article: Spatial and numerical regulation of flagellar biosynthesis results in different flagellation patterns specific for each bacterial species. Campylobacter jejuni produces amphitrichous (bipolar) flagella to result in a single flagellum at both poles. These flagella confer swimming motility and a distinctive darting motility necessary for infection of humans to cause diarrheal disease and animals to promote commensalism. In addition to flagellation, symmetrical cell division is spatially regulated so that the divisome forms near the cellular midpoint. We have identified an unprecedented system for spatially regulating cell division in C. jejuni composed by FlhG, a regulator of flagellar number in polar flagellates, and components of amphitrichous flagella. Similar to its role in other polarly-flagellated bacteria, we found that FlhG regulates flagellar biosynthesis to limit poles of C. jejuni to one flagellum. Furthermore, we discovered that FlhG negatively influences the ability of FtsZ to initiate cell division. Through analysis of specific flagellar mutants, we discovered that components of the motor and switch complex of amphitrichous flagella are required with FlhG to specifically inhibit division at poles. Without FlhG or specific motor and switch complex proteins, cell division occurs more often at polar regions to form minicells. Our findings suggest a new understanding for the biological requirement of the amphitrichous flagellation pattern in bacteria that extend beyond motility, virulence, and colonization. We propose that amphitrichous bacteria such as Campylobacter species advantageously exploit placement of flagella at both poles to spatially regulate an FlhG-dependent mechanism to inhibit polar cell division, thereby encouraging symmetrical cell division to generate the greatest number of viable offspring. Furthermore, we found that other polarly-flagellated bacteria produce FlhG proteins that influence cell division, suggesting that FlhG and polar flagella may function together in a broad range of bacteria to spatially regulate division.
  Due to spatial and numerical regulation of flagellar biosynthesis, bacterial species produce distinct patterns of flagellation. These regulatory mechanisms are especially evident in polarly-flagellated bacteria, which synthesize a defined number of flagella and form flagella only at bacterial poles. For many bacterial pathogens, strict spatial and numerical control of flagellar biosynthesis is essential for promoting proper motility and infection of hosts [1]–[4]. The FlhF and FlhG proteins have been implicated in spatial or numerical control of flagellar biosynthesis in polar flagellates such as Vibrio and Pseudomonas species and Campylobacter jejuni. Whereas Vibrio and Pseudomonas species each produce a monotrichous flagellum (a single flagellum only at one pole of a bacterial cell), C. jejuni and many other Campylobacter species produce amphitrichous (bipolar) flagella to result in a single flagellum at each pole. Although a defined mechanism has remained elusive, the FlhF GTPase appears to be required at an early step in flagellar biosynthesis to specifically influence formation of flagella at bacterial poles [4]–[7]. FlhG, a member of the ParA superfamily of ATPases, is involved in numerical regulation of monotrichous flagellar biosynthesis in Vibrio and Pseudomonas species, presumably by a mechanism that limits flagellar gene expression so that only one flagellum is produced per bacterial cell [1], [2]. Symmetrical cell division in bacteria also must be spatially regulated so that the divisome forms specifically at the cellular midpoint to result in two viable daughter cells of similar lengths (reviewed in [8], [9]). Without spatial regulation, the divisome may form anywhere in a bacterial cell and not always generate viable progenitors as products of cell division. Many commonly studied bacteria encode a Min system, which inhibits divisome formation at poles in Escherichia coli and Bacillus subtilis. Components of the Min system include MinD, another member of the ParA superfamily of ATPases, and MinC, the inhibitor of FtsZ polymerization into the Z-ring [10]–[15]. In E. coli, MinE is a topological specificity factor that spatially restricts MinCD complexes to primarily polar regions so that Z-ring formation is inhibited at poles [16], [17]. MinE stimulates the ATPase activity of MinD, which causes dissociation of MinCD complexes sequentially at each pole, resulting in polar oscillation of MinCD [14], [18]–[25]. As a result, the cellular midpoint remains relatively free of MinCD so that the Z-ring forms at the middle to promote symmetrical cell division. In B. subtilis, DivIVA functions as the topological specificity factor by first recruiting MinJ, which then recruits MinCD to the division site [15], [17], [26]–[28]. MinCD localizes to the divisome after a step when the Z-ring is no longer sensitive to MinC-mediated depolymerization, which likely prevents a second cell division event from occurring at the new pole of the newly formed daughter cells [15], [26], [29]. A second mechanism, termed nucleoid occlusion, also functions in E. coli and B. subtilis to inhibit Z-ring formation at the cellular midpoint [30]–[35]. Specific DNA-bound proteins inhibit Z-ring formation when the chromosomal DNA occupies the midregion of the cell. This inhibitory mechanism is relieved once chromosomal DNA is replicated and segregated to poles. Both Min and nucleoid occlusion systems may cooperatively function in many bacteria to influence formation of the divisome precisely at the midpoint at the appropriate time in a dividing cell. The MipZ ATPase, a MinD ortholog and