I'm a big fan of the Vampire Academy series but this one didn't really do it for me. Part of it might be because of the change in narration. Rose is a bit funnier and spunkier than Sydney. Also, the cast of characters weren't as interesting to me. I was just a little bothered by Jill because she seemed a bit of a Mary Sue. It doesn't bother me too much when this happens but it does irk me a little bit. She had three guys who were interested in/obsessed with her and of course she also had the magical powers and the fact that she was the only moroi in the area and so better looking than her classmates. If that type of thing bothers you, you might want to steer clear. 
 However, I did rate it three stars because, despite its flaws, I did enjoy it overall. I love Mead's writing style and the world she has created in these books. That being said, I probably won't continue with the series but who knows?