Actual rating 4.5 stars. This was such a cute read! It was exactly the right thing to read after two more serious contemporaries. I liked all the three stories in this books, and I loved how they were all connected to each other. They intertwined so well together! All the characters were fun except I found Addie pretty annoying. But her self-absorption and getting rid of that was pretty much the point of the last story so that makes sense. I enjoyed the writing styles of all three authors (I had only read John Green's novels before), and especially their humor! I would recommend this to everyone who wants to read something cute and full of humor. And it doesn't even need to be Christmas to enjoy this novel. ;)