Sentence 1: Gina had a crush on Jamie. 
 Sentence 3: She felt like she was cheating on Jamie by liking josh 
 Sentence 4:  But each time she saw him she knew she liked him 
 Sentence 5:  She didn't really have to choose, since neither of them even knew 
 Given Sentence 2: She donned the hat and used a ruler as a magic wand.