Is OTHER wrong in the post ? POST : So I had a friend,let’s call him Peter,whom I accidently broke his headset by kicking I apologised profusely afterwards of course but however at the end of the day he asked me to pay him $300 in damages(despite the headset only costing around $150-$200) of course I refused to pay him and he kept harrassing me for weeks,thing is it still worked only the sound distorted for a while before going back to normal



I later contacted the Friend who gave him the headset and he said that he had given him a warranty card to exchange the headset however Peter denied getting the card

We then had some drama and broke our friendship cause I believed he was using me for his own gain

 2 Weeks ago(After he threw away his headset which he had been using for 5-6 months) he starts harrassing me again but this time asks for $170 instead of $300 he even called his gf(who was friends with me) to come and convince me to pay him back he then lowered the price again to $130 and asked that I pay him back for what I damaged despite it working pretty fine for those 5-6 months

He has been pestering me to this day and I don’t know whose right in this situation and if I should really pay him back after this