I can't tell how I love this book. :3 It was so beautiful to read about the choir lessons, I felt the connection and the deepest and fondest emotions to sing in a group and the magic of music and what songs can express. <3 
 The growing relationship between Rhys and John was awesome. It was realistic, like a rip off the real life , a slice of life... :3 I really loved how both try to get over their emotions, their burden, their past... 
 The songs mentioned and played in the book fit perfectly... 
 I was totally emotionally bound, I was touched, I laughed, had bittersweet aches while reading and I had to cry (view spoiler)[ when John and Rhys performed at the funeral of the kind lady... This scene made my cry... other parts too, but this was the most emotional part of all (hide spoiler)] 
 I really liked how Jay Northcote combined different things in her book: singing (I sang myself in a choir, too so I loved how well described everything was, including the preparations for a proper singing <3), being in a group including the bonds those coalition made, being kind to older folks (working a retirement center by myself let me recognize a lot of things which were told in the book) and give them something back and on the other hand teaching younger like John does... 
 The book contains a real circle of life... 
 And above all the title stands for it all: imperfect harmony. 
 I'm out of words <3 
 5 out of 5 stars