Judging on illustrations alone: (4.5 stars) 
 Beautiful, they were great. Pretty close to how I imagined the characters too. Except Dimitri. With the exception of his hair, that was not how I pictured him at all. I pictured him taller, thinner, more lithe. This depicts him as sort of bulky, he reminded me of Beast after he turns human. 
 If I'm judging how well the actual plot was translated: (two stars) 
 Basically it goes like this: 
 Info dump. 
 Rose goes into Lissa's mind. 
 Something totally irrelevant. 
 Ross goes into Lissa's mind. 
 Something totally irrelevant. 
 Rose goes into Lissa's mind. 
 Info dump. 
 Weird random scene with Rose and Dimitri.* 
 Rose goes into Lissa's mind. 
 Action. 
 Something that is actually relevant. 
 Action. 
 End. 
 Literally. I know they are supposed to be shortened but this was crazy. Way too many things left out. No character development, no connections, etc. Dimitri all of the sudden "loves" Rose? They had like two scenes together-where he almost called her pretty and when Victor brainwashed them. 
 Please, please read the actual novels. I won't be reading the rest of the graphic novels in this series.