Mammalian bile acids (BAs) are oxidized metabolites of cholesterol whose amphiphilic properties serve in lipid and cholesterol uptake. BAs also act as hormone-like substances that regulate metabolism. The Caenorhabditis elegans clk-1 mutants sustain elevated mitochondrial oxidative stress and display a slow defecation phenotype that is sensitive to the level of dietary cholesterol. We found that: 1) The defecation phenotype of clk-1 mutants is suppressed by mutations in tat-2 identified in a previous unbiased screen for suppressors of clk-1. TAT-2 is homologous to ATP8B1, a flippase required for normal BA secretion in mammals. 2) The phenotype is suppressed by cholestyramine, a resin that binds BAs. 3) The phenotype is suppressed by the knock-down of C. elegans homologues of BA–biosynthetic enzymes. 4) The phenotype is enhanced by treatment with BAs. 5) Lipid extracts from C. elegans contain an activity that mimics the effect of BAs on clk-1, and the activity is more abundant in clk-1 extracts. 6) clk-1 and clk-1; tat-2 double mutants show altered cholesterol content. 7) The clk-1 phenotype is enhanced by high dietary cholesterol and this requires TAT-2. 8) Suppression of clk-1 by tat-2 is rescued by BAs, and this requires dietary cholesterol. 9) The clk-1 phenotype, including the level of activity in lipid extracts, is suppressed by antioxidants and enhanced by depletion of mitochondrial superoxide dismutases. These observations suggest that C. elegans synthesizes and secretes molecules with properties and functions resembling those of BAs. These molecules act in cholesterol uptake, and their level of synthesis is up-regulated by mitochondrial oxidative stress. Future investigations should reveal whether these molecules are in fact BAs, which would suggest the unexplored possibility that the elevated oxidative stress that characterizes the metabolic syndrome might participate in disease processes by affecting the regulation of metabolism by BAs.
In mammals, cholesterol is necessary for the structure and function of membranes, and is the substrate for the biosynthesis of signalling molecules such as sexual steroids, bioactive compounds such as vitamin D, and bile acids (BAs) [1]. Cholesterol is converted into BAs through a series of oxidation reactions, as well as a shortening of the side chain in mammals (Figure S1). The enzymes that catalyze the individual biosynthetic steps of BA synthesis are localized in different cellular compartments, including the endoplasmic reticulum, cytosol, mitochondria, and peroxisomes. For example, the oxidation of the side-chain takes place in the mitochondria, but side-chain shortening takes place in the peroxisomes. In vertebrates, these reactions occur predominantly in hepatocytes. BAs regulate cholesterol and lipid metabolism in a variety of ways. They participate in cholesterol, lipid and hydrophobic vitamin uptake through their properties as detergents. They also participate in cholesterol elimination as they are secreted into the gut from where a fraction is lost every day in the feces. However, most of the secreted BAs are taken up again through the gut epithelium and can be re-circulated to the liver and re-secreted into bile, a process that is called the entero-hepatic circulation of BAs. In addition, BAs are signalling molecules that integrate several aspects of metabolism, including fat, glucose, and energy metabolism by regulating gene expression through nuclear hormone receptors such as the farnesoid X receptor (FXR), the pregnane X receptor (PXR), and the vitamin D receptor (VDR) (BA biology is reviewed in detail in [2], [3]). In mammals, BA excretion and recirculation depend on a number of membrane transporters such as ATP8B1 and ABCB11. ATP8B1, a type 4 P-type ATPase is a predicted phospholipid flippase [4]. Flippases transfer lipids from one leaflet of the membrane to the other thus changing the composition of both leaflets and the properties of the membranes. Several studies in mice suggest that ATP8B1 deficiency causes loss of canalicular membrane phospholipid asymmetry and as a result the resistance of the canalicular membrane to hydrophobic BAs is decreased, which impairs the activity of ABCB11, the BA export pump, and causes cholestasis, a pathological retention of bile [5]. Mutation of ATP8B1 in humans leads to progressive familial intrahepatic cholestasis type 1 (PFIC1) [6]. ATP8B1 shares 56% sequence identity with C. elegans TAT-2 (for Transbilayer Amphipath Transporters) [4], [7], [8]. A tat-2 mutant was found to exhibit hypersensitivity to low dietary cholesterol with decreased reproductive growth [8]. tat-2 mutation also suppresses the conditional growth arrest phenotypes resulting from mutation of elo-5, a gene encoding a very long chain fatty acid (VLCFA) elongase, which is required for the production of two monomethyl branched-chain fatty acids (mmBCFAs) in C. elegans [7]. As tat-2 also partially suppresses developmental defects caused by reduction of the expression of sptl-1, which disrupts sphingolipid biosynthesis, the authors proposed that TAT-2 acts by affecting the localization of mmBCFA-containing sphingolipids. Like vertebrates, C. elegans need sterols (reviewed in [9]). However, as C. elegans is capable only of modifying sterols and not of synthesising them de novo, worms are auxotrophic