Molecular-based surveys have indicated that Ancylostoma ceylanicum, a zoonotic hookworm, is likely the second most prevalent hookworm species infecting humans in Asia. Most current PCR-based diagnostic options for the detection of Ancylostoma species target the Internal Transcribed Spacer (ITS) regions of the ribosomal gene cluster. These regions possess a considerable degree of conservation among the species of this genus and this conservation can lead to the misidentification of infecting species or require additional labor for accurate species-level determination. We have developed a novel, real-time PCR-based assay for the sensitive and species-specific detection of A. ceylanicum that targets a non-coding, highly repetitive genomic DNA element. Comparative testing of this PCR assay with an assay that targets ITS sequences was conducted on field-collected samples from Argentina and Timor-Leste to provide further evidence of the sensitivity and species-specificity of this assay. A previously described platform for the design of primers/probe targeting non-coding highly repetitive regions was used for the development of this novel assay. The assay’s limits of detection (sensitivity) and cross-reactivity with other soil-transmitted helminth species (specificity) were assessed with real-time PCR experiments. The assay was successfully used to identify infections caused by A. ceylanicum that were previously only identified to the genus level as Ancylostoma spp. when analyzed using other published primer-probe pairings. Further proof of sensitive, species-specific detection was provided using a published, semi-nested restriction fragment length polymorphism-PCR assay that differentiates between Ancylostoma species. Due to the close proximity of people and domestic/wild animals in many regions of the world, the potential for zoonotic infections is substantial. Sensitive tools enabling the screening for different soil-transmitted helminth infections are essential to the success of mass deworming efforts and facilitate the appropriate interpretation of data. This study describes a novel, species-specific, real-time PCR-based assay for the detection of A. ceylanicum that will help to address the need for such tools in integrated STH deworming programs. ANZCTR. org. au ACTRN12614000680662
Ancylostoma ceylanicum is the only predominantly animal-infecting hookworm species known to successfully develop into adults within the human intestine [1]. This zoonotic species has been reported to infect animals and humans in Southeast Asia, South America, South Africa, Melanesia and Australia [2–13], and prevalence studies have demonstrated A. ceylanicum to be the second most common hookworm species causing human infection in many parts of Asia [5,14–16]. Equally troubling, a recent study investigating A. ceylanicum transmission conducted in Cambodia demonstrated the ability of this worm to result in burdens of infection comparable to levels caused by Necator americanus [6]. Furthermore, it has been demonstrated that Ancylostoma duodenale can ingest up to eight times the volume of blood consumed by N. americanus, resulting in increased iron depletion [17]. Accordingly, frequent cases of Ancylostoma-associated anemia have been reported, even among properly nourished individuals [12,18]. Although only speculative, similar pathology might exist for human infections with A. ceylanicum, underscoring the potential importance of this zoonotic parasite for both child and maternal health [19]. Despite these findings, methodologies for the reliable, species-specific, and sensitive molecular detection of A. ceylanicum are lacking, resulting in a need for improved diagnostic tools. Historically, diagnosis and detection of all hookworm species has relied heavily on the use of coprological methods [5]. Widespread use of these methods stems from their low cost, simplicity, and minimal infrastructure requirements. By default, microscopy has served as the standard method for gastrointestinal helminth detection [5]. However, at the egg level, and in some cases even at the larval level, certain hookworm species are morphologically indistinguishable [20] and further culturing of worms is required for differentiation. Conducting such coprological techniques is time-consuming and requires highly skilled microscopists for accurate assessment of results [21]. Accordingly, PCR-based molecular diagnostic tests for hookworm provide an attractive alternative to microscopy with more modest training requirements. However, such assays frequently target the internal transcribed spacer regions (ITS) of the rDNA gene clusters, which demonstrate considerable homology between closely related Ancylostoma species [5]. This similarity can lead to species misidentification in hookworm positive samples. Several PCR variations such as nested PCR and PCR coupled with restriction fragment length polymorphism (PCR-RFLP) have been developed to differentiate between the hookworm species. Unfortunately, these methods tend to be laborious, requiring many steps and/or restriction enzyme digestions coupled with agarose gel electrophoresis [4,21,23,24]. In addition, nested PCR is far more likely to result in false positivity due to sample contamination and increased numbers of PCR cycles [22]. Thus, simplified PCR assays, not reliant on nested PCR or restriction enzyme digestions, would be of great benefit to programmatic efforts. Furthermore, while drug intervention and hygiene programs have made substantial gains and continue to show great promise, they frequently fail to account for the control of zoonotic infections [15]. Such concerns are particularly important when proper sanitation is lacking as the potential for zoonotic transmission from wild or domestic animals to humans is dramatically increased [5]. Accordingly, species-level identification provides insight into possible infection reservoirs, which might not be considered utilizing genus-level diagnostics. Herein we report the development and validation of a novel, real-time PCR-based diagnostic assay for the species-specific detection of A. ceylanicum. The development of this test is based on the identification of a highly repetitive, non-coding DNA element using advanced bioinformatics to analyze whole genome sequence data for target discovery and assay design [25]. We posit that the incorporation of this new assay into our previously established diagnostic platform [25] will aid programmatic efforts, as accurate species-level detection and differentiation of Ancylostoma ssp. is now possible.
