Interpreting a Dwarf Nova Eruption as Magnetic Flare Activity

Abstract: We suggest that the radio emission from the dwarf nova SS Cyg during outburst comes from magnetic activity that formed a corona (similar to coronae found in magnetically active stars), rather than from jets. We base our claim on the recent results of Laor & Behar, who found that when the ratio between radio and X-ray flux of accretion disks in radio-quiet quasars is as in active stars, Lr/Lx=10^{-5}, then most of the radio emission comes from coronae. Using observations from the literature we find that for SS Cyg during outburst Lr/Lx<10^{-5}. This does not mean jets are not launched during outbursts. On the contrary, if the magnetic activity in erupting accreting disks is similar to that in stars, then mass ejection, e.g., as in coronal mass ejection, is expected. Hence magnetic flares similar to those in active stars might be the main mechanism for launching jets in a variety of systems, from young stellar objects to massive black holes.

\section{INTRODUCTION}
\label{sec:intro}

In a recent detailed and elegant study, Laor \& Behar (2008) present a
correlation
between radio and X-ray emission over some 15 orders of magnitude, from
magnetically active stars to radio quiet AGN.
The correlation they observe is consistent with $L_r = 10^{-5} L_X$, a
correlation
known as the G\"udel-Benz
relation in magnetically active stars (G\"udel \& Benz 1993). This suggests
that the source of the
radio emission in these highly diverse objects may be related.
Indeed Laor \& Behar (2008) suggest that in
radio quiet AGN the source of radio emission is coronae above accretion
disks.
Suzaku observations of the dwarf nova (DN) SS Cyg (Ishida et al. 2008)
provide spectral evidence for thermal plasma distributed on the disk during
outburst analogous to the Solar corona.
Suggestions for the presence of coronae above accretion disks are not new (e.g., Galeev et al.
1979; Done \& Osborne 1997; Wheatley \& Mauche 2005),
and the connection between coronae and jets were proposed in the past
(e.g., Fender et al. 1999; Markoff et al. 2005).
The results of Laor \& Behar (2008) and Ishida et al. (2008)
put the presence of coronae in accretion disks on solid ground.
The correlation does not hold for radio loud AGN, where
most of the radio emission comes from jets, and
systems show $L_r \gg 10^{-5} L_X$.
Laor \& Behar (2008) find that some galactic black hole (GBH) binaries also
reside close to this correlation.
This implies that the common practice of attributing radio emission
of accreting neutron stars and black holes (BH) to emission from jets
(e.g., Dunn et al. 2008) should be done with caution,
if we assume that these systems are analogous with AGN (e.g., Markoff
2006).
It is correct to attribute the radio emission to jets in some cases,
as in SS~433 (Miller-Jones et al. 2008), but not necessarily in all
binaries.

Jets are not usually observed in cataclysmic variables (CVs),
among them DN.
In CVs a white dwarf (WD) accretes mass from a companion via an accretion
disk.
In many other astrophysical systems accretion disks
are known to launch jets.
The absence of jets in CVs impose strong constraints on some jet
launching models (Soker 2007).
For example, no jets are observed in intermediate polars (DQ Her systems).
These are cataclysmic variables where the magnetic field of the accreting WD
is thought to truncate the accretion disk in its inner boundary.
This magnetic field geometry is the basis for some jet-launching
models in YSOs (e.g., Shu et al. 1991). Why then are no jets observed from
intermediate polars?

Theoretical arguments (Soker \& Lasota 2004), and at least one observation
(Retter 2004) claimed that jets might be present in CVs when the accretion
rate is high.
High accretion rates result in longer diffusion time for photons
(radiation) from the disk,
and might leave time for the energy to be channeled to kinetic
(Soker \& Lasota 2004) or magnetic (Soker 2007) energy.
Soker (2007) proposed that in some cases jets are launched in a manner similar
to coronal mass ejection (CME) in the sun.
Instead of a dynamo and buoyant magnetic flux tubes as in the sun, in
accretion
disks the kinetic energy of the gas in the accretion disk is transferred,
e.g.,
by shock waves, to thermal energy.
The thermal energy builds pressure that inflates magnetic flux loops
above the disk,
and from there on the activity is analogous to solar flares.
It is also possible that the
kinetic energy is transfered directly to the magnetic field.
This model predicts that some burst activity must precede the
magnetic activity.
The idea that jets are launched by magnetic fields reconnection events similar
to that in the sun is not new, e.g., de Gouveia Dal Pino \& Lazarian (2005;
de Gouveia Dal Pino 2006).

In a recent paper K\"ording et al. (2008) attributed radio emission
in an outburst of SS Cyg to jets.
Here we argue in $\S 2$ that the radio emission in SS Cyg is more likely to
come from a corona that was formed during the outburst.
The same activity could have launched jets, or more generally,
collimated outflows, as we argue in $\S 3$.
Fender et al. (1999; also Markoff et al. 2005) proposed that the base of the jet
and the corona are the same region. Our idea goes beyond this identification, and we argue
that the acceleration mechanism of the jet is similar to solar magnetic activity.
Our results are not in contradiction with the results of these works. Our claims are
aiming at identifying the acceleration process of the jet.
To put our claim on a broader view, in $\S 4$ we discuss some related
systems.

\section{THE OUTBURST BEHAVIOR IN SS CYG}
\label{sec:burst}
\subsection{Radio and X-ray fluxes}

K\"ording et al. (2008) conducted radio observation of SS Cyg in its
April 2007 outburst. The peak radio luminosity at 8.6~GHz reached a value
of $\sim 1~$mJy,
and then declined to $\sim 0.3$mJy in a short time.
It then continued slowly to decline. We take the average outburst
radio emission to be $\sim 0.3~$mJy.
This gives a radio flux of
$\bar F_{\rm radio} \simeq 3 \times 10^{-17} {~\rm erg} {~\rm cm}^{-2} {~\rm s}^{-1}$.

No X-ray observations were conducted during the April 2007 outburst,
and K\"ording et al. (2008) refer to X-ray observations at previous
outbursts.
Wheatley et al. (2003) followed the X-ray emission from SS Cyg in its
October 1996
outburst and analyze the X-ray emission as coming from two sources.
Strong emission from the boundary layer (the boundary of the accretion disk and the WD),
with a maximum flux of
$L_{\rm BL} \simeq 3.6\times 10^{-10} {~\rm erg} {~\rm cm}^{-2} {~\rm s}^{-1}$.
(The fluxes here include their correction of a factor of 1.8 to
include the total X-ray emission).
This emission is obscured, because of high optical depth, during most
of the outburst (Patterson \& Raymond 1985a, b). Wheatley et al.
identify another source, the residual,
which they interpret as extended emission, possibly coronal.
The residual X-ray emission flux is
$F_{ex}\simeq 2.5 \times 10^{-11} {~\rm erg} {~\rm cm}^{-2} {~\rm s}^{-1}$.

