The government is reviewing the book 'May13: Declassified Documents on the Malaysian Riots of 1969' authored by Dr Kua Kia Soong to provide an alternative account of the tragic event.
Although several academics interviewed voiced varied concerns surrounding the nature of the book, it should be considered an academic contribution to enhance our understanding of the tragic event.
Prof Shamsul Amri Baharuddin of Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia and the head the Ethnic Relations Module drafting committee said there was no need to jump to conclusions on the book. “They should read the book first and make judgement later. It’s a bad habit among Malaysians,” he said.
Similarly, former World Bank analyst Dr Lim Teck Ghee said the government reaction towards the book was counterproductive and that a ban would eventually be circumvented by electronic communication. “It will further reinforce the public perception that the government has much to hide or cover up in this watershed event of Malaysian history.:
Reknowned historian Prof Khoo Kay Khim however expressed caution over the book and questions the validity of the sources cited. “I don’t think he got very much. If he had access to (police) Special Branch files he might probably get more accurate information,” said Khoo.
Differing academic views should be encouraged and eye-witnesses should be coaxed to come forward to narrate what actually happened during the bloody riots.
Our understanding of the event will help the nation to exorcise the ghost of the May 13th and move forward more confidently as a nation united. The event should not no longer be politicised.
Speaking against the potential ban, Dr Toh Kin Woon said:
Of course, one can disagree with his analysis and viewpoints. If so, one should then engage in a debate with him. But at no time must his book be confiscated and the public denied access to his book.
Unfortunately, this is what is being done. As a result, the freedom to write and speak is once again being curtailed. It looks like the fear of many is coming true in that the government only wants its official version and views on various issues such as the struggle for independence and May 13 disseminated. But this clearly cannot be accepted.
I echo his opinion and urge the government to allow the sale of the book. Individuals and academicians with deferring views should be welcomed to counter Dr Kua's findings.
If Professor Khoo has special access to the Special Branch files, Malaysians would welcome his disclosure.