This podcast is brought to you and made possible by generous financial aid from Peter kanzler K. Ay n z l-- e-- r-- you can buy his Amazon books at your favorite Amazon Branch, for example, the original texts of lock Hobbs and the US Constitution of Pennsylvania put together into one book for only $15. Thanks for listening what happened? So now we've got to the point where the story says. Well human beings became self-conscious. And here's here's the problem with that. The problem is is that we're terribly self conscious about our inadequacies in our vulnerabilities and that that sets up enmity between men and women and it Dooms women to pain in childbirth and child rearing and Adams men to work. It's a big problem. Okay. So now the next story that Hands up in the sequence is the story of Cain and Abel now, you know, we talked about the dragon of chaos, and then the terrible mother and the creative mother and on the tyrannical father in the secure father and then the adversary and the hero Cain and Abel are the first manifestation of the adversary in the hero. And what happens is they emerge as soon as the Genesis the original Genesis story ends. So what the story basically proposes is that we once people became self-conscious two modes of being emerged as a consequence of that and one mode is represented by Kane and the other mode is represented by Abel and that's echoed in the story of the Hostile Brothers in stories of hostile Brothers everywhere, but it's also paralleled in Christianity by the idea of the relationship between Christ and Satan. So it's like Cain and Abel are precursors to the idea of Christ and and and Satan now, what happens is that So Kane is the older brother and that makes him sort of the embodiment of tradition. He would also be the favored one in terms of the traditions of the ancient Israelites because he would be the one that inherits everyone so everything so he's actually the one that's he's like the embodiment of tradition and there's some out some advantages to that because he's privileged because of it but there's some disadvantages because to the degree that culture itself has become sterile and inappropriate and he manifests that that means that he Error by merely being what he was now what happens with an enable is the young is the Young Brother. so Abel was a keeper of sheep, but Cain was a tiller of the ground. Okay. So there's there's a there's a dichotomy of professions here and people have read that in all sorts of different ways. But one of the ways that you can think about it is that there are valid different modes of being in the world, you know, so you can be in this situation. You can be a tiller of the ground or keeper of animals, but in the world in general you can adopt any number of roles that suffice you can be a plumber you can be a lawyer. Um, and there are there's there's ways of acting within those roles that transcend the roles themselves. And so that's part of what's being exemplified in Cain and Abel so they can they can function in the world despite their different. They're different roles in process of time. It came to pass that Cain brought of the fruit of the ground an offering unto the Lord and Abel. He also brought of the firstlings of his flock and of the fat thereof now that's very archaic the idea of sacrifice. Okay, so basically, What happens is that you're trying to get God on your side? And so God seems to want something from you because he's keeps demanding this and that so you might say well reality wants something from you once you to behave in a certain way so that you don't suffer any more than you have to and so that things go well for you now human beings at this point in time. We're trying to work out exactly what that means and they've already got to the point where they're conceptually sophisticated enough to understand that that means that sacrifices are necessary. Now you remember that it's only prior to this that human beings. Over time itself, right? That's when they discovered that their they become self-conscious and discover their extension across time. And so one of the consequences of realizing that your extended across time is that you also will come to the realization that you may have to let go of certain valuable things right now in order to make things work better in the future and you can't imagine that people just woke up and figure that out. I can took people God only knows how long to sort that out its tens of thousands of years to come up with that realization. First of all, they I would have acted it out like bees. Do you know they collect honey and they make it through the winter, but they don't know what the hell they're doing or maybe they do maybe their little supercomputers like these bloody atoms. But you know what, I mean, you can act as sort of thing out with without realizing what you're up to and the motif of sacrifice seem to be exactly that people stumbled onto the dramatic idea that if you gave up something of value there would be some reasonable possibility that God would smile on you in the future. Okay, so so that's why there's the sacrifices You might say well, why did they burn them? And the reason for that is well, as far as I can tell people are trying to understand what the ultimate fabric of existence is. And I think that you can feel that sometimes and one of the places that people feel that regularly is when they're out at night and they look up at the sky and they see this immense blanket of Eternity that's laid out before them and that induces a feeling of awe and I