Lightning & Stars (39-40, Shazam 35-36). This is a nice crossover, featuring two comics with heavy Golden Age influence. It's also just an OK superhero crossover, other than the high point of Starman #40 where Robinson does an awesome job of characterizing Captain Marvel [7+/10]. 
 Villian's Redemption (41). This is more what I love about the series: a deeply personal story that's simultaneously active, retrospective, and an interesting change [8/10]. 
 Times Past: 1944 (42). An OK story that gives some insight into Ted's character, but doesn't have a lot of depth beyond that [6.5/10]. 
 80-Page Special. Some of the past stories are nice for their attention to characters now gone and past. I suspect this first real apperance of the Starman of 1951 was a particular revelation. Some of the stories are good too, but if anything the macguffin African knife that connects everything together is a detriment to the stories, especially when its appearance is more obviously forced [6.5/10]. 
 Knight's Past (43). This issue is solely a bit of continuity, to push along plot. But it's got some nice bits about Jack & Ted's relationship and a cool interaction with the JLA [7.5/10]. 
 The Mist. A fair caper for The Mist [6.5/10]. 
 Times Past: 1943 (44). A fun story mainly for its insight into the character of Phantom Lady [7/10]. 
 Destiny (45). Like #43, this is primarily a bridge story meant to (at last!) move Jack on to his time in space. It's good given its purpose [7/10] 
 Times Past: 1952 (46). The beautiful Gene Ha art is what really makes this story, along with the interactions between Bobo and the Shade. The inclusion of the Jester is nice too [8/10]. 
 Batman/Hellboy/Starman. This last story is unfortunately a pretty dull team-up that just doesn't feel important. Nonetheless, it's interesting to see some of Robinson's themes & ideas from the main series come through. [5/10]. 
 Overall, Volume 4 of Starman is still good superheroes, but it's also the weakest Starman volume to date - I think in part due to Robinson's problems pushing forward on the series, in part due to Harris slowly fading away (resulting in way too many Times Past in a short sequence), and in part due to this being a middle volume between Jack's decision to go to space (in Volume 3) and getting there (in Volume 5).