" 
 You are not a Supreme Court justice! It should not be down to some random closing admin to ""decide"" a 50/50 issue on ""consensus"". The ""right"" thing was not done here. Half the dissenters were ignored in favor of what Jimbo said to do.  You are wrong, and you can alienate me as a ""crank"" all you want. But you were not right on consensus here. At all.   "