think that that archaic people took the notion of that all that was as a consequence of this apprehension and Associated that with some something like communion with the Divine which is actually quite reasonable because when you are looking out into space you are looking into the farthest reaches of being you can see back Millions hundreds of millions of years back into time and you see you gaze out into the infinite expanses of being so it's not unreasonable to assume that in some sense at that moment. You have some connection with what's infinite, whatever that happens to be and I think that you feel that Rather than think it so anyways, the idea basically emerged that the Divine was up in the sky and that because the Divine was up in the sky you could maybe communicate it with it by sending messages up there and one of the ways you could do that was with smoke. And so if you burning these things that you're offering you get to push the smoke up to God and he can do it molecular analysis and see if what you're offering is of any reasonable quality and if it seems to be then poof, you know God's going to be thrilled about that or maybe he's not now. What happens is that Cain's offerings are rejected and Abel's offerings are accepted. And so what that means is that Cain gets the short end of the stick and able gets everything good happening to him. So what you see happening is that there's the notion of two Paths of being one that's favored in one that isn't favored. Now the story's very ambivalent about why Kane is not favored enable is and you can you can read it multiple ways. You can just say well God's basically being a son of a bitch and he's not going to give Anything just because he's not in a very good mood that day or you can say well Abel's doing something right and Kane isn't and I think that interpreting the story in either of those ways is is perfectly Illuminating because part of the time in life, it seems like someone's doing everything right and still they're just getting laid waste left right and center and someone else is doing something terribly and things are going well for them. And but then you also see the reverse where someone who's doing well gets rewarded in someone who isn't doesn't so there's an devil anse about it now. I think the story does indicate that Kane is doing something wrong, but it doesn't do that until later. So anyways Sorry, let me just go down to the next section here. So what it can enable sacrifice in the biblical version cited here the nature of Cain sacrifices left unclear except that it is of the ground its vegetative and therefore bloodless every canonical tail. However carries with it a surrounding cloud of similar stories some derivative sum of the product of a different developmental path and tradition some intermingled with other stories in some variants Cain's sacrifice is not only of the ground but it's of low-quality Kane is unwilling to offer up the finest fruits of his labor. God that's he does not really sacrifice anything he wants to keep everything good to himself. So he's selfish as well as faithless Able by contrast offers up the best of what he has. What does this mean? Once again, we already know we say to our children do your best do not hide your light under a bushel. We do not say conserve your best or hide your best. We mean offer the best you have do it in good faith. You will not be absolutely assured of success, but your chances will begin to increase to the degree that such. Kris is possible. Certainly. It's an overstatement to say that if you do not believe this you at least wish with all your heart that it was true. This is hope to not believe this is to risk descent into the deepest chasms of cynicism. So what happens God accepted Abel's sacrifice offers him respect and renders his life acceptable despite its terrible limitations cane sacrifice. However, he rejects this drives Kane into a murderous rage rage. So the Lord God had respect unto Abel and his offering but unto Cain and his offering Did not have respect. So the idea basically is that able makes these sacrifices? He's putting forth the best that he has he's doing his best and because of that it's actually working Everyone likes able, you know, he has he's getting along with his wives his flocks or increasing its he's a good guy. It's like everything's going well. Whereas cane things aren't going very well at all and no one really cares for him and besides that he's burning with jealousy because you know, despite the fact that he's slaving away raising all these vegetables and try to offer them to God nothing is going his way. So not only are things going badly for him, but he's Increasingly disaffected by it and you know you it's not difficult to understand that, you know perfectly. Well that what happens to you if you're working away you think diligently and properly and nothing is going your way and some other son of a bitch is just flourishing like mad beside you that that's going to make you vengeful and and irritated and anxious and angry and and homicidal for that matter and it doesn't take very long before people reach that stage at least not in their fantasies now the story says And Cain was very wroth and his countenance fell and what that meant is he's angry and his face changes to indicate that so he's got this continual look of Perpetual disaffected ation and anger on his face because things aren't going well for so that's fine. So then he goes and has a chat with God because he's not very happy about the whole situation and I think people do