I had never read this book before, I had only seen the movie... and obviously, the book was so much better! I was so much more detailed and I couldn't believe how much the movie left out... I suppose it was to avoid controversy. Although, I don't see what all the fuss is about, but maybe that's because I'm not religious and I can separate fact from fiction. However, you cannot ignore the historical implications of this book. Pullman is a very good writer, especially in the war/combat department. His scenes of battle are so vivid, sometimes gruesome, but always beautifully written. I really enjoyed reading this, Pullman is a fantastic storyteller and I cannot wait to read the other two.