for sterols, which have to be added to the culture media (generally at 5 µg/ml cholesterol). A reduction in sterol supplementation leads to a complex phenotype that includes abnormal moulting, and inappropriate dauer formation. A complete lack of sterol supplementation leads to lethality. As sterols appear to be required only in very small amounts for normal physiology in worms, the deficit resulting from the absence of dietary cholesterol might result from deficits in the synthesis of signalling molecules derived from cholesterol. Indeed BA-like molecules derived from cholesterol have been identified in C. elegans and shown to have roles in signalling [10]. Dafachronic acid, which is required for bypassing dauer formation, has some characteristics of BAs, with oxidation of the steroid ring and of the side-chain, but its oxidation is not extensive and the side-chain is not shortened [10]. Yet, like vertebrate steroids and BAs, it acts via a nuclear hormone receptor, encoded by daf-12 [10]. In mammals, after BA-mediated absorption, ingested lipids, cholesterol, and lipid-soluble vitamins, are transported from the gut to the tissues that need them via circulating lipoproteins such as chylomicrons. Other lipoproteins such as low density lipoproteins (LDL) distribute lipids and cholesterol from the liver to peripheral tissues, and high density lipoproteins (HDL) transport cholesterol from peripheral tissues back to the liver in a process termed reverse cholesterol transport. The best known lipoproteins in C. elegans are the yolk particles. The protein moieties of yolk particles are vitellogenins, distant homologues of ApoB, which is the apolipoprotein in chylomicrons and LDL [11]. In C. elegans, cholesterol, fatty acids, and possibly other nutrients are transported from the gut to developing oocytes through the pseudocoelomic cavity by means of yolk particles [12], [13]. However, several observations suggest that there is another lipid transport system in worms [14]. For example, hermaphrodites are capable of transporting cholesterol before the vitellogenins are expressed and males do not express vitellogenins yet accumulate cholesterol in developing sperm [13]. Furthermore, a mutation in dsc-4, which encodes the worm homologue of the microsomal triglyceride transfer protein (MTP) [15], which is required in mammals for the synthesis of LDL in the ER, produces multiple phenotypic effects without affecting yolk production. CLK-1 is a conserved mitochondrial enzyme that is necessary for the biosynthesis of the antioxidant and redox cofactor ubiquinone (co-enzyme Q; CoQ). Mutations in C. elegans clk-1 or its mouse orthologue affect mitochondrial function [16], [17], in particular they increase mitochondrial oxidative stress in both organisms [18], [19]. In worms, this results in a number of phenotypes, in particular slow development, slow aging, and slow rhythmic behaviours such as defecation [20]. The defecation cycle of C. elegans generates rhythmic body muscle contractions. This is a well-studied, highly regulated behaviour that is readily quantifiable [21]. dsc-4/mtp was originally identified as a mutation that suppresses the slow defecation of clk-1 mutants [22]. Given the known function of MTP it was concluded that a type of MTP-dependent, LDL-like lipoprotein, distinct from yolk, affects the rate of defecation [14]. Reducing the level of dietary cholesterol mimics the effects of dsc-4 on the defecation cycle length of clk-1 mutants [15], [23]. These observations suggest that clk-1 mutants have slow defecation because they have high levels of LDL-like lipoproteins biosynthesis and secretion. Furthermore, the MTP-dependent lipid transport system appears to be so well conserved between mammals and C. elegans that drugs that have been developed to lower lipid levels in humans can act as suppressors of the slow defecation rate of clk-1 [23]. In particular, the slow defecation is suppressed by drugs that antagonize high LDL levels by increasing HDL levels (e. g. an inhibitor of the HDL receptor SR-BI [24]), or that reverse cholesterol transport by stimulating gene expression through nuclear hormone receptors (e. g. gemfibrozil [25]). Thus, although it is not yet known how elevated lipoprotein biosynthesis slows down the defecation cycle, the clk-1 mutants provide a tractable genetic model for characterizing the mechanisms of lipids and sterol uptake and the biosynthesis and secretion of LDL-like lipoproteins. Here, using genetic and pharmacological approaches, we show that sterol uptake in C. elegans depends on molecules that are functionally similar to BAs and might be structurally similar as well. These molecules are distinct from dafachronic acids and are synthesized and secreted through a pathway that appears to be molecularly very similar to that of BA synthesis and secretion in mammals. We also show that this pathway is altered by the high mitochondrial oxidative stress of clk-1 mutants. A link of oxidative stress and aging with dyslipidemia and with the other cardiovascular risk factors that constitute the metabolic syndrome has repeatedly been evidenced in mammals, but its mechanistic basis has not yet been elucidated. Our findings suggest that the link could be a perturbation of BA biosynthesis, a possibility that has not yet been explored in mammals.
