Is OTHER wrong in the post ? POST : She was speaking to me about how much she loved him, and how much he really, really made her heart brighten up. I allowed it, she said all her other friends didn't support it (I understand why.) He treats her as if he truly loves her, and there's no manipulation in between. She deserves a man that is not manipulative and controlling; he's neither. He did his time. He's still 31, yes. He was 18 when he was convicted. The thing is, I just really feel like she deserves such a man and he deserves another shot. 

Am I the Asshole or am I just a fucking failure at being a good friend