3.5, I think. I absolutely adore Loliver, both together and as individual characters, and their chemistry and resulting sexual tension is utter perfection.... but I think Dirty Rowdy Thing still reigns supreme in the Wild Seasons world for me. The first 60% of this book was fantastic, but as soon as things started to fall apart, I got supremely lost, and I wasn't understanding a lot of what was going on. I'm not sure if the repetitive conversations between Lola and Oliver was due to their personalities and nature of their relationship or if it was just not-great storytelling, but I found myself zoning out for a good long while, and that's not what I expect from CLo. They do deliver sweet characters with explosive chemistry and super hot sex, but the story wasn't exactly what I wanted. I did appreciate the look into Lola's creative process as well as her struggles with the Razor Fish movie and fight against sexism in her experience with Hollywood so that gave the overall plot some direction. Overall, I still love Loliver, I still love Wild Seasons, I still love CLo; Dark Wild Night just isn't my favorite.