** spoiler alert ** 
 Quite liked it, but some parts were too obvious. It was obvious about Adrian and Sidney and I'm quite sure they're going to be together in third book and Sidney leaves the other Alchemists. And it was way too obvious about Trey. It's weird to read about Dimitri, because it isn't Rose's point of view. Just weird. These two book series mess it up a little. But I really liked Adrian in both series.