Okada et al. (2008) find the X-ray luminosity of the September 2000 outburst
to be $\sim 0.3$ that in quiescence. Taking the quiescent flux from
Wheatley et al. (2003), the September 2000 outburst X-ray luminosity is
$\simeq 3 \times 10^{-11} {~\rm erg} {~\rm cm}^{-2} {~\rm s}^{-1}$.
The ASCA flux in the $0.8-10 {~\rm keV}$ band reported by  Baskill et al. (2005)
was higher than the quiescent one: $4 \times 10^{-11} {~\rm erg} {~\rm cm}^{-2}
{~\rm s}^{-1}$
in the outburst versus $2 \times 10^{-11} {~\rm erg} {~\rm cm}^{-2} {~\rm s}^{-1}$ in
quiescence.
Similar X-ray outburst fluxes were observed in the past (e.g., Nousek et al.
1994).

Over all, we find the ratio of radio to residual X-ray emission (the X-ray
emission that
is not attributed to the boundary layer by Wheatley et al. 2003) during
outburst to be
\begin{equation}
\frac{F_{\rm radio}}{F_{x}} \simeq 10^{-6}.
\label{eq:tkh1}
\end{equation}

For a distance of 166 {~\rm kpc}~to SS Cyg (Harrison et al. 1999) the residual
X-ray luminosity is
$L_{x} \simeq 10^{32} {~\rm erg} {~\rm s}^{-1}$. We can now place the eruptive SS Cyg on
the radio vs. X-ray luminosity seminal plot ($L_r$ vs. $L_x$ plane) of Laor \&
Behar (2008).
We do this in Figure 1.
The radio and residual X-ray luminosities of SS Cyg at outburst
put it where the magnetically active stars are.
\begin{figure}  %
\vskip +3.5 cm
\begin{tabular}{cc}
{\includegraphics[scale=0.70]{sscygfig1.eps}}
\end{tabular}
\vskip -4.5 cm
\caption{The position of different objects in the $L_r$ vs. $L_x$ plane
(from Laor \& Behar 2008, beside SS Cyg).
GBHs, ULX, and RQQ stand for Galactic black holes (in the hard state),
ultraluminous X-ray sources, and radio quiet quasars, respectively.
The square is the location of SS Cyg during eruption.
The location of SS Cyg in this plane hints that its eruption is connected to
magnetic flares.
}
\label{fig:models}
\end{figure}

The total flux at maximum, dominated by the extreme UV (Wheatley et al.
2003), is $F_{\rm tot} \simeq 3 \times 10^{-8} {~\rm erg} {~\rm cm}^{-2} {~\rm s}^{-1} \sim 10^{3} F_{x}$.
A bolometric to X-ray ratio of $\sim 10^{3}$ is also observed in
magnetically very active stars, i.e., in the activity saturation regime (Pizzolato et al.
2003).
This further suggests that what we observe in the outburst of SS Cyg
is a magnetic outburst, similar to flares on very active stars.

\subsection{Time delay and kinetic energy}
Wheatley et al. (2003) find that for SS Cyg the X-ray rise occurs $\sim~1$day after the
visible. Most of the initial X-ray rise is due to the emission from the
boundary layer, and not from a corona. For that, we cannot tell when X-ray
emission
from the corona starts. The radio emission, which we attribute to the
corona, is delayed also by $\sim
1~$day after the visible  (K\"ording et al. 2008).
This suggests that coronal emission starts after an instability in the
disk has set in. In our model, kinetic and gravitational
energy released in the disk lead to magnetic activity, rather than
magnetic activity increasing the accretion rate.

In the solar case, the kinetic luminosity of the wind $\sim 2 \times 10^{27}
{~\rm erg} {~\rm s}^{-1}$
is about equal to the average X-ray luminosity.
Applying the same relation to SS Cyg, i.e., taking the kinetic outflow
to be equal to the residual X-ray luminosity, we get the kinetic energy of
the outflow to be $\sim 10^{-3}$ the energy released in the outburst.
If the outflow is equal to the Keplerian velocity at the WD surface,
$\sim 3000 {~\rm km} {~\rm s}^{-1}$, we find the mass loss rate to
accretion rate to be $\sim 10^{-3}$.
This ratio is typical for weak jets.
Namely, it is possible that weak jets are launched by the coronal magnetic
activity.

We further note that in some cases, like the BH candidate Cygnus X-1, the
power of the jets is
about equal to the bolometric X-ray luminosity (Russell et al. 2007).
This points to an ejection mechanism similar to that of
the solar wind, assuming that a large fraction (but not all)
of the X-ray emission is due to a corona.

The radio luminosity of Cyg X-1 is $10^{-8}$ times the X-ray luminosity,
which is typical for many GBH systems and some solar regions (Laor \& Behar
2008).
As this is the case for solar microflares, it is not unlikely that the
explanation
for the outflow is indeed a solar like activity.
The above ratio of $L_r/L_x \simeq 10^{-8}$ is much lower than in
magnetically active stars.
However, Wood et al. (2005) found that the kinetic energy of the wind
decreases
for more magnetically active stars.
The ratio of the average radio luminosity of the quiet sun (Drake et al.
1993)
to the average solar X-ray luminosity  is $\sim 3 \times 10^{-7}$.
Therefore, it is possible that the highest ratio of outflow kinetic energy
to X-ray luminosity
is obtained by activity similar to the less active regions of the suns,
where radio emission can gets as low as $L_r \simeq 10^{-8} L_x$ (G\"udel \&
Benz 1994).
Indeed, microflares can heat the corona and supply the energy to the wind
(Moore et al. 1999).

