I'm swithering between scoring this as a 2.5 or a 3. It took a long time for me to remotely care about any of the characters. I found Lucy to be very draining, very quickly. She felt too two dimensional to me. I enjoyed Ed's POV much more but knowing his mind took away the elements of surprise. On a positive note, I thought the book had great pacing for being set over a 24 hour time period.