4 Stars - Because scarlet deserves it & I liked the flow of the book as a whole even if the romance doesn't seem plausible. 
 The book was very good. Not great and earth shattering as it could have been. It is meant to be a romance like to original with a good thieving twist. It was very obvious the plot twists but very well played out that I can forgive that. 
 I must outline how much I love scarlet's character. She is feisty & strong always ready to take the blow pointed at others and rarely even complains about it. 
 What I disliked was, this is a romance between robin and scarlet, but they rarely ever talk or have anything but angry swooning over each other. Oh, and robin is a jackass throughout the whole book. Not a recipe for a perfect romance.