To be honest, I'm still debating between 3 and 4 stars for this. I love the new take on the Robin Hood idea, and I like most of the characters. I like Scarlet herself, and how she is assertive and refuses to take crap from the boys, calling them out when necessary. I felt like she was sometimes a little too perfect in terms of her combat skills, but other than that, I felt like she was a pretty well-rounded character. Everyone is a bit moody, but this is YA, so I get that. The love triangle bugged me a bit, but I appreciated that the class roles involved were part of the reason behind it, so at lest there was a bit of a reason to the indecision. The villain was a bit one-note, as well. 
 But, I liked most things, I liked the writing, I liked the characters, I liked the voice. So, while there were some things that bugged me a bit or could have used more depth, I definitely enjoyed the book, and will probably check out the next one.