Genome sequences for A. ceylanicum were obtained from NCBI (Sequence Read Archive ID: SRR2037027 and SRR2037046). Analysis of repeat DNA content was performed using the publicly available platform, RepeatExplorer [26], following our previously established bioinformatics workflow [25], and a primer-probe set was designed using the PrimerQuest online tool (Integrated DNA Technologies, Coralville, IA) (Table 1). This candidate primer-probe pairing then underwent further bioinformatics analysis using the Primer-BLAST tool available from the National Center for Biotechnology Information (NCBI) website. Utilizing default parameters, the candidate primer pair did not return any matches to off-target templates within NCBI’s Nucleotide Collection database, indicating target specificity and ensuring that the occurrence of off-target amplification would be extremely unlikely. Default parameters for probe-based PCR were utilized for the assay design and the probe was labeled with 6FAM fluorophore at the 5’ end and double-quenched with ZEN (internal) and 3IABkFQ at the 3’ end. A concentration matrix was created to determine the optimal forward and reverse primer concentration as previously described [25]. All reactions were performed in 7 μl total volumes utilizing 2 μl of template, 3. 5 μl of TaqMan Fast Universal PCR Master Mix (ThermoFisher Scientific, Waltham, MA), and the appropriate concentrations of primers and probe. Cycling conditions consisted of an initial 2-minute incubation step at 50°C, followed by a 10-minute incubation at 95°C. These incubations were followed by 40 cycles of 95°C for 15 seconds for denaturation and 1 minute at 59°C for primer annealing and polymerase extension. All reactions were conducted using the StepOne Plus Real-Time PCR System (Life Technologies, Carlsbad, CA). Following the completion of primer optimization reactions, the sensitivity and specificity of our assay was evaluated. For sensitivity testing, the optimized assay was performed utilizing a titration of genomic DNA concentrations as template. Reactions were conducted using 2 μl of A. ceylanicum genomic template at concentrations of 1 ng/μl, 100 pg/μl, 10 pg/μl, 1 pg/μl, 100 fg/μl, 10 fg/μl, 1 fg/μl, 100 ag/μl 10 ag/μl, and 1 ag/μl. In order to verify assay specificity, optimized conditions were employed to evaluate the potential for non-specific amplification of control genomic DNA from six other species of soil-transmitted helminths (A. duodenale, N. americanus, Trichuris trichiura, Strongyloides stercoralis, Ascaris lumbricoides and Ancylostoma caninum), along with human genomic DNA and DNA of the common gastrointestinal tract commensal bacterium Escherichia coli (strain K-12). All of these control samples were tested utilizing 2 μl of DNA template at concentrations of 1 ng/μl. A panel of six 10-fold serial dilutions of an initial 1 ng/μl stock of A. ceylanicum genomic DNA was created. To each dilution in this panel, genomic DNA was added from both A. caninum and A. duodenale such that the concentrations of DNA from both of these other species were at a final concentration of 1 ng/μl in each panel dilution. The aforementioned panel was tested with the optimized real-time PCR based assay for A. ceylanicum to prove that the presence of other Ancylostoma spp. , simulating mixed infections, would not affect our assay’s specificity. Furthermore, testing of this panel enabled us to determine the assay’s limits of detection when increasingly limited concentrations of target DNA (A. ceylanicum) were intermixed with genomic DNA from the two other Ancylostoma spp. (S1 Table). Sixty-one human stool samples previously collected as part of the “Wash for Worms” intervention trial in Timor-Leste (Trial registration: ACTRN12614000680662) were selected for inclusion in this study. DNA extractions for these samples were previously performed at QIMR Berghofer, and real-time PCR analysis demonstrated the presence of Ancylostoma spp. DNA in 22 of these samples [27]. Eight additional samples, collected in Orán, Argentina, as part of a larger collection effort (IRB00008019), were also selected for inclusion in this study. For Argentinian samples, DNA was previously extracted at Baylor College of Medicine utilizing a published methodology [28]. Prior real-time PCR analysis of these eight samples had demonstrated the presence of Ancylostoma ssp. DNA [28]. A previously published semi-nested conventional PCR assay coupled with restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis [23] was employed to distinguish between the different hookworm species in the samples obtained from both Timor-Leste and Orán, Argentina. All amplification reactions and digestions were conducted in accordance with the previously described methodologies [23]. DNA aliquots of all samples from both Timor-Leste and Orán, Argentina were sent to Smith College for further analysis. Samples were blindly coded and assayed for the presence of both A. duodenale and A. ceylanicum. Testing for the presence of A. duodenale occurred in accordance with the previously described protocol [25], while A. ceylanicum testing was conducted using the novel assay described here.
