I loved this book! I had my doubts when I first started reading the book, especially when the main love interest Seth, the new hot neighbor across the street, was instantly interested in her and was flirting endlessly with her. Seth seemed a little too intense and with his immediate liking to Ellie, it was odd to read about at first but as the story progressed it definitely got better on the Seth aspect. 
 Ellie was one the best main characters I have ever read about. She wasn't like any of the other main characters in books who are always crying and whining and need to be saved or have some sort of dependence on their boyfriend/love interest. This girl could kick butt (she's a hockey player so that's a given), has a mouth on her (the sarcasm and the way she spoke to Seth and everyone was absolutely fun to read) and not to mention has anger issues, which is a good thing in this book when there's a serial redhead killer on the loose and it could possibly be the hot new neighbor across the street who's very interested in her, a redhead! 
 Every time they were together, it was always comedic, with the way Ellie couldn't believe that Seth was interested in her or whenever Seth did something that scared Ellie enough to call him a psycho and get angry at him. I swear this book had me laughing out loud and kept me turning the pages to figure out was going to happen next, especially since Seth fit the description of the Saturday Night Slasher and his actions/words (he's a crime fanatic courtesy of his Aunt, a famous crime mystery novel author) didn't help at all, plus when Ellie and Angela going crazy over the fact that Seth was the killer and they were afraid of him, the hilarity ensued! Totally fell in love with each of the characters, and had me second guessing myself on who the real killer was (at first I thought it was Dave, and then Travis showed up and he was too 'eh' and forward, and then Seth, etc.) 
 At certain times it felt like I was reading some sort of reverse harem where all the guys were interested in Ellie and she didn't know what to do with all the attention, but it was obvious from the start that Seth and her were going to end up together. It was sweet seeing Seth doing all these things for her, and how he acted, because no matter how intense or crazy or "psycho", you could tell that he really loved Ellie. (view spoiler)[Those bonus chapters in Seth's POV were so cute! He liked her from the beginning! (hide spoiler)] I admit that at times even I got annoyed whenever Seth became all possessive, jealous, and started to sort-of order her around but it got better whenever Ellie got annoyed too and didn't let herself be treated that way so she acted in classic Ellie style and either got angry at him, hit him, or did something else to stand up for herself. 
 Although the story was cheesy and predictable, with the way the clues pointed to Seth being the killer but you have to read it to appreciate it and find for yourself that while it's both of those things, it's also a good story with a great plot, comedy, romance, and action. Definitely glad I took the chance to read it! I wouldn't mind if there's a sequel to it- just so that I could read more of Seth and Ellie's relationship!