Although I myself have to put a lot of work into this to get even close to Minecraft, I'm already in deep dept of many other modders in the Minetest forums. This subgame would probably have been much harder without their hard work. I'm also in very deep dept for the textures. Without the hard work of the texture pack makers in the Minecraft community, this subgame might not have even got started. Huge thanks go to daredevils for creating MineClone. I applaud you that you made it that far. Finally, kudos to Jordach for the jukebox music compilation from Big Freaking Dig.Thanks for the absolutely insane people who spend days after days in writing pages for the Minecraft Wiki with absurd attention to detail. I can basically use the wiki as my software requirements. ;-) I am thankful, but I still call you insane because you probably could save a lot of work by using some form of automation, but it seems most of the wiki is hand-written (just like Minetest Community Wiki).It breaks my heart to see the entire wiki is under CC BY-SA-NC. Are community contributers aware that they basically surrender their copyright to Mojang AB when they post anything here?

TODO: Name all mod authors and put links into this list.

Mods (oh gosh, this list is outdated, I get tired of updating this list every release. Sorry …):

mcl_autogroup

mcl_init

mcl_sounds

beds

mcl_books

bucket

mcl_commands

mcl_craftguide

craftingpack

mcl_core

doors

drippingwater

mcl_dye

mcl_farming

mcl_fire

mcl_fishing

mcl_flowers

gemalde

mcl_colorblocks

hbarmor

hbhunger

mcl_heads

hudbars

mcl_item_entity

itemframes

mcl_boats

mcl_cake

mcl_clock

mcl_cocoas

mcl_compass

mcl_death

mcl_end

mcl_ender_pearl

mcl_fences

mcl_flowers

mcl_flowerpots

mcl_hoppers

mcl_jukebox

mcl_minecarts

mcl_mobitems

mcl_nether

mcl_player

mcl_potions

mcl_throwing

mcl_temp_helper_recipes

mcstair

minetest-3d_armor (modpack)

mobs (Mobs Redo)

mobs_mc

playerplus

random_struct

mcl_mapgen_core

redstone (modpack, fork of Mesecons)

signs

mcl_sprint

stairs

mcl_tnt

mcl_torches

walkover

mcl_walls

mcl_wool

xpanes

weather_pack

lightning

flowlib

mcl_ocean

mcl_maps

Don't trust the mod names! Many mods (but not all) have been modified beyond recognition from the original, compability is NOT guaranteed.Mods starting with “mcl_” are mods specifically made/modified for MineClone 2.

Here is a list of some things to change/fix:-torches need to be animated-inventory armor pic needs to be fixed (player preview breaks)-need to be able to punch items to pick up, not just stand close to-cacti need to hurt-need to access player inven in creative (in creative, there is not player preview or armor slots or 2x2 grid)-search realtime (so no need for enter like in minecraft, player type 'C', list of things shortened to things start w/ 'C', add an 'A', shorten down to things start with 'Ca', etc...)-real scroll bar in inven-creeper texture fix (no face, lop sided?)-creeper animation-better arrow mod-fix spider texture (4 or 8 eyes, not 2...)-eat cake (simulate by on_punch change the model and set_hp)-lever,button,solar,piston,command blocks, pressure plates, and other redstone stuff should be included in redstone tab-ender pearl-fix lever model and rotation (is not like MC and is not floor/celing mountable atm)-heads and pumpkins wearable-fix flying villages (villages floating mid-air)-fix burning villages (i come to village and building burns down. Lava in blacksmith maybe? also, fire spread is EXTREMLY fast...)-villagers?-fix boat texture (is not there)-much much much MUCH taller jungle trees-vines on JUST jungle trees-cocoa (in jungle trees)-pages in books-longer eating time-piston sounds-slime block stickyness-keep inven tabs symbol when select (symbols disapere)-tnt needs to fly more when propelled and not light by torch, light by flintsteel-faster snowball-fishingpole line-fix noteblock sounds-gold hearts-fix web (when I dig a web, i get unknown item)-fix fact that web takes 30 seconds with a DIAMOND pic!!!-make all blocks almost insta-dig in creative-background music-anvil (w/ naming?)-enchantments (there is mod for that)-auto-cornerstairs-all redstone things activate tnt-hitting needs to not ignite TNT (i can light tnt with my hand atm)-when player touch lava/fire player ignite temporarily (fire img on hud and extended dmg)-fix world gen keep going thru bedrock. stop it at about -100 so no extra gen. maybe put nether and end in the area freed by stopping world gen-bedrock should contain tnt and not let blast radius out (bedrock stayes, but nodes around it dont-chest open anim (or at least open model)-chest lock 3d-fix item frame texture-rotate items in frame-3d redstone torches-shearing sheep should not sound like snow-repeater should send signal in front of it and one below/front of it

