Sentence 1: Elle had visited Jill's house a few times. 
 Sentence 3: When she spent the night, she got to meet the nocturnal occupant 
 Sentence 4:  Around 10pm, Jill opened the cage door 
 Sentence 5:  An adorable little furry animal with big eyes jumped out 
 Option 1: She refused to stay the night. 
 Option 2: She never saw what was sleeping inside the cage in her room.