Sentence 1: Randy had been fighting with his girlfriend. 
 Sentence 3: Randy decided to wait for her to calm down in the backyard 
 Sentence 4:  It started to get unbearably cold 
 Sentence 5:  Luckily, she eventually calmed down and let him inside 
 Option 1: He kicked her out of the apartment one night. 
 Option 2: She kicked him out of the apartment one night.