I have reviewed the case of Hugo Black, and I believe he has a good case for appeal. The particulars of his case are as follows. His victim Gregory Hammersmith had challenged Hugo Black to a duel, using an ancient custom of official duelling to settle disputes which have persisted in some of the more remote villages and hamlets. Gregory claimed at the time that Hugo had wooed his wife Penelope Hammersmith and had also turned her against him. Hugo claims to this day that this is untrue. He did solicit his wife to leave Gregory because, in his opinion, Gregory was a brute and had caused Penelope significant harm in the past. He claims there were no romantic feelings from either party, but I can find no evidence to support his argument or to the contrary.