that all the time too. Even if they don't necessarily formulate it in those terms. It's like they're thinking well, what's the nature of reality? I'm busting myself in half. Here trying to make things work properly and nothing's going. Well. It's like what kind of stupid universe is that and for all intents and purposes. That's a cola Coy with God because you don't start thinking about the ultimate fabric of reality without bringing religious intuitions into it. You can't even ask such a question without acting in a quasi-religious manner. So this is what happens it took me a long time to unpack this so he goes and has the chat with yahwah with God and the Lord said to Cain why are you angry and downcast? Surely if you do, right you ought to hold your head high sin crouches at your door lusting for you yet. You can Master it now. That's very very interesting. So I translated those. I got a translation to those lines from a guy named miles from 1995 now it's so what happens is that Kane goes and has a chat with God about how things aren't going very well and basically what he's trying to do is hold God to account for why he made such a stupid Universe where everything keeps going wrong and what God says to To him is why are you angry and downcast? If you do write you ought to be able to hold your head high? So there's an intimation there that the reason the cane is wandering around like this is because there's actually something he's doing that's not correct. It's not that the structure of realities got a problem. It's that Kane has a problem. And God says well if you just do things properly then you could stand up you wouldn't have to be a defeated Lobster all hunched over an aggravated you could stand up and you know, hold yourself properly and Beep beep beep thoroughly integrated in a proper manner with the way being is unfolding and then he says sin crutches at your door lusting for you yet. You can Master it now. That's a very interesting line. So I found out that there is a There's an under there's a metaphorical context within which those lines are uttered. And here's the context. So God basically tells cane that sin, which is misbehavior is a kind of personality and the personality that he Associates it with is something like a sexually aroused predatory cat and he tells Kane that he's no canes in the house and that thing is crouching at the door and it's waiting to jump on it, and then he tells cane that. That's a real threat and it's right there, but he could he could not have that happen if he wants it and there's a whole set of inferences in there one inference is Kane invites it in now you remember you may not remember you have to invite a vampire into your house. It can't just come in my of its own accord. You have to open the door. And so that's the first thing God tells Kane. It's like yeah sure things aren't going very well but like that things at your door you invited it in and you could Master it if you want, but you chose not to and then the next thing that That the conceptualization of the sin as this sort of angry and lustful cap. There's a sexual connotation to it. And so the thing pounces on Kane and has its way with him. So there's an idea that there's a like a quasi sexual interaction between Kane and this Force so that it's a creative interplay. It's not only that he's dominated by the sin. It's that he brings it in and enters into a creative Union with it and produces something out of the out of the mixture. ER and so for example when I was reading the Columbine kids, right, it's like you can see exactly that and their behavior. It's like he knew perfectly. Well what he was up to he knew perfectly. Well what he was inviting in and he put his own extraordinarily creative Twist on it wasn't just that he was possessed by an idea. He spent months planning with his horrible little compatriot about exactly how they were going to blow up the school and the town and they would have liked to have blown up the whole damn city that was part of their plan and exactly how they were going to turn that into. a creative spectacle that would be covered by networks all over the land perfectly consciously every single bit of this so they put their own twist on it as a consequence of being angry and resentful and unhappy, you know, so anyways, so God tells Cain, you know, why are you coming to complain to me? There's nothing wrong with reality. It's he like you get your act together and behave properly you can stand up hold your head up high and you don't have to let this thing that's tempting you have its way with you and enter into a creative Union with it. You could just behave properly and so cane leaves and then he's really annoyed and the reason he's annoyed is because he's going in there hoping they'll straighten guard out with a little chat and sent reality straight and basically what he finds out is that as far as God's concerned the reason that all these terrible things are happening to him is Guess he's not anywhere near what he could be and he's setting himself up for continual failure. And so that really annoys him. So not only is he mad about the fact that he's failing but he's even more mad because when he thought it through he realized that it was actually his fault and that the reason these things are happening to him is because he's not what he could be. So then he might think well, what does he do as a consequence, you know, you could think well, he could say well little apology to God and try to get himself on the right track and that isn't what happens at all. He