I enjoyed Pucked Up. It was funny and sweet and had a lot of good aspects to it. I loved all of the characters, just as much as I did in Pucked, and really liked getting to know Buck more. The only thing that bothered me, and continued to bother me throughout the entire book, was that I really didn't feel like Sunny was mature enough for a serious relationship with Buck. She is a sweet girl and a very likeable character, but the match up just seemed off due to her (age appropriate) immaturity. She was so young and it really showed. 
 The other thing that was off for me was the big moment when everything went to shit. It seemed so blown out of proportion when everyone, especially Alex, overreacted about what happened when it truly wasn't as horrible as it was made out to be. The good that came from that though is how Violet handled it. That was such a great part of the book. 
 Overall, I give Pucked Up 3.5 stars. I liked reading it and read it in one day. I'm looking forward to reading Pucked Over next. I didn't care for Lily for most of this book but she totally redeemed herself in my eyes and made me like her. Randy is awesome. He seems like a great guy. I can't wait to see Randy and Lily together. I hope her douchey ex and Sunny's douchey ex both get their asses kicked in the next book. I'm so disappointed that didn't happen in this book.