Sentence 1: Gina's brother had a friend with hazel eyes. 
 Sentence 3: But Gina didn't like his eyes 
 Sentence 4:  There was something cold and evil about them 
 Sentence 5:  Gina never felt comfortable when he was around 
 Option 1: Everyone was always complimenting his eyes. 
 Option 2: Gina thought he was cute.