\section{THE AMPLIFICATION OF THE MAGNETIC FIELD IN THE OUTBURST}
\label{sec:dynamo}

Following the previous section and building on the behavior of the solar
magnetic field,
we consider magnetic fields with coherence lengths much smaller than the
radius of the
disk $r$, rather than the large scale magnetic field that is used in many
jet-launching models.
We take the magnetic pressure to be limited by the thermal pressure of the
disk,
$P_B \simeq P$, and approximate the thermal pressure from the hydrostatic
equation in the vertical
direction $z$: $d P/dz =-\rho (GM/r^2)(z/r)$, where $r$ is the radial
coordinate in
cylindrical coordinates, $\rho$ is the density, and $M$ is the mass of the
central accreting object.
This gives for the magnetic pressure
\begin{equation}
P_B \sim P \simeq \rho \frac{GM}{r} \left( \frac{H}{r} \right)^2,
\label{eq:pb}
\end{equation}
where $H = \epsilon r \sim 0.1r$ is the scale height of the disk in the $z$
direction.
The Alfven speed $v_A^2=(2P_B/\rho)$ is then
\begin{equation}
v_A \sim \frac{H}{r} v_{\rm esc} \ll v_{\rm esc},
\label{eq:va}
\end{equation}
where $ v_{\rm esc}= ({2GM}/{r})^{1/2}$ is the escape velocity from the disk
at radius $r$.
The inequality implies that the magnetic fields do not contain enough energy
to expel
large quantities of gas at high speeds.
If a corona is formed, the typical temperature associated with this
value of
$v_A$ is
\begin{equation}
T_{\rm corona} \sim 5 \times 10^6
\left( \frac{r}{R_{\rm WD}} \right)^{-1}
\left( \frac{H}{0.1r} \right)^{2} K
\label{eq:tcor}
\end{equation}
where for the WD mass and radius we took $M_{\rm WD}=1 M_\odot$ and $R_{\rm
WD}=0.01 r_\odot$,
respectively.
A hot corona can be marginally formed under these conditions, and only very
close to the
WD.

We turn now to an outburst, where the mass accretion rate substantially
increases.
Consider a rapid stochastic dissipation of the kinetic energy of the gas in
the disk.
This can occur through shock waves, i.e., transfer of kinetic energy to
thermal energy,
and through transfer of kinetic energy directly to magnetic fields.
In the case of shock waves the gas will cool via two processes.
Radiative cooling via diffusion of photons, and adiabatic cooling.
When the diffusion time scale is longer than the adiabatic expansion time
scale,
the orbital kinetic energy of the gas in the disk is transferred mainly to
vertical motion (perpendicular to the disk plane), that can lead to the
formation of jets
(Torbett 1984; Torbett \& Gilden 1992; Soker \& Regev 2003; Soker \& Lasota
2004).
This is the thermally launched jet model (Soker 2007).

Soker \& Lasota (2004) found the minimum accretion rate required to launch
jets from WDs in
the thermally launched jet model to be
\begin{equation}
\dot M_b \ga 10^{-6} \left( \frac {\alpha_d}{0.1} \right)^{-1} M_\odot
{~\rm yr}^{-1},
\label{eq:mb}
\end{equation}
where $\alpha_d$ is the disk-viscosity parameter. Due to several
uncertainties,
the limit in equation (\ref{eq:mb}) can be as low as $\sim 10^{-7} M_\odot
{~\rm yr}^{-1}$.
This limit is compatible with the result of Retter (2004), who argued for a
detection
of jets in the transition phase (few months post-outburst) of nova
V1494 Aql.
Considering that $\alpha_d$ can be much lower, and taking into account some
observations
of jets in super-soft X-ray sources (see discussion in Soker \& Lasota
2004),
this limit can be as low as $\sim 10^{-8} M_\odot {~\rm yr}^{-1}$.
The accretion rate at peak luminosity in the eruptions of SS Cyg is
$\sim 10^{-8} M_\odot {~\rm yr}^{-1}$ (Wheatley et al. 2003).
This limit implies that if rapid dissipation of the orbital kinetic energy
occur,
then a large fraction, or even most, of this energy will be channelled to
accelerate gas in the vertical direction.

The vertically accelerated gas can stretch magnetic field lines and amplify
the magnetic fields (Soker 2007).
The strong magnetic fields lead to a second
acceleration stage, where after the primary outflow stretches magnetic
field lines,
the field lines reconnect and accelerate small amount of mass to very high
speeds.
This double-stage acceleration process might form highly relativistic jets
from BH
and neutron stars, as well as jets from brown dwarfs and stars.

Here we raise the possibility that the magnetic fields might be amplified by
an
$\alpha \Omega$ dynamo, in addition to a pure stretching in the vertical
direction.
The amplification of magnetic fields by turbulence dynamo, and the acceleration of gas
by reconnection in accretion disk coronae was considered before by
de Gouveia Dal Pino \& Lazarian (2005).
Here we attribute a major role to the differential rotation velocity and the dissipation
of the kinetic energy of the disk material. We also do not require the presence of a global
field, but rather consider many small scale flares.

In stars, the $\alpha$ effect (not to confuse with the $\alpha_d$ for disk
viscosity)
is attributed to the convection, while in galaxies it can come from
supernovae and other stars,
or from the dynamics of magnetic field lines themselves (Beck et al. 1996).
Basically, local heating (e.g. OB associations and supernova) in the galaxy
can drives the
$\alpha$ effect.
Here the local heating is done by small shocks (Soker \& Regev 2003), which
can then grow
to larger volumes. This result in a rapid increase in the thermal pressure,
and the acceleration of gas, mainly in the vertical direction, but locally
in other directions.
This motion can play the role of the $\alpha$ effect.
Within the disk the accelerated gas move at a fraction of the Keplerian
speed (only the outer layers can be accelerated to the escape speed):
$v_t = \beta v_{\rm Kep}$.
If we take the coherence length of the field to be
$H=\epsilon r$, then $\alpha ={\rm min}(\Omega H, v_t)$ (Beck et al. 1996,
sec. 4.4).
If $\beta \ga \epsilon \simeq 0.1$, then the magnetic growth time is (Beck
et al. 1996, sec. 4.4)
\begin{equation}
\tau_B \simeq \left( \frac{H}{\alpha \Omega} \right)^{1/2} \simeq
\Omega^{-1}.
\label{eq:taub}
\end{equation}

In the eruption phase the Alfven speed is about equal to the Keplerian
speed, and by
equation (\ref{eq:tcor}) (taking $H \simeq r$) a very hot corona is formed
up to a distance of
$r \simeq {\rm few} \times 10 R_{\rm WD}$ (somewhat cooler corona can be
formed at
larger distance as well).
The magnetic field growth time at these radii is
$\tau_B  \simeq \Omega^{-1} \simeq 5 (r/30 R_{\rm Wd})^{3/2}$~min.
This is much shorter than the rise time of the outburst at different bands
(spanning several hours to a day; K\"ording et al. 2008; Wheatley et al.
2003).

