Loved this book. The letters back and forth really made my heart ache, and all the mistaken identity was killing me, and then we had a soldier back from WAR...I can't remember if I had any reservations about this book, especially towards the end, but I remember at the time (jeez, I only read this a month ago), thinking it was the best historical romance from Lisa Kleypas I've read to date, and certainly one of the better Hathaway ones, and I've read a couple.