The Ypd1 phosphorelay protein is a central constituent of fungal two-component signal transduction pathways. Inhibition of Ypd1 in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Cryptococcus neoformans is lethal due to the sustained activation of the ‘p38-related’ Hog1 stress-activated protein kinase (SAPK). As two-component signalling proteins are not found in animals, Ypd1 is considered to be a prime antifungal target. However, a major fungal pathogen of humans, Candida albicans, can survive the concomitant sustained activation of Hog1 that occurs in cells lacking YPD1. Here we show that the sustained activation of Hog1 upon Ypd1 loss is mediated through the Ssk1 response regulator. Moreover, we present evidence that C. albicans survives SAPK activation in the short-term, following Ypd1 loss, by triggering the induction of protein tyrosine phosphatase-encoding genes which prevent the accumulation of lethal levels of phosphorylated Hog1. In addition, our studies reveal an unpredicted, reversible, mechanism that acts to substantially reduce the levels of phosphorylated Hog1 in ypd1Δ cells following long-term sustained SAPK activation. Indeed, over time, ypd1Δ cells become phenotypically indistinguishable from wild-type cells. Importantly, we also find that drug-induced down-regulation of YPD1 expression actually enhances the virulence of C. albicans in two distinct animal infection models. Investigating the underlying causes of this increased virulence, revealed that drug-mediated repression of YPD1 expression promotes hyphal growth both within murine kidneys, and following phagocytosis, thus increasing the efficacy by which C. albicans kills macrophages. Taken together, these findings challenge the targeting of Ypd1 proteins as a general antifungal strategy and reveal novel cellular adaptation mechanisms to sustained SAPK activation.
Candida albicans is the leading cause of systemic fungal infections in humans resulting in over 400,000 deaths each year in immuno-compromised patients [1]. The ability of C. albicans to adapt to host-imposed stresses encountered during infection is an important virulence trait [2]. Central to fungal stress responses are the stress-activated protein kinases (SAPKs), which are conserved eukaryotic signalling enzymes that allow cells to adapt to environmental change [3,4]. In C. albicans, the Hog1 SAPK is activated in response to diverse, physiologically relevant, stress conditions, and cells lacking Hog1 are acutely sensitive to such stresses [5–7]. Consistent with the vital role of the Hog1 SAPK in stress survival, C. albicans cells lacking HOG1 display significantly attenuated virulence in systemic, commensal, and phagocyte infection models [8–11]. All SAPK activation mechanisms reported to date result in the phosphorylation of conserved threonine and tyrosine residues located within the TGY motif of the catalytic domain of the kinase [3]. Such pathways are tightly regulated as the nature of the response is dependent on the extent and period of SAPK activation. For example, in the model yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, transient activation of the Hog1 SAPK is vital to survive osmotic stress [4], whereas sustained activation triggers programmed cell death [12]. Similarly in human cells transient activation of the p38 SAPK promotes stress-induced gene expression and cellular proliferation [13], whereas sustained SAPK activation triggers apoptosis [14]. In contrast, much less is known regarding the regulation and cellular consequences of sustained SAPK activation in C. albicans. Despite the availability of several antifungal drugs, the high mortality rate associated with C. albicans systemic infections and the emergence of drug resistant strains highlights the urgent clinical need for new anti-fungal therapies [15]. Although Hog1 is an essential virulence determinant in C. albicans, the conservation with highly related SAPKs in human cells suggests that Hog1 itself may be unsuitable as an antifungal target. Instead, there has been much interest in identifying fungal-specific regulators of SAPKs as potential drug targets. Candidate targets include two-component related phosphorelay systems which constitute an important mechanism employed by fungi, but not mammals, to sense and relay specific stress signals to SAPK modules [16]. In S. cerevisiae, this system is comprised of a hybrid histidine kinase (Sln1), an intermediary phosphorelay protein (Ypd1), and a response regulator protein (Ssk1) (Fig 1). Following osmotic stress, the Sln1 histidine kinase is inactivated, which halts phosphorelay through Ypd1, and consequently leads to the rapid dephosphorylation of Ssk1 [17]. Dephosphorylated Ssk1 is a potent activator of the Ssk2/Ssk22 MAPKKKs which regulate Hog1 activation [18,19]. Significantly, loss of either Sln1 or Ypd1 function in S. cerevisiae is lethal [20], due to the accumulation of unphosphorylated Ssk1 and the resulting sustained Hog1 activation which triggers apoptosis-mediated cell death [12]. It is likely that sustained Hog1 activation can also not be tolerated in the human fungal pathogen, Cryptococcus neoformans, as Ypd1 is essential for the viability of cells containing Hog1 [21]. The essential nature of Ypd1 in these fungi, and the many reports illustrating the importance of two-component proteins in fungal pathogenicity, has fuelled interest in targeting Ypd1 for antifungal drug development (reviewed in [22]). C. albicans has seven two-component proteins; three histidine kinases (Sln1, Chk1, Nik1), three response regulators (Ssk1, Skn7, Crr1/Srr1), and a single phosphorelay protein (Ypd1) [23]. In S. cerevisiae, Ypd1 plays a pivotal role in mediating all phosphorelay events from the upstream histidine kinases to the downstream Ssk1 and Skn7 response regulators [17,24], which supports the concept that Ypd1 is an appropriate antifungal target. Hence, in this study, we investigated the impact of inactivating Ypd1 upon stress signalling and virulence of C. albicans. As reported recently, we found that C. albicans can survive deletion of YPD1 [25]. Here we extend this finding by illustrating that C. albicans survives the sustained SAPK activation following Ypd1 loss by evoking multiple mechanisms to reduce the level of phosphorylated Hog1. Furthermore, we demonstrate that inactivation of Ypd1 during infection actually increases the virulence of C. albicans in a number of infection models, revealing that Ypd1 may not be a suitable target for anti-fungal drug development.
