BE BRAVE & BOLD ! 
 (view spoiler)[I was between rating this book 1 fucking star or 4 stars , but I decided 4 stars because Colleen is amazing in her writing , I'm not cruel ! I would say I loved this book , but I'm not going too , because it wasn't what I expected ... ! In my head I was trying to create an idea for the end of the book , but when the end comes my idea was totally bullshit ! 
 I loved this book in the begining , when I was at 70% of it I think I hated myself for reading it ! I was like WTF is wrong with these characters *gasps* . The only characters that I liked in all this book was Allysa&Marshall ! 
 In the begining I loved Ryle too , but in the end I was : "Why are you doing this ? Damn it ! You have to changeeee ! " I know you are going to hate him for what he did to Lily (he was abbusive) , but please don't hate him , it's not he's fault ! He killed his brother when he was only 6 years old for Christ sake , of course he was going to have a big problem . I hate Colleen for making Ryle such a bad guy , and not fix him in the end . I loved that character so much , and when I saw that in the end he was alone I crieeeeddd so muccchhh ! *sobs* 
 For Lily I've got to say that she made the right choice even if I hate that choice ! I FUCKING HATE IT ! But I'm not a mother , and I can't judge her . 
 I hate Lily for creating a family with Ryle , and not telling him the truth about Atlas , about the tattoo , about the magnet , about all of that . She loved Atlas all the time :@ , why would she bothered with Ryle , why she didn't search for Atlas ! 
 For Atlas I've got to say that no one is that perfect like he is ! (hide spoiler)] 
 I've got to say that CoHo has an amazing skill for alternating the past with the present in her books ! But Colleen I've got to say to you that this is the last book of yours that I'm reading . I'm not capable of enduring so much heartbreaking ! No one had breaked my heart like you did !