Overall Starred Review: 3.5/5 
 Cover- yaasss it's perfect! Nothing I would do to change it. 5/5 
 Illustrations- Yess, I loved this so much! The drawings in this book were probably the best thing about this book. I loved how the blue pictures kind of set the mood. 5/5 
 Characters- They didn't really have many unique characteristics and were quite boring. 3/5 
 Plot- Really didn't make any sense to me? Like, why would Rose like Dud? Some of the things in the book don't make sense and probably needed more detail. 3/5 
 Suspense- Little to no suspense 3/5