And yet they'd gone the same path. They'd nearly killed each other at the last Quidditch game before graduation, they'd hated each other, anyone with eyes could see they would had died before taking orders from the same leader ... and then. How much of that hatred had been a lie, Remus wondered? Had the Black brothers been lying? (When Regulus died, James and Lily had had to actually sedate Sirius to keep him from having a dramatic and probably violent breakdown, and not everyone had been surprised.) Had Sirius been a spy all along? Had all their time at Hogwarts been a lie? (If it was, Remus maybe didn't want to know.)