id
stringlengths
33
34
title
stringlengths
6
218
authors
stringlengths
5
6.98k
categories
stringlengths
5
188
summary
stringlengths
34
3.26k
link_pdf
stringlengths
33
34
updated
timestamp[s]
published
timestamp[s]
embeddings
dict
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07767v1
GreekT5: A Series of Greek Sequence-to-Sequence Models for News Summarization
Nikolaos Giarelis, Charalampos Mastrokostas, Nikos Karacapilidis
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T07, 68T50, I.2.7
Text summarization (TS) is a natural language processing (NLP) subtask pertaining to the automatic formulation of a concise and coherent summary that covers the major concepts and topics from one or multiple documents. Recent advancements in deep learning have led to the development of abstractive summarization transformer-based models, which outperform classical approaches. In any case, research in this field focuses on high resource languages such as English, while the corresponding work for low resource languages is still underdeveloped. Taking the above into account, this paper proposes a series of novel TS models for Greek news articles. The proposed models were thoroughly evaluated on the same dataset against GreekBART, which is the state-of-the-art model in Greek abstractive news summarization. Our evaluation results reveal that most of the proposed models significantly outperform GreekBART on various evaluation metrics. We make our evaluation code public, aiming to increase the reproducibility of this work and facilitate future research in the field.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07767v1
2023-11-13T21:33:12
2023-11-13T21:33:12
{ "title": [ -0.016342163, 0.0023994446, -0.021255493, -0.0703125, 0.00054836273, 0.01890564, -0.04837036, -0.006111145, 0.0024871826, 0.048706055, -0.018585205, 0.026031494, 0.022460938, -0.004322052, -0.042541504, 0.026428223, 0.0037441254, 0.013389587, -0.021408081, -0.032287598, -0.025115967, -0.04486084, 0.06286621, 0.024993896, 0.018005371, -0.04788208, -0.028915405, 0.00043010712, -0.035247803, -0.030715942, -0.005004883, 0.030136108, 0.04269409, -0.0071754456, 0.013954163, 0.011566162, -0.021621704, -0.004825592, -0.017196655, 0.0013608932, 0.0093307495, 0.006401062, 0.012924194, -0.018127441, -0.03326416, 0.047973633, -0.07543945, -0.020446777, -0.0031414032, 0.021850586, 0.018539429, 0.012046814, 0.01084137, 0.032836914, 0.017593384, -0.017791748, -0.05230713, 0.03579712, 0.039398193, 0.03656006, -0.008110046, -0.04916382, 0.02432251, -0.029296875, -0.047943115, -0.003982544, 0.0036792755, 0.003540039, 0.0519104, -0.03729248, -0.026138306, 0.030456543, 0.002401352, -0.0060691833, -0.06378174, -0.004016876, 0.021728516, 0.0067481995, 0.03894043, -0.016815186, -0.008323669, -0.007896423, 0.009086609, -0.061676025, 0.025024414, -0.055358887, -0.00573349, -0.0069999695, -0.055847168, -0.11553955, -0.017074585, -0.012527466, -0.062042236, -0.019821167, -0.041015625, -0.028762817, -0.014060974, 0.03717041, -0.027633667, -0.024795532, -0.048797607, 0.048614502, -0.051452637, -0.010185242, 0.02722168, 0.017242432, -0.01751709, -0.0068740845, 0.024475098, 0.029785156, -0.029373169, 0.04269409, 0.01651001, -0.013267517, 0.0030097961, 0.026138306, -0.008911133, 0.0234375, 0.020004272, 0.027420044, 0.001821518, -0.031982422, 0.010147095, 0.04800415, 0.014457703, 0.0021362305, -0.048034668, 0.017730713, 0.008407593, 0.04800415, 0.0181427, 0.03665161, -0.12194824, -0.10290527, -0.0836792, 0.042388916, -0.009925842, 0.0152282715, -0.022979736, 0.026824951, -0.015960693, -0.028747559, 0.020553589, -0.014076233, 0.013252258, -0.00793457, 0.066467285, 0.0090789795, -0.059570312, -0.0435791, -0.0037612915, 0.037506104, 0.03540039, -0.02947998, -0.065979004, -0.043670654, -0.1071167, -0.0256958, 0.032958984, -0.036193848, 0.004600525, -0.00617218, -0.020431519, -0.036315918, 0.006958008, -0.004558563, 0.0014028549, 0.028305054, 0.012916565, 0.04208374, -0.017547607, 0.008613586, 0.051879883, 0.004432678, -0.007282257, -0.0033473969, 0.0036392212, -0.013374329, 0.022491455, -0.012458801, 0.009803772, -0.032226562, -0.03765869, 0.06341553, -0.068237305, -0.012359619, -0.004600525, 0.042114258, 0.06524658, 0.020751953, -0.061187744, -0.007980347, -0.0072021484, -0.038085938, -0.023132324, -0.009986877, 0.0033397675, 0.025558472, -0.0038070679, -0.004825592, -0.017684937, 0.024765015, -0.04534912, 0.006340027, -0.03302002, -0.017791748, -0.012802124, 0.014762878, -0.03778076, 0.031463623, 0.058532715, 0.00844574, -0.02368164, -0.0022945404, -0.005104065, -0.0670166, 0.038360596, 0.006996155, 0.0012693405, -0.0066871643, -0.008399963, -0.003129959, -0.00793457, 0.031829834, 0.06854248, -0.030578613, 0.022079468, -0.047973633, 0.07861328, -0.0077819824, 0.043884277, -0.008239746, 0.0647583, 0.004951477, -0.03475952, -0.018249512, -0.010169983, -0.010910034, 0.0011177063, 0.02897644, 0.018218994, -0.0056381226, -0.011688232, 0.00048446655, 0.07269287, 0.006134033, 0.01586914, -0.013618469, 0.02709961, 0.0413208, 0.056854248, 0.013458252, 0.032318115, -0.0064430237, 0.005584717, 0.05609131, 0.04977417, 0.048339844, -0.045074463, 0.009567261, 0.007949829, 0.03466797, -0.024124146, 0.009429932, -0.05722046, 0.038909912, -0.005592346, 0.030944824, 0.00029158592, 0.02116394, 0.01586914, 0.006038666, 0.020767212, 0.008956909, 0.0028076172, -0.047332764, -0.0020065308, 0.008705139, 0.003921509, -0.04748535, 0.006504059, 0.033203125, 0.04559326, 0.005519867, 0.025619507, 0.0121536255, 0.012245178, -0.005619049, -0.057617188, -0.014724731, 0.032226562, 0.03591919, 0.01725769, -0.033081055, 0.038330078, 0.010215759, 0.08795166, 0.050750732, -0.007446289, 0.013618469, -0.028442383, 0.03387451, 0.0155181885, -0.0022468567, 0.020401001, 0.009674072, 0.040008545, -0.005180359, -0.04019165, 0.012260437, -0.05441284, -0.0022945404, 0.015640259, -0.0014181137, -0.044281006, -0.049041748, -0.008399963, -0.026504517, -0.056030273, -0.04043579, 0.066467285, -0.022125244, -0.025802612, -0.0049095154, -0.018096924, -0.023651123, -0.01361084, -0.028747559, -0.009857178, 0.014030457, 0.031402588, 0.00819397, -0.05026245, -0.0006914139, -0.0033550262, 0.017044067, -0.008575439, -0.015144348, -0.026473999, 0.000579834, 0.005214691, 0.010948181, 0.021850586, -0.03955078, 0.027908325, -0.037963867, 0.023071289, 0.005054474, -0.027008057, 0.0099105835, -0.00308609, -0.0129776, -0.018478394, 0.01600647, 0.04611206, -0.0009522438, -0.0093307495, 0.051605225, 0.032287598, 0.0129470825, 0.022064209, 0.020446777, -0.011276245, -0.058898926, 0.005836487, -0.04714966, -0.031463623, -0.013580322, 0.0031261444, 0.048217773, -0.0362854, -0.022247314, -0.027130127, -0.008773804, -0.0099487305, -0.005027771, -0.009506226, -0.039398193, -0.022735596, -0.023834229, -0.016464233, -0.005596161, 0.011054993, 0.018692017, 0.046722412, 0.016448975, 0.004085541, 0.002462387, 0.011405945, 0.0016059875, -0.017990112, -0.0178833, -0.056121826, -0.0010871887, 0.0013055801, 0.012069702, -0.010635376, -0.01600647, -0.07281494, -0.0014514923, 0.06750488, 0.022766113, -0.01374054, 0.048919678, -0.06591797, 0.02760315, 0.017486572, -0.019088745, 0.027038574, 0.027374268, -0.0035171509, 0.021743774, -0.012039185, -0.0014228821, -0.0038261414, -0.038604736, -0.10638428, 0.008338928, -0.016326904, -0.0036716461, 0.012298584, -0.048858643, -0.037078857, 0.009590149, -0.00081682205, 0.040985107, 0.021575928, 0.0011854172, -0.0028247833, -0.005367279, 0.009223938, -0.030700684, -0.028656006, -0.02861023, 0.0070381165, 0.03540039, -0.0021533966, 0.0748291, -0.004085541, 0.0135650635, -0.054595947, 0.0099105835, 0.015136719, 0.015464783, 0.0051956177, -0.04663086, 0.008995056, -0.013290405, -0.032165527, 0.047027588, -0.027069092, 0.00831604, -0.059783936, 0.021835327, -0.029876709, 0.0236969, -0.005428314, 0.011077881, -0.033569336, 0.004131317, 0.0390625, -0.028060913, -0.009811401, 0.003376007, 0.033966064, 0.0101623535, -0.032318115, -0.018875122, -0.052215576, 0.03955078, -0.024093628, -0.005622864, -0.013381958, -0.022964478, 0.03387451, -0.0074882507, -0.048065186, -0.020080566, -0.008674622, 0.0128479, 0.013916016, -0.0069236755, -0.0049743652, -0.08605957, -0.0040359497, 0.002658844, -0.11859131, -0.0435791, 0.013557434, -0.04623413, -0.05718994, -0.04663086, 0.008407593, -0.031188965, -0.04071045, 0.020935059, -0.011024475, -0.009025574, -0.008926392, -0.0625, -0.047668457, 0.10101318, 0.018295288, 0.00014090538, 0.068359375, -0.0154800415, -0.053009033, -0.0032691956, 0.014801025, 0.008460999, 0.040496826, 0.007255554, -0.0060195923, 0.020217896, -0.03338623, 0.0045051575, 0.034088135, 0.0071640015, 0.010635376, 0.0060768127, -0.007598877, 0.009483337, -0.000082969666, 0.05996704, -0.012229919, -0.011421204, -0.048431396, 0.021438599, -0.0060691833, -0.02444458, 0.03161621, -0.024765015, 0.022415161, 0.03942871, -0.0037021637, 0.061462402, -0.022323608, 0.001578331, 0.038360596, -0.00010687113, -0.027038574, -0.028182983, 0.0077667236, 0.030593872, 0.005443573, 0.027297974, 0.0017118454, 0.0259552, -0.025802612, -0.017181396, -0.024551392, 0.0010814667, -0.026489258, -0.000259161, -0.05722046, -0.02947998, -0.02720642, 0.015205383, -0.013572693, 0.06866455, 0.02709961, -0.0012321472, -0.03125, 0.02482605, -0.024551392, 0.013008118, -0.019744873, -0.05883789, -0.0016212463, -0.0044898987, -0.068115234, -0.04071045, -0.043518066, -0.017974854, 0.020111084, 0.0107421875, 0.028320312, 0.014122009, 0.036376953, 0.04083252, 0.042388916, -0.011703491, -0.04272461, 0.028182983, -0.0052948, 0.0031471252, -0.010673523, 0.012138367, 0.011520386, -0.0021362305, -0.017669678, -0.009994507, -0.014564514, -0.017654419, 0.017410278, -0.0064926147, 0.050994873, -0.014724731, 0.018081665, 0.018463135, 0.028442383, 0.018920898, 0.018295288, -0.007675171, -0.02973938, 0.004749298, 0.018676758, 0.030059814, -0.016998291, 0.0071372986, 0.02053833, 0.022064209, 0.019058228, -0.001543045, 0.015060425, 0.0047798157, 0.030715942, 0.03189087, -0.015686035, -0.030883789, 0.006664276, 0.028747559, 0.031402588, -0.041778564, 0.04446411, -0.0038528442, 0.006893158, 0.017349243, -0.01285553, 0.026809692, -0.013847351, 0.009414673, -0.04562378, -0.03302002, 0.002073288, 0.014541626, -0.007980347, -0.004009247, -0.014007568, 0.00308609, -0.01222229, 0.082214355, 0.035369873, 0.003835678, 0.017364502, -0.031097412, -0.025802612, -0.049957275, -0.042114258, -0.011917114, 0.00982666, 0.0023612976, -0.0090789795, 0.018341064, -0.052642822, -0.023223877, -0.041412354, -0.030441284, 0.027252197, -0.05706787, -0.0016078949, 0.06036377, -0.008255005, 0.03942871, -0.008766174, 0.028289795, 0.018859863, 0.054901123, 0.0046577454, 0.0034637451, 0.048461914, -0.059631348, 0.043426514, 0.01285553, 0.021697998, 0.011352539, 0.006462097, -0.000541687, 0.0152282715, -0.04171753, 0.019104004, 0.018188477, 0.019134521, 0.007949829, -0.036865234, 0.023132324, -0.015701294, -0.005935669, 0.01751709, 0.019577026, -0.03845215, -0.030349731, 0.0024490356, -0.050689697, -0.014770508, -0.0076904297, -0.05770874, -0.021621704, 0.022094727, 0.011169434, 0.005012512, -0.003376007, 0.010139465, -0.037353516, 0.021194458, 0.051239014, -0.037841797, 0.019897461, 0.006843567, 0.011116028, 0.061553955, 0.033447266, -0.009689331, -0.015213013, -0.0029792786, -0.041229248, 0.0077400208, 0.013748169, 0.017974854, -0.006378174, -0.002571106, -0.016494751, 0.025512695, -0.014160156, 0.031951904, 0.0034484863, -0.018692017, 0.03173828, -0.015197754, 0.0010442734, 0.0052871704, 0.03439331, 0.008956909, 0.002357483, 0.024673462, -0.076049805, -0.0077781677, 0.038238525, 0.042541504, -0.023986816, -0.05819702, -0.02861023, 0.030395508, 0.020507812, 0.008117676, 0.025817871, 0.027526855, 0.017807007, -0.0041885376, 0.021957397, 0.039642334, -0.047546387, 0.014282227, -0.03253174, 0.0064849854, -0.05340576, 0.028381348, 0.00036120415, 0.021606445, -0.03677368, -0.014167786, -0.02178955, 0.04159546, 0.039367676, -0.014549255, 0.04626465, -0.016906738, 0.016921997, -0.024932861, -0.01260376, -0.039031982, 0.060791016, -0.006313324, -0.020721436, -0.0074806213, -0.028411865, -0.050964355, 0.012290955, 0.0078048706, 0.025634766, -0.004470825, 0.034484863, 0.0023860931, -0.017242432, -0.031433105, -0.035705566, 0.044067383, -0.005455017, -0.0027370453, 0.059020996, -0.015571594, 0.0496521, 0.025558472, 0.052947998, 0.05847168, 0.02217102, 0.014907837, 0.0015182495, 0.013389587, -0.028289795, 0.014823914, -0.037902832, -0.020889282, -0.06530762, -0.01763916, -0.074157715, 0.00983429, -0.011756897, 0.02041626, -0.0015048981, 0.020080566, 0.008392334, -0.018966675, 0.068359375, -0.01914978, 0.07385254, -0.022201538, 0.007217407, -0.006099701, -0.07733154, 0.04071045, 0.046844482, -0.012489319, -0.006641388, -0.05050659, 0.009063721, 0.010513306, -0.026138306, 0.012107849, -0.017944336, 0.0008969307, -0.029663086, 0.0007100105, -0.021102905, 0.005268097, 0.054138184, 0.044403076, -0.015655518, -0.0059280396, 0.015167236, -0.021362305, -0.023956299, 0.014083862, 0.024795532, -0.059143066, 0.046417236, -0.024734497, -0.03250122, 0.004459381, 0.03375244, 0.036956787, -0.05227661, -0.012535095, 0.02684021, 0.03112793, -0.014549255, 0.006706238, -0.02658081, 0.005443573, 0.0033454895, 0.02128601, 0.005218506, 0.021697998, -0.0035858154, 0.039245605, 0.017150879, -0.02923584, 0.007255554, -0.02104187, 0.008743286, 0.036071777, 0.010398865, 0.02319336, -0.012779236, -0.048339844, 0.019485474, -0.0018367767, -0.009162903, -0.030838013, 0.007686615, 0.013023376, 0.03149414, 0.057434082, 0.027389526, -0.004550934, -0.046936035, -0.041931152, 0.028015137, 0.048553467, -0.027664185, -0.0024719238, -0.03152466, -0.046966553, 0.017288208, -0.04763794, 0.059570312, -0.05355835, -0.016540527, -0.03881836, 0.049072266, 0.021514893, -0.02885437, -0.060058594, -0.014633179, -0.015029907, -0.02671814, -0.001449585, -0.016906738, -0.068725586, -0.040649414, 0.06781006, -0.04083252, 0.006801605, 0.03491211, -0.023071289, -0.08337402, 0.015174866, -0.017318726, 0.03616333, -0.027709961, 0.003993988, 0.006717682, -0.012001038, 0.0042304993, -0.040893555, -0.033294678, -0.023971558, -0.014480591, -0.020858765, -0.0042381287, -0.006965637, -0.024902344, -0.02999878, -0.027954102, 0.007446289, -0.036468506, 0.0027122498, 0.035980225, -0.02558899, -0.054718018, -0.0129470825, -0.03366089, 0.03756714, 0.0034694672, -0.0079422, 0.06173706, -0.0027008057, -0.006855011, 0.0022144318, 0.0030269623, 0.020874023, 0.012496948, -0.03955078, 0.022903442, 0.007686615, 0.056884766, -0.04449463, -0.05154419, -0.0071525574, 0.011558533, -0.01966858, 0.06640625, 0.026565552, 0.027908325, -0.012382507, 0.029571533, -0.00762558, -0.05154419, 0.01876831, -0.0546875, 0.0042419434, 0.030151367, -0.012519836, -0.00021231174, 0.04031372, -0.0009031296, 0.026855469, 0.009239197, -0.007030487, 0.025756836, -0.010421753, 0.042022705, -0.013412476, -0.034454346, -0.040100098, 0.037719727, -0.012252808, 0.033447266, -0.020935059, 0.02331543, 0.01473999, 0.040771484, -0.0074424744, -0.055236816, 0.027175903, 0.020141602, 0.02168274, 0.07446289, 0.006576538, -0.030029297, -0.012039185, -0.00504303, 0.0039405823, 0.008224487, 0.01158905, -0.012123108, 0.017974854, -0.059326172, -0.039276123, -0.010223389, -0.041046143, 0.049346924, -0.022399902, -0.00037550926, 0.0113220215, -0.012023926, 0.010894775, 0.01234436, 0.03942871, -0.016326904, -0.040222168, -0.027114868, 0.039215088, -0.01247406 ], "summary": [ 0.032318115, -0.016937256, 0.038909912, -0.052215576, -0.048797607, 0.036987305, -0.058746338, -0.03668213, 0.04852295, 0.056488037, -0.068237305, 0.018569946, 0.019439697, 0.016799927, -0.06689453, -0.011680603, 0.034973145, -0.026397705, 0.008171082, -0.013320923, 0.0028209686, -0.005870819, 0.047546387, 0.022994995, -0.00026750565, -0.04727173, -0.0027427673, 0.015609741, -0.00844574, 0.0074691772, 0.010566711, -0.0012569427, 0.022781372, -0.005306244, 0.00680542, 0.003921509, 0.008590698, -0.025131226, -0.01210022, 0.026626587, 0.018798828, 0.010047913, 0.08959961, 0.0048675537, 0.008529663, 0.04736328, -0.04953003, -0.064331055, 0.024261475, -0.011947632, 0.0009713173, -0.009674072, 0.0029125214, -0.034454346, -0.014083862, 0.011741638, -0.03793335, 0.04751587, 0.014137268, 0.02935791, -0.013183594, 0.01626587, -0.016159058, -0.019821167, -0.020004272, 0.010040283, 0.036895752, 0.0071868896, 0.012664795, -0.05050659, -0.013442993, 0.01889038, 0.012672424, -0.024154663, -0.004337311, -0.004333496, 0.0008907318, 0.0019292831, 0.013473511, -0.010902405, -0.008277893, 0.0146484375, 0.06707764, -0.061187744, -0.0012702942, -0.058288574, -0.018157959, 0.0095825195, -0.049957275, -0.046417236, -0.02784729, 0.0034770966, -0.07751465, 0.004436493, -0.011199951, -0.0074424744, -0.035583496, -0.01979065, -0.054138184, -0.022567749, 0.023513794, -0.007549286, 0.018966675, 0.0006389618, 0.013221741, 0.0259552, -0.012710571, -0.002670288, 0.048187256, 0.025421143, 0.009895325, 0.019302368, -0.004600525, -0.026672363, 0.014213562, 0.024871826, -0.0034236908, 0.035003662, 0.013183594, 0.017944336, 0.0069732666, 0.02658081, -0.018188477, 0.036621094, -0.0362854, -0.02619934, -0.005455017, -0.00655365, 0.07940674, 0.021942139, -0.011222839, 0.008140564, -0.08441162, -0.07092285, -0.05569458, -0.006500244, 0.0043640137, -0.014030457, -0.016418457, -0.011566162, 0.0071525574, -0.009025574, -0.0008945465, -0.015289307, 0.0021381378, -0.007335663, 0.024276733, 0.02281189, -0.017211914, -0.012184143, -0.013381958, 0.037261963, 0.06695557, -0.024978638, -0.087890625, -0.07720947, -0.04675293, -0.037322998, 0.01663208, -0.071899414, 0.009971619, -0.01612854, -0.062683105, 0.007663727, -0.0088272095, -0.0035324097, 0.055908203, 0.020095825, 0.0289917, -0.026138306, -0.0033607483, 0.026657104, 0.08905029, 0.020523071, 0.008361816, -0.006385803, -0.056671143, 0.022720337, 0.03277588, -0.044433594, -0.006378174, -0.029846191, -0.0028152466, 0.047088623, -0.014816284, 0.017425537, -0.0079422, 0.0703125, 0.052093506, 0.037353516, -0.09197998, -0.029556274, -0.009216309, 0.00274086, 0.0075950623, -0.0072517395, -0.06100464, -0.00061035156, -0.02319336, -0.036987305, -0.003955841, 0.011650085, -0.0069618225, -0.02230835, -0.0847168, -0.0044021606, -0.019165039, 0.033355713, -0.072265625, -0.0028266907, 0.044128418, -0.030670166, -0.022399902, 0.041412354, 0.034179688, -0.03668213, 0.039489746, -0.026626587, 0.016998291, -0.039031982, 0.028289795, 0.054534912, -0.015296936, 0.039367676, 0.022201538, -0.030456543, 0.01725769, -0.012023926, 0.11248779, -0.027145386, 0.09979248, -0.02519226, 0.045715332, 0.02911377, -0.04095459, -0.013122559, -0.019989014, -0.018463135, -0.0014944077, 0.029876709, 0.031402588, 0.07055664, -0.022994995, -0.031951904, 0.08178711, -0.021896362, -0.0069274902, -0.036132812, -0.004512787, 0.023513794, 0.017608643, -0.023925781, 0.013656616, -0.0025691986, -0.012184143, 0.02722168, 0.02017212, 0.030853271, -0.04333496, 0.030288696, -0.01626587, 0.032409668, 0.01486969, -0.011985779, 0.031158447, 0.013122559, 0.03427124, 0.046966553, 0.003490448, 0.002286911, -0.0072631836, -0.0112838745, 0.0184021, 0.032958984, -0.06237793, -0.037384033, 0.011474609, 0.0008444786, -0.008277893, -0.01663208, 0.00091791153, 0.03677368, 0.027175903, -0.01789856, 0.017227173, -0.0053138733, 0.0038089752, -0.019241333, -0.03213501, 0.0385437, 0.01852417, 0.052215576, 0.027191162, -0.023529053, 0.012588501, 0.026763916, 0.066589355, 0.028182983, 0.0046043396, -0.0033416748, 0.007980347, 0.042510986, -0.028778076, 0.022323608, 0.020812988, 0.0029506683, 0.015991211, -0.017150879, -0.012199402, 0.00049352646, -0.054748535, -0.01158905, 0.015022278, 0.077697754, -0.05883789, -0.037841797, 0.0018005371, 0.03857422, -0.0064582825, -0.017105103, 0.07714844, -0.045440674, -0.046081543, 0.004196167, -0.048797607, -0.010169983, 0.016052246, -0.024505615, -0.041381836, -0.03652954, 0.02128601, -0.032409668, 0.0043182373, 0.078125, 0.0154418945, -0.0073127747, 0.0151901245, -0.027542114, -0.009353638, -0.013336182, 0.037384033, 0.02166748, 0.0053367615, -0.010223389, 0.01927185, 0.0071754456, 0.015464783, 0.0046920776, 0.010444641, 0.03137207, -0.045135498, -0.017837524, -0.022140503, 0.02432251, 0.010635376, 0.0070381165, 0.034973145, 0.035369873, 0.011528015, -0.018096924, -0.000081539154, 0.0088272095, -0.017150879, -0.06124878, 0.021499634, -0.01939392, -0.038726807, -0.008110046, 0.0096588135, 0.025161743, 0.03756714, 0.03164673, -0.04434204, -0.038146973, -0.043914795, -0.040863037, 0.043182373, -0.021408081, 0.0044403076, 0.024810791, 0.009933472, 0.021911621, -0.0031318665, 0.009887695, 0.038146973, 0.016067505, 0.0026874542, 0.0049552917, 0.030303955, 0.008743286, -0.0017910004, -0.012626648, -0.007858276, -0.014640808, -0.013412476, 0.021148682, -0.031280518, -0.012878418, -0.0012617111, -0.01953125, 0.051330566, 0.03353882, 0.018234253, 0.021957397, -0.018325806, 0.05895996, 0.024154663, 0.0026626587, 0.013877869, -0.033081055, 0.020767212, -0.035369873, 0.0037517548, -0.041015625, 0.024108887, -0.05999756, -0.002571106, -0.0023880005, 0.010246277, -0.054229736, -0.009490967, -0.017990112, 0.0038776398, 0.008598328, -0.034973145, 0.035247803, 0.008720398, 0.041900635, 0.024475098, 0.016616821, 0.007843018, -0.010772705, -0.0005502701, 0.009811401, -0.027328491, 0.050933838, 0.00806427, 0.017486572, 0.019577026, -0.04537964, -0.008262634, 0.016342163, 0.011474609, 0.008468628, -0.01158905, 0.010047913, 0.011810303, -0.00111866, 0.008430481, 0.0826416, -0.02355957, 0.008346558, -0.01939392, 0.03125, -0.051513672, -0.010444641, -0.017501831, 0.026062012, 0.023712158, 0.010154724, 0.012161255, -0.036254883, 0.05633545, 0.03036499, 0.045959473, 0.028152466, -0.08227539, -0.0063438416, -0.071899414, 0.026428223, 0.008041382, -0.024002075, -0.0038871765, -0.023254395, 0.0011796951, -0.013381958, 0.002861023, -0.04333496, 0.05996704, 0.0010871887, -0.041290283, 0.018966675, 0.023727417, -0.09411621, -0.041992188, 0.0053100586, -0.07952881, -0.058654785, -0.011940002, -0.019012451, -0.07086182, -0.02267456, -0.009536743, -0.011680603, -0.040100098, 0.036132812, -0.019989014, 0.068847656, 0.025909424, -0.050933838, 0.012207031, 0.011878967, 0.039855957, -0.0018548965, 0.011390686, 0.011520386, -0.006816864, 0.02998352, 0.012382507, -0.007850647, 0.006252289, -0.0154953, -0.015991211, 0.026901245, -0.034606934, -0.0044555664, 0.0024204254, 0.02293396, -0.013648987, -0.005256653, -0.038116455, 0.0024433136, 0.023849487, 0.014595032, -0.01751709, 0.007446289, -0.009025574, 0.07867432, -0.023239136, -0.017700195, 0.067993164, 0.01512146, 0.0033397675, 0.010948181, -0.026763916, 0.0013742447, -0.01977539, -0.06774902, 0.039611816, 0.07110596, 0.0072669983, -0.01878357, -0.039001465, 0.08282471, 0.010566711, 0.004337311, -0.052337646, 0.008506775, -0.052764893, 0.0206604, -0.05218506, -0.038635254, -0.020217896, -0.011734009, 0.0073547363, -0.015930176, -0.02204895, -0.014228821, -0.008384705, 0.07293701, 0.027954102, -0.0003838539, -0.030670166, 0.015434265, -0.006164551, 0.020492554, -0.040802002, -0.10028076, -0.031707764, -0.008087158, -0.034729004, -0.029373169, -0.07342529, -0.03149414, -0.04925537, 0.0009326935, 0.011161804, -0.008102417, 0.015167236, 0.017486572, 0.022872925, 0.016586304, -0.016906738, -0.016296387, -0.02708435, 0.06298828, -0.028701782, 0.0552063, -0.014862061, 0.012763977, -0.02267456, 0.010437012, -0.0034103394, -0.034454346, -0.017562866, 0.007499695, 0.0003771782, 0.008270264, 0.029922485, 0.003227234, 0.035125732, 0.03527832, 0.016204834, 0.01727295, -0.037017822, 0.020980835, 0.022644043, 0.044311523, -0.037017822, -0.017166138, 0.0005221367, 0.011505127, 0.019851685, -0.018508911, -0.0029830933, 0.04208374, 0.053497314, 0.003540039, 0.03427124, -0.039916992, 0.0118637085, 0.041015625, -0.010681152, 0.009399414, -0.0041236877, 0.010093689, 0.03942871, 0.026672363, -0.015548706, 0.01953125, 0.0050354004, -0.007205963, -0.035736084, -0.005138397, 0.0035209656, -0.017303467, 0.013870239, -0.02027893, -0.0053863525, -0.035064697, -0.02671814, 0.03488159, -0.013000488, 0.02142334, 0.047729492, -0.01966858, -0.016189575, -0.02557373, -0.034484863, -0.040863037, -0.016830444, -0.000056684017, 0.0072517395, -0.0034942627, 0.0059165955, -0.03213501, -0.058654785, 0.014450073, -0.0052948, 0.0010232925, -0.02609253, 0.05368042, -0.013320923, 0.04724121, -0.013008118, -0.01953125, 0.0050735474, 0.05090332, -0.045013428, 0.015304565, 0.01637268, -0.028793335, 0.03475952, -0.015975952, 0.022705078, 0.053710938, -0.0038795471, 0.005054474, 0.031829834, 0.0059013367, -0.013839722, -0.035980225, 0.06201172, -0.016815186, -0.018157959, 0.02532959, -0.02268982, -0.018157959, 0.009521484, 0.04660034, -0.022003174, -0.020996094, 0.017837524, -0.034851074, -0.0002309084, 0.007411957, -0.075683594, -0.0063819885, 0.03591919, 0.03149414, -0.030700684, -0.0064582825, 0.04522705, -0.016921997, 0.0064888, 0.043395996, -0.013557434, 0.029876709, 0.029434204, 0.010826111, 0.033416748, 0.017440796, 0.0006380081, -0.0053253174, -0.0016336441, 0.0043640137, 0.019821167, -0.02960205, -0.020736694, 0.042907715, 0.013969421, 0.026153564, 0.023849487, -0.029403687, 0.0234375, -0.025558472, -0.015640259, 0.031341553, -0.015342712, -0.005924225, 0.00970459, 0.0060424805, -0.0317688, -0.0034770966, 0.03677368, -0.06921387, -0.006023407, 0.0065078735, 0.030685425, -0.06518555, -0.008071899, -0.03111267, 0.037384033, 0.03515625, 0.04586792, 0.018981934, 0.013061523, 0.038208008, 0.018112183, 0.020767212, 0.03540039, -0.016403198, -0.0024032593, -0.018157959, 0.025253296, -0.0158844, -0.0040016174, 0.009841919, 0.017089844, 0.0012731552, -0.011627197, 0.006362915, 0.031341553, 0.03149414, -0.005367279, 0.06738281, -0.0039253235, 0.012527466, -0.026504517, -0.049224854, -0.008735657, 0.061828613, -0.027999878, -0.0758667, 0.026626587, -0.050598145, -0.05102539, 0.056640625, -0.0031166077, 0.00340271, -0.006313324, 0.05783081, 0.043670654, -0.0048561096, -0.019134521, -0.0035629272, 0.030029297, 0.016357422, 0.012435913, 0.039520264, 0.021011353, 0.018539429, 0.03933716, 0.020980835, 0.02279663, -0.016799927, -0.009376526, 0.020401001, 0.010398865, -0.022216797, 0.0064697266, -0.016586304, -0.07836914, -0.07409668, -0.05239868, 0.020111084, 0.029159546, -0.06854248, -0.030899048, 0.010688782, 0.0010404587, -0.008674622, -0.036193848, -0.033966064, -0.0395813, -0.011474609, -0.012786865, -0.011154175, 0.023483276, -0.085510254, 0.032043457, 0.054718018, -0.028045654, 0.010673523, -0.034729004, 0.02458191, 0.033691406, -0.064941406, -0.005844116, -0.04800415, 0.013404846, -0.018112183, -0.00598526, -0.0063972473, 0.02319336, 0.013366699, 0.015792847, 0.017349243, 0.004211426, 0.013137817, 0.036071777, 0.055541992, -0.023330688, 0.025634766, -0.019760132, 0.012840271, 0.0446167, -0.03805542, 0.016296387, 0.014450073, 0.039001465, -0.042419434, -0.00025606155, 0.011001587, 0.006008148, -0.012718201, -0.0032901764, -0.025436401, 0.010093689, 0.02331543, -0.008285522, 0.012313843, -0.010696411, 0.0062408447, -0.0010643005, 0.03466797, -0.019012451, 0.018310547, -0.021362305, 0.027893066, 0.03466797, 0.0127334595, -0.023040771, 0.041412354, -0.02281189, 0.026992798, 0.011985779, 0.040496826, 0.028961182, -0.026550293, -0.021087646, 0.013656616, 0.026107788, 0.0005578995, 0.011390686, -0.0206604, -0.006187439, 0.010505676, -0.019134521, -0.0061035156, -0.051208496, -0.006038666, 0.027633667, -0.03173828, -0.018692017, -0.020996094, -0.04397583, -0.0118255615, -0.049835205, 0.046813965, -0.029006958, -0.02218628, -0.063964844, -0.03768921, -0.034057617, -0.0026378632, 0.0137786865, -0.012840271, -0.064697266, -0.0541687, 0.049804688, -0.05126953, 0.0101623535, 0.02444458, -0.0020046234, -0.027999878, 0.040008545, 0.013954163, 0.07385254, -0.025970459, -0.01687622, 0.05593872, 0.010032654, -0.0049591064, -0.06506348, -0.029327393, -0.0033626556, 0.060760498, -0.051971436, 0.009017944, -0.006374359, -0.031555176, -0.0256958, -0.016433716, -0.0056762695, -0.018035889, -0.015312195, 0.012626648, 0.006225586, -0.017654419, -0.010955811, -0.014266968, -0.018157959, -0.010391235, 0.0112838745, 0.08850098, 0.021835327, 0.006641388, 0.011993408, 0.0035648346, -0.016464233, 0.036712646, -0.043151855, 0.022949219, 0.0068626404, 0.056610107, -0.015411377, 0.012878418, 0.010612488, 0.02998352, 0.0013990402, 0.022094727, 0.0073394775, 0.03967285, -0.020751953, 0.06384277, -0.007369995, -0.06555176, 0.029342651, -0.013076782, 0.045684814, 0.00233078, -0.03086853, -0.0014715195, 0.012458801, 0.004398346, -0.010932922, 0.008575439, 0.026916504, -0.032958984, -0.0039253235, 0.0029144287, -0.018234253, -0.070373535, -0.04714966, 0.01461792, -0.00705719, 0.02659607, -0.03414917, 0.035369873, 0.0024089813, 0.0027866364, -0.024993896, -0.020431519, -0.008575439, -0.00579834, 0.010505676, 0.044158936, 0.036499023, 0.0014762878, 0.0043296814, -0.018997192, 0.00010120869, -0.029937744, -0.008476257, 0.00667572, -0.014007568, -0.048675537, -0.006855011, -0.001086235, -0.031341553, 0.03253174, 0.012420654, -0.014663696, 0.033477783, 0.007522583, 0.040374756, 0.0041999817, 0.014251709, 0.022262573, 0.009559631, 0.02357483, -0.016906738, 0.004585266 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07766v1
Vision-Language Integration in Multimodal Video Transformers (Partially) Aligns with the Brain
Dota Tianai Dong, Mariya Toneva
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
Integrating information from multiple modalities is arguably one of the essential prerequisites for grounding artificial intelligence systems with an understanding of the real world. Recent advances in video transformers that jointly learn from vision, text, and sound over time have made some progress toward this goal, but the degree to which these models integrate information from modalities still remains unclear. In this work, we present a promising approach for probing a pre-trained multimodal video transformer model by leveraging neuroscientific evidence of multimodal information processing in the brain. Using brain recordings of participants watching a popular TV show, we analyze the effects of multi-modal connections and interactions in a pre-trained multi-modal video transformer on the alignment with uni- and multi-modal brain regions. We find evidence that vision enhances masked prediction performance during language processing, providing support that cross-modal representations in models can benefit individual modalities. However, we don't find evidence of brain-relevant information captured by the joint multi-modal transformer representations beyond that captured by all of the individual modalities. We finally show that the brain alignment of the pre-trained joint representation can be improved by fine-tuning using a task that requires vision-language inferences. Overall, our results paint an optimistic picture of the ability of multi-modal transformers to integrate vision and language in partially brain-relevant ways but also show that improving the brain alignment of these models may require new approaches.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07766v1
2023-11-13T21:32:37
2023-11-13T21:32:37
{ "title": [ 0.0104904175, 0.010925293, -0.047729492, -0.013458252, -0.012908936, -0.046844482, -0.0079956055, -0.020523071, -0.0075569153, 0.03604126, -0.030532837, -0.015853882, 0.047912598, -0.041870117, -0.007194519, -0.014022827, 0.024108887, 0.044952393, 0.038726807, 0.00447464, -0.012435913, 0.009468079, 0.035705566, -0.03225708, 0.011795044, 0.0017299652, -0.10412598, -0.008354187, -0.028076172, -0.03161621, 0.009407043, 0.059143066, 0.039093018, -0.0181427, 0.0017614365, -0.029968262, -0.028045654, -0.00044083595, -0.004169464, -0.006412506, -0.0071907043, -0.011245728, -0.023361206, 0.035369873, -0.06121826, 0.011352539, -0.04953003, 0.00881958, 0.019454956, 0.008872986, 0.010223389, -0.009338379, 0.011428833, 0.017333984, -0.008514404, -0.007843018, -0.04574585, 0.01777649, 0.021606445, 0.070251465, 0.007396698, -0.0070991516, -0.011428833, -0.07019043, 0.018798828, -0.023742676, -0.02798462, 0.010055542, 0.043273926, 0.04876709, 0.023162842, -0.019302368, 0.014152527, -0.010681152, -0.02909851, 0.024520874, 0.0075416565, 0.01725769, 0.040130615, -0.040924072, 0.023773193, -0.015792847, 0.018966675, -0.064331055, 0.044525146, -0.041900635, 0.011772156, -0.0029144287, -0.060943604, -0.06665039, -0.03451538, 0.018417358, -0.08300781, -0.035217285, -0.0385437, -0.028030396, -0.0032520294, 0.05831909, -0.015129089, 0.0070266724, -0.04711914, 0.0043029785, -0.015007019, -0.04623413, 0.029907227, -0.020523071, -0.019104004, -0.06304932, 0.03591919, 0.023071289, -0.04751587, 0.10229492, 0.023620605, -0.0072784424, -0.011550903, -0.03314209, -0.010345459, 0.033813477, 0.009536743, 0.029922485, 0.0027503967, 0.0016260147, 0.021575928, 0.021560669, 0.017532349, 0.023529053, -0.020492554, -0.013374329, -0.0073394775, 0.0018520355, 0.008049011, 0.079711914, -0.07684326, -0.083740234, -0.08605957, 0.035491943, -0.00554657, 0.02696228, -0.00056552887, -0.014732361, 0.0051956177, -0.0011415482, 0.051605225, 0.019866943, -0.01146698, 0.006034851, 0.035949707, 0.042144775, -0.023406982, -0.08795166, 0.05697632, -0.024993896, -0.03894043, 0.038391113, 0.02330017, 0.025802612, -0.05581665, 0.015167236, 0.0317688, 0.03237915, 0.0036773682, -0.010017395, -0.008674622, 0.030792236, 0.033477783, 0.010482788, 0.0126571655, 0.023544312, 0.014205933, 0.03930664, -0.00033187866, 0.0003707409, 0.029449463, -0.018463135, -0.01360321, 0.00006365776, -0.0018901825, -0.031341553, 0.009803772, -0.008811951, -0.022766113, -0.040893555, -0.0132751465, 0.01876831, -0.05709839, -0.02796936, 0.0013332367, 0.04324341, 0.040771484, 0.023483276, -0.014274597, -0.0030078888, -0.03366089, -0.019165039, -0.02810669, 0.036895752, -0.007598877, 0.042541504, -0.014221191, -0.012077332, -0.0015382767, 0.016311646, -0.02230835, -0.014381409, -0.050750732, -0.03366089, -0.0015707016, 0.03286743, 0.012550354, 0.014457703, 0.006175995, -0.018661499, 0.024017334, -0.063964844, -0.0395813, -0.027328491, 0.004699707, -0.013618469, -0.007724762, -0.021484375, -0.007820129, -0.0074768066, -0.011390686, 0.038330078, -0.011367798, 0.021560669, 0.007080078, 0.009429932, 0.041107178, 0.022964478, 0.06738281, -0.036346436, -0.02293396, -0.01914978, -0.054107666, -0.019638062, -0.01953125, 0.013206482, 0.02281189, 0.023071289, 0.016983032, -0.012573242, 0.0034122467, 0.012626648, 0.06512451, 0.014312744, 0.016784668, -0.0030784607, 0.03253174, 0.04434204, 0.05960083, -0.006664276, 0.024002075, 0.0046463013, 0.021728516, 0.030944824, -0.04623413, -0.03100586, -0.013511658, -0.02142334, 0.047668457, 0.019302368, 0.010643005, 0.012664795, -0.033203125, 0.00027537346, -0.028427124, 0.0036792755, -0.005569458, 0.011711121, 0.013313293, -0.046417236, 0.0060310364, -0.020935059, 0.00957489, -0.0647583, -0.033233643, 0.037139893, 0.011184692, -0.05581665, -0.007858276, 0.003194809, 0.013313293, -0.007457733, 0.03387451, 0.036193848, 0.027191162, 0.0009622574, -0.048217773, -0.022201538, 0.026733398, 0.025253296, -0.032073975, 0.01600647, -0.0014219284, -0.0072631836, 0.045928955, 0.008453369, 0.0079574585, -0.0056114197, -0.022720337, 0.015411377, -0.022399902, 0.002117157, -0.0011377335, 0.016082764, 0.013977051, -0.010543823, -0.027114868, -0.019302368, -0.040252686, -0.010009766, 0.018600464, -0.00315094, -0.0143585205, -0.022338867, -0.029846191, 0.005458832, -0.07147217, -0.05078125, 0.041015625, 0.0082473755, -0.048736572, 0.0026493073, 0.0013065338, -0.006439209, -0.03048706, -0.04135132, -0.048950195, 0.008033752, 0.061431885, -0.0006175041, -0.017929077, -0.023147583, 0.014045715, 0.010673523, 0.007987976, -0.025024414, 0.00920105, 0.01701355, 0.029937744, 0.008682251, -0.0076522827, -0.027511597, 0.024169922, -0.03942871, -0.010093689, 0.016113281, -0.045776367, -0.0036125183, 0.016616821, -0.023605347, -0.0049743652, 0.0034332275, 0.05444336, -0.04840088, -0.026153564, 0.037872314, 0.02671814, -0.00039982796, 0.020690918, 0.027908325, 0.0007677078, -0.047210693, -0.0056266785, -0.06317139, -0.0209198, -0.01939392, 0.007785797, 0.014595032, -0.03378296, -0.025924683, -0.022644043, 0.0069770813, 0.020950317, 0.016098022, -0.021865845, -0.044311523, 0.00033140182, -0.026489258, -0.03604126, -0.025390625, 0.013877869, -0.007041931, 0.10864258, 0.002002716, 0.006629944, -0.01663208, 0.05114746, 0.012237549, -0.02255249, -0.061279297, -0.026138306, -0.0006785393, 0.028213501, 0.016738892, -0.048553467, -0.030288696, -0.08477783, 0.012496948, 0.0093688965, -0.013160706, -0.026916504, 0.03466797, -0.07287598, 0.023101807, -0.007007599, -0.026901245, 0.03579712, 0.10015869, -0.019592285, 0.008796692, 0.022277832, 0.011871338, -0.0075569153, 0.010246277, -0.09649658, 0.022338867, -0.07543945, 0.023391724, 0.03100586, -0.030822754, -0.053253174, -0.0059432983, 0.021652222, 0.044067383, 0.017456055, -0.018112183, 0.0074310303, 0.0062294006, 0.018569946, -0.018539429, -0.028915405, -0.029144287, -0.022262573, 0.01411438, -0.013160706, 0.027297974, 0.014854431, -0.0016775131, -0.033416748, -0.0026569366, -0.0012712479, 0.0018062592, -0.022476196, -0.019073486, 0.004348755, 0.00024294853, -0.030181885, -0.006336212, -0.017990112, 0.026763916, -0.042114258, 0.01260376, -0.014709473, 0.029937744, 0.015182495, 0.056152344, 0.0005464554, -0.036132812, 0.014480591, -0.043548584, -0.012016296, 0.03302002, 0.014183044, 0.004257202, 0.011749268, -0.0025501251, -0.042266846, 0.031433105, 0.01309967, -0.02507019, 0.027053833, 0.002462387, 0.0010690689, -0.008430481, -0.029815674, -0.0011482239, -0.0071144104, 0.011108398, -0.013519287, 0.0019464493, 0.04321289, -0.0079422, -0.005268097, 0.024810791, -0.044036865, -0.008766174, 0.023605347, -0.011123657, -0.038360596, -0.020843506, 0.039794922, -0.06463623, -0.019744873, 0.01776123, 0.013511658, -0.022537231, 0.002363205, -0.03427124, -0.05404663, 0.03845215, -0.050445557, 0.0017023087, 0.016448975, -0.018661499, -0.0017881393, -0.014678955, 0.03744507, 0.052764893, -0.0010490417, 0.007045746, -0.0082473755, 0.018127441, -0.03125, -0.014076233, 0.05633545, -0.054138184, 0.02418518, 0.042114258, -0.002199173, 0.029571533, -0.018081665, 0.05215454, 0.02494812, -0.021118164, -0.043884277, 0.017074585, 0.0010347366, -0.021240234, 0.006290436, -0.04031372, -0.00031352043, 0.022201538, 0.028076172, 0.05947876, -0.015083313, 0.012619019, -0.0028495789, -0.019180298, -0.021270752, -0.022354126, -0.011436462, -0.006439209, -0.003118515, 0.0034751892, -0.010360718, 0.03149414, 0.023529053, -0.03564453, 0.011360168, 0.04333496, -0.015266418, -0.0076141357, -0.027862549, -0.08453369, -0.027709961, 0.015625, -0.0005803108, 0.028060913, 0.027786255, -0.00642395, -0.0031223297, -0.019134521, 0.046783447, 0.02130127, -0.013824463, -0.06573486, 0.0008740425, -0.028045654, -0.06365967, -0.053466797, -0.023483276, -0.0013456345, -0.024398804, -0.0008625984, -0.051727295, 0.014953613, -0.008110046, 0.10229492, 0.042633057, 0.023208618, -0.08428955, 0.031311035, -0.028121948, -0.003025055, 0.000813961, 0.009315491, -0.0042533875, -0.027542114, -0.019195557, 0.005508423, -0.006324768, -0.05255127, 0.035736084, -0.013648987, 0.038604736, -0.00831604, 0.021499634, 0.010139465, 0.010772705, -0.01234436, 0.0031394958, -0.032318115, 0.01687622, -0.006790161, -0.011543274, 0.031051636, 0.019180298, 0.015388489, -0.0039253235, -0.021774292, -0.0068359375, 0.025863647, 0.0033569336, 0.015777588, 0.013809204, 0.004257202, -0.07006836, -0.027069092, -0.009521484, -0.033813477, 0.01625061, -0.048706055, 0.005508423, -0.035125732, 0.006313324, -0.01889038, -0.028564453, 0.020477295, -0.012817383, 0.015052795, -0.045562744, -0.045806885, -0.012786865, 0.06298828, -0.03643799, -0.040649414, -0.030303955, 0.008575439, 0.012077332, 0.03756714, -0.008865356, -0.005821228, 0.050872803, -0.0070610046, 0.001540184, -0.0077552795, -0.035308838, 0.0074157715, -0.058654785, 0.0036258698, -0.02017212, -0.011383057, -0.010368347, -0.02218628, -0.032104492, -0.0014066696, 0.023742676, -0.009635925, 0.033203125, 0.089782715, -0.031829834, 0.03677368, 0.008644104, 0.018585205, 0.01537323, 0.019058228, -0.004211426, -0.00065517426, 0.023086548, -0.036071777, 0.017486572, 0.01776123, 0.004562378, -0.0087890625, 0.03439331, 0.0018262863, 0.0049858093, -0.025543213, 0.030761719, 0.004524231, -0.025100708, 0.034606934, -0.032836914, 0.023529053, 0.003868103, -0.0026283264, 0.013687134, -0.07904053, -0.04714966, -0.014518738, -0.05355835, -0.0635376, 0.012863159, -0.035186768, -0.03652954, -0.064086914, 0.036315918, 0.017486572, 0.020629883, -0.0491333, 0.004676819, -0.06951904, 0.04849243, 0.0058555603, -0.03451538, -0.028167725, 0.038208008, 0.019058228, 0.012863159, 0.029373169, -0.040222168, -0.014831543, 0.02508545, -0.034423828, 0.028137207, 0.062042236, 0.039398193, -0.038024902, -0.013877869, -0.03149414, -0.029388428, -0.002319336, 0.039123535, -0.049926758, -0.01574707, 0.008842468, -0.015991211, 0.0054130554, 0.014831543, 0.0018358231, 0.035888672, -0.009765625, -0.013801575, -0.06677246, 0.018707275, -0.015792847, 0.0052261353, -0.038085938, -0.038238525, -0.0070533752, 0.023605347, 0.0018911362, -0.064208984, 0.028182983, 0.0046310425, -0.022201538, -0.024368286, -0.021102905, 0.029006958, 0.0037517548, -0.028305054, -0.017059326, 0.005970001, -0.032409668, 0.0061798096, 0.0014400482, -0.00598526, -0.02381897, -0.03955078, -0.012969971, 0.025039673, 0.019851685, 0.0014724731, 0.014060974, -0.07684326, -0.018707275, 0.0043792725, 0.004447937, -0.035949707, 0.010032654, -0.017059326, 0.010696411, 0.0072135925, 0.021713257, -0.040771484, 0.03729248, 0.016067505, 0.06213379, -0.001581192, 0.053985596, -0.042388916, -0.033111572, -0.010726929, 0.005542755, 0.055633545, -0.01977539, -0.017089844, 0.012016296, 0.00002002716, 0.04284668, 0.018096924, 0.04547119, 0.043762207, 0.021194458, -0.014228821, -0.003818512, -0.00083971024, -0.035614014, 0.025283813, -0.04876709, 0.050933838, -0.0039253235, -0.0013151169, -0.061035156, 0.043426514, 0.01473999, 0.044067383, -0.024765015, 0.011604309, -0.009529114, 0.0012960434, 0.017837524, -0.021591187, 0.035888672, -0.010345459, -0.0064888, 0.016403198, -0.03555298, 0.0013580322, 0.029922485, 0.01966858, -0.020248413, -0.03378296, -0.005558014, -0.0009012222, -0.007385254, -0.0020503998, -0.0031337738, 0.019119263, -0.01637268, 0.01878357, 0.013618469, 0.021865845, 0.024414062, 0.026870728, -0.06210327, 0.01927185, 0.00422287, 0.021896362, -0.03265381, 0.015129089, 0.03390503, -0.03265381, 0.029541016, -0.0005879402, -0.04107666, -0.02760315, 0.0637207, -0.00055503845, -0.026794434, 0.020935059, 0.030380249, -0.0066947937, 0.028335571, 0.05630493, -0.037963867, -0.03012085, -0.05078125, -0.020584106, 0.03970337, 0.03363037, 0.0051116943, 0.022338867, 0.021530151, -0.005180359, -0.0013151169, 0.009223938, -0.014030457, 0.019607544, 0.041534424, 0.04437256, -0.024642944, -0.038269043, 0.015670776, 0.012680054, -0.033081055, -0.0027618408, 0.009651184, -0.005859375, 0.021133423, 0.050689697, -0.001657486, 0.0049209595, -0.020019531, -0.0013885498, 0.021224976, 0.014259338, -0.010940552, 0.010894775, -0.044799805, -0.026229858, 0.0054893494, -0.049041748, 0.03274536, -0.0076522827, -0.0034446716, -0.03527832, 0.020004272, 0.021972656, -0.027816772, -0.03555298, 0.0022220612, -0.07537842, 0.0038394928, 0.017211914, -0.0132751465, 0.0061187744, -0.0340271, -0.014137268, 0.00045728683, 0.05154419, 0.057373047, -0.055419922, -0.029159546, 0.058502197, 0.031677246, 0.087646484, 0.025665283, -0.05633545, -0.067871094, 0.027740479, 0.04534912, 0.076171875, -0.0149002075, 0.096191406, -0.0574646, 0.0048294067, -0.013511658, -0.020065308, -0.01939392, -0.018707275, -0.02998352, 0.04071045, -0.037384033, -0.017974854, 0.013031006, -0.014663696, -0.05267334, -0.013923645, -0.017730713, 0.028305054, 0.039489746, -0.010902405, 0.037109375, 0.0029239655, -0.009803772, 0.039123535, 0.045532227, 0.0670166, -0.015586853, -0.0061531067, -0.0129470825, 0.0064468384, 0.015182495, -0.06896973, -0.07122803, -0.021209717, 0.08526611, -0.025268555, -0.003753662, 0.039642334, -0.0015163422, -0.04360962, 0.009788513, -0.020507812, -0.02104187, -0.01789856, 0.008415222, 0.015731812, 0.030166626, -0.010543823, 0.010818481, 0.020202637, -0.03881836, 0.023513794, -0.01033783, -0.0013103485, 0.039123535, -0.026687622, 0.05682373, -0.015670776, 0.01084137, -0.027557373, 0.041015625, -0.01600647, 0.02659607, -0.023529053, 0.028427124, 0.00059890747, 0.022216797, -0.00048041344, -0.053985596, 0.067871094, 0.033294678, 0.030975342, 0.006706238, 0.05203247, -0.030761719, -0.023895264, 0.008354187, 0.02658081, 0.018493652, -0.009529114, -0.013259888, 0.022201538, -0.064697266, -0.05545044, -0.053344727, -0.02355957, -0.018798828, -0.044403076, 0.04647827, -0.026062012, -0.008934021, 0.011390686, 0.011054993, 0.04107666, -0.015853882, -0.036865234, -0.097717285, 0.0154953, 0.0004479885 ], "summary": [ 0.031021118, 0.020401001, -0.0009226799, -0.010505676, -0.024658203, -0.0154418945, -0.036834717, -0.05593872, 0.0038471222, 0.042785645, -0.021499634, -0.016784668, 0.057556152, -0.03062439, 0.0041885376, -0.017150879, 0.026473999, 0.038116455, 0.057556152, 0.006011963, 0.0154800415, 0.018829346, 0.023483276, -0.028259277, 0.04626465, -0.058929443, -0.071899414, 0.051452637, 0.03237915, 0.0413208, 0.03152466, -0.025100708, 0.008331299, 0.0116119385, -0.014129639, -0.064941406, -0.016052246, 0.0064582825, 0.0020523071, 0.013061523, -0.0055007935, 0.014228821, 0.052856445, 0.01852417, -0.0395813, 0.018722534, -0.014434814, -0.0101623535, 0.028793335, -0.012290955, -0.0034751892, -0.017288208, -0.011054993, -0.020950317, -0.023025513, -0.010627747, -0.07623291, 0.028167725, 0.017120361, 0.12237549, 0.038757324, 0.0012321472, -0.041137695, -0.103759766, -0.0022258759, -0.0138549805, 0.0345459, -0.015167236, -0.001540184, 0.010231018, 0.03677368, -0.003063202, 0.035369873, -0.055023193, -0.011398315, 0.036346436, 0.035003662, 0.032165527, 0.0023403168, -0.06365967, 0.02947998, -0.006111145, 0.0284729, -0.08911133, 0.04434204, -0.07067871, 0.014060974, 0.004058838, -0.032836914, -0.013168335, -0.03503418, -0.01878357, -0.06896973, 0.036010742, 0.011375427, -0.005332947, -0.021331787, -0.005092621, 0.006401062, 0.023147583, 0.008926392, -0.020446777, 0.028457642, -0.048461914, 0.01777649, 0.00033783913, 0.0026874542, -0.068359375, 0.024917603, 0.00041246414, -0.037078857, 0.10235596, 0.0039787292, -0.05041504, -0.024230957, 0.051574707, 0.028244019, 0.011222839, 0.016662598, 0.018997192, -0.016021729, 0.019989014, -0.047210693, 0.006778717, 0.021011353, 0.013717651, 0.019882202, 0.021316528, -0.01701355, 0.0181427, 0.0032844543, 0.022964478, -0.023880005, -0.018188477, -0.06304932, -0.00024819374, 0.026519775, 0.027496338, 0.0074501038, -0.009628296, 0.014152527, 0.0019445419, 0.022735596, 0.0032691956, -0.0109939575, 0.016845703, 0.02305603, 0.013771057, -0.030578613, -0.06274414, 0.03967285, -0.028015137, -0.016021729, 0.003238678, 0.059692383, -0.020477295, 0.009086609, -0.02281189, 0.038269043, 0.018356323, 0.007858276, -0.0034999847, 0.01576233, 0.04840088, 0.017074585, 0.015991211, -0.0079574585, 0.008201599, 0.0206604, -0.012306213, -0.0062332153, -0.0047683716, 0.023590088, -0.005874634, 0.0006875992, 0.010856628, 0.004802704, -0.0035324097, 0.0058250427, -0.0012168884, -0.012634277, -0.037139893, 0.027008057, 0.0001796484, -0.061950684, 0.017791748, -0.0138168335, 0.07647705, 0.062042236, 0.0042800903, -0.017944336, -0.016418457, -0.015625, 0.00018262863, -0.0041999817, 0.0446167, -0.014343262, 0.04623413, -0.008430481, -0.039978027, 0.05859375, 0.018630981, -0.017288208, -0.053131104, -0.118652344, 0.0007739067, -0.0181427, 0.025680542, -0.03604126, -0.021469116, 0.015090942, -0.034820557, 0.012420654, -0.026123047, -0.016815186, -0.037628174, 0.012489319, -0.019546509, 0.00242424, -0.027145386, -0.001709938, 0.024963379, -0.030349731, 0.03250122, -0.025665283, 0.013717651, -0.006164551, 0.036132812, 0.026885986, 0.021560669, 0.05795288, -0.049560547, 0.010238647, 0.027404785, -0.030319214, -0.03918457, -0.016494751, -0.06719971, 0.047210693, 0.057281494, 0.015823364, 0.019897461, -0.03302002, -0.004425049, 0.008010864, 0.00021803379, 0.01499176, -0.00806427, 0.013442993, 0.018203735, 0.008804321, -0.016403198, 0.041503906, -0.034973145, 0.02796936, 0.023773193, -0.018249512, -0.06286621, 0.027709961, -0.033050537, 0.043426514, -0.017440796, -0.039886475, 0.008644104, -0.017318726, -0.038085938, -0.026519775, -0.044006348, 0.02079773, -0.023162842, 0.017684937, -0.090026855, -0.0013999939, -0.06088257, -0.03265381, -0.033172607, -0.04119873, 0.05230713, 0.019104004, -0.044921875, 0.021606445, 0.017913818, -0.037994385, -0.021728516, 0.040161133, 0.019577026, -0.016662598, 0.010826111, 0.031066895, 0.049865723, 0.050109863, 0.047088623, 0.025299072, 0.019638062, -0.0043678284, -0.008003235, 0.025390625, -0.054595947, 0.052124023, -0.04135132, 0.01776123, 0.057006836, -0.027679443, 0.0076446533, -0.0037345886, 0.024627686, -0.038330078, 0.029464722, -0.008468628, -0.01348114, -0.049194336, -0.007358551, 0.040802002, 0.055358887, -0.007987976, -0.025100708, -0.010597229, 0.04916382, -0.008651733, 0.0007147789, 0.06939697, 0.0041160583, -0.026397705, 0.018356323, -0.013694763, -0.014656067, 0.018218994, -0.040161133, -0.019470215, 0.009429932, 0.015144348, 0.005420685, 0.0010757446, -0.0076904297, 0.004096985, -0.0031852722, 0.008216858, -0.042510986, 0.007118225, 0.03564453, 0.06463623, 0.013252258, 0.012214661, -0.008575439, -0.03302002, 0.0031547546, 0.0072669983, 0.009803772, -0.037628174, 0.0021133423, 0.015396118, -0.011810303, -0.012893677, 0.034820557, 0.029205322, -0.021102905, 0.011329651, 0.016677856, -0.011924744, -0.026306152, 0.058624268, -0.0041770935, 0.009254456, -0.070495605, -0.006134033, -0.03918457, -0.009109497, -0.054779053, 0.022003174, 0.039733887, -0.013458252, 0.03793335, -0.059753418, -0.0010929108, -0.012031555, 0.015548706, 0.04736328, -0.022842407, -0.02583313, 0.027496338, -0.013595581, 0.0059051514, -0.01209259, -0.0031833649, 0.10247803, -0.0028705597, 0.017333984, 0.045074463, 0.030029297, 0.0044441223, -0.028625488, -0.032226562, -0.004886627, -0.016036987, 0.012168884, 0.011924744, -0.05392456, -0.05319214, -0.048461914, -0.013168335, 0.024520874, 0.023025513, 0.016555786, 0.017074585, -0.04864502, 0.04498291, -0.0121536255, -0.0022621155, 0.023757935, 0.082214355, -0.01802063, -0.040008545, -0.0090789795, -0.007820129, -0.0070610046, 0.029663086, -0.036834717, 0.018310547, -0.038513184, 0.00440979, 0.0018415451, 0.022827148, -0.02507019, 0.0005660057, 0.042236328, 0.040496826, -0.023742676, -0.01361084, -0.025253296, 0.001906395, 0.001449585, -0.0128479, -0.03152466, -0.018798828, -0.022476196, 0.03353882, -0.016204834, -0.013763428, 0.0076522827, -0.03302002, -0.028671265, 0.0016860962, 0.006839752, -0.008079529, -0.02180481, -0.010505676, 0.03253174, 0.0084991455, -0.033050537, -0.01927185, -0.032409668, 0.0063476562, -0.0014848709, 0.034179688, -0.0063209534, 0.03253174, 0.0037441254, 0.046966553, 0.045166016, -0.07495117, 0.0068740845, -0.03933716, -0.039764404, 0.02861023, 0.02267456, 0.026672363, -0.014892578, 0.009941101, -0.041625977, 0.027923584, 0.016555786, -0.043701172, -0.012802124, -0.01739502, -0.0040283203, -0.03668213, -0.010635376, 0.00051259995, 0.05456543, 0.020568848, -0.057861328, 0.012374878, -0.0062561035, 0.0031585693, -0.0033035278, 0.017837524, 0.0016527176, 0.0032463074, 0.027160645, 0.009048462, -0.011390686, -0.015060425, 0.05810547, -0.030761719, -0.012718201, 0.017196655, -0.01096344, 0.05645752, -0.012420654, -0.0491333, 0.010726929, -0.029632568, -0.0019016266, 0.036895752, -0.015151978, 0.021148682, 0.030776978, -0.0021800995, 0.0138168335, -0.0037250519, 0.0059432983, -0.03555298, -0.008880615, -0.0021209717, -0.019607544, -0.026565552, 0.056640625, -0.053253174, 0.022445679, 0.032318115, 0.019882202, 0.03994751, 0.005908966, 0.0047683716, 0.008613586, -0.01171875, 0.0017766953, 0.028717041, 0.0077552795, -0.017120361, -0.0077171326, -0.0040512085, -0.01777649, 0.034362793, 0.041168213, 0.01361084, -0.026809692, -0.02822876, 0.008560181, 0.032714844, -0.022735596, -0.024108887, -0.028579712, 0.049957275, 0.007183075, 0.012237549, 0.012565613, 0.008834839, 0.010536194, -0.02420044, 0.014282227, 0.024627686, -0.003036499, -0.027893066, -0.014518738, -0.059173584, -0.018798828, -0.0026931763, -0.0008263588, 0.05178833, -0.0287323, -0.0024986267, 0.03427124, 0.021331787, 0.03048706, 0.06036377, -0.0881958, -0.08514404, -0.018417358, -0.026672363, -0.036499023, -0.028869629, -0.08203125, -0.0423584, -0.03152466, 0.015335083, -0.052246094, 0.0075798035, 0.01966858, 0.13439941, 0.047790527, 0.04067993, -0.09857178, 0.018569946, -0.047454834, -0.004371643, 0.006214142, 0.005794525, -0.026123047, -0.013511658, 0.047210693, -0.010185242, -0.01159668, -0.06573486, 0.0003464222, 0.023727417, -0.0099487305, 0.025970459, 0.010612488, 0.012077332, 0.008102417, -0.0016775131, 0.014083862, -0.0121154785, 0.0012702942, -0.03201294, -0.043640137, 0.037841797, 0.006629944, 0.00044322014, -0.007949829, -0.030914307, 0.016937256, 0.033691406, 0.019638062, 0.0017194748, -0.012382507, 0.025009155, -0.020004272, -0.020248413, 0.0016698837, -0.033325195, -0.024734497, 0.0006928444, 0.0078125, 0.016143799, -0.009277344, 0.021759033, -0.010253906, 0.012588501, 0.016708374, 0.008041382, -0.055999756, -0.08520508, -0.039215088, 0.09918213, -0.034698486, -0.051208496, -0.03677368, -0.022354126, 0.013771057, 0.012863159, -0.004989624, -0.039154053, 0.06347656, -0.012580872, -0.00022733212, 0.020950317, -0.028915405, 0.00009560585, -0.0473938, 0.0008969307, -0.048675537, -0.02003479, 0.04510498, -0.026550293, -0.015716553, -0.013771057, 0.007534027, -0.039886475, -0.02696228, 0.0010919571, -0.023880005, -0.0027770996, 0.039520264, -0.014007568, -0.02658081, 0.01222229, -0.027557373, 0.0047073364, -0.021331787, -0.045532227, 0.0038433075, 0.01210022, 0.007331848, 0.039886475, 0.044189453, 0.0206604, 0.026168823, -0.012916565, 0.011207581, -0.030349731, -0.02935791, 0.0033035278, -0.0015611649, 0.028564453, 0.0064735413, 0.007751465, 0.005630493, 0.0107803345, -0.037353516, -0.040374756, -0.009666443, -0.06365967, -0.018081665, -0.02796936, -0.06109619, -0.045135498, 0.009597778, 0.025100708, 0.017181396, -0.045898438, 0.008293152, -0.06762695, -0.007045746, -0.018875122, 0.0049476624, -0.012191772, 0.04034424, 0.016860962, -0.011962891, -0.011131287, -0.04714966, -0.018203735, 0.008262634, -0.0143585205, 0.026306152, 0.028518677, 0.0340271, 0.0020751953, 0.0023612976, -0.010879517, -0.011627197, -0.005382538, 0.02960205, -0.05923462, -0.00008815527, 0.023849487, -0.0096588135, -0.009101868, 0.02305603, -0.01763916, 0.018737793, -0.003780365, -0.012863159, -0.04156494, 0.0050964355, -0.0060806274, 0.0031833649, 0.0022335052, -0.00008606911, 0.0033855438, 0.013893127, 0.016723633, -0.046020508, -0.004989624, -0.0067863464, -0.04248047, 0.007209778, -0.030151367, 0.020095825, 0.026626587, 0.0058135986, -0.0055656433, 0.009773254, -0.018554688, 0.018585205, -0.01739502, 0.005207062, -0.021011353, -0.02545166, 0.008743286, 0.020523071, 0.0015802383, -0.015396118, -0.003736496, -0.029785156, -0.019195557, 0.018661499, -0.003528595, -0.036071777, 0.0020065308, -0.029586792, -0.0078086853, 0.033355713, 0.018844604, -0.058135986, 0.056549072, -0.005458832, 0.042785645, -0.008232117, 0.07165527, 0.011116028, -0.027252197, 0.0035495758, 0.04437256, 0.055664062, -0.036468506, -0.0023117065, -0.040924072, 0.028533936, 0.030593872, 0.034576416, 0.0066452026, -0.0028133392, -0.027404785, -0.00223732, 0.010147095, -0.013618469, -0.026870728, 0.042022705, -0.018859863, 0.018234253, -0.017822266, -0.02659607, -0.026260376, 0.064208984, -0.012062073, -0.008453369, -0.0028705597, -0.005645752, -0.0078086853, 0.040985107, -0.043121338, -0.014533997, -0.046417236, -0.010948181, 0.00046372414, 0.0023174286, -0.028381348, 0.00016641617, 0.04498291, 0.0141067505, -0.012641907, -0.02684021, 0.00013697147, 0.018692017, -0.017745972, -0.019897461, -0.03677368, 0.01777649, -0.032592773, 0.011871338, 0.019088745, 0.039154053, -0.0025901794, 0.0070381165, -0.013114929, 0.022583008, 0.005870819, 0.045288086, -0.0068511963, 0.018951416, 0.008422852, 0.007133484, -0.014465332, -0.00022017956, -0.016983032, 0.01537323, 0.048309326, 0.037139893, -0.02645874, 0.014755249, 0.0209198, 0.00057935715, -0.017684937, 0.041656494, -0.030426025, -0.033447266, -0.04119873, -0.019607544, 0.024719238, 0.042938232, -0.0059890747, 0.01675415, 0.04244995, 0.020889282, -0.023269653, 0.027053833, -0.029052734, 0.023284912, 0.019561768, 0.0039520264, 0.0026226044, -0.018676758, 0.020401001, 0.022201538, -0.0038604736, 0.024963379, 0.008300781, 0.050445557, 0.06173706, 0.038208008, -0.029174805, 0.022506714, 0.05999756, -0.023620605, 0.016952515, -0.02722168, -0.006126404, -0.026885986, -0.018966675, 0.022918701, -0.01902771, -0.011505127, 0.011703491, -0.057769775, -0.022445679, -0.050354004, 0.020584106, -0.046722412, 0.0017089844, -0.02128601, -0.043792725, -0.07659912, 0.0073432922, 0.03881836, -0.011100769, 0.017181396, -0.03967285, -0.04586792, 0.0002617836, 0.017089844, 0.03543091, -0.03060913, -0.04046631, 0.061950684, 0.03414917, 0.09887695, 0.016098022, -0.05508423, -0.048858643, 0.039154053, 0.05633545, 0.04324341, -0.030776978, 0.107543945, -0.006526947, -0.009124756, 0.01486969, 0.019805908, 0.017074585, 0.034484863, -0.05496216, 0.03543091, -0.022338867, 0.00440979, 0.022827148, -0.019256592, -0.032226562, 0.0071754456, -0.02722168, 0.041809082, 0.027236938, 0.0061454773, -0.0029411316, 0.047607422, -0.008460999, 0.026687622, 0.01612854, 0.041107178, -0.009262085, -0.043182373, 0.0039749146, -0.023468018, -0.0059814453, -0.049438477, -0.03640747, 0.014831543, 0.07281494, -0.009407043, -0.029785156, -0.009963989, -0.025283813, 0.017745972, 0.04562378, 0.0012378693, -0.0154418945, -0.0071907043, 0.0062561035, 0.05886841, 0.020019531, -0.049926758, 0.023529053, 0.009338379, -0.0715332, 0.0047721863, -0.017303467, 0.0033569336, 0.0057525635, -0.012718201, 0.0287323, -0.012969971, -0.02796936, -0.019638062, 0.006072998, -0.01373291, -0.012069702, -0.013473511, 0.0071411133, -0.02394104, -0.0028095245, -0.008865356, -0.019332886, 0.024917603, 0.0038928986, 0.027816772, -0.007461548, 0.02407837, -0.017974854, -0.014671326, 0.003364563, 0.023986816, 0.02784729, 0.04043579, -0.051727295, 0.023620605, -0.09954834, -0.05316162, -0.046203613, -0.029281616, -0.015625, -0.032714844, 0.045288086, 0.018035889, -0.0020580292, 0.0061302185, 0.026245117, 0.011764526, 0.0014429092, -0.018157959, -0.09020996, 0.012374878, -0.0036201477 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07723v1
Generalization Analogies (GENIES): A Testbed for Generalizing AI Oversight to Hard-To-Measure Domains
Joshua Clymer, Garrett Baker, Rohan Subramani, Sam Wang
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
As AI systems become more intelligent and their behavior becomes more challenging to assess, they may learn to game the flaws of human feedback instead of genuinely striving to follow instructions; however, this risk can be mitigated by controlling how LLMs generalize human feedback to situations where it is unreliable. To better understand how reward models generalize, we craft 69 distribution shifts spanning 8 categories. We find that reward models do not learn to evaluate `instruction-following' by default and instead favor personas that resemble internet text. Techniques for interpreting reward models' internal representations achieve better generalization than standard fine-tuning, but still frequently fail to distinguish instruction-following from conflated behaviors. We consolidate the 15 most challenging distribution shifts into the GENaralization analogIES (GENIES) benchmark, which we hope will enable progress toward controlling reward model generalization.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07723v1
2023-11-13T20:07:36
2023-11-13T20:07:36
{ "title": [ -0.027709961, 0.009864807, -0.0076675415, -0.011428833, -0.014633179, -0.010520935, 0.000005066395, -0.045166016, 0.01474762, 0.017303467, -0.042938232, 0.02671814, -0.0048599243, -0.009292603, -0.027862549, -0.007537842, -0.017669678, 0.04660034, -0.012237549, -0.04498291, -0.018600464, -0.054992676, 0.03869629, 0.058563232, 0.03363037, -0.017028809, -0.085998535, 0.01838684, -0.016601562, -0.0041923523, -0.008781433, -0.012924194, 0.008865356, 0.034973145, -0.0022850037, 0.00868988, -0.04168701, 0.043151855, 0.019805908, 0.008872986, 0.03677368, -0.024627686, 0.02947998, -0.020324707, -0.0034923553, -0.009162903, 0.013259888, -0.013298035, -0.015472412, 0.03451538, 0.017440796, 0.032226562, -0.00982666, 0.029174805, 0.018997192, -0.036895752, -0.022079468, -0.0073013306, 0.049560547, 0.027954102, -0.0077438354, -0.06213379, 0.037994385, -0.02709961, -0.0440979, -0.021865845, -0.020950317, 0.009887695, 0.088256836, 0.013366699, -0.022399902, 0.027252197, -0.0016050339, 0.046295166, -0.044311523, -0.01838684, 0.03201294, 0.025222778, 0.054260254, -0.0065307617, -0.00053453445, -0.023025513, -0.0076942444, -0.022216797, 0.006816864, -0.023452759, -0.0112838745, -0.0038013458, -0.046081543, -0.03591919, -0.015701294, -0.011260986, -0.040924072, 0.020492554, 0.00065135956, -0.037078857, 0.007575989, 0.024810791, 0.012878418, -0.049621582, 0.011993408, 0.011016846, -0.07305908, -0.0036678314, 0.015136719, 0.008491516, -0.023162842, -0.04525757, -0.0033054352, 0.025497437, -0.03994751, 0.030578613, 0.015106201, 0.0070114136, 0.004837036, -0.021148682, -0.035949707, 0.037872314, 0.003665924, 0.027282715, -0.025543213, -0.033294678, 0.037475586, 0.043060303, 0.01499939, 0.024047852, -0.02619934, -0.0110321045, 0.023544312, 0.020324707, 0.0021419525, 0.03942871, -0.07965088, -0.08666992, -0.043823242, 0.028686523, 0.007335663, -0.0033397675, -0.0032653809, -0.0012226105, 0.03805542, -0.007820129, 0.0029582977, 0.017562866, 0.019760132, 0.025680542, 0.061767578, -0.016998291, -0.054504395, -0.03665161, -0.016799927, 0.028411865, 0.015930176, 0.0063438416, -0.049926758, -0.013252258, -0.0914917, 0.00472641, 0.034606934, -0.0017728806, 0.01121521, 0.0026283264, -0.0058288574, -0.0074501038, 0.044952393, -0.01927185, 0.0007596016, 0.041412354, 0.003332138, 0.051757812, -0.007888794, 0.004638672, -0.015274048, -0.003118515, -0.0141067505, -0.0073242188, -0.0141067505, -0.00077056885, 0.011116028, -0.019348145, 0.011512756, -0.020462036, -0.02218628, 0.060150146, -0.0256958, -0.04421997, -0.03945923, -0.06616211, 0.064086914, -0.008331299, -0.03930664, 0.009216309, -0.026016235, -0.023895264, -0.047332764, -0.0209198, 0.008239746, 0.03314209, -0.023330688, 0.011177063, -0.015258789, -0.007896423, -0.023986816, -0.0023994446, -0.015258789, -0.033599854, -0.0036067963, 0.0121154785, -0.022705078, 0.07183838, 0.06365967, 0.022659302, -0.062469482, 0.058563232, -0.0032367706, -0.095825195, 0.037231445, -0.025238037, -0.0040016174, -0.038970947, -0.0074882507, 0.0074882507, -0.007434845, 0.042266846, 0.0014429092, 0.008094788, 0.0034713745, -0.015182495, 0.039886475, 0.02519226, 0.09094238, -0.049621582, 0.038604736, 0.017807007, 0.0032539368, -0.014755249, 0.012397766, -0.078186035, 0.025161743, 0.036071777, 0.0053482056, -0.0032730103, -0.0028572083, 0.033203125, 0.04043579, -0.0070343018, 0.010131836, 0.007709503, 0.0038261414, 0.00409317, 0.057037354, 0.02998352, 0.061553955, 0.018676758, 0.014373779, 0.056732178, -0.0016784668, -0.0056037903, -0.0041007996, -0.011306763, 0.007217407, 0.015686035, -0.006099701, 0.014122009, -0.059661865, 0.01914978, -0.02230835, 0.009735107, -0.012496948, -0.003545761, 0.04067993, -0.006298065, 0.0050239563, -0.0050201416, 0.02192688, -0.022781372, -0.03591919, 0.020324707, 0.038757324, -0.04824829, 0.010932922, 0.023803711, 0.01499176, 0.0013599396, 0.014984131, -0.0126953125, -0.0044670105, 0.0066604614, 0.0031414032, 0.0006017685, 0.03253174, 0.018814087, 0.011276245, -0.0032176971, 0.050109863, -0.02407837, 0.04284668, 0.053222656, -0.018203735, 0.010215759, -0.05731201, 0.0068740845, 0.0066070557, -0.024017334, -0.0003914833, 0.010848999, 0.023162842, 0.0037155151, -0.03387451, -0.002445221, -0.085632324, -0.017349243, -0.00056028366, -0.03543091, -0.017486572, -0.025405884, -0.005821228, -0.01374054, -0.02720642, 0.0070762634, 0.0848999, -0.016433716, -0.0007352829, -0.029129028, -0.0002629757, -0.035858154, -0.028915405, -0.03048706, -0.012931824, 0.027450562, 0.039215088, -0.0012550354, -0.076416016, -0.066223145, 0.011764526, 0.03515625, -0.022384644, 0.0579834, -0.012481689, -0.018798828, 0.0043525696, 0.01020813, 0.03186035, -0.018875122, 0.03353882, -0.08178711, 0.0037994385, 0.025741577, -0.049682617, -0.0025234222, 0.039764404, -0.050445557, -0.025741577, -0.019348145, 0.040008545, -0.012039185, -0.020233154, 0.0038337708, 0.025405884, -0.034729004, 0.034973145, 0.018096924, 0.00374794, -0.06414795, 0.007751465, -0.04916382, -0.014640808, -0.032928467, 0.01586914, 0.04269409, -0.042266846, 0.018035889, -0.067871094, -0.02708435, -0.0076828003, 0.012451172, -0.0126571655, -0.02394104, -0.000664711, -0.008720398, -0.017120361, 0.006706238, -0.023101807, 0.015014648, 0.07775879, -0.0039043427, -0.024765015, 0.019439697, 0.0058898926, 0.013381958, -0.020187378, -0.027786255, -0.055847168, -0.008476257, 0.013687134, 0.011810303, 0.02331543, -0.0154418945, -0.054626465, -0.022384644, 0.0044555664, 0.016204834, 0.005695343, 0.008377075, -0.078125, 0.02041626, -0.034942627, -0.0060539246, 0.031402588, 0.0104522705, 0.03125, 0.009033203, 0.038391113, -0.022323608, 0.008056641, -0.04260254, -0.106933594, 0.02671814, -0.037384033, -0.0078048706, -0.012069702, 0.025421143, -0.06347656, -0.024658203, -0.057769775, 0.041900635, 0.017822266, 0.06524658, -0.02406311, -0.024368286, -0.0010623932, -0.039520264, 0.005130768, -0.023849487, -0.024429321, 0.017547607, -0.017944336, 0.07397461, 0.0019664764, 0.0079574585, -0.05065918, -0.015838623, -0.06048584, -0.019104004, -0.015594482, -0.036132812, 0.0132369995, -0.041900635, -0.020690918, -0.004055023, -0.018417358, -0.007633209, -0.0541687, 0.015991211, -0.020889282, 0.08251953, 0.0034255981, 0.00995636, 0.0018987656, -0.00995636, 0.022583008, -0.013916016, -0.0440979, 0.011184692, -0.0056610107, 0.03527832, -0.019851685, -0.017669678, -0.058380127, 0.01576233, -0.031311035, 0.030639648, -0.00039172173, -0.009460449, -0.0052223206, -0.016311646, -0.0014410019, 0.014717102, -0.020324707, -0.0036468506, 0.027801514, -0.008163452, 0.0019931793, -0.08117676, -0.0027236938, 0.0009598732, -0.14440918, -0.06536865, 0.04144287, -0.022766113, 0.017807007, -0.050567627, 0.034301758, 0.0020961761, -0.0021419525, -0.020248413, -0.024398804, 0.068603516, 0.012031555, -0.077697754, -0.0019550323, 0.0635376, -0.019226074, 0.019607544, 0.004043579, -0.029541016, -0.037902832, -0.04888916, 0.005996704, -0.016525269, -0.009513855, -0.013748169, 0.006793976, 0.050079346, -0.044891357, 0.061523438, -0.04156494, 0.01838684, -0.028884888, 0.014297485, 0.021255493, 0.030029297, -0.014259338, 0.041412354, -0.0015411377, -0.003967285, -0.04977417, 0.024108887, 0.002286911, -0.056854248, 0.040527344, -0.007396698, 0.005027771, 0.04837036, 0.005168915, 0.0871582, -0.03878784, 0.008918762, 0.01576233, -0.014419556, -0.04751587, 0.021026611, 0.03744507, 0.01928711, -0.009613037, 0.047607422, 0.004699707, 0.071777344, -0.019561768, -0.00869751, 0.007232666, 0.01979065, -0.063964844, -0.0023593903, -0.019607544, -0.019638062, -0.039733887, 0.016433716, -0.005088806, 0.0131073, 0.05279541, -0.0071029663, -0.029769897, -0.013961792, 0.009681702, 0.0016708374, 0.001168251, -0.062042236, -0.008239746, -0.014320374, -0.051635742, -0.047210693, -0.0041656494, 0.030654907, 0.0009784698, 0.0019159317, -0.032562256, 0.012641907, 0.021606445, 0.059661865, 0.029785156, 0.0033721924, -0.05038452, -0.00031018257, -0.036621094, -0.019363403, 0.021652222, -0.03366089, -0.016983032, -0.02670288, 0.024902344, 0.005458832, -0.008621216, -0.033172607, 0.02116394, -0.017059326, 0.018539429, 0.010185242, 0.03414917, 0.024032593, 0.008659363, -0.0011405945, 0.009231567, -0.040161133, 0.0015535355, -0.010398865, 0.024978638, 0.009803772, 0.024719238, 0.040374756, 0.0027370453, 0.019577026, -0.011230469, 0.010169983, -0.004245758, -0.010025024, -0.0040130615, 0.029953003, -0.010978699, -0.04144287, -0.0047416687, 0.02078247, 0.0059509277, -0.039611816, 0.05203247, 0.019470215, 0.043151855, 0.041931152, -0.009651184, 0.0060272217, 0.0005364418, -0.011924744, -0.04232788, -0.05368042, -0.01171875, 0.037139893, -0.022323608, -0.020507812, -0.00038695335, 0.019195557, 0.004146576, 0.028869629, 0.0072898865, 0.024032593, 0.020629883, 0.004753113, 0.008857727, 0.0009407997, -0.04638672, 0.0052833557, 0.044555664, 0.018951416, -0.024429321, 0.0059127808, -0.058502197, -0.009269714, -0.00040459633, -0.03579712, 0.019088745, -0.09240723, 0.0036144257, 0.036315918, -0.016082764, 0.035125732, -0.0041160583, -0.022079468, 0.009338379, 0.01939392, -0.014251709, 0.016601562, 0.004009247, -0.009559631, -0.005821228, 0.009422302, 0.04046631, 0.028411865, 0.018676758, 0.020858765, 0.0025997162, -0.055877686, 0.022857666, 0.026931763, 0.01828003, -0.019439697, -0.040863037, 0.025680542, 0.0050964355, -0.002653122, 0.017501831, -0.028121948, -0.03012085, -0.0034313202, -0.017547607, -0.028640747, 0.024383545, 0.0027809143, -0.029190063, -0.027633667, 0.03213501, -0.023132324, -0.008041382, 0.005710602, 0.008712769, -0.009864807, 0.03677368, 0.0287323, -0.06567383, -0.03845215, 0.028564453, 0.028457642, 0.020980835, 0.0050621033, -0.021911621, 0.0055885315, -0.01159668, -0.050598145, -0.044281006, -0.023086548, -0.026351929, 0.040374756, -0.0043029785, -0.04714966, -0.032165527, -0.005104065, 0.002904892, -0.022659302, -0.019058228, 0.037200928, -0.0007529259, -0.0047836304, 0.008079529, 0.020614624, -0.041778564, 0.00969696, 0.037628174, -0.041748047, -0.009887695, 0.00674057, 0.015625, 0.0076179504, -0.044403076, -0.0062179565, 0.022903442, 0.020019531, 0.01083374, -0.0033416748, 0.032836914, 0.007381439, -0.00045204163, 0.0073661804, 0.10119629, -0.07635498, -0.028045654, -0.019180298, 0.012771606, -0.009490967, 0.06652832, -0.024978638, -0.03930664, -0.027786255, -0.03253174, -0.026763916, 0.005710602, 0.040130615, 0.00021767616, 0.056640625, -0.04711914, -0.022003174, -0.020874023, 0.008140564, -0.035858154, 0.0054130554, -0.009506226, 0.009590149, 0.010070801, 0.026672363, 0.005519867, -0.005088806, 0.0101623535, 0.029296875, -0.02027893, 0.060150146, -0.060455322, -0.0022621155, -0.031707764, -0.030914307, 0.008972168, 0.01727295, -0.02609253, 0.034454346, -0.029266357, 0.06512451, 0.0009946823, 0.023651123, 0.0041007996, 0.010101318, 0.01638794, -0.012962341, 0.0072784424, -0.032348633, 0.016494751, -0.057861328, -0.0053710938, -0.04345703, -0.024368286, -0.057159424, -0.0024757385, 0.0178833, 0.017166138, 0.013153076, 0.0031909943, 0.018066406, 0.029830933, 0.014556885, 0.01663208, 0.051879883, 0.029159546, 0.020751953, 0.007171631, -0.043762207, 0.013366699, 0.036743164, 0.009857178, 0.00737381, -0.023361206, -0.00047135353, -0.008956909, 0.0024776459, 0.020355225, -0.02281189, -0.012321472, -0.021713257, 0.06384277, 0.0022888184, 0.010368347, 0.079833984, 0.040618896, -0.035614014, -0.027252197, 0.02078247, -0.035614014, 0.010192871, -0.012825012, 0.024841309, -0.031555176, 0.047546387, -0.0033359528, -0.04135132, -0.015312195, 0.01727295, 0.015701294, -0.06542969, -0.023132324, -0.0042037964, 0.034210205, 0.013420105, 0.011405945, -0.037628174, -0.034606934, -0.0016212463, 0.028121948, -0.0063591003, 0.035064697, 0.012176514, 0.047943115, -0.003665924, 0.01461792, -0.0128479, 0.037872314, -0.0524292, 0.017730713, -0.028961182, 0.02519226, -0.02319336, -0.031036377, -0.0023498535, 0.01158905, -0.054260254, -0.015625, 0.040496826, 0.029693604, -0.019699097, 0.050567627, 0.011871338, -0.03778076, -0.027618408, -0.016342163, 0.009269714, 0.037597656, -0.036743164, 0.01914978, -0.014442444, -0.030441284, 0.05557251, -0.022583008, 0.054229736, -0.016860962, -0.0090789795, -0.007369995, -0.033569336, 0.068725586, -0.03768921, -0.014152527, -0.035827637, 0.02760315, -0.030700684, -0.028121948, -0.036315918, -0.030548096, -0.012496948, 0.04953003, 0.02293396, 0.030441284, 0.02722168, -0.047454834, -0.07397461, 0.04864502, 0.009536743, 0.079833984, 0.010398865, -0.018341064, 0.000015854836, 0.003358841, 0.0033168793, -0.022094727, -0.022155762, 0.0001655817, -0.020019531, -0.017990112, 0.005886078, 0.012130737, -0.019134521, 0.01676941, -0.029190063, 0.033721924, -0.018005371, -0.012741089, 0.06518555, -0.007205963, -0.06756592, -0.019897461, 0.014022827, 0.04852295, 0.00032019615, 0.011436462, -0.03616333, 0.017807007, 0.0012874603, -0.05609131, 0.027893066, 0.04168701, -0.019317627, -0.036956787, -0.009033203, 0.039123535, 0.05633545, -0.028381348, -0.07556152, 0.020492554, -0.004119873, 0.0036716461, 0.04397583, -0.0077285767, -0.0069007874, 0.031021118, 0.062805176, 0.010505676, -0.036193848, -0.004558563, -0.007259369, 0.02168274, 0.025558472, -0.011253357, -0.01108551, 0.014015198, -0.017425537, -0.013587952, 0.0076942444, 0.012199402, -0.00051164627, 0.028381348, 0.049957275, -0.028564453, -0.018356323, -0.035614014, 0.029403687, -0.013999939, -0.0035800934, 0.01008606, 0.020828247, -0.02659607, 0.050628662, -0.038024902, -0.046447754, 0.07745361, 0.041809082, 0.014839172, 0.079956055, 0.003452301, -0.0030574799, -0.030288696, 0.009986877, 0.01600647, 0.013015747, -0.011734009, 0.0034275055, 0.035247803, -0.07458496, -0.045684814, 0.0068626404, -0.015853882, 0.032318115, -0.018203735, 0.016281128, 0.008407593, -0.023132324, 0.008773804, 0.009765625, 0.020263672, -0.024795532, -0.034088135, -0.007446289, 0.027938843, -0.0018062592 ], "summary": [ 0.009681702, 0.013496399, 0.03591919, 0.052490234, -0.021697998, -0.0061454773, 0.01713562, -0.094177246, 0.014251709, 0.050750732, -0.032318115, 0.031921387, -0.016616821, 0.006175995, -0.023345947, -0.018295288, -0.011650085, 0.024139404, -0.0009860992, -0.04034424, 0.01550293, -0.06414795, -0.010147095, 0.04815674, 0.01789856, -0.0064849854, -0.020217896, 0.018127441, 0.04019165, 0.048980713, 0.017547607, -0.07006836, 0.029907227, 0.01285553, -0.021957397, 0.019317627, -0.037597656, 0.028182983, -0.0046577454, -0.006576538, 0.06652832, -0.05130005, 0.05319214, -0.020767212, 0.016784668, 0.040985107, 0.03994751, -0.03894043, 0.020431519, 0.041625977, 0.009819031, 0.046936035, -0.013298035, 0.015945435, -0.011695862, -0.012275696, -0.005672455, -0.02947998, 0.01651001, 0.040374756, 0.021240234, -0.0069770813, 0.0069732666, -0.01737976, 0.014427185, -0.00843811, 0.013847351, 0.01486969, 0.04449463, 0.0501709, 0.008621216, -0.015060425, 0.017791748, 0.00072717667, -0.014373779, -0.017700195, 0.035491943, 0.020370483, 0.015571594, -0.017837524, 0.03262329, -0.018753052, 0.0025901794, -0.022247314, 0.0071868896, -0.008117676, 0.006210327, -0.012207031, 0.007911682, -0.011116028, -0.013122559, -0.019882202, -0.007858276, 0.039886475, 0.003862381, -0.036102295, 0.00289917, -0.0017061234, -0.010749817, -0.04449463, 0.010643005, 0.010040283, -0.04937744, 0.010017395, -0.0015687943, -0.010551453, 0.0048599243, -0.016723633, 0.039276123, 0.03112793, -0.026824951, 0.06719971, 0.010566711, -0.013671875, 0.01259613, -0.027816772, -0.03717041, 0.10913086, 0.013053894, 0.075683594, -0.026306152, -0.00087308884, 0.022705078, 0.064331055, 0.018951416, 0.06585693, 0.03363037, -0.058410645, -0.03363037, 0.016555786, -0.013420105, 0.015991211, 0.0107803345, -0.0013685226, -0.023849487, -0.013916016, 0.004901886, -0.009269714, 0.00038313866, 0.0026474, 0.006084442, -0.017669678, 0.04095459, 0.009414673, 0.0023784637, 0.011207581, 0.039489746, 0.0074043274, -0.03829956, -0.0234375, -0.00011795759, 0.06945801, -0.010421753, 0.0066490173, 0.0061683655, -0.030517578, -0.074035645, 0.0154418945, 0.05493164, 0.029083252, 0.013038635, -0.008781433, -0.0017261505, 0.02267456, -0.008163452, -0.008781433, 0.0009174347, -0.0008711815, 0.009216309, 0.06530762, -0.029251099, -0.008384705, -0.05014038, 0.014785767, -0.0017490387, -0.003791809, -0.02571106, 0.0061950684, 0.021087646, -0.025131226, -0.006980896, -0.026107788, 0.037353516, -0.0010290146, -0.013595581, -0.050109863, -0.027801514, -0.027618408, 0.07312012, -0.0015258789, -0.01852417, -0.018554688, -0.055541992, 0.007671356, -0.012672424, 0.015434265, -0.0018167496, 0.021759033, -0.007648468, -0.011833191, 0.052490234, 0.0017433167, -0.015525818, -0.049804688, -0.09075928, -0.019363403, -0.012283325, 0.01600647, -0.025421143, 0.04156494, 0.02494812, 0.0013494492, -0.047912598, 0.068237305, 0.02017212, -0.035583496, 0.031204224, -0.0031394958, 0.005569458, -0.057525635, 0.0067253113, 0.017074585, -0.0047721863, 0.048706055, -0.012077332, -0.024307251, 0.008529663, 0.022720337, 0.050323486, 0.0040893555, 0.07385254, -0.03817749, 0.004497528, -0.017196655, -0.015640259, -0.013496399, 0.026412964, -0.099243164, 0.021102905, 0.055419922, 0.011528015, 0.04949951, -0.013374329, 0.039886475, 0.01121521, -0.037261963, -0.01272583, 0.021392822, -0.010223389, -0.010101318, 0.007911682, -0.007686615, 0.030685425, -0.04373169, 0.024353027, 0.020095825, -0.03302002, -0.05645752, -0.007698059, 0.004386902, 0.02027893, 0.0021915436, -0.018951416, 0.01802063, -0.07519531, -0.007820129, -0.045684814, -0.030197144, 0.0020160675, -0.027526855, 0.040893555, -0.015426636, -0.0073623657, -0.03668213, -0.0064582825, -0.030593872, -0.026397705, 0.047790527, 0.009979248, -0.03765869, 0.020126343, 0.021713257, 0.038269043, -0.011169434, 0.03567505, 0.049194336, 0.008575439, 0.011528015, -0.04559326, 0.007133484, 0.009147644, 0.058898926, 0.014312744, -0.014129639, 0.010345459, 0.016525269, 0.0132751465, 0.02609253, 0.010910034, -0.017807007, -0.033569336, 0.016799927, -0.01852417, -0.0054779053, -0.013420105, 0.031829834, 0.008407593, -0.015625, -0.026641846, -0.008766174, -0.033081055, -0.026306152, 0.021942139, 0.07891846, -0.024490356, -0.03274536, 0.0069274902, 0.04196167, -0.012542725, -0.013404846, 0.15625, 0.017074585, -0.0071411133, 0.00014483929, 0.0076293945, -0.057281494, 0.019226074, -0.05621338, 0.020904541, -0.016159058, -0.02557373, -0.0052719116, -0.030685425, 0.037231445, 0.01524353, 0.005584717, -0.016357422, 0.05105591, -0.004043579, -0.036376953, -0.001663208, 0.004840851, 0.020965576, 0.00592041, -0.05984497, 0.012420654, 0.015350342, -0.0069389343, 0.004108429, 0.0006380081, 0.016082764, -0.0049743652, 0.004962921, 0.09136963, 0.02444458, 0.00459671, 0.0038528442, 0.05810547, -0.025634766, -0.01864624, 0.052581787, 0.019088745, 0.0002772808, -0.07757568, -0.007736206, -0.039520264, 0.00019073486, -0.05645752, 0.030349731, 0.008331299, -0.026977539, 0.046295166, -0.043304443, -0.014755249, 0.015563965, 0.029937744, 0.118652344, 0.0059127808, -0.03302002, 0.06188965, -0.008224487, 0.04534912, -0.05822754, 0.04272461, 0.048553467, -0.006248474, -0.011581421, -0.021453857, 0.044403076, 0.03262329, 0.018508911, -0.03567505, -0.010375977, -0.036010742, 0.00018167496, -0.0029354095, -0.041168213, 0.024169922, -0.026046753, -0.010154724, 0.051239014, -0.004016876, 0.011276245, 0.010292053, -0.024047852, 0.05429077, 0.0031089783, 0.008369446, 0.0029754639, -0.00008493662, 0.015670776, -0.054016113, -0.0007147789, -0.04336548, 0.039093018, -0.04623413, -0.033081055, 0.0061798096, -0.028167725, -0.00047802925, -0.0073127747, 0.047210693, -0.022567749, -0.010353088, -0.0018501282, 0.027542114, -0.0047950745, 0.013343811, -0.02168274, 0.013504028, 0.012168884, -0.02243042, -0.026138306, 0.003578186, -0.015388489, 0.064697266, 0.00081539154, 0.025314331, 0.016159058, -0.013092041, -0.07458496, -0.041107178, -0.050689697, -0.03201294, -0.012634277, -0.009284973, -0.029022217, -0.06542969, -0.045959473, 0.006500244, 0.002462387, 0.0010528564, -0.013198853, 0.030349731, -0.012145996, 0.07159424, -0.03274536, 0.009628296, 0.06008911, -0.04058838, -0.01361084, -0.011497498, -0.01864624, 0.009422302, 0.017166138, 0.014083862, -0.011543274, -0.023605347, -0.054473877, 0.026519775, -0.037322998, 0.0025310516, 0.001909256, -0.021957397, -0.04019165, -0.06695557, 0.05517578, 0.0090408325, 0.051116943, -0.02885437, -0.022521973, 0.016403198, -0.014671326, -0.092163086, -0.036895752, 0.00029873848, -0.09857178, -0.0680542, 0.0049476624, 0.00095415115, -0.019012451, -0.030151367, 0.029846191, -0.01914978, -0.01499939, 0.023132324, -0.016647339, 0.09375, 0.0044441223, -0.06329346, 0.0074424744, -0.014663696, -0.019821167, 0.01146698, -0.01058197, 0.020843506, -0.012992859, -0.013374329, 0.011909485, -0.044433594, 0.0062179565, -0.044769287, 0.06512451, 0.008880615, 0.009963989, 0.018127441, 0.023040771, -0.022537231, -0.0012454987, 0.025558472, 0.02508545, 0.050445557, -0.013076782, 0.0036373138, 0.020187378, 0.028518677, -0.050476074, 0.034698486, -0.02017212, -0.04953003, 0.0040512085, 0.03475952, -0.024841309, 0.024963379, 0.02330017, 0.003206253, -0.01612854, -0.03970337, -0.051879883, 0.036102295, -0.047546387, -0.026519775, 0.030792236, 0.037963867, -0.028182983, -0.011741638, -0.03765869, 0.0132751465, 0.025665283, -0.043670654, 0.046295166, 0.034179688, -0.03591919, -0.013931274, 0.0031909943, -0.06756592, -0.06311035, 0.021377563, 0.02583313, 0.037475586, 0.012390137, 0.010391235, 0.0029277802, 0.0012292862, -0.004245758, 0.011955261, -0.025344849, -0.053863525, -0.035858154, -0.01499939, -0.031188965, -0.028030396, -0.052978516, -0.023391724, -0.03250122, 0.007232666, -0.013824463, -0.0069999695, 0.038146973, 0.046539307, 0.0059051514, 0.028717041, -0.02911377, -0.022903442, -0.035369873, -0.0033111572, 0.02583313, -0.018600464, -0.018508911, -0.0090408325, 0.045776367, 0.0052986145, -0.0178833, -0.036865234, -0.0033798218, -0.0044174194, 0.03024292, 0.027496338, 0.040649414, 0.021743774, 0.03012085, 0.0011672974, 0.014137268, -0.0018548965, -0.02368164, -0.019012451, -0.0058898926, 0.039489746, 0.007534027, -0.001663208, -0.00573349, 0.0048103333, -0.019744873, 0.013977051, -0.022521973, 0.0003812313, 0.029159546, 0.0062828064, 0.008773804, 0.021316528, 0.039276123, 0.010536194, 0.016143799, 0.006652832, 0.02935791, -0.014663696, -0.0033950806, 0.052581787, 0.014923096, -0.023101807, 0.03451538, -0.02470398, -0.018310547, -0.034088135, 0.0058059692, 0.0077819824, -0.00045347214, -0.007850647, -0.0031032562, -0.0020961761, -0.0014715195, 0.0030326843, -0.031555176, -0.009803772, 0.043029785, -0.00036144257, -0.001121521, 0.008872986, -0.0077552795, -0.03378296, 0.017410278, -0.0062561035, -0.028274536, -0.013008118, 0.04058838, -0.049957275, -0.026809692, -0.04925537, 0.02748108, -0.08093262, -0.083862305, -0.045806885, -0.03012085, -0.008132935, 0.017440796, -0.014549255, -0.013366699, -0.005554199, -0.017562866, -0.009628296, -0.028442383, -0.038970947, 0.03945923, 0.0096588135, 0.029830933, 0.040985107, 0.016525269, 0.011421204, 0.02758789, -0.022827148, 0.014312744, -0.010063171, 0.008354187, -0.04638672, 0.004245758, 0.02897644, 0.0004286766, 0.015213013, -0.006587982, 0.0044136047, -0.017456055, -0.015357971, -0.00749588, -0.037322998, -0.01991272, -0.03302002, 0.0040512085, -0.07879639, 0.039794922, -0.061401367, 0.00083732605, -0.0017127991, -0.00957489, -0.00819397, 0.023010254, 0.048431396, -0.022079468, -0.023406982, 0.029571533, 0.013145447, -0.009597778, 0.017196655, -0.0019254684, 0.0055732727, -0.009521484, -0.022888184, -0.04397583, -0.059539795, -0.060638428, 0.072753906, -0.010139465, 0.0038547516, 0.016860962, -0.0041999817, 0.011550903, 0.0058288574, -0.020355225, 0.026657104, -0.020751953, -0.046691895, 0.0418396, -0.006614685, -0.056671143, 0.018676758, 0.023345947, -0.011505127, -0.009796143, 0.03366089, 0.012832642, 0.011184692, -0.011749268, -0.011299133, 0.03387451, -0.011512756, 0.010299683, 0.0031700134, 0.013465881, -0.028030396, 0.016601562, 0.013595581, 0.056030273, -0.035827637, -0.01763916, -0.0037078857, 0.037994385, -0.0045814514, -0.0129852295, -0.02659607, -0.03918457, 0.0019302368, -0.0071907043, 0.011795044, 0.00066661835, 0.025863647, -0.012023926, 0.06604004, -0.04248047, -0.075927734, -0.012840271, -0.021224976, -0.032196045, 0.006793976, -0.02897644, -0.023849487, 0.058380127, 0.0054626465, -0.006084442, 0.04663086, 0.026245117, -0.0018959045, -0.055358887, 0.059387207, -0.004283905, 0.02053833, 0.009887695, -0.028289795, -0.01020813, -0.003255844, -0.008056641, -0.018798828, -0.017532349, 0.033996582, -0.00969696, -0.024993896, -0.033111572, -0.016906738, 0.021865845, -0.016174316, 0.023986816, -0.012069702, 0.034423828, -0.03930664, -0.038726807, -0.01626587, -0.046081543, 0.0063591003, -0.045318604, 0.050048828, 0.0015144348, 0.0040664673, 0.016540527, -0.015914917, 0.035003662, -0.028701782, 0.0026779175, 0.0052948, 0.04537964, -0.004257202, 0.05581665, -0.046417236, -0.030883789, 0.037902832, 0.016998291, 0.0026283264, 0.0084991455, -0.018920898, 0.03729248, -0.036621094, -0.0107040405, -0.061676025, 0.0020065308, -0.05001831, 0.02720642, -0.013900757, 0.046905518, 0.035491943, -0.016143799, 0.015701294, -0.016082764, -0.0038471222, -0.023986816, 0.011695862, -0.0057258606, -0.012969971, 0.010505676, 0.044555664, 0.018173218, -0.03189087, 0.01914978, 0.038757324, 0.022140503, -0.016540527, 0.031829834, -0.027694702, 0.005619049, -0.02104187, 0.026367188, -0.02557373, -0.03366089, -0.031097412, 0.014129639, 0.0030021667, 0.05429077, -0.011634827, 0.0042037964, 0.036010742, 0.045135498, -0.025543213, 0.0736084, -0.03729248, 0.024780273, -0.04058838, 0.052520752, 0.019134521, -0.019104004, 0.042541504, 0.01876831, -0.032348633, 0.04119873, 0.010520935, 0.04135132, 0.041412354, 0.032592773, -0.0385437, 0.00047802925, 0.05908203, -0.015289307, 0.005428314, 0.020385742, 0.011062622, 0.015419006, -0.006137848, 0.008682251, 0.035186768, 0.017990112, 0.044158936, -0.010910034, 0.0035705566, -0.026626587, -0.031036377, -0.005317688, -0.021820068, 0.0234375, -0.04901123, -0.009780884, 0.017211914, 0.009941101, -0.046417236, 0.04421997, -0.0061683655, -0.040802002, 0.04663086, -0.0076179504, 0.005542755, -0.007926941, -0.050476074, 0.0041999817, -0.000054895878, 0.051971436, 0.030334473, -0.037872314, 0.03604126, 0.00340271, 0.005405426, -0.053253174, -0.036987305, -0.017410278, 0.05911255, 0.012588501, 0.020477295, 0.048828125, 0.0051574707, -0.004840851, -0.010597229, 0.03237915, -0.025009155, 0.010986328, 0.062927246, -0.0023651123, -0.061676025, 0.001657486, -0.0345459, 0.045837402, -0.0058784485, -0.00016605854, 0.019042969, 0.0368042, -0.040893555, 0.0007619858, 0.0037174225, 0.008132935, 0.017944336, -0.037353516, 0.009651184, -0.015167236, 0.00042414665, -0.028564453, -0.0491333, 0.007724762, 0.034301758, 0.01436615, -0.011985779, -0.014266968, -0.022216797, 0.018844604, 0.029754639, 0.0072288513, -0.014846802, 0.052520752, 0.06500244, 0.013160706, -0.0039253235, -0.016479492, -0.0016899109, -0.04623413, -0.045532227, -0.018615723, -0.034454346, -0.025344849, -0.042144775, -0.0010890961, -0.012542725, -0.027801514, 0.023147583, -0.07385254, -0.064208984, 0.022903442, -0.030212402, 0.0054969788, 0.025436401, -0.06298828, 0.08569336, -0.04083252, 0.064331055, -0.040863037, -0.009414673, 0.002193451, 0.028640747, -0.015197754, 0.049041748, 0.004310608, 0.016326904, 0.011741638, 0.01777649, -0.0006084442, -0.0056037903, -0.006690979, -0.046569824, -0.016403198, -0.003578186, -0.021118164, 0.010696411, -0.009674072, 0.012107849, 0.028701782, -0.01109314, 0.025802612, 0.033050537, 0.061706543, 0.009399414, 0.004173279, 0.018432617, 0.027282715, 0.013710022 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07715v1
PolyIE: A Dataset of Information Extraction from Polymer Material Scientific Literature
Jerry Junyang Cheung, Yuchen Zhuang, Yinghao Li, Pranav Shetty, Wantian Zhao, Sanjeev Grampurohit, Rampi Ramprasad, Chao Zhang
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
Scientific information extraction (SciIE), which aims to automatically extract information from scientific literature, is becoming more important than ever. However, there are no existing SciIE datasets for polymer materials, which is an important class of materials used ubiquitously in our daily lives. To bridge this gap, we introduce POLYIE, a new SciIE dataset for polymer materials. POLYIE is curated from 146 full-length polymer scholarly articles, which are annotated with different named entities (i.e., materials, properties, values, conditions) as well as their N-ary relations by domain experts. POLYIE presents several unique challenges due to diverse lexical formats of entities, ambiguity between entities, and variable-length relations. We evaluate state-of-the-art named entity extraction and relation extraction models on POLYIE, analyze their strengths and weaknesses, and highlight some difficult cases for these models. To the best of our knowledge, POLYIE is the first SciIE benchmark for polymer materials, and we hope it will lead to more research efforts from the community on this challenging task. Our code and data are available on: https://github.com/jerry3027/PolyIE.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07715v1
2023-11-13T19:56:18
2023-11-13T19:56:18
{ "title": [ -0.06829834, -0.017959595, -0.09899902, -0.07006836, -0.0010728836, -0.018478394, -0.068237305, 0.03213501, -0.010688782, 0.0154800415, -0.021942139, 0.018325806, -0.008155823, -0.030090332, 0.002248764, 0.01133728, -0.0046920776, 0.052093506, -0.00868988, -0.014297485, -0.031402588, -0.008346558, 0.036743164, -0.021743774, 0.020584106, -0.026397705, -0.019577026, 0.0035705566, -0.03387451, -0.04559326, -0.0060577393, 0.0181427, 0.048675537, 0.017578125, -0.019195557, 0.026855469, -0.025344849, 0.022338867, -0.015052795, 0.0035533905, 0.0043563843, 0.021972656, -0.013381958, -0.012809753, -0.042510986, 0.02722168, -0.07763672, -0.015899658, -0.0079574585, 0.056854248, 0.006904602, 0.0016222, -0.009674072, 0.056365967, 0.018249512, -0.029281616, -0.02859497, 0.0019273758, 0.045410156, 0.03463745, 0.0006737709, -0.06109619, 0.032958984, -0.02583313, -0.052490234, -0.018112183, -0.010292053, 0.024993896, 0.040649414, -0.041809082, -0.008613586, 0.031051636, 0.0062446594, -0.00705719, -0.050476074, 0.0068588257, 0.021377563, 0.007896423, 0.04171753, -0.029281616, -0.033935547, -0.009597778, -0.0076560974, -0.048583984, 0.014953613, -0.03918457, -0.020095825, 0.0029277802, -0.005722046, -0.052001953, 0.0045204163, 0.04058838, -0.022827148, 0.023468018, -0.04034424, -0.020385742, -0.035858154, 0.0064430237, -0.014457703, 0.001625061, 0.0141067505, 0.023727417, -0.014175415, -0.01902771, 0.02684021, 0.0010089874, -0.009208679, -0.03314209, 0.035949707, 0.03491211, -0.024871826, 0.06390381, 0.0049438477, 0.005710602, -0.012687683, 0.016601562, 0.00005596876, -0.0032920837, 0.0026836395, 0.010093689, 0.016036987, -0.0035762787, -0.017807007, 0.007396698, 0.020965576, 0.0021514893, -0.04248047, 0.023010254, -0.015151978, -0.002029419, 0.0143585205, 0.052703857, -0.10870361, -0.05734253, -0.052001953, 0.058013916, 0.03741455, 0.021408081, 0.0027446747, -0.007045746, 0.031921387, -0.002916336, -0.026794434, 0.03161621, -0.03933716, 0.021133423, 0.06072998, -0.011360168, -0.07305908, -0.05255127, -0.040893555, 0.02420044, 0.0491333, -0.013442993, -0.062164307, -0.062683105, -0.06866455, -0.07043457, 0.03475952, -0.05810547, 0.026153564, 0.017730713, 0.0013599396, 0.017730713, 0.05722046, -0.008888245, 0.005897522, 0.025619507, 0.010116577, 0.09588623, -0.030883789, -0.022644043, -0.0011892319, -0.0017623901, -0.026672363, 0.022445679, 0.028701782, 0.019897461, -0.006336212, 0.007534027, 0.008293152, -0.036865234, -0.03643799, 0.048858643, -0.02583313, -0.037261963, 0.004245758, 0.013267517, 0.0256958, 0.025161743, -0.05368042, 0.009780884, -0.029434204, -0.044036865, -0.031219482, -0.0041275024, 0.037994385, 0.03338623, -0.002450943, 0.008346558, -0.074523926, 0.018081665, -0.041534424, 0.07067871, 0.04232788, -0.025482178, 0.013755798, -0.0044174194, -0.06390381, 0.048217773, 0.070007324, 0.029388428, -0.03933716, -0.011024475, 0.013404846, -0.06945801, 0.015533447, -0.01637268, -0.008766174, -0.01574707, -0.017822266, -0.00806427, -0.0028762817, 0.04647827, 0.011077881, 0.0068855286, 0.004497528, -0.019638062, 0.047607422, 0.021087646, 0.07757568, -0.02116394, 0.055664062, 0.047912598, -0.002439499, -0.01058197, -0.005367279, -0.019943237, 0.007255554, 0.014022827, -0.008811951, -0.008323669, 0.00072288513, 0.025772095, 0.07745361, 0.024963379, 0.011299133, 0.012084961, 0.025482178, 0.032226562, 0.028442383, 0.022109985, 0.04586792, 0.0178833, -0.005657196, 0.050842285, 0.019577026, 0.048339844, -0.030929565, 0.016738892, -0.0049476624, 0.07128906, 0.017547607, 0.025344849, -0.016784668, 0.017456055, 0.013038635, 0.050567627, -0.011123657, 0.0010433197, 0.021499634, 0.037261963, -0.00015759468, -0.0021381378, 0.0061683655, -0.03869629, -0.016174316, 0.02508545, -0.012939453, -0.044067383, -0.016418457, 0.001039505, 0.03314209, 0.004917145, 0.018417358, -0.0149002075, 0.03265381, 0.0034332275, -0.03878784, -0.008079529, 0.048858643, 0.04937744, 0.0093307495, -0.01335144, -0.002664566, 0.01852417, 0.10192871, 0.05807495, -0.011657715, 0.010307312, -0.055023193, 0.009178162, 0.0002708435, -0.013687134, 0.014091492, 0.009162903, 0.019683838, -0.00010561943, -0.023971558, 0.009727478, -0.05267334, 0.028366089, 0.0072021484, -0.051818848, -0.017562866, -0.038909912, -0.014633179, -0.034332275, -0.049560547, -0.028640747, 0.076293945, -0.027664185, -0.02609253, -0.010414124, -0.008651733, -0.018112183, -0.031082153, -0.019699097, 0.0026512146, 0.010986328, -0.019561768, 0.0014677048, -0.083984375, -0.0049552917, -0.007583618, 0.029037476, -0.020462036, 0.029708862, -0.03503418, -0.029953003, -0.04660034, -0.016036987, 0.010810852, -0.060546875, -0.00008803606, -0.044555664, 0.014602661, 0.0065689087, -0.014411926, 0.014511108, 0.012268066, -0.014884949, 0.010505676, 0.037322998, 0.072509766, -0.0014533997, -0.03390503, 0.060638428, 0.05645752, 0.002210617, 0.0053482056, 0.028121948, 0.0023765564, -0.0069351196, -0.03878784, -0.05404663, 0.015541077, 0.008155823, -0.015686035, 0.03643799, -0.045166016, -0.014884949, -0.059753418, -0.0021648407, -0.015182495, 0.013076782, -0.015045166, -0.042236328, -0.034576416, -0.029708862, 0.007522583, 0.02130127, -0.006313324, 0.015899658, 0.041503906, 0.021621704, 0.009140015, 0.0029773712, 0.037719727, -0.002336502, -0.00894165, -0.005630493, -0.00024056435, -0.012138367, 0.0013837814, 0.022109985, -0.0017032623, -0.034851074, -0.042999268, -0.00349617, 0.017578125, 0.008674622, -0.023635864, 0.021530151, -0.06964111, 0.036468506, -0.018432617, -0.017303467, 0.025772095, 0.059631348, -0.0141067505, 0.027053833, -0.003004074, 0.012611389, -0.005432129, -0.02507019, -0.052612305, 0.017959595, 0.014305115, -0.04727173, -0.020751953, -0.01020813, -0.04611206, -0.01939392, -0.02671814, 0.031921387, 0.032684326, 0.03793335, 0.0005259514, -0.01739502, -0.0066375732, -0.04083252, -0.016174316, -0.028839111, -0.011756897, 0.004180908, -0.017852783, 0.05783081, 0.0024547577, 0.005569458, 0.0014228821, 0.02696228, 0.030075073, 0.009788513, -0.0011587143, -0.048309326, 0.030563354, 0.02619934, -0.0017681122, 0.028182983, -0.018157959, -0.016601562, -0.005367279, -0.0046043396, -0.040863037, 0.0049552917, 0.012840271, 0.032958984, -0.022964478, -0.0020313263, 0.044891357, -0.027191162, -0.035888672, 0.027908325, 0.028137207, -0.020141602, 0.02192688, -0.019546509, -0.01600647, 0.021453857, -0.030639648, 0.017196655, -0.026977539, 0.0006747246, 0.016998291, 0.037322998, -0.03366089, -0.004753113, -0.02281189, 0.020385742, 0.021896362, -0.0059509277, -0.002046585, -0.0793457, 0.011054993, 0.0015249252, -0.1126709, -0.03149414, 0.009986877, -0.07910156, -0.057800293, -0.050109863, 0.016952515, -0.05001831, -0.03375244, 0.000084877014, -0.00015091896, -0.01398468, -0.009086609, -0.08050537, -0.060424805, 0.080566406, 0.020568848, 0.03439331, 0.062438965, -0.014671326, 0.005554199, 0.000105917454, 0.020202637, 0.056854248, 0.07458496, 0.026062012, -0.016586304, 0.036132812, -0.027313232, 0.03543091, 0.024765015, 0.014434814, 0.0006952286, 0.0034675598, 0.012161255, 0.028930664, -0.007965088, 0.049224854, -0.004425049, -0.011360168, -0.039489746, 0.016143799, -0.006515503, -0.018371582, 0.015457153, 0.0119018555, -0.0055503845, -0.0090408325, 0.024597168, 0.024780273, -0.011375427, 0.02079773, 0.010299683, -0.06756592, 0.0004479885, 0.006767273, 0.0027580261, -0.02949524, -0.00087690353, 0.0028820038, 0.0090789795, 0.035949707, -0.028396606, -0.033294678, 0.004272461, 0.03363037, -0.024490356, -0.012809753, -0.065979004, -0.03186035, -0.026443481, 0.028442383, -0.008743286, 0.021392822, 0.030075073, -0.0067481995, -0.01939392, 0.0027675629, 0.01802063, 0.013328552, -0.014228821, -0.06359863, 0.021194458, 0.007904053, -0.053833008, -0.046875, -0.011520386, 0.005558014, 0.019119263, 0.0001887083, -0.022583008, 0.013404846, 0.022918701, 0.03781128, 0.0463562, -0.00036597252, -0.053497314, 0.021438599, -0.01637268, -0.0018424988, 0.0096206665, -0.0036067963, 0.018188477, -0.0036945343, -0.03363037, -0.0031814575, -0.028839111, -0.048095703, 0.04562378, 0.004085541, 0.045440674, 0.0024909973, 0.038909912, 0.03439331, -0.003780365, -0.0002837181, 0.010818481, -0.044128418, 0.0026168823, 0.0025291443, 0.030075073, -0.0209198, 0.028121948, 0.03552246, -0.0000910759, -0.018722534, -0.0051116943, 0.024642944, 0.02758789, -0.03189087, 0.0065345764, 0.0045318604, -0.055267334, -0.036102295, -0.018844604, 0.005744934, 0.055480957, -0.04208374, 0.024505615, -0.02458191, 0.020950317, 0.010246277, -0.01966858, 0.0115356445, -0.0021705627, 0.016677856, -0.04727173, -0.057739258, -0.01637268, 0.05697632, -0.010696411, -0.0074005127, -0.016860962, 0.03265381, 0.0044059753, 0.038757324, 0.026687622, 0.019302368, -0.010063171, -0.016815186, 0.01727295, -0.0129852295, -0.049438477, 0.020812988, 0.022003174, 0.009986877, -0.030517578, -0.017456055, -0.059051514, -0.026931763, -0.03692627, -0.04159546, 0.03012085, -0.06756592, 0.010429382, 0.08557129, -0.016693115, 0.046783447, -0.03894043, 0.022354126, 0.042419434, 0.043914795, -0.000022053719, 0.00011664629, 0.05154419, -0.02154541, -0.018371582, -0.0021400452, 0.0053482056, 0.0152282715, 0.028839111, 0.013282776, 0.0032787323, -0.03338623, 0.017059326, 0.006614685, 0.0068092346, 0.009384155, -0.027252197, 0.00818634, 0.026672363, 0.010040283, 0.009315491, -0.054840088, -0.024215698, 0.026412964, -0.02407837, -0.019470215, 0.02104187, -0.009429932, -0.049957275, -0.07330322, 0.017654419, -0.010734558, -0.015182495, -0.019760132, 0.03237915, -0.048583984, 0.028671265, 0.04736328, -0.046539307, 0.015296936, -0.012428284, 0.013999939, 0.04953003, 0.016662598, 0.0068511963, 0.0061683655, -0.012367249, -0.06335449, -0.015823364, 0.012413025, -0.017318726, 0.0056991577, -0.0037708282, -0.0039367676, 0.0034866333, -0.028701782, 0.014762878, -0.0039749146, -0.0074691772, 0.026885986, 0.015266418, 0.027420044, 0.01499939, 0.02670288, 0.0021953583, 0.006023407, 0.011550903, -0.0143966675, 0.00121212, 0.010528564, 0.022155762, -0.035186768, -0.057037354, -0.013023376, 0.027832031, 0.022735596, 0.01612854, 0.036193848, 0.03451538, 0.059661865, -0.011642456, 0.027435303, 0.050323486, -0.0435791, -0.027023315, -0.07342529, -0.008125305, -0.08050537, 0.06451416, 0.0013160706, -0.012779236, -0.03692627, -0.035186768, -0.02279663, 0.01424408, 0.017044067, 0.021835327, 0.026870728, -0.034606934, 0.020736694, -0.036743164, -0.0028629303, -0.038757324, 0.0592041, -0.007675171, -0.008926392, -0.018936157, -0.026992798, -0.0015163422, -0.023529053, 0.012939453, 0.003206253, 0.006034851, 0.022369385, -0.03451538, -0.004825592, -0.038879395, -0.0038394928, 0.030685425, 0.0289917, -0.042510986, 0.011604309, 0.0038814545, 0.055786133, 0.032470703, 0.05609131, 0.06695557, 0.021377563, 0.018814087, 0.0072517395, 0.01864624, -0.023071289, 0.004055023, -0.036376953, -0.0012197495, -0.056488037, -0.019592285, -0.060180664, 0.009864807, 0.012519836, 0.023788452, 0.016677856, 0.00022852421, 0.02784729, 0.011627197, 0.034118652, 0.0043258667, 0.0524292, -0.07733154, -0.020843506, -0.014503479, -0.0044441223, 0.031402588, 0.028808594, -0.014335632, 0.013710022, -0.040496826, 0.012962341, 0.01864624, 0.00071668625, -0.012237549, -0.022125244, 0.025665283, -0.04272461, 0.044677734, 0.02758789, 0.056610107, 0.022277832, 0.03756714, -0.034301758, 0.012878418, -0.004875183, -0.009742737, -0.013877869, 0.0035305023, 0.024902344, -0.046539307, 0.024734497, -0.012916565, -0.021194458, -0.028961182, 0.070739746, 0.0077819824, -0.019866943, 0.0055770874, 0.01965332, 0.013877869, 0.009643555, 0.011077881, -0.02243042, -0.016525269, 0.04940796, 0.026031494, -0.006702423, 0.03591919, 0.028747559, 0.019485474, 0.0042381287, -0.032226562, 0.005870819, 0.020721436, -0.0021896362, 0.025802612, 0.019317627, 0.051208496, -0.004753113, -0.04876709, 0.018875122, 0.011756897, -0.039733887, -0.004634857, 0.03161621, 0.025985718, 0.055633545, 0.08538818, 0.044281006, 0.008781433, -0.027694702, -0.03756714, 0.010192871, 0.04373169, -0.02960205, -0.033233643, -0.019470215, -0.04156494, -0.0084991455, -0.04345703, 0.07757568, -0.04119873, -0.002155304, -0.0029315948, 0.011604309, 0.030639648, -0.031555176, -0.05267334, -0.005176544, -0.014320374, -0.017288208, -0.00819397, -0.029418945, -0.018112183, -0.018630981, 0.022598267, 0.000038981438, 0.02444458, 0.035583496, -0.03024292, -0.08081055, 0.031829834, 0.00047063828, 0.06781006, -0.04864502, 0.021362305, -0.0011940002, -0.007835388, -0.020507812, -0.058044434, -0.031311035, -0.0206604, -0.016403198, -0.01612854, 0.0049934387, 0.012969971, -0.022583008, -0.020889282, 0.013145447, 0.00018715858, -0.024490356, -0.01940918, 0.031082153, -0.028289795, -0.01776123, -0.004333496, -0.035980225, 0.032409668, 0.013916016, -0.026260376, 0.022415161, -0.003124237, -0.03375244, -0.0435791, -0.0076942444, 0.010223389, -0.00015747547, -0.01966858, 0.0066452026, 0.038024902, 0.05657959, -0.05355835, -0.02217102, 0.00038313866, 0.017501831, -0.025283813, 0.082092285, 0.016494751, 0.008613586, -0.007835388, 0.039001465, -0.008018494, -0.046905518, 0.0035114288, -0.009300232, 0.008621216, 0.04031372, -0.0068130493, 0.015586853, 0.045074463, -0.03277588, 0.009803772, 0.028915405, -0.023101807, 0.014289856, -0.008605957, 0.022903442, -0.021148682, -0.037353516, 0.0025615692, 0.0088272095, 0.00092697144, 0.0063056946, -0.022094727, 0.006538391, -0.032928467, 0.009552002, -0.011962891, -0.08514404, 0.07470703, 0.043060303, 0.01676941, 0.033203125, 0.008781433, -0.041107178, 0.011070251, 0.0113220215, -0.028015137, 0.019699097, 0.038635254, -0.014968872, 0.0026226044, 0.00982666, -0.023468018, -0.045532227, -0.028045654, 0.030151367, -0.016464233, -0.00028395653, 0.0043945312, -0.025558472, -0.012451172, 0.027175903, -0.017593384, -0.024353027, -0.06097412, -0.023910522, 0.02293396, -0.036499023 ], "summary": [ -0.0423584, -0.025802612, -0.095458984, -0.054107666, -0.025970459, -0.017044067, -0.07745361, 0.055664062, 0.005832672, 0.0063056946, -0.014122009, 0.061279297, -0.017166138, -0.026443481, 0.05368042, 0.012382507, -0.0065727234, 0.043823242, 0.04498291, 0.003572464, -0.001789093, 0.0051193237, 0.027496338, -0.06878662, 0.005832672, -0.01637268, 0.020187378, 0.012680054, -0.008705139, -0.012435913, 0.000007748604, 0.0056495667, 0.02748108, 0.015213013, -0.019195557, 0.003276825, -0.0025691986, 0.0013618469, -0.008041382, 0.027389526, -0.007297516, 0.024902344, 0.0289917, -0.00969696, -0.039093018, 0.043121338, -0.08465576, -0.008987427, 0.009979248, 0.017303467, 0.0005249977, -0.015396118, -0.0011816025, -0.007865906, -0.009353638, -0.010848999, -0.041992188, 0.033691406, 0.025253296, 0.053222656, 0.003168106, -0.015434265, -0.0068359375, -0.033081055, -0.057037354, 0.013298035, 0.059539795, -0.0184021, 0.011726379, -0.05996704, 0.008781433, 0.039794922, 0.03302002, -0.04156494, 0.00082826614, 0.026626587, -0.004386902, 0.024536133, 0.021072388, -0.022918701, -0.04043579, -0.015487671, -0.05291748, -0.033599854, 0.012268066, 0.0003376007, -0.018829346, -0.0009713173, 0.008293152, -0.03866577, -0.0030784607, 0.03692627, -0.06542969, 0.06781006, 0.0023536682, -0.024963379, -0.03503418, -0.04119873, -0.0132751465, 0.01763916, 0.03967285, -0.034210205, 0.06341553, -0.010498047, 0.009437561, 0.012832642, 0.012588501, -0.041870117, 0.017364502, -0.0006918907, -0.02319336, 0.05166626, 0.035583496, -0.02029419, -0.02293396, 0.018341064, 0.04067993, 0.0061187744, 0.020874023, 0.0030155182, 0.029296875, 0.036132812, -0.02822876, 0.021514893, -0.0006432533, 0.01777649, -0.000011086464, -0.0071907043, -0.010665894, -0.031021118, 0.011306763, 0.030853271, -0.04522705, 0.02029419, -0.028961182, 0.023254395, 0.045043945, 0.03857422, 0.0046424866, -0.008666992, 0.030899048, -0.030044556, -0.06390381, 0.04598999, -0.045288086, 0.009231567, 0.014831543, -0.0006957054, -0.020584106, -0.0019741058, -0.059020996, 0.025222778, 0.06088257, -0.055358887, -0.050201416, -0.124816895, -0.041229248, -0.07623291, 0.057800293, -0.06317139, 0.032165527, 0.027755737, 0.03579712, 0.088378906, 0.06713867, -0.027038574, -0.0071029663, 0.0064926147, 0.025222778, 0.10681152, -0.019165039, -0.039123535, 0.00030636787, 0.010223389, -0.022460938, 0.020202637, -0.0014162064, 0.0309906, -0.007671356, 0.02796936, 0.013343811, -0.033050537, -0.020965576, 0.034240723, 0.023864746, -0.0602417, 0.01651001, -0.009063721, 0.015556335, 0.03842163, -0.008102417, 0.0013504028, -0.036376953, -0.024124146, 0.019180298, -0.016281128, 0.024383545, -0.011360168, 0.012649536, -0.0026111603, -0.08428955, 0.012893677, -0.0045433044, 0.055358887, 0.041748047, -0.010734558, 0.017120361, 0.0041007996, -0.10467529, 0.0070762634, 0.07159424, -0.015419006, -0.042938232, 0.025726318, 0.04336548, -0.038208008, 0.022384644, -0.0289917, 0.0023670197, -0.023971558, 0.020126343, 0.019760132, -0.0044822693, 0.056274414, -0.0104522705, 0.0069122314, -0.0036411285, 0.009841919, 0.048309326, 0.018417358, 0.06008911, -0.038635254, 0.050109863, 0.078186035, 0.006046295, 0.012214661, 0.011917114, -0.030380249, 0.00019085407, 0.007507324, 0.014556885, 0.007881165, -0.030639648, -0.028320312, 0.09124756, 0.039886475, 0.01776123, -0.013679504, 0.00027823448, 0.010765076, -0.0069465637, 0.0010404587, 0.021316528, -0.039733887, -0.0036945343, 0.029922485, 0.025558472, 0.048919678, -0.0007004738, 0.0143966675, -0.0057525635, 0.059143066, 0.0140686035, 0.016067505, 0.049926758, -0.010406494, 0.057678223, 0.036224365, -0.026229858, -0.015838623, 0.005645752, 0.012275696, -0.01914978, 0.013595581, -0.021087646, -0.031280518, -0.008895874, 0.014320374, -0.07110596, -0.011886597, -0.011734009, 0.009841919, 0.0057907104, -0.011581421, -0.008934021, -0.025665283, 0.029434204, 0.009651184, -0.031921387, 0.015449524, 0.01701355, 0.07489014, 0.012550354, 0.012771606, 0.0025310516, 0.023971558, 0.053741455, 0.02456665, 0.015563965, -0.023132324, -0.020095825, 0.024612427, -0.037261963, 0.010139465, 0.0055770874, 0.004386902, 0.001534462, -0.045959473, -0.02507019, 0.0036029816, -0.05807495, 0.024963379, 0.01423645, -0.0357666, 0.008026123, -0.013549805, -0.03945923, -0.010246277, -0.078063965, -0.049987793, 0.066833496, -0.015945435, 0.015029907, 0.0049438477, -0.00440979, -0.040252686, 0.011657715, 0.00025582314, 0.015075684, -0.026733398, -0.05609131, -0.05340576, -0.07269287, 0.0030212402, -0.00020372868, 0.019439697, -0.004875183, 0.023986816, -0.025054932, -0.022338867, -0.02532959, 0.0018281937, 0.006587982, -0.026779175, -0.030197144, 0.020828247, 0.043395996, 0.005886078, 0.026000977, 0.022460938, -0.017700195, -0.020614624, 0.027389526, 0.05291748, 0.054504395, 0.01121521, -0.015716553, 0.06964111, 0.051879883, -0.004371643, -0.01373291, 0.031143188, -0.0027580261, 0.03036499, -0.03717041, -0.0390625, 0.03488159, 0.014526367, -0.04046631, 0.00995636, 0.018234253, 0.013023376, -0.07763672, -0.032470703, -0.072021484, 0.022079468, 0.050964355, -0.02053833, -0.026153564, 0.019424438, -0.002439499, 0.02330017, 0.0067596436, 0.0006337166, 0.039886475, 0.025375366, 0.00054454803, -0.0026626587, 0.038238525, 0.005104065, -0.012672424, -0.020050049, 0.011543274, -0.031829834, -0.00970459, 0.014633179, -0.008583069, -0.023895264, 0.025802612, -0.029907227, 0.01374054, 0.012870789, 0.0065307617, -0.004257202, -0.015838623, 0.044189453, -0.008117676, -0.006263733, 0.016906738, -0.011505127, 0.013153076, 0.0075416565, -0.0129470825, 0.010467529, -0.0107421875, -0.03338623, 0.028076172, 0.011047363, 0.044891357, -0.054504395, -0.04324341, 0.07318115, -0.008720398, -0.014083862, -0.047576904, 0.013763428, -0.006919861, 0.04348755, -0.003955841, 0.0340271, -0.0024986267, -0.008331299, 0.0033664703, -0.011489868, -0.0052261353, 0.032806396, -0.016723633, 0.023239136, -0.018371582, -0.019042969, 0.05355835, 0.023849487, 0.016693115, 0.0000782609, -0.0023288727, -0.028778076, 0.040405273, 0.06317139, 0.03036499, 0.039916992, -0.015220642, -0.014953613, 0.0049362183, 0.012062073, -0.056671143, 0.015037537, -0.0028362274, 0.034942627, 0.040405273, 0.017303467, 0.043701172, -0.005794525, -0.009361267, 0.036956787, 0.0151901245, -0.020706177, 0.005214691, 0.008201599, -0.033813477, 0.01007843, 0.0051498413, 0.0042877197, -0.046173096, 0.00381279, 0.00014615059, 0.042877197, 0.007217407, -0.023254395, 0.043548584, 0.034240723, -0.0012149811, 0.012290955, -0.010314941, -0.057037354, -0.023345947, 0.016860962, -0.07574463, -0.059143066, 0.0005803108, -0.03933716, -0.038024902, -0.036102295, 0.025268555, -0.013938904, -0.012069702, 0.0057373047, -0.0037326813, 0.07672119, 0.027252197, -0.044036865, -0.024261475, 0.012207031, 0.036468506, 0.013839722, 0.039611816, 0.006816864, 0.030136108, 0.037902832, 0.007820129, 0.018188477, 0.08380127, -0.009429932, 0.003753662, 0.02078247, -0.01197052, 0.063964844, 0.011550903, 0.031921387, 0.023040771, -0.024002075, 0.0031909943, 0.041015625, 0.02331543, 0.020339966, -0.02748108, -0.0063056946, 0.0104522705, 0.03164673, -0.019760132, -0.024032593, 0.014289856, 0.053588867, -0.045898438, -0.03338623, 0.037384033, -0.03277588, -0.033721924, 0.00045990944, -0.008628845, -0.046081543, -0.0016956329, 0.009170532, -0.013702393, -0.0015354156, 0.013717651, -0.019134521, -0.0082092285, -0.0036716461, -0.050964355, -0.03074646, -0.020721436, 0.01222229, -0.024124146, -0.03640747, -0.037597656, 0.0259552, -0.0053367615, -0.0011100769, -0.01474762, 0.019744873, -0.020370483, 0.0020656586, 0.021102905, -0.017120361, 0.03439331, 0.059326172, -0.07861328, -0.08782959, 0.0074043274, 0.020385742, -0.04071045, -0.024459839, -0.03164673, -0.021697998, -0.012306213, -0.022064209, -0.019439697, 0.017913818, -0.008911133, 0.019058228, 0.0524292, 0.007648468, -0.051696777, -0.0047340393, -0.016204834, 0.027954102, 0.034423828, 0.0060424805, 0.01411438, -0.0054130554, -0.061309814, 0.011245728, -0.04876709, -0.038146973, 0.035247803, 0.03793335, 0.0074806213, 0.013877869, 0.036132812, 0.021820068, -0.008178711, 0.0018587112, 0.009422302, -0.024749756, -0.008079529, 0.0017414093, -0.0047721863, -0.0069351196, 0.0034255981, 0.006462097, -0.03375244, -0.055664062, 0.029647827, 0.022338867, 0.020629883, -0.020126343, 0.007850647, 0.0028438568, -0.030670166, -0.042236328, -0.018096924, -0.004638672, 0.015472412, 0.004135132, -0.041015625, -0.004875183, 0.04824829, -0.016281128, -0.037017822, 0.018341064, -0.009231567, 0.006454468, -0.02230835, -0.062805176, -0.009887695, 0.051605225, 0.013954163, -0.02456665, -0.019210815, 0.028778076, 0.002855301, 0.009475708, 0.0284729, 0.0102005005, 0.011047363, -0.00039720535, 0.030456543, 0.019882202, -0.020462036, 0.010185242, 0.06518555, 0.036834717, 0.011497498, -0.0234375, 0.013305664, -0.00730896, -0.038970947, -0.01713562, -0.007232666, -0.025314331, -0.059143066, 0.015167236, -0.017227173, 0.025787354, -0.029632568, 0.012886047, 0.015090942, 0.038879395, -0.019302368, -0.008735657, 0.022262573, -0.0010604858, -0.007648468, -0.022949219, -0.0013713837, 0.026245117, -0.020248413, 0.011543274, -0.0056495667, 0.003232956, -0.003419876, -0.03717041, 0.03060913, -0.031066895, -0.0023651123, 0.004219055, 0.01737976, 0.030578613, 0.0014324188, -0.016311646, -0.006412506, 0.00021123886, 0.013244629, -0.019897461, 0.0059318542, 0.010475159, -0.034362793, -0.051452637, -0.003238678, -0.026397705, -0.0061187744, -0.003276825, 0.012039185, -0.027420044, 0.00045490265, 0.017730713, -0.0121154785, 0.0073890686, 0.03414917, 0.024627686, 0.00712204, 0.004055023, 0.046447754, 0.0115737915, -0.022750854, -0.05456543, -0.027374268, -0.014442444, -0.04711914, 0.041809082, -0.006454468, 0.041900635, 0.017059326, -0.0574646, 0.02078247, -0.03475952, -0.020385742, 0.008354187, 0.017684937, 0.029266357, 0.014923096, 0.012062073, -0.04397583, 0.006877899, 0.031051636, 0.012466431, 0.015975952, 0.03213501, 0.06591797, -0.06915283, -0.0031604767, -0.040252686, 0.060028076, 0.015548706, 0.054748535, 0.03942871, 0.034576416, 0.083862305, -0.025222778, 0.03463745, 0.0262146, -0.037384033, -0.015174866, -0.066833496, 0.005340576, -0.07952881, 0.007789612, 0.0018873215, -0.0012178421, -0.008056641, -0.021987915, 0.009918213, -0.0116119385, -0.018432617, 0.032684326, 0.025558472, 0.0014429092, 0.025848389, -0.014305115, -0.007713318, -0.003686905, 0.03765869, -0.0090408325, 0.014045715, -0.008407593, -0.030426025, -0.00008404255, -0.009315491, -0.018234253, -0.026153564, 0.021514893, 0.006252289, 0.006767273, 0.0057678223, -0.016952515, 0.03930664, 0.0067977905, 0.040405273, -0.046417236, -0.027542114, 0.024780273, 0.045898438, 0.02720642, 0.0715332, 0.021987915, 0.010971069, 0.04888916, 0.0259552, 0.041809082, -0.016540527, -0.014221191, -0.0032253265, -0.041778564, -0.025283813, -0.025497437, -0.012458801, 0.01625061, -0.0032043457, -0.028930664, 0.060668945, -0.008407593, 0.028411865, 0.029281616, -0.019744873, 0.024291992, 0.0027580261, -0.0970459, -0.03945923, -0.00699234, 0.018539429, 0.020080566, 0.040130615, 0.00806427, -0.00050497055, -0.00014781952, 0.0047454834, 0.044128418, 0.009017944, -0.053588867, -0.04458618, 0.061309814, -0.04623413, 0.040222168, 0.045715332, 0.09338379, -0.022140503, -0.011505127, -0.032409668, 0.02734375, -0.03439331, 0.009376526, 0.004005432, -0.016799927, -0.0058403015, -0.016433716, -0.0032615662, 0.018753052, -0.0041656494, 0.010414124, 0.04260254, 0.004802704, -0.01474762, 0.019592285, -0.018569946, -0.006996155, 0.0017766953, -0.018066406, -0.019226074, -0.022628784, 0.035949707, -0.005844116, 0.0017023087, 0.032470703, 0.021102905, -0.006603241, -0.0016775131, -0.0579834, -0.022109985, -0.0076026917, -0.014984131, 0.028411865, 0.05142212, 0.014251709, -0.016845703, -0.018371582, 0.020599365, 0.0149383545, -0.008399963, 0.01234436, 0.06274414, 0.020248413, 0.054229736, 0.06304932, 0.0055732727, 0.04272461, 0.016220093, -0.010597229, 0.015472412, -0.0053482056, 0.001709938, -0.053588867, -0.0067596436, 0.0051460266, -0.047058105, 0.012649536, 0.04562378, -0.05239868, 0.008255005, 0.0048294067, -0.011024475, -0.023117065, 0.006755829, -0.025665283, -0.00459671, -0.009269714, 0.014915466, 0.028076172, -0.05807495, 0.010147095, -0.027420044, -0.022583008, -0.021377563, 0.0064697266, 0.041992188, -0.0047798157, -0.035095215, 0.0020065308, -0.008964539, 0.050323486, -0.05895996, 0.024734497, 0.055755615, 0.011917114, -0.05279541, -0.09515381, -0.013381958, -0.0012578964, 0.027542114, -0.03338623, 0.041900635, 0.028411865, -0.0077667236, -0.029663086, 0.045074463, -0.006542206, -0.014160156, -0.018661499, 0.036010742, 0.004558563, 0.0055351257, -0.0032615662, -0.0058174133, 0.0048103333, -0.00504303, -0.026641846, 0.032196045, -0.020767212, -0.032104492, -0.07739258, -0.015792847, -0.0020065308, 0.0013093948, 0.0030345917, 0.01927185, 0.005153656, 0.049865723, -0.023254395, 0.022994995, -0.016723633, -0.022705078, 0.003686905, 0.022766113, -0.032928467, -0.0032634735, 0.009147644, 0.03237915, 0.0030975342, -0.029067993, 0.016677856, 0.011856079, -0.0115737915, 0.0011034012, -0.012626648, 0.008842468, 0.017486572, -0.044067383, 0.017486572, 0.0345459, 0.0013141632, 0.005683899, -0.03149414, -0.025604248, -0.03253174, -0.04562378, 0.03289795, -0.04135132, -0.0057907104, -0.05404663, -0.011482239, -0.0063591003, -0.0925293, -0.051239014, -0.0018615723, -0.06262207, 0.05871582, 0.0335083, 0.020523071, -0.030136108, 0.034210205, -0.028778076, -0.008033752, 0.017990112, -0.021713257, 0.021453857, 0.0440979, -0.013465881, 0.0014343262, 0.026992798, 0.00013899803, -0.07299805, -0.014007568, 0.012550354, 0.023956299, -0.0070114136, 0.0670166, -0.0069770813, 0.00844574, 0.022827148, -0.057922363, 0.0065841675, -0.014808655, -0.029418945, -0.040649414, -0.014892578 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07703v1
Measuring Entrainment in Spontaneous Code-switched Speech
Debasmita Bhattacharya, Siying Ding, Alayna Nguyen, Julia Hirschberg
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
It is well-known that interlocutors who entrain to one another have more successful conversations than those who do not. Previous research has shown that interlocutors entrain on linguistic features in both written and spoken monolingual domains. More recent work on code-switched communication has also shown preliminary evidence of entrainment on certain aspects of code-switching (CSW). However, such studies of entrainment in code-switched domains have been extremely few and restricted to human-machine textual interactions. Our work studies code-switched spontaneous speech between humans by answering the following questions: 1) Do patterns of written and spoken entrainment in monolingual settings generalize to code-switched settings? 2) Do patterns of entrainment on code-switching in generated text generalize to spontaneous code-switched speech? We find evidence of affirmative answers to both of these questions, with important implications for the potentially "universal" nature of entrainment as a communication phenomenon, and potential applications in inclusive and interactive speech technology.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07703v1
2023-11-13T19:41:34
2023-11-13T19:41:34
{ "title": [ -0.02748108, -0.0055885315, -0.033416748, 0.00021028519, -0.010353088, -0.01184845, 0.0027809143, -0.0055770874, 0.0020313263, 0.039123535, -0.030151367, 0.014144897, 0.015258789, -0.02558899, -0.020080566, 0.005962372, -0.011703491, 0.03062439, -0.034973145, -0.025802612, 0.009132385, -0.018508911, -0.03665161, 0.0030155182, 0.031707764, -0.010421753, -0.06982422, -0.0011234283, -0.012626648, -0.01927185, 0.002948761, 0.0012626648, 0.057373047, 0.062316895, -0.085510254, -0.022277832, -0.06121826, 0.03704834, -0.022750854, 0.016052246, 0.030151367, -0.016830444, 0.0014324188, -0.015106201, -0.012229919, 0.015975952, -0.018249512, -0.024978638, -0.023147583, 0.012458801, 0.010169983, 0.02331543, 0.0013551712, 0.025924683, 0.021377563, 0.0019407272, -0.00907135, -0.018081665, 0.021087646, 0.050964355, 0.030853271, 0.009483337, 0.007396698, -0.015403748, -0.01966858, -0.04425049, -0.050842285, 0.047027588, 0.07867432, -0.0041656494, -0.03237915, 0.013511658, 0.010826111, -0.032226562, -0.061584473, 0.050445557, 0.024139404, -0.014831543, 0.028564453, -0.05606079, 0.00043821335, -0.020751953, 0.04043579, -0.040924072, 0.039886475, -0.027496338, -0.0027198792, 0.0013723373, -0.048858643, -0.061920166, -0.011604309, 0.018112183, -0.012512207, -0.028503418, -0.048309326, -0.023651123, 0.018478394, 0.019943237, -0.0027179718, -0.037078857, -0.04168701, 0.021575928, -0.06021118, -0.014175415, 0.021362305, -0.0107040405, -0.055389404, -0.057861328, 0.041992188, 0.03793335, -0.020996094, 0.05621338, 0.013580322, -0.012931824, -0.013214111, -0.019500732, -0.02444458, 0.023208618, 0.026901245, 0.016799927, 0.0135650635, 0.00035357475, 0.03277588, -0.032592773, 0.042755127, 0.006931305, -0.044555664, -0.032287598, -0.013954163, 0.053131104, 0.005657196, 0.015625, -0.07696533, -0.040252686, -0.047790527, 0.022857666, -0.0024433136, -0.0143585205, -0.030258179, 0.00031971931, 0.009353638, -0.019332886, 0.015808105, -0.012420654, 0.008377075, 0.03793335, 0.04638672, -0.017990112, -0.049621582, -0.031707764, -0.0016908646, -0.022918701, 0.026321411, -0.023986816, -0.04864502, -0.028198242, -0.1026001, -0.003255844, 0.025390625, 0.0014324188, -0.008636475, -0.01071167, -0.024505615, 0.023117065, 0.022735596, 0.029937744, 0.023849487, 0.020843506, 0.022979736, 0.022277832, -0.008583069, 0.07635498, 0.053741455, 0.026290894, 0.006412506, -0.010848999, 0.008934021, -0.016189575, 0.044036865, -0.028656006, -0.030731201, -0.029006958, 0.015090942, 0.002319336, -0.05645752, -0.001707077, 0.008865356, 0.028900146, 0.013458252, 0.016296387, -0.0053482056, 0.041168213, -0.038330078, -0.020263672, -0.0041999817, 0.0050735474, 0.0143585205, 0.015563965, 0.012809753, -0.023635864, 0.0024776459, 0.0010986328, -0.026138306, -0.0066871643, -0.039001465, -0.041870117, -0.01687622, 0.010360718, 0.012001038, -0.0088272095, 0.019577026, -0.044525146, -0.0010347366, -0.0073547363, -0.049194336, -0.0071258545, 0.010574341, -0.0034046173, 0.008125305, -0.03152466, 0.008163452, -0.028320312, 0.016098022, 0.028198242, 0.014465332, -0.008872986, -0.003955841, -0.027618408, 0.0022830963, 0.032196045, 0.00025081635, -0.014541626, 0.033294678, 0.0124053955, -0.029510498, -0.0029144287, -0.004989624, 0.030654907, 0.014472961, 0.0026016235, 0.009063721, -0.035705566, -0.0040740967, 0.020141602, 0.04989624, 0.014579773, 0.028930664, -0.0019741058, 0.0003285408, 0.0074653625, 0.03994751, 0.007873535, 0.018081665, 0.012062073, 0.016326904, 0.03488159, -0.017410278, 0.016555786, -0.015388489, -0.024368286, 0.02949524, -0.04171753, -0.0115356445, -0.023239136, -0.031921387, -0.014404297, -0.02998352, -0.031982422, 0.01348114, 0.0066490173, 0.00630188, -0.10296631, 0.028182983, -0.005584717, 0.010269165, -0.01108551, -0.019805908, 0.008079529, 0.034942627, -0.03390503, -0.015594482, 0.016967773, -0.0021209717, -0.01965332, 0.007221222, 0.008369446, 0.015312195, -0.014328003, -0.030731201, -0.011650085, 0.048614502, 0.04083252, -0.0027065277, -0.0004708767, 0.004550934, 0.011238098, 0.09765625, 0.0637207, -0.01739502, 0.04119873, -0.04574585, 0.011917114, 0.0016155243, 0.006958008, 0.020904541, -0.023880005, -0.006290436, 0.037200928, 0.00116539, 0.026107788, -0.049804688, 0.049102783, 0.00069236755, -0.03845215, -0.020706177, -0.0440979, -0.013328552, -0.031677246, -0.035614014, 0.031066895, 0.015022278, 0.0013990402, -0.022399902, 0.020828247, -0.0066833496, -0.0016431808, 0.0206604, -0.018051147, 0.015266418, 0.04434204, 0.032714844, 0.019744873, -0.054138184, -0.030288696, -0.006565094, 0.0032806396, -0.0023860931, -0.013694763, -0.01335144, 0.018218994, 0.015670776, -0.009223938, 0.003604889, -0.019012451, -0.008041382, -0.03086853, 0.018127441, 0.019088745, -0.043182373, 0.005504608, 0.01852417, -0.039031982, -0.001294136, 0.03491211, 0.06689453, -0.032806396, -0.025131226, 0.07220459, 0.02520752, 0.01109314, 0.0473938, 0.05206299, 0.045410156, -0.088012695, -0.044952393, -0.07501221, -0.04067993, -0.011207581, -0.035339355, -0.005554199, -0.056488037, -0.04284668, 0.0027484894, -0.00030207634, 0.034606934, 0.039855957, -0.0019311905, -0.036499023, -0.0034160614, -0.014961243, -0.012313843, -0.022949219, -0.0061912537, -0.0076904297, 0.05758667, 0.006290436, -0.0031833649, -0.026687622, 0.055603027, 0.006565094, -0.00079107285, -0.03060913, -0.094055176, -0.013336182, 0.031677246, 0.024993896, -0.005760193, -0.06707764, -0.08343506, -0.025268555, 0.08227539, -0.027069092, -0.03375244, 0.025024414, -0.018173218, -0.026794434, 0.04473877, 0.004722595, 0.044036865, 0.038360596, 0.0056915283, -0.010307312, 0.009941101, -0.045196533, -0.002658844, -0.009590149, -0.081970215, 0.010070801, -0.0037441254, -0.016677856, 0.018447876, -0.0625, -0.0158844, 0.0076789856, 0.014060974, 0.06225586, 0.037231445, -0.015106201, 0.056427002, -0.012496948, 0.027267456, -0.012840271, -0.019851685, -0.011062622, -0.0209198, 0.032714844, 0.006401062, 0.023666382, 0.044677734, -0.027893066, -0.028900146, 0.014526367, -0.0039634705, 0.012001038, -0.011940002, -0.037078857, 0.013504028, 0.010818481, -0.015045166, -0.010353088, -0.003206253, 0.0002310276, -0.063964844, 0.007736206, -0.027160645, 0.05657959, 0.010978699, 0.007534027, 0.0021038055, -0.035125732, -0.01889038, -0.022994995, -0.033355713, -0.003326416, 0.025161743, 0.012756348, -0.014862061, 0.010917664, -0.0049743652, -0.021224976, 0.020751953, -0.015106201, -0.0009212494, -0.019439697, 0.023925781, 0.011734009, -0.025726318, -0.0013408661, -0.029846191, -0.0066986084, -0.023483276, 0.0022068024, -0.04989624, -0.039123535, 0.0027332306, -0.006965637, -0.034332275, 0.036987305, 0.0009918213, -0.04827881, -0.00674057, -0.020507812, 0.009552002, -0.015823364, -0.025650024, -0.030059814, -0.0042762756, -0.043273926, -0.016677856, -0.1071167, -0.010696411, 0.098083496, 0.03302002, 0.041778564, 0.016662598, 0.018981934, 0.016326904, -0.04434204, 0.006755829, -0.011947632, 0.04083252, -0.03289795, 0.0041656494, 0.025558472, -0.026870728, 0.005027771, 0.041992188, -0.02128601, 0.01991272, 0.008804321, 0.06512451, 0.0513916, 0.00970459, 0.04888916, -0.016143799, 0.006465912, -0.054534912, -0.026000977, -0.02909851, -0.022994995, 0.003572464, 0.0066566467, 0.030044556, 0.014701843, 0.017715454, 0.061157227, -0.02142334, 0.009117126, 0.0262146, -0.038330078, -0.034973145, -0.01737976, 0.03564453, 0.018875122, 0.001953125, 0.011260986, -0.0028266907, 0.03643799, -0.011878967, -0.020935059, 0.016998291, 0.020126343, -0.00831604, -0.017837524, -0.05114746, -0.048950195, -0.009010315, -0.003440857, -0.011177063, 0.04135132, 0.0021362305, 0.0034694672, -0.016113281, 0.006336212, 0.08605957, 0.016174316, -0.0035381317, -0.064453125, -0.0061569214, -0.000003993511, -0.051513672, -0.024215698, 0.013259888, -0.0087509155, 0.04559326, -0.033325195, -0.036468506, -0.011497498, 0.031204224, 0.05834961, 0.05380249, -0.026885986, -0.07183838, -0.04257202, -0.022903442, -0.061035156, 0.04272461, -0.028945923, -0.012214661, -0.033233643, 0.057525635, -0.020599365, 0.021072388, 0.030517578, -0.004760742, -0.06677246, 0.062683105, -0.05645752, 0.020217896, -0.0015420914, 0.00075006485, 0.033843994, 0.016540527, -0.0345459, -0.017501831, 0.021820068, 0.02545166, -0.010719299, -0.006629944, 0.020263672, 0.024780273, 0.007888794, 0.0025348663, 0.0014953613, 0.021499634, 0.021011353, -0.01411438, -0.0008034706, -0.05770874, -0.014717102, 0.0026130676, 0.00019288063, 0.06100464, -0.03366089, 0.00027513504, -0.03869629, 0.007095337, 0.0067710876, -0.008094788, 0.020736694, 0.0047912598, 0.01939392, -0.077697754, -0.008743286, 0.0016870499, 0.004398346, -0.04309082, 0.008590698, -0.008682251, -0.04711914, 0.051361084, 0.04055786, 0.018722534, 0.0053100586, -0.05859375, 0.002040863, 0.022415161, -0.038146973, -0.05657959, -0.015510559, -0.013053894, 0.027053833, -0.016403198, 0.059936523, -0.04550171, 0.021148682, -0.032196045, -0.010925293, 0.013198853, -0.045684814, 0.0440979, 0.0637207, -0.018569946, 0.029159546, -0.061676025, -0.013404846, 0.042114258, 0.041259766, -0.0058631897, -0.0029678345, 0.033477783, -0.029037476, -0.0043182373, -0.013191223, 0.006843567, 0.007911682, 0.03149414, 0.01626587, 0.034851074, -0.055725098, 0.008628845, 0.021240234, 0.027664185, 0.0043907166, -0.050994873, 0.01600647, 0.012382507, -0.012588501, 0.011695862, -0.05670166, -0.020736694, -0.019515991, -0.01739502, -0.05758667, 0.029525757, -0.029632568, -0.041168213, -0.026824951, -0.0005068779, -0.014724731, 0.023147583, -0.006969452, -0.010360718, -0.0335083, 0.006298065, 0.039794922, -0.014129639, 0.0062789917, -0.008735657, 0.00409317, 0.03756714, 0.026641846, 0.028152466, 0.008804321, 0.048065186, -0.037109375, -0.00084781647, 0.016479492, -0.03086853, -0.026901245, -0.0149002075, -0.024978638, -0.03250122, -0.033843994, -0.002878189, 0.0129776, -0.008300781, 0.038635254, -0.012466431, 0.0021209717, 0.002729416, -0.031158447, 0.02746582, 0.0109939575, -0.026290894, 0.010818481, 0.012374878, 0.0236969, 0.013305664, -0.011161804, -0.092041016, 0.0020198822, 0.01020813, -0.011024475, -0.0061950684, 0.02519226, 0.03173828, 0.014282227, -0.0413208, 0.008758545, 0.035217285, -0.054382324, -0.006576538, -0.01335907, -0.011634827, -0.005531311, 0.087524414, -0.04852295, -0.024291992, -0.045684814, -0.04321289, -0.028549194, 0.023956299, 0.041870117, 0.002325058, 0.022460938, -0.023651123, 0.013961792, -0.03149414, -0.002336502, -0.0124053955, 0.035705566, -0.0011844635, -0.0023784637, -0.037902832, -0.004032135, -0.013420105, -0.03427124, 0.017730713, 0.02520752, 0.015686035, 0.008895874, -0.016433716, -0.01676941, 0.005542755, -0.0446167, -0.0061187744, 0.000954628, -0.010765076, 0.010345459, -0.045837402, 0.04324341, 0.0029830933, -0.001991272, 0.004802704, 0.012802124, -0.02986145, -0.014678955, -0.015899658, -0.051116943, -0.002090454, -0.034240723, -0.046020508, -0.07208252, -0.026062012, -0.08074951, -0.0099487305, 0.015319824, 0.012321472, 0.012451172, 0.006412506, 0.022460938, -0.045684814, 0.03579712, -0.047790527, 0.043792725, -0.044036865, -0.028015137, 0.01411438, 0.013931274, 0.042266846, 0.038513184, -0.013954163, 0.015792847, -0.023376465, -0.041259766, 0.019348145, 0.018585205, 0.007205963, -0.0065460205, -0.006504059, -0.03201294, 0.019897461, -0.032440186, 0.029327393, 0.06567383, 0.008201599, -0.0033187866, -0.02166748, 0.0049705505, 0.024276733, -0.046905518, 0.029541016, 0.05508423, -0.08526611, 0.020370483, -0.0027370453, -0.017959595, -0.012504578, 0.03677368, 0.009162903, -0.06311035, -0.027404785, 0.018997192, 0.024871826, 0.017242432, -0.0013694763, -0.048919678, -0.039886475, -0.023269653, 0.03286743, -0.019607544, -0.025222778, -0.017807007, 0.012825012, -0.008735657, -0.01713562, -0.01701355, 0.016296387, -0.04699707, 0.033355713, 0.005844116, 0.014038086, 0.008720398, -0.029663086, -0.019180298, 0.0132369995, -0.013008118, -0.022842407, -0.0073280334, 0.028518677, 0.025283813, 0.049194336, 0.011947632, -0.015579224, 0.016967773, -0.034240723, 0.023040771, 0.01914978, -0.034332275, 0.0014705658, -0.0143966675, -0.030471802, 0.03616333, -0.03152466, 0.04196167, -0.06451416, 0.0032100677, -0.059661865, 0.07952881, -0.04812622, -0.046875, -0.03869629, -0.012535095, -0.048797607, 0.028305054, 0.034484863, -0.0390625, -0.020050049, -0.016159058, -0.008613586, 0.0047950745, -0.0076942444, 0.024017334, -0.0066833496, -0.06567383, -0.0015010834, -0.033111572, 0.032714844, -0.04309082, -0.02519226, -0.06500244, 0.037139893, 0.022857666, 0.03366089, -0.011917114, 0.0597229, -0.044311523, -0.039733887, 0.045654297, 0.049438477, 0.0129470825, 0.020080566, -0.03189087, 0.005645752, -0.023269653, -0.039123535, 0.043914795, -0.026275635, -0.064575195, -0.022109985, -0.037200928, 0.022979736, 0.03326416, -0.012939453, 0.018692017, 0.028320312, -0.04373169, 0.012611389, 0.00687027, 0.03692627, 0.0061302185, -0.05496216, 0.00055265427, -0.0023097992, 0.011192322, -0.06210327, -0.08569336, 0.019958496, 0.080566406, -0.0340271, 0.005558014, 0.031982422, 0.003753662, 0.014411926, -0.018157959, -0.0054969788, -0.035888672, -0.033172607, -0.024230957, 0.061309814, 0.007095337, -0.026565552, -0.0044403076, -0.00032663345, -0.03869629, 0.0032596588, -0.023666382, -0.035186768, -0.01689148, -0.01977539, 0.010391235, 0.02835083, -0.0034294128, -0.056030273, -0.0211792, 0.028503418, 0.02154541, -0.017852783, 0.02861023, -0.021697998, 0.059051514, -0.01966858, -0.0005993843, 0.0423584, 0.015792847, 0.024429321, -0.019577026, 0.014678955, 0.018127441, -0.0051994324, -0.011398315, 0.01737976, 0.009536743, 0.03161621, -0.05014038, 0.010299683, -0.078552246, -0.030426025, -0.024520874, -0.013198853, -0.0037727356, -0.046203613, 0.038085938, -0.013908386, -0.02848816, -0.0023727417, -0.022460938, 0.034240723, -0.048553467, -0.060394287, -0.054016113, 0.045715332, -0.019805908 ], "summary": [ -0.0051002502, -0.014350891, -0.0107803345, 0.047058105, -0.043640137, -0.020935059, -0.0034255981, -0.029846191, 0.018737793, 0.014724731, -0.015792847, 0.026901245, 0.043884277, -0.033996582, 0.027877808, 0.016921997, -0.031402588, 0.08850098, -0.012939453, -0.020645142, -0.02017212, -0.034942627, -0.08721924, -0.072265625, 0.030532837, 0.009292603, -0.018615723, -0.0074424744, 0.0206604, 0.023468018, 0.020233154, -0.026947021, 0.0073432922, 0.07086182, -0.08917236, -0.07446289, -0.020217896, 0.020095825, -0.04171753, 0.040618896, 0.03314209, -0.011291504, 0.058044434, -0.01914978, 0.0042762756, 0.007904053, 0.02609253, -0.01625061, 0.009292603, -0.030731201, -0.01889038, 0.007621765, -0.007888794, -0.0040016174, -0.012245178, -0.0063323975, -0.025817871, -0.007335663, -0.0134887695, 0.07531738, 0.0418396, 0.03869629, -0.024520874, -0.03112793, 0.002702713, -0.02835083, -0.012718201, 0.014556885, 0.026290894, 0.007827759, 0.033599854, 0.0027160645, 0.0029678345, -0.045043945, -0.009643555, 0.075927734, -0.02999878, 0.026138306, 0.02456665, -0.010375977, -0.025054932, 0.017913818, 0.040222168, -0.08959961, 0.01802063, -0.067993164, -0.015899658, 0.017822266, -0.021652222, -0.060424805, -0.020111084, 0.03366089, -0.04135132, -0.022781372, -0.026275635, -0.02999878, 0.019302368, 0.032470703, 0.018737793, -0.002779007, -0.013496399, -0.013961792, -0.020080566, -0.030715942, 0.012619019, -0.0028858185, -0.018859863, -0.060424805, 0.028167725, 0.034942627, 0.0008993149, 0.04864502, -0.0063934326, -0.016967773, -0.009605408, -0.038635254, -0.0713501, 0.074035645, 0.017578125, 0.03866577, 0.045562744, 0.046539307, -0.0158844, 0.014808655, -0.010009766, 0.0068969727, -0.0064964294, -0.043945312, 0.021514893, 0.021591187, 0.002872467, 0.0054855347, -0.057800293, -0.0074806213, -0.030975342, 0.006465912, 0.0491333, -0.047180176, -0.02720642, -0.003540039, 0.004295349, -0.0077667236, 0.0020999908, -0.0158844, -0.01751709, 0.036193848, 0.015403748, -0.009346008, -0.016494751, -0.012992859, 0.0031738281, -0.05029297, 0.035461426, -0.052734375, -0.02810669, -0.0814209, -0.046539307, -0.03050232, 0.05215454, -0.027328491, -0.010932922, -0.022918701, -0.015075684, 0.011116028, -0.007129669, 0.02229309, 0.04058838, 0.011451721, 0.018829346, -0.0284729, 0.00566864, 0.02432251, 0.025543213, -0.01537323, -0.002210617, -0.0022506714, -0.0143966675, 0.02861023, 0.015213013, -0.049194336, -0.02810669, -0.039123535, -0.0050621033, 0.0058174133, -0.02557373, 0.028747559, 0.025039673, 0.042663574, -0.005542755, 0.0011072159, 0.022232056, 0.030761719, -0.010971069, 0.008384705, 0.008598328, 0.015777588, -0.033172607, 0.0131073, 0.0047912598, -0.033447266, 0.028167725, -0.03665161, 0.035888672, -0.034484863, -0.0491333, -0.032440186, -0.020965576, 0.019226074, 0.030853271, -0.00548172, -0.01739502, -0.057159424, 0.038513184, -0.036865234, -0.04901123, -0.00068950653, 0.00868988, 0.0287323, 0.03668213, -0.030899048, 0.056671143, -0.056030273, 0.043640137, 0.018112183, -0.05682373, 0.003627777, -0.029037476, 0.029571533, -0.037139893, 0.018051147, 0.021499634, 0.012069702, 0.015594482, 0.015640259, -0.045318604, -0.0030288696, -0.010421753, 0.016098022, 0.011352539, 0.020355225, 0.02670288, -0.02708435, -0.0066223145, 0.004749298, -0.0016269684, 0.0074920654, 0.036499023, -0.017730713, 0.0069503784, 0.039916992, 0.0023117065, -0.01586914, 0.016433716, -0.0065345764, 0.0016126633, 0.0152282715, -0.03753662, -0.04675293, 0.008552551, -0.037506104, 0.018112183, -0.09106445, -0.021224976, -0.03010559, -0.029037476, -0.03475952, -0.038879395, -0.047088623, 0.01574707, -0.025024414, 0.02482605, -0.08795166, 0.012420654, 0.0034732819, -0.013694763, 0.011184692, -0.014221191, 0.008453369, 0.058624268, 0.0004503727, -0.01084137, 0.006187439, -0.046966553, -0.018432617, 0.038482666, 0.0023651123, -0.018371582, -0.010299683, 0.0052223206, 0.037872314, 0.04159546, 0.032928467, -0.0152282715, 0.032196045, 0.00039076805, 0.012535095, 0.022659302, 0.032714844, -0.0009860992, 0.021209717, -0.010360718, 0.044799805, 0.0025482178, 0.005634308, 0.04751587, -0.040527344, 0.0018873215, 0.050689697, 0.050689697, 0.028717041, -0.03137207, 0.057434082, 0.016952515, 0.03161621, -0.010414124, -0.024490356, -0.00093221664, 0.031433105, -0.0029830933, 0.04815674, 0.027999878, -0.024749756, 0.025604248, 0.023834229, -0.010391235, -0.025436401, 0.04525757, -0.008552551, 0.013137817, 0.0033512115, -0.014183044, -0.005645752, -0.027297974, 0.008377075, -0.0052833557, 0.00093078613, 0.008277893, -0.018005371, 0.02305603, 0.01586914, 0.06781006, 0.02482605, -0.0055389404, -0.003835678, -0.0015516281, -0.01751709, 0.0049705505, 0.011161804, -0.0124053955, 0.0056877136, 0.012062073, -0.027633667, -0.00983429, 0.035064697, 0.044647217, -0.025482178, -0.021575928, 0.052612305, 0.029846191, -0.007255554, 0.057159424, 0.062347412, 0.04727173, -0.090270996, -0.077697754, -0.03302002, 0.0047454834, -0.009384155, -0.0107040405, -0.009597778, -0.038024902, 0.0014867783, 0.03427124, -0.00066518784, 0.01638794, 0.03564453, 0.0592041, -0.0132751465, 0.0104522705, 0.020385742, 0.003271103, -0.019165039, -0.0033454895, -0.055541992, 0.03866577, -0.028381348, -0.026016235, -0.014694214, 0.06677246, 0.029769897, 0.027755737, -0.019744873, -0.07269287, -0.014663696, 0.0054893494, 0.011917114, 0.027664185, -0.06781006, -0.02394104, -0.058563232, 0.07324219, -0.019592285, 0.0004968643, 0.01687622, -0.0060768127, 0.041656494, 0.031402588, 0.039764404, 0.046691895, 0.02355957, 0.02798462, -0.067993164, 0.028427124, -0.060516357, -0.012306213, 0.004890442, -0.027114868, -0.017669678, 0.009307861, 0.026168823, 0.010223389, -0.03451538, 0.008842468, 0.035064697, 0.022644043, 0.056884766, -0.012931824, 0.00029301643, -0.010917664, -0.008201599, 0.0079574585, -0.020477295, -0.012168884, 0.033111572, -0.04864502, 0.04626465, 0.024490356, -0.0008497238, 0.101257324, -0.07055664, -0.042541504, 0.027893066, -0.035339355, -0.055725098, -0.03366089, -0.020690918, 0.05709839, -0.018218994, -0.01374054, -0.018066406, -0.02130127, 0.009925842, -0.05783081, 0.030029297, -0.021087646, 0.02192688, 0.004142761, 0.014472961, 0.044128418, -0.01448822, 0.0035324097, -0.0018453598, -0.008003235, 0.0045394897, 0.024383545, 0.010826111, -0.016555786, 0.031311035, -0.003238678, -0.011497498, 0.06616211, -0.03439331, 0.019699097, -0.03302002, -0.009033203, -0.035583496, 0.026184082, -0.025985718, 0.029052734, -0.01890564, -0.020080566, 0.0048828125, -0.058258057, -0.06585693, -0.013069153, -0.0046806335, -0.05847168, 0.017196655, 0.012176514, -0.0054893494, -0.012069702, 0.005580902, 0.052642822, 0.003068924, 0.012756348, 0.00046229362, -0.01360321, 0.052947998, -0.0058250427, -0.061065674, 0.00573349, 0.0079422, 0.033843994, 0.0093688965, 0.016708374, 0.016174316, 0.023605347, 0.018676758, 0.01940918, 0.019515991, 0.026062012, -0.024490356, -0.0018014908, -0.015449524, -0.0029525757, -0.008979797, 0.050689697, -0.08111572, 0.044647217, 0.020950317, 0.058624268, 0.080078125, 0.0010442734, -0.008087158, -0.018844604, 0.019958496, -0.032470703, 0.010307312, -0.008964539, -0.010879517, 0.020812988, 0.014511108, 0.030288696, 0.04385376, -0.007091522, -0.0011501312, -0.024459839, -0.009117126, -0.006198883, 0.017211914, -0.032989502, -0.028961182, 0.016815186, 0.030914307, -0.0076522827, 0.03213501, -0.011398315, 0.036468506, 0.0019168854, 0.00881958, 0.0035114288, 0.0014457703, 0.010757446, -0.021881104, -0.033935547, -0.011917114, -0.009918213, -0.008666992, 0.011123657, 0.039764404, -0.022827148, -0.009757996, 0.0231781, -0.0020923615, 0.066833496, 0.024307251, -0.014923096, -0.04324341, -0.02166748, 0.010902405, -0.02909851, 0.0013256073, -0.022781372, -0.04083252, -0.005821228, -0.030960083, 0.009666443, -0.0037956238, 0.016113281, 0.017120361, 0.036987305, 0.015655518, -0.014801025, 0.01852417, -0.017730713, -0.040161133, 0.026153564, -0.024841309, 0.000021159649, -0.006881714, 0.03869629, -0.02532959, -0.004627228, 0.010055542, 0.02281189, -0.0055618286, 0.06347656, -0.05508423, 0.009750366, 0.007083893, 0.0014696121, 0.0012683868, -0.0050354004, -0.023635864, 0.030975342, 0.018341064, 0.038604736, -0.021270752, -0.013053894, -0.01272583, -0.005428314, 0.0051116943, 0.017120361, 0.009162903, 0.022003174, -0.0118255615, -0.012435913, -0.031829834, -0.052764893, -0.002658844, 0.017822266, -0.03845215, 0.03451538, 0.026916504, -0.039123535, -0.034301758, -0.0052871704, -0.03829956, -0.023040771, 0.009384155, -0.007247925, 0.018997192, -0.017425537, 0.06088257, 0.022521973, -0.04147339, -0.040496826, -0.033966064, -0.05419922, -0.05831909, 0.036224365, 0.035217285, -0.002292633, -0.04272461, 0.012626648, 0.011795044, -0.0010385513, -0.018798828, -0.037261963, -0.040802002, -0.028717041, 0.023895264, 0.028442383, 0.026123047, -0.0024662018, 0.011245728, -0.027435303, -0.0035915375, 0.0020618439, -0.030639648, -0.051483154, 0.003446579, -0.035980225, 0.0025749207, -0.06695557, -0.05218506, 0.019973755, 0.03149414, -0.048217773, -0.03527832, 0.0018529892, -0.0030536652, -0.019302368, -0.03111267, 0.00088882446, 0.061401367, 0.0016288757, 0.027008057, 0.030166626, -0.031204224, -0.003364563, -0.00043034554, 0.004753113, -0.011177063, -0.012496948, 0.037628174, 0.013404846, -0.010437012, 0.008010864, -0.049987793, -0.015129089, -0.041656494, -0.02255249, -0.10571289, 0.01687622, -0.03753662, -0.046051025, -0.035461426, 0.011871338, 0.010040283, -0.00037264824, -0.018203735, 0.008079529, -0.034698486, -0.022277832, 0.015342712, -0.007408142, 0.03225708, -0.010917664, 0.0027751923, 0.026870728, 0.0289917, 0.0413208, -0.0003709793, 0.0345459, -0.009925842, 0.02619934, -0.011222839, -0.040863037, 0.011047363, -0.012123108, 0.020141602, -0.039367676, -0.04537964, 0.00724411, -0.04763794, -0.019348145, 0.019256592, -0.031677246, -0.039093018, 0.023925781, -0.042144775, 0.002796173, 0.005115509, -0.024978638, 0.0054473877, 0.005306244, -0.0026760101, -0.011787415, -0.04421997, -0.051818848, 0.00068569183, 0.007484436, -0.012451172, -0.0020370483, 0.02557373, 0.012199402, 0.038879395, -0.037902832, -0.0017871857, 0.023971558, -0.018310547, 0.040985107, -0.019577026, 0.0053634644, -0.036987305, 0.03668213, -0.04498291, 0.015151978, -0.045410156, -0.03768921, -0.006603241, 0.007331848, 0.030166626, -0.005630493, 0.029251099, -0.03366089, -0.01953125, 0.0021762848, 0.0062942505, 0.036102295, -0.016784668, 0.016098022, 0.027679443, -0.006465912, 0.038879395, -0.062347412, 0.03878784, 0.011444092, 0.034454346, -0.008926392, 0.06561279, 0.030136108, -0.014053345, 0.008964539, -0.0007109642, -0.00623703, -0.008743286, 0.010108948, -0.0058670044, -0.011627197, 0.015914917, 0.020584106, -0.021942139, -0.011436462, -0.035858154, -0.013938904, 0.0041618347, 0.009552002, -0.024093628, -0.0030269623, -0.015777588, -0.046966553, -0.022567749, -0.03604126, -0.016052246, -0.009689331, 0.017532349, -0.022994995, 0.052337646, 0.00137043, 0.002210617, -0.018569946, -0.032836914, -0.011932373, -0.019729614, -0.06100464, -0.04333496, 0.0004222393, -0.019439697, 0.033203125, 0.055511475, -0.0073509216, 0.017944336, -0.005191803, -0.0062332153, 0.015541077, -0.004837036, -0.022628784, -0.044525146, 0.025726318, -0.043518066, -0.023605347, -0.014266968, 0.037384033, 0.028717041, -0.013442993, -0.0017566681, 0.018478394, -0.0017232895, 0.0028057098, -0.010612488, -0.001077652, 0.011978149, -0.017791748, -0.0017786026, 0.026184082, -0.022750854, -0.02923584, 0.02520752, 0.039245605, -0.021240234, 0.033477783, 0.00013303757, 0.0027446747, -0.03186035, -0.03881836, -0.06695557, -0.061950684, -0.068725586, 0.020996094, -0.019073486, -0.056518555, -0.07965088, 0.019607544, -0.01096344, 0.013748169, -0.02168274, 0.009666443, -0.048095703, 0.026351929, 0.000934124, 0.0051078796, 0.0025730133, -0.015136719, -0.018707275, 0.015098572, -0.0038661957, 0.0024909973, 0.0010890961, 0.018203735, 0.031097412, 0.03515625, -0.014579773, 0.014434814, 0.041778564, -0.011383057, 0.029174805, 0.0033512115, -0.015419006, -0.032073975, 0.002729416, 0.008422852, -0.00076293945, -0.00048160553, 0.021957397, -0.0881958, -0.007698059, -0.027053833, 0.076049805, -0.06536865, -0.015701294, -0.09802246, -0.025222778, -0.054229736, 0.04159546, 0.02861023, -0.074645996, 0.017852783, -0.030029297, -0.047851562, -0.013710022, 0.0063209534, 0.024810791, -0.024124146, -0.008972168, 0.033050537, 0.010406494, 0.08312988, -0.018157959, -0.034240723, -0.05493164, 0.05343628, 0.024871826, 0.030792236, -0.024887085, 0.08496094, -0.004749298, -0.04058838, 0.047668457, 0.054870605, 0.010505676, 0.014389038, 0.012794495, -0.0073051453, -0.016860962, -0.03552246, 0.016784668, -0.0065841675, -0.0154800415, -0.02444458, 0.008369446, -0.013191223, 0.016159058, 0.0024433136, 0.028015137, 0.04095459, -0.024032593, 0.04586792, 0.022735596, 0.026779175, -0.009994507, -0.070129395, 0.0018720627, -0.03643799, -0.013648987, -0.039764404, -0.0803833, 0.023635864, 0.0836792, 0.001534462, -0.030273438, 0.02268982, -0.024917603, 0.025421143, -0.030776978, -0.008583069, 0.0028381348, -0.0024681091, 0.01687622, 0.06304932, -0.017700195, -0.03414917, 0.004386902, -0.017578125, -0.0574646, -0.010559082, -0.01424408, -0.026062012, -0.031707764, -0.004184723, -0.0047340393, -0.011444092, 0.022369385, -0.09918213, -0.035369873, 0.028320312, 0.020446777, -0.010665894, 0.046325684, -0.009506226, 0.07537842, -0.010604858, 0.010482788, -0.010795593, -0.0158844, 0.012763977, -0.019699097, 0.0345459, 0.008453369, -0.019500732, -0.0071907043, 0.0206604, 0.023345947, 0.008232117, -0.029403687, 0.021118164, -0.09234619, -0.015571594, -0.093322754, -0.016082764, -0.043640137, -0.01826477, 0.033355713, 0.024597168, -0.031829834, 0.012802124, -0.02003479, 0.014045715, -0.026397705, 0.0004849434, -0.009735107, 0.0065574646, 0.018722534 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07700v1
AuthentiGPT: Detecting Machine-Generated Text via Black-Box Language Models Denoising
Zhen Guo, Shangdi Yu
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Large language models (LLMs) have opened up enormous opportunities while simultaneously posing ethical dilemmas. One of the major concerns is their ability to create text that closely mimics human writing, which can lead to potential misuse, such as academic misconduct, disinformation, and fraud. To address this problem, we present AuthentiGPT, an efficient classifier that distinguishes between machine-generated and human-written texts. Under the assumption that human-written text resides outside the distribution of machine-generated text, AuthentiGPT leverages a black-box LLM to denoise input text with artificially added noise, and then semantically compares the denoised text with the original to determine if the content is machine-generated. With only one trainable parameter, AuthentiGPT eliminates the need for a large training dataset, watermarking the LLM's output, or computing the log-likelihood. Importantly, the detection capability of AuthentiGPT can be easily adapted to any generative language model. With a 0.918 AUROC score on a domain-specific dataset, AuthentiGPT demonstrates its effectiveness over other commercial algorithms, highlighting its potential for detecting machine-generated text in academic settings.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07700v1
2023-11-13T19:36:54
2023-11-13T19:36:54
{ "title": [ -0.018005371, 0.008277893, -0.036865234, -0.033111572, 0.012802124, -0.011878967, -0.03286743, -0.03274536, -0.01751709, 0.034484863, -0.0073890686, 0.033996582, 0.0035438538, -0.010482788, -0.041107178, 0.006412506, -0.03250122, 0.0736084, -0.016143799, -0.042175293, -0.022003174, -0.07092285, 0.0075683594, -0.007621765, 0.012031555, -0.041656494, 0.01737976, -0.00630188, 0.005180359, -0.015792847, -0.001203537, -0.028686523, 0.033294678, 0.041412354, -0.04220581, 0.016036987, -0.05709839, 0.04940796, 0.008476257, -0.01008606, 0.025787354, -0.003452301, 0.018234253, 0.0050315857, -0.02279663, 0.0073280334, -0.031677246, -0.025527954, -0.023483276, 0.06451416, -0.003314972, 0.01499939, -0.009429932, 0.04788208, 0.017181396, -0.049072266, -0.041137695, 0.038848877, 0.029647827, 0.050628662, 0.026687622, -0.04107666, 0.021759033, -0.015823364, -0.021759033, -0.03237915, -0.03161621, 0.021224976, 0.049743652, 0.0014734268, 0.00011909008, 0.017547607, 0.010406494, -0.039276123, -0.048583984, 0.028015137, 0.0059165955, 0.0063056946, 0.04928589, -0.057495117, -0.003528595, -0.020431519, 0.0024700165, 0.0013942719, -0.0020313263, -0.0068588257, -0.017349243, -0.008621216, -0.046051025, -0.06008911, -0.016601562, -0.018356323, -0.016708374, -0.023788452, -0.028961182, -0.04067993, 0.0073890686, 0.062927246, -0.0340271, -0.020050049, -0.03503418, 0.028381348, -0.03994751, -0.015792847, 0.023391724, 0.020584106, -0.0060310364, -0.041778564, 0.0064468384, 0.016555786, -0.05441284, 0.028411865, 0.011672974, -0.02848816, -0.0098724365, 0.036834717, 0.004749298, -0.010765076, 0.011497498, 0.009613037, -0.016967773, -0.043548584, 0.052734375, -0.007282257, 0.047210693, 0.0057754517, -0.050750732, 0.010414124, -0.015419006, 0.039916992, 0.015022278, 0.0574646, -0.0993042, -0.09918213, -0.088012695, 0.032806396, -0.004463196, -0.011482239, -0.005264282, -0.0128479, 0.031463623, -0.0075912476, -0.009819031, 0.004676819, -0.033325195, -0.0035057068, 0.06072998, 0.0060577393, -0.06378174, -0.027618408, -0.031677246, 0.02041626, 0.03656006, -0.007835388, -0.03225708, -0.039276123, -0.07879639, -0.024291992, 0.033111572, -0.03289795, 0.023590088, 0.004749298, -0.013343811, 0.0028133392, 0.03024292, -0.025650024, -0.0085372925, 0.01965332, 0.0031604767, -0.028778076, -0.019958496, 0.021240234, 0.033111572, -0.014083862, -0.008399963, 0.005962372, 0.015037537, 0.025100708, 0.024887085, 0.007972717, 0.03967285, -0.017196655, 0.025497437, 0.055541992, -0.083496094, -0.00198555, 0.005542755, 0.05432129, 0.056610107, 0.00944519, -0.009841919, -0.005268097, -0.0104522705, -0.035003662, -0.028274536, -0.026931763, 0.011199951, 0.013168335, -0.0044403076, 0.025344849, 0.0057296753, -0.01486969, -0.031082153, -0.016860962, -0.021896362, -0.048950195, -0.015716553, -0.0011768341, -0.06359863, 0.013435364, 0.082092285, 0.0054512024, -0.055267334, 0.015060425, 0.00080633163, -0.04296875, 0.012756348, -0.022918701, -0.0007452965, -0.025222778, 0.0079422, 0.0020961761, 0.009918213, 0.026855469, 0.017227173, 0.014915466, 0.0013656616, -0.014640808, 0.05987549, 0.020965576, 0.08703613, -0.035949707, 0.026245117, 0.012634277, -0.027511597, -0.032684326, -0.053131104, -0.05215454, 0.0025939941, 0.047302246, 0.011978149, 0.012069702, -0.001200676, 0.015281677, 0.06542969, -0.032592773, -0.004486084, 0.009063721, 0.051452637, 0.056365967, 0.01525116, 0.010856628, 0.046844482, -0.011856079, 0.03060913, 0.047332764, -0.011047363, 0.012626648, -0.008232117, -0.012550354, 0.007904053, 0.012336731, -0.0022583008, 0.012496948, -0.06011963, 0.043395996, -0.0033721924, 0.026367188, 0.00541687, 0.02822876, 0.01751709, -0.018600464, -0.0031318665, -0.027938843, 0.043304443, 0.008041382, -0.03717041, 0.016464233, 0.029022217, -0.04107666, -0.0045661926, -0.0014123917, 0.02999878, -0.008148193, 0.027954102, -0.002128601, 0.016174316, -0.021270752, -0.05883789, 0.003627777, 0.036071777, 0.072265625, 0.009918213, -0.0035552979, 0.011276245, 0.033935547, 0.083984375, 0.06890869, -0.016036987, 0.0064735413, -0.04446411, 0.0063285828, -0.012565613, -0.0007457733, -0.009246826, 0.03692627, 0.021530151, 0.004562378, -0.03427124, 0.0041656494, -0.06304932, -0.035583496, -0.021072388, -0.016921997, -0.083618164, -0.07775879, -0.029266357, -0.060668945, -0.069885254, -0.008041382, 0.09643555, 0.013542175, -0.020019531, -0.012260437, -0.010818481, -0.035064697, -0.017059326, -0.03878784, -0.01737976, 0.0062408447, 0.033111572, 0.016189575, -0.045928955, 0.0015592575, 0.0025959015, 0.0057525635, 0.0017404556, 0.0055389404, -0.014442444, -0.011749268, 0.0061149597, 0.0026512146, -0.00073480606, -0.021484375, 0.00957489, -0.058563232, 0.009399414, 0.008018494, -0.06378174, -0.009361267, 0.03955078, -0.026229858, -0.012237549, 0.008522034, 0.053863525, -0.045684814, -0.025482178, 0.017868042, 0.003458023, -0.023239136, 0.023208618, 0.027069092, 0.023147583, 0.018341064, -0.048858643, -0.04547119, -0.0016450882, 0.030944824, 0.022613525, 0.064208984, -0.039398193, -0.009239197, -0.006275177, -0.0063285828, 0.007789612, -0.019729614, 0.0067253113, -0.04586792, -0.042755127, -0.024551392, -0.021621704, 0.023010254, -0.04446411, 0.04135132, 0.075927734, -0.0026226044, -0.01914978, 0.018875122, 0.03515625, 0.011856079, 0.011886597, -0.0066566467, -0.058410645, 0.00932312, 0.018463135, 0.0064201355, 0.0023880005, -0.018356323, -0.103149414, -0.008399963, 0.014671326, -0.005470276, -0.014099121, 0.0048713684, -0.052978516, -0.0055389404, -0.011505127, -0.021820068, 0.03640747, 0.029129028, 0.0491333, 0.0006451607, 0.048461914, -0.031341553, 0.011199951, -0.038360596, -0.09399414, 0.019348145, -0.03353882, -0.0020999908, -0.009902954, -0.010322571, -0.0541687, -0.0008111, 0.0070648193, 0.037963867, 0.018447876, -0.013114929, 0.024612427, 0.0037384033, -0.008628845, -0.012290955, -0.021575928, -0.015335083, -0.03262329, 0.034210205, 0.011276245, 0.034576416, 0.06524658, -0.014564514, -0.002073288, -0.004447937, -0.014472961, 0.036956787, 0.019592285, -0.03878784, -0.020568848, -0.017700195, -0.01763916, 0.0234375, -0.008216858, -0.003768921, -0.026885986, 0.0071983337, -0.015159607, 0.024932861, -0.007259369, 0.01689148, -0.0131073, -0.015052795, 0.014266968, -0.021850586, -0.03564453, 0.0017271042, 0.027236938, -0.024765015, 0.014808655, -0.013000488, -0.02178955, 0.019866943, -0.02508545, 0.021896362, 0.018432617, -0.005130768, -0.008041382, -0.0026416779, 0.005054474, -0.009841919, -0.027297974, -0.0065956116, -0.022201538, 0.011299133, -0.013687134, -0.083740234, -0.036071777, 0.0070877075, -0.10888672, -0.045013428, 0.014549255, -0.023590088, -0.045898438, -0.029449463, 0.033233643, -0.028076172, -0.0054626465, 0.013694763, -0.0037899017, -0.026275635, -0.018936157, -0.06774902, -0.020095825, 0.068847656, 0.0105896, 0.02178955, 0.05908203, -0.0066337585, -0.05029297, -0.02923584, 0.03100586, 0.028808594, 0.0077323914, 0.0063552856, -0.047058105, 0.02482605, -0.036987305, 0.022628784, -0.009979248, -0.03479004, -0.007106781, 0.012176514, 0.015640259, 0.022460938, 0.0007405281, 0.053741455, -0.013725281, -0.009536743, -0.06137085, 0.004299164, 0.0014829636, -0.020980835, 0.006881714, 0.0024738312, 0.013282776, 0.03741455, 0.003107071, 0.023223877, -0.013000488, -0.016998291, 0.02758789, -0.011810303, -0.013999939, -0.034851074, -0.014907837, 0.007133484, -0.013641357, 0.016281128, -0.022735596, 0.03829956, -0.026138306, -0.026733398, 0.0047912598, 0.031677246, -0.044006348, -0.017852783, -0.062561035, -0.034729004, -0.02949524, 0.02444458, -0.010681152, -0.005970001, 0.04647827, -0.012298584, -0.01725769, -0.007041931, 0.062927246, 0.0012559891, -0.007827759, -0.06951904, 0.0066871643, -0.02267456, -0.045898438, -0.047058105, -0.018981934, -0.0025424957, 0.020843506, 0.0034656525, -0.0042877197, 0.034454346, 0.016983032, 0.04260254, 0.049682617, -0.016998291, -0.06317139, 0.03173828, -0.009422302, -0.023345947, 0.006931305, -0.0060768127, -0.0018386841, -0.008811951, 0.037475586, -0.034698486, -0.018707275, 0.009590149, 0.059051514, -0.039123535, 0.08514404, -0.04071045, 0.03012085, 0.015975952, 0.004699707, 0.0040130615, 0.010673523, -0.033477783, 0.005329132, 0.0016107559, 0.03314209, -0.008377075, 0.027282715, 0.036315918, -0.008071899, -0.00141716, -0.011749268, 0.018707275, -0.0026397705, 0.0068893433, 0.023971558, 0.03945923, -0.03277588, -0.022994995, -0.013580322, 0.018814087, 0.034301758, -0.07849121, 0.023666382, -0.020767212, -0.008094788, 0.04046631, -0.0011739731, 0.0066604614, 0.025650024, 0.018493652, -0.03967285, -0.025421143, 0.015563965, 0.0060424805, -0.028320312, 0.011329651, -0.014984131, -0.027374268, 0.004043579, 0.033691406, -0.0055007935, 0.03753662, -0.0035572052, -0.008140564, 0.007369995, -0.027420044, -0.05392456, -0.005344391, 0.0058937073, 0.005672455, -0.023452759, 0.038604736, -0.039855957, -0.0015668869, -0.034423828, -0.016052246, 0.020828247, -0.04296875, 0.01210022, 0.08538818, 0.00182724, 0.04876709, -0.03805542, 0.001991272, 0.03704834, 0.056365967, 0.000008940697, -0.015510559, 0.050842285, -0.023117065, 0.00881958, -0.009391785, 0.009773254, 0.031707764, 0.037139893, 0.016723633, 0.039794922, -0.055664062, 0.0102005005, 0.014831543, -0.0032520294, 0.043670654, -0.047332764, 0.018737793, 0.0137786865, -0.013755798, 0.030349731, -0.019805908, -0.021209717, -0.008094788, -0.004131317, -0.033813477, -0.007320404, 0.012207031, -0.04623413, -0.030883789, 0.04345703, -0.013977051, -0.013198853, 0.0025367737, -0.015686035, -0.03717041, 0.018508911, 0.037261963, -0.052093506, 0.012176514, 0.005722046, 0.014678955, 0.044769287, 0.009017944, -0.04498291, -0.010749817, -0.026473999, -0.049835205, -0.058807373, -0.049468994, -0.035339355, 0.042907715, -0.016601562, -0.008987427, 0.004135132, -0.038909912, 0.013038635, -0.010124207, -0.0124053955, 0.02418518, -0.011177063, -0.0099487305, 0.037261963, 0.028793335, 0.026794434, 0.009353638, -0.0004911423, -0.029541016, 0.012237549, -0.0030879974, 0.018112183, -0.047790527, -0.070739746, -0.005420685, 0.023498535, 0.012924194, -0.0132369995, 0.050720215, 0.029922485, -0.0019836426, 0.022140503, 0.01939392, 0.03970337, -0.030090332, -0.029754639, -0.027755737, 0.0035705566, -0.031463623, 0.046203613, -0.0000564456, -0.019515991, -0.02859497, -0.032409668, -0.02268982, 0.02758789, 0.041748047, 0.0035095215, 0.048950195, -0.032714844, 0.03173828, -0.036865234, -0.01285553, -0.024002075, 0.024414062, -0.00844574, -0.022491455, 0.012939453, -0.004802704, -0.030395508, -0.0026111603, 0.0385437, 0.040802002, -0.0087890625, 0.04244995, -0.022247314, -0.022369385, -0.033813477, -0.0069732666, 0.038116455, 0.028503418, -0.015312195, 0.068359375, -0.02784729, 0.05508423, 0.036071777, 0.04547119, 0.08532715, 0.02243042, -0.021362305, 0.0072288513, -0.012771606, -0.040649414, -0.014846802, -0.037750244, -0.029937744, -0.05065918, -0.006187439, -0.06210327, 0.020431519, -0.0047721863, 0.031921387, -0.0016784668, 0.028244019, 0.006904602, -0.00009590387, 0.031982422, -0.0028438568, 0.056762695, -0.03540039, 0.014625549, -0.021743774, -0.054229736, 0.04598999, 0.039733887, -0.02583313, 0.0178833, 0.0066223145, -0.008232117, 0.03366089, -0.00059890747, 0.014442444, -0.038879395, 0.006904602, -0.03488159, 0.039215088, 0.0184021, 0.023498535, 0.044158936, 0.04067993, -0.013069153, -0.008117676, 0.0068511963, -0.059539795, 0.012001038, -0.04525757, -0.0104599, -0.03289795, 0.03878784, -0.010597229, -0.016113281, -0.07324219, 0.034729004, 0.0021915436, -0.020050049, 0.006298065, 0.033935547, 0.024536133, -0.004261017, 0.026794434, -0.045288086, -0.018203735, 0.00756073, 0.018463135, -0.026947021, -0.0015182495, 0.03189087, 0.03152466, 0.0048294067, 0.00712204, 0.019073486, 0.008354187, 0.023895264, 0.026351929, -0.032989502, 0.04434204, -0.018920898, -0.043426514, 0.0052108765, 0.0073165894, -0.056518555, -0.016021729, 0.048431396, 0.037384033, 0.03302002, 0.069885254, 0.023452759, -0.012779236, -0.015365601, -0.032196045, 0.020462036, 0.030639648, -0.029815674, 0.024536133, -0.042053223, -0.044128418, 0.035369873, -0.06604004, 0.077819824, -0.02645874, -0.0035476685, -0.03668213, 0.028945923, 0.031921387, -0.048034668, -0.017990112, -0.025344849, 0.024993896, -0.03591919, -0.026138306, -0.02947998, -0.041137695, -0.02279663, 0.062347412, -0.007335663, 0.01940918, 0.046783447, -0.040863037, -0.06890869, -0.013122559, -0.007926941, 0.029373169, -0.009735107, 0.011459351, 0.0036296844, 0.013656616, 0.0118255615, -0.06329346, -0.035614014, 0.0031986237, 0.0014286041, -0.03918457, 0.016860962, 0.016220093, -0.024124146, -0.056640625, -0.032287598, -0.0017642975, -0.035827637, 0.0063095093, 0.030227661, -0.027069092, -0.042907715, -0.005836487, -0.037750244, 0.03729248, 0.023605347, -0.028793335, 0.042297363, 0.0077209473, -0.027999878, 0.016464233, 0.012420654, 0.040649414, -0.0053901672, -0.035217285, 0.015602112, 0.01940918, 0.049102783, -0.039093018, -0.04437256, -0.003534317, -0.0036067963, -0.017715454, 0.035705566, 0.033599854, 0.027893066, 0.015914917, 0.025756836, -0.0020828247, -0.055419922, -0.012664795, -0.028457642, 0.039215088, 0.009857178, -0.012924194, -0.020614624, 0.011116028, -0.0317688, -0.0033397675, -0.0060043335, -0.022857666, -0.008621216, 0.0048103333, 0.02746582, -0.014183044, 0.009269714, -0.072753906, 0.043395996, 0.0005955696, 0.03390503, -0.011405945, 0.039001465, 0.006916046, 0.050750732, -0.006477356, -0.03665161, 0.029037476, 0.029556274, 0.006664276, 0.045928955, -0.015731812, -0.01687622, -0.0010223389, -0.004070282, -0.013130188, 0.009208679, 0.020843506, -0.039398193, 0.0053367615, -0.05618286, -0.03062439, -0.061065674, -0.019104004, 0.017974854, -0.0289917, 0.021652222, -0.020965576, -0.005958557, -0.0024738312, 0.015388489, 0.0071983337, -0.016799927, -0.057495117, -0.026977539, 0.047668457, -0.025299072 ], "summary": [ -0.002002716, 0.0060157776, -0.0040664673, 0.018478394, -0.038360596, -0.0104599, -0.038848877, -0.06286621, -0.002450943, 0.025512695, -0.0070381165, 0.018936157, -0.026031494, -0.00831604, -0.012306213, -0.031585693, -0.05001831, 0.055847168, -0.0053634644, -0.04171753, 0.010925293, -0.08148193, -0.021759033, -0.038238525, 0.017059326, -0.037353516, 0.0692749, -0.020767212, 0.062805176, 0.029342651, 0.023010254, -0.08691406, 0.023071289, 0.026519775, -0.05697632, 0.040405273, -0.027938843, 0.028366089, 0.00340271, -0.002565384, 0.035369873, -0.004714966, 0.05883789, 0.033416748, -0.020584106, 0.039733887, -0.0024490356, -0.019897461, 0.010360718, 0.036712646, -0.025512695, 0.005329132, -0.034484863, 0.010368347, -0.0071754456, -0.015403748, -0.038269043, -0.0010881424, -0.006664276, 0.03930664, 0.042510986, 0.008270264, 0.013374329, 0.0015220642, -0.030136108, 0.0079422, -0.02986145, -0.008659363, 0.05279541, -0.00844574, -0.0033626556, 0.010673523, 0.0037593842, -0.060058594, -0.020355225, 0.06311035, -0.029067993, -0.0009059906, 0.046966553, -0.04248047, -0.012718201, 0.0087509155, -0.0018138885, -0.018234253, 0.0026474, -0.010269165, -0.021331787, -0.0056915283, 0.004447937, -0.023483276, -0.022155762, 0.010902405, 0.011772156, 0.014839172, -0.0056648254, -0.046142578, -0.018920898, 0.009498596, -0.02960205, 0.0070495605, 0.010070801, -0.024108887, 0.02128601, -0.024795532, -0.01612854, 0.063964844, 0.040740967, -0.026977539, -0.04272461, -0.022491455, -0.034240723, -0.03161621, -0.018218994, -0.08215332, -0.009475708, 0.04510498, -0.020645142, 0.02204895, 0.041748047, -0.010169983, -0.01423645, 0.0030345917, 0.037231445, -0.0020103455, 0.0178833, 0.02960205, -0.0032596588, -0.038909912, -0.017654419, 0.023025513, 0.02305603, 0.03878784, -0.06536865, -0.05432129, -0.09100342, 0.00019931793, 0.007019043, 0.027282715, -0.0053596497, -0.0109939575, 0.039733887, -0.017868042, -0.014274597, 0.031341553, -0.032684326, 0.015342712, 0.031036377, 0.00497818, -0.037628174, -0.028457642, -0.007194519, -0.003982544, 0.038513184, -0.040222168, 0.002046585, -0.07476807, -0.04562378, -0.012512207, 0.044769287, -0.003314972, 0.0021209717, 0.0018224716, -0.009277344, -0.007095337, -0.020095825, -0.032806396, -0.00031399727, -0.0022468567, 0.014122009, -0.05038452, -0.015640259, 0.022827148, 0.06958008, -0.018203735, -0.014427185, 0.004840851, -0.007534027, 0.04574585, 0.0234375, -0.0006966591, 0.024414062, -0.014961243, 0.057128906, 0.015083313, -0.026535034, -0.0053253174, 0.002779007, 0.06124878, 0.035491943, 0.031143188, -0.015563965, -0.031982422, 0.0008392334, -0.006412506, -0.02079773, -0.02758789, 0.0012521744, 0.015731812, -0.019851685, -0.001868248, 0.070007324, -0.004611969, -0.026809692, -0.05456543, -0.11004639, -0.04055786, -0.023132324, 0.015899658, -0.0592041, 0.017684937, 0.048797607, -0.021438599, -0.046081543, 0.05960083, 0.030914307, -0.018096924, 0.0004992485, -0.026000977, 0.0033855438, -0.034301758, 0.022003174, 0.030593872, -0.013084412, 0.028915405, -0.017028809, 0.03488159, -0.02961731, 0.034973145, 0.04083252, 0.03527832, 0.057159424, -0.03479004, 0.006729126, 0.022537231, -0.019577026, -0.02406311, -0.0513916, -0.093444824, 0.015991211, 0.059051514, 0.033355713, 0.03756714, -0.01436615, -0.005340576, 0.02381897, -0.00730896, 0.013504028, -0.016601562, 0.02319336, 0.06689453, -0.011016846, -0.0015239716, 0.008964539, -0.04269409, 0.013793945, 0.04257202, -0.012626648, -0.0034923553, 0.0003900528, 0.011474609, 0.0090408325, -0.0011529922, 0.0030174255, -0.005634308, -0.018035889, 0.0018520355, -0.0075531006, -0.011711121, -0.02180481, -0.0059814453, 0.025680542, -0.010948181, 0.0013504028, -0.05819702, 0.031311035, 0.014755249, -0.026443481, 0.010215759, 0.043395996, -0.015350342, -0.038604736, -0.033081055, -0.019134521, -0.019012451, 0.041290283, 0.012199402, 0.0056037903, -0.04345703, -0.004047394, 0.043884277, 0.020187378, 0.08477783, 0.02053833, 0.01348114, 0.037017822, 0.03842163, 0.049926758, -0.0033283234, 0.033966064, -0.053955078, -0.00020110607, 0.017822266, -0.07171631, 0.02848816, 0.0079193115, 0.01689148, 0.0065231323, 0.01776123, 0.008430481, 0.01625061, -0.083496094, -0.021499634, -0.00058555603, 0.026397705, -0.06365967, -0.05380249, -0.031341553, 0.004623413, -0.06732178, 0.0010652542, 0.09197998, 0.03741455, 0.000036895275, 0.00919342, 0.004432678, -0.041778564, 0.040008545, -0.039031982, 0.017074585, -0.0041542053, 0.0038166046, 0.00037956238, -0.005332947, 0.009338379, -0.002840042, -0.019577026, 0.007160187, 0.019638062, -0.0067100525, -0.011749268, 0.027893066, -0.0013771057, 0.0037460327, 0.019622803, -0.021606445, -0.026611328, 0.004901886, -0.0013446808, -0.008384705, -0.043121338, 0.056396484, -0.031951904, 0.008872986, 0.022506714, 0.03451538, -0.031036377, -0.03326416, 0.0026512146, -0.017562866, -0.05239868, -0.0026893616, 0.062164307, 0.013168335, 0.031585693, -0.05456543, -0.034942627, 0.02468872, 0.043121338, 0.0057258606, 0.031463623, 0.002954483, 0.009925842, 0.011566162, -0.008308411, -0.023834229, -0.018081665, 0.061065674, -0.01637268, -0.0062294006, 0.03161621, 0.005004883, 0.040130615, -0.020080566, 0.04034424, 0.041625977, 0.012619019, -0.015144348, 0.022857666, 0.030151367, -0.0015306473, 0.017288208, 0.0211792, -0.020050049, -0.009902954, 0.015426636, 0.005466461, -0.018234253, -0.0065727234, -0.06951904, -0.011024475, 0.055114746, 0.00051498413, 0.014045715, 0.008430481, -0.025405884, -0.0043029785, 0.021392822, 0.014587402, 0.047790527, -0.060272217, 0.07080078, -0.040985107, 0.053497314, -0.04711914, -0.01663208, -0.03753662, -0.032196045, 0.017196655, -0.058044434, -0.004081726, -0.0011386871, 0.044067383, -0.019882202, -0.0211792, 0.023986816, 0.024810791, -0.016708374, -0.028625488, 0.020065308, 0.051727295, -0.024139404, 0.028549194, -0.011123657, 0.017700195, -0.05682373, 0.033996582, 0.02482605, 0.0101623535, 0.07928467, -0.053710938, 0.0018644333, 0.0016336441, -0.0569458, -0.0018453598, 0.00046396255, -0.035064697, 0.002828598, -0.03866577, 0.007881165, 0.048950195, -0.018005371, -0.014320374, -0.0039253235, 0.017974854, -0.031280518, 0.033325195, -0.032440186, 0.021942139, 0.018661499, -0.028930664, -0.0053710938, -0.024124146, -0.0046844482, -0.005466461, 0.010955811, 0.01977539, -0.023391724, 0.026321411, -0.018920898, 0.002292633, 0.014373779, -0.011741638, 0.02468872, 0.0024414062, -0.023025513, -0.012664795, 0.032287598, 0.0076179504, 0.0019874573, -0.029724121, -0.056732178, 0.031066895, -0.07525635, -0.11254883, -0.06781006, 0.006542206, -0.11279297, -0.08544922, 0.014915466, 0.029571533, -0.048858643, -0.007255554, 0.045410156, -0.008811951, 0.011039734, 0.05114746, -0.016235352, 0.06210327, -0.008880615, -0.060302734, -0.0027923584, -0.015533447, -0.006084442, 0.031555176, -0.0029335022, 0.044647217, -0.006336212, 0.0017738342, 0.0020389557, -0.057647705, 0.008361816, -0.046142578, -0.05670166, 0.013954163, -0.030548096, -0.0071105957, 0.000641346, -0.009742737, -0.033721924, -0.005191803, 0.026992798, 0.037353516, 0.034088135, 0.034332275, -0.061340332, -0.0049362183, -0.014266968, -0.021331787, -0.009880066, -0.028121948, 0.043823242, 0.03111267, -0.019851685, 0.025177002, -0.0029335022, -0.0039100647, -0.025497437, -0.03982544, -0.002193451, 0.019729614, -0.029403687, -0.02909851, -0.00579834, 0.042877197, -0.019012451, 0.014709473, -0.031341553, 0.020965576, -0.036193848, -0.020401001, 0.008613586, 0.023162842, -0.03086853, -0.040649414, -0.017974854, -0.029312134, -0.0074920654, 0.009559631, -0.00724411, -0.011207581, 0.035308838, 0.0050086975, 0.00076818466, -0.031051636, 0.038208008, 0.017028809, -0.028244019, -0.07080078, 0.04333496, -0.02394104, -0.02519226, -0.036987305, -0.031433105, -0.041229248, -0.0062026978, -0.020706177, -0.003288269, 0.007068634, 0.01550293, 0.037261963, 0.026443481, 0.0026874542, -0.047973633, -0.020507812, -0.029632568, 0.008842468, 0.021148682, -0.019836426, -0.0033683777, 0.016784668, 0.028167725, -0.020004272, -0.036712646, -0.017700195, 0.053741455, -0.015548706, 0.06896973, -0.023239136, 0.039642334, 0.023223877, 0.01210022, -0.0093307495, 0.01158905, -0.0030555725, -0.009849548, -0.03326416, -0.027236938, 0.024520874, 0.023223877, 0.048339844, -0.02381897, -0.057891846, 0.018585205, 0.035614014, 0.031158447, 0.002828598, 0.046295166, 0.010566711, -0.009971619, -0.018417358, 0.015045166, -0.0060768127, 0.0084991455, 0.0044555664, -0.031143188, -0.010757446, 0.019424438, 0.014862061, -0.017929077, -0.0018033981, 0.01991272, 0.0031871796, -0.03012085, 0.0019264221, 0.009597778, -0.0017242432, -0.024719238, -0.005794525, -0.030731201, -0.046783447, 0.015411377, -0.011474609, -0.02468872, -0.0041656494, -0.008468628, -0.018737793, -0.0025749207, 0.0051994324, -0.015426636, -0.017410278, 0.00049829483, 0.01676941, 0.011329651, 0.03414917, 0.013923645, 0.02784729, -0.04724121, -0.0023403168, -0.010009766, -0.011917114, -0.035461426, 0.04043579, -0.035339355, 0.04269409, -0.0024356842, -0.0075645447, -0.0023555756, 0.035888672, -0.024261475, -0.030197144, 0.0131073, -0.017059326, 0.016235352, -0.031951904, 0.009513855, 0.035736084, 0.036956787, 0.0234375, 0.06112671, -0.054718018, -0.004261017, -0.039855957, -0.003019333, 0.0025672913, 0.00043940544, 0.023010254, 0.012519836, 0.007297516, 0.015151978, 0.013267517, -0.016403198, -0.012008667, 0.014320374, -0.008468628, -0.038208008, 0.010650635, -0.040252686, 0.030883789, 0.047607422, -0.021743774, -0.020690918, 0.032592773, -0.035949707, -0.0060043335, -0.019927979, 0.067871094, 0.000500679, -0.012817383, 0.014778137, 0.025848389, -0.010551453, -0.024719238, -0.0021095276, -0.00051116943, -0.06286621, -0.050567627, -0.047546387, -0.032318115, -0.02357483, 0.08850098, -0.01902771, 0.019546509, 0.016021729, -0.04864502, 0.02029419, -0.03878784, -0.02520752, 0.0049743652, -0.030975342, -0.049591064, 0.04574585, -0.023788452, -0.009567261, 0.01739502, 0.0067253113, -0.028335571, 0.032928467, 0.03387451, 0.050994873, -0.05102539, -0.062927246, -0.0025901794, 0.039978027, 0.008300781, 0.008026123, 0.07208252, 0.031463623, 0.013420105, 0.02558899, 0.032104492, 0.008384705, -0.02444458, -0.04647827, -0.013137817, 0.008110046, -0.012634277, 0.019073486, 0.023544312, -0.019378662, 0.00065612793, -0.027389526, 0.010498047, 0.0056266785, 0.04067993, 0.0018939972, 0.03665161, -0.019088745, 0.0072135925, 0.016983032, -0.036468506, -0.015365601, 0.013305664, -0.012763977, -0.060272217, 0.07659912, -0.005302429, -0.03768921, 0.015113831, 0.027938843, 0.021240234, -0.003414154, 0.03994751, 0.027160645, -0.019454956, -0.040985107, 0.033203125, 0.03112793, 0.07128906, -0.024520874, 0.045959473, 0.012359619, 0.030288696, 0.03274536, 0.0026988983, 0.032562256, 0.009284973, -0.016357422, 0.0049743652, -0.0075531006, -0.014228821, 0.0050849915, -0.0137786865, -0.04837036, -0.06323242, -0.039245605, -0.011642456, 0.023330688, -0.031829834, -0.0038375854, 0.026794434, 0.0063171387, -0.015144348, -0.0140686035, -0.023712158, 0.031555176, 0.015136719, -0.0385437, -0.0044517517, -0.012870789, -0.07470703, 0.03945923, 0.04977417, -0.032684326, 0.020553589, 0.029586792, 0.03375244, 0.050109863, -0.05218506, -0.032714844, -0.08276367, 0.047424316, -0.040161133, 0.012817383, 0.050201416, 0.030456543, -0.008811951, 0.0037498474, 0.050628662, 0.0011978149, -0.0055656433, -0.04046631, 0.039245605, -0.056732178, -0.04788208, 0.048339844, 0.00039196014, 0.002922058, 0.0030326843, -0.03250122, 0.01411438, 0.016281128, -0.019500732, 0.020233154, -0.002790451, 0.010520935, -0.024230957, 0.018325806, -0.046142578, -0.014511108, -0.020492554, -0.012710571, -0.016143799, -0.025939941, 0.0048446655, 0.01083374, -0.007232666, -0.0055999756, 0.023666382, -0.008331299, 0.033233643, 0.025039673, -0.011695862, 0.02557373, -0.011383057, -0.024093628, 0.009063721, 0.029693604, -0.050079346, 0.014541626, 0.016082764, 0.018875122, 0.040893555, 0.046203613, -0.026245117, 0.008590698, 0.032989502, -0.012214661, 0.029220581, -0.015113831, 0.0007457733, 0.008659363, -0.030914307, 0.0011701584, 0.022369385, -0.023620605, 0.04562378, -0.052886963, 0.014549255, -0.047424316, 0.033355713, -0.03289795, -0.048614502, -0.031036377, -0.041809082, 0.027954102, -0.028869629, -0.021499634, -0.023986816, -0.028564453, -0.029449463, 0.057891846, 0.005718231, 0.011039734, 0.054229736, -0.026992798, -0.037139893, -0.01222229, 0.024597168, 0.04083252, -0.0067634583, -0.014335632, 0.050964355, 0.009422302, -0.012466431, -0.06933594, -0.031982422, 0.0056648254, 0.04647827, -0.044555664, 0.02305603, 0.026855469, -0.008506775, -0.049804688, -0.04776001, 0.0033740997, -0.037719727, 0.054473877, 0.05596924, -0.034057617, -0.027038574, 0.029006958, -0.06573486, 0.07098389, -0.0035190582, -0.02482605, 0.035980225, -0.012336731, -0.042388916, -0.008094788, 0.011528015, 0.02658081, -0.0067443848, -0.058166504, 0.024658203, 0.0013971329, 0.04724121, -0.0079193115, 0.0072135925, 0.006916046, 0.019012451, -0.0048446655, -0.008399963, 0.0023899078, 0.012008667, 0.050109863, 0.01083374, 0.011817932, -0.0435791, 0.01259613, -0.0067367554, 0.054382324, -0.011291504, -0.037628174, 0.020889282, 0.0090789795, -0.048309326, -0.05166626, -0.03161621, 0.040863037, -0.056549072, 0.012039185, -0.008468628, -0.043640137, -0.022872925, -0.026275635, 0.004055023, -0.006099701, -0.017852783, -0.010055542, 0.024047852, -0.037872314, -0.002231598, -0.015655518, -0.0090408325, -0.0095825195, 0.0044937134, 0.013381958, -0.03111267, 0.012504578, 0.017349243, 0.01096344, -0.012420654, 0.009605408, -0.0036029816, 0.013549805, -0.048309326, -0.015449524, -0.064819336, 0.014854431, -0.10070801, -0.014846802, -0.012321472, -0.015037537, 0.009353638, 0.002565384, -0.02331543, 0.011833191, -0.0070152283, 0.008323669, -0.022262573, 0.0044784546, -0.020248413, 0.0077590942, 0.012626648 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07692v1
On The Truthfulness of 'Surprisingly Likely' Responses of Large Language Models
Naman Goel
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT
The surprisingly likely criterion in the seminal work of Prelec (the Bayesian Truth Serum) guarantees truthfulness in a game-theoretic multi-agent setting, by rewarding rational agents to maximise the expected information gain with their answers w.r.t. their probabilistic beliefs. We investigate the relevance of a similar criterion for responses of LLMs. We hypothesize that if the surprisingly likely criterion works in LLMs, under certain conditions, the responses that maximize the reward under this criterion should be more accurate than the responses that only maximize the posterior probability. Using benchmarks including the TruthfulQA benchmark and using openly available LLMs: GPT-2 and LLaMA-2, we show that the method indeed improves the accuracy significantly (for example, upto 24 percentage points aggregate improvement on TruthfulQA and upto 70 percentage points improvement on individual categories of questions).
