Previous studies have shown that EBLV-1 strains exclusively hosted by Eptesicus isabellinus bats in the Iberian Peninsula cluster in a specific monophyletic group that is related to the EBLV-1b lineage found in the rest of Europe. More recently, enhanced passive surveillance has allowed the detection of the first EBLV-1 strains associated to Eptesicus serotinus south of the Pyrenees. The aim of this study is the reconstruction of the EBLV-1 phylogeny and phylodynamics in the Iberian Peninsula in the context of the European continent. We have sequenced 23 EBLV-1 strains detected on nine E. serotinus and 14 E. isabellinus. Phylogenetic analyses were performed on the first 400-bp-5’ fragment of the Nucleoprotein (N) gene together with other 162 sequences from Europe. Besides, fragments of the variable region of the phosphoprotein (P) gene and the glycoprotein-polymerase (G-L) intergenic region were studied on Spanish samples. Phylogenies show that two of the new EBLV-1a strains from Iberian E. serotinus clustered together with French strains from the North of the Pyrenees, suggesting a recent expansion southwards of this subtype. The remaining seven Iberian strains from E. serotinus grouped, instead, within the cluster linked, so far, to E. isabellinus, indicating that spatial distribution prevails over species specificity in explaining rabies distribution and supporting interspecific transmission. The structure found within the Iberian Peninsula for EBLV-1b is in concordance with that described previously for E. isabellinus. Finally, we have found that the current EBLV-1 European strains could have emerged only 175 years ago according to our evolutionary dynamics analyses.
Rabies is caused by viruses of the genus Lyssavirus, which includes so far fourteen species recognized by the International Committee on Taxonomy of Viruses (ICTV), plus the recently proposed Lleida bat Lyssavirus (LLEBV) [1] and Gannoruwa bat lyssavirus (GBLV) [2]. Three of the viruses of the phylogroup 1 are associated with European bats of the family Vespertilionidae: the European bat Lyssaviruses 1 and 2 (EBLV-1 and EBLV-2) and the Bokeloh bat Lyssavirus (BBLV). Besides, the other two lyssaviruses described so far in Europe (West Caucasian bat virus, WCBV; and LLEBV) are hosted by the cave bat Miniopterus schreibersii (Family Miniopteridae) [1,3]. Out of all of them, only EBLV-1 and EBLV-2 have caused rabies in humans, while more than 90% of the bat rabies cases have been reported from serotine bats (E. serotinus) infected by EBLV-1 [4]. EBLV-1 is divided in two main subtypes: EBLV-1a and EBLV-1b. The first one is found in an East-west axis from Ukraine to the north of France, while EBLV-1b is reported from France, southern Germany and the Netherlands [5]. EBLV-1a has been recently described also from Southern France [6]. Nevertheless, the evolutionary relationships among these viral subtypes in Western Europe are only partially known and previous attempts of evolutionary analyses [7] were hampered either by uneven available sampling or the dearth of molecular markers. Two cryptic species of serotine bats (E. serotinus and E. isabellinus) have been lately found within the genus Eptesicus in the Iberian Peninsula [8]. While E. serotinus is distributed across Northern Iberia as well as the rest of Western Europe, the sibling species. E. isabellinus is restricted to the Southern half of the Iberian Peninsula and Northern Africa [9]. So far, EBLV-1 infection has been declared only from E. isabellinus in Spain [7], forming an exclusive monophyletic clade, possibly related to the EBLV-1b subtype. In this study, we described the first EBLV-1 associated to E. serotinus South of the Pyrenees, and show how the inclusion of these new strains in phylogenetic and phylodynamic analyses together with the use of newly developed molecular markers have substantially improved our present knowledge of EBLV-1 molecular epidemiology in Europe and the Iberian Peninsula.
