i-nique Premium Napa leather case (Apple iPod Touch 2nd Gen 2G) (8GB/16GB/32GB) - Black
Major problem:  the 26-mm wide case of the dock connector would not fit into the 24-mm wide slot in the bottom of the first case received, so the iPod touch 2G had to be removed from the case for charging and syncing. I-nique apologized and sent another case and told me to keep the first. Same problem with the second case. After several exchanges of emails during which I attached photographic proof I asked that they send a case hand picked from stock but they countered by asking me to return both cases to E