I was going to give this 3 and a half stars because I found it to be a bit dull but when I actually think back at what happened in the book it wasn't that dull, it was just me not being connected to the story 
 I don't connect that well with Tally, I had hopes she'd grow up a bit more in this but she still stayed the same, this made me a bit annoyed as most the book was just tally. 
 The storyline was great but all the fun exciting stuff really happens towards the end, I hated new pretty town and not having David or any of the other smokies featured more. 
 I did love the new developments and am hoping the last book specials brings this series all together and me and Tally can finally get along