Overall 3.5 for me. (view spoiler)[I enjoyed Dave's part better than Julia's. I didn't like her in the same way I didn't like Margo in Paper Towns. The whole time I was reading Dave's part I was rooting for them not to get together. I was team Gretchen all the way. I enjoyed the way the book ended, my only complaint is that Julia didn't take Brett up on his offer to go to prom with her. I'm still trying to process my thoughts on this book, but I enjoyed it overall. (hide spoiler)] It was laugh out loud funny at times, and I enjoyed the banter between Dave and Julia. It reminded me of Gilmore Girls.