Management of Pediatric Traumatic Macular Holes – Case Report
A 15-year-old boy was hit on his left eye by a soccer ball. At presentation, iVA of the affected eye was hand motion. The adnexa and anterior segment were unremarkable. Fundoscopy showed little intraretinal hemorrhages, commotio retinae in the posterior pole, and the presence of a macular hole. The OCT revealed a full-thickness macular hole with hyaloid still attached (fig. ). The patient underwent surgery 2 days later. Five days after surgery, the OCT confirmed macular hole closure (fig. ) and the VA was counting fingers. Follow-up observations showed sustained heterogeneous areas of retinal pallor mingled with hyperpigmentation zones and maintenance of macular hole closure. The OCT revealed disorganization of the retinal layers with foveal atrophy and disruption of the photoreceptor layer. The VA remained in counting fingers until the end of the follow-up.\nVery little can be found in the literature regarding pediatric TMH management and its results compared to adult population.\nWu et al. [] presented a case series with TMH in which 13 pediatric patients (1–15 years old) were submitted to plasmin-assisted vitrectomy, membrane peeling and gas or silicone oil injection, followed by prone position for 7 days. The macular hole closed in 12 (92%) patients. fVA could be measured only in 12 of 13 patients. From those, 11 (92%) patients had VA improvement of 2 or more lines and six (50%) achieved vision of 20/50 or better; all patients achieved a vision better than 20/200.\nWachtlin and associates [] reported a case series of four pediatric patients with TMH (10–15 years old). All patients underwent pars plana vitrectomy with platelet concentrate, internal limiting membrane (ILM) peeling, and gas tamponade for stage 3 TMH repair. Primary closure was achieved by a single intervention in all patients, with a visual improvement of three to seven lines after surgery. The surgically achieved visual improvement remained stable during the follow-up and no complications were reported.\nIn 2007, Brasil and Brasil [] reported a single case of a 9-year-old boy with a TMH who gained vision from 20/300 to 20/70 after surgery with ILM peeling and silicone oil tamponade, which remained stable one year after the silicone oil removal.\nOn the other hand, the surgical outcomes of TMH in adults have been analyzed in multiple retrospective case series. Closure rate varies from 92 to 100% and fVA <20/40 from 38 to 48% [, , , , , ].\nRubin et al. [] presented a case series of 12 consecutive patients with TMH who underwent vitrectomy, fluid-gas exchange and instillation of bovine or recombinant transforming growth factor beta-2. The closure rate was 92%, repeated surgery having been necessary in 3 patients. The BCVA improved by at least 2 lines in 8 (67%) of 12 eyes. Six (50%) of 12 eyes improved to 20/40 or better.\nAnother reference of the use of platelet concentrate was reported by García-Arumí and associates [] who presented the surgical outcomes of 14 eyes with full-thickness TMH submitted to pars plana vitrectomy with posterior hyaloid dissection, followed by complete fluid-gas exchange, and instillation of 0.1 ml of platelet concentrate just over the macular hole. Closure rate was 93% (13 of 14 eyes), with a vision improvement of at least 4 Snellen lines in every closed hole. The mean fVA was 20/30, and two patients had a fVA of 20/20. No intra- or postoperative complications were noted.\nSeveral studies have demonstrated the benefits of vitrectomy without adjunctive therapy, but almost exclusively in adults.\nIn the series of Amari et al. [] and Chow and associates [] the final closure rate of 96 and 94%, respectively, and a VA improvement of at least two lines in more than 70% of patients were obtained without any adjunctive therapy.\nIn 2001, Kuhn et al. [] reported the benefits of ILM removal in a case series of 17 consecutive TMH patients. All patients were submitted to vitrectomy and ILM removal with no adjuvant therapy. Results showed 100% closure rate. Vision improved by at least 2 Snellen lines in 16 (94%) eyes.\nMore recently, a multicenter case series of 25 TMH cases was published, and the authors observed a 96% closure rate and a vision of 20/50 or better in 64% of the eyes [].\nSome cases of TMH spontaneous resolution have also been published. In total we found 37 cases of spontaneous TMH closure and the majority of them occurred in children [, , , , , , , , , , ]. All the holes closed within up to one year, and 55% within up to three months of trauma [, , , , , , , , , , ]. Therefore, some authors advocate at least an initial period of observation instead of an early intervention []. Although our series is too small to postulate the benefits of an early intervention some features should be highlighted. The iVA in the eyes with spontaneously closed TMH was 20/400 or better in 70.3%, the size of the hole was equal to or less than 0.2 disk diameter (DD) in at least 75.7% of the eyes and 40.5% of the patients were more than 15 years old. On the contrary, all our patients had iVA of 20/400 or worse, the macular hole size was superior to 0.3 DD and our oldest patient was 15 years old. Therefore, spontaneous closures of TMH described are mostly in patients with small holes and VA above 20/400. Larger holes seem to result from higher kinetic energy which causes more severe retinal edema, RPE damage, subretinal bleeding with its possible photoreceptor toxicity, and retinal necrosis with tissue loss. These factors may contribute to inability to reappose the retinal edges by the contracting fibroglial tissue, limiting the reparative process to flattening of the retinal edges surrounding the hole []. From the 37 cases described, only 11 had fluid cuff described, and all but one had the posterior hyaloid attached, thus having a higher probability to spontaneously close. Also the patients that ended up with a BCVA ≥20/25 (12 patients] had holes ≤0.2 DD, initial BCVA between 20/200 and 20/40, and only two had fluid cuff present.\nRegarding only the case series that reported a spontaneous closure rate of TMH [, , ] one can say that most of them did not close spontaneously: only 13 of 34 (38.2%) TMH resolved spontaneously. Few data is found regarding the numbers of non-closing TMH managed with an observational attitude. What size were they? What were their anatomical features? How old were the patients? What was the initial BCVA? And most of all, what was the final BCVA on holes that remained unclosed? Would these patients benefit in the same way with surgery after waiting so long?\nTMH are less frequent than idiopathic ones, have a different pathogenesis and do not have a well-established management guideline, especially in pediatric patients. However, several well-documented retrospective case series have actually shown very similar surgical outcomes for idiopathic and TMH [, , ]. The use of platelet concentrate and autolo-gous plasmin has been described, although more studies are necessary.\nSome authors claim that an observation period of 3 to 6 months is advised, especially in young patients with small holes, good iVA and posterior vitreous adhesion to the TMH edges due to the higher possibility of spontaneous resolution. In the remaining cases the possibility of spontaneous closure is low [, , , , , , ].\nThe photoreceptor damage is more likely, the longer the delay. The consequences of a long period of waiting for the spontaneous closure of the macular hole have not been clarified. Few series have been published concerning this matter, all of them with few cases and controversial results. Many questions remain controversial and unanswered. Until when should we wait? Authors have reported the enlargement of macular hole during the follow-up [] with unclear consequences. Which is the best timing to intervene? Which TMH are more suitable to spontaneously close? Is the probability the same regardless of the child's age? Should we wait in patients in amblyopic ages, in patients with only one eye, or in patients with previous low vision? What impact could this situation have in the psychomotor development in these ages?\nIn conclusion, early pars plana vitrectomy with ILM peeling and gas tamponade seems to be a safe and effective choice for the therapy of TMH in pediatric patients. When compared to spontaneous closure results found in the literature, the surgical closure rate is higher and the fVA is slightly better after vitrectomy. We believe that early vitrectomy could facilitate and accelerate the closure process, preventing irreversible structural changes and consequent permanent damage.\nHigh-resolution cross-sectional retinal images provided by OCT add new data to the understanding of pathogenesis of TMH and may help in management decisions.