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07692v1
2023-11-13T19:21:25
2023-11-13T19:21:25
{ "title": [ -0.028396606, -0.007457733, -0.039154053, -0.05050659, -0.0027065277, -0.012931824, -0.046081543, -0.015113831, -0.00031971931, 0.015571594, -0.017074585, -0.0014257431, -0.013084412, -0.021011353, -0.04144287, 0.0023021698, -0.01852417, 0.048797607, -0.027694702, -0.044128418, -0.023376465, -0.058654785, 0.020111084, 0.00044059753, 0.074157715, -0.061950684, -0.06762695, 0.035491943, -0.02166748, -0.02268982, 0.014518738, -0.0032978058, 0.040100098, 0.033172607, -0.018676758, 0.0043563843, -0.018310547, 0.020492554, -0.0006928444, 0.015945435, 0.010108948, -0.0036392212, -0.008712769, -0.032104492, -0.028900146, 0.018493652, -0.04598999, -0.02848816, -0.0009975433, 0.028686523, 0.0020637512, 0.05718994, -0.028656006, 0.009971619, 0.022216797, -0.020584106, -0.015411377, 0.012863159, 0.025009155, 0.060333252, 0.026016235, -0.013305664, 0.0018377304, -0.019546509, -0.03302002, -0.0042877197, -0.019058228, 0.019348145, 0.06829834, 0.011306763, -0.03540039, -0.0016727448, 0.01360321, -0.016021729, -0.055786133, 0.019012451, 0.034088135, 0.0014162064, 0.044799805, -0.04373169, 0.03829956, -0.005657196, 0.02482605, -0.0019626617, 0.001871109, -0.032989502, -0.012237549, -0.011878967, -0.050323486, -0.07678223, -0.015007019, -0.039794922, -0.033447266, -0.013130188, -0.013679504, -0.04714966, -0.011528015, 0.045288086, -0.016113281, -0.050811768, -0.021774292, 0.03024292, -0.092285156, -0.010856628, 0.011360168, 0.017044067, -0.031463623, -0.024810791, 0.014801025, 0.032928467, -0.014175415, 0.033172607, -0.009536743, -0.0066566467, 0.015426636, 0.0010194778, -0.047424316, 0.03137207, 0.007713318, 0.027053833, -0.00730896, -0.039367676, 0.02861023, 0.0047569275, 0.0345459, 0.00044059753, -0.06890869, 0.011001587, -0.022384644, 0.050872803, 0.028686523, 0.04257202, -0.13964844, -0.090270996, -0.08123779, 0.04748535, -0.018432617, -0.01159668, -0.031677246, 0.020401001, 0.010093689, -0.022247314, 0.012290955, -0.01247406, 0.008460999, 0.0033683777, 0.06903076, -0.009918213, -0.05633545, -0.030303955, -0.02897644, 0.018310547, 0.043273926, -0.010154724, -0.06762695, -0.024337769, -0.1418457, -0.008934021, 0.014503479, 0.0038604736, -0.0006875992, -0.016677856, -0.013717651, -0.0059776306, 0.005844116, 0.017105103, 0.0036907196, 0.009300232, 0.015213013, 0.04449463, -0.025314331, 0.033203125, 0.0073776245, 0.010009766, -0.0021953583, 0.0018644333, 0.021011353, 0.029434204, 0.020629883, -0.013450623, 0.01789856, -0.022720337, 0.03024292, 0.038024902, -0.068603516, -0.023025513, -0.010360718, 0.006767273, 0.06317139, 0.015991211, -0.03475952, 0.011390686, -0.040100098, -0.04397583, -0.02999878, -0.014038086, 0.018081665, 0.020904541, -0.0024108887, 0.0022602081, -0.006828308, -0.003501892, -0.025604248, -0.003850937, -0.031173706, -0.024734497, -0.025878906, 0.017425537, -0.0058670044, 0.057281494, 0.054138184, 0.03527832, -0.05126953, 0.04208374, -0.004917145, -0.05596924, 0.020614624, 0.0026226044, -0.012588501, -0.029067993, -0.023651123, -0.010154724, 0.011787415, 0.062469482, 0.005519867, -0.011314392, 0.009132385, -0.029052734, 0.019515991, 0.012237549, 0.050048828, -0.030838013, 0.006565094, 0.021469116, 0.0036201477, -0.033721924, -0.016464233, -0.027008057, 0.027557373, 0.02418518, 0.000032365322, -0.014076233, -0.010261536, 0.030029297, 0.037139893, 0.012077332, 0.018310547, 0.000119924545, 0.041381836, 0.034851074, 0.057800293, -0.006286621, 0.04647827, -0.04272461, 0.03010559, 0.056854248, 0.0024681091, -0.016098022, -0.007095337, 0.017501831, 0.023468018, 0.013038635, -0.032073975, 0.025268555, -0.06390381, -0.014083862, -0.06304932, -0.024810791, 0.012283325, 0.0012044907, 0.029174805, -0.056121826, 0.019515991, -0.0012025833, 0.006942749, -0.0093688965, -0.02720642, 0.014541626, 0.025680542, -0.051605225, -0.007232666, 0.010482788, 0.027938843, 0.008911133, 0.018127441, 0.013046265, 0.015541077, -0.006652832, -0.002565384, 0.018005371, 0.06384277, 0.058044434, 0.029434204, 0.008377075, -0.011016846, 0.010414124, 0.094055176, 0.042144775, -0.024887085, 0.0256958, -0.029953003, 0.034606934, 0.032165527, -0.014221191, 0.024261475, 0.040222168, 0.05947876, 0.010429382, -0.03894043, 0.024887085, -0.052337646, -0.007030487, 0.012649536, -0.012390137, -0.03314209, -0.029724121, 0.010894775, -0.01838684, -0.020690918, -0.018203735, 0.068603516, 0.0040359497, -0.038116455, -0.004085541, 0.00022399426, -0.016601562, -0.012588501, -0.040039062, -0.009132385, -0.0033397675, 0.024810791, -0.016601562, -0.06616211, -0.058685303, -0.0052986145, 0.010444641, -0.020401001, 0.023376465, -0.024597168, 0.019515991, 0.014549255, -0.0065574646, 0.031097412, -0.041503906, 0.005142212, -0.06085205, 0.020217896, 0.01977539, -0.019927979, -0.011756897, 0.032440186, -0.02456665, -0.013572693, 0.020431519, 0.061553955, -0.031234741, -0.040771484, 0.04638672, 0.010787964, -0.021362305, 0.027282715, 0.03652954, 0.012542725, -0.05178833, -0.037017822, -0.05593872, -0.027709961, 0.0024967194, -0.002527237, 0.038879395, -0.043151855, -0.024780273, -0.026046753, -0.016616821, 0.013000488, 0.0049095154, -0.012062073, -0.035095215, -0.012680054, -0.022369385, -0.017364502, 0.020370483, -0.011711121, 0.056671143, 0.09313965, 0.021224976, 0.018371582, 0.008201599, 0.03994751, -0.008041382, -0.0098724365, -0.014083862, -0.01727295, -0.010498047, 0.0015926361, 0.019973755, -0.011619568, -0.05316162, -0.04425049, 0.0019512177, 0.051757812, -0.003376007, -0.026809692, 0.024780273, -0.06744385, 0.038116455, -0.015853882, -0.0060310364, 0.034332275, 0.012489319, 0.008285522, 0.0042381287, 0.015655518, -0.047058105, 0.008323669, -0.041412354, -0.12414551, 0.03164673, -0.009140015, -0.042907715, -0.029067993, -0.0050086975, -0.04498291, -0.0013198853, 0.0033035278, 0.06311035, 0.003446579, -0.0069770813, 0.03387451, -0.042053223, -0.008079529, -0.021240234, -0.017074585, -0.0052948, -0.0071411133, 0.014915466, -0.0025405884, 0.021713257, 0.022262573, -0.004299164, 0.008262634, -0.02947998, -0.07019043, 0.018417358, -0.017623901, -0.043701172, -0.02305603, -0.0052375793, 0.0009160042, -0.0068740845, -0.021850586, 0.0060768127, -0.024520874, 0.011222839, -0.019515991, -0.002439499, 0.04473877, -0.002494812, -0.015342712, -0.0028190613, 0.013908386, -0.0054244995, -0.060791016, 0.004508972, 0.060791016, 0.014335632, -0.012077332, -0.0063438416, 0.00034070015, 0.0072021484, 0.000041902065, -0.015701294, 0.012908936, 0.0039711, -0.02003479, -0.008590698, -0.0074539185, 0.0018520355, -0.009384155, 0.014434814, -0.0098724365, 0.013000488, -0.008834839, -0.08203125, -0.02267456, 0.00920105, -0.11456299, -0.03363037, -0.0029335022, -0.024749756, -0.019851685, -0.03753662, 0.030776978, -0.0385437, -0.041046143, 0.009124756, -0.022644043, -0.040527344, -0.032073975, -0.08569336, -0.014022827, 0.07891846, 0.010147095, 0.035583496, 0.020431519, -0.02053833, -0.019363403, -0.044006348, 0.02720642, 0.012702942, 0.03137207, -0.005290985, -0.019851685, 0.0390625, -0.03125, 0.024841309, 0.024963379, -0.012504578, 0.0067710876, 0.0062332153, -0.0031852722, 0.04107666, -0.01637268, 0.051361084, -0.002658844, -0.01763916, -0.06689453, 0.02243042, -0.018112183, -0.013381958, 0.022460938, -0.01449585, 0.0012979507, 0.0038585663, 0.015960693, 0.058258057, -0.022125244, 0.022827148, 0.049743652, -0.014533997, -0.028457642, -0.0027809143, 0.024536133, 0.018432617, 0.006752014, 0.0154953, 0.011253357, 0.020050049, -0.009307861, -0.034057617, -0.0026664734, 0.02772522, -0.04574585, 0.012016296, -0.04626465, -0.08093262, -0.046691895, 0.011108398, -0.014076233, 0.061920166, 0.049346924, 0.013137817, -0.02154541, -0.025634766, 0.033203125, -0.003583908, -0.0030441284, -0.054138184, 0.01637268, -0.016677856, -0.04815674, -0.03604126, -0.0013427734, 0.005607605, 0.054107666, -0.0024433136, -0.021316528, 0.01965332, 0.022033691, 0.041290283, 0.03237915, -0.019073486, -0.040771484, 0.018692017, -0.021942139, -0.029327393, 0.031799316, -0.0065193176, 0.00068712234, -0.035064697, 0.01449585, -0.019088745, -0.011726379, -0.041168213, 0.046539307, -0.022415161, 0.080322266, -0.031555176, -0.019515991, 0.0284729, -0.011314392, 0.010650635, 0.010261536, -0.026489258, 0.0178833, 0.017501831, 0.01550293, 0.032836914, 0.008377075, 0.01676941, 0.04019165, 0.011650085, -0.019454956, 0.020812988, -0.0024414062, -0.0044898987, 0.005924225, 0.012283325, -0.02482605, -0.03717041, 0.010345459, 0.010108948, 0.040893555, -0.023498535, 0.050323486, -0.03503418, 0.0010700226, -0.0044174194, -0.01676941, 0.025314331, -0.025009155, 0.026870728, -0.032348633, -0.03265381, 0.028686523, 0.011703491, -0.016525269, 0.013549805, -0.015541077, 0.01776123, 0.021987915, 0.04083252, 0.023712158, -0.03201294, -0.0022525787, -0.024475098, -0.026565552, -0.0035247803, -0.053619385, 0.0058021545, -0.008804321, 0.012382507, -0.029159546, 0.03253174, -0.06567383, 0.0014095306, -0.016601562, -0.03643799, 0.028182983, -0.080444336, 0.017120361, 0.0725708, -0.003829956, 0.046020508, 0.0059928894, 0.010246277, 0.02041626, 0.062683105, -0.010620117, 0.05065918, 0.029434204, -0.03488159, -0.010360718, -0.011940002, 0.03878784, 0.0055122375, 0.024902344, 0.025115967, 0.023483276, -0.07525635, 0.008392334, -0.005874634, 0.013046265, 0.030090332, -0.060302734, 0.014198303, 0.014671326, -0.010429382, 0.020202637, -0.015602112, -0.024398804, -0.013954163, 0.0034370422, -0.035736084, 0.015525818, -0.002729416, -0.038970947, -0.031707764, 0.008735657, -0.022262573, -0.006549835, 0.019897461, 0.0069618225, -0.023788452, 0.020050049, 0.040893555, -0.044006348, 0.00349617, -0.022201538, 0.009101868, 0.032470703, 0.015335083, -0.037506104, -0.016845703, -0.013389587, -0.029037476, 0.0017118454, 0.017959595, 0.012031555, 0.008872986, -0.009994507, 0.0073890686, 0.02796936, -0.023895264, 0.020904541, -0.0015945435, -0.011749268, 0.026290894, -0.008148193, -0.003282547, 0.002773285, 0.029327393, 0.021621704, -0.00566864, 0.0069389343, -0.07775879, 0.0362854, -0.020217896, 0.031280518, -0.055877686, -0.0592041, 0.002565384, 0.019592285, 0.003824234, -0.021194458, 0.0057258606, 0.028411865, 0.0007634163, -0.008804321, -0.0031871796, 0.05596924, -0.035888672, -0.035980225, -0.0058403015, -0.0049934387, -0.02545166, 0.050933838, 0.011062622, -0.02017212, -0.033355713, -0.06365967, -0.029724121, 0.01789856, 0.021911621, 0.023483276, 0.03186035, -0.003982544, 0.04714966, -0.038085938, -0.027801514, -0.032104492, 0.02079773, -0.0087890625, -0.03982544, 0.017242432, -0.027160645, -0.012367249, -0.017791748, 0.030334473, 0.0541687, -0.008636475, 0.025115967, -0.057678223, -0.011703491, -0.009674072, -0.059539795, 0.035888672, -0.01398468, -0.0036621094, 0.053375244, -0.027297974, 0.041809082, 0.019714355, 0.047210693, 0.04284668, 0.015548706, 0.014518738, 0.0008497238, 0.02015686, -0.040740967, 0.024551392, -0.030944824, 0.0023727417, -0.038726807, -0.012451172, -0.082092285, -0.0024929047, 0.039276123, 0.027374268, -0.004447937, 0.0154800415, -0.005455017, -0.0019741058, 0.030578613, 0.0146865845, 0.05883789, 0.01272583, -0.005924225, 0.00869751, -0.040649414, 0.02456665, 0.045684814, -0.0045814514, -0.020690918, -0.02720642, -0.013786316, 0.020721436, 0.009033203, -0.0022468567, -0.024887085, -0.004611969, -0.04473877, 0.026611328, -0.0070610046, 0.02897644, 0.060180664, 0.0068130493, 0.018676758, -0.024368286, -0.01689148, -0.024505615, -0.038513184, -0.00041484833, 0.012496948, -0.054870605, 0.009391785, -0.017745972, -0.008926392, -0.010032654, 0.049682617, 0.01461792, -0.044647217, -0.036468506, 0.014259338, 0.035949707, 0.02331543, 0.009803772, -0.043029785, -0.03640747, -0.025253296, 0.042877197, -0.007873535, 0.022888184, -0.011428833, 0.049224854, -0.022872925, -0.025283813, 0.026123047, -0.018951416, -0.00017476082, 0.027450562, -0.010520935, 0.04248047, -0.011886597, -0.033996582, 0.005004883, 0.014305115, -0.0715332, -0.01701355, 0.028442383, 0.018692017, 0.013687134, 0.06341553, 0.0206604, -0.01260376, -0.037475586, -0.040496826, 0.028533936, 0.02720642, -0.016830444, 0.04360962, -0.06008911, -0.050933838, 0.059631348, -0.038208008, 0.10308838, -0.041168213, -0.014556885, -0.03152466, 0.058776855, -0.00982666, -0.05419922, 0.0013666153, -0.020050049, -0.01689148, 0.0022335052, -0.0077285767, -0.041259766, -0.029022217, -0.0014543533, 0.0068969727, 0.013343811, 0.00058698654, -0.0056114197, -0.017486572, -0.08319092, -0.00039052963, -0.029556274, 0.04144287, -0.035736084, -0.0015563965, -0.01737976, 0.008491516, -0.0029411316, -0.03302002, -0.029342651, -0.019866943, -0.020706177, -0.040039062, 0.012969971, 0.0037574768, -0.026489258, -0.022735596, -0.025466919, 0.0027122498, -0.031951904, 0.020080566, 0.027236938, -0.041503906, -0.042266846, 0.00630188, -0.026443481, 0.05633545, 0.0053634644, -0.012771606, 0.03668213, 0.016540527, -0.03289795, -0.020248413, 0.0025920868, 0.025222778, 0.0074424744, -0.08947754, 0.023284912, 0.0048713684, 0.04043579, -0.042419434, -0.01876831, 0.03161621, 0.025299072, 0.0027427673, 0.024002075, 0.033935547, 0.014099121, 0.010574341, -0.001704216, 0.0037117004, -0.048034668, -0.03515625, -0.0149383545, 0.040130615, 0.051208496, 0.006816864, 0.0026054382, 0.039855957, -0.023986816, -0.011222839, 0.0054512024, -0.0030822754, 0.0074310303, -0.0042877197, 0.014823914, -0.031158447, -0.006576538, -0.03793335, 0.008682251, -0.011177063, -0.004085541, 0.00025439262, 0.021148682, -0.035247803, 0.05380249, -0.033966064, -0.05886841, 0.054229736, 0.021896362, 0.00907135, -0.0018482208, 0.014503479, 0.0012598038, 0.007347107, -0.001578331, -0.0050582886, 0.015357971, 0.018005371, -0.04815674, 0.003036499, -0.052642822, -0.038879395, -0.005882263, -0.029815674, 0.032196045, -0.021514893, 0.008003235, -0.016403198, -0.015151978, -0.00705719, 0.02696228, 0.013381958, -0.024002075, -0.047943115, -0.020736694, 0.04876709, -0.019210815 ], "summary": [ 0.0021953583, -0.009185791, -0.02468872, 0.008552551, -0.032592773, -0.025527954, -0.00674057, -0.033721924, -0.00944519, -0.014099121, 0.028884888, 0.010848999, -0.021728516, -0.051208496, 0.037628174, -0.012229919, -0.018249512, 0.049926758, -0.008956909, -0.041015625, 0.010406494, -0.03692627, -0.06011963, -0.020812988, 0.02684021, 0.017654419, -0.016220093, 0.028442383, 0.042114258, 0.027938843, 0.022445679, -0.061584473, 0.026687622, -0.0040016174, 0.0052833557, -0.0039749146, -0.00069856644, -0.00041246414, -0.013870239, 0.032684326, -0.024856567, 0.005050659, -0.012893677, -0.04977417, -0.02557373, -0.0046081543, -0.035827637, -0.04208374, 0.036315918, 0.014793396, -0.00021374226, 0.05267334, 0.0073509216, 0.029296875, -0.025131226, -0.019729614, -0.026565552, -0.043548584, 0.025665283, 0.030426025, 0.024520874, -0.040618896, 0.01878357, -0.023880005, 0.009292603, -0.040771484, 0.005130768, 0.012870789, 0.040618896, 0.031677246, 0.010292053, 0.014816284, 0.040161133, 0.0025157928, -0.012435913, 0.0004196167, 0.019119263, 0.030670166, 0.032287598, -0.02305603, -0.005493164, -0.016448975, 0.037475586, -0.012489319, 0.003730774, -0.011871338, -0.011558533, 0.010177612, -0.009132385, -0.046783447, -0.015090942, -0.04046631, -0.046417236, 0.024414062, -0.0045051575, -0.050720215, 0.018936157, 0.028427124, -0.015975952, -0.041870117, 0.016815186, -0.021881104, -0.030578613, -0.013015747, -0.04837036, 0.022598267, 0.013809204, -0.036193848, -0.07745361, 0.018356323, -0.04031372, -0.084228516, -0.017349243, -0.034942627, 0.007259369, -0.023406982, -0.047180176, 0.05645752, 0.014404297, -0.0022888184, 0.00067710876, 0.0076293945, 0.04840088, -0.0055618286, 0.005821228, 0.00046253204, -0.043426514, -0.027145386, -0.05722046, 0.07147217, 0.038391113, 0.01689148, -0.07147217, -0.04711914, -0.07922363, -0.01550293, -0.010223389, -0.020950317, -0.00056505203, 0.0073242188, 0.021347046, -0.010925293, 0.07006836, 0.013916016, 0.0044822693, 0.03475952, 0.04925537, 0.005771637, -0.042419434, -0.045440674, 0.00042676926, 0.03286743, 0.021621704, -0.028152466, 0.011039734, -0.047180176, -0.07086182, 0.0037956238, 0.036895752, 0.022476196, 0.012611389, -0.0345459, -0.0017108917, 0.037841797, -0.019210815, 0.022079468, -0.02142334, -0.014411926, 0.010063171, 0.0096206665, 0.018112183, 0.051696777, 0.0018091202, -0.035217285, -0.004776001, -0.059783936, 0.028869629, 0.036468506, 0.019927979, -0.012023926, 0.004085541, -0.011169434, 0.06628418, 0.010513306, -0.029541016, -0.007873535, 0.015014648, 0.035125732, 0.01461792, 0.018234253, -0.005016327, 0.0055503845, -0.03918457, -0.03414917, -0.016464233, -0.0046043396, 0.0038070679, -0.0005941391, -0.0013027191, 0.022476196, 0.031280518, -0.012069702, 0.019302368, -0.017349243, -0.029251099, 0.0055236816, -0.0134887695, 0.018371582, -0.027648926, 0.0031356812, 0.029876709, -0.0019817352, -0.028366089, 0.02406311, -0.025939941, -0.036499023, -0.0050811768, -0.031143188, -0.00919342, -0.055511475, 0.014503479, 0.015640259, 0.0046081543, 0.046173096, 0.004337311, 0.0060157776, -0.012496948, 0.004055023, 0.042877197, 0.011497498, 0.049438477, -0.020202637, -0.010925293, 0.038604736, 0.00010371208, -0.002483368, -0.016494751, -0.062927246, 0.02986145, 0.03466797, 0.034576416, 0.0021533966, -0.010887146, 0.0038261414, 0.0004284382, 0.010131836, 0.04864502, -0.03338623, 0.018981934, 0.017471313, -0.02029419, -0.044555664, 0.044006348, -0.049346924, -0.0020866394, 0.026412964, -0.0070343018, 0.005252838, -0.025512695, 0.0289917, -0.0045280457, 0.021591187, 0.030258179, -0.011932373, -0.03652954, -0.04425049, -0.03564453, -0.028152466, 0.021087646, -0.03942871, 0.014961243, -0.09039307, -0.005420685, -0.008491516, -0.014259338, -0.003818512, -0.05105591, 0.024536133, 0.036621094, -0.015266418, -0.0017547607, 0.02418518, 0.011497498, -0.015945435, 0.03074646, 0.011711121, 0.0119018555, -0.017150879, 0.010551453, 0.057861328, 0.084106445, -0.026519775, -0.028289795, -0.021514893, -0.054992676, -0.031951904, -0.03111267, 0.006591797, 0.027053833, -0.036193848, -0.035217285, 0.026748657, 0.01146698, -0.020095825, 0.0035572052, 0.0814209, 0.014289856, 0.018875122, 0.011932373, -0.015029907, 0.008918762, 0.00415802, 0.022583008, -0.01687622, 0.01486969, 0.022155762, 0.006095886, 0.009086609, 0.0065612793, 0.037628174, 0.06756592, 0.025146484, -0.0012617111, -0.003660202, 0.019485474, -0.032104492, 0.015991211, -0.031707764, -0.0041656494, -0.019882202, 0.008773804, -0.027420044, -0.018951416, -0.0023517609, 0.032470703, 0.0015697479, 0.00060367584, 0.0014133453, -0.021942139, -0.03488159, 0.02357483, -0.008857727, 0.035003662, 0.031188965, -0.036315918, -0.0029087067, 0.019744873, 0.009796143, 0.027359009, -0.0032806396, 0.0043678284, -0.0446167, -0.005176544, 0.08215332, 0.029647827, -0.01928711, -0.0013828278, 0.08105469, -0.013374329, -0.016082764, 0.042755127, 0.026870728, 0.013214111, -0.052764893, -0.05645752, -0.033355713, 0.0037288666, -0.0016345978, 0.0055618286, 0.023651123, -0.00022542477, 0.019866943, -0.032196045, -0.016525269, -0.017929077, 0.011108398, 0.021087646, -0.006549835, 0.021713257, 0.0039749146, 0.06744385, 0.0435791, 0.008605957, 0.014770508, 0.09820557, 0.031021118, -0.019073486, -0.008621216, -0.0095825195, 0.0028457642, -0.045928955, -0.04107666, 0.051605225, -0.06781006, -0.025238037, 0.004512787, 0.033081055, -0.025253296, 0.12646484, -0.034179688, 0.029464722, 0.021865845, 0.030181885, 0.009132385, -0.05307007, 0.0051994324, -0.019302368, -0.01399231, 0.042907715, -0.07055664, 0.03353882, -0.041412354, 0.026138306, -0.07220459, -0.026794434, -0.041015625, 0.0030174255, 0.006626129, 0.006072998, -0.032684326, -0.016464233, 0.04257202, -0.033935547, -0.0072135925, 0.031143188, 0.021911621, 0.010528564, -0.019165039, 0.026275635, -0.014709473, 0.01663208, -0.040893555, -0.0079956055, -0.034210205, -0.04083252, -0.024978638, -0.03338623, -0.0018310547, -0.017410278, -0.028900146, -0.014312744, -0.054718018, -0.073913574, -0.011787415, -0.032043457, -0.02444458, -0.04031372, -0.02758789, -0.020568848, -0.0017662048, -0.033416748, -0.009544373, -0.0011920929, 0.031280518, -0.011802673, 0.07141113, 0.059783936, 0.0058250427, -0.01663208, 0.028396606, -0.017150879, 0.008163452, 0.0046539307, -0.03817749, 0.034362793, 0.050048828, -0.04446411, 0.028305054, 0.02079773, -0.018707275, 0.042053223, -0.024002075, 0.003501892, 0.014579773, 0.013114929, -0.01360321, -0.011909485, 0.027313232, -0.027496338, 0.004119873, 0.0059890747, 0.010932922, 0.029205322, -0.029586792, -0.026184082, 0.01675415, -0.077941895, -0.037963867, 0.005783081, -0.020355225, -0.025619507, -0.036499023, 0.013885498, -0.023513794, -0.04067993, 0.01473999, -0.0146865845, 0.038085938, 0.016357422, -0.017547607, -0.02204895, -0.007881165, -0.023529053, 0.0026760101, 0.008758545, 0.037078857, 0.025314331, -0.00008499622, -0.016830444, 0.0009393692, 0.03186035, -0.029571533, 0.010772705, -0.0076408386, 0.02558899, 0.023742676, 0.06506348, 0.0047340393, 0.041900635, -0.018951416, 0.031707764, 0.0881958, -0.028411865, 0.008132935, 0.06915283, -0.027999878, -0.02670288, 0.01373291, -0.0019836426, -0.009628296, -0.018341064, -0.034820557, -0.031066895, 0.018295288, 0.05593872, 0.023742676, -0.025726318, -0.012748718, 0.046569824, 0.040008545, -0.02142334, -0.05441284, -0.03543091, 0.05734253, -0.010856628, 0.004047394, -0.025024414, 0.018997192, -0.010276794, -0.001127243, -0.0061683655, -0.0019416809, -0.01108551, -0.009635925, -0.0317688, -0.0039901733, -0.035369873, 0.013114929, -0.010101318, 0.022445679, 0.011436462, 0.006980896, -0.003616333, -0.0022697449, -0.007659912, 0.0181427, -0.030075073, -0.06567383, 0.02619934, -0.02015686, -0.029296875, -0.022842407, 0.032318115, 0.011360168, 0.012023926, -0.017608643, -0.0206604, 0.029891968, 0.009788513, 0.015350342, -0.0076904297, 0.0069084167, -0.0070610046, 0.047576904, -0.026443481, 0.029876709, 0.010635376, -0.0019407272, 0.006374359, 0.019546509, -0.00002759695, 0.00034713745, -0.024841309, -0.07104492, 0.0423584, 0.01902771, 0.036102295, -0.011161804, -0.019821167, 0.03265381, -0.021835327, 0.022460938, 0.01676941, 0.014533997, -0.002948761, 0.039489746, -0.0635376, 0.08013916, -0.029083252, -0.030929565, 0.033050537, 0.025222778, -0.029083252, -0.01184082, -0.054016113, 0.016418457, 0.0029773712, -0.01725769, 0.00598526, 0.0034828186, 0.050323486, -0.016952515, 0.030914307, 0.048980713, 0.024978638, -0.034606934, -0.0135269165, 0.0049972534, -0.017623901, -0.019622803, -0.024215698, 0.0012130737, -0.04095459, -0.0020580292, -0.0055770874, -0.0039405823, -0.01259613, -0.0335083, -0.01927185, -0.003458023, 0.05407715, -0.0022563934, -0.024856567, -0.061584473, -0.013900757, -0.0040893555, -0.018173218, -0.0084991455, -0.016586304, -0.044433594, 0.024932861, 0.01423645, -0.027908325, 0.02923584, 0.027008057, -0.0027751923, 0.040039062, 0.012680054, -0.028167725, -0.060791016, -0.051208496, -0.06781006, 0.0051116943, -0.071899414, 0.02116394, -0.013168335, -0.041900635, 0.031982422, -0.031463623, 0.010650635, 0.0068359375, -0.06518555, -0.039367676, -0.0008482933, 0.047302246, -0.023498535, -0.016418457, 0.018112183, -0.038116455, -0.026275635, -0.021759033, -0.05606079, 0.051116943, -0.03186035, -0.0059165955, 0.007396698, 0.023483276, 0.0074768066, -0.0020999908, 0.041625977, -0.053497314, -0.025299072, 0.016159058, -0.035949707, -0.056793213, -0.031555176, -0.011520386, -0.04034424, 0.00013399124, -0.04598999, -0.012382507, -0.0075149536, 0.021987915, -0.0015687943, -0.046722412, 0.005054474, 0.009361267, -0.015808105, -0.01007843, -0.0112838745, -0.018508911, -0.017913818, -0.0501709, -0.020492554, -0.034423828, 0.019485474, 0.036743164, 0.0259552, 0.041412354, 0.031982422, -0.0023384094, -0.009506226, 0.02609253, 0.007762909, 0.014404297, 0.012054443, -0.040252686, 0.030090332, 0.004299164, -0.012641907, 0.02734375, 0.056732178, -0.038726807, 0.0140686035, 0.03857422, 0.0025749207, 0.04953003, -0.020187378, 0.027786255, -0.044799805, -0.0039253235, -0.005859375, 0.03982544, -0.0110321045, -0.016342163, 0.025222778, 0.014015198, -0.0046844482, 0.023971558, -0.0065612793, 0.035095215, 0.01134491, -0.04925537, -0.008460999, 0.0024986267, -0.030792236, 0.028549194, 0.05731201, -0.017166138, -0.024246216, -0.019241333, 0.0062942505, -0.032592773, -0.0032958984, 0.0038986206, 0.02798462, 0.03314209, 0.018127441, 0.012710571, -0.038848877, -0.029556274, -0.012435913, -0.006374359, -0.020202637, 0.09362793, -0.027862549, -0.0146865845, -0.043182373, 0.011871338, 0.053771973, 0.023147583, 0.03390503, 0.0011463165, -0.025054932, 0.009468079, -0.005252838, -0.00073862076, -0.0037631989, -0.007762909, -0.0074386597, -0.0037708282, 0.021362305, 0.030670166, 0.0041236877, -0.0059165955, -0.021713257, 0.013542175, 0.007575989, 0.0042266846, -0.008674622, 0.07196045, -0.031234741, -0.0048675537, -0.0015468597, -0.038757324, -0.0463562, -0.025238037, 0.076660156, -0.010574341, 0.012107849, 0.008651733, 0.013191223, 0.018325806, -0.046569824, -0.026916504, -0.010818481, 0.010650635, -0.035827637, 0.020858765, 0.032073975, 0.0045318604, 0.0368042, 0.013702393, 0.020324707, -0.03048706, 0.03564453, 0.025543213, -0.022109985, -0.068603516, -0.05819702, 0.057861328, -0.05368042, 0.051239014, 0.035614014, 0.038726807, -0.0012197495, 0.007904053, 0.060821533, -0.007297516, -0.014045715, -0.003282547, -0.050720215, 0.018920898, -0.015426636, 0.0028438568, -0.0012760162, -0.031982422, -0.015571594, 0.015594482, 0.04675293, 0.038269043, -0.05697632, -0.0077056885, 0.051849365, -0.024291992, -0.017807007, 0.025726318, -0.05090332, -0.038330078, -0.080444336, -0.014503479, 0.029510498, -0.012718201, -0.0362854, 0.06463623, -0.010688782, -0.0039520264, 0.008354187, -0.060455322, -0.027435303, 0.02255249, 0.0463562, 0.05722046, -0.010681152, -0.011787415, 0.017990112, 0.024276733, -0.037902832, 0.011352539, 0.018295288, 0.06329346, 0.010826111, 0.026260376, -0.037200928, -0.019836426, 0.0357666, -0.007408142, 0.03604126, -0.03277588, 0.012741089, 0.042816162, -0.034301758, 0.016159058, 0.05557251, 0.023345947, 0.059692383, -0.052337646, 0.033935547, -0.020004272, -0.009246826, -0.090270996, 0.014427185, 0.07574463, -0.024993896, -0.0079193115, 0.03086853, -0.0051078796, -0.059265137, 0.03189087, 0.0005450249, -0.026855469, 0.041778564, -0.02658081, -0.018615723, 0.008590698, 0.0025596619, -0.022415161, -0.009719849, 0.037200928, 0.017456055, -0.0423584, 0.044525146, 0.003862381, 0.016113281, -0.03552246, -0.050842285, -0.002653122, 0.073913574, 0.0014066696, 0.008460999, 0.01209259, -0.01108551, 0.016708374, 0.050689697, 0.030685425, -0.005329132, -0.0019197464, 0.01335907, -0.0063171387, -0.036010742, 0.002571106, -0.017532349, 0.020767212, 0.005207062, -0.017349243, 0.076538086, 0.021499634, -0.03704834, -0.061309814, -0.06842041, -0.083740234, 0.016723633, -0.052947998, 0.03466797, -0.046447754, 0.011375427, -0.01576233, 0.014572144, 0.005996704, 0.0158844, 0.039978027, 0.01651001, -0.021102905, -0.020339966, 0.008972168, 0.0019874573, 0.006793976, -0.0059394836, 0.06451416, -0.014625549, 0.031311035, 0.0011959076, -0.032318115, 0.009544373, -0.020370483, 0.0073280334, -0.03062439, -0.039093018, 0.008682251, -0.06695557, -0.0030097961, -0.039489746, -0.052734375, 0.025512695, 0.0063476562, 0.014251709, -0.026031494, -0.062347412, -0.006122589, -0.001162529, -0.04928589, -0.034454346, -0.034729004, 0.04147339, -0.014732361, -0.029434204, 0.014144897, -0.041503906, 0.007888794, 0.03918457, 0.010559082, 0.012786865, 0.010665894, 0.013725281, 0.020767212, -0.033233643, -0.01979065, -0.030029297, -0.055267334, 0.0046081543, -0.037841797, 0.024246216, 0.018798828, 0.020263672, 0.083740234, -0.0084991455, 0.025680542, 0.0647583, 0.047973633, 0.031188965, 0.0040512085, 0.050445557, 0.04095459, -0.005558014 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07689v1
MART: Improving LLM Safety with Multi-round Automatic Red-Teaming
Suyu Ge, Chunting Zhou, Rui Hou, Madian Khabsa, Yi-Chia Wang, Qifan Wang, Jiawei Han, Yuning Mao
cs.CL
Red-teaming is a common practice for mitigating unsafe behaviors in Large Language Models (LLMs), which involves thoroughly assessing LLMs to identify potential flaws and addressing them with responsible and accurate responses. While effective, manual red-teaming is costly, and existing automatic red-teaming typically discovers safety risks without addressing them. In this paper, we propose a Multi-round Automatic Red-Teaming (MART) method, which incorporates both automatic adversarial prompt writing and safe response generation, significantly increasing red-teaming scalability and the safety of the target LLM. Specifically, an adversarial LLM and a target LLM interplay with each other in an iterative manner, where the adversarial LLM aims to generate challenging prompts that elicit unsafe responses from the target LLM, while the target LLM is fine-tuned with safety aligned data on these adversarial prompts. In each round, the adversarial LLM crafts better attacks on the updated target LLM, while the target LLM also improves itself through safety fine-tuning. On adversarial prompt benchmarks, the violation rate of an LLM with limited safety alignment reduces up to 84.7% after 4 rounds of MART, achieving comparable performance to LLMs with extensive adversarial prompt writing. Notably, model helpfulness on non-adversarial prompts remains stable throughout iterations, indicating the target LLM maintains strong performance on instruction following.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07689v1
2023-11-13T19:13:29
2023-11-13T19:13:29
{ "title": [ -0.041778564, 0.0023097992, -0.05731201, -0.05984497, -0.019851685, 0.00079345703, -0.061920166, 0.00806427, -0.03643799, 0.015266418, -0.024261475, 0.047210693, -0.030639648, -0.037841797, 0.019851685, -0.014808655, -0.01071167, -0.026489258, -0.049987793, -0.04537964, -0.030441284, -0.07348633, 0.018661499, 0.018722534, 0.038116455, 0.0050735474, -0.043762207, -0.036010742, 0.026947021, -0.011856079, 0.013763428, -0.017501831, 0.028076172, 0.015327454, 0.015075684, 0.018753052, -0.014465332, 0.018859863, -0.010795593, 0.047729492, 0.021087646, -0.02482605, 0.033325195, -0.017822266, -0.026672363, 0.046417236, -0.036254883, -0.010307312, -0.014556885, 0.031829834, -0.0015983582, 0.030075073, -0.0029830933, 0.05670166, 0.003929138, -0.03186035, -0.045837402, -0.008529663, 0.03012085, 0.062042236, 0.010147095, -0.0496521, 0.013015747, -0.049835205, -0.022766113, -0.0065574646, -0.029541016, 0.0003569126, 0.05508423, 0.027420044, 0.0016517639, -0.0016345978, -0.0063667297, 0.028198242, -0.009162903, -0.024093628, 0.036132812, 0.020507812, 0.0357666, 0.02420044, -0.0090408325, -0.009803772, -0.015716553, -0.017807007, -0.0028209686, -0.0049934387, -0.006591797, -0.0020275116, 0.018203735, -0.04534912, -0.0012359619, 0.048980713, 0.005241394, 0.0077590942, -0.042907715, -0.037963867, 0.01991272, 0.07116699, -0.012229919, -0.03353882, -0.049804688, 0.027404785, -0.089538574, -0.012031555, -0.015670776, -0.02041626, 0.008583069, -0.009635925, -0.013824463, 0.04446411, -0.06149292, 0.028335571, 0.0129470825, -0.00856781, 0.04144287, -0.0057754517, -0.017349243, 0.035095215, -0.012535095, 0.0061836243, -0.014579773, -0.0060310364, 0.013305664, 0.004032135, 0.013450623, 0.0013895035, -0.034118652, 0.0008263588, 0.0002374649, 0.016113281, -0.015411377, 0.042938232, -0.037078857, -0.056365967, -0.04031372, 0.017837524, 0.0033283234, 0.0016145706, -0.0011262894, -0.019226074, 0.018585205, -0.0010795593, 0.021850586, -0.007881165, -0.0054092407, 0.017608643, 0.04547119, 0.011581421, -0.021560669, -0.044433594, -0.01109314, 0.025558472, -0.01348114, -0.019454956, 0.022384644, -0.037902832, -0.08404541, 0.0012807846, 0.076660156, 0.033111572, 0.021514893, 0.0053253174, -0.0039482117, -0.019088745, 0.0146102905, -0.04168701, -0.022705078, 0.026016235, 0.020126343, 0.039215088, 0.016067505, -0.03756714, 0.017623901, -0.016738892, -0.010871887, 0.006942749, 0.034942627, 0.022628784, 0.049224854, -0.069885254, -0.019821167, -0.018493652, 0.07623291, -0.014533997, -0.03845215, -0.028015137, 0.004207611, 0.01071167, 0.031036377, 0.004558563, 0.006313324, 0.0033874512, -0.03930664, -0.020629883, -0.0345459, -0.02760315, -0.004360199, 0.009849548, -0.00008755922, 0.026947021, 0.031082153, -0.01763916, -0.013694763, -0.00016999245, -0.0013456345, -0.03173828, 0.014701843, 0.015686035, 0.00019741058, 0.03955078, 0.033813477, -0.0287323, -0.03817749, 0.049224854, -0.013061523, -0.06707764, -0.0137786865, -0.010116577, 0.012779236, -0.013977051, 0.03060913, 0.012016296, 0.028381348, 0.007545471, -0.009635925, 0.028717041, -0.010627747, 0.00687027, 0.056884766, 0.026977539, 0.0859375, -0.024993896, 0.0113220215, 0.04498291, 0.010414124, -0.0129470825, 0.011421204, -0.08166504, 0.024383545, 0.0345459, -0.0026073456, -0.004878998, -0.004234314, 0.07366943, 0.020568848, 0.00006920099, 0.009407043, 0.036224365, 0.020751953, -0.0013246536, 0.020767212, 0.009170532, 0.07385254, 0.014335632, -0.0010108948, 0.07293701, -0.034606934, -0.011360168, -0.028778076, -0.0006890297, 0.01398468, -0.064086914, -0.040161133, -0.010177612, -0.019744873, -0.020767212, -0.013618469, 0.0129470825, 0.01285553, -0.010612488, 0.024261475, -0.03878784, 0.012580872, 0.0096206665, -0.032104492, -0.020645142, -0.011070251, 0.028945923, 0.0073890686, -0.038360596, -0.018218994, 0.011024475, 0.035095215, -0.016723633, 0.021896362, -0.0074005127, 0.004425049, -0.030395508, -0.04812622, -0.023406982, 0.03201294, -0.0039901733, -0.0178833, -0.011680603, 0.020004272, -0.019683838, 0.05996704, 0.085876465, -0.037597656, 0.036376953, -0.057861328, -0.009742737, 0.020095825, -0.02394104, 0.019226074, 0.036071777, 0.026367188, 0.0016336441, -0.0045547485, 0.0022182465, -0.033935547, 0.000064730644, 0.019607544, 0.0017824173, -0.0057678223, -0.02609253, 0.010566711, 0.0066604614, 0.02482605, 0.016815186, 0.049957275, -0.039398193, -0.008361816, 0.01486969, -0.024551392, -0.04071045, 0.023345947, -0.016281128, -0.020339966, 0.013160706, 0.01940918, 0.018249512, -0.04788208, 0.014198303, 0.014320374, 0.012893677, -0.0019359589, 0.029067993, -0.033355713, -0.038970947, -0.025268555, -0.034973145, -0.007949829, -0.03062439, -0.027160645, -0.027252197, -0.019958496, 0.008743286, -0.051757812, -0.01725769, 0.046569824, -0.03060913, 0.011383057, 0.007858276, 0.067871094, -0.02029419, -0.054504395, 0.04434204, 0.036254883, -0.008476257, 0.039978027, 0.017593384, -0.001666069, -0.06726074, -0.025497437, -0.029373169, -0.021362305, -0.025802612, 0.04168701, 0.061187744, -0.06149292, 0.034057617, -0.043121338, -0.0024547577, 0.026168823, 0.0015544891, -0.051940918, -0.06347656, -0.007144928, -0.043945312, -0.0008983612, -0.0029067993, -0.0023155212, 0.017318726, 0.07659912, 0.005092621, -0.02142334, -0.0041122437, 0.022720337, 0.003414154, -0.0057678223, -0.030883789, -0.015075684, -0.008796692, -0.021057129, -0.006477356, 0.016830444, -0.0009083748, -0.038116455, 0.0022182465, 0.018630981, 0.0008020401, 0.0018177032, 0.014266968, -0.066833496, 0.025161743, -0.01914978, -0.012054443, 0.02859497, 0.004508972, -0.0025310516, -0.0036773682, -0.0014762878, -0.05505371, 0.023162842, -0.041290283, -0.08099365, -0.018692017, -0.04953003, 0.07019043, 0.053833008, -0.055755615, -0.030944824, 0.015068054, -0.03894043, 0.02470398, 0.021530151, 0.018814087, 0.039916992, 0.020370483, 0.0016517639, 0.00712204, 0.058929443, 0.016342163, -0.090270996, -0.04837036, -0.04537964, 0.00472641, 0.05154419, -0.081848145, -0.031555176, 0.00440979, -0.0066947937, 0.03289795, 0.016220093, -0.027313232, -0.020523071, -0.056549072, -0.05731201, 0.020889282, -0.041748047, 0.020004272, -0.054138184, 0.037628174, -0.0146865845, 0.059417725, 0.009803772, 0.017333984, 0.014282227, -0.00881958, -0.004501343, -0.0023880005, -0.046295166, 0.0024604797, -0.012672424, 0.026031494, -0.010650635, -0.022598267, -0.03060913, 0.0068588257, -0.048980713, 0.0657959, 0.03353882, 0.0023555756, -0.010246277, -0.03491211, -0.0021476746, 0.017669678, -0.016693115, -0.02557373, -0.008804321, 0.013259888, -0.0043945312, -0.07159424, -0.0070991516, 0.0063667297, -0.08013916, -0.039642334, -0.012214661, -0.030410767, -0.091796875, -0.009460449, -0.011711121, -0.03024292, -0.021453857, 0.037963867, -0.0011129379, 0.004447937, 0.011833191, -0.059295654, 0.00050497055, 0.035095215, -0.049865723, -0.0037498474, 0.038513184, -0.005634308, -0.014328003, -0.016342163, -0.0005979538, 0.027526855, 0.03756714, -0.0013504028, -0.0206604, -0.010414124, -0.015686035, 0.027954102, 0.027893066, -0.032806396, 0.03048706, 0.015319824, 0.060150146, -0.0017318726, -0.023086548, 0.03451538, 0.05407715, 0.025894165, -0.09686279, -0.019989014, -0.03253174, -0.03451538, 0.025009155, 0.05117798, 0.032043457, 0.016403198, -0.005874634, 0.005760193, -0.011985779, -0.0067749023, -0.002204895, -0.015472412, -0.013618469, -0.037597656, -0.0056037903, 0.0076141357, -0.019622803, 0.037902832, -0.035614014, 0.05532837, 0.029403687, 0.033355713, -0.029083252, -0.03164673, -0.023666382, -0.043548584, -0.078125, 0.0042419434, 0.021194458, -0.019119263, 0.0020503998, 0.029647827, 0.02104187, 0.00919342, -0.015686035, -0.02003479, 0.016845703, 0.0095825195, 0.013648987, -0.023101807, -0.008773804, -0.020309448, -0.06173706, -0.041656494, 0.03640747, 0.04852295, 0.013404846, -0.013679504, 0.006351471, 0.032104492, 0.03955078, 0.008377075, 0.032226562, -0.010932922, -0.023330688, 0.032318115, 0.008491516, -0.017944336, -0.0018615723, 0.014778137, -0.013786316, -0.024780273, 0.014640808, -0.023086548, -0.035491943, -0.047332764, 0.03591919, 0.00774765, 0.062408447, 0.023223877, 0.012840271, 0.031021118, 0.020050049, -0.016418457, 0.0006108284, -0.04598999, 0.035369873, 0.0031223297, 0.019958496, 0.013320923, -0.006877899, -0.0039787292, 0.036743164, 0.001578331, -0.008720398, 0.017684937, -0.02798462, 0.016601562, 0.012779236, 0.020584106, -0.042114258, -0.012588501, 0.014602661, -0.010299683, 0.036254883, -0.03543091, 0.028701782, -0.008872986, 0.009300232, -0.0015506744, -0.019180298, 0.015899658, -0.013908386, 0.0066070557, -0.048461914, -0.0051498413, 0.024749756, 0.01058197, -0.031341553, -0.008522034, -0.003501892, 0.0052261353, 0.0011081696, 0.038970947, 0.0054855347, -0.0231781, 0.004535675, -0.017990112, -0.020828247, -0.022705078, -0.06286621, -0.03967285, 0.008728027, 0.036346436, 0.042663574, 0.03225708, -0.08325195, -0.0070610046, 0.003545761, 0.001124382, -0.002658844, -0.061431885, -0.0037269592, 0.024139404, -0.0012025833, -0.010856628, 0.038391113, 0.023956299, -0.0010786057, 0.049865723, -0.0010108948, 0.00548172, 0.044189453, -0.06274414, -0.039245605, -0.0102005005, 0.02458191, -0.01209259, 0.0368042, 0.017410278, -0.013954163, -0.04473877, 0.03149414, 0.029846191, -0.003982544, -0.01727295, -0.026382446, 0.036590576, -0.02243042, -0.007484436, 0.006351471, -0.0061149597, -0.05117798, -0.03363037, -0.029571533, -0.054779053, 0.010467529, -0.01676941, -0.036346436, -0.006576538, 0.05960083, -0.0036125183, 0.0022449493, 0.012413025, -0.0051727295, -0.00605011, 0.015151978, 0.02407837, 0.02848816, -0.017578125, -0.003332138, -0.021148682, 0.018875122, 0.050201416, -0.052581787, -0.013504028, -0.010414124, -0.06689453, -0.06640625, -0.01234436, 0.000749588, 0.012191772, -0.045562744, -0.01991272, -0.041503906, -0.021835327, 0.013381958, -0.002067566, -0.07476807, -0.0017690659, -0.028244019, -0.03326416, 0.013381958, 0.0067443848, -0.039398193, 0.022247314, 0.010185242, 0.0049934387, 0.03793335, -0.008598328, 0.0101623535, -0.022613525, -0.043304443, 0.005519867, 0.03869629, -0.008323669, -0.013458252, 0.02508545, 0.0112838745, 0.07269287, -0.005710602, -0.0038642883, 0.04925537, -0.0069618225, -0.04168701, -0.037322998, 0.00028204918, -0.038848877, 0.06274414, 0.0009775162, -0.032104492, -0.022399902, -0.011711121, -0.018508911, -0.016967773, -0.00040078163, -0.049560547, -0.019943237, -0.038330078, -0.044036865, -0.02456665, -0.0015201569, -0.04776001, -0.015640259, -0.044006348, -0.08111572, 0.10076904, 0.033569336, 0.020141602, -0.0413208, 0.004009247, 0.009460449, 0.0019102097, 0.020858765, -0.015144348, -0.00907135, -0.05239868, 0.010360718, 0.029724121, 0.041656494, -0.041015625, 0.036010742, -0.009933472, 0.061462402, 0.0050964355, 0.011627197, 0.018066406, 0.033966064, 0.003578186, -0.00091695786, -0.007423401, -0.026824951, 0.02330017, -0.034057617, -0.012145996, -0.037628174, -0.026306152, -0.086242676, 0.016967773, 0.01109314, 0.02671814, -0.033050537, 0.010398865, 0.0031642914, -0.046203613, 0.008728027, -0.066223145, 0.039031982, 0.0118255615, -0.0071907043, 0.03567505, 0.022247314, -0.0009198189, 0.020126343, -0.008918762, 0.03338623, 0.0002477169, -0.0012483597, 0.007671356, -0.014839172, 0.0039405823, -0.025848389, 0.007820129, -0.009712219, 0.0077590942, -0.000049471855, 0.05670166, 0.03125, 0.011810303, 0.0178833, -0.0009880066, -0.03390503, 0.022338867, -0.026138306, 0.03111267, 0.055511475, -0.03591919, 0.03491211, -0.014770508, -0.05050659, 0.02684021, 0.013633728, 0.03475952, -0.04663086, -0.03390503, -0.0054016113, 0.031280518, 0.015930176, 0.058044434, -0.02293396, 0.0026569366, 0.014854431, -0.013267517, 0.033416748, 0.053497314, 0.03552246, 0.04840088, -0.002796173, -0.00077676773, 0.0128479, -0.017486572, -0.005619049, 0.017745972, 0.015029907, 0.07165527, -0.024246216, -0.02848816, 0.023727417, 0.014328003, -0.0927124, -0.011413574, 0.040496826, -0.0035934448, 0.04937744, 0.041137695, 0.027450562, -0.006626129, -0.004322052, -0.06335449, 0.0005965233, 0.033691406, 0.00033283234, 0.014381409, -0.021606445, -0.040161133, 0.05331421, -0.012718201, 0.0657959, -0.05911255, 0.018981934, -0.04083252, 0.022109985, -0.014808655, -0.037475586, -0.0059165955, -0.046966553, 0.004032135, 0.0075569153, 0.0155181885, -0.04574585, -0.043426514, 0.010917664, 0.057861328, 0.00983429, -0.0211792, -0.01235199, 0.0020561218, -0.033081055, -0.025375366, -0.03375244, 0.0059165955, -0.013366699, -0.034820557, -0.016174316, 0.018539429, 0.009414673, -0.006931305, -0.025985718, 0.037750244, -0.022323608, 0.026519775, -0.03729248, -0.025650024, -0.026138306, -0.039733887, 0.0054893494, 0.04144287, -0.04208374, 0.017410278, 0.042633057, -0.022460938, -0.08282471, -0.0110321045, -0.013366699, 0.0569458, 0.009544373, -0.028030396, 0.03857422, 0.015930176, -0.04095459, -0.022277832, -0.03213501, -0.01133728, -0.030258179, -0.016235352, -0.00920105, 0.02279663, 0.03086853, -0.03289795, -0.02835083, -0.00053596497, 0.051696777, 0.004310608, 0.074401855, 0.005882263, -0.008033752, -0.004142761, 0.010063171, -0.006793976, -0.01247406, 0.009780884, 0.021911621, 0.024093628, 0.057128906, -0.015975952, 0.028030396, 0.02180481, -0.00969696, 0.0021095276, 0.0022716522, -0.004673004, -0.033599854, 0.0035324097, -0.002462387, -0.043518066, -0.01965332, 0.020019531, 0.058654785, -0.059051514, -0.03173828, -0.0052986145, 0.016494751, -0.02381897, -0.062469482, -0.027740479, -0.012084961, -0.008224487, 0.03253174, -0.01953125, 0.058288574, -0.044555664, 0.0014772415, -0.006904602, 0.016464233, 0.0058288574, 0.030273438, 0.0015468597, -0.008590698, 0.0028762817, -0.045776367, -0.07043457, -0.015625, -0.011619568, -0.011413574, -0.03866577, 0.052764893, 0.031234741, -0.05215454, 0.016418457, 0.061187744, 0.04928589, -0.0074653625, -0.012084961, 0.009315491, 0.054718018, -0.015777588 ], "summary": [ -0.026504517, -0.01096344, -0.026443481, -0.049438477, -0.043273926, 0.013458252, -0.07928467, -0.0005440712, -0.03479004, 0.017715454, -0.0019388199, 0.035858154, -0.038513184, -0.03274536, 0.03768921, -0.035583496, -0.0069389343, -0.04550171, -0.03555298, -0.03640747, 0.014427185, -0.034484863, -0.010925293, -0.037841797, 0.032684326, -0.05496216, -0.004070282, -0.015945435, 0.044006348, 0.019500732, 0.02293396, -0.014183044, -0.0011577606, 0.036468506, -0.03225708, -0.0045204163, -0.021591187, 0.016036987, -0.014587402, 0.03237915, 0.01689148, -0.01146698, 0.06317139, 0.00043964386, -0.0045166016, 0.05783081, -0.026504517, -0.03314209, 0.01751709, 0.008026123, -0.024276733, 0.02760315, -0.021072388, 0.02809143, -0.013053894, -0.010375977, -0.046051025, 0.02645874, 0.029846191, 0.08483887, 0.021026611, -0.018569946, -0.025436401, -0.07885742, -0.0096206665, 0.009773254, -0.00096416473, -0.020080566, 0.03668213, 0.01914978, -0.008728027, -0.016601562, 0.0054969788, -0.04473877, -0.0031528473, 0.020126343, -0.011566162, -0.018173218, 0.029556274, -0.0025672913, -0.02142334, 0.02645874, 0.0069503784, -0.033721924, -0.005836487, -0.0051956177, -0.022567749, -0.0107803345, 0.013717651, -0.04156494, 0.00415802, 0.012901306, -0.03338623, 0.0129776, -0.00381279, -0.06536865, 0.015419006, 0.017959595, -0.006374359, -0.0006670952, 0.012321472, -0.024505615, 0.010612488, -0.018432617, -0.0289917, -0.008865356, -0.013771057, -0.014572144, 0.0006132126, 0.04260254, -0.027313232, -0.012207031, 0.011428833, -0.036132812, 0.0016736984, 0.0046463013, -0.024139404, 0.04650879, 0.013221741, 0.031555176, -0.002822876, 0.011520386, 0.0135269165, -0.009666443, -0.0032215118, 0.016494751, 0.0024528503, -0.030349731, 0.0231781, -0.012687683, -0.02420044, 0.026397705, 0.012031555, -0.007587433, -0.0027103424, -0.013061523, 0.014144897, 0.0011816025, -0.0046958923, -0.0031337738, 0.030731201, -0.03933716, -0.011955261, 0.020492554, 0.002483368, 0.037261963, 0.018173218, 0.008460999, 0.00025749207, -0.055389404, 0.014144897, -0.02986145, -0.0027179718, -0.01663208, 0.017593384, -0.04437256, -0.055541992, 0.013305664, 0.06323242, 0.030044556, 0.009483337, 0.0077552795, 0.029022217, 0.024765015, 0.007698059, -0.038269043, -0.018997192, -0.009788513, 0.012046814, 0.023345947, 0.015838623, 0.0044784546, -0.010009766, -0.0025749207, 0.007858276, -0.020126343, 0.00982666, 0.01272583, 0.03451538, -0.038909912, -0.013442993, -0.021530151, 0.080200195, -0.029907227, -0.007820129, -0.04788208, 0.0015268326, -0.00015687943, 0.028198242, 0.016906738, 0.017959595, -0.036834717, -0.04397583, -0.018157959, -0.008125305, 0.020736694, -0.024856567, 0.007881165, -0.0012321472, 0.0039901733, 0.068725586, -0.008392334, -0.008369446, -0.05117798, -0.066833496, -0.025497437, -0.005180359, 0.023742676, 0.001996994, 0.013175964, 0.020553589, -0.041412354, -0.022827148, 0.08239746, 0.00605011, -0.039489746, -0.0060195923, -0.021194458, 0.025650024, -0.021499634, 0.04888916, 0.060028076, 0.026794434, 0.016204834, -0.014144897, -0.010215759, -0.015136719, 0.01953125, 0.051879883, -0.0027637482, 0.085998535, -0.02357483, 0.03515625, 0.05432129, 0.017700195, 0.0015125275, 0.04449463, -0.09295654, 0.01197052, 0.029067993, 0.014190674, 0.038909912, -0.019210815, 0.040374756, -0.0005645752, -0.041107178, 0.00030493736, 0.027633667, -0.005634308, 0.01322937, 0.008728027, -0.0047721863, 0.030883789, -0.0013246536, -0.015106201, 0.049835205, -0.032318115, -0.042053223, -0.03286743, -0.0059394836, 0.029937744, -0.1182251, -0.06021118, -0.023101807, -0.0025920868, -0.064453125, -0.017623901, -0.027572632, 0.005607605, -0.05404663, 0.020706177, -0.046020508, 0.011619568, -0.025970459, -0.036376953, -0.007709503, -0.01449585, 0.035583496, 0.007194519, -0.026473999, -0.00409317, 0.03213501, 0.0074768066, -0.023330688, 0.018463135, 0.037109375, -0.012374878, -0.049743652, -0.012145996, 0.014030457, 0.027542114, 0.02973938, 0.0043182373, 0.008506775, 0.019042969, -0.001452446, 0.060821533, 0.052612305, -0.02696228, 0.0019931793, 0.017532349, 0.020187378, -0.01373291, -0.028778076, 0.003944397, 0.03463745, 0.03692627, -0.013053894, -0.0007839203, 0.0071868896, -0.03604126, -0.0121536255, 0.032348633, 0.05810547, -0.01776123, -0.0138168335, 0.0056495667, 0.039276123, -0.0019454956, 0.019897461, 0.10046387, -0.008201599, 0.00818634, 0.027954102, -0.025100708, -0.059265137, 0.06097412, -0.024291992, 0.010772705, -0.019042969, -0.013519287, -0.016830444, -0.038146973, 0.005455017, 0.016998291, -0.005508423, -0.004169464, -0.00028538704, -0.022979736, -0.018417358, 0.011199951, -0.04751587, -0.0035648346, -0.005908966, -0.014884949, -0.02571106, -0.0010156631, 0.0050811768, 0.009605408, -0.016357422, 0.04421997, -0.028320312, 0.01612854, 0.025543213, 0.060424805, -0.015457153, -0.041412354, 0.05709839, 0.039978027, -0.0011901855, 0.029067993, 0.03378296, 0.008338928, -0.049468994, -0.025680542, -0.025970459, -0.0027923584, -0.008338928, 0.064331055, 0.047454834, 0.0052757263, 0.049346924, -0.0647583, -0.00737381, 0.019607544, -0.015670776, 0.011253357, -0.026763916, 0.008964539, 0.014907837, 0.022369385, 0.024536133, 0.014427185, 0.03527832, 0.11102295, 0.0035953522, 0.025894165, 0.027511597, 0.03225708, 0.0045661926, -0.03491211, -0.055145264, 0.0128479, -0.0010519028, -0.017150879, -0.00894928, -0.0050811768, -0.034454346, -0.02861023, -0.0058135986, 0.018447876, -0.0012340546, -0.0064811707, -0.0053215027, -0.03778076, 0.016708374, -0.008331299, -0.0039596558, 0.016235352, -0.045318604, 0.02885437, -0.037200928, 0.010108948, -0.062469482, 0.020462036, -0.051849365, -0.02722168, -0.0062713623, -0.060333252, 0.058166504, 0.039276123, -0.0093688965, -0.021987915, 0.0058059692, -0.023986816, 0.049560547, -0.011108398, 0.008262634, 0.05166626, 0.032989502, -0.0034999847, 0.027511597, 0.045318604, 0.0524292, -0.06939697, -0.016357422, -0.018722534, -0.033691406, 0.07312012, -0.10809326, -0.051574707, -0.010818481, -0.024032593, 0.003698349, 0.016326904, -0.03817749, -0.0211792, -0.0715332, -0.012084961, 0.016311646, -0.038848877, 0.0070114136, -0.016433716, 0.03930664, -0.011558533, 0.056030273, 0.0012111664, 0.01751709, 0.07507324, -0.025939941, -0.00724411, 0.0035057068, -0.04257202, 0.020507812, 0.0028038025, 0.011688232, -0.021774292, 0.0031356812, -0.03479004, -0.0039253235, -0.0024700165, 0.013504028, 0.013023376, 0.012756348, -0.024291992, -0.029174805, 0.030426025, 0.037719727, -0.026641846, -0.04473877, -0.040161133, 0.0127334595, -0.009666443, -0.058166504, -0.016311646, 0.00091171265, -0.06970215, -0.058654785, -0.013450623, 0.01512146, -0.068725586, 0.016998291, 0.0026836395, -0.0058403015, -0.007007599, 0.056030273, -0.004432678, 0.013168335, -0.01663208, -0.06842041, 0.010528564, -0.007751465, -0.014434814, 0.04574585, 0.00068950653, 0.014823914, 0.019577026, 0.01979065, -0.0018377304, 0.01033783, 0.043060303, -0.0069999695, -0.041290283, -0.019348145, -0.0031967163, 0.008552551, 0.043548584, -0.035308838, 0.036010742, -0.009277344, 0.06896973, 0.04067993, -0.03616333, 0.009681702, 0.037475586, 0.030700684, -0.08795166, -0.026306152, -0.03866577, -0.022369385, 0.035583496, 0.05770874, 0.013023376, -0.011817932, -0.004371643, -0.031234741, -0.03366089, -0.011672974, 0.034179688, 0.020050049, -0.025054932, -0.043121338, -0.006969452, 0.059539795, -0.01676941, 0.025100708, -0.09472656, 0.01713562, 0.006336212, 0.0362854, -0.05026245, -0.06756592, 0.00089740753, -0.06536865, -0.051696777, 0.012001038, 0.023254395, -0.003036499, 0.0055236816, -0.0060272217, 0.00044679642, 0.019470215, 0.02027893, -0.044525146, 0.05178833, 0.02545166, 0.007610321, -0.015037537, -0.02911377, -0.007583618, -0.026992798, -0.036376953, 0.018310547, 0.017623901, -0.044952393, -0.012969971, -0.021133423, 0.0037822723, 0.024414062, 0.044189453, 0.018569946, 0.019958496, -0.028442383, -0.0026836395, 0.0041999817, -0.010063171, -0.02116394, 0.02468872, -0.019104004, -0.011001587, 0.036224365, -0.031555176, -0.014968872, -0.032043457, 0.045959473, -0.007259369, 0.064208984, -0.0029850006, 0.005218506, 0.033691406, 0.017303467, -0.0038204193, 0.0121536255, -0.0045547485, 0.0132369995, 0.0062942505, -0.013832092, 0.038024902, -0.020355225, -0.025924683, -0.011054993, -0.014015198, 0.008079529, 0.018859863, -0.029769897, 0.011054993, 0.017929077, 0.013038635, -0.02078247, -0.033477783, 0.014678955, -0.010070801, 0.004085541, 0.012107849, -0.019012451, -0.010986328, 0.013069153, -0.009773254, -0.023513794, 0.01121521, -0.013191223, 0.0030593872, -0.04156494, 0.0012331009, 0.006702423, -0.0074272156, -0.009346008, -0.009628296, -0.0047302246, -0.031463623, 0.013023376, 0.0062026978, -0.009635925, -0.03463745, 0.0010519028, -0.029312134, -0.016662598, 0.012084961, -0.02973938, -0.04940796, 0.0019426346, 0.025222778, 0.039733887, 0.059814453, -0.03024292, 0.036102295, 0.0027923584, -0.0017642975, 0.013221741, -0.055114746, -0.042816162, 0.0049743652, -0.005393982, -0.0335083, 0.029693604, 0.017410278, -0.04147339, 0.040008545, -0.032318115, 0.023147583, 0.025115967, -0.07409668, -0.04147339, -0.022506714, -0.007881165, 0.02684021, 0.01991272, 0.022369385, 0.007980347, -0.033050537, 0.016036987, 0.019958496, -0.029678345, 0.016418457, -0.021652222, 0.03878784, -0.031555176, -0.0011548996, -0.020858765, 0.021850586, -0.06866455, -0.07342529, -0.008369446, -0.07702637, -0.0138549805, -0.056610107, -0.015472412, 0.025939941, 0.021881104, -0.011741638, 0.0064811707, 0.028121948, -0.017807007, 0.011543274, 0.009757996, 0.002292633, 0.034179688, -0.02748108, -0.006389618, -0.0040283203, -0.031280518, 0.05831909, -0.037322998, -0.017501831, -0.03378296, -0.0647583, -0.060943604, -0.022994995, -0.00069379807, 0.045684814, -0.046325684, -0.005153656, -0.027526855, -0.028961182, 0.018478394, -0.030059814, -0.06976318, -0.019805908, -0.029510498, -0.052734375, 0.030731201, -0.028396606, -0.07183838, 0.02961731, 0.025482178, -0.016723633, 0.05859375, -0.005168915, 0.010002136, 0.000008106232, -0.02381897, -0.0006532669, 0.02835083, -0.02142334, 0.0063591003, 0.02482605, 0.0138549805, 0.019195557, 0.031204224, 0.011932373, 0.03579712, 0.0038776398, -0.02947998, -0.020980835, 0.016647339, -0.016067505, 0.03060913, -0.0066719055, -0.035003662, -0.0014247894, 0.011528015, -0.0053901672, -0.034332275, -0.0115356445, -0.04498291, -0.013130188, -0.004764557, -0.022979736, 0.0073776245, -0.0034332275, -0.04748535, -0.03086853, -0.04373169, -0.061279297, 0.11798096, 0.046966553, -0.0064353943, -0.011154175, 0.0053520203, 0.00522995, -0.0036411285, 0.03262329, 0.012924194, -0.002565384, -0.0491333, 0.0055618286, 0.022994995, 0.062042236, -0.05630493, 0.029922485, 0.039001465, 0.054901123, -0.00724411, -0.011932373, -0.0037250519, 0.0054779053, -0.014549255, -0.01789856, -0.0041656494, -0.026611328, 0.037109375, -0.013648987, -0.040985107, -0.059753418, -0.050231934, -0.022613525, 0.042755127, -0.038116455, 0.0107421875, -0.0011587143, 0.01473999, 0.005722046, -0.02720642, -0.043273926, -0.05215454, 0.005908966, 0.057647705, 0.011230469, 0.03656006, -0.0087509155, -0.015144348, 0.020217896, -0.023910522, 0.058929443, 0.013969421, 0.0031337738, 0.03665161, -0.021896362, -0.022521973, -0.048980713, 0.029663086, -0.022766113, -0.0077667236, 0.001832962, 0.028198242, 0.014625549, -0.0076179504, 0.041046143, 0.000028431416, -0.006099701, -0.02029419, 0.016464233, -0.0036506653, -0.024887085, 0.019805908, 0.018966675, 0.013114929, -0.022705078, 0.025421143, 0.012809753, 0.029129028, -0.03137207, -0.014831543, -0.020065308, 0.018859863, 0.010948181, 0.026977539, -0.016357422, -0.022598267, -0.012969971, -0.0016174316, 0.006767273, 0.04220581, 0.015777588, 0.03375244, -0.0015325546, -0.014762878, 0.01626587, -0.039276123, 0.005508423, 0.028686523, 0.016479492, 0.024230957, 0.0011844635, -0.003353119, -0.016723633, 0.038604736, -0.06573486, 0.005630493, 0.021728516, 0.033081055, 0.086242676, 0.057037354, 0.00093221664, 0.023605347, 0.058685303, -0.04272461, 0.021987915, 0.011505127, 0.013893127, 0.0018177032, -0.022750854, -0.0018358231, 0.01574707, 0.009140015, 0.05532837, -0.047027588, 0.0099105835, -0.060516357, 0.05935669, -0.06817627, -0.044708252, 0.020050049, -0.04623413, 0.009429932, 0.0107421875, 0.033996582, -0.057128906, -0.016342163, 0.0005607605, 0.0005226135, -0.0014514923, -0.044708252, -0.02130127, 0.037322998, 0.008262634, -0.041259766, -0.032714844, 0.014671326, -0.016662598, -0.014701843, 0.042907715, 0.022109985, -0.004989624, -0.06286621, -0.036193848, 0.011947632, 0.042419434, 0.0004892349, -0.020401001, 0.0029258728, -0.029708862, -0.06137085, -0.010757446, 0.011703491, -0.057617188, 0.076538086, 0.04031372, -0.0090789795, -0.09844971, 0.01058197, 0.004421234, 0.06149292, -0.026062012, -0.015289307, 0.032043457, 0.007457733, -0.046936035, 0.0058555603, 0.013305664, 0.024337769, -0.020324707, -0.06713867, 0.021484375, -0.0036640167, 0.029083252, -0.0040626526, 0.031036377, 0.035491943, 0.05227661, 0.0022354126, -0.007850647, -0.004081726, -0.018585205, 0.022201538, 0.01927185, 0.0039863586, -0.02029419, -0.02029419, 0.008148193, 0.018447876, 0.019500732, -0.011764526, 0.007850647, 0.04260254, -0.035949707, -0.012519836, -0.0211792, 0.012748718, -0.03677368, -0.011703491, -0.015411377, -0.03894043, 0.0085372925, 0.029708862, 0.035003662, -0.028274536, 0.0011377335, -0.03564453, 0.006095886, -0.0000015497208, -0.05432129, -0.041931152, 0.016479492, -0.01902771, -0.0023860931, -0.009239197, 0.006252289, -0.008934021, 0.029418945, 0.013137817, 0.0018043518, 0.017868042, 0.015731812, -0.01361084, -0.04019165, -0.012420654, -0.07342529, -0.045562744, -0.04046631, -0.012779236, -0.009269714, -0.01537323, 0.023956299, 0.06896973, -0.039916992, 0.025756836, 0.061431885, 0.066467285, 0.017288208, 0.017044067, 0.025741577, 0.04159546, -0.006717682 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07687v1
Language Model-In-The-Loop: Data Optimal Approach to Learn-To-Recommend Actions in Text Games
Arjun Vaithilingam Sudhakar, Prasanna Parthasarathi, Janarthanan Rajendran, Sarath Chandar
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior performance in language understanding benchmarks. CALM, a popular approach, leverages linguistic priors of LLMs -- GPT-2 -- for action candidate recommendations to improve the performance in text games in Jericho without environment-provided actions. However, CALM adapts GPT-2 with annotated human gameplays and keeps the LLM fixed during the learning of the text based games. In this work, we explore and evaluate updating LLM used for candidate recommendation during the learning of the text based game as well to mitigate the reliance on the human annotated gameplays, which are costly to acquire. We observe that by updating the LLM during learning using carefully selected in-game transitions, we can reduce the dependency on using human annotated game plays for fine-tuning the LLMs. We conducted further analysis to study the transferability of the updated LLMs and observed that transferring in-game trained models to other games did not result in a consistent transfer.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07687v1
2023-11-13T19:12:49
2023-11-13T19:12:49
{ "title": [ 0.0044059753, -0.008056641, 0.0049705505, -0.018661499, -0.02178955, -0.007965088, 0.0023975372, -0.0045204163, 0.013885498, 0.026382446, -0.045135498, 0.023010254, -0.020019531, -0.007980347, -0.027450562, -0.015319824, -0.018630981, 0.03225708, -0.026748657, -0.05709839, 0.00059366226, -0.06347656, 0.020446777, 0.05126953, 0.034118652, -0.010307312, -0.058441162, 0.0121154785, -0.025054932, -0.025100708, -0.0059776306, 0.006160736, 0.03286743, -0.0024280548, -0.0031147003, -0.012031555, -0.045410156, 0.007286072, -0.00982666, 0.01713562, 0.025009155, -0.017623901, -0.05633545, -0.006793976, -0.06896973, 0.01499176, -0.043273926, 0.0077400208, -0.034088135, 0.020751953, 0.0049934387, 0.028335571, 0.0078086853, 0.023513794, 0.013450623, -0.043670654, -0.045959473, 0.010398865, 0.017333984, 0.055358887, 0.030090332, -0.017623901, 0.008613586, -0.01096344, 0.0011463165, -0.034118652, -0.0017137527, 0.03289795, 0.062286377, 0.04486084, -0.008743286, 0.012214661, 0.0039520264, -0.014427185, -0.05291748, 0.013031006, 0.049682617, 0.0079193115, 0.013290405, -0.038085938, -0.018859863, -0.0059394836, -0.0050239563, -0.046020508, 0.013282776, -0.06298828, -0.01776123, 0.0047416687, -0.0413208, -0.07623291, -0.011978149, -0.00793457, -0.044281006, -0.0033054352, -0.036895752, -0.027770996, -0.014831543, 0.028305054, 0.014129639, -0.023025513, -0.043029785, 0.028198242, -0.056518555, -0.016693115, 0.019454956, 0.043273926, -0.025482178, -0.015182495, 0.014274597, 0.02607727, -0.012496948, -0.008102417, 0.049957275, 0.040008545, -0.0025730133, -0.04486084, -0.012825012, 0.060821533, 0.003206253, 0.05456543, 0.00680542, -0.014961243, 0.004562378, -0.01272583, 0.014015198, -0.02293396, -0.04650879, 0.021148682, -0.027297974, 0.0680542, 0.011604309, 0.047576904, -0.12213135, -0.0982666, -0.10247803, 0.030532837, -0.019195557, 0.0031929016, -0.0061569214, 0.01663208, 0.006465912, -0.009605408, 0.045562744, 0.0143966675, 0.04736328, -0.0042686462, 0.03503418, -0.003955841, -0.022521973, -0.00459671, -0.0030155182, 0.018798828, -0.0032958984, -0.0018405914, -0.023590088, -0.026763916, -0.1159668, -0.009002686, 0.050964355, 0.012458801, -0.019073486, 0.0056991577, 0.013061523, 0.020385742, 0.042114258, -0.019958496, 0.007820129, 0.015007019, 0.008369446, 0.043670654, -0.006565094, 0.026489258, 0.013412476, -0.027328491, -0.007091522, -0.0129470825, 0.015045166, 0.009628296, 0.012794495, -0.034210205, 0.014892578, -0.008659363, 0.016738892, 0.033935547, -0.04840088, -0.033111572, -0.0070343018, -0.029129028, 0.053253174, -0.005722046, -0.004337311, 0.026504517, -0.0209198, -0.058410645, -0.04095459, -0.013435364, 0.040161133, 0.029281616, -0.002286911, 0.029541016, -0.027877808, 0.0012693405, -0.033935547, -0.009140015, -0.043121338, -0.04220581, -0.015823364, 0.031951904, -0.008651733, 0.029708862, 0.041809082, 0.006652832, -0.04345703, 0.053527832, 0.0045204163, -0.029434204, 0.019424438, -0.013748169, 0.0031642914, -0.020843506, 0.014015198, -0.000103890896, 0.0082473755, 0.037353516, 0.020507812, -0.002040863, 0.0065345764, -0.016204834, 0.039154053, 0.010116577, 0.048339844, -0.013458252, 0.03375244, 0.039794922, -0.0135269165, -0.031188965, -0.034118652, -0.021224976, 0.02279663, 0.018203735, -0.008491516, -0.009269714, 0.0031833649, 0.06604004, 0.0026416779, -0.011856079, 0.013954163, 0.035583496, 0.048034668, 0.0703125, 0.04647827, 0.012763977, 0.033966064, 0.0067596436, 0.034118652, 0.046661377, 0.008552551, -0.0055351257, -0.017349243, 0.0129776, 0.014099121, 0.000020205975, -0.00046277046, 0.00472641, -0.07385254, 0.021697998, -0.045654297, -0.011451721, -0.0012483597, -0.0015163422, 0.026626587, -0.0034236908, 0.013725281, -0.018127441, -0.027999878, -0.03515625, -0.023208618, 0.04598999, 0.010414124, -0.07598877, 0.012268066, 0.032714844, 0.07006836, -0.0056114197, 0.023208618, 0.01398468, 0.032226562, -0.013557434, -0.019683838, -0.020004272, 0.014205933, 0.036193848, -0.007736206, 0.0015258789, 0.020751953, -0.011039734, 0.07019043, 0.09667969, -0.045013428, 0.05505371, -0.039794922, -0.00037193298, 0.006038666, -0.019515991, -0.011978149, 0.020339966, 0.024291992, -0.008102417, -0.04763794, 0.014152527, -0.055419922, -0.010665894, 0.009880066, -0.005130768, -0.049346924, -0.038330078, -0.008117676, -0.018859863, -0.06274414, -0.03189087, 0.1038208, -0.04626465, -0.014717102, 0.0022735596, -0.028442383, -0.029006958, 0.009788513, -0.025360107, -0.015090942, 0.05026245, 0.018600464, 0.025421143, -0.05316162, -0.0107421875, -0.015945435, 0.0143585205, -0.009315491, -0.006942749, -0.01197052, 0.007896423, 0.004711151, -0.007675171, 0.012840271, -0.03213501, -0.009010315, -0.044799805, 0.022567749, 0.0050849915, -0.02734375, 0.0020637512, 0.019561768, -0.018554688, 0.0015659332, 0.043792725, 0.083984375, -0.023330688, -0.04321289, 0.08544922, 0.05230713, 0.014923096, 0.016525269, 0.04623413, 0.015090942, -0.06561279, -0.032104492, -0.043029785, -0.03277588, 0.01083374, -0.01222229, 0.027313232, -0.04360962, -0.014076233, -0.025054932, -0.008224487, 0.0037345886, 0.02468872, 0.060455322, -0.0010662079, -0.022247314, 0.020187378, -0.008560181, 0.015457153, -0.049987793, 0.010856628, 0.11010742, 0.003068924, 0.004383087, 0.011383057, 0.05227661, 0.0056114197, 0.01285553, -0.035949707, -0.0129776, -0.0007133484, 0.04724121, -0.00035262108, -0.03768921, 0.0067825317, -0.10723877, -0.0016717911, 0.027175903, 0.004562378, -0.01828003, 0.038635254, -0.05340576, 0.032409668, 0.012413025, -0.039611816, 0.027389526, 0.013534546, 0.018249512, -0.0013208389, 0.013755798, -0.014755249, 0.0019044876, -0.04827881, -0.08526611, 0.043518066, -0.053344727, -0.03201294, 0.01776123, -0.028503418, -0.028045654, -0.01902771, -0.0019798279, 0.05255127, 0.019882202, -0.0019931793, 0.022979736, -0.009971619, -0.0046539307, -0.021316528, -0.04083252, -0.042419434, -0.008178711, 0.016281128, 0.00894928, 0.05239868, -0.0016870499, 0.014709473, -0.0736084, -0.014030457, -0.01940918, 0.028305054, -0.007434845, -0.0287323, -0.022644043, -0.06329346, -0.026397705, -0.016113281, -0.022979736, 0.018814087, -0.010932922, 0.010421753, -0.0026893616, 0.026153564, 0.0015859604, 0.0032463074, -0.02067566, -0.0014305115, 0.025894165, -0.000098347664, -0.029205322, 0.00049591064, 0.021240234, -0.024597168, 0.020095825, -0.015235901, -0.019226074, 0.02078247, -0.026916504, 0.019927979, 0.0087509155, -0.011550903, -0.0024108887, -0.034362793, 0.0011434555, -0.0013475418, 0.0067367554, -0.015274048, 0.013198853, 0.004623413, 0.03857422, -0.06225586, -0.007598877, -0.0061950684, -0.10369873, -0.013626099, 0.0063171387, -0.01222229, -0.020339966, -0.012062073, 0.015274048, -0.016021729, -0.01751709, -0.0024051666, -0.018508911, 0.015930176, 0.008453369, -0.05758667, 0.011116028, 0.059753418, -0.00056886673, 0.012931824, 0.07373047, -0.02255249, -0.016159058, -0.009841919, 0.026443481, 0.05706787, 0.03817749, 0.023406982, 0.0065307617, 0.041046143, -0.011260986, -0.011940002, 0.05883789, 0.023834229, -0.0073242188, -0.0012302399, 0.0023460388, 0.030517578, -0.040771484, 0.054901123, 0.0061569214, -0.0107040405, -0.06573486, 0.016281128, 0.011688232, -0.0034980774, 0.012771606, -0.033599854, -0.001411438, 0.025314331, 0.016082764, 0.028366089, -0.006038666, -0.035186768, 0.06689453, 0.03829956, 0.02053833, -0.006122589, -0.020614624, 0.051940918, 0.011528015, 0.0071525574, -0.040863037, 0.006126404, 0.0067100525, -0.023666382, -0.02796936, -0.002023697, -0.057434082, -0.024505615, -0.05215454, -0.067993164, -0.029708862, 0.029678345, -0.015258789, 0.015174866, 0.042816162, 0.008117676, -0.013671875, -0.02368164, 0.035247803, -0.00026798248, -0.015396118, -0.066345215, 0.00086307526, -0.011421204, -0.06085205, -0.022735596, -0.057037354, -0.05722046, 0.028152466, 0.0059013367, -0.043762207, 0.020523071, 0.027359009, 0.08905029, 0.050231934, -0.010139465, -0.06585693, 0.01725769, -0.05154419, -0.017578125, 0.01889038, -0.007511139, -0.01474762, -0.01689148, 0.029968262, 0.001958847, -0.023620605, -0.029144287, 0.028121948, -0.020843506, 0.02633667, 0.0013961792, 0.038085938, 0.033111572, 0.0016269684, 0.0181427, 0.009979248, -0.02645874, 0.014205933, 0.019348145, 0.045684814, -0.0035934448, 0.011314392, 0.0289917, -0.011619568, 0.037078857, -0.012268066, -0.018875122, -0.0021190643, 0.0060768127, -0.019348145, 0.041534424, -0.015113831, -0.01889038, -0.0001770258, -0.0011854172, 0.007713318, -0.062072754, 0.074035645, 0.021774292, -0.012718201, 0.044433594, -0.0033473969, 0.019760132, 0.0057868958, 0.00077724457, -0.05029297, -0.035736084, 0.0019426346, 0.019348145, -0.02003479, 0.019577026, 0.015090942, -0.0025730133, 0.030914307, 0.032714844, 0.020828247, -0.0018491745, -0.018844604, 0.0027236938, 0.00365448, -0.037078857, -0.046447754, -0.02720642, -0.010322571, 0.0037593842, -0.034484863, 0.024902344, -0.03817749, -0.013465881, -0.01550293, -0.01550293, 0.016983032, -0.07165527, -0.0014925003, 0.02558899, 0.013954163, 0.011810303, -0.0034980774, -0.010238647, -0.011978149, 0.032409668, -0.017089844, 0.024291992, 0.030593872, -0.03930664, 0.028640747, 0.02331543, 0.029205322, 0.022109985, 0.019119263, 0.00044608116, 0.01499939, -0.02319336, 0.03353882, -0.04248047, -0.0385437, -0.013298035, -0.006477356, 0.0063819885, 0.009819031, 0.013923645, -0.0050735474, -0.015899658, -0.017807007, -0.017227173, -0.034698486, -0.052001953, -0.0012493134, -0.06365967, -0.011932373, -0.06903076, -0.008110046, -0.061553955, -0.0008854866, 0.012718201, 0.009010315, -0.013595581, 0.021240234, 0.034576416, -0.014419556, 0.019302368, 0.004096985, 0.015174866, 0.03881836, 0.020629883, -0.041229248, -0.012542725, -0.014785767, -0.04840088, -0.04876709, 0.020462036, 0.01398468, 0.0056991577, -0.0056266785, -0.02394104, -0.007408142, 0.011070251, 0.010101318, 0.038635254, -0.038024902, 0.04046631, -0.0061073303, -0.013084412, -0.0022583008, 0.024551392, -0.0105896, -0.0005660057, 0.015594482, -0.020401001, 0.035583496, -0.0124435425, 0.010620117, -0.0075569153, -0.055999756, 0.012336731, 0.01939392, -0.0017671585, -0.009216309, 0.033569336, 0.029800415, 0.015960693, -0.019500732, -0.0035800934, 0.051483154, -0.041900635, 0.015434265, -0.006919861, 0.009613037, -0.030715942, 0.0395813, 0.0071754456, 0.006664276, -0.056671143, -0.051361084, -0.0317688, 0.01826477, 0.03363037, 0.009803772, 0.025405884, -0.009506226, 0.043426514, -0.029846191, -0.0071258545, -0.056030273, 0.012145996, -0.014282227, -0.01007843, 0.01499176, 0.014877319, 0.01739502, -0.020721436, -0.0012998581, -0.0057411194, 0.010955811, -0.015075684, -0.043701172, 0.022338867, -0.01637268, 0.00019419193, 0.020263672, 0.021087646, -0.028030396, 0.023376465, -0.03643799, 0.059020996, 0.06573486, 0.04852295, 0.060455322, 0.008590698, 0.010650635, 0.029647827, 0.031219482, -0.016952515, 0.01751709, -0.045532227, 0.004146576, -0.05935669, -0.0046958923, -0.09448242, 0.048706055, -0.00881958, 0.03414917, 0.024429321, 0.0039596558, 0.011405945, 0.02583313, 0.041015625, 0.027389526, 0.062072754, 0.003643036, 0.024429321, -0.021484375, -0.072265625, 0.04156494, 0.05697632, 0.007972717, -0.032409668, 0.011482239, -0.026184082, 0.00092697144, 0.026123047, 0.008262634, -0.03475952, -0.011703491, -0.04336548, 0.020935059, -0.0027637482, 0.0055122375, 0.036621094, 0.048461914, -0.06304932, 0.018676758, 0.028778076, -0.01889038, -0.033996582, 0.011398315, 0.020523071, -0.038085938, 0.03756714, -0.0138549805, -0.026687622, -0.011116028, 0.015365601, 0.043914795, -0.06341553, -0.029678345, 0.029373169, 0.030593872, -0.012145996, 0.046203613, -0.023406982, -0.040802002, -0.022155762, 0.023590088, -0.00056934357, 0.04562378, 0.008865356, 0.0124435425, -0.04147339, 0.003271103, 0.0025424957, 0.038757324, -0.038635254, 0.016799927, -0.07458496, 0.05718994, 0.021224976, -0.036193848, 0.032226562, 0.0067749023, -0.050567627, -0.0024757385, -0.0005955696, 0.06555176, 0.044952393, 0.060913086, -0.005836487, -0.015579224, 0.03237915, -0.047576904, 0.024353027, 0.018615723, -0.023742676, 0.01020813, -0.049468994, -0.038269043, 0.016067505, -0.0713501, 0.022262573, -0.050476074, -0.01675415, -0.007446289, 0.0065612793, 0.034332275, -0.028915405, -0.05505371, -0.013755798, -0.030380249, 0.0007343292, 0.0030059814, -0.020248413, -0.025939941, 0.008201599, 0.021484375, 0.01499939, 0.0026988983, 0.014335632, -0.014045715, -0.049682617, -0.0071640015, -0.027618408, 0.038726807, -0.026550293, -0.012908936, 0.014854431, 0.007881165, 0.0029125214, -0.08581543, -0.056274414, -0.02998352, 0.04537964, -0.070739746, 0.018463135, 0.015487671, -0.012374878, -0.009536743, 0.01902771, -0.0053749084, -0.008102417, -0.030288696, 0.025863647, 0.00049829483, -0.06100464, -0.022018433, -0.040252686, -0.02029419, 0.005355835, -0.010116577, -0.015319824, 0.033477783, -0.05279541, -0.037872314, -0.007331848, 0.016998291, 0.007575989, -0.02557373, 0.0016880035, 0.02709961, 0.043823242, -0.053100586, -0.0154418945, -0.005393982, 0.050811768, 0.0069999695, 0.018249512, 0.014785767, -0.009788513, 0.015960693, 0.0012245178, 0.0030879974, -0.019165039, -0.0017623901, -0.008743286, 0.037719727, 0.041778564, -0.0042533875, -0.013725281, 0.009796143, -0.0013751984, 0.009925842, -0.006252289, 0.0023536682, 0.008804321, -0.013046265, 0.0262146, -0.0118255615, -0.019744873, -0.05239868, 0.043914795, -0.007167816, 0.032073975, 0.001704216, 0.031585693, 0.019180298, 0.046142578, -0.028289795, -0.009162903, 0.0093688965, 0.025299072, -0.0061950684, 0.049194336, -0.026016235, -0.0006933212, -0.0068359375, 0.007282257, -0.0066375732, 0.010009766, 0.0008921623, -0.03286743, -0.001663208, -0.05508423, -0.026763916, -0.03237915, -0.042266846, 0.039398193, -0.009803772, -0.015602112, -0.004096985, -0.029220581, 0.000269413, 0.06008911, 0.006160736, -0.028839111, -0.022781372, 0.006729126, 0.06793213, -0.013450623 ], "summary": [ 0.0068626404, 0.008018494, 0.0072402954, 0.04345703, -0.04776001, -0.01411438, -0.016677856, -0.06390381, 0.011741638, 0.0043525696, -0.025100708, -0.0068244934, -0.014587402, -0.030517578, 0.020339966, -0.03225708, -0.0071907043, -0.009216309, -0.018920898, -0.026382446, 0.023925781, -0.024597168, -0.028823853, 0.0061912537, 0.023223877, -0.03186035, -0.026290894, -0.0012273788, 0.022750854, 0.015960693, 0.0029640198, -0.009162903, 0.02368164, 0.019699097, -0.056610107, 0.0068511963, -0.01651001, 0.0042304993, -0.035614014, 0.047790527, 0.026184082, -0.0063476562, 0.0026130676, -0.0066871643, -0.030563354, 0.030670166, -0.0152282715, -0.023483276, 0.02810669, -0.03237915, -0.0028133392, 0.031433105, 0.0033283234, -0.010726929, -0.032226562, -0.020736694, -0.05947876, -0.020751953, -0.010444641, 0.10900879, 0.07086182, 0.01939392, -0.028945923, -0.04071045, -0.006954193, 0.009376526, 0.024765015, -0.0032901764, 0.051483154, 0.023086548, 0.0009703636, 0.008056641, 0.032470703, -0.043792725, 0.0335083, 0.026031494, -0.017501831, 0.030029297, 0.026626587, -0.021621704, 0.007797241, 0.021347046, 0.0040016174, -0.055419922, 0.018753052, -0.03817749, -0.013038635, -0.0034694672, -0.00014781952, -0.06060791, -0.015586853, -0.016983032, -0.028213501, -0.000202775, -0.019241333, -0.04940796, -0.008430481, -0.005130768, -0.017211914, -0.019317627, 0.025878906, -0.02659607, 0.008026123, -0.01600647, -0.017593384, 0.05178833, -0.008300781, -0.057739258, -0.03387451, 0.01361084, -0.01109314, -0.0703125, 0.0073776245, -0.04119873, 0.024353027, 0.015266418, -0.018997192, 0.09552002, 0.023132324, 0.06262207, -0.0037498474, 0.017105103, -0.011810303, 0.026657104, -0.0016593933, -0.0002014637, -0.009788513, 0.0059547424, -0.01007843, 0.020584106, 0.017547607, 0.057434082, -0.06341553, -0.06317139, -0.08081055, -0.00029587746, -0.0037136078, 0.011993408, -0.02204895, 0.020141602, -0.035217285, -0.018218994, 0.044281006, -0.024414062, 0.02998352, 0.018249512, -0.0027236938, 0.01109314, 0.02960205, -0.0048446655, 0.03527832, -0.054992676, 0.021392822, -0.016967773, 0.004802704, -0.041625977, -0.03189087, -0.0017309189, 0.05126953, -0.008872986, 0.014221191, -0.015022278, -0.028259277, 0.036956787, -0.02545166, 0.02571106, 0.010681152, -0.0070381165, 0.028366089, 0.020507812, 0.008552551, 0.0033111572, 0.06976318, -0.004009247, -0.023208618, -0.011474609, 0.010253906, 0.04925537, 0.013496399, -0.045074463, -0.013534546, -0.049194336, 0.052612305, -0.015434265, 0.0014028549, -0.06488037, -0.0041542053, 0.0058059692, 0.044158936, 0.025421143, -0.03225708, -0.024902344, -0.020339966, -0.014770508, -0.038269043, -0.026885986, 0.041503906, 0.017471313, -0.023162842, 0.027709961, 0.026123047, -0.023452759, -0.014465332, -0.041870117, -0.09301758, -0.025253296, -0.01953125, 0.029266357, -0.008354187, 0.017974854, 0.03201294, 0.01914978, -0.045166016, 0.031158447, -0.0068588257, -0.036315918, 0.020324707, -0.00013661385, 0.016693115, -0.026931763, 0.036010742, 0.0009880066, 0.0018320084, 0.06536865, -0.039916992, 0.024749756, -0.014801025, 0.04171753, 0.02230835, 0.03286743, 0.08093262, -0.04940796, 0.032348633, 0.049194336, 0.0008368492, -0.027709961, 0.028869629, -0.09509277, 0.04751587, 0.040649414, 0.0143966675, 0.0035934448, -0.028671265, 0.0013475418, -0.0087509155, -0.010734558, 0.021133423, -0.0073165894, 0.010002136, 0.039276123, -0.0284729, -0.009628296, 0.029052734, -0.079833984, 0.0012292862, 0.054656982, 0.007396698, -0.041534424, 0.032836914, -0.018569946, 0.019180298, -0.034179688, -0.048828125, 0.0072746277, -0.05441284, -0.026519775, -0.027954102, -0.020385742, 0.004135132, -0.021942139, 0.034851074, 0.010513306, 0.010566711, -0.05178833, -0.02456665, -0.045654297, -0.04168701, 0.036987305, 0.048187256, -0.04852295, 0.008239746, 0.016021729, -0.013137817, -0.01133728, 0.031799316, 0.033843994, -0.002155304, 0.0020179749, 0.0032749176, 0.04547119, 0.045654297, 0.01586914, 0.007911682, -0.020111084, 0.027267456, -0.0019054413, 0.05380249, 0.044830322, -0.0128479, 0.011627197, -0.00957489, 0.022140503, -0.0016975403, -0.034210205, 0.024032593, 0.010848999, 0.04522705, 0.0137786865, 0.0037612915, 0.0023097992, -0.049957275, -0.0317688, 0.023132324, 0.095336914, -0.062805176, -0.026565552, -0.012680054, 0.032104492, 0.0065727234, 0.045318604, 0.04537964, -0.035980225, -0.0030021667, 0.036865234, -0.012466431, -0.029907227, 0.06347656, -0.010482788, 0.0037994385, 0.018066406, 0.008094788, -0.018218994, -0.037994385, -0.037109375, 0.0027275085, 0.0040130615, 0.004940033, -0.0027503967, -0.013038635, 0.004009247, 0.017562866, 0.01789856, 0.01864624, -0.016586304, -0.017227173, -0.012107849, -0.019012451, -0.010940552, 0.03366089, 0.019134521, -0.016723633, 0.031402588, 0.0009803772, 0.07751465, 0.042175293, -0.00522995, -0.023605347, 0.05340576, 0.0034217834, -0.012184143, -0.011787415, 0.058410645, 0.011123657, -0.07366943, -0.043304443, -0.01651001, -0.024902344, 0.018188477, 0.028579712, 0.027740479, 0.03741455, 0.028518677, -0.06665039, -0.021224976, -0.011955261, -0.012466431, 0.061401367, -0.011207581, 0.009300232, 0.03604126, 0.017044067, 0.022644043, -0.0077400208, 0.021942139, 0.08538818, -0.005252838, -0.025665283, -0.01436615, 0.045043945, 0.037322998, 0.00944519, -0.06500244, -0.040771484, -0.016830444, 0.005001068, 0.013137817, -0.03741455, -0.018997192, -0.042114258, -0.016342163, 0.08306885, -0.021133423, 0.020614624, 0.0023708344, -0.031402588, 0.051879883, 0.032684326, 0.029022217, 0.03491211, -0.034484863, 0.04196167, -0.03652954, 0.028961182, -0.029022217, -0.021514893, -0.030761719, -0.029464722, 0.004005432, -0.042938232, 0.02204895, 0.0062065125, 0.03869629, -0.01058197, 0.010093689, 0.028549194, 0.06756592, 0.010658264, -0.013801575, -0.011924744, 0.027297974, 0.038146973, -0.013366699, -0.007610321, -0.0036125183, -0.037902832, 0.030593872, 0.017318726, 0.0068626404, 0.050109863, -0.057525635, -0.055358887, -0.011154175, -0.060302734, -0.0068588257, -0.008277893, -0.031707764, -0.010429382, -0.078063965, -0.008369446, 0.01612854, -0.005176544, -0.00983429, 0.0043144226, 0.021850586, -0.024612427, 0.05142212, 0.009429932, 0.032104492, 0.04498291, -0.025344849, -0.006549835, -0.0049095154, -0.0362854, 0.0006804466, -0.0033092499, 0.02796936, -0.0046691895, 0.019332886, -0.013290405, -0.004798889, 0.010444641, -0.02355957, -0.007583618, -0.030654907, 0.011276245, -0.052093506, 0.024276733, 0.016296387, 0.035461426, -0.040802002, -0.05505371, 0.031433105, -0.053466797, -0.06933594, -0.029541016, 0.0046920776, -0.06921387, -0.04019165, 0.014724731, 0.052947998, 0.0010709763, 0.016235352, 0.045532227, 0.016036987, 0.0035800934, 0.024368286, -0.015319824, 0.044281006, -0.018936157, -0.061401367, 0.037902832, -0.03225708, -0.027816772, 0.04159546, 0.032409668, -0.04663086, -0.014717102, 0.046173096, 0.030044556, 0.024749756, 0.04763794, 0.026931763, -0.03050232, 0.018478394, -0.031402588, 0.0011587143, 0.024368286, -0.0013055801, -0.007911682, -0.008705139, 0.056854248, 0.021011353, 0.015022278, -0.01499176, 0.014846802, 0.03933716, -0.022842407, 0.013404846, 0.011268616, -0.013076782, 0.01373291, -0.042877197, -0.016235352, 0.027679443, 0.04031372, 0.044128418, -0.028198242, -0.032470703, 0.014320374, 0.038635254, -0.018844604, -0.010734558, -0.009773254, 0.07244873, -0.00819397, 0.007911682, -0.017807007, 0.020614624, 0.020523071, -0.01499176, -0.0018434525, 0.004802704, -0.041992188, -0.041259766, -0.038238525, -0.0003798008, -0.016983032, 0.026657104, -0.0146102905, 0.003835678, 0.024612427, 0.005722046, -0.00944519, -0.0028705597, -0.0021877289, 0.0256958, -0.07067871, -0.08972168, -0.021209717, -0.018600464, -0.057434082, -0.039093018, -0.058502197, -0.027069092, -0.03378296, 0.035308838, -0.041290283, 0.021743774, 0.0060424805, 0.08404541, 0.041046143, 0.0005373955, -0.08514404, -0.0074539185, -0.04534912, -0.0065994263, 0.023956299, -0.02394104, -0.022033691, -0.03579712, 0.01965332, 0.009849548, -0.012496948, -0.08215332, 0.01537323, 0.018875122, -0.016647339, -0.0007419586, -0.01020813, 0.015975952, 0.016967773, -0.008163452, 0.008476257, -0.0028572083, 0.0061073303, -0.031829834, -0.038726807, 0.049835205, -0.0033664703, 0.012428284, 0.010276794, 0.013267517, -0.014953613, 0.007160187, -0.0021514893, -0.024536133, -0.015792847, 0.029083252, -0.0016889572, -0.019180298, 0.025863647, -0.026855469, -0.0034389496, 0.03186035, -0.008529663, 0.014175415, 0.024017334, 0.05670166, -0.005947113, -0.02558899, 0.022323608, -0.016693115, -0.054992676, -0.05206299, -0.009338379, 0.06964111, -0.0116119385, -0.012207031, -0.033294678, -0.029083252, 0.010665894, -0.0011692047, 0.002626419, -0.046081543, -0.0006814003, -0.04486084, -0.034454346, 0.005176544, -0.024093628, -0.05291748, 0.00017046928, 0.0040779114, -0.029693604, 0.05508423, -0.0076065063, 0.008979797, 0.016784668, -0.026229858, -0.0014162064, -0.07312012, -0.027053833, -0.026535034, -0.040100098, -0.016479492, 0.026519775, -0.0028076172, -0.02003479, 0.0045280457, -0.0037994385, -0.01612854, -0.026565552, -0.052337646, -0.009590149, -0.016204834, -0.0048103333, -0.0033397675, 0.029815674, 0.01953125, 0.0059509277, -0.028747559, -0.018692017, -0.044921875, 0.004135132, 0.022018433, -0.019836426, 0.014450073, 0.051879883, 0.011451721, -0.008575439, 0.046844482, -0.011993408, -0.008857727, 0.014259338, -0.012123108, -0.05291748, -0.027786255, 0.002571106, -0.041503906, -0.0072631836, -0.04977417, 0.036071777, -0.0040893555, -0.028762817, -0.018875122, -0.017730713, 0.016098022, 0.011428833, 0.010276794, 0.011558533, 0.01651001, -0.0014982224, -0.001282692, -0.0060539246, -0.0012254715, -0.0045280457, -0.030273438, -0.021850586, 0.006401062, -0.012931824, 0.021316528, -0.02381897, 0.0009522438, -0.02027893, -0.0026416779, 0.023803711, -0.037139893, -0.055725098, 0.00028395653, -0.021408081, -0.015472412, -0.00818634, 0.023773193, -0.034332275, -0.0052337646, 0.023223877, -0.04360962, 0.018951416, -0.005874634, 0.011947632, 0.0014343262, -0.070739746, 0.029281616, 0.017120361, 0.011520386, -0.03869629, 0.045318604, 0.013771057, -0.0051498413, 0.008728027, -0.0016851425, 0.02079773, 0.0015659332, 0.0055618286, 0.011192322, 0.023712158, 0.010093689, 0.050994873, 0.0058135986, -0.00749588, -0.040863037, -0.008300781, -0.0053749084, -0.0090408325, 0.028961182, -0.036071777, 0.016921997, -0.003921509, -0.020721436, 0.032104492, -0.010322571, -0.058410645, -0.048339844, -0.03262329, -0.059661865, 0.123046875, 0.088378906, -0.038635254, 0.020553589, 0.0005002022, -0.000014543533, 0.0025615692, 0.013305664, 0.06225586, -0.00024008751, -0.02722168, -0.001991272, 0.022338867, 0.02973938, -0.055664062, -0.0040283203, 0.038360596, 0.052978516, 0.05078125, 0.0051345825, 0.016082764, 0.0015468597, 0.008575439, 0.021591187, 0.04458618, -0.004211426, 0.065979004, -0.03060913, -0.008415222, -0.059936523, -0.053253174, -0.03387451, 0.029510498, -0.015007019, 0.0072364807, 0.038604736, 0.002401352, -0.004650116, 0.022781372, -0.0038490295, 0.038909912, 0.017288208, 0.0059280396, -0.0012521744, -0.026489258, -0.009765625, 0.035308838, 0.049560547, 0.017623901, 0.0053215027, 0.0155181885, -0.003873825, 0.036621094, -0.0098724365, -0.04534912, -0.0670166, 0.03427124, -0.05819702, 0.014823914, 0.027648926, 0.059417725, -0.0010271072, 0.0068473816, -0.015136719, 0.025863647, -0.0001449585, -0.012504578, -0.031585693, 0.042877197, 0.015403748, -0.03668213, 0.040283203, -0.0021419525, -0.023452759, -0.010848999, 0.045562744, 0.04815674, -0.02809143, 0.033294678, 0.02810669, -0.0060195923, -0.050567627, 0.021636963, -0.028808594, -0.025924683, -0.024017334, -0.013900757, 0.009605408, 0.005088806, -0.001329422, 0.013633728, 0.024337769, 0.03604126, 0.0007805824, 0.0101623535, 0.019012451, 0.028244019, -0.05130005, 0.055603027, 0.045654297, -0.027938843, 0.07299805, 0.0047569275, 0.0044288635, 0.028930664, -0.02973938, 0.029953003, 0.039154053, 0.03213501, -0.028656006, -0.009132385, 0.070007324, -0.025405884, -0.024627686, -0.05014038, -0.010246277, -0.037078857, -0.003353119, 0.026855469, -0.0018253326, -0.018554688, -0.0016288757, -0.04977417, 0.028656006, -0.016082764, -0.012825012, -0.008972168, -0.014915466, -0.023864746, 0.0006580353, -0.053985596, 0.02532959, 0.040985107, -0.019241333, -0.013847351, -0.017333984, -0.004180908, -0.007587433, -0.025772095, 0.0206604, 0.017196655, -0.018234253, -0.014892578, -0.016815186, 0.043884277, -0.04824829, -0.033996582, 0.04269409, 0.004600525, 0.018798828, -0.02734375, -0.053375244, 0.044311523, 0.058624268, -0.045928955, -0.0079956055, -0.003074646, -0.021072388, -0.04385376, -0.020843506, -0.009521484, -0.03491211, -0.009208679, 0.041229248, -0.01586914, -0.060516357, -0.013244629, -0.03515625, 0.03591919, 0.033477783, -0.012886047, 0.059265137, 0.005050659, -0.043182373, -0.00088357925, -0.02508545, -0.022262573, 0.032684326, -0.005672455, -0.0018825531, 0.010177612, 0.03967285, -0.02961731, 0.0050468445, -0.0027389526, 0.00063467026, 0.0016384125, -0.021209717, -0.03540039, -0.037475586, 0.057739258, 0.034088135, 0.036010742, -0.00793457, 0.044433594, 0.013343811, 0.059387207, 0.017868042, -0.03765869, 0.031921387, 0.0060310364, -0.020233154, 0.001206398, 0.008956909, -0.009857178, 0.0008583069, -0.01525116, 0.0070228577, -0.029418945, -0.01776123, -0.031021118, 0.018234253, -0.01133728, -0.015289307, -0.0075912476, 0.01625061, -0.016571045, 0.0009765625, -0.01789856, 0.011634827, -0.008277893, 0.007835388, 0.018310547, -0.0011386871, 0.004825592, 0.022247314, -0.0121536255, -0.013404846, 0.027526855, -0.0010843277, -0.0037498474, -0.04550171, 0.01890564, -0.09814453, -0.012817383, -0.07171631, -0.036987305, 0.018035889, -0.008476257, -0.005783081, 0.04272461, -0.04196167, -0.0048103333, 0.046417236, 0.002752304, -0.043304443, 0.023040771, -0.05206299, 0.04925537, 0.013450623 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07682v1
Fuse to Forget: Bias Reduction and Selective Memorization through Model Fusion
Kerem Zaman, Leshem Choshen, Shashank Srivastava
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Model fusion research aims to aggregate the knowledge of multiple models to enhance performance by combining their weights. In this work, we study the inverse, investigating whether and how can model fusion interfere and reduce unwanted knowledge. We delve into the effects of model fusion on the evolution of learned shortcuts, social biases, and memorization capabilities in fine-tuned language models. Through several experiments covering text classification and generation tasks, our analysis highlights that shared knowledge among models is usually enhanced during model fusion, while unshared knowledge is usually lost or forgotten. Based on this observation, we demonstrate the potential of model fusion as a debiasing tool and showcase its efficacy in addressing privacy concerns associated with language models.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07682v1
2023-11-13T19:02:56
2023-11-13T19:02:56
{ "title": [ 0.009750366, 0.0022449493, -0.031463623, -0.053710938, 0.008049011, -0.0115356445, -0.026977539, -0.0262146, 0.004184723, 0.030471802, -0.021362305, 0.002439499, 0.01713562, -0.020965576, -0.037475586, -0.0016021729, -0.007232666, 0.024551392, -0.02029419, -0.035339355, -0.0019893646, -0.04827881, 0.015960693, 0.03253174, 0.030136108, -0.06512451, -0.09625244, 0.021499634, -0.029647827, -0.016418457, -0.009307861, 0.011741638, 0.044891357, 0.039794922, -0.021087646, 0.020629883, -0.035369873, 0.028640747, 0.003063202, 0.02192688, 0.021438599, -0.013839722, -0.03451538, -0.015197754, -0.049713135, 0.0064086914, -0.040039062, -0.01474762, -0.013053894, 0.028518677, -0.0028915405, 0.03704834, -0.020065308, 0.035583496, 0.022140503, -0.031555176, -0.061340332, 0.0231781, 0.02418518, 0.097595215, 0.036499023, -0.03366089, -0.0036029816, -0.041381836, -0.04724121, -0.03540039, -0.016983032, 0.023956299, 0.055541992, 0.0018901825, -0.0098724365, 0.024780273, 0.006706238, 0.02168274, -0.055786133, 0.0043182373, 0.04727173, 0.0345459, 0.028656006, -0.015853882, 0.008934021, 0.003189087, 0.00082302094, -0.024307251, -0.0034751892, -0.05895996, -0.020706177, 0.0018138885, -0.029708862, -0.048065186, -0.014663696, -0.011329651, -0.0012292862, 0.024856567, -0.030700684, -0.00894928, -0.0020961761, 0.025741577, -0.0024681091, -0.034729004, -0.025054932, 0.032073975, -0.079711914, -0.0028324127, -0.002313614, 0.04284668, -0.019836426, -0.0077171326, 0.019226074, 0.024749756, 0.006340027, 0.009513855, -0.033966064, -0.03326416, 0.027389526, 0.046691895, -0.02909851, 0.018859863, 0.011291504, 0.02041626, 0.0010719299, -0.016311646, -0.007575989, 0.021102905, 0.034973145, 0.006225586, -0.038146973, 0.024902344, -0.002790451, 0.010353088, -0.014762878, 0.064941406, -0.064697266, -0.08917236, -0.0647583, 0.039154053, 0.05026245, 0.0043678284, -0.022140503, 0.020904541, -0.014976501, -0.0022258759, 0.013320923, -0.053863525, -0.013626099, 0.02722168, 0.060943604, -0.013900757, -0.044067383, -0.049041748, -0.01776123, 0.0059013367, 0.026626587, 0.002462387, -0.04901123, 0.007144928, -0.13439941, 0.010192871, 0.017044067, 0.03503418, 0.040863037, -0.016204834, -0.029373169, 0.035339355, 0.033416748, 0.025909424, -0.01637268, 0.020431519, 0.0041160583, 0.023391724, -0.015075684, 0.026016235, -0.050354004, -0.00818634, 0.007904053, 0.00020635128, 0.03515625, 0.00052309036, 0.036590576, -0.011238098, 0.006542206, -0.00548172, 0.025466919, 0.031951904, -0.084350586, -0.035186768, -0.0020141602, 0.0010089874, 0.07836914, 0.0019311905, 0.026397705, -0.005279541, -0.01473999, -0.06719971, -0.048431396, -0.0146865845, 0.03894043, 0.03555298, -0.009239197, 0.015701294, -0.015350342, -0.0058021545, -0.02583313, -0.026245117, -0.047912598, -0.03189087, -0.015838623, 0.032958984, -0.038726807, 0.041534424, 0.068359375, 0.019546509, -0.061035156, 0.028411865, -0.0022125244, -0.06384277, 0.023162842, -0.02355957, -0.003604889, -0.015686035, -0.020629883, 0.0012426376, -0.012214661, 0.03744507, 0.008636475, -0.013679504, 0.0005235672, -0.04949951, 0.015899658, 0.00983429, 0.03894043, -0.0064086914, 0.0062294006, 0.012825012, -0.008201599, -0.009132385, -0.0014152527, -0.010192871, 0.014297485, -0.0006632805, -0.0063095093, 0.01676941, -0.007865906, 0.036193848, 0.05731201, -0.03186035, -0.019577026, 0.025283813, -0.00038719177, 0.00021708012, 0.052825928, 0.035949707, 0.047058105, 0.020492554, 0.006881714, 0.06097412, 0.01234436, 0.026321411, -0.003484726, 0.010910034, 0.0013418198, 0.023864746, -0.015686035, 0.008468628, -0.02293396, 0.003227234, -0.0052261353, 0.015029907, 0.016433716, -0.008850098, 0.016555786, -0.016235352, 0.011886597, -0.052093506, -0.015457153, -0.014968872, -0.043548584, 0.04751587, 0.035247803, -0.08319092, 0.0012149811, 0.029083252, 0.028244019, 0.007663727, 0.0087890625, 0.01928711, 0.013702393, 0.022949219, -0.020462036, -0.028808594, 0.033294678, 0.040802002, 0.011077881, -0.003768921, 0.016479492, -0.005001068, 0.013824463, 0.04611206, -0.017166138, 0.031402588, -0.06573486, 0.029296875, 0.04135132, -0.019744873, 0.019332886, 0.012413025, 0.025344849, 0.02848816, -0.012939453, 0.012023926, -0.052093506, 0.016326904, -0.00217247, -0.03579712, -0.037017822, -0.03753662, -0.0096588135, -0.035614014, -0.032318115, 0.005760193, 0.04272461, 0.0046958923, -0.02053833, 0.017929077, 0.0158844, -0.030410767, 0.0013847351, -0.028045654, 0.037994385, 0.020980835, 0.04373169, 0.04208374, -0.051727295, -0.058135986, -0.0059928894, -0.018066406, -0.0033893585, 0.003862381, -0.005680084, 0.05319214, 0.054351807, -0.035980225, 0.030166626, -0.041809082, -0.035095215, -0.064208984, 0.017425537, 0.014411926, -0.042877197, -0.029067993, 0.072753906, -0.028839111, -0.02180481, 0.055511475, 0.061676025, -0.01576233, -0.019805908, 0.068603516, 0.031036377, -0.0104904175, 0.017318726, 0.0149383545, -0.00007122755, -0.039367676, -0.0014696121, -0.041290283, -0.013656616, -0.018127441, 0.011734009, 0.07965088, -0.06829834, 0.021209717, -0.070617676, -0.007003784, -0.009178162, 0.034332275, 0.013664246, -0.027389526, -0.028549194, -0.0012331009, -0.004432678, 0.032806396, -0.034576416, 0.058410645, 0.074035645, 0.0026397705, -0.02748108, -0.0037136078, 0.01637268, 0.011505127, -0.025756836, -0.014541626, -0.032440186, -0.0077781677, -0.0035896301, 0.020690918, 0.020629883, -0.020751953, -0.06201172, -0.026901245, 0.02519226, -0.0054397583, -0.014732361, 0.0115737915, -0.03237915, -0.0022525787, -0.00995636, -0.016540527, 0.03765869, 0.044952393, -0.015052795, 0.020126343, 0.012718201, -0.01134491, -0.0016937256, -0.012687683, -0.09674072, 0.025772095, -0.011756897, -0.025894165, 0.000059127808, -0.046051025, -0.030181885, 0.005634308, -0.0076141357, 0.029571533, 0.015258789, 0.02558899, 0.009986877, -0.048431396, -0.017745972, -0.03842163, -0.016784668, -0.03161621, -0.0005707741, -0.007663727, -0.011116028, 0.05166626, -0.0021591187, 0.008460999, -0.022903442, -0.016220093, -0.024169922, 0.01864624, -0.016723633, -0.026672363, -0.0061798096, 0.0044403076, -0.01878357, -0.0132751465, -0.015350342, 0.0054016113, -0.014122009, 0.020935059, -0.014030457, 0.045928955, 0.020462036, 0.00008094311, -0.0128479, 0.019515991, 0.020019531, -0.010803223, -0.061828613, -0.002298355, 0.024841309, -0.01914978, 0.03756714, -0.033935547, -0.012809753, 0.011291504, -0.056549072, 0.039520264, 0.023910522, 0.019821167, -0.025985718, -0.00031876564, -0.0021533966, 0.00011277199, -0.0064926147, 0.013641357, 0.010345459, -0.008041382, -0.037597656, -0.035980225, 0.0076904297, 0.007843018, -0.09655762, -0.005393982, 0.009391785, 0.012687683, -0.0024871826, -0.05114746, 0.027816772, 0.005214691, -0.056793213, 0.015838623, -0.034332275, -0.0032444, -0.0036315918, -0.07904053, 0.041137695, 0.05404663, 0.007019043, 0.032806396, 0.05606079, -0.018173218, -0.033233643, -0.03314209, -0.004966736, 0.008682251, 0.035095215, -0.015197754, 0.014549255, 0.0501709, -0.025985718, 0.037994385, 0.014190674, 0.030380249, 0.0015850067, -0.0042495728, 0.004501343, 0.011123657, -0.011199951, 0.03842163, 0.023208618, 0.011299133, -0.07495117, 0.038848877, -0.0044898987, -0.01739502, -0.0063591003, -0.014961243, 0.0052490234, 0.030578613, 0.025390625, 0.045196533, -0.0025577545, -0.0058403015, 0.023513794, -0.00028681755, -0.003238678, -0.003358841, 0.0027942657, 0.015731812, 0.01727295, -0.013977051, -0.007785797, 0.024627686, -0.018829346, -0.013572693, -0.01676941, 0.0051879883, -0.0345459, 0.013320923, -0.058624268, -0.03201294, -0.03656006, 0.018936157, 0.00030112267, 0.025054932, 0.035369873, -0.018173218, -0.021560669, -0.0033054352, 0.033691406, 0.011207581, -0.035705566, -0.07489014, -0.021728516, 0.00041866302, -0.072509766, -0.034118652, -0.04949951, -0.010154724, -0.0035820007, 0.0056037903, -0.021697998, 0.00017118454, 0.03918457, 0.08026123, 0.02885437, -0.002407074, -0.053253174, 0.013145447, -0.0068092346, -0.032714844, 0.020339966, -0.012672424, -0.003107071, -0.038360596, 0.0026741028, -0.0034236908, -0.022384644, -0.06341553, 0.020965576, 0.012413025, 0.0069084167, 0.023544312, 0.052368164, 0.038879395, -0.0019321442, 0.00983429, 0.0024356842, -0.040405273, 0.0024871826, 0.015045166, 0.0435791, -0.005443573, 0.00945282, 0.036346436, 0.023498535, 0.003929138, -0.005252838, 0.01838684, 0.017929077, 0.0045394897, 0.0076293945, 0.027038574, -0.057525635, -0.04006958, 0.0135650635, -0.0023326874, 0.04815674, -0.03488159, 0.0423584, -0.03845215, 0.013298035, 0.014266968, -0.008300781, 0.007499695, 0.011207581, 0.026367188, -0.07891846, -0.08251953, -0.028533936, 0.089782715, -0.0385437, -0.0076408386, 0.0036773682, -0.0039138794, 0.027664185, 0.053253174, 0.054016113, -0.050476074, 0.024337769, -0.022323608, -0.021224976, 0.0042533875, -0.05911255, 0.009597778, 0.007118225, 0.011123657, -0.039978027, -0.006591797, -0.06036377, -0.033172607, 0.004722595, -0.0073661804, -0.0036468506, -0.07965088, -0.0070343018, 0.013549805, 0.014816284, -0.0006380081, 0.005706787, 0.015655518, 0.04837036, 0.04626465, 0.012954712, 0.022003174, 0.01878357, -0.0053253174, -0.004711151, -0.028625488, 0.03515625, 0.0061798096, 0.018249512, 0.016662598, 0.030181885, -0.08404541, 0.023345947, -0.004711151, -0.006626129, 0.00617218, -0.0446167, 0.008163452, 0.02168274, 0.0038585663, -0.002866745, -0.032104492, -0.0141067505, 0.019592285, -0.03277588, -0.02456665, 0.034484863, -0.021026611, -0.048828125, -0.054656982, -0.013549805, 0.029129028, 0.04260254, -0.019058228, 0.02218628, -0.06323242, 0.027389526, 0.05505371, -0.04458618, -0.0060310364, 0.0011377335, 0.02041626, 0.034606934, -0.006439209, -0.00047326088, 0.00021898746, -0.0016059875, -0.043395996, -0.0008096695, 0.006549835, -0.0075187683, 0.011199951, -0.0044136047, -0.012924194, 0.02859497, -0.019958496, 0.013191223, 0.02168274, -0.0044555664, 0.02935791, -0.008338928, -0.010848999, 0.016357422, 0.04324341, -0.004928589, -0.0011034012, 0.00274086, -0.041046143, 0.017669678, 0.0063552856, 0.00031852722, 0.008331299, -0.0418396, 0.010696411, 0.026779175, -0.0073661804, -0.002412796, 0.03753662, 0.028411865, -0.004184723, 0.03717041, 0.015899658, 0.06286621, -0.015991211, -0.019058228, -0.004180908, -0.0009493828, -0.013748169, 0.040283203, -0.0036468506, -0.024627686, -0.025466919, -0.060943604, -0.021209717, -0.013160706, 0.029525757, 0.021209717, 0.020477295, -0.06121826, -0.017456055, 0.0069847107, -0.0061454773, -0.042266846, 0.011459351, -0.0048942566, -0.039245605, 0.0446167, 0.011909485, 0.0041160583, -0.030960083, 0.021240234, -0.010429382, -0.01890564, 0.00995636, 0.0038394928, 0.019332886, -0.031433105, -0.014175415, 0.03050232, 0.025115967, -0.03173828, 0.0138168335, 0.0012922287, 0.06549072, 0.026473999, 0.0418396, 0.058654785, 0.01914978, -0.03189087, 0.0017986298, 0.01436615, -0.046417236, 0.049865723, -0.03475952, 0.016662598, -0.053222656, -0.02255249, -0.09576416, 0.03692627, 0.023269653, 0.012191772, -0.022521973, 0.013183594, 0.01525116, 0.012794495, 0.04888916, -0.04119873, 0.038635254, -0.010040283, 0.0046806335, -0.0040740967, -0.066223145, 0.026489258, 0.052581787, -0.011016846, -0.015235901, -0.015853882, -0.0006971359, 0.018249512, -0.0035133362, 0.016723633, -0.049682617, -0.015792847, -0.034118652, 0.04736328, -0.009613037, 0.0413208, 0.057647705, 0.024612427, -0.007320404, -0.0071640015, 0.0013036728, 0.008636475, -0.032104492, -0.0033950806, 0.06970215, -0.091430664, 0.0032520294, -0.026184082, -0.025161743, 0.015777588, 0.04711914, 0.04034424, -0.042419434, -0.041900635, 0.018997192, 0.046051025, 0.03439331, 0.007217407, -0.029327393, -0.0003888607, 0.027511597, 0.02180481, 0.0043411255, 0.03869629, 0.015716553, 0.010299683, -0.01625061, -0.027633667, 0.01826477, 0.01108551, -0.012786865, 0.020736694, 0.0012187958, 0.04953003, 0.0034122467, -0.03845215, 0.0090789795, 0.011558533, -0.07757568, 0.008636475, -0.010131836, 0.072021484, 0.05557251, 0.088134766, 0.0068092346, -0.011947632, 0.027069092, -0.039001465, 0.018753052, 0.044128418, -0.027832031, 0.01826477, -0.045532227, -0.040893555, 0.016708374, -0.07336426, 0.025253296, -0.025283813, -0.0058517456, -0.019485474, 0.010292053, 0.05770874, -0.044128418, -0.037261963, -0.0121536255, -0.06774902, 0.00013875961, -0.037475586, -0.01789856, -0.01977539, -0.018127441, 0.033081055, 0.022094727, -0.00028324127, 0.01109314, -0.013435364, -0.07635498, -0.004463196, -0.03970337, 0.03894043, -0.036132812, -0.023422241, -0.04336548, 0.012413025, 0.038269043, -0.033233643, -0.046417236, 0.012435913, -0.009185791, -0.0031833649, -0.0053253174, -0.0115356445, -0.018844604, 0.028503418, -0.015548706, 0.04031372, -0.018600464, -0.021270752, 0.024597168, -0.058929443, -0.027313232, 0.0013866425, -0.0395813, 0.046173096, 0.033966064, -0.012634277, 0.014274597, 0.013793945, -0.030441284, -0.014289856, -0.0004298687, 0.0362854, 0.001004219, -0.043792725, 0.019104004, 0.018310547, 0.040802002, -0.04046631, -0.048736572, 0.006713867, 0.017715454, 0.013832092, 0.06616211, 0.0054779053, 0.011772156, 0.0060920715, 0.04663086, 0.011917114, -0.04916382, -0.008674622, 0.011756897, 0.049072266, 0.041534424, -0.005783081, -0.0014781952, 0.021972656, -0.028167725, -0.008590698, 0.046417236, -0.010215759, 0.0010156631, 0.006706238, 0.037506104, -0.008583069, -0.05960083, -0.0075187683, -0.039886475, 0.011581421, 0.011947632, -0.026138306, 0.009918213, -0.056762695, 0.046295166, -0.005821228, -0.009002686, 0.03125, 0.028869629, 0.034210205, 0.0077590942, -0.010643005, 0.006351471, -0.008934021, -0.009552002, 0.0016431808, -0.012580872, 0.002861023, -0.02619934, -0.00047945976, -0.019500732, -0.03479004, -0.031097412, -0.022567749, 0.014411926, -0.012756348, 0.023101807, -0.0035991669, -0.024856567, -0.0018444061, 0.013847351, 0.057617188, -0.026611328, -0.030853271, -0.06237793, 0.06286621, -0.007587433 ], "summary": [ -0.0077209473, -0.00012230873, -0.01751709, -0.023452759, -0.024307251, 0.0019378662, -0.06774902, -0.027023315, -0.0003862381, 0.059783936, -0.029678345, 0.025115967, 0.051818848, -0.0009274483, -0.0052604675, -0.0006542206, -0.008483887, 0.02229309, -0.014030457, -0.017456055, 0.026275635, -0.01828003, -0.06524658, -0.025650024, 0.045043945, -0.05368042, -0.04800415, 0.035095215, 0.017196655, 0.028076172, 0.014465332, -0.009017944, 0.031311035, 0.041137695, -0.06286621, 0.020111084, 0.0017662048, 0.009384155, -0.023834229, 0.04486084, 0.036315918, -0.008071899, 0.051483154, 0.018493652, 0.00004339218, 0.0026988983, 0.0025501251, -0.044799805, 0.0078125, 0.018325806, -0.018356323, 0.030563354, -0.02810669, 0.0143585205, -0.00029039383, -0.017074585, -0.06677246, 0.05441284, 0.02558899, 0.058410645, -0.013687134, -0.026138306, -0.0021324158, -0.06829834, 0.003282547, -0.01689148, 0.010406494, 0.009674072, 0.0087509155, 0.017944336, 0.01914978, -0.0071487427, 0.034454346, -0.042114258, -0.046203613, 0.0013599396, 0.029174805, 0.0049819946, 0.00894928, -0.044067383, -0.011253357, 0.02748108, -0.009010315, -0.038146973, -0.014480591, -0.06903076, -0.0046539307, 0.011505127, -0.000010371208, 0.018539429, -0.0045814514, -0.055847168, -0.026062012, 0.097473145, 0.03967285, -0.008346558, -0.011756897, -0.0010318756, -0.008430481, -0.014816284, -0.00089502335, -0.0000030994415, -0.0390625, -0.0049057007, -0.0019779205, 0.015838623, -0.0015563965, 0.030639648, 0.048828125, 0.0051651, -0.011680603, 0.049835205, -0.042938232, -0.04827881, -0.0005517006, 0.026519775, -0.05230713, 0.030593872, 0.005882263, 0.033843994, 0.008979797, 0.027557373, -0.048034668, 0.030471802, 0.012992859, -0.00047159195, 0.00374794, 0.014968872, -0.03302002, 0.013084412, -0.015533447, 0.02279663, -0.02696228, -0.0014467239, -0.040405273, -0.009460449, 0.042236328, 0.013725281, -0.02078247, 0.0078048706, -0.013801575, 0.042999268, 0.041412354, -0.04421997, -0.0357666, 0.033111572, 0.03591919, -0.0067749023, -0.029449463, -0.047332764, -0.023513794, -0.008834839, 0.046173096, -0.034454346, -0.015625, -0.06549072, -0.04260254, -0.020065308, 0.02935791, -0.011550903, 0.010437012, -0.017990112, -0.0047950745, 0.030960083, 0.0053596497, 0.021560669, -0.007675171, -0.006641388, 0.0028514862, -0.01725769, -0.016784668, 0.014450073, -0.08807373, -0.004676819, 0.026275635, 0.0030899048, 0.0158844, 0.034210205, 0.01689148, -0.021575928, 0.0007171631, -0.01424408, 0.08148193, -0.01398468, -0.07183838, -0.0044288635, 0.0107421875, 0.04437256, 0.066101074, -0.008705139, 0.047668457, -0.0413208, -0.031082153, 0.019256592, -0.013809204, 0.002105713, 0.0104904175, 0.039154053, -0.0077819824, -0.034210205, 0.04827881, 0.027267456, -0.02885437, -0.056854248, -0.12878418, 0.0121154785, -0.034057617, 0.057403564, -0.035308838, -0.00065231323, 0.0340271, -0.020751953, -0.029708862, 0.029190063, 0.0107421875, -0.007080078, -0.012908936, -0.0625, -0.0058403015, -0.02279663, -0.0064048767, 0.064697266, -0.033325195, 0.017684937, -0.0524292, -0.008262634, -0.02420044, 0.009773254, -0.04208374, 0.008743286, 0.02305603, 0.00013530254, -0.0041885376, 0.026977539, -0.01637268, -0.023132324, -0.008399963, -0.06890869, 0.037872314, 0.043640137, 0.014343262, 0.033172607, -0.03793335, -0.023773193, 0.03753662, -0.03463745, -0.009231567, -0.0030326843, -0.010414124, 0.045532227, 0.05343628, 0.05090332, -0.0020694733, 0.04055786, 0.0256958, 0.020736694, -0.031280518, -0.054107666, 0.027389526, -0.01802063, 0.034088135, -0.062561035, -0.06451416, -0.011993408, -0.02859497, -0.03552246, -0.047943115, -0.03967285, -0.017364502, -0.0060653687, 0.032836914, -0.050445557, -0.0067863464, -0.05847168, -0.01084137, -0.056030273, -0.039123535, 0.054351807, 0.029541016, -0.0524292, 0.000746727, 0.027862549, -0.0038394928, -0.0059776306, 0.010482788, 0.028442383, -0.00053167343, 0.014595032, 0.0013942719, 0.02078247, 0.013916016, 0.06652832, 0.0038585663, 0.024276733, 0.01499939, 0.01309967, 0.0075416565, -0.008712769, 0.021499634, -0.02394104, -0.015098572, 0.048797607, 0.022979736, -0.017700195, 0.012992859, -0.01979065, 0.009155273, -0.0087509155, -0.016784668, 0.04724121, -0.09613037, 0.019470215, 0.02142334, 0.016159058, 0.003376007, 0.0020313263, -0.011451721, 0.043945312, 0.024261475, 0.07946777, 0.023010254, 0.026275635, -0.0017690659, 0.051605225, 0.019424438, -0.034942627, 0.04623413, -0.015808105, 0.08062744, -0.014389038, -0.00945282, 0.013084412, -0.05581665, -0.027160645, 0.0025634766, -0.026519775, 0.0069465637, -0.0039978027, -0.00045490265, 0.04248047, 0.053985596, -0.0050354004, 0.019134521, -0.026428223, -0.027404785, -0.0736084, 0.04812622, -0.02520752, 0.034729004, 0.00018465519, 0.03643799, 0.011230469, 0.0119018555, 0.031982422, 0.05529785, -0.05596924, -0.042297363, 0.06640625, 0.030181885, -0.005252838, -0.0016708374, 0.04437256, -0.018554688, -0.059173584, -0.0072364807, -0.03805542, -0.006225586, -0.024871826, 0.060638428, 0.047210693, -0.030899048, 0.05142212, -0.037628174, 0.0026073456, 0.035217285, -0.011497498, 0.034484863, -0.018112183, 0.007019043, 0.034057617, 0.026016235, 0.05999756, -0.013092041, 0.1026001, 0.08331299, 0.010009766, -0.0055274963, 0.031066895, 0.017929077, 0.021118164, -0.017105103, -0.036071777, -0.004749298, -0.037963867, -0.016296387, 0.013885498, 0.024810791, -0.026763916, 0.047180176, -0.04800415, 0.022659302, 0.013374329, 0.012519836, 0.028015137, -0.033233643, 0.06365967, 0.011604309, -0.0042686462, 0.01727295, -0.01146698, 0.034729004, -0.033294678, 0.042388916, -0.036315918, 0.000007927418, -0.04107666, 0.0087509155, 0.011062622, 0.027267456, -0.054626465, -0.00957489, -0.007221222, 0.012001038, 0.004310608, -0.017623901, 0.028900146, -0.028701782, 0.02128601, -0.0071525574, -0.021316528, -0.033935547, -0.01890564, 0.0004529953, 0.004753113, -0.04800415, 0.03829956, 0.003326416, 0.019317627, 0.025375366, -0.054901123, 0.016677856, -0.02557373, -0.0010442734, 0.019958496, -0.025222778, 0.023162842, -0.02822876, 0.030273438, 0.023880005, -0.0011053085, -0.031173706, 0.007896423, 0.038604736, 0.029846191, -0.014381409, 0.012550354, -0.0026245117, 0.015129089, 0.021133423, 0.037994385, 0.050048828, 0.025360107, -0.054626465, -0.012031555, 0.035949707, -0.018157959, 0.02507019, -0.010314941, -0.0055770874, 0.018356323, -0.0035800934, -0.023422241, -0.01411438, -0.01348114, -0.031433105, -0.029327393, 0.057647705, -0.0040626526, 0.057891846, -0.03201294, -0.031677246, 0.014732361, -0.044128418, -0.02243042, -0.0137786865, 0.0032691956, -0.064453125, -0.039123535, -0.018051147, -0.020843506, 0.0019016266, -0.022277832, 0.023834229, -0.038146973, -0.029159546, -0.01612854, -0.036987305, 0.086364746, 0.013801575, -0.06274414, 0.09472656, -0.052246094, 0.020004272, 0.013801575, 0.018798828, 0.02609253, 0.022949219, -0.0012636185, 0.005153656, 0.0039253235, 0.022460938, -0.036743164, 0.01612854, 0.017181396, -0.028533936, 0.005279541, -0.014633179, -0.02571106, -0.009864807, 0.0129852295, 0.016586304, 0.055755615, -0.017654419, -0.015655518, 0.045074463, 0.022018433, -0.04046631, 0.06463623, 0.008026123, 0.0036811829, -0.0009622574, 0.007987976, 0.00995636, 0.01234436, 0.019882202, -0.01902771, -0.004096985, -0.040161133, 0.021987915, 0.053649902, -0.0048599243, -0.035461426, -0.03805542, 0.056365967, 0.020065308, -0.023040771, 0.015319824, 0.021697998, -0.037109375, 0.01007843, -0.0146484375, 0.0049095154, -0.034088135, -0.017181396, -0.01626587, -0.05822754, -0.04559326, 0.014030457, 0.009017944, 0.029800415, 0.021240234, -0.00038313866, 0.016021729, -0.039398193, 0.074035645, 0.028442383, -0.06890869, -0.10681152, -0.0055503845, -0.0047798157, -0.055389404, -0.03967285, -0.089416504, -0.03817749, -0.024307251, 0.00944519, -0.031280518, 0.009239197, -0.004749298, 0.013839722, -0.0073776245, 0.009429932, -0.021835327, 0.0038414001, 0.016479492, 0.0023345947, -0.041229248, 0.0046844482, -0.011131287, -0.0043678284, -0.018478394, -0.0035324097, -0.011428833, -0.05404663, 0.009819031, 0.0007343292, -0.01878357, 0.018630981, 0.04815674, 0.012794495, 0.01071167, -0.0017032623, 0.0104522705, -0.0058288574, 0.038635254, -0.024032593, -0.005722046, 0.06011963, -0.0013856888, 0.036376953, -0.023406982, 0.005706787, -0.007118225, -0.01134491, -0.0048179626, 0.028259277, 0.048065186, -0.021911621, -0.013069153, -0.026687622, 0.0126571655, 0.017425537, 0.025054932, 0.024276733, -0.015853882, -0.04788208, 0.001282692, 0.0034446716, 0.0028038025, 0.010124207, 0.03881836, 0.013702393, -0.041107178, -0.000026404858, 0.013282776, 0.028198242, -0.019592285, 0.006614685, -0.04724121, -0.060668945, 0.031280518, -0.00957489, -0.024673462, -0.04864502, 0.013473511, -0.016952515, -0.015640259, 0.024993896, -0.0289917, -0.020309448, -0.008331299, -0.0059280396, 0.020370483, 0.00066900253, -0.00844574, 0.013587952, 0.0042686462, -0.011940002, 0.008293152, -0.059570312, -0.05419922, -0.012435913, -0.036132812, -0.016815186, -0.006439209, -0.0037078857, 0.032409668, 0.016860962, -0.008010864, -0.005466461, -0.005290985, -0.018173218, 0.012886047, -0.029632568, -0.0024642944, 0.016220093, 0.06109619, 0.014083862, 0.062927246, -0.07116699, -0.009460449, -0.032806396, 0.019927979, -0.013671875, -0.0033550262, 0.044036865, 0.05001831, -0.020843506, 0.012489319, -0.028060913, 0.0034122467, 0.005897522, -0.008956909, -0.048797607, 0.0055160522, -0.013916016, -0.039794922, 0.006008148, -0.010749817, 0.019699097, 0.058044434, -0.011726379, -0.02116394, -0.041992188, -0.003967285, 0.031280518, -0.022872925, -0.0036201477, 0.010055542, 0.018997192, -0.0058898926, -0.018676758, 0.032196045, 0.007171631, 0.006816864, -0.03274536, -0.019577026, -0.03112793, -0.05899048, 0.041137695, 0.029067993, 0.031021118, 0.027450562, -0.040039062, -0.0063095093, 0.005279541, 0.010887146, 0.062164307, -0.031433105, -0.034851074, 0.033691406, 0.046569824, -0.0019130707, -0.001958847, -0.0076293945, -0.031311035, 0.030197144, 0.003540039, -0.016036987, 0.04815674, -0.008087158, 0.014968872, 0.023513794, -0.006465912, -0.020446777, 0.027908325, 0.000790596, -0.024215698, 0.06323242, 0.009170532, 0.06237793, 0.010101318, -0.0021915436, -0.008415222, 0.026794434, -0.028900146, -0.040374756, 0.014518738, 0.021362305, -0.0029621124, -0.025558472, 0.013908386, 0.0067710876, 0.0023326874, -0.0035324097, 0.013442993, 0.004360199, 0.020843506, 0.034851074, -0.012329102, -0.03656006, 0.020019531, -0.026412964, -0.060028076, 0.035736084, 0.021850586, -0.05291748, 0.040161133, 0.0050315857, 0.028244019, -0.0014810562, 0.02709961, 0.023544312, -0.0072250366, -0.023422241, 0.012145996, 0.030029297, 0.025131226, -0.047851562, -0.03692627, 0.036254883, 0.049957275, 0.033172607, -0.008239746, 0.012336731, -0.008216858, 0.002008438, 0.0045280457, 0.0041770935, -0.020584106, 0.06036377, -0.014297485, 0.033569336, -0.018218994, -0.021575928, -0.043823242, 0.050811768, 0.019851685, -0.029953003, 0.025634766, -0.0053977966, -0.0047950745, 0.034942627, -0.034454346, 0.024993896, -0.023223877, -0.051330566, -0.018463135, -0.025604248, -0.09350586, 0.057403564, 0.07757568, 0.0023517609, -0.032928467, -0.0103302, 0.008483887, 0.039794922, -0.04421997, -0.02116394, -0.08093262, 0.009101868, -0.051849365, 0.017288208, 0.016296387, 0.01197052, 0.026687622, 0.002937317, 0.037628174, -0.024551392, 0.01576233, 0.03616333, -0.013290405, -0.012313843, 0.023666382, -0.019760132, -0.039398193, -0.0045928955, -0.0019798279, 0.01486969, 0.013961792, 0.04888916, -0.051635742, -0.017425537, 0.012969971, 0.0058631897, -0.012672424, -0.021713257, -0.032684326, -0.008743286, 0.015930176, -0.016998291, 0.0018110275, 0.01576233, 0.030776978, 0.015975952, 0.009292603, 0.0066108704, 0.019805908, -0.0042037964, 0.007965088, 0.0050582886, 0.020202637, 0.028442383, -0.016174316, -0.030212402, 0.010093689, 0.00021445751, -0.04510498, 0.006286621, -0.008018494, 0.09375, 0.052764893, 0.055908203, -0.022628784, 0.009292603, 0.07647705, 0.0013742447, -0.011856079, 0.0025482178, 0.00039601326, -0.013763428, -0.027191162, 0.0028705597, 0.0012950897, -0.0385437, -0.007637024, -0.033966064, -0.0025100708, -0.045318604, 0.034210205, -0.042816162, -0.010360718, 0.0005502701, -0.040924072, -0.07861328, 0.026687622, 0.023712158, -0.01576233, -0.023529053, -0.042816162, -0.0019683838, -0.02571106, 0.026489258, 0.037506104, -0.021697998, 0.0054397583, 0.01689148, 0.020324707, 0.07824707, 0.0015192032, -0.04977417, -0.009399414, 0.015991211, 0.040924072, -0.017074585, -0.036132812, 0.0015487671, 0.038085938, -0.02267456, 0.024871826, 0.025268555, -0.0070495605, -0.023361206, 0.013824463, -0.0056915283, -0.012779236, 0.0028648376, 0.019699097, -0.0069770813, 0.009475708, 0.012054443, -0.02909851, 0.0022907257, -0.021469116, -0.022460938, 0.026107788, 0.025314331, -0.03375244, 0.006790161, -0.010307312, -0.01084137, -0.009384155, -0.06518555, 0.022445679, -0.030822754, 0.037231445, -0.0071372986, -0.05908203, 0.022384644, 0.015808105, 0.03668213, -0.031082153, -0.010101318, -0.017211914, -0.0045318604, 0.027374268, -0.0048675537, -0.014511108, 0.018920898, 0.02734375, 0.056427002, 0.040863037, -0.031219482, 0.029647827, 0.022460938, -0.028030396, -0.013847351, 0.056793213, -0.036621094, 0.0029258728, 0.006881714, -0.0017461777, -0.01637268, -0.042266846, 0.02229309, -0.052368164, 0.015975952, -0.010223389, -0.024734497, 0.0072784424, -0.056671143, 0.0032463074, 0.050750732, 0.029067993, -0.02468872, 0.003282547, 0.0368042, -0.021026611, -0.0056991577, -0.020324707, -0.0015554428, 0.008842468, 0.01550293, 0.010391235, -0.042144775, 0.010360718, 0.00015926361, -0.023925781, -0.037078857, -0.02381897, -0.014533997, -0.010818481, -0.021942139, 0.044891357, 0.013031006, -0.008041382, 0.026992798, 0.0048675537, 0.08660889, 0.0023727417, 0.018798828, -0.011627197, 0.023880005, 0.015579224 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07575v1
SPHINX: The Joint Mixing of Weights, Tasks, and Visual Embeddings for Multi-modal Large Language Models
Ziyi Lin, Chris Liu, Renrui Zhang, Peng Gao, Longtian Qiu, Han Xiao, Han Qiu, Chen Lin, Wenqi Shao, Keqin Chen, Jiaming Han, Siyuan Huang, Yichi Zhang, Xuming He, Hongsheng Li, Yu Qiao
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
We present SPHINX, a versatile multi-modal large language model (MLLM) with a joint mixing of model weights, tuning tasks, and visual embeddings. First, for stronger vision-language alignment, we unfreeze the large language model (LLM) during pre-training, and introduce a weight mix strategy between LLMs trained by real-world and synthetic data. By directly integrating the weights from two domains, the mixed LLM can efficiently incorporate diverse semantics with favorable robustness. Then, to enable multi-purpose capabilities, we mix a variety of tasks for joint visual instruction tuning, and design task-specific instructions to avoid inter-task conflict. In addition to the basic visual question answering, we include more challenging tasks such as region-level understanding, caption grounding, document layout detection, and human pose estimation, contributing to mutual enhancement over different scenarios. Additionally, we propose to extract comprehensive visual embeddings from various network architectures, pre-training paradigms, and information granularity, providing language models with more robust image representations. Based on our proposed joint mixing, SPHINX exhibits superior multi-modal understanding capabilities on a wide range of applications. On top of this, we further propose an efficient strategy aiming to better capture fine-grained appearances of high-resolution images. With a mixing of different scales and high-resolution sub-images, SPHINX attains exceptional visual parsing and reasoning performance on existing evaluation benchmarks. We hope our work may cast a light on the exploration of joint mixing in future MLLM research. Code is released at https://github.com/Alpha-VLLM/LLaMA2-Accessory.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07575v1
2023-11-13T18:59:47
2023-11-13T18:59:47
{ "title": [ -0.0066833496, 0.000078856945, -0.052581787, -0.06567383, -0.002632141, -0.009437561, -0.068481445, -0.007820129, 0.020370483, 0.02658081, -0.017578125, 0.016525269, 0.0071792603, -0.022735596, -0.034118652, 0.008476257, -0.00315094, 0.04724121, -0.02810669, -0.03387451, -0.028442383, -0.04925537, 0.046417236, 0.036010742, 0.034973145, -0.090026855, -0.0657959, 0.029312134, -0.03366089, -0.03955078, 0.004497528, 0.028030396, 0.022415161, 0.036132812, -0.018875122, 0.017196655, -0.046325684, 0.020217896, 0.017471313, -0.007537842, 0.025726318, -0.007881165, 0.014305115, -0.015823364, -0.030685425, 0.041229248, -0.07080078, -0.037963867, -0.005290985, 0.04348755, 0.012489319, 0.049438477, -0.013298035, 0.031585693, 0.028564453, -0.015357971, -0.02168274, 0.008773804, 0.028152466, 0.0670166, 0.019302368, -0.045166016, 0.008110046, -0.03237915, -0.033416748, -0.00043702126, -0.012512207, 0.012878418, 0.052978516, -0.0027770996, -0.017410278, 0.008682251, 0.016601562, -0.035858154, -0.061279297, 0.027572632, 0.03289795, 0.0118637085, 0.048309326, -0.06365967, -0.012680054, -0.004638672, -0.0047683716, -0.022476196, 0.017608643, -0.03894043, -0.029403687, -0.009635925, -0.031463623, -0.059265137, -0.0050621033, -0.00774765, -0.03591919, 0.032958984, -0.0143966675, -0.012748718, -0.010627747, 0.029403687, -0.012962341, -0.020629883, -0.036102295, 0.04559326, -0.035827637, -0.014640808, 0.035095215, 0.018005371, -0.03945923, -0.022918701, 0.03451538, 0.026733398, -0.024978638, 0.060638428, 0.008155823, 0.0024719238, -0.0038986206, 0.006580353, -0.015930176, 0.014717102, 0.0029525757, 0.03274536, -0.012641907, -0.022979736, 0.0030155182, 0.044525146, 0.024719238, 0.018432617, -0.028518677, 0.022491455, -0.0009965897, 0.01586914, 0.010536194, 0.059265137, -0.09625244, -0.07904053, -0.059143066, 0.050476074, -0.05105591, 0.0033626556, -0.051330566, 0.03945923, -0.020706177, -0.03704834, 0.016296387, -0.024963379, -0.035705566, 0.012763977, 0.06335449, -0.010002136, -0.062561035, -0.06793213, -0.03265381, 0.0039596558, 0.028747559, -0.0072517395, -0.03353882, -0.024902344, -0.109802246, -0.01272583, 0.018341064, 0.0036010742, 0.010131836, 0.00894165, 0.028839111, 0.0028896332, 0.028778076, -0.023620605, -0.040924072, -0.0025501251, 0.022994995, 0.022445679, -0.009429932, 0.013404846, 0.039001465, 0.012741089, -0.0121154785, 0.011276245, 0.013977051, -0.0068130493, 0.016159058, -0.0075912476, -0.0034561157, -0.034942627, 0.017852783, 0.026046753, -0.050567627, -0.03302002, -0.009262085, 0.014724731, 0.056121826, 0.022521973, -0.04486084, -0.0060043335, -0.01991272, -0.03869629, -0.034973145, -0.023132324, 0.010894775, 0.029754639, -0.013771057, -0.005378723, 0.0024929047, -0.011932373, -0.017288208, -0.011505127, -0.030670166, -0.017929077, -0.01663208, 0.01940918, -0.026535034, 0.061523438, 0.058288574, 0.022216797, -0.055664062, 0.013420105, 0.007297516, -0.05029297, 0.00566864, -0.021240234, -0.0022773743, -0.018096924, 0.0073127747, -0.010902405, 0.029022217, 0.04849243, 0.009231567, -0.0062026978, 0.012260437, -0.014480591, 0.022644043, 0.01713562, 0.04458618, -0.042816162, 0.039489746, 0.0317688, -0.0033569336, -0.042297363, 0.00094890594, -0.05105591, 0.029785156, 0.027893066, -0.0012865067, -0.00023519993, -0.0033035278, 0.0317688, 0.059387207, -0.0068511963, 0.0017557144, 0.014541626, 0.027938843, 0.05822754, 0.059570312, 0.029891968, 0.030426025, -0.019363403, 0.023849487, 0.05557251, 0.0015773773, -0.016113281, -0.03591919, -0.00061273575, 0.033081055, -0.0011539459, -0.045288086, 0.019454956, -0.07507324, -0.0030670166, -0.057800293, -0.015449524, 0.016296387, -0.00043439865, 0.03744507, -0.017562866, 0.02178955, -0.015838623, 0.03488159, -0.025177002, -0.012214661, 0.0073928833, 0.04574585, -0.055358887, -0.007286072, 0.01020813, 0.047912598, 0.0052757263, 0.03286743, 0.012702942, 0.01259613, -0.025253296, -0.033111572, -0.0049362183, 0.03753662, 0.03427124, -0.0063476562, 0.00762558, 0.024230957, 0.00038671494, 0.10247803, 0.05404663, -0.013244629, 0.024887085, -0.022827148, 0.03289795, -0.0017719269, -0.007537842, 0.014266968, 0.021469116, 0.04031372, -0.003829956, -0.050598145, 0.0033988953, -0.047546387, 0.015472412, 0.0035076141, 0.005874634, -0.056640625, -0.06365967, -0.0026607513, -0.035369873, -0.06890869, -0.040740967, 0.07458496, -0.046203613, -0.0069999695, 0.00289917, -0.016220093, -0.024612427, 0.009864807, -0.027420044, -0.009361267, 0.021133423, 0.035247803, 0.013587952, -0.057678223, -0.021896362, -0.008735657, 0.012069702, -0.019241333, -0.008773804, -0.016937256, 0.046051025, 0.026794434, 0.0075645447, 0.025756836, -0.04510498, 0.018005371, -0.06427002, 0.035217285, 0.013137817, -0.019439697, 0.013198853, 0.011909485, -0.011680603, -0.007865906, 0.018844604, 0.05206299, -0.038513184, -0.027038574, 0.033203125, 0.0007829666, -0.018737793, 0.051605225, 0.0034809113, 0.008735657, -0.05783081, -0.017532349, -0.0340271, -0.029083252, -0.015930176, 0.0038337708, 0.061431885, -0.015991211, -0.02494812, -0.04650879, -0.024551392, -0.004638672, -0.009887695, -0.019729614, -0.044952393, -0.022201538, -0.027267456, -0.036712646, 0.005191803, 0.011909485, 0.03692627, 0.08282471, 0.0071907043, 0.016204834, 0.022537231, 0.028137207, -0.0046653748, -0.012138367, -0.0211792, -0.03894043, 0.0054626465, 0.012359619, 0.010795593, -0.015670776, -0.018829346, -0.1060791, 0.00970459, 0.064575195, 0.018173218, -0.014053345, 0.046691895, -0.09057617, 0.052001953, -0.007270813, -0.015220642, 0.03869629, 0.04623413, 0.017471313, -0.006072998, 0.015625, -0.041534424, -0.0034046173, -0.01838684, -0.10119629, 0.02420044, -0.040130615, -0.021591187, 0.005027771, -0.020568848, -0.04763794, 0.006916046, 0.026321411, 0.06951904, -0.009254456, -0.022903442, -0.005657196, -0.031433105, -0.01939392, -0.027328491, -0.025115967, -0.028457642, -0.03338623, 0.024353027, 0.0063591003, 0.05102539, 0.031158447, -0.013023376, -0.03289795, -0.015060425, -0.024993896, 0.0056037903, -0.006755829, -0.03704834, 0.0032596588, 0.000044047832, -0.009986877, 0.019866943, -0.044128418, -0.0010108948, -0.056396484, 0.014640808, -0.02973938, 0.014350891, 0.019805908, 0.021072388, -0.0038318634, -0.037597656, 0.022903442, -0.027709961, -0.05038452, 0.01625061, 0.06213379, 0.009567261, -0.01826477, -0.0057678223, -0.018920898, 0.019973755, -0.013153076, -0.015068054, 0.003282547, -0.017425537, -0.009155273, -0.027252197, 0.013702393, 0.01751709, -0.013259888, -0.019104004, -0.0030994415, -0.0016307831, -0.013160706, -0.050567627, -0.00074338913, 0.0027866364, -0.097595215, -0.031799316, 0.008361816, -0.037963867, -0.03164673, -0.05380249, 0.0418396, -0.05105591, -0.023651123, 0.020568848, -0.019226074, -0.035003662, -0.00005120039, -0.087768555, 0.00491333, 0.09112549, 0.022766113, 0.027145386, 0.052246094, -0.00021076202, -0.039276123, -0.031280518, 0.025985718, 0.021209717, 0.030822754, 0.002166748, -0.03353882, 0.014709473, -0.025299072, 0.020858765, 0.040863037, -0.024627686, 0.013511658, 0.014175415, 0.015945435, 0.018066406, -0.010726929, 0.035217285, 0.0038833618, -0.0040283203, -0.048187256, 0.017959595, -0.0016975403, 0.0041160583, 0.020080566, -0.024169922, 0.027313232, 0.023269653, 0.0017938614, 0.056518555, -0.01802063, -0.015449524, 0.035888672, -0.006591797, -0.014030457, 0.0061149597, 0.014091492, 0.023544312, -0.0023708344, 0.01828003, 0.0069389343, 0.036193848, -0.019424438, -0.013114929, 0.0020313263, 0.024475098, -0.03741455, -0.005508423, -0.046295166, -0.06311035, -0.026275635, 0.01864624, -0.011161804, 0.023422241, 0.047943115, 0.0044403076, -0.00737381, -0.028198242, 0.039001465, 0.011268616, -0.032348633, -0.07763672, 0.013587952, -0.006580353, -0.047851562, -0.03717041, -0.011367798, -0.022369385, 0.0309906, -0.009246826, -0.0090789795, 0.01852417, 0.026260376, 0.052764893, 0.043304443, -0.0041656494, -0.044006348, 0.030151367, -0.028961182, -0.010063171, 0.014015198, 0.0026283264, -0.010429382, -0.036590576, 0.008636475, -0.015510559, -0.01739502, -0.0362854, 0.005203247, -0.008323669, 0.051849365, 0.016784668, 0.023330688, 0.019882202, 0.021881104, -0.005622864, 0.00083065033, -0.023956299, -0.011146545, -0.011253357, 0.028244019, 0.016082764, -0.0012483597, 0.028625488, 0.009223938, 0.017822266, 0.01234436, -0.0031433105, 0.009506226, 0.000767231, -0.0010213852, 0.029510498, -0.043670654, -0.03845215, -0.012519836, 0.017333984, 0.031341553, -0.05203247, 0.055755615, -0.011375427, -0.017166138, 0.016082764, -0.017684937, 0.008087158, -0.0045204163, 0.018753052, -0.053222656, -0.06390381, -0.013366699, 0.042816162, -0.01727295, 0.010360718, 0.0019130707, -0.00022447109, 0.022140503, 0.047302246, 0.031921387, -0.030960083, 0.00040197372, -0.0256958, -0.017410278, -0.018707275, -0.041656494, -0.0061149597, -0.0021781921, -0.0002734661, -0.023712158, -0.005619049, -0.06298828, -0.022872925, -0.02104187, -0.024139404, 0.036010742, -0.06604004, 0.024719238, 0.093444824, 0.016113281, 0.042053223, -0.00032043457, 0.009941101, 0.019485474, 0.032287598, 0.013153076, 0.0074157715, 0.01776123, -0.04537964, 0.03640747, 0.010482788, 0.009010315, 0.00623703, 0.019241333, 0.0022525787, 0.008575439, -0.03967285, 0.021011353, 0.0008916855, 0.0039367676, 0.036865234, -0.06524658, -0.0033168793, -0.0037937164, -0.0026798248, 0.01524353, -0.020935059, -0.052764893, -0.05480957, -0.012069702, -0.08721924, 0.002866745, -0.021865845, -0.060943604, -0.028869629, 0.03375244, -0.013511658, -0.024353027, 0.020187378, -0.00016450882, -0.03036499, 0.032684326, 0.010421753, -0.011291504, -0.010856628, 0.018539429, 0.014831543, 0.025619507, 0.020126343, -0.04309082, -0.01612854, -0.028671265, -0.03277588, -0.01889038, 0.0155181885, 0.022109985, 0.011390686, -0.0048980713, -0.015617371, 0.004638672, -0.011054993, 0.029647827, -0.019424438, -0.01550293, 0.024017334, -0.003967285, 0.0012149811, 0.017745972, -0.00655365, 0.009277344, 0.012313843, 0.002040863, -0.013534546, 0.04324341, -0.012275696, 0.043518066, -0.017318726, -0.045837402, 0.001584053, 0.03643799, 0.017333984, -0.020996094, 0.024597168, 0.031585693, -0.00944519, 0.0027008057, 0.005432129, 0.04977417, -0.050964355, 0.0069618225, -0.01838684, 0.012268066, -0.04135132, 0.037231445, -0.019866943, 0.0051116943, -0.04019165, -0.03677368, -0.023422241, 0.021255493, 0.0146865845, 0.015655518, 0.04888916, -0.013626099, 0.033416748, -0.03390503, -0.00093889236, -0.05432129, 0.029373169, -0.015258789, -0.02267456, 0.004058838, -0.0056419373, -0.041900635, 0.020370483, 0.03817749, 0.037750244, -0.045928955, 0.04977417, -0.028259277, 0.0025749207, -0.017868042, -0.014472961, 0.06591797, -0.01751709, -0.0039787292, 0.030715942, -0.015853882, 0.059906006, 0.029449463, 0.0413208, 0.0524292, 0.026977539, 0.032958984, 0.005443573, 0.029815674, -0.02835083, 0.022827148, -0.026809692, 0.01953125, -0.0496521, -0.012130737, -0.0847168, 0.02178955, 0.011642456, 0.02017212, 0.005317688, 0.013885498, -0.002002716, 0.0104904175, 0.03540039, 0.0031871796, 0.043762207, 0.0007638931, 0.008003235, 0.014953613, -0.036468506, 0.018310547, 0.047943115, 0.009613037, -0.016906738, -0.018875122, -0.023254395, -0.0113220215, 0.0395813, 0.017608643, -0.0093307495, -0.015853882, -0.035614014, 0.0050811768, -0.01184845, 0.01838684, 0.05340576, 0.0113220215, -0.033203125, 0.005634308, 0.0020828247, -0.026535034, -0.019714355, 0.0073661804, 0.047943115, -0.075683594, 0.03262329, -0.021484375, -0.03201294, -0.0068511963, 0.025222778, 0.030914307, -0.061828613, -0.050201416, 0.018493652, 0.050872803, 0.0050811768, 0.005680084, -0.043518066, -0.015914917, 0.0003323555, 0.028121948, -0.013671875, 0.016952515, 0.025878906, 0.037384033, 0.0082092285, -0.02758789, 0.010017395, -0.009353638, 0.020812988, 0.039978027, 0.0020141602, 0.01272583, -0.006298065, -0.03277588, -0.0064315796, 0.026367188, -0.05279541, -0.015548706, 0.04348755, 0.040283203, 0.040252686, 0.07562256, 0.016571045, 0.008987427, -0.014518738, -0.04788208, 0.018173218, 0.05670166, -0.015701294, 0.03765869, -0.070495605, -0.058898926, 0.017562866, -0.072143555, 0.04937744, -0.04269409, -0.019058228, -0.043060303, 0.04824829, 0.015579224, -0.03741455, -0.020187378, -0.01928711, -0.045715332, -0.008155823, -0.00016522408, -0.014862061, -0.015457153, -0.032409668, -0.0007619858, -0.02432251, 0.0049934387, -0.009338379, -0.026443481, -0.06237793, 0.016784668, -0.03173828, 0.047912598, -0.023895264, 0.0049591064, -0.017593384, -0.0027332306, 0.005378723, -0.041625977, -0.026062012, -0.009635925, -0.04324341, -0.02986145, 0.020965576, 0.0129852295, -0.015266418, -0.06726074, -0.02330017, -0.003042221, -0.031555176, 0.0017938614, 0.038360596, -0.04840088, -0.035125732, -0.00071907043, -0.022888184, 0.05279541, 0.009460449, -0.013015747, 0.0154418945, 0.01574707, -0.027145386, 0.003850937, 0.0071487427, 0.025604248, -0.0014400482, -0.041412354, 0.008102417, 0.0044441223, 0.035095215, -0.055633545, -0.06008911, 0.0035591125, 0.03869629, -0.007286072, 0.020446777, 0.03881836, -0.0058288574, 0.009666443, -0.007865906, -0.0038604736, -0.024520874, -0.019134521, -0.017318726, 0.035858154, 0.03677368, -0.010787964, 0.013015747, 0.032287598, -0.044067383, -0.0033569336, 0.022766113, -0.009117126, 0.017440796, 0.008369446, 0.034698486, -0.031097412, -0.026245117, -0.04019165, 0.03781128, -0.015068054, 0.021240234, -0.01600647, 0.025894165, -0.0036201477, 0.03515625, -0.052581787, -0.08770752, 0.08093262, 0.04837036, -0.007106781, 0.0041999817, 0.0065193176, 0.008338928, -0.007572174, 0.0008792877, -0.0041236877, 0.024230957, 0.013244629, -0.034484863, 0.01625061, -0.05987549, -0.041778564, -0.027145386, -0.02809143, 0.034057617, -0.033447266, 0.018615723, -0.021743774, -0.018661499, -0.006702423, 0.028137207, -0.014152527, -0.024108887, -0.043426514, -0.026565552, 0.0317688, -0.013549805 ], "summary": [ -0.012062073, -0.01751709, -0.04736328, -0.039154053, -0.040496826, 0.0079574585, -0.08105469, 0.010009766, 0.0019550323, 0.031829834, -0.0011644363, 0.016235352, 0.012771606, -0.03451538, 0.018707275, -0.0018253326, -0.010864258, 0.051971436, -0.015083313, -0.011962891, -0.008666992, -0.02178955, -0.04623413, -0.0044288635, 0.02017212, -0.03567505, -0.029571533, 0.0065078735, -0.012863159, -0.002779007, 0.015617371, 0.031097412, 0.009033203, -0.0026245117, 0.0014915466, 0.017044067, -0.0048446655, -0.0088272095, 0.010498047, 0.00995636, 0.012512207, -0.016326904, 0.038116455, 0.0027542114, -0.01789856, 0.062927246, -0.06384277, -0.05657959, 0.020370483, 0.0059165955, 0.022491455, 0.04748535, 0.017089844, 0.009429932, -0.0181427, -0.018844604, -0.0018758774, -0.019378662, 0.010421753, 0.07897949, 0.010971069, 0.0016355515, -0.01586914, -0.064331055, 0.0011291504, 0.015335083, -0.006038666, -0.015640259, 0.02633667, 0.015014648, 0.0061950684, -0.016586304, 0.029907227, -0.10418701, 0.01285553, 0.092285156, -0.018829346, 0.021240234, 0.03817749, -0.061950684, -0.0015707016, 0.016723633, -0.009292603, -0.046691895, 0.021362305, -0.03326416, -0.0064926147, -0.000849247, -0.0011520386, -0.014831543, -0.014808655, 0.034851074, -0.020996094, 0.033599854, -0.0040397644, -0.010536194, 0.0062294006, -0.013420105, -0.00046014786, -0.0067443848, 0.042419434, -0.026443481, 0.05038452, -0.019073486, 0.024597168, 0.024276733, -0.0042915344, -0.059143066, 0.0012636185, -0.008255005, -0.038513184, 0.014884949, -0.00032949448, -0.021484375, -0.011230469, 0.0053596497, -0.006877899, 0.03756714, 0.0059776306, 0.035980225, -0.023071289, -0.008232117, 0.028915405, 0.09515381, -0.025421143, 0.036346436, 0.04119873, -0.05606079, -0.0063934326, -0.011543274, 0.018875122, 0.04727173, -0.042816162, -0.019317627, -0.051361084, 0.012084961, -0.015533447, 0.02017212, -0.053527832, 0.02973938, -0.020599365, -0.028640747, 0.010009766, -0.031082153, -0.053222656, 0.06518555, 0.039886475, -0.017120361, -0.049224854, -0.09887695, 0.004020691, -0.046325684, 0.010620117, -0.014266968, -0.001124382, -0.046295166, -0.042663574, -0.013786316, 0.031707764, 0.009994507, -0.011924744, 0.008453369, 0.0592041, 0.014373779, 0.011642456, -0.026535034, -0.023117065, -0.007709503, 0.03488159, -0.031555176, 0.02684021, 0.014320374, 0.053222656, 0.013168335, 0.012832642, 0.014862061, -0.0085372925, 0.038360596, 0.019500732, -0.045684814, -0.020843506, -0.03945923, 0.08294678, -0.016311646, -0.023086548, -0.019302368, 0.017044067, 0.065979004, 0.00844574, 0.036315918, -0.020492554, -0.026351929, 0.005657196, 0.016036987, -0.014839172, -0.025299072, -0.05343628, 0.015548706, -0.04547119, -0.0098724365, 0.05883789, -0.0050697327, -0.008430481, -0.04296875, -0.07269287, -0.021331787, -0.0015277863, 0.014945984, -0.040374756, 0.052246094, 0.04626465, -0.00087213516, -0.057128906, 0.055114746, 0.033721924, -0.052612305, -0.021728516, -0.013969421, -0.016052246, -0.0385437, 0.0079574585, -0.013305664, 0.008491516, 0.08001709, -0.0037593842, 0.008300781, -0.009117126, 0.018203735, 0.028884888, 0.026794434, 0.024734497, -0.049041748, 0.024093628, 0.0023727417, -0.033447266, -0.022857666, -0.0066833496, -0.07354736, 0.020080566, 0.06286621, 0.018508911, 0.041259766, -0.019927979, -0.006385803, 0.07183838, 0.028549194, 0.019851685, -0.015342712, -0.0070533752, 0.021194458, 0.02935791, 0.006099701, 0.029373169, -0.0075149536, 0.016052246, 0.041625977, -0.011161804, -0.052581787, -0.0137786865, -0.018005371, 0.040008545, -0.04434204, -0.060668945, 0.0017337799, -0.056549072, -0.061828613, -0.044647217, -0.04220581, 0.016464233, -0.040252686, 0.028884888, -0.029724121, 0.014678955, -0.04714966, -0.053588867, -0.025024414, -0.013374329, 0.041992188, 0.031951904, -0.044281006, -0.014549255, -0.0155181885, -0.01878357, -0.010734558, 0.044036865, 0.0021018982, 0.014030457, -0.016784668, 0.026687622, 0.068847656, 0.055633545, 0.023529053, 0.022155762, 0.02748108, -0.02218628, 0.0132369995, 0.006580353, 0.027023315, -0.0022182465, -0.009712219, 0.030319214, 0.04296875, -0.02470398, 0.008293152, -0.0018863678, -0.0024528503, 0.0256958, -0.0073623657, -0.01322937, -0.010749817, -0.009185791, 0.049468994, 0.012550354, 0.05230713, -0.064208984, -0.054992676, -0.031051636, 0.01108551, -0.052337646, -0.0019798279, 0.07287598, -0.042510986, 0.021270752, 0.037139893, -0.01939392, -0.05239868, 0.06542969, -0.019119263, 0.018432617, -0.0077400208, -0.035491943, -0.02218628, -0.04144287, 0.0124435425, -0.009918213, -0.014762878, 0.013168335, -0.020889282, 0.00573349, 0.049926758, 0.06335449, -0.020507812, 0.00057935715, -0.0070991516, -0.029159546, -0.003648758, 0.029251099, 0.005844116, 0.0052948, 0.0032367706, 0.004020691, -0.017150879, 0.013549805, 0.047576904, 0.027236938, -0.080078125, -0.025482178, 0.03677368, -0.050445557, -0.03463745, 0.05227661, -0.0046691895, -0.00095415115, -0.06365967, 0.0066452026, -0.042419434, -0.015945435, -0.05493164, 0.032165527, 0.022994995, 0.02708435, 0.008575439, -0.01991272, -0.021469116, -0.0030117035, -0.034332275, 0.037139893, -0.013473511, -0.006965637, 0.014678955, 0.013252258, 0.021865845, 0.01436615, 0.029022217, 0.10107422, 0.017318726, 0.022781372, 0.018661499, 0.025054932, 0.0038108826, -0.021942139, -0.049072266, -0.00944519, -0.009971619, 0.022399902, 0.008110046, -0.03213501, -0.016601562, -0.060028076, -0.0047683716, 0.054260254, 0.045898438, 0.04244995, 0.024139404, -0.06097412, 0.08050537, -0.0046958923, 0.0127334595, 0.05053711, 0.0050201416, 0.012672424, -0.03543091, 0.0074501038, -0.050720215, -0.031555176, 0.0074501038, -0.051116943, 0.013404846, -0.047821045, 0.012878418, -0.0055274963, 0.04736328, -0.014877319, 0.030273438, 0.016906738, 0.050445557, -0.04425049, -0.018173218, -0.025421143, -0.011520386, -0.027648926, -0.020355225, -0.015914917, -0.019577026, -0.0440979, 0.034454346, 0.0116119385, 0.036499023, 0.028137207, -0.03668213, -0.04510498, -0.027297974, -0.035614014, -0.052246094, -0.021026611, -0.037261963, 0.025222778, -0.011177063, -0.0070343018, 0.032104492, -0.060302734, -0.0141067505, -0.039978027, 0.036224365, -0.047546387, 0.06488037, -0.023025513, 0.028381348, 0.03652954, -0.00017917156, 0.023925781, -0.0071907043, -0.02293396, 0.00038647652, 0.037963867, 0.030197144, -0.032470703, 0.017684937, -0.0037269592, -0.016052246, 0.04257202, -0.035614014, 0.0011434555, -0.014144897, 0.0071258545, -0.03942871, 0.018585205, 0.015838623, 0.010261536, -0.026031494, -0.02218628, 0.013496399, -0.0061035156, -0.016555786, 0.0079193115, 0.0061035156, -0.041900635, -0.03387451, -0.014320374, 0.020584106, 0.008071899, -0.042541504, 0.048309326, -0.055755615, -0.056030273, 0.03186035, -0.014556885, 0.020767212, 0.022079468, -0.036132812, 0.02671814, -0.0014657974, 0.0041275024, 0.014122009, 0.01928711, 0.01159668, 0.0054397583, 0.021072388, 0.0026111603, 0.0049552917, 0.01335907, -0.008674622, -0.016494751, -0.028823853, 0.0057029724, -0.036743164, 0.052703857, -0.07446289, 0.019729614, 0.029693604, 0.0068626404, 0.0018281937, 0.04019165, -0.0042495728, -0.015357971, 0.010269165, 0.034210205, 0.023834229, -0.0010604858, -0.007331848, 0.047729492, -0.0043907166, 0.020965576, 0.013809204, -0.010299683, 0.01512146, -0.04171753, -0.008346558, 0.0019130707, -0.008872986, -0.050994873, -0.017944336, 0.018569946, 0.055389404, -0.0024776459, -0.009666443, -0.0052871704, 0.015388489, 0.008918762, -0.0126953125, 0.002084732, 0.013008118, -0.029632568, -0.032043457, -0.017333984, -0.030426025, 0.003894806, -0.00016438961, -0.013412476, 0.021530151, 0.04156494, 0.023925781, 0.0071525574, -0.042236328, 0.027236938, 0.016738892, -0.042236328, -0.08453369, -0.0064315796, -0.013824463, -0.046813965, -0.035217285, -0.02142334, -0.019195557, -0.024108887, 0.009994507, 0.008956909, 0.028121948, 0.01739502, 0.013511658, 0.027038574, -0.008895874, -0.027496338, 0.002506256, -0.039093018, 0.009353638, -0.0018043518, 0.02696228, -0.02482605, -0.022842407, 0.0104599, -0.00548172, -0.017105103, -0.052001953, -0.0090789795, 0.008346558, 0.008865356, 0.043914795, 0.028640747, 0.014297485, 0.03817749, -0.015731812, 0.0022659302, -0.009780884, -0.009132385, -0.032806396, -0.009208679, 0.05154419, -0.013648987, 0.027496338, -0.016464233, 0.012382507, -0.0026874542, -0.029174805, -0.0072021484, 0.03793335, 0.022598267, -0.0056877136, -0.009437561, -0.026062012, 0.018630981, -0.006855011, 0.011390686, 0.026504517, -0.015991211, -0.00091695786, -0.00068950653, -0.014778137, -0.027511597, 0.030395508, 0.010520935, 0.009468079, -0.0413208, -0.0496521, -0.003232956, 0.059906006, -0.02305603, -0.0057907104, -0.03918457, -0.03704834, 0.011146545, -0.004623413, 0.006866455, -0.038848877, 0.039154053, -0.014503479, 0.003458023, 0.022888184, -0.024093628, -0.014640808, -0.010101318, 0.013397217, 0.023361206, -0.020751953, -0.006641388, -0.016342163, 0.0035514832, 0.0020771027, 0.013374329, -0.039489746, -0.03274536, 0.019989014, -0.020507812, -0.016479492, 0.019744873, -0.016815186, -0.01626587, 0.008552551, -0.026321411, -0.010612488, -0.011711121, -0.06402588, 0.06060791, 0.0024662018, 0.011489868, -0.013381958, 0.01651001, -0.010314941, 0.0031261444, -0.025482178, 0.002840042, -0.04360962, -0.0018463135, -0.0063552856, -0.007785797, -0.0013160706, 0.0049972534, 0.027816772, 0.0015354156, -0.01108551, -0.07287598, -0.10870361, -0.011062622, -0.12188721, -0.026779175, -0.050811768, -0.0524292, -0.02217102, 0.0121154785, -0.0018587112, -0.016403198, 0.0003349781, -0.0044670105, -0.033996582, 0.017242432, -0.0047950745, 0.014976501, -0.034454346, 0.049926758, 0.019042969, -0.014129639, 0.017303467, -0.06161499, -0.02279663, -0.051849365, -0.018341064, -0.0013570786, 0.03274536, 0.048217773, 0.028778076, -0.0022335052, 0.028244019, 0.009429932, -0.030227661, 0.036254883, -0.04598999, -0.028762817, 0.015640259, -0.0066947937, -0.00044679642, -0.0058403015, -0.0146102905, -0.010917664, 0.0011377335, -0.0020332336, 0.009117126, 0.04421997, -0.03652954, 0.021942139, -0.02420044, -0.0021705627, 0.010597229, 0.028778076, 0.012535095, -0.015838623, 0.036315918, 0.017211914, -0.0034656525, 0.007167816, -0.0037765503, 0.007335663, -0.0028305054, 0.011421204, -0.011627197, 0.019241333, -0.04788208, -0.010414124, -0.004673004, 0.029632568, -0.023788452, -0.03869629, -0.007167816, 0.011260986, 0.018737793, 0.026473999, 0.03717041, 0.031677246, 0.049621582, 0.005607605, -0.022399902, -0.043304443, 0.012802124, -0.014328003, -0.018081665, 0.048034668, -0.018356323, -0.059326172, 0.060821533, 0.023040771, 0.034606934, -0.04574585, 0.07946777, -0.010986328, -0.0010347366, -0.019256592, 0.010032654, 0.051635742, 0.0047950745, -0.033569336, -0.00046253204, 0.025466919, 0.044525146, 0.044311523, 0.0019989014, 0.004863739, 0.021118164, 0.047027588, 0.007385254, 0.006652832, 0.0025844574, 0.05895996, -0.019134521, 0.0037765503, -0.05279541, -0.03265381, -0.037902832, 0.03591919, -0.012275696, -0.020065308, -0.029968262, 0.009048462, -0.045135498, 0.051086426, 0.005493164, 0.02986145, -0.0149002075, -0.005378723, -0.0029392242, 0.0113220215, -0.035064697, 0.0074424744, 0.045715332, -0.014961243, 0.022506714, 0.0007863045, -0.009941101, 0.003917694, -0.0024909973, -0.007080078, -0.038085938, 0.014862061, -0.03543091, 0.035186768, 0.024978638, 0.04119873, 0.01940918, -0.00014078617, -0.025909424, 0.009269714, 0.0039978027, 0.03527832, -0.016906738, 0.041107178, 0.037475586, -0.023117065, 0.012939453, 0.02319336, -0.033416748, 0.05026245, 0.0051193237, 0.04031372, -0.043823242, -0.019683838, 0.015594482, 0.018188477, -0.020202637, -0.00022518635, -0.03778076, -0.00605011, -0.03692627, -0.02180481, 0.009918213, 0.00090932846, -0.0057792664, 0.018966675, 0.061431885, 0.0033950806, 0.013786316, -0.009422302, 0.044921875, 0.047973633, 0.024398804, -0.0124435425, -0.009384155, -0.02418518, -0.021957397, 0.04260254, -0.01777649, 0.006587982, 0.029067993, 0.060455322, 0.07659912, 0.06933594, -0.032409668, 0.03074646, 0.070129395, -0.0181427, 0.02999878, 0.027435303, 0.015419006, 0.007335663, -0.06097412, -0.026443481, -0.022064209, -0.07006836, 0.023040771, -0.047821045, -0.016464233, -0.0625, 0.03161621, -0.05050659, -0.021957397, 0.003993988, -0.07165527, -0.068725586, 0.005466461, 0.024887085, -0.026977539, 0.0014419556, -0.039489746, -0.03753662, -0.03353882, -0.0066986084, 0.015205383, -0.012275696, -0.0033092499, 0.010696411, 0.0022392273, 0.054840088, -0.014762878, -0.031951904, 0.021102905, 0.007545471, 0.014122009, -0.061767578, -0.035614014, -0.013557434, 0.014762878, 0.04598999, -0.012825012, 0.024642944, 0.0022697449, -0.05682373, -0.0070343018, 0.020324707, -0.04321289, 0.04711914, 0.03213501, -0.029220581, -0.01763916, 0.020248413, -0.004901886, 0.044036865, -0.011306763, -0.019073486, 0.066345215, 0.004928589, -0.026062012, 0.021255493, -0.01890564, -0.005558014, 0.00046992302, -0.031585693, 0.009681702, -0.048797607, -0.010070801, -0.05517578, -0.103271484, -0.00030112267, 0.06555176, -0.0076904297, -0.038513184, -0.006587982, -0.02999878, 0.03225708, 0.010826111, 0.00039672852, -0.0137786865, 0.025222778, 0.014892578, 0.034210205, 0.00447464, -0.027923584, 0.023803711, 0.0062294006, -0.044677734, -0.022140503, 0.019821167, 0.018951416, -0.0074806213, 0.008331299, 0.010650635, -0.04333496, -0.032989502, 0.057922363, 0.028213501, -0.029846191, -0.0038394928, -0.027511597, -0.015945435, 0.0016078949, -0.048431396, -0.042175293, -0.023025513, 0.03857422, 0.018157959, 0.0141067505, -0.07171631, 0.034362793, 0.030319214, -0.015464783, 0.040893555, 0.004501343, 0.06378174, -0.009773254, 0.00096416473, 0.022125244, -0.0524292, -0.03152466, -0.05633545, -0.008026123, 0.0042266846, -0.017028809, 0.017120361, 0.033416748, -0.034851074, 0.008857727, 0.037322998, 0.0034770966, 0.021453857, -0.0039978027, -0.012428284, 0.00592041, 0.0043678284 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07564v1
Can Authorship Attribution Models Distinguish Speakers in Speech Transcripts?
Cristina Aggazzotti, Nicholas Andrews, Elizabeth Allyn Smith
cs.CL, cs.LG
Authorship verification is the problem of determining if two distinct writing samples share the same author and is typically concerned with the attribution of written text. In this paper, we explore the attribution of transcribed speech, which poses novel challenges. The main challenge is that many stylistic features, such as punctuation and capitalization, are not available or reliable. Therefore, we expect a priori that transcribed speech is a more challenging domain for attribution. On the other hand, other stylistic features, such as speech disfluencies, may enable more successful attribution but, being specific to speech, require special purpose models. To better understand the challenges of this setting, we contribute the first systematic study of speaker attribution based solely on transcribed speech. Specifically, we propose a new benchmark for speaker attribution focused on conversational speech transcripts. To control for spurious associations of speakers with topic, we employ both conversation prompts and speakers' participating in the same conversation to construct challenging verification trials of varying difficulties. We establish the state of the art on this new benchmark by comparing a suite of neural and non-neural baselines, finding that although written text attribution models achieve surprisingly good performance in certain settings, they struggle in the hardest settings we consider.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07564v1
2023-11-13T18:54:17
2023-11-13T18:54:17
{ "title": [ -0.020507812, 0.030334473, -0.055664062, -0.039031982, -0.017440796, -0.009773254, -0.07019043, -0.02330017, -0.038269043, 0.03857422, 0.0031852722, 0.012107849, 0.0002553463, -0.026229858, -0.01033783, -0.007511139, -0.039367676, 0.07611084, 0.0008034706, -0.036193848, 0.0001386404, -0.07055664, -0.037719727, -0.032104492, 0.04647827, -0.017196655, -0.025466919, 0.004032135, 0.021530151, -0.013137817, 0.019683838, -0.035980225, 0.029785156, 0.017868042, 0.00006723404, 0.021865845, -0.04284668, 0.047088623, 0.019485474, -0.017623901, 0.030975342, -0.033416748, 0.0018224716, -0.0004644394, -0.013961792, -0.003780365, 0.011528015, -0.019943237, 0.01058197, 0.03479004, -0.042175293, 0.015380859, -0.027435303, 0.038146973, 0.001326561, -0.045959473, -0.032287598, 0.04425049, 0.016860962, -0.016311646, -0.0014371872, 0.031707764, 0.026031494, 0.044708252, -0.024215698, -0.041534424, -0.028137207, 0.024353027, 0.035858154, -0.010940552, 0.018035889, 0.012008667, -0.00894928, -0.018707275, -0.047729492, 0.011413574, -0.0048599243, -0.01701355, 0.035583496, -0.0289917, -0.021820068, -0.03967285, 0.044403076, -0.029067993, 0.02192688, -0.015853882, -0.00774765, 0.0028305054, -0.031311035, -0.032196045, -0.002166748, -0.010971069, -0.0082473755, 0.01940918, -0.03515625, -0.030441284, 0.019760132, 0.09118652, -0.04144287, -0.06088257, -0.06890869, 0.04296875, -0.124572754, -0.015197754, 0.011978149, 0.03062439, -0.02331543, -0.011924744, 0.021194458, 0.023452759, -0.022445679, 0.038238525, 0.008369446, -0.031463623, -0.010902405, 0.012550354, -0.02279663, 0.01058197, 0.021606445, 0.0035915375, -0.016921997, 0.0010871887, 0.021148682, -0.01348114, 0.046173096, 0.0054016113, -0.03817749, 0.004486084, 0.022842407, 0.031585693, 0.004852295, 0.06616211, -0.07312012, -0.090148926, -0.06713867, 0.031799316, -0.0025615692, -0.013923645, -0.032226562, 0.030883789, 0.009338379, -0.025970459, 0.036743164, -0.015159607, -0.02432251, 0.019577026, 0.038482666, 0.0256958, -0.043884277, -0.061279297, -0.00016152859, 0.002521515, -0.012466431, -0.004524231, 0.02822876, -0.068603516, -0.05722046, -0.032043457, 0.092163086, -0.0020370483, 0.04296875, 0.002231598, -0.02758789, 0.028900146, -0.0014829636, -0.023773193, 0.036346436, 0.024749756, 0.015426636, -0.004009247, -0.034942627, 0.012290955, 0.012481689, 0.035949707, 0.008132935, 0.042053223, -0.00592041, 0.0053138733, 0.0045166016, 0.002828598, 0.0073242188, -0.03074646, -0.03945923, 0.03463745, -0.08721924, 0.007511139, 0.013374329, 0.07287598, 0.040130615, 0.0022907257, 0.015174866, 0.014831543, -0.028533936, -0.068603516, -0.043121338, 0.010101318, 0.025619507, 0.026489258, 0.006011963, 0.027709961, 0.01209259, -0.013389587, 0.00067806244, -0.006214142, -0.037750244, -0.031982422, -0.019515991, 0.0060920715, 0.015975952, 0.031982422, 0.023605347, -0.017410278, -0.016052246, 0.02708435, -0.025161743, -0.046051025, 0.008666992, -0.0061149597, 0.000603199, -0.00806427, -0.007797241, 0.0032920837, -0.010215759, 0.013465881, -0.014976501, -0.0058059692, -0.0013751984, -0.015586853, 0.02180481, 0.007865906, 0.07946777, -0.03100586, 0.07611084, 0.07043457, -0.00013244152, -0.010559082, 0.018295288, -0.044128418, -0.0096206665, 0.0051116943, 0.0068740845, -0.026062012, 0.0004887581, 0.026168823, 0.047180176, 0.0015382767, 0.009429932, 0.011810303, 0.025894165, 0.028015137, 0.039215088, -0.029556274, 0.036224365, -0.044921875, 0.026184082, 0.046203613, -0.021606445, -0.014183044, -0.016723633, -0.01171875, 0.03527832, 0.045013428, 0.016403198, 0.0012178421, -0.041290283, 0.011627197, -0.024169922, 0.0065841675, -0.049682617, 0.009849548, 0.039642334, 0.05883789, 0.0149002075, 0.0178833, 0.03286743, 0.015129089, -0.013961792, -0.011375427, 0.04849243, 0.0028858185, -0.013168335, 0.0027389526, 0.03086853, 0.008590698, -0.0077285767, 0.0064697266, 0.05532837, 0.014732361, -0.03656006, -0.012962341, 0.029769897, 0.04562378, 0.020324707, 0.007461548, 0.019683838, 0.015853882, 0.04260254, 0.027053833, -0.024917603, 0.019515991, -0.029830933, 0.033294678, 0.02204895, 0.0067749023, -0.006549835, 0.03778076, -0.008018494, -0.004508972, -0.018875122, 0.024002075, -0.011795044, 0.043060303, 0.01259613, 0.019210815, -0.025863647, -0.015090942, 0.008842468, 0.011749268, -0.025436401, -0.031585693, 0.089660645, -0.027572632, -0.019592285, -0.02015686, -0.032348633, -0.019210815, -0.024002075, -0.041259766, 0.047821045, 0.014442444, 0.017349243, 0.016403198, -0.07495117, -0.05041504, 0.0047035217, 0.007709503, -0.0039520264, -0.027374268, -0.00094270706, 0.014259338, 0.0061912537, -0.008102417, -0.0066452026, -0.030578613, -0.018554688, -0.0368042, -0.009414673, 0.008392334, 0.00762558, -0.029327393, 0.031311035, -0.0038032532, -0.0054244995, 0.00026369095, 0.055664062, 0.0016489029, -0.010093689, 0.0036334991, 0.022216797, -0.028869629, 0.06707764, 0.042175293, 0.03967285, -0.024414062, -0.045776367, -0.08868408, -0.023071289, 0.0056533813, 0.020523071, 0.036712646, -0.04788208, -0.017059326, -0.034851074, 0.020187378, 0.03213501, 0.015640259, -0.02456665, -0.053253174, -0.0011339188, -0.030075073, -0.009895325, -0.01890564, 0.018936157, 0.02067566, 0.030914307, 0.032714844, 0.0029621124, -0.027160645, 0.012084961, -0.0075531006, -0.010818481, -0.0034732819, -0.048461914, -0.015213013, 0.044677734, 0.010627747, -0.00022470951, 0.005104065, -0.05126953, -0.021118164, 0.054626465, -0.020065308, -0.03463745, 0.051940918, -0.056762695, 0.012931824, 0.024093628, -0.04208374, 0.026535034, -0.010543823, 0.008781433, -0.0033626556, 0.03692627, -0.040893555, 0.009239197, -0.040222168, -0.09460449, 0.016433716, -0.031433105, -0.020965576, -0.00856781, 0.0026779175, -0.038513184, -0.002773285, -0.0121536255, 0.041625977, 0.015159607, -0.001452446, 0.0009288788, -0.007434845, -0.004600525, -0.0126953125, -0.0057029724, -0.03189087, -0.015930176, -0.0025730133, -0.0149002075, 0.05822754, 0.036193848, -0.009407043, -0.035369873, 0.006046295, 0.0034656525, 0.03201294, 0.00054597855, -0.034210205, -0.008972168, -0.02204895, -0.0129776, 0.008125305, -0.010879517, 0.003917694, -0.03326416, 0.015319824, -0.018310547, 0.028671265, -0.018310547, 0.029174805, -0.017120361, 0.016235352, 0.023406982, 0.0011997223, -0.02003479, -0.001750946, 0.014717102, -0.006099701, -0.021713257, 0.009262085, -0.017059326, -0.0032634735, 0.017791748, 0.044952393, -0.020767212, -0.022079468, 0.02696228, 0.04534912, -0.0077056885, -0.021377563, -0.014801025, -0.0107803345, -0.04574585, 0.029876709, -0.05303955, -0.062316895, -0.042999268, 0.015701294, -0.068359375, -0.008682251, 0.035308838, -0.068237305, -0.045043945, -0.026931763, 0.018737793, -0.04937744, -0.012275696, -0.0032157898, -0.011962891, 0.0026512146, -0.012763977, -0.10131836, 0.011070251, 0.059020996, -0.03781128, 0.028747559, 0.024490356, 0.0012521744, 0.016326904, -0.011138916, 0.010314941, -0.015068054, 0.056365967, -0.014457703, -0.0031147003, 0.011253357, -0.009864807, 0.015365601, 0.05331421, -0.019744873, 0.023727417, -0.0018806458, 0.015068054, 0.039031982, -0.021133423, 0.054504395, 0.012199402, -0.020751953, -0.05407715, 0.017044067, -0.032165527, 0.028030396, -0.006149292, 0.004058838, 0.035217285, -0.009536743, 0.038757324, -0.00072336197, -0.018127441, -0.012145996, 0.021102905, -0.023132324, -0.024734497, -0.025360107, -0.00409317, 0.022888184, -0.01309967, -0.0001732111, -0.03567505, 0.022338867, -0.028579712, -0.023117065, 0.013267517, 0.026473999, -0.0036392212, 0.024597168, -0.056274414, -0.029174805, -0.0713501, 0.012329102, -0.0036792755, 0.07720947, 0.016952515, 0.062316895, -0.03869629, -0.02935791, 0.06097412, -0.00024485588, 0.016113281, -0.029800415, -0.031951904, -0.01586914, -0.048187256, -0.0054740906, -0.009269714, -0.029144287, 0.02180481, -0.011764526, -0.02909851, -0.001036644, 0.018096924, 0.01158905, 0.05596924, -0.0070610046, -0.04260254, -0.048065186, -0.041015625, -0.0038337708, 0.012451172, 0.008926392, -0.0135269165, -0.006580353, 0.03439331, -0.017349243, -0.019546509, -0.023529053, 0.054901123, -0.03604126, 0.05596924, -0.021133423, 0.008216858, 0.027053833, 0.008415222, 0.014770508, 0.008407593, -0.025115967, -0.000027418137, 0.007949829, 0.02192688, -0.0019931793, 0.0046958923, 0.0637207, 0.034179688, -0.048797607, 0.013748169, 0.0049743652, 0.04034424, 0.055786133, 0.045410156, -0.028793335, -0.019363403, -0.037353516, 0.01852417, 0.013458252, 0.045196533, -0.0016107559, 0.012756348, -0.02168274, 0.0009794235, 0.011314392, 0.016540527, 0.04006958, 0.017562866, 0.013916016, -0.039398193, -0.008834839, 0.03604126, -0.004787445, -0.029067993, 0.0057525635, -0.013130188, -0.01940918, -0.01133728, 0.01965332, -0.023468018, 0.06072998, -0.036376953, -0.02029419, 0.0010509491, -0.032348633, -0.046417236, -0.042266846, -0.020935059, -0.00831604, 0.0008687973, 0.027496338, -0.039855957, -0.012512207, -0.06945801, -0.028213501, 0.027236938, -0.033355713, 0.022064209, 0.08666992, -0.017959595, 0.09631348, -0.02507019, 0.026489258, 0.0473938, 0.037994385, -0.0028457642, -0.005596161, 0.038970947, -0.042755127, 0.024246216, -0.021530151, 0.025878906, 0.00617218, 0.052124023, 0.029174805, 0.06451416, -0.078186035, 0.00484848, 0.04196167, 0.03048706, 0.0022640228, -0.057525635, 0.0552063, 0.029846191, -0.037231445, 0.018615723, -0.004547119, -0.057037354, -0.016036987, 0.0075035095, -0.017807007, -0.015853882, -0.009506226, -0.06439209, 0.020996094, 0.03552246, 0.019638062, -0.013504028, 0.010391235, 0.010040283, -0.0072746277, 0.021881104, 0.045074463, -0.037139893, 0.021514893, 0.0029582977, 0.0035686493, 0.05697632, 0.04852295, -0.009124756, 0.002960205, -0.013549805, -0.03866577, -0.0057868958, 0.040130615, 0.011482239, -0.00009602308, 0.009086609, -0.033081055, 0.021499634, -0.019119263, 0.016799927, -0.011047363, 0.021438599, 0.036895752, 0.0079574585, 0.025848389, 0.0038642883, 0.0030403137, 0.01335144, 0.0049934387, 0.015808105, -0.060913086, 0.026123047, 0.021499634, 0.05734253, -0.054473877, -0.044708252, -0.004776001, 0.03567505, 0.0132751465, -0.016143799, 0.054138184, 0.03869629, -0.01828003, 0.02293396, 0.025924683, 0.0791626, -0.048919678, -0.024765015, -0.018615723, 0.0027103424, -0.0020503998, 0.03451538, -0.03050232, -0.02659607, -0.02281189, -0.008415222, -0.012756348, 0.020690918, 0.0046310425, -0.04168701, -0.011108398, -0.0119018555, 0.0017795563, -0.043548584, -0.008659363, -0.027648926, 0.0541687, -0.00592041, -0.008972168, -0.008850098, -0.03994751, -0.00008237362, -0.029434204, 0.018539429, 0.026046753, -0.016464233, 0.034088135, -0.008995056, -0.0012102127, -0.03390503, -0.0178833, 0.02923584, 0.03857422, -0.03253174, 0.03845215, -0.01713562, 0.05657959, 0.031219482, 0.07196045, 0.027175903, 0.009353638, 0.015296936, 0.02758789, 0.0031604767, -0.02229309, 0.0209198, -0.07714844, -0.01461792, -0.05532837, -0.015670776, -0.081970215, -0.0128479, 0.009315491, -0.002319336, 0.00894165, 0.011268616, 0.023971558, -0.028137207, 0.039489746, -0.043640137, 0.030548096, -0.026565552, 0.024276733, -0.03857422, -0.08911133, 0.042236328, 0.042053223, -0.010093689, -0.0138549805, -0.020843506, -0.024276733, 0.005580902, -0.014083862, 0.02822876, -0.0064811707, -0.021270752, -0.01739502, 0.02470398, 0.0005726814, 0.023773193, 0.02822876, -0.007003784, -0.008407593, 0.010017395, -0.004245758, -0.024597168, 0.0045204163, -0.06854248, -0.0008955002, -0.009689331, 0.008056641, -0.028137207, -0.007774353, -0.04272461, 0.06536865, -0.0128479, -0.01033783, 0.0033912659, 0.016082764, 0.00819397, 0.04156494, 0.018249512, -0.041381836, -0.05935669, -0.0061912537, 0.03152466, -0.031280518, -0.00774765, -0.0036506653, 0.012542725, -0.011123657, -0.04284668, 0.0037899017, -0.010467529, -0.023925781, 0.032409668, 0.03086853, -0.013618469, -0.022994995, -0.033203125, -0.034484863, 0.01360321, 0.010787964, -0.023864746, 0.013595581, 0.024642944, 0.011390686, 0.05331421, 0.021743774, 0.005470276, -0.03805542, 0.005886078, -0.0013446808, 0.030807495, -0.0077056885, -0.0048103333, -0.014038086, -0.02734375, 0.046875, -0.003829956, 0.09295654, -0.048431396, -0.015419006, -0.056884766, 0.057159424, 0.0049362183, -0.040130615, -0.07354736, -0.019683838, -0.015609741, 0.009262085, 0.034606934, -0.015380859, -0.0037212372, -0.01927185, -0.0024166107, 0.013122559, 0.03555298, 0.066223145, -0.01701355, -0.05142212, 0.054870605, -0.0021877289, 0.09716797, -0.042938232, -0.025268555, -0.010971069, 0.0047073364, 0.047302246, -0.009307861, -0.0368042, 0.021087646, -0.010421753, -0.02027893, 0.0028762817, -0.008232117, -0.018218994, -0.0042037964, 0.015022278, 0.0075645447, -0.023864746, 0.028060913, 0.016235352, -0.023330688, -0.068725586, 0.0050582886, -0.03024292, 0.02041626, -0.0027236938, -0.01737976, 0.04257202, 0.006439209, -0.045562744, 0.01210022, 0.020141602, 0.04244995, 0.0049476624, -0.042022705, 0.022918701, -0.006790161, 0.041137695, -0.045013428, -0.018844604, -0.007423401, 0.051971436, -0.004486084, 0.042053223, 0.044006348, 0.040985107, -0.020767212, -0.00356102, -0.010467529, -0.039978027, 0.034576416, 0.022994995, 0.028457642, 0.0317688, -0.018341064, 0.02104187, -0.017562866, -0.009422302, -0.020706177, 0.011444092, -0.033691406, -0.020584106, 0.01210022, -0.01007843, -0.010124207, -0.035583496, -0.0637207, -0.018188477, 0.0040397644, -0.00040388107, -0.015113831, 0.031082153, -0.034973145, 0.047546387, -0.022888184, -0.046783447, 0.019424438, 0.040283203, 0.0029277802, 0.027572632, 0.0024929047, -0.0074501038, -0.01826477, -0.002161026, 0.015197754, 0.026809692, 0.0362854, -0.054626465, -0.0024089813, -0.07733154, -0.037231445, -0.05331421, -0.032318115, 0.01335144, -0.039489746, 0.03515625, -0.046936035, 0.018615723, 0.019104004, 0.024368286, -0.0040779114, -0.0008997917, -0.041046143, 0.011207581, 0.025131226, -0.029052734 ], "summary": [ 0.017105103, 0.011306763, -0.005027771, -0.033935547, -0.02508545, 0.0015420914, -0.0859375, -0.040863037, -0.037750244, 0.0597229, 0.018127441, 0.01751709, 0.04449463, -0.020980835, 0.017669678, 0.014030457, -0.03878784, 0.05596924, -0.028656006, -0.047546387, -0.014472961, -0.07019043, -0.08441162, -0.017654419, 0.040618896, -0.049316406, 0.07928467, -0.0009841919, 0.059509277, 0.030075073, 0.040496826, -0.09777832, 0.0022354126, 0.038482666, -0.014160156, 0.012710571, -0.027374268, 0.047729492, 0.016235352, 0.0062446594, 0.034210205, -0.021591187, 0.019515991, 0.0025043488, -0.018737793, 0.0077400208, 0.038970947, -0.013999939, 0.05316162, 0.039733887, -0.025222778, 0.0018749237, -0.044952393, 0.011016846, -0.011489868, -0.03314209, -0.030639648, 0.019226074, -0.013366699, 0.02748108, 0.035980225, 0.046295166, 0.0024051666, 0.020248413, -0.0040626526, -0.011993408, -0.0003297329, 0.020553589, 0.030395508, 0.0040893555, 0.0036239624, 0.001698494, -0.02746582, -0.046905518, 0.022445679, 0.07092285, -0.036834717, 0.017410278, 0.0022563934, 0.02861023, -0.022964478, -0.0385437, 0.02609253, -0.016967773, -0.016494751, -0.019897461, -0.012809753, 0.013038635, -0.024429321, -0.017868042, 0.00030136108, -0.023391724, -0.05154419, 0.037322998, 0.019119263, -0.043914795, 0.020828247, 0.06750488, -0.043762207, -0.030685425, -0.003414154, -0.0025615692, -0.05606079, -0.039245605, -0.0009622574, 0.0037059784, -0.023635864, -0.033172607, 0.018051147, 0.028213501, -0.020019531, 0.008285522, -0.01272583, -0.07287598, 0.00737381, 0.06567383, 0.000010967255, 0.02154541, 0.030654907, 0.0015935898, -0.030258179, 0.03086853, -0.012893677, -0.0040664673, 0.017822266, 0.010505676, 0.0042762756, -0.009742737, 0.011558533, 0.009544373, -0.010040283, 0.037353516, -0.012237549, -0.04067993, -0.06021118, 0.006996155, 0.021652222, -0.0025310516, -0.02330017, 0.0051345825, -0.0055503845, 0.01008606, 0.052978516, -0.040618896, -0.062561035, 0.030151367, 0.01928711, -0.013313293, -0.051086426, -0.04043579, -0.029281616, -0.015541077, 0.015472412, -0.025558472, 0.009986877, -0.124938965, -0.039611816, -0.044769287, 0.11193848, -0.030319214, 0.031982422, -0.008842468, -0.0418396, 0.05999756, -0.009857178, 0.0093307495, 0.06329346, -0.0056266785, 0.014259338, -0.008171082, -0.030044556, 0.011581421, 0.002998352, 0.034729004, 0.0056877136, 0.037475586, -0.04083252, 0.0058021545, 0.021972656, 0.0059318542, 0.015052795, -0.03050232, -0.018997192, 0.034820557, -0.03778076, -0.004348755, 0.030654907, 0.07312012, 0.022506714, 0.020339966, 0.009178162, -0.023788452, 0.011985779, -0.04159546, -0.017745972, -0.024459839, 0.010398865, 0.009307861, -0.0042152405, 0.019577026, 0.036132812, -0.035095215, 0.008728027, -0.03149414, -0.059631348, -0.042388916, -0.013450623, 0.0029525757, -0.0003452301, 0.016540527, 0.00793457, -0.014205933, -0.017974854, 0.035614014, -0.014129639, -0.032348633, 0.024551392, 0.0058517456, -0.008926392, -0.0018558502, -0.005016327, -0.008033752, -0.035888672, 0.03378296, -0.04574585, -0.009483337, -0.010543823, 0.005596161, -0.008346558, 0.0002808571, 0.0670166, -0.012962341, 0.049743652, 0.045776367, 0.01789856, 0.011802673, 0.018814087, -0.08428955, -0.016525269, 0.013023376, 0.019470215, -0.00969696, -0.02810669, 0.0063591003, -0.002155304, -0.017745972, 0.011764526, -0.0044441223, 0.031051636, 0.037872314, 0.0004208088, -0.045196533, 0.03237915, -0.05630493, 0.02142334, 0.020568848, -0.011482239, 0.005596161, -0.009239197, -0.01550293, 0.004283905, 0.00944519, 0.013046265, -0.020874023, 0.002325058, -0.009437561, -0.012802124, -0.015258789, -0.035461426, 0.002155304, 0.027786255, 0.0016307831, -0.0126571655, 0.003074646, 0.052093506, 0.045837402, -0.031677246, -0.011421204, 0.03475952, 0.01586914, 0.0011701584, 0.012290955, 0.043304443, 0.00019276142, -0.006198883, 0.0045928955, 0.048034668, 0.027557373, -0.011222839, 0.01574707, 0.044799805, 0.030883789, -0.0051612854, 0.0034503937, 0.033721924, 0.0047569275, 0.040893555, -0.018554688, 0.0045280457, -0.005455017, 0.05899048, 0.058166504, -0.016784668, 0.026779175, 0.017227173, 0.018539429, -0.015571594, -0.0028514862, 0.00083112717, -0.0014677048, 0.015914917, 0.068481445, 0.023712158, 0.05328369, -0.012702942, -0.036987305, 0.013320923, 0.035064697, -0.018310547, -0.034576416, 0.09869385, 0.00017738342, -0.0043258667, 0.013633728, -0.017349243, -0.028213501, 0.0262146, -0.03829956, 0.06262207, -0.021377563, -0.009460449, -0.010681152, -0.084106445, -0.047973633, 0.013153076, 0.0073280334, 0.01838684, -0.0579834, -0.0035362244, 0.021331787, 0.045837402, 0.0039482117, -0.0037708282, -0.004234314, -0.0637207, 0.0340271, 0.0016460419, 0.005706787, -0.020004272, -0.0036907196, 0.018234253, -0.02029419, -0.015296936, 0.0013875961, 0.0262146, 0.0022296906, 0.010551453, 0.014701843, 0.023025513, -0.04144287, 0.042510986, 0.01461792, 0.011512756, -0.047088623, -0.0602417, -0.030456543, -0.0014686584, -0.007408142, 0.021881104, 0.04449463, -0.026672363, -0.0069847107, -0.019882202, 0.0075531006, 0.0015459061, 0.0231781, 0.025619507, -0.040771484, 0.021591187, 0.025115967, -0.010643005, 0.005378723, 0.04196167, 0.042297363, 0.023788452, 0.024383545, 0.038330078, 0.000582695, 0.01876831, -0.0135650635, -0.013175964, 0.02418518, 0.016433716, -0.036743164, 0.035186768, 0.013015747, 0.017028809, 0.023361206, 0.019241333, -0.050872803, 0.04324341, 0.018508911, 0.003917694, 0.028121948, -0.0016832352, -0.013961792, 0.05923462, -0.011482239, 0.040161133, -0.046142578, 0.014465332, 0.00019943714, 0.02331543, -0.038024902, -0.016677856, -0.026184082, -0.031677246, 0.024276733, -0.05368042, -0.011352539, -0.031082153, 0.08337402, -0.042907715, -0.016967773, 0.01966858, 0.02217102, -0.015655518, -0.01939392, -0.039031982, 0.024414062, 0.0033683777, -0.007911682, -0.028335571, -0.0009889603, 0.014419556, 0.013366699, -0.01751709, -0.047546387, 0.02861023, -0.030792236, -0.03363037, 0.0057678223, 0.022735596, 0.0047912598, 0.022567749, -0.015716553, 0.012550354, -0.011680603, 0.0028934479, -0.007888794, -0.012413025, -0.008140564, -0.00006532669, 0.030380249, -0.013763428, 0.06774902, -0.020690918, 0.033325195, 0.0256958, -0.050231934, -0.001449585, -0.02558899, -0.026123047, 0.002439499, 0.027297974, 0.033569336, -0.078063965, 0.027862549, 0.0002503395, -0.032928467, 0.024169922, 0.020904541, -0.03842163, -0.019714355, 0.023620605, 0.020355225, -0.0011768341, 0.004016876, -0.0065460205, -0.011428833, -0.07269287, 0.031082153, -0.06365967, -0.048217773, -0.030639648, 0.020141602, -0.018081665, -0.0076179504, 0.019821167, -0.02708435, -0.074157715, 0.00022220612, 0.038970947, -0.04373169, 0.012634277, 0.024673462, -0.02558899, 0.023086548, -0.017532349, -0.083618164, 0.05014038, -0.013969421, 0.009750366, 0.04763794, -0.00019812584, 0.030914307, 0.0051460266, 0.0052719116, -0.0054397583, -0.036132812, 0.01979065, -0.03366089, 0.0680542, -0.00819397, 0.009147644, 0.017089844, 0.021011353, -0.005962372, 0.009223938, -0.0042495728, 0.06161499, 0.09350586, -0.0067100525, 0.015731812, -0.018066406, -0.036590576, -0.0181427, -0.02923584, -0.029647827, 0.0435791, 0.020980835, 0.037902832, -0.030807495, -0.050720215, 0.051849365, -0.047088623, -0.01737976, -0.03390503, -0.024139404, 0.030166626, -0.037078857, -0.029388428, 0.014228821, 0.0496521, -0.016647339, -0.006515503, -0.056793213, -0.019104004, -0.012535095, -0.0027160645, -0.029449463, -0.016586304, 0.0012168884, 0.0026168823, -0.028808594, 0.049346924, -0.03427124, -0.014579773, -0.00017750263, 0.082336426, -0.014167786, 0.043273926, 0.010368347, -0.051757812, 0.05618286, 0.02557373, -0.00655365, -0.036254883, -0.035583496, -0.023529053, -0.010955811, 0.016952515, -0.028579712, -0.07330322, 0.011161804, -0.0067977905, -0.013877869, 0.010391235, 0.0019550323, -0.006259918, 0.025283813, -0.015586853, -0.045806885, -0.048675537, -0.04736328, 0.0019702911, 0.04244995, -0.03930664, -0.019195557, 0.021728516, 0.040374756, -0.0026988983, -0.025543213, 0.013641357, 0.030471802, -0.01411438, 0.052246094, -0.0048828125, 0.06842041, 0.011398315, 0.006023407, 0.008796692, 0.012466431, -0.00907135, -0.020141602, -0.0024929047, -0.021896362, 0.0019607544, -0.024398804, 0.028579712, -0.005783081, -0.08691406, 0.05810547, -0.010620117, 0.048950195, 0.06958008, 0.06085205, -0.024291992, -0.016174316, -0.021377563, 0.03050232, 0.0051345825, 0.032440186, 0.012054443, 0.020645142, -0.000269413, -0.00554657, 0.011550903, 0.0032367706, 0.0014352798, 0.00088071823, -0.013801575, -0.0021800995, 0.009689331, 0.053527832, -0.016708374, -0.022766113, -0.009613037, -0.018966675, -0.008934021, -0.00932312, 0.010635376, -0.018615723, 0.023834229, -0.031280518, -0.0027828217, 0.002773285, -0.02330017, -0.027618408, -0.06640625, 0.013130188, 0.007019043, -0.02331543, 0.031402588, 0.03048706, -0.035369873, -0.041809082, -0.0158844, 0.028961182, 0.0016708374, -0.012168884, 0.05606079, -0.046844482, 0.046722412, 0.020614624, 0.016464233, 0.03338623, 0.03062439, -0.0076942444, -0.00409317, 0.005886078, 0.011398315, 0.017242432, -0.020233154, -0.00031924248, 0.031021118, 0.05859375, 0.028030396, 0.059173584, -0.055511475, 0.009727478, 0.080200195, 0.02168274, 0.001909256, -0.042297363, 0.05645752, -0.009468079, -0.02885437, 0.02357483, 0.04559326, -0.06414795, -0.059173584, 0.044647217, -0.061035156, -0.055755615, 0.0021896362, -0.0435791, 0.03729248, 0.020263672, 0.0027618408, -0.0035095215, 0.029586792, 0.00066661835, 0.001613617, 0.0029201508, -0.0070114136, -0.0021629333, 0.034606934, 0.02267456, 0.0023441315, 0.031402588, 0.038238525, 0.00356102, 0.0006093979, 0.0129852295, 0.026306152, 0.041290283, 0.0015211105, -0.0044784546, 0.015716553, 0.011909485, -0.0022239685, 0.041809082, -0.0234375, 0.029968262, -0.02168274, 0.025024414, 0.02809143, -0.0018014908, 0.0011205673, 0.011207581, -0.0362854, -0.028320312, 0.0061073303, 0.008911133, -0.032348633, 0.019302368, 0.02168274, 0.091796875, -0.04397583, -0.022598267, -0.00541687, 0.045074463, 0.039276123, -0.001408577, 0.0019569397, -0.00028038025, 0.003232956, 0.031921387, 0.0053138733, 0.06173706, -0.003648758, 0.005756378, -0.01625061, 0.022155762, -0.013900757, 0.04006958, -0.049072266, -0.009750366, -0.022781372, -0.00258255, -0.00025606155, -0.00049591064, 0.00299263, -0.009544373, 0.020217896, 0.012268066, -0.004558563, -0.03363037, -0.026931763, 0.015220642, 0.017181396, -0.0040664673, 0.016433716, 0.010131836, -0.036132812, -0.02935791, 0.01574707, 0.024536133, 0.02923584, -0.031341553, 0.021484375, -0.012901306, -0.0009975433, -0.02935791, -0.0024757385, 0.043151855, 0.007019043, -0.0032615662, 0.034942627, 0.02458191, 0.034820557, 0.022506714, 0.00554657, -0.021484375, -0.035491943, 0.0074920654, 0.02053833, 0.008705139, -0.025421143, -0.0021839142, -0.0057258606, -0.06573486, -0.039794922, -0.045288086, -0.02104187, -0.009963989, 0.0020980835, -0.00086307526, 0.018508911, 0.020401001, 0.033843994, -0.008377075, -0.01576233, -0.06378174, 0.012573242, -0.0051994324, 0.025970459, -0.019317627, -0.06817627, -0.0028877258, 0.044128418, -0.025527954, 0.016220093, 0.006198883, -0.024261475, 0.051971436, -0.032409668, -0.003019333, -0.010948181, -0.014945984, -0.035003662, 0.009269714, 0.03540039, 0.04107666, -0.013404846, -0.049682617, 0.04324341, -0.005252838, -0.011390686, -0.02949524, 0.030822754, -0.062805176, -0.007003784, 0.024368286, 0.0067634583, -0.011619568, -0.012535095, -0.019729614, 0.08117676, -0.000031530857, -0.003993988, 0.024993896, 0.012802124, -0.018936157, 0.009727478, -0.024490356, -0.04006958, -0.04147339, 0.008293152, 0.023406982, -0.027297974, -0.02407837, -0.012992859, 0.0209198, 0.022277832, -0.015975952, 0.010009766, -0.030548096, 0.018295288, 0.024963379, 0.040130615, -0.024841309, -0.016784668, -0.024780273, -0.00097465515, -0.0070152283, 0.037200928, -0.00083732605, -0.010406494, 0.046783447, 0.032318115, 0.052368164, -0.0025634766, 0.0065307617, 0.004020691, 0.0030727386, 0.012107849, 0.011520386, 0.017837524, -0.035980225, 0.009117126, 0.015930176, 0.0027694702, 0.050567627, 0.07220459, -0.06555176, -0.0074806213, -0.0592041, 0.06384277, -0.055633545, -0.024856567, -0.04083252, -0.048828125, -0.0012893677, 0.015930176, 0.040222168, -0.046417236, 0.003435135, -0.03277588, -0.022567749, -0.015274048, 0.0035877228, 0.043395996, -0.000009536743, -0.048095703, 0.03451538, 0.0035514832, 0.08099365, -0.05038452, -0.03491211, 0.025405884, -0.0071144104, 0.022384644, -0.013305664, -0.015945435, 0.012298584, 0.016540527, -0.0541687, 0.037506104, 0.02458191, -0.0031223297, 0.0030345917, -0.015289307, 0.005378723, -0.032318115, 0.041229248, -0.015029907, -0.016723633, 0.000813961, 0.02229309, -0.03326416, -0.010055542, -0.017120361, 0.0127334595, 0.04360962, 0.02619934, 0.011398315, -0.012794495, -0.0043258667, -0.014808655, 0.000031888485, -0.035736084, 0.011711121, -0.018127441, 0.029785156, -0.045898438, -0.042663574, -0.02444458, 0.032409668, -0.017654419, 0.0054016113, 0.047943115, 0.0473938, -0.014122009, 0.035339355, -0.01876831, -0.057922363, 0.077697754, 0.05227661, 0.055511475, 0.030380249, -0.03173828, 0.016052246, -0.032104492, -0.0024471283, 0.0069389343, -0.02720642, -0.0074882507, -0.0059165955, -0.028671265, -0.015914917, -0.017471313, -0.010116577, -0.031982422, -0.02809143, -0.002193451, -0.056488037, -0.020935059, 0.027923584, -0.06964111, -0.019134521, -0.015304565, -0.009757996, -0.017242432, 0.0011672974, 0.013069153, 0.021560669, -0.002506256, -0.0061836243, -0.016067505, -0.040649414, 0.010261536, -0.015029907, 0.045135498, -0.08746338, -0.009185791, -0.08996582, -0.04309082, -0.08343506, -0.04827881, -0.002948761, 0.0028305054, 0.03237915, 0.02166748, 0.02949524, 0.01928711, 0.032958984, -0.014434814, 0.027435303, -0.0029697418, -0.009521484, -0.00381279, -0.008163452 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07556v1
Using Natural Language Explanations to Improve Robustness of In-context Learning for Natural Language Inference
Xuanli He, Yuxiang Wu, Oana-Maria Camburu, Pasquale Minervini, Pontus Stenetorp
cs.CL
Recent studies have demonstrated that large language models (LLMs) excel in diverse tasks through in-context learning (ICL) facilitated by task-specific prompts and examples. However, the existing literature shows that ICL encounters performance deterioration when exposed to adversarial inputs. Enhanced performance has been observed when ICL is augmented with natural language explanations (NLEs) (we refer to it as X-ICL). Thus, this work investigates whether X-ICL can improve the robustness of LLMs on a suite of seven adversarial and challenging natural language inference datasets. Moreover, we introduce a new approach to X-ICL by prompting an LLM (ChatGPT in our case) with few human-generated NLEs to produce further NLEs (we call it ChatGPT few-shot), which we show superior to both ChatGPT zero-shot and human-generated NLEs alone. We evaluate five popular LLMs (GPT3.5-turbo, LLaMa2, Vicuna, Zephyr, Mistral) and show that X-ICL with ChatGPT few-shot yields over 6% improvement over ICL. Furthermore, while prompt selection strategies were previously shown to significantly improve ICL on in-distribution test sets, we show that these strategies do not match the efficacy of the X-ICL paradigm in robustness-oriented evaluations.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07556v1
2023-11-13T18:49:13
2023-11-13T18:49:13
{ "title": [ 0.004283905, -0.019561768, -0.025604248, -0.07159424, -0.0013799667, -0.0029277802, -0.035583496, -0.004360199, 0.0015630722, 0.0046463013, -0.044799805, 0.020339966, -0.004261017, -0.009094238, -0.013023376, -0.011154175, -0.010017395, 0.025604248, -0.0463562, -0.05090332, -0.016403198, -0.06689453, 0.014625549, 0.0317688, 0.048187256, -0.07788086, -0.031677246, 0.015571594, -0.0069503784, -0.013687134, 0.010284424, -0.02708435, 0.04385376, 0.019012451, -0.01991272, -0.03186035, -0.045715332, 0.013633728, -0.018798828, 0.022705078, 0.023040771, -0.015365601, -0.015144348, -0.039642334, -0.035186768, 0.014953613, -0.0423584, -0.020935059, -0.017242432, 0.033721924, 0.004310608, 0.015541077, -0.019882202, 0.03942871, 0.02180481, -0.037902832, -0.03729248, -0.009521484, 0.041290283, 0.061584473, 0.03555298, -0.045013428, 0.012374878, -0.022750854, -0.03793335, -0.034698486, -0.0065231323, 0.014129639, 0.07141113, 0.0015506744, -0.0046463013, 0.026306152, -0.0018415451, -0.015068054, -0.05218506, 0.0102005005, 0.066467285, -0.009475708, 0.022506714, -0.043792725, 0.0060272217, -0.006587982, -0.00013661385, -0.04864502, 0.026031494, -0.04977417, -0.020889282, -0.006248474, -0.028381348, -0.0791626, -0.0069999695, -0.024520874, -0.024963379, 0.000020086765, -0.03656006, -0.047424316, -0.017532349, 0.020812988, -0.004600525, -0.039794922, -0.02633667, 0.041412354, -0.080200195, -0.0126953125, 0.005027771, 0.03768921, -0.009857178, -0.038085938, -0.0018548965, 0.012237549, -0.023345947, 0.03466797, -0.026260376, -0.047210693, 0.012306213, 0.054473877, -0.018341064, 0.012710571, 0.03616333, 0.0049934387, -0.017150879, -0.025650024, 0.005596161, 0.03050232, 0.026931763, 0.013458252, -0.04446411, 0.011711121, -0.0007328987, 0.042053223, 0.009559631, 0.050231934, -0.09454346, -0.09442139, -0.07531738, 0.038848877, 0.015853882, -0.0011320114, -0.028244019, 0.0030784607, 0.0075263977, 0.0015945435, 0.01663208, -0.017578125, 0.0069122314, 0.0046310425, 0.04901123, 0.0051345825, -0.039642334, -0.044708252, -0.0041236877, 0.012863159, 0.033172607, -0.008934021, -0.06011963, -0.04257202, -0.124938965, -0.018997192, 0.036621094, -0.0075912476, 0.0070152283, -4.172325e-7, 0.019714355, -0.015335083, -0.0024738312, -0.0029067993, -0.03552246, -0.0031433105, 0.020141602, 0.037384033, -0.019683838, 0.01977539, 0.001203537, -0.012214661, -0.007106781, -0.0011472702, 0.029190063, 0.01007843, 0.015144348, -0.017166138, 0.008842468, -0.025466919, 0.023544312, 0.03729248, -0.048614502, -0.027526855, -0.0042152405, -0.0060691833, 0.05227661, 0.003955841, -0.03149414, 0.03591919, -0.05026245, -0.050628662, -0.03326416, -0.000088989735, 0.033325195, 0.026031494, 0.002210617, 0.010765076, -0.026031494, 0.019454956, -0.040405273, -0.007949829, -0.019592285, -0.014579773, -0.014770508, 0.029403687, -0.008262634, 0.051971436, 0.041809082, 0.0101623535, -0.03250122, 0.025100708, -0.007972717, -0.046142578, 0.0345459, -0.0024642944, 0.0026054382, -0.0137786865, 0.010955811, -0.021087646, 0.015853882, 0.07836914, -0.012504578, -0.011779785, -0.0021915436, -0.01953125, -0.0019836426, 0.02432251, 0.045806885, -0.0395813, 0.029083252, 0.022064209, -0.004673004, -0.025543213, -0.002588272, -0.02267456, 0.008102417, 0.008270264, -0.010192871, -0.010025024, -0.018356323, 0.037322998, 0.05429077, 0.0059814453, -0.0037975311, 0.024490356, 0.0009379387, 0.03012085, 0.059539795, 0.01878357, 0.04675293, 0.015350342, -0.0017290115, 0.053619385, 0.013809204, 0.015167236, -0.013771057, 0.013420105, -0.010505676, 0.016448975, 0.006084442, 0.008888245, -0.033691406, -0.0055274963, -0.027008057, -0.008575439, -0.0017652512, -0.010932922, 0.03692627, -0.012458801, 0.005722046, -0.009780884, -0.002401352, -0.015777588, -0.022766113, 0.024536133, 0.03186035, -0.05380249, 0.012901306, 0.00920105, 0.050476074, 0.0018396378, 0.028396606, 0.03137207, 0.03503418, -0.0009560585, 0.00024604797, -0.007865906, 0.030044556, 0.041229248, 0.009971619, 0.0073509216, 0.005832672, -0.01084137, 0.07336426, 0.05203247, -0.032409668, 0.020095825, -0.028656006, 0.02482605, 0.014678955, -0.011131287, 0.009185791, 0.009231567, 0.029144287, 0.035949707, -0.023254395, 0.013824463, -0.04434204, 0.013473511, -0.0058288574, -0.0025596619, -0.06359863, -0.057495117, 0.0022792816, -0.019714355, -0.039916992, -0.0046806335, 0.10888672, -0.0071907043, -0.018066406, -0.02923584, 0.007801056, -0.02658081, -0.03564453, -0.037628174, 0.015235901, 0.006729126, 0.017059326, 0.014221191, -0.061157227, -0.020217896, -0.008239746, -0.0002503395, -0.009849548, -0.033721924, -0.027633667, 0.013671875, 0.010604858, -0.015853882, 0.018554688, -0.037963867, 0.0000898242, -0.02708435, 0.016662598, 0.018920898, -0.040740967, 0.008911133, 0.018676758, -0.03567505, -0.030303955, 0.042022705, 0.0569458, -0.05154419, -0.006023407, 0.059265137, 0.015975952, 0.0010490417, 0.04928589, 0.0015602112, 0.017318726, -0.08001709, -0.007701874, -0.04574585, -0.038146973, -0.02053833, -0.02067566, 0.0496521, -0.041503906, -0.013000488, -0.017410278, -0.017807007, 0.0061302185, 0.006614685, 0.015068054, -0.016540527, -0.019729614, 0.0046195984, -0.016067505, -0.00036001205, -0.029922485, 0.0044288635, 0.08770752, 0.007209778, 0.0054893494, 0.023544312, 0.03253174, 0.0031108856, -0.010322571, -0.030197144, -0.035217285, 0.003643036, -0.0018377304, -0.00043606758, -0.022460938, -0.027282715, -0.07946777, -0.0017585754, 0.044189453, -0.0072288513, -0.018234253, 0.027618408, -0.07885742, 0.020050049, -0.019210815, -0.016693115, 0.02067566, 0.0013027191, -0.00010937452, 0.0028877258, -0.0032196045, -0.022491455, 0.011985779, -0.044403076, -0.103271484, 0.02619934, -0.011703491, -0.036621094, -0.0158844, -0.02947998, -0.045410156, -0.017303467, -0.003364563, 0.040802002, 0.045166016, 0.02456665, 0.026687622, -0.026107788, 0.003479004, -0.047424316, -0.009391785, -0.00010061264, -0.037261963, 0.021270752, 0.007205963, 0.03842163, 0.027420044, -0.02684021, -0.012916565, 0.002155304, -0.03225708, 0.033569336, -0.012268066, -0.039489746, -0.010444641, -0.020507812, -0.01687622, -0.0030708313, -0.027923584, -0.016723633, -0.038330078, 0.013404846, -0.034210205, 0.08465576, -0.0077285767, 0.014541626, -0.014778137, -0.01914978, 0.015029907, -0.022476196, -0.032836914, 0.0060806274, 0.046081543, -0.016662598, 0.018966675, -0.024932861, -0.025909424, 0.024627686, -0.021331787, -0.010368347, -0.015312195, -0.02204895, 0.035980225, 0.019485474, -0.023345947, -0.021987915, -0.0050201416, 0.019805908, -0.004501343, 0.0050354004, -0.029754639, -0.06817627, -0.025314331, 0.0099105835, -0.11151123, -0.020706177, 0.015205383, -0.0289917, -0.013648987, -0.06750488, 0.02470398, -0.040985107, -0.0473938, 0.01625061, -0.020477295, 0.004295349, -0.021087646, -0.0803833, -0.026763916, 0.064086914, 0.013847351, 0.016830444, 0.05456543, -0.027359009, -0.037200928, -0.0345459, 0.041778564, 0.012039185, 0.026000977, 0.019897461, -0.021362305, 0.023651123, -0.022903442, 0.021453857, 0.023956299, 0.0021877289, 0.007850647, 0.0031852722, -0.008071899, 0.01838684, -0.020843506, 0.04547119, 0.01399231, 0.0003464222, -0.07220459, 0.04977417, -0.0017385483, -0.0033359528, 0.022506714, -0.00957489, 0.0010070801, 0.0035057068, 0.0074768066, 0.04284668, -0.016799927, -0.00223732, 0.040405273, -0.0013990402, -0.013267517, 0.027770996, 0.02960205, 0.031066895, 0.012542725, 0.04650879, -0.016784668, 0.025100708, -0.033355713, -0.018066406, -0.0284729, 0.002866745, -0.03237915, -0.00031018257, -0.07470703, -0.0071144104, -0.040771484, 0.026046753, -0.013519287, 0.040740967, 0.051757812, -0.009033203, -0.009971619, -0.006149292, -0.0024337769, 0.004917145, -0.026321411, -0.06829834, -0.020690918, -0.015106201, -0.058288574, -0.033935547, -0.039154053, -0.011749268, 0.02734375, 0.016021729, -0.03201294, 0.013122559, 0.018295288, 0.06774902, 0.03604126, 0.004032135, -0.04360962, 0.059570312, -0.026062012, -0.029769897, 0.040039062, -0.018814087, 0.011482239, 0.002325058, 0.038238525, -0.03112793, -0.017288208, -0.0715332, 0.035461426, -0.027313232, 0.054016113, 0.032409668, 0.046539307, 0.04284668, -0.01020813, 0.021820068, 0.0075187683, -0.032409668, 0.016906738, 0.013931274, 0.0340271, -0.0048828125, 0.019256592, 0.0206604, -0.004055023, 0.022262573, 0.00010442734, -0.0046195984, 0.019744873, -0.03060913, -0.03488159, 0.036895752, 0.0046195984, -0.023635864, 0.009521484, 0.023117065, 0.045776367, -0.030822754, 0.039001465, -0.019500732, 0.02394104, 0.036590576, -0.011764526, 0.010673523, -0.0007715225, 0.011260986, -0.06628418, -0.045318604, -0.0068473816, 0.011375427, -0.014022827, 0.013320923, 0.03125, 0.015060425, 0.012207031, 0.042510986, 0.05722046, -0.02810669, 0.002319336, -0.030227661, 0.0034942627, 0.012756348, -0.062042236, -0.029312134, 0.010925293, 0.03540039, -0.04421997, 0.05517578, -0.042755127, -0.0019140244, -0.0059776306, -0.046295166, 0.032806396, -0.10095215, 0.013664246, 0.056274414, -0.007980347, 0.022109985, 0.00082206726, 0.033447266, 0.015533447, 0.060058594, 0.019439697, 0.007865906, 0.050354004, -0.060272217, -0.01739502, 0.008857727, 0.048797607, 0.012039185, 0.045318604, 0.028839111, 0.008010864, -0.064941406, 0.034576416, 0.026306152, -0.011634827, -0.00033664703, -0.041412354, 0.023925781, 0.00774765, 0.00060224533, 0.029388428, -0.023101807, 0.0020217896, -0.002368927, -0.024215698, -0.050079346, 0.012550354, -0.018188477, -0.038848877, -0.04776001, 0.005809784, -0.038604736, -0.0034923553, 0.011482239, -0.005405426, -0.040161133, 0.021438599, 0.021514893, -0.045318604, 0.031463623, -0.0072631836, 0.0023326874, 0.055847168, 0.024871826, -0.0463562, -0.008918762, -0.004722595, -0.047302246, -0.023040771, 0.026016235, 0.011909485, 0.0012865067, 0.013038635, -0.0046691895, 0.018814087, 0.008911133, 0.02822876, 0.027252197, -0.018981934, 0.045806885, 0.0101623535, 0.017410278, -0.0056152344, -0.00907135, -0.011154175, 0.006175995, 0.02079773, -0.030792236, 0.021118164, 0.010292053, 0.034118652, -0.02709961, -0.085510254, 0.007545471, 0.011550903, -0.01574707, 0.0090408325, 0.038848877, 0.04748535, 0.044006348, -0.0012807846, 0.02861023, 0.062164307, -0.04937744, 0.0021076202, -0.027282715, -0.005428314, -0.04623413, 0.060455322, -0.013771057, 0.009475708, -0.054870605, -0.033416748, -0.032348633, 0.022018433, 0.014160156, -0.01109314, 0.000010311604, -0.0009365082, 0.03475952, -0.00749588, -0.022201538, -0.04309082, 0.039215088, -0.00017297268, -0.015777588, 0.008705139, -0.03805542, 0.008964539, -0.026885986, 0.02078247, 0.0082473755, 0.007949829, 0.008872986, -0.026168823, 0.008605957, -0.026245117, -0.031677246, 0.06359863, -0.009559631, -0.006969452, 0.060516357, -0.011184692, 0.049713135, 0.022521973, 0.048675537, 0.02748108, -0.00003325939, 0.029876709, 0.0011129379, 0.008483887, -0.024414062, 0.022064209, -0.04800415, 0.0059661865, -0.059173584, -0.004798889, -0.10040283, -0.014160156, 0.028289795, 0.01259613, 0.006931305, -0.0027198792, 0.0075416565, 0.025024414, 0.033050537, 0.024520874, 0.034973145, -0.006958008, 0.003364563, -0.027511597, -0.031555176, 0.04537964, 0.04559326, 0.0049743652, -0.0038433075, -0.016403198, -0.033447266, -0.0069503784, 0.017181396, 0.030471802, -0.05404663, -0.03845215, -0.04840088, 0.04434204, -0.009735107, 0.02571106, 0.06100464, 0.03479004, -0.017990112, -0.017700195, 0.019119263, -0.025009155, -0.017929077, -0.01789856, 0.01625061, -0.073791504, 0.022964478, 0.00447464, -0.017181396, -0.0069885254, 0.08288574, 0.0138168335, -0.029373169, 0.008872986, 0.00945282, 0.026687622, -0.0018606186, 0.004623413, -0.01828003, -0.0039024353, -0.0066719055, 0.0074768066, 0.024749756, 0.04421997, 0.005836487, 0.025924683, -0.0019435883, -0.00374794, -0.00007671118, 0.032348633, -0.014472961, 0.030822754, -0.041748047, 0.037719727, -0.0007276535, -0.045166016, 0.016494751, 0.014381409, -0.060760498, -0.019622803, 0.003047943, 0.017730713, 0.0124435425, 0.04925537, 0.0013065338, -0.019485474, -0.017684937, -0.034973145, 0.021270752, 0.049072266, -0.02420044, 0.015045166, -0.043121338, -0.05203247, 0.036224365, -0.046295166, 0.06173706, -0.039245605, 0.01322937, -0.023483276, 0.008811951, 0.007610321, -0.037963867, 0.0140686035, -0.0024700165, -0.031829834, 0.0040664673, 0.03152466, -0.011222839, -0.008270264, -0.005657196, -0.007865906, 0.01927185, 0.019836426, 0.018081665, -0.0435791, -0.05532837, 0.031829834, -0.014923096, 0.080566406, -0.022766113, -0.014572144, 0.001789093, 0.009880066, -0.0014982224, -0.037506104, -0.032409668, 0.004962921, 0.011634827, -0.009803772, 0.0040626526, 0.02772522, -0.012771606, -0.052124023, -0.007801056, 0.0020046234, -0.03390503, 0.037109375, 0.024780273, -0.03515625, -0.022521973, 0.010406494, -0.023086548, 0.03036499, 0.0059280396, -0.015533447, 0.023757935, 0.029724121, -0.033843994, -0.0317688, -0.013282776, 0.002855301, -0.00038409233, -0.023773193, 0.003786087, 0.014663696, 0.03982544, -0.058654785, -0.060424805, -0.0058937073, 0.038269043, -0.016464233, 0.053863525, 0.033813477, -0.004940033, -0.008361816, 0.0104599, -0.0082092285, -0.028381348, 0.004085541, -0.00075244904, 0.04776001, 0.06915283, -0.014045715, 0.010650635, 0.030639648, -0.015335083, -0.011184692, -0.009529114, 0.011711121, -0.0018033981, 0.007671356, 0.020645142, -0.024551392, -0.024169922, -0.07867432, 0.031280518, -0.0009303093, 0.026138306, -0.006313324, 0.037231445, 0.00052404404, 0.06945801, -0.017837524, -0.05709839, 0.046875, 0.038116455, 0.0087509155, 0.043945312, -0.000047445297, -0.033416748, 0.016143799, -0.013580322, -0.0003285408, -0.002960205, 0.034484863, -0.040039062, -0.0053138733, -0.09649658, -0.028564453, -0.0335083, -0.017532349, 0.03161621, -0.05303955, 0.006614685, -0.021469116, -0.051239014, -0.007549286, 0.04525757, 0.03439331, -0.03652954, -0.018753052, 0.021224976, 0.06854248, -0.016708374 ], "summary": [ 0.011245728, -0.03967285, -0.013175964, -0.0029506683, -0.055145264, -0.015365601, -0.032440186, -0.001584053, -0.0056991577, 0.012161255, -0.043273926, 0.028182983, -0.012062073, -0.0051574707, 0.021636963, -0.039245605, -0.025726318, 0.028747559, -0.044189453, -0.058410645, 0.042633057, -0.08453369, -0.06536865, 0.030380249, 0.009269714, -0.07495117, -0.008010864, -0.02218628, 0.019958496, 0.009559631, 0.010932922, 0.00541687, 0.015464783, 0.012359619, -0.020065308, -0.020065308, -0.049346924, 0.015823364, -0.0063667297, 0.0124053955, 0.02859497, -0.01852417, 0.074523926, -0.021453857, -0.0009083748, 0.030075073, 0.006580353, -0.02848816, 0.025390625, 0.002407074, 0.002046585, -0.016052246, 0.012023926, -0.014060974, -0.025939941, -0.013122559, -0.053497314, -0.0015239716, 0.010643005, 0.06677246, 0.03479004, -0.0016803741, -0.005138397, -0.038269043, 0.0090789795, -0.00025105476, -0.022949219, -0.0015592575, 0.030471802, 0.03353882, 0.016098022, -0.025238037, 0.007408142, -0.078552246, 0.004863739, 0.070495605, 0.0036563873, 0.00042152405, 0.0070610046, -0.029754639, 0.012825012, 0.031921387, 0.01234436, -0.03945923, 0.011383057, -0.034210205, -0.017562866, -0.012542725, -0.0013837814, -0.05206299, -0.009925842, -0.05682373, -0.02368164, 0.03414917, 0.018463135, -0.07116699, 0.0040359497, -0.018295288, 0.0073547363, -0.025787354, 0.04385376, -0.03289795, 0.0015268326, 0.0041160583, -0.015396118, 0.080078125, 0.010734558, -0.03262329, -0.01084137, -0.013008118, 0.0035877228, -0.0030441284, -0.0012130737, -0.05758667, 0.019805908, 0.030654907, 0.0042915344, 0.070251465, 0.015563965, 0.044433594, -0.010284424, 0.016708374, -0.0001424551, 0.052978516, 0.007408142, 0.03781128, 0.007972717, -0.026138306, 0.014915466, 0.0019321442, 0.0023784637, 0.044311523, -0.033813477, -0.052642822, -0.063964844, 0.0001938343, -0.010093689, 0.006942749, -0.018859863, -0.007572174, 0.011207581, -0.009246826, 0.028518677, -0.0027313232, -0.00076150894, 0.019592285, 0.007545471, 0.0104904175, -0.011177063, -0.035003662, 0.040527344, -0.040039062, 0.04119873, -0.044830322, -0.033813477, -0.091918945, -0.06463623, -0.011039734, 0.033843994, -0.019683838, 0.0012559891, -0.026824951, 0.014213562, -0.023483276, -0.03579712, 0.0155181885, -0.057128906, -0.021835327, 0.0129776, 0.0020999908, 0.0045700073, 0.014709473, 0.026031494, -0.005847931, 0.008163452, -0.009979248, 0.0037841797, 0.042419434, 0.007888794, -0.042266846, -0.010192871, -0.031341553, 0.06427002, -0.0075416565, -0.0115737915, -0.054718018, -0.007972717, 0.01399231, 0.068237305, 0.012969971, -0.021591187, -0.05960083, -0.032287598, -0.015350342, 0.0014314651, -0.00089502335, 0.013458252, 0.012138367, -0.0028247833, -0.001004219, 0.061340332, 0.03010559, -0.034729004, -0.071899414, -0.103759766, -0.008468628, -0.012619019, 0.050750732, 0.02456665, 0.041778564, 0.018341064, 0.0236969, -0.03756714, 0.03060913, -0.013999939, -0.01374054, 0.038085938, 0.003616333, 0.02418518, -0.014755249, 0.056793213, 0.036468506, 0.015960693, 0.054382324, -0.033843994, -0.034423828, 0.012954712, -0.0051116943, 0.017837524, 0.010726929, 0.061462402, -0.046661377, 0.0053901672, 0.015823364, -0.014060974, -0.037994385, 0.0045928955, -0.083496094, 0.042999268, 0.045928955, 0.013389587, 0.020401001, -0.031082153, 0.0079956055, 0.02861023, 0.016921997, 0.016052246, -0.006252289, -0.034851074, 0.015617371, -0.011276245, 0.012641907, 0.03253174, -0.027893066, -0.018188477, 0.05606079, -0.013870239, -0.02609253, -0.0028247833, 0.0024909973, 0.0033874512, 0.010765076, 0.0034446716, 0.0050239563, -0.02067566, -0.06561279, -0.01927185, -0.03503418, 0.012046814, -0.053009033, 0.028961182, -0.027862549, 0.019317627, -0.0256958, -0.039611816, -0.017669678, -0.01109314, 0.01940918, 0.031982422, -0.02458191, 0.012611389, -0.015686035, 0.032073975, -0.0025520325, 0.021240234, 0.014228821, 0.053588867, 0.04675293, 0.0015296936, 0.04232788, 0.037109375, 0.036987305, 0.015853882, 0.012290955, -0.01727295, 0.0035877228, 0.046875, -0.0067443848, 0.009742737, -0.023590088, 0.023803711, 0.036193848, -0.025100708, -0.015960693, 0.02507019, 0.021621704, 0.033111572, 0.049224854, 0.024139404, 0.012863159, -0.049713135, -0.027618408, 0.025939941, 0.11315918, -0.05960083, -0.055603027, -0.0050582886, 0.052764893, -0.017166138, 0.006252289, 0.11706543, 0.0048561096, 0.021011353, -0.003484726, -0.0002424717, -0.064208984, 0.0340271, -0.032836914, 0.032958984, -0.018630981, -0.029647827, -0.01826477, -0.03781128, 0.0015945435, 0.0107421875, -0.012245178, 0.010177612, -0.012359619, -0.0126953125, -0.011940002, 0.01411438, -0.04421997, -0.0062217712, 0.0022144318, -0.015640259, 0.0121536255, 0.0030078888, -0.0037326813, -0.034484863, 0.023452759, -0.0014381409, -0.03253174, -0.011856079, 0.034484863, 0.030532837, -0.0340271, -0.005947113, 0.031311035, -0.0054397583, -0.017044067, 0.050476074, 0.023391724, 0.036743164, -0.06695557, -0.02268982, -0.041748047, -0.011978149, -0.026382446, 0.00605011, -0.000031769276, 0.035461426, 0.019973755, -0.077819824, -0.030288696, -0.033172607, -0.017318726, 0.074035645, 0.0033493042, -0.014038086, 0.04852295, 0.020126343, 0.027404785, 0.0079956055, 0.016418457, 0.11975098, -0.005706787, 0.014808655, 0.043884277, 0.028335571, 0.006038666, -0.02130127, -0.05822754, -0.025665283, -0.00819397, 0.0079422, 0.01663208, -0.047454834, -0.037994385, -0.029678345, -0.008781433, 0.06549072, -0.005004883, 0.012031555, 0.031341553, -0.043792725, 0.06439209, -0.0023059845, 0.014671326, 0.017227173, -0.050109863, 0.044311523, -0.06451416, 0.03302002, -0.07342529, 0.015945435, -0.047729492, -0.039978027, 0.011184692, -0.015411377, 0.005207062, -0.013023376, 0.024673462, -0.028396606, 0.008880615, 0.019866943, 0.057525635, 0.0051460266, 0.0072746277, 0.026382446, 0.013916016, 0.01687622, -0.0131073, -0.00086927414, 0.021316528, -0.044830322, 0.01222229, 0.016433716, -0.000049471855, 0.06713867, -0.07006836, -0.020080566, -0.013702393, -0.06109619, -0.006164551, -0.015670776, -0.04119873, -0.016906738, -0.062561035, 0.029663086, 0.041931152, -0.019104004, -0.029281616, 0.008293152, 0.030059814, -0.05328369, 0.0914917, -0.029449463, 0.034362793, 0.031951904, -0.055541992, -0.0044059753, -0.025375366, -0.024230957, 0.00504303, 0.025222778, 0.038146973, -0.037231445, 0.017501831, -0.013725281, -0.026016235, 0.02168274, -0.035583496, -0.0008687973, -0.0031356812, -0.0129470825, -0.009986877, 0.030776978, -0.008705139, 0.019058228, -0.025253296, -0.0579834, 0.021865845, -0.047180176, -0.06896973, -0.0357666, 0.019882202, -0.057250977, -0.044799805, 0.0022392273, 0.0423584, -0.0027828217, -0.017532349, 0.032989502, -0.012840271, -0.019134521, 0.03466797, -0.02949524, 0.08642578, -0.0131073, -0.07196045, 0.03555298, -0.042266846, 0.01965332, 0.034942627, -0.00667572, -0.019302368, -0.0061950684, 0.0023460388, 0.031066895, -0.008361816, 0.031677246, -0.0042686462, -0.008529663, -0.0067710876, -0.0096588135, 0.029220581, 0.008277893, -0.023452759, 0.022537231, 0.0074691772, 0.032684326, 0.040893555, -0.013183594, 0.00970459, -0.018310547, 0.03955078, -0.058258057, 0.046417236, -0.0110321045, -0.024536133, 0.014663696, 0.005104065, -0.019256592, 0.022109985, 0.025222778, 0.020584106, -0.04437256, -0.0044898987, 0.04135132, 0.019561768, -0.028717041, -0.01663208, 0.018829346, 0.056396484, -0.022949219, 0.03036499, -0.054504395, 0.027770996, -0.017852783, -0.011703491, -0.0036945343, 0.002008438, -0.0132751465, -0.015548706, -0.0418396, 0.010795593, -0.038757324, 0.024642944, 0.0062446594, 0.0138168335, 0.038604736, 0.006072998, 0.017074585, -0.036834717, 0.049041748, 0.03375244, -0.061676025, -0.10449219, 0.0022830963, -0.025726318, -0.026687622, -0.028625488, 0.0072402954, -0.0134887695, -0.018157959, -0.004737854, -0.026153564, 0.013053894, 0.0020313263, 0.04055786, 0.0033664703, 0.030548096, -0.01789856, 0.02609253, 0.0005507469, -0.017791748, 0.013748169, 0.00080394745, 0.006790161, 0.00365448, 0.021697998, -0.022888184, -0.02494812, -0.06378174, 0.039367676, 0.0035800934, 0.040252686, 0.0184021, 0.018859863, 0.03100586, -0.0048675537, 0.0028152466, -0.0024528503, -0.0059280396, 0.024002075, 0.026504517, -0.015014648, 0.027893066, 0.0068893433, 0.023132324, -0.027664185, 0.020751953, -0.010627747, -0.0029277802, 0.0054130554, -0.03543091, -0.0103302, 0.025970459, 0.023254395, -0.013793945, 0.022598267, 0.014076233, 0.001036644, -0.008934021, -0.008728027, 0.0031433105, 0.030899048, 0.045806885, -0.020767212, -0.023101807, 0.01586914, -0.020370483, -0.048675537, -0.031021118, -0.0053138733, 0.025009155, -0.007572174, -0.004108429, 0.005973816, -0.01713562, 0.02810669, -0.020401001, -0.024642944, -0.052612305, 0.013450623, -0.025680542, -0.015426636, 0.026107788, -0.021438599, -0.05718994, 0.010612488, 0.02760315, -0.0138168335, 0.034851074, 0.006664276, -0.009490967, -0.014968872, -0.03982544, 0.015457153, -0.06402588, -0.04837036, -0.010017395, -0.045074463, 0.009025574, 0.05114746, 0.025787354, -0.04156494, 0.043273926, -0.02508545, 0.024902344, 0.02645874, -0.0758667, -0.0037441254, -0.015014648, 0.022521973, 0.028060913, 0.029190063, 0.030670166, 0.018798828, -0.039520264, 0.000076413155, 0.0067367554, 0.0105896, 0.013420105, -0.019592285, 0.0211792, -0.008895874, -0.0059432983, -0.002161026, 0.052581787, -0.036132812, -0.009010315, 0.000446558, -0.019821167, -0.032928467, -0.03805542, -0.013328552, 0.012527466, -0.020095825, -0.033599854, 0.035614014, 0.01626587, -0.04525757, -0.028808594, 0.011054993, -0.042022705, -0.038970947, 0.004463196, 0.031280518, 0.031280518, -0.004600525, 0.011207581, -0.05117798, -0.021148682, -0.016418457, -0.027435303, -0.026870728, -0.0054893494, 0.024337769, 0.027679443, 0.014160156, 0.027679443, 0.023544312, -0.006061554, 0.036590576, -0.000541687, -0.036743164, 0.022476196, -0.021224976, -0.019073486, 0.015220642, -0.055267334, -0.02722168, 0.014572144, 0.007156372, -0.016159058, 0.034729004, 0.0042495728, 0.012535095, -0.0124435425, -0.055755615, 0.017471313, 0.0071144104, 0.000790596, -0.0054092407, 0.042022705, 0.030960083, -0.013206482, 0.02458191, 0.024124146, 0.04119873, -0.02684021, 0.0066986084, -0.028076172, 0.036712646, -0.01789856, 0.041900635, -0.02909851, -0.0054016113, -0.02557373, -0.032958984, -0.004337311, 0.0019016266, -0.0047798157, -0.004020691, 0.0047912598, 0.03213501, 0.04788208, 0.0132369995, -0.035949707, -0.046051025, 0.025054932, -0.032562256, -0.045532227, 0.0770874, -0.030471802, -0.021957397, 0.039489746, -0.012168884, -0.02444458, -0.043151855, 0.024337769, 0.027496338, 0.02027893, -0.035186768, 0.027420044, 0.06561279, 0.026947021, -0.033325195, 0.021835327, 0.0546875, 0.036315918, 0.02406311, 0.0015497208, -0.009666443, -0.0112838745, 0.013916016, 0.005168915, 0.004142761, -0.006286621, 0.035217285, -0.011314392, -0.03878784, -0.049957275, -0.043945312, -0.03756714, 0.01259613, -0.0040130615, -0.016647339, 0.020614624, 0.0045166016, -0.006664276, 0.019195557, -0.046325684, 0.017654419, -0.019180298, 0.026138306, -0.0033397675, 0.01474762, -0.019683838, 0.0022010803, 0.0446167, -0.009292603, 0.02835083, -0.006702423, 0.0052108765, 0.011734009, -0.015335083, -0.041168213, -0.11419678, 0.034362793, -0.07727051, 0.0143585205, 0.0025081635, 0.03945923, 0.027770996, -0.02116394, 0.033355713, -0.015853882, 0.0014238358, -0.009140015, -0.039245605, 0.04156494, 0.0022964478, -0.016418457, 0.025756836, 0.0006775856, -0.039215088, 0.0340271, 0.045410156, 0.040161133, -0.040252686, 0.019332886, 0.0032444, 0.010070801, -0.023986816, -0.023223877, -0.02558899, -0.007335663, -0.010620117, -0.02909851, 0.024276733, 0.017288208, 0.00021708012, 0.013404846, 0.036102295, 0.008460999, 0.014854431, 0.0008649826, 0.004219055, 0.027236938, -0.016357422, 0.06994629, 0.009819031, -0.032440186, 0.01259613, 0.042633057, -0.06640625, 0.016723633, -0.029541016, 0.026153564, 0.030944824, 0.01651001, -0.062042236, 0.006061554, 0.052337646, -0.01096344, 0.018035889, 0.018188477, 0.0068244934, 0.0049324036, -0.027526855, 0.0031433105, 0.01826477, -0.02217102, 0.020614624, -0.035339355, 0.037200928, -0.03793335, 0.015449524, -0.045654297, -0.026947021, 0.02029419, -0.0105896, -0.007896423, 0.03137207, 0.045013428, -0.04888916, -0.016464233, -0.0037136078, -0.016464233, -0.012229919, -0.005355835, 0.027694702, -0.02255249, -0.032165527, 0.0018949509, 0.026382446, 0.058654785, -0.0039901733, -0.028259277, 0.038726807, 0.0005803108, 0.0077323914, -0.05392456, -0.035583496, -0.0067367554, 0.04156494, 0.024383545, -0.01763916, 0.027938843, -0.004497528, -0.06994629, 0.010299683, -0.0010004044, -0.051879883, 0.08660889, 0.04562378, -0.01651001, -0.03982544, 0.03652954, -0.024337769, 0.041015625, -0.046539307, 0.0012435913, 0.06958008, -0.013938904, -0.022079468, 0.01991272, 0.028808594, 0.011802673, 0.0053215027, -0.02746582, 0.0041007996, -0.0045661926, 0.024917603, -0.027130127, -0.03137207, 0.00920105, 0.046539307, -0.0053215027, -0.023864746, -0.0005559921, -0.02508545, 0.039794922, 0.01914978, 0.0008058548, -0.017044067, 0.068115234, 0.044189453, 0.01828003, 0.034454346, -0.030776978, 0.04446411, 0.0020484924, -0.041168213, -0.018371582, -0.004131317, 0.021102905, -0.023040771, 0.0032653809, -0.008529663, -0.029891968, -0.03479004, -0.01600647, -0.008628845, 0.004196167, -0.022613525, -0.015556335, 0.020065308, -0.042663574, 0.004463196, -0.009864807, 0.0017166138, 0.0052223206, 0.017440796, 0.011672974, 0.028839111, -0.0034675598, 0.0021686554, 0.03640747, 0.0060539246, -0.0012903214, 0.023956299, 0.03817749, -0.017868042, -0.0104599, -0.07861328, -0.005634308, -0.050445557, 0.0027160645, 0.0049095154, -0.036987305, 0.0046463013, 0.024169922, -0.072021484, 0.026885986, 0.06262207, 0.036315918, 0.016067505, 0.024627686, 0.023513794, 0.026931763, -0.00025963783 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07547v1
GPT-4V(ision) as A Social Media Analysis Engine
Hanjia Lyu, Jinfa Huang, Daoan Zhang, Yongsheng Yu, Xinyi Mou, Jinsheng Pan, Zhengyuan Yang, Zhongyu Wei, Jiebo Luo
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM
Recent research has offered insights into the extraordinary capabilities of Large Multimodal Models (LMMs) in various general vision and language tasks. There is growing interest in how LMMs perform in more specialized domains. Social media content, inherently multimodal, blends text, images, videos, and sometimes audio. Understanding social multimedia content remains a challenging problem for contemporary machine learning frameworks. In this paper, we explore GPT-4V(ision)'s capabilities for social multimedia analysis. We select five representative tasks, including sentiment analysis, hate speech detection, fake news identification, demographic inference, and political ideology detection, to evaluate GPT-4V. Our investigation begins with a preliminary quantitative analysis for each task using existing benchmark datasets, followed by a careful review of the results and a selection of qualitative samples that illustrate GPT-4V's potential in understanding multimodal social media content. GPT-4V demonstrates remarkable efficacy in these tasks, showcasing strengths such as joint understanding of image-text pairs, contextual and cultural awareness, and extensive commonsense knowledge. Despite the overall impressive capacity of GPT-4V in the social media domain, there remain notable challenges. GPT-4V struggles with tasks involving multilingual social multimedia comprehension and has difficulties in generalizing to the latest trends in social media. Additionally, it exhibits a tendency to generate erroneous information in the context of evolving celebrity and politician knowledge, reflecting the known hallucination problem. The insights gleaned from our findings underscore a promising future for LMMs in enhancing our comprehension of social media content and its users through the analysis of multimodal information.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07547v1
2023-11-13T18:36:50
2023-11-13T18:36:50
{ "title": [ 0.024383545, 0.0039520264, -0.023101807, -0.03543091, -0.00092840195, -0.02116394, -0.01234436, -0.029037476, -0.04815674, 0.052947998, -0.013206482, 0.015808105, 0.015686035, -0.029373169, -0.016647339, 0.0037956238, 0.0017194748, 0.035888672, 0.0073165894, -0.025390625, -0.020767212, -0.034210205, 0.01889038, -0.038024902, 0.0055999756, -0.025939941, -0.024642944, -0.050201416, 0.010681152, -0.052978516, -0.0015268326, 0.018295288, 0.032562256, 0.024139404, -0.01991272, 0.05078125, -0.064697266, 0.046844482, -0.0047302246, 0.015525818, 0.00680542, 0.017562866, 0.012519836, -0.004108429, -0.029388428, 0.010002136, -0.06939697, -0.015235901, -0.02468872, 0.027877808, -0.033172607, 0.008506775, -0.030838013, 0.07739258, -0.005180359, -0.043395996, -0.027511597, -0.008285522, 0.029281616, 0.028244019, -0.00036239624, -0.04437256, 0.03262329, -0.037628174, -0.05718994, -0.024398804, -0.060791016, 0.013656616, 0.037322998, -0.019866943, 0.022415161, -0.0036792755, -0.0032653809, 0.01084137, -0.04034424, -0.03781128, 0.06530762, 0.008102417, 0.0076904297, -0.0053520203, -0.021911621, 0.015174866, -0.024108887, -0.03286743, 0.016647339, -0.0181427, -0.026519775, -0.012619019, -0.006958008, -0.07305908, 0.006160736, -0.04626465, -0.0020503998, 0.019256592, -0.017044067, -0.050964355, -0.0016527176, 0.01637268, 0.00021874905, -0.040802002, -0.033996582, 0.010192871, -0.067871094, 0.00061273575, 0.022567749, 0.018615723, 0.01826477, 0.02658081, 0.03753662, 0.028564453, -0.011726379, 0.043670654, 0.016403198, 0.019134521, -0.010513306, -0.013710022, 0.0107421875, -0.014038086, -0.026275635, 0.0075149536, 0.0057029724, 0.0030384064, 0.027832031, -0.02017212, 0.045440674, 0.022949219, -0.041259766, -0.017730713, 0.0037002563, 0.023132324, -0.011512756, 0.07086182, -0.08203125, -0.097229004, -0.070373535, 0.024642944, 0.0071983337, -0.014694214, -0.009613037, -0.009117126, 0.02507019, -0.032104492, -0.002752304, 0.02116394, 0.0006952286, 0.016571045, 0.075927734, 0.008262634, -0.053985596, -0.042388916, -0.017501831, 0.009796143, 0.019546509, -0.015281677, -0.036743164, 0.007270813, -0.06829834, -0.0006465912, 0.028884888, 0.0013065338, 0.04373169, 0.003786087, -0.015022278, 0.035339355, 0.06762695, -0.005332947, -0.042938232, 0.032165527, 0.0024795532, 0.028213501, -0.018875122, 0.029327393, 0.031677246, -0.026473999, -0.019088745, -0.0132751465, 0.0040512085, 0.0045166016, 0.0031929016, -0.021530151, -0.0026474, -0.027435303, -0.026260376, 0.04562378, -0.052124023, 0.004058838, -0.008232117, 0.014144897, 0.03881836, -0.0007238388, -0.013954163, 0.021087646, -0.036987305, -0.023620605, 0.0031814575, 0.012992859, 0.014671326, 0.036987305, 0.0012683868, -0.05166626, -0.046691895, 0.014770508, -0.051696777, 0.0362854, -0.058258057, 0.0044288635, -0.02331543, 0.01751709, -0.022354126, 0.06530762, 0.024337769, -0.014976501, 0.0006890297, -0.027282715, -0.0047836304, -0.065979004, 0.021438599, -0.0055503845, -0.005973816, -0.013587952, -0.008888245, -0.011154175, -0.008300781, 0.01953125, 0.027267456, 0.009437561, 0.019592285, -0.02571106, 0.08544922, 0.034362793, 0.07702637, -0.03866577, 0.053466797, 0.028533936, -0.028793335, -0.025772095, 0.010528564, -0.020217896, 0.028442383, 0.030334473, 0.025344849, 0.0011329651, 0.013504028, 0.014259338, 0.083740234, -0.036254883, 0.0063934326, -0.0048332214, 0.047088623, 0.053894043, 0.034362793, 0.025878906, 0.056854248, 0.01473999, 0.004966736, 0.088134766, 0.017181396, 0.011436462, -0.017608643, 0.0519104, -0.0057754517, 0.070251465, 0.014251709, 0.031066895, -0.024047852, -0.0019512177, -0.018844604, 0.018112183, -0.014183044, 0.011451721, 0.021331787, 0.017364502, 0.012306213, 0.002128601, 0.026626587, -0.0058174133, -0.036071777, 0.01965332, -0.0028629303, -0.032806396, 0.000895977, 0.037841797, 0.022140503, -0.0021381378, 0.014770508, 0.030044556, 0.0028877258, 0.006855011, -0.039123535, -0.014221191, 0.031433105, 0.036254883, -0.006603241, 0.01537323, 0.0026245117, 0.0079956055, 0.09173584, 0.0619812, -0.027435303, 0.027648926, -0.015640259, 0.0035686493, 0.004333496, -0.0015649796, 0.018951416, 0.004737854, 0.019927979, 0.004573822, -0.019134521, -0.00894165, -0.050567627, 0.021392822, -0.00617218, -0.00074100494, -0.031982422, -0.040740967, -0.022964478, -0.014518738, -0.03567505, -0.015434265, 0.04473877, -0.059143066, -0.011291504, -0.04486084, -0.026382446, -0.029556274, -0.025115967, -0.015609741, -0.0067825317, -0.013374329, 0.0552063, -0.005115509, -0.048553467, -0.0236969, 0.030944824, 0.03656006, -0.010574341, 0.035308838, -0.01701355, -0.0116119385, -0.010070801, 0.00017738342, -0.0021209717, -0.052368164, 0.007068634, -0.029266357, 0.0026874542, 0.0057029724, -0.03253174, 0.012428284, 0.010551453, -0.010681152, -0.011184692, 0.01260376, 0.07116699, -0.031982422, -0.022964478, 0.026977539, 0.03845215, -0.01399231, -0.016815186, 0.05355835, 0.0045318604, -0.041168213, -0.009025574, -0.040130615, -0.04284668, 0.04083252, 0.0019388199, 0.0256958, -0.047424316, 0.016815186, -0.015449524, -0.0115356445, -0.015617371, -0.008384705, -0.05569458, -0.07305908, -0.0079574585, -0.048065186, -0.016540527, -0.01399231, 0.019241333, 0.02229309, 0.070251465, 0.0024471283, -0.0152282715, -0.003353119, 0.0051345825, 0.0035209656, -0.034820557, -0.040130615, -0.023605347, 0.023147583, 0.0011663437, -0.021514893, 0.027633667, 0.01626587, -0.113708496, 0.017593384, 0.06021118, -0.04647827, -0.006088257, -0.011260986, -0.0592041, 0.018844604, 0.0024700165, 0.010322571, 0.031799316, 0.04473877, -0.0010738373, 0.049865723, 0.050750732, -0.000647068, 0.004600525, -0.024505615, -0.072753906, 0.013969421, 0.0053710938, -0.0256958, -0.0028762817, -0.021865845, -0.03363037, -0.0060806274, -0.035125732, 0.033996582, 0.03527832, 0.02368164, -0.0047187805, 0.025512695, 0.015838623, -0.011260986, -0.005504608, -0.016555786, -0.022445679, 0.02229309, -0.0021362305, 0.052642822, 0.02722168, 0.004802704, -0.01751709, -0.009239197, -0.03768921, 0.025848389, -0.01348114, -0.026931763, -0.017364502, -0.028259277, -0.0131073, 0.01448822, -0.012886047, 0.017532349, -0.033081055, -0.0023880005, -0.020996094, 0.003370285, -0.014945984, 0.034179688, -0.01737976, 0.008956909, 0.030838013, -0.012939453, -0.027297974, 0.035461426, 0.0019702911, -0.01966858, 0.02748108, 0.00573349, 0.0029735565, -0.008399963, -0.009605408, 0.042388916, 0.019241333, 0.028915405, -0.027679443, -0.0023555756, -0.015808105, 0.037322998, -0.05178833, 0.000875473, 0.005332947, 0.011657715, -0.04345703, -0.068481445, -0.029403687, 0.024475098, -0.0859375, -0.010406494, -0.0006041527, -0.054138184, -0.07220459, -0.014755249, 0.010185242, -0.03665161, -0.015068054, -0.011985779, 0.006816864, -0.01108551, 0.0009765625, -0.05279541, -0.07928467, 0.060394287, -0.01776123, -0.011802673, 0.017745972, 0.008743286, -0.019058228, 0.008796692, 0.028274536, 0.028121948, 0.011886597, 0.0024108887, -0.027053833, 0.0037498474, -0.02394104, 0.038269043, 0.01777649, -0.023239136, 0.016479492, 0.017654419, 0.02911377, 0.066345215, -0.03274536, 0.043945312, 0.014350891, -0.020095825, -0.08795166, 0.03152466, -0.025909424, -0.037384033, 0.012992859, -0.0002439022, 0.015296936, 0.028030396, 0.02281189, 0.051574707, -0.031188965, -0.007663727, 0.04324341, 0.0013990402, 0.0017604828, -0.03225708, -0.0446167, 0.007633209, -0.00096035004, -0.030044556, 0.003118515, 0.04711914, -0.04034424, -0.012870789, 0.019424438, 0.03604126, -0.070739746, -0.012527466, -0.02949524, -0.0597229, -0.030899048, 0.016479492, -0.017578125, 0.009338379, 0.07110596, -0.0118637085, -0.025726318, -0.031280518, 0.010505676, -0.012084961, 0.00074338913, -0.07684326, 0.0011835098, -0.019424438, -0.09210205, -0.06549072, -0.008277893, 0.043273926, -0.0031909943, 0.0059928894, -0.029632568, 0.029373169, 0.00022423267, 0.011505127, 0.026290894, -0.0065612793, -0.034851074, 0.04171753, -0.006996155, -0.014526367, 0.006828308, -0.02041626, 0.009414673, -0.0017881393, 0.015159607, -0.015930176, -0.010383606, -0.0362854, -0.003282547, -0.01448822, 0.05178833, 0.020141602, 0.01852417, 0.011444092, 0.027236938, -0.004272461, -0.0036315918, -0.029312134, 0.0037212372, 0.007820129, 0.05102539, 0.016662598, 0.02079773, 0.024459839, 0.017974854, -0.030471802, -0.022109985, 0.047698975, -0.0036067963, 0.0033168793, -0.027999878, 0.03125, -0.017730713, -0.022735596, 0.011169434, -0.018539429, 0.045928955, -0.040527344, 0.03527832, -0.065979004, -0.013511658, -0.0052337646, -0.015403748, -0.0023975372, -0.007385254, 0.028823853, -0.034698486, -0.027832031, 0.031555176, 0.022644043, -0.018310547, -0.0054397583, -0.006160736, 0.013801575, 0.021743774, 0.057525635, 0.0023021698, -0.0039405823, 0.022064209, 0.0035533905, -0.008010864, -0.03604126, -0.03857422, 0.007446289, 0.033325195, 0.039642334, -0.036102295, 0.0002297163, -0.008613586, -0.039276123, -0.002298355, 0.009056091, 0.030563354, -0.03262329, 0.03186035, 0.08215332, 0.0064315796, 0.008476257, -0.019699097, 0.016525269, 0.014160156, 0.008728027, 0.0061912537, -0.022842407, -0.0026111603, -0.023895264, -0.045928955, 0.010726929, 0.035064697, 0.021133423, 0.071899414, 0.028839111, 0.028366089, -0.08251953, 0.025146484, -0.021774292, -0.02444458, 0.03479004, -0.04071045, 0.032562256, -0.048339844, -0.015960693, 0.014190674, -0.06665039, -0.0637207, -0.012268066, -0.036834717, -0.03466797, 0.028656006, 0.01335144, -0.050811768, -0.020874023, 0.046417236, 0.015487671, -0.013595581, 0.0022583008, 0.013412476, -0.028701782, 0.045074463, -0.016448975, -0.072631836, 0.0138168335, 0.016174316, 0.016296387, 0.041015625, 0.040924072, -0.004875183, 0.009384155, -0.07611084, -0.05303955, -0.0112838745, 0.02078247, 0.034179688, 0.046325684, -0.030014038, -0.0519104, -0.018814087, -0.023529053, 0.024154663, 0.0006752014, -0.013763428, -0.016921997, -0.0146484375, 0.0070877075, -0.010879517, 0.03829956, 0.0030441284, -0.011917114, 0.008255005, -0.026473999, -0.02142334, 0.031433105, -0.00074005127, -0.034606934, -0.04675293, -0.019989014, 0.01084137, -0.007904053, -0.019836426, 0.038879395, 0.04284668, -0.013938904, -0.0055007935, 0.025970459, 0.062072754, -0.049743652, -0.01939392, -0.028686523, 0.0021324158, -0.080444336, 0.025009155, 0.0065994263, 0.008308411, -0.017532349, -0.039642334, -0.035217285, -0.01020813, 0.029907227, -0.0015554428, 0.024780273, -0.055389404, -0.022705078, -0.025100708, 0.018447876, -0.009880066, 0.036468506, -0.015014648, -0.042144775, 0.00023257732, 0.009719849, -0.0013122559, 0.0026130676, 0.013420105, -0.007904053, -0.017028809, 0.023040771, -0.008232117, 0.011749268, -0.045562744, -0.01651001, 0.04699707, 0.021759033, -0.027618408, 0.036834717, -0.022720337, 0.06652832, 0.032196045, 0.048706055, 0.03567505, 0.04724121, 0.026504517, 0.01335907, 0.012458801, 0.005126953, -0.014816284, -0.027557373, -0.02355957, -0.014656067, -0.0079422, -0.0736084, 0.0135269165, 0.032684326, 0.020309448, 0.003929138, 0.009773254, 0.009857178, -0.016159058, 0.0317688, -0.0046463013, 0.062805176, 0.020385742, 0.028152466, -0.022705078, -0.034484863, 0.010025024, 0.018615723, -0.004058838, 0.030960083, -0.020431519, 0.021270752, 0.013809204, -0.011581421, 0.010818481, -0.0234375, 0.02230835, -0.022384644, -0.008087158, -0.030853271, 0.012229919, 0.06286621, 0.04562378, -0.03894043, -0.0041046143, 0.005996704, 0.012756348, -0.016998291, 0.02330017, 0.068359375, -0.06112671, 0.05328369, -0.015090942, -0.0647583, -0.032440186, 0.03704834, 0.016281128, -0.018615723, -0.0049858093, 0.0068359375, 0.02217102, 0.024520874, 0.020248413, -0.041229248, -0.036346436, 0.015350342, 0.008651733, -0.017944336, -0.010009766, 0.0052452087, 0.068359375, -0.0030784607, 0.008094788, 0.008628845, -0.029312134, 0.004295349, 0.037353516, -0.015579224, 0.052093506, -0.016204834, -0.051086426, 0.035980225, 0.010826111, -0.036956787, -0.0013942719, 0.0146102905, 0.018600464, 0.004184723, 0.035095215, 0.034240723, -0.027755737, -0.02998352, -0.019699097, 0.006980896, -0.0068244934, -0.01701355, -0.005783081, -0.053131104, -0.035583496, -0.007850647, -0.04043579, 0.029037476, -0.002500534, 0.047302246, -0.021408081, -0.022094727, 0.033233643, -0.04006958, -0.03579712, 0.026428223, 0.025253296, -0.007843018, -0.042510986, -0.08673096, -0.029724121, -0.006126404, 0.04373169, 0.009635925, 0.0155181885, 0.046813965, -0.047821045, -0.07067871, 0.05239868, 0.017623901, 0.06237793, -0.01524353, -0.005142212, -0.009796143, 0.030227661, -0.0039711, -0.028839111, -0.018478394, 0.010345459, -0.025894165, 0.014595032, -0.02645874, -0.00919342, -0.028121948, -0.08331299, 0.027679443, -0.008705139, -0.031799316, -0.037902832, 0.017623901, -0.0071525574, -0.081726074, -0.026519775, -0.039093018, -0.013626099, 0.023147583, -0.04107666, 0.037261963, -0.009666443, -0.012283325, -0.027328491, -0.03765869, -0.015609741, -0.038757324, -0.0020809174, -0.037597656, 0.021469116, 0.0029735565, -0.08013916, -0.060699463, -0.0037612915, 0.062805176, 0.01525116, 0.023788452, -0.016845703, -0.00044631958, 0.02760315, 0.012390137, 0.010467529, -0.0395813, -0.03778076, -0.018737793, 0.022033691, 0.014007568, -0.008155823, -0.030349731, 0.011375427, -0.0006017685, 0.027938843, 0.040374756, -0.015335083, 0.054626465, -0.00016117096, 0.057281494, -0.02217102, 0.0032691956, 0.03086853, 0.027908325, -0.010284424, 0.03152466, -0.022003174, 0.0011873245, 0.010520935, 0.028167725, 0.005382538, -0.072265625, 0.030319214, 0.043884277, 0.011543274, 0.10241699, 0.0064201355, -0.05050659, -0.012023926, 0.0057411194, 0.000036776066, -0.0023040771, -0.0006380081, -0.032073975, -0.010818481, 0.005104065, -0.036224365, -0.03527832, -0.022613525, 0.029418945, -0.025802612, 0.026489258, -0.01953125, 0.0065956116, 0.0027999878, 0.004459381, 0.012809753, -0.017211914, -0.019683838, -0.0030288696, 0.010063171, -0.008094788 ], "summary": [ 0.034240723, 0.018173218, 0.011962891, -0.012809753, -0.010978699, -0.01020813, -0.0146102905, -0.04522705, 0.004890442, 0.033721924, -0.031707764, 0.013214111, 0.0040779114, -0.013648987, -0.0072288513, -0.0064086914, -0.020080566, 0.07287598, 0.0206604, -0.018310547, -0.0036029816, -0.042297363, 0.0024471283, -0.08959961, 0.0049209595, -0.031982422, 0.007167816, -0.021636963, 0.018844604, -0.018447876, -0.0010900497, 0.019851685, 0.02406311, 0.029327393, -0.03111267, 0.020065308, -0.038848877, 0.034698486, 0.018051147, 0.0035591125, -0.0056152344, 0.0104904175, 0.08532715, -0.008956909, -0.0019416809, 0.05609131, -0.04119873, -0.039093018, 0.019989014, -0.0053215027, -0.01158905, 0.0029392242, -0.010978699, -0.008956909, -0.025558472, -0.038909912, -0.04776001, 0.030593872, 0.03677368, 0.0970459, 0.0031852722, -0.012771606, -0.026000977, -0.10467529, -0.008842468, 0.0018453598, 0.0041160583, -0.01789856, 0.015838623, 0.01159668, 0.015640259, -0.010353088, 0.029769897, -0.06616211, -0.02078247, 0.06439209, 0.012863159, 0.017059326, 0.013175964, -0.068237305, -0.012931824, 0.05038452, -0.05126953, -0.031143188, -0.0023937225, -0.03274536, -0.015960693, -0.010139465, 0.005256653, -0.02909851, 0.0013456345, -0.047180176, -0.02709961, 0.03744507, 0.01902771, -0.059783936, 0.021072388, 0.020812988, 0.0053367615, -0.030410767, 0.03363037, -0.058746338, 0.015914917, -0.017593384, 0.009346008, -0.010360718, 0.025177002, -0.037078857, 0.019866943, -0.0005965233, -0.0440979, 0.05456543, 0.02607727, -0.03286743, -0.026641846, 0.013343811, 0.042633057, 0.015731812, 0.019470215, 0.012771606, -0.018371582, -0.011680603, -0.0059928894, 0.041168213, 0.04626465, 0.044311523, 0.010360718, 0.0030078888, -0.0062026978, 0.03741455, 0.0027122498, 0.037872314, -0.07196045, -0.064453125, -0.08679199, -0.0056266785, 0.012573242, -0.018081665, -0.0006337166, -0.008766174, 0.019866943, -0.017349243, 0.021728516, 0.0020141602, 0.010070801, 0.034057617, 0.056549072, 0.00052309036, -0.057800293, -0.037109375, 0.015853882, -0.0040016174, -0.0025939941, -0.020065308, 0.02684021, -0.043823242, 0.00012910366, -0.032562256, 0.04727173, -0.011932373, 0.086242676, 0.001203537, -0.0019292831, 0.053588867, -0.0067710876, 0.00069999695, -0.041625977, -0.010368347, 0.01486969, -0.027236938, 0.008758545, 0.02470398, 0.052215576, -0.025344849, -0.018722534, -0.016296387, 0.03111267, 0.0005040169, 0.0014705658, -0.0013809204, -0.025131226, -0.0335083, 0.013938904, -0.005935669, -0.048187256, 0.017700195, -0.007865906, 0.040924072, 0.035339355, -0.005180359, 0.01411438, -0.016860962, -0.019958496, -0.013320923, -0.0011024475, 0.034423828, -0.004219055, 0.052856445, -0.016326904, -0.048980713, 0.06185913, -0.0046920776, -0.024291992, -0.058288574, -0.14697266, -0.035003662, -0.03125, 0.021987915, -0.013641357, 0.004802704, 0.02217102, -0.0054397583, -0.034423828, 0.04776001, -0.006095886, -0.029647827, 0.0047950745, 0.0009326935, -0.020629883, 0.00028252602, -0.023498535, 0.0015182495, -0.03692627, 0.020080566, -0.005382538, 0.0038909912, 0.010978699, 0.02368164, 0.06384277, 0.025497437, 0.07922363, -0.07104492, 0.003698349, 0.0012378693, -0.016174316, -0.011390686, 0.03527832, -0.061309814, 0.039154053, 0.04550171, 0.027816772, 0.052734375, -0.034301758, -0.016540527, 0.046905518, 0.0021705627, 0.026168823, -0.027130127, 0.010307312, 0.050109863, 0.00983429, -0.0011510849, 0.020874023, -0.015899658, -0.005634308, 0.0418396, 0.027664185, -0.011619568, -0.03100586, 0.040771484, 0.010231018, 0.057739258, -0.019119263, 0.032226562, 0.0014123917, -0.031402588, -0.013534546, -0.013946533, 0.0030441284, -0.015975952, 0.00868988, -0.05618286, 0.0018920898, -0.050567627, 0.020477295, 0.007221222, -0.013549805, 0.023849487, 0.012779236, -0.030227661, -0.005996704, 0.0034770966, -0.07702637, -0.012046814, 0.03668213, 0.032104492, -0.035308838, -0.010139465, 0.005252838, 0.07659912, 0.072509766, 0.04260254, 0.018096924, 0.0059165955, -0.026809692, 0.018112183, 0.057373047, -0.012298584, 0.027618408, -0.035705566, 0.068359375, 0.047790527, -0.056121826, 0.037139893, -0.0046539307, 0.018753052, -0.024017334, 0.021270752, 0.018859863, -0.000020623207, -0.003856659, 0.060150146, 0.01914978, 0.07598877, -0.06451416, -0.05316162, -0.040283203, 0.032592773, -0.030212402, 0.006690979, 0.04928589, -0.03024292, -0.02104187, 0.021850586, -0.03781128, -0.016494751, 0.036590576, -0.024246216, -0.02935791, -0.001250267, 0.02494812, -0.0052757263, -0.002506256, 0.00092697144, 0.011627197, 0.007987976, -0.004169464, 0.0063438416, -0.0059928894, 0.0020198822, 0.005748749, 0.012031555, 0.013595581, -0.032165527, -0.031280518, 0.019317627, 0.012069702, 0.016204834, -0.013465881, 0.0016040802, -0.0010843277, -0.0317688, 0.006286621, 0.03717041, 0.054351807, 0.006023407, -0.02734375, 0.030136108, 0.02583313, -0.022521973, -0.019317627, 0.010734558, -0.03579712, -0.078430176, -0.005760193, 0.0049552917, -0.038726807, 0.010795593, 0.042114258, 0.03262329, 0.0013198853, 0.039764404, -0.055908203, 0.0005340576, 0.0028362274, 0.0033092499, -0.0006599426, -0.055511475, 0.04019165, 0.010566711, -0.023468018, 0.004508972, 0.0178833, 0.037109375, 0.08532715, 0.0043792725, 0.006931305, 0.0099105835, 0.016281128, 0.0040130615, -0.046661377, -0.05102539, 0.03427124, 0.0002720356, 0.036132812, -0.02520752, 0.026657104, 0.019485474, -0.059906006, -0.02229309, 0.014625549, -0.015586853, 0.01966858, -0.014541626, -0.046081543, 0.06384277, 0.0003941059, 0.0004105568, 0.036254883, 0.025634766, 0.009437561, -0.010734558, 0.007621765, 0.009864807, -0.01499939, -0.009216309, -0.016616821, 0.0063209534, 0.020736694, -0.01637268, -0.016189575, 0.029403687, -0.016448975, 0.009399414, -0.007820129, 0.03378296, -0.023422241, 0.0038814545, -0.018096924, 0.032073975, -0.0027618408, 0.010848999, -0.044647217, -0.014289856, -0.017059326, 0.042785645, 0.025497437, 0.00014281273, 0.059265137, -0.032318115, -0.0146102905, 0.0038490295, -0.058898926, -0.015319824, -0.028244019, -0.032928467, 0.022598267, -0.016052246, -0.028884888, 0.02659607, -0.017456055, 0.015396118, 0.008918762, 0.03387451, -0.016494751, -0.011062622, -0.021026611, 0.041931152, 0.046691895, -0.044647217, 0.030273438, -0.03289795, -0.041046143, 0.03567505, 0.030960083, 0.004611969, -0.021820068, 0.011230469, -0.019332886, 0.009765625, 0.028198242, -0.020935059, 0.025039673, -0.00299263, -0.00026583672, -0.058746338, 0.015426636, 0.036743164, -0.01940918, -0.041168213, -0.053894043, 0.031707764, -0.10675049, -0.07342529, -0.019210815, -0.01033783, -0.05731201, -0.038024902, 0.02571106, -0.0005197525, -0.037872314, -0.03591919, 0.04083252, -0.016464233, 0.005847931, 0.039611816, 0.00015926361, 0.032836914, -0.018875122, -0.051330566, -0.02507019, -0.00356102, -0.0087509155, 0.03164673, 0.009925842, 0.039398193, 0.033050537, 0.023376465, 0.024734497, -0.01626587, 0.038360596, -0.032409668, -0.031982422, -0.014877319, -0.009536743, -0.015655518, 0.01864624, -0.05130005, 0.01512146, 0.028900146, 0.033111572, 0.064697266, -0.02746582, 0.026565552, -0.005329132, -0.009559631, -0.043670654, 0.020477295, -0.017654419, -0.012496948, 0.010520935, 0.026306152, -0.026947021, 0.01423645, 0.03149414, 0.0013055801, -0.06640625, -0.018707275, 0.027435303, -0.008605957, -0.019561768, -0.02255249, -0.038482666, 0.04916382, -0.013572693, -0.0025634766, -0.019088745, 0.020462036, -0.03643799, -0.025283813, 0.035614014, 0.035888672, -0.0715332, -0.046691895, -0.016967773, -0.05331421, -0.032196045, 0.020217896, -0.006713867, -0.006828308, 0.027267456, -0.026611328, 0.016281128, -0.023910522, 0.010948181, 0.007461548, -0.02180481, -0.08886719, -0.014778137, -0.0022907257, -0.028717041, -0.018295288, 0.000036478043, -0.012199402, -0.036071777, -0.018707275, -0.006954193, 0.022262573, -0.009315491, 0.035949707, 0.025054932, 0.026016235, -0.039489746, 0.039276123, -0.025436401, -0.0042533875, 0.025680542, -0.022521973, -0.007484436, 0.013839722, 0.02671814, -0.024139404, -0.015808105, -0.052337646, -0.019454956, -0.024108887, 0.011955261, 0.05834961, 0.03967285, 0.009056091, 0.023422241, 0.0007300377, -0.00046539307, 0.008728027, -0.007537842, -0.0014352798, -0.0016527176, 0.058563232, 0.013648987, 0.047424316, -0.019699097, -0.035186768, 0.00021386147, 0.025299072, 0.0032405853, 0.030654907, 0.0011510849, 0.006576538, -0.005672455, -0.020828247, 0.02709961, -0.00356102, 0.009429932, 0.035614014, 0.0062828064, -0.0015630722, -0.015014648, -0.0236969, -0.027191162, 0.020721436, -0.024139404, 0.012550354, -0.030029297, -0.08331299, -0.032226562, 0.06695557, -0.0058403015, -0.03289795, -0.0357666, -0.027236938, 0.01348114, 0.020370483, 0.00037622452, -0.0007920265, -0.005432129, -0.0034294128, 0.013038635, -0.02696228, -0.008483887, 0.017181396, -0.0013055801, 0.012748718, -0.044799805, -0.04928589, 0.052734375, -0.0635376, 0.013076782, 0.00085163116, 0.00233078, -0.032562256, -0.013008118, 0.017456055, -0.040283203, 0.014419556, 0.020065308, -0.013763428, -0.04550171, 0.0016422272, -0.034851074, -0.0051994324, -0.026931763, -0.045898438, -0.011734009, -0.0084991455, 0.017959595, 0.046325684, 0.04336548, 0.038146973, 0.05227661, -0.05154419, 0.0049552917, -0.04260254, -0.022109985, -0.007648468, 0.004447937, 0.035888672, -0.020599365, -0.0024147034, 0.00995636, 0.0024852753, -0.016677856, -0.012542725, 0.016494751, -0.004497528, 0.006580353, 0.027786255, -0.05331421, -0.012779236, 0.02255249, 0.01675415, -0.015197754, -0.0049591064, 0.010108948, -0.03488159, 0.016723633, -0.034362793, -0.003944397, -0.04095459, 0.051483154, 0.021530151, -0.022369385, 0.004928589, 0.014144897, 0.007041931, -0.08129883, -0.051727295, -0.02758789, 0.0146484375, 0.025604248, 0.055145264, -0.011741638, -0.007507324, -0.015434265, -0.032592773, 0.029220581, -0.061553955, -0.012390137, -0.009216309, -0.03643799, -0.038970947, 0.010360718, -0.050872803, -0.0063095093, -0.004852295, -0.0018320084, -0.054382324, -0.0134887695, 0.031799316, 0.017837524, -0.037139893, 0.0032653809, -0.02859497, 0.024597168, 0.010818481, -0.023803711, 0.0058670044, 0.02041626, -0.032958984, -0.015655518, -0.0064926147, 0.018630981, -0.0013170242, 0.022109985, -0.031585693, 0.014160156, -0.06756592, -0.032928467, -0.029129028, 0.030181885, -0.01574707, -0.037475586, 0.018447876, 0.012825012, -0.010345459, 0.028533936, 0.013450623, -0.05218506, -0.017791748, -0.026351929, -0.0045204163, -0.005683899, 0.033203125, -0.0036621094, -0.026031494, 0.004924774, -0.0209198, -0.059143066, 0.05532837, 0.006500244, 0.024230957, -0.008506775, 0.03817749, 0.03930664, -0.0010499954, -0.010696411, 0.0023727417, 0.023223877, -0.0061454773, -0.023742676, -0.027954102, 0.0418396, 0.058502197, 0.033935547, 0.011642456, -0.0045433044, -0.0071411133, 0.037078857, 0.017730713, -0.013595581, -0.0072631836, 0.017028809, 0.0027751923, -0.061767578, -0.03933716, -0.05291748, 0.002456665, 0.030914307, -0.028884888, -0.01084137, 0.042541504, -0.011299133, 0.009170532, 0.03741455, -0.01637268, 0.030853271, -0.0025959015, -0.007003784, 0.021133423, -0.03149414, -0.030059814, 0.019058228, 0.030303955, -0.016525269, 0.02645874, -0.018157959, 0.022750854, 0.01448822, -0.037963867, -0.0063438416, -0.05307007, 0.019882202, -0.025894165, -0.0046958923, 0.002286911, 0.02999878, 0.014045715, -0.026290894, 0.056640625, -0.028793335, -0.012634277, 0.03213501, -0.0060310364, 0.035217285, 0.015022278, -0.0025520325, 0.03390503, 0.028305054, -0.05105591, 0.031280518, 0.044769287, 0.055755615, -0.043395996, -0.019424438, 0.07348633, -0.009376526, -0.040039062, -0.0071640015, -0.0579834, -0.017852783, -0.039245605, -0.025299072, 0.026519775, -0.046295166, -0.04031372, 0.026672363, 0.046691895, -0.019378662, -0.0043525696, -0.005203247, -0.009132385, 0.04537964, 0.047698975, -0.009613037, 0.012191772, -0.020462036, 0.011810303, 0.013839722, 0.0041999817, 0.015266418, -0.031585693, 0.05795288, 0.024841309, 0.0231781, -0.050445557, -0.00983429, 0.06237793, -0.0025997162, 0.0025196075, -0.006942749, 0.009033203, -0.040893555, -0.048614502, -0.0015859604, -0.052947998, -0.032806396, 0.04486084, -0.03857422, 0.020065308, -0.022903442, -0.029205322, -0.013771057, -0.011001587, -0.012969971, -0.0051841736, -0.008483887, -0.0021705627, 0.001288414, -0.045013428, 0.016601562, -0.02960205, -0.03717041, 0.004676819, 0.046813965, 0.061431885, -0.05630493, -0.044128418, 0.03677368, 0.03643799, 0.08306885, 0.046783447, -0.015037537, -0.0149383545, 0.044647217, 0.009170532, -0.01838684, -0.026397705, 0.051574707, -0.0059318542, 0.0014543533, -0.00920105, 0.0039482117, -0.02494812, -0.094055176, 0.0023918152, 0.0014505386, -0.0423584, 0.008033752, 0.013168335, -0.0013551712, -0.06781006, -0.012397766, -0.053222656, -0.0039978027, -0.0068969727, -0.016159058, 0.041412354, 0.022369385, -0.017242432, -0.005218506, -0.020126343, -0.025726318, -0.0047302246, -0.016433716, -0.0027561188, -0.028961182, 0.0013275146, -0.0602417, -0.07757568, -0.01763916, 0.07354736, 0.012794495, -0.04510498, -0.0211792, -0.034606934, 0.031143188, 0.0063591003, 0.0112838745, -0.01727295, 0.006149292, 0.014083862, -0.000018954277, 0.017807007, -0.008544922, 0.0055160522, 0.03265381, -0.047729492, -0.007385254, 0.01096344, 0.015838623, 0.0026378632, 0.0010137558, 0.039886475, -0.022918701, -0.02935791, 0.051361084, 0.032836914, -0.028213501, 0.013214111, -0.014877319, -0.027526855, 0.010597229, -0.025680542, -0.012237549, -0.07489014, 0.020980835, 0.014930725, 0.0039787292, 0.047851562, 0.045043945, -0.050994873, -0.0011854172, 0.011962891, 0.0007882118, 0.017929077, 0.028198242, -0.07067871, -0.010070801, -0.04815674, -0.04336548, -0.038482666, -0.03479004, 0.0124053955, -0.02168274, 0.030654907, 0.032592773, 0.028717041, 0.010635376, 0.004611969, -0.00074338913, -0.025512695, 0.009185791, -0.03543091, 0.006916046, 0.019714355 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07538v1
Leveraging Multiple Teachers for Test-Time Adaptation of Language-Guided Classifiers
Kangda Wei, Sayan Ghosh, Rakesh R. Menon, Shashank Srivastava
cs.CL, cs.LG
Recent approaches have explored language-guided classifiers capable of classifying examples from novel tasks when provided with task-specific natural language explanations, instructions or prompts (Sanh et al., 2022; R. Menon et al., 2022). While these classifiers can generalize in zero-shot settings, their task performance often varies substantially between different language explanations in unpredictable ways (Lu et al., 2022; Gonen et al., 2022). Also, current approaches fail to leverage unlabeled examples that may be available in many scenarios. Here, we introduce TALC, a framework that uses data programming to adapt a language-guided classifier for a new task during inference when provided with explanations from multiple teachers and unlabeled test examples. Our results show that TALC consistently outperforms a competitive baseline from prior work by an impressive 9.3% (relative improvement). Further, we demonstrate the robustness of TALC to variations in the quality and quantity of provided explanations, highlighting its potential in scenarios where learning from multiple teachers or a crowd is involved. Our code is available at: https://github.com/WeiKangda/TALC.git.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07538v1
2023-11-13T18:28:25
2023-11-13T18:28:25
