Tin Star was the best-seller in our (my) BN gay fiction section for something like 6 months, so I figured I should check it out. Well, months after starting it, and after having left it on the floor where the cat knocked it from off the table for almost as long (yeah, I'm kind of a slob), I've decided to admit defeat. 
 This book is just meh. Boring. Silly. It's the kind of book where the main characters fall for each other after like 5 seconds and for no reason other than "We're both gay! Must be love!" 
 So if this book starts flying off the shelves again, I will dutifully order it in, but I will never understand why. Maybe if it were pirates instead of cowboys....