Sentence 1: Lucy got a present for her friend. 
 Sentence 3: But Stacy did not want to be rude 
 Sentence 4:  So she told her she loved it 
 Sentence 5:  But later she re gifted it 
 Option 1: When her friend Stacy opened it she didn't like it. 
 Option 2: When her friend Stacy opened it she loved it.