C. albicans contains a single homologue of the S. cerevisiae phosphorelay protein Ypd1 [26]. Although deletion of Ypd1 results in a lethal phenotype in both S. cerevisiae and C. neoformans [20,21], a recent study revealed that YPD1 is not an essential gene in C. albicans, with ypd1Δ cells instead displaying a slow growth phenotype [25]. To investigate this further we created a C. albicans strain, tetO-YPD1 (Fig 2A), in which one allele of YPD1 was deleted and the remaining allele placed under the control of a doxycycline-repressible promoter [27]. Northern analysis confirmed that treatment of tetO-YPD1 cells with doxycycline caused a rapid decrease in YPD1 mRNA levels (Fig 2B). However, whilst repression of YPD1 expression did result in a slower growth rate (Fig 2C, upper panel), the cells were viable. Furthermore, consistent with the previous study [25], we were able to generate a viable homozygous ypd1Δ null mutant which displayed a slower growth rate compared to wild-type cells (Fig 2C, lower panel). Deletion of YPD1 is lethal in S. cerevisiae due to constitutive SAPK activation. Consistent with previous findings [25], we found that repression of YPD1 expression in tetO-YPD1 cells (Fig 2D, upper panel; S1 Fig), or deletion of YPD1 (Fig 2D, lower panel), also stimulated high levels of Hog1 phosphorylation in C. albicans. Together these data indicate that the inhibitory effect of YPD1 on SAPK activation in S. cerevisiae is conserved in C. albicans. However, it was possible that the phosphorylated Hog1 detected did not result in activation of Hog1-dependent downstream events. To test this possibility the expression levels of the Hog1-dependent genes, GPD2 and RHR2 [28], important for glycerol biosynthesis were examined upon repression or deletion of YPD1 (Fig 2E). Both genes were found to be up-regulated and, furthermore, as expected, increased intracellular glycerol concentrations were observed in ypd1Δ cells in the absence of stress (Fig 2F). Thus collectively, these data confirm that the phosphorylated Hog1 kinase triggered by inactivation of Ypd1 in C. albicans is active. However, in contrast to S. cerevisiae and C. neoformans constitutive Hog1 activation does not result in loss of viability in C. albicans. Analyses of cells with loss of Ypd1 function, either by repression or deletion of the YPD1 gene, revealed identical morphological abnormalities and stress-resistance profiles. For example, loss of YPD1 resulted in swollen pseudohyphal-like cells (Fig 3A), possibly due to the increased intracellular levels of the osmolyte glycerol that occurs upon inactivation of Ypd1 (Fig 2F). In addition, as reported previously [25], cells lacking Ypd1 were highly flocculent as demonstrated by their rapid sedimentation rate (Fig 3A). Interestingly, cells lacking Ypd1 displayed acute sensitivity to sodium arsenite, increased resistance to the organic peroxide tert-butyl hydroperoxide (t-BOOH), and wild-type levels of resistance to osmotic stress (Fig 3B). Loss of YPD1 also resulted in increased sensitivity to the cell wall perturbing agent calcofluor white (Fig 3B). This is consistent with Hog1 activation in ypd1Δ cells (Fig 2D), as hog1Δ cells display significant resistance to this drug [6]. Loss of Ypd1 function is predicted to perturb phosphorelay to all three response regulator proteins in C. albicans; Ssk1, Skn7 and Crr1/Srr1 [23,29,30]. In S. cerevisiae it is the accumulation of the unphosphorylated Ssk1 response regulator which triggers hyperactivation of the Hog1 SAPK [18]. Hence, to investigate which phenotypes associated with Ypd1 loss in C. albicans were due to Ssk1-mediated activation of Hog1, hog1Δ ypd1Δ and ssk1Δ ypd1Δ double mutant strains were created. All of the ypd1Δ-associated phenotypes, described above, were found to be dependent on both Hog1 and Ssk1. For example, the swollen pseudohyphal-like morphology associated with ypd1Δ mutant cells was repressed in the absence of either HOG1 or SSK1 (Fig 3C). In fact, the hog1Δ ypd1Δ double mutant cells instead displayed the morphological defects characteristic of hog1Δ cells (Fig 3C). The high glycerol levels characteristic of ypd1Δ cells were dependent on Hog1 (Fig 3D), and the stress-phenotypes associated with deletion of YPD1 were not maintained in hog1Δ ypd1Δ or ssk1Δ ypd1Δ double mutant cells (Fig 3E). Indeed, in all the conditions examined, cells lacking HOG1 and YPD1 displayed similar stress phenotypes as hog1Δ cells, and ssk1Δ ypd1Δ cells were phenotypically similar to ssk1Δ cells. Importantly, confirming the link between Ypd1 and Hog1 activity, reintegration of HOG1 or SSK1 into the hog1Δ ypd1Δ and ssk1Δ ypd1Δ mutants, respectively, resulted in cells that were phenotypically identical to the ypd1Δ strain (Fig 3C and 3E). Furthermore, the hyper-phosphorylation of Hog1 detected in ypd1Δ cells was absent in ssk1Δ ypd1Δ cells, but was restored upon reintegration of SSK1 (Fig 3F). This result confirms that Ssk1 is essential for the high basal level of Hog1 phosphorylation in ypd1Δ cells. Taken together, these results are consistent with the model that accumulation of unphosphorylated Ssk1 triggers the ypd1Δ-dependent sustained activation of Hog1 in C. albicans and, moreover, that this activation underlies the morphological and stress phenotypes associated with loss of