I tried to read this twice. TWICE. Normally I don't give DFN books a second chance, but I mean... come on; it's John Green AND David Levithan. This should have been a huge hit. 
 The cast kinda killed it. They either annoyed me to no ends (Tiny was all DRAMA and angsty Will was rage inducing) or fell completely flat (bland Will was bland and the girl -can't recall her name- was simply forgettable ...and I stopped it yesterday). I could not detect a plot line for the time I gave it; maybe that changes. But I'm just not feeling it anymore. 
 Perhaps some day I'll give it round three? ...Third time is the charm, right?? 
 I still respect the hell out of both writers, despite all this. They can't shake a fan that easily.