We previously carried out a genetic screen to find suppressors of the slow defecation phenotype of clk-1 mutants [22]. In this screen we identified the dsc-4/mtp mutation (described in the Introduction) as well as another mutation, dsc-3 (qm179), which produced a very similar phenotype [22]. As the effects of dsc-4/mtp and dsc-3 (qm179) are not additive (Table S1), they may act in a common pathway or affect a common process. We mapped dsc-3 (qm179) between dpy-13 and unc-5 on LG IV [22]. Using the hypotheses that dsc-3 is involved in lipoprotein metabolism (based on the identity of dsc-4/mtp) we identified tat-2 as a candidate gene in that chromosomal region. We determined that qm179 is allelic to tat-2 (tm1634) based on the following experiments, whose results are shown in full in Table S1 (Table S1 lists all numerical values, samples sizes and statistical analyses for all defecation data shown in figures or mentioned in the text). Firstly, both RNAi against tat-2 and the deletion mutation of tat-2 (tm1634) were phenotypically similar to qm179 in both the wild type and clk-1 backgrounds. Secondly, the tat-2 (tm1634) deletion mutation fails to complement qm179 (Figure 1A). Thirdly, transgenic expression of tat-2 rescues the suppression of clk-1 by qm179 (Figure 1A). Finally, a G-to-A point mutation that results in an amino acid change from Alanine to Threonine at residue 665 of the protein was found by sequencing the coding region of tat-2 in qm179 mutants (Figure 1B). We name the gene tat-2 from this point on. The allele analyzed is always qm179 except when otherwise specified. The high sequence conservation between TAT-2 and ATP8B1 suggests that their functions could be conserved as well. To test this directly we introduced a cDNA coding for mouse ATP8B1 in clk-1; tat-2 mutants under the C. elegans tat-2 promoter (Figure 1C). This could partially rescue the suppression of the defecation phenotype, and was abolished by RNAi against the mouse gene sequence (Figure 1C). Moreover, rescue by the mouse Atp8b1 gene was also prevented by introduction of mutations corresponding to either the tat-2 (qm179) mutation or the human G308V mutation (Table S1), strongly indicating a functional conservation. In order to determine the focus of action of tat-2, we constructed a reporter gene in which the tat-2 gene with 3. 4 kb of upstream promoter sequence was fused in frame to gfp. This construct was capable of rescuing the defecation phenotype of tat-2 (qm179) in the clk-1 background (Table S1). The fusion protein was expressed in the gut, spermatheca, proximal gonad, vulva, excretory cell, excretory gland cell, pharyngeal procorpus, the pharyngeal-intestinal valve and the rectal gland cell (Figure S2), which is consistent with what was previously found by others [7], [8]. We also constructed three other reporters in which 3. 4 kb of the tat-2 promoter were replaced by the promoters from the intestinal specific ges-1, spermatheca-specific sth-1, or excretory canal-specific pgp-12, genes. Only the Pges-1: : tat-2: : gfp construct could rescue the phenotype (Table S1). Given the known function of ATP8B1 in bile acid secretion in mammals (see Introduction), and the fact that eliminating the function of tat-2 suppresses clk-1, we wondered whether a pharmacological agent that targets BAs could also suppress clk-1. Cholestyramine is a BA-binding resin that is taken orally by people to lower the availability and thus the re-absorption of BA in the gut, which ultimately results in lowering in the level of circulating LDL [26]. We found that addition of 0. 025% cholestyramine to worm plates partially suppresses the slow defecation cycle of clk-1 mutants (Figure 2A). Cholestyramine had no effect on the wild type or on isp-1 mutants, which, like clk-1 mutants, have mitochondrial defects and a slow defecation cycle [27]. There was also no effect on tat-2 or dsc-4/mtp mutants (Table S1). Cholestyramine can bind organic molecules of intermediate to low polarity that bear an acidic group. This supports the hypothesis that C. elegans secretes molecules that have chemical properties resembling those of BAs and that the altered defecation cycle of clk-1 mutants is due to enhanced secretion of such molecules. We reasoned that if there are mammalian-like BAs in worms they might be synthesized by enzymes that are similar to those in mammals. Reducing BA synthesis by depleting such enzymes by RNAi knock-down should suppress clk-1, similar to the effect of tat-2 mutations and cholestyramine treatment. The biosynthesis of BAs in mammals is complex and involves a variety of enzymatic steps carried out in diverse cellular compartments [1]. In order to determine if BA-like molecules are synthesised in a similar manner in worms, we examined 17 of the most common of these steps by identifying the best C. elegans homologues of the mammalian enzymes, and testing their impact on the defecation cycle of clk-1 mutants by RNAi (Table 1). Six of these enzymes are part of the same class of proteins, the P450 oxidases. As all the C. elegans proteins of this class are more or less equally similar to each of the vertebrate proteins, we tested all those we found by homology