Terrible....... It was just a horrible waste of time watching Grace vacillate between "I want him" and "he won't be faithful to me" for 300 frigging pages. This is a silly written book with so much character inconsistencies. Grace and Gabriel are both mega idiots. Grace is an idiot for constantly picking on Shane, for thinking he's a womanizer even though its obvious he has told her he loved her since book 1, whereas Gabriel is an idiot for his inexplicable obsession with Grace. If he had only reappeared in Grace's life at the start of her current incarnation, where the hell has he been for the 2000 years? 
 There are no attempts to address the supernatural aspects of the characters, and the wariness of immortality that made the first book so unique is largely absent here. That is to say, if Shane is already mortal, why doesn't Gabriel just smote him????????????????? Even they have obviously recognized who each other is, why do they continue addressing each other as Shane and Grace instead of Shamsiel and Selah? what exactly are Angels capable of? Giving mortals orgasms? That's not a good answer. 
 This entry in the series devolved into just another silly entry of the usual YA paranormal trash. The 2 hours I spent skimming through the novel is, unfortunately, precious time that I would never get back.