Ypd1. We next investigated the molecular mechanism underlying the ability of C. albicans to survive sustained Hog1 activation. In S. cerevisiae, the lethality associated with YPD1 loss can be by-passed by the artificial over-expression of either of the protein tyrosine phosphatases, Ptp2 or Ptp3, which normally dephosphorylate and negatively regulate Hog1 activity [31,32]. Indeed, YPD1 (tyrosine phosphatase dependent) was initially identified in a synthetic lethal screen for S. cerevisiae mutants whose growth was dependent on the expression of PTP2 [33]. Similarly, Ptp2 in C. neoformans [34] and Ptp2 and Ptp3 in C. albicans [35], have been reported to negatively regulate the respective Hog1 SAPK pathways in these pathogenic fungi. Hence, it was possible that the ability of C. albicans ypd1Δ cells to retain viability was linked to the activity of the Ptp2 and Ptp3 phosphatases. Strikingly, we found that the expression of PTP3 is significantly induced in ypd1Δ cells compared to wild-type cells, and PTP2 is also up-regulated albeit to a lesser extent (Fig 4A). Similar findings were also observed upon doxycycline-mediated repression of YPD1 in tetO-YPD1 cells (Fig 4B and 4C). Significant induction of PTP3 occurred with similar kinetics as the increase in Hog1 activation, and some induction of PTP2 was also evident (Fig 4B and 4C). Previous studies revealed that arsenite is a potent inhibitor of protein tyrosine phosphatases that regulate SAPK pathways in both yeast and humans [36–38]. Interestingly, C. albicans cells lacking Ypd1 are acutely sensitive to arsenite (Fig 3B), raising the possibility that arsenite-mediated inhibition of Ptp2 and/or Ptp3 causes catastrophic levels of Hog1 phosphorylation and ultimately cell death. Indeed, in agreement with this hypothesis, sodium arsenite treatment massively increased Hog1 phosphorylation in ypd1Δ but not wild-type cells (Fig 4D). To confirm that arsenite primarily activates Hog1 through phosphatase inhibition, we next examined Hog1 phosphorylation in cells expressing a mutant version of the MAPKK Pbs2 (Pbs2DD), where the activating phosphorylation sites of Pbs2 are mutated to phosphomimetic aspartate residues. The Pbs2DD mutant protein yields basal activation of Hog1 but prevents further upstream signalling events to the SAPK [10]. Consistent with arsenite-dependent inhibition of Hog1-specific phosphatase (s), significant induction of Hog1 phosphorylation was observed in Pbs2DD cells following arsenite treatment (Fig 4E). Furthermore, this arsenite-induction of Hog1 requires Pbs2 activity as arsenite-induced Hog1 phosphorylation does not occur in cells expressing an inactive Pbs2AA kinase where the activating phosphorylation sites of Pbs2 are mutated to alanine residues mimicking hypophosphorylation (Fig 4E, compare PBS2 and PBS2DD with the PBS2AA lanes). Thus, these results strongly suggest that the ability of C. albicans cells to survive sustained activation of Hog1 upon loss of Ypd1 function is due to the action of Ptp phosphatases that reduce the levels of phosphorylated Hog1. To test this directly, we sought to delete both PTP2 and PTP3 in tetO-YPD1 cells with the prediction that doxycycline-mediated repression of YPD1 in this background would result in catastrophic levels of Hog1 activation and cell death. Initially we focused on deleting PTP3 as this gene shows the greatest induction upon loss of YPD1 (Fig 4A and 4B). Deletion of PTP3 in tetO-YPD1 cells resulted in notably higher levels of Hog1 phosphorylation upon repression of YPD1 expression (Fig 4F). Moreover, deletion of PTP3 had a dramatic impact on the growth of tetO-YPD1 cells upon doxycycline-mediated repression of YPD1, but not in the absence of doxycycline (Fig 4G). These results support the model that induction of PTP3 promotes C. albicans survival following Ypd1 loss by limiting Hog1 phosphorylation. However, repression of YPD1 in ptp3Δ cells did not result in a lethal phenotype which is consistent with previous findings that Ptp2 and Ptp3 function redundantly to regulate C. albicans Hog1 [35]. Upon attempting to generate tetO-YPD1 ptp3Δ ptp2Δ cells we found that only one copy of PTP2 could be deleted. This was unexpected as a ptp2Δ ptp3Δ double mutant has previously been characterised [35]. Strikingly, however, tetO-YPD1 ptp3Δ ptp2/PTP2 cells exhibited a much higher basal level of Hog1 activation than that seen cells lacking PTP3 (Fig 4F). Following doxycycline-mediated repression of YPD1 in ptp3Δ ptp2/PTP2 cells, further substantial increases in Hog1 phosphorylation were detected compared to that observed in tetO-YPD1 ptp3Δ cells (Fig 4F). Indeed, consistent with the additive effect of deleting one copy of PTP2, the growth of tetO-YPD1 ptp3Δ ptp2/PTP2 cells was barely detectable upon repression of YPD1 expression (Fig 4G). However, it is important to note that such cells also display a slow growth phenotype under −DOX conditions when YPD1 is expressed (Fig 4G). Nonetheless, taken together, these data support the model that the induction of PTP3 and PTP2, together with the basal expression of PTP2, facilitate C. albicans survival following loss of the Ypd1 phosphorelay protein. Although C. albicans can clearly tolerate sustained Hog1 activation, cells lacking YPD1 display reduced fitness compared to wild-type cells (Fig 2C). Strikingly, however, we noted that ypd1Δ cells, when maintained on rich media plates, lost the morphological abnormalities associated with inactivation of Ypd1 function. Specifically, the swollen pseudohyphal morphology observed in freshly isolated ypd1Δ cells (Day 1), was largely replaced with normal budding cells after incubation on rich media plates for 13 days (Fig 5A). Because of these findings we examined whether the stress phenotypes associated with YPD1 loss also changed over time. In agreement with our previous findings (Fig 3), freshly isolated ypd1Δ cells (Day 1) exhibited a slow growth rate (indicated by small colony size), and increased sensitivity to sodium arsenite and calcofluor white. However, by day 13 the slow growth phenotype was lost, and the sensitivity to sodium arsenite and calcofluor white mimicked that exhibited by wild-type cells (Fig 5B). Consistent with this loss of morphological and stress sensitive phenotypes, we found that the high basal level of Hog1 phosphorylation, triggered by loss of YPD1, decreased over a 13 day period (Fig 5C). Hog1 phosphorylation levels were significantly reduced by day 10, and by day 13 levels were similar to that seen in wild-type cells. Consistent with a reduction in Hog1 activation, the high basal level of expression of the Hog1 target gene, GPD2, also declined over time (Fig 5D). The decrease in Hog1 phosphorylation was not due to a reduction in Hog1 protein and/or HOG1 mRNA levels which remained constant over the 13 day experiment (Fig 5C and 5D). This suggests that the sustained SAPK phosphorylation caused by loss of Ypd1 triggers adaptation within the cell that results in lower levels of activated Hog1. As we had found the negative regulators PTP3 and PTP2 to be induced in ypd1Δ cells, we asked whether a further induction in their expression could contribute to the adaptation mechanism resulting in the time-dependent decline in Hog1 phosphorylation levels. In agreement with our previous findings (Fig 4A), we found PTP3 and PTP2 to be up-regulated in ypd1Δ cells at day 1 and this was maintained at day 7 (Fig 5B). However, by day 10 the levels of PTP3 and PTP2 in ypd1Δ cells had returned to wild-type levels. Hence, although C. albicans appears to adapt to sustained SAPK activation in the short term by triggering the up-regulation of PTP2 and PTP3, this up-regulation is temporary. Indeed, the induction of PTP2 and PTP3 is only observed in cells in which significant levels of Hog1 activation are seen (compare Fig 5C and 5D). This suggests that C. albicans adapts to Hog1 activation in the long term by via another mechanism (s) independent of Ptp2 and Ptp3. Although the specific adaptation mechanism has not been identified, these results illustrate that C. albicans cells adapt to YPD1 loss over time by reducing the levels of phosphorylated Hog1 such that the negative effects of sustained SAPK activation are ablated, and ypd1Δ cells become phenotypically similar to wild-type cells. We asked whether the reduction in Hog1 phosphorylation levels following long-term sustained Hog1 activation was irreversible. Cells lacking ypd1Δ that had been maintained for 11 days on solid rich media, were then either kept on this media (13 day) or patched onto fresh media in the absence (-NaCl) or presence (+NaCl) of 0. 3M NaCl, a stress condition known to transiently activate Hog1 (Fig 6A). Cells were taken from these plates after 2 days, sub-cultured in liquid media, and phosphorylation and total levels of Hog1 examined (Fig 6A). As expected, a high basal level of Hog1 phosphorylation was absent in ypd1Δ cells at 13 days (Fig 6B). However, passage of ypd1Δ cells over plates containing NaCl, but not lacking NaCl, resulted in a restoration of Hog1 phosphorylation (Fig 6B). To determine whether NaCl treatment could fully restore Hog1 activation in ypd1Δ cells, we compared the level of Hog1 phosphorylation in ypd1Δ cells over the 13 day time course with that seen following passage over NaCl plates. Whilst exposure of ypd1Δ cells to NaCl does restore a high basal level of Hog1 phosphorylation, this is not to the same level as that seen in day 1 samples (Fig 6C). Therefore, these data reveal that a transient exposure of ypd1Δ cells to osmotic stress can partially over-ride the adaptation mechanism (s) that prevents sustained Hog1 phosphorylation. Wild-type cells did not exhibit an increase in Hog1 phosphorylation after passage over media containing NaCl, illustrating that the phosphorylation observed in ypd1Δ cells is due to a re-establishment of sustained Hog1 activation, rather than stress-induced activation of the SAPK (Fig 6B). Furthermore, the restoration of sustained Hog1 phosphorylation in ypd1Δ cells, resulted in the return of a swollen pseudohyphal morphology (Fig 6D). Collectively, the results indicate that the cellular adaptation mechanisms that reduce Hog1 activation in cells lacking YPD1 can be partially over-ridden in the presence of stress that requires Hog1 function. The lethality associated with the deletion of YPD1 in S. cerevisiae and the fungal pathogen C. neoformans [20,21], has led to much interest in this phosphorelay protein family as a potential prime antifungal target [22]. Hence, we next examined the impact of doxycycline-mediated repression of YPD1 on C. albicans