So, I thought the fact that the Points of View alternate between first person (Trey) and third person (Vincent) was going to annoy me, but I found that it didn't because it was readily apparent immediately whose POV you were reading from as soon as the chapter/section began. That was useful, and it worked out well. I did notice the transition a couple of times, but it didn't exactly bother me. 
 I identified a lot with Trey because that was me; I wasn't saving myself because I thought it was a sin, I was saving myself because I wanted it to be the right time and person for me, just like Trey did. So, his character resonated really well with me because of that. 
 Vincent had been around the block with three different wives and finally decided maybe he should stop trying to shove urges he'd had in high school to the back of his mind. But he wasn't quite ready to face himself at first either, so "not-dating" while flirting with Trey worked for him. 
 The reason they fell in together the way they did really made sense for where each of them were in their lives. And though neither was ready to go "all the way", they were fairly creative (and even steamy) in their explorations. Fortunately, this wasn't a trope-like "straight guy's experimentation" situation, which was refreshing. And though Trey had the thought once early on, it was a brief moment and not a big hang-up for either of them. 
 I really loved the happenstance of when Trey considered himself not a virgin any longer. That was perfect. (Not spoiling that one.) 
 The coming out to Vincent's very Italian Catholic family was well-played also as far as timing and need. 
 All around, an excellent contemporary read. 
 This story ends at 90%, for what it's worth. The rest is an excerpt of A Private Gentleman. 
 Oh, and though I did comment about one typo, it was the only one I noticed.