For various reasons, I had to restart this book 3 different times. Up until about page 150 I really was not "feeling" Raymie Nightingale the way I've felt most of Kate DiCamillo's other books. I was thinking that the book was really kind of odd and sadly humorous in ways, but I just wasn't feeling like it would be more than a "3 star" book for me. The last 100 pages truly make this story. DiCamillo has a way of addressing that nebulous, abstract heart, or in this story - soul, of her characters so that, in the end you feel as though you've had almost a spiritual experience. That came through for me in the end. The other thing I believe DiCamillo does well is remembering-- and then putting into words-- feelings that are unique to kids. Here's a great example: There was something scary about watching an adult sleep. It was as if no one at all were in charge of the world. Priceless! I can remember that feeling from many years ago, but probably would never have found quite those words for it! Bottom line- Raymie Nightingale is worth the read, and the last half is probably a "5", but balancing that out with the beginning made it a "4" overall for me. I'd urge you to stick with the book if you're thinking of putting it aside. Not my favorite of DiCamillo's, but it ended up being a good story.