I had avoided this book like the plague because I have learned much too much about circuses and when I opened the book and saw it was centering around a circus I put it down. 
 Overall, I really liked it. It was fun, a bit romantic, and engaging. I loved that Sara did touch on some of the harm done to the animals, especially the elephants and then talking about the cat without teeth (which they still do, remove their teeth). I appreciate that she showed that, as I do not support circuses with animals and people haven't a clue how far it really goes. What's sad, is there was a difference. Back then people were desperate. It was the depression and people were scrapping by. I'm not saying that hurting the animals was necessary but just saying that it was a different time. Now, circuses work out of greed and do even more harm to those animals and yet people freak out when there's a stampede and don't know why the animals revolted. Really? You don't know why? Spoiler...I did pretty much love when you know who got what came to him! 
 Anyway, it was overall a great book. My only gripe with it was when Jacob saw the damage done and yet, at the end of the book, still decided to participate in circuses. I understand in the beginning because everyone was still struggling, but for so long after I had trouble with it. At the same time, this may not have happened because the story was told from the perspective of a very old Jacob, who made clear that his memory is fading. Rosemary also pointed out that people sometimes make up lies and begin to believe them as time goes on. I think that statement says a lot in this novel and can make a reader really think. Otherwise, great characters and great storytelling!