I'm docking a star for the non-ending. I really needed an ending today, y'know? Do you have days like that? No? Just me? 
 Other than that, I really did enjoy the hell out of this thing. Stiefvater is a fabulous writer, and she's witty in a way that reminds me of Neil Gaiman. Actually, the whole book reminded me of Neil Gaiman -- and I mean that in a good way. It breezed along beautifully. 
 I really did think it was going to wrap up in one book, though. I know there are more books in the series, but I assumed they were further adventures or something. Do you do that thing where you're guessing how the book will end, and eagerly hoping it's even better than that? Right, well. It didn't end mid-sentence. That's about all I can say for it. A friend of mine once walked into a shin-high pane of glass and hurt herself so badly she missed a semester of school. The ending feels like that (although technically you can feel that there aren't many pages left, unlike my friend, who didn't see that glass at all, poor dear).