Torn between 2.5 and 3 stars because I thought the way in which the "two paths" where done was quite confusing and didn't flow naturally. At first I thought it was a look into the future to see what would've happened on each date and then I thought she was imagining both to see where her mind was at but when I realised what was actually happening and it was combining both nights, the events of each, didn't gel all that well for me. 
 The characters were all fine, apart from her brother, never got to understand why he had a stick up his ass other than alcohol but he was a dick before he drank as well so? The romance element was cute and I liked the overall narrative style so i'd definitely read future books by the author, just a shame that the concept while interesting, didn't come across as nicely executed as I was hoping for.