While not as compelling as a whole as either the Court of Owls or the City of Owls chapterbooks, it's still a worthwhile read. Pathos is granted to several of the talon assassins, and we get to see everything else that was happening on the Night of the Owls. 
 I think this would have been better if the Batman episodes were left out, as we already saw those in the previous two chapterbooks. While their inclusion makes this book better at standing alone, it doesn't save it from being wobbly and riddled with internal inconsistencies. And let's be honest here, if you're reading the book that shows what all the second stringers are doing, you've already read the Batman books. 
 The best chapter in the book was "First Snow" which previously include in The City of Owls and makes Mr. Freeze a real character with serious depth. So discounting the reprint, the Catwoman "Mirrors Come in All Sizes" is the stand-out showing.