How do you rate a story you have already read and rated? 
 I get that there is a new "retellings from the lover's perspective" fad in YA... but I must say I'm missing the point. Nothing new was added to the story. No dramatic irony, no unreleased information (except for Girl Scout cookies and exclusive fights. Fun.) It got me bored over a book I was RAVING about earlier. 
 What we got here was a peek into Rhiannon ...and I liked her way more at a distance when we had A's rose coloured glasses on. Her insecurity was sad and luring in Every Day - you want to help get her in a good place. There was a goal. A purpose. But it's too much on every single page. I liked not knowing how close-minded she was capable of being and how warped her excuses for her shitty boyfriend got. We did see more of Justin ...but he is a horrible character. So this isn't a good thing. Rhiannon refuses to acknowledge they have any problems. She had no aim - therefore the story had no goal - therefore no plot. 
 A is definitely the main character of this story and always will be. Any other perspective losses the magic and wonder that made it special. 
 So while I like the premise, everything I enjoyed here came perfectly fine (and way better) in Every Day. If you are like me and don't reread books, then save your money. Don't bother. Or just reread Every Day. It will be far more fun, I promise.