Java Girl's review posted at Guilty Pleasures Book Reviews 
 4.5 stars 
 Everything I Left Unsaid is a cliffhanger, a fact I wasn't aware of when I chose to read and review it. I'm not a fan of cliffhangers, and I feel strongly that readers should be warned about them in the book descriptions, BUT, I loved this book-the writing, the characters, the plot-everything about it, except the cliffhanger ending. So, I'm a little conflicted. I wouldn't have chosen this book had I known about the cliffhanger, and I would have missed out on a wonderful story, beautifully written, with interesting, well-developed characters whose journeys truly captivated me. Everything I Left Unsaid is refreshingly different and appealing. From M.O'Keefe's word choices, humor, and the way the main characters interacted with one another, I genuinely was enthralled by this book. What kind of romance novel has the H/h not meeting face to face until 70% into the book? Dylan and Annie's contact up to that point is solely via telephone. These conversations between two broken strangers are anything but simple; the calls are revealing, provocative, sexy, and heartbreaking, yet cathartic and healing.I couldn't help but want more for the two of them, yet I completely understood the author keeping them apart. The secondary characters, and there are quite a few in this book, are equally as intriguing to me. Small pieces of their stories and their relationships to the other characters are slowly revealed, just enough to leave me with a burning need to know the rest. 
 I'm still not a fan of cliffhangers, but I am beyond thrilled and excited to have "found" M. O'Keefe. I'm dying to read the next book, The Truth About Him. 
 Review copy provided for an honest review.