Oh, man. I loved Frat Boy and Toppy so much, and I wanted to love this book, too. I liked it, but I didn't love it. 
 Unlike a lot of people, I didn't think Paul was so horrible in FB&T; sure he had a jerky mouth, but it's not like he did anything to try to sandbag Brad or hurt his relationship with Sebastian - he just trash talked a lot. When I found out he would be getting his own story in which we'd find out why he developed his jock hate I was thrilled. Unfortunately, the story was just too rushed for me. 
 Given what Trevor did to Paul in high school, I don't think two meetings (only one of them a "date") in two days (no matter how much he apologized) then a week of thinking about it was nearly enough for Paul to not only forgive him but be ready to give him a second chance. What Trevor did was beyond shitty; I needed to see at least a month - likely several months - worth of meetings and taking it slowly before having Paul move beyond it. Actions that provoked a nine year dislike of athletes needed more than a few days to make up for, imo. 
 One thing I loved in FB&T was the alternating third-person POV; this one only has Paul's POV. If it had to be so short, it would have helped to know what was going on in Trevor's head, too. 
 As I said, I liked the story, and I'll be chomping at the bit for Collin's story and Toby's as well. I just wish this one were longer - not just in length (though I'd have loved that, too), but in story time.