Sentence 1: James loved pizza. 
 Sentence 3: When he woke up he saw it was left out all night 
 Sentence 4:  He grabbed a piece a took a huge bite 
 Sentence 5:  James loved cold counter pizza even more then when it was fresh 
 Option 1: One night, his accidentally threw the left over pizza away. 
 Option 2: One night he forgot to put the pizza away.