Datasets:

commonsense-index-dev

/

DemoFeedback

like 0

Follow

Commonsense Index Team @ AI2 3

6372fbe741eea779

yulinggu

Good

5210d039d9baf6b4

ronanlb

Not enough information

Bad

84d49e7588b88916

xianying

Good

11df1191e101bce9

ronanlb

Not enough information, and only 5 guests (or 2 persons named Alice)

Bad

5bdb7835e0f25513

ronanlb

Answers D & E are both valid.

Bad

4c29a5c2009c9c0b

yulinggu

Bad example. Not constrained enough for D to be the only right answer. Option A should also be correct. C + 2C + B = 25 (total animals) B > 3C (birds outnumber cats and dogs combined) so B = 3C + Y, for some Y C + 2C + B = 25 then becomes 3C + B = 6C + Y = 25. If Y = 1, 6C = 24, C = 4. B = 12 + 1 = 13 (which is option A)

Louis owns animals in three categories: birds, cats, and dogs. He claims that he owns at least one of each and the birds always outnumber cats and dogs combined by 13. If Louis altogether has 25 animals and the number of dogs is double the number of cats, how many birds does he own?

Bad

905c2d3c25fd62fb

yulinggu

The answer is good and one that you can obtain by visualizing, although the reasoning is a bit verbose.

Good

4f755128a28be646

ronanlb

Good

93255a4da208212c

ronanlb

Either include a choice "Can't answer" or change choice to "At what time on that clock did the power return?"

N/A

Bad

502a0cdeff08a0f6

test

test

test

Good

933e42f408013b96

test

test

N/A

Bad

8f99c0aaa2be437f

ronanlb

Good

4c9da1d3693e672a

test

test

N/A

Good

b32cb030ca2653eb

hyunwoo

Good

fa1f0279b2007626

ronanlb

Wrong logical reasoning

N/A

Bad

d09057f72ce55043

xianying

Bad

e67182351bd2d88c

hyunwoo

It was 5 minutes slower, but the wind pushes it 15 minutes forward. So it's now 10 minutes faster.

Good

886ee44bf69bea32

Anonymous

Good

81ab428d1bb927cc

ronanlb

Good

e6de27880959b647

hyunwoo

Good

ee6ae5fa1f3897b8

test

test

N/A

Bad

7a35e53a11ba7b98

ronanlb

Rephrase: starting on the first day of the "year"

N/A

Bad

ee6ae5fa1f3897b8

test

test

N/A

Bad

1e68be77bfd9943e

ronanlb

Good

ac76f96a38be0207

yuchenlin

test

test

Good

b33d1d3833b9b031

xianying

Good

1ff31da7c9537cae

Seungone

N/A

Good

846420b5d62cec2f

ronanlb

Good

ee6ae5fa1f3897b8

test

test

N/A

Bad

1d23cd03a6785e51

ronanlb

Good

02d33e5b2481fb8d

ronanlb

Good

3723e9d961087afa

ronanlb

N/A

Good

360bfa208eab8963

ronanlb

A & B are both correct

Bad

2a011938fd50579f

ronanlb

Good

92b0c95420fbfc12

ronanlb

As stated, it could be either his nephew or his son.

At a family reunion, a man states, 'Brothers I have two younger ones, sisters I have none. That man's father is my father's first son.' Who is he pointing to?

Bad

733c75535d188ed3

hyunwoo

This is a bad example lol. I think option B can also be the answer. And tbh I'm not sure why answer A is a correct answer.

Change answer to B)

Bad

063f7fa263cc85aa

test

test

test

Good

064b23ca9cb1ff1b

ronanlb

Answers A & D both valid

Bad

328fa56da5df8127

ronanlb

Assuming "second" in Answer A refers to the "other" sister, not the second in time.

N/A

Good

96444efdbb9ce3d3

ronanlb

that's simply wrong :D

Bad

c2cf197a46039c03

xianying

Now that 'Where we first saw the stars' could symbolize a place with a clear night sky, it can also refer to a rooftop.

"the stars" should be replaced by "the star", because people can truly see a specific star in an observatory .

Bad

47c73abacb926182

ronanlb

A farmer had nine sheep and four cows. One night, a wolf managed to enter the barn. By morning, all but seven sheep and two cows were dead. How many animals does the farmer have left in total?

Bad

7fa55962bddd49c1

ronanlb

N/A

Good

d3faf7f20f27cf66

yuchenlin

Shouldn’t it to be one?

N/A

Bad

dfe9a4b6713ed139

hyunwoo

Why can't Beth and Daryl also have cats?

