So, first off, I loved reading a YA novel made for teens of faith who want to learn more about the intersection of LGBTQ interests and religion. Jo, an out-and-proud lesbian from Atlanta, is asked to "lie low" by her preacher father when his new marriage moves them to small-town Georgia. Jo immediately meets a cute girl in her church group and in the way of YA, complications and angst ensue. Georgia Peaches teeters precariously between fluffy and dramatic. The drama didn't so much appeal to me, but I appreciate that this book exists, as it will have a wide appeal for teens no matter their sexual identity. Memorable side characters both cause and help to make up for all of the major angst. The end result is thoughtful and sweet. 
 {3.5 stars rounded up}