Ultraviolet Light Curves of Supernovae with Swift Uvot

Abstract: We present ultravioliet (UV) observations of supernovae (SNe) obtained with the UltraViolet/Optical Telescope (UVOT) on board the Swift spacecraft. This is the largest sample of UV light curves from any single instrument and covers all major SN types and most subtypes. The UV light curves of SNe Ia are fairly homogenous while SNe Ib/c and IIP show more variety in their light curve shapes. The UV-optical colors clearly differentiate SNe Ia and IIP, particularly at early times. The color evolution of SNe IIP, however, makes their colors similar to SNe Ia at about 20 days after explosion. SNe Ib/c are shown to have varied UV-optical colors. The use of UV colors to help type SNe will be important for high redshift SNe discovered in optical observations. These data can be added to ground based optical and near infrared data to create bolometric light curves of individual objects and as checks on generic bolometric corrections used in the absence of UV data. This sample can also be compared with rest-frame UV observations of high redshift SNe observed at optical wavelengths.

\section{Ultraviolet SN Observations\label{IaOpt}}

From the earliest photon signal from a SN during the shock breakout,
the UV light from supernovae contains many clues about the explosion
and the environment, with application to both nearby and high-redshift SNe.
The contribution of UV light to the bolometric luminosity can be significant,
particularly at the earliest epochs when the high temperature yields
a large UV flux.  Because line blanketing in the UV is dominated
by iron peak elements, the UV brightness is
sensitive to the ionization level (cf. \citealp{Dessart_etal_2008})
and differences in metallicity \citep{Nugent_etal_1997,Lentz_etal_2000}.
The large UV extinction observed in most extinction curves also allows
UV observations to better constrain the reddening to individual objects
\citep{Jeffery_etal_1994}.

The first observation of UV light from a SN was performed by the
Orbiting Astronomical Observatory in 1972, revealing the
UV faintness of a type I SN \citep{Holm_etal_1974}.
The International Ultraviolet Explorer (IUE)
built up a larger sample with UV spectroscopic observations
of 25 SNe \citep{CTF1995}, with excellent light curves for
SNe IIL 1979C \citep{Panagia_etal_1980} and 1980K, the Ib 1983N,
Ia 1992A \citep{Kirshner_etal_1993},
as well as the II-pec 1987A \citep{Pun_etal_1995}.
The spectacular event of SN~1987A was also observed in the UV by the
Astron Station \citep{Lyubimkov_1990}.  The Hubble Space Telescope (HST)
has added excellent UV spectroscopic and photometric data for
another $\sim$30 SNe (see \citealp{Panagia_2003} for a review of IUE and HST UV
observations up to that time).
The Galaxy Evolution Explorer (Gal-Yam et al., in preparation),
and the Optical Monitor on the XMM-Newton mission
(cf. Immler et al. 2005) have added a few more observations each.
Rest-frame UV observations of higher
redshift SNe observed in the optical from the ground are also now being
regularly obtained \citep{Astier_etal_2006, Foley_etal_2007, Ellis_etal_2008}.

The latest UV observatory is {\sl Swift} UVOT
\citep{Roming_etal_2005}.
The {\sl Swift} observatory's quick response capability and short term scheduling,
necessitated by the unpredictable and variable behavior of individual
gamma ray bursts (GRB), also allows newly discovered
SNe to be observed quickly and with well sampled light curves \citep{Gehrels_etal_2004}.
Data are available in a matter of hours, and observing
 times and filter combinations can be changed on a day to day basis
depending on what is seen in recent observations.
Thus far, {\sl Swift} has focused on nearby SNe ($z\lesssim0.02$) for which
high quality data can be obtained with only a small impact on spacecraft
operations and {\sl Swift}'s primary mission to detect and observe GRBs.
SN observations are performed under {\sl Swift}'s Target of Opportunity (ToO) program
\footnote{http://www.swift.psu.edu/too.html}.
A dedicated website\footnote{see http://swift.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/swift/sne/swift\_sn.html}
 has been set up that gives the status of Swift SN observations, images and
regularly updated light curves
for the benefit of the community.