Utilization of the previously published workflow for repeat analysis led to the identification of a novel target for the sensitive and species-specific real-time PCR-based detection of A. ceylanicum [25]. Employing the PrimerQuest online tool, a primer/probe pairing was identified and oligonucleotides were synthesized. Through the analysis of a titration matrix, primer optimization reactions were performed, and the optimal forward primer concentration was determined to be 125 nM, while the reverse primer was demonstrated to have an optimal concentration of 1000 nM. This combination of concentrations resulted in the lowest Ct values when amplifying 2 μl of A. ceylanicum genomic DNA at a concentration of 1 ng/μl. Assay specificity testing failed to amplify purified genomic DNA from the STH parasites A. duodenale, N. americanus, T. trichiura, S. stercoralis, A. lumbricoides and A. caninum. Testing also failed to amplify human DNA or DNA from the common gastrointestinal bacteria, E. coli (strain K-12), thus demonstrating the assay’s species-specific detection properties. Furthermore, assay sensitivity testing demonstrated consistent detection of purified A. ceylanicum genomic DNA template at all quantities above 200 ag. However, when the A. ceylanicum assay was utilized to analyze samples containing simulated mixed infections of both A. ceylanicum and other Ancylostoma species, the limit of detection was determined to be 13. 3 fg of A. ceylanicum DNA (S1 Table). Importantly, based upon the genome size of A. ceylanicum [29], and assuming that a single egg contains approximately 8 cells, this quantity of template DNA is less than the quantity expected to be found within a single A. ceylanicum egg (theoretically 5520 fg of DNA based on A. ceylanicum’s genome size). To further validate this novel assay, 61 DNA extracts from stool samples collected in Timor-Leste were analyzed. Utilizing a genus-specific real-time PCR assay, previous testing conducted at QIMR Berghofer demonstrated the presence of Ancylostoma ssp. DNA in 22 of these samples [27]. However, follow-up testing of these samples utilizing our previously described A. duodenale-specific primer/probe set excluded the presence of A. duodenale [25], and semi-nested PCR-RFLP analysis demonstrated the presence of A. ceylanicum in 21 of the 22 samples analyzed [25]. The identity of the 22nd sample could not be determined as this sample failed to amplify using both our A. duodenale-specific assays and the semi-nested PCR-RFLP analysis. Two independent sequencing trials were also performed, but meaningful results could not be obtained. These experiments exhausted the sample stock and so no further experiments could be done to identify this sample. This subset of 22 Ancylostoma ssp. -positive samples was then employed to demonstrate the comparative sensitivity and species-specificity of our newly designed A. ceylanicum assay. Utilizing this assay, the same 21 samples which were determined to be A. ceylanicum-positive by RFLP-PCR again tested positive for the presence of A. ceylanicum DNA, while the 22nd sample (PCR-RFLP-negative for A. ceylanicum) was also negative by real-time PCR, likely indicating that the Ancylostoma genus-specific assay (QIMR) had amplified a non-duodenale, non-ceylanicum Ancylostoma target (S2 Table). Equally important, the remaining 39 Timor-Leste-derived samples that tested negative for Ancylostoma spp. using the previously described genus-specific PCR assay [27] also produced a negative result when tested using the newly described A. ceylanicum-specific diagnostic (S2 Table). Thus, negative results agreed across all samples, in all replicates, with all utilized assays. While testing of field-collected samples from Timor-Leste demonstrated the ability of our new assay to detect DNA from A. ceylanicum, we next sought to demonstrate that this A. ceylanicum real-time PCR assay would not amplify DNA from A. duodenale-containing field samples. For this purpose, eight additional DNA extracts from stool samples, obtained from an A. duodenale endemic region near Orán, Argentina, were tested in duplicate. Utilizing a combination of the previously described A. duodenale-specific PCR [25] and the semi-nested PCR-RFLP assays [23], we verified the presence of A. duodenale and the absence of A. ceylanicum within each sample (S1 Fig, S3 Table). Individual samples were then tested using the newly described A. ceylanicum-specific PCR assay, and for all samples, in all replicates, amplification failed to occur. Thus, by selectively amplifying A. ceylanicum-containing samples from Timor-Leste, but failing to amplify Argentinian samples positive for A. duodenale, we successfully demonstrated the species-specific nature of the A. ceylanicum PCR assay on human samples collected in the field. Table 2 summarizes the results of the various molecular approaches used to determine the species of Ancylostoma within samples from both field studies.
