I registered a complaint on pgportal and its status as follows.
Action by Department of Administrative Reforms and public Grievance
Copy of a letter No. 5/1051/2013-TFS from GOI, Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Department of Commerce, Trade Finance Section.
Shri Viju Chacko
Secretary in charge
Kottayam – 686002 (Kerala)
Subject: Electronic Grievance Registration No. DOCOM/E/2013/00065 dated 6.3.2013 of Shri S. Chandrasekharan Nair, regarding mistakes in Indian Rubber Statistics
I am directed to refer the electronic grievance on the above subject forwarded on CPGRAMS on 6.3.2013.
2. It is requested that this department may be apprised of the latest status of action taken in the mater as DARPG is closely monitoring and pressing hard for early redressal and disposal of the grievance.
Copy for information to:
1. Department of Administrative Reforms and public Grievance, (Kind Attn: MS Pratibha Ahuja, Under secretary), 5th floor, Sardar Patel Bhavan, New Delhi – 110001.
2. Shri S. Chandrasekharan nair, C/o shri Raghav, Perukavu, Peyad – PO, Thiruvananthapuram – 695 573 Kerala.
latest status of my complaint. thanks to http://pgportal.gov.in/ViewStatus.aspx
Status as on 01 May 2013 Registration Number : DOCOM/E/2013/00065
Name Of Complainant : S Chandrasekharan Nair
Date of Receipt : 06 Mar 2013
Received by : Department of Commerce
Forwarded to : Rubber Board
Officer name : Viju Chacko FCA
Officer Designation : Secretary i c&Director Fin
Contact Address : Sub-Jail Road, P.B. No. 1122, Kottayam, Kerala
Contact Number : 04812301231
e-mail : firstname.lastname@example.org
Grievance Description : Sir The Indian Rubber Statistics published by Rubber Board with mathematical errors which lime light large quantity of Rubber missing.
Current Status : UNDER PROCESS
Date of Action : 30 Apr 2013
A reply received from the Secretary
I am sorry to say that you are wrong. I was analyzing the Indian Rubber Statistics from 1999 onwards. By purchasing Annual Rubber Statistics published by the Rubber Board periodically. Kindly verify the following spread sheets published online. If I done a mistake I have to correct the same.
I request the Secretary of Rubber Board to verify the above analysis published by me and give me a reply as soon as possible.
The latest annual rubber statistics Vol 35 of 2012 also purchased by me to compile the details published by the Rubber Board.
The international price of RSS 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 at Bangkok, Thailand are collected and converted to INR by the Rubber Board to publish on the site. Price Latex 60% drc and SMR 20 at Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia on the same manner. Domestic market price at Kottayam and Kochi collected and published by the Board. The sister concern of MRF the printed media Malayalamanorama publishing daily the price of RSS 4 and 5 below 3 rupees on Rubber board price. The same market price is followed by the local Dealers in Kerala. Thus purchase by the small scale dealers as ISS is a common factor. The profit divides between middlemen and the quality sheets will reach MRF go-down at low rate on a comparison of grade.
The monthly rubber statistical news http://rubberboard.org.in/monstatsdisplay.asp published by the Rubber Board can’t tally the monthly average price of Latex 60% drc http://rubberboard.org.in/monthlyrubberprice.asp Here is an evidence of Export of wet weight of 16056 Tonnes exported at higher price when the drc was 9634 Tonnes. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/pub?hl=ml&key=0AsBRb8VTiF95dHF0UkpsbEk1S0dsdzRvQUszZTZlVGc&gid=1 The exporters of natural rubber is controlled and licensed by the Rubber Board. The low priced export available in the spread sheet updated from Indian Rubber Statistics vol 35 of 2012. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/pub?key=0AsBRb8VTiF95cFRzWENaU3gzUWttdHZrSnBlemdLRXc&output=html The export of Natural Rubber from India to Malaysia for the year 2011-12 was 4273 Tonnes at a value of 688,000,000 rupees at an average of 161.01/kg. As per the instructions of WTO Malaysia can implement an anti dumping duty which may be the deference between market price and imported price.
The benefits of export import from WTO are encouraged by the irregularities on price. it may be the reason for the deposits of black money at Swiss Bank. The names of Arun Mamen and Rahul Mamen related with black money we know from the English and Hindi Media. Malayalam media knowingly avoided their name from publishing. the data of import published by the rubber board is not sufficient to calculate the irregularities. https://spreadsheets.google.com/pub?key=p1eoUtcZuHJfjLuKYZwqKHA
An analysis of Indian Rubber Statistics published by a Farmer is not available in any other sites. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/pub?key=0AjJUDQUJ7CS-cDFlb1V0Y1p1SEplNi00R21hd3BfTUE&output=html which contains a missing figure obtained from the total availability by adding opening stock, production and import can’t tally by the subtraction of export, consumption and balance stock. http://sites.google.com/a/keralafarmeronline.com/missing/ Missing is always not the same. It will continue for few years as negative and positive alternately. negative missing is that which figures of balance stock is greater than actual stock and positive missing wise versa. This missing had a great role in price fluctuation. When the stock is higher Rubber Board publishes a positive missing (Stock below actual) to permit the import with out anti dumping duty.