virulence. The doxycycline-regulatable gene expression system has been successfully used to control C. albicans gene expression during infection in both a mouse model of systemic candidiasis [27,39], and in a Caenorhabditis elegans infection model [40]. Furthermore, repression of YPD1 expression after infection has three clear advantages over testing the virulence of ypd1Δ cells directly. Firstly, this avoids the problems of accurately obtaining an inoculum size with the highly flocculent and filamentous ypd1Δ strain. Secondly, complications arising from lack of efficient dissemination of a highly flocculent strain are circumvented. Finally, doxycycline-mediated repression of YPD1 following infection more closely mimics the drug-induced inactivation of a particular fungal target following infection. Initially we employed the C. albicans-C. elegans liquid medium pathogenesis assay [40] to examine the impact of YPD1 repression on virulence. Worms were infected with tetO-YPD1 C. albicans cells which had been grown in the absence of doxycycline and thus expressing YPD1 (Fig 2B). Subsequently, the animals were transferred to liquid medium in the presence (+DOX) or absence (-DOX) of doxycycline. Strikingly, we observed a significant increase in C. elegans killing after infection with tetO-YPD1 cells in the presence of doxycycline in which YPD1 expression is repressed (Fig 7A). A total of 41% of infected animals died after 72 h in liquid medium containing doxycycline compared to 11% mortality in media lacking doxycycline (P<0. 001). Importantly, consistent with previous reports [40], doxycycline did not affect the pathogenicity of wild-type C. albicans strains towards C. elegans (S2 Fig). Hence, taken together, these results suggest that doxycycline-mediated repression of YPD1 expression actually enhances the virulence of C. albicans towards C. elegans. To investigate whether these results could be corroborated in a distinct infection model, we employed the three day murine intravenous challenge model of C. albicans infection [41,42]. This model combines weight loss and kidney fungal burden measurements following 3 days of infection to give an ‘outcome score’. A higher outcome score is indicative of greater weight loss and higher fungal burdens and thus increased virulence. Twelve mice were infected intravenously with tetO-YPD1 cells grown in medium lacking doxycycline. Following infection, one group of mice (n = 6) were orally dosed with doxycycline daily (+DOX) to repress YPD1 expression, and the second group of placebo treated mice (n = 6) given water (-DOX). Significantly, inhibition of YPD1 expression during infection resulted in greater weight loss, increased kidney fungal burdens, and thus higher outcome scores compared to cells which continue to express YPD1 (Fig 7B). Consistent with previous studies [27,39], doxycycline treatment alone does not impact on C. albicans virulence in this mouse model of systemic candidiasis (S3 Fig). Histological analysis of the kidneys revealed that there was significant inflammation associated with infection in the doxycycline treated animals (Fig 7C panel i), with little inflammation seen for the placebo treated animals (Fig 7C panel iv). Clusters of filamentous fungal cells were obvious in the doxycycline-treated mouse kidneys (Fig 7C panels ii & iii), whereas only isolated fungal cells were found in the placebo treated kidneys (Fig 7C panels v & vi). This indicates that the CFU measurements underestimate the increased fungal burden following repression of YPD1 expression, presumably as a consequence of the increased filamentation. Nonetheless statistical analysis revealed that the difference between +DOX and −DOX cells was significant for all three parameters, including fungal burden (Fig 7B). Collectively, these studies illustrate that repression of YPD1 expression during infection in two distinct animal models enhances the virulence of C. albicans. These results have clinical significance as they predict that a drug designed to block two-component signalling in C. albicans could actually promote the virulence of this major human fungal pathogen. To further investigate how Ypd1 loss promotes C. albicans virulence, we employed live cell video microscopy to follow the impact of inhibition of YPD1 expression on C. albicans-macrophage interactions. Specifically, tetO-YPD1 cells were treated with (+DOX) or without (-DOX) doxycycline for 3 h prior to co-incubation with murine J774. 1 macrophages, which were then grown in media +/-DOX, respectively. Quantitatively, there were no significant differences between the migration speed of J774. 1 macrophages towards tetO-YPD1 cells treated or not with doxycycline, or rate of engulfment of fungal cells (S4 Fig). Importantly, however, doxycycline mediated-repression of YPD1 resulted in C. albicans cells that displayed a significantly enhanced ability to kill macrophages. It was observed that 82±4. 1% of macrophages were killed following co-incubation with tetO-YPD1 cells in the presence of doxycycline (+DOX), compared to 60±3. 0% macrophages killed in the absence of doxycycline (-DOX) (P<0. 01) (Fig 7D). The ability of C. albicans to transition to the hyphal form following phagocytosis is pivotal in triggering macrophage death [43]. Thus, the rate of hyphae formation of tetO-YPD1 cells following phagocytosis by macrophages was measured. Hyphal growth was significantly faster in tetO-YPD1 cells grown in the presence of doxycycline (0. 35±0. 032 μm/min) than in the absence of doxycycline (0. 26 ± 0. 023 μm/min) (Fig 7E). These results illustrate that repression of YPD1 expression promotes hyphal growth following phagocytosis which in turn likely enhances the ability of C. albicans to kill macrophages. Given the importance of macrophages in immune responses to C. albicans infections, the increased capacity of C. albicans cells lacking Ypd1 to kill macrophages likely contributes to the enhanced virulence observed in a murine model of systemic infection.
