I enjoyed My Best Friend, Maybe so much! I really liked the friendship between Colette and Sadie, and how complicated things were for them. The entire book, I was wondering what drove these two girls apart, and I liked that it slowly unraveled over the course of the book. I really liked how it came together, and I was surprised (in a good way!) by the secret that Sadie kept. I liked that we slowly learned Sadie's side of the story. 
 I will say that I didn't quite understand Mark (Colette's ex-boyfriend) and his issues with Sadie, and why he doesn't want Colette to be around Sadie. Other than Sadie not being a part of the church youth group and no longer being friends with Colette, I'm not really sure where his feeling are coming from. It did become grating after a little bit. While Mark's feeling did get slightly irritating, I found myself confused- and then angry- at why Colette's mom didn't like Sadie and why she didn't want Colette to go on a vacation with Sadie. 
 I really liked how Sadie and Colette were trying to figure things out after several years, and that maybe they could be friends, but not best friends. Everything really is a big misunderstanding- Sadie thought Colette knew but Colette didn't because Sadie never told her. I'm glad they finally figured out what went wrong and it's such a complex, layered look at friendship. 
 Let's Rate It: My Best Friend, Maybe is such a great story about friendship! I liked how complicated things were between Sadie and Colette and how Colette was there for Sadie because she promised she would be, no matter what. There are some really great moments between the two girls. I feel like a tough issue was handled really well and very realistically, and I liked that Colette was never sure of her decisions. And that she started to question everything. My Best Friend, Maybe gets 4 stars.