Sentence 1: When I found Charlie Horse under my bed, his leg was messed up. 
 Sentence 3: The seams had ruptured 
 Sentence 4:  When I looked at my dog, he was also under the bed 
 Sentence 5:  He looked very guilty, leading me to believe he caused the damage 
 Given Sentence 2: Upon closer look, the stuffing was starting to come out.