The generation of fungal pathogen-specific drugs is hindered by the conservation of many potential drug-targets in the human host. Thus the complete absence of two-component related proteins in metazoans, but their presence in fungi, has rendered such pathways attractive drug-targets [22,44,45]. In S. cerevisiae, and the human fungal pathogen C. neoformans, loss of the two-component phosphorelay protein Ypd1 causes lethality due to the sustained activation of their respective SAPK pathways [20,21]. However, as reported during the course of this work [25], a major human fungal pathogen, C. albicans, can tolerate sustained activation of the Hog1 SAPK pathway triggered by loss of Ypd1. We have significantly advanced our understanding of this observation in three main ways. Firstly we find that the constitutive activation of Hog1 in cells lacking YPD1 is mediated through two-component mediated regulation of the Ssk1 response regulator, and that the pleiotropic phenotypes associated with Ypd1 loss are dependent on Ssk1-mediated Hog1 activation. Secondly, we have provided novel insight into the mechanisms by which C. albicans survives and adapts to sustained SAPK activation. Thirdly, we show that inactivation of YPD1 promotes, rather than reduces, the virulence of C. albicans, and we provide evidence to suggest that this is mediated at least in part through effects on fungus-phagocyte interactions. A model summarising the major findings from this work is depicted in Fig 8. One question raised by this study is why is sustained SAPK activation tolerated in some fungi but not others? In S. cerevisiae, prolonged SAPK activation is reported to lead to cell death by causing an increase in reactive oxygen species (ROS) thus triggering apoptosis [12]. Although we do not know whether sustained Hog1 activation triggers an increase in intracellular ROS in C. albicans, it is worth noting that C. albicans is considerably more resistant to oxidative stress than S. cerevisiae [46]. In C. neoformans, lethality due to Hog1 hyperactivation is attributed to the over-accumulation of intracellular glycerol [47]. In C. albicans, sustained Hog1 activation in ypd1Δ cells also triggers an increase in intracellular glycerol levels, presumably contributing to the associated swollen cell phenotype. Interestingly, this is tolerated in these mutant cells and indeed it is noteworthy that C. albicans can withstand higher levels of osmotic stress (which triggers glycerol biosynthesis) than many other fungal species [46]. However, perhaps a key factor in maintaining the viability of ypd1Δ cells, is the significant induction of the tyrosine phosphatase encoding genes PTP2 and PTP3 which negatively regulate Hog1 phosphorylation [35]. Interestingly, the lethality associated with ypd1Δ-mediated sustained Hog1 activation in S. cerevisiae can be by-passed by artificial over-expression of either PTP2 or PTP3 [31,32], suggesting that C. albicans actually adopts this strategy to prevent catastrophic levels of Hog1 activation. Consistent with this hypothesis is the observation that treatment of C. albicans ypd1Δ cells with the tyrosine phosphatase inhibitor, arsenite, triggers a significant increase in levels of Hog1 phosphorylation and cell death. Furthermore, deletion of PTP3 together with deletion of one copy of PTP2, triggers dramatic increases in the level of phosphorylated Hog1 in tetO-YPD1 cells and furthermore, virtually abolishes cell growth following doxycycline-mediated repression of YPD1. It is not clear why we could not generate tetO-YPD1 cells lacking both PTP3 and PTP2, as a double ptp3Δ ptp2Δ mutant has previously been characterised [35], although it is possible that basal YPD1 expression levels are altered in the tetO-YPD1 background. Notably, however, we find that the basal level of expression of PTP2 plays a major role in preventing Hog1 activation under non-stress conditions, as significant increases in the levels of Hog1 phosphorylation are seen upon deleting one copy of PTP2. Similar findings have been reported in both S. cerevisiae and C. neoformans where basal levels of Hog1 are significantly increased in ptp2Δ mutant cells [31,34]. Taken together, the data presented in this paper strongly support the model that induction of PTP3 and PTP2 expression, together with the basal expression of PTP2, allow C. albicans to survive loss of the Ypd1 phosphorelay protein. The viability of C. albicans cells lacking Ypd1 has allowed an investigation of how fungal cells adapt to long-term sustained SAPK activation. Remarkably, we find that cells evoke a mechanism that