After reading lots of reviews, I was expecting to hate this book. I have to admit, I didn't hate it as much as Gone Girl. The characters were all awful in their own ways, but there was a certain amount of redemption at the end. It kept me guessing about whodunnit, but I kind of wished there had been 1 "good" character. Cathy I suppose could fill that role, but she was so 1-dimensional it's hard to call her a good guy.