on the horse, so the other hand has to be holding the axe. Thus, he does not have any hand free to use a sword.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "578-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Not with \"sword\", but with \"axe\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "578-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, with his axe",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 3,
"n": 6,
"c": 91
} |
136360e | I can FEEL him." | I can sense his presence. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "406-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I think \"feel him\" is another way of saying \"sense his presence\".",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "406-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If a person can feel someone, then they most likely also sense their presence.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "406-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"Feel\" is synonym of sense.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "406-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "true, I can feel him, meaning I can sense his presence either physical or spiritually",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 86,
"n": 13,
"c": 1
} |
113193n | of course you could annex Cuba but they wouldn't like that a bit | Cubans would go up in arms if we tried to annex Cuba. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "999-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement could be true, because if Cubans wouldn't like that, it could be possible that they would go up in arms.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "999-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context talks only about the Cubans disliking an annexation of Cuba. That they would use armed resistance is not clear.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "999-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know Cubans reaction if Cuba is annexed.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "999-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "From context, it is only known that the Cubans would not be happy about this, but not known if they will arm themselves",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 69,
"n": 31,
"c": null
} |
120955n | Another thing those early French and Dutch settlers agreed upon was that their island should be free of levies on any imported goods. | The French settlers did not mind income taxes at all. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "480-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context talks about levies on imported goods, it is not clear why this should impact income taxes.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "480-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The French can take tax issues seriously, but still made the decision to reach the agreement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "480-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not mentioned about the income taxes",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "480-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is incorrect, because the French settlers did mind taxing on imported goods.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "480-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "The French only did not mind taxed on imported goods on their islands.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 4,
"n": 41,
"c": 55
} |
88188e | The air is warm. | The arid air permeates the surrounding land. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "540-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Warm air is not necessarily associated with arid air.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "540-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Air can be arid and cold at the same time.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "540-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The air can be warm but mosit.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "540-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelavant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 16,
"n": 75,
"c": 9
} |
138966n | It's thought he used the same architect who worked on the Taj Mahal. | In reality, he did not use the Taj Mahal's architect. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1165-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "People can be wrong about him using the same architect.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1165-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know in reality whether he used the Taj Mahal's architect.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1165-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The reality is not mentioned in the context",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1165-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "The context suggests that he might used the same architect, while the statement states that he did not.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 9,
"n": 66,
"c": 25
} |
48222n | News berates computer users for picking obvious, easily cracked passwords and chastises system administrators for ignoring basic security precautions. | Users and system administrators both do not prioritize security. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "582-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Users pick obvious, easily cracked passwords; administrators ignore basic security precautions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "582-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "true, users pick easy passwords and administrators irgnore basic security precautions, showing the low priority of security for them",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "582-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mentions users' behaviour, we don't know if the system administrators prioritize security.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "582-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The news can be wrong about the prevalence of this problem.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 72,
"n": 25,
"c": 3
} |
18428n | Companies that were foreign had to accept Indian financial participation and management. | Foreign companies had to take Indian money in order to operate their businesses. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "734-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Running businesses are the purpose of opening a company. So based on the context, companies have to satisfiy the prerequisites for accepting indian financial intervention in order to run businesses.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "734-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "That the companies had to accept \"Indian financial participation\" means that they had to take Indian money.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "734-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, if indian financial participation means investment from india",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "734-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Financial participation and management can have other forms, e.g. audit and supervision",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "734-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "financial participation could mean other possibilites other than investing money",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 81,
"n": 17,
"c": 2
} |
116059n | These days, newspaper writers are no longer allowed the kind of license he took. | Newspaper writers need to be more factual and careful these days. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1379-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't specify what kind of license he took. So we don't know whether it is associated with factual and carefull, as suggested in the statement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1379-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear which freedoms the writer in the context took. It might not be about factuality and carefulness.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1379-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"the kind of license\" can mean a facual and careful style, then the opposite should be not rigorous.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1379-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 56,
