I give all these books three stars because even though the plot is semi interesting and I don't feel like I'm so bored I have to put the book down, they: 
 a) have TYPOS. You are a published book. Seriously If I'm paying to read your book can you at least edit it correctly? 
 b) the main character is one of the dumbest protagonists in the history of YA fiction and needs to develop her character and actually be mature for her so called "responsibility" (seriously, it's book four?!) and 
 c) the books relationships are so confusing and weirdly intended I cannot even connect with any of them. At least Aphrodite wanted to be with Erik to be popular. Everyone Zoey wants to be with just doesn't make sense at ALL. And Erik is always way too nice to her and she is always making up crazy excuses to explain why she is right (SERIOUSLY AFTER HOOKING UP WITH 2 OTHER GUYS HE FORGAVE HER?!?! AND HE FELT GUILTY ABOUT GETTING MAD?!?!) 
 All in all this book actually looked like it might be good and then stark dies and it gets weird. I thought this one might be four stars!! but it was just more of the same in the end and seriously I can't stand the fact that Zoey never learns from her mistakes. I can't stand the lack of character development. 
 I'm gonna finish the series out of curiosity. 
 AND FOR APHRODITE I JUST LOVE HER OKAY SHE IS SO GREAT AND BITC--WITCHY (: