I've read a lot of reviews about this book because I was trying to figure out my mixed feelings about it. As much as I love Colleen Hoover and her writing style (that is really easy to read and makes me finish her books in two days with little effort), this story just wasn't quite right. For me, it all came down to one thing: (view spoiler)[ he didn't chose her. I'm a romantic, I'm sorry! I didn't particularly liked the cheating, of course... 
 But I could forgive that if he just chose her in the end! But no - no matter what you say (she was sick, he was loyal, it was 5 years), I don't care. If their love was so big, he should have chose her. 
 (hide spoiler)]