goes and kills Abel with a Iraq Now you think well, why does he do that? Well, that's very complicated. It's partly well able is obviously God's favorite. So he's doing everything he can to pull him down and you think people do that all the time. If you're jealous of someone else's accomplishments these things really play themselves out in junior high and high school, but they also play out in in adult life. You'll do everything you can to pull down the thing that's you know, hovering above you and making you look bad from as a consequence of the reflection. It's easier to Troy the ideal than it is to try to live up to it and people do that all the time and then they're punishing each other for their virtues and they do that because well first of all because they can pull down the ideal and then they don't have the mirror that makes themselves uncomfortable, but they can also do that as revenge against God. It's like well if that's what you favor and you're going to torture me to death then I'll just destroy what you've brought up to be the best manifestation of what is at this point and then we'll just see who's who's winning this war who's winning the war of Being and so that's what happens. He goes out and kills Abel and so God comes along. It's a terrible thing because it means he destroys his own ideal, but he's perfectly willing to pay that price as long as he can get revenge for his misery and his revenge on God and it's interesting too because if you look at the writings of people who commit real atrocities, you can see that they've gone far beyond any desire for individual revenge like the kids that people that the Columbine kids shot up and in the high school. Didn't even necessarily have any grudge against those particular kids. It was like Mayhem for Mayhem sake and it was actually better if they shot someone that was innocent because that was a lot more of a protest and shooting someone who was guilty, you know, if you're shooting someone who's bullied you it's like that's just jealous. That's just Justice. I mean, it's a warped and bent form of justice. But if you go into the high school and shoot someone who's been good to you. Well, then you're really making a statement about just what you think about the world and if you're willing to blow your own, Own head off afterwards. Well, it's just that much more indication that you could say to hell with everything and that nothing is worth having and that's like that's a that's a that's a demonstration of that mode of thinking right down to the bottom. So anyways, he goes out there and he kills Abel. I'll read you this paragraph. Kane is faced with the very Stark Choice his pride his belief in his own omniscience compels him to repeat actions that do not presume to produce their desired outcome despite yourself, Define failure. This breeds a deep resentment once his pride and resentment grow past a certain threshold. He starts to fantasize about revenge and then about murder the gap between fantasy and action grows even smaller as resentment built and one day the opportunity manifests itself. Abel says something optimistic deserving and promising and that straw breaks the camel's back. Perhaps it is at first it is just resentment of the successful deep resentment, but it does not have to end there. There's no real end with enough resentment. You can kill once if you can kill once why not 10 if 10 why not a hundred if a hundred why not ten thousand why not a million Stalin was just getting warmed up when he killed 6 million ukrainians in the 1930s. There's evidence from the KGB archives that Stalin Was preparing for the Third World War when he was killed by his own people in the 1950s and who's to say that Hitler really lost the war depends entirely on what he was aiming for. Maybe he got just what he aimed for when he blew his brains out all over his bunker deep down underneath Berlin while Europe burned to ashes around him. Why do we system on believing that every Tyrant fights a war to win? Cain believed that the world was a terrible an unreasonable Place bent on his suction suffering and destruction. He thought that hard work and sacrifice was for babies and fools, this is from Richard the third why should wrath be mute and fury dumb. I am no baby. I that with base prayers. I should repent the evils that I have done 10,000 worst that ever yet. I did would I perform if I might have my Will if one good deed in all my life. I did I do repent it from my very soul. Eric Harris, this is from Columbine. The most literate of the two killers said I hate the fucking world kill mankind. No one should survive. Most investigators of the Columbine killings claim they cannot understand the boys motivations they could understand them. They just don't want to Harris said I would sooner die than betray my own thoughts. But before I leave this worthless place, I will kill whoever I deem unfit Harris transformed himself into an archetypal embodiment of Cain whose ultimate prototype is motivated. According to Goethe by the following principle. So this is Mephistopheles the spirit. I that endlessly denies and rightly too for all that comes to birth is fit for overthrow as nothing worth where for the world were better sterilized. That's all that's here is evil recognized his game to me in down. 