{ "title": [ -0.029785156, -0.034851074, -0.022262573, -0.03668213, -0.020263672, -0.014595032, -0.019943237, 0.00844574, -0.0065345764, 0.005214691, -0.04083252, 0.034423828, -0.05834961, 0.0025081635, -0.0335083, -0.04336548, -0.00932312, 0.048858643, -0.018341064, -0.037872314, -0.0043792725, -0.05532837, 0.01828003, 0.045532227, 0.03125, -0.0501709, -0.11425781, 0.008087158, -0.018859863, -0.015220642, -0.010513306, 0.030410767, 0.041229248, 0.036376953, -0.04135132, 0.02986145, -0.03378296, 0.015655518, -0.013473511, 0.030929565, 0.017364502, -0.0025978088, -0.016555786, 0.0034732819, -0.048034668, 0.034454346, -0.05947876, -0.013961792, -0.0040664673, 0.00017857552, 0.012718201, 0.024520874, 0.007881165, 0.005504608, 0.0028705597, -0.029342651, -0.024108887, 0.037261963, 0.034088135, 0.034210205, -0.008804321, -0.0006608963, 0.0032463074, -0.016784668, -0.017028809, -0.0031490326, -0.0079422, 0.018371582, 0.060333252, -0.009010315, -0.04949951, 0.022369385, 0.013175964, -0.007881165, -0.048980713, 0.007843018, 0.03552246, -0.008796692, 0.026885986, -0.029220581, 0.021987915, 0.013595581, 0.026489258, -0.034240723, 0.028747559, -0.027511597, -0.00048732758, -0.0071487427, -0.049224854, -0.07043457, -0.016845703, -0.019210815, -0.06567383, 0.00065660477, -0.0018377304, -0.050079346, -0.00049829483, 0.040283203, -0.041412354, -0.062683105, -0.01512146, 0.024673462, -0.08013916, -0.004875183, 0.0024261475, 0.013877869, -0.0008764267, -0.0126953125, 0.01133728, 0.030075073, -0.043121338, 0.009124756, 0.033050537, -0.005970001, -0.029220581, -0.008659363, -0.0053253174, -0.0036296844, 0.016693115, -0.020584106, -0.013916016, -0.026947021, 0.030807495, -0.008483887, 0.019836426, -0.006702423, -0.025222778, 0.0015125275, 0.026992798, -0.0007619858, 0.021224976, 0.043121338, -0.109680176, -0.07019043, -0.053863525, 0.049835205, 0.0032634735, -0.036254883, -0.013572693, 0.02722168, 0.029037476, -0.042633057, -0.0011987686, 0.010559082, -0.025741577, 0.021820068, 0.058654785, -0.0055351257, -0.053649902, -0.060638428, 0.0031013489, -0.020629883, 0.026443481, -0.014968872, -0.06591797, -0.020431519, -0.1303711, -0.00015032291, 0.036895752, 0.008880615, -0.0033664703, -0.004600525, 0.016662598, 0.025680542, 0.020843506, 0.010864258, 0.0077171326, 0.014389038, 0.01612854, -0.029144287, 0.028396606, 0.013015747, 0.0463562, 0.0018339157, 0.0048713684, 0.013877869, 0.026992798, 0.0181427, 0.009590149, -0.026428223, 0.016967773, -0.019851685, 0.005630493, 0.025299072, -0.04296875, -0.06756592, 0.0020046234, -0.017242432, 0.049926758, 0.012374878, -0.016998291, 0.015434265, -0.024993896, -0.019744873, -0.027938843, -0.0067749023, -0.014762878, 0.02053833, -0.013687134, -0.020431519, -0.008903503, 0.0058631897, -0.025344849, 0.022521973, -0.045837402, -0.009048462, -0.03579712, 0.012573242, -0.010749817, 0.019073486, 0.034362793, -0.009300232, -0.025985718, 0.017944336, -0.018035889, -0.05630493, 0.028289795, 0.0051841736, -0.0048942566, -0.033966064, 0.036102295, -0.025894165, 0.026000977, 0.049591064, -0.035125732, 0.029785156, -0.016571045, 0.010322571, 0.011520386, 0.028396606, 0.099853516, -0.054351807, 0.028869629, 0.028366089, -0.0035648346, -0.00289917, -0.008964539, -0.017028809, 0.0121154785, 0.005634308, -0.017578125, -0.022384644, -0.035949707, 0.01966858, 0.01360321, 0.010223389, 0.021713257, 0.0129470825, 0.0073432922, 0.012336731, 0.027832031, 0.02017212, 0.054656982, -0.012619019, 0.0013570786, 0.05493164, -0.009216309, -0.03967285, 0.03704834, -0.008377075, 0.017211914, -0.03677368, -0.02192688, -0.004245758, -0.042785645, -0.016174316, -0.03704834, -0.014839172, -0.0033359528, -0.007701874, 0.029418945, -0.017318726, 0.014266968, -0.034240723, -0.018585205, 0.006603241, -0.018829346, 0.029296875, 0.02798462, -0.05899048, 0.0037651062, 0.037475586, 0.064086914, -0.01928711, 0.01033783, 0.015037537, 0.023971558, -0.019943237, -0.022567749, -0.033111572, 0.02961731, 0.0016040802, -0.015571594, -0.01625061, 0.0209198, -0.022521973, 0.08685303, 0.101257324, -0.038635254, 0.048034668, -0.06341553, -0.007797241, 0.009353638, -0.021636963, 0.0015869141, 0.017044067, 0.010070801, 0.014976501, -0.01838684, 0.0005469322, -0.0058937073, 0.028823853, 0.0038967133, 0.015365601, -0.06903076, -0.06451416, 0.0031433105, -0.020019531, -0.031921387, 0.0026340485, 0.10614014, -0.019378662, 0.0009551048, 0.018997192, 0.0050201416, -0.05279541, 0.02545166, -0.0362854, 0.018859863, 0.027999878, 0.03274536, 0.044769287, -0.05218506, -0.023605347, -0.0003130436, 0.015655518, 0.0004720688, -0.03488159, -0.01914978, 0.017196655, 0.0004312992, 0.03314209, 0.028274536, -0.04159546, -0.0040016174, -0.04321289, 0.00466156, 0.015213013, -0.05697632, -0.017974854, 0.03857422, -0.04171753, -0.016326904, 0.044311523, 0.0597229, -0.041992188, -0.020690918, 0.06500244, 0.0030231476, -0.004688263, 0.08215332, 0.021453857, 0.04748535, -0.077697754, -0.056396484, -0.05239868, -0.014381409, -0.04309082, -0.041992188, 0.048675537, -0.02848816, -0.028396606, -0.044952393, -0.019882202, -0.020141602, 0.020019531, -0.01663208, -0.03756714, -0.0010519028, -0.025390625, -0.01637268, -0.00504303, -0.021316528, 0.017959595, 0.0234375, 0.037719727, 0.013031006, 0.003862381, -0.0010309219, -0.017120361, -0.0034656525, 0.0256958, -0.050689697, -0.0033340454, 0.021606445, 0.019897461, -0.0181427, -0.0496521, -0.07299805, -0.022598267, 0.050079346, -0.019454956, -0.030258179, 0.01612854, -0.051483154, -0.0033283234, 0.023391724, -0.020645142, 0.029647827, 0.049713135, 0.016357422, 0.004951477, 0.048034668, -0.029541016, 0.0118255615, -0.017196655, -0.11035156, 0.027664185, -0.0423584, 0.0037612915, 0.005847931, -0.018798828, -0.049987793, -0.00084877014, 0.030899048, 0.07635498, 0.040496826, -0.026641846, 0.08062744, 0.020736694, 0.04473877, 0.009315491, 0.0012807846, 0.005004883, -0.0289917, 0.024978638, -0.00002026558, 0.016281128, 0.047424316, -0.037628174, -0.026504517, -0.0074501038, -0.03189087, 0.033294678, 0.0026474, -0.034301758, -0.024307251, -0.030548096, 0.0035972595, -0.011894226, -0.017456055, -0.012893677, -0.0011749268, 0.009284973, -0.02053833, 0.064331055, 0.016937256, 0.009170532, -0.015853882, -0.021209717, 0.017684937, -0.022918701, -0.026275635, 0.009498596, 0.013587952, 0.030029297, -0.01071167, -0.0049972534, -0.04525757, 0.012451172, -0.011421204, -0.016815186, -0.0072746277, -0.010757446, 0.013633728, -0.010269165, -0.008361816, 0.0064315796, -0.013328552, 0.00092697144, -0.038970947, 0.017807007, -0.03765869, -0.09289551, -0.008766174, -0.0032081604, -0.08874512, -0.034332275, 0.029205322, -0.014930725, -0.027770996, -0.03765869, 0.027526855, 0.0024261475, -0.0004143715, 0.036621094, -0.011978149, -0.0029582977, 0.02355957, -0.07312012, 0.01361084, 0.09552002, 0.01689148, -0.0027160645, 0.00756073, 0.00868988, -0.018493652, -0.043060303, 0.018035889, -0.0524292, 0.0055618286, -0.03515625, 0.006290436, 0.03062439, -0.022979736, 0.010276794, 0.024734497, 0.0057907104, 0.007286072, -0.00016057491, -0.006034851, 0.022735596, -0.0010490417, 0.057861328, -0.014450073, -0.01864624, -0.026184082, 0.0124053955, -0.011459351, -0.01927185, 0.029937744, -0.0040626526, 0.02645874, 0.020721436, -0.013870239, 0.062927246, -0.015365601, -0.017227173, 0.025650024, 0.007896423, -0.015594482, 0.00056505203, 0.0069618225, 0.034332275, -0.012786865, 0.007217407, -0.02218628, 0.018493652, -0.0032024384, -0.04736328, 0.016159058, 0.04788208, -0.042633057, -0.007369995, -0.047607422, -0.042022705, -0.023513794, 0.018310547, -0.025680542, 0.015304565, 0.033325195, -0.020736694, -0.020339966, 0.018478394, 0.04458618, 0.00015377998, 0.009506226, -0.052642822, -0.0023174286, 0.00051641464, -0.072387695, -0.014343262, -0.04071045, -0.009521484, 0.031921387, 0.004711151, -0.01953125, 0.009613037, 0.02708435, 0.04852295, 0.015457153, -0.022277832, -0.03768921, -0.0011749268, -0.0008969307, -0.027145386, 0.026123047, 0.0059013367, 0.0013160706, -0.004787445, 0.022338867, -0.019699097, -0.012931824, -0.057037354, 0.023956299, -0.0023097992, -0.020248413, 0.0035820007, 0.034729004, 0.018798828, -0.008766174, 0.014045715, 0.0064888, -0.03439331, 0.02017212, 0.0025844574, 0.02532959, -0.014793396, 0.030685425, 0.08135986, 0.008811951, 0.015472412, -0.02331543, 0.017303467, 0.023269653, -0.012878418, 0.009216309, 0.023468018, -0.034484863, -0.06161499, 0.012046814, 0.008415222, 0.032073975, -0.0045204163, 0.015640259, 0.02178955, 0.036315918, 0.0049972534, -0.038330078, 0.04888916, -0.033325195, 0.013595581, -0.07672119, -0.045959473, -0.021820068, 0.033203125, -0.03778076, -0.013931274, 0.022598267, -0.0073623657, 0.0234375, 0.024108887, 0.020690918, -0.007904053, -0.012535095, -0.011474609, -0.008300781, -0.021347046, -0.026855469, -0.026062012, 0.003686905, 0.020202637, -0.059143066, 0.03869629, -0.0066947937, -0.019454956, -0.018615723, -0.006134033, 0.016525269, -0.07562256, -0.008705139, 0.017593384, 0.018463135, 0.007144928, -0.034240723, 0.008338928, 0.020996094, 0.0357666, -0.0026550293, -0.011199951, 0.020584106, -0.0060691833, -0.0110321045, -0.012588501, 0.018859863, 0.023498535, 0.052124023, 0.012313843, 0.03152466, -0.05166626, 0.033721924, -0.004421234, -0.038116455, 0.03378296, -0.048217773, 0.004798889, -0.0051994324, 0.008224487, 0.02268982, -0.032073975, -0.013641357, -0.023345947, -0.0110321045, -0.06738281, 0.023635864, -0.013160706, -0.042022705, -0.014389038, -0.020141602, 0.00012600422, 0.016601562, 0.011909485, 0.019866943, -0.01864624, 0.027664185, 0.015640259, -0.076049805, -0.023208618, 0.003211975, 0.017562866, 0.009902954, 0.011993408, -0.06427002, -0.0057296753, 0.0050201416, -0.025909424, -0.025238037, 0.016799927, 0.028305054, 0.0013256073, -0.0029754639, -0.00011134148, -0.011604309, -0.012252808, 0.020477295, -0.0011930466, -0.056488037, 0.046203613, -0.018127441, -0.013450623, 0.0009121895, 0.005973816, -0.008361816, -0.004966736, -0.0010623932, -0.030288696, 0.012046814, 0.015625, 0.015319824, -0.0016002655, -0.02545166, -0.0004093647, 0.029327393, -0.0044403076, 0.014518738, 0.049072266, 0.030792236, 0.059692383, 0.017913818, 0.023071289, 0.0579834, -0.023391724, -0.037597656, 0.0028247833, 0.012664795, 0.03552246, 0.10473633, -0.02659607, -0.05105591, -0.039001465, -0.030456543, -0.03665161, 0.010894775, 0.037261963, 0.008407593, 0.016830444, -0.020523071, 0.008743286, 0.004184723, -0.032348633, -0.08062744, 0.019622803, 0.00032162666, -0.036834717, 0.06652832, -0.016586304, -0.00076055527, -0.02507019, 0.021911621, 0.018508911, 0.006008148, 0.019561768, -0.03152466, -0.0047416687, -0.04751587, -0.00982666, 0.012504578, 0.03933716, -0.039764404, 0.04827881, -0.039978027, 0.06451416, 0.0036830902, 0.031188965, 0.0006957054, 0.015823364, 0.018157959, -0.0059394836, -0.002866745, -0.020828247, 0.02368164, -0.045318604, 0.010604858, -0.06530762, -0.0033073425, -0.09765625, 0.04510498, -0.009185791, 0.02357483, -0.0036411285, 0.011299133, -0.0052604675, 0.015235901, 0.03164673, 0.029556274, 0.038085938, -0.041046143, 0.0005249977, -0.004131317, -0.043945312, 0.04119873, 0.046905518, -0.024307251, 0.009284973, -0.016433716, -0.05050659, -0.011375427, 0.027954102, 0.013809204, -0.04171753, -0.028961182, -0.05493164, 0.021774292, -0.005619049, 0.01663208, 0.05630493, 0.018554688, 0.0029125214, -0.011024475, 0.010116577, -0.018951416, -0.008003235, 0.00058698654, 0.015266418, -0.040039062, 0.045898438, -0.0046157837, -0.02508545, -0.011405945, 0.051361084, 0.013824463, -0.042419434, 0.0023479462, 0.025299072, 0.023544312, 0.0084991455, 0.01663208, -0.016555786, -0.01940918, 0.019546509, 0.027023315, 0.000685215, 0.05041504, 0.013267517, 0.028182983, -0.01058197, 0.02835083, 0.0004389286, 0.037841797, -0.020477295, 0.021072388, -0.07672119, 0.017349243, -0.021911621, -0.017364502, -0.03314209, 0.03717041, -0.07501221, 0.01499176, 0.070251465, 0.06542969, 0.044647217, 0.059509277, -0.00818634, -0.02619934, 0.050720215, -0.053833008, -0.0051498413, 0.014465332, -0.04019165, 0.009155273, -0.015174866, -0.021713257, 0.032318115, -0.023132324, 0.015083313, -0.0501709, -0.008522034, -0.04421997, 0.028274536, -0.0027313232, -0.04257202, -0.012268066, -0.029525757, -0.029312134, -0.0073509216, 0.013641357, -0.0418396, -0.021591187, -0.030197144, 0.0017604828, -0.023223877, 0.0073127747, 0.0032958984, -0.008857727, -0.04220581, 0.025115967, -0.027252197, 0.06964111, -0.050231934, -0.009643555, 0.00075244904, -0.0020198822, 0.011932373, -0.015640259, -0.026046753, -0.006877899, -0.0027122498, -0.04248047, 0.008842468, 0.01777649, -0.030731201, -0.046447754, 0.008636475, -0.013374329, -0.04562378, -0.0068588257, 0.04360962, -0.04019165, 0.00073480606, -0.0020446777, -0.033843994, 0.06274414, 0.035247803, 0.006893158, 0.009109497, 0.010345459, 0.0053710938, 0.0037593842, 0.038970947, 0.042541504, -0.009086609, -0.0061454773, 0.0005931854, 0.03829956, 0.04348755, -0.054016113, -0.023361206, 0.009841919, 0.02949524, -0.0053863525, 0.02671814, 0.004211426, -0.03729248, -0.0058059692, 0.007972717, 0.004634857, 0.0027198792, 0.0079956055, -0.011672974, 0.015899658, 0.044525146, -0.016845703, 0.018157959, 0.040893555, -0.020019531, -0.017929077, 0.039245605, 0.02998352, -0.001124382, 0.012992859, 0.051513672, -0.0236969, -0.07312012, -0.051635742, 0.006980896, 0.008285522, 0.01953125, 0.013534546, 0.015792847, -0.013298035, 0.08807373, -0.035003662, -0.024398804, 0.0068893433, 0.023132324, 0.001912117, 0.022247314, -0.016525269, 0.020874023, -0.015052795, -0.01121521, 0.008857727, -0.0065956116, 0.030807495, -0.027740479, 0.014282227, -0.0859375, -0.029510498, -0.008071899, -0.010864258, 0.033447266, -0.019104004, 0.0036144257, -0.012466431, -0.03387451, 0.0026683807, -0.0031833649, 0.057373047, -0.025894165, -0.016189575, -0.023727417, 0.04586792, -0.0037403107 ], "summary": [ -0.008033752, -0.050567627, 0.0018796921, -0.016174316, -0.082458496, -0.0015659332, -0.077697754, 0.0032596588, -0.010894775, 0.003917694, -0.054260254, 0.034240723, -0.018737793, -0.002784729, 0.03579712, -0.045196533, 0.0051116943, 0.019836426, 0.014762878, -0.02760315, -0.011512756, -0.04840088, 0.057556152, 0.028701782, 0.031555176, -0.039642334, 0.0041236877, 0.017868042, 0.025405884, 0.027008057, 0.018661499, -0.021240234, 0.004699707, 0.021270752, -0.013847351, 0.040802002, 0.015144348, 0.004436493, 0.016677856, 0.008354187, 0.023101807, -0.02130127, 0.0040740967, 0.0058288574, -0.01424408, 0.014450073, -0.011131287, -0.042236328, 0.033172607, 0.0010976791, -0.005760193, 0.00064992905, -0.016830444, -0.0035991669, -0.0284729, -0.030654907, -0.022247314, 0.026229858, 0.009750366, 0.05831909, -0.008995056, 0.001408577, -0.013114929, -0.03845215, -0.030807495, 0.016220093, 0.0073432922, -0.00096845627, 0.02822876, -0.046936035, -0.038330078, 0.01991272, -0.01007843, -0.019485474, -0.017593384, 0.061340332, 0.026046753, 0.036254883, 0.0073165894, -0.01374054, 0.011459351, 0.012680054, 0.017074585, -0.047332764, 0.017349243, -0.040740967, -0.001159668, -0.0021648407, -0.0027675629, -0.012390137, -0.013702393, 0.022399902, -0.046081543, 0.023757935, 0.0045700073, -0.038604736, 0.026138306, -0.015945435, -0.006549835, -0.034606934, 0.008422852, -0.010192871, -0.030914307, 0.012504578, -0.0068206787, 0.024734497, 0.022369385, -0.033203125, -0.023468018, -0.0026474, -0.039276123, -0.027160645, 0.005027771, -0.05126953, -0.005264282, 0.020828247, -0.013473511, 0.011238098, 0.01890564, -0.011528015, 0.0019130707, 0.011817932, 0.022766113, -0.034576416, 0.018722534, -0.0012321472, -0.031799316, -0.0038871765, 0.033599854, -0.019241333, 0.02003479, 0.023040771, -0.07244873, -0.014083862, -0.035064697, 0.023727417, 0.0030956268, 0.004547119, 0.001168251, -0.011390686, 0.022735596, 0.005142212, 0.021743774, 0.018630981, -0.024002075, 0.016540527, 0.007827759, 0.015731812, 0.00774765, -0.04711914, 0.014297485, -0.032928467, 0.033599854, -0.013946533, -0.05722046, -0.031463623, -0.05239868, 0.004989624, 0.010932922, -0.03302002, 0.03643799, 0.0009288788, 0.023284912, 0.010551453, -0.034179688, 0.010406494, -0.03753662, -0.012969971, 0.022033691, -0.004386902, 0.03955078, 0.038879395, 0.02571106, 0.00035524368, 0.013153076, -0.038024902, -0.03012085, 0.04486084, 0.023788452, -0.053466797, 0.003452301, -0.043670654, 0.034576416, 0.035247803, -0.013389587, -0.042999268, -0.009414673, -0.017807007, 0.04208374, -0.0033016205, -0.011627197, 0.00039219856, 0.00018036366, -0.022460938, -0.033416748, -0.03286743, -0.062683105, -0.0059776306, -0.060699463, 0.060455322, 0.05340576, -0.003709793, -0.006793976, -0.0206604, -0.06555176, -0.010261536, -0.01637268, 0.019317627, -0.016647339, -0.013786316, 0.023132324, -0.04849243, -0.022750854, 0.065979004, 0.0066604614, -0.028259277, -0.010124207, 0.009735107, -0.0018854141, -0.031021118, 0.034973145, -0.005821228, 0.021331787, 0.04837036, -0.02810669, 0.040649414, -0.032073975, 0.037078857, 0.027313232, 0.0059280396, 0.11077881, -0.014503479, 0.013465881, 0.033599854, -0.01676941, 0.0023441315, 0.0155181885, -0.04119873, 0.016342163, 0.01789856, 0.01663208, 0.015403748, -0.027420044, -0.0090408325, 0.0927124, 0.06463623, 0.036865234, -0.022018433, -0.04925537, 0.017578125, 0.0056762695, 0.05026245, 0.01687622, 0.0076446533, -0.039154053, 0.060058594, -0.014556885, -0.04434204, 0.009094238, -0.0012111664, 0.010559082, 0.004688263, -0.01777649, 0.008071899, -0.0036392212, -0.045928955, -0.018981934, -0.03112793, -0.004863739, -0.028503418, 0.03427124, -0.023269653, 0.009605408, -0.0057754517, -0.00093603134, 0.03677368, -0.05126953, 0.021881104, 0.042053223, 0.0058937073, 0.025238037, 0.026779175, 0.016525269, -0.014427185, 0.011474609, -0.009849548, 0.02470398, 0.030929565, -0.01826477, -0.0087890625, 0.0027427673, 0.021194458, -0.01638794, 0.00052404404, 0.03640747, -0.021942139, 0.025115967, 0.045532227, -0.000998497, -0.015991211, -0.034729004, 0.015670776, -0.033935547, -0.0022354126, 0.0032215118, -0.01423645, 0.032196045, 0.0047073364, -0.011482239, -0.0075569153, -0.027816772, -0.00088596344, 0.018249512, 0.120910645, -0.05718994, -0.0680542, -0.00522995, 0.04925537, -0.050872803, -0.04699707, 0.122924805, -0.012924194, 0.041381836, 0.0074157715, -0.0033283234, -0.08648682, 0.04046631, -0.028564453, 0.013160706, 0.043701172, -0.019363403, 0.023880005, -0.019088745, 0.025100708, -0.016845703, 0.0059165955, 0.018737793, 0.0050811768, 0.007926941, 0.0045814514, 0.021774292, 0.0090408325, 0.0041236877, 0.008888245, -0.03567505, -0.043762207, 0.007789612, 0.0011672974, 0.002729416, -0.030563354, 0.035064697, -0.014251709, 0.012504578, 0.023071289, 0.024520874, -0.02885437, -0.022064209, 0.023223877, -0.0015707016, -0.026687622, 0.05102539, 0.05239868, 0.034057617, -0.0947876, -0.06011963, -0.022399902, -0.0066871643, -0.024871826, -0.006477356, 0.027999878, -0.009605408, 0.018814087, -0.061920166, -0.022476196, -0.057495117, 0.012039185, 0.029449463, -0.025543213, 0.019699097, 0.015029907, 0.00919342, 0.007411957, -0.03540039, -0.03164673, 0.07763672, 0.002210617, 0.037017822, 0.06390381, 0.018508911, -0.008972168, -0.034210205, -0.026626587, -0.05795288, -0.0027332306, 0.039093018, 0.042755127, -0.024383545, -0.038085938, -0.06463623, -0.041259766, -0.032318115, -0.019210815, 0.005191803, -0.012718201, -0.008323669, 0.014831543, -0.006023407, -0.017684937, 0.044067383, -0.0001386404, 0.040130615, -0.05657959, 0.03729248, -0.0541687, -0.009559631, -0.01071167, -0.025527954, 0.0030384064, -0.008613586, 0.0051345825, -0.016189575, 0.043518066, -0.0317688, 0.009796143, 0.012672424, 0.04840088, 0.018875122, -0.0043792725, 0.07348633, 0.03366089, 0.040039062, 0.0073776245, -0.009162903, 0.025146484, -0.03378296, 0.06088257, 0.025558472, -0.011688232, 0.053955078, -0.06427002, -0.012054443, 0.0038814545, -0.05142212, 0.008651733, -0.027435303, -0.022125244, -0.010070801, -0.031829834, 0.018447876, -0.009033203, -0.020431519, -0.015731812, 0.05429077, 0.02532959, -0.020690918, 0.077697754, 0.0345459, 0.025344849, 0.07672119, -0.0335083, -0.03717041, -0.02809143, 0.01525116, -0.00007605553, 0.03375244, 0.0112838745, 0.0049858093, 0.009246826, -0.007858276, 0.011428833, 0.042907715, -0.057678223, -0.0013628006, -0.0065956116, 0.002002716, 0.019317627, 0.039367676, -0.012016296, -0.010612488, -0.02720642, -0.04257202, 0.028045654, 0.00023424625, -0.06854248, -0.012191772, -0.0016841888, -0.07366943, -0.066711426, 0.030426025, 0.045562744, 0.006259918, -0.040496826, 0.04168701, -0.0064735413, -0.013259888, 0.056243896, -0.029129028, 0.121276855, 0.011390686, -0.036590576, 0.009689331, -0.027557373, 0.03253174, -0.0058059692, -0.024673462, 0.014320374, 0.0054512024, -0.014793396, 0.017807007, -0.032073975, -0.028640747, -0.02357483, -0.02748108, -0.0049362183, -0.018676758, -0.0020542145, 0.022125244, -0.041625977, 0.014472961, 0.011024475, -0.0047683716, 0.044555664, 0.030197144, 0.018112183, -0.026947021, -0.008918762, 0.04650879, 0.03286743, -0.021224976, -0.014633179, 0.057525635, 0.028335571, 0.0026607513, -0.009597778, -0.013809204, 0.010070801, -0.04144287, -0.04296875, -0.0056533813, 0.047546387, -0.0390625, 0.015396118, 0.04711914, 0.09246826, -0.001534462, 0.006916046, 0.013442993, 0.010948181, -0.018051147, -0.015235901, -0.013938904, 0.01727295, -0.036346436, -0.0015449524, -0.01878357, 0.031829834, -0.035003662, 0.020584106, -0.0085372925, 0.03378296, 0.03753662, 0.026306152, -0.010314941, -0.0473938, 0.01007843, 0.012390137, -0.043273926, -0.07373047, -0.011528015, -0.01689148, -0.07122803, -0.019973755, -0.06390381, -0.044433594, -0.024871826, 0.0259552, -0.007865906, 0.01687622, 0.0146102905, 0.045654297, 0.027755737, 0.012130737, -0.035583496, -0.015579224, -0.012481689, -0.021942139, -0.029754639, -0.033325195, -0.026519775, -0.014724731, 0.039154053, -0.015838623, 0.0035648346, -0.093444824, -0.0234375, -0.015045166, -0.023986816, 0.04562378, -0.00012660027, 0.011604309, -0.00995636, 0.009391785, -0.00002783537, -0.013221741, -0.00076055527, 0.014152527, 0.010810852, 0.0015325546, 0.021316528, 0.02128601, -0.035614014, 0.010482788, -0.007888794, 0.024932861, 0.0021324158, -0.040924072, 0.009109497, 0.021377563, 0.0077934265, -0.008872986, 0.007911682, -0.0009946823, 0.0039367676, -0.029693604, -0.01424408, 0.06958008, 0.055908203, 0.06573486, -0.021011353, -0.00655365, 0.023269653, -0.03286743, -0.03164673, -0.024887085, -0.012290955, -0.014755249, 0.0075683594, -0.0024204254, -0.0056533813, -0.03375244, 0.017196655, 0.014953613, 0.0057258606, -0.03387451, 0.020767212, -0.013221741, -0.010848999, 0.002822876, -0.020065308, -0.029449463, -0.015144348, 0.0056495667, -0.051757812, 0.004798889, 0.053131104, -0.039276123, 0.0035820007, 0.010810852, -0.006565094, -0.043914795, -0.02470398, 0.0026416779, -0.01486969, -0.005340576, 0.019882202, -0.024871826, -0.044952393, 0.030548096, -0.052001953, 0.018127441, 0.007598877, -0.011779785, -0.0154800415, -0.01576233, -0.0018196106, 0.029586792, 0.0077209473, 0.009613037, -0.009414673, 0.0045280457, 0.018127441, -0.012741089, -0.023025513, 0.0023422241, -0.012184143, 0.027069092, -0.017318726, 0.0028362274, 0.0042495728, 0.020614624, -0.042816162, -0.046020508, -0.008018494, -0.061920166, -0.013641357, -0.031143188, -0.024291992, -0.011123657, 0.021972656, -0.028503418, 0.00075149536, 0.009819031, -0.009559631, -0.000024855137, -0.032348633, 0.003458023, -0.00932312, 0.013214111, -0.026916504, 0.013435364, -0.019424438, 0.012519836, -0.046966553, 0.0032730103, -0.010673523, -0.016357422, -0.066467285, -0.00605011, -0.02748108, 0.03579712, 0.0061912537, -0.037109375, -0.017700195, -0.014381409, -0.019226074, -0.017837524, -0.008071899, 0.038024902, 0.0029563904, 0.0135269165, 0.012123108, -0.027252197, -0.013183594, 0.001745224, 0.0077209473, -0.0234375, 0.03427124, -0.00041747093, 0.05581665, -0.08105469, -0.05215454, 0.0048103333, 0.036346436, 0.018875122, 0.053527832, 0.040496826, 0.019439697, 0.04663086, 0.014167786, 0.04626465, 0.021636963, -0.03125, -0.0019950867, 0.011734009, 0.03427124, 0.012626648, 0.052825928, -0.008987427, -0.017669678, -0.022735596, -0.010765076, 0.004890442, 0.012969971, 0.011100769, -0.029342651, 0.02015686, -0.00093078613, -0.006755829, 0.03137207, -0.005207062, -0.048309326, 0.0058288574, -0.014450073, -0.018676758, 0.055999756, 0.017532349, -0.024871826, 0.02961731, 0.0023097992, 0.020141602, -0.025009155, 0.038238525, -0.019241333, -0.0012731552, -0.025634766, 0.004447937, 0.0501709, 0.008583069, -0.020202637, 0.032836914, 0.0072250366, 0.049957275, 0.033721924, -0.0019798279, -0.019622803, -0.0287323, 0.024368286, 0.00995636, 0.031982422, -0.004283905, 0.034210205, -0.030975342, -0.014373779, -0.04650879, -0.031799316, -0.034210205, 0.025558472, -0.028839111, -0.035308838, 0.080444336, -0.009223938, -0.00957489, 0.0014867783, -0.03475952, 0.0715332, -0.021469116, -0.061920166, -0.022949219, -0.007003784, -0.021987915, 0.032196045, 0.041870117, -0.03390503, 0.042419434, 0.0060577393, -0.0045433044, 0.016235352, -0.027709961, 0.0034809113, -0.09387207, -0.008880615, -0.047210693, 0.05392456, 0.02355957, 0.031433105, 0.035308838, 0.0035076141, 0.0011405945, -0.020767212, 0.023986816, -0.016906738, 0.01864624, 0.0008420944, -0.029067993, 0.009544373, 0.030685425, 0.027770996, -0.022583008, -0.00022339821, 0.024017334, 0.030303955, -0.03829956, 0.013084412, 0.008232117, 0.00920105, -0.028884888, 0.020065308, -0.020462036, -0.03933716, 0.0063972473, 0.004032135, 0.008010864, 0.029388428, 0.000957489, -0.0256958, -0.012268066, -0.011817932, 0.0005335808, 0.029708862, -0.002286911, 0.03074646, -0.023956299, 0.020370483, 0.0051651, -0.0048065186, -0.018676758, 0.042510986, -0.07122803, 0.034118652, 0.0016851425, 0.022964478, 0.05645752, 0.06088257, -0.023010254, 0.0061416626, 0.058776855, -0.024963379, -0.023864746, 0.008621216, -0.00579834, -0.026168823, -0.018615723, -0.011665344, 0.015716553, -0.016220093, 0.054504395, -0.04714966, -0.008636475, -0.022888184, 0.015457153, -0.042144775, 0.013580322, -0.0340271, -0.014228821, 0.039276123, 0.0048294067, 0.032287598, -0.04486084, 0.016479492, -0.0041122437, -0.027297974, 0.0047683716, 0.032165527, 0.03878784, -0.025436401, -0.027740479, 0.049346924, 0.02494812, 0.119628906, -0.020767212, -0.0072898865, 0.04043579, -0.015090942, -0.020935059, -0.06890869, -0.01158905, -0.04864502, 0.016098022, -0.033294678, -0.01360321, -0.010940552, -0.03363037, -0.07507324, 0.06915283, -0.017501831, -0.02911377, 0.03149414, 0.07867432, -0.0017271042, -0.019638062, -0.00030636787, 0.020477295, 0.046081543, -0.04421997, 0.008415222, 0.01864624, 0.03289795, 0.0036144257, -0.0030155182, 0.0020771027, -0.008628845, -0.0043640137, -0.0061912537, -0.0368042, 0.030456543, 0.0046920776, -0.042877197, 0.008430481, 0.021377563, 0.06048584, 0.018188477, -0.01739502, -0.02142334, -0.03515625, -0.025939941, 0.029190063, -0.00035309792, -0.00072956085, 0.04434204, -0.0048332214, -0.0054016113, 0.0146484375, -0.003967285, -0.0056915283, 0.0038661957, 0.0044822693, 0.0006451607, 0.017608643, 0.06738281, -0.004886627, 0.0042800903, 0.07562256, -0.021347046, -0.13330078, -0.04083252, 0.010437012, 0.0070991516, 0.03366089, 0.014205933, 0.015213013, 0.019363403, 0.07733154, -0.0158844, 0.006843567, 0.0317688, 0.030960083, 0.02418518, -0.03366089, 0.023376465, 0.018844604, 0.013046265, 0.007232666, 0.015060425, 0.03161621, 0.008094788, -0.03286743, -0.0061073303, -0.09436035, 0.025894165, -0.06109619, -0.014663696, 0.037872314, -0.003616333, -0.014007568, -0.0067863464, -0.038208008, 0.027755737, 0.048797607, 0.026031494, -0.024932861, 0.053527832, 0.057556152, 0.0057296753, 0.024353027 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07536v1
A Comprehensive Evaluation of GPT-4V on Knowledge-Intensive Visual Question Answering
Yunxin Li, Longyue Wang, Baotian Hu, Xinyu Chen, Wanqi Zhong, Chenyang Lyu, Min Zhang
cs.CL
The emergence of multimodal large models (MLMs) has significantly advanced the field of visual understanding, offering remarkable capabilities in the realm of visual question answering (VQA). Yet, the true challenge lies in the domain of knowledge-intensive VQA tasks, which necessitate not just recognition of visual elements, but also a deep comprehension of the visual information in conjunction with a vast repository of learned knowledge. To uncover such capabilities of MLMs, particularly the newly introduced GPT-4V, we provide an in-depth evaluation from three perspectives: 1) Commonsense Knowledge, which assesses how well models can understand visual cues and connect to general knowledge; 2) Fine-grained World Knowledge, which tests the model's skill in reasoning out specific knowledge from images, showcasing their proficiency across various specialized fields; 3) Comprehensive Knowledge with Decision-making Rationales, which examines model's capability to provide logical explanations for its inference, facilitating a deeper analysis from the interpretability perspective. Extensive experiments indicate that GPT-4V achieves SOTA performance on above three tasks. Interestingly, we find that: a) GPT-4V demonstrates enhanced reasoning and explanation when using composite images as few-shot; b) GPT-4V produces severe hallucinations when dealing with world knowledge, highlighting the future need for advancements in this research direction.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07536v1
2023-11-13T18:22:32
2023-11-13T18:22:32
{ "title": [ 0.006378174, 0.007896423, -0.00894928, -0.026153564, -0.010902405, -0.010169983, -0.0018949509, -0.014030457, 0.03378296, 0.023162842, -0.0309906, -0.0059394836, -0.017028809, -0.0110321045, -0.07373047, 0.0016021729, 0.0074806213, 0.018539429, -0.016860962, -0.033721924, 0.006965637, -0.034240723, 0.01687622, 0.030075073, 0.0090789795, -0.038879395, -0.06137085, 0.013893127, -0.047332764, -0.054229736, -0.022537231, 0.040527344, 0.033966064, 0.017791748, -0.0075798035, 0.026397705, -0.040222168, 0.02192688, 0.02670288, 0.00019049644, 0.0058135986, 0.00014960766, -0.024963379, -0.046203613, -0.047973633, 0.033721924, -0.082092285, -0.020111084, 0.0025615692, 0.022140503, 0.001036644, 0.052764893, -0.008613586, 0.027511597, 0.015144348, -0.011955261, -0.004650116, -0.06286621, 0.054138184, 0.04071045, 0.018737793, -0.07421875, 0.034362793, -0.031829834, -0.02116394, -0.018569946, -0.008071899, -0.004611969, 0.076171875, 0.008728027, -0.017700195, 0.02708435, 0.008781433, -0.008911133, -0.023803711, 0.024383545, 0.038970947, 0.021316528, 0.022903442, -0.030181885, 0.013717651, -0.0002682209, -0.02204895, 0.0068626404, 0.007019043, -0.016220093, -0.018585205, -0.026290894, -0.043395996, -0.095214844, -0.007896423, -0.074645996, -0.042785645, -0.013809204, 0.006374359, -0.07684326, -0.014892578, -0.008674622, -0.0064430237, -0.032928467, 0.00831604, 0.01210022, -0.026397705, -0.00459671, 0.0044784546, 0.00030374527, -0.019500732, -0.015136719, 0.01574707, 0.039764404, -0.024139404, 0.020401001, -0.0007634163, -0.014259338, -0.0026817322, 0.051879883, 0.012123108, 0.01171875, 0.003068924, 0.045776367, -0.01663208, -0.034210205, 0.035614014, 0.019378662, 0.03817749, 0.02571106, -0.04345703, 0.0037231445, -0.008712769, 0.016662598, 0.015159607, 0.0657959, -0.08135986, -0.082092285, -0.06854248, 0.041625977, -0.012580872, -0.014221191, -0.02458191, 0.016738892, 0.022918701, -0.033325195, 0.0035438538, -0.0023498535, 0.0050735474, 0.045166016, 0.08001709, -0.013465881, -0.07342529, -0.09338379, 0.0062942505, 0.0026359558, 0.008049011, -0.013221741, -0.04525757, -0.022216797, -0.11920166, -0.006565094, 0.042236328, 0.024353027, 0.0044517517, 0.02671814, 0.04360962, 0.021438599, 0.042938232, -0.046783447, -0.02432251, 0.010391235, 0.021514893, 0.02104187, -0.008010864, 0.016815186, 0.035186768, -0.00932312, -0.018936157, 0.002866745, 0.01663208, -0.02079773, 0.014297485, 0.033721924, 0.023025513, -0.03100586, -0.011650085, 0.031341553, -0.040405273, -0.024520874, -0.01109314, -0.0036830902, 0.0440979, 0.00033307076, -0.054473877, 0.025009155, -0.030029297, -0.0052261353, -0.010383606, -0.0129470825, 0.009757996, 0.011749268, 0.009857178, -0.026306152, -0.017211914, -0.022247314, -0.010795593, -0.022583008, -0.072143555, -0.01902771, -0.04244995, 0.02267456, -0.030914307, 0.052368164, 0.055847168, 0.019470215, -0.042510986, 0.030578613, 0.0055885315, -0.061187744, 0.019256592, -0.010627747, 0.0032920837, -0.0435791, 0.022720337, 0.013763428, 0.026916504, 0.030044556, -0.0025177002, -0.0038452148, 0.024978638, -0.016693115, 0.03475952, 0.02810669, 0.0592041, -0.056793213, 0.038085938, 0.030700684, -0.006164551, -0.034057617, 0.011634827, -0.033477783, 0.027618408, 0.0124435425, 0.0037384033, -0.018844604, -0.031311035, -0.01914978, 0.065979004, 0.031311035, 0.014526367, -0.02017212, 0.007507324, 0.025344849, 0.0423584, 0.027420044, 0.029510498, 0.02911377, 0.005104065, 0.05117798, 0.023742676, 0.036712646, 0.007949829, 0.0070724487, -0.014419556, 0.035827637, 0.030776978, 0.0034446716, -0.031066895, 0.014091492, -0.021255493, 0.0058670044, -0.0074310303, 0.008163452, 0.021224976, -0.01638794, 0.001033783, -0.024108887, 0.019927979, -0.021881104, -0.05053711, 0.037384033, 0.0146484375, -0.048736572, -0.005138397, -0.016799927, 0.03616333, -0.00894165, 0.04119873, 0.009048462, 0.015556335, -0.022247314, -0.020370483, 0.0005097389, 0.052978516, 0.02633667, 0.014320374, 0.005783081, -0.012557983, 0.0038337708, 0.07019043, 0.07476807, -0.021850586, 0.046783447, -0.0096206665, 0.026855469, -0.0020103455, -0.004951477, 0.0021972656, 0.024993896, 0.023605347, 0.016067505, -0.009094238, 0.0006456375, -0.03363037, 0.015213013, -0.000053942204, 0.018814087, -0.07556152, -0.07678223, -0.027801514, -0.034362793, -0.06762695, -0.03668213, 0.034210205, -0.0051116943, -0.027374268, -0.0063476562, 0.010505676, -0.0016288757, -0.017227173, -0.020141602, -0.051849365, 0.024719238, 0.05645752, 0.0042266846, -0.035095215, -0.02142334, -0.011909485, 0.019546509, -0.001001358, -0.0025844574, -0.027236938, 0.022033691, 0.027832031, -0.05065918, 0.006439209, -0.03677368, -0.017837524, -0.03640747, 0.032684326, 0.011604309, -0.06201172, 0.00054454803, 0.03878784, -0.033294678, 0.028533936, 0.0028953552, 0.064086914, -0.011680603, -0.0602417, 0.0062561035, 0.022827148, -0.036895752, 0.02923584, 0.023834229, 0.015777588, -0.06903076, -0.022735596, -0.037078857, -0.037139893, -0.007499695, 0.021011353, 0.037994385, -0.017684937, 0.0029029846, -0.047454834, -0.014045715, 0.02192688, -0.023132324, -0.041412354, -0.044158936, 0.007133484, -0.030395508, 0.000344038, 0.024719238, -0.025100708, 0.047332764, 0.0692749, 0.041503906, 0.00041770935, -0.0022392273, 0.010421753, -0.021362305, -0.017578125, -0.0051231384, 0.00699234, -0.0033473969, 0.011138916, -0.0016593933, -0.022872925, -0.010948181, -0.07531738, 0.0009036064, 0.045959473, 0.0015888214, -0.0023517609, 0.005290985, -0.07788086, 0.027511597, -0.03778076, -0.019744873, 0.01776123, 0.036865234, 0.007396698, 0.029144287, -0.009437561, 0.0067749023, -0.012123108, -0.036071777, -0.12414551, 0.016540527, -0.015113831, 0.0011062622, -0.02003479, -0.01576233, -0.06137085, 0.0017852783, -0.016418457, 0.045684814, 0.018707275, 0.02696228, -0.00024867058, -0.039520264, -0.0027751923, -0.03387451, -0.01828003, -0.032104492, -0.009155273, 0.009307861, -0.012130737, 0.03250122, -0.0016078949, -0.0036411285, -0.021362305, 0.01550293, -0.027862549, 0.021820068, -0.0072402954, -0.053894043, 0.009346008, -0.021606445, -0.026321411, 0.011405945, -0.0011253357, 0.00983429, -0.031951904, 0.007396698, -0.02217102, 0.028274536, 0.00730896, 0.0317688, 0.011665344, -0.052612305, 0.009506226, -0.04031372, -0.03253174, 0.032562256, 0.05960083, -0.029281616, -0.0026378632, -0.028152466, -0.05215454, 0.042785645, -0.0074424744, -0.007980347, 0.008033752, -0.00050115585, -0.0017080307, -0.011245728, -0.0014123917, 0.03277588, -0.03643799, -0.011192322, -0.01576233, 0.0016860962, -0.0034484863, -0.08251953, -0.025772095, 0.013717651, -0.10119629, -0.020965576, 0.0181427, -0.012077332, -0.0149002075, -0.048095703, 0.038726807, -0.0446167, -0.023101807, 0.019927979, 0.0027999878, -0.007408142, -0.016220093, -0.06665039, -0.047668457, 0.083740234, 0.0027942657, 0.0061149597, 0.0670166, 0.012557983, -0.019210815, -0.002828598, 0.012069702, 0.0033226013, 0.048675537, 0.004447937, -0.046936035, 0.026947021, -0.03277588, 0.027542114, 0.0048294067, -0.06262207, 0.01020813, 0.039489746, -0.02720642, -0.00015449524, -0.0135269165, 0.06707764, -0.023971558, -0.0067214966, -0.06561279, 0.049346924, 0.008255005, -0.030700684, 0.02154541, -0.029418945, -0.008033752, 0.022369385, 0.003194809, 0.075927734, -0.035491943, -0.011665344, 0.04763794, -0.007827759, -0.0028591156, -0.0052375793, -0.009460449, 0.04046631, -0.00365448, 0.049224854, -0.016815186, 0.05657959, -0.013076782, -0.011756897, -0.0012016296, 0.023895264, -0.044403076, -0.018081665, -0.07501221, 0.0035743713, -0.026351929, 0.0209198, -0.014228821, 0.03869629, 0.048187256, -0.016494751, -0.012229919, -0.0026950836, 0.0625, -0.008117676, -0.013916016, -0.09277344, 0.02532959, -0.0076179504, -0.06365967, -0.028549194, -0.032043457, -0.01486969, 0.027328491, -0.006122589, -0.031463623, 0.009490967, 0.0032615662, 0.059631348, 0.049041748, 0.031982422, -0.035888672, 0.07910156, -0.017486572, -0.039001465, 0.008972168, -0.013633728, -0.01247406, -0.027618408, 0.028686523, -0.011558533, -0.029769897, -0.07446289, 0.025756836, 0.007472992, 0.032226562, 0.0340271, 0.01965332, 0.026657104, 0.028808594, 0.028793335, 0.0040626526, -0.028900146, -0.033172607, 0.015304565, 0.046569824, 0.05609131, 0.017745972, 0.048553467, 0.019195557, -0.0184021, 0.0043296814, 0.028427124, 0.014862061, 0.010772705, -0.01701355, 0.014411926, -0.038909912, -0.021774292, 0.001291275, -0.023132324, 0.034606934, -0.03189087, 0.03744507, -0.032043457, 0.02041626, 0.010818481, -0.024490356, -0.000028312206, -0.024276733, 0.0067481995, -0.062469482, -0.08319092, -0.021865845, 0.07171631, -0.02671814, -0.0071792603, 0.010894775, 0.025604248, 0.027297974, 0.06561279, 0.0501709, -0.021972656, -0.015419006, -0.00015890598, 0.0029525757, -0.03817749, -0.026321411, 0.02545166, 0.016815186, 0.013114929, -0.08294678, 0.0006246567, 0.0027484894, -0.04168701, -0.020492554, -0.029510498, 0.03503418, -0.07171631, 0.0026988983, 0.059173584, 0.0032100677, 0.021194458, 0.004016876, 0.025848389, -0.03878784, 0.038482666, -0.0074424744, 0.03591919, 0.026306152, -0.06347656, 0.021896362, 0.009269714, 0.02432251, -0.0022029877, 0.023956299, 0.0059547424, 0.021453857, -0.04534912, 0.012001038, -0.0042381287, -0.0020141602, 0.027908325, -0.0446167, 0.030212402, -0.0017213821, -0.018218994, 0.012680054, -0.055267334, -0.013587952, -0.0023078918, -0.029953003, -0.04083252, 0.037231445, -0.0023403168, -0.036071777, -0.029159546, 0.011642456, -0.011352539, -0.0012722015, 0.014343262, 0.007637024, -0.03994751, 0.04815674, 0.021133423, -0.04168701, -0.033050537, 0.044708252, 0.029922485, 0.034118652, -0.008834839, -0.03579712, -0.010398865, -0.06573486, -0.02947998, 0.0036907196, -0.006980896, 0.03994751, 0.05026245, 0.0021476746, -0.035888672, -0.02154541, -0.0012960434, 0.018173218, -0.017593384, -0.0031356812, 0.02973938, -0.017150879, 0.008049011, -0.0049057007, 0.010093689, 0.00037264824, 0.004386902, 0.008644104, -0.015060425, 0.0018167496, 0.01802063, 0.052642822, -0.04486084, -0.062438965, 0.00059890747, 0.028518677, 0.008956909, -0.013626099, 0.01928711, 0.03479004, 0.038635254, 0.0014791489, 0.013900757, 0.06951904, -0.031341553, 0.008224487, -0.007843018, 0.011360168, -0.03567505, 0.0519104, -0.018447876, 0.011123657, -0.04425049, -0.05038452, -0.020248413, 0.016723633, 0.01486969, 0.015197754, 0.015556335, -0.050048828, 0.020874023, -0.04522705, -0.0022792816, -0.041656494, 0.019317627, -0.025100708, -0.032165527, 0.02305603, 0.014663696, -0.018859863, -0.015274048, 0.029663086, 0.010093689, -0.0018959045, 0.03604126, 0.0068893433, -0.00071048737, -0.03451538, -0.018585205, 0.014526367, 0.035339355, -0.039642334, 0.019226074, -0.00258255, 0.074523926, 0.021377563, 0.047851562, 0.03717041, 0.004207611, 0.008392334, 0.0035648346, -0.0033168793, -0.032196045, -0.004425049, -0.043640137, -0.005710602, -0.035095215, 0.0029792786, -0.0637207, 0.011962891, 0.025817871, 0.009857178, -0.0027484894, 0.001991272, 0.0013914108, 0.022216797, 0.009094238, -0.011779785, 0.033294678, 0.012245178, 0.031829834, -0.022506714, -0.032684326, 0.026870728, 0.02407837, -0.018051147, 0.027252197, -0.055999756, -0.019195557, -0.011985779, -0.0017576218, 0.017105103, -0.03152466, -0.04397583, -0.034729004, -0.0017824173, -0.008079529, -0.0105896, 0.039855957, 0.03100586, -0.031829834, 0.011581421, 0.012832642, 0.008979797, -0.016998291, 0.005542755, 0.045074463, -0.034332275, 0.014427185, -0.011123657, -0.025985718, -0.021484375, 0.05908203, 0.016281128, -0.033050537, -0.01676941, 0.039367676, 0.023132324, 0.026824951, -0.014175415, -0.049560547, -0.016220093, 0.009552002, -0.0016183853, -0.010787964, -0.0008535385, 0.044433594, 0.06347656, -0.006832123, 0.031234741, 0.015914917, -0.0067825317, 0.004852295, 0.032989502, -0.066223145, 0.045562744, -0.010917664, -0.04446411, 0.013381958, 0.0066871643, -0.041931152, -0.0234375, 0.0013332367, 0.022979736, 0.025741577, 0.03933716, 0.010971069, -0.010681152, -0.0010185242, -0.047973633, 0.027038574, 0.044921875, -0.020370483, 0.014564514, -0.0435791, -0.04888916, 0.021820068, -0.03753662, 0.05517578, -0.031402588, 0.008392334, -0.025161743, -0.014541626, 0.040405273, -0.023223877, -0.023025513, -0.01763916, -0.017456055, 0.02003479, 0.010307312, -0.035064697, 0.002954483, 0.00012910366, -0.02168274, 0.020217896, 0.011161804, -0.0038700104, -0.037231445, -0.039123535, 0.059143066, -0.0104904175, 0.088256836, 0.0047035217, -0.022750854, -0.028305054, 0.026184082, -0.012428284, -0.010032654, -0.01008606, 0.018600464, -0.015571594, 0.010620117, 0.004272461, 0.024810791, -0.014778137, -0.07543945, -0.037322998, 0.005531311, -0.041412354, 0.030822754, -0.0046157837, -0.04623413, -0.025619507, 0.007396698, -0.0289917, 0.02609253, 0.012794495, -0.013946533, 0.043701172, -0.0032215118, -0.021972656, -0.002653122, 0.007293701, 0.019546509, 0.012359619, -0.010948181, -0.00021862984, 0.012382507, 0.01751709, -0.07183838, -0.06512451, -0.016311646, 0.041137695, 0.0001938343, 0.030761719, 0.017028809, 0.00060224533, 0.02192688, -0.0005469322, 0.0012025833, -0.034454346, 0.020492554, 0.0024051666, 0.036376953, 0.034057617, -0.016082764, 0.02470398, 0.019592285, -0.035339355, -0.0018920898, -0.01626587, 0.013572693, 0.0067100525, -0.0064468384, 0.030288696, -0.030380249, -0.0048713684, -0.022583008, 0.009796143, -0.00033640862, 0.0076026917, -0.02482605, 0.009742737, -0.023101807, 0.00881958, -0.01637268, -0.08068848, 0.056427002, 0.02607727, 0.009086609, 0.025558472, 0.010307312, -0.033996582, -0.018615723, 0.0007762909, -0.002483368, -0.007926941, 0.03479004, -0.045837402, 0.0045814514, -0.029251099, -0.025466919, 0.008232117, -0.012924194, 0.027450562, -0.028625488, 0.0069274902, -0.028335571, -0.012741089, -0.0020542145, 0.026947021, 0.032806396, -0.014930725, -0.0056610107, -0.008262634, 0.029006958, 0.00056886673 ], "summary": [ 0.004386902, -0.0093307495, -0.00920105, -0.029632568, -0.034057617, -0.004463196, -0.042755127, -0.0020141602, 0.047576904, -0.0022735596, -0.017913818, -0.039215088, -0.0075531006, -0.04208374, -0.022949219, -0.044158936, 0.028381348, -0.000808239, 0.015289307, -0.012176514, 0.04043579, 0.0024909973, 0.014923096, 0.012130737, 0.0067596436, -0.012718201, -0.049926758, 0.015975952, -0.009094238, 0.002784729, -0.005783081, 0.0084991455, 0.0104904175, -0.008796692, 0.01725769, 0.003250122, -0.012496948, 0.0037765503, 0.031280518, -0.000046551228, 0.010856628, -0.013298035, 0.040161133, -0.04827881, -0.021270752, 0.06695557, -0.04071045, -0.01828003, 0.053741455, -0.007446289, -0.008842468, 0.019729614, -0.016036987, 0.005596161, -0.02229309, -0.00078964233, -0.007663727, -0.026748657, 0.036712646, 0.081970215, 0.016998291, -0.019699097, -0.004272461, -0.087768555, -0.011955261, 0.017715454, 0.0053138733, -0.035736084, 0.07098389, 0.004875183, -0.020690918, 0.011375427, 0.015548706, -0.033569336, -0.010551453, 0.043121338, 0.021438599, 0.022705078, 0.007003784, -0.03363037, 0.012893677, 0.00447464, -0.007129669, -0.008094788, -0.0036258698, -0.01878357, -0.0069236755, -0.018188477, -0.014549255, -0.040527344, -0.016159058, -0.06762695, -0.03427124, 0.044403076, 0.009613037, -0.03805542, -0.002811432, -0.039642334, 0.009338379, -0.03845215, 0.050811768, -0.052612305, 0.009941101, 0.002286911, -0.008796692, 0.0023002625, 0.0009946823, 0.0012273788, 0.018997192, 0.02268982, -0.027145386, -0.026672363, -0.017471313, -0.03326416, -0.0032348633, 0.05239868, -0.0016078949, 0.032348633, 0.0034008026, 0.05734253, -0.027374268, -0.021118164, 0.013206482, 0.0703125, 0.0034484863, 0.042938232, 0.013122559, -0.030075073, -0.020996094, 0.027435303, 0.005268097, 0.021560669, -0.032287598, -0.024169922, -0.051116943, -0.004753113, 0.020996094, -0.026748657, -0.029144287, -0.006591797, 0.025604248, -0.014984131, -0.0020942688, -0.02015686, -0.015823364, 0.043701172, 0.050811768, 0.017181396, -0.060913086, -0.091430664, 0.02079773, 0.009376526, 0.0035362244, 0.0024299622, 0.002117157, -0.023239136, -0.04928589, -0.010620117, 0.02684021, 0.024978638, 0.016571045, 0.013153076, 0.056121826, 0.023101807, 0.009788513, -0.02230835, -0.06976318, -0.020431519, 0.019226074, 0.007843018, -0.0043563843, 0.017990112, 0.02468872, 0.0006914139, -0.007888794, -0.0023059845, 0.0009255409, -0.0010643005, 0.005710602, -0.0053100586, -0.00078964233, -0.029968262, 0.011138916, 0.0071029663, -0.040222168, -0.003025055, -0.023666382, 0.05508423, 0.07312012, -0.0012550354, -0.03842163, -0.060760498, 0.0031547546, 0.010032654, 0.01184845, -0.002325058, 0.013145447, 0.018585205, -0.010246277, -0.049987793, 0.049468994, -0.0022239685, -0.007446289, -0.047729492, -0.12200928, 0.004371643, -0.029510498, 0.027618408, -0.01739502, 0.020385742, 0.026168823, -0.010391235, -0.023757935, 0.0423584, -0.007537842, -0.053222656, 0.005783081, -0.01473999, -0.014976501, -0.032958984, 0.012390137, 0.018081665, -0.020370483, 0.03186035, -0.046539307, 0.017791748, 0.006893158, 0.046905518, 0.03237915, 0.04373169, 0.054473877, -0.08947754, -0.011512756, 0.01966858, -0.013648987, -0.04699707, 0.0057373047, -0.08276367, 0.052368164, 0.050109863, 0.018600464, -0.0010757446, -0.03491211, -0.01398468, 0.0058517456, 0.009757996, 0.029144287, -0.017868042, -0.01600647, 0.017059326, 0.02986145, 0.021469116, 0.027191162, 0.046173096, -0.005306244, 0.040863037, 0.042938232, 0.011909485, -0.01889038, 0.037963867, -0.005592346, 0.046173096, -0.0102005005, 0.018951416, -0.013755798, -0.03753662, -0.015716553, -0.017181396, 0.012939453, -0.026947021, 0.016708374, -0.049713135, -0.009223938, -0.050598145, -0.00067424774, -0.004940033, -0.04537964, 0.035614014, 0.0107040405, -0.018493652, -0.018829346, -0.04510498, -0.019622803, -0.009971619, 0.05355835, 0.024139404, 0.013671875, -0.0064430237, -0.013031006, 0.07269287, 0.09118652, 0.015914917, 0.023101807, -0.015686035, -0.04525757, 0.01499939, -0.009490967, -0.011184692, 0.04147339, -0.043884277, 0.030715942, 0.052825928, -0.04043579, 0.032165527, 0.0067825317, -0.0012626648, -0.0014238358, 0.021392822, 0.009300232, 0.0047073364, -0.02911377, 0.03250122, 0.017227173, 0.067993164, -0.05996704, -0.053466797, -0.041748047, 0.030700684, -0.015777588, 0.049865723, 0.05859375, 0.009887695, -0.0072364807, 0.014816284, 0.014877319, -0.025894165, 0.015808105, -0.025619507, -0.033691406, 0.015533447, -0.0027103424, -0.035858154, -0.017486572, -0.008880615, -0.009277344, -0.004436493, 0.00007790327, -0.006603241, -0.010345459, 0.05130005, 0.04360962, -0.074645996, -0.003168106, -0.025512695, -0.045135498, -0.030151367, 0.026489258, -0.008094788, -0.016281128, -0.016860962, 0.03994751, -0.025726318, 0.020980835, 0.019241333, 0.04458618, -0.0023269653, -0.036193848, 0.015419006, 0.008392334, -0.049591064, 0.013084412, 0.009902954, -0.025024414, -0.099975586, 0.014419556, -0.023345947, -0.040893555, -0.022247314, 0.04260254, 0.03390503, 0.011489868, 0.054626465, -0.07287598, -0.0022792816, 0.005317688, -0.004486084, 0.035247803, -0.03604126, 0.022491455, 0.035064697, -0.0030460358, 0.048553467, -0.016571045, 0.06689453, 0.082092285, 0.012382507, -0.022125244, 0.020874023, 0.008255005, -0.0009908676, -0.03375244, -0.02746582, 0.03439331, -0.019134521, 0.015853882, -0.019470215, -0.016326904, 0.021133423, -0.04498291, -0.01537323, -0.01209259, 0.040496826, 0.03012085, 0.0025577545, -0.05834961, 0.057250977, -0.050598145, -0.026260376, 0.018676758, 0.00063848495, -0.011856079, -0.015457153, -0.030075073, -0.019470215, -0.024520874, -0.016860962, -0.036376953, -0.0023536682, 0.015304565, 0.008888245, -0.035308838, 0.05255127, -0.035949707, 0.010040283, 0.0056114197, 0.059448242, -0.022018433, 0.013214111, -0.032806396, -0.010650635, 0.0008716583, -0.031204224, -0.024230957, -0.023651123, -0.032440186, -0.008666992, 0.0011949539, -0.017364502, 0.02243042, -0.03942871, -0.0064086914, -0.007297516, -0.049713135, -0.00020360947, -0.011993408, -0.041290283, 0.003376007, -0.010604858, -0.044525146, 0.004962921, -0.021392822, 0.017410278, -0.0018415451, 0.027297974, -0.01739502, 0.013320923, -0.030548096, 0.036895752, 0.07470703, -0.07678223, -0.0033302307, -0.04107666, -0.051086426, 0.014755249, 0.049224854, 0.013641357, -0.022094727, -0.0077667236, -0.047668457, 0.03173828, 0.0033226013, -0.058776855, -0.005138397, -0.013549805, -0.012214661, -0.052093506, 0.029846191, 0.021530151, 0.029724121, -0.029205322, -0.038146973, 0.016662598, -0.056274414, -0.050445557, -0.013725281, 0.0020561218, -0.0435791, -0.015991211, 0.00605011, -0.00037574768, -0.0061836243, -0.04269409, 0.05215454, -0.07293701, -0.038635254, 0.03173828, 0.0012636185, 0.035308838, -0.033355713, -0.04055786, -0.018829346, -0.013305664, -0.005634308, 0.04901123, 0.022857666, 0.0345459, 0.03125, 0.0022029877, -0.010299683, -0.021972656, 0.049682617, -0.044555664, -0.03564453, -0.006374359, -0.0135650635, -0.0021209717, 0.02217102, -0.075683594, 0.024734497, 0.029830933, 0.0018606186, 0.0066184998, 0.031555176, 0.021743774, -0.036346436, 0.020462036, -0.008270264, 0.050201416, -0.0024433136, -0.038116455, 0.032196045, -0.010261536, -0.0390625, 0.014122009, 0.020736694, 0.04269409, -0.057434082, -0.0020828247, 0.048309326, 0.0066375732, -0.025924683, -0.035827637, -0.022140503, 0.05529785, -0.004940033, 0.03677368, -0.004863739, 0.048339844, -0.024429321, 0.01448822, 0.0146865845, 0.014282227, -0.060180664, -0.01499176, -0.008148193, -0.00072050095, -0.04458618, 0.022644043, -0.015045166, 0.010856628, 0.03527832, -0.018295288, 0.014923096, -0.016159058, 0.056488037, 0.007980347, -0.047973633, -0.11401367, 0.04385376, -0.03189087, -0.05029297, -0.048034668, -0.039215088, -0.010543823, -0.008743286, 0.014717102, -0.007286072, 0.013694763, -0.012023926, 0.035614014, 0.040405273, 0.05392456, -0.029418945, 0.06890869, -0.02835083, 0.009590149, 0.023880005, -0.0010614395, -0.026245117, -0.015151978, -0.013435364, 0.02760315, -0.03665161, -0.081726074, -0.0039138794, 0.020019531, -0.010665894, 0.053222656, 0.019088745, 0.015045166, 0.04812622, -0.003293991, 0.007434845, 0.013336182, -0.035003662, -0.019714355, 0.006603241, 0.08270264, -0.017913818, 0.03616333, 0.01739502, -0.019607544, 0.001698494, 0.0063819885, -0.0015916824, 0.03427124, 0.016906738, -0.0066719055, -0.012962341, -0.01272583, 0.026473999, -0.0054244995, 0.019104004, 0.027160645, -0.014427185, -0.020950317, 0.03439331, 0.010871887, -0.020599365, -0.000079631805, 0.0018920898, -0.0038833618, -0.010971069, -0.119628906, -0.0074768066, 0.113098145, 0.014762878, -0.024490356, -0.025177002, 0.035003662, 0.03475952, 0.017959595, 0.023895264, -0.03933716, 0.011886597, -0.009857178, 0.004585266, 0.015060425, 0.0044059753, 0.005493164, -0.0066833496, 0.01612854, -0.06384277, -0.009674072, 0.061920166, -0.03265381, -0.009384155, -0.013549805, 0.021331787, -0.040252686, -0.024780273, 0.025878906, -0.036376953, 0.0070762634, 0.06915283, 0.007282257, -0.070373535, 0.009048462, -0.044006348, 0.04800415, -0.027923584, -0.059417725, 0.04321289, 0.004070282, 0.013458252, 0.020004272, 0.035125732, 0.012489319, 0.03186035, -0.030303955, 0.0017404556, -0.020202637, -0.019302368, 0.012641907, -0.014404297, 0.028671265, -0.018630981, -0.003276825, 0.013374329, -0.0029335022, -0.0007362366, -0.0060195923, 0.00086688995, -0.020523071, 0.008743286, 0.03137207, -0.017211914, -0.032684326, 0.004878998, -0.015083313, 0.016723633, -0.0036849976, -0.0009355545, -0.04397583, -0.00032687187, -0.012565613, -0.0050735474, -0.020614624, 0.040130615, 0.025741577, -0.015541077, -0.017303467, -0.024932861, -0.018356323, -0.04647827, -0.013069153, 0.012374878, 0.023040771, 0.04562378, 0.032440186, -0.01234436, -0.019165039, 0.00081157684, -0.0028438568, 0.037872314, -0.035980225, -0.024032593, 0.008361816, -0.037750244, -0.0423584, 0.011260986, -0.005748749, -0.021713257, -0.0051193237, 0.0069465637, -0.035705566, 0.020751953, 0.0029201508, 0.021133423, -0.03366089, 0.0006837845, -0.009880066, 0.020965576, -0.019561768, -0.016403198, 0.019897461, 0.0017614365, 0.016326904, 0.0008339882, 0.00945282, 0.027236938, 0.016403198, 0.025970459, -0.013702393, 0.021118164, -0.043548584, -0.020126343, -0.009376526, 0.028503418, -0.015617371, -0.046539307, 0.0046310425, -0.016113281, 0.006046295, 0.025482178, 0.008239746, -0.026275635, -0.004676819, -0.0073242188, -0.016082764, -0.0075263977, 0.00844574, -0.010505676, -0.033447266, 0.043823242, 0.0077323914, -0.055114746, 0.020477295, 0.020401001, 0.04623413, 0.010421753, 0.037719727, 0.022659302, -0.014160156, -0.03668213, 0.02961731, 0.029006958, 0.037384033, -0.024520874, 0.01411438, 0.03781128, 0.044952393, 0.061279297, -0.0053749084, 0.0023021698, -0.0055999756, 0.044067383, 0.022109985, -0.009376526, 0.0062828064, 0.067993164, -0.022247314, -0.038604736, -0.067993164, -0.060394287, -0.029937744, 0.012268066, -0.01335907, -0.004714966, 0.06210327, -0.012626648, 0.006713867, 0.033172607, -0.040252686, 0.061828613, -0.004386902, -0.00920105, -0.0030345917, 0.010574341, -0.028152466, 0.00024485588, 0.031829834, -0.021011353, 0.031799316, -0.036193848, -0.0033893585, 0.025177002, -0.026443481, -0.036010742, -0.056915283, 0.009536743, -0.046813965, -0.008071899, 0.018829346, 0.018692017, -0.00630188, -0.015213013, 0.04321289, -0.011062622, -0.011245728, 0.04260254, 0.014663696, -0.0034046173, 0.011482239, 0.027450562, -0.014945984, -0.004917145, -0.03955078, 0.038726807, 0.06304932, 0.035858154, -0.016479492, -0.014892578, 0.04876709, -0.0025024414, 0.017501831, -0.031066895, -0.060424805, -0.006580353, -0.027542114, -0.034118652, 0.036895752, -0.009651184, -0.011436462, 0.013092041, 0.044647217, 0.0132369995, 0.023269653, 0.008026123, 0.03314209, 0.034729004, -0.001376152, 0.0103302, 0.0044441223, -0.025558472, 0.010147095, 0.01309967, -0.016723633, 0.016677856, -0.059631348, 0.08404541, 0.03945923, 0.02760315, -0.070495605, -0.0043754578, 0.08734131, 0.007648468, 0.02078247, -0.01625061, 0.020965576, -0.029937744, -0.052368164, -0.010192871, -0.032104492, -0.031341553, 0.06341553, -0.03869629, 0.01966858, -0.023345947, -0.035186768, -0.023223877, 0.0034160614, 0.0057754517, -0.0006699562, -0.025482178, 0.023269653, 0.017166138, -0.020492554, 0.03845215, -0.015220642, -0.043914795, 0.034576416, 0.025924683, 0.026947021, -0.050048828, -0.038848877, 0.044921875, 0.044708252, 0.095825195, 0.07067871, -0.026763916, -0.005531311, 0.034942627, 0.014892578, -0.011779785, -0.036254883, 0.074157715, 0.011146545, 0.03692627, 0.023895264, 0.0473938, 0.0034751892, -0.07550049, -0.00919342, 0.0018167496, -0.032958984, 0.061035156, -0.021591187, -0.01991272, -0.038208008, 0.020248413, -0.035491943, 0.0158844, -0.003528595, -0.014892578, 0.03363037, 0.019012451, -0.020065308, 0.010536194, -0.013633728, -0.0041236877, -0.007537842, -0.0004916191, -0.0030059814, -0.01725769, 0.014953613, -0.039123535, -0.056488037, -0.0158844, 0.029586792, 0.0027332306, -0.02923584, -0.00069618225, -0.00299263, 0.014823914, 0.025238037, -0.002298355, -0.033355713, 0.044830322, 0.031555176, 0.035705566, 0.0013999939, -0.033416748, 0.04058838, -0.002626419, -0.058807373, -0.01953125, 0.011665344, 0.022750854, -0.005050659, 0.00025320053, 0.01864624, -0.048980713, -0.007736206, 0.049926758, -0.0045547485, -0.012001038, -0.017349243, -0.022537231, -0.03338623, -0.028686523, -0.029464722, -0.02684021, -0.044189453, 0.028579712, 0.020339966, 0.006175995, -0.0032138824, 0.03616333, -0.0046424866, 0.012718201, 0.021972656, 0.013465881, 0.017578125, -0.008460999, -0.037963867, -0.0046577454, -0.06262207, -0.03643799, -0.007888794, -0.0037956238, -0.013206482, -0.021133423, 0.02998352, 0.03378296, -0.006175995, 0.009124756, 0.022232056, 0.006298065, 0.010520935, 0.025878906, -0.0053100586, -0.014884949, 0.016479492 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07532v1
It's Not Easy Being Wrong: Evaluating Process of Elimination Reasoning in Large Language Models
Nishant Balepur, Shramay Palta, Rachel Rudinger
cs.CL
Chain-of-thought (COT) prompting can help large language models (LLMs) reason toward correct answers, but its efficacy in reasoning toward incorrect answers is unexplored. This strategy of process of elimination (PoE), when used with COT, has the potential to enhance interpretability in tasks like medical diagnoses of exclusion. Thus, we propose PoE with COT, a new task where LLMs must reason toward incorrect options on multiple-choice questions. We evaluate the ability of GPT-3.5, LLaMA-2, and Falcon to perform PoE with COT on 2-choice commonsense and scientific reasoning datasets. We show that PoE consistently underperforms directly choosing the correct answer. The agreement of these strategies is also lower than the self-consistency of each strategy. To study these issues further, we conduct an error analysis and give suggestions for future work.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07532v1
2023-11-13T18:18:22
2023-11-13T18:18:22
{ "title": [ -0.020385742, -0.013885498, -0.029663086, -0.06060791, -0.0026512146, -0.0006160736, -0.040985107, 0.0020332336, 0.01977539, 0.023757935, -0.015029907, -0.015365601, 0.0129776, -0.015083313, -0.055236816, 0.00085639954, -0.027297974, 0.042510986, -0.03414917, -0.041748047, -0.011909485, -0.06451416, 0.010627747, -0.005672455, 0.05633545, -0.068603516, -0.055786133, 0.01889038, -0.013763428, -0.015281677, -0.0061836243, 0.017868042, 0.032806396, 0.009460449, 0.018051147, -0.0077285767, -0.014961243, 0.013214111, 0.009819031, 0.012557983, 0.020050049, -0.007850647, -0.0063171387, -0.020324707, -0.0368042, 0.015220642, -0.049621582, -0.029571533, 0.004589081, 0.034179688, 0.010299683, 0.032928467, -0.00894928, 0.04055786, 0.007160187, -0.024902344, -0.01486969, 0.0008392334, 0.016052246, 0.06378174, 0.026046753, -0.006298065, -0.0045928955, -0.015777588, -0.039855957, -0.010375977, -0.014961243, 0.011932373, 0.07727051, 0.0022525787, -0.042388916, 0.031234741, 0.0131073, -0.006374359, -0.04244995, 0.031143188, 0.022613525, 0.009902954, 0.032836914, -0.037322998, 0.012886047, -0.011222839, -0.0067634583, -0.004295349, 0.008857727, -0.017074585, -0.0129852295, -0.0061912537, -0.03930664, -0.08343506, -0.014846802, -0.01890564, -0.048217773, -0.021896362, -0.019363403, -0.05419922, -0.018661499, 0.027435303, -0.011360168, -0.06286621, -0.021835327, 0.037872314, -0.094055176, 0.0067214966, -0.0012264252, 0.02619934, -0.029541016, -0.041870117, 0.008285522, 0.034454346, -0.006252289, 0.024093628, -0.0013875961, -0.0473938, 0.024978638, 0.028366089, -0.013076782, 0.03277588, 0.03564453, 0.028579712, -0.033691406, -0.05899048, 0.0008034706, 0.026306152, 0.03604126, 0.004261017, -0.045654297, 0.050231934, 0.0105896, 0.022125244, -0.00017344952, 0.037353516, -0.08306885, -0.08099365, -0.048187256, 0.032165527, -0.009170532, -0.0010290146, -0.026672363, 0.021560669, 0.012130737, -0.03768921, 0.0029029846, -0.0042686462, 0.0067634583, 0.022247314, 0.076538086, -0.012145996, -0.06222534, -0.047607422, -0.025466919, 0.010810852, 0.047210693, -0.029022217, -0.06738281, -0.042663574, -0.12670898, -0.0019302368, 0.011184692, -0.01727295, 0.012786865, 0.0024547577, 0.0058517456, -0.0064468384, -0.01071167, 0.006084442, -0.024490356, -0.007499695, 0.014533997, 0.028823853, -0.020690918, 0.018341064, -0.026168823, 0.0038967133, 0.0063972473, 0.006877899, -0.0023403168, 0.03225708, 0.005367279, 0.00015032291, 0.027236938, -0.023910522, 0.0016336441, 0.054504395, -0.0657959, -0.023361206, 0.0049438477, -0.0077667236, 0.05505371, 0.0065307617, 0.0070648193, 0.025421143, -0.019104004, -0.035736084, -0.015808105, -0.032318115, 0.022079468, 0.008087158, 0.0014514923, -0.0048332214, -0.024658203, 0.016799927, -0.033447266, 0.0072517395, -0.059753418, -0.013000488, -0.031463623, 0.026351929, -0.039916992, 0.0692749, 0.07086182, 0.044921875, -0.0803833, 0.062927246, 0.019088745, -0.096191406, 0.029769897, -0.009742737, 0.0062179565, -0.015640259, 0.009735107, 0.0005402565, 0.015098572, 0.037200928, 0.0022964478, -0.008529663, 0.00039887428, -0.032318115, 0.024642944, 0.0069084167, 0.04232788, -0.029769897, 0.036895752, 0.033233643, -0.0044937134, -0.029663086, -0.019927979, -0.030136108, 0.0062675476, 0.020950317, 0.008613586, -0.019226074, -0.017425537, 0.0013666153, 0.01689148, -0.032104492, 0.006099701, -0.012130737, 0.028457642, 0.028533936, 0.06964111, 0.006263733, 0.04714966, -0.0039100647, 0.01637268, 0.05609131, -0.004169464, -0.023971558, 0.0035362244, 0.0181427, 0.022735596, -0.0059432983, -0.03857422, 0.010177612, -0.038726807, -0.011795044, -0.049072266, -0.029937744, -0.0015487671, 0.0029392242, 0.025039673, -0.061950684, 0.014320374, -0.032073975, -0.012306213, 0.010826111, -0.026138306, 0.029129028, 0.013702393, -0.059539795, -0.018997192, 0.011039734, 0.06262207, 0.0026760101, -0.012779236, -0.0146102905, 0.03643799, -0.028564453, -0.029296875, -0.0054359436, 0.038238525, 0.04876709, 0.00969696, 0.000075638294, 0.011505127, 0.000875473, 0.09539795, 0.07574463, -0.0385437, 0.035095215, -0.03945923, 0.014122009, 0.025924683, -0.04272461, 0.02746582, 0.019256592, 0.055541992, 0.02218628, -0.022460938, 0.014328003, -0.055877686, -0.019348145, 0.0024585724, -0.033477783, -0.029663086, -0.031021118, 0.017105103, -0.031921387, 0.0066490173, 0.0002156496, 0.055786133, 0.0021400452, -0.02154541, 0.013206482, 0.008712769, -0.025543213, 0.012557983, -0.033233643, 0.00038957596, 0.024337769, 0.032318115, 0.013977051, -0.057403564, -0.06549072, -0.008911133, 0.004928589, -0.016845703, 0.04071045, -0.031402588, 0.0029850006, -0.002773285, -0.03866577, 0.018615723, -0.029693604, -0.013458252, -0.034698486, 0.007949829, 0.018005371, -0.017196655, -0.026428223, 0.02798462, -0.02368164, -0.014144897, 0.016662598, 0.050872803, -0.027938843, -0.023406982, 0.03591919, -0.0021820068, -0.03652954, 0.03869629, 0.036865234, 0.025619507, -0.040405273, -0.05819702, -0.0569458, -0.017120361, 0.009521484, -0.015159607, 0.013801575, -0.021697998, -0.02368164, -0.03387451, -0.019180298, 0.007221222, -0.008659363, 0.034301758, -0.024841309, -0.047790527, 0.0027694702, -0.041656494, 0.01927185, -0.06616211, 0.050933838, 0.10357666, 0.00084877014, 0.0423584, 0.014480591, 0.07281494, -0.00053977966, 0.0021972656, -0.03375244, 0.004875183, -0.015716553, 0.01171875, 0.011985779, -0.010810852, -0.02319336, -0.029403687, 0.0061531067, 0.030258179, 0.011146545, -0.018447876, 0.027618408, -0.08050537, 0.04031372, -0.048858643, -0.013938904, 0.03781128, -0.02067566, 0.02607727, -0.0009441376, 0.01979065, -0.058898926, -0.010467529, -0.04083252, -0.10662842, 0.03933716, -0.043182373, -0.038085938, -0.0085372925, 0.005645752, -0.046142578, -0.015670776, -0.031082153, 0.04019165, 0.010391235, 0.035705566, 0.00856781, -0.026062012, -0.022750854, -0.0090789795, -0.010787964, 0.0005302429, -0.034240723, 0.034118652, -0.00011640787, 0.05203247, 0.033843994, -0.012504578, 0.005218506, -0.0154418945, -0.06689453, 0.010093689, -0.017715454, -0.03967285, -0.0090789795, -0.0037727356, 0.007881165, -0.0027275085, -0.022918701, 0.004180908, -0.00793457, 0.01260376, -0.021728516, 0.0051116943, 0.01838684, -0.0012865067, -0.016784668, -0.012062073, 0.011383057, -0.0058670044, -0.060150146, -0.0018224716, 0.048950195, 0.016235352, -0.020263672, -0.012649536, -0.03579712, 0.036987305, -0.00868988, -0.0050239563, 0.01637268, 0.013366699, -0.028961182, 0.0019445419, 0.0073890686, 0.0042915344, -0.01828003, 0.005432129, -0.01448822, 0.012062073, -0.026733398, -0.08337402, -0.035491943, 0.00756073, -0.13012695, -0.039642334, 0.010650635, -0.028717041, -0.010383606, -0.0619812, 0.012863159, -0.02267456, -0.039489746, 0.009902954, -0.020080566, -0.010429382, -0.0046424866, -0.07891846, 0.007434845, 0.07684326, 0.010925293, 0.014328003, 0.019119263, -0.020248413, -0.034942627, -0.050201416, 0.03967285, 0.004234314, 0.008636475, -0.016281128, -0.049743652, 0.03668213, -0.03286743, 0.04647827, 0.022628784, -0.022979736, 0.019577026, 0.010505676, 0.009185791, 0.02178955, -0.0052604675, 0.038330078, 0.00075149536, 0.0026512146, -0.07531738, 0.026412964, -0.02935791, -0.024246216, 0.022872925, -0.0018415451, 0.0054473877, 0.019683838, 0.023422241, 0.0725708, -0.023391724, 0.014480591, 0.04071045, -0.009231567, -0.01914978, 0.006450653, 0.012130737, 0.024993896, 0.017974854, 0.033721924, -0.0061187744, 0.04348755, -0.011459351, -0.01939392, -0.012580872, 0.0082092285, -0.03286743, 0.011352539, -0.060516357, -0.031280518, -0.038208008, 0.018188477, -0.016296387, 0.051879883, 0.037719727, 0.0072517395, -0.00069093704, -0.0345459, 0.070495605, 0.011985779, -0.017059326, -0.076293945, 0.0056533813, -0.01084137, -0.058654785, -0.035247803, -0.025650024, -0.006210327, 0.033203125, 0.014060974, -0.031707764, 0.014823914, 0.030166626, 0.064819336, 0.03353882, -0.016525269, -0.048950195, 0.027893066, -0.0074501038, -0.037750244, 0.02645874, -0.0077171326, 0.01259613, -0.017501831, 0.024810791, -0.027954102, -0.0066604614, -0.04586792, 0.025634766, -0.009170532, 0.037109375, -0.008079529, 0.010345459, 0.027267456, -0.0039253235, 0.019927979, 0.0042648315, -0.03555298, -0.0035171509, 0.019119263, 0.06185913, -0.02053833, -0.0067710876, 0.0078125, 0.039978027, 0.027923584, -0.019836426, 0.0010175705, -0.023208618, 0.018569946, 0.029083252, 0.0054397583, -0.054016113, -0.060028076, -0.009803772, 0.01436615, 0.0211792, -0.020996094, 0.05532837, -0.028335571, 0.005756378, 0.017364502, -0.009506226, 0.0110321045, -0.014266968, 0.012588501, -0.053833008, -0.017669678, 0.001789093, 0.002866745, -0.036376953, 0.0032787323, 0.015296936, -0.00374794, 0.02015686, 0.043151855, 0.052001953, -0.027114868, -0.010231018, -0.025894165, -0.024307251, -0.005279541, -0.06390381, 0.008354187, -0.0040893555, 0.019424438, -0.046203613, 0.025817871, -0.054138184, -0.012786865, -0.016906738, -0.02230835, 0.028396606, -0.07098389, 0.03387451, 0.09698486, 0.0028152466, 0.049926758, 0.003332138, -0.0032539368, 0.013244629, 0.05078125, -0.013870239, 0.033081055, 0.024032593, -0.07763672, -0.02746582, -0.0064811707, 0.04171753, 0.0052719116, 0.02671814, 0.021026611, 0.00894928, -0.06561279, 0.010543823, 0.0068855286, 0.002653122, 0.017562866, -0.048614502, 0.020233154, 0.010498047, 0.002735138, 0.012893677, -0.026885986, -0.03152466, -0.02229309, -0.0014972687, -0.03253174, 0.033813477, 0.0044670105, -0.05203247, -0.035247803, 0.0038471222, 0.0048103333, -0.0053863525, 0.017303467, 0.02015686, -0.038970947, 0.013504028, 0.053375244, -0.015586853, 0.016357422, -0.03677368, -0.015029907, 0.045074463, 0.04373169, -0.013008118, -0.0033302307, -0.0045700073, -0.043060303, -0.012573242, 0.009346008, -0.011413574, 0.00070619583, -0.005252838, -0.022903442, -0.0010738373, -0.0067367554, 0.02947998, -0.024658203, 0.0028057098, 0.025558472, -0.0132751465, -0.0069770813, 0.0030651093, 0.018051147, 0.0073890686, 0.0063591003, 0.00554657, -0.03579712, 0.015296936, 0.0004684925, 0.02229309, -0.04736328, -0.078063965, 0.002374649, 0.020690918, 0.007713318, 0.0011177063, 0.012809753, 0.03942871, 0.03387451, -0.021621704, 0.0053710938, 0.052856445, -0.045562744, -0.0067481995, 0.005027771, 0.0062942505, -0.004497528, 0.06750488, -0.010955811, -0.00274086, -0.036621094, -0.056640625, -0.018692017, 0.008865356, 0.01436615, 0.013336182, 0.02017212, -0.028198242, 0.027236938, -0.04159546, -0.01486969, -0.025726318, 0.008171082, -0.020111084, -0.051361084, 0.03527832, -0.0022468567, -0.001991272, 0.0020198822, 0.0107421875, 0.03265381, -0.0067253113, 0.03503418, -0.057373047, 0.0007519722, -0.024169922, -0.045715332, 0.030395508, 0.016540527, -0.009376526, 0.04260254, -0.019104004, 0.0541687, 0.0012025833, 0.0647583, 0.033691406, 0.017730713, 0.010932922, -0.0066871643, 0.010612488, -0.0362854, 0.034179688, -0.03515625, 0.0059280396, -0.060455322, -0.002407074, -0.0859375, 0.016098022, 0.0049324036, 0.047576904, -0.0031051636, 0.021102905, 0.024536133, 0.011207581, 0.049468994, 0.013092041, 0.09320068, 0.0115356445, -0.0018615723, 0.017654419, -0.0021247864, 0.0060310364, 0.032836914, -0.0015268326, 0.010482788, -0.009712219, -0.0020427704, 0.01386261, -0.0039901733, 0.013282776, -0.023513794, -0.005126953, -0.02192688, 0.03074646, 0.0038089752, 0.03756714, 0.052764893, 0.007972717, 0.014320374, -0.022705078, -0.006214142, -0.037200928, -0.028335571, 0.0048713684, 0.0060768127, -0.05230713, 0.04058838, -0.0051879883, -0.01335144, -0.016433716, 0.045166016, 0.026351929, -0.039276123, -0.007980347, -0.007259369, 0.02949524, -0.00038290024, 0.006099701, -0.029830933, -0.02229309, 0.02798462, 0.052490234, -0.009284973, 0.03488159, -0.0025539398, 0.010139465, -0.0068969727, -0.0635376, 0.029342651, -0.017608643, 0.011810303, 0.031829834, 0.029525757, 0.023345947, 0.014015198, -0.019241333, -0.004470825, 0.021743774, -0.060516357, 0.013580322, -0.02217102, 0.018157959, 0.0044441223, 0.06109619, 0.017211914, -0.008773804, -0.02168274, -0.033172607, 0.018798828, 0.047424316, -0.016860962, 0.04373169, -0.0513916, -0.0541687, 0.035827637, -0.03857422, 0.055633545, -0.06640625, 0.0018024445, -0.03250122, 0.046051025, -0.0025806427, -0.048736572, -0.040100098, -0.007549286, -0.030212402, -0.012771606, -0.027297974, -0.033569336, -0.042175293, -0.025741577, 0.020568848, -0.008781433, -0.0024471283, -0.009155273, -0.022598267, -0.055908203, -0.01826477, -0.025268555, 0.030639648, -0.018844604, 0.019241333, -0.009353638, 0.023895264, -0.019515991, -0.045898438, -0.037750244, 0.00033593178, -0.01184082, -0.024719238, 0.015319824, 0.015731812, -0.0119018555, -0.023132324, -0.034820557, -0.00014960766, -0.031921387, 0.025299072, 0.0056381226, -0.046966553, -0.037109375, 0.007385254, -0.01979065, 0.038757324, 0.013664246, -0.0034694672, 0.035705566, 0.0084991455, -0.021942139, -0.0087890625, 0.015159607, 0.03842163, 0.010353088, -0.053375244, 0.01449585, 0.02305603, 0.041107178, -0.038604736, -0.020523071, 0.023620605, 0.008171082, 0.0068588257, 0.031433105, 0.017471313, 0.0035934448, 0.02897644, 0.003993988, 0.00365448, -0.040802002, -0.027893066, 0.021438599, 0.049346924, 0.026473999, 0.008041382, -0.010574341, 0.010238647, -0.053253174, 0.005001068, -0.006023407, -0.005142212, 0.015144348, -0.012435913, 0.011581421, -0.027297974, 0.005634308, -0.019958496, -0.017974854, 0.008522034, 0.020324707, -0.028808594, 0.010040283, -0.034729004, 0.02633667, -0.024612427, -0.07067871, 0.05014038, 0.06774902, 0.010528564, 0.046417236, -0.018035889, -0.028503418, 0.0063667297, 0.005054474, -0.001824379, 0.0027313232, -0.00434494, -0.022964478, 0.00049877167, -0.044647217, -0.029129028, 0.012054443, -0.032470703, 0.024642944, -0.024429321, 0.024139404, -0.016708374, 0.0013132095, -0.0064201355, 0.029953003, 0.018432617, -0.050964355, -0.027130127, 0.027816772, 0.064941406, 0.003068924 ], "summary": [ 0.017440796, -0.011817932, 0.01600647, 0.044189453, -0.02255249, -0.015899658, 0.018753052, -0.043395996, 0.015434265, -0.0012645721, -0.0259552, -0.021224976, 0.020553589, -0.03866577, 0.016098022, -0.030273438, -0.016830444, 0.0061302185, -0.026123047, -0.027175903, 0.009559631, -0.04260254, -0.026229858, -0.016723633, -0.023468018, 0.03152466, -0.020095825, -0.026672363, 0.004623413, -0.006702423, -0.0030097961, 0.021057129, 0.018035889, 0.00806427, -0.03289795, -0.013473511, -0.01159668, 0.021392822, -0.014549255, 0.022598267, 0.010040283, 0.00057411194, -0.013839722, -0.028137207, -0.056762695, 0.0206604, -0.03640747, 0.0023059845, 0.029159546, 0.020004272, 0.018066406, -0.005214691, 0.022354126, 0.06958008, -0.045776367, -0.033294678, -0.023880005, -0.02166748, 0.008628845, 0.11431885, 0.04159546, 0.007881165, -0.039520264, -0.08251953, -0.0061798096, 0.00017368793, 0.008125305, 0.007820129, 0.0680542, 0.017318726, -0.0129852295, 0.025802612, 0.018371582, -0.021102905, -0.026412964, 0.0026683807, 0.027679443, -0.008712769, 0.017593384, -0.024642944, -0.022567749, 0.021209717, 0.005531311, -0.058898926, 0.030853271, -0.005256653, -0.019714355, -0.011726379, -0.018157959, -0.0826416, -0.0126953125, -0.035186768, -0.07458496, 0.00036501884, -0.003200531, -0.07531738, 0.02281189, -0.0038757324, -0.0093307495, -0.06384277, 0.042541504, -0.028762817, -0.053375244, 0.021636963, -0.0020523071, 0.030776978, -0.028640747, -0.03375244, 0.027526855, 0.02885437, 0.0012617111, 0.011726379, 0.012542725, -0.06713867, 0.01197052, 0.0637207, 0.03189087, 0.04168701, 0.04284668, 0.024612427, -0.023284912, -0.03765869, 0.033996582, 0.062042236, 0.015388489, 0.03289795, -0.027526855, 0.0061454773, 0.0064086914, -0.008277893, -0.008453369, 0.02760315, 0.035705566, 0.008926392, -0.021453857, -0.00642395, 0.0053634644, 0.004714966, -0.016998291, -0.009231567, 0.06732178, -0.015716553, -0.00554657, 0.03692627, -0.0016736984, 0.060302734, 0.024261475, -0.013160706, -0.0051193237, -0.053771973, -0.014663696, -0.031463623, 0.043121338, -0.028518677, -0.07269287, -0.063964844, -0.10992432, 0.008087158, 0.04324341, -0.02557373, 0.005973816, 0.005592346, 0.016204834, 0.017486572, -0.023986816, -0.010223389, 0.0049591064, -0.009719849, 0.023406982, 0.06286621, -0.0053138733, 0.011802673, 0.031402588, -0.002401352, -0.008041382, -0.015548706, -0.0056877136, 0.030639648, 0.0043182373, 0.053375244, 0.036499023, -0.027267456, 0.022125244, 0.02217102, -0.02684021, 0.024368286, 0.029937744, 0.098083496, -0.004600525, 0.03451538, -0.002161026, -0.008636475, -0.048461914, -0.012756348, 0.008369446, -0.030471802, 0.011878967, -0.029037476, 0.014160156, 0.016189575, 0.04046631, 0.0005955696, 0.0012683868, -0.02204895, -0.07623291, 0.006843567, -0.02508545, 0.022567749, -0.012458801, 0.031066895, 0.032928467, -0.0000564456, -0.037750244, 0.017654419, -0.025772095, -0.059051514, 0.03125, -0.029281616, 0.011398315, -0.035614014, 0.017669678, 0.035308838, -0.015914917, 0.019958496, 0.025512695, -0.0077667236, -0.012687683, -0.013931274, 0.0057373047, 0.028366089, -0.04034424, -0.008674622, 0.0075569153, 0.044433594, -0.0025539398, -0.015144348, 0.029144287, -0.029464722, 0.01675415, 0.017089844, 0.02444458, -0.0019073486, -0.06774902, -0.0690918, 0.06744385, 0.025604248, 0.0079574585, -0.024337769, 0.008041382, 0.030517578, -0.0006866455, 0.022491455, 0.033294678, 0.07421875, 0.024856567, 0.029434204, -0.040161133, -0.03439331, -0.00049209595, -0.0062179565, 0.011909485, -0.024536133, -0.01171875, -0.0052948, 0.026916504, -0.03955078, 0.0040283203, -0.015808105, -0.003332138, -0.016586304, 0.019973755, -0.083740234, 0.018997192, -0.0385437, -0.025878906, 0.0121154785, -0.018844604, 0.010314941, 0.055023193, -0.028259277, -0.011962891, 0.017456055, 0.01586914, -0.004890442, -0.00340271, -0.008811951, 0.03375244, 0.011543274, -0.021102905, 0.007030487, 0.033050537, 0.00056028366, -0.026260376, 0.0051345825, 0.00040197372, -0.021759033, 0.008384705, 0.04156494, -0.011474609, -0.005329132, -0.022903442, 0.024215698, 0.003490448, -0.031051636, 0.022369385, 0.008682251, 0.0345459, 0.019882202, 0.019607544, 0.0026168823, -0.032592773, -0.006099701, 0.019882202, 0.064941406, -0.06750488, -0.0592041, -0.025131226, 0.015625, -0.031036377, 0.012435913, 0.08685303, 0.016799927, -0.012680054, 0.034576416, 0.0008301735, -0.049346924, 0.053253174, -0.029937744, 0.019744873, 0.011657715, 0.0018339157, 0.0025405884, -0.015075684, -0.010055542, 0.013954163, -0.01158905, 0.017211914, 0.059661865, 0.014205933, -0.041625977, 0.026153564, -0.04031372, -0.025604248, 0.028335571, -0.018875122, 0.010284424, -0.011924744, 0.006916046, -0.0028018951, -0.012786865, -0.0014705658, -0.010513306, -0.0039482117, 0.027404785, 0.01713562, -0.025527954, -0.014633179, 0.018005371, -0.010726929, -0.05014038, 0.026000977, 0.014221191, 0.018737793, 0.011985779, -0.04547119, -0.017807007, -0.017654419, 0.049346924, 0.01197052, 0.0070114136, -0.0060920715, 0.052246094, -0.07147217, -0.019836426, -0.0009994507, 0.004047394, 0.10626221, -0.0014352798, -0.04043579, 0.037231445, 0.019180298, 0.037353516, -0.029449463, 0.005214691, 0.07745361, 0.027236938, 0.08178711, 0.029785156, 0.051086426, -0.035095215, 0.0079574585, -0.0042648315, 0.017547607, -0.04171753, -0.027954102, 0.028625488, -0.032104492, -0.051330566, 0.061279297, -0.01776123, 0.07879639, -0.0040664673, 0.0151901245, 0.018157959, -0.042022705, 0.045074463, 0.021377563, 0.024749756, 0.052581787, -0.036834717, 0.047088623, -0.030807495, 0.05633545, -0.07055664, -0.013305664, -0.021469116, -0.02330017, 0.019561768, -0.026367188, -0.008369446, 0.012832642, 0.0028209686, -0.00046634674, 0.0021076202, 0.0031166077, 0.048919678, -0.018753052, 0.0012044907, 0.002922058, -0.003616333, 0.0034694672, -0.013504028, -0.0138168335, -0.016616821, -0.023727417, 0.013557434, 0.009796143, 0.0317688, 0.024475098, -0.023376465, 0.0016059875, -0.017944336, -0.068359375, -0.00806427, -0.022140503, -0.028381348, -0.016235352, -0.0015125275, -0.02784729, -0.0017642975, -0.021026611, 0.0046310425, 0.025283813, 0.032440186, -0.0053520203, 0.06652832, -0.03265381, -0.0032920837, 0.013885498, -0.003293991, -0.024932861, 0.019805908, -0.038879395, -0.044433594, 0.022644043, 0.021774292, -0.03265381, 0.020523071, -0.016479492, 0.0019626617, 0.046875, -0.011650085, -0.0025138855, 0.028533936, -0.014724731, 0.040161133, 0.00046730042, 0.006084442, -0.019424438, 0.0035381317, -0.056610107, 0.03955078, -0.036346436, -0.07574463, -0.07299805, 0.021194458, -0.07727051, -0.07330322, -0.009803772, 0.0011701584, 0.057128906, -0.03451538, 0.051879883, -0.038848877, -0.030731201, -0.032043457, -0.034820557, 0.06628418, 0.005264282, -0.05545044, 0.060333252, -0.0054397583, -0.03643799, 0.017288208, -0.011459351, -0.010429382, 0.013710022, -0.007820129, 0.008026123, 0.013908386, 0.0044136047, -0.01637268, -0.01928711, 0.012672424, -0.024917603, 0.020309448, 0.01864624, -0.024505615, 0.011177063, 0.0050964355, 0.03894043, 0.029922485, -0.015174866, -0.009353638, 0.039398193, -0.0043792725, -0.025283813, 0.019943237, 0.003206253, -0.020980835, -0.002855301, -0.012084961, -0.018325806, 0.012893677, 0.04272461, 0.027709961, -0.03741455, -0.008926392, 0.046813965, 0.018005371, -0.0158844, -0.018539429, -0.0014362335, 0.06237793, 0.0053863525, 0.03475952, 0.0021381378, 0.03149414, -0.027435303, 0.004322052, -0.02973938, -0.016311646, -0.014022827, -0.008354187, -0.04940796, 0.020523071, -0.042114258, 0.016571045, -0.0015621185, 0.012886047, 0.02407837, 0.009033203, -0.017974854, -0.011413574, 0.07019043, 0.0021686554, -0.020401001, -0.08306885, -0.057891846, -0.0049934387, -0.03616333, -0.018966675, -0.086120605, -0.07525635, -0.0385437, 0.026260376, -0.023513794, 0.023986816, -0.019744873, 0.0335083, 0.062164307, 0.002166748, -0.08496094, 0.04196167, -0.01626587, 0.02027893, 0.007419586, -0.0018548965, -0.0020332336, 0.00038266182, -0.00868988, 0.01121521, -0.039794922, -0.07281494, 0.018249512, 0.034301758, 0.0074653625, 0.044677734, 0.02444458, 0.030334473, 0.022018433, 0.013244629, -0.00035357475, -0.011299133, -0.017684937, 0.020599365, 0.01663208, 0.03829956, -0.04208374, -0.028335571, 0.04348755, 0.013626099, -0.01576233, -0.005290985, -0.03656006, 0.018829346, -0.0390625, 0.053985596, 0.0149383545, 0.00047945976, 0.01940918, -0.014434814, 0.01574707, -0.020507812, -0.0068206787, -0.026550293, -0.020965576, 0.009414673, -0.0055732727, -0.0038661957, 0.013824463, 0.001329422, -0.031173706, -0.006717682, 0.0059280396, 0.0063171387, -0.026535034, -0.024017334, -0.010154724, -0.0019893646, 0.0051498413, 0.04663086, 0.064819336, -0.05001831, 0.040100098, -0.018432617, -0.005153656, 0.014060974, -0.020599365, -0.019973755, -0.0020141602, 0.014190674, -0.051940918, 0.025268555, 0.043304443, -0.023071289, -0.0096206665, -0.008422852, -0.0011491776, -0.042175293, -0.023132324, -0.0035324097, -0.03778076, 0.0132369995, 0.0413208, -0.004085541, -0.03967285, 0.042816162, -0.053222656, 0.047943115, 0.0024337769, -0.044921875, -0.054992676, -0.012901306, 0.031021118, 0.03540039, 0.021102905, 0.03363037, -0.003850937, -0.037872314, -0.0017385483, 0.00969696, -0.018844604, 0.017318726, -0.02835083, 0.051239014, 0.016738892, -0.0063667297, -0.006362915, 0.032348633, -0.032165527, -0.016860962, 0.008033752, -0.023132324, -0.030517578, -0.0362854, -0.027786255, 0.02848816, 0.004009247, -0.012527466, -0.00623703, 0.02558899, 0.005596161, 0.010604858, -0.019058228, 0.03753662, -0.016952515, 0.0069351196, 0.00069379807, 0.02394104, -0.015731812, -0.005970001, -0.034698486, -0.008049011, -0.016479492, 0.00049066544, 0.008125305, 0.056732178, 0.030029297, -0.0034313202, 0.004131317, 0.026931763, 0.051483154, -0.0076446533, 0.03479004, -0.012939453, -0.037506104, 0.014053345, -0.027038574, -0.043121338, 0.022003174, 0.050445557, -0.099487305, 0.029800415, 0.06088257, -0.010559082, 0.008895874, 0.013679504, 0.03756714, -0.04788208, -0.035339355, -0.008033752, 0.04510498, 0.00008159876, -0.012306213, -0.0047073364, -0.0046958923, 0.031402588, -0.06378174, -0.035095215, -0.010009766, 0.011993408, -0.06378174, -0.007358551, 0.016983032, 0.008674622, 0.058654785, -0.016799927, -0.070129395, -0.012451172, -0.036712646, 0.0011062622, -0.0028858185, 0.02746582, -0.013534546, 0.024154663, -0.003660202, 0.016220093, 0.050628662, -0.007888794, -0.033569336, -0.027633667, -0.016952515, -0.021713257, 0.08087158, 0.064086914, 0.00472641, -0.016067505, -0.000957489, -0.0070228577, -0.005924225, 0.026443481, 0.00642395, 0.0058631897, -0.011619568, 0.0010557175, 0.053588867, 0.0044898987, -0.0011720657, 0.03491211, 0.04473877, 0.023376465, -0.0036716461, 0.05557251, -0.007423401, -0.0033454895, 0.049682617, 0.0057258606, -0.00075769424, -0.024490356, 0.043273926, -0.0395813, 0.004333496, -0.016738892, -0.018844604, -0.012145996, 0.0029830933, 0.028579712, 0.0074043274, 0.0017118454, 0.0010023117, 0.0030937195, 0.034942627, -0.033172607, 0.0058135986, 0.017730713, -0.01763916, -0.027038574, 0.014724731, 0.0541687, -0.013557434, 0.010986328, 0.00919342, 0.042755127, -0.07183838, 0.06939697, 0.0035381317, -0.06359863, -0.011703491, -0.00031924248, 0.025238037, 0.0025959015, -0.011833191, 0.037109375, 0.030914307, -0.020355225, -0.029632568, 0.021957397, 0.015312195, -0.022491455, 0.0028324127, 0.0063705444, -0.021621704, -0.00092697144, 0.013656616, -0.008071899, -0.0043411255, -0.017074585, -0.033294678, 0.02142334, 0.029647827, -0.047729492, 0.03479004, -0.020370483, -0.0025615692, -0.023422241, 0.031311035, -0.020523071, -0.03717041, -0.010551453, 0.021347046, 0.002363205, 0.045135498, -0.015914917, -0.014839172, 0.014762878, -0.041503906, -0.0019760132, 0.0029945374, -0.007789612, 0.03213501, 0.045837402, 0.040924072, 0.042114258, -0.0016260147, 0.045928955, 0.037841797, -0.024429321, 0.044158936, 0.0046958923, 0.049194336, -0.021453857, 0.03604126, -0.032592773, -0.029464722, 0.0044059753, 0.029418945, 0.015350342, 0.024627686, 0.030044556, 0.012001038, -0.046844482, -0.0072402954, 0.006111145, 0.0112838745, 0.05480957, -0.07269287, 0.016326904, -0.014060974, 0.029754639, -0.041137695, 0.00894165, -0.06842041, 0.027267456, -0.023620605, 0.007381439, 0.010498047, -0.032562256, 0.018615723, -0.039855957, -0.02923584, 0.012207031, -0.0005578995, -0.0010147095, -0.011711121, 0.011756897, -0.0019550323, 0.024871826, 0.04348755, 0.038970947, -0.033569336, 0.019805908, 0.0289917, 0.026901245, -0.038269043, -0.059539795, 0.07696533, 0.05908203, 0.037384033, -0.017105103, 0.012878418, -0.02279663, -0.07672119, 0.022399902, 0.02029419, -0.045928955, 0.029586792, 0.0015201569, 0.0046691895, -0.047607422, 0.0010538101, -0.031951904, -0.0004940033, -0.004886627, -0.03074646, 0.072143555, -0.0015306473, -0.023651123, -0.0047912598, -0.034942627, -0.046691895, -0.009483337, -0.06524658, 0.0018625259, -0.009490967, 0.028259277, -0.020339966, 0.0075569153, 0.027633667, 0.053588867, -0.004486084, 0.0000066161156, -0.0010251999, 0.02079773, 0.040802002, 0.009262085, 0.012825012, -0.033233643, 0.014625549, 0.044799805, 0.036956787, -0.005126953, -0.023651123, 0.009223938, -0.0035648346, -0.040405273, -0.018371582, -0.016418457, 0.029052734, -0.034362793, 0.00015640259, -0.015716553, -0.0317688, -0.06021118, -0.003232956, -0.01828003, 0.018569946, 0.04537964, -0.064208984, 0.026763916, -0.0020008087, -0.03768921, 0.0029144287, 0.01285553, -0.00983429, 0.019485474, 0.010879517, 0.018432617, -0.0042800903, -0.00089502335, 0.034454346, -0.009155273, -0.0040779114, -0.011703491, 0.021621704, -0.0013227463, -0.030471802, -0.025726318, -0.07720947, 0.030838013, -0.00774765, -0.031555176, -0.029693604, 0.07550049, 0.07305908, -0.012687683, 0.037475586, 0.019973755, 0.029708862, 0.008491516, 0.031280518, 0.052093506, -0.010116577, 0.023101807 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07509v1
A Benchmark to Understand the Role of Knowledge Graphs on Large Language Model's Accuracy for Question Answering on Enterprise SQL Databases
Juan Sequeda, Dean Allemang, Bryon Jacob
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DB
Enterprise applications of Large Language Models (LLMs) hold promise for question answering on enterprise SQL databases. However, the extent to which LLMs can accurately respond to enterprise questions in such databases remains unclear, given the absence of suitable Text-to-SQL benchmarks tailored to enterprise settings. Additionally, the potential of Knowledge Graphs (KGs) to enhance LLM-based question answering by providing business context is not well understood. This study aims to evaluate the accuracy of LLM-powered question answering systems in the context of enterprise questions and SQL databases, while also exploring the role of knowledge graphs in improving accuracy. To achieve this, we introduce a benchmark comprising an enterprise SQL schema in the insurance domain, a range of enterprise queries encompassing reporting to metrics, and a contextual layer incorporating an ontology and mappings that define a knowledge graph. Our primary finding reveals that question answering using GPT-4, with zero-shot prompts directly on SQL databases, achieves an accuracy of 16%. Notably, this accuracy increases to 54% when questions are posed over a Knowledge Graph representation of the enterprise SQL database. Therefore, investing in Knowledge Graph provides higher accuracy for LLM powered question answering systems.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07509v1
2023-11-13T17:54:50
2023-11-13T17:54:50
{ "title": [ -0.01737976, -0.027069092, -0.044952393, -0.048461914, -0.043060303, -0.014373779, -0.06085205, 0.030944824, 0.025619507, 0.052093506, -0.034698486, 0.019302368, 0.012718201, -0.0062065125, -0.050048828, -0.014389038, 0.022018433, 0.015960693, 0.03277588, 0.0036296844, 0.0052757263, 0.015991211, 0.015098572, 0.016479492, 0.051452637, -0.06604004, -0.030548096, -0.011436462, 0.04660034, -0.0047454834, 0.017150879, -0.013504028, 0.03591919, -0.013160706, -0.0048332214, 0.0055122375, -0.05178833, 0.021392822, 0.009277344, -0.023376465, 0.046844482, -0.04586792, 0.076293945, -0.016662598, 0.029571533, 0.059539795, -0.013893127, -0.05709839, 0.029205322, -0.019699097, 0.011932373, 0.037628174, 0.050323486, 0.016036987, -0.03048706, -0.00299263, -0.064941406, -0.045166016, -0.0017566681, 0.05206299, 0.026931763, -0.0007266998, 0.021957397, -0.004837036, -0.004837036, 0.0050201416, -0.0009784698, -0.024520874, 0.06378174, 0.0053100586, -0.026321411, 0.01876831, 0.020141602, -0.006652832, -0.013908386, 0.019836426, 0.0036582947, 0.033691406, 0.020385742, -0.027389526, -0.018997192, -0.0056533813, -0.005584717, -0.023086548, -0.023452759, -0.039794922, -0.021652222, 0.005004883, -0.029296875, -0.075683594, -0.010108948, -0.05545044, -0.0770874, 0.015701294, 0.022827148, -0.07092285, 0.037384033, 0.026977539, -0.007217407, -0.06567383, -0.011276245, -0.018798828, -0.08959961, 0.007926941, 0.03265381, 0.02178955, -0.01826477, 0.013748169, 0.051208496, 0.026367188, -0.0126571655, 0.036315918, 0.023834229, -0.04486084, -0.006702423, -0.0024356842, -0.028945923, 0.022216797, 0.031677246, 0.02406311, -0.029632568, -0.013298035, 0.015571594, -0.0073013306, 0.035003662, -0.01838684, -0.02784729, 0.0395813, -0.030929565, 0.019302368, -0.0035362244, 0.058807373, -0.025421143, -0.04876709, -0.05307007, 0.007575989, 0.0042419434, 0.018295288, -0.016998291, 0.030761719, -0.008277893, -0.03161621, 0.027908325, 0.0029335022, -0.022750854, 0.018737793, 0.034057617, 0.003967285, -0.0151901245, -0.077941895, -0.0024108887, 0.0096206665, 0.019088745, -0.027572632, -0.04623413, -0.041259766, -0.114990234, 0.015655518, 0.03817749, 0.0039634705, -0.0061302185, 0.025115967, 0.047302246, -0.0236969, -0.022644043, -0.030715942, -0.026565552, -0.018157959, 0.0021038055, 0.02331543, -0.048065186, 0.028915405, 0.039031982, -0.01133728, -0.017974854, 0.020462036, 0.008201599, -0.017166138, -0.00023949146, 0.012069702, 0.016555786, -0.013572693, -0.013633728, 0.044128418, -0.020858765, -0.017700195, 0.005153656, 0.014251709, 0.032470703, 0.0007047653, 0.00497818, 0.0036525726, -0.0067634583, -0.009719849, -0.027267456, -0.028717041, -0.007293701, 0.010429382, -0.0042877197, 0.001455307, -0.041290283, 0.0057144165, -0.02168274, 0.06304932, 0.005115509, -0.032043457, 0.007003784, -0.012786865, 0.05822754, 0.057525635, 0.010887146, 0.06713867, -0.049438477, -0.01763916, -0.04611206, -0.03552246, -0.009780884, -0.046142578, 0.005554199, -0.033416748, 0.02722168, 0.043151855, 0.008354187, 0.023788452, -0.031173706, 0.015464783, -0.012184143, 0.012084961, -0.024353027, 0.016357422, 0.06842041, -0.010116577, 0.09991455, 0.071777344, -0.014053345, -0.021362305, 0.011131287, -0.059661865, -0.008354187, 0.035125732, 0.01096344, -0.07104492, -0.018310547, 0.004840851, -0.048919678, -0.023284912, 0.018508911, -0.008087158, 0.026504517, 0.060791016, 0.0015697479, 0.01576233, -0.0052757263, 0.034332275, 0.016555786, 0.029663086, -0.0063056946, 0.031341553, -0.018341064, 0.005176544, 0.012123108, 0.024795532, 0.022354126, 0.00818634, -0.016403198, 0.019927979, -0.00819397, 0.014663696, -0.003704071, 0.0087890625, -0.0033283234, -0.043823242, 0.018936157, -0.0070266724, -0.03652954, -0.0017747879, -0.016586304, 0.03125, 0.032836914, -0.029891968, -0.0138168335, 0.035980225, 0.05041504, -0.020385742, -0.027572632, 0.049438477, 0.03781128, -0.02230835, -0.0013017654, 0.018356323, 0.03048706, 0.035339355, 0.009284973, 0.02407837, 0.04626465, 0.0018968582, 0.061401367, 0.04916382, -0.0184021, 0.017242432, -0.012260437, 0.023330688, -0.010025024, -0.005672455, 0.038085938, -0.02381897, 0.051696777, -0.001411438, -0.013595581, 0.009727478, -0.06088257, -0.010681152, 0.01953125, 0.007858276, -0.008872986, -0.02935791, -0.020095825, 0.015319824, -0.07556152, -0.036102295, 0.055236816, 0.021743774, -0.02633667, -0.014564514, 0.009765625, -0.027816772, -0.038604736, -0.02154541, 0.0031147003, -0.02178955, -0.010681152, -0.045013428, -0.062316895, -0.028823853, 0.016357422, 0.0069122314, -0.005771637, 0.014328003, -0.016052246, 0.0052223206, -0.007003784, -0.08538818, -0.02078247, -0.04647827, 0.0036525726, -0.045043945, 0.013648987, -0.031951904, -0.0016326904, 0.026168823, -0.003835678, 0.026260376, 0.033447266, 0.011749268, 0.08154297, -0.09881592, -0.0692749, 0.051452637, -0.0039711, -0.0088272095, -0.008255005, 0.036621094, -0.0010786057, -0.041412354, -0.020324707, -0.013069153, -0.030319214, 0.013679504, 0.018035889, 0.006668091, -0.0068893433, -0.0067749023, -0.047698975, 0.002231598, 0.021347046, 0.009590149, 0.03253174, -0.029830933, 0.0041999817, 0.013031006, 0.0044403076, 0.025314331, 0.00015377998, 0.03781128, 0.036865234, 0.012054443, 0.01259613, 0.031799316, 0.03173828, -0.010246277, 0.010475159, 0.008468628, 0.036468506, -0.009025574, -0.0032978058, -0.018981934, -0.05291748, 0.0074424744, -0.032989502, 0.021850586, 0.03729248, -0.0034313202, 0.0058555603, 0.041229248, -0.08306885, 0.0770874, -0.011024475, -0.0056648254, 0.032470703, -0.038024902, 0.020965576, 0.012428284, -0.006134033, -0.010032654, -0.026641846, -0.0446167, -0.08288574, 0.0146484375, -0.020904541, 0.022705078, -0.0064048767, 0.007331848, -0.07098389, -0.025817871, -0.017822266, 0.011688232, 0.017700195, 0.018066406, 0.00022637844, 0.0036907196, 0.008666992, -0.032714844, -0.0012569427, -0.028503418, -0.03567505, 0.038757324, -0.0040664673, 0.048065186, -0.0038261414, -0.014778137, -0.030303955, -0.030654907, -0.019363403, -0.008087158, -0.03552246, 0.0059394836, -0.027282715, -0.008743286, 0.013366699, 0.02748108, -0.014389038, 0.0018596649, -0.019104004, 0.004600525, -0.046325684, 0.04425049, 0.013885498, 0.04611206, -0.011245728, 0.014854431, 0.03845215, -0.018218994, -0.024230957, 0.016403198, 0.047729492, -0.013763428, -0.01209259, -0.004108429, -0.025482178, 0.010131836, -0.0064849854, -0.017593384, 0.008155823, -0.0055389404, -0.016677856, -0.024597168, 0.0051078796, 0.0011043549, 0.024642944, -0.019439697, -0.033355713, 0.03475952, -0.023239136, -0.036071777, -0.015098572, 0.0007457733, -0.068603516, -0.054351807, -0.0047035217, 0.051452637, 0.023330688, -0.024978638, 0.054718018, -0.010528564, -0.02746582, 0.02204895, -0.002380371, 0.06161499, 0.0026950836, -0.09954834, 0.05682373, 0.01966858, -0.02999878, 0.03616333, 0.04876709, 0.032562256, -0.02809143, -0.0010986328, 0.006893158, 0.015510559, -0.006515503, -0.011802673, -0.041107178, -0.0034427643, -0.02218628, 0.043182373, -0.030593872, -0.0770874, 0.015655518, 0.032470703, -0.0007882118, 0.033721924, -0.033111572, 0.02230835, 0.03857422, -0.019348145, -0.03515625, 0.042541504, -0.00092315674, -0.05911255, 0.011398315, -0.011444092, 0.008056641, 0.054107666, -0.0050621033, 0.037322998, -0.033233643, 0.016342163, 0.048980713, -0.0020523071, -0.030212402, -0.047302246, -0.005908966, 0.019088745, 0.01159668, 0.05859375, 0.0077400208, 0.07110596, -0.010276794, 0.005466461, -0.011383057, 0.017730713, -0.020507812, -0.024749756, -0.039794922, 0.047607422, -0.005077362, 0.010688782, -0.028884888, 0.03366089, 0.019622803, 0.013893127, -0.010223389, -0.03112793, 0.026733398, -0.0018615723, 0.0002322197, -0.06286621, 0.018554688, -0.037719727, -0.049804688, -0.03756714, 0.0033626556, 0.008621216, 0.0023841858, -0.0103302, -0.011253357, 0.0052337646, 0.01828003, 0.008552551, -0.008934021, 0.0129470825, 0.011390686, -0.008468628, -0.026382446, 0.008605957, -0.0042419434, -0.019989014, -0.017059326, -0.02027893, 0.0052108765, 0.0016889572, -0.034851074, -0.037872314, 0.046936035, 0.03579712, 0.015022278, -0.031555176, 0.004383087, 0.012580872, -0.0038452148, 0.020523071, -0.01928711, -0.005584717, 0.035980225, 0.016921997, 0.023529053, 0.026062012, 0.0033111572, 0.010894775, 0.003484726, -0.00004416704, -0.041534424, 0.010772705, -0.035705566, -0.0023078918, 0.016952515, 0.02645874, 0.016738892, -0.018737793, 0.013267517, 0.007911682, 0.019012451, 0.0064697266, 0.003944397, -0.052581787, -0.009384155, -0.03869629, -0.015304565, 0.048553467, 0.0070228577, 0.025344849, -0.001876831, -0.010787964, 0.023788452, -0.002166748, 0.014205933, 0.005317688, -0.014381409, 0.002571106, 0.026016235, 0.021377563, 0.03567505, -0.062683105, -0.028823853, -0.021850586, -0.02067566, 0.011108398, -0.009529114, -0.0036373138, -0.00041890144, 0.00907135, 0.0069236755, -0.021377563, 0.010864258, 0.0042533875, -0.030334473, -0.010047913, 0.013954163, -0.02053833, 0.014175415, 0.066223145, -0.027832031, 0.040740967, 0.018676758, 0.0010089874, -0.02734375, 0.03149414, -0.018630981, 0.01071167, 0.045196533, -0.0793457, 0.008033752, 0.0028743744, 0.0073509216, -0.018859863, 0.019866943, 0.015411377, 0.01184082, -0.034332275, 0.0060691833, 0.015899658, 0.051727295, -0.03225708, -0.034454346, 0.050628662, -0.010345459, -0.018249512, 0.009094238, -0.037322998, -0.033416748, 0.020996094, -0.013397217, 0.010429382, -0.0007624626, -0.015541077, -0.009277344, -0.028198242, -0.005859375, -0.030517578, 0.0077934265, 0.020584106, 0.00447464, -0.007698059, 0.015716553, 0.03225708, -0.018676758, 0.03274536, 0.0259552, 0.031280518, 0.04449463, 0.0038280487, -0.05734253, -0.013801575, 0.016357422, -0.008094788, -0.020767212, -0.05206299, -0.031021118, 0.026901245, 0.013641357, -0.02557373, -0.0024223328, -0.019714355, 0.001036644, -0.007221222, 0.016494751, 0.041137695, -0.027832031, -0.0019054413, 0.033325195, -0.010879517, 0.028915405, -0.005794525, -0.0048828125, -0.08099365, 0.046936035, 0.0038871765, 0.060943604, -0.06274414, -0.07757568, 0.00047135353, 0.04309082, 0.0053367615, 0.012794495, 0.057434082, 0.04534912, 0.02861023, 0.015090942, 0.038391113, 0.05895996, -0.057800293, 0.005748749, -0.040039062, 0.013008118, -0.07623291, 0.020706177, -0.016143799, 0.032836914, -0.03552246, -0.059753418, 0.0026855469, 0.011741638, -0.00983429, 0.030212402, 0.0099105835, 0.0055274963, 0.03945923, -0.045776367, 0.0006008148, -0.016525269, -0.0046653748, -0.033233643, -0.0143585205, 0.04800415, 0.011711121, 0.02015686, -0.04196167, 0.015144348, 0.012359619, 0.020370483, -0.014060974, 0.0063095093, -0.0058403015, -0.026260376, -0.0019664764, 0.002752304, 0.05819702, -0.050994873, 0.022232056, -0.0062217712, 0.06732178, 0.021026611, 0.012298584, 0.0146865845, 0.012039185, 0.011642456, 0.01789856, 0.037078857, -0.008735657, 0.017944336, 0.0017948151, 0.03866577, 0.0023593903, 0.025360107, -0.08093262, 0.10046387, 0.008216858, 0.031921387, 0.027679443, 0.005744934, 0.019195557, 0.029220581, -0.032684326, 0.03881836, 0.05215454, 0.038970947, 0.015068054, 0.02178955, -0.036071777, 0.0045166016, 0.031585693, -0.01953125, 0.04638672, -0.0056762695, -0.022216797, 0.040985107, -0.020599365, -0.012054443, -0.011238098, 0.014137268, -0.038085938, 0.001376152, 0.008666992, 0.011543274, 0.004722595, -0.042144775, -0.045135498, 0.031311035, -0.006126404, 0.03326416, -0.03237915, 0.038635254, 0.053344727, -0.06774902, -0.011177063, -0.02468872, -0.021530151, 0.017410278, 0.0680542, 0.037475586, -0.012237549, 0.024765015, 0.025268555, -0.02041626, 0.0024375916, -0.006340027, -0.03479004, 0.0044555664, 0.027755737, -0.06640625, 0.008407593, -0.036376953, 0.040374756, 0.03677368, -0.014732361, 0.021652222, 0.003616333, -0.016723633, 0.026031494, 0.026428223, -0.061309814, 0.072631836, -0.01739502, -0.035064697, 0.011268616, 0.023513794, -0.050567627, -0.010871887, 0.022033691, 0.06008911, 0.047851562, 0.10003662, 0.038879395, 0.029251099, -0.0026474, -0.008796692, 0.009208679, 0.079833984, 0.017288208, 0.015975952, -0.046539307, -0.03112793, -0.00434494, 0.0013828278, 0.05218506, -0.013748169, 0.008079529, -0.03967285, 0.016479492, -0.011207581, -0.017211914, -0.019363403, -0.027191162, -0.051513672, 0.033447266, -0.0042648315, -0.022338867, 0.035064697, -0.048828125, -0.06713867, 0.0066108704, 0.02482605, 0.04385376, -0.04660034, -0.026763916, 0.03845215, 0.015258789, 0.06976318, 0.008865356, -0.0087509155, 0.039215088, 0.0046463013, -0.007144928, -0.015068054, -0.021606445, 0.035003662, 0.00035858154, -0.054595947, 0.0048942566, -0.024978638, -0.037139893, -0.09301758, 0.024169922, -0.026611328, -0.03277588, 0.062316895, 0.02130127, 0.0010137558, -0.057403564, 0.022705078, -0.033935547, 0.009231567, -0.045043945, -0.0027694702, 0.035339355, 0.013519287, -0.029510498, 0.0007238388, 0.009681702, 0.0059928894, 0.008216858, -0.014434814, -0.016647339, 0.02558899, 0.07714844, -0.024398804, -0.040893555, -0.007671356, 0.019897461, -0.012809753, -0.0013856888, 0.052246094, 0.012672424, -0.04296875, -0.022109985, -0.03375244, -0.021102905, 0.010795593, 0.017120361, 0.01828003, 0.053497314, -0.019592285, 0.06958008, 0.04711914, -0.037963867, 0.00881958, -0.005466461, 0.009277344, 0.010604858, -0.031921387, -0.007411957, -0.05630493, 0.015007019, -0.008865356, 0.0005259514, -0.013252258, -0.037902832, -0.0051956177, 0.02268982, -0.049621582, -0.026489258, -0.01828003, -0.03665161, 0.05126953, 0.037017822, 0.0060310364, -0.035705566, 0.033569336, -0.010498047, -0.0022220612, 0.026000977, -0.005836487, 0.009460449, -0.01171875, 0.033111572, -0.00484848, 0.0019130707, 0.010856628, -0.022537231, -0.020248413, 0.05126953, -0.026367188, -0.020996094, -0.017211914, -0.026306152, 0.036224365, 0.021316528, 0.032684326, -0.0039749146, 0.02267456, 0.03314209, 0.0060424805, -0.0017080307 ], "summary": [ -0.02053833, -0.02027893, -0.046020508, -0.0026798248, -0.040893555, -0.01878357, -0.04727173, 0.0035915375, 0.055664062, 0.016403198, -0.03479004, -0.0031795502, 0.005706787, -0.023971558, -0.017242432, -0.016601562, 0.011421204, 0.00013887882, 0.009796143, -0.018661499, 0.01727295, -0.0158844, 0.010047913, -0.010734558, 0.05117798, -0.067871094, 0.017578125, 0.010925293, 0.044433594, 0.02192688, 0.027740479, -0.04827881, 0.027252197, -0.006275177, 0.019470215, -0.009933472, -0.04220581, 0.009941101, 0.015045166, -0.005428314, 0.035491943, -0.027450562, 0.081604004, -0.036956787, 0.009269714, 0.06677246, -0.02758789, -0.06414795, 0.022750854, -0.023010254, 0.003534317, 0.056365967, 0.0078086853, -0.010650635, -0.018508911, 0.026107788, -0.049468994, -0.082458496, -0.0030384064, 0.082092285, 0.06652832, -0.02116394, 0.0087509155, -0.017623901, -0.012191772, 0.0039253235, 0.028930664, -0.025558472, 0.076171875, 0.013824463, -0.012863159, 0.03302002, 0.009521484, -0.032562256, 0.016525269, 0.038970947, -0.010215759, 0.035369873, 0.010040283, -0.003786087, 0.029953003, 0.03829956, -0.018722534, -0.006931305, -0.021896362, -0.019638062, -0.015464783, -0.029327393, 0.00737381, -0.06939697, 0.0027751923, -0.0541687, -0.03656006, 0.012268066, 0.02204895, -0.082336426, 0.03704834, -0.018814087, -0.01739502, -0.080566406, 0.053527832, -0.044799805, -0.027053833, 0.017044067, -0.004562378, 0.023864746, -0.0048713684, 0.016662598, 0.0385437, 0.034332275, 0.0040512085, 0.002029419, 0.012611389, -0.055664062, 0.006916046, 0.044677734, 0.025863647, 0.025497437, 0.01966858, 0.012298584, -0.045043945, -0.022567749, 0.018417358, 0.029708862, 0.015419006, 0.008743286, -0.010444641, 0.026443481, -0.030227661, 0.010543823, 0.0024967194, 0.04916382, -0.013595581, -0.03552246, -0.06036377, 0.014572144, 0.014038086, -0.010902405, -0.0035572052, -0.0067329407, 0.019638062, -0.013031006, 0.005027771, 0.0043258667, 0.0042877197, 0.032440186, 0.031951904, -0.0003039837, -0.01574707, -0.040496826, -0.0066070557, 0.03390503, 0.036987305, -0.04849243, -0.050842285, -0.080322266, -0.101257324, -0.008621216, 0.0637207, -0.012428284, -0.0087509155, 0.0022296906, 0.043762207, -0.023788452, -0.021469116, -0.007484436, -0.043426514, -0.017074585, -0.00030064583, 0.0098724365, -0.052764893, 0.042175293, 0.045959473, -0.035858154, -0.031829834, 0.004055023, 0.020599365, 0.006752014, 0.020492554, 0.0027770996, -0.0015878677, -0.0335083, 0.05078125, 0.0051231384, -0.0075263977, 0.0050849915, 0.009155273, 0.03604126, 0.0038661957, 0.0068626404, -0.0029010773, -0.0099487305, -0.0051879883, -0.027526855, -0.011802673, -0.02003479, -0.005432129, 0.006362915, -0.016342163, 0.010108948, 0.0038433075, -0.018615723, 0.005279541, 0.020812988, -0.0118637085, -0.019882202, 0.0003502369, 0.0007839203, 0.02406311, 0.05117798, 0.021713257, 0.041656494, -0.045196533, 0.020507812, -0.021194458, -0.044647217, 0.033355713, -0.024780273, 0.031463623, -0.05795288, 0.02204895, 0.058380127, 0.005252838, 0.043792725, -0.052001953, -0.00032949448, -0.004650116, 0.0181427, -0.022949219, 0.0012216568, 0.082092285, -0.007701874, 0.06341553, 0.060668945, 0.009017944, -0.0061187744, 0.03540039, -0.093933105, 0.012199402, 0.024475098, 0.012245178, -0.04837036, -0.05078125, -0.009132385, -0.064697266, -0.012329102, 0.025238037, -0.006511688, -0.0017118454, 0.038757324, -0.002937317, 0.0065307617, 0.0042915344, 0.04058838, -0.027893066, 0.026260376, 0.00026369095, 0.01953125, -0.0030441284, -0.009162903, -0.0053138733, -0.022766113, -0.006008148, 0.006576538, 0.0064888, -0.018630981, 0.018096924, 0.0046310425, 0.013580322, -0.020095825, 0.0029850006, -0.03265381, 0.0048599243, -0.04135132, -0.058502197, 0.012397766, -0.036102295, 0.049682617, 0.043884277, -0.029922485, -0.011100769, 0.004760742, 0.010009766, -0.01739502, 0.009803772, 0.034301758, 0.008346558, -0.0028533936, 0.031585693, 0.03668213, 0.048339844, -0.015235901, -0.015045166, 0.01902771, 0.0045928955, -0.02708435, 0.03302002, 0.030563354, 0.0021095276, 0.021636963, 0.025772095, 0.04309082, -0.012710571, 0.009399414, 0.020614624, -0.02130127, 0.019058228, 0.025787354, 0.018814087, -0.017974854, -0.010566711, 0.019821167, 0.012619019, 0.018508911, -0.023864746, -0.025100708, -0.018157959, 0.01473999, -0.051452637, -0.0060310364, 0.09967041, 0.011444092, -0.029190063, 0.008087158, 0.0077323914, -0.035125732, 0.02017212, -0.024597168, 0.0070228577, -0.037322998, -0.04397583, -0.068847656, -0.054718018, -0.014541626, 0.017532349, -0.004470825, 0.0048675537, 0.02848816, -0.008033752, -0.006587982, 0.015098572, -0.07287598, -0.019012451, -0.024459839, -0.024551392, -0.02418518, 0.028442383, -0.020736694, -0.0034599304, 0.019302368, 0.015975952, -0.010482788, 0.015144348, 0.04156494, 0.04232788, -0.062042236, -0.038909912, 0.026473999, -0.025268555, -0.03994751, -0.032043457, 0.039123535, -0.0072631836, -0.017959595, -0.02960205, -0.009590149, -0.020874023, 0.058441162, 0.025009155, 0.014350891, 0.009811401, 0.021133423, -0.06970215, -0.01474762, -0.0034637451, 0.0053138733, 0.051483154, -0.008155823, 0.0054512024, 0.033935547, 0.04763794, 0.053253174, -0.016998291, 0.021606445, 0.016204834, 0.0143585205, -0.013389587, 0.013214111, 0.029830933, 0.0033512115, 0.0135269165, 0.023330688, 0.054870605, -0.013885498, -0.009727478, -0.005569458, -0.037628174, 0.00459671, -0.014930725, -0.0044670105, 0.040100098, 0.023223877, 0.04736328, 0.011306763, -0.055389404, 0.07531738, -0.021942139, 0.014717102, 0.0435791, -0.06335449, 0.019470215, 0.006259918, -0.006263733, -0.017944336, -0.0345459, -0.03781128, -0.07989502, 0.003955841, -0.014015198, 0.0491333, -0.0014562607, -0.006385803, -0.056243896, 0.009475708, -0.013755798, 0.0052833557, 0.011734009, 0.042663574, -0.03086853, -0.027816772, -0.009521484, -0.046142578, -0.006313324, -0.03591919, -0.026062012, 0.0053100586, -0.0146484375, 0.014251709, -0.017593384, -0.02684021, -0.011459351, -0.010002136, -0.043701172, -0.0013885498, -0.03010559, -0.016723633, -0.0029392242, -0.023513794, 0.0048217773, 0.025802612, 0.0016651154, -0.011734009, -0.003967285, 0.025924683, -0.029708862, 0.072143555, -0.016784668, 0.038085938, 0.020080566, -0.012565613, 0.01260376, -0.022506714, -0.019515991, 0.00749588, 0.046936035, -0.011993408, -0.00073337555, 0.0040664673, -0.010307312, 0.015777588, 0.017028809, -0.046905518, -0.00009971857, -0.024154663, 0.0025348663, -0.016036987, 0.026031494, -0.0018529892, 0.024780273, -0.03756714, -0.036743164, 0.032684326, -0.05935669, -0.05822754, -0.046722412, 0.009231567, -0.0904541, -0.05899048, -0.025741577, 0.048797607, 0.0056648254, -0.007843018, 0.040771484, -0.002046585, -0.024215698, 0.022598267, -0.013404846, 0.08648682, -0.022338867, -0.08428955, 0.03237915, -0.022125244, -0.025253296, 0.043151855, 0.0076560974, 0.0023078918, 0.0020065308, 0.013381958, -0.012245178, -0.008903503, 0.02420044, -0.011878967, -0.030761719, -0.0079574585, -0.01651001, 0.027297974, -0.008651733, -0.06286621, 0.022323608, 0.01675415, 0.014503479, 0.03265381, -0.003408432, 0.0055618286, -0.019363403, 0.010467529, -0.017822266, 0.049591064, -0.0031032562, -0.050445557, 0.014968872, -0.006969452, -0.02015686, 0.025985718, 0.011047363, 0.01928711, -0.046417236, -0.002199173, 0.041748047, 0.015335083, -0.020828247, -0.049591064, -0.0033016205, 0.053833008, -0.014152527, 0.061279297, -0.02268982, 0.07232666, -0.037322998, 0.023590088, -0.0019550323, -0.0023956299, -0.017211914, -0.040618896, -0.045928955, 0.07385254, 0.0076942444, 0.006954193, -0.02468872, 0.025512695, 0.025756836, -0.001707077, 0.0019054413, -0.0062294006, 0.00027370453, -0.010986328, 0.016204834, -0.036712646, 0.01828003, -0.015403748, -0.007499695, -0.021896362, 0.01727295, -0.017074585, -0.012649536, -0.016036987, -0.00050354004, 0.013221741, -0.0057525635, -0.024887085, -0.0011196136, 0.01424408, 0.012390137, 0.015403748, 0.010215759, 0.0118255615, -0.013542175, -0.041625977, -0.00065231323, 0.009178162, -0.005874634, 0.005153656, -0.04336548, -0.064575195, 0.04321289, 0.066223145, 0.029724121, -0.014259338, -0.0284729, 0.027297974, 0.01991272, 0.009178162, -0.006061554, 0.0050697327, 0.023605347, 0.0077819824, 0.017028809, 0.062438965, -0.013504028, 0.006877899, 0.010612488, 0.019058228, -0.03302002, 0.0016384125, -0.038482666, 0.0014724731, -0.00014436245, 0.035064697, 0.02015686, 0.003332138, 0.016235352, -0.012413025, 0.014503479, -0.0011940002, -0.0357666, -0.04046631, 0.026168823, -0.04660034, -0.03479004, 0.037139893, -0.021148682, 0.029342651, -0.004135132, 0.015579224, 0.01876831, -0.041625977, 0.013259888, -0.0018692017, -0.012939453, -0.0107421875, 0.022003174, 0.026687622, 0.014083862, -0.04208374, 0.042785645, -0.007709503, -0.004917145, 0.020309448, 0.011772156, 0.007080078, 0.04373169, 0.0113220215, 0.021835327, -0.05419922, -0.0041503906, 0.006591797, -0.01197052, -0.017578125, 0.01235199, -0.0491333, -0.030578613, -0.0018405914, -0.033416748, -0.0017995834, 0.05529785, 0.01977539, -0.08343506, 0.033721924, -0.034362793, 0.026992798, 0.0146102905, -0.09777832, -0.038970947, 0.01158905, 0.01576233, 0.021377563, 0.011833191, 0.026550293, -0.019332886, -0.0029907227, -0.009643555, -0.02645874, 0.045959473, -0.037353516, -0.0032863617, 0.019180298, -0.019760132, 0.013725281, 0.020812988, 0.007408142, -0.04586792, -0.0029773712, 0.014808655, -0.0038833618, -0.003364563, 0.021987915, 0.011230469, -0.004562378, -0.00920105, -0.04876709, 0.0077934265, 0.04510498, 0.0008716583, 0.0236969, -0.000037550926, 0.009216309, -0.033233643, -0.0057525635, 0.021133423, 0.042266846, 0.0045433044, -0.026855469, -0.036346436, 0.00005018711, -0.042297363, -0.011459351, -0.0546875, -0.03778076, -0.009841919, 0.06121826, 0.030761719, 0.009025574, 0.026107788, -0.010971069, 0.023330688, 0.0019292831, 0.019592285, 0.059173584, -0.032440186, -0.042175293, 0.02116394, -0.025161743, 0.011932373, -0.011894226, -0.011756897, -0.07720947, 0.000910759, 0.011482239, 0.06738281, -0.11651611, -0.07550049, -0.018707275, 0.054473877, 0.025863647, 0.0028209686, 0.023925781, 0.01600647, 0.022857666, -0.0058174133, 0.0060691833, 0.022766113, -0.022018433, 0.019378662, -0.004135132, 0.028213501, -0.041778564, 0.032470703, -0.0050735474, 0.030456543, -0.035247803, -0.044921875, 0.012832642, -0.0017623901, -0.008605957, 0.03225708, 0.008010864, 0.00774765, 0.047698975, 0.0031757355, -0.0062408447, -0.027633667, -0.02949524, -0.031829834, -0.02696228, 0.091674805, 0.035736084, 0.019165039, -0.033081055, 0.004711151, -0.010658264, 0.012023926, -0.017166138, 0.0019454956, 0.013801575, -0.042541504, 0.0074653625, -0.0063209534, 0.072509766, -0.06225586, 0.009979248, 0.006641388, 0.06530762, 0.016204834, -0.004501343, -0.0054359436, 0.00819397, 0.041046143, 0.010383606, 0.013847351, -0.009002686, 0.017990112, 0.021011353, -0.0013904572, -0.010292053, 0.0028629303, -0.029037476, 0.12011719, -0.027618408, 0.011512756, 0.017318726, 0.008453369, 0.003025055, 0.015701294, -0.04714966, 0.005897522, 0.009887695, 0.050720215, 0.00063610077, 0.029754639, 0.004638672, -0.012481689, 0.022735596, -0.0103302, 0.05404663, -0.021942139, 0.003364563, 0.01638794, -0.016067505, -0.033569336, -0.044799805, 0.033935547, -0.049438477, 0.005470276, 0.033569336, 0.05166626, -0.024780273, -0.043914795, 0.017105103, 0.01360321, -0.03414917, 0.053894043, -0.021347046, 0.03942871, 0.045928955, -0.043792725, -0.024627686, 0.0027370453, -0.024368286, 0.015205383, 0.057525635, 0.033935547, -0.012863159, 0.013877869, 0.022445679, -0.0079193115, -0.0032081604, -0.02519226, -0.034851074, 0.026153564, 0.032714844, -0.059265137, 0.026168823, -0.029586792, 0.039886475, 0.06719971, 0.033325195, 0.071899414, 0.02696228, -0.008132935, 0.03515625, 0.028549194, -0.030715942, 0.031555176, -0.007850647, -0.036590576, 0.039001465, 0.0109939575, -0.0090789795, 0.007659912, 0.0129852295, 0.043182373, 0.0769043, 0.08679199, 0.021408081, 0.03036499, 0.032409668, -0.021636963, 0.029052734, 0.018493652, 0.018356323, -0.017501831, -0.03491211, -0.00484848, -0.021820068, 0.014556885, 0.044311523, -0.037750244, 0.035247803, -0.023666382, -0.019958496, -0.015930176, -0.015838623, -0.01574707, -0.018859863, -0.032836914, 0.03869629, 0.018753052, -0.023422241, 0.038513184, -0.01361084, -0.0524292, 0.02720642, 0.007499695, 0.011672974, -0.016723633, -0.015068054, 0.027496338, 0.01889038, 0.05822754, 0.008644104, -0.029067993, 0.022415161, 0.019805908, 0.017105103, -0.021575928, -0.033477783, 0.0231781, 0.025238037, 0.0033798218, -0.019821167, -0.0025806427, -0.028930664, -0.093933105, 0.023651123, 0.0016269684, -0.032287598, 0.062072754, 0.016738892, -0.018997192, -0.052581787, -0.005176544, 0.0039367676, 0.025756836, -0.02255249, -0.015045166, 0.076660156, 0.011779785, -0.03237915, 0.006465912, -0.033050537, -0.046203613, 0.0012388229, -0.012268066, 0.0053710938, 0.0019893646, 0.04559326, -0.0231781, -0.017044067, -0.00819397, 0.021499634, 0.006000519, -0.022445679, 0.006591797, -0.010231018, 0.00033283234, 0.012329102, -0.012672424, -0.01777649, 0.04623413, 0.01210022, 0.027359009, 0.036621094, -0.026870728, 0.05859375, 0.036224365, -0.027160645, -0.0059776306, -0.011993408, 0.016677856, -0.027267456, -0.016311646, -0.037200928, -0.04815674, -0.037139893, 0.0044822693, -0.0064468384, -0.020217896, -0.057891846, -0.016555786, 0.006919861, -0.06512451, -0.070373535, -0.066467285, -0.021774292, 0.013793945, 0.011817932, -0.018600464, -0.03173828, 0.022338867, 0.040893555, 0.001534462, 0.027770996, -0.012336731, 0.02444458, 0.024154663, 0.00349617, -0.010536194, 0.012382507, 0.027618408, -0.06732178, -0.0124435425, 0.048309326, 0.0018119812, -0.037139893, 0.024536133, -0.050872803, 0.027740479, 0.01751709, 0.019485474, -0.009567261, 0.050354004, 0.053985596, -0.0018072128, 0.023239136 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07497v1
Multilingual Nonce Dependency Treebanks: Understanding how LLMs represent and process syntactic structure
David Arps, Laura Kallmeyer, Younes Samih, Hassan Sajjad
cs.CL
We introduce SPUD (Semantically Perturbed Universal Dependencies), a framework for creating nonce treebanks for the multilingual Universal Dependencies (UD) corpora. SPUD data satisfies syntactic argument structure, provides syntactic annotations, and ensures grammaticality via language-specific rules. We create nonce data in Arabic, English, French, German, and Russian, and demonstrate two use cases of SPUD treebanks. First, we investigate the effect of nonce data on word co-occurrence statistics, as measured by perplexity scores of autoregressive (ALM) and masked language models (MLM). We find that ALM scores are significantly more affected by nonce data than MLM scores. Second, we show how nonce data affects the performance of syntactic dependency probes. We replicate the findings of M\"uller-Eberstein et al. (2022) on nonce test data and show that the performance declines on both MLMs and ALMs wrt. original test data. However, a majority of the performance is kept, suggesting that the probe indeed learns syntax independently from semantics.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07497v1
2023-11-13T17:36:58
2023-11-13T17:36:58
{ "title": [ -0.035461426, -0.024673462, -0.030883789, -0.08166504, -0.038238525, 0.02355957, -0.10308838, 0.030014038, -0.009887695, 0.03164673, -0.025970459, 0.031204224, -0.011268616, -0.021514893, -0.017486572, 0.0047798157, -0.014968872, 0.018692017, -0.03475952, -0.03717041, -0.021102905, -0.038879395, 0.0021381378, -0.023635864, 0.040618896, -0.09210205, -0.01965332, -0.027145386, 0.011398315, -0.04208374, 0.009399414, 0.014099121, 0.045318604, -0.010978699, 0.0023670197, -0.005302429, -0.04397583, 0.009941101, -0.004802704, -0.011016846, 0.019592285, 0.008682251, 0.026351929, -0.021453857, -0.02418518, 0.0032749176, -0.05227661, -0.03945923, -0.007911682, 0.0037727356, 0.0031166077, 0.0029621124, 0.00730896, 0.00579834, -0.0069999695, -0.01977539, -0.05923462, -0.00096559525, -0.00705719, 0.093444824, 0.0647583, -0.010688782, -0.005306244, -0.0039253235, -0.006679535, -0.023422241, -0.092041016, 0.023788452, 0.060333252, 0.023422241, 0.0026283264, -0.00762558, 0.01512146, 0.0014028549, -0.0073623657, -0.00007426739, -0.0029678345, 0.024414062, 0.057678223, -0.028945923, 0.036956787, 0.02130127, 0.0007610321, -0.0395813, 0.033355713, -0.022842407, -0.012588501, -0.017715454, -0.025772095, -0.06933594, -0.016067505, 0.021316528, -0.040985107, -0.020996094, -0.029846191, -0.034118652, 0.0035305023, 0.016693115, -0.012191772, -0.04711914, -0.0289917, 0.022949219, -0.055664062, 0.005554199, 0.020629883, 0.018508911, -0.013648987, -0.04638672, 0.009811401, 0.025650024, -0.027923584, 0.043151855, 0.03692627, -0.027755737, 0.013771057, -0.011940002, -0.003025055, 0.0463562, 0.029190063, 0.011795044, -0.035827637, -0.036132812, 0.0025501251, 0.037841797, 0.044311523, 0.034057617, -0.029190063, 0.038513184, 0.024368286, 0.033203125, 0.0037136078, 0.05569458, -0.080566406, -0.11273193, -0.08312988, 0.029953003, -0.000011086464, -0.010414124, -0.027526855, 0.016693115, 0.0096588135, -0.022033691, 0.010414124, -0.005897522, 0.029632568, -0.001455307, 0.053131104, 0.0078125, -0.046081543, -0.038208008, 0.031066895, -0.0051116943, 0.053527832, -0.047668457, -0.10205078, -0.055633545, -0.09564209, -0.023513794, -0.005001068, -0.050720215, -0.005016327, -0.0135269165, -0.008857727, -0.012962341, 0.011367798, 0.0048065186, -0.0029182434, 0.029647827, 0.017166138, -0.012245178, 0.01071167, -0.03439331, 0.025344849, -0.028045654, -0.02168274, 0.019515991, 0.018463135, 0.027282715, -0.010688782, -0.012245178, 0.029953003, -0.029708862, -0.012992859, 0.054229736, -0.050933838, -0.030761719, 0.016784668, 0.03829956, 0.041229248, 0.022750854, -0.005393982, -0.004989624, -0.04437256, -0.009475708, -0.03656006, -0.020462036, 0.039031982, 0.019302368, 0.009246826, 0.0023460388, -0.011711121, -0.019729614, -0.02255249, 0.0017004013, 0.0013465881, -0.047668457, 0.007286072, -0.00067186356, -0.016326904, 0.051239014, 0.06097412, 0.041931152, -0.0692749, 0.03338623, -0.002811432, -0.057647705, 0.033233643, -0.0056915283, -0.0006971359, -0.026229858, 0.027999878, -0.041503906, -0.003534317, 0.05493164, -0.02659607, 0.032348633, -0.025268555, 0.014884949, -0.01637268, 0.044067383, 0.01687622, -0.023529053, 0.04309082, 0.022125244, -0.028671265, -0.019470215, -0.02607727, -0.05569458, -0.002609253, 0.031143188, 0.0069999695, -0.024261475, -0.021591187, -0.006832123, 0.043945312, 0.0047416687, 0.006072998, -0.003458023, 0.0014390945, 0.015357971, 0.06390381, 0.02897644, 0.038482666, 0.0030899048, 0.004032135, 0.064941406, -0.008659363, -0.015281677, 0.006099701, 0.013786316, -0.006427765, 0.020187378, 0.004463196, 0.019561768, 0.019424438, -0.04727173, -0.011291504, -0.0024108887, 0.0012979507, -0.026123047, 0.023269653, -0.012901306, 0.025405884, -0.0103302, -0.045837402, 0.0020389557, -0.0037326813, 0.015380859, 0.025115967, -0.049865723, -0.0030269623, 0.048187256, 0.087890625, 0.0030460358, -0.0041122437, -0.004257202, 0.034698486, -0.013183594, -0.040252686, -0.0056991577, 0.044647217, 0.02128601, -0.006629944, 0.0050849915, 0.029205322, -0.00007146597, 0.095458984, 0.066833496, -0.043945312, 0.033935547, -0.025421143, 0.022567749, 0.0340271, -0.03753662, 0.022918701, 0.030715942, 0.05218506, -0.0039024353, -0.04071045, 0.015182495, -0.071899414, -0.03643799, 0.00080919266, -0.040802002, -0.028823853, -0.036956787, -0.00409317, -0.03161621, -0.03765869, 0.0051116943, 0.021728516, -0.0047416687, -0.0154418945, -0.003189087, 0.010009766, -0.0154953, -0.008110046, -0.010955811, -0.0135650635, 0.0062065125, 0.032073975, -0.00029826164, -0.047576904, -0.02104187, 0.0011930466, -0.0054092407, -0.00705719, 0.035736084, -0.009361267, 0.021972656, 0.010002136, -0.003921509, -0.004714966, -0.060150146, -0.021728516, 0.00409317, 0.027053833, 0.02041626, -0.05493164, -0.012702942, 0.027755737, -0.023635864, 0.03451538, 0.039611816, 0.082336426, -0.038513184, -0.07513428, 0.0309906, 0.003604889, -0.02154541, 0.039001465, 0.012321472, 0.008560181, -0.017120361, -0.027282715, -0.024642944, -0.0071525574, -0.0030021667, -0.007205963, 0.05596924, -0.031829834, 0.00045275688, -0.026031494, -0.015487671, -0.006832123, -0.019515991, 0.0259552, -0.015823364, -0.006160736, 0.0031471252, -0.001502037, 0.020858765, -0.035125732, 0.011444092, 0.05279541, -0.008491516, 0.0004143715, -0.02079773, 0.053131104, 0.014053345, 0.014251709, -0.037597656, -0.047729492, -0.009536743, 0.033294678, 0.024169922, -0.035949707, -0.027908325, -0.062927246, 0.0067863464, 0.07336426, -0.017868042, -0.022720337, 0.04046631, -0.06695557, 0.040008545, 0.008293152, 0.004146576, 0.037109375, 0.026565552, -0.008911133, -0.0010900497, -0.00022625923, -0.043060303, 0.0023612976, -0.038269043, -0.0970459, 0.02532959, -0.03704834, -0.006198883, 0.011207581, -0.023254395, -0.04611206, -0.009803772, -0.026412964, 0.042266846, 0.026733398, 0.040802002, -0.004146576, -0.020843506, 0.015701294, -0.034301758, -0.04055786, -0.0022258759, -0.029724121, 0.05911255, 0.01864624, 0.022598267, 0.051696777, -0.02078247, -0.0597229, -0.0010356903, 0.012794495, 0.011474609, 0.0055999756, -0.0146865845, 0.01940918, -0.04498291, 0.017288208, 0.017333984, 0.008163452, 0.0053749084, -0.008094788, -0.01260376, -0.031677246, -0.004333496, 0.0079574585, -0.010612488, -0.03994751, -0.0022087097, 0.012046814, 0.026489258, -0.053588867, -0.040252686, 0.019439697, 0.05596924, -0.03982544, 0.013931274, -0.025299072, 0.013717651, 0.029037476, -0.04522705, 0.019729614, -0.0031738281, 0.007850647, 0.000045239925, -0.035614014, -0.014953613, -0.026672363, 0.0054969788, -0.010231018, 0.023117065, -0.024673462, -0.06640625, -0.021408081, 0.009490967, -0.09375, -0.03137207, 0.0025177002, -0.022064209, -0.06585693, 0.02003479, 0.016799927, -0.01586914, -0.002313614, 0.025039673, -0.0037727356, 0.003036499, 0.0004079342, -0.08105469, -0.022399902, 0.07885742, -0.02748108, 0.0095825195, 0.055786133, -0.03567505, -0.04550171, -0.022781372, 0.022994995, 0.05230713, 0.014320374, 0.007762909, -0.027114868, 0.0014047623, -0.0023479462, 0.026687622, 0.053833008, -0.033813477, 0.051605225, 0.026794434, 0.008277893, 0.03302002, -0.018234253, 0.054656982, -0.011138916, -0.016662598, -0.04510498, 0.012184143, -0.0026435852, 0.0056991577, 0.016952515, -0.018203735, 0.016418457, 0.011886597, -0.0036373138, 0.03744507, 0.0042686462, -0.0015487671, 0.025970459, -0.00014090538, -0.005531311, -0.00051116943, 0.021911621, 0.018218994, -0.007865906, 0.047912598, -0.0064926147, 0.04562378, 0.000024139881, -0.01966858, 0.0076026917, 0.021484375, -0.019882202, 0.009727478, -0.045715332, -0.037200928, -0.02758789, 0.02381897, -0.006767273, 0.024383545, 0.037597656, -0.018005371, -0.020004272, -0.0044403076, 0.008682251, -0.006412506, 0.010543823, -0.04824829, -0.025909424, -0.004562378, -0.07269287, -0.045562744, -0.03463745, -0.007987976, 0.008781433, 0.003189087, -0.03842163, 0.021606445, 0.02305603, 0.089660645, 0.049591064, 0.007209778, -0.068115234, 0.042175293, -0.03652954, 0.04852295, -0.035095215, 0.030975342, -0.023483276, -0.002664566, -0.030578613, 0.022277832, -0.020523071, -0.04675293, 0.017654419, 0.01828003, 0.02658081, 0.0074424744, 0.0075645447, 0.02659607, 0.0019302368, 0.026870728, 0.0010814667, -0.03475952, 0.03137207, 0.013626099, 0.030914307, 0.007457733, 0.0077705383, 0.03765869, 0.008956909, -0.011154175, -0.0075950623, 0.0054130554, 0.01096344, -0.0017051697, 0.034332275, -0.010269165, -0.05996704, -0.02796936, -0.0057678223, 0.0063209534, 0.031555176, -0.033294678, -0.014968872, -0.027328491, 0.01675415, 0.02279663, -0.023849487, 0.02357483, 0.030151367, 0.032958984, -0.023620605, -0.027893066, 0.012077332, 0.0088272095, -0.0016880035, -0.0016317368, 0.0029525757, 0.008033752, 0.0020332336, 0.032836914, 0.0036964417, -0.010543823, 0.023406982, -0.016143799, -0.0017681122, -0.008743286, -0.032348633, 0.0026569366, -0.0023059845, 0.015266418, 0.046051025, -0.009307861, -0.09655762, 0.025222778, 0.0023212433, -0.009613037, 0.02279663, -0.061035156, 0.023895264, 0.06964111, -0.0006380081, 0.017425537, -0.0013713837, 0.014038086, 0.0032196045, 0.07055664, -0.028167725, 0.01058197, 0.057250977, -0.04425049, -0.009170532, -0.000014126301, 0.040924072, 0.014678955, 0.0146484375, 0.013450623, 0.014427185, -0.049926758, 0.013465881, -0.0028190613, -0.024337769, 0.029815674, -0.04244995, 0.051818848, -0.013031006, -0.033721924, 0.017990112, -0.021011353, -0.0546875, -0.014053345, -0.018966675, -0.03100586, 0.015914917, -0.0061073303, -0.06976318, 0.011375427, 0.08026123, -0.005542755, -0.026046753, 0.038604736, -0.013557434, -0.0020217896, 0.002412796, 0.023834229, -0.032928467, 0.03564453, -0.029968262, 0.009796143, 0.03086853, 0.017456055, -0.037719727, -0.0012845993, -0.010261536, -0.023880005, -0.023422241, -0.013298035, -0.008285522, 0.008422852, -0.004676819, -0.006160736, -0.014205933, -0.000446558, 0.016815186, -0.017593384, -0.029022217, 0.03286743, 0.003665924, 0.029586792, 0.01436615, 0.050048828, 0.02709961, 0.00856781, 0.013130188, -0.033294678, 0.010017395, -0.01966858, 0.0010967255, -0.07165527, -0.049438477, -0.0068969727, 0.0234375, 0.00054883957, -0.0074920654, -0.009681702, 0.023590088, 0.027908325, -0.002910614, -0.0014629364, 0.068725586, -0.060638428, -0.016281128, -0.0104522705, -0.009048462, -0.031402588, 0.051605225, 0.019256592, 0.0037555695, -0.044921875, -0.05316162, -0.029418945, 0.015144348, 0.027801514, -0.005050659, 0.0017414093, -0.011688232, 0.039215088, 0.0051841736, -0.039031982, -0.048187256, 0.029968262, -0.005104065, -0.026794434, 0.06048584, -0.036376953, 0.00042057037, -0.005432129, 0.020339966, -0.006111145, -0.041931152, 0.036224365, 0.015136719, 0.013252258, -0.008049011, -0.05419922, 0.007751465, -0.006538391, 0.0029678345, 0.035583496, -0.0446167, 0.06341553, -0.005493164, 0.06262207, 0.03982544, 0.012046814, 0.025405884, -0.009056091, 0.0022258759, -0.030181885, 0.013496399, -0.041046143, 0.010978699, -0.028366089, 0.0046920776, -0.07476807, 0.00844574, 0.025115967, 0.005748749, -0.009437561, 0.0033740997, -0.008293152, 0.0048942566, 0.022140503, 0.015090942, 0.02267456, -0.005443573, -0.012245178, 0.017913818, 0.030441284, 0.006576538, 0.028366089, 0.010406494, 0.0028533936, 0.013122559, -0.004714966, -0.024276733, 0.019973755, 0.025131226, -0.021743774, 0.0060310364, -0.016616821, -0.013496399, -0.008758545, 0.036376953, 0.017669678, 0.012207031, -0.040771484, 0.023010254, -0.007217407, -0.02204895, 0.0041389465, -0.012886047, 0.01914978, -0.039733887, 0.054901123, -0.009033203, -0.03753662, 0.017166138, 0.057739258, 0.0137786865, -0.03665161, -0.017730713, -0.00022685528, 0.02128601, 0.035980225, 0.010658264, -0.026397705, -0.0064964294, -0.008453369, -0.00699234, 0.029647827, 0.036621094, -0.0020141602, 0.03149414, 0.0008006096, -0.044921875, 0.005264282, -0.024932861, -0.014274597, 0.031463623, 0.04763794, 0.05984497, -0.020889282, -0.04446411, -0.001871109, 0.0077438354, -0.08685303, -0.015991211, 0.0014276505, 0.013252258, 0.068359375, 0.09289551, 0.0690918, 0.024154663, -0.018112183, -0.05505371, 0.012535095, 0.049072266, -0.0038471222, 0.030700684, -0.05050659, -0.04498291, 0.030273438, -0.021453857, 0.06561279, -0.023880005, 0.003042221, -0.02671814, 0.025100708, -0.0030269623, -0.0028743744, -0.0062294006, 0.0026607513, -0.029937744, -0.0027713776, 0.0008034706, -0.04559326, -0.016174316, -0.032958984, 0.0071640015, -0.030075073, 0.028915405, 0.033966064, -0.053741455, -0.037261963, 0.064331055, 0.011062622, 0.097229004, -0.02394104, 0.0095825195, 0.015052795, 0.0050964355, -0.022888184, -0.021438599, -0.010810852, 0.0056991577, -0.018737793, -0.025817871, -0.0099105835, -0.0004234314, -0.038391113, -0.09844971, 0.017349243, -0.017044067, -0.050933838, 0.014373779, 0.011001587, -0.0158844, -0.0463562, -0.0022621155, -0.034942627, 0.022857666, 0.016082764, -0.009246826, 0.03387451, 0.017227173, 0.002313614, -0.01751709, 0.006225586, 0.0056610107, -0.018814087, -0.0015506744, -0.0033111572, 0.026611328, 0.030639648, -0.06341553, -0.06561279, -0.008049011, 0.028900146, 0.0065231323, 0.04534912, 0.020019531, -0.0055770874, -0.0054855347, -0.016433716, -0.020385742, -0.013755798, 0.016143799, -0.013214111, 0.002904892, 0.002664566, 0.0010709763, -0.0087509155, 0.006088257, -0.0048599243, -0.0048713684, -0.00058555603, -0.006565094, -0.007583618, 0.010635376, 0.021438599, -0.025375366, -0.035339355, -0.06640625, 0.038238525, 0.0034675598, 0.0289917, -0.0058784485, 0.036315918, 0.004562378, 0.044891357, -0.04638672, -0.045043945, 0.046966553, 0.06317139, -0.0116119385, 0.030181885, -0.005832672, 0.0059165955, -0.03250122, 0.004814148, 0.008255005, 0.031799316, 0.011116028, -0.017669678, 0.026779175, -0.024337769, -0.013839722, -0.02583313, -0.021102905, 0.046325684, -0.041931152, 0.0034694672, -0.038146973, -0.04019165, 0.011245728, 0.048919678, 0.014190674, -0.00094127655, -0.033447266, -0.0039596558, 0.034729004, -0.017959595 ], "summary": [ 0.032440186, -0.035491943, -0.01965332, -0.07702637, -0.035125732, 0.0015296936, -0.0552063, 0.025817871, 0.014923096, 0.048095703, -0.028747559, 0.030334473, 0.0049705505, -0.006038666, -0.012649536, 0.01084137, -0.015197754, 0.03024292, -0.007408142, -0.004924774, -0.006263733, -0.00844574, -0.04888916, -0.06585693, 0.03817749, -0.09698486, -0.019866943, -0.005466461, 0.03414917, -0.007675171, 0.02420044, 0.035003662, 0.0065612793, 0.046325684, -0.04296875, -0.034210205, -0.0022506714, 0.0077323914, -0.002878189, 0.02822876, 0.0052261353, 0.022888184, 0.119628906, 0.019485474, 0.021392822, -0.015075684, 0.0026397705, -0.068359375, 0.016662598, -0.015449524, -0.011581421, 0.0034675598, -0.00083732605, -0.050750732, -0.025970459, -0.04019165, -0.06488037, 0.022384644, -0.02204895, 0.07293701, 0.05670166, 0.032836914, -0.009559631, 0.01399231, 0.017486572, -0.04397583, -0.024642944, 0.032684326, 0.0015058517, 0.013908386, 0.03189087, 0.015792847, 0.0053710938, -0.038085938, -0.02180481, 0.019866943, 0.039611816, -0.009361267, -0.0013818741, -0.00061655045, 0.012161255, -0.014877319, -0.029830933, 0.006134033, -0.012588501, 0.0095825195, -0.0032787323, -0.007980347, -0.042114258, -0.061950684, -0.023849487, -0.060791016, -0.10321045, 0.02406311, 0.0309906, -0.031402588, -0.026885986, -0.03466797, -0.020492554, -0.024505615, 0.0025749207, -0.010635376, -0.011810303, 0.009170532, 0.0149002075, 0.032073975, -0.018859863, -0.03677368, 0.030761719, 0.008277893, 0.0077285767, 0.026153564, 0.010948181, -0.023651123, -0.03100586, 0.017578125, 0.003955841, -0.011062622, -0.002325058, -0.0030174255, -0.019577026, -0.01361084, -0.000033199787, 0.050567627, 0.016235352, 0.013282776, -0.019973755, 0.023971558, 0.003648758, 0.011306763, 0.0033302307, 0.02142334, -0.048217773, -0.0055885315, -0.04660034, 0.010002136, 0.025131226, 0.010765076, -0.010437012, 0.035125732, 0.036956787, -0.055145264, -0.012557983, 0.02268982, 0.065979004, 0.030181885, 0.03479004, -0.019088745, -0.02619934, -0.012176514, 0.036987305, -0.0135650635, 0.07397461, -0.052734375, -0.09472656, -0.08087158, -0.071777344, -0.024017334, -0.012680054, -0.056671143, -0.054718018, -0.050842285, -0.024337769, 0.023925781, 0.0003862381, 0.06506348, 0.062164307, 0.015037537, 0.02281189, 0.002588272, 0.0036849976, -0.004299164, 0.01739502, -0.003458023, -0.0053367615, 0.016036987, -0.029647827, 0.10357666, -0.009773254, 0.0026607513, 0.047088623, -0.038116455, 0.070495605, 0.02130127, -0.030319214, 0.001414299, 0.006832123, 0.051483154, 0.0149383545, 0.01689148, 0.008003235, -0.010803223, -0.061279297, 0.037139893, 0.0017547607, -0.021591187, 0.011657715, 0.012252808, -0.004310608, -0.028076172, -0.0071029663, -0.020187378, -0.025131226, -0.015640259, -0.032836914, -0.05581665, 0.0016431808, 0.0030670166, -0.04425049, 0.019317627, 0.0435791, -0.00932312, -0.05505371, 0.07397461, 0.012626648, -0.04333496, -0.008766174, -0.005405426, -0.0049209595, -0.013954163, 0.030715942, -0.024230957, 0.00020992756, 0.051513672, -0.03250122, 0.026306152, -0.010856628, 0.047180176, 0.025650024, 0.028213501, 0.073791504, -0.03692627, 0.03817749, 0.027267456, -0.032440186, -0.0069389343, 0.009643555, -0.02319336, 0.0039100647, 0.025299072, 0.023483276, 0.017852783, -0.055603027, -0.045715332, 0.009376526, 0.0032348633, 0.008636475, -0.020050049, -0.050933838, -0.019546509, 0.044006348, 0.033721924, 0.008926392, 0.01727295, -0.008308411, 0.028808594, -0.036743164, -0.04849243, 0.026138306, -0.010414124, 0.010131836, 0.03062439, 0.012062073, 0.019012451, 0.0020523071, -0.08166504, -0.0018491745, -0.011909485, 0.040283203, -0.07977295, 0.015686035, -0.017593384, 0.004486084, -0.0011959076, 0.027526855, -0.012130737, -0.011726379, -0.0132369995, 0.026855469, -0.0013427734, 0.02494812, 0.08905029, 0.07635498, -0.016067505, 0.005180359, 0.03050232, 0.00299263, -0.025939941, 0.005580902, 0.054138184, 0.037322998, 0.050598145, 0.002910614, 0.028503418, 0.04751587, 0.016586304, 0.009613037, -0.03277588, 0.025390625, -0.03086853, -0.01927185, 0.06286621, -0.00035595894, 0.003829956, 0.011688232, 0.03503418, 0.031707764, -0.053222656, -0.038879395, 0.011993408, -0.047088623, -0.0066070557, 0.020065308, -0.012924194, -0.015274048, -0.0236969, -0.01663208, 0.0090789795, -0.00819397, 0.0064353943, 0.0062675476, 0.010314941, 0.025268555, 0.003698349, 0.021133423, -0.03302002, 0.014228821, 0.010902405, -0.015853882, 0.008811951, -0.009208679, 0.0024318695, -0.006351471, 0.024230957, -0.013549805, -0.0058937073, 0.002571106, 0.006504059, -0.011482239, 0.054779053, 0.02128601, 0.017181396, 0.0038070679, -0.050872803, -0.029434204, -0.0005736351, 0.04550171, -0.0020885468, -0.0206604, 0.014854431, 0.009513855, -0.01928711, 0.042663574, 0.045196533, 0.054504395, -0.035247803, -0.06707764, 0.039733887, 0.008934021, -0.01701355, 0.00018239021, 0.056030273, 0.012382507, -0.013473511, -0.062194824, -0.022003174, 0.056610107, 0.016082764, -0.0017232895, 0.03137207, 0.03164673, 0.009933472, -0.07305908, -0.039794922, -0.05316162, -0.021377563, 0.06262207, -0.011962891, -0.029907227, 0.01864624, 0.022094727, 0.046966553, -0.034362793, 0.028762817, 0.0602417, 0.009246826, 0.044830322, 0.021026611, 0.03842163, -0.017501831, -0.014671326, -0.030883789, -0.027999878, -0.03656006, 0.032226562, 0.037963867, -0.01234436, -0.030029297, 0.0039634705, -0.057128906, 0.052947998, -0.0038089752, 0.00069236755, 0.026519775, -0.014831543, 0.056549072, 0.03994751, -0.001253128, 0.0057868958, -0.006717682, -0.004787445, 0.0047187805, -0.021316528, 0.0055999756, -0.00006580353, -0.05078125, -0.022460938, 0.003206253, -0.007446289, -0.011604309, -0.008651733, 0.014526367, -0.002073288, 0.019699097, -0.010284424, 0.014221191, -0.014251709, 0.018692017, -0.019515991, 0.0034923553, -0.008270264, -0.015419006, -0.041656494, 0.0016946793, -0.028427124, 0.060546875, 0.039733887, -0.02017212, 0.064331055, -0.031234741, -0.06567383, -0.024597168, 0.0035991669, 0.016799927, -0.03994751, 0.050628662, -0.029907227, -0.04522705, 0.014480591, 0.032287598, -0.013961792, 0.0046806335, 0.010055542, 0.00048422813, -0.034484863, 0.0048828125, 0.021102905, -0.011795044, -0.017456055, -0.013847351, -0.036254883, 0.03466797, -0.060638428, -0.07849121, 0.031951904, 0.054107666, -0.05380249, 0.03189087, -0.040374756, 0.025405884, 0.06896973, -0.06359863, 0.039367676, 0.007896423, -0.0047721863, 0.03668213, 0.0034046173, -0.016281128, -0.022735596, -0.0005965233, -0.046813965, 0.024353027, -0.041900635, -0.014892578, -0.023544312, 0.015670776, -0.02658081, -0.019836426, 0.03012085, 0.032348633, -0.022628784, 0.012237549, 0.0357666, 0.039215088, 0.029632568, 0.029922485, -0.002866745, 0.060913086, -0.04333496, -0.05834961, -0.029159546, -0.02357483, -0.0038700104, 0.053588867, 0.0107421875, 0.02960205, 0.013572693, 0.005584717, 0.0027236938, -0.0023765564, 0.003692627, -0.031066895, -0.01550293, -0.016494751, -0.0037193298, 0.00869751, 0.027832031, -0.043151855, 0.025299072, 0.0066452026, 0.018310547, 0.04421997, 0.014160156, 0.026885986, -0.0390625, -0.008972168, 0.00007998943, -0.018417358, -0.01361084, -0.01335144, 0.014038086, 0.038146973, -0.045074463, -0.014350891, 0.014854431, -0.04458618, 0.016921997, 0.009208679, 0.06402588, 0.009788513, 0.00705719, 0.02116394, 0.011985779, 0.019577026, -0.016342163, 0.00097322464, -0.040161133, -0.0028839111, -0.0012016296, -0.03265381, 0.0004515648, 0.01701355, -0.036621094, -0.02633667, -0.014259338, 0.006011963, -0.010986328, 0.0060157776, -0.010574341, 0.027908325, 0.0030288696, 0.0051078796, -0.024505615, 0.008552551, -0.009666443, 0.013900757, -0.010505676, -0.034942627, 0.006412506, -0.020385742, -0.018676758, -0.00067567825, -0.010879517, -0.066467285, 0.0129776, -0.014915466, -0.037994385, 0.041137695, -0.03591919, 0.037353516, 0.08453369, -0.0064315796, -0.093444824, 0.034973145, -0.034820557, 0.08203125, -0.042510986, 0.0038146973, -0.029769897, 0.01600647, -0.009231567, 0.02268982, -0.033294678, -0.055358887, 0.0050354004, 0.018508911, 0.0021858215, 0.045196533, 0.041412354, 0.022338867, -0.018035889, 0.031188965, 0.012664795, -0.0011453629, -0.0029754639, 0.030471802, -0.026321411, 0.04345703, 0.011894226, 0.039794922, -0.03527832, -0.037750244, 0.002483368, -0.0026931763, 0.014755249, 0.019577026, 0.014831543, 0.030731201, -0.04360962, -0.034362793, -0.007575989, -0.0021686554, 0.00073719025, -0.048187256, -0.033935547, 0.025146484, 0.027374268, 0.021057129, -0.022644043, 0.009712219, 0.01914978, 0.007701874, -0.028884888, -0.04055786, -0.00983429, 0.028564453, -0.0060920715, -0.03250122, 0.0016155243, -0.01159668, 0.0031986237, 0.008407593, -0.02104187, 0.000521183, -0.0075149536, -0.020217896, -0.011192322, -0.01184082, -0.013809204, -0.0026416779, -0.0019683838, 0.006958008, 0.032806396, 0.004261017, -0.03414917, 0.054138184, 0.030319214, 0.031799316, 0.0028381348, -0.013595581, 0.015640259, 0.030380249, -0.03152466, -0.035308838, 0.02255249, -0.010856628, 0.029022217, 0.084350586, -0.039276123, 0.0027008057, 0.058563232, -0.0143966675, 0.02029419, -0.00248909, -0.01461792, 0.018371582, 0.007709503, 0.00085783005, -0.010887146, 0.006134033, 0.0039596558, -0.04812622, -0.06149292, 0.010612488, -0.002462387, 0.06402588, -0.018356323, -0.04034424, 0.0057144165, 0.0463562, -0.058532715, -0.048706055, 0.025939941, -0.043548584, -0.02015686, 0.018920898, -0.05255127, 0.034179688, 0.039215088, 0.011703491, -0.013442993, 0.033416748, -0.010574341, 0.00028705597, -0.059570312, 0.042144775, 0.001080513, 0.0635376, -0.047943115, 0.010513306, 0.009979248, 0.00085544586, -0.008666992, 0.0071868896, -0.0140686035, -0.014595032, -0.018173218, -0.052001953, -0.0524292, 0.05102539, -0.0012435913, 0.021865845, 0.028503418, -0.022262573, 0.024108887, -0.012786865, -0.03363037, 0.020935059, 0.0050315857, -0.0018005371, 0.028060913, -0.0006723404, 0.024520874, 0.00063562393, -0.014732361, -0.03503418, 0.017654419, 0.041107178, 0.029525757, -0.03640747, -0.006526947, -0.031097412, 0.054260254, -0.0072288513, 0.006198883, -0.014083862, -0.0055007935, 0.054718018, 0.022842407, -0.0056610107, 0.047607422, 0.002565384, 0.015823364, 0.015808105, 0.013946533, 0.0073127747, 0.05480957, 0.03189087, 0.032440186, -0.0423584, -0.021438599, -0.012840271, -0.006855011, 0.0029449463, -0.026931763, -0.0053367615, 0.05770874, 0.048583984, 0.035003662, -0.032440186, -0.019546509, 0.028198242, -0.0038604736, -0.034698486, 0.02809143, -0.009742737, -0.006389618, 0.0019989014, 0.0077819824, -0.006072998, -0.02279663, 0.04486084, 0.013046265, 0.015792847, 0.012825012, -0.04498291, 0.011627197, -0.0236969, 0.039276123, 0.010246277, -0.0017375946, 0.022720337, 0.019485474, -0.0002861023, 0.019012451, 0.021057129, -0.0047683716, -0.012748718, -0.022979736, -0.022857666, -0.017852783, 0.015174866, -0.049743652, -0.034729004, -0.024139404, -0.0033092499, 0.056762695, -0.036590576, -0.044036865, 0.05316162, -0.018844604, 0.0061035156, 0.02128601, -0.04019165, 0.013442993, -0.043273926, -0.003232956, -0.023529053, 0.03289795, 0.0033721924, 0.016342163, 0.046569824, 0.0015468597, 0.018157959, 0.0018377304, -0.0048828125, 0.03866577, -0.011329651, -0.014579773, -0.008888245, 0.01424408, -0.021408081, -0.002538681, 0.012123108, 0.046325684, -0.011672974, -0.040252686, -0.016677856, 0.017593384, -0.011154175, -0.0045318604, 0.013397217, -0.032562256, -0.0073165894, -0.008018494, -0.0051841736, -0.0045814514, -0.011383057, 0.02420044, 0.020935059, 0.019256592, -0.05429077, -0.020339966, 0.0059547424, 0.00592041, 0.0070724487, -0.008544922, -0.029006958, 0.008483887, -0.01876831, -0.028289795, 0.030700684, -0.0018043518, -0.017074585, 0.0022087097, 0.003250122, -0.05105591, -0.002275467, -0.028869629, -0.015037537, 0.026046753, 0.05291748, 0.046203613, -0.0211792, -0.033447266, 0.0061073303, 0.02053833, -0.047943115, -0.004245758, 0.03753662, 0.023422241, 0.07659912, 0.09094238, 0.035888672, 0.04827881, 0.00390625, -0.021514893, 0.012649536, 0.025466919, 0.019927979, -0.0034599304, -0.049957275, -0.02180481, -0.010673523, -0.032226562, 0.038208008, -0.029846191, 0.019561768, 0.005306244, -0.032440186, -0.020309448, 0.025772095, -0.0026836395, 0.01727295, -0.04812622, -0.0055389404, -0.0047569275, -0.019989014, -0.026489258, -0.04348755, 0.028213501, -0.006034851, 0.012458801, 0.03527832, -0.026916504, -0.021469116, 0.034606934, 0.030654907, 0.06640625, 0.010902405, 0.010101318, 0.037017822, 0.019210815, -0.017181396, -0.088134766, -0.007904053, -0.03479004, 0.003665924, -0.054779053, 0.031555176, 0.009269714, -0.03967285, -0.11645508, 0.03152466, -0.041229248, -0.04144287, 0.02760315, 0.0115737915, 0.013664246, -0.028274536, 0.009796143, -0.029815674, -0.030044556, -0.034423828, -0.010749817, 0.0049819946, 0.012817383, 0.017364502, 0.006576538, 0.020355225, 0.032348633, -0.056152344, -0.036956787, 0.017349243, -0.0014286041, 0.03161621, -0.009315491, -0.01889038, 0.02015686, -0.010955811, -0.006038666, -0.022079468, -0.007293701, -0.0084991455, 0.049346924, 0.02861023, 0.0061798096, -0.0345459, -0.02835083, -0.051239014, -0.004623413, -0.034362793, 0.00223732, -0.03378296, 0.031188965, -0.038238525, -0.026062012, -0.025634766, 0.024887085, -0.028564453, 0.010887146, 0.046661377, -0.012413025, -0.031585693, -0.07147217, -0.008354187, 0.024246216, 0.004169464, -0.028686523, 0.051605225, -0.021606445, 0.04446411, -0.033355713, -0.037109375, 0.058013916, 0.04421997, 0.0060043335, -0.03543091, 0.04095459, 0.020599365, -0.015701294, -0.0056381226, 0.012199402, 0.03942871, 0.023254395, -0.043151855, 0.005115509, -0.03933716, -0.00818634, -0.05493164, -0.0046691895, 0.031143188, -0.024673462, -0.010025024, 0.007183075, -0.058044434, 0.033691406, 0.027877808, 0.040008545, 0.053771973, -0.010177612, 0.00034213066, -0.012199402, -0.013938904 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07491v1
A Step Closer to Comprehensive Answers: Constrained Multi-Stage Question Decomposition with Large Language Models
Hejing Cao, Zhenwei An, Jiazhan Feng, Kun Xu, Liwei Chen, Dongyan Zhao
cs.CL
While large language models exhibit remarkable performance in the Question Answering task, they are susceptible to hallucinations. Challenges arise when these models grapple with understanding multi-hop relations in complex questions or lack the necessary knowledge for a comprehensive response. To address this issue, we introduce the "Decompose-and-Query" framework (D&Q). This framework guides the model to think and utilize external knowledge similar to ReAct, while also restricting its thinking to reliable information, effectively mitigating the risk of hallucinations. Experiments confirm the effectiveness of D&Q: On our ChitChatQA dataset, D&Q does not lose to ChatGPT in 67% of cases; on the HotPotQA question-only setting, D&Q achieved an F1 score of 59.6%. Our code is available at https://github.com/alkaidpku/DQ-ToolQA.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07491v1
2023-11-13T17:28:03
2023-11-13T17:28:03
{ "title": [ -0.01763916, -0.001876831, -0.026428223, -0.06750488, 0.00093221664, 0.011405945, -0.042541504, 0.0053710938, 0.0053100586, 0.008575439, -0.0078048706, 0.018249512, -0.018234253, -0.021224976, -0.026931763, 0.013664246, 0.006614685, 0.008163452, -0.036987305, -0.0289917, -0.018112183, -0.051452637, 0.021957397, 0.039031982, 0.04788208, -0.043121338, -0.06732178, 0.03656006, -0.030029297, -0.012138367, -0.007827759, -0.0049743652, 0.038757324, 0.002773285, 0.014549255, 0.020874023, -0.004047394, 0.009216309, 0.01826477, -0.002128601, 0.015945435, -0.009666443, -0.022155762, -0.007286072, -0.061187744, 0.0018081665, -0.04525757, -0.0039138794, 0.018829346, 0.019943237, -0.013656616, 0.036224365, -0.03277588, 0.010520935, 0.01586914, -0.011459351, 0.014785767, -0.03817749, 0.033203125, 0.042907715, 0.009490967, -0.03366089, 0.01953125, -0.027526855, -0.024490356, -0.0022411346, -0.019683838, 0.0052452087, 0.08618164, -0.0019340515, -0.04333496, 0.020004272, 0.012046814, -0.002861023, -0.04257202, 0.006717682, 0.026855469, 0.01411438, 0.036987305, -0.029693604, 0.0051612854, -0.0036449432, 0.023147583, -0.025543213, 0.011329651, -0.03793335, -0.023162842, -0.009300232, -0.03970337, -0.08734131, -0.016662598, -0.05545044, -0.0713501, 0.017028809, 0.009384155, -0.042144775, 0.022354126, 0.028839111, -0.00818634, -0.056854248, -0.011627197, 0.026260376, -0.062194824, 0.0028057098, 0.007598877, 0.022018433, -0.030532837, -0.010055542, 0.016464233, 0.054656982, -0.00258255, 0.04623413, -0.012763977, -0.033111572, 0.012191772, 0.02281189, -0.02279663, 0.011222839, 0.026824951, 0.016418457, -0.027023315, -0.04046631, 0.043304443, -0.008094788, 0.027648926, 0.0054016113, -0.043121338, 0.012496948, -0.0060691833, 0.03274536, 0.016220093, 0.045440674, -0.099731445, -0.08508301, -0.06719971, 0.04446411, -0.024627686, -0.03186035, -0.038513184, 0.023117065, 0.0029735565, -0.022613525, 0.010734558, -0.019592285, -0.00579834, 0.027679443, 0.08502197, -0.009147644, -0.072753906, -0.071777344, -0.029052734, 0.039794922, 0.04611206, -0.02772522, -0.1027832, -0.03414917, -0.13671875, 0.0053863525, 0.0012626648, -0.0138549805, 0.008033752, 0.021362305, 0.028701782, -0.021499634, 0.018173218, -0.052581787, -0.03466797, 0.012954712, 0.018859863, 0.033721924, -0.018157959, 0.03265381, 0.03137207, 0.011268616, -0.0035743713, 0.013534546, 0.021896362, -0.032440186, 0.007293701, 0.0015888214, 0.0023670197, -0.034179688, -0.034210205, 0.05935669, -0.054901123, -0.031707764, 0.00012302399, 0.008407593, 0.048095703, 0.009262085, -0.033325195, 0.018692017, -0.032806396, -0.043518066, -0.04269409, -0.018463135, 0.03463745, 0.021774292, 0.013282776, 0.01777649, -0.045013428, 0.013320923, -0.023452759, 0.018569946, 0.024459839, -0.017990112, -0.003440857, 0.017532349, -0.01852417, 0.046051025, 0.06915283, 0.031433105, -0.054626465, 0.049041748, 0.018753052, -0.04421997, 0.032287598, -0.026428223, -0.0030117035, -0.0418396, 0.01537323, 0.0041999817, 0.0021457672, 0.06976318, 0.01374054, -0.014923096, 0.022399902, -0.02281189, 0.06298828, 0.018661499, 0.066589355, -0.044799805, 0.049957275, 0.04019165, 0.011161804, -0.004108429, 0.02128601, -0.014411926, -0.0049591064, -0.007144928, -0.0066184998, -0.022903442, -0.015220642, 0.029388428, 0.023956299, -0.020019531, -0.006134033, 0.012237549, 0.0206604, 0.03112793, 0.057525635, 0.009384155, 0.026992798, 0.01725769, 0.012001038, 0.039978027, 0.023208618, 0.009101868, 0.008720398, 0.0036029816, 0.0021343231, -0.024520874, -0.040496826, 0.0059890747, -0.045959473, -0.004295349, -0.027954102, 0.0061531067, 0.015602112, -0.011680603, 0.0085372925, -0.013084412, 0.02822876, -0.019805908, 0.004184723, 0.009521484, -0.017913818, 0.011131287, 0.037597656, -0.040130615, -0.0049934387, 0.03488159, 0.045288086, -0.004184723, -0.010475159, 0.013175964, 0.018951416, 0.0010175705, -0.014709473, -0.010551453, 0.036895752, 0.03591919, -0.014671326, 0.034454346, -0.0010738373, 0.001411438, 0.08642578, 0.05609131, -0.020355225, 0.033996582, -0.031341553, 0.02848816, 0.023895264, -0.024093628, 0.017929077, 0.037322998, 0.047302246, 0.007865906, -0.028198242, 0.018371582, -0.062683105, -0.011627197, 0.0024852753, -0.02079773, -0.031082153, -0.051452637, 0.01184082, -0.042541504, -0.02432251, -0.030914307, 0.057556152, -0.011146545, -0.01953125, 0.00048470497, 0.006801605, -0.027404785, -0.0031642914, -0.019180298, -0.014701843, 0.02798462, 0.000049471855, -0.01109314, -0.064086914, -0.021606445, -0.014526367, 0.01625061, -0.0038223267, -0.0063209534, -0.027328491, 0.014770508, 0.014717102, -0.036895752, 0.018707275, -0.028793335, 0.008117676, -0.04800415, 0.042877197, 0.009216309, -0.026916504, 0.007583618, 0.020645142, -0.021575928, 0.0034656525, 0.018310547, 0.056762695, -0.026519775, -0.038879395, 0.026870728, -0.00046753883, -0.030288696, 0.04864502, 0.013343811, 0.022644043, -0.07165527, -0.0158844, -0.048675537, -0.043762207, -0.023773193, 0.0049438477, 0.026535034, -0.03024292, -0.027740479, -0.033691406, -0.0017299652, 0.039733887, -0.01096344, -0.015090942, -0.038330078, -0.004169464, -0.021209717, -0.021987915, 0.011375427, -0.018508911, 0.0395813, 0.06060791, 0.042053223, 0.036193848, 0.004966736, 0.022415161, -0.028381348, -0.014793396, -0.01360321, -0.030838013, -0.0067977905, 0.02331543, 0.021484375, -0.036193848, -0.026916504, -0.04824829, -0.006614685, 0.07220459, -0.00082302094, -0.0050201416, 0.029846191, -0.060424805, 0.020812988, 0.0017261505, -0.007282257, 0.025619507, -0.01071167, 0.00655365, 0.037078857, -0.0076408386, -0.011688232, -0.0026054382, -0.055480957, -0.11743164, 0.028549194, -0.010063171, -0.030822754, -0.0060272217, -0.0574646, -0.05053711, -0.006465912, -0.0101623535, 0.06964111, 0.000177145, 0.017105103, 0.02670288, -0.06781006, -0.010421753, -0.04446411, -0.013420105, -0.0103302, 0.005924225, 0.03164673, -0.01373291, 0.027114868, 0.0022296906, -0.00082731247, -0.019104004, -0.011184692, -0.051086426, 0.013404846, -0.0049324036, -0.048095703, -0.015075684, -0.027359009, -0.03451538, 0.02128601, -0.018005371, 0.013938904, -0.06335449, 0.015022278, -0.026473999, 0.0025577545, 0.008468628, 0.011070251, 0.004310608, -0.002243042, 0.03552246, -0.0072288513, -0.045959473, 0.020263672, 0.04940796, 0.017654419, -0.025146484, -0.008041382, -0.033111572, 0.026809692, 0.0055885315, -0.02381897, 0.005279541, -0.00522995, 0.0031337738, -0.02067566, -0.0049819946, 0.018676758, -0.025497437, -0.001335144, -0.009468079, 0.010925293, -0.008346558, -0.07824707, -0.010917664, -0.0003437996, -0.11230469, -0.041625977, 0.0016317368, 0.0015640259, -0.0118637085, -0.04107666, 0.038208008, -0.033355713, -0.036315918, 0.023605347, -0.0068855286, -0.014678955, -0.037872314, -0.08905029, -0.022949219, 0.07489014, -0.001789093, 0.032592773, 0.053985596, 0.011604309, -0.005657196, -0.020202637, 0.025482178, 0.020812988, 0.03945923, -0.010345459, -0.046722412, 0.0029850006, -0.011909485, 0.019683838, 0.03817749, -0.04360962, 0.033935547, 0.020904541, -0.020751953, 0.012954712, -0.022888184, 0.051574707, 0.0060195923, -0.012298584, -0.06500244, 0.04840088, 0.0016803741, 0.010566711, 0.020263672, -0.042633057, 0.030639648, 0.011192322, 0.004047394, 0.05670166, -0.014678955, 0.008056641, 0.054260254, -0.011329651, -0.0042152405, 0.018966675, 0.024047852, 0.030944824, 0.007701874, 0.015975952, -0.03378296, 0.026824951, 0.01789856, -0.005142212, -0.018127441, 0.0015468597, -0.024291992, 0.012168884, -0.060302734, -0.058532715, -0.0357666, 0.008110046, -0.0061683655, 0.07543945, 0.043884277, 0.005088806, -0.026626587, -0.005897522, 0.04849243, -0.007686615, -0.0016784668, -0.06939697, 0.0074653625, -0.008552551, -0.054656982, -0.039886475, -0.009216309, 0.014045715, 0.017654419, -0.0033226013, 0.021560669, 0.021850586, 0.031051636, 0.013931274, 0.03817749, -0.013824463, -0.011161804, 0.039276123, -0.013671875, -0.024169922, 0.015213013, 0.02583313, 0.018051147, -0.01966858, 0.008399963, -0.026412964, -0.016494751, -0.05630493, 0.04006958, 0.022979736, 0.057678223, -0.012084961, -0.013725281, 0.02973938, 0.0135269165, 0.011833191, 0.0015573502, -0.01928711, -0.012207031, 0.018569946, 0.038085938, 0.016433716, -0.003440857, -0.0043754578, 0.032928467, 0.018569946, 0.005001068, 0.00087594986, -0.00390625, 0.008926392, 0.019012451, 0.01966858, -0.023330688, -0.019439697, -0.0044441223, -0.0055656433, 0.041107178, -0.052734375, 0.050872803, -0.0009627342, -0.009567261, -0.0010728836, -0.037841797, 0.019622803, -0.037109375, 0.002527237, -0.05697632, -0.030349731, -0.0034179688, 0.020980835, -0.026123047, 0.007194519, 0.008361816, -0.000023007393, 0.029388428, 0.06945801, 0.064941406, -0.045959473, 0.0105896, -0.0025463104, -0.015487671, -0.02267456, -0.051513672, -0.0026168823, -0.017868042, 0.0057907104, -0.047180176, 0.050720215, -0.046325684, 0.003238678, -0.04812622, -0.040618896, 0.04248047, -0.056488037, 0.012611389, 0.07702637, 0.0038452148, 0.054107666, 0.0027122498, -0.008255005, -0.011070251, 0.06365967, -0.025024414, 0.045837402, 0.04852295, -0.06298828, -0.021194458, -0.0078125, 0.04336548, -0.010528564, 0.05026245, 0.018478394, 0.026046753, -0.086242676, 0.010620117, 0.014038086, 0.026489258, 0.01411438, -0.05606079, 0.021377563, -0.001241684, -0.015625, 0.01285553, -0.020141602, -0.004558563, -0.0013122559, -0.01977539, -0.042541504, -0.0008587837, -0.030212402, -0.05731201, -0.016799927, 0.031799316, 0.0018129349, 0.0012960434, 0.0317688, -0.01600647, -0.036315918, 0.031463623, 0.026260376, -0.027191162, -0.009979248, 0.0025367737, 0.021697998, 0.041778564, 0.022583008, -0.052886963, -0.022125244, -0.023635864, -0.034942627, 0.009414673, 0.008148193, 0.015823364, 0.008171082, -0.00995636, 0.0032348633, 0.030654907, -0.022415161, 0.02609253, 0.0025806427, -0.023925781, 0.01763916, -0.010925293, 0.004753113, 0.0028133392, 0.012199402, 0.000054836273, 0.010055542, 0.016342163, -0.05895996, 0.010635376, -0.004711151, 0.021636963, -0.054748535, -0.037994385, -0.013908386, 0.03137207, -0.004322052, -0.015808105, 0.03729248, 0.030471802, 0.033203125, -0.011451721, 0.011497498, 0.03250122, -0.020858765, -0.050476074, -0.018875122, -0.0004453659, -0.019714355, 0.071777344, 0.011070251, -0.052978516, -0.022125244, -0.058013916, -0.02079773, 0.014968872, 0.03086853, 0.039093018, 0.04486084, 0.006816864, 0.04949951, -0.007881165, -0.0075569153, -0.038604736, 0.007369995, -0.016220093, -0.04498291, 0.042236328, 0.02633667, -0.010269165, -0.03741455, 0.01777649, 0.04147339, 0.008773804, 0.018325806, -0.04159546, -0.0064888, -0.010826111, -0.053253174, 0.035980225, -0.0060043335, -0.0052108765, 0.04660034, 0.00054359436, 0.053222656, 0.014122009, 0.066589355, 0.046905518, 0.019256592, 0.022384644, 0.0020160675, 0.029052734, -0.03567505, 0.03945923, -0.037200928, 0.010391235, -0.033447266, -0.0034923553, -0.09472656, 0.01171875, 0.030776978, 0.03604126, -0.011634827, 0.022583008, -0.0075302124, 0.008560181, 0.031799316, 0.032104492, 0.06762695, -0.020446777, 0.0020503998, -0.0032100677, -0.045684814, 0.03427124, 0.04824829, 0.00010097027, -0.024536133, -0.038604736, -0.026794434, 0.008018494, 0.006843567, 0.015930176, -0.026809692, -0.036071777, -0.04727173, -0.0053634644, -0.015602112, 0.009338379, 0.041290283, 0.011856079, -0.022872925, 0.006866455, 0.013694763, -0.051879883, -0.04916382, -0.0060310364, 0.007843018, -0.07055664, 0.022598267, -0.03375244, -0.012557983, -0.009185791, 0.04473877, 0.018447876, -0.03677368, -0.041809082, 0.008354187, 0.035064697, 0.02947998, 0.010879517, -0.024734497, 0.017730713, 0.021362305, 0.00699234, 0.017440796, 0.032684326, 0.013763428, 0.0579834, -0.0012769699, 0.005470276, 0.023391724, -0.018798828, 0.014526367, 0.025283813, -0.019927979, 0.03463745, 0.012107849, -0.028701782, 0.0029411316, 0.024658203, -0.06982422, -0.0035533905, -0.024459839, 0.022064209, 0.04486084, 0.08691406, 0.03744507, 0.0007519722, -0.0262146, -0.052703857, 0.017852783, 0.050964355, -0.0181427, 0.05682373, -0.06311035, -0.05783081, 0.04510498, -0.08105469, 0.055236816, -0.047088623, -0.022628784, -0.025466919, 0.034057617, -0.0015420914, -0.014411926, -0.02909851, -0.015167236, -0.046569824, 0.0062217712, -0.0059814453, -0.03253174, -0.007091522, -0.026245117, -0.008003235, 0.011001587, -0.012687683, -0.025665283, -0.0068206787, -0.056915283, 0.0129470825, -0.02784729, 0.049835205, -0.026855469, -0.018447876, -0.040283203, 0.016098022, 0.02104187, -0.025543213, -0.027404785, -0.0013580322, -0.004852295, -0.009483337, 0.01184082, 0.016479492, -0.020721436, -0.0690918, -0.011978149, 0.002828598, -0.03527832, -0.00365448, 0.0034675598, -0.026992798, -0.043060303, -0.017929077, -0.010322571, 0.014717102, 0.0064849854, -0.019699097, 0.033081055, 0.010444641, -0.028869629, -0.01084137, 0.018371582, 0.035949707, -0.0019016266, -0.02909851, 0.015777588, 0.024230957, 0.036590576, -0.044067383, -0.034973145, 0.0010671616, -0.0011548996, -0.0073890686, 0.04638672, 0.033843994, -0.0038166046, 0.0015649796, 0.013214111, -0.01197052, -0.03866577, 0.046936035, 0.017120361, 0.009513855, 0.047058105, -0.003112793, 0.026351929, 0.023239136, -0.022323608, -0.020080566, 0.017578125, -0.013710022, -0.015083313, 0.01687622, -0.004272461, -0.027740479, -0.019012451, -0.057159424, -0.005016327, -0.0026741028, -0.021316528, -0.009361267, 0.026977539, -0.05279541, 0.010353088, -0.028518677, -0.032196045, 0.045166016, 0.030426025, 0.015533447, 0.009765625, -0.0053100586, -0.0028247833, -0.0019292831, -0.001789093, -0.002916336, -0.014984131, 0.020324707, -0.011177063, -0.004371643, -0.014053345, -0.0385437, 0.003118515, -0.02079773, 0.021865845, 0.0053901672, 0.015617371, 0.0063209534, -0.007896423, 0.004508972, 0.009239197, 0.0026874542, -0.02658081, -0.023284912, 0.014892578, 0.036224365, 0.00077724457 ], "summary": [ 0.01763916, -0.008377075, -0.02507019, -0.01725769, -0.017166138, 0.0068511963, -0.040252686, -0.026763916, 0.042785645, 0.05230713, -0.013572693, -0.025787354, 0.04421997, -0.019470215, -0.059661865, 0.002746582, 0.003112793, -0.0077400208, -0.0026168823, -0.02355957, 0.032928467, -0.0446167, 0.018753052, 0.011451721, -0.007545471, 0.013282776, 0.029327393, 0.01889038, -0.005279541, 0.014572144, 0.005996704, -0.020248413, 0.03704834, 0.005596161, -0.02468872, 0.010391235, -0.023895264, 0.009399414, 0.0042304993, -0.0011854172, 0.023483276, -0.009681702, 0.01007843, 0.008811951, -0.025741577, 0.005710602, -0.020828247, -0.038208008, 0.033447266, -0.005645752, -0.008674622, 0.03668213, -0.0087509155, -0.024215698, -0.015533447, -0.0039978027, 0.00819397, -0.07055664, 0.020202637, 0.036224365, 0.0019426346, -0.024139404, 0.009315491, -0.035339355, -0.011390686, 0.024230957, 0.036834717, -0.01309967, 0.02760315, -0.011062622, -0.018661499, 0.0054092407, 0.029037476, -0.024154663, -0.0031700134, 0.0032024384, 0.018692017, 0.011116028, 0.018478394, 0.008636475, 0.0025939941, -0.0050239563, -0.015823364, -0.00038909912, 0.011955261, 0.013435364, -0.009094238, -0.0013990402, -0.031677246, -0.026641846, -0.01826477, -0.022476196, -0.0836792, 0.03326416, 0.022628784, -0.032348633, 0.010810852, -0.03149414, 0.0368042, 0.030654907, 0.03378296, -0.03656006, 0.03152466, -0.00025987625, 0.010612488, 0.049926758, -0.014266968, -0.029800415, 0.023132324, 0.012924194, -0.011291504, -0.0016202927, -0.029525757, -0.103515625, 0.019302368, 0.07373047, -0.008651733, 0.020462036, 0.038726807, -0.0018348694, -0.022003174, -0.01348114, 0.05014038, 0.0015096664, 0.0362854, 0.027114868, -0.018722534, -0.008110046, 0.007358551, -0.005783081, -0.010421753, 0.030883789, -0.0077705383, -0.017089844, -0.035980225, 0.004348755, 0.027633667, 0.0012693405, -0.01309967, 0.0070495605, 0.028305054, -0.02015686, 0.012825012, 0.009353638, -0.044708252, 0.0592041, 0.039276123, -0.034301758, -0.05657959, -0.09320068, -0.023269653, -0.023498535, 0.040130615, -0.004802704, -0.08178711, -0.036590576, -0.07635498, 0.0018959045, -0.010055542, -0.018295288, 0.020874023, 0.028839111, 0.05117798, 0.033294678, 0.015930176, -0.034942627, -0.0579834, -0.016357422, 0.01927185, 0.011566162, -0.0027713776, 0.015808105, 0.009933472, 0.0075683594, 0.004875183, 0.0068206787, -0.044891357, 0.0058403015, -0.008590698, -0.011199951, 0.01184845, -0.0340271, -0.042633057, 0.06829834, -0.06555176, 0.059051514, -0.02293396, 0.05557251, 0.056732178, -0.01676941, 0.005924225, 0.0030899048, -0.034362793, 0.0054359436, -0.041137695, 0.011253357, -0.017059326, 0.03390503, -0.02116394, -0.012359619, 0.016204834, 0.030929565, -0.05316162, -0.012741089, -0.12322998, 0.012435913, -0.030670166, 0.03164673, -0.015434265, 0.05255127, 0.05105591, 0.041381836, -0.08911133, 0.11828613, 0.040924072, -0.01914978, 0.0017290115, -0.008491516, 0.011932373, -0.042785645, 0.0317688, 0.018173218, 0.018173218, 0.04550171, 0.012245178, -0.004421234, -0.009101868, 0.00052404404, 0.031021118, 0.026489258, 0.0075416565, -0.013069153, 0.07501221, 0.0574646, -0.03756714, -0.004878998, 0.005657196, -0.045440674, -0.01739502, 0.048706055, 0.010192871, 0.036895752, -0.057556152, -0.031433105, 0.041503906, 0.0026893616, 0.010154724, -0.014862061, -0.0042266846, 0.03314209, 0.010513306, 0.02897644, 0.0012750626, 0.031433105, -0.015266418, 0.02822876, -0.0118255615, -0.0019378662, 0.00957489, -0.014701843, 0.022827148, -0.0024909973, -0.013587952, -0.0075683594, -0.024978638, -0.050872803, -0.0015640259, -0.026473999, 0.050598145, -0.054107666, 0.0024089813, -0.05441284, 0.014503479, -0.024917603, -0.03086853, -0.011413574, -0.023849487, 0.03475952, 0.02230835, -0.03074646, -0.01033783, -0.0022792816, 0.030059814, -0.009674072, 0.005844116, 0.006122589, 0.03451538, -0.004470825, 0.0015058517, 0.058654785, 0.030578613, 0.06573486, 0.044891357, 0.011184692, 0.014633179, 0.023513794, 0.022155762, 0.0418396, -0.020629883, 0.01209259, 0.018798828, 0.039398193, -0.007904053, 0.006980896, 0.019958496, 0.023208618, 0.022842407, 0.0077934265, -0.0035915375, -0.0008740425, -0.058288574, -0.0105896, 0.026260376, 0.06506348, -0.020996094, -0.040100098, -0.0053596497, 0.035064697, -0.042388916, -0.056732178, 0.054138184, 0.030258179, 0.0033245087, 0.020980835, 0.035308838, -0.048431396, 0.013084412, -0.010810852, -0.012535095, 0.00831604, -0.04977417, -0.032989502, -0.023330688, -0.0048713684, -0.016357422, -0.015991211, 0.015060425, -0.0029945374, 0.010559082, 0.03817749, 0.08654785, -0.088012695, -0.013122559, 0.028259277, -0.014595032, 0.003068924, 0.047332764, 0.0088272095, 0.009506226, 0.004173279, -0.0019798279, -0.03930664, 0.0054016113, 0.0014820099, 0.026519775, -0.037200928, -0.027053833, 0.035736084, 0.0008854866, -0.027053833, -0.0063667297, -0.0093307495, -0.04626465, -0.05340576, 0.039031982, -0.0098724365, -0.048980713, -0.028305054, 0.061950684, 0.0362854, 0.0088272095, 0.041534424, -0.064697266, -0.003929138, 0.015716553, -0.02760315, 0.10845947, -0.025405884, -0.0023155212, 0.0647583, -0.033416748, 0.04244995, -0.068603516, 0.07476807, 0.09259033, 0.016815186, 0.048095703, 0.045898438, 0.03491211, -0.025177002, -0.01109314, -0.026535034, -0.01499176, -0.0076675415, 0.006580353, 0.015716553, -0.04748535, -0.035858154, -0.03643799, -0.0056991577, 0.091430664, -0.018356323, 0.0002667904, 0.009468079, -0.009521484, -0.0121536255, 0.025939941, -0.0017929077, 0.025665283, -0.02658081, 0.019210815, -0.006099701, 0.022857666, -0.03918457, -0.019180298, -0.042816162, -0.008087158, 0.0008559227, 0.007019043, -0.01600647, -0.0061569214, 0.016845703, 0.006134033, 0.02330017, -0.011230469, 0.053894043, -0.013015747, 0.0137786865, 0.034240723, -0.014373779, 0.0014362335, -0.020812988, -0.014122009, 0.00091362, -0.0035362244, 0.016433716, -0.016998291, -0.045684814, 0.025909424, -0.048309326, -0.020721436, -0.042938232, -0.04095459, -0.0007328987, -0.006816864, -0.015991211, -0.0335083, -0.023468018, 0.015258789, 0.0021457672, -0.016403198, -0.011634827, 0.035217285, 0.027557373, -0.023849487, 0.064697266, -0.017684937, 0.036468506, 0.025421143, 0.005508423, 0.027450562, -0.008369446, -0.034851074, 0.010131836, 0.054504395, 0.005065918, -0.021255493, 0.0023326874, -0.024490356, 0.027770996, 0.012741089, -0.04324341, -0.011306763, -0.013298035, -0.014381409, -0.0063209534, 0.041381836, -0.017852783, 0.028579712, -0.023605347, -0.10571289, 0.053588867, -0.047302246, -0.06628418, -0.0340271, 0.0045280457, -0.008224487, -0.040618896, 0.0057029724, 0.04373169, 0.032928467, -0.021118164, 0.05923462, -0.043670654, -0.03591919, 0.021377563, -0.013267517, 0.07836914, -0.027526855, -0.07904053, 0.045288086, -0.028427124, 0.009895325, 0.06628418, -0.021072388, 0.004425049, 0.010253906, 0.0010128021, 0.027862549, 0.011787415, 0.009605408, -0.0058403015, -0.029830933, -0.007850647, -0.0057678223, 0.024642944, 0.027389526, -0.046173096, 0.023727417, 0.00881958, 0.018478394, 0.034851074, -0.0044136047, 0.001083374, 0.002193451, 0.016098022, -0.04559326, 0.052764893, 0.020935059, -0.020385742, 0.045959473, -0.025863647, -0.0022258759, 0.0435791, 0.008872986, 0.031066895, -0.015808105, -0.00033521652, 0.062927246, 0.0069618225, -0.010108948, -0.008140564, -0.0077667236, 0.05102539, 0.020462036, 0.02432251, 0.0362854, 0.028030396, -0.003446579, -0.0027599335, -0.00793457, 0.0030727386, -0.014038086, 0.015327454, -0.00013196468, 0.011581421, -0.04373169, 0.0017023087, -0.016662598, 0.07348633, 0.0046577454, 0.028823853, 0.0021381378, -0.025314331, 0.07104492, 0.029388428, -0.025375366, -0.07519531, -0.009475708, -0.02746582, -0.028427124, -0.044067383, -0.05117798, -0.014373779, -0.047668457, 0.016082764, -0.0055656433, 0.01285553, 0.027008057, 0.03189087, -0.005958557, 0.007106781, -0.011222839, 0.009475708, -0.017944336, 0.029586792, -0.014526367, 0.018295288, -0.021591187, -0.00010186434, -0.0034885406, -0.0010108948, -0.012817383, -0.050445557, -0.0146102905, 0.037200928, -0.028579712, 0.005592346, 0.0044898987, 0.012237549, 0.04220581, 0.013153076, 0.002752304, 0.010810852, -0.05734253, -0.019180298, 0.011878967, 0.05404663, -0.01637268, 0.028045654, 0.030258179, -0.02758789, -0.012123108, -0.0011634827, -0.011138916, 0.02267456, 0.0012607574, 0.0052261353, 0.0068855286, 0.024154663, 0.007827759, 0.00006455183, 0.008712769, -0.035736084, 0.02784729, -0.021514893, -0.011245728, -0.007873535, -0.011665344, 0.009475708, -0.0041389465, -0.0017967224, -0.010902405, -0.051696777, 0.009315491, 0.042175293, 0.011802673, -0.015655518, -0.01398468, 0.016723633, 0.04446411, 0.012649536, 0.021713257, -0.053466797, 0.023880005, -0.00029206276, -0.010040283, 0.0158844, -0.021240234, -0.012237549, -0.015586853, 0.010643005, -0.04525757, 0.03375244, 0.044921875, 0.03237915, -0.013549805, -0.015792847, 0.04196167, -0.030349731, -0.036590576, 0.03982544, -0.027832031, 0.0017433167, 0.04647827, 0.0053977966, -0.03375244, 0.038970947, -0.050048828, 0.030471802, -0.0013113022, -0.0340271, 0.002149582, -0.028366089, 0.022277832, -0.01574707, 0.024337769, 0.017929077, 0.021514893, -0.064086914, -0.008705139, 0.033203125, 0.07891846, -0.020507812, -0.03112793, 0.049926758, -0.020584106, -0.020828247, -0.02079773, 0.025878906, -0.04360962, -0.030212402, 0.0026741028, -0.013290405, -0.014884949, -0.020568848, 0.007724762, -0.04336548, 0.0044937134, -0.04815674, 0.03753662, -0.00023770332, -0.03100586, -0.020629883, -0.030838013, 0.031555176, 0.032989502, 0.027694702, -0.021499634, -0.0049209595, -0.010574341, 0.02267456, -0.04623413, -0.012527466, -0.031280518, -0.024398804, -0.03643799, -0.0146865845, -0.01259613, 0.0413208, -0.019348145, -0.000002026558, -0.0015268326, -0.026504517, 0.015388489, -0.033416748, -0.041656494, -0.005645752, -0.02458191, -0.012107849, 0.016235352, 0.024032593, -0.008995056, -0.0077934265, 0.011619568, -0.057861328, 0.013137817, 0.04852295, 0.033599854, -0.036193848, -0.03829956, -0.018096924, 0.046936035, -0.008888245, 0.04989624, 0.051635742, 0.029083252, 0.048736572, -0.0054969788, 0.037017822, -0.0054092407, -0.0152282715, 0.043701172, -0.010070801, 0.03527832, -0.04156494, -0.0025634766, -0.015640259, 0.06173706, -0.0289917, -0.06640625, 0.0065689087, 0.0011119843, 0.02267456, 0.022827148, 0.027526855, 0.028076172, 0.064086914, 0.040374756, -0.001540184, -0.015472412, -0.0065231323, -0.025482178, -0.035614014, 0.051605225, 0.06222534, -0.029434204, -0.011688232, 0.018661499, 0.030975342, -0.001789093, 0.028137207, 0.0345459, -0.012283325, 0.006801605, 0.015037537, 0.031051636, -0.012161255, -0.0059890747, -0.026397705, 0.044189453, 0.023117065, 0.0044288635, 0.04638672, 0.021591187, 0.011657715, 0.008453369, 0.005077362, 0.021697998, -0.018218994, 0.072387695, 0.0048942566, 0.015205383, -0.024154663, -0.024658203, -0.08929443, 0.05822754, 0.013313293, -0.035339355, 0.0055351257, -0.010101318, -0.004425049, 0.061035156, -0.043304443, 0.049591064, -0.029663086, 0.011550903, -0.013694763, 0.026245117, -0.007926941, 0.012817383, 0.05319214, -0.0015048981, 0.010612488, 0.00051498413, 0.022583008, -0.013015747, 0.003850937, -0.010864258, -0.06738281, 0.030700684, -0.020507812, -0.0067329407, -0.00868988, 0.0109939575, 0.030136108, 0.0032749176, 0.017837524, -0.0039634705, 0.019012451, 0.014122009, -0.024520874, 0.023483276, -0.012252808, 0.028411865, 0.0065727234, -0.021072388, -0.026611328, 0.04269409, -0.0028514862, 0.033935547, -0.0690918, -0.04449463, -0.013145447, 0.01411438, 0.005847931, -0.020645142, -0.037109375, -0.0107421875, 0.035858154, 0.014053345, -0.019485474, -0.0131073, -0.0060424805, 0.0049324036, 0.0099487305, -0.025787354, 0.029510498, -0.044952393, 0.08001709, 0.04144287, -0.030258179, 0.08477783, 0.054779053, -0.016708374, 0.021377563, 0.054748535, -0.043701172, 0.017669678, 0.011871338, 0.03086853, 0.050323486, 0.052612305, 0.019836426, 0.031799316, 0.01828003, -0.03237915, -0.025177002, 0.0047187805, -0.008987427, 0.011917114, -0.030319214, -0.018249512, 0.031585693, -0.053649902, 0.06549072, -0.021377563, 0.035339355, -0.013191223, -0.014251709, -0.019515991, -0.01789856, -0.0008125305, 0.009559631, -0.006324768, 0.025970459, 0.022354126, -0.042633057, 0.015289307, -0.023330688, -0.030471802, 0.007633209, 0.016403198, 0.037322998, -0.0256958, -0.039886475, 0.017227173, 0.017852783, 0.055603027, 0.008773804, -0.016723633, 0.04168701, 0.002313614, 0.020736694, -0.05996704, -0.02470398, -0.016983032, 0.04562378, 0.018997192, 0.010719299, 0.02810669, -0.015235901, -0.098083496, 0.018356323, 0.0035858154, -0.039215088, 0.04324341, 0.01977539, -0.002090454, -0.038391113, 0.01423645, -0.011497498, -0.010894775, -0.0647583, -0.010093689, 0.07067871, 0.0038890839, -0.016952515, -0.00031256676, 0.004207611, 0.0038547516, 0.010368347, -0.06304932, 0.00004839897, 0.0020809174, 0.009666443, -0.008102417, -0.018493652, 0.054016113, 0.0501709, -0.020462036, 0.055358887, 0.033050537, 0.026672363, 0.01373291, 0.04272461, -0.010002136, -0.032348633, -0.013687134, -0.004425049, 0.066223145, 0.0025806427, -0.031951904, 0.0050201416, 0.02154541, -0.026550293, -0.029190063, 0.037902832, -0.018539429, -0.014694214, 0.023391724, 0.0036373138, -0.0423584, 0.007472992, 0.020965576, -0.0014562607, -0.0042495728, -0.021118164, -0.0035438538, -0.0053749084, -0.032043457, 0.013053894, -0.019317627, 0.039093018, 0.031341553, -0.0012969971, 0.03668213, -0.04916382, 0.032470703, 0.051879883, 0.025268555, -0.0064697266, 0.0037498474, 0.007347107, 0.0178833, -0.035858154, -0.020065308, -0.046844482, -0.021316528, -0.015319824, -0.026931763, 0.005554199, -0.00021159649, 0.02861023, 0.051849365, -0.015899658, 0.033172607, 0.010978699, 0.008735657, 0.00566864, 0.008430481, 0.03012085, -0.019256592, 0.02154541 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07484v1
Psychometric Predictive Power of Large Language Models
Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Yohei Oseki, Timothy Baldwin
cs.CL, cs.AI
Next-word probabilities from language models have been shown to successfully simulate human reading behavior. Building on this, we show that, interestingly, instruction-tuned large language models (LLMs) yield worse psychometric predictive power (PPP) for human reading behavior than base LLMs with equivalent perplexities. In other words, instruction tuning, which helps LLMs provide human-preferred responses, does not always make them human-like from the computational psycholinguistics perspective. In addition, we explore prompting methodologies in simulating human reading behavior with LLMs, showing that prompts reflecting a particular linguistic hypothesis lead LLMs to exhibit better PPP but are still worse than base LLMs. These highlight that recent instruction tuning and prompting do not offer better estimates than direct probability measurements from base LLMs in cognitive modeling.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07484v1
2023-11-13T17:19:14
2023-11-13T17:19:14
{ "title": [ -0.028442383, -0.01966858, -0.034698486, -0.050598145, -0.023345947, -0.0034675598, -0.054748535, -0.00592041, -0.0061416626, 0.02796936, -0.008544922, -0.0077209473, 0.0012073517, -0.032714844, -0.033477783, 0.008102417, -0.0069885254, 0.053527832, -0.0056037903, -0.040863037, -0.013908386, -0.04864502, 0.03543091, 0.023025513, 0.055114746, -0.06689453, -0.07891846, 0.019012451, -0.030075073, -0.023025513, -0.007911682, 0.021743774, 0.03677368, 0.018066406, -0.0073661804, 0.008102417, -0.041931152, 0.016159058, -0.001045227, -0.0023345947, 0.022003174, -0.0056114197, -0.014923096, -0.020812988, -0.045440674, 0.026855469, -0.05307007, -0.021453857, 0.0007596016, -0.012588501, -0.0030059814, 0.046936035, -0.027618408, -0.0066070557, 0.022644043, -0.0041503906, -0.040161133, 0.0015773773, 0.01676941, 0.07312012, 0.040252686, -0.014190674, -0.00053071976, -0.013511658, -0.04949951, 0.0027675629, -0.052764893, 0.0140686035, 0.08691406, -0.008308411, -0.056610107, 0.004310608, -0.0045776367, -0.009117126, -0.062438965, 0.049743652, 0.024291992, -0.0022506714, 0.048828125, -0.0385437, 0.0052452087, 0.0014648438, -0.00088071823, -0.0067710876, 0.0104522705, -0.02394104, -0.022094727, -0.018035889, -0.021972656, -0.07763672, -0.005004883, -0.02330017, -0.023101807, 0.014564514, -0.008621216, -0.036834717, -0.037078857, 0.027069092, -0.010398865, -0.042388916, -0.02166748, 0.031677246, -0.07269287, -0.012680054, 0.0033607483, 0.033477783, -0.04736328, -0.010139465, 0.025131226, 0.03933716, -0.0011358261, 0.012039185, -0.0040626526, 0.027893066, -0.007320404, 0.004837036, -0.023651123, 0.015617371, -0.0078125, 0.04724121, -0.009391785, -0.016403198, 0.012535095, -0.0010919571, 0.02532959, 0.013084412, -0.038024902, -0.014503479, -0.041625977, 0.060394287, 0.034606934, 0.027069092, -0.14099121, -0.07952881, -0.084472656, 0.026321411, -0.016052246, -0.016723633, -0.02784729, 0.041625977, -0.029083252, -0.036499023, 0.026763916, -0.023254395, -0.0013437271, 0.0107040405, 0.06109619, -0.0038070679, -0.052093506, -0.07324219, 0.0042533875, -0.010040283, 0.050811768, -0.0013017654, -0.1015625, -0.0041923523, -0.15490723, 0.0028324127, -0.008293152, 0.00075912476, 0.037353516, -0.018737793, -0.043823242, 0.00053834915, 0.016052246, 0.010025024, -0.013389587, 0.025360107, 0.009651184, 0.038970947, -0.01309967, 0.022277832, -0.0025959015, 0.021026611, -0.00032877922, 0.01335144, 0.017608643, 0.013290405, 0.03640747, -0.02104187, 0.00027012825, -0.018096924, 0.050994873, 0.0340271, -0.054870605, -0.03677368, -0.016311646, -0.024383545, 0.062683105, 0.017181396, -0.03503418, 0.016738892, -0.02027893, -0.043762207, -0.030517578, -0.026763916, 0.03125, 0.021102905, -0.002527237, -0.0060920715, 0.023162842, -0.01725769, -0.023040771, -0.034973145, -0.07336426, -0.035858154, -0.030639648, 0.016448975, -0.0061187744, 0.041290283, 0.04660034, 0.0062408447, -0.046142578, 0.039398193, -0.02696228, -0.06958008, 0.014472961, 0.0018033981, -0.0001449585, -0.02104187, -0.0020542145, -0.0020599365, 0.023452759, 0.0524292, -0.020599365, -0.0016994476, 0.009635925, -0.019073486, 0.011734009, 0.01701355, 0.07965088, -0.045776367, 0.038360596, 0.015563965, -0.0009036064, -0.028671265, -0.010536194, -0.027877808, 0.018096924, 0.018707275, -0.003929138, -0.027954102, -0.024047852, 0.009513855, 0.029388428, 0.019729614, 0.021011353, -0.007835388, 0.05407715, 0.049316406, 0.038482666, 0.0030593872, 0.047332764, -0.021347046, 0.02848816, 0.0625, -0.0055236816, -0.030014038, 0.020553589, 0.0075187683, 0.03451538, 0.021408081, -0.031463623, 0.029724121, -0.06689453, 0.015113831, -0.051635742, -0.0008134842, 0.0099487305, 0.00566864, 0.025878906, -0.030944824, 0.023849487, -0.026733398, -0.0035190582, -0.017410278, -0.02079773, 0.02986145, 0.015174866, -0.058807373, -0.0019521713, 0.024307251, 0.014389038, -0.000059962273, 0.0033912659, 0.0031433105, 0.0027179718, -0.010620117, 0.014953613, -0.00554657, 0.041503906, 0.03778076, 0.018173218, 0.02748108, -0.0052452087, -0.004798889, 0.08123779, 0.0501709, -0.013130188, 0.017822266, -0.01689148, 0.018814087, 0.0044517517, 0.0047187805, 0.004131317, 0.040039062, 0.03201294, 0.012420654, -0.036315918, 0.0057868958, -0.041107178, -0.00079107285, 0.019058228, -0.027008057, -0.01739502, -0.031433105, 0.021240234, -0.01259613, -0.00894165, -0.023727417, 0.050323486, -0.015174866, -0.013870239, -0.0067634583, 0.0055122375, -0.024734497, -0.012336731, -0.027877808, 0.0049324036, 0.013183594, 0.05078125, 0.005142212, -0.045898438, -0.06713867, -0.011154175, -0.006855011, -0.016433716, 0.0051574707, -0.03475952, 0.02909851, -0.016052246, -0.026931763, 0.026229858, -0.06237793, 0.0050621033, -0.06048584, 0.020355225, 0.018234253, -0.025497437, -0.007247925, 0.029953003, -0.015808105, -0.012084961, 0.037841797, 0.07281494, -0.032165527, -0.034973145, 0.053619385, 0.02709961, -0.019424438, 0.03866577, 0.020935059, 0.015731812, -0.033843994, -0.037384033, -0.059783936, -0.0132369995, -0.0071754456, -0.023132324, 0.031707764, -0.05706787, -0.029876709, -0.03036499, -0.009880066, 0.00013566017, 0.035949707, 0.026153564, -0.016281128, -0.041168213, -0.0023117065, -0.017044067, 0.016296387, -0.028213501, 0.02760315, 0.06921387, 0.004043579, 0.016174316, 0.0104599, 0.04559326, 0.006801605, 0.008995056, 0.00028944016, -0.046813965, 0.0052261353, 0.009178162, 0.015792847, -0.013877869, -0.03062439, -0.092163086, -0.007896423, 0.051696777, -0.027404785, -0.023971558, 0.022903442, -0.08294678, 0.06976318, -0.021636963, 0.008277893, 0.036346436, 0.028549194, -0.0075263977, 0.03427124, 0.018798828, -0.03781128, 0.010406494, -0.02394104, -0.10632324, 0.031433105, -0.0019893646, -0.04272461, -0.0060157776, -0.03753662, -0.046783447, 0.007095337, 0.0013198853, 0.06585693, 0.016571045, 0.010551453, 0.029342651, -0.014503479, 0.012001038, -0.0054016113, -0.007293701, 0.00497818, -0.02923584, 0.024536133, 0.00182724, 0.03656006, 0.039978027, -0.027435303, 0.010429382, -0.01802063, -0.05529785, 0.019577026, -0.013465881, -0.034057617, -0.018005371, 0.0011758804, 0.008895874, -0.0025806427, -0.019012451, -0.0015258789, 0.0010089874, 0.013412476, -0.024047852, 0.012619019, 0.042388916, 0.0014228821, -0.0066947937, -0.019058228, -0.0007367134, -0.024459839, -0.033691406, -0.005886078, 0.047912598, 0.023284912, -0.008140564, -0.00037050247, 0.00027012825, -0.0038051605, 0.0012645721, -0.011505127, 0.015213013, -0.0048179626, -0.0236969, -0.008613586, 0.013282776, -0.0033302307, 0.007293701, -0.0050468445, -0.024475098, 0.025299072, -0.0042419434, -0.10662842, -0.019256592, 0.0045280457, -0.122924805, -0.057037354, -0.011352539, -0.011077881, -0.026947021, -0.0082473755, 0.007835388, 0.0010614395, -0.030548096, -0.001698494, -0.028900146, -0.017318726, -0.023147583, -0.082336426, 0.018569946, 0.060516357, 0.00078105927, 0.043701172, 0.025115967, -0.0049552917, -0.0009613037, -0.045654297, 0.027633667, -0.014923096, 0.04522705, -0.017990112, -0.04208374, 0.035064697, -0.034851074, 0.018508911, 0.03201294, 0.0026626587, -0.0020923615, -0.001540184, 0.011787415, 0.04623413, -0.020431519, 0.04095459, 0.011558533, -0.008483887, -0.06317139, 0.020401001, -0.009712219, -0.004386902, 0.014228821, -0.022659302, 0.0096588135, 0.008880615, 0.018310547, 0.05731201, -0.014076233, 0.007774353, 0.054107666, -0.01197052, -0.012924194, 0.021484375, 0.0034370422, 0.020187378, 0.011436462, 0.020996094, 0.0028591156, 0.054534912, -0.021774292, -0.015380859, 0.005832672, 0.02456665, -0.060638428, -0.012451172, -0.045654297, -0.11035156, -0.035888672, 0.021240234, -0.020431519, 0.03186035, 0.042175293, -0.0021629333, -0.020507812, -0.019256592, 0.03866577, 0.0032520294, -0.008834839, -0.057678223, 0.025390625, -0.016357422, -0.030654907, -0.026412964, 0.041168213, 0.012664795, 0.029693604, -0.012886047, -0.020385742, -0.0022640228, 0.016647339, 0.058441162, 0.022750854, 0.01058197, -0.03213501, -0.0020427704, -0.014907837, -0.024139404, 0.017715454, -0.0206604, -0.0017852783, -0.021560669, 0.01576233, -0.01436615, 0.0007324219, -0.01751709, 0.023391724, -0.029418945, 0.064086914, -0.038909912, -0.006587982, 0.013534546, -0.0012817383, -0.00806427, 0.006336212, -0.036132812, -0.0061149597, -0.0010814667, 0.03353882, -0.004085541, 0.0006890297, 0.03970337, 0.025283813, 0.0075035095, 0.0062713623, -0.00087213516, 0.030044556, 0.024475098, 0.009918213, 0.020584106, -0.0440979, -0.04071045, -0.00006598234, 0.0032749176, 0.04562378, -0.037322998, 0.03616333, -0.01977539, 0.015701294, 0.013832092, -0.014411926, 0.029525757, 0.003921509, 0.023117065, -0.06878662, -0.039794922, 0.01360321, 0.03463745, -0.032836914, 0.013557434, 0.011169434, -0.006336212, 0.015396118, 0.024215698, 0.007873535, 0.020462036, 0.00869751, -0.021484375, -0.0037784576, -0.005355835, -0.046173096, -0.0005764961, 0.016799927, 0.009544373, -0.038269043, 0.008491516, -0.0473938, -0.016723633, -0.023666382, -0.019348145, 0.028945923, -0.07446289, 0.010070801, 0.06976318, -0.0007696152, 0.043640137, 0.019897461, -0.011917114, 0.023269653, 0.06048584, -0.00969696, 0.047668457, 0.014976501, -0.037597656, 0.02470398, -0.011566162, 0.020751953, -0.0021743774, 0.030334473, 0.007843018, 0.03543091, -0.057159424, 0.014038086, 0.002752304, -0.013542175, 0.032806396, -0.059906006, 0.0028915405, 0.0118637085, 0.0015439987, 0.004096985, -0.022369385, -0.034423828, -0.0037059784, -0.011497498, -0.025802612, 0.014205933, -0.019241333, -0.044799805, -0.053131104, 0.014442444, -0.008544922, 0.016235352, -0.002445221, -0.007335663, -0.04034424, 0.02947998, 0.02041626, -0.04019165, -0.0028209686, -0.018295288, 0.006324768, 0.028747559, 0.038879395, -0.050323486, -0.011566162, -0.0184021, -0.048431396, -0.015640259, 0.019958496, 0.020111084, 0.0022354126, -0.013908386, -0.035308838, -0.0024471283, -0.007896423, 0.02218628, -0.0051231384, -0.015197754, 0.033447266, -0.0181427, -0.025299072, 0.006248474, 0.012275696, -0.00022041798, 0.0036697388, -0.00157547, -0.06604004, 0.03741455, -0.02406311, 0.017730713, -0.055664062, -0.0519104, -0.0037326813, 0.0206604, 0.01159668, -0.004966736, 0.02583313, 0.027908325, -0.0039043427, 0.0027694702, 0.01939392, 0.05014038, -0.032409668, -0.04324341, 0.0013999939, -0.009544373, -0.009315491, 0.08465576, 0.011756897, -0.036376953, -0.04208374, -0.058563232, -0.029434204, 0.018661499, 0.030548096, 0.038360596, 0.03491211, -0.0141067505, 0.044647217, -0.021194458, -0.017990112, -0.022277832, 0.020080566, -0.012741089, -0.061523438, 0.017120361, -0.0059928894, 0.01020813, -0.04144287, 0.020187378, 0.020690918, 0.0076560974, 0.0056915283, -0.04586792, 0.001282692, -0.01789856, -0.024139404, 0.03186035, -0.0011491776, -0.0056037903, 0.03930664, -0.036834717, 0.040222168, 0.019561768, 0.04208374, 0.02230835, 0.016937256, 0.021881104, -0.0026817322, 0.025375366, -0.024642944, 0.004486084, -0.028778076, 0.0044059753, -0.058288574, -0.006149292, -0.07489014, 0.052520752, -0.0056495667, 0.030776978, -0.0049476624, 0.01725769, 0.0031719208, -0.016586304, 0.046203613, 0.0040626526, 0.07409668, 0.019241333, 0.016845703, -0.011314392, -0.031021118, 0.011604309, 0.03768921, -0.003944397, -0.010124207, -0.01940918, -0.017700195, 0.018051147, -0.002090454, -0.004901886, -0.011726379, -0.002286911, -0.03930664, 0.026367188, -0.005935669, 0.029052734, 0.052459717, 0.0058898926, 0.021697998, -0.022201538, -0.005558014, -0.024871826, -0.00982666, -0.0071372986, 0.027801514, -0.06097412, 0.036590576, 0.006263733, -0.023635864, -0.021957397, 0.034088135, 0.030075073, -0.036376953, -0.03314209, 0.004787445, 0.047729492, 0.02154541, 0.033477783, -0.049987793, -0.021453857, -0.00045323372, 0.021850586, -0.013366699, 0.00970459, 0.019332886, 0.017364502, -0.021575928, -0.031982422, 0.027923584, -0.0061836243, 0.0073127747, 0.027267456, -0.009529114, 0.006084442, -0.0032043457, -0.031341553, -0.003211975, 0.01675415, -0.05517578, -0.006580353, 0.017166138, 0.0413208, 0.030258179, 0.07043457, 0.022949219, -0.01727295, -0.0209198, -0.053527832, 0.029937744, 0.04385376, -0.02268982, 0.021713257, -0.042999268, -0.046295166, 0.031158447, -0.04953003, 0.06713867, -0.07141113, 0.0007381439, -0.026382446, 0.06585693, 0.0026168823, -0.054626465, -0.05606079, 0.013572693, -0.041137695, -0.00055503845, 0.00957489, -0.033111572, -0.034942627, -0.02017212, 0.012672424, -0.001329422, 0.008377075, 0.0047798157, -0.022567749, -0.07696533, 0.0075645447, -0.01902771, 0.04071045, -0.023742676, 0.007713318, -0.008529663, 0.016738892, -0.012001038, -0.03869629, -0.037902832, 0.008216858, -0.009498596, -0.046661377, 0.026977539, 0.014221191, -0.013046265, -0.013000488, -0.029052734, -0.0070610046, -0.028945923, 0.02130127, 0.016937256, -0.035461426, -0.046447754, -0.0012788773, -0.02432251, 0.02331543, 0.008468628, -0.011627197, 0.017044067, 0.0014801025, -0.033325195, -0.021713257, 0.03314209, 0.06317139, -0.0033798218, -0.072631836, 0.009803772, 0.019439697, 0.034820557, -0.052581787, -0.007545471, 0.038238525, 0.04751587, -0.020217896, 0.03778076, 0.050689697, 0.011787415, 0.012771606, -0.00018000603, -0.0026626587, -0.043670654, -0.030563354, -0.021316528, 0.042022705, 0.060791016, 0.0034103394, 0.004787445, 0.050598145, -0.006881714, -0.0078048706, 0.03704834, -0.006801605, 0.026245117, 0.0020389557, 0.02456665, -0.036193848, -0.025268555, -0.02192688, -0.023666382, 0.009735107, 0.02848816, -0.030807495, 0.020706177, -0.03778076, 0.044525146, -0.032196045, -0.027282715, 0.03503418, 0.025466919, 0.020690918, -0.007881165, -0.004878998, 0.019302368, 0.010360718, -0.015342712, -0.0041618347, -0.0032863617, 0.012184143, -0.04626465, -0.0050964355, -0.042053223, -0.03314209, -0.044067383, -0.021774292, 0.022232056, -0.020080566, 0.022583008, -0.023925781, -0.014434814, -0.007637024, -0.0015325546, 0.018829346, -0.04345703, -0.04156494, -0.014595032, 0.04800415, -0.004558563 ], "summary": [ -0.05050659, -0.047912598, 0.04434204, 0.041809082, -0.12426758, 0.012283325, -0.057037354, -0.041290283, -0.005836487, 0.020141602, -0.035736084, 0.016326904, 0.0087890625, -0.009880066, 0.027252197, -0.030258179, -0.015991211, 0.02293396, -0.0046310425, -0.03604126, 0.007183075, -0.03765869, -0.009765625, 0.0005979538, 0.034606934, -0.008361816, -0.032318115, -0.017364502, 0.029388428, 0.0158844, 0.010749817, -0.010772705, 0.022521973, 0.022979736, -0.047027588, 0.0020923615, -0.03778076, 0.024612427, -0.008285522, -0.0027046204, 0.014381409, -0.014671326, 0.010559082, 0.0036582947, -0.025772095, 0.019012451, -0.013381958, -0.03387451, 0.037994385, -0.033691406, -0.022323608, 0.066711426, -0.016174316, -0.039978027, -0.011894226, -0.014190674, -0.022262573, 0.027862549, -0.019134521, 0.052520752, 0.04006958, 0.06060791, -0.0076065063, -0.00063085556, 0.0017356873, 0.017623901, -0.06542969, -0.006919861, 0.055755615, 0.04421997, -0.019119263, -0.037139893, 0.014862061, -0.07232666, -0.014038086, 0.04147339, -0.0077209473, -0.010505676, 0.020767212, -0.02835083, 0.036956787, 0.0003182888, -0.009544373, -0.02973938, 0.0033912659, -0.028930664, 0.009117126, -0.0075416565, -0.0019245148, -0.015022278, -0.017120361, -0.004360199, 0.02684021, 0.016479492, -0.023223877, -0.032806396, -0.027893066, -0.011604309, -0.0209198, -0.05230713, 0.018615723, -0.0039520264, -0.054138184, 0.022079468, 0.010116577, 0.021057129, -0.020492554, -0.0011053085, 0.043273926, 0.010887146, -0.009796143, 0.016143799, 0.0066490173, -0.026672363, 0.021499634, -0.0021476746, -0.031799316, 0.07720947, 0.025283813, 0.044891357, -0.0052490234, 0.0043678284, 0.02027893, 0.026504517, 0.010543823, 0.03591919, 0.017105103, -0.03945923, -0.019424438, 0.029067993, 0.009468079, 0.018234253, -0.05218506, -0.020935059, -0.062927246, 0.0023345947, 0.030288696, 0.0013589859, -0.02986145, 0.03475952, -0.029251099, -0.02458191, 0.02154541, -0.030670166, -0.0085372925, 0.031066895, 0.021438599, 0.002872467, -0.0033512115, -0.038635254, 0.020370483, -0.029159546, 0.02671814, -0.03656006, -0.027557373, -0.06890869, -0.098083496, 0.001326561, 0.059906006, 0.013214111, 0.029632568, -0.017501831, -0.02078247, 0.025146484, -0.016906738, 0.013473511, -0.0067596436, 0.0010900497, 0.028259277, 0.021652222, 0.02041626, -0.008651733, 0.0015707016, 0.008964539, 0.002614975, 0.007286072, 0.02166748, 0.0423584, 0.011245728, -0.00983429, -0.012542725, -0.034729004, 0.090148926, -0.022003174, -0.018859863, -0.027755737, -0.0024433136, 0.04208374, 0.053100586, 0.022232056, -0.039916992, -0.037994385, -0.03265381, -0.023925781, 0.0055732727, -0.002937317, -0.0021247864, 0.0025920868, 0.0068626404, -0.010269165, 0.04168701, -0.028778076, -0.009147644, -0.053619385, -0.109069824, -0.03933716, -0.019897461, 0.012069702, 0.017181396, 0.020935059, 0.02809143, 0.02760315, -0.066833496, 0.07171631, -0.032073975, -0.030960083, 0.003332138, 0.021942139, -0.0103302, -0.029968262, 0.010604858, 0.0026111603, 0.007522583, 0.058532715, -0.04397583, -0.0231781, -0.0017633438, 0.002023697, 0.038085938, -0.0076179504, 0.08703613, -0.016662598, -0.005847931, 0.007598877, -0.0018033981, -0.0016441345, 0.015975952, -0.0715332, 0.030914307, 0.031097412, 0.027801514, 0.005393982, -0.015617371, 0.006351471, 0.031280518, 0.03527832, 0.04522705, -0.03363037, 0.028686523, 0.026138306, -0.0028190613, -0.048034668, 0.03955078, -0.01285553, 0.010986328, 0.03488159, 0.001958847, -0.025222778, 0.042541504, -0.025527954, 0.029541016, 0.033691406, -0.0335083, 0.0345459, -0.04550171, -0.044403076, -0.042755127, -0.04309082, 0.029724121, -0.032836914, 0.027694702, -0.08892822, -0.00026249886, -0.07720947, -0.036834717, -0.04800415, -0.04220581, 0.0690918, 0.031585693, -0.0690918, 0.008018494, 0.022766113, -0.008071899, -0.011932373, 0.017501831, 0.012016296, -0.0005173683, 0.028915405, 0.03604126, 0.035705566, 0.04348755, 0.016677856, 0.016784668, 0.012527466, -0.0073242188, -0.016540527, 0.053833008, 0.017440796, 0.007736206, -0.008926392, 0.03125, 0.029037476, -0.017288208, 0.0019197464, 0.014701843, 0.015579224, 0.01966858, 0.018295288, 0.0017156601, 0.009162903, -0.03286743, -0.000096321106, 0.035461426, 0.012390137, 0.03387451, 0.029586792, 0.028747559, 0.052490234, 0.05078125, 0.03225708, 0.10180664, 0.004573822, -0.016738892, -0.0126571655, -0.012763977, -0.04321289, 0.010879517, -0.03543091, 0.05267334, -0.029830933, -0.01776123, -0.035003662, -0.061767578, -0.007713318, 0.008972168, 0.002779007, -0.025436401, 0.0362854, -0.02243042, 0.027496338, -0.01612854, -0.07989502, 0.01133728, -0.030303955, -0.05404663, 0.019943237, 0.0048675537, -0.013885498, 0.028182983, 0.014152527, 0.006187439, 0.00094795227, -0.017166138, 0.051635742, 0.030776978, -0.012535095, -0.003894806, 0.036743164, -0.012748718, -0.04119873, 0.033569336, 0.030395508, 0.011367798, -0.025299072, -0.034576416, -0.03717041, 0.0064048767, 0.0027122498, 0.020492554, 0.01184845, -0.01927185, 0.017562866, -0.036956787, 0.0011291504, 0.015625, 0.02885437, 0.08538818, 0.013916016, -0.037231445, 0.03643799, 0.027328491, 0.033935547, 0.00054597855, -0.010566711, 0.050872803, 0.009307861, 0.006942749, 0.015838623, 0.032470703, 0.010063171, 0.0049552917, -0.0006456375, -0.03112793, -0.02154541, 0.019851685, 0.018356323, -0.06088257, -0.005870819, -0.058898926, -0.0051994324, 0.06744385, -0.011817932, 0.025283813, 0.02178955, -0.06048584, 0.078552246, -0.019195557, 0.030090332, 0.024627686, 0.0012407303, 0.003112793, -0.061035156, 0.0013971329, -0.076293945, -0.0050315857, -0.0006213188, -0.057861328, -0.0026340485, 0.013084412, 0.008804321, 0.0032081604, -0.01689148, -0.018066406, 0.0057792664, 0.023895264, 0.03866577, 0.0055389404, -0.02458191, 0.035308838, 0.050109863, 0.0335083, 0.0034561157, -0.042114258, 0.00907135, -0.031051636, 0.05947876, 0.035186768, 0.0064430237, 0.061767578, -0.038238525, -0.0211792, -0.040618896, -0.08441162, 0.0055236816, -0.028015137, -0.007965088, -0.038726807, -0.058166504, -0.020645142, 0.005378723, 0.00083208084, -0.002462387, 0.030899048, 0.043395996, -0.009521484, 0.083984375, -0.020111084, 0.021255493, 0.04949951, -0.04562378, -0.035125732, -0.01751709, -0.0071258545, -0.013397217, 0.0008535385, -0.00932312, 0.010025024, 0.036346436, 0.01939392, -0.025970459, 0.011650085, -0.0017957687, 0.0014915466, -0.03189087, -0.02973938, -0.040374756, 0.046417236, -0.019363403, 0.08691406, -0.021987915, -0.02746582, 0.027130127, 0.010284424, -0.072753906, -0.028396606, 0.009689331, -0.062194824, -0.044555664, -0.01399231, 0.027374268, -0.032562256, 0.014862061, 0.009101868, 0.009483337, -0.015991211, 0.015319824, -0.016525269, 0.045532227, -0.01713562, -0.074645996, 0.015403748, -0.021774292, 0.02507019, 0.03314209, 0.0063285828, -0.008003235, 0.0014123917, 0.00020098686, 0.02166748, 0.015602112, 0.021392822, -0.0007801056, -0.03475952, 0.0010528564, -0.008674622, 0.0074310303, 0.02746582, -0.03869629, 0.022781372, 0.0014600754, 0.020751953, 0.04421997, 0.013267517, 0.0028381348, -0.015281677, 0.029525757, -0.025405884, 0.044921875, -0.012634277, -0.06561279, 0.014007568, -0.021224976, -0.02330017, 0.05303955, 0.021942139, 0.05709839, -0.045135498, 0.0022964478, 0.007583618, 0.010398865, -0.06060791, 0.00072956085, 0.03527832, 0.048736572, -0.018493652, 0.043518066, -0.018600464, 0.032714844, 0.044158936, -0.044769287, 0.016647339, 0.01751709, -0.027572632, -0.016036987, -0.028366089, -0.040161133, -0.028961182, 0.020980835, -0.00919342, 0.03237915, 0.012481689, 0.016342163, -0.010009766, -0.0071105957, 0.033477783, 0.014793396, -0.045410156, -0.06732178, -0.045135498, 0.020736694, -0.05279541, -0.027633667, -0.052490234, -0.048034668, -0.028717041, -0.013076782, -0.018661499, -0.0024204254, -0.013221741, 0.016799927, -0.015945435, 0.031555176, 0.0047569275, 0.0040245056, -0.0592041, -0.0011405945, 0.021072388, 0.009887695, -0.03842163, -0.016052246, 0.036010742, -0.0056991577, 0.01436615, -0.03414917, -0.0121536255, -0.022109985, -0.0047454834, -0.026550293, 0.0064201355, -0.0052871704, -0.010795593, -0.009048462, 0.011314392, -0.009124756, 0.0046081543, 0.01461792, -0.006679535, 0.031082153, -0.00016915798, -0.029556274, 0.016845703, 0.00094890594, -0.0138549805, 0.028289795, -0.01525116, -0.017593384, 0.02029419, -0.0126571655, -0.02355957, 0.0076408386, 0.035369873, -0.00749588, 0.03729248, 0.037078857, -0.019119263, -0.01537323, 0.02798462, 0.048583984, -0.009597778, -0.001707077, 0.04937744, -0.018615723, -0.02859497, 0.0034046173, 0.014968872, -0.028167725, -0.01676941, -0.002670288, -0.011634827, -0.040252686, 0.016555786, -0.029312134, -0.04660034, 0.0013542175, 0.033081055, -0.0034389496, 0.012535095, 0.037719727, -0.013160706, -0.045562744, -0.013031006, 0.0011482239, -0.020477295, 0.020812988, 0.024246216, -0.03567505, -0.008544922, -0.02420044, 0.014228821, -0.06524658, -0.04525757, -0.0018014908, -0.026306152, 0.0011577606, 0.08105469, 0.00040888786, -0.016998291, 0.004699707, -0.0017623901, 0.009124756, -0.026824951, -0.074157715, 0.030929565, -0.0132369995, 0.011703491, 0.018539429, 0.004058838, 0.012374878, 0.011009216, -0.025604248, -0.0054893494, -0.05493164, -0.024887085, 0.033691406, -0.025848389, 0.018554688, 0.016433716, 0.0068130493, -0.022949219, 0.0040130615, -0.036865234, 0.0044898987, -0.017242432, -0.0029678345, -0.008811951, -0.038024902, 0.010986328, -0.038848877, -0.0005683899, -0.0680542, 0.02508545, 0.005378723, -0.014755249, -0.009918213, -0.0041503906, 0.03793335, -0.016235352, 0.017715454, 0.0007491112, 0.009742737, 0.0027275085, 0.026107788, -0.059692383, -0.02458191, 0.0038471222, -0.016204834, -0.01473999, -0.024124146, -0.011138916, 0.034484863, -0.014152527, 0.031341553, 0.018432617, -0.020736694, 0.040100098, -0.036254883, -0.03942871, -0.009147644, -0.042907715, -0.05935669, 0.025634766, 0.026519775, -0.041534424, -0.0019521713, 0.019302368, -0.0262146, 0.018493652, -0.0014314651, 0.015640259, -0.062469482, -0.050964355, -0.0042152405, 0.02142334, 0.003068924, -0.007171631, 0.035064697, 0.019210815, -0.02468872, 0.0012187958, 0.0019626617, 0.0072021484, -0.0075569153, -0.030914307, -0.036376953, 0.00075387955, -0.04949951, 0.03515625, -0.0037403107, -0.025100708, -0.022384644, -0.02407837, 0.017150879, 0.006252289, 0.008735657, -0.012794495, 0.022735596, -0.07348633, -0.030471802, -0.008293152, -0.031311035, -0.050323486, 0.0140686035, -0.034851074, -0.06323242, 0.07281494, -0.0028038025, 0.009010315, 0.03189087, -0.008087158, -0.020996094, -0.054870605, 0.047668457, -0.023910522, 0.024795532, -0.014533997, 0.016830444, -0.028320312, 0.049316406, -0.015716553, 0.0046577454, -0.031982422, 0.025680542, 0.030639648, -0.019454956, -0.011520386, 0.018585205, 0.02696228, 0.0115737915, 0.032958984, 0.00040769577, -0.009147644, -0.030548096, 0.00032687187, -0.0073242188, 0.007835388, -0.02218628, 0.062408447, -0.014083862, 0.011482239, 0.013397217, 0.016647339, 0.021438599, -0.022827148, 0.008155823, -0.01927185, 0.03942871, 0.014678955, 0.022445679, 0.023284912, -0.0736084, -0.016998291, 0.0309906, 0.0006656647, 0.0035743713, 0.011146545, 0.021133423, 0.061584473, -0.06536865, -0.034240723, -0.07733154, 0.016586304, -0.05404663, 0.010261536, 0.030838013, 0.017684937, 0.009353638, -0.006790161, 0.117370605, -0.040222168, -0.013633728, 0.006214142, 0.020324707, 0.008361816, -0.0063934326, 0.016845703, 0.02015686, 0.020233154, -0.03665161, -0.016220093, 0.054138184, 0.02168274, 0.0038986206, 0.023712158, 0.010063171, 0.014701843, 0.025039673, 0.004207611, -0.048309326, -0.041992188, -0.044189453, -0.0135650635, 0.012535095, 0.025543213, 0.0026893616, 0.0107803345, 0.020950317, 0.015052795, 0.017044067, -0.0011835098, 0.03475952, 0.049560547, -0.02861023, 0.027877808, 0.027542114, -0.01852417, 0.027923584, 0.034179688, -0.04663086, 0.02420044, -0.0132369995, 0.039764404, 0.038238525, 0.038635254, -0.019622803, 0.0062789917, 0.026397705, -0.01184082, 0.051727295, 0.033325195, 0.015960693, 0.019958496, -0.026260376, -0.007423401, 0.031158447, 0.016601562, 0.0579834, -0.060943604, 0.016143799, -0.015808105, 0.01663208, -0.012802124, -0.016723633, -0.06149292, -0.009307861, -0.04269409, 0.007843018, 0.030792236, -0.023025513, -0.011154175, -0.027908325, 0.005748749, -0.004135132, -0.0072517395, 0.036071777, -0.013206482, -0.08319092, 0.032196045, 0.028656006, 0.07867432, -0.011268616, -0.020065308, 0.047454834, 0.033081055, -0.0044898987, -0.07476807, -0.045837402, 0.005252838, 0.07458496, -0.020828247, 0.0027656555, -0.0052223206, -0.023071289, -0.028030396, -0.05810547, 0.019363403, -0.035491943, 0.0135650635, 0.06756592, -0.007949829, -0.060424805, 0.0029296875, -0.029266357, 0.03753662, -0.007797241, -0.02003479, 0.033233643, 0.014427185, -0.015113831, -0.006717682, 0.0048828125, 0.017288208, -0.020629883, -0.050750732, 0.005153656, -0.020950317, -0.0029392242, -0.023086548, -0.06750488, 0.028656006, 0.047729492, -0.010803223, -0.052825928, 0.005580902, -0.0134887695, 0.018157959, 0.0054969788, 0.0038890839, -0.023284912, 0.009407043, 0.04559326, 0.059417725, 0.025802612, -0.02935791, 0.014564514, -0.00365448, -0.031982422, -0.010414124, 0.0059547424, -0.0073432922, -0.026062012, -0.02293396, -0.02319336, -0.025970459, -0.019714355, -0.056549072, -0.018539429, -0.0020179749, -0.03567505, -0.0074501038, 0.04031372, -0.047668457, -0.009674072, -0.037597656, 0.035369873, -0.0118255615, 0.012001038, 0.011390686, -0.023880005, 0.001420021, 0.050964355, 0.02470398, -0.020431519, -0.010681152, -0.02444458, 0.011360168, -0.031463623, -0.03274536, -0.028869629, 0.008262634, -0.06213379, -0.013389587, -0.003419876, 0.025756836, -6.556511e-7, 0.03540039, -0.006679535, 0.0062332153, 0.008201599, -0.016540527, -0.018432617, -0.017456055, -0.06561279, -0.017745972, 0.01020813 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07470v1
Finding and Editing Multi-Modal Neurons in Pre-Trained Transformer
Haowen Pan, Yixin Cao, Xiaozhi Wang, Xun Yang
cs.CL
Multi-modal large language models (LLM) have achieved powerful capabilities for visual semantic understanding in recent years. However, little is known about how LLMs comprehend visual information and interpret different modalities of features. In this paper, we propose a new method for identifying multi-modal neurons in transformer-based multi-modal LLMs. Through a series of experiments, We highlight three critical properties of multi-modal neurons by four well-designed quantitative evaluation metrics. Furthermore, we introduce a knowledge editing method based on the identified multi-modal neurons, for modifying a specific token to another designative token. We hope our findings can inspire further explanatory researches on understanding mechanisms of multi-modal LLMs.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07470v1
2023-11-13T17:03:02
2023-11-13T17:03:02
{ "title": [ 0.03439331, 0.027877808, -0.011138916, 0.0023288727, -0.0053482056, -0.028213501, -0.0019626617, -0.07006836, -0.022033691, 0.032196045, 0.0013370514, -0.014602661, 0.036712646, -0.058410645, 0.012001038, 0.0031852722, 0.0019388199, 0.03970337, 0.0015010834, -0.014183044, -0.031585693, -0.005428314, 0.01751709, 0.034210205, -0.008621216, -0.012039185, -0.08679199, 0.037261963, -0.01424408, -0.01828003, 0.0025806427, 0.024642944, 0.055023193, -0.009277344, 0.001250267, -0.0050964355, -0.0178833, 0.012550354, 0.0022468567, -0.017196655, 0.029785156, -0.0082473755, -0.03125, 0.0072517395, -0.04852295, -0.006832123, 0.0010690689, 0.020721436, 0.001666069, 0.017730713, -0.014572144, 0.012016296, -0.012329102, 0.03277588, -0.0074653625, -0.032958984, -0.05517578, 0.0082473755, 0.026550293, 0.09423828, 0.009155273, -0.02784729, -0.006511688, -0.08959961, -0.007270813, -0.020767212, -0.018981934, 0.023208618, 0.029174805, -0.0020046234, -0.0016441345, 0.012619019, 0.02822876, -0.0065956116, -0.054107666, 0.0015764236, 0.042663574, 0.060455322, 0.038879395, -0.06890869, 0.055145264, -0.02619934, 0.04699707, -0.053527832, 0.0524292, -0.04837036, 0.013877869, -0.0006260872, -0.032104492, -0.039520264, -0.02116394, -0.019302368, -0.019332886, 0.025665283, -0.033050537, -0.014381409, -0.03515625, -0.02079773, 0.019699097, 0.036956787, 0.0019350052, -0.017654419, 0.049346924, -0.038360596, 0.038909912, 0.0012483597, -0.024398804, -0.044281006, 0.046936035, 0.012451172, -0.034210205, 0.078186035, 0.024902344, 0.008544922, -0.0072250366, -0.005542755, 0.018951416, -0.00028705597, -0.018966675, 0.008323669, -0.028030396, -0.022506714, 0.026321411, -0.05706787, 0.025619507, -0.011024475, -0.026885986, 0.01159668, -0.0055389404, 0.028076172, -0.04095459, 0.04272461, -0.025146484, -0.0496521, -0.04260254, -0.006198883, -0.020904541, 0.01525116, 0.0036144257, -0.029510498, 0.05783081, -0.013244629, -0.012588501, 0.023956299, -0.023605347, 0.011810303, 0.061035156, 0.0026111603, -0.047698975, -0.03955078, -0.01902771, 0.027297974, 0.00072813034, -0.000068843365, 0.020889282, -0.010658264, -0.027267456, -0.030319214, 0.023498535, 0.0019073486, 0.013969421, -0.0023612976, 0.018875122, 0.028274536, 0.03765869, 0.024108887, -0.04345703, 0.021011353, 0.020202637, 0.040924072, -0.017410278, -0.005138397, 0.05596924, -0.0021038055, -0.011924744, 0.015670776, -0.046722412, 0.013496399, 0.027313232, -0.047058105, 0.012619019, -0.01121521, -0.00087070465, 0.0635376, -0.07537842, -0.013031006, -0.007286072, 0.07373047, 0.07342529, 0.0236969, -0.0463562, -0.040771484, -0.031143188, 0.0028324127, -0.044067383, 0.009635925, 0.0066490173, 0.03717041, -0.027145386, 0.0055656433, -0.033599854, 0.025604248, -0.03640747, 0.008140564, -0.056365967, 0.0015487671, -0.014533997, 0.022003174, -0.0231781, 0.04458618, 0.008674622, -0.023468018, 0.015472412, -0.05041504, -0.014228821, -0.041046143, -0.011734009, -0.042266846, 0.0022563934, -0.0104522705, 0.009857178, -0.006690979, -0.00491333, 0.01398468, -0.000091552734, 0.046325684, -0.0071487427, 0.0033416748, 0.043792725, 0.04071045, 0.06213379, -0.03427124, 0.0058784485, 0.013465881, -0.02357483, -0.01499176, -0.020965576, -0.031188965, 0.04119873, 0.033050537, 0.03074646, 0.015686035, 0.016311646, 0.007461548, 0.08343506, 0.0014133453, 0.02305603, -0.022567749, 0.0236969, 0.0051460266, 0.06512451, -0.007751465, 0.04940796, -0.0055618286, 0.031402588, 0.053985596, 0.00894928, -0.010032654, 0.00065755844, -0.002035141, 0.028259277, 0.01763916, -0.033111572, 0.01878357, -0.022064209, -0.009925842, -0.009284973, 0.01461792, -0.009597778, 0.011756897, 0.028198242, -0.033996582, 0.014953613, -0.014785767, -0.02558899, -0.018814087, -0.035888672, 0.026931763, 0.025894165, -0.038970947, -0.0051841736, 0.033416748, 0.020462036, -0.016555786, 0.013572693, -0.009979248, 0.01776123, 0.008049011, -0.05770874, -0.010475159, 0.043670654, 0.017974854, -0.022369385, 0.016937256, 0.0077171326, -0.0044288635, 0.08514404, 0.024169922, -0.021820068, 0.011016846, 0.0010681152, 0.015266418, -0.006210327, -0.0025081635, 0.0118637085, -0.0050315857, 0.0181427, 0.004699707, -0.01234436, 0.014213562, -0.07495117, 0.029220581, -0.00044870377, 0.0037822723, -0.04537964, -0.06530762, -0.026382446, -0.024337769, -0.060028076, -0.050109863, 0.07287598, -0.015274048, -0.023727417, -0.016677856, -0.02218628, -0.026245117, -0.004962921, -0.028930664, -0.02923584, 0.02911377, 0.049560547, 0.024291992, -0.027770996, -0.013084412, 0.01966858, 0.035339355, 0.010498047, 0.013763428, -0.0031833649, -0.019897461, 0.020492554, 0.014404297, -0.007572174, -0.017868042, -0.009880066, -0.017242432, -0.009811401, 0.0093307495, -0.028778076, 0.016311646, 0.012008667, -0.024734497, -0.00409317, 0.021881104, 0.029830933, -0.04373169, 0.011123657, 0.037231445, -0.004386902, 0.00019657612, 0.06628418, 0.00067806244, 0.035827637, -0.016693115, -0.004966736, -0.08355713, -0.019851685, -0.006351471, 0.027755737, 0.070129395, -0.025482178, 0.008415222, -0.049743652, -0.011009216, -0.008407593, -0.0018177032, 0.014923096, -0.04147339, -0.057037354, -0.010597229, -0.005050659, 0.016342163, -0.014923096, 0.022109985, 0.08355713, -0.01399231, -0.027175903, -0.011657715, 0.023376465, 0.013717651, -0.03753662, -0.0657959, -0.0440979, -0.004421234, 0.033050537, -0.0014591217, -0.009597778, 0.00031089783, -0.09057617, 0.016815186, 0.008117676, 0.015380859, -0.005832672, 0.00043463707, -0.06500244, -0.024642944, -0.038238525, -0.013587952, 0.022445679, 0.08026123, -0.0129852295, -0.03326416, 0.039276123, -0.049865723, 0.017028809, 0.0037651062, -0.0848999, 0.039855957, -0.049865723, -0.00030899048, -0.0070228577, 0.031082153, -0.049224854, -0.006000519, 0.026901245, 0.041381836, 0.022537231, -0.024108887, -0.011833191, 0.00844574, 0.008033752, -0.016464233, -0.022415161, -0.019561768, -0.003376007, 0.032958984, -0.035888672, 0.005207062, -0.021621704, 0.0042037964, -0.025619507, -0.0104599, -0.019485474, 0.01701355, -0.02293396, -0.028366089, -0.013191223, -0.030914307, -0.03591919, 0.001698494, -0.024108887, 0.008903503, -0.020050049, 0.008399963, 0.0007452965, 0.023895264, 0.0007429123, 0.042022705, 0.03390503, -0.055419922, 0.014892578, -0.041290283, -0.0670166, 0.048919678, 0.003419876, 0.01084137, 0.016036987, -0.012954712, -0.04067993, 0.022583008, -0.033447266, 0.014259338, -0.022384644, -0.019012451, -0.0006685257, -0.06048584, -0.011108398, 0.012527466, 0.023223877, -0.005420685, -0.00068473816, -0.013092041, 0.03778076, 0.007724762, -0.00067281723, 0.020355225, -0.02029419, 0.027572632, 0.025726318, -0.014274597, -0.044921875, -0.049072266, 0.04043579, -0.028137207, -0.028442383, 0.034240723, 0.0025310516, -0.029434204, -0.00497818, -0.06512451, -0.051239014, 0.040222168, 0.020217896, 0.0033168793, 0.0037631989, -0.005302429, -0.028060913, 0.0028743744, 0.015167236, -0.0184021, 0.017974854, -0.02218628, -0.049713135, 0.023269653, -0.036346436, 0.05126953, -0.011451721, -0.002691269, -0.004722595, 0.017105103, 0.01209259, 0.006816864, -0.014884949, 0.051452637, 0.042266846, -0.0015459061, -0.04446411, 0.0033683777, 0.01348114, -0.04031372, 0.011314392, -0.02507019, 0.046142578, 0.072143555, -0.0028648376, 0.06518555, 0.01247406, -0.003583908, 0.0048103333, -0.017074585, 0.00071048737, 0.010826111, -0.026489258, -0.019195557, 0.0024356842, -0.02003479, -0.002450943, 0.025756836, -0.019851685, -0.037750244, 0.012138367, 0.024261475, -0.031982422, -0.022079468, -0.034820557, -0.041290283, -0.021331787, -0.00009447336, -0.034179688, 0.028579712, -0.0011529922, -0.012771606, -0.010101318, 0.0036411285, 0.0060272217, 0.020584106, -0.035369873, -0.05126953, -0.0020599365, -0.034332275, -0.07159424, -0.059448242, -0.056488037, -0.0058670044, -0.004989624, 0.013252258, -0.04296875, 0.014579773, 0.023162842, 0.0970459, 0.07635498, -0.003736496, -0.10241699, 0.020889282, -0.018600464, -0.013832092, -0.0024967194, -0.0043182373, -0.030471802, -0.028152466, 0.053588867, -0.01486969, 0.013290405, -0.044525146, -0.013885498, -0.029006958, 0.0262146, -0.024887085, -0.008163452, -0.0028762817, 0.010467529, 0.007797241, 0.0036563873, -0.045318604, 0.0010995865, -0.010246277, 0.010810852, -0.003376007, 0.020507812, 0.020080566, 0.024230957, -0.0041770935, -0.020599365, 0.047821045, 0.0003490448, -0.0184021, 0.007511139, 0.032836914, -0.05682373, -0.041137695, 0.0023651123, -0.014793396, 0.027328491, -0.01574707, 0.018722534, -0.006175995, 0.006416321, 0.05014038, -0.0014820099, 0.020370483, 0.059509277, 0.017959595, -0.09588623, -0.072143555, -0.0335083, 0.08905029, -0.07165527, -0.033172607, -0.010475159, -0.016494751, 0.0029277802, 0.029586792, 0.034057617, -0.0032596588, 0.015159607, -0.001408577, 0.014877319, -0.0058174133, -0.054229736, 0.013748169, -0.057434082, 0.021835327, 0.0053863525, -0.010406494, -0.03744507, 0.0013980865, -0.02319336, 0.0066184998, 0.0032100677, -0.019515991, 0.0093307495, 0.05340576, 0.010520935, 0.028045654, 0.0060310364, 0.01902771, 0.037628174, 0.0053215027, 0.01727295, -0.004432678, -0.0028972626, -0.0065574646, -0.0019893646, -0.0076789856, 0.033447266, 0.031280518, 0.010475159, 0.02166748, 0.04660034, -0.0574646, 0.004119873, -0.019699097, 0.01222229, 0.031921387, -0.047607422, 0.01626587, -0.011268616, -0.028640747, -0.012939453, -0.08496094, -0.070007324, -0.009529114, -0.0793457, -0.060668945, 0.04248047, -0.039093018, -0.052642822, -0.019989014, 0.084106445, 0.0068588257, -0.012008667, -0.006679535, -0.002632141, -0.03213501, 0.02331543, 0.0016126633, -0.054779053, -0.0024261475, 0.0018997192, 0.025115967, 0.023483276, 0.0119018555, -0.032104492, -0.0023860931, -0.0036258698, -0.03652954, -0.003276825, 0.014099121, 0.0038318634, -0.00014615059, 0.013015747, 0.0076522827, 0.0015525818, -0.04537964, 0.0037460327, 0.0032634735, -0.008354187, 0.024871826, 0.0000705719, 0.01777649, 0.010673523, 0.022476196, 0.035949707, -0.0023899078, 0.006034851, -0.0309906, -0.0064315796, 0.0063438416, -0.0024738312, 0.0008792877, -0.00919342, -0.0009045601, 0.024917603, 0.0035381317, 0.0022563934, 0.036315918, 0.024841309, 0.0152282715, 0.015174866, 0.0131073, 0.052124023, -0.010513306, -0.03491211, -0.02935791, -0.009765625, -0.04574585, 0.074035645, 0.011604309, -0.02468872, -0.023361206, -0.06628418, -0.02279663, 0.004360199, 0.042877197, 0.006023407, 0.03829956, -0.047332764, 0.00630188, -0.009712219, -0.0020217896, -0.05014038, 0.02696228, -0.015472412, -0.031082153, 0.013793945, -0.023071289, -0.010818481, 0.0036678314, 0.020812988, 0.010528564, -0.017181396, 0.02961731, -0.023727417, -0.0052757263, -0.009399414, 0.0030441284, 0.05606079, -0.011528015, 0.016082764, 0.02746582, -0.0231781, 0.03704834, 0.011749268, 0.051879883, 0.017745972, -0.03050232, -0.0062942505, 0.031585693, -0.022949219, -0.044769287, 0.026992798, -0.042510986, 0.023223877, -0.032196045, -0.0132369995, -0.094177246, 0.016311646, 0.02180481, 0.009025574, 0.0034923553, 0.01184845, 0.00920105, 0.008476257, 0.026443481, -0.009780884, 0.026824951, -0.012741089, -0.0034694672, -0.02041626, -0.010101318, 0.04638672, 0.03967285, 0.004169464, 0.0053749084, -0.032684326, -0.0074043274, 0.022628784, 0.0020713806, 0.009254456, 0.018432617, 0.0004386902, -0.00749588, 0.03515625, -0.00057411194, 0.03225708, 0.040771484, 0.025543213, -0.057250977, 0.016815186, 0.0024261475, 0.016723633, -0.007881165, -0.004711151, 0.043762207, -0.04534912, 0.022537231, -0.006591797, -0.023101807, -0.026275635, 0.05633545, 0.023666382, -0.005569458, 0.013465881, 0.022109985, 0.020217896, 0.0209198, 0.05380249, -0.012924194, -0.017059326, -0.0008254051, 0.00919342, 0.034576416, 0.0793457, 0.020690918, 0.0051574707, 0.022476196, 0.007926941, -0.0007619858, 0.057434082, 0.0054244995, 0.020889282, -0.03552246, 0.047973633, -0.00018501282, -0.03060913, 0.011352539, 0.03768921, -0.057861328, 0.022064209, 0.026016235, 0.08807373, 0.05581665, 0.07611084, -0.0016117096, 0.008895874, 0.025375366, -0.01838684, 0.05722046, -0.005142212, -0.027359009, 0.017364502, -0.029129028, -0.01763916, 0.013191223, -0.04006958, 0.017211914, -0.0053482056, 0.021438599, -0.038604736, -0.017807007, 0.033355713, -0.0385437, -0.0044021606, -0.025894165, -0.06097412, 0.004459381, -0.013442993, 0.040130615, 0.0079193115, -0.012413025, 0.03326416, 0.057800293, 0.0008945465, 0.041931152, -0.029373169, -0.036956787, 0.038085938, -0.001367569, 0.05630493, -0.011909485, -0.042175293, -0.0552063, 0.0073547363, 0.05557251, 0.02331543, -0.042297363, 0.057861328, -0.042236328, -0.00053691864, -0.0009469986, -0.0021686554, -0.02456665, -0.008605957, -0.04446411, 0.020553589, -0.034301758, -0.021377563, 0.017486572, -0.019378662, -0.070373535, -0.009300232, -0.021408081, 0.026550293, 0.03274536, -0.034088135, 0.014564514, 0.006931305, -0.021499634, 0.02558899, 0.023895264, 0.057281494, -0.022827148, -0.030914307, 0.0132369995, 0.006374359, 0.020507812, -0.0692749, -0.05493164, -0.025299072, 0.10534668, -0.008117676, 0.039154053, -0.024139404, 0.0021152496, 0.017807007, 0.06365967, 0.0052452087, -0.025054932, 0.017608643, 0.021881104, 0.020904541, 0.018508911, -0.037384033, 0.035217285, 0.0045204163, -0.03656006, -0.0021972656, -0.0073394775, 0.013969421, 0.006439209, -0.0021877289, 0.044036865, -0.032562256, 0.014190674, 0.01411438, 0.01159668, 0.0005207062, 0.0029354095, -0.036132812, -0.0016784668, -0.022750854, 0.027542114, -0.00014770031, -0.0770874, 0.062683105, 0.036224365, 0.023498535, 0.00579834, 0.008270264, -0.037109375, -0.029037476, 0.0034599304, 0.017364502, 0.01083374, 0.028427124, -0.011199951, 0.02835083, -0.047698975, -0.0418396, 0.0046310425, -0.013542175, 0.022979736, -0.05255127, 0.045135498, -0.028747559, -0.014411926, -0.01423645, 0.005706787, -0.00198555, -0.011177063, -0.057281494, -0.09197998, 0.0009326935, -0.025970459 ], "summary": [ -0.027938843, 0.0053138733, -0.018737793, 0.030639648, -0.04989624, -0.009613037, -0.05456543, -0.048095703, 0.018066406, 0.02520752, -0.014251709, -0.02154541, 0.03829956, -0.046936035, 0.00008004904, -0.014083862, 0.0017204285, 0.036499023, 0.0035991669, -0.01675415, 0.0027484894, -0.0006227493, -0.0060577393, 0.005455017, 0.030563354, -0.033233643, -0.012199402, 0.016082764, 0.03060913, 0.016845703, 0.02720642, -0.036621094, 0.015716553, -0.035339355, 0.04525757, -0.031158447, -0.030090332, -0.002626419, 0.02432251, -0.03262329, 0.010246277, -0.01663208, 0.04425049, 0.0030460358, -0.02519226, 0.055755615, -0.040039062, -0.023071289, 0.036834717, -0.011451721, 0.003528595, 0.014076233, 0.0075569153, -0.017318726, -0.03741455, -0.03451538, -0.038391113, -0.003408432, 0.006542206, 0.11828613, 0.04067993, 0.008621216, -0.03439331, -0.08691406, -0.004547119, 0.02281189, -0.021057129, -0.011833191, 0.030288696, 0.00299263, -0.022705078, -0.01537323, 0.02607727, -0.043548584, 0.017669678, 0.03439331, 0.010864258, 0.014122009, 0.02684021, -0.031982422, 0.07342529, -0.01184845, 0.02482605, -0.030014038, 0.052520752, -0.017700195, 0.02355957, -0.022842407, -0.017913818, -0.01550293, -0.01675415, -0.007965088, -0.036315918, 0.018630981, -0.005443573, -0.027267456, -0.031173706, -0.009506226, -0.009994507, 0.022598267, 0.015159607, -0.01739502, 0.055541992, -0.044433594, 0.027832031, 0.014312744, -0.020584106, -0.026779175, 0.03201294, 0.0021457672, -0.027572632, 0.049621582, 0.032318115, -0.01927185, -0.014312744, -0.008964539, 0.0058517456, 0.05218506, 0.00630188, 0.030197144, -0.051574707, -0.01838684, -0.020019531, 0.033569336, -0.0019426346, 0.0062561035, 0.021331787, 0.021591187, 0.0009384155, 0.043395996, -0.0028839111, 0.01739502, -0.034301758, -0.015083313, -0.05038452, -0.007850647, -0.021835327, 0.045410156, -0.0037727356, -0.027175903, 0.05279541, 0.0031909943, 0.012428284, 0.029006958, -0.018615723, 0.036499023, 0.041015625, -0.0038700104, -0.060302734, -0.049041748, -0.0058288574, 0.0011959076, 0.017715454, -0.02116394, -0.007659912, -0.06323242, -0.028564453, -0.039276123, 0.04525757, -0.025039673, -0.013900757, 0.0018701553, 0.050750732, 0.018844604, 0.014953613, -0.005340576, -0.048950195, -0.0058937073, 0.029464722, 0.0015668869, -0.0069999695, 0.012535095, 0.029296875, 0.015625, 0.008865356, 0.015045166, -0.031402588, 0.017196655, 0.008384705, -0.016601562, 0.019424438, -0.029006958, 0.04284668, 0.019241333, -0.05432129, -0.008644104, -0.006877899, 0.111572266, 0.07019043, 0.03503418, 0.0017786026, -0.08514404, 0.018722534, -0.00299263, -0.029159546, -0.013549805, 0.0076560974, 0.021072388, -0.027542114, -0.008987427, 0.06878662, 0.010475159, -0.015625, -0.054901123, -0.12145996, 0.0056762695, -0.027862549, 0.028366089, 0.020309448, 0.025878906, 0.0012664795, -0.00031137466, -0.015281677, -0.011413574, -0.04220581, -0.051757812, 0.0076942444, -0.053985596, -0.005580902, -0.061187744, 0.021255493, -0.00044322014, -0.00881958, 0.076538086, -0.043060303, 0.010856628, -0.011306763, 0.035583496, -0.0017547607, 0.030380249, 0.026473999, -0.04727173, -0.016571045, 0.028717041, -0.0012378693, -0.042633057, -0.0003080368, -0.12109375, 0.07562256, 0.06222534, 0.009109497, 0.032226562, -0.0062675476, 0.037384033, 0.0236969, 0.027954102, 0.029342651, -0.016937256, -0.018310547, 0.028030396, 0.017807007, 0.0013742447, 0.026245117, -0.02519226, -0.00091695786, 0.049224854, -0.004535675, -0.04058838, -0.00033068657, 0.009628296, 0.022247314, -0.0035762787, -0.021331787, 0.0037250519, -0.022323608, -0.06842041, -0.02748108, -0.04547119, 0.02748108, -0.05279541, 0.014297485, -0.07196045, 0.0154800415, -0.03845215, -0.04840088, -0.008560181, -0.008605957, 0.028137207, 0.03475952, -0.033081055, -0.0143585205, -0.00793457, -0.03527832, -0.019500732, 0.036193848, -0.009216309, -0.0015945435, 0.0027503967, -0.009681702, 0.040527344, 0.03479004, 0.039093018, 0.0012340546, 0.026153564, -0.015098572, 0.008865356, 0.053741455, -0.01914978, 0.030014038, -0.01499176, 0.051727295, 0.06774902, -0.023452759, 0.020568848, 0.01235199, 0.024871826, 0.01876831, 0.0033454895, -0.0059776306, 0.016693115, -0.0597229, -0.002828598, 0.014724731, 0.027297974, -0.050323486, -0.047424316, -0.022781372, -0.008590698, -0.06311035, -0.012123108, 0.07196045, -0.007843018, -0.005088806, 0.015617371, -0.023544312, -0.017593384, 0.048614502, -0.02798462, -0.026382446, -0.0077590942, 0.015655518, -0.017974854, -0.006778717, 0.028152466, 0.004119873, 0.0026931763, -0.0042037964, 0.012512207, -0.0234375, -0.0132369995, 0.0037002563, -0.039123535, 0.0007824898, -0.018814087, -0.04852295, -0.00070381165, 0.021499634, 0.0015144348, -0.0357666, 0.014533997, 0.009803772, -0.018844604, 0.027191162, 0.04144287, 0.033111572, -0.057617188, -0.023895264, 0.045196533, -0.046936035, -0.020950317, 0.02456665, -0.0010728836, 0.011192322, -0.041381836, -0.011154175, -0.015434265, -0.02293396, -0.0045547485, 0.054504395, 0.031921387, -0.0132751465, 0.023605347, -0.045684814, -0.0028877258, 0.036956787, -0.014312744, 0.061798096, -0.0076065063, -0.030960083, 0.03729248, 0.018966675, 0.03692627, -0.009155273, 0.014190674, 0.09259033, 0.0005187988, -0.040893555, 0.0047683716, 0.016952515, 0.022399902, -0.028198242, -0.049102783, -0.014389038, -0.035095215, -0.0020999908, 0.008338928, -0.03945923, 0.014892578, -0.03250122, 0.0048294067, 0.005531311, 0.03652954, 0.045532227, -0.0018548965, -0.073791504, 0.073913574, -0.06945801, 0.011924744, 0.038269043, -0.0027313232, 0.004749298, -0.035614014, 0.0028495789, -0.040252686, -0.019317627, 0.0029754639, -0.08319092, -0.00093746185, -0.050628662, 0.04888916, 0.012458801, 0.022216797, -0.01398468, 0.032806396, 0.02381897, 0.048675537, -0.029937744, -0.028717041, -0.011390686, 0.041412354, -0.010353088, 0.013664246, -0.01133728, 0.003200531, -0.03970337, 0.03475952, -0.00969696, -0.02520752, 0.026428223, -0.056518555, -0.014839172, -0.02041626, -0.07287598, -0.0042877197, -0.027618408, -0.032989502, -0.01763916, -0.04159546, -0.009674072, 0.03286743, -0.0013446808, 0.015853882, 0.03137207, 0.017913818, -0.013687134, -0.02809143, -0.017288208, 0.025939941, 0.05731201, -0.06921387, -0.021209717, -0.019744873, -0.041259766, -0.00054836273, 0.016418457, 0.045440674, -0.019638062, 0.03491211, -0.03111267, 0.008552551, 0.03756714, -0.05078125, -0.03793335, -0.042877197, 0.023025513, -0.05545044, 0.007637024, -0.00001680851, 0.045959473, -0.026748657, -0.04486084, 0.008071899, -0.05065918, 0.01687622, -0.0048980713, 0.0067367554, -0.013755798, 0.01448822, -0.002796173, 0.02279663, -0.010948181, -0.03274536, 0.036743164, -0.025024414, -0.030654907, 0.026260376, -0.020996094, 0.044708252, -0.014076233, -0.06555176, 0.036590576, -0.012496948, 0.025939941, 0.05596924, -0.0056152344, 0.006011963, -0.020095825, -0.0001283884, 0.007843018, -0.012008667, -0.006614685, -0.005558014, -0.043548584, -0.019180298, -0.014656067, 0.00033020973, 0.033599854, -0.037231445, 0.019104004, 0.008674622, 0.018539429, 0.007091522, 0.014839172, 0.008964539, -0.0035991669, 0.009216309, 0.011474609, 0.019622803, 0.003709793, -0.014450073, 0.04824829, 0.012062073, 0.014343262, 0.035339355, -0.027893066, 0.0112838745, -0.024917603, -0.024505615, -0.015823364, -0.015701294, -0.0027313232, 0.013313293, -0.010223389, 0.014785767, -0.0066337585, -0.01638794, -0.022094727, 0.0056152344, -0.02267456, -0.016525269, 0.007335663, 0.011894226, -0.034057617, -0.039794922, -0.0013475418, -0.08477783, -0.024749756, 0.006515503, 0.0074386597, 0.022125244, 0.020767212, 0.0051612854, 0.028579712, -0.030548096, 0.064697266, 0.024642944, -0.041809082, -0.078125, 0.027038574, -0.029418945, -0.04333496, -0.047210693, -0.06225586, -0.028549194, -0.013946533, 0.01209259, -0.040222168, 0.02545166, -0.0010499954, 0.083984375, 0.06982422, 0.010826111, -0.09460449, 0.029006958, -0.026473999, 0.03878784, -0.015899658, 0.044067383, -0.018737793, 0.014762878, 0.0024929047, -0.012138367, -0.005519867, -0.060943604, -0.02659607, 0.0043678284, -0.01713562, 0.028793335, 0.016601562, 0.0035629272, 0.025253296, -0.008804321, 0.009094238, -0.016494751, -0.02255249, -0.036010742, -0.03564453, 0.034973145, -0.0071105957, 0.04727173, 0.008132935, -0.025772095, 0.017593384, 0.0072784424, 0.029205322, 0.012786865, -0.009437561, 0.013458252, 0.0044136047, 0.011672974, 0.03463745, -0.012123108, 0.01638794, 0.041503906, -0.010894775, 0.007881165, 0.001408577, 0.012794495, -0.024230957, 0.010055542, 0.03302002, -0.0035438538, -0.05532837, -0.06262207, -0.032409668, 0.05392456, -0.027435303, -0.02381897, -0.00091552734, -0.016738892, 0.009483337, -0.0032234192, -0.0077438354, -0.026473999, 0.025741577, -0.020401001, -0.008468628, 0.027114868, -0.012130737, 0.023239136, -0.028945923, 0.019607544, 0.019088745, -0.04486084, 0.0018386841, -0.0032634735, -0.018447876, -0.016708374, 0.005847931, -0.027679443, -0.015960693, 0.036834717, -0.024246216, 0.04345703, 0.08013916, -0.0057907104, -0.027297974, 0.00856781, -0.0048599243, 0.0340271, -0.017959595, -0.074279785, -0.0028934479, -0.001958847, 0.011672974, 0.04699707, 0.0017967224, 0.026412964, 0.014305115, -0.011581421, -0.016586304, -0.03845215, 0.029968262, 0.0050849915, -0.007484436, 0.027526855, 0.0096588135, -0.027053833, -0.019607544, -0.026824951, -0.04928589, -0.015007019, -0.04058838, -0.029434204, 0.008682251, -0.029663086, -0.06451416, 0.003824234, 0.035491943, 0.017852783, 0.016357422, -0.012611389, -0.037506104, -0.05557251, 0.005252838, -0.01838684, -0.014343262, -0.028961182, 0.019378662, 0.019073486, -0.029037476, 0.006286621, 0.02078247, -0.005783081, -0.017654419, -0.036010742, -0.004714966, 0.03237915, 0.004386902, 0.024597168, -0.001490593, 0.00056791306, 0.0039596558, -0.030456543, 0.011299133, -0.030441284, 0.008735657, 0.0007658005, -0.0119018555, 0.005138397, 0.033935547, -0.0048828125, 0.01335144, 0.01335144, -0.0030536652, -0.042541504, 0.009048462, -0.01600647, 0.015701294, -0.04837036, -0.0006713867, 0.00024485588, 0.021057129, 0.011291504, -0.020812988, 0.010551453, 0.004753113, -0.0011615753, 0.013244629, -0.017730713, 0.024505615, 0.019134521, -0.024215698, -0.004928589, 0.024734497, -0.03665161, -0.012611389, 0.016113281, -0.0032196045, -0.0037975311, -0.030731201, 0.006587982, 0.0051651, 0.010368347, 0.012771606, 0.051513672, -0.0036182404, -0.01625061, -0.0023956299, -0.018859863, -0.02633667, 0.03149414, -0.033081055, -0.05899048, 0.045440674, -0.011566162, -0.04333496, 0.024841309, 0.0017604828, 0.025131226, -0.01663208, 0.05609131, 0.0064735413, -0.0073928833, 0.01108551, -0.001405716, 0.05883789, -0.03527832, 0.010978699, 0.004547119, 0.04434204, 0.01675415, 0.032440186, 0.024108887, 0.00712204, -0.007331848, 0.013702393, 0.016952515, 0.009979248, -0.029663086, 0.071899414, -0.011528015, -0.013336182, -0.06732178, -0.056854248, -0.045166016, 0.047027588, -0.020385742, -0.022369385, 0.015426636, -0.0088272095, -0.013442993, 0.011367798, -0.022247314, 0.019454956, -0.0138549805, -0.0041999817, -0.012298584, 0.020126343, -0.010826111, 0.00024223328, 0.037719727, -0.010665894, 0.017440796, -0.048034668, 0.009567261, 0.023071289, -0.017868042, -0.033996582, -0.018173218, 0.020095825, -0.038208008, 0.004383087, 0.021865845, 0.039215088, -0.004966736, -0.016189575, -0.0033454895, 0.018676758, -0.013442993, 0.030853271, 0.013908386, 0.008575439, 0.011558533, 0.007762909, -0.01826477, 0.014015198, -0.015899658, 0.014091492, 0.056915283, 0.0289917, -0.0040397644, -0.0024032593, 0.02178955, 0.020370483, 0.023849487, 0.05709839, -0.015419006, 0.010688782, -0.03955078, -0.04385376, 0.06719971, 0.07928467, 0.03616333, 0.00042295456, 0.04598999, -0.0051002502, 0.014533997, 0.009689331, 0.026947021, 0.02180481, 0.03302002, 0.043426514, 0.0032997131, -0.026397705, 0.024658203, 0.033599854, -0.050201416, 0.020263672, 0.0051651, 0.05444336, 0.074157715, 0.03262329, -0.056427002, 0.018112183, 0.099487305, -0.028259277, 0.013832092, -0.02268982, 0.0104522705, -0.013374329, -0.03326416, 0.02558899, -0.014091492, 0.031677246, 0.034942627, -0.048583984, 0.019515991, -0.04498291, 0.03225708, -0.027359009, -0.02909851, -0.023757935, -0.024963379, -0.029159546, 0.014945984, 0.027770996, 0.006111145, 0.030334473, -0.0038833618, -0.023269653, 0.027191162, 0.03213501, 0.02142334, -0.029006958, 0.031173706, 0.041107178, 0.044128418, 0.08660889, 0.022521973, -0.03842163, -0.0031032562, 0.020401001, 0.01914978, -0.011695862, -0.03451538, 0.043060303, 0.009750366, 0.03274536, -0.010498047, 0.0034656525, -0.003583908, -0.03778076, -0.07421875, 0.042419434, -0.045776367, 0.007083893, 0.01625061, -0.017471313, -0.064331055, -0.0032749176, -0.029464722, 0.02381897, 0.027252197, -0.024337769, 0.015510559, 0.035949707, -0.031402588, 0.025482178, 0.0060920715, 0.018981934, -0.03326416, -0.0023326874, -0.001449585, -0.026885986, 0.011154175, -0.06085205, -0.10430908, -0.039733887, 0.062561035, 0.026245117, 0.0027332306, -0.029525757, -0.008468628, 0.00044298172, 0.046051025, 0.006061554, -0.022140503, 0.074523926, 0.054534912, 0.027450562, 0.036102295, -0.025024414, 0.025054932, -0.021835327, -0.02293396, -0.03604126, 0.0043029785, 0.04559326, -0.033843994, 0.015930176, 0.0028076172, -0.056243896, -0.048797607, 0.041625977, 0.025314331, -0.02923584, -0.022903442, -0.035064697, -0.006679535, -0.02168274, -0.06994629, -0.051849365, -0.027191162, 0.03955078, 0.03326416, -0.0017309189, -0.024414062, 0.0036525726, 0.022827148, -0.013305664, 0.015266418, 0.01826477, 0.03289795, 0.021621704, -0.033477783, 0.018997192, -0.060272217, -0.031707764, -0.015472412, -0.008880615, 0.010040283, -0.045318604, 0.031433105, 0.0149002075, -0.03857422, -0.009086609, 0.068359375, -0.028656006, -0.03237915, 0.00020575523, -0.018478394, 0.031311035, 0.014190674 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07469v1
InCA: Rethinking In-Car Conversational System Assessment Leveraging Large Language Models
Ken E. Friedl, Abbas Goher Khan, Soumya Ranjan Sahoo, Md Rashad Al Hasan Rony, Jana Germies, Christian Süß
cs.CL, cs.AI
The assessment of advanced generative large language models (LLMs) poses a significant challenge, given their heightened complexity in recent developments. Furthermore, evaluating the performance of LLM-based applications in various industries, as indicated by Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), is a complex undertaking. This task necessitates a profound understanding of industry use cases and the anticipated system behavior. Within the context of the automotive industry, existing evaluation metrics prove inadequate for assessing in-car conversational question answering (ConvQA) systems. The unique demands of these systems, where answers may relate to driver or car safety and are confined within the car domain, highlight the limitations of current metrics. To address these challenges, this paper introduces a set of KPIs tailored for evaluating the performance of in-car ConvQA systems, along with datasets specifically designed for these KPIs. A preliminary and comprehensive empirical evaluation substantiates the efficacy of our proposed approach. Furthermore, we investigate the impact of employing varied personas in prompts and found that it enhances the model's capacity to simulate diverse viewpoints in assessments, mirroring how individuals with different backgrounds perceive a topic.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07469v1
2023-11-13T17:02:06
2023-11-13T17:02:06
{ "title": [ -0.036590576, -0.021850586, -0.037597656, -0.009689331, -0.024612427, -0.020431519, -0.04220581, -0.003408432, -0.005756378, 0.024719238, -0.03463745, 0.00843811, -0.0033740997, -0.020751953, -0.041931152, -0.015792847, -0.025970459, 0.011131287, -0.0592041, -0.045684814, -0.011512756, -0.08258057, 0.024642944, 0.012664795, 0.034240723, -0.031921387, -0.103759766, 0.016586304, -0.021392822, -0.022644043, -0.0046157837, 0.031341553, 0.013084412, 0.055419922, -0.04864502, 0.010520935, -0.024841309, 0.04309082, 0.020858765, 0.016357422, 0.034454346, -0.023422241, -0.02708435, 0.0067863464, -0.035095215, 0.009483337, -0.031234741, -0.012641907, 0.009864807, -0.0021305084, 0.0065727234, 0.032440186, 0.017410278, 0.015159607, -0.015213013, -0.025253296, -0.03842163, 0.027694702, 0.026260376, 0.0770874, 0.027786255, -0.008720398, -0.012687683, -0.054107666, -0.03302002, -0.0027580261, -0.03845215, 0.02796936, 0.06378174, -0.015991211, -0.051696777, 0.010749817, -0.00039672852, -0.016204834, -0.03845215, 0.03427124, 0.022094727, 0.0107803345, 0.03591919, -0.02458191, 0.031219482, 0.004348755, 0.05529785, -0.025238037, 0.0096588135, -0.030685425, -0.005897522, -0.014823914, -0.009185791, -0.060180664, -0.0051078796, -0.017166138, -0.043121338, 0.014404297, 0.0034313202, -0.045715332, 0.018341064, 0.04486084, 0.0016393661, -0.03857422, -0.02760315, 0.016921997, -0.06439209, -0.015174866, 0.032470703, 0.035125732, -0.038024902, -0.01612854, 0.03164673, 0.03164673, -0.016815186, 0.06304932, -0.010871887, -0.025314331, 0.011383057, 0.020996094, -0.01285553, 0.026000977, 0.005241394, 0.023605347, -0.0015888214, -0.014762878, 0.0010128021, 0.0052490234, 0.04269409, 0.008972168, -0.04638672, 0.026657104, -0.032806396, 0.036834717, 0.021270752, 0.042236328, -0.10827637, -0.064819336, -0.07348633, 0.032562256, -0.008483887, -0.003479004, -0.03945923, 0.03503418, -0.005279541, -0.027526855, 0.02494812, -0.026443481, -0.0013141632, 0.013710022, 0.054595947, 0.007507324, -0.038970947, -0.072631836, 0.022903442, -0.0039405823, 0.019317627, -0.010810852, -0.06173706, -0.015258789, -0.0982666, -0.004714966, 0.008766174, -0.009727478, 0.0043678284, 0.0068359375, 0.0050849915, 0.02394104, 0.013557434, -0.012290955, 0.008651733, 0.01335907, 0.0121536255, 0.028747559, -0.023391724, 0.012763977, -0.01737976, -0.011169434, -0.00818634, -0.0045928955, -0.012763977, 0.007293701, 0.033416748, -0.058410645, -0.023590088, -0.030303955, 0.026367188, 0.024993896, -0.07836914, 0.011390686, 0.0049858093, 0.04031372, 0.04067993, 0.008422852, 0.004470825, 0.022415161, -0.061065674, -0.00705719, -0.041778564, -0.024902344, 0.007774353, 0.022277832, 0.0014076233, 0.0043678284, -0.019592285, 0.008964539, -0.040649414, 0.0015821457, -0.0869751, -0.032287598, -0.034484863, 0.03729248, 0.011047363, 0.06225586, 0.032806396, 0.025299072, -0.049346924, 0.0390625, -0.015975952, -0.04788208, 0.0078125, -0.011024475, -0.014564514, -0.03982544, -0.0019292831, -0.013298035, 0.008110046, 0.06549072, -0.040802002, 0.026046753, -0.004776001, 0.017105103, 0.007286072, 0.041015625, 0.105285645, -0.05795288, 0.041503906, 0.06329346, -0.00026512146, -0.017623901, -0.0011997223, -0.028076172, 0.03503418, -0.0017681122, 0.00006222725, -0.039978027, 0.012207031, 0.061309814, 0.0066871643, -0.024993896, 0.014823914, 0.032562256, 0.0027713776, 0.0034599304, 0.055267334, 0.0043144226, 0.036193848, 0.004714966, 0.018432617, 0.026473999, -0.027252197, -0.017364502, -0.0061454773, -0.019378662, 0.023544312, -0.043182373, -0.006149292, -0.010910034, -0.03353882, 0.007888794, -0.03793335, 0.0035820007, -0.008377075, 0.004611969, 0.032989502, -0.010406494, 0.017028809, -0.020370483, -0.024169922, 0.016921997, -0.02368164, 0.0140686035, 0.025665283, -0.041137695, -0.012634277, 0.010696411, 0.040405273, -0.01701355, 0.023880005, 0.006412506, 0.016464233, -0.039367676, -0.046783447, -0.011054993, 0.037872314, 0.012245178, -0.015930176, -0.0017757416, -0.01108551, -0.0059432983, 0.08880615, 0.08081055, -0.03970337, 0.04824829, -0.045288086, 0.0055770874, 0.01864624, -0.024017334, 0.024002075, 0.0064353943, 0.03869629, 0.003900528, -0.010261536, 0.03225708, -0.062408447, 0.019622803, 0.012779236, -0.00541687, -0.03768921, -0.04751587, 0.0058517456, -0.021133423, -0.02709961, 0.00078964233, 0.09118652, -0.046142578, 0.00762558, -0.009254456, -0.022521973, -0.037719727, -0.012840271, -0.027618408, 0.007461548, 0.037475586, 0.027267456, 0.023147583, -0.064208984, -0.047821045, -0.0038318634, 0.019073486, -0.0043029785, -0.014297485, -0.029830933, -0.003944397, -0.005874634, -0.017288208, 0.010360718, -0.019866943, -0.0054397583, -0.049804688, 0.03552246, -0.0059051514, -0.047332764, 0.014045715, 0.013687134, -0.010971069, 0.014205933, 0.02734375, 0.074401855, -0.07281494, -0.07159424, 0.04345703, -0.0008969307, -0.011161804, 0.066467285, 0.04272461, 0.04031372, -0.08123779, -0.048187256, -0.057861328, -0.025512695, -0.019607544, -0.023788452, -0.014022827, -0.055389404, -0.034057617, -0.016113281, -0.013725281, 0.02166748, 0.024673462, 0.008178711, -0.03579712, -0.036010742, -0.01713562, -0.01939392, 0.018112183, -0.023223877, 0.03768921, 0.07745361, 0.011909485, 0.018188477, 0.006450653, 0.029312134, -0.008087158, -0.015930176, -0.023605347, -0.06329346, 0.019699097, 0.00605011, -0.004875183, -0.030715942, -0.008483887, -0.12670898, 0.01977539, 0.05630493, -0.006904602, -0.023513794, 0.022369385, -0.049041748, 0.023269653, 0.0104522705, -0.0036449432, 0.037200928, -0.0039787292, 0.01637268, -0.011871338, 0.012878418, -0.03643799, -0.0050468445, -0.040527344, -0.100097656, 0.02609253, -0.01625061, -0.020812988, -0.016815186, 0.0118637085, -0.04257202, 0.0022182465, 0.0022277832, 0.0491333, 0.015571594, 0.0023097992, -0.02520752, -0.020751953, 0.0135650635, -0.03616333, -0.008399963, -0.010398865, 0.009086609, 0.012077332, -0.010169983, 0.011604309, 0.012931824, -0.0113220215, -0.015457153, 0.02027893, 0.01512146, 0.024810791, 0.012374878, -0.03842163, 0.022460938, -0.010002136, -0.04421997, -0.024017334, -0.026397705, 0.015975952, -0.036346436, 0.02418518, 0.0013074875, 0.04309082, -0.021072388, 0.025024414, 0.0036010742, -0.054656982, -0.008148193, -0.041259766, -0.024230957, 0.0062217712, 0.037902832, 0.016906738, 0.000385046, -0.0010948181, -0.030532837, 0.016082764, 0.011924744, -0.010139465, -0.015289307, -0.018569946, -0.012390137, -0.003835678, 0.019165039, -0.012634277, 0.030883789, -0.014045715, -0.052215576, 0.03366089, -0.06121826, -0.07269287, -0.02571106, 0.005832672, -0.0635376, -0.022781372, 0.0028820038, 0.02166748, -0.010765076, 0.013961792, 0.031173706, 0.0058250427, -0.01524353, 0.013046265, 0.010848999, -0.05368042, -0.014755249, -0.0881958, -0.024169922, 0.085510254, -0.0099487305, 0.025665283, 0.05557251, -0.018569946, -0.018127441, -0.0007662773, 0.02720642, 0.04196167, 0.033935547, 0.015365601, -0.03692627, 0.020324707, -0.030914307, 0.011558533, 0.042510986, -0.03451538, 0.014450073, 0.022842407, 0.0056762695, 0.04437256, -0.03125, 0.06939697, -0.019119263, 0.0006175041, -0.093566895, 0.012023926, -0.015960693, -0.040618896, 0.024414062, -0.012786865, 0.008071899, 0.038482666, -0.00042533875, 0.07904053, 0.005256653, 0.03024292, 0.032226562, -0.024230957, -0.0209198, -0.011940002, 0.021606445, -0.006843567, -0.00894928, 0.040100098, -0.011665344, 0.061279297, -0.013435364, 0.005268097, -0.006412506, 0.015731812, -0.033966064, 0.0023021698, -0.054351807, -0.06323242, -0.041290283, 0.012298584, -0.0004427433, 0.050628662, 0.049865723, 0.0015172958, -0.025177002, -0.0027484894, 0.080322266, 0.0012197495, -0.018707275, -0.08886719, 0.024810791, -0.01927185, -0.05899048, -0.04373169, -0.023788452, -0.013626099, 0.034729004, -0.008293152, -0.010093689, 0.022918701, 0.020248413, 0.047668457, 0.040130615, 0.0044021606, -0.034332275, 0.045318604, -0.020385742, -0.036224365, 0.03427124, 0.0037937164, 0.0070114136, -0.02281189, 0.018005371, -0.027877808, -0.0033798218, -0.013999939, 0.020324707, -0.008972168, 0.04776001, -0.036132812, 0.0036735535, 0.0047950745, 0.034729004, -0.005756378, 0.0018901825, -0.041137695, -0.0054855347, -0.027069092, 0.03010559, 0.00066900253, 0.011199951, 0.014221191, 0.03262329, 0.016281128, -0.000872612, 0.011550903, -0.005645752, -0.0107421875, -0.045440674, 0.05783081, -0.018234253, -0.03286743, -0.017105103, -0.016342163, 0.013587952, -0.061584473, 0.055480957, -0.042633057, -0.023605347, -0.02418518, -0.0017137527, 0.03225708, -0.02305603, 0.029663086, -0.031555176, -0.041412354, 0.023483276, 0.027709961, -0.016448975, 0.0019874573, 0.004966736, 0.01965332, 0.0115737915, 0.041259766, 0.0021629333, -0.011924744, 0.014839172, -0.008583069, -0.023910522, -0.027114868, -0.027252197, -0.02180481, 0.014526367, 0.004989624, -0.025268555, 0.017318726, -0.04748535, 0.01096344, -0.026412964, -0.03353882, 0.02545166, -0.048583984, 0.01651001, 0.06304932, -0.015731812, 0.03945923, -0.006072998, 0.011505127, 0.019958496, 0.06149292, -0.008422852, 0.0079574585, 0.04147339, -0.035064697, 0.036315918, 0.0028877258, 0.025878906, -0.004058838, 0.03475952, -0.00014948845, 0.02293396, -0.06896973, 0.009460449, -0.0008482933, 0.008659363, 0.02178955, -0.06341553, 0.015670776, 0.0033817291, -0.00730896, 0.011230469, -0.022399902, -0.02810669, -0.0058784485, -0.020843506, -0.041168213, 0.016418457, -0.030807495, -0.046722412, -0.024520874, 0.0146102905, -0.012001038, 0.006629944, 0.017791748, -0.0020046234, -0.006248474, 0.034606934, 0.011772156, -0.013137817, -0.006034851, 0.004299164, -0.014579773, 0.025344849, 0.06982422, -0.0748291, -0.018829346, -0.00217247, -0.044952393, -0.056396484, 0.0069847107, 0.0060920715, 0.007499695, -0.01171875, -0.060394287, -0.0110321045, 0.0028514862, 0.026763916, -0.01928711, -0.009887695, 0.0025634766, -0.00920105, 0.010810852, 0.016952515, 0.041412354, 0.004501343, 0.01184082, 0.01739502, -0.036468506, 0.034088135, -0.010238647, 0.023284912, -0.002040863, -0.049713135, 0.013160706, 0.018722534, -0.012260437, -0.032196045, 0.0496521, 0.025466919, -0.03387451, 0.004814148, 0.0020885468, 0.055725098, -0.047698975, -0.01777649, -0.023376465, 0.0035076141, -0.021957397, 0.05255127, 0.0033512115, -0.013961792, -0.035064697, -0.057769775, -0.04144287, 0.0016508102, 0.03414917, 0.008415222, 0.032226562, -0.007858276, 0.00944519, -0.028274536, 0.0067443848, -0.050476074, 0.02078247, -0.008026123, -0.0033187866, -0.005531311, 0.022720337, 0.00026106834, -0.03756714, 0.0146102905, 0.036193848, 0.000015676022, 0.029220581, -0.053100586, -0.017715454, -0.037353516, -0.026321411, 0.046722412, 0.009483337, -0.015205383, 0.053253174, -0.010276794, 0.045288086, 0.0024108887, 0.050933838, 0.054718018, 0.033996582, -0.009880066, 0.0048103333, 0.00012397766, -0.043670654, -0.016799927, -0.037506104, -0.006690979, -0.025222778, -0.00009512901, -0.0793457, 0.017028809, 0.009529114, 0.03250122, 0.0024318695, 0.014587402, 0.022003174, -0.014030457, 0.0236969, -0.03274536, 0.036743164, -0.021636963, -0.009819031, -0.003944397, 0.00085639954, 0.026153564, 0.033233643, -0.0026741028, 0.005706787, -0.018630981, -0.0284729, 0.0076026917, 0.01184845, 0.0068969727, -0.008850098, -0.010902405, -0.028503418, 0.03201294, -0.005306244, 0.02709961, 0.062805176, 0.027923584, 0.0079193115, -0.022399902, -0.0065574646, -0.022842407, -0.0446167, 0.029144287, 0.039978027, -0.06378174, 0.0446167, -0.015205383, -0.041900635, -0.007041931, 0.031951904, 0.028640747, -0.038513184, 0.005115509, -0.012046814, 0.028411865, -0.014778137, 0.0029678345, -0.032409668, 0.008300781, 0.03579712, 0.02305603, -0.011634827, 0.023620605, 0.0051231384, 0.03186035, 0.013076782, -0.02720642, 0.020385742, -0.02305603, 0.02406311, 0.04397583, 0.0016565323, 0.030029297, -0.016464233, -0.036468506, -0.0075798035, 0.018508911, -0.052124023, -0.016113281, 0.027130127, 0.025619507, -0.014953613, 0.024490356, -0.017822266, -0.021987915, 0.019851685, -0.023498535, 0.013748169, 0.022720337, -0.01878357, 0.012535095, -0.042755127, -0.03668213, 0.0058288574, -0.036376953, 0.033843994, -0.040771484, -0.026031494, -0.05545044, 0.055389404, 0.00422287, -0.053741455, -0.03656006, -0.047943115, -0.01763916, -0.0059890747, 0.0038394928, -0.042999268, -0.007133484, -0.01902771, 0.008148193, -0.0022029877, 0.012779236, 0.03213501, -0.033203125, -0.058166504, 0.028945923, -0.006690979, 0.066101074, -0.031982422, -0.022613525, -0.022583008, 0.0154418945, 0.026168823, 0.011512756, -0.032928467, 0.033996582, -0.013252258, -0.02709961, 0.022994995, 0.029205322, 0.00712204, -0.0054740906, 0.024932861, -0.008201599, -0.022262573, 0.00356102, 0.05029297, -0.025039673, -0.031951904, -0.0034751892, -0.033172607, 0.032989502, -0.01247406, 0.011207581, 0.016983032, 0.014556885, -0.011047363, -0.008705139, 0.023773193, 0.032043457, 0.032684326, -0.04901123, 0.0021896362, 0.010955811, 0.032165527, -0.046325684, -0.068115234, 0.01398468, 0.04537964, 0.013687134, 0.023651123, 0.039978027, 0.00013232231, -0.028305054, -0.028747559, -0.0071029663, -0.0049324036, 0.018203735, 0.041046143, 0.03277588, 0.04562378, -0.006793976, 0.02798462, 0.0050468445, -0.018463135, 0.01739502, -0.004348755, -0.0021648407, 0.02709961, -0.007949829, 0.028869629, -0.040222168, 0.017547607, -0.04925537, 0.019729614, -0.013542175, 0.018096924, -0.01638794, 0.025741577, -0.011260986, 0.04135132, -0.018997192, -0.043151855, 0.037322998, 0.05505371, 0.0027828217, 0.030731201, -0.023513794, -0.0046958923, -0.00957489, -0.013587952, -0.0034503937, 0.016494751, 0.0126571655, -0.046905518, 0.003156662, -0.084472656, -0.04498291, -0.037475586, -0.041259766, 0.021728516, -0.028182983, 0.032104492, -0.006832123, -0.01725769, 0.007511139, 0.028076172, -0.003227234, -0.012054443, -0.03982544, 0.011253357, 0.026397705, -0.014312744 ], "summary": [ -0.02772522, -0.050598145, -0.028289795, 0.027191162, -0.051452637, -0.027175903, -0.017791748, -0.0021743774, 0.021728516, 0.016952515, -0.064575195, 0.012954712, -0.013710022, -0.011444092, -0.01979065, -0.045013428, -0.022766113, 0.02508545, -0.027145386, -0.040649414, 0.021575928, -0.06866455, -0.012878418, 0.020019531, 0.0362854, -0.020706177, -0.0090789795, 0.01663208, -0.008331299, 0.008850098, 0.008781433, -0.01158905, -0.03060913, 0.016036987, 0.046020508, 0.04623413, -0.011581421, 0.02557373, 0.072387695, 0.0038452148, 0.04284668, -0.018585205, 0.053344727, 0.016403198, -0.016998291, 0.037872314, -0.025390625, -0.03274536, 0.026809692, -0.011894226, 0.011627197, 0.042633057, 0.009986877, -0.0064582825, -0.030685425, 0.00079631805, -0.023254395, -0.030258179, 0.027023315, 0.09649658, 0.027877808, -0.020706177, -0.013648987, -0.081726074, -0.0047073364, 0.017486572, 0.024749756, -0.00089359283, 0.05621338, -0.0075263977, -0.03665161, 0.029144287, 0.0082473755, -0.02897644, 0.0058898926, 0.024627686, 0.007965088, 0.0057411194, 0.015380859, 0.012710571, 0.030029297, 0.02684021, 0.030593872, -0.0076293945, 0.015167236, 0.009399414, -0.00680542, -0.04949951, 0.012771606, -0.061676025, -0.001288414, -0.004020691, -0.0541687, 0.0026130676, 0.022216797, -0.076171875, 0.01625061, 0.0140686035, -0.022888184, -0.046875, 0.0541687, -0.029754639, 0.0050315857, -0.020507812, 0.035491943, 0.07336426, -0.020126343, -0.015426636, 0.03463745, 0.000081181526, 0.005218506, 0.0077171326, -0.007041931, -0.039245605, 0.007484436, 0.023223877, -0.0032691956, 0.03945923, -0.000021517277, 0.018875122, -0.004550934, 0.011024475, -0.0061683655, 0.035369873, -0.0049324036, 0.030807495, -0.0018434525, -0.019897461, -0.05029297, 0.03967285, 0.012908936, 0.025375366, -0.04321289, -0.016479492, -0.050628662, -0.010406494, 0.012825012, -0.012413025, -0.016220093, 0.0056610107, -0.005519867, -0.028274536, -0.008308411, -0.009384155, 0.0005617142, 0.045959473, 0.02381897, 0.012359619, -0.012435913, -0.06384277, 0.028930664, -0.013961792, 0.04067993, -0.044158936, -0.042755127, -0.058624268, -0.07116699, -0.004486084, 0.012626648, -0.010009766, 0.00008916855, 0.010650635, 0.032165527, 0.04586792, 0.014457703, -0.021774292, -0.011299133, -0.00983429, -0.0066490173, 0.02684021, -0.029800415, 0.031677246, -0.016281128, -0.015571594, -0.013450623, -0.013282776, -0.035614014, 0.028137207, 0.038513184, -0.049713135, -0.025726318, -0.042175293, 0.06768799, 0.007621765, -0.040008545, 0.019973755, 0.00016915798, 0.056488037, 0.009750366, 0.0038013458, 0.0021038055, 0.0021133423, -0.0090408325, -0.009284973, -0.011566162, -0.024597168, -0.020309448, 0.0033569336, -0.014472961, -0.007434845, 0.06921387, 0.0067977905, -0.016220093, -0.043548584, -0.12841797, -0.0019760132, -0.027633667, 0.02746582, -0.0236969, 0.040863037, 0.055480957, 0.024627686, -0.07867432, 0.111572266, 0.029403687, -0.04650879, 0.026443481, -0.046691895, -0.011978149, -0.07519531, -0.0013113022, 0.039001465, -0.037628174, 0.0692749, -0.08459473, 0.03225708, -0.01146698, 0.048919678, 0.024307251, 0.0259552, 0.12915039, -0.08862305, 0.059906006, 0.070129395, -0.0057144165, 0.004634857, 0.032073975, -0.0390625, 0.011405945, 0.020446777, 0.01612854, -0.012336731, -0.0155181885, 0.05984497, -0.00730896, 0.006893158, 0.029190063, 0.023757935, -0.0077552795, 0.041381836, -0.011108398, -0.0075416565, 0.012107849, -0.028076172, -0.029312134, 0.029663086, -0.0010890961, -0.00054073334, 0.013366699, -0.010971069, -0.0032291412, -0.055755615, -0.0028591156, -0.020080566, -0.01940918, -0.021820068, -0.015151978, -0.0017690659, -0.0069351196, -0.025177002, 0.027572632, 0.003873825, -0.0013341904, -0.042816162, -0.053344727, -0.012008667, -0.028152466, 0.043792725, 0.0236969, -0.039733887, -0.014251709, -0.0037326813, 0.026290894, -0.011550903, 0.016281128, 0.027954102, 0.02507019, -0.015579224, -0.0112838745, 0.05154419, 0.052246094, -0.004322052, -0.010551453, -0.006664276, -0.011116028, -0.012863159, 0.06524658, 0.041778564, -0.004989624, 0.0027656555, 0.023620605, 0.03253174, -0.025482178, 0.016174316, 0.010131836, 0.008583069, 0.003194809, 0.025894165, 0.019882202, 0.0032615662, -0.018463135, 0.03062439, 0.022445679, 0.023284912, -0.015304565, -0.037017822, -0.0059776306, 0.019012451, -0.021835327, 0.029769897, 0.11395264, -0.042999268, 0.01512146, -0.022354126, -0.03125, -0.060302734, 0.028381348, -0.015266418, 0.027755737, -0.023620605, -0.009422302, -0.033172607, -0.025360107, -0.03100586, 0.013694763, -0.013412476, 0.0036029816, 0.047668457, 0.003250122, -0.030517578, 0.022872925, -0.07421875, -0.022918701, 0.03817749, -0.020996094, 0.003435135, 0.027038574, -0.00025129318, -0.021881104, 0.036865234, -0.009880066, -0.025680542, 0.031021118, 0.0357666, 0.054138184, -0.060180664, -0.06896973, 0.010383606, -0.0178833, -0.055114746, 0.040405273, 0.035247803, 0.03237915, -0.080322266, -0.04623413, -0.028076172, -0.009292603, -0.0063934326, -0.027694702, -0.015129089, -0.008285522, -0.017974854, -0.035003662, -0.010688782, -0.0045700073, 0.032806396, 0.08532715, -0.008094788, -0.022460938, 0.03994751, 0.011741638, 0.053619385, -0.035614014, 0.051208496, 0.048095703, 0.023345947, 0.0115356445, -0.01838684, 0.033569336, -0.009460449, 0.005039215, 0.0016002655, -0.0044441223, -0.022491455, 0.024276733, 0.018569946, -0.07086182, 0.0023555756, -0.034484863, -0.00093889236, 0.07293701, 0.025253296, 0.045166016, 0.011703491, -0.048095703, 0.06750488, -0.015151978, 0.02470398, 0.022888184, -0.04083252, 0.026870728, -0.05758667, -0.004886627, -0.056121826, -0.010185242, -0.046813965, -0.033294678, 0.016830444, -0.013397217, 0.0093307495, -0.029052734, 0.05239868, -0.038482666, -0.0002579689, -0.028305054, 0.03488159, -0.011207581, 0.03945923, -0.04425049, -0.01940918, -0.011054993, -0.031433105, -0.030578613, -0.010978699, 0.004673004, 0.021499634, 0.0026168823, -0.03704834, 0.0047569275, -0.031402588, -0.000063955784, -0.0012016296, -0.032562256, 0.026229858, 0.009902954, -0.025894165, -0.009674072, -0.0423584, -0.031829834, 0.005554199, -0.026931763, -0.0043563843, -0.0129852295, 0.045532227, -0.015808105, 0.070373535, -0.059417725, 0.045684814, 0.04257202, -0.04522705, 0.0014419556, -0.024002075, -0.017333984, 0.016952515, 0.034210205, 0.052581787, -0.032440186, 0.03253174, -0.014457703, -0.012580872, 0.05517578, -0.0552063, -0.023468018, -0.040374756, -0.016555786, -0.02243042, 0.050720215, -0.020233154, 0.0826416, -0.038116455, -0.046173096, 0.02748108, -0.06109619, -0.08355713, -0.008644104, -0.005252838, -0.06768799, -0.051879883, -0.011581421, 0.041046143, 0.0059928894, 0.018295288, 0.05871582, -0.009864807, -0.0054969788, 0.017913818, -0.008979797, -0.002626419, -0.03778076, -0.07922363, -0.011199951, -0.0074920654, 0.015052795, 0.05770874, 0.0033893585, -0.0058403015, 0.015457153, 0.004924774, 0.006061554, 0.013374329, 0.02961731, -0.0116119385, -0.075927734, -0.024032593, -0.022644043, 0.029083252, -0.0036678314, -0.05026245, 0.02444458, -0.0017671585, 0.038116455, 0.058410645, -0.016113281, 0.038238525, -0.015930176, -0.007171631, -0.051849365, 0.0104599, 0.006164551, -0.04260254, 0.020736694, -0.024902344, -0.032409668, 0.034362793, 0.034057617, 0.046722412, -0.018554688, 0.016708374, 0.030197144, -0.013542175, -0.025909424, -0.020233154, 0.023529053, 0.0231781, -0.013549805, 0.037109375, -0.05895996, 0.03277588, -0.02885437, 0.020736694, -0.0051078796, -0.010345459, 0.020523071, -0.018936157, -0.015701294, -0.032592773, -0.02293396, -0.0014657974, 0.013381958, 0.04348755, 0.0069274902, -0.004261017, 0.013397217, 0.003982544, 0.08862305, 0.026046753, -0.03552246, -0.09802246, 0.017211914, -0.027450562, -0.007232666, -0.014953613, 0.013137817, -0.017364502, 0.014709473, -0.012519836, -0.0016336441, 0.013305664, 0.004966736, -0.0028476715, -0.009849548, 0.03289795, 0.023773193, 0.022140503, 0.00001591444, -0.034179688, 0.01687622, 0.0041999817, -0.011756897, -0.013885498, 0.031433105, -0.031921387, -0.022277832, -0.021087646, 0.013870239, 0.009185791, -0.0017738342, -0.005393982, 0.035888672, 0.010910034, 0.0569458, -0.008483887, 0.013496399, 0.009231567, -0.07141113, -0.032318115, -0.0034618378, 0.07141113, -0.020751953, -0.0050621033, 0.02053833, -0.007987976, 0.013786316, 0.0022583008, -0.024505615, 0.015617371, -0.0206604, 0.06561279, 0.053131104, -0.008659363, 0.021362305, 0.023376465, 0.00043010712, -0.014671326, 0.021499634, -0.008651733, -0.029800415, -0.013305664, -0.0077285767, 0.018035889, -0.003068924, 0.0070877075, -0.04135132, -0.027740479, -0.020736694, 0.02911377, -0.010726929, -0.035827637, 0.00059604645, 0.011451721, 0.008674622, 0.011306763, -0.05001831, 0.0037517548, 0.0068588257, 0.0033569336, -0.006164551, -0.033203125, 0.013542175, -0.054901123, 0.02168274, 0.007598877, -0.00073862076, -0.006504059, 0.014503479, -0.02017212, -0.018844604, -0.027114868, 0.015365601, -0.03768921, -0.034057617, -0.0036239624, -0.056793213, 0.023101807, 0.0025138855, -0.011436462, -0.02166748, 0.041503906, -0.048736572, 0.011436462, 0.021392822, -0.05166626, 0.041656494, -0.002948761, 0.017074585, 0.040893555, 0.008728027, 0.0073051453, 0.021347046, -0.010437012, -0.015586853, -0.030136108, 0.032440186, 0.0061531067, -0.017456055, 0.036895752, -0.022506714, -0.026733398, 0.013244629, 0.033996582, -0.025787354, -0.021499634, 0.018630981, -0.012817383, -0.023727417, -0.0070152283, -0.019363403, 0.01966858, -0.01725769, -0.022918701, -0.00057792664, 0.032409668, 0.0061454773, 0.01360321, 0.00009137392, -0.019317627, 0.011436462, -0.030273438, 0.01979065, 0.016906738, -0.03933716, 0.019317627, -0.070129395, -0.00491333, -0.040618896, -0.010559082, -0.057006836, -0.051483154, -0.009689331, 0.05899048, -0.0007581711, -0.016967773, -0.0006184578, -0.009277344, 0.022033691, -0.012069702, -0.029342651, 0.028808594, -0.01940918, -0.023727417, 0.01826477, -0.0018501282, 0.009529114, 0.0017108917, -0.0015277863, -0.00022697449, 0.022216797, 0.022033691, 0.031799316, -0.04095459, -0.07299805, 0.00027942657, 0.03225708, 0.0028152466, -0.013328552, 0.01637268, 0.00022101402, -0.010955811, 0.023223877, -0.0037136078, 0.044830322, -0.0011405945, -0.004081726, 0.007385254, 0.020584106, -0.005126953, 0.051757812, 0.005138397, -0.0013723373, -0.030792236, -0.046569824, -0.009010315, 0.023406982, 0.030395508, 0.023925781, 0.06933594, -0.0034065247, 0.037994385, 0.013031006, -0.006713867, -0.03640747, -0.0059661865, -0.020202637, -0.018539429, 0.055725098, 0.04321289, -0.03024292, 0.0060310364, -0.004207611, 0.040008545, 0.008743286, 0.06085205, -0.036193848, -0.029937744, -0.021728516, 0.00075912476, 0.02178955, 0.03125, -0.03540039, 0.010620117, 0.018692017, 0.05105591, 0.0151901245, -0.002998352, 0.0046195984, 0.00032496452, 0.005970001, 0.008628845, 0.024765015, -0.008346558, 0.020996094, 0.014839172, -0.051239014, -0.048858643, -0.04385376, -0.04171753, 0.058807373, -0.031463623, -0.003408432, 0.0010128021, 0.009513855, -0.0072669983, -0.00083732605, -0.025604248, -0.009262085, -0.0019025803, -0.02507019, -0.014762878, 0.023727417, 0.030761719, 0.0018939972, 0.032287598, -0.008384705, 0.044525146, 0.008079529, -0.0104599, 0.02519226, -0.022628784, 0.0020503998, -0.013938904, 0.008087158, -0.023849487, 0.026443481, 0.02230835, 0.054260254, 0.015281677, -0.03857422, 0.095825195, -0.04559326, -0.037384033, 0.022521973, -0.013870239, 0.04437256, 0.042144775, -0.027511597, 0.009643555, 0.00042319298, -0.044158936, 0.0063285828, 0.028427124, 0.042755127, 0.012825012, 0.0105896, -0.016464233, 0.020050049, -0.003850937, 0.0025081635, -0.044647217, 0.016036987, -0.0018205643, -0.025756836, 0.019470215, -0.021087646, -0.0028591156, 0.038909912, 0.053131104, 0.017242432, 0.026901245, -0.005039215, 0.0519104, 0.035888672, 0.013938904, 0.02355957, -0.040527344, -0.028518677, 0.014572144, 0.0096588135, -0.031219482, 0.0054512024, 0.02696228, 0.023910522, 0.059265137, 0.041015625, -0.040893555, 0.020019531, 0.07324219, -0.031585693, 0.011054993, 0.0014848709, 0.0055236816, -0.017120361, -0.016433716, 0.003200531, -0.011291504, 0.027526855, -0.0009918213, -0.04244995, -0.01878357, -0.046966553, 0.053344727, -0.04788208, -0.014030457, -0.0072898865, -0.06341553, -0.0002605915, 0.006095886, 0.018203735, -0.03894043, 0.024551392, -0.03729248, -0.018615723, 0.00868988, -0.0033454895, 0.039031982, -0.011245728, -0.06112671, 0.036132812, -0.012687683, 0.077819824, -0.025650024, -0.037841797, 0.0012130737, 0.0024318695, 0.0070381165, -0.010719299, -0.016983032, 0.047058105, -0.0076179504, -0.013832092, 0.026321411, 0.048736572, -0.0033397675, -0.025680542, 0.03665161, -0.008361816, -0.010139465, 0.031204224, 0.025527954, -0.000487566, -0.058563232, -0.004432678, -0.004119873, -0.004055023, -0.032165527, 0.0096206665, 0.05429077, -0.0035514832, 0.0018882751, -0.05014038, 0.010536194, -0.015472412, 0.036102295, -0.037017822, 0.006336212, 0.005180359, 0.035949707, -0.014801025, -0.017303467, 0.01260376, 0.047912598, 0.014404297, -0.0069503784, 0.010231018, -0.016937256, -0.029876709, -0.02229309, -0.018600464, 0.020462036, 0.044555664, 0.059173584, 0.047576904, 0.0056114197, -0.03387451, 0.02017212, -0.006752014, -0.021209717, 0.0017347336, -0.04663086, 0.01675415, -0.021987915, -0.03086853, -0.00053977966, -0.041107178, 0.02911377, -0.02078247, 0.001449585, -0.008979797, -0.005783081, -0.0128479, 0.011459351, -0.021316528, -0.007007599, -0.009979248, -0.0050239563, 0.0074043274, -0.0053596497, 0.023132324, -0.005859375, 0.014762878, -0.0014638901, -0.011955261, 0.007118225, 0.011383057, 0.02684021, 0.026672363, -0.043670654, -0.009811401, -0.05770874, -0.0309906, 0.0023860931, -0.0017471313, -0.024978638, -0.0074157715, 0.040618896, 0.055633545, -0.021408081, 0.013832092, 0.040740967, -0.0087509155, 0.0006427765, 0.003917694, 0.03491211, 0.0074424744, 0.0031147003 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07468v1
