Read more reviews at my blog, Words and Tea Bottles. 
 I will admit that it's been years since I've read the first book in this series, and it probably would've helped to pick that up and reread it before reading Supernaturally, because it took me a bit to remember everything that had happened and get back into the world. I won't blame the book for that; it's my fault. As with the first book, Supernaturally presents and incredibly interesting mythology and take on the supernatural creatures you know and love (and even some you might not know about, such as the fossegrim that attacks Evie in the lake). Although it is kind of annoying when Evie starts making fun of people who go by the traditional views of vampires, such as when her English class is reading Dracula and she complains about how inaccurate it is. They don't know any better, so what do you have to complain about? 
 Beyond the mythology, though, this book is just okay. There are definitely times in which the narration is very, very clever, because Evie is a pretty clever girl, despite being naive. And the ending was one I expected as far as her learning to do a certain thing, but it wasn't in the way I had expected so that was good. But it wasn't a book that made me reluctant to put it down most of the time. (view spoiler)[Jack ending up being somewhat of a bad guy didn't surprise me, (hide spoiler)] although there could have been more lead-up to it. There are plenty of hints, but they're ones you can dismiss pretty easily. Not enough foreshadowing, I guess. And the plot doesn't really seem to revolve around what was hinted in the summary. In fact, because (view spoiler)[Jack ended up being the bad guy (hide spoiler)], you could say the summary doesn't really fit it at all. Yeah, the faeries are asses, and Reth is annoying, but they have very little part in anything. 
 Still, I'll be looking around for Endlessly so I can finish up the series and see how things go. Happy reading!