Context: 'No it's not.  Since my fever is very high and my chills are very bad I'd appreciate you letting me have 2 firewoods and in exchange you could have all the extra food.' 'That is an interesting proposition.  What about the water?' 'I think if you let me have 2 waters I might survive this scourge!'
Utterance: 'I think that your reasons are very compelling.  I would also like to survive.'