4.5 stars!!! 
 I've had this on my TBR forever and I'm so glad that I finally got the chance to read it! I've never read anything by Abbi before and now I can't wait to read the rest of this series!! 
 Maggie and West's characters absolutely stole my heart! Both were going through things that would difficult for anyone to deal with, let alone at their age. I loved how each character was the others perfect counter part and solace. 
 Maggie is the perfect kind of YA heroine. Everyone thinks that she is weak and fragile, but in reality she is a pillar of strength. When Maggie opened herself up to talking to West, I FELL IN LOVE. Totally. Completely. In. Love. And there was no going back. I wanted to walk around like Buddy the Elf yelling, "I'm in love, I'm in love and I don't care who knows it!!!!" 
 I was soooooo close to a full 5 star, but there were a few things that just were never full addressed and that drives me wacko. Maybe they'll be addressed in the next few books, but I was disappointed that they weren't wrapped up in this books. This will definitely not deter me from the rest of the series! Bring on Under The Lights!