To summarize, in this section we examined a chain of events starting with
some disk instabilities that lead to enhanced mass accretion rate (Lasota
2001).
Local dissipation of orbital kinetic energy of the disk material, e.g., via
shocks, lead to
local expansion of many regions in the disk (Soker \& Regev 2003), because
radiative
cooling proceeds on a time scale longer than the expansion time (Soker \&
Lasota 2004).
The gas motion in the disk can amplify magnetic fields by stretching
magnetic field lines,
or by being the source of the $\alpha$ effect in an $\alpha \Omega$ dynamo.
These magnetic fields are likely to behave similarly to stellar magnetic
fields (Laor \& Behar 2008). Namely, they can be the main radio source and can
eject material by reconnecting in the disk corona (de Gouveia Dal Pino \& Lazarian 2005).
When collimated, the ejected gas becomes jets.

\section{RELATED OBJECTS}
\label{sec:objects}

Several authors (e.g. Nipoti et al 2005; Massi 2005) have pointed out
that X-ray binaries, and in
particular the subset within them that are called microquasars,
show evidence for radio-loud and radio-quiet states similar to that
observed in AGN.
The obvious analogy is that radio-loud systems emit strong jets and
radio quiet systems do not.
SS 433 is a complicated object, but shows that in cases where
jets are strong radio sources the ratio of radio to X-ray emission
can be $L_r/L_x \gg 10^{-5}$.
On July 11, 2003, the ratio of radio to X-ray emission from the core was
$(L_r/L_x)_{\rm core} \simeq 2 \times 10^{-5}$
(Migliari et al. 2005; Miller-Jones et al. 2008).
The radio contribution outside the core was $0.54$ times that in the core.
At other times X-ray and radio measurements are not performed
simultaneously,
but we note that  the core X-ray emission is $\sim
0.025-0.25$
times that in July 11, 2003 (Migliari et al. 2005) ,
while the total radio emission is larger (Miller-Jones et al. 2008) by
factor of $\sim 2$.
Over all, for most of the time in SS 433, the radio to X-ray ratio is
$L_r/L_x \sim 10^{-4}-10^{-3}$.
This ratio resides between radio quiet and radio loud AGN.

In Table 1 we list the $F_r/F_x$ ratios of a few  X-ray binaries
associated with micro-quasars that are listed as ``radio-loud" by Massi (2005).
We determine the majority of our ratios from numbers obtained from Figures 2 and 6
of Gallo, Fender, \& Pooley (2003; hereafter GFP03).
Where available, for each object we give the range from each of the the states: quiescent, hard,
soft, and transient.  GFP03 note that the quiescent state is dominated by
jets, no jets are observed in the hard state, and jets again in the soft and transient state.
The majority of the ratios do lie below 1.e-5 as noted by Loar \& Behar (2008).
Nevertheless, as GFP03 note, many of these systems do show jets.
The reason is that the accretion disks around neutron stars and GBHs has
a substantial fraction of their emission in the X-ray band. Disks around
stars and massive BH emits mainly in the IR to UV bands.
The strong thermal X-ray emission from disks around neutron stars and GBHs
(X-ray binaries) reduces the ratio of $L_r/L_x$.
The inner region of disks around WDs contribute to the X-ray emission,
particularly from the boundary layer.
The `trick' in SS Cyg in eruption is that the optical depth to the boundary layer becomes
very large, such that the energy is radiated from a larger area at longer wavelengths.
This allows the detection of the residual X-ray emission, which is assumed to come
from the coronae.

Not only are the disks in X-ray binaries strong x-ray emitters, but the observed luminosity
is strongly influenced by the geometry of the system. This is because the flux comes from
a small region towards the center of the disk that can be easily obscured by flared
edges of the disk, if observed edge on.
We conclude that the observed X-ray flux from X-ray binaries is not a reliable measure
of the X-ray flux from the disk corona.
Hence the ratio $F_r/F_x$ can not be used as an indicator for jet formation.

\begin{table}

{\bf Table 1: Related Objects}

\footnotesize
\bigskip
\begin{tabular}{lcccc} \hline

Source& Fr/Fx& State&Jets&Reference\\
\hline
\hline
V404 Cyg&5.2e-5&quiescent&yes&Gallo et al. 2003\\
&4.0e-6-1.0e-5&hard&no&Gallo et al. 2003\\
&&&\\
GX339-4&1.2e-5-6.3e-6&quiescent&yes&Gallo et al. 2003\\
&2.1e-8-2.7e-6&hard&no&Gallo et al. 2003\\
&&&\\
XTEJ1118+480 &   1.5e-6 &outburst&   yes         &   Chaty et al. 2003\\
 & 2.4e-6&hard&no&Gallo et al. 2003\\
&&&\\
Cygnus X-1&7.5e-8-7.5e-7&hard&no&Gallo et al. 2003\\
&&&\\
Cygnus X-3&1.0e-7-1.5e-5&soft&yes&Gallo et al. 2003\\
&&&\\
GRS 1915+105&2.0e-9-5e-7&transient&yes&Gallo et al. 2003\\
&&&\\
SS433        & 1.0e-3-1.0e-4 & & yes-steady &  Miller-Jones et al 2008\\
            &   1.0e-4 &   &yes        &   Kotani et al. 1999\\
\hline
\hline
\end{tabular}
\footnotesize
\bigskip

\normalsize
\end{table}

\section{SUMMARY AND DISCUSSION}
\label{sec:summary}

Magnetically active stars follow the
G\"udel-Benz relation ($L_r \simeq 10^{-5} L_X$;
G\"udel \& Benz
1993).
In a recent paper Laor \& Behar (2008) found this correlation
to hold over some 15 orders of magnitude, from magnetically active stars to
radio quiet AGN.
For strong jets to be present in AGN $L_r \gg 10^{-5} L_X$.

The new finding of Laor \& Behar (2008), and the observations of Ishida et al.
(2008) of disk coronae formed during an outburst of SS Cyg,
motivated us to examine whether the radio emission found in the
outburst of the dwarf nova SS Cyg by K\"ording et al. (2008) is due
to magnetic flaring as well.

In accreting WD and neutron stars the task of finding the ratio $L_r/L_x$
is more complicated, as the accreting gas near the boundary layer emits in
the X-ray band.
As we showed in section \ref{sec:objects}, the strong X-ray emission from the
disks in X-ray binaries prevent us from using the ratio $L_r/L_x$ to learn about the
presence of absence of a jet.

However, in the case of SS Cyg
the high accretion rate during outburst obscures the boundary layer, and the
residual X-ray emission observed by Wheatley et al. (2003) can be attributed
to a corona.
In $\S 2$ we found the ratio between the peak radio emission at outburst
(K\"ording et al. 2008)
and the residual X-ray emission at outburst (Wheatley et al. 2003) of SS Cyg
to be
$L_r/L_x \simeq 10^{-6}$.
Note that the two measurements are in two different outbursts, but the
outbursts peaks
of SS Cyg are quite regular (Wheatley et al. 2003).