In this paper we present some of the overall UV properties of SNe
seen in our sample.  In particular, we contrast the UV light curve shapes
and colors of the different types, which is best done with a sample observed
with the same instrumental setup.  Understanding the brightness
(relative to the optical) and temporal
behavior should assist future observatories to understand the sampling and depth necessary to
characterize a UV light curve.

\section{Observation Summary\label{sample}}

{\sl Swift} UVOT has observed 48 SNe
between March 2005 \citep{Brown_etal_2005} and August 2007.
UVOT typically observes SNe with three UV
and three optical broadband filters.  The central wavelengths and
widths are given in Table 1 \citep{Poole_etal_2007}.
\citet{Brown_etal_2007b}
display the transmission of these filters with respect to SNe spectra.
However, like IUE, they are limited to the brightest
epochs of the the nearest SNe.  Here we focus on results from the
photometry; spectroscopic results will be presented elsewhere
(Bufano et al. in prep).

\begin{deluxetable}{cccccc}

\tablecaption{{\sl Swift} UVOT Filter Characteristics}
\tablehead{\colhead{Filter} & \colhead{$\lambda_{central}$} &
\colhead{FWHM} & \colhead{Zeropoint}  \\
\colhead{} & \colhead{(\AA)} & \colhead{(\AA)} &
\colhead{(mag)} }

\startdata
uvw2 & 1928 & 657 & $17.35 \pm 0.03$\\
uvm2 & 2246 & 498 & $16.82 \pm 0.03$ \\
uvw1 & 2600 & 693 & $17.49 \pm 0.03$\\
$u$ & 3465 & 785 & $18.34 \pm 0.020$\\
$b$ & 4392 & 975 & $19.11 \pm 0.016$\\
$v$ & 5468 & 769 & $17.89 \pm 0.013$\\
\enddata

\end{deluxetable}

Images were obtained from the {\sl Swift} archive, and for those whose most recent
processing occurred prior to 2007, the raw images and event lists
were reprocessed, primarily to utilize an improved plate scale for the uvw2 images
and corrections to exposure times in the headers.
Exposures were aspect corrected then coadded by epoch, usually corresponding
to unique observation numbers.  Due to the rapid evolution of SN~2006aj/GRB060218
during the first day the exposures in the first observation number were used
individually and subsequent observations coadded as usual.
We performed aperture photometry using a 3\arcsec~source aperture
to improve the signal to noise and minimize galaxy contamination compared
to larger apertures (cf. \citealp{Li_etal_2006}).  A
background region was chosen by eye to be similar to the galaxy background
near the SN.    Over or undersubtraction of the underlying galaxy leads to the
magnitudes being under or overestimated when the SN fades close the the galaxy level,
so here we focus on the brightest epochs and less contaminated events where the
galaxy contribution is less significant.
Counts within a 5\arcsec~aperture around the SN were used
to compute the coincidence loss correction factor (to be consistent with the calibration),
and an average point spread function (psf) for
each filter was used to compute the aperture correction factor from our
3\arcsec~aperture to the 5\arcsec~for which the zeropoints are calibrated
\citep{Poole_etal_2007}.
The light curves of those with at least 3 UV detections well above the estimated
galaxy background (26 out of the 48 SNe observed during this period)
are displayed on a continuous timeline in Fig.\ 1, with individual light curves displayed in Figs. 2 and 3.
 Fig.\ 1 illustrates the dynamic range and frequency of Swift SN observations.
The bright limit, above which coincidence losses are hard to correct,
is approximately 12th magnitude in the UV. In practice this saturation limit
from a bright SN or a SN on a bright galaxy background has affected the optical light curves of
some of these SNe but not the UV light curves.
The faint limit can be as deep as about 21 mag
but observations are typically terminated once the galaxy light dominates within
the aperture.

