This one is hard to rate. I really enjoyed the story and it was so hard to put down at times, but I am not overly in love with this book. 
 I liked Violet much more than I like Finch. That doesn't necessarily mean that I didn't like Finch (I did, a lot) I just didn't find him to be realistic. His character seemed off and I couldn't connect with him, even when I was reading his point of view. I enjoyed some of his gestures towards Violet but that's it. I didn't get excited for anything and felt neutral throughout the entire books. 
 Still, a nice contemporary. 
 Also, I didn't cry and I'm someone who is SUPER emotional when reading so this goes to prove how disconnected I was with these characters.