4,5/5 ! This is probably my favorite of the serie so far, I really prefered the plot of that book than the one of the previous two. I would recommand to take some notes though because there A LOT of new names and they all kind of look the same and I was quite confused sometimes. 
 I wish we had more character developement for Alec though, we get a lot of Seregil's over and over an over and poor Alec is just kind of there. He could be much more than what he has shown so far. It's like he is only Seregil's tali sometimes and it bothers me. I still have hope for him in the newt books though !