3.5... Maybe 4/5 stars, but it'll probably stay at 3.5 
 Review after I sleep on it! 
 So I slept on it, and I think I'd still give this a 3.5/5 stars. 
 It would've been a 4 if the beginning didn't drag on for SO FREAKING LONG. Like yes Feyre, I know you want to run. Yes Feyre, I know you want to keep your promise to your mother. But no, Feyre, no matter who you fucking ask, they will say you can't. (view spoiler)[ And I can't believe how she automatically believed that Suriel so quickly. For the WHOLE time before that she believed that faeries couldn't lie and she had SUCH a hard time believing Tamlin and Lucien and SHE AUTOMATICALLY believed the Suriel. Yes, even though the Suriel are to tell you everything you want to know, I'm still astounded by how little doubt she had in that fae. (hide spoiler)] I swear we went through so many loops with her hating, disbelieving, pitying, liking, AND REPEAT. Way too many times for almost half of the book. 
 But then, when you get past that, I started to really like it. I think it became more intriguing at the halfway point (view spoiler)[with the whole Fire Night and Rhysand showing up (hide spoiler)] and from that point on, I was hooked. 
 (view spoiler)[Just another few points though: 
 - THAT RIDDLE THOUGH. It was SO easy to figure out. I mean, Armarantha said "The answer is lovely." LOVELY. 
 - Then Tamlin was just weird since he was by Armarantha's side... Well I already doubted his love for Feyre ever since he said "you're exactly how I dreamt you'd be" 
 - And I can see how people thought this was insta-love but they skipped quite a few weeks in between, as noted when Feyre recalled eating this berry that Lucien said would be fine and ended up with hours of hallucinations 
 (hide spoiler)] 
 My bias is Rhysand though.