I had been dying for this book and Amazon totally messed up when it finally came out and I got it late. 
 I still devoured it in one night. 
 That said, I love Anna and Lola more as far as the books go. St Clair was very lovable even if he wasn't my type and Cricket was everything I've ever wanted from a teenage book boyfriend, seriously. But Josh doesn't do it for me. I don't know why, I think it's because he has such genuinely teenage issues and it's not the book's fault, it's realistic, but it's hard for me as an adult who shouldn't be reading YA anymore to really relate to. Now, I'm obviously being tongue in cheek, because really, is this a fair criticism? Not really, but it's an honest one and I review books on GoodReads purely on how I feel about them and not so much on how I objectively view them. 
 Isla is a character that I can relate to a LOT on the other hand. Oh girlfriend, we are a bucket of the same issues. I felt her journey and I felt like she could be me. But at the same time, I wanted to smack her because really, I would smack me of that era too. Maybe a smack would be too harsh, I'm thinking a good shaking followed by a bear hug would be more appropriate. 
 Despite not loving this one as much as the other two, I still loved it. I still read it as fast as humanly possible. I still want more books from Stephanie Perkins with all of my heart.