3.5 stars 
 This is one of those books that while I was reading it I really loved it, but then after it settled with me I realized I didn't like it as much as I thought I did. Ultimately, I did still really enjoy this book, but the "OMG I LOVE THIS BOOK" feeling did fade the more I thought about what I had read. 
 There are three main characters in the story: Maggie, Caleb, and Mrs. Reynolds. Maggie and Caleb both narrate the story (alternating chapters) and I found them both likable and sympathetic. Mrs. Reynolds is one of those too-good-to-be-true fictional characters that make me feel so good I don't care if they're just a little *too* perfect or convenient. Maggie and Caleb's interactions with Mrs. Reynolds are predictable (and reminded me of a bunch of other books/movies) but enjoyable to read about nonetheless. 
 There really are two parts to this story, the first being the romantic relationship between Caleb and Maggie and the second being how they each adjusted to the aftermath of the accident. The romantic storyline is sweet and should appeal to readers looking for one of those "perfect boy" love stories. I certainly found myself melting for Caleb. 
 Even though we're shown Maggie and Caleb's perspectives, they both sounded like Maggie's perspective (where the relationship is concerned). What I mean by that is that Caleb's feelings and actions about their relationship felt very much like what Maggie would wish them to be. If I were Maggie and I were to dream up the best possible Caleb actions, they would be pretty much what happened. It didn't seem entirely realistic, but it was satisfying like a daydream where you can make everything happen exactly as you wish they would happen (except for the whole "Show me your scars" thing, which I thought was kind of strange). 
 The second part is how each character dealt with the aftermath of the accident. This part had a lot of depth and emotion. If the romance is the fluff of day dreams, this part is a raw nightmare. Some parts seemed unbelievably harsh, like how the school responded to Maggie. I don't really understand why the students would turn away from her and make fun of her for limping, especially since she had been popular. Wouldn't people rally around her as an innocent victim? Wouldn't they support her? Instead they shun her and mock her, which I found a little confusing. 
 Other parts were completely believable, particularly the way Caleb's family reacted. This part was harsh and cruel, but also very realistic. His parents' reactions were terrible and made me really feel for Caleb. I despised his ex-girlfriend and the callous way she treated him. I am glad Simone Elkeles didn't shy away from these nastier sides of humanity. She could have taken the easy way out by having his parents shun him on moral grounds (driving drunk). Instead she confronted the issue by showing his parents disintegrate over petty but very realistic fears of appearances and simply not knowing how to deal with their child driving drunk and the ramifications of that act. I hated his parents for the way they behaved, but I also understood and pitied them. 
 There is a twist toward the end that makes Caleb much easier to like, but I think cheapened the story a little. On one hand I appreciate that it is there because it improves Caleb, but on the other I wish she hadn't taken what seems to me to be an easy out. The open ending allows for a sequel (Return to Paradise) but the book does stand well on its own and doesn't really require a sequel. Even with my complaints, I am happy I read this one and I do recommend it. 
 Originally posted at Small Review