This completes the detailed comparison of the Kubo formulas and chiral responses with and without torsion. To conclude, in our view, some of the conclusions of [1]} (see also [2]}) regarding torsion are not correct. In particular, torsion leads to non-vanishing, independent currents with similar DC anomaly coefficients as for CVE. We have obtained the response in terms of explicit torsional currents, equivalent to results of previous work, utilizing the same linear response Kubo formulas. The only case when torsion does not contribute, is when it vanishes for the background (as is the case for the original Kubo formula computations). Again, it is a separate problem to ascribe the hydrodynamic degrees of freedom and constitutive relations with sources for a particular problem of chiral fermions and transport. Our results simply says that when torsion (i.e. tetrad and connection) is an independent hydrodynamic source variable, it activates chiral currents at finite chemical potential and temperature in relativistic systems. If only the metric enters, the response in terms of the CVE follows.
