Sentence 1: Will and his sister loved to make mud pies in the summer. 
 Sentence 3: Then one day Will forgot it was pretend and bit into one of the pies 
 Sentence 4:  Mud oozed out of his mouth 
 Sentence 5:  His sister couldn't stop laughing 
 Option 1: They would mix dirt with water, shape it and pretend it was real food. 
 Option 2: Will tricked his sister into eating one of the pies.