I liked the book and for the first time in a VERY long time the female narrator didn't annoy me to death. Ewan was hunky enough, but he didn't make my toes curl. I was also a bit disappointed that there was no big climax to the story. (view spoiler)[ I expected a huge battle or something after Duncan won Mairin in court. For Ewan and company to just sneak into Duncan's keep steal her away without anything happening was just mind boggling to me. (hide spoiler)] It seems like the conflict will carry on into the second book, so there's still hope that something big will happen. 
 story - 3 
 narrator - 3 
 I still feel that men should narrate Highlander books but Kirsten Potter did a well enough job. I'd like her a bit more if she could deepen her voice a bit for the men but she's passable.