"Never judge a book by its cover" like we usually say... and I would add "by its success" too 
 When Dad offered me this book I was like : Oh no I didn't want to read it at all !!! pfff It must be really boring and the writing must be totally bad! Then I started reading it because I wanted to have my own opinion. 
 The first 100 pages were dreadful to me... I hated the writing, it was horrible. But I kept reading and I found out that I wasn't as terrible as I thought it will be. 
 For the writing, I find it too bad that it wasn't good because I would have like the story way better ! 
 As for the plot, we have already read stories like this one before but I find myself enjoying it pretty much! Obviously it was a little cheesy, but we have too admit that sometimes a little love story it's good to take ! :) 
 I adored the relationship between Penny and Noah and i loved the travel in NY, the way it is described and the favourite places of Noah in the city!