'full downfall runes sin. Very element. I prosper in Harris the day before his mass murder about twenty six point five hours from now the judgment will begun begin difficult but not impossible necessary nerve-wracking and fun. What fun is life without a little death. It's interesting when I'm in my human form knowing I'm going to die Everything Has It triviality to it leader. Yeah, so what happens then is God finds Kayden has a little chat with him. He says when you tell the ground it will not henceforth yield unto thee unto thee her strength. You'll be a fugitive and a vagabond and Cain said unto the Lord. My punishment is greater than I can bear behold thou Hast driven me out of this day from the face of the Earth and from thy face shall I be hidden and I shall be a fugitive and a vagabond in the earth and that it shall come to pass that everyone who finds me will slay me and the Lord said therefore whoever slayeth Cain Vengeance shall be taken. Can upon Him Sevenfold and the Lord said a mark on Cain lest any finding him should kill him. Now what happens in the in the aftermath of that story seems to be something like that. So there's Kane and then Adam and Eve have another son whose name is Seth and Seth produces descendants and want and one of them down. The chain is Noah and he saves the world from the flood but Kane produces descendants to and each of the descendant generation seem to get more and more aggressive and and the generation that produces a man named tubal-cain seems to be the same generation as Noah on the other branch and tubal-cain is by tradition the first person who produces artifacts tools of warfare, and so there's an idea in that Old Testament in this story that it's the individual murderous resentment of the individual who won't make the proper sacrifices that distributes itself into the community and culminates in increasing brutality atrocity and only into war Tubal-cain T. UB Al - Cai n yeah, and so lamech is one of the one of the cane Cain's descendants and this Islamic lamech kills two men when he is wounded and hurt and lamech says unto his wives. Adah and Zillah hear my voice is he wives of lamech hearken unto my speech for I have slain a man to my wounding. And a young man to my hurt if Cain shall be Avenged Sevenfold truly lamech seventy and Sevenfold So This is the idea of the exponential distribution of brutality into the community as a consequence of this initial adoption of a particular form of being. Okay. So here's the situation that that's laid out in Genesis. As far as I can tell is that people emerges self-conscious and not produces a terrible burden on people and then the burden is even either handled in the Free manner with the proper sacrifices or it's not if it's not the consequences are that everything degenerates into brutality and atrocity? And that seems to me to be approximately correct. And so you can understand both Cain and Abel is motivations, you know Cain gets brutal and resentment fold because things don't go well for him and because he's suffering and it might be arbitrary, you know, and sometimes you're suffering does seem to be entirely arbitrary but part of the moral of the story is that if you allow that to make you resentful and vengeful that you'll participate in processes that make things absolutely unbearable and make the entire situation. much worse and all the existential commentary I've read on the things that happened in the second world war and in stallonus Soviet Union and in China for that matter seemed to lay out exactly the same story which is once individuals get corrupted because they're unhappy with the structure of their being they can corrupt the entire social landscape and the entire world and things go from bad to worse until they're as bad as they can possibly be So that's how things go badly. You might think. Well, how do things go well and you know, unfortunately we missed one lecture but there's some things that I can tell you that I that I think I know about what what are you laughing about? No, no, no, no. Well, there's there's other things that I wanted to tell you about, but I can tell you about this. Anyways, I just can't do it in quite as much depth as I would have liked to so it doesn't seem to me that it's reasonable to try to impose an ideological Solution on the world. And the reason that that's not reasonable is because it leads you into something that's akin to a sin of Pride you think you have the damn answer you think, you know everything and you can impose that answer, but the problem with that is that it seems to That's the kind of sacrifice or that produces the kind of sacrifices that God doesn't find very acceptable and things go from bad to worse. So you might say well, what's the alternative what's the potential alternative mode of being and so here's something that you can think about and there's one thing that I want to tell you about Christianity that's relevant in this regard so you can you'll see this in the last quarter of the maps of meaning when you read it, but there's there's images that have popped up in the Middle Ages. Where the trio. Of the tree in the in the Garden of Eden is there again and on the one side of the tree there are skulls and those are being handed out by Eve and on the other side. There are these little things that are there like fruits but their representatives of the hosts that are given to people when they undergo the mass in Christianity. And so those little hosts which are made out of wheat, which is a dying and resurrecting God are like the body of the hero and so the idea behind the mass is that in order to overcome death. You're supposed to incorporate the boss. E of the hero and the body of the hero the hero is the person in this mythological landscape who is willing to voluntarily confront death and