What Happened to Goodbye would be be a 4-4.5 for me. I read about over 90+% of this book while on a plane than school started up and it was killing me to take so long to read that last little bit all the while having to read all these dumb books for school. This book did live up the the Sarah Dessen name and after having an awful plane ride this book kept me in calm despite the 3+ delays. Mclean (at first I was heistant with this name I know squat about basketball so that might be the reason). Mclean is a girl just trying out different costumes of a person to figure out who she really is as a way to cope to deal with her mother's new family in addition to her father keep moving her around the country. Dessen creates a fun cast of characters that all have a differenet personality, but when it all comes down to it are similar and are able to come together to be friends. David is yet another awsomely cute leading guy that Dessen has created that has the readers want to fall for him. (view spoiler)[The only issue I had was that I wish there was just a little more to the ending. I get the whole mystery of things, but I just wish there was a slightly more settled feeling. (hide spoiler)] Overall it was a great read that I really liked and would recommend to others who love a fun easy read that will have them in smiles and really hope that Sarah Dessen has more to come out!