The first half of this book, I'd honestly rate at a 3.5. The second half is what redeemed it for me. At first, I thought that I didn't like the different POV formats, the tape recording transcripts, the journal, etc. But, what I realized was that I really just hated Barbara She was literally the worst person. As the story went on, I had a gut feeling of what would happen, and I ended up being right. I knew from the start that (view spoiler)[ Sandy knew what had happened to the baby. But, I also had a feeling that it wasn't hers. When the part came that Hannah said she wanted to wait until marriage to have sex, I immediately knew that she was the mother. At this point, I put my book down and legitimately said to my husband, "Oh my God. Justin is the F-ing Father!!!!" And....that scumbag was. (hide spoiler)] This book was so good. You want to know about these characters. Is he really a bad guy or is he just awkward? Is she the mother, or isn't she? What happened to the baby?? Is this all somehow connected to the death 20 years previously??? I definitely recommend this book!