will as a consequence be reborn now, I think that that can be read at a psychological level because we already talked about the fact that one of the things that happens that when you're in deep error is that you can allow the erroneous structure to dissolve into something that's chaotic and then have it re-emerged as something that's new the idea. That's and behind this idea of transformation is that you should identify yourself not with the initial state of order, which is like a particular way of looking at the world and you shouldn't identify yourself with the state of chaos that's there when everything collapses around you but that you should identify yourself with the process of transformation from order through chaos and then into a new form of being and so the way that you confront the fact that reality is continually transforming is By allowing yourself to transform with it and that's the volunteer. That's the voluntary that's the taking on of the voluntary that of continual voluntary death and rebirth in the service of higher being and we don't know the potential limits to that. You know, I mean obviously in the current situation everyone is still faced with the possibility of ill health and finite lifespan and all the things that go along with that, but we don't know the Limits of our potential Dynamic flexibility and we sure do know that if you hold onto ways of being that are counterproductive for any length of time that that kills you faster and makes you more miserable. Well, it's happening and the same thing happens as well when you're you know, wallowing and trapped in a chaotic situation. So so here's a hypothesis. So, you know, one of the things that the new agers will tell you is that you should follow your bliss and I have a big problem with that because first of all, I don't think it's true. true and second because you pointed out that if you do follow what you find deeply meaningful, it's likely to take you to a place that you're most afraid of and so to me there's a barrier to Enlightenment and the barrier is that You'll face things that will pull you apart before you'll face things. That'll put you together. And I think that what you face that will pull you apart is all the things that you've done in the past that have been the sambal suboptimal. Those things have to be repaired and fixed now, If you put yourself in a situation where you're able to rectify the errors that you've made in the past so that you straighten out the manner in which you're organized. Then I think that it might be possible to live so that your forthrightly confronting things as they move towards you and if your oriented towards making them better like assume that that's your highest value say well, what's the purpose of life and the purpose of life is to make things as good as you can possibly make them and that might be for you and it might be for those around you and you might not even know exactly what that means. So sometimes you're going to have to let go of what you think good is as you progress towards it. Well, it seems to me that if you Orient yourself towards that and you allow yourself to stop living in in in theories that you know to be false and carrying falsehoods that you're acting out and and believing in that, you know to be not true, but you can start to live in a different way. So here's the different way in some sense. so the first thing you have to figure out is that you don't know what the hell you're doing. The second you have to think to figure out and that's humility. I think the second thing you have to figure out is what you want and you either want things to be better or you want them to be worse and there's reasons for wanting them to be worse and the reasons are deep and they're justifiable, but they're not helpful. So then let's assume that you notice the part of you that's devoted like Cain to the destruction of things and you understand what that is and you're willing to take it on to yourself to repair. Then it isn't other people's evil that you have to worry about. Its your own then you might say well, what should you do next and one of the one of the pieces of literature from which I've learned from that seems to address that is The Sermon on the Mount in the New Testament and one thing that happens in The Sermon on the Mount is this so Christ says to his followers that they should there isn't something specifically that they should be pursuing. What they should be doing instead is orienting themselves in a particular direction and the direction would be towards what's best and what's true. So that's the first step is you figure out do you want things to be better or do you want them to be worse? That's the fundamental question. So are you working for the betterment of being or for its transformation into hell then you think well, I want things to be better than the next thing you think is well, you don't exactly know how to go about that. Okay, so then what do you do? Well, it seems to me that that's the point at time when you try to eradicate from your field of apprehension everything that you know to be false and unworthy. You get rid of it as much as you can as fast as you can and part of the way you can do that is by listening to what you say and watching what you do and you can listen to what you say and you can find out if you're actually saying what you believe to be true now, here's a hypothesis and I think this is Hypothesis that's laid out in the transformation from the Old Testament to the New Testament Christianity. But I also think it's the same