Inactivation of the Rb tumor suppressor can lead to increased cell proliferation or cell death depending on specific cellular context. Therefore, identification of the interacting pathways that modulate the effect of Rb loss will provide novel insights into the roles of Rb in cancer development and promote new therapeutic strategies. Here, we identify a novel synthetic lethal interaction between Rb inactivation and deregulated Wg/Wnt signaling through unbiased genetic screens. We show that a weak allele of axin, which deregulates Wg signaling and increases cell proliferation without obvious effects on cell fate specification, significantly alters metabolic gene expression, causes hypersensitivity to metabolic stress induced by fasting, and induces synergistic apoptosis with mutation of fly Rb ortholog, rbf. Furthermore, hyperactivation of Wg signaling by other components of the Wg pathway also induces synergistic apoptosis with rbf. We show that hyperactivated Wg signaling significantly increases TORC1 activity and induces excessive energy stress with rbf mutation. Inhibition of TORC1 activity significantly suppressed synergistic cell death induced by hyperactivated Wg signaling and rbf inactivation, which is correlated with decreased energy stress and decreased induction of apoptotic regulator expression. Finally the synthetic lethality between Rb and deregulated Wnt signaling is conserved in mammalian cells and that inactivation of Rb and APC induces synergistic cell death through a similar mechanism. These results suggest that elevated TORC1 activity and metabolic stress underpin the evolutionarily conserved synthetic lethal interaction between hyperactivated Wnt signaling and inactivated Rb tumor suppressor.
The Retinoblastoma protein Rb is a tumor suppressor inactivated in a broad spectrum of cancers [1], [2]. Rb functions mainly through binding to the E2F family of transcription factors and regulating the expression of diverse cellular targets involved in cell cycle regulation, DNA replication and repair, apoptosis, metabolism, as well as differentiation. Consistent with this, loss of Rb can lead to increased cell proliferation or increased cell death, depending on specific cellular contexts. Therefore identification and characterization of the genes or signaling pathways that can modulate the consequences of Rb loss in cell proliferation or cell death will significantly advance our understanding of the role of Rb in cancer development, and may potentially help the development of novel approaches for therapeutic interventions [3]. The function of Rb and E2F proteins are highly conserved and much simpler in Drosophila. These features, in conjunction with a plethora of sophisticated genetic tools, make Drosophila an ideal model to identify genes that modulates the consequences of Rb loss [4], [5]. Forward genetic screens have identified several genes that show synergistic effects on apoptosis or differentiation with rbf (fly Rb) mutation [6], [7], [8], [9], [10]. Of particular interest is the synthetic lethal interactions between rbf and TSC genes [10], [11], which is conserved in mammalian systems [10], [12]. TSC2 functions in a complex with TSC1 to inhibit TORC1 activity by promoting Rheb in the inactive GDP-bound form [13], [14]. Mutations of TSC induce hyperactive TORC1 activity, which leads to excessive cellular stress, including ROS and energetic stress, and causes synergistic cell death in conjunction with Rb inactivation [9], [10], [12]. Consistent with this, several recent studies demonstrate that Rb also plays important roles in cell metabolism and stress induction. In Drosophila, rbf mutation was shown to cause metabolic reprogramming and rbf mutants are sensitized to conditions that impose metabolic stress such as fasting, which can be rescued by glutamine supply [15]. In C. elegans, transcriptome analysis of wild type and Rb mutant under normal or starving conditions revealed that Rb is essential not only to repress stress-inducible and metabolic genes, but also to activate stress-resistant genes, mitochondrial genes, and potential insulin pathway antagonists [16]. Furthermore, studies using mouse embryonic fibroblasts (MEFs) from triple knock-outs of all three Rb family members show that Rb/E2F directly regulate genes involved in glutamine metabolism [17]. Taken together, these studies suggest that Rb has conserved functions modulating cellular metabolism as well as the sensitivity of cells to additional metabolic stresses induced by specific environmental or genetic conditions. In the current study, we identify a novel synthetic lethal interaction between deregulated Wg signaling and rbf mutation through genetic screens in Drosophila. We show that mutation of axin (axn), a negative regulator of the Wg signaling, significantly alters the expression of metabolic genes and is hypersensitive to metabolic stress induced by fasting, which can be rescued by glutamine supply. We further demonstrate that deregulated Wg signaling increased TORC1 activity, which induced excessive metabolic stress and synergistic cell death with rbf mutation. Finally we show that inactivation of APC and Rb induces synergistic apoptosis in human cancer cells through a similar mechanism. These results provide an alternative explanation for the long standing but confusing observation that colorectal cancers, which have deregulated Wnt signals, generally preserve Rb function and may even have amplification of the Rb loci.
