Probably a 3.5 cause while the story held my attention not much of anything happens. Basically Skye just turned 17 and realizes she has some freaky silver eyes and powers. Her parents died when she was six and she lives with her Mom's best friend. Now two new boys are in town, dark confident sarcastic bad boy rebel Asher, and nice quiet calm shy good listener guardian Devin, who appear to be cousins that are fighting over her. And that is the whole book. The two of them reveal themselves to be angels on opposite sides who were both sent to protect her and find out which powers she possess because she has one parent that came from both sides, the rebels and the guardians. While I liked Devin better, both the guys were rather annoying and I myself would have ditched them both for Ian, the sweet human guy that has liked Skye forever. They both so clearly have ulterior motives and she shouldn't trust either of them but of course falls for both of them. I'm like why are they sending two young guys to watch her anyway? How about some female angels? But yeah the angels thought of that and wanted the guys to seduce her onto their side. They want to force her to choose a side but both sides suck. If you don't love a love triangle you will definitely hate this book because instead of it being a story with a love triangle it is more like a love triangle with some story thrown in to try to make it into a book. I might read the next one out of curiosity.