searching (78 genes). For other classes we tested several of the most homologous proteins (Table 1). Some classes of homologues did not have any effect on the defecation phenotype of clk-1 mutants, e. g. 3β-hydroxy-Δ5-C27 steroid oxidoreductase, 2-methylacyl-CoA racemase, and bile acid CoA: amino acid N-acyltransferase. However, thirteen P450 enzymes as well as worm genes encoding proteins that are highly similar to mammalian branched-chain acyl-CoA oxidase and 3α-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase, cholesterol 25-hydroxylase, bile acid CoA ligase, the D-bifunctional protein, and the two genes (daf-22 and nlt-1) that separately encode the two activities of mammalian peroxisomal thiolase, were effective in affecting the defecation cycle of clk-1 mutants (Table 1), suggesting that they may participate in the biosynthesis of BA-like molecules. Note that RNAi against daf-9/cyp-22A1 and hsd-1, which encode activities that are known to participate in the synthesis of dafachronic acids, did not affect clk-1 defecation (Table 1). daf-12, the nuclear receptor target of dafachronic acids, was also knocked down by RNAi under the same conditions as the enzymes: it produced only a very small, not significant, suppression (−2. 8±3. 9 seconds (P = 0. 4795); n = 27 for the control, n = 38 for daf-12 (RNAi) ). Interestingly, in addition to suppressors of the phenotype, we also obtained a few enhancers, mostly among the P450s (Table 1). P450s in mammals have numerous functions besides BA synthesis, and thus have the potential to affect the rate of defecation in ways unrelated to the synthesis of BA-like molecules. This is consistent with the observation that most genetic changes that affect defecation tend to slow it down [21]. DAF-36 is a Rieske oxygenase that acts as a cholesterol 7-desaturase that converts cholesterol to 7-dehydrocholesterol [28], [29]. DAF-36 is necessary for dafachronic acid biosynthesis, which is why mutation of daf-36 leads to a dauer constitutive phenotype. We found that daf-36 (k114) also suppresses the slow defecation cycle of clk-1 (by 19. 4 seconds), with only a very small effect (1. 5 seconds) on the wild type (Table S1). This is consistent with the hypothesis that the active molecules that are transported by TAT-2 and are bound by cholestyramine could be oxidized cholesterol derivatives, although they are clearly distinct from dafachronic acids (see above). Lowering the level of the hypothetical BA-like molecules by reducing their secretion via mutation of tat-2, reducing their biosynthesis by RNAi or mutations against potential biosynthetic enzymes, or by sequestration through cholestyramine suppresses the clk-1 phenotype. We reasoned that the phenotype might therefore be enhanced by BA supplementation. We treated clk-1 mutants with mixed mammalian BAs and found that their phenotype was indeed enhanced while the wild type was completely insensitive (Figure 2B). These findings show that externally applied BAs can act on C. elegans. It also suggests that in the wild type the processes that are affected by BAs and that ultimately determine the defecation cycle, such as cholesterol handling (see below) and lipoprotein metabolism (see Introduction), are better regulated than in clk-1 mutants. In mammals, BAs of different structures have been found to interact differently with nuclear hormone receptors thus affecting differently the regulation of BA synthesis and secretion, and also to be more or less efficient in cholesterol uptake [2]. In particular, more hydrophobic BAs appear to result in greater cholesterol uptake [30]. To test whether the structures of the BAs are important for their effects on clk-1 mutants we treated the wild type and clk-1 mutants with three concentrations of cholic acid (CA), one of the main relatively hydrophilic mammalian BA, and chenodeoxycholic acid (CDCA), one of the main relatively hydrophobic mammalian BA. No treatment had any effect on the wild type (Table S1). However, at two concentrations (0. 15 mM and 0. 6 mM), CA suppressed the defecation cycle of clk-1 mutants, although it enhanced the phenotype at 2. 5 mM, while CDCA enhanced the phenotype in a dose-dependent manner at all concentrations tested (Figure 2C). One possibility to explain the ability of CA to suppress clk-1 suggests that it might be more hydrophilic than the average BA-like molecules secreted by worms, thus effectively diluting their strength in taking up cholesterol. This notion is also supported by the observation that CA was a better suppressor at lower (0. 15 mM) than at the higher (0. 6 mM) concentration, and enhanced the phenotype at the highest concentration (2. 5 mM). This suggests that at the higher concentrations the greater amount of BA (here CA) provided by the treatment in part compensates for the fact that CA is a more hydrophilic BA. CDCA had no effect at the lowest concentration but enhanced the phenotype at higher concentrations (Figure 2C). The results presented above suggest that C. elegans produces and secretes molecules with BA-like properties, and possibly structures, and that this process is deregulated in clk-1 mutants. We reasoned that the hypothetical endogenous BA-like molecules should have the same effect on the wild type and clk-1 mutants as exogenous BAs. To test this we made lipid extracts [31] from both the wild type and clk-1 mutants and assayed them on the defecation cycle of both genotypes. The lipid extracts were applied to plates in the same way as BAs in previous experiments. Extracts from both genotypes had no effect on the defecation of the wild type. However, extract from clk-1 mutants at 0. 