This finding leads us to suggest that most of the radio emission in the
outburst
of SS Cyg comes from a magnetically newly formed corona, and not from jets
as
argued by K\"ording et al. (2008).
This does not mean that jets, or a collimated outflow, were not launched in
the outburst.
On the contrary, if the magnetic activity on the surface of accretion disks
is similar to stellar magnetic activity, then ejection of mass is expected
(e.g., de Gouveia Dal Pino  \& Lazarian  2005).
Soker (2007) suggested that jets are launched in a manner analogous
to stellar magnetic eruptions and coronal mass ejection.
We have elaborated on this idea in $\S 3$.
We do note that Fender et al. (1999) and Markoff et al. (2005) proposed that
the base of the jet and the corona are the same region. We are not in dispute
with their claim. We simply argue that processes similar to solar flares form
the corona and accelerate the jets (de Gouveia Dal Pino \& Lazarian 2005),
and that this magnetic activity is the source
of the radio emission in SS Cyg, rather than the already collimated outflow (jets).

The main assumption of the stellar-like magnetic activity is that local
heating occurs
in the regions of the disk close to the accreting object, in a manner
described by
Soker \& Regev (2003):
if the accretion rate is high enough
such that
radiative cooling occurs on a time scale longer than the expansion time
scale,
then the gas motion due to the local heating is mainly in the vertical
direction.
The critical mass accretion rate for WDs is
$\sim 10^{-8}-10^{-7} M_\odot {~\rm yr}^{-1}$ (Soker \& Lasota 2004).

The vertical motion can stretch magnetic field lines and amplify the
magnetic fields
(Soker 2007). Here we considered the $\alpha \Omega$ dynamo
(see also de Gouveia Dal Pino \& Lazarian 2005 who considered a turbulence dynamo).
Local velocities can be in all directions, not only vertical.
We assumed that such a motion can play the $\alpha$ role in the $\alpha
\Omega$
dynamo mechanism, and concluded that the time scale for the amplification of
the
magnetic field is very short compared with the rise time of the outburst.
It is very likely that the strong magnetic fields behave similarly to
stellar
magnetic fields (Laor \& Behar 2008).
We argued that these magnetic fields emit most of the radio emission observed
by K\"ording et al. (2008) in the eruption of SS Cyg.
The magnetic flares can also lunch jets, and might even be the main
mechanism for
lunching jets in variety of objects, from YSOs to massive BHs (Soker 2007).

\acknowledgements

This research was supported by the Asher Fund for Space
Research at the Technion, the Israel Science foundation, and a Smithsonian
short term visitor grant to Soker and NSF grant AST--0507637 and NASA grant
NNX08AJ61G to SDV.

High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena (astro-ph.HE); Solar and Stellar Astrophysics (astro-ph.SR)


Machine learning can guide experimental approaches for protein digestibility estimations

Abstract: Food protein digestibility and bioavailability are critical aspects in addressing human nutritional demands, particularly when seeking sustainable alternatives to animal-based proteins. In this study, we propose a machine learning approach to predict the true ileal digestibility coefficient of food items. The model makes use of a unique curated dataset that combines nutritional information from different foods with FASTA sequences of some of their protein families. We extracted the biochemical properties of the proteins and combined these properties with embeddings from a Transformer-based protein Language Model (pLM). In addition, we used SHAP to identify features that contribute most to the model prediction and provide interpretability. This first AI-based model for predicting food protein digestibility has an accuracy of 90% compared to existing experimental techniques. With this accuracy, our model can eliminate the need for lengthy in-vivo or in-vitro experiments, making the process of creating new foods faster, cheaper, and more ethical.

\section{Introduction}\label{sec1}

The increase in the world population and the need for more nutritious food will increase the demand for animal-based foods by nearly 70\%, particularly from ruminant meat \cite{world_bank_world_2007}. Closing this food gap will intensify the pressure on land usage and contribute to an increase in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions \cite{henchion_future_2017}.
Due to such environmental concerns, transitioning towards more sustainable diets and exploring alternative protein sources have been at the forefront of 21st century research \cite{nadathur_sustainable_2017}.

Although plant proteins have already been associated with lowering the risk of type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular diseases, hypertension, obesity, metabolic syndrome and all-cause mortality in prospective cohort studies \cite{yokoyama_vegetarian_2014,satija_plant-based_2016, dinu_vegetarian_2017,kim_plantbased_2019}, there is still a long way to go in terms of texture, flavor, and bioavailability.
A common concern among consumers is recognizing which foods are good protein sources and whether proteins from plants are of as good quality as those from animal-derived foods. The interaction between animal and plant proteins is being comprehensively investigated to develop balanced mixtures of animal and vegetable proteins. These studies involve determining and understanding protein structure-function relations, optimizing the use of the components of the product, improving the quality, reducing costs, and finding new protein applications.

Protein quality is defined by the essential amino acid composition of the protein, as well as the bioavailability and digestibility of its constituent amino acids. Over the last few decades, tremendous effort has been made to develop methodologies for measuring protein quality.
The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) currently advises evaluating protein quality in human diets using Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score (DIAAS) values, which are measured through human or pig ileal digesta \cite{fao_dietary_2013}. Unlike older methods such as Protein Digestibility Corrected Amino Acid Score (PDCAAS) values, DIAAS values are obtained by multiplying the digestibility of each essential AA by its concentration in the protein and then comparing the results to a scoring system \cite{rutherfurd_protein_2015}. This digestion process can also be simulated \textit{in-vitro}. In this case, the digestibility is measured by monitoring the amount of soluble proteins, changes in digesta pH (reflecting protein hydrolysis), or the level of increase in the nitrogen not incorporated in protein structures (i.e., nonprotein nitrogen) \cite{karlund_harnessing_2020}. Although \textit{in-vitro} analysis can be cheaper and easier than the methods to predict the outcome of \textit{in-vivo}
digestibility, the complexity of \textit{in-vivo} digestibility has not been realized fully in an \textit{in-vitro} model \cite{bohn_correlation_2018}. In addition, working with animals can be time consuming, costly and one could face ethical barriers.

