The Basics 
 To start, this was a sweet but not too shallow story, albeit lacking in historical detail. There is a whole lot of instalove, but mostly implied and I liked most of the love interests. However, in the end it ended up with too many plot twists and the characters all ended up being terribly one-dimensional. 
 Overall Religious-ness of book labeled "Christian" 
 I think secular readers can still enjoy this one. The main thing is that the main character does pray at many points in the story and that's about it. It also doesn't follow the conventional "girl meets boy who changes her life" storyline found all over romance in general, including most "Christian" romance, so this element is well-done. 
 Trope Check 
 *younger sibling with undefined mental disability 
 *love square 
 *Everyone loves the MC 
 *love interest from childhood (x2) 
 Full Review 
 Initially, I found few things at fault with this novel. It was sweet, with a nice main character and a bit more depth that the typical regency romance. However, one thing I began to notice as we moved along was that, though I was not bored, everyone seemed to love Lilly, and with good reason. Lilly is basically perfect. She's strong, but not selfish, disrespectful or inaccurate for the period. She can potentially choose between four different guys, she remembers everything, and you get the idea. 
 Another thing that annoyed me about this was that there just had to be a potential love interest, Roderick, who teases her in childhood and then a few years later becomes the perfect gentleman. I know it's possible, but it's not terribly appealing. And, of course, he's lost faith because he lost a loved one and - despite his cocky exterior - is all soft and fuzzy inside. 
 "When I first saw you... I thought I was imagining things. Why did you run from me 
 And then he pulls a Jace Wayland. 
 "But if you happen to mention my name to God now and again, I should not object." 
 She smiled. "I shall ask Him to give you humility." 
 He cleared his throat. "Let's not ask for a miracle right off, shall we 
 Nevertheless, the rest of the first half is well-done and the chemistry with all the other love interests is quite enjoyable. Adam was probably my favorite but I also liked Francis. 
 "Turns out your leaving was good for me," he continued. "I had to learn to do things myself.... Took more time, but in the end, I remembered the answers." 
 "I am glad someone benefited from my absence." 
 Only in the second half of the book do we encounter all those random plot twists that make good chunks of the first part seem quite unnecessary to achieve the end we arrive at. 
 A good read for the most part but a bit of a HEA ending that seems unrealistic, not to mention those unnamed plot twists and the addition of one man who basically becomes the villain in a genre that really doesn't need one.