This study aimed to compare the prevalence of Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBc) lineages between direct genotyping (on sputum) and indirect genotyping (on culture), to characterize potential culture bias against difficult growers. Smear-positive sputa from consecutive new tuberculosis patients diagnosed in Cotonou, (Benin) were included, before patients had started treatment. An aliquot of decontaminated sputum was used for direct spoligotyping, and another aliquot was cultured on Löwenstein Jensen (LJ) medium (90 days), for indirect spoligotyping. After DNA extraction, spoligotyping was done according to the standard method for all specimens, and patterns obtained from sputa were compared versus those from the derived culture isolates. From 199 patient’s sputa, 146 (73. 4%) yielded a positive culture. In total, direct spoligotyping yielded a pattern in 98. 5% (196/199) of the specimens, versus 73. 4% (146/199) for indirect spoligotyping on cultures. There was good agreement between sputum- and isolate derived patterns: 94. 4% (135/143) at spoligotype level and 96. 5% (138/143) at (sub) lineage level. Two of the 8 pairs with discrepant pattern were suggestive of mixed infection in sputum. Ancestral lineages (Lineage 1, and M. africanum Lineages 5 and 6) were less likely to grow in culture (OR = 0. 30,95%CI (0. 14 to 0. 64), p = 0. 0016); especially Lineage 5 (OR = 0. 37 95%CI (0. 17 to 0. 79), p = 0. 010). Among modern lineages, Lineage 4 was over-represented in positive-culture specimens (OR = 3. 01,95%CI (1. 4 to 6. 51), p = 0. 005). Ancestral lineages, especially M. africanum West African 1 (Lineage 5), are less likely to grow in culture relative to modern lineages, especially M. tuberculosis Euro-American (Lineage 4). Direct spoligotyping on smear positive sputum is effective and efficient compared to indirect spoligotyping of cultures. It allows for a more accurate unbiased determination of the population structure of the M. tuberculosis complex. ClinicalTrials. gov NCT02744469
Tuberculosis (TB), caused by bacteria of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBc), remains a public health problem. Globally, over 8 million new patients with TB disease arise each year, including 2 million deaths. The vast majority (95%) of global TB is detected in limited-resource countries [1], including West-Africa. Each year in Benin, over 4000 cases of TB are detected, and the incidence of smear-positive pulmonary TB is 39 per 100000 inhabitants. Genotypic characterization is important in order to understand the population structure of the MTBc for better insights into endemic- and epidemic strains and to identify instances of nosocomial transmission or laboratory contamination. M. tuberculosis sensu stricto and M. africanum sub-species within the MTBc have been subdivided into 7 main lineages of human importance [2,3]. These 7 MTBc lineages are classified as ancestral (or ‘ancient’) (Lineages 1,5, 6) [4,5], intermediate (Lineage 7) [3,4] and modern lineages (Lineages 2,3, 4) [4]. Lineage 5 (M. africanum West African 1) and Lineage 6 (M. africanum West African 2) are only found in West- and Central Africa, where they cause up to 40% of all TB [6,7]. Recent reports suggested a decrease in prevalence of M. africanum in some West-African countries [8–10]. Whether methodological issues explain the apparent disappearance of M. africanum has not been excluded to date. For the determination of the population structure of the MTBc, genotyping is usually applied on culture isolates [11]. M. africanum grows significantly slower than the other members of the MTBc (M. tuberculosis sensu stricto) [12] and cultures should be incubated for 90 days rather than the usual 56 days, before reporting a negative result [13]. However, even this extended incubation time may not permit recovery of M. africanum isolates at the same rate as M. tuberculosis, and thus bias the population structure derived from cultured isolates, especially in settings where M. africanum is endemic. Differences in expression of genes involved in metabolism pathways of the various MTBc lineages may also affect their growth in culture, as recently reported for M. africanum Lineage 6 which has an under-expression for the gene (Dos R) involved in adaptation to lower oxygen tension relative to Lineage 4 [14]. For isolation, of some MTBc species, including M. africanum, the need for pyruvate to support growth in culture [15] has been known for a long time [16]. Few studies evaluated genotyping, such as spoligotyping, directly on clinical specimens such as sputa [17,18], sputum smears [19], paraffin wax-embedded tissues [20] or mummified remains of human [20]. Only one study from Brazil, where M. africanum is not endemic, compared spoligotyping on sputum to spoligotyping from the respective isolates [21]. Moreover, to the best of our knowledge, no study has investigated whether the proportional prevalence of MTBc lineages differs among specimens with a positive culture versus culture-negative specimens. In this study, we determined the performance of spoligotyping on sputum (‘direct spoligotying’) relative to its yield on culture (‘indirect spoligotyping’) for genotypic characterization of MTBc, and evaluated for a potential culture bias against difficult-growers, even when incubation was prolonged to enhance detection of M. africanum.