Currently, an important goal for food manufacturers is to replicate the flavor profiles, texture, and bioavailability of a meat replacement. This approach has traditionally been quite repetitious, with hundreds of alternative protein source formulations eventually narrowed down to the most comparable profile. In this work, we aim to provide a solution to accelerate this process at a reduced cost through the use of an AI model for protein digestibility prediction.
Our contributions are as follows:
\begin{enumerate}
        \item \textbf{Dataset creation} We combine nutritional information such as dietary fiber content, fat, and vitamins of various foods with the FASTA sequences of their protein families. We use these sequences for a feature extraction step that aims to identify protein structural characteristics. The extracted structural features and the nutritional information formed the basis of our dataset used to predict the DIAAS value.  The feature vector for each food consists of their structural and nutritional characteristics, amino acid composition and some categorical variables related to the food type. To our knowledge, this is the first attempt to associate these disparate features and use them in a machine learning (ML) model.
    \item \textbf{Interpretability}
   We select the features with higher predictive power, and, consequently, facilitate the model's interpretability. Selecting these features enhanced the model's performance due to dimensionality reduction. Exploring model interpretability is an important step to guide new experiments and new food design processes, as it gives insight on how protein engineering can be used to change protein's structural information to increase a food's digestibility. Similarly, it can guide how we can add/remove salts, decrease dietary fiber content and manipulate the nutritional information to achieve higher bioavailability. In addition to that, we were able to confirm some important proved correlations between food nutrients and protein digestibility.
    \item \textbf{ML modeling} We developed an alternative ML-based approach to predict the DIAAS score that avoids \textit{in-vivo} and \textit{in-vitro} testing, is cost-effective, and fast. With a 90\% accuracy compared to experimental approaches, our model can be used to guide experimental approaches by testing new protein sources in a faster, cheaper, and ethical manner. Our ML model targets true ileal digestibility coefficient of each indispensable amino acid, which allows us to calculate DIAAS for each food item, considering the reference values.
\end{enumerate}

\section{Results}\label{sec2}
\subsection{Dataset curation}

To be able to train a model that can predict digestibility, it is necessary to obtain training data. To our knowledge, there was no public ground truth data available at this point, especially for DIAAS, as it has been proposed more recently. Thus, a complete database was developed for this analysis using the following original data:

\begin{itemize}
    \item First, a database containing ileal amino acid digestibility values for more than 180 food items along with the associated DIAAS values in cases where adequate information was reported to derive this score \cite{molly_muleya_ileal_2021} was used. This data was obtained from over 30 references presented in supplementary table \ref{references}. This feature is defined as our target variable.
    \item Nutritional information for foods such as fat, potassium and sodium content was obtained from data from the FoodData Central of the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) \cite{us_department_of_agriculture_usda_agricultural_research_service_nutrient_data_usda_nodate} and Food Data from the National Food Institute in the Technical University of Denmark \cite{FRIDA}. For each food item in the database, the features presented in supplementary tables \ref{table1} and \ref{table2} were also added.
    \item In order to capture additional protein features, the FASTA sequence of at least two of the most abundant proteins from different protein families of each food item were added to the dataset. Then, their physio-chemical and biochemical properties were generated using Protlearn \cite{dorfer_protlearn_nodate} and added to the database. These features are shown in section \ref{features_protlearn} of the Supplementary Material.
\end{itemize}

\subsection{Baseline models}

First, 12 baseline regressors were trained on all 1671 features of 189 food items. The R$^2$ values and RMSE of the 12 models is shown in section \ref{regressors} of the Supplementary Material. The 3 top-performing models were based on boosting and bagging techniques applied to decision trees: LightGBM, XGBoost and Random Forest. The target variable was defined as the true ileal digestibility coefficient of each indispensable amino acid, as further detailed in Methods. As reported in section \ref{regressors} of the Supplementary Material, we found that the Random Forest, XGBoost, and LightGBM models predicted the ileal digestibility coefficient with a validation $R^{2}$ of 0.83, 0.87, and 0.88 respectively.

\subsection{Feature selection and SHAP values}

The second step of many ML methods is the feature extraction, the aim of which is to get the most effective features from the obtained raw segment. This problem was approached as a feature selection or dimensionality reduction method, which is pervasive in all domains of application of machine learning and data mining. To understand the importance of the features in the model and provide some explainability, a sensitivity based method called SHAP \cite{guyon_advances_2017} was used for feature importance evaluation \cite{lundberg_unified_2017} (see Methods).
First, we determined the importance of the features using SHAP. Then, we used Principal Component Analysis \cite{noauthor_principal_2002} and determined that the top 20 features explained above 95\% of the model variance. Therefore, we selected these features for our model, as shown in figure \ref{fig2}. The color represents the feature value, where red indicates high and blue indicates low. It is noticeable that some of the SHAP-selected features presented as important are known in the literature for their direct effect on digestibility. For instance, Mongeau \cite{mongeau_relationship_1989} shows that the true protein digestibility in rats was negatively correlated with the total food fiber level. Likewise, the type of limiting amino acid is directly associated with the true ileal digestibility of that amino acid. Salts like magnesium and manganese are also associated with a lower rate of protein digestibility, disrupting the enzymatic process \cite{kaspchak_effect_2019,geboes_magnesium_2002}.

\begin{figure}[h!]
  \includegraphics[width=\linewidth]{figs/shap_lgbm.jpg}
  \caption{The local explanation summary of the model represents a set of beeswarm
plots, where each dot corresponds to an individual sample in the study. The dot’s position on the x axis shows the impact that feature has on the model’s
prediction for that person. When multiple dots land at the same x position, they pile up to show density.}
  \label{fig2}
\end{figure}

Protein digestibility is also found to be positively correlated with surface hydrophobicity of proteins through a study on heat-induced protein unfolding \cite{tang_heat-induced_2022}. Hydrophobic groups are normally buried within protein structure. However, the unfolding of proteins exposes hydrophobic residues to the surface, increasing overall surface hydrophobicity and providing easier access for digestive enzymes to hydrolyze the protein \cite{tang_heat-induced_2022}.  Our model found other features associated with surface hydrophobicity, such as hydration number and linker propensity, to also confirm this correlation. For example, the hydration number indicates how likely a water molecule is to bind to a solute as compared to other water molecules \cite{zavitsas_opinions_2016}, implying that the hydration number is inversely linked to hydrophobicity and therefore to protein digestibility too \cite{sagawa_are_2014}. Similarly, linker propensity, or a tendency of a protein to have high numbers of linkers, can be linked to hydrophilicity since preferred linker amino acids have been established to be mostly hydrophilic \cite{sagawa_are_2014}.

