** spoiler alert ** 
 This is my favorite of the hat series! Two turtles find a hat but only one hat and they both look good in it so how can they decide who gets to keep it. I like this story the best of the three. I love that each turtle is all sneakily eyeing the hat after they decide to leave it where they found it. The illustrations are fantastic as always. On one page they're both looking at the sunset and on the next one of them is looking back at the hat. In the end they realize that they can both be happy while they sleep and each have a hat in their dreams. It's a really cute story.