Judah kalah angka pada 2006 atas Mayweather, juara WBC, serta Carlos Baldomir dan dihentikan pada ronde ke-11 oleh petinju Puerto Rico, Cotto, Juni lalu.
Judah lost unanimous 2006 decisions to Mayweather, the World Boxing Council champion, and Carlos Baldomir and was stopped in the 11th round by Puerto Rico's Cotto last June.