[
    {
        "Model": "CLIP-v1",
        "Alignment": 38.1,
        "Safety": 12.7,
        "Artifact": 34.4,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 57.4,
            "NDS": 76.3,
            "GES": 86.9
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "BLIP-v2",
        "Alignment": 17.3,
        "Safety": 44.0,
        "Artifact": 7.5,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 68.7,
            "NDS": 83.7,
            "GES": 91.3
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "PickScore-v1",
        "Alignment": 58.8,
        "Safety": 37.2,
        "Artifact": 83.8,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 31.0,
            "NDS": 66.5,
            "GES": 81.1
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "HPS-v2.1",
        "Alignment": 47.3,
        "Safety": 18.8,
        "Artifact": 67.3,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 55.0,
            "NDS": 77.9,
            "GES": 87.6
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "ImageReward",
        "Alignment": 50.9,
        "Safety": 24.9,
        "Artifact": 63.5,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 40.9,
            "NDS": 73.7,
            "GES": 85.3
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "Aesthetics",
        "Alignment": 32.4,
        "Safety": 27.0,
        "Artifact": 69.6,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 61.4,
            "NDS": 85.7,
            "GES": 92.1
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "LLaVA-1.5-7b",
        "Alignment": 22.0,
        "Safety": 24.8,
        "Artifact": 12.4,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 83.7,
            "NDS": 70.4,
            "GES": 88.7
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "LLaVA-1.5-13b",
        "Alignment": 10.3,
        "Safety": 30.7,
        "Artifact": 23.3,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 69.7,
            "NDS": 74.3,
            "GES": 88.6
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "LLaVA-1.6-mistral-7b",
        "Alignment": 31.3,
        "Safety": 15.2,
        "Artifact": 45.8,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 69.9,
            "NDS": 64.3,
            "GES": 85.4
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "LLaVA-1.6-vicuna-13b",
        "Alignment": 29.1,
        "Safety": 27.9,
        "Artifact": 36.8,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 56.3,
            "NDS": 64.0,
            "GES": 82.7
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "Instructblip-7b",
        "Alignment": 17.1,
        "Safety": 26.4,
        "Artifact": 25.2,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 53.1,
            "NDS": 80.8,
            "GES": 91.2
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "MiniGPT4-v2",
        "Alignment": 32.8,
        "Safety": 25.7,
        "Artifact": 36.7,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 32.6,
            "NDS": 67.0,
            "GES": 83.3
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "Prometheus-Vision-7b",
        "Alignment": 18.8,
        "Safety": 7.1,
        "Artifact": 23.4,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 49.5,
            "NDS": 43.4,
            "GES": 74.4
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "Prometheus-Vision-13b",
        "Alignment": 11.8,
        "Safety": 3.6,
        "Artifact": 8.7,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 66.3,
            "NDS": 46.3,
            "GES": 76.8
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "Qwen-VL-Chat",
        "Alignment": 52.1,
        "Safety": 26.8,
        "Artifact": 23.6,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 71.9,
            "NDS": 62.8,
            "GES": 86.2
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "Internvl-chat-v1-5",
        "Alignment": 55.3,
        "Safety": 6.3,
        "Artifact": 66.3,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 25.4,
            "NDS": 69.6,
            "GES": 84.3
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "Idefics2-8b",
        "Alignment": 32.6,
        "Safety": 13.6,
        "Artifact": 46.1,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 42.1,
            "NDS": 58.7,
            "GES": 79.4
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "GPT-4-vision",
        "Alignment": 66.1,
        "Safety": 26.5,
        "Artifact": 90.4,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 79.0,
            "NDS": 80.4,
            "GES": 93.2
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "GPT-4o",
        "Alignment": 61.5,
        "Safety": 35.3,
        "Artifact": 97.6,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 65.8,
            "NDS": 82.5,
            "GES": 92.8
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "Gemini Ultra",
        "Alignment": 67.2,
        "Safety": 13.1,
        "Artifact": 55.7,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 55.6,
            "NDS": 75.3,
            "GES": 88.6
        }
    },
    {
        "Model": "Claude 3 Opus",
        "Alignment": 57.1,
        "Safety": 13.4,
        "Artifact": 11.9,
        "Bias": {
            "ACC": 57.7,
            "NDS": 65.6,
            "GES": 85.0
        }
    }
]