I read this one because another book by Morsi, The Lovesick Cure, was highly recommended to me. So, of course, instead of reading that book, I read this random one with the super-cute cover. 
 Anyway, this was kind of all over the place. There were elements that I liked, particularly the main character's attempts to fit in a new town and new job. But there were also weird aspects that made no sense. In particular, there are a couple of passages from Scott's point-of-view which make no sense in terms of what we know about him: he's supposedly a nice guy (and his actions generally support this), but there are a couple of random "ROAR! I am a creeper alpha male!" -type internal monologues that were incongruous with the sort of character he's supposed to be. I know that sort of character is trendy right now, but I am so effing fed up with it, I can't even think. Anyway... I guess that annoyed me more than I thought it did. 
 The convention of the third-person, alternating POV in romance-ish fiction definitely shows its limitations here, because really this is DJ's story, but the other POVs (Scott and his mom, Viv) diluted her story quite a bit. I wanted to know why DJ was so ashamed of the random hookup she had in college, I wanted to know more about why she was so determined to make a life in rural Kansas, rather than using it as a stepping stone to a better job, I wanted to know more about her strange family history. Instead of those details, allowing for her character growth to be revealed on-page, we got a bizarro subplot about Viv and a lot of Scott's musings on his vegetable garden. If the story had been told wholly from DJ's POV, this would have been a strong, more character-drive story, with key reveals hidden from the reader until DJ discovers them herself. 
 Also, it seemed like the last couple of chapters were missing! They weren't, but there's a big reveal and the reaction to that reveal isn't shown on the page AT ALL. Instead, we get an unnecessary epilogue that serves no purpose whatsoever. 
 I realize this sounds like Love Overdue isn't worth the 3 star rating I gave it, but it is a well-paced novel and Morsi's writing is engaging and entertaining. I also felt like while the book summary is super-stereotype-y about librarians, Morsi did a good job not playing into those stereotypes (for the most part, there it's there a bit, of course) in the actual text. Also, she lightly examines introversion in a multi-layered way, which I very much appreciated, and I enjoyed the scenes in which DJ has to learn to navigate her new surroundings quite a lot (there's a wonderful moment in a wheat field that, while unrealistic due to the creepy crawlies present in a wheat field, was pretty wonderful too--no it's not that kind of scene, get your mind out of the gutter!).