Sentence 1: There was a kid named Mary that had a black cat. 
 Sentence 3: Normally the black cat would sit in the window or look at Mary 
 Sentence 4:  One day Mary opened the door and cat got out and it ran away 
 Sentence 5:  After that Mary lived a happy life, and not a scary one 
 Option 1: The black cat always gave her the creeps. 
 Option 2: The black cat was her favorite.