This study is part of the BeniDiT study that has been approved by the national ethics committee of Benin, the Institutional Review Board of the Institute of Tropical Medicine of Antwerp, Belgium and the ethics committee of the University of Antwerp. It is registered on ClinicalTrials. gov under the registration number NCT02744469. All sputa were anonymized before laboratory analyses. Smear-positive sputa from consecutive new TB patients diagnosed in the Centre National Hospitalier Universitaire de Pneumo-Phtisiologie in Cotonou, (Benin) were prospectively included (Fig 1), before patients initiated TB treatment. Laboratory analyses were conducted in the National Reference Laboratory for Mycobacteria (Laboratoire de Référence des Mycobactéries) in Cotonou, Benin. Spoligotype patterns were recorded in an Excel file using a binary code (1 for presence of a given spacer and 0 for the absence of a given spacer). Entered profiles were verified and validated by an independent person. The persons who typed and validated the data were blinded to the spoligotype pattern of the corresponding sputum or isolate. The Excel file was loaded into the TBlineage database http: //tbinsight. cs. rpi. edu/run_tb_lineage. html [26] for lineage assignment. Sub-lineages (spoligotype families) were obtained by loading the Excel file with the spoligotype patterns in the SPOTCLUST database http: //tbinsight. cs. rpi. edu/run_spotclust. html [27]. Data was analyzed using the statistical software Stata/IC 12. 0 (StataCorp). The two-group proportion test or the Fisher Exact test was used to analyze independent data. Mc Nemar Chi2 test was used to compare paired proportions. Two-sided p-values were calculated and for differences in proportion, odds ratios were calculated along with 95% confidence interval. Differences were considered statistically significant when p<0. 05.
From the 199 recruited TB patients and their sputum samples, 146 (73. 4%) yielded a positive culture, whereas 36 (18. 1%) remained negative and 17 (8. 5%) were contaminated. Spoligotype patterns were obtained for all the 146 culture isolates, and for 196 of the 199 sputa, yielding an overall success for direct spoligotyping of 98. 5%. All of the extraction controls and amplification/hybridization controls yielded expected results, and repeat spoligotyping for discordant results between sputum and culture confirmed the original patterns. Stratified by culture result, direct spoligotyping reached a success of 100% (53/53) for culture-negative or contaminated sputa, and 98% (143/146) for culture-positive sputa. Microscopy was negative in 6 sediments after decontamination, while all the others had positive microscopy. Of the 6 microscopy negative sediments, 3 failed direct spoligotyping and 2 others had a negative culture. Spoligotype patterns were available for 98. 5% of sputa versus 73. 4% of cultures (Table 1). Comparison between respective direct and indirect spoligotypes showed 94. 4% (135/143) agreement. In total three types of discrepancies were observed (Fig 2): mixed infection with one pattern found in sputum and the other found in the culture isolate (n = 3, discrepancy 5–7), mixed infection with overlapping spoligotype patterns in sputum (n = 2, discrepancies 1 and 4), and false negative (missing) spacers in sputum (n = 3, discrepancies 2,3 and 8). Five (5) of these patterns led to inter-lineage discrepancies, and three (3) to intra-lineage discrepancies. For inter-lineage discrepancies, sub (lineages) observed in isolates are shaded grey. The five inter-lineage discrepant pairs (discrepancy 4–8) showed patterns suggestive of a simultaneous presence of ancestral and modern lineages, while these yielded only the ancestral lineage in sputum and only the modern lineage in culture. Three (discrepancy 5–7) of these five inter-lineage pairs showed this (ancestral M. africanum in sputum and modern Lineage 4 in culture), without any other possible explanation, while the other two (discrepancy 