-search realtime (so no need for enter like in minecraft, player type 'C', list of things shortened to things start w/ 'C', add an 'A', shorten down to things start with 'Ca', etc...)

Not possible with the current engine yet. :-(Thanks for spotting these engine limitations, they should be posted on GitHub.

-longer eating time

No idea how to do this.

-fishingpole line

No idea how this should work with the current engine. The pole would be doable, but not the line. But more importantly, fishing needs to be much slower anyway (no instant cheap fish).

-slime block stickyness

I need an explanation for this. Isn't the slime block supposed to be bouncy?

-fix fact that web takes 30 seconds with a DIAMOND pic!!!

LOL! The cobweb is not supposed to be dug by a pickaxe. Maybe this is just the digging time of the hand, so this is correct behaviour. Try shears or sword. http://minecraft.gamepedia.com/CobwebCan you tell me the digging time of a diamond pickaxe on cobweb in Minecraft?

-background music

There is a jukebox. But sound effects need more love as well, sure. I need to know a good libre resource pack, otherwise I have to search each sound on my own, which is probably of lower priority.

This will be (hopefully) added when I add status effects. Maybe my old playereffects mod will finally pay off! :-)Oh, wait, it only supports players at the moment, not all entities. So I need to update this mod either way. :-/

-enchantments (there is mod for that)

Link, please.

-fix world gen keep going thru bedrock. stop it at about -100 so no extra gen. maybe put nether and end in the area freed by stopping world gen

Good idea. That's basically what I planned, too, by using a layering technique. Void and bedrock will be used that the player can never legally enter the other “dimensions” by movement alone (no portals).The nether is easy as it is completely enclosed in bedrock. The End is trickier. If I put it very high then the end islands will cast shadows on the overworld. If I put it underground, then it will lack “sunlight”, but maybe I can fake it somehow.

Maybe: Overworld: -100 .. +31000. Nether: -30000 .. 29744 (fixed size). The End: -28744 .. -1100. Bedrock forms the “dimension” boundaries, the remaining space will become the Void which kills the player very quickly. I am not sure about these numbers. Maybe I want to keep the possibility to add mod support for more dimensions, then I need to rethink this.

All other comments: 100% agree!

I am aware of most of the problems, but some of the things you mentioned are new to me. I can use your list as my TODO list. So, thanks! :-)

I'm creating MineClone 2, a Minecraft clone for Minetest. I made the Help modpack, adding in-game help to Minetest.

I need an explanation for this. Isn't the slime block supposed to be bouncy?

Indeed! But if used with a piston, it should move blocks along with it. Like the all-side sticky block in mesecons but bouncy as well

-enchantments (there is mod for that)

Link, please.

The mod is actually xdecor, which contains functional enchantment table.

I will eventually get back to you on the other questions (webs and items). EDIT: Cobwebs: thx 4 that :P dig by sword/shears says "0.4" whatev that means :P but if hand takes "20", then I think that diamond pick can stay as is xD

I also suggest watching some Minecrafters on youtube (MagmaMusen [creative w/ blocks and such], PrestonPlays [pvp and tnt wars expert imo], MumboJumbo [redstone mega-expert], DanTDM [idk i just watch him :P], BajanCanadian [also dunno...], etc...). It might get you more acquainted with MC.

Oops, I thought you meant the slime block is supposed to be sticky to players, meaning they can't jump on it. I was already aware that the slime block is supposed to be sticky to block when moved by a piston. I think the Mesecons sticky block is still buggy, which is why it can't be crafted and looks ugly.

Times are in seconds in the Minecraft Wiki.

And yes, I already watched way more MC videos than is good for my mental health. xD

Enchanting looks challenging to implement. But on first sight in Minecraft is is WAY more complex than in xdecor. So either I find a better mod or I have to implement it on my own.But xdecor has many nice Minecraft-like features I could use, I already noticed. I guess I will take the ender chest from it.

