Sadly, not one of my favorites. Lies, is truly hard to read about because Gideon, as Lies, is forced to say, "I hate you," rather than I love you. He says, "Why aren't you here?" meaning, "Why are you here?" This makes for a hard time reading and while I know Lies has to be part of Pandora's box, why not make it so the woman he loves own ability makes it so Gideon can tell the truth, which is part was done but almost as an afterthought. 
 I did feel like this book was a little bit drawn out and like it wouldn't end though I did enjoy Strider finding Haidee (the killer of Baden). Also, I was very much interested in why William scares Lucifer who referred to him as brother and I was interested in Legion being saved from Hell. Because Amun (Secrets) went to hell he is now got a little problem but is also the subject of the next book which I'm interested enough to read.... once I get it. I also can't wait to read about Strider and then Paris. Though I must admit I'm curious how Torin's story will go considering the warrior can't touch anyone. 
 As for this story. Gideon is less interesting to me than the other warriors while Scarlet is a little more entertaining but overall I was less interested in there story than some of the others. Despite that, their story was bittersweet and a necessary step on the journey through this series.