Rating: 4.5 
 This whole book seemed like it would be the perfect "script" for a tv show. This was intriguing & mysterious which kept me reading it and not wanting to put it down. 
 I know I would have loved to live in this kind of situation when I was in high school but it was kind of unbelievable. April's dad was kind of a idiot for thinking that Vi's mom was ok with her moving it. 
 Speaking of characters, I liked April. I thought the author really was able to bring her alive and I sympathized with her with everything that she went through. And Noah, what a jerk! I totally knew he cheated on April. The signs were blaring but poor April didn't see it. And I loved Donut, so cute! It had such personality. 
 I have to say I am a pretty liberal when it comes to buying books for my school library but I probably wouldn't purchase this one for my library. It has a lot of mature topics in it and I'm not sure if I would want a freshman reading it.