idea that the daoist were pursuing and the Buddhists were pursuing. So the idea is this and it's based on the idea of logos what would happen if instead of pursuing what you think you should be pursuing you did something else which is used to say yourself in a position where you're trying to make things better and the next consequence of that is to try I to say as clearly as what you pause as you possibly can what it is that you believe to be true in every situation. And then to see what happens. It's a different way of playing the same game now in The Sermon on the Mount what Christ tells his followers is to orient themselves towards paradise and Truth fundamentally and then to concentrate on doing everything. They possibly can moment to moment as carefully and correctly as possible and then to see what happens. So there's this ancient idea that that route of Western culture that being is spoken into existence. And that's the that's the that's the speech of the logos. And and the idea there is also partly that that in hairs inside people if they if they're willing to utilize it and that they know how they can utilize it and the way to utilize that is to straighten out your speech and action and to act as well as you can moment to moment and to let go other than that. And see what happens because and I think that that's the movement of faith that the existentialist Christians continually talk about you can't because the thing is if you're aiming at something specific that constitutes the good then basically what you've done is made yourself a kind of idle you said well, this is Paradise and gone, but the thing is you don't know that because you're not sufficiently informed understand the ultimate nature of the good. But I think you're sufficiently informed to figure out when you're not using your language properly. And I think one of the things that you can notice is that if you're not using it properly it makes you ashamed and week and embarrassed and I think you can feel that you can feel it fully embodied. And I think that's what Kane does and that's what God tells them to stop doing. He says if you're doing things right you can stand up with your head held high and if you're not you can't you're downcast and angry and resentful and murderous and I think That's the case. so and I do believe that it's a different way of being because it's not aimed at something. It's not aimed at something that's predefined. You have to under you have to allow what constitutes the good and your understanding of the good to continually be updated as you pursue it and I think all you have to do to do that is to speak words while Northrop Frye would say is that you have to speak words with power and I think you can learn to do that, but you have to let go I think that that's the that's the cure for radiology. You know because what's the alternative you can lay out a belief system and try to impose it. Or you can play along and see if you can figure out what's going on. If you have a productive conversation with someone that's what you're doing. You know, you say well, let's see if we can figure out how to get along. Maybe this is within the confines of an intimate relationship. It's like, okay. What do you want? What do I want? How is that going to fit together? Can we communicate honestly about exactly what that is and how we might get it and it's a it's a process of code Discovery. It's not like, you know the answer to begin with and you're not going to find it unless you tell each other the truth and you're not going to be able to pursue it unless you act out the truth that you articulate and I don't think you're going to be able to articulate the truth properly unless what you want is the good. And that's a very difficult thing to figure out but I think one of the things we do know after the 20th century that the continual attempt to make the world as atrocious of places possible seems to be searching in the wrong direction, you know, you know, I've tried this sort of thing for a very long period of time because I think that what I try to do or why what I try to do is to say what I believe to be the case in every situation that I'm in and to see what happens and my experience has been that really works. really works you can learn to get along with the people in your family and help them straighten out and you can start to have a relatively beneficial effect on processes that are outside of your you know of what's right in front of you and within your grasp so you can practice trying to figure out how to set things straight and I have no idea what the ultimate limits of that might be but I can tell you one thing it certainly makes your life and ridiculously interesting and you know, that in itself is one of the things that takes away the sting of immortality because if what you're doing is so damn interesting you can hardly stand it the fact that you have to pay a price as you move along starts to become acceptable, you know, because you'll pay a price if it's worth it. It's Nietzsche said if you have a why you can bear anyhow, and I think there's some truth in that and you know, you might say well, what's what's a good that sufficiently good to justify voluntarily participating in being that's bent on your misery and destruction. That's the fundamental question of life. Well, I would say you need a pretty elevated Vision in order to counteract that and I think that's what a vision of paradise is. And I think that paradise is something that people have to build I think if we build it properly it would