The joint venture of political parties, bulk dealers, rubber board and the media are responsible for the price fluctuation of natural rubber. The speculation of media is supported by the statistics and economic experts.
Rubber Board is responsible for the price fluctuations of natural rubber not only in India, but also at International market
For more details Visit: https://sites.google.com/a/keralafarmeronline.com/stats/Home/indian-rubber-statistics-its-analysis
Translated the document in Hindi from Malayalam and shared with Sri Arvind Kejriwal with edit option. I am confident that he should understand the details of corruption of Rubber Board led by Political Parties. An open challenge with rubber growers done by this statutory body is supported by the Indian Media. We have to change it. AAP Kerala can do a good job to spread the irregularities in front of common man at grass root level.
Performance of Natural Rubber 2011-12 Stock at the beginning of the year 253975 Tonnes Area 734780 hectares 3.3 % Growth Production 903700 Tonnes 4.8% Growth Consumption 964415 Tonnes 1.8% Growth Import 213785 Tonnes –% Growth Export 27145 Tonnes – % Growth Average Market Price for RSS 4 grade Rs. 20805/100Kg Rs. 208.05 per Kg Stock at the end of the year 236275 Tonnes 236275 + 149550 Tonnes Number of small holdings 1.2 Million Number of large estates 538 Average yield per hectare 1841 Kg Customs duty on Natural rubber Solid Form 20% or Rs 20/kg which ever is lower Latex 70.00% or Rs 49/kg which ever is lower
Value of Natural Rubber Imported Rs. 4248.2 crore Rs. 198.71 per Kg Value of Natural Rubber Exported Rs. 441.3 crore Rs. 162.57 per Kg Value of rubber products imported Rs. 5074.16 crore (2010-11) Value of rubber products exported Rs. 11514.27 crore Income from NR to growers Rs. 18800 crore Cess of NR collected Rs. 101.01 crore —– Tonnes at cess Rs. 2/kg (Import 213785 + Purchase 758961 Tonnes?) Number of licensed dealers 9593 Number of licensed manufacturers 4386 Tyre and Non-tyre consumption ratio 65:35 NR and SR consumption ratio 69:31 Per capita consumption of elastomer 1.14 Kg Tyre industry turnover Rs. 43000 crores Tyre production 125.40 Million Numbers Value of tyre exports Rs. 4209 crores Costoms duty on tyres World production 10.978 million tonnes World consumption 10.919 million tonnes World NR & SR consumption ratio 42:58 International price RSS 3 Rs. 20915/100 Kg Rs. 209.15 per Kg
Opening Stock 277600 Tonnes Consumption 964415 Tonnes Production 903700 Tonnes Export 27145 Tonnes Import 213785 Tonnes Balance Stock 236275 Tonnes Missing 167250 Tonnes Total 1395085 Tonnes Total 1395085 Tonnes
Can you imagine how India got the productivity of 1819 kg/hectare in 2011. It is a mathematical game. Highest monthly production and lower balance stock at the end of December. World statistics covers from January to December and India April to March. Thus a comparison is impossible.If 90067 Tonnes for the year 2011 is +Ve missing how the productivity increased?
Will be published
Join Trivandrum Bloggers Group
|Visit this group|
The world’s greatest scam?
A Real Farmer
- News (165)
- Agriculture (67)
- GNU-Linux (23)
- General (605)
- Letter to Ministers (5)
- Rubber (140)
- right to information (9)
- Help (8)
- Technology (14)
- Spices (1)
- My communities
- My personal Rubber Statistics
- My Programmes
- Dr. Shashi Tharoor a different MP
- My Other Blogs
- My videos – Audios
- Online News
- Complete list of Cabinet ministers and portfolios
- Few Important Links
- Sorry, but this post is not available in English
- Organic Farming
- Monthly Rubber Statistical News
- Rubber Statistics
- Rubber Board Phone. Numbers
- Did you want to install GNU/Linux?
- RTI Information: Unwanted information given by the Rubber Board on First appeal under RTI Act – 2005
- keralafarmer on പാല് ചുരത്തുവാന് അകിട് വേണ്ട
- പ്രധാനപ്പെട്ട ചില പോസ്റ്റുകള് on Grading on Rubber
- An evidence of the Violation of RTI Act | IAC Trivandrum on Excellence in Export Award for the export at the rate of Rs. 2.13/Kg for RSS4
- An evidence of the Violation of RTI Act | IAC Trivandrum on First appeal under RTI Act – 2005
- മാതൃഭൂമിയ്ക്കിതെങ്ങനെ കിട്ടി? « റബ്ബര് വാര്ത്തകള് on Performance of Natural Rubber 2010-11
- ബ്രൊമാഡിയോലോണ് എന്ന എലിവിഷം മനുഷ്യനും ഹാനികരം on Sorry, but this post is not available in English
- കര്ഷകരോട് എന്തിനീ ശത്രുത on Sorry, but this post is not available in English
- Rss 3 Price | AllGraphicsOnline.com on Rubber Prices for the month of August 2008
- ഡോ. ആര്. ഗോപിമണിയ്ക്ക് ഭ്രാന്താണോ? « കാര്ഷിക വാര്ത്തകള് on നാളികേര കര്ഷകരുടെ ശ്രദ്ധയ്ക്ക്