"n": 37,
"c": 7
} |
67610c | Sorry but that's how it is. | This is how things are and there are no apologies about it. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "2-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context can be interpreted as being unapologetic.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "2-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know the \"sorry\" in the context is meant to be an apology or just to comfort someone, so the need for an apology is unknown.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "2-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context can also be interpreted as being matter of factly but not unapologetic.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "2-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In context, it reads \"sorry\", and usually it means apology.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "2-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There are apologies in the context",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 48,
"n": 12,
"c": 40
} |
95186n | The cane plantations, increasingly in the hands of American tycoons, found a ready market in the US. | The US market was ready for the cane plantations, according to the economists. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "861-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions that there is a ready market in the US, but it's not clear who indicates this.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "861-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not say anything about whether economists believed that the market was ready.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "861-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know the resource of this ovservation that \"The cane plantations ... found a ready market in the US.\"",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "861-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not mentioned about the economists",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 58,
"n": 41,
"c": 1
} |
77875e | As legal scholar Randall Kennedy wrote in his book Race, Crime, and the Law , Even if race is only one of several factors behind a decision, tolerating it at all means tolerating it as potentially the decisive factor. | Race is one of several factors in some judicial decisions | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1559-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only means decisions, not judicial decisions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1559-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The conditional in the context does not assert whether race is one of several reasons or the only one in all judicial decisions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1559-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether in fact race is one of several factors in some judicial decisions.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1559-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not mentioned in what process is the race a factor of",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 81,
"n": 15,
"c": 4
} |
65879c | After the recovery of Jerusalem in 1099, it took four hundred years of sieges and battles, treaties, betrayals, and yet more battles, before Christian kings and warlords succeeded in subduing the Moors. | The Moors were able to subdue the Christian kings after just a decade of war. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "754-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context refers to the success of the Christian kings and warlords, but the statement refers in the opposite direction",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "754-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Christian kings subdued the Moors, not the other way around.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "754-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It was Christian kings who subdued the Moors, not inverse.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "754-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The Moors were then one subdued; It took the Chrisitans four hundred years.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 3,
"n": 8,
"c": 89
} |
86331e | 'Would you like some tea?' | DO you want a cup of tea? | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "165-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context and statement have the same meaning, both refer to the question about the willingness to drink tea.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "165-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In both context and statement, the speaker asks whether another person wants tea.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "165-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the answer for \"Would you like some tea\" is yes, then the answer for \"Do you want a cup of tea\" should also be yes.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "165-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "paraphrases",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 90,
"n": 10,
"c": null
} |
65130n | In Mumbai, both Juhu and Chowpatty beaches are, for instance, definitely a bad idea, and though the Marina beaches in Chennai are cleaner, there may be sharks. | The beaches are very dirty in Mumbai. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1588-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Mumbai's beaches are dirtier than beaches in Chennai, and described as \"definitely a bad idea.\"",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1588-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Marian beaches are compared to Juhu and Chowpatty cleaner, meaning the beaches in Mumbai beaches are dirty.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1588-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There could be other beaches than Juhu and Chowpatty in Mumbai which could be cleaner.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1588-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Mumbai's beaches are dirtier than beaches in Chennai, but it is not promised that they are very dirty objectively.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1588-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions that two beaches in Mumbai are cleaner than others, but the statement suggests that all beaches in Mumbai are dirty.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 47,
"n": 48,
"c": 5
} |
19578n | Moreover, Las Vegas has recently started to show signs of maturity in its cultural status as well. | The culture of Las Vegas has a lot of room for improvement. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "525-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context states that the culture of Las Vegas is improving, but the is no information about the room for improvement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "525-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "That there were signs of maturity indicates improvement. However, it does not say anything about whether things can improve further.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "525-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether the culture has a lot of room to improve.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "525-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context is talking about the cultural status, whereas the statement the culture",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "525-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The culture started to show signs of maturity, then they must have reached some standard and doesnot have much to improve.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 24,
"n": 70,
"c": 6
} |