\section{Light Curves}

The temporal behavior of the UV light varies with SN type.  Fig.\ 2 shows UVOT
lightcurves for the individual SNe Ia.  SNe Ia rise to a
maximum in the UV peaking just before the optical. Similar to the optical, the UV brightness decays
first steeply and then shallower due to radioactive decay of Nickel and Cobalt.
The uvm2 photometry is much fainter than the other bands, so the points have larger errors,
but the light curves seem to be
broader (decaying shallower) than the other UV filters.
In Table 2 we report the typical decay rate in mags/100 days as in \citet{Pskovskii_1967},
with $\beta$ representing the early decay and $\gamma$ the later shallow decay.
The UV lightcurves of SNe Ia are fairly uniform, and the uvw1 curves match
well with the HST/IUE spectrophotometry of SN~1992A in the comparable F275W band
\citep{Kirshner_etal_1993,Brown_etal_2005,Milne_etal_2007}.
More details on the lightcurves and generation
of UV lightcurve templates for SNe Ia will be presented in Milne et al. (in preparation).

From a sample of light curves one can begin
to discern what is normal and what is peculiar behavior.  Two SNe Ia that stand
out are SNe 2005hk and 2005ke.
SN~2005hk was already fading in the UV when {\sl Swift} observations began, nearly 10
days before the optical maximum.
SN~2005ke followed the typical Ia decay until about 15 days after maximum light
when the UV brightness remained
nearly constant for $\sim$20 days before fading again.
In conjunction with a marginal x-ray
detection, this plateau in the UV light curves has been attributed to interaction with the
circumstellar material \citep{Immler_etal_2006}, though other causes such as
reduced line blanketing have been suggested \citep{Kasliwal_etal_2008}.
Contamination could
be ruled out for SN~2005ke because the first observation showed the SN fainter
than the plateau level and subsequent observations showed it had faded again.
For other SNe contamination is harder to rule out, but SNe 2007ax \citep{Kasliwal_etal_2008}
and 2006mr show hints of extended emission above the background.
SN~2006E also stands out with its relatively flat light curves, but that is because
the peak and early decay were missed and the
slow decay merely represents the shallower late time decay also seen in other SNe Ia.

For SNe Ib/c, the sample of well observed SNe is much smaller, with 3 light curves
in our sample, but they appear to be as diverse in the UV as they are in the optical (see Fig.\ 3).
Other SNe Ib/c were also observed but for only a single epoch or were not well detected
(see \citet{Holland_etal_2007} for additional SNe Ib/c observed during {\sl Swift}'s first two years).
It is hard to define a generic
UV behavior, so instead we briefly describe each well sampled SN.

SN~2006aj, a Ic SN, was
discovered following {\sl Swift} BAT trigger on GRB060218 \citep{Campana_etal_2006}.
The UV initially rose rapidly reaching
a bright peak about half a day after the trigger.
This first peak has been attributed to the shock breakout from a dense
stellar wind \citep{Campana_etal_2006,Blustin_2007,Waxman_etal_2007} or
self-absorbed synchrotron radiation \citep{Ghisellini_etal_2007}.
This faded rapidly
in the UV, plateauing briefly from 4$--$10 days after
the trigger as the radioactive decay powered a supernova light curve,
and then faded again.  In uvw2 and uvm2 this
SN peaked 4 magnitudes fainter than the earlier peak.
The optical curves are consistent with a SN Ic of intermediate luminosity
between normal SNe Ic and previous GRB-associated, overluminous SNe Ic
(cf. \citealp{Pian_etal_2006} and \citealp{Modjaz_etal_2006}).

SN~2006jc was a peculiarly bright and blue SN Ib \citep{Foley_etal_2007},
and the UVOT grism spectra
show an indication of MgII emission \citep{Immler_etal_2008}.
Discovered near maximum light, the UV and optical light curves all
fade steeply and then shallower and then steeper again.  The UVOT light curves
will be studied in more detail in Modjaz et al. (in preparation).
SN~2007Y, a peculiar Ib/c with spectral similarities to SN~2005bf \citep{Folatelli_etal_2007},
behaved more like a Ia in shape and color with the UV
brightness rising with the optical, peaking a little sooner and fading
slightly quicker.

