This book was... ok, I guess. I don't know. When I first saw this book, I thought that it will be an very exciting adventure, but as it turns out, it really wasn't that exciting. I guess I have too much expectation for this book. And Lily's personality was completely different from what I have imagine. Plus, she wasn't the one who had the notebook idea, it was her brother. So I guess I was really disappointing with that fact. I think that maybe if I haven't had such an high expectation for it I would have gave it a higher rating, but since I do.... I guess this is it.