The Sky Is Everywhere is a book about grief and while it does have its magical moments at times, it still was rather ordinary for me. The main crux of the story, I felt, was the love triangle and how Lennie is trying to cope with her sister's sudden death. While I did like the little poems scattered across the books as they gave us glimpses of the life Lennie shared with her sister, I didn't really feel a connect to that life. I didn't feel like I was part of Lennie's grief; like I was rather disconnected with the story. 
 The love triangle involves Lennie's sister's boyfriend (Toby) and a new guy named Joe. While I understand how Toby and Lennie got together and did what they did, I still find it difficult to reconcile with it. It's almost clear that Toby is on the rebound but I would have thought that Lennie would have been clear-headed enough to reject him. As for Joe, he felt very much like a token character and when he is hurt by Lennie due to part of his past, it felt unreal and that he was written in for the sake of making the story a little more interesting. 
 The Sky Is Everywhere is not a bad book. It's realistic and can be heartbreaking at times but overall, I think it could have been better.