justify everything that happened on the way to building it or at least that might be the case and I think you can do it locally first. So and I can't see and I've watched people I've watched how people live live live now for decades and I have two clients in my practice right now who one of them was pretty damn straight to begin with but he's set up his his business. It happens to be a firm and he's tried to make absolutely straight decisions that were really informed and proper the entire way along in the bloody thing is running like a like It's running its the equilibrated. It's extremely effective. It's not wasteful everybody who's inside. The organization is developing properly. No one's getting screwed over like it's an honest and straightforward Enterprise and everybody seems to be benefiting from it. And I have another client who was pretty damn confused and arrogant and resentful when he first started changing his life and he put together a relatively small business and I would say it's a low status But he's done it as honestly as he possibly could and he tried to keep himself on the straight and narrow while he's doing it and he's trying to give his customers outstanding service and to be clear and straight with them at every single Choice moment. And that's lifted his cynicism and it's made his business very very productive and and positive and so I can't see first of all there has to be some antidote to the ology because it's corrosive and and destructive and I can't see. That there's any any end that you can attain at any means that you can Implement that's more meaningful and Rich and deep than that. And I do think it's sufficient to stop you from being corrupted and Jenna Seidel and that's a good thing because you can get corrupted in Genesis idle and if there's enough of us who are corrupt and Jenna Seidel Then things are going to get very bad instead of very good. so well, so then you can think about that and I think it's an easy thing to start to try. The first thing you have to do is decide if you want things to be better or worse and that's not a simple question because they'll be a lot of you that's bitter and resentful and vengeful and angry for all of your inadequacies in the way the world's treated you and so and the second thing is pay attention to what you say and see if you believe it and if you don't quit saying it See what happens like you can tell if what you say makes you stronger if it makes you weak all you have to do is feel it and you can stop saying things that make you weak but it'll change you completely so you'll find that you won't be able to associate with people who only allow you to say things that make you weak for example, because lots of people would be upset if you say things that make you strong around the because they don't want you to flourish and grow partly because it sheds a bad light on them. Anyways, this is more of elaborated in the last quarter of the book or thereabouts. And so you'll get a chance to read that if you want to do it and I guess I'll see you guys when you when you have the final but in the meantime, well think about it, you know, I think we have more opportunity now at this point in history to make things good than we could have possibly imagined 50 years ago and it's necessary, you know, there's lots of things that are falling apart and people get cynical about that and that's the wrong attitude is like you have No idea how much power you might have at your disposal if you used it properly and I think we could set things right if we decided that it was worth doing and so it certainly seems to me to beat the alternative because in the 20th century we bloody well learned what the alternative was and it is as horrible as anything you could possibly imagine. So it seems to me that it's very much worth a while avoiding that even if we can't make things perfect, so See you all. This podcast is brought to you and made possible by generous financial aid from Peter kanzler K. Ay n z l-- e-- r-- you can buy his Amazon books at your favorite Amazon Branch, for example, the original texts of lock Hobbs and the US Constitution of Pennsylvania put together into one book. For only $15. Thanks for listening.
2015 Maps of Meaning 11 Conclusion - The Hero Part 2 (Jordan Peterson) Too Much Jordan B Peterson Podcast TMJBP 🐸 MAPS OF MEANING PODCAST JORDAN B PETERSON PODCAST Jordan B Peterson is light on the horizon. He wants his message to be heard. The TOO MUCH JORDAN B PETERSON PODCAST uploads all of his (especially older) YouTube Content to make it available immediately to download or listen to without being "glued to a screen". We try to put the media back into immediate. https://www.bit.ly/JBPQUOTES Here's your chance to help the publishing endeavour sustain itself: Support the Too Much Jordan B Peterson Podcast that provides video free content for you by starting an own website with Siteground which is the Number One in Price and Speed: http://bit.ly/SITEGROUNDSALE or by getting a book by SC: http://bit.ly/SCHRIST If you really want to help out, get your free Audiobook via http://bit.ly/AUDIBLESALES (BTW: 1 Free audiobook for every country account!) Support the Too Much Jordan B Peterson Podcast that provides old good content for you by getting some #Bitcoin via Coinbase: https://www.bit.ly/COINBASESALE Or simply donate to or search for: 3AqWZuAE4VKRdS2k4v1zmAwn9pNkGY4rkd The Leviathan (1651), The Two Treatises of Government (1689), The Constitution of Pennsylvania (1776) in one Binding for 14.95$ by Peter Kanzler: https://amzn.to/2KQT8U1 