A promising series opener. 3.5/5 stars. 
 This review was originally posted on my book blog. 
 As YA fantasy series openers go, this was fine (I've read a few after all. Sometimes I wonder if I'm approaching saturation point!). The writing was particularly good and that's why I've given it the extra half star. 
 I had to give a lot of thought to why I didn't enjoy Ink and Bone more. The concept was excellent, its execution good, and I liked the characters. So why wasn't I enthralled? 
 Then I hit on it: I preferred the book while it was on firm speculative fiction territory. I thought it was a great idea to imagine what a near future would be like if access to all the world's books and therefore knowledge had been restricted since ancient Egypt by the repeated suppression of the printing press. In fact, there are quite a few interesting parallels to be drawn between the control of society by the Catholic Church in medieval Europe and that exercised by Caine's Great Library, a control which began to weaken with the advent of Gutenberg's game-changing invention. 
 But then the story starts to stray off into the realm of fantasy and, after such a brilliant speculative set-up, this felt a little lazy. How does the library keep control? Brute force? Well yes. Keeping all the books to itself? Yes. But behind all of this, how do its systems work? What wonders of science, technology and engineering has this ultra-secretive organisation been keeping to itself? None, because it's all powered by magic of course! 
 And I could have done without the doomed(?) romance story too. The friendships in the group of trainees were strong and endearing and would have been enough for me. 
 Overall: I don't want to sound like I'm down on this book, because I'm not. But I think I'd have liked it even more had the author not played the magic card. I do look forward to reading the next book in the series.