I was actually a big fan of The Hunger Games which might be surprising since I'm usually not the target audience for YA fiction. It's actually a little embarassing to admit the degree to which I liked the first book. I enjoyed the premise, thought the story was quite unique, and found it to be a fun/suspenseful read. I thought that book also had some smart things to say about society's obsession with violence and reality TV. 
 Unforunately, Catching Fire is a step back into mediocrity. The second installment basically feels like a repeat of the first (it's like if Ocean's Twelve was about robbing Caeser's because Rusty's ex is now dating that casino's owner). The pacing isn't as good and the suspense isn't really there. The love triangle is obnoxious but it would be much worse if Katniss didn't keep critizing herself/asking herself questions (which is unintentionally hilarious). 
 When you take away what was unique and exciting about the first book, all you're really left with is a YA novel that isn't particularly well written. I don't think Suzanne Collins will be confused with Jennifer Egan anytime soon. It's not terrible and I'm sure some will find it to be a page turner. But it definitely is a step down.