High Redshift HI 21cm Absorption toward Red Quasars

Abstract: We have searched for redshifted absorption in the 21 cm line of neutral hydrogen toward `red quasars', which are extragalactic radio sources with a steep spectral drop between optical and infrared wavelengths. The success rate for detecting HI 21cm absorption toward a representative sample of such sources is 80%. This compares to the much lower success rate of 11% for detecting HI 21cm absorption associated with optically selected Mg II absorption line systems. The large neutral hydrogen column densities seen toward red quasars supports the hypothesis that these sources are reddened by dust, as opposed to having an intrinsically red spectrum due to the AGN emission mechanism. The lower limits to the spin temperatures for the neutral hydrogen are between 50 K and 1000 K, assuming a Galactic dust-to-gas ratio. We consider the question of biases in optically selected samples of quasars due to dust obscuration. The data on the red quasar sub-sample support the models of Fall and Pei for dust obscuration by damped Ly alpha absorption line systems, and suggest that: (i) there may be a significant, but not dominant, population of quasars missing from optically selected samples due to dust obscuration, perhaps as high as 20% at the POSS limit for an optical sample with a redshift distribution similar to the 1 Jy, flat spectrum quasar sample, and (ii) optically selected samples may miss about half the high column density quasar absorption line systems.

\section{Introduction}

Quasar absorption line systems provide a distance-independent means of
studying baryonic matter cosmologically distributed throughout the
universe. The neutral hydrogen column density distribution
function for these systems  can be characterized roughly by a single
power-law between  10$^{13}$ cm$^{-2}$ and 10$^{22}$
cm$^{-2}$, with an index of
$-$1.5. (Tytler 1987).
The implication is that absorption line systems with neutral
hydrogen column  densities greater than 10$^{21}$ cm$^{-2}$ are
very rare:  for every 1000 absorption line systems with
N(HI) $<$ 10$^{14}$ cm$^{-2}$ there is one system with N(HI) $>$
10$^{21}$ cm$^{-2}$.
Although the  highest column density systems are
rare, study of these systems is critical to our understanding of the
high redshift universe for a number of reasons, including:

\begin{itemize}

\item  Most of the neutral baryonic material at high redshift
may reside in the highest column density systems (Lanzetta et al. 1995).

\item The very high column  systems are thought to be absorption by
gas associated with  the pre-cursors of present day disk galaxies
(Wolfe et al. 1986).

\item Obscuration by dust associated with the high column density
systems may affect the observed statistics of quasar populations at high
redshifts, and perhaps more significantly, the observed statistics of the
cosmic evolution of the neutral baryon density (Fall \&\ Pei 1995).

\item Perhaps most importantly in the cases of  radio loud
background sources, the high column density systems
allow studies of the HI 21cm line in
absorption, and in the more extreme cases, of associated molecular
absorption at high redshift.

\end{itemize}

Spectroscopic imaging at radio wavelengths
of  molecular and HI 21cm absorption line systems
opens a new window into the physics of these systems, including
detailed studies of astrochemistry at high redshift, and new methods
for determining basic
cosmological parameters such as the evolution of the temperature of
the microwave background radiation and the deuterium abundance.
These systems probe the dense, pre-star-forming
interstellar medium (ISM) in galaxies at substantial look-back
times. Background radio continuum sources typically show spatial
structure on scales ranging from parsecs to kilo-parsecs. Radio
interferometers  allow for direct spectroscopic imaging of the spatial
structure in the absorbing  gas over this entire range of spatial scales.
Also, radio spectroscopy allows for study of the velocity structure in
the absorption lines down to 10 m s$^{-1}$.

\section{Red Quasars}

Over the last few years we have developed an effective  technique for
discovering very high column density quasar absorption line systems by
searching for redshifted HI 21cm absorption toward
flat spectrum radio sources with faint, red optical
counterparts. The physical basis for selecting these `red quasars' for
radio absorption  searches is the hypothesis that these sources are
red due to dust obscuration. Dust obscuration leads to a natural bias
against finding the highest column density absorbers using optical
techniques in two ways: (i) sources may drop out of optical magnitude
limited samples due to dust obscuration, and (ii) follow-up
optical spectroscopy typically requires fairly bright, blue objects
(Heisler \&\ Ostriker 1988,
Fall \&\ Pei 1993, Webster et al. 1995, Shaver et al. 1996).
Hence, radio spectroscopy may provide the {\sl only method} for
studying the very highest column density quasar absorption line
systems, as has long been the case for studies of the early stages of
star formation in Galactic dark molecular clouds.

In this paper we present a summary of recent detections of
redshifted neutral hydrogen 21cm absorption toward red quasars
using the new UHF system at the Westerbork Synthesis Radio
Telescope (WSRT), and the NRAO 140ft telescope in Green Bank WV
(see Carilli et al. 1997, 1998). These observations are intended to
address a number of issues. First, we want to address the
question whether some AGNs have intrinsically red,
rather than dust-reddened, spectra.
Second is the question of the fraction of quasars missing from optical
samples due to dust obscuration, as well as the fraction of missing
high column density quasar absorption line systems.
Third, we wish to enlarge the
sample of dusty, high column density absorption line systems
in order to study the dense ISM in
galaxies at significant look-back times.
An earlier review of redshifted HI 21cm absorption line systems can be
found in Carilli (1995). More recent results using the new UHF
system at the WSRT can be found in Vermeulen et al. and Lane et al.
(this volume).

The resulting sample of very high column density absorption line
systems detected in the radio  via HI 21cm absorption and/or molecular
absorption, falls into two classes: (i) associated absorbers,
ie. absorption by gas
in the host galaxy of the quasar, and (ii) cosmologically intervening
absorbers. For the associated absorbers the gas can be either
`circumnuclear material' directly associated with the active galactic
nucleus (AGN), or gas in the general ISM of the AGN host galaxy. For the
cosmologically intervening systems the interesting trend has arisen
that  many of these systems are gravitational lenses. In retrospect
the association
of lensing with very high column density absorbers may not be surprising,
since high column density absorption requires a
fairly small impact parameter on the intervening galaxy. The surprise
has been that many gravitational lenses are gas rich systems, as
opposed to the original naive hypothesis that most lenses would be
gas poor elliptical galaxies.

Parameters for the radio continuum sources, and for Gaussian models
fit to  the HI absorption lines, are given in Table 1.  The reference
redshift corresponding to zero velocity is given in each figure, and in
the table, as z$_0$.

\section{Individual Sources}

\subsection{0108+388}

The radio source 0108+388 is located at the center of a narrow emission
line galaxy at z = 0.670  (Stickel et al. 1996a,
Stanghellini et al. 1993). The radio source shows
twin-jets on 3 mas scales, plus extended structure on large scales (Taylor,
Readhead, \&\ Pearson 1996).
This source also shows an inverted spectrum at low frequency, perhaps
indicating free-free absorption. Optical images of the field show a
very red, `slightly asymmetric' galaxy, perhaps a face-on
spiral (Stanghellini et al. 1993).
The lack of a point source in R band images, and the presence of
a compact I band source, have led Stanghellini et al. (1993)
to propose `the existence of nuclear obscuration' toward 0108+388.

