My  girlfriend, let's call her Alice, originally came to me with the idea of traveling to Havasu waterfall this year. It's on her bucket list of places to go to and she missed out on doing it last year. I'm a fairly outdoorsy person and it looks pretty cool so she's totally convinced me and I'm totally down to do this. Alice is a planner and does all the research for when the best times are. We talked about it together after the research and decide on a couple of possible time slots. The day that tickets open up, we both wake up at 7 am and proceed to click refresh for around an hour get into the website to buy the tickets. Finally, I manage to get in after 50 minutes of clicking the page and buy a reservation for 2 for a time slot we picked under my name. This means I have to be there to claim the tickets the day of. Keep in mind, these are really hard to get and were completely sold out for the year by the end of the first day. 

&amp;#x200B;

We were talking in the car yesterday and I made a joke that even if we broke up, the tickets are in my name and I'd keep them. She says in that case, I should transfer them to her (which is totally possible via the website and of course she would pay me full price of the tickets). She thinks she should get the tickets since it was her original idea to go and she did all the research for the best times. I think I get to keep the tickets since I'm also excited to go now, spent the time to acquire them and it's under my name. We both read this subreddit so we decided to let reddit users vote on who is in the "right". So in this scenario, WIBTA if I didn't give transfer her the tickets in that scenario? 