For a book that's only a few hundred pages long, a lot happens in this book! I liked it a lot better than the previous book, and I should have known it really wasn't Ian. Who is A and why are they only sending texts to Emily? What is Wilden up to? And most importantly, if Ian didn't kill Alison, who did? And Ali died, so how on earth did they manage to see her? 
 The mystery definitely continues, and I honestly don't see any of the revelations coming. Just when you think you know who the killer is, or what's going on, it turns out that you're wrong. It's been a fun read, though, and I want to know what happens! Is Ian really alive and hiding or is it all a ruse by the police because they screwed up and don't want anyone to know? I have the feeling that Officer Wilden may not have been involved, but then again, he could be. 
 It gets a 4 out of 5. It's fun and Shepard is pretty good at keeping the mystery alive!