SNe IIP start off very bright and blue.  Brightening to a maximum just a
few days after explosion, the UV magnitudes then fade rather linearly,
with the uvm2 filter decaying slightly faster than the others.  Individual
light curves of the SNe IIP are displayed in Fig.\ 3.
This rapid drop in the UV brightness is driven
by the cooling photosphere and the resulting line blanketing of heavy
elements (cf. \citealp{Brown_etal_2007a}).   \citet{Dessart_etal_2008} compare the UVOT
photometry of SNe II 2005cs and 2006bp with model spectra and demonstrate
the usefulness of UV photometry in constraining the extinction and the
temporal change in temperature and ionization.
The optical brightness remains constant, resulting in a
steady reddening with time. While this reddening is common
to all the SNe IIP observed by UVOT, the decay slopes vary by nearly a
factor of 2 (as shown in Table 2),
possibly reflecting the different cooling rates of the SN photospheres.

In order to better contrast the SN types, Fig.\ 4 shows the UVOT light curves
of a well observed example of each type.  For easy comparison, the time and
magnitude axis are the same across the plots and the magnitudes are unshifted
to show the relative colors.  The explosion dates for SNe 2007af and 2007Y
assume a rise time of 18 days to the maximum light in the V band
for SNe Ia/b/c \citep{Garg_etal_2007, Stritzinger_etal_2002},
while SN~2006bp uses the explosion date determined by \citet{Dessart_etal_2008}.
The main SN subtypes missing from our sample are SNe IIL, IIn, and IIb.
Fortuitously, examples of these classes, along with the peculiar SN II 1987A
were well observed with IUE and HST, making these sets complementary.

\begin{deluxetable}{ccccc}
\tablecaption{Decay Slopes}
\tablehead{\colhead{Filter} & \colhead{SN Ia $\beta$ } &
\colhead{SN Ia $\gamma$ } & \colhead{SN Ibc $\beta$ } & \colhead{SN II  $\beta$ } \\
\colhead{} & \colhead{(mag/100 d)} & \colhead{(mag/100 d)} &
\colhead{(mag/100 d)} & \colhead{(mag/100 d)}}

\startdata
uvw2 &  9$--$10 &  3 &  18 &  23$--$37\\
uvm2 &  7$--$9 &  3 &  14 &  23$--$41\\
uvw1 &  11$--$13 &  2 &  18 &  20$--$32
\enddata

\tablecomments{
SNe used: Ia $\beta$ (SNe 2007af, 2005ke), SN Ia $\gamma$ (SN~2006E),
SN Ibc  $\beta$  (SN~2007Y), SN II $\beta$ (SNe 2005cs, 2006at, 2006bp) }
\end{deluxetable}

\section{Colors}

In addition to physical properties like temperature and extinction,
UV and UV-optical colors are also useful in differentiating SN types.  The use of optical
colors to distinguish SNe of different types has been explored by
multiple authors \citep{VandenBerk_etal_2001, Poznanski_etal_2002,
Gal-Yam_etal_2004, Sullivan_etal_2006, Kuznetsova_Connolly_2007,
Poznanski_Maoz_2007}.   These techniques are of primary importance
for large and deep surveys and searches for which the SN candidates
are either too faint or too numerous for spectroscopic classification
of all candidates.  The upcoming Pan-STARRS could discover on the order of
10,000 SNe/year\footnote{http://pan-starrs.ifa.hawaii.edu/project/reviews\\/PreCoDR/documents/scienceproposals/sne.pdf} and
the Large Synoptic Survey Telescope 250,000 SNe/year.\footnote{http://www.lsst.org/Science/fs\_transient.shtml}
Thus photometric measures
of the SNe will be critical
to classifying SNe, as well as determining photometric redshifts.  Rest frame
UV observations can greatly improve the accuracy of such determinations.
 Fig.\ 6 compares the color-color location of two SNe Ia (SNe 2007af and 2005ke,
well observed examples of a normal and sub-luminous Ia respectively) and two SNe IIP
(the well observed SNe 2005cs and 2006bp) in the
5 colors (using neighboring filter combinations) available from the UVOT observations.
Extinction vectors, corresponding to a color excess E(B-V)=0.1 and the
Milky Way extinction law \citep{Cardelli_etal_1989} evaluated at the central wavelengths,
are plotted in each color-color plot, though the effect of extinction can vary
with different source spectra and choices of extinction laws.
As the UVOT $u,b,$ and $v$ magnitudes are similar to the Johnson $UBV$, the bottom
right panel is comparable to Fig.\ 3 in \citet{Poznanski_etal_2002}.  In those colors
there is still a lot of overlap between SNe Ia and II.  As one
adds progressively bluer filters, SNe Ia and II are better separated, showing the
advantage of rest-frame UV observations.  In the upper left panel, SNe Ia are actually
bluer than SNe II in the uvw2-uvm2 color, but this is likely due to the red tail of the uvw2
filter allowing more optical photons through and making the uvm2 look fainter by comparison.
As discussed more below, the UV and UV-optical colors of SNe II evolve dramatically,
making their colors more similar to SNe Ia.