In a genetic screen to identify mutations that can modulate rbf mutant phenotypes, we identified an EMS mutant 127. In Drosophila adult eyes with mosaic clones, mutant clones are in white color and wild type cells in red color (Fig. 1A). Comparing to wild-type control clones, rbf single mutant clones were generally a bit smaller while 127 single mutant clones were similar to or moderately larger than WT clones (Fig. 1B–C). However, rbf and 127 double mutant clones were very small or undetectable in the adult eyes (Fig. 1D), suggesting that rbf and 127 mutations have synergistic effects against clonal growth or survival. We tested whether the decreased amount of rbf and 127 (rbf 127) double mutant clones in adult eyes correlated with increased apoptosis in larval eye discs. Apoptosis in eye discs can be detected by the anti-cleaved caspase3 (C3) antibody. As shown previously [10], [18], [19], rbf mutation caused increased apoptosis just anterior to the morphogenetic furrow (MF) while little apoptosis was detected in wild type cells (GFP positive) at this stage (Fig. 1E). Although 127 mutant clones showed little apoptosis (Fig. 1F), rbf and 127 double clones located anterior to the MF exhibited significantly increased level of apoptosis compared to the single mutant clones (Fig. 1G, the results were quantified in 1N). The 127 mutation was mapped to the Drosophila genomic region between 99D1-99E1 where the axn gene is located. Several evidences demonstrate that 127 mutation is an allele of axn: 1) 127 mutation failed to complement with the previously generated axn alleles; 2) DNA sequencing and mRNA RACE of the axn gene in 127 mutants revealed that Exon 10 of axn is linked to a repetitive heterochromatin sequence instead of Exon 11. Therefore the axn gene in 127 mutants encodes a protein lacking part of the DIX domain at the C-terminus (Supplementary Fig. S1A–D); 3) 127 homozygous mutants die at the pupal stage. Expression of wild-type Axn protein by hs-Gal4/UAS-Axn can partially rescue the pupal lethality, resulting in the development of adult flies without obvious defects; and 4) 127 mutant significantly increased Armadillo (Arm, fly β-catenin) protein levels (Supplementary Fig. S1E). Therefore, we renamed 127 as axn127. Since the phenotypes of axn127 in lethality and in cell fate changes are much weaker than the previously reported axn alleles (see below), we consider axn127 as a weak axn mutant allele. To determine whether the axn mutation mediates the observed synergistic apoptosis phenotype with rbf, we tested the effects of the previously reported strong axn alleles, including axnEY10228 (axnEY), axnE77, and axnS044230 (axnS) [20], [21], [22]. Low level of apoptosis was observed in single mutant clones of these strong axn alleles, and much stronger apoptosis was observed in axn, rbf double mutant clones (Fig. 1H–M, results were quantified in 1O). Consistent with the notion that axn127 is a weak allele, apoptosis in rbf- axnEY, axnE77, or axnS double mutant clones were observed in both anterior as well as posterior of the eye discs, while apoptosis in rbf axn127 mutant cells were restricted to the region anterior to the MF. The different patterns of apoptosis in eye discs are likely due to the different effects of the strong and the weak axn alleles on cell fate determination. Photoreceptor differentiation in eye disc can be detected by staining with the neuronal marker Elav. While the strong axn alleles blocked photoreceptor differentiation (Supplementary Fig. S2D) [21], [23], axn127 did not (Supplementary Fig. S2B). In addition, rbf mutation did not have obvious effects on photoreceptor differentiation either alone or together with the axn alleles (Supplementary Fig. S2 A, C, E). To further compare the effects of the axn alleles on differentiation, we examined the effect of axn mutation on Senseless (Sens) expression, which is expressed in the SOPs along the presumptive wing margin [24]. We found that the strong axnEY mutation caused ectopic expression of Sens in wing discs, while axn127 mutation did not (Supplementary Fig. S2 G, I). Again rbf mutation did not affect Sens expression either alone or together with the axn alleles (Supplementary Fig. S2 F–J). Taken together, these data show that axn127 does not affect photoreceptor differentiation in contrast to the previously identified strong axn alleles, and that rbf mutation has synergistic effects with axn on apoptosis but not on cell fate determinations. To determine whether deregulated Wg signaling mediates the synergistic cell death effect of axn with rbf, we examined the effect of inactivating APC genes, which encode proteins that are in a complex with Axin protein to regulate β-catenin degradation and Wg signaling activity. As shown in Fig. 2, Drosophila APC1-APC2 mutations also induce strong synergistic apoptosis with rbf mutation in eye discs (Fig. 2A–B, quantified in 2K). Therefore deregulation of the Wg signaling by inactivation of APC also induces synergistic apoptosis with rbf mutation. We further tested the effect of deregulating Wg signaling by using dominant negative GSK3 (GSK-DN) or dominant active Armadillo (Arm-DA). Specifically, heat shock FLP-out approach was used to express GSK-DN or Arm-DA with or without rbf-RNAi in the whole eye discs at early L3 larval stage when photoreceptor differentiation has initiated in the posterior eye disc (Fig. 2F–J, samples with GFP shown in Fig. S1F). With this approach, rbf-RNAi induced a stripe of apoptosis just anterior to MF (Fig. 2F), while expression of GSK-DN or Arm-DA alone did not induce obvious apoptosis (Fig. 2G, 2I). However, GSK-DN or Arm-DA together with rbf-RNAi induced apoptosis in a broad region anterior to MF (Fig. 2H, 2J, quantified in 2L), which is similar to the apoptosis induced by axn127 rbf mutations. Therefore, deregulation of Wg signaling using dominant-negative GSK3 or dominant-active Armadillo also induce synergistic cell death in conjunction with rbf inactivation. Furthermore, inhibiting Wg signaling by expressing dominant negative TCF (TCF-DN) significantly inhibited synergistic cell death observed in axnS rbf double mutant clones (Fig. 2C–E, 2M), indicating that synergistic cell death of axn and rbf double mutants depends, at least in part, on the transcriptional activities of Arm/TCF. Synergistic apoptosis was also observed in axn rbf mutant clones in wing discs (Supplementary Fig. S2K–N), although the apoptotic levels were significantly lower than those observed in eye discs (Fig. 1K, 1O). This difference is likely associated with the different effects of axn mutation on differentiation in the wing and eye discs. As discussed above, the strong axn mutations promote wing margin SOP cell fate as shown by ectopic Sens expression (Fig. S2I–J) while suppress photoreceptor differentiation in eye discs as shown by the block of Elav expression (Fig. S2D–E). The EGFR pathway is an important survival signal that is coupled with photoreceptor and SOP differentiation [25], [26], [27], [28]. We found that EGFR signaling activities, reflected by pERK antibody staining and Argos-lacZ reporter expression, are downregulated in and posterior to the MF in eye discs (Fig. 2N–O′) but are upregulated in wing discs in axn mutant clones (Supplementary Fig. S2O–P′). Therefore the differential effects of axn mutation on EGFR signaling in eye and wing tissues likely influenced the level of axn rbf synergistic cell death. In summary, these results show that hyperactivation of the Wg signaling in conjunction with rbf mutation induce synergistic apoptosis in developing imaginal discs, and that the level of apoptosis is also influenced by tissue-specific effects of Wg signaling on cell differentiation and survival signaling. We determined the effect of axn mutation on cell growth by comparing the ratio of individual mutant clone area over the corresponding WT twin spot area. Although axn127 and other strong axn mutations have different effects on cell fate determination, all axn mutant clones show increased clone growth compared to WT controls (Supplementary Fig. S3 A–D). One important growth and proliferation regulator in fly imaginal discs is the TSC-Rheb-TOR pathway. To determine whether TOR signaling is affected by axn mutation, we examined the phosphorylation of S6K, a direct target of TORC1, in eye discs that consist of mostly axn or tsc1 mutant clones. The level of phospho S6K was significantly increased in axn mutant eye discs and similar to that of the tsc1 mutant discs, which was used as a positive control (Fig. 3A). Therefore TORC1 signaling activity is significantly increased by mutation of axn. A previous study showed that deregulated TORC1 increased dE2F1 protein level and promote S phase entry [11]. Indeed, increased expression of PCNA-GFP, an E2F reporter, was observed in both the strong and the weak axn mutant clones (Supplementary Fig. S3 E–F′). In addition, increased dE2F1 protein and increased BrdU incorporation were also observed in axn mutant clones (Supplementary Fig. S3G–H′). Since previous studies showed that high TORC1 activities induced synergistic apoptosis with rbf mutation [10], [11], we tested whether increased TORC1 signaling activity contributes to synergistic cell death in axn rbf double mutant cells. Inhibition of TORC1 activity by mutation of Rheb, a direct upstream activator of TORC1, significantly decreased apoptosis in axnS rbf mutant cells (Fig. 3B–C, quantified in 3F). Similarly, knockdown of Raptor, a component of TORC1 complex, also significantly suppressed apoptosis in axnS rbf double mutant clones (Fig. 3D–E, quantified in G). These results suggest that inactivation of axn leads to increased TORC1 signaling activity, which contributes to synergistic cell death in conjunction with rbf mutation. Deregulated activation of TORC1 by Tsc1 or Tsc2 mutation causes an imbalance between the metabolic demand and supply, and the Tsc1/Tsc2 mutant cells are highly dependent on glutamine metabolism for survival during energy stress [29]. Similarly, rbf mutants were found to exhibit altered glutathione metabolism and are hypersensitive to energy stress induced by fasting [15]. The observed effect of axn mutant on TORC1 signaling prompted us to test whether axn127 mutant larva also show hypersensitivity to fasting. Interestingly, axn127 mutant larva are much more sensitive to fasting than the controls (FRT 82B) and addition of glutamine to PBS largely suppressed the observed sensitivity of the axn127 mutants (Fig. 4A). The increased sensitivity of axn127 mutant to fasting correlated with increased sensitivity to fasting-induced cell death in axn127 mutant clones, which is enhanced by lkb1 mutation (Fig. 4C–G). LKB1 is a kinase that functions to balance cellular energetic needs and supply through AMPK-dependent and-independent pathways. Inactivation of LKB1 has been shown to increase death of cells under energy stress [9]. Taken together, these observations suggest that axn127 mutants have an altered metabolic process and show increased sensitivity to energy stress induced by fasting. Consistent with this notion, genome-wide expression studies using third instar axn127 homozygous mutants showed that the