Sentence 1: Lou was the most popular kid in school. 
 Sentence 3: He loved to write poetry 
 Sentence 4:  He was really good but he was too ashamed to share it himself 
 Sentence 5:  Instead, he forced a nerd named Carl to read them as his own 
 Option 1: He was a star athlete but he also had a secret hobby, fostering kittens. 
 Option 2: He was a star athlete but he also had a secret.