Originally Posted On The Sassy Book Geek 
 **** Big thank you to Margaret K. McElderry Books for sending me an ARC in exchange for an honest review**** 
 I was almost positive I would adore this book because the cover is so gorgeous and the synopsis sounds amazing, however, that really wasn't the case and I couldn't be more saddened by it. I can't tell if I'm more disappointed with myself for not liking it as much, the book for not living up to my expectations, or just a bit of both which I'm sure it is. 
 Plot 
 My biggest problem with this book was that it had pretty slow pacing and the overall storyline was very....vague. I spent a lot of time wondering what exactly the main plot was or what was even supposed to happen, there was also never any sort of climax in the story either. Nothing was ever really explained and I felt that I was supposed to already know what was going on before I started reading. I spent a lot of time confused and bored. 
 On top of that there was virtually no world building whatsoever and we are in some type of fantasy world with the Beast and soul eaters with some type of magic but none of it is ever fleshed out our further developed. Everything is just sort of .......there. Which is very unfortunate since this world had a lot of potential but it fell completely short. I would have at least liked to know more about the Beast and what it is or how the soul eaters become what they are....but no. 
 I can't explain what kept me reading but some parts of the story were interesting and the atmosphere was eerie and mysterious (the only reasons this is getting 2.5 stars instead of 1), it's just that overall I honestly couldn't tell you what the story was even about. 
 The Characters 
 The characters were a little better than the plot, more developed and I cared more about them than the story but they STILL fell flat for me. When something tragic happened to a character I felt a little sad maybe but overall I didn't much care either way. 
 Alys was an alright heroine she was curious, clever, and cared a lot about the well being of others. Other than that though she wasn't a very memorable protagonist just as many of the characters weren't memorable either. 
 The Romance 
 At first I thought for sure there would be no romance in this story and there did end up being some, just when I thought the plot couldn't get more tedious. Alys meets a boy that travels with other characters she knows and ends up falling in insta-love with him and vice versa. Overall it was an extremely pointless romance and become a big focus at the end of the book and I felt nothing for it because it was so underdeveloped. 
 In Conclusion 
 I was extremely disappointed with this book since I thought it had such wonderful potential but ultimately fell very short. Honestly though I found it to be quite a mess. 
 What I Liked: 
 -Alys and a handful of characters 
 -The story was interesting in certain bits 
 -The atmosphere was mysterious and eerie at parts 
 What I Didn't Like: 
 -The plot was confusing and messy 
 -No clue what was going on at all whatsoever 
 -Lack of world building 
 -Slow pacing 
 -Pointless romance with insta-love 
 Recommend 
 Sorry but I just can't recommend this one especially if you're thinking this will be a dark, action packed book. It's slow and confusing and there's no world building at all, just those things right there are enough for me not to recommend this book.