top functions affected in axn127 mutant include genes involved in metabolism, oxidation-reduction, stress response, signal transduction, and developmental processes (Supplemental Tables S1, S2). We generate axn127 rbf120 double mutants to further test whether rbf axn mutations show synergistic effects in hypersensitivity to fasting. rbf120 is a viable weak rbf allele [30]. Consistent with previous reports [15], more rbf120 larvae died than WT control after 28 hour fasting. axn127 larvae were also more sensitive than WT control to fasting. Interestingly, rbf120 axn127 double larvae were even more sensitive to fasting than either axn127 or rbf120 single mutants (Fig. 4B). To test if excessive metabolic and energy stress contribute to the synergistic cell death of axn rbf double mutants similar to that observed for the rbf tsc2 mutant cells, we first determined whether axn single and axn rbf double mutant cells were under energy stress. The ATP/ADP ratio of eye discs with axn, axn rbf, or axn rbf Rheb mutant clones in Minute background were determined. Compared to wild-type cells (FRT 82B), axn mutant cells had slightly lower ATP/ADP ratio (P<0. 01), suggesting that they were under mild energy stress. The ATP/ADP ratio of axn rbf mutant cells was significantly lower than that of the axn mutant cells (P<0. 0001), indicating that the double mutant cells were under severe energy stress (Fig. 4L). Interestingly, blocking TORC1 activation by Rheb mutation increased the ATP/ADP ratio of axn rbf mutant cells to a level similar to that of the axn mutants (Fig. 4L, Fig. S4, p = 0. 4, between axn and axn rbf rheb), suggesting that inhibition of TORC1 activity decreased energy stress of the axn, rbf mutants. We further tested whether lkb1 mutation showed synergistic effects with axn or axn rbf. Although lkb1 single mutant did not show significant levels of apoptosis, lkb1 mutation induced synergistic cell death with axnS mutation and lkb1 axn rbf triple mutant cells had very high levels of cell death (Fig. 4G–J, quantified in 4M). Taken together, these results suggest that axn mutants are under energy stress and require the LKB1 pathway for survival. In addition, it is likely that excessive metabolic stress of axn, rbf mutants contributes to the synergistic cell death. Hid is a critical regulator of apoptosis in Drosophila imaginal discs, and is induced by diverse developmental and stress signals including cell competition and DNA damage [31], [32]. Rbf-E2f1 directly regulates Hid expression [8], [33]. However the upregulated Hid expression and Hid protein level in rbf mutant clones were relatively weak and limited to the stripe just anterior to MF where rbf apoptosis occurs (Fig. 5A, 5D). Mutation of axn127 alone did not affect Hid transcription or Hid protein levels (Fig. 5B, 5E). Interestingly, significantly expanded Hid transcription and Hid protein were observed in axn127 rbf double mutant clones anterior to the MF (Fig. 5C, 5F), which correlated with the observed synergistic apoptosis of these cells (Fig. 1G and N). We further tested the effect of strong axn alleles on Hid. Both Hid expression and Hid protein were significantly upregulated in axnS as well as in axnS rbf double mutant clones, however it is difficult to tell if the Hid expression is synergistically upregulated in the double mutant clones (Fig. 5J, L and data not shown). To determine if Hid induction contributes to the synergistic cell death observed in axn, rbf double mutant clones, axn, rbf mutant clones were induced in the hid mutant background. As shown in Fig. 5G–I, mutation of hid largely blocked apoptosis of the axnS, rbf double mutant cells, demonstrating the critical role of Hid induction to synergistic cell death of axnS, rbf mutant cells. Since blocking TORC1 activity blocks synergistic apoptosis of axn, rbf mutants, we tested the effect of inhibiting TORC1 on Hid induction. We observed that inhibiting TORC1 signaling by a rheb mutation strongly blocked induction of Hid transcription as well as accumulation of Hid protein (Fig. 5J–M′, white arrowheads), suggesting that induction of Hid in axn, rbf mutant clones is TORC1 dependent. Since TORC1 activity significantly alters cellular metabolic and energetic demand and supply and inhibition of TORC1 helps to restore the energy balance in axn, rbf mutant cells (Fig. 4L), these results suggest that Hid induction and apoptosis in axn, rbf mutant cells is regulated, at least in part, by metabolic and energy stress, similar to the synergistic cell death of tsc2, rbf mutant cells. The Rb/E2F and the Wnt signaling pathways are highly conserved between fly and mammalian systems. To determine whether deregulated Wnt signaling and Rb inactivation can also induce synergistic cell death in mammalian cells, we first determined whether activation of Wnt signaling can induce cell death in DU145 cells, a Rb mutant prostate cancer cell line [34]. Knockdown of Wnt signaling negative regulator APC using shRNA constructs strongly reduced the level of APC protein as shown by antibody staining (Fig. 6A) and increased the Wnt signaling reporter activities (Fig. 6B, Supplementary Fig. S5A). To determine whether deregulation of Wnt signaling by APC knockdown induced cell death, we stained cells with an early apoptosis marker Annexin V together with the nucleic acid dye propidium iodide. We observed that depletion of APC significantly increased cell death in DU145 cells (Fig. 6C, Supplementary Fig. S5B). In addition, knockdown of APC in DU145 cells significantly decreased viable cell numbers (Fig. 6D, Supplementary Fig. S5C), and decreased