another ParA ATPase family member, spatially regulates Z-ring formation in Caulobacter crescentus [36]. Unlike MinD, MipZ itself directly dissociates FtsZ polymers and inhibits Z-ring formation. MipZ interacts with ParB, which is bound to DNA near the chromosomal origin of replication, and moves with the replicated chromosome as it segregates to the opposite pole before cell division. MipZ depolymerizes polar FtsZ polymers present from the last round of cell division, causing reorganization of FtsZ into the Z-ring near the midpoint. Interaction of MipZ with ParB-bound DNA spatially restricts MipZ to inhibit cell division primarily at poles. Most Campylobacter species are amphitrichous organisms, a fairly unusual pattern of flagellation amongst polar flagellates. Flagellar motility of C. jejuni is an essential virulence and colonization factor required for infection of humans to result in diarrheal disease and many animals to promote commensalism [37]–[40]. Upon analysis of factors that regulate amphitrichous flagellar biosynthesis, we identified an unprecedented system to spatially regulate symmetrical cell division that involves FlhG, an ortholog of the MinD and MipZ ATPases, and components of amphitrichous flagella. We discovered that FlhG not only regulates flagellar number, but FlhG also influences where cell division occurs in C. jejuni. We found that deletion of flhG in C. jejuni resulted in a minicell phenotype, which is an indication of cell division occurring at polar regions rather than strictly at the cellular midpoint. Unexpectedly, mutants lacking components of the flagellar MS and C rings, which have established motor, switch, and secretory functions for the flagellum, also possessed a minicell phenotype. We propose that due to the lack of a Min system in C. jejuni, the flagellar MS ring and switch complex may serve as a topological specificity factor to modulate or localize a FlhG-dependent mechanism to inhibit cell division specifically at polar regions so that symmetrical division occurs to generate viable progenitors. Furthermore, our results demonstrate that amphitrichous flagellation in C. jejuni is not only essential for conferring motility required for infection of hosts, but also significantly influences symmetrical cell division to generate viable daughter cells. Our study also reveals that FlhG proteins of other polarly-flagellated bacteria influence placement of division sites in C. jejuni, suggesting that FlhG and polar flagellar biosynthesis may spatially influence cell division in a broad range of motile bacteria.
  Members of the ParA ATPase superfamily are involved in process such as numerical regulation of flagellar biosynthesis and spatial regulation of cell division. Many polarly-flagellated bacteria appear to encode FlhG/FleN orthologs and a complete Min system including MinD (for a sequence alignment of FlhG and MinD proteins, see Figure S1). Although Min systems have not been analyzed in polar flagellates, FlhG/FleN numerically regulate flagellar biosynthesis in the monotrichous species, V. cholerae and P. aeruginosa [1], [2]. In contrast, C. crescentus produces the MipZ ATPase to spatially regulate cell division and does not appear to encode MinD or FlhG [36]. Completed genomes of all Campylobacter species encode the putative FlhG ATPase, but not MinD or any other Min proteins. Therefore, we analyzed C. jejuni 81–176 with an in-frame deletion within flhG (Cjj81176_0101) to ascertain a role for FlhG in flagellar biosynthesis and other processes such as cell division. We first observed that FlhG numerically controls amphitrichous flagellation by examining flagellar biosynthesis of populations of wild-type C. jejuni and ΔflhG mutant strains. Over 90% of individual wild-type cells produced a single flagellum at one or both poles (62% were amphitrichous, 29% were monotrichous), which together were classified as the normal flagellar number phenotype (Figure 1A and 1C). Only about 1% of wild-type C. jejuni produced more than one flagellum at least at one pole. In contrast, approximately 40% of C. jejuni ΔflhG cells produced extra flagella at least at one pole, with a correlative decrease in the population producing wild-type flagellar numbers (Figure 1B and 1C). As a population, the ΔflhG mutant was less motile than wild-type C. jejuni (Figure S2A). Both motility and wild-type flagellar numbers were restored to C. jejuni ΔflhG by expressing flhG in trans (Figure 1C and Figure S2A). In V. cholerae or P. aeruginosa, FlhG/FleN negatively regulates flagellar gene expression. As such, flhG/fleN mutants demonstrate increased expression of almost all classes of flagellar genes, which is believed to contribute to extra polar flagella [1], [2], [41]. Unlike these mutants, deletion of flhG in C. jejuni did not result in augmented expression of all classes of flagellar genes. Instead, we observed less than a 2. 5-fold increase in expression of only σ54-dependent flagellar genes (encoding primarily rod and hook proteins), but not for other classes of flagellar genes, such as the early class encoding the flagellar type III secretion system (T3SS) or the late σ28-dependent flaA gene encoding the major flagellin (Figure S2B). These results suggest that FlhG is involved in numerical control of amphitrichous flagellation by a process different from monotrichous bacteria. Since deletion of flhG resulted in an increase in the bacterial population that were hyperflagellated at least at one pole, we hypothesized that increasing the levels of FlhG in wild-type C. jejuni may suppress flagellation and increase the population of aflagellated bacteria. Systems to induce protein production are lacking in C. jejuni. Therefore, to increase FlhG levels in C. jejuni, flhG was overexpressed in wild-type C. jejuni by using the plasmid that complemented the C. jejuni ΔflhG mutant to restore proper flagellar numbers. However, overproduction of FlhG did not increase the aflagellated population compared to wild-type C. jejuni (Figure 1C). Upon closer examination of the C. jejuni ΔflhG mutant by electron microscopy, we observed a change in the distribution of lengths of the bacterial cell bodies. In addition to bacteria of normal size, minicells were abundant in the C. jejuni ΔflhG population (Figure 2A-D). The minicells were normally 0. 