Colton Underwood didn't propose to Cassie Randolph during the season finale of The Bachelor. However, he still got a Neil Lane ring. The happy couple appeared on Tuesday's episode of Jimmy Kimmel Live!, where they received a little gift from The Bachelor's go-to jeweler. Jimmy Kimmel joked the two got "cheated a little bit" because they didn't walk away with a shiny new sparkler. So, the late-night host called Lane and had him send a ring. At first, it looked like Underwood might pop the question then and there; however, Kimmel assured the former football player he could hold onto the piece. "You know, we've already talked about this," Underwood said, hinting an engagement could be in their future. The ring was quite the stunner, too—featuring a gorgeous center diamond and square halo. It also included a diamond band. However, Kimmel told the reality stars they could also exchange it. "But if you don't want that one, you can pick out a different one. It doesn't have to be that ring," he said. "Or, go to a pawnshop and get loaded."<doc-sep>Many Bachelor Nation fans would agree that this season of The Bachelor was the most dramatic yet. When Colton Underwood and Cassie Randolph announced their relationship to the world, sans an engagement ring, everyone gasped in shock. The audacity! However, the reality TV star still snagged a massive diamond sparkler from the franchise's go-to jeweler, Neil Lane. Surprisingly, it was all thanks to Jimmy Kimmel. On Tuesday's episode of Jimmy Kimmel Live!, Cassie left the show with a new accessory, despite the fact that Colton didn't drop down to one knee. The beautifully demure jewelry piece comes with a pretty penny, as it's estimated to retail for $25,000. "In such a Neil Lane setting, this ring would probably retail for around $25k," Andrew Brown, President of WP Diamonds tells E! News. As for the details on the dazzling rock? It's a "diamond and platinum set princess cut ring," Lane states in a press release sent to us. It's "just over 3 carats, with the center diamond accented by 162 round brilliant cut diamonds."<doc-sep>Colton Underwood also opens up about his recent move to Los Angeles to be closer to Cassie Randolph The Bachelor's Colton Underwood on Engagement Plans with Cassie: 'She Will Have a Ring One Day' The Bachelor duo Colton Underwood and Cassie Randolph have been waiting four long months for the world to find out about their relationship, and now they’re ready to shout it from the rooftops. “We’re so excited to be out in public and not have to hide anymore,” Underwood, 27, tells PEOPLE in the latest cover story. “I’m so in love, and I’m ready for everyone to know it.” Get push notifications with news, features and more. Adds Randolph, 23: “We can finally be outwardly happy, and not have to keep this big secret.” For more on Cassie and Colton, pick up this week’s issue of PEOPLE, on stands Friday 3_25_cover Credit: Jim Wright It was a season to remember, most notably because the former football player diverged from the traditional Bachelor path in more ways than one. “I know there’s a certain format that comes along with being The Bachelor,” says Underwood, who broke things off with runners-up Tayshia Adams and Hannah Godwin after Randolph left, overwhelmed by the possibility of an imminent proposal. “But this was about the rest of my life. And I couldn’t risk giving Cassie up.” That means the pair aren’t engaged — for now, at least. “She doesn’t have a ring on her finger yet,” says Underwood. “But she will, one day.” “We definitely talk about our future engagement,” Randolph, a speech pathologist, adds. “We’re both excited to get to that point.” bachelorwin-1 Credit: Jim Wright Ring or no ring, they are making (major) moves for the future. “I am now a California resident,” says Underwood, who moved from Denver to Los Angeles to be closer to Randolph, whom he calls “girlfriend,” in West Hollywood. Still, the couple says they won’t move in together, just yet. “Our goal is to buy a house in Huntington Beach in the next year, but we probably won’t move in together until we’re engaged or married,” says Underwood. “As much as I want her to live with me, it’s a big step and something we both take very seriously.”<doc-sep>The wait is over, you can finally see this adorable panda cub Viral 'Charlie bit my finger' video to be taken down. Here's why (CNN) — The article contains spoilers about the season 23 finale of “The Bachelor” It’s the moment “Bachelor” fans have been waiting for, Colton Underwood handed out his final rose on “The Bachelor” finale Tuesday night. It was a suspenseful two-night finale for fans after Underwood was dumped by Cassie Randolph on Monday night’s episode, leaving him with Tayshia and Hannah G. But in a shocking turn of events, Underwood turned around and said goodbye to both remaining women in order to ask Randolph for another chance. Underwood was able to chase Randolph down before she left Portugal and she agreed to meet his family and travel with him to Mallorca, Spain. They dated for a week and even had their night in the fantasy suite. But big questions still remained: Are they engaged? Did Underwood lose his virginity? Underwood and Randolph did get back together in Portugal and are still together. But they are not engaged, not living together and just taking things day by day. Underwood did reveal that he recently moved to Los Angeles to be closer to Randolph. As for whether Underwood lost his virginity, he and Randolph played coy and would only say they did what was “best” for their relationship. Host Chris Harrison took that as a yes. Although fans may have been disappointed that this season did not end in an engagement, Underwood did get a chance to hand out his final rose to Randolph during the live portion of the finale. Sometimes slow and steady wins the race, folks.<doc-sep>
Ever since the latest season of The Bachelor ended, fans have been eagerly anticipating the moment Colton Underwood and Cassie Randolph announce their engagement. It seemed that moment might be imminent when it was revealed that Underwood already has a ring stored away in an underwear drawer somewhere. Alas, apparently that won't be the ring. A report by Marie Claire indicates that Underwood is looking to return that particular piece of jewelry. The couple, who opted not to get engaged in the finale of the show, was still given a Neil Lane ring by ABC late night talk show host Jimmy Kimmel with which Underwood could pop the question. Unfortunately, the ring is not their style at all. The publication describes the ring as a "square-cut, three-carat diamond which is set in a platinum band and surrounded by a double halo made of 162 smaller brilliant-cut diamonds." Sadly, it hasn't wowed Randolph at all, who appears to have somewhat lukewarm feelings about the piece. Luckily for her, it appears her beau seems to agree with her and has decided that rather than stick them both with a ring they would happily walk past in the store, they will be trading it in for something that is more their style. Here's Why Colton Underwood Is Returning the Engagement Ring He Got The Bachelor Winner Cassie Randolph https://t.co/EHh3nRbZaE pic.twitter.com/pfx9dXsnmn — BRIDES (@brides) March 30, 2019 "I was told that I could trade it in," Colton explained to the hosts when he appeared on LadyGang. "I didn't order it!" Randolph was also phoned by the hosts on the show to confirm that she didn't like the ring either. Her response? "I just have a very particular idea in my mind." And let's be realistic, every girl has a "particular idea" in mind when it comes to the ring she wants to wear for the rest of her life. Underwood then further impressed the LadyGang hosts by showing he knows exactly what his girl really wants to see in that little black box when he does get down on one knee. "Cass wants a gold, simple band, with an oval-cut [stone]." The couple has explained that they are not only planning on moving in together sometime in the not-too-distant future but are also already planning for their future engagement. Although they haven't made the big move (in) just yet, Underwood has moved to Los Angeles so that the couple can be together. Making sure their fans know they have plenty of big plans for their future already, Underwood and Randolph appeared in a photo posted to his Instagram account wearing matching jackets, with Randolph's reading "Future Mrs." next to Underwood's with his name splashed across the back.