Is AUTHOR wrong in the post ? POST : My now ex girlfriend bought tickets for us to go see one of my all time favorite artists for Christmas. The tickets were relatively cheap, about $17 a piece. Small venue, nothing fancy. She had never heard of the guy until I mentioned that I wanted to go see him, and that tickets would be a great Christmas gift, it was cheap and something I really wanted. 

Fast forward a couple weeks, she split up with me, and a couple days later asked for the tickets back because she wanted to sell them. I told her no because they were a gift, and I still planned on using them. She got mad, and it turned into a pretty big argument, that ended when I asked for one of her gifts back so I could return it and get my money back if she was going to sell the tickets. She didn’t like that idea, told me to keep them, and just go to the show. I made plans with a good friend of mine to go with me, and that was that.

Fast forward to today, she asked for just one of tickets back so she could go with some of her friends. Again I told her no that ticket was now being used, and she got mad which again turned into the same argument as before. I told her that if she wanted to go, that she would have to buy another ticket because I already gave it to my friend to go with me.

AITA for not giving her at least her ticket back since she didn’t plan on using it until after I had promised it to a friend? 