2–0. 4 µm in diameter and originated from the poles of ΔflhG cells (Figure 2A and 2B). Many minicells were flagellated, and some were multiply flagellated due to the increased flagellation phenotype of the ΔflhG mutant (Figure 2C and 2D). We were unable to determine by phase-contrast or darkfield microscopy if the flagella rotated on minicells to confer motility (data not shown). These findings indicate that minicells are most likely generated due to division occurring at poles of C. jejuni ΔflhG, similar to observations of E. coli and B. subtilis minD mutants and a C. crescentus mipZ mutant [16], [36], [42]. We analyzed the lengths of individual C. jejuni cells to assess the abundance of minicells and distribution of cell lengths within a population. Wild-type C. jejuni cells averaged 1. 41 µm in length with approximately 88% of the population between 1–2 µm (Figure 2E). More in depth analysis revealed about 54% of the bacteria were within a narrow range of 1. 1–1. 5 µm (Figure S3). Only 1. 6% of wild-type C. jejuni were minicells, which were classified as bacterial-derived, spherical particles under 0. 5 µm in diameter (Figure 2E). In contrast, the minicell phenotype of C. jejuni ΔflhG was pronounced, composing 28% of the cellular population (Figure 2E). In E. coli min mutants, both elongated cells and minicells are present in the bacterial populations [43], [44]. However, our analysis of the C. jejuni ΔflhG mutant, did not reveal an increase in the elongated cell population. Instead, the number of bacterial cells between 1–2 µm in the ΔflhG population was reduced, with the average cell length of the bacterial population consequently decreased compared to wild-type C. jejuni to 1. 12 µm (Figure 2E and Figure S3). The reason for these differences in the population composition of E. coli and C. jejuni mutants producing minicell phenotypes is currently unknown. Complementation of C. jejuni ΔflhG in trans with wild-type flhG greatly reduced the minicell population to less than 9%, demonstrating that the minicell phenotype of the ΔflhG mutant was due to loss of flhG (Figure 2E). We also noticed upon addition of flhG in trans to either wild-type C. jejuni or C. jejuni ΔflhG, the elongated cell population (>2 µm) increased to 24–26%, an approximately four-fold increase relative to wild-type C. jejuni (Figure 2E). This elongated cell phenotype is reminiscent of E. coli or B. subtilis strains upon minD overexpression in the presence of the FtsZ polymerization inhibitor, MinC, or mipZ overexpression in C. crescentus [15], [16], [36]. The occurrence of minicells upon elimination of flhG and the elongated cell phenotype upon increased FlhG production suggest that FlhG is involved in a process to inhibit cell division in C. jejuni. We next verified that minicell production in C. jejuni ΔflhG was the result of a cell division event. Cephalexin is a late-stage cell division inhibitor that targets FtsI, which is required for peptidoglycan production at a septum during the final stages of cell division [45], [46]. We monitored minicell production in wild-type C. jejuni and ΔflhG mutant strains before and after a 6-hour incubation with the highest concentration of cephalexin that caused a noticeable cell division defect without killing the bacteria. Like untreated cells, the generation time of wild-type C. jejuni treated with 15 µg/ml cephalexin for six hours progressed normally through 1. 5–2 doublings (data not shown). However, the cephalexin-treated bacteria displayed an increase in the population of elongated cells relative to untreated bacteria (Table 1). Upon examination of the C. jejuni ΔflhG mutant, we noticed that the mutant was more sensitive to 15 µg/ml cephalexin that wild-type cells as indicated by cell lysis that obscured confident identification of minicell production by electron microscopy. Therefore, we treated the C. jejuni ΔflhG mutant with 12. 5 µg/ml cephalexin. At this concentration, the ΔflhG mutant progressed through two doublings similar to untreated C. jejuni ΔflhG (data not shown). Without cephalexin treatment, the minicell population only slightly increased with time compared to the ΔflhG culture at the beginning of the experiment (Table 1), suggesting that minicell production is fairly consistent over time. However, six hours after cephalexin treatment, the minicell population was reduced about 56% compared to untreated ΔflhG cells (Table 1). Furthermore, an increased number of elongated cells was observed in the cephalexin-treated ΔflhG cells, indicating that cephalexin influenced cell division. We interpret the data as suggesting that minicells present after cephalexin treatment were likely those present at the start of the experiment and that cephalexin largely inhibited formation of new minicells. Therefore, we conclude that minicells are formed by a process that involves cell division in C. jejuni ΔflhG. Members of the ParA family of ATPases contain a conserved aspartic acid residue that has been proposed to be required for ATP hydrolysis, but not for ATP binding [47], [48] (Figure