4.5 (I'm a rounder upper) 
 Even though I had the little nitpicks about the college stuff, this book was outstanding, exactly what I'd expect out of Gayle Forman. I love that it's so Different from If I Stay/Where She Went and I really, really related to the main character and the way traveling changed her. If things don't work out for Allyson in the sequel, I may set something on fire. 
 I do suspect that the sequel will be really interesting, because we really don't know anything about Willem at that book's from his POV.