4 and 8) can also be interpreted as follows. Inter-lineage pair 8 and intra-lineage pairs 2 and 3 showed patterns suggestive of false negative spacers in sputum (spacer present in isolate but absent in sputum). Intra-lineage pair 1 and inter-lineage pair 4 showed patterns suggestive of overlapping spoligotype signatures in sputum (discrepancy 1 and 4) and/or in isolate (discrepancy 1). Discrepancy 4 suggested an overlapping of Lineages 2 and 4 signatures in sputum, with only the Lineage 2 grown in culture. Discrepancy 1 was suggestive of overlapping spoligotype signatures in sputum and in culture isolate that could be a mixture of Lineages 2 and 4. The distribution of lineages in culture-positive sputa versus directly in sputum with unsuccessful culture differed, with Lineage 5 (M. africanum West African 1) being significantly less prevalent among culture-positive sputa (OR = 0. 48 95%CI (0. 24 to 0. 94) p = 0. 033, Table 2). This association became more significant when contaminated cultures were excluded from the analysis (OR = 0. 37,95%CI (0. 17 to 0. 8), 21% vs 41. 7%, p = 0. 011, Table 2). Ancestral lineages (Lineages 1,5 and 6) were significantly less present among culture-positive sputa (OR = 0. 33,95%CI (0. 16 to 0. 7), 37. 1% vs 63. 9%, p = 0. 004, Table 2). Lineage 4 (M. tuberculosis Euro-American), a modern lineage, was most overrepresented in culture-positive sputa (OR = 2. 81,95%CI (1. 30 to 6. 03) 55. 2% vs 30. 5%, p = 0. 008, Table 2). Excluding discrepant spoligotypes between direct and indirect spoligotype analysis, the association gained further statistical significance. The odds of detecting ancestral lineages in positive-cultures was 0. 30 fold (95% CI (0. 14 to 0. 64); p = 0. 0016) less in positive-cultures relative to negative cultures, especially Lineage 5 (OR = 0. 37 95%CI (0. 17 to 0. 79); p = 0. 010) (S1 Table). Modern lineages were inversely more represented in positive-culture specimens (OR = 3. 31,95%CI (1. 57 to 6. 99), p = 0. 0016), especially Lineage 4 (OR = 3. 01,95%CI (1. 4 to 6. 51), p = 0. 005) (S1 Table). The prevalence of L1, L5, L6 tended to be higher among culture-negative specimens (respectively 8. 3%, 41. 7%, 13. 9%; S1 Table) than in culture-positive specimens (7. 4%, 20. 7%, 6. 7%; S1 Table). In contrast the prevalence of L2, L3, L4 tended to be lower among culture-negative specimens (5. 6%, 0%, 30. 5%) than in culture-positive specimens (6. 7%, 1. 5%, 57. 0%; S1 Table). This justified the analysis in subgroup of ancestral and modern lineages. The distribution of sub-lineages (families) within Lineage 4 showed that LAM 10, LAM 9, LAM 1, T1, T2, Haarlem 1, Haarlem 2, Haarlem 3, X3 families were present in new TB patients in Cotonou. This distribution of Lineage 4 families did not differ significantly in culture-positive versus culture-negative sputa (S2 Table). Almost all positive cultures were positive within 8 weeks of incubation, while prolonged incubation only yielded one additional positive culture. This was a Lineage 5/ M. africanum West African 1 strain. Among positive cultures, over half (5/9: 55. 5%) of the Lineage 6/ M. africanum West African 2 cultures became positive between 6 to 8 weeks of incubation, whereas most of positive cultures from other lineages specimens were positive within 6 weeks: 10/11 (90. 9%) for Lineage 1,10/10 (100%) for Lineage 2,2/2 (100%) for Lineage 3,83/85 (97. 6%) for Lineage 4 and 28/29 (95. 6%) for Lineage 5. Despite the prolonged incubation period, over a third of specimens from each M. africanum lineage remained culture negative (34. 1% for Lineage 5 and 35. 7% for Lineage 6), while for other lineages, none (Lineage 3) or fewer specimens (21. 4% for Lineage 1,16. 7% for Lineage 2,11. 5% for Lineage 4) remained negative (Table 3). The sediment smear of the culture negative specimens from Lineage 1 and 2 had low AFB-grading or were negative whereas nearly all (14/15) the culture negative specimens from Lineage 5 had high smear grading (S3 Table).
