4.5 stars 
 John Logan wants his best friend's girl. Watching Hannah and Garrett together is getting to be too much for Logan and he uses any opportunity he can find to avoid them, from partying to one night stands that leave him feeling empty. 
 Grace Ivers just wants to lose her V-card. When John Logan, the hottest guy on campus, mistakenly knocks on her door, she thinks she'll finally do the deed. But a series of setbacks mean Logan doesn't sleep with her, and her freshman year is less than stellar. 
 When they return to school in the Fall, Logan is determined to fix his mistakes and get Grace back, while Grace is determined to make him work for it. 
 Logan had a lot of learning about himself to do over the course of the book. For being such a confident hockey player, he actually had quite a few things off the ice that needed his attention. He is dreading a future running his father's garage and taking care of his father rather than playing hockey professionally, which causes him to react less than rationally when faced with questions of the future. 
 Grace is such a straight shooter, that even when things are looking down, she doesn't stay down and fights to find herself again. She is clear about what she wants, and focused on her goals. Though she wasn't always so sure of herself. Freshman Grace was very different than Sophomore Grace, and I can't say I wasn't glad she did so much growing up over the summer. 
 Her friends were less than helpful, often. Her freshman roommate, Ramona, was probably the worst of all and had me wishing I could reach through my Kindle to smack her. I didn't like the way she treated Grace, or the way Grace let her influence things rather blindly. But when Daisy, the new roommate showed up, there is a different Grace in the room and I loved the dynamic those two quickly developed. 
 This story had me alternately cheering and heartbroken for these two. Miscommunication, misinformation, and fear often get in the way of what should have been an easy start for them. There is plenty from Garrett and Hannah, and the other roommates, Tucker and Dean. 
 I was gifted a copy in exchange for an honest review.