02 and 0. 1 mg significantly enhanced the phenotype of clk-1 mutants (Figure 2D). At these concentrations wild type extracts had no significant effect on the mutants. Thus to establish that the wild type also contains the activity, and to measure how much higher the activity was in clk-1 mutants, we produced a large quantity of extract from the wild type, which allowed to test 0. 4 mg of activity on the wild type and clk-1. The high concentration of wild type extract was again ineffective on wild type animals but enhanced the phenotype of clk-1 as much as 0. 1 mg of extract from clk-1 (Figure 2D). We conclude that both the wild type and clk-1 mutants contain the activity but that clk-1 mutants contain approximately 4× time higher steady-state levels of the activity. One of the functions of BAs is to regulate cholesterol uptake and handling. We therefore measured the level of cholesterol in the wild type and in clk-1 mutants grown under low (2 µg/ml), standard (5 µg/ml) and high (50 µg/ml) levels of cholesterol supplementation. Both the wild type and clk-1 mutants grown on high cholesterol contained significantly more cholesterol than when grown under standard conditions (Figure 3A). However the increase was significantly greater in clk-1 mutants. There was no significant difference between 2 µg and 5 µg/ml of supplementation for either genotype. We also assayed the cholesterol content of tat-2 and clk-1; tat-2 mutants. The cholesterol content of tat-2 was similar to that of the wild type at all levels of cholesterol supplementation. However the increase of cholesterol content observed in clk-1 mutants under high cholesterol supplementation was fully abolished in clk-1; tat-2 double mutants (Figure 3A and Table S2). Furthermore, cholesterol content in the double mutants was elevated at low and standard level of supplementation and thus similar at all levels of cholesterol supplementation, indicating that clk-1 and tat-2 interact in determining the level of cholesterol uptake and content. We have previously shown that the defecation cycle of clk-1 mutants, but not that of the wild type, is suppressed by lowering the levels of dietary cholesterol from 5 µg/ml to 2 µg/ml [23]. We have now extended this observation to the effect of high cholesterol (50 µg/ml), which has no effect on the wild type but further slows down the defecation of clk-1 (qm30) mutants (Figure 3B). We had observed (Figure 3A) that clk-1 and tat-2 interact in determining the level of cholesterol uptake. We therefore wondered if the metabolism of the BA-like molecules was involved in these effects of the level of dietary cholesterol on the defecation cycle. We found that low cholesterol shortened the defecation cycle of clk-1; tat-2, but that the effect of high cholesterol on clk-1 mutants was fully suppressed in clk-1; tat-2 mutants (Figure 3B). The observation that altering the level of media cholesterol can affect the defecation phenotype of clk-1 mutants in both directions suggests that uptake or subsequent handling of cholesterol can change the phenotype caused by the deregulated metabolism of the BA-like molecules in clk-1 mutants. The results described above suggest that the suppression produced by the tat-2 mutation might be due to lower secretion of the BA-like molecules. To test this directly we treated tat-2 and clk-1; tat-2 mutants with a small amount (0. 015%) of mixed mammalian BAs (Figure 2E and Table S1). These exogenous BAs had no effect on the wild type or dsc-4 mutants but rescued the tat-2 phenotype in both the wild-type and clk-1 backgrounds. Furthermore, these effects of the exogenous BAs were abolished in the absence of cholesterol supplementation (Figure 2E). We also found that the effects of BAs we have previously observed, such as suppression and enhancement of clk-1 by pure CA or CDCA at various concentrations require cholesterol supplementation (Figure 2C). These results indicate: 1) that the effect of tat-2 on clk-1 mutants is mediated by a reduction in the secretion of BA-like molecules; and 2) that the effects of BAs and tat-2 on clk-1 mutants implicate changes in cholesterol uptake. We have shown above that the phenotypes of clk-1 mutants include deregulated metabolism of BA-like molecules, which results in altered cholesterol content and abnormal sensitivity to the level of cholesterol supplementation. Previous studies of clk-1 indicated that the principal cellular defect of these mutants is an elevated level of mitochondrial oxidative stress, characterized by elevated mitochondrial ROS production [18], elevated oxidative damage [32], [33], and increased sensitivity to pro-oxidant drugs [34]. In addition, several of the clk-1 phenotypes are strongly enhanced when the expression of the