We investigate the optimal response of unemployment insurance to economic shocks, both with and without commitment. The optimal policy with commitment follows a modified Baily-Chetty formula that accounts for job search responses to future UI benefit changes. As a result, the optimal policy with commitment tends to front-load UI, unlike the optimal discretionary policy. In response to shocks intended to mimic those that induced the COVID-19 recession, we find that a large and transitory increase in UI is optimal;and that a policy rule contingent on the change in unemployment, rather than its level, is a good approximation to the optimal policy.
Whether, When and How to Extend Unemployment Benefits: Theory and Application to COVID-19