Tim Tony Mowbray unggul dua gol saat mereka ditahan imbang 2-2 setelah perpanjangan waktu di Hawthorns, tetapi Charlton gagal dalam dua tembakan dari titik penalti dalam adu penalti tersebut dan Albion menang 4-3.
Tony Mowbray's team blew a two-goal lead as they were held 2-2 after extra-time at the Hawthorns, but Charlton missed two of their five spot-kicks in the shoot out and Albion won 4-3.