1,5 stars. 
 This book was not at all what I had expected. 
 I didn't feel connected with Tiger Lily for most part of the book, and I think that was because it was not written in her POV. 
 The entire book is written in Tinkerbell's POV, which was at times either very pleasant or very annoying. I missed being able to truely see what was going on in Tiger Lily's head, and for me that caused a distance between her character and myself. Only near the end of the book did I start to feel like I was getting a connection with her, because we get to see more of the feelings she hides from everyone around her. It was too bad that only started to happen for me while I was already at the last pages. 
 Besides this, I didn't like Peter Pan at all in this book. He wasn't the confident, care-lacking, risk-taking fellow you are used too. He was so.... unsteady? Yeah, I think that sums up how I feel about this Peter Pan. Throughout the book he constantly seems to be unsure of what he wants, which I found annoying. He loves Tiger Lily, but he is also afraid of her and the feelings he has for her, and I didn't really get why until it gets explained at the last two pages of the book. Perhaps that is a part of the mystery of this book, but it truely did annoy me. 
 He just seems to change moods constantly, like he is happy now, and distant a minute later. Or he gets angry at some of the lost boys, only to come back a second later to apologize. 
 Also, and this might be a spoiler so... ((view spoiler)[ Why the hell do the pirates age?! Yes, I know it sort of gets explained why, but it's lame. They don't age in the original story, so what was the point of them aging in this retelling? It only results in Hook getting to envy Peters youth, thus making Hook hate Peter even more, but it felt quite unnecessary to me. This was not needed in the original story, and it didn't feel needed in this book, except to make Hook more grumpy and angry at Peter. (hide spoiler)]) 
 I don't know... I think this book could've appealed to me more if the POV had been Tiger Lily's, instead of Tink's. It's not like I didn't like Tink's POV, but I felt like it didn't work for me a lot of times during the reading of this book. 
 I'm quite sad this book didn't work out for me, as I am a big fan of Peter Pan, and I read a lot of good things about it. This just shows how we can all differ from opinions, although I'm sad I didn't like it as much as most people did.