the colony growth in soft agar (Fig. 6E, Supplementary Fig. S5D). To determine whether the observed shAPC-induced death depends on the absence of Rb function, we investigated the effect of expressing WT Rb in APC knockdown DU145 cells. Expression of the transduced WT Rb can be easily detected (Fig. 6F). Expression of WT Rb significantly decreased APC knockdown-induced death (Fig. 6G), and partially restored the total viable cell numbers (Fig. 6H). Taken together, these results demonstrate that knockdown of APC significantly induced the cell death, which is dependent on the absence of Rb function. Colorectal cancer cells commonly have deregulated Wnt signaling and intact Rb/E2F pathway [35]. Consistent with a previous report [36], knockdown of Rb in HCT116 colorectal cancer cells leads to decreased Wnt signaling reporter activity (Fig. 6I–J, Supplementary Fig. S5E–F) and increased cell death (Fig. 6K, Supplementary Fig. S5G). Rb knockdown-induced cell death in colorectal cancer cells was attributed to the reduced Wnt signaling activity [36]. To determine whether Rb knockdown induced cell death in HCT116 cells was due to reduced Wnt signaling or due to synergistic cell death induced by deregulated Wnt signaling and Rb inactivation, we set to distinguish these two possibilities in cells with depleted APC. Knockdown of APC significantly increased the Wnt signaling in HCT116 cells (Fig. 6J, Supplementary Fig. S5F), indicating that APC significantly inhibited Wnt signaling even though these cells contain a β-catenin gain of function mutant allele. Importantly, Wnt signaling reporter activity was higher in APC and Rb double knockdown cells than that in control knockdown cells (Fig. 6J, Supplementary Fig. S5F). However, increased Wnt signaling in the double knockdown cells did not suppress Rb knockdown-induced cell death. In fact, the cell death in Rb and APC double knockdown cells was even higher than those of the single or control knockdown cells (Fig. 6k, Supplementary Fig. S5G). Therefore, although Rb depletion decreases Wnt signaling activity in colorectal cancer cells, its induction of cell death is likely mediated by the synergistic death effect from pRb inactivation and deregulated Wnt signaling. Synergistic cell death from inactivated Rb and deregulated Wg signaling in Drosophila depends on upregulated TORC1 activity (Fig. 3). To determine whether TORC1 activity also contributes to the synergistic cell death in mammalian cells, we determined the effect of inhibiting mTORC1 activity using rapamycin. Rapamycin potently blocked APC knockdown induced cell death in Rb mutant DU145 cells as well as Rb knockdown induced cell death in HCT116 cells (Fig. 7A, B). These observations suggest that, similar to Drosophila, TORC1 activity is required for synergistic cell death induced by Rb inactivation in conjunction with deregulated Wnt signaling in mammalian cells. Our previous studies have shown that inactivation of Rb and TSC2, a negative regulator of TORC1, induced synergistic cell death in cancer cells through induction of excessive cellular stress, including oxidative stress [10]. We used DHE, a dye that detects superoxide, to determine whether oxidative stress is also associated with deregulated Wnt signaling and Rb inactivation induced cell death. As shown in Fig. 7, highly elevated levels of DHE fluorescence were observed in APC-knockdown DU145 cells as well as in Rb-knockdown HCT116 cells grown in soft agar (Fig. 7C–D). Furthermore, Rapamycin, which inhibits TORC1 activity, suppressed the ROS level in these knockdown cells (Fig. 7E–F). Finally, NAC, a ROS scavenger, strongly rescued the knockdown-induced colony growth defects in soft agar (Fig. 7G–H). Taken together, these observations suggest that Rb inactivation and deregulated Wnt signaling induced cell death requires TORC1 activity and involves oxidative stress induction.
This study revealed a novel and evolutionarily conserved synthetic lethal interaction between hyperactivated Wnt signaling and inactivated Rb. We show that a weak allele of axn with deregulated Wg signaling significantly alters the expression of metabolic genes and is hypersensitive to metabolic stress induced by fasting in Drosophila. Furthermore, we observe that hyperactivation of Wg signaling significantly increased TORC1 activity and induced excessive energy stress and synergistic cell death in conjunction with rbf mutation. These observations are consistent with the previous studies, which showed increased TORC1 activity by tsc1 or tsc2 mutation induced synergistic apoptosis with Rb mutation [10], [11]. Our previous studies showed that mutation of lkb1, a key regulator of energy metabolism under energy stress conditions, promoted synergistic cell death with rbf tsc1 mutations [9]. Similarly, we show here that axn rbf cells are also energy deficient and lkb1 mutation strongly enhanced the apoptotic effects of axn or rbf axn mutants. Interestingly, inhibition of TORC1 activity significantly suppressed synergistic cell death induced by deregulated Wg signaling and rbf inactivation, which correlated with decreased energy stress and decreased induction of apoptotic regulator Hid. These results provide further evidence that excessive metabolic and energetic stress contributes to the synergistic cell death. Finally we demonstrate that the phenotypes and mechanisms of axn rbf synergistic apoptosis in Drosophila are conserved in mammalian cells and that inactivation of Rb and APC induces synergistic cell death that requires TORC1 activity and involves oxidative stress induction. Wnt/Wg signaling is one of