Sentence 1: Eddie put a container of milk on the counter. 
 Sentence 3: He heard a big thump 
 Sentence 4:  When he turned, he found his cat had knocked over the carton 
 Sentence 5:  She was licking up the milk that had spilled everywhere 
 Option 1: It had gone bad so he decided to throw it away. 
 Option 2: He walked to the pantry to get some cereal.