" 

 :I understand, and appreciate your explanation of the situation. The perception of the list's purpose changing is accurate though, the different names each describe different lists the page has been as you are aware. To your knowledge has anyone explained this to him/her? Using an example sentence about Dylan I'll illustrate why the title of the current list should include Dylan. 
 :;Bob Dylan's religious affiliation can best be currently described as Jewish, however he had previously converted to Christianity for a time. 
 :# ""List of converts to Christianity"" implies a list of people who are Christian converts. The key word being are. Bob Dylan is not a current convert of Christianity and so wouldn't belong on that list. 
 :# ""List of notable converts to Christianity"" implies the same current status as the previous name but excludes unknown/not notable people. Even though Dylan is notable, he still isn't a current convert, so also wouldn't belong on this list. 
 :# ""List of notable people who converted to Christianity"" removes the current convert status requirement to be on the list by including people who have converted to Christianity at any time in the past. Bob Dylan belongs in this list because he is notable (per the current title) and converted at one point. 

 :I was also wondering if anyone has suggested another list for current Christians, separate from this one, for Christians that are notable to other Christians?  "