Actually, I wanted to give this 5 instead of 4. But then, I remember some nonsense, forced plot twist, forced shocking ending, forced climax in this book(?) that somehow works quite well.... and decided to just give it 4. Besides, It didn't leave quite impression to me. The world that is built in this story doesn't quite haunt me after I've closed the book. So, not really my favorite but it's still a great journey with Amy and Elder