main mitochondrial superoxide dismutase (SOD-2) is reduced by RNAi [32] or mutation [33]. In fact defecation was among the phenotypes that were found to be enhanced in the clk-1; sod-2 double mutants [33]. To further explore the link between ROS and the clk-1 defecation phenotype we first determined whether RNAi against the other C. elegans sod genes had any effect. We found that in addition to sod-2, RNAi knockdown of sod-3, the gene encoding the other mitochondrial superoxide dismutase, enhanced the defecation phenotype of clk-1 (Figure 4A). However, RNAi against the three non-mitochondrial sod genes (sod-1, sod-4, and sod-5) did not affect the phenotype (Figure 4A), indicating that the enhancement of the phenotype is specific to alterations in mitochondrial ROS levels. Consistent with previous findings, this suggests that the slow defecation phenotype of clk-1 mutants might be due to their elevated mitochondrial ROS production. In order to test this further we treated clk-1 mutants with the antioxidant N-acetyl-cysteine (NAC) a commonly used hydrophilic antioxidant, which can reduce mitochondrial ROS production [18]. We found that NAC treatment could partially suppress the slow defecation cycle in a dose-dependent manner (Figure 4B). Complete suppression could not be obtained because higher levels of the compound was toxic, possibly because of inhibition of normal ROS levels in other compartments. Finally, to test whether the increased mitochondrial oxidative stress is the cause of the deregulated metabolism of the BA-like molecules we tested whether the tat-2 (qm179) mutation could suppress the effect of antioxidant treatment. We found that treatment with 10 mM NAC was without effect on tat-2; clk-1 (Figure 4C and Table S1), indicating that tat-2 (qm179) is epistatic to antioxidant treatment. This is consistent with the elevated mitochondrial oxidative stress being the primary cause of the deregulation of the metabolism of the BA-like molecules observed in clk-1 mutants. The hypothesis suggested by the results described so far is that the clk-1 defecation phenotype is the result of increased mitochondrial oxidative stress in these mutants, which increases the level of activity of BA-like molecules. We tested this hypothesis directly by producing and testing lipid extracts from clk-1 mutants treated with NAC and from clk-1 (qm30); sod-2 (ok1030) double mutants (Figure 5). NAC treatment reduced the level of the activity found in the extract, and the extract from clk-1; sod-2 double mutants contained substantially higher level of activity than the clk-1 extract. For an unknown reason the clk-1; sod-2 extract was the most variable in terms of its activity on individual worms (Figure 5 and Table S1).
Here we have shown that: 1) clk-1 mutants are suppressed by mutations of TAT-2, the worm orthologue of an ATPase that is necessary for BA secretion in mammals, 2) the suppression by tat-2 can be rescued by exogenous BAs, 3) RNAi knockdown of several C. elegans enzymes homologous to those that are implicated in BA synthesis in mammals suppress the clk-1 phenotype, but not the knockdown of some of the enzymes known to be necessary for dafachronic acid synthesis, 4) clk-1 mutants display a cholesterol-dependent sensitivity to exogenous BAs, as well as a sensitivity to cholestyramine, a drug that sequesters BAs, 5) clk-1 mutants but not the wild type are sensitive to an activity contained in lipid extracts from worms, 6) the clk-1 defecation phenotype is suppressed by a mutation in daf-36, which encodes a cholesterol 7-desaturase, suggesting that the activity is a cholesterol derivative, 7) clk-1 mutants contain more of this activity, 8) the level of the activity is altered by mitochondrial oxidative stress, 9) clk-1 mutants have a deregulated cholesterol metabolism, as indicated by the fact that their phenotype can be affected by reducing or increasing the level of dietary cholesterol and that they accumulate more cholesterol than the wild type when supplied with high levels of dietary cholesterol, 10) clk-1 and tat-2 interact in determining cholesterol content as, in contrast to what is observed in the wild type, the cholesterol content of clk-1; tat-2 is similar at all levels of dietary cholesterol supplementation. This last observation suggests that the abnormal cholesterol metabolism is caused by the deregulated metabolism of the BA-like molecules that are affected by clk-1 and tat-2. Together all these observations imply that there are BA-like molecules involved in cholesterol uptake in C. elegans, but also that these molecules are likely to be structurally similar to BAs, as their biosynthesis and secretion are affected by activities that are known to affect BAs in mammals. The results summarized in the previous paragraph lead to a model of regulatory relationships between cholesterol availability, cholesterol uptake, the synthesis and secretion of BA-like molecules, and LDL-like lipoprotein synthesis and secretion in C. elegans (Figure 6). All our findings appear to be remarkably consistent with what is known about the synthesis and regulation of BAs and LDL in vertebrates. Thus we propose that secreted BA-like molecules