OK now where to started. I'm 14 and well Susie seemed so childish to me. I mean wow it wasn't even what she did or what she was like it was the way she talked how things were phrase it got on my nerves the whole way through. that's not even the worst. 
 I didn't feel sympathy towards her when she died the scene was just too rushed and even though it was a good idea to know who killed her I think the book lost its eeriness and mystery the whole way through. it felt like a romance between 3 couples rather than anything else I honestly forgot all about Susie for the majority of the book. 
 I gave two stars because it wasn't awful but it was great either. there was a fair amount of detail but there could have been more to do with character appearance like what did hal look like I really wanted to know well I hope that's his name. there were some good bits in there which I'm glad for but there is no way I will ever recommend it considering it was recommended to me.