Are We Falling in a Middle-Intelligence Trap? An Analysis and Mitigation of the Reversal Curse
Ang Lv, Kaiyi Zhang, Shufang Xie, Quan Tu, Yuhan Chen, Ji-Rong Wen, Rui Yan
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Recent studies have highlighted a phenomenon in large language models (LLMs) known as "the reversal curse," in which the order of knowledge entities in the training data biases the models' comprehension. For example, if a model is trained on sentences where entity A consistently appears before entity B, it can respond to queries about A by providing B. However, it may encounter confusion when presented with questions concerning B. We contend that the reversal curse is partially a result of specific model training objectives, particularly evident in the prevalent use of the next-token prediction within most causal language models. For the next-token prediction, models solely focus on a token's preceding context, resulting in a restricted comprehension of the input. In contrast, we illustrate that the GLM, trained using the autoregressive blank infilling objective where tokens to be predicted have access to the entire context, exhibits better resilience against the reversal curse. We propose a novel training method, BIdirectional Casual language modeling Optimization (BICO), designed to mitigate the reversal curse when fine-tuning pretrained causal language models on new data. BICO modifies the causal attention mechanism to function bidirectionally and employs a mask denoising optimization. In the task designed to assess the reversal curse, our approach improves Llama's accuracy from the original 0% to around 70%. We hope that more attention can be focused on exploring and addressing these inherent weaknesses of the current LLMs, in order to achieve a higher level of intelligence.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07468v1
2023-11-13T17:01:12
2023-11-13T17:01:12
{ "title": [ -0.001964569, -0.006755829, -0.014305115, 0.00598526, 0.015090942, -0.027709961, 0.052490234, -0.052978516, -0.04562378, 0.045135498, -0.013717651, 0.007797241, -0.0077552795, -0.00137043, -0.06011963, -0.01713562, -0.0053138733, 0.025039673, -0.0055160522, -0.014556885, -0.020401001, -0.03149414, 0.023712158, -0.012542725, 0.03125, -0.053527832, -0.069885254, 0.00095415115, -0.010246277, -0.022033691, -0.002609253, 0.015403748, 0.0657959, 0.008285522, -0.0065307617, 0.021911621, -0.056365967, 0.024276733, -0.007881165, 0.024215698, -0.005126953, 0.0020809174, -0.027694702, -0.04562378, -0.059387207, 0.012863159, -0.07299805, 0.01676941, -0.033111572, 0.039794922, 0.024551392, -0.008285522, 0.0020008087, 0.057281494, -0.0014209747, -0.037841797, -0.00957489, 0.005050659, 0.01701355, 0.06604004, 0.021530151, -0.007881165, 0.008529663, -0.016571045, -0.031433105, -0.01940918, -0.018753052, 0.03286743, 0.05630493, 0.0008845329, 0.005847931, 0.01096344, 0.007205963, 0.01600647, -0.036865234, -0.020248413, 0.042816162, 0.016098022, 0.039916992, -0.024093628, -0.043670654, -0.03225708, 0.0034732819, -0.013999939, -0.01576233, -0.02746582, -0.036743164, 0.01625061, -0.02709961, -0.009796143, -0.008132935, -0.005710602, 0.0070724487, 0.006252289, -0.020187378, -0.014144897, 0.001408577, 0.048797607, -0.0068244934, -0.04159546, -0.03086853, 0.020217896, -0.08856201, -0.009483337, 0.012275696, 0.010513306, -0.012184143, -0.03656006, 0.013168335, 0.037994385, -0.018920898, 0.046813965, -0.004497528, -0.017303467, 0.009796143, 0.022155762, -0.015792847, 0.033325195, 0.0079422, 0.05239868, 0.005088806, -0.015014648, 0.025543213, 0.016677856, 0.00920105, 0.004825592, -0.03781128, -0.014785767, -0.016464233, 0.05407715, 0.01675415, 0.017700195, -0.07727051, -0.05657959, -0.052581787, 0.026428223, 0.014328003, -0.0033187866, -0.012626648, 0.019699097, -0.0016241074, -0.04550171, -0.008918762, 0.0042266846, -0.005470276, -0.005004883, 0.047210693, -0.009101868, -0.02973938, -0.011917114, -0.034729004, -0.010063171, 0.02999878, -0.015823364, -0.026107788, -0.014213562, -0.13244629, 0.0013608932, 0.024307251, 0.025299072, 0.005001068, 0.006465912, -0.030670166, 0.002861023, 0.04815674, -0.005580902, -0.0011138916, 0.03878784, 0.012611389, 0.050231934, -0.03326416, -0.004470825, -0.024612427, -0.010284424, -0.016281128, 0.0050735474, 0.031707764, -0.008049011, 0.019104004, -0.016448975, -0.003955841, -0.0076026917, -0.015686035, 0.059631348, -0.06365967, 0.019546509, -0.008117676, 0.022232056, 0.034118652, -0.0028362274, -0.01676941, 0.04925537, -0.032684326, -0.05404663, -0.021377563, -0.014892578, 0.03060913, 0.014694214, 0.0015287399, 0.006629944, 0.0058898926, 0.033813477, -0.04812622, -0.003168106, -0.048919678, -0.021209717, -0.0126571655, 0.020309448, 0.0040740967, 0.04321289, 0.03050232, -0.01638794, -0.018295288, 0.03842163, -0.01576233, -0.067871094, 0.011459351, -0.008811951, 0.007987976, 0.0029697418, -0.012168884, -0.007522583, -0.021240234, -0.0007419586, 0.0052948, -0.0027332306, 0.009384155, -0.034362793, 0.06097412, 0.035247803, 0.08428955, -0.05532837, 0.013000488, -0.013076782, -0.0211792, -0.01058197, -0.008560181, 0.003452301, 0.0010232925, 0.016067505, -0.0024108887, -0.032287598, -0.025878906, 0.020095825, 0.006702423, -0.04486084, 0.00095176697, 0.02078247, 0.013771057, -0.018829346, 0.018463135, -0.0063285828, 0.08117676, 0.029464722, -0.0057907104, 0.06072998, -0.01701355, -0.015686035, 0.01651001, 0.011558533, -0.002494812, 0.024383545, 0.005104065, 0.019699097, -0.043121338, -0.012908936, -0.030197144, -0.002090454, -0.0079956055, 0.0065078735, 0.046051025, -0.0070877075, -0.0062446594, -0.012054443, 0.0041046143, -0.0004518032, -0.046539307, 0.042266846, 0.004146576, -0.03555298, 0.00096321106, 0.033996582, 0.0060920715, -0.011940002, 0.022476196, 0.014137268, -0.00945282, -0.02330017, -0.023757935, -0.02645874, 0.039794922, 0.022750854, -0.009460449, -0.010353088, 0.020309448, -0.01890564, 0.07421875, 0.06262207, -0.0184021, 0.03375244, -0.061706543, 0.017608643, 0.01725769, -0.027938843, 0.0043029785, 0.018875122, 0.017364502, 0.012893677, -0.02104187, -0.0049705505, -0.03527832, 0.012626648, -0.010353088, -0.05822754, 0.02859497, -0.02029419, 0.02128601, -0.022323608, 0.0056762695, 0.03390503, 0.02645874, -0.028137207, -0.017837524, -0.007949829, 0.005428314, -0.016281128, -0.0206604, -0.015350342, -0.0056381226, 0.009819031, 0.056518555, -0.02331543, -0.07183838, -0.08465576, 0.019805908, 0.016403198, -0.008026123, 0.00032520294, -0.015075684, -0.021469116, 0.0063476562, -0.031433105, 0.006893158, -0.032196045, 0.0020256042, -0.050720215, 0.002445221, 0.02961731, -0.03970337, -0.027770996, 0.057006836, -0.036102295, -0.040771484, -0.011001587, 0.04949951, 0.0040283203, -0.0043144226, 0.021606445, 0.05596924, -0.01890564, 0.036895752, 0.011100769, -0.002117157, -0.044525146, 0.009727478, -0.05319214, -0.02696228, -0.026367188, 0.014480591, 0.05899048, -0.088134766, 0.0041389465, -0.021911621, 0.00066947937, 0.032409668, 0.032958984, -0.0027046204, -0.039154053, -0.012161255, -0.023986816, -0.026260376, 0.012374878, -0.030319214, 0.03237915, 0.0579834, -0.01776123, -0.08532715, -0.030426025, 0.031234741, 0.036834717, 0.012252808, -0.01789856, -0.080200195, -0.000043153763, 0.0048446655, 0.012275696, 0.012107849, 0.008911133, -0.096191406, -0.015586853, 0.038085938, -0.023345947, -0.018585205, 0.0053482056, -0.043792725, 0.013710022, -0.0070724487, -0.012283325, 0.03640747, 0.05001831, 0.007118225, 0.04345703, 0.0005021095, 0.016998291, -0.011299133, -0.01966858, -0.101989746, 0.014091492, -0.021759033, -0.017562866, 0.00063848495, -0.030197144, -0.040649414, 0.010620117, -0.029937744, 0.03955078, 0.041809082, 0.022384644, 0.034484863, -0.023757935, 0.009613037, -0.03488159, -0.0008649826, -0.00016891956, -0.014427185, -0.010543823, -0.020553589, 0.031158447, 0.018676758, -0.014556885, -0.023895264, -0.022216797, -0.00089263916, 0.018692017, -0.0011425018, -0.02848816, -0.014183044, -0.0069885254, -0.028457642, -0.004371643, -0.014381409, -0.006416321, -0.05340576, 0.022964478, -0.026901245, 0.05731201, 0.032684326, 0.003982544, -0.031036377, 0.0034542084, 0.0060691833, -0.009719849, -0.062072754, -0.008392334, 0.01083374, -0.012809753, 0.072753906, -0.020965576, -0.014762878, 0.012260437, -0.033203125, 0.012161255, 0.0135269165, 0.014076233, -0.0024471283, 0.017608643, -0.009292603, 0.0042686462, -0.041259766, 0.002275467, 0.014175415, 0.003540039, 0.026443481, -0.06793213, -0.007911682, 0.020202637, -0.11785889, -0.058898926, 0.0040512085, -0.06121826, -0.038635254, -0.038909912, 0.025970459, -0.059906006, -0.019821167, -0.028274536, -0.03527832, 0.055541992, 0.022140503, -0.075805664, 0.032104492, 0.035369873, -0.02848816, -0.007133484, 0.022994995, 0.0064086914, -0.0063972473, -0.044952393, 0.002506256, -0.04196167, 0.04736328, -0.02482605, -0.0058898926, 0.04071045, -0.03857422, -0.00089263916, 0.022277832, 0.0029087067, -0.018310547, 0.010803223, 0.010398865, 0.004562378, -0.014282227, 0.030960083, 0.050476074, 0.024841309, -0.08905029, 0.027420044, -0.033813477, -0.021270752, 0.005130768, 0.0317688, 0.03302002, 0.016403198, -0.003080368, 0.04257202, -0.01222229, 0.019317627, 0.042938232, -0.020553589, -0.025924683, -0.008705139, 0.030532837, 0.022506714, 0.013023376, -0.0026378632, 0.0023498535, 0.049926758, -0.032562256, 0.0015039444, -0.007461548, 0.002773285, -0.06390381, 0.0010499954, -0.055633545, -0.059387207, -0.05267334, 0.029403687, -0.0006966591, 0.014427185, 0.016098022, -0.015655518, -0.009559631, -0.009300232, 0.030578613, 0.010314941, 0.012466431, -0.036987305, -0.008178711, -0.004497528, -0.079711914, -0.04324341, -0.007965088, 0.0035896301, -0.0013275146, -0.027694702, 0.021560669, 0.017562866, 0.016616821, 0.013336182, 0.033599854, -0.013069153, -0.014060974, 0.02268982, -0.030334473, -0.038269043, 0.03717041, -0.0040893555, 0.007461548, 0.0022602081, 0.046173096, -0.05404663, -0.011909485, -0.02041626, 0.02230835, -0.018295288, 0.07098389, -0.00541687, 0.032196045, 0.027908325, -0.0110321045, 0.02960205, 0.010681152, -0.017944336, -0.052337646, 0.04421997, 0.0065307617, 0.001821518, -0.02619934, 0.014701843, 0.023880005, -0.012619019, 0.017364502, 0.008117676, 0.015975952, 0.019058228, 0.01210022, 0.0044517517, -0.049072266, -0.04876709, -0.0018262863, -0.014022827, 0.045013428, -0.049041748, 0.061431885, -0.024169922, -0.02619934, 0.014923096, -0.011070251, 0.012710571, -0.001964569, 0.020187378, -0.06768799, -0.036346436, -0.015106201, 0.04498291, -0.052764893, -0.008155823, -0.0044059753, -0.004951477, 0.042236328, 0.06561279, 0.027542114, -0.041534424, 0.02897644, -0.0015802383, -0.01486969, -0.03491211, -0.060333252, -0.002916336, -0.014694214, 0.027374268, -0.06402588, 0.054138184, -0.055358887, -0.0047569275, 0.0047454834, -0.024841309, 0.01499939, -0.09112549, -0.01777649, 0.028930664, 0.014923096, 0.029876709, 0.028244019, 0.025131226, 0.028671265, 0.05392456, 0.010375977, 0.02130127, 0.008842468, -0.011650085, -0.0418396, -0.0138168335, 0.028839111, -0.01171875, 0.039733887, 0.016082764, -0.0096588135, -0.07788086, 0.040740967, 0.019241333, -0.01928711, 0.003868103, -0.05218506, 0.030883789, -0.025390625, -0.034698486, 0.010314941, 0.0054359436, -0.01966858, 0.007259369, -0.011047363, -0.008148193, 0.002866745, -0.004081726, -0.024841309, -0.07385254, 0.03100586, -0.004814148, 0.031585693, -0.015365601, 0.00085639954, -0.048339844, 0.027648926, 0.025512695, -0.04812622, -0.0146484375, -0.0127334595, 0.0037174225, 0.046203613, 0.046295166, -0.03173828, -0.004497528, -0.02722168, -0.044128418, -0.01335907, 0.0061836243, 0.004055023, 0.014915466, -0.013465881, -0.04248047, -0.011253357, -0.007827759, 0.020202637, -0.002866745, -0.026290894, 0.028320312, -0.008544922, -0.017990112, 0.00037908554, 0.06604004, -0.017471313, -0.0034618378, 0.013763428, -0.03479004, 0.020645142, -0.029632568, -0.007411957, -0.013717651, -0.05291748, 0.01285553, 0.0126571655, 0.018844604, -0.008255005, 0.008293152, 0.033721924, 0.035949707, -0.010177612, 0.0028038025, 0.061676025, -0.04244995, -0.06921387, 0.015541077, -0.0104599, -0.0050354004, 0.05697632, 0.03125, -0.050079346, -0.024673462, -0.044830322, -0.03338623, 0.0026855469, 0.009010315, -0.0046806335, 0.01638794, 0.03591919, 0.04788208, -0.0056915283, -0.016464233, -0.034301758, 0.011077881, 0.0036010742, -0.027694702, 0.02217102, -0.002861023, 0.003004074, -0.018249512, -0.0012216568, 0.031951904, -0.0032024384, 0.033325195, -0.06756592, 0.00026392937, -0.013877869, -0.005256653, 0.043426514, -0.007209778, -0.021713257, 0.028137207, -0.03857422, 0.048034668, 0.021377563, 0.05340576, 0.038848877, 0.03765869, 0.03152466, 0.008636475, 0.0541687, -0.024749756, -0.01234436, -0.027862549, -0.048309326, -0.049591064, -0.018295288, -0.07281494, 0.016098022, -0.007835388, 0.044799805, -0.022720337, 0.02381897, 0.033294678, 0.01751709, 0.04510498, -0.038726807, 0.06768799, 0.041503906, 0.014259338, -0.015342712, -0.02949524, 0.003232956, 0.037200928, -0.011039734, 0.0262146, -0.034118652, -0.01109314, 0.008148193, 0.003194809, -0.0074691772, 0.004840851, -0.0040740967, -0.016357422, -0.007461548, -0.024887085, 0.037628174, 0.042114258, 0.042388916, -0.03378296, 0.0069770813, 0.001666069, -0.018722534, -0.03970337, -0.009246826, 0.04498291, -0.09185791, 0.028060913, -0.025726318, -0.031341553, 0.0041885376, 0.030059814, 0.02406311, -0.043945312, -0.062805176, 0.0032901764, 0.040924072, 0.04058838, 0.018630981, -0.021102905, 0.009017944, 0.0007634163, 0.02558899, 0.03338623, 0.003370285, -0.032073975, 0.040893555, -0.008148193, -0.0032424927, -0.015213013, 0.030181885, -0.04812622, 0.021621704, -0.0013446808, 0.030471802, 0.0021400452, -0.037231445, 0.022613525, 0.0067329407, -0.064575195, -0.0052375793, 0.012649536, 0.042541504, -0.00088071823, 0.05596924, 0.01838684, -0.02720642, -0.0256958, -0.02192688, 0.011810303, 0.08642578, -0.019622803, 0.03060913, -0.044769287, -0.0602417, 0.038116455, -0.040893555, 0.08502197, -0.010673523, -0.016143799, 0.005279541, -0.018035889, 0.076049805, -0.038360596, -0.014884949, -0.014625549, -0.00064468384, -0.0064430237, -0.021194458, -0.044891357, -0.014633179, 0.014320374, 0.035949707, 0.039611816, 0.008392334, -0.02470398, -0.023345947, -0.026977539, 0.017227173, -0.019699097, 0.053344727, -0.03186035, -0.027557373, -0.035125732, 0.013046265, 0.012390137, -0.0020999908, -0.026107788, 0.025756836, -0.02456665, -0.046325684, 0.038879395, 0.023345947, 0.0028076172, 0.056365967, -0.05871582, 0.03604126, -0.0053749084, 0.025619507, 0.023971558, -0.035369873, -0.043884277, 0.0009660721, -0.013938904, 0.034240723, 0.010124207, -0.010040283, 0.011932373, 0.026138306, -0.021881104, -0.03250122, 0.0069503784, 0.039642334, -0.0047798157, -0.06439209, 0.0034923553, 0.039978027, 0.0107803345, -0.04336548, 0.0017995834, 0.041931152, 0.052001953, 0.018112183, 0.049621582, 0.013595581, -0.002161026, -0.025909424, -0.009002686, -0.00004774332, -0.046875, -0.038757324, -0.01348114, 0.03543091, 0.04244995, 0.0058250427, -0.025909424, 0.028259277, 0.0025539398, 0.004924774, 0.019622803, -0.0065574646, 0.009284973, -0.0011482239, 0.02432251, -0.016723633, -0.017547607, -0.030960083, -0.000015377998, 0.0028247833, 0.024765015, -0.024337769, 0.029067993, -0.0062026978, 0.05279541, -0.053741455, -0.0413208, 0.06976318, 0.05935669, -0.002735138, 0.049102783, -0.021453857, 0.021102905, 0.00006586313, 0.0046653748, -0.0002117157, 0.020629883, 0.0068855286, -0.00037431717, 0.0039520264, -0.028137207, -0.057800293, 0.02230835, -0.021881104, 0.03024292, -0.022827148, 0.027999878, -0.021438599, -0.019424438, 0.0059013367, 0.03265381, 0.028320312, -0.024398804, -0.05517578, 0.021209717, 0.07354736, -0.016098022 ], "summary": [ -0.030685425, -0.021896362, -0.009742737, 0.007423401, -0.06738281, -0.0007596016, -0.06921387, -0.02722168, 0.0045280457, 0.059020996, -0.037719727, -0.022827148, 0.07110596, 0.0003848076, -0.022567749, -0.02394104, -0.037719727, 0.060791016, -0.0004775524, -0.03543091, 0.0073509216, -0.061950684, -0.031158447, -0.0496521, 0.029708862, -0.04525757, -0.014328003, -0.0012321472, 0.048461914, 0.0335083, 0.022781372, -0.020019531, 0.02279663, 0.04824829, -0.062316895, -0.025787354, -0.046417236, 0.023025513, -0.026000977, 0.050445557, 0.030807495, -0.009506226, 0.028060913, -0.021362305, -0.014213562, 0.04031372, -0.023986816, -0.031829834, 0.014030457, 0.034851074, -0.0037460327, 0.008071899, -0.01663208, 0.006023407, -0.020095825, -0.015838623, -0.05105591, 0.035125732, 0.014282227, 0.09875488, 0.023147583, 0.023162842, -0.030273438, -0.0692749, 0.0036582947, 0.011772156, -0.02130127, 0.0011081696, 0.049987793, 0.014060974, 0.012367249, -0.002664566, 0.0082092285, -0.06488037, 0.022140503, 0.034820557, -0.0309906, -0.010856628, 0.041656494, -0.014060974, -0.004371643, 0.0070762634, 0.0028381348, -0.032989502, 0.0010023117, -0.017501831, -0.018249512, -0.004764557, 0.016662598, -0.020553589, -0.0061149597, -0.03894043, 0.021240234, 0.040405273, -0.00762558, -0.032226562, 0.01260376, -0.013900757, -0.0070533752, -0.0446167, -0.003353119, -0.001203537, -0.041229248, 0.01890564, 0.02784729, 0.0010690689, -0.04171753, -0.053619385, 0.03933716, 0.020599365, -0.025512695, 0.02470398, 0.023269653, -0.048034668, 0.0000071525574, 0.0073928833, 0.0077934265, 0.049346924, 0.03515625, 0.011291504, -0.04434204, -0.032104492, -0.0020885468, 0.055999756, 0.01852417, 0.03173828, 0.0047187805, 0.03225708, -0.03778076, 0.04486084, 0.0107040405, 0.014213562, -0.05783081, -0.0115737915, -0.046966553, -0.0047912598, -0.0059547424, 0.0040130615, -0.038970947, 0.023086548, -0.006412506, -0.037872314, 0.026443481, -0.014450073, 0.0021743774, 0.020645142, 0.044128418, -0.0030326843, -0.047851562, -0.050994873, 0.031585693, 0.005607605, 0.04736328, -0.050567627, -0.01637268, -0.06976318, -0.056884766, -0.014640808, 0.012588501, -0.017959595, -0.012016296, -0.011116028, 0.012268066, 0.014259338, -0.041992188, 0.023132324, 0.0012512207, -0.019104004, 0.007709503, 0.019760132, -0.005203247, 0.038909912, 0.005264282, -0.02204895, -0.010475159, -0.027435303, 0.000106573105, 0.022445679, 0.020385742, -0.021438599, -0.005355835, -0.025466919, 0.032592773, 0.028671265, -0.036132812, -0.004299164, -0.0017633438, 0.05493164, 0.038513184, 0.014373779, 0.0053634644, -0.025558472, -0.041381836, 0.00095129013, -0.030670166, 0.00299263, 0.034851074, 0.030334473, -0.015037537, -0.018325806, 0.059448242, 0.049438477, -0.040252686, -0.089660645, -0.12939453, -0.016052246, -0.024215698, 0.066345215, 0.01625061, 0.034423828, 0.03527832, 0.02192688, -0.072631836, 0.08288574, -0.015396118, -0.074645996, 0.017181396, 0.0017738342, 0.016540527, -0.021911621, 0.031341553, 0.016296387, 0.007259369, 0.046447754, -0.05331421, -0.0143966675, 0.0053710938, 0.016967773, -0.0027122498, 0.0049476624, 0.07299805, -0.032958984, 0.014015198, -0.021697998, -0.024047852, -0.0017318726, 0.027709961, -0.07879639, 0.024810791, 0.04296875, -0.00085258484, -0.026229858, -0.04727173, 0.03048706, -0.05834961, -0.02243042, 0.0209198, 0.0018625259, -0.006000519, 0.011650085, 0.017562866, -0.018692017, 0.020477295, -0.01146698, 0.018218994, 0.02192688, -0.008964539, -0.09326172, 0.02067566, -0.0026226044, 0.0357666, -0.038848877, -0.0713501, 0.016281128, -0.041259766, -0.060668945, -0.0362854, -0.044189453, 0.015975952, -0.04940796, 0.026916504, -0.03793335, 0.012588501, -0.03137207, -0.052124023, -0.013633728, -0.022384644, 0.03933716, 0.0141067505, -0.029418945, 0.013175964, 0.045288086, 0.019012451, -0.016571045, 0.04168701, 0.0076141357, -0.013687134, -0.020263672, -0.0018491745, 0.02861023, 0.026184082, 0.05569458, 0.011772156, 0.008224487, 0.0054969788, 0.011779785, 0.03829956, -0.00062322617, 0.005622864, -0.014801025, -0.003522873, 0.042144775, -0.003025055, -0.024871826, 0.030715942, -0.01586914, 0.013114929, -0.0032253265, -0.011116028, 0.043304443, -0.09552002, 0.010398865, 0.04006958, 0.070007324, -0.020324707, -0.03451538, -0.0015640259, 0.065979004, 0.006778717, 0.031219482, 0.0713501, -0.011528015, 0.0013132095, 0.04031372, -0.010482788, -0.043395996, 0.07434082, -0.018325806, 0.07348633, -0.016906738, -0.010063171, -0.037506104, -0.070373535, -0.08239746, 0.021484375, -0.013160706, 0.019882202, 0.0031776428, 0.01335907, -0.0025596619, 0.05895996, -0.016555786, -0.005970001, 0.022918701, -0.020263672, -0.0046424866, 0.005405426, 0.011108398, 0.0052452087, 0.006351471, 0.0015459061, -0.024414062, 0.021774292, 0.04989624, 0.03781128, 0.019821167, -0.030166626, 0.03527832, 0.018554688, -0.02861023, -0.016052246, 0.018157959, -0.041107178, -0.05697632, 0.006214142, -0.016311646, -0.030929565, -0.0035362244, 0.03918457, 0.028442383, -0.04611206, 0.02558899, -0.0073623657, 0.008613586, 0.064697266, 0.0026760101, 0.1159668, 0.032196045, -0.045684814, 0.047210693, 0.053222656, 0.059020996, -0.052734375, -0.012016296, 0.05770874, -0.0064697266, -0.03466797, 0.012641907, 0.029693604, 0.022445679, 0.0017700195, -0.0058250427, -0.044189453, -0.008270264, 0.017501831, 0.015380859, -0.047973633, 0.020111084, -0.068481445, 0.0039138794, 0.022354126, 0.01134491, 0.04901123, -0.0003466606, -0.028656006, 0.087890625, -0.03112793, 0.016540527, 0.030548096, -0.05569458, 0.04067993, -0.01651001, 0.026321411, -0.028503418, -0.0050201416, -0.054779053, -0.056518555, 0.0045280457, -0.02243042, 0.02684021, -0.0009393692, 0.0073547363, -0.032562256, 0.015068054, 0.028289795, 0.020858765, 0.026779175, -0.015640259, 0.02432251, 0.026947021, 0.037200928, -0.021484375, -0.01725769, 0.026016235, -0.020996094, 0.043945312, 0.0033512115, -0.019134521, 0.036071777, -0.06304932, -0.024993896, -0.024780273, -0.007881165, -0.017684937, 0.0051193237, -0.012214661, -0.006214142, -0.009727478, 0.02027893, 0.010902405, 0.0033988953, -0.017822266, 0.013763428, 0.023071289, -0.041229248, 0.09289551, 0.03616333, 0.028305054, 0.014656067, -0.011230469, -0.032562256, -0.025054932, 0.020462036, -0.022232056, 0.040130615, -0.0005455017, -0.0032634735, -0.00062561035, -0.006980896, -0.004611969, 0.02079773, -0.047698975, -0.019073486, -0.00982666, -0.003698349, -0.041809082, 0.023635864, 0.028030396, 0.023971558, -0.033721924, -0.049560547, 0.027374268, 0.012306213, -0.0647583, -0.0236969, 0.020965576, -0.050567627, -0.058685303, -0.0020256042, -0.009712219, -0.012794495, -0.014579773, 0.038726807, -0.03375244, 0.008255005, 0.0064811707, -0.024047852, 0.0814209, -0.0051727295, -0.07470703, 0.04006958, -0.04269409, -0.031707764, 0.0082473755, -0.030303955, -0.003200531, -0.01550293, 0.01902771, 0.03048706, -0.05429077, 0.029144287, -0.011726379, -0.023025513, 0.016464233, -0.01966858, 0.016983032, 0.041290283, 0.004295349, 0.028121948, -0.01576233, 0.008003235, 0.027175903, 0.012016296, 0.0024051666, 0.0056762695, 0.012077332, -0.018722534, 0.03866577, -0.029037476, -0.02078247, -0.0076446533, 0.041259766, -0.019943237, 0.0076446533, 0.022476196, -0.0309906, -0.034606934, 0.024459839, 0.07751465, 0.016098022, -0.019180298, -0.0066070557, 0.017440796, 0.047851562, -0.0055160522, 0.032806396, -0.023712158, 0.034942627, -0.0071792603, 0.0066452026, -0.003528595, 0.0006275177, -0.024551392, -0.032470703, -0.039886475, -0.026947021, -0.006954193, 0.00844574, -0.0019235611, -0.0028533936, 0.016204834, 0.035369873, -0.012580872, -0.026885986, -0.037322998, 0.030975342, -0.058288574, -0.06732178, -0.05050659, -0.011306763, -0.039123535, -0.040740967, -0.08758545, -0.025039673, -0.05908203, 0.00894928, 0.0077438354, 0.011299133, -0.0025043488, -0.02861023, 0.015136719, -0.005405426, -0.015045166, -0.042114258, -0.029464722, -0.005130768, 0.033325195, -0.018493652, 0.008033752, 0.0236969, 0.04650879, -0.029556274, -0.028686523, -0.062438965, -0.018005371, 0.015274048, 0.025802612, 0.04748535, 0.03338623, 0.019805908, 0.0076141357, 0.018341064, 0.015579224, -0.0068092346, -0.028579712, 0.018096924, -0.027801514, 0.041900635, 0.004360199, 0.047729492, -0.01777649, 0.0073661804, -0.02357483, -0.0031929016, 0.0021209717, 0.0065231323, 0.002462387, -0.023925781, -0.018722534, 0.020767212, 0.033966064, -0.010673523, 0.052703857, 0.025894165, -0.010185242, 0.022125244, -0.0025024414, 0.030029297, -0.016708374, 0.024093628, 0.03668213, -0.001958847, -0.022705078, -0.04727173, -0.011657715, 0.051605225, -0.011680603, -0.023986816, -0.04248047, -0.0057792664, 0.020904541, 0.008155823, -0.020492554, -0.05847168, -0.007270813, -0.029830933, -0.03062439, -0.013038635, -0.024414062, -0.035125732, -0.05822754, 0.0049362183, 0.035095215, 0.013938904, -0.0030574799, -0.001537323, -0.0074882507, -0.028808594, 0.0064086914, -0.048583984, -0.060699463, -0.021697998, -0.04949951, 0.007423401, 0.06286621, -0.029037476, -0.022277832, 0.04800415, -0.048706055, 0.040130615, 0.0046539307, -0.05441284, -0.018035889, -0.02128601, -0.0003194809, 0.034820557, 0.017318726, 0.024520874, 0.022735596, -0.043395996, 0.000069618225, -0.034973145, 0.0063972473, -0.027175903, -0.0011014938, 0.028762817, -0.00087070465, -0.0051612854, -0.015113831, 0.032714844, -0.014732361, 0.0009908676, -0.0045700073, -0.010070801, -0.03378296, -0.044128418, -0.0048980713, -0.030700684, 0.017440796, -0.062683105, 0.00017046928, 0.021209717, -0.017150879, -0.000055491924, -0.0075645447, -0.01713562, -0.039978027, 0.027526855, -0.024353027, 0.0005850792, -0.0012741089, 0.058929443, -0.06213379, -0.015274048, -0.012817383, -0.00932312, -0.014778137, 0.004749298, 0.014533997, 0.017791748, 0.03475952, 0.012908936, 0.013153076, -0.0045051575, 0.047424316, -0.06036377, -0.008895874, 0.034332275, -0.010116577, -0.00793457, -0.000088095665, 0.03933716, -0.05886841, 0.013137817, 0.043670654, -0.029891968, 0.04144287, -0.0042304993, 0.050323486, -0.041809082, -0.021850586, -0.008140564, 0.03878784, 0.022094727, 0.0057411194, 0.031829834, 0.019897461, -0.0077285767, -0.001964569, 0.010627747, 0.013084412, -0.029327393, -0.052124023, 0.009277344, 0.009223938, -0.018081665, 0.026397705, 0.029251099, -0.027328491, -0.017242432, -0.02897644, -0.010368347, -0.01525116, 0.008911133, -0.00085926056, 0.008491516, 0.036499023, 0.03390503, 0.013191223, -0.02418518, -0.034362793, 0.024887085, -0.01953125, -0.04888916, 0.059814453, -0.016540527, -0.010894775, 0.0044784546, -0.0005326271, 0.02168274, -0.013938904, 0.039276123, -0.013694763, -0.006832123, -0.0035572052, 0.01689148, 0.040222168, -0.0055732727, -0.004558563, 0.016799927, 0.0036964417, 0.019943237, 0.01071167, 0.0018539429, -0.007663727, 0.0036067963, 0.023895264, 0.01436615, 0.031341553, -0.011024475, 0.044158936, -0.0019626617, -0.0236969, -0.0357666, -0.033599854, -0.047973633, 0.061401367, -0.018295288, 0.016098022, 0.01890564, 0.020339966, 0.019699097, 0.04574585, -0.026046753, 0.015083313, 0.027572632, 0.039978027, 0.014457703, 0.0146865845, -0.049438477, -0.00008028746, 0.045837402, -0.013458252, 0.022460938, -0.008300781, 0.0074157715, 0.0206604, -0.040527344, 0.0070762634, -0.049743652, 0.009674072, -0.03390503, -0.014259338, 0.009963989, 0.0579834, 0.0046310425, -0.025680542, -0.00029063225, 0.0075187683, -0.016143799, 0.011978149, -0.025665283, 0.037261963, 0.013137817, -0.02557373, 0.0181427, 0.017120361, -0.03314209, 0.0043296814, 0.01776123, 0.031555176, -0.031982422, -0.0047416687, -0.0058288574, 0.0021743774, -0.003376007, -0.0057678223, -0.017913818, -0.0013141632, -0.0028743744, 0.01638794, 0.03253174, 0.022827148, -0.039367676, -0.00289917, 0.0423584, -0.000009775162, 0.022781372, 0.0033435822, 0.022766113, 0.043182373, 0.03050232, 0.042510986, 0.027038574, -0.024398804, 0.021133423, 0.046203613, -0.044006348, 0.007675171, 0.023620605, 0.023605347, 0.027832031, 0.032714844, -0.03289795, 0.0231781, 0.020858765, 0.0037059784, 0.012046814, 0.044189453, 0.018157959, 0.0055007935, -0.050445557, -0.024780273, -0.0023612976, -0.025924683, 0.058380127, -0.05996704, 0.012214661, -0.028945923, 0.02507019, -0.05126953, 0.0025081635, -0.024963379, -0.019622803, -0.033111572, 0.0066719055, -0.00007224083, -0.037963867, -0.009010315, -0.06329346, -0.008773804, -0.026260376, -0.016021729, 0.0181427, 0.008621216, -0.012039185, -0.030761719, -0.020019531, 0.020553589, -0.024917603, -0.02067566, 0.021453857, 0.018569946, 0.0014638901, -0.049346924, -0.011375427, -0.012496948, 0.02420044, -0.014762878, 0.021713257, 0.036712646, -0.017166138, -0.053344727, -0.028778076, 0.007675171, -0.04840088, 0.049194336, 0.033111572, -0.01449585, -0.039520264, 0.008178711, -0.021484375, 0.021697998, -0.039093018, -0.008964539, 0.03717041, 0.002029419, -0.043304443, -0.02468872, 0.015731812, 0.032409668, 0.017089844, -0.06903076, 0.026275635, -0.030899048, 0.015045166, -0.027526855, 0.006000519, 0.02507019, 0.07525635, -0.0070343018, -0.025863647, 0.008964539, -0.024353027, -0.003271103, 0.020690918, -0.007297516, 0.0005517006, 0.02130127, 0.01651001, 0.046936035, 0.00248909, -0.013076782, -0.020721436, -0.018371582, 0.00063943863, -0.035888672, 0.025756836, 0.046783447, -0.022735596, 0.0078125, -0.012619019, -0.052490234, -0.09790039, -0.030349731, 0.002614975, 0.009338379, 0.005519867, -0.02909851, 0.033233643, -0.016342163, -0.01966858, -0.072753906, 0.0057373047, 0.016845703, 0.013702393, -0.0076789856, -0.013122559, 0.020401001, 0.055908203, -0.015197754, -0.017654419, 0.028808594, -0.010864258, 0.015304565, -0.057617188, -0.00056552887, -0.057128906, -0.019622803, -0.016143799, -0.012245178, 0.016586304, -0.036621094, 0.024337769, 0.0035095215, -0.037872314, 0.02357483, 0.016174316, 0.0039711, 0.02218628, -0.005970001, 0.0178833, 0.02468872, 0.0031986237 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07466v1
On Measuring Faithfulness of Natural Language Explanations
Letitia Parcalabescu, Anette Frank
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68Txx, I.2.7; I.2.10
Large language models (LLMs) can explain their own predictions, through post-hoc or Chain-of-Thought (CoT) explanations. However the LLM could make up reasonably sounding explanations that are unfaithful to its underlying reasoning. Recent work has designed tests that aim to judge the faithfulness of either post-hoc or CoT explanations. In this paper we argue that existing faithfulness tests are not actually measuring faithfulness in terms of the models' inner workings, but only evaluate their self-consistency on the output level. The aims of our work are two-fold. i) We aim to clarify the status of existing faithfulness tests in terms of model explainability, characterising them as self-consistency tests instead. This assessment we underline by constructing a Comparative Consistency Bank for self-consistency tests that for the first time compares existing tests on a common suite of 11 open-source LLMs and 5 datasets -- including ii) our own proposed self-consistency measure CC-SHAP. CC-SHAP is a new fine-grained measure (not test) of LLM self-consistency that compares a model's input contributions to answer prediction and generated explanation. With CC-SHAP, we aim to take a step further towards measuring faithfulness with a more interpretable and fine-grained method. Code available at \url{https://github.com/Heidelberg-NLP/CC-SHAP}
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07466v1
2023-11-13T16:53:51
2023-11-13T16:53:51
{ "title": [ -0.024002075, -0.004989624, -0.021636963, -0.07720947, -0.005672455, 0.013000488, -0.064697266, -0.022460938, -0.017486572, 0.019226074, -0.01574707, 0.012641907, -0.0138549805, -0.015823364, -0.028442383, 0.0006275177, -0.010772705, 0.018585205, -0.04019165, -0.04019165, -0.034484863, -0.0513916, 0.050231934, -0.005180359, 0.05218506, -0.076416016, -0.0019359589, 0.021514893, 0.0132369995, -0.0051651, 0.01424408, -0.046905518, 0.04827881, 0.024246216, -0.027893066, -0.035888672, -0.052642822, 0.013320923, -0.032684326, 0.023880005, 0.015151978, -0.009422302, -0.0042686462, -0.042419434, -0.026275635, 0.025619507, -0.042419434, -0.029876709, -0.01259613, 0.03189087, 0.0057258606, 0.022445679, -0.021865845, 0.018661499, 0.018737793, -0.015350342, -0.018478394, -0.045196533, 0.029006958, 0.049194336, 0.044006348, -0.054016113, 0.020690918, 0.008224487, -0.043945312, -0.016723633, -0.0029563904, 0.010749817, 0.053222656, -0.021148682, -0.027404785, 0.011512756, -0.002363205, -0.005340576, -0.043701172, 0.0058250427, 0.036834717, -0.018707275, 0.024154663, -0.016799927, 0.018966675, -0.0007019043, 0.013870239, -0.011222839, 0.017578125, -0.024871826, -0.008842468, -0.027420044, -0.052246094, -0.10058594, -0.005886078, -0.046875, -0.051361084, -0.0003759861, -0.0256958, -0.046417236, -0.0029640198, 0.03314209, -0.008117676, -0.047180176, -0.027053833, 0.036499023, -0.08648682, -0.0037975311, 0.010284424, 0.020263672, -0.0077323914, -0.037353516, 0.0073013306, 0.020126343, -0.02960205, 0.05441284, 0.0031204224, -0.04083252, 0.02078247, 0.036621094, -0.012313843, 0.034210205, 0.030532837, 0.041656494, -0.03970337, -0.04373169, 0.012420654, 0.013694763, 0.036071777, 0.0074920654, -0.047027588, 0.014503479, 0.023132324, 0.045410156, 0.014709473, 0.019470215, -0.11468506, -0.08508301, -0.056549072, 0.030914307, -0.03942871, -0.037231445, -0.04067993, 0.020095825, -0.031341553, 0.0020942688, 0.07330322, -0.05142212, 0.014183044, -0.0036811829, 0.052581787, 0.005432129, -0.030792236, -0.03781128, -0.017974854, 0.015853882, 0.039031982, -0.02041626, -0.07006836, -0.036621094, -0.13745117, -0.009490967, 0.03555298, 0.0036144257, -0.0211792, -0.0045166016, 0.024490356, -0.01309967, 0.00023567677, 0.017608643, -0.022109985, 0.009773254, 0.01965332, 0.045196533, -0.0154953, 0.031585693, -0.00032043457, -0.012023926, -0.01739502, -0.026611328, 0.020263672, 0.012413025, 0.019012451, -0.0018234253, 0.024276733, -0.023880005, 0.01675415, 0.051116943, -0.07220459, -0.000017464161, -0.009307861, 0.0070266724, 0.0385437, 0.0046310425, -0.032928467, 0.038085938, -0.03741455, -0.04647827, -0.02670288, -0.023803711, 0.023834229, 0.023239136, -0.0023860931, 0.008560181, -0.037322998, 0.0065193176, -0.02734375, -0.0041503906, -0.020339966, -0.02722168, -0.023864746, 0.021575928, -0.03366089, 0.054016113, 0.070495605, 0.011131287, -0.070373535, 0.07269287, 0.017532349, -0.07800293, 0.0345459, -0.0075569153, -0.01146698, -0.039978027, -0.010154724, -0.010314941, -0.008796692, 0.06591797, -0.006679535, -0.001282692, -0.0033245087, -0.013404846, 0.041900635, 0.017822266, 0.07373047, -0.05899048, 0.06439209, 0.030593872, -0.015182495, -0.021606445, -0.006164551, -0.02810669, -0.008544922, 0.024398804, -0.010253906, -0.022384644, -0.021972656, 0.019256592, 0.051879883, 0.01852417, 0.015899658, 0.004928589, 0.0036811829, 0.024169922, 0.07702637, 0.025619507, 0.0317688, -0.029785156, 0.0017309189, 0.057159424, 0.01499176, 0.024780273, 0.0015478134, 0.02204895, -0.015304565, 0.026168823, 0.010650635, 0.0059509277, -0.05633545, 0.025634766, -0.038085938, 0.0070610046, -0.008613586, 0.0053977966, 0.02128601, -0.003419876, 0.009170532, -0.0072402954, 0.015731812, 0.009994507, -0.04006958, 0.012077332, 0.039520264, -0.042053223, 0.009140015, 0.0032405853, 0.045013428, 0.008842468, 0.006214142, -0.0025367737, 0.040161133, 0.0072364807, -0.014160156, 0.021575928, 0.057006836, 0.046173096, 0.031982422, -0.011772156, 0.027130127, 0.00730896, 0.040161133, 0.060302734, -0.023635864, 0.013397217, -0.038391113, 0.038848877, 0.031280518, -0.0010290146, 0.010688782, 0.03488159, 0.030853271, 0.03540039, -0.021331787, 0.016342163, -0.051208496, -0.015914917, -0.006385803, -0.026245117, -0.043060303, -0.060821533, -0.0024204254, -0.042022705, -0.06011963, -0.030395508, 0.07080078, 0.009628296, -0.014976501, -0.006702423, 0.008987427, -0.028808594, -0.0134887695, -0.028289795, -0.026535034, -0.0038986206, 0.046020508, -0.0030231476, -0.04232788, -0.018722534, -0.0024318695, -0.0012836456, -0.01927185, -0.005207062, -0.028305054, 0.027038574, 0.0027503967, -0.008003235, 0.024032593, -0.058166504, -0.0026493073, -0.035186768, 0.041168213, 0.018661499, -0.043518066, -0.0023517609, 0.037200928, -0.050231934, -0.025405884, 0.009597778, 0.06549072, -0.031707764, -0.012374878, 0.05783081, 0.050964355, -0.00022602081, 0.042266846, 0.0019836426, 0.015586853, -0.06317139, -0.013458252, -0.048217773, -0.028656006, -0.022109985, -0.01689148, 0.03515625, -0.02067566, -0.027420044, -0.03805542, -0.00881958, -0.0076026917, 0.0064201355, -0.0015220642, -0.034576416, -0.035003662, -0.00995636, -0.011375427, 0.013946533, -0.03111267, 0.028182983, 0.06915283, 0.027328491, 0.0038337708, 0.017715454, 0.039245605, 0.0041999817, -0.008346558, -0.008842468, -0.015167236, -0.01121521, -0.0030174255, 0.00068569183, -0.0051498413, -0.004638672, -0.054870605, 0.005027771, 0.0065574646, 0.00078868866, -0.022888184, 0.017318726, -0.07598877, 0.007949829, -0.03878784, -0.02520752, 0.030670166, -0.0069732666, -0.009643555, 0.004924774, -0.008979797, -0.04751587, 0.0025901794, -0.040649414, -0.11254883, 0.024841309, 0.0037651062, -0.02168274, -0.01448822, -0.02861023, -0.032958984, -0.0024471283, 0.004573822, 0.04937744, 0.025009155, 0.013053894, 0.028533936, -0.035125732, 0.0033035278, -0.034210205, -0.010543823, -0.016189575, -0.031463623, -0.008399963, -0.009025574, 0.04159546, 0.02243042, -0.0061187744, 0.0022258759, -0.015960693, -0.06311035, 0.017700195, -0.020935059, -0.028884888, -0.019424438, -0.006038666, -0.0181427, 0.0049972534, -0.019927979, -0.0024909973, -0.025146484, 0.012756348, -0.015449524, 0.026779175, -0.013122559, 0.017852783, -0.027267456, -0.011154175, 0.023529053, -0.020080566, -0.041992188, 0.010826111, 0.064941406, -0.011390686, 0.02760315, -0.019378662, -0.0024375916, 0.014724731, -0.02319336, -0.014953613, -0.025772095, -0.016220093, 0.03955078, 0.00033926964, -0.045013428, 0.010978699, -0.035614014, 0.02178955, 0.0056266785, -0.01109314, -0.026992798, -0.07574463, 0.0011463165, -0.005268097, -0.10784912, -0.020187378, 0.0014915466, -0.013587952, -0.01876831, -0.033325195, 0.02053833, -0.016311646, -0.04626465, 0.011657715, -0.027145386, 0.01902771, -0.015670776, -0.07678223, -0.0010948181, 0.07141113, 0.025543213, 0.030807495, 0.046081543, 0.0013875961, -0.031143188, -0.04837036, 0.013946533, 0.005847931, -0.0014677048, -0.015396118, -0.03387451, 0.022155762, -0.041656494, 0.042236328, -0.011268616, -0.009475708, -0.006526947, 0.015640259, -0.00076293945, 0.0154418945, -0.01751709, 0.05279541, 0.030014038, -0.030456543, -0.056121826, 0.037872314, -0.019607544, -0.020721436, 0.029266357, -0.01071167, 0.0060043335, 0.01373291, 0.009773254, 0.062469482, -0.015625, 0.009933472, 0.07324219, 0.0000910759, -0.031219482, 0.016403198, 0.026916504, 0.04147339, 0.01876831, 0.022567749, -0.023040771, 0.005104065, -0.024841309, -0.008346558, -0.03161621, -0.027420044, -0.052246094, 0.010383606, -0.046875, -0.04324341, -0.043395996, 0.0065727234, -0.025741577, 0.056030273, 0.046813965, -0.009437561, -0.019073486, -0.003610611, 0.027893066, -0.0030879974, -0.0011968613, -0.072143555, -0.012969971, -0.017471313, -0.053833008, -0.030960083, -0.012413025, 0.028717041, 0.036621094, 0.0020256042, -0.0006456375, 0.009895325, 0.036315918, 0.04675293, 0.059906006, -0.0010509491, -0.037353516, 0.05630493, -0.020462036, -0.026657104, 0.04244995, -0.039978027, 0.0068626404, -0.029006958, 0.01878357, -0.009429932, -0.0149002075, -0.033355713, 0.03552246, -0.030471802, 0.06286621, 0.009048462, 0.030075073, 0.028182983, -0.021331787, 0.031036377, 0.010643005, -0.03640747, 0.00042200089, 0.018417358, 0.026641846, 0.003047943, 0.0022659302, -0.0062332153, 0.019821167, 0.029434204, -0.017044067, 0.016723633, -0.008781433, -0.004589081, 0.014457703, 0.024658203, -0.019088745, -0.020385742, 0.023101807, 0.029388428, 0.07598877, -0.026412964, 0.029388428, -0.02557373, 0.021820068, 0.015136719, -0.020339966, 0.025253296, -0.0095825195, 0.024642944, -0.055786133, -0.044799805, 0.00014972687, 0.026641846, -0.020523071, 0.0131073, 0.006839752, 0.02394104, 0.01411438, 0.061401367, 0.057434082, -0.013511658, -0.00085926056, -0.02368164, -0.005531311, -0.021759033, -0.06060791, -0.014129639, 0.0031814575, 0.02078247, -0.025604248, 0.04272461, -0.07092285, -0.007926941, -0.011688232, -0.04336548, 0.02279663, -0.0871582, 0.023880005, 0.06713867, -0.018554688, 0.060638428, -0.007221222, 0.014373779, 0.013938904, 0.058532715, -0.017486572, 0.05026245, 0.021591187, -0.059295654, -0.035949707, -0.0016031265, 0.04650879, -0.015525818, 0.033111572, 0.02406311, 0.008163452, -0.066223145, 0.011856079, 0.016174316, 0.024536133, 0.009208679, -0.052001953, 0.025421143, 0.000893116, -0.0036735535, 0.03262329, -0.0038204193, -0.023773193, -0.020355225, 0.010910034, -0.036590576, 0.016281128, 0.017028809, -0.05807495, -0.011550903, 0.004627228, -0.009864807, -0.012573242, 0.027145386, 0.0016584396, -0.029205322, 0.02078247, 0.017974854, -0.036376953, 0.031082153, -0.019073486, -0.0035820007, 0.049102783, 0.037475586, -0.03668213, -0.0060539246, -0.03100586, -0.03656006, -0.0070343018, -0.0032577515, 0.008262634, 0.024627686, -0.005115509, -0.03768921, 0.0018539429, 0.0052948, 0.014701843, 0.007598877, -0.029373169, 0.039398193, 0.013305664, 0.014923096, 0.0015506744, 0.00073194504, -0.008705139, 0.008354187, 0.021499634, -0.031585693, 0.008529663, 0.0021133423, 0.010536194, -0.016052246, -0.047912598, -0.004558563, 0.014892578, -0.00039720535, 0.01209259, 0.021392822, 0.043060303, 0.051849365, -0.0022258759, 0.03201294, 0.07525635, -0.049682617, -0.039123535, -0.0055770874, 0.004623413, -0.030532837, 0.028686523, 0.0079574585, -0.013702393, -0.022277832, -0.077697754, -0.0413208, 0.0040283203, 0.039123535, 0.02166748, 0.0234375, -0.03643799, 0.03161621, -0.013404846, -0.026016235, -0.017868042, 0.031082153, 0.004875183, -0.02015686, 0.016326904, -0.02633667, 0.026229858, -0.063964844, 0.009765625, 0.042938232, 0.031951904, 0.018417358, -0.041870117, -0.0076560974, -0.024780273, -0.048461914, 0.031051636, 0.005710602, -0.01259613, 0.053344727, -0.026733398, 0.06161499, 0.04083252, 0.040924072, 0.019302368, 0.013641357, 0.037475586, 0.0072402954, 0.01473999, -0.021240234, 0.002380371, -0.045074463, -0.00036621094, -0.031082153, 0.0015850067, -0.08123779, -0.004348755, 0.043426514, 0.030273438, -0.0050239563, 0.0046539307, 0.013641357, -0.0066375732, 0.026931763, 0.0061416626, 0.055145264, 0.021484375, 0.007835388, -0.0074272156, -0.025878906, 0.028549194, 0.042541504, 0.00090265274, 0.0030288696, -0.020141602, -0.03640747, 0.032989502, 0.024841309, -0.0052986145, -0.0059051514, -0.009933472, -0.04348755, 0.021270752, -0.010612488, 0.00843811, 0.066101074, 0.036010742, 0.0054740906, -0.023864746, 0.024475098, -0.05709839, -0.015159607, -0.035461426, 0.00819397, -0.05807495, 0.03262329, -0.025558472, -0.0028362274, -0.0079422, 0.051879883, 0.023513794, -0.0368042, -0.011917114, 0.003982544, 0.024154663, 0.0006685257, 0.0026245117, -0.04812622, -0.03164673, -0.005832672, 0.0143966675, -0.0044021606, 0.010017395, 0.037506104, 0.040527344, -0.0012187958, -0.025894165, 0.022384644, -0.0047187805, -0.013793945, 0.016662598, 0.0028190613, 0.011192322, -0.010932922, -0.040527344, 0.005329132, 0.00097227097, -0.035614014, -0.019180298, 0.012001038, 0.024032593, 0.0289917, 0.05569458, 0.019256592, -0.01335907, -0.025360107, -0.053833008, 0.013923645, 0.03768921, -0.03942871, 0.018844604, -0.026672363, -0.043792725, 0.05697632, -0.0060310364, 0.09753418, -0.050048828, -0.0007266998, -0.040222168, 0.04159546, 0.002691269, -0.045898438, -0.004436493, -0.030441284, -0.010101318, 0.0049095154, 0.01890564, -0.025939941, -0.011924744, 0.01374054, 0.0034332275, 0.044555664, 0.010719299, -0.006969452, -0.05126953, -0.041412354, 0.029190063, 0.004306793, 0.0670166, -0.023605347, -0.0068969727, -0.02696228, 0.02015686, 0.0047187805, -0.018722534, -0.015960693, -0.010681152, -0.027404785, -0.03125, 0.020217896, 0.01675415, -0.007724762, 0.008926392, -0.031097412, 0.010223389, -0.0143585205, -0.0019741058, 0.006591797, -0.044158936, -0.012710571, 0.00079250336, -0.03225708, 0.018218994, 0.025558472, -0.015159607, 0.025344849, 0.0079956055, -0.005634308, -0.038330078, 0.002325058, 0.0074920654, -0.006500244, -0.041809082, 0.015777588, 0.01876831, 0.04034424, -0.048706055, -0.056610107, 0.01234436, 0.014793396, -0.00957489, 0.048797607, 0.01739502, 0.013458252, -0.0055770874, 0.031433105, -0.010917664, -0.04055786, -0.012504578, -0.002626419, 0.01436615, 0.067871094, -0.0015554428, 0.019485474, 0.043518066, -0.024749756, 0.02458191, -0.0104599, 0.0039978027, 0.018798828, -0.018615723, 0.03930664, -0.0158844, -0.027648926, -0.050994873, 0.03225708, -0.0063476562, 0.019699097, -0.005191803, 0.0181427, 0.0058021545, 0.06982422, -0.002790451, -0.028625488, 0.031082153, 0.02218628, 0.016967773, 0.033081055, -0.009223938, -0.027893066, 0.006626129, 0.00003451109, -0.0099105835, 0.006664276, 0.03778076, -0.036102295, -0.016586304, -0.051513672, -0.039611816, -0.02293396, -0.03201294, 0.039093018, -0.023162842, 0.0036621094, 0.0062942505, -0.028869629, -0.004196167, 0.020889282, 0.012527466, -0.0501709, -0.021636963, -0.00034213066, 0.04458618, 0.001241684 ], "summary": [ -0.08502197, -0.01966858, -0.059814453, -0.003921509, -0.054382324, 0.020477295, -0.08703613, 0.005836487, 0.016586304, 0.022872925, -0.003921509, -0.0060920715, 0.014297485, -0.031082153, -0.031311035, -0.013908386, -0.0073394775, 0.010543823, -0.0014724731, -0.021820068, 0.009613037, -0.024475098, 0.0021038055, -0.0070152283, 0.032348633, -0.06555176, 0.040039062, -0.01914978, 0.07751465, 0.032043457, 0.029510498, -0.060638428, 0.040924072, 0.034698486, -0.08874512, 0.022735596, -0.024047852, 0.012382507, -0.044433594, 0.038085938, 0.028945923, -0.016494751, 0.02947998, 0.018722534, -0.017303467, 0.052734375, -0.036224365, -0.044799805, 0.04522705, 0.04498291, -0.0152282715, 0.038848877, -0.0128479, -0.017578125, -0.0038471222, 0.0025672913, -0.015281677, -0.06317139, -0.0040245056, 0.078430176, 0.058013916, 0.016174316, -0.018722534, -0.017654419, -0.011634827, 0.0041236877, 0.047912598, -0.012527466, 0.05697632, 0.00020802021, -0.022003174, 0.05026245, 0.02331543, -0.042114258, 0.0013628006, 0.020935059, 0.014007568, -0.0013360977, 0.004383087, -0.016693115, 0.020370483, -0.04385376, -0.04724121, 0.026779175, -0.01966858, 0.028244019, 0.0009870529, -0.023620605, -0.012687683, -0.057037354, -0.011405945, -0.029342651, -0.0289917, 0.0067481995, -0.014213562, -0.03717041, -0.006252289, 0.019012451, -0.05718994, -0.04107666, 0.023345947, -0.014556885, -0.021377563, -0.008720398, 0.012916565, 0.015197754, -0.03111267, -0.05886841, -0.0034236908, 0.02368164, -0.033843994, -0.026977539, 0.031829834, -0.03414917, 0.030471802, -0.019683838, -0.00970459, 0.073791504, 0.024383545, 0.008049011, -0.011177063, 0.01574707, -0.022003174, 0.02861023, 0.020721436, 0.03048706, 0.022781372, -0.014656067, -0.03652954, 0.018112183, 0.011062622, 0.031799316, -0.020858765, -0.0064353943, -0.034088135, 0.0011129379, -0.02760315, -0.025360107, -0.018753052, 0.013420105, -0.008728027, -0.009002686, 0.09057617, -0.013092041, -0.0013504028, 0.028747559, 0.030029297, 0.005809784, -0.017959595, -0.047729492, -0.016616821, -0.017837524, 0.012199402, -0.03314209, -0.014564514, -0.048797607, -0.07507324, 0.0034732819, 0.04724121, 0.0029964447, -0.013946533, -0.025970459, 0.00907135, 0.012237549, -0.04788208, 0.043792725, -0.008255005, -0.017410278, 0.020477295, 0.037139893, 0.010070801, 0.01763916, 0.049560547, 0.018463135, -0.0038967133, -0.015686035, -0.026428223, 0.06567383, 0.0121154785, 0.021011353, 0.047454834, -0.030197144, 0.06274414, 0.030975342, -0.023117065, -0.002090454, -0.0008664131, 0.041778564, 0.03677368, 0.023208618, -0.024612427, -0.01828003, -0.023468018, -0.0016326904, -0.021133423, -0.02482605, 0.011444092, 0.010391235, -0.028335571, 0.017700195, 0.01838684, 0.03652954, -0.0077667236, -0.066223145, -0.08917236, -0.003326416, -0.02532959, 0.07019043, -0.01725769, 0.01109314, 0.04547119, -0.009773254, -0.08026123, 0.12854004, -0.013977051, -0.07849121, 0.034088135, -0.03945923, -0.0206604, -0.05429077, -0.0007815361, 0.00806427, -0.028182983, 0.09429932, -0.020965576, 0.0087509155, -0.01436615, 0.032043457, 0.019210815, 0.031143188, 0.030563354, -0.044799805, 0.067993164, 0.043151855, -0.038726807, -0.03353882, -0.039276123, -0.07885742, 0.00957489, 0.076049805, 0.021438599, 0.018035889, -0.05883789, -0.020874023, 0.04837036, 0.015205383, 0.005680084, -0.004863739, -0.00028967857, 0.027420044, -0.0043945312, -0.027893066, 0.018554688, -0.050354004, -0.016479492, 0.038726807, -0.015945435, -0.013618469, 0.007347107, 0.006088257, -0.0059127808, -0.018997192, 0.0031414032, -0.011856079, -0.02394104, -0.04345703, -0.025878906, -0.0154800415, 0.0017967224, -0.047210693, 0.028762817, -0.014389038, 0.01424408, -0.0096206665, 0.0017261505, -0.023529053, -0.023712158, 0.016906738, 0.026275635, -0.019714355, 0.0007481575, 0.0015525818, 0.032928467, -0.0006752014, -0.007282257, -0.03543091, 0.05630493, 0.052337646, 0.000055730343, 0.07183838, 0.054992676, 0.017654419, 0.028320312, -0.010192871, 0.015312195, 0.024551392, 0.021835327, 0.026351929, 0.021255493, -0.008338928, 0.017471313, 0.060913086, -0.016983032, 0.042114258, 0.018432617, 0.04510498, 0.048461914, 0.007118225, -0.0031661987, 0.040863037, -0.06866455, -0.048034668, 0.019836426, 0.026885986, -0.017120361, -0.019607544, -0.0061836243, 0.019470215, 0.01878357, 0.016311646, 0.07244873, 0.023208618, 0.0014066696, 0.019348145, 0.01586914, -0.04434204, 0.039978027, -0.021606445, 0.013206482, -0.012275696, 0.00091934204, -0.03515625, -0.035980225, -0.049987793, 0.008110046, -0.015487671, 0.01184082, 0.046417236, 0.014297485, 0.035095215, 0.034423828, -0.053222656, -0.031219482, -0.035888672, -0.003944397, -0.023040771, 0.054382324, 0.008293152, 0.008956909, 0.027008057, 0.0010023117, -0.027282715, -0.020080566, 0.013961792, 0.031921387, -0.04928589, -0.0045700073, 0.053649902, 0.02772522, -0.0010814667, 0.009346008, 0.0027675629, -0.018676758, -0.032958984, -0.018615723, -0.007369995, -0.003484726, -0.006717682, 0.013809204, -0.006877899, 0.02229309, 0.016174316, -0.08734131, -0.01826477, 0.0027751923, -0.01133728, 0.080322266, -0.00075626373, -0.04248047, 0.029312134, 0.00856781, 0.025878906, 0.014434814, 0.044952393, 0.047058105, 0.025054932, 0.012031555, 0.05670166, -0.0057754517, -0.010231018, -0.042816162, 0.01889038, -0.025436401, -0.044677734, 0.00001591444, 0.029144287, -0.021102905, -0.018981934, 0.030914307, -0.013404846, 0.005607605, -0.0018644333, 0.005607605, 0.01260376, -0.04711914, 0.05807495, -0.034057617, -0.015899658, 0.01852417, -0.083496094, -0.008987427, -0.045013428, -0.027755737, -0.09423828, 0.012832642, -0.04421997, -0.023605347, 0.0063323975, -0.036468506, 0.020889282, 0.01084137, 0.021560669, -0.013000488, 0.007255554, 0.038513184, 0.033996582, -0.018585205, -0.024673462, 0.0017595291, -0.031402588, 0.0067634583, -0.036865234, -0.008285522, 0.009002686, -0.011428833, 0.007396698, 0.005065918, 0.0034503937, 0.03805542, -0.03805542, 0.018463135, -0.03314209, -0.06573486, 0.0030574799, -0.04043579, -0.006587982, -0.022628784, 0.007156372, 0.0090789795, 0.040161133, -0.029006958, 0.0043907166, -0.008056641, 0.013221741, -0.037139893, 0.0047454834, -0.03942871, -0.0008625984, 0.02432251, -0.0023479462, -0.009475708, 0.0051574707, -0.020202637, -0.031097412, 0.06109619, -0.0041160583, 0.0018959045, 0.036621094, 0.037231445, -0.036010742, 0.06970215, -0.045135498, -0.041931152, 0.0062179565, 0.016174316, -0.004676819, 0.019042969, 0.03869629, -0.02078247, -0.020736694, -0.030380249, 0.021621704, -0.051757812, -0.025558472, -0.041229248, 0.021621704, -0.049804688, -0.030197144, -0.022506714, -0.0034427643, 0.021347046, 0.014389038, 0.03488159, -0.00018882751, -0.005657196, -0.03744507, -0.03591919, 0.07763672, 0.017364502, -0.0597229, 0.039215088, -0.016815186, -0.0006299019, 0.014595032, -0.010856628, 0.027053833, -0.0017414093, -0.0052948, 0.016937256, -0.015136719, -0.018569946, -0.025756836, -0.039489746, 0.0077323914, -0.035339355, 0.052001953, -0.03829956, -0.045166016, 0.0052948, 0.020202637, 0.017120361, 0.028915405, 0.018951416, 0.027145386, -0.032348633, -0.016143799, -0.009216309, -0.0029964447, 0.023269653, -0.025466919, 0.011695862, -0.002609253, -0.027832031, 0.024642944, 0.011695862, 0.004295349, -0.05456543, 0.0056381226, 0.049072266, -0.0038528442, -0.019561768, -0.0121154785, -0.0033073425, 0.051940918, -0.0033016205, 0.012046814, -0.038482666, -0.007484436, -0.01689148, -0.018081665, -0.014633179, -0.013183594, -0.05593872, -0.036743164, 0.0017986298, -0.016433716, 0.007522583, -0.020004272, -0.038391113, 0.03186035, 0.012992859, -0.00057029724, -0.028320312, 0.013626099, 0.015357971, 0.014694214, -0.04232788, -0.08135986, -0.020889282, 0.009803772, -0.057373047, -0.030029297, -0.028396606, -0.018463135, -0.022140503, -0.012901306, -0.0152282715, 0.024536133, -0.012924194, -0.011543274, 0.014892578, 0.0010871887, -0.01108551, 0.0027675629, -0.0158844, 0.019866943, 0.018585205, -0.0020942688, -0.00019943714, 0.004146576, -0.016189575, -0.0027198792, -0.0149002075, -0.08123779, 0.00043797493, -0.0058898926, 0.004131317, 0.046905518, 0.01084137, 0.020629883, -0.008132935, -0.0003066063, 0.00075149536, 0.0025634766, 0.01979065, 0.02130127, -0.022720337, 0.05895996, -0.0107040405, 0.012130737, 0.0065841675, 0.0061073303, -0.0007882118, 0.004508972, 0.00141716, -0.020385742, 0.03668213, -0.010917664, 0.04385376, -0.010292053, 0.03677368, 0.04333496, 0.025939941, 0.013290405, -0.037872314, 0.003118515, 0.007255554, 0.011024475, -0.021606445, 0.044799805, 0.053955078, 0.015007019, -0.024932861, -0.045806885, -0.007522583, 0.011756897, 0.018234253, -0.010795593, 0.022460938, 0.020324707, 0.0038833618, 0.011993408, 0.018081665, -0.021392822, -0.004802704, -0.034606934, -0.017120361, -0.0020198822, -0.030197144, -0.047973633, -0.0009784698, 0.036621094, 0.03112793, 0.033050537, -0.009307861, 0.008277893, 0.014511108, -0.0066337585, -0.013618469, -0.026565552, -0.00806427, 0.012825012, -0.04498291, 0.02142334, 0.09954834, -0.0051612854, -0.011703491, 0.037506104, -0.038970947, 0.06738281, -0.020217896, -0.028305054, -0.038360596, -0.0357666, 0.008972168, 0.044708252, -0.02961731, 0.033996582, 0.00554657, -0.022994995, -0.021575928, -0.025314331, 0.026321411, 0.0390625, -0.034484863, 0.018539429, 0.011932373, -0.012664795, 0.007949829, 0.050689697, -0.05230713, -0.034820557, 0.023986816, -0.023910522, -0.03253174, -0.022994995, -0.02128601, 0.041534424, -0.0007929802, -0.0072364807, 0.006580353, 0.034729004, -0.032989502, 0.006385803, -0.040405273, -0.0055656433, -0.028518677, 0.03604126, -0.0552063, -0.011924744, -0.02255249, 0.041809082, -0.0057029724, 0.006587982, -0.037231445, -0.021026611, -0.015380859, 0.010215759, 0.0001373291, 0.042755127, 0.010025024, 0.02935791, 0.0124435425, -0.025634766, 0.01701355, -0.017822266, -0.04864502, 0.03161621, 0.0017614365, -0.01826477, 0.04043579, 0.019134521, -0.051086426, 0.029678345, 0.02734375, 0.023498535, 0.0135269165, 0.012641907, 0.033691406, -0.03955078, -0.04031372, -0.012001038, 0.029846191, -0.003408432, 0.005592346, -0.0049209595, 0.002084732, 0.03579712, 0.0029716492, -0.0027332306, 0.049835205, -0.014907837, -0.055114746, 0.017562866, 0.022338867, 0.0129776, 0.02658081, 0.00843811, -0.038116455, -0.0014400482, -0.039611816, -0.0035800934, -0.026748657, -0.0022716522, 0.005519867, 0.012069702, -0.01008606, 0.015914917, -0.013122559, -0.023849487, 0.0038204193, 0.01802063, -0.026748657, -0.06439209, 0.05557251, -0.013320923, -0.011184692, -0.02961731, -0.018661499, 0.050079346, 0.047607422, -0.010231018, -0.0029506683, -0.032073975, 0.0063285828, -0.009468079, 0.002603531, 0.008644104, 0.0011577606, 0.006389618, -0.01675415, 0.029464722, 0.025054932, -0.033996582, -0.009101868, 0.024765015, 0.014144897, -0.0018577576, 0.046325684, 0.008392334, 0.050872803, -0.01033783, -0.013999939, -0.04083252, -0.030914307, -0.03265381, 0.01134491, 0.0026493073, 0.039367676, 0.016296387, 0.01272583, -0.0004079342, -0.027999878, -0.033935547, 0.016296387, 0.05935669, 0.05895996, 0.014923096, 0.013839722, -0.025939941, -0.018829346, 0.033081055, 0.004776001, 0.02017212, 0.019180298, 0.024551392, 0.06298828, -0.054718018, -0.033447266, -0.06524658, 0.04071045, -0.041656494, -0.005970001, 0.018096924, 0.035858154, 0.009895325, -0.017715454, 0.03451538, -0.011894226, -0.013381958, 0.00042319298, -0.012786865, 0.008857727, 0.00084638596, -0.008285522, 0.0027256012, 0.0017318726, -0.018798828, 0.026672363, 0.036895752, 0.021621704, -0.05340576, 0.0015268326, 0.01007843, -0.0069847107, -0.010253906, -0.051239014, -0.044158936, -0.01461792, 0.039978027, 0.01626587, -0.022277832, -0.018081665, 0.011329651, 0.040130615, 0.021591187, -0.040802002, 0.018859863, -0.0871582, 0.031082153, 0.0390625, 0.045196533, 0.01612854, -0.012672424, -0.027420044, 0.018997192, 0.007347107, -0.013008118, 0.0038890839, -0.027526855, 0.06506348, 0.04916382, 0.0574646, -0.034088135, 0.012298584, 0.064819336, -0.0028896332, 0.043182373, -0.010223389, 0.0066833496, 0.0032749176, -0.024536133, 0.0011825562, 0.0149383545, 0.018676758, 0.077941895, -0.08325195, 0.016311646, -0.05029297, 0.06793213, -0.06008911, -0.020980835, -0.052734375, -0.022888184, 0.036895752, 0.021316528, -0.015411377, -0.083862305, 0.017669678, 0.0038528442, -0.027252197, 0.03982544, -0.018981934, -0.0015125275, 0.0009217262, -0.05114746, 0.028900146, 0.0074005127, 0.050231934, -0.001414299, -0.014373779, 0.052642822, 0.005367279, -0.007965088, -0.07128906, -0.033721924, -0.021499634, 0.04711914, -0.02293396, 0.00060653687, -0.00039720535, -0.01210022, -0.0027484894, -0.016326904, 0.024429321, -0.021850586, 0.021377563, 0.026947021, -0.019515991, -0.08441162, -0.018127441, -0.0054740906, 0.036956787, 0.0124435425, -0.026550293, 0.045837402, 0.0041885376, -0.013420105, 0.0143966675, 0.0034446716, 0.011955261, -0.03289795, -0.031799316, 0.00038838387, -0.007663727, 0.031341553, -0.015174866, -0.061584473, 0.0077400208, 0.0026454926, 0.03161621, -0.042388916, 0.000854969, -0.003818512, -0.04434204, 0.016830444, -0.019882202, -0.018081665, 0.015113831, 0.02986145, 0.014030457, 0.02609253, -0.034942627, 0.045410156, 0.025558472, -0.06121826, 0.019058228, -0.0151901245, 0.04095459, 0.009140015, -0.036102295, 0.0077590942, -0.06707764, -0.0027694702, -0.008705139, -0.031585693, 0.00381279, -0.03161621, -0.009292603, 0.0011606216, -0.060028076, 0.012588501, -0.011184692, 0.023147583, -0.008598328, -0.026016235, 0.026306152, -0.024398804, 0.034851074, 0.0070114136, 0.021209717, -0.015449524, 0.0019817352, -0.012863159, 0.02218628, -0.05770874, -0.04714966, -0.04473877, -0.008384705, -0.050231934, -0.018478394, 0.03918457, -0.028274536, -0.005393982, 0.013999939, -0.040771484, 0.025665283, -0.033477783, -0.052947998, -0.009689331, 0.011787415, 0.0027103424, -0.06021118, 0.026565552 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07463v1
MEGAVERSE: Benchmarking Large Language Models Across Languages, Modalities, Models and Tasks
Sanchit Ahuja, Divyanshu Aggarwal, Varun Gumma, Ishaan Watts, Ashutosh Sathe, Millicent Ochieng, Rishav Hada, Prachi Jain, Maxamed Axmed, Kalika Bali, Sunayana Sitaram
cs.CL
Recently, there has been a rapid advancement in research on Large Language Models (LLMs), resulting in significant progress in several Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks. Consequently, there has been a surge in LLM evaluation research to comprehend the models' capabilities and limitations. However, much of this research has been confined to the English language, leaving LLM building and evaluation for non-English languages relatively unexplored. There has been an introduction of several new LLMs, necessitating their evaluation on non-English languages. This study aims to expand our MEGA benchmarking suite by including six new datasets to form the MEGAVERSE benchmark. The benchmark comprises 22 datasets covering 81 languages, including low-resource African languages. We evaluate several state-of-the-art LLMs like GPT-3.5-Turbo, GPT4, PaLM2, and Llama2 on the MEGAVERSE datasets. Additionally, we include two multimodal datasets in the benchmark and assess the performance of the LLaVa-v1.5 model. Our experiments suggest that GPT4 and PaLM2 outperform the Llama models on various tasks, notably on low-resource languages, with GPT4 outperforming PaLM2 on more datasets than vice versa. However, issues such as data contamination must be addressed to obtain an accurate assessment of LLM performance on non-English languages.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07463v1
2023-11-13T16:45:37
2023-11-13T16:45:37
{ "title": [ -0.036865234, -0.020812988, -0.041900635, -0.06726074, -0.000017106533, 0.00712204, -0.072143555, 0.010116577, 0.0067749023, 0.030456543, -0.00010848045, 0.009399414, 0.013763428, -0.029800415, -0.034118652, 0.026031494, -0.008865356, 0.025024414, -0.028182983, -0.03125, -0.007881165, -0.046966553, 0.046691895, 0.032714844, 0.06500244, -0.08685303, -0.093566895, 0.04144287, -0.03237915, -0.030838013, 0.00019109249, 0.041503906, 0.030807495, 0.035583496, -0.015655518, 0.018997192, -0.04901123, 0.025009155, 0.0029392242, -0.008110046, 0.03967285, -0.0037708282, -0.007850647, 0.010421753, -0.03817749, 0.008758545, -0.03756714, -0.028030396, -0.005836487, 0.01789856, 0.011947632, 0.035736084, -0.011245728, 0.031311035, 0.0073394775, -0.03164673, -0.03488159, 0.032714844, 0.022888184, 0.07989502, 0.026443481, -0.032470703, -0.00028419495, -0.029296875, -0.040985107, -0.0018596649, -0.042114258, 0.01600647, 0.081970215, 0.00075626373, -0.043823242, 0.014724731, -0.00024354458, -0.019592285, -0.057525635, 0.030929565, 0.019073486, -0.013244629, 0.050079346, -0.0473938, 0.003982544, -0.02116394, -0.0016841888, -0.0135650635, 0.025726318, -0.027450562, -0.022247314, -0.011108398, -0.022750854, -0.08215332, 0.00029993057, -0.022094727, -0.045898438, 0.015487671, -0.013519287, -0.04119873, -0.018417358, 0.02394104, -0.011054993, -0.01864624, -0.013931274, 0.02243042, -0.039764404, -0.009162903, 0.019577026, 0.031707764, -0.030670166, 0.0025138855, 0.021484375, 0.034362793, -0.020126343, 0.03741455, 0.013206482, -0.000030517578, -0.0028038025, -0.019989014, -0.021209717, 0.022994995, 0.012588501, 0.022613525, -0.007205963, -0.016067505, 0.010650635, -0.00039982796, 0.033050537, 0.010757446, -0.04824829, 0.012413025, -0.014915466, 0.039031982, 0.017593384, 0.042938232, -0.12164307, -0.08660889, -0.07147217, 0.041259766, -0.02142334, 0.014770508, -0.026519775, 0.035186768, -0.015098572, -0.03591919, 0.013633728, -0.0065689087, 0.005634308, 0.012489319, 0.06970215, -0.016159058, -0.045776367, -0.061706543, -0.016067505, 0.0079193115, 0.053894043, -0.028259277, -0.07159424, -0.015274048, -0.14099121, 0.0052833557, -0.009933472, -0.0015525818, -0.0070381165, -0.004348755, -0.0021190643, -0.032684326, 0.0034503937, 0.006454468, -0.010673523, -0.001367569, 0.013313293, 0.028259277, -0.019180298, 0.038269043, 0.022781372, -0.006084442, -0.012718201, 0.0005478859, 0.012275696, 0.008674622, 0.020980835, -0.038391113, -0.008621216, -0.03189087, 0.015914917, 0.046783447, -0.050811768, -0.043304443, 0.0006990433, -0.0040359497, 0.05166626, 0.016342163, -0.009933472, -0.0013132095, -0.03967285, -0.021636963, -0.035064697, -0.039611816, 0.020599365, 0.025604248, -0.0043640137, -0.010551453, -0.016418457, -0.011291504, -0.033050537, 0.0077056885, -0.033081055, -0.031707764, -0.026016235, 0.008918762, -0.009246826, 0.051940918, 0.047973633, 0.025405884, -0.055847168, 0.028717041, -0.008613586, -0.043701172, 0.015235901, 0.0018939972, 0.0026111603, -0.01411438, 0.012886047, -0.017562866, 0.037902832, 0.054351807, -0.0040893555, 0.0075683594, -0.0048713684, -0.0043525696, 0.033294678, 0.03010559, 0.054718018, -0.04776001, 0.052886963, 0.031280518, -0.004131317, -0.031433105, -0.00009924173, -0.034088135, 0.0050964355, 0.012748718, -0.008918762, -0.026885986, -0.020111084, 0.032348633, 0.012184143, -0.013061523, 0.007904053, 0.029190063, 0.044036865, 0.068603516, 0.030883789, 0.023376465, 0.033355713, -0.02128601, 0.020401001, 0.058532715, 0.016418457, 0.0056991577, -0.00315094, 0.0026683807, 0.023330688, 0.005142212, -0.044830322, 0.01914978, -0.07092285, 0.022201538, -0.039245605, -0.0008430481, 0.012184143, 0.016326904, 0.031021118, -0.0357666, 0.019821167, -0.0084991455, -0.0027160645, -0.017684937, -0.017807007, 0.014984131, 0.03024292, -0.048431396, -0.010307312, 0.017059326, 0.049072266, 0.002916336, 0.0050201416, 0.009391785, 0.01965332, -0.02571106, -0.017105103, -0.014305115, 0.04916382, 0.023269653, -0.002855301, 0.002796173, 0.020324707, -0.0076942444, 0.1348877, 0.064941406, -0.028335571, 0.038269043, -0.02230835, 0.02571106, -0.002840042, -0.010787964, 0.023498535, 0.0070991516, 0.03048706, 0.028274536, -0.029800415, 0.022445679, -0.072387695, -0.011917114, 0.00894165, -0.02230835, -0.037628174, -0.05908203, -0.005340576, -0.04559326, -0.06707764, -0.04244995, 0.06878662, -0.017654419, -0.015235901, 0.0027999878, -0.0017404556, -0.020843506, 0.0044021606, -0.03125, 0.0054473877, 0.01272583, 0.04360962, -0.004173279, -0.060821533, -0.087524414, -0.011764526, -0.006263733, -0.023101807, 0.024246216, -0.03024292, 0.025222778, 0.0038452148, 0.00023674965, 0.01826477, -0.05618286, 0.010040283, -0.047546387, 0.03286743, 0.010131836, -0.029541016, 0.016937256, 0.004383087, -0.010238647, 0.0027179718, 0.012664795, 0.07373047, -0.047180176, -0.06100464, 0.034484863, 0.027420044, -0.023254395, 0.019882202, 0.022644043, 0.008331299, -0.028778076, -0.0236969, -0.04510498, -0.014785767, -0.006816864, -0.012214661, 0.04055786, -0.028717041, -0.040863037, -0.021896362, -0.020065308, -0.001080513, -0.0048561096, -0.0071258545, -0.0335083, -0.019866943, -0.013389587, -0.012283325, 0.027069092, -0.017440796, 0.032104492, 0.07208252, 0.0031833649, 0.012031555, 0.01979065, 0.035186768, 0.003982544, -0.011245728, -0.012893677, -0.024307251, 0.011123657, 0.012718201, 0.01890564, -0.03213501, -0.025878906, -0.091430664, 0.004219055, 0.08215332, -0.00084877014, -0.017440796, 0.031219482, -0.085876465, 0.048950195, -0.022338867, 0.0129470825, 0.03616333, 0.01473999, 0.023010254, 0.0073623657, 0.022476196, -0.05038452, 0.003168106, -0.04232788, -0.10748291, 0.03591919, -0.027893066, -0.022338867, -0.0033397675, -0.028747559, -0.05429077, -0.008346558, 0.0006222725, 0.06286621, 0.014915466, 0.013145447, 0.020523071, -0.018478394, 0.01285553, -0.021896362, -0.031951904, -0.00844574, -0.032165527, 0.046722412, 0.022201538, 0.05130005, 0.051513672, -0.015213013, -0.0073165894, -0.02243042, -0.034210205, 0.003528595, -0.0027008057, -0.038513184, 0.0010728836, 0.010902405, 0.002193451, 0.020324707, -0.027267456, 0.0040740967, -0.033355713, 0.013000488, -0.022979736, -0.014968872, 0.037139893, 0.009941101, -0.006893158, -0.03086853, -0.008712769, -0.030044556, -0.030273438, 0.000031411648, 0.06958008, 0.027496338, -0.032226562, -0.0034980774, -0.027740479, 0.0262146, 0.00844574, -0.026184082, 0.011230469, 0.0038547516, -0.019927979, -0.0013036728, -0.0009522438, 0.005706787, -0.011390686, 0.0071792603, -0.011917114, 0.012710571, -0.028457642, -0.059051514, -0.00843811, 0.0056533813, -0.10662842, -0.03845215, 0.0023765564, 0.008102417, -0.016479492, -0.021392822, 0.037139893, -0.007461548, -0.021499634, 0.022750854, -0.020599365, -0.043273926, -0.000005364418, -0.08068848, 0.005592346, 0.095703125, 0.023376465, 0.025466919, 0.036346436, 0.0016546249, -0.020889282, -0.024551392, 0.031341553, 0.021209717, 0.025634766, -0.007904053, -0.018600464, 0.01600647, -0.031555176, 0.0519104, 0.016342163, -0.03414917, 0.021469116, 0.016784668, 0.018371582, 0.027145386, -0.0057678223, 0.0335083, -0.007633209, -0.0028076172, -0.05657959, 0.0155181885, -0.0063476562, -0.016616821, 0.014816284, -0.012809753, 0.02355957, 0.03149414, -0.003162384, 0.05996704, -0.011764526, 0.018539429, 0.04498291, -0.011497498, -0.031799316, -0.016998291, 0.021392822, 0.018218994, 0.007827759, 0.029449463, 0.0072784424, 0.05303955, -0.024978638, -0.0015583038, -0.0067710876, 0.009284973, -0.053833008, -0.007648468, -0.05343628, -0.044891357, -0.011199951, 0.0067253113, -0.0309906, 0.050567627, 0.039123535, 0.0025596619, 0.0003232956, -0.018936157, 0.057281494, 0.006465912, -0.008560181, -0.05810547, 0.018234253, -0.0138549805, -0.050201416, -0.041900635, -0.011161804, -0.01146698, 0.029174805, -0.0056991577, -0.02142334, 0.012924194, 0.016723633, 0.051330566, 0.026565552, -0.00039696693, -0.04257202, 0.01525116, -0.02645874, -0.038513184, -0.0006041527, -0.0058288574, -0.026565552, -0.046844482, 0.01914978, -0.015930176, -0.010231018, -0.018554688, 0.029022217, -0.015930176, 0.049102783, -0.024627686, 0.020874023, 0.017303467, 0.018981934, -0.0012054443, -0.0031013489, -0.029205322, -0.0211792, -0.0048217773, 0.047821045, -0.017684937, 0.01737976, 0.03274536, 0.005809784, -0.0028629303, 0.0015335083, 0.019042969, 0.008110046, -0.016555786, 0.005039215, 0.013259888, -0.042663574, -0.033447266, -0.0023994446, 0.0076179504, 0.03845215, -0.045776367, 0.051483154, -0.011100769, -0.006427765, 0.020965576, -0.018051147, 0.009674072, -0.011795044, 0.024856567, -0.044921875, -0.051818848, -0.002483368, 0.03463745, -0.014129639, 0.0037593842, -0.0062561035, 0.007698059, 0.0061683655, 0.036987305, 0.032958984, 0.0036888123, -0.015029907, -0.019714355, -0.0072021484, -0.010520935, -0.048034668, -0.0020103455, -0.009490967, 0.011978149, -0.0209198, 0.028335571, -0.07623291, 0.00056266785, -0.016479492, -0.040039062, 0.040771484, -0.078186035, 0.01361084, 0.080566406, -0.023727417, 0.051086426, 0.010437012, 0.01927185, 0.024719238, 0.06781006, 0.0020256042, 0.020385742, 0.0395813, -0.025024414, 0.0043754578, 0.0113220215, 0.023452759, -0.010353088, 0.027709961, 0.0030231476, 0.0041770935, -0.049835205, 0.018692017, 0.02180481, 0.016571045, 0.02772522, -0.06524658, 0.003921509, 0.0023040771, -0.0021438599, 0.018676758, -0.025543213, -0.046081543, -0.026306152, -0.008094788, -0.051818848, 0.0051002502, -0.013298035, -0.06304932, -0.023254395, 0.02619934, -0.00970459, -0.007911682, 0.02468872, -0.011688232, -0.025299072, 0.03378296, 0.023635864, -0.035827637, 0.007091522, -0.00198555, 0.012573242, 0.037261963, 0.032318115, -0.0357666, -0.00655365, -0.014152527, -0.035064697, -0.019500732, -0.008712769, -0.0015668869, 0.0056266785, -0.013809204, -0.016738892, 0.003528595, -0.0056114197, 0.030075073, -0.025100708, -0.020187378, 0.015571594, -0.0011205673, -0.0022468567, 0.004840851, 0.00002270937, 0.00038433075, 0.008163452, 0.002439499, -0.0256958, 0.02722168, 0.002216339, 0.02243042, -0.010047913, -0.08135986, 0.015266418, 0.024032593, 0.005680084, -0.012397766, 0.028915405, 0.039855957, 0.0011749268, -0.0014638901, 0.011039734, 0.048919678, -0.059265137, -0.010269165, -0.0032100677, 0.003894806, -0.016586304, 0.053649902, -0.010131836, -0.0070381165, -0.041229248, -0.05557251, -0.025375366, 0.0031700134, 0.013084412, 0.03173828, 0.040405273, -0.011657715, 0.035064697, -0.024932861, -0.026565552, -0.0446167, 0.0121154785, -0.018310547, -0.02456665, 0.03677368, -0.010986328, -0.0038490295, -0.04071045, 0.03768921, 0.039001465, -0.017059326, 0.02319336, -0.035003662, -0.0058555603, -0.019805908, -0.051940918, 0.033325195, 0.008049011, -0.008377075, 0.041809082, -0.021820068, 0.05886841, 0.006160736, 0.041778564, 0.049468994, 0.0070495605, 0.004173279, -0.0027694702, 0.034118652, -0.038848877, 0.0004940033, -0.033111572, 0.023605347, -0.045898438, 0.0028018951, -0.05026245, 0.02947998, 0.0082473755, 0.0385437, -0.005882263, 0.018844604, -0.0018157959, 0.0068244934, 0.025512695, 0.0059432983, 0.05429077, 0.014915466, 0.0029354095, 0.029006958, -0.048034668, 0.018066406, 0.045440674, -0.004043579, -0.021575928, -0.0036830902, -0.013458252, 0.018005371, 0.0053367615, 0.006996155, -0.008987427, 0.0010614395, -0.03479004, 0.017593384, -0.018814087, 0.0390625, 0.07421875, 0.016189575, 0.0049362183, -0.014823914, -0.0026817322, -0.03366089, -0.01991272, 0.0071487427, 0.032226562, -0.06842041, 0.03237915, -0.011566162, -0.025390625, -0.01878357, 0.026229858, 0.03555298, -0.053741455, -0.036987305, 0.02281189, 0.04711914, 0.00018930435, -0.002040863, -0.028167725, -0.015029907, 0.023132324, 0.05090332, -0.01864624, 0.03036499, -0.010002136, 0.003900528, 0.003982544, -0.054870605, 0.017181396, -0.0051231384, 0.014579773, 0.030456543, 0.010131836, 0.026031494, -0.0049324036, -0.036590576, 0.006462097, 0.015487671, -0.055480957, -0.011192322, 0.02859497, 0.030334473, 0.03982544, 0.07965088, 0.013397217, 0.0015220642, -0.00242424, -0.041900635, 0.023712158, 0.03930664, -0.014579773, 0.035980225, -0.049591064, -0.04324341, 0.019226074, -0.036712646, 0.039215088, -0.058135986, -0.014945984, -0.037902832, 0.08416748, -0.0010957718, -0.05206299, -0.056671143, -0.011062622, -0.03591919, -0.0068740845, 0.004798889, -0.013061523, -0.024414062, -0.029327393, 0.010353088, -0.019744873, 0.0035934448, 0.011062622, -0.027160645, -0.08148193, 0.004711151, -0.022903442, 0.04260254, -0.044555664, 0.009361267, 0.004508972, -0.01020813, -0.015350342, -0.04208374, -0.025177002, -0.008346558, -0.020980835, -0.045715332, 0.01209259, -0.0021343231, -0.023117065, -0.03668213, -0.025039673, -0.0065078735, -0.030563354, -0.002117157, 0.04269409, -0.03967285, -0.025146484, -0.00008380413, -0.031402588, 0.05456543, 0.011459351, 0.006515503, 0.0014953613, 0.007972717, 0.0061531067, -0.020584106, 0.05050659, 0.05795288, 0.008865356, -0.070739746, 0.020706177, 0.01928711, 0.06915283, -0.03894043, -0.043670654, 0.02545166, 0.00655365, 0.0021038055, 0.048919678, 0.024429321, -0.0029067993, 0.005027771, 0.011947632, -0.0067710876, -0.028182983, -0.018997192, -0.008224487, 0.022964478, 0.05026245, 0.008979797, -0.006111145, 0.040802002, -0.03579712, 0.016662598, 0.01386261, 0.0016717911, 0.037139893, -0.0046043396, 0.038482666, -0.04034424, -0.0013856888, -0.029830933, 0.013168335, -0.0034866333, 0.014160156, -0.023590088, 0.014450073, -0.017791748, 0.042541504, -0.028717041, -0.06549072, 0.06347656, 0.040496826, 0.014709473, 0.027389526, 0.0034713745, -0.010322571, -0.014343262, -0.0050315857, 0.007411957, 0.009765625, -0.012672424, -0.036254883, 0.014892578, -0.030014038, -0.034179688, -0.009162903, -0.03149414, 0.04888916, -0.04067993, 0.010437012, -0.025100708, -0.021224976, 0.00014710426, 0.029724121, -0.003932953, -0.020065308, -0.04940796, -0.023483276, 0.038269043, -0.016525269 ], "summary": [ -0.053009033, -0.02708435, -0.014923096, 0.0010948181, -0.0793457, 0.008125305, -0.11279297, -0.0037174225, 0.006385803, 0.041412354, 0.006526947, 0.022720337, 0.013442993, -0.0345459, 0.0061073303, 0.018478394, -0.004886627, 0.008026123, -0.0064811707, -0.034301758, 0.009124756, -0.051971436, 0.014434814, -0.013664246, 0.048614502, -0.089660645, -0.03717041, 0.009552002, 0.009628296, 0.00041770935, 0.019180298, 0.023529053, -0.0020198822, 0.006538391, 0.013839722, -0.0042762756, -0.035858154, 0.00724411, 0.016845703, -0.003868103, 0.045806885, -0.011138916, 0.044708252, 0.020065308, -0.012573242, 0.036895752, -0.012245178, -0.050567627, 0.02645874, -0.0143585205, 0.018051147, 0.040008545, 0.011558533, -0.006755829, -0.025253296, -0.0009255409, -0.061309814, 0.032104492, -0.0013179779, 0.07623291, 0.02053833, 0.017547607, -0.0099487305, -0.048553467, -0.025100708, 0.02935791, -0.028564453, -0.020706177, 0.083618164, -0.006565094, -0.028762817, 0.0025863647, 0.0259552, -0.016998291, -0.026443481, 0.033294678, -0.007881165, 0.023040771, 0.045715332, -0.04626465, 0.005519867, 0.01802063, -0.016723633, -0.053649902, 0.037994385, -0.015930176, -0.01727295, -0.020217896, 0.01259613, -0.06500244, -0.004688263, -0.045898438, -0.05807495, 0.04650879, 0.01574707, -0.07171631, 0.011108398, 0.0065727234, -0.051361084, -0.051635742, 0.02067566, -0.017745972, -0.0023784637, 0.013748169, -0.0018281937, 0.016647339, -0.022521973, -0.047912598, 0.0020503998, 0.02268982, -0.014442444, -0.0067977905, 0.032958984, -0.019897461, -0.0020942688, -0.0039863586, 0.012924194, 0.05001831, 0.019180298, 0.028961182, -0.013175964, 0.005970001, -0.024993896, 0.04171753, 0.023986816, 0.029556274, -0.010307312, 0.032989502, 0.0013713837, 0.03390503, 0.038116455, 0.033599854, -0.13183594, -0.07373047, -0.10534668, 0.018432617, 0.023254395, 0.03488159, -0.008010864, 0.000115036964, -0.009902954, -0.015991211, 0.015296936, -0.014221191, 0.042816162, 0.014389038, 0.0077056885, 0.00026273727, 0.020706177, -0.012527466, 0.0390625, -0.021209717, 0.03302002, -0.060638428, -0.018737793, -0.06970215, -0.081726074, -0.010223389, 0.036895752, -0.0049476624, -0.0004506111, -0.014961243, 0.00046896935, -0.0052948, -0.031219482, 0.0060653687, 0.002811432, -0.0020637512, 0.009162903, -0.014373779, 0.0060043335, -0.0051574707, 0.023162842, -0.028213501, -0.013908386, 0.0025138855, -0.0012578964, 0.027023315, 0.021194458, -0.055023193, -0.019958496, -0.04547119, 0.037719727, 0.008918762, -0.004798889, -0.0748291, 0.020965576, 0.024673462, 0.041656494, 0.038726807, -0.020401001, -0.04876709, -0.026824951, 0.03012085, -0.0061569214, -0.015640259, -0.018341064, 0.027862549, -0.0069999695, -0.06744385, 0.05557251, -0.016540527, 0.004753113, -0.06173706, -0.105773926, -0.02407837, -0.03338623, 0.025360107, 0.011993408, 0.014846802, 0.0178833, 0.005847931, -0.0491333, 0.08117676, -0.013412476, -0.029891968, 0.014602661, 0.0018577576, 0.030944824, -0.023345947, 0.09411621, -0.007789612, 0.045654297, 0.062194824, -0.036865234, 0.02142334, -0.0031108856, 0.034057617, 0.028335571, 0.021316528, 0.049865723, -0.0395813, 0.049804688, 0.026916504, -0.0008573532, 0.0069236755, 0.03741455, -0.073913574, 0.01524353, 0.014183044, 0.0053634644, -0.0049095154, -0.026000977, 0.030319214, -0.03201294, 0.0016183853, 0.02810669, 0.00033211708, 0.033355713, 0.050872803, 0.00258255, -0.029067993, 0.024368286, -0.052703857, 0.0026016235, 0.035003662, -0.007835388, -0.0519104, 0.014213562, -0.0039901733, 0.019882202, -0.0027713776, -0.016586304, 0.014389038, -0.005542755, -0.045166016, -0.033325195, -0.03778076, -0.011474609, -0.004722595, 0.033081055, -0.048431396, 0.008285522, -0.038726807, -0.032104492, 0.0008416176, -0.02609253, 0.020706177, 0.045318604, -0.013160706, -0.008666992, -0.00076055527, 0.031829834, -0.007572174, 0.044769287, -0.0033664703, 0.023864746, -0.023345947, -0.0036773682, 0.03567505, 0.043670654, 0.0052604675, -0.0054397583, 0.0006709099, 0.01725769, -0.0046424866, 0.074279785, 0.02557373, -0.005584717, -0.0037498474, 0.02947998, 0.035064697, -0.033416748, 0.012756348, 0.03753662, 0.002357483, 0.010238647, 0.03262329, 0.024353027, 0.025482178, -0.06414795, 0.012954712, 0.027801514, 0.020553589, -0.03466797, -0.026351929, -0.01020813, 0.009361267, -0.044006348, -0.007522583, 0.055786133, 0.0075302124, 0.0050315857, 0.027938843, 0.00014436245, -0.042022705, 0.043670654, -0.025009155, 0.034973145, -0.009483337, -0.0079574585, -0.022781372, -0.039764404, -0.057525635, -0.004878998, -0.026565552, -0.0035381317, 0.049865723, -0.023239136, -0.007545471, -0.010482788, -0.0068855286, 0.00009995699, -0.026977539, -0.024810791, 0.046905518, 0.013000488, -0.0039482117, -0.0060920715, 0.040130615, -0.03253174, -0.0011548996, 0.03353882, 0.027938843, 0.05532837, -0.061828613, -0.07019043, 0.0058555603, -0.032287598, -0.05279541, 0.0007777214, 0.022994995, 0.0036621094, -0.006652832, -0.023834229, -0.01449585, -0.013664246, 0.021957397, 0.015670776, 0.026428223, -0.011894226, 0.043762207, -0.04547119, -0.028518677, -0.01121521, 0.0025939941, 0.08831787, 0.0010967255, 0.0059318542, 0.051483154, 0.009437561, 0.031234741, -0.0007286072, 0.037353516, 0.06732178, 0.0014820099, 0.0026302338, 0.008544922, 0.026412964, 0.008987427, 0.000202775, -0.02482605, 0.007396698, -0.005592346, 0.016906738, 0.00041747093, -0.027740479, 0.00015771389, -0.037902832, 0.000875473, 0.08795166, -0.0010633469, 0.04534912, 0.009300232, -0.046875, 0.099731445, -0.012039185, 0.050689697, 0.041259766, -0.022140503, 0.037200928, -0.044067383, -0.0042304993, -0.0418396, -0.030960083, -0.010223389, -0.040252686, 0.007003784, -0.023971558, 0.004699707, -0.009155273, 0.019897461, -0.027328491, 0.0033626556, 0.004840851, 0.069885254, -0.015655518, 0.0121154785, -0.0022068024, 0.019592285, 0.016830444, -0.006641388, -0.03805542, 0.0005302429, -0.00844574, 0.052490234, 0.021606445, 0.015327454, 0.052368164, -0.043182373, 0.009361267, -0.0035533905, -0.06518555, -0.026062012, -0.00087308884, -0.056152344, 0.014320374, -0.019042969, 0.019058228, 0.056732178, -0.03994751, 0.009963989, -0.014007568, 0.016143799, -0.047576904, -0.035461426, -0.018447876, 0.020462036, 0.033599854, -0.025009155, -0.016159058, -0.01763916, 0.008995056, 0.0010318756, 0.04498291, 0.09307861, -0.08203125, 0.028137207, -0.034454346, 0.004863739, 0.07672119, -0.10748291, 0.024658203, 0.0042152405, -0.033691406, -0.03741455, 0.038024902, 0.026763916, 0.0065841675, -0.04663086, -0.072265625, 0.026657104, -0.086120605, -0.06976318, -0.025390625, 0.00037193298, -0.040527344, -0.052093506, -0.0029335022, 0.042999268, -0.010231018, 0.0070762634, 0.031585693, 0.009742737, 0.015319824, 0.013839722, -0.008483887, 0.018234253, -0.004650116, -0.058776855, 0.0053634644, 0.012458801, 0.010002136, 0.03643799, -0.00894928, 0.0058059692, -0.00349617, -0.0021400452, 0.03503418, 0.0052223206, 0.0016965866, -0.013542175, -0.010856628, 0.00083208084, -0.012756348, 0.0054626465, 0.03704834, -0.050628662, 0.045715332, 0.027755737, 0.045318604, 0.037384033, 0.024459839, 0.009796143, -0.026184082, 0.019577026, -0.0149002075, -0.004753113, 0.001499176, -0.03857422, 0.028884888, 0.004787445, -0.024780273, 0.039276123, 0.0181427, 0.028289795, -0.028320312, -0.01499176, 0.016952515, -0.001203537, -0.010314941, -0.0070114136, -0.014160156, 0.035369873, 0.0032691956, 0.005619049, -0.017990112, 0.038970947, -0.007423401, 0.020141602, -0.012832642, -0.0107040405, -0.03668213, -0.04244995, -0.03552246, -0.019226074, 0.0020599365, 0.016586304, -0.011367798, 0.0012359619, 0.043060303, -0.010421753, -0.0016460419, -0.003627777, 0.05596924, 0.013725281, -0.03668213, -0.1104126, 0.034698486, -0.021453857, -0.033325195, -0.046325684, -0.017654419, -0.008224487, -0.03656006, 0.008972168, -0.0020141602, 0.00023031235, -0.00034427643, 0.02015686, -0.013046265, 0.01713562, -0.002571106, -0.0072250366, -0.022094727, 0.012466431, -0.020767212, -0.014091492, -0.036956787, 0.008392334, 0.041534424, -0.00655365, -0.032562256, -0.07019043, 0.00075769424, 0.03488159, -0.0052871704, 0.013839722, -0.018737793, 0.015838623, 0.03744507, -0.007003784, -0.01689148, -0.015090942, -0.0015392303, -0.0038700104, 0.027770996, 0.033233643, -0.0030326843, 0.031051636, 0.0051498413, -0.027908325, 0.024551392, 0.010444641, 0.023651123, 0.006351471, 0.03201294, -0.0059394836, -0.004787445, -0.013259888, 0.027633667, 0.000022470951, 0.01550293, 0.02609253, -0.026733398, 0.01727295, 0.03515625, 0.010925293, -0.024932861, 0.0019836426, -0.00045990944, -0.010757446, -0.029129028, -0.06384277, -0.014205933, 0.026977539, 0.0052757263, -0.020858765, -0.009300232, -0.016952515, 0.0093307495, -0.005306244, -0.02973938, 0.011230469, -0.0024337769, -0.003019333, 0.0063438416, -0.009513855, -0.026260376, -0.018844604, -0.026992798, 0.021224976, 0.026885986, 0.00920105, -0.0057525635, 0.0043296814, -0.030700684, -0.056121826, 0.026443481, -0.05606079, -0.083862305, -0.005970001, -0.04989624, 0.021514893, 0.055236816, -0.01033783, -0.012825012, 0.04901123, -0.038604736, 0.016906738, 0.012496948, -0.020233154, -0.020599365, 0.0008659363, -0.020553589, 0.020050049, 0.00844574, 0.0025939941, -0.007522583, 0.013023376, 0.009750366, -0.021453857, -0.014770508, 0.004611969, -0.013259888, 0.032318115, -0.048706055, -0.012710571, -0.0034065247, 0.032592773, -0.008178711, 0.016998291, 0.0012407303, 0.0019369125, -0.009284973, -0.0051612854, -0.053894043, 0.014160156, 0.027145386, -0.010299683, -0.014656067, 0.019378662, -0.009048462, -0.017913818, 0.0070228577, -0.0023918152, -0.04171753, -0.028671265, 0.017089844, 0.03616333, -0.026626587, -0.0017852783, -0.03704834, -0.0056877136, -0.018753052, -0.0146484375, -0.041625977, -0.006793976, 0.0000885725, 0.011909485, -0.004299164, 0.036468506, -0.017730713, -0.04135132, 0.022888184, -0.035125732, -0.041931152, 0.010231018, -0.04031372, -0.05130005, 0.030395508, -0.024841309, -0.0058021545, 0.012626648, -0.009033203, -0.052001953, 0.017562866, 0.026779175, 0.037719727, -0.06732178, -0.07269287, -0.0068511963, 0.033233643, 0.010353088, -0.019332886, 0.024978638, 0.012611389, -0.017074585, 0.019485474, 0.0010662079, 0.019195557, -0.014518738, 0.01499176, 0.01802063, 0.0036315918, -0.0032672882, 0.05618286, 0.0060043335, 0.016723633, -0.038879395, -0.061279297, 0.0014734268, 0.0022850037, 0.015457153, 0.0345459, 0.04171753, 0.011177063, 0.05154419, 0.014633179, -0.046569824, -0.046722412, 0.007293701, -0.03552246, -0.06793213, 0.113098145, -0.023986816, -0.015571594, -0.0032539368, 0.015930176, 0.010787964, -0.020339966, 0.04144287, 0.012481689, -0.015037537, -0.021850586, 0.009765625, 0.016998291, 0.03475952, -0.021240234, -0.0069618225, 0.024246216, 0.04574585, 0.02947998, 0.0005078316, 0.007385254, 0.0022830963, 0.009338379, 0.011100769, 0.0082092285, -0.007247925, -0.00459671, -0.024475098, -0.008598328, -0.039978027, -0.020874023, 0.023010254, 0.05429077, -0.047546387, 0.0015563965, 0.005340576, 0.009269714, -0.012550354, 0.0059776306, -0.03161621, 0.011802673, 0.0104522705, 0.0066452026, -0.0048942566, 0.060577393, -0.037017822, -0.015296936, 0.03527832, -0.026412964, 0.031311035, -0.008110046, -0.0000885129, 0.014198303, -0.02444458, -0.0038719177, -0.030029297, 0.023605347, -0.033691406, 0.024230957, 0.031097412, 0.04837036, 0.020111084, -0.022491455, 0.04006958, -0.037078857, -0.0071258545, 0.0047187805, -0.015556335, 0.048919678, 0.014129639, -0.008430481, 0.06112671, 0.025970459, -0.058410645, 0.023712158, 0.0008802414, 0.031982422, -0.064453125, -0.012863159, 0.0016727448, 0.013183594, -0.015457153, -0.04046631, -0.023986816, 0.0052986145, 0.02029419, 0.015556335, 0.029083252, 0.038879395, -0.03149414, 0.0062294006, 0.040008545, -0.029296875, 0.010269165, -0.022064209, 0.028900146, 0.048950195, 0.06347656, 0.0335083, -0.016174316, -0.030960083, 0.01096344, 0.028289795, -0.05038452, 0.016464233, 0.0289917, -0.006504059, 0.06304932, 0.022827148, -0.024963379, 0.02267456, 0.045898438, -0.036010742, 0.030197144, 0.038848877, 0.03338623, 0.02420044, -0.03945923, 0.0046195984, 0.0017147064, 0.046905518, 0.02027893, -0.061950684, -0.014884949, -0.050079346, 0.04736328, -0.06488037, 0.01309967, -0.029312134, -0.046905518, -0.038116455, 0.016159058, 0.026321411, -0.036010742, -0.016677856, -0.04458618, -0.021499634, -0.040100098, -0.027679443, 0.022766113, -0.007106781, -0.050811768, -0.012466431, 0.011627197, 0.029022217, -0.013786316, -0.0073280334, 0.07324219, -0.015838623, -0.008758545, -0.04135132, -0.0138549805, -0.012290955, 0.028884888, -0.009780884, 0.006576538, 0.031036377, -0.008560181, -0.06341553, 0.0146102905, -0.016860962, -0.03918457, 0.024032593, 0.07098389, -0.00001591444, -0.044433594, -0.0028209686, -0.0034942627, 0.0390625, -0.033325195, 0.015357971, 0.04458618, -0.0042037964, 0.020462036, 0.013061523, 0.044952393, 0.023040771, 0.005970001, -0.03918457, 0.007030487, 0.0065612793, 0.038604736, -0.018096924, -0.030944824, 0.024429321, 0.02482605, 0.015853882, -0.01838684, -0.026306152, -0.026107788, 0.029510498, 0.003955841, 0.01914978, -0.007881165, 0.046447754, 0.04244995, -0.0011262894, 0.017868042, -0.0060539246, 0.04257202, 0.023544312, -0.05618286, 0.0035686493, -0.010292053, 0.042663574, 0.0037670135, -0.017807007, 0.013290405, -0.04522705, -0.057525635, 0.016494751, 0.0067443848, -0.016082764, -0.019378662, -0.019500732, 0.0028800964, -0.025161743, -0.05456543, -0.033325195, -0.01889038, 0.04034424, 0.018035889, 0.008613586, -0.018341064, 0.04714966, 0.023620605, -0.012886047, 0.012062073, 0.019256592, 0.03466797, -0.025253296, -0.01927185, -0.012237549, -0.006023407, -0.003255844, -0.03463745, -0.005378723, 0.02508545, -0.043670654, 0.0013017654, -0.001964569, -0.053222656, 0.019256592, 0.010871887, -0.004524231, 0.0021419525, 0.007293701, -0.0082092285, -0.012481689, 0.012969971 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07453v1
ChartCheck: An Evidence-Based Fact-Checking Dataset over Real-World Chart Images
Mubashara Akhtar, Nikesh Subedi, Vivek Gupta, Sahar Tahmasebi, Oana Cocarascu, Elena Simperl
cs.CL, cs.CV
Data visualizations are common in the real-world. We often use them in data sources such as scientific documents, news articles, textbooks, and social media to summarize key information in a visual form. Charts can also mislead its audience by communicating false information or biasing them towards a specific agenda. Verifying claims against charts is not a straightforward process. It requires analyzing both the text and visual components of the chart, considering characteristics such as colors, positions, and orientations. Moreover, to determine if a claim is supported by the chart content often requires different types of reasoning. To address this challenge, we introduce ChartCheck, a novel dataset for fact-checking against chart images. ChartCheck is the first large-scale dataset with 1.7k real-world charts and 10.5k human-written claims and explanations. We evaluated the dataset on state-of-the-art models and achieved an accuracy of 73.9 in the finetuned setting. Additionally, we identified chart characteristics and reasoning types that challenge the models.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07453v1
2023-11-13T16:35:29
2023-11-13T16:35:29
{ "title": [ 0.016571045, -0.0018224716, -0.035614014, -0.05831909, 0.005138397, -0.021408081, -0.026367188, -0.02331543, -0.00022161007, 0.028747559, -0.017562866, 0.0029182434, -0.0059661865, -0.028579712, -0.03817749, 0.00050115585, 0.0035877228, 0.03918457, 0.0015850067, -0.027801514, -0.018341064, -0.029953003, 0.028762817, 0.032958984, -0.0017299652, -0.021987915, 0.024902344, -0.00111866, -0.027862549, -0.042816162, -0.008857727, 0.005519867, 0.022903442, 0.040374756, -0.023010254, 0.044708252, -0.057678223, 0.059631348, 0.01600647, 0.022064209, 0.015434265, -0.0010099411, 0.017700195, -0.036987305, -0.03744507, 0.046081543, -0.067993164, -0.0067329407, -0.027816772, 0.07989502, 0.009559631, 0.030471802, -0.018157959, 0.07885742, 0.021911621, -0.023468018, -0.04260254, -0.026809692, 0.028945923, 0.06555176, 0.03552246, -0.05859375, 0.02319336, -0.014984131, -0.046051025, -0.028686523, -0.0032348633, 0.026107788, 0.048034668, -0.019485474, -0.0057640076, 0.030075073, 0.009605408, -0.0044403076, -0.023742676, -0.0014066696, 0.024108887, 0.019073486, 0.027908325, -0.008392334, -0.0040283203, -0.02684021, 0.007381439, -0.005935669, -0.015655518, -0.02949524, -0.012939453, -0.010658264, -0.037506104, -0.071899414, -0.006122589, -0.018325806, -0.050567627, 0.03616333, -0.0070724487, -0.027069092, 0.008224487, 0.092163086, -0.029510498, -0.034423828, -0.0725708, 0.056762695, -0.12310791, -0.013946533, 0.027877808, 0.00944519, -0.02949524, -0.0178833, 0.03869629, 0.04269409, -0.004257202, 0.049682617, -0.03933716, -0.071777344, 0.020523071, 0.07873535, 0.00014066696, 0.014312744, 0.024505615, 0.029037476, 0.0030765533, -0.019134521, 0.014907837, 0.015899658, 0.0435791, 0.009315491, -0.053649902, 0.014579773, -0.04360962, 0.05783081, 0.0023155212, 0.039916992, -0.05960083, -0.06439209, -0.043182373, 0.021026611, -0.012771606, -0.014251709, -0.0022602081, 0.021408081, 0.006362915, -0.023788452, 0.02407837, -0.0025730133, 0.003786087, 0.005722046, 0.06628418, -0.002494812, -0.05154419, -0.034851074, -0.020889282, 0.04324341, 0.028320312, -0.028259277, -0.031829834, -0.026412964, -0.12322998, -0.016021729, 0.01991272, 0.0096588135, 0.035308838, -0.013969421, -0.027175903, -0.0022068024, 0.0048446655, 0.011741638, -0.014129639, 0.013374329, 0.009719849, 0.005142212, -0.030471802, 0.0090408325, 0.0034179688, -0.004524231, 0.00080156326, 0.019485474, 0.037902832, 0.0141067505, 0.0008802414, 0.03668213, 0.01247406, -0.019958496, 0.0039787292, 0.034729004, -0.058929443, -0.047576904, 0.02029419, -0.008171082, 0.039855957, 0.015380859, -0.000626564, 0.017913818, -0.012779236, -0.037628174, -0.04547119, -0.008918762, -0.007167816, 0.03652954, -0.035491943, 0.009162903, -0.017684937, 0.028762817, -0.044647217, 0.03668213, -0.0037612915, -0.02670288, -0.0053596497, 0.0008749962, -0.06573486, 0.082214355, 0.07128906, 0.018249512, -0.05886841, 0.053253174, 0.0597229, -0.09503174, 0.020645142, -0.03213501, -0.010658264, -0.050872803, 0.0036411285, -0.0064201355, 0.014198303, 0.057861328, 0.0104904175, -0.017868042, 0.013671875, -0.05130005, 0.023269653, -0.0050849915, 0.08270264, -0.022506714, 0.041809082, 0.015541077, 0.0010147095, -0.021697998, -0.014053345, -0.07696533, 0.0076293945, 0.043762207, 0.011123657, 0.0034255981, -0.01637268, 0.027267456, 0.045532227, -0.022460938, 0.0029449463, 0.023468018, 0.024536133, 0.024658203, 0.067993164, 0.006122589, 0.038848877, 0.042633057, -0.0047798157, 0.03729248, 0.0071640015, 0.017486572, -0.04425049, 0.00894165, 0.009002686, 0.043121338, -0.010810852, 0.016403198, -0.028045654, -0.012939453, -0.014892578, 0.012054443, 0.006011963, -0.011474609, 0.020324707, -0.023040771, 0.009811401, 0.007259369, 0.0029907227, 0.007129669, -0.02029419, 0.0037765503, 0.034576416, -0.03427124, -0.0069999695, -0.013595581, 0.048034668, 0.008682251, 0.041625977, 0.005470276, 0.031402588, -0.014312744, -0.017120361, -0.021438599, 0.03100586, 0.017730713, 0.011787415, -0.009300232, 0.042175293, -0.025787354, 0.04345703, 0.04019165, -0.015403748, 0.014312744, -0.058380127, 0.01739502, 0.005443573, -0.0027599335, -0.0012807846, 0.02809143, 0.013038635, 0.012184143, -0.025009155, -0.031066895, -0.010597229, 0.045318604, 0.0023097992, -0.07128906, -0.040863037, -0.051086426, -0.040283203, -0.061340332, -0.08099365, -0.012580872, 0.052856445, 0.0018901825, -0.04638672, -0.0018119812, -0.0041542053, -0.004005432, -0.008216858, -0.03451538, -0.02671814, 0.04510498, 0.04559326, 0.033172607, -0.038482666, -0.012016296, -0.001209259, 0.015045166, -0.011878967, 0.018371582, -0.025268555, -0.025390625, -0.0206604, -0.010932922, 0.021820068, -0.028244019, 0.008651733, -0.051879883, 0.024291992, 0.029815674, -0.030700684, -0.000022888184, 0.021636963, -0.03793335, -0.034362793, -0.0058631897, 0.02507019, -0.012275696, 0.0019741058, -0.0073509216, 0.015930176, -0.028213501, -0.0049705505, 0.023040771, -0.019012451, -0.05065918, -0.008224487, -0.04663086, -0.022140503, 0.0048713684, 0.04449463, 0.091308594, -0.033050537, 0.03567505, -0.04244995, -0.018371582, -0.008354187, -0.020721436, -0.057006836, -0.056243896, -0.0019798279, -0.053588867, -0.014556885, -0.017440796, 0.005065918, 0.021438599, 0.06665039, -0.009925842, -0.007865906, 0.049560547, 0.0116119385, 0.0046653748, -0.028442383, 0.01222229, -0.02178955, -0.0048828125, -0.0015583038, 0.0048828125, 0.025253296, 0.014678955, -0.068481445, -0.004825592, -0.029418945, 0.0047569275, -0.022842407, -0.011436462, -0.045806885, -0.024658203, -0.040283203, -0.051818848, 0.031585693, 0.030471802, -0.0107040405, 0.0435791, -0.017654419, 0.01486969, -0.005970001, -0.036315918, -0.09100342, 0.03579712, -0.053222656, -0.011520386, 0.007484436, -0.005832672, -0.030349731, 0.0043563843, -0.012336731, 0.0395813, 0.014549255, 0.037719727, -0.0070228577, -0.04525757, -0.013587952, -0.048187256, -0.0036392212, -0.02746582, -0.0013380051, 0.0043754578, -0.030929565, 0.06124878, -0.013397217, 0.010116577, -0.031311035, -0.032806396, -0.004508972, 0.031707764, -0.0076065063, -0.020324707, -0.027435303, 0.002363205, 0.024429321, 0.025650024, -0.006538391, -0.013542175, -0.004436493, -0.00028586388, -0.037597656, -0.021240234, 0.023727417, 0.027786255, -0.020477295, -0.008865356, 0.025772095, -0.016357422, -0.04748535, 0.012191772, 0.0113220215, 0.00969696, 0.0035991669, -0.011016846, -0.010879517, -0.012046814, -0.011505127, 0.031341553, 0.010261536, 0.013542175, -0.00315094, -0.013420105, -0.028213501, 0.029678345, -0.031280518, 0.02406311, 0.046081543, -0.009376526, 0.030426025, -0.0637207, 0.0015621185, 0.00762558, -0.11981201, -0.03378296, 0.033569336, -0.012229919, -0.046661377, -0.064208984, 0.031311035, -0.023895264, -0.038391113, 0.042053223, -0.006828308, 0.008460999, -0.017852783, -0.097717285, -0.004425049, 0.058013916, -0.011726379, 0.050964355, 0.060760498, 0.0028495789, -0.015380859, -0.03289795, 0.004890442, 0.035308838, 0.037902832, -0.0079574585, -0.011047363, 0.015022278, -0.024307251, 0.03338623, -0.011253357, -0.020950317, -0.007183075, 0.022476196, 0.022628784, 0.03414917, -0.034606934, 0.04171753, 0.030303955, -0.033599854, -0.052215576, 0.01576233, -0.0069351196, -0.027618408, 0.02267456, -0.023483276, -0.007369995, 0.008239746, 0.041870117, 0.05316162, -0.0234375, -0.028259277, 0.013931274, -0.002216339, -0.016174316, -0.007633209, 0.0053710938, 0.030853271, 0.007713318, -0.0126953125, 0.009689331, 0.019744873, 0.005886078, -0.028076172, -0.007171631, 0.0019035339, -0.060668945, -0.009033203, -0.057037354, -0.019744873, -0.03692627, 0.033966064, -0.01638794, 0.016952515, 0.011222839, -0.018371582, -0.03074646, 0.012687683, -0.00035119057, -0.0024356842, -0.0010623932, -0.0473938, 0.029937744, -0.022155762, -0.033813477, -0.04147339, -0.030380249, -0.017913818, 0.043182373, 0.004962921, 0.0042495728, 0.03967285, 0.0032997131, 0.014953613, 0.031219482, -0.006755829, -0.0099105835, 0.06817627, -0.013923645, -0.016952515, -0.0036525726, -0.0082092285, -0.030853271, -0.04168701, -0.018798828, 0.003955841, -0.024932861, -0.008094788, 0.03677368, -0.0063552856, 0.03845215, -0.006919861, 0.04510498, 0.035339355, 0.011062622, 0.0066337585, 0.006801605, -0.02571106, -0.024856567, 0.02810669, 0.03375244, 0.013496399, 0.04031372, 0.028839111, -0.010391235, -0.004108429, -0.033203125, 0.03668213, -0.016433716, -0.022583008, 0.008201599, 0.009399414, -0.05630493, -0.025604248, -0.0033740997, -0.009689331, 0.035125732, -0.06201172, 0.030532837, -0.010169983, 0.0069465637, 0.020828247, -0.0055351257, 0.012016296, 0.0051345825, 0.016616821, -0.045288086, -0.057556152, -0.0045318604, 0.032836914, -0.018539429, -0.016189575, -0.007545471, 0.027526855, 0.012886047, 0.06713867, 0.049041748, 0.0037155151, 0.0008568764, -0.0135650635, -0.0032482147, -0.03173828, -0.045043945, 0.034088135, 0.040039062, 0.023544312, -0.06781006, -0.01977539, -0.009887695, -0.03164673, 0.006641388, 0.0023117065, 0.0026779175, -0.05697632, 0.04550171, 0.068115234, 0.008560181, 0.034118652, 0.0057525635, 0.020309448, 0.03744507, 0.039916992, 0.019073486, -0.003376007, 0.023956299, -0.03427124, -0.0027980804, 0.021850586, 0.018325806, 0.007545471, 0.03289795, 0.014793396, -0.0141067505, -0.03314209, 0.022842407, -0.012863159, -0.034088135, 0.021026611, -0.04574585, 0.00059223175, -0.027572632, 0.028015137, 0.010307312, 0.000016093254, -0.038146973, -0.02456665, -0.0036888123, -0.05682373, 0.007888794, 0.00016522408, -0.016662598, -0.068481445, -0.011520386, -0.012962341, 0.033172607, -0.013496399, 0.018417358, -0.044769287, 0.034118652, 0.030090332, -0.046142578, -0.015541077, 0.0010995865, 0.0004169941, 0.025314331, 0.029876709, -0.050048828, -0.021896362, -0.0018835068, -0.039520264, -0.005630493, -0.015655518, 0.006580353, 0.010131836, -0.01838684, -0.06726074, -0.022064209, 0.011489868, 0.02822876, -0.022384644, -0.0067481995, 0.013809204, 0.012176514, 0.0149002075, 0.016845703, -0.0127334595, 0.0109939575, 0.0044441223, 0.019073486, -0.061462402, 0.0064849854, -0.004169464, -0.010101318, -0.01651001, -0.08203125, 0.025177002, -0.00014925003, 0.0065460205, 0.0018148422, 0.042144775, 0.03640747, 0.029159546, 0.022399902, 0.020141602, 0.06738281, -0.030426025, -0.05444336, -0.03894043, 0.0074920654, -0.031204224, 0.044525146, -0.02067566, -0.054595947, -0.015007019, -0.040771484, -0.020843506, 0.004047394, 0.0032615662, 0.01209259, 0.014389038, -0.018051147, 0.039001465, -0.03475952, -0.0039978027, -0.03540039, 0.046447754, -0.016860962, -0.013008118, -0.015304565, -0.015403748, 0.0062675476, -0.014587402, 0.0019168854, 0.00026464462, -0.019989014, 0.0033283234, -0.032043457, 0.020553589, -0.032440186, 0.004261017, 0.04449463, 0.031799316, -0.043395996, 0.011291504, 0.011772156, 0.059692383, 0.029922485, 0.027755737, 0.017410278, 0.019256592, 0.030273438, 0.006587982, 0.012954712, -0.021255493, -0.018310547, -0.034210205, -0.01826477, -0.034423828, -0.009628296, -0.05923462, 0.012039185, 0.007904053, 0.011550903, 0.015975952, -0.0019741058, 0.026794434, 0.022659302, 0.0124053955, -0.003774643, 0.02671814, -0.0016536713, 0.0039482117, 0.0049362183, -0.019607544, 0.008483887, 0.032989502, -0.01486969, 0.025497437, -0.00907135, -0.009101868, -0.0023002625, 0.0132751465, 0.021255493, -0.036193848, -0.013618469, -0.032348633, 0.052978516, 0.024383545, 0.05078125, 0.05178833, 0.032287598, -0.023223877, -0.02758789, 0.00080251694, 0.01348114, -0.017486572, -0.0031852722, 0.06323242, -0.051605225, 0.01007843, -0.024459839, -0.02909851, 0.014427185, 0.008850098, 0.0440979, -0.08074951, -0.07092285, 0.051361084, 0.029586792, 0.0047569275, -0.014038086, -0.043121338, -0.026626587, -0.011833191, 0.0076065063, 0.0020256042, 0.002117157, 0.016952515, 0.047790527, 0.0034179688, 0.00077819824, 0.023147583, -0.0046157837, 0.031188965, 0.034423828, -0.043029785, 0.052368164, -0.030975342, -0.041931152, 0.0019779205, 0.016021729, -0.07043457, -0.03326416, 0.02986145, -0.005996704, -0.0036945343, 0.0435791, 0.010108948, -0.023925781, -0.029891968, -0.027023315, -0.0029411316, 0.08996582, -0.005882263, 0.04837036, -0.052612305, -0.052093506, 0.051757812, -0.014595032, 0.1027832, -0.026290894, 0.016159058, -0.01689148, -0.0027198792, 0.043670654, -0.044525146, 0.0046043396, -0.0029125214, -0.014823914, 0.0043182373, -0.026016235, -0.046295166, -0.0063552856, 0.0025024414, 0.008056641, 0.033355713, -0.0038604736, 0.0018730164, -0.021377563, -0.041931152, 0.0073890686, -0.024917603, 0.037475586, -0.009681702, -0.0099487305, -0.037597656, -0.0008363724, 0.0082473755, 0.011688232, -0.007896423, 0.010414124, -0.072265625, -0.027038574, 0.008987427, 0.0032634735, -0.014564514, -0.003818512, -0.03414917, 0.01979065, -0.029449463, 0.009407043, 0.036254883, -0.043701172, -0.023864746, 0.0066871643, -0.038513184, 0.060302734, 0.02166748, -0.01979065, 0.017654419, 0.018615723, -0.03262329, -0.035125732, -0.018081665, 0.009056091, 0.010177612, -0.034606934, -0.03024292, 0.039367676, 0.028671265, -0.05895996, -0.08258057, 0.024337769, 0.040649414, -0.043029785, 0.038085938, 0.054473877, 0.00005865097, 0.023742676, 0.007865906, 0.0039100647, -0.0362854, -0.019500732, -0.022216797, 0.041625977, 0.05227661, -0.006954193, -0.0067443848, 0.041534424, -0.0014705658, 0.0036392212, 0.0039482117, -0.010009766, 0.009300232, 0.013008118, 0.061340332, -0.014884949, -0.016906738, 0.0072669983, 0.0126953125, -0.006160736, 0.021026611, -0.027877808, 0.006919861, -0.020690918, 0.016281128, -0.022781372, -0.045898438, 0.031173706, 0.013061523, 0.009750366, 0.0014038086, 0.00573349, 0.004463196, 0.0041656494, -0.024993896, -0.016113281, -0.018692017, 0.027755737, -0.032440186, -0.004837036, -0.03845215, -0.033996582, 0.0025749207, -0.025497437, 0.054870605, -0.021774292, -0.0061416626, -0.019561768, -0.010818481, 0.0074157715, 0.020706177, 0.008087158, -0.016662598, -0.040618896, -0.053100586, 0.026138306, -0.014823914 ], "summary": [ 0.046020508, -0.008621216, -0.0043907166, -0.044311523, 0.0051002502, -0.014656067, -0.023773193, -0.02305603, 0.0070343018, 0.022155762, -0.04055786, 0.0033893585, -0.020217896, -0.016967773, -0.022079468, -0.03543091, 0.011726379, 0.022872925, 0.043640137, 0.00699234, 0.020217896, -0.010955811, 0.019470215, 0.03729248, -0.027069092, 0.011123657, 0.060913086, 0.0357666, -0.03137207, -0.010093689, 0.00035738945, -0.015289307, 0.00945282, 0.03137207, -0.0418396, 0.04699707, -0.024368286, 0.033081055, 0.015655518, 0.024017334, 0.022125244, -0.0046539307, 0.103515625, -0.028442383, -0.00049829483, 0.062316895, -0.012580872, -0.027008057, 0.009529114, 0.052856445, 0.0129852295, 0.04019165, -0.0029201508, 0.054473877, 0.006023407, 0.0101623535, -0.0011692047, -0.050842285, 0.01361084, 0.0236969, 0.019699097, -0.013557434, 0.020080566, -0.0040664673, -0.02746582, -0.005970001, -0.0035133362, 0.011779785, 0.013618469, -0.028533936, 0.0063438416, 0.0019407272, 0.025375366, -0.02670288, -0.005947113, 0.03439331, -0.00023412704, 0.03125, 0.01612854, -0.016921997, -0.0023612976, -0.022354126, -0.0030345917, -0.0044898987, -0.033843994, -0.01763916, -0.0019083023, 0.000854969, -0.01586914, -0.036987305, -0.022399902, -0.011741638, -0.049224854, 0.03579712, -0.0035572052, -0.03286743, 0.009178162, 0.045898438, -0.055786133, -0.038269043, -0.055999756, 0.031799316, -0.123046875, 0.0066604614, 0.012580872, 0.021636963, -0.02368164, -0.008399963, 0.052093506, 0.040985107, 0.015167236, 0.023895264, -0.06262207, -0.08111572, 0.012268066, 0.08148193, -0.029891968, 0.034698486, 0.025939941, 0.038085938, 0.001616478, 0.013595581, -0.036865234, 0.053894043, 0.05065918, 0.045318604, -0.010902405, 0.015686035, -0.049591064, 0.04849243, -0.0234375, 0.003112793, 0.030227661, 0.016235352, -0.01826477, -0.024765015, 0.0014457703, 0.0021820068, 0.0012569427, 0.00047945976, 0.03390503, -0.020324707, 0.004383087, 0.023269653, 0.020812988, 0.016052246, 0.024978638, 0.0075683594, -0.025436401, -0.022003174, 0.024658203, 0.023925781, 0.014671326, -0.02557373, -0.01751709, -0.04800415, -0.052124023, -0.0007195473, 0.010848999, 0.008239746, 0.012252808, -0.01096344, -0.015274048, -0.013122559, -0.0368042, 0.01864624, -0.018157959, 0.0032920837, 0.010856628, -0.04989624, 0.0014104843, -0.010566711, 0.021850586, -0.01574707, 0.014541626, 0.028701782, 0.028533936, 0.011047363, -0.0116119385, 0.051086426, 0.025100708, -0.029373169, 0.004589081, 0.003112793, -0.03668213, -0.009269714, 0.02659607, 0.022598267, 0.020935059, 0.012588501, 0.020050049, 0.011764526, 0.014862061, 0.017166138, -0.015945435, -0.027328491, -0.018203735, 0.010971069, -0.031982422, -0.0015735626, 0.0769043, 0.023605347, 0.008773804, 0.0066947937, -0.052856445, 0.014419556, -0.017822266, -0.00013589859, -0.06097412, 0.08129883, 0.04763794, -0.005256653, -0.06677246, 0.12927246, 0.105285645, -0.052612305, 0.02494812, -0.027328491, -0.011528015, -0.0769043, 0.039611816, 0.010818481, -0.002439499, 0.071777344, -0.02861023, -0.025054932, 0.0053215027, -0.012054443, -0.0028438568, -0.021774292, 0.08123779, 0.00082826614, 0.069885254, 0.043060303, 0.0024051666, -0.015090942, 0.040893555, -0.13647461, -0.0021438599, 0.05722046, 0.028213501, 0.025482178, -0.04208374, -0.033569336, -0.020874023, -0.047210693, 0.00073575974, -0.019058228, -0.017166138, 0.035949707, 0.03778076, 0.0209198, 0.0011987686, 0.028671265, 0.0023403168, -0.0012388229, -0.00037312508, 0.019927979, -0.051635742, 0.0038452148, 0.008781433, 0.05166626, -0.0057754517, 0.019042969, 0.027633667, -0.035827637, -0.0017328262, -0.015449524, 0.0002706051, -0.029830933, 0.006465912, -0.058532715, -0.004547119, 0.0058135986, 0.0050811768, 0.014442444, -0.046325684, 0.0078125, 0.030181885, 0.0070610046, -0.00093078613, -0.056732178, -0.016937256, -0.0127334595, 0.048553467, 0.020568848, 0.018630981, -0.011062622, 0.009033203, 0.034057617, 0.045776367, 0.016357422, 0.019607544, -0.014549255, 0.043914795, -0.008102417, 0.0066070557, -0.0021095276, 0.018325806, -0.032409668, 0.009384155, 0.03643799, -0.036468506, 0.03366089, 0.0046043396, 0.0030937195, 0.0057029724, 0.004470825, 0.01083374, -0.052978516, 0.030090332, 0.06951904, 0.017913818, -0.023132324, -0.019989014, -0.024963379, -0.045806885, -0.0023288727, -0.06274414, -0.030563354, 0.07873535, 0.033203125, -0.05529785, 0.006164551, 0.0016517639, -0.004299164, 0.014274597, -0.029632568, -0.045440674, -0.00021457672, 0.032196045, -0.014625549, 0.012786865, 0.029296875, 0.0048942566, -0.026351929, -0.0077056885, 0.023208618, -0.020050049, -0.01727295, -0.018188477, -0.03314209, 0.0256958, -0.0044555664, -0.015838623, -0.014793396, 0.034698486, 0.017868042, 0.003370285, -0.0048828125, 0.016342163, -0.03265381, -0.015083313, -0.0053253174, -0.017456055, 0.019882202, 0.007637024, -0.04147339, -0.014533997, -0.04650879, -0.006324768, 0.019165039, -0.021484375, -0.028884888, -0.034210205, -0.012771606, -0.013595581, 0.038513184, 0.07067871, 0.09539795, 0.0054473877, 0.08105469, -0.016677856, -0.022354126, -0.02671814, -0.05078125, -0.013168335, -0.051483154, 0.055480957, 0.00001257658, -0.016693115, -0.0032444, 0.025314331, 0.05621338, 0.05328369, -0.009712219, 0.022415161, 0.07299805, 0.015220642, 0.0018501282, -0.016067505, 0.013618469, 0.011230469, -0.015419006, -0.00025486946, -0.0054779053, 0.023284912, 0.033203125, -0.0040893555, -0.024246216, -0.0871582, -0.0075035095, 0.0058403015, -0.05218506, 0.009086609, -0.013710022, -0.043884277, -0.04623413, 0.021774292, 0.010131836, -0.0053749084, 0.008079529, -0.0076408386, 0.01058197, -0.004962921, -0.022964478, -0.016540527, 0.015930176, -0.046691895, -0.0027580261, -0.010131836, 0.044708252, 0.005569458, 0.01727295, -0.021392822, 0.026321411, -0.038604736, 0.030151367, -0.027755737, -0.025253296, -0.01020813, -0.032104492, 0.011558533, -0.010429382, 0.008331299, 0.014259338, -0.025024414, 0.011764526, -0.03161621, -0.015289307, -0.019088745, -0.033233643, -0.022338867, 0.0058898926, 0.004589081, -0.018951416, -0.01966858, -0.030593872, 0.07122803, 0.076416016, -0.018676758, -0.006832123, 0.0335083, 0.0022678375, -0.067993164, -0.06628418, -0.00459671, 0.041778564, 0.03488159, -0.022720337, 0.01197052, -0.031143188, 0.00020623207, 0.010505676, 0.0109939575, 0.009017944, -0.012336731, 0.003829956, -0.040527344, 0.009269714, -0.0052719116, 0.022445679, 0.009147644, 0.013923645, 0.0012960434, 0.019561768, -0.010498047, 0.020706177, -0.0340271, 0.008308411, -0.002998352, 0.01727295, 0.014968872, -0.029724121, -0.026412964, 0.014808655, -0.06628418, -0.062561035, 0.011680603, 0.052764893, -0.0016832352, -0.03274536, 0.03866577, -0.00081014633, -0.029022217, 0.070739746, -0.020095825, 0.09857178, -0.031585693, -0.09246826, 0.05731201, -0.03100586, -0.017303467, 0.06591797, 0.02709961, 0.014793396, 0.008666992, -0.010070801, -0.0010795593, 0.017745972, 0.009254456, -0.028625488, 0.0028839111, -0.0025634766, -0.015716553, 0.05026245, -0.039245605, -0.037017822, -0.005970001, 0.02255249, 0.045654297, 0.064331055, -0.018447876, 0.009529114, 0.03527832, -0.034484863, -0.014518738, -0.00061273575, -0.018249512, -0.024307251, 0.015411377, 0.015548706, -0.03375244, -0.01398468, 0.035858154, 0.0025520325, -0.042144775, -0.0491333, -0.010810852, 0.035614014, -0.017242432, -0.03277588, -0.0032958984, 0.04724121, 0.014587402, -0.012535095, 0.020187378, 0.014335632, -0.02519226, -0.003314972, -0.028396606, -0.021347046, -0.082458496, -0.015655518, -0.020065308, 0.021209717, -0.07171631, 0.026931763, -0.011940002, 0.003753662, -0.018478394, 0.0046463013, -0.008857727, 0.015777588, -0.042877197, 0.02218628, -0.011360168, -0.042755127, 0.027191162, -0.020019531, -0.015136719, -0.022033691, -0.032073975, -0.061950684, 0.01449585, -0.02885437, 0.012565613, 0.0284729, -0.011154175, -0.005104065, 0.03692627, -0.0018167496, -0.011070251, 0.05029297, -0.028411865, 0.021240234, -0.003786087, -0.0076904297, -0.055389404, -0.03881836, -0.027236938, 0.024734497, -0.026733398, 0.0102005005, 0.00995636, -0.004005432, 0.02671814, -0.012283325, 0.040924072, 0.010498047, -0.0015449524, -0.0121154785, 0.001253128, -0.0099487305, 0.022979736, 0.01777649, 0.002275467, 0.029006958, 0.038482666, -0.0005645752, -0.035858154, -0.024932861, -0.03164673, 0.06640625, -0.019805908, -0.046447754, 0.033325195, -0.015350342, -0.02671814, -0.030822754, -0.008415222, -0.0048942566, 0.0063095093, -0.0073509216, -0.024505615, 0.00920105, 0.0413208, 0.024261475, -0.009727478, -0.018829346, -0.0019931793, -0.02128601, -0.003929138, -0.04812622, -0.0076675415, 0.0037994385, 0.014312744, -0.035888672, 0.0020618439, 0.04812622, 0.012161255, 0.014167786, -0.011627197, -0.009140015, -0.008407593, -0.0019416809, -0.0063171387, -0.020065308, -0.012481689, 0.017730713, -0.00045275688, -0.0043296814, -0.06878662, -0.038146973, 0.077941895, -0.050567627, 0.009613037, 0.006122589, 0.008865356, -0.0011377335, -0.0007009506, 0.059173584, -0.04135132, 0.016815186, 0.0116119385, -0.0034255981, 0.03164673, 0.021469116, -0.018569946, -0.006755829, -0.0035266876, -0.010971069, 0.0024642944, 0.017074585, 0.038391113, 0.020996094, 0.017028809, 0.020950317, -0.020187378, -0.014846802, 0.025817871, 0.024139404, -0.0140686035, -0.013969421, -0.027267456, 0.022445679, -0.050872803, 0.04940796, -0.027145386, -0.0031986237, -0.03164673, -0.0053596497, -0.008872986, -0.023376465, -0.009735107, -0.030334473, 0.017074585, -0.058410645, -0.03933716, -0.018997192, 0.0569458, -0.019256592, 0.015686035, -0.020767212, -0.008003235, 0.013053894, -0.02633667, 0.017181396, -0.00031471252, 0.0063209534, -0.0076408386, 0.023269653, -0.03289795, -0.023162842, -0.0045204163, -0.007156372, 0.002855301, -0.032348633, -0.009902954, 0.033355713, -0.024139404, -0.061767578, 0.019180298, 0.009353638, 0.023849487, -0.034698486, 0.0121154785, -0.0262146, 0.005821228, -0.010658264, 0.051818848, -0.03970337, -0.010368347, 0.020187378, 0.0011262894, -0.024978638, 0.001701355, -0.017532349, -0.023910522, -0.0368042, -0.09362793, 0.022491455, -0.0061302185, 0.0030288696, 0.040039062, 0.05404663, 0.025848389, 0.047576904, 0.038085938, 0.03643799, 0.029525757, -0.011817932, -0.03302002, -0.03010559, 0.022125244, -0.016967773, -0.015594482, -0.025344849, -0.029174805, 0.00920105, -0.034973145, 0.020202637, -0.017745972, -0.020462036, 0.030426025, 0.0074157715, -0.008041382, 0.03225708, -0.04586792, -0.0014123917, -0.0011196136, 0.02508545, -0.032440186, -0.012573242, -0.007980347, -0.0010156631, 0.009719849, 0.015701294, -0.00086927414, -0.020080566, -0.024673462, 0.020355225, -0.0015602112, 0.025756836, -0.04949951, 0.06518555, 0.02923584, 0.052978516, -0.04925537, -0.04849243, 0.07434082, 0.0357666, 0.029037476, -0.009002686, -0.032836914, -0.01864624, 0.03616333, 0.0061416626, 0.016479492, -0.002603531, -0.028793335, 0.028396606, -0.05984497, 0.005367279, -0.025466919, 0.032440186, 0.019470215, 0.0031013489, -0.035125732, 0.08123779, -0.016357422, 0.03845215, 0.053466797, -0.057250977, 0.024871826, -0.035461426, 0.0045166016, -0.0075798035, 0.041107178, -0.009147644, -0.022521973, 0.0340271, -0.0395813, 0.039978027, 0.0124053955, -0.0016269684, 0.028427124, 0.022232056, -0.046661377, -0.07287598, 0.037597656, -0.05355835, 0.047668457, 0.040222168, 0.06390381, 0.004699707, -0.015823364, 0.017623901, -0.027954102, -0.009719849, 0.04046631, 0.015113831, -0.019302368, 0.03930664, 0.0045661926, -0.030029297, 0.0027866364, -0.0060920715, 0.048034668, -0.012260437, 0.041107178, -0.059906006, -0.04852295, 0.022155762, 0.016494751, 0.018096924, -0.04135132, -0.047607422, -0.047790527, -0.02947998, 0.0058555603, -0.0017032623, -0.0026721954, 0.00422287, 0.040100098, 0.010421753, -0.005344391, 0.007637024, -0.021240234, 0.030380249, 0.028518677, -0.013290405, 0.025863647, -0.025527954, -0.025741577, -0.022827148, 0.026473999, -0.04852295, -0.03125, -0.01625061, 0.0030708313, 0.017074585, 0.020980835, -0.005847931, -0.010406494, 0.042053223, -0.01574707, -0.038513184, 0.069885254, 0.026351929, 0.012779236, -0.037475586, -0.008522034, 0.020095825, 0.048858643, 0.10626221, -0.010345459, 0.036865234, -0.0043182373, -0.03024292, -0.0038547516, -0.027923584, 0.042114258, -0.007358551, 0.0011167526, 0.016693115, -0.04058838, -0.07611084, 0.02935791, -0.010383606, -0.032104492, 0.03778076, -0.008300781, -0.0071258545, -0.0077285767, 0.008453369, 0.003818512, -0.0008087158, 0.04647827, 0.0135269165, -0.01713562, -0.020385742, 0.021972656, -0.020584106, 0.010353088, 0.02949524, 0.034576416, -0.042907715, -0.052337646, 0.01902771, 0.003501892, -0.023025513, -0.014717102, -0.061553955, 0.014076233, -0.028762817, 0.018814087, 0.055603027, -0.0093307495, -0.0020961761, 0.0056495667, -0.045410156, 0.031463623, -0.022155762, -0.004650116, 0.033477783, 0.0062675476, 0.00579834, -0.05456543, -0.025604248, -0.045318604, 0.02142334, -0.042053223, -0.009231567, 0.018676758, 0.049713135, -0.007232666, -0.05105591, 0.036499023, 0.03765869, -0.021728516, -0.021453857, 0.025665283, -0.008094788, 0.04168701, 0.010360718, 0.005130768, -0.033416748, -0.033111572, -0.017745972, 0.054840088, 0.020828247, -0.027862549, -0.023468018, 0.030349731, 0.0005340576, 0.0027256012, -0.023147583, 0.021728516, -0.018051147, 0.0051078796, 0.040222168, 0.0056762695, -0.04348755, 0.02180481, -0.03552246, -0.004173279, -0.020812988, -0.013015747, -0.019638062, -0.053466797, -0.009185791, -0.023910522, -0.02810669, -0.009490967, -0.012199402, 0.016296387, -0.025817871, 0.01713562, 0.0041542053, 0.013427734, -0.048736572, -0.0036888123, -0.0440979, 0.041900635, -0.04296875, -0.032440186, -0.056274414, 0.015548706, -0.029724121, -0.021209717, 0.030151367, -0.0050811768, -0.02230835, 0.012504578, -0.016052246, 0.035461426, 0.02029419, -0.015296936, 0.027923584, 0.016159058, -0.038970947, -0.036621094, -0.00016355515 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07445v1
Think Before You Speak: Cultivating Communication Skills of Large Language Models via Inner Monologue
Junkai Zhou, Liang Pang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
cs.CL, cs.AI
The emergence of large language models (LLMs) further improves the capabilities of open-domain dialogue systems and can generate fluent, coherent, and diverse responses. However, LLMs still lack an important ability: communication skills, which makes them more like information seeking tools than anthropomorphic chatbots. To make LLMs more anthropomorphic and proactive during the conversation, we add five communication skills to the response generation process: topic transition, proactively asking questions, concept guidance, empathy, and summarising often. The addition of communication skills increases the interest of users in the conversation and attracts them to chat for longer. To enable LLMs better understand and use communication skills, we design and add the inner monologue to LLMs. The complete process is achieved through prompt engineering and in-context learning. To evaluate communication skills, we construct a benchmark named Cskills for evaluating various communication skills, which can also more comprehensively evaluate the dialogue generation ability of the model. Experimental results show that the proposed CSIM strategy improves the backbone models and outperforms the baselines in both automatic and human evaluations.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07445v1
2023-11-13T16:19:42
2023-11-13T16:19:42
{ "title": [ -0.03552246, -0.020095825, -0.039794922, -0.018661499, -0.020874023, -0.015289307, -0.025100708, -0.0055770874, -0.03744507, 0.011016846, -0.009246826, 0.015716553, 0.004600525, -0.032073975, -0.0070228577, -0.0107803345, -0.012886047, 0.042053223, -0.0058784485, -0.03378296, -0.0004310608, -0.043395996, 0.026367188, -0.0024986267, 0.037994385, -0.04534912, -0.11773682, 0.018341064, -0.03604126, -0.011047363, -0.012817383, 0.031433105, 0.03363037, 0.03540039, -0.0345459, -0.028427124, -0.06585693, 0.02986145, -0.00724411, -0.012168884, 0.0051002502, 0.0034561157, -0.032836914, -0.0038146973, -0.059814453, 0.017700195, -0.06707764, -0.006252289, 0.0028038025, 0.022094727, -0.008216858, 0.047332764, -0.019744873, 0.012184143, 0.01939392, -0.0032691956, -0.02494812, -0.002790451, 0.024917603, 0.07232666, 0.02684021, -0.017837524, -0.0024261475, -0.037963867, -0.011779785, -0.0309906, -0.04284668, 0.03555298, 0.066833496, 0.023529053, -0.0256958, 0.014221191, 0.0036067963, -0.017562866, -0.014770508, 0.04815674, 0.017364502, 0.04345703, 0.03250122, -0.02809143, 0.0061149597, 0.012710571, 0.010696411, -0.027145386, 0.018432617, -0.03289795, -0.0073165894, -0.008972168, -0.020812988, -0.050567627, -0.011665344, -0.0050239563, 0.023971558, -0.01449585, -0.050750732, -0.016525269, -0.014022827, 0.010978699, -0.011260986, -0.01789856, -0.032592773, 0.030151367, -0.049957275, -0.021575928, 0.013427734, 0.015823364, -0.041015625, -0.042388916, 0.026885986, 0.046539307, -0.01701355, 0.021362305, 0.0008096695, -0.025238037, 0.017623901, 0.0095825195, -0.019882202, 0.038330078, 0.016571045, 0.038360596, 0.010513306, -0.016937256, 0.0023078918, 0.02532959, 0.034179688, 0.04196167, -0.030532837, -0.0107421875, 0.026031494, 0.027832031, 0.0064849854, 0.04196167, -0.10467529, -0.08258057, -0.058502197, 0.044281006, -0.014160156, 0.00040483475, -0.029174805, 0.027740479, -0.0011224747, -0.018630981, 0.033050537, -0.013633728, -0.014968872, 0.018722534, 0.06262207, -0.003730774, -0.07104492, -0.07141113, -0.0105896, -0.0010709763, 0.012374878, 0.0019016266, -0.07098389, 0.006252289, -0.13232422, 0.01939392, 0.014251709, 0.023361206, 0.009414673, -0.0055160522, -0.0026683807, 0.022827148, 0.024642944, 0.01838684, -0.0018701553, 0.006401062, 0.009864807, 0.045532227, -0.008087158, 0.0004222393, -0.0024166107, -0.018005371, -0.012763977, -0.00095939636, 0.010757446, 0.004501343, 0.030761719, -0.032684326, -0.009628296, -0.021438599, 0.011672974, 0.031555176, -0.04800415, -0.011421204, -0.004688263, 0.014038086, 0.05291748, 0.007587433, -0.029953003, 0.018066406, -0.034088135, -0.04638672, -0.050872803, -0.02319336, 0.058135986, 0.020095825, 0.0052948, 0.025161743, -0.022521973, -0.014007568, -0.027908325, -0.0062675476, -0.055145264, -0.023208618, -0.02798462, 0.028778076, 0.016799927, 0.041809082, 0.030395508, 0.018478394, -0.012054443, -0.024215698, -0.048675537, -0.04144287, 0.0014677048, 0.007068634, 0.00522995, -0.0010652542, -0.006755829, -0.016998291, 0.0066490173, 0.022033691, -0.0073509216, 0.0022888184, 0.003490448, -0.011962891, 0.0077667236, 0.0546875, -0.0074043274, -0.050598145, 0.02330017, 0.035369873, -0.018051147, -0.02835083, -0.022598267, -0.019989014, 0.019943237, 0.01687622, -0.004272461, -0.018630981, 0.010696411, 0.052215576, 0.015930176, -0.02609253, 0.0132751465, 0.0154800415, 0.018066406, -0.013336182, 0.04727173, 0.0007534027, 0.06555176, 0.007911682, 0.03250122, 0.03829956, -0.025253296, -0.02116394, -0.00447464, -0.013458252, 0.03640747, -0.008911133, -0.025741577, 0.0131073, -0.054138184, 0.028564453, -0.036590576, 0.007865906, 0.0053253174, 0.014053345, 0.032287598, -0.0463562, 0.009010315, -0.011398315, -0.0008382797, -0.02003479, -0.0236969, 0.025772095, 0.025131226, -0.053100586, -0.008613586, 0.011054993, 0.026565552, -0.008117676, 0.03314209, 0.027633667, 0.010894775, -0.03842163, -0.013084412, -0.022872925, 0.040405273, 0.0118255615, -0.015281677, 0.012611389, 0.017440796, -0.035064697, 0.07171631, 0.060333252, -0.015235901, 0.02909851, -0.015640259, 0.026367188, -0.0026988983, 0.002216339, 0.010498047, -0.04220581, 0.013145447, 0.014526367, -0.032989502, -0.0030002594, -0.048553467, 0.026672363, 0.012817383, -0.0059776306, -0.00440979, -0.018753052, 0.020187378, -0.010627747, 0.008003235, 0.004837036, 0.07183838, -0.022354126, -0.03152466, -0.016204834, -0.010231018, -0.015388489, -0.02720642, -0.040161133, 0.010063171, 0.013641357, 0.033843994, -0.005256653, -0.055633545, -0.059906006, 0.00067806244, 0.0073623657, -0.0017089844, -0.024749756, -0.018432617, 0.014984131, 0.013832092, -0.022262573, 0.022064209, -0.03375244, 0.0071144104, -0.068237305, -0.0022277832, 0.004722595, 0.029144287, 0.0039901733, -0.0027160645, 0.0075149536, -0.012321472, 0.016525269, 0.058044434, -0.017608643, -0.029434204, 0.042114258, 0.014633179, -0.020309448, 0.054626465, 0.014923096, 0.014083862, -0.043121338, -0.012397766, -0.04159546, -0.030456543, -0.010787964, -0.0040283203, 0.030807495, -0.045196533, 0.0028438568, -0.03591919, -0.0209198, -0.0057907104, 0.00579834, 0.040863037, -0.017791748, -0.046783447, 0.0011844635, -0.0065994263, 0.021026611, -0.04650879, 0.005870819, 0.11010742, -0.0082092285, 0.0018510818, -0.0025806427, 0.04763794, 0.016586304, -0.0078086853, -0.05444336, -0.062927246, 0.011299133, 0.022384644, 0.013168335, -0.016433716, -0.027389526, -0.10437012, -0.009399414, 0.06677246, -0.02835083, -0.042663574, 0.039031982, -0.08239746, 0.06021118, -0.0034046173, -0.008529663, 0.036499023, 0.021026611, -0.005455017, -0.003643036, 0.01260376, -0.047973633, 0.012145996, -0.026397705, -0.13781738, 0.03137207, -0.042877197, -0.0030136108, 0.0053100586, -0.019760132, -0.04373169, 0.0112838745, -0.00023555756, 0.048065186, 0.029373169, 0.0082092285, 0.0070343018, -0.026123047, -0.0013751984, -0.020965576, -0.0039711, 0.012191772, -0.035369873, 0.020874023, -0.015213013, 0.029571533, 0.032165527, -0.029708862, -0.025268555, -0.011703491, -0.01701355, 0.013908386, -0.012863159, -0.023147583, -0.023986816, -0.014808655, -0.025436401, -0.007926941, -0.018569946, 0.0137786865, -0.050048828, 0.013587952, -0.021728516, 0.020812988, 0.026641846, 0.022094727, -0.039123535, -0.027618408, 0.00945282, -0.013320923, -0.044036865, -0.00065660477, 0.022384644, -0.00046515465, 0.028564453, -0.0079574585, -0.027572632, 0.0146865845, -0.0028133392, 0.00233078, 0.027908325, 0.012298584, -0.024169922, -0.011650085, -0.0047950745, -0.004447937, -0.0042915344, -0.0014829636, -0.008308411, 0.021911621, -0.03353882, -0.07678223, -0.02935791, -0.0070152283, -0.11450195, -0.03616333, -0.0070533752, -0.017120361, -0.019042969, -0.03491211, 0.019302368, -0.02909851, -0.04336548, -0.00024533272, -0.016815186, -0.007949829, -0.00642395, -0.07110596, -0.025878906, 0.078125, -0.022537231, 0.011871338, 0.05331421, -0.029663086, -0.0095825195, 0.0002579689, 0.044006348, 0.04156494, 0.042388916, 0.022323608, -0.01259613, 0.023773193, -0.018554688, -0.01953125, 0.087402344, -0.022079468, 0.02798462, 0.027511597, 0.009262085, 0.03363037, -0.028366089, 0.04458618, 0.0042686462, 0.009674072, -0.08996582, 0.020111084, 0.018814087, -0.007194519, 0.024795532, -0.016601562, 0.007980347, 0.032806396, -0.007194519, 0.05795288, -0.011184692, 0.013938904, 0.05340576, -0.007583618, -0.01260376, -0.03213501, 0.0061302185, 0.016555786, 0.011711121, 0.0256958, 0.0039367676, 0.068603516, -0.029006958, 0.008666992, -0.0005159378, 0.010498047, -0.040252686, 0.0056152344, -0.05126953, -0.10296631, -0.05126953, 0.02394104, 0.0034980774, 0.037322998, 0.0491333, 0.01701355, -0.023757935, -0.008285522, 0.06921387, -0.00044584274, -0.025177002, -0.07434082, 0.015975952, -0.019058228, -0.059661865, -0.041870117, -0.008720398, -0.018127441, 0.019302368, -0.0008111, -0.029266357, 0.014442444, 0.030334473, 0.06896973, 0.047973633, -0.015075684, -0.06378174, 0.014663696, -0.03656006, -0.027755737, 0.03201294, 0.0047416687, -0.0047073364, 0.00072288513, 0.026947021, -0.029953003, -0.012145996, -0.030639648, 0.024505615, -0.012435913, 0.053955078, -0.037994385, 0.0026474, 0.021942139, 0.025344849, -0.00096559525, -0.003376007, -0.027709961, 0.004600525, -0.00041747093, 0.03955078, 0.012123108, -0.0071868896, 0.025146484, 0.041168213, 0.005115509, 0.0055351257, 0.0014810562, 0.011169434, 0.021316528, -0.0036621094, 0.005241394, -0.049346924, -0.03164673, -0.0076789856, -0.0107803345, 0.024139404, -0.023849487, 0.054473877, -0.034210205, -0.036254883, 0.02859497, 0.014038086, 0.02357483, 0.04284668, 0.019989014, -0.046325684, -0.043945312, 0.027114868, 0.03488159, -0.03378296, 0.029541016, -0.0015964508, 0.0010251999, 0.011703491, 0.05105591, 0.042785645, -0.00843811, 0.017089844, -0.019363403, -0.018447876, -0.00724411, -0.035705566, 0.009643555, 0.0077209473, 0.014945984, -0.06524658, 0.048858643, -0.0317688, 0.020629883, -0.0236969, -0.0007791519, 0.012229919, -0.03656006, 0.051605225, 0.099853516, -0.009613037, 0.048034668, -0.004081726, 0.00028276443, 0.0052261353, 0.06274414, -0.022262573, 0.020492554, 0.03390503, -0.060516357, 0.004676819, -0.00049591064, 0.038146973, 0.02130127, 0.016616821, 0.0027198792, 0.010665894, -0.038604736, 0.017990112, 0.021438599, -0.016723633, 0.030517578, -0.059783936, 0.021972656, 0.030822754, 0.0026187897, 0.0061912537, -0.010902405, -0.041107178, -0.0053634644, -0.026504517, -0.024597168, -0.0104522705, -0.03866577, -0.03967285, -0.038269043, 0.018325806, 0.0039711, 0.018478394, 0.0034751892, -0.014564514, -0.039489746, 0.017929077, 0.0129470825, -0.014724731, -0.005405426, -0.025909424, -0.022583008, 0.0129776, 0.040283203, -0.009902954, -0.006832123, -0.008728027, -0.013320923, 0.009292603, 0.021133423, 0.0069084167, 0.0036773682, -0.015556335, -0.01713562, -0.025283813, -0.006427765, 0.023849487, -0.027374268, -0.038757324, 0.02748108, -0.02078247, -0.018432617, 0.020050049, 0.009529114, -0.026794434, 0.021484375, 0.010398865, -0.0158844, 0.02180481, 0.0042381287, -0.0046424866, 0.0016956329, -0.06390381, 0.010665894, 0.013648987, 0.0015640259, -0.0046958923, 0.074035645, 0.03302002, -0.0034656525, -0.0023288727, 0.030563354, 0.042907715, -0.03302002, -0.02166748, 0.003824234, -0.008605957, -0.010734558, 0.053344727, 0.019500732, -0.012680054, -0.03466797, -0.04837036, -0.032470703, 0.0029506683, 0.019714355, 0.008361816, 0.005558014, 0.012741089, 0.027893066, -0.029815674, 0.009490967, -0.050933838, 0.026443481, -0.020584106, -0.023208618, 0.009208679, 0.018478394, -0.0007238388, -0.014625549, 0.048706055, 0.02017212, -0.014312744, 0.020065308, -0.012992859, 0.0012149811, -0.017547607, -0.039367676, 0.059051514, -0.0045700073, 0.0011854172, 0.059692383, -0.03036499, 0.034942627, 0.021102905, 0.08099365, 0.057006836, 0.030151367, -0.0012969971, 0.008796692, 0.015167236, -0.04348755, 0.030548096, -0.05380249, -0.013450623, -0.07684326, -0.030395508, -0.09057617, 0.0005469322, -0.0053138733, 0.027252197, 0.006511688, 0.014175415, 0.015197754, -0.017974854, 0.0289917, -0.0020065308, 0.049804688, -0.0034618378, 0.011360168, -0.0007972717, -0.034362793, 0.027572632, 0.049316406, -0.007408142, -0.005264282, -0.022262573, 0.002658844, 0.0076293945, -0.0047340393, 0.012168884, -0.031799316, -0.01272583, -0.025650024, -0.0073661804, -0.027526855, 0.021697998, 0.068725586, 0.036010742, -0.027297974, 0.003479004, 0.006122589, -0.027496338, -0.009170532, -0.027420044, 0.024719238, -0.07055664, 0.029769897, 0.0034599304, -0.02407837, -0.053710938, 0.055603027, 0.026260376, -0.021896362, 0.017211914, 0.013900757, 0.026611328, 0.0011787415, 0.008384705, -0.026809692, -0.041168213, 0.005302429, 0.035217285, -0.023925781, 0.029159546, 0.013175964, 0.011169434, -0.025039673, -0.043426514, -0.0051574707, -0.0019197464, -0.044158936, 0.020004272, 0.024017334, -0.005168915, 0.0040130615, -0.029678345, -0.017120361, 0.020980835, -0.037139893, -0.013595581, 0.0012722015, 0.028945923, 0.046081543, 0.063964844, -0.0003247261, -0.005836487, 0.0067367554, -0.04647827, 0.043182373, 0.030395508, -0.038879395, 0.007183075, -0.020599365, -0.03692627, 0.027130127, -0.034057617, 0.03488159, -0.0395813, 0.012634277, -0.016525269, 0.017532349, 0.03491211, -0.035949707, -0.037506104, 0.025604248, -0.041137695, 0.0009946823, 0.0047340393, -0.02192688, -0.008728027, -0.0076560974, 0.0034160614, 0.023162842, 0.009300232, 0.0062942505, -0.018341064, -0.05419922, 0.027633667, -0.023788452, 0.066467285, -0.03012085, -0.027496338, -0.027542114, 0.022781372, 0.019515991, -0.008117676, -0.045410156, 0.056671143, -0.011184692, -0.07623291, 0.05441284, 0.03869629, -0.0029716492, -0.013587952, -0.011795044, -0.0138549805, -0.016738892, 0.0047340393, 0.049194336, -0.04220581, -0.060180664, 0.004470825, -0.051574707, 0.057647705, 0.022018433, -0.004562378, 0.034729004, 0.0105896, -0.015022278, 0.020523071, 0.047851562, 0.051513672, 0.008270264, -0.05154419, 0.0012626648, 0.003578186, 0.03314209, -0.04647827, -0.081848145, 0.008117676, 0.033050537, 0.0015707016, 0.031555176, 0.021881104, -0.0013074875, 0.0062332153, -0.004798889, -0.000014305115, -0.045898438, -0.0043182373, 0.011726379, 0.03869629, 0.037902832, 0.005493164, -0.004043579, 0.015151978, -0.026153564, 0.0057792664, 0.005947113, 0.0014734268, 0.02760315, -0.008110046, 0.049591064, -0.013595581, 0.013633728, -0.06536865, -0.0021858215, -0.00085783005, 0.009063721, -0.021606445, 0.038360596, -0.024642944, 0.055603027, -0.042144775, -0.049041748, 0.051635742, 0.062164307, 0.0045928955, 0.04345703, -0.017791748, -0.00078487396, -0.01374054, -0.003194809, 0.005012512, 0.022476196, 0.010848999, -0.059539795, 0.006729126, -0.06738281, -0.04876709, -0.009338379, -0.039398193, 0.025421143, -0.03387451, 0.021057129, -0.018188477, -0.01687622, -0.008926392, 0.018203735, -0.019348145, -0.03640747, -0.062438965, -0.013893127, 0.04260254, -0.019699097 ], "summary": [ -0.010543823, -0.025009155, -0.015396118, 0.017318726, -0.04537964, -0.009857178, -0.03062439, -0.010467529, 0.004837036, 0.013061523, 0.023971558, 0.014373779, -0.010681152, -0.055267334, 0.01763916, -0.0055656433, -0.017105103, 0.026931763, -0.028289795, -0.031951904, 0.016830444, -0.035583496, -0.06719971, 0.033203125, 0.04135132, -0.051757812, -0.042175293, -0.0001385212, 0.018310547, 0.01486969, 0.013008118, 0.007472992, 0.021499634, 0.00522995, -0.012649536, -0.010299683, -0.03262329, -0.00025367737, -0.0033874512, -0.0082092285, 0.043945312, -0.021835327, 0.04547119, -0.019256592, -0.009414673, 0.06768799, -0.021514893, -0.052001953, 0.04824829, -0.02746582, 0.006679535, 0.010726929, 0.0052833557, -0.02305603, -0.03564453, 0.0061149597, -0.053955078, -0.015556335, 0.005531311, 0.07232666, 0.04586792, -0.010986328, -0.0019187927, -0.022384644, -0.011962891, 0.020324707, 0.00048470497, -0.025131226, 0.039276123, 0.004348755, -0.0051498413, 0.006084442, 0.012023926, -0.051879883, 0.031799316, 0.06237793, -0.058654785, 0.023544312, 0.044769287, -0.008468628, -0.010177612, 0.015083313, -0.009674072, -0.07318115, 0.038635254, -0.040863037, -0.013687134, 0.0031700134, 0.0037269592, -0.014785767, -0.008041382, -0.0078125, -0.008850098, 0.023391724, 0.0068092346, -0.04660034, -0.025924683, -0.032226562, -0.01675415, -0.011199951, 0.048431396, -0.010673523, 0.01828003, -0.009597778, 0.02229309, 0.06689453, -0.03375244, -0.027175903, 0.026275635, 0.017715454, 0.018875122, -0.018249512, 0.013313293, -0.03930664, 0.0057754517, 0.006626129, -0.010063171, 0.052520752, 0.009056091, 0.039520264, -0.02571106, -0.008911133, 0.0090408325, 0.06518555, -0.006111145, 0.038909912, 0.023605347, -0.02748108, 0.015563965, 0.01525116, -0.000834465, 0.01486969, -0.031829834, -0.0016736984, -0.025787354, 0.010879517, 0.0037574768, -0.013473511, -0.01826477, 0.0036125183, 0.015594482, -0.020812988, 0.0051994324, -0.0031871796, 0.01725769, 0.010543823, 0.044952393, 0.013374329, -0.026748657, -0.03024292, 0.023239136, 0.019439697, 0.014595032, -0.022445679, -0.017791748, -0.05621338, -0.053222656, -0.01374054, 0.041931152, -0.026535034, 0.015625, -0.0069847107, 0.01600647, 0.0036792755, -0.015174866, -0.019134521, -0.023147583, -0.01133728, 0.014511108, 0.057617188, -0.010665894, 0.031555176, -0.0064697266, -0.0028514862, -0.009277344, -0.028823853, 0.0038433075, 0.037200928, 0.015792847, -0.05984497, -0.00021588802, -0.026794434, 0.066833496, 0.0066070557, -0.020187378, 0.014549255, -0.008605957, 0.027313232, 0.033691406, 0.005393982, -0.029556274, -0.021972656, 0.011161804, -0.03704834, -0.04824829, -0.027175903, 0.048034668, 0.020141602, -0.009101868, 0.02784729, 0.04888916, -0.015350342, -0.014221191, -0.031188965, -0.08300781, -0.01322937, -0.009735107, 0.01852417, 0.019042969, 0.040405273, 0.010574341, -0.006965637, -0.019515991, 0.024459839, -0.004310608, -0.044006348, 0.039611816, -0.021697998, 0.013946533, -0.019088745, 0.036315918, 0.034057617, 0.007331848, 0.07159424, -0.029891968, 0.0027065277, 0.016708374, 0.045074463, 0.049987793, 0.046020508, 0.043548584, -0.09033203, 0.0519104, 0.062683105, 0.003604889, -0.016708374, 0.0023593903, -0.09643555, 0.018249512, 0.037994385, 0.023269653, 0.027038574, -0.011772156, 0.018417358, -0.003917694, 0.002506256, 0.044158936, -0.03488159, -0.008125305, -0.015159607, -0.0029468536, -0.033203125, 0.04244995, 0.010314941, -0.016281128, 0.026504517, -0.04156494, -0.028335571, -0.0082092285, -0.04425049, 0.022109985, -0.091796875, -0.040649414, -0.027160645, -0.052490234, -0.022384644, -0.045013428, -0.03387451, 0.01574707, -0.013671875, 0.028503418, -0.03213501, 0.0021400452, -0.03062439, -0.036956787, -0.006996155, -0.019515991, 0.042999268, 0.016403198, -0.0345459, -0.0007548332, 0.00712204, 0.042755127, -0.016998291, 0.040252686, 0.027801514, 0.016571045, -0.020004272, 0.026046753, 0.057922363, 0.05807495, -0.010246277, -0.0184021, 0.020462036, -0.018005371, -0.015548706, 0.06402588, 0.01737976, 0.0057868958, -0.014160156, 0.021652222, 0.037994385, -0.02217102, 0.0022678375, 0.0155181885, -0.004283905, 0.019012451, 0.018127441, 0.0154418945, 0.0007095337, 0.00036787987, 0.051818848, 0.037231445, 0.028823853, -0.0003399849, -0.013046265, -0.00038957596, 0.037506104, -0.002866745, 0.03857422, 0.09338379, -0.017074585, -0.0063819885, 0.021759033, -0.0146102905, -0.036224365, 0.045318604, -0.02923584, 0.026168823, -0.021911621, -0.042236328, -0.046783447, -0.05822754, -0.011100769, -0.00021135807, -0.004058838, 0.001162529, -0.016403198, -0.010375977, 0.012786865, 0.019989014, -0.037628174, -0.0058898926, -0.019363403, 0.011917114, -0.01386261, 0.006706238, -0.014945984, 0.059387207, 0.043701172, -0.05154419, 0.009231567, -0.010826111, 0.056243896, 0.026046753, -0.004043579, -0.0045051575, 0.012260437, -0.030258179, -0.04559326, 0.054901123, 0.03781128, 0.034942627, -0.07739258, -0.052764893, -0.027023315, -0.014701843, -0.013206482, 0.017578125, 0.013656616, 0.0014896393, 0.0046043396, -0.038482666, -0.022827148, -0.007335663, 0.0020160675, 0.13464355, 0.02458191, -0.05596924, 0.06585693, 0.031188965, 0.057495117, -0.06048584, 0.023712158, 0.07623291, 0.01272583, -0.0019874573, -0.00010710955, 0.017807007, 0.007926941, -0.014160156, -0.042297363, -0.041107178, -0.005428314, 0.018127441, 0.005268097, -0.037597656, 0.029800415, -0.064941406, -0.0075263977, 0.051361084, 0.01991272, 0.031433105, 0.021194458, -0.04156494, 0.10308838, -0.0009880066, 0.011543274, 0.041809082, -0.036315918, 0.03793335, -0.06713867, 0.03768921, -0.08898926, 0.0038795471, -0.02558899, -0.041015625, -0.0011377335, -0.00730896, 0.01864624, -0.0005803108, -0.0032100677, -0.027328491, 0.0082473755, 0.022079468, 0.02053833, -0.006454468, -0.010597229, -0.018829346, -0.0063972473, 0.0032653809, -0.02645874, -0.017425537, -0.0022678375, -0.013908386, 0.017349243, -0.0063056946, -0.04034424, 0.03817749, -0.055755615, -0.051635742, -0.047973633, -0.09301758, -0.047302246, -0.021011353, -0.04815674, -0.035461426, -0.06011963, -0.039123535, -0.0069999695, -0.025985718, 0.0096206665, -0.024368286, 0.03878784, -0.018432617, 0.09124756, -0.05206299, 0.025360107, 0.05456543, -0.060302734, 0.010681152, -0.019989014, -0.04550171, 0.009376526, 0.06744385, 0.021774292, -0.049957275, 0.02279663, -0.009971619, 0.014945984, 0.046722412, -0.0519104, -0.006919861, -0.009742737, -0.036712646, -0.036102295, 0.06573486, 0.015174866, 0.01914978, -0.076293945, -0.042907715, 0.015586853, -0.06542969, -0.07727051, -0.012901306, -0.007785797, -0.090270996, -0.047698975, -0.009094238, 0.01838684, -0.043304443, -0.00712204, 0.018295288, -0.0053520203, -0.030395508, 0.037597656, -0.012123108, 0.033996582, 0.024887085, -0.033355713, 0.006046295, 0.011528015, -0.028060913, -0.000037252903, 0.060821533, -0.0037002563, -0.01574707, 0.040161133, 0.01626587, -0.0009331703, 0.06317139, 0.0059165955, -0.030136108, -0.0077934265, -0.0022392273, 0.010269165, 0.033569336, -0.06518555, 0.031982422, 0.024307251, 0.044799805, 0.039245605, 0.010383606, 0.005432129, -0.01651001, 0.00178051, -0.024032593, 0.0043945312, 0.009994507, -0.011451721, 0.035308838, -0.0028438568, 0.013320923, 0.03173828, -0.0013332367, 0.011047363, -0.02798462, 0.008522034, 0.0602417, 0.034088135, -0.031982422, -0.042938232, 0.0059814453, 0.0619812, -0.0030498505, 0.010261536, -0.022323608, 0.03302002, -0.0034503937, 0.014389038, -0.0076789856, -0.00869751, -0.014137268, -0.019683838, -0.00831604, -0.10241699, -0.036193848, 0.016326904, 0.015174866, 0.037628174, 0.061950684, 0.020492554, -0.018478394, -0.035980225, 0.04977417, -0.019317627, -0.0050239563, -0.0836792, -0.0029830933, -0.01953125, -0.032073975, -0.033996582, -0.020385742, -0.035705566, -0.0335083, -0.00207901, -0.017837524, 0.014717102, 0.0073013306, 0.014465332, 0.009170532, 0.008796692, -0.010467529, -0.02859497, -0.004825592, -0.015129089, 0.020767212, -0.007461548, 0.010749817, 0.007637024, 0.027938843, -0.039215088, -0.020874023, 0.0016870499, 0.038635254, 0.038116455, 0.046936035, -0.06549072, -0.021713257, 0.009635925, 0.057891846, 0.012390137, -0.0037460327, 0.00021898746, -0.020492554, 0.01424408, 0.02809143, 0.053131104, -0.0340271, 0.005455017, 0.028137207, 0.011550903, -0.00055933, -0.012123108, -0.009666443, 0.014251709, 0.010017395, 0.029800415, 0.030883789, -0.02532959, 0.01247406, 0.017303467, -0.0059432983, 0.017974854, 0.033111572, 0.0057373047, -0.02418518, 0.030639648, 0.00022435188, -0.0067329407, 0.02709961, -0.00844574, -0.015419006, 0.0082092285, 0.034851074, -0.033233643, 0.0021305084, -0.002998352, -0.007041931, -0.013412476, 0.0037117004, 0.0082473755, -0.052581787, -0.01133728, 0.048706055, 0.0056381226, -0.014770508, -0.007572174, -0.02142334, -0.02897644, -0.03817749, 0.0011148453, 0.012451172, 0.010879517, 0.007881165, -0.0107040405, -0.026748657, -0.01537323, 0.001285553, -0.019363403, -0.02180481, 0.017059326, -0.050354004, 0.03314209, 0.057006836, -0.04135132, -0.06738281, 0.0335083, -0.06817627, 0.035095215, -0.0045051575, -0.074401855, 0.026016235, -0.032165527, 0.014015198, 0.044891357, 0.03302002, 0.014328003, 0.05899048, -0.041870117, -0.0045547485, -0.00019311905, 0.03652954, -0.004951477, -0.0158844, 0.019927979, 0.0026721954, -0.0030498505, -0.0057792664, 0.02734375, -0.047729492, -0.024337769, -0.010803223, -0.023330688, -0.03665161, -0.032348633, -0.027633667, 0.035614014, 0.020065308, -0.030029297, 0.01058197, 0.03552246, -0.02835083, 0.014595032, 0.0010929108, 0.0042152405, -0.025344849, 0.0022888184, -0.015449524, -0.004638672, -0.025024414, 0.045898438, 0.0154953, -0.00077581406, -0.021255493, -0.022201538, -0.02053833, -0.019241333, -0.03152466, 0.037902832, -0.018432617, 0.003835678, -0.01864624, -0.042022705, 0.016937256, -0.044769287, -0.038482666, -0.002450943, -0.036193848, -0.056732178, 0.032958984, -0.043273926, -0.048553467, 0.025650024, 0.0018806458, -0.025299072, 0.012145996, 0.023529053, 0.02281189, -0.03475952, -0.018539429, -0.011413574, 0.038146973, -0.0042304993, -0.0022068024, 0.044830322, 0.0065841675, -0.005924225, -0.012336731, -0.0005874634, -0.015312195, -0.016967773, -0.03552246, -0.023925781, 0.028427124, -0.04309082, -0.027023315, 0.010040283, -0.0054779053, 0.012298584, -0.058532715, 0.002565384, 0.0007238388, 0.009490967, 0.04574585, 0.014595032, 0.023223877, 0.06335449, 0.04663086, 0.0033283234, -0.03543091, -0.012382507, -0.015205383, -0.0022850037, 0.052642822, 0.0635376, -0.01763916, 0.010414124, 0.012069702, 0.014343262, -0.010513306, 0.007724762, 0.009048462, 0.0011892319, -0.010276794, -0.0069122314, 0.05682373, 0.0062561035, 0.0064048767, 0.064941406, 0.016540527, 0.002281189, 0.021118164, 0.028457642, 0.0059318542, -0.0013179779, 0.018112183, 0.02217102, 0.040496826, -0.018432617, 0.07989502, -0.019195557, -0.004753113, -0.021697998, -0.05142212, -0.0345459, -0.009033203, 0.038269043, -0.039978027, 0.032958984, -0.0026016235, -0.02355957, -0.008102417, -0.046081543, 0.058013916, -0.016815186, -0.070251465, -0.04135132, 0.03918457, -0.009132385, 0.022964478, 0.06112671, -0.0154953, 0.017562866, -0.033599854, 0.012031555, 0.01928711, -0.024032593, -0.041748047, -0.021484375, 0.021820068, -0.0435791, 0.0073890686, 0.027114868, 0.042633057, -0.0022563934, -0.0069732666, 0.024246216, 0.010757446, -0.012832642, 0.015274048, 0.032928467, -0.005874634, 0.009735107, -0.014602661, -0.0013036728, 0.02166748, -0.034362793, -0.0012874603, 0.047180176, 0.030838013, -0.010734558, 0.032043457, -0.00137043, 0.009025574, -0.011566162, -0.016784668, -0.04159546, -0.011993408, -0.0209198, -0.0317688, 0.013893127, -0.016601562, -0.0009098053, 0.023605347, 0.01626587, -0.0036029816, 0.016113281, -0.028701782, 0.0140686035, 0.035736084, 0.014472961, 0.016860962, -0.002840042, -0.027130127, 0.017822266, 0.025283813, -0.022460938, 0.024154663, 0.0074768066, 0.06011963, 0.048950195, 0.050964355, -0.046295166, 0.013473511, 0.068115234, -0.005455017, 0.022735596, 0.00082969666, 0.0015621185, -0.0154953, -0.016723633, 0.002105713, -0.0028820038, 0.01689148, 0.060180664, -0.0574646, 0.026657104, -0.013633728, -0.013938904, -0.012428284, 0.0012702942, -0.03543091, -0.02027893, -0.0031356812, 0.023513794, 0.032836914, -0.038360596, 0.018066406, -0.009231567, -0.022537231, 0.0022716522, -0.0043296814, 0.023086548, -0.0041236877, 0.008338928, 0.014419556, 0.021728516, 0.059265137, -0.012451172, -0.03250122, 0.025924683, 0.016983032, 0.026428223, -0.02407837, -0.04888916, 0.06213379, 0.045074463, -0.01953125, 0.02670288, 0.05319214, 0.011581421, -0.0070762634, -0.01991272, 0.0063476562, -0.019073486, 0.04156494, 0.028930664, -0.008094788, -0.07305908, 0.00381279, -0.009056091, 0.033843994, -0.025787354, -0.009918213, 0.023742676, 0.040008545, -0.049438477, 0.015899658, -0.023071289, 0.0011863708, -0.0011262894, -0.040130615, 0.017669678, -0.015602112, 0.029754639, -0.0134887695, -0.053985596, 0.007881165, 0.01637268, -0.010574341, -0.0345459, 0.026473999, -0.007843018, 0.019104004, -0.015838623, -0.009170532, -0.011199951, 0.052978516, 0.060668945, -0.005783081, 0.022506714, -0.008384705, 0.023361206, 0.001876831, -0.04937744, 0.0048103333, 0.0038890839, -0.0104522705, 0.012275696, -0.012519836, 0.016693115, -0.045074463, 0.037109375, -0.013397217, 0.038482666, -0.03237915, -0.024902344, -0.02166748, 0.014976501, -0.014709473, -0.05041504, -0.036132812, -0.0069236755, 0.001996994, 0.0051193237, 0.008544922, 0.006252289, 0.010322571, 0.01802063, -0.003534317, 0.007083893, 0.008071899, 0.030349731, 0.012428284, -0.03970337, 0.008987427, -0.066589355, -0.018341064, -0.061157227, -0.03048706, 0.006198883, 0.041870117, -0.00088119507, 0.081726074, -0.018661499, 0.01486969, 0.031311035, -0.025634766, -0.013412476, 0.017150879, 0.07635498, 0.0033092499, 0.024963379 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07439v2
Investigating Multi-Pivot Ensembling with Massively Multilingual Machine Translation Models
Alireza Mohammadshahi, Jannis Vamvas, Rico Sennrich
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Massively multilingual machine translation models allow for the translation of a large number of languages with a single model, but have limited performance on low- and very-low-resource translation directions. Pivoting via high-resource languages remains a strong strategy for low-resource directions, and in this paper we revisit ways of pivoting through multiple languages. Previous work has used a simple averaging of probability distributions from multiple paths, but we find that this performs worse than using a single pivot, and exacerbates the hallucination problem because the same hallucinations can be probable across different paths. As an alternative, we propose MaxEns, a combination strategy that is biased towards the most confident predictions, hypothesising that confident predictions are less prone to be hallucinations. We evaluate different strategies on the FLORES benchmark for 20 low-resource language directions, demonstrating that MaxEns improves translation quality for low-resource languages while reducing hallucination in translations, compared to both direct translation and an averaging approach. On average, multi-pivot strategies still lag behind using English as a single pivot language, raising the question of how to identify the best pivoting strategy for a given translation direction.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07439v2
2023-11-14T14:01:46
2023-11-13T16:15:20
{ "title": [ -0.04144287, -0.026657104, -0.013092041, -0.056243896, -0.036071777, 0.035369873, -0.064819336, 0.007785797, 0.015853882, 0.05682373, -0.017623901, 0.032836914, 0.027008057, -0.009757996, -0.024749756, 0.030578613, -0.0048217773, 0.013923645, -0.035308838, -0.03152466, 0.0028209686, -0.03942871, 0.012390137, 0.008003235, 0.031051636, -0.05807495, -0.066345215, 0.019317627, -0.033599854, -0.02456665, -0.004486084, 0.026000977, 0.06451416, -0.02079773, -0.0043945312, 0.00881958, -0.034698486, -0.010520935, -0.018035889, 0.0029296875, 0.030883789, -0.008811951, -0.01600647, 0.0066184998, -0.039001465, 0.035583496, -0.072021484, -0.04055786, -0.04397583, 0.052642822, 0.037384033, 0.004951477, 0.035247803, 0.018493652, 0.015640259, -0.041107178, -0.019729614, -0.002500534, 0.027069092, 0.048461914, 0.035247803, -0.01448822, -0.0025310516, -0.032989502, -0.04638672, -0.022781372, 0.0023212433, 0.0154953, 0.05819702, -0.027435303, -0.02885437, 0.045043945, -0.0020275116, -0.014015198, -0.0647583, 0.0004541874, 0.02645874, -0.030181885, 0.035369873, -0.047424316, 0.005191803, -0.008872986, 0.0037517548, -0.015090942, 0.03302002, -0.016616821, -0.011886597, -0.024917603, -0.06274414, -0.060943604, -0.021759033, -0.03326416, -0.0635376, 0.0020942688, 0.0067214966, -0.040405273, -0.011230469, 0.03933716, -0.0029850006, -0.005886078, -0.043640137, 0.028656006, -0.048858643, -0.038238525, 0.017791748, -0.00080156326, -0.008583069, -0.031234741, 0.017410278, 0.020828247, -0.050109863, 0.06719971, 0.0013008118, 0.001458168, 0.010017395, -0.002281189, -0.017028809, 0.021636963, -0.0073890686, 0.012161255, -0.033966064, -0.050079346, 0.01777649, 0.028717041, 0.017303467, -0.016845703, -0.03366089, 0.039001465, 0.0035686493, 0.034240723, -0.0013008118, 0.04168701, -0.07849121, -0.08227539, -0.06341553, 0.025115967, -0.017593384, -0.0029449463, -0.017166138, 0.0071640015, 0.009429932, -0.03375244, -0.010025024, -0.003168106, 0.0046310425, 0.003944397, 0.0748291, -0.0036563873, -0.061553955, -0.029907227, -0.022399902, 0.02255249, 0.025848389, -0.012809753, -0.04928589, -0.03970337, -0.1159668, -0.016662598, 0.030822754, -0.001332283, 0.0038890839, 0.0055885315, 0.005355835, -0.016311646, -0.0059776306, -0.009735107, 0.0030765533, 0.009033203, 0.021408081, 0.0058135986, -0.032958984, 0.03503418, 0.037109375, 0.0131073, 0.0060577393, 0.005809784, 0.010551453, -0.02734375, 0.0011339188, 0.028564453, 0.037353516, -0.017150879, -0.03137207, 0.06750488, -0.07519531, 0.011703491, -0.00894165, 0.027526855, 0.062072754, 0.006587982, -0.020858765, 0.0045814514, -0.072509766, -0.01084137, -0.017150879, 0.023712158, 0.00983429, 0.029449463, 0.019699097, -0.026641846, -0.021240234, 0.009857178, -0.022079468, 0.0072135925, -0.039886475, -0.015472412, -0.030014038, 0.016952515, -0.042114258, 0.038757324, 0.07183838, 0.038482666, -0.06842041, 0.036132812, 0.025466919, -0.028457642, 0.022949219, 0.007083893, 0.014976501, -0.021636963, 0.0018024445, -0.01159668, 0.01008606, 0.019805908, -0.010055542, 0.012794495, 0.009422302, 0.0020751953, 0.033111572, 0.028549194, 0.054992676, -0.042755127, 0.03945923, 0.023117065, -0.04586792, -0.017745972, -0.03326416, 0.037872314, -0.017730713, 0.009429932, -0.00042176247, -0.034332275, 0.007850647, 0.04095459, 0.028518677, -0.011985779, 0.01436615, 0.014030457, 0.037200928, 0.062805176, 0.06976318, 0.0039749146, 0.011558533, -0.0345459, 0.012832642, 0.022781372, 0.014190674, -0.0077209473, -0.0014028549, -0.009880066, 0.01612854, -0.03173828, -0.04449463, -0.012359619, -0.04537964, -0.010391235, -0.033447266, -0.014854431, -0.016418457, -0.0051994324, 0.033813477, 0.004383087, 0.015960693, -0.0049934387, -0.019683838, -0.024871826, 0.0023288727, 0.012939453, 0.0005950928, -0.0418396, -0.01939392, 0.02053833, 0.010116577, -0.012382507, 0.00920105, -0.004245758, -0.0015487671, -0.039978027, -0.02557373, -0.015449524, 0.046203613, 0.035003662, 0.012084961, -0.017456055, -0.0135269165, 0.0019302368, 0.09686279, 0.03189087, -0.013053894, 0.01776123, -0.015701294, 0.036834717, 0.010482788, -0.0028305054, 0.0115737915, 0.05444336, 0.017623901, 0.017715454, -0.019348145, 0.036468506, -0.06048584, 0.007980347, 0.00944519, 0.009025574, -0.06774902, -0.05340576, -0.019866943, -0.012466431, -0.04321289, 0.003604889, 0.08544922, -0.021240234, -0.020935059, 0.013008118, -0.01638794, -0.02053833, 0.0036239624, -0.036193848, 0.02368164, 0.015106201, 0.043823242, 0.012588501, -0.05621338, -0.04071045, -0.005340576, 0.012832642, -0.00957489, -0.0017290115, -0.0121536255, 0.049957275, 0.013877869, 0.0041618347, 0.015167236, -0.075805664, 0.016967773, -0.02470398, 0.022125244, 0.016479492, -0.037597656, -0.0022296906, 0.003993988, -0.03253174, -0.0018358231, 0.0046958923, 0.088378906, -0.056488037, -0.049102783, 0.07196045, 0.03918457, 0.004386902, 0.027572632, 0.024383545, 0.009437561, -0.04800415, -0.0064201355, -0.0579834, -0.028945923, -0.025436401, 0.04534912, 0.056365967, -0.031951904, 0.007888794, -0.016967773, 0.016189575, 0.06060791, -0.029678345, 0.05215454, -0.01939392, -0.015159607, 0.018066406, 0.0005865097, 0.031280518, -0.052856445, 0.019897461, 0.036315918, 0.013290405, 0.006515503, 0.0060920715, 0.017791748, -0.004753113, 0.0012702942, 0.018127441, -0.031707764, -0.013214111, 0.012908936, 0.019439697, -0.029907227, -0.023361206, -0.04727173, 0.009521484, 0.07446289, -0.010818481, -0.025436401, 0.04019165, -0.08227539, 0.050201416, -0.01096344, -0.005519867, 0.027999878, 0.045043945, 0.0009484291, -0.0016851425, 0.009780884, -0.040527344, 0.018432617, -0.031204224, -0.11566162, 0.031982422, -0.03491211, -0.010093689, 0.0011539459, -0.012184143, -0.030960083, -0.0060539246, 0.0038890839, 0.093444824, 0.005355835, -0.0051727295, 0.010383606, -0.01360321, 0.019332886, -0.008255005, -0.001294136, -0.0028133392, -0.01789856, 0.060272217, 0.006465912, 0.08874512, 0.019607544, -0.0075683594, -0.019973755, 0.010047913, -0.0151901245, 0.045898438, -0.013328552, -0.015510559, -0.0036182404, -0.027023315, 0.020858765, 0.048034668, -0.013923645, -0.009056091, -0.025360107, 0.005077362, -0.05441284, -0.006996155, 0.006954193, 0.008102417, -0.033966064, -0.017150879, 0.016784668, -0.0012836456, -0.03945923, -0.006008148, 0.07110596, 0.0002720356, -0.042236328, -0.007659912, -0.02305603, 0.030593872, 0.02720642, -0.021087646, 0.011161804, -0.0026111603, -0.015899658, -0.03463745, 0.0032405853, 0.008857727, -0.010231018, -0.016342163, -0.044891357, 0.022201538, -0.018341064, -0.079956055, -0.002035141, -0.004547119, -0.062561035, -0.023468018, 0.01159668, -0.0335083, -0.087402344, -0.034942627, 0.018920898, -0.042297363, -0.013244629, 0.040252686, -0.017730713, -0.023849487, -0.012062073, -0.09234619, -0.023269653, 0.09210205, 0.018371582, 0.034973145, 0.03942871, 0.0045776367, 0.0029659271, -0.022949219, 0.022567749, 0.03567505, 0.037628174, -0.01210022, -0.017684937, 0.0009255409, -0.007003784, -0.010261536, 0.051361084, -0.00868988, 0.0022563934, 0.008628845, 0.0075645447, -0.0059928894, -0.015457153, 0.0362854, 0.033966064, 0.0052833557, -0.06756592, 0.020721436, -0.04147339, 0.0014410019, 0.010169983, 0.024642944, 0.005973816, -0.017425537, 0.023406982, 0.019729614, -0.02708435, 0.009506226, 0.02166748, -0.037750244, -0.015411377, -0.022262573, 0.009391785, 0.0076522827, 0.016708374, 0.010612488, -0.0030288696, 0.021972656, -0.006866455, -0.010116577, -0.011543274, 0.003320694, -0.036743164, 0.006046295, -0.05606079, -0.019256592, -0.044433594, 0.030853271, -0.0146484375, 0.030410767, 0.020645142, 0.005378723, -0.009864807, 0.023742676, 0.05429077, 0.011169434, -0.013374329, -0.0635376, 0.028442383, -0.00699234, -0.051605225, -0.043151855, -0.009056091, 0.024505615, 0.034942627, -0.011024475, 0.0018310547, 0.021224976, 0.009307861, 0.0030441284, 0.05267334, -0.013397217, -0.026763916, 0.045928955, -0.061065674, -0.005004883, 0.036071777, 0.008110046, -0.02368164, -0.013191223, 0.03326416, -0.0022277832, -0.030181885, -0.021881104, 0.034332275, 0.019180298, 0.054748535, -0.02583313, -0.025177002, 0.019958496, 0.009185791, 0.012199402, 0.008964539, -0.040802002, 0.024368286, -0.020019531, 0.030349731, 0.0032444, 0.0033569336, 0.038085938, 0.017196655, 0.023910522, -0.0027313232, -0.014122009, 0.010749817, 0.005821228, 0.028503418, -0.0025558472, -0.03656006, -0.022537231, 0.0009899139, 0.007144928, 0.045318604, -0.036499023, 0.019882202, -0.02720642, 0.03857422, 0.009521484, -0.03274536, -0.004047394, -0.031280518, 0.0069274902, -0.06933594, -0.024337769, -0.022598267, 0.0015497208, -0.029708862, -0.008293152, -0.0077438354, -0.035339355, 0.010032654, 0.040863037, 0.039031982, -0.0057411194, 0.009132385, -0.022766113, 0.0007815361, -0.010414124, -0.054473877, -0.011962891, -0.008346558, 0.018035889, -0.025756836, 0.06036377, -0.035339355, -0.00022995472, -0.044525146, -0.038391113, 0.01979065, -0.04748535, 0.024002075, 0.0826416, -0.01991272, 0.06817627, -0.039733887, -0.0053863525, 0.023727417, 0.048858643, 0.0064964294, -0.008590698, 0.042938232, -0.064819336, 0.019226074, 0.01852417, 0.016235352, -0.028823853, 0.04650879, -0.006980896, 0.003168106, -0.05215454, 0.010894775, 0.031585693, -0.026367188, 0.02859497, -0.03857422, 0.030319214, 0.016403198, -0.015068054, 0.026687622, -0.030548096, -0.019012451, -0.033203125, -0.0008735657, -0.0748291, 0.01625061, -0.010612488, -0.070129395, -0.002773285, 0.026611328, 0.005004883, -0.018554688, 0.017929077, 0.008476257, -0.03466797, 0.033172607, 0.062805176, -0.01676941, 0.039276123, 0.014785767, -0.0051116943, 0.07745361, 0.05429077, -0.052764893, -0.017089844, -0.006038666, -0.019989014, 0.00089263916, 0.021469116, 0.029754639, -0.0077590942, -0.018707275, -0.005493164, 0.0024547577, -0.0095825195, 0.024475098, 0.005859375, -0.04071045, 0.00831604, -0.0151901245, -0.0032577515, 0.025558472, 0.042419434, 0.008682251, 0.013061523, 0.007484436, -0.00076818466, 0.021469116, -0.011955261, 0.02041626, -0.018447876, -0.024642944, -0.00022792816, 0.0262146, -0.013450623, 0.012893677, 0.036743164, 0.02923584, 0.037139893, 0.0020198822, 0.01739502, 0.042053223, -0.02330017, -0.0023860931, -0.012481689, 0.0046653748, -0.027450562, 0.0552063, -0.015350342, 0.013320923, -0.055358887, -0.036895752, -0.032318115, 0.011497498, 0.024658203, -0.004234314, 0.022567749, 0.019805908, 0.034606934, -0.015777588, -0.029968262, -0.07336426, 0.043823242, -0.016159058, -0.044128418, 0.033691406, -0.035339355, -0.05303955, 0.031143188, 0.032592773, 0.070739746, -0.01977539, 0.08050537, -0.048736572, -0.03237915, -0.0007863045, -0.021987915, 0.022628784, -0.010169983, -0.0076446533, 0.0012636185, -0.005672455, 0.060424805, 0.000087082386, 0.042175293, 0.024780273, -0.009986877, -0.0019216537, 0.004940033, 0.01737976, -0.0423584, 0.00027370453, -0.020492554, -0.015945435, -0.042388916, -0.02810669, -0.070373535, 0.017333984, 0.012275696, 0.052215576, 0.035339355, 0.011734009, 0.027770996, 0.0046463013, 0.007030487, 0.020812988, 0.055480957, 0.005264282, -0.004425049, 0.022766113, -0.023605347, 0.02822876, 0.041290283, -0.00497818, -0.004798889, -0.021911621, -0.008132935, 0.0031852722, -0.0010051727, 0.0041122437, -0.036590576, 0.007144928, -0.039367676, 0.029312134, -0.023086548, 0.04486084, 0.062683105, 0.013244629, -0.033203125, -0.000010311604, -0.0054740906, -0.010765076, -0.017486572, 0.023910522, 0.028259277, -0.04714966, 0.05404663, -0.013137817, -0.03793335, -0.0041122437, 0.015945435, 0.0390625, -0.06378174, -0.05090332, 0.045776367, 0.04699707, 0.005847931, 0.0049552917, -0.049621582, -0.018218994, 0.015380859, 0.03250122, -0.01020813, 0.0076828003, 0.008956909, 0.016204834, 0.03213501, -0.005973816, 0.000038027763, 0.021270752, -0.0033340454, 0.035736084, 0.017669678, 0.0061798096, -0.0012683868, -0.023895264, -0.019836426, 0.027130127, -0.047912598, -0.016067505, 0.019592285, 0.038909912, 0.017974854, 0.06817627, 0.025970459, -0.000808239, -0.014190674, -0.038726807, 0.018859863, 0.014472961, -0.009727478, -0.0048599243, -0.05026245, -0.05316162, 0.0060539246, -0.06774902, 0.07330322, -0.04309082, -0.0076179504, -0.036499023, 0.049621582, 0.009384155, -0.06488037, -0.064086914, -0.010437012, -0.061279297, 0.013641357, 0.0131073, -0.0028800964, -0.021697998, -0.022964478, 0.0011482239, -0.007205963, -0.013534546, 0.011436462, -0.009117126, -0.07696533, -0.004585266, -0.029251099, 0.039733887, -0.019744873, -0.020080566, -0.024917603, 0.009819031, 0.020904541, -0.020721436, -0.033477783, -0.01448822, 0.006996155, -0.026290894, 0.002040863, 0.008392334, -0.025924683, -0.05105591, 0.00013661385, -0.010383606, -0.034729004, 0.00088357925, -0.012924194, -0.064331055, -0.0018358231, -0.0096206665, -0.01687622, 0.035125732, 0.04977417, -0.0012331009, 0.015655518, 0.018112183, -0.030715942, -0.027923584, 0.012580872, 0.018569946, 0.030136108, -0.04638672, -0.0057411194, 0.032958984, 0.052337646, -0.035369873, -0.031677246, 0.031982422, 0.007511139, -0.01600647, 0.034851074, 0.026641846, 0.03933716, 0.01991272, 0.030654907, 0.0052986145, -0.051361084, 0.007972717, -0.007873535, 0.024765015, 0.04650879, -0.0004377365, 0.0041046143, 0.03488159, 0.0005354881, -0.009750366, 0.015090942, -0.033325195, 0.0056762695, 0.013374329, 0.0061149597, -0.037078857, 0.009490967, -0.018539429, 0.044952393, -0.03189087, -0.033843994, -0.0073051453, 0.017211914, -0.042297363, -0.024993896, -0.047454834, -0.027404785, 0.035491943, 0.035491943, -0.0022888184, 0.008644104, 0.0013141632, 0.023956299, 0.0022029877, 0.02041626, -0.0012435913, 0.04043579, 0.016143799, -0.00856781, 0.011528015, -0.055358887, -0.021240234, -0.013244629, -0.018951416, 0.040740967, -0.042388916, 0.0076179504, -0.036376953, -0.012779236, 0.008781433, 0.0074501038, 0.024246216, -0.017440796, -0.019546509, -0.026351929, 0.026733398, -0.0012702942 ], "summary": [ -0.030975342, -0.054901123, 0.014167786, -0.009536743, -0.09326172, 0.02418518, -0.07543945, -0.006843567, 0.00617218, 0.085998535, 0.01751709, 0.019622803, 0.04937744, -0.022506714, -0.017044067, 0.029663086, -0.007843018, 0.012565613, -0.004852295, -0.045532227, 0.030395508, -0.061767578, 0.0025672913, 0.0023708344, 0.035064697, -0.06286621, -0.026733398, -0.006011963, -0.012008667, 0.00057411194, 0.01473999, 0.054534912, 0.016464233, -0.01876831, 0.013572693, -0.027557373, -0.005657196, -0.023269653, -0.017501831, 0.021591187, 0.01966858, -0.0076904297, 0.035827637, 0.0012874603, 0.0074272156, -0.018203735, 0.008377075, -0.049865723, -0.0053520203, 0.04486084, 0.027999878, -0.0071411133, 0.025741577, -0.0009784698, -0.03414917, -0.047027588, -0.047546387, 0.036987305, 0.013504028, 0.04055786, 0.011947632, 0.014968872, -0.018859863, -0.03677368, 0.0009455681, -0.0027046204, 0.025314331, 0.0098724365, 0.034210205, 0.0071792603, -0.004524231, 0.0047836304, 0.02671814, -0.03677368, -0.058929443, 0.04522705, -0.0231781, -0.010185242, 0.070739746, -0.07244873, -0.021835327, 0.008796692, 0.03677368, -0.036712646, -0.021881104, -0.042541504, -0.032196045, 0.0055999756, -0.07849121, -0.011207581, -0.051330566, -0.0005021095, -0.08886719, 0.00390625, 0.014411926, -0.014167786, -0.038360596, -0.026519775, -0.0011425018, -0.0009765625, 0.0014295578, -0.00447464, -0.013931274, -0.005710602, 0.012199402, -0.037475586, -0.005130768, -0.029632568, 0.027679443, 0.021377563, -0.04888916, 0.06756592, -0.0071105957, 0.012260437, -0.027069092, -0.018844604, -0.03564453, 0.0017576218, -0.010231018, 0.0055656433, -0.027664185, 0.0026836395, -0.0017213821, 0.023223877, -0.03137207, -0.02684021, 0.0060272217, 0.015205383, -0.047851562, 0.020202637, 0.0022411346, 0.046142578, -0.036590576, -0.04248047, -0.074035645, -0.012290955, 0.019714355, 0.017120361, 0.016189575, -0.018051147, 0.056854248, -0.028182983, -0.025848389, 0.05218506, 0.009307861, 0.0046195984, 0.02545166, 0.013618469, -0.0017271042, -0.0099487305, 0.003452301, -0.030700684, 0.021133423, -0.02243042, -0.00000333786, -0.053344727, -0.048919678, -0.005001068, 0.045959473, 0.011383057, -0.017105103, -0.011917114, 0.0027885437, 0.0041046143, -0.010093689, 0.0030460358, 0.013755798, -0.012084961, 0.0027999878, -0.06085205, -0.02331543, 0.056427002, 0.018951416, -0.020233154, 0.008125305, -0.010551453, -0.042663574, 0.011421204, 0.0015954971, 0.013748169, 0.03817749, -0.034240723, -0.012367249, 0.05834961, -0.027832031, 0.004940033, -0.015075684, 0.034423828, 0.047058105, 0.02444458, -0.034423828, -0.010955811, -0.07141113, -0.0019235611, 0.040893555, 0.03387451, -0.0012264252, 0.014266968, 0.031555176, -0.08477783, 0.05517578, 0.016998291, -0.014633179, -0.02998352, -0.041290283, -0.01133728, -0.009254456, 0.021881104, -0.01890564, 0.022445679, 0.018356323, -0.0056610107, -0.028701782, 0.038513184, 0.033721924, -0.0010795593, 0.055358887, 0.023086548, 0.0317688, -0.032470703, 0.048797607, -0.00039172173, 0.010017395, 0.07147217, -0.014572144, 0.013656616, -0.020431519, 0.012176514, 0.02734375, -0.008666992, 0.06903076, 0.019241333, 0.0005888939, -0.015853882, -0.05392456, 0.0103302, -0.0046195984, -0.008728027, -0.01876831, 0.029754639, 0.0063171387, -0.019607544, -0.04840088, 0.011138916, -0.03427124, -0.05819702, -0.004425049, 0.023849487, 0.006336212, -0.0072669983, 0.015975952, -0.0140686035, 0.046905518, -0.021484375, 0.013687134, 0.020996094, 0.0006737709, -0.025939941, 0.04510498, -0.058807373, 0.0259552, -0.043273926, -0.062927246, 0.010475159, -0.058929443, -0.04348755, -0.048431396, -0.04171753, 0.026138306, -0.04650879, 0.027023315, -0.050842285, 0.01928711, -0.032562256, -0.03555298, 0.0007572174, -0.0018854141, -0.0028972626, 0.044525146, -0.023880005, -0.023803711, 0.021865845, -0.053344727, -0.03137207, 0.00029468536, -0.0038814545, -0.022018433, -0.042144775, 0.010894775, 0.025314331, 0.032073975, 0.009338379, -0.008758545, 0.019210815, -0.017288208, -0.020202637, 0.05834961, 0.0030498505, 0.014671326, -0.0017795563, 0.009529114, 0.043151855, 0.0067367554, -0.030014038, 0.0026683807, 0.06161499, 0.035095215, 0.018692017, 0.015899658, -0.01966858, -0.006980896, -0.033843994, 0.015670776, 0.051818848, -0.07513428, -0.040283203, -0.043762207, -0.0035915375, -0.018951416, 0.045562744, 0.11340332, 0.03363037, 0.028305054, 0.052459717, 0.008796692, -0.08734131, 0.06854248, -0.03137207, 0.041168213, -0.033477783, -0.035217285, -0.032836914, -0.05783081, -0.030380249, -0.00040268898, -0.027435303, 0.00970459, -0.015930176, -0.009933472, 0.017471313, 0.019134521, 0.040527344, -0.0066566467, -0.04660034, -0.00274086, 0.00008881092, 0.0013399124, 0.004650116, 0.009521484, 0.03970337, -0.046783447, 0.0043754578, -0.018447876, 0.022033691, 0.037261963, -0.04928589, -0.0017795563, 0.0625, 0.029205322, 0.00459671, 0.010757446, 0.0045051575, -0.021408081, -0.034973145, 0.006427765, -0.03286743, -0.021774292, -0.022888184, 0.07159424, 0.039855957, 0.009857178, 0.028930664, -0.040985107, 0.008979797, 0.028320312, -0.027023315, 0.09240723, 0.0033340454, 0.0063591003, 0.051239014, 0.023452759, 0.031951904, 0.010101318, 0.022521973, 0.03643799, -0.0067977905, -0.00079488754, -0.0041236877, 0.05203247, 0.011749268, 0.034729004, -0.017440796, -0.005306244, -0.036895752, -0.021972656, 0.016723633, -0.0031661987, -0.026885986, 0.037506104, -0.016952515, 0.05517578, 0.023666382, 0.01739502, 0.01713562, -0.032836914, 0.02658081, 0.0077552795, -0.010635376, 0.03152466, 0.022216797, 0.029296875, -0.0513916, 0.015731812, -0.040618896, -0.008888245, -0.02418518, -0.03842163, 0.0181427, -0.028457642, 0.024505615, -0.02027893, 0.023620605, -0.020477295, 0.010757446, -0.0032653809, 0.09454346, -0.032440186, 0.013595581, 0.011772156, -0.011512756, -0.0062446594, 0.00069379807, -0.022399902, 0.0079193115, -0.030227661, 0.049926758, -0.01146698, -0.0105896, 0.026031494, -0.036987305, -0.04434204, -0.015266418, -0.029373169, -0.0141067505, -0.009422302, -0.02017212, -0.014442444, -0.038513184, 0.044647217, 0.02986145, -0.019866943, -0.024795532, 0.048919678, 0.0028648376, -0.050994873, 0.022155762, 0.033813477, 0.009353638, 0.036590576, -0.019119263, -0.046966553, -0.007396698, -0.0034942627, -0.031433105, 0.038360596, 0.026245117, -0.05340576, 0.0077781677, 0.0016155243, -0.018051147, 0.018920898, -0.014793396, 0.012084961, 0.02053833, -0.03643799, -0.053588867, 0.04751587, 0.04473877, 0.0071525574, -0.04248047, -0.0736084, 0.040802002, 0.012619019, -0.07507324, -0.03414917, 0.015945435, -0.038360596, -0.041870117, 0.0008940697, 0.04776001, -0.029403687, 0.025115967, 0.033081055, -0.0008869171, 0.001364708, 0.030319214, -0.013175964, 0.024414062, -0.009529114, -0.07128906, -0.011367798, -0.0011711121, -0.0065956116, 0.01739502, -0.010147095, 0.0030059814, -0.0012264252, -0.005191803, 0.024261475, 0.0017232895, -0.00028824806, -0.017807007, 0.004245758, -0.03955078, 0.018005371, -0.00868988, 0.043670654, -0.05496216, 0.02619934, 0.027709961, -0.024749756, 0.026107788, -0.044281006, 0.008926392, 0.06451416, 0.0017089844, -0.064819336, 0.06060791, -0.004917145, 0.012557983, 0.026062012, 0.02909851, 0.012001038, 0.0034828186, -0.005859375, -0.031204224, -0.015335083, 0.012359619, 0.031066895, 0.0078125, -0.011787415, -0.026626587, -0.022949219, 0.02192688, 0.0054855347, 0.003074646, 0.003255844, 0.00712204, 0.002746582, -0.0440979, 0.010864258, 0.023071289, -0.02494812, -0.041900635, 0.0024604797, 0.008476257, 0.008399963, -0.0041007996, -0.014465332, 0.009254456, 0.010192871, 0.0054779053, 0.024398804, -0.0090789795, 0.051635742, 0.036743164, -0.06329346, -0.09515381, -0.024627686, 0.018325806, -0.046417236, -0.04168701, -0.039886475, -0.018951416, -0.04446411, -0.0071907043, -0.031311035, 0.010887146, -0.01109314, 0.026046753, 0.0051498413, 0.015792847, -0.010810852, 0.01626587, -0.04663086, 0.02003479, 0.0032978058, -0.021408081, -0.021575928, 0.0131073, 0.04953003, 0.0024318695, -0.010887146, -0.002696991, 0.013450623, 0.011314392, 0.02835083, -0.045837402, -0.0011787415, 0.005252838, 0.023391724, -0.0057373047, -0.0043792725, -0.01777649, 0.013885498, -0.029647827, 0.022735596, 0.012298584, -0.011482239, 0.020462036, -0.0140686035, 0.0082473755, 0.0019874573, -0.012931824, 0.0107421875, 0.013687134, 0.023635864, -0.019470215, 0.0234375, -0.00447464, 0.037231445, -0.008781433, 0.012535095, 0.021942139, -0.022750854, 0.056854248, 0.028564453, -0.013267517, -0.047210693, 0.020843506, -0.056640625, 0.002439499, -0.04562378, 0.015930176, -0.012130737, -0.023345947, -0.036468506, -0.027542114, -0.026138306, -0.055389404, -0.008895874, -0.00774765, -0.005317688, -0.004638672, 0.0030536652, -0.03652954, -0.0019512177, 0.016525269, -0.031585693, -0.019638062, -0.0055389404, 0.020568848, -0.025772095, 0.03439331, 0.029769897, 0.005947113, -0.0011892319, -0.04675293, 0.002790451, -0.046844482, -0.02684021, -0.009651184, -0.06304932, 0.012077332, 0.012107849, -0.0014009476, 0.0029010773, 0.06542969, -0.033477783, -0.0017023087, 0.025726318, -0.027450562, 0.053466797, 0.031311035, 0.0126571655, -0.050445557, 0.040527344, -0.022247314, -0.013282776, -0.0107421875, -0.008102417, -0.005191803, 0.014701843, 0.039215088, -0.04006958, 0.041656494, -0.042633057, -0.022613525, 0.028152466, 0.010231018, -0.002281189, -0.051239014, 0.023635864, -0.064086914, 0.0011930466, 0.010055542, -0.02658081, 0.028167725, 0.046691895, -0.02015686, -0.00856781, 0.03488159, -0.010223389, 0.009811401, -0.007865906, 0.014839172, 0.0068130493, 0.04611206, 0.034851074, 0.014801025, 0.03515625, 0.015289307, -0.09777832, -0.023529053, -0.031982422, 0.029434204, 0.017578125, 0.017166138, 0.039398193, 0.017654419, 0.0002834797, 0.004398346, 0.024917603, 0.0050964355, 0.04486084, -0.00957489, -0.04623413, 0.009002686, -0.030700684, -0.038116455, 0.029052734, 0.027053833, -0.03704834, 0.008323669, 0.029159546, -0.031707764, 0.032714844, 0.010055542, -0.0016746521, 0.023651123, -0.00037837029, 0.007965088, 0.022903442, -0.024749756, 0.010101318, 0.035705566, 0.014770508, 0.022277832, -0.0076560974, 0.0048065186, -0.008850098, 0.010955811, 0.024398804, 0.008163452, 0.02192688, -0.002286911, 0.040527344, -0.010643005, 0.037963867, -0.050476074, -0.009475708, 0.0001885891, 0.014335632, 0.017730713, -0.0022144318, 0.019943237, 0.022964478, 0.033355713, 0.018722534, -0.019882202, -0.027816772, 0.011955261, -0.006587982, -0.039794922, 0.038726807, -0.010536194, -0.056274414, 0.057006836, 0.044677734, 0.08331299, -0.046173096, 0.11407471, -0.046081543, -0.02508545, -0.009857178, 0.01309967, 0.023422241, 0.0046081543, -0.03555298, -0.053588867, 0.041870117, 0.04626465, -0.015296936, 0.017944336, 0.0004079342, 0.0032901764, 0.016326904, -0.00041294098, -0.0048942566, -0.023025513, 0.0050964355, -0.006816864, -0.0680542, -0.055725098, -0.06286621, -0.016525269, 0.03778076, -0.049621582, 0.027770996, 0.02168274, 0.007419586, -0.0062179565, 0.010650635, -0.068237305, 0.060943604, 0.012580872, 0.017227173, -0.011634827, 0.021499634, 0.0028648376, -0.00033688545, 0.045715332, -0.027023315, 0.035247803, -0.034210205, 0.0234375, 0.054138184, -0.07672119, -0.020706177, -0.008491516, 0.021759033, -0.023635864, 0.025161743, 0.018310547, 0.050567627, 0.015731812, 0.018035889, 0.02482605, 0.001824379, 0.017196655, -0.017303467, -0.037719727, 0.051513672, 0.0069999695, -0.0345459, 0.04928589, 0.0047798157, -0.04421997, 0.059020996, 0.026351929, 0.04711914, -0.04434204, -0.01399231, 0.029022217, 0.0070152283, 0.0038986206, -0.010917664, -0.03704834, -0.017318726, -0.040130615, 0.008171082, 0.026260376, 0.009109497, -0.058288574, 0.005012512, 0.04345703, 0.019226074, -0.001282692, 0.028015137, 0.015029907, 0.027267456, 0.017913818, 0.027755737, 0.021987915, -0.015686035, 0.0014762878, 0.035003662, -0.027908325, 0.01751709, 0.007888794, 0.026885986, 0.021011353, 0.013412476, -0.04360962, 0.020263672, 0.04019165, -0.013328552, 0.025421143, -0.003736496, 0.009117126, 0.017700195, -0.040008545, -0.014213562, 0.013374329, -0.05493164, 0.05606079, -0.03741455, -0.039794922, -0.05923462, 0.0657959, -0.0440979, -0.009590149, -0.07116699, -0.06390381, -0.07623291, 0.027893066, 0.023544312, -0.014633179, -0.0014743805, -0.022094727, -0.009536743, -0.010467529, -0.02494812, 0.0011920929, 0.0075531006, -0.048339844, -0.007911682, -0.003314972, 0.04147339, 0.009086609, -0.032562256, 0.04486084, -0.03314209, 0.013214111, -0.0113220215, -0.011291504, -0.02331543, -0.0039405823, -0.035339355, 0.01739502, 0.023132324, -0.010536194, -0.010757446, 0.011070251, 0.000113368034, -0.023239136, -0.0066337585, -0.008682251, -0.03778076, 0.04776001, 0.0041046143, -0.022537231, 0.016296387, 0.015052795, 0.011001587, 0.03729248, 0.0050735474, 0.0030670166, 0.011558533, 0.01676941, 0.01222229, 0.026397705, -0.06665039, 0.005355835, 0.0055160522, 0.045043945, 0.022384644, -0.042877197, 0.07788086, -0.01864624, -0.012214661, -0.034606934, -0.009895325, 0.010864258, 0.040252686, 0.0395813, 0.004634857, -0.047180176, 0.06976318, 0.029342651, 0.034820557, 0.03829956, -0.0259552, 0.034210205, 0.00381279, -0.0030708313, -0.004261017, 0.02128601, 0.012825012, 0.017684937, -0.0036907196, 0.0053634644, -0.05960083, 0.018478394, -0.011016846, 0.049468994, -0.027755737, -0.016220093, -0.010643005, 0.008087158, 0.011077881, -0.020324707, -0.042114258, 0.011978149, 0.03213501, 0.018295288, 0.017700195, -0.009552002, 0.03942871, 0.044128418, -0.011749268, 0.052856445, 0.008850098, 0.075805664, 0.00687027, -0.0023517609, 0.042541504, -0.072387695, -0.017669678, 0.009391785, 0.0029449463, 0.03741455, -0.03829956, 0.0023269653, -0.01576233, -0.020767212, 0.023406982, 0.022827148, 0.03604126, 0.014122009, 0.04168701, 0.009765625, 0.011001587, 0.022659302 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07430v1
Controlled Text Generation for Black-box Language Models via Score-based Progressive Editor
Sangwon Yu, Changmin Lee, Hojin Lee, Sungroh Yoon
cs.CL
Despite recent progress in language models, generating constrained text for specific domains remains a challenge, particularly when utilizing black-box models that lack domain-specific knowledge. In this paper, we introduce ScoPE (Score-based Progressive Editor) generation, a novel approach for controlled text generation for black-box language models. We employ ScoPE to facilitate text generation in the target domain by integrating it with language models through a cascading approach. Trained to enhance the target domain score of the edited text, ScoPE progressively edits intermediate output discrete tokens to align with the target attributes throughout the auto-regressive generation process of the language model. This iterative process guides subsequent steps to produce desired output texts for the target domain. Our experimental results on diverse controlled generations demonstrate that ScoPE effectively facilitates controlled text generation for black-box language models in both in-domain and out-of-domain conditions, which is challenging for existing methods.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07430v1
2023-11-13T16:03:23
2023-11-13T16:03:23
{ "title": [ -0.02949524, -0.023727417, -0.03515625, -0.06488037, -0.027557373, 0.008514404, -0.07409668, 0.008171082, 0.0040016174, 0.03111267, -0.015609741, 0.00969696, -0.0063667297, -0.008430481, -0.056884766, -0.0044555664, -0.015945435, 0.036132812, -0.039367676, -0.055114746, -0.012924194, -0.076538086, -0.0007677078, 0.02633667, 0.019607544, -0.032684326, -0.051971436, 0.015541077, -0.020950317, -0.0053863525, -0.017608643, -0.004257202, 0.04626465, 0.024002075, -0.028823853, 0.030685425, -0.04458618, 0.020736694, 0.0057258606, 0.0030097961, 0.02960205, -0.0048217773, -0.011428833, 0.007472992, -0.04397583, -0.0072021484, -0.017227173, -0.015396118, -0.0014362335, 0.014923096, -0.0035762787, 0.061950684, 0.0019416809, 0.024291992, 0.01638794, -0.010406494, -0.050323486, 0.026794434, 0.04736328, 0.05050659, 0.0154953, -0.055633545, 0.010368347, -0.043945312, -0.019378662, -0.0067825317, -0.01209259, 0.0002937317, 0.07159424, 0.010360718, -0.028366089, -0.00080776215, 0.020202637, -0.04244995, -0.042144775, 0.049346924, -0.0099487305, 0.02104187, 0.05239868, -0.06500244, 0.031921387, 0.012252808, 0.022872925, 0.0049438477, 0.0101623535, -0.0068359375, -0.010574341, -0.031036377, -0.0345459, -0.09851074, -0.007949829, -0.012809753, -0.05706787, -0.028366089, -0.018173218, -0.064208984, -0.048797607, -0.013305664, -0.013618469, -0.022857666, 0.0057525635, 0.015686035, 0.0021839142, -0.032989502, 0.024505615, 0.02381897, -0.042236328, -0.02331543, 0.03933716, 0.03555298, -0.020629883, 0.019927979, 0.029373169, 0.015792847, -0.0053482056, -0.011695862, -0.010818481, 0.02078247, -0.0029697418, 0.023803711, -0.024841309, -0.034179688, 0.06109619, -0.0018024445, 0.004524231, -0.0090789795, -0.027511597, -0.014579773, 0.008117676, 0.027175903, -0.0023899078, 0.030410767, -0.06555176, -0.054504395, -0.03729248, 0.023971558, -0.042785645, -0.021942139, -0.039520264, -0.0011358261, -0.0041160583, -0.023513794, 0.022949219, -0.04107666, -0.0069274902, 0.008262634, 0.058776855, 0.0075035095, -0.049072266, -0.024871826, -0.028289795, 0.014297485, 0.027282715, -0.019180298, -0.04071045, -0.05065918, -0.08654785, -0.025665283, 0.035461426, -0.025268555, 0.018035889, 0.012252808, 0.0068473816, 0.011756897, 0.027008057, -0.03527832, -0.027923584, 0.011177063, 0.020950317, 0.01687622, -0.0077056885, 0.038238525, 0.027893066, -0.010894775, -0.0054244995, -0.01727295, -0.0049095154, -0.019363403, 0.032287598, 0.008369446, 0.038970947, -0.0055618286, -0.010040283, 0.06500244, -0.07232666, -0.029968262, 0.0011892319, 0.042541504, 0.05355835, 0.023361206, -0.012420654, -0.014793396, -0.028213501, -0.05105591, -0.035614014, -0.005569458, -0.0107040405, 0.00869751, -0.008102417, 0.03289795, -0.018463135, -0.013885498, -0.0116119385, -0.03475952, -0.037628174, -0.03805542, -0.024459839, 0.022994995, -0.03050232, 0.005672455, 0.07574463, 0.008720398, -0.055236816, 0.02508545, -0.027832031, -0.052093506, 0.036132812, 0.00504303, 0.03112793, -0.04046631, 0.056640625, -0.0010633469, 0.050445557, 0.043792725, 0.0026245117, -0.013076782, 0.016738892, -0.013572693, 0.060180664, -0.0074272156, 0.09295654, -0.030471802, 0.025115967, 0.018844604, -0.016647339, -0.022384644, -0.031188965, -0.029205322, 0.014381409, 0.025222778, 0.018371582, 0.023223877, 0.0009226799, -0.008552551, 0.039855957, -0.01889038, 0.026794434, -0.030471802, 0.0340271, 0.042236328, 0.020645142, 0.0067214966, 0.046417236, -0.018875122, 0.011802673, 0.056732178, 0.012962341, 0.012390137, -0.00043916702, 0.003118515, 0.011871338, 0.010612488, -0.0022964478, 0.007129669, -0.04724121, -0.00065279007, -0.0006594658, 0.0209198, 0.017730713, -0.01890564, 0.011993408, 0.0017518997, -0.0013074875, -0.038330078, 0.004020691, 0.0030517578, -0.03503418, 0.047546387, 0.011177063, -0.056915283, 0.00440979, 0.004085541, 0.036621094, -0.014289856, 0.028686523, -0.011512756, -0.0035972595, -0.024597168, -0.025115967, 0.0039405823, 0.040924072, 0.024612427, -0.009841919, 0.010772705, 0.0013837814, -0.0019721985, 0.10900879, 0.062042236, -0.013694763, 0.02571106, -0.02204895, 0.023849487, 0.009552002, 0.009086609, -0.007965088, 0.022247314, -0.0067825317, 0.024459839, -0.027404785, -0.013870239, -0.05166626, -0.010719299, 0.0011434555, -0.013832092, -0.048095703, -0.057281494, 0.0026798248, -0.026168823, -0.034729004, -0.018218994, 0.13146973, -0.027145386, -0.021881104, -0.004764557, -0.024459839, -0.046875, 0.023910522, -0.040893555, 0.010971069, 0.0055274963, 0.045776367, 0.041625977, -0.04244995, -0.003484726, -0.0008215904, 0.004497528, -0.015342712, 0.009239197, -0.029418945, -0.0079956055, -0.021606445, -0.0060806274, 0.008735657, -0.018920898, -0.008232117, -0.068237305, 0.03741455, -0.011810303, -0.0067749023, 0.010955811, 0.02331543, -0.005168915, -0.018692017, 0.032958984, 0.0440979, -0.015899658, -0.0070343018, 0.049468994, 0.021469116, -0.0000014901161, 0.0362854, 0.048919678, 0.027374268, -0.010009766, -0.05130005, -0.054016113, 0.0028266907, 0.022262573, 0.004386902, 0.04928589, -0.018875122, 0.0016870499, -0.020843506, -0.028457642, -0.0211792, -0.0262146, 0.031097412, -0.017669678, -0.026916504, -0.0010004044, -0.011962891, 0.015640259, -0.03274536, 0.036193848, 0.062683105, 0.014518738, -0.014556885, -0.016677856, 0.03137207, 0.013679504, 0.016159058, -0.012901306, -0.044769287, 0.009971619, 0.01940918, 0.009979248, -0.01713562, -0.018234253, -0.107543945, -0.011444092, 0.013343811, 0.028518677, -0.0019950867, 0.011116028, -0.05606079, 0.028671265, -0.030548096, -0.01991272, 0.035064697, 0.025466919, 0.028152466, 0.021835327, 0.033294678, -0.027328491, -0.016555786, -0.0178833, -0.097595215, 0.028656006, -0.03378296, -0.033569336, -0.010955811, -0.020828247, -0.06970215, -0.013641357, 0.0018415451, 0.06555176, 0.02079773, 0.00674057, 0.036254883, -0.03390503, -0.0044937134, -0.022109985, -0.037963867, -0.023757935, 0.00484848, 0.053619385, 0.016586304, 0.018814087, 0.034332275, 0.00024914742, -0.04006958, -0.01890564, -0.032287598, 0.02432251, 0.005264282, -0.023025513, -0.04083252, -0.030212402, -0.017074585, -0.005962372, -0.009376526, 0.003074646, -0.023239136, 0.015350342, -0.0068740845, 0.032073975, 0.00048971176, 0.020629883, 0.0029640198, -0.045806885, 0.015136719, -0.035003662, -0.045684814, 0.0206604, 0.025421143, 0.007827759, -0.0140686035, -0.007888794, -0.045898438, 0.015403748, -0.009986877, 0.009460449, 0.02041626, 0.017547607, -0.006198883, -0.04385376, 0.00003772974, 0.025924683, -0.032592773, -0.004825592, 0.0019721985, 0.009651184, 0.033843994, -0.05178833, -0.0015411377, 0.009674072, -0.091918945, -0.0259552, 0.026290894, -0.003200531, -0.050048828, -0.01574707, 0.039489746, 0.005004883, -0.0046043396, 0.018920898, -0.010566711, -0.035705566, -0.010887146, -0.07006836, -0.014907837, 0.09411621, 0.026306152, 0.03643799, 0.04977417, -0.029327393, -0.0110321045, -0.0057792664, 0.054016113, 0.046875, 0.044952393, 0.026992798, -0.043182373, 0.031219482, -0.025161743, 0.011947632, 0.034301758, 0.017730713, -0.0077667236, -0.0046157837, 0.013504028, 0.026519775, -0.022033691, 0.043640137, 0.012207031, 0.0087509155, -0.08355713, 0.020828247, -0.0016469955, -0.005596161, -0.015052795, -0.024932861, 0.027175903, 0.02331543, 0.017730713, 0.028839111, 0.0031051636, -0.04437256, 0.033172607, 0.028320312, 0.009239197, -0.00440979, -0.0073623657, 0.049835205, -0.010185242, 0.029647827, -0.041137695, 0.059906006, -0.027557373, 0.010154724, -0.010536194, 0.009010315, -0.05709839, -0.016540527, -0.043304443, -0.04711914, -0.025054932, 0.018127441, -0.019866943, 0.037322998, 0.03845215, -0.011192322, -0.023712158, 0.01374054, 0.042114258, -0.017913818, -0.0031337738, -0.06677246, -0.0006952286, -0.0010738373, -0.040100098, -0.031707764, -0.008903503, 0.001449585, 0.012207031, -0.011230469, -0.025146484, 0.014549255, 0.014091492, 0.036132812, 0.046295166, -0.021865845, -0.048583984, 0.03866577, -0.0033435822, -0.027450562, -0.0074005127, 0.028244019, -0.0074424744, -0.014427185, 0.021087646, -0.03137207, -0.015289307, 0.006511688, 0.039916992, -0.041015625, 0.06738281, -0.03842163, 0.025497437, 0.007675171, 0.004989624, 0.020080566, 0.031143188, -0.029769897, 0.00022554398, 0.0020256042, 0.010574341, 0.012672424, -0.0065345764, 0.024749756, -0.0042304993, 0.012535095, 0.024871826, -0.0181427, 0.008743286, 0.03765869, 0.036010742, 0.004360199, -0.04626465, -0.021316528, 0.0036315918, 0.0047340393, 0.040771484, -0.03817749, 0.036468506, -0.038238525, 0.038146973, 0.03439331, -0.0022583008, 0.026245117, 0.0021686554, 0.023269653, -0.032562256, -0.025680542, 0.025894165, 0.005329132, -0.028121948, -0.004798889, -0.016189575, 0.006778717, 0.007167816, 0.04360962, 0.011665344, 0.0129470825, 0.0010175705, -0.014076233, -0.0018091202, -0.015052795, -0.06137085, -0.007408142, -0.033477783, 0.0040740967, -0.03479004, 0.03640747, -0.032440186, -0.0029182434, -0.04434204, -0.042053223, 0.016296387, -0.061584473, 0.0019817352, 0.04598999, -0.010414124, 0.06359863, -0.048797607, 0.012069702, 0.008087158, 0.07757568, -0.017669678, 0.008361816, 0.0647583, -0.027938843, 0.019012451, 0.0060424805, 0.020645142, 0.00907135, 0.040527344, 0.0022239685, 0.03466797, -0.04437256, -0.0079574585, 0.024658203, 0.00982666, 0.0055885315, -0.03753662, 0.030059814, 0.036712646, -0.030975342, 0.012489319, -0.044769287, -0.0141067505, -0.012268066, -0.027191162, -0.0637207, 0.03274536, -0.0093307495, -0.019226074, -0.038909912, 0.010955811, -0.04815674, 0.00844574, 0.023071289, -0.01687622, -0.026367188, 0.002840042, 0.024871826, -0.039794922, 0.035583496, -0.029541016, -0.0119018555, 0.040985107, 0.04522705, -0.050445557, -0.015991211, -0.000415802, -0.029220581, -0.04296875, -0.015777588, -0.010887146, 0.008720398, -0.012557983, -0.012863159, 0.032318115, -0.008796692, 0.031066895, 0.02670288, -0.011604309, 0.02128601, -0.023101807, -0.029571533, 0.018234253, -0.0022449493, 0.026901245, 0.011352539, -0.01576233, -0.004711151, 0.008453369, 0.027313232, 0.039276123, -0.04949951, -0.045776367, -0.023239136, 0.0385437, -0.008148193, -0.016983032, 0.025131226, 0.020584106, -0.03237915, 0.02532959, 0.012374878, 0.045135498, -0.027404785, -0.041900635, -0.012252808, -0.00831604, -0.010925293, 0.05496216, 0.007209778, -0.02798462, -0.021911621, -0.012756348, -0.024139404, 0.03062439, 0.03692627, -0.009559631, 0.05429077, -0.008758545, 0.025039673, -0.040863037, -0.010787964, -0.027572632, 0.012298584, -0.007896423, -0.06750488, 0.039031982, 0.01651001, -0.006931305, -0.02645874, 0.01940918, 0.02571106, -0.0034370422, 0.031463623, -0.041748047, -0.017364502, -0.02432251, -0.017654419, 0.023895264, 0.010696411, -0.013671875, 0.054138184, -0.024108887, 0.049194336, 0.012237549, 0.05630493, 0.048461914, 0.012565613, 0.01625061, 0.012054443, -0.0060539246, -0.037994385, -0.011558533, -0.04248047, 0.003484726, -0.050323486, 0.0082092285, -0.080322266, 0.049316406, -0.0073623657, 0.030654907, -0.012268066, 0.023376465, -0.019546509, -0.0075531006, 0.05154419, 0.004749298, 0.06549072, -0.020477295, 0.006893158, 0.017929077, -0.048858643, 0.027450562, 0.038391113, -0.03112793, 0.008758545, -0.024887085, -0.020126343, 0.02810669, -0.009246826, 0.014770508, -0.013137817, -0.016677856, -0.041748047, 0.015701294, -0.0030956268, 0.010871887, 0.08294678, 0.018875122, 0.033447266, -0.027435303, 0.03010559, -0.044128418, 0.0061950684, -0.021713257, 0.001991272, -0.045806885, 0.032073975, -0.0073547363, -0.017105103, -0.047790527, 0.049194336, 0.009429932, -0.022521973, -0.009010315, 0.03186035, 0.027023315, 0.017501831, 0.015975952, -0.032684326, -0.010673523, 0.037261963, 0.048828125, -0.015113831, 0.040252686, 0.038482666, 0.029312134, 0.0070648193, -0.0036506653, 0.024780273, 0.0016117096, 0.012039185, 0.019866943, -0.018371582, 0.022872925, 0.009529114, -0.023590088, 0.004638672, 0.0079193115, -0.035461426, -0.009849548, 0.0071640015, 0.06100464, 0.050048828, 0.08428955, 0.032073975, 0.0046653748, 0.000259161, -0.04071045, 0.04437256, 0.02545166, -0.03201294, -0.021087646, -0.047210693, -0.056030273, -0.0018177032, -0.08300781, 0.059020996, -0.046875, -0.03201294, -0.047851562, 0.050109863, 0.010383606, -0.0390625, -0.042022705, -0.015388489, 0.009925842, -0.007637024, 0.0049476624, -0.03010559, -0.074645996, 0.00667572, 0.08129883, -0.0035266876, -0.0014181137, 0.033203125, -0.008506775, -0.082092285, 0.022155762, -0.035369873, 0.060272217, -0.046203613, 0.017044067, 0.009567261, 0.023254395, -0.008720398, -0.06762695, -0.02645874, -0.010414124, 0.005706787, -0.026794434, -0.022872925, -0.014755249, -0.03286743, -0.028945923, -0.06756592, 0.01473999, -0.041168213, 0.022079468, 0.02192688, -0.0413208, -0.02670288, 0.005706787, -0.013938904, 0.04156494, 0.00094509125, -0.021133423, 0.026992798, 0.02381897, -0.039489746, -0.0027866364, -0.0010175705, 0.021392822, 0.00002527237, -0.03768921, 0.012680054, 0.018493652, 0.042663574, -0.037475586, -0.055847168, 0.010444641, -0.0027370453, -0.015945435, 0.019622803, 0.017944336, 0.016647339, 0.033081055, 0.029586792, -0.000541687, -0.05102539, 0.008880615, -0.028793335, 0.038482666, 0.029510498, -0.004383087, -0.025405884, 0.014671326, 0.00459671, -0.014625549, -0.016342163, -0.021636963, -0.026367188, 0.012588501, 0.018661499, -0.0056648254, -0.0036411285, -0.104003906, 0.039001465, 0.0079574585, 0.03488159, 0.004863739, 0.05105591, 0.009109497, 0.084106445, -0.03274536, -0.030014038, 0.022659302, 0.03869629, -0.0007367134, 0.03744507, -0.010574341, 0.0014390945, -0.021316528, 0.0027160645, -0.0030670166, -0.0022735596, 0.0024604797, 0.0040779114, 0.01776123, -0.012809753, -0.06137085, -0.046966553, -0.033721924, 0.011024475, -0.031677246, 0.03201294, -0.008903503, 0.0071525574, 0.004421234, 0.0012159348, 0.030670166, 0.00077676773, -0.06951904, -0.0039100647, 0.02268982, -0.022109985 ], "summary": [ -0.023605347, -0.03741455, -0.042053223, -0.07885742, -0.05203247, 0.021255493, -0.10394287, 0.03289795, 0.024337769, 0.048950195, -0.024291992, 0.0016307831, 0.029434204, -0.0010757446, -0.019134521, -0.0076026917, -0.014511108, 0.028137207, -0.01285553, -0.040771484, 0.008216858, -0.057128906, -0.05001831, 0.026611328, 0.0058288574, -0.002231598, -0.016143799, 0.0055999756, 0.0023937225, 0.014587402, -0.0057029724, 0.0022563934, 0.0057029724, 0.006023407, 0.0105896, 0.008987427, -0.016952515, 0.003414154, 0.014579773, 0.00007367134, 0.033477783, -0.009292603, 0.044433594, 0.015525818, -0.010482788, -0.022277832, 0.03652954, -0.03982544, 0.038238525, 0.019332886, -0.0011148453, 0.02659607, -0.008682251, 0.0024032593, -0.02230835, -0.008308411, -0.05569458, 0.030258179, 0.005706787, 0.08868408, 0.036346436, 0.0062446594, -0.023834229, -0.05911255, 0.016220093, 0.0098724365, 0.036712646, -0.023101807, 0.045959473, 0.052001953, -0.0007286072, -0.020095825, 0.017990112, -0.08068848, 0.01727295, 0.061645508, -0.04348755, 0.0073776245, 0.041229248, -0.033966064, 0.019592285, 0.006614685, -0.008972168, 0.0143585205, -0.010414124, 0.014137268, -0.013374329, -0.025741577, -0.017105103, -0.049072266, -0.017654419, 0.034210205, -0.048339844, -0.027038574, -0.022567749, -0.05001831, -0.03543091, -0.041290283, -0.00868988, -0.0024929047, 0.035369873, -0.024124146, 0.013572693, -0.008262634, 0.020507812, 0.025299072, -0.047058105, 0.012832642, 0.04260254, 0.043884277, 0.0023727417, -0.029708862, 0.029632568, 0.011070251, -0.043395996, -0.031799316, -0.010917664, -0.014503479, -0.012168884, -0.017959595, -0.04800415, -0.021591187, 0.03756714, 0.041168213, 0.0038108826, 0.022323608, 0.0032863617, -0.007663727, 0.057037354, -0.0064888, -0.009399414, -0.00094509125, -0.005947113, 0.015319824, 0.004432678, 0.007648468, -0.027542114, -0.0032634735, -0.023376465, -0.007068634, 0.011024475, -0.021560669, 0.020233154, -0.004486084, -0.035827637, 0.000054001808, 0.02810669, 0.02986145, -0.039245605, -0.05126953, 0.0069389343, 0.00340271, 0.046844482, -0.046569824, -0.058624268, -0.09851074, -0.064086914, -0.034332275, 0.045074463, -0.060180664, 0.010902405, 0.02281189, 0.01939392, -0.0007638931, -0.020019531, -0.04522705, -0.017990112, -0.015571594, 0.017227173, 0.027404785, 0.001004219, 0.019714355, 0.037322998, -0.014801025, -0.010551453, -0.018829346, -0.039520264, 0.012619019, 0.014755249, -0.002374649, 0.025863647, -0.021560669, -0.00011360645, 0.054626465, -0.025222778, -0.04385376, -0.014533997, -0.018188477, 0.06072998, 0.0020313263, 0.015640259, -0.028656006, -0.029891968, -0.04562378, -0.012916565, 0.015808105, -0.029830933, 0.0031833649, -0.017745972, 0.026657104, 0.023025513, -0.013008118, 0.010528564, -0.04953003, -0.013954163, -0.068603516, 0.008491516, 0.013961792, -0.014877319, -0.007598877, 0.044555664, -0.008995056, -0.025970459, 0.0075531006, -0.04324341, -0.038909912, 0.025177002, -0.0050964355, 0.036590576, -0.05480957, 0.10095215, 0.015457153, 0.064331055, 0.07354736, 0.016845703, -0.03137207, 0.019470215, -0.004085541, 0.06713867, -0.01171875, 0.050750732, -0.028274536, 0.044555664, 0.039093018, -0.00018978119, 0.0066184998, 0.016677856, -0.06903076, -0.0019397736, 0.043670654, 0.035736084, 0.0690918, -0.019424438, -0.05984497, 0.012466431, -0.029220581, 0.029006958, -0.059692383, 0.017105103, 0.03753662, -0.018981934, -0.004180908, 0.028213501, -0.024398804, -0.0077781677, 0.034362793, 0.0072517395, -0.013580322, -0.010635376, -0.018310547, 0.013153076, -0.0014066696, -0.023788452, 0.0062561035, -0.02494812, -0.030151367, 0.005420685, 0.01373291, 0.01335907, -0.05114746, 0.013038635, 0.023590088, -0.0063705444, -0.047729492, 0.020584106, -0.016433716, -0.023422241, 0.0368042, 0.0019798279, -0.03942871, -0.00667572, 0.0067367554, -0.008766174, -0.016403198, 0.010955811, 0.028533936, 0.0034103394, -0.019042969, 0.019226074, 0.0418396, 0.043304443, 0.021652222, -0.0043640137, 0.03012085, 0.0039901733, -0.0033740997, 0.051513672, 0.0056037903, 0.0022945404, -0.008781433, 0.025878906, 0.03656006, -0.002790451, -0.0007724762, 0.0041046143, 0.0056266785, 0.0022411346, 0.0012950897, 0.0030670166, -0.03149414, -0.010238647, 0.035614014, 0.021652222, 0.01461792, 0.000003874302, -0.022827148, 0.0030460358, 0.016036987, 0.016464233, 0.043182373, 0.13549805, 0.0116119385, -0.008262634, 0.018356323, -0.028259277, -0.049438477, 0.066101074, -0.040618896, 0.039093018, -0.017974854, -0.012367249, 0.016983032, -0.017196655, 0.03125, -0.0009775162, -0.009361267, 0.0013847351, -0.026733398, -0.013832092, -0.0038280487, 0.020477295, 0.0068473816, 0.004917145, 0.015701294, -0.035980225, -0.048614502, 0.013885498, -0.011634827, 0.050964355, -0.0032081604, 0.034423828, 0.007534027, -0.01713562, 0.04547119, 0.025650024, -0.050994873, 0.006980896, 0.04663086, 0.004436493, -0.0074691772, 0.026245117, 0.045013428, 0.024139404, 0.010528564, -0.046325684, -0.036621094, 0.0042686462, 0.044830322, 0.02658081, 0.025634766, 0.01914978, 0.020980835, -0.0073127747, -0.026123047, -0.024337769, -0.03515625, 0.0881958, -0.002161026, -0.04776001, 0.028060913, 0.0007891655, 0.018829346, -0.028579712, 0.008995056, 0.021072388, 0.035491943, -0.00856781, -0.035461426, 0.043884277, 0.0022506714, 0.031188965, 0.0031223297, -0.06097412, -0.006454468, 0.028427124, 0.01713562, 0.008293152, 0.0010070801, -0.062927246, -0.035308838, -0.00083494186, 0.04901123, 0.044525146, -0.0027103424, -0.05380249, 0.05886841, -0.031982422, 0.0041389465, 0.042938232, -0.009017944, 0.041290283, -0.0026721954, 0.05819702, -0.04421997, -0.026229858, -0.0052604675, -0.032348633, 0.008087158, -0.015777588, 0.008224487, -0.0036697388, 0.017608643, -0.018737793, 0.015686035, -0.01789856, 0.05404663, -0.021530151, 0.020858765, 0.012214661, -0.0119018555, -0.0035743713, -0.008651733, -0.03314209, 0.0061149597, 0.012825012, 0.059753418, 0.007457733, -0.007835388, 0.028060913, -0.022979736, -0.07696533, -0.022659302, -0.031021118, 0.008483887, 0.0053634644, -0.0178833, -0.034118652, -0.08850098, 0.02558899, -0.024749756, -0.0042915344, 0.0010223389, 0.042938232, 0.02659607, -0.0075531006, 0.072753906, 0.0024929047, 0.034454346, 0.0703125, -0.06756592, -0.018615723, -0.03918457, -0.0010442734, 0.018005371, 0.0118255615, 0.016967773, -0.03817749, 0.02017212, -0.03717041, -0.0012264252, 0.0132751465, 0.01109314, 0.017349243, 0.002746582, -0.018218994, -0.03817749, 0.026550293, -0.0026569366, 0.029129028, -0.01651001, -0.005355835, 0.006565094, 0.05456543, -0.016174316, -0.003396988, 0.008590698, -0.059936523, -0.03378296, 0.018371582, 0.036376953, -0.028045654, 0.0028381348, 0.040283203, -0.0017280579, -0.0011262894, 0.033813477, -0.011116028, -0.003042221, 0.005367279, -0.06793213, -0.0073623657, 0.032440186, 0.046722412, 0.01852417, -0.0028190613, 0.034118652, 0.021514893, 0.0035552979, 0.04510498, 0.009918213, 0.021209717, -0.013435364, -0.029907227, 0.0016889572, -0.009216309, -0.018997192, 0.012084961, 0.0016460419, -0.009498596, -0.0012779236, 0.025161743, 0.04159546, -0.037261963, 0.013954163, 0.02949524, 0.018661499, -0.062347412, 0.034576416, -0.015991211, 0.01828003, -0.027374268, -0.007335663, -0.024795532, -0.01713562, 0.05886841, -0.025878906, -0.0067214966, -0.08416748, -0.012802124, 0.068481445, 0.0061454773, -0.0037498474, -0.0065307617, 0.06555176, -0.022506714, -0.0014009476, -0.06536865, 0.009033203, -0.02116394, -0.012199402, 0.0062294006, 0.008964539, -0.05718994, -0.026824951, -0.01158905, -0.011253357, -0.03567505, 0.018218994, -0.014678955, 0.009216309, 0.0211792, 0.0113220215, -0.004535675, -0.018188477, 0.01436615, 0.0071029663, -0.0019836426, -0.046417236, -0.03842163, -0.01486969, -0.008010864, -0.006298065, -0.061187744, -0.06542969, -0.033081055, 0.0003221035, -0.02835083, 0.046142578, -0.016967773, 0.022262573, 0.054534912, -0.016464233, -0.06542969, 0.01927185, -0.0017566681, 0.0032520294, -0.04559326, 0.05041504, -0.018173218, 0.0023384094, 0.015487671, -0.027008057, -0.022262573, -0.029632568, 0.0030384064, -0.005584717, 0.03387451, 0.025894165, 0.04815674, 0.013504028, 0.034210205, -0.012718201, 0.009033203, 0.0033130646, 0.001086235, -0.018325806, -0.008705139, 0.055267334, -0.037017822, 0.03555298, -0.015640259, 0.016448975, 0.027435303, -0.047790527, 0.009170532, 0.07159424, 0.054504395, 0.011474609, -0.0027484894, -0.030715942, 0.0000014305115, 0.022842407, 0.002708435, -0.027526855, -0.0012998581, -0.03543091, 0.035186768, 0.033599854, -0.008911133, -0.0068473816, 0.015319824, -0.007572174, -0.0052986145, 0.01953125, 0.0105896, -0.04083252, -0.017974854, -0.037475586, -0.027038574, -0.0017900467, -0.004096985, 0.027648926, 0.008201599, -0.013191223, 0.0154953, -0.008087158, -0.0033817291, -0.009384155, -0.017486572, -0.036895752, -0.010391235, 0.008361816, -0.0012331009, 0.031143188, 0.0059394836, 0.017242432, -0.028213501, -0.012084961, 0.014305115, -0.022766113, -0.04562378, 0.029266357, -0.044006348, 0.030761719, 0.00029420853, -0.0017957687, -0.024978638, 0.0592041, -0.045654297, 0.02609253, 0.041625977, -0.03918457, 0.026382446, 0.0007996559, 0.0037250519, 0.03930664, 0.02180481, 0.0048332214, 0.019073486, 0.0038986206, -0.01902771, 0.007621765, 0.018081665, 0.022857666, -0.03555298, 0.03387451, 0.022109985, -0.02128601, -0.0021705627, -0.037109375, -0.044647217, -0.034851074, -0.023773193, -0.06756592, 0.04714966, 0.0082473755, -0.03173828, 0.0058059692, 0.020935059, -0.022399902, 0.0016851425, 0.014633179, -0.027130127, -0.01939392, -0.039367676, 0.0095825195, 0.026412964, 0.043029785, 0.0050086975, -0.0019140244, 0.026885986, 0.024917603, -0.007774353, -0.0039253235, -0.034729004, -0.017684937, -0.016357422, -0.036895752, -0.015792847, 0.060272217, -0.004016876, 0.030044556, 0.05493164, -0.034210205, 0.02909851, -0.0056114197, -0.0061149597, 0.0050086975, -0.019973755, -0.049987793, 0.030776978, -0.028411865, -0.027313232, 0.018569946, -0.004386902, 0.034484863, -0.008552551, 0.05307007, 0.03491211, -0.089416504, -0.033813477, -0.04208374, 0.04647827, -0.009391785, -0.004184723, 0.0039634705, -0.0033721924, -0.034729004, 0.022583008, -0.0003209114, 0.03503418, -0.0033740997, -0.059539795, -0.019104004, 0.0104599, -0.0051651, 0.0004916191, 0.023666382, -0.043823242, 0.00907135, -0.01071167, -0.0037651062, 0.0064926147, 0.036193848, 0.019424438, 0.05899048, 0.04336548, 0.057128906, -0.0158844, 0.008361816, 0.0013723373, 0.014183044, -0.018569946, -0.033050537, 0.009994507, 0.024337769, -0.018417358, 0.002773285, 0.005908966, 0.05178833, 0.010726929, 0.055114746, -0.06573486, -0.03778076, -0.036743164, 0.008766174, 0.042877197, 0.037963867, -0.036621094, 0.027572632, 0.044128418, 0.031433105, 0.049041748, 0.026870728, 0.028259277, -0.001452446, 0.025436401, 0.010650635, -0.028335571, -0.013954163, 0.0053977966, -0.017791748, -0.0079574585, -0.03640747, -0.0127334595, -0.026046753, 0.057495117, -0.02394104, 0.013168335, -0.0038909912, 0.011726379, -0.03390503, 0.009185791, -0.012031555, 0.05923462, 0.03741455, 0.02041626, 0.03010559, 0.009292603, -0.101257324, 0.005882263, 0.0579834, -0.043182373, 0.014518738, -0.001373291, -0.00459671, 0.042633057, -0.012413025, -0.019622803, -0.035491943, 0.019805908, -0.047607422, 0.014251709, 0.03274536, 0.025131226, 0.025482178, 0.01776123, 0.02293396, -0.0010280609, 0.02166748, -0.005344391, 0.04940796, -0.028274536, -0.004009247, -0.0024681091, 0.03100586, 0.04949951, -0.028945923, -0.07513428, 0.010551453, 0.006504059, -0.01071167, 0.009552002, 0.018615723, 0.011619568, -0.005340576, 0.021820068, -0.009521484, -0.011329651, 0.024765015, 0.015167236, 0.02168274, 0.07525635, 0.04473877, 0.008552551, 0.019592285, 0.014472961, 0.011779785, -0.005657196, 0.021835327, 0.02456665, -0.019470215, 0.014282227, -0.009613037, -0.018569946, 0.0056915283, 0.011878967, -0.020523071, -0.016479492, 0.023391724, 0.056610107, 0.037109375, 0.07299805, -0.0031051636, 0.040283203, -0.007167816, 0.0006418228, 0.05456543, -0.04284668, 0.0072669983, -0.026290894, -0.06109619, -0.017654419, -0.034332275, -0.07531738, 0.047332764, -0.050628662, 0.01411438, -0.01386261, 0.024169922, -0.035125732, -0.0026721954, -0.05316162, 0.020980835, 0.011421204, 0.013847351, 0.045837402, -0.048706055, -0.03515625, -0.0042419434, 0.027908325, -0.01272583, 0.029968262, 0.070495605, -0.026519775, -0.041503906, 0.037384033, 0.008705139, 0.080078125, -0.018005371, -0.022720337, 0.03010559, 0.014907837, 0.012557983, -0.032409668, -0.031204224, 0.021896362, 0.03778076, -0.021972656, -0.00932312, -0.00022494793, -0.024490356, -0.047607422, -0.09246826, 0.011199951, -0.053771973, 0.035583496, 0.018371582, -0.0005764961, -0.0065231323, 0.018478394, -0.027374268, 0.0048942566, -0.042022705, -0.02319336, 0.035461426, 0.027755737, -0.026565552, 0.0132751465, -0.0046424866, 0.003686905, -0.04034424, -0.029708862, 0.004470825, -0.021102905, 0.035308838, -0.017242432, -0.068481445, -0.0023155212, -0.020187378, -0.0032444, -0.021728516, -0.025268555, 0.00041794777, 0.07714844, 0.055145264, 0.026565552, -0.051940918, 0.006290436, -0.021987915, -0.0032615662, -0.01965332, 0.013404846, -0.06719971, 0.0020065308, 0.015083313, -0.031219482, -0.011642456, -0.018096924, -0.043884277, 0.013885498, -0.009384155, -0.005870819, -0.049713135, -0.09625244, -0.021942139, 0.0026054382, -0.02784729, 0.0036888123, 0.053771973, -0.0670166, 0.028076172, -0.041168213, 0.027999878, -0.026611328, -0.012702942, 0.010505676, -0.0036239624, 0.015899658, 0.033447266, -0.02722168, 0.02204895, 0.024108887, 0.03414917, -0.044708252, 0.042633057, 0.031707764, 0.014282227, -0.048309326, -0.05368042, -0.025360107, -0.01071167, -0.030670166, 0.046569824, 0.041992188, -0.0007452965, 0.028945923, 0.0015239716, 0.019119263, 0.038970947, -0.023895264, 0.006877899, -0.030212402, 0.0096588135 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07424v1
Hallucination Augmented Recitations for Language Models
Abdullatif Köksal, Renat Aksitov, Chung-Ching Chang
cs.CL, cs.AI
Attribution is a key concept in large language models (LLMs) as it enables control over information sources and enhances the factuality of LLMs. While existing approaches utilize open book question answering to improve attribution, factual datasets may reward language models to recall facts that they already know from their pretraining data, not attribution. In contrast, counterfactual open book QA datasets would further improve attribution because the answer could only be grounded in the given text. We propose Hallucination Augmented Recitations (HAR) for creating counterfactual datasets by utilizing hallucination in LLMs to improve attribution. For open book QA as a case study, we demonstrate that models finetuned with our counterfactual datasets improve text grounding, leading to better open book QA performance, with up to an 8.0% increase in F1 score. Our counterfactual dataset leads to significantly better performance than using humanannotated factual datasets, even with 4x smaller datasets and 4x smaller models. We observe that improvements are consistent across various model sizes and datasets, including multi-hop, biomedical, and adversarial QA datasets.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07424v1
2023-11-13T15:58:18
2023-11-13T15:58:18
{ "title": [ -0.011192322, 0.0016565323, -0.027801514, -0.05999756, -0.026565552, -0.000053465366, -0.058380127, -0.006385803, 0.010620117, 0.051116943, -0.010360718, 0.0013523102, 0.019592285, -0.010063171, -0.057434082, 0.026657104, 0.00017213821, 0.04336548, -0.009773254, -0.03829956, -0.0052986145, -0.05026245, 0.005088806, 0.014564514, 0.0025806427, -0.028381348, -0.045684814, 0.030441284, -0.022613525, 0.0050621033, -0.008163452, -0.015304565, 0.041137695, 0.037597656, -0.032287598, -0.0073623657, -0.040130615, 0.010536194, -0.005432129, 0.012527466, 0.01436615, -0.0064964294, -0.01651001, -0.015853882, -0.0569458, 0.01977539, -0.054382324, 0.00041508675, 0.00055933, 0.023803711, -0.0034866333, 0.05718994, -0.00712204, 0.019882202, 0.014793396, -0.019897461, -0.041625977, 0.017150879, 0.0209198, 0.052093506, 0.0030078888, -0.021484375, 0.0062942505, -0.01878357, -0.010917664, -0.020111084, -0.02166748, 0.030197144, 0.057495117, 0.00248909, -0.03427124, -0.0007648468, 0.015388489, -0.030929565, -0.016845703, 0.020645142, 0.022155762, 0.018722534, 0.018295288, -0.03363037, 0.010406494, 0.008811951, 0.06829834, -0.011138916, 0.0050735474, -0.046142578, -0.0014982224, -0.0055160522, -0.047546387, -0.080322266, -0.015853882, -0.02796936, -0.033050537, -0.0129852295, -0.0357666, -0.028335571, -0.015655518, 0.014564514, -0.00006979704, -0.035949707, -0.007659912, 0.019989014, -0.05102539, -0.017486572, 0.033935547, 0.021072388, -0.030792236, -0.040893555, 0.02456665, 0.015670776, -0.0340271, 0.04220581, 0.027160645, -0.030349731, 0.007259369, 0.014671326, -0.0078048706, 0.014892578, 0.016952515, 0.007633209, -0.009506226, -0.025009155, 0.016738892, 0.032226562, 0.020141602, 0.011276245, -0.03149414, -0.00051498413, -0.0017871857, 0.022720337, 0.011810303, 0.053894043, -0.11291504, -0.0803833, -0.07348633, 0.046020508, -0.012702942, 0.0038337708, -0.031463623, -0.0039367676, 0.00002527237, -0.012573242, 0.028884888, -0.014038086, 0.004135132, 0.016693115, 0.04864502, -0.00907135, -0.042236328, -0.036254883, -0.030914307, -0.007408142, -0.015083313, 0.023590088, -0.0031204224, -0.010398865, -0.09564209, -0.0073432922, 0.057250977, 0.029403687, 0.028457642, -0.012527466, -0.02734375, 0.040740967, 0.014389038, 0.026443481, 0.02381897, 0.013038635, 0.022018433, 0.03656006, -0.021514893, 0.00039076805, 0.055664062, 0.02532959, -0.0060691833, 0.027404785, 0.005580902, -0.0019893646, 0.027694702, -0.028427124, 0.0029296875, -0.010139465, 0.02116394, 0.038909912, -0.10626221, -0.0017795563, -0.009887695, 0.052703857, 0.08544922, 0.00844574, 0.000017940998, -0.009864807, -0.01902771, -0.011947632, -0.047668457, -0.029388428, 0.041931152, 0.03265381, -0.012397766, 0.018814087, -0.008926392, 0.008033752, -0.0435791, -0.029022217, -0.06317139, -0.03024292, -0.02519226, 0.021194458, -0.006843567, 0.020004272, 0.0569458, 0.028533936, -0.05038452, 0.024520874, -0.025314331, -0.02166748, -0.010818481, 0.042266846, -0.0039024353, 0.025238037, 0.01360321, -0.04437256, 0.03591919, 0.02696228, 0.03173828, 0.011955261, 0.009963989, -0.026473999, 0.053863525, 0.021652222, 0.023910522, -0.03555298, 0.013023376, 0.019119263, -0.019989014, -0.01411438, -0.041046143, -0.04135132, 0.0103302, 0.031677246, 0.0033187866, -0.020080566, -0.004146576, 0.013000488, 0.026748657, -0.019165039, 0.016860962, -0.007911682, -0.0038585663, -0.012367249, 0.064697266, 0.01777649, 0.051086426, 0.060058594, 0.004940033, 0.046569824, 0.024093628, 0.006931305, 0.027999878, -0.020690918, 0.024047852, 0.020202637, -0.030334473, 0.01525116, -0.058746338, 0.0146102905, -0.04714966, -0.013076782, -0.010803223, 0.025634766, 0.024414062, -0.03616333, 0.016830444, -0.027297974, -0.018630981, -0.021240234, -0.0076560974, 0.04055786, 0.02003479, -0.06604004, 0.0012731552, 0.027252197, 0.020126343, -0.0034828186, 0.0021877289, 0.019165039, 0.004825592, -0.011077881, -0.034240723, 0.0058021545, 0.046203613, 0.037384033, 0.0340271, -0.015327454, 0.031188965, 0.01361084, 0.062347412, 0.041656494, -0.012771606, 0.014411926, -0.053375244, 0.016036987, 0.013496399, 0.00007921457, 0.007637024, -0.005367279, 0.014892578, 0.00712204, -0.03201294, 0.0044822693, -0.043304443, 0.027496338, 0.0075683594, -0.011734009, -0.03050232, -0.020507812, 0.0030384064, -0.026855469, -0.044952393, -0.030914307, 0.10144043, 0.01625061, -0.02319336, -0.0074005127, 0.002380371, -0.04562378, -0.012557983, -0.04220581, 0.011306763, 0.017150879, 0.059631348, 0.027877808, -0.05117798, -0.06262207, 0.009742737, 0.008987427, -0.010055542, -0.022201538, -0.026473999, 0.03930664, 0.010787964, -0.036224365, 0.016845703, -0.04345703, -0.0021457672, -0.0287323, 0.023803711, 0.003080368, 0.0093307495, 0.0067329407, -0.002752304, -0.0060653687, -0.007232666, 0.03186035, 0.058044434, -0.006324768, -0.032287598, 0.06222534, 0.017318726, -0.004310608, 0.035461426, 0.023773193, 0.00059986115, -0.06500244, 0.020126343, -0.07434082, -0.018539429, -0.04055786, -0.00036907196, 0.042541504, -0.015434265, -0.011581421, -0.061584473, -0.01423645, -0.01108551, -0.0044441223, 0.03475952, -0.01651001, -0.046661377, 0.0042800903, -0.018127441, 0.0079422, -0.014778137, 0.020904541, 0.10321045, -0.0024032593, 0.01008606, 0.018707275, 0.048461914, 0.015670776, -0.011199951, -0.029525757, -0.026733398, -0.012420654, 0.026641846, 0.011444092, -0.023040771, -0.018066406, -0.08105469, 0.005783081, 0.022109985, 0.025390625, -0.011627197, 0.027542114, -0.05130005, -0.010047913, -0.009994507, -0.030090332, 0.026412964, -0.0041046143, 0.010147095, 0.0013103485, 0.014526367, -0.032684326, 0.0060653687, -0.058044434, -0.13671875, 0.021743774, -0.04534912, 0.00015628338, 0.009140015, -0.0552063, -0.02709961, 0.009742737, 0.028900146, 0.024169922, 0.020828247, -0.017745972, 0.01108551, -0.03427124, -0.0075531006, -0.025756836, -0.0025577545, 0.0022239685, -0.024932861, 0.007835388, -0.014816284, 0.011749268, 0.047607422, -0.028289795, 0.010414124, -0.0063591003, -0.01461792, 0.01448822, 0.009208679, -0.036834717, -0.020874023, 0.018508911, -0.030456543, 0.011772156, -0.02444458, 0.01940918, -0.038970947, 0.0049438477, -0.014945984, 0.04284668, 0.009750366, -0.0013341904, -0.0013608932, -0.03704834, -0.01713562, -0.0033740997, -0.06213379, -0.023483276, 0.05105591, -0.0031585693, -0.0087890625, -0.013572693, -0.022338867, 0.024108887, 0.00349617, -0.012229919, -0.0020065308, 0.0064582825, -0.010055542, -0.004436493, -0.012901306, 0.0008735657, 0.0104904175, 0.01550293, -0.029968262, 0.023910522, -0.029129028, -0.06695557, -0.015083313, -0.0028743744, -0.06970215, -0.021606445, 0.014595032, -0.028808594, -0.020629883, -0.042419434, 0.0010890961, 0.0041122437, -0.043518066, -0.0008883476, -0.019363403, -0.014923096, -0.020721436, -0.09838867, 0.024276733, 0.066711426, -0.008926392, 0.034973145, 0.052124023, -0.035308838, -0.07171631, -0.007774353, 0.04083252, 0.027862549, 0.0006837845, 0.02709961, 0.0062217712, 0.03463745, -0.021621704, -0.0007314682, 0.06213379, -0.024032593, 0.010231018, 0.016937256, -0.007007599, 0.056365967, -0.014144897, 0.06689453, -0.012741089, -0.022720337, -0.074645996, 0.017318726, 0.0019798279, 0.015670776, -0.005630493, -0.037200928, -0.017929077, -0.007926941, 0.03994751, 0.039245605, -0.0030441284, -0.007381439, 0.023620605, 0.024795532, -0.026779175, -0.01713562, 0.02909851, 0.032318115, -0.0039138794, 0.057922363, 0.00497818, 0.07684326, 0.023208618, -0.015571594, 0.016479492, 0.029510498, -0.045135498, 0.0009651184, -0.040740967, -0.038970947, -0.02293396, 0.0029087067, -0.020858765, 0.035736084, 0.04156494, 0.0031166077, -0.026885986, -0.0031585693, 0.09094238, -0.016052246, 0.007522583, -0.0715332, -0.004234314, 0.0018520355, -0.057525635, -0.036193848, -0.022323608, -0.0038890839, -0.006755829, -0.024734497, 0.0030059814, 0.02458191, 0.024871826, 0.028076172, 0.057006836, -0.030090332, -0.047973633, 0.027404785, -0.009483337, -0.03793335, 0.022827148, 0.010124207, 0.0043296814, -0.028503418, 0.007320404, -0.031555176, -0.0036849976, -0.0061950684, 0.025756836, -0.018463135, 0.05456543, -0.05444336, -0.0016775131, 0.010505676, 0.03062439, 0.00818634, 0.010543823, -0.032409668, 0.025817871, -0.0065307617, 0.029678345, 0.009597778, 0.020904541, 0.035064697, 0.020492554, 0.015640259, -0.019088745, 0.004501343, 0.0010166168, 0.015258789, 0.024734497, -0.029220581, -0.080322266, -0.010063171, 0.0043411255, -0.007801056, 0.047027588, -0.02722168, 0.032440186, -0.012390137, 0.012313843, 0.015434265, -0.0063972473, 0.033843994, 0.00289917, 0.014930725, -0.03289795, -0.07269287, -0.0032539368, 0.047576904, -0.021972656, -0.012535095, 0.0059280396, 0.040100098, 0.052459717, 0.032104492, 0.024246216, -0.010925293, -0.02470398, -0.015472412, 0.0011548996, -0.00068187714, -0.060638428, -0.021133423, -0.033447266, 0.013420105, -0.02633667, 0.035614014, -0.02684021, -0.017684937, -0.04031372, -0.024291992, 0.04510498, -0.029052734, 0.047912598, 0.12573242, -0.01663208, 0.07232666, 0.004009247, 0.0023040771, 0.031829834, 0.076171875, -0.009010315, 0.025970459, 0.055511475, -0.04058838, 0.048217773, 0.015182495, 0.025848389, -0.009216309, 0.029190063, -0.0011520386, 0.014373779, -0.04449463, 0.010520935, -0.0014381409, -0.0038986206, 0.022338867, -0.06008911, 0.024169922, 0.0021095276, -0.0032444, 0.019470215, 0.005886078, -0.04864502, -0.03857422, 0.012321472, -0.037506104, -0.006752014, 0.0062026978, -0.034301758, -0.023239136, 0.04598999, -0.035217285, 0.020980835, 0.014640808, -0.039489746, -0.039855957, 0.0067749023, 0.008377075, -0.015602112, 0.023773193, -0.015853882, -0.00623703, 0.020950317, 0.03543091, 0.0016622543, 0.010169983, -0.006702423, -0.04751587, -0.016433716, -0.002588272, -0.01109314, 0.0041389465, -0.0018873215, -0.011833191, -0.0057754517, -0.004043579, 0.020767212, -0.0065574646, -0.019439697, 0.03540039, -0.032958984, -0.03604126, 0.003074646, 0.050811768, 0.020339966, -0.014419556, -0.008331299, -0.026535034, 0.027893066, 0.015930176, 0.02607727, 0.012649536, -0.025924683, -0.0018386841, 0.030914307, 0.0067100525, -0.03152466, 0.04348755, 0.025238037, -0.05529785, 0.027420044, 0.027740479, 0.057159424, -0.03451538, 0.0057525635, -0.03466797, -0.0008573532, -0.047424316, 0.03161621, -0.014778137, 0.014175415, -0.030258179, -0.042510986, -0.019973755, 0.03164673, 0.04043579, 0.0005578995, 0.019088745, -0.037475586, 0.017486572, -0.018447876, -0.01713562, -0.033569336, 0.023590088, -0.014312744, -0.027328491, 0.029953003, 0.019836426, -0.007637024, -0.03111267, 0.027389526, 0.025527954, -0.019470215, 0.031555176, -0.01197052, 0.0013599396, -0.015312195, -0.007774353, 0.030014038, -0.0070381165, -0.012680054, 0.021575928, -0.052581787, 0.05166626, 0.024795532, 0.040100098, 0.030090332, 0.0107421875, 0.0023937225, 0.013397217, 0.02015686, -0.03262329, 0.00019550323, -0.050628662, -0.02053833, -0.053894043, 0.0040283203, -0.105773926, 0.013420105, -0.0072669983, 0.015487671, -0.028167725, 0.023605347, -0.0051078796, -0.0064315796, 0.059173584, -0.034118652, 0.05697632, -0.021728516, 0.00919342, -0.015930176, -0.02961731, 0.020965576, 0.041900635, 0.0038890839, -0.013000488, -0.026687622, -0.0049438477, 0.04876709, -0.006137848, -0.011077881, -0.008811951, 0.013420105, -0.035980225, -0.011978149, -0.023986816, 0.031188965, 0.04727173, -0.0066871643, 0.0048217773, -0.0068359375, -0.0037899017, -0.033416748, -0.0011005402, -0.033233643, 0.028182983, -0.088256836, 0.029571533, 0.0013856888, -0.008987427, -0.03186035, 0.055999756, 0.025802612, -0.020324707, 0.0052719116, 0.025924683, 0.031051636, 0.019958496, 0.034301758, -0.044647217, -0.034088135, -0.0055274963, 0.029373169, -0.019760132, 0.008262634, 0.0073928833, 0.024765015, -0.03237915, -0.03338623, 0.023895264, -0.027801514, -0.0020484924, 0.013053894, 0.018585205, 0.034729004, -0.0046195984, -0.036834717, 0.009521484, 0.0018501282, -0.03366089, -0.016326904, -0.014762878, 0.0395813, 0.02027893, 0.047454834, -0.0006737709, -0.018875122, -0.0010299683, -0.039276123, 0.0016536713, 0.0074157715, -0.028869629, 0.019042969, -0.018920898, -0.012542725, 0.037902832, -0.017150879, 0.039245605, -0.054992676, 0.02444458, -0.025665283, 0.032684326, 0.019882202, -0.03955078, -0.061645508, 0.015289307, -0.03439331, 0.011581421, 0.033111572, -0.0357666, -0.035736084, -0.008232117, 0.0036697388, -0.011955261, 0.010543823, 0.029190063, -0.021072388, -0.0692749, 0.010345459, -0.016921997, 0.04776001, -0.04168701, -0.030639648, -0.022491455, 0.013420105, 0.035461426, -0.0040283203, -0.04650879, 0.050476074, -0.031036377, -0.0390625, 0.026977539, 0.027832031, -0.0051574707, -0.010986328, -0.051208496, 0.009300232, -0.03100586, 0.034606934, 0.013511658, -0.03326416, -0.016036987, 0.0119018555, -0.041229248, 0.009399414, -0.020950317, -0.019119263, 0.027282715, 0.0027770996, -0.034973145, 0.007396698, 0.022842407, 0.06500244, 0.0018501282, -0.043762207, 0.028503418, -0.01966858, 0.027755737, -0.048217773, -0.08514404, -0.015533447, 0.024108887, -0.023132324, 0.03616333, 0.031951904, 0.018173218, 0.011222839, 0.019454956, -0.0067634583, -0.037597656, -0.03363037, -0.006198883, 0.037750244, 0.041412354, -0.0031795502, -0.016601562, 0.022583008, 0.0007019043, -0.004337311, 0.004852295, -0.01322937, 0.005832672, 0.0008158684, 0.023132324, -0.030212402, -0.0013504028, -0.06188965, -0.0060920715, 0.011260986, 0.022216797, 0.0044937134, 0.025177002, -0.027786255, 0.0914917, -0.0395813, -0.04711914, 0.060150146, 0.043182373, 0.015556335, 0.022918701, 0.0154418945, 0.0011253357, 0.012298584, 0.002193451, 0.014015198, 0.018356323, 0.031143188, -0.056243896, 0.00004249811, -0.0881958, -0.048950195, -0.056365967, -0.046325684, 0.019943237, -0.037628174, 0.0262146, -0.018463135, -0.0032444, 0.00793457, 0.004371643, 0.029296875, 0.0075569153, -0.071899414, -0.07318115, 0.030532837, -0.029052734 ], "summary": [ 0.0002411604, -0.021377563, -0.010375977, 0.029846191, -0.0552063, -0.018325806, -0.037963867, -0.041778564, 0.014625549, 0.02746582, -0.030578613, 0.0057754517, 0.01108551, -0.0095825195, -0.000042021275, -0.00894165, -0.010238647, 0.051879883, -0.010246277, -0.021850586, -0.019226074, -0.025924683, -0.062194824, -0.00680542, 0.045043945, -0.05734253, 0.01689148, -0.008583069, 0.054138184, 0.03778076, 0.03265381, -0.05633545, 0.051574707, -0.0038452148, -0.047851562, -0.031402588, -0.047332764, 0.00037050247, -0.048065186, 0.032836914, 0.026473999, -0.013145447, 0.0078048706, -0.021255493, -0.016845703, 0.0047721863, 0.013931274, -0.03527832, 0.05718994, 0.009628296, -0.009437561, 0.036193848, -0.009155273, 0.042999268, -0.03918457, -0.050750732, -0.02520752, -0.026397705, -0.0011262894, 0.0423584, 0.038330078, 0.012138367, -0.00055265427, -0.010231018, -0.0036678314, -0.020736694, -0.007751465, -0.0049438477, 0.042388916, 0.004638672, 0.01864624, 0.0154800415, 0.02142334, -0.03475952, 0.0158844, 0.029968262, 0.01701355, 0.03692627, 0.0051651, -0.010276794, 0.018997192, 0.0345459, 0.038330078, -0.01878357, -0.0067863464, -0.033447266, -0.0105896, -0.006793976, 0.0128479, -0.041168213, 0.014732361, -0.02520752, -0.05078125, 0.040130615, 0.022994995, -0.07910156, 0.038970947, 0.02885437, -0.0023956299, -0.06665039, 0.04385376, -0.016433716, -0.07092285, 0.019546509, 0.020553589, 0.033691406, -0.04940796, -0.04135132, 0.033050537, 0.01828003, -0.012458801, -0.0059051514, -0.02696228, -0.07562256, 0.0129470825, 0.04168701, -0.025650024, 0.064086914, 0.030197144, 0.027328491, -0.03125, -0.012466431, 0.025360107, 0.032440186, 0.0026855469, 0.036315918, 0.0061302185, -0.011810303, -0.027450562, 0.038513184, 0.0031814575, 0.025924683, -0.02684021, -0.03012085, -0.051239014, -0.00881958, 0.016021729, 0.0055160522, -0.022323608, 0.022644043, -0.005168915, -0.0045776367, 0.050354004, -0.02305603, -0.015022278, 0.030273438, 0.017471313, -0.0043525696, -0.028671265, -0.029190063, 0.002281189, -0.040039062, 0.022979736, -0.0020103455, -0.038085938, -0.059326172, -0.053588867, -0.0038375854, 0.0418396, -0.014381409, 0.03265381, -0.010368347, -0.021469116, 0.025146484, -0.041046143, -0.009025574, 0.016021729, -0.022140503, 0.00737381, 0.0028209686, -0.008674622, 0.022079468, -0.021697998, -0.009429932, -0.0015096664, -0.016540527, -0.025726318, 0.07208252, 0.0007047653, -0.021621704, 0.036010742, -0.021530151, 0.053497314, 0.037139893, -0.047912598, -0.026931763, -0.0031394958, 0.040252686, 0.07293701, 0.024505615, 0.0011959076, -0.05783081, 0.020431519, -0.04046631, -0.019515991, 0.0002977848, 0.0012111664, 0.039978027, -0.0154953, -0.00541687, 0.049957275, -0.0006542206, -0.031036377, -0.04623413, -0.10675049, -0.019454956, -0.015434265, 0.016525269, -0.043884277, 0.015487671, 0.04815674, 0.025466919, -0.06585693, 0.08874512, 0.04135132, -0.016448975, 0.0019311905, -0.031433105, 0.018447876, -0.04660034, 0.045532227, 0.04699707, 0.01374054, 0.06542969, -0.04714966, -0.020141602, 0.0033416748, 0.006126404, -0.00623703, 0.005218506, 0.036254883, -0.046905518, 0.068115234, 0.042419434, -0.018753052, -0.009185791, -0.011940002, -0.11047363, -0.004558563, 0.061706543, 0.017791748, -0.005218506, -0.027908325, 0.008178711, 0.016998291, 0.038513184, 0.04852295, -0.034973145, -0.003856659, 0.01259613, -0.003982544, 0.0054016113, 0.039794922, -0.029190063, -0.0038585663, 0.06463623, -0.01197052, -0.03704834, 0.019683838, -0.009315491, 0.041778564, 0.008613586, -0.03186035, -0.0009174347, -0.0038414001, -0.034484863, -0.028305054, -0.032989502, -0.026550293, -0.00033569336, 0.027770996, -0.031921387, 0.011940002, -0.06274414, -0.01121521, 0.013328552, -0.024642944, 0.031188965, 0.08483887, -0.027618408, 0.0070114136, -0.004398346, 0.042541504, -0.011154175, 0.06549072, 0.043304443, -0.0026340485, -0.049713135, -0.0039482117, 0.04849243, 0.047698975, 0.0099487305, 0.016937256, -0.024963379, 0.062072754, 0.010276794, 0.0284729, 0.0211792, 0.013885498, -0.011451721, -0.0012578964, 0.03945923, -0.01222229, 0.019638062, 0.018478394, -0.012023926, -0.0031223297, 0.0051727295, -0.01197052, 0.023971558, -0.042297363, 0.046661377, 0.021987915, 0.06414795, -0.04156494, -0.041229248, -0.008087158, 0.023468018, -0.013214111, -0.00932312, 0.13879395, 0.022033691, 0.042999268, 0.01777649, 0.025421143, -0.09277344, 0.039215088, -0.031555176, 0.047088623, 0.0017318726, -0.0024089813, 0.0072135925, -0.048339844, -0.082214355, 0.0054779053, -0.01676941, 0.006790161, -0.031036377, -0.012779236, 0.020309448, 0.027389526, -0.05142212, 0.015037537, 0.005622864, -0.02923584, -0.007511139, 0.0067596436, -0.0063819885, 0.022521973, -0.002609253, 0.016311646, 0.0012159348, -0.013069153, 0.024459839, 0.010421753, 0.02180481, 0.010108948, 0.011543274, 0.0037231445, -0.03173828, 0.0058937073, 0.031585693, -0.011390686, -0.09136963, -0.015113831, -0.02947998, -0.021316528, -0.020965576, 0.029083252, 0.026855469, 0.032348633, 0.0026664734, -0.06518555, -0.016052246, -0.0033664703, -0.022583008, 0.041107178, -0.014701843, -0.0042877197, 0.020004272, 0.037994385, 0.025344849, 0.0018110275, 0.040802002, 0.0770874, 0.016235352, 0.01007843, 0.032318115, 0.028274536, -0.00015771389, 0.007259369, 0.00843811, -0.028930664, -0.031463623, -0.023544312, 0.0028629303, -0.028060913, 0.0007381439, 0.004333496, 0.00031924248, 0.011634827, 0.022476196, 0.030029297, 0.037322998, -0.020355225, 0.06512451, 0.009361267, -0.03427124, 0.049743652, -0.06274414, 0.031204224, -0.019195557, 0.02204895, -0.04928589, -0.036010742, -0.034698486, -0.029037476, 0.015159607, -0.021774292, -0.0032691956, -0.0040130615, 0.020126343, -0.022338867, -0.0020599365, 0.028244019, 0.026855469, -0.0104522705, -0.008331299, -0.0023231506, -0.026641846, -0.019226074, -0.023788452, -0.019042969, 0.006816864, 0.003206253, 0.025177002, -0.0048179626, -0.02381897, 0.030380249, -0.05368042, -0.023376465, -0.027526855, -0.081726074, -0.005039215, 0.000048041344, -0.05731201, -0.036895752, -0.039215088, 0.007587433, 0.034210205, 0.014060974, -0.006378174, -0.012756348, 0.010566711, -0.041137695, 0.047851562, -0.023391724, 0.03314209, 0.03475952, -0.02268982, 0.002040863, -0.010551453, -0.017562866, 0.0050964355, 0.074035645, -0.0211792, -0.029586792, 0.0149383545, 0.006454468, -0.012451172, 0.046142578, -0.026107788, -0.062347412, -0.00894165, 0.013702393, -0.009727478, 0.004360199, 0.03262329, 0.020492554, -0.016448975, -0.07409668, 0.033569336, -0.014312744, -0.09063721, -0.027511597, 0.0055007935, -0.05029297, -0.051574707, 0.025604248, 0.038208008, -0.008323669, 0.00058841705, 0.06512451, -0.01234436, 0.020385742, 0.030654907, -0.030441284, 0.06225586, -0.030197144, -0.11187744, 0.06878662, -0.032562256, 0.0019416809, 0.0793457, -0.0005874634, 0.017166138, 0.011108398, 0.017288208, 0.0062294006, -0.021026611, 0.035583496, -0.01071167, 0.0039520264, 0.0007100105, -0.003250122, 0.02960205, 0.024627686, -0.0095825195, 0.01966858, -0.015777588, -0.007167816, 0.060058594, -0.011886597, 0.040863037, -0.03982544, -0.0031414032, -0.04824829, 0.018005371, 0.019546509, 0.030731201, -0.013801575, -0.017440796, -0.023376465, -0.0023593903, 0.039489746, -0.027450562, -0.03475952, 0.004047394, 0.029724121, 0.007297516, -0.054718018, -0.022567749, 0.031707764, 0.072631836, 0.0032691956, 0.01159668, -0.007785797, 0.0079193115, -0.026733398, -0.011207581, -0.017089844, 0.0032844543, -0.01864624, 0.0027866364, -0.011947632, 0.05368042, -0.041992188, 0.01121521, -0.032470703, 0.046051025, 0.016677856, 0.023605347, 0.0036239624, -0.022521973, 0.021942139, 0.020950317, -0.023880005, -0.07128906, 0.005748749, -0.026306152, -0.028640747, -0.013458252, -0.010795593, -0.032287598, -0.012573242, -0.015655518, -0.017318726, 0.0007658005, -0.0058670044, -0.007293701, 0.021255493, 0.011787415, 0.0015115738, -0.014923096, -0.0007915497, 0.0068588257, -0.014427185, 0.0074920654, 0.003736496, 0.029663086, 0.0059165955, -0.0284729, -0.035858154, -0.05480957, 0.018249512, 0.04034424, 0.03390503, 0.029220581, 0.0010251999, 0.030654907, 0.0134887695, 0.0026893616, -0.017532349, 0.0020141602, 0.025802612, 0.014328003, 0.0028133392, 0.027328491, 0.0084991455, 0.038391113, 0.006290436, -0.052612305, -0.0044670105, 0.026687622, 0.008590698, 0.0029411316, 0.021453857, 0.0011301041, 0.035247803, 0.009735107, 0.051818848, -0.0018892288, 0.036102295, 0.020065308, 0.027816772, 0.012390137, -0.007007599, 0.06286621, -0.005332947, -0.040863037, 0.026947021, -0.043304443, -0.020736694, -0.06298828, -0.0021953583, 0.050689697, -0.0046577454, -0.021743774, 0.0005736351, 0.043792725, 0.04397583, -0.022857666, -0.024047852, -0.0036468506, -0.008560181, -0.0046424866, 0.009254456, 0.0065574646, -0.029174805, -0.034698486, -0.039276123, 0.0030784607, 0.017105103, -0.0076141357, 0.013145447, -0.029785156, -0.0637207, -0.01966858, 0.020126343, -0.00087070465, -0.0491333, 0.041778564, -0.035186768, 0.055603027, 0.050231934, 0.017852783, 0.006385803, 0.03555298, -0.0101623535, -0.013458252, 0.010375977, -0.013908386, -0.0036849976, 0.001250267, 0.022506714, 0.001871109, 0.03439331, 0.02458191, 0.007610321, -0.02960205, -0.00642395, -0.016113281, 0.027114868, 0.010231018, -0.023666382, 0.04812622, 0.009094238, -0.027633667, 0.015899658, 0.0619812, -0.060577393, -0.037384033, 0.0546875, 0.015083313, -0.036102295, 0.014953613, -0.0018663406, 0.022338867, 0.006252289, -0.034729004, 0.03479004, 0.030517578, -0.036956787, -0.001367569, -0.011520386, 0.0012598038, 0.009887695, -0.022903442, -0.032073975, -0.019485474, -0.04196167, 0.045196533, -0.050445557, -0.015525818, -0.022338867, -0.032806396, -0.010101318, -0.0038433075, 0.021057129, 0.02456665, 0.003578186, 0.0049972534, 0.029220581, -0.033843994, 0.0014362335, -0.010787964, 0.0049362183, 0.047332764, -0.01737976, -0.03111267, 0.019714355, 0.02609253, -0.062683105, 0.0231781, 0.04095459, -0.041870117, 0.018600464, 0.05050659, 0.042510986, -0.033416748, -0.054260254, -0.012161255, 0.033081055, -0.012786865, -0.0050964355, 0.070617676, 0.01626587, 0.017593384, 0.04522705, 0.026794434, 0.016967773, 0.012077332, -0.03353882, 0.0043678284, 0.043518066, 0.011367798, 0.0002629757, -0.042419434, -0.027267456, -0.010292053, -0.008323669, 0.011459351, 0.0008940697, -0.012130737, -0.010620117, -0.0045204163, -0.02406311, -0.009117126, 0.023635864, -0.015960693, -0.039733887, 0.001420021, -0.022613525, -0.022445679, 0.06011963, 0.017791748, -0.031402588, -0.026733398, 0.022064209, 0.03717041, -0.0011453629, 0.034240723, 0.025375366, -0.0052833557, -0.019577026, 0.020370483, 0.022415161, 0.027801514, -0.036865234, -0.0066566467, 0.004547119, 0.04055786, 0.05517578, 0.00907135, 0.0039405823, -0.0057411194, 0.0141067505, 0.011375427, 0.013381958, 0.009384155, 0.07067871, -0.021591187, -0.004814148, -0.059783936, -0.039154053, -0.066101074, 0.025604248, -0.015640259, -0.00011008978, -0.009292603, 0.020690918, 0.0018148422, 0.010002136, -0.031280518, -0.0052337646, 0.0067100525, -0.0061149597, -0.0031642914, 0.028259277, -0.068847656, 0.0073394775, 0.042816162, -0.03173828, 0.0093688965, -0.02293396, 0.03829956, 0.05291748, -0.063964844, -0.033569336, -0.0046844482, 0.051483154, -0.020477295, 0.030181885, 0.027297974, 0.06817627, -0.00009858608, -0.053375244, 0.03994751, -0.019134521, -0.028411865, 0.01864624, 0.018325806, -0.011657715, 0.021224976, -0.025527954, -0.00806427, 0.0038871765, -0.023284912, -0.00881958, 0.028793335, 0.006839752, -0.04269409, -0.018829346, -0.003692627, 0.007019043, 0.02619934, -0.0023994446, -0.039245605, 0.003578186, 0.007736206, -0.025054932, 0.00073862076, -0.025177002, 0.0121536255, -0.00024151802, 0.013305664, -0.026016235, 0.032928467, -0.04031372, 0.03656006, 0.01991272, 0.014312744, 0.059143066, 0.019378662, -0.021530151, 0.012809753, 0.033813477, -0.043426514, 0.028182983, -0.020614624, 0.046051025, 0.06347656, 0.066223145, 0.009483337, 0.0138168335, 0.03475952, -0.021316528, 0.0040283203, 0.01928711, 0.010871887, -0.01171875, 0.002407074, -0.0038642883, 0.026443481, 0.026473999, 0.055847168, -0.033050537, 0.032562256, -0.03488159, -0.0003130436, -0.027160645, -0.0206604, 0.017532349, -0.011734009, -0.000934124, 0.022247314, 0.03286743, -0.039886475, -0.0057296753, -0.008926392, -0.011474609, -0.0022659302, 0.00315094, 0.01776123, 0.00033974648, 0.025100708, -0.013381958, 0.0038490295, 0.045654297, -0.0206604, -0.04168701, 0.011116028, 0.026809692, 0.027999878, -0.03692627, -0.032287598, 0.031173706, 0.022766113, -0.014038086, -0.01448822, -0.006855011, -0.01676941, -0.0024967194, 0.00078725815, 0.028564453, -0.026107788, 0.04953003, -0.0059890747, -0.029815674, 0.019515991, 0.032043457, -0.028305054, -0.0051002502, -0.028686523, 0.006790161, 0.09484863, -0.0023078918, -0.017227173, -0.006164551, -0.019683838, -0.034606934, 0.026260376, -0.0206604, 0.0008983612, 0.01423645, 0.010803223, -0.037384033, -0.0071907043, 0.015220642, 0.054107666, 0.0067596436, -0.0032463074, -0.010231018, -0.03604126, -0.010810852, 0.029251099, -0.006290436, -0.0034427643, 0.035095215, -0.0037822723, 0.02520752, 0.01626587, -0.03201294, 0.0287323, 0.024139404, -0.031021118, -0.050079346, 0.0072402954, 0.0184021, -0.039367676, 0.024551392, 0.008483887, -0.04446411, -0.04071045, -0.02746582, -0.03805542, 0.0051345825, -0.03466797, -0.011741638, 0.010124207, -0.07720947, 0.0077667236, -0.035583496, -0.02645874, 0.03665161, 0.0027008057, 0.019561768, -0.030303955, 0.04888916, 0.031982422, 0.016235352, -0.0087890625, 0.015686035, 0.021270752, 0.03463745, -0.05026245, -0.008026123, -0.12176514, -0.031677246, -0.030975342, -0.038146973, 0.019332886, -0.047943115, 0.03213501, 0.009353638, -0.018417358, 0.036956787, 0.00982666, 0.03881836, 0.026733398, -0.004398346, 0.007255554, -0.0060653687, 0.003358841 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07418v1
