Rating over-inflated. 
 Plot is like a 2/5 or 3/5 and writing is like 3/5, but match it up altogether...and you get someone easily enchanted by the easy-goingness and charm. Hear that? I give out high scores if you charm me, even if your writing is straight out of cliche-fest, or there are plotholes. First of the Oxford books follows Penelope Pope moving to NYC, becoming co-sports editor with Cole (god, I've forgotten his surname already) and they have a friends-with-benefits going on, until they just cast away all pretenses, and get together...generic, but very satisfying. Generic is underrated. Especially this easy-going kind! Not much brain cells needed - thank goodness. Brilliant chick-lit writing.