I thought this was going to be a lot better to be perfectly honest. There was this insta love thing between Penn and Ella, and I didn't really see it between the two of them. I loved Ella's relationship with Ruby. Ruby and Penn's father really annoyed me, and creeped me out for a majority of this. I feel like maybe this concept would have been executed better if it wasn't a young adult book. But it was a YA, and ultimately it was disappointing.