Speech-based Slot Filling using Large Language Models
Guangzhi Sun, Shutong Feng, Dongcheng Jiang, Chao Zhang, Milica Gašić, Philip C. Woodland
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
Recently, advancements in large language models (LLMs) have shown an unprecedented ability across various language tasks. This paper investigates the potential application of LLMs to slot filling with noisy ASR transcriptions, via both in-context learning and task-specific fine-tuning. Dedicated prompt designs and fine-tuning approaches are proposed to improve the robustness of LLMs for slot filling with noisy ASR transcriptions. Moreover, a linearised knowledge injection (LKI) scheme is also proposed to integrate dynamic external knowledge into LLMs. Experiments were performed on SLURP to quantify the performance of LLMs, including GPT-3.5-turbo, GPT-4, LLaMA-13B and Vicuna-13B (v1.1 and v1.5) with different ASR error rates. The use of the proposed fine-tuning together with the LKI scheme for LLaMA-13B achieved an 8.3% absolute SLU-F1 improvement compared to the strong Flan-T5-base baseline system on a limited data setup.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07418v1
2023-11-13T15:54:30
2023-11-13T15:54:30
{ "title": [ -0.016738892, -0.004722595, -0.023864746, -0.057128906, 0.006668091, 0.0146865845, -0.060394287, -0.003818512, -0.0043678284, 0.047424316, -0.04269409, -0.018066406, 0.0066375732, -0.002565384, -0.061767578, -0.016220093, -0.022720337, 0.031799316, -0.04019165, -0.05255127, 0.020904541, -0.093444824, -0.0062446594, 0.036071777, 0.02760315, -0.053527832, -0.043395996, 0.025100708, -0.043304443, -0.023269653, -0.008323669, 0.015342712, 0.040740967, 0.011657715, 0.0070762634, 0.026168823, -0.023269653, 0.029632568, 0.023895264, 0.00819397, 0.037719727, -0.014183044, -0.04043579, -0.033172607, -0.06390381, 0.037475586, -0.05279541, 0.010879517, -0.01965332, -0.0063934326, 0.015045166, 0.016647339, 0.015068054, 0.0082473755, 0.0005631447, -0.023666382, -0.048583984, 0.031921387, 0.012451172, 0.04849243, 0.01977539, -0.0021190643, -0.0012397766, -0.015426636, -0.04940796, 0.00015056133, -0.0087890625, 0.017959595, 0.042022705, -0.02949524, -0.02734375, -0.0012626648, -0.028289795, -0.023132324, -0.046142578, 0.05142212, 0.00983429, -0.002904892, 0.032440186, -0.019760132, 0.0109939575, -0.0006175041, 0.03390503, -0.055419922, 0.03753662, -0.057006836, -0.0073661804, -0.008148193, -0.034301758, -0.08270264, -0.018569946, -0.008293152, -0.015449524, 0.01914978, -0.029800415, -0.015640259, -0.0017776489, 0.038635254, -0.026626587, -0.02848816, -0.02003479, 0.024597168, -0.036376953, -0.031829834, 0.017532349, 0.027145386, -0.030471802, -0.044647217, 0.018035889, 0.029006958, -0.009468079, 0.035461426, 0.014808655, 0.030853271, -0.022735596, -0.0031738281, -0.011375427, -0.0013933182, -0.0075416565, 0.02722168, -0.034240723, -0.032714844, -0.0009794235, -0.02420044, 0.023712158, -0.021575928, -0.04852295, 0.036621094, -0.03692627, 0.0368042, 0.013381958, 0.03250122, -0.10656738, -0.05319214, -0.06555176, 0.03765869, -0.021118164, -0.0072250366, -0.03881836, 0.0041618347, 0.010620117, -0.022338867, -0.01260376, -0.01737976, -0.0027160645, 0.005508423, 0.059265137, -0.011222839, -0.04711914, -0.013298035, -0.019424438, 0.011909485, 0.010528564, 0.00097084045, -0.019210815, -0.019470215, -0.107543945, -0.013847351, 0.029373169, 0.023666382, -0.007320404, -0.0043945312, -0.015235901, -0.017364502, -0.012588501, 0.00440979, 0.017868042, 0.016220093, 0.007911682, -0.014183044, 0.004825592, 0.045898438, 0.008346558, 0.0015678406, 0.0067329407, -0.00680542, 0.047821045, 0.011367798, 0.03286743, -0.0335083, -0.0012254715, -0.011688232, 0.04611206, 0.00932312, -0.056365967, -0.040283203, 0.014549255, 0.018508911, 0.033569336, 0.028213501, -0.009056091, 0.013832092, -0.014549255, -0.025512695, -0.059326172, -0.054504395, 0.029373169, 0.020385742, -0.0073547363, 0.014480591, -0.0026359558, 0.015029907, -0.02230835, -0.015472412, -0.015609741, -0.035064697, -0.008842468, 0.02432251, -0.01133728, 0.04107666, 0.054504395, 0.011413574, -0.04650879, -0.0040740967, -0.015136719, -0.045654297, 0.016571045, 0.051696777, 0.010383606, 0.025894165, 0.0022640228, -0.06500244, 0.036621094, 0.031280518, 0.016464233, -0.008575439, 0.005996704, -0.029067993, 0.027053833, 0.027191162, 0.020141602, -0.027542114, 0.03463745, 0.015151978, -0.027694702, -0.011260986, -0.011276245, 0.013198853, 0.001461029, 0.0021419525, -0.003376007, 0.0012168884, -0.026290894, 0.02406311, 0.02142334, -0.016525269, 0.0072898865, 0.012931824, 0.011726379, 0.039794922, 0.041778564, 0.035491943, 0.033691406, 0.004673004, -0.0064582825, 0.06695557, 0.017089844, -0.0019893646, -0.018005371, -0.0012874603, 0.023376465, -0.01966858, -0.037475586, 0.005580902, -0.03894043, 0.013076782, -0.03933716, -0.0107040405, -0.0061569214, 0.018966675, 0.022583008, -0.040130615, 0.017807007, -0.018249512, -0.00022113323, -0.01335144, -0.010658264, 0.0079193115, 0.021850586, -0.0541687, -0.007843018, 0.015899658, -0.0022277832, -0.00037527084, -0.00299263, 0.0006284714, 0.016067505, 0.015342712, 0.0069999695, -0.0075149536, 0.03326416, 0.056518555, 0.018875122, 0.022735596, 0.023590088, 0.007858276, 0.07879639, 0.054901123, -0.024032593, 0.037750244, -0.04425049, 0.012557983, 0.0143585205, -0.016098022, 0.008293152, 0.011543274, 0.021865845, 0.02279663, -0.0017776489, 0.01007843, -0.024719238, 0.045654297, 0.004119873, -0.021987915, -0.052764893, -0.044555664, 0.0026226044, -0.02708435, -0.03439331, -0.0063591003, 0.10083008, -0.021881104, -0.026565552, -0.005996704, -0.01826477, -0.03817749, -0.0076522827, -0.04562378, 0.0026950836, 0.0056877136, 0.052520752, 0.032958984, -0.04067993, -0.022506714, -0.0005478859, -0.022537231, -0.012962341, 0.0006995201, -0.01486969, 0.024276733, 0.014320374, 0.0071983337, 0.011581421, -0.043884277, 0.007408142, -0.051849365, 0.031051636, -0.004573822, -0.026245117, 0.011711121, 0.015075684, -0.0068855286, -0.017684937, 0.036224365, 0.057739258, -0.0044403076, -0.02494812, 0.048858643, 0.022964478, -0.016235352, 0.072143555, 0.038757324, 0.040802002, -0.07019043, -0.043884277, -0.07501221, -0.012168884, -0.037231445, -0.027755737, 0.029449463, -0.06060791, -0.0335083, -0.0124053955, -0.012451172, -0.005836487, 0.039978027, 0.045898438, -0.016799927, -0.033416748, 0.0066223145, -0.017120361, 0.04171753, -0.051879883, 0.06536865, 0.0680542, 0.027648926, 0.021636963, 0.016311646, 0.022994995, -0.016571045, -0.027420044, 0.014480591, -0.020004272, -0.0014286041, 0.038238525, 0.018859863, -0.021865845, -0.023269653, -0.10437012, -0.003194809, 0.047088623, 0.006668091, -0.017166138, 0.04434204, -0.058776855, 0.0368042, 0.01600647, -0.013153076, 0.039489746, 0.012397766, 0.018692017, 0.01663208, 0.040283203, -0.034454346, 0.018508911, -0.05609131, -0.08178711, 0.020721436, 0.005115509, -0.046447754, -0.020263672, -0.042114258, -0.036499023, -0.0036525726, 0.028717041, 0.054534912, 0.035125732, -0.016677856, 0.04284668, -0.031463623, 0.018859863, -0.026794434, -0.036071777, -0.028503418, -0.010536194, 0.03704834, 0.012588501, 0.04107666, 0.03289795, 0.0060272217, -0.007675171, -0.0037059784, -0.024978638, 0.005672455, 0.0049591064, -0.021881104, 0.006629944, 0.0026187897, -0.013031006, -0.0040397644, -0.016571045, 0.0009765625, -0.018173218, 0.010559082, -0.010223389, 0.025939941, 0.013832092, 0.008132935, -0.010139465, -0.033813477, -0.009147644, -0.026138306, -0.035827637, -0.0010356903, 0.05307007, 0.025161743, -0.046722412, 0.017745972, 0.002878189, -0.0075645447, 0.020111084, -0.019363403, 0.005191803, 0.0010576248, 0.00073862076, -0.03387451, -0.017608643, 0.041046143, -0.04345703, -0.010154724, -0.009811401, 0.0069732666, 0.0018815994, -0.07556152, -0.015640259, 0.0064315796, -0.09448242, 0.0008006096, -0.00598526, 0.0007915497, -0.031585693, -0.015365601, 0.0039138794, -0.014945984, -0.04534912, 0.017318726, -0.010650635, -0.08685303, -0.027908325, -0.08270264, -0.027557373, 0.10241699, 0.031585693, 0.03074646, 0.0703125, -0.023101807, -0.034423828, -0.009033203, 0.031463623, 0.057128906, 0.04748535, 0.020111084, -0.0096588135, 0.04473877, -0.029220581, -0.017715454, 0.0541687, 0.027282715, -0.02583313, 0.0012292862, 0.020507812, 0.050689697, -0.008399963, 0.038146973, 0.003873825, -0.0063323975, -0.051483154, 0.017486572, -0.010375977, -0.01878357, 0.009757996, -0.02229309, -0.011161804, 0.007194519, 0.02418518, 0.057037354, -0.0014543533, 0.022720337, 0.017532349, -0.036071777, -0.021057129, 0.013542175, 0.046203613, -0.013198853, 0.0051231384, 0.03466797, -0.00674057, 0.033447266, 0.027664185, -0.025360107, -0.0093688965, 0.015571594, -0.03942871, -0.011581421, -0.0552063, -0.048583984, -0.010070801, 0.0057296753, -0.021392822, 0.027786255, 0.044921875, -0.0060272217, -0.0395813, 0.006290436, 0.058776855, -0.016921997, 0.0046577454, -0.0847168, -0.021102905, -0.015182495, -0.07342529, -0.048706055, -0.05050659, 0.00774765, -0.0135650635, 0.017303467, -0.0031204224, 0.021453857, 0.020446777, 0.03451538, 0.039001465, -0.032958984, -0.048583984, 0.034423828, -0.033050537, -0.062469482, 0.061065674, -0.045013428, -0.00062799454, -0.029556274, 0.05581665, -0.017227173, -0.014411926, -0.031097412, 0.038879395, -0.033996582, 0.061065674, -0.011077881, 0.02885437, 0.033233643, 0.0072288513, 0.008583069, 0.012512207, -0.037628174, 0.020690918, -0.0028839111, 0.046569824, -0.007911682, -0.0030612946, 0.013160706, 0.032562256, 0.0044937134, 0.006931305, 0.0079956055, 0.012062073, 0.011817932, -0.009101868, 0.032287598, -0.029052734, -0.025100708, 0.003501892, -0.0024738312, 0.038330078, -0.037384033, 0.017868042, -0.008155823, 0.03741455, 0.038269043, -0.003648758, 0.026321411, 0.013839722, 0.010467529, -0.049804688, -0.04333496, -0.00030755997, 0.042877197, -0.044647217, -0.005290985, -0.021209717, -0.01084137, 0.021347046, 0.051696777, 0.035247803, -0.02357483, 0.014953613, -0.014770508, -0.016448975, -0.0023212433, -0.07122803, -0.005153656, -0.013832092, 0.017669678, -0.002035141, 0.04574585, -0.07470703, 0.025680542, -0.030761719, -0.024353027, 0.057037354, -0.06536865, 0.011383057, 0.061798096, 0.0051879883, 0.02519226, -0.008476257, 0.020523071, 0.022872925, 0.0635376, 0.00548172, 0.027511597, 0.03152466, 0.00016915798, 0.022979736, 0.0014381409, 0.012466431, 0.0052757263, 0.03768921, 0.005683899, 0.02796936, -0.056274414, 0.017608643, 0.01209259, -0.024475098, 0.016693115, -0.037628174, 0.013450623, 0.038208008, 0.011940002, 0.03982544, -0.029937744, -0.02684021, -0.03579712, 0.012863159, -0.06567383, 0.025680542, 0.02180481, -0.04135132, -0.0021705627, 0.014793396, -0.045898438, -0.003665924, 0.040771484, -0.0038433075, 0.003288269, 0.027114868, 0.014976501, -0.0357666, 0.003967285, 0.014984131, 0.019882202, 0.027633667, 0.017654419, -0.02659607, -0.0070152283, -0.00070524216, -0.06365967, -0.023986816, 0.020080566, 0.009902954, -0.0038661957, -0.015670776, 0.010612488, -0.0040740967, -0.023025513, 0.024536133, 0.018295288, -0.0390625, 0.041046143, -0.01499176, -0.021575928, 0.00605011, -0.0118637085, -0.0038852692, -0.003118515, -0.005065918, -0.035827637, 0.007347107, 0.011108398, 0.029083252, -0.039642334, -0.07006836, 0.009780884, 0.030212402, 0.00793457, 0.0069618225, 0.046661377, 0.028060913, 0.026184082, -0.0035552979, 0.02017212, 0.032958984, -0.054016113, -0.0069618225, -0.00793457, -0.0035209656, -0.020050049, 0.0619812, -0.010009766, -0.0021133423, -0.032348633, -0.083618164, -0.029449463, 0.018569946, 0.040802002, 0.030029297, 0.021011353, -0.029281616, 0.04083252, -0.0154800415, -0.016952515, -0.035858154, 0.015274048, 0.010772705, -0.0140686035, 0.0075416565, 0.013664246, 0.022735596, -0.032104492, 0.037902832, 0.012565613, -0.043395996, 0.024642944, -0.06323242, 0.0027446747, -0.009155273, -0.041015625, 0.04171753, -0.02507019, -0.00063943863, 0.05380249, -0.010643005, 0.04937744, 0.020050049, 0.032714844, 0.04458618, -0.0005335808, 0.0010356903, 0.019683838, -0.000018239021, -0.039764404, -0.004131317, -0.026855469, -0.031707764, -0.05718994, -0.021865845, -0.06530762, 0.010414124, 0.012535095, 0.017669678, 0.0047454834, 0.0071029663, 0.017425537, -0.00032114983, 0.032928467, -0.030776978, 0.05014038, -0.030212402, -0.008049011, 0.013954163, -0.037078857, 0.01965332, 0.047729492, -0.014122009, -0.0077285767, -0.026428223, -0.020645142, 0.022872925, -0.005695343, 0.00932312, -0.02746582, -0.016281128, -0.050079346, -0.007633209, -0.016296387, 0.021606445, 0.056732178, 0.006866455, -0.01852417, 0.0066490173, 0.009788513, -0.02078247, -0.053894043, 0.023956299, 0.03515625, -0.10095215, 0.036224365, -0.0031776428, -0.013313293, -0.0154800415, 0.020355225, 0.022232056, -0.048553467, -0.04321289, 0.0079422, 0.045288086, 0.011627197, 0.006248474, -0.047729492, 0.0029506683, 0.0317688, 0.019729614, -0.021072388, 0.0022659302, 0.028625488, 0.028839111, 0.0015182495, -0.021057129, 0.015205383, -0.0052108765, 0.030319214, 0.035583496, -0.020019531, 0.03262329, -0.031799316, -0.047821045, -0.0026874542, -0.005672455, -0.05822754, -0.0357666, 0.02935791, 0.048583984, 0.053466797, 0.08331299, 0.021102905, 0.012016296, 0.0034122467, -0.040161133, 0.03765869, 0.038909912, -0.028366089, 0.016479492, -0.040863037, -0.049804688, 0.016983032, -0.05831909, 0.041900635, -0.056121826, 0.00248909, -0.022979736, 0.031707764, 0.003107071, -0.044647217, -0.041656494, -0.02255249, -0.036376953, 0.018173218, 0.04949951, -0.030639648, -0.01852417, 0.001250267, -0.005203247, -0.0129776, 0.000330925, 0.022140503, -0.015396118, -0.087768555, 0.009483337, -0.03137207, 0.055358887, -0.047454834, -0.0033226013, -0.01751709, 0.0011367798, 0.000746727, -0.0385437, -0.01701355, -0.018478394, -0.018295288, -0.054016113, 0.023956299, 0.02432251, -0.013015747, -0.0015850067, -0.035980225, -0.0039863586, -0.03677368, 0.0019416809, 0.03817749, -0.034179688, -0.03024292, -0.022201538, -0.026046753, 0.02557373, 0.00087213516, -0.0038909912, -0.011924744, 0.027786255, -0.04156494, -0.0137786865, 0.024337769, 0.0625, -0.008766174, -0.0066490173, -0.01586914, 0.036468506, 0.04888916, -0.06616211, -0.073913574, -0.0067825317, -0.019348145, -0.0054473877, 0.046203613, 0.035247803, 0.017074585, -0.0055236816, -0.018478394, -0.004627228, -0.028869629, -0.017166138, -0.015945435, 0.043640137, 0.04763794, -0.006641388, 0.0069503784, 0.026275635, -0.023757935, 0.0045814514, 0.0040397644, 0.0013570786, 0.0009160042, -0.014450073, 0.012557983, -0.02381897, -0.019882202, -0.034851074, 0.013923645, -0.013893127, -0.013290405, -0.01096344, 0.022247314, -0.046203613, 0.014511108, -0.042877197, -0.058898926, 0.047302246, 0.050811768, -0.010467529, 0.027832031, -0.0079193115, 0.0073661804, -0.010955811, -0.00090932846, 0.0073165894, 0.03503418, -0.01033783, -0.0074539185, 0.037139893, -0.06591797, -0.02911377, -0.04498291, -0.027450562, 0.019454956, -0.009475708, 0.010314941, 0.013244629, -0.016647339, -0.010108948, 0.005718231, -0.00945282, -0.015159607, -0.040008545, -0.06640625, 0.028274536, -0.018066406 ], "summary": [ -0.018447876, -0.027511597, -0.031585693, -0.051086426, -0.05328369, 0.010055542, -0.08392334, 0.020324707, 0.0054397583, 0.015052795, -0.07080078, -0.0021076202, 0.0052948, -0.0096206665, 0.008270264, -0.04598999, -0.0033092499, 0.0178833, -0.02255249, -0.04324341, 0.022277832, -0.046722412, -0.0552063, 0.007701874, 0.021591187, -0.021530151, -0.033447266, -0.006576538, 0.0154953, 0.0284729, 0.012023926, -0.018539429, 0.012184143, 0.013763428, -0.01687622, 0.0078125, -0.025375366, 0.021316528, 0.018325806, 0.013809204, 0.03387451, -0.018554688, 0.06652832, 0.00095653534, -0.004760742, 0.05279541, -0.016815186, -0.029968262, 0.0011072159, -0.014862061, 0.003238678, -0.021606445, 0.016860962, -0.0019168854, -0.042877197, -0.028839111, -0.054901123, 0.051727295, -0.018600464, 0.08117676, 0.0335083, 0.052246094, -0.02432251, -0.027420044, 0.012969971, 0.00409317, -0.02557373, 0.005882263, 0.047088623, 0.030822754, -0.002111435, -0.017074585, -0.0061035156, -0.048095703, -0.009552002, 0.038848877, 0.0072784424, 0.0021781921, 0.0015554428, -0.025802612, 0.058807373, 0.03475952, 0.053894043, -0.06982422, 0.046539307, -0.07183838, 0.00058698654, 0.00025892258, 0.018997192, -0.03765869, 0.0028743744, -0.0038204193, -0.008308411, 0.043640137, 0.012046814, -0.058166504, 0.027648926, 0.000011086464, -0.005001068, -0.0058555603, 0.038879395, -0.042510986, 0.043151855, -0.013618469, 0.0009660721, 0.033325195, -0.026824951, -0.04562378, 0.021987915, 0.015472412, -0.008811951, 0.009757996, 0.0029258728, -0.046569824, 0.0115356445, 0.021392822, -0.009773254, 0.06048584, 0.016036987, 0.042755127, -0.034698486, 0.0021343231, -0.04031372, 0.01914978, 0.019989014, 0.013748169, 0.008964539, 0.024002075, -0.07775879, 0.017868042, 0.013320923, 0.026931763, -0.026626587, 0.0069389343, -0.05810547, -0.0018100739, 0.029937744, 0.018081665, -0.0053901672, -0.034332275, 0.012496948, 0.0073051453, -0.0028514862, -0.007446289, 0.014633179, 0.028579712, 0.023162842, -0.0032176971, -0.02796936, -0.027374268, 0.03060913, -0.025970459, 0.016113281, -0.030715942, 0.0072021484, -0.07611084, -0.06567383, -0.002632141, 0.06359863, 0.0062713623, 0.013122559, -0.010292053, -0.017059326, 0.0015382767, -0.046661377, 0.006023407, 0.006324768, -0.001627922, 0.010070801, -0.020629883, -0.002960205, 0.021377563, 0.009002686, -0.014801025, -0.008666992, -0.00869751, 0.06124878, 0.037719727, 0.003238678, -0.0104522705, -0.0017566681, -0.043273926, 0.07904053, -0.04458618, -0.004600525, -0.03475952, -0.009399414, 0.015396118, 0.037902832, 0.023895264, -0.019332886, -0.056152344, 0.011634827, 0.0020542145, -0.018218994, -0.04067993, -0.0027694702, 0.007610321, -0.02355957, -0.0065460205, 0.029785156, 0.022338867, -0.023208618, -0.04510498, -0.061828613, -0.012634277, -0.00077342987, 0.029846191, 0.022827148, 0.009239197, 0.012786865, -0.0016431808, -0.01600647, -0.015426636, -0.04650879, -0.038269043, 0.006778717, 0.012954712, 0.0056114197, -0.014663696, 0.01335907, -0.02659607, 0.0017328262, 0.039367676, -0.028671265, -0.019592285, -0.014457703, 0.01322937, -0.008331299, -0.010055542, 0.050567627, -0.016448975, 0.024856567, 0.0259552, -0.011932373, -0.01625061, -0.00026369095, -0.066711426, 0.022598267, 0.040740967, 0.020004272, 0.0115737915, -0.022628784, 0.031280518, -0.00983429, -0.018249512, 0.012840271, 0.0030670166, 0.010688782, 0.044189453, 0.004299164, -0.025283813, 0.013725281, -0.057250977, -0.01725769, 0.03692627, -0.011688232, -0.029891968, 0.005874634, -0.026519775, 0.024169922, -0.061431885, -0.054748535, 0.0040283203, 0.009338379, -0.062042236, -0.013900757, -0.04071045, 0.0025997162, -0.0362854, 0.022338867, -0.056243896, 0.022140503, -0.05126953, -0.05407715, -0.00083589554, 0.003194809, 0.023071289, 0.029571533, -0.04156494, -0.007347107, 0.0033817291, -0.021987915, -0.005718231, -0.0023117065, -0.034301758, 0.03289795, 0.036315918, 0.022750854, 0.032714844, 0.027175903, 0.061279297, 0.022338867, 0.013092041, 0.056121826, 0.0033130646, 0.068359375, -0.0131073, 0.025985718, -0.006454468, 0.010314941, 0.038513184, 0.0010147095, -0.008598328, 0.029556274, -0.017623901, -0.00080776215, 0.045440674, 0.040252686, 0.0090789795, -0.047821045, 0.0152282715, 0.02520752, 0.06112671, -0.041503906, -0.0390625, -0.004917145, 0.034851074, 0.032989502, 0.08081055, 0.12634277, -0.0064086914, 0.015609741, -0.0003106594, -0.0015602112, -0.053344727, 0.019104004, -0.038330078, 0.047332764, -0.008255005, 0.0058021545, -0.0008049011, -0.037628174, -0.011245728, 0.014305115, -0.010681152, 0.0061149597, 0.015289307, 0.0038166046, 0.027786255, 0.010665894, -0.017532349, -0.01725769, -0.043548584, -0.008430481, -0.026428223, 0.0023956299, -0.01878357, 0.010543823, 0.05001831, -0.017532349, -0.00258255, -0.002363205, 0.042663574, 0.034820557, -0.017242432, -0.014808655, 0.027893066, -0.006931305, -0.027450562, 0.05831909, 0.06222534, 0.05038452, -0.0758667, -0.0680542, -0.05517578, 0.01675415, -0.031555176, -0.001074791, -0.011299133, -0.002002716, 0.013191223, -0.045959473, -0.016189575, -0.0031108856, 0.014434814, 0.09576416, 0.005382538, -0.03768921, 0.046905518, 0.0063323975, 0.056152344, -0.02670288, 0.040405273, 0.047576904, 0.011238098, 0.0064849854, 0.021011353, 0.014122009, -0.0023326874, -0.013412476, 0.0048065186, -0.024337769, -0.011077881, 0.011184692, 0.027664185, -0.040100098, -0.03869629, -0.038513184, 0.0058288574, 0.062683105, 0.00049591064, 0.010017395, 0.030670166, -0.02079773, 0.04751587, 0.026428223, 0.0071411133, 0.04498291, -0.08105469, 0.028808594, -0.07141113, 0.04284668, -0.10723877, 0.0035362244, -0.037231445, -0.019363403, 0.014701843, -0.009803772, -0.009590149, -0.01940918, 0.016220093, -0.014434814, 0.00088119507, 0.029129028, 0.038635254, 0.0082092285, -0.009239197, -0.0039711, 0.00548172, 0.024337769, -0.020935059, -0.033294678, -0.0033817291, -0.015625, 0.05255127, 0.017700195, 0.00091362, 0.045074463, -0.043701172, -0.01940918, -0.009773254, -0.0541687, -0.022659302, -0.0075263977, -0.04095459, 0.0059509277, -0.046569824, 0.03656006, 0.03475952, -0.007881165, -0.015449524, 0.012786865, 0.020751953, -0.037078857, 0.04522705, -0.016464233, 0.01890564, 0.033843994, -0.034454346, -0.015304565, -0.010513306, -0.019363403, -0.027160645, 0.02835083, 0.0592041, -0.11138916, 0.054779053, 0.004108429, -0.04321289, 0.05392456, -0.013641357, 0.0068130493, -0.015777588, -0.012557983, -0.06628418, 0.022613525, 0.027130127, 0.020095825, -0.04638672, -0.0725708, 0.037200928, -0.070739746, -0.04498291, -0.029800415, 0.020767212, -0.024108887, -0.02720642, -0.008422852, 0.027832031, -0.01285553, -0.010444641, 0.03152466, -0.027282715, -0.03387451, 0.03086853, -0.018310547, 0.0054130554, -0.015914917, -0.070373535, 0.023651123, 0.0051231384, 0.023101807, 0.05001831, 0.017562866, -0.012374878, -0.0017795563, 0.025421143, 0.012435913, -0.0005259514, 0.050445557, 0.0066223145, 0.0059928894, 0.012992859, -0.013000488, -0.013793945, 0.04711914, -0.037902832, 0.019607544, 0.016281128, 0.028320312, 0.057647705, 0.004386902, 0.0085372925, -0.024658203, 0.005897522, -0.020843506, 0.032409668, -0.014480591, -0.015159607, 0.022827148, -0.0031490326, -0.045166016, -0.013923645, 0.0519104, 0.020889282, -0.033294678, 0.026947021, -0.0038833618, -0.044311523, -0.039367676, -0.015342712, 0.018127441, -0.004146576, -0.012748718, 0.014221191, -0.007858276, 0.049438477, 0.0017681122, 0.0109939575, -0.0037269592, 0.015541077, -0.04800415, -0.024612427, -0.0021781921, -0.013214111, -0.030303955, 0.0209198, 0.0132369995, -0.014671326, 0.036224365, -0.009742737, -0.01625061, -0.0062332153, 0.05065918, 0.009346008, -0.036712646, -0.09692383, -0.048828125, -0.010269165, -0.041412354, -0.048339844, -0.072021484, -0.031585693, -0.05621338, 0.009605408, -0.015434265, 0.021591187, -0.015899658, -0.0064315796, 0.01083374, 0.0022239685, -0.012016296, -0.022705078, -0.050842285, -0.025100708, 0.056365967, -0.03567505, -0.018005371, -0.0038452148, 0.046875, -0.00982666, -0.026641846, -0.033050537, 0.00440979, 0.012168884, 0.03665161, -0.004486084, 0.008125305, 0.019760132, 0.011985779, -0.015068054, -0.004802704, -0.013626099, 0.036743164, -0.022201538, 0.005882263, 0.033416748, -0.0015649796, 0.014816284, -0.0022830963, -0.0012044907, -0.011222839, -0.0063667297, 0.0010271072, 0.010734558, -0.022918701, 0.024017334, 0.024490356, 0.0018510818, 0.029815674, -0.014320374, 0.016220093, 0.015052795, -0.016448975, -0.024719238, 0.04446411, 0.04486084, -0.010864258, 0.009483337, 0.04095459, -0.005012512, -0.028778076, -0.026229858, 0.003479004, 0.020874023, -0.020248413, -0.028518677, -0.021118164, -0.0070724487, 0.051696777, -0.010040283, -0.0017204285, -0.015159607, -0.03881836, -0.003583908, 0.00484848, 0.001619339, -0.03326416, -0.04626465, -0.007205963, 0.021392822, 0.048828125, 0.022201538, -0.019943237, 0.02357483, -0.024887085, -0.028945923, -0.0073547363, -0.06188965, -0.05670166, -0.041870117, -0.016784668, -0.0009484291, 0.061767578, -0.02218628, -0.011077881, 0.025848389, -0.017807007, -0.0124053955, 0.014541626, -0.07183838, -0.0037193298, -0.037597656, 0.010276794, 0.05532837, 0.04257202, 0.029403687, 0.06414795, -0.061828613, -0.0020217896, -0.018707275, 0.02168274, -0.030090332, -0.007648468, 0.02104187, 0.019180298, -0.0077705383, 0.022247314, 0.04257202, -0.052520752, -0.028884888, 0.030212402, -0.04586792, -0.027893066, 0.008407593, -0.017150879, 0.034301758, 0.0029640198, -0.06616211, 0.01663208, 0.040802002, -0.050201416, 0.0067367554, 0.00881958, -0.022247314, -0.01499176, -0.015075684, 0.034423828, 0.016540527, -0.013633728, 0.0052757263, -0.03579712, 0.00856781, 0.0023422241, -0.033233643, -0.043121338, 0.021392822, 0.015014648, -0.006828308, 0.0019187927, 0.033935547, -0.0019054413, -0.04788208, 0.020187378, -0.014579773, -0.021072388, 0.033843994, -0.030807495, -0.045043945, 0.031311035, -0.026885986, -0.015960693, 0.011444092, -0.004085541, -0.047576904, 0.018585205, 0.008628845, 0.029541016, -0.03842163, -0.051757812, 0.0070610046, 0.03640747, -0.014984131, -0.0038528442, 0.07116699, 0.021011353, 0.0034866333, 0.01939392, 0.015930176, 0.01360321, -0.015792847, -0.038909912, 0.00007498264, 0.021118164, 0.0050086975, 0.02835083, -0.025939941, -0.024337769, -0.0022735596, -0.031951904, 0.00017738342, 0.0012083054, 0.02230835, 0.008155823, 0.0395813, 0.010116577, 0.038482666, 0.02394104, -0.02406311, -0.0335083, -0.0028762817, -0.025619507, -0.052856445, 0.07702637, 0.012786865, 0.0023269653, -0.041046143, -0.0010728836, 0.020751953, -0.008300781, -0.007286072, -0.011817932, 0.0037250519, -0.00491333, -0.018859863, 0.02734375, 0.012771606, -0.030059814, 0.015235901, 0.019165039, 0.050231934, 0.011138916, -0.009185791, -0.0048675537, -0.009147644, -0.0057754517, 0.0077323914, -0.00818634, -0.024032593, 0.030639648, 0.0053215027, -0.041137695, -0.05859375, -0.041137695, -0.048461914, 0.054107666, -0.027877808, 0.023513794, 0.018539429, 0.0068473816, 0.0065994263, 0.031951904, -0.041992188, 0.033721924, 0.017349243, -0.012481689, -0.019546509, 0.02961731, -0.028961182, 0.013885498, 0.05340576, -0.012199402, 0.008224487, -0.0052604675, -0.020019531, 0.034210205, -0.017150879, -0.019134521, -0.08459473, 0.0010757446, -0.070251465, 0.02418518, 0.03451538, 0.05279541, -0.010765076, -0.035247803, 0.03378296, -0.0019741058, -0.020217896, 0.018463135, -0.033721924, 0.06201172, 0.016220093, -0.04449463, 0.002363205, 0.01826477, -0.025177002, 0.027069092, 0.045166016, 0.002603531, -0.033966064, 0.002752304, -0.01802063, 0.003501892, 0.01461792, 0.0012712479, -0.024520874, -0.020874023, 0.008270264, 0.013801575, 0.0058135986, 0.020477295, -0.01739502, 0.0023841858, 0.0018968582, -0.006542206, 0.02116394, -0.0071487427, 0.019378662, 0.032165527, 0.005886078, 0.05633545, -0.035583496, -0.031158447, 0.0038375854, 0.02330017, -0.0892334, -0.012260437, 0.021209717, 0.04360962, 0.044433594, 0.046783447, -0.043823242, 0.007511139, 0.052520752, 0.008399963, -0.0019779205, 0.013221741, 0.009529114, 0.0036716461, -0.046722412, -0.005508423, -0.007980347, -0.016296387, 0.009887695, -0.051208496, 0.029373169, -0.044311523, 0.02456665, -0.07977295, -0.024291992, 0.010681152, -0.022201538, -0.029342651, 0.018035889, 0.031341553, -0.054779053, -0.023330688, -0.017974854, -0.0003812313, -0.013519287, 0.0044059753, 0.06768799, -0.013290405, -0.07067871, 0.00076913834, 0.01802063, 0.049804688, -0.03366089, -0.023468018, 0.04586792, 0.0034980774, -0.003610611, -0.09136963, -0.040008545, -0.031951904, 0.06768799, -0.008972168, -0.0049819946, 0.0134887695, -0.0053100586, -0.03656006, -0.0017747879, 0.009254456, -0.04296875, 0.049346924, 0.022399902, -0.037841797, -0.034484863, 0.0006079674, 0.036956787, 0.04840088, -0.012664795, -0.017791748, 0.03149414, -0.0043907166, -0.018997192, 0.016479492, 0.023742676, 0.03527832, -0.025238037, 0.009292603, -0.033203125, 0.006134033, 0.034820557, -0.038635254, -0.08605957, -0.01612854, -0.006416321, -0.011642456, -0.009750366, -0.0049209595, 0.004173279, 0.05166626, 0.029342651, 0.009338379, -0.028030396, 0.064086914, 0.027923584, 0.01852417, 0.027832031, -0.026626587, 0.04055786, -0.006374359, -0.03564453, 0.006793976, -0.0070533752, 0.007835388, -0.008384705, -0.013580322, 0.00090408325, -0.036956787, -0.014404297, -0.0017595291, 0.0032424927, -0.022338867, -0.056549072, -0.02079773, 0.02243042, -0.048858643, -0.0713501, -0.056671143, 0.02960205, -0.0066871643, -0.018356323, -0.0033111572, -0.03237915, 0.028717041, 0.0602417, 0.019943237, 0.0064735413, -0.0015459061, 0.042999268, -0.0041046143, -0.002527237, -0.0021438599, -0.0791626, 0.02822876, -0.061920166, -0.024551392, 0.029556274, -0.00049972534, -0.012588501, 0.012435913, -0.019058228, 0.01878357, 0.013923645, 0.009376526, -0.021820068, 0.024993896, -0.027999878, 0.011917114, 0.01474762 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07397v1
An LLM-free Multi-dimensional Benchmark for MLLMs Hallucination Evaluation
Junyang Wang, Yuhang Wang, Guohai Xu, Jing Zhang, Yukai Gu, Haitao Jia, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Jitao Sang
cs.CL, cs.CV
Despite making significant progress in multi-modal tasks, current Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs) encounter the significant challenge of hallucination, which may lead to harmful consequences. Therefore, evaluating MLLMs' hallucinations is becoming increasingly important in model improvement and practical application deployment. Previous works are limited in high evaluation costs (e.g., relying on humans or advanced LLMs) and insufficient evaluation dimensions (e.g., types of hallucination and task). In this paper, we propose an LLM-free multi-dimensional benchmark AMBER, which can be used to evaluate both generative task and discriminative task including object existence, object attribute and object relation hallucination. Based on AMBER, we design a low-cost and efficient evaluation pipeline. Additionally, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation and detailed analysis of mainstream MLLMs including GPT-4V(ision), and also give guideline suggestions for mitigating hallucinations. The data and code of AMBER are available at https://github.com/junyangwang0410/AMBER.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07397v1
2023-11-13T15:25:42
2023-11-13T15:25:42
{ "title": [ -0.0045928955, -0.0075912476, -0.01574707, -0.04248047, -0.03829956, 0.00095033646, -0.021133423, -0.010971069, -0.0068893433, 0.045166016, 0.02268982, 0.031066895, 0.007789612, -0.021408081, -0.01751709, 0.022415161, -0.009674072, 0.028182983, -0.008956909, -0.037872314, -0.035461426, -0.05895996, 0.0059776306, 0.017089844, 0.0012607574, -0.022354126, -0.044677734, -0.012176514, -0.01335144, -0.013618469, -0.0017976761, 0.013755798, 0.04147339, -0.026565552, 0.031051636, 0.026260376, -0.05404663, 0.012359619, 0.011749268, -0.009666443, 0.022384644, -0.00012516975, 0.004463196, -0.0031833649, -0.04748535, 0.032714844, -0.047576904, -0.0028743744, -0.00085401535, -0.024475098, 0.010055542, 0.03326416, 0.009338379, 0.02748108, -0.0077209473, -0.012084961, -0.036956787, -0.0020256042, 0.02796936, 0.059448242, 0.011291504, -0.016799927, 0.0049591064, -0.05340576, 0.011650085, -0.00274086, -0.032928467, 0.035064697, 0.118652344, 0.05505371, -0.06903076, 0.013023376, 0.0115737915, -0.01777649, -0.019180298, 0.03274536, 0.016342163, 0.009170532, 0.007659912, -0.025039673, -0.008178711, -0.021102905, 0.011329651, 0.009460449, -0.01158905, 0.0036964417, -0.01600647, -0.01360321, -0.032562256, -0.048980713, -0.01940918, -0.0065307617, -0.003540039, -0.011260986, -0.041503906, -0.043121338, -0.014884949, 0.015487671, 0.002216339, -0.021514893, 0.026733398, -0.017456055, -0.02633667, -0.011917114, 0.01889038, 0.012664795, -0.0048065186, -0.0791626, -0.02532959, -0.0074043274, -0.046203613, 0.0038700104, 0.042785645, -0.029129028, 0.04437256, 0.0013685226, 0.0048294067, 0.050750732, 0.015396118, 0.020095825, -0.046447754, -0.052124023, 0.039031982, 0.057525635, 0.027328491, 0.04425049, -0.017044067, -0.0014467239, -0.04421997, 0.057037354, 0.010643005, 0.029312134, -0.078552246, -0.038726807, -0.052368164, -0.00037503242, 0.0012197495, 0.01626587, 0.014930725, -0.047851562, 0.018356323, -0.0039405823, 0.018966675, -0.005153656, 0.01727295, 0.07537842, 0.046142578, -0.047424316, -0.029418945, -0.07293701, -0.016799927, -0.026687622, 0.005718231, -0.006175995, -0.010421753, -0.022491455, -0.113586426, 0.019882202, 0.05706787, 0.024047852, 0.017089844, -0.018493652, -0.039855957, 0.031799316, 0.051879883, 0.019378662, 0.007007599, 0.03994751, 0.026306152, 0.06451416, -0.02545166, 0.010871887, 0.048187256, 0.0022640228, -0.019973755, 0.017700195, 0.007232666, 0.020736694, 0.027862549, -0.05203247, 0.020751953, -0.008094788, 0.020019531, 0.0413208, -0.08746338, 0.003917694, -0.0051002502, 0.046569824, 0.049835205, 0.002609253, 0.033996582, -0.015563965, -0.018447876, -0.02633667, -0.03262329, -0.042388916, 0.01977539, 0.012901306, -0.013061523, 0.027236938, -0.010017395, -0.006942749, -0.037872314, 0.0061798096, -0.0059051514, -0.04486084, 0.009338379, -0.010002136, 0.013893127, 0.023391724, 0.0256958, 0.0046691895, -0.058776855, 0.0670166, -0.016952515, -0.05731201, -0.007873535, -0.0044822693, 0.0051651, -0.01828003, 0.03225708, -0.0039367676, 0.025344849, 0.028030396, -0.009284973, 0.039367676, 0.0006155968, -0.0064315796, 0.067993164, 0.030853271, 0.08178711, -0.050476074, -0.019180298, -0.033325195, -0.021652222, -0.004600525, -0.029418945, -0.044036865, 0.0010480881, 0.025268555, 0.00566864, 0.008178711, -0.0076446533, 0.032592773, 0.0154953, -0.0017957687, 0.029159546, 0.024536133, 0.0014801025, -0.01751709, 0.033477783, 0.020507812, 0.05206299, 0.059020996, -0.011039734, 0.054473877, 0.024780273, 0.025985718, 0.045684814, -0.0032157898, -0.008911133, 0.049743652, -0.004070282, 0.019515991, -0.05517578, 0.005378723, -0.020767212, 0.0014095306, -0.0043754578, 0.017364502, 0.028213501, -0.023513794, 0.021728516, -0.039916992, -0.06088257, -0.0038108826, -0.005935669, 0.045043945, -0.013648987, -0.046966553, -0.027236938, -0.012504578, -0.004463196, -0.009361267, 0.0049209595, 0.0021190643, 0.019165039, 0.0044174194, -0.019989014, 0.025878906, 0.05316162, 0.016433716, 0.03302002, -0.026489258, 0.012512207, 0.007659912, 0.017486572, 0.02645874, -0.005836487, 0.018218994, -0.05596924, 0.02973938, 0.0068969727, 0.0006098747, 0.004585266, 0.02998352, 0.016098022, 0.020233154, -0.00932312, -0.05908203, 0.011909485, -0.0009536743, 0.0019950867, -0.05041504, -0.034362793, -0.04058838, -0.01713562, -0.037963867, -0.04446411, -0.016662598, 0.07104492, 0.0054740906, -0.01309967, -0.017349243, 0.02204895, -0.04925537, -0.03466797, -0.026977539, -0.0317688, -0.012161255, 0.040496826, -0.013191223, -0.046539307, -0.037322998, 0.010269165, -0.013916016, -0.006767273, 0.034606934, -0.016983032, -0.0004181862, -0.017990112, -0.012718201, 0.014205933, -0.047576904, -0.04360962, 0.04849243, -0.008140564, 0.024841309, -0.04324341, 0.01914978, -0.0008864403, -0.03466797, -0.0309906, 0.0340271, 0.022247314, -0.022644043, -0.0077590942, 0.056640625, 0.012413025, -0.006149292, 0.031677246, 0.012992859, -0.0011262894, -0.05307007, -0.0051193237, -0.06341553, 0.012626648, -0.0647583, -0.007221222, 0.05444336, -0.023376465, -0.010643005, -0.0054359436, -0.004283905, -0.017028809, -0.00066137314, 0.05065918, -0.02330017, -0.055419922, 0.0044670105, -0.00623703, 0.0053100586, -0.047943115, -0.0068244934, 0.12005615, -0.038513184, -0.03527832, 0.015617371, 0.04046631, 0.051452637, -0.037506104, -0.089904785, 0.011253357, -0.035186768, -0.0017242432, 0.014076233, -0.0032787323, 0.021606445, -0.026245117, 0.003293991, -0.060943604, -0.000047147274, 0.011268616, -0.044006348, -0.0037612915, -0.004234314, -0.03579712, -0.027816772, 0.02935791, 0.019470215, 0.0025577545, 0.00566864, -0.008544922, -0.026489258, -0.00957489, -0.027542114, -0.09777832, 0.0038375854, -0.026473999, 0.04550171, 0.00605011, -0.017288208, -0.026687622, 0.010803223, 0.007987976, 0.04940796, 0.010375977, 0.00299263, -0.0039405823, -0.018173218, 0.020980835, -0.023376465, -0.01876831, -0.044952393, -0.0491333, -0.07006836, -0.014076233, 0.027908325, 0.028152466, -0.00869751, 0.011238098, -0.033355713, 0.010665894, -0.0030078888, 0.0345459, -0.03692627, -0.016708374, 0.027557373, 0.003993988, 0.06866455, -0.037139893, -0.009094238, -0.021438599, 0.012069702, -0.04321289, 0.02268982, 0.0013198853, -0.0018320084, 0.017456055, -0.0026474, -0.008979797, 0.004634857, -0.040740967, -0.015571594, 0.039794922, 0.034729004, 0.016967773, -0.010726929, 0.015289307, -0.02027893, -0.0041656494, -0.03375244, 0.017562866, 0.031143188, -0.011299133, 0.014289856, -0.029678345, 0.023895264, -0.013549805, 0.010414124, -0.04159546, 0.036132812, -0.06161499, -0.08392334, -0.018081665, -0.00015199184, -0.047180176, -0.06072998, 0.00054073334, 0.015304565, -0.02406311, -0.024429321, 0.0054473877, 0.0017976761, -0.032836914, 0.020187378, -0.009460449, 0.00207901, -0.0052871704, -0.08782959, 0.012016296, 0.047607422, -0.031311035, 0.037719727, 0.017410278, -0.027069092, -0.051849365, -0.028411865, 0.0008292198, -0.005832672, -0.011657715, -0.011550903, 0.047790527, 0.00036287308, 0.0065231323, 0.01574707, 0.03842163, -0.057891846, 0.036224365, 0.030578613, 0.024490356, 0.016586304, -0.0024776459, 0.040649414, -0.0012149811, -0.014625549, -0.04345703, -0.011375427, -0.013145447, 0.0033359528, -0.017959595, -0.026184082, 0.024795532, 0.02330017, 0.050567627, 0.047698975, -0.023834229, 0.031463623, 0.011169434, -0.033081055, -0.040924072, -0.0051002502, 0.036315918, 0.008132935, -0.006477356, 0.050628662, 0.022857666, 0.09503174, 0.044830322, -0.023162842, 0.026626587, 0.03375244, -0.091308594, -0.01625061, -0.013069153, -0.04547119, -0.019836426, -0.010299683, -0.030593872, 0.032287598, 0.074279785, -0.0015459061, -0.004043579, -0.04058838, 0.08862305, -0.01939392, 0.009750366, -0.0770874, -0.001332283, -0.019989014, -0.045532227, -0.027053833, 0.053344727, 0.01398468, 0.023147583, -0.03842163, 0.0014953613, 0.006706238, 0.035949707, 0.020065308, 0.024734497, -0.004184723, -0.006919861, -0.009033203, -0.0045928955, -0.03604126, 0.032287598, -0.0051574707, -0.018188477, -0.012123108, 0.03074646, -0.024765015, 0.003692627, 0.017700195, -0.029953003, -0.008857727, 0.022018433, -0.028289795, 0.017578125, -0.0018072128, 0.024307251, 0.0052986145, -0.003232956, -0.0463562, 0.0033988953, -0.008544922, 0.039611816, 0.0011644363, 0.009788513, 0.050994873, -0.012031555, -0.013259888, 0.012229919, -0.008468628, 0.026382446, 0.035369873, 0.05645752, -0.035369873, -0.05368042, -0.014289856, 0.024230957, 0.018463135, 0.037017822, -0.006626129, 0.013381958, 0.06530762, 0.031951904, 0.06707764, -0.017089844, 0.0134887695, 0.024505615, -0.014205933, -0.061065674, -0.06149292, -0.0141067505, 0.055358887, -0.042297363, -0.027526855, 0.025177002, 0.02947998, 0.027191162, 0.030059814, 0.009902954, 0.009971619, -0.0042800903, 0.016204834, 0.021148682, -0.017700195, -0.061584473, 0.011810303, -0.001455307, 0.02973938, -0.04623413, -0.0013275146, -0.020599365, -0.010612488, -0.025115967, -0.019180298, 0.00008922815, -0.038024902, 0.008270264, 0.04647827, -0.013900757, 0.029922485, 0.0038547516, 0.009239197, 0.017868042, 0.051971436, 0.0005774498, -0.016159058, 0.025512695, 0.009613037, 0.051116943, -0.0069770813, 0.013458252, 0.00077199936, 0.016113281, -0.010856628, 0.035339355, -0.0362854, 0.010063171, -0.022399902, -0.004814148, -0.00087594986, -0.041778564, -0.007709503, -0.041870117, 0.012290955, 0.009887695, 0.042114258, -0.02571106, -0.0104904175, 0.0044174194, -0.01966858, 0.0035743713, 0.00983429, -0.07159424, -0.039367676, 0.022628784, 0.019805908, 0.03387451, -0.028717041, -0.026397705, -0.091918945, 0.000053703785, 0.0036773682, 0.011856079, 0.015914917, -0.0128479, -0.009735107, 0.0035419464, 0.036621094, -0.035186768, 0.0071105957, -0.026916504, -0.036376953, -0.012367249, 0.0032958984, 0.018615723, 0.019729614, -0.00642395, 0.012832642, 0.0060424805, -0.008514404, 0.020446777, 0.00548172, -0.04486084, 0.027420044, -0.024032593, -0.014556885, 0.012779236, 0.0069351196, 0.03250122, -0.019515991, -0.025787354, -0.024871826, 0.036071777, -0.02468872, -0.0018568039, 0.0071487427, -0.03262329, 0.015838623, 0.020980835, -0.0340271, -0.0211792, 0.029953003, 0.017532349, 0.017364502, -0.032928467, -0.008583069, 0.020980835, -0.029586792, -0.0390625, -0.009185791, -0.003004074, -0.017120361, 0.045684814, -0.015541077, -0.020080566, -0.007965088, -0.07324219, -0.011581421, 0.007385254, 0.036132812, 0.018081665, 0.00025105476, -0.06060791, 0.014915466, -0.030014038, -0.0211792, -0.037963867, -0.014579773, -0.032684326, -0.08337402, 0.10192871, 0.022583008, 0.0021572113, -0.052764893, 0.010955811, 0.018676758, 0.019454956, -0.001619339, -0.005771637, -0.0236969, -0.010856628, 0.01789856, -0.013381958, 0.01398468, -0.02482605, 0.0074653625, -0.027359009, 0.0546875, 0.02671814, 0.04852295, 0.0076789856, 0.0037841797, 0.013954163, 0.020858765, 0.03857422, -0.02835083, 0.0011138916, -0.0345459, 0.00030303, -0.02128601, -0.009750366, -0.07556152, 0.01979065, 0.016342163, 0.031280518, -0.06774902, 0.021377563, -0.035308838, 0.005241394, 0.03326416, -0.020339966, 0.07879639, 0.0104599, -0.014892578, 0.03326416, 0.046661377, -0.00983429, 0.02015686, -0.018722534, 0.03353882, -0.029129028, -0.002067566, 0.034454346, -0.019592285, -0.015899658, 0.03744507, 0.045288086, -0.012496948, 0.023880005, -0.011909485, 0.061553955, 0.053894043, -0.00060224533, 0.012672424, -0.013450623, -0.0063095093, 0.017730713, 0.0037460327, 0.012367249, 0.064453125, -0.08416748, 0.03152466, 0.0048599243, -0.032806396, 0.020812988, 0.05255127, 0.02456665, -0.030731201, -0.0069274902, 0.007511139, 0.024246216, 0.027297974, 0.026672363, -0.029815674, -0.0024719238, -0.014793396, 0.010139465, 0.03213501, -0.0006098747, -0.03652954, 0.012413025, 0.012397766, -0.049804688, 0.017501831, -0.01777649, 0.0066108704, 0.020355225, 0.06512451, 0.01638794, 0.03842163, -0.017318726, 0.018295288, 0.023498535, -0.0317688, 0.020736694, -0.066589355, 0.03314209, 0.041778564, 0.021881104, -0.03845215, -0.019317627, 0.049560547, -0.04928589, 0.01411438, -0.001958847, -0.014427185, 0.005821228, 0.016235352, -0.012008667, 0.045440674, 0.005706787, 0.041992188, -0.06567383, 0.010871887, -0.024795532, 0.020706177, -0.00592041, -0.01600647, -0.031677246, -0.02720642, -0.021148682, 0.013465881, 0.012817383, -0.05581665, -0.040496826, 0.008758545, 0.03643799, 0.006904602, -0.013877869, 0.014831543, -0.009841919, -0.07208252, 0.02619934, -0.0014944077, 0.05493164, -0.043792725, -0.0546875, -0.04345703, 0.024032593, 0.037902832, 0.053955078, -0.017623901, 0.05230713, -0.06036377, -0.022018433, 0.028686523, 0.030960083, -0.003583908, 0.008285522, -0.04196167, 0.03475952, -0.02998352, 0.013084412, 0.00026869774, -0.034606934, -0.004447937, -0.005218506, 0.0022354126, 0.016677856, 0.011802673, -0.008865356, 0.0045433044, -0.009521484, -0.0016403198, -0.031433105, 0.0072288513, 0.030807495, -0.012870789, -0.037902832, 0.0054512024, 0.0050964355, 0.010482788, -0.037994385, -0.03668213, 0.0035057068, 0.037139893, -0.027893066, 0.055664062, -0.0016326904, 0.008964539, 0.056365967, 0.053588867, 0.012626648, -0.029830933, -0.012786865, 0.023620605, 0.024856567, 0.027648926, 0.01737976, -0.022201538, 0.03050232, 0.0022525787, -0.0077285767, 0.005355835, 0.019363403, -0.00945282, 0.0074501038, 0.017791748, -0.039611816, -0.024871826, 0.018798828, 0.0015888214, 0.025100708, 0.017837524, 0.0021018982, -0.0039711, -0.0066947937, 0.04309082, 0.0027313232, 0.025268555, 0.034484863, 0.0067100525, 0.05090332, -0.0046043396, 0.03515625, 0.021469116, -0.013572693, -0.012069702, 0.013076782, -0.025650024, 0.03756714, -0.054595947, 0.0013380051, -0.060150146, -0.05307007, 0.0034561157, -0.032226562, 0.030258179, -0.0071372986, 0.025268555, 0.024871826, -0.01966858, 0.010261536, -0.007926941, 0.023727417, 0.0030288696, -0.03930664, -0.09106445, 0.0027713776, -0.012840271 ], "summary": [ -0.04156494, -0.009185791, -0.044921875, -0.024230957, -0.04119873, 0.013710022, -0.09338379, -0.00957489, 0.01071167, 0.038726807, -0.0037612915, 0.01259613, 0.028900146, -0.01826477, -0.005115509, -0.0078086853, -0.036712646, 0.039520264, -0.010192871, -0.04562378, 0.015670776, -0.070373535, -0.028182983, -0.009788513, 0.030319214, -0.059051514, -0.012023926, 0.013519287, 0.015426636, 0.0013952255, 0.015930176, 0.00009471178, 0.010482788, -0.0051193237, 0.018676758, 0.025009155, -0.07525635, 0.01777649, 0.014656067, -0.0066452026, 0.018692017, 0.016677856, 0.03768921, 0.006958008, -0.039794922, 0.026550293, -0.035369873, -0.023071289, 0.03062439, -0.04522705, 0.018356323, 0.03918457, 0.022033691, -0.021896362, -0.042938232, -0.00919342, -0.03970337, -0.010047913, 0.016342163, 0.10992432, 0.026565552, 0.0018825531, -0.029724121, -0.07867432, 0.02758789, 0.027496338, -0.028442383, 0.01058197, 0.0713501, 0.041656494, -0.0513916, -0.0048828125, 0.018569946, -0.049224854, -0.007713318, 0.04547119, -0.0046691895, -0.001584053, 0.018875122, -0.033691406, 0.0031204224, 0.02355957, -0.00680542, -0.0021915436, -0.007007599, -0.0115737915, -0.010444641, -0.012969971, -0.010986328, -0.032165527, -0.007270813, 0.009086609, -0.041931152, 0.012199402, 0.0146484375, -0.054748535, 0.0079574585, -0.025314331, 0.016693115, -0.01108551, 0.0491333, -0.045013428, 0.03945923, -0.015777588, 0.021453857, 0.026565552, -0.008018494, -0.03970337, 0.015510559, -0.0040283203, -0.032958984, 0.03427124, 0.015792847, -0.026611328, 0.00053596497, 0.009468079, -0.016311646, 0.054504395, 0.0038814545, 0.05947876, -0.031951904, -0.023666382, 0.009132385, 0.070129395, -0.0032863617, 0.04168701, 0.010467529, 0.000025570393, 0.0030727386, -0.0028381348, 0.006626129, 0.0524292, -0.0597229, -0.0418396, -0.058410645, 0.0146102905, -0.04119873, -0.0035095215, 0.0018320084, -0.025177002, 0.04147339, -0.011978149, 0.02748108, 0.038330078, 0.014976501, 0.05380249, 0.037017822, -0.0137786865, -0.0345459, -0.058044434, 0.006778717, -0.008666992, 0.025878906, -0.016098022, -0.005203247, -0.04421997, -0.059661865, 0.013458252, 0.03149414, 0.001657486, -0.022918701, -0.016723633, 0.012573242, 0.0034656525, -0.010131836, 0.0102005005, -0.0027427673, -0.011100769, 0.03036499, 0.037353516, -0.024917603, 0.027679443, 0.058776855, 0.020401001, -0.015075684, 0.010559082, -0.027618408, 0.042297363, 0.016174316, -0.031204224, 0.0032634735, -0.02947998, 0.05810547, 0.0023117065, -0.08099365, 0.016647339, -0.014411926, 0.061920166, 0.06567383, -0.006385803, 0.03793335, -0.04348755, -0.024368286, 0.015945435, -0.042816162, -0.023223877, -0.008560181, 0.036315918, -0.055236816, 0.010238647, 0.048797607, 0.0033187866, -0.020553589, -0.042266846, -0.09265137, -0.016036987, -0.013031006, 0.0078125, 0.014663696, 0.04058838, 0.027832031, 0.021636963, -0.064941406, 0.083496094, 0.011184692, -0.048675537, -0.028808594, -0.01008606, 0.003522873, -0.0068206787, 0.031585693, -0.0046691895, 0.024047852, 0.046691895, -0.014099121, 0.028411865, -0.0056152344, 0.038604736, 0.062561035, 0.03152466, 0.08520508, -0.062408447, -0.0016078949, 0.005252838, -0.013908386, -0.020645142, -0.011764526, -0.08880615, 0.028518677, 0.053710938, -0.0036773682, 0.024734497, -0.010101318, 0.06359863, -0.018554688, -0.0048599243, 0.028045654, 0.02468872, -0.014762878, 0.021377563, -0.020309448, 0.016555786, 0.028442383, 0.03050232, -0.0047302246, 0.038879395, 0.007583618, -0.042510986, 0.028869629, -0.0020637512, 0.028259277, 0.019302368, -0.039489746, 0.013923645, -0.054260254, -0.015449524, -0.040771484, -0.029174805, 0.012840271, -0.024307251, 0.022354126, -0.039001465, 0.011177063, -0.05255127, -0.051086426, 0.010192871, 0.0021877289, 0.030960083, -0.011482239, -0.040863037, -0.014678955, 0.0014410019, 0.0058059692, -0.02079773, 0.021224976, 0.020553589, 0.01576233, -0.029663086, -0.04156494, 0.052093506, 0.043548584, 0.038360596, 0.025375366, -0.020874023, -0.002450943, 0.023666382, 0.041381836, -0.006214142, 0.04147339, -0.02420044, -0.006214142, 0.050872803, -0.04916382, 0.022033691, 0.00034689903, 0.02166748, 0.016311646, 0.00712204, -0.0119018555, -0.03186035, -0.029815674, -0.01939392, 0.02532959, 0.025360107, -0.04296875, -0.04837036, -0.023040771, -0.0053710938, -0.08526611, -0.046691895, 0.093811035, 0.0028266907, 0.018737793, 0.0022792816, 0.014190674, -0.050354004, 0.02015686, -0.018600464, 0.021453857, 0.002670288, 0.008369446, -0.0029621124, -0.018753052, -0.04458618, 0.00011956692, -0.025024414, -0.0037231445, 0.037750244, -0.0138549805, 0.0012187958, -0.0020008087, -0.03955078, 0.0027103424, -0.013793945, -0.031982422, 0.032958984, 0.026489258, 0.011360168, 0.00856781, 0.02217102, -0.022491455, -0.02507019, -0.003168106, 0.03918457, 0.037506104, -0.04269409, -0.02078247, 0.04168701, -0.0011892319, -0.021759033, 0.035980225, 0.014122009, 0.0003619194, -0.05206299, -0.0184021, -0.03201294, 0.0102005005, -0.041778564, 0.03302002, 0.027618408, 0.044799805, 0.014251709, -0.06640625, -0.01499939, -0.010498047, -0.021530151, 0.058929443, -0.023529053, -0.04095459, 0.01876831, -0.019332886, 0.014076233, -0.016098022, 0.029342651, 0.11383057, -0.020095825, -0.006996155, 0.0061073303, 0.062805176, 0.027038574, -0.009391785, -0.066467285, -0.00010937452, -0.015274048, -0.010772705, -0.0015525818, -0.020370483, 0.0076141357, -0.034851074, -0.003522873, 0.0036792755, 0.02458191, 0.02418518, 0.010231018, -0.028579712, 0.05279541, -0.0206604, -0.0064201355, 0.03704834, -0.038208008, 0.03277588, -0.038024902, 0.01096344, -0.074523926, -0.03363037, -0.020080566, -0.033081055, 0.024856567, -0.052612305, 0.014724731, 0.022232056, 0.036346436, 0.002117157, 0.02003479, 0.018600464, 0.08404541, -0.039276123, -0.007659912, -0.012527466, -0.0071105957, 0.009391785, 0.0018806458, -0.008056641, 0.008728027, -0.038330078, 0.01058197, -0.00039458275, -0.025878906, 0.045318604, -0.06719971, 0.011161804, -0.033996582, -0.020965576, -0.03173828, 0.021728516, -0.0362854, -0.019897461, 0.010643005, -0.021377563, 0.08288574, -0.056243896, 0.017227173, -0.0309906, 0.030197144, -0.047668457, 0.0035324097, -0.030303955, 0.021270752, 0.032958984, -0.04776001, -0.031463623, -0.02029419, -0.016342163, -0.01134491, 0.08026123, 0.013893127, -0.02267456, 0.005695343, -0.010482788, 0.010299683, 0.032287598, -0.05404663, 0.012916565, 0.0071640015, 0.0059432983, -0.0093307495, -0.0020599365, 0.014831543, 0.0034294128, -0.008575439, -0.062561035, 0.040161133, -0.07397461, -0.060791016, -0.033843994, 0.009155273, -0.044281006, -0.08502197, -0.007511139, 0.046142578, 0.0020103455, 0.010696411, 0.03567505, 0.010307312, -0.008918762, 0.021209717, -0.024810791, 0.028335571, -0.0058898926, -0.06161499, 0.060272217, -0.0073890686, -0.019378662, 0.05328369, -0.008125305, 0.02923584, -0.00006699562, 0.01020813, 0.018966675, -0.03302002, 0.017990112, -0.029266357, -0.048583984, -0.018051147, -0.011108398, 0.028396606, 0.023986816, -0.056488037, 0.026779175, 0.019134521, 0.024459839, 0.047821045, 0.00623703, 0.015136719, -0.011856079, -0.0071868896, -0.028411865, 0.012306213, -0.010284424, -0.0034999847, 0.0043411255, -0.0035266876, -0.0065689087, 0.016098022, 0.027877808, 0.024230957, -0.023162842, 0.008918762, 0.017501831, -0.009750366, -0.027236938, -0.04119873, -0.0070762634, 0.024261475, -0.027328491, 0.052001953, -0.013053894, 0.043029785, 0.027755737, -0.027709961, 0.032043457, 0.036895752, -0.04699707, -0.024856567, 0.009796143, -0.047576904, -0.0026855469, -0.0052452087, -0.028427124, 0.020935059, 0.046569824, -0.005130768, 0.01360321, -0.03289795, 0.070129395, 0.0026302338, -0.02079773, -0.10614014, 0.0068092346, -0.036743164, -0.03274536, -0.042266846, -0.029449463, -0.030715942, -0.0206604, 0.0036735535, -0.01626587, 0.010475159, 0.0012588501, 0.02029419, 0.052764893, 0.017532349, -0.030517578, -0.014373779, -0.042114258, 0.004207611, 0.010856628, -0.019363403, -0.04421997, -0.010597229, 0.04067993, -0.00447464, -0.0014152527, -0.0007276535, -0.021850586, -0.015113831, 0.027450562, -0.027908325, 0.0025310516, -0.0017271042, 0.03265381, -0.010948181, -0.0074806213, -0.017501831, -0.0057296753, -0.028137207, 0.014945984, 0.02319336, -0.0035438538, 0.026535034, -0.00592041, -0.021987915, 0.024520874, 0.011787415, 0.017608643, -0.012298584, 0.019073486, -0.0033340454, -0.02532959, 0.0027122498, 0.007209778, -0.009017944, 0.0008506775, -0.018234253, -0.017364502, 0.04623413, 0.032440186, 0.043273926, -0.027282715, 0.008552551, 0.011604309, -0.013801575, -0.024368286, -0.05834961, -0.0014657974, 0.03781128, -0.004638672, -0.012588501, -0.011077881, -0.01725769, 0.025497437, -0.011451721, -0.008392334, 0.00025725365, -0.014060974, 0.004535675, 0.016937256, -0.00021731853, -0.012809753, -0.02116394, -0.013534546, 0.019012451, -0.057403564, 0.022079468, 0.05984497, -0.008132935, -0.030380249, -0.009025574, 0.011817932, -0.01651001, -0.044799805, 0.03086853, -0.023529053, 0.027252197, 0.02696228, -0.0027694702, -0.012214661, 0.024993896, -0.013221741, -0.011062622, 0.0038261414, -0.034210205, 0.025650024, -0.027954102, 0.007045746, 0.012481689, 0.00459671, 0.0062446594, 0.028930664, -0.031707764, -0.011703491, -0.0390625, 0.00037622452, 0.042114258, -0.035064697, 0.016845703, -0.036071777, -0.01966858, -0.002696991, 0.004257202, -0.037597656, -0.050842285, -0.008682251, -0.057800293, -0.003566742, -0.013679504, -0.0713501, 0.015571594, 0.021484375, 0.008117676, -0.0020179749, 0.01008606, -0.032226562, -0.045562744, -0.004119873, -0.013694763, 0.027755737, -0.015220642, 0.0035171509, -0.008842468, -0.037628174, 0.059143066, -0.040039062, 0.0026073456, -0.044677734, -0.026550293, -0.05508423, -0.020812988, -0.0049591064, 0.045562744, -0.0033893585, 0.04171753, -0.008911133, -0.017501831, 0.039276123, -0.067871094, -0.05606079, 0.008338928, -0.020812988, -0.02758789, 0.027664185, 0.0034999847, 0.02720642, 0.0057754517, -0.014839172, -0.016723633, 0.04675293, -0.00447464, 0.033813477, -0.040771484, 0.008399963, -0.0138549805, 0.048095703, -0.021240234, -0.025741577, 0.0002527237, 0.0058784485, -0.04046631, -0.030731201, -0.025527954, 0.014190674, -0.030166626, -0.022964478, 0.0042266846, 0.035308838, -0.014335632, -0.021194458, 0.010765076, 0.007232666, 0.008468628, -0.045166016, 0.00491333, 0.015594482, 0.01864624, 0.04147339, 0.051574707, -0.014480591, 0.025100708, -0.026992798, -0.023025513, -0.015281677, 0.02268982, -0.042297363, -0.097595215, 0.076293945, 0.005004883, -0.044189453, -0.010765076, 0.01209259, 0.0423584, 0.017745972, 0.037017822, 0.027923584, -0.020904541, -0.003232956, 0.04751587, -0.001865387, 0.015312195, -0.014862061, -0.03378296, 0.0039482117, 0.02659607, 0.04055786, 0.0016727448, 0.011001587, -0.023071289, -0.022415161, 0.017181396, 0.020339966, -0.025390625, 0.04736328, -0.0014743805, -0.010948181, -0.04333496, -0.032928467, -0.05014038, 0.066101074, -0.029953003, -0.015052795, 0.0049705505, -0.003993988, -0.011528015, 0.017105103, -0.040527344, 0.012016296, -0.008636475, 0.025283813, -0.015220642, 0.027526855, 0.014564514, -0.009384155, 0.041503906, -0.012825012, 0.03527832, -0.010826111, 0.010093689, 0.06506348, -0.037872314, -0.03353882, 0.01725769, 0.060150146, -0.012817383, 0.003692627, 0.004837036, 0.049743652, 0.012313843, -0.022491455, 0.042633057, -0.0149002075, -0.01209259, 0.0011177063, 0.02571106, -0.0096588135, -0.005504608, -0.02545166, -0.007499695, 0.030288696, -0.00970459, 0.04043579, 0.039489746, 0.05569458, -0.03463745, 0.017990112, 0.0058898926, 0.011138916, -0.032348633, 0.014198303, -0.027572632, -0.025131226, -0.03149414, 0.006511688, 0.0062789917, 0.015365601, -0.017807007, 0.023422241, 0.028579712, -0.029632568, 0.016113281, -0.027404785, 0.018585205, 0.022003174, 0.051483154, 0.040161133, 0.049346924, -0.017181396, 0.010635376, 0.042175293, -0.027770996, 0.027267456, -0.046844482, 0.057891846, 0.048461914, 0.01576233, -0.0793457, 0.008224487, 0.0927124, -0.02420044, 0.02218628, -0.026168823, 0.014801025, -0.015975952, -0.03048706, 0.010238647, -0.012908936, -0.010314941, 0.023620605, -0.07989502, 0.033355713, -0.05114746, 0.07659912, -0.0758667, -0.03579712, -0.039398193, -0.009391785, -0.035308838, 0.006011963, 0.019439697, -0.0072288513, -0.009765625, -0.029693604, -0.013221741, -0.019241333, 0.0021781921, 0.017700195, -0.021194458, -0.051116943, 0.0052833557, 0.009963989, 0.04864502, 0.020065308, -0.02218628, 0.008270264, 0.012359619, -0.008224487, 0.0033512115, -0.0067710876, 0.02444458, -0.027420044, -0.017868042, 0.038482666, 0.057800293, -0.010185242, -0.07775879, -0.039367676, -0.005584717, -0.045837402, 0.04321289, 0.001241684, 0.00072574615, -0.049865723, 0.0110321045, -0.009605408, -0.01751709, -0.042816162, 0.005695343, 0.02381897, -0.012756348, 0.0022029877, -0.008003235, 0.030929565, 0.02861023, 0.016586304, -0.06365967, 0.031921387, -0.02758789, 0.02659607, -0.007095337, -0.0028877258, 0.015899658, 0.06201172, 0.004432678, -0.001876831, -0.030014038, -0.019622803, 0.02746582, 0.04360962, 0.015129089, -0.009483337, 0.023529053, 0.031677246, 0.02835083, 0.009757996, -0.012763977, 0.01134491, 0.0036296844, -0.043670654, -0.007980347, 0.008110046, 0.029815674, -0.0013132095, 0.0049705505, 0.0116119385, -0.056610107, -0.020523071, 0.030288696, -0.013549805, 0.013076782, 0.0033550262, -0.021713257, -0.014053345, -0.019805908, 0.010948181, -0.037475586, -0.013435364, 0.05734253, 0.017700195, 0.030853271, -0.016052246, 0.054992676, 0.027038574, -0.0026397705, -0.009216309, 0.029220581, -0.0020179749, -0.010414124, -0.07244873, -0.0056381226, -0.067993164, -0.02078247, -0.026550293, -0.02229309, 0.029541016, -0.012306213, 0.016677856, 0.027709961, -0.024749756, 0.030395508, 0.016281128, 0.014717102, 0.024307251, -0.010063171, -0.05203247, -0.014945984, 0.0050239563 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07387v1
Assessing Logical Puzzle Solving in Large Language Models: Insights from a Minesweeper Case Study
Yinghao Li, Haorui Wang, Chao Zhang
cs.CL
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown remarkable proficiency in language understanding and have been successfully applied to a variety of real-world tasks through task-specific fine-tuning or prompt engineering. Despite these advancements, it remains an open question whether LLMs are fundamentally capable of reasoning and planning, or if they primarily rely on recalling and synthesizing information from their training data. In our research, we introduce a novel task -- Minesweeper -- specifically designed in a format unfamiliar to LLMs and absent from their training datasets. This task challenges LLMs to identify the locations of mines based on numerical clues provided by adjacent opened cells. Successfully completing this task requires an understanding of each cell's state, discerning spatial relationships between the clues and mines, and strategizing actions based on logical deductions drawn from the arrangement of the cells. Our experiments, including trials with the advanced GPT-4 model, indicate that while LLMs possess the foundational abilities required for this task, they struggle to integrate these into a coherent, multi-step logical reasoning process needed to solve Minesweeper. These findings highlight the need for further research to understand and nature of reasoning capabilities in LLMs under similar circumstances, and to explore pathways towards more sophisticated AI reasoning and planning models.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07387v1
2023-11-13T15:11:26
2023-11-13T15:11:26
{ "title": [ -0.039123535, -0.022735596, -0.015975952, 0.0015745163, -0.025634766, -0.0128479, -0.030090332, -0.014167786, -0.010292053, 0.026275635, -0.014297485, 0.0022068024, 0.0010814667, -0.018920898, -0.033813477, -0.01272583, -0.03479004, 0.037384033, -0.034179688, -0.039093018, 0.012298584, -0.0592041, -0.008232117, -0.0079574585, 0.03994751, -0.026550293, -0.047698975, 0.026397705, -0.005622864, -0.0023059845, 0.0075035095, -0.02748108, 0.050933838, -0.014526367, -0.008712769, 0.013702393, -0.011672974, -0.0061836243, -0.012702942, 0.03286743, 0.025283813, -0.02154541, -0.026519775, 0.0021038055, -0.04800415, 0.02079773, -0.05319214, -0.0064811707, -0.0034828186, 0.0020885468, -0.0073242188, 0.023788452, -0.011940002, 0.005680084, -0.0013046265, -0.015686035, -0.02067566, -0.033081055, 0.009979248, 0.089416504, 0.040802002, -0.012062073, -0.0124435425, -0.037963867, -0.0041542053, 0.0017366409, 0.010574341, 0.011955261, 0.04168701, 0.014465332, -0.02935791, 0.014442444, 0.021621704, -0.0032291412, -0.010910034, -0.0118637085, 0.04397583, 0.021972656, 0.015060425, -0.010101318, 0.017944336, -0.009246826, 0.011627197, -0.007850647, 0.009773254, -0.022827148, -0.006362915, -0.007499695, -0.025024414, -0.07946777, -0.010215759, 0.0184021, -0.037750244, -0.044189453, -0.026367188, -0.049957275, -0.010620117, 0.010429382, 0.011009216, -0.043640137, -0.012634277, 0.017196655, -0.07763672, -0.0026512146, -0.013702393, 0.042816162, 0.0129776, -0.032348633, -0.017974854, 0.018997192, -0.021316528, -0.0056610107, 0.014266968, -0.032806396, 0.029037476, -0.006576538, -0.010520935, 0.052124023, 0.037384033, 0.031463623, -0.040649414, -0.044158936, 0.03074646, 0.0039253235, 0.030136108, 0.0062408447, -0.030319214, 0.021499634, 0.013412476, 0.044708252, -0.010063171, 0.023483276, -0.0793457, -0.083740234, -0.06311035, 0.008720398, -0.024154663, -0.016342163, -0.016494751, -0.010726929, 0.03451538, -0.02507019, 0.02734375, -0.0057029724, 0.028152466, 0.0021209717, 0.058776855, 0.0042152405, -0.0552063, -0.028167725, 0.00036621094, 0.02420044, 0.012199402, -0.011207581, -0.037200928, -0.01209259, -0.11419678, 0.01399231, 0.030715942, 0.017654419, 0.0012636185, 0.015838623, 0.02128601, -0.004386902, -0.0124435425, -0.02885437, -0.013153076, -0.0015115738, 0.0051574707, 0.009437561, -0.02760315, 0.059753418, 0.000207901, -0.0047950745, 0.014122009, -0.01777649, 0.016113281, 0.031951904, -0.0079193115, 0.017288208, 0.03149414, -0.0236969, -0.0041542053, 0.036224365, -0.061950684, -0.017745972, -0.016433716, 0.008506775, 0.078063965, -0.0062942505, -0.032470703, -0.0007138252, -0.013061523, -0.004272461, -0.015571594, -0.04598999, 0.011627197, 0.013328552, -0.006591797, -0.013664246, -0.05557251, 0.01676941, -0.038726807, 0.027145386, -0.020599365, -0.013961792, -0.013626099, 0.024337769, -0.010932922, 0.05050659, 0.04147339, 0.024520874, -0.04727173, 0.058135986, 0.014892578, -0.06878662, 0.007144928, -0.008605957, 0.01071167, -0.016204834, 0.017181396, -0.009353638, 0.008003235, 0.00054979324, -0.021072388, 0.036254883, -0.022277832, 0.0046043396, 0.045806885, 0.019546509, 0.099853516, -0.047729492, 0.06262207, 0.043395996, -0.019180298, -0.023544312, -0.028640747, -0.048828125, -0.00021839142, 0.031799316, 0.000044107437, -0.024215698, -0.019134521, -0.006298065, 0.004573822, -0.03186035, 0.01675415, -0.003955841, -0.0014591217, 0.037963867, 0.05709839, 0.034851074, 0.021011353, 0.045288086, -0.03933716, 0.053222656, -0.026000977, -0.029724121, -0.0017433167, 0.031173706, 0.008987427, -0.020965576, 0.005218506, -0.013908386, -0.038085938, -0.027770996, -0.050964355, -0.028930664, -0.01285553, -0.014915466, 0.035247803, -0.03652954, 0.025161743, -0.0022735596, -0.048950195, 0.013046265, -0.014083862, 0.01448822, 0.03970337, -0.04498291, -0.007575989, 0.013320923, 0.03982544, -0.016906738, 0.0072364807, 0.012039185, 0.018707275, -0.047058105, 0.023834229, 0.02986145, 0.04925537, 0.03363037, 0.01108551, 0.041137695, -0.01234436, -0.012283325, 0.077941895, 0.051940918, -0.007637024, 0.005504608, -0.03817749, 0.009239197, -0.007572174, -0.0035762787, 0.018569946, 0.0016746521, 0.04547119, 0.02633667, -0.018112183, 0.033721924, -0.07336426, -0.026687622, 0.015426636, -0.014915466, -0.020446777, -0.045959473, 0.015525818, -0.015457153, -0.019424438, -0.0154953, 0.044158936, -0.009536743, -0.027893066, 0.010917664, 0.007030487, -0.021759033, 0.01374054, -0.03112793, -0.019317627, 0.0025501251, 0.036743164, 0.0028305054, -0.024719238, -0.031982422, -0.0018081665, -0.0030403137, -0.013114929, 0.026168823, -0.03845215, -0.0008215904, -0.029953003, -0.06958008, 0.0013284683, -0.037200928, -0.011062622, -0.046081543, 0.00047659874, 0.00844574, -0.032562256, -0.01725769, 0.028442383, -0.025634766, -0.0030784607, 0.059387207, 0.099609375, -0.044769287, -0.049682617, 0.08728027, 0.022613525, 0.0044898987, 0.026000977, 0.051239014, 0.03845215, -0.0048446655, -0.07159424, -0.047302246, 0.003288269, 0.03363037, 0.023468018, 0.0385437, -0.051361084, -0.0031433105, -0.016326904, -0.0038871765, 0.046020508, -0.0050582886, 0.022827148, -0.027694702, -0.018203735, 0.0036315918, -0.033599854, 0.017303467, -0.049591064, 0.06008911, 0.101257324, 0.008094788, 0.019866943, 0.02204895, 0.04849243, -0.0069236755, -0.0002644062, -0.022354126, -0.012008667, -0.019805908, 0.018234253, 0.01322937, -0.036499023, -0.0029621124, -0.04421997, 0.006023407, 0.058044434, -0.0158844, -0.03466797, 0.032165527, -0.054992676, 0.022949219, 0.006511688, -0.017425537, 0.020095825, 0.007980347, 0.010955811, 0.009269714, -0.008026123, -0.022918701, -0.00025629997, -0.03857422, -0.1104126, 0.026367188, -0.0065956116, -0.026657104, -0.018112183, 0.0057678223, -0.037109375, -0.008514404, -0.019348145, 0.027557373, 0.030792236, 0.014572144, 0.020446777, 0.028701782, 0.0006890297, 0.006099701, -0.006427765, 0.014572144, -0.010368347, 0.03753662, -0.00062942505, 0.026443481, 0.036834717, -0.020706177, -0.0021476746, -0.0028018951, -0.05532837, 0.0070648193, 0.0024719238, -0.05935669, -0.0009775162, -0.023971558, -0.013343811, 0.009628296, -0.031051636, 0.015472412, -0.005756378, 0.012672424, -0.013053894, -0.007850647, 0.012809753, 0.01651001, -0.007293701, -0.046539307, -0.0012187958, -0.017074585, -0.072143555, 0.013702393, 0.045135498, -0.00819397, -0.00995636, 0.0048332214, -0.023803711, 0.017227173, 0.014831543, -0.008872986, 0.021881104, -0.010871887, -0.003232956, -0.009208679, 0.0087509155, 0.00008481741, -0.029968262, -0.020309448, -0.031951904, 0.01789856, -0.018554688, -0.087768555, -0.02822876, 0.0052223206, -0.07519531, -0.0026187897, -0.004497528, 0.0047416687, -0.021697998, -0.025054932, 0.012306213, -0.019607544, -0.04537964, 0.017440796, -0.0053863525, 0.046569824, -0.017227173, -0.08117676, -0.020095825, 0.055389404, -0.018127441, 0.040130615, 0.077819824, -0.0015850067, -0.046020508, -0.035980225, 0.0046310425, 0.051574707, -0.0054473877, -0.00007814169, -0.040496826, 0.029724121, -0.03527832, 0.014221191, 0.0105896, -0.006095886, -0.022583008, 0.026367188, -0.03918457, -0.0027275085, -0.0071144104, 0.059020996, -0.01927185, 0.010978699, -0.0770874, 0.064575195, -0.0028381348, -0.006046295, 0.024139404, -0.042022705, 0.011100769, 0.019042969, 0.018798828, 0.068847656, 0.004108429, -0.004508972, 0.012260437, 0.0011358261, -0.010131836, -0.014579773, -0.0067977905, 0.023132324, -0.008232117, 0.039398193, -0.011512756, 0.06359863, -0.018875122, 0.004776001, 0.01322937, 0.020812988, -0.040649414, -0.0012559891, -0.06262207, -0.002565384, -0.0019893646, 0.0095825195, -0.028961182, 0.053833008, 0.01763916, 0.0063934326, -0.01725769, -0.011116028, 0.06402588, 0.019439697, -0.044677734, -0.09460449, -0.0075531006, -0.0028839111, -0.06365967, -0.033935547, 0.000051796436, 0.002216339, 0.02357483, -0.009414673, -0.038970947, 0.011405945, 0.02394104, 0.062347412, 0.026000977, 0.008613586, -0.04333496, 0.05429077, -0.016677856, -0.038970947, 0.013656616, -0.004852295, -0.02798462, -0.040405273, 0.029922485, -0.005695343, -0.011581421, -0.03010559, 0.04043579, 0.00000500679, 0.0362854, -0.03262329, -0.014717102, 0.017929077, 0.0029296875, -0.005847931, -0.003063202, -0.03488159, 0.037475586, -0.025726318, 0.05029297, -0.015777588, -0.029174805, 0.0062408447, 0.038757324, 0.023101807, 0.007194519, -0.010948181, -0.023452759, 0.03616333, 0.026184082, 0.012275696, -0.048553467, -0.028945923, -0.0129776, 0.01234436, 0.021240234, -0.061645508, 0.032592773, -0.024856567, 0.01979065, 0.006881714, -0.021621704, 0.042419434, -0.008262634, 0.032409668, -0.062469482, -0.03994751, -0.004257202, 0.02897644, -0.03463745, 0.006187439, 0.009796143, -0.029006958, 0.015205383, 0.061462402, 0.047851562, -0.02394104, 0.029464722, -0.002450943, -0.01235199, -0.005088806, -0.054656982, -0.03173828, 0.016784668, 0.024749756, -0.09210205, 0.084106445, -0.024368286, -0.0034065247, -0.002588272, -0.014961243, -0.00983429, -0.06903076, 0.022476196, 0.04208374, 0.00289917, 0.0155181885, -0.0035915375, 0.008720398, -0.028869629, 0.045806885, -0.02709961, 0.020736694, 0.033172607, -0.065979004, 0.013885498, -0.000071167946, 0.011016846, -0.014015198, 0.03842163, -0.00009471178, 0.014923096, -0.04675293, 0.020019531, 0.020751953, -0.005569458, 0.024475098, -0.050842285, 0.029663086, -0.002412796, -0.011734009, 0.009429932, 0.00440979, -0.026107788, -0.017730713, 0.008232117, -0.0044937134, 0.009635925, 0.006298065, -0.013923645, -0.057525635, 0.009346008, -0.035736084, 0.005241394, 0.01625061, 0.0074806213, -0.020767212, 0.030654907, 0.03918457, -0.0047340393, 0.010520935, -0.037139893, -0.028793335, 0.033477783, 0.07623291, 0.0047073364, -0.003944397, 0.012794495, -0.025756836, -0.009513855, -0.0013523102, -0.021697998, 0.006111145, -0.01576233, -0.026031494, -0.02810669, 0.010658264, 0.026901245, -0.011070251, -0.039093018, 0.008285522, -0.017700195, -0.013473511, 0.044189453, 0.052215576, -0.0051574707, 0.02810669, 0.021377563, -0.033081055, 0.034698486, -0.013305664, -0.005092621, 0.013175964, -0.051116943, 0.015586853, 0.015037537, -0.019073486, -0.023223877, 0.020751953, 0.02116394, 0.018356323, -0.022842407, -0.010566711, 0.028457642, -0.02633667, 0.024291992, 0.024520874, 0.011444092, 0.010902405, 0.07318115, -0.015899658, 0.015556335, -0.0446167, -0.05419922, -0.025894165, 0.018722534, 0.026306152, 0.009010315, 0.03591919, -0.015945435, 0.039642334, -0.007091522, -0.022979736, -0.09075928, -0.02571106, -0.029800415, -0.051574707, 0.11004639, 0.024536133, -0.01789856, -0.005153656, 0.0005226135, 0.039123535, 0.010818481, 0.056549072, -0.036865234, -0.017471313, -0.017410278, -0.066833496, 0.031707764, 0.015335083, 0.0073890686, 0.08795166, -0.022018433, 0.035308838, 0.0010519028, 0.0362854, 0.0002901554, 0.0158844, 0.028793335, 0.008338928, 0.028137207, -0.014945984, 0.04473877, -0.028152466, -0.0018930435, -0.06439209, -0.024490356, -0.07989502, 0.010345459, 0.010032654, 0.041809082, 0.022140503, 0.001709938, 0.03778076, 0.010879517, 0.020141602, -0.003791809, 0.06713867, -0.013923645, -0.0011615753, -0.0054969788, -0.020767212, 0.037139893, 0.057647705, -0.0012750626, 0.0010128021, -0.017242432, -0.043914795, 0.015899658, 0.026809692, -0.011062622, -0.02281189, -0.0049362183, -0.04901123, -0.0045051575, -0.02166748, 0.0027675629, 0.06640625, 0.017807007, -0.015670776, -0.0034694672, 0.018203735, -0.047943115, -0.016159058, -0.010421753, -0.0025482178, -0.044647217, 0.03677368, -0.017913818, -0.01663208, -0.023391724, 0.0012874603, 0.032409668, -0.072143555, -0.013130188, 0.0014104843, 0.02168274, -0.019058228, -0.0025138855, -0.028457642, -0.011207581, 0.029678345, 0.023223877, 0.012039185, 0.0413208, 0.015319824, 0.047912598, -0.008399963, -0.030395508, 0.017410278, -0.039367676, -0.0006155968, 0.025421143, 0.02178955, 0.00491333, -0.005203247, -0.028518677, -0.014213562, 0.0074386597, -0.037322998, -0.012016296, -0.030303955, 0.06854248, 0.066589355, 0.08630371, 0.022644043, 0.004463196, 0.03060913, -0.048309326, 0.024169922, 0.07104492, -0.0019245148, 0.047454834, -0.053497314, -0.06793213, 0.048187256, -0.043395996, 0.06951904, -0.06286621, 0.014389038, -0.05545044, 0.0736084, -0.034698486, -0.05154419, -0.04724121, -0.025253296, -0.038726807, 0.008987427, 0.0024700165, -0.034454346, -0.009918213, -0.009384155, 0.0065231323, -0.008308411, -0.000007927418, 0.019348145, -0.038391113, -0.08703613, 0.0070991516, -0.00049495697, 0.02885437, -0.006504059, -0.012809753, -0.014137268, 0.0028686523, 0.009460449, -0.041656494, -0.033203125, -0.02772522, -0.01033783, -0.03665161, 0.023666382, 0.03463745, -0.000279665, -0.016998291, -0.03161621, -0.0056381226, -0.02658081, 0.03994751, 0.015914917, -0.040985107, -0.016693115, 0.012374878, -0.027359009, 0.040374756, -0.013832092, -0.011833191, 0.033721924, 0.010772705, -0.038635254, -0.0036334991, 0.004348755, 0.025878906, 0.0007824898, -0.04623413, 0.0044555664, 0.014213562, 0.0345459, -0.02897644, -0.048828125, 0.02468872, 0.026901245, 0.009262085, 0.05618286, 0.014656067, 0.016677856, -0.0005803108, 0.021255493, 0.0023651123, -0.044708252, -0.026306152, 0.026565552, 0.037902832, 0.035980225, -0.0035800934, -0.002090454, 0.014099121, -0.03543091, -0.0012168884, 0.011489868, -0.010192871, 0.014343262, 0.00008010864, 0.03378296, -0.018585205, -0.00655365, -0.00566864, 0.019592285, -0.0065689087, -0.0022773743, 0.0121154785, 0.01260376, -0.019454956, 0.01285553, -0.023635864, -0.04171753, 0.054382324, 0.06274414, 0.008049011, 0.03161621, -0.022766113, -0.0038070679, 0.0041389465, 0.00881958, -0.018310547, -0.015365601, 0.020629883, -0.0024032593, -0.010429382, -0.019683838, -0.02053833, 0.010620117, -0.025634766, 0.045043945, -0.020263672, -0.0052986145, -0.020477295, -0.0158844, 0.016204834, 0.0413208, 0.017745972, -0.0077819824, -0.03515625, 0.044891357, 0.021591187, -0.017089844 ], "summary": [ -0.035247803, -0.030227661, 0.008575439, 0.032409668, -0.068603516, 0.0015172958, -0.041015625, -0.026885986, 0.006614685, -0.005329132, -0.03378296, -0.0020008087, -0.033355713, -0.01991272, 0.019332886, -0.05670166, 0.003206253, 0.014038086, -0.01586914, -0.03869629, 0.028289795, -0.051086426, -0.019348145, 0.050750732, 0.01436615, 0.012626648, -0.03717041, 0.026138306, 0.020050049, 0.046417236, 0.021377563, -0.059570312, 0.010124207, -0.014015198, 0.018173218, 0.0041656494, -0.004386902, -0.0050239563, 0.0011615753, 0.01864624, 0.02027893, -0.008148193, 0.030456543, -0.006916046, -0.029449463, 0.03945923, -0.024383545, -0.025939941, 0.023468018, 0.0007042885, 0.010444641, 0.027862549, -0.0015745163, -0.019195557, -0.023788452, 0.0068969727, -0.025222778, -0.033935547, 0.0017261505, 0.07623291, 0.036987305, 0.020935059, -0.0109939575, -0.04296875, -0.005252838, 0.0154953, 0.037139893, -0.025848389, 0.009498596, 0.01033783, 0.020812988, -0.0046958923, 0.04006958, 0.004196167, 0.019638062, -0.026000977, 0.024673462, 0.02861023, 0.015686035, -0.004676819, 0.037994385, 0.014152527, -0.000017344952, -0.035339355, 0.008453369, -0.03314209, 0.003068924, -0.008872986, -0.0019025803, -0.056488037, -0.024017334, 0.014877319, -0.031951904, -0.0031204224, -0.014892578, -0.037628174, -0.0154953, -0.02609253, -0.002981186, -0.037597656, 0.024963379, -0.030319214, -0.020446777, 0.0014352798, 0.00036501884, 0.072387695, 0.00081014633, -0.0463562, -0.0073509216, -0.003742218, 0.0038394928, -0.047180176, 0.022247314, -0.06890869, 0.020095825, 0.018356323, 0.014579773, 0.0725708, 0.034301758, 0.02458191, -0.055908203, -0.03439331, 0.0047340393, 0.05807495, 0.041809082, 0.05545044, 0.027709961, 0.011650085, 0.02557373, 0.013946533, 0.0046577454, 0.047943115, -0.07366943, -0.094055176, -0.085754395, -0.013076782, 0.0131073, -0.010795593, 0.0029659271, -0.021316528, 0.043548584, -0.0132369995, 0.0052871704, 0.029327393, 0.017105103, 0.024978638, 0.04067993, 0.0044517517, -0.04562378, -0.027267456, 0.022842407, 0.00504303, 0.010498047, -0.0013513565, 0.0022830963, -0.032073975, -0.04159546, 0.0096588135, 0.028213501, 0.0048599243, 0.023513794, 0.016799927, -0.00006687641, -0.024291992, -0.0501709, -0.033569336, -0.038024902, -0.0077323914, 0.0033512115, -0.015625, 0.007881165, 0.04547119, -0.0062026978, -0.015258789, 0.015205383, -0.027816772, 0.012084961, 0.045013428, -0.031677246, 0.011054993, 0.030441284, -0.053863525, -0.004169464, 0.009727478, -0.016586304, -0.009849548, -0.018829346, 0.01360321, 0.066467285, 0.008071899, -0.050720215, -0.020553589, 0.022445679, 0.01398468, -0.0002169609, -0.02142334, 0.0013189316, 0.029388428, -0.017364502, -0.03100586, 0.010398865, 0.0049476624, -0.010971069, -0.036224365, -0.052886963, -0.002910614, -0.017150879, 0.044555664, 0.009223938, 0.014221191, 0.019515991, 0.015533447, -0.037139893, 0.022354126, -0.026763916, -0.053527832, 0.008781433, -0.013626099, 0.0018911362, -0.02923584, 0.020568848, 0.0090408325, -0.024505615, 0.029251099, -0.043518066, 0.018920898, -0.018722534, 0.02746582, 0.020858765, 0.029373169, 0.07647705, -0.056121826, 0.04864502, 0.04119873, -0.016677856, -0.025009155, 0.010246277, -0.07562256, 0.02218628, 0.04751587, 0.008476257, 0.02279663, -0.028060913, -0.0030841827, 0.0066452026, 0.018554688, 0.03643799, -0.02418518, -0.015342712, 0.05670166, 0.006881714, 0.023025513, 0.015914917, -0.0038280487, -0.030914307, 0.048614502, -0.011383057, -0.051330566, 0.007686615, 0.008857727, 0.020599365, -0.04156494, -0.030029297, -0.013137817, -0.006351471, -0.062316895, -0.041259766, -0.047729492, -0.014343262, -0.041656494, 0.044067383, -0.030532837, 0.010467529, -0.03741455, -0.043762207, -0.009048462, -0.032836914, 0.037994385, 0.031982422, -0.035827637, -0.0019683838, 0.0049972534, -0.034820557, -0.014579773, 0.041870117, 0.008628845, -0.014839172, 0.003774643, 0.032348633, 0.07104492, 0.057800293, 0.029800415, 0.01889038, 0.016418457, 0.0020275116, -0.0016021729, 0.060272217, 0.023620605, 0.013061523, -0.024307251, -0.008865356, 0.03363037, -0.033233643, 0.0010032654, 0.03778076, -0.019714355, 0.043914795, 0.02456665, 0.020187378, 0.024642944, -0.07513428, -0.033325195, 0.041290283, 0.07476807, -0.011207581, -0.023742676, 0.029037476, 0.061950684, 0.0018510818, -0.0023822784, 0.117370605, 0.020751953, 0.0055503845, 0.020858765, 0.01121521, -0.06286621, 0.04800415, -0.039855957, -0.027496338, -0.014129639, -0.0029640198, -0.05114746, -0.017410278, -0.012268066, 0.008361816, 0.0047073364, -0.0029716492, 0.013023376, -0.030517578, -0.0039405823, -0.007873535, -0.07043457, 0.0017051697, -0.019134521, -0.029922485, -0.00055265427, -0.0049057007, 0.01272583, -0.0031661987, -0.0035209656, 0.006008148, -0.027801514, 0.028762817, 0.06829834, 0.04852295, -0.0118255615, -0.044128418, 0.02204895, -0.033721924, -0.04727173, -0.005405426, 0.036712646, 0.0024356842, -0.016571045, -0.042938232, -0.02217102, 0.0021858215, 0.035308838, 0.052581787, 0.03677368, -0.017929077, 0.06121826, -0.088012695, -0.0067825317, 0.027938843, 0.011619568, 0.09991455, 0.001914978, -0.009712219, 0.047607422, 0.021118164, 0.042541504, -0.027648926, 0.015731812, 0.068603516, -0.005847931, -0.031280518, 0.007549286, 0.045959473, 0.017684937, 0.007663727, -0.031341553, -0.026168823, -0.010513306, 0.010253906, 0.021743774, -0.04244995, -0.023773193, -0.036590576, -0.0034313202, 0.05831909, 0.009803772, 0.013015747, 0.017578125, -0.03543091, 0.056793213, -0.0021438599, 0.013038635, 0.031463623, -0.02557373, 0.02482605, -0.03817749, 0.015701294, -0.03829956, -0.017349243, -0.018417358, -0.053497314, 0.003791809, -0.006538391, 0.018966675, -0.03994751, 0.042877197, -0.028503418, 0.009117126, 0.011764526, 0.008880615, 0.007789612, -0.002796173, 0.015609741, 0.045776367, 0.00013029575, 0.013267517, 0.00048017502, 0.036590576, -0.0032615662, 0.05102539, -0.004512787, -0.04107666, 0.040130615, -0.05847168, -0.0048675537, 0.01586914, -0.07885742, -0.009437561, -0.03302002, -0.02607727, 0.026016235, -0.04650879, -0.014289856, 0.0079193115, -0.023849487, 0.015655518, 0.010772705, 0.025970459, -0.015327454, 0.0050964355, -0.021133423, 0.03463745, 0.051483154, -0.04711914, 0.011558533, -0.020446777, -0.07385254, 0.03250122, 0.026565552, 0.027389526, -0.06506348, 0.035308838, -0.00920105, -0.00932312, 0.033569336, -0.017211914, 0.028427124, -0.02619934, -0.020111084, -0.06652832, 0.059783936, 0.0029392242, 0.023773193, -0.06188965, -0.07989502, 0.026931763, -0.07128906, -0.08453369, -0.049865723, 0.009376526, -0.05911255, -0.02973938, -0.0034637451, 0.015136719, -0.038085938, -0.0039100647, 0.029449463, -0.020339966, -0.0065193176, 0.03112793, -0.02217102, 0.091430664, 0.006614685, -0.05883789, 0.024230957, -0.008544922, 0.002401352, 0.032440186, 0.027618408, -0.01826477, -0.008094788, 0.015701294, 0.012214661, 0.050750732, 0.0032424927, 0.007045746, -0.037841797, 0.00037431717, -0.033416748, -0.004058838, 0.026565552, -0.011383057, -0.0042304993, 0.011489868, 0.016830444, 0.018554688, 0.0069236755, 0.0065574646, -0.017944336, 0.050964355, -0.046813965, 0.0657959, -0.011116028, -0.0032215118, 0.03933716, 0.01424408, -0.031982422, -0.01322937, 0.017852783, -0.002960205, -0.016693115, -0.007247925, 0.0021381378, 0.0043258667, -0.018615723, -0.01991272, -0.008377075, 0.025131226, -0.019042969, 0.060791016, -0.0038967133, 0.07196045, -0.027938843, 0.029571533, -0.0049438477, -0.0014915466, -0.030975342, -0.03591919, -0.04135132, 0.017593384, -0.0025177002, 0.019348145, -0.018035889, 0.008987427, 0.04055786, 0.018600464, 0.0059051514, -0.03375244, 0.05505371, 0.02229309, -0.06402588, -0.115478516, -0.021636963, 0.004348755, -0.054840088, -0.032836914, -0.06402588, -0.029510498, -0.050964355, 0.007183075, -0.049835205, 0.021774292, 0.01979065, 0.08532715, 0.02204895, 0.009544373, -0.06124878, 0.015174866, -0.035125732, -0.0093688965, 0.009925842, -0.03640747, -0.031097412, -0.009803772, 0.04727173, 0.0059013367, -0.015098572, -0.045074463, -0.0061836243, 0.01663208, -0.00015461445, -0.0039978027, -0.019515991, 0.00217247, 0.02482605, -0.03149414, -0.008079529, -0.016540527, 0.05117798, -0.037841797, 0.026992798, 0.02519226, -0.023864746, 0.04196167, 0.027130127, 0.011383057, 0.0071792603, -0.026046753, 0.011123657, 0.028259277, -0.0008177757, 0.028762817, -0.011779785, 0.008094788, 0.027709961, -0.0087890625, 0.015899658, 0.0012521744, -0.020492554, -0.011276245, 0.04324341, 0.01838684, -0.02684021, 0.007820129, 0.004760742, 0.0041236877, -0.029785156, -0.06085205, -0.0037403107, 0.044189453, 0.0027217865, 0.008522034, 0.0052261353, -0.039276123, 0.013061523, 0.019821167, -0.005622864, -0.04537964, 0.055725098, -0.011192322, -0.015823364, 0.029876709, -0.02154541, -0.024734497, -0.015312195, 0.015701294, -0.050323486, 0.027954102, 0.03237915, -0.017456055, -0.0051651, -0.0043182373, -0.0018663406, -0.05154419, -0.021499634, 0.0057792664, -0.0070152283, 0.003074646, 0.040863037, -0.023376465, -0.038604736, 0.027908325, -0.049926758, 0.010551453, 0.011932373, -0.07067871, 0.0071411133, -0.007987976, 0.039794922, 0.009506226, 0.008148193, 0.019882202, 0.0062294006, -0.041900635, -0.008270264, -0.023406982, -0.00983429, 0.021911621, -0.012214661, 0.026611328, 0.008483887, 0.0005950928, 0.0048599243, 0.012207031, 0.00071525574, 0.017684937, 0.0045166016, 0.024978638, 0.005672455, 0.014701843, 0.038482666, -0.0021343231, 0.0075187683, -0.07434082, 0.014053345, 0.038757324, -0.0032730103, 0.03652954, 0.007843018, -0.011016846, 0.008422852, -0.010063171, -0.00050497055, -0.004447937, -0.013496399, 0.04006958, 0.019515991, -0.0010242462, -0.010124207, -0.023147583, -0.016357422, -0.0039711, -0.018447876, 0.036834717, -0.016952515, -0.0023918152, -0.011161804, 0.01826477, 0.03945923, -0.034179688, -0.058654785, -0.010131836, -0.047210693, -0.06298828, 0.07171631, 0.010375977, -0.038360596, 0.023086548, 0.011665344, -0.051605225, 0.036376953, -0.0129852295, 0.026885986, -0.04135132, -0.029449463, -0.00029301643, 0.028671265, -0.010131836, -0.002811432, 0.010734558, 0.0062942505, -0.0033283234, -0.020065308, -0.0014705658, 0.0056152344, -0.02180481, 0.01461792, 0.02406311, 0.022354126, 0.010017395, 0.046722412, -0.0058059692, -0.0015115738, -0.02319336, -0.033691406, 0.0016975403, -0.0043678284, 0.024246216, 0.009513855, 0.030212402, -0.0025978088, 0.006416321, 0.0046920776, -0.048095703, -0.054840088, -0.029922485, -0.031677246, -0.066467285, 0.14990234, 0.007835388, -0.042541504, 0.05355835, 0.0099487305, 0.011955261, -0.028747559, 0.061462402, 0.013900757, 0.0008864403, -0.034088135, 0.0058288574, 0.03314209, 0.013626099, -0.011657715, 0.0340271, 0.0073890686, 0.04031372, 0.03225708, -0.018753052, -0.0048446655, -0.0023479462, 0.010948181, 0.0050964355, 0.0063591003, -0.006351471, 0.07513428, -0.014976501, -0.028747559, -0.06274414, -0.0748291, -0.013389587, 0.0030117035, -0.015960693, -0.015365601, 0.04827881, -0.0064735413, 0.01512146, 0.039245605, -0.028442383, 0.04144287, 0.000017404556, 0.030670166, -0.0017404556, 0.010093689, -0.045043945, 0.0103302, 0.058624268, 0.00047683716, 0.006465912, 0.010475159, 0.0013103485, 0.03503418, -0.025009155, -0.024749756, -0.09832764, 0.025985718, -0.05407715, -0.010848999, 0.010299683, 0.01751709, 0.011192322, -0.009033203, -0.013053894, 0.018096924, 0.01210022, -0.012565613, 0.025177002, -0.0066452026, -0.018127441, 0.012039185, 0.0127334595, 0.017059326, -0.02204895, 0.031433105, 0.003917694, 0.03137207, -0.049804688, -0.026062012, 0.0039901733, 0.015113831, 0.0006055832, -0.039642334, -0.04425049, 0.009063721, 0.0076179504, -0.019317627, 0.018356323, 0.012359619, 0.018936157, 0.030349731, 0.018127441, -0.013931274, 0.0110321045, -0.033203125, 0.005680084, 0.024841309, 0.062805176, 0.019348145, 0.020126343, -0.013130188, 0.007183075, 0.026107788, -0.009185791, 0.01852417, 0.0058403015, 0.0637207, 0.056762695, 0.06262207, -0.012245178, 0.008560181, 0.03765869, -0.0047416687, 0.026290894, -0.0019187927, 0.0093688965, -0.011962891, -0.038391113, -0.015548706, -0.007419586, -0.023269653, 0.041809082, -0.0597229, 0.021194458, -0.03677368, 0.015930176, -0.0078048706, -0.01876831, -0.066101074, -0.0015411377, -0.007019043, 0.01727295, 0.015823364, -0.053710938, 0.009231567, 0.006088257, -0.02229309, 0.0103302, -0.0010709763, 0.022140503, -0.033721924, -0.05041504, 0.025375366, 0.040039062, 0.05102539, 0.02243042, -0.03488159, 0.0035743713, 0.016036987, 0.024139404, -0.026992798, -0.03579712, 0.014770508, 0.029159546, 0.010017395, -0.0068893433, 0.013381958, -0.01701355, -0.04949951, -0.027694702, 0.00945282, -0.039764404, 0.034088135, 0.06298828, -0.0020160675, -0.05734253, 0.00365448, -0.024963379, 0.0524292, -0.028152466, -0.02268982, 0.01876831, 0.0034370422, -0.02456665, 0.0040016174, 0.0037670135, 0.019424438, -0.029205322, -0.012619019, -0.023086548, 0.023742676, 0.051116943, -0.02015686, -0.044799805, 0.0132369995, 0.007698059, 0.01928711, -0.016052246, -0.04498291, -0.0072669983, 0.031585693, 0.05130005, 0.023040771, -0.027664185, 0.039398193, 0.05392456, 0.05709839, 0.011306763, -0.039123535, 0.05456543, 0.0060577393, -0.060546875, 0.00012153387, 0.015731812, 0.021026611, -0.0038414001, -0.0082473755, -0.0021190643, -0.042114258, -0.060638428, -0.007167816, 0.002735138, -0.016494751, -0.037261963, -0.0101623535, 0.009918213, -0.04437256, -0.045562744, -0.024139404, -0.03152466, 0.038635254, 0.028335571, 0.007850647, 0.013916016, 0.01600647, -0.0026874542, 0.001991272, 0.010185242, 0.0032043457, 0.0005674362, 0.01361084, -0.023468018, 0.002357483, -0.039520264, 0.012214661, -0.029281616, -0.017318726, 0.027404785, -0.008003235, -0.012779236, 0.011505127, -0.019744873, 0.026367188, 0.047210693, 0.013504028, 0.039489746, -0.0070533752, -0.004261017, -0.00014853477, -0.012489319 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07383v1
LM-Polygraph: Uncertainty Estimation for Language Models
Ekaterina Fadeeva, Roman Vashurin, Akim Tsvigun, Artem Vazhentsev, Sergey Petrakov, Kirill Fedyanin, Daniil Vasilev, Elizaveta Goncharova, Alexander Panchenko, Maxim Panov, Timothy Baldwin, Artem Shelmanov
cs.CL, cs.LG
Recent advancements in the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have paved the way for a myriad of groundbreaking applications in various fields. However, a significant challenge arises as these models often "hallucinate", i.e., fabricate facts without providing users an apparent means to discern the veracity of their statements. Uncertainty estimation (UE) methods are one path to safer, more responsible, and more effective use of LLMs. However, to date, research on UE methods for LLMs has been focused primarily on theoretical rather than engineering contributions. In this work, we tackle this issue by introducing LM-Polygraph, a framework with implementations of a battery of state-of-the-art UE methods for LLMs in text generation tasks, with unified program interfaces in Python. Additionally, it introduces an extendable benchmark for consistent evaluation of UE techniques by researchers, and a demo web application that enriches the standard chat dialog with confidence scores, empowering end-users to discern unreliable responses. LM-Polygraph is compatible with the most recent LLMs, including BLOOMz, LLaMA-2, ChatGPT, and GPT-4, and is designed to support future releases of similarly-styled LMs.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07383v1
2023-11-13T15:08:59
2023-11-13T15:08:59
{ "title": [ -0.06567383, -0.016143799, -0.049224854, -0.028366089, -0.020141602, -0.0016613007, -0.052520752, -0.009063721, -0.0030498505, 0.0073661804, -0.010894775, 0.0031814575, 0.006275177, -0.033172607, -0.02142334, 0.012176514, -0.013900757, 0.03778076, -0.042785645, -0.04284668, -0.009231567, -0.05996704, -0.0008406639, 0.003293991, 0.0635376, -0.07684326, -0.087646484, 0.040649414, -0.011352539, -0.0013628006, 0.0074920654, -0.005809784, 0.02998352, 0.046173096, -0.018997192, 0.01449585, -0.045410156, 0.02696228, 0.019134521, 0.013366699, 0.027816772, -0.0049743652, -0.029342651, -0.022567749, -0.05633545, 0.026672363, -0.05380249, -0.015213013, -0.004547119, 0.07891846, 0.010734558, 0.037597656, -0.014221191, 0.037322998, 0.02720642, -0.03945923, -0.0014867783, 0.01939392, 0.014137268, 0.048919678, 0.024520874, 0.0010566711, 0.0063476562, -0.004886627, -0.039886475, -0.025741577, -0.010559082, 0.030975342, 0.05255127, -0.009765625, -0.018447876, 0.016174316, 0.0017089844, -0.01777649, -0.027252197, 0.023391724, 0.0026931763, 0.027633667, 0.050323486, -0.026245117, 0.037261963, -0.026245117, 0.008415222, -0.020736694, 0.03765869, -0.029510498, -0.011062622, -0.01965332, -0.032684326, -0.066223145, -0.013214111, -0.0138168335, -0.017837524, 0.0064964294, -0.028640747, -0.022109985, -0.0040245056, 0.023071289, -0.020080566, -0.054626465, -0.02835083, 0.030670166, -0.08319092, 0.0026302338, 0.014984131, 0.023605347, -0.03048706, -0.038208008, 0.02281189, 0.025970459, -0.017959595, 0.06201172, 0.002626419, -0.0099105835, 0.0038452148, 0.03918457, 0.005958557, 0.007587433, 0.011856079, 0.044067383, -0.0129852295, -0.029190063, 0.011764526, -0.008087158, 0.03543091, -0.00043010712, -0.05255127, 0.013320923, -0.037597656, 0.04107666, 0.013954163, 0.041137695, -0.09844971, -0.07672119, -0.07788086, 0.03274536, -0.012496948, -0.033447266, -0.028640747, 0.0082473755, 0.00093364716, -0.03050232, -0.002998352, -0.024246216, -0.043640137, 0.0075263977, 0.0657959, -0.002319336, -0.06982422, -0.069885254, -0.0129852295, 0.005584717, 0.037750244, -0.0033073425, -0.06774902, -0.01096344, -0.12866211, -0.0051612854, 0.0076828003, 0.010620117, 0.011268616, 0.0013380051, -0.006374359, 0.034301758, 0.038360596, 0.009552002, 0.0049438477, 0.0070266724, 0.017333984, 0.03112793, -0.030517578, 0.029312134, 0.013641357, 0.028076172, -0.00017178059, 0.026000977, 0.024246216, -0.0073547363, 0.03756714, -0.015335083, 0.011642456, -0.005317688, 0.045410156, 0.037841797, -0.06121826, -0.018737793, 0.012504578, 0.027374268, 0.046813965, 0.021133423, -0.006587982, 0.0037994385, -0.041748047, -0.023147583, -0.04156494, -0.020431519, 0.047607422, 0.03955078, -0.006996155, -0.008392334, 0.005344391, 0.004550934, -0.024108887, -0.0042495728, -0.021133423, -0.031982422, -0.015731812, 0.010231018, -0.006965637, 0.05316162, 0.06604004, 0.02142334, -0.06329346, 0.058441162, -0.02508545, -0.06549072, 0.03338623, -0.01083374, 0.007106781, -0.010169983, -0.009880066, 0.010131836, 0.006504059, 0.053527832, 0.027023315, -0.0049057007, -0.0023097992, -0.0395813, 0.04031372, -0.0011806488, 0.049316406, -0.01499939, 0.03262329, 0.041809082, 0.0005531311, -0.03201294, -0.011940002, -0.008018494, 0.027267456, 0.014122009, 0.014305115, -0.014541626, -0.0069122314, 0.011131287, 0.081970215, -0.0015335083, 0.0049743652, -0.004928589, 0.0395813, 0.02468872, 0.04232788, 0.013298035, 0.05822754, -0.014884949, 0.028900146, 0.070739746, -0.013076782, -0.012062073, 0.007896423, -0.0093307495, 0.02848816, -0.019500732, -0.03326416, 0.0044136047, -0.047088623, -0.0069007874, -0.050231934, -0.019592285, 0.0013790131, 0.002090454, 0.030639648, -0.025482178, 0.026397705, -0.009063721, -0.019256592, 0.0054092407, -0.005039215, 0.013465881, 0.016815186, -0.05911255, 0.0012607574, 0.04348755, 0.05596924, -0.00023376942, -0.01625061, -0.009422302, 0.021438599, -0.016067505, -0.00027441978, 0.010848999, 0.05722046, 0.028381348, 0.009262085, 0.0068969727, 0.011642456, -0.014526367, 0.08843994, 0.055877686, -0.014877319, 0.04107666, -0.033233643, 0.026046753, 0.028182983, -0.01348114, 0.008598328, 0.029556274, 0.017044067, 0.03186035, -0.025741577, -0.004070282, -0.04067993, 0.02166748, -0.00491333, -0.090148926, 0.004814148, -0.01663208, -0.0027694702, -0.040496826, -0.026565552, -0.0020980835, 0.07525635, -0.019470215, -0.029251099, -0.0077400208, -0.015914917, -0.014297485, -0.015403748, -0.03262329, 0.0041503906, -0.0064353943, 0.026779175, -0.010047913, -0.0670166, -0.05117798, -0.008087158, 0.0077171326, -0.022583008, 0.0071640015, -0.030593872, 0.0049591064, -0.015853882, 0.0036296844, 0.028503418, -0.055023193, -0.0096588135, -0.03189087, 0.043304443, 0.021499634, -0.05355835, -0.0078125, 0.026672363, -0.049041748, -0.010635376, 0.03463745, 0.070617676, -0.055145264, -0.02911377, 0.057495117, 0.0071105957, -0.009384155, 0.04638672, 0.035186768, 0.029663086, -0.030258179, -0.05709839, -0.07519531, -0.007751465, -0.00062417984, 0.0085372925, 0.0491333, -0.045440674, -0.013305664, -0.02607727, -0.011688232, 0.004459381, 0.006340027, -0.0033798218, -0.036895752, 0.009902954, -0.004310608, -0.0037975311, 0.021621704, -0.0017747879, 0.032714844, 0.06878662, 0.021972656, 0.025619507, -0.01574707, 0.055877686, -0.008934021, -0.008331299, -0.02607727, -0.026687622, -0.009231567, 0.02017212, 0.015853882, -0.012916565, -0.030563354, -0.06011963, -0.009376526, 0.037322998, -0.014595032, -0.029785156, 0.01209259, -0.058410645, 0.006034851, -0.02217102, -0.021530151, 0.0284729, -0.0027885437, 0.005847931, 0.00017285347, 0.009986877, -0.05142212, 0.024932861, -0.054748535, -0.070373535, 0.039154053, 0.027740479, -0.08807373, -0.04360962, -0.02268982, -0.05206299, -0.02468872, -0.017501831, 0.05041504, 0.007259369, 0.002922058, 0.028045654, -0.009635925, -0.009376526, -0.006374359, -0.0115737915, 0.00037384033, -0.004798889, 0.0059814453, -0.009902954, 0.011528015, 0.033081055, -0.007003784, -0.00730896, 0.0006699562, -0.022598267, 0.0236969, -0.0061187744, -0.0309906, 0.001584053, 0.006542206, -0.013885498, 0.0022621155, -0.018447876, -0.0023860931, -0.027755737, 0.019546509, -0.020019531, 0.03753662, 0.018188477, 0.016464233, -0.028747559, -0.01991272, 0.027633667, -0.015670776, -0.049560547, -0.000101447105, 0.046966553, 0.018432617, -0.05279541, 0.012054443, -0.0070114136, -0.000279665, 0.008415222, -0.010658264, 0.00040864944, 0.0027942657, -0.001490593, 0.020904541, -0.015991211, -0.014472961, 0.00007355213, 0.0259552, -0.021118164, 0.016189575, -0.04537964, -0.091308594, -0.026550293, 0.00038456917, -0.111083984, -0.034851074, 0.020751953, -0.030853271, -0.0028057098, -0.041229248, 0.040283203, -0.033569336, -0.030670166, -0.003622055, -0.015991211, -0.07147217, -0.027679443, -0.08709717, -0.0115737915, 0.08404541, 0.002620697, 0.038085938, 0.047821045, -0.025146484, -0.043029785, -0.023452759, 0.029434204, 0.009963989, 0.034301758, 0.005470276, -0.0028438568, 0.021331787, -0.02407837, 0.019943237, 0.03225708, -0.014129639, 0.008079529, -0.0008940697, 0.0066184998, 0.06567383, -0.010063171, 0.046905518, 0.002357483, -0.018844604, -0.06335449, 0.022994995, -0.0048332214, -0.016662598, 0.006549835, -0.008300781, -0.014205933, 0.006904602, 0.021392822, 0.038238525, -0.027389526, 0.016967773, 0.038116455, -0.024475098, -0.018295288, -0.018829346, 0.013175964, 0.019866943, -0.0030727386, 0.006351471, -0.011726379, 0.013511658, -0.016952515, -0.028701782, 0.0018672943, 0.028717041, -0.03427124, 0.0075683594, -0.08251953, -0.016052246, -0.043395996, 0.016952515, -0.0077934265, 0.037384033, 0.045715332, -0.02407837, -0.015716553, -0.0023994446, 0.055725098, -0.0050239563, -0.0069007874, -0.074035645, 0.026138306, -0.021011353, -0.03289795, -0.04321289, 0.008323669, 0.013061523, 0.036468506, -0.012016296, -0.012557983, -0.0014810562, 0.03652954, 0.066223145, 0.030578613, 0.0016746521, -0.0463562, -0.008743286, -0.015975952, -0.041290283, 0.03933716, -0.017852783, 0.015792847, -0.014160156, 0.036987305, -0.038879395, 0.009269714, 0.01675415, 0.006252289, -0.046661377, 0.061462402, -0.03225708, 0.033843994, 0.007896423, -0.0065727234, 0.012908936, 0.0056991577, -0.024734497, -0.0063095093, 0.02798462, 0.022918701, 0.04623413, 0.008102417, 0.03466797, -0.004146576, 0.004600525, 0.0034561157, -0.0068473816, -0.0003976822, 0.035827637, -0.003047943, 0.021469116, -0.035827637, -0.018096924, 0.008895874, -0.001074791, 0.054382324, -0.048553467, 0.023956299, -0.039215088, 0.035064697, 0.014846802, -0.0141067505, 0.041870117, 0.002614975, 0.022521973, -0.048553467, -0.023620605, 0.020858765, 0.0023880005, -0.024154663, -0.004764557, 0.0007390976, 0.024749756, 0.031311035, 0.050750732, 0.016113281, -0.0146484375, -0.016357422, -0.0037670135, -0.0028305054, -0.025665283, -0.074035645, -0.010292053, 0.005821228, 0.014472961, -0.012901306, 0.04348755, -0.06414795, -0.008155823, -0.028015137, -0.02230835, 0.02268982, -0.07910156, 0.013404846, 0.05697632, 0.027908325, 0.031188965, -0.023971558, 0.0055656433, 0.052520752, 0.04336548, 0.010826111, 0.014961243, 0.029678345, -0.043670654, 0.030715942, 0.003074646, 0.028030396, 0.009559631, 0.0070114136, 0.012382507, 0.0039405823, -0.049987793, 0.023712158, 0.013015747, -0.017562866, -0.013420105, -0.038970947, 0.022064209, 0.013137817, -0.006843567, 0.02255249, -0.0068893433, -0.043273926, -0.022583008, 0.010437012, -0.051483154, -0.011291504, -0.010574341, -0.031066895, -0.016433716, 0.01071167, -0.033081055, 0.01651001, 0.02281189, -0.006401062, -0.014381409, 0.008880615, 0.046691895, -0.04333496, 0.021713257, -0.008552551, 0.018112183, 0.050354004, 0.023239136, -0.014343262, 0.0026474, -0.004169464, -0.0579834, -0.020904541, 0.024627686, 0.014961243, -0.00315094, 0.016220093, 0.019119263, 0.010353088, -0.023513794, 0.029327393, -0.024917603, 0.013916016, 0.053985596, -0.0021419525, 0.0012207031, -0.011405945, 0.00869751, -0.0027885437, 0.0011310577, 0.0049819946, -0.05206299, 0.025924683, -0.005504608, 0.033843994, -0.040618896, -0.049865723, -0.003686905, 0.020599365, 0.008460999, -0.029266357, 0.039520264, 0.040252686, -0.03741455, 0.012466431, 0.004146576, 0.048065186, -0.046447754, -0.049804688, -0.0013685226, 0.0017766953, -0.0010766983, 0.052642822, -0.017547607, -0.037506104, -0.020858765, -0.03125, -0.024749756, 0.029434204, 0.02432251, 0.010620117, 0.03543091, -0.0021629333, 0.049346924, -0.010185242, -0.015029907, -0.027420044, 0.015312195, 0.007381439, -0.016815186, -0.004711151, -0.008758545, -0.0041542053, -0.029510498, 0.0048599243, 0.03036499, -0.006298065, 0.02722168, -0.045074463, -0.009613037, -0.00081062317, -0.0435791, 0.031234741, -0.015052795, -0.014915466, 0.035308838, -0.032836914, 0.05935669, 0.009506226, 0.05456543, 0.033599854, 0.011459351, 0.02067566, 0.0024490356, -0.0109939575, -0.046081543, -0.006008148, -0.0050735474, -0.002735138, -0.054748535, -0.0035800934, -0.07928467, 0.07550049, -0.023101807, 0.012168884, -0.0036354065, 0.006046295, 0.012588501, -0.0042800903, 0.021713257, -0.028076172, 0.038879395, -0.0024204254, 0.00894165, -0.005290985, -0.014549255, -0.0053596497, 0.028640747, 0.0061187744, -0.0049972534, -0.025558472, -0.02217102, 0.016937256, 0.017242432, 0.00029945374, -0.046447754, -0.001876831, -0.058410645, 0.0178833, -0.008163452, 0.051513672, 0.035949707, -0.0040397644, 0.0023288727, -0.008613586, -0.029296875, -0.029403687, -0.028686523, 0.005695343, 0.012542725, -0.059387207, 0.028656006, -0.010688782, -0.024841309, -0.0050621033, 0.07055664, 0.008377075, -0.055999756, -0.025375366, 0.0066871643, 0.027893066, 0.011253357, 0.021133423, -0.028701782, -0.00054740906, 0.0063591003, 0.03781128, 0.0155181885, 0.03366089, -0.024475098, 0.03390503, -0.016448975, -0.015457153, 0.023513794, -0.005794525, 0.013465881, 0.023971558, -0.020492554, 0.031402588, -0.044067383, -0.039245605, 0.0059776306, -0.0025463104, -0.074401855, -0.036499023, 0.06304932, 0.021194458, 0.056427002, 0.073913574, 0.03857422, -0.005493164, -0.008880615, -0.06237793, 0.007522583, 0.018798828, -0.00983429, 0.029586792, -0.056915283, -0.047698975, 0.043395996, -0.026947021, 0.10614014, -0.048339844, -0.010147095, -0.041290283, 0.064086914, -0.01474762, -0.040405273, -0.026931763, -0.013687134, -0.01374054, 0.014312744, 0.021469116, -0.059326172, -0.019805908, -0.00019860268, -0.0069389343, -0.00957489, 0.011886597, 0.029891968, -0.03414917, -0.080200195, -0.003774643, -0.021697998, 0.038726807, -0.043670654, -0.0031414032, -0.01966858, 0.013381958, 0.006290436, -0.03765869, -0.030197144, -0.011077881, -0.030395508, -0.004737854, -0.0045700073, 0.01574707, -0.02243042, -0.043823242, -0.013328552, 0.006252289, -0.04083252, 0.022644043, 0.027572632, -0.034454346, -0.054260254, -0.015113831, -0.014335632, 0.03756714, -0.0053977966, -0.022659302, 0.050201416, -0.0034103394, -0.03717041, 0.013923645, -0.0038433075, 0.031036377, -0.013748169, -0.044799805, 0.0045204163, 0.024032593, 0.051361084, -0.0463562, -0.019561768, 0.013900757, -0.007549286, -0.017333984, 0.009552002, 0.00969696, 0.005748749, 0.024978638, 0.027404785, 0.009719849, -0.047698975, 0.018676758, -0.011642456, 0.028884888, 0.058807373, -0.007575989, 0.014480591, 0.014419556, -0.008331299, -0.009963989, 0.030822754, -0.030151367, 0.0004374981, 0.0049362183, 0.01576233, -0.027435303, -0.014411926, -0.0552063, 0.02218628, -0.010879517, 0.0051460266, -0.015289307, 0.03274536, -0.034179688, 0.01927185, -0.01020813, -0.03970337, 0.03741455, 0.008888245, 0.026992798, -0.00075244904, 0.016540527, -0.004486084, -0.009429932, -0.010360718, 0.013267517, 0.009475708, -0.002790451, -0.058166504, 0.0060043335, -0.08972168, -0.01084137, -0.037078857, -0.012832642, 0.04397583, -0.013061523, -0.008033752, -0.013954163, -0.042938232, -0.0040130615, 0.0063972473, 0.00021970272, -0.018447876, -0.06317139, -0.03427124, 0.04055786, -0.018676758 ], "summary": [ -0.041656494, -0.034362793, -0.035888672, -0.019744873, -0.066711426, -0.0015983582, -0.0769043, 0.0039482117, -0.012557983, -0.005531311, -0.00983429, -0.005531311, 0.012069702, -0.045166016, 0.03366089, -0.0052833557, -0.0158844, 0.024887085, -0.03161621, -0.047943115, 0.0037975311, -0.04827881, -0.03567505, -0.018508911, 0.034088135, -0.051330566, -0.0059394836, 0.030639648, 0.013191223, 0.036956787, 0.010185242, -0.033843994, 0.010795593, 0.02684021, -0.021148682, 0.010314941, -0.036102295, 0.009727478, 0.0047340393, 0.028442383, 0.03652954, -0.019470215, -0.00043964386, -0.03274536, -0.02784729, 0.044677734, -0.035888672, -0.030563354, 0.03250122, 0.03692627, -0.0020179749, 0.009811401, -0.0030212402, 0.042663574, -0.029220581, -0.019500732, -0.018539429, 0.010910034, 0.004119873, 0.044311523, 0.014602661, 0.013511658, 0.00894928, -0.017333984, 0.0021839142, -0.006931305, 0.0024108887, -0.020828247, 0.070617676, 0.03604126, -0.015342712, 0.019866943, 0.0024909973, -0.049041748, 0.0063438416, 0.05456543, -0.0074653625, 0.031402588, 0.013175964, 0.0010585785, 0.032592773, 0.006374359, 0.0075302124, -0.024093628, 0.0070648193, -0.022460938, -0.0073623657, -0.029251099, -0.0056495667, -0.029785156, -0.011054993, -0.025756836, -0.033477783, 0.045959473, 0.030929565, -0.050628662, 0.011009216, 0.010437012, -0.030792236, -0.04321289, 0.017608643, -0.019638062, -0.026535034, -0.0014123917, -0.006412506, 0.054016113, -0.0016050339, -0.051849365, -0.0077819824, 0.0035171509, 0.00027108192, 0.0036468506, 0.0046310425, -0.054229736, 0.018234253, 0.053588867, 0.01373291, 0.051330566, 0.020523071, 0.058654785, -0.011245728, 0.0063705444, 0.006298065, 0.039245605, 0.005809784, 0.017333984, 0.014533997, -0.011642456, -0.012458801, 0.012046814, -0.0026054382, 0.036376953, -0.035369873, -0.04144287, -0.06542969, -0.0019464493, -0.0018014908, -0.023544312, -0.029968262, -0.0041275024, -0.0015287399, -0.041534424, -0.016067505, -0.0102005005, -0.03930664, 0.027786255, 0.0335083, 0.00409317, -0.04949951, -0.04827881, 0.0014095306, -0.0121154785, 0.020706177, -0.026992798, -0.009559631, -0.05166626, -0.07446289, 0.00067949295, 0.039764404, 0.028320312, -0.001750946, -0.012771606, 0.012107849, 0.051818848, 0.020355225, 0.030441284, 0.00052690506, -0.004459381, 0.013549805, 0.006374359, -0.002445221, -0.004436493, 0.022445679, 0.0023345947, -0.007698059, 0.022521973, -0.007797241, 0.048858643, 0.0035305023, -0.0098724365, 0.021194458, -0.03353882, 0.058380127, 0.00674057, -0.027313232, -0.0362854, 0.017227173, 0.04727173, 0.04788208, 0.028533936, 0.017715454, -0.053497314, -0.009246826, -0.011627197, -0.043304443, -0.005508423, -0.0043258667, 0.028793335, -0.027236938, 0.005970001, 0.06359863, 0.005836487, -0.0034561157, -0.054840088, -0.06713867, -0.017028809, -0.008331299, 0.024627686, 0.030944824, 0.05670166, 0.021881104, 0.023330688, -0.05883789, 0.08465576, -0.044189453, -0.063964844, 0.01058197, -0.04397583, 0.005104065, -0.027069092, 0.018798828, 0.06335449, -0.0087890625, 0.03488159, 0.009552002, -0.021835327, -0.009941101, 0.0019111633, 0.034820557, -0.01676941, 0.051971436, -0.013931274, 0.014381409, 0.03729248, -0.010719299, -0.023803711, -0.009887695, -0.06311035, 0.027267456, 0.052886963, 0.041290283, 0.045318604, -0.025100708, -0.028533936, 0.051513672, 0.0012197495, 0.019073486, -0.04360962, 0.0064086914, 0.012802124, -0.0046424866, -0.017547607, 0.043426514, -0.023635864, -0.015274048, 0.054534912, -0.040374756, -0.014015198, 0.0034427643, -0.031707764, 0.017684937, -0.04449463, 0.0030918121, -0.024383545, -0.020904541, -0.0725708, -0.031799316, -0.04043579, 0.03186035, -0.071899414, 0.01713562, -0.028671265, 0.0077552795, -0.064819336, -0.05987549, 0.026153564, -0.0011482239, 0.036621094, 0.027511597, -0.052246094, -0.012428284, 0.008117676, 0.018325806, -0.012550354, 0.0047798157, -0.025680542, 0.021759033, -0.024932861, 0.050689697, 0.06555176, 0.060028076, 0.022781372, 0.010398865, 0.043029785, -0.022003174, -0.007255554, 0.026260376, 0.0028514862, 0.010169983, -0.025756836, 0.028747559, 0.04840088, -0.017745972, 0.0002039671, 0.02268982, 0.026489258, 0.016738892, 0.03692627, 0.021240234, -0.008987427, -0.030029297, 0.0037574768, 0.01737976, -0.054840088, 0.004306793, 0.007820129, -0.029342651, 0.00894928, -0.041870117, 0.02420044, 0.12524414, -0.04559326, -0.00793457, 0.0025806427, -0.04272461, -0.03982544, 0.04208374, -0.037963867, 0.021972656, -0.01737976, -0.03677368, -0.034179688, -0.041290283, -0.007724762, 0.006084442, -0.01259613, -0.0062026978, 0.009437561, -0.029708862, -0.005794525, -0.029281616, -0.018081665, 0.007972717, -0.048309326, -0.01309967, 0.028564453, 0.046295166, 0.0077781677, -0.024154663, 0.020980835, -0.021102905, -0.045715332, 0.019317627, 0.0435791, 0.030059814, -0.05505371, -0.023239136, 0.0026493073, -0.05871582, -0.05960083, 0.03805542, 0.05126953, 0.024658203, -0.004234314, -0.066101074, -0.05142212, 0.019683838, 0.009246826, 0.016616821, 0.023162842, 0.03262329, 0.02418518, -0.05783081, -0.032318115, -0.048858643, -0.016464233, 0.05038452, -0.013320923, 0.04623413, 0.039764404, 0.025985718, 0.034179688, 0.0028057098, 0.008544922, 0.080078125, 0.026519775, 0.042419434, -0.014389038, 0.044921875, -0.01914978, -0.008102417, -0.051818848, 0.0049476624, -0.017868042, 0.0064315796, -0.007335663, -0.012519836, 0.040039062, -0.011924744, -0.01751709, 0.025177002, 0.0107040405, 0.017852783, 0.0024852753, -0.02949524, 0.039764404, -0.01171875, 0.005367279, 0.030578613, -0.09094238, 0.020721436, -0.04699707, -0.006351471, -0.070617676, -0.014305115, -0.04852295, -0.0064811707, 0.029266357, -0.005001068, -0.064208984, -0.04119873, 0.055633545, -0.016906738, -0.033996582, 0.0067634583, 0.051239014, -0.024093628, -0.012771606, 0.019104004, 0.023895264, -0.0017910004, 0.0109939575, 0.005580902, 0.01121521, -0.02281189, 0.0013008118, -0.026489258, -0.0519104, 0.020431519, -0.04824829, 0.018188477, -0.0070533752, -0.06756592, 0.00010871887, -0.0028438568, -0.03692627, -0.021469116, -0.021591187, -0.0041389465, 0.029907227, -0.007282257, -0.0061454773, 0.022003174, 0.03488159, -0.021514893, 0.039398193, -0.018661499, 0.034240723, 0.029891968, -0.029953003, 0.042633057, -0.001496315, -0.028152466, 0.014160156, 0.03918457, 0.007091522, -0.093688965, 0.029586792, -0.006958008, -0.019332886, 0.03488159, -0.018249512, -0.012458801, 0.00806427, 0.0041046143, -0.0006828308, 0.009338379, 0.0041046143, 0.0033168793, -0.012802124, -0.059814453, 0.041046143, -0.09197998, -0.060913086, -0.054016113, 0.005958557, -0.06188965, -0.074157715, 0.024154663, 0.026550293, 0.010269165, -0.008964539, 0.059539795, -0.02230835, 0.00009095669, 0.0032787323, -0.015640259, 0.02619934, -0.011054993, -0.08319092, 0.0340271, 0.014282227, -0.025421143, 0.04824829, 0.0051994324, -0.001244545, 0.007167816, 0.0035533905, 0.020080566, -0.0024337769, 0.02381897, -0.016281128, -0.009864807, -0.016174316, -0.00020778179, 0.016052246, 0.03152466, -0.0385437, 0.022384644, -0.009552002, 0.053100586, 0.091796875, -0.019943237, 0.009246826, -0.01651001, 0.0038490295, -0.053253174, 0.004676819, -0.015220642, -0.011726379, 0.04650879, 0.029342651, -0.037994385, -0.02279663, 0.01689148, -0.013160706, -0.052124023, -0.007144928, 0.028274536, 0.017715454, -0.03189087, -0.035491943, 0.001376152, 0.06323242, -0.024719238, 0.012741089, -0.04522705, 0.013641357, -0.029312134, -0.022033691, 0.008735657, 0.01663208, -0.049224854, -0.008155823, -0.023849487, -0.0042495728, -0.051727295, 0.03277588, 0.0082473755, 0.006717682, 0.031677246, -0.013626099, 0.021697998, -0.036834717, 0.053741455, 0.012298584, -0.024276733, -0.08282471, 0.0019683838, -0.03366089, -0.018753052, -0.044036865, -0.017028809, 0.008773804, -0.042419434, 0.013999939, -0.011138916, 0.0015821457, 0.0046157837, 0.015731812, 0.011627197, 0.020492554, -0.007575989, -0.050720215, -0.01209259, 0.00071907043, 0.027282715, 0.011199951, 0.01008606, 0.0126953125, -0.002292633, -0.02947998, -0.004623413, 0.017791748, 0.009399414, -0.009048462, 0.055755615, -0.04699707, 0.009300232, -0.010223389, 0.006225586, -0.0062675476, -0.00050735474, 0.0062942505, 0.012390137, 0.002696991, -0.024627686, 0.101135254, -0.01928711, -0.025436401, -0.0143966675, -0.008377075, -0.0061836243, -0.0011339188, -0.024719238, 0.043914795, -0.00504303, 0.024551392, 0.019256592, 0.0034542084, 0.02166748, -0.01966858, 0.013931274, -0.010177612, -0.030288696, -0.033569336, 0.010902405, 0.008422852, -0.016403198, 0.018600464, 0.027374268, -0.007385254, -0.01763916, -0.0262146, 0.015670776, 0.01876831, -0.0071258545, -0.03741455, -0.0073661804, 0.040161133, 0.032043457, 0.010520935, -0.007659912, -0.001414299, -0.013534546, 0.0004553795, 0.025665283, -0.019866943, -0.037384033, -0.053375244, -0.004360199, 0.017028809, 0.011520386, 0.04348755, 0.009033203, 0.0055007935, -0.0124053955, -0.026809692, 0.007926941, -0.059814453, -0.014518738, 0.014152527, -0.0256958, 0.007080078, 0.04888916, -0.029205322, -0.0007920265, 0.020996094, -0.02279663, 0.0016746521, -0.0051879883, -0.052490234, 0.037506104, -0.0021648407, 0.029418945, 0.025268555, -0.032348633, 0.0055503845, -0.0069465637, -0.0033359528, -0.020080566, -0.023040771, 0.018661499, -0.03515625, 0.005252838, 0.03567505, 0.04147339, 0.0017747879, -0.0013780594, 0.038360596, -0.044158936, -0.027267456, 0.025268555, -0.0054016113, -0.04119873, -0.006046295, 0.00077676773, 0.020141602, -0.015625, -0.054626465, 0.01235199, 0.037139893, -0.011154175, 0.01663208, -0.022583008, 0.031097412, -0.013725281, 0.026046753, -0.01399231, 0.010299683, 0.0019664764, 0.027328491, -0.022888184, -0.0006117821, -0.04446411, -0.041625977, -0.043823242, 0.02166748, 0.033599854, 0.043518066, 0.023406982, 0.049957275, 0.020065308, -0.02633667, 0.035339355, -0.0463562, 0.010658264, 0.03970337, -0.03262329, -0.050567627, 0.024368286, -0.010231018, -0.032073975, 0.009765625, 0.00932312, -0.05883789, 0.0546875, -0.004634857, 0.021209717, -0.041259766, -0.019699097, -0.0033512115, 0.021987915, -0.021759033, -0.0093307495, 0.028564453, 0.0063056946, -0.04135132, 0.021530151, 0.008842468, 0.02696228, -0.010429382, -0.055541992, 0.0027446747, 0.015365601, -0.001036644, -0.009780884, 0.005432129, -0.04119873, 0.007873535, -0.012771606, 0.008277893, -0.0039253235, 0.0052948, 0.011054993, 0.034454346, 0.001868248, 0.01878357, -0.01663208, -0.010658264, -0.029907227, 0.014053345, -0.027160645, -0.019073486, 0.037322998, -0.0018510818, -0.04031372, 0.0054893494, -0.006893158, 0.029891968, 0.0014801025, 0.03201294, 0.011016846, -0.014968872, -0.020980835, -0.006034851, 0.027816772, 0.0357666, -0.006401062, 0.030151367, 0.021713257, 0.029724121, 0.007686615, 0.037109375, 0.0035133362, 0.0095825195, 0.03060913, 0.0036849976, -0.015853882, -0.02420044, 0.033325195, 0.022537231, -0.033569336, -0.05444336, -0.036956787, -0.0289917, 0.08831787, -0.050720215, -0.021148682, 0.018569946, -0.002632141, -0.012084961, -0.012962341, -0.029953003, 0.00082302094, -0.0069236755, -0.031982422, -0.0049972534, 0.011787415, -0.00082063675, -0.015556335, 0.0345459, 0.0031051636, 0.036499023, -0.028015137, 0.03555298, 0.04751587, -0.038726807, -0.06112671, -0.061645508, 0.058380127, -0.05505371, -0.01878357, 0.01486969, 0.045959473, -0.022720337, -0.035095215, 0.023834229, 0.0047416687, -0.034576416, 0.018661499, -0.017105103, 0.030532837, -0.020553589, 0.019195557, 0.0051727295, 0.028823853, -0.031433105, 0.04071045, 0.059051514, 0.009101868, -0.033599854, -0.0021076202, -0.008674622, -0.008369446, 0.006958008, 0.010353088, -0.021530151, -0.005908966, -0.0046463013, 0.009269714, 0.029510498, 0.045043945, -0.037353516, 0.024734497, 0.0158844, -0.010765076, 0.012741089, -0.021331787, -0.0013990402, 0.023010254, 0.038513184, 0.05038452, -0.03338623, -0.026565552, 0.011314392, 0.02218628, -0.066223145, -0.020629883, 0.04437256, 0.037261963, 0.0579834, 0.059692383, -0.0023059845, 0.010719299, 0.04660034, -0.023101807, -0.0027599335, -0.029403687, 0.02204895, 0.0020885468, -0.051208496, -0.0008234978, 0.015113831, -0.01007843, 0.0970459, -0.053375244, 0.015106201, -0.04272461, 0.045776367, -0.07531738, -0.025009155, -0.01725769, -0.023635864, -0.020812988, 0.01914978, 0.02468872, -0.049194336, -0.02041626, -0.0206604, -0.011665344, -0.026885986, 0.010238647, 0.052642822, -0.008369446, -0.04309082, -0.014160156, 0.012504578, 0.02746582, -0.039642334, -0.020309448, 0.030471802, 0.013427734, 0.028961182, -0.078186035, -0.05380249, -0.013313293, 0.04598999, 0.0037193298, -0.003440857, 0.02810669, -0.017822266, -0.095825195, -0.0005068779, -0.00036001205, -0.05239868, 0.035614014, 0.05621338, -0.016235352, -0.05117798, 0.0034942627, -0.0060806274, 0.05606079, -0.030593872, -0.020828247, 0.07110596, 0.0072746277, -0.033996582, 0.03363037, -0.020584106, -0.0104599, -0.018676758, -0.024810791, -0.028381348, 0.015266418, 0.05407715, -0.022323608, -0.031799316, 0.023757935, -0.0032997131, -0.02331543, -0.024658203, -0.050079346, -0.003768921, 0.07647705, 0.07897949, 0.024902344, -0.041534424, 0.07745361, 0.013587952, 0.013343811, 0.018005371, -0.01965332, 0.01675415, -0.003534317, -0.00983429, -0.016998291, 0.032226562, -0.023773193, -0.02720642, 0.0021572113, -0.02003479, -0.026931763, -0.019882202, -0.010467529, -0.008522034, -0.016708374, -0.054718018, -0.012138367, 0.011039734, -0.07019043, -0.042785645, -0.033721924, 0.018127441, -0.0015897751, -0.028152466, 0.013282776, -0.016174316, 0.03125, 0.022384644, -0.0032520294, -0.0015563965, 0.014198303, 0.02268982, -0.010093689, -0.025314331, 0.0042648315, -0.07342529, 0.011062622, -0.07354736, -0.027679443, 0.03024292, 0.012382507, -0.019180298, 0.04449463, -0.03753662, 0.026748657, 0.005897522, -0.016708374, 0.03036499, -0.026977539, -0.010498047, -0.02708435, 0.0028705597 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07635v1
Past as a Guide: Leveraging Retrospective Learning for Python Code Completion
Seunggyoon Shin, Seunggyu Chang, Sungjoon Choi
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL
This work presents Past as a Guide (PaG), a simple approach for Large Language Models (LLMs) to improve the coding capabilities by integrating the past history with interactive and iterative code refinements. To be specific, inspired by human cognitive processes, the proposed method enables LLMs to utilize previous programming and debugging experiences to enhance the Python code completion tasks. The framework facilitates LLMs to iteratively refine the Python code based on previous execution and debugging results and optimize learning and reasoning capabilities. The proposed methodology achieved a 92\% pass@1 on HumanEval, demonstrating the potential to advance the field by leveraging retrospection from past experiences and interactive and iterative refinement processes without external correctness indicators.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07635v1
2023-11-13T14:40:33
2023-11-13T14:40:33
{ "title": [ -0.0036201477, -0.022598267, -0.057434082, -0.09277344, 0.0021438599, -0.0107803345, -0.035614014, 0.04736328, 0.037261963, 0.03543091, -0.031555176, 0.003686905, -0.009857178, -0.0069084167, -0.07366943, -0.0104599, -0.0034217834, 0.01902771, -0.019821167, -0.040893555, -0.019210815, -0.050964355, 0.045013428, 0.007965088, 0.020523071, -0.018814087, -0.036346436, 0.010475159, -0.031188965, -0.020507812, -0.0043144226, 0.012260437, 0.03173828, 0.014694214, -0.008049011, 0.017471313, -0.061309814, 0.03765869, 0.0124435425, -0.0048599243, 0.01687622, -0.00894165, -0.077697754, -0.03878784, -0.075927734, 0.017028809, -0.06951904, 0.013549805, -0.0047836304, 0.022460938, -0.0030841827, 0.023040771, -0.007095337, 0.017944336, 0.00016641617, -0.04953003, -0.031585693, 0.019470215, 0.049804688, 0.05267334, 0.0038414001, -0.04638672, 0.008026123, -0.049468994, -0.004447937, -0.028625488, 0.0048561096, 0.028671265, 0.062438965, 0.017913818, -0.023620605, 0.02053833, 0.002067566, 0.012062073, -0.008148193, -0.021621704, 0.07928467, 0.04559326, 0.0050697327, 0.013534546, 0.018508911, 0.003484726, 0.014663696, -0.033325195, 0.023483276, -0.0345459, -0.008094788, -0.0054359436, -0.045074463, -0.057037354, -0.0033607483, -0.042388916, -0.03439331, -0.0052452087, 0.00010031462, -0.045715332, 0.022216797, 0.018157959, 0.0053634644, -0.021865845, 0.0126571655, 0.003704071, -0.04449463, -0.010810852, 0.006214142, 0.025985718, -0.022705078, -0.0019702911, 0.013587952, 0.049438477, -0.02128601, 0.002483368, -0.000895977, -0.014274597, 0.0112838745, 0.017745972, -0.016464233, 0.023513794, 0.0154800415, 0.022903442, 0.0013418198, -0.0006275177, 0.0025577545, -0.022521973, 0.012245178, -0.016738892, -0.043304443, -0.00045013428, 0.017715454, 0.0061302185, 0.0045547485, 0.051208496, -0.08691406, -0.0993042, -0.08215332, 0.037353516, -0.042175293, 0.006313324, -0.03213501, 0.02142334, -0.009674072, -0.017456055, 0.040740967, -0.024627686, 0.03744507, -0.006275177, 0.029647827, 0.018997192, -0.00062942505, -0.030334473, 0.017471313, 0.0074653625, 0.025878906, -0.016235352, -0.062347412, -0.024749756, -0.12609863, 0.0049095154, 0.037078857, 0.008743286, 0.03869629, -0.015899658, -0.031280518, 0.014015198, 0.0017108917, 0.0028686523, 0.002609253, 0.01096344, 0.011734009, 0.029006958, -0.036315918, -0.009239197, 0.041381836, -0.021728516, -0.015792847, 0.028381348, 0.03036499, -0.0054779053, 0.005153656, 0.0002641678, 0.009284973, -0.021759033, -0.005329132, 0.04006958, -0.06488037, -0.033447266, 0.0044555664, 0.0062332153, 0.056488037, -0.00365448, 0.013366699, 0.010902405, -0.04156494, -0.037353516, -0.04171753, 0.0048828125, 0.02168274, 0.042053223, -0.0047569275, 0.014160156, -0.0099105835, 0.013717651, -0.014343262, 0.0075035095, 0.0047416687, -0.011878967, -0.0137786865, 0.01777649, -0.056274414, 0.023468018, 0.0690918, 0.0068359375, -0.040008545, 0.021194458, -0.0015125275, -0.07659912, 0.001701355, 0.027130127, 0.017440796, 0.009811401, -0.0005378723, -0.01687622, 0.02418518, -0.00024271011, -0.0010128021, -0.012130737, -0.013069153, -0.0017461777, -0.0013923645, 0.028121948, 0.039001465, -0.01689148, 0.013557434, 0.00856781, -0.021118164, -0.037750244, -0.027816772, -0.07873535, 0.025039673, 0.04547119, -0.0050621033, 0.009513855, -0.013839722, 0.027816772, 0.0519104, -0.0029335022, 0.0056266785, 0.021087646, 0.007144928, 0.0075683594, 0.03942871, 0.009361267, 0.034820557, -0.0058250427, 0.000790596, 0.04345703, -0.021011353, -0.00017499924, 0.0066986084, -0.011619568, 0.006454468, -0.027435303, 0.004673004, -0.013381958, -0.05480957, 0.015686035, -0.023513794, 0.0119018555, -0.012634277, -0.0068626404, 0.035125732, 0.026000977, 0.0042037964, 0.011108398, 0.049804688, -0.014305115, -0.014083862, -0.0063285828, 0.028518677, -0.026123047, 0.01449585, 0.018096924, 0.052337646, -0.005924225, 0.030380249, -0.009223938, 0.009841919, 0.0003631115, 0.02078247, 0.019760132, 0.042510986, 0.039245605, 0.0003604889, 0.0287323, 0.015548706, -0.011375427, 0.08465576, 0.080444336, -0.032409668, 0.03778076, -0.0635376, 0.008651733, 0.027435303, -0.040985107, 0.0014324188, 0.03652954, 0.045837402, -0.0107421875, -0.033355713, 0.01423645, -0.039367676, -0.00554657, 0.01574707, 0.06677246, -0.080200195, -0.082336426, -0.0037670135, -0.011512756, -0.06298828, -0.03390503, 0.07702637, -0.023406982, -0.013946533, -0.019866943, -0.021133423, -0.016616821, -0.025604248, -0.020248413, 0.03955078, 0.009811401, -0.009986877, -0.009628296, -0.10467529, -0.07397461, -0.00198555, 0.017471313, -0.030761719, 0.025970459, -0.030715942, 0.016784668, -0.016235352, -0.040100098, 0.028411865, -0.053222656, 0.0003786087, -0.06921387, 0.0060768127, -0.010818481, -0.023345947, -0.0018014908, 0.033721924, -0.0028362274, -0.0035190582, 0.027755737, 0.053100586, -0.003850937, -0.017425537, 0.024993896, 0.019973755, -0.00894928, 0.04800415, 0.029510498, 0.019760132, -0.059814453, -0.04208374, -0.039794922, 0.0025405884, -0.0011692047, -0.0022239685, 0.030349731, -0.047851562, -0.027236938, -0.022384644, 0.006580353, 0.049804688, 0.027542114, 0.056427002, -0.0071868896, -0.032684326, 0.009124756, 0.011024475, 0.01651001, -0.041259766, -0.04446411, 0.05215454, 0.006668091, -0.01121521, 0.02545166, 0.0017786026, -0.00019991398, -0.0181427, 0.015853882, -0.06549072, 0.009437561, 0.027267456, -0.0031318665, -0.00088882446, -0.010429382, -0.11431885, -0.01474762, 0.017303467, 0.014724731, -0.0052719116, 0.01701355, -0.04901123, 0.00018250942, -0.008834839, -0.02381897, 0.018585205, 0.033111572, 0.02331543, -0.020339966, 0.016418457, -0.020736694, 0.0027561188, -0.046295166, -0.11871338, 0.04626465, -0.059631348, -0.0082473755, 0.012794495, -0.015991211, -0.0385437, -0.015045166, 0.0090408325, 0.008651733, 0.058288574, 0.009864807, 0.03262329, -0.0041160583, 0.016708374, -0.036712646, -0.021850586, -0.01461792, 0.0005559921, 0.041870117, -0.0026416779, 0.027145386, -0.00055885315, -0.013336182, -0.02015686, 0.0047340393, 0.0017471313, 0.0077667236, -0.0076560974, -0.03366089, 0.010528564, 0.006427765, -0.013954163, 0.033172607, -0.027359009, -0.010467529, -0.042175293, 0.010597229, -0.035125732, 0.066345215, 0.026931763, 0.0068893433, -0.013870239, -0.041381836, -0.024414062, -0.0154800415, -0.030548096, -0.01737976, 0.012367249, 0.008049011, -0.005493164, 0.0023899078, -0.053894043, 0.028335571, 0.005306244, -0.010635376, 0.011833191, 0.015060425, 0.008621216, 0.014656067, -0.0146484375, 0.0043907166, -0.028015137, 0.015472412, -0.0035648346, 0.003250122, -0.005657196, -0.05203247, 0.004486084, -0.0006132126, -0.07659912, -0.024597168, 0.02961731, -0.020431519, 0.00068569183, -0.050201416, 0.04425049, -0.01828003, -0.0028686523, -0.012016296, -0.013641357, 0.0021190643, 0.00674057, -0.049041748, -0.015594482, 0.06463623, -0.020935059, 0.0033016205, 0.039001465, 0.001042366, 0.00039100647, -0.008987427, 0.024642944, 0.032348633, 0.034057617, -0.00166893, -0.022018433, 0.042114258, -0.012428284, 0.017456055, 0.049102783, 0.045440674, 0.0036087036, -0.0044517517, -0.014328003, 0.01727295, -0.048858643, 0.058258057, 0.023391724, -0.013931274, -0.08874512, 0.034484863, -0.007633209, 0.0062561035, 0.018478394, 0.0072364807, -0.004348755, -0.012763977, 0.020843506, 0.02029419, -0.012901306, -0.0015649796, 0.03250122, -0.0024909973, -0.0068473816, 0.0010032654, 0.006374359, 0.030426025, -0.018829346, 0.04736328, -0.028518677, 0.04586792, -0.00033068657, -0.020523071, -0.0068206787, 0.010627747, -0.049804688, -0.017425537, -0.059173584, -0.004711151, -0.034057617, 0.031555176, -0.008544922, 0.006008148, 0.024337769, 0.0025539398, -0.022476196, -0.010192871, 0.023635864, -0.0096206665, 0.012008667, -0.037353516, 0.0029830933, -0.0045661926, -0.08099365, -0.03970337, -0.040008545, -0.0049934387, 0.03375244, -0.000066399574, -0.023605347, 0.01953125, 0.01977539, 0.08935547, 0.05947876, 0.0075950623, -0.06088257, 0.066467285, -0.010215759, -0.02357483, 0.014724731, -0.008255005, 0.006793976, -0.014213562, 0.013801575, -0.010261536, -0.022735596, -0.034729004, 0.0158844, -0.004135132, 0.013198853, 0.0015048981, 0.039154053, 0.014228821, -0.011642456, 0.03753662, 0.0085372925, -0.015960693, 0.0058555603, 0.029907227, 0.01826477, 0.004337311, 0.046295166, 0.0579834, 0.0022220612, -0.012329102, -0.0051994324, 0.019592285, 0.022064209, -0.026855469, -0.0037269592, 0.009429932, -0.0317688, 0.009422302, -0.00009828806, -0.021209717, 0.044769287, -0.03463745, 0.03491211, -0.019577026, 0.0065727234, 0.014503479, -0.0019435883, 0.020599365, 0.0060920715, 0.01739502, -0.043060303, -0.056732178, 0.000105917454, 0.062194824, -0.019729614, 0.009414673, -0.016296387, -0.017837524, 0.021255493, 0.043548584, 0.03201294, -0.0019130707, -0.0206604, -0.007881165, 0.0099487305, -0.018997192, -0.07800293, -0.011962891, -0.042999268, 0.019119263, -0.025863647, 0.04006958, -0.04876709, -0.0045318604, -0.017440796, -0.012458801, 0.006351471, -0.070739746, 0.0006465912, 0.038513184, 0.02357483, 0.024856567, 0.013061523, 0.018981934, 0.0058174133, 0.048583984, -0.019058228, 0.035705566, 0.03451538, -0.03552246, 0.009536743, 0.0184021, 0.017456055, -0.0034942627, 0.029632568, 0.006023407, 0.006336212, -0.030670166, 0.01979065, -0.00006890297, -0.0040626526, 0.0011148453, -0.028518677, 0.016159058, -0.0004181862, 0.015411377, 0.008987427, -0.0043640137, -0.020126343, 0.0018692017, -0.019363403, -0.013336182, 0.004081726, -0.036987305, -0.035888672, -0.013877869, 0.050048828, 0.0011224747, -0.02053833, 0.022109985, 0.016433716, -0.014701843, 0.011184692, 0.03314209, -0.04800415, 0.032836914, -0.02128601, -0.0064964294, 0.035125732, 0.029846191, -0.03942871, 0.0014562607, -0.01751709, -0.034606934, -0.049804688, -0.0063438416, -0.019470215, 0.024398804, -0.002603531, -0.007949829, 0.01121521, -0.02897644, 0.018356323, -0.00071525574, -0.014984131, 0.013885498, -0.0053367615, 0.005268097, 0.031097412, 0.022705078, 0.016357422, 0.024795532, -0.0011310577, -0.025772095, 0.046661377, 0.0035648346, 0.006877899, 0.030944824, -0.01676941, 0.008804321, 0.033233643, -0.0020332336, 0.021194458, 0.03262329, 0.036468506, 0.021026611, 0.023498535, 0.03970337, 0.0736084, -0.034210205, 0.008560181, -0.030227661, 0.010475159, -0.024887085, 0.047912598, -0.038116455, -0.021896362, -0.04248047, -0.04458618, -0.027145386, -0.004535675, 0.015853882, -0.008453369, 0.01537323, -0.039978027, 0.017730713, -0.02178955, -0.034729004, -0.07342529, 0.022521973, -0.012390137, -0.017868042, 0.06378174, -0.026153564, 0.020690918, -0.03186035, 0.021713257, -0.01777649, -0.019226074, 0.010002136, -0.02432251, 0.021957397, -0.03074646, -0.024505615, 0.03062439, 0.012924194, -0.010696411, 0.042297363, -0.035339355, 0.043151855, 0.024215698, 0.041656494, 0.05142212, -0.01020813, -0.02722168, 0.008666992, -0.03451538, -0.047912598, 0.011695862, -0.044403076, -0.022583008, -0.063964844, -0.021636963, -0.08654785, -0.003446579, -0.0044059753, 0.00034189224, 0.018066406, -0.011749268, 0.0013599396, 0.043060303, 0.011962891, 0.04031372, 0.027404785, -0.009666443, -0.003042221, -0.032684326, -0.036956787, 0.05706787, 0.054016113, 0.012214661, 0.004219055, 0.0055656433, -0.06262207, 0.01121521, 0.034423828, 0.027572632, -0.016113281, -0.025741577, -0.035583496, -0.03173828, -0.046020508, -0.00856781, 0.061523438, 0.057525635, -0.0803833, 0.029312134, 0.034210205, -0.020568848, -0.021575928, -0.02029419, 0.03173828, -0.11151123, 0.0072364807, -0.004802704, 0.00039958954, -0.019073486, 0.017852783, 0.026535034, -0.033996582, -0.022369385, 0.020462036, 0.027923584, -0.0013084412, -0.019729614, -0.027755737, -0.007873535, 0.061340332, 0.042236328, -0.035186768, -0.00024962425, -0.002210617, -0.0019626617, -0.03100586, -0.028244019, -0.016311646, 0.02935791, -0.035583496, 0.021743774, -0.04458618, 0.07763672, -0.009490967, -0.042114258, 0.029190063, 0.0030288696, -0.076049805, -0.018920898, 0.026519775, 0.04473877, 0.020767212, 0.08050537, 0.0059013367, 0.000024199486, -0.028915405, -0.010803223, 0.022598267, 0.04067993, -0.03665161, 0.025299072, -0.039398193, -0.053955078, 0.035186768, -0.058776855, 0.0418396, -0.031341553, 0.0068626404, -0.026397705, 0.026901245, 0.04928589, -0.059448242, -0.059295654, -0.0031642914, -0.012130737, -0.0032863617, -0.01600647, -0.0075645447, 0.004863739, -0.017929077, 0.0074691772, 0.017471313, 0.023742676, 0.039123535, -0.03640747, -0.045166016, 0.03616333, -0.009063721, 0.07867432, -0.06756592, -0.011672974, 0.019317627, -0.012016296, 0.0020275116, -0.06021118, -0.04260254, -0.005771637, 0.004890442, -0.037322998, -0.013153076, -0.010009766, -0.04083252, -0.053100586, -0.029373169, 0.014755249, -0.03152466, -0.0074386597, 0.0072631836, -0.04147339, -0.0028915405, 0.0050201416, -0.03967285, 0.029022217, 0.036956787, -0.019088745, 0.03704834, -0.0010442734, -0.015617371, -0.003932953, 0.011146545, 0.016860962, -0.0069618225, -0.052703857, 0.015197754, 0.0035190582, 0.050445557, -0.035461426, -0.04458618, 0.010040283, 0.02255249, -0.019500732, 0.031433105, -0.0054893494, 0.0012521744, 0.056152344, 0.057250977, 0.0132369995, -0.052581787, -0.0010738373, 0.01235199, 0.0020313263, 0.040161133, -0.0019226074, -0.011749268, 0.020996094, -0.011741638, -0.005142212, 0.04257202, -0.0317688, -0.005378723, 0.0119018555, 0.01473999, -0.011566162, -0.054718018, -0.06463623, 0.011703491, 0.020996094, 0.041412354, 0.0010890961, 0.030532837, 0.0079574585, 0.089538574, 0.009315491, -0.009849548, 0.034301758, 0.000875473, 0.04650879, 0.022491455, 0.02406311, -0.024642944, 0.0013523102, 0.0013656616, -0.023025513, -0.0079574585, 0.03567505, -0.0041542053, 0.0015678406, -0.02507019, -0.035980225, -0.019317627, -0.018966675, 0.0256958, -0.032043457, 0.0012788773, -0.018661499, -0.007408142, 0.0067977905, 0.04006958, 0.026931763, -0.036712646, -0.0043029785, 0.047058105, 0.0473938, -0.0073432922 ], "summary": [ 0.008705139, -0.04788208, -0.021453857, -0.06402588, -0.04397583, -0.017547607, -0.035858154, 0.042266846, 0.047332764, 0.028945923, -0.011375427, -0.0084991455, -0.0027923584, -0.031677246, -0.038116455, -0.013893127, -0.00002092123, -0.0025844574, -0.027786255, -0.028305054, 0.013633728, -0.026947021, -0.02357483, 0.026672363, 0.04071045, -0.0046577454, 0.021148682, -0.0141067505, 0.047943115, 0.027008057, 0.026535034, -0.06262207, 0.021987915, -0.013847351, 0.0019426346, 0.02508545, -0.03152466, -0.00065660477, -0.009300232, 0.013442993, 0.00017809868, 0.013656616, -0.031433105, -0.028533936, -0.09899902, 0.034698486, -0.059936523, 0.048034668, 0.017501831, 0.036346436, -0.009712219, 0.0041542053, -0.019195557, 0.058929443, -0.025558472, -0.042175293, -0.028198242, -0.040252686, 0.022521973, 0.057495117, 0.019699097, -0.04006958, 0.005218506, -0.027236938, 0.0051345825, -0.009147644, -0.029388428, 0.008033752, 0.057159424, 0.0071525574, -0.03591919, -0.0031871796, 0.018951416, -0.04107666, 0.047332764, 0.03527832, 0.032836914, 0.07019043, -0.011428833, 0.009437561, 0.008201599, 0.04647827, 0.061462402, -0.060546875, -0.00005531311, -0.05532837, -0.017608643, 0.0055656433, -0.0053138733, -0.01424408, -0.0061836243, 0.031188965, -0.03829956, -0.0016040802, 0.0046691895, -0.049316406, 0.018249512, -0.0004491806, -0.008926392, -0.0074424744, 0.018310547, -0.029937744, -0.013366699, -0.008010864, -0.0023918152, 0.04925537, 0.024841309, -0.0068969727, -0.02243042, -0.0044174194, -0.023880005, -0.00024962425, 0.009963989, -0.03475952, 0.012207031, 0.024917603, -0.0030269623, 0.014556885, 0.0045166016, -0.0021476746, -0.002084732, 0.0418396, -0.0053634644, -0.012008667, -0.0037460327, -0.011665344, 0.00491333, -0.03488159, 0.051849365, 0.016906738, -0.0029888153, 0.0149383545, -0.052246094, -0.037078857, -0.04925537, -0.0040016174, -0.04800415, -0.020812988, -0.045684814, 0.052581787, -0.013282776, -0.050567627, 0.02986145, 0.01272583, -0.010475159, -0.018585205, -0.015609741, 0.023834229, 0.03475952, 0.0102005005, -0.010810852, -0.028045654, 0.040740967, -0.037628174, -0.029571533, -0.034179688, -0.082336426, 0.01763916, 0.02267456, 0.00283432, 0.04434204, -0.0124435425, -0.020751953, -0.016113281, -0.06774902, 0.004535675, -0.032562256, -0.018066406, 0.008804321, 0.0041770935, -0.030792236, 0.014328003, 0.057281494, 0.013694763, -0.0068969727, 0.020706177, 0.013320923, 0.011253357, 0.019454956, 0.045043945, 0.03878784, -0.0025234222, 0.037231445, 0.014144897, -0.048950195, -0.031799316, 0.007965088, 0.021362305, 0.048095703, 0.008773804, 0.053131104, -0.009651184, -0.014984131, -0.0119018555, -0.0096206665, -0.032226562, 0.0023021698, -0.021392822, -0.017059326, 0.020950317, 0.050048828, 0.033081055, -0.03488159, -0.015342712, -0.06323242, -0.020629883, 0.000004172325, 0.02973938, -0.0021266937, 0.04562378, 0.0390625, 0.035339355, -0.064819336, 0.039215088, -0.011909485, -0.061676025, -0.01184082, 0.00085544586, 0.034698486, -0.010017395, 0.03479004, 0.031829834, 0.020248413, 0.012420654, -0.04071045, -0.009307861, -0.020126343, 0.01751709, -0.02355957, 0.020568848, 0.027328491, -0.010261536, 0.035369873, 0.0006146431, -0.052124023, -0.014671326, -0.0234375, -0.09729004, 0.012863159, 0.08569336, 0.022705078, 0.004928589, -0.016159058, 0.010925293, 0.040252686, -0.030258179, -0.0003926754, 0.008850098, -0.030441284, -0.033050537, -0.021987915, 0.01020813, 0.049957275, -0.009559631, -0.013137817, 0.043029785, -0.018081665, -0.0093307495, -0.012702942, -0.008590698, 0.009155273, -0.06768799, -0.042236328, -0.02772522, -0.014694214, -0.034851074, -0.013893127, -0.0010557175, -0.014442444, -0.032958984, 0.037872314, 0.02067566, 0.0037021637, -0.012542725, 0.010543823, -0.01878357, -0.014312744, 0.019760132, 0.018585205, -0.0289917, -0.014961243, -0.015602112, 0.02708435, 0.0022621155, 0.0017690659, -0.021087646, 0.05239868, 0.031982422, 0.035461426, 0.014701843, 0.033996582, 0.0041542053, -0.045074463, 0.044281006, 0.017715454, -0.05038452, 0.033294678, 0.07080078, -0.021606445, 0.00014340878, -0.03842163, 0.014717102, 0.019241333, -0.053009033, -0.0049934387, 0.010643005, -0.002439499, -0.0031089783, -0.004673004, -0.016418457, -0.0011444092, 0.03555298, 0.014053345, 0.05682373, -0.03567505, -0.026245117, -0.025421143, 0.011871338, -0.016952515, 0.01222229, 0.08728027, -0.044403076, -0.016708374, 0.019363403, -0.037750244, -0.03781128, 0.07244873, -0.020599365, 0.08129883, -0.041046143, -0.025665283, -0.047729492, -0.08288574, -0.042785645, 0.020095825, -0.0038528442, -0.016296387, 0.011421204, -0.021759033, 0.01991272, 0.0042381287, -0.054382324, 0.02104187, -0.033355713, -0.022903442, -0.010696411, 0.026611328, 0.01512146, -0.010017395, 0.009307861, -0.008880615, -0.013671875, 0.004753113, 0.020706177, 0.025161743, -0.009475708, -0.005012512, 0.015274048, -0.0013608932, -0.025253296, 0.011001587, 0.047668457, 0.0064353943, -0.05178833, -0.04486084, -0.018966675, 0.03314209, -0.020050049, 0.015365601, 0.022628784, -0.018966675, 0.012207031, -0.04257202, -0.0024852753, 0.0126571655, 0.015464783, 0.14074707, 0.0259552, -0.028274536, 0.062927246, 0.030853271, 0.031234741, -0.047729492, -0.0657959, 0.05618286, -0.0022258759, -0.000023722649, 0.022018433, 0.04321289, 0.011413574, 0.0064735413, -0.019561768, -0.04510498, -0.011787415, 0.022109985, 0.0046195984, 0.020843506, 0.00074863434, -0.054656982, -0.024734497, 0.015541077, 0.014556885, 0.020126343, -0.00008755922, -0.026687622, 0.026672363, -0.010620117, 0.0044174194, 0.057006836, -0.014526367, 0.012924194, -0.01864624, 0.045440674, -0.0715332, -0.031188965, 0.0012044907, -0.097229004, 0.0012292862, -0.050872803, 0.06335449, 0.016464233, 0.007171631, -0.028442383, 0.031585693, 0.0028762817, 0.0076942444, 0.058624268, 0.011833191, 0.033843994, 0.02229309, 0.04336548, -0.03173828, -0.020599365, -0.011123657, -0.005531311, -0.007949829, -0.019958496, -0.023010254, 0.0096206665, -0.046173096, -0.045135498, -0.006893158, -0.016036987, -0.009422302, -0.010513306, -0.016235352, 0.017440796, -0.03414917, 0.0107040405, 0.04724121, -0.035461426, -0.012962341, 0.010772705, 0.026901245, -0.035247803, 0.066345215, -0.0049209595, -0.00020873547, -0.004966736, -0.026168823, -0.038238525, 0.006210327, -0.012626648, -0.056854248, 0.00005888939, 0.046905518, -0.067871094, 0.05505371, -0.0099105835, -0.030822754, 0.05307007, 0.015609741, 0.01637268, 0.0071907043, 0.0022258759, 0.002696991, 0.02003479, 0.00970459, -0.026504517, -0.026245117, -0.01574707, 0.0041770935, 0.020050049, -0.018966675, -0.0018033981, 0.0016746521, -0.046203613, 0.00020503998, 0.017562866, 0.025634766, -0.0060310364, -0.0141067505, 0.03717041, 0.008506775, 0.0052757263, 0.0005683899, -0.018753052, 0.032470703, 0.006286621, -0.076171875, 0.045166016, -0.01675415, -0.008010864, 0.032318115, 0.0065231323, 0.024642944, -0.00705719, 0.03967285, 0.041290283, -0.009407043, 0.034362793, 0.0015773773, 0.020629883, -0.007408142, 0.009819031, 0.009918213, 0.030181885, 0.017608643, 0.011131287, -0.018310547, -0.02507019, 0.01008606, 0.00182724, 0.03262329, -0.013374329, -0.0058670044, -0.013031006, 0.033203125, -0.013305664, 0.004348755, 0.012863159, -0.0031089783, -0.028793335, -0.015716553, 0.03414917, -0.0031871796, -0.028259277, -0.02281189, 0.032043457, 0.021774292, 0.020507812, 0.009963989, -0.014526367, 0.06500244, 0.007282257, 0.006893158, -0.015777588, 0.050079346, -0.041931152, 0.03970337, -0.038116455, -0.045013428, -0.041870117, -0.045410156, -0.004890442, 0.051086426, 0.024780273, 0.0138549805, -0.03060913, 0.0071868896, 0.041503906, -0.012329102, 0.003993988, -0.03338623, 0.023162842, 0.010749817, -0.014419556, -0.07342529, -0.027496338, 0.006652832, -0.055786133, -0.022827148, -0.061523438, -0.04421997, -0.039978027, 0.0007510185, -0.035491943, 0.02281189, 0.0040130615, 0.0892334, 0.06137085, 0.044433594, -0.064819336, 0.06323242, 0.027664185, 0.028533936, -0.048797607, 0.028823853, -0.006210327, 0.0064353943, -0.018997192, -0.0054779053, 0.006904602, -0.046783447, -0.012283325, -0.009849548, -0.03375244, 0.019836426, 0.0309906, 0.006580353, -0.04031372, 0.0013504028, -0.008384705, -0.0003669262, 0.04940796, 0.055267334, -0.007194519, 0.011497498, 0.029800415, 0.011436462, -0.014984131, -0.026367188, -0.00920105, 0.036376953, -0.007850647, -0.062805176, 0.01638794, -0.0154953, -0.012290955, 0.020568848, 0.021011353, -0.0077438354, 0.039031982, -0.0018548965, -0.029785156, 0.028900146, 0.039642334, -0.020935059, -0.029525757, 0.03656006, 0.0022621155, 0.02017212, -0.017929077, -0.04650879, 0.012687683, 0.043273926, 0.0087509155, -0.0011281967, -0.0034236908, 0.008659363, 0.030090332, 0.0066223145, 0.037841797, -0.013328552, 0.0012512207, -0.016708374, 0.018096924, 0.01423645, -0.027770996, -0.012199402, -0.029769897, 0.0013847351, -0.020401001, 0.012374878, -0.0151901245, -0.016967773, -0.02748108, -0.0059776306, -0.024139404, -0.034332275, -0.05303955, -0.01876831, -0.021591187, 0.01902771, 0.054473877, 0.0011053085, 0.0055122375, 0.00730896, -0.010055542, 0.009994507, -0.014915466, -0.018539429, -0.0026683807, 0.004508972, 0.0011100769, -0.0019931793, 0.017196655, 0.0057640076, -0.024963379, -0.011489868, -0.0018701553, -0.048065186, -0.00881958, -0.022155762, -0.00095939636, 0.019073486, -0.0046424866, 0.022338867, -0.0050697327, 0.005996704, -0.07647705, -0.054656982, 0.005859375, -0.031082153, 0.0031166077, -0.018035889, 0.0035820007, 0.012649536, -0.026153564, -0.011459351, 0.042907715, 0.022964478, -0.013397217, -0.0025844574, -0.01637268, 0.02684021, -0.008590698, 0.017150879, -0.04324341, -0.009666443, -0.0045814514, 0.04598999, -0.01197052, 0.010482788, -0.027359009, -0.048431396, -0.07525635, -0.0362854, -0.053619385, 0.048309326, -0.023376465, -0.023513794, -0.0014390945, -0.016418457, 0.015396118, -0.0050086975, -0.021316528, -0.005947113, -0.024551392, -0.038909912, 0.030059814, 0.0073127747, -0.040985107, 0.03086853, 0.0056533813, -0.0006747246, 0.02760315, 0.026947021, -0.010932922, -0.01637268, -0.039245605, -0.003025055, 0.024261475, -0.01727295, 0.0069770813, 0.039611816, 0.022003174, -0.0004787445, 0.00044846535, 0.014678955, 0.016906738, -0.0050201416, -0.023712158, 0.036621094, 0.025497437, 0.01828003, 0.0004284382, 0.030960083, -0.009346008, 0.0007724762, -0.024856567, -0.0076675415, -0.04510498, 0.009002686, -0.024032593, 0.01838684, 0.0044174194, 0.0008325577, 0.010269165, -0.011947632, -0.04333496, -0.002029419, -0.018417358, -0.040985107, 0.0758667, 0.023132324, 0.0051193237, 0.0050811768, -0.0037555695, -0.009750366, -0.0073242188, 0.015701294, -0.01058197, 0.00009447336, -0.029586792, 0.025604248, 0.026611328, 0.035125732, -0.016082764, 0.046051025, -0.040771484, 0.02961731, 0.002374649, 0.035339355, -0.00012362003, -0.009788513, -0.009384155, -0.00070381165, 0.027404785, -0.02885437, 0.047729492, 0.0007443428, -0.034362793, -0.07165527, -0.061157227, -0.059143066, 0.05645752, -0.040496826, -0.04055786, 0.034851074, -0.022613525, -0.032592773, 0.041503906, -0.04660034, 0.090148926, -0.028533936, 0.02243042, 0.01083374, -0.0141067505, -0.039794922, 0.006378174, 0.029846191, -0.0064430237, 0.027877808, 0.043670654, 0.019546509, 0.0049972534, -0.038330078, -0.001958847, -0.038238525, 0.036743164, -0.017791748, -0.015174866, -0.032440186, 0.016098022, 0.04800415, 0.004306793, 0.022979736, -0.01158905, 0.011451721, -0.021850586, -0.015716553, -0.0057678223, -0.0037841797, -0.064697266, 0.004131317, 0.01739502, -0.002658844, 0.013435364, -0.0126571655, 0.04360962, -0.057647705, -0.029663086, -0.013587952, 0.0158844, -0.025314331, -0.05996704, -0.032562256, -0.0076065063, 0.0690918, 0.033111572, -0.025558472, -0.012168884, 0.0014753342, -0.024475098, 0.033813477, -0.029754639, 0.0077056885, 0.011642456, 0.029296875, 0.039886475, 0.0018100739, 0.032470703, -0.013267517, -0.019622803, 0.0030784607, 0.023986816, -0.048187256, 0.0027675629, 0.006477356, 0.019958496, 0.01424408, 0.052337646, -0.038024902, 0.022079468, 0.001332283, 0.02519226, 0.0009422302, -0.0211792, -0.00046992302, 0.016082764, -0.038848877, -0.010643005, 0.0011548996, -0.046295166, -0.042938232, -0.023391724, -0.01348114, -0.0234375, 0.018951416, 0.0309906, -0.018234253, -0.09118652, -0.018432617, -0.01977539, -0.0009036064, -0.01939392, -0.035186768, 0.002916336, -0.04385376, 0.00466156, -0.0063285828, 0.017807007, 0.0039482117, -0.0033550262, -0.043029785, 0.06640625, 0.0066871643, 0.11138916, 0.0051345825, -0.004917145, 0.06793213, 0.030532837, -0.028915405, -0.12658691, -0.05407715, 0.030410767, 0.06958008, -0.010498047, -0.046203613, -0.037719727, -0.044677734, -0.064697266, -0.009849548, 0.024276733, -0.040222168, 0.01663208, 0.059326172, -0.032104492, 0.04095459, 0.025497437, -0.024749756, 0.050598145, -0.02130127, -0.040130615, 0.082092285, -0.00050640106, -0.023284912, 0.0026493073, -0.0256958, -0.045806885, -0.03137207, -0.044189453, -0.014625549, 0.0062179565, -0.013015747, -0.021240234, -0.021148682, 0.043701172, 0.04876709, -0.0009589195, -0.028656006, -0.026977539, -0.039855957, 0.025680542, 0.029434204, 0.014091492, -0.007297516, 0.031799316, 0.027526855, -0.06188965, 0.02104187, 0.01725769, 0.005832672, 0.028320312, -0.024520874, -0.0035419464, 0.06317139, -0.028137207, -0.008682251, 0.0016593933, 0.022354126, -0.008987427, -0.056030273, -0.06341553, -0.005142212, 0.018112183, 0.020553589, 0.0099105835, 0.035003662, -0.013450623, 0.07745361, 0.0052490234, 0.0209198, 0.008590698, -0.034606934, 0.053009033, -0.049835205, 0.056671143, 0.006664276, -0.013511658, -0.0034332275, -0.007881165, -0.022201538, 0.024017334, 0.005886078, 0.0013628006, 0.035614014, 0.005382538, -0.023895264, -0.020568848, 0.018966675, -0.02230835, -0.008430481, 0.01448822, -0.02255249, 0.043792725, 0.029891968, 0.056518555, -0.0012073517, 0.04916382, 0.028884888, -0.0000013113022, 0.02609253 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07362v2
Volcano: Mitigating Multimodal Hallucination through Self-Feedback Guided Revision
Seongyun Lee, Sue Hyun Park, Yongrae Jo, Minjoon Seo
cs.CL, cs.CV
Large multimodal models (LMMs) suffer from multimodal hallucination, where they provide incorrect responses misaligned with the given visual information. Recent works have conjectured that one of the reasons behind multimodal hallucination might be due to the vision encoder failing to ground on the image properly. To mitigate this issue, we propose a novel approach that leverages self-feedback as visual cues. Building on this approach, we introduce Volcano, a multimodal self-feedback guided revision model. Volcano generates natural language feedback to its initial response based on the provided visual information and utilizes this feedback to self-revise its initial response. Volcano effectively reduces multimodal hallucination and achieves state-of-the-art on MMHal-Bench, POPE, and GAVIE. It also improves on general multimodal abilities and outperforms previous models on MM-Vet and MMBench. Through a qualitative analysis, we show that Volcano's feedback is properly grounded on the image than the initial response. This indicates that Volcano can provide itself with richer visual information, helping alleviate multimodal hallucination. We publicly release Volcano models of 7B and 13B sizes along with the data and code at https://github.com/kaistAI/Volcano.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07362v2
2023-11-14T06:04:31
2023-11-13T14:26:24
{ "title": [ -0.016174316, 0.009681702, -0.031280518, -0.034088135, -0.019119263, -0.007980347, -0.03152466, -0.030410767, -0.03186035, 0.031402588, -0.0049209595, 0.028137207, 0.0095825195, -0.02607727, -0.020996094, 0.008041382, 0.013824463, 0.028182983, -0.010620117, -0.021270752, -0.033172607, -0.02116394, 0.019897461, 0.012817383, -0.036315918, 0.029769897, -0.05532837, 0.0005340576, -0.05505371, -0.03652954, -0.016860962, 0.03253174, 0.054138184, 0.031402588, -0.0597229, 0.016082764, -0.027282715, 0.0047798157, -0.017730713, 0.022079468, 0.01828003, -0.011619568, -0.026947021, 0.0044822693, -0.064331055, 0.0209198, -0.055664062, 0.008125305, -0.0038414001, 0.010093689, 0.009460449, 0.052490234, 0.01739502, 0.024169922, -0.003572464, -0.00554657, -0.04626465, 0.01751709, 0.03552246, 0.04345703, -0.0056381226, -0.04006958, 0.012886047, -0.029815674, -0.014663696, -0.024490356, -0.008270264, 0.031051636, 0.050628662, -0.00076293945, -0.035247803, 0.019592285, 0.018463135, -0.0071907043, -0.021224976, 0.033325195, 0.017303467, 0.052520752, 0.02583313, -0.027145386, -0.019927979, -0.0231781, 0.003932953, -0.013900757, 0.0025558472, 0.0015354156, -0.013000488, 0.0021190643, -0.052703857, -0.054382324, -0.008651733, -0.035095215, -0.06463623, 0.008338928, -0.0010175705, -0.035003662, 0.0015573502, 0.022338867, 0.01096344, -0.030426025, 0.005092621, -0.00078344345, -0.044708252, -0.033843994, 0.010971069, 0.037872314, -0.013717651, -0.054626465, -0.0025997162, 0.01638794, -0.026824951, 0.042907715, 0.024246216, -0.032348633, 0.011688232, 0.02885437, 0.0231781, 0.01737976, 0.01689148, 0.012611389, -0.0051231384, -0.024597168, 0.012428284, 0.024551392, 0.03050232, 0.013961792, -0.033172607, 0.0256958, -0.004085541, 0.012374878, -0.0079193115, 0.057678223, -0.070129395, -0.06549072, -0.051605225, 0.027709961, -0.014183044, 0.01348114, -0.013702393, -0.014953613, 0.008155823, 0.0030670166, 0.04336548, -0.030715942, 0.007171631, 0.02470398, 0.0413208, -0.0065345764, -0.021484375, -0.055908203, 0.008255005, -0.037994385, -0.0042037964, 0.00023460388, 0.020080566, 0.0012979507, -0.06488037, -0.009727478, 0.042114258, 0.020050049, 0.03050232, -0.017700195, -0.015701294, 0.06222534, 0.044647217, 0.036895752, 0.0010461807, 0.019729614, 0.035095215, 0.04827881, -0.023040771, 0.010231018, 0.05947876, 0.005744934, -0.0074501038, 0.030273438, 0.013832092, 0.011672974, 0.0021533966, 0.0021343231, 0.0054969788, -0.019058228, 0.0143585205, 0.039001465, -0.09338379, 0.015365601, -0.009460449, 0.03842163, 0.051483154, -0.009277344, 0.009216309, 0.031066895, -0.028778076, -0.037353516, -0.072387695, -0.005340576, -0.0000410676, 0.035064697, -0.034423828, 0.04525757, -0.016525269, 0.007183075, -0.03704834, -0.01574707, -0.07965088, -0.029846191, -0.023071289, 0.030563354, -0.0015029907, 0.02784729, 0.041168213, 0.009384155, -0.050323486, 0.040649414, -0.009185791, -0.056274414, -0.028305054, 0.006549835, -0.012283325, 0.027435303, -0.007282257, -0.023147583, -0.0008459091, -0.004611969, 0.030212402, -0.0025234222, 0.003074646, -0.024093628, 0.052124023, 0.022125244, 0.039642334, -0.023529053, 0.038909912, -0.012039185, -0.032287598, -0.0050621033, -0.017623901, -0.06311035, 0.0024814606, 0.050109863, -0.009140015, -0.013221741, -0.014030457, 0.02420044, 0.0033454895, -0.012672424, 0.023162842, 0.01852417, -0.0076904297, -0.027145386, 0.05706787, 0.013916016, 0.054473877, 0.06982422, 0.008926392, 0.034057617, -0.030960083, -0.008850098, 0.013053894, -0.02420044, 0.031051636, 0.01751709, -0.0067825317, 0.022415161, -0.02330017, 0.0047187805, -0.0051193237, 0.021881104, 0.0206604, -0.003917694, 0.012039185, -0.04083252, 0.013214111, -0.07019043, 0.005531311, -0.023422241, -0.027786255, 0.039733887, 0.040100098, -0.06921387, -0.041809082, -0.025100708, -0.014053345, -0.015037537, 0.015716553, 0.0040664673, 0.017654419, -0.0637207, -0.072631836, -0.002632141, 0.0435791, 0.017074585, 0.012969971, -0.036010742, 0.028564453, 0.014595032, 0.0076408386, 0.038513184, -0.012054443, 0.0070648193, -0.06329346, 0.017410278, 0.022369385, -0.008232117, -0.008903503, 0.031921387, 0.010406494, 0.00390625, -0.01259613, -0.020507812, -0.008766174, 0.012039185, -0.0013875961, -0.04550171, -0.03289795, -0.037109375, -0.038513184, -0.03527832, -0.05230713, 0.005191803, 0.03253174, 0.012718201, -0.03414917, 0.018371582, 0.0074691772, -0.020568848, -0.014930725, -0.029251099, -0.0021800995, 0.019821167, 0.043670654, 0.025466919, -0.061462402, -0.055664062, 0.019454956, 0.0070724487, -0.0021629333, 0.000065505505, -0.026367188, 0.023529053, -0.0021629333, -0.061706543, 0.005836487, -0.045654297, -0.020584106, -0.012062073, -0.011276245, 0.019042969, -0.04888916, -0.020965576, 0.024215698, -0.026504517, -0.01184845, -0.0007753372, 0.042022705, 0.012023926, 0.0017328262, 0.061187744, 0.04953003, 0.015716553, 0.03152466, -0.0024757385, -0.0022697449, -0.033172607, 0.017501831, -0.05444336, -0.034973145, -0.017333984, 0.03829956, 0.054901123, -0.016174316, 0.03302002, -0.057434082, -0.0031967163, 0.0044059753, -0.009666443, 0.041046143, -0.018493652, -0.05090332, 0.0041122437, -0.023498535, -0.01576233, -0.027938843, -0.0078125, 0.11456299, -0.016555786, 0.0059432983, 0.039611816, 0.029693604, 0.015472412, -0.03717041, -0.05496216, -0.04385376, -0.0040740967, 0.02571106, -0.0035209656, -0.026153564, 0.022415161, -0.10418701, 0.004562378, -0.020431519, -0.004753113, -0.020629883, -0.020080566, -0.047210693, -0.026351929, -0.034118652, -0.030731201, 0.04458618, 0.017211914, -0.0043258667, 0.011383057, 0.023376465, -0.019042969, -0.0007901192, -0.028900146, -0.16052246, 0.0137786865, -0.047973633, 0.041778564, -0.0021381378, -0.009140015, -0.038726807, 0.027374268, 0.016204834, 0.0657959, 0.035339355, -0.0018749237, 0.037963867, -0.029327393, 0.03665161, -0.024017334, -0.0047721863, -0.012069702, -0.021255493, -0.06573486, -0.02798462, -0.0052375793, 0.036254883, -0.023040771, -0.027694702, -0.0070991516, -0.015853882, 0.005279541, 0.015312195, -0.06713867, -0.009841919, -0.019088745, -0.051574707, 0.027038574, -0.03665161, 0.027786255, -0.027770996, 0.020599365, -0.0047950745, 0.014541626, -0.008407593, 0.011199951, -0.015426636, -0.03527832, -0.020584106, -0.02331543, -0.031463623, -0.014595032, -0.025314331, 0.002910614, 0.04559326, -0.040649414, -0.040161133, 0.006980896, -0.06964111, 0.04196167, 0.005054474, -0.005329132, 0.039154053, -0.030059814, -0.04345703, 0.008735657, -0.01184082, 0.013442993, -0.019104004, 0.01914978, -0.019485474, -0.062164307, -0.020553589, 0.006385803, -0.07910156, -0.05343628, 0.037872314, -0.030838013, -0.03604126, -0.04852295, 0.029846191, -0.032836914, -0.009300232, 0.0070228577, -0.0045318604, 0.015045166, 0.008285522, -0.08227539, 0.00749588, 0.054718018, -0.06341553, 0.018859863, 0.0513916, -0.023880005, -0.048980713, -0.021621704, 0.021224976, 0.03173828, -0.0015230179, -0.0055007935, 0.030899048, 0.032318115, -0.00970459, 0.0126571655, 0.015090942, -0.030822754, 0.011871338, 0.028717041, 0.008735657, 0.06341553, -0.050750732, 0.06616211, 0.028518677, -0.002729416, -0.110961914, 0.027053833, 0.011222839, -0.016555786, -0.02166748, -0.028701782, -0.026168823, 0.017684937, 0.043701172, 0.04852295, 0.015136719, 0.015113831, 0.016860962, -0.018569946, -0.014526367, 0.017562866, 0.021438599, -0.01687622, -0.005908966, 0.021102905, -0.021972656, 0.048553467, 0.015281677, -0.031829834, 0.010070801, 0.022155762, -0.07836914, -0.015731812, -0.030807495, -0.055389404, -0.034820557, 0.01751709, -0.017715454, 0.0039634705, 0.037231445, 0.012672424, -0.0052948, -0.031402588, 0.055145264, 0.00021731853, 0.0026378632, -0.06097412, -0.02319336, -0.0076675415, -0.07745361, -0.028030396, -0.013587952, -0.0072746277, 0.0048179626, -0.013946533, -0.029632568, 0.0039978027, 0.021331787, 0.07489014, 0.056549072, 0.014968872, -0.0496521, 0.03552246, -0.019454956, -0.040252686, 0.018463135, -0.006477356, -0.023040771, -0.03768921, 0.0104599, -0.016067505, -0.018615723, -0.013343811, 0.01424408, 0.0021343231, 0.031921387, -0.014755249, 0.022735596, 0.016555786, 0.012229919, -0.0038833618, -0.003932953, -0.053100586, 0.037384033, -0.026763916, 0.022338867, -0.023391724, 0.020355225, 0.044281006, 0.017425537, 0.0037498474, -0.003326416, 0.018493652, 0.012428284, 0.0015735626, 0.01979065, -0.0047683716, -0.029647827, -0.014297485, 0.024993896, 0.006866455, 0.042785645, -0.010345459, 0.013679504, 0.024276733, 0.0154800415, 0.026275635, -0.009796143, 0.025634766, 0.016311646, 0.0087890625, -0.040039062, -0.04006958, 0.002708435, 0.023727417, -0.010070801, -0.013504028, 0.02519226, 0.052490234, 0.05291748, 0.035858154, 0.03262329, -0.00944519, -0.032318115, 0.0028839111, 0.004886627, -0.030181885, -0.048583984, -0.01600647, -0.019226074, 0.009757996, -0.05114746, 0.015220642, -0.017303467, -0.017425537, -0.025970459, -0.009857178, 0.018676758, -0.03881836, 0.029937744, 0.07952881, 0.008354187, 0.031051636, 0.031463623, 0.012168884, -0.00071668625, 0.048736572, -0.017654419, 0.0055236816, 0.027618408, -0.043182373, 0.022766113, -0.009239197, 0.0042495728, -0.0008621216, -0.011985779, -0.0013580322, 0.011909485, -0.03387451, 0.025436401, 0.037353516, 0.020584106, -0.011207581, -0.047912598, 0.019241333, -0.032562256, 0.003353119, 0.017440796, -0.00894165, -0.04876709, -0.03439331, -0.039855957, -0.055908203, 0.026290894, -0.017868042, -0.08331299, -0.017791748, 0.04248047, 0.036132812, 0.04385376, -0.027557373, -0.028213501, -0.0692749, -0.012886047, 0.022262573, 0.038360596, 0.0039596558, -0.02432251, -0.02557373, 0.013626099, 0.044067383, -0.02180481, 0.01360321, -0.02003479, -0.024520874, -0.018539429, -0.0047950745, -0.010765076, 0.015731812, -0.0023765564, -0.05343628, -0.004573822, 0.022842407, 0.038879395, -0.015487671, -0.022094727, 0.016418457, -0.02218628, -0.011985779, 0.02432251, 0.027923584, -0.019088745, 0.022567749, 0.0124435425, 0.013793945, 0.035705566, 0.0004594326, 0.011230469, 0.028778076, -0.01651001, -0.0023155212, 0.028869629, 0.003408432, -0.036071777, 0.046539307, 0.026565552, -0.03274536, -0.00078582764, 0.0018339157, 0.02859497, -0.0067367554, -0.023849487, -0.024856567, -0.006954193, -0.03491211, 0.03515625, 0.011878967, -0.016784668, -0.020965576, -0.04397583, -0.02456665, 0.0034980774, 0.02053833, -0.0027217865, -0.00043535233, -0.039886475, 0.009292603, 0.006248474, 0.00894928, -0.028030396, -0.0043792725, -0.007843018, -0.018188477, 0.052246094, 0.061645508, -0.021987915, -0.05014038, 0.021621704, 0.00894165, 0.028625488, 0.0012283325, 0.038757324, -0.009124756, -0.013114929, 0.011367798, 0.037231445, -0.007041931, -0.03010559, -0.025344849, -0.0059013367, 0.0524292, 0.03012085, 0.036499023, 0.039886475, 0.021255493, -0.03817749, 0.011268616, 0.0008354187, -0.039642334, 0.039398193, -0.04525757, 0.021072388, -0.04067993, -0.013198853, -0.10412598, 0.025466919, 0.011543274, 0.03161621, -0.04058838, 0.013381958, -0.008163452, 0.020996094, 0.032104492, -0.010040283, 0.05178833, -0.007507324, -0.012229919, 0.013885498, 0.018218994, 0.023529053, 0.030776978, 0.0005145073, 0.020339966, -0.031982422, -0.013061523, 0.037078857, -0.011238098, 0.011024475, 0.009437561, -0.0001796484, -0.019927979, -0.0009622574, -0.01739502, 0.030654907, 0.044158936, 0.014022827, -0.013320923, 0.0021209717, -0.012306213, -0.014640808, -0.003118515, -0.034820557, 0.039093018, -0.07647705, 0.036499023, -0.007106781, -0.026306152, -0.025466919, 0.0703125, 0.026870728, -0.012329102, 0.030548096, 0.035614014, 0.0054473877, 0.0042304993, 0.0059013367, -0.019256592, -0.018798828, 0.028335571, 0.046295166, 0.0072135925, 0.03466797, -0.022979736, 0.018920898, 0.004951477, -0.020523071, -0.011482239, 0.010688782, -0.039031982, 0.021057129, 0.029541016, 0.031677246, 0.016021729, -0.024856567, 0.008613586, 0.022949219, -0.044189453, 0.0051841736, -0.035217285, 0.027938843, -0.012168884, 0.024047852, -0.043945312, -0.03567505, -0.0033798218, 0.0032787323, 0.02418518, 0.055541992, -0.021072388, 0.01210022, -0.03829956, -0.04324341, 0.008811951, -0.047821045, 0.026168823, -0.028335571, 0.032989502, -0.028015137, -0.011161804, 0.048614502, -0.04727173, -0.0011749268, 0.0049057007, -0.046691895, 0.00207901, -0.0020599365, -0.02859497, -0.007232666, -0.007183075, 0.004776001, 0.0132751465, -0.010810852, 0.0036964417, -0.02268982, -0.04623413, 0.0076141357, -0.011672974, 0.026550293, -0.014785767, -0.06112671, -0.050750732, 0.03475952, 0.056793213, 0.02482605, -0.053527832, 0.07507324, -0.014892578, -0.023117065, 0.022079468, 0.02772522, -0.01134491, -0.014205933, -0.0066986084, 0.015777588, -0.021942139, -0.00223732, 0.016830444, -0.04638672, 0.010955811, 0.004180908, -0.047332764, 0.0340271, 0.016357422, -0.0035800934, 0.02760315, -0.0014123917, 0.0134887695, 0.0154418945, 0.03137207, 0.050079346, -0.0132751465, -0.031829834, 0.006416321, 0.0023479462, 0.007247925, -0.05935669, -0.086364746, -0.009010315, 0.069885254, -0.021697998, 0.061645508, 0.0013170242, 0.011444092, 0.024719238, 0.06085205, 0.004108429, -0.045928955, 0.013969421, 0.004547119, -0.00042510033, 0.04888916, 0.011993408, -0.0070495605, 0.016967773, 0.008674622, -0.0014839172, 0.021881104, -0.014823914, -0.005176544, 0.015991211, 0.047546387, -0.011024475, -0.010650635, -0.054016113, -0.003736496, 0.03048706, 0.0446167, -0.006298065, 0.029724121, -0.0025997162, 0.11236572, -0.022567749, -0.015655518, 0.032714844, 0.027023315, 0.030197144, 0.0058784485, 0.0076904297, 0.0035057068, 0.005065918, -0.00365448, 0.008239746, -0.024414062, 0.06311035, -0.06964111, -0.020568848, -0.043670654, -0.06573486, -0.042938232, -0.027008057, 0.0005197525, -0.025360107, 0.047332764, 0.01953125, -0.016952515, 0.016021729, 0.016403198, 0.047821045, -0.0007276535, -0.045318604, -0.07208252, 0.03591919, -0.023590088 ], "summary": [ -0.025222778, 0.008392334, -0.013389587, -0.018478394, -0.03994751, 0.009567261, -0.06561279, -0.028244019, 0.038513184, 0.033599854, -0.023376465, -0.004638672, 0.0231781, -0.01373291, -0.018951416, 0.0027160645, 0.025894165, -0.0013780594, 0.008781433, -0.0028705597, 0.0057373047, 0.004043579, 0.009300232, 0.024749756, -0.02670288, 0.05734253, -0.0054512024, 0.015007019, -0.04525757, -0.0028457642, -0.0032577515, 0.016555786, 0.039489746, 0.018692017, -0.056518555, 0.0209198, 0.008094788, -0.015838623, -0.0015563965, 0.013847351, 0.022628784, -0.0072898865, 0.033294678, -0.029846191, -0.0231781, 0.06341553, -0.031280518, -0.019714355, 0.018188477, -0.022644043, 0.0055274963, 0.04446411, 0.006046295, -0.00881958, -0.019638062, -0.0011444092, -0.039398193, 0.0010080338, 0.007949829, 0.115112305, 0.040802002, 0.023422241, -0.03970337, -0.07330322, 0.001159668, 0.010406494, 0.02218628, -0.0029582977, 0.04547119, -0.0006995201, -0.038970947, 0.011688232, 0.04067993, -0.047027588, 0.0022296906, 0.06011963, 0.006843567, 0.05722046, 0.010643005, -0.03665161, 0.012107849, 0.0003836155, -0.030410767, -0.0033245087, -0.017166138, -0.015777588, -0.007972717, -0.012863159, -0.05038452, -0.029785156, -0.03289795, -0.027297974, -0.0793457, 0.022918701, 0.008117676, -0.009109497, -0.015823364, -0.0012865067, 0.023757935, 0.029647827, 0.037872314, -0.039245605, 0.048950195, -0.039611816, 0.018417358, 0.043426514, -0.0051498413, -0.07220459, -0.001033783, -0.020614624, -0.034484863, 0.025253296, 0.018310547, -0.027770996, -0.010047913, 0.018951416, 0.0011606216, 0.034606934, 0.0029830933, 0.026184082, -0.0032844543, -0.011436462, 0.029632568, 0.038635254, 0.008666992, 0.020690918, 0.0045051575, -0.027069092, -0.011604309, -0.00667572, -0.011779785, 0.060943604, -0.010383606, -0.026504517, -0.049194336, 0.01461792, -0.0019321442, 0.021316528, -0.00014233589, -0.00061035156, 0.009780884, 0.0021800995, 0.04437256, -0.008857727, -0.0079422, 0.034118652, 0.02822876, -0.00724411, -0.034210205, -0.05014038, 0.010261536, -0.033935547, -0.018035889, -0.0073928833, 0.079956055, -0.013809204, -0.0048828125, -0.012756348, 0.036071777, 0.031280518, 0.024307251, -0.028671265, 0.023529053, 0.05267334, -0.0050086975, 0.04019165, -0.048583984, -0.015777588, 0.03829956, 0.032318115, 0.0057144165, 0.021560669, 0.06756592, 0.020355225, -0.0036907196, -0.005542755, 0.024520874, 0.011329651, 0.022827148, -0.01739502, -0.026046753, -0.02470398, 0.0758667, -0.03277588, -0.05697632, 0.030288696, -0.0010318756, 0.07507324, 0.022262573, 0.0076065063, 0.0042381287, 0.004337311, -0.013931274, 0.013824463, -0.041656494, 0.0057868958, -0.046905518, 0.03390503, -0.048950195, 0.012359619, 0.015975952, 0.01939392, -0.034362793, -0.060638428, -0.1307373, -0.024765015, -0.026184082, 0.045043945, -0.025878906, 0.02418518, 0.044647217, 0.02684021, -0.05557251, 0.05203247, 0.010002136, -0.03945923, -0.024047852, 0.005455017, 0.00015866756, -0.008857727, 0.0138549805, -0.020843506, -0.011817932, 0.016448975, 0.0075263977, -0.010643005, 0.006626129, 0.019470215, 0.044647217, 0.024139404, 0.016571045, -0.04437256, 0.011047363, -0.030532837, -0.032989502, -0.014663696, 0.018341064, -0.08135986, 0.015075684, 0.05831909, 0.0031223297, 0.03652954, -0.020706177, 0.034729004, 0.0073432922, 0.03942871, 0.03744507, 0.0029125214, -0.038909912, -0.038085938, 0.020370483, 0.0074882507, 0.05340576, 0.048065186, 0.003271103, 0.031143188, -0.026229858, -0.04232788, -0.0043029785, -0.013168335, 0.050476074, -0.00065755844, -0.027053833, 0.014205933, -0.03463745, -0.04006958, -0.02319336, -0.027893066, 0.03213501, -0.03778076, 0.01448822, -0.062805176, 0.0018129349, -0.07067871, -0.018112183, -0.035247803, -0.0047302246, 0.03805542, 0.02279663, -0.05215454, -0.04788208, -0.08380127, -0.06329346, -0.024246216, 0.06304932, 0.0141067505, 0.020233154, -0.058380127, -0.05871582, 0.032592773, 0.03604126, 0.04650879, 0.02067566, -0.024597168, 0.0055732727, 0.040008545, -0.021621704, -0.025405884, 0.048583984, -0.042388916, 0.002407074, 0.05847168, -0.028030396, 0.036071777, -0.008369446, 0.009864807, -0.014312744, -0.0045661926, -0.016189575, -0.013504028, -0.01802063, 0.031677246, 0.014846802, 0.0070724487, -0.029373169, -0.038024902, -0.04147339, -0.00033426285, -0.036499023, 0.013938904, 0.05859375, 0.025436401, -0.03729248, 0.037078857, 0.010498047, -0.018585205, 0.038726807, -0.037353516, 0.023880005, -0.010726929, -0.006919861, -0.019165039, -0.039642334, -0.04156494, 0.012504578, -0.011817932, -0.012382507, 0.03543091, -0.013145447, 0.011993408, -0.0060653687, -0.044555664, -0.007965088, -0.038909912, -0.02607727, -0.00932312, -0.011245728, 0.009124756, -0.028396606, -0.015556335, 0.02041626, -0.012413025, -0.02810669, 0.031555176, 0.018173218, 0.009681702, 0.03286743, 0.0657959, 0.030349731, 0.004234314, -0.010795593, -0.0012998581, -0.045196533, -0.06109619, 0.031188965, -0.016204834, -0.04067993, -0.016082764, 0.049865723, 0.046051025, 0.018096924, 0.050933838, -0.055908203, -0.022140503, -0.0028514862, -0.0151901245, 0.091796875, 0.0011606216, -0.032196045, 0.042297363, -0.0003209114, 0.020050049, -0.03262329, 0.008483887, 0.12683105, -0.0049743652, 0.01965332, 0.059570312, 0.040100098, 0.014190674, -0.03555298, -0.049743652, -0.029052734, 0.0016460419, 0.023666382, -0.021209717, -0.016418457, 0.01838684, -0.09112549, -0.006965637, -0.05859375, 0.026245117, 0.033111572, -0.027816772, -0.03704834, 0.050811768, -0.05130005, -0.01776123, 0.0211792, -0.0052223206, 0.017074585, -0.03466797, 0.0021381378, -0.023757935, -0.0031089783, -0.036895752, -0.10107422, -0.0011854172, -0.015670776, 0.042541504, -0.03024292, 0.06378174, -0.038146973, 0.030075073, -0.006587982, 0.034484863, -0.019210815, 0.01776123, 0.023132324, -0.00053071976, 0.0073394775, -0.010124207, 0.008552551, -0.0013589859, -0.03729248, -0.0072631836, -0.010215759, -0.010543823, 0.027755737, -0.05505371, -0.053100586, -0.016082764, -0.044158936, -0.022659302, 0.002822876, -0.053649902, -0.008850098, -0.050048828, -0.053985596, 0.04989624, -0.036590576, 0.021575928, -0.009468079, 0.039154053, -0.008262634, 0.017349243, -0.0395813, 0.017822266, 0.05041504, -0.048339844, -0.014511108, -0.025177002, -0.035827637, 0.0035915375, -0.012954712, 0.0060195923, 0.007762909, -0.010246277, -0.024734497, -0.007217407, -0.016403198, 0.010360718, 0.008079529, -0.0034294128, 0.0101623535, -0.056762695, -0.0062561035, 0.036010742, -0.014762878, -0.015853882, -0.07183838, 0.03753662, -0.058685303, -0.023162842, -0.015258789, -0.0023097992, -0.019058228, -0.050354004, 0.045013428, 0.02230835, -0.03817749, -0.029891968, 0.044677734, -0.013694763, 0.011161804, 0.058258057, 0.0013713837, 0.03137207, 0.004261017, -0.043121338, -0.0035953522, -0.0047187805, -0.03363037, 0.008964539, 0.0132751465, -0.0034694672, -0.010925293, 0.0018424988, 0.036315918, 0.0211792, 0.00049829483, -0.003479004, 0.017089844, 0.012756348, -0.0075912476, 0.01071167, 0.0065231323, -0.02720642, -0.0021018982, 0.022262573, 0.015823364, 0.053375244, -0.0068740845, 0.024276733, -0.008308411, 0.018203735, -0.05026245, 0.02067566, 0.0062828064, -0.014015198, -0.02432251, -0.0066566467, -0.01133728, 0.013664246, 0.036865234, 0.00894165, -0.0098724365, 0.0075798035, 0.02331543, -0.019256592, 0.002614975, 0.02633667, -0.017593384, 0.00045609474, 0.004421234, 0.010910034, -0.009246826, 0.0074768066, 0.010826111, -0.023666382, 0.0065345764, 0.013320923, -0.05041504, -0.012786865, -0.0071258545, -0.04272461, -0.060943604, 0.022018433, 0.018188477, 0.023239136, 0.034576416, 0.026885986, -0.004184723, -0.038146973, 0.0051193237, 0.018035889, -0.03201294, -0.07373047, 0.021881104, -0.049957275, -0.052490234, -0.0340271, -0.018753052, -0.032226562, -0.0037822723, 0.0037345886, -0.030288696, 0.00944519, -0.003627777, 0.04724121, 0.03753662, 0.015434265, -0.061462402, 0.0040016174, -0.020553589, -0.024429321, 0.010673523, -0.005569458, -0.032562256, -0.042541504, -0.00012934208, -0.0027713776, -0.022903442, -0.008171082, 0.0011777878, 0.004234314, 0.03994751, -0.006374359, 0.014785767, 0.007484436, 0.010169983, -0.0005135536, -0.010314941, -0.0027179718, -0.0028705597, 0.0064888, 0.0072746277, 0.02331543, -0.004234314, 0.0027866364, 0.0010814667, 0.024902344, -0.0011405945, 0.0000020861626, 0.0010414124, -0.020095825, 0.037017822, -0.010864258, -0.0042037964, -0.022872925, 0.025054932, 0.024505615, 0.017074585, 0.038208008, 0.013252258, 0.04220581, 0.022583008, 0.024032593, -0.026748657, 0.0023059845, 0.0058517456, -0.01965332, -0.03378296, -0.064941406, -0.0062789917, 0.059051514, -0.015357971, -0.027557373, 0.007820129, 0.029724121, 0.014884949, 0.007575989, -0.0124053955, -0.0061187744, 0.033477783, -0.007724762, -0.000852108, -0.000869751, -0.02104187, -0.0236969, -0.029037476, 0.002483368, -0.013305664, -0.0068473816, 0.0037231445, -0.0047302246, -0.0140686035, 0.029403687, -0.005378723, -0.017547607, -0.011604309, 0.033050537, -0.00027179718, -0.0001809597, 0.06591797, -0.004890442, -0.027450562, 0.040161133, -0.033477783, 0.01751709, -0.0054130554, -0.038238525, 0.061309814, -0.03881836, -0.0057792664, 0.05819702, -0.032165527, 0.018508911, 0.052490234, -0.020126343, 0.0024433136, 0.028427124, 0.03488159, -0.011474609, -0.022369385, 0.024597168, -0.00793457, -0.0027332306, -0.011650085, -0.004878998, -0.048706055, -0.042877197, -0.024902344, -0.061767578, 0.016815186, -0.033569336, -0.056884766, 0.015701294, 0.018371582, 0.028137207, 0.036376953, -0.013244629, -0.042419434, -0.048339844, -0.03250122, 0.000975132, 0.05407715, 0.0002644062, -0.014884949, -0.027145386, -0.021194458, 0.046783447, 0.013542175, 0.008110046, -0.04660034, -0.0039863586, 0.010467529, 0.00020110607, 0.00033545494, 0.052368164, 0.0047416687, -0.00869751, 0.040405273, 0.009178162, 0.03277588, -0.013694763, -0.0087890625, 0.0259552, -0.021484375, -0.015525818, 0.0028476715, 0.029876709, -0.0076065063, -0.0056114197, 0.0048446655, -0.046813965, 0.042938232, -0.007659912, -0.00080156326, 0.04953003, -0.0056152344, 0.0067214966, 0.020828247, -0.00090408325, -0.08190918, 0.02734375, 0.0034389496, -0.12176514, 0.010284424, -0.044006348, 0.0025482178, 0.051330566, -0.023239136, -0.013809204, 0.017333984, -0.030136108, -0.023788452, 0.029281616, 0.006122589, -0.0066337585, -0.039733887, 0.008987427, -0.003206253, -0.0013980865, 0.018493652, 0.016799927, -0.03111267, -0.017364502, 0.0037975311, -0.018493652, -0.004459381, -0.006187439, -0.02279663, -0.030715942, 0.06317139, 0.031082153, -0.04611206, -0.00042653084, 0.008056641, 0.016998291, 0.023391724, 0.029846191, 0.036499023, -0.011169434, -0.007873535, 0.027267456, 0.030792236, 0.009552002, -0.016296387, -0.013259888, 0.001996994, 0.020050049, 0.039916992, 0.03878784, 0.032104492, 0.020080566, -0.010658264, 0.0116119385, 0.006919861, -0.02507019, 0.095336914, -0.017669678, -0.014724731, -0.0625, -0.06427002, -0.04562378, 0.007144928, -0.0036678314, -0.03237915, 0.04449463, -0.014732361, -0.02999878, 0.04321289, -0.034973145, 0.068115234, -0.028335571, 0.013160706, -0.033325195, 0.062805176, 0.009819031, -0.011428833, 0.03692627, -0.0010290146, 0.015159607, -0.029129028, 0.004184723, 0.030288696, -0.019805908, -0.037261963, -0.04119873, 0.028533936, -0.040985107, -0.0009889603, 0.009017944, 0.05508423, 0.010597229, -0.035339355, 0.04046631, -0.016342163, -0.030212402, 0.0054244995, 0.03540039, -0.035217285, 0.0010223389, -0.018035889, 0.0014743805, 0.004558563, -0.024230957, 0.016738892, 0.06088257, 0.029403687, -0.023864746, 0.018173218, 0.04714966, -0.003967285, -0.0056266785, -0.024871826, -0.026245117, 0.014007568, 0.040374756, 0.011276245, 0.016326904, 0.015853882, -0.016601562, 0.024505615, 0.044006348, -0.021743774, -0.010414124, -0.011749268, 0.005756378, 0.03640747, 0.027008057, 0.034942627, 0.009674072, -0.022949219, -0.00096845627, 0.03074646, -0.043395996, 0.012817383, -0.060028076, 0.064941406, -0.00868988, -0.0009741783, -0.11566162, -0.013412476, 0.07537842, 0.028884888, 0.01939392, 0.030914307, 0.01335907, -0.007858276, -0.04953003, -0.015579224, -0.00484848, -0.031951904, 0.07171631, -0.04626465, 0.033691406, -0.035247803, 0.0046081543, -0.027526855, -0.037597656, 0.026321411, -0.01247406, -0.04284668, 0.00907135, 0.028121948, -0.012954712, 0.009483337, -0.025680542, -0.021530151, 0.017669678, -0.0069770813, 0.016235352, -0.006942749, -0.027267456, -0.03149414, -0.006603241, 0.008979797, 0.0040130615, -0.045837402, -0.0038642883, 0.011497498, 0.04498291, 0.004890442, -0.0357666, 0.03652954, 0.00044298172, -0.006980896, 0.0256958, 0.032989502, -0.00040268898, -0.023406982, -0.03390503, 0.020904541, -0.042419434, 0.030410767, 0.014442444, -0.044311523, 0.027694702, 0.02180481, -0.03765869, 0.03756714, -0.002494812, 0.014694214, 0.033477783, -0.013809204, 0.03286743, 0.0065078735, 0.039916992, 0.031463623, -0.0047683716, -0.029251099, 0.0061569214, -0.014671326, 0.0057029724, -0.039276123, -0.0970459, 0.0061073303, 0.06451416, -0.024978638, 0.008544922, 0.0104904175, -0.004016876, 0.050109863, 0.043182373, 0.003791809, -0.026443481, -0.0046691895, 0.009689331, 0.022338867, 0.009719849, -0.012779236, 0.0012283325, 0.014862061, -0.038970947, -0.021591187, 0.046447754, 0.016723633, -0.0061531067, 0.023483276, 0.052490234, -0.04031372, -0.048706055, -0.007167816, -0.030731201, 0.013549805, 0.014549255, -0.0044403076, -0.0029830933, -0.022247314, 0.070495605, -0.013381958, -0.015068054, 0.0028038025, 0.008811951, 0.01751709, -0.0041275024, 0.0073623657, -0.00077962875, 0.006427765, 0.020629883, 0.013725281, 0.037628174, 0.02798462, -0.06652832, -0.014297485, -0.04660034, -0.058929443, -0.07550049, -0.049041748, 0.0023727417, -0.031951904, 0.031951904, 0.041412354, -0.017303467, 0.026153564, 0.012779236, 0.045806885, 0.031921387, -0.010276794, -0.051971436, 0.0012807846, 0.004386902 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07361v1
The Impact of Large Language Models on Scientific Discovery: a Preliminary Study using GPT-4
Microsoft Research AI4Science, Microsoft Azure Quantum
cs.CL, cs.AI
In recent years, groundbreaking advancements in natural language processing have culminated in the emergence of powerful large language models (LLMs), which have showcased remarkable capabilities across a vast array of domains, including the understanding, generation, and translation of natural language, and even tasks that extend beyond language processing. In this report, we delve into the performance of LLMs within the context of scientific discovery, focusing on GPT-4, the state-of-the-art language model. Our investigation spans a diverse range of scientific areas encompassing drug discovery, biology, computational chemistry (density functional theory (DFT) and molecular dynamics (MD)), materials design, and partial differential equations (PDE). Evaluating GPT-4 on scientific tasks is crucial for uncovering its potential across various research domains, validating its domain-specific expertise, accelerating scientific progress, optimizing resource allocation, guiding future model development, and fostering interdisciplinary research. Our exploration methodology primarily consists of expert-driven case assessments, which offer qualitative insights into the model's comprehension of intricate scientific concepts and relationships, and occasionally benchmark testing, which quantitatively evaluates the model's capacity to solve well-defined domain-specific problems. Our preliminary exploration indicates that GPT-4 exhibits promising potential for a variety of scientific applications, demonstrating its aptitude for handling complex problem-solving and knowledge integration tasks. Broadly speaking, we evaluate GPT-4's knowledge base, scientific understanding, scientific numerical calculation abilities, and various scientific prediction capabilities.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07361v1
2023-11-13T14:26:12
2023-11-13T14:26:12
{ "title": [ -0.037200928, -0.014450073, -0.045806885, -0.02760315, -0.007396698, -0.0064430237, -0.033294678, -0.008605957, -0.00050354004, 0.022628784, 0.010475159, -0.0057525635, -0.012428284, -0.029464722, -0.03970337, 0.013160706, -0.019134521, 0.037231445, -0.01020813, -0.035095215, 0.006542206, -0.04800415, 0.036712646, -0.029296875, 0.028045654, -0.06762695, -0.049987793, 0.016189575, -0.04083252, -0.045318604, -0.009590149, 0.034606934, 0.052490234, 0.028320312, -0.027236938, 0.0206604, -0.034210205, 0.012069702, -0.0018005371, 0.021133423, 0.008216858, 0.006313324, 0.005542755, -0.012435913, -0.03942871, 0.02166748, -0.069885254, -0.030776978, -0.008560181, 0.024475098, 0.0043258667, 0.020492554, -0.025512695, 0.029052734, 0.011604309, -0.020339966, -0.014945984, 0.007396698, 0.037231445, 0.038085938, 0.010070801, -0.033355713, 0.023773193, -0.011405945, -0.060760498, 0.00072050095, -0.029846191, -0.0040512085, 0.07989502, 0.010185242, -0.010116577, 0.017929077, -0.009353638, -0.005996704, -0.052368164, 0.017700195, 0.043701172, -0.0031051636, 0.02848816, -0.035064697, 0.020111084, -0.007522583, -0.0070152283, -0.0184021, 0.0026397705, -0.023376465, -0.025177002, -0.014442444, -0.018661499, -0.07446289, -0.0034713745, -0.039154053, -0.020233154, 0.021057129, -0.0029792786, -0.03652954, -0.0124435425, 0.00932312, -0.020614624, -0.026977539, -0.01184845, 0.012062073, -0.025650024, -0.01083374, 0.0014019012, 0.022384644, -0.015258789, -0.030212402, 0.0030460358, 0.040039062, -0.013748169, 0.0027828217, 0.014122009, 0.008972168, -0.000010848045, 0.01524353, -0.0008406639, 0.031585693, 0.0032844543, 0.04827881, -0.0069007874, -0.017318726, 0.0014352798, -0.0031318665, 0.034423828, -0.009132385, -0.052581787, 0.024749756, -0.032196045, 0.041381836, 0.029754639, 0.041870117, -0.13208008, -0.07867432, -0.08898926, 0.042663574, -0.006931305, -0.004611969, -0.005290985, 0.015419006, -0.018203735, -0.033569336, 0.009971619, -0.015777588, -0.0029411316, 0.0030765533, 0.054779053, 0.0028839111, -0.041229248, -0.04269409, -0.009147644, 0.01486969, 0.057006836, -0.032348633, -0.09362793, -0.0368042, -0.14978027, -0.0062942505, 0.013595581, -0.0025119781, -0.00223732, -0.0059928894, -0.023620605, -0.007347107, 0.009529114, 0.013191223, -0.003227234, 0.016357422, 0.012397766, -0.004627228, -0.017456055, 0.056396484, 0.015106201, -0.02633667, 0.0021362305, -0.010620117, 0.019165039, 0.0011100769, 0.019866943, 0.0019054413, 0.019073486, -0.009353638, -0.0041389465, 0.054870605, -0.038269043, -0.049224854, -0.0002477169, -0.008850098, 0.06640625, 0.0112838745, -0.05441284, 0.011009216, -0.04748535, -0.045166016, -0.028335571, 0.0065345764, 0.027008057, 0.02519226, 0.008834839, -0.023361206, -0.014160156, 0.005455017, -0.03036499, -0.0005197525, -0.02178955, -0.008628845, -0.013679504, 0.021240234, -0.0010738373, 0.03366089, 0.040039062, 0.029937744, -0.04095459, 0.0059013367, -0.020767212, -0.031311035, 0.044952393, 0.00919342, 0.017181396, -0.014083862, 0.014976501, -0.009002686, 0.030593872, 0.032165527, -0.018218994, 0.011070251, -0.00028467178, -0.019012451, 0.028244019, 0.032989502, 0.05380249, -0.0519104, 0.043701172, 0.02760315, 0.0028362274, -0.017166138, -0.008735657, -0.03125, 0.013221741, 0.0043525696, -0.003435135, -0.008979797, -0.038726807, -0.0121154785, 0.037597656, 0.00019872189, 0.00932312, -0.007080078, 0.034484863, 0.057281494, 0.04144287, 0.0287323, 0.035369873, -0.03213501, -0.00040912628, 0.06878662, 0.016204834, -0.020095825, 0.013069153, 0.024978638, 0.01637268, 0.02279663, -0.040405273, 0.02418518, -0.058380127, -0.0051841736, -0.048858643, -0.015838623, -0.0076026917, -0.0011692047, 0.051330566, -0.0010328293, 0.012084961, -0.014389038, -0.0060806274, -0.009628296, -0.027740479, 0.011627197, 0.012367249, -0.04953003, -0.012924194, 0.010231018, 0.021514893, 0.0019664764, 0.020355225, -0.006980896, 0.009086609, -0.01272583, 0.000828743, -0.0019426346, 0.049560547, 0.034729004, 0.015731812, 0.008338928, 0.01222229, 0.0016479492, 0.09020996, 0.059631348, -0.03010559, 0.048431396, -0.017501831, 0.027328491, 0.028015137, -0.024383545, 0.02180481, 0.029373169, 0.03842163, 0.017669678, -0.028793335, 0.014389038, -0.07244873, -0.0036258698, 0.009170532, 0.0022945404, -0.03967285, -0.052612305, -0.002002716, -0.014343262, -0.035888672, -0.036102295, 0.076171875, -0.012008667, -0.0071868896, -0.013771057, 0.007423401, -0.032440186, -0.014877319, -0.025817871, -0.01449585, 0.008903503, 0.03857422, 0.00077724457, -0.05303955, -0.03878784, -0.0048828125, 0.004169464, -0.012969971, 0.02015686, -0.032287598, 0.015670776, 0.008605957, 0.0074691772, 0.024398804, -0.052642822, -0.0051994324, -0.03225708, 0.027328491, 0.016952515, -0.0061073303, 0.011352539, -0.00067424774, -0.0075187683, 0.005794525, 0.032043457, 0.081726074, -0.042907715, -0.05606079, 0.046142578, 0.016082764, -0.023223877, 0.0112838745, 0.028808594, 0.00705719, -0.04574585, -0.029907227, -0.042510986, -0.033721924, 0.0020694733, 0.009101868, 0.03302002, -0.05307007, -0.0050315857, -0.03604126, -0.013694763, 0.025756836, -0.004184723, 0.003200531, -0.025405884, -0.036499023, -0.008201599, -0.00774765, 0.031051636, -0.042297363, 0.04638672, 0.097961426, -0.00044727325, -0.019500732, 0.009422302, 0.031097412, 0.014556885, -0.011238098, -0.026809692, -0.023086548, -0.003698349, -0.004146576, 0.013542175, -0.021011353, -0.030899048, -0.07196045, 0.004749298, 0.09118652, -0.0019226074, -0.007194519, 0.028564453, -0.07293701, 0.03616333, -0.0010900497, 0.01348114, 0.028152466, 0.027755737, 0.012939453, 0.014099121, 0.00617218, -0.016159058, 0.0031013489, -0.02935791, -0.10888672, 0.018615723, 0.01826477, -0.04135132, -0.043884277, -0.0079956055, -0.06628418, -0.012321472, -0.0104599, 0.046203613, 0.022750854, 0.011772156, 0.026550293, 0.025054932, 0.009796143, 0.004322052, -0.01914978, -0.013053894, -0.024978638, 0.062194824, 0.017913818, 0.079589844, 0.01626587, -0.0057792664, 0.0036354065, -0.013145447, -0.028198242, 0.020431519, 0.0053367615, -0.041809082, -0.0009293556, 0.012962341, 0.010398865, -0.0011720657, -0.013648987, -0.0036334991, -0.0025634766, 0.0061416626, -0.022506714, -0.010871887, 0.030303955, 0.019958496, -0.008682251, -0.024856567, 0.01689148, -0.038604736, -0.02961731, 0.025299072, 0.035827637, -0.003063202, 0.005756378, -0.0022907257, -0.010803223, -0.004627228, -0.018585205, 0.008964539, 0.008758545, 0.016921997, -0.015090942, 0.023925781, -0.007698059, 0.010475159, -0.034362793, 0.014701843, -0.03692627, 0.035949707, -0.051971436, -0.1307373, -0.047698975, 0.004032135, -0.13928223, -0.066711426, 0.0025730133, -0.03677368, -0.07421875, -0.04067993, 0.0124435425, -0.027786255, -0.029022217, 0.04006958, -0.018981934, 0.015640259, -0.0041389465, -0.073791504, -0.0018281937, 0.07507324, -0.0050315857, 0.013244629, 0.038208008, -0.0033740997, -0.0066986084, -0.026794434, 0.014724731, 0.021911621, 0.05130005, -0.002822876, -0.034210205, 0.04437256, -0.027297974, 0.03237915, 0.031402588, -0.007472992, 0.0129852295, 0.009140015, 0.010726929, 0.015327454, 0.0065574646, 0.030532837, -0.013366699, 0.010108948, -0.054901123, 0.035858154, -0.014640808, -0.0020198822, 0.019470215, -0.006137848, 0.0041160583, -0.005771637, 0.021621704, 0.053344727, -0.022140503, -0.015098572, 0.046691895, 0.0003976822, -0.0062026978, 0.00056028366, -0.0020332336, 0.04525757, 0.0025539398, 0.04168701, 0.0035266876, 0.070495605, -0.033813477, 0.0035991669, -0.0066833496, 0.021148682, -0.04345703, 0.0027217865, -0.050689697, -0.055633545, -0.03125, 0.0064048767, -0.0158844, 0.049316406, 0.050476074, -0.013023376, -0.010887146, -0.025177002, 0.06738281, 0.012802124, -0.03125, -0.101745605, 0.032104492, -0.024795532, -0.057281494, -0.040924072, -0.015342712, 0.00092840195, 0.02192688, 0.009918213, -0.0317688, -0.0048217773, 0.012451172, 0.07080078, 0.050201416, 0.0051231384, -0.06427002, 0.01550293, -0.034484863, -0.016677856, 0.009017944, -0.011100769, -0.013664246, -0.0076675415, 0.035247803, -0.010818481, -0.02154541, -0.048339844, 0.0287323, -0.003271103, 0.051971436, -0.0056648254, 0.0043411255, 0.023880005, 0.005970001, -0.015266418, -0.0028190613, -0.031433105, -0.008232117, -0.00881958, 0.026290894, 0.016540527, 0.03970337, 0.06591797, 0.0038661957, -0.021255493, 0.011489868, 0.028167725, 0.03186035, -0.025878906, -0.010131836, 0.008995056, -0.043792725, -0.028015137, -0.00015759468, -0.011497498, 0.04953003, -0.014862061, 0.027557373, -0.04486084, 0.0181427, 0.0029525757, -0.028060913, 0.0029315948, -0.0138168335, 0.021591187, -0.07507324, -0.07366943, -0.009162903, 0.072753906, -0.035949707, -0.0010728836, 0.010696411, 0.020446777, 0.013870239, 0.045928955, 0.044281006, -0.024368286, 0.0048332214, -0.021896362, -0.016586304, -0.013282776, -0.053375244, 0.016418457, -0.00076150894, 0.019454956, -0.066101074, 0.020309448, -0.06518555, -0.010536194, -0.008300781, -0.036376953, 0.0519104, -0.08081055, 0.004589081, 0.06573486, 0.0025367737, 0.03781128, -0.007461548, 0.00995636, 0.013313293, 0.046722412, -0.006416321, 0.011520386, 0.018066406, -0.017150879, -0.012275696, -0.005378723, 0.023071289, 0.010421753, 0.034118652, 0.011009216, 0.01398468, -0.057250977, 0.026931763, -0.009902954, -0.007411957, 0.035339355, -0.06506348, 0.002374649, -0.015975952, -0.0042304993, -0.0003964901, -0.02079773, 0.006832123, 0.028381348, -0.017562866, -0.0070762634, 0.038848877, 0.0056915283, -0.039031982, -0.062194824, 0.012214661, -0.014228821, 0.008666992, 0.001203537, 0.0054512024, -0.033172607, 0.036102295, -0.00082445145, -0.068847656, -0.016921997, -0.006778717, 0.017349243, 0.028839111, 0.025238037, -0.00021445751, 0.0066719055, -0.030319214, -0.054229736, -0.03173828, 0.0018892288, -0.011657715, 0.029922485, -0.0047454834, -0.02468872, -0.0019702911, 0.015327454, 0.030044556, 0.010803223, -0.016616821, 0.032958984, -0.008232117, -0.012199402, -0.0032787323, 0.02394104, -0.013946533, 0.007419586, 0.004421234, -0.041381836, -0.00080394745, 0.00504303, 0.021331787, -0.04196167, -0.072509766, 0.006210327, 0.01852417, 0.0026016235, -0.0011129379, 0.019424438, 0.03060913, 0.026290894, -0.01474762, 0.0054473877, 0.051849365, -0.050872803, -0.023986816, 0.014251709, 0.001619339, -0.017074585, 0.07635498, 0.019744873, -0.0011901855, -0.046020508, -0.051849365, -0.022384644, 0.004436493, 0.020904541, 0.014976501, 0.013870239, 0.0032444, 0.0552063, -0.04660034, -0.0068511963, -0.0362854, 0.0074424744, -0.0116119385, -0.050048828, 0.03540039, 0.008110046, -0.03189087, -0.013671875, 0.034454346, 0.030517578, -0.0012102127, 0.019546509, -0.0119018555, -0.006679535, -0.03781128, -0.03326416, 0.039978027, 0.02418518, -0.036895752, 0.045806885, 0.0006046295, 0.058807373, 0.027359009, 0.0657959, 0.03967285, 0.014732361, 0.031341553, 0.00033307076, 0.0060577393, -0.02784729, -0.005836487, -0.024887085, -0.015167236, -0.06311035, -0.011505127, -0.05307007, 0.027191162, -0.009063721, 0.0036334991, -0.0047340393, 0.0030765533, -0.0014667511, 0.008590698, 0.026901245, 0.029800415, 0.04486084, 0.0038528442, 0.025909424, -0.011352539, -0.06604004, 0.013305664, 0.04525757, -0.030181885, 0.0024871826, -0.030792236, 0.007659912, 0.002248764, -0.015060425, -0.005756378, -0.022964478, -0.0013885498, -0.028808594, 0.035095215, -0.0066375732, 0.036071777, 0.06274414, 0.025314331, 0.006034851, -0.018844604, -0.002790451, -0.036071777, -0.009628296, -0.026748657, 0.012123108, -0.045684814, 0.016586304, -0.017990112, -0.014717102, -0.044067383, 0.03149414, 0.02267456, -0.045196533, -0.031982422, -0.002500534, 0.057617188, 0.013458252, -0.017059326, -0.036865234, -0.029190063, 0.010322571, 0.040252686, -0.01600647, 0.031829834, 0.004875183, 0.047576904, -0.006477356, -0.027496338, 0.0036754608, -0.017059326, -0.003168106, 0.031173706, 0.003458023, 0.008163452, -0.007850647, -0.031555176, 0.00762558, 0.013961792, -0.031280518, -0.014183044, 0.033477783, 0.008026123, 0.016967773, 0.056762695, 0.028030396, -0.009643555, -0.019180298, -0.046691895, -0.0042037964, 0.061035156, -0.024520874, 0.031158447, -0.05279541, -0.058135986, 0.04046631, -0.06640625, 0.06518555, -0.062408447, 0.008453369, -0.0064086914, 0.022537231, 0.032165527, -0.039001465, -0.053833008, 0.020355225, -0.031066895, 0.006210327, 0.0027885437, -0.036010742, -0.032043457, 0.0013523102, -0.0015478134, -0.0046539307, -0.001080513, -0.0005660057, -0.03439331, -0.08087158, 0.009475708, -0.016235352, 0.047302246, -0.026687622, 0.008758545, -0.016433716, 0.004863739, -0.0037574768, -0.024841309, -0.023757935, -0.013038635, -0.02583313, -0.019805908, 0.004966736, 0.01838684, -0.02130127, -0.050933838, -0.03555298, -0.0065345764, -0.041809082, 0.03100586, 0.0039367676, -0.060516357, 0.0079956055, 0.0058631897, -0.016998291, 0.036102295, 0.023773193, -0.014793396, 0.029022217, 0.0053138733, -0.028060913, 0.008132935, 0.0067481995, 0.030670166, -0.01512146, -0.0413208, -0.005130768, 0.029174805, 0.020599365, -0.06011963, -0.025024414, 0.03475952, 0.03744507, -0.0030956268, 0.01914978, 0.019088745, -0.006855011, 0.030822754, 0.005680084, 0.008560181, -0.044891357, 0.011650085, -0.0071907043, 0.022628784, 0.038330078, 0.0044174194, 0.0037670135, 0.028015137, -0.042175293, 0.0006890297, 0.018737793, -0.004070282, 0.027633667, 0.0004515648, 0.03338623, -0.036987305, 0.008804321, -0.022857666, -0.027816772, 0.0070114136, 0.012992859, -0.023162842, 0.0076293945, -0.049957275, 0.03817749, -0.021209717, -0.05041504, 0.05178833, 0.040924072, 0.02609253, 0.017578125, 0.0104904175, 0.0009841919, 0.0079956055, -0.013259888, -0.015274048, -0.0053863525, 0.020385742, -0.03475952, -0.008132935, -0.020599365, -0.0048561096, -0.03717041, -0.03491211, 0.051086426, -0.015029907, -0.001490593, -0.04586792, -0.023208618, -0.004398346, 0.020812988, 0.009155273, -0.033050537, -0.042114258, -0.047607422, 0.032562256, -0.015449524 ], "summary": [ -0.020553589, -0.010681152, -0.009048462, 0.0017547607, -0.038116455, 0.0011253357, -0.0362854, -0.0051116943, 0.008262634, 0.036865234, 0.015548706, -0.0027256012, -0.0016431808, -0.044067383, -0.004432678, 0.00023710728, -0.014564514, 0.01777649, -0.001742363, -0.03479004, 0.03967285, -0.059265137, -0.0032138824, -0.062683105, 0.018920898, -0.07470703, -0.020584106, 0.00082731247, -0.006038666, -0.00036501884, 0.002286911, 0.0340271, 0.022720337, -0.008323669, 0.0032806396, 0.015586853, -0.020645142, 0.00066661835, 0.014877319, -0.0064926147, 0.019958496, -0.00024282932, 0.08660889, -0.008255005, -0.005012512, 0.049713135, -0.03878784, -0.041412354, 0.036071777, 0.0065689087, -0.0030555725, 0.03149414, -0.016342163, -0.010322571, -0.036468506, -0.005973816, -0.030334473, 0.009536743, 0.029281616, 0.06085205, -0.0060768127, 0.0026683807, -0.00021469593, -0.057556152, -0.020019531, 0.009048462, -0.033721924, -0.023590088, 0.06591797, 0.014427185, -0.0096588135, 0.005748749, 0.017028809, -0.039978027, -0.01309967, 0.03125, 0.006095886, 0.0031661987, 0.014923096, -0.041412354, 0.012542725, 0.026153564, -0.021514893, -0.023635864, 0.0041923523, -0.018981934, -0.017456055, -0.027877808, 0.013046265, -0.04260254, -0.0034103394, -0.010879517, -0.012809753, 0.028259277, 0.0058555603, -0.059814453, 0.0039138794, -0.064086914, -0.005466461, -0.016738892, 0.064453125, -0.0670166, 0.055908203, -0.000849247, -0.012863159, 0.04244995, -0.008094788, -0.039245605, -0.025909424, 0.012428284, -0.015312195, -0.07550049, 0.042785645, -0.0050735474, -0.018630981, -0.001332283, 0.023544312, 0.06262207, -0.008171082, 0.06384277, -0.008934021, -0.00075626373, -0.004623413, 0.020385742, 0.020080566, 0.012763977, -0.012672424, 0.013298035, -0.009651184, 0.03741455, 0.025299072, 0.035491943, -0.10412598, -0.049926758, -0.09716797, 0.0075645447, 0.02999878, 0.020401001, 0.010292053, -0.018356323, -0.0022087097, -0.045898438, -0.0141067505, 0.017059326, 0.0066375732, 0.02949524, 0.029251099, 0.010772705, -0.020263672, -0.030883789, -0.004348755, 0.015045166, 0.039031982, -0.061187744, -0.049713135, -0.07318115, -0.10247803, 0.0017681122, 0.03427124, -0.0026988983, 0.02835083, 0.01374054, 0.007675171, 0.022750854, -0.02255249, 0.016723633, -0.01902771, -0.0137786865, 0.013771057, -0.035888672, -0.0028362274, 0.05532837, 0.00013685226, -0.035125732, 0.0021705627, -0.027572632, -0.015464783, 0.021026611, 0.017654419, 0.00027537346, 0.0037956238, -0.0345459, 0.017700195, 0.016418457, 0.030654907, -0.051574707, 0.02053833, 0.010124207, 0.021942139, 0.019195557, -0.049468994, -0.03338623, -0.0231781, -0.0033779144, 0.009300232, -0.001332283, -0.010231018, 0.010322571, -0.0064468384, -0.022781372, 0.023223877, 0.022247314, -0.006374359, -0.03805542, -0.07244873, 0.0038013458, -0.006641388, 0.03515625, 0.03390503, 0.012245178, 0.0181427, -0.010795593, -0.023849487, 0.057434082, -0.039276123, -0.058044434, 0.039642334, 0.00970459, 0.015319824, -0.0013723373, 0.042266846, 0.037231445, 0.013442993, 0.022018433, -0.026306152, 0.025405884, 0.00042533875, 0.020324707, 0.04449463, 0.035095215, 0.05496216, -0.074279785, 0.04562378, 0.049926758, -0.007858276, -0.014694214, 0.013458252, -0.07220459, 0.019607544, 0.030548096, 0.010520935, 0.013465881, -0.054718018, -0.029190063, 0.032073975, 0.041809082, 0.032196045, -0.03451538, 0.035125732, 0.09729004, -0.012748718, -0.00009685755, 0.004180908, -0.047058105, -0.015510559, 0.05456543, 0.0067863464, -0.018325806, 0.01713562, 0.011634827, 0.017593384, 0.04083252, -0.012420654, 0.01424408, -0.019454956, -0.0491333, -0.029953003, -0.02229309, -0.014221191, -0.023590088, 0.03945923, -0.010475159, -0.010421753, -0.047973633, -0.046295166, -0.012817383, -0.03274536, 0.05303955, -0.0012388229, -0.03942871, -0.0064582825, -0.00005733967, -0.023269653, -0.003019333, 0.023330688, 0.028442383, 0.0001411438, 0.00548172, 0.041137695, 0.061950684, 0.059906006, 0.0006580353, -0.001285553, 0.034210205, 0.004753113, -0.0128479, 0.05050659, 0.04824829, -0.014587402, 0.01979065, 0.025741577, 0.03161621, 0.0006098747, -0.007019043, 0.020431519, 0.026931763, 0.032104492, -0.0121154785, 0.0073242188, 0.037475586, -0.064086914, -0.0062332153, 0.033325195, 0.07141113, -0.045410156, -0.049835205, -0.030975342, 0.032287598, -0.07092285, -0.04171753, 0.05142212, 0.018051147, 0.002565384, 0.0151901245, 0.009048462, -0.039642334, 0.032958984, -0.009841919, -0.012329102, -0.01737976, -0.018936157, -0.026687622, -0.03466797, 0.014305115, -0.0063285828, 0.014930725, -0.0030002594, 0.026809692, -0.01687622, 0.028182983, 0.004310608, -0.019821167, -0.00092601776, -0.058746338, -0.026794434, 0.00466156, 0.027236938, -0.010787964, 0.04309082, 0.022460938, -0.028640747, 0.003025055, 0.03604126, 0.057434082, 0.06378174, -0.027801514, -0.04260254, 0.043029785, 0.0036735535, -0.0395813, -0.0031108856, 0.04586792, 0.0019569397, -0.053985596, -0.034057617, -0.037322998, 0.0017681122, 0.0007944107, 0.037109375, 0.016937256, 0.0032367706, 0.049957275, -0.050079346, -0.017440796, 0.0053253174, -0.01789856, 0.07366943, -0.006778717, 0.012893677, 0.059936523, 0.02986145, 0.05718994, -0.034576416, 0.01423645, 0.058929443, 0.0035076141, -0.030838013, -0.014602661, 0.034973145, 0.022155762, -0.01574707, -0.051361084, 0.02670288, -0.016479492, 0.009552002, -0.007083893, -0.036743164, -0.013473511, -0.042419434, -0.005870819, 0.074645996, 0.03201294, 0.037139893, 0.017044067, -0.06335449, 0.061920166, -0.007904053, 0.035369873, 0.032958984, -0.034118652, 0.021011353, -0.050567627, -0.019317627, -0.04815674, -0.013587952, -0.02420044, -0.015655518, 0.012084961, 0.022018433, -0.032989502, -0.04824829, 0.04812622, -0.012786865, 0.011657715, -0.0061073303, 0.037109375, -0.014419556, 0.0013217926, -0.0079956055, 0.041412354, -0.008094788, 0.0076942444, -0.034332275, 0.0066871643, -0.014625549, 0.062072754, 0.009979248, 0.0048179626, 0.035949707, -0.034362793, 0.038208008, -0.0034446716, -0.038269043, -0.013626099, -0.01411438, -0.049041748, 0.023345947, 0.012229919, 0.026748657, 0.01574707, 0.003036499, -0.0055236816, 0.023742676, 0.017364502, -0.03704834, 0.0033798218, -0.035125732, 0.031982422, 0.029037476, -0.056762695, 0.0032424927, -0.043518066, -0.01889038, 0.0077056885, 0.0040016174, 0.016418457, -0.01335907, 0.030700684, 0.00014662743, -0.029632568, 0.027450562, -0.0075569153, 0.0024909973, -0.019897461, -0.014328003, -0.03555298, 0.058044434, -0.00060892105, 0.015174866, -0.043273926, -0.09338379, 0.048919678, -0.07299805, -0.11828613, -0.06530762, 0.0064735413, -0.082458496, -0.07019043, -0.0048065186, -0.0006055832, -0.05960083, -0.0047416687, 0.0140686035, -0.01525116, -0.014167786, 0.034973145, -0.017669678, 0.07623291, 0.013053894, -0.059020996, 0.0102005005, 0.004470825, 0.0063934326, 0.019424438, 0.0058631897, 0.0025577545, 0.02420044, 0.025344849, 0.032592773, -0.005554199, 0.07531738, -0.00579834, -0.02456665, -0.015701294, -0.016662598, 0.0011339188, 0.031280518, -0.04171753, 0.024307251, 0.01953125, 0.05831909, 0.043273926, 0.0036754608, -0.002401352, -0.0014190674, 0.037078857, -0.053863525, 0.021575928, -0.014625549, -0.025634766, 0.018234253, 0.0061950684, -0.047790527, -0.00062799454, 0.034698486, 0.02142334, -0.05126953, -0.024124146, 0.013824463, 0.01512146, -0.011306763, -0.02923584, -0.015853882, 0.053833008, -0.02015686, 0.037078857, -0.022109985, 0.08618164, -0.08508301, 0.045715332, 0.0067214966, 0.008895874, -0.049224854, -0.015274048, 0.00077676773, -0.04699707, -0.04071045, 0.03366089, -0.015716553, -0.0054855347, 0.03945923, -0.009880066, 0.017547607, -0.024383545, 0.08483887, 0.011123657, -0.055541992, -0.13537598, 0.0027656555, -0.020111084, -0.033325195, -0.020233154, -0.032928467, -0.025390625, -0.035827637, 0.018707275, -0.033050537, -0.011459351, 0.004070282, 0.06213379, 0.0178833, 0.039123535, -0.051513672, -0.040771484, -0.020202637, -0.002046585, -0.016540527, -0.0023479462, -0.03945923, -0.00340271, 0.029525757, -0.014099121, -0.02078247, -0.040740967, 0.003917694, 0.011192322, 0.0057373047, -0.015151978, 0.021057129, -0.0020942688, 0.028640747, -0.0118255615, -0.0010652542, -0.00046372414, -0.016189575, -0.011528015, 0.008110046, 0.048614502, 0.018417358, 0.057525635, -0.0079574585, -0.050354004, 0.016525269, 0.032073975, 0.02017212, -0.01386261, -0.02268982, 0.007358551, -0.0076065063, 0.008460999, 0.031066895, -0.025817871, 0.032958984, 0.04925537, -0.04071045, -0.015556335, 0.049987793, -0.015533447, -0.036987305, 0.032714844, -0.0052490234, 0.021865845, -0.041046143, -0.08947754, -0.024658203, 0.08117676, 0.0033569336, -0.034698486, -0.021347046, 0.0015439987, 0.011985779, 0.028060913, 0.03253174, -0.02204895, 0.03225708, -0.018478394, 0.0004518032, 0.0015640259, -0.014076233, -0.0063438416, -0.0029277802, 0.008987427, -0.04296875, 0.0011234283, 0.029327393, -0.03173828, 0.0034313202, -0.020004272, 0.031921387, -0.052368164, -0.032684326, 0.022277832, -0.038116455, 0.015655518, 0.04257202, -0.009162903, -0.0473938, 0.019958496, -0.041656494, 0.019683838, -0.010467529, -0.036346436, -0.042816162, -0.018615723, 0.009712219, 0.018188477, 0.03074646, 0.028152466, 0.027816772, -0.045196533, -0.002319336, -0.041412354, 0.03164673, 0.009513855, -0.030563354, 0.012763977, -0.0008149147, 0.011405945, -0.018051147, 0.004383087, 0.016555786, 0.040924072, -0.01399231, 0.041778564, 0.012535095, -0.0053138733, -0.015716553, -0.032592773, 0.0044288635, -0.04437256, 0.034362793, -0.0021800995, -0.012145996, -0.018112183, 0.014533997, -0.032165527, -0.026107788, -0.027664185, 0.033599854, 0.007911682, -0.010093689, 0.018585205, 0.0065841675, -0.0023822784, -0.05166626, -0.036132812, -0.025817871, -0.008239746, -0.007980347, 0.058380127, 0.0015707016, -0.012466431, -0.016967773, 0.0067634583, 0.03540039, -0.027999878, -0.052520752, 0.00844574, -0.038391113, -0.060180664, 0.0047836304, 0.01184082, -0.03112793, -0.009811401, -0.0001847744, -0.04333496, -0.013572693, 0.009719849, 0.0066375732, -0.07574463, -0.040771484, -0.01979065, 0.029006958, 0.0057373047, 0.0010242462, 0.01876831, 0.014335632, 0.013885498, -0.03149414, 0.0025730133, 0.0028591156, -0.04156494, 0.011749268, 0.0039711, 0.011375427, -0.020736694, 0.034851074, 0.019134521, 0.021606445, -0.027404785, -0.06439209, 0.004962921, -0.009292603, 0.010444641, 0.037963867, 0.023208618, 0.011039734, 0.04812622, -0.035217285, -0.022567749, -0.018417358, 0.008964539, -0.03878784, -0.06262207, 0.089416504, 0.008285522, -0.06036377, 0.042633057, 0.01625061, 0.043914795, 0.015182495, 0.039276123, 0.011260986, -0.026733398, -0.028656006, 0.03475952, 0.022521973, 0.05227661, -0.038146973, 0.010757446, 0.015419006, 0.039886475, 0.0041007996, 0.00047779083, -0.01171875, -0.013442993, 0.025543213, -0.0075416565, -0.01486969, -0.0088272095, 0.0016613007, 0.019943237, -0.042297363, -0.05267334, -0.04788208, 0.004081726, 0.058410645, -0.035736084, -0.009941101, 0.021270752, -0.005290985, -0.0109939575, 0.029571533, -0.01096344, 0.012748718, 0.010032654, -0.005859375, 0.00031495094, 0.017349243, -0.05834961, 0.016082764, 0.056121826, -0.035125732, 0.020263672, -0.023513794, 0.01171875, 0.03491211, -0.051971436, -0.009567261, -0.029876709, 0.009315491, -0.035827637, 0.036468506, 0.05130005, 0.05596924, -0.024398804, -0.019500732, 0.043701172, -0.0121154785, -0.030471802, 0.039276123, 0.024963379, 0.0018348694, 0.017715454, 0.017089844, 0.009635925, 0.033294678, -0.040740967, 0.01436615, 0.027297974, 0.018875122, -0.0044059753, 0.0035495758, -0.0021953583, 0.022781372, -0.0044021606, -0.037109375, -0.033721924, -0.0107421875, 0.023498535, 0.001420021, 0.00869751, 0.017410278, 0.012496948, 0.025558472, 0.015060425, -0.020980835, -0.004119873, -0.022583008, -0.0047035217, 0.028045654, 0.04840088, 0.010032654, -0.018005371, -0.019134521, 0.01222229, 0.016235352, -0.006088257, 0.007850647, 0.029922485, -0.008834839, 0.022903442, 0.012275696, -0.045959473, 0.004802704, 0.045532227, -0.00843811, -0.0017776489, 0.0038814545, 0.022659302, -0.003982544, -0.053985596, -0.0051193237, -0.031066895, -0.0088272095, 0.03427124, -0.05758667, 0.014228821, -0.04232788, 0.02758789, -0.0368042, -0.0027122498, -0.042510986, -0.01876831, 0.0056533813, 0.023406982, 0.017440796, -0.049713135, 0.013893127, -0.010795593, -0.027145386, -0.008079529, -0.0046310425, 0.005180359, -0.012565613, -0.055236816, 0.020843506, 0.0079956055, 0.064819336, -0.000027656555, -0.013961792, 0.011795044, 0.012191772, -0.008911133, -0.04626465, -0.014579773, -0.005001068, -0.0003669262, 0.003955841, 0.01373291, 0.040863037, 0.0058937073, -0.066345215, -0.0026798248, -0.011146545, -0.034118652, 0.04119873, 0.013511658, -0.021499634, 0.0058631897, 0.008850098, -0.0154800415, 0.02494812, -0.010314941, -0.022201538, 0.047424316, -0.01701355, -0.00737381, -0.007610321, 0.0029525757, -0.0069732666, -0.010765076, -0.022079468, -0.011474609, 0.00018155575, 0.019195557, -0.047088623, -0.05984497, 0.001996994, 0.037384033, 0.01209259, -0.02128601, -0.026260376, -0.016906738, 0.0440979, -0.0048446655, 0.017059326, -0.011764526, 0.07879639, 0.023635864, 0.004951477, 0.023361206, -0.02281189, 0.032073975, 0.012451172, -0.036499023, 0.011924744, 0.011116028, 0.00080776215, 0.022354126, -0.03378296, 0.006210327, -0.039154053, 0.0042495728, 0.015945435, -0.016433716, -0.008918762, -0.021743774, -0.026473999, -0.008110046, -0.046203613, -0.04119873, -0.03378296, 0.021011353, -0.0023880005, 0.00010192394, 0.021499634, -0.01979065, 0.022705078, 0.03842163, -0.007911682, 0.00064992905, -0.020339966, -0.012702942, 0.03555298, -0.023025513, -0.0068855286, 0.014564514, 0.023162842, -0.048461914, -0.00995636, 0.033966064, -0.007167816, -0.019104004, 0.0064201355, -0.0184021, 0.013137817, 0.018051147, 0.004196167, -0.015144348, 0.0039482117, -0.0446167, -0.007045746, 0.012306213 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07314v1
Semi-automatic Data Enhancement for Document-Level Relation Extraction with Distant Supervision from Large Language Models
Junpeng Li, Zixia Jia, Zilong Zheng
cs.CL, cs.AI
Document-level Relation Extraction (DocRE), which aims to extract relations from a long context, is a critical challenge in achieving fine-grained structural comprehension and generating interpretable document representations. Inspired by recent advances in in-context learning capabilities emergent from large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, we aim to design an automated annotation method for DocRE with minimum human effort. Unfortunately, vanilla in-context learning is infeasible for document-level relation extraction due to the plenty of predefined fine-grained relation types and the uncontrolled generations of LLMs. To tackle this issue, we propose a method integrating a large language model (LLM) and a natural language inference (NLI) module to generate relation triples, thereby augmenting document-level relation datasets. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach by introducing an enhanced dataset known as DocGNRE, which excels in re-annotating numerous long-tail relation types. We are confident that our method holds the potential for broader applications in domain-specific relation type definitions and offers tangible benefits in advancing generalized language semantic comprehension.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07314v1
2023-11-13T13:10:44
2023-11-13T13:10:44
{ "title": [ -0.0033226013, -0.0048332214, -0.045440674, -0.10534668, 0.007068634, 0.003545761, -0.06604004, 0.012573242, 0.030593872, 0.008361816, -0.035217285, -0.009605408, 0.011802673, -0.011222839, -0.035858154, -0.010955811, -0.018936157, 0.046142578, -0.030685425, -0.044006348, -0.0015802383, -0.07043457, 0.017486572, -0.02571106, 0.039855957, -0.067993164, -0.02267456, 0.015716553, -0.001329422, -0.01751709, 0.009773254, -0.023040771, 0.04397583, 0.010910034, -0.013412476, 0.00081062317, -0.024612427, 0.0043258667, -0.0076446533, 0.008712769, 0.02458191, -0.01007843, -0.009819031, -0.017364502, -0.03768921, 0.047821045, -0.06011963, -0.022735596, -0.00093460083, 0.03225708, -0.007911682, 0.028961182, -0.030380249, 0.041992188, 0.017593384, -0.045288086, -0.029220581, 0.0051193237, 0.023895264, 0.05053711, 0.024337769, -0.02104187, -0.0015697479, -0.012634277, -0.03967285, -0.021774292, -0.030410767, 0.015777588, 0.04736328, -0.026260376, -0.016952515, 0.010887146, -0.0032844543, -0.009544373, -0.055480957, 0.026855469, 0.017410278, 0.0039711, 0.043701172, -0.027755737, -0.01675415, 0.022079468, -0.013130188, -0.012321472, 0.029693604, -0.004966736, -0.034240723, -0.02758789, -0.031921387, -0.06008911, 0.00062036514, -0.03375244, -0.05609131, 0.021713257, 0.002614975, -0.03387451, -0.00093126297, 0.059661865, -0.011550903, -0.033294678, -0.017684937, 0.032165527, -0.06518555, -0.018066406, 0.026870728, 0.012771606, -0.012466431, -0.050811768, 0.025100708, 0.018127441, -0.03314209, 0.06173706, -0.0028419495, -0.0036125183, -0.019454956, 0.026107788, -0.00007861853, 0.008575439, 0.017944336, 0.032958984, -0.005645752, -0.009765625, -0.039123535, 0.02748108, 0.009689331, -0.014633179, -0.030426025, 0.05960083, 0.00970459, -0.00066423416, 0.026977539, 0.039642334, -0.10235596, -0.074401855, -0.06866455, 0.059753418, -0.011741638, -0.0026893616, -0.00007212162, -0.010734558, 0.03878784, -0.019165039, 0.0006227493, 0.037384033, -0.022857666, 0.00881958, 0.06774902, -0.011962891, -0.06738281, -0.013885498, -0.05886841, 0.041656494, 0.052215576, -0.04333496, -0.0748291, -0.07574463, -0.11505127, -0.046905518, 0.04800415, -0.041290283, 0.03817749, 0.008384705, -0.011207581, -0.028411865, -0.011192322, -0.02331543, -0.022567749, 0.0073280334, 0.027542114, 0.016586304, -0.014572144, 0.0058288574, 0.027694702, 0.01550293, 0.00058984756, 0.03024292, 0.022903442, 0.003704071, -0.0064048767, 0.008049011, 0.021102905, -0.029205322, -0.024490356, 0.058288574, -0.047943115, -0.01777649, 0.008308411, 0.011192322, 0.058532715, 0.01525116, -0.035186768, 0.017074585, -0.034729004, -0.03729248, -0.0368042, -0.013168335, 0.043640137, 0.012939453, 0.015060425, 0.01727295, -0.034942627, 0.0030784607, -0.040924072, 0.0110321045, 0.008758545, -0.046783447, 0.0019702911, -0.0027008057, -0.017333984, 0.050323486, 0.06536865, 0.03338623, -0.065979004, 0.014976501, -0.00566864, -0.054107666, 0.02935791, -0.0007944107, 0.010032654, -0.013298035, 0.011238098, -0.010696411, 0.016189575, 0.039855957, -0.009498596, -0.016662598, 0.006290436, -0.019226074, -0.003408432, 0.016983032, 0.055877686, -0.024383545, 0.049957275, 0.058288574, 0.008598328, -0.020843506, 0.0058174133, -0.022140503, 0.012168884, -0.0040016174, 0.0012969971, -0.007446289, -0.017410278, 0.0076942444, 0.026809692, -0.034820557, 0.0059928894, -0.00013947487, 0.020187378, 0.010612488, 0.030700684, 0.005619049, 0.036071777, 0.025848389, 0.0095825195, 0.046447754, 0.020126343, -0.011436462, -0.0413208, 0.032958984, 0.015106201, -0.021224976, -0.036865234, 0.0042762756, -0.045806885, 0.010757446, -0.015556335, 0.010543823, -0.0069732666, -0.0030612946, 0.028167725, 0.029464722, 0.00932312, -0.032592773, -0.034057617, -0.014915466, -0.011657715, 0.042999268, 0.014320374, -0.058624268, -0.01638794, 0.008262634, 0.060028076, 0.00029468536, 0.008728027, -0.0026474, 0.027755737, -0.030151367, -0.05758667, -0.020828247, 0.02772522, 0.0368042, 0.0061302185, -0.025604248, 0.01626587, 0.020095825, 0.12597656, 0.05682373, -0.012077332, 0.04827881, -0.02130127, 0.025100708, 0.0045051575, 0.008590698, 0.025848389, 0.02658081, 0.039276123, 0.020446777, -0.011207581, 0.038848877, -0.064086914, 0.008735657, -0.00970459, 0.007709503, -0.082092285, -0.06768799, -0.007926941, -0.044799805, -0.06311035, -0.031677246, 0.053344727, -0.03314209, -0.03274536, 0.008049011, -0.015090942, -0.005191803, 0.012611389, -0.024337769, -0.0027389526, 0.018371582, 0.011894226, 0.009643555, -0.06628418, -0.0004851818, -0.009895325, 0.0067825317, -0.011329651, -0.011672974, -0.023101807, 0.031433105, 0.023422241, -0.03579712, 0.014816284, -0.053955078, -0.017211914, -0.026916504, 0.044403076, 0.014221191, -0.015388489, -0.012023926, 0.008972168, -0.028320312, 0.0055618286, 0.055114746, 0.09362793, -0.037506104, -0.053894043, 0.06304932, 0.0113220215, -0.0056419373, 0.021331787, 0.032714844, 0.012649536, -0.0592041, -0.03201294, -0.035491943, -0.011192322, -0.012901306, 0.021347046, 0.051635742, -0.05026245, -0.00039291382, -0.055633545, -0.000500679, 0.040985107, -0.00036001205, 0.03555298, -0.0046539307, -0.04928589, 0.0002913475, 0.0049057007, 0.023483276, -0.044311523, 0.014129639, 0.050964355, 0.02154541, -0.010177612, 0.0038604736, 0.01259613, -0.0007863045, -0.016677856, 0.004638672, -0.006225586, -0.016723633, 0.040527344, 0.019088745, -0.007987976, 0.0064468384, -0.06732178, -0.02558899, 0.039245605, 0.010818481, -0.0137786865, 0.030700684, -0.07873535, 0.016357422, -0.029266357, -0.02859497, 0.031951904, 0.03414917, -0.016921997, 0.036743164, -0.0067443848, -0.008102417, -0.024627686, -0.014076233, -0.07501221, 0.019989014, 0.0012350082, -0.04736328, -0.017196655, -0.034210205, -0.059326172, -0.017364502, -0.005821228, 0.023773193, 0.015350342, 0.0025138855, 0.014923096, 0.0065574646, -0.012084961, -0.016159058, -0.026626587, -0.032836914, -0.019805908, 0.021972656, -0.0039978027, 0.05505371, -0.004146576, 0.008712769, -0.03152466, 0.006717682, -0.01625061, 0.009857178, 0.008544922, -0.04937744, 0.011436462, -0.0044174194, 0.00072813034, 0.0105896, -0.02229309, -0.0041046143, -0.04272461, 0.004966736, -0.028442383, 0.0078125, -0.02154541, 0.005924225, -0.037200928, -0.005367279, 0.028152466, -0.011047363, -0.040893555, -0.0013370514, 0.07208252, 0.0046043396, -0.057128906, -0.010276794, -0.040130615, 0.03302002, 0.02960205, -0.025985718, -0.013298035, -0.017700195, -0.002298355, -0.008758545, 0.0005760193, -0.0025634766, 0.012435913, 0.0007839203, 0.0060043335, 0.004108429, -0.011993408, -0.074401855, 0.005542755, -0.01838684, -0.1303711, -0.05178833, 0.004337311, -0.019454956, -0.03656006, -0.05215454, 0.02067566, -0.023101807, -0.05114746, 0.049072266, -0.018127441, -0.0047302246, -0.0035076141, -0.08337402, 0.007621765, 0.08166504, 0.026657104, 0.0340271, 0.0670166, -0.00223732, -0.04473877, -0.01121521, 0.026641846, 0.008338928, 0.035186768, 0.010353088, -0.048034668, 0.01184845, -0.02003479, 0.014480591, 0.046051025, -0.011978149, 0.024017334, -0.003627777, -0.0071105957, -0.001206398, -0.0020370483, 0.05154419, 0.01360321, -0.00894928, -0.059509277, 0.015213013, -0.023986816, 0.009056091, 0.007446289, -0.013015747, 0.027313232, -0.0024871826, 0.0028934479, 0.03768921, -0.0066337585, -0.01084137, 0.07495117, 0.02909851, -0.002243042, -0.016738892, 0.011550903, 0.059753418, 0.009506226, 0.03945923, -0.020492554, 0.023635864, -0.006828308, -0.02734375, -0.015563965, 0.0007638931, -0.02357483, -0.025253296, -0.0625, -0.051940918, 0.0010385513, 0.024734497, -0.018539429, 0.032684326, 0.033935547, 0.0027542114, -0.030059814, 0.0054359436, 0.023529053, -0.00081062317, 0.0072898865, -0.041809082, 0.013496399, -0.017562866, -0.056365967, -0.044525146, -0.037506104, 0.020645142, 0.020904541, 0.03137207, -0.022201538, 0.013336182, 0.025512695, 0.046722412, 0.050994873, -0.01802063, -0.06185913, 0.007083893, -0.014297485, -0.016189575, 0.006275177, 0.030166626, 0.0008816719, -0.024291992, -0.0022010803, -0.02142334, -0.025619507, -0.05722046, 0.032043457, 0.001914978, 0.029968262, 0.020126343, 0.012779236, 0.032714844, 0.026290894, 0.0067100525, 0.006454468, -0.029647827, 0.006587982, -0.02508545, 0.049438477, -0.0036296844, 0.02406311, 0.05444336, -0.010803223, -0.019104004, 0.017654419, 0.00039339066, 0.024307251, 0.006416321, 0.0003452301, 0.011421204, -0.05456543, -0.034729004, -0.02659607, 0.0090408325, 0.044189453, -0.03326416, 0.006046295, -0.014785767, 0.042816162, 0.0044441223, -0.039978027, 0.014320374, -0.025909424, 0.022338867, -0.028366089, -0.06085205, 0.00011396408, 0.054748535, -0.0062408447, 0.0026397705, -0.015342712, 0.027114868, 0.020248413, 0.030273438, 0.023117065, -0.005214691, -0.011329651, -0.014175415, 0.0046043396, -0.006187439, -0.070007324, 0.015327454, -0.0062942505, 0.0044784546, -0.0031852722, -0.013328552, -0.080444336, -0.023605347, -0.020629883, 0.0030288696, 0.022460938, -0.058135986, 0.015068054, 0.07647705, 0.034973145, 0.0066108704, -0.021026611, 0.007926941, 0.037628174, 0.04437256, 0.010223389, 0.00017464161, 0.038330078, -0.041748047, -0.010070801, -0.0033111572, 0.012962341, -0.028289795, 0.07287598, 0.0018482208, 0.020309448, -0.079833984, 0.020980835, -0.007904053, -0.03741455, 0.018692017, -0.030303955, 0.016357422, 0.024353027, -0.0028896332, 0.017578125, 0.018005371, -0.023117065, -0.0335083, 0.021850586, -0.03894043, -0.006111145, 0.009651184, -0.06561279, -0.024383545, 0.019989014, -0.002653122, -0.0041160583, 0.020080566, -0.0044136047, -0.042907715, 0.017089844, 0.03414917, -0.026000977, 0.03189087, -0.00019621849, 0.013343811, 0.055908203, 0.013755798, -0.025756836, 0.0056915283, -0.0041046143, -0.060180664, -0.06008911, 0.0007481575, -0.0029354095, 0.009757996, -0.016647339, -0.013549805, -0.0031967163, 0.009338379, 0.026046753, -0.012275696, -0.032073975, 0.037902832, 0.005886078, 0.028701782, -0.012168884, 0.019546509, 0.0034236908, -0.013130188, 0.018936157, -0.054840088, 0.000018715858, 0.0184021, 0.035461426, -0.045715332, -0.07647705, -0.004169464, 0.015167236, -0.0063438416, 0.0029563904, 0.017852783, 0.033355713, 0.039245605, -0.014564514, 0.0057258606, 0.042388916, -0.044799805, -0.038024902, -0.028839111, -0.002275467, -0.040649414, 0.060821533, 0.0015916824, -0.0155181885, -0.030715942, -0.020050049, -0.0181427, 0.03302002, 0.008346558, -0.008125305, 0.0018186569, -0.0057029724, 0.05682373, -0.022644043, -0.015960693, -0.019592285, 0.04220581, 0.011680603, -0.032165527, -0.010154724, -0.009689331, -0.0044174194, 0.004020691, 0.011405945, -0.010826111, -0.018753052, -0.0005726814, -0.024719238, 0.02027893, -0.016571045, -0.035095215, 0.01348114, -0.0071525574, -0.0059051514, 0.024505615, -0.016204834, 0.05606079, 0.022033691, 0.071777344, 0.06329346, -0.008293152, -0.0010890961, 0.0052604675, -0.005935669, -0.052246094, 0.0021705627, -0.03817749, 0.007156372, -0.039123535, 0.016784668, -0.091918945, 0.03253174, 0.019866943, 0.019744873, 0.0340271, 0.007080078, 0.037597656, 0.021377563, 0.036834717, 0.0005607605, 0.043060303, -0.016082764, -0.002614975, 0.0016880035, -0.020492554, 0.020385742, 0.028625488, -0.01651001, 0.01928711, -0.014251709, -0.004699707, 0.008239746, 0.0048332214, 0.02684021, -0.005203247, -0.0043754578, -0.0211792, 0.047851562, 0.021087646, 0.054626465, 0.020843506, 0.019073486, -0.019180298, -0.00083208084, -0.01008606, -0.024429321, 0.010795593, -0.03378296, 0.021575928, -0.06939697, 0.01084137, -0.008758545, -0.0012836456, -0.00020241737, 0.049926758, 0.031463623, -0.031829834, -0.022781372, -0.010223389, 0.037353516, 0.0022735596, 0.008491516, -0.0357666, -0.0029315948, -0.01751709, 0.020248413, 0.004840851, 0.0113220215, 0.019348145, 0.013114929, -0.009796143, -0.04425049, 0.021972656, -0.01625061, 0.0362854, 0.042144775, -0.021316528, 0.035705566, -0.007858276, -0.045898438, 0.013053894, 0.0055274963, -0.048553467, -0.025970459, 0.045684814, 0.013999939, 0.044830322, 0.078552246, 0.04724121, 0.010810852, -0.032318115, -0.04748535, 0.013572693, 0.047821045, -0.043945312, 0.006855011, -0.03164673, -0.045837402, 0.014503479, -0.074035645, 0.021972656, -0.04446411, -0.032928467, -0.01927185, 0.021560669, 0.030380249, -0.022140503, -0.022491455, -0.029922485, -0.05303955, 0.009185791, -0.0071411133, -0.020187378, -0.022857666, -0.022827148, -0.0017299652, -0.009223938, 0.025726318, 0.010925293, -0.026535034, -0.053649902, 0.020446777, -0.016616821, 0.059143066, -0.044403076, 0.022644043, 0.006767273, -0.012832642, -0.015960693, -0.037200928, -0.018676758, -0.010757446, -0.029693604, -0.026687622, 0.009483337, 0.016052246, -0.016921997, -0.043304443, -0.023147583, -0.008705139, -0.041229248, 0.012001038, 0.007019043, -0.060302734, 0.004688263, 0.006126404, -0.04385376, 0.042388916, 0.037628174, -0.017181396, 0.050476074, 0.001584053, -0.039978027, 0.0134887695, 0.012252808, 0.037017822, 0.012908936, -0.044555664, 0.03616333, 0.014678955, 0.050048828, -0.044067383, -0.032684326, 0.013511658, -0.0002655983, -0.0028305054, 0.055358887, 0.019210815, -0.0049209595, 0.014213562, 0.011199951, -0.0069084167, -0.047912598, 0.014587402, -0.011878967, 0.024475098, 0.03604126, -0.009170532, 0.010665894, 0.031234741, -0.030960083, -0.012565613, 0.009925842, -0.01322937, -0.01033783, 0.022842407, 0.02709961, -0.03237915, -0.016815186, -0.029037476, 0.020629883, -0.012077332, 0.013130188, -0.0026493073, 0.0074272156, -0.016983032, 0.03265381, -0.03616333, -0.08288574, 0.064697266, 0.045318604, 0.0052452087, 0.00223732, 0.01473999, -0.008377075, -0.015274048, 0.002658844, -0.00085020065, 0.008834839, 0.014389038, -0.029968262, 0.025161743, -0.042388916, -0.015090942, -0.034332275, -0.03540039, 0.03491211, -0.040771484, -0.011199951, -0.04385376, -0.014350891, -0.019180298, 0.018707275, -0.014564514, -0.05041504, -0.01096344, 0.019210815, 0.037902832, -0.0071754456 ], "summary": [ 0.021896362, -0.026367188, -0.044677734, -0.0725708, -0.041656494, -0.001748085, -0.062347412, 0.022583008, 0.05239868, 0.027114868, -0.025665283, -0.0021095276, 0.026046753, -0.008918762, -0.010810852, 0.012306213, -0.01134491, 0.03451538, 0.012817383, -0.023529053, 0.0049819946, -0.04260254, -0.01499176, -0.0524292, 0.00945282, -0.057006836, 0.060516357, -0.016052246, 0.06677246, 0.032073975, 0.021621704, -0.07946777, 0.035339355, -0.019622803, -0.0041007996, -0.018875122, -0.031982422, -0.013839722, -0.0077667236, -0.006538391, 0.02432251, -0.0039367676, 0.030700684, -0.037078857, -0.0138168335, 0.06555176, -0.042297363, -0.015312195, 0.04663086, 0.020980835, -0.011375427, -0.004966736, -0.018722534, -0.014137268, -0.029541016, -0.034301758, -0.052124023, -0.012512207, -0.011520386, 0.03945923, 0.053863525, 0.013519287, 0.007835388, 0.017410278, -0.011955261, 0.0022659302, -0.025115967, -0.018127441, 0.048675537, 0.0008993149, -0.0066719055, 0.003271103, 0.03250122, -0.04135132, -0.008003235, 0.03768921, 0.0113220215, 0.0154953, 0.028518677, -0.053009033, -0.00014066696, 0.039123535, -0.022994995, -0.01928711, 0.0028476715, 0.008514404, -0.015823364, -0.02772522, -0.005542755, -0.042266846, 0.0027427673, 0.014762878, -0.084228516, 0.018615723, 0.017822266, -0.060028076, 0.011566162, -0.009147644, -0.017822266, -0.024658203, -0.0025787354, -0.020965576, -0.006816864, -0.008285522, 0.04437256, 0.04537964, -0.008758545, -0.06939697, 0.022842407, -0.009529114, -0.0061912537, 0.053619385, -0.0051002502, -0.045928955, 0.010787964, 0.033477783, -0.0027313232, 0.06768799, 0.031402588, 0.06112671, -0.02217102, 0.023925781, -0.04385376, 0.054016113, 0.0020484924, 0.01348114, 0.032348633, -0.0060539246, 0.031921387, -0.020141602, 0.026290894, 0.030288696, -0.08129883, -0.025817871, -0.04888916, 0.013618469, 0.020324707, 0.018508911, -0.019561768, -0.011459351, 0.052215576, -0.017745972, -0.029907227, 0.019241333, -0.04333496, 0.029190063, 0.050476074, -0.001748085, -0.0670166, -0.03894043, -0.052703857, 0.06567383, 0.05618286, -0.070373535, -0.042938232, -0.14050293, -0.0552063, -0.054718018, 0.082092285, -0.060577393, 0.019836426, 0.0018749237, 0.00078487396, 0.0041389465, -0.029434204, -0.00024342537, -0.017608643, -0.022827148, 0.03237915, 0.032562256, 0.022872925, -0.007686615, 0.022232056, 0.0065727234, -0.004371643, 0.010772705, -0.01612854, -0.008926392, -0.025314331, 0.051635742, 0.030853271, -0.036834717, -0.046142578, 0.04727173, -0.019363403, -0.0007777214, 0.018371582, 0.025466919, 0.011932373, 0.018295288, 0.010368347, 0.009552002, -0.035064697, 0.0015916824, -0.006832123, -0.026260376, 0.016677856, -0.009376526, -0.0053367615, 0.018951416, -0.0049476624, 0.040252686, -0.024124146, 0.01210022, 0.00043535233, 0.0030841827, 0.0069770813, 0.011711121, -0.018951416, 0.036956787, 0.054626465, 0.02180481, -0.051879883, 0.019866943, -0.021148682, -0.044647217, 0.013084412, -0.049316406, 0.024307251, -0.012924194, 0.046447754, 0.02243042, 0.012489319, 0.04168701, -0.0031356812, -0.0039253235, -0.012451172, 0.014030457, -0.012939453, 0.037261963, -0.0021953583, -0.023880005, 0.029083252, 0.05557251, -0.023788452, -0.016921997, -0.0018634796, -0.0034294128, 0.0072021484, 0.015930176, 0.014755249, 0.020996094, -0.046417236, -0.032196045, 0.028747559, -0.033477783, -0.008628845, -0.0038757324, -0.024612427, 0.028121948, 0.011924744, 0.045410156, -0.014602661, 0.008850098, -0.0047454834, 0.028381348, 0.0023002625, -0.0037612915, -0.009895325, -0.0004451275, 0.009857178, -0.022445679, -0.038726807, -0.003376007, 0.005634308, -0.02720642, 0.019958496, 0.016998291, -0.015792847, -0.03616333, 0.02659607, 0.024475098, -0.0073661804, -0.038085938, -0.051239014, -0.040527344, -0.010093689, 0.041259766, 0.0073547363, -0.040130615, 0.008621216, 0.012718201, 0.040863037, -0.0074157715, 0.030761719, 0.027954102, 0.02178955, 0.0028076172, -0.043640137, 0.019638062, 0.009796143, 0.086364746, 0.022659302, -0.0020065308, 0.004135132, 0.035308838, 0.060028076, -0.055541992, 0.03326416, -0.04650879, 0.009757996, 0.053375244, -0.020324707, 0.003271103, 0.024627686, -0.0012893677, -0.017028809, 0.016525269, 0.037506104, 0.010871887, -0.041656494, 0.03866577, -0.0066337585, 0.040802002, -0.070007324, -0.056274414, -0.034454346, -0.0025997162, -0.07525635, -0.012840271, 0.09350586, -0.027511597, 0.010559082, 0.017471313, -0.030151367, -0.049926758, 0.049072266, -0.028381348, 0.006591797, -0.0021972656, -0.09490967, -0.03668213, -0.07171631, 0.029846191, -0.019226074, 0.0027198792, 0.017623901, -0.027893066, 0.0013847351, 0.01927185, 0.072265625, -0.004421234, 0.0016317368, 0.015022278, -0.021957397, 0.023666382, 0.028427124, -0.0027008057, 0.006576538, 0.013618469, -0.006843567, -0.017852783, 0.034729004, 0.032562256, 0.051879883, -0.030838013, -0.050323486, 0.037017822, 0.020904541, -0.02897644, 0.033203125, 0.053344727, 0.011779785, -0.07489014, -0.05429077, -0.03277588, -0.0029392242, -0.0071983337, 0.015411377, -0.0015764236, -0.023010254, 0.01537323, -0.03463745, -0.00945282, 0.028335571, 0.012046814, 0.10974121, 0.0034618378, -0.0769043, 0.034210205, 0.0055122375, 0.017318726, -0.019454956, -0.010360718, 0.054718018, -0.006855011, -0.03503418, 0.034362793, 0.014297485, 0.0032634735, -0.019973755, -0.019683838, 0.008178711, -0.009010315, 0.020126343, 0.010093689, -0.026824951, 0.0095825195, -0.035064697, -0.0129776, 0.09210205, 0.0016975403, 0.0036468506, 0.03375244, -0.06112671, 0.08190918, 0.014450073, 0.016647339, 0.03366089, -0.034240723, -0.006164551, -0.00045967102, -0.017471313, -0.025619507, -0.019134521, -0.0014219284, 0.0073165894, 0.006454468, -0.018585205, -0.009819031, 0.0070381165, 0.010650635, -0.0099487305, -0.008979797, 0.038726807, 0.03189087, 0.036224365, 0.0037517548, -0.0113220215, -0.016281128, 0.024398804, -0.04437256, -0.016998291, -0.009109497, -0.0019950867, 0.025497437, -0.009239197, 0.007698059, -0.0007367134, -0.021591187, -0.011222839, 0.018554688, -0.03237915, -0.014160156, 0.012901306, -0.04840088, 0.016616821, -0.021469116, 0.008163452, 0.030303955, -0.048675537, -0.009353638, -0.012367249, 0.018432617, -0.03137207, 0.028503418, -0.03302002, 0.03543091, 0.01134491, -0.008415222, 0.02609253, -0.016311646, 0.007926941, 0.021331787, 0.05078125, 0.015571594, -0.032043457, -0.011665344, -0.0340271, 0.014579773, 0.016281128, -0.058776855, -0.06518555, -0.0076942444, 0.0028648376, 0.014411926, 0.009536743, 0.028442383, 0.04336548, -0.0077781677, -0.03564453, 0.00009530783, 0.0023460388, -0.063964844, 0.006164551, -0.017974854, -0.058624268, -0.032226562, 0.012077332, -0.0025615692, -0.026992798, -0.04159546, 0.039367676, -0.01763916, -0.018600464, 0.026611328, -0.01966858, 0.10443115, 0.015052795, -0.08807373, 0.035217285, -0.0055160522, 0.017700195, 0.0418396, 0.025726318, 0.00089120865, 0.025894165, 0.021087646, 0.007232666, 0.019851685, 0.06793213, -0.006614685, -0.07611084, 0.0018424988, -0.027435303, 0.00806427, 0.01600647, -0.021408081, 0.026412964, 0.008041382, 0.046783447, 0.045410156, 0.024139404, -0.0064888, -0.011520386, 0.024749756, -0.013092041, 0.013183594, -0.020812988, 0.014808655, 0.045318604, 0.038848877, -0.04876709, -0.047027588, 0.017578125, -0.032318115, -0.020095825, -0.055023193, -0.005176544, 0.06866455, -0.022476196, -0.0368042, 0.019821167, 0.08068848, -0.0033302307, 0.03137207, -0.020111084, 0.008506775, -0.048553467, -0.021896362, -0.024841309, -0.00096797943, -0.03665161, -0.058441162, -0.016540527, 0.008201599, 0.010757446, 0.02015686, -0.0052604675, -0.009101868, -0.0038642883, 0.0069999695, -0.0019779205, -0.007369995, -0.0017518997, 0.026641846, -0.0072021484, -0.04144287, -0.011726379, -0.03289795, -0.033416748, -0.016174316, -0.06365967, -0.05130005, 0.0010890961, 0.039489746, -0.018630981, 0.034820557, 0.004508972, 0.039398193, 0.084228516, -0.016784668, -0.092041016, 0.000050842762, -0.0001540184, 0.00023949146, 0.010139465, 0.04449463, 0.013885498, -0.01876831, -0.059936523, -0.011566162, -0.042877197, -0.03616333, 0.01953125, 0.036224365, 0.017211914, 0.019256592, 0.037719727, 0.024917603, 0.025238037, 0.008178711, 0.00002938509, -0.01739502, -0.0063552856, -0.008102417, 0.03375244, 0.0015420914, 0.0044555664, 0.037078857, -0.052703857, -0.020217896, 0.0058021545, -0.018051147, 0.014862061, 0.04724121, 0.03387451, -0.008300781, -0.020401001, -0.02671814, 0.0023097992, -0.0043907166, 0.017303467, 0.010040283, -0.029037476, 0.021560669, 0.040039062, -0.025924683, -0.057647705, -0.024978638, -0.05633545, -0.020736694, -0.007865906, -0.06719971, -0.024932861, 0.030456543, 0.026489258, -0.03741455, -0.0018138885, 0.048706055, 0.021133423, -0.021636963, -0.025299072, -0.058166504, 0.017044067, -0.016052246, -0.011489868, 0.03656006, -0.03338623, -0.04611206, -0.0010566711, 0.024841309, 0.07543945, -0.01134491, -0.020568848, 0.004196167, -0.0073127747, 0.029663086, -0.009422302, -0.021713257, -0.036712646, 0.021118164, 0.0021629333, -0.02243042, 0.011123657, -0.01876831, -0.004550934, 0.024917603, -0.016860962, -0.040527344, 0.025360107, -0.10345459, -0.018234253, -0.03692627, 0.033416748, 0.012550354, 0.0052833557, 0.023788452, 0.020980835, -0.05203247, -0.02217102, -0.033325195, -0.044891357, 0.027191162, -0.0058517456, 0.021484375, 0.043823242, 0.007911682, -0.005092621, 0.043823242, -0.022354126, -0.040039062, 0.022827148, -0.019577026, -0.012763977, 0.007068634, -0.047912598, -0.0063591003, 0.00032949448, 0.007888794, 0.009590149, 0.0021915436, 0.00087308884, -0.024337769, -0.0001193881, 0.013534546, 0.04510498, 0.037597656, 0.004878998, -0.016799927, 0.01864624, 0.051483154, -0.0118637085, -0.0029010773, -0.030838013, -0.06549072, -0.03363037, 0.021392822, 0.012489319, 0.025161743, 0.024307251, -0.03591919, 0.014259338, 0.035339355, 0.047058105, -0.04849243, 0.0040016174, 0.013290405, -0.019302368, -0.031234741, -0.0030174255, -0.016540527, -0.05734253, -0.004337311, 0.03186035, -0.008834839, 0.012496948, 0.039398193, 0.037322998, -0.045959473, -0.0770874, 0.00063705444, 0.023391724, -0.008026123, -0.0031375885, 0.01637268, -0.0009264946, 0.05621338, -0.01574707, 0.005092621, 0.01701355, -0.008369446, 0.020980835, -0.015838623, 0.021636963, -0.025680542, 0.032714844, -0.016647339, 0.015258789, -0.018951416, -0.016174316, -0.0044441223, -0.021499634, -0.012001038, -0.017791748, -0.021499634, 0.0031757355, 0.03086853, 0.016998291, -0.02458191, -0.00497818, 0.027877808, -0.006160736, -0.035125732, 0.031311035, -0.016967773, 0.0032730103, 0.005279541, 0.0058631897, -0.047668457, -0.034973145, -0.011512756, 0.04534912, 0.03475952, 0.0070610046, 0.029693604, 0.041625977, -0.031021118, 0.018569946, -0.018630981, 0.02078247, 0.02671814, 0.005859375, 0.05795288, 0.023925781, -0.046661377, 0.0005097389, 0.0051727295, -0.024032593, -0.047821045, 0.027572632, -0.009819031, -0.0014266968, -0.027145386, -0.017807007, -0.028549194, 0.040222168, 0.016555786, -0.044891357, 0.013008118, -0.013206482, -0.0025939941, 0.060150146, -0.04321289, 0.0035953522, -0.03656006, -0.034088135, -0.029022217, -0.004463196, 0.024734497, -0.0027332306, 0.03387451, 0.019927979, 0.01436615, 0.0034103394, 0.01586914, 0.023544312, -0.012580872, -0.028656006, -0.043670654, 0.044067383, -0.028656006, 0.0134887695, 0.029129028, 0.04437256, -0.011894226, 0.05456543, -0.019821167, 0.041809082, 0.010429382, 0.0021362305, 0.0368042, -0.025497437, -0.010658264, -0.010002136, 0.009063721, 0.029647827, -0.017791748, 0.055236816, -0.002828598, 0.048919678, -0.036010742, -0.030014038, -0.01965332, 0.025604248, -0.016906738, 0.031707764, -0.02748108, -0.02394104, -0.01689148, -0.018920898, -0.0013847351, -0.0056610107, 0.034057617, -0.0028533936, 0.032073975, -0.011497498, 0.012214661, -0.0019388199, 0.036315918, 0.033203125, 0.0061187744, 0.033203125, 0.007724762, -0.02810669, 0.032836914, 0.022659302, -0.020980835, 0.010284424, 0.024795532, 0.029205322, 0.031555176, 0.07086182, 0.009475708, 0.02822876, 0.010131836, -0.010978699, 0.025375366, 0.023712158, -0.02456665, -0.031951904, -0.011329651, -0.0056915283, -0.020523071, -0.041809082, -0.02142334, -0.043762207, -0.008888245, -0.020431519, -0.011993408, -0.031097412, 0.014282227, -0.0018510818, -0.057617188, -0.02293396, 0.030456543, 0.02079773, -0.026245117, 0.009422302, -0.0013141632, -0.0262146, 0.007030487, 0.019927979, 0.02507019, -0.029937744, 0.0012750626, 0.038757324, 0.022964478, 0.08081055, 0.007160187, -0.00085926056, 0.029159546, 0.020339966, -0.021102905, -0.087890625, -0.0069847107, -0.016143799, 0.02758789, -0.050750732, 0.019958496, 0.029754639, -0.013633728, -0.059783936, -0.03363037, -0.014656067, -0.04638672, 0.01902771, 0.00093746185, -0.03062439, 0.009513855, 0.015487671, -0.059814453, 0.01878357, 0.019577026, -0.022613525, 0.0680542, -0.017745972, -0.00970459, 0.011955261, 0.009590149, 0.012954712, -0.0077705383, -0.001534462, -0.0035381317, 0.017150879, 0.074401855, -0.0206604, -0.0030021667, -0.0031738281, -0.029281616, 0.0056533813, 0.0002951622, -0.02659607, -0.028076172, 0.06628418, -0.015258789, 0.0074157715, -0.012023926, 0.060180664, 0.0069847107, -0.0051498413, -0.0079422, -0.016708374, 0.021194458, 0.008277893, -0.050354004, -0.021087646, -0.0022525787, 0.0418396, -0.02470398, 0.015975952, 0.0022563934, -0.06506348, -0.034729004, 0.011360168, -0.0022354126, -0.009841919, -0.01751709, -0.0034885406, 0.0043182373, -0.040527344, -0.011360168, 0.02142334, -0.010650635, 0.007381439, 0.0050086975, 0.023071289, -0.015838623, 0.022827148, -0.03744507, -0.01776123, 0.015068054, 0.013587952, 0.02281189, 0.0038032532, -0.012664795, 0.021255493, -0.025787354, 0.006111145, -0.04837036, -0.018630981, 0.01576233, -0.014808655, -0.012207031, 0.007221222, -0.0062789917, 0.004371643, 0.036102295, -0.00592041, -0.026931763, 0.062469482, 0.057861328, 0.025802612, 0.042388916 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07311v1
Do large language models and humans have similar behaviors in causal inference with script knowledge?