83657c | Think of it this When consumer confidence declines, it is as if, for some reason, the typical member of the co-op had become less willing to go out, more anxious to accumulate coupons for a rainy day. | Coupon collecting is no longer allowed in most US stores. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1132-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions that some people tend to collect coupon, which implies that coupon collection is actually allowed. However, it doesn't include location information, so we don't know if it refers to the United States.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1132-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not say anything about whether coupon collection is legal or not in most US stores.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1132-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether the context is based on the U.S. society.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1132-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Not to collect coupon is a choice of the consumers. It is not forbidden.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 5,
"n": 54,
"c": 41
} |
102817c | yes they would they just wouldn't be able to own the kind of automobiles that they think they deserve to own or the kind of homes that we think we deserve to own we might have to you know just be able to i think if we a generation went without debt then the next generation like if if our our generation my husband and i we're twenty eight if we lived our lives and didn't become you know indebted like you know our generation before us that um the budget would balance and that we became accustomed to living with what we could afford which we wouldn't be destitute i mean we wouldn't be living on the street by any means but just compared to how spoiled we are we would be in our own minds but i feel like the generation after us would oh man it it would be so good it would be so much better it wouldn't be perfect but then they could learn to live with what what they could afford to save to buy and if you want a nicer car than that well you save a little longer | I am glad our generation has no debt. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1328-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker in the context would be glad if their generation had no debt, but does not assert this.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1328-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether \"our generation\" has no debt.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1328-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We are indebted and therefore living on the street",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1328-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context implies that our generation does have debt, so the statement is wrong.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 23,
"n": 34,
"c": 43
} |
124590c | The great attraction of the church is the splendid exterior, which is crowned by golden onion-shaped cupolas. | The outside of the church isn't much to look at, but the inside is intricately decorated. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "942-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context states that the exteroir of the church is great acctraction, but the statement implies the opposite.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "942-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context clearly states that the exterior of the church is splendid.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "942-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The outside of the church is attactive.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "942-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Is is the exterior that is a great attraction.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 4,
"n": 9,
"c": 87
} |
96583n | Mack Lee, Body Servant of General Robert E. Lee Through the Civil War , published in 1918. | The book was first drafted in early 1915. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1170-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context only mention the year the book published, no when it was drafted.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1170-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions only the publication date, not the date of the first draft.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1170-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We just know the publishment of the book, but don't know about the draft.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1170-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about the first draft only the first publication",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 78,
"c": 22
} |
132525n | She had the pathetic aggression of a wife or mother--to Bunt there was no difference. | Bunt was raised motherless in an orphanage. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "394-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is unclear where Bunt was raised based on the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "394-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not mention anything about Bunt having or not having a mother or where they were raised.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "394-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know where and how Hunt grew up.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "394-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know what the relation \"she\" is to Bunt. She could also be his wife",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 88,
"c": 12
} |
11362e | The volumes are available again but won't be returned to the stacks until the damp library itself gets renovated. | The volumes will be available to the public after renovation. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "719-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether the library is a public or a private library.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "719-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether after renovation the volumes will be available to the public or not after renovation..",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "719-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions that the library needs to be renovated, not the volumes.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "719-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The volumes are available before the renovation.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "719-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is already availabe before the renovation of stacks are done.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 79,
"n": 14,
"c": 7
} |
107468n | You have to walk through it). | Walking is the best way to get through it. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "588-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "Statement is a clear paraphrase of the context.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "588-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"The best way\" is not mentioned in the context. It is unclear if walking is the best way.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "588-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know what is the best way to get through it, maybe driving is better than walking.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "588-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Walking is not meant as best way but the only way",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 64,
"n": 36,
"c": null
} |
145047e | The management of the cafe has established the rules for the use of their facility. | The management of the cafe is strict about how they manage it. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "272-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We only know that there is management of the cafe, but the context doesn't mention how strict it is.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "272-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement talks about the management being strict about their management, whereas the context talks about rules for the use of the cafe.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "272-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether the rules are strict or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "272-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Established rules do not mean strict management if they are not followed. Or the rules could be not strict rules",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 34,