A strong HI 21cm absorption line is detected at z = 0.66847
with a width of 100 km  s$^{-1}$ and a peak optical depth of
0.44 (Carilli et al. 1998).
The integrated HI column density for this system
is 81$\times$10$^{18}$$\times({{T_s}\over{f}})$ cm$^{-2}$,
where T$_s$ is the spin
temperature of the gas and $f$ is the HI covering factor (Figure 1).
Using the VLBI structure of the radio source, and the high opacity of
the HI line,  Carilli et al. (1998) estimate a
lower limit to the absorbing cloud size of
about 6 mas, or 36 pc (H$_o$ = 65 km s$^{-1}$ Mpc$^{-1}$ and q$_o$
= 0.5).

The  velocity width for the HI 21cm absorption line toward
0108+388 is comparable to  linewidths
seen for systems associated with nearby Seyfert
galaxies and other low redshift AGN (Pedlar et al., this volume;
Conway, this volume). High resolution imaging of the
absorption toward a number of nearby AGN indicates that
the high velocity dispersion gas is local to the AGN, perhaps
in a circumnuclear torus or ring with size of order 10 pc,  and
that the velocity width reflects the torus dynamics (Pedlar et al.,
and Conway this volume).

\begin{figure}
\psfig{figure=carillif1.ps,width=12cm}
\caption{Spectra of redshifted HI 21cm absorption toward three red
quasars. These three systems are likely to be absorption by
gas associated with the host galaxy of the AGN.
The sources and redshifts are listed in each frame. The
redshifts  listed correspond to zero velocity.
The parameters for the radio source and the
Gaussian model fit, are given in Table 1.}
\end{figure}

\subsection{0218+357}

The radio source 0218+357 is the `smallest Einstein ring', with a
radio ring with diameter of $0{\rlap.}{''}37$ plus two  point sources, one at
the center of the ring and the second on the ring. Differential
reddening in the optical toward the two compact sources has led to the
hypothesis of a dusty gravitational lens (O'Dea et al. 1992, Patnaik
et al. 1993). HI 21cm absorption has been detected toward 0218+357
by the lensing galaxy at z = 0.6847 (Carilli, Rupen, \&\ Yanny 1993),
with N(HI) = 3$\times$10$^{18}$$\times({{T_s}\over{f}})$ cm$^{-2}$
(Figure 2). Subsequent imaging spectroscopy has
revealed molecular absorption at z = 0.6847 toward  the redder of the two
compact radio components (Wiklind \&\ Combes 1995 and this volume; Menten \&\
Reid 1996). Lens models predict a velocity dispersion for the lensing
galaxy  of 100 km s$^{-1}$, suggesting lensing by the bulge of a
spiral  galaxy. The HI 21cm line has a FWHM = 43 km s$^{-1}$,
suggesting that the disk of the lensing galaxy may be fairly close to
the sky plane (Carilli et al. 1993).

\subsection{0414+055}

The radio source 0414+055 is an `Einstein quad' with a
maximum component separation of 1$''$.
Optical and near IR imaging by
Lawrence et al. (1995) indicates that the
optical components are
heavily reddened by dust. The source redshift is 2.636.
The redshift of the lens remains unknown. Moore, Carilli, \&\
Menten (1999) have detected HI 21cm absorption at z = 2.636 toward
0414+055 with N(HI) = 7.5$\times$10$^{18}$$\times({{T_s}\over{f}})$
cm$^{-2}$ (Figure 3). The large velocity dispersion
of this gas (FWHM $\approx$ 300 km s$^{-1}$) suggests absorption by
circumnuclear material. The observed HI 21cm absorption
implies that much of the reddening  is by gas in the AGN host
galaxy. However, differential colors for the optical components may
require additional reddening by dust in the lens (McLeod et al. 1998).

\subsection{0500+019}

The radio source 0500+019 is unresolved at cm wavelengths at resolutions
ranging from a few mas to
a few arcseconds (Taylor \&\ Perley 1996).
A 2.2 $\mu$m image of this source reveals a point source
with faint emission extending 3$''$ to the south, while an R band image shows
an inclined  disk galaxy with a major axis of about 4$''$ (Stickel et
al. 1996b).   There is no evidence for a point source in the R band image,
although the galaxy brightness profile is asymmetric, peaking about
1$''$ to the north of center along the major axis of the galaxy,
coincident within the errors with the position of the K band point source.
The galaxy redshift is  z = 0.5834$\pm$0.0014, but there is
a narrow emission line at 0.6354 $\mu$m
which cannot be reasonably identified with the galaxy (Stickel et al. 1996b).
This unidentified emission line, the off-center
location of the 2.2 $\mu$m point source relative to the galaxy center,
and the asymmetric galaxy profile in the R band image, lead Stickel et
al. to suggest that the quasar may be a background source at z $>$ 0.5834,
and that the red color of the quasar is due to dust in the foreground
galaxy.

HI 21cm absorption has been detected toward 0500+019 at z = 0.58472,
with N(HI) = 7$\times$10$^{18}$$\times({{T_s}\over{f}})$ cm$^{-2}$
(Carilli et al. 1998). The observed spectrum is fit reasonably
well by two Gaussians (Figure
3). The total HI linewidth is about 140 km s$^{-1}$. This
broad profile toward 0500+019 could be used to
argue for absorption by circumnuclear material.
However, there are the additional puzzles that
the HI redshift is offset from the optical redshift by  240
km s$^{-1}$, plus the offset between the K band point source and the
galaxy center and the unidentified optical emission line.
A possible model to explain all these data is that the quasar is a
background source which projects off-center from the z = 0.5834 galaxy.
The large velocity offset of the HI line relative to the
galaxy, and the large velocity dispersion, would then be
explained by galactic rotation. For instance, assuming  a  galaxy
rotation velocity of 200 km sec$^{-1}$, and the fact that
the line-of-sight to the quasar cut through the edge-on disk halfway out
along the major axis, the expected linewidth due to differential
rotation would be about 100 km s$^{-1}$.

\subsection{1413+135}

The flat spectrum radio source 1413+135 is located at the center of
an edge on spiral galaxy at z = 0.247 (Perlman et al. 1996), and the
radio AGN is situated behind the galaxy's dust lane (McHardy et
al. 1994).  Carilli, Perlman, \&\ Stocke (1992) have detected HI 21cm
absorption at z = 0.247 with
N(HI) = 17$\times$10$^{18}$$\times({{T_s}\over{f}})$
cm$^{-2}$ (Figure 1). The HI 21cm absorption line is fairly narrow
(FWHM $\approx$ 20 km s$^{-1}$), and very narrow molecular absorption
(FWHM $\approx$ 1 km s$^{-1}$) has been detected at the redshift of
the HI line (Wiklind \&\ Combes 1994 and this volume). The narrow velocity
width of the absorption toward 1413+135 suggests
that it does not occur in circumnuclear gas, but in the general
ISM of the AGN host galaxy. Perlman et al. propose that 1413+135 is a
young radio loud AGN (age $\le$ 10$^4$ years) behind a giant molecular
cloud in the disk of the host galaxy.

\begin{figure}
\psfig{figure=carillif2.ps,width=12cm}
\caption{Spectra of redshifted HI 21cm absorption toward the Einstein
ring radio sources 1830-211 and 0218+357. The
redshifts  listed correspond to zero velocity.
These systems are due to cosmologically intervening gas.
The parameters for the Gaussian model fit, and the source continuum
flux densities, are given in Table 1.
Note that the spectrum of 1830-211  is corrupted
by terrestrial interference velocity = +100 km s$^{-1}$ in this
spectrum. A second peak in HI
21cm absorption has been detected at this velocity  (see Chengalur, de
Bruyn, \&\ Narasimha, this volume).
}
\end{figure}

