Arg. I don't know what's wrong with me. Second Kasie book in a row to only get two stars from me, even though I adore Distance and On the Fence. I think the problem with PSILY is I never connected to Lily's voice. She seemed inconsistent to me, as did the boy. They really were horrible to one another, and although it was mostly petty, I didn't feel the chemistry between them. Oh the irony because they're sending notes in chemistry class. I like Lily's family, but not much else really captured my attention. I love Kasie. She's a very talented writer and a lovely person, but it might be time for me to temper my expectations a bit and also take a break before I try another one of her books. To anyone reading this, I very much hope your experience is better with PSILY and that you love it!