Pansy falls into both categories. Despite the chaos, I noticed that she only defended herself and never attacked. She's not a fighter, never has been, and Smith still cursed her, that irascible bastard. In doing so, he provoked the death of a person who might survive the Exit and thus be useful to the Resistance. His behavior was exceptionally stupid. I actually thought Potter's orders were sacred to the rebels, but hey, idiots are obviously everywhere.