Of course, it could all be a trick; she knew that. But why give her the note in the first place, a note that felt brutally honest and true to Nott’s character. It didn’t add up. She had questioned the kindness of Daphne and Blaise, but hearing Malfoy’s earlier explanation made sense. Daphne was an older sister, no wonder she instinctively would seek to comfort the women around her, and Blaise was probably too scared of her to go against anything she asked. So, why did Theo now wish to treat her with dignity - especially after performing quite a harsh unforgivable on her. 