Sentence 1: I had cut sugar from my diet for two months. 
 Sentence 3: I gave in 
 Sentence 4:  The cheesecake was magnificent 
 Sentence 5:  I planned to relapse now and then in the future, but prudently 
 Option 1: At a party, a piece of cheesecake tempted me. 
 Option 2: At a party, a bowl of candy tempted me.