the key developmental signaling pathways repeatedly used in different developmental settings to regulate cell proliferation, apoptosis, as well as cell differentiation. The consequence of deregulated Wnt signaling depends on particular cellular contexts. In Drosophila larval eye discs, Wg signaling is essential for proliferation of the progenitor cells anterior to the MF. Mutant clones of axn127, which does not affect cell type specification or patterning, showed Hid upregulation and synergistic cell death with rbf only in the anterior proliferating region. In contrast, strong axn alleles, which blocks photoreceptor differentiation, caused synergistic cell death with rbf in both the anterior and the posterior clones. Therefore, it appears that synergistic cell death of deregulated Wnt signaling and rbf inactivation is mainly observed in the proliferating progenitor cells. Consistent with this, we found that the observed synergistic cell death is associated with increased TORC1 activity, metabolic stress, and cell proliferation. In mammalian systems, Wnt signaling plays important roles in maintaining stem cell and progenitor cell homeostasis and deregulated Wnt signaling is observed in many types of cancers, particularly the colorectal cancers. It is quite likely that synergistic cell death interactions between deregulated Wnt signaling and inactivated Rb potentially play important roles in maintaining stem cell homeostasis as well as during cancer development. While Wnt signaling is required to maintain intestine stem cells, hyperactivation of Wnt signaling results in increased cell proliferation as well as increased apoptosis [37], [38]. Similarly inactivation of APC in hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) increases cell proliferation as well as apoptosis, leading to HSC exhaustion and bone marrow failure [39]. Since pRb is inactivated during G1/S transition, pRb is partially inactivated as these stem cells or progenitor cells proliferate. An interesting possibility is that different levels of Wnt signaling activation or pRb inactivation will cause graded levels of metabolic alterations. When combined Wnt signaling hyperactivation and pRb inactivation induced metabolic change past a certain threshold, excessive metabolic stress and cell death will be induced. It is interesting to note that although Rb inactivation is found in almost half of cancer cells, colorectal cancers often show Rb copy gains with high level of Rb expression [35]. Since deregulated Wnt activities is the key cancer initiating event that exists in almost all colorectal cancer cells, the high Rb level can potentially prevent cell death induced by hyperactivated Wnt signaling, particularly during early cancer progression. In addition to inducing synergistic cell death with deregulated Wnt signaling, high E2F activities were also found to antagonize Wnt signaling by degrading β-catenin in a GSK3β independent manner [36]. It is possible that the Rb-E2F and Wnt signaling pathway may crosstalk at multiple levels, and Wnt signaling can induce either pro-apoptotic or survival signals depending on particular cellular context. The observed synergistic cell death between hyperactive Wnt signaling and inactivated Rb may also contribute to the cancer cells drug sensitivity. A recent study showed that upregulation of Wnt signaling is required for cell death induction in melanoma cells by PLX4720, a selective inhibitor of activated BRAF (V600E). PLX4720 increased Wnt signaling and induced Bim expression and cell death in A375 melanoma cells, which was blocked by β-catenin (CTNNB1) siRNA [40]. A375 cells have lost the expression of p16INK4a, which is a cyclin dependent kinase (CDK) inhibitor that regulates the phosphorylation of pRb by D-type CDKs [41]. Therefore, pRb is likely at least partially inactivated in these cells. Interestingly, analysis of the Genomics of Drug Sensitivity in Cancer database [42], a publicly available IC50 dataset of 147 anticancer agents on over 1000 tumor cell lines, revealed that PLX4720 was one of the seven drugs that show increased effectiveness toward cancers that have genomic alterations of the Rb gene [43]. Therefore, it will be interesting to investigate whether Wnt induced apoptosis in A375 cells requires Rb inactivation. Deregulated TORC1 activity is often observed in cancers and inhibition of TORC1 activity can potentially be used as a strategy to inhibit cancer growth. However, the clinical trials of the TORC1 inhibitor Rapamycin and its derivatives have only seen very limited success in small subset of cancers [44]. Besides the possibilities that these inhibitors are not potent enough to completely inhibit TORC1 or they activate feedback signaling, our studies raise the possibility that inhibition of TORC1 decreases the stress levels in cancer cells and promotes cancer cell survival. Indeed, decreasing the activities of TORC1 or its downstream target S6K partially rescues the Rb- TSC synergistic cell death [10], [11]. Several studies described how increased Wnt signaling activates TORC1 activity. One possible mechanism is mediated by the inhibition of mTOR by GSK3 through the phosphorylation of TSC2 [45], [46], [47], [48], [49]. In this case, increased Wnt signaling will activate mTOR by inhibiting GSK3. Another mechanism described recently is that GSK3 and mTOR cooperate to regulate S6K phosphorylation [50]. Additionally, canonical Wg signaling has been shown to promote insulin sensitivity by upregulating insulin receptor expression [51]. Therefore, Wnt and TOR signaling pathways intersect at multiple levels.