\subsection{1504+377}

The flat spectrum radio source 1504+377
is located at the center of an inclined disk
galaxy with a moderate-excitation narrow emission line spectrum at z =
0.674$\pm$0.001.
The source shows evidence for flaring of its  near IR intensity,
although optical images of 1504+377  show no indication of a bright AGN
(Stickel et al. 1996a).
Radio spectroscopic observations of 1504+377 have revealed
strong HI 21cm absorption (Figure 1), and absorption by a number of
molecular species, at the redshift of the parent galaxy (Wiklind \&\
Combes 1996a, Carilli et al. 1998). The HI profile is
reasonably fit by three Gaussians, with  a total N(HI) =
45$\times$10$^{18}$$\times({{T_s}\over{f}})$ cm$^{-2}$.
The broad absorption line in
this case again argues for absorption by circumnuclear material
(Wiklind \&\ Combes 1996a, Carilli et al. 1997, 1998).

The molecular absorption toward 1504+377 also shows a narrow feature
at z = 0.67150 (linewidth $\le$ 10 km s$^{-1}$), or 330 km s$^{-1}$ relative to
the broad line. No HI 21cm absorption is detected at
the redshift of this narrow molecular feature. This and
the velocity difference between the broad and narrow absorption
components in 1504+377 is discussed by Carilli et al. (1997, 1998).

\subsection{1830-211}

The radio source 1830$-$211 is the `brightest Einstein ring', with a
ring of 1$''$ diameter and two point sources located on opposite sides
of the ring. The source remains unidentified in the optical, but there
is a possible detection in the near IR (Frye et al. this
volume). Strong molecular and HI 21cm absorption has been detected toward
1830$-$211 at z = 0.886 (Wiklind \&\ Combes 1996b and this volume; Frye
et al. 1997 and this volume; Menten, Carilli, \&\ Reid, this volume;
Chengalur et al., this volume). The HI 21cm
absorption is broad, with two components separated by 146 km
s$^{-1}$. Spectroscopic imaging of the molecular absorption
shows strong absorption toward the SW radio component at z = 0.88582,
and weaker absorption toward the NE component at $-$146 km s$^{-1}$
relative to the strong lines. This velocity separation is consistent
with the dynamics for the lensing galaxy predicted by lens models
(Wiklind \&\ Combes 1998 and this volume; Menten et al. this volume).

A second HI 21cm absorption system has been discovered toward
1830$-$211 at z = 0.1926 with N(HI) =
1.2$\times$10$^{18}$$\times({{T_s}\over{f}})$ cm$^{-2}$.
No molecular absorption has been detected at this redshift (Wiklind
\&\ Combes this volume). This second absorption component complicates
the lens models for 1830$-$211, implying that this source is a
compound gravitational lens (Lovell et al. 1997).

\begin{figure}
\psfig{figure=carillif3.ps,width=12cm}
\caption{Spectra of redshifted HI 21cm absorption toward the `Einstein
Quad'  radio source 0414+055, and toward 0500+019. The
redshifts  listed correspond to zero velocity.
The absorption toward 0414+055 is by gas associated with the AGN.
For 0500+019 it is unclear whether the gas is associated with the AGN, or
cosmologically intervening. Note the different velocity scales for
the two frames.
The parameters for the Gaussian model fit, and the source continuum
flux densities, are given in Table 1.}
\end{figure}

\begin{table}
\begin{center}
Table 1. ~~Gaussian Model Parameters

\scriptsize
\begin{tabular}{cccrcrrc}
\tableline
\tableline
\noalign{\vskip 0.07in}
~ & S$_\nu$ & z$_{0}$ & Velocity & Int. Opt. Depth & Opt. Depth & FWHM
& N(HI) \\
\tableline
\noalign{\vskip 0.07in}
~ & Jy & ~ & km s$^{-1}$ &  km s$^{-1}$ & ~ & km s$^{-1}$ &
$\times$${T_s}\over{f}$10$^{18}$cm$^{-2}$ \\
\tableline
\noalign{\vskip 0.07in}
0108+388 & 0.18 & 0.66847 & 0$\pm$4 & 46$\pm$7 & 0.44$\pm$0.04
& 94$\pm$10 & 81$\pm$12 \\
\tableline
\noalign{\vskip 0.07in}
0218+357 & 1.8 & 0.68466 & $-$13$\pm$7 & 1.7$\pm$0.3 &
0.034$\pm$0.005 &  45$\pm$4 & 3.0$\pm$0.5 \\
\tableline
\noalign{\vskip 0.07in}
0414+055 & 3.3 & 2.63647 & 93$\pm$12  & 1.6$\pm$0.4 & 0.011$\pm$0.001 &
140$\pm$33 & 3.0$\pm$0.8 \\
0414+055 & ~ & ~ & $-$94$\pm$12 & 2.4$\pm$0.5 & 0.015$\pm$0.001 &
154$\pm$28 & 4.5$\pm$0.9 \\
\tableline
\noalign{\vskip 0.07in}
0500+019 & 1.6 & 0.58457 & 43$\pm$3 & 2.5$\pm$0.3 & 0.036$\pm$0.003
& 62$\pm$7 & 4.5$\pm$0.5 \\
0500+019 & ~ & ~ & $-$27$\pm$5 & 1.4$\pm$0.3
& 0.027$\pm$0.003 & 45$\pm$9  & 2.5$\pm$0.4 \\
\tableline
\noalign{\vskip 0.07in}
1413+135 & 1.1 & 0.24671 & 0$\pm$2 & 9.6$\pm$0.6 & 0.41$\pm$0.02 &
21$\pm$1 &  17$\pm$1 \\
\tableline
\noalign{\vskip 0.07in}
1504+377 & 1.0 & 0.67150 & 325$\pm$19 & 7.0$\pm$4.3 &
0.073$\pm$0.045 & 85$\pm$22 & 12.8$\pm$8  \\
1504+377 & ~ & ~ & 313$\pm$1 & 4.0$\pm$0.6 & 0.22$\pm$0.03
& 16$\pm$2  & 7.3$\pm$1 \\
1504+377 & ~ & ~ & 347$\pm$1 & 13.4$\pm$4 & 0.34$\pm$0.08
& 34$\pm$5 & 24$\pm$7 \\
\tableline
\noalign{\vskip 0.07in}
1830$-$211 & 11 & 0.88536 & $-$141$\pm$3 & 5.8$\pm$0.4 & 0.041$\pm$0.002 &
127$\pm$6 & 10.1$\pm$0.7 \\
1830$-$211 & 12 & 0.19260 & $-$28$\pm$2 & 0.28$\pm$0.05 & 0.009$\pm$0.001 &
30$\pm$5 &  0.53$\pm$0.1 \\
1830$-$211 & 12 & 0.19260 & 15$\pm$2 & 0.36$\pm$0.05 & 0.010$\pm$0.001 &
35$\pm$5 &  0.68$\pm$0.1 \\
\tableline
\end{tabular}
\end{center}
\end{table}

\section{Discussion}
\subsection{The Statistics of Red Quasars}

We  have searched for HI 21cm absorption
toward  a representative sub-sample of five red quasars from the
complete sample of Stickel et al. (1996a).
(Note that 1830$-$211,
1413$-$135, and 0414+055 are not in the Stickel et al.  red quasar
sub-sample due to various selection criteria.)
We have detected high column density
absorption systems in four of five sources (Carilli et al. 1998).
This 80$\%$ detection rate is significantly
higher than in optically selected samples:
searches for HI 21cm absorption associated with optically
selected MgII absorption line systems result in two detections out
of 18 systems  (Lane et al. this volume).

