3.5 stars! I will admit that it took me a while to get into Paper Valentine, but get into it I did. I can't say that I loved it as much as The Replacement or The Space Between, but I did love it. Mainly, I loved Hannah. What a fantastic character she was. And Finny was something completely new. I loved the emotions that this book provoked in me. The struggles that Hannah was going through. The pain and the anger, and especially the guilt. She really is a remarkable character. And Lillian, while I wasn't a fan of her, was a great character as well. And by the end, I fell for her. She showed her true colors by then. Besides Hannity though, Ariel was my favorite. I would take her for a little sister any day. And Pinky as her best friend, too! Brenna Yovanoff is still an author that I will keep an eye out for!