I'm being generous with my rating here. I didn't hate it, but that's maybe because I haven't read the first two books, I didn't even know it was part of a series when I got the audio book. It could have been worse I guess...it helped me pass some time and it wasn't the worst book I have ever read. But despite the questionable plot (made even more so now I've read a bit about the first two books) there were some simple editing mistakes. Like how when Ivy and Gabriel leave them at the cabin they don't take the car, but when they return I think Beth says she heard the car so knew they were back. Also she had pyjamas...but Gabriel and Ivy came in a rush so how would they have packed? This is just going from memory so I may have missed something but little errors like that really annoy me, there's just no reason. The book was kind of bad anyway but that makes it even worse.