Oh, I like Puffin Island: friendly, nosy, mildly quirky people, beaches, and puffins! The book could have used more puffins actually. Although the island is named after them, there aren't many as they nearly died out. :( But the people were friendly, helpful, and always willing to lend a hand. I live in a small town and my neighbors aren't nearly so helpful. (But I do have good neighbors and after all these folks were fictional.) 
 Ryan and Emily are similar in some respects: Both have childhoods that placed too much responsibility on them and left them, though for different reasons, reluctant to take on having families of their own, a reluctance to have children, and a fear of getting emotionally close to someone. Ryan grew up on the island while Emily used to visit in the summers while at college but their paths never crossed. Emily's good friend from college, Brittany, has a cottage on the island and when Emily has a crisis, she goes there to stay. There's a problem though - Emily is terrified of water. She won't go to the beach or even sit looking towards the water. That's a problem on an island, especially one that's a favorite spot for tourists going to the beach and where kayaking is a major activity. My heart broke for her when we find out why she's so terrified and I applauded her when she determined it was time to work on ridding herself of her fear. 
 Emily is motivated by Lizzy, her six year old niece, who is now her responsibility. Lizzy's mother, an infamous film star and Emily's sister, died and left Emily as the guardian though the two sisters hadn't had contact in years and Emily and Lizzy had never met. Besides caring for Lizzy, Emily is also trying to protect her from reporters and paparazzi. Emily has closed off her feelings as they are too uncomfortable and messy and she doesn't want to get hurt again. She's petrified that she can't properly care for Lizzy while at the same time she doesn't want to care about her. She spends a lot of time feeling terrified and incompetent. 
 Into this mess comes Ryan. Ryan's a former war journalist who chose to change careers and now runs the marina and yacht club. He's also a friend of Brittany's and at her request checks in on Emily. He's immediately attracted to her and they spend the bulk of the book dancing around each other and dealing with coitus interruptus. There are several misunderstandings but happily Morgan doesn't milk them or draw them out; they're dealt with fairly quickly. The main stumbling block for both is opening up emotionally, and in Emily's case, learning to trust. 
 Emily and Ryan are good together even when Emily is pushing him away. He doesn't give up easily and he has a knack for knowing what Emily needs. He knows when to be assertive, when to back off, and, despite his claims to the contrary, is a nice man. The interactions are delightful and the friendships that Emily has and that she makes are strong, vibrant ones. The characters are fun to spend time with and I cared about everyone, wanted everyone to be happy and have their dreams come true. "First Time in Forever" was a quick read despite it's length and I enjoyed every minute I spent on Puffin Island.