"n": 65,
"c": 1
} |
55888c | You've got the keys still, haven't you, Poirot? I asked, as we reached the door of the locked room. | I had the keys in my pocket. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "681-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear from the premise where the keys are.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "681-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We can't make sure whether I have the key or not.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "681-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the speaker had the keys, then she/he won't ask whether the other one had keys.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "681-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If I have the keys, usually I will open the door, instead of asking others.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "681-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"I\" think Poirot has the keys",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 7,
"n": 52,
"c": 41
} |
138285n | i cried when the horse got killed and when the wolf got killed | Animal killings make me want to cry. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1319-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both horse and wolf are animals, the speaker cried when they got killed. So the statement is correct.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1319-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If killings of two different animals make the narrator cry, then they probably generally care about animal killings.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1319-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Some animal like horse and wolf killings make me cry.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1319-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It could be that the narrator had a personal relationship to the killed animals and does not care about animal killings in general.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1319-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether all kinds of animal killings will make me want to cry, maybe I don't want to cry for a rat killing.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1319-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Overgeneralization. I could be sad maybe only because I know the horse and wolf",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 77,
"n": 22,
"c": 1
} |
57454c | what does um is Robby Robin Williams does he have a funny part in the movie or is | How much went into making the movie? | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "749-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The content of the statement is independent of the context. The statement is just a question.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "749-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In context there is nothing about the cost.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "749-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Not sure of \"how much\" of what went into the movie",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 63,
"c": 37
} |
88605n | The remaining parts of the north, although enticing, are difficult to explore. | Inexperienced explorers should take care to avoid dangerous areas of the north. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "204-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The exploration of north parts is difficult based on the context, so it's true that inexperienced explorers should avoid those parts.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "204-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Inexperienced explorers probably should be careful when exploring difficult to explore parts.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "204-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Some parts of the north are diffcult to explore, so inexperienced explorers should take care.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "204-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The remaining parts of the north are generally difficult to explore, meaning especially for the Inexperienced.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "204-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Inexperienced explorers should take care, but maybe they can also explore their with some guidance and help.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 56,
"n": 41,
"c": 3
} |
72721e | no i i i don't i it completely beyond me i went to my under graduate uh education | I can't remember, I did my undergraduate education. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "174-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions that the speaker did undergraduate education, the statement is false if the speaker of both sentences is the same person.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "174-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In context, it read \"I went to my under graduate uh education\", so \"I\" do remember it.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
1,
3
] | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 2,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 41,
"n": 54,
"c": 5
} |
49611e | How did you get it?" A chair was overturned. | "How did you get your hands on this object?" | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "714-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "“get your hands on this object” can be understood as get something",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "714-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "paraphrases",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "714-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I am asking my self whether the question belongs to a kind of hypothesis/statement. I can't make a conclusion based on the two questions in the provided context and statement.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 45,
"n": 52,
"c": 3
} |
16989c | Auditors from another country engaged to conduct audits in their country should meet the professional qualifications to practice under that country's laws and regulations or other acceptable standards, such as those issued by the International Organization of Supreme Audit Institutions. | All auditors report to a globally managed governing body. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "418-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not say anything about to whom the auditors report.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "418-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether auditors dealing with domestic companies need to report to a globally managed governing body.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "418-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In the context, it is not mentioned that they report to the globally managed governing body",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "418-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context implies that there are several possibilities for the standards that the auditors are expected meet, so the standard mentioned in the statement is one of the standards, not a mandatory one.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 39,
"n": 42,
"c": 19
} |
