Has the process of appointing a Judge of a High Court been consistently criticized or challenged in the Indian legal system?
Yes, the process of appointing a Judge of a High Court has been consistently criticized or challenged in the Indian legal system. The criticism stems from concerns about transparency, objectivity, and independence in the selection process. Some argue that the involvement of executive authorities, such as the President and Governors, may compromise the judiciary's autonomy. Moreover, there have been instances where the National Judicial Appointments Commission, which was tasked with recommending candidates for High Court judgeship, faced legal challenges and was eventually struck down by the Supreme Court in 2015.