Sentence 1: John loved reading the newspaper every day. 
 Sentence 3: One morning the newspaper was nowhere to be found 
 Sentence 4:  He looked around and noticed a cat holding something in its mouth 
 Sentence 5:  The cat noticed John and dropped the newspaper in a puddle 
 Option 1: Every morning he went out to his doorstep to get the newspaper. 
 Option 2: Every morning he went out to his doorstep to throw the newspaper.