• The only two published studies on subliminal anchoring report contradictory results. • In two replications of these studies we could not find any evidence for subliminal anchoring. • Replications were as close as possible and high data quality was ensured, for example by introducing new manipulation checks. • Both our studies feature entirely open materials and preregistration of all materials including the analysis scripts. OPEN SCIENCE BADGES: Please grant all three badges, Preregistration, Open Materials, and Open Data.
Evidence against subliminal anchoring: Two close, highly powered, preregistered, and failed replication attempts