How do I start? Well, the promise was enough to keep me reading ... however, the plot just didn't feel strong enough to tug me along. Don't get me wrong, I can see why I a lot of people loved it. It just wasn't for me. Ben's death felt a little bit odd, so maybe it's significant later on. Also, it was pretty easy to guess who the "Rogue Librarian" was. It had to be someone who the main character talked to, not someone from a distance, so that eliminated Beth and that other guy. Patrick was out for sure. Roland I didn't trust. But Carmen was my first guess.