Cute story. Short, but sweet. 
 Paul is called to the office of the new softball coach about tutoring some of the girls, only to find out the new coach is his betrayer from high school, also known as his jock ex-boyfriend, Trevor, the guy who broke his heart and sacrificed everything they had for Trevor's Major League Baseball dreams. Nine years later, Trevor's finally retired from the MLB, out, and asking Paul to forgive him. And Paul's not really interested in rekindling, until Trevor seduces him. And then Paul freezes up and shoots off his big mouth, like usual, and pains Trevor as much as he himself felt nine years earlier. Now Paul is rethinking what he might really want, but Trevor ran off after Paul's hurtful outburst. 
 Trevor was very apologetic and you can feel the push-pull between him and Paul as they gravitate toward each other. (Well, Paul's more like a magnet constantly flipping over, really.) Both understand why the other is/was the way he is/was, but there's a lot of damage to repair between them. Trevor pushes too hard because he's had more time to come to his conclusions, but the pain is fresh again to Paul, and he has trouble dealing with the betrayal of trust and the fear of being ripped apart again. It's a very touching story about second chances.