Is AUTHOR wrong in the post ? POST : So my mom got me an Xbox one for Christmas which is a really nice thoughtful gift. The thing is that I already have an Xbox one, but mine is slightly damaged. Some backstory to it is that my friends and I went on a ski trip over spring break and brought our Xbox’s. Apparently we didn’t pack well enough and when we opened the back of the car my Xbox fell out and now none of the buttons on the front work so I can’t get my game out or put new ones in. Other than that it works perfectly, and this doesn’t really bother me since most of my games are downloaded. But my mom knew it was broken and decided to get me a new one, which I appreciate and understand why she did, but I feel like it’s a useless gift since I already have one. I started thinking about selling it and getting a switch instead so I talked to my girlfriend about it and she told me it was a bad idea and that I’d seem ungrateful. I then talked to my dad and he said it’d be fine and that it made sense for me to do that. So I finally brought it up with my mom and it didn’t go over well. She took offense and was upset that I would want to sell her gift. I explained my reasoning and she said i can do whatever I want with it since it’s my gift but I know that she’s still upset about it. I haven’t sold or done anything with it, so would I be an asshole if I sold it?