Fly stocks used in this study include: rbf15aΔ [8], dtsc129 [52], lkb1X5 [53], hid138 [8]. axnEY10228 (BL17649), axnE77 [21], axnS044230 [54], APC1Q8 APC279 [54], Hid-lacz [55], Rheb4L1 (BL39737), UAS-Axn-GFP (BL7224), UAS-Raptor RNAi (BL34814), UAS-Rbf RNAi (BL36744), UAS-ArmS10 (BL 4782), aos-lacz (BL2513), UAS-TCFDN (BL4785), UAS-RasV12 (BL4847), UAS-GSK3DN, PCNA-GFP [56]. Ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) -induced screen to identify mutations that can modulate the phenotypes of rbf was carried similar as described [8], except that w; p{ry+, neoFRT82B} males were used for mutagenesis, and rbf15aΔ, w, eyFLP; p{ry+, neoFRT82B} p{w+, Ubi-GFP} p{w+, rbf-G3} and w, eyFLP; p{ry+, neoFRT82B} p{w+, Ubi-GFP} stocks were used for screening and rbf dependence test. Total RNA was isolated with TRIzol (Invitrogen). cDNA was synthesized with 1 µg total RNA, M-MLV Reverse Transcriptase (Invitrogen), and 3′RACE-T7 primer (5′-TAATACGACTCA CTATAGGGTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTV-3′ (V = A, G, or C) ). Nested PCR was first performed with the Axin3′middleF primer (5′-CGGGTGTGGAAGGACCAAA-3′) and T7 primer (5′-TAATACGACTCACTATAGGG-3′), and then the Axin3′middleF-2 primer (5′-ATTCCGGAATGGTCAGCGA-3′) and T7 primer. PCR products were gel purified and sequenced. Immunostaining was performed at room temperature unless indicated otherwise. Larval imaginal discs were dissected in 1× PBS, fixed with 4% formaldehyde in PBS for 25 min, washed twice with 1× PBS with 0. 3% Triton-X100 (PBST), and incubated with primary antibody in blocking solution (PBST plus 5% normal goat serum) overnight at 4°C. Primary antibodies used: rabbit anti-activated Caspase-3 (C3,1∶300 from Cell Signaling), mouse anti-β-Galactosidase (1∶100, DSHB), rat anti-ELAV (1∶50, DSHB), Guinea pig anti-Senseless [57], and Guinea pig anti-E2F1 (Orr-Weaver lab). Guinea pig anti-Hid antibody was affinity purified with recombinant GST-Hid [58]. Following incubation with primary antibody, samples were washed three times (10 minutes each) in PBST, and incubated with secondary antibodies from Jackson ImmunoResearch (1∶200 to 1∶400). Sample was mounted in 70% Glycerol with 1,4-diazabicyclo[2. 2. 2]octane (DABCO) at 12. 5 mg/mL. For mammalian cell staining, infected cells were seeded onto glass coverslips, and processed for staining. Fixed, permeabilized, and blocked cells were incubated with rabbit anti-APC M2 (kindly provided by Kristi Neufeld, University of Kansas), followed by FITC-coupled secondary antibody. Imaging was done with the Zeiss Axioscope/ApoTome microscope using the AxioCam CCD camera controlled by Zeiss Axiovision software. In experiments with internal controls (for example, the WT tissues from the same disc that do not show cell death), the exposure time for each sample were determined using the “measure” function in Axiovision for each channel to get optimal exposure without signal oversaturation. For experiments with no internal controls, exposure time was fixed using the genotype with brightest signal to avoid overexposure. Cell death (%) is determined as described previously [10] by the percentage of clone area (pixels) that have above background level of caspase 3 (C3) signal using the Histogram function in Photoshop. The background level of C3 signal was determined as the level that is equal or below 99% of the C3 signal in the WT tissues that have no apoptosis. The Average and standard deviation of percent cell death for each genotype discs was then determined and compared. 40 Drosophila eye discs with each specific genotype were dissected in insect cell media CCM3 (Hyclone), and moved to 1. 5 ml tubes with 100 µl 1× SDS-PAGE loading buffer immediately. The samples were pipetted for several times, boiled for 5 minutes, quickly centrifuged, and 20 µl of them were loaded for SDS-PAGE. For mammalian samples, cells were washed twice with 1× PBS, and lysed in RIPA buffer (50 mm Tris. Cl [pH 7. 4], 150 mm NaCl, 2 mm EDTA, 1% NP40,0. 1% SDS, 0. 5% sodium deoxycholate, plus protease inhibitors). Primary antibodies are rabbit anti-pS6K (1∶300, Cell Signaling), mouse anti β-actin (1∶1000 Santa Cruz), and mouse anti-Rb 4. 1 (1∶10, Developmental Studies Hybridoma Bank). The goat anti-mouse IgG and goat anti-rabbit IgG secondary antibodies were obtained from Li-Cor. Western detection was carried out using a Li-Cor Odyssey image reader. Eye imaginal discs with specific genotypes were dissected, pipetted with 120 uL 1× Passive Lysis Buffer (Promega) for 15 times in a 1. 5 mL tube on ice, boiled for 5 minutes, then incubated on ice for 2 minutes. After centrifugation at 18,000G for 2 minutes, 20 uL of each sample was used to assay the ADP∶ATP ratio using the Enzylight kit according the manufacturer' s protocol (BioAssay Systems). To induce metabolic stress, FRT 82B Axn127 and FRT 82B control 2nd instar larvae were collected at 72 hour after egg lay, rinsed to remove any residual fly food, and transferred into empty vials containing one 11 cm by 21 cm Kimwipe soaked with 1 ml of either 1× PBS or PBS with glutamine. Eight vials containing 25 larvae each were used per genotype per condition. These vials were incubated at 25°C for 48 hours, at which point the Kimwipe was extracted and the larvae were characterized. Drosophila larvae were determined to be viable if they responded to stimuli from poking with a blunted pair of forceps. For eye disc starvation, dissected eye discs were left in 1× PBS at room temperature for 3 hours before fixation, and eye discs fixed immediately after dissection were used as control (0 hr). The immunostaing with C3 antibody is the same as described above. Larvae of Oregon R Drosophila (control) and axn127 homozygous mutants (w1118; +; FRT82B axn127) were collected at the third instar wandering stage. Total RNA was extracted from three larvae per sample with 1. 