The average value of the radio-to-optical spectral index,
$\alpha_{rad}^{opt}$, for optically identified, flat
spectrum radio loud quasars is:~  $\alpha_{rad}^{opt}$ = $-0.6$
(Condon et al. 1983), while the values for the Stickel et al. (1996a)
red quasar sub-sample are: $\alpha_{rad}^{opt}$ $<$ $-0.9$.
On the other hand, the radio-to-near IR spectral indices
for most of the red quasar sub-sample are: $\alpha_{rad}^{IR}$
$\ge$  $-0.8$, implying significant steepening of the spectra
between the near IR and the optical:~
$\alpha_{IR}^{opt} \ll -1$ (Stickel et al. 1996a).
A rough lower limit to the required extinction can be derived by
comparing the observed optical flux density with that predicted by
extrapolating the radio-to-IR spectrum into the optical. This is a
lower limit due to confusion by emission from
stars in the galaxy with which the absorbing gas is
associated. Values of the rest frame visual
extinction, A$_V$, range from: ~A$_V$ $\ge$ 2 for
0108+388 and 0500+019, to A$_V$ $\ge$ 3 for 0218+357, and  A$_V$ $\ge$
7 for 1504+377.
Using the observed value of N(HI) derived from the HI 21cm absorption lines
leads to  lower limits to the spin temperatures of about 50 K for
0108+388, 300 K for 1504+377, 500 K for 0500+019, and 1000 K for 0218+357,
assuming a Galactic dust-to-gas ratio, and $f~=~1$.

Carilli et al. (1998) consider in detail the question of biases in
optically selected samples of quasars due to dust obscuration,
using the  statistics of red quasars and
the high detection rate of HI 21cm absorption toward
red quasars. They find that the fraction of quasars
`missing' from  optically selected samples
due to dust obscuration is between 6$\%$ and 20$\%$, and that
the fraction of high column density absorption systems missing from
optically selected samples of quasars is between 40$\%$ and 70$\%$, where
`optically selected sample' means a sample of quasars selected from a
moderately deep optical survey such as the POSS, with a redshift
distribution comparable to the 1 Jy quasar sample.

Fall and Pei (1993) have
presented detailed models of the numbers of quasars missing from
optically selected samples due to obscuration by dust associated with
high column density quasar absorption line systems as a function of
redshift. Using the redshift distribution for the 1 Jy sample, the
models of Fall and Pei
predict that between 2$\%$ and 12$\%$ of the sources would be missing
from such a sample due to dust obscuration.
The comparative numbers for the fraction of missing high column
density quasar absorption line systems
from the models of  Fall and Pei (1993) are between 30$\%$ and
60$\%$. In both cases (missing quasar
fraction and missing high column absorber fraction), the models
of Fall and Pei agree reasonably well with the data on the 1 Jy
sample.

We should emphasize that there are a number of significant
uncertainties in the statistics presented above.
First is simply the small number of red quasars searched thus far for
redshifted HI 21cm absorption.
Second are the possible biases introduced
by the fact that, due to
practical observational limitations, our absorption searches were
limited to the specific redshifts of the parent galaxies of the
absorbing clouds, as determined from emission lines seen
in  deep optical spectra (Stickel et al. 1996a).
It is possible that we have under-estimated the number
of high column density systems by not searching over the full
redshift range in each case.
Conversely, this selection criterion might skew the results toward
absorbers at the redshift of the quasar host galaxy,
which perhaps could bias the statistics in the
opposite sense.
And third is the fact that the fairly high radio flux density
limit of the 1 Jy sample
biases the sample toward lower redshift quasars. The redshift
distribution of the 1 Jy quasar
sample peaks at z $\approx$ 1, while quasar samples derived from
radio surveys with
lower flux density limits peak at z $\approx$ 2, close to the
redshift peak found for optically selected quasar samples (Shaver et
al. 1996).
While the redshift distribution is used explicitly
in the calculations above, unbiased
searches for redshifted HI 21cm absorption
toward a sample of red quasars selected from fainter radio catalogs
would make for a fairer comparison with the optical data.

Overall, the statistics presented above should not be considered
rigorous, but only representative. Still, the red quasar data
support the basic conclusions of Fall and Pei (1993):
(i) there may be a significant, but not dominant, population of
quasars missing from optically selected samples due to
obscuration, perhaps as high as 20$\%$ at the POSS limit
for an optical sample
with a redshift distribution similar to the 1 Jy, flat spectrum quasar
sample, and (ii) optically
selected samples may miss about half the high column density
quasar absorption line systems.
A final point made by Fall and Pei is that the strongest bias in  optical
samples  may be against the high column density systems with
high metalicities and  dust-to-gas ratios.
Such systems might be the most interesting
from the perspective of follow-up radio studies
of the dense, pre-star forming ISM in galaxies at significant look-back
times. The data presented herein suggests that
searching for redshifted HI 21cm absorption toward radio-loud
red quasars may be
an effective method for circumventing this bias.

\acknowledgments{The National Radio Astronomy Observatory is a
facility of the National Science Foundation
operated under cooperative agreement by Associated
Universities, Inc.}


On the atomistic energetics of carbon nanotube collapse from AIREBO potential

Abstract: Molecular dynamics simulations based on the adaptive intermolecular reactive empirical bond order (AIREBO) were performed to probe hydrostatic pressure induced collapse of single-walled and double-walled carbon nanotubes. It was unveiled that the torsion term, which is a specific potential component involved in the AIREBO scheme, plays a vital role in stabilizing fully collapsed cross-sections of the carbon nanotubes. Evolution of the cross-sectional deformation along the loading-unloading curve was also elucidated, showing strong dependence on the presence of a structural defect on the outer carbon wall.

\section{Introduction}

Radial buckling of carbon nanotubes is one of the most important deformation modes
that give rise to dramatic changes in their physical properties \cite{ShimaMater2012}.
It is mainly a consequence of the hollow cylindrical structure of carbon nanotubes;
the radial stiffness of the monoatomic cylinder, made by rolling up a graphene sheet,
is much less than its remarkably high axial stiffness.
Such the anisotropy in the stiffness allows cross-sectional buckling of carbon nanotubes
when they are subjected to external high pressure
or suffered from mechanical instability \cite{ShimaBook2012}.