No live animals were used for this study. All the work has been done with bat carcasses from, either animals directly submitted to the Laboratory by public health services, or admitted in wildlife care Centers, which submitted to the laboratory those bats which could not be recovered after treatment. Consequently, the need for approval by an IACUC/ethics committee does not apply. We have sequenced three fragments of the viral genome of 23 EBLV-1 strains detected in brains of nine E. serotinus and 14 E. isabellinus sent to the National Center for Microbiology (Majadahonda, Spain) for rabies diagnosis and that were found positive for Lyssavirus antigen by the fluorescence antibody test and real time polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) [10]. Morphological bat identification was confirmed in most cases by genomic sequencing of several diagnostic mtDNA fragments [9]: 69R99 (MG211681), 80R99 (MG211682), 56R00 (MG211683), 69R00Eis (MG211684), 211R07 (MG211685), 86R08 (MG211686), 2011Riglos (MG211687), 201127004 (MG211688), 201149008 (MG211689), 201238163 (MG211690), 201325895 (MG211691), 200928458 (MG211692), 201544034 (MG211693), 201548093 (MG211694), 201539228 (MG211695), 201427094 (MG211696), 201539226 (MG211697), 44R02 (MG211698), 292R07 (MG211699). The 400-bp-5' terminal sequence of the nucleoprotein (N-400) gene was amplified and sequenced as described previously [7]. Besides, a 686-bp variable region of the phosphoprotein (P) and a 763-bp fragment including the glycoprotein-polymerase (G-L) intergenic region were amplified by EBLV-1 specific primers in nested RT-PCR reactions specific for each region (Table 1). All 23 N-400 sequences from Spain were aligned using the MAFFT software (http: //mafft. cbrc. jp/alignment/software/) together with 162 sequences from other European countries available on GenBank (S1 Table). The fittest nucleotide substitution model was selected according to the Bayesian information criterion (BIC) using jModelTest v. 2. 1. 10 (http: //darwin. uvigo. es/our-software/). For the Iberian samples we selected the substitution models HKY, K80 + I, K80 for the alignments of the P, G-L and N400 markers respectively. Besides, a GTR model was selected for the alignment of all Iberian and European N400 fragments. Only for the Iberian samples, the N, P and G-L fragments were concatenated into a 1809 base pair (bp) alignment using Sea View v. 4. 6. (Table 1) and a HKY nucleotide substitution model was selected from this concatenated alignment using Partition Finder v. 1. 1. 1. (http: //www. robertlanfear. com/partitionfinder/). Phylogenetic relationships were reconstructed for each alignment using a Bayesian approach with the program MrBayes (version 3. 1. 2) with two runs of 1 x 106 generations. Additional phylogenies were reconstructed using other three optimality criteria: Minimum Evolution (ME), Maximum Likelihood (ML) and Maximum Parsimony (MP). ME was obtained through a Neighbor-Joining algorithm with MEGA7 (http: //www. megasoftware. net/), ML was constructed with PHYML software (http: //www. atgc-montpellier. fr/phyml/) and finally, MP trees were inferred with PAUP* 4. 0b10 (http: //paup. csit. fsu. edu/) weighting transversions differentially according to the transitions/transversion ratio of the selected substitution model. Confidence in the topologies was inferred after 1,000 bootstrap replicates. Trees were edited using the FigTree v1. 4. 1 program (http: //tree. bio. ed. ac. uk/software/figtree/). Viral genetic geographic structure across Europe was examined for each lineage data set, EBLV-1a and EBLV-1b, through parsimony-based haplotype networks employing the Median Joining (MJ) algorithm implemented in Network (v5. 0, Fluxus Technology (http: //www. fluxus-engineering. com/sharenet. htm), without star-contraction pre-processing or post-processing clean-up options. To reconstruct phylodynamic patterns of EBLV-1 we analysed the N-400 sequence dataset in a Bayesian framework implemented in the BEAST software (Bayesian Evolutionary Analysis Sampling Trees (http: //beast. bio. ed. ac. uk/) [11]. For model parameters we follow Hughes 2008’s analyses that use similar sequences of the same marker and virus. Accordingly, evolution rates were assumed to fit an uncorrelated lognormal molecular clock [12] and two MCMC chains were run for 5 x 107 generations each with trees and parameters sampled every 1000 steps. We used the SRD06 option for codon partition and substitution model according to the recommendation of Hughes 2008. This option includes an HKY substitution model and four gamma rates with two codon partitions for the alignment: first and second codons were analysed together and separately from the third codon. Analyses started with a random starting tree with a constant population size prior, according to Hughes 2008. Then, chains were run to an effective sample size (ESS) of parameters higher than 200 (following BEAST’s recommendations) and chains convergence was assessed from standard deviation and likelihood values using Tracer (http: //tree. bio. ed. ac. uk/software/tracer/) with the first 10% of the trees discarded as burning. Bayesian credible intervals or 95% Highest Posterior Density (95% HDP) were inferred as uncertainty evaluation. Finally, the consensus phylogenetic tree was built with TreeAnnotator (BEAST software package) and edited in FigTree (http: //tree. bio. ed. ac. uk/software/figtree/).
