I really agonized on how to rate this book. I finished it at almost 2AM last night, woke up and have fought with myself about how to rate it. In the end I'm going 3 Stars and I think that is being generous, mostly because I don't want to be a complete bitch about a book. Again. 
 On the one hand I couldn't put it down and I was VERY invested. 
 On every other hand (in the universe) it drove me absolute coo coo for cocoa puffs. The grammar and editing was VERY bad, the plot and characters went round and round and round and round and OMG I just wanted to shoot myself or Lea or Grace or Shane. Repeatedly. 
 I read a book recently that was two books written into one and THAT drove me crazy. By the same vein, Fall for Grace and Saving Grace were ONE book - right down to the splitting LoTR into three movies style non-ending of the first book - divided into two and the only reason I can think of is because the author couldn't figure out a way to stretch the story even further without having to actually utilize a plot so she could make it a trilogy. 
 But my real problems were all spoilery.... 
 First, THE WAITING!!! (view spoiler)[Waiting for them to talk. Waiting for them to quit jumping to conclusions about each other. But most of all the waiting for them to finally have sex. If it wasn't one thing it was a damn 'nother. The sex wait was about a book too long in my opinion. It was insane, and then when it finally DID happen -- WAYYYY PAST TO LATE, it was glossed over and it wasn't really a sexual payoff AT ALL. Totally infuriating. (hide spoiler)] 
 Then, THE SECRETS!!! (view spoiler)[Ok, so I was OK with Shane being Shamsiel and not revealing it until Lea told him when Grace was in a coma & then him making a deal with Michael to save her life. That worked. What didn't work is finding out at the end of this second book that he didn't get his Shamsiel soul ripped out of Shane like we all & Grace thought, but STILL had all of those memories and thoughts and still played this merry go round game with Grace threw the entire book only to reveal at the end that he was still very much Shamsiel and was still just NOT TELLING HER THE TRUTH OR EVEN HOW HE FELT AT ALL. It totally ruined whatever buildup I had been working on throughout the book/books. Of course, Grace didn't tell him crap either. It was beyond infuriating. But finding out that he basically just wasn't talking to her until the big conclusion so the author could have her moment on stage... I thought my head was going to explode. (hide spoiler)] 
 And of course, THE BATSHIT!!! (view spoiler)[You've lived for 2000 years, Grace? Really? I felt your pain to an extent in the first book. As the whining drug on and on and on I was like, you know what, put your big girl panties on and ACT LIKE YOU'VE SEEN A THING OR TWO GAZILLION! And Lea. Geez if she wasn't a Mary Sue of a best friend I don't know what is. AND SHANE: TALK TO THE GIRL ALREADY!!! And those friends of his, especially Tucker - you are kidding me right? Also, I have NEVER read a book where the characters drank the way these characters did. Like 18 year old frat kids, every last one of them. They didn't just drink, they were constantly drunk. It was very disgusting. (hide spoiler)] 
 I have rage issues with this book. I have a lot of rage toward a lot of books lately. I have just had it with these same games. 
 I will say that this book/books had plenty of steam, but repetitive and uncreative. The dialogue could be snappy and witty, but at times it felt like too much. The characters weren't fleshed out, none of them felt like real people. BUT I couldn't stop turning pages hoping and praying that some kind of huge payoff would come. The basis of the plot had so much potential and I felt like it just drifted away with all of the mind games. 
 And Grace should have been a character, that if written correctly - like On Dublin Street's Jocelyn - could have come across as tragically broken but redemptive. Grace should have been more than that because she should have also been wise. But no. And Shane... Oh Shane. You had so much book boyfriend potential, but you refused to talk when you should have and continued to play games. It whittled away at your hotness and just made you an asshole. 
 Yeah. Lots of rage. 
 If I keep on I'm going to take away another star and then I'd really feel like a bitch because so many people loved this book. So I'm stopping.