Jennifer Egan's new book Manhattan Beach is a puzzle. I enjoyed reading it, and then felt less than positive about it...but now, a few weeks later, I realize I keep thinking about certain aspects of it, so I think that adds at least one star! The story begins in Brooklyn during the Depression, when we meet Anna Kerrigan. She is almost twelve years old and loves accompanying her father as he "does business." It's clear both her father and her mother are extremely influential in her view of the world: "Never part with a fact unless you've no choice. Her father's voice in her ears." And "Working with your hands meant taking orders--in her mother's case, from Pearl Gratzky..." While accompanying her father on a particular visit, she views an interaction that leads her to understand there is some secret pact between her father and a man named Dexter Styles. Not long after, her father disappears, leaving Anna alone with her mother and sister. 
 Two major events as Anna is growing up: her father disappears and the country goes to war. She needs to work as she is the sole support of her mother and her beautiful sister (who is totally disabled). She begins working at the Navy Yard in Brooklyn where, suddenly, women are being allowed to do work that had always been men's jobs. Egan does a great job using that environment to convey a great deal about her characters using descriptive language: " Dunellen gave a drooping, corroded impression, like a freighter bone to rust after being too long at anchor." Egan also shows the reader Anna's unique personality and quirkiness: "She'd never been good at banter; it was like a skipping rope whose rhythm she couldn't master enough to jump in with confidence." But she DOES have the confidence to jump into being the first female diver, an incredibly dangerous job, repairing the ships that are critical to the War effort. 
 One night, she is at a nightclub and meets Dexter Styles, the man she visited with her father before he vanished. Anna's life away from work leads her to begin to understand the reality of her father's life and the reasons he might have been murdered (which is surely what happened, otherwise why would he have just gone away and she would never have heard from him?). 
 The story is historical fiction and also sort of a "noir thriller." There is a ton of information about organized crime, the merchant marine and the clash of classes in New York, Thinking about it after the fact, I realize it was the ending/resolution that made me think I didn't care for it. (Also perhaps my extremely high expectations based on all the hype). But the story of a young woman fighting to make it in a man's world at a time of social turmoil is fascinating, and Egan does have an outstanding gift for character development. I'm grateful to Scribner and NetGalley for providing an advance copy of Manhattan Beach in exchange for my honest review. I first thought four stars, then it slipped to two and a half, but after a couple of weeks' reflection, it is back to a solid four stars.