I wanted to love absolutely everything about this book, because I genuinely love the series, but this one missed a few things for me. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed it. However, there were key things that made this one fall off the mark for me. 
 Pro: Loved that the book shows the side characters growth. These books are not set back to back so the time frame allows us to witness moments of the families growing up. We get Joss and Braden's kids, Nate and Olivia as a couple, a more mature Cole, and so forth. That's very different from various other books in this genre. 
 Con: Hannah from the start was kind of a bitch. I liked her in previous books and I liked her in the subsequent book, but this one not so much. I thought she was uptight, rude, and kind of mean. I understand her backstory hardened her, but it was difficult to feel sympathy for her when she was acting so awful. 
 Pro: I thought the relationship between her horrid friend and her was portrayed very well and true to life. I've been in that situation before. There are always three sides to a story: yours, mine, and the truth. While her rude friend was ranting her side, ignoring key details, she was keeping things to herself. When Hannah finally said what was going on, she thought her version was closer to the truth. I liked that. It didn't redeem her, but it made me feel for her there. 
 Con: Did not like the stalking. I didn't find it romantic or sexy. Period. He showed up at her gym and book club! What the hell? 
 Pro: Hannah's relationship with Cole. It was sweet and made me fall so in love with that boy! 
 Con: The big secret. Come on - we all saw that coming. I would be shocked if anyone actually was surprised by it. 
 Sigh. 
 I'm more nitpicking at this one and I think it's because I loved the other ones so much. They feature debonair, masculine men with such sweet, romantic sides. It's a stereotype, but I dig on it. This one just fell a little flat for me.