Question: Would keelhauling be a fair punishment under the Eighth Amendment?, Answer:No, Description of Eighth Amendment to the United States Constitution: prohibits cruel and unusual punishment and excessive bail, Fact1: Keelhauling was a severe punishment whereby the condemned man was dragged beneath the ship’s keel on a rope., Fact2: Keelhauling is considered a form of torture., Fact3: Torture is considered cruel., Fact4: The Eighth Amendment forbids the use of "cruel and unusual punishment".
Step1: What kind of punishment is keelhauling considered a form of?, Step2: Does the Eighth Amendment allow #1?, Wikipedia page for step 1: keelhauling, Wikipedia page for step 2: Eighth Amendment, not_definitive_answer: False, incorrect_answer: False