Pros: 
 -Rape survivor story, pretty realistic growth for someone who had such a terrible tragedy dealt to them copes and moves on with their life. 
 -Although the main theme behind Garrett is "jock who is man whore falls in love with girl and changes his ways" his character is surprisingly likeable and tackles just as much issues as Hannah's. (view spoiler)[Garrett comes from an abusive family where his father used to beat him and his mother. This is equally realistically portrayed. (hide spoiler)] 
 -The way Garrett goes above and beyond what I expect of him and takes care of and truly cares for Hannah and her experiences. 
 Cons: 
 -This is a typical New Adult book about a man whore who essentially falls in love with a girl and he changes his ways. 
 -This book has a bet/deal/compromise that makes them fall for each other. I see this used a lot in New Adult books. Not sure if it's overused since sometimes they are really well done. Just wish some authors were more creative.