I have heard a lot of good things about this author, so I was excited to start reading this book. Unfortunately, the best word I can come up with to describe this is 'okay'. It wasn't bad, there wasn't anything particularly annoying about the book, but it wasn't great either. 
 I spent a lot of the book wishing that the story had started earlier, ideally back when Madison first moved in with her dad, because without all of that it felt like we just jumped straight into the action and I didn't really have any time to get to know the characters or to start caring about them. I found out later on that the first story in this series was actually a short story in an anthology called "Prom Nights from Hell". It still frustrated me though, because I feel as though I should be able to pick up book one in a series and be able to enjoy it without having to read something else first. Also, by the time I felt there had been a really good explanation of how this light/dark reaper thing worked, it was already the final chapter and the story was over. 
 I will say that the ending was great, and after seeing the setup for the next book I still want to read it even with all of my frustrations with this book. But, I want to read it because of the situation that Harrison left, not because I have any particular attachment to the characters, which sadly makes books easily forgettable.