Initial reaction: I have immense hatred for this book!!! Ugh! 
 -------- 
 Spoilery and angry review below. You've been warned. 
 Seriously. I should have stopped reading this 100 pages before the end because I knew what was going to happen, I didn't even care what was going to happen, and I was sick to death of all of the staged/predictable/cliche/ridiculously overused tropes going on in this book. If I would've had a physical copy of the book, I would've thrown it by the end. I'm pretty sure I yelled at my kindle at one point. Like the writing. I hated it. Abhorred. Despised. Ridiculed. Wanted it just stop. I got used to the short chapters and shifting POVs pretty quickly, but I felt like I was reading a fanfiction written by a teenager learning how to write stories... like how do people like the writing??? There was nothing beautiful about it. The sentences were simple and none of the ideas were complex, ever. I had hope in the beginning, wondering what kind of drama would come out of a drunken hit-and-run jail bird returning home to face the damaged and injured victim of the accident. BUT NO. THEY FALL IN LOVE AFTER LIKE A WEEK. Just stop. Ugh. It seriously felt like the author had no idea how to wrap up the story in a believable way. Like realistically, what happened to the physical therapy in the last half of the book? Why did Caleb insist Maggie show him her scars or the relationship was done? (It felt a little rape-y with how insistent he was on needing to see her freaking scars) How does Caleb leave Paradise WHEN HE IS ON PROBATION? You can't do that!!!! Like legally!!! WTF? Who really did call in the complaint against Caleb on Maggie's behalf? (Why was that even in the book anyway? And then Caleb tries to scare her afterward? Maybe you should have a complaint against you if you're going to act like that.) WTF were his parents doing the entire time? His dad almost-literally said, "Our lives were better before you got here, son." I cringed reading that sentence. Son? And the big secret that no one can know about but somehow Caleb's crazy ex-girlfriend knows...? It just doesn't make sense. AND THE STUPID REVELATION THAT MAGGIE SUDDENLY REMEMBERS. I guess this book is really about magic and we didn't know it because that's how everything happens. MAGIC. AND GLITTER. AND HATRED. 
 Not to mention the fact that the characters all knew a little too much about the real reasoning behind their actions. "I'm trying so hard at tennis to impress a Daddy that left me so maybe he'll love me again." "I am more alive now than when I was before the accident." LIKE WHAT. 
 STUPID STUPID STUPID. I'm angry.