Several minerals have also been shown to impact digestibility in accordance with our Shapley value results. For instance, Pallauf and Kirchgessner demonstrate that zinc deficiency has a negative effect on nutrient digestibility in weaned male rats \cite{pallauf_einflus_1976}. Salts containing potassium, such as Potassium thiocyanate, were shown to be trypsin inhibitors, which are in turn known to reduce the digestion and absorption of dietary proteins \cite{shikimi_modes_1979} \cite{aviles-gaxiola_inactivation_2018}. Additionally, specific amino acids have been established as having an impact on protein digestibility. Amino acids such as lysine and histidine have been demonstrated to have a positive impact on food intake and metabolism \cite{baruffol_l-lysine_2014} \cite{moro_histidine_2020}. For example, L-lysine delayed intestinal transit in rats \cite{baruffol_l-lysine_2014}, potentially increasing ileal protein absorption by increasing the time the protein resided in the small intestine \cite{zhao_protein_1996}. Other amino acids, such as Tryptophan and phenylalanine, have been shown to modulate gut microbiota and the secretion of digestive enzymes \cite{taleb_tryptophan_2019} \cite{guo_phenylalanine_2018}, likely increasing the amount of protein absorption.

\subsection{Protein embeddings from language model}

It is known that protein structure helps in understanding function. To be able to understand how the structure of proteins modify the digestibility of proteins, we used a language model approach. Here, we assume that the protein sequence is a series of tokens, or characters, such as a text corpus. Protein sequences are inherently similar to natural languages: amino acids arrange in a multitude of combinations to form structures that carry function, the same way as letters form words and sentences, which carry meaning
\cite{ferruz_controllable_2022}.

To make the model more robust, we extracted embeddings from the protein sequences using ProtTrans, a language model trained with UniRef50 and BFD100 \cite{elnaggar_prottrans_2022} and added these embeddings to the final dataset. The final architecture of our method is shown in figure \ref{fig1}.

\begin{figure}
  \includegraphics[scale=0.9]{figs/final_arc.png}
  \caption{Final architecture of the proposed method. For each food item, nutritional information, amino acid composition and protein sequences of at least two families are required. The algorithm includes two feature extraction steps: biochemical information is extracted using Protlearn \cite{dorfer_protlearn_nodate} and embeddings are extracted using ProtT5 \cite{elnaggar_prottrans_2022}. The baseline regressors are trained and two feature selection approaches are compared: feature importance from LGBM and SHAP \cite{guyon_advances_2017}. The true ileal digestibility for each indispensible amino acid and food item is predicted and the DIAAS value is calculated for three different categories: infants, children and adults.}
  \label{fig1}
\end{figure}

\subsection{Model results}
When creating this unique machine learning model, we used several concepts that contribute to the overall model performance. In the ablation study, we try to identify the influence of each of these innovations separately. Details of the ablation study can be found on section \ref{ablation} of the Supplementary Material.

The results of the ablation study are shown in table \ref{tab3}, which shows the R$^2$ of each model. We see that the SHAP method performed better than solely using feature importance from the LGBM model. Additionally, adding the ProtTrans embeddings also increases the model's R$^2$. The R$^2$ of the final model is shown in figure \ref{figR}. The sensitivity analysis done for each group of variables is also shown in section \ref{sensitivity} of the Supplementary Material.

\begin{table}[h!]
\centering
{%
\begin{tabular}{|l|l|l|}
\hline
\textbf{Model} & \textbf{Description} & \textbf{R²} \\ \hline
Model A & Baseline LGBM &   0.87730 \\ \hline
Model B & \begin{tabular}[c]{@{}l@{}}After LGBM feature importance selection\end{tabular} & 0.89256  \\ \hline
Model C & \begin{tabular}[c]{@{}l@{}}After LGBM feature importance selection\\ + transformer embeddings\end{tabular} &  0.90003 \\ \hline
Model D & After SHAP selection &   0.89901 \\ \hline
Model E & \begin{tabular}[c]{@{}l@{}}After SHAP selection \\ + transformer embeddings\end{tabular} &   0.90165 \\ \hline
\end{tabular}%
}
\caption{R$^2$ of the models trained on the ablation study.}
\label{tab3}
\end{table}

\begin{figure}[h!]
\centering
  \includegraphics[scale=1.3]{figs/r_squared.png}
  \caption{The R$^2$ of the model can be visually represented by the trend analysis of the ground truth data plotted against the predicted values. For each data point the values should be similar. Besides a few outliers, both ground truth and predicted distributions are similar.}
  \label{figR}
\end{figure}

\pagebreak

\pagebreak
\section{Discussion}\label{sec4}
We propose an approach that allows us to predict the true ileal digestibility coefficient for each indispensable amino acid in a food, a value normally determined experimentally using \textit{in-vivo} or \textit{in-vitro} methods. Our data-science based method enabled us to estimate this value with 90\% R$^2$ accuracy. Not only is our proposed method novel in approximating the ileal digestibility coefficient of foods, as it is solely computational, but is also able to capture established relationships through its features and model output. Additionally, there are many potential downstream applications of our approach.

For instance, the approach itself can help accelerate the production of alternative protein products. Food scientists can use this approach to evaluate a large number of promising target proteins computationally and decrease the size of their experimental matrices. This methodology can also help predicting DIAAS for complex food matrices or for scenarios where \textit{in-vivo} and \textit{in-vitro} options cannot be used. In addition to the potential to streamline experimentation, our methodology's interpretability could incite scientists to propose new scientific experiments to better understand how protein structure is related to digestibility. We were able to capture some of these structure-activity relationships using the 20 most important features generated by Shapley value analysis. Our model's interpretability could guide \textit{in-vivo} experiments to better identify the direct relationship of these other variables with digestibility, reducing the array of possible experimental combinations when investigating these relationships. As new primary data is collected and becomes available, it is important perform regular re-trainings on our model to improve its explanatory power.

This highlights one of the fundamental challenges of our approach and the basis for our future research: the size of our curated dataset. As more data becomes available, we can retrain the model to capture less frequent patterns that are specific to local contexts, foods, and proteins. ML techniques often do not make assumptions on the exact functional form of the model and attempt to learn the model form directly from the data, such that it maximizes prediction accuracy. To do so, they take into account linear and non-linear correlations between the data, but do not take into account cause and effect relationships. In this situation, this means that the model learns patterns in the data based on the most commonly observed relationships across protein families. Therefore, with a  dataset with items ranging from processed foods to raw foods and meat analogues to animal products, more variability would be added and a generalizable model can be obtained.