I'm creating MineClone 2, a Minecraft clone for Minetest. I made the Help modpack, adding in-game help to Minetest.

FYI: I am getting this info from my cousin who actually plays Minecraft somewhat regularly.Fire technically should not be obtainable even in creative mode.Lava/water sources should also not be obtainable. Just never-ending buckets.

I can't download the subgame from that website it does nothing like if the link was down.

Weird. It works for me. Sure you clicked on the link labeled “Download” and NOT on the “Git” link?

xeranas:Jeez, why is there always so much hate against repo.or.cz? It's just a repository hoster. That's it! It's not a wiki/bug tracker/pull request manager/chat/forum/etc.Potential contributors should just start to learn Git. If you *only* know how to use GitHub, you don't know how to use Git. Git users should be able to use it regardless of the hoster. ESPECIALLY regardless of the bling-bling or not-so-bling-bling website built around it (if there even is one).

I use repo.or.cz simply because I feel more comfortable in using it. It's that simple. :-)Also, I dislike bloat and feature creep, like on GitHub.

Contributions to this project could work like this:Either send patches (for simple changes) or fork this repository (and host it WHEREVER you like!) and talk to me if you want to get your branch or feature or whatever. The “Pull Request” is sending a message to me. :PI think these “requirements” are really not too much to ask.

Also, Free Software != collaborative development.Please notice there is no guarantee I will accept any contribution. Simple reason, it's my project after all, and I am not really a collaborative worker. Reviewing pull requests just adds more work for me.A good way to get my attention is to simply write a good standalone mod which imitates a Minecraft feature well. Or point me towards a mod which does. Not neccessarily directly tailored towards MineClone 2, but in general. I'd like this approach even more because that way, other subgame authors could easily include your mod as well, benefitting the Minetest community as a whole. If I think the mod is well-programmed and including this mod would save me work, there are very good chances I include it. My requirement is that it reflects the Minecraft gameplay very well, but I am less strict about graphics or the GUI.If you REALLY want to directly contribute to MineClone 2, be warned: This project is in an early stage, so I will do many changes which WILL surprise you, in a bad way. Better talk to me about your precise intentions beforehand to avoid later tears. ;-)

But you DO have a point about bugtracking. The amount of bugs will obviously be HUGE (it already is ... :D). So I don't really have an excuse for not having a bugtracker. Sigh. I need to look around if I find a clean and simple solution which doesn't make me puke. :DThe GitHub bugtracker is pretty lame in my opinion.

But I will certainly NOT host a stinking wiki, as I think it is a HUGE timesink and is technically very questionable. I don't understand how wikis have nowadays become the accepted “norm” of game documentation although it is rotten to the core (excuse not to distribute help files with the game, excuse for developers not to write documentation (“Yay! Let players do the work WE were supposed to do.”), doomed to be redundant and inconsistent, very bad in crunshing number, fighting with the wiki software eats away precious contributer time, etc. etc.). While wikis may still have their place as *supplemental* and *non-essential* information sources (I think of strategy guides and other fan-created stuff), they should IMO never be a *replacement* for the core documentation.

Instead, I will add an in-game documentation, making a wiki obsolete. I will treat any help which is not distributed with the game (either in-game or as README or similar files) as non-existant. Because people have a right to be offline. :DAnyone can host their own wikis if they insist, but you will be mostly on your own.

Long story short: Sorry for sounding so arrogant here. The reason for this is because this is pretty much an one-person project. Well, if you ignore that I collect tons of work of others, that is. xD But you know what I mean.

FYI: I am getting this info from my cousin who actually plays Minecraft somewhat regularly.Fire technically should not be obtainable even in creative mode.Lava/water sources should also not be obtainable. Just never-ending buckets.

Thanks, noted. Keep these infos coming, if they can't be found in Minecraft Wiki.

I'm creating MineClone 2, a Minecraft clone for Minetest. I made the Help modpack, adding in-game help to Minetest.

As for project I suggest to define which version of Minecraft this clone aim to mimic (at least until first major milestone). Minecraft still releases new versions and it cloud be overwhelming difficult to catch up newest version content/functionality. For users it would be easier to report which parts still missing and for you it would be easier to decide which content will go on next phase and focus on current version remaining issues.