Xudong Hong, Margarita Ryzhova, Daniel Adrian Biondi, Vera Demberg
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7; I.2.0
Recently, large pre-trained language models (LLMs) have demonstrated superior language understanding abilities, including zero-shot causal reasoning. However, it is unclear to what extent their capabilities are similar to human ones. We here study the processing of an event $B$ in a script-based story, which causally depends on a previous event $A$. In our manipulation, event $A$ is stated, negated, or omitted in an earlier section of the text. We first conducted a self-paced reading experiment, which showed that humans exhibit significantly longer reading times when causal conflicts exist ($\neg A \rightarrow B$) than under logical conditions ($A \rightarrow B$). However, reading times remain similar when cause A is not explicitly mentioned, indicating that humans can easily infer event B from their script knowledge. We then tested a variety of LLMs on the same data to check to what extent the models replicate human behavior. Our experiments show that 1) only recent LLMs, like GPT-3 or Vicuna, correlate with human behavior in the $\neg A \rightarrow B$ condition. 2) Despite this correlation, all models still fail to predict that $nil \rightarrow B$ is less surprising than $\neg A \rightarrow B$, indicating that LLMs still have difficulties integrating script knowledge. Our code and collected data set are available at https://github.com/tony-hong/causal-script.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07311v1
2023-11-13T13:05:15
2023-11-13T13:05:15
{ "title": [ -0.022842407, -0.018478394, -0.029129028, -0.042663574, -0.058044434, -0.016098022, -0.0491333, 0.025436401, -0.010147095, -0.00566864, -0.052825928, 0.0065460205, 0.008399963, -0.022827148, 0.021240234, -0.028717041, 0.009895325, 0.029907227, 0.018707275, -0.01914978, -0.0073623657, -0.005367279, 0.025054932, -0.006210327, 0.05758667, -0.016830444, -0.046844482, 0.03173828, 0.008049011, 0.0023441315, 0.01940918, -0.03842163, 0.027236938, 0.04168701, -0.040161133, -0.00081920624, -0.030532837, 0.033416748, -0.004180908, 0.01651001, 0.03036499, -0.033721924, 0.057647705, -0.019042969, -0.005077362, 0.055786133, -0.033599854, -0.031341553, 0.03262329, 0.024002075, -0.024246216, 0.03652954, -0.015335083, 0.017944336, -0.00030755997, -0.008903503, -0.020568848, -0.005870819, 0.031402588, 0.027069092, 0.0027427673, -0.019088745, 0.015686035, -0.05419922, -0.012237549, -0.010627747, -0.028289795, 0.0015907288, 0.06793213, 0.034210205, -0.013473511, -0.015396118, -0.012771606, -0.009902954, -0.025650024, 0.0090789795, 0.010536194, 0.0026378632, 0.014884949, -0.008285522, -0.0013875961, 0.009742737, -0.012481689, -0.02015686, -0.016815186, -0.040374756, -0.003932953, 0.016586304, -0.038726807, -0.057037354, -0.026947021, -0.014091492, -0.02104187, -0.020095825, -0.0284729, -0.0657959, 0.0067634583, -0.001455307, 0.00013685226, -0.048095703, -0.0491333, 0.016723633, -0.09161377, 0.019134521, 0.0060691833, -0.00242424, -0.0335083, 0.006477356, 0.025283813, 0.030715942, -0.04663086, 0.015151978, 0.012939453, -0.009971619, 0.011016846, -0.015670776, -0.064819336, 0.06512451, 0.016052246, 0.06585693, -0.017700195, -0.0034942627, 0.0051345825, 0.030212402, 0.031204224, 0.018005371, -0.015960693, -0.0067825317, -0.04220581, 0.031021118, 0.020935059, 0.03881836, -0.0803833, -0.037597656, -0.056030273, 0.013809204, -0.007232666, -0.0418396, -0.048583984, 0.05227661, -0.026351929, -0.0345459, 0.039733887, -0.042663574, -0.026931763, 0.01914978, 0.026992798, 0.00932312, -0.0395813, -0.044403076, -0.0077400208, 0.023025513, 0.012802124, -0.0063323975, -0.007232666, -0.04598999, -0.10192871, -0.0028495789, 0.048187256, 0.028152466, -0.015014648, -0.016998291, -0.029464722, -0.028427124, -0.04421997, -0.0063438416, 0.03439331, 0.009788513, 0.016296387, 0.008621216, -0.0016002655, 0.016464233, 0.007217407, 0.010154724, 0.014266968, 0.008354187, -0.010116577, 0.02029419, -0.020751953, 0.006511688, 0.014778137, -0.042785645, -0.064331055, 0.03652954, -0.056854248, -0.034851074, -0.031829834, -0.006690979, 0.093688965, -0.008308411, -0.0006427765, -0.019561768, -0.02861023, -0.033172607, -0.0119018555, 0.000011563301, 0.020599365, 0.0074310303, 0.01108551, 0.00995636, 0.02178955, 0.0061149597, 0.002746582, -0.044006348, -0.08111572, -0.018447876, -0.016357422, 0.027893066, 0.027496338, 0.049743652, 0.0029907227, 0.0038414001, -0.0184021, 0.020248413, -0.011138916, -0.028060913, 0.01058197, -0.0029296875, 0.0057411194, -0.03881836, 0.015411377, -0.015716553, 0.0020484924, 0.0026054382, -0.04638672, -0.012367249, -0.009803772, -0.015525818, -0.014450073, -0.0138549805, 0.08215332, 0.009559631, -0.0005264282, -0.000351429, -0.027877808, -0.025375366, -0.009033203, -0.064331055, 0.022247314, 0.052124023, 0.009185791, -0.025848389, -0.01739502, 0.021774292, -0.027526855, -0.02709961, 0.011688232, -0.014266968, 0.026428223, 0.048706055, 0.056640625, -0.005836487, 0.020263672, 0.01838684, -0.0010919571, 0.04714966, 0.028656006, -0.026153564, -0.008079529, 0.03918457, 0.03387451, 0.025604248, -0.03491211, 0.03704834, -0.07348633, -0.008743286, -0.044708252, -0.019546509, 0.0056610107, -0.029953003, 0.0317688, -0.021621704, 0.007369995, -0.020309448, -0.0036449432, -0.05331421, -0.017868042, 0.022766113, 0.011512756, -0.04776001, -0.0066375732, 0.0056533813, 0.017959595, -0.005748749, 0.017089844, 0.033691406, 0.027709961, 0.007534027, -0.0012521744, 0.03173828, 0.043304443, 0.040374756, 0.012138367, 0.024475098, 0.028579712, 0.0023384094, 0.03074646, 0.027511597, -0.0064811707, 0.010620117, 0.0026302338, 0.035614014, 0.00819397, 0.034362793, 0.029586792, 0.020309448, 0.06317139, -0.007827759, -0.023376465, 0.038604736, -0.0703125, -0.00039696693, 0.026672363, 0.052734375, -0.020477295, -0.013198853, -0.010665894, 0.046020508, -0.046783447, -0.06384277, 0.092285156, 0.012840271, 0.007911682, -0.047088623, 0.0049934387, -0.05328369, -0.057495117, -0.031433105, 0.026138306, -0.0028018951, 0.015037537, -0.018692017, -0.07086182, -0.04953003, 0.010063171, -0.003917694, -0.0119018555, 0.0037899017, -0.009727478, 0.012428284, -0.0042762756, -0.055511475, 0.004627228, -0.034118652, 0.024169922, -0.044555664, 0.01928711, -0.009269714, -0.0126571655, 0.02557373, -0.013839722, 0.0047569275, -0.00084638596, -0.00573349, 0.05810547, -0.021270752, -0.03970337, 0.0541687, 0.018676758, -0.015220642, 0.043823242, 0.051574707, 0.013328552, -0.06604004, -0.028930664, -0.068847656, -0.010681152, -0.011665344, 0.03201294, 0.01020813, -0.08087158, 0.0010061264, -0.028762817, 0.036346436, 0.08654785, 0.057861328, 0.0463562, -0.015312195, -0.016311646, 0.015007019, -0.0027503967, 0.012084961, -0.023452759, 0.0368042, 0.099121094, 0.021133423, 0.037506104, 0.0048446655, 0.05508423, -0.005718231, -0.011062622, -0.045684814, -0.0357666, -0.031341553, 0.017623901, 0.023727417, -0.050933838, -0.007965088, -0.039520264, 0.00072813034, 0.034210205, -0.0026340485, 0.0064697266, 0.040771484, -0.07757568, 0.068359375, -0.0368042, 0.0005660057, 0.03488159, -0.030441284, 0.017730713, -0.02229309, 0.023361206, -0.044555664, 0.0013179779, -0.04168701, -0.07043457, 0.009109497, -0.06100464, 0.00793457, 0.03439331, -0.011398315, -0.018325806, -0.010559082, -0.009933472, 0.049865723, -0.0005097389, 0.010887146, 0.015220642, -0.009780884, -0.021438599, -0.009666443, -0.0029087067, -0.024475098, -0.014503479, 0.044799805, -0.008796692, 0.059692383, 0.012779236, -0.0074005127, -0.026473999, 0.0012674332, -0.042297363, -0.008148193, -0.01890564, -0.031021118, -0.0043296814, -0.012504578, -0.045043945, -0.008544922, -0.014411926, 0.031082153, -0.00881958, 0.02848816, -0.009529114, 0.036346436, 0.022323608, 0.004989624, -0.008560181, 0.00024580956, 0.0048332214, 0.023986816, -0.046539307, -0.017074585, 0.043640137, -0.04675293, 0.041503906, -0.0073509216, 0.0019311905, 0.024414062, 0.0043144226, 0.011627197, 0.01084137, -0.023757935, -0.0009293556, -0.035308838, 0.008621216, -0.008651733, 0.03390503, -0.014038086, -0.013122559, 0.021072388, -0.041503906, -0.05731201, -0.08282471, 0.032165527, -0.10021973, -0.015098572, 0.038513184, -0.024505615, -0.0128479, -0.036865234, 0.05444336, -0.07092285, -0.019973755, 0.014404297, -0.026565552, 0.06463623, 0.023330688, -0.06707764, 0.025802612, 0.028198242, 0.011749268, -0.020141602, 0.03643799, -0.0017690659, 0.013847351, -0.020828247, 0.012054443, 0.044158936, 0.020431519, -0.010360718, -0.022094727, 0.010856628, -0.018295288, 0.027557373, 0.025665283, 0.0008058548, 0.026550293, 0.0024909973, 0.022979736, 0.04638672, 0.009307861, 0.0368042, -0.022262573, -0.005405426, -0.02659607, 0.0071754456, -0.0033226013, -0.014053345, 0.020843506, -0.0005917549, 0.02973938, 0.03744507, -0.00056552887, 0.01576233, -0.030593872, -0.011047363, 0.04135132, 0.030548096, -0.039733887, 0.003829956, -0.001288414, 0.06896973, -0.0047683716, 0.01928711, -0.025009155, 0.05831909, 0.0010147095, 0.018493652, -0.0021400452, 0.003353119, -0.026535034, 0.0028839111, -0.037384033, -0.06976318, -0.05380249, 0.01675415, 0.006011963, 0.049926758, 0.035491943, 0.059448242, -0.026733398, -0.051696777, 0.018127441, -0.019714355, 0.0053215027, -0.022583008, 0.009223938, -0.054901123, -0.03942871, -0.052947998, -0.066101074, -0.008651733, 0.036193848, 0.050689697, -0.06323242, 0.0066490173, 0.006576538, 0.061676025, 0.031311035, 0.0029945374, -0.057434082, -0.014015198, -0.038146973, 0.04248047, 0.013450623, 0.016677856, -0.0023593903, 0.016525269, 0.015022278, -0.0013017654, -0.014572144, -0.079956055, 0.017608643, -0.016159058, 0.021987915, 0.03201294, -0.0058937073, 0.021316528, -0.0077056885, 0.019332886, -0.0053634644, -0.012794495, 0.005504608, 0.04849243, 0.025863647, -0.0016241074, 0.030563354, 0.02748108, 0.015144348, -0.0039596558, -0.044708252, 0.036895752, -0.014060974, -0.03970337, -0.0068092346, 0.004333496, 0.0005145073, 0.0005030632, 0.024749756, -0.0051994324, 0.018859863, 0.004600525, 0.009338379, -0.025360107, -0.009521484, -0.011169434, -0.018005371, 0.0012016296, -0.0061187744, 0.010429382, -0.023605347, -0.024230957, 0.030014038, 0.03201294, -0.019439697, 0.001707077, -0.025161743, -0.00497818, 0.013442993, 0.029571533, 0.023025513, -0.052825928, 0.023117065, -0.023361206, -0.027618408, 0.04083252, -0.038116455, -0.03869629, -0.05441284, 0.00623703, 0.028076172, 0.012359619, -0.015365601, -0.0007429123, -0.02923584, -0.042388916, 0.010292053, -0.04660034, -0.0008869171, 0.04006958, -0.029312134, 0.037506104, -0.01725769, -0.0085372925, 0.016601562, 0.010025024, -0.012588501, -0.0063667297, 0.0018672943, -0.0703125, 0.02708435, -0.0070762634, 0.038208008, -0.010375977, -0.0043144226, 0.0018453598, 0.029510498, -0.048583984, 0.008529663, -0.005317688, 0.020324707, -0.012954712, -0.029129028, 0.050628662, 0.0149383545, -0.026626587, 0.007209778, -0.046081543, -0.03778076, -0.013671875, -0.01902771, -0.036102295, 0.015701294, -0.00166893, 0.008766174, -0.03677368, 0.02243042, -0.04714966, 0.021606445, 0.009773254, -0.009590149, 0.0013313293, 0.024368286, 0.04623413, -0.04647827, 0.011451721, -0.0143966675, 0.005897522, 0.025161743, 0.038024902, -0.043701172, -0.019622803, 0.00016582012, -0.033233643, -0.01449585, 0.035583496, 0.014175415, 0.01927185, -0.028060913, -0.005531311, -0.014297485, -0.013061523, 0.031158447, -0.048187256, -0.020126343, -0.030090332, -0.03161621, -0.021377563, -0.004371643, -0.005580902, -0.014480591, -0.0011301041, 0.005252838, -0.022369385, 0.004650116, 0.049438477, 0.035736084, -0.03250122, -0.07128906, -0.0076904297, 0.014579773, -0.010986328, -0.042297363, 0.016906738, 0.01789856, -0.02859497, 0.0051345825, 0.0032482147, 0.0690918, -0.03881836, 0.00995636, -0.009399414, 0.030838013, -0.027786255, 0.020721436, -0.0044403076, 0.025741577, -0.029891968, -0.05758667, -0.014518738, 0.0037956238, 0.040924072, -0.013435364, 0.028671265, -0.009262085, 0.001909256, -0.03527832, 0.0043563843, -0.0073509216, 0.007648468, -0.012718201, -0.01965332, 0.01235199, -0.0065956116, -0.019165039, -0.0026512146, 0.001086235, 0.049560547, 0.022109985, 0.024368286, -0.023147583, -0.031082153, -0.0007266998, -0.012046814, 0.037322998, -0.03375244, 0.033416748, 0.024230957, 0.0053215027, 0.005695343, 0.036071777, 0.0647583, 0.011291504, 0.0126571655, 0.037750244, 0.035186768, 0.032287598, -0.009292603, 0.031585693, -0.04724121, 0.020004272, -0.015380859, -0.0046539307, -0.05947876, 0.045196533, 0.010719299, 0.019622803, 0.025848389, -0.010154724, -0.0010633469, 0.013648987, 0.020339966, 0.08117676, 0.044769287, 0.035064697, 0.005592346, 0.037902832, -0.05596924, -0.0054016113, 0.040252686, 0.017120361, -0.03173828, 0.006290436, -0.035491943, 0.04147339, -0.0012865067, -0.011894226, -0.0362854, 0.0043678284, -0.031677246, 0.004470825, 0.0137786865, 0.009300232, 0.0015230179, 0.0023345947, -0.016479492, 0.020309448, -0.0011739731, 0.0057640076, -0.00081014633, 0.012878418, 0.014404297, -0.020080566, 0.05029297, 0.028869629, -0.053222656, -0.018249512, 0.06677246, 0.040283203, -0.0013437271, 0.026672363, 0.042938232, -0.000019311905, 0.002916336, -0.027633667, -0.04864502, -0.025939941, 0.004058838, 0.0022449493, 0.00056505203, 0.030014038, 0.014274597, 0.0036239624, 0.013267517, -0.0061302185, 0.0000031590462, -0.0030231476, -0.0138168335, 0.026916504, 0.017959595, 0.057250977, -0.016983032, -0.024108887, -0.0066223145, 0.038146973, -0.055603027, -0.0045051575, 0.027755737, 0.016662598, 0.028900146, 0.06774902, 0.008766174, 0.029434204, -0.022201538, 0.00031971931, 0.01953125, 0.02507019, -0.002456665, 0.032196045, -0.03186035, -0.04562378, 0.066223145, -0.017791748, 0.10180664, -0.047088623, -0.039489746, -0.046569824, 0.03857422, -0.006454468, -0.036071777, -0.050048828, -0.053253174, -0.032958984, -0.0006465912, -0.009757996, -0.0067443848, -0.022064209, -0.03756714, 0.017669678, 0.00315094, 0.045440674, 0.045898438, -0.04949951, 0.004096985, 0.06854248, 0.042510986, 0.13879395, -0.0038547516, -0.016159058, -0.016357422, 0.026992798, 0.05239868, -0.012428284, -0.068603516, 0.072387695, 0.01625061, -0.02017212, 0.029571533, 0.02822876, -0.011482239, -0.048187256, 0.011276245, -0.023284912, -0.037963867, -0.01360321, 0.022323608, 0.00014925003, -0.049591064, -0.010177612, -0.044189453, 0.0124435425, -0.0067863464, -0.011734009, 0.027740479, -0.013221741, -0.04586792, -0.013053894, 0.0076446533, 0.032318115, 0.0035705566, -0.036499023, 0.0044670105, 0.00047183037, 0.049621582, -0.008705139, -0.03250122, 0.0126571655, 0.015777588, -0.0055732727, 0.008628845, 0.03567505, 0.026641846, -0.027542114, 0.019165039, -0.01574707, -0.023757935, 0.013664246, 0.06304932, 0.04928589, 0.020263672, -0.01763916, 0.029571533, -0.0010213852, -0.04446411, -0.014801025, -0.014091492, 0.048675537, -0.0044517517, -0.009468079, 0.03152466, -0.037322998, -0.0098724365, -0.024658203, 0.015388489, -0.00774765, -0.0065231323, -0.0064849854, 0.030227661, -0.00806427, 0.019699097, -0.014328003, -0.035980225, 0.029876709, 0.042144775, 0.0063705444, -0.018188477, 0.027236938, 0.008659363, 0.028213501, 0.00868988, 0.017715454, 0.018951416, -0.009269714, -0.048217773, -0.017227173, -0.07507324, -0.011413574, -0.087768555, -0.03527832, 0.01878357, -0.024993896, 0.019165039, -0.04751587, 0.0098724365, 0.0014848709, 0.030227661, 0.008033752, -0.04046631, 0.008163452, 0.0079422, 0.020935059, -0.00088119507 ], "summary": [ 0.0075531006, -0.042266846, 0.0062446594, -0.0418396, -0.06732178, -0.007801056, -0.05496216, 0.0051727295, 0.011817932, -0.015419006, -0.03692627, 0.0063972473, -0.016098022, -0.03366089, 0.02255249, -0.044281006, -0.0073928833, 0.04257202, 0.019638062, -0.0262146, 0.015075684, -0.027191162, -0.017333984, -0.02204895, 0.023345947, -0.011352539, 0.035369873, 0.007911682, 0.05407715, 0.042633057, 0.029388428, -0.101379395, 0.010643005, 0.030532837, -0.02961731, -0.028869629, -0.010498047, 0.024780273, 0.0053367615, 0.015068054, 0.0017127991, -0.007545471, 0.019973755, -0.018676758, -0.017303467, 0.019256592, -0.033477783, -0.03225708, 0.03829956, 0.0234375, -0.0010375977, 0.0309906, -0.015060425, 0.021102905, -0.007293701, 0.0061187744, -0.05355835, 0.010520935, 0.033233643, 0.053253174, 0.025634766, -0.02696228, -0.014015198, -0.050079346, -0.011192322, 0.013893127, 0.0093307495, -0.0036621094, 0.05819702, 0.013130188, -0.013824463, 0.010360718, -0.0052833557, -0.05078125, 0.026428223, 0.06298828, -0.021743774, 0.016052246, 0.015144348, 0.001335144, 0.00029349327, -0.007019043, 0.0055007935, -0.03616333, -0.0149002075, -0.0423584, 0.0039787292, 0.010749817, -0.024246216, -0.019882202, -0.0284729, -0.05456543, -0.0015115738, -0.003074646, -0.008323669, -0.054595947, -0.003501892, -0.023834229, -0.0059394836, -0.037017822, -0.021728516, 0.00617218, -0.05847168, 0.016647339, -0.011741638, -0.0027942657, 0.008605957, 0.0074501038, 0.00041604042, 0.024246216, -0.041656494, -0.013519287, -0.010536194, -0.050628662, 0.014945984, 0.04486084, -0.02897644, 0.07800293, 0.023956299, 0.072143555, -0.016830444, -0.0018024445, -0.021957397, 0.047332764, 0.013214111, 0.03253174, -0.007041931, 0.0181427, -0.027542114, 0.04711914, 0.009727478, 0.0033931732, -0.06323242, -0.029251099, -0.051696777, -0.023391724, 0.030441284, -0.066467285, -0.018127441, 0.01864624, -0.009971619, -0.002779007, 0.028686523, -0.041900635, -0.018127441, 0.010856628, 0.026123047, 0.020004272, -0.042510986, -0.04046631, 0.030258179, -0.0018854141, 0.022399902, -0.016220093, -0.03201294, -0.08087158, -0.091308594, -0.019851685, 0.063964844, -0.010795593, -0.0028018951, -0.009231567, -0.0028495789, -0.049804688, -0.054748535, -0.0035820007, -0.010292053, 0.00053071976, 0.0090789795, 0.02508545, 0.011711121, -0.0034885406, 0.012023926, -0.009223938, -0.010002136, -0.011116028, 0.005191803, 0.03414917, 0.0077590942, -0.015380859, 0.004924774, -0.04055786, 0.021896362, 0.024215698, -0.041809082, 0.0048675537, -0.018203735, 0.053375244, 0.05316162, -0.0016384125, -0.014343262, -0.022720337, 0.02166748, -0.020080566, -0.02293396, -0.01322937, 0.00015175343, 0.014587402, -0.017929077, 0.0075416565, 0.06555176, -0.01991272, 0.012237549, -0.07775879, -0.1026001, 0.0075416565, -0.032287598, 0.038848877, -0.006439209, 0.016799927, 0.038269043, 0.033721924, -0.049346924, 0.053009033, -0.013923645, -0.0023860931, 0.02684021, 0.018325806, 0.021896362, -0.02557373, 0.03515625, 0.01461792, 0.00705719, 0.020645142, -0.0335083, 0.006477356, -0.010734558, 0.019882202, 0.030029297, -0.01966858, 0.12634277, -0.023620605, 0.019058228, -0.007472992, -0.029251099, -0.0011081696, 0.012466431, -0.039154053, 0.014541626, 0.0395813, 0.022109985, -0.032806396, -0.04385376, -0.01838684, -0.0446167, -0.051940918, 0.0014753342, -0.012336731, -0.012481689, 0.011817932, 0.042388916, -0.005214691, 0.026947021, 0.01499176, -0.017364502, 0.035736084, 0.008148193, -0.032287598, 0.022476196, 0.012290955, 0.011695862, 0.0069351196, -0.008102417, 0.0118637085, -0.051818848, -0.028244019, -0.031280518, -0.025146484, 0.007583618, -0.040893555, 0.028060913, -0.042877197, -0.006046295, -0.05117798, -0.008453369, -0.021133423, -0.0038928986, 0.04699707, -0.014884949, -0.044555664, -0.0028877258, 0.020553589, 0.0262146, -0.011993408, 0.017028809, -0.008415222, 0.017440796, 0.0054473877, 0.030792236, 0.05883789, 0.04937744, 0.03050232, 0.007091522, 0.007286072, 0.020111084, -0.020736694, 0.027175903, -0.014122009, 0.018997192, -0.006793976, 0.034851074, 0.058624268, 0.0016403198, 0.028808594, 0.02708435, 0.0036334991, 0.041137695, 0.01763916, 0.002204895, 0.028335571, -0.06317139, -0.0020561218, 0.02482605, 0.06604004, -0.044555664, -0.028396606, -0.016937256, 0.036621094, -0.01953125, -0.015625, 0.10510254, -0.005958557, 0.007293701, 0.0019245148, -0.022262573, -0.054779053, 0.028747559, -0.029876709, 0.017745972, -0.034240723, 0.012054443, -0.024490356, -0.008491516, 0.020935059, 0.00957489, -0.023757935, 0.0021343231, -0.0009698868, -0.017227173, -0.010986328, -0.0051879883, -0.025466919, -0.0063056946, -0.025283813, -0.031158447, 0.008575439, 0.014205933, 0.0030288696, 0.012924194, 0.012329102, -0.008773804, -0.01864624, 0.028305054, 0.04473877, 0.052124023, 0.031829834, -0.027404785, 0.053833008, 0.033813477, -0.017929077, 0.02583313, 0.031097412, -0.0017709732, -0.08050537, -0.034088135, -0.028381348, -0.006919861, -0.011054993, 0.022354126, 0.052459717, -0.042175293, 0.04522705, -0.05822754, -0.0012874603, 0.015960693, 0.046020508, 0.0904541, 0.003156662, -0.027069092, 0.034301758, 0.018447876, 0.022460938, -0.052947998, -0.01499939, 0.091552734, -0.006839752, -0.020401001, 0.01386261, 0.028945923, 0.03390503, -0.019012451, -0.0340271, -0.032592773, -0.032318115, 0.01374054, 0.016357422, -0.026275635, -0.008758545, 0.00079393387, -0.023361206, 0.010559082, 0.017211914, 0.0181427, 0.024337769, -0.06286621, 0.08148193, -0.020111084, -0.011383057, 0.05065918, -0.056518555, 0.0151901245, -0.03262329, 0.023895264, -0.06585693, -0.030654907, -0.01651001, -0.039855957, -0.0036258698, -0.019180298, 0.023162842, 0.017807007, -0.00970459, -0.015899658, 0.011802673, 0.029785156, 0.02029419, -0.0034542084, -0.022201538, -0.0064735413, 0.027633667, 0.004497528, -0.0062675476, -0.014076233, 0.0019607544, -0.024841309, 0.014434814, -0.0206604, -0.034576416, 0.015167236, -0.047790527, -0.032104492, -0.01399231, -0.024902344, -0.039398193, -0.015541077, -0.01914978, 0.026779175, -0.021057129, -0.059417725, -0.0034694672, 0.0015974045, 0.0037078857, 0.009483337, 0.043426514, 0.007129669, 0.08648682, 0.012390137, 0.011459351, 0.01977539, -0.046081543, -0.03213501, -0.010047913, -0.015731812, -0.020629883, 0.052642822, -0.027374268, 0.014015198, 0.0052261353, 0.008468628, 0.011222839, 0.04788208, -0.04800415, -0.014953613, -0.016525269, 0.0018911362, -0.01247406, 0.0039596558, -0.016738892, 0.03945923, -0.0020828247, 0.003156662, 0.0020446777, -0.036468506, -0.038238525, -0.05480957, 0.034576416, -0.08300781, -0.009056091, -0.004837036, -0.012962341, 0.015716553, -0.022125244, 0.05142212, -0.06585693, -0.027526855, -0.020126343, -0.033447266, 0.064331055, 0.00037527084, -0.052612305, 0.0023956299, -0.017745972, 0.0022182465, -0.012710571, 0.015258789, 0.002456665, 0.021896362, -0.006626129, 0.0063934326, 0.047546387, 0.009605408, -0.017684937, -0.015640259, 0.007881165, -0.01701355, 0.0020713806, 0.037109375, -0.026687622, 0.028411865, -0.0061454773, 0.052612305, 0.052886963, 0.019012451, -0.0035495758, -0.0017213821, 0.0012102127, 0.0067100525, 0.004497528, 0.004886627, -0.035369873, 0.02645874, 0.022644043, 0.0016479492, 0.037506104, -0.0032310486, 0.002336502, -0.029708862, -0.016555786, 0.050933838, 0.08111572, -0.04067993, -0.040222168, -0.001953125, 0.09869385, -0.022506714, 0.03387451, -0.029632568, 0.034454346, -0.027618408, 0.012046814, 0.002878189, -0.002714157, 0.009628296, -0.00674057, -0.056121826, -0.012969971, -0.043670654, 0.018310547, 0.01965332, 0.0446167, 0.01727295, 0.020690918, -0.0069351196, -0.023391724, -0.0052375793, 0.025634766, -0.03878784, -0.05618286, -0.014419556, -0.044799805, -0.040863037, -0.039367676, -0.11340332, -0.055877686, -0.009559631, 0.043884277, -0.023101807, 0.0143585205, 0.00919342, 0.07287598, 0.062316895, 0.015525818, -0.07861328, 0.009025574, -0.0066070557, 0.049346924, -0.017349243, 0.030227661, 0.0016489029, 0.017807007, -0.017196655, 0.005504608, -0.029205322, -0.08312988, 0.020324707, 0.0063476562, 0.029769897, 0.045806885, 0.011482239, 0.025558472, -0.029418945, 0.02748108, 0.02658081, -0.0065345764, -0.024642944, 0.0524292, -0.044036865, 0.03237915, 0.01423645, 0.013793945, -0.015594482, 0.01725769, -0.044555664, 0.016357422, -0.018753052, -0.008094788, -0.016479492, 0.030899048, 0.021713257, 0.007926941, 0.03930664, -0.00869751, 0.007369995, -0.005268097, 0.009529114, 0.015853882, -0.018981934, 0.0013980865, -0.022567749, -0.0033226013, -0.014793396, 0.000103116035, -0.04284668, -0.020935059, 0.006160736, 0.017044067, -0.020980835, -0.020645142, -0.037353516, -0.04107666, 0.018112183, 0.034942627, 0.04135132, -0.037139893, 0.019241333, -0.0052604675, -0.0027770996, 0.010948181, -0.030212402, -0.04449463, -0.024505615, 0.014343262, 0.044525146, 0.024246216, -0.016143799, 0.03515625, -0.019424438, -0.025421143, 0.008743286, -0.050720215, -0.03857422, -0.008888245, -0.030639648, -0.00028586388, 0.010101318, -0.013496399, -0.05960083, 0.005809784, -0.037506104, -0.0063667297, -0.01322937, -0.07489014, -0.0022144318, 0.00090169907, 0.031188965, 0.0385437, -0.020401001, 0.02217102, 0.0051651, 0.0064582825, -0.020629883, -0.033569336, 0.020355225, -0.03567505, 0.0028018951, 0.03579712, 0.04071045, -0.010864258, 0.0043296814, 0.005256653, -0.04458618, -0.019241333, 0.0037117004, -0.019180298, -0.010177612, 0.0027751923, -0.008781433, -0.03503418, 0.022857666, -0.05206299, 0.012489319, 0.0067481995, -0.014083862, -0.017089844, -0.018295288, 0.026611328, -0.02368164, 0.06756592, -0.006416321, -0.008972168, 0.04095459, 0.023239136, -0.017868042, -0.01171875, 0.015960693, -0.010269165, -0.007965088, 0.052703857, 0.028121948, -0.0055007935, -0.010810852, -0.008911133, -0.027801514, 0.022842407, 0.03579712, -0.05886841, -0.060638428, -0.009185791, -0.030212402, -0.041809082, 0.024169922, -0.01979065, -0.019119263, 0.012550354, 0.004764557, -0.018966675, 0.0056762695, 0.049743652, 0.036254883, -0.034820557, -0.09326172, -0.009140015, 0.017044067, 0.011245728, -0.0030879974, -0.0050315857, 0.02053833, -0.07208252, -0.00024724007, -0.00003796816, 0.025634766, -0.034576416, -0.0010995865, 0.002904892, 0.033081055, 0.00022661686, 0.02168274, 0.01133728, 0.010978699, -0.021896362, -0.066223145, -0.0011196136, -0.006877899, 0.027175903, -0.012199402, -0.000808239, -0.022216797, 0.0076675415, 0.024139404, -0.031082153, -0.008926392, -0.019180298, 0.0003643036, -0.00957489, 0.08392334, 0.012748718, -0.022354126, 0.005065918, 0.0048217773, 0.049438477, 0.015182495, 0.030456543, -0.018875122, -0.019180298, 0.013328552, -0.0062561035, 0.010032654, -0.027374268, 0.02885437, -0.02633667, 0.013664246, 0.0146102905, 0.04269409, 0.011192322, -0.0059394836, -0.012138367, 0.018569946, 0.027526855, 0.017623901, -0.0126953125, 0.022445679, -0.021102905, -0.00040602684, -0.027954102, -0.020736694, -0.027267456, 0.053344727, -0.012435913, 0.007709503, -0.0063323975, 0.012298584, -0.031341553, 0.036102295, 0.0011491776, 0.06707764, 0.018035889, 0.015129089, 0.0025367737, 0.020629883, -0.020812988, 0.0016918182, 0.051757812, 0.032806396, -0.021514893, 0.0132751465, 0.004470825, 0.06518555, -0.042999268, -0.031433105, -0.05706787, 0.02104187, -0.04559326, -0.009490967, 0.014518738, 0.01940918, -0.0051994324, 0.028686523, -0.03289795, 0.047698975, 0.011505127, 0.020309448, 0.006340027, 0.0039901733, 0.005504608, 0.0048942566, 0.015037537, 0.02154541, -0.029876709, 0.005367279, 0.0496521, 0.025436401, -0.02645874, 0.025878906, 0.028625488, -0.0025997162, -0.0032920837, -0.02142334, -0.04711914, -0.005504608, -0.0068473816, -0.0011253357, 0.014022827, 0.020187378, -0.0044517517, 0.033111572, 0.036224365, 0.02720642, -0.009498596, 0.009269714, -0.04296875, 0.021697998, 0.05340576, 0.033203125, 0.028671265, -0.010002136, 0.014602661, 0.052001953, -0.03933716, 0.021377563, 0.010040283, 0.023895264, 0.023422241, 0.04006958, -0.027740479, 0.015464783, 0.017120361, 0.005504608, 0.02407837, -0.030654907, 0.013015747, -0.006011963, -0.025741577, 0.00033903122, 0.0289917, 0.010940552, 0.105895996, -0.07086182, -0.021911621, -0.045806885, 0.015426636, -0.038208008, 0.0020103455, -0.046813965, -0.06512451, 0.0056533813, -0.0062828064, 0.022079468, -0.0519104, -0.03302002, -0.018356323, 0.024291992, -0.0143585205, 0.018844604, 0.03390503, -0.04055786, 0.0044021606, 0.016937256, 0.04034424, 0.06958008, 0.005405426, -0.04309082, -0.019088745, 0.058532715, 0.040893555, -0.0008468628, -0.06304932, 0.09423828, 0.025894165, -0.015655518, 0.009788513, 0.023803711, -0.015426636, -0.025436401, -0.027023315, 0.01689148, -0.03491211, -0.0036182404, 0.048095703, -0.0036621094, -0.039520264, -0.0093688965, -0.032073975, 0.026672363, -0.007843018, -0.033599854, 0.06713867, 0.009803772, -0.04714966, -0.01133728, -0.04019165, -0.03375244, -0.0034389496, -0.012329102, -0.000029861927, -0.02444458, 0.014305115, -0.062469482, -0.009361267, -0.031280518, 0.07836914, -0.00504303, -0.026504517, -0.03869629, -0.01512146, 0.058685303, 0.053253174, 0.024414062, -0.035003662, 0.020889282, 0.059539795, 0.0027332306, -0.006126404, -0.0014982224, -0.011001587, -0.011734009, -0.06329346, -0.028396606, -0.0031089783, 0.03640747, -0.0287323, -0.004760742, 0.012298584, -0.037322998, -0.07904053, -0.0052948, 0.0024166107, -0.008201599, 0.01474762, -0.038482666, 0.014427185, -0.0007662773, -0.0413208, 0.0016536713, -0.007610321, -0.013008118, 0.015129089, 0.00579834, -0.0031433105, -0.0115356445, -0.014205933, 0.019973755, -0.015670776, -0.00869751, -0.024398804, 0.041870117, -0.0927124, -0.054992676, -0.015037537, 0.014175415, -0.07684326, -0.038085938, 0.03475952, -0.0065727234, -0.019882202, -0.02067566, 0.01210022, 0.019119263, 0.026550293, 0.025344849, -0.008255005, 0.015808105, 0.010749817, 0.025817871, 0.010368347 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07296v1
BIDRN: A Method of Bidirectional Recurrent Neural Network for Sentiment Analysis
Dr. D Muthusankar, Dr. P Kaladevi, Dr. V R Sadasivam, R Praveen
cs.CL, cs.IR
Text mining research has grown in importance in recent years due to the tremendous increase in the volume of unstructured textual data. This has resulted in immense potential as well as obstacles in the sector, which may be efficiently addressed with adequate analytical and study methods. Deep Bidirectional Recurrent Neural Networks are used in this study to analyze sentiment. The method is categorized as sentiment polarity analysis because it may generate a dataset with sentiment labels. This dataset can be used to train and evaluate sentiment analysis models capable of extracting impartial opinions. This paper describes the Sentiment Analysis-Deep Bidirectional Recurrent Neural Networks (SA-BDRNN) Scheme, which seeks to overcome the challenges and maximize the potential of text mining in the context of Big Data. The current study proposes a SA-DBRNN Scheme that attempts to give a systematic framework for sentiment analysis in the context of student input on institution choice. The purpose of this study is to compare the effectiveness of the proposed SA- DBRNN Scheme to existing frameworks to establish a robust deep neural network that might serve as an adequate classification model in the field of sentiment analysis.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07296v1
2023-11-13T12:36:53
2023-11-13T12:36:53
{ "title": [ 0.0025520325, -0.0039863586, -0.031982422, -0.06173706, 0.01977539, -0.0028495789, -0.015434265, -0.015380859, 0.0206604, 0.0491333, -0.009300232, 0.0044784546, -0.014137268, -0.0074882507, -0.07574463, 0.0067634583, -0.022644043, 0.055725098, -0.015686035, -0.027801514, -0.014099121, -0.04458618, 0.01637268, 0.020690918, 0.035461426, -0.056243896, -0.04824829, 0.00044178963, -0.004562378, -0.012680054, 0.0049057007, -0.013168335, 0.03994751, 0.0029067993, 0.020004272, -0.010848999, -0.05529785, 0.012771606, 0.006839752, -0.000009417534, 0.00868988, 0.010147095, -0.040100098, -0.018539429, -0.050628662, 0.019592285, -0.057739258, -0.017456055, -0.017593384, 0.055267334, 0.029510498, 0.0026874542, -0.007873535, 0.033233643, 0.0138168335, -0.0395813, -0.0357666, 0.004802704, 0.026626587, 0.07128906, 0.033233643, -0.044311523, 0.002752304, -0.01991272, -0.05340576, 0.00032305717, 0.013114929, 0.013160706, 0.064697266, -0.025146484, -0.0231781, 0.032592773, 0.0003774166, -0.01739502, -0.06555176, -0.005004883, 0.04336548, -0.0124435425, 0.033843994, -0.04324341, -0.023361206, -0.034118652, 0.00066900253, -0.015342712, 0.008934021, -0.010406494, -0.029830933, -0.0008673668, -0.04067993, -0.06542969, -0.005859375, -0.05090332, -0.051361084, 0.041290283, -0.004611969, -0.023849487, -0.0079574585, 0.026138306, -0.017059326, -0.0038261414, -0.04144287, 0.043182373, -0.031082153, -0.009124756, 0.03668213, 0.005947113, -0.046875, -0.03967285, 0.03137207, 0.04458618, -0.02722168, 0.039520264, 0.008262634, 0.011497498, -0.015670776, 0.0073432922, -0.014076233, 0.005405426, -0.007675171, 0.01838684, -0.0079574585, -0.030807495, 0.024215698, 0.026107788, 0.021987915, 0.004299164, -0.054260254, 0.0017518997, -0.0050201416, 0.028167725, 0.010757446, 0.047912598, -0.1104126, -0.08483887, -0.06939697, 0.03704834, -0.005126953, 0.016021729, -0.011886597, -0.009521484, 0.028137207, -0.018295288, -0.016693115, 0.020202637, 0.035308838, 0.012580872, 0.06762695, -0.007522583, -0.035339355, -0.024139404, -0.014305115, 0.017303467, 0.02357483, -0.0070724487, -0.051971436, -0.002904892, -0.12054443, -0.0057525635, 0.008659363, 0.0038280487, 0.02607727, 0.0099105835, -0.0072517395, 0.022705078, 0.040252686, -0.0082473755, -0.0004825592, 0.019515991, 0.0064353943, 0.05911255, -0.02571106, 0.013122559, -0.0012512207, -0.017028809, -0.027633667, -0.0038661957, 0.022277832, 0.007572174, 0.0155181885, -0.02279663, 0.004306793, -0.029953003, -0.028900146, 0.057281494, -0.068725586, -0.0033016205, 0.01739502, 0.03286743, 0.044067383, 0.018814087, -0.014572144, 0.019546509, -0.011444092, -0.04876709, -0.055541992, -0.024505615, 0.027694702, 0.034454346, -0.011398315, 0.01398468, -0.046142578, 0.0014839172, -0.03286743, -0.010772705, -0.03250122, -0.016113281, -0.030395508, 0.037597656, -0.05038452, 0.071899414, 0.07055664, 0.035217285, -0.053588867, 0.0021820068, 0.010368347, -0.103393555, 0.03677368, -0.004917145, 0.013168335, -0.012611389, -0.014457703, -0.0077438354, -0.016098022, 0.038604736, 0.012710571, -0.014389038, 0.01033783, -0.030044556, 0.039733887, 0.031982422, 0.040985107, -0.039367676, 0.058563232, 0.008140564, -0.0056648254, -0.015266418, -0.0032806396, -0.043029785, -0.011512756, 0.02822876, 0.0057792664, -0.0029792786, -0.006587982, 0.03591919, 0.060638428, -0.017196655, 0.008850098, 0.014671326, 0.038604736, 0.048583984, 0.04776001, 0.026550293, 0.032348633, -0.025100708, 0.018920898, 0.058898926, 0.01083374, 0.018234253, -0.021911621, 0.018218994, -0.0017957687, 0.043945312, -0.0050697327, 0.021911621, -0.023223877, -0.016189575, -0.0126571655, 0.0041389465, 0.0059661865, -0.006252289, 0.037261963, 0.0137786865, 0.02532959, -0.015716553, -0.0042686462, -0.026351929, -0.018875122, 0.014671326, 0.03277588, -0.06463623, -0.021026611, 0.018188477, 0.023925781, 0.001086235, 0.021499634, 0.006542206, 0.0048675537, -0.015106201, -0.029434204, -0.018493652, 0.023117065, 0.06604004, 0.003047943, 0.0033473969, 0.0076026917, 0.011894226, 0.0769043, 0.058807373, -0.02331543, 0.029830933, -0.022201538, 0.037231445, 0.012786865, -0.014595032, 0.00919342, 0.025497437, 0.034057617, 0.017364502, -0.024642944, 0.0064926147, -0.055480957, -0.0050697327, -0.0034160614, -0.0048065186, -0.04650879, -0.05340576, 0.0028190613, -0.0362854, -0.015960693, -0.0066833496, 0.077941895, -0.02355957, -0.012504578, -0.0046958923, -0.011787415, -0.01966858, -0.0025253296, -0.02456665, 0.016036987, 0.01309967, 0.037109375, 0.023498535, -0.055847168, -0.030685425, -0.005470276, 0.0049362183, -0.022003174, 0.03201294, -0.01802063, 0.005001068, 0.007507324, 0.01373291, 0.016662598, -0.055023193, 0.010276794, -0.035705566, 0.0058250427, 0.030044556, -0.018341064, -0.0019760132, 0.008911133, -0.026870728, -0.03527832, 0.033813477, 0.05142212, -0.021743774, -0.0015716553, 0.04663086, 0.017654419, -0.015686035, -0.001534462, 0.0009660721, -0.013725281, -0.066345215, -0.007221222, -0.02760315, -0.041870117, 0.008987427, -0.02015686, 0.057922363, -0.052947998, -0.0124435425, -0.017227173, -0.021697998, -0.023727417, 0.00087833405, -0.022827148, -0.029174805, -0.025939941, -0.033355713, -0.00856781, -0.013771057, -0.018447876, -0.051330566, 0.061706543, 0.013343811, -0.016464233, -0.0058288574, 0.035736084, 0.0066070557, -0.014312744, -0.020965576, -0.011383057, 0.025024414, 0.0102005005, -0.005104065, -0.0003464222, -0.015640259, -0.12036133, 0.0067977905, 0.058288574, 0.011291504, -0.022888184, 0.028671265, -0.072021484, 0.039001465, -0.013412476, -0.016677856, 0.037353516, 0.020095825, 0.0049934387, 0.03817749, 0.0067749023, 0.004299164, -0.00920105, -0.041900635, -0.05834961, 0.015083313, -0.021759033, -0.046966553, 0.0025177002, -0.04095459, -0.034973145, -0.007583618, 0.0039596558, 0.046325684, 0.006526947, -0.00051927567, -0.015396118, -0.010513306, 0.005268097, -0.03186035, -0.013946533, -0.020095825, -0.020523071, 0.021133423, -0.011154175, 0.06964111, 0.011497498, -0.0041160583, -0.036865234, -0.018661499, 0.005558014, 0.01965332, 0.0067710876, -0.033721924, -0.013038635, -0.0087509155, -0.018920898, -0.005115509, -0.013389587, 0.013656616, -0.03213501, 0.008766174, -0.008132935, -0.013069153, 0.01625061, 0.025421143, -0.012741089, -0.020858765, 0.017684937, -0.023925781, -0.032318115, 0.033355713, 0.028884888, 0.008598328, 0.020019531, -0.01386261, -0.005329132, 0.020614624, -0.028060913, -0.022262573, 0.01713562, -0.009735107, -0.008056641, -0.015174866, -0.025039673, 0.009239197, -0.0317688, 0.0014076233, 0.0035800934, 0.00073862076, -0.04827881, -0.07574463, 0.0014562607, 0.0016717911, -0.109436035, -0.042388916, 0.00504303, -0.054718018, -0.051879883, -0.038848877, 0.020751953, -0.019882202, -0.017089844, 0.010643005, -0.009864807, -0.012260437, -0.029724121, -0.06719971, -0.06060791, 0.08081055, -0.00084352493, 0.030258179, 0.030654907, -0.0040779114, -0.022140503, -0.03326416, 0.014144897, -0.0044937134, 0.04159546, -0.018875122, -0.011581421, 0.04385376, -0.03717041, 0.005744934, 0.039215088, 0.015037537, -0.008674622, 0.0045776367, 0.018844604, 0.046417236, -0.024627686, 0.04272461, 0.0031051636, -0.024215698, -0.074645996, 0.0131073, -0.0020885468, 0.009590149, 0.016311646, -0.0047035217, 0.014213562, 0.0018949509, 0.010475159, 0.029159546, -0.02229309, 0.02658081, 0.0703125, -0.035003662, -0.00982666, 0.028671265, 0.027328491, 0.019332886, 0.0132751465, 0.008026123, -0.00028395653, 0.02281189, -0.017959595, -0.011199951, -0.028411865, -0.010185242, -0.041046143, -0.0084991455, -0.037902832, -0.07354736, -0.02949524, 0.0016641617, -0.004486084, 0.03616333, 0.047210693, -0.008094788, -0.023880005, -0.0016145706, 0.018218994, -0.011459351, 0.008666992, -0.05606079, -0.01361084, -0.009880066, -0.05215454, -0.03552246, -0.005756378, 0.010643005, 0.021255493, -0.005302429, 0.013397217, 0.027694702, 0.01625061, 0.030715942, 0.029754639, -0.018127441, -0.033599854, 0.044677734, -0.012123108, -0.0051879883, -0.0010223389, -0.0039520264, 0.0060424805, -0.010482788, 0.0014829636, -0.025115967, -0.010070801, -0.027542114, 0.009376526, -0.0006890297, 0.032104492, -0.000045716763, 0.020584106, 0.017089844, 0.015594482, 0.022903442, 0.013786316, -0.028198242, -0.053833008, 0.020980835, 0.048980713, 0.0013961792, 0.012069702, 0.039916992, 0.011177063, -0.016143799, 0.008041382, 0.02670288, 0.014274597, -0.014564514, -0.021484375, 0.020339966, -0.031173706, -0.016448975, 0.0053634644, -0.009979248, 0.05218506, -0.049591064, 0.07421875, -0.03543091, -0.009056091, 0.04446411, 0.00029969215, -0.01939392, -0.0032424927, 0.008926392, -0.06506348, -0.0569458, -0.009483337, 0.058532715, -0.02017212, 0.018356323, 0.0066223145, -0.014694214, 0.015052795, 0.048553467, 0.0035133362, 0.009559631, 0.00032901764, -0.014221191, -0.01586914, -0.029968262, -0.038513184, 0.012542725, 0.030334473, -0.0018663406, -0.05154419, -0.025634766, -0.053466797, -0.0546875, -0.007537842, -0.017471313, 0.016738892, -0.060668945, 0.013542175, 0.06185913, -0.0135650635, 0.04864502, -0.014350891, 0.025665283, 0.010353088, 0.049194336, 0.008659363, 0.007019043, 0.032592773, -0.06390381, -0.024124146, -0.010032654, 0.039215088, 0.03302002, 0.0010919571, 0.031829834, -0.0032444, -0.057128906, 0.039123535, 0.0044898987, -0.037719727, 0.030227661, -0.041229248, 0.0128479, -0.004070282, 0.015060425, 0.0035800934, -0.021591187, -0.017654419, -0.01158905, -0.032806396, -0.07067871, -0.009140015, -0.0513916, -0.0602417, -0.039154053, 0.036193848, 0.0068740845, -0.0065193176, -0.008720398, 0.011383057, -0.04724121, 0.018356323, 0.017532349, -0.07470703, 0.0050201416, -0.012565613, 0.024932861, 0.035888672, 0.015731812, -0.02607727, -0.0058784485, -0.011428833, -0.038848877, -0.02003479, 0.031311035, 0.024795532, -0.009628296, 0.007621765, -0.05328369, 0.039916992, 0.028656006, 0.026779175, 0.017623901, 0.0065689087, 0.02204895, 0.024658203, 0.051513672, 0.013946533, 0.038635254, 0.039733887, -0.0047683716, 0.0012130737, -0.04522705, 0.0021629333, 0.0014429092, 0.016540527, -0.017959595, -0.0692749, 0.0028419495, 0.019943237, 0.019058228, 0.012718201, 0.018753052, 0.040649414, 0.028411865, -0.0021572113, 0.019210815, 0.060150146, -0.044067383, -0.04534912, -0.034179688, -0.0031719208, -0.049041748, 0.059661865, -0.021697998, -0.035217285, -0.038879395, -0.044677734, -0.025268555, 0.019882202, 0.032836914, 0.016845703, 0.045959473, -0.04309082, 0.007286072, -0.023986816, -0.013198853, -0.027404785, 0.030090332, -0.004306793, 0.0024738312, -0.000115156174, -0.013191223, 0.015914917, -0.035614014, 0.022628784, 0.015914917, -0.019836426, 0.022949219, -0.050109863, 0.017654419, 0.012367249, -0.04055786, 0.03488159, -0.036987305, 0.0068893433, 0.015266418, -0.014060974, 0.053344727, 0.0046310425, 0.048858643, 0.050811768, 0.0126953125, 0.010879517, -0.007785797, 0.0067367554, -0.046295166, -0.0079193115, -0.015022278, -0.023452759, -0.034332275, -0.012016296, -0.067993164, 0.026992798, 0.013519287, 0.03878784, 0.0030937195, 0.024551392, 0.027374268, -0.0041122437, 0.075805664, -0.01977539, 0.08502197, 0.028533936, 0.02557373, -0.018585205, -0.049713135, 0.010475159, 0.039245605, 0.0010643005, 0.010116577, -0.013053894, -0.011978149, 0.02015686, 0.015686035, 0.010887146, 0.0056915283, -0.0011472702, -0.028076172, 0.020736694, -0.01701355, 0.031204224, 0.062194824, 0.054595947, -0.03857422, -0.0021514893, 0.013748169, -0.01939392, -0.038635254, 0.015075684, 0.037017822, -0.05770874, 0.029266357, -0.038604736, -0.029937744, -0.030776978, 0.032928467, 0.013267517, -0.05203247, -0.036865234, 0.02029419, 0.045074463, 0.012817383, 0.022247314, -0.04360962, -0.01626587, 0.020614624, 0.028152466, -0.028427124, -0.008995056, 0.044799805, 0.04397583, -0.01928711, -0.009544373, 0.001162529, 0.008628845, -0.029556274, 0.036315918, -0.01322937, 0.024276733, -0.005756378, -0.047302246, 0.016815186, 0.017837524, -0.05444336, -0.018844604, 0.05899048, 0.023071289, 0.020233154, 0.0670166, 0.03137207, -0.0035114288, -0.02949524, -0.0362854, 0.013618469, 0.02406311, -0.031555176, 0.0041236877, -0.037261963, -0.03152466, 0.0011692047, -0.023529053, 0.07244873, -0.01802063, -0.008102417, -0.020874023, 0.02217102, 0.027648926, -0.041046143, 0.0012779236, -0.007282257, -0.0033397675, -0.029769897, -0.013328552, -0.035949707, -0.03173828, -0.025238037, 0.028030396, -0.011001587, -0.012290955, -0.005580902, -0.015556335, -0.06939697, -0.01210022, -0.02406311, 0.023086548, -0.013412476, 0.019973755, 0.00340271, 0.013313293, -0.0006942749, -0.041412354, -0.026428223, 0.00082302094, -0.037994385, -0.043792725, 0.01966858, 0.0058403015, -0.028503418, -0.025970459, -0.031402588, 0.0027694702, -0.026947021, -0.005592346, 0.044433594, -0.040496826, -0.051940918, -0.0020656586, -0.03942871, 0.05496216, 0.0064353943, -0.01966858, 0.019546509, 0.00806427, -0.015472412, -0.008422852, 0.00869751, 0.034179688, -0.013053894, -0.035491943, -0.019744873, 0.034332275, 0.028198242, -0.07733154, -0.061462402, -0.00014698505, 0.055786133, -0.022155762, 0.056396484, 0.03390503, -0.0073127747, 0.024261475, -0.003396988, -0.008110046, -0.021636963, -0.08026123, -0.06512451, 0.06414795, 0.015808105, -0.0099487305, -0.047607422, 0.037322998, -0.00069618225, 0.019332886, 0.002986908, -0.009025574, 0.017028809, -0.013343811, 0.014175415, -0.02558899, -0.025039673, -0.038391113, 0.049621582, -0.0076828003, 0.06210327, -0.02494812, 0.02558899, 0.035980225, 0.06994629, -0.01966858, -0.05810547, 0.050109863, 0.018508911, 0.018249512, 0.06719971, 0.004421234, -0.022262573, -0.00056886673, -0.025177002, -0.019042969, -0.0124435425, 0.02822876, -0.016845703, 0.0038661957, -0.01612854, -0.033325195, -0.025024414, -0.0541687, 0.06414795, -0.040771484, -0.0044021606, -0.03086853, -0.009017944, -0.019485474, 0.027069092, -0.015411377, -0.05831909, -0.031555176, 0.0061836243, 0.058502197, -0.003768921 ], "summary": [ 0.027816772, -0.00094747543, 0.004558563, -0.015419006, -0.0061454773, -0.017715454, -0.011528015, -0.024719238, 0.031799316, 0.047668457, -0.02960205, 0.004386902, 0.012916565, -0.00025177002, -0.050445557, -0.028869629, -0.01953125, 0.006336212, -0.024215698, -0.024612427, 0.00042414665, -0.025650024, -0.010864258, -0.03692627, 0.044555664, -0.07458496, 0.018661499, 0.010353088, 0.05029297, 0.032318115, 0.044677734, -0.057037354, 0.017669678, -0.007659912, 0.028076172, -0.035308838, 0.013221741, -0.016647339, 0.01386261, -0.0033798218, 0.018341064, -0.008270264, 0.062438965, 0.013198853, -0.008369446, 0.026855469, -0.012275696, -0.0231781, 0.03161621, 0.034576416, -0.009597778, -0.02003479, -0.019332886, -0.01675415, -0.009315491, 0.008773804, -0.057739258, 0.009529114, 0.015342712, 0.06726074, 0.026107788, -0.017654419, -0.0036506653, -0.02658081, -0.02670288, 0.026229858, 0.028625488, -0.026657104, 0.009796143, -0.019836426, 0.004562378, -0.00090169907, 0.03387451, -0.060333252, -0.021881104, 0.0036563873, 0.023971558, -0.0064849854, -0.014633179, -0.024414062, -0.05581665, -0.002231598, -0.020080566, -0.03744507, -0.013114929, -0.027770996, -0.04373169, 0.011100769, -0.024215698, 0.0035991669, -0.021026611, -0.056854248, -0.041625977, 0.087646484, 0.03086853, -0.012634277, -0.026168823, -0.033599854, -0.04269409, 0.015335083, -0.0004348755, -0.011512756, 0.024337769, -0.0058631897, 0.01197052, -0.015579224, -0.050964355, -0.10644531, 0.018737793, 0.047698975, -0.024368286, 0.018341064, 0.014480591, -0.014915466, -0.035125732, 0.016479492, 0.012878418, 0.010147095, 0.0184021, 0.015991211, -0.027359009, -0.0032863617, 0.009605408, -0.0065994263, -0.0007648468, -0.017578125, 0.0030612946, 0.0032691956, -0.024124146, 0.017959595, 0.0037937164, 0.024246216, -0.060638428, -0.01864624, -0.05517578, 0.012084961, -0.03253174, -0.005882263, 0.020477295, -0.059661865, 0.08215332, -0.003396988, -0.0043029785, 0.087890625, 0.037628174, -0.01386261, 0.032714844, 0.026351929, 0.01158905, 0.0009775162, 0.009025574, 0.020996094, 0.023468018, -0.020812988, -0.036956787, -0.05819702, -0.042266846, -0.032928467, 0.03173828, -0.030944824, 0.05178833, 0.016189575, -0.0019989014, 0.0848999, 0.038482666, -0.011695862, 0.014320374, 0.0035896301, 0.0026512146, -0.0026016235, 0.01071167, 0.04425049, 0.0289917, -0.02557373, 0.005012512, -0.016616821, -0.020645142, 0.0022468567, 0.0024967194, 0.0054130554, -0.00039577484, -0.032928467, -0.043182373, 0.03060913, 0.0010251999, 0.020904541, 0.039245605, 0.085998535, -0.010765076, 0.032318115, -0.014511108, 0.003955841, 0.007843018, 0.005130768, -0.030532837, -0.03881836, 0.010002136, 0.011726379, -0.017791748, 0.011558533, -0.013313293, 0.021133423, -0.024719238, -0.041625977, -0.09313965, -0.004787445, -0.032958984, 0.0597229, -0.03982544, 0.03074646, 0.041168213, 0.008476257, -0.0592041, 0.047454834, -0.0028820038, -0.07684326, 0.030288696, -0.035888672, -0.01751709, -0.007369995, -0.010902405, 0.015426636, -0.042663574, 0.041748047, 0.00091934204, -0.021865845, 0.009315491, -0.0071754456, 0.026290894, 0.01739502, 0.023605347, -0.017852783, 0.07763672, 0.05130005, -0.015129089, -0.012428284, 0.022247314, -0.08605957, 0.0072517395, 0.050598145, 0.046783447, 0.059326172, -0.015716553, -0.031311035, -0.0026664734, -0.03253174, 0.034088135, -0.060028076, 0.027069092, 0.052856445, -0.012954712, 0.0074501038, 0.013908386, -0.020248413, 0.03543091, 0.034301758, 0.00038027763, -0.0059280396, -0.0074653625, 0.018371582, -0.0058288574, 0.013389587, 0.006450653, 0.0079422, -0.026519775, -0.03564453, 0.027786255, 0.025314331, 0.032196045, -0.06768799, 0.010032654, 0.01737976, 0.019973755, -0.04647827, -0.04626465, -0.03286743, -0.027664185, 0.038757324, 0.060943604, -0.047332764, -0.011398315, -0.0006971359, -0.027420044, -0.01977539, 0.053894043, 0.0056915283, -0.02986145, -0.038848877, -0.019088745, 0.049438477, 0.016204834, 0.091796875, 0.0065078735, 0.038848877, -0.0010566711, 0.044281006, 0.029342651, 0.023773193, -0.00919342, -0.006839752, 0.005176544, 0.028762817, -0.023101807, 0.007648468, 0.03286743, 0.03314209, 0.027664185, 0.015403748, 0.034973145, 0.029159546, -0.020599365, 0.01586914, 0.011985779, 0.04434204, -0.030288696, -0.027359009, -0.008522034, 0.041748047, 0.0041007996, 0.034240723, 0.11376953, -0.018859863, 0.010498047, -0.043548584, -0.035888672, -0.04244995, -0.014442444, -0.02557373, 0.034088135, -0.014007568, -0.017303467, -0.0074005127, -0.03277588, 0.022079468, -0.00065612793, -0.019348145, 0.02708435, -0.00969696, 0.011962891, -0.0033721924, 0.04815674, -0.0010271072, -0.030456543, 0.008743286, -0.005432129, -0.024307251, -0.02029419, 0.0044288635, 0.009162903, 0.011268616, -0.021942139, -0.009994507, -0.03289795, 0.030380249, -0.0073547363, 0.017227173, 0.04067993, 0.014289856, 0.007282257, -0.029785156, 0.025344849, 0.012878418, 0.006351471, -0.057495117, -0.03237915, -0.008911133, -0.026565552, 0.01309967, -0.00030350685, 0.01335907, 0.044799805, 0.028869629, -0.004421234, -0.030914307, -0.042053223, -0.05432129, 0.034942627, 0.0033435822, 0.020431519, 0.032958984, 0.03262329, 0.0044555664, 0.011360168, -0.041931152, -0.004573822, 0.0062294006, -0.036224365, -0.020751953, 0.03793335, 0.025344849, 0.011123657, -0.008720398, 0.02458191, -0.009239197, 0.018035889, 0.00046730042, -0.0129852295, 0.0066719055, -0.024353027, -0.022018433, 0.012031555, 0.03894043, -0.0045814514, 0.048706055, -0.045715332, 0.017425537, 0.011505127, -0.024551392, 0.024215698, -0.046539307, 0.03491211, 0.016571045, -0.01965332, 0.046173096, -0.015655518, -0.054656982, 0.034210205, 0.004917145, 0.0090789795, -0.056274414, -0.014442444, 0.052093506, -0.0049438477, -0.009735107, 0.011650085, 0.03213501, -0.05206299, -0.040649414, -0.0076408386, 0.07220459, -0.0024166107, 0.0345459, -0.0032691956, -0.012168884, -0.033721924, 0.01473999, 0.0019388199, 0.04800415, 0.02104187, -0.030319214, -0.021331787, -0.02128601, -0.0019130707, 0.0005173683, 0.012641907, -0.036010742, -0.014511108, -0.008895874, 0.009063721, -0.018112183, -0.009536743, 0.026016235, 0.07940674, 0.007385254, 0.008674622, -0.07293701, -0.017181396, 0.049560547, 0.0345459, -0.0703125, -0.015670776, -0.05166626, 0.056396484, 0.030532837, 0.054779053, -0.023071289, -0.011367798, 0.0028362274, -0.010116577, 0.015914917, 0.037322998, -0.03363037, -0.008201599, -0.03692627, 0.0079193115, -0.054626465, 0.012779236, -0.004722595, 0.03439331, -0.028808594, -0.039855957, 0.02029419, -0.04333496, -0.06542969, -0.005126953, -0.0013875961, -0.06506348, -0.070739746, 0.024505615, -0.03692627, -0.017486572, -0.04840088, 0.03186035, 0.0019483566, 0.010566711, -0.008132935, -0.017623901, 0.10723877, -0.00566864, -0.05319214, -0.0016794205, -0.031402588, 0.0010156631, 0.017471313, -0.026763916, 0.045806885, 0.028335571, -0.0051651, 0.019058228, -0.053527832, 0.011947632, -0.022506714, -0.03010559, 0.044830322, -0.059661865, -0.028396606, 0.0020389557, 0.04510498, -0.04525757, -0.00868988, 0.040222168, 0.05810547, -0.037994385, 0.007820129, 0.025375366, -0.0002541542, -0.04815674, 0.0003027916, -0.013916016, 0.030548096, 0.02708435, 0.052764893, 0.0138168335, -0.025985718, -0.0049209595, -0.07867432, -0.052947998, 0.011886597, 0.045837402, -0.02331543, -0.02230835, 0.010063171, 0.009254456, 0.028411865, 0.021942139, -0.027114868, -0.01876831, -0.008323669, -0.058410645, -0.0018224716, -0.041229248, -0.03201294, -0.061553955, -0.04748535, 0.00756073, -0.0814209, -0.027282715, -0.015792847, 0.016067505, 0.01687622, 0.012207031, 0.03604126, -0.013870239, -0.018753052, 0.05102539, 0.001531601, 0.010772705, -0.03878784, -0.06210327, -0.008079529, -0.038146973, 0.0023708344, -0.026184082, -0.04537964, -0.01197052, 0.0008006096, 0.00026988983, 0.019897461, -0.021499634, -0.0093688965, 0.0075187683, 0.008384705, -0.010627747, 0.0054359436, -0.046173096, 0.053649902, -0.020523071, 0.05529785, -0.021438599, 0.012329102, -0.0058555603, -0.014724731, -0.010955811, -0.0791626, -0.024307251, -0.013206482, -0.0015764236, 0.038269043, 0.009643555, 0.005973816, 0.025054932, 0.006576538, -0.0036792755, -0.004589081, -0.019180298, 0.023330688, 0.026473999, 0.034973145, 0.036468506, 0.061309814, -0.014060974, -0.0463562, -0.012306213, 0.046173096, 0.03540039, -0.04144287, 0.0037231445, 0.011802673, 0.015350342, -0.013298035, 0.012878418, -0.013885498, 0.0135269165, -0.014022827, 0.023971558, -0.014701843, -0.0105896, 0.02432251, -0.010040283, -0.049041748, -0.021957397, -0.024032593, -0.057525635, -0.048187256, -0.033233643, 0.052459717, -0.0066986084, 0.00033974648, -0.007549286, -0.038269043, -0.004234314, 0.00831604, -0.026687622, 0.009147644, 0.018463135, -0.0063209534, -0.012069702, -0.00080394745, 0.007171631, -0.0065078735, 0.05065918, 0.010726929, -0.036834717, -0.039886475, 0.039794922, -0.026367188, -0.0065841675, -0.008583069, -0.0038890839, -0.038513184, -0.02720642, 0.002439499, -0.03173828, 0.011184692, -0.029556274, 0.01713562, -0.01751709, 0.033721924, -0.017059326, -0.028259277, 0.03390503, -0.036346436, -0.004547119, -0.02104187, 0.032165527, 0.040771484, 0.006286621, 0.034606934, 0.019332886, -0.050323486, 0.005672455, -0.033966064, -0.037963867, 0.031311035, -0.023712158, -0.009414673, -0.021453857, 0.047180176, 0.0041656494, 0.015319824, 0.035308838, 0.023803711, -0.011367798, -0.032836914, -0.048858643, -0.06726074, -0.037963867, -0.036071777, -0.008140564, -0.011367798, -0.010154724, -0.002790451, 0.028930664, -0.017501831, 0.012321472, -0.011367798, -0.03677368, -0.028930664, 0.04055786, 0.028381348, -0.004016876, -0.004207611, -0.0065841675, -0.008888245, -0.0049552917, -0.03479004, -0.036743164, 0.018157959, 0.010696411, 0.022857666, 0.02381897, 0.0058784485, 0.066711426, -0.03286743, 0.0063591003, 0.034606934, 0.03274536, 0.02268982, 0.0036678314, 0.019729614, 0.026748657, 0.0022277832, 0.018066406, -0.005050659, -0.0018081665, -0.028045654, -0.028701782, 0.01890564, 0.018798828, -0.06506348, -0.06982422, -0.008308411, 0.021713257, 0.027938843, 0.061157227, 0.001581192, 0.02696228, 0.03842163, -0.009185791, 0.03125, 0.050872803, -0.05392456, -0.036499023, -0.05038452, 0.01071167, -0.074279785, -0.022369385, -0.007575989, -0.017333984, 0.0048713684, 0.00066804886, 0.018234253, 0.0032253265, -0.0035533905, -0.0054092407, 0.049560547, 0.0098724365, 0.008979797, -0.03768921, -0.033721924, -0.025497437, 0.040100098, -0.025390625, -0.04168701, 0.02545166, -0.054382324, 0.015640259, 0.02128601, -0.004863739, -0.02305603, -0.022613525, 0.0513916, -0.013511658, 0.015213013, 0.017929077, -0.013504028, 0.03439331, -0.019073486, 0.022766113, 0.0069465637, 0.031082153, 0.017074585, 0.017837524, 0.026794434, 0.018936157, 0.022842407, 0.047607422, 0.0066108704, 0.007850647, 0.0055122375, -0.028060913, 0.029647827, -0.070007324, -0.031219482, -0.017089844, 0.00021481514, 0.063964844, -0.042541504, 0.0040779114, 0.0043792725, 0.018218994, 0.025238037, -0.02911377, 0.0074920654, -0.0869751, 0.034057617, 0.02935791, 0.013893127, -0.0026302338, -0.05343628, 0.009284973, 0.04425049, -0.004699707, 0.01574707, 0.007751465, 0.0059051514, 0.02130127, -0.016586304, -0.017562866, -0.016677856, 0.028793335, -0.02961731, 0.047943115, 0.014526367, 0.045196533, 0.021743774, 0.02772522, -0.023986816, -0.008056641, 0.027374268, 0.017227173, -0.058807373, 0.031082153, 0.011581421, -0.011245728, -0.024993896, 0.0014867783, 0.0032539368, 0.0040359497, 0.025268555, 0.02243042, -0.030838013, -0.022018433, 0.0143585205, 0.0051879883, 0.024291992, 0.002193451, -0.042114258, -0.023162842, 0.025878906, 0.003162384, -0.02027893, -0.03137207, 0.028427124, 0.032440186, -0.002948761, 0.004173279, 0.0019187927, 0.0066490173, -0.018218994, 0.022750854, -0.009002686, -0.005847931, -0.00843811, -0.027313232, -0.0018835068, 0.0236969, -0.022521973, -0.0018520355, 0.014793396, 0.0051841736, 0.044799805, 0.07354736, -0.025360107, 0.032196045, 0.018127441, 0.013946533, 0.013259888, 0.004722595, -0.017791748, -0.033233643, -0.023513794, 0.004299164, -0.027450562, -0.023986816, 0.020523071, -0.009254456, 0.023269653, -0.028274536, 0.009384155, -0.036071777, -0.016998291, 0.032928467, -0.013717651, -0.044891357, 0.016952515, -0.00869751, -0.037384033, -0.021057129, -0.019638062, -0.0056114197, -0.0002629757, -0.011146545, 0.02456665, -0.014755249, -0.026779175, -0.0209198, 0.01977539, 0.0178833, 0.01651001, 0.0075569153, 0.039367676, 0.009239197, -0.015426636, -0.056243896, -0.022323608, 0.01902771, 0.017166138, -0.07165527, 0.029815674, 0.014190674, -0.027145386, -0.060791016, -0.024627686, -0.027130127, -0.02507019, 0.033996582, 0.040527344, -0.008171082, -0.06262207, 0.00724411, -0.036621094, 0.040618896, -0.011009216, 0.011077881, 0.021133423, 0.011207581, -0.011184692, 0.004562378, 0.032104492, 0.032226562, -0.0034694672, -0.0010948181, -0.029159546, 0.021057129, 0.0071792603, -0.06506348, -0.050109863, 0.0058670044, 0.05053711, -0.0035591125, 0.0077323914, -0.0031719208, -0.008895874, 0.018508911, -0.0022449493, -0.002117157, -0.011177063, -0.08428955, -0.054382324, 0.08660889, -0.02734375, -0.030303955, -0.047424316, 0.03781128, -0.0033817291, -0.030441284, 0.019973755, 0.018585205, -0.033935547, 0.013191223, 0.0013341904, -0.030426025, -0.049835205, -0.0052452087, 0.024795532, 0.0018491745, 0.04660034, -0.012298584, 0.018173218, 0.02961731, 0.03189087, -0.03768921, -0.013580322, 0.04345703, 0.004547119, 0.022109985, 0.024673462, 0.046722412, 0.014801025, 0.018844604, -0.04144287, -0.02772522, -0.04248047, 0.050811768, -0.018295288, -0.024124146, -0.014129639, 0.0060768127, -0.03540039, -0.06817627, 0.08544922, -0.032928467, -0.020935059, -0.020584106, -0.002790451, 0.0049743652, -0.017028809, -0.051452637, -0.049316406, 0.043548584, 0.11505127, -0.031463623, 0.029129028 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07277v1
AdaCCD: Adaptive Semantic Contrasts Discovery based Cross Lingual Adaptation for Code Clone Detection
Yangkai Du, Tengfei Ma, Lingfei Wu, Xuhong Zhang, Shouling Ji
cs.SE, cs.CL
Code Clone Detection, which aims to retrieve functionally similar programs from large code bases, has been attracting increasing attention. Modern software often involves a diverse range of programming languages. However, current code clone detection methods are generally limited to only a few popular programming languages due to insufficient annotated data as well as their own model design constraints. To address these issues, we present AdaCCD, a novel cross-lingual adaptation method that can detect cloned codes in a new language without any annotations in that language. AdaCCD leverages language-agnostic code representations from pre-trained programming language models and propose an Adaptively Refined Contrastive Learning framework to transfer knowledge from resource-rich languages to resource-poor languages. We evaluate the cross-lingual adaptation results of AdaCCD by constructing a multilingual code clone detection benchmark consisting of 5 programming languages. AdaCCD achieves significant improvements over other baselines, and it is even comparable to supervised fine-tuning.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07277v1
2023-11-13T12:20:48
2023-11-13T12:20:48
{ "title": [ -0.031555176, -0.017440796, -0.038970947, -0.034851074, -0.0138168335, -0.008735657, -0.0446167, -0.009063721, 0.0037784576, 0.055541992, -0.02507019, 0.021606445, 0.030380249, -0.009140015, -0.019332886, 0.010375977, -0.010360718, 0.053344727, 0.016204834, -0.029525757, -0.00762558, -0.021820068, 0.031799316, 0.01763916, 0.047973633, -0.08392334, -0.028701782, 0.0053520203, 0.026184082, -0.011741638, 0.016494751, 0.000521183, 0.06185913, 0.010238647, -0.039001465, 0.015007019, -0.0637207, 0.01776123, -0.02960205, 0.035614014, 0.036499023, -0.019012451, 0.04425049, -0.028701782, 0.020843506, 0.017486572, -0.015449524, -0.042785645, -0.030792236, 0.012832642, -0.0016260147, -0.019699097, -0.00422287, 0.03161621, 0.008232117, -0.042266846, -0.023880005, 0.041870117, 0.038391113, 0.046203613, 0.0024776459, -0.013511658, -0.002544403, -0.031311035, -0.0236969, -0.03062439, -0.0009589195, 0.014831543, 0.046844482, -0.0129470825, -0.0014238358, 0.03866577, 0.013694763, -0.033081055, -0.028411865, 0.035736084, -0.014625549, -0.014099121, 0.055023193, -0.031433105, -0.023544312, -0.034454346, 0.019439697, -0.023376465, 0.011779785, -0.019821167, -0.016082764, 0.008811951, -0.050689697, -0.072631836, -0.018234253, 0.014511108, -0.0770874, -0.024917603, -0.010643005, -0.056121826, 0.0007343292, 0.0657959, -0.024154663, -0.019927979, -0.044281006, 0.034179688, -0.060516357, -0.040252686, 0.0066947937, 0.0034446716, 0.011772156, -0.0206604, 0.0064926147, 0.015625, -0.05230713, 0.038879395, -0.00504303, 0.007785797, -0.03048706, 0.026992798, -0.0035991669, -0.030334473, -0.01777649, -0.002904892, -0.008934021, -0.0039787292, 0.0057792664, 0.00021624565, 0.02192688, 0.013755798, -0.013748169, -0.0023288727, 0.029800415, 0.022079468, 0.0041656494, 0.0103302, -0.06439209, -0.046081543, -0.039215088, 0.019821167, -0.00995636, 0.0026493073, 0.0072631836, -0.022079468, 0.02267456, -0.018157959, 0.018249512, 0.012832642, 0.006526947, 0.016693115, 0.028045654, -0.009269714, 0.007461548, -0.0009074211, -0.03338623, -0.006164551, 0.042022705, -0.023361206, -0.06542969, -0.053985596, -0.10882568, -0.024414062, 0.044433594, -0.02633667, -0.0013074875, -0.014228821, -0.007499695, 0.029037476, 0.0289917, 0.023330688, 0.01008606, 0.0036964417, 0.034606934, 0.052215576, -0.014259338, 0.01586914, 0.023086548, -0.0056152344, -0.019378662, 0.00004029274, 0.044281006, 0.0004107952, 0.0068626404, -0.031051636, 0.0050697327, -0.019592285, 0.021408081, 0.011672974, -0.071899414, -0.028381348, 0.022613525, 0.05819702, 0.02772522, 0.009231567, 0.039276123, 0.00007086992, -0.029907227, -0.02619934, -0.03540039, -0.019073486, 0.02923584, 0.030288696, -0.00680542, 0.0043640137, -0.015235901, 0.003145218, -0.010101318, 0.0029735565, -0.036468506, -0.016296387, -0.023208618, 0.018630981, -0.0012054443, 0.050933838, 0.036224365, 0.013633728, -0.054382324, 0.06677246, 0.00737381, -0.07318115, 0.018478394, -0.00566864, 0.032104492, -0.0042800903, 0.016983032, 0.019348145, 0.003288269, 0.0055274963, -0.020050049, -0.0018157959, -0.0058937073, -0.0077171326, 0.0033607483, 0.016418457, 0.061065674, -0.019088745, 0.04031372, 0.00078105927, -0.020706177, -0.019683838, 0.000120699406, -0.045684814, 0.0064468384, 0.03475952, -0.0008044243, 0.012382507, -0.025161743, -0.020507812, 0.07336426, -0.0012979507, 0.0029506683, -0.0032596588, 0.028167725, 0.04586792, 0.03265381, 0.005935669, 0.028640747, -0.034851074, 0.0033073425, 0.054107666, -0.033355713, 0.0033245087, -0.0050811768, 0.005039215, 0.0065193176, -0.01701355, 0.0010557175, 0.0011701584, -0.032165527, 0.0031356812, 0.0039978027, 0.0075645447, -0.018081665, -0.0047836304, 0.028289795, 0.036987305, 0.014373779, -0.0027008057, 0.033172607, 0.01374054, -0.026779175, -0.0063667297, 0.06088257, -0.020843506, -0.011436462, 0.036987305, -0.008415222, -0.037231445, 0.021469116, 0.011230469, -0.034210205, -0.059539795, -0.027832031, -0.0065956116, 0.04977417, 0.03387451, -0.0020103455, -0.0032844543, 0.0029182434, -0.0014276505, 0.12670898, 0.05899048, -0.020965576, 0.043640137, -0.021240234, 0.013542175, 0.00793457, -0.0154953, 0.0024776459, 0.025100708, 0.0093307495, -0.00040102005, -0.031707764, 0.018203735, -0.06726074, -0.015022278, -0.0019311905, -0.009338379, -0.06732178, -0.06732178, -0.02418518, -0.030380249, -0.064941406, -0.03375244, 0.06506348, -0.0068206787, 0.013168335, 0.028045654, 0.012634277, -0.052368164, 0.02848816, -0.0034885406, 0.020767212, 0.0036029816, 0.01222229, 0.020812988, -0.06842041, -0.06048584, -0.004119873, -0.006298065, -0.001906395, -0.046905518, -0.0138549805, 0.031188965, 0.040496826, 0.045806885, 0.023971558, -0.038970947, 0.009101868, -0.070251465, 0.017700195, 0.009971619, -0.07293701, -0.010505676, 0.045440674, -0.043792725, 0.005207062, 0.024902344, 0.051879883, -0.025650024, -0.04043579, 0.054260254, 0.025909424, 0.00944519, 0.034484863, 0.03765869, 0.018997192, -0.00983429, -0.029144287, -0.06222534, 0.005470276, -0.0048942566, 0.008171082, 0.0602417, -0.03164673, -0.028533936, -0.017562866, -0.005367279, 0.014602661, -0.017562866, -0.0058784485, -0.034454346, 0.009521484, -0.015579224, -0.00079774857, 0.016998291, -0.0021648407, 0.036132812, 0.03414917, 0.010940552, -0.02168274, 0.017715454, -0.005458832, -0.0041999817, -0.014045715, 0.022521973, -0.056030273, 0.005783081, 0.050811768, -0.004917145, 0.0021209717, 0.037109375, -0.10913086, -0.01134491, 0.018859863, 0.022415161, 0.018249512, 0.021728516, -0.06518555, 0.03137207, -0.019760132, -0.0005464554, 0.037109375, 0.036834717, 0.035125732, 0.0040245056, 0.029632568, -0.0061187744, -0.0015716553, -0.03717041, -0.11022949, 0.021606445, -0.048431396, -0.0014429092, -0.013290405, -0.002407074, -0.06304932, -0.00970459, -0.00035309792, 0.05532837, 0.030334473, 0.0016670227, 0.027694702, -0.009346008, 0.023330688, -0.0345459, -0.015792847, -0.0047836304, -0.0440979, 0.014274597, 0.008430481, 0.045410156, 0.061157227, -0.03967285, -0.052825928, -0.00894165, 0.0045547485, -0.022903442, 0.0064048767, -0.04373169, 0.016693115, -0.007881165, 0.007419586, 0.036621094, -0.05230713, -0.0056991577, -0.03010559, 0.013046265, -0.03137207, -0.009048462, 0.036743164, 0.00026988983, -0.031433105, 0.00028514862, 0.010887146, -0.0068969727, -0.018798828, -0.026504517, 0.0101623535, 0.041168213, -0.081970215, 0.024246216, -0.040496826, 0.005748749, 0.03326416, 0.013832092, 0.007850647, 0.012313843, -0.023803711, 0.011695862, 0.0093307495, 0.0070648193, -0.02381897, -0.004005432, -0.030685425, 0.024917603, -0.04348755, -0.08654785, -0.025634766, 0.0013170242, -0.09100342, -0.026885986, 0.020614624, -0.021377563, 0.010536194, -0.03842163, 0.057891846, -0.037475586, -0.006061554, 0.010345459, -0.006008148, -0.0016212463, 0.0013465881, -0.093566895, -0.00055217743, 0.049560547, 0.002708435, 0.025772095, 0.010025024, -0.0077552795, -0.055267334, -0.02104187, 0.03817749, -0.009880066, -0.0128479, -0.009246826, -0.013008118, 0.022155762, -0.028320312, 0.028259277, -0.019897461, -0.01965332, 0.0010290146, 0.017501831, -0.0023326874, -0.00073862076, 0.0038223267, 0.0635376, -0.023406982, -0.013786316, -0.03668213, -0.008872986, -0.01789856, -0.009674072, 0.02178955, 0.011917114, 0.009651184, 0.01259613, 0.014755249, 0.035705566, -0.021743774, 0.035247803, 0.04837036, -0.013122559, -0.03390503, -0.03591919, 0.013542175, 0.032562256, -0.025817871, 0.021438599, -0.05432129, 0.013053894, 0.009414673, -0.05307007, 0.014755249, 0.031951904, -0.03894043, -0.023483276, -0.04058838, -0.019866943, -0.013496399, 0.0020942688, -0.013328552, 0.030044556, 0.023757935, -0.011444092, 0.007701874, -0.005794525, 0.057647705, 0.006134033, 0.030654907, -0.040100098, -0.019012451, 0.008148193, -0.053100586, -0.019821167, -0.03503418, -0.027359009, 0.022384644, -0.02293396, -0.046295166, 0.00674057, 0.024673462, 0.08654785, 0.029754639, -0.0013580322, -0.072753906, 0.0137786865, -0.022979736, -0.014198303, 0.008964539, -0.0031394958, -0.019515991, -0.010551453, 0.028808594, -0.002122879, -0.040740967, -0.033996582, 0.034942627, 0.0039978027, 0.009399414, 0.021087646, 0.0619812, 0.02760315, -0.00067710876, 0.010192871, 0.009979248, -0.042541504, -0.0052986145, -0.00605011, 0.038391113, -0.067993164, 0.0045700073, 0.04144287, 0.017852783, -0.015670776, -0.0025539398, 0.016433716, 0.019195557, -0.0053977966, 0.030258179, 0.006313324, -0.059020996, -0.009887695, 0.01802063, -0.0149383545, 0.05215454, -0.01121521, 0.04324341, -0.017318726, 0.00037646294, -0.0016040802, -0.0206604, -0.0012655258, -0.04220581, 0.017410278, -0.06201172, -0.027877808, 0.0034809113, 0.03186035, -0.04949951, 0.0027999878, -0.0016765594, -0.024230957, 0.011459351, -0.004016876, -0.05218506, 0.024368286, -0.025131226, -0.010734558, -0.00011372566, -0.025238037, -0.075927734, -0.004749298, -0.024963379, 0.040496826, 0.0048942566, 0.053131104, -0.066345215, 0.036499023, -0.018478394, -0.028167725, 0.017929077, -0.06933594, 0.0141067505, 0.06317139, -0.00036525726, 0.03479004, -0.011024475, 0.056518555, 0.02822876, 0.04486084, 0.007358551, -0.0073013306, 0.025314331, 0.0003478527, -0.041015625, 0.026138306, 0.033081055, -0.0003643036, 0.036468506, 0.010864258, -0.02734375, -0.035827637, 0.023208618, 0.04248047, 0.04916382, -0.012619019, -0.03643799, 0.03378296, 0.0018987656, -0.01940918, 0.021713257, -0.0546875, -0.028518677, -0.026931763, -0.025253296, -0.07336426, 0.026733398, 0.0030956268, -0.06744385, -0.053833008, 0.033721924, 0.005882263, -0.0015230179, -0.0104904175, -0.006580353, -0.05682373, 0.015090942, 0.04208374, -0.01802063, 0.02861023, 0.0048599243, 0.0044555664, 0.052001953, 0.027908325, 0.0066184998, -0.0073928833, 0.0046081543, -0.02003479, -0.030838013, -0.03173828, -0.032318115, 0.02935791, -0.018600464, -0.0073280334, -0.03894043, -0.037750244, 0.0051879883, -0.0116119385, -0.03201294, 0.032104492, -0.0079574585, -0.010650635, -0.0014123917, 0.03390503, -0.025802612, 0.0033111572, 0.01777649, -0.013221741, 0.013183594, 0.0007972717, 0.0071792603, -0.020553589, -0.06750488, 0.00080156326, 0.011634827, -0.011795044, 0.017944336, 0.027374268, 0.024765015, 0.064819336, 0.0038833618, 0.009429932, 0.042541504, -0.033325195, -0.026870728, 0.027069092, 0.021575928, 0.032043457, 0.07611084, -0.014625549, -0.018341064, -0.03237915, -0.059417725, -0.022918701, 0.0074806213, 0.008506775, 0.0020751953, 0.005458832, -0.04437256, 0.029296875, -0.030471802, -0.0066070557, -0.05505371, 0.020202637, -0.002565384, -0.02835083, 0.0289917, -0.014770508, -0.0013208389, -0.016357422, -0.0051078796, 0.01235199, 0.0129776, 0.016464233, -0.037200928, 0.0039749146, -0.028656006, -0.022140503, -0.007762909, 0.031463623, -0.045410156, 0.023498535, -0.030807495, 0.07293701, -0.008377075, 0.0074806213, 0.028747559, 0.012397766, -0.034698486, -0.0014877319, -0.010665894, -0.034484863, 0.04159546, -0.03970337, -0.019454956, -0.063964844, -0.022033691, -0.08892822, 0.015541077, 0.0051574707, 0.021774292, 0.057403564, -0.0014076233, 0.03845215, -0.018814087, 0.030670166, 0.008331299, 0.034118652, -0.010040283, 0.024993896, -0.053375244, -0.056274414, 0.058441162, 0.05923462, -0.017333984, -0.0005464554, 0.025497437, -0.0440979, -0.018203735, 0.044525146, 0.030548096, 0.0015144348, -0.0126953125, -0.007659912, 0.022644043, 0.017288208, 0.015266418, 0.039398193, 0.056396484, -0.012374878, 0.0025138855, 0.02520752, -0.030380249, -0.00039052963, -0.00894165, 0.009773254, -0.048339844, 0.043121338, -0.0066833496, -0.013916016, -0.035980225, -0.0043907166, 0.03869629, -0.05935669, -0.021392822, 0.018722534, 0.033416748, -0.010353088, -0.016601562, -0.03149414, -0.0031776428, 0.025787354, 0.021774292, -0.00014698505, -0.004760742, -0.0035190582, 0.019088745, 0.0064888, -0.0009589195, 0.0070762634, 0.021209717, -0.00982666, 0.020126343, -0.010665894, 0.021102905, -0.021514893, -0.038116455, 0.0029449463, -0.003856659, -0.027877808, -0.019744873, 0.047668457, 0.026306152, 0.047698975, 0.044952393, 0.0015087128, -0.0018224716, 0.025939941, -0.048431396, 0.041290283, 0.05105591, -0.02041626, 0.039611816, -0.015777588, -0.038848877, 0.060760498, -0.030776978, 0.0579834, -0.052825928, -0.008575439, -0.03692627, 0.034454346, 0.013793945, -0.061462402, -0.025405884, -0.030075073, -0.017288208, -0.019714355, -0.036590576, -0.026275635, -0.055358887, -0.008102417, 0.077819824, -0.006793976, 0.0047454834, 0.03366089, -0.013137817, -0.06628418, 0.0053100586, -0.031204224, 0.047576904, -0.03781128, 0.005039215, 0.0154953, -0.008491516, 0.001209259, -0.025375366, -0.022888184, -0.03253174, -0.027542114, -0.049102783, 0.005355835, -0.007347107, -0.032043457, -0.0084991455, -0.028900146, 0.015991211, -0.024047852, 0.018753052, 0.006965637, -0.046936035, -0.0036888123, 0.0002272129, -0.008422852, 0.035736084, 0.028030396, -0.014717102, 0.03475952, 0.0014457703, 0.0033340454, 0.026626587, 0.048980713, 0.05758667, -0.01638794, -0.06665039, 0.025680542, 0.02861023, 0.048431396, -0.0015668869, -0.05545044, 0.052703857, -0.011352539, 0.012519836, 0.029205322, 0.006526947, -0.002828598, 0.022903442, 0.006996155, 0.0030326843, -0.035247803, -0.01651001, -0.028823853, 0.03451538, 0.034240723, -0.012763977, 0.0007157326, 0.051574707, -0.011680603, -0.007980347, 0.025558472, -0.015571594, -0.03010559, 0.0074272156, -0.0063056946, -0.02911377, -0.066833496, -0.022232056, 0.074645996, -0.014640808, 0.0184021, 0.018188477, 0.012557983, 0.042999268, 0.07409668, -0.021118164, -0.04925537, 0.028533936, 0.018997192, 0.011779785, 0.029006958, 0.01763916, -0.01499176, 0.005443573, 0.0026302338, 0.012893677, 0.005054474, -0.030776978, -0.0028858185, -0.0070533752, -0.06323242, -0.012069702, 0.0038833618, -0.0038604736, 0.042175293, -0.035614014, 0.002149582, -0.049438477, -0.024230957, -0.0119018555, 0.016174316, -0.0020561218, -0.038208008, -0.03387451, 0.015617371, 0.040161133, -0.0116119385 ], "summary": [ -0.006565094, -0.019729614, -0.02633667, -0.03213501, -0.026245117, -0.0065689087, -0.07305908, -0.023635864, 0.00793457, 0.039398193, -0.031677246, 0.028884888, 0.014717102, -0.0043144226, 0.016067505, 0.006477356, -0.0036964417, 0.04095459, 0.030349731, -0.023666382, -0.001414299, -0.0107421875, 0.025466919, -0.018081665, 0.024459839, -0.05783081, 0.032592773, 0.012245178, 0.06304932, 0.025466919, 0.02885437, -0.03604126, 0.030303955, 0.0064315796, -0.02960205, 0.004875183, -0.056915283, 0.0043258667, -0.030319214, 0.028167725, 0.030639648, -0.01600647, 0.0769043, -0.02180481, 0.029464722, 0.020019531, 0.01171875, -0.045959473, -0.030761719, 0.009384155, -0.012031555, -0.04019165, -0.0138168335, 0.008041382, -0.0031280518, -0.022216797, -0.02923584, 0.050109863, 0.015022278, 0.05621338, 0.0072288513, 0.027496338, -0.018737793, -0.038330078, -0.016296387, -0.018798828, -0.004611969, -0.01083374, 0.05126953, 0.014266968, 0.014389038, 0.029830933, 0.02809143, -0.06384277, 0.0019283295, 0.046295166, -0.047027588, -0.010192871, 0.047607422, -0.038970947, -0.01878357, -0.029251099, 0.025680542, -0.026885986, -0.018157959, -0.025268555, -0.016143799, 0.007183075, -0.05340576, -0.05267334, -0.038604736, 0.023345947, -0.076049805, -0.055755615, -0.012016296, -0.045959473, -0.01586914, 0.034423828, -0.031463623, -0.0030174255, -0.012535095, -0.009384155, -0.0012340546, -0.04748535, 0.0032691956, 0.009384155, 0.022979736, -0.03363037, -0.0146484375, -0.005794525, -0.0513916, -0.0048561096, -0.019104004, 0.0007305145, -0.061157227, 0.03753662, -0.01777649, -0.039398193, -0.0112838745, 0.010368347, 0.0084991455, 0.055847168, -0.03955078, -0.025741577, 0.02508545, 0.031677246, 0.017105103, -0.014976501, 0.060455322, 0.008056641, -0.006416321, -0.0026073456, -0.030654907, -0.010368347, -0.024673462, -0.010444641, 0.0069770813, 0.0037517548, 0.011207581, -0.024230957, 0.04421997, 0.0016536713, 0.01751709, 0.028244019, -0.008476257, 0.009422302, -0.010627747, 0.018493652, 0.021865845, -0.00983429, -0.0149002075, -0.017288208, 0.049987793, -0.04135132, -0.047180176, -0.062347412, -0.064331055, -0.010971069, 0.033233643, -0.021026611, 0.01499176, -0.025375366, -0.013725281, 0.035583496, -0.018737793, 0.032318115, 0.030761719, -0.006752014, 0.019424438, 0.035614014, -0.018997192, 0.004688263, 0.008049011, -0.015594482, -0.02432251, -0.010169983, 0.033691406, 0.029586792, 0.0014514923, -0.03277588, 0.00349617, -0.024017334, 0.046936035, 0.0016126633, -0.0579834, -0.021560669, 0.024215698, 0.050476074, 0.01725769, 0.00299263, 0.064331055, -0.019500732, -0.02407837, -0.02458191, -0.024917603, 0.01737976, 0.006702423, 0.036376953, -0.017089844, -0.0051727295, 0.023971558, 0.012649536, 0.0023708344, -0.0107803345, -0.03945923, -0.008483887, -0.010314941, 0.021621704, -0.008979797, 0.035247803, 0.026855469, -0.018875122, -0.043121338, 0.09197998, 0.015556335, -0.061340332, -0.002603531, -0.0104599, 0.012794495, 0.009208679, 0.017562866, 0.022735596, -0.02609253, 0.013832092, -0.021194458, -0.008583069, -0.023956299, 0.004890442, -0.005138397, -0.0034656525, 0.030838013, 0.021636963, 0.0042762756, -0.025909424, -0.026046753, -0.007987976, 0.011314392, -0.07720947, 0.005844116, 0.06112671, 0.01525116, 0.045928955, -0.04586792, -0.035491943, 0.043121338, 0.017150879, 0.0126953125, -0.01725769, 0.016738892, 0.027267456, 0.013343811, -0.005760193, 0.019348145, -0.0030269623, 0.0030498505, 0.03604126, -0.028839111, -0.010940552, -0.01612854, 0.010856628, 0.00018811226, -0.036346436, -0.011375427, -0.017669678, -0.017944336, -0.006980896, 0.0035762787, -0.014884949, -0.023956299, 0.00038409233, 0.03640747, 0.020904541, 0.0061149597, -0.011680603, 0.026504517, 0.035736084, -0.03665161, -0.0065193176, 0.06951904, 0.0067977905, -0.009902954, 0.06072998, -0.023757935, -0.043548584, 0.011199951, 0.0020561218, -0.049438477, -0.090148926, -0.014793396, 0.0418396, 0.04171753, 0.045166016, -0.0035820007, 0.0049324036, -0.00097465515, 0.019226074, 0.08013916, 0.04006958, 0.0034275055, 0.0121536255, 0.0039787292, 0.026992798, -0.022949219, -0.00548172, 0.002735138, 0.015274048, -0.005542755, 0.01020813, 0.0016202927, -0.00039243698, -0.036468506, -0.0063819885, 0.013336182, 0.060272217, -0.07196045, -0.07159424, -0.0181427, 0.015396118, -0.07672119, -0.058441162, 0.04949951, 0.031036377, 0.033355713, 0.047698975, 0.023162842, -0.062164307, 0.05999756, 0.0007843971, 0.04421997, 0.008163452, -0.00090789795, 0.033233643, -0.018875122, -0.032104492, 0.0014324188, -0.01876831, 0.005947113, -0.05883789, -0.014381409, 0.021850586, 0.04360962, 0.0496521, 0.027359009, -0.031158447, -0.019424438, -0.04272461, 0.031799316, 0.00040245056, -0.060913086, -0.008682251, 0.042907715, -0.028930664, -0.0057907104, 0.020248413, 0.029907227, -0.03366089, -0.019638062, 0.03338623, 0.011581421, -0.020401001, 0.033447266, 0.022384644, 0.015960693, -0.004825592, -0.0390625, -0.023910522, 0.029693604, 0.008911133, 0.029129028, 0.03643799, -0.025115967, -0.006252289, 0.0034370422, 0.01474762, 0.031433105, 0.0112838745, 0.055145264, -0.010261536, 0.018844604, 0.037872314, 0.024093628, 0.042236328, 0.007888794, 0.0317688, 0.015686035, 0.025726318, 0.010314941, 0.035308838, 0.0055160522, -0.026916504, -0.004447937, 0.047210693, -0.040618896, -0.004257202, 0.035308838, -0.0062713623, 0.0181427, 0.042510986, -0.065979004, -0.0345459, 0.03540039, 0.04067993, 0.054382324, 0.00548172, -0.02911377, 0.036834717, -0.0022888184, 0.021606445, 0.030685425, 0.00274086, 0.064331055, -0.04534912, 0.051727295, -0.033721924, -0.008392334, -0.033050537, -0.051574707, 0.014877319, -0.03857422, 0.006576538, -0.025726318, 0.06021118, -0.035369873, -0.0008969307, -0.022476196, 0.041046143, -0.0043640137, 0.030441284, 0.013137817, 0.008132935, -0.0015134811, -0.022079468, -0.02470398, 0.0132369995, -0.014839172, 0.05429077, 0.013755798, -0.0022602081, 0.046539307, -0.045898438, -0.03189087, -0.018188477, 0.00078201294, -0.031585693, -0.009895325, -0.01663208, 0.030319214, 0.0014095306, 0.0031795502, 0.03704834, -0.06173706, -0.0017957687, -0.021026611, 0.02545166, -0.033050537, 0.0072402954, 0.0345459, -0.004825592, -0.0025177002, 0.0072517395, -0.017654419, 0.0021743774, -0.0008559227, -0.058685303, 0.0039100647, 0.058532715, -0.11242676, 0.03390503, -0.020370483, -0.022720337, 0.060943604, 0.034118652, 0.015487671, 0.020080566, -0.042999268, 0.010032654, 0.026947021, 0.025177002, -0.030044556, -0.023757935, -0.06695557, 0.038726807, -0.04559326, -0.06137085, -0.03643799, 0.0071640015, -0.05090332, -0.051635742, 0.021850586, 0.031188965, 0.06555176, -0.013320923, 0.07006836, 0.005672455, 0.012306213, -0.0072364807, -0.009307861, 0.02909851, -0.0074539185, -0.067993164, 0.010009766, -0.017807007, 0.0039253235, 0.03353882, -0.04458618, 0.043426514, -0.019683838, -0.0043182373, 0.038482666, -0.038604736, -0.04373169, -0.054992676, 0.025756836, 0.012077332, -0.02734375, 0.036621094, -0.032562256, -0.0082473755, -0.0018424988, 0.012298584, 0.004299164, 0.012329102, 0.022567749, 0.025375366, -0.04284668, -0.0055885315, 0.0006365776, -0.0024089813, 0.002904892, -0.01928711, 0.015167236, 0.03768921, -0.0013160706, 0.032226562, -0.002374649, -0.02357483, -0.032440186, 0.0052375793, 0.03152466, 0.02571106, -0.05355835, -0.06732178, 0.0030708313, 0.05569458, -0.028335571, -0.007858276, -0.057525635, -0.00919342, 0.0152282715, -0.058563232, 0.020599365, 0.020935059, -0.014015198, -0.042816162, -0.008972168, 0.029190063, 0.030944824, -0.021835327, -0.015434265, 0.014465332, 0.0071105957, -0.0046806335, 0.02798462, -0.027191162, 0.040100098, 0.020828247, 0.021774292, -0.041381836, -0.008422852, -0.019042969, -0.05987549, -0.01449585, -0.06173706, -0.057861328, -0.015403748, 0.0029907227, -0.046539307, 0.006134033, 0.014778137, 0.097595215, 0.020263672, 0.025177002, -0.076293945, -0.0042533875, -0.033569336, 0.026611328, -0.0037574768, -0.006942749, -0.0256958, 0.010070801, 0.025924683, 0.005680084, -0.028625488, -0.03894043, 0.017837524, 0.0053901672, 0.007507324, 0.0064735413, 0.04421997, 0.008666992, 0.0004954338, 0.026550293, 0.0050811768, -0.019454956, -0.025360107, 0.017852783, 0.02355957, -0.034332275, 0.01449585, 0.019317627, -0.022705078, -0.017745972, -0.015296936, 0.024749756, -0.008155823, -0.031051636, 0.028762817, 0.011711121, -0.029449463, 0.0045318604, 0.01953125, -0.017608643, 0.028747559, 0.0020046234, 0.010368347, 0.03378296, -0.001285553, -0.039794922, -0.037506104, -0.006668091, -0.06976318, -0.00415802, -0.05230713, -0.031402588, 0.0049057007, 0.042053223, -0.030227661, -0.0021591187, -0.011810303, -0.05053711, 0.0047302246, -0.05230713, -0.09552002, 0.029846191, -0.019897461, -0.01210022, -0.0029296875, -0.008842468, -0.045715332, -0.0074310303, -0.043914795, 0.043640137, 0.045013428, 0.06088257, -0.022384644, 0.06945801, -0.017700195, -0.004447937, -0.0013694763, -0.0423584, -0.0284729, 0.0256958, -0.021209717, 0.003376007, 0.011962891, 0.028900146, 0.0039749146, 0.03744507, -0.009788513, -0.02281189, 0.0043640137, 0.0025501251, -0.05407715, 0.016357422, 0.020019531, 0.022201538, 0.020385742, 0.02053833, -0.031463623, -0.012756348, 0.00554657, 0.053375244, 0.041015625, -0.004890442, -0.03237915, 0.06530762, 0.00932312, -0.024124146, 0.01285553, -0.020904541, -0.006793976, -0.020401001, 0.0024089813, -0.045318604, -0.01008606, 0.00818634, -0.027435303, -0.068603516, 0.017547607, 0.01159668, 0.015037537, -0.027359009, -0.0022773743, -0.05709839, -0.015365601, 0.0079193115, 0.013168335, 0.020492554, -0.0021018982, 0.0070610046, 0.0035686493, 0.021530151, -0.0032978058, 0.0050354004, -0.019332886, -0.018844604, -0.058624268, -0.061645508, -0.049041748, 0.06451416, -0.035369873, 0.01033783, -0.012298584, -0.08831787, -0.028305054, -0.01398468, -0.017974854, 0.0023670197, -0.018615723, -0.038085938, -0.0061912537, 0.02809143, -0.041900635, -0.00762558, 0.023513794, -0.009208679, 0.01838684, -0.000027000904, -0.011024475, 0.0007405281, -0.050445557, 0.010520935, 0.01626587, -0.009315491, 0.02758789, 0.024108887, 0.019424438, 0.053649902, 0.010437012, 0.02230835, 0.02243042, -0.023147583, -0.0032043457, 0.07141113, 0.035339355, 0.06591797, 0.058746338, -0.0069503784, -0.011962891, -0.029785156, -0.057159424, 0.007972717, 0.0043029785, 0.0061187744, 0.030288696, 0.012229919, -0.012428284, 0.04043579, -0.01436615, -0.02708435, -0.044677734, 0.014297485, -0.022476196, -0.03894043, 0.06964111, -0.035736084, -0.007358551, -0.014755249, -0.005836487, 0.0023403168, 0.020233154, 0.0211792, 0.016204834, 0.014213562, -0.027954102, 0.0045204163, -0.019851685, 0.046661377, -0.057434082, 0.009353638, -0.038879395, 0.07366943, 0.015411377, -0.039794922, 0.0012397766, 0.0050964355, -0.02885437, -0.00008183718, -0.007598877, -0.013336182, 0.051879883, -0.006664276, -0.02772522, -0.049316406, -0.042816162, -0.043884277, 0.029312134, -0.011070251, -0.009750366, 0.06524658, -0.004043579, -0.005657196, -0.0050735474, -0.020706177, 0.054351807, -0.008453369, -0.009712219, 0.01486969, -0.04724121, -0.0769043, 0.039978027, 0.059631348, -0.0132369995, 0.010276794, 0.06210327, -0.022338867, -0.004589081, 0.016189575, 0.0058631897, -0.032165527, 0.02116394, -0.0023384094, 0.007320404, 0.0023002625, 0.0038585663, 0.039367676, 0.039245605, 0.0046463013, 0.00932312, 0.033355713, -0.037475586, 0.0065574646, -0.021408081, -0.028121948, -0.01953125, 0.029067993, 0.018997192, 0.007217407, -0.023513794, -0.034729004, 0.0446167, -0.054626465, -0.036346436, 0.016311646, 0.030593872, -0.013031006, -0.009185791, -0.023529053, -0.013137817, 0.007335663, 0.014160156, 0.006729126, 0.008102417, -0.035827637, 0.0025024414, 0.030960083, 0.019897461, 0.019104004, 0.03378296, 0.017532349, 0.016571045, -0.003578186, 0.035583496, -0.015487671, -0.023239136, 0.004776001, 0.011260986, -0.020462036, -0.008399963, 0.05303955, 0.038726807, 0.07348633, 0.048919678, -0.029830933, 0.021011353, 0.06781006, -0.029312134, 0.049621582, 0.008613586, 0.013252258, 0.020614624, -0.012870789, -0.008453369, 0.040252686, -0.01247406, 0.05819702, -0.05419922, -0.01701355, -0.0463562, 0.040863037, -0.036590576, -0.022262573, -0.030899048, -0.05441284, 0.009170532, -0.01802063, -0.033447266, -0.047790527, -0.027618408, -0.023269653, 0.05203247, 0.010925293, 0.009422302, 0.03793335, -0.018478394, -0.06762695, 0.014556885, 0.012763977, 0.046966553, 0.01763916, 0.002090454, 0.070129395, -0.015686035, -0.024154663, -0.061828613, -0.015266418, -0.026626587, 0.008895874, -0.075683594, 0.009094238, -0.01083374, -0.029327393, -0.016296387, -0.03363037, 0.010940552, -0.025436401, 0.013679504, 0.012168884, -0.008132935, -0.013320923, -0.00957489, -0.011398315, 0.0030784607, 0.010543823, -0.0019226074, 0.02571106, 0.017410278, -0.00844574, 0.04547119, 0.038604736, 0.0440979, -0.010757446, -0.05807495, 0.0064315796, 0.023910522, 0.05609131, 0.016921997, -0.019973755, 0.056640625, -0.021850586, 0.0045700073, -0.02645874, -0.019424438, -0.024490356, 0.06744385, 0.018707275, 0.016601562, -0.03125, -0.011566162, -0.033111572, 0.041290283, -0.0012512207, -0.025009155, -0.013549805, 0.042236328, 0.004306793, -0.011413574, 0.0042037964, 0.033050537, -0.034729004, 0.0045776367, -0.0010852814, -0.020080566, -0.08850098, -0.0012645721, 0.061920166, -0.02178955, 0.014076233, 0.020812988, -0.011276245, 0.052764893, 0.06744385, -0.003419876, -0.005809784, -0.014282227, -0.012588501, 0.018829346, -0.0037956238, 0.018112183, -0.008743286, 0.009132385, -0.004295349, 0.025558472, -0.016036987, -0.031707764, -0.0028514862, -0.019210815, -0.058776855, 0.026473999, -0.013145447, 0.0041999817, 0.045776367, -0.012802124, -0.02520752, -0.013633728, -0.039916992, 0.01751709, 0.0021095276, -0.0019931793, 0.0005955696, 0.008422852, 0.044281006, -0.008987427, 0.0126571655 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07264v1
Danish Foundation Models
Kenneth Enevoldsen, Lasse Hansen, Dan S. Nielsen, Rasmus A. F. Egebæk, Søren V. Holm, Martin C. Nielsen, Martin Bernstorff, Rasmus Larsen, Peter B. Jørgensen, Malte Højmark-Bertelsen, Peter B. Vahlstrup, Per Møldrup-Dalum, Kristoffer Nielbo
cs.CL
Large language models, sometimes referred to as foundation models, have transformed multiple fields of research. However, smaller languages risk falling behind due to high training costs and small incentives for large companies to train these models. To combat this, the Danish Foundation Models project seeks to provide and maintain open, well-documented, and high-quality foundation models for the Danish language. This is achieved through broad cooperation with public and private institutions, to ensure high data quality and applicability of the trained models. We present the motivation of the project, the current status, and future perspectives.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07264v1
2023-11-13T12:03:52
2023-11-13T12:03:52
{ "title": [ -0.022247314, 0.0036201477, -0.052368164, -0.011680603, -0.048461914, -0.018997192, -0.061645508, -0.0050964355, 0.01247406, 0.045074463, 0.016723633, -0.034820557, 0.019546509, -0.032104492, 0.014549255, 0.0058937073, 0.026763916, -0.0031032562, 0.002008438, 0.00080919266, 0.017349243, 0.03527832, -0.055023193, 0.0039482117, -0.0039253235, 0.01133728, -0.012557983, -0.024520874, 0.028167725, -0.018493652, -0.013397217, -0.0042266846, 0.02079773, -0.02848816, 0.034210205, 0.009216309, 0.0059432983, -0.004673004, 0.009643555, -0.034088135, -0.0017881393, 0.00630188, 0.04916382, 0.05670166, -0.0031433105, -0.048217773, 0.04953003, -0.038269043, 0.00065135956, 0.02859497, -0.04046631, -0.025604248, -0.034973145, 0.06512451, -0.013633728, -0.014976501, -0.05105591, 0.02420044, 0.0137786865, -0.0039253235, -0.028182983, 0.012893677, 0.03225708, -0.0028839111, 0.008171082, -0.03010559, -0.05239868, 0.015213013, 0.08001709, 0.03930664, -0.0119018555, 0.0070343018, -0.0014858246, -0.029022217, 0.002576828, 0.024108887, 0.03817749, 0.03543091, -0.054504395, -0.006629944, -0.030181885, -0.006942749, -0.031402588, 0.00466156, -0.016448975, 0.014541626, -0.0015201569, -0.0069122314, -0.03289795, -0.016601562, -0.02130127, -0.020065308, -0.06112671, 0.08190918, 0.01360321, 0.008468628, -0.028198242, -0.012039185, -0.011909485, -0.036376953, -0.015617371, -0.0064353943, -0.04473877, -0.01158905, -0.021957397, 0.014221191, 0.03930664, 0.00041222572, 0.001704216, 0.016174316, -0.006515503, 0.067993164, -0.012283325, 0.0335083, 0.017074585, -0.015975952, -0.053131104, 0.0013923645, -0.06762695, -0.02027893, 0.03152466, 0.028518677, 0.034210205, -0.005050659, 0.006916046, 0.039489746, -0.035339355, -0.06274414, 0.0076293945, -0.03942871, -0.064453125, 0.030426025, 0.022903442, 0.012023926, 0.042022705, -0.020858765, -0.06341553, -0.027618408, -0.024658203, -0.02986145, 0.033203125, -0.022567749, 0.00006484985, 0.01651001, -0.025238037, 0.027542114, 0.03186035, -0.0069084167, -0.03225708, -0.038024902, -0.027374268, 0.016860962, -0.03479004, 0.060516357, 0.0053634644, 0.03753662, 0.039276123, -0.02809143, -0.008125305, 0.023162842, 0.010032654, -0.022018433, -0.009483337, 0.005153656, -0.024932861, 0.06427002, 0.01096344, 0.0022449493, -0.007381439, 0.07885742, -0.021530151, -0.0061187744, -0.03186035, -0.008613586, -0.008026123, -0.014976501, -0.008659363, -0.0259552, 0.04852295, -0.030883789, -0.03338623, -0.029876709, -0.042785645, -0.006526947, -0.022369385, -0.06713867, 0.0008368492, -0.006248474, 0.024658203, 0.022994995, -0.02947998, 0.016235352, -0.012519836, 0.016036987, -0.039489746, -0.020996094, 0.01789856, 0.021469116, -0.013397217, 0.011665344, 0.028289795, 0.06402588, -0.014007568, -0.00687027, 0.030899048, -0.0050964355, 0.039520264, -0.0060195923, 0.04257202, 0.031829834, 0.002746582, 0.023651123, 0.00749588, -0.06829834, -0.054016113, -0.03829956, -0.04937744, -0.030822754, -0.027801514, 0.014717102, 0.0029029846, 0.022628784, -0.005168915, 0.01322937, 0.0048980713, 0.052001953, -0.002418518, 0.009376526, 0.010169983, 0.045715332, -0.015052795, -0.043395996, -0.0044555664, -0.022964478, -0.05987549, -0.013786316, 0.00013661385, -0.0037784576, 0.016326904, 0.048675537, 0.023025513, 0.029968262, 0.018341064, 0.030197144, 0.087646484, 0.08166504, 0.058624268, -0.015541077, 0.012123108, 0.009635925, 0.013153076, -0.021408081, 0.044281006, 0.021484375, 0.011581421, 0.052978516, 0.0102005005, -0.045715332, 0.03060913, 0.005607605, 0.028778076, 0.030944824, -0.041290283, 0.0005378723, 0.00075387955, -0.04244995, 0.004058838, 0.025512695, -0.008766174, -0.03274536, 0.014266968, 0.018157959, 0.0031986237, -0.005859375, 0.03010559, -0.0034923553, -0.004196167, -0.010269165, 0.0020885468, -0.001739502, 0.0005455017, 0.033966064, 0.06774902, 0.013305664, -0.015625, 0.045684814, 0.048187256, 0.009849548, -0.04550171, -0.03729248, 0.032196045, 0.018218994, -0.014053345, 0.007858276, -0.0072288513, 0.017059326, -0.028274536, -0.008590698, 0.01637268, -0.033111572, -0.053009033, 0.037994385, -0.025405884, 0.028884888, -0.0079193115, 0.04031372, 0.008544922, -0.018920898, -0.022369385, -0.011787415, 0.0017347336, 0.01525116, 0.040985107, 0.05154419, 0.030853271, -0.022247314, 0.015380859, 0.041992188, -0.0007867813, -0.00381279, -0.020858765, 0.023483276, -0.00920105, -0.041046143, 0.039855957, -0.0071487427, -0.06762695, -0.004711151, -0.01322937, 0.016525269, 0.008666992, -0.020950317, -0.03652954, -0.050201416, 0.0071792603, -0.00844574, 0.008201599, 0.033966064, -0.007686615, -0.0021800995, -0.016998291, -0.016677856, -0.009094238, -0.043640137, 0.0028800964, -0.059906006, -0.012435913, -0.01260376, -0.005092621, 0.000998497, 0.052886963, -0.0030879974, 0.00090551376, 0.013572693, 0.035980225, 0.0087890625, -0.018615723, 0.0061950684, 0.0074157715, -0.049468994, 0.021636963, 0.009681702, 0.012809753, 0.009590149, 0.0026226044, -0.08074951, -0.0065231323, 0.011009216, 0.016616821, 0.0023460388, -0.048736572, 0.0011091232, 0.015853882, 0.021743774, -0.003921509, 0.004425049, -0.005050659, -0.021316528, -0.036102295, -0.018676758, 0.055541992, 0.03363037, 0.025787354, 0.019378662, 0.040008545, 0.005420685, 0.025970459, 0.046783447, 0.05419922, 0.008476257, 0.013069153, 0.0035533905, -0.013519287, -0.026397705, 0.029281616, -0.006023407, 0.01889038, 0.03579712, -0.07183838, -0.000562191, 0.0016117096, -0.017196655, -0.039031982, -0.012207031, -0.010414124, -0.051818848, 0.010681152, -0.036621094, 0.015930176, -0.0017356873, -0.023452759, 0.0418396, 0.013442993, -0.004962921, -0.032928467, -0.014152527, -0.025817871, 0.016159058, -0.00019669533, 0.017425537, 0.03463745, -0.043304443, -0.010643005, 0.0073661804, -0.0037250519, -0.032409668, 0.01953125, -0.0046195984, 0.01525116, -0.0061683655, -0.0062789917, -0.009315491, -0.029388428, 0.005393982, 0.023345947, 0.082092285, -0.00642395, 0.051208496, -0.0010576248, 0.00687027, 0.025650024, 0.011787415, -0.042114258, 0.009147644, -0.050720215, -0.00762558, 0.024017334, -0.015899658, -0.043151855, -0.0033874512, -0.034423828, -0.0037822723, -0.037628174, 0.02494812, -0.012901306, 0.042297363, -0.004058838, 0.03366089, -0.016830444, 0.029159546, 0.05606079, -0.021835327, 0.000116705894, 0.02810669, -0.026138306, 0.0025520325, 0.072143555, 0.010955811, -0.019577026, -0.0019626617, 0.013336182, -0.023529053, 0.014381409, 0.031982422, -0.044921875, 0.023345947, -0.014884949, -0.010185242, -0.003326416, 0.036315918, 0.028945923, -0.036621094, 0.023742676, 0.016326904, 0.06210327, 0.0040779114, -0.008544922, 0.0925293, 0.015258789, -0.063964844, -0.058563232, -0.03842163, -0.017486572, -0.026672363, -0.030319214, -0.01927185, -0.014480591, -0.01727295, -0.037994385, -0.06677246, -0.028030396, -0.016921997, -0.003627777, 0.03378296, -0.022460938, -0.032989502, 0.014678955, 0.025360107, 0.040618896, -0.0009651184, 0.012062073, 0.0022888184, -0.010398865, 0.02041626, -0.042419434, -0.006816864, -0.0034999847, 0.01360321, -0.035614014, 0.011138916, 0.042419434, 0.011886597, 0.04220581, 0.008468628, 0.028808594, 0.01235199, -0.0059394836, 0.011375427, -0.041748047, -0.074401855, -0.013549805, 0.003250122, 0.008712769, 0.02508545, 0.035217285, 0.072387695, 0.010528564, -0.016998291, 0.013168335, 0.0061836243, 0.028686523, -0.023376465, -0.06921387, -0.0209198, -0.02355957, -0.00415802, -0.028503418, 0.04852295, 0.079833984, -0.018661499, 0.06768799, 0.039764404, 0.046203613, 0.002735138, -0.051727295, -0.035003662, -0.033599854, 0.0040130615, -0.01600647, 0.0013895035, -0.016723633, 0.034606934, -0.024978638, 0.01979065, -0.029678345, 0.008331299, -0.0001565218, 0.0024757385, 0.07147217, -0.054870605, -0.056793213, -0.049468994, 0.018951416, 0.055999756, 0.009689331, 0.033721924, -0.022476196, 0.003862381, 0.0093688965, -0.043792725, 0.01235199, 0.03024292, 0.035064697, 0.0073051453, 0.030960083, -0.00869751, -0.047851562, -0.011482239, -0.026901245, 0.0024147034, -0.009056091, 0.0063552856, 0.01675415, -0.050231934, -0.0340271, -0.021530151, 0.0020217896, -0.01512146, -0.029632568, -0.014160156, 0.035095215, -0.0116119385, 0.012634277, -0.037322998, 0.0055885315, -0.053894043, 0.05505371, -0.05105591, -0.0034389496, 0.012374878, -0.0013637543, 0.025100708, -0.030044556, -0.0020542145, -0.010185242, -0.004146576, 0.042236328, -0.005935669, -0.051208496, -0.0012779236, 0.016281128, -0.028244019, 0.029281616, -0.05508423, -0.047454834, -0.058135986, 0.09100342, 0.023376465, 0.017227173, 0.033294678, 0.014877319, 0.007698059, -0.03845215, -0.046905518, 0.013298035, 0.0657959, -0.046417236, -0.0074691772, -0.0064353943, 0.036712646, -0.01184845, 0.016174316, -0.027069092, 0.001080513, 0.009109497, -0.026947021, -0.011802673, 0.003528595, -0.029968262, -0.0046043396, -0.014915466, 0.01727295, 0.051971436, -0.014030457, 0.0039138794, 0.011703491, -0.06021118, 0.022232056, 0.002811432, -0.031799316, -0.030944824, 0.05368042, -0.011260986, 0.01576233, 0.025131226, -0.058624268, 0.055786133, 0.031311035, -0.036102295, 0.022827148, -0.004333496, 0.024658203, -0.026916504, -0.012718201, 0.0055732727, -0.011833191, 0.0077438354, 0.015640259, 0.017822266, -0.024398804, -0.015975952, -0.023742676, 0.027008057, -0.046844482, -0.0011034012, 0.021652222, -0.017456055, 0.007434845, -0.0071372986, -0.0013942719, -0.04119873, 0.030410767, -0.014724731, -0.006843567, -0.004962921, -0.0019302368, 0.0066719055, -0.029418945, 0.07446289, -0.03842163, 0.00969696, -0.010498047, 0.0103302, -0.0035381317, 0.031158447, 0.023773193, -0.03753662, -0.010871887, 0.012680054, 0.020111084, 0.0074424744, -0.010429382, 0.020736694, 0.019424438, 0.016036987, -0.022827148, 0.006286621, 0.04425049, 0.0036945343, -0.016799927, -0.056243896, -0.024291992, -0.04043579, -0.05142212, -0.0141067505, 0.032287598, -0.06262207, -0.0013418198, -0.013549805, -0.0019798279, -0.0001026392, 0.042388916, 0.0042686462, -0.022064209, 0.02053833, -0.10119629, 0.02658081, -0.02319336, -0.0067329407, 0.015304565, 0.0041770935, 0.010246277, 0.023162842, 0.04220581, 0.008087158, 0.08709717, 0.018066406, 0.044128418, 0.011131287, 0.031082153, 0.0014095306, 0.024398804, -0.005218506, 0.0006432533, 0.0009508133, -0.024749756, -0.021331787, 0.017288208, 0.021316528, 0.003967285, -0.014854431, -0.032470703, -0.032989502, 0.04638672, -0.074523926, -0.010261536, -0.0021343231, -0.03161621, 0.00079250336, 0.0012283325, 0.0017213821, 0.039154053, -0.043518066, -0.08886719, 0.0104904175, 0.010017395, -0.023483276, 0.00035381317, 0.019546509, 0.045013428, 0.030822754, 0.032928467, 0.028182983, -0.047454834, -0.009124756, 0.018127441, 0.010665894, 0.04019165, -0.034606934, -0.014328003, -0.024810791, 0.048583984, -0.019104004, -0.0077934265, 0.021820068, 0.009246826, 0.004295349, -0.00054073334, 0.008384705, 0.0007958412, -0.015022278, -0.051971436, 0.020004272, 0.0256958, 0.030334473, -0.07928467, -0.012649536, 0.08215332, 0.01436615, -0.015975952, 0.016403198, -0.019088745, -0.015174866, -0.0036144257, -0.005317688, 0.026992798, -0.025848389, -0.02218628, 0.029281616, 0.020935059, 0.002620697, 0.034423828, 0.011886597, -0.0061683655, 0.03074646, -0.011566162, 0.035949707, -0.045166016, 0.030929565, -0.014205933, -0.0043182373, -0.0026931763, -0.0022792816, 0.006175995, 0.0022201538, 0.03918457, -0.0140686035, 0.020935059, -0.0047302246, 0.011474609, 0.06378174, -0.066833496, 0.041107178, 0.041381836, -0.029449463, -0.00036215782, -0.020645142, -0.0016794205, 0.0440979, 0.015609741, 0.033325195, 0.00705719, -0.0071754456, -0.03237915, 0.020477295, 0.037597656, 0.02658081, -0.047851562, -0.049591064, -0.00018501282, 0.00080156326, -0.036712646, -0.042541504, -0.007144928, 0.04055786, 0.0032691956, -0.027297974, -0.018463135, -0.032440186, -0.0009832382, 0.017684937, 0.019744873, 0.0579834, 0.0009446144, -0.016540527, 0.047698975, -0.006187439, -0.024490356, 0.045043945, -0.056610107, 0.06719971, 0.025741577, 0.031585693, 0.008262634, -0.015380859, 0.012527466, -0.0036449432, 0.025344849, -0.023513794, -0.04257202, 0.005420685, -0.013648987, 0.0000603199, 0.009025574, -0.10656738, -0.07598877, -0.0010871887, 0.0340271, -0.035949707, -0.04925537, -0.004573822, -0.049316406, 0.061798096, -0.07086182, -0.019485474, 0.015289307, -0.026519775, -0.017974854, -0.022994995, -0.021896362, 0.033599854, 0.045135498, 0.043151855, 0.059631348, -0.037963867, -0.026473999, 0.10168457, 0.049621582, 0.116882324, 0.025939941, -0.026046753, 0.007205963, -0.04031372, -0.0020542145, -0.009719849, -0.0007715225, -0.082458496, -0.01687622, -0.028335571, -0.0079422, -0.022232056, -0.04437256, -0.049682617, 0.03717041, -0.011245728, -0.03555298, 0.021697998, -0.0010137558, -0.00041937828, -0.0357666, 0.00066137314, -0.010223389, -0.015014648, -0.0069274902, -0.055419922, 0.031158447, 0.0010938644, -0.068481445, -0.046081543, -0.040771484, 0.004825592, -0.01474762, 0.03643799, -0.027938843, 0.041625977, 0.07287598, -0.013931274, -0.04196167, 0.003271103, -0.010002136, -0.028305054, -0.00724411, 0.07055664, -0.00016868114, -0.06719971, -0.034606934, -0.054351807, 0.02911377, 0.0368042, 0.039215088, -0.028442383, 0.0124053955, -0.009963989, 0.0045166016, 0.0017719269, -0.0002194643, 0.013397217, 0.019760132, -0.04550171, 0.034088135, 0.002691269, 0.05984497, -0.011161804, 0.066589355, -0.014640808, 0.009750366, -0.01121521, -0.002960205, -0.0043258667, -0.0029449463, -0.021911621, 0.045074463, -0.0030174255, 0.0074501038, 0.023269653, 0.03265381, 0.019317627, 0.025436401, 0.013252258, -0.015045166, 0.010383606, 0.038269043, 0.01612854, 0.02218628, -0.017578125, 0.02128601, -0.00033426285, 0.038391113, 0.008033752, 0.02331543, 0.004432678, 0.039123535, -0.06756592, -0.0035247803, -0.047058105, -0.06359863, 0.0017375946, -0.029281616, -0.025894165, -0.034423828, -0.027877808, -0.0018339157, -0.008674622, 0.0010604858 ], "summary": [ -0.056152344, -0.0104522705, -0.037231445, -0.026412964, -0.04071045, 0.0003926754, -0.072021484, 0.00774765, 0.021331787, 0.020004272, 0.009391785, -0.020645142, 0.033721924, -0.06088257, 0.008758545, -0.007789612, -0.007232666, 0.016983032, 0.0013494492, -0.006500244, 0.05105591, -0.004901886, -0.06185913, -0.021987915, 0.019561768, -0.02798462, -0.033691406, 0.017044067, 0.003206253, 0.004173279, 0.0038433075, -0.006755829, 0.02229309, -0.019683838, -0.018920898, -0.049804688, -0.018692017, -0.01727295, -0.016799927, -0.030944824, 0.035339355, -0.021438599, 0.09429932, 0.06555176, 0.029067993, -0.017944336, 0.04260254, -0.06689453, 0.011741638, 0.050872803, -0.028869629, 0.012077332, -0.040618896, 0.012123108, -0.0005121231, -0.017501831, -0.03866577, 0.040130615, 0.004764557, 0.02670288, -0.003129959, 0.016067505, 0.009628296, -0.022949219, -0.016052246, -0.0014591217, -0.047576904, -0.0051994324, 0.065979004, 0.0044441223, -0.010169983, 0.011398315, 0.002670288, -0.036010742, -0.030975342, 0.054992676, -0.012924194, 0.0063476562, 0.023773193, -0.022262573, 0.010070801, 0.028625488, -0.013473511, 0.0037517548, -0.010040283, 0.003479004, -0.019088745, -0.012680054, -0.042144775, -0.014343262, -0.029754639, -0.050109863, -0.077819824, 0.06222534, 0.044647217, -0.0007109642, -0.04058838, -0.030319214, -0.02432251, -0.020736694, 0.0102005005, 0.0057792664, -0.012611389, 0.012893677, -0.016784668, 0.04373169, -0.008934021, -0.006500244, -0.0031795502, 0.017974854, 0.00472641, -0.017501831, -0.0045166016, -0.033172607, -0.0033664703, -0.0061950684, -0.03086853, 0.02130127, 0.015434265, 0.01473999, 0.044067383, 0.04269409, 0.024017334, -0.020263672, 0.024414062, 0.023117065, -0.027938843, -0.0423584, 0.024383545, 0.021377563, -0.016448975, 0.012535095, 0.004009247, 0.019760132, -0.0059394836, -0.015014648, -0.040222168, -0.0115737915, -0.04510498, 0.00969696, 0.03970337, -0.038909912, -0.0016479492, 0.009735107, -0.009506226, 0.0064964294, 0.026473999, 0.0028858185, -0.03479004, -0.018981934, -0.022338867, 0.023162842, 0.026870728, -0.017532349, -0.023468018, -0.034484863, -0.008926392, -0.01373291, -0.013397217, -0.02684021, -0.010261536, -0.0098724365, 0.0033874512, 0.021011353, -0.030288696, 0.041656494, 0.024902344, -0.021087646, 0.00081682205, 0.025253296, -0.012191772, 0.034820557, -0.037200928, 0.014961243, 0.0135650635, -0.011795044, -0.022125244, 0.013832092, 0.0101623535, 0.013954163, -0.0025424957, -0.02986145, 0.0026607513, 0.00088882446, -0.008018494, -0.046691895, -0.004245758, 0.016860962, 0.07104492, 0.02368164, -0.03781128, -0.054656982, -0.016525269, 0.03152466, -0.03265381, -0.023010254, 0.010131836, 0.040649414, -0.033569336, -0.005012512, 0.029281616, 0.040130615, -0.008430481, -0.029724121, 0.0023593903, -0.02911377, 0.025360107, 0.021743774, 0.036712646, 0.030776978, 0.02255249, 0.029678345, -0.05456543, 0.030181885, -0.028656006, -0.026672363, 0.021621704, -0.041381836, -0.004611969, -0.012367249, 0.003929138, 0.03656006, -0.031585693, 0.03100586, -0.032318115, 0.028945923, -0.0073013306, 0.039794922, -0.00793457, 0.05593872, 0.005756378, -0.03918457, 0.030303955, 0.05508423, -0.01625061, -0.00869751, -0.01927185, -0.078125, 0.014228821, 0.041290283, 0.0098724365, -0.0066184998, -0.0129852295, 0.0024967194, 0.023132324, 0.03488159, 0.04095459, -0.025985718, 0.022567749, 0.03918457, -0.002363205, -0.022750854, 0.031204224, -0.051574707, 0.0042152405, 0.039794922, -0.01826477, -0.09301758, 0.032806396, -0.02444458, 0.062316895, -0.04611206, -0.10253906, 0.018981934, -0.018585205, -0.065979004, 0.0015382767, -0.010551453, 0.014595032, -0.05996704, 0.024414062, -0.004837036, -0.00079107285, -0.008392334, 0.0026741028, -0.023376465, -0.003873825, 0.001953125, -0.0005669594, -0.0012969971, -0.010017395, 0.036743164, 0.0074424744, -0.02078247, -0.00944519, 0.026733398, 0.01007843, -0.006046295, -0.023376465, 0.02418518, 0.02760315, 0.019699097, -0.024398804, 0.004623413, 0.015472412, -0.0018892288, 0.05529785, 0.004764557, 0.0071640015, -0.031036377, 0.007446289, 0.029571533, -0.021347046, -0.013290405, 0.018173218, 0.02583313, 0.042907715, -0.035736084, -0.023025513, 0.01146698, -0.01828003, 0.0017957687, 0.04837036, 0.097595215, -0.030227661, -0.034851074, -0.0070762634, 0.049041748, -0.019805908, -0.0031719208, -0.025405884, -0.0003926754, -0.009963989, 0.011138916, 0.02053833, -0.0035820007, 0.007347107, -0.008285522, 0.03567505, 0.0061836243, -0.03237915, -0.018173218, -0.06463623, -0.03817749, -0.010322571, -0.002866745, 0.0035858154, 0.024734497, -0.016784668, 0.013076782, -0.005329132, -0.008277893, 0.0007972717, -0.03878784, -0.031707764, -0.061706543, 0.0118255615, -0.024536133, 0.01902771, 0.00065898895, 0.02017212, 0.032104492, 0.010650635, 0.02684021, 0.019012451, 0.014793396, -0.016723633, -0.017974854, -0.03152466, -0.05883789, 0.038604736, 0.024429321, 0.032806396, -0.015640259, -0.021987915, -0.053741455, -0.012283325, -0.00018978119, 0.009056091, 0.0061035156, -0.040649414, 0.011383057, 0.006542206, -0.011802673, 0.011657715, -0.0010643005, 0.07220459, 0.013931274, -0.03250122, 0.03717041, 0.01979065, 0.03591919, -0.026885986, 0.02293396, 0.07531738, 0.03805542, 0.014045715, 0.013420105, 0.029220581, -0.008415222, 0.00073480606, 0.0042877197, -0.015274048, -0.024963379, 0.019515991, 0.005256653, -0.0131073, 0.03036499, -0.061462402, -0.013206482, 0.063964844, 0.0048217773, 0.008621216, 0.029144287, -0.013931274, 0.030334473, 0.04260254, 0.011436462, 0.03353882, -0.042510986, 0.04232788, 0.010673523, 0.033569336, -0.02798462, -0.026931763, -0.023498535, -0.027435303, 0.01689148, 0.0051612854, -0.029403687, 0.0032234192, -0.049194336, 0.017349243, 0.02279663, 0.007423401, 0.001004219, -0.021865845, -0.023071289, 0.016540527, 0.028076172, -0.013259888, 0.009666443, -0.049621582, 0.011390686, -0.0016269684, 0.12164307, 0.04953003, 0.019241333, 0.045166016, -0.011856079, 0.045043945, -0.008934021, -0.07421875, -0.017211914, -0.041778564, -0.0044517517, 0.0018148422, 0.00970459, 0.009628296, 0.008659363, -0.045928955, 0.008201599, -0.011077881, 0.026535034, -0.026168823, 0.005016327, -0.0010156631, 0.03729248, 0.036102295, 0.019210815, 0.024871826, -0.035858154, 0.04031372, 0.03074646, 0.030410767, 0.0635376, -0.04043579, 0.054229736, -0.006793976, -0.031951904, 0.07757568, -0.06549072, -0.0046806335, 0.020965576, -0.041046143, 0.027191162, 0.0044021606, -0.0032310486, 0.034576416, 0.025756836, -0.012550354, 0.006378174, 0.003353119, -0.03994751, -0.009407043, 0.0121536255, -0.074401855, -0.060455322, 0.01676941, -0.009567261, -0.054351807, -0.0059776306, 0.018798828, -0.0041656494, 0.00061035156, 0.021850586, -0.024139404, 0.047790527, -0.009033203, -0.08355713, 0.027770996, -0.008598328, 0.04949951, 0.048034668, 0.00027179718, -0.0079956055, 0.012214661, 0.01637268, 0.017593384, 0.02041626, 0.02861023, 0.0004117489, -0.049041748, 0.021224976, -0.036590576, -0.004219055, 0.029327393, 0.031311035, -0.02268982, -0.01713562, 0.030929565, 0.037475586, 0.03189087, 0.0051994324, -0.015792847, -0.0014400482, -0.00016129017, 0.006290436, -0.020095825, -0.009651184, 0.02746582, 0.0023975372, -0.021255493, -0.013916016, 0.020767212, 0.0037822723, -0.010826111, -0.013542175, 0.031234741, 0.02923584, 0.0134887695, -0.005580902, -0.014579773, 0.024475098, -0.023773193, 0.005001068, -0.026397705, 0.018692017, 0.01838684, -0.030303955, 0.027389526, 0.031555176, 0.025634766, 0.0032482147, -0.034973145, -0.07086182, -0.019210815, 0.007873535, 0.022644043, 0.02960205, -0.018493652, 0.019515991, 0.03463745, -0.03778076, 0.06347656, 0.049102783, -0.060516357, -0.0625, 0.05911255, -0.03765869, -0.06341553, -0.064453125, -0.049194336, 0.002954483, -0.022094727, 0.041931152, -0.01939392, 0.007648468, 0.010292053, 0.015960693, 0.013809204, 0.028884888, -0.024505615, 0.0025157928, -0.013252258, 0.025344849, -0.03866577, 0.04244995, -0.037719727, -0.006614685, -0.0012044907, -0.0023555756, -0.006427765, -0.04031372, -0.012550354, 0.027069092, -0.015716553, -0.025604248, -0.014282227, 0.0018539429, 0.022064209, -0.012687683, 0.00881958, -0.012031555, 0.010826111, -0.039154053, 0.029083252, -0.046020508, -0.00969696, 0.038604736, -0.0048828125, 0.0045433044, 0.014122009, -0.04562378, 0.029464722, 0.00025963783, 0.064819336, -0.037506104, -0.043670654, -0.004108429, -0.010864258, 0.005279541, 0.020233154, -0.046813965, -0.020904541, -0.0236969, 0.064941406, 0.014289856, -0.014633179, 0.025787354, -0.0016641617, 0.020401001, -0.025375366, -0.053894043, -0.002855301, 0.04574585, -0.010864258, 0.00029492378, -0.0029144287, -0.032592773, 0.015426636, 0.016448975, -0.024124146, -0.034362793, -0.0135269165, -0.02482605, -0.031555176, -0.030090332, -0.012390137, -0.01991272, 0.009742737, 0.020935059, 0.008148193, 0.03781128, 0.0038928986, 0.035125732, -0.032592773, -0.0007367134, 0.019454956, -0.023452759, -0.04043579, 0.039520264, -0.01424408, 0.009979248, 0.05807495, -0.04547119, 0.0031776428, 0.044525146, -0.052093506, 0.05154419, -0.005744934, -0.012130737, -0.040252686, -0.039489746, 0.014770508, -0.0077323914, -0.0010690689, 0.01914978, 0.015449524, -0.043121338, -0.009254456, -0.041107178, 0.021560669, -0.0032997131, -0.008407593, 0.010787964, 0.0076293945, 0.004802704, -0.013664246, 0.01197052, -0.03451538, -0.011886597, -0.0034236908, -0.019821167, -0.023864746, -0.023529053, -0.0069351196, 0.01020813, 0.030471802, -0.061798096, -0.014411926, 0.033935547, -0.029541016, 0.010803223, 0.007858276, 0.007827759, 0.021865845, -0.013870239, 0.024765015, 0.008636475, -0.011199951, 0.014984131, 0.007080078, 0.0035800934, -0.0014305115, -0.039398193, -0.036499023, -0.012863159, -0.04916382, 0.03491211, -0.020904541, 0.010360718, 0.010139465, -0.045013428, 0.009757996, -0.00957489, -0.014389038, 0.0017032623, -0.02720642, -0.048187256, 0.026855469, 0.024215698, -0.036987305, -0.00070524216, 0.027618408, -0.07739258, 0.03540039, -0.029541016, 0.028182983, -0.0104904175, -0.0044136047, 0.012794495, 0.04309082, 0.027053833, 0.01676941, 0.08105469, 0.025283813, 0.054870605, -0.023345947, 0.023345947, -0.026535034, -0.021347046, 0.03189087, 0.0013885498, 0.02406311, -0.030578613, -0.028060913, 0.01158905, 0.039764404, -0.012176514, -0.016799927, -0.015991211, -0.030288696, 0.02734375, -0.00187397, 0.044677734, 0.07232666, 0.024734497, -0.020126343, -0.026916504, -0.012756348, 0.021530151, -0.030548096, -0.076660156, 0.057250977, -0.0035266876, -0.04559326, 0.008125305, 0.0054969788, 0.015838623, 0.021270752, 0.0049362183, 0.063964844, -0.013748169, -0.0040283203, 0.007686615, 0.011627197, 0.010765076, -0.03225708, -0.018356323, 0.00067424774, 0.041168213, 0.00051116943, 0.0007686615, 0.0012407303, -0.006427765, 0.01210022, 0.0071372986, 0.06781006, -0.01084137, 0.017852783, 0.0116119385, -0.0149383545, -0.026519775, -0.020828247, -0.035003662, 0.047058105, -0.0010433197, -0.01499176, 0.041015625, -0.00957489, -0.009284973, 0.026428223, -0.043518066, 0.08319092, 0.0027370453, -0.022979736, -0.03250122, 0.06390381, -0.017318726, 0.0046691895, 0.048736572, -0.012992859, 0.004257202, 0.03967285, -0.0031929016, 0.04446411, -0.06689453, 0.010688782, -0.07476807, -0.007926941, -0.031829834, 0.019958496, 0.026885986, 0.0079193115, 0.020889282, -0.0069999695, 0.08691406, -0.030853271, -0.0013141632, 0.017364502, -0.008232117, 0.019439697, 0.015357971, -0.0055236816, -0.005596161, -0.0075912476, -0.022445679, 0.01586914, -0.0184021, 0.036468506, -0.057769775, -0.014793396, -0.03479004, 0.015098572, -0.020507812, -0.027618408, -0.024337769, -0.027618408, 0.039093018, 0.041992188, -0.028366089, -0.024154663, -0.051574707, 0.014717102, -0.018859863, -0.049713135, 0.019638062, -0.06008911, 0.03918457, 0.029129028, -0.0002617836, 0.0011396408, -0.0031795502, -0.0158844, 0.002155304, 0.017852783, -0.020507812, 0.019119263, -0.04119873, 0.064208984, 0.05441284, 0.052612305, -0.008331299, 0.009086609, 0.061157227, -0.016189575, 0.02230835, 0.0077171326, 0.0057792664, 0.012016296, -0.055847168, -0.0012807846, -0.02609253, -0.05709839, -0.033325195, -0.024368286, 0.02192688, -0.064086914, 0.05441284, -0.08666992, -0.049072266, 0.06549072, -0.044067383, -0.05050659, 0.023208618, 0.0028057098, -0.024673462, 0.010353088, -0.035217285, -0.024612427, 0.010253906, 0.049682617, 0.053894043, -0.017700195, -0.02444458, 0.08001709, 0.028335571, 0.12524414, 0.0041122437, -0.02999878, 0.022491455, -0.029830933, 0.015563965, -0.04473877, -0.0034618378, -0.08013916, -0.0031909943, -0.07348633, 0.006210327, -0.021118164, -0.055145264, -0.07989502, 0.018112183, -0.021255493, -0.034484863, 0.07727051, -0.0051841736, -0.025268555, 0.019622803, 0.03515625, -0.031982422, 0.0027542114, -0.03491211, -0.008979797, 0.007701874, 0.040802002, -0.04586792, -0.019073486, 0.0018949509, 0.020187378, 0.0055122375, -0.021591187, -0.0013246536, 0.013916016, 0.062042236, 0.00667572, -0.02760315, 0.020126343, -0.046142578, 0.01209259, -0.08166504, 0.03378296, -0.038482666, -0.0113220215, -0.05987549, -0.02027893, 0.007926941, 0.018508911, 0.03652954, 0.008071899, 0.03253174, -0.015449524, 0.032836914, 0.01802063, -0.049957275, -0.016616821, 0.015541077, -0.0006494522, 0.015449524, 0.008636475, 0.045196533, -0.04815674, 0.050048828, -0.059539795, 0.002878189, -0.0055007935, -0.021987915, 0.0074691772, 0.028961182, -0.03353882, 0.07220459, -0.042297363, 0.0063438416, 0.024215698, 0.016204834, 0.009162903, -0.03265381, 0.028930664, 0.03753662, 0.008453369, 0.016159058, 0.007858276, 0.045318604, -0.037719727, 0.006072998, 0.0061035156, -0.037902832, 0.025100708, -0.032470703, -0.0054397583, 0.052490234, -0.045898438, -0.015464783, -0.07989502, -0.044128418, -0.00074243546, 0.022903442, -0.01737976, -0.0022144318, -0.02545166, -0.008094788, -0.0014896393, -0.00089263916 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07237v1
In Search of the Long-Tail: Systematic Generation of Long-Tail Knowledge via Logical Rule Guided Search
Huihan Li, Yuting Ning, Zeyi Liao, Siyuan Wang, Xiang Lorraine Li, Ximing Lu, Faeze Brahman, Wenting Zhao, Yejin Choi, Xiang Ren
cs.CL, cs.AI
Since large language models have approached human-level performance on many tasks, it has become increasingly harder for researchers to find tasks that are still challenging to the models. Failure cases usually come from the long-tail distribution - data that an oracle language model could assign a probability on the lower end of its distribution. Current methodology such as prompt engineering or crowdsourcing are insufficient for creating long-tail examples because humans are constrained by cognitive bias. We propose a Logic-Induced-Knowledge-Search (LINK) framework for systematically generating long-tail knowledge statements. Grounded by a symbolic rule, we search for long-tail values for each variable of the rule by first prompting a LLM, then verifying the correctness of the values with a critic, and lastly pushing for the long-tail distribution with a reranker. With this framework we construct a dataset, Logic-Induced-Long-Tail (LINT), consisting of 200 symbolic rules and 50K knowledge statements spanning across four domains. Human annotations find that 84% of the statements in LINT are factually correct. In contrast, ChatGPT and GPT4 struggle with directly generating long-tail statements under the guidance of logic rules, each only getting 56% and 78% of their statements correct. Moreover, their "long-tail" generations in fact fall into the higher likelihood range, and thus are not really long-tail. Our findings suggest that LINK is effective for generating data in the long-tail distribution while enforcing quality. LINT can be useful for systematically evaluating LLMs' capabilities in the long-tail distribution. We challenge the models with a simple entailment classification task using samples from LINT. We find that ChatGPT and GPT4's capability in identifying incorrect knowledge drop by ~3% in the long-tail distribution compared to head distribution.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07237v1
2023-11-13T10:56:59
2023-11-13T10:56:59
{ "title": [ -0.01878357, -0.019317627, -0.055847168, -0.06088257, -0.003917694, -0.0061569214, -0.025802612, 0.0024433136, -0.014717102, 0.021331787, -0.020690918, 0.015213013, -0.03338623, -0.02999878, -0.04675293, -0.031082153, 0.0062713623, 0.015014648, -0.0022296906, -0.02532959, -0.014579773, -0.02180481, 0.03201294, 0.04598999, 0.027893066, -0.015579224, -0.010391235, 0.021881104, -0.0070152283, 0.0049095154, -0.000019848347, -0.04434204, 0.06500244, -0.0077781677, 0.003993988, 0.015625, -0.027130127, 0.00049591064, -0.00818634, 0.011444092, 0.010231018, -0.0003244877, -0.014678955, -0.051727295, -0.048919678, 0.042144775, -0.060028076, -0.007575989, 0.00027537346, 0.06652832, 0.007484436, -0.0022773743, -0.02796936, 0.05734253, 0.005722046, -0.049926758, 0.004295349, -0.031311035, 0.031280518, 0.041229248, 0.01184845, -0.04562378, 0.03062439, -0.030014038, -0.05432129, -0.02142334, -0.005065918, 0.010185242, 0.08703613, -0.0075798035, -0.015113831, 0.05050659, -0.0056114197, 0.025527954, -0.034484863, -0.04916382, 0.07757568, 0.013389587, -0.006061554, 0.016098022, -0.017288208, -0.012535095, -0.006164551, -0.016723633, -0.0033435822, -0.025726318, -0.024047852, -0.0014505386, 0.0073661804, -0.048309326, 0.015022278, 0.033691406, -0.019088745, 0.013877869, -0.0132751465, -0.062194824, -0.028869629, 0.0093688965, -0.0015220642, -0.008956909, -0.025299072, 0.014816284, -0.04067993, -0.02229309, 0.0013093948, 0.046020508, 0.009841919, -0.008460999, 0.010627747, 0.012199402, 0.0021476746, 0.008621216, 0.01838684, -0.008117676, 0.02180481, 0.018951416, 0.010627747, 0.034332275, 0.007751465, 0.03390503, -0.010803223, -0.010101318, 0.035491943, -0.01739502, 0.01713562, 0.001953125, -0.031021118, -0.0151901245, 0.0016288757, 0.021560669, 0.027511597, 0.028884888, -0.13317871, -0.07849121, -0.07086182, 0.031982422, 0.040771484, -0.042266846, 0.014419556, -0.0027942657, 0.01335907, -0.01940918, -0.005126953, -0.006385803, -0.0027160645, 0.023956299, 0.060668945, -0.021774292, -0.025268555, 0.0049095154, -0.08929443, 0.06866455, 0.05517578, -0.04562378, -0.107543945, -0.064086914, -0.19396973, 0.005722046, 0.04220581, 0.002696991, 0.0045318604, -0.0073242188, -0.026794434, -0.016815186, 0.012077332, 0.010414124, -0.017791748, 0.029693604, 0.0060653687, 0.03314209, -0.04019165, 0.028961182, -0.011817932, -0.016998291, 0.002910614, 0.0010843277, 0.047790527, 0.0025253296, 0.01637268, -0.010559082, 0.0026435852, -0.008132935, -0.0052490234, 0.039245605, -0.07128906, -0.00093126297, -0.018875122, -0.021774292, 0.054595947, -0.0149002075, 0.0037021637, 0.021972656, -0.026016235, -0.04522705, -0.042633057, -0.011833191, 0.02418518, 0.039245605, -0.0077438354, -0.006259918, -0.043029785, 0.03579712, -0.037231445, 0.026641846, 0.0026073456, 0.002571106, -0.011711121, 0.02015686, -0.012939453, 0.04827881, 0.050872803, 0.017547607, -0.060516357, 0.052581787, 0.016708374, -0.05718994, 0.027313232, -0.02003479, 0.016494751, -0.012809753, 0.027511597, -0.0016307831, 0.012207031, 0.033172607, -0.016204834, 0.02166748, -0.011329651, -0.0057754517, 0.011810303, 0.035614014, 0.06274414, -0.03326416, 0.003282547, 0.014122009, -0.017303467, -0.012611389, -0.03640747, -0.005783081, -0.005958557, 0.014862061, 0.014724731, -0.008995056, -0.014007568, -0.00409317, 0.0036525726, -0.037017822, 0.020599365, -0.0103302, 0.015464783, 0.03717041, 0.0602417, 0.030715942, 0.039367676, 0.068359375, -0.0124053955, 0.044952393, 0.026260376, 0.03677368, -0.025115967, 0.031311035, -0.022003174, -0.009780884, -0.0206604, -0.013786316, -0.04714966, -0.02078247, -0.036254883, -0.012046814, -0.009063721, -0.005001068, 0.0541687, 0.0009775162, 0.0098724365, -0.031585693, 0.002336502, -0.037719727, -0.022476196, 0.02017212, 0.036010742, -0.06201172, -0.020507812, 0.04058838, 0.053588867, -0.008651733, -0.00969696, -0.007209778, 0.0088272095, -0.027511597, 0.012229919, 0.019607544, 0.05718994, 0.045898438, -0.00299263, 0.024291992, -0.022720337, 0.017562866, 0.014465332, 0.04156494, -0.009979248, 0.029708862, -0.057922363, 0.015899658, 0.034729004, -0.03543091, 0.012306213, 0.03390503, 0.034301758, 0.017089844, -0.009086609, 0.003540039, -0.051086426, -0.0019798279, -0.0056114197, -0.052337646, -0.028381348, -0.04473877, 0.0090789795, -0.041168213, 0.0049858093, 0.0054779053, 0.062683105, -0.00182724, -0.036499023, -0.010665894, 0.018692017, -0.021072388, -0.036193848, -0.04019165, -0.015434265, 0.027053833, 0.012268066, 0.017227173, -0.06274414, -0.010025024, -0.003829956, 0.013687134, -0.014533997, 0.023330688, -0.02645874, -0.040527344, -0.030899048, -0.0385437, 0.006587982, -0.03564453, -0.0340271, -0.04901123, -0.0007214546, 0.0027179718, -0.04650879, -0.0059013367, 0.041503906, -0.006450653, -0.036346436, 0.028564453, 0.053619385, -0.068237305, -0.008483887, 0.04748535, -0.0018978119, -0.024169922, 0.025985718, 0.020843506, 0.014862061, -0.047180176, -0.05090332, -0.05126953, -0.03567505, 0.018447876, 0.0039138794, 0.068725586, -0.05819702, 0.006942749, -0.036224365, -0.0025596619, -0.010971069, 0.014671326, 0.04449463, -0.012954712, -0.041137695, 0.018707275, -0.0054016113, 0.025756836, -0.07647705, 0.0039405823, 0.06878662, 0.012321472, 0.006198883, 0.012901306, 0.031829834, -0.008354187, -0.016693115, -0.019348145, -0.0025157928, 0.0019330978, 0.014572144, 0.028549194, -0.009033203, -0.007843018, -0.07702637, 0.001449585, -0.019515991, 0.02053833, -0.022369385, -0.010536194, -0.0368042, -0.019897461, -0.030288696, -0.030776978, 0.04107666, 0.03793335, -0.0076026917, 0.018157959, 0.01071167, -0.043304443, 0.0034637451, -0.01109314, -0.07928467, 0.013092041, -0.0024929047, -0.017547607, 0.008399963, -0.08691406, -0.019683838, 0.0032253265, -0.016021729, 0.015792847, 0.049713135, 0.03829956, 0.032348633, -0.0013408661, 0.0055007935, -0.018447876, -0.0033626556, -0.02558899, 0.012252808, -0.008239746, -0.034362793, 0.046783447, -0.03918457, 0.0077934265, -0.049926758, -0.031051636, -0.027450562, 0.009262085, 0.0022830963, -0.03982544, -0.028259277, -0.0390625, 0.030044556, -0.010025024, 0.008300781, -0.0178833, 0.04498291, 0.007019043, -0.02796936, 0.038726807, 0.017791748, 0.013465881, 0.0060043335, 0.0016555786, 0.020889282, -0.010681152, -0.06652832, 0.0021438599, 0.012359619, 0.04006958, -0.012367249, 0.0027446747, -0.025314331, -0.0065345764, -0.042419434, 0.021957397, 0.019042969, 0.00667572, -0.022521973, -0.020095825, -0.021972656, 0.00017726421, 0.0032215118, 0.018188477, 0.02267456, 0.0016393661, 0.028701782, -0.05657959, 0.023788452, -0.0042304993, -0.09863281, -0.03665161, 0.0009965897, -0.013046265, -0.043182373, -0.08062744, 0.025421143, -0.027923584, -0.052124023, 0.031311035, -0.018371582, 0.014671326, 0.02456665, -0.048461914, -0.0121154785, 0.058929443, -0.001045227, 0.00969696, 0.024475098, 0.004512787, -0.033721924, -0.035339355, -0.013214111, -0.022079468, 0.027954102, -0.020858765, -0.026672363, 0.04385376, -0.027664185, 0.017074585, 0.023590088, 0.005958557, 0.009864807, 0.014579773, -0.011230469, -0.02796936, 0.0069770813, 0.038482666, -0.02168274, 0.04171753, -0.06549072, 0.05505371, -0.015090942, -0.01184845, 0.03857422, -0.0055160522, 0.009902954, 0.008262634, 0.004962921, 0.03137207, -0.012123108, -0.017715454, 0.048461914, 0.036102295, -0.016525269, 0.014625549, 0.02911377, 0.029769897, -0.007965088, 0.0073623657, -0.0017557144, 0.08111572, -0.046661377, 0.025177002, 0.0038547516, 0.0049972534, -0.089416504, -0.016403198, -0.02305603, 0.0040626526, -0.017333984, 0.012413025, -0.02960205, 0.005268097, 0.041625977, -0.020385742, -0.027023315, -0.015930176, 0.0035114288, -0.021377563, 0.029647827, -0.029632568, -0.039215088, -0.007972717, -0.053588867, -0.010734558, 0.009567261, -0.0064315796, 0.038208008, -0.0028362274, -0.0019569397, 0.026184082, 0.020446777, 0.031463623, 0.030380249, -0.019638062, -0.0496521, 0.020401001, 0.0037117004, -0.004825592, -0.0009074211, -0.029663086, 0.0053100586, -0.017089844, -0.008148193, 0.0046539307, -0.014533997, -0.059326172, 0.020751953, -0.01737976, 0.023864746, 0.037628174, 0.06781006, 0.044921875, 0.004386902, 0.004348755, 0.011154175, -0.028015137, -0.005016327, -0.00067424774, 0.052490234, 0.008270264, -0.016998291, 0.010604858, 0.01977539, -0.015434265, 0.019195557, 0.005622864, 0.0060920715, 0.017852783, -0.02772522, 0.027938843, -0.0061454773, -0.038085938, 0.01751709, -0.0053749084, 0.036102295, -0.0006108284, 0.07043457, -0.008277893, 0.010635376, 0.031707764, -0.014381409, 0.0002770424, 0.0025997162, 0.009223938, -0.07763672, -0.028823853, -0.039733887, 0.058898926, -0.06640625, -0.009971619, 0.0026741028, -0.024551392, 0.029830933, 0.034973145, 0.05429077, -0.050720215, -0.015014648, -0.010154724, -0.015525818, 0.0046653748, -0.052246094, -0.012565613, 0.016525269, 0.014167786, -0.06762695, 0.015670776, -0.03237915, -0.028625488, -0.004032135, -0.0009036064, -0.0041503906, -0.059783936, 0.014160156, 0.053771973, 0.01586914, 0.022766113, 0.026535034, -0.011184692, 0.0317688, 0.026885986, 0.0029067993, 0.02079773, 0.01108551, -0.020858765, -0.0423584, -0.02432251, 0.0031986237, -0.003665924, 0.038269043, 0.00374794, -0.005050659, -0.05834961, 0.028656006, 0.0013418198, -0.03363037, -0.013191223, -0.025512695, 0.008087158, 0.0099105835, 0.02470398, 0.0064582825, -0.032287598, -0.021820068, -0.011619568, -0.015655518, -0.07318115, 0.04309082, 0.016906738, 0.0031929016, -0.042663574, 0.008934021, -0.02734375, 0.017181396, 0.013916016, 0.028625488, -0.0047302246, 0.002861023, 0.040893555, -0.000044226646, 0.026412964, -0.038269043, -0.014823914, 0.04623413, 0.05114746, 0.010002136, -0.006000519, -0.008544922, -0.061523438, -0.015701294, -0.010505676, -0.014968872, 0.025604248, -0.00046539307, 0.015029907, 0.036590576, -0.0435791, 0.025939941, 0.021911621, -0.010513306, 0.03250122, -0.0023117065, -0.010864258, 0.030639648, -0.0019264221, 0.010597229, -0.0035419464, 0.017028809, -0.08093262, 0.022964478, 0.013755798, 0.012283325, -0.03225708, -0.09124756, 0.005809784, 0.027862549, -0.008331299, 0.0061454773, 0.02305603, 0.033294678, 0.064941406, -0.032073975, 0.004070282, 0.03869629, -0.036224365, -0.048614502, -0.02708435, -0.010475159, -0.034088135, 0.056488037, -0.013885498, -0.04449463, -0.019485474, -0.058746338, -0.0317688, -0.0076828003, 0.031021118, 0.016235352, 0.015975952, 0.013015747, 0.05001831, -0.029037476, -0.017425537, -0.013923645, 0.024780273, -0.011856079, -0.05987549, 0.014045715, -0.0103302, -0.0030918121, -0.012275696, 0.0072021484, 0.003276825, 0.0023899078, -0.0019569397, -0.033050537, 0.0061035156, -0.030776978, -0.04522705, 0.03829956, 0.043518066, -0.015777588, 0.061462402, -0.0020694733, 0.05026245, 0.0059547424, 0.043518066, 0.010299683, -0.008666992, 0.014579773, 0.0048065186, 0.01272583, -0.036590576, 0.038909912, -0.042785645, 0.01889038, -0.0524292, -0.0044288635, -0.06829834, 0.01826477, 0.009597778, 0.030288696, 0.005783081, 0.02357483, 0.0032081604, 0.0015125275, 0.046844482, 0.039520264, 0.074401855, 0.0045051575, -0.0023975372, 0.008903503, -0.0014629364, -0.0039978027, 0.043823242, 0.011871338, -0.008125305, -0.05105591, 0.01727295, -0.017456055, 0.0077590942, 0.011672974, -0.00036120415, -0.0070724487, -0.022491455, 0.017242432, -0.011360168, 0.026687622, 0.060058594, 0.047576904, -0.018188477, -0.0035476685, 0.012641907, -0.026062012, -0.02557373, 0.0056419373, 0.028274536, -0.0748291, 0.017318726, -0.025222778, -0.015625, 0.0047569275, 0.01550293, 0.04550171, -0.037231445, -0.024505615, -0.0059776306, 0.046875, 0.0008301735, 0.023361206, -0.028366089, 0.010421753, -0.0074272156, -0.002729416, 0.048614502, 0.03173828, 0.008491516, 0.06161499, 0.013160706, 0.017303467, 0.014404297, 0.008377075, 0.017730713, 0.024032593, -0.009674072, 0.036224365, -0.019424438, -0.045532227, 0.029296875, -0.002128601, -0.06384277, -0.0036144257, 0.022369385, 0.061035156, 0.030136108, 0.08679199, 0.0154953, -0.0023612976, -0.0095825195, -0.024215698, 0.02671814, 0.04626465, -0.016525269, 0.018005371, -0.04248047, -0.051330566, 0.022109985, -0.033813477, 0.08325195, -0.04321289, 0.015129089, 0.01474762, -0.012123108, 0.02949524, -0.00082063675, -0.042114258, 0.010765076, -0.027572632, -0.009483337, -0.040618896, -0.012390137, -0.039123535, -0.0042915344, 0.06341553, 0.030548096, -0.0047721863, -0.002040863, -0.035369873, -0.047576904, 0.019973755, -0.007865906, 0.058410645, -0.019348145, -0.008804321, 0.0013380051, 0.0029659271, 0.007801056, -0.048614502, -0.036102295, -0.01687622, 0.017974854, -0.014373779, 0.016204834, 0.03289795, 0.003753662, 0.03503418, -0.0541687, 0.025848389, -0.028152466, -0.013465881, 0.014663696, -0.0491333, 0.0019483566, -0.0014476776, -0.016693115, 0.06262207, 0.041229248, -0.019470215, -0.0071907043, 0.011146545, -0.0063667297, -0.031204224, -0.010894775, 0.013648987, -0.038604736, -0.04196167, 0.008003235, 0.017089844, 0.029037476, -0.051635742, -0.043548584, 0.012382507, 0.00086545944, 0.009231567, 0.06161499, -0.0013885498, 0.0041542053, 0.027359009, 0.0362854, 0.02104187, -0.05368042, -0.022598267, -0.015426636, 0.023330688, 0.030319214, 0.012489319, -0.015716553, 0.033172607, -0.023010254, -0.015296936, -0.0029697418, 0.029922485, -0.0042495728, 0.017807007, 0.039276123, -0.041625977, -0.016586304, 0.020217896, 0.021255493, -0.0057411194, -0.0011663437, -0.016952515, 0.008323669, -0.018112183, 0.0056648254, 0.0060310364, -0.019821167, 0.03302002, 0.03503418, 0.026489258, 0.04272461, -0.0034713745, -0.014526367, -0.0029029846, -0.015602112, -0.007598877, -0.017959595, -0.035339355, 0.03036499, 0.0050582886, 0.000746727, 0.002254486, -0.027648926, -0.022827148, 0.048675537, -0.0099105835, -0.0181427, -0.020431519, -0.046173096, -0.0022525787, 0.025482178, 0.0012998581, -0.030654907, -0.031951904, 0.011001587, 0.04067993, -0.0059013367 ], "summary": [ -0.00774765, -0.020324707, -0.027954102, 0.0004506111, -0.047607422, -0.012237549, -0.027359009, -0.012802124, 0.009246826, 0.02168274, -0.02180481, -0.00056552887, -0.031677246, -0.010391235, -0.022232056, -0.03793335, -0.023468018, 0.046447754, 0.023391724, -0.04269409, 0.030670166, -0.054016113, -0.00013053417, -0.01424408, 0.026016235, -0.031982422, 0.046966553, 0.017532349, 0.043945312, 0.024810791, 0.026062012, -0.0715332, 0.033966064, 0.0077552795, -0.021118164, 0.026901245, -0.019348145, 0.0076141357, -0.009559631, 0.013771057, 0.008880615, -0.0028362274, 0.056274414, -0.001657486, -0.02319336, 0.048614502, -0.030075073, -0.027755737, 0.0635376, 0.024856567, -0.05267334, 0.03137207, -0.058929443, 0.004135132, -0.017181396, -0.027328491, 0.0082092285, -0.031463623, 0.005622864, 0.023773193, 0.0113220215, -0.006790161, 0.0236969, -0.009475708, -0.012557983, -0.012374878, 0.029205322, -0.030426025, 0.060150146, 0.010047913, 0.011405945, 0.030578613, -0.004749298, -0.01965332, -0.025924683, 0.004890442, 0.028533936, -0.0077171326, 0.009918213, -0.0023727417, -0.010124207, -0.0023212433, -0.008918762, -0.002714157, -0.012008667, -0.0067749023, -0.009498596, -0.006980896, 0.0042495728, -0.008659363, -0.0032787323, 0.010925293, 0.0046195984, 0.019226074, -0.007926941, -0.0446167, -0.00077056885, -0.02798462, 0.013885498, -0.033447266, 0.026016235, -0.03265381, -0.033294678, 0.0013685226, -0.0062179565, 0.024475098, -0.02015686, -0.030273438, 0.024871826, 0.022094727, -0.0062675476, 0.010528564, -0.015220642, -0.054840088, 0.0070610046, 0.05392456, 0.0017385483, 0.063964844, 0.025680542, 0.07141113, -0.026855469, -0.0069007874, 0.03552246, 0.044708252, -0.006324768, -0.000062704086, 0.009292603, -0.03111267, 0.017410278, 0.028167725, 0.026687622, 0.01727295, -0.08178711, -0.02949524, -0.06689453, 0.0039596558, 0.011627197, -0.022460938, -0.02128601, 0.014045715, 0.009346008, -0.0121154785, 0.012519836, -0.009010315, -0.0022258759, 0.048431396, 0.039886475, -0.012870789, -0.01210022, -0.013320923, -0.035125732, -0.000029146671, 0.050689697, -0.07897949, -0.080322266, -0.1282959, -0.1508789, 0.008575439, 0.069885254, -0.0007019043, -0.018554688, 0.008384705, 0.008743286, -0.010223389, -0.04373169, -0.01424408, 0.010597229, -0.0052261353, 0.012840271, 0.009506226, -0.034851074, 0.006351471, -0.016525269, -0.0066108704, 0.008483887, 0.005847931, 0.021072388, 0.025009155, 0.0075645447, -0.007331848, -0.0013132095, -0.034698486, 0.039276123, -0.013687134, -0.03378296, 0.013580322, -0.0035152435, 0.028579712, 0.051208496, 0.00067043304, 0.02168274, -0.011764526, -0.007801056, 0.011154175, -0.0095825195, -0.025939941, 0.007965088, 0.024963379, -0.0079193115, -0.013839722, 0.0066490173, 0.008102417, -0.01626587, -0.021484375, -0.09039307, 0.025863647, -0.035125732, 0.033050537, -0.022109985, 0.04345703, 0.032165527, 0.020858765, -0.06262207, 0.06933594, 0.032226562, -0.021102905, 0.029541016, -0.033233643, 0.029144287, -0.057617188, 0.044555664, 0.044708252, 0.02142334, 0.03768921, -0.039611816, 0.020202637, -0.025909424, 0.012825012, -0.012466431, 0.018234253, 0.04043579, -0.018753052, -0.0054397583, 0.0053977966, -0.029190063, -0.026641846, -0.026138306, -0.0592041, 0.019989014, 0.055358887, 0.036865234, 0.021102905, -0.029449463, -0.04876709, 0.034942627, 0.0067634583, 0.0390625, -0.05682373, -0.014312744, 0.029144287, 0.028701782, 0.012649536, 0.0050201416, 0.034454346, -0.005126953, 0.017730713, 0.002002716, 0.00030755997, -0.006038666, -0.015090942, 0.008850098, -0.032928467, -0.02758789, -0.015556335, 0.0070877075, -0.093566895, -0.014564514, -0.04385376, 0.005088806, -0.0670166, 0.035095215, -0.043762207, 0.011230469, -0.082092285, -0.020248413, -0.047973633, -0.015701294, 0.036712646, 0.03756714, -0.07537842, -0.008583069, 0.045562744, 0.056671143, -0.010826111, -0.00894165, 0.015960693, 0.021713257, -0.02760315, 0.009262085, 0.06359863, 0.03479004, 0.064453125, 0.002817154, 0.047088623, -0.027816772, 0.02420044, -0.0026798248, -0.007030487, -0.0000615716, -0.015319824, 0.0068473816, 0.04989624, -0.0034370422, 0.009208679, 0.020202637, 0.023071289, 0.06036377, -0.010398865, 0.005680084, 0.0052986145, -0.014175415, 0.0134887695, 0.006931305, 0.032043457, -0.01259613, -0.048797607, 0.020523071, 0.021942139, -0.01852417, 0.008956909, 0.11047363, 0.040039062, 0.024902344, -0.0008301735, 0.017196655, -0.062316895, 0.017456055, -0.03086853, 0.03930664, 0.014045715, -0.05065918, -0.017364502, -0.047058105, -0.0049362183, -0.0040626526, 0.001499176, -0.009162903, 0.042053223, -0.016342163, -0.051239014, -0.028884888, -0.022766113, -0.023132324, -0.019348145, -0.029418945, -0.03137207, 0.030456543, -0.0068206787, 0.024765015, -0.0050582886, 0.020019531, -0.010810852, 0.014465332, 0.028671265, 0.04901123, -0.047302246, -0.040802002, 0.013160706, -0.00036382675, -0.054351807, 0.014152527, 0.03250122, 0.010398865, -0.054656982, -0.07727051, -0.015464783, -0.04586792, 0.071899414, 0.06335449, 0.047210693, 0.0028152466, 0.064941406, -0.052825928, -0.007320404, 0.010826111, -0.029525757, 0.096191406, -0.014892578, -0.03250122, 0.05368042, 0.0026245117, 0.032562256, -0.04208374, 0.03201294, 0.05682373, 0.009391785, 0.029830933, 0.061523438, 0.04928589, -0.016494751, 0.012527466, 0.0126571655, 0.021865845, -0.02897644, 0.030929565, 0.013023376, -0.006931305, 0.006378174, -0.0066223145, -0.012207031, 0.035064697, 0.0024909973, 0.011909485, 0.015556335, -0.017288208, 0.016860962, -0.00007510185, -0.0047340393, 0.025619507, -0.01953125, 0.030822754, -0.050689697, 0.010864258, -0.050842285, -0.011627197, -0.02470398, -0.030258179, -0.0073890686, 0.016021729, 0.018005371, 0.0107421875, -0.025756836, -0.0070762634, 0.011268616, 0.0018663406, -0.016464233, 0.011199951, 0.01259613, -0.0017471313, 0.042510986, 0.0028896332, 0.0003130436, 0.0041999817, -0.015274048, -0.045776367, 0.04006958, -0.0066070557, 0.054260254, -0.007797241, -0.025024414, -0.05758667, -0.032714844, -0.053894043, -0.003583908, 0.004085541, -0.037475586, -0.03967285, -0.064331055, 0.023895264, 0.02067566, 0.003932953, -0.022705078, 0.03741455, 0.021362305, -0.032440186, 0.06970215, -0.023910522, 0.015411377, 0.042938232, 0.004173279, 0.011947632, 0.017974854, -0.039123535, -0.01713562, 0.0049209595, 0.04534912, -0.0847168, 0.055389404, -0.00025439262, -0.030883789, 0.057006836, -0.009651184, -0.002035141, 0.012542725, -0.026687622, 0.016143799, 0.022155762, 0.008575439, 0.003993988, -0.008255005, -0.040802002, 0.014587402, -0.064331055, -0.05203247, -0.023971558, -0.008781433, -0.06750488, -0.050964355, -0.0011005402, 0.0012168884, -0.0052757263, -0.042144775, 0.038208008, -0.0154800415, -0.013763428, 0.008659363, -0.026245117, 0.099121094, 0.021621704, -0.046173096, 0.027282715, -0.014640808, -0.0059509277, 0.0042495728, -0.024871826, 0.04840088, 0.043548584, -0.016311646, -0.016113281, -0.030075073, 0.01108551, -0.04928589, 0.003967285, 0.009757996, -0.0025863647, 0.041412354, 0.0063171387, -0.041809082, 0.031463623, 0.007575989, 0.012229919, 0.009674072, 0.008132935, 0.009590149, -0.03314209, 0.053649902, -0.038116455, 0.041381836, -0.03793335, -0.06121826, 0.009849548, 0.03152466, -0.036132812, 0.020599365, 0.022262573, 0.013183594, -0.025390625, -0.017700195, 0.008857727, 0.028564453, -0.036712646, -0.04534912, 0.01828003, 0.03967285, -0.043701172, 0.0015926361, -0.03012085, 0.07489014, -0.059051514, 0.015808105, 0.04498291, 0.03024292, -0.05239868, -0.019805908, -0.026565552, 0.042053223, -0.030929565, 0.035247803, -0.017486572, -0.0035324097, 0.013282776, 0.026367188, -0.022720337, -0.016708374, -0.00724411, -0.0047721863, -0.00028967857, -0.048065186, -0.04928589, 0.014533997, -0.028656006, 0.002866745, -0.027389526, -0.04663086, -0.022445679, -0.024749756, 0.0127334595, 0.035217285, 0.005153656, -0.03161621, 0.0015583038, -0.00042581558, 0.007637024, 0.005130768, -0.010971069, 0.011146545, 0.029556274, -0.028335571, 0.0045280457, -0.009315491, -0.01878357, 0.009986877, -0.020095825, -0.048614502, 0.0090408325, -0.015930176, 0.009819031, 0.037841797, 0.06347656, 0.031188965, -0.020736694, 0.016952515, 0.006969452, 0.0059890747, 0.010383606, 0.052001953, -0.0011749268, 0.06762695, -0.024612427, 0.0064926147, 0.017410278, 0.012123108, -0.000834465, 0.0010232925, -0.008712769, -0.0036010742, -0.01209259, 0.03100586, 0.03302002, -0.008506775, 0.047332764, 0.010566711, 0.019851685, 0.042633057, 0.0016088486, 0.02142334, -0.009086609, 0.044708252, -0.0033512115, -0.02178955, 0.026748657, -0.033721924, -0.05328369, -0.0011959076, -0.025253296, 0.014701843, -0.039367676, -0.018508911, -0.009864807, -0.032348633, 0.037078857, 0.0020484924, 0.04309082, -0.07287598, -0.012451172, -0.02243042, -0.018707275, 0.016937256, -0.01108551, -0.030700684, 0.0049438477, 0.00447464, -0.0317688, -0.013725281, 0.012870789, -0.037719727, -0.023208618, -0.01828003, 0.0004286766, -0.04196167, -0.037139893, 0.016677856, -0.012046814, 0.014984131, 0.0715332, -0.0017633438, 0.0002937317, -0.0007362366, -0.0017614365, 0.0012817383, -0.011795044, -0.052978516, -0.017807007, -0.021697998, -0.0077056885, 0.0146865845, 0.04385376, 0.02079773, 0.01852417, -0.05206299, 0.005329132, -0.027252197, -0.014022827, -0.027252197, -0.0030078888, 0.0146865845, -0.012008667, 0.031143188, -0.003458023, 0.022644043, -0.045013428, -0.026916504, 0.020553589, -0.03778076, -0.016494751, 0.0012722015, 0.029418945, -0.015991211, -0.022216797, -0.048675537, 0.024841309, 0.025817871, 0.0069236755, 0.015357971, -0.018966675, 0.040649414, -0.0021190643, 0.03933716, -0.017044067, 0.0071983337, 0.027114868, 0.026626587, 0.03262329, -0.00076675415, -0.0362854, -0.027114868, -0.05166626, -0.069885254, -0.057678223, 0.083984375, -0.006450653, 0.037994385, 0.026290894, -0.058380127, 0.0121154785, -0.017868042, -0.005443573, 0.020385742, -0.043121338, -0.06088257, 0.02104187, -0.026138306, -0.010643005, 0.00092458725, -0.006942749, -0.03729248, 0.03479004, 0.051574707, 0.07299805, -0.06341553, -0.113464355, -0.0008020401, 0.040100098, 0.00642395, 0.015129089, 0.015930176, 0.026809692, 0.040222168, -0.00843811, 0.009239197, 0.033447266, -0.01234436, 0.011672974, -0.037353516, 0.019897461, -0.03793335, 0.012718201, -0.03427124, 0.00012624264, -0.021697998, -0.03414917, 0.0050354004, 0.00037550926, 0.0062675476, 0.010223389, 0.022598267, 0.037872314, 0.05517578, -0.04663086, -0.025772095, -0.0076522827, 0.020965576, -0.030517578, -0.03353882, 0.04006958, -0.029312134, -0.028778076, 0.033966064, 0.014602661, 0.012565613, -0.029541016, 0.045135498, 0.005344391, 0.008911133, -0.027496338, -0.0050582886, 0.025344849, 0.04248047, 0.0020637512, 0.039215088, -0.030853271, 0.030578613, 0.019882202, 0.009536743, -0.011993408, -0.034057617, -0.007007599, 0.00137043, -0.016189575, -0.028945923, 0.03125, -0.0016288757, -0.012916565, -0.03717041, -0.016464233, -0.030410767, 0.05947876, -0.033233643, -0.018371582, 0.016448975, 0.008216858, -0.011665344, 0.023010254, -0.03527832, 0.02357483, -0.0040397644, -0.010276794, -0.030838013, 0.034606934, -0.0067329407, 0.015289307, 0.041503906, 0.00026273727, 0.0045433044, -0.014457703, 0.019088745, 0.0019378662, -0.008796692, -0.026000977, -0.0236969, 0.034088135, -0.02305603, -0.024337769, 0.026367188, 0.020599365, -0.025878906, -0.008415222, 0.013191223, 0.022384644, -0.018447876, -0.0031852722, -0.010269165, 0.007331848, -0.0041160583, -0.0041999817, 0.017089844, 0.011734009, -0.02381897, 0.03942871, 0.012069702, 0.06463623, -0.044281006, -0.008468628, 0.0077323914, 0.015472412, -0.022827148, 0.011146545, -0.03857422, -0.03567505, -0.02482605, -0.0067329407, 0.008125305, 0.017349243, 0.006465912, 0.017105103, 0.04611206, 0.019226074, 0.009414673, 0.02053833, 0.02859497, 0.02645874, 0.004207611, 0.05368042, -0.022903442, -0.027069092, 0.014335632, 0.016830444, -0.029586792, -0.00894928, 0.049743652, 0.066467285, 0.03729248, 0.05343628, -0.041503906, 0.010093689, 0.033691406, 0.008460999, 0.046813965, 0.017456055, 0.025344849, -0.015182495, -0.056030273, -0.026153564, -0.00046944618, -0.023406982, 0.11590576, -0.038330078, 0.01725769, -0.02848816, -0.01486969, -0.03765869, 0.01071167, 0.017593384, -0.03378296, 0.009918213, 0.008132935, 0.01600647, -0.035736084, -0.01473999, -0.014152527, 0.009010315, 0.0025997162, 0.0041236877, 0.030593872, -0.029266357, -0.040283203, 0.029129028, 0.032409668, 0.06970215, -0.000096678734, -0.020690918, 0.019973755, 0.020645142, 0.027770996, -0.08581543, -0.05810547, 0.0028800964, 0.047912598, -0.01360321, 0.00024330616, 0.0041389465, -0.00491333, -0.044555664, -0.024658203, 0.009147644, -0.038269043, 0.064819336, 0.01638794, -0.041412354, 0.021224976, 0.042999268, -0.040924072, 0.045959473, -0.014854431, -0.042541504, 0.05429077, -0.0022792816, -0.033477783, -0.009140015, -0.030059814, -0.028121948, -0.025741577, -0.0413208, -0.002702713, -0.012619019, 0.022003174, -0.025314331, -0.024032593, 0.003030777, 0.019989014, 0.0010023117, -0.0017375946, -0.022201538, -0.011405945, 0.040863037, 0.030639648, 0.013008118, -0.018447876, 0.03250122, 0.02633667, 0.034820557, 0.011962891, -0.026275635, 0.02381897, -0.002811432, -0.05154419, -0.025497437, 0.0006952286, 0.026489258, -0.030792236, 0.012634277, 0.02407837, -0.027526855, -0.043029785, 0.0031356812, -0.007637024, 0.007713318, 0.0055770874, -0.03314209, 0.010444641, -0.021987915, -0.028442383, 0.018997192, 0.006137848, -0.0029449463, 0.0073661804, 0.03302002, -0.022994995, 0.021530151, -0.010520935, 0.022964478, -0.0023975372, 0.006225586, 0.0055999756, -0.016662598, -0.025863647, -0.029647827, 0.024169922, 0.021026611, -0.04925537, -0.0006599426, 0.007549286, -0.04397583, -0.012207031, -0.0345459, -0.03677368, 0.019454956, 0.039276123, 0.017425537, 0.008842468, 0.012916565, 0.028930664, 0.014167786, 0.008987427 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07230v1
How are Prompts Different in Terms of Sensitivity?
Sheng Lu, Hendrik Schuff, Iryna Gurevych
cs.CL
In-context learning (ICL) has become one of the most popular learning paradigms. While there is a growing body of literature focusing on prompt engineering, there is a lack of systematic analysis comparing the effects of prompts across different models and tasks. To address this gap, we present a comprehensive prompt analysis based on the sensitivity of a function. Our analysis reveals that sensitivity is an unsupervised proxy for model performance, as it exhibits a strong negative correlation with accuracy. We use gradient-based saliency scores to empirically demonstrate how different prompts affect the relevance of input tokens to the output, resulting in different levels of sensitivity. Furthermore, we introduce sensitivity-aware decoding which incorporates sensitivity estimation as a penalty term in the standard greedy decoding. We show that this approach is particularly helpful when information in the input is scarce. Our work provides a fresh perspective on the analysis of prompts, and contributes to a better understanding of the mechanism of ICL.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07230v1
2023-11-13T10:52:01
2023-11-13T10:52:01
{ "title": [ 0.02809143, 0.0118255615, 0.016555786, 0.033569336, -0.018325806, -0.017196655, 0.009422302, -0.06567383, 0.01096344, 0.030181885, -0.0017795563, -0.0143585205, -0.016342163, -0.0256958, -0.01335144, -0.01991272, 0.022399902, -0.013114929, -0.041290283, -0.041503906, -0.021087646, -0.030059814, -0.052612305, 0.06628418, 0.058807373, -0.009902954, -0.095703125, 0.028656006, 0.011230469, 0.03111267, 0.01524353, -0.007858276, 0.0046920776, 0.067993164, -0.060638428, 0.0309906, -0.0231781, 0.042999268, 0.0032444, 0.027313232, 0.018569946, -0.023925781, -0.006767273, -0.018356323, -0.03378296, -0.039611816, 0.050933838, -0.009895325, 0.041229248, -0.045410156, -0.029373169, -0.0236969, 0.000008404255, -0.055358887, -0.05432129, -0.035583496, -0.015449524, 0.047424316, 0.0070343018, -0.031799316, -0.022109985, 0.030334473, 0.024276733, 0.012969971, 0.0143585205, -0.014877319, 0.013465881, 0.031143188, 0.06677246, 0.012481689, -0.0340271, 0.025848389, 0.015159607, -0.04534912, -0.021591187, 0.029296875, -0.03024292, 0.005466461, 0.02420044, -0.037750244, -0.02609253, 0.0552063, -0.051086426, -0.029708862, -0.012840271, -0.014205933, -0.016937256, -0.015396118, 0.0018291473, -0.040252686, -0.007270813, -0.0009589195, -0.033966064, 0.049621582, -0.0064926147, -0.028564453, -0.0023479462, -0.031311035, -0.02861023, -0.074157715, 0.027679443, -0.0345459, -0.046325684, 0.024612427, -0.0019741058, 0.008735657, 0.029907227, -0.027420044, 0.023422241, 0.016098022, 0.005065918, 0.06903076, 0.037200928, 0.034698486, -0.005756378, -0.032165527, -0.008995056, 0.019561768, -0.025894165, -0.019302368, -0.024963379, 0.0010919571, 0.09661865, -0.02947998, 0.030456543, 0.046020508, -0.014480591, -0.082458496, -0.033691406, -0.0009889603, 0.004383087, 0.024002075, -0.012046814, 0.010055542, -0.023162842, 0.000006020069, 0.018753052, -0.0007405281, -0.024383545, -0.0158844, 0.020065308, -0.009170532, -0.041046143, -0.011199951, 0.010520935, 0.07348633, 0.02722168, 0.001200676, 0.0023612976, -0.08288574, 0.04550171, -0.03930664, -0.020904541, 0.02520752, 0.010284424, 0.045532227, -0.06347656, 0.044128418, 0.024108887, 0.064697266, 0.0029907227, 0.0009045601, -0.0012292862, 0.021896362, 0.024490356, -0.01789856, 0.008895874, 0.013931274, 0.017547607, 0.09448242, -0.018325806, 0.031402588, -0.002248764, 0.00969696, -0.00067043304, -0.010246277, 0.0010824203, 0.008262634, 0.038391113, -0.022476196, 0.0043563843, -0.0107803345, 0.05218506, 0.005958557, -0.03866577, -0.002313614, -0.01576233, -0.0126953125, 0.04559326, -0.0020370483, -0.015281677, 0.01852417, 0.02305603, -0.041381836, -0.010040283, -0.012741089, -0.0048561096, -0.004043579, -0.0104904175, 0.04272461, 0.03201294, -0.016708374, 0.03579712, -0.017425537, -0.005958557, 0.02243042, -0.010475159, -0.0029411316, 0.057006836, 0.020401001, -0.019348145, -0.031585693, -0.0003950596, -0.012817383, -0.05050659, -0.013755798, -0.0030136108, -0.022079468, 0.02053833, -0.025436401, 0.027450562, 0.03866577, -0.008155823, -0.007282257, 0.0046691895, -0.029144287, 0.012435913, -0.023101807, 0.05810547, -0.038116455, 0.09832764, 0.013519287, -0.024047852, 0.06274414, 0.027572632, 0.008926392, 0.055603027, -0.023513794, 0.0062332153, -0.014434814, 0.010414124, 0.018554688, -0.04421997, -0.009284973, 0.030197144, 0.03579712, 0.034820557, -0.0029010773, 0.040039062, -0.017562866, 0.011123657, -0.06555176, 0.061676025, -0.014595032, 0.04446411, 0.023788452, 0.012893677, -0.023071289, -0.015083313, 0.030319214, -0.0016708374, 0.01374054, -0.017120361, 0.008384705, -0.018371582, -0.05496216, -0.019821167, -0.01525116, 0.012069702, -0.026275635, 0.030548096, -0.03756714, -0.00048565865, -0.029708862, 0.04711914, -0.015174866, -0.011657715, -0.0087890625, 0.00894165, -0.012008667, -0.0061149597, 0.017318726, -0.01889038, -0.007160187, 0.009719849, 0.009490967, -0.010269165, 0.0022659302, 0.021392822, 0.006298065, 0.058410645, -0.034942627, 0.0006904602, 0.014503479, -0.041290283, -0.049621582, -0.006996155, 0.021759033, -0.000013113022, -0.02267456, -0.019927979, 0.0287323, -0.03366089, 0.0317688, -0.015625, 0.02305603, -0.009376526, 0.007156372, -0.007434845, -0.021896362, -0.02986145, -0.002204895, 0.008529663, 0.00030875206, -0.008094788, -0.003742218, 0.013031006, 0.008308411, 0.024795532, 0.0016527176, 0.091796875, -0.012207031, 0.02696228, -0.055511475, -0.005256653, -0.05593872, -0.050750732, -0.007820129, 0.002336502, -0.02709961, -0.016235352, -0.055358887, -0.045806885, -0.03451538, 0.01638794, -0.018432617, -0.003692627, 0.004085541, -0.0121536255, 0.03201294, -0.012298584, -0.017028809, 0.018249512, -0.057037354, 0.029006958, -0.016357422, 0.011367798, 0.025527954, -0.03149414, 0.019638062, -0.016296387, -0.040985107, -0.006942749, 0.0014362335, 0.01625061, 0.014328003, -0.0046920776, -0.0057792664, -0.00024104118, -0.055725098, -0.004688263, -0.0077400208, -0.050079346, 0.022003174, 0.040039062, -0.037475586, -0.011375427, 0.010475159, 0.0058517456, 0.03616333, 0.022201538, -0.010375977, -0.011909485, 0.0031986237, -0.0099487305, -0.008636475, -0.043182373, -0.05722046, 0.025238037, -0.02796936, -0.020248413, 0.0069274902, 0.03765869, 0.082214355, 0.029815674, -0.004081726, -0.009063721, 0.0023517609, 0.025787354, 0.0098724365, -0.004207611, -0.0206604, -0.02708435, -0.02494812, 0.0024204254, 0.027175903, -0.028427124, -0.04940796, -0.0118637085, -0.034088135, 0.03414917, -0.04244995, -0.009086609, -0.016952515, -0.046081543, 0.013961792, -0.010612488, 0.0075416565, 0.03086853, 0.0069236755, 0.0206604, -0.056549072, 0.04437256, -0.06768799, 0.002532959, -0.03173828, -0.05279541, 0.0015106201, 0.012145996, 0.0134887695, -0.007987976, -0.007270813, -0.005290985, 0.035736084, -0.01210022, 0.039520264, -0.0037670135, 0.017791748, -0.0057868958, -0.012062073, -0.009391785, -0.019470215, -0.05215454, -0.025680542, 0.009086609, -0.00058317184, -0.018661499, -0.015266418, 0.011054993, -0.010887146, -0.053375244, -0.013198853, -0.052734375, -0.004562378, 0.010658264, -0.060333252, 0.0132369995, -0.06896973, -0.029418945, -0.024215698, -0.022583008, 0.013969421, -0.0107421875, 0.02078247, 0.00080919266, 0.081726074, -0.03817749, 0.033843994, 0.034454346, 0.0031013489, 0.026611328, -0.022750854, -0.016830444, 0.029708862, -0.041778564, 0.001077652, 0.03262329, -0.011123657, -0.04534912, 0.019348145, -0.018615723, 0.048736572, 0.00032186508, -0.010269165, -0.0074653625, 0.010665894, 0.025344849, -0.02558899, 0.003129959, -0.014160156, 0.023727417, -0.011329651, 0.015930176, -0.019607544, -0.0022468567, 0.016494751, -0.071899414, -0.00079393387, 0.0029773712, 0.017684937, -0.014572144, 0.011192322, 0.00749588, 0.026519775, 0.0020008087, -0.017410278, -0.0048713684, -0.016540527, 0.00248909, -0.051208496, -0.04800415, 0.0077552795, -0.0038852692, -0.00944519, -0.022262573, -0.06323242, -0.039093018, 0.0041503906, 0.054718018, -0.004676819, -0.019805908, 0.026763916, -0.053771973, -0.043762207, -0.0069770813, 0.06542969, -0.04550171, -0.061157227, 0.026519775, 0.0042495728, -0.006931305, 0.047790527, -0.03842163, 0.024475098, 0.041412354, 0.0065307617, -0.04437256, 0.053649902, 0.0016841888, -0.045715332, -0.013000488, -0.03866577, 0.009010315, 0.039764404, 0.034484863, 0.05899048, -0.007987976, 0.051483154, 0.029464722, -0.050445557, -0.021575928, -0.031219482, -0.0062026978, -0.020690918, -0.029647827, 0.011932373, -0.024215698, 0.049102783, 0.007221222, -0.0052833557, 0.019699097, 0.008964539, 0.010574341, 0.023864746, -0.022125244, -0.017929077, -0.042785645, -0.0077590942, -0.012748718, 0.064819336, 0.01977539, 0.04171753, -0.029296875, -0.013473511, 0.008323669, -0.031402588, 0.053009033, -0.0026378632, -0.050964355, -0.0109939575, -0.02607727, -0.010513306, -0.025970459, -0.064086914, -0.03616333, -0.009849548, -0.047851562, -0.029418945, 0.0046195984, 0.039520264, 0.046142578, 0.04598999, -0.048461914, -0.030166626, 0.018707275, -0.08068848, 0.037139893, -0.023406982, -0.010391235, -0.06329346, 0.020492554, -0.03326416, 0.008293152, -0.037384033, 0.026535034, -0.016342163, 0.03466797, -0.0473938, -0.06652832, 0.0033912659, 0.01651001, 0.014701843, 0.01676941, -0.00674057, -0.045166016, 0.030776978, 0.006816864, 0.03491211, 0.005744934, 0.0181427, 0.0073890686, -0.052856445, 0.026855469, 0.035308838, -0.012306213, 0.0154800415, -0.004714966, 0.010818481, -0.03540039, -0.036254883, 0.0060691833, -0.024383545, 0.02696228, 0.0058135986, 0.014213562, 0.0121536255, -0.0050582886, 0.006198883, -0.014175415, 0.00034213066, -0.03817749, -0.011909485, 0.004573822, -0.017745972, 0.053771973, 0.009162903, -0.010475159, 0.018295288, -0.027557373, -0.009429932, -0.0259552, 0.02293396, -0.0021076202, 0.023742676, 0.040802002, -0.031829834, 0.021652222, 0.0033130646, -0.057922363, -0.0041275024, -0.03451538, 0.018478394, -0.013847351, 0.040985107, 0.018234253, -0.009460449, 0.0034713745, -0.037902832, -0.020629883, -0.06286621, -0.048736572, -0.022994995, -0.044189453, 0.009223938, -0.003238678, 0.017028809, 0.062438965, 0.030151367, 0.0026779175, -0.0126953125, -0.010986328, 0.056152344, 0.008300781, -0.0052108765, -0.007881165, 0.05895996, -0.017333984, 0.0053100586, -0.005378723, 0.042510986, 0.025177002, 0.03945923, -0.0059394836, -0.034332275, -0.020843506, 0.039276123, -0.029327393, 0.013053894, -0.011642456, -0.035980225, -0.04727173, -0.00048542023, -0.032928467, -0.031021118, -0.011451721, -0.046875, -0.013313293, -0.06829834, 0.04067993, -0.0008034706, 0.0014295578, -0.035186768, 0.015541077, -0.040161133, -0.0025691986, -0.025848389, -0.025741577, -0.04321289, 0.02810669, 0.038513184, -0.05041504, -0.011795044, -0.033843994, -0.012519836, 0.06994629, 0.019500732, 0.0234375, -0.008804321, -0.035186768, -0.028930664, -0.020996094, -0.0009050369, 0.013687134, -0.05291748, 0.019210815, -0.03677368, -0.015853882, -0.01626587, 0.009605408, 0.0015935898, 0.017425537, 0.038757324, -0.0105896, -0.0010480881, 0.0104522705, -0.049591064, -0.0007033348, 0.00038170815, 0.0073013306, -0.07733154, -0.050231934, -0.004737854, 0.01727295, -0.005039215, 0.012870789, 0.0259552, 0.0034656525, 0.012908936, 0.015701294, -0.006916046, 0.029510498, -0.004432678, -0.066345215, -0.030731201, -0.009841919, -0.003414154, 0.061676025, -0.019470215, -0.067871094, -0.005821228, -0.04623413, -0.00081014633, 0.00015962124, 0.057922363, -0.011451721, 0.043060303, -0.05731201, -0.031066895, 0.017822266, 0.018035889, -0.008361816, -0.027267456, 0.0008020401, 0.005683899, 0.031051636, 0.08605957, -0.0060272217, 0.007751465, 0.012634277, 0.0056648254, -0.027511597, 0.052764893, 0.016464233, -0.009101868, -0.019943237, 0.017181396, 0.033599854, 0.03225708, -0.050750732, 0.010406494, 0.02178955, 0.064208984, 0.00035905838, 0.0184021, 0.017440796, -0.01739502, -0.004421234, 0.0068893433, -0.03161621, -0.035980225, 0.0006041527, -0.052124023, 0.06109619, 0.06689453, 0.031677246, -0.0019836426, 0.011810303, 0.0869751, 0.005168915, 0.064331055, -0.0035419464, 0.027160645, 0.032714844, -0.020477295, 0.02104187, 0.0256958, 0.027542114, -0.006427765, 0.015174866, -0.059814453, 0.0056495667, 0.034729004, -0.0002541542, -0.021057129, 0.024963379, -0.016342163, -0.0055236816, -0.0069503784, 0.03125, -0.034973145, -0.010414124, -0.030456543, -0.039367676, -0.007423401, 0.006046295, 0.015541077, -0.03366089, 0.06161499, -0.013847351, -0.01663208, 0.08215332, 0.020828247, 0.009796143, 0.017929077, 0.053833008, -0.04547119, -0.0024757385, -0.02746582, 0.008140564, 0.057922363, -0.01979065, 0.023254395, 0.033050537, -0.00057554245, 0.0014019012, 0.055236816, -0.05291748, -0.050842285, -0.02519226, 0.019470215, 0.028030396, -0.028198242, -0.032470703, -0.016799927, 0.013496399, 0.00063085556, -0.0038719177, -0.008399963, -0.011978149, -0.017684937, 0.020629883, -0.006389618, 0.034057617, -0.008026123, -0.013450623, -0.0019931793, 0.0259552, -0.06439209, 0.020553589, -0.009887695, 0.07421875, -0.053527832, 0.022781372, -0.047973633, -0.043762207, -0.002696991, 0.03543091, 0.027435303, 0.026397705, 0.0090408325, 0.03918457, -0.031280518, -0.0038909912, 0.03817749, 0.0005311966, 0.034088135, 0.00920105, 0.04534912, -0.03012085, -0.00818634, -0.011390686, -0.05557251, 0.04699707, 0.0034828186, -0.02355957, -0.012245178, -0.02508545, 0.010871887, -0.00092840195, -0.06707764, 0.031021118, 0.02079773, 0.018707275, 0.06866455, -0.030349731, -0.09210205, 0.02758789, 0.016052246, 0.07397461, -0.019424438, -0.017303467, 0.007980347, -0.003408432, -0.0029525757, 0.014373779, 0.004470825, 0.007896423, -0.024978638, 0.020248413, -0.005756378, 0.024902344, -0.010223389, -0.0034275055, 0.001115799, 0.046020508, -0.025650024, 0.013000488, 0.009284973, 0.012413025, -0.02053833, -0.008628845, -0.010505676, -0.0135650635, -0.025115967, -0.013893127, 0.027618408, -0.017807007, -0.006072998, -0.015052795, 0.026550293, 0.03173828, -0.0014667511, -0.04031372, 0.016082764, -0.041778564, 0.0025978088, -0.05532837, -0.08312988, -0.016357422, 0.10333252, -0.039093018, 0.021713257, 0.05065918, 0.051574707, -0.011566162, 0.047302246, -0.028823853, -0.02822876, 0.06518555, 0.04940796, 0.015007019, 0.030303955, -0.0385437, 0.047424316, 0.010017395, -0.01675415, 0.013809204, 0.011146545, -0.026794434, -0.015617371, -0.0022716522, 0.012466431, 0.020095825, -0.05706787, -0.08465576, -0.002986908, 0.0011339188, -0.027511597, 0.01600647, 0.03778076, -0.036743164, 0.033569336, 0.009880066, 0.046081543, -0.014663696, -0.009346008, 0.034057617, -0.03274536, 0.018692017, 0.008407593, 0.0055885315, -0.019317627, 0.011604309, -0.039154053, 0.050689697, -0.066345215, -0.025604248, -0.021728516, 0.00040316582, 0.03640747, -0.016326904, 0.060913086, -0.010681152, -0.0035591125, 0.015319824, -0.022277832, 0.028808594, -0.0037879944, 0.05718994, 0.016983032, 0.013847351, 0.023025513, -0.022216797, -0.0010223389 ], "summary": [ 0.04046631, -0.014915466, 0.0048294067, 0.02494812, -0.03717041, -0.04196167, 0.006549835, -0.049041748, 0.013702393, 0.035583496, -0.030639648, -0.0034828186, -0.0052871704, -0.00881958, -0.029434204, -0.033416748, -0.004219055, 0.0231781, 0.0009608269, -0.033721924, 0.018539429, -0.04800415, -0.02671814, 0.03552246, 0.016693115, -0.058532715, -0.034729004, 0.0007109642, 0.022003174, 0.01361084, 0.009887695, -0.004383087, 0.0011053085, 0.053710938, -0.018753052, 0.04208374, -0.050048828, 0.047973633, 0.022705078, 0.028198242, 0.035736084, -0.0206604, 0.01713562, -0.046173096, -0.012207031, 0.033355713, 0.0067367554, -0.0057029724, 0.0025558472, 0.018478394, -0.0027332306, 0.008262634, -0.0071029663, -0.0041999817, -0.021865845, -0.04751587, -0.066589355, -0.0021820068, 0.0042762756, 0.07147217, 0.04498291, -0.011917114, -0.0050964355, -0.022415161, 0.006843567, 0.0034122467, 0.023117065, 0.00844574, 0.04510498, 0.0051879883, -0.006137848, 0.022369385, 0.014808655, -0.054626465, -0.031280518, 0.03704834, 0.008346558, 0.004184723, 0.023666382, -0.056732178, -0.0016965866, 0.024414062, -0.040283203, -0.031036377, -0.016860962, -0.036834717, -0.017089844, -0.011772156, 0.005718231, -0.05026245, -0.0038986206, 0.0024662018, 0.0054359436, -0.009338379, -0.012435913, -0.046783447, 0.011100769, -0.0009737015, 0.01473999, -0.037200928, 0.0143966675, -0.017028809, -0.045532227, 0.0019416809, 0.017852783, 0.05001831, -0.0051651, -0.015731812, 0.050720215, 0.009757996, -0.003063202, 0.0635376, -0.0038528442, -0.017807007, -0.006275177, -0.015625, -0.027816772, 0.04309082, 0.0020198822, -0.0076293945, -0.022277832, 0.028533936, 0.047454834, -0.0033836365, 0.019866943, 0.040924072, 0.016815186, -0.070373535, -0.032318115, 0.011192322, -0.023086548, 0.06518555, -0.004081726, -0.016677856, -0.040893555, -0.008308411, 0.023620605, 0.014274597, -0.001865387, -0.011001587, 0.0051841736, -0.030029297, -0.019363403, 0.0007047653, 0.027389526, 0.047088623, 0.0055656433, 0.0012769699, 0.0017967224, -0.044708252, 0.045532227, -0.034851074, 0.03112793, -0.029907227, -0.039794922, -0.06298828, -0.08099365, -0.013748169, 0.04815674, -0.024169922, 0.028305054, 0.0070877075, 0.022918701, 0.06347656, 0.028564453, -0.012321472, 0.0036849976, -0.014205933, 0.0042762756, 0.056610107, -0.021865845, 0.025634766, -0.0154953, 0.011703491, -0.00283432, -0.007369995, -0.008361816, 0.028686523, 0.011169434, 0.05343628, 0.036895752, -0.010528564, 0.05709839, -0.0054969788, -0.011268616, -0.012809753, -0.013412476, 0.008171082, 0.06628418, -0.0013027191, -0.029922485, -0.025390625, -0.018081665, -0.052246094, -0.013595581, 0.02192688, 0.008224487, 0.014053345, -0.008010864, 0.023025513, 0.085754395, 0.025283813, -0.0023880005, -0.037109375, -0.078308105, 0.017089844, -0.018554688, 0.022460938, 0.046569824, 0.041503906, -0.010879517, 0.004257202, 0.0017728806, -0.01247406, -0.026290894, 0.016662598, 0.057556152, -0.0013103485, 0.015151978, -0.0044670105, 0.021957397, 0.00818634, -0.014785767, 0.0513916, -0.0029010773, -0.03579712, 0.016036987, -0.0017595291, 0.0625, -0.010925293, 0.10070801, -0.039123535, -0.04260254, 0.013893127, 0.001739502, -0.028625488, -0.018234253, -0.093688965, 0.05117798, 0.052642822, 0.0049095154, 0.03616333, -0.057922363, -0.014511108, 0.052703857, 0.006454468, -0.0046195984, 0.022903442, 0.016983032, -0.021636963, 0.009803772, -0.060424805, 0.032989502, -0.04446411, 0.026290894, 0.0073013306, -0.03414917, -0.027893066, -0.01033783, -0.005531311, 0.013343811, 0.01600647, 0.018814087, -0.007106781, -0.0524292, -0.043823242, -0.03552246, -0.030960083, 0.026367188, -0.050476074, 0.03665161, -0.036987305, -0.005088806, -0.032684326, -0.011100769, -0.053588867, -0.048583984, 0.0423584, 0.024963379, -0.04916382, -0.0049858093, 0.0016326904, -0.021224976, -0.012390137, -0.0059547424, 0.008003235, 0.011894226, 0.005924225, 0.028366089, 0.0440979, 0.046539307, 0.05065918, 0.00730896, 0.034942627, -0.034973145, 0.0009727478, 0.009788513, 0.03149414, -0.0007891655, -0.0115737915, 0.01739502, 0.038360596, -0.027526855, 0.019485474, 0.014724731, -0.008415222, 0.014846802, 0.019348145, 0.02079773, 0.006996155, -0.008224487, 0.034484863, 0.029510498, 0.070495605, -0.041625977, -0.029373169, -0.0058517456, 0.05432129, -0.015167236, -0.0038776398, 0.114868164, -0.024673462, 0.027877808, -0.025390625, -0.01979065, -0.059783936, 0.0146102905, -0.018035889, 0.013961792, -0.01058197, -0.075927734, -0.026931763, -0.050628662, 0.04458618, -0.004764557, 0.008163452, 0.0076408386, -0.027664185, 0.013023376, 0.02331543, 0.031799316, -0.019760132, -0.0036811829, -0.027130127, -0.06994629, 0.0077934265, -0.0051956177, 0.0008430481, -0.021408081, -0.026397705, 0.03942871, -0.019943237, -0.0135650635, 0.03451538, -0.00111866, -0.007926941, 0.027526855, 0.0107803345, -0.02796936, -0.03439331, 0.025161743, 0.044708252, 0.003818512, -0.05834961, -0.01637268, -0.030944824, 0.023544312, -0.0491333, -0.0066833496, 0.014282227, -0.010696411, 0.02519226, -0.015312195, -0.023468018, -0.022109985, 0.002773285, 0.06530762, -0.0014667511, -0.002281189, 0.0491333, 0.023651123, 0.040039062, -0.035888672, 0.02784729, 0.07635498, 0.011459351, 0.0027065277, 0.06036377, 0.045776367, -0.006965637, 0.010124207, 0.00806427, -0.010734558, -0.016143799, -0.011802673, 0.0016508102, -0.004852295, -0.017562866, -0.011260986, -0.019866943, 0.07348633, -0.006374359, -0.0029258728, 0.0287323, -0.02217102, 0.042816162, 0.037322998, 0.0036735535, 0.016448975, -0.00459671, 0.033355713, -0.070373535, 0.02368164, -0.058807373, 0.0024318695, -0.031433105, -0.025161743, 0.014328003, -0.027770996, -0.002840042, -0.010467529, 0.020324707, -0.0009756088, -0.0041389465, 0.008338928, 0.0692749, -0.010429382, 0.016784668, 0.0124053955, -0.02633667, -0.006099701, -0.029571533, -0.032470703, 0.047058105, -0.027023315, 0.03933716, 0.019500732, -0.054107666, 0.07342529, -0.07446289, -0.051086426, -0.011520386, -0.03112793, 0.0026664734, -0.03866577, 0.0078048706, -0.0026607513, -0.060272217, -0.0010461807, 0.018478394, -0.049926758, -0.0055274963, -0.036254883, 0.033111572, -0.032592773, 0.06982422, -0.01966858, 0.046691895, 0.045684814, -0.0068130493, 0.049194336, -0.031219482, -0.0065231323, 0.036895752, 0.024765015, -0.0032634735, 0.02508545, 0.006008148, -0.011642456, 0.0024490356, 0.0046806335, -0.027633667, -0.037078857, -0.029190063, 0.004470825, 0.020904541, 0.030517578, -0.029190063, 0.042541504, -0.022338867, -0.027893066, -0.003276825, 0.03466797, -0.018218994, 0.021575928, 0.009262085, -0.032104492, -0.013648987, 0.037322998, 0.017181396, 0.014335632, -0.053222656, 0.052215576, -0.017974854, -0.00995636, 0.01008606, -0.032165527, 0.049621582, -0.012214661, -0.06738281, -0.00070381165, -0.0357666, 0.022979736, 0.005142212, -0.0042495728, -0.013496399, -0.010368347, 0.009056091, 0.037261963, -0.02217102, 0.019134521, -0.00029730797, 0.0064926147, 0.017288208, -0.024993896, 0.040405273, -0.00046157837, 0.010551453, 0.009063721, -0.008338928, 0.005958557, 0.050811768, -0.051361084, 0.039001465, 0.025054932, 0.019821167, -0.074279785, 0.06161499, -0.029510498, -0.010528564, -0.016235352, 0.014511108, -0.048950195, -0.0054473877, 0.06652832, 0.012458801, -0.04824829, 0.02003479, 0.035614014, 0.009094238, -0.064819336, -0.067993164, 0.018463135, 0.035247803, -0.017654419, 0.054656982, -0.033203125, 0.012489319, -0.040893555, -0.012840271, 0.006843567, 0.023986816, -0.021514893, -0.01651001, -0.022659302, 0.03869629, -0.029006958, 0.012458801, 0.0030956268, 0.01838684, 0.021102905, -0.007160187, 0.010261536, -0.009048462, -0.0038337708, 0.007545471, -0.042266846, -0.06793213, -0.056610107, 0.005558014, -0.022140503, 0.014556885, -0.046081543, -0.11029053, -0.009529114, -0.04852295, -0.03289795, -0.00091362, 0.010040283, 0.045928955, 0.030273438, 0.027435303, -0.046569824, -0.0041275024, 0.010513306, -0.020645142, 0.04522705, 0.008140564, 0.016296387, 0.008384705, 0.0056495667, -0.034423828, -0.004322052, -0.046173096, -0.004951477, -0.0023994446, 0.01751709, -0.0026988983, 0.0072898865, 0.0062828064, -0.014297485, 0.029525757, 0.0012588501, -0.008956909, 0.012588501, 0.053894043, 0.021148682, 0.041900635, 0.010543823, 0.0019197464, -0.023117065, -0.024887085, 0.010505676, 0.02357483, -0.004383087, -0.008979797, 0.0039520264, -0.00623703, 0.0042762756, -0.0011358261, 0.009399414, -0.012496948, 0.0178833, -0.0026493073, 0.033935547, 0.01789856, -0.0020751953, 0.037872314, 0.0041046143, -0.024841309, -0.0035057068, -0.027374268, -0.038208008, -0.016021729, -0.031158447, 0.02798462, -0.027679443, -0.03994751, -0.024536133, -0.014595032, 0.009681702, 0.0047340393, -0.008758545, -0.010025024, -0.0115356445, -0.010551453, 0.0022659302, -0.0146484375, -0.02670288, -0.04284668, 0.012611389, 0.0289917, -0.05947876, 0.04815674, 0.051757812, -0.02104187, -0.021865845, -0.017608643, -0.0017557144, -0.057434082, -0.05996704, -0.027999878, -0.023361206, 0.006690979, 0.047210693, -0.0015544891, -0.04006958, 0.04296875, -0.045318604, 0.048797607, 0.012451172, -0.03390503, 0.00022125244, 0.019546509, 0.01751709, 0.064819336, 0.014923096, 0.012825012, -0.008125305, 0.014259338, 0.0064086914, 0.012512207, 0.0044136047, -0.036865234, -0.0007867813, 0.039978027, 0.007572174, -0.009689331, 0.015083313, 0.042877197, 0.028396606, 0.011459351, 0.011955261, -0.011184692, -0.040374756, -0.03933716, -0.03768921, -0.046295166, 0.010231018, -0.0073013306, -0.012840271, -0.018615723, 0.030075073, -0.0335083, -0.011413574, -0.0096588135, 0.016036987, -0.014961243, 0.0049743652, 0.014587402, -0.035705566, 0.004432678, -0.099121094, -0.024856567, 0.03338623, 0.0012254715, -0.04269409, -0.05429077, -0.020263672, 0.020874023, 0.0063972473, 0.005493164, 0.058288574, -0.016845703, 0.039367676, -0.005870819, -0.008201599, 0.0082473755, -0.010498047, -0.021835327, -0.017181396, 0.03463745, -0.046875, -0.013046265, 0.028045654, -0.016906738, 0.033569336, -0.02394104, -0.0054397583, -0.015106201, -0.0155181885, 0.018157959, 0.012145996, -0.01234436, 0.015052795, 0.007205963, 0.012290955, 0.045532227, 0.023101807, 0.0138549805, 0.047943115, -0.01386261, -0.010826111, -0.022521973, 0.01096344, 0.0028076172, 0.0869751, -0.028121948, -0.033813477, -0.0390625, -0.030456543, 0.0059165955, 0.011390686, -0.0026874542, -0.012535095, 0.011390686, -0.027770996, 0.014022827, 0.004219055, -0.022109985, -0.022003174, 0.0042304993, -0.015472412, -0.020126343, 0.06915283, 0.000084102154, 0.009056091, -0.009498596, -0.01335144, -0.021057129, -0.004928589, -0.017456055, 0.010398865, 0.022262573, -0.018585205, 0.02178955, 0.019897461, 0.023208618, -0.017974854, -0.0058670044, 0.022140503, 0.05267334, 0.0149002075, -0.004878998, -0.038391113, -0.064331055, 0.012130737, 0.022735596, -0.0025520325, -0.02468872, 0.041046143, -0.026275635, 0.016326904, -0.0024356842, -0.00819397, -0.026397705, 0.013153076, 0.03451538, -0.0309906, 0.07421875, -0.016357422, 0.018539429, 0.043792725, -0.07775879, 0.028274536, -0.032989502, 0.06329346, 0.015602112, 0.003566742, -0.05908203, 0.0037727356, 0.044555664, -0.0026798248, 0.0076942444, 0.045959473, -0.008293152, 0.013694763, -0.006965637, -0.01424408, -0.103393555, 0.023727417, -0.042053223, 0.048797607, 0.0289917, 0.048980713, 0.029449463, 0.013572693, 0.030822754, -0.02999878, 0.0060310364, 0.06781006, -0.015670776, 0.036956787, 0.029876709, 0.011787415, -0.023849487, 0.0005736351, -0.020233154, -0.015701294, 0.051208496, 0.006793976, -0.030914307, 0.021911621, 0.009231567, -0.0025348663, -0.0013465881, -0.021209717, -0.01776123, 0.0051498413, 0.041656494, 0.015823364, -0.0028018951, 0.013290405, -0.020858765, -0.026138306, -0.013511658, -0.029144287, -0.008781433, 0.03829956, -0.01763916, 0.029556274, -0.026321411, 0.058532715, 0.00006222725, -0.03010559, -0.008956909, 0.048217773, -0.08380127, 0.027572632, 0.0045661926, 0.07312012, 0.02041626, 0.04888916, -0.05343628, 0.010864258, 0.04537964, 0.023086548, 0.025268555, 0.008026123, 0.010147095, 0.014961243, -0.040283203, 0.0059928894, -0.0051116943, -0.03149414, -0.00066137314, -0.0042533875, 0.054901123, -0.031951904, 0.00095939636, -0.035736084, -0.03253174, 0.03250122, 0.013542175, -0.028244019, 0.0131073, 0.017807007, -0.022537231, -0.021621704, -0.032562256, 0.011192322, -0.0064735413, 0.014343262, 0.07330322, -0.023666382, -0.0680542, 0.009727478, -0.015960693, 0.06982422, -0.053619385, -0.030212402, 0.04763794, -0.016098022, -0.010192871, -0.01158905, -0.026504517, 0.013946533, 0.0031967163, 0.0062217712, 0.007106781, 0.042663574, 0.018997192, -0.031204224, -0.0009717941, 0.02166748, -0.02168274, 0.032440186, 0.050598145, -0.014320374, 0.002822876, 0.021636963, -0.026977539, 0.027038574, -0.057281494, -0.0020046234, 0.008590698, 0.01777649, -0.06951904, -0.05496216, -0.0073165894, 0.016174316, 0.033111572, -0.03955078, 0.021881104, -0.04257202, 0.01689148, -0.033966064, -0.07720947, -0.026290894, 0.0635376, -0.020812988, 0.004245758, 0.02670288, 0.006134033, 0.026779175, 0.012664795, -0.02015686, -0.021057129, 0.04763794, 0.035339355, 0.03845215, 0.053894043, -0.061431885, 0.06896973, 0.043304443, -0.060577393, 0.019195557, -0.028823853, 0.00046229362, -0.012619019, -0.02116394, -0.002248764, 0.010810852, -0.015975952, -0.039154053, -0.00084781647, 0.0024318695, -0.00019490719, 0.017669678, 0.018005371, -0.019317627, 0.06121826, 0.0052375793, 0.037200928, -0.029937744, -0.025253296, 0.029388428, -0.009292603, 0.0024814606, 0.0027618408, 0.018188477, -0.016082764, 0.010047913, -0.013496399, 0.021331787, -0.061035156, -0.021194458, -0.06933594, -0.013290405, 0.004348755, -0.019134521, 0.032592773, -0.0045166016, -0.008369446, 0.07635498, -0.05557251, 0.026275635, 0.03555298, 0.032165527, -0.00856781, 0.030792236, 0.014823914, 0.03878784, 0.02330017 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07217v1
Troubles and Failures in Interactional Language. Towards a Linguistically Informed Taxonomy
Martina Wiltschko
cs.CL
The goal of this talk is to introduce a systematic research agenda which aims to understand the nature of interaction between humans and artificial conversational agents (CA) (henceforth humanmachine interaction, HMI). Specifically, we shall take an explicit linguistic perspective focusing on linguistically defined variables that are known to influence the flow of conversations among humans (henceforth human-human interaction, HHI).
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07217v1
2023-11-13T10:24:51
2023-11-13T10:24:51
{ "title": [ -0.006099701, -0.010559082, -0.010238647, -0.04562378, 0.00090026855, 0.004562378, -0.029083252, -0.025131226, -0.0076293945, 0.02897644, -0.0082473755, 0.010765076, -0.011230469, -0.023071289, -0.04574585, 0.00012791157, -0.015716553, 0.026779175, -0.04144287, -0.038482666, -0.032958984, -0.06518555, 0.03250122, -0.036743164, 0.061767578, -0.05206299, -0.06939697, 0.013122559, -0.017745972, -0.020812988, 0.0061683655, -0.0031013489, 0.035186768, 0.05444336, -0.039245605, -0.03363037, -0.046020508, 0.01763916, -0.016662598, 0.030532837, 0.0068893433, -0.010017395, -0.04837036, -0.010169983, -0.06549072, 0.008262634, -0.055847168, -0.011154175, -0.004547119, 0.029266357, 0.018539429, 0.019683838, -0.0067100525, -0.00023198128, -0.0039711, -0.037506104, -0.014144897, -0.015258789, 0.03010559, 0.07116699, 0.029159546, -0.029754639, 0.00070238113, -0.006134033, -0.02468872, -0.024459839, -0.05090332, 0.047424316, 0.072509766, 0.00756073, -0.018508911, 0.011161804, 0.009506226, 0.0012807846, -0.028503418, 0.027267456, 0.037506104, 0.023391724, 0.031799316, -0.018676758, 0.01184082, -0.002204895, -0.011276245, -0.011146545, 0.011978149, -0.022506714, -0.016311646, -0.018493652, -0.006996155, -0.056427002, 0.007621765, 0.0063438416, -0.010032654, 0.0018882751, -0.026611328, -0.027511597, -0.025390625, 0.025924683, -0.0056991577, -0.031341553, -0.040771484, 0.041290283, -0.07373047, -0.0079193115, 0.019607544, 0.009765625, -0.020065308, -0.0061187744, 0.026733398, 0.04888916, -0.017990112, 0.06762695, 0.016113281, 0.017990112, -0.019805908, -0.008155823, -0.015457153, 0.023483276, 0.0034637451, 0.05456543, -0.018936157, -0.026733398, -0.0060577393, 0.018569946, 0.004386902, -0.0051612854, -0.021438599, 0.00039362907, -0.0004248619, 0.011741638, 0.020370483, 0.0491333, -0.0848999, -0.07159424, -0.064453125, 0.059051514, -0.006198883, -0.012237549, -0.025360107, 0.024856567, 0.00178051, -0.018692017, 0.012512207, -0.008613586, -0.0079956055, 0.0023155212, 0.046661377, 0.005657196, -0.050201416, -0.054260254, 0.008926392, -0.015174866, 0.046936035, 0.013404846, -0.09008789, 0.0032367706, -0.11968994, -0.013893127, 0.0022525787, -0.017211914, 0.0055999756, -0.0008997917, -0.0024299622, 0.00504303, 0.03869629, 0.0063323975, -0.008598328, 0.026809692, 0.012672424, 0.036865234, -0.02268982, 0.021957397, -0.0057907104, -0.002922058, -0.0087890625, -0.0068855286, 0.032348633, -0.0006299019, 0.015655518, -0.007701874, 0.0019836426, -0.01789856, 0.01499176, 0.051818848, -0.059631348, -0.015899658, 0.0076560974, -0.018493652, 0.036468506, 0.006690979, 0.0046958923, 0.06793213, -0.040100098, -0.043945312, -0.050445557, -0.024017334, 0.027404785, 0.016555786, -0.014724731, 0.022109985, -0.02607727, 0.008453369, -0.03326416, -0.007850647, -0.047302246, -0.014221191, -0.021896362, 0.0418396, 0.008735657, 0.061706543, 0.02897644, 0.011421204, -0.04336548, 0.019607544, -0.027282715, -0.061645508, 0.006351471, 0.013877869, 0.012969971, -0.010185242, -0.0231781, -0.022247314, -0.006641388, 0.03970337, -0.0061912537, 0.000022411346, 0.0004968643, -0.022003174, 0.027542114, 0.03186035, 0.040924072, -0.05117798, 0.049804688, 0.031280518, 0.007247925, -0.0049209595, 0.020568848, -0.0054855347, 0.00008672476, -0.009857178, -0.017654419, -0.028320312, -0.011962891, 0.039398193, 0.011550903, -0.031921387, 0.0011997223, 0.037994385, 0.014175415, 0.0009121895, 0.060546875, 0.0008955002, 0.06524658, 0.027313232, 0.0046653748, 0.037139893, -0.026641846, -0.02130127, 0.0025043488, -0.0054893494, 0.026031494, -0.03302002, -0.017059326, 0.005531311, -0.060302734, 0.00340271, -0.039367676, -0.007865906, 0.013168335, 0.004070282, 0.016708374, -0.0637207, 0.015014648, 0.00048041344, 0.004337311, 0.006427765, -0.031021118, 0.014892578, 0.015159607, -0.048583984, -0.009513855, 0.015686035, 0.047210693, 0.0069007874, 0.012268066, 0.0036334991, 0.031143188, 0.00058317184, -0.010810852, -0.027694702, 0.030761719, 0.020065308, -0.0070762634, 0.0028820038, -0.0036678314, -0.018051147, 0.06982422, 0.09515381, -0.04525757, 0.046966553, -0.048034668, 0.011779785, 0.035125732, -0.040039062, 0.013893127, 0.006336212, 0.019607544, 0.031311035, -0.018707275, -0.0059661865, -0.011962891, 0.030517578, 0.006801605, -0.019744873, -0.011795044, -0.027267456, 0.031799316, -0.0062217712, -0.005153656, -0.0073623657, 0.060668945, -0.042999268, -0.015014648, -0.013130188, -0.017547607, -0.0020370483, -0.022964478, -0.023376465, 0.023788452, 0.0132369995, 0.027374268, 0.017669678, -0.059326172, -0.03805542, 0.0018138885, 0.0021762848, -0.018432617, 0.031463623, -0.01977539, 0.0054016113, -0.00010919571, -0.034454346, 0.018814087, -0.032196045, 0.02204895, -0.050079346, 0.023330688, 0.019989014, -0.025909424, 0.0051612854, 0.004688263, -0.025512695, -0.02444458, 0.03250122, 0.07019043, -0.019515991, -0.022003174, 0.058807373, 0.03866577, -0.0047912598, 0.054595947, 0.014045715, 0.026641846, -0.049224854, -0.035186768, -0.050598145, -0.017242432, -0.005558014, -0.022460938, 0.02760315, -0.029510498, -0.052978516, -0.008880615, -0.017349243, 0.0053482056, 0.011528015, -0.033203125, -0.038970947, -0.006011963, -0.035095215, -0.029769897, -0.012039185, -0.018218994, -0.01007843, 0.08282471, -0.012069702, -0.032989502, -0.0032196045, 0.029067993, 0.029525757, -0.012512207, -0.04284668, -0.03878784, 0.004432678, -0.00756073, 0.013122559, -0.030456543, -0.024353027, -0.078552246, 0.004016876, 0.060333252, -0.011695862, -0.03366089, 0.03640747, -0.06518555, 0.03869629, 0.0018119812, -0.00012588501, 0.04348755, 0.049316406, -0.023712158, 0.017303467, -0.010940552, -0.021865845, -0.010902405, -0.012084961, -0.11395264, 0.012565613, -0.0049858093, -0.023208618, -0.009033203, -0.05621338, -0.03894043, 0.014831543, -0.008460999, 0.027923584, 0.038909912, 0.006500244, 0.01360321, -0.031707764, 0.0022068024, -0.020980835, -0.0022411346, 0.0013046265, -0.05609131, -0.010917664, 0.003540039, 0.037200928, 0.05718994, -0.03857422, -0.008384705, 0.0112838745, -0.017807007, 0.026107788, -0.012489319, -0.019363403, 0.012458801, -0.0024433136, -0.038513184, -0.016815186, -0.013038635, 0.023239136, -0.05227661, 0.008583069, -0.006378174, -0.008422852, 0.029830933, 0.009475708, -0.027557373, -0.015510559, -0.008659363, -0.025344849, -0.027008057, -0.015563965, 0.030532837, 0.009803772, 0.018325806, -0.017333984, -0.03250122, 0.034698486, 0.00018405914, -0.01374054, 0.002614975, 0.014205933, -0.008430481, 0.055267334, -0.022781372, -0.00447464, -0.035491943, 0.030715942, -0.011764526, 0.028549194, -0.027618408, -0.091918945, -0.040496826, 0.011405945, -0.13464355, -0.050323486, -0.020126343, -0.056365967, -0.08312988, -0.0031394958, 0.01927185, -0.054016113, -0.023376465, 0.011680603, -0.009056091, -0.036224365, 0.0014696121, -0.06665039, -0.017318726, 0.084350586, -0.038024902, 0.015945435, 0.08703613, -0.025314331, -0.014526367, -0.018005371, 0.03567505, 0.07287598, 0.039764404, 0.02670288, -0.016052246, 0.034973145, -0.030044556, 0.01473999, 0.0435791, -0.010818481, 0.010940552, -0.00027537346, 0.007045746, 0.008773804, 0.011367798, 0.046569824, -0.016174316, 0.0024642944, -0.03829956, 0.0060043335, -0.013938904, 0.0011491776, 0.02406311, 0.0007791519, 0.010238647, -0.0065727234, 0.012008667, 0.053619385, 0.011512756, 0.026641846, 0.03363037, -0.037078857, -0.021362305, -0.0029964447, 0.04296875, -0.011489868, 0.0049095154, 0.018081665, -0.017593384, 0.032287598, -0.014022827, -0.032287598, 0.00089120865, 0.017425537, -0.052093506, 0.0035190582, -0.040527344, -0.09313965, -0.05029297, 0.0070648193, -0.011116028, 0.04711914, 0.029464722, -0.016143799, -0.010803223, 0.005962372, 0.06903076, -0.0024681091, 0.034820557, -0.035980225, 0.0005249977, -0.021560669, -0.07122803, -0.03552246, -0.039855957, -0.017440796, 0.016601562, 0.011154175, -0.016830444, 0.020477295, 0.02079773, 0.061065674, 0.064819336, -0.004814148, -0.049102783, 0.033996582, -0.04940796, -0.029708862, 0.042510986, -0.045654297, -0.009307861, -0.012390137, 0.04067993, -0.020889282, -0.017715454, -0.035461426, 0.03427124, -0.017150879, 0.059661865, 0.009788513, 0.029251099, 0.0259552, -0.0048713684, 0.0012550354, 0.0076065063, -0.04067993, 0.00066137314, 0.009559631, 0.03414917, -0.009376526, -0.0018577576, 0.04260254, 0.01927185, 0.00957489, 0.011779785, -0.01309967, 0.0211792, 0.007293701, 0.0075416565, -0.019378662, -0.06994629, -0.028717041, -0.009437561, -0.009887695, 0.056030273, -0.06390381, 0.06781006, -0.03237915, -0.026000977, 0.025756836, 0.0008993149, 0.020645142, -0.012268066, 0.021102905, -0.036315918, -0.0014810562, 0.046569824, -0.002986908, -0.035095215, 0.019927979, -0.0025253296, 0.010879517, -0.002313614, 0.04901123, 0.017501831, 0.0035247803, 0.03753662, -0.011154175, -0.024230957, -0.028366089, -0.04067993, 0.03024292, -0.017501831, 0.017929077, -0.025054932, 0.007865906, -0.08081055, 0.021835327, -0.0073127747, -0.018310547, 0.010139465, -0.06829834, 0.02470398, 0.08532715, -0.0061531067, 0.043304443, -0.030685425, 0.023498535, 0.017364502, 0.053741455, -0.010810852, 0.033172607, 0.023406982, -0.040283203, -0.0029716492, 0.0022640228, 0.032226562, 0.012519836, 0.03366089, 0.017410278, -0.00504303, -0.042938232, 0.021408081, 0.015197754, -0.0128479, 0.010108948, -0.060302734, 0.020645142, 0.00932312, -0.014717102, 0.016937256, -0.034454346, -0.045043945, -0.026489258, -0.019439697, -0.061920166, 0.016921997, -0.006713867, -0.046691895, -0.052703857, 0.022109985, 0.003774643, 0.011123657, -0.0037345886, -0.009178162, -0.04663086, 0.023361206, 0.030914307, -0.0440979, 0.029525757, -0.04171753, -0.011131287, 0.057037354, 0.0657959, -0.022079468, 0.0048980713, -0.020370483, -0.041625977, -0.01638794, 0.016799927, 0.0050086975, 0.014884949, -0.009376526, -0.04458618, -0.03262329, 0.013931274, 0.024658203, -0.022979736, -0.027786255, 0.015640259, 0.022338867, 0.017288208, -0.0010471344, 0.043395996, -0.022140503, 0.014144897, 0.014762878, -0.002204895, 0.04446411, -0.017745972, 0.01625061, -0.0138168335, -0.04208374, 0.011756897, 0.00957489, -0.0049209595, -0.023773193, 0.009681702, 0.03225708, 0.041870117, -0.044403076, -0.016036987, 0.0385437, -0.015792847, -0.025253296, -0.026885986, -0.012771606, -0.06347656, 0.059173584, 0.0068626404, -0.023284912, -0.045440674, -0.049072266, -0.030639648, 0.0040397644, 0.0026607513, 0.00944519, 0.0022449493, -0.010696411, 0.040863037, -0.013687134, 0.0044403076, -0.015655518, 0.021575928, 0.01953125, 0.00920105, -0.04385376, 0.016143799, 0.0032691956, -0.024917603, 0.015655518, 0.04083252, 0.0019798279, 0.02633667, -0.097595215, 0.0068359375, -0.024810791, -0.030029297, 0.043884277, -0.008934021, 0.001698494, 0.05078125, -0.05029297, 0.026046753, 0.029205322, 0.055358887, 0.021240234, 0.004299164, 0.03982544, 0.0049743652, 0.022003174, -0.03250122, -0.01537323, -0.035583496, -0.009002686, -0.042877197, 0.004386902, -0.049346924, 0.012611389, -0.0042762756, 0.0035743713, 0.016937256, 0.004776001, 0.028198242, 0.003616333, 0.027908325, -0.0034885406, 0.027297974, -0.0149002075, -0.016082764, 0.000011205673, 0.018051147, 0.024780273, 0.043701172, 0.01725769, -0.008773804, -0.032287598, -0.029251099, 0.0044174194, 0.02810669, 0.00048613548, 0.0021305084, -0.010292053, -0.030212402, 0.03665161, 0.0000410676, 0.038085938, 0.048736572, 0.04071045, 0.010437012, -0.018066406, -0.0009288788, -0.03805542, -0.012809753, -0.032226562, 0.015098572, -0.06781006, 0.024520874, -0.0033397675, -0.01499176, -0.018234253, 0.025939941, 0.035064697, -0.05392456, -0.034484863, 0.009521484, 0.051605225, -0.005077362, 0.052520752, -0.027008057, -0.021026611, -0.0009083748, 0.032470703, -0.0079956055, 0.02268982, 0.02319336, 0.023956299, -0.02166748, -0.052124023, 0.0063323975, 0.005958557, -0.025482178, 0.027694702, 0.010215759, 0.017791748, -0.030090332, -0.050231934, 0.0058059692, -0.019226074, -0.050201416, -0.033569336, 0.021484375, 0.0032291412, 0.011993408, 0.052215576, 0.01348114, -0.0140686035, -0.041168213, -0.033447266, 0.025405884, 0.0385437, -0.020202637, 0.03173828, -0.044158936, -0.03994751, 0.03933716, -0.025115967, 0.08648682, -0.049926758, -0.0042648315, -0.010093689, 0.023483276, 0.025283813, -0.038330078, -0.0178833, -0.010536194, -0.037017822, -0.0077667236, 0.031921387, -0.02734375, 0.009681702, -0.0063095093, -0.02357483, 0.00447464, 0.018600464, -0.0075531006, -0.03543091, -0.056793213, 0.023529053, -0.013221741, 0.044403076, -0.03778076, -0.018371582, -0.02897644, 0.0023822784, 0.0093688965, -0.0030765533, -0.016448975, -0.013313293, -0.037322998, -0.011123657, 0.0066871643, 0.016921997, -0.015083313, -0.010414124, 0.020843506, 0.0056915283, -0.011207581, 0.0041770935, 0.006198883, -0.032196045, -0.036102295, -0.018310547, -0.005970001, 0.010147095, 0.024398804, -0.002412796, 0.019607544, 0.023223877, -0.011375427, -0.024841309, 0.014137268, 0.019927979, 0.003528595, -0.04449463, 0.0037136078, 0.023925781, 0.035064697, -0.06439209, -0.081970215, 0.016143799, 0.050445557, 0.008674622, 0.04144287, 0.0345459, -0.013885498, -0.025360107, -0.011329651, -0.003206253, -0.033294678, -0.0035057068, 0.0007214546, 0.030029297, 0.046813965, -0.0003182888, -0.022720337, 0.00856781, 0.006164551, 0.024261475, 0.015556335, -0.015014648, 0.030929565, -0.015411377, 0.03845215, -0.015945435, -0.006374359, -0.076049805, 0.015403748, 0.000117599964, 0.04055786, -0.01600647, 0.033325195, 0.014801025, 0.083496094, -0.033325195, -0.062805176, 0.05114746, 0.042053223, -0.0014810562, 0.065979004, -0.013053894, -0.018096924, 0.004917145, -0.008872986, -0.0019607544, 0.007003784, 0.020202637, -0.028076172, -0.005744934, -0.030532837, -0.034698486, -0.03161621, -0.032226562, 0.04031372, -0.0056991577, -0.00025177002, -0.0022907257, -0.02619934, -0.012069702, 0.05493164, -0.009170532, -0.04522705, -0.028411865, 0.025894165, 0.0715332, -0.018493652 ], "summary": [ -0.005126953, -0.008323669, -0.024353027, -0.009246826, -0.027282715, -0.022201538, -0.010665894, -0.0019102097, 0.0011997223, 0.016815186, -0.005115509, 0.00062179565, 0.028274536, -0.05307007, 0.017929077, -0.008255005, -0.0049934387, 0.012886047, -0.006752014, -0.03048706, 0.009475708, -0.029083252, -0.005367279, -0.050842285, 0.06762695, -0.05206299, -0.10961914, 0.020843506, 0.023376465, 0.015312195, 0.023513794, 0.0017061234, -0.00046014786, 0.02470398, -0.04309082, -0.017654419, 0.0046310425, -0.0019464493, -0.012504578, 0.015029907, 0.016082764, -0.010673523, 0.009002686, -0.0057678223, -0.03277588, -0.014709473, 0.00029540062, -0.00868988, 0.030166626, -0.021331787, -0.019104004, -0.0018987656, 0.005882263, -0.030395508, -0.03918457, -0.04901123, -0.0044937134, -0.08972168, 0.030029297, 0.024353027, 0.025466919, -0.04699707, 0.032836914, -0.0054626465, -0.010665894, -0.008369446, -0.00737381, 0.008666992, -0.033294678, -0.01474762, 0.04257202, -0.021347046, 0.008605957, -0.0059318542, -0.035461426, 0.029693604, 0.007801056, 0.03326416, 0.022583008, -0.00390625, 0.017822266, 0.0053138733, -0.014656067, -0.02796936, 0.012229919, -0.01927185, 0.0025939941, -0.009307861, -0.02722168, 0.011604309, -0.026657104, 0.027053833, -0.015838623, 0.009399414, -0.023925781, 0.009613037, -0.016921997, -0.007522583, 0.0491333, 0.032043457, -0.022384644, -0.015686035, 0.0014028549, -0.01977539, 0.015258789, 0.050750732, -0.016662598, 0.025512695, 0.053741455, 0.016143799, 0.014633179, 0.02758789, 0.03643799, 0.016616821, -0.018508911, -0.045074463, -0.0071029663, 0.04034424, -0.0037269592, 0.030517578, -0.014282227, 0.015563965, -0.020431519, 0.039398193, 0.009460449, 0.048461914, 0.025665283, -0.044036865, -0.018615723, 0.03918457, 0.0048675537, -0.0069732666, -0.021774292, 0.012901306, -0.019104004, -0.010536194, -0.015258789, -0.06689453, -0.0049705505, 0.023483276, -0.006706238, -0.030319214, 0.035980225, 0.013458252, -0.054595947, 0.02255249, 0.008422852, 0.0072898865, -0.016738892, 0.0013580322, -0.0619812, -0.021255493, 0.0049476624, 0.006198883, -0.01701355, -0.00064229965, -0.058563232, 0.0070343018, 0.029830933, 0.010871887, 0.03186035, 0.003282547, 0.016098022, 0.029953003, 0.027175903, -0.014526367, -0.040740967, 0.014381409, 0.017410278, -0.033477783, 0.03894043, 0.04220581, 0.019195557, -0.025741577, -0.0027503967, -0.02798462, -0.034729004, -0.048461914, 0.0013275146, 0.07672119, 0.015167236, -0.018920898, -0.07110596, 0.053588867, -0.050598145, 0.040618896, 0.003271103, 0.013458252, 0.007850647, -0.008407593, 0.02192688, 0.06561279, -0.043884277, -0.02281189, -0.0284729, -0.027938843, 0.011566162, -0.02671814, -0.0102005005, 0.067871094, 0.021987915, -0.015975952, -0.0072402954, -0.041870117, -0.10266113, -0.017074585, -0.03475952, 0.03161621, 0.042785645, 0.024887085, -0.005718231, -0.019454956, 0.007217407, -0.026809692, -0.029083252, 0.009361267, -0.026367188, -0.002658844, -0.0053367615, 0.0010643005, 0.009963989, 0.004383087, -0.0031223297, 0.031311035, -0.036834717, 0.032409668, -0.018249512, 0.037994385, 0.00039315224, 0.05041504, 0.017913818, -0.03982544, 0.038909912, 0.05770874, 0.005794525, 0.021881104, 0.05102539, -0.024612427, -0.0033473969, -0.0035552979, 0.022247314, -0.017547607, -0.010231018, 0.008491516, 0.014961243, -0.034332275, 0.014984131, 0.009429932, -0.016998291, -0.016189575, 0.034423828, 0.0004298687, 0.037384033, 0.040771484, -0.016281128, 0.022460938, -0.026504517, -0.072265625, -0.028030396, 0.012168884, 0.048431396, -0.06109619, -0.064575195, 0.01486969, -0.00021409988, -0.046020508, -0.018508911, -0.032470703, -0.000521183, -0.02734375, 0.02166748, -0.028518677, 0.008857727, 0.0044555664, -0.007835388, -0.017852783, -0.0009403229, -0.004463196, 0.01727295, -0.019363403, 0.002023697, 0.0151901245, 0.016021729, -0.008140564, 0.041900635, -0.0032806396, 0.0013208389, -0.023757935, 0.000091314316, 0.068481445, 0.0524292, 0.051696777, 0.0024757385, 0.0075950623, -0.033325195, 0.040100098, -0.027633667, 0.025482178, 0.008163452, -0.0043754578, -0.045135498, 0.03289795, 0.0041160583, 0.019424438, 0.002614975, 0.0012216568, -0.0034694672, 0.014984131, 0.0074386597, -0.0068969727, -0.02330017, 0.03982544, 0.0098724365, -0.0058135986, -0.0041770935, -0.028396606, -0.012565613, 0.016815186, -0.042816162, 0.014038086, 0.10070801, -0.02468872, -0.0028362274, -0.034118652, -0.026779175, -0.03302002, -0.011199951, -0.020645142, -0.005279541, -0.009887695, 0.01084137, -0.0010738373, -0.018981934, -0.005809784, 0.013221741, -0.0023918152, 0.013580322, 0.013008118, 0.008293152, -0.03265381, 0.022949219, 0.0029754639, -0.013168335, 0.01058197, -0.030975342, -0.005531311, 0.05859375, -0.012931824, 0.0059928894, 0.031829834, -0.011352539, -0.015213013, -0.005619049, 0.013717651, 0.019088745, 0.004863739, 0.005290985, 0.044158936, 0.028900146, -0.008728027, 0.07373047, 0.029342651, 0.027191162, -0.09741211, -0.037261963, -0.02418518, -0.008575439, -0.0357666, 0.004535675, 0.011581421, -0.04574585, 0.027908325, -0.0058174133, -0.012580872, -0.006969452, 0.024978638, 0.042816162, 0.0011386871, -0.011207581, 0.010345459, 0.022735596, 0.0031051636, 0.01852417, -0.015899658, 0.11004639, -0.022994995, -0.006801605, 0.017913818, 0.053222656, 0.038513184, -0.015449524, -0.08093262, -0.024215698, -0.055725098, -0.010444641, 0.010498047, -0.012969971, 0.06530762, 0.018157959, -0.038269043, 0.0022296906, 0.011726379, -0.01210022, 0.044647217, -0.06085205, 0.06124878, -0.009750366, -0.0023651123, 0.03942871, -0.026947021, -0.0027580261, -0.021728516, 0.00121212, -0.029815674, -0.019012451, -0.020141602, -0.004016876, -0.026473999, 0.05050659, -0.0121154785, -0.0056533813, -0.0597229, -0.0016527176, 0.02432251, -0.022521973, 0.090148926, -0.022781372, 0.00920105, -0.0044555664, 0.02078247, 0.02116394, 0.011878967, -0.0052261353, 0.00021445751, -0.039794922, 0.012428284, 0.0076065063, -0.00016319752, 0.042785645, -0.046051025, -0.07904053, 0.019332886, 0.030471802, -0.032714844, -0.0024986267, 0.0021972656, 0.051757812, -0.027770996, -0.06237793, -0.014099121, -0.014183044, 0.031280518, -0.0135269165, 0.025924683, 0.0062942505, 0.02848816, 0.010139465, 0.024475098, 0.031280518, 0.007484436, -0.01725769, -0.00141716, 0.014831543, -0.010925293, 0.0637207, 0.00016212463, 0.006511688, 0.013061523, -0.010757446, 0.031097412, 0.0770874, -0.078430176, -0.035125732, -0.019042969, 0.00047588348, -0.0035171509, 0.017669678, -0.021118164, 0.07196045, 0.0057907104, -0.02180481, 0.027770996, 0.0151901245, -0.12194824, -0.056396484, 0.024154663, -0.13977051, -0.08868408, -0.015426636, -0.051879883, -0.050750732, 0.02571106, 0.02684021, -0.038635254, 0.003604889, -0.04852295, -0.011047363, 0.008140564, 0.004650116, -0.012687683, -0.02027893, -0.012260437, -0.024856567, -0.011375427, 0.042938232, 0.014266968, 0.0020751953, 0.029296875, 0.016830444, 0.047058105, -0.020599365, 0.010475159, -0.05090332, 0.023620605, -0.022644043, 0.015945435, 0.018692017, -0.04260254, 0.012245178, 0.013572693, 0.01612854, 0.056640625, -0.023483276, 0.016983032, 0.041290283, -0.018295288, -0.03668213, 0.023651123, -0.013534546, -0.039093018, 0.01789856, 0.07067871, 0.010665894, 0.015281677, -0.020324707, -0.044708252, -0.0099487305, 0.011276245, 0.038635254, 0.013870239, -0.010345459, -0.018722534, 0.0042495728, 0.019165039, -0.0084991455, 0.0057678223, -0.022872925, 0.04095459, -0.0015707016, 0.02911377, -0.0019159317, -0.0104904175, 0.0031833649, -0.007183075, -0.0023822784, -0.097595215, -0.044403076, 0.011001587, 0.011138916, 0.051208496, -0.0033340454, 0.020217896, 0.05215454, -0.046844482, 0.10699463, 0.020248413, -0.035247803, -0.052612305, -0.048736572, -0.0074043274, -0.06390381, -0.015991211, -0.07672119, -0.07324219, -0.013633728, -0.0023002625, -0.03274536, 0.045135498, -0.02029419, 0.037506104, 0.078308105, -0.018630981, -0.07507324, 0.049102783, -0.07342529, 0.048706055, 0.02407837, -0.022842407, -0.036224365, -0.0061798096, 0.0496521, 0.021102905, 0.003932953, 0.03744507, -0.003408432, 0.00484848, 0.0024471283, -0.070007324, 0.04019165, -0.010803223, -0.027023315, -0.0076560974, -0.009994507, -0.043701172, 0.07324219, 0.015945435, 0.017868042, -0.043945312, 0.021835327, 0.01802063, -0.0008816719, -0.0256958, -0.008018494, 0.03250122, 0.003856659, -0.036956787, -0.026992798, 0.002855301, 0.0104904175, -0.0059890747, 0.011520386, 0.005783081, 0.021942139, -0.0030670166, 0.017990112, -0.057800293, -0.043823242, -0.027252197, 0.0017557144, 0.035064697, 0.012283325, 0.02619934, -0.007572174, -0.0070381165, 0.03475952, 0.04196167, -0.0236969, -0.0051498413, -0.07598877, -0.010513306, 0.0073661804, 0.03942871, 0.00011110306, -0.04660034, 0.033416748, -0.024124146, -0.029327393, -0.00092220306, -0.021728516, -0.0057373047, -0.04486084, -0.00044369698, 0.023422241, -0.00030088425, -0.02180481, 0.023223877, -0.04144287, -0.013580322, 0.041137695, 0.0008702278, -0.044311523, 0.056762695, -0.044067383, 0.039794922, 0.0074653625, -0.0050735474, 0.022079468, 0.019577026, -0.016189575, -0.0071868896, -0.01739502, 0.016708374, 0.020355225, -0.054779053, -0.010116577, 0.07269287, -0.004058838, 0.032409668, 0.0546875, -0.017807007, 0.0002553463, -0.028045654, -0.01525116, -0.015182495, 0.000029861927, 0.01739502, 0.040405273, 0.0004916191, 0.0022010803, 0.0063667297, -0.038269043, -0.020614624, 0.010635376, -0.048095703, -0.05130005, -0.025726318, -0.023910522, -0.047302246, 0.0038337708, -0.015045166, 0.014846802, -0.012519836, 0.011390686, -0.024887085, 0.014541626, 0.023239136, -0.034332275, 0.009140015, 0.0018844604, -0.0059280396, 0.0039596558, 0.04269409, -0.023803711, -0.006061554, -0.027679443, -0.015556335, -0.017105103, -0.020965576, -0.018920898, 0.04937744, -0.026779175, -0.04574585, -0.032165527, 0.014305115, 0.011558533, -0.014785767, -0.043823242, 0.008178711, -0.017852783, -0.019195557, -0.0043754578, 0.043518066, 0.002380371, -0.006790161, -0.008468628, 0.013175964, 0.045959473, -0.0006699562, 0.0019798279, 0.039886475, -0.011917114, 0.026992798, 0.012840271, -0.0021877289, 0.01083374, -0.02947998, 0.008277893, 0.009124756, -0.0059432983, -0.013076782, 0.0552063, -0.025726318, -0.05267334, -0.042663574, 0.017425537, -0.06488037, -0.050811768, 0.030090332, -0.023544312, 0.032318115, -0.03805542, -0.006412506, 0.0037899017, 0.02368164, 0.019348145, 0.030853271, 0.006626129, 0.015007019, 0.043304443, 0.018463135, -0.005168915, 0.0027751923, 0.035003662, 0.06585693, -0.051483154, 0.05203247, -0.03439331, 0.030197144, 0.011550903, 0.01386261, -0.0028209686, 0.022583008, 0.025634766, -0.010116577, -0.016403198, -0.0041503906, 0.0022621155, 0.03805542, -0.03024292, 0.018997192, -0.021362305, 0.037628174, 0.009056091, 0.041900635, 0.010971069, 0.023895264, 0.034484863, -0.0013141632, 0.033294678, -0.014129639, 0.0018320084, -0.015556335, -0.020187378, 0.002243042, -0.0309906, 0.0015211105, 0.007789612, 0.018112183, -0.0541687, 0.03414917, -0.022369385, 0.0067443848, 0.014625549, -0.047973633, -0.007587433, -0.05441284, -0.012176514, -0.023712158, 0.0040779114, 0.015792847, 0.0041007996, 0.038024902, 0.037109375, -0.015640259, -0.034423828, 0.013633728, 0.029418945, -0.026168823, -0.01574707, -0.017242432, 0.010818481, -0.0395813, 0.02166748, 0.03237915, 0.02116394, -0.006893158, 0.02458191, 0.010368347, 0.012527466, 0.020935059, 0.009117126, -0.0096588135, 0.0003581047, -0.010795593, 0.026107788, 0.017028809, 0.012397766, -0.026031494, -0.023880005, 0.029586792, 0.06274414, -0.014724731, 0.028961182, 0.017654419, 0.009902954, -0.050811768, 0.04699707, -0.033477783, 0.017410278, -0.014060974, -0.048553467, 0.0206604, -0.028961182, 0.021591187, 0.0053901672, -0.022781372, -0.003189087, -0.023406982, -0.003025055, -0.026687622, 0.027359009, -0.03111267, -0.0012607574, -0.007801056, -0.027618408, 0.025878906, -0.010734558, 0.019332886, 0.005168915, 0.016189575, 0.01965332, -0.0031280518, 0.029144287, -0.040130615, 0.010513306, 0.007858276, 0.012802124, 0.04623413, -0.011566162, -0.0001705885, 0.012969971, -0.003358841, 0.01235199, 0.030914307, 0.02407837, 0.035369873, -0.04257202, -0.013557434, -0.030776978, 0.046539307, -0.03729248, -0.009063721, -0.039520264, -0.036468506, -0.029006958, 0.02923584, 0.054534912, -0.03579712, 0.012130737, -0.019927979, -0.03491211, -0.0127334595, -0.009468079, 0.023971558, -0.02041626, -0.013793945, 0.009750366, 0.010971069, 0.037475586, -0.025283813, -0.030059814, -0.0006723404, 0.036254883, 0.0046958923, -0.035888672, -0.020690918, 0.046966553, 0.005256653, -0.008834839, 0.02557373, 0.05697632, -0.0037326813, -0.023391724, -0.009124756, 0.000114917755, -0.018432617, -0.0113220215, 0.008522034, 0.05001831, -0.07989502, -0.013282776, -0.0087509155, -0.06512451, -0.03945923, -0.00006687641, -0.037078857, 0.050231934, -0.048217773, -0.038726807, -0.017074585, 0.012634277, 0.010650635, -0.023864746, 0.004272461, -0.035614014, -0.00223732, -0.045898438, -0.05496216, -0.017425537, 0.05267334, 0.030288696, -0.0099487305, -0.021728516, -0.021469116, 0.010505676, -0.03729248, 0.006916046, -0.0077209473, 0.034210205, 0.08508301, 0.0690918, 0.015823364, -0.04864502, 0.050476074, -0.036132812, -0.07727051, -0.01083374, -0.032928467, 0.043151855, -0.0009918213, -0.0065727234, 0.031158447, -0.04800415, 0.034362793, -0.035339355, 0.027740479, -0.039154053, -0.058685303, 0.031982422, -0.0008459091, -0.035705566, 0.029144287, 0.00086164474, -0.018005371, 0.014564514, 0.017349243, 0.017105103, -0.013282776, 0.016952515, -0.017547607, 0.010635376, 0.023895264, 0.029418945, 0.061798096, 0.006538391, -0.00881958, 0.0072250366, -0.09991455, 0.000436306, -0.08709717, -0.022750854, 0.019500732, 0.038726807, -0.021316528, 0.036346436, -0.029006958, -0.0013628006, 0.0019741058, -0.051818848, -0.022262573, -0.008972168, 0.056854248, -0.02897644, 0.01008606 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07215v1
Coffee: Boost Your Code LLMs by Fixing Bugs with Feedback
Seungjun Moon, Yongho Song, Hyungjoo Chae, Dongjin Kang, Taeyoon Kwon, Kai Tzu-iunn Ong, Seung-won Hwang, Jinyoung Yeo
cs.CL, cs.SE
Code editing is an essential step towards reliable program synthesis to automatically correct critical errors generated from code LLMs. Recent studies have demonstrated that closed-source LLMs (i.e., ChatGPT and GPT-4) are capable of generating corrective feedback to edit erroneous inputs. However, it remains challenging for open-source code LLMs to generate feedback for code editing, since these models tend to adhere to the superficial formats of feedback and provide feedback with misleading information. Hence, the focus of our work is to leverage open-source code LLMs to generate helpful feedback with correct guidance for code editing. To this end, we present Coffee, a collected dataset specifically designed for code fixing with feedback. Using this dataset, we construct CoffeePots, a framework for COde Fixing with FEEdback via Preference-Optimized Tuning and Selection. The proposed framework aims to automatically generate helpful feedback for code editing while minimizing the potential risk of superficial feedback. The combination of Coffee and CoffeePots marks a significant advancement, achieving state-of-the-art performance on HumanEvalFix benchmark. Codes and model checkpoints are publicly available at https://github.com/Lune-Blue/COFFEE.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07215v1
2023-11-13T10:15:19
2023-11-13T10:15:19
{ "title": [ -0.03756714, -0.044647217, -0.043701172, -0.04232788, -0.034332275, -0.0024795532, -0.032836914, 0.028442383, -0.027679443, -0.004207611, -0.038391113, 0.021621704, -0.0019779205, -0.037750244, 0.018539429, -0.051513672, -0.0003607273, 0.009567261, -0.012237549, -0.029815674, 0.0037612915, -0.058807373, 0.016479492, 0.00020039082, -0.00024843216, 0.04714966, -0.036224365, -0.04748535, -0.0132751465, -0.044006348, 0.0045433044, 0.029525757, 0.028793335, 0.009185791, -0.012107849, 0.05432129, -0.0067443848, 0.007587433, 0.0001629591, 0.036590576, 0.030410767, -0.013221741, -0.049438477, -0.0017929077, -0.04119873, -0.0038051605, -0.0126953125, -0.012466431, 0.014625549, 0.0021953583, 0.01537323, 0.03866577, 0.021728516, 0.04208374, -0.00504303, 0.008911133, -0.0013923645, -0.025878906, 0.008995056, 0.033599854, 0.008903503, -0.014770508, 0.022766113, -0.023712158, -0.015838623, 0.0003876686, -0.06878662, 0.016479492, 0.06695557, 0.0050811768, -0.03555298, -0.0017147064, -0.0015325546, 0.04119873, -0.010673523, -0.06512451, 0.070739746, 0.028823853, -0.008331299, 0.0413208, 0.013595581, -0.005088806, 0.056274414, -0.027786255, 0.014137268, -0.0048294067, -0.020126343, -0.003396988, -0.007411957, -0.028869629, -0.026733398, 0.012962341, -0.03955078, 0.01965332, -0.017623901, -0.0149002075, 0.030044556, 0.044799805, 0.0027046204, -0.026916504, -0.033477783, -0.00920105, -0.047088623, -0.0046195984, 0.00070524216, 0.014457703, 0.019180298, -0.014137268, 0.0049209595, 0.030227661, -0.029724121, 0.031066895, 0.012664795, -0.06414795, 0.022445679, 0.004398346, -0.010940552, 0.06149292, 0.037963867, 0.008346558, 0.018508911, 0.03677368, -0.010597229, -0.0368042, 0.01574707, -0.0036029816, -0.022415161, -0.008834839, 0.011978149, -0.0062332153, -0.007926941, 0.07336426, -0.05697632, -0.062316895, -0.064697266, 0.023483276, -0.010116577, 0.014434814, 0.013183594, 0.014877319, -0.0014562607, -0.010108948, 0.06616211, 0.008766174, -0.008277893, -0.0036067963, 0.027160645, 0.012840271, -0.003019333, -0.02319336, -0.01197052, 0.04953003, -0.029449463, 0.007827759, 0.028427124, 0.0211792, -0.049041748, 0.024459839, 0.031677246, 0.04724121, 0.025772095, 0.0031738281, 0.0010156631, 0.023895264, -0.020141602, 0.0019607544, -0.015853882, -0.002986908, 0.021942139, 0.057434082, -0.049835205, -0.022781372, 0.04067993, 0.012451172, -0.02545166, 0.031707764, 0.021621704, 0.04156494, 0.03869629, -0.041412354, -0.026992798, -0.03930664, 0.060028076, -0.018447876, -0.0054397583, -0.04812622, 0.011154175, -0.0009384155, 0.022628784, 0.00052928925, 0.014053345, 0.00015497208, -0.012397766, -0.05026245, -0.038391113, -0.017990112, 0.02671814, 0.019256592, -0.022460938, 0.03778076, -0.07647705, 0.025802612, -0.01651001, 0.03451538, 0.013877869, -0.0033550262, 0.012786865, 0.0317688, 0.0026512146, 0.05883789, 0.018173218, 0.004878998, -0.024658203, -0.000054955482, -0.024246216, -0.056396484, 0.01486969, -0.01285553, 0.024475098, -0.033111572, 0.018630981, 0.03250122, -0.002544403, 0.020187378, 0.018051147, 0.057281494, -0.037200928, 0.029953003, 0.04434204, 0.039520264, 0.027664185, -0.010223389, 0.041046143, 0.016738892, -0.02420044, 0.0038814545, 0.04562378, -0.067993164, 0.010551453, 0.03527832, 0.02746582, -0.044281006, 0.011161804, 0.014175415, 0.08770752, 0.040496826, 0.030593872, -0.0064048767, 0.03579712, 0.043518066, -0.0524292, 0.03086853, 0.056365967, 0.031204224, -0.0056533813, 0.082214355, -0.010787964, 0.01197052, -0.08068848, 0.042785645, -0.0006456375, 0.042419434, 0.0040245056, 0.007205963, -0.03652954, 0.01940918, -0.025146484, 0.014953613, -0.027557373, 0.015129089, 0.03579712, 0.0059165955, 0.01927185, 0.016967773, -0.0012350082, 0.029251099, -0.024841309, 0.008346558, 0.03048706, -0.011993408, -0.0077934265, 0.03479004, 0.05899048, -0.023925781, 0.023284912, 0.027938843, 0.01675415, -0.062927246, -0.026733398, 0.04107666, 0.038208008, 0.029647827, -0.0058555603, -0.0016374588, 0.06359863, 0.008880615, 0.089782715, 0.085754395, -0.038482666, 0.05166626, -0.062438965, 0.002073288, 0.057922363, -0.059509277, 0.014587402, -0.018005371, 0.016082764, -0.012489319, -0.011314392, 0.009048462, -0.047302246, 0.008018494, 0.014160156, 0.06451416, -0.019012451, -0.041046143, -0.005657196, 0.025344849, -0.044708252, -0.07910156, 0.021636963, -0.017349243, -0.017578125, 0.0054473877, -0.0025501251, -0.009941101, 0.007095337, -0.016082764, 0.023025513, -0.033325195, -0.0076446533, -0.028549194, -0.050567627, 0.002878189, 0.020858765, 0.0017271042, 0.025009155, -0.011123657, -0.0031490326, -0.03765869, -0.004753113, -0.030548096, -0.0385437, -0.024337769, 0.033233643, -0.013938904, -0.031311035, -0.002620697, -0.027328491, 0.012145996, -0.03100586, -0.009300232, -0.0023670197, 0.014549255, 0.04031372, -0.0491333, -0.017944336, 0.03543091, -0.0053253174, -0.019638062, 0.02571106, 0.016845703, -0.006801605, -0.027755737, 0.0047302246, -0.03640747, -0.05206299, 0.015716553, 0.006542206, 0.023391724, 0.006706238, -0.016967773, 0.024673462, -0.0029582977, -0.01574707, -0.04019165, 0.013145447, -0.039123535, -0.016830444, -0.0038375854, -0.007850647, -0.01525116, 0.016052246, -0.012817383, 0.08544922, -0.010528564, -0.018829346, 0.04425049, 0.0075683594, 0.011390686, -0.045715332, -0.034851074, -0.0317688, -0.0022449493, 0.03604126, 0.0076560974, -0.040863037, 0.03338623, -0.10760498, 0.009422302, 0.072021484, -0.00548172, 0.0024547577, 0.031219482, -0.08062744, 0.09075928, -0.015457153, 0.02911377, 0.01687622, 0.01335907, -0.0024318695, -0.06726074, 0.010505676, -0.07507324, 0.021575928, -0.015792847, -0.115356445, 0.0087890625, -0.052215576, 0.032928467, 0.017120361, -0.011047363, -0.029251099, 0.011444092, -0.011497498, -0.0019102097, 0.026794434, 0.017807007, 0.019546509, 0.009521484, 0.011871338, -0.03656006, 0.00095796585, -0.032592773, -0.025115967, 0.01751709, -0.006175995, 0.046783447, 0.0054969788, -0.0069503784, -0.03744507, -0.021896362, 0.008613586, -0.02507019, 0.01335907, -0.0413208, -0.011314392, -0.007850647, -0.03451538, 0.012573242, -0.010253906, -0.0017461777, -0.032104492, 0.01751709, -0.015945435, 0.0970459, 0.034454346, 0.02180481, 0.00049877167, -0.03604126, -0.03390503, -0.013343811, -0.038269043, -0.03387451, -0.012756348, -0.03161621, 0.02041626, 0.0079422, -0.011238098, -0.012359619, -0.022415161, 0.06298828, 0.017700195, -0.0084991455, 0.011795044, -0.027404785, 0.0042495728, 0.021255493, -0.023239136, -0.016281128, 0.036956787, 0.0066337585, 0.013542175, -0.013557434, -0.032165527, 0.023483276, -0.10095215, -0.072753906, 0.012229919, -0.011474609, -0.03277588, -0.017089844, 0.043304443, -0.039916992, -0.014221191, 0.01171875, -0.010307312, 0.07507324, 0.036987305, -0.019561768, 0.003643036, -0.017700195, -0.056030273, -0.031082153, 0.06915283, 0.008934021, -0.044830322, 0.023254395, 0.01335144, 0.052825928, -0.00080919266, 0.00038170815, 0.029022217, 0.010185242, -0.02268982, 0.032684326, -0.008010864, -0.059814453, 0.0046844482, 0.045166016, 0.0022354126, 0.00007802248, -0.040740967, 0.037384033, 0.04751587, 0.009246826, -0.07434082, -0.008514404, 0.031097412, -0.04473877, -0.009170532, -0.003929138, 0.004283905, 0.05050659, 0.0021343231, 0.03414917, -0.029190063, -0.02255249, -0.018707275, -0.008995056, -0.014854431, -0.027770996, -0.025100708, 0.018920898, -0.0063819885, 0.006591797, 0.019332886, 0.05078125, 0.017166138, 0.0053596497, -0.008224487, 0.001033783, -0.02835083, 0.00060606, -0.014511108, -0.029647827, -0.056152344, 0.016479492, 0.014213562, 0.029251099, 0.01373291, -0.017929077, 0.002708435, -0.010108948, -0.010566711, 0.017501831, 0.021087646, -0.03164673, -0.034423828, 0.0015974045, -0.11804199, -0.047180176, -0.080566406, -0.01210022, -0.013343811, 0.022094727, -0.011917114, 0.033813477, -0.021408081, 0.030181885, 0.015388489, 0.018630981, -0.03125, 0.026855469, 0.0069274902, 0.022750854, -0.017822266, 0.047302246, -0.0018720627, -0.020812988, -0.038635254, -0.0093307495, -0.028289795, -0.035949707, 0.07006836, 0.029830933, 0.025421143, -0.043762207, 0.0040397644, 0.022323608, -0.006641388, -0.021453857, -0.023590088, -0.02053833, 0.031677246, -0.0042266846, 0.04660034, -0.007347107, -0.0025100708, -0.03475952, 0.014923096, 0.00472641, -0.0129470825, 0.0127334595, -0.022567749, 0.0014419556, 0.013954163, 0.02444458, -0.011444092, -0.021743774, -0.008659363, 0.00374794, 0.018493652, -0.039978027, 0.002506256, -0.023666382, -0.002008438, 0.004333496, -0.020980835, -0.019500732, 0.01083374, -0.0023174286, -0.0054855347, 0.0070648193, 0.025985718, -0.02709961, -0.0020160675, -0.03717041, 0.023483276, 0.06021118, 0.045166016, -0.009521484, -0.012458801, -0.03894043, -0.0023612976, 0.0040245056, -0.0053482056, 0.004108429, -0.03527832, -0.03451538, -0.013008118, 0.01940918, -0.011764526, 0.0039520264, -0.021102905, -0.02279663, -0.0011997223, 0.016159058, 0.0017385483, 0.001121521, 0.0058174133, 0.044281006, -0.039215088, 0.0146865845, 0.047851562, 0.019943237, 0.0001090765, 0.028717041, 0.0026397705, 0.012687683, 0.008079529, -0.06951904, -0.013130188, -0.0032444, 0.032073975, -0.016113281, 0.03857422, 0.022598267, -0.011497498, -0.053741455, 0.03656006, 0.025100708, -0.0016088486, 0.024612427, -0.047332764, 0.032318115, -0.080200195, 0.0015077591, -0.00945282, -0.0362854, -0.046569824, 0.0132751465, -0.022003174, 0.004142761, 0.009056091, -0.019744873, -0.016815186, 0.0045204163, 0.018218994, -0.00957489, 0.039764404, 0.010879517, -0.036010742, -0.02407837, 0.006778717, -0.009727478, -0.023483276, 0.01763916, -0.012535095, -0.024261475, 0.012504578, 0.07702637, -0.012031555, -0.013961792, -0.035339355, -0.031677246, -0.024459839, -0.0030403137, -0.02520752, 0.0335083, -0.025268555, -0.033996582, -0.027755737, -0.008163452, 0.025512695, -0.020965576, -0.057373047, 0.004398346, -0.012718201, 0.010040283, 0.009506226, -0.000048220158, 0.023361206, -0.0036678314, -0.0121154785, 0.018600464, -0.012001038, -0.021881104, -0.029586792, -0.005207062, -0.017044067, -0.00907135, 0.022994995, 0.015914917, 0.0061454773, 0.040374756, 0.036132812, 0.033111572, -0.01663208, 0.018585205, 0.053588867, -0.040283203, -0.05343628, -0.013298035, 0.0063667297, -0.031280518, 0.033691406, 0.015960693, -0.040008545, -0.0008611679, -0.038146973, -0.017028809, 0.0019073486, 0.035949707, -0.0063171387, 0.06317139, -0.079589844, -0.03314209, -0.022354126, 0.0072631836, -0.027618408, 0.013954163, -0.04196167, -0.014404297, 0.037200928, 0.030151367, -0.0045166016, -0.015312195, -0.0049057007, 0.025558472, 0.006340027, 0.013259888, -0.05355835, -0.02078247, -0.045135498, 0.010513306, 0.029510498, 0.03616333, -0.011566162, 0.044708252, -0.044128418, 0.028686523, -0.012962341, 0.020126343, 0.019515991, 0.016662598, -0.027511597, 0.013519287, 0.071899414, -0.024368286, 0.036712646, -0.025146484, 0.004627228, -0.014305115, -0.019760132, -0.06222534, -0.017807007, 0.040802002, 0.027191162, -0.050598145, 0.011642456, -0.038879395, 0.034332275, 0.010467529, 0.00894928, 0.03488159, 0.0009608269, -0.022155762, 0.029342651, -0.0065574646, 0.011741638, 0.034729004, 0.028213501, 0.01071167, -0.017730713, 0.0068740845, 0.009033203, -0.011222839, -0.006252289, 0.028076172, 0.031158447, 0.014266968, -0.054504395, -0.02432251, 0.011795044, 0.024734497, 0.00006604195, -0.03262329, 0.032470703, 0.0011873245, -0.0019893646, -0.029891968, 0.031555176, 0.062042236, -0.08343506, 0.06439209, -0.0072402954, -0.057647705, 0.004764557, 0.05807495, -0.00027871132, -0.020889282, -0.0025501251, -0.0059394836, 0.0014753342, 0.027954102, -0.011985779, -0.025024414, 0.010879517, 0.047454834, -0.015182495, 0.019226074, 0.01309967, -0.003932953, 0.04449463, -0.008453369, 0.00415802, -0.0016641617, -0.011444092, -0.012145996, 0.012535095, -0.0012273788, 0.12512207, -0.031082153, -0.048706055, 0.05984497, 0.00070238113, -0.078430176, -0.0029411316, 0.06378174, -0.0036182404, 0.019882202, 0.028793335, -0.021270752, -0.030166626, 0.015777588, -0.01789856, 0.006843567, 0.06451416, 0.010047913, 0.056365967, -0.050048828, -0.012268066, 0.026687622, 0.005935669, 0.014305115, 0.0015363693, -0.0006403923, -0.042144775, 0.02482605, -0.010101318, -0.018753052, -0.010307312, -0.021575928, -0.024856567, 0.009979248, 0.0041046143, -0.017333984, -0.013114929, -0.004283905, 0.05734253, 0.017852783, 0.0072364807, 0.027801514, -0.04260254, -0.02960205, 0.024505615, 0.020980835, 0.054595947, 0.0079956055, -0.0062217712, 0.0034008026, 0.007724762, -0.025817871, -0.02609253, -0.013725281, -0.0027160645, -0.011299133, -0.010513306, -0.02885437, -0.032989502, -0.041748047, -0.10583496, -0.033966064, 0.0009417534, -0.05303955, -0.0046539307, 0.007736206, -0.014907837, -0.006793976, 0.0062332153, -0.03439331, 0.010978699, 0.02798462, 0.00082826614, 0.051849365, -0.0056266785, 0.027679443, 0.017089844, 0.025222778, 0.015045166, -0.037872314, -0.011100769, -0.0017786026, 0.015930176, 0.047332764, -0.025253296, -0.060424805, 0.0053215027, 0.0076141357, 0.026306152, 0.0010051727, -0.013763428, -0.008270264, 0.042419434, 0.0128479, 0.017150879, -0.04019165, 0.045013428, -0.008529663, -0.0052719116, 0.025604248, -0.01626587, -0.00806427, -0.013336182, 0.031982422, 0.019332886, -0.016586304, -0.050354004, 0.0056915283, -0.014808655, 0.01940918, -0.0028457642, 0.062805176, -0.048736572, 0.057434082, 0.008010864, 0.08306885, -0.017318726, 0.051086426, 0.08001709, 0.09033203, 0.008483887, -0.012763977, 0.005970001, 0.03616333, 0.021606445, 0.00089263916, -0.0036525726, -0.014350891, -0.0020599365, 0.015960693, 0.013389587, 0.032073975, -0.0063285828, -0.007129669, -0.0075416565, -0.011428833, -0.036468506, 0.02104187, -0.015274048, 0.014343262, -0.021606445, 0.019592285, 0.037200928, -0.03427124, 0.01474762, 0.046325684, -0.005504608, -0.011657715, 0.0317688, -0.01638794, -0.0062294006, 0.017074585 ], "summary": [ -0.052947998, -0.051330566, 0.0051841736, 0.0066947937, -0.057647705, 0.015029907, -0.02357483, -0.0060310364, -0.0050201416, 0.01725769, -0.036376953, -0.015510559, 0.035461426, -0.016723633, 0.019073486, -0.027572632, -0.042114258, -0.004623413, -0.05117798, -0.06774902, 0.035491943, -0.10028076, -0.02330017, -0.0096588135, -0.0043792725, 0.012260437, 0.03778076, 0.008781433, 0.01676941, 0.011756897, 0.008728027, -0.027740479, 0.035949707, 0.016921997, -0.03942871, 0.026733398, -0.0023536682, -0.006439209, -0.0113220215, 0.043060303, 0.049865723, -0.02859497, -0.023422241, -0.010360718, -0.028213501, 0.018325806, 0.0046806335, -0.015823364, 0.027496338, -0.022613525, -0.0029029846, 0.003063202, 0.006164551, 0.041625977, -0.029556274, 0.008850098, -0.0067634583, -0.08129883, -0.004383087, 0.056915283, 0.043029785, -0.018493652, 0.009391785, -0.004119873, -0.0074691772, 0.016784668, 0.008735657, -0.001786232, 0.05303955, -0.0053977966, -0.03753662, 0.007965088, 0.017456055, -0.024642944, 0.0048332214, 0.011154175, 0.037109375, 0.035308838, -0.016586304, 0.016784668, 0.041168213, 0.04397583, 0.019180298, -0.02230835, 0.021911621, -0.016159058, -0.00056028366, -0.02494812, -0.021713257, -0.023422241, -0.0022602081, -0.032318115, -0.057769775, 0.046020508, 0.03741455, -0.03479004, -0.013015747, -0.033233643, 0.0064926147, -0.016113281, 0.034729004, -0.036621094, 0.01828003, 0.0008907318, -0.0149002075, 0.018936157, -0.004245758, -0.04486084, -0.0076293945, 0.025390625, -0.031036377, -0.026443481, 0.00022184849, -0.076293945, -0.008964539, 0.033599854, 0.018218994, 0.021591187, 0.03753662, -0.0036334991, -0.020187378, -0.0035972595, -0.013168335, -0.023727417, 0.035491943, 0.0064353943, -0.024932861, 0.027450562, 0.019424438, -0.014389038, -0.0362854, 0.035186768, 0.052124023, 0.011634827, -0.005252838, 0.00045251846, -0.037200928, 0.0116119385, -0.020828247, -0.00299263, -0.008659363, 0.0011663437, 0.041625977, -0.015548706, 0.027297974, 0.03439331, 0.021362305, -0.008674622, -0.014434814, 0.009552002, -0.029144287, 0.015525818, 0.011070251, -0.022949219, 0.028152466, -0.048706055, -0.013946533, -0.021240234, 0.04699707, 0.0023937225, -0.016021729, -0.020370483, 0.020706177, 0.026000977, -0.026931763, 0.044006348, -0.006450653, -0.012565613, 0.022018433, 0.013458252, -0.025970459, 0.0065956116, 0.038909912, -0.005722046, -0.01411438, 0.006011963, 0.011680603, 0.03781128, -0.006755829, -0.017669678, 0.03302002, -0.01826477, 0.043792725, 0.013038635, -0.028564453, -0.05609131, 0.0496521, 0.057617188, 0.006362915, 0.020751953, 0.052764893, -0.034332275, 0.04611206, 0.007434845, -0.0435791, -0.060394287, 0.0026626587, 0.02861023, -0.05050659, 0.042633057, 0.007637024, 0.005355835, -0.005344391, -0.017150879, -0.085876465, 0.016143799, -0.026626587, 0.03289795, -0.04437256, 0.01222229, 0.039215088, -0.035186768, -0.03213501, 0.060546875, -0.008979797, -0.05340576, 0.006755829, 0.013847351, 0.029922485, -0.026123047, 0.05154419, 0.0043258667, 0.035705566, 0.0231781, 0.007358551, 0.022354126, -0.027404785, 0.018188477, 0.037384033, 0.0075645447, 0.029159546, 0.009559631, 0.003610611, 0.009407043, -0.021820068, -0.009521484, 0.02432251, -0.04736328, 0.012901306, 0.032684326, 0.01889038, 0.029571533, -0.045013428, -0.019119263, 0.10748291, 0.101135254, 0.042053223, -0.02204895, 0.039611816, 0.07067871, -0.04827881, 0.001739502, 0.00818634, -0.04598999, -0.004119873, 0.028396606, -0.05090332, -0.027557373, 0.022735596, -0.019012451, 0.0008735657, -0.057891846, -0.009994507, -0.0446167, 0.025772095, -0.04348755, 0.011131287, -0.004310608, -0.040527344, -0.018798828, 0.035491943, 0.028671265, 0.0066375732, -0.025894165, -0.009086609, 0.017288208, -0.017059326, 0.019943237, 0.02305603, -0.031188965, -0.02268982, -0.021774292, 0.041809082, -0.022628784, 0.04925537, 0.01600647, 0.02130127, -0.071777344, 0.022628784, 0.05657959, 0.042266846, 0.03189087, 0.016189575, 0.01159668, 0.036315918, 0.0012178421, 0.11846924, 0.041778564, -0.0065956116, 0.030029297, 0.022857666, 0.030929565, -0.008338928, -0.013824463, 0.004135132, -0.006702423, -0.011627197, 0.004852295, 0.01309967, 0.012931824, -0.055511475, 0.016143799, 0.017562866, 0.09790039, -0.05618286, -0.05709839, -0.029830933, 0.025924683, -0.037200928, -0.0368042, 0.06890869, 0.01777649, -0.0049819946, 0.044769287, 0.0065994263, -0.044830322, 0.07006836, -0.012382507, 0.04296875, -0.012580872, -0.017593384, 0.00049972534, -0.03552246, -0.008346558, -0.0010299683, -0.007633209, -0.0012292862, 0.04031372, -0.006095886, 0.0031852722, 0.00074863434, -0.024551392, -0.0068969727, -0.02796936, 0.00065898895, -0.03515625, -0.0014619827, -0.0107040405, -0.0041542053, 0.006752014, 0.0005674362, -0.008026123, -0.027282715, 0.011878967, -0.0029697418, -0.013412476, 0.029953003, 0.017852783, 0.004673004, -0.014137268, 0.017120361, 0.01914978, 0.0040245056, -0.038269043, -0.035339355, -0.016036987, -0.02949524, 0.036834717, 0.048034668, 0.030883789, 0.055633545, 0.017105103, -0.009300232, -0.014205933, -0.008293152, -0.07147217, 0.09106445, -0.008522034, -0.030639648, 0.037750244, 0.021560669, 0.027160645, -0.013885498, 0.0011196136, 0.09564209, -0.0007624626, -0.0025024414, 0.052124023, 0.0074310303, 0.013153076, -0.045196533, -0.03074646, -0.0024414062, 0.00004005432, 0.015281677, -0.0009379387, 0.0062675476, 0.028518677, -0.05618286, -0.020812988, 0.028457642, 0.025009155, 0.047943115, -0.008346558, -0.04006958, 0.038330078, -0.024917603, 0.021499634, 0.019256592, -0.018356323, 0.032073975, -0.044891357, 0.03704834, -0.062561035, -0.010139465, -0.019897461, -0.084350586, 0.013023376, -0.055145264, 0.048736572, 0.046936035, -0.034057617, 0.0021209717, 0.015167236, -0.024932861, 0.022155762, 0.00036382675, 0.050811768, -0.0003130436, -0.008613586, 0.0007929802, -0.034088135, -0.02281189, 0.0021190643, -0.01739502, 0.06225586, 0.011749268, 0.013320923, 0.02973938, -0.042419434, -0.034179688, -0.030975342, -0.0017738342, -0.01878357, 0.001821518, -0.021347046, -0.018447876, -0.01991272, -0.0048179626, 0.024749756, -0.009864807, -0.00009590387, 0.02999878, 0.018676758, -0.015327454, 0.04244995, 0.007247925, 0.015625, 0.024261475, -0.044067383, -0.008232117, -0.00573349, -0.058166504, -0.018493652, -0.004737854, 0.008621216, -0.033935547, 0.034820557, 0.018600464, -0.05178833, 0.02305603, 0.04269409, -0.013839722, -0.019104004, 0.046447754, -0.022369385, 0.013549805, 0.013313293, -0.01626587, -0.020828247, -0.039245605, 0.024627686, 0.019866943, -0.044036865, -0.036346436, 0.018569946, -0.055541992, -0.04486084, 0.01966858, 0.010360718, 0.022064209, -0.04547119, 0.0390625, 0.0057907104, -0.0032653809, -0.0043945312, -0.030014038, 0.08843994, 0.019042969, -0.07324219, 0.039520264, -0.005832672, -0.0025939941, 0.0115737915, 0.027770996, 0.024749756, 0.014709473, -0.0037078857, -0.010421753, 0.0088272095, 0.017196655, -0.032806396, 0.014541626, 0.010498047, -0.028015137, 0.024734497, -0.007820129, -0.016525269, -0.022888184, 0.025665283, 0.046325684, 0.060424805, -0.018630981, 0.009010315, 0.021911621, 0.01109314, -0.04031372, -0.0052223206, 0.013900757, -0.03729248, 0.0002040863, 0.00046563148, -0.015716553, 0.043518066, 0.023284912, 0.030731201, -0.039215088, -0.028137207, 0.060302734, 0.023666382, -0.008888245, 0.013267517, -0.029510498, 0.06585693, -0.001496315, -0.025909424, -0.020263672, -0.0036010742, 0.01789856, -0.024261475, -0.003967285, 0.00409317, -0.027236938, -0.003921509, -0.015991211, -0.013801575, -0.052215576, 0.023376465, -0.0030345917, 0.051239014, 0.014511108, -0.051330566, 0.019500732, -0.0020198822, 0.025421143, 0.0025691986, 0.025848389, -0.0463562, -0.048065186, 0.012878418, -0.07775879, -0.021743774, -0.115112305, -0.05001831, -0.042053223, 0.035125732, -0.046173096, 0.027069092, -0.031341553, 0.04699707, 0.024856567, 0.017791748, -0.044769287, 0.061553955, 0.030044556, 0.015174866, -0.02519226, 0.016845703, 0.021011353, 0.012275696, -0.029083252, -0.02229309, -0.018417358, -0.009132385, 0.029281616, 0.0053367615, 0.007461548, -0.033355713, 0.017456055, 0.0051841736, -0.017150879, 0.008178711, 0.0011997223, -0.012527466, 0.004924774, 0.0079574585, 0.006587982, -0.008857727, -0.000726223, 0.017105103, -0.025894165, 0.00818634, -0.00970459, -0.018341064, -0.012969971, 0.00073480606, -0.024124146, 0.03186035, 0.023147583, -0.019943237, 0.003955841, -0.016036987, -0.008888245, 0.013313293, -0.025756836, -0.013572693, 0.031829834, 0.015487671, -0.015037537, -0.0039901733, 0.003036499, -0.0064353943, -0.022064209, -0.0073890686, 0.022109985, -0.023269653, -0.0016059875, -0.0069732666, 0.0206604, 0.0025806427, 0.037963867, -0.0031719208, 0.0036735535, 0.011932373, -0.049957275, -0.0018043518, 0.021224976, -0.008132935, -0.030258179, -0.05130005, 0.016723633, 0.006893158, -0.0028705597, 0.010673523, -0.0017175674, -0.0027885437, -0.0035381317, 0.00023651123, -0.015151978, -0.02935791, -0.042297363, -0.014045715, -0.031951904, -0.011604309, 0.07006836, -0.023712158, -0.016555786, 0.045928955, -0.043823242, 0.051940918, 0.006336212, -0.032714844, 0.022384644, 0.001914978, -0.00655365, 0.022888184, 0.022567749, 0.011627197, -0.0038967133, 0.009429932, 0.012931824, 0.02519226, 0.006248474, 0.014595032, -0.02911377, 0.04421997, -0.07196045, -0.0054855347, -0.024139404, 0.0076179504, -0.039733887, -0.03111267, -0.004173279, -0.034332275, 0.0012083054, -0.037139893, 0.0016613007, -0.018066406, 0.023040771, -0.050689697, 0.022598267, 0.01638794, -0.026275635, -0.0014724731, -0.009094238, 0.031433105, 0.0206604, -0.00365448, -0.023468018, -0.009216309, -0.02357483, 0.048614502, 0.018341064, 0.019973755, -0.08557129, -0.033325195, -0.09259033, -0.061340332, -0.039611816, 0.10650635, -0.0057640076, -0.034698486, -0.03086853, 0.010902405, 0.025787354, -0.048614502, -0.033355713, 0.015296936, -0.015365601, -0.02381897, 0.0005068779, -0.0058898926, -0.0031223297, -0.00566864, -0.005596161, 0.0020694733, 0.0006427765, 0.007648468, 0.0011034012, 0.005958557, -0.045562744, 0.0024166107, 0.026824951, 0.014976501, 0.000995636, 0.01979065, 0.016326904, 0.01197052, -0.00054216385, 0.0012207031, 0.032440186, -0.0063209534, -0.030059814, 0.00592041, 0.02192688, 0.01939392, 0.055541992, -0.020706177, -0.044067383, -0.013084412, -0.0027122498, -0.0077934265, 0.004627228, 0.01802063, 0.00033259392, 0.08453369, -0.027786255, -0.01637268, 0.004497528, 0.009101868, -0.022949219, -0.036224365, -0.021316528, 0.0055274963, 0.058898926, 0.0647583, 0.004760742, -0.008132935, -0.018875122, -0.012321472, -0.008934021, 0.021224976, -0.009315491, 0.014343262, -0.04663086, 0.0018367767, -0.008918762, 0.06427002, -0.011070251, 0.024642944, -0.00969696, 0.03604126, 0.0010519028, 0.02128601, -0.024505615, -0.034454346, -0.0033416748, 0.0047302246, 0.013710022, -0.042114258, 0.021759033, -0.0037841797, -0.020111084, -0.01991272, -0.03225708, -0.013214111, 0.028259277, 0.0013971329, -0.034820557, 0.0070381165, -0.00258255, -0.01638794, 0.057739258, -0.039978027, -0.0032081604, -0.033843994, 0.0009407997, -0.039886475, 0.04888916, -0.011489868, 0.01763916, 0.051696777, 0.0076179504, -0.004299164, -0.0385437, -0.01461792, 0.021362305, -0.020553589, -0.016342163, -0.010353088, 0.0014829636, -0.04043579, -0.03466797, -0.026809692, -0.007335663, 0.049072266, -0.0077400208, 0.036071777, -0.014930725, 0.008453369, -0.023635864, 0.005027771, -0.012924194, -0.008110046, -0.038330078, 0.003112793, 0.0093688965, -0.00894165, 0.03656006, -0.021469116, 0.021957397, -0.0713501, -0.02684021, -0.0335083, 0.020446777, -0.014595032, -0.01876831, -0.024673462, -0.0029258728, 0.03894043, 0.01259613, -0.0032653809, 0.022064209, 0.025390625, 0.031402588, -0.003604889, 0.026794434, 0.0037269592, -0.0010576248, 0.009422302, 0.020935059, -0.0592041, 0.13464355, 0.0018720627, -0.039276123, 0.039794922, 0.020767212, -0.08428955, -0.008293152, 0.05532837, 0.05078125, 0.054656982, 0.052246094, -0.03451538, 0.009613037, 0.07293701, -0.013252258, 0.0178833, 0.08294678, 0.009719849, 0.0031032562, -0.04550171, -0.027816772, -0.0036525726, -0.021377563, 0.01953125, -0.0021953583, 0.009254456, -0.055511475, 0.031280518, -0.03845215, -0.03149414, 0.031082153, -0.029174805, 0.007419586, 0.022125244, 0.017349243, -0.040374756, -0.014968872, 0.004322052, 0.03491211, 0.008598328, -0.007789612, 0.031051636, 0.004173279, -0.05819702, 0.012298584, -0.0020179749, 0.048034668, -0.030929565, -0.0030403137, 0.04901123, 0.009384155, -0.013595581, -0.06512451, -0.050109863, 0.036499023, 0.04385376, 0.0051727295, -0.025604248, -0.027023315, -0.028213501, -0.04925537, -0.0647583, 0.032836914, -0.039978027, 0.07141113, -0.020599365, -0.048034668, 0.0077323914, 0.031402588, -0.01889038, 0.054351807, 0.027954102, -0.01399231, 0.089782715, -0.0013189316, 0.008201599, 0.06237793, 0.014343262, -0.009048462, -0.023345947, -0.04498291, 0.006877899, 0.0043563843, 0.041931152, -0.0024223328, -0.03503418, 0.032226562, -0.0021457672, 0.009307861, -0.0069847107, -0.055511475, -0.05908203, 0.09075928, 0.008163452, 0.030532837, 0.008468628, 0.061645508, 0.025131226, -0.023529053, 0.011680603, -0.004432678, -0.0075798035, -0.00016236305, -0.0004079342, -0.0039520264, 0.016998291, -0.034301758, -0.016815186, -0.0075569153, -0.030883789, -0.040039062, 0.023040771, -0.048828125, 0.039215088, -0.00011771917, 0.036865234, -0.003446579, 0.03414917, 0.032318115, 0.04724121, 0.021255493, 0.0107803345, -0.045837402, -0.014404297, 0.030090332, 0.025482178, -0.0026073456, -0.05038452, -0.0070228577, -0.008049011, 0.0060806274, -0.0069770813, 0.022918701, -0.042175293, 0.00070667267, -0.011199951, -0.025360107, -0.035186768, -0.03643799, 0.04333496, -0.0154418945, -0.002067566, 0.02420044, -0.022903442, 0.012237549, 0.033691406, 0.0112838745, -0.020996094, 0.03665161, 0.01197052, 0.0154800415, 0.027252197 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07194v1
Exploring the Dialogue Comprehension Ability of Large Language Models
Shuaijie She, Shujian Huang, Xingyun Wang, Yanke Zhou, Jiajun Chen
cs.CL
The recent emergence of large language models (LLMs) have attracted considerable attention. LLMs may interact with users in the form of dialogue and generate responses following their instructions, which naturally require dialogue comprehension abilities. Without correct comprehension of the dialogue, the model may inevitably generate incorrect responses. However, dialogue comprehension is a general language ability which is hard to be evaluated directly. In this work, we propose to perform the evaluation with the help of the dialogue summarization task. Beside evaluating and analyzing the dialogue summarization performance (DIAC-Sum), we also derive factual questions from the generated summaries and use them as a more flexible measurement of dialogue comprehension (DIAC-FactQA). Our evaluation shows that, on average, 27% of the summaries generated by LLMs contain factual inconsistency. Even ChatGPT, the strongest evaluated model, has such errors in 16% of its summaries. For answering the factual questions, which is more challenging, the average accuracy of all evaluated LLMs is only 62.8%. Both results indicate serious deficiencies. Detailed analysis shows that the understanding of subject/object of the conversation is still the most challenging problem for LLMs. Furthermore, to stimulate and enhance the dialogue comprehension ability of LLMs, we propose a fine-tuning paradigm with auto-constructed multi-task data. The experimental results demonstrate that our method achieved an accuracy improvement of 8.9% on DIAC-FactQA.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07194v1
2023-11-13T09:32:12
2023-11-13T09:32:12
{ "title": [ -0.040893555, -0.007221222, -0.027542114, -0.064575195, -0.0141067505, 0.011207581, -0.07879639, 0.0049934387, 0.02243042, 0.02078247, -0.017700195, -0.025054932, -0.0027446747, -0.018249512, -0.059936523, 0.004901886, -0.025634766, 0.033233643, -0.029754639, -0.04147339, 0.0071411133, -0.066711426, 0.0069351196, 0.020935059, 0.04055786, -0.060424805, -0.07458496, 0.034210205, -0.031921387, -0.011871338, -0.012145996, 0.0040130615, 0.036346436, 0.016616821, -0.021194458, -0.009239197, -0.043518066, 0.013587952, 0.0060310364, -0.0008020401, 0.0231781, -0.011383057, -0.008880615, -0.009902954, -0.0357666, 0.023452759, -0.042022705, -0.021697998, 0.0066566467, 0.02684021, -0.0029850006, 0.016311646, -0.015464783, 0.01876831, 0.0051193237, -0.026184082, -0.022781372, -0.0019159317, 0.03050232, 0.05316162, 0.022155762, -0.028717041, 0.0038795471, -0.022750854, -0.03994751, -0.0070114136, -0.021057129, 0.0014190674, 0.06222534, -0.0015411377, -0.028518677, 0.009384155, 0.012435913, -0.03643799, -0.018203735, 0.041259766, -0.009979248, 0.011817932, 0.045928955, -0.04525757, -0.014137268, -0.007221222, 0.016693115, -0.026489258, 0.02053833, -0.03149414, -0.018737793, -0.0118637085, -0.029647827, -0.08691406, -0.008979797, -0.024856567, -0.028884888, -0.014320374, -0.03010559, -0.03955078, -0.023773193, 0.010971069, -0.0005135536, -0.037628174, -0.012542725, 0.024902344, -0.05569458, -0.009567261, 0.025985718, 0.042877197, -0.031036377, -0.03515625, 0.014152527, 0.032562256, -0.014465332, 0.031082153, -0.007232666, -0.011657715, 0.0041885376, 0.007610321, -0.031951904, 0.034973145, 0.011810303, 0.038085938, -0.039489746, -0.05203247, 0.0016174316, 0.014877319, 0.04147339, 0.010734558, -0.02746582, 0.032104492, -0.01121521, 0.029052734, 0.020019531, 0.031951904, -0.12487793, -0.070739746, -0.06640625, 0.043762207, -0.011924744, -0.003168106, -0.022109985, 0.033966064, -0.00020897388, -0.03439331, 0.012680054, -0.009864807, 0.0026931763, 0.013084412, 0.066345215, -0.0023021698, -0.06726074, -0.059539795, 0.010055542, 0.010536194, 0.025131226, 0.0011663437, -0.04727173, -0.019317627, -0.10455322, -0.024398804, 0.016571045, -0.012077332, -0.0050086975, 0.012290955, 0.018539429, -0.03488159, -0.011856079, -0.025787354, -0.015144348, -0.00047039986, 0.014129639, 0.032073975, -0.019592285, 0.019210815, 0.00655365, 0.020980835, -0.00052022934, 0.0149383545, 0.028152466, 0.0026111603, 0.02746582, -0.009536743, -0.0015592575, -0.022659302, 0.021759033, 0.03692627, -0.041229248, -0.034362793, 0.0032596588, -0.0044822693, 0.042266846, 0.021591187, -0.042419434, 0.022583008, -0.034851074, -0.05053711, -0.05038452, -0.01889038, 0.040130615, 0.024414062, 0.012313843, 0.015975952, -0.023254395, -0.008590698, -0.015220642, -0.015052795, -0.037017822, -0.015991211, -0.02859497, 0.023162842, -0.0026454926, 0.06903076, 0.06713867, 0.052490234, -0.072143555, 0.035827637, -0.013908386, -0.050445557, 0.02130127, -0.005580902, 0.011451721, -0.015930176, 0.0140686035, 0.0008740425, 0.024383545, 0.044555664, -0.0007009506, 0.0056877136, 0.009277344, -0.008094788, 0.034240723, 0.035736084, 0.061035156, -0.064941406, 0.062072754, 0.042785645, -0.013587952, -0.0066604614, 0.0051994324, -0.012229919, 0.0045433044, 0.004425049, 0.009307861, -0.012145996, -0.016952515, -0.0018720627, 0.022567749, -0.04260254, 0.0022945404, -0.008796692, 0.00041985512, 0.012329102, 0.04260254, 0.01007843, 0.044006348, 0.024047852, -0.01626587, 0.045654297, 0.009117126, -0.028137207, -0.029678345, 0.029464722, 0.020248413, -0.020736694, -0.04244995, 0.01499939, -0.08630371, 0.010726929, -0.061920166, -0.023239136, 0.010696411, -0.006832123, 0.03274536, -0.01600647, 0.025115967, -0.005886078, -0.034820557, 0.00027441978, -0.009346008, 0.019195557, 0.029205322, -0.054534912, -0.013519287, 0.017944336, 0.025726318, -0.012962341, 0.00749588, 0.02078247, -0.0038261414, -0.048309326, 0.0011482239, -0.00059604645, 0.046813965, 0.01828003, 0.011802673, 0.006504059, 0.0006380081, -0.0102005005, 0.11102295, 0.0395813, -0.0050964355, 0.022888184, -0.015167236, 0.036346436, -0.006916046, 0.0118637085, 0.01928711, -0.011390686, 0.041046143, 0.0019359589, -0.026947021, 0.030563354, -0.06390381, 0.033966064, 0.010475159, -0.021865845, -0.031280518, -0.026443481, 0.004009247, -0.018676758, -0.04711914, -0.019042969, 0.10809326, -0.03277588, -0.040527344, -0.024734497, -0.027679443, -0.011016846, -0.02255249, -0.043548584, -0.026901245, 0.008590698, 0.036376953, -0.014602661, -0.04827881, -0.034332275, -0.0050621033, 0.0025253296, -0.013015747, 0.0002808571, -0.030563354, 0.019882202, 0.0047836304, -0.034088135, 0.007736206, -0.045166016, 0.008171082, -0.037628174, 0.032562256, 0.010475159, 0.01776123, 0.0057640076, -0.009262085, -0.01713562, -0.0051193237, 0.041625977, 0.08135986, -0.013420105, -0.044769287, 0.045684814, 0.024002075, -0.017822266, 0.04510498, 0.033203125, 0.014503479, -0.08679199, -0.020950317, -0.049987793, -0.028625488, -0.02470398, 0.011947632, 0.03515625, -0.031234741, -0.014442444, -0.036590576, -0.0011940002, 0.035888672, -0.008636475, 0.022460938, -0.021484375, -0.03942871, -0.0054016113, -0.029403687, 0.016708374, -0.0345459, 0.031921387, 0.075683594, 0.013870239, -0.0014286041, 0.016098022, 0.031799316, 0.008926392, -0.010864258, -0.017822266, -0.035888672, 0.0020389557, 0.03137207, 0.012130737, -0.030380249, -0.0030212402, -0.09918213, -0.00035309792, 0.068237305, -0.0007491112, -0.02809143, 0.05343628, -0.08355713, 0.074401855, -0.013053894, -0.007926941, 0.033203125, 0.0107040405, 0.0053138733, 0.00019145012, 0.014083862, -0.05102539, 0.009887695, -0.042022705, -0.12512207, 0.019454956, 0.0071907043, -0.01713562, -0.018005371, -0.03250122, -0.045684814, 0.012779236, 0.007575989, 0.05517578, 0.008270264, -0.006866455, 0.016113281, -0.031799316, -0.003982544, -0.016967773, -0.018569946, -0.013656616, -0.016647339, 0.03111267, -0.0048713684, 0.056518555, 0.011978149, -0.0043792725, -0.020812988, -0.014656067, -0.052001953, 0.00061035156, -0.010612488, -0.037963867, -0.009292603, -0.02015686, -0.028427124, -0.013450623, -0.010971069, 0.012367249, -0.035125732, 0.016860962, -0.01259613, 0.044311523, -0.0032863617, 0.015716553, -0.010444641, -0.031829834, 0.01398468, -0.033813477, -0.031829834, 0.016418457, 0.06781006, 0.0013818741, -0.022857666, 0.0020961761, -0.01701355, 0.024551392, 0.029769897, -0.022354126, -0.008911133, -0.0018320084, -0.017791748, -0.013916016, -0.0003540516, -0.0017213821, 0.02557373, 0.011207581, -0.018295288, 0.01184082, -0.04925537, -0.0713501, -0.002773285, -0.014434814, -0.08947754, -0.015289307, 0.0014848709, 0.0082473755, -0.024978638, -0.029281616, 0.014328003, 0.0049972534, -0.044677734, 0.02470398, -0.028701782, -0.017044067, -0.020599365, -0.091430664, -0.006591797, 0.08465576, 0.003490448, 0.02520752, 0.078063965, -0.021575928, -0.020370483, -0.010063171, 0.039093018, 0.051635742, 0.04776001, 0.02243042, -0.03543091, 0.040496826, -0.031463623, 0.02230835, 0.0418396, -0.030334473, 0.018203735, 0.015975952, 0.008712769, 0.035217285, -0.008331299, 0.05267334, -0.010177612, -0.0155181885, -0.06561279, 0.01876831, -0.012573242, -0.0019187927, 0.022247314, -0.029693604, 0.0064353943, 0.0053863525, 0.003944397, 0.06591797, -0.005329132, 0.017120361, 0.03881836, -0.012794495, -0.020370483, -0.0107803345, 0.02482605, 0.01309967, 0.009307861, 0.03062439, -0.0034160614, 0.042999268, 0.0026607513, -0.017654419, -0.0042266846, 0.01222229, -0.039398193, -0.0054740906, -0.054504395, -0.03942871, -0.025939941, 0.009651184, -0.017288208, 0.050354004, 0.06829834, 0.008049011, -0.02696228, -0.020843506, 0.060394287, -0.023834229, 0.011947632, -0.075927734, 0.0016241074, -0.018096924, -0.064208984, -0.038909912, -0.048065186, -0.021316528, 0.025146484, 0.009498596, -0.015556335, 0.019134521, 0.032043457, 0.062469482, 0.061553955, -0.012458801, -0.05392456, 0.03677368, -0.038116455, -0.03466797, 0.03933716, -0.00039744377, -0.0031051636, -0.023651123, 0.022537231, -0.023803711, -0.013038635, -0.00017797947, 0.039611816, -0.01725769, 0.07928467, -0.048950195, 0.0024356842, 0.014732361, 0.022384644, 0.026168823, 0.007091522, -0.0309906, -0.023773193, 0.022125244, 0.04449463, 0.009269714, 0.0015335083, 0.03491211, 0.045410156, 0.03353882, -0.010879517, -0.002922058, -0.0009069443, 0.012763977, 0.008056641, 0.02166748, -0.017593384, -0.03793335, -0.011108398, 0.024093628, 0.023223877, -0.038482666, 0.045898438, -0.03265381, 0.0152282715, -0.005683899, -0.019119263, 0.028320312, -0.03643799, 0.027755737, -0.03540039, -0.05859375, 0.01586914, 0.04284668, -0.02029419, 0.012512207, -0.015731812, 0.006996155, 0.013725281, 0.06738281, 0.036376953, -0.0030326843, 0.009384155, -0.013969421, -0.009490967, -0.025100708, -0.048034668, -0.00005531311, -0.024459839, 0.002998352, -0.027023315, 0.03640747, -0.04989624, -0.015022278, -0.01914978, -0.036590576, 0.029647827, -0.06982422, 0.02619934, 0.08392334, -0.023605347, 0.049835205, 0.011390686, 0.010009766, 0.0018177032, 0.07495117, -0.018218994, 0.05328369, 0.03643799, -0.05908203, 0.01637268, -0.00033020973, 0.035003662, -0.006767273, 0.036315918, 0.0053253174, 0.023895264, -0.06088257, 0.013954163, 0.008674622, -0.0211792, 0.031082153, -0.05126953, 0.016799927, 0.021743774, 0.0031585693, 0.022842407, -0.023376465, -0.016281128, -0.014373779, -0.004245758, -0.037261963, 0.0038051605, -0.002588272, -0.047058105, -0.04815674, 0.03753662, -0.029754639, 0.0034561157, 0.012245178, -0.024337769, -0.041107178, 0.025283813, 0.02748108, -0.034210205, 0.009902954, -0.029708862, 0.0018148422, 0.033081055, 0.039093018, -0.011009216, -0.0045318604, -0.0075645447, -0.055847168, -0.03149414, 0.019821167, 0.0033950806, -0.0031433105, -0.022033691, -0.02268982, -0.013160706, -0.003627777, 0.022018433, -0.011695862, -0.032836914, 0.014076233, -0.0075263977, 0.0045051575, -0.00024342537, -0.0059890747, -0.0063323975, -0.0014982224, 0.0046539307, -0.049102783, 0.012786865, 0.008125305, 0.028549194, -0.028015137, -0.07287598, 0.0034160614, 0.0149002075, 0.0039711, -0.024017334, 0.031173706, 0.038513184, -0.017944336, -0.016326904, 0.0058403015, 0.040405273, -0.06311035, -0.014328003, -0.019714355, -0.008407593, -0.037628174, 0.040252686, 0.0017414093, 0.00096321106, -0.03894043, -0.055877686, -0.021026611, 0.013053894, 0.015144348, 0.011390686, -0.0019330978, -0.0087890625, 0.04876709, -0.019302368, -0.0061683655, -0.039398193, 0.019378662, 0.0006790161, -0.01890564, 0.012916565, 0.0052871704, -0.007411957, -0.0158844, 0.03491211, 0.042388916, -0.015174866, 0.030776978, -0.03756714, -0.004951477, -0.0056991577, -0.05532837, 0.038330078, -0.0049324036, -0.007709503, 0.036590576, -0.014579773, 0.060272217, 0.02128601, 0.05368042, 0.030883789, -0.0056495667, 0.032104492, 0.017150879, 0.023544312, -0.03277588, 0.036468506, -0.04611206, 0.007293701, -0.046844482, -0.013442993, -0.0836792, -0.004211426, 0.035186768, 0.021865845, 0.011177063, 0.0063972473, 0.0002450943, -0.0154953, 0.0390625, 0.005584717, 0.048950195, 0.0069274902, -0.0013990402, 0.023468018, -0.022277832, 0.01612854, 0.043273926, -0.017944336, 0.0039253235, -0.036834717, 0.0030994415, 0.012619019, -0.012527466, -0.006511688, -0.01965332, -0.0020217896, -0.035614014, -0.0025577545, -0.0031700134, 0.027069092, 0.04623413, 0.029724121, -0.025909424, 0.013084412, 0.009674072, -0.05618286, -0.012329102, -0.03378296, 0.0031986237, -0.056732178, 0.037841797, -0.008331299, -0.013084412, -0.024536133, 0.045959473, 0.03488159, -0.042053223, -0.012916565, 0.023727417, 0.03250122, -0.0056648254, 0.009300232, -0.04522705, -0.022216797, 0.009666443, 0.037231445, -0.008148193, 0.01776123, 0.00541687, 0.019104004, -0.010047913, -0.018951416, 0.008308411, 0.010940552, -0.0035305023, 0.037322998, -0.009979248, 0.0023899078, -0.00066947937, -0.030303955, -0.025024414, 0.026443481, -0.0491333, -0.019104004, 0.019729614, 0.023651123, 0.02458191, 0.06964111, 0.011817932, -0.006259918, -0.009254456, -0.038024902, 0.029464722, 0.034973145, -0.03253174, 0.009979248, -0.037506104, -0.03643799, 0.017807007, -0.040740967, 0.042999268, -0.055541992, 0.0017375946, -0.02305603, 0.027313232, 0.015731812, -0.051330566, -0.03704834, -0.017745972, -0.04257202, 0.017059326, 0.012680054, -0.010498047, -0.025497437, -0.01789856, 0.005569458, -0.0001591444, 0.021560669, 0.016845703, -0.039367676, -0.04815674, 0.03036499, -0.011680603, 0.07714844, -0.026473999, -0.0076179504, -0.011886597, 0.003566742, 0.010429382, -0.009864807, -0.0340271, 0.022628784, -0.024093628, -0.034729004, 0.029022217, 0.03289795, -0.00111866, -0.02355957, -0.016433716, -0.01676941, -0.024276733, 0.0038661957, 0.025024414, -0.036743164, -0.034484863, -0.014053345, -0.03552246, 0.029754639, 0.010261536, -0.01725769, 0.014762878, 0.013038635, -0.062805176, 0.007358551, 0.025344849, 0.07043457, 0.0014476776, -0.06173706, 0.020462036, 0.012336731, 0.049804688, -0.035064697, -0.068603516, 0.026779175, 0.013031006, 0.003030777, 0.04067993, 0.04522705, 0.014968872, -0.011482239, -0.014801025, -0.013168335, -0.028884888, 0.02947998, 0.019241333, 0.03729248, 0.051849365, -0.0063209534, 0.023376465, 0.0073432922, -0.02558899, 0.00055122375, 0.015602112, -0.0126571655, 0.02267456, -0.00082445145, 0.023895264, -0.033325195, 0.013084412, -0.05307007, 0.02659607, -0.02268982, 0.0073432922, -0.0090789795, 0.023620605, -0.017318726, 0.03189087, -0.047729492, -0.05569458, 0.04244995, 0.040222168, 0.0002732277, 0.024307251, -0.004837036, 0.0066490173, 0.006465912, 0.008659363, -0.00021719933, 0.020751953, 0.013824463, -0.046966553, -0.0062446594, -0.053466797, -0.029266357, -0.028564453, -0.04071045, 0.040100098, -0.008926392, -0.0027484894, -0.0011301041, -0.0158844, 0.0024356842, 0.029312134, 0.00022566319, -0.018569946, -0.031280518, 0.045837402, 0.040100098, -0.010025024 ], "summary": [ -0.028518677, -0.03555298, -0.0041046143, -0.0016937256, -0.072143555, 0.015525818, -0.07702637, -0.021194458, 0.014335632, 0.018966675, -0.015533447, 0.003900528, -0.021102905, -0.020126343, -0.030136108, -0.017913818, -0.038085938, 0.025466919, -0.028152466, -0.047424316, 0.011627197, -0.084350586, -0.022827148, 0.0075531006, -0.010353088, -0.07165527, 0.024108887, 0.017532349, 0.00289917, 0.01789856, -0.0018281937, -0.014755249, 0.031677246, -0.012229919, -0.017730713, 0.024459839, -0.02659607, -0.0020141602, -0.008361816, 0.009025574, 0.027740479, -0.015113831, 0.05142212, 0.011627197, -0.01285553, 0.033691406, -0.0023460388, -0.03527832, 0.04852295, 0.0015163422, 0.0051460266, 0.022003174, 0.0071144104, -0.02015686, -0.023773193, 0.013877869, 0.011726379, -0.031402588, 0.011016846, 0.03866577, 0.013504028, -0.00009381771, 0.0043907166, -0.024856567, 0.0079193115, 0.017974854, 0.004470825, -0.025604248, 0.042938232, 0.023025513, -0.00038528442, -0.0038223267, 0.019241333, -0.020736694, 0.022460938, 0.022964478, -0.023666382, 0.028274536, 0.04168701, -0.0022125244, 0.0017719269, 0.01914978, -0.004142761, -0.0231781, 0.009887695, -0.0022583008, -0.0093307495, -0.021896362, -0.015335083, -0.06750488, -0.0074920654, -0.057800293, -0.0597229, 0.03262329, 0.023483276, -0.07019043, 0.010284424, 0.0022411346, -0.029312134, -0.056152344, 0.029006958, -0.014038086, -0.009300232, -0.0024681091, 0.029464722, 0.04107666, -0.02015686, -0.030807495, 0.038085938, 0.031311035, -0.0021133423, 0.0067749023, -0.015655518, -0.07714844, 0.028839111, 0.031234741, -0.018127441, 0.0791626, 0.03945923, 0.03353882, -0.057739258, -0.027786255, -0.016036987, 0.05026245, 0.0077819824, 0.021118164, 0.004802704, 0.04067993, 0.031463623, -0.00068616867, 0.0020179749, 0.040161133, -0.04663086, -0.039978027, -0.05255127, 0.009613037, -0.022979736, 0.0013313293, -0.015975952, -0.0026435852, 0.004096985, -0.0181427, 0.03503418, -0.01977539, -0.0031032562, 0.05279541, 0.048065186, -0.0035877228, -0.052520752, -0.079589844, 0.037750244, -0.0090408325, 0.020080566, -0.026855469, -0.017684937, -0.08538818, -0.06890869, -0.006626129, 0.06951904, -0.017059326, 0.010307312, -0.007873535, -0.011940002, 0.0038394928, -0.030441284, -0.00233078, 0.006614685, 0.0002746582, 0.00894928, 0.021575928, -0.02798462, 0.027618408, 0.025131226, 0.01802063, 0.003993988, 0.010902405, -0.015167236, 0.0028686523, 0.03375244, -0.0317688, -0.0020256042, -0.028442383, 0.04547119, 0.017120361, -0.016082764, -0.008377075, -0.0069503784, 0.015586853, 0.039031982, 0.0054969788, -0.015899658, -0.013435364, -0.022125244, 0.004722595, -0.028442383, -0.04208374, -0.0019168854, 0.0039596558, -0.019729614, 0.0129852295, 0.06652832, 0.010368347, -0.015350342, -0.06100464, -0.14770508, 0.0032520294, -0.03845215, 0.038909912, 0.0036373138, 0.06451416, 0.04446411, 0.046569824, -0.08203125, 0.09674072, 0.0041236877, -0.062927246, 0.037902832, -0.005466461, 0.011100769, -0.036895752, 0.054718018, 0.039886475, 0.022384644, 0.07531738, -0.027282715, -0.030471802, 0.013725281, 0.001613617, 0.055511475, -0.0052108765, 0.09033203, -0.047088623, 0.032928467, 0.022125244, -0.032226562, -0.005996704, -0.0005812645, -0.04385376, -0.0052452087, 0.03201294, 0.022705078, 0.037261963, -0.03616333, -0.0055770874, 0.04220581, -0.03463745, 0.0007176399, -0.00623703, -0.0051002502, 0.052093506, -0.030197144, 0.0061569214, 0.010131836, -0.0015268326, -0.026260376, 0.041107178, 0.015335083, -0.036193848, -0.030471802, 0.025360107, 0.010040283, -0.05102539, -0.040893555, -0.0024204254, -0.03353882, -0.049713135, -0.045898438, -0.04269409, -0.0046043396, -0.045074463, 0.039154053, -0.0101623535, 0.01737976, -0.018417358, -0.072509766, -0.010047913, -0.009613037, 0.035247803, 0.013931274, -0.0335083, -0.0015077591, 0.017837524, 0.029083252, -0.010940552, 0.018814087, -0.015945435, 0.00017273426, -0.005332947, 0.012992859, 0.04675293, 0.042236328, 0.0038928986, -0.003156662, 0.010131836, 0.016235352, -0.011756897, 0.07446289, -0.004058838, 0.01625061, -0.011856079, 0.042022705, 0.062408447, -0.019378662, 0.01701355, 0.026062012, -0.015304565, 0.034057617, 0.006866455, 0.006385803, 0.0088272095, -0.04940796, 0.018859863, 0.037872314, 0.060760498, -0.033111572, -0.030670166, -0.015464783, 0.032806396, -0.05899048, -0.041778564, 0.107421875, -0.03161621, -0.031341553, -0.027954102, -0.046051025, -0.013999939, -0.0121154785, -0.041137695, 0.020568848, -0.029022217, -0.021636963, -0.032165527, -0.019363403, 0.018157959, 0.007858276, -0.014472961, -0.0076522827, 0.016326904, -0.009254456, 0.0019683838, 0.018218994, -0.030410767, -0.009773254, -0.011001587, 0.00957489, 0.031921387, 0.021453857, 0.0055618286, 0.015823364, 0.040008545, -0.049957275, -0.03149414, 0.020187378, 0.059753418, 0.038085938, 0.0014219284, -0.03488159, 0.029953003, -0.0050697327, -0.039367676, 0.035003662, 0.06137085, 0.024902344, -0.083740234, -0.03955078, -0.04812622, -0.01828003, -0.023025513, 0.04937744, 0.032196045, 0.03930664, 0.030548096, -0.04434204, -0.011306763, -0.00040340424, -0.04928589, 0.08630371, -0.02658081, -0.0023727417, 0.04147339, -0.0067710876, 0.025726318, -0.055541992, 0.017089844, 0.09503174, 0.0096588135, -0.009712219, 0.036132812, 0.0033569336, 0.006362915, -0.033691406, -0.04168701, 0.004108429, -0.029830933, 0.022598267, 0.020217896, -0.039855957, 0.018447876, -0.0075912476, -0.012069702, 0.06964111, 0.006954193, 0.025787354, 0.024291992, -0.030334473, 0.0692749, 0.007965088, 0.012565613, 0.052764893, -0.062805176, 0.021331787, -0.045043945, -0.0011329651, -0.07458496, -0.023071289, -0.023895264, -0.010238647, -0.015655518, 0.055023193, -0.0010910034, -0.023223877, 0.005405426, -0.016143799, 0.032684326, 0.0027809143, 0.042144775, -0.013908386, 0.01789856, -0.011917114, 0.009681702, -0.00091314316, -0.01586914, -0.013069153, -0.009971619, 0.0004711151, 0.026870728, -0.013839722, 0.0040245056, 0.011985779, -0.022277832, -0.022979736, -0.016067505, -0.054626465, -0.010269165, -0.01309967, -0.02571106, -0.00066423416, -0.043640137, -0.013053894, 0.022354126, -0.027130127, 0.0020866394, -0.015838623, 0.03640747, -0.02961731, 0.09033203, -0.038024902, 0.03793335, 0.050720215, -0.02116394, 0.008026123, -0.03363037, 0.015487671, 0.03277588, 0.07312012, 0.032073975, -0.07293701, 0.03616333, -0.013252258, 0.006134033, 0.077819824, -0.062805176, 0.0057411194, -0.014427185, -0.012268066, -0.03475952, 0.027053833, -0.0041885376, 0.034210205, -0.030410767, -0.06008911, 0.016662598, -0.053955078, -0.077941895, -0.013343811, -0.006778717, -0.04574585, -0.01171875, 0.0072402954, 0.03390503, -0.015159607, -0.022399902, 0.028945923, 0.0023860931, -0.02180481, 0.038391113, -0.033843994, 0.06738281, 0.0014095306, -0.04623413, 0.021270752, -0.016937256, -0.007835388, 0.023223877, 0.031311035, 0.0017614365, 0.017471313, 0.024459839, 0.0062179565, 0.026870728, 0.04043579, -0.008003235, -0.03604126, -0.014595032, -0.008987427, 0.024642944, 0.018676758, -0.048461914, 0.03012085, 0.015060425, 0.01449585, 0.04626465, 0.004722595, 0.00749588, -0.01171875, -0.019577026, -0.0107803345, 0.03201294, -0.0158844, -0.0178833, 0.059783936, -0.0053596497, -0.018615723, 0.0037136078, 0.012290955, 0.024536133, -0.013641357, -0.0029029846, 0.037902832, 0.011138916, -0.017303467, -0.021469116, -0.009094238, 0.029403687, -0.0034885406, 0.0029792786, -0.026733398, 0.035247803, -0.01335144, 0.015205383, -0.010177612, -0.0067481995, -0.0070114136, -0.010391235, -0.021636963, 0.0021648407, -0.027877808, 0.0079422, 0.009918213, 0.05899048, 0.06427002, 0.0032176971, -0.012123108, -0.024047852, 0.047058105, -0.0037956238, -0.025405884, -0.113342285, -0.028457642, -0.0140686035, -0.050842285, -0.04019165, -0.06573486, -0.04385376, -0.068115234, 0.012466431, 0.0077705383, 0.032989502, 0.017547607, 0.01020813, -0.007904053, -0.01991272, -0.006126404, 0.0037841797, -0.04660034, 0.019729614, 0.006626129, -0.012390137, -0.027114868, -0.0060768127, 0.013916016, 0.0075645447, -0.008621216, 0.02003479, 0.013763428, 0.0009226799, 0.028671265, -0.05831909, 0.009613037, 0.0033168793, 0.027633667, 0.024108887, 0.0016927719, -0.005317688, -0.029968262, 0.03137207, 0.0025672913, 0.06933594, -0.0335083, -0.010787964, 0.014961243, 0.038848877, -0.021575928, -0.0066070557, -0.02909851, -0.0013875961, 0.013023376, 0.01889038, 0.03677368, -0.018066406, 0.024368286, 0.021957397, -0.00011974573, -0.007835388, 0.007133484, -0.017486572, 0.037628174, 0.0041046143, -0.026000977, -0.007194519, -0.024505615, -0.0043144226, -0.0069389343, -0.029724121, 0.024429321, 0.013809204, 0.003955841, -0.020629883, -0.0073890686, 0.030380249, 0.00699234, 0.021148682, -0.020095825, -0.012542725, -0.008232117, -0.014305115, -0.0044441223, -0.022354126, -0.0032405853, -0.023651123, -0.0026607513, 0.0076828003, -0.010848999, 0.0029563904, 0.013420105, -0.009971619, -0.009056091, -0.04269409, 0.018707275, -0.05886841, -0.028915405, 0.005138397, -0.06781006, 0.021484375, 0.010002136, -0.027618408, -0.05078125, 0.051574707, -0.06262207, 0.034179688, 0.020889282, -0.06008911, 0.010414124, -0.025024414, 0.021942139, 0.05319214, 0.028396606, 0.0137786865, 0.052215576, -0.03543091, -0.005859375, -0.012634277, 0.01777649, -0.01966858, -0.00089120865, 0.032318115, 0.0135650635, 0.0005297661, -0.0043258667, 0.066345215, -0.044799805, -0.01977539, 0.019119263, 0.0064582825, -0.060943604, -0.022964478, -0.0004749298, -0.0061569214, -0.004753113, -0.043060303, 0.028915405, 0.02885437, -0.003189087, 0.009109497, -0.0079193115, 0.026611328, -0.02229309, 0.02645874, -0.022201538, 0.0042037964, 0.0025177002, 0.042541504, -0.023086548, -0.013084412, -0.008087158, -0.004337311, -0.026031494, 0.0014514923, -0.00016009808, 0.01247406, -0.0031394958, -0.020706177, -0.016708374, -0.035095215, 0.015159607, -0.052093506, -0.0045051575, 0.015594482, -0.019180298, -0.010986328, 0.010597229, -0.040985107, -0.029968262, 0.01109314, 0.009002686, -0.030670166, 0.008033752, 0.030899048, 0.04449463, -0.060180664, -0.032470703, -0.017333984, 0.0368042, 0.015129089, 0.001367569, 0.03111267, 0.024765015, -0.0340271, -0.0028953552, 0.012451172, 0.013542175, -0.053222656, -0.001499176, -0.016906738, 0.027389526, -0.029418945, 0.01776123, -0.0010814667, 0.0046463013, -0.02368164, -0.041259766, 0.014289856, 0.011795044, 0.0076065063, 0.011688232, 0.011070251, 0.02809143, 0.064575195, 0.019485474, -0.01914978, -0.03112793, 0.030975342, -0.019851685, -0.035736084, 0.038269043, -0.00072813034, -0.041656494, 0.03970337, 0.005493164, 0.03869629, -0.0362854, 0.07080078, -0.0039043427, -0.01247406, -0.0047836304, -0.0067214966, 0.032196045, 0.009216309, -0.020629883, 0.0019350052, 0.019943237, 0.041992188, 0.005706787, 0.014350891, -0.01121521, -0.014656067, 0.014297485, 0.015182495, 0.0005660057, -0.023239136, 0.049346924, -0.014144897, -0.0035858154, -0.027236938, -0.03036499, -0.018569946, 0.048736572, -0.00111866, -0.021377563, 0.0049552917, 0.0055732727, 0.0030269623, 0.008636475, -0.041259766, -0.026138306, -0.015106201, 0.009925842, -0.0036621094, 0.034179688, -0.025558472, -0.00043296814, 0.0446167, -0.026916504, 0.035186768, -0.04977417, 0.042785645, 0.028137207, -0.07287598, -0.03164673, -0.029647827, 0.023468018, -0.038330078, 0.007183075, 0.01689148, 0.04449463, 0.0053749084, -0.01335907, 0.040618896, -0.010757446, -0.009506226, -0.011177063, -0.013084412, -0.002866745, -0.000097453594, -0.034088135, -0.0031013489, -0.006351471, -0.019058228, 0.054779053, 0.028366089, 0.045532227, -0.03729248, 0.0018405914, 0.004245758, 0.012809753, -0.01953125, -0.0131073, -0.033050537, -0.0028076172, -0.019866943, -0.0011453629, 0.018966675, 0.009941101, -0.021133423, 0.009895325, 0.020584106, 0.0128479, 0.02128601, -0.012550354, 0.027908325, 0.035949707, -0.011665344, 0.020553589, 0.013366699, -0.023468018, -0.0034217834, 0.043518066, -0.030639648, 0.010696411, 0.0077934265, 0.02243042, 0.03805542, 0.05303955, -0.0056114197, 0.022964478, 0.014709473, 0.0004377365, 0.00017130375, -0.0124435425, 0.0022830963, -0.05444336, -0.0038223267, 0.012588501, -0.026824951, 0.035125732, 0.047973633, -0.063964844, 0.012458801, -0.039642334, 0.00381279, -0.043701172, 0.00749588, -0.022964478, -0.047973633, -0.028869629, 0.023773193, 0.022750854, -0.023284912, -0.0011825562, -0.018341064, -0.021026611, -0.0061798096, 0.0065193176, 0.050354004, -0.020446777, -0.064819336, 0.0209198, 0.036132812, 0.06188965, -0.019805908, -0.032073975, 0.019866943, 0.022460938, 0.03161621, -0.040496826, -0.047973633, 0.026367188, 0.059936523, -0.0064582825, 0.020874023, 0.0357666, 0.0045776367, -0.039031982, -0.019454956, -0.0067329407, -0.03488159, 0.02041626, 0.06451416, -0.013168335, -0.06903076, -0.010398865, -0.029342651, 0.054626465, -0.016555786, 0.010002136, 0.032440186, 0.012161255, -0.031143188, 0.005306244, 0.010375977, 0.024246216, 0.023498535, -0.05368042, -0.0021953583, 0.0013151169, 0.028945923, -0.017105103, -0.016647339, 0.038391113, 0.04043579, 0.016281128, -0.007320404, -0.001332283, -0.013717651, 0.002286911, 0.013999939, -0.006893158, -0.0071525574, 0.103027344, 0.05871582, 0.02482605, 0.0209198, -0.023635864, 0.041656494, -0.020339966, -0.027557373, -0.029327393, -0.018615723, 0.005947113, -0.038391113, 0.0032634735, -0.007949829, -0.03753662, -0.016281128, -0.031051636, -0.0026798248, -0.018920898, -0.036071777, -0.006790161, 0.017150879, -0.048706055, -0.0184021, -0.041992188, 0.029373169, 0.003068924, -0.014183044, 0.027160645, -0.011253357, 0.037872314, 0.041625977, 0.00003916025, -0.008201599, 0.01184845, -0.0011701584, 0.012779236, -0.024520874, -0.0055732727, -0.06210327, -0.0057411194, -0.018463135, -0.02822876, 0.012458801, 0.037261963, -0.013343811, 0.103149414, -0.040496826, 0.033355713, 0.014137268, -0.00381279, -0.013053894, 0.030151367, 0.086120605, -0.00084257126, 0.029876709 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07172v1