S1). E. coli MinD and C. crescentus MipZ mutant proteins lacking this aspartic acid are thought to be locked into an ATP-bound state that caused cell elongation due to increased inhibition of cell division [36], [49]. Analysis of this type of mutation in E. coli MinD, revealed an increased association of the mutant protein with phospholipids even in the presence of MinE, and a peripheral distribution of the protein along the cytoplasmic membrane [49]. This distribution allowed the protein to function with MinC to inhibit cell division throughout the cell to result in elongation. In C. crescentus, production of the MipZD42A mutant protein resulted in a hyperactive form of the protein that was dominant over wild-type MipZ to result in cell elongation [36]. Considering these findings, we examined a role the putative ATPase domain of FlhG in influencing cell division by mutating the similarly conserved aspartic acid residue (D61) in FlhG. To perform these experiments, we replaced chromosomal wild-type flhG with flhGD61A, which we predicted would encode an FlhG mutant protein locked into an ATP-bound state, which may cause increased inhibition of cell division. In the C. jejuni flhGD61A mutant population, we noticed a mixed population of cells, which contained cells of normal length and cells with elongated bodies (compare wild-type cells in Figure 3A with the flhGD61A mutant in Figure 3B and 3C). By analyzing the distribution of the lengths of cell bodies of the C. jejuni flhGD61A population, we found that approximately 24% of cells were elongated (>2 µm in length), compared to only 4% of wild-type C. jejuni (Table 2 and Figures 3D-F). Whereas elongated wild-type cells were largely confined to 2–3 µm in length, elongated C. jejuni flhGD61A cells of up to 9 µm in length were observed (Figure S4). A significant proportion of the flhGD61A population continued to produce cells of wild-type length between 1–2 µm (73. 9% for C. jejuni flhGD61A vs 92. 4% for wild-type C. jejuni; Table 2), suggesting that symmetrical cell division to produce daughter cells of normal lengths occurs with some frequency in many of these mutant cells. Of note, many flhGD61A cells produced wild-type flagella with a single flagellum at the poles and were motile as observed by darkfield microscopy (Figure 3D and 3F; data not shown). These observations suggest that the cells were metabolically active and viable. As observed by electron microscopy, elongated bodies of the C. jejuni flhGD61A mutant often appeared to lack septa, indicating that FlhG may function in a mechanism to inhibit divisome formation (Figure 3D-F). One of the first steps in initiating cell division is formation of FtsZ into the Z-ring. Therefore, we tested if increasing the levels of FtsZ in C. jejuni flhGD61A could overcome the apparent cell division block in these cells and reduce the cell elongation phenotype of this mutant. Similar to E. coli [50], overexpression of ftsZ in trans in wild-type C. jejuni caused a 5-fold increase in minicell production (Table 2), indicating that FtsZ functions in cell division. Overexpression of ftsZ in C. jejuni flhGD61A reduced the elongated cell phenotype of this mutant from 24% to 9% (Table 2). These results suggest a regulatory link between FlhG and FtsZ, with Z-ring formation as a potential target of cell inhibition mediated by an FlhG-dependent mechanism. Factors that spatially regulate formation of cell division sites have not been examined in other polar flagellates. Because other polarly-flagellated bacteria produce FlhG homologs that control flagellar number, we reasoned that these FlhG proteins may have an additional capacity like C. jejuni FlhG to influence cell division. Therefore, we analyzed if either FlhG or MinD proteins from other polarly-flagellated bacteria or E. coli MinD could functionally complement C. jejuni ΔflhG for numerical control of flagellar biosynthesis or spatial control of cell division to reduce the minicell phenotype. For these experiments, heterologous flhG or minD genes were cloned into a plasmid downstream of a constitutive promoter to ensure expression. These plasmids were then used to complement in trans C. jejuni ΔflhG. We found that H. pylori FlhG was just as competent as C. jejuni FlhG in reducing extra polar flagella and restoring wild-type flagellar numbers to C. jejuni ΔflhG (Figure 4A). Furthermore, H. pylori FlhG dramatically reduced the minicell population of the C. jejuni ΔflhG mutant and even caused an increase in elongated cells (Figure 4B), suggesting that H. pylori FlhG can function in a mechanism to inhibit cell division. In addition, V. cholerae FlhG partially restored both wild-type flagellar numbers and normal cell division to C. jejuni ΔflhG (Figure 4A and 4B). In contrast, all MinD proteins failed to complement C. jejuni ΔflhG for either phenotype (Figure 4A and 4B). These results indicate that H. pylori FlhG, and to a lesser extent V. cholerae FlhG, have the ability to modulate cell division. Secondly, these findings suggest that C. jejuni has evolved to preferentially use FlhG to regulate cell division and numerically control flagellar biosynthesis. Our data suggest that the lack of FlhG results in the production of minicells due to polar cell division. Therefore, if FlhG is involved in a mechanism to prevent cell division at poles, it may be expected that FlhG localizes to polar regions to mediate this division inhibitory effect. We attempted to analyze the ability of FlhG to localize to poles of C. jejuni ΔflhG by using a plasmid to express flhG-gfp, which produces wild-type FlhG with a C-terminal GFP. The use of fluorescent protein technology to analyze cellular localization of proteins