A primary example of the radial buckling mode
is the one observed in pressurized many-walled carbon nanotubes.
This mode is characterized by wavy-shaped cross-sections \cite{ShimaNTN2008,ShimaPRB2010,UmenoPE2014},
which result from mechanical instability of outer walls that are reinforced by inner walls.
Another example of radial buckling mode occurs in single-walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs) with large radius.
In the latter systems,
loss of reinforcing inner walls makes the circular cross-section
be energetically unstable.
Beyond a threshold radius, therefore,
they undergo spontaneous collapse in the radial direction
\cite{ChopraNature1995,BenedictCPL1998,GHGaoNTN1998,PantanoJMPS2004,ElliottPRL2004,
HJLiuAPL2004,BLiuPRB2004,DYSunPRB2004,XHZhangPRB2004,ZWWangJPCB2004,TTangJAP2005,
SLZhangPRB2006,JXiaoNTN2007,MottaAdvMater2007,TChangNanoLett2010,
CHZhangACSNano2012,YLiPCCP2014,HMaACSNano2014,CerqueiraCarbon2014}.
A fully collapsed cross-section is composed of two parallel line segments
whose ends are capped by two highly strained circular edges.
Similar collapsing behavior was found to occur in double-wall carbon nanotubes (DWNTs)
\cite{XYangAPL2006,AnisPRB2012,AguiarJPCC2012,AlencarCarbon2017}.

From the physics perspective,
the significance of nanotube collapse lies in that it may cause
semiconductor-metal transition \cite{BarbozaPRL2008,GiuscaNanoLett2008},
optical response change \cite{ThirunavukkuarasuPRB2010},
magnetic moment quenching \cite{DinizPRB2010},
as well as interwall sp$^3$ bonding
between adjacent walls \cite{FonsecaPRB2010,SakuraiPhysicaE2011,
ZHXiaPRL2007,ByrnePRL2009,FilleterAdvMater2011,YYZhangJAP2011}.
Furthermore, nanotube collapse is expected to provide a way of synthesizing
closed-edged bilayer graphene nanoribbons \cite{CZhangACSNano2012,DHChoiSciRep2013},
which hold promise as building blocks in high-performance nanoelectronics
because of the fascinating mechanical
\cite{MottaAdvMater2007,XHZhongNTN2012,VilatelaCarbon2011}
and electrical properties \cite{SengaAPL2012,DHChoiSciRep2013}.
Against the backdrop, deep insight into an atomistic-scale mechanism of nanotube collapse
will provide important clues for the discovery of novel physical properties of carbon nanotubes
and their potential advantages in the field of nanoengineering.

In the present work, we perform molecular dynamics (MD) simulations
of collapsing SWNTs and DWNTs with and without structural defects.
Our MD simulation code is based on a broadly used interatomic potential
(called AIREBO potential \cite{StuartJCP2000}; see \S \ref{subsec_AIREBO}),
which makes it possible to express gradual changes from covalent to non-covalent bonds
and vice versa in accord with interatomic distance as well as
local atomic configuration.
The main purpose of this work is to clarify what parts of AIREBO potential components
should be dominant for driving and finally stabilizing the collapsed cross-section
of nanotubes under high hydrostatic pressure.
We also establish the pathway of cross-sectional deformation along the loading-unloading curve,
paying attention to the way how the presence of structural defects in the wall
gives feasible changes in the deformation pathway.

\section{Method}

\subsection{Atomistic model of CNTs}

\begin{figure}[ttt]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=7.5cm]{fig01.pdf}
\caption{(Left) Overall view of a zigzag SWNT with chiral index of (36,0).
(Right) A unit cell surrounded by the simulation box having 12.78 \AA$\;$ in height.}
\label{fig_unitcell}
\end{figure}

In this study we deal with zigzag SWNTs with the chiral index of (36,0)
and DWNTs with (27,0)@(36,0).
Figure \ref{fig_unitcell} presents the simulation cell of a (36,0) SWNT.
The unit cell is arranged such that the tube axis is parallel to the $z$ axis;
the height of the simulation box depicted in Fig.~\ref{fig_unitcell} by solid lines equals three times
the unit length of the (36,0) SWNT
along the tube axis (12.78 \AA), in which 432 carbon atoms are contained.
The periodic boundary condition is imposed only in the $z$ direction.

We also deal with SWNTs and DWNTs endowed with a structural defect,
called the Stone-Wales (SW) defect \cite{StoneCPL1986}.
A SW defect is formed by a $\pi/2$ rotation of a C-C bond, which transforms four hexagonal carbon rings
into two pentagons and two heptagons.
This defect structure is a metastable state,
in the sense that the system needs to overcome an activation barrier of several eV to realize it.
It was suggested that the presence of SW defects gives an impact on the mechanical stability
of collapsing carbon nanotubes \cite{CCLing2012}.
In our actual simulations, one SW defect is imposed to each nanotube sample
at the midpoint in the height of the unit cell.

\subsection{Mechanical energy}\label{subsec_AIREBO}

\begin{figure}[ttt]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=9.5cm]{fig02.pdf}
\caption{(a) Two different types of carbon-carbon bonds in a DWNT.
Neighboring carbon atoms are covalently bonded
if they are contained in the same graphitic wall;
otherwise, they are bonded by van der Waals forces
defined by the Lennard-Jones potential.
(b) Local atomic configuration adjacent to the covalent bond
connecting the atoms $i$ and $j$ in a graphene sheet.
The dihedral angle between the two triangles,
marked by $i-j-k$ and $i-j-\ell$,
determines the torsion energy of the C-C-C-C chain that bridges
the atom $k$ with its third nearest neighbor $\ell$.}
\label{fig_bonding}
\end{figure}

Forces exerted on atoms are calculated by
implementing the adaptive intermolecular reactive empirical bond order (AIREBO)
interatomic potential \cite{StuartJCP2000}.
The mechanical energy of a given nanotube is represented by
\begin{equation}
E = \frac12 \sum_i \sum_{j\ne i}
\left(
E_{ij}^{\rm REBO} + E_{ij}^{\rm LJ} + \sum_{k\ne i,j} \sum_{\ell \ne i,j,k} E_{kij\ell}^{\rm tors}
\right),
\label{eq_005}
\end{equation}
with $i,j,k$ and $\ell$ being atom numbering.
The three terms involved in the parenthesis in Eq.~(\ref{eq_005})
represent different energy components as explained below in turn.

The first term, written by $E_{ij}^{\rm REBO}$,
is the second generation reactive empirical bond order (2g-REBO) potential
\cite{BrennerJPCM2002}.
It represents the potential energy of covalent bonds between nearest-neighbor carbon atoms,
which are highlighted by thick arrows (colored in red) in Fig.~\ref{fig_bonding}(a).
The value of $E_{ij}^{\rm REBO}$ depends not only on the interatomic distance between $i$th and $j$th atoms
but also local atomic configuration around the two atoms.
In general, the 2g-REBO potential
makes it possible to evaluate with high accuracy
the in-plane elasticity and bending rigidity of
a graphene layer that consists of sp$^2$ bonds.

The second term in the parenthesis, $E_{ij}^{\rm LJ}$, accounts for
the van der Waals (vdW) interaction between atoms that belong to different graphitic layers
facing each other, as marked by thin arrows (colored in blue) in Fig.~\ref{fig_bonding}(a).
The dependence of $E_{ij}^{\rm LJ}$ on the interatomic distance
was set to be the same as that of the ordinary Lennard-Jones (LJ) 6-12 interatomic potential,
as implied by the superscript;
the well depth and equilibrium distance of the LJ potential were set to be
2.84 meV and 3.4 \AA, respectively.

