I'm sure that the first time I read this book, I didn't leave a review because I was like "Nope, no time, must read next book immediately" because that cliffhanger is a lot to process. That's about where I am right now. The first time I read this, I totally missed the subtext of what Ash says before he leaves Meghan at the tree- that a simple I promise can change everything. I also am so excited (once again) that the fourth book is from Ash's perspective, because he and Meghan do not exchange a lot of dialogue and its difficult to discern how he actually feels about a lot of things. Also, he and Puck are totally gonna be besties again afterwards (: 
 First read: September 2012