I'd actually give NOGGIN 4 1/2 stars if I could. The only thing that detracted was that I just found his response to his girlfriend and what he was so SURE would happen (being vague to avoid spoilers) to be unbelievable, given the situation. But the voice was fantastic, the premise is fascinating and the plot was fast-paced without racing through the story. I laughed and cried-- a really great read and I'd recommend it to anyone who reads YA.