濒危动物：为什么防止物种灭绝十分重要 - 世界经济论坛
2020年的一篇论文指出，如果没有保护计划，1993年至2020年的鸟类和哺乳动物灭绝率将高出约3-4倍。Cox说，大象、鲨鱼或老虎这样的关键物种对于生态系统明显有 ...
颇具争议的亲商综合法
天蓝寿带鸟是在桑吉河群岛发现的几种鸟类之一，该群岛大约位于印度尼西亚苏拉威西岛和菲律宾棉兰老岛之间。桑吉河南部的一座死火山——萨亨达鲁曼山上现存的主要雨林，是这群有着明显白色眼圈的淡色蓝鸟最后的据点。自从印尼 <anchor>颇具争议的亲商综合法</anchor> 通过后，这个栖息地就受到了采矿业的威胁。加拿大一家金矿开采公司获得了一项采矿权，该采矿权覆盖了桑吉河一半以上的土地，但目前尚不清楚该采矿权是否有效。国际鸟盟与当地非政府组织Burung Indonesia一道，一直在与社区合作来保护剩下的山地森林。Jain说：“我们一直在努力让政府、社区和利益相关者参与进来，以确保这一地区不会被开采。但我们仍然非常担心，因为萨亨达鲁曼山的植被即使是稍有损失，也将是绝对的坏消息。”
Activists want repeal of Indonesia’s controversial new law, while investors warn of 'severe' environmental, human rights repercussions | News | Eco-Business | Asia Pacific
MenuSearch

English

- English
- 简体中文
- Bahasa Indonesia
- Bahasa Malaysia

Search
Close search bar

Show all news, opinion, videos and press releases matching  →

#### About Eco-Business

#### Topics

#### Tags

#### Regions

#### Sustainable Development Goals

#### Series

International Edition

International Edition

Search Eco-Business
Search

# Activists want repeal of Indonesia’s controversial new law, while investors warn of ‘severe’ environmental, human rights repercussions

## Meant to draw domestic and foreign investment, Indonesia’s new Omnibus Law on Job Creation has triggered massive outrage over weakening of protection for workers and the environment.

omnibus law protest
Indonesia’s new Job Creation Law has triggered widespread protests. Image: Monitor Civicus, CC BY-SA 4.0

https://www.eco-business.com/news/activists-want-repeal-of-indonesias-controversial-new-law-while-investors-warn-of-severe-environmental-human-rights-repercussions/

Copy

By

Johanes Hutabarat and Jennar Kiansantang

5 minute read

Oct. 12, 2020

Read the story in Bahasa Indonesia here.

### To continue reading, subscribe to Eco‑Business.

#### There's something for everyone. We offer a range of subscription plans.

- Access our stories and receive our Insights Weekly newsletter with the free EB Member plan.
- Unlock unlimited access to our content and archive with EB Circle.
- Publish your content with EB Premium.

As protests in Indonesia continue against a controversial jobs creation bill passed in parliament last week, environmental and labour activists are calling for the new law to be repealed and for the government to conduct more extensive consultations with stakeholders.

The country’s largest Muslim group, Nahdlatul Ulama,  and labour organisations have said they will seek a judicial review at the Constitutional Court, while several provincial governors have opposed the law or said they would relay protesters’ demands to president Joko Widodo.

Calling for the government to revoke the Job Creation Law by issuing a regulation in lieu of law, Iswan Abdullah, vice-president of the Indonesian Trade Union Confederation (KSPI), added: “Or maybe it’s better to restart the deliberation and open it to the stakeholders. So far, it seems to be just for the corporations. The government must be wise not to trigger instability.”

Wahyu Perdana, campaign manager for food, water, and essential ecosystems at the Indonesian Forum for the Environment (Walhi), told Eco-Business the repeal of the law is “not negotiable”.

The 905-page Omnibus Law on Job Creation, spanning 15 chapters, revises 79 existing laws that do away with overlapping rules on a wide range of issues. Meant to stimulate domestic and foreign investment by getting rid of certain licensing requirements and inefficiencies, it has triggered a massive outcry over provisions that would weaken protection for workers and the environment.

From Medan to Makassar, tens of thousands of people have poured onto the streets in protests across more than 20 cities in the past week. Thousands of protestors have been arrested and the police have deployed tear gas and water cannons.

President Widodo has said that the protests were “basically driven by disinformation about the law’s substance and social media hoaxes”. He reiterated that the new law was meant to improve workers’ welfare and that the government urgently needs to create jobs for the 2.9 million young Indonesians who enter the labour market each year.

The Covid-19 pandemic has also hit Indonesia’s economy and caused millions of workers to lose their livelihoods. As of end-July, about 3.5 million workers in formal and informal employment had been laid off due to the pandemic.

Some observers have noted that without reforms, Indonesia’s labour-intensive industries will remain unattractive to investors due to labour regulations that are too rigid and make it almost impossible to terminate a permanent employee.

But they also acknowledged that workers’ interests must be protected and that wages must enable them to meet the basic cost of living.

The new law cuts severance pay of workers from a maximum of 32 months to 25 months (inclusive of support from the Workers’ Social Security Agency), and removes a two-year cap on firms keeping workers on contract, allowing them to do so indefinitely.

