You should understand that I always have high expectations for Richelle Mead books. She is very talented writer and her works are always excellent quality. So when I read another one of her story, I expect the best and if I don't get it, I tend to judge very strictly. So if "The Golden Lily" was written by some other author it would easily get 4 stars from me, but Ms.Mead can do so much better. 
 The biggest problem I had with this book was that the plot was very transparent. All so called "mystery" was clear like baby's tears. I figured out everything in the beginning and then spent remaining time waiting for Sydney to see and put elephant-size clues together. 
 And I still can't get used to Sydney being main heroine. I loved Rose fiercely and on her background Sydney seems plain and uptight. Also her inability to fight and protect herself prevents her from being kick-ass(though this is something she started working on). And because of that I can't work out enthusiasm I had for Vampire Academy books. 
 Of course you can say, who cares about Sydney when we get to read about Adrian?! Usually I would agree with that. Although I was rooting for Dimitri, I always thought that Adrian was wonderful character. (Being honest, I was more on the "let them have threesome" team). But in this book from humorous, arrogant, confident party-playboy Adrian turned into uncertain, emotionally unstable and just too sweet usual YA boyfriend material. 
 As a book in common, it was still good, but as another installment in spin-off of legendary series, "The Golden Lily" was below the average. I can see that Ms.Mead put new story lines for the future installment and they look pretty promising. So I am looking forward to the next book and hope Richelle Mead will pour all her awesomeness into it.