I'm giving those 4 stars for Patch! I'm ready to read the second, third, and fourth just for him. The story is good, I didn't get bored reading it, I enjoyed a lot of parts, tho I have to say I wish to change few things about Nora's way of acting, I mean who does those stuff? I felt like she was 12 more than 16, but Patch made it better, he was the highlight of it!