has typically been challenging in C. jejuni and other ε-proteobacteria. However, we were able to observe fluorescence due to FlhG-GFP in a small population of cells. In these bacteria, fluorescence was observed often at both poles, with some diffuse cellular fluorescence also visible (Figure 5). In contrast, C. jejuni ΔflhG producing GFP alone demonstrated diffuse fluorescence throughout the cell (Figure 5). These results suggest that FlhG is likely polarly localized and possibly available at poles to function in a mechanism to prevent cell division. Because FlhG-GFP was detected primarily at poles in bacteria producing FlhG-GFP, we considered if other factors present at poles of C. jejuni may function with FlhG to limit cell division at poles. A leading candidate for a polarly-localized protein that may interact with FlhG is the FlhF GTPase. Previous studies suggested that the FlhF and FlhG proteins of C. jejuni and Vibrio alginolyticus interact, which may influence their respective ability to spatially and numerically control flagellar biosynthesis [4], [51]. FlhF of C. jejuni and other polar flagellates has been implicated as a regulatory factor required for expression of flagellar genes and to properly localize flagellar biosynthesis to poles [1], [4], [5], [7], [52]. Of note, FlhF polar localization has been observed in C. jejuni [53]. A current hypothesis for a role of C. jejuni FlhF in polar flagellar placement suggest that the GTPase activity of FlhF may influence its positioning to the new pole after cell division. After polar localization, FlhF may promote organization of the initial flagellar proteins, such as the motor, switch, and secretory components at the pole [6]. Considering the potential interactions between FlhF and FlhG, we examined a C. jejuni ΔflhF mutant and observed a minicell population that was at least as prevalent as that of C. jejuni ΔflhG (Figure 6A and Figure S5). To determine if the minicell phenotype of the ΔflhF mutant was linked to FlhG, we expressed flhG in trans in the ΔflhF mutant to result in flhG overexpression due to the presence of both chromosomal- and plasmid-encoded copies of the gene. In this strain, the minicell phenotype caused by deletion of flhF was suppressed (Figure 6C). These results suggest that FlhF and FlhG are linked in a mechanism to influence cell division in C. jejuni. Furthermore, by overexpressing FlhG in the ΔflhF background, FlhG overcomes an apparent dependency on FlhF to modulate cell division. Two hypotheses were developed for how FlhF may influence an FlhG-dependent mechanism to inhibit cell division at poles. First, we considered if either σ54-dependent flagellar gene expression or flagellar rod biosynthesis, which are both dependent on FlhF [6], [54], are required for FlhG to function in a mechanism to inhibit cell division at poles. If lack of σ 54-dependent flagellar gene expression or rod biosynthesis caused the minicell phenotype in the ΔflhF mutant, minicell production in a ΔrpoN mutant (which lacks σ 54) or a ΔfliE mutant (which lacks rod biosynthesis) would be expected. However, neither mutant demonstrated a significant minicell phenotype compared to the ΔflhG or ΔflhF mutants (Figure 6A). For the second hypothesis, we considered if flagellar components, which are likely dependent on FlhF for polar formation, are required to inhibit minicell formation. Although the very initial steps in flagellar biosynthesis are unknown in C. jejuni, it is likely that the first components of a flagellum that are constructed include: FliF (which forms the inner membrane MS ring); FliG, FliM, and FliN (the motor/switch components of the cytoplasmic C ring); and the flagellar T3SS (which is located within the MS ring) [55]. These components mediate motor, switch, and secretory functions for a flagellum. Of note, the MS ring of V. cholerae appears to be dependent on FlhF for polar localization [5]. We analyzed a panel of C. jejuni mutants lacking these flagellar components for a defect in cell division that results in production of minicells. Inactivation of fliF, fliM, and fliN resulted in strong minicell phenotypes comparable to C. jejuni ΔflhF and ΔflhG mutants (Figure 6A and Figure S5). In contrast, a fliG mutant or mutants lacking a single component of the flagellar T3SS either did not produce a significant level of minicells or showed a significantly reduced minicell phenotype relative to C. jejuni ΔflhG (Figure 6A). These findings suggest that the MS ring and switch complex (made up of FliM and FliN) are involved in a mechanism to influence cell division in C. jejuni. To verify that minicells are products of cell division in the flhF, fliF, fliM, and fliN mutants, minicell production was monitored in mutants after exposure to cephalexin. In each case, the minicell population was reduced in cephalexin-treated cells (Figure 6B). In the fliF, fliM, and fliN mutants, the minicell population was reduced over 50%. We next determined if the minicell phenotypes of the fliF, fliM, and fliN mutants are linked to FlhG, similar to what we observed with C. jejuni ΔflhF. When we overexpressed flhG in trans in each of these mutants, the minicell phenotype decreased (Figure 6C). Furthermore, deletion of flhG in the fliF, fliM, or fliN mutants did not augment minicell production in the mutants compared to single deletions of each gene (Figure 6D), suggesting that the MS and switch complex of flagella function in the same pathway as FlhG to influence a mechanism to inhibit cell division. Considering our findings, we surmise that polar flagellar biosynthesis influences formation of cell division sites via FlhG to ultimately result in symmetrical cell division in C. jejuni.
