I have to say, I was both sort of let-down as well as pleasantly surprised, by this book. It wasn't quite as romantic or sweepingly lovely as I feel like popular opinion led me to believe, though there were times where it was romantic. I have to say I far prefer the historical fiction aspects and the thrilling bits over the rest. Honestly I felt like the author leaned a bit heavily on the many depictions or threats of rape throughout, also frequently the descriptions of things were a bit on the flowery side and it made it confusing to understand what was happening. I would've preferred some straight-up sex scenes over the vague flowery descriptions but maybe that's just me. I do see why many people have issues with the brutality, especially of Jamie, but I do think it about fits the era and circumstances, plus Claire does rectify that problem eventually. 
 All in all, the book was a bit sloppy in character development sometimes, but there are scenes that are very well-done. It was good enough that I want to read the next one, but not great enough that I feel like I have to go out and buy it right this second. I'd recommend to those who enjoy a good, harsh, historical fiction, rather than those that enjoy romance.