This is more of a 1.5. I thought this was going to be so much better than it was. The summary made it seem like it would be this cutesy kind of sotry, but really it was just a bunch of stalking from both Lincoln and Beth. I don't like that they didn't meet until the very end, and I don't like that it moved so fast once they did. I've read fanfictions with this same basic plot that were better executed than this was. I know Rainbow Rowell books are loved by many, but I'm honestly not sure if I want to read another one.