4.5 
 This was just such a fun (and funny) book. Brad and Sebastian were just so cute and hot together. 
 I loved watching Brad's thoughts as he came to accept that he was gay, and I loved the way he was just so into Sebastian. Though he was the "tough guy" jock in a frat full of guys just like him, he had no problems at all with Sebastian being the "alpha" and letting his friends know that, too. It was so cute that Brad was every bit as turned on by Sebastian's "nerdiness" (like his reward for being a good student) as Sebastian was by Brad's athleticism (not just his body but how he got hotter as Brad got sweatier). 
 I loved Brad's friends - Collin was just adorable, Kyle's reaction then his full-on support, even Ashley turned out to be a good friend. It was kind of funny to watch how bewildered and frustrated Brad got when people kept questioning or disbelieving he was gay - it was like, "how many times do I need to come out to the same people before they get it?!" I also enjoyed watching Sebastian (view spoiler)[go from I-don't-love-him-but-I'm-an-ass-for-hurting-him to oh-shit-am-I-stupid-for-not-seeing-what-was-right-in-front-of-me (hide spoiler)]. Those kinds of lightbulb moments are some of my favorites. 
 The two niggly little quibbles I had were: 
 1. I don't think Brad's actions with girls in the past were all that horrible. Sure he was somewhat of a player but no more so than his friends. It's not like he was misleading the girls (no more than he was misleading himself); he just kept trying to find the girl who'd make him feel what he thought he was supposed to feel and not understanding why he couldn't. 
 2. (view spoiler)[Sebastian's reaction to Brad asking him what would happen if he took too long to come out was a little extreme. Sure, I can understand not wanting to be someone's dirty secret, but by the time Brad asked the question he had already come out to his family, his best friend, his ex-girlfriend, and Sebastian's friends. I know, it needed to be done to set up the conversation that came after, but still... Brad was coming out, he just was taking it in steps. (hide spoiler)] 
 Other than those two tiny things, I really liked this book. I've already re-read in a couple of times just because it's such a fun, drama-free (well, it has a little, but even the drama is done in a humorous way) read. 
 One thing about that cover though. I like a guy with hot abs as much as anyone, but the dude in front looks like he's standing on a scale checking his weight.