When I showed up at his house, I texted him asking where to park. He came outside and showed me to this little side concrete thing. I pulled forward til he waved for me to stop. I got out, we kissed, and went inside. 

Overall it was an awesome night. His house was clean and nice, so was he. The sex was phenomenal, he was really funny, if not a little boring, and I would’ve loved to see him again. 

He wanted to leave to go get us breakfast, so I gave him my $10 and laid back in his bed. I heard something outside (like metal on metal) and so I just jumped and looked outside. He had backed into my car SO HARD that my bumper fell off. The entire right side is smashed. I swear it looks like he just went pedal to the metal and hit my car. He drove off went to get breakfast and I was kind of panicking on what to do. 

He came back and literally acted like nothing happened. He didn’t mention my car or anything. We ate breakfast and I did mention it, and he seemed kinda surprised I mentioned it. He said it’s cosmetic and his friend could fix it for hardly anything f. 

I did get his insurance information, but he seemed surprised that I even asked. He said it was a small fix and he would rather just have his friend fix it. It’s a 2015 Kia Soul that I am still making payments on. I’m really mad and feel like it will cost a lost to fix. I don’t want a random friend of my hookup to fix it. 

WIBTA if I file an insurance claim? 

TL;DR Hookup hit my car. Wants his friend it fix it but I want to file an insurance claim and take it to a reputable shop. WIBTA? 