0 ml of TRIzol Reagent (Life Technologies Corporation) according to the manufacturer' s instructions. The microarray analysis was performed according to the protocol that was described previously [59]. The complete sets of microarray data have been deposited in the ArrayExpress database (http: //www. ebi. ac. uk/arrayexpress/; accession number is E-MTAB-2342). Gene Ontology was performed with GO-TermFinder (http: //amigo. geneontology. org/cgi-bin/amigo/term_enrichment) [60]. DU145 and HCT116 cells were obtained from the American Type Culture Collection. All the cells were maintained in Dulbecco' s modified Eagle' s medium supplemented with 10% fetal bovine serum (FBS, Atlas Biologicals), 50 IU penicillin/streptomycin, and 2 mmol/l L-glutamine (Invitrogen) in a humidified atmosphere with 5% CO2 at 37°C. Human pRb was subcloned into the lentiviral expression vector pCDHCMV-EF1-puro (System Biosciences). The pLKO. 1 lentiviral RNAi expression system was used to construct lentiviral shRNA. The sequences of shRNA used in this study included the following: shAPC-1: 5′-CCGGTGAGGTCATCTCAGAACAAGCTCGAGCTTGTTCTGAGATGACCTCtttttt-3′ shAPC-2: 5′-CCGGTAAGACGTTGCGAGAAGTTGGACTCGAGTCCAACTTCTCGCAACGTCTTtttttt-3′ shpRb-1: 5′-CCGGCGACGAGTCAAACAAGCCAATCTCGAGATTGGCTTGTTTGACTCGTCGTTTTTG shRb-3: 5′-CCGGTGGTTGTGTCGAAATTGGATCACTCGAGTGATCCAATTTCGACACAACCTTTTTT-3′ shGFP: 5′-CCGGTACGTCTATATCATGGCCGACAACTAGTTGTCGGCCATGATATAGACGTTTTTTG-3′ The shGFP was used as a control in this study. Viral packaging was done according to the previously described protocol [10]. Briefly, expression plasmids pCMV-dR8. 91 and pCMV-VSV-G were cotransfected into HEK293T cells using the calcium phosphate method at 10∶5∶5 µg (for a 10-cm dish). The transfection medium containing calcium phosphate and plasmid mixture was replaced with fresh complete medium after incubation for 6 hr. Media containing virus was collected 48 hr after transfection, and then concentrated at 19,400 g for 2 hr. The virus pellet was re-dissolved, and stocked at −80°C. Cells were infected with the viruses for 48 hr, and were treated as described. Quantification of cell death was performed using FACSCanto (BD Biosciences) after cells were stained with Annexin V-FITC (BD Biosciences) and propidium iodide (Sigma) according to manufacturer' s specifications. Rapamycin rescue assays were performed in the presence of 20 ng/ml Rapamycin or vehicle control. Cells were treated with lentivirus as described above, and were plated into a 24-well plate, followed by transfection by lipofectamine 2000 (Invitrogen) according to the manufacturer' s instruction. Each transfection contained 800 ng of TOPflash-luc or FOPflash-luc, and 5 ng of phRL-Luc. Cell extracts were prepared 48 hrs post-transfection, and the luciferase activity was measured using Dual Luciferase Reporter Assay System (Promega) according to the manufacturer' s instruction. Luciferase activity was read on a BD Monolight 3010 Luminometer. All data points presented are the average measurement of three independent transfections. For growth assay, 104 cells suspended in 0. 35% agarose solution were poured over hard-bottomed agar (0. 6%) previously solidified in 6-well plates. Cells were cultured in a humidified atmosphere with 5% CO2 at 37°C for 3–4 weeks, and then colonies were counted. Soft agar growth rescue assays were performed in the presence of 10 mM NAC or vehicle control added to the top layer mix at the time of plating. For ROS assay, 105 cells were seeded between top agar layer and bottom agar layer for 16 hrs, and then 1 ml of complete medium containing 20 µM of DHE was added onto the top agar layer. After incubation for 1 hr, the medium was aspirated and the top agar layer was carefully removed. Cells were processed for imaging with a Zeiss fluorescence microscope.
Inactivation of Rb tumor suppressor is common in cancers. Therefore, identification of genes and pathways that are synthetic lethal with Rb will provide new insights into the role of Rb in cancer development and promote the development of novel therapeutic approaches. Here we identified a novel synthetic lethal interaction between Rb inactivation and hyperactivated Wnt signaling and showed that this synthetic lethal interaction is conserved in mammalian systems. We demonstrate that hyperactivated Wnt signaling activate TORC1 activity and induce excessive energy stress with inactivated Rb tumor suppressor, which underpins the evolutionarily conserved synthetic lethal interaction. This study provides novel insights into the interactions between the Rb, Wnt, and mTOR pathways in regulating cellular energy balance, cell growth, and survival.
oncology
developmental biology
medicine and health sciences
cell biology
genetics
biology and life sciences
molecular cell biology
Hyperactivated Wnt Signaling Induces Synthetic Lethal Interaction with Rb Inactivation by Elevating TORC1 Activities