The third term, $E_{kij\ell}^{\rm tors}$, the so-called ``torsion term",
is derived from the energy required for
torsional displacement of a carbon atom relative to its third nearest neighbor
in the same graphitic layer.
Figure \ref{fig_bonding}(b) illustrates the way of evaluating
the torsion term from local atomic configuration in a graphene layer.
Note that a covalent bond that connects the atoms $i$ and $j$
is associated with four dihedral angles,
one of which is the angle between the two triangular planes depicted in Fig.~\ref{fig_bonding}(b).
Each of the four dihedral angles accounts for an interaction
between one atom (e.g., labeled by $k$) and one of its third nearest neighbors ($\ell$).
A dihedral angle $\omega_{kji\ell}$ is either 0 or $\pi$ if all the four relevant atoms lie in a flat plane;
specifically in the flat configuration, $E_{kij\ell}^{\rm tors}$ takes a maximum (or minimum) value
at $\omega_{kji\ell}=0$ (or $\pi$)
that corresponds to {\it cis-} ({\it trans-})geometry of the C-C-C-C chain.

Among the three constituent terms in AIREBO,
the working of the first two,
$E_{ij}^{\rm REBO}$ and $E_{ij}^{\rm LJ}$,
on mechanical properties of collapsing carbon nanotubes
has been intensively investigated.
In particular, $E_{ij}^{\rm LJ}$ is known to play a crucial role in
radial collapse of nanotubes,
because the attraction and repulsion between opposing graphene walls
are believed to stabilize collapsed cross-sections.
The remaining one, $E_{kij\ell}^{\rm tors}$, however, has not been paid
sufficient attention thus far.
This fact motivated the authors to examine
the impact of torsional atomic interaction represented by this term
on the nanotube collapse.

\subsection{Torsion term in AIREBO}

This subsection describes certain details
in the mathematical expression of $E_{kij\ell}^{\rm tors}$
for later use.
Suppose the local configuration of nearby six atoms, as depicted in Fig.~\ref{fig_bonding}(b),
for which the relative position of the $i$th atom locating at $\bm{r}_i$
with respect to the $j$th atom at $\bm{r}_j$ can be represented by $\bm{r}_{ij} \equiv \bm{r}_i - \bm{r}_j$.
Then $\omega_{kji\ell}$ is defined by the angle between the plane spanned by the two vectors
$\bm{r}_{ik}$ and $\bm{r}_{ij}$
and the plane spanned by
$\bm{r}_{ij}$ and $\bm{r}_{j\ell}$,
satisfying the relation:
\begin{equation}
\cos \left( \omega_{kji\ell} \right) =
\frac{\bm{r}_{ik} \times \bm{r}_{ij}}{\left| \bm{r}_{ik} \times \bm{r}_{ij} \right|}
\cdot
\frac{\bm{r}_{ij} \times \bm{r}_{j\ell}}{\left| \bm{r}_{ij} \times \bm{r}_{j\ell} \right|}.
\end{equation}
Following Ref.~\cite{StuartJCP2000}, $E_{kij\ell}^{\rm tors} $ is expressed by
\begin{equation}
E_{kij\ell}^{\rm tors} =
\sum_i
\sum_{j\ne i}
\sum_{k\ne i,j}
\sum_{\ell\ne i,j,k}
W_{kji\ell}
V^{\rm tors} \left( \omega_{kji\ell} \right),
\label{eq_123}
\end{equation}
where
\begin{equation}
W_{kji\ell} =
w_{ki} \left( r_{ki} \right)
w_{ij} \left( r_{ij} \right)
w_{j\ell} \left( r_{j\ell} \right),
\label{eq_123a}
\end{equation}
and
\begin{equation}
V^{\rm tors} \left( \omega_{kji\ell} \right)
=
 \varepsilon_{kji\ell}
\left[
\frac{256}{405} \cos^{10} \left( \frac{\omega_{kji\ell}}{2} \right)
-\frac{1}{10}
\right].
\label{eq_125}
\end{equation}
In Eq.~(\ref{eq_123a}), $w_{ij}(r_{ij})$ is a bond weight function
that permits the identification of atom pairs as bonded ($w_{ij}=1$),
nonbonded ($w_{ij}=0$), or partially dissociated ($0<w_{ij}<1$),
depending on the interatomic distance $r_{ij}$ \cite{StuartJCP2000}.
In our MD simulations, the barrier height $\varepsilon_{kji\ell}$ in Eq.~(\ref{eq_125})
was set to be 0.3079 eV in accord with Ref.~\cite{StuartJCP2000}.

\begin{figure}[ttt]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=8.7cm]{fig03a.pdf}
\includegraphics[width=8.7cm]{fig03b.pdf}
\caption{Deformation pathway of (36,0) SWNTs under hydrostatic pressure.
(a) Pristine SWNT with no defect.
The load was increased from the initial state A to the most-squeezed state F
adiabatically in the alphabetic order,
then decreased from F to the fully-unloaded state H adiabatically, too.
The numeric data in unit of \AA$\;$ indicate the interlayer distance at the closest point in the cross-section.
(b) Defective SWNT with a SW defect. The load was adiabatically imposed in a similar manner to the case of (a).}
\label{fig_swnt}
\end{figure}

\subsection{Hydrostatic pressure application}

In principle, application of external hydrostatic pressure to a CNT
implies that forces are exerted on all the constituent carbon atoms
in the normal direction of the outmost wall.
In practice, however, careful consideration is requisite for
determining the normal direction of the wall at a given atom,
since the wall is not a continuum layer but a discrete atomic network
and thus there is no unique definition of the direction normal to the wall.
In our simulations, the direction normal to wall is defined by the following procedure \cite{UmenoPE2014}.

Since an atom in the honeycomb-shaped
carbon network has three nearest neighbors, we find three
isosceles triangles consisting of the atom and its two neighbors.
We next define planes on which the three atoms lie and
its normal vector. Then, a force vector parallel to the
normal vector is applied to the three atoms that form the isosceles
triangle. In this way, an atom receives three force vectors combined,
each of which corresponds to the three planes on which the
atom sits.
The vector sum of the three force vectors determines
the direction which we regard as the normal-to-wall direction at the given atom.
For instance, when force vectors with a norm of 0.01 nN
were assigned to the three atoms on the vertices of each isosceles triangle,
they result in a load of 0.03 nN on an atom in the outmost graphene layer
(note that each atom belongs to vertices of nine triangles).

\subsection{Structural relaxation}

The structural relaxation was performed in the following manner.
First, structural perturbation was given to the initial configuration of
concentric nanotube cylinders by MD calculation
at a temperature ($T$) of 100 K for around 100 steps with the time
step ($\Delta t$) of 2.0 fs. Then, the structure was relaxed employing the
FIRE algorithm \cite{BitzekPRL2006} until all forces exerted on atoms became less
than 0.01 eV/\AA. To rule out the possibility of the system falling into
an unstable equilibrium, another MD run at $T = 10$ K was performed
for around 100 steps with $\Delta t = 2.0$ fs and then the structure was
relaxed again with the same tolerance for forces as above. The
conditions for the initial perturbation were chosen so that the
nanotube with cylindrical structure was slightly nudged
to optimize its structure, because otherwise the structure would stay
unchanged at the unstable equilibrium.

