4.5 actually. This was a really cute story. I was somewhat annoyed with Charlie for the way she felt she had to keep it a secret that she wore makeup from her family, and that she liked sports from her new friends. I was expecting there to be more romace between Charlie and Braden then there was, but everything worked out in the end, so I really can't complain too much. This was a nice quick read and I'm glad I picked it up