Stars above 
 I really liked this set of novellas. I thought that it was a great asset to the series to see events from different perspectives. Especially the keeper, I thought that this short story was well needed. But it did feel like it should have been released when the series was still going on because I didn't feel as excited to read it. I felt like the last novella could have been included in Winter and that the book could have been released just before winter came out. I think that because most of the short stories in this book happened before winter, they should have been released before winter. I did already read most of the short stories online before winter so it would have been nice to have the majority of these short stories be new ones but I am glad that they included the ones that were written before. 
 Overall I thought that this was a nice read and it is nice to finally get the novellas in physical form