\section{Deformation pathway}

\subsection{Radial deformation of SWNTs}

Figure \ref{fig_swnt} shows the pathway of radial deformation of (36,0) SWNTs
under hydrostatic pressure.
The vertical axis represents the mechanical energy of the system
calculated by Eq.~(\ref{eq_005}),
and the horizontal axis indicates the pressure applied to the outer cylindrical wall.
The panels of (a) and (b) correspond to a pristine SWNT without defect and
a defective SWNT containing one SW defect, respectively.
The line graph in the plot is a loading-unloading curve along which
radial deformation proceeds in the alphabetic order;
both the loading (indicated by arrows in magenta) and
unloading (blue) is adiabatically imposed to the system.
Sequential variation in the cross-section during the loading-unloading process
is also illustrated in the plot.
Numeric data in unit of \AA, attached to a few cross-section views,
show the interlayer distance,
{\it i.e.,} the distance of the two opposed walls at the closest point;
for the circular cross-section, it merely means the diameter of the wall.

It follows from Fig.~\ref{fig_swnt}(a) that a pristine (36,0) SWNT
with no defect shows an abrupt change in the energy at a critical state,
{\it i.e.,} at the state B in the plot.
Across the state B, the system undergoes the transition
from the initial circular cross-section to a radially deformed one,
which causes a sudden increase in the energy
while the applied pressure is kept to be constant.
The energy keeps rising until the system arrives at another critical state,
labeled by D in Fig.~\ref{fig_swnt}(a).
Afterwards, the energy starts to decline suddenly,
even though the magnitude of radial deformation continues to increase.
Further loading results in a most-squeezed state F.
At this extreme state, decompression starts and then the pressure is continued to be reduced adiabatically
until the fully-unloaded state H.
It should be noted that
even after the load is completely released,
the initial circular cross-section is not recovered.
This implies that the nanotube collapse is stabilized
due to a certain mechanism, as discussed later.

\begin{figure}[ttt]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=8.7cm]{fig04a.pdf}
\includegraphics[width=8.7cm]{fig04b.pdf}
\caption{Deformation pathway of (27,0)@(36,0) DWNTs under hydrostatic pressure.
(a) Pristine DWNT with no defect. (b) Defective DWNT having one SW defect.
Pressure was varied adiabatically in the alphabetic order.}
\label{fig_dwnt}
\end{figure}

A similar deformation pathway was observed
for the (36,0) defective SWNT with a SW defect,
as shown in Fig.~\ref{fig_swnt}(b).
The most important difference from the pristine-SWNT case
is the absence of the first critical state
at which the radial buckling occurs.
Instead, the defective SWNT shows a gradual change in the cross-section
from the initial state A to the highest energy state C.
Beyond the state C,
the system undergoes a similar deformation process
to that in Fig.~\ref{fig_swnt}(a).

\subsection{Radial deformation of DWNTs}

Figure \ref{fig_dwnt} shows the deformation pathway
of (27,0)@(36,0) DWNTs;
the panel (a) shows the result of a pristine DWNT,
and the panel (b)  shows the result of a defective DWNT
in which one SW defect is embedded in the outer wall.
As similar to the case of SWNTs,
defect-induced vanishing of the radial buckling is observed in the defective DWNT.
It is also found that the value of pressure requisite for collapsing
is larger than that in the SWNT case.
This is essentially because a DWNT can be viewed as a SWNT filled by a thinner SWNT.
As such, it is reasonable that the inner tube provides mechanical support against
radial compression \cite{AlencarCarbon2017}
and thus a DWNT should show higher mechanical stability than a SWNT.

A noticeable difference from the case of SWNTs is the suppression of the overshoot
in the loading-unloading curve near the state C shown in Figs.~\ref{fig_dwnt}(a) and \ref{fig_dwnt}(b).
This suppression can be attributed to lowering of the height in an activation barrier
that separates elastic and plastic deformation phases,
as will be discussed later.

\section{Energy variation during radial deformation}

\begin{figure}[ttt]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=8.7cm]{fig05a.pdf}
\includegraphics[width=8.7cm]{fig05b.pdf}
\caption{AIREBO-derived mechanical energy of pressurized nanotubes.
(a) Pristine (27,0) SWNT; (b) Pristine (36,0) SWNT; (c) Defective (36,0) SWNT;
(d) Defective (27,0)@(36,0) DWNT.
Contributions from three relevant terms contained in AIREBO
are plotted in a separated manner.
Inset: Enlarged view of the total energy curve near the shallow peak.}
\label{fig_component}
\end{figure}

\subsection{Contributions from different AIREBO components}

Figure \ref{fig_component} shows the evolution in the mechanical energy of pressurized SWNTs and DWNTs
with progress of reducing the interlayer distance.
The horizontal axis shows the interlayer distance of the system that tends to decline
as the radial compression proceeds.
The vertical axis is the mechanical energy of the system
calculated on the basis of the AIREBO potential scheme;
contributions from three terms in Eq.~(\ref{eq_005})
are each individually plotted as explained in the legend.
A pristine (27,0) SWNT is also considered together with the nanotube systems
discussed in Figs.~\ref{fig_swnt} and \ref{fig_dwnt},
in order to investigate the effect of tube radius on the energy evolution.

In all the plots in Fig.~\ref{fig_component},
it is commonly observed that
the total energy starts to increase in a monotonic manner
with decreasing interlayer distance,
followed by a slight drop.
In the vicinity of ca. 5 \AA,
the total energy curve shows a convex shape,
as illustrated by the magnified view in the insets.
This convex energy profile plays a role of the activation barrier
beyond which the collapsed cross-section is stabilized;
see Fig.~\ref{fig_barrier} for schematic illustrations
of energy evolution near the activation barrier.
Given an insufficient radial deformation,
the system can not reach a full collapse state but return to
the initial circular cross-section after full unloading.
In contrast, if the cross-section is significantly squeezed and the mechanical energy is raised
enough to overcome the activation barrier,
then the collapsed cross-section is stabilized even after full unloading

It is interesting to note that the interlayer distance which corresponds to the maximum position
[{\it e.g.,} 5.3 \AA$\;$ for pristine (36,0) SWNT ]
is nearly equal to that realized in the second critical state
in the deformation pathway
[5.38 \AA$\;$ for pristine (36,0) SWNT as marked at the state D in Fig.~\ref{fig_swnt}(a)].
This implies that the overshoot height in the loading-unloading curve
is determined by the activation barrier height
estimated from the energy evolution curve in Fig.~\ref{fig_component}.

\begin{figure}[ttt]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=8.8cm]{fig06.pdf}
\caption{Diagram of energy evolution near the activation barrier.
(a) When the magnitude of radial deformation is not sufficient for the system
to overcome the barrier, then the initial circular cross-section will be recovered
after full unloading.
(b) If the cross-section is significantly squeezed and the mechanical energy is raised
enough to overcome the barrier,
then the collapsed cross-section is stabilized even after full unloading.}
\label{fig_barrier}
\end{figure}

\subsection{Mechanism of negative contribution from the torsion term}

The most important observation in Fig.~\ref{fig_component} is
the monotonically decreasing trend in the energy curve derived from the torsion term.
As followed from Fig.~\ref{fig_component},
the torsion term as well as the vdW term
give negative contributions at all the interlayer distance,
and their magnitudes are enhanced as the collapse advances.
In contrast, the REBO term gives positive contribution at every interlayer distance.
The sum of the positive and negative contributions
results in the convex shape in the total energy curve.

