I thought this was an YA at first, and I think I can be forgiven for this error, since the main character behaves so much like a rebellious teenager. I didn't like it, even as a light read. I found Rebekkah self-centered and too willful, and Byron was a complete doormat. I found the actions of the characters unbelievable, and there were insufficient explanations as to what was going on. The mystery behind the town; the entire reason for the existence behind the characters of the Undertaker and the Graveminder were poorly explained, also. I expected more about Mr. Charlie and the mystery of the town that lies underneath since the author built up to it. I was disappointed at the loose ends and the poor plot lines.