Sentence 1: Jimmy used to really hate salad. 
 Sentence 3: Surprised, I asked him what happened 
 Sentence 4:  He told me that he had a heart attack and needed to eat better 
 Sentence 5:  I think now I might start eating more salad myself 
 Option 1: The other day, I actually saw him eating a big bowl. 
 Option 2: The other day, I saw him eat an entire pizza along with a side salad.