We emphasize here that
the absolute value of the torsion term contribution (negative)
is always greater than that of the vdW term contribution (negative),
as least in the range of interlayer distance we have considered.
This fact indicates that the interatomic interaction described by the torsion term
is fundamental for stabilizing the collapsed cross-section,
together with the attractive interaction driven by the vdW forces
between the two opposing walls.
To the knowledge of the authors,
the contribution from the torsion term to the radial deformation of carbon nanotubes
has never been examined in detail thus far,
compared with the intense studies on the counterparts
regarding the REBO term and vdW term.
In this sense, this is the first numerical evidence
that the torsion term plays a significant role in the stabilization
of collapsed cross-section of carbon nanotubes.

\begin{figure}[ttt]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=8.2cm]{fig07.pdf}
\caption{Profile of the normalized potential $V^{\rm tors}/\varepsilon_{kji\ell}$
with regard to the dihedral angle $\omega_{kji\ell}$ (abbreviated by $\omega$).
The upward sharp peak at $\omega=0$ (or $2\pi$) indicates that
the {\it cic}-geometry is energetically unstable for a four-atomic carbon chain.
In contrast, the downward plateau around $\omega=\pi$ indicates
that the {\it trans}-geometry is energetically favored and
rather robust against twist deformation of the chain.}
\label{V_potential_profile}
\end{figure}

The reason why the torsion term decreases monotonically with approaching the interlayer distance
is explained by considering the dependence of $V^{\rm tors}$,
defined by Eq.~(\ref{eq_125}),
on the dihedral angle $\omega_{kji\ell}$.
Figure \ref{V_potential_profile}
shows the profile of $V^{\rm tors}$ as a function of $\omega_{kji\ell}$.
We see from the figure that
$V^{\rm tors}$ has
a relatively sharp upward peak at $\omega_{kji\ell}=0$,
which corresponds to {\it cis}-type geometry of the $k$-$j$-$i$-$\ell$ carbon atomic chain
that was depicted in Fig.~\ref{fig_bonding}(b).
In addition, $V^{\rm tors}$ has
a very broad minimum around $\omega_{kji\ell}=\pi$,
which corresponds to {\it trans}-type geometry of the $k$-$j$-$i$-$\ell$ chain.

An important feature of the profile is the significant asymmetry in the peak width
between the upward peak at $\omega=0$ (sharp) and the plateau-like downward peak
around $\omega=\pi$ (quite broad).
The upward peak at $\omega=0$ indicates that {\it cis}-type geometry of a four-atom chain
is energetically unstable and thus a feasible decline in the mechanical energy
of chain will be observed if it is twisted ({\it i.e.,} if $\omega$ deviates from 0).
In contrast, the downward plateau around $\omega=\pi$ indicates that
a {\it trans}-type chain will show only a slight change in energy
even when it is twisted.
Therefore, if both {\it cis}- and {\it trans}-type chains are twisted simultaneously
with the same twist angle, then the energy decrease caused by {\it cis} deformation will overcome
the energy increase by {\it trans} deformation,
and thus the total energy of the two chains will be reduced.

The above argument regarding a pair of {\it cis}- and {\it trans}-type chains
holds true for a monoatomic carbon cylinder ({\it i.e.,} a SWNT),
in which many {\it cis}- and {\it trans}-type chains are embedded.
Under cross-sectional deformation of a SWNT, therefore,
accumulation of local energy reduction derived from many twisted {\it cis}-chains
will overcome a slight energy increase derived from many twisted {\it trans}-chains.
As a result, $E_{kij\ell}^{\rm tors}$ of the system will decrease as the cross-sectional deformation proceeds.

Our finding provides a new insight into the atomistic-scale energetics of collapsing carbon nanotubes.
It has been conventionally thought that the vdW force is a primary (and perhaps the only) driving force
that stabilizes fully collapsed cross-sections, because the attractive nature of vdW interaction between to opposing carbon walls
may result in high mechanical stability of the full collapse.
But as clearly demonstrated in Fig.~\ref{fig_component},
the monotonic decline in the torsion-induced energy curve
should be also indispensable for realizing the stabilization of the full collapse,
taking a complementary role with the attractive vdW interaction.
This is the main finding of this article.

\subsection{Crossover between elastic and plastic deformation phases}

We have seen that there is an activation barrier for stabilizing collapsed cross-sections.
If the pressure-induced reduction in the interlayer distance at the closest point is not sufficiently
small, then the system behaves elastically so that the initial circular cross-section will be recovered
after complete unloading [see Fig.~\ref{fig_barrier}(a)].
In contrast, once the cross-section is squeezed sufficiently,
then the system undergoes plastic deformation;
in this case, the collapsed cross-section is stabilized even after complete unloading
[see Fig.~\ref{fig_barrier}(b)].
In this context, it is interesting to probe the threshold interlayer distance
that separates the elastic and plastic deformation phases.

\begin{figure}[ttt]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=8.7cm]{fig08.pdf}
\caption{Diagram of the threshold interlayer distance (ID)
that separates elastic and plastic deformation phases.
Each vertical segment indicates the marginal region of ID.
If radial compression continues until ID is reduced below the bottom edge of the segment,
then the system will fall into a full collapse
even after complete unloading [see Fig.~\ref{fig_barrier}(a)].
If radial compression stops before ID goes below the upper edge of the segment,
then the system will recover the initial circular cross-section
after complete unloading [see Fig.~\ref{fig_barrier}(b)].
}
\label{fig_threshold}
\end{figure}

Figure \ref{fig_threshold} presents a diagram of the threshold interlayer distance (ID)
that separates elastic and plastic deformation phases.
Each vertical segment indicates the marginal region of ID.
If radial compression continues until ID is reduced below the bottom edge of the segment,
then the system will fall into a full collapse
even after complete unloading [see Fig.~\ref{fig_barrier}(a)].
If radial compression stops before ID goes below the upper edge of the segment,
then the system will recover the initial circular cross-section
after complete unloading [see Fig.~\ref{fig_barrier}(b)].

Figure \ref{fig_threshold}(a) indicates that for SWNT,
SW defect insertion leads to upward shifts both in the two threshold interlayer distances,
{\it i.e.,} the bottom limit of the elastic deformation phase
and the upper limit of the plastic deformation phase.
These upward shifts are intuitively understood
as the defect insertion may cause reduced softening and thus the collapse becomes easy to occur
even at a relatively large interlayer distance compared with the defect-free counterpart.
But this softening effect is not significant for DWNTs as shown in Fig.~\ref{fig_threshold}(b).
This is because in the defective DWNT,
it is the outer wall that contains a defect;
the inner wall is free from the defect
and thus tends to push back the outer wall under radial compression.

\section{Conclusion}

We have conducted AIREBO-based MD simulations of collapsing SWNTs and DWNTs
under hydrostatic pressure.
The main finding is that the torsion term, one of the constituent potential terms in AIREBO,
takes a vital role in stabilizing fully collapsed cross-section of carbon nanotubes.
The novelty of this result stems from the fact that
in established understandings, the vdW term is quite often considered
as the only potential term that stabilizes collapsed cross-sections.
Our simulation data clearly demonstrate that
the sum of decreases both in the torsion term and the vdW term
with progress of radial compression,
not only the contribution from the vdW term,
is the physical origin of carbon nanotube collapse.
It was also found that the above conclusion holds true
no matter whether the system contains a SW defect.

\section*{Acknowledgments}
This work was supported by JSPS KAKENHI Grant Numbers
JP 15H03888, 15H04207, and 15KK0220.

\bibliographystyle{elsarticle-num}

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics (cond-mat.mes-hall); Materials Science (cond-mat.mtrl-sci); Applied Physics (physics.app-ph); Computational Physics (physics.comp-ph)