** spoiler alert ** 
 I don't know what to say about this book. 
 On one hand I was annoyed at Kate throughout most of the book for pushing herself to stay with Max although there were plenty of hints along the way for her to know hat Max isn't for her. 
 On the other hand I'm glad she finally realized it but it was towards the last ten pages of the book. Plus I wanted to see more of her and Liam. I was left hanging because I wanted more. 
 That's mostly why this got a 3 star from me. I like the lesson this book teaches you. It just was a little tedious to read about all her ways to get Max back and stay with her.