For me, this book wasn't the worst out of the series but it wasn't the best. I thoroughly enjoyed learning more and more about Christian's life and I thought the idea of someone haunting him from the past was interesting because we barely know anything about him. Despite E.L James trying to give some suspense and make me question whether our characters were in danger at any point, I always knew that the character would be saved which disappointed me, there was never a point where I felt like I didn't know what was going to happen- way too predictable. I don't like how the characters handled a certain life changing situation and how it was blamed on Ana, even though I don't like Ana I felt like this reaction was just blown so far out of proportion and in real life people would not act in such a way. The series for me is around a 2.5/5.