Sentence 1: Finn's mom and dad had been separated for a while. 
 Sentence 3: He invited them both to his baseball game 
 Sentence 4:  He saw that they met each other and began talking 
 Sentence 5:  It looked good and he was thankful that they had begun talking again 
 Option 1: He hated seeing them talk to each other. 
 Option 2: He always wished they would come back together.