Shannon Hale is one of my favorite authors. Her portrayal of female heroines is so strong and amazing. But this book was a disappointment. This was actually her first time (I'm pretty sure) writing a science fiction novel. In my opinion, I don't think she did as well as she did with fantasy. The book was quite cliche. The romance with Wilder was so irritating. Maisie was very intelligent with one arm and all, but its like so many other books I've read before. The love triangle just pissed me off. If Luther had feelings why didn't he tell her? Okay, fine he didn't tell her but it was so typical and I felt like I was in a high school drama. The plot was pretty enticing. Overall, a big disappointment. Note to Shannon Hale: Please continue to do fantasy. No offense, but those books are so much better.