This clear difference between the UV-bright SNe II and the UV-faint SNe Ia
was noticed after a few IUE observations of SNe Ia and II (\citealp{Panagia_1982},
see also \citealp{Panagia_2003}).  This "UV deficit" is caused by the very
red Ia spectrum between $\sim2500$ and 4000 \AA~
(cf.\citealp{Kirshner_etal_1993}), and was exploited
by \citet{Riess_etal_2004} to identify SNe Ia in the Hubble Deep Field.
The left panel of Fig.\ 6 uses filters on either side and in the middle of that
red spectral slope to give two colors, uvm2-uvw1 and uvw1-b, which best show the
contrast between SNe Ia and II.  The SNe II
are clearly separated into the top left portion of the plot, while the SNe Ia
are in the bottom right.  The uvw1-b color is sufficient by itself to make the
distinction, with uvw1$--$b$\la$1 corresponding to young SNe II.
The right panel of Fig.\ 6 adds the colors of our
three SNe Ib/c, spanning the range of colors seen in SNe Ia and II,
complicating their differentiation.  The similarities of SN~2006jc with SNe IIn
\citep{Pastorello_etal_2008} explains the blue
UV-optical colors.  More typical SNe Ib/c have lower effective
temperatures and the subsequent UV line blanketing make their colors more similar
to SNe Ia. The contamination of SNe Ib/c from cosmological samples of SNe Ia,
as discussed in \citet{Riess_etal_2004}, is reduced because
the SNe Ib/c are less common and usually much fainter than SNe Ia.

While red UV-optical colors differentiate well between young SNe II and Ia,
they are not conclusive, as SNe II become redder with time.
In Fig.\ 7 we display the uvw1-b color evolution of these same SNe.
To determine the explosion date we have assumed a rise time of 18 days to
the maximum light in the V band for SNe Ia \citep{Garg_etal_2007}
and for the SNe II we use the explosion times
determined by \citet{Dessart_etal_2008}.  At early times, there is a
3 magnitude difference between the uvw1-B color of SNe Ia and II.
However, this large difference does not persist as the SN II temperature
(and correspondingly the UV flux) drops with time creating a redder spectrum
whose colors become similar to SNe Ia (whose red colors evolve rather slowly) by day 20.
\citet{Fransson_etal_1987} noticed this rapid reddening in SN~1987A and
cautioned against using the UV alone to distinguish SNe I from II.  Even a
rough determination of the SN epoch, through either the light curve behavior
or even the cadence of the SN search
observations can help make the distinction.  Reddening is a further degeneracy
which can also be broken
by monitoring the color evolution, as reddening would cause a shift in
the colors at a given epoch but not mask the differing slopes of the color evolution.

