4 stars - rated as a light fluffy YA romance 
 Ground breaking full-of-twists novel this is not, but if you are craving a light fluffy YA romance this will satisfy. 
 Plotline is predictable, but it doesn't mean it wasn't be enjoyable, as long as you go in with the right expectations. It started off at 5 stars, great humour kept it from being too cheesy, but the wit slows a little as we get into the story. 
 The characters for the most part fit the stereotypes. Heroine Avery is a shy nerd who grows after her unrequited love rejects her. Our hero Grayson a jock womanizer who fails at science and who begins to notice said heroine, a girl who has been in his life as his brother's best friend. It wasn't that the main characters were too flat, the humour helped here, but it could have been more. I wish there were some more characters traits that broke the mould. Libby, the heroine's nerd BFF with sass, is an example of how great it can be when the author breaks the mould. Her lines were scene stealers. 
 I also felt like Grayson's turnaround from womanizer to devoted romantic hero was too sudden. Yes there was that funny shower scene where he notices her for the first time physically. But from there I didn't feel like there was much there that would attract an outgoing charming good looking jock to an extremely shy nerd like Avery, beyond her physical assets. Here I did wish there was just a little more depth - a discovery of Avery on a more emotional level. Maybe a revealed shared interest, a bonding moment, something else. I get why Avery would fall for Grayson. I just don't see what Grayson saw in Avery and he never attempted to explain it (yes book is dual POV). 
 At A Glance 
 Cheating (view spoiler)[Not really. Avery kisses her old crush once to come to realization there were no feelings but it wasn't steamy and at that point she wasn't a couple with Grayson (hide spoiler)] 
 Descriptive Sex with OW/OM (view spoiler)[No. Actually this is a clean novel so no descriptive sex at all (hide spoiler)] 
 HEA (view spoiler)[Yes with dual POV epilogue. (hide spoiler)]