Moonlight on Nightingale Way has all the elements I love from a Samantha Young book, despite some elements I didn't quite like. This one is quite the emotional and heartfelt book that brings home the importance of family, whether they're family by blood or by choice. 
 Grace was a great character. She's had terrible luck in the love dept and we see her go on a few dates in the book, which turn out to be disasters. There was one prospect though that I would've liked her to explore before investing in Logan and I'm sad nothing came of it. I loved that she was a book editor and how that tied into the other characters in this series. I also loved that she had her own set of lovable friends and I could easily see myself enjoying reading stories of them. She's a very nice person and she doesn't like confrontations, which plays into how she lets Logan do what he does even though it disrupts her life. She's also had quite the terrible childhood. I seriously hated her family and even though we don't get to meet any of them, except her father briefly, I could already tell they're terrible people. I'm glad Grace was able to maintain some semblance of normalcy and turned her life around, in part, thanks to her friends. 
 I liked Logan for the part. I loved how important family is to him, especially his sister. The sacrifice he made for her was touching and it's sad to see how much he changed because of it. He's one of those guys who are pretty guarded and it was tough to get behind his facade to see what he was really thinking and feeling, which was probably why it took awhile for me to really warm up him. He's got the sexy thing down, that's not a problem, getting him to open up and be vulnerable was, which was understandable given his circumstances, but still. When he finally did, that when I fell. He won me over in the end, although he's certainly not my favorite from the series. 
 The big problem I had with this book, and what kept it from being a 4 star read for me, was Maya, which I'll go into in a bit. Another element that I didn't care for was how there was such a sudden, very abrupt, change in Logan from being the inconsiderate playboy next door to the loving guy he ended up being. Logan has a revolving door of women come through his apartment and none of them are considerate of the fact that Grace is living next door. That's all fine and dandy, but because of one crazy wrench that's thrown into Logan's life, the switch is flipped in a nanosecond, and we're supposed to forget the way he treated, and viewed, Grace and how Grace saw him. I couldn't get on board with how that aspect was executed. 
 As for Maya, I just couldn't connect with her at all. Yes, I sympathized with her situation, but I didn't agree with a lot of what she did. At times she seemed so mature and responsible, especially given her up-bringing, but then at times, she was so immature and whiney, it annoyed me. Her role in Logan's life is important, yes I get it, but the way she clung to Grace and acted out because of what she wanted, not what Grace or Logan wanted, it was selfish and I didn't care for it. This is another one of those times where I felt like this kind of plot tool was just added in order to get the main characters together. There was too much of Maya, and everyone else, wanting Grace and Logan to be together and not enough of Young actually showing that they should be together, them, as two individuals as a couple, separated from Maya and Logan's extended "family". There's a right way and a wrong way to use this plot tool, and this wasn't the right way for me. 
 In any case, I'm definitely sad to see this series end, even though I know Young recently announced she wrote a novella related to the series. Either way, I have grown to love and cherish these characters and these stories over the years. This series and Young have been consistent in their ability to grab my attention and tell a captivatingly romantic story with each book. Despite my obvious gripes with this book in particular, there were certain elements from Young that I still loved and in the end, I rooted for Logan and Grace. Seeing how each couple is now, enjoying their happily-ever-afters, makes my heart swell and I couldn't be happier having read and completed this series.