I can usually read trashy books with glee, but I couldn't get through this. I got sick of feeling like I was being manipulated by the author. And though I did not finish this, I am so worried that the solution is "the protagonist was drunk." I didn't care what the solution was because I was like, "the protagonist sounds legit nuts." It wasn't eerie enough for me to really wonder what had happened. Someone probably smuggled the girl on the boat and threw her over? Is that what happens? I don't care. 
 I hate-read my way through IN A DARK, DARK WOOD in a really fun way. But I was not having fun reading this. With 100 pages left, I was eyeing my copy of THE HAUNTING OF HILL HOUSE and wishing I could get on to it, and it was such a relief to allow myself to give up on THE WOMAN IN CABIN 10 and get on to better reading.