I love Jay Asher's "Thirteen Reasons Why." It was so well written and literally brought tears to my eyes. So I guess I was expecting a little more from this book. I love the idea. It's interesting and unique, so I thought it would be a winner. Unfortunately, certain parts of it just fell flat for me. Mainly, the character Emma. She just didn't click for me. She came off as ridiculously shallow, reckless, self-obsorbed...it just didn't work. I like Josh's character (courtesy of Jay Asher) but Emma honestly just ruined the book for me. It was still well written and the premise was awesome, so I'm giving it 3/5. Still worth a read but not a purchase.