SPOILER FREE!!! 
 3.75* ( may change) 
 This book had very realistic scenarios. I did enjoy the writing and the friendship aspect.It was an emotional roller coaster and it contained a lot of touchy subjects. I knew the author wrote from her heart and I am really glad with the ending. It had something in it different that made it stand out. Lily is such a strong character and I loved her. However one of my complaints is that I was not touched emotionally with Lily and Rhyle's relationship. For me it did not feel real and it felt as if it was more of a sexual relationship pertaining to lust more than love. I did not really enjoy all the time jumps the author. Maybe I am just not accustomed to her writing style. Oh and can I just say how much more I was interested in Marshall than Rhyle???? Marshall is so funny and cute ;) My ratings may change depending on how I feel about this book. Oh and I can not forget Atlas. He was one of my favourite character and I loved the scenes with him. It felt more real some how. 
 FRTC