Bad

9a25e155ee24e628

xianying

Good

ca6790f26483c4e9

ronanlb

Good

469201b849e719dd

xianying

Good

aed9e52c4136080f

ronanlb

Good

50e75b12708f857e

yuchenlin

duplicate choices A and C are the same.

Bad

868a20f4b38e91b7

ronanlb

Good

01d28df4ad30b653

ronanlb

Good

54055bc68ccd3757

ronanlb

Good

c27d151bac25cc12

ronanlb

N/A

Good

1531116861dd99e9

xianying

Good

7e2e39bde850db81

hyunwoo

'm' appears once in the word 'minute', twice in the word 'moment', but absent from the word 'eon'.

Add reasoning

Bad

501dc3794d2c99f9

ronanlb

Good

283c0a8a4c225d14

ronanlb

Good

d162ba0d87b1be1a

xianying

Good

8985a4219607b491

ronanlb

Farfetched

Good

9e57610102640798

ronanlb

Good

87b4c57efdb778f7

ronanlb

Good

27a1ebed3017e019

yuchenlin

Probably duplicate

N/A

Good

868a20f4b38e91b7

ronanlb

Good

7ffd165483a1fd21

ronanlb

Bad

68e3e5c5ae9d95d4

Seungone

N/A

Good

2dd08cec5dd0a4ad

hyunwoo

Good

569dff92ffc87ae2

ronanlb

Good

2582bcf6eb973f2c

ronanlb

N/A

Good

fd224fd14895a9a2

ronanlb

Not enough information

In a small village, every household either has a dog or a cat but not both. There are 20 households, and on a particular day, 12 dogs are seen outside. If no dogs or cats from outside the village are present, at most how many households have cats?

Bad

57363435d53205ea

ronanlb

Ambiguous

N/A

Bad

351c4d241253b7de

xianying

Good

73d7ec16653f018e

ronanlb

Ambiguous

A room is filled with a dozen people, all born in different months. They decide to play a game where they predict the birth month of a new person entering the room without any clues. What strategy should they use to maximize the chance of one of them guessing correctly?

Bad

276b197f77feb7e2

Anonymous

While I think the correct answer D) make most sense, C) might be plausible as well.

N/A

Good

9bf1a1bfd49c673c

yulinggu

The use of "minimum" in the question can be somewhat confusing. Removing it or changing to "maximum" would make it easier to arrive at the answer.

In a room, there are 4 machines and 4 computers. Each machine can only be operated by one computer at one time, and each machine must be operated to function. If one computer breaks down, what is the number of machines that will still function?

Good

e01f13e4295a4a3c

ronanlb

Good

4c9da1d3693e672a

test

test

N/A

Good

3b3a47a527f4b11f

hyunwoo

Straightforward calculation

Good

df5767901f0b9279

ronanlb

Good

af760897244d1e75

ronanlb

Good

e5a9d1370b716b15

ronanlb

A woman owns a rectangle-shaped garden and plants four rows of flowers. Each row has an equal number of flowers, totaling 80 flowers. If she decides to add an extra flower and rearrange the garden into a square shape with the same total number of flowers, how many flowers will each side of the square contain?

Bad

e57353e74767e1a6

ronanlb

A & C are both correct

N/A

Bad

7e024acb5b079049

ronanlb

Rephrase "whose approach to the castle allows them to avoid the dragon's first fiery attack?" to "whose approach to the castle most likely allows them to avoid the dragon's first fiery attack?"

N/A

Bad

5cd13fe86833cbbf

ronanlb

N/A

Good

91da48fee44ea480

ronanlb

"can't answer"

N/A

Bad

0421141b3fdb680d

Seungone

N/A

Bad

e5be4d99b8d3673c

ronanlb

Good

880b34634bb82876

ronanlb

Good

53fc5b70b4d514c9

test

test

N/A

Good

9bb3b9f0348a37aa

xianying

Good

db672524bb539294

ronanlb

Good

4e1ff80881a4c9f0

ronanlb

Ambiguous

In a village where everyone tells the truth all day and lies all night, a visitor asks a villager right before sunset, 'Will you lie tomorrow night?' How should the villager respond?

Bad

fabb3fa614f02967

ronanlb

Good

81dd0aeb2af91edc

xianying

Good

1ee9b6f0915a6a4a

Seungone

N/A

Good

c8d9475c63e7be3c

ronanlb

Good

c38bf6fca87e76eb

xianying

Bad

bf9bcaae6ca4e618

ronanlb

Good

7252edb86eccd7e0

ronanlb

Good

35cc15d38c9d0bf1

xianying

Good