3.5 actually. I still like the first book the best so far. I really didn't like that Nora had no memories of what happened in the first two books. It made certain things seem repetitive, because as a reader I already knew some of the things that Nora was figuring out along the way while she was trying to fill in the gaps of her life. I still enjoyed this, but I think it's the weakest out of all the books so far. I'm looking forward to reading about the impending war in the next book. And hopefully Nora and Patch get some decent time together, because their relationship sort of lacked in this book and the last. I'm keeping my finger crossed.