Our results show that indirect spoligotyping provided spoligotype profiles for all 146 culture-positive specimens (73. 4%), while direct spoligotyping provided spoligotyping profiles for 50 more sputa (+ 25. 1% of all 199 specimens, 95% CI (18. 1% to 32. 1%) ) that would not otherwise be genotyped in the absence of an isolate. Direct spoligotyping on sputum after semi-automated DNA extraction using Maxwell DNA tissue purification kit, has a high sensitivity (98. 5% (196/199) ) to detect MTBc genotypes. The 98. 5% (196/199) overall availability of spoligotype profiles in our study is higher than the 90. 9% (159/175) found on smear-positive sputa by Goyal et al. in Ghana (p = 0. 001) [18] and the 49. 1% (28/57) found by Heyderman et al. in Zimbabwe [17]. This could be explained by the variability of methods used for DNA extraction from sputa and/or the variability in PCR reagents mix. The overall availability of spoligotype profiles on sputa in our study (98. 5%) is also higher than the 77. 7% (41/53) found by Suresh et al. and 90. 5% (19/21) by Zanden et al. on smears [19,28], which likely have less mycobacterial DNA than a 200 μL sputum sample. The fact that- within mixed infections- ancestral lineages are found with direct spoligotyping on sputum, suggests that the load of ancestral lineage bacilli in vivo exceeds the load of the modern lineage bacilli, with subsequent out-competition in culture by the latter. Sarkar et al. also found that Lineage 4 grows more rapidly (in liquid medium) than other lineages including Lineage 1, an ancestral lineage [29]. Moreover, Gehre et al. found that Lineage 6, another ancestral lineage, grows more slowly than MTBc lineages other than M. africanum in liquid medium [12]. Sputum provided the most representative population distribution of lineages of the MTBc in new TB patients in Cotonou, with more TB due to ancestral lineages, including M. africanum. This distribution did not alter when the three isolates which sputum failed direct spoligotyping were added (two from Lineage 4 and one from Lineage 5; Table 2). The ‘most true’ distribution is the one combining profiles obtained directly from sputum, complemented by profiles on isolates from failed direct spoligotyping, and includes: 8. 0% (16/199) for Lineage 1,5. 6% (11/199) for Lineage 2,1% (2/199) for Lineage 3,51. 8% (103/199) for Lineage 4,25. 1% (50/199) for Lineage 5,8. 5% (17/199) for Lineage 6, or 41. 7% for ancestral lineages, and 33. 7% for M. africanum (Table 2). This distribution would have been different if smear-negative specimens were also genotyped, as it had been previously reported that M. africanum is more likely to be found in lower grade smear-positive specimens [30], and Lineage 6 is associated with HIV infection [31], which is in turn associated with smear-negativity [32–34]. The comparison of the distribution of MTBc lineages in a similar population, also consisting of consecutive smear-positive new pulmonary TB patients aged at least 15 years old of Cotonou in year 2005–2006 on cultured isolates [9,35], to the one obtained in our study indirectly on cultured isolates from similar patients in Cotonou 10 years later, showed that the previous prevalence of Lineage 1 (7. 7%), Lineage 2 (10. 3%), Lineage 3 (0%), Lineage 6 (6. 2%) are similar to our findings in this study (respectively: 7. 5%, 6. 8%, 1. 4% and 6. 2%). Yet the prevalence of Lineage 4 (42. 3% in year 2005–2006) has increased to 58. 2% (difference: +15. 9%), and Lineage 5 prevalence (30. 9% in year 2005–2006) has decreased to 19. 9% (difference: -11. 0%). While we demonstrate that the present L5 prevalence of 19. 9% on indirect genotyping is an underestimate, even the present ‘true’ L5 prevalence of 25. 1% on direct genotyping would constitute a decline from the L5 prevalence of 30. 9% on indirect genotyping in 2005–2006. Other authors also reported a decrease of M. africanum [8,9]. Our results show that rates of culture isolation from smear-positive pulmonary TB patients are lower for Lineages 5 and 6 of the MTBc, despite prolonged incubation of cultures for 90 days [13]. Extending the incubation time beyond 6 weeks enhanced isolation of Lineage 6 (between 6–8 weeks) yet did not further augment the isolation rate. Ancestral lineages, especially Lineage5/M. africanum West African 1 are ‘difficult-growers’ in culture relative to modern lineages, such as Lineage 4. The decreased odds of ancestral lineages to grow in culture could partly be due to culture procedures (culture medium or decontamination method) that were originally developed for modern lineages prevalent in Europe. Ofori-Anyinam et al. reported that Lineage 6 as compared to Lineage 4, is more adapted to microaerobic growth [14] which may be the reason for its impaired growth on solid media such as LJ used in this study. Furthermore Gehre et al. found that Lineage 6 has mutations in genes that lead to its attenuated growth in vitro[12]. Such genetic analyses need to be conducted on Lineage 5 in order to understand the reasons for its difficult growth in vitro. Further studies should also be conducted on other lineages to find out the genetic basis of their in vitro growth pattern. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first demonstration that ancestral lineages are underrepresented in positive cultures. Direct spoligotyping is thus more appropriate for unbiased determination of MTBc population structure in settings where ancestral lineages, including M. africanum, are common. The implications of our findings also affect MTBc population structures generated with different typing methods, including whole genome sequencing. Such studies tend to be culture-based, given the ongoing limitations of sequencing entire MTBc genomes directly from clinical material. While direct genome sequencing is technically feasible given sufficient coverage, in practice the associated costs are prohibitive. Studies to date have shown limited coverage, precluding SNP cut-offs for molecular epidemiological studies [36]. Optimized methods to sequence genomes directly from clinical material are thus urgently needed. One strength of this study is the prolonged incubation time, to maximize the yield of M. africanum in culture. Other strengths include the paired design for the comparison of direct spoligotyping versus indirect spoligotyping and the inclusion of multiple controls and blinding of operators, and the fact that the study was conducted in a setting where M. africanum is prevalent. A limitation is that only LJ medium was used, and we do not know whether other medium, such as liquid medium (known to enable the growth of more non-tuberculous mycobacteria) may also favor the growth of ancestral MTBc lineages. This study was conducted only on fresh unshipped acid-fast bacilli positive sputa from new TB patients. Culture positivity may be worse if sputa had to be shipped from peripheral laboratories to a reference or central laboratory where spoligotyping can be done. Another limitation is that the number of specimens with Lineages 1,2, 3,6 among culture negative specimens under-powered the estimation of any difference in the prevalence of these individual lineage among culture-negative versus culture-positive specimens. So, although no evidence of such difference in prevalence among culture-negative versus –positive specimens was found in Lineages 1,2, 3,6 in the present study, such difference could be tested for in settings with higher prevalence of these lineages. In conclusion, ancestral lineages especially M. africanum West African 1 (Lineage 5), are less likely to grow in culture, unlike modern lineages especially M. tuberculosis Euro-American (Lineage 4). Direct spoligotyping on sputum is effective, and saves effort and time compared to indirect spoligotyping of cultures. It has an important gain in sensitivity, especially for ancestral lineages that may not yield a positive culture, allowing a more precise unbiased determination of the population structure of the MTBc. It can also be used for specimens from patients under TB treatment and other specimens in which culture may be negative or contaminated. While differences in culture isolation technique and reliance on indirect spoligotyping may partially account for the reduction in the prevalence of M. africanum observed in several West African countries [8,9], comparison of our findings with the genotyping study from Cotonou 10 years ago suggests that the decline in M. africanum is not explained by the lower sensitivity of culture isolation. The potential decline of M. africanum lineages will be addressed in more depth in a larger ongoing study on the population structure of the M. tuberculosis complex in Benin, in which direct genotyping will be applied, given the findings presented in this manuscript. Further studies must be conducted to investigate whether culture procedures (medium, decontamination) can be optimized for growth of ancestral lineages. Additional studies should address the frequency and role, if any, of a mixed infection between an ancestral- and modern lineage in the faster spread of modern lineages [4] and disappearance of ancestral lineages [8,9].
The vast majority (95%) of tuberculosis (TB) patients worldwide live in low-income countries, including in West-Africa. Typing the bacteria responsible for TB (tuberculosis; Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex) is important for targeted TB control. Typing is usually performed on isolates obtained after the culture isolation of TB bacteria in the sputa from patients. However, cultures can be false negative, and some ‘ancestral’ strains, only found in West-Africa (Mycobacterium africanum), require more time (90 days versus the usual 56 days) to grow in culture. To characterize potential culture bias against such “difficult growers”, we compared the performance of direct typing (on sputum) relative to its yield on culture isolates. We found that ancestral types of TB bacteria were significantly less likely to grow in culture despite the 90-day incubation. This suggests that typing results of cultured isolates are not representative of the diversity in the population of TB bacteria causing disease in patients. Typing sputum directly is effective and can be used for a more precise, unbiased determination of the proportion of different TB bacteria in a population.
africans
root structure
plant anatomy
medicine and health sciences
body fluids
tropical diseases
ethnicities
bacterial diseases
plant science
geology
molecular biology techniques
genotyping
bacteria
extraction techniques
petrology
research and analysis methods
sputum
infectious diseases
mucus
tuberculosis
actinobacteria
molecular biology
people and places
dna extraction
anatomy
plant roots
mycobacterium tuberculosis
physiology
earth sciences
sediment
biology and life sciences
population groupings
sedimentary geology
organisms
Genotypic characterization directly applied to sputum improves the detection of Mycobacterium africanum West African 1, under-represented in positive cultures