  Elegant studies of E. coli, B. subtilis, and C. crescentus have elucidated highly refined mechanisms by which bacteria regulate precise placement of the divisome to promote cell division and generate viable progenitors. Although the mechanisms vary, a common theme in regulating divisome placement is that bacterial poles are usually protected from cell division so that the divisome more likely forms near the cellular midpoint for symmetrical division. We have identified a new collection of factors that compose a system to regulate formation of cell division sites in C. jejuni. This novel system is composed of the ParA ATPase family member FlhG and the MS ring and switch complex of polar flagella. Our work indicates that FlhG numerically controls amphitrichous flagellation and spatially regulates cell division. Furthermore, components of polar flagella are required for FlhG produced at normal levels to inhibit cell division specifically at polar regions. In the absence of FlhG, the MS ring, or switch components, cell division at poles more freely occurs to generate minicells. Thus, FlhG and polar flagellar biosynthesis block cell division from occurring at poles so that symmetrical division predominates to ensure generation of viable progenitors. Other ParA ATPase family members, such as E. coli and B. subtilis MinD or C. crescentus MipZ, regulate formation of cell division sites by protecting poles from cell division, but the mechanisms by which these proteins function differ. MinD proteins do not directly inhibit cell division. Instead, these proteins localize MinC, the FtsZ inhibitor, to poles or maturing septa to inhibit divisome formation [10]–[13], [15], [56]. In contrast, C. crescentus MipZ directly mediates FtsZ depolymerization at polar sites [36]. C. jejuni FlhG is more homologous to MinDs than MipZ, with approximately 55% similarity and 35% identity between a 167-amino acid region of FlhG and E. coli MinD. This region includes the ATPase domains and some surrounding residues. In addition, a C-terminal amphipathic helix present in MinDs, but absent in MipZ, that is required for membrane interactions at poles to mediate inhibition of cell division is predicted at the C-terminus of FlhG [10], [57]–[59]. In contrast, FlhG and MipZ only share homology that is limited to a 40-amino acid region within the ATPase domains. Considering how MinD and MipZ spatially mediate inhibition of cell division, it is currently unclear how FlhG may modulate cell division in C. jejuni. Production of FlhGD61A, which is predicted to be locked into an ATP-bound state, resulted in an elongated phenotype likely due to the mutant FlhG protein conferring a heightened cell division inhibitory activity. These results suggest that cycles of ATP binding and hydrolysis by FlhG are likely important for normal spatial regulation of Z-ring formation, similar to what has been observed with MinD and MipZ [18]–[20], [36], [60]. Due to the lack of genes encoding MinC and MinE in C. jejuni, it is unlikely that FlhG functions in an identical mechanism as MinD to inhibit cell division. However, FlhG may interact with and polarly localize other proteins with MinC-like functions in directly inhibiting Z-ring formation. Alternatively, FlhG may function similarly to C. crescentus MipZ to directly interact with FtsZ and inhibit Z-ring formation at poles. However, preliminary experiments failed to demonstrate that purified FlhG stimulated the GTPase activity of C. jejuni FtsZ in vitro (MB and DRH, unpublished observations), which would promote depolymerization of Z-rings into FtsZ monomers and inhibit cell division in the bacterium [61]–[63]. In addition, we were unable to detect an in vitro ATPase activity for FlhG (MB and DRH, unpublished observations), yet in vivo analysis of the elongated phenotype promoted by the flhGD61A mutant suggested that FlhG binds and hydrolyzes ATP for normal spatial regulation of Z-ring formation. These results indicate either that our in vitro conditions are not optimal for detecting a direct inhibitory activity of FlhG for FtsZ polymerization into Z-rings or that other components are required to activate or function with FlhG to inhibit FtsZ polymerization. Due to the requirement of flagellar components to limit cell division at poles, FlhG may require intact flagellar MS ring and switch structures to inhibit Z-ring formation and cell division. As with the Min and MipZ division-site determination systems, we expect that an FlhG-dependent mechanism to protect poles from cell division likely requires some sort of topological specificity factor that either spatially confines or specifically activates this system at polar regions. Due to the minicell phenotype of MS ring and switch complex mutants, it is tempting to speculate that formation of a MS ring and C-ring switch complex at a pole, which is numerically regulated by FlhG, forms a topological specificity factor that assists FlhG and possibly other associated factors to facilitate inhibition of cell division specifically at poles. Without fliF, fliM, and fliN, a mechanism involving FlhG to inhibit cell division at poles is inoperable. Furthermore, the lack of an elongated cell phenotype in these mutants also suggests that this mechanism is not simply spatially deregulated and blocking divisome formation throughout the cell. Hence, specific flagellar components function with FlhG to inhibit cell division when the protein is produced at normal levels in the bacterium. The minicell phenotype of fliF, fliM, and fliN mutants could be suppressed by increasing expression of flhG. Furthermore, analysis of double mutants lacking flhG and either fliF, fliM, or fliN did not reveal an increase in minicell production compared to the deletion of flhG alone. These findings together suggest that FlhG functions downstream of these flagellar components to influence cell division, rather than FlhG, the MS ring, and switch complex functioning in two separate pathways to influence cell division. Curiously, the base of the MS ring (composed by FliF) and the FliM and FliN structures in the switch complex of the C ring are cytoplasmic-accessible portions of the flagellar organelle, which may be available to interact with FlhG. In contrast, the flagellar T3SS and FliG, which are internal components of the MS and C rings, respectively, did not appear to be required to inhibit cell division at poles. If the MS ring and switch complex compose a topological specificity factor, FlhG may require a superficial domain of the flagellar motor and switch complex to initiate a mechanism to spatially inhibit cell division specifically at polar