I don't have that much to say about this one since it was fairly basic. But I enjoyed all the characters, even if I did find the acceptance of Peysho/Kio a bit odd and I liked the developing relationship between Scarlet and Liall. I was glad this was less focused on romance than I originally thought and more about characterization. I also enjoyed all the allusions to Little Red Riding Hood. Some were especially clever. (view spoiler)[I especially liked that they did not require physical intimacy to show their genuine affection. A huge change for this style of books. (hide spoiler)] There were quite a few typos and the plot wasn't that involving, especially since it just barely begins by the time the story ends so I can't give it anything higher than average. But I had fun and look forward to the sequel.