4.25 stars because I'm nitpicking. I really enjoyed this so much. I love Keating's books so far because the premises are incredibly unique and so fun. This made it onto my TBR ASAP because of her name, first of all, and also because of the Stranger Than Fiction premise - one of my favorite movies. I don't think she took the idea too far, where it felt like that was the only thing happening. Annabelle didn't have a lot of personality though, which is probably my biggest issue with the story. The love triangle was incredibly clever and super meta. I didn't love the actual triangle but I did love the boys and the reasoning behind it.