regions. Possible hypotheses for a mechanism by which flagellar components assist in modulating cell division include: 1) the flagellar structures may interact with FlhG to accumulate the protein to a critical concentration necessary to specifically inhibit Z-ring formation and cell division at poles; or 2) specific flagellar proteins or flagellum-associated components may activate a FlhG-dependent mechanism to inhibit cell division that is spatially confined to poles. Currently, our data do not allow for discerning which hypothesis may be true. The observation that FlhG alone did not stimulate the GTPase activity of C. jejuni FtsZ in preliminary assays suggests that FlhG may require intact flagellar components or other factors to promote FtsZ depolymerizaton (MB and DRH, unpublished observations). On the other hand, the fact that flhG overexpression suppressed the minicell phenotype of MS ring and switch complex mutants suggest that a FlhG-dependent mechanism to inhibit cell division is functional without flagella if FlhG levels are artificially high, which may add more strength to the hypothesis that polar flagellar structures promote polar accumulation of FlhG when produced at normal levels to inhibit cell division at poles. We attempted to determine if polar localization of FlhG-GFP was dependent on the flagellar motor and switch complex. Due to the low number of cells producing fluorescence and the low level of fluorescence of the fusion protein in these flagellar mutants, we were unable to confidently conclude that polar flagellar structures are required to localize FlhG to poles (MB and DRH, unpublished observations). Improved fluorescence microscopic procedures will be required to identify factors required for polar localization of FlhG. Although much more is to be learned about this system, our data suggest that polar flagellar biosynthesis functions with FlhG to inhibit cell division at poles. Our findings have also revealed a previously unrecognized biological advantage for amphitrichous flagellation of C. jejuni that extends beyond an obvious role in promoting motility. Amphitrichous flagellation confers a characteristic darting motility for C. jejuni that assists in colonization of the intestinal mucosa in hosts [64], [65]. However, our studies have found that C. jejuni possesses a flagellum-influenced cell division inhibition system. The construction of such a system appears to allow amphitrichous flagellar biosynthesis, which is numerically controlled by FlhG, to influence an FlhG-dependent mechanism to prevent cell division at both poles. We propose that immediately after cell division, two daughter cells lack a flagellum at the new pole. Initiation of a single round of flagellar biosynthesis at this pole to complete the amphitrichous flagellation pattern would result in a MS ring and switch complex structure that an FlhG-dependent mechanism requires to inhibit cell division specifically at the new pole. A strictly monotrichous flagellar pattern in C. jejuni may inhibit cell division only at the flagellated pole with the aflagellated pole susceptible to divisome formation. A peritrichous flagellation pattern in C. jejuni may inhibit division throughout the cell. As such, amphitrichous flagella facilitate a mechanism so that FlhG-dependent cell division inhibition primarily occurs at the poles, which encourages symmetrical cell division to generate the highest number of viable C. jejuni daughter cells. The polarly-flagellated bacteria commonly studied for motility, such as Vibrio, Pseudomonas, and Helicobacter species, encode FlhG and all Min components, except for Campylobacter species. A likely hypothesis for most polar flagellates is that FlhG controls numerical parameters of polar flagellar biosynthesis, whereas the Min system influences division-site placement. However, we observed that H. pylori FlhG, and to a lesser extent V. cholerae FlhG, resolved the minicell phenotype of C. jejuni ΔflhG, indicating that these proteins have the ability to influence cell division and possibly spatially regulate divisome formation. Therefore, the ability of FlhG to influence cell division may extend to other polarly-flagellated bacteria and form a broad mechanism used by many other motile bacteria to regulate cell division processes. In this work, we have established a new paradigm that links polar flagellar biosynthesis to cell division in bacteria. Furthermore, we showed how amphitrichous flagellation is beneficial for influencing symmetrical cell division in Campylobacter so that two normal daughter cells are generated during each round of division. In addition, we provided a new function for the flagellar MS ring and switch complex in functioning with FlhG to prevent cell division from occurring at polar sites. Further exploration of this system will undoubtedly lead to a new understanding of the process of cell division that may occur in a broad range of polar flagellates.
  All C. jejuni 81–176 SmR strains and procedures for generating mutants are described in Text S1 and Tables S1 and S2. For all experiments, C. jejuni strains were grown from freezer stocks on Mueller-Hinton (MH) agar containing 10 µg/ml trimethoprim for 48 h under microaerobic conditions at 37°C. Strains with plasmids for complementation analyses were grown with 50 µg/ml kanamycin. Strains were then restreaked onto MH agar containing appropriate antibiotics and grown for an additional 16 h and then used in experiments accordingly as described. Introduction of flhG or minD alleles on plasmids into wild-type C. jejuni 81–176 SmR or C. jejuni 81–176 SmR ΔflhG for overexpression or complementation was accomplished by amplifying the alleles with primers containing 5' BamHI restriction sites immediately upstream of the start and stop codons of the respective genes. flhG alleles were amplified from the chromosomal DNA of C. jejuni 81–176, H. pylori J99, and V. cholerae O395. minD alleles were amplified from the chromosomal DNA of H. pylori J99, V. cholerae O395, and E. coli MG1655. The alleles were cloned into BamHI-digested pCE107, an E. coli-C. jejuni shuttle vector containing the σ28-dependent flaA promoter of C. jejuni followed by a BamHI site fused in-frame to a gene for the Zoanthus species green-fluorescent protein [66]. Insertion of flhG or minD alleles in the correct orientation placed a stop codon between the allele and the gene for GFP, preventing the formation of a fusion protein. All plasmids were sequenced and then transformed into DH5α/RK212. 