Sentence 1: Matt took his wife to the store after work. 
 Sentence 3: They went to the fanciest restaurant in town 
 Sentence 4:  They both really enjoyed their meal that night 
 Sentence 5:  Matt and his wife now have a favorite new place to eat 
 Option 1: After the store, Matt surprised her with a movie ticket. 
 Option 2: After the store, Matt surprised her a dinner date.