VerityMath: Advancing Mathematical Reasoning by Self-Verification Through Unit Consistency
Vernon Toh, Ratish Puduppully, Nancy F. Chen
cs.CL, cs.PL
Large Language Models (LLMs) combined with program-based solving techniques are increasingly demonstrating proficiency in mathematical reasoning. However, such progress is mostly demonstrated in closed-source models such as OpenAI-GPT4 and Claude. In this paper, we seek to study the performance of strong open-source LLMs. Specifically, we analyze the outputs of Code Llama (7B) when applied to math word problems. We identify a category of problems that pose a challenge for the model, particularly those involving quantities that span multiple types or units. To address this issue, we propose a systematic approach by defining units for each quantity and ensuring the consistency of these units during mathematical operations. We developed Unit Consistency Programs (UCPs), an annotated dataset of math word problems, each paired with programs that contain unit specifications and unit verification routines. Finally, we finetune the Code Llama (7B) model with UCPs to produce VerityMath and present our preliminary findings.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07172v1
2023-11-13T09:06:58
2023-11-13T09:06:58
{ "title": [ -0.018554688, -0.000035583973, -0.060272217, -0.0690918, 0.02658081, -0.019470215, -0.01448822, -0.006462097, -0.00819397, 0.02279663, -0.009689331, 0.009002686, 0.012870789, -0.03741455, -0.023788452, 0.0054626465, -0.0073623657, 0.028915405, -0.021224976, -0.02406311, -0.017669678, -0.03945923, 0.037506104, 0.048828125, 0.027252197, -0.044647217, -0.05105591, 0.011398315, -0.029571533, -0.031799316, -0.0093307495, 0.029388428, 0.03277588, 0.034729004, -0.028961182, 0.0017843246, -0.041992188, 0.027542114, -0.029296875, 0.033691406, 0.021575928, -0.0012874603, -0.06695557, -0.012611389, -0.06866455, 0.01802063, -0.05770874, -0.0019550323, -0.016983032, 0.06817627, 0.026046753, 0.01424408, -0.015045166, 0.08666992, 0.018112183, -0.017791748, 0.00066185, -0.057434082, 0.037963867, 0.05529785, 0.024139404, -0.07678223, 0.03338623, -0.020980835, -0.02998352, -0.026168823, 0.00038170815, 0.04385376, 0.061340332, -0.028518677, -0.043060303, 0.046325684, 0.014724731, 0.04434204, -0.042663574, -0.048828125, 0.05923462, 0.0056266785, 0.035614014, 0.0007071495, 0.025131226, -0.053619385, -0.0065727234, 0.00014436245, 0.019119263, 0.0051460266, -0.00073575974, -0.0178833, -0.053741455, -0.0736084, -0.018630981, -0.03668213, -0.03665161, -0.0012378693, -0.019592285, -0.035705566, -0.0070495605, 0.018875122, -0.011711121, -0.012886047, -0.02027893, 0.03262329, -0.054870605, -0.009109497, 0.003200531, 0.03466797, -0.015113831, -0.003967285, -0.0026016235, 0.035705566, -0.023727417, -0.018981934, 0.0017271042, -0.036956787, 0.0021133423, 0.024017334, -0.0078086853, 0.014434814, 0.027374268, 0.023773193, 0.02027893, -0.0065231323, 0.0184021, -0.00680542, 0.038726807, 0.021881104, -0.049743652, -0.0071983337, 0.038085938, 0.023452759, -0.0060272217, 0.05130005, -0.09674072, -0.106933594, -0.057739258, 0.037719727, 0.008964539, -0.013641357, -0.01637268, 0.018127441, 0.015457153, -0.018585205, 0.017700195, -0.000119924545, -0.038909912, 0.030670166, 0.05795288, -0.0078086853, -0.050842285, -0.07067871, -0.025543213, -0.011772156, 0.00063705444, 0.002128601, -0.048431396, 0.021743774, -0.16174316, 0.037628174, 0.04071045, 0.048614502, 0.028182983, -0.000021159649, -0.023666382, 0.002128601, 0.018310547, -0.0014810562, -0.015571594, 0.011741638, -0.004032135, 0.021026611, -0.008888245, 0.0025100708, -0.0056419373, -0.019989014, -0.016479492, -0.0011501312, 0.02130127, -0.016738892, 0.0231781, 0.013381958, 0.0032138824, -0.013664246, -0.014564514, 0.06274414, -0.009941101, -0.06274414, 0.018997192, -0.0491333, 0.012771606, 0.027633667, -0.037200928, 0.04660034, -0.043273926, -0.024154663, -0.027542114, -0.036590576, -0.0060768127, 0.011940002, -0.0124053955, 0.020874023, -0.03363037, 0.026824951, -0.04119873, 0.023452759, -0.014846802, -0.017852783, -0.014442444, 0.031143188, -0.019821167, 0.078430176, 0.059753418, 0.040496826, -0.049438477, 0.020874023, 0.0020446777, -0.08062744, 0.03515625, -0.03793335, -0.0079956055, -0.018249512, -0.010101318, -0.0013723373, -0.018096924, 0.04916382, -0.028289795, -0.0062713623, -0.0060424805, -0.027862549, 0.0016927719, 0.018585205, 0.06317139, -0.031143188, 0.052581787, 0.031051636, -0.0050201416, -0.01687622, -0.003211975, -0.020446777, -0.0031223297, 0.022644043, 0.0005912781, -0.05895996, -0.030654907, 0.007865906, 0.03564453, -0.0053215027, 0.0104904175, 0.013847351, 0.0068511963, 0.010917664, 0.04309082, 0.022415161, 0.04559326, 0.013793945, -0.013595581, 0.05770874, -0.0033359528, 0.034851074, -0.03866577, 0.0259552, -0.005619049, 0.023605347, 0.011276245, 0.002117157, -0.0030231476, 0.0007171631, -0.0071411133, 0.026504517, 0.010307312, 0.0154800415, 0.01977539, -0.038513184, 0.008415222, -0.032714844, -0.023986816, -0.0082092285, -0.016601562, 0.020248413, 0.025619507, -0.07220459, -0.0072784424, -0.0003106594, 0.023330688, -0.00548172, 0.0074310303, -0.013137817, 0.017578125, -0.0063552856, -0.024658203, -0.02708435, 0.036865234, 0.028656006, 0.00497818, 0.00066423416, 0.027267456, -0.021560669, 0.02998352, 0.0690918, -0.005065918, 0.0057373047, -0.06921387, 0.020141602, 0.014442444, -0.015556335, 0.00605011, 0.041748047, 0.016983032, 0.027954102, -0.0050849915, -0.0074272156, -0.026779175, 0.004173279, 0.0045166016, -0.032562256, -0.031173706, -0.050445557, -0.016052246, -0.04901123, -0.048217773, 0.006801605, 0.03564453, -0.0071411133, -0.003604889, 0.0047302246, 0.021575928, -0.01576233, 0.0017461777, -0.02722168, -0.025512695, 0.002614975, 0.032348633, 0.013084412, -0.043945312, 0.028549194, 0.012168884, 0.027191162, -0.013877869, -0.037109375, -0.050750732, 0.014671326, -0.035827637, -0.023513794, 0.023254395, -0.08081055, -0.009513855, -0.040985107, -0.0023498535, 0.027435303, -0.029159546, -0.012588501, 0.024032593, -0.020599365, -0.0113220215, 0.0105896, 0.074279785, -0.009140015, -0.034423828, 0.054138184, 0.05529785, -0.01361084, 0.032348633, 0.0027637482, 0.023223877, 0.009132385, -0.014701843, -0.051116943, -0.0138549805, 0.012832642, -0.0021705627, 0.050109863, -0.031433105, -0.027114868, -0.036315918, -0.00818634, -0.0025730133, 0.011222839, -0.021118164, -0.03942871, -0.028411865, -0.028411865, 0.007904053, 0.01436615, -0.012512207, 0.010910034, 0.09552002, 0.009048462, 0.008308411, 0.034179688, 0.01574707, -0.007633209, -0.02696228, -0.013977051, -0.04196167, -0.004459381, 0.0028438568, 0.021835327, -0.020935059, -0.029663086, -0.07208252, 0.0073928833, 0.07220459, -0.0104904175, -0.03567505, 0.019699097, -0.07159424, 0.014015198, -0.007270813, -0.0036811829, 0.036132812, -0.018676758, -0.0003633499, 0.03878784, -0.011688232, -0.024795532, -0.0010223389, -0.041503906, -0.111083984, 0.016036987, -0.021591187, 0.015266418, 0.010276794, -0.021377563, -0.041290283, 0.019592285, -0.030975342, 0.027435303, 0.024536133, 0.03466797, 0.0031089783, -0.039886475, -0.0023212433, -0.041778564, -0.0035495758, 0.0026302338, -0.0021686554, 0.011161804, -0.018478394, 0.03378296, 0.019958496, -0.005771637, -0.0035705566, -0.0256958, -0.017837524, 0.048675537, -0.016204834, -0.004535675, -0.026229858, 0.0021972656, 0.0016546249, 0.0024700165, -0.013267517, 0.007686615, -0.03652954, 0.004306793, -0.01260376, -0.015129089, 0.01890564, 0.0031166077, -0.031158447, -0.0068206787, 0.00945282, -0.015960693, -0.052215576, -0.014556885, 0.056152344, -0.020507812, 0.018310547, -0.015525818, -0.015388489, 0.025741577, -0.028274536, 0.02015686, 0.011909485, 0.014152527, -0.001458168, 0.043395996, -0.032165527, 0.0071411133, -0.046417236, 0.032440186, 0.013717651, 0.0039596558, -0.0055656433, -0.051940918, 0.0026054382, -0.004131317, -0.12042236, -0.05239868, 0.017593384, -0.008377075, 0.024398804, -0.036224365, 0.0284729, 0.02104187, -0.026824951, -0.012214661, -0.013534546, -0.0028743744, 0.0135650635, -0.04168701, -0.014892578, 0.08300781, -0.010818481, 0.007724762, 0.042785645, 0.0002501011, -0.034698486, -0.03741455, 0.014595032, -0.0151901245, 0.015541077, -0.020370483, -0.028121948, 0.022857666, -0.03326416, 0.016235352, -0.00029611588, 0.009162903, -0.024978638, 0.015090942, 0.00881958, 0.0075950623, -0.036071777, 0.03845215, 0.03390503, 0.0014753342, -0.092163086, 0.03805542, 0.006980896, -0.03262329, 0.014289856, -0.019348145, 0.006877899, 0.043640137, -0.008666992, 0.06762695, -0.025634766, -0.008026123, 0.016784668, 0.0018911362, -0.022781372, -0.010986328, 0.012451172, 0.03918457, 0.008735657, 0.033569336, -0.008041382, 0.055358887, -0.02357483, 0.031036377, -0.030090332, -0.01473999, -0.04660034, 0.0048599243, -0.059631348, 0.0017824173, -0.033447266, 0.020751953, -0.015945435, 0.0060653687, 0.024169922, 0.0019464493, -0.022247314, -0.0079574585, -0.0007762909, 0.003780365, 0.008453369, -0.025878906, -0.010498047, -0.0029506683, -0.070251465, -0.052001953, -0.022842407, 0.016296387, 0.011222839, 0.0051498413, 0.00033926964, 0.020248413, 0.030914307, 0.020339966, 0.022262573, -0.018966675, -0.021453857, 0.030395508, -0.004562378, -0.050598145, 0.032318115, -0.018051147, -0.005519867, -0.044128418, -0.0085372925, -0.017425537, 0.0060157776, -0.025283813, 0.018829346, -0.016418457, 0.042114258, -0.02885437, -0.000022113323, 0.018920898, -0.010910034, 0.018981934, -0.0027866364, -0.039398193, 0.010681152, 0.021316528, 0.058502197, -0.03427124, -0.0021915436, 0.002243042, 0.05545044, 0.020690918, -0.010978699, 0.02067566, -0.008255005, -0.0011453629, 0.0074653625, 0.026641846, -0.043823242, -0.037506104, -0.004802704, 0.0037174225, 0.038604736, -0.055145264, 0.03668213, 0.023223877, 0.02027893, 0.020095825, -0.030822754, 0.019210815, -0.020751953, 0.017089844, -0.06689453, -0.06750488, -0.023910522, 0.035949707, -0.016357422, -0.014892578, 0.045837402, 0.055725098, 0.008346558, 0.061767578, 0.07458496, -0.03427124, 0.032043457, -0.027389526, -0.0062332153, 0.011268616, -0.051116943, -0.01600647, 0.0005850792, 0.025665283, -0.040374756, 0.03466797, -0.056518555, 0.0033912659, 0.011756897, -0.0075263977, 0.011894226, -0.057647705, 0.042053223, 0.07336426, -0.017242432, 0.040161133, 0.03540039, 0.0065689087, 0.018539429, 0.058380127, 0.0046577454, 0.021408081, 0.029647827, -0.034942627, -0.019058228, 0.0025482178, 0.04815674, 0.0023670197, 0.0062065125, 0.029205322, -0.009414673, -0.049957275, 0.03010559, 0.045288086, -0.030303955, 0.025894165, -0.064331055, 0.011016846, 0.0073127747, 0.019073486, 0.03677368, -0.03744507, -0.01574707, -0.007259369, -0.009353638, -0.04336548, 0.0129470825, 0.013130188, -0.01914978, -0.05795288, 0.014808655, -0.005962372, 0.009796143, 0.0049972534, 0.024841309, -0.023147583, 0.016448975, 0.008850098, -0.008415222, 0.0049934387, -0.036956787, -0.030471802, 0.04348755, 0.0657959, -0.0259552, 0.0027389526, -0.020812988, -0.051513672, -0.024627686, 0.015838623, 0.00021445751, 0.014587402, -0.013595581, -0.0715332, 0.0038146973, 0.0090408325, 0.021881104, 0.014846802, -0.0031204224, 0.01008606, 0.021469116, 0.020385742, 0.018188477, 0.04434204, -0.013374329, 0.016052246, 0.028961182, 0.0033073425, 0.012771606, 0.008300781, -0.0035438538, 0.0034713745, -0.05947876, 0.0065307617, 0.023101807, 0.006336212, 0.0063552856, 0.045654297, 0.043640137, 0.06439209, -0.01966858, 0.021484375, 0.050598145, -0.04522705, -0.04220581, -0.009101868, 0.007980347, -0.013999939, 0.043701172, -0.013153076, -0.037261963, -0.021835327, -0.050811768, -0.028625488, -0.013671875, 0.0072517395, 0.008460999, -0.000090777874, -0.03439331, 0.0074653625, -0.035217285, 0.0007133484, -0.0423584, 0.016616821, -0.017807007, -0.023727417, 0.02923584, 0.0031929016, -0.015129089, -0.026260376, 0.01902771, 0.053344727, 0.0135269165, 0.02973938, -0.05834961, -0.015319824, -0.056884766, -0.013145447, 0.055389404, 0.03189087, -0.018875122, 0.043304443, -0.002532959, 0.045196533, 0.02357483, 0.022567749, 0.04043579, 0.027954102, -0.018661499, -0.008804321, -0.016921997, -0.029037476, -0.004737854, -0.026977539, -0.0010004044, -0.052581787, -0.009986877, -0.066467285, 0.0020713806, 0.012214661, 0.04953003, 0.019302368, 0.012710571, 0.03604126, 0.00026583672, 0.037353516, -0.003293991, 0.08294678, -0.016677856, -0.0234375, 0.0014476776, 0.01423645, 0.026885986, 0.043395996, 0.010498047, 0.0017366409, -0.015274048, -0.020996094, 0.05026245, -0.012893677, 0.011436462, -0.049835205, -0.01828003, -0.03781128, 0.024383545, -0.012573242, 0.038604736, 0.069885254, 0.041992188, -0.02067566, -0.005050659, 0.0016851425, -0.02180481, -0.019760132, -0.0107803345, 0.02670288, -0.040618896, 0.015327454, -0.032592773, -0.021377563, -0.014801025, 0.03475952, 0.04034424, -0.04800415, -0.036193848, 0.031921387, 0.035186768, 0.009803772, 0.019454956, -0.0256958, -0.006839752, 0.02357483, 0.01737976, 0.007419586, 0.035095215, 0.017059326, 0.030639648, -0.022399902, -0.04284668, 0.0026855469, -0.017959595, -0.009727478, 0.030578613, 0.006462097, 0.01687622, 0.006877899, -0.027893066, 0.0015764236, 0.01966858, -0.045166016, 0.006187439, -0.020904541, 0.07733154, 0.062316895, 0.095947266, 0.024475098, -0.011077881, 0.038391113, -0.046539307, 0.035339355, 0.026168823, -0.043518066, 0.008834839, -0.039215088, -0.054016113, 0.032714844, -0.04736328, 0.07055664, -0.038360596, 0.02180481, -0.033721924, 0.024810791, 0.014175415, -0.041015625, -0.01423645, -0.009384155, -0.016342163, -0.023773193, -0.017166138, -0.007522583, -0.012184143, -0.00806427, 0.047912598, 0.025344849, 0.0057907104, -0.010894775, -0.044769287, -0.05038452, 0.02432251, 0.014343262, 0.04373169, 0.03060913, -0.020141602, -0.0070762634, -0.010047913, 0.004055023, -0.020385742, -0.032440186, -0.024414062, -0.013793945, -0.017974854, 0.0050354004, 0.0077590942, -0.011062622, 0.021316528, -0.038513184, 0.033233643, -0.0082092285, -0.015777588, 0.005279541, -0.059753418, -0.0004682541, -0.010566711, -0.045135498, 0.028793335, 0.03930664, -0.008140564, 0.014915466, 0.020095825, -0.0289917, -0.068847656, -0.02178955, -0.0060539246, 0.018188477, -0.02708435, -0.00415802, 0.02557373, 0.039123535, -0.06506348, -0.06359863, -0.004009247, 0.029937744, -0.0028896332, 0.0335083, 0.00944519, -0.014350891, 0.021118164, 0.020446777, -0.0036716461, -0.038269043, -0.012680054, 0.0070343018, 0.018051147, 0.043914795, -0.015365601, 0.008178711, 0.028625488, -0.04360962, 0.008865356, 0.0146484375, -0.0023956299, 0.0079422, -0.002445221, 0.032287598, -0.022399902, -0.025527954, -0.021942139, -0.033081055, 0.006958008, 0.015640259, -0.03945923, 0.019256592, -0.051849365, 0.03074646, 0.012313843, -0.04458618, 0.042510986, 0.048950195, 0.030212402, 0.036468506, -0.024597168, -0.023895264, 0.003604889, 0.0016241074, -0.020339966, -0.0012245178, 0.03338623, -0.030090332, -0.0018987656, -0.024795532, -0.022567749, 0.01398468, -0.028137207, 0.05496216, -0.019760132, -0.014770508, -0.02230835, -0.032928467, 0.0052337646, 0.012664795, -0.01574707, -0.019500732, -0.06561279, -0.010879517, 0.018447876, -0.008842468 ], "summary": [ -0.015022278, 0.0033340454, -0.007785797, -0.004306793, -0.03567505, 0.009994507, -0.03942871, -0.021255493, -0.0020694733, 0.033569336, -0.019042969, 0.004863739, 0.039764404, -0.035583496, 0.03427124, -0.007888794, -0.0072250366, 0.020935059, -0.0025634766, -0.037353516, 0.030380249, -0.02708435, -0.021484375, 0.021011353, 0.020843506, -0.04638672, -0.010665894, -0.016403198, 0.0029392242, -0.0015144348, 0.0014209747, 0.030899048, 0.037200928, 0.0119018555, -0.033721924, 0.01940918, -0.042053223, 0.0096206665, -0.039764404, 0.041992188, 0.033843994, -0.0057373047, 0.0335083, 0.0022392273, -0.0105896, 0.028305054, -0.01828003, -0.04348755, 0.010856628, 0.030776978, 0.011421204, 0.023880005, 0.0013990402, 0.048828125, -0.011428833, 0.0009112358, -0.008346558, -0.041259766, 0.012542725, 0.04058838, 0.010620117, -0.0138549805, 0.015853882, -0.005458832, -0.020385742, 0.0028018951, -0.004524231, -0.0035190582, 0.068481445, -0.010955811, -0.026107788, 0.027328491, 0.011276245, -0.0058517456, 0.017974854, -0.012367249, 0.018066406, 0.0013837814, 0.009246826, 0.019592285, 0.083618164, 0.018554688, 0.029693604, -0.012466431, 0.026290894, 0.0024051666, 0.0126571655, -0.032165527, -0.021392822, -0.045562744, -0.015975952, -0.015960693, -0.070251465, 0.008346558, 0.02583313, -0.06555176, -0.023834229, -0.018493652, -0.047943115, -0.02420044, 0.042510986, -0.024932861, 0.020996094, -0.004753113, -0.018920898, 0.06274414, -0.025131226, -0.021636963, -0.012664795, 0.021469116, 0.006702423, -0.09613037, 0.015975952, -0.051086426, 0.01637268, 0.0015888214, -0.002735138, 0.06414795, 0.03466797, 0.019424438, -0.0003736019, 0.028030396, -0.009155273, 0.032287598, 0.0020771027, 0.029922485, 0.010131836, -0.022201538, 0.019363403, 0.007980347, 0.016983032, 0.044891357, -0.07531738, -0.045928955, -0.0670166, 0.014038086, 0.023422241, -0.01675415, -0.010101318, 0.022384644, -0.038146973, -0.033935547, 0.019897461, -0.028381348, -0.005908966, 0.06945801, 0.04385376, -0.025772095, -0.04257202, -0.07122803, 0.0029296875, -0.033996582, 0.018157959, -0.030151367, -0.018600464, -0.041503906, -0.078430176, 0.01676941, 0.048217773, 0.017364502, 0.023376465, -0.006526947, 0.003408432, 0.030700684, -0.031341553, 0.004207611, -0.0040512085, -0.0048065186, 0.0070381165, -0.013381958, -0.0046691895, 0.031799316, 0.014587402, -0.00007390976, -0.0032463074, -0.002243042, 0.004016876, 0.024795532, 0.016952515, -0.039154053, 0.0066184998, -0.018920898, 0.037109375, 0.013969421, 0.020355225, -0.08294678, 0.0076828003, -0.008338928, 0.034210205, 0.04598999, -0.03555298, -0.021347046, 0.016082764, 0.009376526, -0.0025901794, -0.052581787, -0.022827148, 0.0033283234, -0.025558472, -0.004009247, 0.039001465, 0.017410278, -0.021347046, -0.031234741, -0.06726074, 0.021575928, -0.017181396, 0.039215088, -0.04220581, 0.04046631, 0.041381836, 0.016708374, -0.05758667, 0.09259033, 0.027740479, -0.067871094, 0.034240723, -0.012176514, 0.028320312, -0.013160706, 0.041870117, 0.033325195, -0.012870789, 0.024124146, -0.074523926, 0.014472961, -0.02420044, 0.029541016, -0.027709961, 0.015808105, 0.062194824, -0.036224365, 0.03479004, 0.032043457, -0.018081665, -0.018753052, -0.012260437, -0.07672119, 0.020690918, 0.049560547, 0.027114868, -0.023620605, -0.04623413, -0.028701782, 0.024917603, 0.045166016, 0.04473877, -0.031097412, 0.0039405823, 0.026412964, 0.0034942627, 0.0012102127, 0.016860962, -0.04321289, -0.012588501, 0.041381836, -0.023010254, -0.016708374, 0.007019043, 0.0041160583, 0.006038666, -0.014907837, 0.004432678, -0.014404297, 0.023773193, -0.04473877, 0.00027179718, -0.009719849, -0.015289307, -0.00598526, 0.018066406, -0.0418396, -0.004398346, -0.06652832, -0.025726318, -0.011550903, -0.021774292, 0.034240723, 0.03744507, -0.052764893, -0.006401062, -0.005443573, 0.02355957, -0.009902954, 0.023483276, -0.0037212372, 0.025054932, 0.00028014183, 0.028518677, 0.042388916, 0.015640259, 0.064697266, 0.037475586, 0.028121948, 0.017471313, 0.016525269, 0.03640747, 0.050079346, 0.0031356812, 0.00037813187, 0.04055786, 0.041381836, -0.026947021, 0.018814087, 0.031982422, 0.032287598, 0.039764404, 0.007297516, 0.029449463, 0.042114258, -0.047943115, 0.011947632, 0.025924683, 0.061920166, -0.06549072, -0.054138184, -0.03353882, 0.017944336, -0.044921875, -0.007820129, 0.041992188, -0.0028743744, 0.028259277, 0.0357666, 0.01713562, -0.044891357, 0.084106445, -0.008361816, 0.053619385, -0.018737793, -0.035491943, -0.01838684, -0.056274414, -0.0030899048, 0.009513855, -0.0059013367, -0.0049324036, -0.0052452087, -0.02458191, -0.004634857, -0.010047913, -0.015625, -0.0027427673, -0.037963867, -0.023727417, -0.0026016235, -0.0058403015, -0.005264282, -0.013404846, 0.014320374, -0.012619019, -0.004562378, 0.02583313, 0.010467529, 0.062438965, 0.0039482117, -0.055419922, 0.005001068, 0.01977539, -0.052459717, -0.0020866394, 0.04525757, 0.008613586, -0.008140564, -0.04019165, -0.025497437, 0.020507812, 0.019332886, 0.01737976, 0.010124207, -0.019500732, 0.009185791, -0.01197052, -0.006629944, 0.011039734, 0.0039100647, 0.09338379, 0.0090789795, -0.02079773, 0.04144287, 0.03781128, 0.031204224, 0.01878357, 0.008277893, 0.09814453, 0.019363403, 0.024414062, 0.032196045, 0.024093628, -0.005428314, -0.043395996, -0.022476196, -0.0032672882, 0.0022392273, -0.008705139, 0.013832092, -0.06555176, -0.04397583, -0.034484863, 0.020446777, 0.11743164, 0.004009247, 0.03793335, 0.01902771, -0.054870605, 0.084472656, 0.009231567, 0.045776367, 0.040283203, -0.10784912, 0.043029785, -0.024887085, 0.020355225, -0.06585693, -0.027633667, -0.05065918, -0.070251465, 0.0023536682, -0.02130127, 0.0692749, 0.02027893, -0.020736694, -0.02935791, 0.00497818, -0.04284668, 0.01411438, -0.029266357, 0.05203247, -0.043548584, -0.006252289, -0.024642944, -0.014404297, -0.0075035095, 0.03326416, -0.003686905, 0.074157715, 0.016052246, 0.0056877136, 0.052520752, -0.044708252, 0.008956909, -0.021118164, -0.03878784, -0.010047913, -0.011917114, -0.020431519, 0.0073165894, -0.00027179718, 0.005596161, 0.039093018, -0.045898438, 0.002796173, -0.035980225, 0.024871826, -0.023590088, -0.010551453, -0.04208374, 0.009605408, 0.018341064, -0.03591919, -0.012916565, -0.007904053, -0.023620605, -0.023269653, 0.04260254, 0.03768921, -0.06677246, 0.04559326, 0.0045547485, -0.030471802, 0.07043457, -0.040527344, -0.010612488, -0.0043525696, -0.004283905, 0.014770508, 0.03363037, -0.00029349327, 0.012168884, -0.024017334, -0.06976318, 0.038909912, -0.06213379, -0.039123535, -0.04562378, 0.009735107, -0.053894043, -0.04348755, -0.005340576, 0.034729004, 0.015586853, 0.024108887, 0.031555176, 0.0519104, 0.012199402, -0.008621216, -0.023040771, 0.06793213, 0.019714355, -0.052337646, 0.033050537, -0.009063721, -0.02229309, 0.016067505, 0.008758545, 0.032592773, 0.01675415, -0.011962891, 0.0058021545, -0.017578125, 0.02418518, -0.035247803, -0.05706787, -0.01991272, -0.024414062, -0.004360199, 0.014953613, -0.048095703, 0.007091522, 0.014671326, 0.021987915, 0.020309448, 0.0024814606, -0.0013132095, 0.0023612976, 0.038391113, -0.048919678, 0.051879883, 0.013427734, -0.012359619, 0.02166748, -0.02696228, -0.022323608, 0.022216797, 0.02571106, 0.048461914, -0.036712646, -0.041931152, 0.020874023, 0.0725708, -0.019470215, -0.010246277, 0.013626099, 0.10180664, -0.01247406, 0.039031982, -0.02848816, 0.04333496, 0.0109939575, 0.02217102, -0.02722168, -0.029083252, 0.020431519, -0.036315918, -0.051452637, -0.009590149, 0.0012712479, 0.010917664, 0.015510559, 0.010864258, 0.03616333, 0.006587982, -0.010177612, -0.032562256, 0.034454346, 0.0016994476, -0.0040626526, -0.0524292, -0.042633057, 0.0008649826, -0.041534424, -0.034362793, -0.018981934, 0.01789856, -0.032287598, 0.0046310425, -0.012191772, 0.0016231537, -0.0046653748, -0.013885498, 0.012588501, 0.019607544, -0.006412506, -0.014053345, -0.007858276, -0.017227173, -0.008110046, -0.0013694763, -0.021621704, -0.020965576, 0.0016469955, 0.0012550354, -0.005504608, -0.04119873, 0.01158905, 0.0000029206276, 0.02003479, -0.030197144, -0.0317688, 0.008468628, -0.01838684, 0.0028858185, -0.009017944, -0.010040283, 0.033447266, 0.021820068, 0.013725281, 0.002861023, -0.02067566, 0.03173828, 0.043060303, 0.000073850155, -0.0010995865, -0.022094727, 0.0006723404, 0.037475586, 0.018371582, 0.007713318, 0.02166748, -0.014976501, 0.011360168, 0.012718201, 0.0051994324, 0.0031986237, -0.04333496, 0.030899048, 0.038024902, 0.001332283, -0.04083252, 0.020233154, 0.010688782, 0.0027046204, -0.037475586, -0.076049805, -0.003578186, 0.0670166, 0.0071411133, 0.0021457672, 0.015289307, -0.0093688965, 0.0016546249, 0.026031494, 0.020843506, -0.05142212, 0.0423584, -0.033721924, -0.02279663, 0.018493652, -0.017242432, -0.0524292, 0.008255005, 0.026367188, -0.0234375, 0.034454346, 0.014923096, 0.009544373, -0.009719849, -0.002910614, 0.0045661926, -0.03262329, -0.033721924, 0.015655518, -0.019088745, 0.007572174, 0.041809082, -0.020721436, -0.03189087, 0.04925537, -0.05493164, 0.02357483, 0.011329651, -0.0546875, -0.027511597, -0.0074806213, 0.028198242, 0.019195557, -0.033813477, 0.01977539, -0.02748108, 0.0231781, -0.005466461, 0.0046577454, 0.017028809, 0.010772705, -0.034576416, 0.022644043, 0.0022125244, 0.0018749237, 0.005794525, 0.0181427, -0.005908966, -0.015060425, 0.017150879, -0.013885498, -0.0065689087, -0.0025310516, 0.012390137, -0.030914307, 0.0101623535, -0.06689453, 0.00642395, 0.0149383545, -0.0043907166, 0.00374794, -0.00016498566, -0.0041046143, 0.011749268, -0.0023174286, -0.018722534, -0.017440796, -0.001739502, 0.040252686, -0.0062789917, 0.007926941, -0.051361084, -0.03994751, -0.036010742, 0.008293152, 0.0055122375, 0.050445557, -0.030471802, -0.03265381, -0.0040626526, -0.023590088, 0.027023315, -0.050750732, -0.021896362, -0.030685425, -0.007446289, -0.032287598, 0.037475586, -0.0064048767, -0.029937744, 0.029663086, 0.02394104, -0.0074501038, -0.0033493042, 0.013084412, 0.00028419495, -0.059661865, -0.04269409, -0.009819031, 0.023345947, -0.012702942, 0.0087509155, 0.024215698, 0.013961792, 0.027862549, -0.038848877, 0.012466431, 0.005054474, -0.030212402, -0.045013428, 0.019439697, 0.027038574, 0.008895874, 0.012054443, 0.019424438, -0.01335144, 0.0037403107, -0.019638062, 0.013961792, -0.0047340393, 0.002609253, 0.0023975372, 0.017044067, 0.025924683, 0.03955078, -0.01448822, -0.0054855347, -0.03555298, -0.017623901, -0.04458618, -0.064941406, 0.09277344, 0.03326416, -0.03564453, 0.040771484, -0.0022182465, 0.03894043, -0.004638672, 0.054351807, -0.029724121, -0.018661499, -0.034179688, 0.003742218, 0.028045654, 0.046813965, -0.032196045, 0.0012588501, 0.037017822, 0.043060303, -0.0013990402, -0.012077332, -0.033599854, -0.009864807, 0.011360168, -0.00047016144, 0.0031661987, -0.005584717, -0.0028533936, 0.024673462, -0.07867432, -0.059570312, -0.06237793, -0.010467529, 0.029708862, -0.048950195, 0.015281677, 0.04711914, 0.004863739, 0.018295288, 0.025741577, -0.025619507, 0.035369873, 0.043914795, -0.027252197, -0.038116455, 0.02911377, -0.00029420853, 0.0069732666, 0.049804688, -0.0019741058, 0.025634766, -0.010467529, -0.011367798, 0.06463623, -0.037719727, -0.02911377, -0.052612305, 0.01411438, -0.055725098, 0.018371582, 0.010116577, 0.048583984, 0.039276123, -0.015792847, 0.019699097, -0.020187378, -0.0099487305, 0.0028686523, -0.020706177, 0.023651123, -0.00080919266, 0.012084961, 0.003458023, -0.016235352, -0.021514893, 0.04699707, -0.01525116, 0.038330078, -0.060577393, -0.050720215, -0.012062073, 0.030441284, -0.0027484894, 0.0058937073, -0.030776978, 0.0024795532, 0.0025234222, -0.022903442, 0.021881104, 0.011703491, 0.01966858, 0.022155762, 0.0005364418, -0.03591919, 0.027389526, -0.06347656, 0.038269043, 0.032318115, 0.024017334, 0.046691895, -0.0010156631, -0.025131226, 0.0050697327, 0.034088135, -0.05328369, 0.026565552, 0.0054473877, 0.08129883, 0.09857178, 0.08288574, -0.017486572, 0.028671265, 0.08874512, -0.026565552, 0.030807495, 0.015556335, 0.0045814514, 0.003112793, -0.035461426, -0.017364502, 0.019119263, 0.000192523, 0.042297363, -0.06347656, 0.04626465, -0.050323486, 0.035247803, -0.06542969, -0.006767273, -0.0057640076, -0.0074920654, -0.021148682, 0.002281189, -0.00037312508, -0.035308838, -0.01826477, -0.031951904, 0.020767212, -0.0026779175, -0.0022659302, 0.016845703, -0.0065345764, -0.036132812, 0.006767273, 0.0032749176, 0.042022705, 0.019577026, -0.013397217, 0.040283203, -0.006629944, 0.0025596619, -0.076171875, -0.032073975, -0.045410156, 0.036590576, -0.002450943, -0.011932373, -0.0031757355, -0.014930725, -0.013496399, -0.059417725, 0.025009155, -0.033325195, 0.03125, -0.002292633, -0.0236969, 0.013328552, 0.014060974, -0.010116577, -0.006084442, -0.011329651, -0.01977539, 0.034240723, 0.027313232, -0.06304932, -0.024887085, -0.039733887, -0.027359009, 0.003124237, 0.0022716522, -0.018615723, 0.026443481, 0.057739258, -0.027313232, -0.033966064, 0.010864258, -0.012748718, -0.0036182404, -0.03652954, -0.02784729, -0.029678345, 0.052734375, 0.017669678, 0.0014791489, -0.008415222, 0.027282715, 0.07043457, 0.023971558, 0.021347046, -0.024734497, 0.042785645, 0.008422852, -0.066345215, -0.017425537, 0.03591919, -0.019500732, -0.015792847, 0.013015747, -0.028198242, -0.043273926, -0.020462036, -0.032165527, -0.052215576, 0.0072517395, -0.05303955, -0.021835327, 0.018859863, -0.08068848, -0.032287598, 0.011505127, -0.018157959, 0.013435364, 0.0317688, 0.034576416, -0.02494812, -0.00012719631, -0.011581421, -0.019378662, 0.012840271, -0.0026435852, 0.00072336197, -0.021514893, -0.009140015, 0.010406494, 0.020111084, 0.012565613, -0.033813477, -0.023986816, 0.023742676, -0.018051147, -0.009971619, 0.0112838745, -0.017196655, 0.021453857, 0.019454956, -0.01586914, 0.009376526, -0.010925293, 0.00856781, -0.020980835, 0.0077667236 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07171v1
calamanCy: A Tagalog Natural Language Processing Toolkit
Lester James V. Miranda
cs.CL
We introduce calamanCy, an open-source toolkit for constructing natural language processing (NLP) pipelines for Tagalog. It is built on top of spaCy, enabling easy experimentation and integration with other frameworks. calamanCy addresses the development gap by providing a consistent API for building NLP applications and offering general-purpose multitask models with out-of-the-box support for dependency parsing, parts-of-speech (POS) tagging, and named entity recognition (NER). calamanCy aims to accelerate the progress of Tagalog NLP by consolidating disjointed resources in a unified framework. The calamanCy toolkit is available on GitHub: https://github.com/ljvmiranda921/calamanCy.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07171v1
2023-11-13T09:06:43
2023-11-13T09:06:43
{ "title": [ 0.0019130707, -0.036315918, -0.017654419, -0.05718994, -0.020523071, 0.008880615, -0.044311523, 0.009536743, -0.008880615, 0.04421997, -0.031555176, 0.021942139, 0.014122009, -0.003540039, -0.032440186, -0.001490593, -0.0056991577, 0.0012845993, -0.034942627, -0.027786255, -0.038757324, -0.047546387, 0.019241333, -0.016433716, 0.020614624, -0.012168884, -0.071777344, -0.019439697, 0.0023174286, -0.022476196, 0.0057754517, 0.022949219, 0.029342651, 0.0041656494, -0.0211792, 0.0009326935, -0.06323242, 0.035003662, 0.00003939867, -0.020477295, 0.027267456, 0.012825012, -0.023483276, 0.01159668, -0.054779053, -0.029754639, -0.035461426, -0.001291275, -0.017166138, -0.013122559, -0.021438599, -0.0077438354, -0.0023422241, 0.031829834, -0.009498596, -0.04663086, -0.060180664, 0.026779175, 0.04272461, 0.03451538, -0.0025672913, -0.054870605, 0.019897461, -0.037261963, -0.04232788, -0.0023269653, -0.03756714, 0.015914917, 0.0473938, -0.033355713, -0.015182495, 0.004398346, -0.0022640228, -0.025665283, -0.031051636, 0.022628784, -0.028686523, -0.0059776306, 0.053222656, -0.03677368, 0.024536133, 0.020370483, -0.005455017, -0.051757812, 0.03665161, -0.041809082, 0.0073661804, 0.0031604767, -0.020202637, -0.05316162, -0.0058517456, 0.027923584, -0.03656006, -0.014770508, -0.027862549, -0.056274414, 0.026107788, 0.03692627, 0.020050049, -0.014549255, -0.036956787, 0.014381409, -0.038085938, -0.012718201, 0.0181427, 0.07299805, -0.012336731, -0.023361206, 0.018081665, 0.016357422, 0.0006122589, 0.00869751, 0.018966675, -0.016067505, -0.012962341, 0.0030918121, -0.0037937164, -0.0058937073, 0.020462036, 0.027526855, -0.015029907, -0.023376465, -0.0048103333, 0.021697998, 0.04071045, -0.00041365623, -0.026000977, 0.03918457, 0.009384155, 0.049621582, 0.0036468506, 0.047302246, -0.10321045, -0.08856201, -0.07696533, 0.033172607, -0.042175293, -0.010124207, -0.0041122437, -0.04171753, 0.052856445, 0.022872925, 0.042816162, 0.025985718, -0.03302002, -0.029129028, 0.030075073, 0.04220581, -0.026016235, -0.050872803, 0.019760132, -0.0019407272, -0.005393982, -0.014099121, -0.0078048706, -0.017486572, -0.07495117, -0.0029029846, 0.04397583, 0.006832123, 0.02116394, -0.016983032, -0.019180298, 0.014038086, 0.038269043, 0.009437561, 0.005619049, 0.027297974, 0.010047913, 0.022140503, -0.019042969, 0.038879395, -0.006778717, -0.016723633, -0.005428314, -0.009933472, -0.00078964233, 0.0395813, 0.020004272, -0.012466431, 0.0009303093, -0.03817749, 0.013000488, 0.024642944, -0.05557251, -0.020431519, 0.016494751, 0.03414917, 0.05126953, 0.026123047, -0.026275635, 0.0049934387, -0.052337646, 0.0047912598, -0.05355835, 0.004940033, 0.05810547, 0.05871582, -0.0043678284, -0.027572632, -0.021377563, 0.023162842, -0.046020508, 0.024551392, -0.050689697, -0.0020980835, -0.033416748, 0.023071289, 0.029159546, 0.040985107, 0.010223389, -0.043945312, 0.025268555, 0.007167816, -0.00032830238, -0.066711426, 0.0054855347, 0.025177002, 0.013427734, -0.019943237, 0.03363037, -0.034423828, 0.04397583, 0.043395996, 0.009162903, 0.027786255, -0.015106201, -0.0055274963, 0.031051636, 0.027877808, 0.0236969, 0.0007658005, 0.048706055, 0.0231781, -0.030700684, 0.0018291473, 0.0005106926, -0.039489746, -0.0071144104, 0.036865234, 0.0055999756, -0.02810669, -0.03262329, -0.011856079, 0.04119873, 0.0018959045, 0.016937256, -0.0039596558, 0.028869629, 0.006500244, 0.036102295, -0.014427185, 0.05404663, 0.051940918, 0.021499634, 0.036010742, -0.02192688, -0.019577026, 0.003047943, -0.022445679, 0.022445679, -0.011703491, -0.016540527, 0.012931824, -0.0395813, 0.0036582947, -0.0019292831, 0.018035889, 0.00019037724, -0.0063095093, 0.011650085, 0.023849487, 0.021713257, -0.03277588, -0.007259369, -0.005428314, -0.00983429, 0.0064430237, 0.02281189, -0.06793213, -0.015388489, 0.034057617, 0.0597229, -0.006000519, -0.01927185, 0.00040745735, 0.046875, -0.005630493, -0.060394287, -0.04421997, -0.0030841827, 0.07739258, 0.0113220215, 0.0012636185, 0.005607605, 0.029724121, 0.10205078, 0.05847168, -0.035339355, 0.009613037, -0.049346924, 0.011207581, 0.041870117, -0.050872803, 0.02319336, -0.0066108704, 0.01373291, 0.03213501, 0.0017242432, 0.009567261, -0.061706543, 0.037078857, 0.00011330843, -0.0015230179, -0.057434082, -0.06677246, -0.03173828, -0.007221222, -0.07989502, -0.031463623, 0.06451416, -0.016479492, -0.0052719116, -0.016937256, 0.00026488304, -0.048553467, -0.008201599, -0.009666443, -0.032806396, 0.043945312, 0.040863037, 0.048583984, -0.03842163, 0.025390625, 0.009689331, 0.045013428, -0.004825592, 0.011192322, -0.014137268, 0.022064209, 0.019058228, 0.011238098, 0.005191803, -0.04067993, -0.0014238358, -0.03137207, -0.0019397736, -0.009414673, -0.026229858, 0.010643005, 0.0040130615, 0.016708374, 0.012916565, 0.018157959, 0.07287598, -0.040924072, -0.049743652, 0.013847351, 0.0032958984, -0.020339966, 0.024658203, 0.015075684, 0.011360168, -0.055603027, -0.009162903, -0.04144287, -0.046966553, 0.010864258, 0.019424438, 0.03164673, -0.03741455, -0.025634766, -0.026016235, 0.021072388, 0.020523071, 0.009681702, -0.032348633, -0.04385376, -0.020324707, -0.024734497, -0.008972168, -0.00085926056, -0.011253357, 0.04031372, 0.047973633, 0.009246826, -0.023834229, -0.043823242, 0.014038086, 0.026763916, -0.007347107, -0.03302002, -0.017059326, -0.010940552, 0.0063934326, 0.0014333725, -0.036712646, 0.018920898, -0.05847168, 0.020935059, 0.011787415, -0.0006122589, 0.003578186, 0.022277832, -0.064086914, 0.052520752, -0.022369385, -0.010292053, 0.04135132, 0.00258255, 0.027648926, 0.0023651123, 0.033843994, -0.022338867, 0.0069999695, -0.06329346, -0.084350586, 0.005756378, -0.014724731, 0.016540527, 0.019042969, -0.026733398, -0.019241333, 0.006160736, -0.020568848, 0.032196045, 0.027755737, 0.019821167, 0.021835327, -0.025680542, 0.013404846, -0.041015625, -0.020248413, 0.02027893, 0.0037460327, 0.021820068, 0.0107803345, 0.023147583, 0.06048584, -0.02154541, -0.014480591, -0.014579773, -0.024810791, 0.010932922, -0.02305603, -0.019226074, -0.005290985, -0.023025513, 0.023086548, 0.03475952, -0.02128601, 0.013458252, -0.0035915375, -0.0064315796, -0.03213501, -0.050567627, 0.00831604, 0.026367188, -0.002811432, -0.049438477, -0.013961792, -0.02947998, -0.029418945, -0.0011806488, 0.05480957, 0.022415161, -0.02557373, 0.01007843, -0.0018596649, -0.00003385544, 0.03387451, -0.04345703, 0.006126404, -0.008094788, 0.009643555, -0.036254883, -0.019927979, 0.005378723, 0.005176544, 0.008888245, -0.018951416, 0.0099487305, 0.0011043549, -0.10394287, -0.014556885, 0.008125305, -0.09100342, -0.051483154, 0.031829834, -0.052947998, -0.016555786, -0.01878357, 0.04815674, -0.02835083, 0.012550354, -0.023223877, 0.0026226044, -0.021759033, 0.015792847, -0.0670166, -0.03881836, 0.08093262, -0.032440186, -0.021713257, 0.03060913, -0.0368042, -0.025482178, 0.01184082, 0.031677246, 0.037017822, 0.009506226, 0.027694702, -0.048583984, 0.011054993, -0.036987305, 0.025009155, -0.01499939, -0.032043457, 0.0076408386, 0.036743164, 0.025039673, 0.045532227, -0.012519836, 0.03970337, -0.008621216, -0.009178162, -0.049865723, 0.018737793, -0.0072631836, -0.024368286, 0.022247314, 0.007820129, 0.0016326904, 0.020111084, -0.0015649796, 0.014122009, -0.00957489, -0.011306763, 0.031982422, 0.023971558, -0.020828247, -0.032592773, 0.013786316, 0.045715332, -0.017349243, 0.043395996, -0.017868042, 0.046691895, -0.00957489, 0.01411438, -0.022735596, -0.004322052, -0.053100586, -0.012969971, -0.049743652, 0.010360718, -0.023651123, 0.005859375, -0.031555176, 0.032165527, 0.033996582, -0.0040779114, -0.029296875, -0.018112183, 0.010032654, -0.011924744, 0.01991272, -0.037841797, -0.012680054, -0.005958557, -0.11004639, -0.055786133, -0.070251465, 0.029129028, -0.007347107, 0.024734497, 0.015838623, 0.027236938, 0.056365967, 0.049804688, 0.039367676, -0.02999878, -0.046722412, 0.029449463, -0.046081543, 0.024230957, -0.014045715, -0.00048327446, -0.040771484, -0.023910522, -0.0010623932, 0.027893066, 0.0034656525, -0.031463623, -0.024337769, -0.0095825195, 0.01576233, 0.020355225, 0.03665161, 0.00027918816, -0.0010633469, 0.0151901245, -0.0035133362, -0.047454834, 0.03729248, 0.0099105835, 0.023406982, -0.0041122437, 0.004623413, 0.0058135986, 0.024887085, 0.009963989, -0.020950317, 0.02670288, -0.014411926, -0.013870239, -0.00036096573, 0.04776001, -0.03375244, -0.013015747, 0.0034313202, -0.03652954, 0.028839111, -0.051696777, 0.014526367, 0.031799316, 0.0211792, 0.025344849, -0.020004272, 0.020614624, 0.013626099, 0.0059318542, -0.0362854, -0.0025024414, 0.021438599, 0.011795044, -0.020095825, -0.027160645, -0.002632141, 0.014305115, 0.007381439, 0.05709839, 0.008575439, 0.0045394897, 0.019485474, 0.0048065186, -0.0028190613, -0.03265381, -0.046905518, -0.026306152, 0.0006580353, 0.03225708, 0.043914795, 0.020309448, -0.053253174, -0.01864624, -0.024169922, -0.01612854, 0.025802612, -0.048706055, 0.004447937, 0.07293701, -0.0020656586, 0.036468506, -0.02482605, -0.013900757, 0.04336548, 0.018875122, -0.0026512146, -0.017242432, 0.010559082, -0.055755615, -0.015380859, 0.006416321, 0.040496826, 0.015991211, -0.010116577, 0.00598526, -0.0020999908, -0.037719727, 0.021591187, 0.0121536255, -0.010673523, 0.02130127, -0.04675293, 0.05532837, -0.025527954, -0.02810669, 0.0104522705, -0.049194336, -0.04058838, -0.027740479, -0.030517578, -0.06951904, 0.026306152, -0.026535034, -0.061798096, -0.010948181, 0.048431396, 0.023803711, -0.018661499, -0.00248909, 0.03955078, -0.012016296, 0.010658264, 0.023742676, -0.060943604, 0.036590576, 0.0029144287, 0.024337769, 0.035858154, 0.0074272156, -0.036865234, 0.0036563873, -0.013473511, -0.005870819, -0.0047798157, 0.0050621033, 0.0063056946, 0.007896423, -0.04373169, -0.047851562, -0.02960205, -0.028823853, 0.005935669, -0.043273926, -0.028182983, -0.02381897, -0.013717651, 0.015838623, -0.02507019, 0.059326172, -0.0023212433, -0.010955811, 0.028839111, -0.037902832, 0.0020580292, 0.01209259, 0.042510986, -0.07281494, -0.06878662, -0.0013065338, 0.032409668, 0.023605347, -0.013687134, 0.02911377, 0.03338623, 0.028869629, -0.01335144, 0.0046310425, 0.06021118, -0.06512451, -0.07434082, -0.034057617, -0.0127334595, -0.060913086, 0.022949219, 0.034301758, -0.022338867, -0.011756897, -0.09564209, -0.034362793, 0.0018224716, 0.056365967, 0.03463745, 0.038208008, -0.015625, 0.03277588, -0.017730713, 0.006084442, -0.022628784, 0.0058631897, -0.010795593, -0.023864746, 0.033966064, 0.030014038, -0.021972656, -0.0082473755, 0.006717682, 0.024490356, -0.029327393, 0.08123779, -0.02067566, -0.009735107, 0.0038795471, -0.033355713, 0.026367188, -0.03265381, -0.023895264, 0.022781372, -0.025604248, 0.06567383, 0.0052833557, 0.029129028, 0.046081543, 0.030883789, -0.004585266, -0.00027894974, 0.016540527, -0.01751709, 0.013435364, -0.034210205, 0.00447464, -0.007865906, -0.007713318, -0.07080078, -0.0018672943, 0.043914795, 0.014251709, -0.03353882, 0.0113220215, -0.028671265, 0.023422241, 0.005180359, 0.039154053, 0.051940918, -0.043548584, -0.015151978, -0.029129028, -0.016235352, 0.050231934, 0.04788208, -0.0017414093, -0.0011262894, -0.030517578, -0.007881165, 0.03378296, -0.029800415, 0.019302368, -0.017486572, 0.0005297661, -0.034454346, 0.03656006, 0.007331848, 0.005355835, 0.06286621, 0.06768799, -0.009414673, -0.020477295, 0.029754639, -0.009277344, -0.0048217773, -0.0055351257, 0.018066406, -0.029693604, 0.04244995, -0.017044067, -0.041900635, -0.02041626, 0.015319824, 0.037872314, -0.03591919, -0.013053894, 0.016418457, 0.025115967, 0.003967285, 0.008232117, -0.043060303, -0.018737793, -0.015213013, -0.004878998, 0.007598877, 0.02859497, 0.04019165, -0.0017471313, 0.023162842, -0.03692627, -0.013923645, 0.015625, 0.0020046234, 0.039276123, 0.003528595, 0.047790527, -0.02935791, -0.04638672, 0.0007638931, 0.015403748, -0.049621582, -0.0065727234, 0.044799805, 0.022018433, 0.013412476, 0.051727295, 0.033081055, -0.00390625, -0.017700195, -0.02017212, -0.016906738, 0.0074539185, -0.035339355, 0.026519775, -0.040222168, -0.050079346, 0.017578125, -0.08886719, 0.0256958, -0.0592041, 0.030822754, -0.028335571, 0.03793335, -0.010391235, -0.035064697, -0.02696228, 0.0019016266, 0.021514893, 0.0007481575, -0.003232956, -0.08129883, 0.008865356, -0.024658203, -0.0037765503, -0.014297485, 0.012519836, 0.07897949, -0.041168213, -0.10144043, 0.031433105, 0.01586914, 0.0546875, -0.05291748, 0.0104522705, 0.04623413, -0.037078857, -0.0024929047, -0.036376953, -0.0317688, -0.01158905, 0.004749298, -0.026367188, -0.00083494186, -0.0017976761, -0.029754639, -0.08166504, -0.0038433075, -0.021408081, -0.036987305, 0.009819031, 0.01158905, -0.015106201, -0.037231445, -0.0050354004, -0.027740479, -0.0005393028, -0.008506775, -0.01474762, 0.033843994, 0.014915466, -0.013137817, -0.029281616, -0.0049705505, 0.0039405823, 0.023513794, -0.04159546, 0.017120361, -0.017700195, 0.04360962, -0.03161621, -0.05795288, -0.0038204193, 0.037475586, 0.013656616, 0.019866943, 0.010848999, 0.004447937, -0.0043296814, 0.0031833649, 0.00016188622, -0.011871338, 0.0047340393, -0.0032596588, 0.029525757, 0.0077209473, -0.025283813, 0.019332886, 0.007282257, -0.021026611, 0.040496826, -0.028961182, 0.02973938, 0.027755737, -0.03363037, 0.049468994, -0.017242432, -0.027359009, -0.074523926, 0.025817871, -0.007255554, 0.05215454, -0.03010559, 0.05618286, 0.019958496, 0.039154053, -0.014328003, -0.07800293, 0.06945801, 0.06173706, 0.017349243, 0.029220581, 0.016235352, -0.03010559, -0.007865906, 0.0042037964, 0.0014572144, 0.025650024, -0.0007801056, -0.013076782, 0.008178711, -0.06323242, -0.027862549, -0.01108551, -0.026290894, 0.026931763, -0.05456543, 0.03970337, -0.028289795, -0.010444641, 0.0037937164, 0.009857178, 0.0011892319, -0.030136108, -0.0088272095, 0.0025482178, 0.008857727, 0.0178833 ], "summary": [ -0.0038051605, -0.052734375, -0.014862061, -0.08843994, -0.031463623, 0.029190063, -0.062164307, 0.043640137, -0.013717651, 0.030685425, -0.0368042, 0.02407837, -0.019515991, 0.013465881, -0.014152527, -0.022598267, -0.0013389587, -0.028381348, -0.02658081, -0.023468018, -0.029678345, -0.045776367, 0.002904892, -0.04840088, 0.015419006, -0.0023479462, -0.022735596, 0.008201599, 0.022506714, 0.013664246, 0.01285553, 0.005130768, 0.03326416, 0.0035934448, -0.02468872, -0.020309448, -0.02897644, 0.014328003, -0.0017881393, -0.025817871, 0.036590576, -0.0020713806, -0.031951904, 0.021224976, -0.038269043, -0.023330688, 0.009513855, -0.03074646, 0.00299263, -0.044769287, -0.012207031, -0.02180481, -0.0028266907, -0.008926392, -0.027008057, -0.04260254, -0.08123779, 0.004524231, 0.01701355, 0.0579834, 0.0070877075, -0.04660034, 0.0017108917, -0.029083252, -0.049316406, -0.00048685074, -0.03353882, -0.0014982224, 0.018814087, -0.054504395, -0.015068054, 0.0043563843, -0.0013942719, -0.0368042, -0.02154541, 0.07525635, -0.031066895, 0.02973938, 0.04434204, -0.04257202, 0.034576416, 0.0592041, -0.037139893, -0.04824829, 0.047668457, -0.0418396, 0.009132385, -0.020935059, 0.0003414154, -0.028182983, -0.0066604614, 0.057556152, -0.035064697, 0.0014305115, -0.016052246, -0.029296875, -0.015716553, -0.038879395, 0.005706787, 0.025314331, 0.03286743, -0.045288086, 0.06036377, -0.0126571655, -0.020996094, 0.06829834, -0.0146102905, -0.025985718, -0.010826111, 0.016860962, 0.016082764, -0.07684326, 0.006755829, -0.05267334, -0.004673004, 0.012313843, -0.0019626617, 0.03366089, 0.03152466, 0.032104492, -0.0055122375, 0.0024604797, -0.011077881, 0.02255249, 0.026306152, 0.0107803345, 0.00029206276, 0.009414673, 0.02633667, 0.026565552, -0.013694763, 0.024383545, -0.038635254, -0.019104004, -0.036468506, -0.004547119, -0.017364502, -0.03149414, 0.013137817, -0.036895752, 0.057281494, 0.040283203, 0.06427002, 0.05050659, -0.031341553, -0.034729004, -0.012931824, 0.034729004, 0.02204895, -0.013832092, 0.011352539, -0.016571045, 0.0005478859, 0.00018393993, 0.04248047, -0.03265381, 0.00079488754, -0.009994507, 0.040496826, -0.0050849915, 0.0020599365, -0.015029907, -0.001288414, 0.042541504, 0.0037269592, 0.017913818, 0.029464722, 0.00945282, 0.017150879, -0.012931824, -0.0087890625, 0.08258057, 0.022018433, 0.002506256, 0.011543274, -0.030563354, -0.011253357, 0.07678223, 0.028930664, -0.021102905, 0.008033752, -0.041168213, 0.07904053, -0.0044898987, -0.02671814, -0.0057907104, 0.0016613007, 0.022460938, 0.04598999, 0.008926392, -0.00447464, -0.022384644, -0.0317688, 0.007396698, -0.02720642, 0.007320404, 0.054016113, 0.048980713, -0.0093688965, -0.044952393, -0.016983032, 0.032226562, -0.03817749, 0.0071487427, -0.075683594, 0.017745972, -0.024490356, 0.033966064, 0.0052223206, -0.0027885437, -0.01838684, -0.12347412, 0.03756714, 0.057647705, 0.01058197, -0.011604309, -0.0041618347, 0.033966064, 0.045074463, -0.0124053955, 0.071899414, -0.01374054, 0.07330322, 0.033813477, -0.00969696, 0.01586914, -0.022521973, 0.005874634, -0.007411957, 0.021621704, -0.00724411, 0.0038642883, 0.0039596558, 0.020828247, -0.021194458, 0.015586853, 0.0027503967, -0.0181427, -0.0012750626, 0.021331787, 0.023468018, 0.0017967224, -0.062927246, -0.06500244, 0.05847168, 0.028076172, 0.022369385, -0.04510498, -0.03390503, -0.013557434, 0.017028809, -0.0058250427, 0.020339966, 0.038238525, -0.020339966, 0.008293152, -0.042419434, -0.07952881, 0.022583008, -0.02494812, 0.037231445, -0.009384155, -0.050567627, 0.025222778, -0.015113831, -0.023712158, 0.012878418, 0.005264282, -0.006954193, -0.03579712, 0.023498535, 0.025634766, 0.0061454773, -0.010719299, 0.0038280487, -0.018371582, -0.040527344, 0.012588501, 0.001613617, -0.03729248, -0.0019893646, 0.046539307, 0.024871826, -0.008132935, -0.01852417, -0.016571045, 0.023956299, 0.0037212372, -0.035308838, -0.021347046, -0.032989502, 0.10479736, 0.025878906, 0.026733398, 0.052001953, 0.03189087, 0.078125, 0.014503479, -0.0022449493, -0.0028247833, -0.0055274963, 0.035949707, 0.014015198, -0.033172607, 0.019317627, -0.008987427, 0.0057411194, 0.031280518, 0.026306152, -0.002796173, -0.0368042, 0.025146484, 0.006164551, 0.024978638, -0.040985107, -0.061065674, -0.034179688, 0.024398804, -0.06359863, -0.027694702, 0.06359863, 0.005962372, 0.04095459, -0.0077934265, 0.014030457, -0.06933594, 0.025222778, -0.007472992, -0.03274536, 0.036102295, -0.018814087, 0.023330688, -0.019012451, 0.0473938, -0.010734558, 0.036102295, 0.009727478, 0.035583496, 0.01247406, 0.0058250427, 0.02998352, 0.01499176, 0.011230469, 0.0063285828, -0.008728027, -0.026397705, -0.012901306, 0.0029277802, 0.0418396, 0.021957397, -0.021942139, 0.021240234, 0.020965576, 0.017745972, 0.023849487, 0.002122879, -0.029663086, -0.018173218, -0.012664795, -0.06536865, 0.016281128, 0.0022888184, -0.014282227, -0.030410767, -0.014595032, -0.00447464, -0.031829834, 0.00067186356, 0.03012085, 0.023925781, 0.010612488, -0.00390625, -0.01737976, 0.009559631, -0.0055885315, 0.0008211136, 0.041290283, -0.037475586, -0.0063934326, 0.022109985, -0.017456055, 0.025543213, -0.023117065, 0.04522705, 0.052703857, 0.026504517, 0.0014972687, -0.03543091, 0.012031555, 0.015945435, -0.017608643, -0.021621704, 0.008300781, -0.016357422, 0.0051727295, 0.0065994263, -0.02809143, 0.036468506, -0.020858765, -0.0058174133, -0.00447464, -0.015670776, -0.0020484924, 0.0015134811, -0.019973755, 0.045959473, 0.004180908, -0.006362915, 0.017044067, -0.065979004, 0.03375244, -0.032043457, 0.05014038, -0.04977417, 0.010314941, -0.06958008, -0.054473877, -0.0070724487, -0.043151855, 0.0446167, 0.031097412, -0.031280518, -0.008636475, 0.0067214966, -0.03286743, 0.0010757446, 0.0073776245, 0.024246216, 0.045837402, -0.0076522827, -0.013244629, -0.023864746, -0.009170532, 0.03744507, 0.01991272, 0.038208008, 0.005622864, -0.016021729, 0.027191162, -0.03604126, -0.0020122528, -0.021728516, -0.055786133, -0.019714355, -0.057159424, 0.007911682, -0.01939392, -0.010383606, 0.06994629, 0.01586914, -0.0099105835, 0.003686905, 0.029968262, -0.0032234192, -0.033935547, -0.058258057, 0.01184082, 0.025894165, 0.07067871, -0.05014038, -0.05368042, -0.021759033, -0.010131836, 0.0017051697, 0.07269287, 0.055725098, -0.07354736, 0.053527832, 0.02017212, -0.044830322, 0.10638428, -0.07928467, -0.019897461, 0.012718201, 0.028335571, 0.013946533, -0.019165039, 0.005882263, 0.0024356842, 0.009925842, -0.034301758, 0.017913818, -0.014076233, -0.046813965, -0.027130127, 0.010444641, -0.06011963, -0.0836792, 0.015670776, -0.03656006, 0.009735107, -0.008476257, 0.03677368, 0.016525269, 0.027160645, -0.034301758, -0.012428284, 0.061462402, 0.03161621, -0.020370483, -0.03665161, 0.010284424, -0.025924683, -0.029327393, -0.0021972656, -0.0036640167, 0.015396118, 0.022613525, 0.010597229, -0.014518738, 0.024169922, -0.024215698, -0.038604736, 0.00749588, -0.037017822, 0.024154663, -0.05130005, -0.036834717, -0.008255005, 0.008033752, 0.012008667, 0.05026245, 0.0071144104, 0.021697998, -0.0067710876, -0.016326904, -0.0034637451, 0.014312744, -0.022354126, 0.010276794, 0.007511139, 0.024612427, -0.02709961, -0.042938232, 0.028045654, -0.030334473, -0.028839111, -0.044830322, 0.048797607, 0.066711426, -0.008888245, -0.0076904297, 0.012557983, 0.09863281, -0.0035591125, 0.004184723, -0.017745972, -0.007858276, -0.02204895, -0.017944336, -0.03366089, -0.00712204, -0.028533936, -0.038269043, -0.02684021, 0.015777588, -0.0028076172, -0.010566711, -0.0473938, 0.04067993, 0.0049705505, 0.0060920715, -0.010498047, -0.02571106, 0.007007599, 0.0026245117, 0.02961731, -0.009017944, -0.013931274, 0.007347107, -0.07940674, -0.014083862, -0.08331299, -0.019088745, -0.037902832, 0.030151367, 0.0013036728, 0.027404785, 0.027908325, 0.07067871, 0.040039062, 0.0019836426, -0.06817627, 0.011627197, -0.042633057, 0.076293945, -0.047576904, 0.004180908, -0.049835205, -0.004501343, -0.00919342, 0.03286743, 0.006500244, -0.043945312, -0.033355713, 0.024765015, -0.03277588, 0.00945282, 0.018875122, -0.007789612, -0.026672363, -0.0047912598, -0.0016117096, -0.021194458, 0.036468506, 0.021255493, -0.023788452, 0.008216858, -0.019836426, -0.010276794, 0.006591797, 0.00017380714, 0.01197052, -0.0018987656, -0.010559082, 0.008804321, -0.018737793, 0.07635498, 0.025619507, -0.044769287, 0.019256592, -0.013412476, -0.014350891, 0.016693115, -0.0105896, 0.058013916, 0.051818848, 0.030288696, -0.014785767, 0.020629883, 0.008758545, -0.025466919, -0.041809082, -0.009292603, 0.011367798, 0.012931824, -0.009666443, -0.025894165, 0.00340271, 0.0025577545, 0.010101318, 0.021621704, -0.017837524, 0.015579224, 0.046417236, 0.020553589, 0.017486572, -0.01600647, -0.03289795, -0.040618896, -0.0038261414, 0.03930664, 0.061309814, 0.038635254, -0.03842163, 0.027420044, -0.0075263977, 0.008430481, -0.026763916, -0.00121212, -0.019210815, 0.015419006, -0.04336548, 0.025863647, -0.0029392242, -0.037139893, -0.004722595, -0.018371582, -0.02760315, -0.020385742, -0.021469116, -0.05731201, -0.0018758774, -0.0023078918, 0.00063848495, 0.031982422, -0.022598267, 0.0060806274, -0.026153564, 0.021636963, 0.01876831, 0.011985779, -0.007282257, 0.026977539, -0.04196167, 0.043670654, -0.033691406, 0.00041508675, -0.001080513, -0.007598877, -0.027236938, -0.019210815, 0.0032863617, -0.037109375, 0.023132324, -0.02178955, -0.038909912, 0.04660034, 0.023544312, -0.013320923, -0.023788452, 0.036132812, 0.0071868896, 0.026855469, -0.024215698, 0.040374756, -0.06555176, 0.028427124, -0.03250122, 0.025146484, 0.0053977966, -0.0065307617, -0.02885437, 0.01626587, -0.028366089, -0.010978699, -0.038391113, -0.011253357, -0.010353088, 0.044555664, -0.05114746, -0.05142212, -0.012245178, -0.016967773, 0.01965332, -0.07574463, -0.023452759, -0.04876709, 0.01008606, 0.0234375, -0.024719238, 0.015930176, -0.00217247, -0.026641846, 0.019348145, -0.048614502, 0.013038635, -0.014251709, 0.031051636, -0.07006836, -0.012817383, -0.012573242, 0.050201416, 0.016189575, 0.0054740906, -0.019638062, 0.013786316, 0.034606934, -0.04019165, -0.013397217, 0.034851074, -0.056915283, -0.06738281, -0.018112183, 0.020736694, -0.032958984, -0.042785645, 0.033599854, -0.03112793, 0.023803711, -0.09564209, 0.0019435883, -0.005886078, 0.021194458, 0.04550171, 0.036254883, -0.017333984, 0.033447266, 0.015525818, -0.013198853, 0.020706177, -0.0013074875, 0.0074272156, -0.020324707, 0.021759033, 0.020339966, -0.0119018555, 0.00093221664, -0.015556335, 0.0158844, -0.030532837, 0.07891846, -0.030914307, 0.0062713623, 0.027313232, -0.019088745, 0.001543045, -0.03149414, -0.026504517, -0.025390625, 0.008293152, 0.046020508, 0.026260376, -0.0021915436, 0.005180359, 0.011314392, 0.008155823, 0.00086450577, 0.03866577, -0.0070991516, 0.021713257, 0.011886597, -0.036132812, -0.0032444, -0.04864502, -0.02116394, 0.0032348633, 0.02381897, -0.021560669, -0.0029010773, 0.0015220642, -0.06982422, 0.034576416, -0.06842041, 0.08319092, -0.005672455, -0.02305603, -0.03543091, -0.0055351257, 0.0024375916, 0.030548096, 0.05230713, 0.012374878, 0.0047302246, -0.006790161, -0.00048971176, 0.03994751, -0.059051514, 0.0284729, 0.006072998, -0.008491516, -0.0023517609, 0.06573486, 0.034454346, 0.02709961, 0.034332275, 0.04925537, -0.013908386, -0.016784668, 0.03274536, -0.0099487305, 0.018737793, -0.021194458, -0.022399902, 0.008613586, 0.01625061, 0.0041656494, -0.006793976, 0.0058670044, -0.017730713, 0.033111572, -0.038970947, -0.040039062, -0.014717102, 0.04006958, 0.012199402, 0.009849548, -0.03050232, -0.019638062, -0.014015198, -0.013969421, 0.025787354, 0.0056877136, 0.009918213, -0.007789612, 0.017044067, -0.03414917, -0.015426636, 0.006828308, 0.024536133, 0.039611816, -0.014915466, 0.06762695, -0.0036315918, -0.028686523, 0.0027370453, 0.024230957, -0.05731201, 0.00919342, 0.061157227, 0.021759033, 0.04763794, 0.058654785, -0.0055274963, 0.020111084, 0.02508545, -0.012825012, -0.024795532, -0.057159424, -0.007446289, -0.0059280396, -0.025726318, 0.0050201416, -0.00712204, -0.038360596, -0.009216309, -0.033447266, 0.028457642, -0.0019435883, 0.048095703, -0.06161499, 0.01108551, 0.006374359, 0.046905518, 0.03375244, -0.021377563, -0.0013427734, -0.09082031, 0.013000488, -0.052856445, -0.024169922, -0.030227661, 0.01763916, 0.071899414, -0.021316528, -0.06817627, 0.010238647, 0.014930725, 0.04937744, -0.04309082, 0.010276794, 0.05404663, -0.011154175, -0.03137207, -0.07019043, -0.013175964, -0.021331787, 0.021011353, -0.055236816, 0.013999939, -0.0018692017, -0.052612305, -0.07745361, 0.00023889542, -0.019577026, -0.03164673, 0.005859375, 0.0065956116, 0.016845703, 0.0057907104, 0.0038471222, 0.0070991516, -0.0340271, -0.027313232, -0.010894775, 0.029876709, 0.01828003, -0.010307312, -0.003025055, 0.0084991455, 0.011421204, 0.0021762848, -0.06866455, 0.033203125, -0.044769287, 0.025543213, -0.016830444, -0.035003662, 0.014411926, -0.0040512085, 0.019195557, -0.006664276, -0.021011353, -0.003955841, 0.02067566, 0.025848389, 0.01713562, -0.014816284, -0.009902954, 0.013931274, 0.00983429, 0.00008302927, 0.0016174316, -0.008369446, -0.001115799, -0.014556885, 0.030563354, -0.01335907, 0.024139404, 0.012573242, -0.034057617, 0.044281006, -0.017318726, -0.026290894, -0.03225708, -0.016082764, 0.009033203, 0.05734253, -0.038879395, 0.026992798, 0.018173218, 0.028762817, -0.014457703, -0.049316406, 0.026977539, 0.01701355, 0.020736694, -0.0259552, 0.0340271, -0.014923096, -0.021057129, 0.007499695, 0.02368164, 0.038024902, -0.023468018, -0.028869629, -0.0013074875, -0.04147339, -0.01626587, 0.006542206, -0.025665283, 0.023727417, -0.051361084, 0.027175903, -0.014282227, -0.013999939, 0.014228821, 0.011619568, 0.005443573, -0.016616821, 0.03717041, 0.007282257, -0.019927979, 0.032287598 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07167v1
STEER: Unified Style Transfer with Expert Reinforcement
Skyler Hallinan, Faeze Brahman, Ximing Lu, Jaehun Jung, Sean Welleck, Yejin Choi
cs.CL, cs.AI
While text style transfer has many applications across natural language processing, the core premise of transferring from a single source style is unrealistic in a real-world setting. In this work, we focus on arbitrary style transfer: rewriting a text from an arbitrary, unknown style to a target style. We propose STEER: Unified Style Transfer with Expert Reinforcement, a unified frame-work developed to overcome the challenge of limited parallel data for style transfer. STEER involves automatically generating a corpus of style-transfer pairs using a product of experts during decoding. The generated offline data is then used to pre-train an initial policy before switching to online, off-policy reinforcement learning for further improvements via fine-grained reward signals. STEER is unified and can transfer to multiple target styles from an arbitrary, unknown source style, making it particularly flexible and efficient. Experimental results on a challenging dataset with text from a diverse set of styles demonstrate state-of-the-art results compared to competitive baselines. Remarkably, STEER outperforms the 175B parameter instruction-tuned GPT-3 on overall style transfer quality, despite being 226 times smaller in size. We also show STEER is robust, maintaining its style transfer capabilities on out-of-domain data, and surpassing nearly all baselines across various styles. The success of our method highlights the potential of RL algorithms when augmented with controllable decoding to overcome the challenge of limited data supervision.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07167v1
2023-11-13T09:02:30
2023-11-13T09:02:30
{ "title": [ -0.022232056, -0.0054397583, -0.041534424, -0.06088257, 0.010070801, 0.008201599, -0.03564453, -0.010612488, -0.01234436, 0.0362854, 0.012519836, 0.01687622, 0.02027893, -0.032165527, -0.00025057793, 0.025177002, 0.00459671, 0.023147583, -0.03314209, -0.044952393, -0.030899048, -0.055114746, 0.022384644, 0.066467285, 0.042755127, -0.023544312, -0.08148193, 0.023605347, -0.02394104, -0.02468872, -0.002729416, 0.007381439, 0.04348755, 0.051849365, -0.051116943, 0.014808655, -0.060394287, 0.020523071, -0.022369385, 0.03567505, 0.032562256, -0.007621765, -0.048858643, -0.011116028, -0.07098389, 0.0027885437, -0.03375244, 0.006816864, -0.027786255, 0.04522705, -0.0017023087, 0.022247314, -0.023406982, 0.044769287, 0.023483276, -0.018157959, -0.036254883, -0.0074386597, 0.028671265, 0.07891846, 0.037597656, -0.05117798, 0.009284973, -0.0552063, -0.026535034, -0.022888184, -0.023986816, 0.03161621, 0.07159424, 0.014823914, -0.022094727, 0.0158844, 0.012870789, -0.035705566, -0.007972717, 0.050811768, 0.005088806, 0.025177002, 0.044189453, -0.02772522, 0.008255005, -0.021377563, -0.0017557144, -0.014533997, 0.015525818, -0.03652954, -0.010658264, -0.013702393, -0.02696228, -0.08001709, -0.00033855438, -0.025375366, -0.030838013, 0.0134887695, -0.018539429, -0.03265381, -0.033172607, 0.0041656494, 0.01373291, 0.026489258, -0.0034122467, 0.008201599, 0.009033203, -0.0390625, 0.019927979, 0.0076560974, 0.0012350082, 0.0024299622, 0.02949524, 0.0317688, -0.0181427, 0.07067871, 0.023040771, 0.048065186, -0.009017944, -0.020202637, -0.022918701, 0.023422241, -0.018417358, 0.050048828, -0.0041923523, -0.020523071, 0.022140503, -0.0028591156, 0.01663208, 0.009529114, -0.03543091, -0.021987915, -0.007835388, -0.020401001, 0.010513306, 0.089782715, -0.07910156, -0.08721924, -0.062072754, 0.05166626, -0.0090789795, -0.0025730133, -0.031021118, 0.018722534, -0.014511108, -0.017120361, -0.00064611435, -0.036621094, 0.019348145, 0.027114868, 0.06518555, -0.017166138, -0.046203613, -0.04611206, -0.0019397736, -0.0050964355, 0.029312134, 0.014122009, -0.006427765, -0.025375366, -0.08770752, -0.026367188, 0.031219482, -0.00077676773, 0.0019798279, 0.0051879883, 0.010025024, -0.0038204193, 0.057159424, -0.0062789917, -0.03387451, 0.02003479, 0.017822266, 0.081970215, -0.04574585, 0.0025081635, 0.026916504, 0.013092041, -0.024246216, 0.012908936, 0.015075684, 0.030197144, 0.026855469, -0.042266846, 0.009170532, -0.017150879, 0.03237915, 0.040893555, -0.029663086, -0.0635376, 0.012542725, -0.024398804, 0.026290894, 0.035491943, -0.02482605, 0.019348145, -0.05130005, -0.04864502, -0.047302246, -0.0022640228, 0.031707764, 0.047576904, 0.003917694, 0.019470215, -0.030899048, -0.018875122, -0.016113281, 0.00932312, -0.01234436, -0.018295288, -0.025146484, 0.027069092, -0.03277588, 0.03982544, 0.05517578, 0.013641357, -0.05831909, 0.036834717, 0.015556335, -0.05355835, 0.0317688, 0.0042304993, 0.0107421875, -0.0073623657, 0.003786087, -0.009597778, -0.000042557716, 0.04660034, -0.02734375, -0.0013360977, -0.0013227463, -0.0076293945, -0.01209259, 0.04397583, 0.029922485, -0.04144287, -0.002828598, -0.0066184998, -0.0181427, -0.012954712, -0.024246216, -0.005519867, 0.000895977, 0.020828247, -0.0040245056, -0.009231567, -0.00818634, 0.04043579, 0.048095703, 0.036590576, 0.026016235, 0.008781433, 0.02609253, 0.009208679, 0.06088257, 0.015167236, 0.04864502, -0.039001465, 0.019577026, 0.0619812, -0.014663696, 0.013000488, -0.010932922, -0.014450073, 0.0051879883, -0.0132369995, -0.009780884, -0.0004131794, -0.044647217, 0.0047798157, -0.035858154, -0.0013780594, -0.0026760101, 0.016845703, 0.025878906, -0.033233643, 0.020812988, 0.0036773682, 0.028442383, -0.008232117, -0.023773193, -0.0016841888, 0.04269409, -0.053619385, -0.01423645, 0.010322571, 0.07122803, -0.0055122375, 0.022338867, 0.017410278, 0.024017334, -0.045440674, -0.020507812, -0.0044441223, 0.055664062, 0.022064209, 0.0071411133, -0.0008482933, 0.0061454773, -0.00381279, 0.08508301, 0.074401855, -0.035003662, 0.03692627, -0.026672363, 0.018966675, 0.023254395, -0.04208374, 0.006996155, 0.036743164, 0.035095215, 0.022033691, -0.009735107, -0.011177063, -0.006008148, 0.016860962, -0.0101623535, 0.01828003, -0.083984375, -0.07019043, -0.0022201538, -0.05508423, -0.028945923, -0.00504303, 0.070251465, -0.05001831, -0.0413208, 0.013343811, -0.024215698, -0.017669678, 0.021316528, -0.034118652, 0.0058937073, 0.032104492, 0.056365967, 0.04046631, -0.059906006, -0.050598145, 0.0064315796, 0.010444641, -0.0027675629, -0.04107666, -0.016799927, 0.033081055, 0.037200928, 0.02204895, 0.02104187, -0.057769775, -0.005176544, -0.05593872, 0.015655518, -0.0028686523, -0.048858643, 0.010940552, 0.0262146, -0.008033752, -0.04345703, 0.02029419, 0.043884277, 0.0031986237, 0.011802673, 0.037078857, 0.027709961, -0.026473999, -0.00087690353, 0.006893158, -0.02281189, 0.014144897, 0.020645142, -0.041778564, -0.012458801, 0.0010356903, -0.0048179626, 0.060516357, -0.052856445, -0.002653122, -0.016647339, -0.007209778, -0.00065755844, 0.010063171, -0.023849487, -0.037750244, -0.012580872, -0.014533997, -0.0037555695, 0.024871826, -0.017700195, 0.032196045, 0.07800293, 0.0009331703, 0.0006580353, 0.00055217743, 0.043762207, 0.01776123, 0.0048599243, -0.037841797, -0.039245605, 0.010238647, 0.027786255, -0.0101623535, 0.01739502, 0.041137695, -0.14123535, -0.0158844, -0.0058021545, 0.002653122, -0.02557373, 0.004135132, -0.06536865, 0.01210022, -0.03366089, -0.037506104, 0.03302002, 0.051635742, -0.001748085, 0.005268097, 0.0039787292, -0.038360596, -0.0009889603, -0.02130127, -0.09674072, 0.026321411, -0.037872314, -0.022735596, 0.0045814514, -0.009307861, -0.042938232, 0.0017385483, -0.0074272156, 0.050048828, 0.013755798, 0.022201538, 0.02859497, -0.040100098, -0.016723633, -0.020385742, -0.036315918, -0.01626587, -0.017868042, -0.0054626465, 0.0024471283, 0.043884277, 0.042114258, -0.020843506, -0.04107666, -0.031921387, -0.002603531, 0.019943237, 0.011772156, -0.02999878, -0.029678345, -0.01007843, -0.0069389343, -0.023406982, -0.017318726, -0.009590149, -0.019927979, 0.017242432, -0.01651001, 0.06750488, 0.008644104, 0.027297974, 0.01159668, -0.046417236, 0.011116028, -0.043060303, -0.06707764, 0.022583008, 0.045166016, 0.0067481995, -0.025802612, -0.03277588, -0.049682617, 0.025299072, -0.03137207, 0.027786255, 0.029403687, 0.013298035, -0.011123657, -0.004386902, -0.010612488, 0.01777649, -0.041107178, 0.0070724487, 0.035949707, -0.015823364, 0.017822266, -0.04498291, 0.0093307495, 0.00013113022, -0.09362793, -0.01852417, 0.003124237, -0.02746582, -0.040863037, -0.0463562, 0.02861023, -0.031829834, -0.030029297, 0.009307861, 0.004299164, -0.042785645, -0.0064430237, -0.06549072, -0.058410645, 0.087890625, 0.018692017, 0.0037002563, 0.0395813, -0.003894806, -0.033966064, -0.032958984, 0.007118225, 0.0045661926, 0.042663574, -0.015670776, -0.016281128, 0.031463623, -0.030731201, 0.04083252, 0.003068924, 0.051330566, -0.014343262, -0.010475159, -0.016052246, -0.013679504, -0.0013341904, 0.033721924, 0.009307861, 0.019195557, -0.06616211, 0.048187256, -0.015419006, 0.004180908, 0.03955078, 0.018005371, 0.013198853, -0.014343262, -0.003704071, 0.023040771, -0.021911621, -0.015411377, 0.038726807, -0.0006375313, -0.02015686, 0.0082473755, 0.020736694, 0.04345703, -0.007701874, -0.011001587, 0.014274597, 0.026641846, 0.017700195, -0.053588867, 0.018692017, 0.040893555, -0.042419434, 0.0010280609, -0.03869629, -0.06109619, -0.028823853, 0.011741638, -0.011886597, 0.031082153, 0.012054443, -0.03277588, -0.005115509, -0.007648468, 0.008476257, 0.0034236908, 0.015068054, -0.027282715, 0.02229309, -0.021453857, -0.05722046, -0.028656006, 0.00868988, -0.014404297, 0.03012085, -0.0061035156, -0.026687622, 0.015151978, 0.010574341, 0.05670166, 0.037139893, 0.0012321472, -0.053863525, 0.024734497, -0.010917664, -0.019866943, 0.02104187, -0.023284912, 0.0031471252, -0.015136719, 0.012161255, -0.00459671, -0.03515625, -0.019897461, 0.021652222, -0.005710602, 0.042633057, 0.040283203, 0.072509766, 0.034423828, 0.031982422, -0.024047852, 0.006904602, -0.041412354, -0.0011205673, -0.07678223, 0.02355957, -0.013771057, 0.006149292, 0.039978027, 0.01374054, -0.028427124, 0.037353516, 0.011955261, 0.044708252, 0.01625061, 0.012817383, 0.011520386, -0.058258057, -0.03050232, -0.001241684, -0.02218628, 0.04232788, -0.049804688, 0.031051636, 0.03729248, 0.009162903, 0.022842407, -0.039520264, 0.040802002, -0.010284424, 0.01675415, -0.038909912, -0.039031982, 0.0034503937, 0.032196045, -0.0362854, -0.0026016235, -0.017089844, 0.013496399, 0.006904602, 0.056854248, 0.0357666, 0.0013008118, -0.0038223267, -0.014282227, -0.0027179718, -0.040252686, -0.041046143, -0.010597229, 0.019836426, 0.018432617, -0.037841797, 0.0015897751, -0.053894043, -0.021438599, -0.0042762756, 0.009155273, -0.009719849, -0.050750732, 0.040222168, 0.08306885, -0.0048599243, 0.045684814, -0.0009365082, 0.018035889, 0.054748535, 0.038848877, 0.022918701, 0.005962372, -0.0052604675, 0.01713562, 0.0028133392, -0.010345459, 0.0017108917, -0.009933472, 0.054260254, -0.0011224747, 0.032043457, -0.06756592, 0.020706177, 0.013114929, -0.005455017, 0.0027370453, -0.038757324, 0.018493652, 0.023910522, 0.0047912598, 0.017623901, -0.014045715, -0.062164307, -0.080200195, -0.0039043427, -0.11871338, 0.018310547, -0.018859863, -0.038024902, -0.060821533, 0.020324707, 0.008277893, 0.007858276, -0.0016975403, 0.026565552, -0.03857422, 0.018371582, 0.028945923, -0.027694702, -0.00969696, -0.019882202, 0.004207611, 0.015991211, 0.023101807, -0.029815674, -0.011802673, -0.022460938, -0.024597168, 0.0018033981, 0.024017334, 0.025314331, -0.0026016235, -0.003156662, -0.04284668, -0.011619568, 0.0037250519, 0.03125, -0.015449524, -0.02357483, 0.031219482, 0.012008667, 0.009666443, 0.01285553, 0.014053345, -0.03451538, 0.016983032, 0.029586792, -0.038146973, 0.033355713, -0.011131287, 0.003791809, -0.017105103, -0.061431885, 0.010192871, 0.023330688, -0.015563965, -0.009468079, 0.014076233, 0.026657104, 0.012672424, 0.0066337585, 0.007030487, 0.07342529, -0.030044556, 0.0085372925, -0.0075035095, 0.0051231384, -0.020599365, 0.024276733, -0.036254883, -0.0013551712, -0.030151367, -0.035705566, -0.022216797, 0.008308411, 0.0045318604, -0.003501892, 0.003583908, -0.05508423, -0.0020484924, -0.013786316, 0.004814148, -0.020004272, -0.008483887, 0.0076293945, 0.0004618168, -0.004760742, 0.025039673, -0.009391785, -0.00017404556, 0.014862061, 0.011711121, -0.021469116, 0.04107666, -0.050048828, 0.008773804, -0.021057129, -0.019180298, 0.03768921, 0.00028896332, -0.0084991455, 0.064331055, -0.044036865, 0.060546875, -0.010429382, 0.032958984, 0.042297363, 0.00497818, -0.030029297, -0.00894165, -0.008682251, -0.06378174, 0.013710022, -0.04208374, 0.0045776367, -0.03173828, -0.018249512, -0.06762695, -0.013839722, 0.041015625, 0.032348633, 0.0067100525, 0.01461792, 0.013999939, -0.027694702, 0.029693604, -0.015029907, 0.053466797, 0.013999939, -0.0028953552, -0.008262634, -0.0018758774, 0.028381348, 0.049438477, 0.010475159, -0.0045204163, -0.018951416, -0.025512695, 0.010383606, 0.027938843, 0.016159058, -0.00007086992, -0.0038928986, -0.029037476, 0.012046814, -0.027191162, 0.01210022, 0.089660645, 0.040039062, 0.005088806, -0.032958984, 0.009483337, -0.018981934, -0.032928467, 0.012626648, 0.048217773, -0.079589844, 0.039794922, -0.027297974, -0.02734375, -0.03857422, -0.009422302, 0.042297363, -0.05670166, -0.05609131, 0.02444458, 0.04888916, 0.0064811707, -0.006526947, -0.052093506, -0.023803711, -0.004600525, 0.028778076, -0.0026855469, 0.015060425, 0.015655518, -0.008155823, 0.010757446, -0.029190063, 0.011123657, 0.03829956, 0.0058288574, 0.02204895, -0.017471313, 0.0046310425, 0.035461426, -0.019165039, 0.0131073, 0.01574707, -0.021453857, 0.02168274, 0.000013709068, 0.056793213, 0.047973633, 0.08679199, 0.017044067, -0.000667572, -0.0023422241, -0.042663574, 0.022994995, 0.0025844574, -0.03881836, -0.009765625, -0.022247314, -0.026657104, 0.00687027, -0.043670654, 0.018173218, -0.038330078, 0.0019817352, -0.024002075, 0.015670776, 0.030380249, -0.0546875, -0.020721436, -0.01826477, -0.03201294, 0.012969971, 0.021759033, -0.033111572, -0.013572693, 0.0041618347, 0.0011177063, -0.001830101, -0.0018625259, -0.010658264, -0.017532349, -0.035125732, 0.014816284, -0.022338867, 0.05340576, -0.04333496, -0.024536133, -0.0030136108, -0.009468079, 0.017715454, -0.0262146, -0.019546509, -0.0103302, -0.03463745, -0.046875, -0.0037498474, -0.0047721863, -0.030944824, -0.007507324, -0.028457642, 0.01184082, -0.030883789, 0.018493652, 0.010894775, -0.05557251, -0.018920898, 0.0104904175, -0.028640747, 0.05328369, 0.019073486, -0.020614624, 0.04458618, 0.0021972656, -0.036254883, -0.005722046, 0.00016331673, 0.019897461, 0.0057754517, -0.06585693, 0.022628784, 0.021240234, 0.02017212, -0.046173096, -0.03604126, 0.030593872, 0.050811768, 0.0064201355, 0.045288086, 0.042419434, 0.010276794, 0.025604248, 0.008766174, -0.0038871765, -0.049621582, -0.0045166016, 0.00415802, 0.016220093, 0.024749756, 0.005592346, -0.03074646, 0.0008330345, -0.007762909, 0.011016846, -0.0005297661, -0.019073486, -0.0017871857, 0.0012512207, 0.024047852, -0.018371582, 0.012168884, -0.046417236, 0.044830322, -0.0046691895, 0.05606079, -0.0049934387, 0.019485474, 0.025161743, 0.1015625, -0.04510498, -0.035583496, 0.014884949, 0.038116455, -0.010154724, 0.020965576, -0.033355713, 0.01499939, -0.0064430237, -0.0049819946, -0.008171082, 0.0036945343, 0.018997192, -0.015235901, 0.0077705383, -0.013168335, -0.057128906, -0.045440674, -0.043273926, 0.025299072, -0.016113281, 0.029785156, -0.009056091, -0.0033111572, -0.00680542, 0.016662598, 0.025924683, -0.052215576, -0.026748657, 0.0038585663, 0.059417725, 0.005180359 ], "summary": [ -0.015068054, -0.021392822, -0.046905518, -0.02571106, -0.040161133, -0.0039100647, -0.0546875, 0.010124207, -0.017333984, 0.044647217, 0.0077819824, 0.021850586, 0.046936035, -0.041259766, 0.058258057, 0.019851685, -0.01763916, 0.032470703, -0.013084412, -0.034210205, 0.020645142, -0.056640625, -0.03149414, 0.021942139, 0.021392822, 0.0062332153, -0.04144287, 0.024139404, 0.025268555, 0.026611328, 0.016784668, -0.048675537, 0.018081665, 0.070373535, -0.070251465, 0.013961792, -0.02722168, 0.019454956, -0.004699707, 0.027557373, 0.042816162, -0.008911133, -0.0078125, -0.004638672, -0.046569824, 0.018997192, -0.008216858, -0.0021457672, 0.01146698, 0.064819336, -0.017318726, 0.016555786, -0.029205322, 0.026489258, 0.0016756058, -0.020935059, -0.03869629, -0.006538391, 0.025436401, 0.06518555, 0.020248413, -0.02960205, -0.01084137, -0.06365967, 0.013442993, -0.014091492, 0.050567627, 0.009796143, 0.05166626, 0.032989502, 0.015419006, 0.03390503, 0.029083252, -0.06329346, 0.014961243, 0.053100586, -0.037078857, 0.0006055832, 0.031585693, -0.028701782, -0.015640259, -0.01612854, 0.012130737, -0.018554688, -0.006916046, -0.017852783, -0.022766113, 0.008056641, 0.00605011, -0.051635742, -0.005508423, 0.026031494, -0.068115234, 0.022537231, 0.007835388, -0.045654297, -0.005340576, -0.003686905, 0.013153076, 0.038269043, -0.0029277802, -0.026138306, 0.04360962, -0.044311523, 0.0211792, -0.019943237, -0.0015516281, -0.0154800415, 0.03866577, 0.02519226, -0.03213501, 0.045318604, 0.017150879, 0.041381836, -0.046081543, -0.021331787, -0.015792847, 0.026138306, -0.02230835, 0.047424316, 0.0050811768, 0.048461914, -0.0053367615, 0.010826111, -0.0038871765, 0.019836426, 0.010292053, -0.0395813, 0.019958496, -0.07928467, 0.029968262, 0.090270996, -0.032928467, -0.03579712, -0.05630493, 0.041900635, 0.007297516, 0.0058021545, -0.024032593, 0.011688232, 0.0055351257, -0.028961182, -0.023223877, 0.00031614304, 0.004852295, 0.06149292, 0.025314331, -0.032958984, -0.045196533, -0.05557251, -0.008522034, -0.03805542, 0.027908325, -0.029937744, -0.031173706, -0.107421875, -0.055664062, -0.04598999, 0.08996582, -0.042144775, 0.0032310486, 0.021621704, 0.047851562, 0.034942627, 0.023239136, -0.032928467, -0.013191223, -0.011749268, 0.009590149, 0.029846191, -0.044067383, 0.035369873, 0.034057617, -0.00016236305, -0.006904602, -0.0023880005, -0.04864502, 0.038116455, 0.00349617, -0.036346436, 0.009933472, -0.041748047, -0.014732361, 0.041107178, -0.009819031, -0.023834229, 0.0032157898, 0.05859375, 0.03213501, 0.045654297, -0.034851074, -0.033294678, -0.04724121, -0.04711914, -0.010246277, 0.051605225, -0.0061950684, 0.02508545, -0.0060577393, 0.019943237, 0.020736694, -0.0076408386, -0.0008621216, -0.036254883, -0.07336426, -0.020996094, -0.024887085, 0.034729004, -0.03665161, 0.02684021, 0.02859497, -0.014846802, -0.046844482, 0.06878662, 0.027770996, -0.020584106, -0.00032925606, -0.028182983, -0.0016202927, -0.036895752, 0.0057868958, -0.0062789917, -0.020309448, 0.03338623, -0.0524292, -0.0057640076, -0.021057129, 0.02330017, -0.036071777, 0.0004940033, 0.078308105, -0.0069122314, 0.0020618439, -0.007247925, -0.03488159, 0.0035037994, -0.016525269, -0.004753113, -0.0043945312, 0.02508545, 0.0026683807, 0.013916016, -0.048431396, -0.01675415, 0.00006765127, -0.010536194, 0.0053634644, -0.0010852814, -0.006755829, 0.01979065, 0.025314331, -0.014770508, 0.019454956, -0.035308838, -0.006000519, 0.042663574, -0.044647217, -0.026870728, 0.0064811707, -0.026947021, 0.00868988, -0.0259552, 0.016967773, -0.028060913, -0.0082092285, -0.024398804, -0.0023536682, -0.0038795471, -0.0126953125, -0.029693604, 0.016540527, -0.009529114, 0.00233078, -0.024597168, 0.023925781, -0.036590576, -0.02897644, 0.0021686554, 0.042175293, -0.018951416, -0.009681702, 0.03479004, 0.03955078, -0.027648926, 0.008583069, 0.036956787, 0.022857666, -0.050323486, 0.012527466, 0.0713501, 0.07623291, 0.024490356, 0.0074310303, 0.021636963, -0.0077171326, 0.012466431, 0.012748718, 0.04989624, -0.043762207, 0.015991211, -0.0008635521, 0.032440186, 0.005004883, -0.028671265, 0.020645142, 0.03237915, 0.0690918, 0.004749298, 0.025039673, -0.0069618225, 0.00005608797, 0.0042686462, 0.00894928, 0.06585693, -0.0758667, -0.052368164, -0.023880005, 0.0045051575, -0.046051025, 0.007987976, 0.097717285, -0.054870605, -0.018875122, 0.014953613, -0.048309326, -0.025344849, 0.05569458, -0.036224365, 0.03778076, 0.019485474, -0.010627747, 0.018920898, -0.032470703, -0.006427765, 0.0017623901, 0.0018129349, 0.01360321, -0.064819336, -0.012573242, 0.023971558, 0.03250122, 0.033081055, 0.0030345917, -0.0440979, -0.037322998, -0.009719849, 0.019836426, -0.014694214, -0.009124756, 0.0065307617, 0.017349243, 0.0061035156, -0.0028190613, 0.0236969, 0.013938904, -0.05609131, 0.016204834, 0.016586304, -0.02104187, -0.032714844, -0.025100708, 0.03643799, -0.014801025, -0.020980835, 0.0070495605, -0.026550293, 0.0011415482, 0.018844604, -0.0025863647, 0.019042969, 0.036376953, -0.0126953125, -0.01864624, -0.019500732, -0.02973938, -0.014724731, 0.00078201294, -0.041381836, 0.03793335, 0.01878357, -0.010498047, 0.011146545, 0.029296875, 0.033843994, 0.033233643, 0.019042969, 0.020553589, -0.0079574585, 0.044189453, 0.0023040771, 0.01876831, -0.02053833, -0.04776001, -0.01361084, 0.008010864, 0.006614685, 0.025436401, 0.0099487305, -0.026016235, -0.034606934, 0.020812988, 0.015914917, -0.0036792755, 0.0033855438, -0.016174316, 0.022109985, 0.013465881, -0.014404297, 0.027526855, -0.014533997, 0.026504517, -0.025604248, 0.025466919, -0.033721924, -0.021102905, -0.028961182, -0.020339966, 0.019317627, -0.033172607, -0.00035595894, -0.009277344, 0.06866455, -0.02659607, -0.00349617, -0.0020980835, 0.044830322, -0.0071487427, 0.016082764, -0.0037517548, -0.016052246, -0.0036811829, -0.016036987, -0.030426025, -0.010406494, -0.014823914, 0.02746582, 0.019836426, 0.014854431, 0.048706055, -0.026519775, -0.06378174, -0.003824234, 0.0044784546, 0.011413574, 0.021530151, -0.031921387, -0.021591187, -0.07373047, 0.021530151, 0.027572632, -0.025390625, -0.015266418, 0.00894928, 0.021102905, -0.042633057, 0.06933594, -0.002746582, 0.038513184, 0.06964111, -0.08911133, -0.035339355, -0.03289795, -0.052337646, 0.013542175, 0.060394287, -0.007797241, -0.0692749, -0.009979248, -0.03466797, 0.020080566, 0.026931763, 0.0074272156, 0.04272461, -0.0053977966, 0.0020217896, -0.0287323, 0.04095459, 0.005622864, -0.028945923, -0.048797607, -0.017929077, 0.011367798, 0.0044136047, -0.055541992, -0.03894043, 0.013084412, -0.062194824, -0.02180481, -0.0052871704, 0.039398193, 0.008544922, -0.020828247, 0.04360962, -0.036193848, -0.025390625, 0.029129028, 0.006175995, 0.00630188, -0.000027656555, -0.051483154, -0.032226562, 0.016860962, 0.03869629, 0.00856781, -0.013671875, 0.01902771, 0.019042969, 0.004589081, 0.026184082, -0.001958847, 0.020065308, -0.02508545, 0.014274597, 0.003004074, -0.017669678, 0.008491516, -0.035369873, 0.018005371, -0.050323486, 0.0050315857, -0.014793396, 0.004989624, -0.01966858, 0.008262634, 0.039642334, 0.018539429, -0.051574707, 0.058624268, -0.016067505, 0.023361206, 0.05517578, 0.06008911, -0.03375244, -0.054382324, -0.0035171509, -0.074523926, -0.029006958, -0.020324707, 0.037597656, 0.034179688, -0.030166626, -0.006877899, 0.008895874, 0.07495117, -0.019302368, -0.010047913, -0.041534424, -0.012756348, 0.0132369995, -0.032348633, -0.0008611679, 0.015159607, -0.031585693, -0.0140686035, -0.022598267, -0.0234375, -0.0284729, 0.012123108, -0.004634857, 0.035491943, -0.008018494, 0.005531311, 0.007457733, -0.027053833, -0.027862549, 0.015365601, -0.0054473877, -0.030014038, -0.03048706, -0.013954163, -0.03186035, -0.009780884, -0.026763916, -0.060821533, -0.022399902, -0.009101868, -0.0569458, 0.016708374, -0.028533936, 0.037597656, 0.029647827, 0.029296875, -0.04901123, -0.010826111, -0.021224976, 0.016555786, -0.02218628, 0.016616821, -0.017929077, -0.012268066, 0.006122589, 0.0124435425, -0.044067383, -0.019592285, 0.038208008, -0.018859863, 0.03390503, 0.07537842, 0.12524414, 0.037994385, 0.017059326, -0.033843994, 0.00083589554, -0.020446777, 0.026809692, -0.06378174, -0.0078125, 0.011512756, 0.017242432, 0.06414795, -0.03668213, -0.03869629, 0.027801514, 0.0042800903, 0.04949951, 0.0050811768, -0.009902954, 0.031036377, -0.021209717, -0.03765869, -0.005306244, -0.042785645, 0.0022773743, -0.0005912781, -0.028198242, 0.070129395, 0.0041160583, 0.01612854, -0.03451538, 0.027832031, -0.0066490173, -0.008728027, -0.030258179, -0.016448975, -0.009895325, -0.006263733, -0.017181396, -0.023666382, -0.0070266724, 0.018508911, 0.015808105, 0.013786316, 0.000069499016, -0.04269409, -0.0056114197, -0.018569946, -0.019836426, -0.010185242, 0.0023593903, -0.048797607, 0.052703857, 0.006580353, -0.02911377, 0.0059432983, 0.035491943, -0.017593384, -0.020736694, -0.0018310547, -0.028137207, -0.023147583, -0.008720398, 0.014625549, -0.022537231, 0.021484375, -0.00032186508, 0.008148193, 0.0011940002, 0.008148193, -0.009002686, -0.020462036, -0.0418396, 0.03817749, -0.0059547424, -0.039794922, 0.022918701, 0.006664276, 0.051361084, 0.019302368, 0.0602417, -0.07861328, 0.0008196831, -0.023666382, -0.009223938, -0.007045746, -0.009498596, 0.01033783, 0.008552551, 0.026657104, 0.0056915283, 0.002866745, -0.031555176, -0.071777344, 0.00082063675, -0.113586426, -0.018859863, -0.041992188, -0.03375244, -0.0014419556, 0.012031555, 0.0032844543, 0.0005850792, 0.0042877197, -0.008338928, -0.023651123, -0.017562866, 0.037384033, 0.027648926, 0.002796173, -0.00074625015, 0.0259552, -0.006526947, 0.0023956299, -0.035003662, -0.030395508, -0.035186768, 0.013763428, 0.047180176, 0.0010099411, 0.01991272, 0.025497437, 0.00025486946, 0.013381958, -0.007820129, -0.03982544, 0.031677246, -0.051879883, -0.026779175, 0.0184021, 0.0018787384, 0.0030841827, 0.018035889, -0.0054092407, -0.062438965, 0.016784668, 0.048858643, -0.024749756, 0.025680542, -0.00043320656, 0.04244995, -0.1005249, -0.033325195, -0.016311646, 0.035888672, -0.010169983, 0.042022705, -0.023132324, 0.0031223297, 0.07763672, -0.023971558, -0.000019967556, 0.028381348, -0.0006713867, 0.053253174, 0.03475952, 0.038482666, 0.016418457, 0.013511658, -0.030395508, 0.046417236, -0.033691406, 0.0073165894, 0.010040283, -0.0054740906, -0.015640259, -0.006603241, 0.0056152344, -0.035614014, -0.017791748, -0.023101807, -0.0031166077, -0.013595581, 0.0008664131, -0.025787354, 0.011802673, 0.011306763, 0.025039673, -0.04699707, 0.05029297, 0.030090332, 0.022521973, -0.033691406, 0.06781006, -0.0061302185, 0.0056648254, -0.0077705383, -0.007671356, 0.019058228, 0.014251709, -0.016174316, 0.0206604, -0.007850647, 0.0395813, -0.00093603134, 0.009757996, 0.0061950684, -0.030197144, -0.021224976, -0.0051498413, -0.04562378, -0.057281494, -0.011276245, -0.01499176, -0.0340271, -0.03463745, -0.032196045, -0.032348633, 0.034301758, -0.028045654, -0.0025806427, 0.030929565, 0.006427765, 0.010429382, -0.012565613, -0.026779175, -0.022247314, 0.00064992905, -0.022384644, -0.008834839, -0.030532837, 0.014190674, 0.0025310516, 0.0390625, -0.0064315796, 0.051452637, 0.0121154785, -0.0034313202, 0.055877686, -0.03378296, -0.001613617, -0.029876709, 0.017044067, -0.02909851, -0.0037517548, 0.005367279, 0.019088745, 0.030807495, -0.0011100769, 0.024047852, -0.0038433075, 0.0060043335, 0.04550171, 0.013221741, 0.014320374, 0.023529053, 0.01651001, 0.0044670105, 0.024414062, -0.02229309, 0.001288414, -0.043060303, 0.054504395, -0.074523926, -0.026565552, 0.024246216, 0.012481689, -0.036071777, 0.019317627, -0.03250122, -0.044525146, -0.028076172, 0.0072669983, -0.0063552856, 0.01701355, -0.0037784576, -0.025268555, 0.051727295, -0.009933472, 0.01776123, 0.025543213, 0.037719727, 0.031051636, 0.009796143, -0.0030612946, 0.036895752, 0.0066947937, 0.016220093, 0.02545166, 0.02418518, 0.033843994, 0.023208618, 0.05609131, 0.011421204, 0.061706543, -0.010818481, 0.009773254, 0.018035889, 0.02607727, -0.009300232, -0.060546875, -0.00762558, -0.035064697, -0.01612854, 0.021209717, -0.02418518, -0.040863037, 0.023635864, -0.058135986, -0.0022506714, -0.040130615, 0.045410156, -0.055999756, -0.022644043, -0.05218506, -0.026916504, -0.023239136, 0.028213501, 0.05871582, -0.04611206, -0.032714844, -0.0110321045, 0.013298035, -0.026412964, 0.0016965866, 0.026779175, -0.015617371, 0.018218994, 0.012992859, 0.017684937, 0.04537964, -0.030426025, -0.017532349, 0.031463623, -0.0052490234, 0.016494751, -0.049468994, -0.03463745, 0.007007599, 0.021514893, -0.053710938, 0.0034999847, -0.0052948, -0.01876831, -0.015541077, -0.047973633, 0.010391235, -0.03656006, 0.03366089, 0.007873535, -0.022903442, -0.010795593, 0.01701355, -0.028839111, 0.02709961, -0.013031006, -0.028656006, 0.09197998, -0.02633667, -0.027297974, 0.03503418, 0.01209259, 0.017730713, -0.0028820038, -0.055114746, -0.017730713, -0.003704071, -0.014633179, -0.048461914, 0.00058078766, 0.03842163, 0.08544922, -0.017288208, -0.00037431717, -0.026824951, 0.01651001, 0.08929443, 0.07446289, 0.026748657, -0.064208984, 0.019805908, 0.018585205, 0.014373779, 0.008285522, -0.0031013489, -0.021896362, -0.00013029575, -0.012077332, -0.029724121, -0.020248413, -0.021942139, -0.056610107, 0.01096344, -0.029083252, 0.0022563934, -0.023757935, -0.018035889, 0.016601562, 0.011520386, 0.06567383, -0.024978638, 0.017547607, 0.033691406, 0.06933594, -0.055633545, 0.0082473755, -0.05404663, -0.024673462, -0.033416748, 0.027648926, -0.01210022, 0.03552246, -0.0001399517, 0.008911133, -0.0099487305, -0.007713318, 0.015777588, 0.0039367676, 0.003112793, 0.033172607, -0.053985596, -0.058532715, -0.03729248, 0.013069153, -0.036865234, 0.039398193, 0.012313843, 0.012062073, 0.02470398, 0.017318726, 0.045135498, -0.0023155212, 0.03741455, 0.0059776306, 0.013664246, 0.026763916 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07161v1
Developing a Named Entity Recognition Dataset for Tagalog
Lester James V. Miranda
cs.CL
We present the development of a Named Entity Recognition (NER) dataset for Tagalog. This corpus helps fill the resource gap present in Philippine languages today, where NER resources are scarce. The texts were obtained from a pretraining corpora containing news reports, and were labeled by native speakers in an iterative fashion. The resulting dataset contains ~7.8k documents across three entity types: Person, Organization, and Location. The inter-annotator agreement, as measured by Cohen's $\kappa$, is 0.81. We also conducted extensive empirical evaluation of state-of-the-art methods across supervised and transfer learning settings. Finally, we released the data and processing code publicly to inspire future work on Tagalog NLP.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07161v1
2023-11-13T08:56:47
2023-11-13T08:56:47
{ "title": [ 0.0011940002, -0.007987976, -0.040252686, -0.06365967, -0.0031700134, -0.007659912, -0.054016113, 0.0030727386, -0.01007843, 0.043548584, -0.05001831, 0.023345947, -0.004173279, -0.0004863739, -0.047546387, -0.016281128, 0.0009860992, 0.023101807, -0.014320374, -0.026275635, -0.020751953, -0.023803711, 0.024963379, -0.054870605, 0.039916992, -0.058288574, -0.07879639, 0.00006836653, 0.0025787354, -0.025344849, 0.010444641, 0.015777588, 0.022491455, 0.018966675, -0.013824463, 0.03387451, -0.039123535, 0.028182983, 0.005004883, 0.0019273758, 0.025375366, 0.00074625015, 0.00023508072, 0.0009889603, -0.033599854, -0.017745972, -0.025863647, -0.013824463, 0.006515503, 0.015327454, -0.00667572, 0.0211792, 0.0012426376, 0.008834839, 0.01398468, -0.03201294, -0.066467285, 0.029312134, 0.042877197, 0.050811768, 0.0074043274, -0.033935547, 0.01939392, -0.023223877, -0.008453369, -0.023605347, -0.011329651, 0.016616821, 0.07305908, -0.011428833, -0.021224976, 0.03173828, -0.022399902, -0.024871826, -0.03387451, 0.011924744, 0.008636475, -0.0064926147, 0.027160645, -0.0129852295, 0.005836487, 0.012916565, 0.0032291412, -0.047912598, 0.032562256, -0.036254883, 0.0051651, -0.005466461, -0.035980225, -0.06896973, -0.0021839142, 0.011894226, -0.043304443, -0.012702942, -0.026229858, -0.04547119, 0.021453857, 0.05102539, -0.001906395, -0.04083252, -0.05041504, 0.028778076, -0.066101074, -0.007949829, 0.03640747, 0.04260254, -0.024841309, -0.038726807, 0.03527832, 0.032196045, -0.0023593903, 0.042877197, 0.023086548, -0.017562866, -0.0184021, 0.016662598, 0.0079193115, -0.012550354, 0.013114929, 0.016723633, -0.009941101, -0.01071167, -0.02734375, -0.009559631, 0.041290283, -0.0107421875, -0.030029297, 0.046417236, 0.009361267, 0.03564453, 0.0074386597, 0.042907715, -0.103149414, -0.09637451, -0.07702637, 0.028701782, -0.023391724, 0.004951477, -0.012252808, -0.006702423, 0.03616333, -0.008743286, 0.028686523, 0.034118652, -0.004512787, -0.014053345, 0.035949707, 0.029312134, -0.018417358, -0.0435791, -0.009414673, 0.010032654, 0.005844116, -0.024795532, -0.03378296, -0.036468506, -0.07366943, -0.027389526, 0.03062439, -0.010902405, 0.023208618, 0.0059165955, 0.0071105957, 0.01737976, 0.036590576, -0.013252258, 0.0024108887, 0.014724731, -0.00042128563, 0.017730713, -0.013031006, 0.0236969, 0.039520264, -0.007648468, -0.008735657, -0.003326416, 0.0054473877, 0.00020694733, 0.02406311, 0.0076828003, 0.0005283356, -0.0390625, -0.031707764, 0.03286743, -0.073913574, -0.0019416809, 0.0049476624, 0.039520264, 0.06518555, 0.013420105, -0.01448822, 0.00868988, -0.041748047, -0.014556885, -0.031982422, 0.0132369995, 0.036102295, 0.04248047, 0.0109939575, -0.021102905, -0.039367676, 0.031280518, -0.027130127, 0.007972717, 0.007080078, -0.008903503, -0.015449524, 0.026245117, -0.012924194, 0.03805542, 0.045654297, -0.01902771, -0.017028809, 0.009712219, -0.006465912, -0.058013916, 0.0007519722, -0.011398315, 0.017211914, -0.039123535, 0.049743652, -0.034118652, 0.030883789, 0.03074646, -0.010147095, 0.03817749, -0.024993896, 0.01272583, 0.001745224, 0.02418518, 0.04901123, -0.0074272156, 0.03314209, 0.0473938, -0.028549194, -0.02355957, -0.022460938, -0.030273438, 0.020050049, 0.02961731, -0.0071525574, -0.047058105, -0.024765015, 0.009338379, 0.006580353, -0.0041046143, 0.019042969, -0.00223732, 0.005180359, 0.0011482239, 0.068237305, 0.013626099, 0.04550171, 0.068359375, -0.009262085, 0.059692383, -0.012619019, -0.0181427, -0.0009455681, -0.010826111, 0.025375366, -0.0077323914, -0.005016327, 0.0028038025, -0.028335571, 0.044921875, -0.0068092346, 0.019210815, -0.01890564, 0.03955078, 0.0057640076, -0.009963989, 0.010955811, -0.0049057007, -0.02696228, -0.01852417, 0.00774765, 0.01524353, 0.015327454, -0.050750732, -0.02355957, 0.023345947, 0.04837036, 0.003932953, -0.020401001, -0.0025577545, 0.047698975, -0.013618469, -0.06378174, -0.07159424, -0.0038776398, 0.06439209, 0.008842468, 0.003200531, 0.008514404, 0.013923645, 0.09777832, 0.05557251, -0.042938232, 0.022003174, -0.039154053, 0.015129089, 0.038085938, -0.02468872, 0.010246277, 0.009803772, 0.015655518, 0.007843018, -0.020858765, 0.009208679, -0.04751587, 0.02720642, -0.0046043396, -0.0022602081, -0.05911255, -0.0592041, -0.007904053, -0.020309448, -0.085876465, -0.03869629, 0.043304443, -0.0060691833, -0.031463623, 0.0020446777, 0.00056886673, -0.015213013, -0.023757935, -0.007369995, -0.024810791, 0.021713257, 0.028335571, 0.019302368, -0.05419922, -0.0063056946, 0.007423401, 0.028152466, 0.00036525726, 0.0008158684, -0.006313324, 0.05316162, 0.037139893, -0.016342163, 0.006313324, -0.051483154, -0.038391113, -0.010192871, 0.012069702, -0.0057640076, -0.064697266, -0.010314941, 0.035247803, -0.000998497, 0.007499695, 0.008049011, 0.07336426, -0.038848877, -0.045959473, 0.0063095093, 0.0076675415, -0.02355957, 0.022338867, 0.027511597, 0.015037537, -0.047027588, -0.03289795, -0.03604126, -0.025680542, 0.024475098, 0.0002424717, 0.032073975, -0.060455322, 0.0022525787, -0.021865845, 0.0007419586, 0.01612854, 0.035339355, -0.018585205, -0.0236969, -0.014984131, -0.024765015, 0.012031555, -0.0063209534, 0.018859863, 0.001906395, 0.025253296, 0.03274536, -0.025497437, -0.02507019, 0.016189575, 0.0035381317, 0.008720398, 0.006549835, -0.0039901733, -0.0016012192, 0.019363403, -0.0037631989, -0.036010742, 0.011474609, -0.0925293, 0.02243042, 0.052246094, 0.004322052, -0.011436462, 0.03125, -0.056121826, 0.044647217, 0.0014762878, -0.020065308, 0.026275635, 0.0058517456, 0.03604126, -0.0014953613, 0.025970459, -0.016921997, 0.021911621, -0.07922363, -0.101257324, 0.028533936, -0.008018494, -0.009780884, 0.0068969727, -0.009460449, -0.042236328, -0.0072784424, 0.0027828217, 0.037139893, 0.031982422, 0.008934021, 0.030853271, -0.023132324, 0.026184082, -0.033935547, -0.030014038, 0.0039100647, 0.008895874, 0.072387695, 0.0013589859, 0.047332764, 0.005794525, -0.0048675537, -0.033935547, 0.018600464, 0.005378723, 0.02180481, -0.01096344, -0.015930176, 0.029907227, -0.032409668, 0.013420105, 0.07165527, 0.0038852692, 0.014259338, -0.010284424, -0.009338379, -0.05545044, -0.06500244, 0.0007762909, 0.03149414, -0.0037212372, -0.02545166, 0.014389038, -0.020599365, -0.01725769, 0.020629883, 0.015220642, 0.031143188, -0.0006504059, 0.0023021698, -0.053741455, 0.028762817, 0.015266418, -0.03060913, -0.027297974, -0.008018494, 0.008018494, 0.000075638294, -0.009986877, -0.0067481995, 0.019363403, 0.0041007996, -0.020584106, 0.013877869, 0.005203247, -0.08135986, -0.024215698, 0.01411438, -0.091918945, -0.03656006, 0.027633667, -0.049102783, -0.052642822, -0.026290894, 0.027709961, -0.020843506, -0.0028324127, 0.01576233, -0.012435913, -0.023880005, 0.0037841797, -0.095825195, -0.029830933, 0.08355713, -0.017333984, -0.0026283264, 0.027328491, -0.036102295, -0.031188965, -0.0046424866, 0.04397583, 0.023284912, 0.014228821, 0.020553589, -0.06530762, 0.020355225, -0.042510986, 0.041809082, -0.0056495667, -0.011436462, 0.0028839111, 0.013206482, 0.042022705, 0.037078857, -0.013420105, 0.049865723, 0.008163452, -0.010017395, -0.062805176, -0.012825012, -0.01486969, -0.0077667236, -0.0018539429, 0.016815186, -0.005657196, -0.0063972473, 0.020721436, 0.016662598, 0.0074653625, -0.013137817, -0.004146576, -0.0021781921, -0.02861023, -0.025039673, 0.01361084, 0.02809143, 0.0034389496, 0.01586914, -0.026535034, 0.028076172, -0.026824951, 0.0022182465, -0.013076782, -0.002243042, -0.047821045, -0.020401001, -0.060272217, 0.0059394836, -0.012336731, 0.01424408, -0.027633667, 0.012680054, 0.023147583, 0.03302002, -0.055786133, -0.008071899, 0.010986328, -0.003566742, 0.020980835, -0.018295288, 0.023788452, -0.034729004, -0.0826416, -0.04510498, -0.018569946, 0.002603531, 0.033599854, 0.0024662018, -0.0024147034, 0.019592285, 0.04171753, 0.047454834, 0.060913086, -0.01939392, -0.04815674, 0.047607422, -0.048034668, 0.03338623, -0.019424438, -0.008361816, -0.03527832, -0.019958496, 0.0009326935, 0.018096924, -0.010505676, -0.020858765, -0.0069465637, 0.005382538, 0.0057525635, -0.0039901733, 0.039001465, -0.0011806488, -0.0116119385, 0.027389526, 0.008712769, -0.048980713, 0.002735138, 0.020370483, 0.016921997, -0.010154724, -0.0021953583, 0.027648926, 0.030883789, 0.008255005, -0.016021729, 0.011459351, 0.0066719055, 0.007648468, 0.023666382, 0.018432617, -0.04473877, -0.020767212, -0.00038790703, -0.012802124, 0.037506104, -0.07208252, 0.0019626617, -0.02017212, 0.0031108856, 0.01676941, -0.020584106, 0.023513794, 0.016448975, 0.024734497, -0.02861023, -0.021820068, 0.01713562, 0.022872925, -0.0181427, -0.011810303, -0.019943237, 0.019195557, 0.027832031, 0.038757324, 0.011497498, -0.022323608, -0.031707764, -0.019302368, -0.01184845, -0.026275635, -0.03704834, -0.00374794, 0.0010843277, 0.025604248, 0.025741577, 0.010360718, -0.040863037, -0.009765625, -0.025497437, -0.0098724365, 0.015136719, -0.043395996, 0.0019035339, 0.052825928, 0.006980896, 0.031311035, -0.020812988, 0.012672424, 0.05911255, 0.046020508, -0.0014667511, 0.013572693, 0.036834717, -0.04901123, -0.008575439, -0.0069236755, 0.01727295, -0.004878998, 0.007896423, 0.0024642944, 0.016815186, -0.048095703, 0.032470703, 0.016860962, -0.009643555, 0.0055732727, -0.04550171, 0.048583984, -0.027679443, -0.024917603, 0.008117676, -0.070495605, -0.035308838, -0.031707764, -0.03540039, -0.060943604, 0.027557373, -0.015129089, -0.072753906, -0.03378296, 0.05331421, 0.029342651, -0.025924683, -0.015167236, 0.027282715, -0.042175293, 0.02507019, 0.025878906, -0.053375244, 0.031829834, 0.024169922, 0.042053223, 0.04876709, 0.0007352829, -0.042419434, -0.0073928833, 0.044555664, -0.025619507, -0.007472992, -0.011932373, -0.008865356, -0.03378296, -0.015853882, -0.061035156, -0.029190063, -0.017059326, 0.0009393692, -0.029312134, -0.0001616478, 0.0019874573, -0.009353638, -0.0035705566, -0.0049591064, 0.025253296, -0.0023517609, 0.00044846535, 0.022460938, -0.021240234, 0.013618469, 0.03277588, 0.081970215, -0.08459473, -0.09075928, -0.0053482056, 0.02960205, 0.030395508, -0.0005412102, 0.058288574, 0.037322998, 0.043273926, -0.0036239624, 0.027832031, 0.04788208, -0.041046143, -0.030593872, -0.013252258, -0.00699234, -0.034362793, 0.033325195, 0.0031318665, 0.006111145, -0.02444458, -0.06750488, -0.036865234, 0.012565613, 0.052764893, 0.011161804, 0.036621094, -0.005493164, 0.04055786, -0.037719727, 0.0061912537, -0.035980225, 0.010864258, -0.0074157715, -0.009147644, 0.029037476, 0.0023117065, -0.011276245, 0.008140564, 0.024902344, 0.006790161, -0.043273926, 0.015792847, -0.01184082, 0.016433716, -0.014411926, -0.012504578, 0.028579712, -0.017654419, -0.015014648, 0.028656006, -0.055480957, 0.06536865, 0.020614624, 0.038513184, 0.068603516, 0.023925781, -0.00207901, 0.010612488, 0.008911133, -0.013793945, 0.016738892, -0.053863525, 0.017913818, -0.02859497, 0.014533997, -0.105895996, 0.008346558, 0.038391113, 0.004600525, 0.0036582947, 0.0104904175, -0.0038585663, 0.0034313202, 0.032989502, 0.045043945, 0.058502197, -0.042510986, -0.007827759, -0.024795532, -0.015930176, 0.049621582, 0.042175293, 0.017730713, -0.0003991127, -0.022369385, -0.007156372, 0.017227173, -0.025497437, 0.024673462, -0.025222778, -0.010726929, -0.032409668, 0.0413208, 0.0071525574, 0.020111084, 0.0501709, 0.009994507, 0.0021419525, -0.033172607, 0.004486084, -0.023620605, -0.014434814, -0.0064811707, -0.0024909973, -0.043640137, 0.05480957, -0.013404846, -0.037750244, -0.013938904, 0.032592773, 0.020996094, -0.041656494, -0.003900528, 0.02243042, 0.0015544891, -0.009681702, 0.0104522705, -0.036895752, -0.019241333, -0.009490967, -0.005191803, -0.01259613, 0.03338623, 0.04309082, 0.024932861, 0.005104065, -0.039398193, -0.0031280518, -0.015556335, -0.016036987, 0.034729004, 0.018722534, 0.027816772, -0.06628418, -0.057647705, -0.017837524, -0.025482178, -0.040527344, -0.041900635, 0.020935059, 0.039398193, 0.028198242, 0.06100464, 0.04815674, -0.012039185, -0.013793945, -0.031921387, 0.016647339, 0.033050537, -0.037231445, 0.014099121, -0.028274536, -0.047607422, 0.016677856, -0.05569458, 0.040374756, -0.044708252, 0.015396118, -0.033172607, 0.034729004, -0.0013656616, -0.045166016, -0.025527954, -0.010871887, -0.027282715, 0.00680542, 0.025024414, -0.04208374, -0.02772522, -0.022033691, 0.012298584, -0.03765869, 0.01159668, 0.057403564, -0.031433105, -0.11279297, 0.03918457, -0.006549835, 0.05203247, -0.038604736, 0.00031638145, 0.03982544, -0.03189087, -0.022857666, -0.033996582, -0.0115737915, -0.03753662, -0.0070877075, -0.04034424, 0.020050049, 0.015396118, -0.032928467, -0.08868408, 0.028045654, -0.04916382, -0.03111267, 0.0129852295, 0.020065308, -0.024291992, -0.039733887, -0.012710571, -0.007255554, 0.023101807, 0.008987427, -0.021118164, 0.056549072, -0.0016126633, -0.016677856, 0.004081726, 0.022384644, 0.048706055, 0.015388489, -0.020858765, -0.0001257658, 0.00724411, 0.039764404, -0.0625, -0.07165527, -0.014228821, 0.057647705, 0.005367279, 0.016921997, 0.0024757385, 0.013267517, -0.0012626648, 0.01600647, -0.0070877075, -0.033721924, 0.020645142, -0.014595032, 0.0011453629, 0.030395508, -0.019592285, 0.013763428, 0.019927979, -0.0020141602, 0.033233643, -0.028793335, 0.022613525, 0.019943237, -0.033599854, 0.025787354, -0.020050049, -0.024459839, -0.06262207, 0.03829956, -0.015899658, 0.012542725, -0.023239136, 0.044067383, -0.0033416748, 0.020370483, -0.058685303, -0.07055664, 0.09185791, 0.049591064, 0.010383606, 0.016815186, 0.030761719, -0.00008904934, -0.01335907, 0.008979797, 0.0115356445, 0.030654907, 0.0019426346, -0.03286743, 0.014778137, -0.07458496, -0.050720215, -0.030899048, -0.030044556, 0.025924683, -0.064453125, 0.03387451, -0.027114868, -0.0135650635, 0.009094238, -0.0008997917, 0.016540527, -0.030349731, -0.01739502, -0.0029830933, 0.0068855286, 0.0058135986 ], "summary": [ 0.034973145, -0.022476196, -0.018829346, -0.042236328, -0.022506714, -0.017868042, -0.048706055, 0.004470825, 0.010467529, 0.035339355, -0.06994629, 0.056671143, -0.000872612, 0.0069465637, -0.0069885254, -0.013763428, 0.000006198883, 0.018859863, -0.004524231, -0.004261017, -0.025314331, -0.005180359, -0.00995636, -0.08862305, 0.05807495, -0.09454346, -0.04763794, 0.0008854866, 0.044189453, 0.03314209, 0.02394104, -0.005542755, -0.004558563, 0.028701782, -0.006542206, 0.0024280548, -0.0066871643, 0.006263733, 0.02116394, 0.0013809204, 0.02911377, 0.002204895, 0.07470703, 0.023834229, -0.011627197, 0.0019044876, 0.012359619, -0.030441284, 0.048828125, 0.007896423, -0.023971558, 0.027297974, -0.029403687, -0.05407715, -0.0048942566, -0.039886475, -0.075683594, 0.028076172, 0.015838623, 0.0541687, 0.006225586, -0.03250122, 0.0072784424, -0.020721436, -0.024642944, -0.0178833, 0.028274536, 0.002204895, 0.043395996, -0.026275635, -0.0074310303, 0.038604736, -0.015640259, -0.0670166, -0.015220642, 0.038513184, -0.0155181885, -0.027801514, 0.017837524, -0.018234253, 0.025939941, 0.06347656, 0.00019061565, -0.043151855, 0.009178162, -0.047210693, -0.015090942, -0.018814087, -0.03161621, -0.041046143, -0.012878418, -0.009689331, -0.043701172, -0.0063476562, -0.011497498, -0.028442383, -0.00844574, 0.0016355515, -0.029129028, -0.010688782, -0.030700684, 0.0044898987, -0.010856628, -0.002588272, 0.017974854, 0.033355713, -0.043182373, -0.07269287, 0.05102539, 0.032104492, 0.019134521, 0.013336182, 0.011550903, -0.039123535, -0.0138168335, 0.036499023, 0.00023519993, 0.036224365, 0.027069092, 0.05407715, -0.011314392, 0.0076560974, -0.03488159, 0.0053863525, 0.039916992, 0.013000488, -0.002117157, 0.026046753, 0.0062942505, 0.025024414, 0.0072135925, 0.012702942, -0.07891846, -0.026626587, -0.05328369, 0.0067596436, 0.020599365, -0.019256592, -0.012207031, -0.0034675598, 0.045928955, -0.004096985, 0.0021190643, 0.04345703, 0.030029297, 0.0025043488, 0.013511658, 0.022720337, 0.024398804, -0.0015554428, -0.014793396, 0.0050354004, 0.03289795, -0.025283813, -0.011512756, -0.060455322, -0.0073928833, -0.03253174, 0.021652222, -0.03390503, 0.044036865, 0.003206253, 0.004016876, 0.05606079, 0.017974854, -0.0118637085, -0.0104599, -0.006416321, 0.009536743, 0.0030651093, -0.0054130554, 0.000003516674, 0.068725586, 0.0019989014, -0.012626648, 0.0067481995, -0.0036506653, 0.021896362, 0.011657715, 0.0019245148, -0.0054016113, -0.05218506, -0.03439331, 0.014434814, -0.01586914, -0.0032596588, -0.004043579, 0.019134521, 0.032928467, 0.016647339, 0.0002617836, -0.0048828125, -0.028930664, 0.006500244, -0.010551453, -0.008003235, 0.029205322, 0.01940918, -0.0049705505, -0.03161621, 0.018371582, -0.0009851456, 0.008331299, -0.010154724, -0.03665161, 0.006099701, -0.016342163, 0.016204834, -0.008605957, 0.0014762878, 0.016220093, -0.05984497, -0.014198303, 0.0501709, -0.0049591064, -0.01676941, 0.012191772, -0.018539429, 0.02456665, -0.027297974, 0.056365967, -0.0070648193, 0.02204895, 0.055114746, -0.022705078, 0.04272461, -0.034118652, 0.034820557, -0.017501831, 0.016525269, 0.024932861, -0.0072631836, 0.016433716, 0.0680542, 0.0050697327, -0.00040984154, -0.0010108948, -0.057128906, 0.021850586, 0.016952515, 0.0067481995, -0.018722534, -0.068237305, -0.03857422, -0.0026245117, -0.02822876, -0.004890442, -0.010482788, -0.054138184, -0.012016296, 0.0423584, 0.030303955, 0.014144897, 0.054656982, -0.04067993, 0.034942627, -0.044677734, -0.04071045, 0.010253906, -0.01802063, 0.025146484, -0.02168274, -0.012573242, -0.007041931, 0.00831604, 0.040740967, 0.033691406, 0.03466797, -0.030059814, 0.023757935, 0.003791809, 0.022491455, 0.012832642, -0.014831543, -0.061309814, -0.017364502, -0.003112793, 0.015823364, 0.01096344, -0.035064697, -0.012794495, 0.020935059, 0.001033783, -0.015655518, 0.009536743, -0.0025253296, 0.010871887, -0.014053345, -0.07696533, -0.03829956, -0.02961731, 0.09637451, -0.0026073456, 0.012779236, 0.0057907104, 0.02722168, 0.093566895, -0.051879883, 0.01398468, -0.027175903, 0.064208984, 0.054504395, 0.010345459, -0.00969696, 0.005744934, -0.020462036, -0.0026283264, 0.03302002, 0.015144348, -0.028121948, -0.03503418, -0.003255844, 0.0010070801, 0.001285553, -0.045043945, -0.036315918, -0.033813477, -0.0036392212, -0.07220459, -0.021942139, 0.02720642, 0.03656006, -0.019332886, 0.029403687, 0.011161804, -0.014823914, 0.026062012, -0.009262085, -0.03781128, 0.019515991, -0.035827637, -0.002111435, -0.012817383, 0.053985596, -0.015792847, 0.009552002, 0.021011353, 0.0010023117, 0.009552002, 0.052978516, 0.066345215, -0.015914917, 0.0038700104, -0.013687134, -0.08453369, 0.01939392, 0.016067505, -0.0096206665, -0.039764404, -0.010398865, 0.048980713, 0.005958557, -0.0032234192, 0.007282257, 0.032287598, -0.045928955, -0.009399414, -0.012901306, -0.019104004, -0.05859375, 0.023223877, 0.025344849, 0.010429382, -0.0758667, -0.05316162, -0.015357971, -0.024841309, 0.0055732727, 0.0132751465, 0.023468018, -0.03604126, 0.032806396, -0.0053367615, -0.014289856, -0.016860962, 0.03591919, 0.025497437, -0.010116577, 0.016723633, 0.020019531, 0.009750366, 0.009529114, 0.034179688, -0.022018433, -0.02494812, 0.032348633, -0.034362793, -0.033721924, 0.012275696, 0.006439209, 0.017074585, 0.025314331, 0.042755127, -0.011291504, -0.039031982, -0.00033068657, -0.02268982, -0.011779785, -0.0073547363, 0.002357483, 0.030258179, 0.025054932, 0.0146484375, -0.001244545, -0.003326416, 0.019241333, 0.030456543, -0.0056266785, 0.02027893, -0.017623901, 0.035980225, -0.031921387, 0.038269043, -0.036010742, 0.029953003, -0.06567383, -0.018997192, 0.0009841919, 0.006023407, -0.008293152, -0.011566162, 0.026168823, -0.017074585, 0.0013237, -0.0044937134, -0.002943039, 0.016113281, 0.017059326, 0.0075645447, -0.003332138, 0.009376526, -0.025543213, -0.020217896, 0.017196655, 0.008758545, 0.0713501, 0.0046081543, -0.014961243, -0.0032730103, -0.028503418, -0.012962341, 0.03375244, 0.0029945374, 0.00011527538, -0.030181885, 0.0013551712, 0.0524292, -0.01574707, 0.04421997, 0.09075928, -0.013664246, -0.0023422241, 0.026351929, 0.005153656, -0.06390381, -0.084350586, 0.015594482, 0.043426514, 0.054992676, -0.0041770935, 0.01864624, -0.020706177, 0.014709473, 0.039520264, 0.06500244, 0.045074463, -0.04248047, 0.014266968, -0.03881836, 0.020599365, 0.064453125, -0.08843994, -0.052886963, -0.027618408, 0.0006465912, -0.029067993, 0.044433594, 0.0041923523, 0.080078125, -0.027267456, -0.032409668, 0.008758545, -0.006969452, -0.052856445, -0.008087158, -0.005718231, -0.05508423, -0.053222656, 0.010932922, 0.013206482, -0.023712158, 0.015403748, 0.039794922, 0.013626099, 0.027832031, 0.026992798, -0.0022830963, 0.017471313, 0.005355835, -0.07611084, -0.03326416, 0.019470215, 0.03201294, -0.0070114136, -0.010437012, 0.0013313293, 0.019989014, 0.007648468, 0.01235199, -0.020477295, 0.011810303, -0.02267456, -0.07556152, 0.0033397675, -0.037628174, 0.015808105, -0.0005636215, -0.027435303, 0.002084732, 0.0007715225, 0.040618896, 0.016296387, 0.030090332, 0.00944519, 0.0018777847, 0.013298035, -0.022155762, -0.02583313, -0.05078125, 0.000046133995, -0.014915466, 0.06359863, -0.032592773, -0.049560547, 0.04888916, -0.043640137, 0.000890255, -0.04144287, -0.043792725, 0.020126343, -0.0036811829, -0.028915405, 0.0021953583, 0.022476196, -0.0014429092, -0.008422852, -0.033233643, 0.000053465366, -0.050689697, -0.0035114288, -0.018630981, -0.005531311, -0.05795288, -0.040740967, -0.0035877228, 0.013183594, -0.00016283989, 0.0012788773, -0.034729004, 0.0072669983, -0.029525757, 0.02305603, 0.0025520325, -0.030166626, -0.030532837, 0.034606934, -0.0048446655, 0.00070524216, 0.046783447, -0.062408447, -0.029830933, -0.005012512, 0.014930725, -0.03378296, 0.04373169, 0.0046653748, 0.021881104, 0.037475586, 0.030349731, 0.021057129, 0.044921875, -0.03869629, -0.07788086, -0.01361084, -0.0446167, 0.04776001, -0.020599365, -0.029953003, -0.04815674, -0.028366089, -0.02330017, 0.04043579, 0.0032520294, -0.050872803, -0.042541504, 0.021865845, -0.040039062, 0.01713562, 0.016921997, -0.007095337, -0.016281128, 0.018005371, 0.013557434, -0.002948761, -0.015197754, 0.03466797, -0.047302246, 0.01448822, -0.02420044, -0.006942749, 0.00920105, -0.012245178, 0.010986328, 0.001616478, -0.0023651123, 0.009414673, 0.034973145, 0.01335144, -0.011878967, -0.05065918, 0.008071899, 0.031707764, 0.0037708282, -0.00020718575, -0.03845215, 0.029769897, 0.005214691, 0.01889038, -0.031921387, 0.016494751, 0.018463135, -0.008270264, -0.035736084, -0.060516357, -0.01197052, 0.057281494, -0.003452301, -0.03100586, -0.01802063, 0.008834839, 0.029037476, -0.011627197, -0.050476074, -0.04937744, -0.020812988, -0.023376465, -0.03704834, 0.0025253296, -0.025756836, -0.019485474, -0.0032482147, 0.010231018, 0.071777344, -0.024490356, -0.018508911, -0.010482788, -0.033294678, 0.037902832, -0.017150879, 0.010986328, -0.04815674, 0.01689148, 0.011741638, 0.01222229, -0.032562256, -0.02305603, 0.03137207, 0.024490356, -0.03515625, -0.016189575, 0.0116119385, -0.020980835, -0.012168884, -0.026672363, -0.0063209534, 0.043762207, -0.009376526, 0.01838684, 0.012748718, 0.0018577576, 0.025024414, 0.024597168, -0.017440796, 0.011459351, -0.035705566, 0.049316406, -0.05419922, -0.0141067505, 0.023345947, -0.03161621, -0.020904541, -0.043182373, 0.00042915344, -0.06640625, 0.024291992, -0.0028133392, -0.06970215, 0.0055732727, 0.021972656, 0.017715454, -0.025787354, 0.0028324127, 0.007446289, -0.022155762, -0.0036468506, 0.004699707, -0.041992188, 0.033355713, 0.036468506, 0.03466797, 0.019210815, -0.02658081, -0.04550171, -0.009666443, 0.057373047, 0.0018005371, -0.016448975, -0.0340271, -0.052337646, -0.008979797, -0.0077056885, -0.053375244, 0.02168274, -0.010665894, 0.020980835, -0.06976318, 0.028305054, -0.010437012, -0.009101868, -0.01576233, 0.020095825, -0.002193451, -0.008171082, -0.0071487427, 0.01612854, -0.046539307, 0.021377563, 0.021942139, 0.08996582, -0.09655762, -0.08947754, -0.0060424805, 0.043670654, 0.036468506, 0.0112838745, 0.031143188, 0.007881165, 0.07696533, 0.0042419434, 0.0126953125, 0.027999878, 0.01109314, 0.009017944, 0.008300781, 0.027770996, -0.020874023, -0.0021839142, -0.005882263, 0.03338623, -0.016067505, -0.09838867, -0.0063323975, 0.0019226074, 0.04449463, 0.035095215, 0.029296875, -0.00667572, 0.05633545, -0.0021457672, -0.022537231, -0.0042495728, 0.0077590942, -0.0071792603, -0.00674057, 0.035705566, -0.015022278, 0.0096206665, 0.011566162, -0.0022621155, -0.029663086, -0.03543091, -0.0039749146, -0.0020332336, 0.04916382, 0.039489746, -0.01574707, -0.01828003, -0.04248047, 0.029464722, 0.0046691895, -0.06088257, 0.022155762, 0.030761719, 0.02482605, 0.033355713, 0.0037078857, 0.0042152405, 0.012229919, -0.0062026978, -0.011764526, -0.0039596558, -0.0064468384, 0.0024929047, -0.004814148, -0.0060043335, -0.042236328, 0.069885254, -0.0069618225, -0.000029623508, 0.014335632, 0.012634277, -0.019897461, 0.016113281, -0.021209717, 0.04510498, 0.029296875, -0.015792847, -0.025436401, -0.00037002563, -0.006500244, 0.027801514, 0.054534912, 0.025482178, -0.013557434, -0.0027122498, 0.006134033, 0.025848389, -0.034088135, 0.005897522, -0.041412354, 0.00881958, -0.025115967, 0.035339355, 0.028533936, 0.045043945, 0.029144287, -0.0035114288, 0.01675415, -0.018508911, 0.017059326, -0.08093262, 0.02381897, -0.023147583, -0.049316406, -0.00082445145, 0.08770752, 0.011199951, -0.0262146, 0.021240234, 0.023406982, 0.05633545, -0.080322266, -0.009017944, 0.036346436, -0.0065345764, -0.06378174, 0.011795044, -0.03152466, -0.020263672, -0.009750366, -0.04284668, 0.0016994476, 0.0039711, 0.042816162, -0.009521484, 0.0034732819, -0.015960693, -0.016708374, 0.006290436, -0.029937744, 0.028030396, 0.033416748, 0.009101868, -0.03314209, -0.03894043, 0.00011152029, -0.016036987, -0.014350891, -0.03491211, 0.020233154, 0.049713135, 0.03527832, 0.05618286, -0.006252289, 0.0012226105, 0.02583313, -0.006298065, 0.026245117, 0.015090942, -0.028244019, -0.026885986, 0.0049591064, 0.0018224716, 0.006969452, -0.017166138, 0.026443481, -0.050598145, -0.004207611, -0.010864258, 0.03125, -0.060913086, -0.00021970272, -0.02355957, -0.019744873, 0.0024089813, 0.0043754578, 0.05014038, -0.05331421, -0.020889282, -0.035186768, -0.0042686462, -0.040863037, -0.005580902, 0.05621338, 0.0015153885, -0.11218262, -0.0028266907, -0.014984131, 0.03942871, -0.0178833, 0.0038890839, 0.056030273, -0.021987915, -0.0013208389, -0.052886963, -0.021530151, -0.006515503, -0.006465912, -0.08477783, 0.049865723, 0.030700684, -0.042633057, -0.099243164, 0.06970215, -0.053588867, -0.025009155, 0.039733887, -0.0036849976, 0.01461792, -0.051330566, -0.009681702, 0.02909851, -0.010307312, -0.03189087, -0.012557983, 0.06451416, 0.00003415346, -0.01423645, 0.017120361, 0.015075684, 0.02394104, 0.006126404, -0.028656006, -0.0028038025, -0.01486969, -0.0025520325, -0.046539307, -0.05709839, 0.013290405, 0.07019043, -0.020721436, -0.03302002, 0.014808655, 0.007949829, 0.0073013306, 0.018249512, -0.011894226, -0.034301758, 0.048065186, 0.0057792664, -0.008384705, 0.023544312, -0.008598328, 0.011116028, 0.008407593, -0.021987915, -0.0051078796, -0.028366089, 0.053985596, -0.010147095, -0.018188477, 0.028137207, -0.029510498, -0.04534912, -0.031204224, -0.026473999, 0.006225586, -0.012496948, -0.03475952, 0.03237915, -0.043914795, 0.0028858185, -0.08795166, -0.022766113, 0.04095459, 0.018707275, -0.0049324036, -0.02029419, 0.034088135, 0.052001953, -0.008995056, -0.0068206787, 0.021240234, 0.005126953, -0.017105103, -0.05609131, -0.0075531006, -0.063964844, -0.038238525, -0.016677856, -0.030197144, 0.004558563, -0.040740967, 0.035827637, 0.013267517, 0.010940552, 0.025512695, 0.0013427734, 0.036010742, -0.011985779, 0.0345459, 0.025527954, -0.009101868, 0.03201294 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07150v1
Interaction is all You Need? A Study of Robots Ability to Understand and Execute
Kushal Koshti, Nidhir Bhavsar
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
This paper aims to address a critical challenge in robotics, which is enabling them to operate seamlessly in human environments through natural language interactions. Our primary focus is to equip robots with the ability to understand and execute complex instructions in coherent dialogs to facilitate intricate task-solving scenarios. To explore this, we build upon the Execution from Dialog History (EDH) task from the Teach benchmark. We employ a multi-transformer model with BART LM. We observe that our best configuration outperforms the baseline with a success rate score of 8.85 and a goal-conditioned success rate score of 14.02. In addition, we suggest an alternative methodology for completing this task. Moreover, we introduce a new task by expanding the EDH task and making predictions about game plans instead of individual actions. We have evaluated multiple BART models and an LLaMA2 LLM, which has achieved a ROGUE-L score of 46.77 for this task.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07150v1
2023-11-13T08:39:06
2023-11-13T08:39:06
{ "title": [ -0.0066452026, 0.0022678375, -0.031097412, -0.028182983, 0.019958496, -0.029891968, -0.0052719116, -0.024017334, -0.015808105, 0.024734497, -0.029022217, -0.00050497055, -0.0034980774, -0.015205383, -0.040740967, -0.020324707, 0.011695862, 0.018829346, -0.007270813, -0.024414062, -0.020462036, -0.033416748, 0.058258057, -0.0005660057, 0.061462402, -0.02861023, -0.10797119, -0.0036735535, -0.023468018, -0.029815674, 0.0033073425, 0.02067566, 0.027923584, -0.007205963, 0.015388489, -0.012611389, -0.03488159, 0.018341064, -0.02432251, -0.00018405914, 0.014328003, -0.016220093, -0.052215576, 0.0037078857, -0.06137085, 0.014694214, -0.049865723, 0.011955261, -0.009361267, 0.02835083, 0.020812988, 0.029342651, -0.0032024384, 0.050811768, 0.0017843246, -0.020019531, -0.02230835, -0.02609253, 0.032684326, 0.05105591, 0.011787415, -0.06347656, 0.02734375, -0.025115967, -0.013633728, -0.04360962, -0.047790527, 0.050872803, 0.054748535, 0.025283813, 0.0023040771, 0.013336182, -0.0027713776, 0.014198303, -0.03125, -0.018371582, 0.03375244, 0.022766113, 0.03353882, 0.0012598038, -0.006000519, -0.03112793, 0.024398804, -0.031951904, 0.007736206, -0.05038452, -0.010902405, 0.008613586, -0.033721924, -0.05908203, -0.016708374, 0.020889282, -0.018478394, -0.025009155, -0.059295654, -0.02192688, -0.01499939, 0.0035800934, 0.02708435, 0.012382507, -0.012084961, 0.009269714, -0.026168823, -0.007183075, 0.023590088, 0.026123047, -0.0034599304, -0.017303467, 0.026351929, 0.020111084, -0.03050232, 0.064453125, 0.00843811, 0.0024414062, -0.022201538, -0.0121154785, -0.027267456, 0.009376526, 0.0077705383, 0.032287598, -0.0027580261, -0.009399414, 0.003622055, 0.020904541, 0.015396118, 0.022323608, -0.023086548, -0.023101807, 0.017059326, 0.0009589195, -0.011161804, 0.06561279, -0.083740234, -0.09844971, -0.053100586, 0.051086426, 0.010932922, 0.005012512, 0.0029201508, 0.018661499, -0.0023155212, -0.02748108, 0.030380249, 0.024017334, -0.02720642, -0.017623901, 0.060913086, 0.0126571655, -0.056274414, -0.039764404, -0.018981934, 0.02935791, -0.0104904175, 0.011566162, -0.0049743652, 0.0025577545, -0.09906006, -0.00843811, 0.052764893, 0.016433716, 0.041778564, 0.036865234, 0.006454468, 0.0029716492, 0.04888916, -0.039642334, -0.021636963, 0.027511597, -0.005592346, 0.045135498, -0.0074501038, 0.00093889236, -0.017318726, -0.005683899, -0.019821167, -0.008026123, 0.017364502, -0.00774765, 0.018753052, -0.030380249, -0.029586792, -0.038330078, 0.010375977, 0.04623413, -0.031463623, -0.030288696, -0.0065460205, -0.036132812, 0.04232788, 0.0028190613, -0.05404663, 0.045318604, -0.023651123, -0.06011963, -0.022598267, -0.007511139, 0.021697998, 0.042175293, -0.009796143, 0.0035419464, -0.027160645, -0.002861023, -0.02935791, 0.023620605, 0.0018405914, -0.035217285, 0.00013244152, 0.019607544, -0.008026123, 0.06744385, 0.046051025, 0.028869629, -0.021072388, -0.01020813, -0.018508911, -0.07092285, 0.011833191, 0.000068843365, -0.030899048, -0.0058250427, -0.041656494, -0.026046753, -0.009262085, 0.04928589, 0.03652954, 0.010429382, 0.00819397, -0.020019531, 0.07928467, 0.031173706, 0.07989502, -0.059783936, 0.051940918, 0.035369873, -0.012252808, -0.024368286, -0.002691269, -0.011276245, 0.0101623535, 0.022460938, 0.0007677078, -0.042022705, 0.010185242, 0.04815674, 0.04159546, -0.025039673, -0.0012187958, 0.017410278, 0.014595032, 0.013694763, 0.04888916, 0.01133728, 0.0569458, 0.034179688, 0.0039978027, 0.053222656, -0.016021729, -0.0008773804, -0.034362793, 0.028839111, 0.0051612854, 0.019119263, 0.014350891, 0.009147644, -0.05343628, 0.031311035, -0.033935547, 0.016906738, 0.0077323914, 0.038482666, 0.03010559, -0.034820557, -0.007724762, 0.009796143, -0.011543274, -0.029464722, -0.021072388, 0.028961182, 0.0032691956, -0.060546875, -0.00091171265, 0.00592041, 0.053344727, 0.007030487, 0.034973145, 0.02432251, 0.026733398, -0.0072898865, -0.002254486, -0.005958557, 0.06121826, 0.018585205, 0.0063705444, -0.0104522705, 0.02116394, -0.0074539185, 0.08569336, 0.07110596, -0.02923584, 0.029266357, -0.05859375, 0.017929077, 0.024536133, -0.024337769, 0.023284912, -0.022155762, 0.027389526, 0.01285553, -0.028671265, 0.005882263, -0.068603516, -0.0044288635, 0.012840271, -0.0055274963, -0.014038086, -0.042297363, 0.013130188, -0.021469116, -0.04522705, -0.0340271, 0.03805542, -0.034301758, -0.018859863, -0.032318115, -0.012329102, 0.00036644936, -0.040618896, -0.028320312, -0.01373291, 0.030761719, 0.03994751, 0.010848999, -0.053985596, -0.014099121, 0.009117126, 0.03164673, -0.012588501, 0.0317688, -0.014625549, -0.022857666, -0.0020523071, -0.03326416, -0.00308609, -0.02935791, 0.014297485, -0.039916992, 0.0003774166, 0.014945984, -0.021560669, -0.0013532639, 0.01008606, -0.018463135, -0.02255249, 0.007217407, 0.06317139, -0.039855957, -0.028839111, 0.03918457, 0.02255249, -0.008125305, 0.040405273, 0.0011453629, 0.00051498413, -0.01927185, 0.0023460388, -0.047973633, -0.026031494, -0.0029067993, 0.0074424744, 0.053497314, -0.055877686, 0.0020103455, -0.058502197, -0.0138549805, -0.003534317, 0.02923584, -0.019866943, -0.04888916, -0.03390503, -0.034423828, -0.019012451, -0.0042800903, -0.009429932, 0.0016012192, 0.07647705, 0.013397217, -0.0014638901, 0.014785767, 0.033203125, -0.0018224716, -0.014450073, -0.018707275, -0.025024414, 0.0016384125, -0.001543045, 0.014785767, -0.0070533752, -0.003780365, -0.09863281, 0.0064582825, 0.041381836, 0.0024166107, -0.028869629, 0.03274536, -0.06237793, 0.02507019, -0.0028266907, -0.01625061, 0.034118652, 0.07922363, -0.010665894, 0.0028762817, 0.01965332, -0.03540039, 0.0025291443, 0.0037002563, -0.08288574, 0.040374756, -0.037475586, -0.03717041, 0.012908936, -0.011268616, -0.045715332, -0.013183594, -0.026824951, 0.04953003, 0.015304565, 0.028213501, -0.015457153, -0.024658203, -0.00166893, -0.027511597, -0.0045318604, 0.0055007935, -0.021194458, -0.008674622, -0.020889282, 0.026138306, 0.017150879, -0.0140686035, -0.042144775, -0.022903442, 0.0062408447, 0.011413574, -0.0069503784, -0.01826477, -0.010757446, -0.01411438, -0.053375244, -0.013801575, 0.0004017353, 0.019622803, -0.057647705, 0.012168884, -0.005558014, 0.05633545, 0.015914917, 0.024612427, -0.0061531067, -0.024215698, 0.0137786865, -0.037261963, -0.053222656, 0.018325806, 0.035736084, -0.031021118, 0.059265137, -0.0069351196, -0.014503479, 0.03390503, -0.009170532, 0.012237549, 0.014808655, 0.012512207, -0.015197754, 0.032226562, -0.02935791, -0.02029419, 0.003112793, 0.041748047, 0.016540527, -0.00793457, 0.015342712, -0.04547119, -0.022232056, 0.011306763, -0.11035156, -0.028533936, 0.000063061714, -0.023025513, -0.02947998, -0.03137207, 0.027740479, -0.04647827, -0.03768921, -0.007762909, -0.013671875, -0.03744507, -0.0035381317, -0.036254883, -0.044891357, 0.06286621, -0.020904541, 0.0009403229, 0.066345215, -0.032836914, -0.02204895, -0.00434494, 0.02015686, 0.06530762, 0.022003174, 0.02255249, -0.006412506, 0.054595947, -0.045959473, 0.012184143, 0.028137207, 0.008743286, -0.009979248, 0.018737793, -0.004787445, 0.015060425, -0.032104492, 0.034973145, 0.059509277, -0.013725281, -0.07128906, 0.038085938, 0.008232117, -0.014328003, 0.016784668, -0.01979065, 0.019180298, 0.02305603, -0.0034103394, 0.03439331, -0.028411865, 0.030334473, 0.022140503, -0.02670288, -0.042175293, -0.04660034, 0.016601562, 0.0036010742, 0.011894226, 0.025131226, 0.01638794, 0.049224854, -0.0019950867, -0.0019702911, -0.00012755394, 0.0032806396, -0.023742676, 0.0036849976, -0.060821533, -0.04776001, -0.044036865, 0.018356323, 0.011627197, 0.024047852, 0.049468994, -0.013626099, -0.026504517, -0.0013027191, 0.010482788, -0.004047394, 0.014671326, -0.053710938, 0.014289856, -0.008468628, -0.07879639, -0.06298828, -0.03250122, -0.018157959, 0.016448975, 0.0118637085, -0.028808594, 0.0289917, 0.024856567, 0.10681152, 0.031311035, 0.0124435425, -0.0713501, 0.04901123, -0.04309082, -0.014457703, 0.025222778, 0.007648468, -0.009140015, -0.03768921, 0.024139404, -0.021270752, 0.0024681091, -0.02104187, 0.014289856, -0.026977539, 0.05117798, -0.012283325, 0.04147339, 0.010383606, -0.003435135, -0.0025463104, -0.014503479, -0.028945923, 0.030578613, 0.02027893, 0.040649414, -0.014305115, 0.011993408, 0.04144287, 0.023239136, 0.008987427, -0.0043258667, 0.01210022, 0.032409668, -0.021392822, 0.0050849915, 0.021820068, -0.03845215, -0.028701782, -0.0036506653, 0.015266418, 0.035064697, -0.068237305, 0.056365967, -0.0040130615, -0.012207031, -0.018722534, -0.035217285, 0.0051574707, -0.047851562, 0.010505676, -0.041809082, -0.05050659, -0.008094788, 0.058898926, -0.030685425, -0.0045166016, -0.017547607, 0.006954193, 0.021011353, 0.050720215, 0.0011081696, 0.0046806335, 0.02670288, 0.000787735, -0.007648468, -0.030639648, -0.04333496, -0.004333496, -0.01574707, 0.022750854, -0.0017910004, 0.017959595, -0.06677246, 0.01171875, 0.005054474, -0.014785767, 0.018447876, -0.057373047, 0.01991272, 0.08166504, -0.025436401, 0.05166626, 0.0181427, 0.049438477, 0.019226074, 0.062042236, -0.0005168915, 0.034973145, 0.037597656, -0.041992188, -0.007106781, -0.007522583, 0.020751953, 0.019958496, 0.023483276, 0.019638062, 0.022750854, -0.05731201, 0.026687622, 0.016601562, 0.0006184578, 0.008377075, -0.04537964, 0.015075684, 0.016067505, 0.0037937164, 0.011413574, -0.04272461, -0.038909912, 0.016342163, -0.040527344, -0.0087509155, 0.0025405884, -0.029800415, -0.037322998, -0.059539795, 0.01625061, 0.0056037903, 0.0032997131, -0.0048675537, 0.019866943, -0.032714844, 0.029205322, 0.017929077, -0.04522705, 0.01146698, -0.015052795, -0.0041503906, 0.051940918, 0.03125, -0.038726807, 0.008766174, 0.020385742, -0.05053711, -0.033691406, 0.03463745, -0.006843567, -0.022415161, -0.017440796, -0.06225586, -0.015945435, 0.0015735626, 0.008674622, 0.0027389526, -0.0345459, 0.019058228, 0.0015325546, -0.000114798546, 0.000667572, 0.018234253, 0.00762558, -0.006793976, -0.006958008, 0.00044441223, 0.018051147, -0.006549835, -0.009384155, -0.020843506, -0.04522705, -0.0035247803, 0.020568848, -0.0041275024, -0.016601562, 0.02558899, 0.02961731, 0.035217285, 0.0055160522, 0.010643005, 0.068603516, -0.02494812, -0.011619568, -0.0184021, -0.0057678223, -0.039367676, 0.059265137, 0.01751709, -0.010925293, -0.039611816, -0.04864502, -0.031707764, 0.01751709, 0.03933716, 0.014984131, 0.04977417, -0.05130005, -0.023147583, -0.015258789, 0.014770508, -0.025970459, 0.0069274902, -0.010360718, -0.0011510849, 0.0096588135, 0.04385376, 0.004753113, -0.009994507, 0.032104492, 0.013061523, -0.021377563, 0.018035889, -0.054779053, 0.016357422, -0.038269043, -0.010643005, 0.042999268, 0.0132751465, -0.029174805, 0.01348114, -0.04336548, 0.06744385, 0.049041748, 0.06591797, 0.04776001, 0.019821167, 0.041534424, 0.020828247, 0.039794922, -0.019378662, -0.016693115, -0.049743652, -0.012260437, -0.021469116, -0.0099487305, -0.049438477, -0.027435303, 0.0335083, 0.02116394, 0.0058403015, 0.009315491, -0.0065345764, -0.004962921, 0.03387451, 0.022140503, 0.05014038, -0.010765076, -0.01474762, -0.0071640015, -0.0054512024, 0.018661499, 0.029632568, 0.010894775, 0.0126571655, -0.039978027, -0.008308411, 0.00844574, 0.008514404, 0.0095825195, -0.019546509, -0.007549286, -0.02128601, 0.020065308, -0.02041626, 0.029647827, 0.05114746, 0.03930664, -0.041534424, -0.003616333, 0.0029392242, -0.02305603, -0.027038574, 0.0017080307, 0.04736328, -0.078186035, 0.036499023, -0.010406494, -0.04650879, -0.023483276, 0.06964111, 0.009750366, -0.03375244, 0.0051994324, 0.029708862, 0.011497498, 0.0073890686, 0.02607727, -0.02748108, -0.009155273, 0.009315491, 0.01108551, 0.010566711, 0.038330078, 0.015029907, 0.027618408, -0.028869629, -0.020401001, -0.013542175, 0.01979065, -0.046173096, 0.01789856, -0.003786087, 0.0736084, -0.024368286, -0.04953003, 0.033416748, -0.0061035156, -0.053375244, -0.024383545, 0.045898438, 0.017700195, 0.034973145, 0.07897949, 0.030136108, -0.00843811, -0.037384033, -0.02911377, 0.026641846, 0.046447754, -0.02885437, 0.020187378, -0.053131104, -0.04901123, 0.03164673, -0.050750732, 0.09124756, -0.013305664, -0.0044822693, -0.01499939, 0.029403687, 0.046936035, -0.03793335, -0.045928955, -0.01828003, -0.019958496, 0.011940002, 0.0259552, -0.015197754, 0.002752304, 0.029541016, 0.0051994324, 0.044281006, 0.03463745, 0.027954102, -0.06890869, -0.05718994, 0.021713257, 0.026290894, 0.04864502, 0.013977051, -0.028793335, -0.044433594, 0.017837524, 0.00015044212, 0.013572693, -0.01776123, 0.044036865, -0.047912598, -0.023910522, 0.0021362305, -0.004760742, -0.019927979, 0.01335907, -0.026062012, 0.03250122, -0.01134491, -0.0004963875, 0.028869629, -0.022445679, -0.049804688, -0.005191803, -0.035003662, 0.022567749, 0.018310547, -0.031921387, 0.002735138, 0.012336731, -0.039611816, -0.012023926, -0.0011825562, 0.05645752, -0.01739502, -0.027130127, -0.010536194, 0.03665161, 0.042816162, -0.074279785, -0.061584473, -0.02671814, 0.021606445, 0.029510498, 0.052581787, -0.0079422, 0.015289307, 0.006652832, 0.045196533, 0.01133728, -0.07611084, -0.021377563, -0.011299133, 0.032165527, 0.039855957, -0.013587952, 0.0015668869, 0.015487671, -0.019805908, 0.023971558, 0.0027046204, 0.0026721954, 0.04660034, -0.019439697, 0.057250977, -0.029571533, 0.007835388, -0.036712646, 0.036956787, -0.003047943, 0.03086853, -0.025817871, 0.038330078, 0.014427185, 0.05368042, -0.0033035278, -0.03945923, 0.038848877, 0.027511597, 0.022750854, 0.056427002, -0.017700195, -0.031921387, -0.00843811, 0.030670166, 0.0019226074, 0.051330566, 0.011245728, -0.003929138, 0.017074585, -0.023269653, -0.053497314, -0.012168884, -0.03692627, 0.03479004, -0.008514404, 0.008583069, 0.01260376, -0.030319214, 0.005115509, 0.016204834, 0.019378662, -0.030181885, -0.02470398, 0.002380371, 0.040405273, -0.006134033 ], "summary": [ 0.021392822, -0.016494751, 0.010917664, 0.008857727, -0.04309082, -0.009239197, -0.03945923, -0.015808105, 0.0045928955, 0.02935791, -0.02519226, 0.019241333, -0.009170532, -0.013313293, 0.00667572, -0.022735596, -0.015914917, 0.038208008, -0.006729126, -0.046173096, 0.01008606, -0.058166504, -0.030395508, 0.02130127, 0.051818848, -0.0284729, -0.04473877, 0.022247314, 0.041809082, 0.036254883, 0.02532959, -0.04534912, 0.023391724, -0.023620605, 0.031921387, -0.0059776306, -0.013336182, -0.0026474, 0.0031433105, 0.0128479, 0.050323486, -0.0149002075, 0.028701782, -0.03515625, -0.020095825, 0.024490356, 0.012863159, 0.007789612, 0.031280518, 0.04446411, -0.0018072128, 0.025314331, -0.023422241, 0.02180481, -0.014305115, -0.024169922, -0.05505371, 0.00038218498, 0.036071777, 0.11376953, 0.027160645, -0.013458252, -0.03567505, -0.079956055, 0.0054855347, -0.0015363693, 0.012802124, 0.024337769, 0.004600525, -0.008834839, 0.014282227, 0.004333496, 0.015052795, -0.035614014, 0.029144287, 0.045715332, -0.03375244, 0.019577026, 0.026916504, -0.02204895, 0.011192322, 0.019546509, 0.054656982, -0.09515381, 0.02923584, -0.08734131, 0.00083971024, 0.017852783, -0.0158844, -0.038879395, -0.030670166, 0.030334473, -0.039764404, -0.005355835, -0.035705566, -0.020828247, -0.0052757263, -0.06689453, 0.027786255, 0.010406494, 0.060424805, -0.05078125, 0.0635376, -0.011024475, 0.012367249, 0.03656006, 0.024917603, -0.051635742, -0.009742737, -0.034698486, -0.043792725, 0.031555176, -0.005531311, -0.037475586, 0.00623703, 0.006095886, -0.01725769, 0.03967285, 0.009277344, -0.00094127655, -0.03643799, -0.01033783, -0.0033607483, 0.06390381, 0.0031375885, 0.04498291, 0.013015747, -0.0054130554, 0.1083374, -0.041259766, 0.004550934, 0.038024902, -0.05734253, -0.061157227, -0.040802002, 0.028366089, 0.026733398, -0.034576416, 0.0028629303, -0.005317688, 0.03237915, 0.00497818, 0.011978149, 0.012260437, -0.0046081543, 0.022598267, 0.046020508, 0.0019435883, -0.06506348, -0.039611816, 0.013000488, 0.031433105, -0.008323669, -0.014793396, 0.047973633, -0.034698486, -0.060058594, 0.014122009, 0.05847168, 0.043060303, 0.009010315, 0.017181396, 0.02571106, 0.024093628, 0.012367249, -0.025924683, -0.0031280518, 0.0066337585, 0.0008535385, 0.007598877, -0.015106201, 0.012527466, 0.011001587, -0.01727295, -0.008491516, -0.011657715, -0.002664566, 0.010017395, 0.005718231, -0.013809204, -0.017623901, -0.032409668, 0.011291504, -0.002916336, 0.0014705658, -0.015174866, -0.008964539, 0.019317627, 0.021881104, 0.029220581, -0.044799805, 0.022888184, 0.0011138916, -0.005748749, -0.0234375, -0.04940796, 0.04498291, 0.005252838, -0.021591187, 0.0031356812, 0.0914917, 0.002275467, -0.029067993, -0.034057617, -0.1217041, -0.0008049011, -0.014266968, 0.004917145, 0.002532959, 0.047790527, 0.020492554, 0.034088135, -0.038116455, 0.019561768, -0.000118374825, -0.024902344, -0.003293991, 0.012039185, 0.0074806213, -0.013595581, 0.007167816, -0.00919342, -0.012611389, 0.04046631, -0.02885437, 0.00022935867, -0.0075912476, 0.027801514, 0.024841309, 0.037139893, 0.051116943, -0.07946777, 0.02470398, 0.052764893, 0.008590698, 0.0048599243, 0.026306152, -0.03375244, 0.002002716, 0.019485474, 0.0340271, 0.0020580292, -0.02772522, 0.007965088, -0.0023441315, -0.019042969, 0.008979797, -0.0013341904, -0.021575928, 0.0063972473, 0.02331543, 0.020385742, 0.038391113, 0.010787964, -0.0027866364, 0.037384033, -0.022979736, -0.03665161, 0.0011844635, -0.009422302, 0.037322998, -0.0546875, -0.05126953, 0.0055122375, -0.005218506, -0.022659302, -0.016448975, -0.015991211, -0.008087158, -0.010231018, 0.032958984, -0.008636475, 0.003004074, -0.025115967, -0.045440674, 0.011276245, -0.024856567, 0.025756836, 0.0309906, -0.04244995, 0.0018644333, 0.028182983, 0.032104492, -0.012634277, 0.0033550262, 0.040008545, 0.023498535, 0.009719849, 0.027755737, 0.02268982, 0.03768921, 0.025909424, -0.0016107559, 0.016937256, 0.005882263, -0.01586914, 0.047058105, 0.0069732666, 0.0039901733, -0.009002686, 0.02671814, 0.036254883, -0.01725769, -0.018981934, 0.034301758, -0.03955078, 0.02458191, 0.02671814, 0.015335083, 0.031158447, -0.06945801, 0.021118164, 0.05545044, 0.107788086, -0.03253174, -0.040863037, 0.023742676, 0.06921387, -0.010734558, -0.036010742, 0.095703125, -0.013710022, -0.0046424866, 0.019302368, -0.005054474, -0.042236328, 0.056488037, -0.022109985, -0.01576233, -0.01158905, -0.016296387, -0.026000977, 0.0022220612, 0.045135498, 0.00223732, 0.0017900467, 0.0063972473, 0.029769897, 0.006084442, -0.030838013, 0.03729248, -0.040252686, -0.019088745, 0.029342651, -0.014602661, -0.0061149597, 0.012107849, -0.0042152405, 0.04272461, 0.01737976, -0.024017334, -0.008338928, 0.021224976, 0.041778564, 0.032165527, -0.042053223, -0.017074585, 0.008987427, -0.049224854, -0.051574707, 0.036346436, 0.013473511, 0.010070801, -0.06161499, -0.015914917, -0.017303467, -0.030380249, -0.015533447, 0.041412354, 0.054504395, 0.0048599243, 0.064697266, -0.07525635, -0.023483276, -0.02709961, -0.015731812, 0.07696533, -0.00067567825, -0.023834229, 0.025527954, -0.00447464, -0.009239197, -0.0043640137, -0.042785645, 0.051239014, 0.022247314, 0.0066566467, -0.014030457, 0.030563354, 0.0005393028, -0.0008134842, -0.018478394, 0.0017366409, -0.021255493, -0.0112838745, 0.004135132, -0.02772522, 0.0048561096, -0.014404297, -0.009902954, 0.013412476, 0.01663208, 0.011528015, 0.003540039, -0.0043525696, -0.009895325, -0.00223732, -0.009101868, 0.041809082, -0.0035800934, 0.024215698, -0.051757812, 0.026550293, -0.07165527, -0.019317627, -0.0025100708, -0.053466797, 0.022460938, -0.033599854, 0.0127334595, 0.0041618347, 0.016586304, -0.027267456, -0.0010662079, 0.0045204163, 0.02822876, -0.016281128, 0.01109314, -0.031555176, -0.0064888, -0.019622803, -0.022537231, 0.00970459, 0.055786133, -0.022064209, 0.051208496, -0.007949829, -0.02885437, 0.06915283, -0.07696533, -0.056671143, -0.010696411, -0.01512146, -0.03111267, 0.025131226, -0.04473877, 0.011955261, -0.04348755, -0.03729248, -0.04598999, -0.014282227, 0.012512207, -0.017456055, 0.034301758, 0.008110046, 0.11968994, -0.03161621, 0.029434204, 0.0690918, -0.06707764, -0.0143966675, -0.020690918, -0.052001953, 0.01512146, 0.054534912, 0.027191162, -0.033081055, 0.008117676, -0.00048542023, 0.004219055, 0.036376953, -0.045898438, -0.003314972, -0.0041389465, -0.020111084, -0.01701355, 0.03466797, -0.003484726, 0.039855957, -0.013015747, -0.07336426, 0.01108551, -0.0016412735, -0.08502197, -0.020401001, 0.013893127, -0.039916992, -0.01235199, -0.016494751, 0.034088135, 0.014968872, -0.021392822, 0.038360596, -0.02357483, -0.036712646, 0.016906738, -0.01008606, 0.031188965, -0.0021514893, -0.03753662, -0.0135269165, -0.012008667, -0.0063819885, 0.015617371, 0.015792847, -0.01133728, 0.019638062, 0.058258057, 0.015731812, -0.009246826, 0.07891846, 0.012458801, 0.0022792816, 0.017242432, -0.03111267, -0.018447876, 0.036224365, -0.003545761, -0.008460999, 0.013786316, 0.016601562, 0.037994385, -0.018600464, 0.014923096, 0.013748169, 0.008407593, -0.0287323, 0.04736328, 0.026138306, 0.01789856, 0.025924683, -0.0014486313, -0.017669678, -0.0047035217, 0.010536194, -0.03567505, -0.015602112, 0.015853882, 0.050079346, 0.025146484, -0.021530151, -0.028076172, 0.007003784, 0.052734375, -0.022644043, 0.032226562, -0.049743652, 0.05960083, -0.012992859, 0.031555176, -0.0029735565, -0.017623901, 0.008850098, -0.029220581, -0.032684326, 0.01725769, -0.000010073185, 0.0006327629, -0.0014276505, 0.0053863525, 0.04534912, 0.0013961792, 0.0014257431, -0.026107788, 0.05718994, 0.017593384, -0.031677246, -0.10333252, -0.032104492, 0.0078048706, -0.045684814, -0.025161743, -0.07019043, -0.037261963, -0.03479004, 0.0116119385, -0.0496521, 0.017700195, 0.014045715, 0.095581055, 0.049346924, 0.025268555, -0.08703613, 0.022491455, -0.055389404, 0.008087158, 0.03414917, -0.0043640137, -0.026992798, -0.011924744, 0.032043457, 0.016952515, 0.015731812, 0.007335663, -0.0016765594, -0.045013428, 0.06311035, -0.044677734, 0.0050735474, 0.0011386871, 0.0075187683, 0.00059747696, -0.014656067, 0.0012760162, 0.014671326, 0.030776978, 0.033111572, -0.00015103817, 0.0020179749, 0.015670776, 0.0049858093, 0.015914917, -0.024398804, -0.0005426407, -0.0027313232, -0.024505615, -0.028335571, 0.023223877, 0.012062073, 0.0063323975, 0.015151978, -0.018096924, 0.0037117004, 0.004211426, 0.026443481, 0.029785156, -0.043304443, 0.009544373, -0.0043640137, 0.022155762, 0.012229919, -0.0059814453, -0.052978516, -0.09112549, -0.021697998, 0.08770752, 0.008155823, -0.014076233, -0.0027675629, -0.0043640137, -0.0064926147, 0.06124878, 0.053771973, -0.053894043, 0.051635742, -0.020736694, -0.023361206, 0.0030231476, -0.032958984, -0.03225708, -0.036956787, 0.017959595, -0.0023212433, 0.04119873, 0.024520874, 0.017028809, 0.0010852814, -0.037750244, 0.039794922, -0.051940918, -0.049346924, 0.011505127, -0.04925537, 0.004047394, 0.030822754, -0.01802063, -0.026733398, 0.039642334, -0.038146973, 0.021759033, 0.023605347, -0.07940674, 0.0036773682, -0.023590088, 0.0065994263, 0.035308838, 0.0023384094, 0.019760132, 0.017715454, -0.024230957, -0.015129089, 0.00004351139, 0.039154053, -0.002588272, -0.025054932, 0.011627197, 0.038269043, 0.01574707, -0.004627228, -0.0023460388, -0.0513916, -0.033813477, -0.009414673, -0.0574646, -0.046905518, -0.056396484, -0.013641357, -0.02218628, -0.038726807, -0.018875122, 0.0032653809, 0.0036182404, 0.047058105, 0.01889038, 0.001824379, -0.0055770874, -0.009407043, 0.010658264, 0.018356323, 0.0140686035, 0.008987427, 0.003982544, -0.053466797, -0.005859375, 0.015930176, 0.0035743713, -0.035461426, -0.0014371872, -0.012550354, 0.0035495758, -0.01701355, -0.0036182404, -0.0062828064, -0.020141602, 0.022064209, -0.041503906, -0.044647217, -0.020401001, -0.03062439, -0.053863525, 0.027389526, -0.016433716, -0.013404846, 0.011024475, -0.009094238, 0.009963989, 0.043914795, -0.011329651, 0.023620605, -0.014930725, 0.013153076, -0.0031166077, 0.04373169, 0.0015048981, 0.008300781, 0.01751709, 0.015930176, 0.042541504, -0.0138549805, -0.011146545, 0.0047721863, 0.008377075, 0.015075684, -0.00944519, 0.034942627, -0.023666382, 0.008094788, -0.018737793, 0.017318726, -0.013160706, -0.018661499, -0.010223389, -0.040802002, 0.022415161, -0.03137207, -0.0038833618, 0.009513855, -0.038848877, 0.03186035, 0.0003669262, -0.048583984, -0.04333496, -0.015235901, -0.002243042, 0.08660889, 0.06439209, -0.018035889, 0.03564453, 0.02281189, 0.017486572, -0.018966675, 0.044830322, -0.024337769, 0.00013077259, -0.00819397, -0.013557434, 0.031036377, -0.0051002502, 0.002986908, 0.014984131, -0.0015239716, 0.027114868, 0.004501343, 0.040374756, 0.0017843246, 0.01676941, 0.022033691, 0.007675171, 0.026367188, -0.017150879, 0.0029239655, -0.0016355515, -0.028366089, -0.009094238, -0.021774292, -0.023483276, 0.06585693, -0.015335083, -0.012428284, 0.012573242, -0.008659363, -0.008262634, 0.040985107, -0.031463623, 0.029678345, -0.016647339, 0.030548096, -0.024963379, 0.0335083, 0.0011310577, 0.005706787, 0.06402588, 0.032562256, -0.008331299, -0.0637207, 0.00178051, 0.041656494, -0.02796936, -0.02670288, -0.036499023, 0.015167236, -0.06161499, 0.0012807846, 0.005367279, 0.03289795, 0.022979736, 0.0013809204, -0.040985107, 0.025146484, 0.024337769, -0.038970947, -0.021209717, 0.013664246, -0.017242432, -0.036499023, 0.03302002, 0.017456055, -0.016662598, 0.015144348, 0.030899048, 0.024124146, -0.046691895, -0.011489868, 0.032318115, 0.008506775, 0.0090789795, -0.005153656, -0.031219482, -0.05432129, -0.04333496, -0.0026435852, 0.018569946, 0.0413208, 0.0035381317, -0.004283905, 0.030563354, 0.01651001, -0.03463745, 0.051727295, -0.039642334, 0.031555176, -0.0069236755, 0.05718994, 0.026641846, -0.018936157, 0.033569336, 0.026138306, -0.028259277, 0.02142334, 0.044921875, 0.016555786, 0.0423584, 0.038238525, -0.010543823, 0.02267456, 0.024520874, -0.018463135, 0.002155304, -0.013801575, 0.006385803, -0.0055160522, -0.026870728, -0.0062675476, 0.0032310486, -0.019439697, 0.025909424, -0.053375244, -0.030548096, -0.031402588, 0.018966675, -0.056030273, 0.02708435, -0.020889282, -0.06262207, -0.034301758, 0.046142578, 0.069885254, -0.023223877, 0.04067993, 0.0060272217, -0.06707764, 0.0236969, 0.0028877258, -0.01071167, -0.013061523, -0.0340271, 0.029876709, 0.0011320114, 0.066101074, 0.05657959, -0.028030396, -0.008728027, 0.019958496, -0.006011963, -0.035980225, -0.016983032, 0.010124207, 0.0047836304, 0.0146484375, 0.012840271, 0.045440674, -0.0044441223, -0.026062012, -0.012916565, 0.018615723, -0.019729614, 0.027557373, 0.026916504, 0.00907135, -0.06756592, -0.001493454, -0.010871887, 0.0073394775, -0.04257202, -0.035217285, 0.06347656, -0.020629883, -0.07745361, 0.040100098, 0.003610611, 0.058807373, 0.011909485, -0.0045700073, -0.0016899109, 0.015403748, 0.03363037, -0.038208008, -0.013656616, -0.016525269, 0.05038452, -0.031280518, -0.009536743, 0.019180298, 0.035614014, 0.059295654, 0.051757812, 0.0029182434, -0.070739746, 0.07104492, 0.026184082, 0.0077705383, 0.01486969, -0.031555176, 0.022109985, -0.010360718, -0.019348145, 0.0030956268, -0.030181885, 0.032226562, -0.0063056946, -0.018859863, -0.010650635, -0.057037354, -0.0016698837, -0.04058838, -0.00065231323, -0.008323669, -0.009437561, 0.00093078613, 0.020095825, -0.027069092, 0.019515991, -0.018325806, 0.0093307495, -0.0087509155, -0.00017929077, 0.019882202, 0.0010070801, 0.010879517, 0.000026226044, -0.0069465637, 0.029922485, 0.010231018, 0.026855469, -0.031188965, 0.0065231323, 0.013267517, -0.035461426, -0.01878357, -0.025299072, -0.014556885, -0.0028820038, 0.014091492, 0.0113220215, 0.07330322, -0.037078857, 0.022125244, 0.028686523, 0.020904541, 0.0038013458, 0.020599365, 0.038269043, 0.01197052, 0.013053894 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07138v1
WaterBench: Towards Holistic Evaluation of Watermarks for Large Language Models
Shangqing Tu, Yuliang Sun, Yushi Bai, Jifan Yu, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
cs.CL, cs.AI
To mitigate the potential misuse of large language models (LLMs), recent research has developed watermarking algorithms, which restrict the generation process to leave an invisible trace for watermark detection. Due to the two-stage nature of the task, most studies evaluate the generation and detection separately, thereby presenting a challenge in unbiased, thorough, and applicable evaluations. In this paper, we introduce WaterBench, the first comprehensive benchmark for LLM watermarks, in which we design three crucial factors: (1) For \textbf{benchmarking procedure}, to ensure an apples-to-apples comparison, we first adjust each watermarking method's hyper-parameter to reach the same watermarking strength, then jointly evaluate their generation and detection performance. (2) For \textbf{task selection}, we diversify the input and output length to form a five-category taxonomy, covering $9$ tasks. (3) For \textbf{evaluation metric}, we adopt the GPT4-Judge for automatically evaluating the decline of instruction-following abilities after watermarking. We evaluate $4$ open-source watermarks on $2$ LLMs under $2$ watermarking strengths and observe the common struggles for current methods on maintaining the generation quality. The code and data are available at \url{https://github.com/THU-KEG/WaterBench}.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07138v1
2023-11-13T08:09:01
2023-11-13T08:09:01
{ "title": [ -0.019012451, 0.0032978058, -0.036102295, -0.06774902, 0.020736694, 0.0021629333, -0.058166504, -0.008384705, 0.0031147003, 0.036621094, -0.009109497, 0.008544922, 0.009284973, -0.016067505, -0.04272461, 0.01512146, -0.021713257, 0.038482666, -0.0413208, -0.039916992, -0.0132751465, -0.057647705, 0.010299683, -0.019744873, 0.042999268, -0.10461426, -0.031097412, 0.022720337, -0.009216309, -0.03060913, 0.005367279, 0.020584106, 0.028533936, 0.032836914, -0.018417358, 0.022125244, -0.06994629, 0.048736572, 0.019592285, -0.01576233, 0.04083252, -0.01763916, 0.028442383, -0.0066871643, -0.021087646, 0.044921875, -0.048675537, -0.026870728, -0.022506714, 0.042175293, 0.007827759, 0.020126343, -0.011581421, 0.06072998, 0.010345459, -0.029464722, -0.03427124, 0.0037975311, 0.012565613, 0.10668945, 0.05105591, -0.0107040405, -0.007850647, -0.03225708, -0.018920898, -0.0078125, -0.020950317, 0.029464722, 0.044677734, 0.009613037, -0.026977539, 0.0101623535, 0.006084442, -0.03186035, -0.04058838, 0.04458618, 0.016784668, 0.015151978, 0.03970337, -0.042175293, 0.016555786, -0.025161743, 0.013465881, 0.032073975, -0.0059165955, -0.0013885498, -0.011894226, -0.028366089, -0.02104187, -0.05895996, -0.006832123, 0.0016946793, -0.035186768, -0.0015506744, -0.02406311, -0.02947998, -0.010673523, 0.043273926, -0.014312744, -0.018035889, -0.011650085, 0.016738892, -0.022872925, -0.027618408, 0.0003285408, 0.044525146, -0.010971069, 0.0056495667, 0.01725769, 0.0262146, -0.00932312, 0.024810791, 0.02330017, -0.008087158, 0.011695862, -0.0010032654, -0.008407593, 0.016464233, 0.013000488, 0.013786316, -0.0085372925, -0.0211792, 0.02470398, 0.0050086975, 0.008117676, -0.007247925, -0.024551392, -0.016860962, -0.002286911, 0.009376526, 0.015090942, 0.053771973, -0.09802246, -0.090026855, -0.062316895, 0.035003662, -0.042785645, -0.0025157928, -0.018066406, 0.010894775, -0.024612427, -0.013824463, 0.055908203, -0.022827148, 0.018585205, 0.025543213, 0.062438965, -0.0181427, -0.05331421, -0.039886475, -0.022598267, 0.0018472672, 0.051208496, -0.029296875, -0.040405273, -0.030929565, -0.10632324, -0.009017944, -0.001625061, -0.009628296, 0.010063171, 0.011627197, 0.00592041, 0.021759033, 0.04928589, -0.017562866, 0.0021858215, 0.011169434, 0.023284912, 0.038848877, -0.026000977, 0.01701355, 0.01399231, 0.021224976, -0.007926941, 0.006072998, 0.027862549, 0.019577026, 0.033203125, -0.009117126, 0.028686523, -0.009857178, 0.05935669, 0.02432251, -0.060516357, -0.049682617, 0.0025730133, 0.0074005127, 0.06555176, 0.014694214, -0.023666382, -0.018218994, -0.05380249, -0.012542725, -0.05105591, -0.027664185, 0.023223877, 0.032928467, -0.017074585, 0.012565613, -0.016052246, 0.01209259, -0.039520264, 0.0158844, -0.02217102, -0.011756897, -0.020095825, 0.011489868, -0.03366089, 0.030731201, 0.063964844, 0.011505127, -0.05657959, 0.0592041, 0.008758545, -0.04537964, 0.028381348, 0.028244019, 0.014328003, -0.0093688965, 0.0051193237, -0.0044174194, 0.029434204, 0.03414917, -0.03375244, 0.0019044876, -0.0017023087, -0.004142761, 0.0010757446, 0.03326416, 0.064331055, -0.041259766, 0.064208984, 0.049865723, -0.0116119385, -0.05215454, -0.056884766, -0.08654785, 0.016479492, 0.058410645, -0.007698059, 0.0027923584, -0.02204895, 0.0012130737, 0.048187256, -0.012481689, 0.006248474, 0.013946533, 0.025665283, 0.05239868, 0.035339355, 0.020446777, 0.025741577, -0.05215454, 0.010322571, 0.06121826, -0.012817383, -0.0055999756, 0.0034370422, 0.012260437, 0.014533997, 0.005962372, -0.0146484375, 0.0047340393, -0.062561035, 0.0069351196, -0.041503906, -0.01008606, -0.005455017, 0.0023269653, 0.041625977, 0.008476257, 0.0152282715, 0.010925293, 0.0127334595, -0.0024604797, 0.0023441315, 0.001001358, 0.015914917, -0.037872314, -0.016448975, -0.0026283264, 0.025039673, -0.011940002, 0.014717102, 0.026977539, 0.021575928, -0.032318115, -0.054779053, -0.018341064, 0.028442383, 0.06286621, -0.008560181, 0.0005354881, 0.035858154, 0.020523071, 0.11352539, 0.057678223, -0.026290894, 0.039886475, -0.021881104, 0.021087646, 0.013504028, -0.0181427, 0.015823364, 0.0014562607, 0.049560547, 0.009529114, -0.037994385, 0.0067749023, -0.044158936, 0.005340576, 0.00015461445, -0.02482605, -0.050445557, -0.06652832, -0.011726379, -0.037994385, -0.07147217, -0.030044556, 0.066711426, -0.009147644, -0.024307251, 0.018157959, 0.0035171509, -0.020248413, 0.0042304993, -0.036193848, -0.027526855, 0.010803223, 0.04156494, -0.0020160675, -0.059051514, -0.0446167, -0.012336731, 0.0028266907, -0.022872925, 0.011550903, -0.026870728, 0.035949707, 0.0072746277, 0.008995056, 0.026809692, -0.056243896, -0.016357422, -0.04522705, 0.028778076, 0.010643005, -0.028656006, -0.0027713776, 0.029586792, -0.022109985, -0.00074100494, 0.0043792725, 0.056915283, -0.0209198, -0.042144775, 0.01979065, 0.022384644, -0.029174805, 0.038208008, 0.018859863, 0.013153076, -0.03564453, -0.059326172, -0.033081055, -0.026550293, 0.010574341, 0.02204895, 0.0670166, -0.037841797, -0.01651001, -0.016479492, -0.0019054413, 0.0206604, -0.020477295, -0.021240234, -0.03668213, 0.009979248, -0.0029907227, -0.00055885315, 0.02166748, -0.023895264, 0.04159546, 0.07714844, 0.005607605, -0.004180908, 0.027420044, 0.026153564, 0.0038604736, -0.015899658, -0.0015993118, -0.0132751465, -0.0027389526, 0.034942627, 0.007183075, -0.01083374, 0.023010254, -0.08081055, -0.00995636, 0.02267456, 0.021606445, -0.004272461, 0.01626587, -0.062408447, 0.009376526, -0.035064697, -0.017486572, 0.029174805, 0.013961792, 0.019363403, 0.003993988, 0.021865845, -0.0501709, 0.01625061, -0.05429077, -0.099975586, 0.031585693, -0.041290283, -0.031463623, -0.009613037, -0.02796936, -0.052337646, -0.016235352, -0.011924744, 0.05343628, 0.004436493, 0.02482605, -0.0067329407, -0.018859863, -0.003358841, -0.02696228, -0.022033691, -0.021255493, -0.0690918, 0.004623413, 0.012825012, 0.051971436, 0.050750732, -0.025527954, 0.011146545, -0.0066375732, 0.00039887428, 0.024810791, 0.031707764, -0.05230713, -0.012168884, 0.019500732, 0.019439697, 0.016281128, -0.04135132, 0.01373291, -0.020339966, 0.0068893433, -0.023864746, -0.02923584, 0.0039520264, 0.0040740967, -0.016494751, -0.025634766, 0.012161255, -0.022018433, -0.027816772, -0.0107040405, 0.036987305, 0.019943237, -0.03125, 0.004146576, -0.019500732, -0.0009613037, 0.004081726, 0.014480591, 0.008674622, 0.00009506941, -0.0065574646, -0.019302368, -0.008140564, 0.016067505, -0.023269653, -0.010520935, -0.025360107, 0.009979248, -0.0079422, -0.06500244, -0.0011529922, 0.0035209656, -0.078186035, -0.011016846, 0.014335632, -0.019119263, -0.04248047, -0.034454346, 0.031021118, -0.024749756, -0.026855469, 0.023757935, -0.009773254, -0.014595032, -0.020965576, -0.10180664, 0.0029830933, 0.056762695, 0.0038795471, 0.046173096, 0.060791016, -0.011627197, -0.051971436, -0.018310547, 0.029403687, 0.018600464, 0.025817871, 0.011749268, -0.028289795, 0.0107040405, -0.019943237, 0.038360596, 0.011878967, -0.06738281, 0.024642944, 0.03062439, 0.02458191, 0.025863647, 0.0007677078, 0.037994385, -0.0011758804, -0.011505127, -0.053527832, -0.0018444061, -0.016464233, 0.0009365082, 0.011978149, -0.003288269, -0.011657715, 0.004737854, 0.031707764, 0.038238525, -0.015075684, -0.006713867, 0.030441284, -0.019302368, -0.007003784, -0.0021648407, 0.0044403076, 0.024978638, 0.00067949295, -0.0023975372, -0.010871887, 0.025436401, -0.012878418, -0.023590088, 0.000682354, 0.023712158, -0.040130615, 0.006904602, -0.04336548, -0.01701355, -0.022781372, -0.009552002, -0.027557373, 0.07727051, 0.031707764, 0.018051147, -0.009063721, -0.027755737, 0.05569458, 0.008735657, -0.0023097992, -0.047576904, 0.014503479, -0.0033874512, -0.053375244, -0.03656006, 0.010215759, 0.014404297, 0.028930664, -0.0029582977, -0.012245178, 0.018707275, 0.02027893, 0.036865234, 0.030776978, -0.0032653809, -0.02734375, 0.05529785, -0.025024414, -0.036102295, 0.019119263, -0.01838684, -0.029724121, -0.032348633, 0.03717041, -0.017410278, -0.026733398, 0.013313293, 0.041015625, -0.01625061, 0.073913574, -0.008987427, 0.04522705, 0.018661499, 0.036712646, -0.015838623, 0.0038337708, -0.029144287, -0.014945984, -0.027053833, 0.038879395, 0.014511108, 0.025024414, 0.08178711, 0.007888794, -0.008132935, -0.0041999817, -0.0060424805, 0.012580872, 0.018157959, 0.04324341, -0.0036582947, -0.06311035, -0.0519104, 0.006603241, 0.010391235, 0.047973633, 0.008987427, 0.03100586, -0.045959473, 0.035339355, 0.0055389404, -0.023010254, 0.027648926, -0.023269653, 0.03942871, -0.040924072, -0.0602417, -0.025009155, 0.031951904, -0.015716553, -0.011131287, -0.0034713745, 0.023803711, 0.011413574, 0.03363037, 0.005378723, 0.026275635, -0.043792725, -0.023513794, -0.007083893, -0.037200928, -0.049560547, -0.0029315948, 0.018936157, 0.013008118, -0.026794434, 0.02015686, -0.07495117, -0.025680542, -0.014450073, -0.035247803, 0.020721436, -0.06341553, 0.013931274, 0.06994629, -0.024169922, 0.06286621, 0.017562866, 0.020446777, 0.029800415, 0.052093506, -0.0010185242, 0.030960083, 0.029174805, -0.03503418, 0.031555176, 0.015319824, 0.0132369995, -0.0012578964, 0.022918701, -0.00907135, -0.0013895035, -0.024368286, 0.012069702, 0.0051231384, -0.0011043549, 0.017868042, -0.04159546, 0.0035953522, 0.02406311, 0.006099701, 0.020584106, -0.015052795, -0.042419434, -0.027832031, 0.004459381, -0.048980713, -0.0048675537, 0.0013046265, -0.055755615, -0.008216858, 0.025527954, -0.00095415115, 0.0051498413, 0.018096924, -0.032714844, -0.044555664, 0.027770996, 0.04864502, -0.014801025, 0.015113831, -0.0072517395, 0.0032806396, 0.045898438, 0.030578613, 0.0010213852, -0.008552551, 0.0013799667, -0.04458618, -0.035247803, -0.010047913, -0.027313232, -0.0022144318, 0.004837036, -0.028656006, -0.027389526, 0.010429382, 0.03640747, -0.056152344, -0.011207581, 0.039886475, 0.00061035156, 0.001914978, 0.009155273, -0.003578186, 0.0041542053, 0.0060424805, 0.003074646, -0.02746582, 0.013511658, -0.0077552795, 0.005126953, -0.014137268, -0.06939697, 0.010719299, 0.013755798, 0.015655518, -0.004146576, 0.025253296, 0.027282715, -0.004673004, 0.02017212, 0.017654419, 0.06677246, -0.045166016, -0.019882202, 0.023040771, 0.013504028, -0.002746582, 0.066345215, -0.0012540817, -0.010238647, -0.039794922, -0.031311035, -0.024047852, 0.01828003, 0.021865845, -0.009468079, 0.033691406, -0.038604736, -0.0074653625, -0.023269653, -0.019348145, -0.045440674, 0.022750854, 0.00085258484, -0.016021729, 0.009841919, -0.018447876, -0.007949829, -0.023147583, 0.003332138, 0.012527466, -0.008644104, -0.0022354126, -0.03353882, -0.004055023, -0.031707764, -0.026275635, 0.027664185, 0.025741577, -0.043823242, 0.03439331, -0.020385742, 0.078430176, 0.006767273, 0.02947998, 0.038726807, 0.013916016, -0.00472641, -0.007575989, 0.017868042, -0.03564453, 0.032470703, -0.03164673, 0.007534027, -0.06323242, -0.013748169, -0.082214355, 0.0146865845, 0.019226074, 0.022033691, 0.016525269, 0.010047913, 0.022109985, -0.022033691, 0.02973938, -0.019989014, 0.047851562, -0.01146698, -0.0013151169, 0.0022659302, -0.048553467, 0.040618896, 0.051727295, -0.01600647, -0.010047913, -0.003370285, -0.024353027, 0.007129669, 0.015464783, 0.009483337, -0.032714844, -0.0066452026, -0.03817749, 0.031799316, 0.011627197, 0.047302246, 0.043273926, 0.0071029663, 0.025802612, -0.020309448, -0.022949219, -0.05429077, -0.014282227, -0.01777649, 0.0135269165, -0.07775879, 0.02482605, -0.01828003, -0.00223732, -0.044891357, 0.01499939, 0.030776978, -0.044647217, -0.031082153, 0.022354126, 0.04147339, -0.002363205, -0.021835327, -0.042907715, -0.015808105, 0.015823364, 0.03074646, -0.015945435, 0.0031604767, 0.0060272217, 0.036102295, -0.009284973, -0.046447754, 0.0231781, -0.03475952, 0.024276733, 0.019866943, -0.009376526, 0.036743164, -0.021148682, -0.028671265, 0.0018196106, 0.009963989, -0.07067871, -0.00944519, 0.030288696, 0.019683838, 0.0619812, 0.085510254, 0.024993896, 0.012763977, 0.011077881, -0.064331055, 0.02507019, 0.0051879883, -0.011375427, 0.02684021, -0.04888916, -0.020492554, 0.020904541, -0.0357666, 0.024032593, -0.054229736, -0.01461792, -0.03933716, 0.061828613, 0.0035476685, -0.05126953, -0.037719727, -0.018692017, 0.0067481995, -0.027633667, -0.031021118, -0.005748749, -0.056274414, -0.027770996, 0.07055664, -0.015930176, -0.0012140274, 0.0016441345, -0.012062073, -0.060668945, 0.00466156, -0.039276123, 0.05126953, -0.035186768, 0.012580872, 0.0006957054, -0.019638062, -0.012168884, -0.041656494, -0.012138367, -0.058044434, -0.05609131, -0.050994873, 0.009544373, 0.0057258606, -0.018203735, -0.031311035, -0.042633057, 0.0038928986, -0.042144775, 0.024459839, 0.020996094, -0.06524658, 0.0015096664, 0.010749817, -0.026947021, 0.052459717, 0.020248413, -0.021438599, 0.0317688, 0.0011539459, -0.030776978, 0.003917694, 0.02255249, 0.046173096, -0.0075263977, -0.05908203, 0.0181427, 0.029373169, 0.06225586, -0.023513794, -0.033203125, 0.022247314, 0.00014972687, 0.008850098, 0.0317688, -0.007369995, 0.0056648254, 0.039520264, 0.024276733, 0.011100769, -0.05255127, -0.02558899, -0.015419006, 0.037475586, 0.032196045, 0.010375977, -0.0284729, 0.015838623, -0.019699097, -0.0041160583, -0.0044937134, 0.011039734, 0.017700195, -0.00066137314, 0.053527832, -0.027313232, -0.006401062, -0.07196045, 0.05859375, -0.009269714, 0.026168823, -0.0059661865, 0.041809082, 0.011177063, 0.062438965, -0.008415222, -0.08343506, 0.038635254, 0.050750732, -0.004333496, 0.021453857, -0.018508911, -0.032196045, -0.013748169, -0.004180908, -0.007446289, 0.022659302, 0.008232117, -0.029067993, 0.015655518, -0.03692627, -0.035461426, -0.013412476, -0.030319214, 0.03656006, -0.038208008, 0.017807007, -0.038391113, 0.0053710938, -0.0048103333, 0.02645874, 0.008872986, -0.02178955, -0.038024902, -0.052947998, 0.039093018, -0.018630981 ], "summary": [ -0.012939453, 0.007873535, -0.023345947, -0.0072669983, -0.013870239, 0.0059051514, -0.06542969, -0.027648926, -0.0146865845, 0.015808105, -0.0069618225, 0.031829834, 0.00024867058, -0.039916992, 0.027328491, -0.025466919, -0.017089844, 0.022872925, -0.019714355, -0.023742676, 0.024032593, -0.036102295, -0.052947998, -0.012641907, 0.037017822, -0.10296631, 0.047210693, -0.0056533813, 0.034423828, 0.013793945, 0.017684937, -0.016616821, -0.019729614, 0.03555298, 0.011955261, 0.041137695, -0.058807373, 0.053253174, 0.05307007, -0.027770996, 0.044158936, -0.024734497, 0.06488037, -0.000040888786, 0.009559631, 0.054016113, -0.0072746277, -0.04425049, 0.016799927, 0.007858276, -0.0018453598, 0.0035095215, -0.012008667, 0.06463623, -0.022476196, -0.016952515, -0.07086182, -0.0030326843, 0.0059318542, 0.097473145, 0.03805542, -0.005935669, -0.014274597, -0.043945312, 0.012245178, 0.023147583, -0.011299133, 0.0024814606, 0.033477783, 0.028625488, -0.015296936, -0.016235352, 0.029769897, -0.035369873, -0.026977539, 0.056396484, -0.0050201416, 0.034332275, 0.043701172, -0.047546387, 0.022537231, -0.033294678, 0.009780884, 0.0037403107, -0.005874634, 0.0132751465, 0.0030078888, -0.027359009, 0.015365601, -0.030258179, -0.008460999, 0.0060653687, -0.021530151, 0.032470703, 0.0007791519, -0.047332764, 0.0118255615, 0.015945435, -0.044433594, -0.026168823, 0.021026611, -0.019882202, -0.008552551, -0.0032958984, -0.013977051, 0.04296875, 0.00016653538, 0.0039043427, 0.005657196, 0.012199402, -0.0084991455, -0.010482788, -0.0044441223, -0.0602417, 0.0054893494, 0.0135650635, -0.011978149, 0.034606934, 0.029129028, 0.005859375, -0.035736084, -0.0020542145, 0.03652954, 0.027938843, -0.004020691, 0.0413208, 0.01852417, -0.05960083, 0.0112838745, -0.025512695, -0.008071899, 0.047973633, -0.014198303, -0.044555664, -0.038513184, 0.001953125, -0.02998352, 0.0042152405, -0.008399963, -0.0057678223, -0.027511597, 0.0028972626, 0.062561035, -0.007297516, 0.04058838, 0.056121826, 0.031021118, -0.020980835, -0.0058517456, -0.039245605, 0.007019043, -0.012313843, 0.05984497, -0.06036377, -0.03137207, -0.06958008, -0.066833496, 0.0025138855, 0.017974854, -0.020828247, 0.02494812, 0.0014686584, 0.02268982, 0.047332764, 0.030685425, -0.0041275024, -0.010223389, 0.0036678314, 0.026641846, 0.043792725, 0.0034542084, -0.0066871643, 0.021347046, 0.007144928, -0.021820068, 0.0033054352, 0.0064849854, 0.04220581, 0.00415802, -0.010124207, 0.037261963, -0.035308838, 0.06311035, 0.004501343, -0.026550293, -0.049621582, -0.024749756, 0.0015335083, 0.086120605, 0.012107849, -0.016067505, -0.06225586, -0.03286743, 0.014862061, -0.045135498, -0.02923584, -0.009361267, 0.023422241, -0.033233643, 0.016403198, 0.064086914, 0.0031967163, -0.010505676, -0.028900146, -0.051208496, -0.017166138, -0.0026798248, 0.015716553, -0.012557983, -0.00023472309, 0.0052604675, -0.039093018, -0.034973145, 0.08679199, 0.009086609, -0.023635864, 0.014213562, 0.03552246, 0.017593384, -0.009475708, 0.03265381, -0.0075798035, 0.020645142, 0.032470703, -0.050872803, 0.034118652, -0.020812988, 0.05319214, 0.01247406, 0.041290283, 0.048095703, -0.06341553, 0.070373535, 0.061431885, -0.004940033, -0.02520752, -0.035247803, -0.12451172, -0.007850647, 0.07299805, 0.015274048, 0.04168701, -0.052886963, -0.02027893, 0.05429077, 0.003124237, 0.01259613, 0.004459381, 0.0026340485, 0.050750732, -0.0181427, 0.0030288696, -0.014083862, -0.07104492, -0.019744873, 0.02319336, -0.042419434, -0.004749298, 0.0018930435, -0.008758545, 0.0056762695, -0.036193848, 0.0033454895, -0.02558899, -0.021438599, -0.036895752, -0.019760132, -0.023544312, -0.004180908, -0.026351929, 0.024169922, -0.01625061, 0.012252808, -0.025970459, 0.00043654442, -0.006385803, -0.008651733, 0.0027332306, 0.016098022, -0.022262573, 0.0010585785, -0.005882263, 0.015083313, -0.013191223, 0.02305603, 0.027191162, 0.027572632, -0.015388489, -0.030685425, 0.020080566, 0.021728516, 0.043182373, 0.00944519, -0.0041885376, 0.021438599, 0.024124146, 0.06866455, 0.0087890625, 0.015670776, -0.0087890625, 0.04498291, 0.038848877, -0.033172607, 0.009803772, 0.0140686035, -0.010437012, 0.034606934, 0.0038318634, -0.008399963, 0.004459381, -0.06085205, -0.0058059692, 0.0140686035, 0.0062789917, -0.039978027, -0.036376953, -0.051849365, 0.0046844482, -0.07312012, 0.020553589, 0.093444824, 0.007965088, 0.016693115, 0.056915283, 0.0008687973, -0.053253174, 0.075683594, -0.0345459, 0.003894806, -0.004524231, -0.010574341, -0.03857422, -0.05065918, 0.010475159, 0.00040221214, -0.012001038, -0.0019607544, 0.025390625, -0.006023407, 0.022628784, 0.0066108704, 0.02520752, 0.012321472, -0.02947998, -0.039031982, 0.008705139, 0.027557373, -0.008041382, -0.026809692, 0.019958496, 0.01537323, -0.017547607, 0.012634277, -0.009422302, 0.012382507, -0.017166138, -0.038269043, -0.039398193, -0.03665161, -0.084106445, 0.05633545, 0.012306213, 0.037017822, 0.01979065, -0.08868408, -0.015304565, -0.00025868416, 0.026382446, 0.049072266, 0.049468994, 0.005207062, 0.03503418, -0.01625061, -0.019424438, -0.010658264, -0.038726807, 0.024169922, -0.018081665, 0.03353882, 0.034332275, 0.022979736, 0.05911255, -0.004589081, 0.07092285, 0.0579834, 0.0051460266, 0.02230835, 0.02204895, 0.031799316, -0.00712204, -0.006298065, 0.0026416779, -0.020080566, -0.026916504, 0.03967285, -0.0023880005, -0.0030288696, 0.064697266, -0.03491211, -0.027694702, -0.0074691772, 0.0236969, 0.039642334, -0.0340271, -0.0015287399, -0.026672363, -0.034179688, -0.004699707, 0.025314331, -0.043182373, 0.03717041, -0.053131104, 0.027114868, -0.07055664, -0.0074539185, -0.028823853, -0.039794922, 0.015594482, -0.043273926, -0.02017212, -0.0087890625, 0.017669678, -0.015731812, -0.012588501, -0.002527237, 0.06298828, -0.01838684, 0.012252808, -0.015411377, -0.0014944077, 0.009101868, -0.018310547, -0.00598526, -0.010604858, -0.06402588, 0.011764526, 0.0104904175, -0.0015993118, 0.05117798, -0.060699463, -0.0053863525, 0.0020999908, 0.006290436, 0.0040512085, 0.015792847, -0.02268982, 0.006465912, -0.015159607, 0.031463623, 0.023117065, -0.021972656, 0.0060424805, 0.020202637, 0.015930176, -0.018753052, -0.030471802, -0.043426514, 0.024887085, 0.041015625, -0.0056648254, 0.025604248, -0.016784668, -0.0009765625, -0.008575439, 0.02720642, 0.04864502, -0.075805664, 0.016967773, -0.012611389, -0.023422241, 0.027542114, 0.0088272095, 0.0038661957, -0.0039100647, 0.013267517, -0.049346924, 0.023666382, 0.053375244, -0.05758667, -0.051483154, -0.07067871, 0.036987305, -0.043884277, -0.026931763, -0.020355225, 0.016937256, -0.021499634, -0.0146484375, -0.0072250366, 0.031173706, -0.029083252, -0.0105896, 0.044677734, -0.023117065, -0.019622803, 0.042907715, -0.017044067, 0.056488037, -0.0060653687, -0.05847168, 0.021850586, -0.017807007, -0.008140564, 0.04434204, -0.0021591187, 0.0018548965, -0.009002686, 0.0020999908, 0.0043563843, -0.059173584, 0.047973633, -0.028518677, -0.02218628, -0.012954712, -0.0066566467, 0.03756714, 0.02078247, -0.10449219, 0.0574646, 0.026184082, 0.064208984, 0.022018433, 0.026535034, -0.01461792, 0.019958496, 0.005428314, -0.0079956055, -0.007785797, -0.02128601, -0.011787415, 0.041503906, 0.03475952, -0.034179688, -0.014312744, 0.026351929, -0.015930176, -0.035095215, -0.03237915, -0.0035514832, 0.031021118, -0.025100708, -0.038269043, -0.0021018982, 0.062683105, -0.0075149536, -0.034057617, -0.0067710876, 0.029144287, -0.016952515, -0.013839722, 0.020309448, 0.019821167, -0.0119018555, -0.004043579, -0.014221191, 0.03189087, -0.026046753, 0.0011968613, -0.026763916, 0.046813965, 0.024108887, 0.016937256, 0.007896423, -0.030593872, 0.05441284, 0.010299683, 0.0006632805, -0.05633545, -0.026550293, -0.0040779114, -0.03024292, -0.012054443, 0.0017032623, -0.015457153, -0.004020691, -0.015602112, -0.016784668, 0.02116394, 0.0039405823, 0.014526367, 0.00187397, 0.017349243, -0.014343262, 0.009384155, -0.02368164, 0.0052604675, -0.0066337585, -0.054748535, -0.044708252, -0.00737381, 0.046020508, 0.0030612946, -0.015098572, 0.0119018555, 0.01499176, -0.0031337738, 0.054107666, -0.035003662, 0.0037155151, -0.0038795471, 0.0446167, -0.032836914, 0.0061798096, -0.009651184, 0.00071668625, -0.06561279, -0.0028152466, 0.034729004, 0.0017089844, 0.061828613, 0.00047922134, -0.053894043, 0.02633667, -0.0051498413, 0.02420044, 0.028305054, 0.02079773, -0.004802704, -0.01864624, -0.034484863, 0.033691406, -0.0014486313, 0.023620605, 0.06402588, -0.0121154785, -0.03237915, -0.0058250427, 0.0041160583, -0.005367279, -0.0025043488, 0.02558899, 0.0035076141, -0.030838013, -0.029067993, -0.014404297, 0.019012451, -0.008110046, -0.026550293, -0.022644043, -0.019851685, 0.023651123, -0.029205322, -0.033996582, 0.0284729, -0.053375244, -0.0059127808, 0.010017395, -0.008430481, -0.019317627, -0.010978699, 0.043792725, 0.01586914, -0.017944336, 0.020309448, -0.0013246536, 0.009742737, -0.02696228, -0.03173828, -0.029800415, -0.017547607, -0.033355713, -0.0014429092, -0.047607422, 0.045684814, 0.07495117, -0.029510498, -0.010620117, 0.018737793, -0.03302002, 0.0155181885, -0.016418457, -0.03604126, -0.004878998, -0.0045394897, 0.012557983, 0.03817749, 0.0038547516, 0.01864624, -0.006401062, 0.0013990402, -0.01737976, 0.0028915405, 0.03125, -0.009246826, -0.009223938, 0.016601562, 0.019332886, 0.015037537, -0.024658203, 0.043273926, -0.04837036, -0.004360199, 0.0102005005, 0.017044067, -0.03527832, -0.024887085, -0.025497437, 0.03829956, 0.007881165, -0.011306763, 0.023269653, 0.024291992, -0.05621338, -0.019088745, 0.0039749146, 0.0340271, -0.000074625015, 0.009841919, 0.007724762, -0.007598877, 0.00042057037, 0.03375244, -0.019592285, -0.007858276, -0.0037670135, -0.028762817, -0.04788208, -0.016921997, -0.026977539, 0.016555786, -0.0021743774, 0.0038833618, -0.032165527, -0.015625, 0.031677246, -0.08300781, -0.019165039, 0.012924194, -0.017837524, -0.022201538, 0.028747559, -0.017410278, -0.021530151, 0.0058631897, 0.004722595, -0.04901123, 0.012321472, -0.027557373, 0.01133728, -0.047576904, -0.05038452, -0.003583908, 0.027008057, 0.016311646, 0.032440186, 0.043701172, 0.019500732, 0.032043457, 0.008369446, 0.033294678, 0.032684326, -0.028305054, -0.049224854, 0.030792236, 0.022979736, 0.03326416, 0.058807373, 0.02470398, -0.04574585, -0.013069153, -0.009216309, 0.0076179504, -0.0028057098, 0.0020771027, -0.008804321, 0.016494751, -0.03012085, -0.027175903, 0.00017154217, -0.031082153, -0.04940796, -0.018600464, -0.036468506, -0.040222168, 0.09887695, 0.005847931, 0.007637024, -0.0049591064, -0.0010251999, -0.008377075, -0.020645142, -0.011619568, -0.009819031, 0.009170532, -0.028457642, 0.037078857, 0.004627228, 0.078430176, -0.05419922, 0.003665924, 0.017440796, 0.076171875, 0.0073890686, -0.012718201, -0.024093628, -0.017654419, -0.0049743652, 0.0042800903, 0.02734375, -0.021316528, 0.045959473, -0.0051002502, -0.020095825, -0.04486084, -0.037597656, -0.036071777, 0.026519775, -0.02067566, 0.007171631, 0.016708374, 0.021606445, -0.00015032291, -0.020248413, -0.034332275, -0.023498535, 0.0079422, -0.036987305, -0.006603241, 0.03237915, -0.07348633, 0.016067505, 0.05441284, -0.054870605, 0.029556274, 0.030853271, -0.010864258, 0.030166626, -0.0072288513, -0.025741577, -0.04989624, 0.03062439, -0.035095215, 0.022583008, 0.026992798, 0.03704834, -0.004550934, -0.025726318, 0.0602417, -0.026947021, -0.015136719, -0.020599365, -0.008666992, 0.0039901733, -0.0026950836, -0.035217285, 0.01033783, 0.014823914, -0.0058517456, -0.0013771057, -0.0038108826, 0.017318726, -0.027450562, -0.020080566, -0.006706238, 0.030303955, 0.0000121593475, -0.011207581, -0.031433105, 0.004142761, 0.0023670197, -0.020523071, 0.018234253, -0.0012750626, 0.017105103, 0.03503418, 0.0021629333, -0.012145996, 0.005027771, -0.033721924, 0.011299133, 0.027496338, 0.007381439, -0.0004556179, -0.023513794, -0.016662598, -0.010940552, 0.030731201, -0.054107666, 0.030288696, -0.022232056, 0.03845215, 0.12609863, 0.084472656, -0.019683838, 0.054840088, 0.09338379, -0.05328369, 0.006259918, -0.0037002563, 0.039916992, 0.0104904175, -0.052337646, 0.015640259, -0.017562866, 0.017715454, 0.03378296, -0.054870605, -0.0040016174, -0.057739258, 0.053985596, -0.055267334, -0.02355957, -0.020812988, -0.04675293, 0.035339355, -0.032196045, -0.029968262, -0.022888184, -0.049468994, -0.062316895, 0.078552246, -0.05819702, -0.023620605, 0.019332886, -0.0019798279, -0.041259766, -0.029876709, 0.0025920868, 0.017059326, 0.011146545, -0.029403687, 0.021835327, -0.020996094, 0.0068130493, -0.060699463, -0.011207581, -0.077819824, -0.0053367615, -0.016647339, -0.011070251, -0.0022258759, -0.020126343, -0.02619934, -0.05041504, 0.021972656, -0.03842163, 0.057647705, 0.029296875, -0.04611206, -0.02178955, 0.030899048, -0.022521973, 0.06359863, 0.005443573, -0.01940918, 0.023529053, 0.0031433105, -0.008590698, -0.010826111, 0.011123657, 0.0050354004, -0.020858765, -0.041107178, 0.0025291443, 0.01789856, 0.06274414, 0.003900528, -0.0044288635, 0.022155762, 0.0070877075, 0.009651184, -0.002111435, -0.0597229, -0.025161743, 0.06878662, 0.05227661, 0.028076172, -0.028808594, 0.044647217, 0.04333496, -0.003929138, -0.0020484924, -0.0074539185, -0.01838684, -0.015571594, -0.026809692, -0.006877899, -0.018966675, 0.03894043, -0.026397705, -0.008735657, 0.01600647, -0.028274536, -0.05508423, -0.031585693, 0.032287598, -0.017990112, -0.022232056, 0.012008667, 0.014022827, -0.024230957, -0.017532349, 0.0019283295, -0.023452759, -0.0012731552, 0.013877869, 0.008728027, 0.008575439, 0.0053215027, -0.028060913, -0.012123108, -0.0005803108, 0.008811951, 0.033477783, 0.010276794, -0.02558899, 0.015945435, -0.05734253, -0.015426636, -0.010726929, -0.012886047, 0.027542114, -0.016433716, 0.011764526, 0.012718201, 0.0044288635, 0.013633728, 0.047180176, 0.009933472, 0.009490967, 0.011856079, -0.06378174, 0.013938904, -0.005420685 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07115v1
Gen-Z: Generative Zero-Shot Text Classification with Contextualized Label Descriptions
Sachin Kumar, Chan Young Park, Yulia Tsvetkov
cs.CL
Language model (LM) prompting--a popular paradigm for solving NLP tasks--has been shown to be susceptible to miscalibration and brittleness to slight prompt variations, caused by its discriminative prompting approach, i.e., predicting the label given the input. To address these issues, we propose Gen-Z--a generative prompting framework for zero-shot text classification. GEN-Z is generative, as it measures the LM likelihood of input text, conditioned on natural language descriptions of labels. The framework is multivariate, as label descriptions allow us to seamlessly integrate additional contextual information about the labels to improve task performance. On various standard classification benchmarks, with six open-source LM families, we show that zero-shot classification with simple contextualization of the data source of the evaluation set consistently outperforms both zero-shot and few-shot baselines while improving robustness to prompt variations. Further, our approach enables personalizing classification in a zero-shot manner by incorporating author, subject, or reader information in the label descriptions.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07115v1
2023-11-13T07:12:57
2023-11-13T07:12:57
{ "title": [ -0.010887146, 0.000726223, -0.035095215, -0.055664062, 0.0011844635, -0.0052833557, -0.026321411, -0.008377075, 0.0141067505, 0.03793335, -0.028259277, 0.030960083, -0.007549286, 0.0027503967, -0.050964355, -0.00016629696, -0.025482178, 0.05883789, -0.028701782, -0.04824829, -0.019012451, -0.07684326, 0.038909912, 0.025939941, 0.016494751, -0.057495117, -0.031433105, 0.018249512, -0.030593872, -0.01361084, -0.0015239716, -0.0068473816, 0.04031372, 0.018997192, 0.018051147, 0.05795288, -0.041992188, 0.030151367, 0.039764404, -0.006752014, 0.032196045, -0.0131073, -0.031585693, -0.013824463, -0.044128418, 0.008956909, -0.03942871, -0.013786316, -0.01979065, 0.033721924, 0.015045166, 0.027618408, -0.010505676, -0.0051193237, 0.018707275, -0.040496826, -0.056518555, 0.01348114, 0.052368164, 0.060668945, 0.015106201, -0.080322266, 0.024291992, -0.019866943, -0.039855957, -0.034057617, -0.027664185, 0.012023926, 0.061584473, -0.010009766, -0.012466431, 0.019546509, -0.009567261, -0.036468506, -0.06323242, 0.046813965, 0.027053833, -0.0049972534, 0.020446777, -0.046051025, 0.0044937134, -0.019241333, 0.030090332, -0.010444641, 0.008232117, -0.01889038, -0.015541077, -0.013519287, -0.03616333, -0.053344727, -0.0031089783, -0.017547607, -0.032989502, 0.011787415, -0.014602661, -0.029678345, -0.013114929, 0.05508423, -0.0013990402, -0.026138306, -0.011695862, 0.03717041, -0.06323242, -0.004184723, 0.029876709, 0.019042969, -0.029815674, -0.02507019, 0.018341064, 0.021240234, -0.04135132, 0.04776001, 0.021606445, 0.013175964, -0.021011353, -0.0011482239, -0.0124053955, 0.002878189, 0.003610611, 0.023025513, 0.006072998, -0.015357971, 0.019866943, 0.028884888, 0.030059814, 0.007621765, -0.048065186, 0.004032135, 0.0067710876, 0.012008667, 0.024414062, 0.05834961, -0.08459473, -0.093688965, -0.0769043, 0.056427002, -0.021057129, -0.016586304, -0.025009155, 0.017547607, 0.013504028, -0.030792236, -0.0032615662, 0.0054397583, 0.010185242, 0.00995636, 0.06542969, 0.008338928, -0.041778564, -0.028305054, -0.023757935, 0.04336548, 0.06488037, -0.025512695, -0.08148193, -0.028259277, -0.0970459, -0.04107666, -0.00881958, -0.036071777, 0.035949707, 0.009269714, 0.0017185211, 0.0026016235, 0.030654907, -0.038146973, -0.02368164, 0.015434265, 0.006351471, -0.015594482, -0.025848389, 0.04333496, 0.01197052, 0.00491333, 0.010910034, 0.006679535, 0.02949524, 0.0007300377, 0.02394104, -0.014312744, -0.0013866425, -0.03189087, -0.010818481, 0.05206299, -0.057891846, -0.037322998, 0.010398865, 0.024902344, 0.043823242, 0.016937256, -0.032958984, -0.006313324, -0.04949951, -0.059539795, -0.047576904, -0.004272461, 0.0021781921, 0.024673462, -0.013000488, 0.032226562, -0.019012451, -0.028701782, -0.03366089, 0.0011196136, -0.036895752, -0.03302002, -0.032989502, 0.012237549, -0.064331055, 0.03164673, 0.06500244, 0.006587982, -0.04977417, 0.02142334, 0.028121948, -0.042541504, 0.010513306, -0.0152282715, -0.0041275024, -0.030883789, -0.012413025, 0.002752304, 0.0013046265, 0.05001831, 0.034210205, -0.012268066, 0.012504578, -0.029296875, 0.06567383, 0.003829956, 0.07318115, -0.019760132, 0.025939941, -0.003982544, -0.021392822, -0.019989014, -0.0056610107, -0.007762909, 0.01461792, 0.01612854, -0.0024414062, 0.020645142, -0.02583313, 0.01638794, 0.060272217, -0.0033359528, 0.008056641, 0.014968872, 0.022918701, 0.044555664, 0.045928955, 0.02279663, 0.034088135, -0.006454468, 0.014808655, 0.047729492, 0.02204895, 0.030395508, -0.03881836, 0.026992798, -0.0047302246, 0.05706787, 0.016052246, 0.021575928, -0.061798096, 0.026123047, -0.006389618, 0.025970459, 0.014434814, 0.0054893494, 0.009994507, 0.010826111, 0.004840851, -0.009506226, 0.048736572, -0.0009331703, -0.006427765, -0.0025024414, 0.015220642, -0.047821045, -0.0022640228, -0.0007534027, 0.028533936, 0.006664276, 0.039398193, -0.0010490417, 0.012901306, -0.0030994415, -0.034942627, -0.018997192, 0.018417358, 0.054840088, 0.00674057, -0.026565552, 0.031219482, 0.016021729, 0.109802246, 0.06549072, -0.033416748, 0.03970337, -0.03503418, 0.020629883, 0.0059051514, -0.01260376, 0.0022087097, 0.030319214, 0.015388489, 0.035064697, -0.0066337585, 0.010948181, -0.039489746, 0.016036987, -0.0041999817, -0.021560669, -0.054016113, -0.064941406, 0.00030970573, -0.035186768, -0.06304932, -0.052337646, 0.12109375, -0.033416748, -0.011604309, -0.013710022, -0.019012451, -0.039276123, 0.007835388, -0.040985107, -0.017410278, 0.008453369, 0.009429932, 0.0053482056, -0.06463623, 0.018218994, -0.0073890686, 0.023483276, -0.010353088, 0.010032654, -0.01637268, 0.009025574, 0.015029907, 0.023147583, 0.023071289, -0.025863647, 0.01889038, -0.085754395, 0.020233154, 0.015342712, -0.059661865, -0.007446289, 0.048706055, -0.022491455, -0.007457733, 0.026367188, 0.054229736, -0.0049057007, -0.030944824, 0.017822266, 0.021362305, -0.02696228, 0.009437561, 0.027145386, 0.014030457, -0.035827637, -0.039978027, -0.03857422, -0.02520752, 0.03479004, -0.023971558, 0.056274414, -0.032470703, -0.018936157, -0.05026245, -0.02960205, -0.03781128, 0.022155762, -0.024093628, -0.04940796, 0.016479492, -0.022369385, -0.00579834, 0.0005874634, -0.0079193115, -0.0001219511, 0.036224365, 0.025421143, -0.041137695, -0.009689331, 0.009384155, 0.010314941, -0.011878967, 0.005203247, -0.05718994, 0.010246277, 0.024612427, 0.0021648407, 0.032684326, 0.02015686, -0.1149292, -0.025344849, 0.0068740845, 0.013595581, -0.012611389, 0.013847351, -0.05923462, 0.031585693, -0.028533936, -0.026290894, 0.030410767, 0.06335449, -0.00315094, 0.015945435, 0.013664246, -0.010223389, 0.00422287, -0.03074646, -0.08807373, 0.028381348, -0.009475708, -0.04574585, -0.03152466, -0.011810303, -0.05255127, -0.0014238358, 0.007610321, 0.03918457, 0.011367798, 0.0000782609, 0.009613037, -0.021652222, -0.008811951, -0.041290283, -0.0032081604, -0.021560669, -0.043640137, 0.006641388, -0.017456055, 0.037475586, 0.0054359436, -0.0259552, -0.021636963, -0.012809753, -0.03378296, 0.0154800415, -0.0033607483, -0.041381836, -0.012191772, -0.014839172, -0.005138397, 0.013870239, -0.0067749023, -0.019973755, -0.03366089, 0.012756348, -0.02470398, 0.047729492, 0.0025024414, 0.013290405, -0.0033855438, -0.034606934, 0.013244629, -0.040039062, -0.022109985, 0.01689148, 0.022506714, 0.006542206, 0.014633179, -0.015472412, -0.025558472, 0.01828003, -0.030380249, -0.0032806396, -0.0023994446, -0.0053253174, -0.009559631, -0.010353088, 0.013931274, -0.0009784698, -0.0012187958, -0.015777588, 0.04333496, -0.014411926, 0.017120361, -0.08557129, 0.004299164, -0.00793457, -0.16101074, -0.050872803, 0.008056641, -0.0132751465, -0.05029297, -0.04525757, 0.032806396, -0.033325195, -0.03265381, 0.04031372, -0.008468628, -0.003835678, -0.025466919, -0.07531738, -0.03942871, 0.0770874, 0.013504028, 0.025878906, 0.05493164, -0.0039253235, -0.0010309219, -0.0071754456, 0.027862549, 0.01751709, 0.052215576, 0.008079529, -0.033050537, 0.028930664, -0.029388428, 0.0082092285, 0.011993408, -0.009117126, -0.00818634, 0.0020523071, 0.010032654, 0.028671265, -0.004928589, 0.04852295, 0.0076408386, -0.012168884, -0.042388916, 0.017837524, 0.00016224384, -0.011505127, 0.00945282, -0.0101623535, 0.03125, 0.024887085, 0.0076789856, 0.04598999, -0.013023376, -0.010551453, 0.058807373, 0.00674057, 0.0025596619, 0.01272583, 0.023742676, 0.028076172, -0.011459351, 0.04458618, -0.007232666, 0.04373169, -0.02670288, -0.02482605, 0.0059127808, 0.03479004, -0.034576416, -0.030670166, -0.05496216, -0.039123535, -0.02407837, 0.011451721, -0.01977539, 0.045440674, 0.02947998, 0.0043296814, -0.033966064, 0.0033683777, -0.0041389465, 0.008796692, -0.0025997162, -0.04547119, -0.0109939575, -0.01727295, -0.02658081, -0.020019531, -0.015220642, -0.026428223, 0.035125732, -0.0074272156, -0.004421234, 0.015930176, 0.014671326, 0.044830322, 0.054534912, -0.0034313202, -0.05529785, 0.027175903, 0.00248909, -0.03250122, -0.016998291, -0.010932922, -0.008720398, -0.01008606, 0.034820557, -0.041137695, -0.019927979, -0.026657104, 0.030456543, -0.019073486, 0.0680542, 0.017196655, 0.02784729, 0.03100586, 0.0070762634, 0.019470215, 0.026443481, -0.024383545, -0.05496216, 0.011657715, 0.007663727, 0.006916046, 0.0096588135, 0.038085938, 0.0007314682, 0.0024318695, 0.0029506683, 0.0025024414, 0.01335144, 0.012550354, 0.014144897, 0.017791748, -0.035949707, -0.045532227, -0.013267517, 0.007522583, 0.024551392, -0.057556152, 0.051116943, 0.014343262, 0.0021190643, 0.06866455, -0.007774353, -0.011909485, 0.009788513, -0.0071258545, -0.050445557, -0.05899048, -0.014083862, 0.033233643, -0.021881104, -0.005645752, -0.022079468, -0.020584106, 0.036071777, 0.06097412, 0.04727173, 0.0031166077, -0.008087158, 0.0069770813, 0.013069153, -0.033569336, -0.035491943, 0.001039505, 0.0009455681, -0.020553589, -0.042907715, -0.013259888, -0.03933716, -0.02381897, -0.00856781, -0.0059394836, -0.0009007454, -0.054107666, 0.018630981, 0.05014038, -0.0023498535, 0.02407837, -0.049560547, 0.03945923, 0.01763916, 0.04888916, 0.01424408, 0.0056648254, 0.03062439, -0.020614624, -0.013626099, -0.014221191, -0.0062561035, 0.029052734, 0.011505127, 0.023162842, 0.013679504, -0.04486084, 0.019546509, -0.0017518997, -0.029891968, -0.005809784, -0.020889282, 0.012504578, 0.010688782, -0.0044670105, 0.017196655, -0.043670654, -0.01576233, 0.00504303, -0.026992798, -0.045959473, 0.02168274, -0.023971558, -0.076049805, -0.04257202, 0.014831543, 0.020950317, -0.022232056, -0.013793945, 0.03677368, -0.038269043, 0.023590088, 0.042022705, -0.032287598, 0.002117157, -0.0013828278, 0.014930725, 0.044403076, 0.00995636, -0.059906006, -0.015052795, -0.014785767, -0.069885254, -0.066345215, 0.019760132, 0.01876831, -0.002035141, 0.01776123, -0.0262146, 0.015144348, 0.03100586, 0.04171753, -0.0077400208, -0.013046265, 0.051696777, -0.008323669, -0.00034689903, 0.006011963, -0.023910522, -0.010520935, 0.014038086, 0.00642395, 0.003019333, 0.014526367, -0.009819031, 0.037200928, -0.027008057, -0.05596924, -0.0064697266, 0.025772095, 0.0074043274, -0.005405426, 0.019821167, 0.03237915, 0.011657715, -0.0068969727, 0.0061683655, 0.05621338, -0.057128906, -0.008934021, -0.020019531, -0.000118255615, -0.04119873, 0.05105591, -0.011695862, -0.0061416626, -0.04156494, -0.054656982, -0.020492554, 0.027175903, 0.012527466, 0.011421204, 0.01701355, -0.028808594, 0.038024902, -0.018676758, -0.022827148, -0.027435303, 0.04269409, 0.007091522, 0.0065574646, -0.019226074, -0.053985596, -0.025619507, -0.012252808, 0.024902344, 0.021255493, -0.0042304993, 0.026382446, -0.0309906, 0.0021877289, -0.018325806, -0.033966064, 0.045562744, 0.0071983337, -0.005672455, 0.05783081, -0.0029067993, 0.057006836, 0.03845215, 0.040222168, 0.06341553, 0.009010315, 0.008743286, 0.0050354004, -0.0044670105, -0.031555176, 0.0010890961, -0.032440186, -0.021591187, -0.051574707, -0.022720337, -0.054138184, 0.014472961, -0.002161026, 0.025222778, 0.0016098022, 0.0017232895, -0.00712204, 0.010932922, 0.044158936, 0.026489258, 0.039855957, -0.024459839, 0.007820129, -0.034301758, -0.03286743, 0.034454346, 0.041259766, 0.00069999695, 0.0060539246, -0.026412964, -0.0060691833, 0.0006790161, 0.014381409, 0.018966675, -0.026473999, -0.012367249, -0.036254883, 0.049468994, 0.0032081604, 0.037628174, 0.054748535, 0.034606934, -0.015777588, -0.015716553, 0.004234314, -0.021835327, -0.0050964355, -0.0064926147, 0.0014629364, -0.031433105, 0.02330017, -0.0009484291, -0.021331787, -0.035247803, 0.03237915, 0.030731201, -0.06222534, -0.022476196, 0.035095215, 0.04296875, -0.019897461, 0.00084638596, -0.049682617, -0.029556274, 0.0044288635, 0.04336548, -0.023590088, 0.013282776, 0.023498535, 0.0435791, 0.010139465, -0.018920898, 0.027175903, -0.0010643005, 0.01927185, 0.041015625, -0.0019626617, 0.023330688, -0.010894775, -0.04647827, 0.008872986, 0.011260986, -0.05328369, -0.007083893, 0.027511597, 0.033172607, 0.04940796, 0.076416016, 0.030395508, 0.0029850006, -0.020874023, -0.048217773, -0.007926941, 0.014717102, -0.039398193, -0.0021820068, -0.041168213, -0.037597656, 0.009628296, -0.057647705, 0.05987549, -0.043304443, -0.01361084, -0.020935059, 0.008850098, 0.046936035, -0.05014038, -0.026779175, -0.021865845, 0.023757935, -0.0184021, 0.005256653, -0.04638672, -0.061523438, -0.014915466, 0.054779053, -0.023269653, 0.0049057007, -0.0036201477, -0.027496338, -0.046905518, 0.012306213, -0.02279663, 0.06060791, -0.02619934, 0.007572174, 0.0058174133, -0.0039634705, -0.0048294067, -0.041503906, -0.033599854, 0.002008438, -0.026763916, -0.028671265, -0.016845703, -0.00894928, -0.023406982, -0.047973633, 0.0016708374, 0.00818634, -0.028137207, 0.02583313, 0.031402588, -0.06222534, -0.02734375, -0.003479004, -0.022750854, 0.04977417, 0.009422302, -0.022201538, 0.02230835, 0.009773254, -0.012931824, -0.034484863, -0.009605408, 0.0043182373, 0.00053071976, -0.036254883, 0.011566162, 0.017852783, 0.04425049, -0.055877686, -0.039489746, -0.00617218, 0.034179688, -0.0048942566, 0.039520264, 0.03451538, -0.009857178, 0.013381958, -0.0043792725, -0.0007967949, -0.019180298, -0.030914307, -0.024734497, 0.044403076, 0.041625977, -0.00667572, -0.01612854, 0.03945923, -0.020217896, -0.00869751, 0.0040359497, -0.021606445, -0.009963989, 0.022247314, 0.030639648, -0.004207611, -0.036010742, -0.06555176, 0.025466919, 0.015296936, 0.03555298, -0.017562866, 0.033843994, -0.002363205, 0.05331421, -0.025970459, -0.058898926, 0.025405884, 0.028396606, -0.00907135, 0.05203247, -0.024002075, -0.01133728, -0.004463196, -0.020874023, -0.02128601, -0.015159607, 0.029754639, -0.055236816, -0.0063667297, -0.04385376, -0.017150879, -0.06463623, -0.041015625, 0.04019165, -0.02508545, -0.0022239685, -0.022232056, 0.006843567, -0.011528015, 0.040740967, 0.015701294, -0.03152466, -0.030059814, -0.018707275, 0.06463623, -0.012458801 ], "summary": [ 0.00036668777, -0.02482605, -0.02571106, -0.04736328, -0.03805542, -0.0021324158, -0.05307007, 0.0028591156, 0.020370483, 0.006378174, -0.044769287, 0.036590576, -0.024810791, -0.012802124, 0.007789612, -0.026947021, -0.02331543, 0.030715942, -0.0335083, -0.050109863, -0.009346008, -0.0769043, -0.008041382, 0.002418518, 0.0055007935, 0.0071983337, -0.01083374, -0.010292053, 0.0024871826, 0.018341064, 0.014801025, -0.030273438, -0.0073280334, 0.034973145, 0.008766174, 0.060668945, -0.035888672, 0.04309082, 0.07757568, -0.026885986, 0.06604004, -0.035491943, -0.021270752, 0.0018138885, -0.035949707, 0.005760193, 0.04345703, -0.011489868, 0.050933838, 0.0051498413, -0.0011959076, 0.000043034554, -0.004207611, -0.0064849854, -0.036376953, -0.015670776, -0.08331299, 0.015586853, 0.0036392212, 0.06756592, 0.024215698, -0.03375244, -0.003364563, -0.014549255, -0.0027809143, -0.0054473877, -0.019760132, 0.0054512024, 0.034606934, -0.0049095154, -0.0036449432, -0.0058631897, -0.0021820068, -0.08148193, -0.027526855, 0.061431885, 0.00019323826, -0.036315918, 0.0009088516, -0.013252258, 0.032196045, 0.026184082, 0.029632568, -0.024215698, 0.020080566, -0.029586792, -0.003063202, -0.02116394, -0.024612427, -0.0435791, -0.017929077, -0.026031494, -0.06390381, 0.008369446, 0.019821167, -0.06329346, -0.01878357, -0.011108398, -0.010871887, -0.037017822, 0.025787354, -0.005645752, -0.046295166, 0.018814087, 0.020446777, 0.03717041, -0.01979065, -0.047210693, 0.021011353, 0.011268616, -0.015220642, 0.02305603, 0.018173218, -0.012748718, -0.021255493, -0.0034980774, 0.0005173683, 0.013137817, 0.0024547577, -0.0020103455, -0.021850586, -0.0025348663, 0.037384033, 0.035064697, 0.019882202, 0.016952515, -0.001326561, -0.024505615, -0.009307861, -0.012878418, 0.006061554, 0.057281494, 0.011070251, -0.039611816, -0.06488037, 0.026275635, 0.010292053, 0.0118255615, -0.009315491, -0.010131836, 0.05340576, -0.02178955, -0.030319214, 0.04284668, 0.0004632473, 0.00605011, 0.00011253357, 0.008628845, 0.026016235, -0.020721436, 0.0134887695, -0.030166626, 0.058441162, -0.023666382, -0.0748291, -0.059143066, -0.046203613, -0.055511475, 0.018814087, -0.05557251, 0.0068244934, 0.010894775, 0.04550171, -0.0051460266, -0.031280518, -0.018035889, -0.020980835, -0.0131073, 0.018325806, -0.030914307, 0.0065689087, 0.059783936, 0.046447754, 0.007381439, 0.018707275, -0.014518738, -0.007587433, 0.026168823, 0.018707275, 0.022949219, 0.012641907, -0.021865845, 0.0635376, 0.0019798279, -0.017333984, -0.0087509155, -0.007522583, 0.02267456, 0.050048828, 0.006904602, -0.017303467, -0.028076172, -0.038024902, -0.044830322, -0.046142578, 0.038757324, -0.02583313, 0.03137207, -0.02281189, 0.03189087, 0.032104492, -0.021240234, -0.01108551, -0.035339355, -0.084106445, -0.029449463, -0.024353027, 0.026062012, -0.004497528, -0.00045228004, 0.028793335, 0.011810303, -0.048065186, 0.027664185, -0.024520874, 0.006099701, -0.027938843, -0.029159546, -0.009391785, -0.04977417, -0.005458832, 0.02355957, -0.024108887, 0.039398193, 0.015617371, -0.039276123, 0.017562866, -0.02267456, 0.05529785, -0.025939941, 0.07147217, -0.0011634827, -0.005004883, 0.0146865845, -0.010360718, 0.014663696, 0.029876709, -0.016448975, 0.02116394, 0.012245178, 0.015563965, 0.01902771, -0.044189453, -0.014228821, 0.05355835, 0.03643799, 0.022720337, -0.02178955, 0.022445679, 0.05053711, -0.025878906, -0.021072388, 0.016067505, -0.026168823, -0.019454956, 0.04147339, -0.014472961, -0.04434204, -0.013839722, 0.0068969727, 0.01977539, -0.032836914, -0.019348145, -0.0036144257, -0.04788208, 0.005432129, 0.010848999, 0.013549805, 0.015182495, -0.029037476, 0.0068855286, -0.024291992, -0.007835388, -0.017669678, 0.015197754, -0.01687622, -0.037261963, 0.028396606, 0.022354126, -0.032714844, 0.010620117, 0.0009098053, -0.01222229, -0.0054397583, 0.019210815, 0.011398315, 0.019363403, 0.04244995, -0.017120361, 0.0090789795, 0.01486969, 0.044311523, 0.005844116, 0.013626099, -0.006565094, 0.0054893494, 0.025421143, 0.04083252, -0.015274048, -0.009109497, -0.028320312, 0.02357483, -0.013000488, 0.0018978119, 0.0037612915, 0.02142334, 0.014953613, 0.009391785, 0.011230469, -0.01675415, -0.0118637085, 0.026748657, 0.02368164, 0.055755615, -0.02571106, -0.034118652, 0.0041503906, 0.037261963, -0.022445679, -0.039093018, 0.1538086, -0.021743774, 0.02935791, 0.0011529922, -0.02670288, -0.090148926, 0.059814453, -0.025741577, 0.010894775, -0.030654907, -0.060516357, -0.04937744, -0.06085205, 0.035217285, 0.0042800903, 0.011444092, 0.0056610107, -0.0074157715, 0.009742737, 0.0074691772, 0.03717041, 0.0075531006, 0.005142212, 0.0073051453, -0.024337769, -0.06341553, 0.026031494, -0.016723633, -0.044555664, -0.0090408325, 0.053253174, -0.01802063, 0.0032634735, 0.017730713, 0.0067863464, -0.012519836, 0.006454468, -0.0011749268, -0.006412506, -0.035125732, 0.0126571655, 0.052246094, 0.041503906, -0.03778076, -0.07659912, -0.031066895, -0.030792236, 0.052764893, -0.0031166077, 0.027709961, -0.0039520264, 0.027893066, -0.070007324, -0.021438599, -0.039001465, 0.022720337, 0.05532837, -0.036102295, 0.059417725, 0.050445557, -0.003742218, 0.030410767, -0.045684814, 0.0043296814, 0.029510498, 0.0112838745, -0.013420105, 0.0019159317, 0.034851074, 0.014457703, 0.029022217, -0.0032310486, -0.047332764, -0.020446777, 0.028869629, 0.028442383, 0.0032024384, 0.0060310364, -0.028289795, -0.049804688, 0.034332275, -0.0002644062, 0.00065279007, -0.0025959015, -0.0077781677, 0.0069618225, 0.03643799, -0.011650085, 0.013793945, 0.0073242188, 0.036254883, -0.049072266, 0.040527344, -0.039215088, 0.0072517395, -0.043304443, -0.037597656, 0.0055236816, 0.008918762, -0.014923096, -0.015701294, 0.0047798157, -0.0035972595, 0.022262573, 0.03652954, 0.025436401, -0.003921509, -0.019348145, 0.010864258, 0.037719727, 0.012031555, -0.0010690689, -0.000259161, 0.0063171387, -0.050933838, 0.017730713, -0.004005432, -0.05328369, 0.043426514, -0.07019043, -0.018707275, -0.028015137, -0.090026855, 0.013084412, -0.046173096, -0.01663208, -0.037078857, -0.0736084, 0.021530151, 0.022216797, 0.019805908, -0.029953003, 0.0519104, 0.021011353, -0.029006958, 0.08380127, -0.00983429, 0.024856567, 0.07702637, -0.033325195, -0.00969696, -0.018066406, -0.007080078, 0.0178833, -0.0066566467, 0.022842407, -0.019577026, 0.021713257, -0.025787354, 0.0013866425, 0.03665161, -0.012329102, 0.000647068, -0.010055542, -0.0362854, -0.017532349, 0.06591797, -0.004047394, 0.039154053, -0.04562378, -0.025054932, 0.039764404, -0.03591919, -0.08972168, -0.05496216, 0.016174316, -0.11456299, -0.10479736, 0.011787415, 0.021728516, -0.04208374, -0.008514404, 0.024017334, -0.0025577545, -0.0061454773, 0.035461426, -0.012672424, 0.060546875, -0.0069274902, -0.035583496, -0.028427124, -0.018630981, -0.012435913, 0.004447937, -0.014251709, 0.01878357, 0.06378174, 0.03012085, 0.018539429, -0.01586914, 0.05154419, -0.011299133, -0.020401001, -0.0038890839, -0.015701294, -0.006450653, -0.007007599, -0.023773193, -0.020645142, 0.0050964355, -0.00484848, 0.036834717, 0.015419006, 0.023117065, -0.0059890747, -0.017684937, 0.015899658, 0.015304565, -0.005996704, -0.011444092, -0.0068893433, 0.026428223, -0.017959595, 0.012741089, 0.022003174, -0.008354187, -0.036956787, -0.01411438, 0.05407715, 0.043548584, -0.024414062, -0.028457642, 0.0009498596, 0.06762695, -0.020004272, 0.009292603, -0.003047943, 0.030639648, -0.025756836, -0.017349243, 0.021453857, 0.034942627, -0.03564453, -0.034820557, -0.00566864, -0.021759033, -0.008705139, -0.0014505386, -0.011917114, 0.020431519, 0.005897522, 0.029815674, -0.03994751, -0.0025615692, -0.035095215, 0.02229309, -0.029159546, -0.043762207, -0.048034668, -0.015106201, -0.017822266, -0.0023326874, -0.037384033, -0.06719971, -0.019165039, -0.0079574585, -0.018630981, -0.001909256, -0.00409317, 0.028793335, 0.0368042, 0.018707275, -0.039886475, -0.030838013, 0.007118225, -0.02960205, -0.020492554, -0.028015137, -0.0061073303, 0.0016708374, 0.036590576, -0.04498291, -0.019241333, -0.030807495, 0.030014038, 0.0046844482, 0.026916504, -0.002878189, 0.009407043, 0.015060425, 0.0035991669, 0.033935547, 0.034423828, 0.008888245, -0.07897949, 0.032562256, -0.07458496, 0.08850098, -0.018600464, 0.02947998, -0.006401062, -0.026733398, 0.034576416, -0.010116577, 0.020599365, 0.04876709, 0.001036644, 0.005027771, -0.017120361, -0.040802002, -0.015144348, -0.01626587, -0.0059509277, -0.029083252, -0.002090454, 0.023117065, 0.013977051, 0.07006836, -0.0021152496, -0.026504517, 0.02772522, -0.031585693, -0.01689148, -0.03326416, -0.0050849915, 0.012008667, -0.00447464, -0.010253906, -0.054229736, -0.059143066, 0.03237915, -0.008148193, 0.0036087036, 0.006336212, -0.021072388, 0.0055389404, 0.01927185, -0.011978149, -0.02281189, -0.0592041, -0.060546875, -0.024932861, -0.027023315, -0.004676819, 0.04385376, -0.0491333, 0.018310547, 0.026397705, -0.024032593, -0.03250122, -0.018707275, -0.010871887, -0.03933716, -0.024597168, 0.032592773, 0.02281189, -0.03729248, 0.017654419, -0.015403748, 0.01966858, -0.013771057, -0.02444458, 0.009765625, -0.017608643, -0.01222229, 0.024230957, 0.018630981, 0.015548706, 0.010116577, -0.013557434, -0.005241394, -0.013534546, -0.019042969, 0.0004119873, -0.0058937073, 0.036468506, -0.007282257, -0.023849487, -0.0126953125, -0.030456543, -0.055419922, -0.019119263, -0.027496338, -0.03466797, 0.010658264, -0.05105591, -0.07244873, -0.011024475, 0.053741455, 0.021499634, -0.039093018, -0.006389618, 0.023330688, -0.021865845, -0.0037193298, 0.027526855, 0.004764557, -0.010101318, 0.030059814, 0.033050537, -0.00025129318, -0.018554688, -0.10839844, -0.015136719, -0.043426514, -0.036254883, -0.07702637, -0.012321472, 0.024154663, 0.0546875, 0.0039863586, 0.0011167526, 0.027633667, 0.0043296814, 0.026000977, -0.003786087, -0.026779175, 0.024398804, -0.036499023, -0.04458618, 0.0057678223, -0.0029258728, -0.039611816, 0.010795593, 0.014297485, 0.014030457, 0.079589844, -0.029388428, 0.07348633, -0.05645752, -0.025650024, 0.016189575, 0.041900635, 0.02418518, 0.012565613, 0.011619568, 0.011627197, 0.031707764, -0.009216309, 0.003326416, 0.031082153, -0.012367249, -0.023910522, 0.007633209, 0.022781372, -0.011131287, -0.018005371, 0.005973816, -0.016845703, 0.0023040771, -0.051757812, 0.0103302, 0.044891357, 0.0231781, 0.009246826, 0.019561768, -0.024627686, 0.05783081, 0.011222839, -0.021377563, -0.025344849, 0.04864502, -0.016906738, -0.016952515, -0.007091522, -0.040374756, -0.023590088, 0.024002075, 0.015205383, 0.013961792, -0.022338867, 0.04046631, -0.0034294128, 0.0020561218, -0.019485474, -0.026260376, 0.02848816, 0.036254883, 0.01260376, 0.0625, 0.0074272156, 0.022064209, 0.053710938, -0.00617218, 0.020614624, -0.008285522, -0.001531601, 0.015792847, -0.00995636, -0.020217896, -0.0073394775, -0.013725281, -0.045898438, -0.04248047, -0.030380249, 0.0063171387, 0.023803711, -0.028900146, -0.044281006, 0.024765015, -0.019989014, -0.020050049, 0.039001465, -0.043060303, 0.07104492, -0.038848877, -0.053344727, 0.009727478, -0.064086914, -0.020568848, 0.023376465, 0.041778564, 0.014137268, 0.009353638, 0.012763977, 0.02015686, 0.017486572, -0.014785767, -0.0395813, -0.084472656, 0.042144775, -0.043945312, 0.0020275116, 0.012245178, 0.023666382, 0.009681702, -0.015068054, 0.030181885, -0.0009803772, -0.013290405, 0.0071487427, 0.010559082, -0.014007568, -0.031433105, 0.03375244, -0.01574707, 0.013343811, -0.010406494, -0.045898438, 0.02381897, 0.031921387, -0.043792725, 0.02444458, 0.02935791, 0.003293991, -0.035125732, -0.0028514862, -0.037200928, -0.024627686, 0.009864807, 0.014419556, -0.008148193, -0.013061523, -0.014976501, 0.012756348, 0.02709961, -0.017837524, 0.015716553, -0.01335144, 0.024795532, 0.036254883, 0.02142334, 0.04144287, 0.0040016174, -0.023147583, 0.031585693, 0.03213501, -0.052581787, 0.03363037, -0.015426636, 0.086242676, 0.04852295, 0.055023193, -0.025161743, 0.0074310303, 0.053741455, -0.018875122, 0.016281128, -0.048736572, -0.005455017, -0.058929443, -0.025436401, 0.02330017, -0.031463623, -0.010231018, 0.018173218, -0.015914917, 0.028213501, -0.036254883, 0.016540527, -0.010398865, -0.07336426, -0.017410278, -0.020462036, 0.0087890625, -0.0013198853, 0.042144775, -0.05606079, -0.0033226013, -0.048675537, -0.013961792, -0.041900635, 0.009796143, 0.040283203, -0.034362793, 0.0020065308, 0.012611389, 0.0524292, 0.06695557, -0.0057411194, -0.04107666, 0.030899048, -0.017211914, 0.012962341, -0.039764404, -0.038360596, -0.020645142, 0.040527344, -0.006843567, -0.02243042, -0.0059509277, -0.0231781, -0.09442139, 0.020751953, 0.00016009808, -0.03741455, 0.08544922, 0.043426514, -0.020492554, -0.01713562, 0.024673462, -0.010047913, 0.030761719, -0.060394287, -0.01335907, 0.023529053, 0.0038223267, -0.009559631, -0.056640625, -0.010002136, -0.014701843, -0.0048103333, -0.032562256, 0.0056266785, -0.023239136, -0.0066871643, -0.03567505, -0.038208008, -0.0027618408, 0.050598145, 0.0018396378, -0.022003174, 0.015701294, -0.0061302185, 0.004234314, -0.009819031, -0.0033245087, -0.024215698, 0.033233643, -0.0030155182, 0.017868042, 0.028167725, -0.015220642, 0.0014572144, 0.015327454, 0.0054130554, -0.019699097, 0.027511597, -0.031143188, -0.04626465, 0.013954163, -0.018432617, -0.011054993, -0.0473938, -0.041656494, -0.009887695, 0.012565613, 0.0056610107, 0.0009613037, 0.029434204, -0.024429321, 0.04244995, 0.009788513, 0.052947998, -0.027389526, -0.007080078, 0.022659302, -0.01259613, -0.0023670197, 0.017440796, 0.022537231, -0.02558899, -0.012863159, -0.020690918, 0.033355713, -0.029510498, -0.035339355, -0.03274536, 0.0045051575, -0.07989502, -0.022033691, 0.031341553, -0.008934021, -0.011131287, 0.01651001, -0.023986816, 0.03579712, 0.021972656, 0.06677246, 0.017562866, 0.01524353, 0.007648468, 0.014907837, 0.012428284 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07102v1
Fovea Transformer: Efficient Long-Context Modeling with Structured Fine-to-Coarse Attention
Ziwei He, Jian Yuan, Le Zhou, Jingwen Leng, Bo Jiang
cs.CL
The quadratic complexity of self-attention in Transformers has hindered the processing of long text. To alleviate this problem, previous works have proposed to sparsify the attention matrix, taking advantage of the observation that crucial information about a token can be derived from its neighbors. These methods typically combine one or another form of local attention and global attention. Such combinations introduce abrupt changes in contextual granularity when going from local to global, which may be undesirable. We believe that a smoother transition could potentially enhance model's ability to capture long-context dependencies. In this study, we introduce Fovea Transformer, a long-context focused transformer that addresses the challenges of capturing global dependencies while maintaining computational efficiency. To achieve this, we construct a multi-scale tree from the input sequence, and use representations of context tokens with a progressively coarser granularity in the tree, as their distance to the query token increases. We evaluate our model on three long-context summarization tasks\footnote{Our code is publicly available at: \textit{https://github.com/ZiweiHe/Fovea-Transformer}}. It achieves state-of-the-art performance on two of them, and competitive results on the third with mixed improvement and setback of the evaluation metrics.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07102v1
2023-11-13T06:24:27
2023-11-13T06:24:27
{ "title": [ 0.009544373, 0.01448822, -0.042236328, -0.076660156, 0.026992798, -0.007572174, -0.02722168, -0.009086609, 0.018814087, 0.031188965, -0.028198242, -0.008224487, 0.015167236, -0.016174316, -0.034851074, 0.0010070801, 0.0005326271, 0.028518677, -0.018188477, -0.030319214, -0.026779175, -0.0423584, 0.057037354, 0.06964111, 0.017944336, -0.05404663, -0.086364746, 0.049957275, -0.050872803, -0.021820068, 0.0046081543, 0.013641357, 0.045318604, 0.043914795, -0.019454956, 0.016571045, -0.047332764, 0.026412964, 0.02319336, -0.011634827, 0.022460938, -0.008049011, -0.04144287, -0.048553467, -0.046936035, 0.03189087, -0.052337646, -0.010719299, -0.008049011, 0.044677734, 0.014526367, 0.001039505, -0.018600464, 0.016586304, 0.019836426, -0.04006958, -0.01399231, -0.028411865, 0.023208618, 0.079711914, 0.04156494, -0.038146973, 0.0047836304, -0.017745972, -0.050476074, -0.010314941, -0.02973938, 0.015716553, 0.07409668, 0.0017528534, -0.031066895, 0.008460999, 0.002161026, -0.020889282, -0.053131104, 0.035217285, 0.054626465, 0.027572632, 0.031707764, -0.04788208, -0.004764557, -0.02532959, -0.020141602, -0.0020198822, 0.009460449, -0.013656616, -0.02029419, -0.022460938, -0.033813477, -0.076171875, -0.02720642, -0.018661499, -0.009292603, -0.022918701, -0.040130615, -0.026672363, -0.019577026, 0.029785156, 0.0042762756, 0.0018377304, -0.014556885, 0.0119018555, -0.0053482056, -0.02557373, 0.013008118, 0.010551453, -0.027908325, -0.04031372, 0.009757996, 0.03378296, -0.019546509, 0.03656006, 0.014007568, 0.017959595, 0.00023543835, 0.00053453445, -0.009971619, 0.01725769, -0.004322052, 0.031951904, -0.010566711, -0.03604126, 0.028884888, 0.023788452, 0.033691406, 0.018493652, -0.050964355, -0.0025672913, -0.014633179, 0.009727478, -0.0069465637, 0.05316162, -0.06842041, -0.070373535, -0.058563232, 0.04147339, 0.024520874, 0.008460999, -0.008140564, -0.009536743, 0.00957489, -0.009399414, -0.02357483, -0.022216797, -0.005756378, 0.023605347, 0.07470703, -0.009422302, -0.06738281, -0.060028076, -0.01424408, 0.01701355, 0.029434204, -0.013916016, -0.039978027, -0.021835327, -0.113586426, -0.029678345, 0.009223938, 0.008674622, 0.021774292, 0.011009216, 0.010749817, 0.013938904, 0.043640137, -0.029754639, -0.03036499, 0.019332886, 0.0065345764, 0.028579712, -0.036895752, 0.007637024, -0.012489319, -0.0029239655, -0.00111866, 0.016311646, 0.024169922, -0.018875122, 0.029907227, -0.017990112, -0.0051002502, -0.019760132, -0.0062561035, 0.048919678, -0.041381836, -0.028915405, -0.02444458, 0.008857727, 0.06451416, 0.018875122, -0.073791504, -0.004928589, -0.04437256, -0.023040771, -0.06842041, -0.0033054352, 0.05319214, 0.05355835, 0.00044679642, -0.0020694733, 0.008377075, -0.00957489, -0.013084412, -0.015930176, -0.01651001, -0.024047852, -0.023513794, 0.026275635, -0.03237915, 0.05307007, 0.05239868, 0.018676758, -0.0284729, -0.006668091, -0.0021629333, -0.044281006, 0.03390503, -0.024856567, 0.0018091202, -0.01789856, 0.0019683838, 0.008987427, 0.010971069, 0.056030273, 0.023010254, -0.0051727295, 0.026809692, -0.016403198, 0.041870117, 0.020095825, 0.05065918, -0.05480957, -0.0004284382, 0.0010242462, -0.012016296, -0.025161743, -0.0020656586, -0.014251709, 0.027496338, 0.012275696, 0.027679443, 0.010955811, 0.00022888184, 0.022491455, 0.08544922, -0.01512146, -0.0065727234, 0.009460449, 0.0158844, 0.028060913, 0.045684814, 0.032165527, 0.04446411, -0.041503906, 0.008422852, 0.062805176, 0.010643005, 0.02947998, -0.02078247, -0.007335663, -0.0029830933, 0.025314331, 0.0013713837, 0.006477356, -0.044067383, -0.007858276, -0.024780273, -0.0042266846, 0.0158844, 0.010681152, 0.034332275, -0.0181427, 0.020843506, -0.040740967, -0.009895325, -0.024871826, -0.0026836395, 0.017745972, 0.02909851, -0.086242676, -0.007671356, -0.0019702911, 0.02178955, -0.00087594986, 0.035186768, -0.006290436, 0.004257202, -0.0231781, -0.007007599, -0.0013141632, 0.034484863, 0.041381836, 0.014724731, 0.0054893494, 0.010322571, -0.0022392273, 0.069885254, 0.041229248, 0.0017032623, 0.020355225, -0.025909424, 0.04623413, -0.009315491, -0.0016384125, 0.00957489, 0.016967773, 0.038208008, 0.019927979, -0.018218994, 0.017089844, -0.05065918, 0.0035171509, 0.00054740906, 0.012191772, -0.073791504, -0.08081055, -0.0017604828, -0.037353516, -0.03540039, -0.025421143, 0.088256836, -0.014770508, -0.03024292, -0.008399963, -0.0129852295, -0.021987915, -0.004890442, -0.0395813, -0.059631348, 0.04046631, 0.04815674, 0.02407837, -0.033172607, -0.008140564, -0.010414124, 0.014022827, -0.011894226, -0.01828003, -0.023040771, 0.016555786, 0.021957397, -0.039489746, 0.024597168, -0.042663574, -0.026611328, -0.037597656, 0.024475098, 0.019180298, -0.059295654, -0.0028076172, 0.03616333, -0.025131226, -0.03488159, 0.016220093, 0.043945312, -0.03390503, -0.009468079, 0.025527954, -0.01828003, -0.03616333, 0.035858154, -0.001288414, 0.006248474, -0.052337646, 0.009529114, -0.047424316, -0.027145386, -0.021224976, 0.0135269165, 0.075927734, -0.04437256, 0.009185791, -0.04156494, -0.016036987, 0.0024223328, 0.01374054, -0.014465332, -0.02809143, -0.028411865, -0.016296387, -0.019836426, 0.024368286, -0.014076233, 0.027114868, 0.07989502, 0.0038108826, 0.007598877, 0.026870728, 0.055603027, -0.014045715, -0.00075006485, -0.013290405, -0.032073975, 0.00687027, 0.01789856, 0.009765625, -0.017303467, -0.019088745, -0.13012695, -0.009483337, 0.029006958, 0.0020503998, -0.017288208, 0.005756378, -0.071777344, 0.03213501, -0.030395508, -0.020874023, 0.02470398, 0.05908203, -0.008201599, -0.0058021545, -0.004535675, -0.052246094, 0.018325806, -0.017501831, -0.0970459, 0.025543213, -0.0057144165, -0.039794922, -0.0127334595, -0.040100098, -0.034729004, -0.0010137558, 0.034179688, 0.05178833, 0.00078868866, -0.006134033, 0.024169922, -0.028274536, -0.0070343018, -0.037231445, -0.028121948, -0.03475952, -0.007659912, 0.008323669, -0.012863159, 0.03967285, -0.0039482117, 0.0002323389, 0.0009899139, -0.010292053, -0.007865906, 0.02104187, -0.0027122498, -0.017944336, 0.008544922, 0.038360596, -0.008964539, -0.004573822, -0.03439331, -0.01675415, -0.043151855, 0.032226562, -0.02407837, 0.07196045, -0.0017223358, 0.03302002, -0.0021076202, -0.032287598, 0.05218506, -0.038970947, -0.036956787, 0.041778564, 0.03665161, 0.012779236, -0.011917114, -0.008865356, -0.036224365, 0.017318726, -0.013069153, -0.010772705, 0.00447464, -0.012451172, 0.0053710938, -0.022109985, -0.011070251, -0.013519287, 0.007736206, 0.015296936, 0.025726318, -0.025360107, 0.0019359589, -0.019622803, 0.023712158, 0.0020427704, -0.07220459, 0.011581421, 0.01159668, -0.046325684, -0.04547119, -0.050323486, 0.019424438, -0.024093628, -0.024124146, 0.012588501, -0.017364502, -0.036193848, -0.0034770966, -0.07531738, -0.013557434, 0.08703613, 0.015365601, 0.017501831, 0.03463745, -0.008033752, -0.024475098, -0.02180481, 0.009773254, -0.014373779, 0.052215576, -0.0090789795, -0.025680542, 0.060699463, -0.05444336, 0.018753052, 0.012397766, -0.008506775, -0.012268066, 0.015457153, -0.007843018, 0.002937317, -0.0014533997, 0.05508423, -0.009719849, 0.0020484924, -0.061523438, 0.014076233, 0.01348114, -0.017486572, 0.004501343, -0.015655518, 0.009162903, 0.04522705, 0.016983032, 0.0625, -0.023971558, 0.0063285828, 0.039611816, -0.009162903, -0.016799927, 0.015823364, 0.02104187, 0.009544373, -0.010978699, 0.045196533, 0.011314392, 0.048553467, -0.018844604, -0.034729004, 0.012107849, 0.024017334, -0.040252686, -0.014389038, -0.04421997, -0.0096588135, -0.01739502, 0.006881714, -0.020095825, 0.02545166, 0.043823242, 0.0062408447, -0.012283325, -0.029968262, 0.01739502, 0.0063438416, -0.037719727, -0.077819824, -0.004425049, -0.023880005, -0.057037354, -0.039611816, -0.034454346, -0.035614014, 0.025054932, 0.010795593, -0.014755249, 0.0209198, 0.005050659, 0.06060791, 0.04751587, -0.0036849976, -0.07745361, 0.03286743, -0.013053894, -0.026657104, 0.021774292, -0.009017944, -0.019500732, -0.04724121, 0.0038433075, -0.0038223267, 0.002588272, -0.023605347, 0.004196167, -0.015571594, 0.025985718, 0.016662598, 0.040985107, 0.018539429, 0.035827637, -0.0149383545, 0.013679504, -0.052764893, -0.019073486, -0.060760498, 0.040130615, 0.008659363, 0.01083374, 0.02760315, 0.021392822, -0.028213501, 0.034851074, 0.022613525, 0.034606934, -0.0038166046, 0.0059051514, 0.018737793, -0.03753662, -0.038238525, -0.0013799667, 0.000078082085, 0.04776001, -0.038208008, 0.068115234, -0.008377075, 0.0073661804, 0.055145264, -0.0051651, 0.0007944107, 0.020874023, 0.013374329, -0.057434082, -0.08929443, -0.015159607, 0.08068848, -0.029724121, 0.0068244934, 0.011360168, 0.018218994, 0.021072388, 0.05834961, 0.028686523, 0.012390137, -0.0039520264, -0.009170532, 0.0032672882, -0.019943237, -0.028823853, 0.024383545, 0.014465332, 0.009529114, -0.06439209, -0.022369385, -0.04019165, -0.017166138, -0.00737381, 0.0017461777, -0.0068130493, -0.058410645, 0.014305115, 0.057678223, 0.019332886, 0.027191162, 0.040893555, 0.027328491, 0.010345459, 0.051849365, 0.010215759, 0.057159424, 0.026748657, -0.026184082, 0.030227661, 0.0028057098, -0.00756073, 0.009376526, 0.017364502, 0.0004813671, 0.013671875, -0.041900635, 0.018936157, -0.010513306, -0.010604858, 0.034729004, -0.04647827, 0.014778137, 0.031219482, -0.021255493, 0.026290894, -0.017684937, -0.020492554, -0.03050232, -0.0071487427, -0.07159424, 0.02960205, 0.009429932, -0.04550171, -0.049224854, 0.051605225, -0.00491333, -0.010139465, -0.0023765564, -0.004234314, -0.0423584, 0.018035889, 0.01977539, -0.040252686, 0.00096035004, 0.020599365, 0.015838623, 0.027633667, 0.0067634583, -0.021621704, -0.00040578842, -0.026382446, -0.04852295, -0.024017334, 0.014297485, 0.024169922, 0.009994507, -0.0035820007, -0.033416748, 0.023925781, 0.038604736, 0.028274536, 0.017181396, -0.018066406, 0.030670166, 0.014312744, 0.017852783, 0.03427124, 0.0135269165, 0.0014467239, 0.011703491, 0.012687683, -0.053009033, 0.011436462, 0.0115356445, 0.02734375, -0.0073051453, -0.072021484, 0.0013170242, 0.02053833, -0.0055770874, -0.009002686, 0.0027828217, 0.026016235, -0.018417358, -0.0059051514, 0.007709503, 0.063964844, -0.04714966, -0.008216858, -0.019821167, 0.0012245178, -0.047943115, 0.021530151, -0.013206482, -0.019851685, -0.022247314, -0.05731201, -0.024002075, 0.010749817, 0.026000977, 0.014190674, 0.02458191, -0.074279785, -0.019195557, -0.02734375, -0.007926941, -0.016342163, 0.005088806, -0.0047073364, -0.010299683, -0.0075950623, -0.0059127808, -0.014968872, -0.014762878, 0.025314331, 0.008972168, -0.009315491, 0.0075683594, -0.0019102097, 0.011642456, -0.019973755, -0.017669678, 0.0713501, -0.02331543, -0.0033798218, 0.021759033, -0.0096206665, 0.07501221, 0.011749268, 0.053863525, 0.056915283, 0.0033092499, -0.007007599, 0.002204895, -0.0039596558, -0.057434082, 0.024795532, -0.027175903, -0.00030207634, -0.027450562, -0.030532837, -0.06585693, -0.015609741, 0.02658081, 0.045562744, 0.0023326874, 0.019119263, 0.0059280396, 0.007358551, 0.026855469, -0.000040769577, 0.053497314, 0.022705078, 0.021530151, 0.010353088, -0.04031372, 0.008483887, 0.04147339, 0.00027608871, -0.00856781, -0.026992798, -0.010437012, -0.020385742, 0.04083252, 0.023239136, -0.038391113, -0.029510498, -0.03729248, 0.056243896, 0.003862381, 0.043304443, 0.06781006, 0.03955078, -0.033477783, -0.020828247, -0.0009446144, 0.0007638931, -0.046875, 0.021347046, 0.05215454, -0.06866455, 0.020004272, -0.009422302, -0.030532837, -0.015945435, 0.037322998, 0.028564453, -0.057403564, -0.047912598, 0.016906738, 0.049102783, 0.00806427, -0.018829346, -0.04776001, 0.0034046173, 0.013389587, 0.033325195, 0.00642395, -0.0015907288, -0.0073280334, 0.0060920715, -0.009788513, -0.02760315, 0.0181427, 0.026000977, 0.012954712, 0.03479004, -0.017333984, 0.041259766, 0.0061035156, -0.028747559, 0.029449463, 0.018005371, -0.062164307, 0.015914917, 0.049560547, 0.060577393, 0.04107666, 0.078430176, -0.004322052, 0.005126953, -0.0024909973, -0.044921875, 0.03112793, 0.03060913, -0.04159546, 0.03164673, -0.039123535, -0.031463623, 0.024108887, -0.053497314, 0.037506104, -0.044281006, 0.009757996, -0.017913818, 0.0064086914, 0.00944519, -0.033294678, 0.015022278, -0.022720337, -0.042816162, -0.0003130436, 0.027877808, -0.002254486, -0.023849487, -0.010353088, 0.019943237, 0.018615723, 0.009933472, 0.0018692017, -0.02017212, -0.074523926, 0.01727295, -0.040527344, 0.050933838, -0.0184021, -0.02331543, -0.036132812, 0.0032539368, 0.024887085, -0.0018310547, -0.03100586, 0.041900635, -0.05178833, -0.0138168335, 0.017410278, 0.008979797, -0.006290436, 0.0051498413, -0.04788208, 0.027114868, -0.016159058, -0.005584717, 0.038085938, -0.055023193, -0.0073661804, -0.0026416779, -0.019699097, 0.062561035, 0.033599854, -0.0129470825, 0.009117126, 0.02545166, -0.042663574, -0.0038871765, 0.012527466, 0.046447754, 0.00066185, -0.05392456, 0.017074585, 0.017303467, 0.03515625, -0.051513672, -0.03237915, 0.0047416687, 0.009902954, -0.003396988, 0.03781128, 0.031799316, 0.0048332214, 0.03744507, 0.0011291504, 0.0035972595, -0.029022217, -0.017929077, -0.017944336, 0.029144287, 0.05218506, -0.010238647, 0.02053833, 0.04748535, -0.047821045, 0.0030136108, 0.004798889, 0.032714844, 0.027557373, -0.0034370422, 0.06573486, -0.034423828, -0.013671875, -0.025115967, 0.0158844, -0.0035381317, 0.017669678, -0.028884888, 0.014297485, -0.023925781, 0.055664062, -0.02720642, -0.051330566, 0.06085205, 0.027740479, 0.017944336, 0.0018501282, -0.0020103455, -0.022018433, -0.0043640137, 0.0036792755, -0.00592041, 0.018112183, 0.021469116, -0.055603027, 0.010147095, -0.03842163, -0.018508911, -0.006893158, -0.014701843, 0.010696411, -0.027740479, 0.015113831, -0.032562256, -0.007209778, -0.024673462, 0.026046753, -0.018310547, -0.021209717, -0.04864502, -0.052215576, 0.04421997, -0.0071640015 ], "summary": [ 0.039276123, 0.008598328, -0.013580322, -0.06903076, -0.01411438, 0.0031661987, -0.058929443, 0.0018882751, 0.0051231384, 0.06677246, -0.038208008, -0.0077819824, 0.055023193, -0.005355835, -0.02243042, -0.037506104, 0.010543823, 0.01651001, -0.00091171265, -0.01576233, -0.016159058, -0.019989014, 0.011833191, 0.051971436, 0.012084961, -0.046905518, 0.02659607, 0.016723633, 0.024887085, 0.010108948, 0.034820557, -0.020507812, 0.023590088, 0.009490967, -0.010124207, 0.013710022, -0.017196655, 0.020370483, 0.022018433, -0.021728516, 0.020492554, -0.006866455, 0.037078857, -0.016815186, -0.0104904175, 0.041381836, -0.01058197, -0.035064697, 0.051452637, 0.0031414032, -0.012611389, -0.012062073, -0.017349243, -0.04748535, -0.01902771, -0.017868042, -0.042877197, 0.015716553, -0.003080368, 0.06866455, 0.047424316, 0.026275635, -0.020996094, -0.019729614, 0.012199402, 0.020568848, 0.02973938, 0.00016796589, 0.04824829, 0.01210022, -0.016311646, 0.002418518, 0.0063819885, -0.022232056, -0.049804688, 0.041168213, 0.03414917, 0.0073051453, 0.017562866, -0.04159546, -0.032043457, 0.005504608, -0.012031555, -0.04336548, 0.0141067505, -0.020584106, -0.024154663, -0.005252838, -0.01474762, -0.056274414, -0.024780273, -0.0042037964, -0.035461426, -0.0037269592, -0.014831543, -0.029342651, 0.032165527, 0.035064697, -0.005622864, 0.0019350052, 0.022644043, -0.039611816, 0.057647705, -0.03967285, 0.018234253, 0.025024414, -0.010719299, -0.036193848, 0.027145386, 0.004016876, -0.0059776306, 0.005218506, 0.027694702, -0.0041923523, -0.024917603, -0.032684326, -0.0124435425, 0.02571106, 0.012779236, -0.010673523, -0.009483337, -0.007621765, 0.011138916, 0.0552063, 0.00060510635, 0.017028809, -0.006095886, 0.012321472, 0.05078125, -0.015342712, -0.013092041, 0.03338623, -0.03277588, -0.025787354, -0.04272461, 0.0146102905, 0.012359619, -0.009208679, -0.02418518, 0.006664276, 0.03869629, -0.03186035, -0.03857422, 0.032928467, 0.015419006, 0.045837402, 0.05722046, -0.020324707, -0.0574646, -0.06994629, 0.028808594, 0.0033607483, 0.08093262, -0.07836914, -0.06100464, -0.13000488, -0.0423584, -0.0793457, 0.03100586, -0.07940674, -0.008674622, -0.009559631, 0.0022945404, 0.04107666, 0.016235352, -0.004634857, 0.031021118, 0.012367249, 0.018829346, -0.012741089, -0.023849487, 0.004611969, 0.022949219, -0.0132369995, -0.0005941391, 0.029418945, -0.027008057, -0.005458832, 0.010787964, -0.042663574, -0.015487671, -0.03829956, -0.03793335, 0.040496826, -0.017181396, -0.00017142296, -0.026168823, 0.06781006, 0.047027588, 0.038391113, -0.06713867, -0.039215088, -0.013687134, 0.03918457, -0.02796936, 0.00730896, 0.0016098022, 0.057678223, -0.015419006, -0.06585693, 0.075805664, -0.00063848495, -0.0052261353, -0.0647583, -0.09869385, -0.0068206787, -0.0368042, 0.03540039, -0.011650085, 0.020507812, 0.015991211, -0.0044937134, -0.012313843, -0.013946533, 0.0049819946, 0.005054474, 0.013511658, -0.023422241, 0.009712219, -0.042266846, 0.016708374, 0.02029419, -0.0025615692, 0.05203247, -0.011482239, -0.000541687, -0.008880615, 0.028457642, 0.011329651, 0.019683838, 0.030395508, -0.031097412, 0.009918213, 0.008415222, -0.024093628, -0.01184082, 0.004753113, -0.05001831, 0.023666382, 0.03414917, 0.05432129, 0.076660156, -0.01651001, -0.035461426, 0.060302734, -0.07342529, -0.0062446594, -0.020385742, -0.03842163, -0.020263672, 0.043762207, -0.014099121, 0.010810852, -0.062286377, -0.0050201416, 0.022750854, -0.020736694, 0.03765869, -0.017654419, -0.03488159, 0.004802704, 0.0107040405, 0.030014038, -0.015670776, 0.006160736, -0.027267456, 0.01158905, 0.0016508102, 0.023117065, -0.028045654, 0.007091522, -0.02168274, 0.0052833557, -0.054229736, -0.042297363, -0.02897644, -0.0140686035, 0.039245605, 0.0030765533, -0.048950195, 0.0104599, 0.008964539, -0.029373169, -0.008712769, 0.032348633, 0.013847351, -0.0036315918, 0.020843506, -0.015388489, 0.046142578, 0.016052246, 0.07171631, 0.017623901, 0.013877869, -0.008285522, 0.030944824, 0.0635376, -0.041290283, 0.029327393, -0.022277832, 0.07550049, 0.077819824, -0.026138306, 0.051483154, 0.01751709, 0.028152466, 0.036621094, 0.00042915344, 0.015068054, 0.023986816, -0.054260254, -0.0051994324, 0.018188477, 0.11871338, -0.064086914, -0.07672119, 0.015823364, 0.034240723, -0.025970459, -0.013656616, 0.13244629, -0.014198303, 0.010360718, 0.006713867, -0.031188965, -0.046081543, 0.03994751, -0.037872314, -0.04434204, 0.002313614, -0.026473999, -0.030685425, -0.011779785, 0.060760498, -0.005428314, -0.0058288574, 0.0051498413, -0.004058838, 0.0066719055, 0.02746582, 0.021713257, -0.032043457, -0.024978638, -0.047302246, -0.023849487, 0.010444641, 0.005973816, 0.012962341, -0.04660034, -0.0024280548, 0.0018596649, -0.03314209, -0.018844604, 0.0029640198, 0.027557373, -0.051086426, -0.00983429, 0.0181427, -0.023345947, -0.039245605, 0.03982544, 0.014228821, 0.012359619, -0.10192871, -0.01763916, -0.017166138, -0.038879395, -0.01763916, 0.04272461, 0.03125, 0.06903076, 0.049713135, -0.07305908, -0.029373169, -0.02507019, -0.05078125, 0.05529785, -0.028656006, -0.03543091, 0.026672363, -0.019180298, 0.035736084, -0.026626587, 0.061645508, 0.039367676, 0.017471313, 0.021850586, -0.010482788, 0.04284668, 0.003271103, 0.0017938614, -0.033935547, -0.017852783, -0.016662598, 0.012130737, 0.008880615, -0.04397583, -0.029708862, -0.05419922, -0.024215698, 0.022415161, 0.008331299, 0.006160736, 0.008964539, -0.016204834, 0.04925537, 0.021835327, -0.013458252, 0.037261963, -0.05441284, 0.010101318, -0.030395508, -0.006023407, -0.054260254, -0.013511658, -0.03414917, -0.045135498, -0.0049095154, 0.015640259, 0.0138549805, -0.000770092, 0.0013093948, 0.0019254684, 0.019744873, 0.035583496, 0.051239014, -0.03378296, -0.019332886, -0.012031555, 0.018356323, 0.0008611679, -0.023986816, -0.012046814, 0.0018901825, 0.0061187744, 0.031585693, 0.0003681183, -0.013717651, 0.01084137, -0.048736572, -0.019760132, -0.00017416477, 0.00018656254, 0.01889038, -0.031402588, 0.00818634, 0.027542114, -0.00831604, 0.009117126, 0.06536865, -0.020828247, -0.017730713, -0.013801575, 0.019882202, -0.058898926, 0.04559326, -0.02609253, 0.043426514, 0.014816284, -0.041381836, 0.017608643, -0.039489746, 0.012420654, 0.014251709, 0.05609131, 0.040100098, -0.01285553, 0.0066566467, -0.06732178, 0.047424316, 0.056640625, -0.097961426, 0.000767231, -0.03189087, 0.0057640076, -0.042938232, 0.03050232, -0.028564453, 0.06201172, -0.040618896, -0.030883789, 0.00093889236, -0.0020179749, -0.03237915, -0.012023926, 0.006664276, -0.020477295, 0.0014181137, -0.0027198792, -0.02571106, -0.015853882, -0.045074463, 0.026031494, -0.01763916, -0.019348145, 0.010604858, -0.008125305, 0.047912598, -0.0018663406, -0.055633545, 0.027542114, -0.006175995, 0.00856781, 0.029678345, 0.0030136108, 0.016937256, 0.020446777, 0.019500732, 0.021011353, -0.019699097, 0.033050537, -0.024291992, -0.06335449, 0.018188477, -0.024154663, -0.006664276, 0.016098022, -0.037384033, 0.008087158, 0.010887146, -0.03463745, 0.0070877075, -0.015022278, 0.032806396, 0.005077362, 0.0016260147, -0.039031982, 0.055419922, 0.019577026, -0.0054473877, 0.011520386, -0.002368927, -0.0037345886, 0.03729248, 0.0053367615, -0.006046295, -0.0023059845, 0.0024051666, 0.05014038, 0.029006958, -0.01083374, -0.014045715, 0.0003950596, 0.017807007, -0.0132369995, 0.012420654, -0.027404785, 0.006965637, -0.018707275, 0.00040555, 0.0056533813, -0.0017328262, -0.029647827, -0.020904541, 0.028167725, -0.004524231, -0.02861023, 0.0047836304, -0.011734009, 0.021606445, 0.01524353, 0.040740967, -0.0021877289, -0.036956787, -0.005794525, 0.029647827, -0.037261963, -0.070495605, -0.026794434, -0.0065689087, -0.049926758, -0.025802612, -0.096069336, -0.060058594, -0.013038635, 0.01007843, -0.02192688, 0.042175293, -0.0013151169, 0.038024902, 0.023132324, 0.011856079, -0.05859375, 0.04724121, -0.04751587, -0.0048675537, 0.039123535, 0.026626587, -0.025283813, -0.016220093, 0.013954163, -0.0029125214, 0.019592285, -0.057617188, -0.038879395, -0.031707764, -0.00035476685, 0.041137695, 0.016311646, 0.008415222, 0.020355225, -0.0055007935, 0.0027446747, -0.0124053955, 0.0069847107, -0.03491211, -0.028289795, 0.047210693, -0.012001038, 0.005077362, -0.0022888184, -0.020858765, 0.02468872, 0.0072784424, 0.017456055, 0.018875122, 0.03845215, -0.0025291443, -0.0052337646, -0.022735596, 0.0045394897, -0.0053863525, 0.0004632473, -0.005279541, 0.029296875, 0.0039520264, 0.014419556, 0.048034668, -0.0066070557, -0.015060425, 0.009727478, -0.018218994, -0.046020508, -0.09082031, -0.025985718, 0.07727051, -0.010643005, -0.025299072, -0.0018587112, 0.004058838, -0.00087833405, 0.033233643, 0.0070152283, 0.0040245056, 0.016998291, 0.005870819, 0.019744873, -0.02017212, 0.011024475, -0.019470215, -0.0068855286, -0.0013980865, -0.033813477, -0.031555176, 0.041046143, -0.013298035, -0.036376953, 0.01158905, -0.011077881, -0.016937256, -0.049804688, -0.0035800934, 0.00843811, -0.008735657, 0.055755615, 0.014167786, -0.0051651, 0.03955078, -0.010871887, 0.026687622, 0.00012993813, -0.032104492, 0.044433594, -0.0181427, -0.0335083, 0.01133728, 0.009422302, -0.01651001, 0.017547607, -0.014381409, -0.019378662, -0.021316528, 0.017166138, 0.007621765, -0.018203735, 0.025436401, 0.012466431, -0.022842407, 0.018203735, -0.0211792, -0.04586792, -0.053649902, 0.001414299, -0.068359375, -0.0058250427, 0.0026550293, -0.072631836, 0.022277832, 0.057617188, 0.02229309, -0.027008057, 0.015434265, -0.008583069, -0.007282257, -0.029251099, 0.03274536, -0.0129776, 0.024642944, 0.013458252, 0.023849487, 0.009796143, -0.0073776245, -0.014595032, -0.009605408, -0.0435791, -0.014205933, -0.034118652, -0.017623901, -0.010070801, 0.05999756, 0.0035591125, 0.023361206, 0.030685425, 0.0003323555, 0.029556274, -0.016601562, -0.021270752, 0.0042800903, 0.009063721, 0.0317688, 0.050109863, 0.021484375, 0.012771606, 0.010986328, 0.01260376, -0.04626465, 0.0075187683, 0.047210693, 0.046142578, -0.051116943, -0.044799805, -0.01537323, 0.04095459, 0.014167786, 0.037384033, -0.00056505203, 0.010139465, 0.03805542, 0.0041656494, 0.018112183, 0.0473938, -0.03314209, 0.00023460388, -0.016525269, 0.019226074, -0.026504517, -0.013671875, -0.01676941, 0.011177063, 0.006793976, -0.026672363, 0.004711151, -0.016723633, 0.014465332, -0.021453857, -0.003929138, -0.0048713684, 0.0034809113, -0.015777588, -0.02166748, -0.013710022, 0.029724121, -0.0009613037, -0.0052223206, 0.020309448, -0.026382446, -0.031188965, 0.037261963, 0.0088272095, -0.024856567, -0.027359009, 0.019378662, 0.050842285, 0.024902344, 0.021148682, 0.0029296875, 0.046081543, -0.039733887, 0.017150879, -0.021453857, 0.05429077, 0.037200928, 0.0057373047, -0.01701355, -0.008872986, -0.021911621, -0.015205383, 0.008476257, -0.011947632, -0.020980835, 0.03543091, -0.018692017, -0.0077590942, -0.017623901, -0.02532959, -0.039031982, -0.0025749207, 0.013450623, 0.027297974, -0.0030021667, 0.01058197, -0.0138549805, 0.012290955, -0.05444336, 0.0024700165, 0.005897522, 0.0032367706, 0.0012512207, -0.033843994, -0.042297363, 0.020111084, 0.043121338, -0.0067253113, 0.015571594, -0.04284668, -0.0061454773, -0.0067634583, 0.011688232, -0.0036945343, -0.051116943, -0.0077323914, -0.03616333, 0.026138306, 0.017868042, 0.051879883, 0.02418518, 0.015510559, -0.027175903, 0.0048179626, 0.0007414818, 0.052642822, -0.024169922, 0.03878784, 0.042999268, -0.06008911, 0.010177612, 0.03829956, -0.029251099, 0.01751709, 0.008491516, 0.062927246, -0.039855957, -0.012840271, 0.02571106, 0.022537231, -0.041412354, 0.006324768, -0.03488159, 0.009780884, -0.030776978, -0.02708435, 0.033203125, -0.007904053, -0.02532959, -0.02281189, 0.0151901245, -0.010612488, 0.0014896393, 0.026626587, -0.0003631115, 0.035888672, 0.0005135536, 0.044952393, 0.0045547485, -0.031173706, 0.029907227, 0.04650879, -0.050720215, 0.016036987, 0.04849243, 0.04849243, 0.055603027, 0.06951904, -0.023239136, 0.027893066, 0.027740479, 0.0008587837, 0.025253296, -0.006706238, -0.021316528, -0.008712769, -0.026016235, 0.019378662, -0.016616821, -0.030914307, -0.016937256, -0.038635254, 0.03302002, -0.008468628, -0.0042762756, -0.06677246, 0.015174866, 0.016708374, -0.0060195923, -0.09069824, 0.0071487427, 0.012237549, 0.01763916, -0.007610321, -0.059570312, -0.010757446, -0.011161804, 0.0016775131, 0.051513672, -0.014328003, -0.052215576, 0.010635376, -0.002714157, 0.054595947, -0.011444092, -0.0046577454, 0.0036125183, 0.01928711, -0.004463196, -0.0020103455, -0.021148682, 0.074401855, -0.01725769, -0.004169464, 0.018554688, 0.025360107, 0.011207581, -0.034942627, -0.09277344, 0.016159058, -0.039916992, 0.01953125, -0.026321411, -0.034942627, 0.0015974045, 0.005344391, -0.024871826, 0.010955811, 0.030410767, -0.020385742, 0.03829956, -0.00655365, -0.021499634, 0.012435913, 0.015464783, 0.021438599, 0.00042057037, -0.050445557, -0.0012216568, 0.003004074, 0.039916992, -0.02355957, 0.009513855, 0.0154953, 0.057891846, 0.00029206276, 0.008453369, 0.012184143, 0.015991211, 0.0019216537, 0.046661377, -0.008987427, -0.034484863, 0.01071167, 0.04788208, 0.037719727, 0.016403198, -0.044799805, 0.046966553, 0.02180481, -0.10614014, -0.016723633, 0.023971558, 0.043395996, -0.0006427765, 0.022277832, 0.07116699, -0.0345459, -0.066223145, -0.049438477, -0.0047454834, 0.005012512, -0.01108551, -0.019866943, 0.032196045, -0.03164673, 0.009536743, -0.008758545, -0.028549194, 0.032043457, 0.017684937, 0.034301758, -0.026901245, 0.052581787, -0.019348145, 0.020935059, 0.002231598, 0.0010356903, 0.018432617, 0.012084961, -0.051086426, -0.022903442, -0.0637207, 0.000726223, -0.0044059753, -0.008995056, 0.006412506, -0.020584106, -0.0012807846, 0.023986816, -0.00034427643, 0.0041389465, 0.015701294, -0.018188477, -0.0042877197, 0.007774353, -0.055480957, -0.0019283295, 0.0093307495 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07099v1
Explanation-aware Soft Ensemble Empowers Large Language Model In-context Learning
Yue Yu, Jiaming Shen, Tianqi Liu, Zhen Qin, Jing Nathan Yan, Jialu Liu, Chao Zhang, Michael Bendersky
cs.CL, cs.AI
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in various natural language understanding tasks. With only a few demonstration examples, these LLMs can quickly adapt to target tasks without expensive gradient updates. Common strategies to boost such 'in-context' learning ability are to ensemble multiple model decoded results and require the model to generate an explanation along with the prediction. However, these models often treat different class predictions equally and neglect the potential discrepancy between the explanations and predictions. To fully unleash the power of explanations, we propose EASE, an Explanation-Aware Soft Ensemble framework to empower in-context learning with LLMs. We design two techniques, explanation-guided ensemble, and soft probability aggregation, to mitigate the effect of unreliable explanations and improve the consistency between explanations and final predictions. Experiments on seven natural language understanding tasks and four varying-size LLMs demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed framework.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07099v1
2023-11-13T06:13:38
2023-11-13T06:13:38