1 [67]. The plasmids were then conjugated into the appropriate C. jejuni 81–176 SmR strains by a previously published method [68]. To increase expression of ftsZ in C. jejuni SmR flhGD61A (MB1054), ftsZ was amplified from chromosomal DNA of C. jejuni 81–176 using primers containing 5' BamHI restriction sites immediately upstream of the start and stop codons of the gene. ftsZ was cloned into BamHI-digested pCE107 and then conjugated into wild-type C. jejuni or the flhGD61A mutant as described above. Expression of ftsZ from this plasmid, along with constitutive expression of ftsZ from the native chromosomal locus allowed for expression of ftsZ at increased levels relative to wild-type C. jejuni. To increase expression of flhG in the C. jejuni ΔflhF (DRH1056), ΔfliF (DRH2074), fliM (DRH3304), and fliN (DRH1407) mutants, the coding sequence of flhG was amplified from chromosomal DNA from C. jejuni 81–176 with primers containing BamHI restriction sites in-frame to codon 2 and the stop codon. flhG was then cloned into BamHI-digested pECO101, an E. coli-C. jejuni shuttle vector containing the promoter of the chloramphenicol-acetyltransferase (cat) gene. After screening for correct orientation of flhG and sequencing, one plasmid (pMB1230) was transformed into DH5α/RK212. 1 for conjugation into C. jejuni mutants as described above. Constitutive expression of flhG from the cat promoter on the plasmid, along with constitutive expression of flhG from the native chromosomal locus allowed for expression of flhG at increased levels relative to wild-type C. jejuni. Construction of a plasmid to produce a FlhG-GFP fusion protein was accomplished by amplifying the coding sequence of flhG from C. jejuni 81–176 chromosomal DNA with primers containing BamHI restriction sites in frame the start and penultimate codons. This fragment was then cloned into BamHI-digested pCE107 [53]. One plasmid, pMB722, contained flhG in the correct orientation to produce a FlhG-GFP fusion protein. pMB722 and pCE107, which expressed GFP alone, was transformed into DH5α/pRK212. 1 for conjugation into C. jejuni 81–176 SmR ΔflhG (MB770) as described above. Strains were grown for 16 h on agar plates and then resuspended in PBS, pelleted for 3 min at full speed in a microcentrifuge, resuspended in 2% gluteraldehyde in 0. 1 M cacodylate, and then incubated on ice for 1 h for fixation. Samples were then stained with 2% uranyl acetate and visualized with a FEI Technai G2 Spirit BioTWIN transmission electron microscope. For analysis of the effect of cephalexin treatment on cell length and minicell production, strains were suspended from agar plates after growth for 16 h on agar plates and diluted to an OD600 1. 0. Each strain was diluted 1∶10 in MH broth in two separate flasks. Cephalexin was added at a final concentration of 15 or 12. 5 µg/ml for wild-type C. jejuni or the C. jejuni ΔflhG mutant, respectively. Cultures were then incubated under microaerobic conditions at 37°C for 6 h. Samples were taken at time 0 h and 6 h to determine the number of viable bacteria in each culture and for analysis by electron microscopy. Samples were then fixed and stained as described above for visualization by transmission electron microscopy. Data from two separate experiments were combined and averaged to determine the proportion of bacterial populations producing different numbers of polar flagella or cell bodies of different lengths as visualized by transmission electron microscopy. In total, over 210 individual bacteria were analyzed for each strain. For analysis of flagellar numbers, bacteria were placed into one of three categories: >2 flagella, producing at least two flagella at one or both poles; wild-type flagella, producing a single flagellum at one or both poles; or 0 flagella, aflagellated bacteria. For analysis of cell body lengths, bacteria were placed into one of four categories: <0. 5 µm, minicells; 0. 5–1 µm; 1–2 µm; and >2 µm. After averaging, the standard error for each population was calculated. After 16 h growth, bacteria were suspended from agar plates in MH broth and then diluted to OD600 1. 0. Approximately 1. 5 ml of culture was pelleted in a microcentrifuge, followed by fixation with 4% formalin. Then, 350 µl of fixed cells were stained with 20 µl of 1 mg/ml FM4–64 for 15 min. Samples were added to poly-L-lysine-coated chamber slides. After 5 min, excess liquid was removed with a vacuum. ProLong Gold antifade reagent was applied to the chamber slides. After 24 h, fluorescent images were obtained with an Applied Precision PersonalDV deconvolution microscope with an Olympus 100x objective lens and a CoolSNAP_HQ2 camera. Images were processed using the ImageJ program. The following GenBank accession numbers identify all previously uncharacterized proteins that were analyzed in this work: Campylobacter jejuni 81–176 FlhG, EAQ71939; Campylobacter jejuni 81–176 FliE, EAQ73125; Campylobacter jejuni 81–176 FliQ, EAQ72806; Campylobacter jejuni 81–176 FliM, EAQ71948; Campylobacter jejuni 81–176 FliN, 73197; Campylobacter jejuni 81–176 FliG, EAQ73253; Helicobacter pylori 26695 FlhG, AAD08077; Helicobacter pylori 26695 MinD, AAD07400; Vibrio cholerae O395 MinD, ACP10067.
summary: Campylobacter jejuni is a leading cause of gastroenteritis in humans and requires amphitrichous (bipolar) flagella to promote infection of hosts. This pattern of flagellation results in a single flagellum at both poles, which is characteristic of many Campylobacter species, but fairly unusual amongst other motile bacteria. In this work, we discovered an unprecedented system to spatially regulate cell division that relies on the FlhG ATPase and amphitrichous flagellar biosynthesis. In addition to its role in other polar flagellates in controlling flagellar number, we discovered that FlhG influences spatial regulation of cell division in C. jejuni. Further analysis revealed that components of the flagellar motor and switch are required with FlhG to inhibit cell division specifically at the poles of the bacterium. These findings indicate that flagella have an additional function in C. jejuni beyond promoting motility, virulence, and colonization in functioning in a mechanism with FlhG to inhibit cell division specifically at poles. Furthermore, our findings suggest that the specific amphitrichous pattern of flagellar biosynthesis in this pathogen is an essential determinant for inhibiting cell division at both bacterial poles so that symmetrical cell division occurs and generates viable progenitors.
keywords: microbial pathogens
  biology
  microbiology
  microbial growth and development
  bacterial pathogens
  pathogenesis
title: Polar Flagellar Biosynthesis and a Regulator of Flagellar Number Influence Spatial Parameters of Cell Division in Campylobacter jejuni