The 5 star stories for me in this collection were Suma, Ryan, Bardugo, Tucholke, Kristoff, and Lu. In fairness the only stories I would read a second time were Suma and Tucholke - shockingly, their stories were more on the magical side than the truly scary. Fans of horror will appreciate more of these stories than I did; the writing is tight and the scares were legit, just too legit for me to actually like them, or to want to read them while in the middle of nowhere. Basically would recommend to anyone less of a scaredy cat than I am.