participate in cholesterol uptake and that the function of TAT-2 is required for their secretion. Cholesterol is used in the synthesis of the BA-like molecules and, as in mammals, the BA-like molecules act directly on cholesterol uptake but also as signalling molecules that positively regulate the synthesis of LDL-like lipoproteins. The core of our model is that CLK-1, via its effect on limiting mitochondrial ROS generation, is required for a negative feedback mechanism that down-regulates the synthesis of the BA-like molecules as a function of cholesterol uptake. In the absence of CLK-1 more BA-like molecules are synthesized (Figure 2D) and more cholesterol can be taken up (Figure 3A). The increased synthesis of the BA-like molecules up-regulates the level of LDL-like lipoprotein synthesis and secretion, which in turn determines the length of the defecation cycle. Our data show that availability of BA-like molecules and the rate of defecation are tightly linked as shown by the sensitivity of the mutant defecation cycle to BA supplementation, sequestration of the BA-like molecules, and the inhibition of the synthesis of the BA-like molecules. The hypothesis that CLK-1 is necessary for a feed-back from cholesterol uptake to the synthesis of the BA-like molecules provides the link between the level of cholesterol supplementation and the level of the BA-like molecules (and thus between the level of cholesterol supplementation and defecation) (Figure 6). However, the model cannot accurately predict the effect of mutations on the level of whole-animal cholesterol. Indeed, the level of cholesterol likely depends on cholesterol flux through the entire organism. This is determined by a number of factors that we cannot precisely quantify at this stage, including the exact quantitative relationship between the level of cholesterol uptake and the level of synthesis of the BA-like molecules via the CLK-1-dependent mechanism, the level of cholesterol loss through the synthesis of BA-like molecules if these are cholesterol-derived, and the loss of the BA-like molecules through secretion, the level of cholesterol loss through LDL-like lipoprotein secretion (whose target in the organism is unknown), the level of cholesterol loss through yolk synthesis and egg-laying, and in fact any other form of cholesterol elimination or storage, whether or not regulated by the BA-like molecules. Suppression of the clk-1 defecation phenotype can be obtained by knocking down the enzymes necessary for peroxisomal β-oxidation that in mammals are necessary for shortening the side-chain of cholesterol (Table 1). This suggests that if the C. elegans BA-like molecules are cholesterol derived they might have a shortened side-chain. This is in contrast to dafachronic acid (Figure S1), which is a steroid that acts as a hormone that regulates development in C. elegans [35]. We have not yet tested if the BA-like molecules can affect other clk-1 phenotypes in addition to defecation, such as slow aging. More detailed structural information on the C. elegans BA-like molecules, and possibly the availability of synthetic molecules, might be necessary to test rigorously their effect on phenotypes that are harder to quantify than defecation. The suppressive effect of cholic acid (CA) at very low concentrations is difficult to explain unless the BA-like molecules are indeed structurally similar to BAs. However, if this is the case the observed effect might result from the dilution by CA of the native and potentially more hydrophobic BA secreted by worms. However, as CA serves as negative feedback for BA synthesis and secretion in mice [36], it is possibly that it could carry out a similar role in C. elegans, which would provide an alternative explanation for its paradoxical action at low concentration. If this is the case, further study of this phenomenon might help in identifying the nuclear hormone receptors (NHRs) through which the C. elegans BAs might regulate metabolism and their own synthesis. We have already identified a number of nuclear hormone receptor loci whose down-regulation suppresses clk-1 mutants (not shown). One or several of these could be the receptors for the BA-like molecules. The metabolic syndrome is a collection of age-associated disease risk factors that includes obesity, insulin resistance, hypertension and dyslipidemia. Oxidative stress, which is well known to increase with age and in obese individuals [37], has been implicated in most of the components of the metabolic syndrome and might be the common link between them [38], [39], [40]. Our findings with C. elegans, where there appears to be BA-like molecules whose synthesis, secretion and activity shares strong similarities with BAs in mammals, suggest that mitochondrial oxidative stress can lead to deregulation of BA synthesis. Abnormal BA levels in turn could lead to metabolic disease processes via the action of BAs on sterol, lipid and glucose metabolism by signalling through BA receptors. Interestingly, the possibility of an involvement of oxidative stress on the regulation of BA synthesis and thus on the consequences of a deregulation of this process has not yet been explored in mammals.
