As the title says, I received a part of my gift from the Movie exchange that’s going on. I collect VHS so one of the gifts was a VHS movie I’ve had on my list to get. 

The movie is 2 separate tapes and was shipped directly from Amazon. The sticker on the movie states that it’s new, although the seal is broken. The first tape has a crack down the front of it, but I’m still able to play it. 

Would I be the asshole if I told them what happened so they could just get a refund? The movie still works, so I have no issue. The sticker indicating it being new pisses me off. The Amazon seller clearly was being shady and sold something opened and cracked. 

I just don’t know if it would make them feel bad or if it’s worth it. 