Unfortunately for Tony, that meant that Abby had plenty of time to share office gossip. Abby usually didn’t mean anything bad by it, but she was always super friendly and talkative when a new girl joined the office. Tony wasn’t sure if she ever did that with new guys, but Abby definitely loved making new girl friends. So, Caitlin quickly discovered the "Tony is a playboy’ gossip and Tony did nothing to dissuade them the next time he saw them. He only smirked at the disgusted stares from Kate and laughter from Abby. He even fired back, talking about women who didn’t exist and making up grand stories about them. He loved the look on Kate’s face, the wideness of her eyes and how innocent and naive she was.