112349c | The idea that Clinton's approval represents something new and immoral in the country is historically shortsighted. | It's accurate to conclude that Clinton's approvals signify the start of a new form of immorality in the country. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "469-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "the approval only signified that the somehting immoral is historically shortsighted but does not introduce it.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "469-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The contexts suggests that the conclusion about Clinton's approval is shortsighted, while the statement refers to the accuration of this conclusion, so it is incorrect.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "469-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If an idea is historically shortsighted it is not accurate.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "469-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "To the same idea, the context remarked it as \"historically shortsighted\", but the statement took it as \"accurate\".",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 21,
"n": 16,
"c": 63
} |
119768n | I had rejected it as absurd, nevertheless it persisted. | I rejected it as absurd but it persisted out of protest. | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1349-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "paraphrases",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1349-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is unclear if it persisted out of protest or of other reasons.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1349-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context does not say anything about the reasons for the persistence.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1349-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know the reason for persisting, maybe my rejection was overmitted.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 49,
"n": 50,
"c": 1
} |
111680e | He dismounted and Ca'daan saw he was smaller than the rest. | He was shorter than the others. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "732-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "I think the two conclusion \"smaller after dismounting\" in the context and \" shorter\" in the statement both refer to the height of him So the statement is true.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "732-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement is a paraphrase of a part of the context.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "732-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"smaller than the rest\" means \"shorter than the others\"",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "732-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Ca'daan saw he was smaller thant he rest",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 91,
"n": 7,
"c": 2
} |
43440n | And you are wrong in condemning it. | Everybody does it; it's normal. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "730-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context refers to the wrongfulness of the condemnation,it is unclear what the normal situation is to which the statement refers.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "730-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "You cannot infer that something is normal because it is wrong to condemn it.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "730-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We can not say a thing is correct, juest because everybody does it.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "730-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The reason of wrongfulness in condemning is not known",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "730-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "In reality, if everybody does a thing, the thing will become a costum, and will not be condemned.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 15,
"n": 64,
"c": 21
} |
91709c | San'doro didn't make it sound hypothetical, thought Jon. | San'doro's words were hollow, and Jon knew the truth of that immediately. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1493-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Jon only thought about how San'doro made it sound. This doesn't tell us anything about whether he believed the words.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1493-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"didn't sound hypothetical\" implies that San'doro's words were actually not hollow, so the statement is false.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1493-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Jon did not regard San'doro's words as hollow, instead, he regarded it as not hypothetical.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1493-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "san'doro's words sound factual.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 19,
"n": 49,
"c": 32
} |
47798n | On the west side of the square is Old King's House (built in 1762), which was the official residence of the British governor; it was here that the proclamation of emancipation was issued in 1838. | The Old King's House had an incident where the King was murdered inside of it. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "921-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is no information in the context about the murder inside of the Old King's House, so the statement could be true or false.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "921-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context doesn't say anything about whether someone was killed in Old King's House.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "921-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether a King was murdered inside of the Old King's House.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "921-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info about the murder",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": null,
"n": 72,
"c": 28
} |
103364n | Several of its beaches are officially designated for nudism (known locally as naturisme) the most popular being Pointe Tarare and a functionary who is a Chevalier de la L??gion d'Honneur has been appointed to supervise all aspects of sunning in the buff. | They do not mind having nude people. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "391-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The beaches mentioned in the context accept people sunning naked, so we can conclude that they don't mind having nude people.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "391-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Beaches officially designated for nudism do not mind having nude people.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "391-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Some beaches are offically designated for nudism, which means nude people are allowed to be there.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "391-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Overgeneralization: they do not mind only in several of its beaches",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "391-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The nude people are supervised. If they don't mind, there should be no supervisors especially for such issues.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 75,
"n": 24,
"c": 1
} |
49462c | The village is Sainte-Marie, named by the explorer when he landed on 4 November 1493, attracted by the waterfalls and river he could see flowing down the green inland mountains. | The village is not named after the settling explorer. | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1274-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is named by the settling explorer, but named after.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1274-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "There is no information in the context about how the village is named, so the statement could be true or false.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1274-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The village was named by the explorer, it is not clear whether he named it after himself.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1274-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "It is named after him",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"contradiction",