Highlighting the under-recognized importance of A. ceylanicum as a public health concern, a study in northern Cambodia recently implicated A. ceylanicum as the causative agent responsible for as many as half of all human hookworm infections among the young adult population [6]. However, despite such prevalence, zoonotic parasites are typically given little consideration during the implementation of mass deworming efforts. Accordingly, increased awareness of the potential impact of A. ceylanicum infection on the human population is required, and more sensitive tools are needed for monitoring this important zoonotic STH. Such tools will provide a more complete picture of the role such zoonotic parasites play in global health. While current treatments for human hookworm infection are not species-dependent, it has been demonstrated that responses to drug treatments can vary in a species-dependent manner [30]. Because species-specific diagnostics are lacking, misidentification of the infecting species may lead to a lack of clarity in understanding drug-responses in infected populations. While benzimidazole-based interventions have not yet resulted in the reporting of any such species-specific responses, such responses may develop, or they may simply be underreported. As A. duodenale and A. ceylanicum are both capable of causing significant human infection, and A. caninum has the capacity to infect humans in an “unsuccessful” manner [23,31], species-specific diagnostic assays are needed to fully evaluate the progress of drug intervention programs. Furthermore, given the increasing concerns surrounding the possible development of drug resistance [32–34], species-level knowledge of infection is critical, as it is likely that different hookworm species may evolve resistance via different mechanisms and at different rates. The importance of species-level identification is further supported by the phenomenon of refugia, as the presence of an untreated animal reservoir may slow the evolutionary pressures on a pathogen, in turn slowing the development of drug resistance mechanisms [32,34]. While the A. ceylanicum-specific assay described here has potential usefulness as a tool for monitoring veterinary infections, its specificity and performance in such settings has not yet been evaluated. In order to evaluate such applications, additional testing and validation of this assay against common animal hookworm species such as Ancylostoma braziliense, Ancylostoma tubaeforme, and Uncinaria stenocephala, as well as other common veterinary intestinal helminths would be required. Similarly, employment of this assay for the purposes of environmental monitoring would require, at a minimum, testing against common free-living nematode species. Given the importance of the accurate, species-level identification of STH infections, we believe that the real-time PCR-based assay for the detection of A. ceylanicum described here, in combination with our previously described real-time PCR assays, will aid future hookworm monitoring efforts. With the demonstrated capacity to detect DNA isolated from a single egg, this assay provides a sensitive and species-specific diagnostic tool capable of more fully informing program managers, enabling more appropriate decision-making and allowing for improved programmatic outcomes. Finally, it should be noted that this A. ceylanicum PCR assay is easily integrated into our current multi-parallel PCR system [25] to provide a more complete picture of the STH infection status in studied populations.
Historically, Ancylostoma ceylanicum has been viewed as an uncommon cause of human hookworm infection, with minimal public health importance. However, recent reports have indicated that this zoonotic hookworm causes a much greater incidence of infection within certain human populations than was previously believed. Current methods for the species-level detection of A. ceylanicum rely on techniques that involve conventional PCR accompanied by restriction enzyme digestions. These PCR-based assays are not only laborious but they lack sensitivity as they target suboptimal regions on the DNA. As efforts aimed at the eradication of hookworm disease have grown substantially over the last decade, the need for sensitive and specific tools to monitor and evaluate programmatic successes has correspondingly escalated. Since a growing body of evidence suggests that patient responses to drug treatment can vary based upon the species of hookworm that is causing infection, accurate species-level diagnostics are advantageous. Accordingly, the novel real-time PCR-based assay described here provides a sensitive, species-specific diagnostic tool that will facilitate the accurate mapping of disease endemicity and will aid in the evaluation of progress of programmatic deworming efforts.
invertebrates
medicine and health sciences
helminths
hookworms
parasitic diseases
animals
genome analysis
molecular biology techniques
ancylostoma
research and analysis methods
infectious diseases
zoonoses
genomics
artificial gene amplification and extension
molecular biology
helminth infections
polymerase chain reaction
genetics
nematoda
biology and life sciences
computational biology
organisms
A novel, species-specific, real-time PCR assay for the detection of the emerging zoonotic parasite Ancylostoma ceylanicum in human stool