Sentence 1: Lucy's grandma had gotten her favorite ice cream. 
 Sentence 3: She sat on the porch and ate on a warm summer day 
 Sentence 4:  She sat her bowl down and played with a neighbor's cat 
 Sentence 5:  When Lucy returned her ice cream was soup 
 Option 1: Lucy was sick though and not allowed to eat it. 
 Option 2: Lucy filled her bowl with the ice cream.