prevents the long-term constitutive phosphorylation of Hog1. Moreover, this decrease in Hog1 phosphorylation is actually accompanied by a reduction in the levels of PTP2 and PTP3, the negative regulators of Hog1, raising the possibility that an upstream signalling branch to Hog1 is inhibited instead. Furthermore, this mechanism is reversible as it can be over-ridden following a transient exposure to stress that requires Hog1 activity. Do these observations that C. albicans can survive and adapt to sustained SAPK activation have physiological relevance? As a human commensal, this fungal pathogen is continuously exposed to host-imposed stresses. Indeed, Hog1 is vital for C. albicans to exist commensally in the gut [11], cause systemic infections [8,10], and survive phagocytosis [9]. Thus, the ability of this pathogen to adapt to sustained SAPK activation by actively modulating Hog1 phosphorylation levels may be important to promote survival in certain host niches that continuously generate a stressful environment. Furthermore, we propose that the capacity of C. albicans to restore levels of SAPK phosphorylation, upon subsequent exposure to conditions that require Hog1-mediated stress responses, underpins the flexibility needed to allow adaptation of C. albicans to the range of environments encountered within the host [48]. Interestingly, long-term SAPK activation can be tolerated in other organisms. For example, in some human cell types sustained SAPK activation promotes either cell survival [49] or cellular differentiation [50], rather than apoptosis. However, whether similar mechanisms are evoked in humans and C. albicans, to adapt to sustained SAPK activation is unknown. The main findings reported here in this paper focused on cells in which HOG1 is expressed from its native chromosomal locus. However, during the course of this work we noted that the cellular response of C. albicans to YPD1 loss differed depending on whether the HOG1 gene was present at its native locus, or re-integrated at the RPS10 locus in hog1Δ ypd1Δ+HOG1 cells. In both instances, cells adapted to long term SAPK activation by reducing the levels of phosphorylated Hog1 (S5A and S5B Fig). However, when HOG1 was reintegrated at the RPS10 locus, this was also accompanied by a reduction in HOG1 mRNA levels (S5C Fig). Consistent with the decrease in Hog1 levels, hog1Δ ypd1Δ+HOG1 cells changed dramatically over time to phenocopy hog1Δ cells (S5D Fig). These results contrast significantly with those from ypd1Δ cells when HOG1 is expressed from its normal locus where the cells change over time to phenocopy wild type cells (compare Fig 5 and S5 Fig). Indeed, the ypd1Δ-dependent down-regulation of HOG1 located at the RPS10 locus was independent of HOG1 promoter and terminator sequences (S5E Fig), suggesting that this is a genome position-effect rather than a gene-specific phenomenon. Insertion of genes at the RPS10 locus has been employed by numerous labs to successfully generate re-integrant strains [51,52]. Significantly, the present study has highlighted the importance of studying a gene at its native chromosomal locus when investigating the role and/or regulation of the gene. Two-component proteins represent attractive antifungal targets as these signal transduction proteins are absent in metazoans [22,44,45]. Indeed, deletion of any one of the three C. albicans histidine kinases, or the Ssk1 response regulator, attenuate virulence in mouse systemic infection models. Furthermore, the Ypd1 phosphorelay protein has generated significant interest as an antifungal target, due to the lethality associated with its deletion in both S. cerevisiae and the human fungal pathogen C. neoformans [20,21]. However, in this study we report that inhibition of YPD1 expression during infection actually increases the virulence of C. albicans in two distinct infection models; a C. elegans pathogenesis model [40] and a murine model of systemic candidiasis [41,42]. Histology images from murine kidneys show that, similar to that seen in vitro, repression of YPD1 during infection results in clusters of highly filamentous cells. Enhanced filamentation in vivo has previously been shown to increase virulence [39], and thus the increased virulence associated with YPD1 loss in vivo may be due to the formation of clusters of hyper-filamentous cells. Moreover, we show that drug mediated inhibition of YPD1 expression increases the efficacy by which C. albicans can kill macrophages. This is likely related to the observation that Ypd1 loss also results in increased filamentation within this infection model, as hyphae formation within the macrophage promotes C. albicans-mediated killing of macrophages by triggering pyroptosis [53], and by mechanically rupturing the macrophage cell membrane [54]. The molecular basis underlying the increased virulence seen upon repressing YPD1 expression is unknown, but given that Hog1 is essential for C. albicans virulence in several infection models [8–11], it is possible that the concomitant increases in Hog1 activity as a consequence of Ypd1 loss promotes C. albicans survival in the host (Fig 8). It is important to note here that the filamentous phenotype exhibited by cells lacking Ypd1 is due to the concomitant sustained Hog1 activation. To explore whether the