Sentence 1: John was buying some pumpkins for his family to carve. 
 Sentence 3: Just as we was going to load up the car, he dropped the pumpkin 
 Sentence 4:  It broke into pieces 
 Sentence 5:  Luckily, John found another pumpkin that was almost as good 
 Option 1: He had found his wife the perfect, unmarked pumpkin. 
 Option 2: He had found his wife, the nastiest, most rotted pumpkin.