Sentence 1: Charles loves banana pudding. 
 Sentence 3: They put candles in it, but it they sank to the bottom 
 Sentence 4:  Despite this, Charles was so happy for his birthday pudding 
 Sentence 5:  Now he gets pudding instead of cake every year 
 Option 1: For his birthday, his friends made him pudding instead of cake. 
 Option 2: For his birthday, his friends made him a banana flavored cake.