enhanced virulence seen upon Ypd1 loss was dependent on Hog1, we compared the virulence of wild-type, hog1Δ and hog1Δ ypd1Δ C. albicans cells in the three day murine infection model described above. Although it was not feasible to analyse ypd1Δ cells in this model due to the highly flocculent nature of this strain, hog1Δ and hog1Δ ypd1Δ cells demonstrated equally impaired virulence in the three-day murine systemic infection model (S1 Table). Thus the impaired virulence exhibited by hog1Δ cells is not improved upon deletion of YPD1 and, therefore, is consistent with the hypothesis that the enhanced virulence observed upon loss of YPD1 may be dependent on the concurrent increased activation of the Hog1 SAPK to promote fungal stress resistance and/or filamentation. Importantly, the data presented here illustrating that Ypd1 loss potentiates C. albicans virulence, indicates that antifungals administered to treat C. albicans infections that target Ypd1 have the potential to actually enhance the virulence of this major pathogen. It is also noteworthy that SAPKs are important for the virulence of other human and plant fungal pathogens [55]. Consequently, any compound capable of inhibiting two-component signalling that leads to SAPK activation, may promote the survival of other fungal pathogens when encountering host-imposed stresses. Thus, in conclusion, our findings question the validity of the Ypd1 protein as a broad-spectrum antifungal target. Indeed, the significant differences in stress-signalling outputs between S. cerevisiae and C. albicans, underscores the importance of directly studying predicted ‘essential’ genes in pathogenic fungi, rather than in model yeast.
All the C. albicans strains used in this study are listed in Table 1. Cells were grown at 30°C in YPD rich medium [56]. Addition of 20μg/ml doxycycline was used to repress expression from the tetO promoter. The strains used in this study are listed in Table 1, and oligonucleotides used for their construction are listed in S2 Table. Glycerol concentrations were determined using The Free Glycerol Determination Kit (Sigma-Aldrich), following the manufacturer’s instructions. Three independent biological replicates were performed. Protein extracts were prepared from mid-exponential phase cells and phosphorylated Hog1 was detected by western blot analysis with an anti-phospho-p38 antibody (New England Biolabs) as described previously [6]. Blots were stripped and total levels of Hog1 were determined by probing with an anti-Hog1 antibody (Santa Cruz Biotechnology), and in some cases protein loading determined using an anti-tubulin antibody (DSHB, University of Iowa). RNA preparation and Northern blot analyses were performed as described previously [6]. Gene-specific probes were amplified by PCR from genomic DNA using oligonucleotide primers specific for YPD1, GPD2, RHR2, PTP2, PTP3, HOG1 and ACT1 (S1 Table). C. albicans strains were grown at 30°C to exponential phase and then 10 fold serial dilutions were spotted onto YPD plates containing the indicated compounds. Plates were incubated at 30°C for 24 h. Differential interference contrast images were captured using a Zeiss Axioscope microscope as described previously [6]. All animal experiments were conducted in compliance with United Kingdom Home Office licenses for research on animals (project license number PPL 60/4135), and were approved by the University of Aberdeen Animal Welfare and Ethical Review Body (AWERB). Animal experiments were minimised, and all animal experimentation was performed using approaches that minimised animal suffering and maximised our concordance with the 3Rs.
As fungi-attributed human deaths are increasing, there is an urgent need to develop new antifungal treatments. Two-component related proteins, such as the Ypd1 phosphorelay protein, have been heralded as antifungal targets as they are not found in humans and because inactivation of YPD1 in several different fungi causes sustained SAPK activation and cell death. However, we have discovered that inactivation of YPD1 in the major human pathogen, Candida albicans, actually enhances virulence. Furthermore, we reveal that this fungus adapts to the sustained activation of the Hog1 SAPK triggered by Ypd1 loss by mounting distinct mechanisms that actively reduce the level of phosphorylated Hog1. These findings question the validity of Ypd1 proteins as broad-spectrum antifungal targets and provide insights into the cellular adaptation to sustained SAPK activation.
blood cells
phosphorylation
medicine and health sciences
immune cells
pathology and laboratory medicine
pathogens
animal models of disease
immunology
microbiology
animal models
fungi
model organisms
experimental organism systems
kidneys
fungal pathogens
research and analysis methods
saccharomyces
animal models of infection
mycology
white blood cells
animal cells
proteins
medical microbiology
animal studies
microbial pathogens
mouse models
yeast
biochemistry
candida
cell biology
post-translational modification
anatomy
biology and life sciences
yeast and fungal models
cellular types
macrophages
saccharomyces cerevisiae
renal system
organisms
candida albicans
Blocking two-component signalling enhances Candida albicans virulence and reveals adaptive mechanisms that counteract sustained SAPK activation