Understanding the UV color differences within and across types is
especially important for classifying high redshift SNe.  Some UV information is
being incorporated into such photoyping (cf. \citealp{Riess_etal_2004,Johnson_Crotts_2006})
but in the past has been limited due to the limited epochs at which UV information
is available.
The addition of this UV photometry should help improve
the understanding of the diversity and temporal change of the UV flux
to allow SNe to be better identified at larger redshifts.  Other high redshift applications
are discussed below.

\section{High Redshift Application}

In addition to SN observations by UV satellites, deep optical observations will
observe the rest-frame UV light from higher redshift SNe.  Fig.\ 8 displays
the rest frame UV light sampled by the UVOT UV filters as it corresponds to
observed wavelengths as a function
of redshift, highlighting regions where the UV filters correspond well with commonly
used optical and infrared filters.  To highlight the regions where the overlap
between the filters is greatest, the bands are centered on the central wavelength
and extend one quarter of the full width half max of the filter transmission in
both directions \citep{Poole_etal_2007,Fukugita_etal_1996,Hewett_etal_2006}.
This graphically depicts useful regions of
overlap.  For example, the photons corresponding with the rest-frame uvw1 begins
to be redshifted into the optical u' band
(e.g. SDSS-II SN survey; \citealp{Sako_etal_2008}; and LSST) for objects at a redshift of $z\sim0.4$
and the g' band (e.g. SNLS; \citealp{Astier_etal_2006}) at $z\sim0.8$, where the
u'-g' colors also correspond well with our uvw2$--$uvw1 colors.  While chasing the
optical light to high redshifts will require observing into the infrared,
the use of rest frame UV light can be done with optical and near-IR observations
possible with current and planned large ground based telescopes.

\citet{Aldering_etal_2006}
discuss many uses for rest-frame UV observations of these high redshift SNe
in the context of SNAP, and this local sample should allow a comparison
looking for evolutionary effects.  Since SNAP is planned to have
logarithmically spaced filters beginning at 4000 \AA, they will cover the restframe
UV observed by the UVOT filters for redshifts beyond z$\sim0.8$.
More generally, any deep SN search
optimized for finding and following high redshift SNe in the optical will likely
also detect the rest-frame UV light of SNe (preferentially SNe II due to their
brighter UV luminosities) at the high end of
their target redshift and beyond.
Measuring SN rates at higher redshifts is only one of many uses of these high redshift detections.
Making full use of this data will require a better
understanding of the UV light best obtained for nearby SNe for which multi-wavelength
photometry and spectroscopy over a larger portion of the light curve is possible.
Rest-frame UV observations of a local sample of SNe have the further advantage
of being a comparison sample with which to understand the high redshift SNe,
look for evolutionary differences (see e.g. \citealp{Foley_etal_2007, Ellis_etal_2008}),
and further constrain photometric redshifts,
extinction, and luminosity distances.

\section{Future Work}

We have presented here the largest collection of UV light curves obtained by
any single instrument, which have allowed the study of individual objects as well
as comparisons within and across SN types.  In addition to these apparent magnitudes, we are also
working to calibrate the absolute magnitudes to many of these objects (Brown et al.
in preparation).
The absolute magnitudes can be used to study the utility of rest frame UV
observations for cosmological measurements and for determining high redshift SN rates.
We are also combining this data with optical and near-infrared observations to
construct bolometric lightcurves that encompass more of the spectrum for individual objects
 and refining bolometric corrections used in constructing bolometric curves
from optical data alone (cf. \citealp{Contardo_etal_2000}).
The light curve shapes and colors of our large sample should also help in the
classification of SNe, particularly at higher redshifts when spectra are
unobtainable and fewer rest-frame optical bands are observable.
Future UV observatories, including a refurbished HST, TAUVEX \citep{Safonova_etal_2007},
WSO-UV \citep{Pagano_etal_2008} and others, as well as optical observatories observing
the high redshift universe, can also benefit from these light curves
to better understand and plan effective UV SN observations.

\acknowledgements
This work made use of public data from the {\sl Swift} data archive.
This work is supported at Penn State by NASA Contract NAS5-00136
and {\sl Swift} Guest Investigator grant NNH06ZDA001N.