Fourth larval stage (L4) animals were transferred to the test plates and grown at 20°C. The effects of the different cholesterol concentrations or compounds were scored after raising the worms on the test plates for one generation. Defecation cycle rates were measured as previously described [22], at 20°C for all experiments except for the RNAi and antioxidant treatments for which 25°C was used. Compounds (cholestyramine, mixed bile acids, cholic acid, and chenodeoxycholic acid were tested by spreading them on plates, except that N-acetyl-L-cysteine was added to the nematode growth media (NGM) prior to pouring it into plates. See also Text S1. dsc-3 had previously been mapped to LG IV, between unc-33 and dpy-4 [22]. By using 2-point and 3-point mapping strategies, the genetic position of qm179 was refined to a position between the two cloned gene dpy-13 and unc-5. Due to the incomplete cosmid coverage of the tat-2 gene, no cosmid that spans this region can rescue the qm179 mutants. Therefore qm179 mutants were rescued by injecting two partially overlapping PCR fragments of tat-2 genomic DNA (from −3123 to +7277 and from +7252 to +13567, which includes the UTRs) for in vivo recombination. Two other mutations allelic to qm179 had been originally identified, qm180 and qm184 [22]. The lesion in qm184 was identical to the qm179 lesion, and the lesion in qm180 was not found in the tat-2 exonic sequences. The tat-2 (tm1634) allele was obtained from the National Bioresource Project and outcrossed three times. See also Text S1. The tat-2 transcriptional reporter, Ptat-2: : gfp (pCDB898) was used as backbone to build the Ptat-2: : mAtp8b1, Ptat-2: : mAtp8b1 A705T, Ptat-2: : mAtp8b1 G308V clones. The PCR product of 3. 4 kb upstream of the initiating ATG of tat-2 was cloned into the PstI and SmaI sites of the pPD95_77 vector. The full length of mouse Atp8b1 cDNA was amplified from the RIKEN clone F830210O18. To construct Ptat-2: : tat-2: : gfp (pCDB902) a 3945 bp long wild type tat-2 cDNA containing 22 exons was inserted into the SmaI site of pCDB898. To construct Pges-1: : tat-2: : gfp, Psth-1: : tat-2: : gfp, and Ppgp-12: : tat-2: : gfp, (pCDB906, pCDB905 and pCDB904, respectively) the tat-2 promoter of pCDB902 was replaced by PCR products of 2 kb upstream of the ges-1 initiation codon, 1. 6 kb upstream of the sth-1 initiation codon or 2. 7 kb upstream of the pgp-12 initiation codon. These constructs were injected into clk-1; tat-2 (qm179) mutants at a concentration of 0. 1 ng/µl along with the transformation marker ttx-3: : gfp at a concentration of 200 ng/µl. See also Text S1. Lipids were extracted following [41], and the cholesterol content was determined with a kit (10007640) from Cayman Chemical. The final concentration of Triton X-100 in each sample was 0. 5%. We also measured the volumes of young adults for all genotypes as previously described [42], and no difference from the wild type was found (data not shown). See also Text S1. The lipid extracts were prepared as previously described [31] and re-suspended in DMSO. To assay the activity of extracts from the wild type, clk-1 (qm30), clk-1 (qm30); sod-2 (ok1030) or clk-1 mutants treated with NAC, 36 µl of DMSO-dissolved extract (or 36 µl of DMSO as control) was spread onto 5 cm plates. Phenotypes of adult progeny were measured after raising L4 animals on the test plates for one generation. Due to the sensitivity of clk-1 mutants to dietary cholesterol level, we measured and calculated that the final concentrations of extracts applied to the plates contained less than 0. 1 µg/ml of cholesterol, which cannot therefore be responsible for any of the effects observed (Figure 2D). See also Text S1. 5–10 clk-1 (qm30) hermaphrodites L4 larvae were picked to RNAi plates. For the following 3 days, worms were transferred to new RNAi plates to rid of contaminating OP50 bacteria. Progeny worms were grown to the L4 stage and were then picked to new RNAi plates for scoring. 18 hours later, they were transferred to 25°C. After two hours of acclimation, their defecation phenotype was scored. We used 25°C for all RNAi experiments, except those shown in Figure 1C, because the responses tend to be more robust [22]. For each RNAi clone, five worms were scored for one defecation cycle. Clones that had a significant effect on defecation rate were re-screened 2–3 times.
Cholesterol metabolism, in particular the transport of cholesterol in the blood by lipoproteins, is an important determinant of human cardiovascular health. Bile acids are breakdown products of cholesterol that have detergent properties and are secreted into the gut by the liver. Bile acids carry out three distinct roles in cholesterol metabolism: 1) Their synthesis from cholesterol participates in cholesterol elimination. 2) They act as detergents in the uptake of dietary cholesterol from the gut. 3) They regulate many aspects of metabolism, including cholesterol metabolism, by molecular mechanisms similar to that of steroid hormones. We have found that cholesterol uptake and lipoprotein metabolism in the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans are regulated by molecules whose activities, biosynthesis, and secretion strongly resemble that of bile acids and which might be bile acids. Most importantly we have found that oxidative stress upsets the regulation of the synthesis of these molecules. The metabolic syndrome is a set of cardiovascular risk factors that include obesity, high blood cholesterol, hypertension, and insulin resistance. Given the function of bile acids as metabolic regulators, our findings with C. elegans suggest the unexplored possibility that the elevated oxidative stress that characterizes the metabolic syndrome may participate in mammalian disease processes by affecting the regulation of bile acid synthesis.
animal models
biochemistry
model organisms
biology
Mitochondrial Oxidative Stress Alters a Pathway in Caenorhabditis elegans Strongly Resembling That of Bile Acid Biosynthesis and Secretion in Vertebrates