Actual rating: 3.5 
 I fell in love with Morgan Matson after reading Since You've Been Gone. This was her first book, and while it was a solid debut novel, I didn't devour it like I did with her other two. Amy was an okay heroine. She's very stubborn about holding onto her guilt, but it was nice to see her let it go. I appreciated that the romance was pretty believable. 
 What I didn't like was that Amy only got like 15 minutes to talk to her brother, and there were years worth of things to say that would have helped them both out. And the ending. It just... ended. I flipped to the next page and thought for sure I was missing something, and turned it back to make sure it was over. I wanted see Amy talk to her mother, and have them both learn about each other and how they'd been feeling. 
 I just had wished for a bit more from the ending, mostly. The supporting cast of characters were wonderful, and all helped Amy on her journey in some way. 
 I would recommend this book, but highly recommend you pick up the other two as well, I thought they were better.