Timboel Siregar, secretary-general of the Indonesian Workers Organisation (OPSI), noted that it alters minimum wage standards, putting workers at a disadvantage.

According to the previous provision, Act No.13/ 2003 Concerning Manpower, a company has to adjust minimum wage to a city or regency’s minimum wage standards, which are usually higher than provincial wage standards.

“If every city or regency now refers to the province’s minimum wage standards, the workers’ income will drop and purchasing power also drops,” said Siregar.

The new regulation will apply to workers hired after the law was passed, but Siregar said this poses the risk to existing employees. “In the near future, maybe there will be massive layoffs where a company will hire new workers to replace the old ones, so they can pay for cheaper wages,” he said.

The new law also imposes no limits to the types of jobs that can be outsourced. This differs from the previous rule that only permitted five types of jobs to be outsourced: Catering, mining support services, driving, cleaning, and security service, Siregar said.

#### ‘Counterintuitive’ to weaken environmental protection

Critics have also questioned why the government involved the Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, but not the wider public, when the proposed law was drafted.

The omnibus law’s weaker environmental safeguards have also drawn the attention of global investors and environmental activists.

Concerns include procedures governing how nature exploration permits are granted—for instance, the new law reduces the participation of communities in environmental impact assessments for industrial and agribusiness projects, said Walhi’s Perdana.

It poses a threat to Indonesia’s rich tropical forests by eliminating the need to maintain at least 30 per cent forest cover in provincial lands. “The bill may escalate deforestation, ” he said.

Environmental campaign group Mighty Earth said the new law empowers the central government to approve business and investment in officially designated forest and peatland areas, which are currently under a deforestation moratorium. It also eliminates strict legal liability for companies with fires occurring on their concession areas, which has served as a key incentive for companies to prevent and extinguish fires and refrain from burning, Mighty Earth added.

Last Monday (5 October) when the bill was passed, 36 global investors that manage US$4.1 trillion in assets warned of its potentially “severe environmental, human rights and labour-related repercussions”.

“Efforts to stimulate foreign investment by weakening regulations, such as easing restrictions on clearing land in palm oil concessions, are counterintuitive in light of investors’ growing desire for environmental protections and rising international demand for responsible commodity production and regulation on imported deforestation,” the investors said in an open letter. Signatories included Aviva Investors, the Church of England Pensions Board, and Japan’s Sumitomo Mitsui Trust Asset Management.

The European parliament is, for instance, moving towards a legal framework to ensure deforestation-free supply chains, they noted.  This year, concerns over deforestation in the supply chain “almost derailed” the approval of a trade deal between the European Union and the Mercosur states of Argentina, Brazil Paraguay and Uruguay this year.

“Instead of rolling back these regulations, we urge [the government of Indonesia] to take a longer-term perspective and adopt a ‘green’ recovery plan to address the economic devastation caused by the pandemic,” the investors said.

Johanes Hutabarat and Jennar Kiansantang are part of the Eco-Business regional journalist network. To join this network or pitch your stories, write to editors@eco-business.com.

### Related to this story

##### Topics

##### Regions

##### Tags

##### SDGs

### Most popular

- #### News  /      Energy

### Indonesia and Singapore advance low-carbon energy deals

Singapore is set to import 3.4 gigawatts of low-carbon electricity from its neighbour, following substantive progress made by …

- #### News  /      Carbon & Climate

### Digital transformation key to future-proofing climate-stressed Southeast Asia: report

EB Studio

Southeast Asia is a particularly vulnerable region to climate threats. Digital solutions may be key to helping the …

- #### News  /      Policy & Finance

### Rabobank backs Musim Mas’ first sustainability-linked loan without finalising external verifiers

The palm oil giant says "reputable assessors" will track progress against goals in its US$217 million loan for …

- #### News  /      Policy & Finance

### US election 2024: How Kamala Harris and Donald Trump differ starkly on energy and climate

On 5 November, US voters will elect either Kamala Harris or Donald Trump as their next president.

- #### News  /      Cities

### ‘I need to plant more trees than they cut’: Cambodia’s environment minister wants to boost nation’s green credentials

Exclusive

Eang Sophalleth acknowledges that the problem of deforestation does not go away with just tree-planting. But at the …

- #### News  /      Waste Management

### Climate action through circularity and waste management: Malaysian palm oil company IOI’s approach

Integrated palm oil player, IOI Corporation Berhad adopts a holistic approach towards waste management and is committed to …

### Featured Events

- #### Thailand

### SEA of Solutions 2024 | Hybrid

18 Sep 2024 • Conference

- #### Jakarta

### The 10th Indonesia International Geothermal Convention & Exhibition (IIGCE) 2024

18 Sep 2024 • Conference

- #### Makati

### Strengthening resilience: Scaling the Philippine private sector’s net zero ambitions

19 Sep 2024 • Conference

- #### Singapore

### Cities: Possibilities 2024 – A CapitaLand Sustainability Edition

28 Oct 2024 • Conference

## Transforming Innovation for Sustainability Join the Ecosystem →

### Receive the latest news in sustainability, daily or weekly.

## Strategic Organisations

#### Sections

#### Services

#### Subscribe

#### About

#### Policy

© Eco-Business 2009—2024

### Support our independent journalism. #newsthatimpacts