Wuzzy wrote:Long story short: Sorry for sounding so arrogant here. The reason for this is because this is pretty much an one-person project. Well, if you ignore that I collect tons of work of others, that is. xD But you know what I mean.

You could still host the project on GitHub for their more reliable service and more familiar user interface.

Just mention in the description that pull requests and feature requests may or may not be accepted. Some GitHub projects are very open by nature and merge almost any halfway reasonable PR, others are more tightly controlled and reject a lot of stuff. I don't see a problem with that as long as the project policy is spelled out clearly.

As for project I suggest to define which version of Minecraft this clone aim to mimic (at least until first major milestone). Minecraft still releases new versions and it cloud be overwhelming difficult to catch up newest version content/functionality. For users it would be easier to report which parts still missing and for you it would be easier to decide which content will go on next phase and focus on current version remaining issues.

Very good idea! You're totally right, it will be very hard to go after a “moving target”.I really haven't thought of it, I just base my requirements on the wiki, so my initial goal was just “latest version”.In this case it will be version 1.11.0, I guess.

Too bad they just have a wiki, and not a versioned documentation (another huge disadvantage of wikis). And I never really know to which version the text in a wiki page currently refers to, and if it is actually up-to-date. At least they wrote down a “history” section so I am not totally helpless.

I already heard Minecraft version 1.12.0 is on the way. I'm not sure if I'm going to recreate features of this version, too.

So maybe I first just try to stick with version 1.11.0. Simply because that's I hope the current state of the wiki is. As soon all features of 1.11.0 are done, I might go on with later versions. Since the goal is to recreate Minecraft, re-implementing new features should also be part of this project.

But yeah, I try to stick with version 1.11.0 for now, to not have a moving target.

GitHub for their more reliable service

Pics or it didn't happen. :P

Just mention in the description that pull requests and feature requests may or may not be accepted.

Yeah, this must go into the readme no matter where I host it.

I'm creating MineClone 2, a Minecraft clone for Minetest. I made the Help modpack, adding in-game help to Minetest.

- Complete rework of fences- Replace all mobs, use Mobs Redo 1.33 and mobs_mc. Many new mobs are now included, and they are much better now- Add monster spawner- Add 5 new fence types, one for each wood type- Rework HUD system, now uses hudbars- Clean up some creative inventory categories (redstone, foodstuffs, etc.)- Add corner stairs (hopefully it works)- Make redstone ore light up when being walked on- Make cacti hurt- Add suffocation- Cake can now be eaten- Adjust weapon damage and attack delay- Add milk (only a craft item for now)- Immediate digging in creative mode

IMPORTANT: Since I reorganized many mobs, I strongly advice you to start with a new world for testing. Future versions won't be different, as I am still reorganizing like crazy. Hopefully this won't take forever.

Having to press a button 20 times is NOT my definition of "it works". :-)

Wuzzy wrote:- Replace all mobs, use Mobs Redo 1.33 and mobs_mc. Many new mobs are now included, and they are much better now

Dogs attack the player even in creative mode. The other mobs seem to be OK in creative.

And the Ghast needs to be much larger and should probably have textures on the other sides too. :-)

Note that my villagers in Stampy game also have a primitive trading mode if you right click them. You cannot cycle through trades, you simply get a different trade offer each time you click. Maybe something you could put in MC2 too.

I don't know if this helps, but here is a subgame i made that was similar to MC. There are a few good mods in there like ender chest, ender pearl, compas, clock, and vines. Feel free to pick through this.

Thanks, maikerumine. MineClone 2 aready has compass, clock and vines, but not a functioning ender pearl and ender chest. I will keep your subgame in mind.

Version 0.3.0 released!

- Basic functionality of hoppers is implemented, based on the hoppers mod my jordan4ibanez. The have an inventory with 5 slots, suck in all items from above and put it into chests below- Redstone now drops when near water- Add a few missing node sounds- Pressure plates now have to be attached to the floor- Finally a proper formspec for large chests- Hide monster spawner in creative

Hoppers are not perfectly re-implemented yet, but this is of course planned for the future.

I'm creating MineClone 2, a Minecraft clone for Minetest. I made the Help modpack, adding in-game help to Minetest.