I want to start off by saying that I did enjoy this book, and think that it is overall an interesting read. I am wholeheartedly glad that I picked it up as my pre-Halloween read. 
 That being said, the reason I gave this book three stars rather than four was simply, what I felt to be, misrepresentation. I feel that title was misleading, as Magdalena plays a much smaller role than her father & Simon. 
 I also don't feel that the blibs about this book are a full representation of the story either. This book deserves a better hook. 
 I was left feeling underwhelmed on the subject of the witch, as well as underwhelmed with the development and character of Magdalena. I felt that she was shallow - but this could be due to my strong liking of her father and Simon. 
 I also felt like there was a lot left in the air, minor details (such as the fate of Sophie, and the relationship between Simon and his father) but now have seen that there is a sequel. Hopefully these holes have been addressed. 
 What I did love about this book was the clear love the author has for the subject matter and the history. It was fascinating to read about an executioner in such a ... refreshing light. He is sympathetic but still a hardened executioner - and I feel that the line was drawn perfectly. I think it was wonderfully done. I loved the parts where his humanity came through, especially when it's clear that he will continue to do his job (even if it's against his own belief to do so). It was wonderful. 
 I will definitely be reading the next instalment as soon as I am able, especially to see where some of these lesser characters wind up.