A solid four stars. I actually really enjoyed this book, even if I recognize it's not completely original. I do appreciate the world building of it and learning about the everyday minutiae of Tearling as well as the hints of the pre-Crossing world. It's likewise refreshing to have a YA fantasy heroine who's both normal and competent at what she's supposed to be doing. I found Kelsea to be an engaging protagonist and I liked the way she actually seems like a competent ruler, whose major special skill to speak of is linked to knowing a lot about political history and political theory. Yeah, she's got special jewels or whatever, but she'd be a good ruler without them, too. She also didn't undergo any makeover of any sort, despite being repeatedly described as "plain," so that was pretty novel and welcome. I also appreciate the fact that she's surrounded by grumpy middle-aged men who are intent on protecting her and not falling in love with her. Finally, there was a blessedly small amount of time dedicated to "The Fetch," and everyone including Kelsea regards her fascination with him with a sort of chagrin that I appreciate.