EBLV-1 is mostly found associated with the bat E. serotinus north of the high mountain ranges of Southern Europe, such as the Alps or the Pyrenees, which seem to hinder virus expansion to the south. However, a group of sequences from Southern Spain were found to cluster in a monophyletic group associated with a different bat, the sibling species E. isabellinus [7]. In this study, we report for the first time nine EBLV-1 strains found in E. serotinus south of the Pyrenees and describe their evolutionary relationships (Fig 1A and 1B). Two of them grouped within the recently described cluster of EBLV-1a sequences from Southern France [6], extending this group now to Northern Spain. The EBLV-1a subtype is otherwise typically distributed through Northern Europe, along an east-west axis from The Netherlands to Ukraine [5]. The shallow genetic differentiation (Figs 1B and 2A) found between the strains on both slopes of the Pyrenees of this Southern group of EBLV-1a suggests a recent geographical expansion of this subtype across southern France, with very recent arrival to the Iberian Peninsula. On the other hand, one of the new EBLV-1a strains was found only 24 km away from the nearest Iberian EBLV-1b strain (Fig 1A), with no significant geographical barriers between them. This supports a hypothesis of current southwards expansion of EBLV-1a, as was proposed for Western Europe by Vázquez-Morón et al. [7]. The clear star-like structure observed for EBLV-1a in the haplotype network provides additional support for this hypothesis (Fig 2A). The remaining seven new EBLV-1 sequences detected in E. serotinus cluster together with the Iberian clade that had been exclusively found in E. isabellinus in the Southern half of the Iberian Peninsula [7] (Fig 1B). This Iberian clade was considered to be differentiated from both EBLV-1a and EBLV-1b [7]. However, our new phylogenetic analyses show that this Iberian lineage shared by the two species of Eptesicus is actually part of the EBLV-1b subtype. This fact points again to a more predominant role of geographical factors than the host species in determining EBLV-1’s phylogenetic structure in Iberia. Both Eptesicus species are phylogenetically close and show some overlap in their geographical distribution in Iberia [13]. Interestingly, phylogenetic relatedness and geographic contact, were considered the two main conditions for interspecific transmission of rabies among bats in America [14]. The haplotype network (Fig 2B) shows a much more complex structure and higher haplotype diversity for EBLV-1b than for EBLV-1a, suggesting a much longer evolutionary history. The analyses also suggest that Iberian EBLV-1b has evolved isolated from the rest of European EBLV-1b, from a still unknown common ancestor, although more geographic coverage is still necessary to fully reconstruct this event. Our coalescence based analysis (S3 Fig) suggests that the Most Recent Common Ancestor (tMRCA) for the entire EBLV-1 lineage currently circulating in Eptesicus bats dates to 175 years ago ([47; 260] HDP). This value is remarkably similar (just five years older) to the date previously proposed [12], but with narrower 95% HDP intervals. The tMRCA estimated for the whole EBLV-1a lineage was approximately 70 years ([59; 158] HDP), while the Iberian EBLV-1a strains could have emerged less than 15 years ago, ([4; 13] HDP) giving additional support to the hypothesis of a recent southward expansion from France across the Pyrenees. On the other hand, the tMRCA for the subtype EBLV-1b is estimated be around 110 years ago, ([53; 187] HDP). This result suggests a longer evolutionary history than EBLV-1a in agreement with the Network analysis. The Iberian EBLV-1b strains would have spawned approximately 55 years ago, ([31; 82] HDP). Nevertheless, we suggest caution on this dating since some uncertainty for the marginal posterior distribution of all the tMRCA was noticed, which will, most probably, be solved when additional cases of Iberian EBLV-1 infection are available. In addition to the nucleoprotein gene, the two hypervariable regions studied enlighten the internal structure within the Iberian EBLV-1b cluster. The