Sentence 1: Amy was a great baker. 
 Sentence 3: Everyone gobbled it up 
 Sentence 4:  They asked for her recipe 
 Sentence 5:  Amy had a reputation as a great baker because of this delicious treat 
 Option 1: She made an amazing dessert for the potluck. 
 Option 2: Running late she had to buy a dessert at the store for the potluck.