4 stars! 
 Critica em Portugues disponivel no Blog Pepita Magica/ Part of this review was originally published in Pepita Magica 
 Sarah and Angus Moorcroft were once a happily married couple... 
 They were once the proud parents of identical twin girls... 
 But Not Anymore! 
 Now, they are a grieving couple... 
 You see, a year ago, one of their twin daughters, Lydia, fell from a first floor balcony, in her grandma's house, and died. 
 Fourteen months later, Sarah and Angus are still trying to rebuild their lives with their remaining daughter, Kirstie, who is now 7 years old. 
 Things haven't been easy, this past year ... 
 Kirstie, who was energetic, cheerful and very social, became reserved, quiet and timid. 
 Angus who was a brilliant and successful Architect, began to drink constantly, which lead him to become violent, hit his boss at work and lose his job. 
 So...With almost no money left and a life in ruins, the couple decide to sell their house, move to a small Scottish island that Angus inherited from his grandmother, and start over. 
 But what to do when Kirstie starts to insist that she is Lydia and not Kirstie! 
 " 'Mummy, why do you keep calling me Kirstie?' 
 I say nothing. The silence is ringing. I speak: 
 'Sorry, sweetheart. What?' 
 'Why do you keep calling me Kirstie, Mummy? Kirstie is dead. 
 It was Kirstie that died. I'm Lydia.'." 
 Is it possible that, when faced with both daughters - identical twins dressed exactly the same and with the same haircut - they have mistakenly identified the daughter who passed away?! 
 The surviving twin is Kirstie or Lydia?! 
 With the move to the island the situation only gets worse... as their daughter begins to say that she can see her deceased twin sister! 
 "...Kirstie was there! She was there! She's here! She's here!" 
 "'You keep saying she's dead but she comes back to play with me, she was here, she was at school, she plays with me, she is my sister, it doesn't matter if she's dead, she's still here, still here, I'm here, we are here - why do you keep saying we're dead, when we're not we're not we're not.' " 
 Is it all her imagination? Is it the way her mind is coping with the loss of her twin sister? Or is their daughter hallucinating and going crazy? 
 As time passes by and their daughter's mental state keeps getting worse, Sarah can't help but wonder: 
 What really happened on the day her daughter died? Where was Angus? And worse, is it possible that her daughter's death was not an accident?! 
 And, Throughout the book, we, as readers, constantly, keep questioning: 
 Which twin died? Which one Survived? 
 What about the supposed sightings of the dead twin... Is there a ghost? Is it only imagination? or is the surviving twin going mad? 
 And... if the death of the twin who fell off the balcony was Not an Accident, then: 
 Who's to blame for the girl's death? 
 ... Is it Angus? ... Sarah? ... Her twin sister? ... Or herself?! 
 Do read the book to find out ;) 
 *********************************************** 
 I really Liked this book :) 
 I enjoyed reading it and I recommend it to anyone who likes mystery books that makes us constantly question what is going on. 
 I really liked that the book was written in a Double POV, because it makes us know both main characters - Sarah and Angus - more deeply, it creates more suspense and it, also, allows us to see how there's so much Distrust, Suspicion and Secrets between the couple! 
 I kept creating theories about what I thought had happened, and then, in the following chapters, I'd be totally taken aback by what it was revealed! Some may think this makes the book confusing, but to me, this was exciting. I was curious, and constantly trying to guess what happened. 
 What I didn't like much in this book was the lack of emotion and scariness. Being the book about losing a daughter, I really expected to feel a lot more. And being the book in the Horror category (with supposed sightings of a deceased child) I really expected it to be scarier. 
 Also, I cannot say that the main characters were the greatest. It's difficult not to condemn some of their actions when, slowly, we start to know the whole story. 
 I'll finish by saying that the ending was not entirely surprising to me, but I liked the way it was written. Although many may not agree, I think it's a good end for a book like this.