What I Liked: Jennifer E. Smith's writing is inherently readable - I finished this book in a little less than a day. I liked remembering what it felt like to be on the cusp of something huge and major in my life, and it definitely brought back all of the emotions of that time for me. I enjoyed Aidan's character a lot, and loved his hope and optimism for the future. I also enjoyed the scavenger hunt of going back through all of the special places that held memories for their relationship. 
 What I Wanted: I wanted Claire to let go of the logic a little bit, and *feel* a bit more. Nearly all of the book was just so unbelievably depressing; it was hard to keep going at times! However, this being said - I'm all for letting your heart rule your head at times, but I could have done without the overwhelming amount of the more sentimental statements. (Just saying.) 
 Recommended to: Fans of YA coming of age stories, the in between from high school to college