Sentence 1: Matt and Caroline lived together and had been fighting. 
 Sentence 3: Unsure what to do, he just hung out in the yard 
 Sentence 4:  He was cold and bored for a really long time 
 Sentence 5:  Finally, she let him back inside after she calmed down 
 Option 1: Caroline was fed up and kicked Matt out. 
 Option 2: Matt was fed up and kicked Caroline out.