Much of the ground truth data used in this study was experimentally determined using the grown pig model, which is a valid animal model for this purpose \cite{moughan_piglet_1992, deglaire_animal_2012}. However, it has been established that food particle size impacts ileal digestibility values in pigs, with a decrease in particle size increasing apparent ileal digestibility \cite{flis_effect_2014}. This might introduce variance into the model, as the ileal digestibility values in our dataset were obtained from different experiments; there is likely limited consistency in food particle size across these experiments.

Another avenue for future research is to add features related to food processing.
For instance, it is known that heat treatments applied to food can alter AA digestibility and bioavailability levels when compared to the same, untreated food \cite{hodgkinson_determination_2020,rutherfurd_application_1997,almeida_amino_2013,sa_food_2020}. Other values which we have not featurized are antinutritional factors, whose presence are known to decrease protein digestibility. For instance, tannins or polyphenols produce denaturation of proteins, and protease inhibitors can inhibit trypsin, pepsin, and other proteases in the gut, preventing digestion and absorption of proteins and amino acids. The dataset also fails to consider farming practices, which also affect the protein content of plants and livestock. For example, fertilization regimes can promote nutrients transfer to grains and changes in protein content \cite{preet_antinutrients_2000,yan_quantifying_2022}. Animal husbandry and nutrition also impact growth, productivity and protein content of animal products \cite{zhang_effect_2019,coulon_variations_1991,tyasi_assessing_2015}.

Overall, our model could be enriched with features that represent a food's structural information, antinutrients, processing, and the farming practices employed when it was growing. However, obtaining these data for a large number of food items is challenging. This demonstrates the strong need for a unified database that contains such information, more experiments to create ground truth values, and the need to iterate over our existing methodology to make it more robust once new data becomes available. In the meantime, using this purely computational, ethical, and affordable model can enable scientists to reduce the size of their experimental food matrices during protein digestibility experiments, especially in the development of new foods.

\section{Methods} \label{methods}

\subsection{Dataset creation details}

The final dataset obtained was created using the original 300 food items present on Muleya and Salter dataset \cite{molly_muleya_ileal_2021}. In cases where digestibility information was missing for some amino acids, an average value based on the reported amino acid data was assigned - average values are indicated in the dataset.
Total amino acid and protein composition was obtained from the same source. Values were expressed in g/kg and recalculation was done in cases where the units reported in the reference were different. Digestible indispensable amino acids were calculated by multiplying the digestibility coefficient with the corresponding indispensable amino acid composition expressed in g/kg. Finally, digestible indispensable amino acids were expressed as mg/g protein by dividing the digestible indispensable amino acid composition with the total protein and converting to mg. DIAAS values were calculated for all age groups using the FAO recommended reference patterns. DIAAS values for some foods are missing due to insufficient information being reported in some cases.

The nutritional information for foods was obtained from the FoodData Central of the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) \cite{us_department_of_agriculture_usda_agricultural_research_service_nutrient_data_usda_nodate}. FoodData Central is an integrated data system that provides expanded nutrient profile data and links to related agricultural and experimental research. For each food item in the database, the features presented in tables \ref{table1} and \ref{table2} were added.

In order to capture additional protein features, their physio-chemical and biochemical properties were added to the database.
For this, the amino acid FASTA sequence for each protein was first collected from UniProt \cite{bateman_uniprot_2021} or from the NCBI \cite{ncbi_national_nodate} protein database. For this, we selected up to three protein families of the food items, such as albumins, caseins and globulins, when present and Protlearn v2.1 \cite{dorfer_protlearn_nodate} was then used to extract the features from the FASTA sequences. This led to a total of 1671 features that were added to the database for each protein. All features obtained from Protlearn are present in section \ref{features_protlearn} of the Supplementary Material.

Finally, the language model was used to obtain the embeddings of each protein family. The cleaned dataset was composed of almost 200 food items.

\subsection{Baseline modeling approach}
First, baseline regressors on all 1671 features of 189 food items were trained. The first 3 top-performing models were based on boosting and bagging techniques of decision trees. These models are also able to deal with high-dimensional data that may contain non-linear effects and many interactions between covariates, and can be used to rank the most important predictors to gain insight into the resulting prediction model. Hyperparameters of these three models were optimized using a combination of a randomized grid search technique and manual tuning using stratified 5-fold cross-validation on the training set. Using the optimized tree-based models, the validation R$^{2}$ accuracy was calculated on a held-out test set.

\subsection{SHAP}

Interpretability of models in AI is central to the practical impact of AI on society. Thus it can be treated as a problem of attribution. Shapley values \cite{kuhn_17_1953} provide the unique attribution method satisfying a set of intuitive axioms, e.g. they capture all interactions between features and sum to the model prediction. Given our baseline predictive model, SHAP yields a vector of importance scores associated with the underlying features. The Shapley value was first introduced as an axiomatic characterisation of a fair distribution of a total surplus from all players, and it may be used in predictive models where each feature is treated as a participant in the underlying game. While the Shapley value technique is conceptually appealing, it is also computationally demanding: in general, each Shapley value assessment demands an exponential number of model evaluations.

Classic Shapley values calculated through SHAP can be considered optimal since, within a large class of approaches, they are the only way to measure feature importance while maintaining several natural properties from cooperative game theory \cite{lundberg_local_2020}. Shapley also observes the value as an index for assessing the power of participants in a game, in addition to a model that seeks to predict the distribution of resources in multi-feature interactions. The value, like a price index or other market indices, aggregates the strength of actors in their numerous cooperation opportunities using averages (or weighted averages in certain extensions). The Shapley value may also be thought of as a measure of the utility of players/features in a game/model. Several studies have used Shapley values and SHAP package to improve the
interpretability of tree-based models \cite{lundberg_local_2020,lundberg_explainable_2018}.

\subsection{ProtTrans}

The goal of language modelling is to estimate the probability distribution of various linguistic units, e.g., words, sentences. After training the language model (LM), we can extract some information learned by the LMs, referred to as embeddings. This process indicates that when a language model better understands the sequence, it also better understands the structure.

Protein Language Models (pLMs) copy the concepts of Language Models from NLP by using tokens (words in NLP), i.e., amino acids from protein sequences, and treating entire proteins
like sentences in LMs. In step 1, these pLMs are trained in a self-supervised manner, essentially learning to predict masked amino acids (tokens) in already known sequences.

ProtTrans \cite{elnaggar_prottrans_2022} is a 3B-parameter model that has an encoder and decoder architecture and allows us to extract 1024 embeddings for each protein sequence using the 1B-parameter encoder. Thus, 1024 embeddings were generated for each of the three protein families of each food item.

\backmatter

\bibliographystyle{naturemag}

Quantitative Methods (q-bio.QM); Machine Learning (cs.LG)