Sentence 1: One day, Jacob bought a new baseball glove. 
 Sentence 3: He would never explain why he always kept his old one 
 Sentence 4:  All his friends decided his old glove must be secretly valuable 
 Sentence 5:  Jacob loved messing with his friends' heads in this way 
 Option 1: However, Jacob still used his old, dirty, and worn glove. 
 Option 2: He kept the old one because it felt lucky.