Second Read: Listened to City of Ashes on audible from November 22 to December 6, 2016. Rated 4/5 stars. 
 First Read: Read a paperback copy of City of Ashes from November 17 to December 14, 2012 -- I'm so in love with this series. A whole lot of cliff hangers at the end of the book so don't read unless you plan on continuing the series.