Finders Keepers is yet another wonderful addition to this amazing series, and to the NA genre, in general. I've got to give Williams credit, she killed it with the dialogue in this book. That back-and-forth banter between Garth and Josie WAS the book. I loved it! I kind of wish we got more of Josie and her side of things, but I know this was more about Garth and his inner struggles. I especially loved how she incorporated the title into the story, so sweet and so clever. 
 Garth was truly a character after my own heart. The whole time I read this book, I just wanted to hug him! He was definitely a lot deeper than I initially thought. He goes through a slew of emotions in this book. You get a few glimpses of his past, especially how he met and fell for Josie, ugh, I just wanted to hug this guy! A lot of things happened in Garth's life, especially his relationship with his father, to turn him into the man he is now. His tough and devil-may-care exterior obviously masked deeper emotions he just didn't know how to show, and I loved being in his head and seeing him work through it all. Sometimes it did feel a bit much, but I understood why he was so self-deprecating due to his past, so I didn't mind much. 
 Finders Keepers is a great novel. Garth is a complex character that stirs a lot of emotions in you and really makes you feel. The story flowed smoothly and quickly. I flew through the pages! Nicole's writing is engaging, her characters are fun, and the dialogue is witty. What's not to love?