strains associated with E. serotinus seem particularly related to those associated with E. isabellinus from the South West (Fig 3). In fact, the presence of a strain (69R00_SE) from Seville (South West) in the new group of viruses associated with E. serotinus (North East) points to an inter-specific transmission of EBLV-1 (Fig 1A and Fig 3) and suggests that this particular Iberian lineage has extended northwards from E. isabellinus to E. serotinus. In fact, the Network shows the Northern Iberian EBLV-1b strains associated with E. serotinus branching off from a common Southern haplotype (in an expansion star-like shape), providing additional support for this hypothesis (Fig 2B). On the other hand, the Iberian South West seems to concentrate the highest variability within the Iberian EBLV-1b lineage (Fig 1A), including a sub-lineage represented by two sequences (155R99, R75) which occupied the most basal position and have never been detected after 1999 (Fig 3). An east-west discrimination of two groups of viruses in the South is in agreement with the east-west population subdivision described for the host bat E. isabellinus [9]. Interestingly, this study suggests a close genetic relatedness between South Western Iberian and North-African populations for E. isabellinus [9]. This genetic pattern strongly supports the possibility of the presence of EBLV-1 in North Africa from where it has not been reported yet. In conclusion, the increasing involvement of wild life rescue centers in bat rabies surveillance has allowed us to detect the first cases in Iberian E. serotinus and we hope it will allow us to increase the overall number of Iberian strains in the upcoming years. Unfortunately, active screening of healthy bats captured in colonies by testing oral fluids and blood does not usually provide enough genomic material to perform this kind of study [15]. The use of highly variable genomic regions (Fig 3, S3A and S3B Fig) has clearly improved the resolution of the virus evolutionary phylogenetic reconstructions [16], and has provided a better understanding of the phylogenetic structure of the Iberian EBLV-1 populations, pointing to evolutionary patterns at a continental level that deserve further research.
Rabies is caused by at least fourteen different viruses of the genus Lyssavirus. Although the classical rabies virus transmitted by the dog accounts for most human cases, most lyssaviruses are hosted by bats, which are able to transmit the disease to humans. The European bat lyssaviruses 1 (EBLV-1) and 2 (EBLV-2) have caused human rabies in Europe, while more than 90% of the bat rabies cases have been reported from serotine bats (Eptesicus serotinus) infected by EBLV-1. These cases clearly accumulate in certain areas of Europe, but the factors driving this distribution are unknown. The evolutionary relationships among these viral strains provide valuable information, however, they are only partially known. The south of the Iberian Peninsula is the only location within Europe with an additional reservoir for EBLV-1, the isabelline serotine bat (Eptesicus isabellinus) which is present also in North Africa. In this study we have reconstructed the EBLV-1 phylogeny and phylodynamics in the Iberian Peninsula in the context of the European continent. Our results suggest that some lineages have longer evolutionary history in their distribution areas, than others which seem to be in the process of a geographical expansion.
taxonomy
organismal evolution
medicine and health sciences
pathology and laboratory medicine
pathogens
geographical locations
microbiology
vertebrates
animals
mammals
genetic mapping
viruses
phylogenetics
data management
rna viruses
phylogenetic analysis
microbial evolution
europe
rabies virus
computer and information sciences
medical microbiology
microbial pathogens
evolutionary systematics
viral evolution
people and places
lyssavirus
haplotypes
eukaryota
virology
viral pathogens
bats
genetics
heredity
biology and life sciences
evolutionary biology
amniotes
organisms
First cases of European bat lyssavirus type 1 in Iberian serotine bats: Implications for the molecular epidemiology of bat rabies in Europe