Really a 3.5/5 stars 
 I LOVED My Life Next Door, so I went into WITWT with high expectations.I enjoyed reading about Gwen's family and her time with Mrs.E, however, I really didn't enjoy the romance part of this novel, unlike My Life Next Door. I just wasn't a fan of Cass, and I found his chemistry with Gwen a bit confusing at times. I also found the book to be a bit slow.