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | true | {
"e": 10,
"n": 20,
"c": 70
} |
97011c | Expectations that the ANC would oversee land reform--returning land seized during apartheid's forced migrations--and wealth redistribution have not been met. | The ANC would not be in charge of land reform. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "680-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The expectations have not been met, which means the the ANC didn't voersee land reform, so the statement is true.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "680-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If the ANC does oversee the land reform then it isn't in charge of it.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "680-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The expectations have not been met.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "680-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "True, the expections that ANC oversees this is not met",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 38,
"n": 31,
"c": 31
} |
56743e | I found her leaning against the bannisters, deadly pale. | She couldn't stand on her own so she leaned against the bannisters until I found her. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "470-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The reason why she leaned against the bannisters in unclear, it may or may not have been because she couldn't stand on her own.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "470-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "She could have leaned on the bannisters for other reasons than not being able to stand on her own.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "470-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Maybe she could stand on her own, but she would not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "470-neutral-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info: no info about if she standed there till I found her, or if she really couln't stand on her own",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 4
} | [
"neutral"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 46,
"n": 54,
"c": null
} |
48300c | The activities included in the Unified Agenda are, in general, those expected to have a regulatory action within the next 12 months, although agencies may include activities with an even longer time frame. | Some actions were implemented for being shorter than 12 months. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "195-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions that some activities with an longer time frame than 12 months will be included, so it could be true that there are some activities are shorter that 12 months.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "195-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context states that the actions should generally see action within 12 months, so at least some are implemented for being shorter than 12 months.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "195-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Some activities are maybe longer than 12 months.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "195-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Miss interpretation: some actions were to be implemented in less than 12 months",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 41,
"n": 22,
"c": 37
} |
105769c | yeah yeah i i went i went off to school wanting to either be a high school algebra teacher or high school French teacher because my two favorite people in the in high school were my algebra teacher and French teacher and uh and i was going to do that until the end of our sophomore year when we wanted uh we came time to sign up for majors and i had taken chemistry for the first time that year and surprised myself i did well in it | You are required to sign up for a major freshman year. | [] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "782-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker in the context mentions that he/she sign up for major until the end of the sophomore year, not freshman year, so the statement is false, people don't need to sign up in their freshman year.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "782-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context states that the time for signing up for majors is sophomore year, not freshman year.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "782-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "At the end of our sophomore year, you are required to sign up for majors.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "782-contradiction-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No, it happens in the sophomore year",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 4,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 8,
"n": 36,
"c": 56
} |
53866e | kind of kind of nothing i won't have anything to do with | I don't want anything to do with it, no doubts about it. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "267-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context is a paraphrase of the statement.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "267-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker won't have anything to do with it could because she/he don't want or can't.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "267-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether \"I\" want anything to do with it, we just know it is none of \"my\" business.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "267-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info: Whether I want or not is not known, it's only mentioned that I will NOT have anything to do with it",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 74,
"n": 22,
"c": 4
} |
136752e | The questions may need to be tailored to | There are some questions that may or may not need to be tailored to. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "185-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "If some questions may need to be tailored to, then it is true that others may not need to.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "185-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context is a paraphrase of the statement.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "185-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The both show the uncertainty, whether some questions need to be tailored to.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "185-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "paraphrases",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 83,
"n": 9,
"c": 8
} |
14388e | life in prison then he's available for parole if it's if it's life and a day then he's not eligible for parole so what you know let's quit BSing with the system | The system is corrupt because he won't be able to get parole if it's life and a day. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "534-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Complaints were made about the system, as implied both in the context and statement.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "534-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The speaker thinks the system is very bad but doesn't say anything about corrupt.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "534-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The system can be corrupt, but also can be ridiculous.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "534-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No info: there is not comment about whether or not the rules of this system are counted as corrupted.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 56,
"n": 39,
"c": 5
} |
103559e | A martini should be gin and vermouth and a twist. | A martini must be composed by gin and vermouth. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "134-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context clearly states that a martini should contain gin and vermouth.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "134-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Gin and vermouth are necessary for a martini.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "134-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "true. The ingredients of martini are gin and vermouth",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "134-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The statement doesn't mention twist, but it is mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [
"contradiction",
"entailment"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 64,
"n": 23,
"c": 13
} |
132019n | and uh really they're about it they've got a guy named Herb Williams that that i guess sort of was supposed to take the place of uh Tarpley but he uh he just doesn't have the offensive skills | Tarpley is a better offensive player that Herb Williams. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "252-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context mentions that Williams doesn't have the offensive skills, even though he will replace Tarpley. So we can conclude from the context that Tarpley's offensive skills is better than Williams'.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "252-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Herb Williams couldn't replace Tarpley because of his lack of offensive skills. Thus, it is reasonable to assume that Tarpley is the better offensive player.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "252-entailment-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Herb Williams doesn't have the offensive skills and falls to take the place of Tarpley. So Tarpley should be a better offensive player.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "252-entailment-4",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Herb williams does not have the offensive skills like Tarpley do",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 4,
"neutral": null
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 3,
"neutral": null
} | [
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [] | false | {
"e": 75,
"n": 5,
"c": 20
} |
118999n | that's true i didn't think about that | You've changed my mind with a new perspective. | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "996-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": true,
"reason": "The context is a paraphrase of the statement.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "996-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The only thing mention in the context is the new perspective, we can't conclude whether the speaker changed mind.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "996-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "\"I\" can also keep my mind, although you offer a new perspective.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "996-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No Info: no info about whether or not I have changed my mind",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 71,
"n": 27,
"c": 2
} |
47404e | do you really romance | Do you really have an affair? | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "1562-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Both are questions and are asking about the same thing, which is about having an affair.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "1562-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "You can have other types of romance than an affair.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "1562-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "A romance can happen between two unmarried single person",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "1562-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "romance does not directly relate to affair.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [] | [] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 1,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"entailment"
] | false | {
"e": 21,
"n": 68,
"c": 11
} |
30171n | Until all members of our society are afforded that access, this promise of our government will continue to be unfulfilled. | The government is flawed and unfulfilled. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "155-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether all members of the society are afforded that access.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "155-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The promise of the government is unfulfilled. Can not conclude that the government is therefore flawed and unfulfilled.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "155-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The government will not always be unfulfilled. If all menbers are afforded that access, the government could fulfill the promise mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 2
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 56,
"n": 38,
"c": 6
} |
134514c | However, co-requesters cannot approve additional co-requesters or restrict the timing of the release of the product after it is issued. | They will restrict timing of the release of the product. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "331-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Whether they can restrict the timing of the product at all is not clear beacuse we don't know whether it was already issued.",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "331-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They can't restrict the release time, as mentioned in the context.",
"self_corrected": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "331-contradiction-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "Co-requesters cannot restrict the timing of the release of the product.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "331-contradiction-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "They can NOT restrict the timing of the release",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 3,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 1
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [] | true | {
"e": 7,
"n": 13,
"c": 80
} |
52542n | The long-sought, the mysterious, the elusive Jane Finn! | Jane Finn is as beautiful as she is mysterious. | [] | [
{
"annotator": 1,
"id": "696-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "It is not clear whether Jane Finn is beautiful.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "696-neutral-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "We don't know whether Jane Finn is beautiful or not.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "696-neutral-3",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "No Info: No Info about the beauty of Jane Finn",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "696-contradiction-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The comment about Jane Finn stated both in the context and statement is mysterious. There is no mention of \"beautiful\" in the context.",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | {
"contradiction": 1,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": null,
"neutral": 3
} | [
"neutral",
"contradiction"
] | [
"neutral"
] | [
"contradiction"
] | false | {
"e": 16,
"n": 83,
"c": 1
} |
47408n | the net cost of operations. | That's how it expensive it runs. | [
{
"annotator": 0,
"id": "703-entailment-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The context and statement are both talking about the running cost.",
"self_corrected": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"id": "703-entailment-2",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": true
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "The cost can be described as \"how expensive\".",
"self_corrected": false
}
] | [
{
"annotator": 3,
"id": "703-neutral-1",
"judgments": [
{
"annotator": 0,
"makes_sense": false
},
{
"annotator": 1,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 2,
"makes_sense": true
},
{
"annotator": 3,
"makes_sense": false
}
],
"label_correction": false,
"reason": "irrelevant",
"self_corrected": true
}
] | [] | [
1
] | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": 1
} | {
"contradiction": null,
"entailment": 2,
"neutral": null
} | [
"neutral",
"entailment"
] | [
"entailment"
] | [
"neutral"
] | false | {
"e": 47,
"n": 49,
"c": 4
} |