{ "title": [ -0.008255005, -0.018035889, -0.037506104, -0.083984375, -0.0058517456, -0.0038051605, -0.035217285, 0.04510498, 0.00016248226, 0.016067505, -0.033416748, -0.0017366409, 0.023895264, -0.02229309, -0.0036811829, -0.0025291443, 0.000090539455, 0.039764404, -0.017700195, -0.043029785, -0.019744873, -0.04800415, 0.046722412, 0.035705566, 0.034851074, -0.085998535, -0.06604004, 0.025970459, -0.023864746, -0.025863647, 0.0020523071, 0.019866943, 0.029891968, 0.018692017, -0.02381897, -0.02897644, -0.052246094, 0.026443481, -0.010559082, -0.005706787, 0.022125244, 0.0029582977, 0.005908966, -0.014694214, -0.021972656, 0.020339966, -0.047576904, -0.022583008, -0.0009841919, -0.010047913, 0.00025081635, 0.029891968, -0.0126953125, 0.0110321045, 0.007835388, -0.023849487, -0.04095459, 0.02217102, 0.03439331, 0.061584473, 0.009460449, -0.022613525, 0.0017566681, -0.044921875, -0.04812622, -0.0211792, -0.014030457, 0.0050354004, 0.05783081, -0.012054443, -0.011276245, 0.03338623, -0.010383606, -0.0063095093, -0.078125, 0.02722168, 0.034179688, -0.0061149597, 0.038146973, -0.041046143, 0.0016641617, 0.01247406, 0.017929077, -0.03475952, 0.012275696, -0.045135498, -0.025985718, -0.00579834, -0.008972168, -0.09112549, -0.0048179626, -0.046569824, -0.015205383, 0.012878418, -0.03503418, -0.05279541, -0.015174866, -0.0041007996, -0.009506226, -0.058380127, -0.008850098, 0.022628784, -0.06542969, 0.006137848, 0.009506226, 0.029037476, -0.011268616, 0.0005970001, 0.023452759, 0.007797241, -0.019485474, 0.03656006, -0.014671326, -0.032836914, 0.008865356, -0.018051147, -0.058044434, 0.036071777, 0.032958984, -0.016921997, -0.013435364, -0.02142334, 0.036468506, -0.006099701, 0.022766113, 0.0045547485, -0.05053711, -0.0033817291, 0.019973755, 0.04473877, -0.0076942444, 0.047424316, -0.0892334, -0.09814453, -0.07928467, 0.02947998, -0.04232788, -0.0005707741, -0.011726379, -0.013336182, -0.00730896, -0.032806396, 0.025863647, 0.0031280518, 0.03451538, -0.008071899, 0.054779053, 0.019638062, -0.03491211, -0.027801514, -0.004310608, 0.027999878, 0.032806396, -0.022994995, -0.05621338, -0.022232056, -0.12695312, -0.005115509, 0.015975952, 0.00032114983, 0.009384155, -0.0036811829, 0.0033416748, -0.005809784, 0.0041007996, -0.0029907227, 0.005542755, -0.0047836304, 0.017578125, 0.018707275, 0.017181396, 0.031066895, 0.0012769699, -0.016723633, -0.006801605, -0.027038574, 0.007019043, 0.037963867, 0.009513855, -0.006828308, 0.02684021, -0.036468506, 0.017868042, 0.032958984, -0.03692627, -0.053863525, -0.024154663, -0.017044067, 0.083862305, 0.004447937, -0.04244995, -0.022750854, -0.023239136, -0.04824829, -0.030975342, -0.0026512146, 0.018325806, 0.038238525, -0.012229919, 0.013191223, 0.007827759, 0.021331787, -0.021942139, -0.0071983337, 0.0035858154, -0.02041626, 0.0018577576, 0.017227173, 0.0077590942, 0.033111572, 0.03488159, 0.010971069, -0.033294678, 0.016296387, -0.030288696, -0.033477783, 0.02456665, -0.024429321, -0.01776123, -0.023208618, 0.011444092, -0.005947113, 0.020111084, 0.08538818, 0.016723633, 0.009803772, -0.0050354004, 0.0025367737, 0.03475952, 0.03262329, 0.04196167, -0.05505371, 0.014862061, 0.015296936, -0.009757996, -0.020553589, -0.01966858, -0.012237549, 0.019195557, 0.00447464, -0.005382538, -0.011528015, -0.01826477, 0.021774292, 0.053527832, 0.026626587, 0.0041885376, 0.004459381, -0.0025939941, 0.03665161, 0.057922363, 0.023483276, 0.02319336, 0.0030956268, -0.01586914, 0.05154419, 0.02027893, -0.0057373047, -0.032684326, 0.018447876, 0.021835327, 0.031433105, -0.02923584, 0.024871826, -0.07849121, 0.011604309, -0.046051025, -0.009155273, 0.01663208, -0.008171082, 0.026565552, -0.026504517, 0.009765625, -0.0027217865, -0.030319214, -0.0021743774, -0.008728027, 0.021957397, 0.021942139, -0.043701172, 0.0058631897, 0.0012521744, 0.05218506, -0.0019378662, 0.03010559, 0.023605347, 0.038482666, -0.0037345886, -0.019104004, -0.0028800964, 0.037963867, 0.060424805, 0.031219482, -0.005748749, 0.021209717, 0.015625, 0.09033203, 0.05795288, -0.032104492, 0.033966064, -0.046661377, 0.02357483, 0.017196655, -0.016937256, 0.015579224, -0.0010271072, 0.033569336, 0.01889038, -0.03515625, 0.026550293, -0.09716797, -0.024093628, 0.0028076172, 0.0026874542, -0.06781006, -0.06414795, 0.00039839745, -0.016586304, -0.032806396, -0.013717651, 0.107666016, -0.006088257, -0.012954712, -0.0019426346, 0.009361267, -0.03656006, 0.013031006, -0.03994751, 0.011062622, 0.02394104, 0.02444458, 0.02748108, -0.06335449, -0.041412354, -0.014144897, -0.0035533905, -0.0048179626, -0.036834717, -0.025512695, 0.03164673, 0.020690918, -0.018875122, 0.030899048, -0.032958984, -0.030761719, -0.049102783, 0.016815186, 0.012390137, -0.000097095966, -0.01890564, 0.04321289, -0.016204834, -0.03543091, 0.013244629, 0.04711914, -0.06414795, -0.011421204, 0.039093018, 0.003145218, -0.0054626465, 0.03201294, 0.030044556, 0.006088257, -0.0793457, -0.0011253357, -0.052246094, -0.01979065, -0.028411865, -0.04257202, 0.022476196, -0.014060974, -0.017166138, -0.046691895, -0.032226562, -0.01991272, 0.0061531067, 0.016403198, -0.0206604, -0.020187378, 0.001121521, -0.021133423, 0.003162384, -0.013084412, 0.013122559, 0.08404541, -0.0020866394, -0.009552002, 0.027557373, 0.032836914, 0.014190674, -0.018966675, -0.027450562, -0.028366089, 0.004917145, 0.018554688, 0.005088806, -0.012397766, -0.025131226, -0.09240723, -0.0099487305, 0.04727173, -0.0090408325, -0.03677368, 0.033599854, -0.07122803, 0.016540527, -0.013999939, -0.01828003, 0.013511658, 0.019241333, 0.015686035, -0.026397705, 0.010375977, -0.038757324, 0.010482788, -0.03717041, -0.09136963, 0.03451538, -0.04058838, -0.03479004, 0.0049858093, -0.012329102, -0.048919678, -0.026824951, 0.0184021, 0.081604004, 0.026260376, -0.003818512, 0.036468506, -0.05908203, 0.004337311, -0.046936035, -0.016433716, 0.016677856, -0.025985718, 0.051574707, 0.0118637085, 0.012420654, 0.05618286, -0.040649414, -0.007003784, -0.025894165, -0.05303955, 0.02835083, -0.03137207, -0.030258179, -0.031951904, -0.017364502, 0.008453369, 0.016677856, -0.033599854, -0.0072746277, -0.027420044, 0.010009766, -0.03744507, 0.016937256, -0.009635925, 0.021835327, 0.0048713684, -0.01966858, 0.038757324, -0.020767212, -0.045318604, 0.02999878, 0.02999878, 0.0069084167, 0.0039596558, -0.008377075, -0.04421997, 0.033935547, -0.009933472, -0.030059814, -0.019699097, -0.013923645, 0.024734497, 0.0060310364, -0.009681702, -0.010246277, -0.00024676323, 0.0027656555, 0.00086832047, 0.008293152, -0.059570312, -0.050811768, -0.0032958984, 0.009933472, -0.09490967, -0.046081543, 0.012145996, -0.017715454, -0.017868042, -0.08355713, 0.022537231, -0.03805542, -0.049072266, 0.027496338, -0.017745972, 0.011451721, -0.0075302124, -0.09844971, 0.00085926056, 0.068359375, 0.0002875328, 0.01876831, 0.037841797, -0.014144897, -0.03048706, -0.013793945, 0.034332275, -0.01953125, 0.043060303, 0.0041160583, -0.014373779, 0.020568848, -0.025283813, 0.027648926, 0.016647339, -0.012580872, 0.008224487, 0.012809753, -0.008293152, 0.005809784, -0.0039520264, 0.039855957, -0.0032405853, 0.0017175674, -0.04324341, 0.025131226, -0.0051116943, -0.010635376, 0.026916504, -0.00013041496, 0.02331543, 0.026000977, -0.0149383545, 0.03881836, -0.009552002, 0.0107803345, 0.029037476, -0.006706238, -0.024978638, 0.006225586, 0.01763916, 0.018249512, -0.0044174194, 0.048431396, 0.00094652176, 0.05227661, -0.03994751, -0.010139465, 0.00005686283, 0.03024292, -0.04827881, 0.0101623535, -0.04046631, -0.05340576, -0.040496826, 0.02571106, -0.020614624, 0.025726318, 0.051940918, -0.009506226, -0.0064964294, -0.015945435, 0.033843994, 0.012588501, -0.07501221, -0.105773926, -0.0031833649, -0.009437561, -0.0625, -0.03387451, -0.021102905, -0.02796936, 0.028320312, 0.0049743652, -0.02923584, 0.0035877228, 0.018051147, 0.06439209, 0.028167725, 0.015571594, -0.05291748, 0.028564453, -0.03338623, -0.01398468, 0.0259552, 0.019165039, -0.0047454834, -0.017089844, 0.020095825, -0.02558899, -0.0015172958, -0.0692749, 0.016113281, -0.021438599, 0.050476074, -0.0017166138, 0.008850098, 0.022018433, -0.013145447, 0.012466431, 0.0047340393, -0.030471802, 0.031463623, 0.006454468, 0.0006046295, -0.008407593, 0.0005555153, 0.003250122, 0.010726929, 0.018081665, 0.015464783, -0.007522583, 0.019424438, -0.006450653, -0.0056152344, 0.023849487, -0.02128601, -0.019683838, -0.005176544, -0.0013933182, 0.022521973, -0.06188965, 0.028182983, -0.030715942, 0.008842468, 0.018035889, 0.00041556358, 0.017868042, 0.023986816, 0.023406982, -0.056365967, -0.05316162, -0.0104599, 0.034576416, -0.013008118, 0.010437012, 0.011749268, 0.0055160522, 0.03390503, 0.028289795, 0.051818848, -0.03326416, -0.016235352, -0.026855469, 0.006893158, 0.024612427, -0.041992188, -0.04324341, 0.006767273, 0.020324707, -0.033813477, 0.043182373, -0.027236938, 0.0048675537, -0.011390686, -0.03552246, 0.02078247, -0.079833984, 0.0317688, 0.07330322, -0.013641357, 0.033233643, 0.013687134, 0.035339355, 0.026123047, 0.052886963, 0.016784668, 0.014221191, 0.039093018, -0.05239868, 0.0107421875, -0.011024475, 0.013496399, -0.006580353, 0.03527832, 0.005908966, 0.038604736, -0.07324219, 0.021575928, -0.005050659, -0.009933472, -0.004009247, -0.042907715, 0.0309906, 0.012435913, -0.01651001, 0.04522705, -0.04449463, -0.008026123, -0.006038666, -0.009017944, -0.042633057, 0.029388428, 0.015144348, -0.044128418, -0.06173706, 0.015792847, -0.03616333, -0.0011053085, -0.008377075, 0.0025978088, -0.038970947, 0.009841919, 0.014015198, -0.058685303, 0.02897644, -0.026901245, -0.0029067993, 0.033355713, 0.01890564, -0.058624268, -0.014976501, -0.008430481, -0.0317688, -0.007282257, 0.014038086, 0.017959595, -0.004814148, 0.008735657, 0.0021247864, 0.01550293, 0.013839722, 0.02999878, 0.0152282715, -0.0368042, 0.030136108, 0.0019264221, 0.008049011, 0.010345459, 0.026382446, -0.006839752, 0.0107421875, 0.024429321, -0.0463562, 0.02079773, -0.005748749, 0.011314392, -0.01991272, -0.083496094, -0.00009804964, 0.01121521, -0.0046958923, 0.027130127, -0.014953613, 0.02217102, 0.023513794, 0.0073127747, 0.033355713, 0.08258057, -0.06866455, -0.013053894, -0.031082153, -0.0070266724, -0.034484863, 0.06512451, -0.00137043, -0.008483887, -0.04159546, -0.039215088, -0.013877869, 0.021621704, 0.008033752, 0.011054993, 0.026260376, -0.019378662, 0.021759033, -0.032714844, -0.020065308, -0.03805542, 0.038635254, -0.011802673, -0.035736084, 0.0038032532, -0.039215088, -0.005622864, -0.029754639, 0.01550293, 0.013809204, 0.010292053, -0.003698349, -0.021957397, -0.00043964386, -0.02268982, -0.033050537, 0.029296875, 0.020767212, -0.015930176, 0.046325684, -0.038726807, 0.06536865, 0.0082092285, 0.050994873, 0.021270752, -0.0040359497, 0.029800415, 0.0025482178, 0.013595581, -0.03363037, 0.049682617, -0.05645752, 0.043151855, -0.082458496, -0.011566162, -0.10205078, 0.008575439, 0.0030975342, 0.04309082, -0.0029716492, 0.007873535, -0.017837524, 0.0035190582, 0.04397583, 0.025436401, 0.07269287, -0.04107666, -0.014129639, 0.0038776398, -0.014823914, 0.035186768, 0.043670654, -0.0033435822, 0.003736496, -0.020751953, -0.039886475, 0.027557373, 0.016098022, 0.015029907, -0.035064697, -0.028945923, -0.05178833, 0.015586853, -0.012878418, 0.021591187, 0.03543091, 0.0491333, -0.010368347, -0.00182724, 0.0049095154, -0.019699097, -0.02357483, 0.0056877136, 0.035827637, -0.07458496, 0.03253174, 0.007347107, -0.028884888, -0.023605347, 0.031082153, 0.024810791, -0.038208008, -0.013717651, 0.010673523, 0.031982422, -0.0037765503, -0.009147644, -0.022460938, -0.011177063, 0.032348633, 0.040161133, -0.007381439, 0.03201294, -0.007949829, -0.01689148, -0.0024089813, -0.033569336, 0.0009803772, 0.053771973, -0.032989502, 0.02243042, -0.005203247, 0.031982422, -0.016967773, -0.032928467, 0.0119018555, 0.004764557, -0.048583984, -0.01096344, 0.030136108, 0.025268555, 0.020935059, 0.06536865, -0.0076141357, -0.0052223206, -0.013961792, -0.021652222, 0.023849487, 0.05508423, -0.02720642, 0.004184723, -0.023849487, -0.025039673, 0.019210815, -0.03604126, 0.0054626465, -0.058776855, 0.011741638, -0.030349731, 0.04220581, -0.019104004, -0.044891357, -0.01890564, 0.015403748, -0.017822266, -0.0065612793, 0.010864258, -0.016601562, -0.029037476, -0.017105103, 0.02734375, -0.0029335022, 0.014022827, 0.02319336, -0.025527954, -0.03527832, 0.0013418198, -0.033294678, 0.05441284, -0.03729248, 0.0015010834, -0.003566742, 0.01828003, -0.02407837, -0.038757324, -0.022872925, 0.012649536, -0.01007843, -0.031982422, 0.022827148, 0.018249512, -0.015975952, -0.047607422, -0.010955811, -0.00868988, -0.03503418, 0.026367188, 0.040161133, -0.043395996, -0.02810669, 0.01739502, -0.035003662, 0.07165527, 0.012992859, -0.0072288513, -0.009536743, 0.019165039, -0.030471802, -0.038238525, 0.00447464, 0.018341064, 0.0013389587, -0.0317688, 0.0033893585, 0.008773804, 0.043182373, -0.049072266, -0.042663574, 0.004585266, 0.02709961, -0.00095558167, 0.045166016, 0.022247314, -0.007549286, -0.006111145, 0.010383606, -0.0064697266, -0.018127441, -0.0019702911, 0.00044035912, 0.05065918, 0.05618286, -0.010948181, 0.0055122375, 0.032348633, -0.004257202, 0.010681152, 0.021652222, 0.0018033981, 0.027542114, -0.011039734, 0.028015137, -0.036499023, -0.006702423, -0.035217285, 0.0082092285, 0.009094238, 0.02772522, -0.013320923, 0.020202637, -0.016525269, 0.056671143, -0.028060913, -0.057678223, 0.061645508, 0.028244019, 0.010528564, -0.0021915436, 0.027450562, -0.0031795502, -0.0062942505, -0.01486969, 0.017120361, -0.007381439, -0.008460999, -0.040161133, 0.012359619, -0.09124756, -0.041534424, -0.02418518, -0.025115967, 0.0390625, -0.04107666, 0.013893127, -0.011962891, -0.041503906, -0.003004074, -0.0030460358, -0.0034809113, -0.028518677, -0.037017822, 0.016616821, 0.016082764, -0.014335632 ], "summary": [ -0.0018596649, -0.040283203, -0.03845215, -0.04574585, -0.046325684, 0.0035266876, -0.06616211, 0.03314209, 0.0181427, 0.013664246, -0.03778076, -0.008636475, 0.011169434, -0.02142334, 0.008270264, -0.024993896, 0.0033397675, 0.0058250427, -0.013496399, -0.034057617, 0.0062789917, -0.043792725, 0.017532349, 0.014419556, 0.02368164, -0.07098389, 0.032196045, 0.009429932, 0.034118652, 0.027786255, 0.02432251, -0.048706055, 0.0071105957, -0.014633179, 0.0017271042, -0.056396484, -0.07147217, 0.018753052, -0.016021729, -0.0029525757, 0.02659607, -0.005241394, 0.06298828, -0.034423828, 0.0021038055, 0.04373169, -0.011756897, -0.031082153, 0.023208618, -0.032806396, -0.006099701, 0.019195557, -0.011436462, -0.024398804, -0.019195557, 0.0041999817, -0.055389404, 0.028198242, 0.0112838745, 0.07299805, 0.01121521, 0.009529114, -0.009933472, -0.051757812, -0.008659363, 0.006931305, 0.023345947, -0.023956299, 0.041778564, -0.00071525574, 0.009483337, 0.019378662, 0.01574707, -0.058258057, -0.019729614, 0.045684814, 0.027618408, 0.015838623, 0.00085258484, -0.037841797, 0.0062217712, 0.027389526, 0.046966553, -0.060760498, 0.014671326, -0.056854248, -0.01612854, 0.0059013367, 0.039611816, -0.041809082, 0.004119873, -0.02027893, 0.008460999, 0.03955078, -0.00818634, -0.046722412, -0.0001437664, -0.024093628, -0.0043296814, -0.046691895, 0.02230835, -0.018569946, -0.030441284, 0.0067863464, 0.006816864, 0.039794922, 0.009529114, -0.027801514, 0.014961243, -0.002401352, -0.008682251, 0.017654419, -0.0049095154, -0.058807373, 0.024642944, -0.0018825531, -0.031829834, 0.068481445, 0.032348633, 0.0025253296, -0.028533936, 0.0005145073, 0.026382446, 0.051940918, -0.008361816, 0.034973145, 0.010940552, -0.022613525, 0.05822754, 0.014038086, -0.0023441315, 0.025131226, -0.08721924, -0.061706543, -0.061279297, 0.007843018, -0.039245605, 0.010246277, -0.01612854, -0.010421753, -0.01474762, -0.024246216, 0.025817871, -0.0067443848, 0.00617218, 0.018173218, 0.0071525574, 0.012550354, 0.002357483, -0.0236969, 0.00642395, -0.01436615, 0.03845215, -0.03970337, -0.020324707, -0.07043457, -0.06677246, -0.014541626, 0.027038574, -0.009010315, -0.008468628, -0.01626587, 0.019561768, -0.0033893585, -0.042663574, 0.015899658, 0.010055542, -0.026016235, 0.0072631836, -0.021377563, 0.029968262, 0.031219482, -0.014350891, -0.015365601, -0.0015172958, -0.025314331, -0.0007829666, 0.06262207, -0.018310547, -0.004814148, 0.016311646, -0.047454834, 0.038757324, 0.0002503395, -0.010360718, -0.057617188, -0.021224976, 0.0032653809, 0.0826416, 0.010238647, -0.04724121, -0.068847656, -0.00774765, -0.01802063, -0.017288208, -0.0017261505, 0.0032157898, 0.024093628, -0.01876831, -0.0022277832, 0.04953003, 0.009223938, -0.006099701, -0.035339355, -0.022033691, -0.011161804, 0.009284973, 0.013114929, 0.01524353, 0.021591187, 0.014755249, 0.0082092285, -0.04257202, 0.03765869, -0.010940552, -0.018035889, 0.038238525, -0.000213027, -0.019851685, -0.044525146, 0.029800415, -0.02142334, 0.03111267, 0.15014648, -0.0040245056, 0.011459351, -0.008476257, 0.037628174, 0.036468506, 0.024291992, 0.05291748, -0.048309326, 0.02583313, 0.03012085, -0.019317627, -0.011268616, 0.003850937, -0.037628174, 0.025878906, 0.02911377, 0.006668091, 0.00042796135, -0.039245605, -0.015853882, 0.024932861, 0.033477783, 0.027297974, -0.029373169, -0.023666382, 0.01763916, -0.001121521, -0.0014219284, 0.008682251, -0.023605347, -0.026763916, 0.051879883, 0.015808105, -0.02519226, -0.007045746, 0.0050621033, 0.017288208, -0.004169464, -0.040222168, 0.010292053, -0.03564453, -0.037322998, -0.022949219, -0.03286743, 0.0118637085, -0.039489746, 0.02796936, -0.022415161, -0.0017814636, -0.020629883, -0.04776001, 0.0029964447, -0.00598526, 0.03265381, 0.028274536, -0.025268555, -0.005710602, -0.020324707, 0.011238098, -0.008377075, 0.029510498, 0.00088882446, 0.028839111, 0.012306213, 0.0042686462, 0.062408447, 0.035980225, 0.08001709, 0.04675293, -0.001791954, 0.023269653, 0.03616333, 0.056121826, -0.01625061, 0.006702423, -0.016525269, 0.017913818, 0.05593872, -0.004234314, -0.007205963, 0.018157959, -0.0041275024, 0.010627747, 0.01979065, -0.0027809143, 0.011558533, -0.076660156, -0.03149414, 0.023651123, 0.07421875, -0.06185913, -0.040649414, 0.0003812313, 0.028701782, -0.0050582886, 0.032989502, 0.13964844, 0.008529663, 0.011894226, 0.030700684, 0.0032215118, -0.06982422, 0.05834961, -0.045928955, 0.052642822, 0.007282257, -0.022888184, 0.015022278, -0.04067993, -0.0038013458, -0.0065231323, -0.026443481, 0.009757996, -0.040802002, -0.006793976, 0.04989624, 0.05505371, -0.038146973, 0.021820068, -0.0110321045, -0.038635254, -0.0059013367, 0.003955841, -0.005256653, 0.01008606, -0.007801056, 0.017700195, -0.011428833, -0.029022217, 0.02758789, 0.012840271, -0.045654297, 0.008255005, 0.008415222, -0.023422241, -0.037719727, 0.019012451, 0.026260376, -0.0041923523, -0.10180664, -0.0053215027, -0.018692017, -0.02734375, -0.026290894, -0.002981186, 0.012367249, 0.026184082, 0.010124207, -0.04611206, -0.02217102, -0.014122009, -0.022949219, 0.087524414, 0.016723633, -0.009094238, 0.054718018, -0.0030498505, 0.0027599335, -0.0028972626, -0.018707275, 0.074401855, 0.010223389, 0.002313614, 0.0463562, 0.019332886, 0.0023956299, -0.007030487, -0.0036582947, -0.021072388, -0.0025234222, -0.014289856, 0.000028371811, -0.037994385, -0.026992798, -0.047943115, -0.0066871643, 0.06726074, 0.015701294, 0.022338867, 0.011619568, -0.03765869, 0.0657959, -0.004058838, 0.011375427, 0.016036987, -0.016464233, 0.027877808, -0.06402588, 0.025314331, -0.061584473, 0.0012168884, -0.03100586, -0.03475952, 0.016189575, -0.035949707, -0.0027008057, -0.002817154, 0.013504028, -0.012054443, 0.004108429, 0.025894165, 0.055847168, 0.0018672943, -0.005710602, 0.024017334, -0.016174316, 0.0065460205, -0.02230835, -0.007144928, 0.040771484, -0.0446167, 0.053344727, 0.022521973, -0.041534424, 0.071777344, -0.08691406, -0.022766113, -0.03289795, -0.0791626, -0.006095886, -0.043670654, -0.004207611, -0.035003662, -0.041290283, 0.014350891, 0.05117798, -0.029281616, -0.026275635, -0.002149582, 0.0335083, -0.049926758, 0.05996704, -0.049621582, 0.01525116, 0.046722412, -0.02470398, 0.02355957, -0.015098572, -0.032287598, 0.009338379, 0.043273926, 0.026489258, -0.0050086975, 0.016281128, 0.0048294067, -0.010658264, 0.02961731, -0.070251465, -0.034729004, -0.019012451, 0.016525269, -0.021331787, 0.019088745, -0.0006175041, 0.036254883, -0.02407837, -0.035217285, 0.021759033, -0.06726074, -0.045837402, -0.013175964, 0.0058670044, -0.05758667, -0.03753662, 0.020507812, 0.017456055, -0.0021629333, -0.066833496, 0.02809143, -0.01550293, -0.029586792, 0.043914795, -0.035339355, 0.087524414, 0.0003721714, -0.081970215, 0.08325195, -0.027679443, 0.006641388, 0.06121826, 0.000078976154, -0.0073242188, -0.015159607, 0.0047035217, 0.015342712, -0.056396484, 0.04034424, -0.020843506, 0.015655518, 0.0033340454, -0.003189087, 0.008087158, 0.01600647, -0.01309967, 0.009666443, 0.0016822815, 0.046722412, 0.03552246, 0.009536743, -0.008346558, -0.004257202, 0.02520752, -0.015098572, 0.025604248, 0.00096797943, -0.021575928, 0.046051025, 0.020812988, -0.015388489, 0.0073127747, -0.0022411346, 0.012016296, -0.022781372, 0.0040779114, 0.0070533752, -0.010848999, -0.023483276, -0.009513855, 0.0038604736, 0.025238037, 0.009712219, 0.043121338, 0.015388489, 0.042816162, -0.04373169, 0.018692017, -0.012611389, 0.008094788, -0.026351929, 0.0031547546, -0.0012550354, -0.03540039, -0.052581787, 0.020080566, -0.013122559, 0.02381897, 0.038360596, -0.011154175, 0.019851685, -0.027023315, 0.019882202, 0.016937256, -0.085510254, -0.12756348, -0.042236328, -0.0061836243, -0.046966553, -0.02281189, -0.059326172, -0.051727295, -0.026794434, 0.009841919, -0.02949524, 0.006904602, -0.005706787, 0.027267456, 0.03274536, 0.015731812, -0.035827637, -0.018447876, -0.037200928, -0.0012617111, 0.033477783, 0.019760132, 0.0017261505, 0.0019931793, 0.015586853, -0.024673462, -0.020462036, -0.107543945, 0.006340027, 0.020721436, 0.008911133, 0.04284668, -0.0021419525, 0.023162842, -0.021774292, -0.009712219, -0.0013828278, -0.0031795502, 0.070007324, 0.015670776, -0.012763977, 0.02960205, -0.027191162, -0.001080513, -0.012191772, 0.0044898987, 0.019256592, -0.031280518, 0.02168274, 0.008033752, -0.0069274902, 0.019042969, 0.011123657, 0.0052604675, 0.020736694, -0.008583069, 0.008026123, -0.006412506, -0.052703857, -0.0073051453, 0.037322998, 0.0065307617, -0.022354126, 0.012161255, 0.028259277, 0.008598328, -0.015487671, -0.033721924, -0.0019025803, 0.0056419373, 0.01411438, -0.006729126, -0.00995636, -0.0010099411, 0.0075950623, -0.0046195984, 0.025817871, -0.033294678, 0.0020694733, -0.043792725, -0.012336731, 0.0309906, -0.006626129, -0.059326172, 0.008666992, 0.025466919, -0.025360107, 0.045318604, 0.031219482, 0.010520935, -0.011268616, -0.031433105, 0.013763428, -0.06738281, -0.04525757, -0.010192871, -0.026870728, -0.0060157776, 0.11566162, -0.0098724365, -0.022323608, 0.022903442, -0.013244629, 0.028076172, -0.0151901245, -0.07409668, -0.006088257, -0.033599854, 0.019622803, -0.0022621155, 0.027435303, 0.012283325, 0.025131226, -0.057128906, -0.030456543, -0.06677246, 0.032684326, -0.02368164, 0.0025253296, 0.014907837, 0.03894043, -0.0093688965, 0.030029297, 0.012718201, 0.020874023, 0.0026550293, 0.0019311905, -0.009498596, 0.0040245056, 0.010902405, -0.017807007, -0.0035972595, -0.000113487244, -0.038726807, 0.008491516, 0.019515991, -0.010848999, -0.0006904602, -0.023513794, -0.026885986, -0.0033245087, 0.015296936, 0.003396988, 0.014282227, -0.019729614, -0.0037269592, -0.034729004, -0.004673004, -0.033966064, -0.023498535, -0.034973145, 0.031829834, 0.023468018, 0.023162842, 0.014442444, 0.0071258545, 0.023483276, 0.002544403, 0.022567749, 0.0018234253, -0.027908325, 0.030899048, -0.019470215, -0.021957397, 0.011741638, 0.004032135, -0.029830933, -0.0077781677, 0.023925781, -0.04711914, 0.041625977, -0.024230957, 0.016693115, -0.0463562, -0.061340332, 0.0045051575, 0.012374878, 0.002450943, 0.01360321, -0.010108948, 0.0016851425, 0.032958984, 0.00434494, 0.012107849, 0.047607422, -0.022888184, -0.0073432922, -0.029647827, 0.004547119, -0.04473877, 0.0055885315, 0.012084961, 0.010154724, -0.027435303, -0.012809753, 0.017471313, 0.011581421, 0.010009766, -0.0079574585, 0.031677246, -0.00308609, 0.01876831, -0.012252808, -0.017501831, -0.0059127808, 0.011734009, -0.02281189, -0.048095703, 0.041290283, -0.007972717, -0.017791748, -0.010391235, 0.013923645, 0.0030899048, -0.004108429, -0.004119873, 0.040893555, 0.0028457642, -0.03564453, 0.006958008, 0.04901123, 0.032043457, -0.037017822, 0.043121338, 0.025802612, 0.05126953, 0.019729614, 0.0041046143, -0.028793335, -0.020858765, 0.050201416, 0.01171875, 0.014877319, -0.0074806213, 0.084472656, -0.01890564, -0.0048446655, -0.07525635, -0.048034668, -0.06390381, 0.028366089, -0.023162842, 0.0023899078, 0.020050049, 0.00299263, -0.012374878, 0.004776001, -0.0362854, 0.03503418, 0.01184845, -0.06542969, -0.035736084, 0.023742676, -0.0072517395, 0.028717041, 0.05392456, -0.014259338, 0.020599365, -0.011405945, 0.010314941, 0.04159546, -0.03665161, -0.02456665, -0.09802246, 0.010124207, -0.05758667, 0.012901306, 0.022201538, 0.038269043, 0.0010795593, 0.0184021, 0.03302002, -0.0008301735, 0.0017442703, 0.024002075, -0.016845703, 0.024368286, 0.0063705444, -0.0064048767, -0.008087158, 0.021011353, -0.028518677, 0.028320312, 0.0418396, 0.031311035, -0.018966675, 0.02079773, -0.012519836, -0.0009050369, -0.008522034, -0.03164673, -0.0234375, 0.008804321, 0.0054512024, -0.011749268, 0.01991272, -0.0011100769, -0.02897644, -0.04559326, 0.048095703, -0.031433105, -0.0003874302, 0.056762695, -0.015312195, 0.032073975, 0.053833008, 0.014633179, 0.038360596, -0.014152527, 0.021011353, 0.04348755, -0.015197754, 0.03427124, 0.01424408, 0.027694702, 0.030212402, 0.047332764, -0.035736084, 0.010421753, 0.040008545, -0.008010864, -0.022567749, 0.013038635, -0.0030231476, -0.024169922, -0.017105103, 0.010910034, -0.004058838, -0.0079193115, 0.011749268, -0.08050537, 0.035308838, -0.04321289, 0.061553955, -0.08996582, -0.037475586, -0.023345947, -0.004295349, -0.03881836, 0.01977539, 0.039276123, -0.007911682, -0.013031006, -0.024291992, -0.008552551, -0.008796692, 0.018569946, 0.025238037, -0.01890564, -0.01259613, 0.008621216, 0.018600464, 0.062561035, -0.013061523, -0.0062217712, 0.039855957, -0.0006532669, -0.010879517, -0.041625977, -0.035736084, 0.03213501, 0.027420044, -0.02659607, 0.019485474, 0.027175903, -0.010231018, -0.09222412, -0.0068740845, -0.018569946, -0.041168213, 0.03579712, 0.047424316, -0.032409668, -0.036315918, 0.02470398, -0.05078125, 0.066101074, 0.0008020401, -0.008811951, 0.0045814514, 0.027786255, -0.036102295, -0.0158844, -0.011688232, -0.011894226, -0.02067566, -0.006340027, -0.0010080338, 0.0022735596, 0.034118652, -0.017913818, -0.015136719, 0.0013847351, -0.00088500977, 0.024780273, -0.009811401, -0.013961792, -0.028656006, 0.008720398, 0.007835388, 0.0070343018, 0.0046539307, 0.07513428, 0.026763916, 0.036102295, 0.050598145, -0.03112793, 0.041137695, 0.020324707, -0.0073623657, -0.007080078, 0.032165527, 0.0020942688, -0.007232666, 0.009689331, 0.011734009, -0.040374756, -0.038208008, -0.0050201416, 0.0026664734, -0.001408577, -0.0078125, -0.026504517, 0.016998291, -0.027496338, -0.011405945, -0.033416748, -0.019073486, 0.025253296, -0.0038375854, 0.018936157, -0.04284668, 0.04562378, 0.017913818, -0.0023288727, -0.004245758, 0.024612427, 0.017745972, -0.016784668, -0.019165039, 0.019866943, -0.070495605, -0.018936157, -0.04272461, -0.013534546, 0.019317627, -0.029205322, 0.010192871, 0.032684326, -0.04748535, 0.019805908, 0.0087890625, -0.022125244, 0.019683838, 0.0021457672, 0.0126571655, -0.02104187, 0.012191772 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07093v2
On the Effectiveness of ASR Representations in Real-world Noisy Speech Emotion Recognition
Xiaohan Shi, Jiajun He, Xingfeng Li, Tomoki Toda
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
This paper proposes an efficient attempt to noisy speech emotion recognition (NSER). Conventional NSER approaches have proven effective in mitigating the impact of artificial noise sources, such as white Gaussian noise, but are limited to non-stationary noises in real-world environments due to their complexity and uncertainty. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a new method for NSER by adopting the automatic speech recognition (ASR) model as a noise-robust feature extractor to eliminate non-vocal information in noisy speech. We first obtain intermediate layer information from the ASR model as a feature representation for emotional speech and then apply this representation for the downstream NSER task. Our experimental results show that 1) the proposed method achieves better NSER performance compared with the conventional noise reduction method, 2) outperforms self-supervised learning approaches, and 3) even outperforms text-based approaches using ASR transcription or the ground truth transcription of noisy speech.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07093v2
2023-11-14T13:09:51
2023-11-13T05:45:55
{ "title": [ 0.0062713623, 0.001156807, -0.021957397, -0.06262207, 0.0060653687, -0.0112838745, -0.02067566, 0.011077881, 0.011657715, 0.04663086, -0.022384644, -0.014205933, 0.042755127, -0.020843506, -0.04751587, 0.008377075, 0.008895874, 0.041168213, -0.0022296906, -0.026504517, 0.018753052, -0.022201538, 0.011955261, 0.022583008, 0.047851562, -0.043121338, -0.07897949, 0.019195557, -0.022781372, -0.036712646, 0.0073509216, 0.0033550262, 0.035705566, 0.037963867, -0.029891968, -0.011146545, -0.07244873, 0.03652954, 0.0053863525, -0.006919861, 0.025970459, -0.023468018, -0.008476257, -0.016418457, -0.00894165, 0.03955078, -0.038848877, -0.030426025, -0.039154053, 0.04232788, 0.0143966675, 0.035736084, -0.0015649796, 0.040405273, 0.02104187, -0.05368042, -0.04272461, 0.0129470825, 0.03265381, 0.064208984, 0.040771484, -0.024520874, -0.0007815361, 0.0025539398, -0.023345947, -0.015899658, -0.00157547, 0.025161743, 0.08081055, -0.023208618, -0.038360596, 0.030044556, 0.0061950684, -0.02418518, -0.04812622, 0.036315918, 0.0418396, 0.019165039, 0.0206604, -0.042663574, 0.01146698, 0.025863647, 0.006652832, -0.0209198, 0.0236969, -0.046936035, -0.014556885, -0.0184021, -0.041107178, -0.05026245, 0.00062704086, 0.0026550293, -0.030715942, 0.0011138916, -0.018081665, -0.036132812, 0.020431519, 0.048706055, 0.014450073, -0.041259766, 0.0025558472, 0.008354187, -0.044555664, -0.011444092, 0.010520935, -0.009338379, -0.03994751, -0.04928589, 0.028381348, 0.04058838, -0.04248047, 0.039489746, 0.013168335, -0.022216797, 0.008903503, 0.013435364, -0.023864746, 0.04055786, 0.028289795, 0.02885437, 0.0035762787, -0.029022217, 0.008041382, -0.014480591, 0.041778564, 0.0033454895, -0.045562744, -0.005706787, -0.016601562, 0.02355957, 0.018066406, 0.03753662, -0.109802246, -0.074279785, -0.070617676, 0.041809082, 0.00019478798, -0.01625061, -0.016036987, 0.014633179, 0.0017757416, -0.015571594, 0.018844604, 0.008781433, 0.02168274, 0.0060653687, 0.058441162, -0.0066947937, -0.050079346, -0.023498535, -0.0077819824, 0.009880066, 0.025024414, -0.00869751, -0.01626587, -0.012687683, -0.09790039, -0.013290405, 0.014289856, 0.009315491, 0.06750488, 0.007545471, -0.03036499, 0.07116699, 0.041137695, -0.008888245, -0.0020999908, 0.022460938, 0.012557983, 0.031311035, -0.024902344, 0.011421204, 0.027923584, 0.0020561218, -0.023727417, -0.012832642, 0.01914978, -0.0036201477, 0.03414917, -0.018249512, -0.005130768, -0.025741577, 0.00920105, 0.022842407, -0.04837036, 0.0052833557, 0.0041656494, 0.0007586479, 0.03353882, 0.002614975, -0.02015686, 0.0463562, 0.003528595, -0.027130127, -0.033721924, -0.060455322, 0.018325806, -0.00039172173, -0.005947113, 0.011505127, -0.042785645, -0.011054993, -0.022506714, 0.009536743, -0.028411865, -0.031341553, -0.018692017, 0.024261475, -0.029037476, 0.0423584, 0.054840088, 0.0017957687, -0.041046143, 0.016998291, -0.015304565, -0.0541687, 0.012886047, -0.01259613, -0.005695343, -0.03756714, -0.04321289, 0.00059223175, -0.024993896, 0.032348633, 0.03353882, 0.0013999939, -0.013755798, -0.028686523, 0.018249512, 0.012382507, 0.033050537, -0.02027893, 0.05810547, 0.031707764, 0.010658264, -0.013771057, 0.008842468, -0.0317688, 0.006767273, 0.0104599, 0.00009000301, -0.009300232, 0.00070905685, 0.04815674, 0.042938232, -0.012992859, 0.0019292831, 0.03262329, 0.008308411, 0.019760132, 0.054504395, -0.0014829636, 0.029022217, -0.055267334, -0.0020389557, 0.047454834, -0.0006837845, 0.0014705658, 0.0050468445, -0.024398804, 0.012962341, -0.009399414, -0.005153656, 0.003774643, -0.039093018, -0.006996155, -0.02798462, -0.0044403076, 0.01965332, -0.0052452087, 0.020889282, -0.051452637, 0.026107788, -0.013847351, -0.053863525, -0.025680542, 0.005180359, 0.026031494, -0.00081539154, -0.07409668, -0.013175964, -0.0006971359, 0.03390503, -0.004508972, 0.010955811, -0.019378662, 0.04284668, -0.007762909, 0.011550903, -0.011871338, 0.033416748, 0.068725586, 0.027648926, 0.010246277, 0.020095825, 0.009216309, 0.06512451, 0.057647705, -0.020111084, 0.03845215, -0.07324219, 0.025405884, 0.032928467, -0.015167236, 0.0011720657, -0.0020179749, 0.00059890747, 0.027496338, -0.019500732, 0.030441284, -0.05368042, 0.043518066, 0.016784668, 0.013587952, -0.03277588, -0.05001831, 0.0068893433, -0.017440796, -0.052978516, -0.031280518, 0.08898926, -0.026672363, -0.03338623, -0.0063476562, -0.022354126, -0.0129470825, -0.003900528, -0.035736084, -0.010917664, 0.026626587, 0.06201172, 0.03286743, -0.030517578, -0.0024261475, 0.005569458, 0.0046195984, -0.011100769, 0.003566742, -0.01687622, 0.00065135956, 0.009773254, -0.00016236305, 0.007095337, -0.026229858, -0.015533447, -0.052124023, 0.027938843, 0.0043792725, 0.004119873, 0.009124756, 0.015853882, -0.012290955, -0.025863647, 0.006565094, 0.041778564, 0.025985718, 0.00434494, 0.01586914, 0.035491943, -0.01007843, 0.03555298, 0.023132324, 0.0042037964, -0.060028076, -0.024459839, -0.041412354, -0.014770508, -0.020568848, -0.01638794, 0.043060303, -0.02760315, -0.0073127747, -0.053131104, -0.024627686, -0.0069274902, 0.016494751, -0.01083374, -0.023468018, -0.03237915, -0.025985718, -0.017715454, -0.012763977, 0.0027179718, -0.00843811, 0.07733154, 0.0062179565, -0.02104187, -0.0012264252, 0.03274536, 0.006225586, -0.012451172, -0.021224976, -0.049591064, -0.0011863708, 0.024780273, 0.005332947, -0.003250122, -0.015686035, -0.09527588, -0.006210327, 0.08905029, 0.005340576, -0.037506104, 0.05834961, -0.052947998, 0.031799316, 0.04269409, -0.0068969727, 0.03451538, -0.011276245, 0.0129776, 0.005405426, 0.013496399, -0.041046143, 0.011810303, -0.05267334, -0.10131836, 0.04031372, -0.021820068, -0.062286377, -0.015304565, -0.01637268, -0.045043945, -0.015899658, -0.007610321, 0.03289795, 0.023101807, -0.011482239, 0.013809204, -0.0029773712, 0.0070762634, -0.016479492, -0.008872986, -0.019989014, -0.029144287, 0.01651001, -0.009880066, 0.04727173, 0.024673462, -0.015777588, -0.016311646, 0.003850937, 0.0046424866, 0.04660034, 0.0032405853, -0.033111572, 0.0013618469, -0.0036525726, -0.053649902, 0.0050354004, -0.014228821, 0.027053833, -0.059143066, 0.0068740845, -0.011383057, -0.018218994, 0.01525116, 0.008102417, -0.030303955, -0.018203735, 0.0043258667, -0.018463135, -0.017349243, -0.02444458, 0.02722168, -0.0073890686, 0.014480591, -0.018463135, -0.027114868, 0.026947021, -0.013641357, 0.003080368, -0.01171875, -0.026489258, -0.0029506683, -0.020462036, -0.025009155, 0.01423645, 0.019515991, 0.013679504, -0.024642944, 0.009269714, -0.054901123, -0.06677246, -0.017333984, -0.010223389, -0.07348633, -0.022415161, 0.014923096, -0.05831909, -0.02217102, -0.048309326, 0.0033626556, -0.02003479, -0.034088135, -0.005836487, 0.002544403, -0.05819702, -0.027114868, -0.05758667, -0.0435791, 0.08856201, -0.0051193237, 0.039520264, 0.019134521, 0.013252258, -0.0055732727, -0.02709961, 0.022155762, -0.03704834, 0.025924683, -0.014350891, 0.0028877258, 0.0496521, -0.028930664, 0.010498047, 0.03439331, -0.0076179504, 0.00819397, -0.004878998, 0.013031006, 0.019332886, 0.002708435, 0.05871582, -0.006324768, -0.0209198, -0.052520752, -0.012016296, -0.015686035, 0.0069122314, 0.0076942444, -0.012176514, -0.010482788, -0.020614624, 0.031799316, 0.05947876, -0.011558533, 0.027282715, 0.021850586, -0.037475586, -0.033111572, -0.0043907166, 0.04260254, -0.0072669983, 0.0051994324, 0.03302002, 0.0070343018, 0.031341553, -0.011650085, -0.053253174, 0.023345947, 0.05041504, -0.060150146, -0.0020828247, -0.031402588, -0.0670166, -0.06100464, 0.014259338, -0.009292603, 0.04071045, 0.050872803, 0.01991272, -0.039642334, -0.008239746, 0.06274414, -0.003124237, -0.006454468, -0.072509766, 0.026901245, -0.017959595, -0.052124023, -0.036956787, -0.014633179, -0.020095825, 0.052581787, -0.010314941, -0.020095825, 0.009025574, 0.032714844, 0.08117676, 0.04144287, -0.017944336, -0.0657959, -0.005908966, -0.040618896, -0.032409668, 0.05569458, -0.012886047, -0.010520935, -0.028717041, 0.03302002, -0.02494812, -0.005264282, 0.00605011, 0.015625, -0.028045654, 0.04724121, -0.04437256, 0.015991211, 0.0070152283, 0.0011978149, 0.008277893, 0.01084137, -0.04360962, 0.00018906593, -0.023147583, 0.034484863, -0.035339355, 0.018295288, 0.03564453, 0.0095825195, -0.012329102, 0.0005545616, 0.012664795, 0.025985718, 0.00983429, -0.015899658, 0.021560669, -0.057159424, -0.041015625, -0.018875122, -0.010345459, 0.038513184, -0.057769775, 0.060668945, -0.029067993, -0.007472992, 0.0126953125, -0.00349617, 0.014480591, -0.027114868, 0.015007019, -0.0574646, -0.029754639, 0.0043640137, 0.029037476, -0.048828125, 0.0102005005, -0.015777588, -0.012908936, 0.023101807, 0.04168701, 0.006416321, 0.040283203, -0.045898438, 0.0018072128, 0.011314392, -0.054260254, -0.017059326, -0.011383057, 0.047729492, -0.0008649826, -0.061157227, 0.0012798309, -0.044677734, -0.02268982, -0.0032958984, -0.014266968, -0.013847351, -0.07092285, 0.034301758, 0.027908325, -0.0068740845, 0.024414062, -0.020111084, 0.018600464, 0.04385376, 0.016662598, 0.04147339, -0.009010315, 0.027389526, -0.058410645, 0.034423828, 0.016860962, 0.017028809, 0.0050849915, 0.028137207, 0.00730896, 0.012023926, -0.059570312, 0.022033691, 0.006877899, -0.00088596344, 0.0005478859, -0.03652954, 0.021118164, 0.026977539, -0.00983429, 0.014862061, -0.038848877, -0.028259277, 0.012245178, -0.006980896, -0.020614624, 0.0051460266, -0.008216858, -0.06878662, -0.036376953, -0.0062065125, -0.0010585785, -0.003376007, -0.0026874542, -0.000044882298, -0.052368164, 0.03353882, 0.028915405, -0.06530762, -0.017730713, 0.035736084, 0.03012085, 0.043182373, -0.026016235, -0.02418518, 0.008598328, 0.023162842, -0.032470703, -0.03829956, 0.024291992, -0.0053520203, -0.023025513, -0.0014629364, -0.034942627, -0.0051956177, -0.01890564, -0.0010871887, 0.0084991455, 0.0027008057, 0.043182373, -0.0040626526, -0.005844116, -0.0045776367, -0.002401352, 0.039215088, -0.008056641, -0.013755798, -0.06750488, -0.00995636, 0.0037956238, -0.0014705658, 0.011726379, -0.0803833, 0.0036067963, -0.0011062622, 0.0028762817, -0.009254456, 0.027420044, 0.047332764, -0.040802002, -0.001964569, 0.02003479, 0.056274414, -0.07104492, -0.027389526, -0.01285553, 0.011116028, -0.0006418228, 0.081726074, -0.052612305, -0.03277588, -0.042419434, -0.057525635, -0.02861023, 0.03567505, 0.04348755, 0.0015649796, 0.036743164, -0.06173706, 0.019805908, -0.04837036, -0.0020198822, -0.01008606, 0.022720337, -0.007820129, -0.01687622, -0.020248413, -0.0009703636, 0.010528564, -0.055725098, 0.031555176, 0.035003662, 0.012741089, 0.011528015, -0.048309326, -0.0055503845, -0.010749817, -0.059753418, 0.015914917, -0.016220093, 0.00084257126, 0.03857422, -0.044555664, 0.04864502, 0.005432129, 0.016921997, 0.01737976, 0.005554199, 0.007331848, -0.011833191, -0.03945923, -0.052215576, -0.008102417, -0.06463623, -0.0007677078, -0.051361084, 0.0030078888, -0.07836914, 0.004875183, 0.016983032, 0.031585693, 0.007091522, 0.009384155, 0.028640747, 0.0044174194, 0.028549194, -0.036346436, 0.057159424, -0.024368286, -0.007736206, -0.037628174, 0.017059326, 0.039154053, 0.028289795, 0.022491455, 0.007896423, -0.015556335, -0.019119263, 0.016555786, 0.017852783, 0.0027065277, -0.042419434, -0.00907135, -0.050750732, 0.046813965, -0.0068588257, 0.03125, 0.0513916, 0.033935547, 0.00066804886, -0.023040771, 0.006690979, -0.0035591125, -0.020706177, -0.013519287, 0.036224365, -0.090270996, 0.01864624, 0.001039505, -0.006500244, -0.023880005, 0.056549072, -0.026687622, -0.049743652, -0.030319214, 0.023635864, 0.022476196, 0.037231445, 0.040863037, -0.045013428, -0.037231445, -0.031036377, 0.012123108, -0.017913818, -0.009353638, 0.027008057, 0.028686523, -0.030044556, -0.012886047, -0.006401062, 0.021362305, -0.036193848, 0.030471802, -0.05105591, 0.04522705, -0.04852295, -0.05065918, -0.0017576218, -0.0184021, -0.048309326, -0.06536865, 0.06500244, 0.021652222, -0.007987976, 0.04788208, 0.007572174, -0.02355957, -0.03842163, -0.019577026, 0.015823364, 0.030349731, -0.025482178, 0.022949219, -0.035217285, -0.0317688, 0.02708435, -0.024429321, 0.061676025, -0.059692383, -0.011726379, -0.0362854, 0.04510498, -0.016784668, -0.036193848, -0.017288208, -0.022094727, -0.020309448, -0.014709473, 0.0096588135, -0.0059127808, -0.032348633, -0.017028809, 0.019256592, 0.013084412, 0.017501831, 0.024032593, -0.019958496, -0.05319214, -0.005622864, -0.041809082, 0.041931152, -0.044403076, -0.018539429, -0.035461426, 0.0026550293, 0.02355957, 0.03552246, -0.019821167, 0.030761719, -0.047454834, -0.038116455, 0.029144287, 0.026290894, -0.013885498, -0.015945435, 0.010696411, 0.0005054474, -0.02748108, 0.0069084167, 0.03189087, -0.02003479, -0.07543945, -0.01109314, -0.024627686, 0.03338623, 0.024536133, -0.0033664703, -0.0027065277, 0.03579712, -0.038482666, -0.0024223328, 0.027801514, 0.06112671, 0.005756378, -0.034576416, -0.009025574, 0.020339966, 0.022842407, -0.0680542, -0.07543945, 0.009521484, 0.051483154, -0.01159668, 0.031982422, 0.016464233, 0.00381279, 0.024261475, -0.016036987, 0.011070251, -0.03111267, -0.04208374, -0.015434265, 0.030685425, 0.04928589, -0.007858276, -0.010383606, 0.030471802, -0.012626648, 0.018829346, 0.016647339, -0.036315918, 0.026763916, -0.027420044, 0.03390503, -0.0090789795, 0.009628296, -0.05331421, 0.037139893, -0.009262085, 0.02798462, -0.02293396, 0.022964478, 0.012924194, 0.037628174, -0.0077209473, -0.047302246, 0.059143066, 0.0036258698, 0.032928467, -0.014595032, 0.016738892, -0.0061073303, -0.0038471222, -0.005996704, -0.0037670135, 0.016693115, 0.037261963, -0.02960205, 0.0013122559, -0.05355835, -0.0418396, -0.0413208, -0.05331421, 0.03756714, -0.038391113, 0.007751465, -0.010612488, -0.0031852722, -0.005039215, 0.018966675, 0.013168335, -0.032348633, -0.03945923, -0.019073486, 0.032043457, -0.017303467 ], "summary": [ 0.029876709, 0.024017334, -0.023147583, -0.03427124, 0.00017762184, -0.019546509, -0.040618896, -0.022567749, 0.02520752, 0.034851074, -0.008483887, -0.044189453, 0.059417725, -0.044036865, -0.00028657913, 0.0021076202, 0.010848999, 0.020858765, 0.01524353, -0.027008057, 0.022354126, -0.0070114136, -0.03842163, -0.013839722, 0.030181885, -0.045837402, 0.006919861, 0.030303955, 0.033172607, 0.023117065, 0.026153564, -0.062072754, -0.014724731, 0.06549072, -0.031555176, -0.031677246, -0.048675537, 0.043273926, 0.022247314, 0.013381958, 0.031173706, -0.0076942444, 0.034973145, -0.0067100525, -0.008415222, 0.022109985, 0.015029907, -0.0099105835, -0.010421753, 0.020431519, -0.028076172, 0.015342712, -0.03164673, -0.0038890839, -0.011581421, -0.054779053, -0.05822754, 0.048217773, -0.026351929, 0.049835205, 0.055267334, 0.044677734, 0.005844116, 0.02696228, -0.018493652, -0.008995056, 0.02482605, 0.018585205, 0.02420044, -0.072387695, -0.017578125, 0.03062439, -0.009963989, -0.074401855, -0.00035643578, 0.0748291, -0.0049438477, 0.024841309, -0.01576233, -0.010856628, -0.009315491, 0.055725098, 0.023590088, -0.0814209, 0.012756348, -0.10467529, -0.019607544, 0.009986877, -0.029067993, -0.005115509, -0.014060974, 0.032318115, -0.064208984, 0.0368042, 0.01637268, -0.023910522, 0.024719238, -0.0071144104, 0.023788452, -0.0010700226, 0.04272461, -0.05581665, 0.03955078, -0.018432617, -0.017547607, 0.00856781, -0.010101318, -0.08880615, 0.010772705, 0.008811951, -0.022064209, 0.015899658, -0.0072288513, -0.047454834, 0.012062073, 0.04650879, -0.0127334595, 0.027496338, 0.010246277, 0.023971558, -0.01033783, 0.009178162, -0.013824463, -0.0009860992, 0.022323608, 0.011100769, -0.000995636, -0.008659363, 0.0049438477, -0.03086853, -0.022506714, 0.027938843, 0.010299683, 0.00071430206, -0.02218628, 0.008384705, 0.04446411, 0.010726929, 0.015655518, -0.0413208, 0.05456543, 0.0044898987, -0.013267517, 0.041381836, 0.018508911, 0.01083374, 0.0076904297, 0.0023975372, -0.00067281723, 0.0079574585, 0.017364502, -0.011291504, 0.031341553, -0.020309448, 0.0069236755, -0.062072754, -0.0362854, -0.022521973, 0.04119873, -0.015838623, 0.064331055, -0.00074768066, 0.0039787292, 0.11126709, 0.024475098, 0.025604248, -0.014099121, 0.00374794, 0.007888794, -0.025985718, -0.008872986, 0.0011396408, 0.054382324, 0.007663727, -0.009178162, -0.002614975, -0.01701355, 0.007549286, 0.030014038, -0.031219482, 0.0045166016, -0.03781128, 0.0103302, 0.0099105835, -0.014793396, 0.012771606, 0.012741089, 0.0340271, 0.0033740997, 0.010345459, 0.008163452, 0.0033855438, 0.022277832, -0.0060768127, 0.002588272, -0.057525635, 0.013923645, -0.0078125, -0.0018482208, -0.005092621, -0.023284912, -0.0002168417, -0.018295288, -0.005744934, -0.048583984, -0.03060913, -0.0013036728, 0.021713257, -0.03744507, -0.0056610107, 0.036346436, -0.052368164, -0.02420044, 0.011177063, -0.01852417, -0.042266846, 0.016571045, -0.026428223, -0.0016822815, -0.03274536, -0.0071029663, 0.019561768, -0.042663574, 0.039398193, 0.03704834, 0.0017814636, -0.03173828, -0.01651001, 0.007987976, -0.014953613, -0.013458252, 0.028167725, -0.0045661926, 0.046783447, 0.019332886, 0.007774353, 0.038116455, -0.040771484, 0.030776978, 0.005847931, 0.03161621, 0.040100098, -0.019119263, -0.0037555695, 0.04309082, -0.047607422, -0.005657196, -0.0045394897, -0.010520935, -0.009742737, 0.0036125183, -0.003030777, 0.023513794, -0.0569458, -0.010879517, 0.025848389, -0.007850647, -0.009735107, 0.0011310577, -0.0340271, 0.018951416, -0.07928467, -0.03488159, -0.019058228, -0.016204834, -0.043426514, 0.003944397, -0.014953613, 0.03277588, -0.03845215, 0.012580872, -0.036743164, 0.018615723, -0.040496826, -0.096069336, -0.03265381, 0.02784729, 0.02609253, -0.004470825, -0.06463623, 0.009963989, 0.021453857, 0.037200928, -0.016174316, 0.022964478, -0.02178955, 0.024307251, 0.0070381165, 0.021850586, 0.055786133, 0.02949524, 0.089416504, 0.016296387, 0.042022705, 0.0045166016, 0.03744507, 0.011787415, -0.013626099, 0.009170532, -0.015289307, -0.011238098, 0.035614014, 0.02998352, -0.019317627, 0.015975952, -0.05102539, -0.03579712, 0.020507812, 0.020614624, 0.049560547, -0.097961426, 0.050109863, 0.030258179, 0.06896973, -0.03756714, -0.04269409, -0.020645142, 0.04058838, -0.01184082, -0.010848999, 0.0814209, -0.021942139, -0.021224976, 0.043395996, -0.027526855, -0.03845215, 0.07385254, -0.03213501, -0.016174316, 0.013442993, -0.0041618347, 0.018859863, 0.005859375, 0.070739746, -0.0012292862, 0.004169464, 0.018936157, -0.030014038, 0.0030574799, -0.0013980865, 0.03250122, 0.024276733, -0.017242432, 0.001701355, -0.035064697, -0.025253296, 0.0020618439, -0.014457703, -0.0011663437, 0.009017944, 0.016189575, -0.013328552, -0.034729004, 0.021026611, 0.004989624, 0.020950317, 0.04046631, 0.009094238, 0.018112183, -0.023239136, 0.048553467, 0.008514404, 0.02015686, -0.03756714, -0.021240234, -0.03643799, -0.0065841675, -0.030578613, -0.00018620491, 0.02796936, 0.011726379, 0.026489258, -0.06298828, -0.024658203, -0.03765869, 0.0040626526, 0.046966553, -0.0014533997, 0.004787445, 0.03149414, 0.032043457, -0.0071372986, 0.07055664, -0.02772522, 0.060028076, 0.008834839, 0.005504608, 0.0037612915, 0.02331543, -0.0017375946, -0.021362305, -0.02658081, -0.058654785, -0.035461426, 0.033996582, 0.019012451, 0.024917603, -0.006187439, -0.020431519, -0.042785645, 0.062286377, 0.032440186, 0.005241394, 0.03918457, 0.0058670044, 0.03225708, 0.07836914, 0.0013074875, 0.028564453, -0.07385254, 0.0008406639, -0.034484863, 0.0060577393, -0.064453125, 0.015945435, -0.040008545, -0.0013828278, 0.032440186, -0.027023315, -0.06890869, -0.03729248, 0.07110596, -0.020401001, -0.019744873, -0.005836487, 0.043640137, -0.037475586, -0.02281189, 0.0073661804, 0.022598267, -0.023635864, 0.01977539, -0.01675415, -0.017211914, -0.024215698, 0.01927185, 0.009841919, -0.0023345947, 0.041870117, -0.037628174, 0.007671356, 0.0035648346, 0.017044067, -0.005710602, 0.0071754456, -0.023117065, 0.025024414, 0.03414917, -0.026031494, 0.011672974, 0.010787964, 0.016464233, 0.005027771, 0.021469116, -0.012672424, -0.008987427, -0.005630493, 0.042541504, 0.01826477, -0.010620117, -0.0077667236, -0.032592773, 0.053710938, -0.013473511, 0.0023841858, 0.0059127808, -0.006450653, 0.012062073, -0.0138549805, -0.012283325, 0.01398468, 0.0071907043, -0.04550171, -0.029876709, 0.0006875992, -0.0546875, -0.024887085, 0.032989502, 0.043792725, 0.015808105, -0.043792725, 0.012771606, -0.056793213, -0.036254883, -0.0069007874, 0.0004684925, -0.022781372, -0.013496399, -0.0026073456, -0.022735596, -0.012962341, -0.008888245, 0.036865234, -0.0418396, -0.010406494, -0.008888245, 0.0070343018, -0.012550354, -0.029251099, -0.045532227, -0.041137695, -0.008857727, 0.022827148, 0.030914307, -0.015777588, 0.050445557, 0.04034424, 0.009414673, 0.0006146431, -0.06866455, 0.034606934, -0.047821045, 0.012451172, 0.018325806, -0.014434814, -0.019439697, 0.02760315, -0.0068855286, -0.0043411255, -0.0076293945, 0.032562256, 0.046081543, 0.008338928, 0.013290405, 0.0015306473, 0.009246826, -0.03753662, 0.0053901672, -0.03265381, -0.0027313232, -0.0020523071, 0.058013916, -0.048034668, -0.047576904, 0.05316162, -0.055511475, -0.02658081, 0.01725769, 0.029159546, 0.0093307495, -0.025421143, -0.01133728, 0.023101807, 0.026657104, -0.004753113, 0.010284424, -0.011802673, -0.002855301, 0.0013055801, -0.04159546, 0.0071983337, 0.0385437, -0.06451416, -0.010261536, 0.028015137, -0.04171753, -0.065979004, 0.0046806335, -0.00680542, 0.042266846, 0.011520386, 0.02104187, -0.005001068, -0.018127441, 0.06738281, 0.04031372, -0.0670166, -0.08483887, 0.05206299, -0.02708435, -0.03302002, -0.038848877, -0.03555298, -0.039642334, 0.008575439, -0.0017814636, -0.029815674, 0.014373779, 0.005012512, 0.04815674, 0.0284729, -0.015083313, -0.0881958, -0.050811768, -0.045684814, -0.021530151, 0.050201416, -0.038085938, -0.019104004, -0.011787415, 0.05206299, -0.028778076, -0.021270752, 0.0021877289, 0.0053901672, -0.0044517517, 0.05038452, -0.01600647, 0.016998291, 0.0007739067, -0.010223389, 0.0061798096, -0.00005429983, -0.027359009, -0.017150879, -0.03741455, 0.009742737, -0.056762695, 0.03414917, -0.0009646416, -0.013908386, -0.03942871, 0.0015926361, 0.040924072, 0.016494751, -0.02381897, 0.0063285828, 0.03967285, -0.008026123, -0.05038452, -0.008308411, 0.00057029724, -0.0054244995, -0.02998352, 0.05065918, 0.013626099, 0.0048103333, 0.009422302, -0.010986328, 0.00047945976, -0.033111572, -0.01108551, -0.018035889, 0.0017032623, 0.029037476, 0.026412964, -0.037475586, 0.0033283234, -0.058807373, -0.04257202, 0.0064315796, -0.0124435425, -0.049224854, 0.039367676, -0.062927246, 0.0023117065, -0.0046157837, -0.047698975, 0.0073890686, -0.019485474, 0.055419922, -0.008010864, -0.015808105, -0.023803711, 0.017288208, 0.0017547607, -0.028518677, 0.0007452965, -0.03338623, -0.044799805, -0.0440979, -0.043670654, -0.01222229, -0.0036087036, 0.0033569336, 0.002292633, -0.008392334, -0.0039787292, 0.009536743, -0.039276123, -0.0113220215, -0.056365967, 0.048309326, -0.025497437, 0.0055274963, 0.015396118, 0.04144287, 0.0048980713, 0.048950195, -0.06506348, -0.017837524, -0.042114258, 0.044769287, -0.019332886, -0.01096344, 0.0015592575, 0.01550293, 0.003396988, 0.026687622, 0.022537231, -0.00032138824, 0.025344849, 0.038482666, 0.009651184, -0.016799927, 0.007293701, -0.059295654, 0.045440674, -0.0055236816, 0.0023078918, -0.012710571, 0.019927979, -0.016921997, -0.023712158, 0.006374359, -0.040039062, -0.056793213, 0.002904892, 0.09466553, 0.032043457, 0.01626587, -0.046661377, -0.023666382, 0.0047073364, 0.04244995, -0.017349243, -0.022476196, 0.005332947, -0.030700684, -0.0109939575, 0.007774353, -0.0043678284, 0.038970947, -0.0413208, -0.00021231174, -0.0035552979, 0.04031372, 0.042266846, -0.0022735596, -0.0074806213, 0.006111145, -0.050323486, 0.014915466, -0.02458191, -0.012779236, -0.056121826, -0.002521515, 0.022827148, 0.014762878, -0.014091492, -0.03439331, -0.006752014, 0.028411865, -0.019226074, -0.024398804, 0.042663574, 0.0178833, -0.06225586, 0.018096924, 0.0018310547, 0.035125732, -0.02835083, -0.034820557, -0.02935791, 0.03289795, 0.017501831, 0.025360107, -0.07305908, -0.050933838, -0.000035226345, -0.048217773, 0.0046920776, -0.016326904, 0.02420044, 0.00032782555, 0.0065460205, -0.035888672, -0.010604858, -0.035614014, 0.018508911, 0.06921387, 0.024520874, -0.0037765503, -0.026763916, -0.037719727, -0.0011110306, 0.014297485, -0.042938232, 0.00920105, 0.011924744, -0.0056495667, 0.015640259, 0.013938904, 0.008613586, 0.004878998, -0.03302002, -0.010520935, -0.010185242, 0.023529053, 0.046142578, -0.050811768, 0.030776978, -0.016906738, -0.014282227, -0.022247314, -0.033325195, -0.0184021, -0.008895874, -0.07824707, -0.062805176, -0.015129089, -0.009468079, -0.027832031, -0.018875122, -0.022384644, -0.02720642, 0.022201538, 0.013366699, 0.0005941391, 0.027313232, 0.0030002594, 0.019943237, 0.011512756, -0.07458496, -0.020492554, -0.0072288513, -0.030181885, -0.03878784, -0.00459671, 0.06097412, 0.0010118484, 0.026779175, 0.046539307, -0.0034255981, -0.010032654, 0.03427124, 0.02746582, -0.031021118, -0.03982544, -0.059570312, 0.047454834, -0.026794434, 0.028793335, 0.021896362, 0.066589355, 0.0105896, -0.008041382, 0.021316528, -0.015396118, -0.003019333, 0.010795593, -0.0012750626, -0.00012397766, 0.022949219, -0.0546875, 0.010971069, 0.033599854, -0.0055389404, -0.008522034, 0.074523926, -0.015563965, 0.007167816, 0.018463135, -0.0059509277, -0.0068130493, 0.041931152, 0.047210693, -0.03250122, -0.040985107, -0.04321289, -0.019012451, 0.005039215, -0.018814087, -0.005256653, 0.019592285, -0.021087646, 0.02885437, -0.005962372, 0.010795593, -0.011482239, 0.028915405, -0.050445557, 0.051635742, -0.06222534, -0.045532227, 0.035461426, -0.028778076, -0.022094727, -0.04220581, 0.037353516, 0.06072998, -0.013130188, 0.043945312, -0.06414795, 0.0012340546, -0.001496315, 0.051818848, 0.028640747, -0.0007677078, -0.005542755, -0.0015325546, -0.024230957, -0.0039634705, -0.011123657, -0.016235352, 0.04196167, -0.056518555, -0.027679443, -0.04623413, 0.041107178, -0.068359375, -0.010688782, -0.009796143, -0.07067871, -0.030715942, -0.008476257, 0.002922058, -0.024673462, -0.013389587, -0.04837036, -0.007575989, -0.0032463074, 0.0006518364, 0.041290283, 0.010215759, -0.004611969, -0.029953003, -0.029434204, 0.02973938, -0.04660034, -0.020858765, -0.015129089, 0.014091492, 0.019714355, 0.030899048, 0.0012321472, 0.07507324, -0.040100098, -0.02760315, 0.006324768, 0.00818634, -0.023864746, -0.039978027, 0.018356323, 0.0051612854, -0.03503418, 0.01398468, 0.013404846, 0.01411438, -0.07409668, -0.019638062, 0.0058174133, -0.0029144287, -0.007160187, -0.0093307495, 0.010284424, 0.022842407, -0.061035156, 0.018249512, 0.020401001, 0.048614502, 0.02116394, -0.039093018, 0.010131836, -0.02168274, 0.018051147, -0.03692627, -0.064086914, -0.0046920776, 0.010520935, -0.016281128, 0.0024986267, 0.002565384, 0.019958496, 0.056793213, -0.0023956299, 0.008766174, -0.037902832, -0.0022697449, 0.022491455, 0.025848389, -0.013710022, -0.008911133, -0.028839111, -0.00881958, -0.02720642, 0.018585205, 0.031799316, -0.058776855, 0.0076789856, -0.025650024, -0.022155762, -0.012672424, -0.014312744, -0.053955078, 0.045013428, -0.025238037, -0.03186035, 0.0014429092, 0.026504517, -0.013839722, -0.00056648254, -0.007972717, 0.019638062, 0.018875122, -0.033843994, 0.036499023, -0.082092285, 0.05505371, 0.04208374, 0.007663727, -0.0067634583, 0.010505676, 0.022705078, 0.026031494, -0.0042533875, 0.00062036514, -0.10235596, -0.010047913, -0.07183838, -0.048431396, 0.00491333, -0.0036716461, 0.013252258, 0.044647217, -0.0017118454, 0.017944336, 0.018630981, 0.008583069, 0.0040664673, -0.0063819885, -0.022247314, 0.008880615, 0.008132935 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07092v1
To Tell The Truth: Language of Deception and Language Models
Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Sanchaita Hazra
cs.CL, cs.AI
Text-based misinformation permeates online discourses, yet evidence of people's ability to discern truth from such deceptive textual content is scarce. We analyze a novel TV game show data where conversations in a high-stake environment between individuals with conflicting objectives result in lies. We investigate the manifestation of potentially verifiable language cues of deception in the presence of objective truth, a distinguishing feature absent in previous text-based deception datasets. We show that there exists a class of detectors (algorithms) that have similar truth detection performance compared to human subjects, even when the former accesses only the language cues while the latter engages in conversations with complete access to all potential sources of cues (language and audio-visual). Our model, built on a large language model, employs a bottleneck framework to learn discernible cues to determine truth, an act of reasoning in which human subjects often perform poorly, even with incentives. Our model detects novel but accurate language cues in many cases where humans failed to detect deception, opening up the possibility of humans collaborating with algorithms and ameliorating their ability to detect the truth.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07092v1
2023-11-13T05:40:11
2023-11-13T05:40:11
{ "title": [ -0.039001465, -0.014831543, -0.039886475, -0.024414062, -0.009147644, -0.0019798279, -0.015556335, -0.014678955, -0.03164673, 0.032165527, 0.003704071, 0.012680054, 0.009986877, -0.0256958, -0.020721436, 0.009017944, -0.02381897, 0.038391113, -0.02557373, -0.03955078, -0.016464233, -0.062286377, 0.019241333, -0.040924072, 0.062683105, -0.052093506, -0.036834717, 0.0262146, -0.006904602, -0.013389587, 0.008590698, -0.016311646, 0.039916992, 0.052368164, -0.04547119, -0.025390625, -0.06365967, 0.030578613, -0.024551392, 0.029937744, 0.014778137, -0.012435913, -0.034729004, -0.011131287, -0.057891846, 0.004940033, -0.0413208, -0.006690979, -0.01701355, 0.085998535, 0.024719238, 0.014694214, -0.0107040405, 0.049194336, 0.011459351, -0.033050537, -0.038635254, 0.022659302, 0.022079468, 0.0748291, 0.021987915, -0.021591187, -0.0070152283, -0.03286743, -0.042541504, -0.020217896, -0.019363403, 0.025100708, 0.05895996, -0.0076293945, -0.0040512085, 0.008628845, 0.008590698, -0.024612427, -0.046020508, 0.04058838, 0.018051147, 0.016403198, 0.043518066, -0.04547119, 0.020019531, -0.023834229, 0.005886078, -0.0029659271, 0.012496948, -0.018722534, -0.007873535, -0.012046814, -0.032287598, -0.06097412, -0.013969421, -0.00052547455, 0.004508972, -0.0072784424, -0.03277588, -0.011756897, -0.017822266, 0.034576416, -0.028945923, -0.029678345, -0.059539795, 0.05331421, -0.097351074, -0.0011806488, 0.004917145, 0.020645142, -0.018127441, -0.011039734, 0.0054626465, 0.039367676, -0.020355225, 0.05102539, -0.0035972595, -0.0044555664, -0.0011701584, 0.014160156, -0.028930664, 0.02470398, 0.012199402, 0.03744507, 0.00032663345, -0.037994385, 0.03112793, 0.002620697, 0.026977539, 0.013473511, -0.06072998, -0.0051651, 0.0016374588, 0.027740479, 0.010536194, 0.043395996, -0.10144043, -0.08868408, -0.06213379, 0.04949951, -0.016296387, -0.0052375793, -0.033691406, 0.021102905, -0.002609253, -0.023498535, -0.0052757263, -0.010795593, -0.0099487305, 0.0067710876, 0.0635376, -0.013412476, -0.06323242, -0.042877197, -0.021636963, 0.021102905, 0.045684814, 0.007949829, -0.05960083, 0.023269653, -0.12359619, -0.0064048767, -0.011924744, 0.009925842, 0.0046844482, 0.0020008087, 0.0047950745, 0.023239136, 0.037109375, 0.008110046, 0.0034275055, 0.02078247, 0.012893677, 0.042022705, -0.0004143715, 0.026687622, -0.03652954, 0.002117157, 0.0008893013, -0.012672424, 0.006134033, 0.0050621033, 0.044006348, -0.016189575, 0.007434845, -0.007972717, 0.044158936, 0.046783447, -0.08532715, 0.006046295, 0.010520935, 0.028625488, 0.046783447, -0.0003733635, -0.0036621094, 0.04486084, -0.019592285, -0.038482666, -0.039154053, -0.03152466, 0.024612427, 0.024856567, -0.0013103485, -0.0008010864, -0.0022068024, 0.010826111, -0.040893555, 0.0036468506, -0.050231934, -0.0072402954, -0.024353027, 0.023284912, -0.019378662, 0.04324341, 0.05331421, 0.018692017, -0.052947998, 0.02482605, -0.020385742, -0.051574707, 0.011978149, 0.024108887, 0.0158844, -0.01008606, -0.011550903, -0.01473999, 0.011703491, 0.038269043, 0.014404297, -0.013687134, 0.0074043274, -0.036132812, 0.046722412, 0.024017334, 0.04852295, -0.04537964, 0.04937744, 0.031082153, -0.014030457, -0.02293396, -0.024475098, -0.006038666, -0.0010576248, 0.022918701, -0.00072288513, -0.0054512024, -0.018966675, 0.00932312, 0.052978516, -0.01625061, 0.0070877075, 0.0077285767, 0.033447266, -0.009521484, 0.074523926, -0.007156372, 0.06652832, -0.017822266, 0.022445679, 0.051818848, -0.012901306, -0.008239746, -0.006801605, 0.0041503906, 0.023544312, 0.0041503906, -0.026260376, 0.0047073364, -0.046539307, -0.0022239685, -0.0418396, -0.005519867, 0.009498596, 0.013641357, 0.029678345, -0.04824829, 0.026870728, -0.005252838, -0.014732361, -0.014228821, -0.011459351, 0.012901306, 0.0074310303, -0.060791016, 0.0032291412, 0.011634827, 0.033996582, 0.0041923523, 0.02178955, 0.017822266, 0.024414062, -0.005886078, -0.0025997162, -0.011604309, 0.036010742, 0.039520264, 0.0050354004, 0.03086853, 0.005844116, -0.0063209534, 0.07366943, 0.06072998, -0.015808105, 0.041748047, -0.052001953, 0.028625488, 0.03741455, -0.027526855, 0.013999939, 0.0045394897, 0.031280518, 0.035247803, -0.021255493, -0.007850647, -0.02746582, 0.02520752, -0.0026893616, -0.06903076, 0.0009851456, -0.017456055, 0.0060653687, -0.030319214, -0.015090942, 0.027709961, 0.059936523, -0.017501831, -0.0209198, 0.007850647, -0.0070762634, -0.020599365, 0.0030498505, -0.023788452, 0.013839722, 0.022766113, 0.053131104, 0.01525116, -0.04949951, -0.047912598, 0.008644104, 0.00066280365, -0.009338379, 0.02331543, -0.0109939575, 0.006591797, 0.008857727, -0.0052719116, 0.027542114, -0.034179688, 0.016235352, -0.06124878, 0.024291992, 0.013008118, -0.014389038, 0.00579834, 0.016571045, -0.0046806335, -0.002210617, 0.04345703, 0.07928467, -0.035003662, -0.046691895, 0.053833008, 0.016464233, -0.017623901, 0.016586304, 0.026428223, 0.0011882782, -0.05114746, -0.025405884, -0.04071045, -0.025268555, 0.00060749054, 0.0052452087, 0.043518066, -0.025680542, -0.014839172, -0.04827881, -0.012535095, 0.006137848, 0.0065345764, 0.002336502, -0.029953003, -0.008361816, -0.011367798, -0.015777588, 0.02998352, -0.034729004, 0.045410156, 0.09350586, -0.0038585663, -0.018218994, -0.0018625259, 0.04751587, 0.022491455, 0.009841919, -0.033172607, -0.03466797, -0.0072898865, 0.006214142, 0.018737793, -0.009086609, -0.025527954, -0.06878662, -0.020202637, 0.031173706, -0.00945282, -0.022262573, 0.01928711, -0.05935669, -0.007080078, -0.021896362, -0.029052734, 0.042053223, 0.041015625, -0.009422302, 0.03869629, 0.002216339, -0.010192871, -0.0054244995, -0.025512695, -0.11859131, 0.023330688, 0.001326561, -0.039093018, -0.020202637, -0.038604736, -0.02079773, 0.014556885, 0.008010864, 0.03375244, 0.034118652, -0.0043525696, 0.028518677, -0.025177002, -0.004032135, -0.014587402, -0.0256958, -0.023101807, -0.020431519, -0.011795044, 0.00085401535, 0.041137695, 0.032440186, 0.001996994, 0.01914978, -0.013298035, -0.046905518, 0.01474762, -0.012046814, -0.03451538, -0.0068893433, 0.012466431, -0.032226562, -0.033447266, -0.015579224, 0.01576233, -0.04473877, 0.011276245, 0.0015659332, 0.007911682, 0.019836426, 0.014320374, -0.030899048, -0.006187439, 0.019332886, -0.025634766, -0.049835205, 0.0005002022, 0.04031372, 0.0069618225, 0.0118637085, -0.014808655, -0.0012712479, 0.018554688, 0.010887146, -0.01550293, 0.008514404, 0.012298584, 0.0025138855, 0.031829834, -0.042297363, -0.00016307831, -0.043823242, 0.038208008, -0.0024051666, 0.0095825195, 0.012458801, -0.09790039, -0.026611328, 0.009513855, -0.13024902, -0.028640747, 0.0011854172, -0.047302246, -0.037506104, -0.03262329, 0.035827637, -0.06451416, -0.03729248, 0.0013513565, -0.021911621, -0.053894043, -0.030929565, -0.08862305, 0.011070251, 0.084106445, -0.012832642, 0.051818848, 0.043640137, -0.024642944, -0.04095459, -0.041656494, 0.020462036, 0.021270752, 0.01386261, -0.0014390945, -0.0011692047, 0.041229248, -0.029464722, 0.016311646, 0.047729492, 0.0063285828, 0.008148193, -0.008377075, 0.009277344, 0.040405273, -0.010284424, 0.031921387, 0.007537842, -0.004951477, -0.046173096, 0.023635864, -0.025024414, -0.013145447, 0.021743774, 0.005958557, 0.011497498, -0.0030460358, 0.011711121, 0.053619385, -0.020523071, 0.026031494, 0.06100464, -0.0059280396, -0.046691895, -0.022201538, 0.036468506, 0.03918457, 0.015144348, 0.0016202927, -0.0075950623, 0.016723633, 0.013931274, -0.03488159, -0.013092041, -0.00066518784, -0.039611816, 0.0037555695, -0.048583984, -0.04598999, -0.03741455, 0.006164551, -0.017745972, 0.041290283, 0.04168701, -0.016906738, -0.023925781, -0.006801605, 0.04385376, -0.010421753, 0.024307251, -0.049621582, 0.011962891, -0.02067566, -0.03643799, -0.031402588, 0.0005340576, -0.0038375854, 0.01247406, -0.008712769, -0.020217896, 0.0124435425, 0.007926941, 0.040618896, 0.044525146, -0.0005455017, -0.015434265, 0.022903442, -0.019958496, -0.021102905, 0.022644043, -0.0032997131, 0.0014009476, -0.02583313, -0.005592346, -0.018356323, -0.008773804, -0.029953003, 0.04324341, -0.028625488, 0.06561279, -0.013442993, 0.0138549805, 0.0289917, -0.005176544, 0.013404846, 0.0043678284, -0.024398804, -0.017471313, 0.03778076, 0.047729492, -0.002571106, -0.0034236908, 0.028793335, 0.019485474, 0.007286072, 0.0076293945, -0.0043182373, 0.0072021484, 0.017089844, 0.03463745, -0.010635376, -0.051361084, -0.045043945, -0.00667572, 0.012107849, 0.04714966, -0.036315918, 0.041656494, -0.054718018, -0.010559082, 0.009063721, -0.011062622, 0.031188965, -0.0043296814, 0.030517578, -0.027923584, -0.0001257658, 0.04534912, -0.017974854, -0.018539429, 0.030181885, -0.0029315948, 0.024612427, 0.010726929, 0.04437256, 0.0151901245, -0.023727417, 0.036010742, -0.020385742, -0.033203125, -0.010185242, -0.048583984, 0.016235352, 0.0033664703, 0.020645142, -0.050811768, 0.03994751, -0.07098389, 0.018417358, -0.013847351, -0.013969421, 0.022399902, -0.07824707, 0.027252197, 0.091552734, 0.011985779, 0.05206299, -0.027313232, 0.0088272095, 0.02218628, 0.066833496, -0.015945435, 0.027618408, 0.03994751, -0.037475586, -0.004650116, 0.006954193, 0.037017822, 0.00035595894, 0.025680542, 0.012992859, -0.009750366, -0.04284668, 0.004009247, -0.0072135925, -0.0024929047, 0.0340271, -0.060516357, 0.009643555, 0.023727417, 0.001288414, 0.008110046, -0.001074791, -0.06555176, -0.017822266, -0.004535675, -0.014755249, -0.008079529, -0.01222229, -0.04876709, -0.048736572, 0.0051116943, 0.005783081, 0.00944519, -0.0047836304, 0.008300781, -0.043914795, 0.027282715, 0.055236816, -0.068115234, -0.0022525787, -0.049560547, 0.011138916, 0.041259766, 0.030349731, -0.010055542, 0.0065727234, -0.033996582, -0.052001953, -0.020263672, 0.03173828, 0.015525818, 0.009292603, -0.016296387, -0.042175293, 0.004055023, 0.033355713, 0.024841309, 0.023956299, -0.031036377, 0.034423828, -0.002603531, -0.010635376, 0.0053749084, 0.0413208, -0.021133423, 0.00869751, 0.019805908, -0.04458618, 0.02784729, -0.0064849854, 0.013847351, -0.034210205, -0.04345703, 0.004611969, 0.02017212, 0.016403198, -0.006175995, 0.051086426, 0.036590576, 0.017913818, 0.018173218, 0.014823914, 0.044708252, -0.012374878, -0.0524292, 0.0027885437, -0.0008459091, -0.016494751, 0.03466797, 0.01928711, -0.038269043, -0.025222778, -0.05166626, -0.02734375, 0.016830444, 0.023422241, 0.013908386, 0.0211792, 0.01008606, 0.054840088, -0.014915466, -0.029449463, -0.022888184, 0.01737976, -0.0016555786, -0.030090332, 0.014060974, -0.005088806, 0.008399963, -0.051818848, 0.023147583, 0.044403076, 0.00831604, 0.011070251, -0.070495605, -0.0066108704, -0.019851685, -0.043518066, 0.046813965, -0.012535095, 0.007751465, 0.070495605, -0.052337646, 0.035614014, 0.03640747, 0.067871094, 0.064697266, 0.040374756, 0.030044556, 0.0047302246, -0.009506226, -0.030883789, 0.023422241, -0.032989502, -0.0063095093, -0.05718994, -0.015060425, -0.07519531, 0.017196655, -0.0016860962, 0.025848389, -0.0024471283, 0.014480591, 0.023895264, -0.015235901, 0.033233643, -0.03527832, 0.049804688, 0.003118515, 0.0043945312, 0.0041122437, -0.039642334, 0.016571045, 0.04537964, -0.005695343, -0.012763977, -0.01902771, 0.009941101, 0.0075149536, -0.00749588, -0.0013589859, -0.058746338, -0.0066223145, -0.042297363, 0.021392822, -0.014732361, 0.021072388, 0.05895996, 0.030380249, 0.0061531067, -0.02078247, -0.0021152496, -0.058685303, 0.011802673, -0.050933838, 0.010612488, -0.057373047, 0.030044556, -0.008399963, -0.021072388, -0.031951904, 0.040222168, 0.032348633, -0.041137695, -0.01763916, 0.005706787, 0.044677734, 0.003993988, 0.026107788, -0.034118652, -0.031555176, 0.0011548996, 0.052734375, -0.016296387, 0.022201538, -0.00705719, 0.039001465, -0.01360321, -0.044921875, 0.004463196, -0.013122559, -0.02281189, 0.02709961, 0.02658081, 0.004310608, 0.00087594986, -0.027023315, 0.0043792725, 0.0093688965, -0.030960083, -0.016815186, 0.018096924, 0.007949829, 0.00920105, 0.043395996, 0.024749756, -0.022705078, -0.03173828, -0.031021118, 0.0037727356, 0.041412354, -0.014205933, 0.043884277, -0.05206299, -0.038024902, 0.052215576, -0.020950317, 0.09881592, -0.024154663, -0.0030899048, -0.019958496, 0.020339966, 0.030899048, -0.038085938, -0.0017843246, -0.00409317, -0.0045204163, 0.000057280064, 0.020126343, -0.044158936, 0.0060424805, 0.0051651, -0.019577026, 0.017501831, 0.006958008, -0.0027866364, -0.025100708, -0.07647705, 0.004096985, -0.017196655, 0.02709961, -0.03050232, -0.0146865845, -0.041748047, 0.019485474, 0.010322571, -0.023590088, -0.025909424, 0.004295349, -0.039978027, -0.022583008, -0.008834839, -0.010299683, -0.021331787, 0.00059080124, 0.004623413, 0.012260437, -0.017105103, 0.025100708, 0.04058838, -0.0413208, -0.049438477, 0.0069770813, -0.029846191, 0.05480957, 0.016998291, -0.011207581, 0.046661377, 0.011985779, -0.030456543, 0.0051879883, 0.009689331, 0.039276123, 0.0020809174, -0.06402588, 0.019226074, 0.027236938, 0.049682617, -0.046783447, -0.043884277, 0.020141602, 0.028045654, -0.007701874, 0.021850586, 0.027770996, -0.015304565, 0.021362305, -0.012001038, 0.009788513, -0.04537964, -0.014877319, -0.025314331, 0.04058838, 0.054840088, -0.008331299, 0.011558533, 0.043151855, -0.014457703, 0.024032593, -0.0029659271, -0.017562866, 0.020858765, -0.009498596, 0.028656006, -0.0025138855, -0.0028820038, -0.040771484, 0.033050537, -0.022415161, 0.02885437, -0.009635925, 0.017211914, 0.00919342, 0.06536865, -0.037231445, -0.0670166, 0.04321289, 0.06072998, -0.011619568, 0.043029785, -0.043884277, -0.0041618347, -0.005962372, 0.012504578, 0.00548172, 0.032806396, 0.018936157, -0.031311035, 0.00983429, -0.038116455, -0.054229736, -0.0047950745, -0.039520264, 0.046783447, -0.022735596, 0.018173218, -0.008621216, -0.011566162, 0.0010633469, 0.034088135, 0.013801575, -0.019561768, -0.05847168, -0.051849365, 0.059753418, -0.026626587 ], "summary": [ 0.029830933, -0.00749588, -0.012741089, 0.0440979, -0.04196167, -0.034576416, 0.009819031, -0.053863525, 0.006916046, 0.020080566, -0.014831543, -0.017044067, 0.047424316, -0.02758789, -0.0029411316, -0.01184845, -0.02885437, 0.047912598, 0.008407593, -0.026290894, -0.012588501, -0.044036865, -0.011856079, -0.04559326, 0.031173706, -0.031951904, 0.06591797, -0.0015144348, 0.07269287, 0.029647827, 0.03164673, -0.07910156, 0.021759033, 0.054779053, -0.0904541, -0.03213501, -0.041046143, 0.032409668, -0.039123535, 0.05545044, 0.037994385, -0.010871887, 0.04574585, -0.0017967224, -0.0061187744, 0.011184692, 0.017990112, -0.034332275, 0.047058105, 0.04095459, -0.0093307495, 0.01398468, -0.03250122, -0.0055503845, -0.019165039, -0.023391724, -0.0020427704, 0.04055786, 0.01474762, 0.006378174, -0.021118164, 0.010070801, -0.0008277893, -0.03756714, -0.00730896, 0.013183594, 0.05682373, -0.019744873, 0.015960693, -0.00356102, 0.01979065, 0.0011901855, 0.022857666, -0.05444336, 0.025512695, 0.062561035, 0.0024318695, 0.037628174, -0.0032901764, -0.019561768, -0.027297974, 0.0021820068, 0.020324707, -0.03781128, -0.005252838, -0.023544312, -0.0110321045, 0.001698494, -0.043304443, -0.038116455, -0.036834717, 0.013023376, -0.047027588, -0.029205322, -0.015701294, -0.04711914, 0.02470398, 0.051361084, -0.04940796, -0.025299072, -0.039886475, 0.017730713, -0.061645508, -0.0126571655, -0.0016841888, 0.00023126602, 0.017166138, -0.03414917, -0.010673523, 0.0018968582, -0.028381348, 0.029205322, -0.035186768, -0.06021118, -0.0099487305, 0.0625, -0.009552002, 0.008644104, 0.01209259, 0.0067710876, 0.00680542, 0.026260376, -0.010414124, 0.024047852, 0.0045166016, 0.021072388, 0.0021953583, -0.023925781, -0.025634766, 0.038757324, -0.01637268, 0.025543213, -0.02319336, -0.048431396, -0.061645508, -0.016052246, 0.016326904, -0.0009288788, -0.007282257, -0.0063705444, 0.03503418, -0.008140564, -0.0005226135, 0.031677246, -0.021499634, 0.0046539307, 0.040222168, 0.007701874, -0.04421997, -0.02935791, 0.0012693405, 0.037506104, 0.0435791, -0.032409668, -0.004512787, -0.061309814, -0.035858154, -0.015945435, 0.032806396, -0.008804321, 0.0107040405, -0.00869751, 0.0008993149, 0.011123657, -0.020187378, 0.007545471, -0.015083313, 0.0075912476, -0.0022907257, -0.038726807, -0.0014066696, 0.034851074, -0.01966858, -0.011222839, 0.014831543, -0.014701843, 0.009292603, 0.019165039, -0.0050315857, 0.03390503, 0.037872314, -0.020309448, 0.03152466, 0.014503479, -0.07122803, 0.05178833, 0.0005083084, 0.086364746, 0.042755127, 0.013282776, 0.014411926, 0.0065345764, 0.0107803345, -0.045135498, -0.032562256, 0.002325058, -0.028900146, 0.019958496, -0.023773193, 0.036071777, 0.05859375, 0.027999878, -0.03250122, -0.024673462, -0.14038086, 0.010391235, -0.03781128, 0.035980225, 0.006717682, 0.0107040405, 0.024490356, -0.0030918121, -0.038391113, 0.04888916, -0.02859497, -0.06011963, -0.0025291443, -0.011634827, 0.015991211, -0.028411865, 0.025177002, 0.0073394775, -0.023422241, 0.014266968, 0.0040626526, -0.004951477, 0.012504578, -0.0077819824, 0.09674072, 0.00969696, 0.106933594, -0.063964844, 0.039855957, 0.03010559, -0.017791748, -0.002910614, -0.018035889, -0.08905029, -0.0029525757, 0.0569458, 0.038085938, 0.06945801, -0.03515625, -0.06665039, 0.02746582, -0.056518555, -0.0019426346, -0.045898438, 0.030136108, 0.02267456, -0.011505127, -0.052642822, 0.04144287, -0.0368042, 0.003501892, 0.022659302, -0.011505127, 0.009162903, -0.008407593, 0.019439697, -0.020874023, -0.012039185, 0.027786255, -0.027511597, -0.0050468445, -0.05331421, -0.030975342, -0.05508423, 0.010871887, -0.03161621, 0.02116394, -0.06793213, 0.017654419, -0.02394104, -0.00945282, -0.010505676, -0.03201294, 0.004535675, 0.068115234, -0.021362305, 0.0031757355, -0.025939941, -0.031021118, -0.0067596436, 0.071899414, 0.027297974, -0.01322937, -0.008621216, 0.04071045, 0.041870117, 0.021102905, 0.05697632, -0.013298035, 0.07348633, -0.013214111, 0.0024337769, -0.00089359283, -0.010665894, 0.036987305, -0.04168701, 0.0061569214, 0.040618896, -0.025421143, 0.024536133, 0.029525757, 0.016693115, 0.037963867, 0.033966064, 0.01222229, -0.004501343, -0.039520264, -0.017990112, 0.036132812, -0.022918701, 0.02267456, 0.0027694702, -0.034179688, 0.036834717, -0.032073975, 0.01889038, 0.095947266, -0.013504028, -0.020828247, 0.016677856, -0.026672363, -0.026031494, 0.037322998, -0.03253174, -0.014434814, -0.000995636, 0.009544373, -0.022277832, -0.017974854, 0.036743164, 0.007686615, -0.0043258667, 0.005367279, -0.047912598, -0.010429382, -0.0039253235, 0.0184021, 0.018035889, 0.012176514, -0.030853271, -0.05038452, -0.005279541, 0.010421753, 0.002456665, -0.026138306, -0.02796936, 0.027267456, -0.014701843, 0.011650085, 0.054138184, 0.05718994, -0.020187378, -0.041137695, 0.033355713, 0.0039138794, -0.023422241, 0.013580322, 0.05871582, 0.00040602684, -0.060272217, -0.07696533, -0.008010864, 0.0345459, -0.0053482056, 0.050811768, 0.031829834, 0.03918457, 0.024719238, -0.030838013, -0.0029506683, 0.0026226044, -0.031982422, 0.01474762, -0.04425049, 0.01739502, 0.008262634, -0.009986877, 0.026290894, 0.020629883, 0.08843994, 0.06524658, -0.0017528534, -0.0050239563, 0.016082764, 0.023590088, 0.011558533, -0.005683899, -0.02217102, 0.010795593, -0.044677734, 0.010246277, 0.011940002, 0.030776978, 0.02659607, 0.017837524, -0.043304443, -0.011726379, 0.011199951, 0.011695862, -0.0028324127, -0.01473999, 0.01424408, -0.017425537, -0.017608643, 0.035736084, -0.023040771, 0.05230713, -0.017791748, 0.03665161, -0.014091492, 0.0004901886, -0.05731201, -0.00793457, 0.000647068, -0.0029392242, -0.017425537, -0.02355957, 0.043823242, -0.019836426, -0.0128479, 0.015930176, 0.06616211, -0.013214111, -0.019943237, 0.005138397, 0.01058197, 0.021560669, -0.0069503784, -0.0050239563, -0.030853271, -0.021957397, -0.00944519, -0.020324707, -0.00043344498, 0.007472992, -0.024353027, -0.000014066696, -0.015716553, -0.05630493, -0.009307861, -0.014793396, -0.017044067, -0.017120361, -0.028182983, -0.017623901, -0.034851074, -0.030044556, 0.017150879, 0.043945312, 0.037322998, 0.0059928894, -0.004673004, 0.012306213, 0.03652954, 0.049926758, -0.020309448, 0.030456543, 0.0007510185, -0.07281494, 0.027542114, 0.03475952, 0.009269714, -0.021606445, 0.016647339, -0.02017212, 0.015716553, 0.037841797, -0.019119263, -0.020187378, -0.0053482056, 0.0028934479, -0.002325058, -0.014404297, 0.0027637482, 0.03286743, 0.0051231384, -0.023986816, 0.0070877075, -0.01335907, -0.07751465, -0.024887085, -0.006298065, -0.07562256, -0.0069618225, 0.0082092285, -0.025634766, 0.0026683807, -0.027328491, 0.04727173, -0.070617676, -0.031097412, -0.0024795532, -0.026504517, 0.05996704, -0.03253174, -0.0574646, 0.027542114, -0.029464722, 0.021957397, 0.0597229, -0.009162903, 0.014755249, 0.01727295, -0.0098724365, 0.00390625, 0.01550293, -0.0093307495, -0.02784729, -0.042907715, -0.017166138, -0.010261536, -0.016571045, 0.04156494, -0.055633545, 0.014823914, -0.0023670197, 0.054260254, 0.085754395, -0.020370483, 0.0127334595, 0.010597229, -0.021636963, -0.037231445, -0.0048675537, -0.023666382, -0.042663574, 0.04574585, 0.012016296, -0.019195557, 0.014404297, 0.02432251, 0.049713135, -0.03829956, 0.0054512024, 0.04525757, 0.05227661, -0.05923462, -0.038238525, 0.017349243, 0.097961426, 0.010238647, 0.013725281, -0.029281616, -0.011802673, 0.05722046, -0.013809204, -0.013702393, -0.026626587, -0.035369873, -0.03665161, -0.014320374, -0.0054092407, -0.012931824, 0.009178162, 0.0045204163, 0.023773193, 0.02772522, -0.008384705, 0.016098022, -0.039276123, 0.026046753, 0.011711121, -0.03302002, -0.09082031, -0.04623413, -0.02204895, -0.0021381378, 0.004146576, -0.051330566, -0.05581665, -0.011047363, 0.0055351257, -0.016204834, 0.019622803, 0.0012283325, 0.037261963, 0.017089844, 0.028778076, -0.021850586, 0.025817871, -0.03338623, 0.009895325, 0.009788513, -0.014320374, -0.020217896, -0.01020813, -0.00013959408, 0.01033783, -0.029281616, -0.030410767, 0.024627686, 0.008140564, 0.04498291, -0.0011692047, 0.01914978, 0.027297974, -0.011619568, 0.00052547455, -0.011474609, 0.011917114, 0.03744507, 0.03665161, 0.023147583, 0.026626587, -0.009056091, -0.044036865, 0.0046691895, 0.0023460388, -0.0025310516, 0.025390625, -0.02760315, -0.009880066, 0.030303955, 0.012619019, -0.0035705566, -0.040222168, 0.021362305, -0.006919861, -0.0014352798, 0.020233154, 0.007419586, -0.031951904, -0.053100586, 0.004852295, 0.018981934, -0.004699707, 0.027923584, -0.008743286, 0.012535095, 0.005695343, 0.06896973, -0.00349617, -0.0013113022, 0.014190674, -0.051727295, -0.0049743652, 0.029846191, 0.0012969971, -0.028213501, -0.059692383, 0.046539307, -0.01322937, -0.028396606, 0.0057411194, -0.022369385, -0.028121948, 0.01083374, 0.030288696, -0.03717041, 0.06085205, 0.03475952, 0.029312134, -0.025619507, -0.00006622076, 0.0006117821, -0.040008545, -0.027648926, 0.012367249, 0.000082075596, 0.010948181, -0.0104599, -0.04156494, -0.058288574, 0.011367798, -0.059020996, -0.0047340393, -0.0038585663, -0.06173706, 0.004787445, -0.009963989, 0.015533447, 0.044189453, -0.007045746, 0.023620605, -0.001253128, -0.0010061264, -0.024261475, -0.036987305, 0.048980713, -0.00856781, -0.023590088, 0.031021118, 0.018234253, -0.0053215027, -0.023773193, 0.036468506, -0.05822754, -0.022644043, -0.00061035156, -0.002111435, -0.036956787, -0.01637268, -0.030075073, -0.035858154, -0.027175903, -0.00053310394, 0.01486969, -0.017364502, 0.022659302, -0.03262329, -0.01751709, 0.039611816, -0.041168213, 0.02947998, -0.01663208, 0.01751709, 0.018417358, 0.004081726, -0.015541077, -0.018981934, -0.0052337646, -0.0030345917, 0.011146545, 0.00712204, 0.0075035095, 0.029190063, -0.018844604, -0.005252838, 0.016235352, 0.0000054836273, 0.019607544, 0.008460999, -0.035705566, 0.0055007935, -0.030532837, -0.05404663, 0.020706177, 0.004096985, -0.04800415, 0.01234436, 0.032989502, -0.08911133, 0.02519226, 0.010658264, 0.036132812, -0.06585693, -0.08282471, 0.0045700073, 0.026626587, 0.018127441, 0.013160706, 0.02746582, 0.0029392242, 0.05154419, 0.030456543, 0.016036987, 0.03677368, 0.0011758804, -0.011985779, -0.030197144, 0.0022716522, -0.038085938, -0.009742737, 0.0021076202, -0.004486084, -0.006324768, -0.049926758, 0.015930176, -0.0046539307, -0.0069618225, 0.02909851, 0.010429382, 0.020980835, 0.067993164, 0.024734497, -0.056854248, -0.023345947, -0.022705078, 0.0055236816, 0.0035514832, 0.087646484, -0.01838684, -0.02935791, 0.012763977, -0.014579773, 0.03765869, 0.022994995, 0.044555664, -0.008872986, -0.01247406, -0.03604126, 0.014328003, 0.032318115, 0.021118164, -0.008804321, 0.025314331, 0.018951416, 0.028701782, 0.041290283, 0.029571533, 0.026779175, 0.030044556, 0.04547119, 0.0060310364, -0.047729492, -0.0043182373, 0.012039185, -0.010360718, -0.017684937, -0.03302002, -0.025970459, -0.018310547, 0.06878662, -0.04055786, -0.010154724, 0.035858154, 0.008712769, 0.056396484, 0.012489319, -0.026931763, -0.06665039, 0.0028419495, -0.029129028, -0.015274048, 0.011550903, -0.048095703, 0.010108948, 0.044281006, -0.005264282, -0.001739502, 0.027832031, 0.009513855, 0.028167725, -0.03842163, -0.020767212, -0.1027832, 0.015197754, -0.043884277, 0.058776855, 0.03744507, 0.05883789, 0.020843506, -0.005970001, -0.005519867, -0.028503418, 0.012435913, -0.015113831, -0.0021839142, -0.02822876, -0.0033683777, 0.015419006, 0.00056123734, -0.014472961, -0.02809143, 0.00043201447, 0.036865234, 0.064697266, -0.008422852, 0.011001587, 0.024963379, 0.009468079, -0.02305603, 0.005355835, -0.02180481, -0.045837402, -0.02229309, 0.017700195, -0.0026187897, 0.03112793, -0.023025513, 0.047943115, 0.009918213, 0.015823364, -0.014953613, -0.02684021, -0.025924683, 0.016967773, 0.028625488, 0.03805542, 0.0064048767, -0.010437012, 0.0012540817, 0.03439331, -0.044128418, 0.0074806213, 0.041412354, 0.028335571, 0.0007390976, 0.015045166, -0.020507812, -0.013725281, 0.023040771, 0.022460938, -0.011413574, 0.030334473, 0.0054359436, 0.022888184, -0.033843994, -0.0033817291, 0.04623413, 0.016815186, 0.115722656, -0.04208374, -0.0075798035, -0.014457703, -0.040252686, -0.010673523, 0.010070801, 0.026412964, -0.07537842, 0.0020599365, 0.027145386, 0.0259552, -0.09490967, 0.009216309, 0.012313843, -0.058776855, 0.009796143, 0.00058603287, 0.007904053, 0.0013561249, -0.012451172, -0.004802704, -0.00415802, 0.043029785, -0.0000150203705, -0.028076172, -0.03152466, 0.038360596, 0.025482178, -0.049591064, -0.036010742, 0.03668213, 0.021011353, -0.0340271, -0.004207611, -0.0045433044, -0.016860962, -0.008659363, 0.020828247, 0.006259918, -0.011817932, 0.018188477, 0.030380249, 0.029327393, -0.090148926, -0.011627197, -0.039001465, -0.006362915, -0.026550293, -0.01777649, 0.03189087, 0.011497498, -0.04156494, -0.03778076, -0.034484863, -0.023239136, 0.009666443, -0.038208008, -0.00687027, 0.0042266846, 0.02961731, -0.032073975, -0.03567505, 0.021499634, 0.05758667, 0.009101868, -0.06878662, 0.016540527, -0.006549835, 0.02029419, -0.019515991, -0.005748749, -0.022338867, -0.011856079, 0.024230957, 0.041809082, 0.0029144287, -0.030212402, 0.013031006, 0.018920898, -0.06744385, -0.0054740906, -0.03173828, -0.0068855286, -0.020599365, -0.00340271, 0.013679504, -0.014503479, 0.015777588, -0.060760498, 0.031188965, -0.025466919, -0.030761719, 0.0076675415, 0.017837524, -0.017959595, 0.002210617, -0.008338928, -0.049713135, -0.015991211, 0.026901245, -0.0045547485, 0.0073890686, -0.011543274, -0.03375244, 0.008560181, -0.015991211, -0.0040626526, -0.017028809, 0.02003479, -0.024841309, -0.016860962, -0.064208984, -0.0068626404, -0.017059326, -0.034851074, 0.033935547, 0.0010585785, 0.0006928444, 0.0034065247, 0.012565613, 0.035888672, 0.02178955, 0.026550293, 0.01424408, 0.0068473816, 0.006023407, 0.016662598, -0.006034851 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07076v1
On the Discussion of Large Language Models: Symmetry of Agents and Interplay with Prompts
Qineng Wang, Zihao Wang, Ying Su, Yangqiu Song
cs.CL
Two ways has been discussed to unlock the reasoning capability of a large language model. The first one is prompt engineering and the second one is to combine the multiple inferences of large language models, or the multi-agent discussion. Theoretically, this paper justifies the multi-agent discussion mechanisms from the symmetry of agents. Empirically, this paper reports the empirical results of the interplay of prompts and discussion mechanisms, revealing the empirical state-of-the-art performance of complex multi-agent mechanisms can be approached by carefully developed prompt engineering. This paper also proposes a scalable discussion mechanism based on conquer and merge, providing a simple multi-agent discussion solution with simple prompts but state-of-the-art performance.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07076v1
2023-11-13T04:56:48
2023-11-13T04:56:48
{ "title": [ -0.022888184, -0.0063438416, -0.035949707, -0.035003662, -0.016601562, -0.022750854, -0.0368042, 0.005657196, -0.02444458, 0.031921387, -0.041931152, 0.0033988953, 0.0206604, -0.018203735, -0.008766174, -0.009422302, -0.0055389404, 0.046081543, -0.010734558, -0.0262146, -0.010810852, -0.038238525, -0.0018424988, 0.023345947, 0.061523438, -0.04776001, -0.07421875, 0.011154175, -0.007949829, -0.014884949, 0.015281677, 0.0027332306, 0.025665283, 0.032989502, -0.02104187, 0.013305664, -0.022506714, 0.031311035, 0.009864807, -0.0028800964, 0.029586792, -0.029312134, -0.0066833496, 0.00042271614, -0.02255249, 0.022644043, -0.02822876, -0.017684937, 0.0118255615, 0.037597656, -0.006706238, 0.021530151, -0.00022041798, 0.017684937, -0.010269165, -0.043701172, -0.026412964, 0.018341064, 0.032714844, 0.02609253, 0.0003478527, -0.016662598, 0.019424438, -0.02609253, 0.004886627, -0.014251709, -0.05480957, 0.028198242, 0.041870117, 0.046325684, -0.0025634766, -0.02268982, 0.0035266876, -0.029174805, -0.041748047, 0.033813477, -0.0012102127, 0.00970459, 0.052581787, -0.04937744, 0.0028476715, 0.016342163, -0.0025463104, -0.036712646, 0.0053138733, -0.045684814, -0.017822266, 0.00060653687, -0.025115967, -0.06414795, -0.0059928894, -0.0045661926, -0.022079468, -0.013496399, -0.02758789, -0.046783447, -0.011741638, 0.027740479, 0.0019931793, -0.02116394, -0.026641846, 0.018722534, -0.055541992, -0.013916016, 0.009902954, 0.018112183, -0.019210815, 0.014144897, 0.028152466, 0.04763794, -0.022216797, 0.026855469, 0.02848816, -0.0001758337, 0.008911133, -0.050811768, -0.04244995, 0.05709839, 0.020706177, 0.038970947, -0.014976501, -0.023071289, 0.04525757, -0.008094788, 0.032562256, 0.011222839, -0.032470703, -0.0256958, 0.0006093979, 0.004825592, 0.02204895, 0.06756592, -0.10040283, -0.0791626, -0.078186035, 0.046295166, -0.014732361, -0.015701294, -0.035095215, 0.024780273, 0.031799316, -0.03466797, 0.03289795, 0.0103302, -0.004383087, 0.0004479885, 0.050689697, 0.013504028, -0.03463745, -0.064819336, 0.007068634, 0.016220093, -0.0039253235, 0.0102005005, -0.008300781, -0.0010433197, -0.10253906, 0.015388489, 0.051696777, 0.043884277, -0.037261963, 0.016815186, 0.043762207, -0.031311035, 0.0012836456, -0.01914978, 0.007522583, 0.014907837, 0.016143799, 0.06021118, -0.0004851818, 0.028305054, 0.020690918, 0.012954712, 0.0032424927, -0.008178711, -0.0011377335, -0.02394104, -0.00005733967, -0.007949829, 0.0008740425, -0.026062012, -0.048431396, 0.040618896, -0.04574585, -0.033203125, -0.030685425, -0.018859863, 0.076171875, -0.0021152496, -0.0335083, -0.003042221, -0.05001831, 0.006954193, -0.04171753, -0.0137786865, 0.025009155, 0.025177002, -0.0023612976, 0.008743286, -0.029510498, 0.011268616, -0.03945923, 0.023864746, -0.029907227, -0.025054932, -0.011352539, 0.016418457, 0.04043579, 0.050476074, 0.025115967, 0.024765015, -0.046051025, 0.041931152, -0.027145386, -0.028198242, 0.015640259, -0.011360168, -0.00007843971, -0.011474609, 0.0058898926, -0.002544403, 0.0049209595, 0.029052734, -0.0019235611, 0.0028018951, 0.0013666153, -0.004714966, 0.014945984, 0.02619934, 0.02720642, -0.02696228, 0.008453369, 0.07696533, 0.0034103394, -0.05178833, -0.01473999, -0.06817627, 0.055480957, 0.03012085, -0.0076789856, -0.041534424, 0.0019664764, 0.034332275, -0.021896362, -0.019989014, 0.027496338, -0.007797241, 0.048919678, 0.06573486, 0.017318726, -0.013748169, 0.029251099, 0.0061531067, 0.026290894, 0.032684326, -0.009063721, -0.014335632, -0.019073486, 0.017547607, 0.03277588, 0.016204834, -0.016448975, 0.0209198, -0.06341553, 0.0014858246, -0.06390381, -0.02319336, -0.0048103333, 0.0046463013, 0.04156494, -0.046325684, 0.01335907, -0.025360107, 0.004535675, -0.010902405, -0.03918457, 0.03652954, 0.025344849, -0.047088623, -0.0027923584, 0.039733887, 0.0524292, -0.0048599243, -0.005645752, 0.017303467, 0.034484863, -0.008094788, 0.0053749084, 0.017349243, 0.05480957, 0.029083252, 0.014961243, 0.021484375, 0.010879517, -0.011131287, 0.061828613, 0.068725586, -0.01713562, -0.003929138, -0.042938232, 0.003288269, -0.015411377, 0.008735657, 0.028579712, -0.008605957, 0.06707764, -0.011138916, -0.034118652, 0.014328003, -0.057373047, -0.009414673, 0.013908386, 0.023773193, -0.014816284, -0.021408081, 0.0138549805, 0.01977539, 0.000090539455, -0.01737976, 0.07550049, -0.017791748, -0.019378662, -0.027450562, -0.01637268, -0.028823853, -0.03543091, -0.029571533, -0.008026123, -0.0234375, 0.010154724, -0.05657959, -0.074645996, -0.050628662, 0.009246826, 0.026977539, -0.012420654, 0.015853882, -0.012908936, 0.017288208, -0.0053710938, -0.036743164, 0.0036087036, -0.04486084, 0.032165527, -0.081604004, 0.003665924, -0.0060195923, 0.01940918, -0.002735138, 0.015136719, 0.005466461, 0.013763428, 0.0060310364, 0.06970215, -0.027694702, -0.045806885, 0.04925537, 0.028625488, -0.010559082, 0.03729248, 0.023162842, 0.011787415, -0.033843994, -0.0048675537, -0.064697266, -0.035736084, -0.0068359375, 0.0057868958, 0.009742737, -0.02104187, -0.03955078, -0.015609741, 0.005264282, 0.031143188, -0.0017976761, -0.0027103424, -0.026351929, 0.009544373, 0.0019378662, -0.026443481, 0.010551453, -0.010414124, 0.04269409, 0.124694824, 0.01084137, 0.026626587, 0.024627686, 0.04473877, -0.0058631897, -0.01939392, -0.042816162, -0.023529053, -0.007205963, 0.00687027, 0.003917694, -0.06365967, -0.043762207, -0.06750488, 0.032958984, 0.0657959, -0.019012451, -0.009887695, 0.024108887, -0.055755615, 0.035888672, -0.004436493, 0.017440796, 0.047454834, -0.04928589, 0.015899658, -0.022079468, 0.036743164, -0.08068848, -0.008659363, -0.042816162, -0.09631348, 0.013008118, -0.03363037, 0.0036754608, 0.018447876, -0.045959473, -0.025527954, 0.003698349, -0.0146102905, 0.05307007, 0.014976501, 0.008117676, -0.010726929, -0.016326904, -0.0018367767, -0.024368286, -0.025177002, 0.01348114, -0.011711121, 0.048339844, 0.012199402, 0.0017995834, 0.032958984, -0.008758545, -0.02619934, -0.026824951, -0.0496521, -0.0031929016, -0.018630981, -0.022277832, -0.016693115, -0.018035889, -0.03982544, 0.002904892, -0.031188965, 0.028930664, -0.04727173, 0.012748718, -0.0209198, -0.0041618347, 0.00819397, 0.027542114, -0.02104187, -0.021453857, 0.022979736, -0.0066108704, -0.071777344, 0.0007214546, 0.01322937, 0.010635376, 0.012039185, 0.008605957, -0.035614014, 0.018310547, 0.0154800415, -0.001159668, 0.002418518, -0.002254486, -0.0017118454, -0.014076233, -0.001080513, 0.00566864, -0.020080566, -0.018692017, -0.015266418, 0.020904541, -0.008361816, -0.06933594, -0.047973633, 0.023406982, -0.1116333, -0.043670654, 0.02494812, -0.01676941, -0.032287598, -0.02319336, 0.043060303, -0.034118652, 0.0012788773, 0.0079574585, -0.025878906, -0.015701294, 0.012123108, -0.048553467, 0.0035991669, 0.057128906, -0.008613586, -0.00082969666, 0.06677246, -0.024093628, -0.023788452, -0.0031337738, 0.040771484, 0.08843994, 0.015602112, 0.036895752, -0.02897644, 0.038024902, -0.03277588, 0.03677368, 0.03314209, -0.0413208, 0.013725281, 0.0236969, 0.007270813, 0.042236328, -0.013755798, 0.040893555, 0.021118164, 0.000067174435, -0.059753418, 0.022506714, 0.008735657, -0.029418945, 0.026824951, -0.036315918, 0.031143188, 0.061798096, -0.0076026917, 0.070007324, 0.004459381, 0.003189087, 0.032989502, 0.0042762756, -0.021240234, -0.02268982, -0.00497818, 0.005531311, 0.009269714, 0.029434204, 0.0050735474, 0.062683105, 0.0007009506, 0.024963379, -0.014167786, -0.003768921, -0.03945923, 0.0034751892, -0.04034424, -0.07952881, -0.0519104, 0.022827148, 0.0054512024, 0.04360962, 0.050872803, 0.012275696, -0.015991211, -0.028869629, 0.050842285, -0.009895325, 0.0060310364, -0.058258057, 0.011505127, -0.030075073, -0.076171875, -0.05215454, -0.03817749, 0.009735107, 0.012756348, 0.025024414, -0.034362793, 0.031158447, 0.0055236816, 0.039978027, 0.040374756, -0.023956299, -0.048614502, 0.0335083, -0.03567505, -0.024612427, 0.013366699, 0.019439697, -0.010810852, -0.030166626, 0.023208618, -0.024353027, -0.011711121, -0.046844482, 0.04135132, -0.016403198, 0.046844482, -0.018585205, 0.0069770813, 0.01574707, 0.014129639, -0.011833191, -0.004875183, -0.026733398, 0.043640137, -0.008285522, 0.01689148, 0.025863647, 0.00077581406, 0.026916504, 0.044830322, 0.0056381226, -0.014450073, -0.0032215118, 0.0016727448, 0.0056381226, 0.012374878, -0.012321472, -0.045959473, -0.023269653, -0.0041656494, -0.0024204254, 0.04119873, -0.021514893, 0.0256958, -0.05731201, -0.022994995, -0.008476257, -0.011054993, 0.042938232, 0.01210022, 0.026519775, -0.022125244, -0.035827637, 0.013534546, 0.021728516, -0.010017395, 0.01008606, -0.014892578, -0.007347107, 0.027175903, 0.039093018, 0.024490356, -0.03564453, 0.0021133423, -0.021896362, -0.019012451, 0.0017004013, -0.03942871, -0.04348755, -0.0541687, -0.0043411255, 0.0028324127, 0.039489746, -0.034729004, -0.0050239563, -0.051757812, -0.03390503, 0.04171753, -0.04534912, 0.015731812, 0.10003662, -0.0132751465, 0.066711426, 0.021316528, 0.015640259, 0.010864258, 0.04031372, -0.008102417, 0.03842163, 0.028823853, -0.04675293, -0.0053253174, -0.0071487427, 0.025497437, 0.005569458, 0.018310547, 0.02394104, 0.017211914, -0.05227661, 0.015174866, 0.021392822, -0.00067710876, 0.03086853, -0.05392456, 0.043884277, 0.012756348, -0.02168274, 0.011489868, -0.043548584, -0.08062744, -0.056671143, -0.009757996, -0.051757812, 0.007801056, -0.013069153, -0.04385376, -0.032073975, 0.03338623, -0.028961182, -0.016143799, 0.015151978, -0.020050049, -0.044403076, 0.031829834, 0.03390503, -0.058135986, 0.017303467, -0.029418945, -0.0066604614, 0.030395508, 0.049957275, -0.022827148, -0.020111084, 0.00087594986, -0.033813477, 0.007156372, 0.009529114, -0.0056991577, 0.008094788, -0.029190063, -0.017120361, -0.0010871887, -0.027496338, 0.019363403, -0.017929077, -0.019012451, -0.00818634, -0.031951904, -0.012870789, 0.018051147, 0.036499023, 0.027832031, -0.016067505, -0.0066337585, -0.07318115, 0.04824829, -0.023361206, 0.026031494, -0.0025100708, -0.03857422, 0.01689148, 0.02456665, 0.00007367134, -0.03567505, 0.04208374, 0.030639648, -0.0035572052, -0.0037136078, 0.013969421, 0.044525146, -0.025421143, -0.02406311, -0.026672363, -0.0011491776, -0.048980713, 0.04623413, 0.010108948, -0.0006637573, -0.038085938, -0.054656982, -0.036743164, 0.011749268, 0.03866577, 0.0032787323, 0.02835083, -0.034484863, -0.009681702, -0.04321289, -0.005054474, -0.045928955, 0.038085938, -0.024414062, -0.033996582, 0.016494751, -0.010147095, -0.027511597, 0.033325195, 0.02482605, 0.043029785, -0.024795532, 0.03744507, -0.031707764, -0.005710602, -0.008163452, -0.04473877, 0.056396484, -0.014801025, -0.006336212, 0.048065186, -0.017807007, 0.044555664, 0.03314209, 0.08001709, 0.025268555, 0.0025997162, 0.03161621, 0.03225708, 0.05621338, -0.030395508, 0.028076172, -0.060272217, 0.024917603, -0.04321289, -0.017791748, -0.05834961, -0.03012085, 0.024780273, 0.026947021, 0.0184021, -0.0029582977, 0.004486084, -0.00894928, 0.016784668, 0.020126343, 0.054229736, -0.020751953, 0.0047454834, -0.013626099, -0.035949707, 0.039855957, 0.042633057, 0.0132751465, -0.010734558, -0.0002901554, -0.031707764, 0.024032593, 0.009315491, 0.007637024, -0.025238037, -0.0070114136, -0.02947998, -0.040100098, -0.014381409, -0.010726929, 0.030288696, -0.003929138, 0.02281189, 0.004512787, -0.0068626404, -0.005847931, -0.047943115, 0.028793335, 0.017288208, -0.026504517, 0.019210815, -0.014595032, -0.025970459, -0.03842163, 0.04434204, 0.019500732, -0.031311035, 0.011474609, 0.0021858215, 0.016174316, -0.007396698, 0.039611816, -0.0423584, -0.03164673, -0.020355225, 0.0060691833, 0.010345459, 0.023880005, 0.0017995834, 0.020736694, -0.0076065063, -0.05279541, 0.0055007935, -0.02142334, -0.025634766, 0.019119263, 0.053588867, 0.05883789, -0.007789612, -0.03652954, -0.0033416748, 0.026412964, -0.08380127, 0.008628845, -0.009307861, 0.052490234, 0.027999878, 0.09350586, 0.025878906, -0.00083494186, -0.011856079, -0.016281128, 0.006652832, 0.039123535, -0.0074539185, 0.02798462, -0.053100586, -0.05026245, 0.029785156, -0.029067993, 0.06384277, -0.03842163, 0.00983429, -0.027832031, 0.030426025, 0.017074585, -0.0435791, -0.03552246, -0.008079529, -0.027282715, -0.0019330978, 0.0024604797, -0.009971619, 0.015312195, -0.018432617, -0.016448975, 0.019744873, 0.0075683594, 0.017929077, -0.022323608, -0.04083252, 0.0101623535, 0.0050697327, 0.050598145, 0.0055351257, 0.0006933212, 0.0034980774, 0.009292603, -0.012588501, -0.019439697, -0.034362793, 0.033050537, -0.00157547, -0.05267334, 0.03062439, 0.028762817, -0.008644104, -0.037750244, -0.025131226, -0.009155273, -0.024658203, 0.03857422, 0.0077934265, -0.017242432, -0.038391113, 0.0036678314, -0.012321472, 0.004875183, -0.02835083, -0.021316528, 0.02798462, 0.0107040405, -0.03463745, 0.005382538, 0.0184021, 0.049804688, -0.012413025, -0.03363037, -0.0042266846, -0.0035095215, 0.045318604, -0.037261963, -0.1105957, 0.0018110275, 0.009155273, 0.013290405, 0.014480591, 0.029754639, 0.014076233, -0.022750854, -0.029968262, -0.005039215, -0.028442383, 0.004184723, 0.020980835, 0.05810547, 0.04425049, -0.025650024, 0.015525818, -0.0011167526, -0.023468018, 0.015853882, 0.009674072, -0.014083862, 0.025650024, -0.027450562, 0.0035247803, -0.03543091, -0.0049362183, -0.0541687, 0.018951416, -0.01486969, 0.0059165955, -0.00969696, 0.037475586, -0.019683838, 0.03604126, -0.051971436, -0.019042969, 0.04269409, 0.053253174, -0.011062622, 0.013687134, -0.01687622, 0.032348633, -0.0016965866, 0.010093689, 0.00793457, 0.009841919, 0.0037059784, -0.007358551, 0.016906738, -0.06274414, -0.028030396, -0.044647217, -0.02659607, 0.020065308, -0.02281189, 0.00806427, -0.016082764, -0.029876709, 0.015388489, 0.051940918, 0.01373291, -0.011520386, -0.048461914, 0.010681152, 0.034729004, -0.015945435 ], "summary": [ -0.010169983, -0.040130615, -0.0048713684, -0.03237915, -0.044158936, 0.0037250519, -0.057647705, 0.019470215, 0.01878357, 0.00082206726, 0.002861023, -0.025314331, 0.014511108, -0.047912598, 0.0023498535, -0.019210815, 0.011253357, 0.0149002075, 0.021331787, -0.014297485, 0.012550354, 0.0026855469, -0.007472992, 0.025405884, 0.051971436, -0.03213501, -0.031921387, 0.018585205, 0.03366089, 0.03125, 0.02507019, -0.032165527, 0.026947021, -0.019805908, 0.023620605, 0.012870789, -0.014762878, -0.013412476, -0.013168335, 0.013969421, 0.024734497, -0.0103302, 0.037017822, -0.0040130615, -0.0034484863, 0.02734375, -0.0018949509, -0.053131104, 0.05911255, 0.008049011, -0.024459839, -0.009132385, -0.031829834, 0.029556274, -0.037017822, -0.023651123, -0.030517578, -0.015113831, 0.01247406, 0.038635254, 0.01574707, -0.021759033, 0.009674072, -0.02748108, -0.003168106, 0.035705566, 0.041259766, -0.006778717, 0.0309906, -0.0075569153, -0.039093018, -0.0022068024, 0.033294678, -0.060150146, -0.004119873, 0.029876709, -0.02027893, -0.004760742, 0.03366089, -0.046020508, -0.019699097, 0.02319336, -0.026519775, -0.049072266, 0.002500534, -0.049468994, -0.027053833, 0.012252808, -0.024795532, -0.010261536, -0.005455017, -0.024658203, -0.061309814, 0.038482666, 0.029647827, -0.038970947, -0.03540039, -0.013824463, -0.008979797, 0.0007009506, 0.024917603, -0.013031006, 0.024810791, -0.025344849, -0.0038528442, 0.05657959, -0.0102005005, 0.00756073, 0.018035889, 0.018508911, 0.014282227, -0.017211914, -0.00006467104, -0.012565613, 0.016143799, -0.008773804, -0.03125, 0.056610107, 0.0014076233, 0.038146973, -0.028717041, -0.017288208, -0.015258789, 0.05596924, 0.04751587, 0.030914307, -0.012924194, 0.026382446, 0.03265381, 0.010299683, -0.017028809, 0.019134521, -0.003824234, -0.017333984, -0.029312134, -0.009170532, 0.0062179565, -0.0018501282, -0.010795593, -0.010192871, 0.05368042, -0.0012512207, 0.008934021, 0.0059432983, -0.0546875, 0.01184082, 0.028335571, 0.011688232, -0.027633667, -0.055511475, -0.0029563904, -0.014038086, 0.02809143, -0.026107788, -0.0029354095, -0.09918213, -0.07751465, -0.02229309, 0.0881958, -0.005393982, -0.008430481, 0.0026626587, 0.04208374, -0.0003554821, -0.00434494, 0.0038604736, -0.040039062, -0.010498047, -0.0011548996, -0.023406982, -0.043640137, 0.03894043, 0.04119873, -0.021911621, -0.015838623, -0.0070495605, 0.0033893585, -0.0031166077, -0.01033783, 0.020568848, 0.01802063, -0.022766113, 0.007762909, 0.013420105, -0.027389526, 0.005344391, 0.0069999695, 0.05404663, 0.029312134, 0.018035889, -0.009841919, -0.014625549, -0.014862061, -0.0118637085, 0.0074653625, -0.002046585, -0.027496338, -0.0037937164, -0.0011863708, -0.0115737915, -0.0037288666, 0.027816772, -0.039093018, -0.011512756, -0.0513916, -0.0044822693, 0.0003643036, 0.035217285, 0.039367676, 0.031280518, 0.0129470825, 0.014465332, -0.03451538, 0.0075683594, -0.03955078, -0.042175293, 0.008552551, -0.0000047683716, 0.013374329, -0.009643555, 0.0231781, 0.0135650635, 0.0014371872, 0.025238037, -0.02029419, -0.014472961, -0.0028705597, 0.0072746277, 0.014953613, 0.037261963, 0.0031986237, -0.046539307, 0.074279785, 0.10345459, 0.026565552, -0.017333984, 0.04333496, -0.10211182, 0.034454346, 0.036224365, 0.014129639, -0.026062012, -0.026916504, -0.005279541, -0.08111572, -0.049682617, 0.0362854, -0.0340271, 0.016952515, 0.006752014, -0.0036296844, -0.027954102, 0.036895752, 0.017227173, -0.0034484863, 0.014801025, 0.014167786, -0.045928955, 0.016281128, -0.003894806, 0.028305054, -0.047058105, -0.08099365, 0.019134521, -0.020065308, -0.021453857, -0.03161621, -0.030197144, -0.03186035, -0.014167786, 0.041229248, -0.03289795, -0.0012426376, -0.042816162, -0.013870239, 0.0044441223, -0.04434204, 0.034332275, 0.02885437, -0.023498535, 0.0011835098, 0.046691895, 0.004219055, -0.024551392, -0.009803772, 0.02758789, -0.0064926147, -0.010101318, 0.006286621, 0.05105591, 0.05899048, 0.0335083, 0.002407074, 0.01461792, -0.04458618, 0.002544403, -0.017852783, -0.014030457, 0.03805542, -0.061523438, -0.024887085, 0.051696777, -0.005268097, -0.008171082, 0.033325195, 0.008583069, 0.052215576, -0.0068359375, -0.005382538, 0.007659912, -0.014389038, 0.039733887, 0.037078857, -0.033721924, 0.039215088, 0.0284729, -0.00831604, 0.026657104, 0.01348114, 0.03857422, 0.12902832, -0.01121521, -0.005542755, 0.01260376, -0.019302368, -0.05834961, 0.03250122, -0.027618408, -0.024307251, -0.020217896, -0.041931152, -0.051971436, -0.04006958, 0.022598267, 0.0045280457, 0.010978699, 0.018173218, 0.013298035, 0.016952515, 0.004901886, 0.048614502, -0.07171631, -0.026763916, 0.0011558533, 0.005748749, -0.033233643, 0.03086853, -0.008491516, 0.022781372, 0.012481689, -0.0042800903, -0.017410278, 0.0026950836, 0.01940918, 0.00027251244, -0.0138549805, 0.01184082, 0.025436401, -0.012886047, -0.029266357, 0.043762207, 0.0016727448, 0.0011796951, -0.06524658, -0.012268066, -0.032989502, -0.01928711, -0.024765015, 0.032806396, 0.020004272, 0.01348114, 0.027709961, -0.0440979, -0.015403748, -0.004486084, -0.0146865845, 0.05291748, -0.01687622, 0.040649414, 0.043701172, 0.0058517456, 0.012489319, -0.00315094, 0.0018177032, 0.1005249, -0.0046539307, 0.0035591125, 0.051208496, 0.036132812, 0.008491516, -0.03186035, -0.048461914, 0.027023315, -0.037231445, 0.0046043396, 0.009155273, -0.034301758, -0.0005683899, 0.021377563, -0.00548172, 0.076293945, 0.024749756, -0.009796143, 0.041229248, -0.045837402, -0.0056610107, 0.013206482, 0.006904602, 0.048217773, -0.07019043, 0.032562256, -0.033203125, 0.02720642, -0.05331421, -0.02520752, -0.03869629, -0.03488159, -0.015991211, -0.004650116, 0.025466919, 0.017440796, -0.059661865, -0.020446777, 0.020721436, 0.011207581, 0.00818634, 0.001373291, 0.009605408, -0.022323608, -0.0076026917, -0.014694214, -0.022857666, 0.0015134811, 0.038330078, -0.006046295, 0.06958008, 0.0023708344, -0.03378296, 0.039489746, -0.051879883, -0.025726318, -0.05029297, -0.07110596, -0.027145386, -0.025894165, -0.02319336, -0.035736084, -0.027175903, -0.003566742, -0.006313324, -0.03375244, 0.002199173, 0.024139404, 0.026153564, -0.011177063, 0.024749756, -0.0071754456, -0.00894165, 0.008178711, -0.011199951, -0.0027942657, 0.032287598, -0.06390381, -0.038482666, 0.0115737915, 0.059387207, -0.04373169, 0.05154419, -0.020645142, 0.009063721, 0.06768799, -0.043151855, 0.024612427, 0.0010566711, -0.021881104, -0.030212402, 0.036712646, 0.028335571, -0.017822266, -0.047424316, -0.046417236, 0.031677246, -0.022277832, -0.06161499, -0.032104492, 0.015655518, -0.06451416, -0.058563232, -0.0021858215, 0.041412354, -0.008026123, -0.015045166, 0.024017334, 0.040649414, -0.015579224, 0.039916992, -0.023666382, 0.0340271, 0.02558899, -0.04360962, 0.010368347, 0.014152527, 0.029586792, -0.010787964, 0.050567627, 0.0073547363, 0.01096344, 0.013755798, 0.0009589195, 0.029769897, 0.044433594, -0.012260437, -0.018417358, -0.007610321, -0.01322937, -0.009552002, 0.03869629, -0.076416016, 0.028747559, 0.019119263, 0.03768921, 0.055755615, -0.003282547, -0.015640259, 0.03479004, -0.0009355545, -0.019760132, 0.043823242, 0.00029230118, -0.011398315, 0.043548584, -0.011230469, -0.009895325, 0.020645142, -0.0088272095, 0.028793335, -0.014968872, -0.007820129, 0.038360596, 0.044281006, -0.0048179626, -0.036865234, -0.010688782, 0.042907715, 0.012908936, 0.012763977, -0.0035953522, 0.05303955, -0.02923584, 0.05255127, -0.023117065, -0.03463745, -0.00048589706, -0.0024871826, 0.01209259, -0.003993988, -0.03451538, 0.006401062, 0.013214111, 0.019805908, 0.07299805, -0.0066337585, 0.0068969727, -0.04135132, 0.091430664, -0.01449585, -0.004688263, -0.1104126, -0.015686035, 0.004463196, -0.051239014, -0.032714844, -0.059173584, -0.0368042, -0.03665161, -0.0005393028, -0.034698486, 0.018798828, -0.02960205, 0.018096924, 0.061950684, 0.0025920868, -0.0597229, 0.04055786, 0.0024929047, -0.009262085, 0.016799927, -0.010444641, 0.028579712, 0.010871887, 0.023239136, -0.03942871, -0.016296387, -0.037719727, 0.025466919, 0.012107849, 0.004447937, -0.032714844, -0.010292053, 0.015007019, -0.004386902, -0.020126343, -0.0030021667, -0.026016235, 0.064453125, -0.030761719, 0.00004339218, -0.020217896, -0.038848877, -0.010475159, 0.046295166, 0.011764526, -0.017349243, -0.007537842, -0.026046753, 0.03086853, 0.0075798035, 0.008232117, 0.024932861, 0.00015318394, 0.032806396, 0.0074043274, 0.023986816, 0.041748047, 0.01361084, -0.048706055, -0.00083589554, -0.0056381226, -0.002773285, 0.011260986, -0.009017944, 0.0112838745, -0.016845703, 0.0051460266, 0.027236938, -0.0033016205, -0.011054993, 0.012756348, -0.030807495, -0.050720215, 0.024612427, 0.011016846, 0.0058135986, -0.03692627, -0.01777649, -0.031082153, -0.0289917, -0.009963989, -0.025634766, -0.028549194, -0.05984497, 0.012451172, -0.01600647, 0.067871094, 0.015701294, 0.022567749, -0.034454346, -0.021087646, 0.013877869, -0.03274536, -0.019836426, 0.05783081, -0.024139404, 0.041503906, 0.053588867, -0.0060539246, -0.036193848, 0.037841797, -0.036071777, 0.044281006, 0.026809692, -0.070739746, -0.032104492, 0.005039215, 0.029129028, -0.0048675537, 0.07067871, 0.024932861, 0.01235199, -0.063964844, 0.008682251, 0.059265137, -0.0018205643, 0.008674622, -0.021362305, 0.073913574, 0.014419556, -0.030349731, 0.020141602, -0.016159058, -0.042236328, -0.06011963, 0.017456055, -0.08068848, -0.004257202, 0.017837524, -0.020828247, -0.0018644333, 0.002855301, -0.023422241, 0.023269653, 0.009986877, -0.022842407, -0.03289795, -0.0011129379, 0.01550293, -0.03289795, 0.053344727, -0.018539429, -0.0027828217, 0.02217102, 0.030975342, 0.008232117, -0.009994507, -0.017227173, -0.013961792, -0.0058135986, -0.006313324, -0.010734558, 0.033233643, -0.01612854, 0.020523071, 0.029632568, -0.04812622, 0.028289795, -0.02418518, -0.021865845, -0.025100708, -0.043792725, -0.055389404, 0.030029297, 0.0013179779, -0.024154663, 0.004688263, 0.00010710955, -0.030807495, 0.05493164, -0.023849487, 0.015533447, -0.006099701, -0.016677856, 0.009338379, 0.02961731, 0.010887146, -0.03567505, 0.03463745, 0.00869751, -0.02218628, 0.031433105, -0.0107421875, 0.026992798, 0.023162842, -0.00944519, -0.017425537, 0.021636963, -0.045013428, -0.008796692, 0.00957489, 0.010398865, -0.0041236877, -0.04421997, -0.0036678314, -0.021255493, 0.015617371, 0.01751709, 0.02986145, 0.053497314, 0.054534912, 0.0011529922, -0.007724762, -0.027023315, 0.0024738312, -0.019165039, -0.03817749, 0.05038452, 0.024414062, -0.045532227, 0.048858643, -0.00749588, 0.044311523, 0.013168335, 0.040008545, -0.0038795471, -0.009208679, -0.030883789, -0.016677856, 0.05630493, 0.031463623, -0.008728027, 0.044830322, 0.042877197, 0.022155762, 0.028747559, 0.035217285, -0.000541687, 0.0053749084, 0.05090332, 0.015808105, 0.030166626, -0.009361267, 0.07501221, -0.02571106, -0.04711914, -0.06567383, -0.07006836, -0.034973145, -0.014541626, 0.008857727, -0.026626587, 0.021316528, -0.009407043, 0.0038414001, 0.009681702, -0.037261963, 0.017044067, 0.005622864, -0.00818634, -0.0067100525, -0.017074585, -0.0067825317, 0.024642944, 0.047424316, -0.017547607, 0.03479004, -0.028121948, 0.010665894, 0.051574707, -0.04336548, -0.049194336, -0.0446167, 0.034057617, -0.050842285, -0.051971436, -0.0138168335, -0.0032978058, -0.0019292831, 0.020736694, 0.065979004, 0.023010254, 0.002626419, -0.020996094, -0.041625977, 0.03604126, -0.03125, 0.013633728, 0.012687683, -0.010971069, -0.02798462, 0.006801605, 0.041503906, 0.037475586, -0.03652954, 0.034088135, -0.008125305, -0.006336212, -0.03277588, 0.004600525, -0.022491455, -0.0035266876, 0.008407593, -0.025177002, 0.022598267, 0.006790161, 0.0008325577, -0.0016517639, -0.012084961, -0.039031982, -0.012062073, -0.01007843, -0.060760498, 0.01600647, 0.083984375, 0.016067505, 0.004753113, -0.01638794, -0.010818481, 0.030212402, -0.06036377, 0.040008545, -0.032440186, 0.056732178, 0.01928711, 0.05810547, -0.023757935, -0.0043258667, 0.014762878, 0.008552551, 0.025543213, -0.040863037, -0.0002975464, -0.04763794, -0.015029907, 0.01638794, -0.035614014, 0.015655518, 0.03074646, -0.046691895, 0.02935791, -0.022705078, 0.018005371, -0.020141602, -0.038879395, -0.0287323, -0.007156372, -0.04321289, 0.008369446, 0.00012803078, -0.026321411, 0.021514893, -0.04006958, -0.033416748, -0.0036830902, 0.012916565, -0.00006175041, -0.02645874, 0.036376953, 0.0079956055, 0.0692749, 0.058166504, 0.06585693, -0.00025749207, 0.04724121, 0.013931274, -0.0051879883, -0.04812622, -0.0463562, 0.05130005, 0.04699707, -0.04989624, 0.04626465, 0.050628662, -0.0025691986, -0.0019426346, 0.0023937225, 0.00049066544, -0.0068359375, 0.049865723, 0.003829956, 0.0037651062, -0.03503418, 0.012329102, -0.014457703, -0.020141602, -0.046142578, -0.02720642, 0.02519226, 0.03894043, -0.061401367, -0.017929077, -0.036102295, -0.021484375, -0.013015747, -0.014984131, -0.01399231, 0.0034999847, 0.049987793, -0.0104599, -0.07946777, 0.0030097961, -0.0018396378, 0.028823853, 0.008125305, 0.030761719, 0.015266418, -0.043945312, -0.021026611, -0.021713257, -0.0036315918, 0.06225586, 0.05444336, 0.035888672, 0.009162903, -0.02456665, 0.033294678, -0.02168274, -0.056152344, -0.0013990402, 0.005176544, -0.010894775, 0.006881714, -0.010864258, 0.007896423, -0.04888916, -0.000059604645, 0.038726807, -0.005054474, -0.015701294, -0.03503418, -0.01902771, -0.003967285, -0.050354004, -0.068237305, -0.013313293, 0.0068473816, -0.0025119781, 0.025405884, 0.013465881, -0.010383606, -0.013427734, 0.007881165, 0.032196045, 0.022369385, 0.0032215118, 0.02947998, -0.024978638, 0.029663086, -0.0013341904, -0.041625977, -0.015899658, -0.0647583, -0.026687622, 0.0017366409, -0.0044403076, 0.017181396, 0.02999878, 0.001581192, 0.020904541, 0.04434204, 0.011505127, -0.014320374, 0.025009155, 0.09838867, 0.030929565, 0.017822266 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07070v1
Explain-then-Translate: An Analysis on Improving Program Translation with Self-generated Explanations
Zilu Tang, Mayank Agarwal, Alex Shypula, Bailin Wang, Derry Wijaya, Jie Chen, Yoon Kim
cs.CL
This work explores the use of self-generated natural language explanations as an intermediate step for code-to-code translation with language models. Across three types of explanations and 19 programming languages constructed from the MultiPL-E dataset, we find the explanations to be particularly effective in the zero-shot case, improving performance by 12% on average. Improvements with natural language explanations are particularly pronounced on difficult programs. We release our dataset, code, and canonical solutions in all 19 languages.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07070v1
2023-11-13T04:28:49
2023-11-13T04:28:49
{ "title": [ -0.044952393, -0.016189575, 0.0014858246, -0.050445557, -0.014007568, 0.01852417, -0.054718018, -0.003414154, -0.022827148, 0.024673462, 0.016036987, 0.017654419, -0.028289795, -0.026016235, -0.044677734, 0.0018157959, 0.001083374, -0.0031642914, -0.03414917, -0.04244995, -0.0054397583, -0.0513916, 0.03805542, 0.019500732, 0.028533936, -0.072021484, -0.0033893585, 0.0018939972, -0.019866943, -0.039123535, -0.0019483566, 0.018920898, 0.03366089, 0.023513794, -0.014862061, -0.026947021, -0.02960205, 0.0021190643, -0.028015137, 0.03652954, 0.005519867, -0.0030269623, -0.0079193115, -0.03564453, -0.019622803, -0.002193451, -0.03527832, -0.03286743, -0.02368164, 0.045654297, 0.01600647, 0.02381897, 0.0056114197, 0.039764404, 0.020324707, -0.023483276, -0.033050537, 0.027923584, 0.02947998, 0.050048828, 0.013374329, -0.017959595, -0.0032978058, -0.0206604, -0.03125, -0.018432617, -0.0021305084, 0.012390137, 0.05307007, -0.012161255, -0.025238037, 0.033599854, 0.03338623, -0.0012159348, -0.020370483, -0.010818481, 0.028915405, 0.026824951, 0.038726807, -0.029174805, 0.033050537, -0.0077285767, 0.04421997, -0.0181427, 0.017196655, -0.030258179, 0.0019197464, -0.017211914, -0.035614014, -0.09454346, -0.004714966, -0.023880005, -0.03427124, -0.013618469, -0.028915405, -0.047576904, -0.009361267, -0.0015678406, -0.015991211, -0.008987427, -0.041137695, 0.034454346, -0.02067566, -0.017791748, -0.0059547424, 0.0132369995, 0.0017604828, -0.028274536, 0.004173279, 0.044128418, -0.031311035, 0.04711914, 0.021392822, -0.014587402, -0.0049476624, 0.021316528, 0.012550354, 0.01927185, 0.011947632, 0.04067993, -0.007835388, -0.03805542, 0.037963867, 0.020370483, 0.022064209, 0.011474609, -0.038146973, 0.008544922, 0.038391113, 0.02029419, -0.00894928, 0.018203735, -0.04724121, -0.06222534, -0.0340271, 0.027633667, -0.0059013367, -0.0074806213, -0.026168823, 0.020904541, -0.009407043, -0.01121521, 0.03894043, -0.030578613, -0.00014781952, -0.0021038055, 0.045135498, -0.003206253, -0.035247803, -0.021972656, -0.027801514, -0.0011520386, 0.021362305, 0.008560181, -0.028427124, -0.0024147034, -0.11907959, 0.009048462, 0.014556885, 0.025405884, -0.025009155, 0.00051546097, 0.00623703, -0.016433716, -0.003238678, -0.0066452026, 0.035186768, 0.002521515, 0.012237549, 0.026733398, -0.0044555664, 0.021438599, 0.020980835, -0.026031494, -0.015167236, -0.018127441, 0.026748657, 0.012458801, 0.022247314, -0.012008667, 0.022583008, -0.010093689, 0.03152466, 0.046966553, -0.055145264, -0.012466431, -0.0005955696, 0.016433716, 0.05340576, 0.005657196, -0.049621582, 0.02482605, -0.0435791, -0.018157959, -0.04269409, -0.020568848, 0.0031871796, 0.04260254, -0.0044784546, 0.0036697388, -0.042144775, 0.005760193, -0.014953613, 0.02456665, -0.00074005127, -0.011100769, -0.011604309, 0.016403198, -0.022628784, 0.043884277, 0.056762695, 0.018234253, -0.044555664, 0.043548584, -0.012962341, -0.08325195, 0.038146973, 0.009063721, 0.012512207, -0.02935791, 0.02822876, -0.029281616, 0.017486572, 0.04748535, 0.008300781, 0.019973755, -0.014625549, 0.004470825, 0.043151855, 0.03878784, 0.050720215, -0.05596924, 0.035949707, -0.0044403076, -0.039215088, -0.018951416, -0.030715942, -0.0016202927, -0.019989014, 0.025253296, -0.0140686035, 0.0036506653, -0.018859863, 0.0231781, 0.037841797, 0.0074653625, 0.012298584, 0.019683838, 0.02104187, 0.021224976, 0.056793213, -0.017608643, 0.047180176, -0.054992676, -0.0024547577, 0.053588867, -0.010925293, -0.012702942, 0.01360321, -0.010215759, 0.017349243, -0.011016846, -0.020767212, 0.0013961792, -0.072387695, 0.026779175, -0.022140503, 0.005870819, -0.004638672, 0.0042800903, 0.027801514, -0.0045166016, 0.004837036, -0.01676941, -0.024246216, 0.000852108, -0.009101868, 0.027999878, 0.007980347, -0.05847168, 0.0037136078, 0.023132324, 0.01197052, -0.013343811, 0.021514893, 0.020431519, -0.008171082, -0.026672363, -0.019973755, 0.003490448, 0.04534912, 0.027191162, 0.003709793, 0.001832962, 0.011940002, -0.007091522, 0.11956787, 0.06555176, -0.03050232, 0.032684326, -0.037200928, 0.021652222, 0.028137207, -0.041259766, -0.0040130615, 0.02116394, 0.021392822, 0.006008148, -0.02607727, 0.012084961, -0.045562744, -0.025726318, -0.0017356873, -0.0007901192, -0.068847656, -0.06976318, -0.013343811, -0.04650879, -0.061645508, -0.02607727, 0.056518555, 0.008972168, -0.04638672, 0.020309448, 0.012176514, -0.005207062, 0.002878189, -0.035736084, -0.0013456345, 0.0065727234, 0.05581665, 0.01322937, -0.048095703, -0.030944824, 0.0014877319, 0.005317688, -0.009033203, -0.029907227, -0.032348633, 0.035614014, 0.01436615, -0.019714355, 0.02835083, -0.050109863, 0.011253357, -0.042907715, 0.03125, 0.011100769, -0.012863159, 0.00242424, 0.014152527, -0.016036987, -0.023040771, 0.019134521, 0.062438965, -0.038024902, -0.010826111, 0.046936035, 0.025817871, -0.009963989, 0.05303955, -0.005382538, 0.015602112, -0.059265137, -0.030685425, -0.03955078, -0.048583984, 0.006034851, 0.008270264, 0.042663574, -0.0073165894, -0.016967773, -0.015365601, -0.008590698, 0.028167725, -0.027053833, 0.0047683716, -0.027572632, -0.030075073, -0.014945984, 0.009490967, 0.031677246, -0.058807373, 0.013191223, 0.08026123, 0.015357971, 0.018829346, 0.028900146, 0.037231445, 0.009170532, 0.0027313232, -0.00970459, -0.005947113, -0.006668091, 0.03567505, -0.013748169, -0.005016327, 0.03201294, -0.09277344, -0.011856079, 0.080322266, -0.006252289, -0.026672363, 0.035369873, -0.081848145, 0.008399963, -0.007598877, -0.010635376, 0.021209717, 0.045715332, 0.012176514, -0.018585205, -0.0010976791, -0.048431396, 0.0121154785, -0.013717651, -0.115722656, 0.030029297, -0.046295166, -0.0057640076, 0.01737976, -0.006877899, -0.042419434, 0.0005054474, -0.014099121, 0.04257202, 0.04437256, 0.03277588, 0.042907715, -0.06021118, 0.0063552856, -0.03845215, -0.0043182373, 0.029556274, -0.015281677, 0.070739746, 0.0059661865, 0.03414917, 0.05682373, -0.040985107, -0.03515625, -0.036224365, -0.0385437, 0.014122009, -0.007659912, -0.02722168, -0.045074463, -0.017608643, -0.009361267, 0.005493164, -0.020339966, 0.011566162, -0.04043579, 0.009796143, -0.020462036, 0.0116119385, 0.011001587, -0.0017385483, -0.007873535, -0.005748749, 0.004108429, -0.015579224, -0.031799316, 0.0038547516, 0.020019531, 0.000828743, 0.02330017, -0.021102905, -0.042663574, 0.015327454, -0.024719238, -0.0135650635, -0.01689148, 0.0057868958, 0.025222778, 0.014045715, -0.03475952, -0.00042891502, -0.01828003, 0.023391724, 0.0138549805, 0.011367798, 0.019500732, -0.09161377, -0.033447266, 0.014289856, -0.13244629, -0.053131104, 0.018341064, -0.010292053, -0.015197754, -0.05529785, 0.030136108, -0.030227661, -0.041412354, 0.016494751, -0.005672455, -0.000032365322, -0.017150879, -0.050933838, -0.052215576, 0.07940674, -0.0005340576, 0.0068740845, 0.061798096, -0.024520874, -0.03390503, -0.012290955, 0.03378296, 0.024520874, 0.0184021, 0.007987976, -0.054382324, 0.024597168, -0.031311035, 0.014930725, 0.028839111, -0.02708435, 0.007331848, 0.02835083, -0.019088745, 0.018508911, -0.009094238, 0.042175293, 0.0073280334, -0.022155762, -0.047332764, 0.04348755, -0.0099487305, -0.0049972534, 0.01448822, -0.0021572113, -0.0155181885, -0.006336212, 0.0070228577, 0.032073975, -0.018417358, 0.006996155, 0.024047852, -0.029327393, -0.013916016, 0.003545761, 0.006034851, 0.0259552, 0.013023376, 0.028503418, -0.00056886673, 0.02281189, -0.020126343, -0.012313843, -0.022079468, 0.0032310486, -0.038024902, 0.009284973, -0.04940796, 0.014579773, -0.032409668, 0.031677246, -0.0146484375, 0.031143188, 0.019012451, -0.04626465, 0.002090454, 0.022384644, 0.031402588, -0.0007367134, 0.004875183, -0.06994629, -0.04067993, 0.004547119, -0.072509766, -0.027053833, -0.07098389, -0.014404297, -0.0011367798, 0.014762878, -0.01576233, 0.021575928, 0.024520874, 0.052093506, 0.030700684, -0.007446289, -0.044555664, 0.074645996, -0.02420044, -0.025253296, 0.0385437, -0.015434265, 0.003944397, 0.0005378723, 0.018676758, -0.022460938, -0.025558472, -0.012084961, 0.039489746, -0.0206604, 0.0793457, 0.0014266968, 0.03488159, 0.024475098, 0.0007123947, 0.03152466, 0.0025577545, -0.013961792, 0.02229309, 0.025314331, 0.06335449, -0.025177002, -0.007205963, 0.0107040405, 0.03353882, 0.0131073, -0.0049324036, 0.003824234, -0.0031929016, 0.0066947937, -0.007347107, 0.008964539, -0.013397217, -0.012969971, 0.011177063, 0.0011148453, 0.040527344, -0.017333984, 0.039916992, 0.02909851, 0.027526855, -0.005191803, -0.043792725, 0.056243896, -0.048309326, 0.028411865, -0.05480957, -0.015640259, 0.020309448, -0.010467529, -0.023483276, 0.020004272, 0.008514404, -0.001004219, -0.0012645721, 0.048828125, 0.030883789, -0.0020370483, 0.020324707, -0.016952515, -0.013328552, -0.03173828, -0.040252686, 0.0074043274, 0.03527832, 0.023468018, -0.05355835, 0.036132812, -0.05718994, 0.029632568, -0.007843018, -0.028915405, 0.036315918, -0.06616211, 0.036346436, 0.09265137, -0.026992798, 0.04812622, 0.027114868, 0.036346436, 0.0129470825, 0.060943604, 0.015167236, 0.016113281, 0.018508911, -0.0418396, -0.022445679, 0.0024967194, 0.020843506, -0.013198853, 0.039367676, 0.008407593, 0.0030326843, -0.05239868, 0.007850647, 0.034240723, 0.024505615, 0.020751953, -0.062408447, 0.010437012, 0.013130188, 0.006549835, 0.029830933, -0.055145264, -0.034698486, -0.05041504, -0.012825012, -0.08392334, 0.035461426, -0.010261536, -0.053466797, -0.049835205, 0.022979736, -0.015640259, -0.021331787, 0.00066137314, 0.0044174194, -0.0340271, -0.011039734, 0.052978516, -0.0105896, 0.049468994, -0.048065186, -0.025161743, 0.05770874, 0.060699463, -0.018203735, 0.004875183, -0.0053901672, -0.013923645, -0.019073486, -0.0033302307, -0.021728516, 0.007583618, -0.0004632473, -0.017303467, -0.037597656, 0.0019369125, 0.018325806, -0.008865356, -0.052215576, 0.0368042, 0.010566711, -0.0011234283, -0.012039185, 0.030639648, -0.03643799, 0.027633667, 0.02949524, 0.01852417, 0.005962372, -0.002588272, -0.00957489, -0.0024051666, -0.06286621, -0.0017910004, 0.008613586, -0.00007605553, 0.03488159, 0.027832031, 0.03439331, 0.0814209, -0.020095825, 0.024154663, 0.04159546, -0.041992188, -0.017684937, 0.014915466, 0.007217407, 0.0020427704, 0.04324341, 0.0028095245, -0.015220642, -0.02796936, -0.020339966, -0.015991211, 0.020477295, 0.013084412, -0.005645752, 0.01914978, -0.040740967, 0.001950264, -0.031311035, -0.017654419, -0.039978027, 0.027267456, -0.009292603, -0.020629883, 0.020568848, -0.014945984, -0.02243042, -0.00070524216, 0.028045654, 0.042175293, -0.0039978027, 0.0619812, -0.040252686, -0.016433716, -0.025543213, -0.037506104, 0.022064209, 0.017410278, -0.013191223, 0.049224854, -0.043792725, 0.048828125, 0.0032215118, 0.041259766, 0.016159058, 0.026351929, 0.018508911, -0.0074501038, 0.024246216, -0.020050049, 0.033294678, -0.061035156, 0.01838684, -0.061828613, -0.008171082, -0.06402588, -0.015975952, 0.014373779, 0.04083252, 0.030303955, 0.013282776, 0.0016040802, 0.004676819, 0.036987305, 0.06854248, 0.08178711, 0.004508972, 0.0032463074, -0.01159668, -0.03213501, 0.04031372, 0.045928955, -0.00011944771, 0.0047187805, 0.0023040771, -0.05154419, 0.01828003, 0.0072288513, 0.027359009, -0.03604126, -0.027114868, -0.0340271, -0.031021118, -0.04510498, -0.00010430813, 0.07354736, 0.021514893, -0.010444641, -0.00059890747, 0.001865387, -0.06829834, -0.031433105, -0.011009216, 0.015548706, -0.120910645, 0.06021118, -0.00592041, -0.015853882, -0.047058105, 0.01914978, 0.04788208, -0.01789856, 0.009315491, 0.013473511, 0.03201294, -0.014328003, -0.004776001, -0.029342651, -0.014862061, 0.02418518, 0.039794922, -0.0022640228, 0.024536133, -0.0007843971, 0.025405884, -0.0090408325, -0.025421143, 0.00085926056, -0.007896423, -0.018966675, 0.03164673, -0.012298584, -0.013534546, -0.022613525, -0.030731201, 0.0046195984, 0.0021877289, -0.010116577, -0.026031494, 0.03164673, 0.00011628866, -0.0016241074, 0.051757812, -0.011383057, -0.010948181, -0.032684326, -0.031036377, 0.04071045, 0.058288574, -0.035461426, 0.025787354, -0.03564453, -0.057037354, 0.045532227, -0.042510986, 0.05178833, -0.040618896, -0.005290985, -0.039489746, 0.057434082, 0.013305664, -0.03616333, -0.0501709, -0.013084412, -0.0155181885, -0.016799927, -0.02166748, -0.00050878525, -0.009887695, -0.013450623, 0.034484863, 0.028366089, 0.007949829, -0.0007762909, -0.024353027, -0.04699707, 0.045684814, -0.014480591, 0.073913574, -0.023590088, -0.013160706, 0.020401001, -0.0055770874, -0.0121536255, -0.047332764, -0.026779175, -0.03503418, -0.007858276, -0.023025513, 0.0047798157, -0.00029325485, -0.0053901672, 0.011245728, -0.030853271, 0.037750244, -0.015975952, 0.009605408, -0.0012311935, -0.053741455, 0.0064086914, 0.010665894, -0.04321289, 0.04336548, 0.03060913, -0.029006958, 0.06402588, -0.0018463135, -0.028030396, 0.001578331, -0.0006723404, 0.007827759, 0.0011978149, -0.06021118, 0.039093018, 0.0024375916, 0.019241333, -0.045196533, -0.03793335, 0.017288208, 0.027755737, -0.018249512, 0.05819702, 0.010932922, 0.014053345, 0.0076141357, 0.041168213, -0.001376152, -0.044525146, 0.014045715, 0.003200531, 0.026611328, 0.053222656, -0.0017948151, -0.018493652, 0.009994507, 0.0025844574, -0.002368927, 0.010292053, -0.010818481, 0.014533997, 0.0039405823, 0.018951416, -0.04748535, 0.01763916, -0.07495117, 0.04660034, -0.00024068356, 0.02067566, 0.0072402954, 0.037078857, 0.01676941, 0.08117676, -0.040649414, -0.025253296, 0.04348755, 0.037231445, 0.0070648193, 0.036987305, -0.016052246, 0.013954163, 0.021636963, 0.003194809, -0.002664566, 0.011650085, 0.0013008118, 0.00566864, -0.0039482117, -0.06188965, -0.025726318, -0.00051021576, -0.0134887695, 0.04675293, -0.05102539, -0.004261017, -0.030776978, -0.03668213, 0.00642395, 0.030014038, 0.0025501251, -0.013282776, -0.040374756, -0.0052833557, 0.022949219, -0.017929077 ], "summary": [ -0.008880615, -0.07006836, 0.031051636, -0.031311035, -0.07647705, 0.0077056885, -0.07366943, 0.023757935, 0.0005168915, 0.018936157, 0.035217285, 0.0055007935, 0.027114868, -0.059143066, 0.036071777, 0.013938904, -0.004737854, 0.007904053, -0.02619934, -0.026412964, -0.00020968914, -0.047302246, -0.002500534, 0.0076026917, 0.005783081, -0.055786133, 0.052825928, -0.025024414, 0.020980835, -0.017547607, 0.01864624, 0.0141067505, 0.0038414001, -0.0059776306, 0.016433716, -0.018630981, -0.011367798, -0.003768921, 0.002008438, 0.0357666, 0.014801025, -0.021316528, 0.10040283, -0.0519104, 0.047943115, 0.014144897, 0.018234253, -0.07623291, 0.00029277802, 0.01210022, 0.01890564, -0.009567261, 0.018692017, 0.0018100739, -0.02268982, -0.014831543, -0.06048584, 0.006137848, -0.0007138252, 0.040039062, 0.02470398, 0.009216309, -0.0013370514, -0.010879517, 0.0027713776, -0.012306213, -0.020523071, 0.0041046143, 0.052978516, -0.022888184, -0.02319336, 0.01499176, 0.020584106, -0.06719971, 0.0006842613, 0.04159546, 0.004562378, 0.037078857, 0.006134033, -0.039398193, 0.02545166, 0.035614014, 0.035980225, -0.04660034, -0.0024871826, -0.06719971, 0.009994507, -0.008613586, -0.046722412, -0.052368164, -0.01737976, -0.04763794, -0.108947754, 0.009536743, 0.024459839, -0.05126953, -0.006706238, -0.03189087, -0.0078125, -0.0030879974, -0.0055618286, -0.015510559, 0.013076782, -0.004131317, -0.0049324036, 0.02128601, 0.024124146, -0.041290283, 0.009002686, -0.003774643, -0.035827637, 0.035461426, -0.0007147789, -0.042236328, 0.008338928, 0.017807007, -0.019348145, 0.03717041, 0.009407043, 0.010276794, 0.004676819, 0.0010385513, 0.0045814514, 0.02748108, 0.042541504, 0.010803223, -0.027786255, 0.019622803, 0.06677246, 0.022949219, -0.009552002, 0.0012741089, -0.018753052, -0.027786255, -0.02671814, -0.0031204224, 0.017501831, -0.015014648, -0.028060913, -0.0019254684, 0.0015163422, 0.0048599243, 0.021438599, -0.020935059, 0.022628784, -0.0026168823, 0.006275177, 0.02645874, 0.030212402, 0.0027694702, 0.010215759, -0.023025513, 0.025039673, -0.0077056885, -0.010879517, -0.045776367, -0.045288086, 0.00089645386, 0.033203125, -0.0075263977, -0.042938232, -0.02130127, 0.02885437, -0.03692627, -0.062194824, 0.030532837, 0.0018587112, -0.029129028, 0.012634277, -0.018127441, -0.030822754, 0.03010559, 0.02810669, -0.013633728, -0.0043258667, -0.019592285, -0.029159546, 0.028442383, 0.027816772, -0.024749756, 0.02658081, -0.0068206787, 0.03591919, 0.05496216, -0.04348755, -0.0027389526, 0.008850098, 0.04034424, 0.043273926, -0.0056648254, 0.023727417, -0.03427124, -0.018554688, 0.00064754486, 0.02180481, -0.023010254, -0.054901123, -0.012435913, -0.004558563, 0.0032749176, -0.010505676, 0.021881104, -0.0035152435, -0.011436462, -0.027313232, -0.0010766983, -0.00982666, 0.026657104, -0.012084961, 0.017242432, 0.03289795, -0.010543823, -0.030456543, 0.05154419, 0.030029297, 0.0033245087, 0.04031372, 0.0056114197, 0.0340271, -0.048095703, 0.1060791, -0.0050086975, 0.049713135, 0.07385254, -0.021530151, 0.02949524, -0.03173828, 0.034423828, 0.015449524, 0.004310608, 0.0647583, -0.018692017, 0.034057617, 0.011245728, -0.034362793, -0.01902771, 0.00667572, -0.033447266, -0.0024852753, 0.035095215, 0.013999939, 0.00415802, -0.03668213, -0.034362793, 0.0736084, 0.062561035, 0.024459839, -0.029708862, 0.019607544, 0.04437256, 0.0021076202, -0.016723633, 0.009597778, -0.08282471, -0.010726929, 0.048675537, -0.005504608, -0.045562744, 0.016845703, -0.03201294, 0.026657104, 0.01335144, -0.027648926, 0.020187378, -0.025680542, 0.0059928894, -0.0050621033, -0.0007648468, -0.025146484, -0.0072746277, 0.01965332, 0.008605957, -0.005504608, -0.013885498, -0.042388916, -0.01939392, -0.0015096664, 0.034088135, 0.021392822, -0.027862549, 0.012161255, 0.056640625, -0.017868042, -0.026168823, -0.0019102097, 0.014022827, -0.028747559, -0.020965576, -0.021911621, 0.028625488, 0.03515625, 0.02772522, -0.0020694733, -0.017807007, 0.04348755, 0.009674072, 0.040283203, -0.0038070679, 0.03152466, -0.031433105, 0.0087890625, 0.06262207, 0.0025081635, 0.0017690659, 0.00091934204, 0.03277588, 0.0077552795, 0.00029301643, -0.0002758503, 0.013420105, -0.020217896, 0.018844604, 0.012138367, 0.0758667, -0.06652832, -0.080200195, -0.029510498, -0.004798889, -0.06866455, -0.028869629, 0.06317139, 0.059265137, 0.0034503937, 0.012969971, 0.04647827, -0.05456543, 0.002904892, -0.029510498, 0.000037431717, -0.018569946, 0.008811951, -0.0054740906, -0.012252808, 0.017059326, 0.006526947, -0.013908386, 0.006034851, -0.012710571, -0.013198853, 0.032806396, 0.02746582, 0.01751709, 0.020996094, -0.032714844, -0.03451538, -0.025939941, 0.047576904, -0.02053833, 0.009407043, 0.0037822723, 0.024505615, -0.0032730103, -0.023010254, 0.028961182, 0.020874023, -0.052001953, 0.0049324036, 0.047821045, 0.00022172928, -0.010627747, 0.044921875, 0.02255249, 0.022415161, -0.0715332, -0.030929565, -0.048065186, -0.026763916, -0.0021686554, 0.019714355, 0.019363403, -0.007381439, 0.010391235, 0.0064468384, -0.0113220215, 0.010658264, -0.031204224, 0.07928467, -0.0010623932, -0.01259613, 0.031799316, 0.013511658, 0.015594482, -0.019165039, -0.0262146, 0.107421875, 0.014953613, 0.043121338, 0.056671143, 0.034606934, -0.0099105835, -0.015342712, -0.021255493, 0.005214691, -0.023086548, -0.013313293, -0.009712219, -0.029647827, 0.026504517, -0.010902405, -0.006034851, 0.037200928, 0.038208008, 0.017837524, 0.028503418, -0.018661499, 0.013801575, 0.021255493, 0.0041160583, 0.020935059, 0.0014686584, 0.036712646, -0.09301758, 0.033447266, -0.12512207, 0.019104004, -0.0050315857, -0.044403076, 0.010292053, -0.0049476624, -0.0178833, -0.014404297, 0.012359619, 0.014602661, 0.04067993, 0.01651001, 0.032318115, -0.026107788, 0.010925293, 0.016143799, -0.044311523, -0.025314331, -0.04071045, -0.0013427734, 0.023391724, -0.021850586, 0.04888916, 0.0046691895, -0.011352539, 0.046020508, -0.06866455, -0.01486969, -0.03189087, -0.03100586, -0.013511658, -0.021697998, -0.01914978, -0.024124146, 0.0034599304, 0.030014038, 0.018966675, -0.018707275, 0.0014047623, -0.013442993, 0.016052246, -0.03845215, 0.02545166, -0.023910522, 0.008346558, 0.030273438, 0.0006070137, -0.00033831596, -0.0028362274, -0.0034160614, -0.026626587, 0.03793335, 0.0059127808, -0.012336731, 0.007270813, -0.03225708, 0.013412476, 0.04171753, -0.047576904, -0.027053833, -0.013259888, 0.005214691, -0.010406494, 0.047973633, -0.007724762, 0.023071289, -0.03616333, -0.028778076, 0.018218994, 0.028671265, -0.05065918, -0.03466797, 0.024169922, -0.0680542, -0.042236328, -0.0026760101, 0.072387695, -0.0034618378, -0.0026245117, 0.04309082, 0.008079529, -0.024963379, 0.06958008, -0.008239746, 0.09051514, -0.025985718, -0.044769287, -0.04107666, -0.012191772, 0.009986877, 0.028182983, -0.0013780594, 0.028945923, 0.014343262, 0.007583618, 0.038360596, -0.009613037, -0.0019664764, -0.034698486, -0.02822876, -0.012191772, -0.007850647, -0.008972168, 0.007980347, -0.033355713, -0.0008225441, 0.03427124, 0.0034217834, 0.008995056, 0.013893127, -0.011390686, 0.022247314, 0.02178955, -0.029067993, 0.05731201, 0.027618408, -0.012710571, -0.000992775, -0.008132935, -0.024597168, 0.02029419, 0.0034236908, -0.013114929, -0.031280518, -0.021881104, 0.05001831, 0.013877869, -0.012054443, 0.011566162, -0.028182983, 0.05908203, 0.009773254, 0.036193848, 0.009246826, 0.037261963, -0.03314209, 0.0211792, -0.027114868, -0.015960693, 0.0011034012, -0.031158447, -0.035858154, 0.017303467, -0.0012836456, 0.012069702, 0.013244629, 0.048797607, 0.0031661987, -0.016525269, 0.005340576, 0.013885498, 0.050354004, 0.02998352, -0.047912598, -0.11468506, 0.003856659, -0.02758789, -0.019424438, -0.005947113, -0.025863647, -0.028686523, 0.01058197, 0.0021209717, -0.0074043274, 0.01473999, 0.009613037, 0.044006348, 0.028152466, 0.011306763, -0.05532837, 0.020812988, -0.021896362, -0.029129028, -0.03137207, -0.0075950623, -0.022064209, -0.01890564, 0.026000977, -0.021621704, -0.024536133, -0.023544312, 0.027130127, 0.004962921, 0.068237305, -0.024002075, -0.0052948, 0.010688782, -0.014762878, 0.038208008, 0.012680054, 0.005016327, 0.018341064, 0.047698975, 0.017501831, -0.0035858154, 0.015174866, 0.011604309, -0.014968872, -0.008583069, -0.013320923, 0.025268555, -0.014472961, -0.009010315, -0.006038666, 0.03643799, 0.06842041, -0.01335144, 0.027389526, 0.029083252, 0.009094238, 0.029144287, -0.0056877136, 0.04473877, 0.022827148, -0.004020691, -0.046325684, 0.020965576, -0.020431519, -0.0029144287, -0.017059326, 0.03491211, 0.030532837, -0.051452637, -0.014602661, -0.00774765, -0.016738892, -0.009231567, -0.01751709, 0.0011148453, -0.021316528, -0.02003479, 0.047088623, -0.04397583, -0.03363037, -0.00484848, -0.025665283, -0.012611389, -0.015380859, 0.026046753, 0.0132369995, 0.03265381, -0.01725769, 0.06756592, -0.012718201, -0.026550293, 0.03024292, -0.042053223, -0.0033874512, 0.034942627, -0.063964844, 0.025512695, 0.05355835, -0.004096985, -0.02192688, 0.039398193, -0.03475952, 0.027038574, 0.0016717911, -0.05343628, -0.044830322, 0.0055274963, 0.0007572174, 0.02180481, 0.052612305, 0.014656067, -0.0003657341, -0.016159058, -0.014472961, 0.021408081, 0.026626587, 0.0020122528, -0.031951904, 0.053100586, 0.0046195984, -0.024673462, 0.014846802, -0.052215576, -0.061279297, -0.05065918, -0.020843506, -0.05319214, 0.03277588, -0.0016231537, -0.028152466, 0.009788513, 0.007358551, -0.015777588, 0.014533997, 0.009384155, -0.023422241, -0.020355225, -0.026809692, 0.0146484375, 0.007926941, 0.048309326, -0.004184723, -0.0036468506, 0.034851074, 0.022918701, -0.052124023, -0.0065994263, -0.019088745, 0.0078086853, -0.025436401, -0.056549072, -0.034423828, 0.04647827, -0.00002360344, 0.036224365, 0.0013494492, -0.01083374, 0.014831543, -0.0030517578, -0.057861328, 0.031066895, -0.014633179, -0.05105591, -0.009727478, -0.00894928, -0.055541992, 0.020889282, 0.029373169, 0.025421143, 0.038909912, -0.011665344, 0.007118225, 0.010375977, -0.07336426, 0.009788513, 0.008285522, 0.0066719055, 0.024536133, 0.030960083, 0.014305115, 0.05130005, -0.007194519, 0.010223389, 0.014030457, -0.009086609, 0.01689148, -0.008232117, 0.017318726, -0.02798462, 0.010429382, -0.009292603, 0.038208008, -0.0284729, -0.033081055, 0.013168335, -0.011482239, -0.010353088, 0.010116577, 0.02507019, -0.0018815994, 0.020812988, -0.026184082, -0.039611816, -0.026657104, 0.013946533, -0.024276733, -0.026657104, 0.05935669, -0.032592773, -0.043914795, 0.008422852, 0.015304565, 0.069885254, 0.014862061, 0.050323486, -0.040863037, -0.036071777, -0.023803711, 0.0020561218, 0.019226074, 0.045806885, -0.00762558, 0.045715332, -0.0072898865, 0.034179688, 0.032165527, 0.0096206665, -0.0066375732, -0.0035572052, 0.031402588, 0.0071640015, 0.0008792877, 0.000012695789, 0.01864624, -0.04135132, -0.029022217, -0.05114746, -0.029541016, -0.0134887695, -0.006980896, -0.017059326, -0.04449463, 0.07647705, -0.01638794, -0.0040016174, 0.042999268, -0.024917603, 0.10461426, 0.0041656494, -0.011497498, -0.009346008, 0.0053520203, -0.0090408325, 0.013069153, 0.049926758, 0.008056641, 0.015960693, -0.0076446533, -0.034820557, 0.039794922, -0.0046539307, -0.023956299, -0.07299805, 0.0073509216, -0.07116699, -0.044708252, -0.0446167, -0.04232788, 0.05895996, -0.0005927086, -0.0095825195, 0.012039185, 0.046844482, -0.040863037, -0.022064209, 0.011543274, 0.010513306, -0.054840088, 0.042510986, 0.0076522827, -0.020095825, -0.03062439, 0.0031013489, 0.048034668, -0.0007019043, 0.052368164, -0.015525818, 0.0029087067, -0.047973633, -0.05770874, -0.04336548, -0.0033454895, 0.00016784668, -0.030548096, 0.02897644, -0.0009946823, -0.0008997917, 0.023971558, 0.022094727, -0.00034284592, -0.005519867, -0.010826111, -0.0013723373, 0.032226562, -0.0014801025, 0.010124207, 0.012512207, -0.025756836, -0.013450623, 0.036987305, -0.014953613, 0.013755798, -0.03250122, 0.020904541, 0.034484863, 0.052978516, -0.032073975, 0.030334473, 0.021499634, -0.0067634583, 0.05444336, 0.052947998, -0.0018396378, -0.019943237, -0.02558899, -0.023757935, 0.0061950684, -0.0067100525, 0.057128906, -0.0736084, 0.003900528, -0.06762695, 0.10601807, -0.11218262, 0.0029392242, -0.030639648, -0.0390625, 0.015075684, 0.007259369, 0.0096588135, -0.009429932, 0.0068855286, -0.008224487, 0.0074653625, 0.027542114, 0.018615723, 0.007572174, -0.026046753, 0.0070266724, 0.07305908, 0.032470703, 0.12683105, 0.028884888, -0.012611389, 0.05432129, -0.0023441315, -0.02357483, -0.08117676, -0.03152466, -0.01524353, 0.043151855, -0.03277588, 0.0021533966, 0.0057640076, -0.029769897, -0.04660034, 0.025772095, -0.0042152405, -0.020904541, 0.013076782, -0.0038852692, -0.016357422, -0.013847351, 0.0068893433, -0.01083374, -0.0049591064, -0.019302368, -0.028778076, 0.093566895, -0.007610321, 0.007030487, 0.02255249, 0.0143966675, -0.020263672, -0.013435364, -0.026123047, 0.030654907, -0.017578125, 0.024612427, -0.017105103, -0.030731201, 0.007911682, 0.0012464523, 0.018707275, -0.016311646, -0.022323608, -0.019882202, -0.020553589, 0.027786255, -0.009811401, -0.009010315, 0.061035156, 0.07757568, 0.006969452, 0.05606079, -0.015296936, 0.023498535, -0.010314941, -0.022018433, -0.03050232, 0.010101318, 0.0045318604, -0.016418457, 0.01687622, -0.0067596436, -0.06707764, 0.0115356445, -0.040496826, 0.0155181885, -0.008644104, -0.018081665, 0.028381348, 0.012626648, -0.0046043396, 0.06524658, -0.031707764, -0.004058838, 0.023345947, 0.004119873, 0.014442444, -0.016296387, 0.03829956, 0.013679504, 0.0069274902, 0.022033691, 0.022628784, 0.049682617, -0.033325195, 0.009559631, 0.010444641, -0.07324219, -0.023147583, -0.017868042, -0.015930176, 0.018661499, -0.022613525, 0.0073776245, 0.0146484375, -0.032318115, 0.030456543, 0.0074882507, 0.013031006, 0.027328491, 0.024215698, 0.042266846, -0.039733887, 0.011070251 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07066v1
Context Consistency between Training and Testing in Simultaneous Machine Translation
Meizhi Zhong, Lemao Liu, Kehai Chen, Mingming Yang, Min Zhang
cs.CL
Simultaneous Machine Translation (SiMT) aims to yield a real-time partial translation with a monotonically growing the source-side context. However, there is a counterintuitive phenomenon about the context usage between training and testing: e.g., the wait-k testing model consistently trained with wait-k is much worse than that model inconsistently trained with wait-k' (k' is not equal to k) in terms of translation quality. To this end, we first investigate the underlying reasons behind this phenomenon and uncover the following two factors: 1) the limited correlation between translation quality and training (cross-entropy) loss; 2) exposure bias between training and testing. Based on both reasons, we then propose an effective training approach called context consistency training accordingly, which makes consistent the context usage between training and testing by optimizing translation quality and latency as bi-objectives and exposing the predictions to the model during the training. The experiments on three language pairs demonstrate our intuition: our system encouraging context consistency outperforms that existing systems with context inconsistency for the first time, with the help of our context consistency training approach.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07066v1
2023-11-13T04:11:32
2023-11-13T04:11:32
{ "title": [ -0.03265381, -0.0066184998, -0.02607727, -0.072021484, -0.011543274, 0.006340027, -0.04083252, 0.008338928, -0.033569336, 0.05847168, -0.008979797, 0.022109985, 0.018051147, -0.012252808, -0.029129028, 0.0016832352, -0.014129639, 0.02848816, -0.037963867, -0.048950195, 0.015274048, -0.068725586, 0.0049743652, 0.022903442, 0.025848389, -0.0670166, -0.06994629, -0.0042304993, -0.04107666, -0.039093018, -0.009025574, 0.05303955, 0.038146973, 0.025878906, -0.039276123, -0.036346436, -0.046936035, 0.017120361, -0.034118652, 0.02456665, 0.016708374, -0.009124756, -0.0067367554, -0.004753113, -0.030349731, 0.008720398, -0.038391113, -0.03503418, -0.017684937, 0.046966553, 0.020248413, 0.032714844, 0.0055885315, 0.030914307, 0.03237915, -0.016571045, -0.03543091, 0.0041656494, 0.03353882, 0.06506348, 0.034362793, -0.026733398, -0.00032687187, -0.025985718, 0.0001386404, -0.023742676, 0.0037975311, 0.024841309, 0.031799316, 0.015007019, -0.007194519, 0.010467529, 0.0060272217, -0.03414917, -0.017059326, 0.015090942, 0.026031494, -0.0068359375, 0.022781372, -0.029953003, 0.04525757, -0.0020332336, 0.01537323, -0.0032787323, 0.022155762, -0.013404846, 0.008384705, -0.022918701, -0.05859375, -0.073913574, -0.01953125, -0.028442383, -0.053833008, -0.023132324, -0.022659302, -0.04751587, 0.013549805, 0.03982544, 0.007987976, -0.031204224, -0.046691895, 0.030029297, -0.06286621, -0.020935059, 0.021438599, -0.010147095, -0.022567749, -0.029388428, 0.032073975, 0.035308838, -0.05557251, 0.054016113, 0.0042648315, -0.029083252, 0.007255554, 0.012817383, -0.0032539368, 0.009475708, 0.020721436, -0.013633728, 0.006336212, -0.014701843, 0.042388916, 0.015144348, 0.018188477, 0.02079773, -0.045928955, -0.027145386, -0.011009216, 0.031829834, 0.01826477, 0.041503906, -0.092163086, -0.066101074, -0.0473938, 0.031188965, -0.005683899, -0.003835678, -0.032073975, 0.037719727, -0.0041236877, -0.022644043, 0.028427124, -0.008659363, -0.038970947, 0.037322998, 0.06817627, -0.013977051, -0.0836792, -0.076538086, -0.029251099, -0.018615723, 0.016174316, -0.007675171, -0.024505615, -0.02571106, -0.105163574, -0.0006875992, 0.033203125, 0.017593384, -0.013710022, 0.0068244934, 0.017364502, -0.01928711, 0.00712204, -0.0021629333, 0.019927979, 0.0065612793, 0.009262085, 0.004924774, -0.05517578, 0.057250977, 0.035308838, -0.012962341, -0.010101318, -0.010910034, 0.0038146973, 0.022994995, 0.0046844482, -0.024017334, 0.016357422, -0.029251099, 0.0040245056, 0.030670166, -0.05810547, -0.031051636, -0.013671875, 0.012840271, 0.056671143, 0.019515991, -0.036590576, 0.0076675415, -0.028900146, -0.011146545, -0.004486084, 0.005329132, -0.055358887, 0.01977539, -0.013092041, -0.0184021, -0.019897461, 0.0041618347, -0.02784729, 0.00058555603, -0.019882202, -0.029922485, -0.019897461, 0.015289307, -0.047302246, 0.02281189, 0.050476074, -0.025939941, -0.024993896, 0.02180481, -0.0009841919, -0.074523926, 0.017349243, -0.009414673, 0.005569458, -0.014450073, -0.013053894, -0.010307312, -0.013244629, 0.015174866, 0.0006403923, 0.033447266, -0.02458191, 0.012390137, 0.03692627, 0.029830933, 0.07385254, -0.03942871, 0.04248047, 0.0040016174, -0.033325195, -0.015403748, -0.025039673, -0.0052986145, -0.011291504, 0.02243042, -0.00365448, -0.01927185, -0.020706177, 0.03466797, 0.01235199, 0.019348145, 0.018966675, 0.014282227, 0.0289917, 0.057769775, 0.051239014, -0.014907837, 0.030685425, -0.041381836, 0.03062439, 0.014266968, -0.018722534, -0.016113281, 0.0099105835, -0.043029785, 0.03692627, -0.04220581, -0.025756836, -0.00793457, -0.024749756, 0.0014705658, -0.022399902, -0.0068855286, -0.025680542, 0.010986328, 0.03173828, -0.0068473816, 0.004135132, -0.00466156, -0.009124756, -0.017669678, -0.018829346, 0.019882202, 0.03253174, -0.048339844, -0.011947632, 0.011154175, 0.052520752, -0.008522034, 0.012809753, 0.050628662, 0.03164673, -0.051818848, -0.018051147, -0.046813965, 0.024765015, -0.0031394958, -0.00881958, 0.0013179779, 0.02545166, -0.042236328, 0.08270264, 0.068359375, -0.029663086, 0.033996582, -0.034454346, 0.02293396, 0.016067505, -0.008056641, 0.007259369, 0.029022217, 0.040130615, -0.007598877, -0.027114868, 0.040100098, -0.059143066, -0.00059080124, -0.0010881424, -0.013656616, -0.05758667, -0.052612305, -0.017532349, -0.04071045, -0.061279297, 0.0077323914, 0.06744385, -0.0006222725, -0.019241333, 0.011756897, 0.013015747, -0.01184082, -0.0029449463, -0.032684326, 0.014907837, 0.012161255, 0.027313232, 0.018051147, -0.08166504, -0.031341553, -0.0018053055, 0.013320923, -0.008102417, -0.0038776398, -0.010192871, 0.015609741, 0.0018930435, -0.0062446594, 0.016433716, -0.04458618, 0.00774765, -0.032073975, 0.0143585205, 0.006023407, -0.03213501, 0.01398468, 0.004463196, -0.027313232, 0.013000488, 0.027191162, 0.07989502, -0.04144287, -0.05142212, 0.08709717, 0.052581787, 0.023864746, 0.043151855, 0.015235901, 0.027435303, -0.03062439, -0.030548096, -0.049072266, -0.007270813, -0.009880066, 0.02268982, 0.04751587, 0.0060272217, -0.0077705383, -0.03741455, -0.008300781, 0.031188965, -0.03933716, 0.0010356903, -0.013938904, -0.039398193, -0.025680542, 0.02027893, 0.010017395, -0.027420044, -0.024475098, 0.034332275, 0.03390503, 0.027999878, 0.028320312, 0.010101318, -0.008300781, -0.007434845, 0.024414062, -0.013282776, -0.017181396, 0.024627686, 0.00932312, -0.024490356, -0.011306763, -0.056152344, -0.0024471283, 0.09680176, 0.0021591187, -0.03793335, 0.061157227, -0.082458496, 0.034973145, 0.03552246, -0.004096985, 0.014427185, 0.03857422, 0.010505676, -0.017929077, -0.007736206, -0.036834717, 0.025299072, -0.03564453, -0.118774414, 0.03414917, -0.0546875, 0.011222839, 0.024887085, -0.007904053, -0.05722046, 0.00079774857, 0.011604309, 0.07397461, 0.03149414, -0.0062294006, 0.044311523, -0.016952515, 0.016326904, -0.012557983, -0.012565613, -0.004169464, -0.0016975403, 0.05831909, 0.0043640137, 0.047607422, 0.03378296, -0.021621704, 0.00064754486, 0.0024375916, -0.016601562, 0.006591797, -0.015625, -0.03286743, -0.004432678, 0.01663208, 0.011734009, 0.029830933, -0.02607727, 0.0024909973, -0.046936035, 0.0065193176, -0.037353516, 0.024795532, -0.004611969, 0.024398804, -0.01902771, -0.031463623, 0.018310547, -0.033447266, -0.03881836, 0.024368286, 0.04006958, 0.034301758, -0.029693604, 0.0017080307, -0.04537964, 0.022781372, 0.030654907, -0.04031372, 0.00021827221, -0.010246277, 0.029785156, -0.0025310516, -0.030639648, -0.0021152496, -0.0047187805, 0.021774292, -0.00033783913, 0.0013942719, -0.02192688, -0.06451416, -0.006843567, 0.0054512024, -0.10015869, -0.014518738, 0.021514893, -0.009941101, -0.0023117065, -0.03677368, 0.03918457, -0.02368164, -0.0038871765, 0.0036754608, -0.019180298, -0.008995056, -0.012145996, -0.076416016, -0.002779007, 0.076049805, 0.013282776, 0.020126343, 0.045440674, -0.003835678, -0.04272461, -0.025726318, 0.031158447, 0.0020561218, 0.0017089844, 0.00308609, -0.03250122, -0.0016107559, -0.021697998, 0.030059814, 0.0317688, -0.045166016, 0.019424438, 0.008132935, 0.03326416, 0.037719727, -0.012718201, 0.0345459, 0.03652954, -0.037872314, -0.047729492, 0.0032844543, -0.040100098, -0.03552246, 0.031280518, 0.011306763, -0.0033416748, 0.0036468506, 0.0055007935, 0.072753906, -0.017974854, 0.004650116, 0.022125244, -0.015388489, -0.027038574, -0.0056419373, 0.04574585, 0.029205322, 0.0061836243, 0.024459839, -0.02722168, 0.020858765, -0.0013608932, -0.019622803, -0.0029411316, 0.01348114, -0.039642334, -0.016815186, -0.064086914, 0.00945282, -0.002319336, 0.014923096, -0.03955078, 0.029037476, 0.024215698, -0.0048713684, -0.026031494, 0.03463745, 0.0104904175, 0.005947113, -0.027740479, -0.06915283, -0.01802063, 0.014755249, -0.06713867, -0.031234741, -0.06604004, -0.027313232, 0.029281616, -0.0049209595, -0.011802673, 0.0047836304, 0.025222778, 0.027496338, 0.01486969, 0.0015649796, -0.012435913, 0.032836914, -0.027450562, -0.029449463, 0.017547607, 0.0012464523, -0.018096924, -0.013183594, 0.04647827, -0.029205322, -0.015960693, -0.038757324, 0.029571533, -0.023834229, 0.048980713, -0.005519867, 0.011314392, 0.025115967, -0.031982422, 0.021209717, -0.0016841888, -0.034423828, 0.060424805, 0.03756714, 0.024154663, 0.0014228821, 0.0034618378, 0.018203735, 0.020950317, 0.009162903, -0.02015686, 0.01737976, -0.0020217896, 0.0017929077, 0.011955261, -0.016342163, -0.04824829, -0.038024902, -0.0008158684, 0.005695343, 0.043273926, -0.005016327, 0.041931152, -0.008544922, -0.00932312, -0.011650085, -0.026687622, 0.04309082, -0.03817749, 0.039215088, -0.06463623, -0.012954712, 0.0034236908, 0.0005927086, -0.053375244, -0.010810852, -0.019088745, -0.02760315, 0.03189087, 0.04043579, 0.049102783, -0.0181427, -0.026000977, -0.018859863, -0.0022239685, -0.018829346, -0.044891357, -0.020141602, 0.014259338, 0.020690918, -0.026565552, 0.039733887, -0.028823853, -0.0037326813, -0.02532959, -0.010932922, 0.00793457, -0.056640625, 0.03024292, 0.06732178, 0.0001103878, 0.039978027, -0.026931763, 0.03793335, 0.029632568, 0.05987549, 0.013870239, -0.008872986, 0.04537964, -0.032836914, -0.013877869, 0.014839172, 0.049468994, -0.024719238, 0.028839111, 0.0027542114, 0.00029706955, -0.053222656, 0.016784668, 0.034179688, 0.010017395, 0.013999939, -0.05340576, 0.018508911, 0.0009889603, -0.019973755, 0.03591919, -0.04901123, -0.017150879, -0.012298584, -0.012969971, -0.051483154, 0.017837524, -0.012413025, -0.054992676, -0.0011110306, 0.001745224, 0.0026874542, -0.018844604, 0.021270752, 0.025222778, -0.015159607, 0.01977539, 0.042816162, -0.03729248, 0.0149383545, -0.01739502, 0.0005774498, 0.03137207, 0.050628662, -0.06567383, -0.013687134, 0.035186768, -0.008621216, 0.017501831, 0.020553589, 0.010139465, -0.023239136, 0.0032901764, -0.02885437, -0.009338379, 0.018493652, 0.030456543, -0.025268555, -0.03643799, 0.018844604, -0.017288208, -0.029663086, 0.003293991, 0.029556274, -0.0018157959, 0.017944336, 0.0047302246, 0.0059013367, 0.011650085, 0.010055542, 0.017303467, 0.0031147003, -0.028823853, -0.0015478134, 0.028839111, 0.00434494, 0.009437561, 0.06341553, 0.046722412, 0.036895752, -0.012626648, 0.029556274, 0.036743164, -0.032073975, -0.041992188, -0.025909424, 0.0030384064, -0.008895874, 0.0619812, -0.009918213, -0.029281616, -0.031219482, -0.038116455, -0.028381348, 0.007507324, 0.015625, -0.0036182404, -0.0077056885, -0.012329102, 0.022491455, -0.010688782, -0.023162842, -0.06854248, 0.014518738, -0.013580322, -0.014007568, 0.0725708, -0.0034255981, -0.036499023, 0.028945923, 0.038391113, 0.061340332, -0.017837524, 0.068359375, -0.057006836, -0.015640259, -0.017456055, -0.024902344, 0.01222229, 0.021072388, -0.040283203, 0.005065918, -0.01727295, 0.062927246, 0.024642944, 0.014694214, 0.04019165, 0.019424438, -0.0036449432, -0.002658844, 0.0010004044, -0.01965332, 0.001958847, -0.032196045, -0.010391235, -0.049102783, -0.009254456, -0.08526611, 0.008293152, 0.017852783, 0.043914795, -0.013023376, 0.010894775, -0.022399902, 0.004295349, 0.03265381, 0.032928467, 0.068359375, 0.026885986, -0.004348755, -0.002691269, -0.01966858, 0.03543091, 0.041046143, 0.011405945, 0.012466431, 0.0011806488, -0.04446411, 0.0049209595, 0.0023117065, 0.046936035, -0.056640625, -0.037628174, -0.029876709, 0.03024292, 0.0047721863, 0.06744385, 0.031280518, 0.002696991, -0.028671265, -0.00019192696, -0.019241333, -0.03439331, -0.02128601, -0.008018494, 0.026123047, -0.07342529, 0.025665283, -0.019699097, -0.014007568, -0.00932312, 0.059814453, 0.004459381, -0.046020508, 0.0048179626, 0.037139893, 0.012809753, 0.015487671, 0.013710022, -0.03062439, -0.04425049, 0.00068473816, 0.06414795, -0.03149414, 0.019119263, -0.029327393, 0.034942627, 0.009971619, -0.0025081635, -0.00019025803, 0.0055236816, -0.012260437, 0.028930664, -0.014831543, 0.009475708, -0.029846191, -0.036254883, -0.015510559, 0.0121154785, -0.035888672, -0.03173828, 0.023086548, 0.046813965, 0.011383057, 0.061523438, 0.0067481995, -0.021011353, -0.007381439, -0.017669678, 0.036132812, 0.0035152435, -0.025848389, 0.013412476, -0.045288086, -0.039093018, 0.031921387, -0.056549072, 0.054382324, -0.03277588, -0.006126404, -0.06921387, 0.050964355, -0.0005950928, -0.06427002, -0.014663696, -0.046936035, -0.034454346, -0.013114929, 0.009109497, 0.012313843, -0.013679504, -0.004917145, 0.023742676, 0.021316528, -0.0060920715, 0.016967773, -0.019317627, -0.08099365, 0.0022468567, -0.02911377, 0.036499023, -0.034698486, -0.0054512024, 0.01676941, -0.011390686, -0.0013561249, -0.022140503, -0.03274536, -0.0055618286, -0.0039138794, -0.04623413, 0.011306763, 0.012290955, -0.03555298, -0.051757812, -0.024505615, 0.0066337585, -0.04248047, -0.032409668, -0.006515503, -0.043945312, -0.015670776, -0.012954712, -0.039886475, 0.007331848, 0.054260254, -0.018310547, 0.019515991, 0.011444092, -0.037261963, -0.01373291, 0.011886597, 0.03414917, -0.0048103333, -0.026428223, 0.02104187, 0.01058197, 0.037353516, -0.05114746, -0.07159424, 0.0017604828, 0.028503418, -0.04852295, 0.046081543, 0.042053223, 0.027236938, 0.030044556, 0.05267334, -0.0038032532, -0.057647705, 0.018295288, 0.019256592, 0.033477783, 0.060913086, -0.0110321045, 0.017364502, 0.021469116, -0.022750854, -0.015029907, 0.0079574585, -0.014472961, -0.010810852, 0.0071411133, 0.021011353, -0.010276794, -0.036071777, -0.08215332, 0.061645508, -0.01737976, -0.0017557144, -0.006919861, 0.039123535, -0.019332886, 0.027420044, 0.0028495789, 0.0012683868, 0.02357483, -0.000056922436, 0.040374756, -0.026611328, 0.037139893, -0.015777588, -0.015914917, -0.012794495, 0.016784668, -0.0014257431, 0.013153076, -0.044830322, 0.011688232, -0.062408447, -0.018051147, 0.03149414, -0.022720337, 0.05419922, -0.04449463, -0.017227173, -0.05230713, -0.016723633, -0.0035495758, 0.007534027, 0.028823853, -0.033203125, -0.03781128, -0.0027618408, 0.04071045, -0.007358551 ], "summary": [ 0.028076172, -0.030670166, -0.001294136, -0.040161133, -0.039733887, 0.0067253113, -0.03338623, -0.004611969, -0.052124023, 0.08874512, 0.008659363, 0.014083862, 0.040924072, -0.013633728, -0.017837524, -0.007156372, -0.012817383, 0.025100708, 0.0005455017, -0.040161133, 0.02079773, -0.06097412, -0.003786087, -0.012557983, 0.012779236, -0.051330566, -0.042541504, -0.012023926, -0.0056152344, 0.020767212, 0.0052719116, 0.015388489, 0.038024902, 0.011375427, -0.05529785, -0.057861328, -0.032470703, -0.0005059242, -0.044036865, 0.053741455, 0.014030457, 0.0061912537, 0.0418396, -0.027236938, -0.012489319, 0.0126953125, -0.031219482, -0.050354004, -0.00009858608, 0.044677734, 0.014976501, 0.020751953, 0.005847931, 0.010307312, 0.0026073456, -0.0022945404, -0.049835205, 0.018936157, 0.0016212463, 0.08959961, 0.04989624, 0.017028809, -0.0149002075, -0.030380249, 0.040527344, -0.0121536255, 0.053497314, 0.024368286, -0.01386261, 0.032470703, 0.037231445, 0.006088257, 0.015853882, -0.08630371, 0.0041885376, 0.07086182, -0.015731812, 0.0022125244, 0.019454956, -0.04901123, 0.038116455, 0.026901245, -0.018615723, 0.0070114136, -0.043151855, -0.01197052, -0.0065727234, -0.026306152, -0.047424316, -0.056640625, -0.027053833, -0.01612854, -0.06695557, -0.035614014, 0.018585205, -0.067993164, 0.017547607, -0.0016088486, 0.026824951, -0.01499939, -0.02444458, -0.01878357, -0.03149414, -0.0115737915, 0.014335632, -0.02293396, -0.031707764, -0.030715942, 0.04348755, 0.02798462, -0.033111572, 0.017807007, -0.004211426, -0.036499023, -0.011390686, 0.011123657, 0.006023407, -0.010559082, 0.007987976, -0.04437256, 0.02029419, 0.024429321, 0.0335083, 0.046844482, -0.0060310364, 0.045776367, -0.007007599, -0.057861328, -0.02758789, 0.01550293, 0.0052337646, 0.023773193, -0.024307251, 0.008605957, -0.023803711, -0.008674622, 0.026489258, -0.000192523, 0.0018091202, 0.009178162, 0.013908386, -0.022583008, -0.0014972687, 0.012756348, -0.019714355, 0.044311523, 0.03677368, -0.016815186, -0.04901123, -0.04458618, 0.0006327629, -0.04031372, 0.017456055, -0.052581787, -0.012817383, -0.062683105, -0.08758545, 0.009140015, 0.045318604, 0.033721924, -0.013839722, 0.0061569214, 0.01838684, -0.00035762787, -0.0158844, -0.015045166, 0.04309082, -0.008514404, -0.0015592575, -0.04650879, -0.040649414, 0.06329346, 0.031829834, -0.017471313, 0.005832672, -0.0075569153, -0.0016765594, 0.05770874, -0.011253357, -0.028686523, -0.0063972473, -0.041107178, 0.029953003, -0.006542206, -0.027770996, 0.011154175, -0.033569336, 0.026382446, 0.06286621, 0.0042381287, -0.023590088, -0.029586792, -0.0390625, 0.039520264, 0.023803711, 0.02885437, -0.08074951, 0.021942139, -0.023895264, -0.058532715, 0.011260986, -0.014945984, -0.013473511, -0.00699234, -0.07098389, -0.010025024, -0.038330078, 0.022247314, -0.06323242, -0.013504028, 0.02961731, -0.03842163, -0.010299683, -0.005958557, 0.005783081, -0.013069153, 0.02709961, -0.0357666, 0.023956299, -0.014282227, 0.012794495, 0.016326904, -0.03543091, 0.023010254, -0.038757324, 0.02519226, -0.019958496, 0.035095215, 0.010314941, 0.031280518, 0.052978516, -0.04333496, 0.010124207, 0.0099487305, -0.04815674, -0.003929138, -0.035186768, -0.00409317, -0.016906738, 0.02861023, 0.021316528, -0.016403198, -0.043151855, 0.016220093, -0.033203125, 0.0013113022, 0.013343811, 0.009666443, 0.016143799, 0.049346924, 0.028259277, -0.03643799, -0.005771637, -0.08306885, 0.013221741, -0.011772156, -0.01852417, -0.0060157776, 0.020645142, -0.058441162, 0.021560669, -0.076416016, -0.023620605, -0.021347046, 0.018966675, -0.057617188, -0.014266968, -0.037963867, -0.017288208, -0.020187378, 0.038726807, -0.0357666, 0.0005469322, -0.04724121, -0.03491211, -0.042663574, -0.022094727, 0.02935791, 0.050994873, -0.0423584, -0.018203735, -0.02015686, -0.00217247, -0.02279663, 0.026290894, 0.038024902, 0.02645874, -0.048065186, 0.019851685, 0.020568848, 0.02784729, -0.00093126297, 0.0012321472, -0.0018262863, 0.040649414, -0.03010559, 0.058258057, 0.028518677, -0.010772705, 0.011001587, 0.06213379, 0.032226562, -0.016204834, 0.0063667297, 0.020217896, 0.026657104, 0.051727295, -0.017349243, 0.010391235, 0.062805176, -0.076049805, 0.0048294067, 0.019165039, 0.072143555, -0.06463623, -0.06304932, -0.012527466, 0.033843994, -0.015975952, 0.04373169, 0.09185791, 0.018585205, 0.02671814, 0.018432617, 0.022628784, -0.044921875, 0.037963867, -0.023254395, -0.0013628006, 0.0008044243, -0.053985596, -0.016403198, -0.049957275, 0.03878784, -0.011207581, 0.0016374588, 0.012512207, -0.010482788, 0.0066986084, 0.005180359, 0.020446777, 0.006954193, -0.014663696, -0.036193848, -0.011444092, -0.03024292, 0.014907837, -0.004470825, -0.023269653, 0.026275635, -0.0022907257, -0.019699097, -0.019210815, 0.029037476, 0.033477783, -0.020095825, -0.00079250336, 0.087524414, 0.060394287, 0.019882202, 0.021575928, 0.016082764, 0.010360718, -0.05596924, -0.017196655, -0.009147644, -0.018722534, 0.006614685, 0.023361206, 0.017974854, 0.033447266, 0.013122559, -0.0040130615, -0.017669678, 0.00440979, -0.046325684, 0.047668457, 0.0008163452, -0.042541504, 0.010398865, 0.018829346, 0.021484375, -0.022644043, -0.025497437, 0.055725098, 0.017150879, 0.037597656, 0.07714844, 0.016998291, -0.019348145, -0.023040771, 0.025939941, -0.025344849, -0.034088135, 0.013702393, 0.01725769, 0.03543091, 0.00025701523, 0.01826477, -0.05126953, 0.086364746, 0.024261475, 0.000045359135, 0.0362854, -0.023529053, 0.057525635, 0.053344727, 0.010047913, 0.009231567, 0.014541626, 0.04031372, -0.025146484, 0.022415161, -0.032196045, 0.021224976, -0.044555664, -0.01461792, 0.008644104, -0.027938843, 0.020599365, 0.0063667297, 0.039855957, -0.03314209, 0.0046310425, 0.043823242, 0.08081055, -0.03942871, -0.042663574, 0.012962341, -0.00059986115, -0.009468079, 0.003643036, -0.013290405, 0.031311035, -0.010986328, 0.07373047, 0.0143585205, -0.015419006, 0.039001465, -0.062347412, -0.016159058, -0.0368042, -0.0041236877, -0.025634766, -0.011314392, 0.007911682, -0.00374794, 0.009346008, 0.036895752, 0.022628784, -0.016540527, -0.013664246, -0.029754639, 0.023147583, -0.04574585, 0.041259766, -0.026229858, 0.037139893, 0.048828125, -0.0335083, 0.002193451, -0.030014038, -0.008422852, 0.02104187, 0.02456665, 0.054260254, -0.040985107, 0.027328491, -0.015083313, -0.002658844, 0.04977417, -0.051239014, -0.045135498, -0.0033550262, 0.006713867, -0.0005083084, 0.019760132, 0.035705566, -0.0077209473, -0.01828003, -0.04446411, 0.021484375, -0.023208618, -0.051757812, -0.005962372, 0.003528595, -0.04663086, -0.021270752, 0.0104599, 0.023391724, -0.0023765564, -0.015029907, 0.057495117, -0.013893127, 0.017044067, 0.0064811707, -0.027191162, 0.041290283, 0.010696411, -0.037078857, -0.0073928833, -0.0082092285, 0.037506104, -0.011192322, -0.002067566, 0.022583008, -0.006793976, 0.00038218498, 0.012710571, -0.018569946, -0.006313324, -0.022079468, -0.013137817, -0.025100708, -0.0023479462, 0.021606445, 0.038208008, -0.05419922, 0.033721924, 0.0064888, 0.04888916, 0.047729492, -0.002363205, -0.0069236755, 0.03768921, -0.018203735, -0.022415161, -0.00092601776, -0.03353882, -0.0619812, 0.021636963, 0.0368042, -0.03970337, 0.015716553, 0.014038086, 0.022827148, -0.013954163, 0.020080566, 0.02885437, 0.022155762, -0.03555298, -0.028167725, 0.03869629, 0.029464722, -0.0026855469, 0.031341553, -0.03253174, -0.0012521744, -0.013282776, -0.0030517578, -0.015945435, -0.003894806, 0.00053977966, -0.0340271, -0.051330566, 0.07904053, 0.013069153, -0.0058174133, -0.024627686, 0.024612427, -0.02154541, -0.0072021484, 0.013618469, 0.039916992, 0.007270813, 0.042877197, -0.08703613, -0.07800293, -0.042053223, 0.011367798, -0.04321289, -0.017868042, -0.07745361, -0.04812622, -0.015426636, 0.0095825195, 0.009895325, 0.012611389, -0.0019302368, -0.017074585, -0.015457153, 0.019546509, 0.010063171, 0.012962341, -0.06109619, 0.017044067, 0.028884888, 0.006099701, -0.021820068, 0.014961243, 0.054229736, -0.014976501, -0.023162842, -0.027832031, 0.019515991, -0.0035209656, 0.037322998, -0.007217407, 0.015106201, 0.022521973, -0.012145996, 0.026641846, -0.0061073303, -0.011871338, 0.05053711, 0.053619385, 0.03062439, 0.031311035, -0.029846191, -0.007713318, 0.017440796, -0.02381897, 0.0039043427, 0.006816864, -0.007411957, 0.023803711, 0.022125244, -0.031982422, 0.011451721, -0.023406982, 0.020751953, 0.009811401, 0.008354187, 0.018188477, 0.023757935, 0.020721436, -0.00434494, -0.0015487671, -0.01576233, 0.003030777, -0.034057617, 0.0071372986, -0.06274414, 0.01638794, -0.012710571, -0.003572464, -0.05722046, -0.02116394, -0.032806396, -0.072631836, 0.0423584, 0.0001950264, 0.028427124, -0.046051025, -0.047058105, -0.017547607, -0.0043563843, 0.00060653687, -0.02520752, -0.037384033, -0.012573242, 0.02116394, 0.023101807, 0.010284424, -0.0014591217, 0.010398865, -0.01625061, 0.017868042, -0.0335083, -0.014427185, -0.025787354, -0.0037078857, -0.016036987, 0.004924774, -0.0005803108, 0.015357971, -0.025222778, 0.03479004, -0.020553589, -0.015655518, 0.018325806, -0.03479004, -0.03274536, 0.010513306, 0.009803772, 0.024353027, -0.008041382, 0.009231567, -0.022491455, 0.011375427, 0.011238098, 0.014587402, 0.012207031, 0.005393982, -0.026016235, 0.024459839, -0.025314331, 0.0026607513, 0.052368164, 0.0032444, -0.012283325, -0.045318604, 0.02507019, -0.08178711, -0.014404297, 0.008872986, -0.027313232, 0.012786865, 0.004173279, -0.01184845, -0.021270752, 0.027679443, 0.029083252, 0.0073509216, -0.011604309, 0.011238098, -0.051696777, 0.0209198, -0.02217102, 0.0138549805, -0.017654419, 0.019836426, -0.058563232, -0.011795044, 0.024353027, 0.0309906, 0.028045654, -0.0057754517, 0.014404297, 0.0064201355, 0.014038086, -0.012123108, 0.007282257, 0.020065308, 0.027816772, -0.028442383, -0.01852417, 0.030181885, -0.012748718, -0.042144775, 0.0066604614, 0.0011367798, -0.05505371, 0.020767212, 0.018875122, 0.020431519, 0.03010559, -0.03062439, 0.013343811, 0.013961792, -0.0014019012, 0.018157959, 0.029815674, 0.015777588, -0.002368927, 0.074401855, 0.030029297, 0.03955078, -0.011474609, 0.007820129, -0.025939941, 0.038482666, -0.028930664, -0.020599365, 0.025115967, -0.0109939575, 0.0059165955, 0.009468079, -0.02017212, -0.0038585663, -0.0032958984, 0.006416321, -0.014152527, -0.024398804, -0.026428223, -0.02848816, 0.025863647, 0.014839172, 0.020767212, -0.018722534, -0.05114746, 0.010147095, -0.014579773, -0.0056419373, 0.052581787, -0.0051345825, -0.05102539, 0.04562378, 0.04473877, 0.043762207, -0.02381897, 0.0690918, -0.001499176, -0.009941101, 0.008216858, 0.035583496, 0.0152282715, -0.0070381165, -0.019088745, -0.029937744, -0.0074501038, 0.046813965, 0.0121154785, -0.021194458, 0.013511658, 0.018341064, 0.010284424, 0.0024147034, 0.008155823, 0.001156807, 0.011184692, 0.02671814, -0.0847168, -0.036834717, -0.05682373, -0.02420044, -0.010475159, 0.0013685226, 0.02609253, 0.018692017, 0.008613586, 0.006565094, 0.04763794, -0.05758667, 0.008590698, 0.00920105, 0.04586792, 0.0027370453, 0.000562191, -0.008621216, -0.0070533752, 0.042755127, 0.01020813, 0.02619934, 0.035888672, -0.007980347, 0.0052833557, -0.027374268, 0.025009155, -0.08557129, -0.011276245, -0.021133423, 0.015357971, 0.013015747, 0.07696533, 0.010787964, -0.019363403, 0.007068634, -0.005756378, -0.012077332, 0.015449524, -0.06222534, 0.050476074, 0.031707764, -0.072143555, 0.01675415, 0.027191162, -0.009544373, 0.0050086975, 0.026733398, 0.034698486, -0.060546875, -0.002248764, 0.02619934, 0.00014233589, -0.022247314, -0.017593384, -0.030700684, -0.030227661, 0.021514893, 0.03665161, -0.020263672, 0.009674072, -0.025054932, -0.008354187, 0.029388428, -0.0037841797, 0.0129470825, 0.028900146, 0.035186768, 0.049224854, -0.014060974, -0.003358841, -0.027954102, -0.03366089, 0.0011377335, 0.009101868, 0.00005120039, -0.01360321, 0.015586853, 0.06640625, 0.023925781, 0.039855957, -0.06347656, 0.004009247, 0.059173584, 0.021133423, 0.036254883, -0.028289795, -0.015052795, 0.012275696, -0.037078857, -0.0018005371, 0.011108398, -0.040496826, 0.023529053, -0.051696777, 0.011070251, -0.05593872, 0.042755127, -0.047943115, -0.04046631, -0.031204224, -0.038757324, -0.053009033, 0.005470276, 0.027664185, -0.008628845, -0.016235352, -0.012496948, 0.011955261, 0.006084442, 0.008468628, 0.05569458, -0.012588501, -0.066589355, -0.0154418945, -0.010665894, 0.03012085, -0.035827637, -0.009941101, 0.045959473, -0.003929138, -0.017044067, -0.025619507, -0.028305054, 0.01966858, -0.003370285, -0.057556152, 0.02557373, 0.013641357, -0.022384644, -0.035339355, -0.018188477, 0.007904053, -0.03111267, -0.013259888, -0.017700195, -0.028549194, -0.0043907166, -0.025497437, -0.012069702, -0.006061554, 0.03265381, -0.02192688, 0.013572693, 0.03665161, -0.08258057, -0.008529663, -0.026885986, 0.015930176, -0.004589081, -0.028717041, 0.027313232, -0.033081055, 0.028259277, -0.018035889, -0.05899048, -0.0017623901, -0.01020813, -0.03451538, 0.00868988, 0.041229248, 0.03338623, 0.03878784, 0.043029785, -0.009628296, -0.050811768, 0.075805664, 0.045410156, 0.028381348, 0.03289795, -0.03945923, 0.039794922, 0.008033752, -0.045806885, -0.044921875, 0.03111267, 0.0032691956, -0.035003662, 0.025817871, 0.0018587112, -0.04296875, -0.0395813, -0.03933716, 0.029190063, -0.020462036, -0.026947021, -0.0061416626, 0.013092041, -0.034606934, -0.020202637, 0.01184845, 0.05529785, -0.009223938, -0.049224854, 0.06365967, -0.10699463, 0.07659912, 0.013809204, -0.018814087, -0.02029419, 0.00843811, 0.0008802414, 0.039276123, -0.06842041, 0.00166893, -0.0524292, 0.015174866, -0.008140564, -0.0034885406, 0.032043457, -0.05090332, -0.01940918, -0.03970337, -0.042755127, 0.017959595, -0.033966064, 0.0062446594, -0.018066406, 0.005241394, -0.017730713, -0.013053894, 0.02998352 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07064v1
PROPANE: Prompt design as an inverse problem
Rimon Melamed, Lucas H. McCabe, Tanay Wakhare, Yejin Kim, H. Howie Huang, Enric Boix-Adsera
cs.CL
Carefully-designed prompts are key to inducing desired behavior in Large Language Models (LLMs). As a result, great effort has been dedicated to engineering prompts that guide LLMs toward particular behaviors. In this work, we propose an automatic prompt optimization framework, PROPANE, which aims to find a prompt that induces semantically similar outputs to a fixed set of examples without user intervention. We further demonstrate that PROPANE can be used to (a) improve existing prompts, and (b) discover semantically obfuscated prompts that transfer between models.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07064v1
2023-11-13T04:08:49
2023-11-13T04:08:49
{ "title": [ -0.0009121895, 0.0017604828, -0.04171753, -0.0031471252, -0.015594482, -0.031341553, -0.0028743744, -0.03186035, -0.031082153, -0.02067566, -0.040924072, -0.008766174, -0.06072998, -0.04534912, 0.01675415, -0.04574585, -0.021255493, 0.042816162, -0.030441284, -0.037963867, -0.038909912, -0.058898926, -0.023498535, 0.0036201477, 0.010520935, 0.035095215, -0.029327393, -0.025344849, -0.0010681152, -0.013916016, 0.008651733, -0.0129776, 0.03778076, 0.032348633, -0.012001038, 0.048858643, -0.012786865, 0.027893066, -0.005744934, 0.03845215, -0.000022232533, 0.009468079, -0.039916992, -0.013252258, -0.06561279, -0.012916565, -0.013031006, 0.01121521, 0.013885498, 0.07531738, -0.019561768, -0.04321289, -0.023635864, 0.05960083, -0.014404297, -0.043151855, -0.012588501, 0.007801056, 0.043792725, -0.0062675476, -0.030151367, -0.022750854, 0.04208374, -0.022781372, 0.004714966, -0.0058555603, -0.017593384, 0.042297363, 0.0463562, 0.025253296, -0.025787354, -0.00630188, -0.011352539, 0.004196167, -0.051849365, 0.010986328, 0.02168274, 0.010498047, 0.035583496, -0.022979736, -0.017852783, 0.0000053048134, -0.036499023, -0.017486572, -0.024673462, -0.026184082, -0.024917603, 0.007411957, -0.037109375, -0.050201416, -0.015296936, 0.032073975, -0.008735657, -0.040161133, -0.043395996, -0.037017822, -0.001996994, -0.0115737915, 0.041625977, -0.028778076, -0.002937317, -0.027633667, -0.024429321, -0.007659912, 0.033447266, 0.018508911, -0.025756836, -0.026412964, 0.042388916, 0.044952393, 0.012565613, 0.06311035, 0.016296387, 0.009796143, 0.035583496, 0.004421234, -0.014274597, 0.048034668, -0.011520386, 0.035308838, -0.022964478, -0.026473999, 0.029129028, -0.05505371, 0.025115967, -0.027740479, -0.05279541, 0.022583008, -0.048461914, -0.0067443848, -0.007827759, 0.06518555, -0.02407837, 0.005428314, -0.02760315, 0.03540039, 0.008880615, -0.027008057, -0.01890564, 0.014846802, 0.016784668, -0.01876831, 0.006072998, -0.030731201, -0.024520874, 0.043182373, 0.03567505, -0.017959595, -0.033996582, -0.051635742, -0.014930725, -0.040252686, 0.012748718, 0.0070762634, -0.061553955, 0.018997192, -0.113342285, 0.015640259, 0.03237915, 0.014007568, -0.015975952, -0.01626587, 0.004032135, 0.02720642, 0.050933838, 0.027999878, 0.0017681122, 0.036590576, 0.01651001, 0.14477539, -0.05404663, 0.033447266, 0.037017822, 0.006164551, -0.024795532, -0.011077881, 0.04800415, -0.013793945, 0.025314331, 0.005962372, 0.016479492, -0.007926941, 0.008392334, 0.03062439, -0.061462402, -0.009773254, -0.0064353943, -0.0059547424, 0.039367676, -0.005645752, -0.007843018, 0.052886963, -0.05722046, -0.022598267, -0.027435303, -0.016525269, -0.0031147003, 0.005622864, 0.00548172, 0.025863647, -0.024978638, 0.020767212, -0.00749588, 0.044769287, 0.014022827, 0.0010690689, 0.0014896393, 0.009666443, 0.02949524, 0.034332275, 0.022964478, -0.014724731, -0.025299072, 0.010955811, -0.040985107, -0.057281494, -0.00059843063, -0.025238037, -0.0038108826, -0.023147583, 0.0124435425, -0.007698059, 0.0019197464, 0.03286743, 0.009277344, -0.01852417, -0.0009012222, -0.039794922, 0.06530762, -0.005760193, 0.09643555, 0.0031280518, 0.04953003, 0.10595703, 0.024002075, 0.008903503, 0.05999756, 0.012413025, 0.0118637085, -0.024124146, 0.004787445, -0.010032654, -0.005996704, 0.026504517, 0.03161621, 0.009185791, 0.04083252, 0.008270264, 0.0362854, -0.009521484, 0.06347656, -0.0022068024, 0.061309814, 0.050079346, 0.036132812, 0.039855957, -0.008972168, 0.0068359375, 0.016662598, 0.009239197, -0.0027065277, 0.043121338, 0.007827759, 0.010787964, 0.004840851, -0.02394104, -0.00920105, 0.0079422, -0.012962341, 0.005420685, 0.031311035, -0.015808105, 0.017181396, -0.04046631, -0.021347046, 0.011192322, -0.047729492, 0.03778076, 0.0473938, -0.05819702, -0.024246216, -0.011192322, 0.033966064, -0.007282257, 0.026687622, 0.046813965, 0.033569336, -0.01739502, -0.004142761, 0.025802612, 0.054718018, 0.017196655, 0.00049829483, 0.019302368, -0.038085938, -0.0030078888, 0.02557373, 0.061920166, -0.016784668, -0.0031337738, -0.07080078, -0.004425049, -0.009162903, 0.016052246, -0.008850098, 0.044708252, 0.0028190613, 0.019470215, -0.002243042, -0.0131073, -0.018218994, 0.008216858, 0.008018494, -0.015098572, 0.012435913, -0.016799927, 0.028793335, 0.021606445, 0.06921387, 0.040649414, 0.07922363, -0.012542725, -0.032440186, -0.057281494, 0.00447464, -0.02494812, -0.09326172, -0.027511597, 0.014175415, -0.02268982, 0.046569824, -0.037139893, -0.06854248, -0.054138184, 0.030548096, 0.012863159, -0.00040602684, 0.035858154, -0.0017910004, -0.0012874603, 0.00015509129, -0.04006958, -0.0073547363, -0.034057617, 0.002483368, -0.048461914, 0.0019798279, -0.0057525635, -0.016952515, -0.0016078949, 0.03503418, -0.030029297, -0.032470703, -0.016433716, 0.03149414, 0.030227661, 0.01550293, 0.0044670105, 0.05609131, -0.017410278, 0.02180481, -0.011978149, -0.019577026, -0.005695343, 0.050201416, -0.050964355, -0.042053223, -0.019989014, -0.012557983, 0.029769897, -0.034362793, -0.0047721863, -0.026519775, -0.004096985, -0.015670776, 0.015266418, 0.028167725, -0.04333496, 0.0050849915, 0.007843018, 0.013252258, 0.026031494, -0.037017822, 0.028671265, 0.111572266, -0.010719299, 0.018005371, 0.046447754, 0.055419922, 0.010894775, -0.004184723, -0.026031494, -0.08306885, -0.0015821457, 0.015045166, 0.0068473816, -0.017303467, -0.016555786, -0.09588623, 0.00033903122, -0.004673004, -0.01473999, -0.00831604, -0.012496948, -0.03540039, -0.016021729, -0.03378296, -0.022781372, 0.032226562, 0.027908325, -0.0034389496, -0.0032176971, 0.02130127, -0.04800415, 0.000059604645, -0.01386261, -0.080444336, 0.0054626465, -0.016860962, -0.00894928, 0.029891968, -0.06323242, -0.0061569214, 0.00844574, -0.028213501, 0.027374268, 0.038513184, 0.034576416, -0.0013303757, -0.01272583, 0.004272461, -0.026367188, -0.02659607, 0.0005393028, 0.032043457, 0.015213013, -0.012413025, -0.013923645, 0.0096206665, -0.019256592, -0.032562256, -0.032165527, -0.023849487, 0.04437256, -0.040008545, 0.010070801, -0.018722534, -0.041412354, 0.0018434525, 0.0056762695, -0.013961792, -0.013961792, -0.012565613, 0.010681152, -0.027420044, 0.08465576, 0.041381836, 0.034423828, 0.0047683716, -0.01687622, -0.011039734, -0.013786316, -0.057373047, 0.006816864, -0.021514893, -0.023880005, 0.080322266, -0.0095825195, -0.018936157, 0.0062561035, -0.044006348, 0.04095459, 0.023757935, 0.016815186, -0.026504517, -0.0018949509, -0.0011577606, 0.012077332, -0.013626099, -0.021194458, 0.042419434, -0.014053345, 0.036834717, -0.031188965, 0.0473938, 0.010505676, -0.063964844, 0.016159058, 0.019104004, -0.0040130615, -0.01763916, -0.01638794, 0.033477783, -0.008964539, -0.006034851, -0.019927979, 0.0056114197, -0.05886841, 0.0069351196, -0.06237793, -0.037231445, 0.05380249, -0.043273926, -0.013465881, 0.013961792, -0.059326172, -0.022476196, -0.032562256, 0.027526855, 0.042297363, 0.02394104, 0.01600647, -0.040100098, 0.018661499, -0.028503418, 0.019577026, 0.013908386, -0.013046265, 0.0073394775, 0.019866943, -0.0066223145, 0.022872925, -0.025802612, 0.064086914, 0.04119873, -0.006263733, -0.08850098, 0.015899658, -0.03781128, -0.009895325, -6.556511e-7, 0.016998291, 0.0056762695, -0.03262329, 0.061676025, 0.03164673, 0.020629883, 0.021316528, -0.0034122467, -0.044281006, -0.017578125, -0.006755829, 0.009895325, -0.020217896, -0.020736694, 0.013511658, 0.0025978088, 0.056640625, -0.003736496, -0.0011949539, 0.0116119385, 0.031280518, -0.047668457, -0.008483887, -0.05621338, 0.0064735413, -0.046844482, 0.002904892, -0.015327454, 0.030197144, 0.022567749, -0.009559631, -0.058013916, 0.010345459, -0.02394104, -0.024002075, 0.04055786, -0.02331543, 0.000048696995, -0.009094238, -0.06286621, -0.033599854, -0.009468079, -0.019958496, 0.008682251, -0.014411926, -0.010536194, 0.030288696, 0.023925781, 0.011703491, 0.028884888, -0.018157959, -0.019088745, 0.033569336, -0.007259369, -0.04348755, 0.040802002, -0.03265381, -0.008270264, -0.044158936, 0.014373779, -0.014854431, -0.0035095215, -0.018859863, 0.017974854, 0.007881165, 0.027679443, -0.045837402, -0.029296875, 0.011650085, -0.0003170967, 0.016281128, -0.00023543835, -0.032165527, 0.0065574646, 0.04928589, 0.03741455, 0.03540039, -0.025466919, 0.0062675476, 0.037506104, -0.0011453629, -0.014053345, 0.012779236, -0.017333984, 0.03756714, -0.024414062, 0.018249512, -0.016204834, -0.015525818, 0.020553589, -0.017059326, 0.043670654, -0.045806885, 0.0390625, -0.008171082, 0.022537231, -0.0028533936, -0.010955811, 0.01991272, -0.008140564, 0.012916565, -0.023803711, -0.043945312, 0.015563965, 0.05682373, -0.02420044, -0.004989624, -0.009460449, 0.04058838, 0.01626587, 0.04449463, -0.015586853, -0.021636963, 0.041900635, 0.012901306, -0.017318726, -0.024139404, -0.0552063, 0.009902954, -0.027770996, 0.016708374, -0.060546875, 0.038146973, -0.018615723, -0.0019893646, -0.037475586, -0.040252686, 0.02960205, -0.061676025, 0.0014028549, 0.06274414, -0.015434265, 0.06536865, 0.006969452, 0.014564514, 0.03829956, 0.038482666, 0.0146865845, 0.0059127808, 0.024002075, -0.027664185, 0.011207581, 0.017868042, 0.03060913, -0.047088623, 0.0625, -0.015037537, -0.002855301, -0.04486084, 0.02986145, 0.042633057, 0.0042419434, -0.008956909, -0.03753662, 0.064208984, -0.028259277, -0.04425049, 0.0044784546, -0.01020813, -0.06970215, -0.0056495667, -0.021697998, -0.024642944, 0.0118255615, -0.020874023, -0.017089844, -0.030166626, 0.06616211, -0.0077285767, 0.0042877197, 0.001660347, -0.0040893555, -0.023757935, 0.024230957, 0.011428833, -0.03805542, -0.015144348, -0.0062828064, 0.0010852814, 0.010551453, 0.021057129, -0.052215576, -0.0060920715, -0.004070282, -0.022583008, -0.013870239, 0.017166138, 0.013763428, -0.0012874603, -0.026992798, -0.054107666, -0.00289917, -0.021087646, 0.020263672, 0.022857666, -0.02684021, -0.006515503, 0.0033416748, 0.009941101, 0.01134491, 0.05847168, -0.0010948181, -0.005924225, 0.024887085, -0.0680542, 0.031066895, -0.02670288, -0.03213501, 0.0043525696, -0.011352539, 0.0061798096, 0.0070610046, 0.008613586, -0.050872803, 0.02909851, 0.014144897, -0.010650635, -0.018341064, -0.020584106, 0.04748535, -0.016464233, -0.054473877, 0.005142212, 0.0023918152, -0.011924744, 0.050354004, 0.0015449524, -0.043670654, -0.014289856, -0.052612305, -0.029449463, -0.017288208, 0.03353882, -0.024673462, 0.012748718, -0.04925537, -0.02909851, -0.010177612, 0.011489868, -0.025115967, 0.011138916, -0.0087890625, -0.06951904, 0.06390381, 0.045959473, 0.037139893, -0.036132812, 0.004650116, 0.0023326874, -0.022003174, 0.02558899, -0.068603516, -0.0005354881, -0.034729004, 0.015548706, 0.041015625, 0.028366089, -0.042541504, 0.025756836, -0.028717041, 0.04776001, 0.015014648, 0.05105591, 0.042175293, 0.007019043, -0.029159546, 0.015930176, -0.0016241074, -0.044433594, -0.009841919, -0.089782715, -0.014862061, -0.051361084, -0.0131073, -0.050201416, -0.025009155, 0.009628296, -0.010803223, 0.039245605, -0.017669678, 0.01689148, -0.0027065277, -0.017578125, 0.03741455, 0.020568848, -0.01537323, -0.00605011, -0.013076782, -0.028305054, 0.022766113, 0.044647217, -0.0105896, 0.0040626526, -0.049591064, -0.012214661, 0.0206604, -0.012268066, -0.0032730103, -0.017318726, -0.010360718, -0.037078857, -0.019744873, -0.010482788, -0.002532959, 0.045715332, 0.023834229, 0.060577393, -0.033935547, -0.0051612854, 0.017562866, -0.05328369, 0.032562256, 0.025985718, 0.018417358, 0.019561768, -0.054016113, -0.059753418, -0.04748535, 0.02684021, 0.03427124, -0.016967773, 0.0014953613, 0.0016860962, 0.023986816, 0.032470703, 0.03048706, -0.027038574, -0.007881165, -0.0015697479, 0.026657104, 0.031051636, 0.04663086, -0.0037384033, 0.024734497, 0.019226074, -0.06750488, 0.0184021, -0.036712646, 0.009796143, 0.03729248, 0.05407715, 0.03640747, -0.04159546, -0.039794922, 0.012084961, -0.005153656, -0.04437256, 0.014038086, 0.008071899, 0.0657959, 0.009353638, 0.09338379, 0.03878784, 0.012489319, -0.056640625, -0.000934124, 0.039886475, 0.037902832, -0.00056886673, 0.02911377, -0.02645874, -0.038085938, 0.05078125, -0.013206482, 0.049468994, -0.015014648, 0.019607544, -0.039733887, 0.00617218, 0.034973145, -0.06677246, -0.021194458, -0.019683838, -0.009429932, -0.021606445, -0.01411438, -0.04699707, -0.051330566, -0.03704834, 0.053497314, -0.026123047, -0.024841309, 0.01876831, -0.03491211, -0.052886963, -0.005027771, 0.007911682, 0.017196655, -0.017684937, -0.01423645, -0.015167236, 0.005580902, 0.006679535, -0.012901306, -0.01600647, -0.010307312, -0.038848877, -0.046661377, 0.026245117, 0.009994507, 0.00021982193, 0.027191162, -0.010467529, 0.015617371, -0.0031051636, 0.06359863, -0.009407043, -0.051330566, -0.016281128, 0.022994995, -0.023986816, 0.016738892, -0.009918213, -0.026107788, 0.024353027, 0.0041923523, -0.0008177757, -0.05126953, -0.020492554, -0.008705139, -0.01638794, -0.027770996, -0.00013935566, 0.02810669, 0.028045654, -0.033569336, -0.023590088, 0.009429932, 0.049194336, 0.007472992, 0.00497818, 0.07873535, 0.028717041, -0.048950195, -0.027435303, -0.034240723, -0.025543213, 0.037139893, 0.013572693, 0.017669678, 0.064086914, -0.01802063, 0.023529053, 0.008148193, 0.008071899, 0.018936157, 0.00680542, 0.0038013458, 0.012390137, -0.016082764, 0.025100708, -0.022583008, -0.023406982, -0.055541992, 0.020080566, -0.008644104, -0.0034275055, -0.0024700165, 0.0390625, -0.030319214, 0.04434204, 0.0124435425, -0.005001068, 0.016723633, 0.04034424, 0.019378662, 0.036224365, -0.0039901733, -0.022705078, 0.015510559, -0.002401352, -0.0034809113, -0.020492554, -0.000054180622, 0.0099487305, -0.012992859, 0.013755798, -0.03314209, -0.06896973, -0.029968262, 0.014717102, -0.006126404, 0.013000488, 0.029129028, -0.039978027, 0.011650085, 0.0019359589, 0.017486572, -0.03741455, -0.031951904, 0.015899658, 0.038757324, -0.007904053 ], "summary": [ -0.025772095, -0.016647339, -0.058898926, -0.020812988, -0.033599854, -0.010528564, -0.06719971, 0.0036125183, -0.011177063, -0.009605408, -0.0395813, 0.016342163, -0.023956299, -0.030014038, 0.039001465, -0.041992188, -0.018676758, 0.0014038086, -0.050231934, -0.060180664, 0.026977539, -0.0847168, -0.036956787, 0.044677734, 0.023086548, -0.043884277, 0.02558899, 0.017700195, 0.0066223145, 0.003791809, 0.019561768, -0.010215759, 0.01600647, 0.033111572, -0.027740479, -0.0023841858, 0.00712204, 0.0010690689, 0.014389038, 0.017288208, 0.02041626, 0.009887695, 0.021377563, 0.017913818, -0.03829956, 0.014945984, -0.024765015, -0.02368164, 0.05340576, 0.02999878, -0.024368286, -0.0112838745, -0.037719727, 0.008293152, -0.04071045, -0.044036865, -0.015640259, 0.00749588, 0.013679504, 0.036712646, -0.010192871, -0.0069236755, 0.009849548, -0.032104492, 0.0127334595, 0.018798828, -0.030426025, -0.007896423, 0.052246094, 0.017959595, -0.014137268, -0.01512146, 0.002910614, -0.032165527, -0.005088806, 0.03591919, -0.0054016113, 0.036987305, 0.034210205, -0.004306793, 0.016067505, 0.029525757, -0.013153076, -0.021759033, 0.00016522408, -0.0178833, -0.0084991455, -0.0079956055, -0.033355713, -0.04776001, -0.031555176, 0.044189453, -0.040924072, -0.030685425, -0.031234741, -0.032196045, -0.0064315796, -0.030197144, 0.032226562, -0.01826477, 0.05404663, -0.05130005, 0.025222778, -0.0029716492, 0.018417358, 0.057891846, -0.011993408, -0.013946533, 0.017150879, 0.007358551, 0.0033168793, -0.020355225, 0.01158905, 0.00017797947, -0.0047721863, -0.015716553, -0.033691406, 0.032470703, -0.00944519, 0.018325806, -0.028137207, -0.022720337, 0.04522705, -0.011184692, -0.01739502, -0.01902771, -0.027267456, 0.00017595291, -0.034301758, -0.015136719, 0.015686035, 0.043762207, -0.04525757, 0.001086235, -0.04296875, 0.024291992, 0.016235352, -0.005279541, -0.009765625, 0.033477783, 0.02835083, -0.044403076, -0.01828003, 0.020843506, -0.0135650635, 0.05480957, 0.028533936, -0.03955078, -0.034973145, -0.03778076, -0.044555664, -0.028305054, 0.026367188, -0.049072266, -0.033966064, -0.06124878, -0.10595703, 0.008583069, 0.0440979, -0.0004541874, -0.02027893, -0.013458252, 0.04916382, 0.02810669, -0.0029621124, 0.01939392, -0.013084412, -0.008476257, 0.02532959, 0.10021973, -0.022155762, 0.039031982, 0.04763794, 0.013389587, -0.027008057, -0.031341553, 0.03274536, 0.009735107, 0.028717041, -0.00070762634, -0.013053894, -0.0129776, 0.09222412, -0.026412964, -0.030044556, -0.013793945, -0.0087509155, 0.02796936, 0.053619385, 0.014350891, -0.0121154785, -0.033233643, -0.031799316, -0.027816772, -0.010314941, 0.011695862, -0.026565552, 0.017822266, -0.014732361, 0.009552002, 0.026290894, -0.01737976, 0.0021953583, -0.029006958, -0.041015625, -0.03149414, 0.006038666, 0.015609741, 0.04232788, 0.024093628, 0.0085372925, -0.0018854141, -0.024139404, 0.01651001, -0.025817871, -0.019515991, 0.010017395, -0.014137268, 0.0058174133, -0.053710938, 0.030883789, 0.019729614, 0.024093628, 0.07897949, -0.020889282, -0.021377563, -0.013717651, 0.006134033, 0.015609741, -0.00869751, 0.07208252, 0.008354187, 0.050323486, 0.1116333, 0.023086548, -0.025802612, 0.05029297, -0.0513916, 0.040405273, 0.01234436, 0.010818481, 0.04864502, -0.035369873, -0.016540527, 0.03994751, 0.03970337, 0.04083252, -0.030670166, 0.008728027, 0.014266968, 0.003145218, -0.01826477, 0.024047852, -0.0009899139, -0.014167786, 0.029953003, -0.023086548, -0.033172607, 0.0032405853, -0.0131073, 0.019714355, -0.020614624, -0.028030396, 0.009002686, -0.01322937, -0.053588867, -0.01828003, -0.026153564, 0.019256592, -0.030532837, 0.020523071, -0.064208984, 0.019042969, -0.060058594, -0.043762207, 0.018951416, -0.011779785, 0.036315918, 0.05117798, -0.041992188, -0.020584106, -0.018920898, 0.023620605, -0.01826477, 0.034973145, 0.05303955, 0.026550293, -0.025375366, 0.007972717, 0.04699707, 0.05770874, 0.034332275, 0.011505127, 0.015838623, -0.033843994, 0.009765625, 0.060180664, 0.023803711, 0.01777649, -0.029953003, 0.005657196, 0.016494751, -0.051208496, 0.024490356, -0.0044403076, 0.04269409, 0.010734558, 0.023635864, 0.010383606, 0.0018119812, -0.040283203, -0.009735107, 0.02116394, 0.055633545, -0.041992188, -0.029312134, -0.0112838745, 0.0309906, -0.006462097, -0.0044670105, 0.11218262, 0.009925842, 0.007621765, 0.0074920654, -0.00044631958, -0.056732178, 0.032470703, -0.039215088, 0.013290405, -0.017364502, -0.013221741, -0.043395996, -0.033081055, 0.0010519028, 0.010269165, -0.01209259, 0.0058937073, 0.06060791, 0.0038871765, -0.0078086853, 0.03100586, -0.06762695, -0.019882202, 0.012748718, -0.025390625, -0.03338623, 0.04135132, -0.01739502, 0.06201172, 0.008758545, 0.000055909157, -0.0079574585, -0.016311646, 0.018676758, 0.011947632, 0.006904602, 0.013092041, 0.0036258698, 0.019317627, -0.038269043, 0.009468079, 0.0009036064, -0.028137207, -0.028701782, 0.014793396, -0.016937256, -0.012145996, -0.022567749, 0.013092041, 0.014854431, -0.013633728, 0.027145386, -0.032836914, -0.02116394, -0.013465881, 0.014770508, 0.11413574, 0.0022449493, 0.014709473, 0.074279785, 0.011192322, 0.05569458, -0.0736084, 0.03314209, 0.121520996, 0.004673004, 0.0395813, 0.052337646, 0.06439209, -0.0018377304, 0.009819031, -0.038848877, -0.018096924, -0.011978149, 0.012573242, -0.00048685074, -0.050842285, 0.00007879734, -0.07293701, -0.0023326874, 0.013015747, 0.014053345, 0.022979736, 0.0043029785, -0.052001953, 0.029541016, -0.04385376, -0.006324768, 0.037078857, -0.012748718, 0.029678345, -0.034362793, 0.014350891, -0.046295166, -0.00031590462, -0.018997192, -0.058380127, -0.0062026978, -0.0076522827, 0.02079773, 0.021759033, -0.04953003, 0.013961792, 0.029327393, -0.017700195, 0.017166138, 0.024459839, 0.039215088, 0.02859497, 0.034606934, 0.01902771, -0.0040245056, -0.033355713, 0.0031108856, -0.008010864, 0.07647705, 0.028640747, 0.013191223, 0.054229736, -0.037750244, -0.047821045, -0.038604736, -0.051696777, 0.0158844, -0.03692627, 0.0071487427, -0.054779053, -0.058624268, 0.00340271, 0.0019817352, -0.006576538, -0.0046043396, 0.032836914, 0.019210815, -0.023223877, 0.08911133, 0.0031032562, 0.014930725, 0.040283203, -0.024612427, -0.030670166, -0.0155181885, -0.01550293, -0.015792847, 0.039733887, 0.002658844, -0.045043945, 0.028213501, 0.015945435, -0.020523071, 0.034332275, 0.011444092, -0.0010137558, 0.0019283295, -0.021240234, -0.015556335, 0.041168213, 0.030319214, -0.022567749, -0.05343628, -0.022064209, 0.021972656, 0.051757812, -0.0657959, -0.007545471, 0.008956909, -0.082458496, -0.06793213, -0.00037264824, 0.040985107, 0.021194458, -0.000910759, 0.04006958, 0.006801605, -0.012969971, 0.005092621, -0.015266418, -0.009971619, 0.0052604675, -0.045288086, 0.0031356812, 0.00793457, 0.016311646, 0.0029125214, 0.0008740425, -0.005012512, -0.008331299, 0.0034332275, 0.03152466, 0.0014858246, 0.0036354065, -0.003189087, -0.027954102, -0.009002686, -0.009002686, 0.009559631, 0.01638794, -0.054229736, 0.016921997, 0.028579712, 0.00020086765, 0.052093506, -0.05307007, 0.049102783, 0.019805908, 0.014663696, -0.10772705, 0.033843994, -0.034729004, 0.00026869774, 0.013137817, 0.023925781, -0.0020446777, -0.04168701, 0.04144287, 0.005126953, -0.029846191, 0.010574341, 0.011154175, -0.0033779144, -0.044158936, -0.025375366, 0.027648926, 0.05203247, -0.021575928, 0.024261475, -0.025817871, 0.02633667, -0.009666443, 0.0079956055, -0.01689148, -0.0032463074, -0.032592773, -0.008132935, -0.018844604, -0.009178162, -0.03829956, 0.021911621, 0.012557983, 0.037628174, 0.02947998, 0.012245178, -0.003414154, -0.017333984, 0.0042381287, 0.0071258545, -0.032073975, -0.083740234, -0.045715332, 0.012664795, -0.043762207, -0.016479492, -0.06188965, -0.074523926, -0.039154053, -0.002166748, -0.02760315, 0.020568848, 0.0021686554, 0.039886475, 0.03479004, 0.014961243, -0.046295166, 0.024642944, -0.01474762, -0.006427765, -0.0039711, 0.012176514, -0.025482178, -0.0256958, -0.000110566616, -0.0023918152, -0.028411865, -0.035339355, 0.012535095, 0.032958984, -0.0087509155, -0.023452759, -0.009262085, 0.012825012, -0.000374794, 0.016311646, -0.0020275116, -0.010795593, 0.026550293, 0.032928467, 0.021911621, 0.049835205, -0.018325806, 0.00045990944, 0.0031967163, 0.003900528, -0.0026111603, 0.00028705597, -0.023162842, 0.015975952, -0.025848389, 0.015220642, 0.023986816, 0.004333496, 0.008224487, -0.014556885, 0.011871338, -0.012420654, -0.020141602, 0.026641846, 0.0362854, 0.018234253, -0.023635864, 0.010795593, 0.011039734, -0.009017944, -0.01133728, 0.003692627, -0.012466431, -0.0022888184, -0.014961243, -0.03866577, -0.036346436, -0.002029419, 0.005054474, 0.006454468, -0.015670776, -0.03668213, 0.04055786, -0.008399963, -0.010650635, 0.015640259, -0.026184082, -0.04232788, -0.026138306, -0.009498596, -0.03652954, 0.051940918, 0.01763916, -0.018661499, -0.006198883, -0.045410156, 0.010543823, -0.06854248, -0.027893066, 0.0052871704, -0.052093506, 0.029022217, 0.0592041, 0.0009899139, -0.0031032562, 0.049987793, -0.017028809, 0.029953003, 0.008834839, -0.010040283, -0.0020523071, 0.007888794, 0.009994507, -0.02784729, 0.05255127, -0.0010604858, -0.007297516, -0.036315918, 0.006000519, 0.013671875, 0.01737976, 0.0020313263, -0.011329651, 0.046722412, 0.011878967, -0.017410278, -0.015487671, 0.022338867, -0.07897949, -0.06793213, 0.0026435852, -0.052520752, -0.029281616, -0.038238525, -0.020462036, -0.022644043, 0.05783081, -0.05154419, -0.008178711, 0.014564514, -0.035858154, -0.015487671, -0.0028095245, 0.0028839111, -0.009971619, -0.024459839, -0.026489258, 0.010665894, -0.049865723, 0.027999878, -0.05343628, -0.0010766983, -0.049194336, -0.023605347, -0.07849121, -0.03591919, -0.022918701, 0.06365967, -0.029632568, 0.0010700226, 0.010223389, -0.03668213, 0.03152466, -0.02532959, -0.03918457, -0.016784668, -0.013710022, 0.003326416, 0.021636963, 0.010009766, -0.021972656, 0.008605957, 0.035888672, -0.08746338, 0.055511475, -0.0058403015, 0.029342651, -0.007587433, -0.008857727, 0.010612488, 0.029800415, 0.017730713, -0.026855469, 0.011657715, -0.0010604858, -0.0052337646, 0.005645752, -0.030639648, 0.015411377, 0.01876831, -0.032348633, -0.004081726, 0.019454956, -0.017242432, -0.014762878, 0.0042304993, -0.020065308, 0.0050811768, -0.064331055, -0.000023424625, -0.009597778, 0.020950317, 0.01902771, 0.03768921, -0.03677368, -0.00422287, 0.0035171509, 0.0012083054, -0.009727478, -0.030853271, -0.02748108, -0.031463623, 0.0725708, 0.062438965, 0.048065186, -0.01864624, -0.0005197525, -0.032989502, -0.04043579, 0.028869629, -0.02067566, 0.030029297, -0.04699707, 0.0077209473, 0.037078857, 0.074401855, -0.026504517, 0.06878662, 0.0011062622, 0.040496826, 0.019546509, 0.042236328, 0.031677246, -0.01763916, -0.043518066, 0.008903503, 0.012130737, -0.045684814, 0.036987305, -0.04260254, -0.015899658, -0.035461426, -0.039794922, -0.029388428, -0.01235199, 0.021560669, -0.027160645, 0.036315918, -0.0027370453, 0.0020771027, 0.01586914, -0.04647827, 0.03274536, -0.016845703, 0.001449585, 0.008544922, 0.027832031, -0.06958008, -0.015808105, 0.039520264, 0.00091838837, -0.012252808, -0.024917603, 0.033843994, 0.019638062, -0.043518066, -0.033935547, -0.07122803, 0.02758789, -0.04776001, -0.044036865, -0.005531311, -0.0028324127, 0.020568848, -0.010910034, 0.08117676, -0.020065308, -0.007411957, -0.013832092, -0.04309082, 0.022979736, -0.036376953, 0.05923462, -0.0058517456, -0.03591919, -0.020309448, -0.051757812, 0.028198242, 0.032440186, 0.010864258, 0.041992188, -0.014282227, 0.011451721, -0.0037441254, -0.0015354156, -0.011672974, -0.039642334, 0.005619049, 0.05480957, -0.0043029785, 0.06719971, -0.013694763, 0.017913818, 0.034057617, -0.040649414, 0.03112793, -0.05682373, 0.035339355, 0.02998352, 0.0496521, 0.046539307, -0.039398193, -0.026107788, 0.011947632, 0.0085372925, -0.062408447, -0.004875183, 0.012908936, 0.058563232, 0.041778564, 0.06384277, -0.016830444, 0.018920898, 0.027404785, -0.0043258667, 0.045562744, -0.0014247894, 0.021209717, 0.023605347, -0.031677246, -0.0022468567, 0.029464722, -0.01525116, 0.022949219, -0.022872925, 0.03152466, -0.032989502, 0.0340271, -0.02558899, -0.04067993, -0.032226562, 0.007457733, -0.0463562, -0.012527466, -0.01965332, -0.008987427, -0.019180298, -0.066101074, 0.02218628, -0.023254395, -0.01725769, 0.037200928, -0.013549805, -0.03817749, -0.0211792, 0.016525269, 0.015838623, -0.027709961, -0.02229309, 0.047210693, -0.012245178, -0.017211914, -0.06506348, -0.027160645, -0.032318115, 0.02861023, -0.0340271, 0.031188965, 0.030517578, -0.014549255, -0.06976318, -0.027053833, 0.000019490719, -0.04046631, 0.062347412, 0.023635864, -0.010955811, -0.052856445, 0.011878967, -0.023284912, 0.016067505, -0.04196167, -0.009117126, 0.020477295, 0.020950317, 0.015434265, -0.025344849, 0.014808655, -0.010292053, -0.032165527, -0.032073975, -0.0070343018, 0.00207901, 0.025344849, -0.011253357, -0.032592773, 0.010910034, -0.0104904175, 0.017242432, -0.027755737, 0.026473999, 0.010002136, -0.0031871796, -0.013763428, -0.008811951, -0.016357422, 0.0154418945, 0.019226074, 0.02909851, 0.0211792, -0.02166748, 0.009223938, 0.008468628, -0.03086853, 0.0037250519, -0.0049552917, 0.015777588, 0.0032920837, -0.018508911, 0.014427185, -0.03475952, -0.025634766, -0.03164673, 0.0317688, -0.019683838, -0.0064697266, -0.0052604675, 0.029327393, -0.013671875, -0.00067949295, -0.011856079, 0.050445557, -0.00856781, -0.019546509, 0.01826477, -0.019821167, 0.012245178, 0.022354126, -0.00006330013, 0.017913818, 0.009750366, 0.039001465, -0.019561768, 0.0129470825, -0.00223732, 0.0013608932, -0.032440186, -0.08831787, -0.028915405, 0.0017766953, -0.011558533, 0.0074386597, 0.053894043, -0.036865234, 0.01725769, 0.042236328, -0.017425537, 0.019851685, 0.008842468, 0.036193848, 0.00982666, 0.0039043427 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07052v1
Towards the Law of Capacity Gap in Distilling Language Models
Chen Zhang, Dawei Song, Zheyu Ye, Yan Gao
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
Language model (LM) distillation is a trending area that aims to distil the knowledge resided in a large teacher LM to a small student one. While various methods have been proposed to push the distillation to its limits, it is still a pain distilling LMs when a large capacity gap is exhibited between the teacher and the student LMs. The pain is mainly resulted by the curse of capacity gap, which describes that a larger teacher LM cannot always lead to a better student LM than one distilled from a smaller teacher LM due to the affect of capacity gap increment. That is, there is likely an optimal point yielding the best student LM along the scaling course of the teacher LM. Even worse, the curse of capacity gap can be only partly yet not fully lifted as indicated in previous studies. However, the tale is not ever one-sided. Although a larger teacher LM has better performance than a smaller teacher LM, it is much more resource-demanding especially in the context of recent large LMs (LLMs). Consequently, instead of sticking to lifting the curse, leaving the curse as is should be arguably fine. Even better, in this paper, we reveal that the optimal capacity gap is almost consistent across different student scales and architectures, fortunately turning the curse into the law of capacity gap. The law later guides us to distil a 3B student LM (termed MiniMA) from a 7B teacher LM (adapted LLaMA2-7B). MiniMA is demonstrated to yield a new compute-performance pareto frontier among existing 3B LMs on commonly used benchmarks, and its instruction-tuned version (termed MiniChat) outperforms a wide range of 3B competitors in GPT4 evaluation and could even compete with several 7B chat models.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07052v1
2023-11-13T03:36:18
2023-11-13T03:36:18
{ "title": [ -0.033966064, -0.0022144318, -0.05419922, -0.07952881, -0.004180908, 0.01398468, -0.09106445, 0.0042915344, 0.023147583, 0.020401001, -0.04559326, -0.020141602, 0.002948761, -0.008705139, -0.06329346, -0.01537323, -0.01737976, 0.051727295, -0.015274048, -0.03704834, -0.0010795593, -0.05722046, -0.0027809143, 0.03353882, 0.051635742, -0.062072754, -0.057495117, 0.012435913, -0.018707275, -0.023773193, -0.0042648315, 0.007095337, 0.040405273, 0.0137786865, -0.0066947937, -0.008018494, -0.027664185, 0.00970459, -0.0068893433, 0.012550354, 0.03491211, -0.010154724, 0.012458801, -0.008155823, -0.042663574, 0.04537964, -0.042907715, -0.011726379, -0.020263672, 0.03314209, -0.0062675476, 0.03010559, -0.02293396, 0.022750854, 0.025482178, -0.024093628, -0.031921387, 0.0025959015, 0.01675415, 0.055541992, 0.028533936, -0.016799927, 0.010101318, -0.00038051605, -0.017288208, -0.011192322, -0.025741577, 0.029815674, 0.057800293, -0.005126953, -0.03149414, 0.0074806213, -0.009498596, -0.030929565, -0.053710938, 0.009941101, 0.027999878, -0.035339355, 0.027389526, -0.023040771, 0.009742737, -0.0025920868, 0.012107849, -0.008666992, -0.0008254051, -0.030593872, -0.016723633, -0.013183594, -0.022216797, -0.063964844, -0.007671356, -0.005519867, -0.013412476, 0.012817383, -0.024047852, -0.019363403, -0.0047569275, 0.003124237, -0.0006198883, -0.042877197, -0.019256592, 0.028396606, -0.06341553, 0.004901886, 0.027191162, 0.00983429, -0.04473877, -0.021957397, 0.046905518, 0.04736328, -0.017700195, 0.04135132, 0.0031776428, -0.026519775, 0.016357422, 0.027496338, 0.00093603134, 0.014373779, 0.011749268, 0.02633667, -0.022216797, -0.040039062, 0.006881714, -0.0032749176, 0.015167236, -0.0149002075, -0.051208496, 0.028320312, -0.007083893, 0.04714966, 0.023132324, 0.033233643, -0.12890625, -0.07684326, -0.076660156, 0.04421997, 0.0039634705, -0.028244019, -0.03540039, 0.003955841, 0.031311035, -0.0060424805, 0.00070667267, -0.021118164, -0.012718201, 0.01033783, 0.056396484, -0.010719299, -0.051452637, -0.048950195, -0.03604126, 0.0050849915, 0.049987793, -0.020080566, -0.08728027, -0.03564453, -0.114746094, -0.02192688, 0.010848999, -0.032318115, 0.016952515, 0.0026550293, -0.024795532, -0.011627197, 0.011642456, -0.0155181885, -0.003068924, 0.02407837, 0.01448822, 0.02633667, -0.020889282, 0.0048179626, 0.010368347, 0.013221741, -0.006252289, 0.024169922, 0.03100586, -0.014427185, 0.01864624, -0.007774353, 0.016693115, -0.011482239, -0.008163452, 0.059539795, -0.075927734, -0.020629883, -0.014221191, 0.005054474, 0.06463623, 0.0005083084, -0.019683838, 0.011497498, -0.026062012, -0.03604126, -0.049194336, -0.026992798, 0.04473877, 0.034851074, -0.0052223206, 0.028335571, -0.011375427, 0.023803711, -0.030426025, -0.02279663, -0.03353882, -0.020843506, -0.01763916, 0.028167725, -0.019210815, 0.054901123, 0.04949951, 0.0008940697, -0.036010742, 0.030700684, 0.012924194, -0.05343628, 0.05078125, 0.026397705, 0.008880615, -0.0018968582, -0.0028209686, -0.026657104, 0.016662598, 0.06719971, 0.014778137, 0.004371643, -0.0016126633, -0.01739502, 0.04348755, 0.018554688, 0.045043945, -0.03302002, 0.049926758, 0.028396606, -0.014122009, -0.02909851, 0.00005185604, -0.025512695, 0.01826477, 0.018096924, -0.007858276, -0.01689148, -0.014282227, 0.026504517, 0.051940918, 0.01600647, 0.0065727234, 0.013641357, 0.02243042, 0.04776001, 0.04296875, 0.025680542, 0.02079773, -0.013687134, -0.007534027, 0.06530762, -0.0060310364, -0.015487671, -0.017807007, 0.013557434, 0.028045654, -0.011581421, -0.033325195, -0.0015487671, -0.06347656, -0.0028572083, -0.052246094, -0.010498047, 0.010597229, -0.00071811676, 0.02017212, -0.030075073, 0.025512695, -0.00018906593, -0.053771973, -0.008872986, -0.010719299, 0.027038574, 0.019012451, -0.05718994, -0.010818481, 0.019897461, 0.016921997, 0.004447937, -0.0011701584, 0.0040664673, 0.01914978, 0.0129470825, -0.0014820099, 0.007457733, 0.039886475, 0.04534912, 0.010650635, 0.021408081, 0.005809784, 0.0025672913, 0.11187744, 0.06402588, -0.04244995, 0.055236816, -0.008125305, 0.03579712, 0.036010742, -0.006374359, 0.014167786, 0.03829956, 0.030090332, 0.022491455, -0.017700195, 0.016601562, -0.050720215, 0.008903503, -0.0040359497, -0.031707764, -0.040283203, -0.034179688, -0.0021133423, -0.035858154, -0.006549835, 0.005256653, 0.091552734, -0.040527344, -0.0071029663, -0.00712204, -0.015510559, -0.036376953, -0.013557434, -0.025802612, 0.0017642975, 0.012748718, 0.030654907, 0.012008667, -0.0670166, -0.03933716, -0.015106201, 0.007980347, -0.01499939, 0.03451538, -0.011444092, 0.029190063, 0.017501831, -0.0041007996, 0.0206604, -0.03918457, -0.00038266182, -0.04916382, 0.028717041, -0.004261017, 0.0052490234, -0.004337311, 0.015838623, -0.0018119812, -0.012939453, 0.0385437, 0.05279541, -0.027938843, -0.028701782, 0.04751587, 0.026016235, -0.002035141, 0.03466797, 0.018585205, 0.005027771, -0.05517578, -0.010688782, -0.06695557, -0.039215088, -0.01663208, -0.008705139, 0.025405884, -0.06555176, -0.021972656, -0.022598267, -0.0013484955, 0.023376465, 0.014915466, 0.040863037, -0.014411926, -0.014945984, 0.018478394, -0.0014305115, 0.034423828, -0.05340576, 0.024749756, 0.07836914, 0.00712204, 0.016738892, 0.013748169, 0.06173706, 0.0079956055, 0.0016613007, -0.012817383, -0.046813965, -0.0042495728, 0.026657104, 0.033203125, -0.028961182, -0.05331421, -0.06488037, -0.00025582314, 0.07299805, -0.03540039, -0.04159546, 0.03967285, -0.06365967, 0.030944824, 0.008857727, -0.01424408, 0.042297363, 0.016464233, 0.015357971, -0.007572174, 0.035461426, -0.064331055, 0.008651733, -0.04135132, -0.11706543, 0.030563354, -0.012390137, -0.05709839, -0.013031006, -0.05178833, -0.030151367, -0.0044174194, -0.0024757385, 0.0435791, 0.014160156, 0.0058174133, 0.011116028, -0.008590698, -0.001420021, -0.014717102, -0.037628174, -0.020004272, 0.0012769699, 0.026901245, 0.008590698, 0.04711914, 0.01939392, 0.011116028, -0.026870728, -0.0025482178, 0.0010194778, 0.0118637085, -0.00299263, -0.034576416, 0.0021476746, 0.00086450577, 0.02709961, 0.009033203, -0.016098022, 0.0004208088, 0.005836487, -0.0025806427, -0.025924683, 0.009757996, 0.0071907043, 0.013343811, -0.014503479, -0.025665283, 0.010169983, -0.016784668, -0.061950684, 0.0012598038, 0.03062439, 0.036895752, -0.043548584, 0.006111145, -0.024475098, 0.00409317, 0.008529663, 0.0019054413, 0.0046806335, 0.018127441, -0.0037155151, -0.0001591444, -0.023086548, 0.02243042, -0.039001465, 0.0071487427, -0.007472992, 0.009590149, -0.03970337, -0.052764893, -0.0011367798, 0.004283905, -0.08569336, -0.014419556, 0.01449585, -0.013572693, -0.027175903, -0.025848389, 0.03543091, -0.01676941, -0.031707764, 0.022842407, -0.029571533, -0.03050232, -0.0029335022, -0.08258057, 0.013702393, 0.0791626, 0.024002075, 0.019805908, 0.027236938, -0.008262634, -0.00012469292, -0.031311035, 0.028869629, 0.01927185, 0.031555176, -0.0041275024, -0.013465881, 0.03189087, -0.022109985, 0.021560669, 0.020889282, -0.00015962124, -0.008407593, 0.013504028, -0.015563965, 0.028137207, 0.016021729, 0.06689453, -0.047576904, -0.023254395, -0.024993896, -0.0016002655, -0.019332886, -0.01977539, 0.016357422, -0.012710571, 0.011245728, 0.02406311, 0.0032176971, 0.06463623, 0.0074005127, 0.0009965897, 0.037902832, -0.006362915, -0.010101318, 0.0075302124, 0.037200928, 0.015380859, -0.008018494, 0.031311035, 0.015838623, 0.048034668, 0.009643555, -0.01890564, 0.005844116, 0.037963867, -0.020370483, -0.0001733303, -0.059265137, -0.023452759, -0.003408432, 0.000044822693, -0.027069092, 0.06854248, 0.032592773, -0.029541016, -0.025619507, 0.029403687, 0.03778076, -0.00026154518, -0.023590088, -0.07965088, -0.00039362907, -0.026260376, -0.060180664, -0.053863525, -0.030532837, 0.035614014, 0.022918701, 0.036499023, -0.008010864, 0.023666382, 0.033477783, 0.04623413, 0.04647827, -0.026184082, -0.037139893, 0.047943115, -0.03717041, -0.022079468, 0.02394104, -0.004776001, -0.005607605, -0.01940918, 0.026153564, -0.016174316, -0.012565613, -0.022644043, 0.031707764, -0.026931763, 0.07342529, -0.009132385, 0.007522583, 0.025802612, -0.006290436, 0.022079468, 0.0047340393, -0.036315918, 0.010276794, 0.009025574, 0.037902832, -0.00030589104, 0.031143188, 0.07305908, -0.0005722046, -0.004585266, -0.01171875, -0.0038471222, 0.010612488, 0.014213562, 0.028717041, 0.011627197, -0.03756714, -0.043945312, 0.0034770966, 0.01020813, 0.039367676, -0.057037354, 0.037322998, -0.04196167, 0.031433105, 0.024978638, -0.008834839, 0.026321411, 0.0040397644, 0.02748108, -0.052490234, -0.00073957443, 0.022369385, 0.013839722, -0.046081543, 0.017181396, -0.020843506, -0.017227173, 0.020233154, 0.049743652, 0.024353027, -0.027786255, 0.018417358, -0.02180481, -0.019180298, -0.01713562, -0.062194824, -0.0119018555, -0.011657715, 0.023849487, -0.009315491, 0.06329346, -0.072631836, 0.033233643, -0.013175964, -0.017211914, 0.041778564, -0.06842041, 0.031555176, 0.08843994, 0.0036945343, 0.041656494, -0.0065307617, 0.012046814, 0.03842163, 0.061798096, -0.0022449493, 0.034973145, 0.038024902, -0.060333252, -0.01953125, -0.014091492, 0.02645874, -0.009376526, 0.045440674, 0.017425537, 0.024017334, -0.074523926, 0.01878357, 0.014953613, 0.0035362244, 0.030044556, -0.053375244, 0.016204834, 0.0049972534, -0.012435913, 0.025512695, -0.047698975, -0.027542114, -0.02545166, -0.0049362183, -0.057006836, 0.008468628, -0.0033626556, -0.052642822, -0.024520874, 0.04537964, -0.029067993, 0.010986328, 0.024108887, -0.033721924, -0.03869629, 0.04006958, 0.036346436, -0.044799805, 0.039855957, -0.0021076202, 0.0020561218, 0.06561279, 0.04043579, -0.01890564, -0.002357483, 0.007843018, -0.049987793, -0.021606445, -0.0076828003, -0.010246277, -0.0015487671, 0.0033092499, -0.021911621, 0.013648987, 0.0011281967, 0.032714844, -0.013648987, -0.008834839, 0.03086853, 0.00029683113, 0.0065612793, -0.016601562, -0.009086609, 0.00957489, 0.0033473969, 0.00497818, -0.03314209, 0.00472641, 0.009536743, 0.009490967, -0.032440186, -0.0657959, 0.0020141602, 0.013465881, 0.006412506, 0.009895325, 0.03744507, 0.039764404, 0.04663086, -0.030181885, 0.021240234, 0.033172607, -0.049926758, -0.027175903, -0.014282227, -0.012550354, -0.025741577, 0.06665039, 0.013916016, -0.0026855469, -0.044769287, -0.031951904, -0.03286743, 0.014350891, 0.0079193115, 0.0046691895, 0.0009937286, 0.015357971, 0.059295654, -0.021865845, -0.01146698, -0.038238525, 0.022705078, -0.007713318, -0.018539429, -0.007335663, 0.0026111603, 0.0059814453, -0.034820557, 0.010261536, 0.039794922, -0.01876831, 0.020217896, -0.0657959, -0.014572144, -0.015609741, -0.036010742, 0.029785156, 0.0025959015, -0.014251709, 0.02230835, -0.010475159, 0.064697266, -0.007736206, 0.022338867, 0.0079956055, -0.007534027, 0.00006842613, -0.002216339, 0.002412796, -0.043029785, 0.017974854, -0.04156494, -0.00623703, -0.078186035, -0.013534546, -0.08673096, 0.026229858, -0.014877319, 0.030975342, -0.0021972656, 0.008918762, 0.010063171, -0.0038490295, 0.0126571655, 0.004447937, 0.057159424, -0.007472992, 0.0031757355, 0.006729126, -0.045440674, 0.009147644, 0.0385437, -0.012931824, -0.009208679, -0.0024414062, -0.020965576, -0.0073165894, 0.018630981, 0.013702393, -0.034576416, -0.0017728806, -0.03173828, 0.029052734, 0.008010864, 0.03878784, 0.054473877, 0.025878906, -0.0075645447, -0.009757996, -0.008171082, 0.008453369, -0.017654419, 0.008354187, 0.016174316, -0.046020508, 0.012039185, -0.002691269, -0.015296936, -0.023483276, 0.030044556, 0.024398804, -0.061187744, -0.037628174, 0.017333984, 0.041870117, 0.011856079, 0.0184021, -0.04727173, -0.005218506, 0.014801025, 0.024429321, -0.01084137, 0.009498596, 0.02180481, 0.03149414, -0.029815674, -0.049865723, 0.011161804, -0.029052734, -0.024505615, 0.01914978, 0.027770996, 0.023361206, -0.021270752, -0.036499023, -0.001912117, 0.0021190643, -0.05331421, -0.006652832, 0.019470215, 0.037200928, 0.028717041, 0.05380249, 0.014038086, -0.015640259, 0.011367798, -0.041900635, -0.0012559891, 0.010803223, -0.016220093, 0.013916016, -0.05368042, -0.0473938, 0.025299072, -0.055358887, 0.087524414, -0.059783936, -0.0026855469, -0.02330017, 0.034942627, 0.009757996, -0.025543213, -0.059539795, 0.000033199787, -0.060699463, 0.005783081, -0.014587402, -0.027160645, -0.035125732, -0.016174316, 0.012016296, 0.0085372925, 0.011428833, 0.018981934, -0.034576416, -0.085632324, 0.023620605, -0.018463135, 0.06060791, -0.023712158, 0.0012903214, 0.0021915436, 0.0011034012, -0.0058059692, -0.043182373, -0.024841309, -0.028625488, -0.0020809174, -0.033477783, -0.004699707, -0.017044067, -0.027923584, -0.03173828, -0.026641846, 0.0012464523, -0.032104492, 0.028564453, 0.010543823, -0.048461914, -0.028930664, 0.008323669, -0.039642334, 0.020645142, -0.00932312, -0.026428223, 0.024856567, 0.0013160706, -0.03265381, -0.007385254, 0.009292603, 0.02607727, -0.016937256, -0.07647705, 0.025604248, 0.01259613, 0.050201416, -0.032409668, -0.060028076, 0.026229858, 0.0059280396, 0.0015363693, 0.02810669, 0.053833008, 0.0018796921, -0.032958984, -0.012702942, -0.025894165, -0.020233154, 0.00047969818, 0.0047798157, 0.030670166, 0.04360962, 0.0005683899, -0.011672974, 0.0076446533, -0.01449585, -0.018157959, 0.0038223267, -0.034454346, -0.010215759, 0.014335632, 0.015899658, -0.008255005, -0.0053977966, -0.053497314, 0.01335144, 0.0033130646, 0.01399231, -0.0060577393, 0.025466919, -0.011985779, 0.06008911, -0.033203125, -0.07495117, 0.052246094, 0.049194336, 0.0058517456, 0.04248047, 0.0021572113, -0.02017212, -0.0058135986, 0.016708374, 0.004169464, 0.052459717, -0.004585266, -0.01725769, 0.018829346, -0.07476807, -0.035858154, -0.016799927, -0.016189575, 0.021392822, -0.031311035, 0.019104004, -0.01902771, -0.02949524, 0.0030174255, 0.018432617, 0.024368286, -0.031677246, -0.0413208, -0.027740479, 0.05267334, -0.0019836426 ], "summary": [ -0.0178833, -0.006362915, -0.020050049, -0.026992798, -0.027404785, 0.007423401, -0.05255127, -0.011299133, 0.035858154, -0.005012512, -0.09008789, -0.02571106, 0.02017212, -0.0154800415, 0.015319824, -0.05810547, -0.011405945, 0.02696228, 0.0048294067, -0.019210815, 0.037017822, -0.032562256, -0.042877197, -0.009010315, 0.022598267, -0.042907715, -0.031188965, 0.023864746, -0.008956909, 0.011451721, -0.002532959, 0.0134887695, 0.03704834, 0.004875183, -0.028152466, 0.008300781, -0.040649414, -0.00166893, -0.015289307, 0.016708374, 0.024505615, -0.016555786, 0.011497498, -0.009056091, -0.03366089, 0.050567627, -0.049804688, -0.01953125, 0.028213501, 0.015510559, -0.033935547, 0.038726807, -0.025405884, 0.010009766, -0.0054244995, 0.005393982, -0.035186768, 0.024383545, -0.01763916, 0.06878662, 0.03479004, 0.046783447, -0.027069092, 0.0020809174, 0.0134887695, 0.013084412, -0.044555664, 0.009346008, 0.054656982, 0.017959595, -0.025024414, -0.0030212402, 0.005191803, -0.054016113, -0.008583069, 0.015365601, 0.027755737, -0.014839172, -0.004623413, -0.004722595, -0.011161804, 0.019744873, -0.037597656, -0.031341553, 0.009963989, -0.0154953, -0.022888184, -0.015914917, 0.024429321, -0.014289856, 0.012489319, -0.019561768, 0.0009551048, 0.047088623, -0.009925842, -0.03753662, 0.0006661415, -0.00944519, -0.0074691772, -0.026626587, 0.021652222, -0.026153564, -0.009681702, 0.010940552, 0.021652222, -0.014526367, -0.064086914, -0.051086426, 0.051116943, 0.052581787, -0.020126343, 0.01423645, -0.01727295, -0.06237793, 0.020751953, 0.024810791, -0.02192688, 0.066589355, 0.034851074, 0.024154663, -0.016693115, -0.02229309, 0.025299072, 0.010322571, 0.003900528, -0.010902405, -0.03161621, -0.0017290115, 0.0004541874, 0.01864624, 0.029266357, 0.037353516, -0.06744385, -0.02432251, -0.06085205, 0.0024204254, 0.007156372, -0.05014038, -0.031158447, 0.01448822, 0.042541504, 0.00079631805, 0.028320312, 0.0073928833, -0.055236816, 0.044555664, 0.01260376, -0.014564514, -0.015701294, -0.04989624, -0.025436401, -0.039764404, 0.030929565, -0.05102539, -0.05206299, -0.010498047, -0.122680664, 0.041168213, 0.010513306, 0.038482666, 0.023895264, 0.03149414, 0.016616821, 0.058654785, 0.022354126, -0.03829956, 0.0132369995, -0.008216858, 0.025390625, -0.007499695, 0.007286072, -0.0023174286, 0.0014133453, -0.0010786057, 0.0062713623, 0.006980896, 0.029205322, -0.02432251, 0.017456055, -0.0013132095, -0.012954712, -0.018325806, 0.0049934387, -0.0063323975, -0.00919342, -0.03286743, -0.014907837, -0.0021381378, 0.03353882, 0.019714355, -0.035949707, -0.000975132, -0.022384644, 0.040222168, -0.015594482, -0.053131104, 0.010696411, 0.010650635, -0.011642456, -0.0016880035, 0.023788452, 0.05291748, -0.013320923, -0.036254883, -0.08105469, 0.029541016, -0.032287598, 0.06573486, 0.017181396, 0.0440979, 0.0061149597, 0.007171631, -0.02279663, 0.03768921, 0.0054359436, -0.0231781, 0.006500244, -0.0131073, 0.0054969788, 0.016464233, 0.011871338, 0.002286911, -0.01524353, 0.038330078, -0.039154053, -0.0061569214, 0.011421204, 0.029724121, 0.01373291, 0.042388916, 0.06555176, -0.07867432, 0.04385376, 0.05630493, -0.011169434, -0.018722534, 0.004207611, -0.052581787, 0.023345947, 0.03164673, -0.00053167343, -0.031311035, -0.044311523, 0.01234436, -0.032318115, -0.044769287, -0.001581192, 0.030395508, 0.011703491, 0.058258057, 0.021224976, 0.024276733, 0.011138916, -0.02949524, 0.0048217773, 0.039276123, -0.0574646, -0.03439331, -0.016189575, -0.0054512024, 0.037719727, 0.02520752, 0.001964569, -0.0028762817, -0.056884766, -0.0057144165, -0.04458618, -0.018569946, -0.003572464, -0.0008096695, 0.018875122, -0.039093018, 0.029632568, -0.026977539, -0.11199951, -0.0038471222, -0.013244629, 0.054534912, 0.032562256, -0.05407715, 0.013435364, 0.009002686, 0.0008368492, -0.008323669, 0.0368042, -0.04473877, 0.017288208, 0.02722168, 0.009544373, 0.033599854, 0.017929077, 0.0519104, 0.0051460266, 0.009742737, 0.054656982, 0.008087158, 0.040527344, 0.034851074, -0.021652222, 0.0062026978, 0.048461914, 0.036590576, -0.022125244, 0.016311646, 0.026657104, 0.015731812, 0.0317688, 0.029205322, 0.022628784, 0.004348755, -0.006504059, 0.005458832, 0.018478394, 0.024932861, -0.030014038, 0.00054597855, -0.017547607, 0.011894226, 0.03881836, 0.06561279, 0.09295654, -0.04647827, 0.023269653, 0.007843018, -0.01550293, -0.05166626, 0.033447266, -0.027053833, 0.05899048, -0.0054473877, -0.0141067505, 0.01398468, -0.05810547, -0.015083313, 0.0067749023, 0.010040283, 0.00033330917, 0.0030593872, -0.006526947, 0.0262146, 0.008010864, -0.02696228, 0.00015878677, -0.03805542, -0.01713562, 0.014419556, -0.0031089783, 0.00617218, 0.012367249, 0.021575928, -0.03515625, 0.01689148, 0.013725281, 0.008918762, 0.0236969, -0.010864258, -0.041809082, 0.0061073303, 0.0028324127, -0.04925537, -0.0158844, 0.034729004, -0.036590576, -0.080444336, 0.033111572, -0.03942871, -0.027252197, -0.027267456, -0.029159546, 0.0001487732, 0.009490967, -0.019577026, -0.0037231445, -0.007751465, -0.016921997, 0.004699707, 0.08782959, 0.0028324127, -0.009498596, 0.052093506, 0.045898438, 0.059783936, -0.052978516, 0.041809082, 0.099365234, 0.008255005, -0.008232117, 0.026641846, 0.05038452, 0.017715454, -0.013458252, -0.045928955, -0.025161743, -0.011116028, 0.01914978, 0.023223877, -0.029510498, -0.04510498, -0.021972656, -0.015411377, 0.07574463, -0.038146973, 0.0027999878, 0.018035889, -0.022750854, 0.014434814, 0.03137207, 0.0076675415, 0.032958984, -0.06732178, 0.027252197, -0.051696777, 0.03439331, -0.0770874, -0.0075531006, -0.043060303, -0.033172607, -0.011108398, -0.024261475, 0.015434265, 0.012504578, -0.016830444, -0.011367798, -0.002161026, 0.03652954, 0.040222168, -0.007408142, -0.021499634, -0.017288208, 0.024993896, 0.045654297, -0.01158905, 0.00054359436, -0.0069503784, -0.03366089, 0.0014410019, 0.0063209534, 0.015388489, 0.025970459, -0.050201416, -0.091918945, -0.032928467, -0.0020313263, -0.014160156, 0.0059165955, -0.024795532, -0.015213013, -0.066101074, 0.05053711, 0.033325195, -0.005340576, -0.002122879, 0.02456665, -0.014930725, -0.04434204, -0.004257202, -0.018035889, 0.037506104, 0.012123108, -0.05734253, -0.039367676, -0.024337769, -0.025726318, -0.029953003, 0.035369873, 0.01939392, -0.02178955, 0.034301758, 0.02027893, -0.02897644, 0.06793213, -0.03062439, 0.014404297, -0.0012617111, 0.01701355, -0.03010559, 0.016677856, 0.068603516, -0.05380249, -0.061645508, -0.024398804, 0.021057129, -0.05142212, 0.0075531006, 0.00043439865, -0.004211426, -0.030914307, -0.0181427, 0.026412964, 0.06359863, -0.018600464, 0.020431519, 0.06173706, -0.00023066998, 0.0178833, 0.04800415, -0.019500732, 0.031585693, 0.02809143, -0.048339844, 0.03262329, 0.0066719055, 0.020217896, -0.006099701, -0.03363037, 0.03250122, 0.046447754, 0.0050621033, -0.01524353, -0.074157715, 0.051879883, -0.05722046, -0.008094788, -0.041412354, -0.0033893585, -0.030029297, 0.042419434, -0.071777344, 0.030853271, 0.014732361, 0.011962891, 0.010765076, 0.046844482, 0.019256592, -0.06109619, 0.047729492, -0.007709503, 0.038909912, -0.0021629333, -0.017913818, 0.03604126, -0.011878967, 0.021942139, 0.025405884, -0.016220093, 0.033416748, -0.027664185, 0.0016078949, 0.047454834, 0.01576233, -0.009605408, -0.025283813, -0.009506226, 0.03387451, -0.022735596, 0.020111084, 0.006275177, 0.0236969, 0.021331787, -0.042633057, 0.010047913, 0.048828125, -0.009857178, -0.032836914, -0.074157715, 0.030838013, 0.001906395, 0.028137207, -0.008850098, -0.010665894, -0.027999878, -0.036132812, -0.012191772, 0.054138184, -0.024017334, 0.03604126, -0.042266846, -0.059448242, -0.035308838, -0.011146545, -0.028167725, -0.037078857, -0.052520752, 0.009742737, -0.05114746, 0.036468506, 0.0046157837, 0.011428833, -0.005092621, -0.022232056, -0.03225708, 0.009239197, 0.03277588, -0.009727478, -0.03125, 0.010536194, -0.00737381, -0.009117126, -0.029586792, -0.035247803, 0.0034694672, 0.021697998, -0.0030841827, -0.04260254, -0.0016422272, -0.012176514, 0.018432617, -0.013206482, -0.011390686, 0.0022621155, 0.012397766, 0.0209198, -0.0047683716, 0.0095825195, -0.0048828125, 0.026260376, 0.0026226044, 0.06750488, 0.029312134, 0.07043457, -0.037261963, -0.023269653, -0.018707275, -0.0020942688, 0.0048828125, 0.0075263977, 0.00040578842, 0.0088272095, 0.0013122559, -0.022491455, 0.0072250366, 0.0056915283, -0.006351471, -0.017471313, -0.021896362, -0.01676941, 0.046203613, 0.006454468, -0.020523071, 0.018112183, 0.021377563, 0.0013113022, -0.05508423, -0.014625549, -0.004924774, 0.049713135, -0.054901123, -0.021560669, -0.03793335, -0.019058228, 0.022354126, 0.005622864, 0.024963379, -0.053344727, 0.002521515, -0.024627686, -0.00091028214, 0.010795593, -0.027114868, -0.056518555, -0.0143585205, 0.029907227, 0.023010254, 0.045562744, -0.0067825317, 0.03591919, 0.020980835, 0.013839722, 0.006034851, -0.06451416, -0.015045166, 0.016555786, -0.002620697, -0.022064209, 0.008605957, 0.014877319, -0.011009216, 0.04486084, -0.030075073, 0.008140564, 0.019180298, -0.068115234, -0.015571594, -0.035705566, 0.0231781, -0.020019531, 0.047210693, 0.017303467, 0.021072388, -0.08135986, 0.01158905, -0.007789612, -0.0048446655, 0.008934021, -0.01876831, 0.016998291, 0.014076233, 0.010147095, 0.0029335022, 0.012939453, -0.032684326, -0.014556885, -0.0014238358, -0.026153564, -0.008239746, -0.01600647, -0.01675415, 0.0087509155, 0.039794922, -0.045654297, 0.008934021, 0.027496338, -0.051239014, -0.012687683, 0.019851685, -0.008041382, -0.008872986, 0.018539429, 0.061279297, 0.00022029877, 0.034118652, 0.027191162, -0.053497314, -0.011779785, -0.027313232, -0.02545166, -0.017150879, -0.034606934, -0.011680603, 0.042663574, -0.017974854, 0.021697998, 0.02444458, -0.015548706, 0.028701782, -0.014045715, -0.038208008, 0.00012934208, -0.020202637, 0.0023174286, -0.012542725, -0.009933472, -0.0061836243, -0.024612427, -0.005519867, -0.042236328, 0.0070114136, 0.020126343, 0.00003272295, -0.030303955, -0.044128418, -0.00010752678, 0.024627686, 0.020996094, 0.011451721, 0.057250977, 0.036132812, 0.07348633, -0.024612427, 0.028335571, 0.011138916, -0.025985718, -0.010475159, -0.010559082, 0.008377075, 0.0059890747, 0.082214355, -0.0023880005, -0.029541016, -0.039733887, -0.013511658, 0.0024642944, -0.0034828186, -0.033447266, 0.015151978, -0.005744934, 0.036499023, 0.034973145, 0.0009212494, -0.02180481, -0.03878784, -0.0037059784, -0.01914978, -0.024215698, 0.0680542, 0.0031223297, 0.0040626526, -0.019241333, -0.017807007, -0.0072746277, -0.008895874, 0.02381897, 0.008270264, 0.0036621094, -0.028915405, 0.004573822, -0.015205383, 0.059387207, -0.051116943, -0.02670288, 0.019546509, 0.06628418, -0.019500732, -0.007774353, -0.026550293, 0.004135132, 0.012672424, -0.014282227, 0.0025348663, -0.02130127, 0.07287598, -0.029449463, -0.03503418, -0.10559082, -0.06463623, -0.038482666, 0.02468872, -0.061798096, -0.005054474, -0.009109497, 0.012313843, -0.033233643, 0.0090408325, -0.027938843, 0.020568848, 0.006515503, -0.010101318, -0.0116119385, 0.031707764, 0.002729416, 0.00088739395, 0.023361206, -0.03881836, 0.045928955, -0.00026226044, 0.005748749, -0.0395813, 0.0010519028, -0.0064430237, -0.040496826, 0.019165039, -0.010612488, -0.0008482933, 0.008583069, 0.03427124, 0.015060425, 0.023635864, -0.0029201508, 0.006362915, 0.011184692, 0.018508911, 0.0023384094, 0.018920898, 0.013084412, -0.011688232, 0.019348145, 0.02508545, -0.032165527, 0.03149414, -0.0048713684, 0.047454834, -0.08099365, -0.036712646, -0.02041626, 0.019866943, -0.0102005005, -0.020324707, -0.03466797, -0.0345459, 0.036499023, 0.00049734116, -0.03793335, 0.012969971, 0.055267334, 0.011497498, 0.016738892, -0.0023899078, 0.00036597252, 0.006877899, -0.0011129379, 0.02418518, 0.028457642, 0.053771973, 0.021743774, -0.008262634, 0.040008545, 0.00919342, -0.0231781, 0.042144775, -0.003194809, 0.07635498, 0.09893799, 0.06616211, -0.026641846, 0.0069999695, 0.107299805, -0.03869629, -0.0071525574, -0.013679504, 0.015060425, -0.0029697418, -0.03543091, 0.010658264, -0.008110046, -0.023788452, 0.025177002, -0.07739258, 0.024475098, -0.0058021545, -0.012718201, -0.028823853, 0.025482178, -0.038513184, -0.017868042, -0.0368042, 0.017044067, -0.026000977, -0.037872314, -0.012145996, -0.025604248, 0.018692017, 0.016616821, -0.008888245, 0.025558472, 0.0011949539, -0.042236328, 0.014595032, -0.019638062, 0.08380127, -0.035888672, -0.028686523, 0.055664062, 0.0020828247, 0.00856781, -0.046691895, -0.025283813, -0.012504578, 0.033294678, 0.009887695, -0.035736084, -0.014923096, -0.03277588, -0.00005441904, -0.04156494, 0.04724121, -0.042755127, 0.042022705, 0.03237915, -0.014228821, -0.006587982, 0.019973755, -0.029800415, 0.03286743, -0.02230835, -0.03262329, -0.0052490234, 0.038238525, -0.023376465, -0.012916565, -0.012321472, -0.006462097, -0.053222656, -0.042541504, 0.01386261, 0.006214142, 0.055847168, -0.0064086914, -0.018478394, 0.015022278, 0.013381958, 0.029891968, 0.0020561218, -0.0015945435, -0.027679443, -0.019119263, 0.0017156601, 0.0023231506, 0.013954163, 0.05734253, 0.041137695, -0.011116028, -0.0018978119, -0.011299133, -0.013145447, -0.024734497, -0.022903442, -0.04800415, 0.015670776, -0.023849487, -0.037384033, 0.01486969, -0.012062073, -0.045928955, 0.015136719, -0.011245728, -0.025009155, 0.0104599, -0.012176514, -0.036743164, 0.024627686, -0.046020508, 0.0041122437, -0.052612305, -0.025512695, -0.024353027, -0.0038604736, -0.019256592, 0.001584053, 0.0066070557, 0.016296387, -0.017654419, 0.050048828, 0.023880005, 0.08093262, -0.007129669, 0.009407043, 0.03375244, -0.04373169, -0.026657104, -0.021484375, -0.034301758, 0.037597656, 0.0024814606, -0.0060157776, 0.05883789, -0.044067383, 0.010139465, 0.024154663, 0.020431519, -0.02670288, 0.030166626, -0.004009247, 0.036010742, 0.027893066 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07037v1
Phonological Level wav2vec2-based Mispronunciation Detection and Diagnosis Method
Mostafa Shahin, Julien Epps, Beena Ahmed
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL
The automatic identification and analysis of pronunciation errors, known as Mispronunciation Detection and Diagnosis (MDD) plays a crucial role in Computer Aided Pronunciation Learning (CAPL) tools such as Second-Language (L2) learning or speech therapy applications. Existing MDD methods relying on analysing phonemes can only detect categorical errors of phonemes that have an adequate amount of training data to be modelled. With the unpredictable nature of the pronunciation errors of non-native or disordered speakers and the scarcity of training datasets, it is unfeasible to model all types of mispronunciations. Moreover, phoneme-level MDD approaches have a limited ability to provide detailed diagnostic information about the error made. In this paper, we propose a low-level MDD approach based on the detection of speech attribute features. Speech attribute features break down phoneme production into elementary components that are directly related to the articulatory system leading to more formative feedback to the learner. We further propose a multi-label variant of the Connectionist Temporal Classification (CTC) approach to jointly model the non-mutually exclusive speech attributes using a single model. The pre-trained wav2vec2 model was employed as a core model for the speech attribute detector. The proposed method was applied to L2 speech corpora collected from English learners from different native languages. The proposed speech attribute MDD method was further compared to the traditional phoneme-level MDD and achieved a significantly lower False Acceptance Rate (FAR), False Rejection Rate (FRR), and Diagnostic Error Rate (DER) over all speech attributes compared to the phoneme-level equivalent.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07037v1
2023-11-13T02:41:41
2023-11-13T02:41:41
{ "title": [ 0.012542725, -0.006313324, -0.06085205, -0.046722412, -0.0075950623, -0.02519226, -0.011276245, 0.021194458, -0.018814087, 0.055999756, -0.01965332, -0.011558533, 0.047180176, -0.05154419, -0.004119873, -0.0013513565, -0.014404297, 0.06890869, 0.021469116, -0.02229309, 0.015098572, -0.033172607, 0.00674057, -0.021270752, -0.026504517, -0.04232788, -0.031143188, -0.010826111, -0.025604248, -0.03692627, -0.009460449, 0.03152466, 0.032836914, 0.039764404, -0.041778564, -0.004047394, -0.07092285, 0.051696777, 0.005710602, 0.0022525787, 0.0028877258, 0.019485474, 0.043914795, -0.03479004, 0.002576828, 0.02331543, -0.03503418, -0.015701294, 0.005542755, 0.03265381, 0.0048294067, 0.034332275, 0.0110321045, 0.035125732, 0.0105896, -0.027908325, -0.020477295, 0.009689331, 0.004760742, 0.044128418, 0.013282776, 0.020614624, 0.004501343, -0.004371643, -0.035736084, -0.022705078, -0.04144287, 0.033569336, 0.04537964, -0.037139893, -0.015991211, 0.017578125, -0.028030396, -0.0054855347, -0.039215088, 0.023132324, 0.034332275, 0.008232117, 0.032714844, -0.004173279, -0.0030517578, -0.010749817, 0.017410278, -0.034240723, 0.056732178, -0.019714355, -0.005420685, -0.013092041, -0.06945801, -0.076293945, -0.025878906, -0.029373169, -0.047912598, -0.025390625, -0.024154663, -0.036590576, 0.024749756, 0.02947998, -0.023071289, -0.029006958, -0.039794922, 0.013557434, -0.020111084, -0.013374329, 0.037200928, 0.011054993, -0.06317139, -0.03994751, 0.04458618, 0.0287323, -0.023452759, 0.01878357, 0.015487671, -0.06304932, 0.012260437, 0.023712158, 0.018295288, 0.010879517, 0.04196167, -0.028305054, 0.019607544, 0.002878189, 0.009353638, -0.022216797, 0.032928467, 0.0029792786, -0.047698975, -0.00233078, -0.0020160675, 0.04537964, 0.015533447, 0.0423584, -0.068359375, -0.07550049, -0.07318115, 0.0129776, 0.014602661, 0.029464722, -0.007522583, -0.012908936, -0.0074806213, -0.021942139, 0.0015592575, -0.0017700195, 0.0095825195, 0.0017223358, 0.045532227, 0.010421753, -0.03781128, -0.041107178, -0.0141067505, 0.040130615, 0.012924194, -0.03173828, -0.017227173, -0.057769775, -0.10443115, -0.03942871, 0.06945801, -0.005203247, -0.00036907196, 0.00068092346, 0.013549805, 0.03552246, 0.013473511, 0.026535034, 0.0018310547, 0.0047416687, 0.0061836243, -0.019012451, -0.031951904, 0.033355713, 0.025253296, -0.019607544, -0.013549805, -0.0138549805, 0.007232666, 0.017120361, 0.035888672, 0.0024414062, 0.01436615, -0.0116119385, 0.054351807, 0.018310547, -0.04522705, -0.037078857, 0.011230469, -0.0025482178, 0.034240723, 0.014411926, 0.036834717, 0.010154724, -0.0072746277, 0.026916504, -0.028839111, -0.06951904, 0.02897644, -0.0034980774, -0.010749817, 0.006580353, -0.039733887, 0.009185791, -0.024993896, -0.008834839, -0.06298828, -0.019866943, -0.02532959, 0.029067993, 0.010635376, 0.028900146, 0.021728516, -0.023788452, -0.0181427, 0.02456665, -0.034942627, -0.042907715, 0.024429321, 0.0018310547, -0.010147095, -0.0038471222, -0.046325684, -0.007797241, -0.03656006, 0.023956299, 0.021850586, -0.012359619, 0.004425049, -0.025863647, 0.04257202, 0.016464233, 0.05041504, -0.01638794, 0.040924072, 0.027511597, -0.01889038, -0.009773254, 0.003982544, -0.008033752, 0.015319824, 0.004962921, -0.009819031, -0.03656006, -0.009185791, 0.047576904, 0.04888916, 0.01007843, 0.0067710876, 0.027008057, -0.015777588, 0.008728027, 0.05480957, 0.038360596, 0.036346436, 0.020965576, -0.00856781, 0.078063965, -0.0055122375, -0.0102005005, -0.01713562, -0.015007019, 0.021850586, -0.03186035, -0.018737793, -0.013877869, -0.056488037, -0.023712158, -0.050048828, -0.022979736, 0.011772156, -0.0075683594, 0.014877319, -0.026138306, 0.01675415, 0.007331848, -0.018173218, -0.008117676, -0.02633667, 0.0060539246, 0.031280518, -0.02923584, 0.002313614, 0.02607727, 0.013931274, -0.015136719, 0.010055542, 0.014282227, 0.017654419, -0.0066947937, -0.06304932, -0.008705139, 0.03793335, 0.050720215, 0.0052604675, -0.015716553, 0.056365967, 0.032348633, 0.07092285, 0.082458496, -0.043151855, 0.049835205, -0.07922363, -0.00655365, 0.019973755, -0.032165527, 0.016418457, 0.046051025, 0.051818848, -0.009178162, -0.0101623535, 0.028198242, -0.049316406, 0.0042381287, -0.018447876, -0.026916504, -0.05319214, -0.030059814, -0.021621704, -0.04336548, -0.04852295, -0.0124053955, 0.015449524, 0.042663574, -0.008232117, 0.027893066, 0.02609253, -0.01966858, 0.015472412, -0.023620605, 0.0025997162, 0.022964478, 0.076660156, 0.03286743, -0.042236328, -0.03527832, 0.013458252, 0.010406494, 0.0059280396, -0.012626648, 0.0028457642, 0.026809692, 0.046051025, 0.029785156, -0.010597229, -0.027359009, -0.016159058, -0.034729004, 0.009552002, 0.0076141357, -0.07458496, -0.023895264, 0.05819702, -0.037322998, 0.031799316, -0.016586304, 0.0748291, -0.015579224, -0.05154419, 0.02696228, 0.040618896, -0.003921509, 0.04864502, 0.047668457, 0.035888672, -0.03604126, -0.044036865, -0.06567383, -0.009605408, -0.0040512085, -0.028259277, 0.008422852, -0.036834717, -0.023284912, -0.025283813, -0.021911621, -0.01878357, 0.01701355, -0.009788513, -0.051757812, -0.0309906, -0.034118652, -0.015525818, -0.013793945, 0.015930176, 0.018875122, 0.05581665, 0.002166748, 0.0040779114, 0.0004181862, 0.022201538, -0.008262634, -0.015777588, -0.02017212, -0.04837036, -0.021148682, 0.043273926, 0.0027828217, 0.021331787, 0.0024681091, -0.06573486, -0.012519836, 0.04763794, -0.0211792, -0.02822876, 0.028259277, -0.03741455, -0.016494751, 0.03869629, -0.0087509155, 0.03552246, 0.024047852, 0.030532837, 0.016693115, 0.043395996, -0.030059814, -0.002248764, -0.029846191, -0.05105591, 0.03375244, -0.013061523, -0.044006348, -0.01058197, -0.01890564, -0.037597656, -0.023498535, -0.018051147, 0.05819702, 0.01486969, -0.022125244, 0.02357483, 0.007873535, 0.025238037, -0.0023899078, 0.0050621033, -0.031280518, -0.0074424744, 0.028717041, -0.020767212, 0.05343628, -0.0048294067, 0.009307861, 0.00048446655, 0.010063171, -0.009590149, 0.046173096, -0.02128601, -0.015686035, 0.0028686523, 0.0028190613, -0.034118652, 0.03363037, -0.016601562, 0.008239746, -0.06512451, 0.023025513, -0.025100708, 0.035064697, 0.01927185, 0.041229248, 0.021347046, -0.025985718, -0.002439499, -0.03491211, -0.022369385, 0.012161255, -0.013015747, 0.02432251, -0.02609253, 0.009246826, -0.014320374, -0.022918701, 0.009277344, 0.018737793, 0.0010232925, -0.01890564, 0.0067634583, -0.024383545, -0.010322571, 0.024108887, -0.023010254, -0.028762817, -0.013687134, 0.010009766, -0.01158905, -0.053619385, -0.0059890747, -0.016433716, -0.059936523, -0.013420105, -0.0035057068, -0.055877686, -0.049560547, -0.024505615, -0.0011644363, -0.02709961, -0.04598999, 0.014328003, 0.0072746277, -0.06561279, -0.0101623535, -0.05050659, -0.07128906, 0.07952881, -0.010276794, 0.010383606, 0.029296875, -0.035308838, -0.014884949, 0.0061683655, 0.035583496, -0.0035076141, 0.052001953, 0.0050621033, -0.023361206, 0.035064697, -0.026779175, 0.0048942566, 0.04434204, -0.010009766, 0.025497437, -0.003479004, -0.0048599243, -0.0031394958, 0.015777588, 0.079833984, -0.016937256, -0.010269165, -0.045654297, -0.004299164, -0.020614624, -0.030181885, -0.012176514, -0.009315491, -0.033966064, 0.0045318604, 0.059570312, 0.047210693, 0.021453857, -0.029373169, -0.022064209, -0.0054473877, -0.007534027, -0.0010614395, 0.01272583, -0.0017108917, 0.01889038, -0.02305603, 0.00504303, 0.0234375, 0.015823364, -0.020355225, -0.0061187744, 0.017608643, -0.012229919, -0.010894775, -0.048065186, -0.041992188, -0.022720337, 0.009536743, 0.00573349, 0.014556885, -0.007850647, 0.018112183, -0.053741455, 0.026565552, 0.030654907, 0.011619568, -0.032073975, -0.06689453, -0.024978638, -0.00970459, -0.076660156, -0.026901245, -0.02720642, -0.04559326, 0.02281189, -0.038085938, -0.044555664, -0.0042533875, 0.032043457, 0.068847656, 0.021377563, -0.013038635, -0.06982422, -0.052337646, -0.03881836, -0.048309326, 0.029006958, -0.061431885, -0.013160706, -0.023513794, 0.062408447, -0.017974854, -0.010307312, 0.024917603, 0.0060272217, -0.05886841, 0.048614502, -0.022415161, 0.07952881, 0.0075912476, 0.012298584, 0.016342163, 0.008125305, -0.032470703, 0.009757996, 0.01977539, 0.034576416, 0.0040245056, -0.0015535355, 0.024963379, 0.022598267, -0.025985718, 0.026275635, 0.024642944, 0.026626587, 0.04425049, -0.024917603, 0.028900146, -0.041259766, -0.023590088, -0.011749268, -0.024505615, 0.028335571, -0.061401367, -0.0017690659, -0.040008545, 0.0289917, 0.047302246, 0.009727478, -0.004207611, 0.04953003, 0.004131317, -0.052856445, -0.04046631, 0.0054512024, 0.041900635, -0.046203613, -0.0036449432, 0.0006580353, 0.006542206, 0.030166626, 0.030593872, 0.038848877, 0.039489746, -0.042388916, -0.0069274902, 0.04525757, -0.02746582, -0.034484863, 0.0036029816, 0.020233154, 0.027191162, -0.003850937, 0.027297974, -0.04714966, 0.012886047, -0.009811401, 0.004901886, -0.00018513203, -0.038848877, 0.014801025, 0.037628174, 0.014968872, 0.0046958923, -0.0036258698, 0.002960205, 0.023284912, 0.029754639, 0.010223389, -0.005241394, 0.045166016, -0.08850098, 0.045043945, 0.0007276535, -0.012924194, -0.022201538, 0.025939941, -0.012962341, 0.014801025, -0.042419434, 0.01576233, 0.0018415451, 0.00068187714, 0.018112183, -0.049835205, 0.025161743, 0.010009766, -0.019546509, 0.007896423, -0.0574646, -0.053344727, 0.0049057007, -0.04196167, -0.03717041, 0.011222839, -0.009719849, -0.053100586, -0.010658264, 0.04660034, -0.024032593, 0.013870239, 0.012702942, -0.02520752, -0.028030396, 0.002008438, 0.048706055, -0.054504395, -0.00091362, -0.018951416, 0.020187378, 0.02545166, 0.012359619, -0.05935669, -0.0082092285, 0.039276123, -0.04611206, -0.031219482, 0.04107666, 0.013511658, -0.036621094, 0.0006928444, -0.07800293, -0.02003479, 0.0067596436, 0.010314941, -0.014732361, 0.019805908, 0.027496338, -0.0023117065, 0.0118255615, -0.0024280548, -0.00038075447, 0.030853271, -0.0012140274, -0.013702393, 0.0012722015, 0.01360321, 0.016174316, 0.049224854, -0.046142578, -0.06842041, -0.002166748, 0.022064209, -0.0018253326, -0.024398804, 0.045715332, 0.02470398, -0.020385742, 0.02658081, 0.016693115, 0.05822754, -0.02909851, -0.044555664, -0.024353027, -0.025848389, -0.036956787, 0.103393555, 0.008987427, -0.04196167, -0.052978516, -0.0368042, -0.0067329407, 0.01864624, 0.021728516, 0.008071899, 0.04058838, -0.03363037, 0.006652832, -0.030929565, -0.022857666, -0.039093018, 0.012176514, -0.0045814514, 0.010765076, 0.027008057, -0.030227661, 0.014137268, -0.008201599, -0.019866943, 0.012199402, -0.016571045, 0.0063476562, -0.076416016, 0.005622864, -0.00995636, 0.0042152405, 0.013420105, -0.0020427704, 0.0031967163, 0.021224976, -0.035308838, 0.033721924, -0.002363205, 0.028869629, 0.028930664, -0.0006723404, -0.0259552, 0.0043525696, -0.016326904, -0.045135498, -0.018508911, -0.06210327, -0.00957489, -0.07330322, 0.008285522, -0.0713501, 0.054504395, -0.040527344, 0.009231567, 0.0033302307, 0.005115509, 0.031463623, -0.014465332, 0.03918457, -0.07849121, 0.03982544, -0.016464233, 0.0072746277, -0.02204895, -0.016494751, 0.020614624, 0.026153564, -0.0033607483, 0.017349243, 0.0058174133, -0.049926758, 0.028808594, 0.005683899, 0.018218994, -0.030838013, -0.0058059692, -0.041992188, 0.05267334, 0.01586914, 0.044952393, 0.039855957, 0.030853271, -0.011955261, -0.021896362, -0.017684937, -0.019744873, -0.029434204, -0.010513306, 0.04626465, -0.06750488, 0.04019165, -0.012817383, -0.028381348, -0.044799805, 0.051483154, -0.00655365, -0.012794495, 0.016036987, 0.00076913834, 0.012084961, 0.015274048, 0.04244995, -0.02558899, -0.05178833, -0.016494751, 0.045074463, -0.023483276, 0.027496338, -0.0008845329, 0.010414124, 0.03289795, -0.022125244, 0.027313232, 0.015312195, 0.04067993, 0.029647827, 0.011688232, 0.03781128, -0.027694702, -0.038085938, -0.026611328, 0.016067505, -0.057891846, -0.032196045, 0.03604126, -0.024917603, -0.050079346, -0.003238678, -0.013916016, -0.041015625, -0.037597656, -0.0099487305, 0.014892578, 0.04650879, -0.026107788, 0.0101623535, -0.0019664764, -0.0036411285, 0.060150146, -0.009552002, 0.03604126, -0.031234741, 0.015357971, -0.028213501, 0.009185791, -0.0021858215, -0.028945923, -0.005493164, -0.00087594986, -0.044128418, 0.0071754456, -0.002483368, -0.058013916, -0.026489258, -0.02659607, 0.017059326, -0.007572174, 0.006099701, 0.03930664, -0.020523071, -0.028503418, 0.008720398, -0.019760132, 0.053833008, -0.026153564, -0.040039062, -0.039733887, -0.0046424866, 0.031204224, -0.002368927, -0.013023376, -0.023269653, -0.032836914, 0.0047798157, -0.004802704, 0.017089844, -0.017868042, -0.006198883, 0.002998352, 0.010375977, -0.04046631, 0.018569946, -0.0013837814, -0.0019989014, -0.092163086, -0.017303467, -0.024047852, -0.030197144, -0.0015487671, -0.029006958, 0.037384033, -0.008575439, -0.003534317, 0.009284973, 0.033050537, 0.03353882, -0.036590576, -0.0013093948, -0.01878357, 0.04046631, 0.04534912, -0.053009033, -0.103515625, -0.013954163, 0.0052375793, -0.02229309, 0.005428314, 0.0038108826, 0.009056091, 0.033233643, 0.000259161, 0.0024223328, -0.025863647, 0.021438599, -0.028747559, 0.020965576, 0.030715942, -0.026565552, 0.023651123, 0.0025787354, 0.019683838, -0.0036125183, 0.0017528534, -0.025802612, -0.010528564, -0.008529663, 0.01600647, -0.025009155, 0.006668091, -0.044189453, 0.03186035, -0.005619049, 0.00818634, -0.016433716, 0.025375366, -0.005329132, 0.040374756, -0.012840271, -0.07171631, 0.08416748, 0.031311035, 0.034454346, -0.018051147, 0.056030273, -0.017028809, -0.013809204, -0.010353088, 0.017486572, 0.026885986, 0.01675415, -0.06982422, 0.0026607513, -0.09661865, -0.036743164, -0.016235352, -0.04397583, 0.048614502, -0.011802673, 0.004550934, 0.006641388, -0.009086609, 0.0030097961, 0.01020813, 0.0014038086, -0.007156372, -0.06060791, -0.03842163, 0.022155762, -0.02267456 ], "summary": [ 0.016555786, -0.010284424, -0.01586914, -0.022628784, -0.037719727, -0.016479492, -0.009986877, 0.004436493, 0.00010359287, 0.034484863, 0.02507019, -0.00052309036, 0.039611816, -0.058807373, 0.024505615, 0.012931824, -0.04711914, 0.08618164, 0.01360321, -0.039489746, 0.0015668869, -0.06781006, -0.032165527, -0.04095459, -0.0289917, 0.0021629333, -0.009307861, 0.0152282715, -0.031982422, -0.0034332275, -0.0038871765, 0.015548706, 0.00035238266, 0.04751587, -0.011177063, 0.06774902, -0.024551392, 0.0435791, 0.031463623, 0.013374329, 0.043945312, -0.024307251, 0.07043457, -0.0031967163, 0.0020771027, 0.033813477, 0.03729248, -0.019210815, 0.025299072, 0.016983032, 0.006549835, 0.01007843, 0.0015163422, -0.025726318, -0.00592041, 0.0034923553, -0.045288086, 0.021972656, -0.03994751, 0.0970459, 0.06866455, 0.074157715, -0.04385376, 0.0014286041, -0.014694214, -0.011222839, -0.007572174, 0.0032577515, 0.018722534, -0.029144287, 0.016098022, 0.024505615, -0.01171875, -0.026321411, -0.029205322, 0.03265381, 0.010772705, 0.0077323914, 0.0129852295, -0.012161255, -0.008575439, 0.0129852295, 0.0112838745, -0.025314331, 0.0048217773, -0.005722046, -0.010360718, -0.0113220215, -0.052520752, -0.038208008, -0.022476196, -0.005004883, -0.08123779, 0.0063171387, 0.008262634, -0.016571045, 0.029556274, 0.016723633, -0.0018882751, -0.021209717, -0.009895325, -0.027694702, -0.006881714, -0.021774292, 0.021453857, 0.022079468, -0.044708252, -0.06829834, 0.024642944, 0.019821167, -0.021392822, -0.0025024414, 0.01159668, -0.09161377, 0.014335632, 0.0463562, 0.03616333, 0.026428223, 0.05218506, -0.037963867, 0.000048279762, 0.041778564, -0.028182983, -0.005634308, 0.029754639, 0.02532959, 0.010696411, -0.023590088, 0.042663574, 0.05456543, -0.009613037, 0.0022468567, -0.036590576, -0.04058838, -0.0496521, -0.00844574, 0.043945312, 0.010070801, -0.01953125, -0.0022449493, -0.0015048981, -0.016113281, -0.0090408325, 0.0044898987, -0.0026950836, 0.008743286, 0.00015068054, 0.040496826, 0.0037498474, -0.04055786, 0.042541504, -0.004878998, 0.040985107, -0.030975342, -0.03781128, -0.09979248, -0.05847168, -0.027664185, 0.045288086, -0.047851562, 0.017730713, -0.015792847, -0.019546509, 0.0647583, -0.012283325, 0.041778564, 0.032287598, -0.0099487305, 0.002418518, -0.046295166, -0.0102005005, 0.06188965, 0.013328552, 0.00070667267, 0.0039253235, -0.021697998, 0.016677856, 0.042938232, 0.017852783, 0.015174866, 0.025863647, -0.02470398, 0.06695557, 0.0028705597, -0.025421143, -0.015853882, 0.013595581, 0.0124435425, 0.022018433, 0.008712769, 0.037017822, -0.014427185, 0.020492554, 0.016342163, -0.008117676, -0.046813965, -0.007904053, -0.003692627, -0.024032593, -0.014694214, 0.015731812, 0.040527344, 0.013221741, -0.0065841675, -0.07098389, 0.06793213, -0.041229248, 0.05935669, -0.030731201, 0.028427124, 0.036468506, -0.041412354, -0.047058105, 0.08215332, 0.007041931, -0.05050659, 0.0020179749, -0.030670166, -0.003522873, -0.010658264, -0.01966858, 0.00724411, -0.04510498, 0.03567505, -0.009307861, 0.019973755, -0.02545166, 0.022277832, 0.0056114197, 0.042877197, -0.0023899078, -0.025024414, -0.005153656, 0.002073288, -0.020690918, 0.015289307, 0.008621216, -0.039733887, 0.005607605, 0.025344849, 0.01210022, -0.015670776, -0.007247925, 0.040649414, 0.016174316, -0.015579224, 0.006587982, 0.011802673, -0.02456665, -0.0021419525, 0.01838684, 0.011268616, 0.031433105, 0.015823364, -0.008407593, 0.036712646, -0.016921997, -0.05908203, -0.01121521, -0.010498047, 0.0256958, -0.09118652, -0.068847656, -0.013656616, -0.03137207, -0.011367798, -0.030807495, -0.033935547, 0.017456055, -0.0035076141, 0.001036644, -0.06744385, 0.010231018, -0.015991211, -0.06365967, 0.02027893, -0.02758789, 0.039916992, 0.020050049, -0.015701294, -0.00969696, 0.028213501, 0.03353882, -0.02470398, -0.007209778, -0.014083862, 0.025848389, -0.016525269, -0.013679504, 0.01776123, 0.023727417, 0.06921387, 0.023483276, -0.0014829636, 0.04852295, 0.023864746, 0.017990112, 0.0546875, -0.016799927, 0.021713257, -0.06097412, 0.008460999, 0.02293396, -0.041107178, 0.01687622, 0.016693115, 0.009223938, -0.0008096695, 0.016723633, -0.004081726, -0.0045776367, 0.02923584, 0.0098724365, 0.056884766, -0.06185913, -0.05105591, -0.026031494, 0.007205963, -0.043029785, 0.01499176, 0.03955078, 0.005153656, 0.015777588, 0.030166626, 0.0013027191, -0.04437256, 0.08013916, -0.007419586, 0.027709961, 0.012039185, 0.010375977, 0.0107421875, -0.042999268, -0.048187256, 0.010223389, -0.0017004013, 0.022781372, -0.057281494, 0.008865356, 0.028915405, 0.06518555, 0.034454346, -0.011734009, -0.014503479, -0.06915283, 0.04135132, 0.015975952, -0.005203247, -0.015197754, -0.009803772, 0.026901245, -0.029968262, 0.0070152283, 0.03378296, 0.037384033, 0.0016622543, -0.012298584, 0.025100708, 0.039215088, -0.01979065, 0.06878662, 0.05609131, 0.06384277, -0.032806396, -0.09173584, -0.043426514, 0.015701294, -0.011436462, -0.024139404, 0.0018873215, 0.0058670044, 0.001543045, -0.03692627, -0.02545166, -0.050048828, 0.0069122314, 0.047729492, -0.030334473, -0.02935791, 0.0074920654, 0.0022583008, 0.01197052, -0.003818512, 0.01727295, 0.061065674, 0.0034542084, 0.008514404, 0.024841309, 0.035583496, -0.0056037903, 0.0034675598, -0.007724762, -0.028289795, -0.013290405, 0.034301758, 0.032928467, -0.013404846, -0.008522034, -0.035095215, -0.023361206, 0.0017786026, 0.040771484, 0.023345947, 0.017700195, 0.010047913, -0.008201599, 0.041900635, -0.003648758, 0.050628662, -0.06536865, 0.022003174, -0.028015137, 0.01739502, -0.06021118, -0.0121154785, -0.03277588, 0.026641846, 0.029937744, -0.064453125, -0.015419006, 0.012001038, 0.036193848, -0.017456055, -0.025360107, 0.002204895, 0.097839355, -0.016281128, -0.014503479, 0.034973145, 0.012863159, 0.04034424, 0.008666992, -0.0034618378, -0.0027122498, -0.040649414, 0.044525146, 0.0037975311, 0.05392456, 0.022842407, -0.03729248, 0.016540527, 0.02255249, -0.026947021, 0.027679443, -0.010307312, -0.016036987, 0.008430481, -0.022903442, -0.00021743774, 0.008522034, -0.027633667, -0.0030956268, 0.00053167343, 0.026184082, -0.011642456, 0.047546387, 0.00063467026, 0.027877808, 0.025344849, -0.011505127, 0.009353638, -0.004386902, -0.023406982, -0.00705719, 0.041137695, 0.023834229, -0.053222656, 0.03527832, 0.018615723, -0.018203735, 0.05947876, -0.031951904, -0.0035171509, -0.03643799, 0.03250122, -0.04888916, -0.017303467, 0.014411926, 0.0077705383, -0.008453369, -0.042877197, 0.02420044, -0.0211792, -0.070129395, -0.015037537, 0.0032806396, -0.07287598, -0.02619934, -0.010124207, -0.0031223297, -0.006664276, -0.013305664, 0.025360107, -0.015289307, -0.034301758, -0.011192322, -0.011703491, 0.013534546, -0.029907227, -0.08111572, 0.00009423494, 0.0024986267, 0.0023536682, 0.042816162, -0.008239746, -0.00920105, 0.0137786865, 0.0026798248, 0.023330688, -0.01914978, 0.01625061, -0.014930725, -0.0035419464, 0.03567505, -0.022354126, 0.024261475, 0.04586792, 0.039520264, 0.012451172, -0.03062439, 0.0060310364, 0.045654297, 0.028076172, 0.068603516, -0.064208984, -0.01108551, -0.0017271042, -0.02619934, -0.03768921, -0.014472961, 0.00623703, 0.05340576, -0.088012695, -0.05078125, 0.052642822, -0.046783447, -0.0152282715, -0.0049552917, -0.0491333, -0.010475159, -0.032714844, -0.0129470825, 0.056610107, 0.009353638, 0.008102417, -0.023666382, -0.014778137, -0.031402588, 0.0024967194, -0.044647217, 0.0066070557, 0.03378296, -0.02229309, -0.04937744, -0.050109863, -0.03414917, -0.0029296875, 0.016921997, 0.011474609, -0.026168823, -0.034606934, 0.0055999756, -0.005973816, 0.016647339, -0.002904892, 0.03967285, -0.055358887, -0.05404663, -0.0051841736, 0.0043029785, -0.04574585, -0.0044403076, -0.033447266, -0.0881958, -0.011054993, -0.027801514, -0.018753052, -0.00598526, 0.025131226, 0.03930664, 0.03555298, 0.008018494, -0.06011963, -0.064819336, -0.0335083, -0.040039062, 0.034301758, -0.099853516, -0.01777649, -0.0093307495, 0.08465576, -0.014907837, -0.010940552, 0.0141067505, -0.026351929, 0.000021755695, 0.015289307, -0.022521973, 0.04446411, -0.0055236816, -0.0057525635, 0.013389587, -0.0028038025, -0.014305115, -0.005645752, 0.025299072, 0.00932312, 0.009635925, -0.03845215, -0.018051147, -0.010414124, -0.0054855347, 0.045196533, -0.027236938, 0.039520264, 0.04220581, -0.017990112, 0.01209259, -0.034423828, -0.036468506, -0.0063819885, -0.042541504, 0.012893677, -0.009506226, -0.035095215, 0.010643005, 0.020095825, 0.031951904, -0.013168335, -0.016647339, 0.028564453, -0.02558899, -0.035736084, -0.014045715, 0.0055007935, 0.021865845, -0.032989502, -0.015258789, -0.053100586, -0.053833008, 0.013084412, 0.0059509277, 0.0079193115, 0.020767212, -0.04638672, -0.024597168, 0.010894775, -0.02861023, -0.008850098, -0.004211426, 0.015899658, 0.006855011, 0.022994995, -0.0068740845, -0.0068244934, -0.0018749237, -0.011650085, 0.032562256, -0.0074882507, -0.027877808, -0.02394104, 0.0025043488, -0.011627197, 0.0088272095, 0.008972168, -0.014373779, 0.0070724487, 0.014694214, -0.005241394, -0.05038452, 0.00818634, -0.06048584, 0.040924072, -0.024963379, -0.028152466, -0.007106781, 0.018295288, -0.013328552, 0.004714966, -0.029129028, 0.0029468536, 0.0014162064, 0.00083351135, -0.024383545, -0.0007686615, 0.028671265, 0.009742737, -0.018203735, -0.027297974, -0.021774292, -0.036468506, 0.010917664, -0.042144775, -0.025924683, -0.00055933, -0.05227661, -0.052520752, 0.0046539307, 0.0236969, -0.041534424, -0.024917603, 0.025115967, -0.0012302399, -0.0039749146, -0.040649414, 0.005760193, -0.0014247894, 0.025939941, -0.0076942444, 0.008834839, -0.002828598, -0.009346008, -0.016586304, -0.0049972534, 0.022064209, -0.019088745, -0.015167236, 0.0335083, 0.018096924, -0.01322937, 0.016784668, -0.032226562, 0.035858154, -0.044799805, 0.011947632, -0.043548584, 0.04925537, 0.018356323, -0.027008057, -0.055236816, 0.010139465, -0.027420044, 0.026885986, -0.0047035217, -0.0357666, -0.023452759, 0.050079346, 0.008918762, 0.06311035, -0.025360107, -0.010169983, 0.00491333, 0.046051025, 0.0017185211, -0.008758545, 0.03552246, 0.008369446, 0.028396606, 0.012794495, -0.0034809113, 0.0184021, 0.0055274963, -0.049743652, -0.0435791, 0.011383057, -0.010177612, 0.067993164, -0.033081055, -0.06549072, -0.01637268, -0.043518066, 0.011680603, -0.0025978088, 0.0033473969, 0.012542725, 0.021270752, -0.02130127, 0.028701782, -0.021377563, -0.03503418, -0.014732361, 0.049743652, -0.007648468, -0.00015413761, 0.015289307, -0.045654297, 0.0014600754, 0.0056419373, -0.020370483, 0.030960083, -0.016921997, 0.016113281, -0.054138184, -0.00022053719, -0.014953613, 0.02696228, -0.034942627, 0.040527344, -0.03125, -0.024856567, -0.025253296, 0.04296875, 0.017410278, -0.004196167, 0.013961792, -0.033355713, -0.05456543, 0.0052223206, -0.04525757, -0.04888916, -0.024917603, -0.01940918, -0.02558899, -0.042785645, -0.014816284, 0.013244629, 0.0914917, -0.072143555, -0.04675293, 0.049682617, -0.013885498, 0.014472961, -0.01550293, -0.049865723, -0.042266846, -0.032684326, -0.04336548, -0.03237915, 0.00029110909, 0.008529663, 0.026321411, 0.039886475, 0.026153564, -0.020858765, 0.01361084, -0.040039062, 0.038238525, -0.010765076, 0.0040893555, -0.046691895, 0.008277893, -0.041625977, 0.08905029, 0.03845215, 0.087524414, 0.017501831, -0.01637268, 0.03375244, -0.047027588, -0.007888794, -0.009674072, 0.027633667, -0.037231445, 0.0057640076, -0.013381958, -0.009918213, 0.020202637, -0.008071899, 0.011299133, 0.053741455, -0.0046463013, -0.009429932, 0.011238098, -0.023803711, 0.0107040405, 0.021835327, 0.04748535, -0.008056641, -0.05078125, -0.017074585, 0.031204224, -0.007835388, 0.041931152, -0.007118225, -0.014709473, -0.00072813034, 0.012565613, 0.020614624, 0.03149414, 0.010002136, 0.016845703, -0.0357666, 0.007106781, 0.02494812, -0.008964539, 0.013175964, 0.0101623535, 0.036468506, 0.016311646, 0.07159424, 0.026794434, 0.013053894, 0.028900146, -0.04901123, -0.011528015, 0.050628662, 0.022750854, -0.0088272095, -0.02281189, -0.033233643, -0.040618896, 0.01626587, 0.041137695, 0.019348145, 0.01864624, 0.0048599243, -0.049224854, 0.0061149597, -0.012519836, -0.0070648193, -0.052093506, 0.023864746, 0.033050537, -0.04248047, -0.021438599, 0.029464722, 0.022384644, -0.07336426, 0.01676941, -0.020751953, -0.036834717, 0.0051498413, 0.013977051, 0.05319214, -0.0082092285, -0.023742676, 0.022338867, -0.000031471252, 0.075683594, -0.03213501, -0.04849243, -0.0063552856, 0.008560181, 0.019485474, -0.03945923, -0.029342651, 0.0041007996, 0.022583008, -0.045928955, 0.013839722, 0.012168884, -0.013839722, 0.002822876, 0.057159424, -0.008087158, -0.011016846, 0.039855957, -0.025878906, -0.028244019, -0.019180298, 0.008178711, -0.011413574, -0.005355835, -0.016189575, 0.010719299, 0.021774292, 0.009483337, -0.0007510185, -0.0052871704, 0.02142334, 0.026947021, 0.0046577454, -0.033599854, 0.005142212, 0.019561768, 0.06304932, -0.011482239, -0.052001953, 0.012481689, -0.024917603, 0.016571045, -0.05227661, -0.013633728, -0.022033691, 0.042877197, -0.02696228, -0.0041007996, -0.00043916702, 0.03567505, 0.02104187, 0.04751587, 0.027679443, -0.032470703, 0.02507019, -0.011222839, -0.019744873, 0.0016946793, 0.005332947, -0.002817154, 0.0026855469, -0.0052108765, 0.006591797, -0.029525757, -0.007888794, -0.031677246, 0.027160645, -0.015625, -0.017166138, 0.00038194656, 0.01902771, -0.01751709, 0.005886078, -0.04220581, 0.008407593, 0.031707764, -0.009284973, 0.023956299, -0.060150146, 0.06732178, 0.049316406, 0.006942749, -0.044677734, 0.0029354095, -0.029083252, 0.04763794, -0.09112549, -0.031433105, -0.09564209, 0.009483337, -0.04107666, -0.026809692, 0.026168823, -0.0067825317, -0.019882202, -0.0000308156, -0.0071640015, 0.027114868, -0.026992798, 0.020721436, -0.005001068, -0.006965637, 0.039520264, -0.0040626526, 0.027496338 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07032v1
ExpNote: Black-box Large Language Models are Better Task Solvers with Experience Notebook
Wangtao Sun, Xuanqing Yu, Shizhu He, Jun Zhao, Kang Liu
cs.CL, cs.AI
Black-box Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown great power in solving various tasks and are considered general problem solvers. However, LLMs still fail in many specific tasks although understand the task instruction. In this paper, we focus on the problem of boosting the ability of black-box LLMs to solve downstream tasks. We propose ExpNote, an automated framework to help LLMs better adapt to unfamiliar tasks through reflecting and noting experiences from training data and retrieving them from external memory during testing. We evaluate ExpNote on multiple tasks and the experimental results demonstrate that the proposed method significantly improves the performance of black-box LLMs. The data and code are available at https://github.com/forangel2014/ExpNote
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07032v1
2023-11-13T02:31:16
2023-11-13T02:31:16
{ "title": [ -0.007896423, -0.035003662, -0.01701355, -0.02670288, -0.04800415, -0.015930176, -0.03488159, -0.0069503784, -0.0012149811, 0.032409668, -0.026885986, 0.001499176, 0.003753662, -0.028686523, -0.0031204224, -0.028442383, 0.0027370453, 0.03289795, -0.019927979, -0.022842407, -0.03050232, -0.02142334, -0.009567261, 0.012779236, 0.04550171, -0.0059280396, -0.06896973, 0.0033130646, -0.0066947937, -0.03274536, 0.018692017, 0.017227173, -0.013664246, 0.03665161, 0.0060577393, 0.008071899, -0.033355713, 0.047973633, 0.035888672, -0.007041931, -0.0037879944, 0.004673004, 0.019622803, -0.009490967, 0.00806427, 0.009239197, -0.03930664, -0.052581787, -0.004524231, 0.030181885, -0.002538681, 0.031463623, 0.011787415, 0.047943115, -0.0015192032, -0.008468628, -0.033599854, 0.01687622, 0.025253296, 0.00749588, -0.009735107, -0.02659607, 0.036834717, -0.025604248, 0.0011930466, -0.010017395, -0.029464722, 0.0107803345, 0.07165527, 0.03390503, -0.0184021, -0.0024375916, -0.011688232, 0.0019359589, -0.034576416, 0.0014352798, 0.030700684, 0.014228821, 0.009132385, 0.009857178, -0.026855469, -0.02822876, 0.026824951, -0.04425049, -0.0044441223, -0.044921875, -0.012214661, 0.018127441, -0.00069475174, -0.033203125, -0.0037136078, -0.017486572, -0.055847168, 0.042633057, 0.019073486, -0.06506348, 0.013282776, 0.027053833, -0.030944824, -0.048828125, -0.042816162, -0.0019664764, -0.06591797, -0.008659363, 0.025527954, 0.027023315, -0.008117676, -0.019165039, 0.024139404, 0.0132369995, -0.032409668, 0.04397583, 0.038238525, -0.020965576, 0.032928467, -0.020858765, -0.02848816, 0.09222412, 0.021499634, 0.05886841, 0.000647068, -0.0014266968, 0.016448975, 0.026306152, 0.00086069107, 0.0047416687, -0.012550354, 0.011245728, 0.025421143, 0.03289795, -0.029968262, 0.05947876, -0.07885742, -0.10748291, -0.07946777, -0.006149292, -0.015975952, 0.012611389, -0.01626587, 0.012077332, 0.010375977, -0.023651123, 0.03237915, 0.012191772, -0.0178833, 0.030456543, 0.040618896, -0.008163452, -0.0231781, -0.054473877, -0.019348145, 0.0020561218, -0.014503479, -0.0051078796, -0.012664795, -0.020965576, -0.11352539, 0.021011353, 0.05960083, 0.034942627, 0.054107666, 0.0132751465, -0.026367188, -0.009361267, -0.008155823, -0.05545044, -0.023880005, 0.013534546, 0.0026931763, 0.035614014, -0.030883789, 0.005771637, -0.008895874, -0.0049476624, 0.006477356, 0.022705078, -0.05618286, 0.03982544, 0.030166626, -0.059753418, 0.019363403, -0.020385742, -0.0050239563, 0.0569458, -0.031341553, -0.03439331, -0.015045166, -0.009315491, 0.083862305, -0.012557983, 0.011909485, -0.03515625, 0.011779785, -0.016571045, -0.0006079674, -0.027954102, 0.019256592, 0.009284973, 0.010543823, -0.009254456, -0.015319824, 0.008308411, -0.058135986, 0.009338379, -0.04248047, -0.06427002, 0.019302368, -0.0003979206, 0.031143188, 0.051574707, 0.014564514, 0.048858643, -0.03665161, -0.026412964, -0.031799316, -0.036346436, -0.0116119385, -0.017807007, 0.0032920837, -0.03265381, 0.031402588, 0.0181427, 0.015327454, 0.039978027, 0.015457153, 0.010002136, 0.0051345825, 0.008918762, 0.028961182, 0.03866577, 0.01953125, -0.038024902, 0.05441284, 0.046325684, -0.020263672, -0.009590149, 0.038360596, -0.01222229, 0.027435303, 0.02357483, 0.027160645, -0.017486572, 0.015823364, 0.00995636, 0.021316528, -0.042999268, 0.019561768, -0.0155181885, 0.013938904, 0.035339355, 0.014572144, 0.028457642, 0.020019531, 0.039123535, 0.007724762, 0.036254883, -0.021606445, 0.006134033, -0.01675415, 0.018661499, 0.008110046, 0.032684326, 0.022994995, 0.0021820068, -0.03164673, 0.004600525, -0.019363403, 0.01335907, -0.0036239624, -0.0062065125, 0.0037288666, -0.030776978, 0.0018730164, -0.0055160522, 0.0023002625, -0.006362915, -0.024154663, 0.024902344, -0.01550293, -0.039733887, 0.024307251, 0.053253174, 0.052764893, -0.005367279, 0.018295288, 0.025436401, 0.01486969, -0.0036773682, -0.064941406, 0.002910614, 0.019897461, 0.040100098, -0.027862549, 0.019210815, 0.044067383, 0.012840271, 0.11517334, 0.06921387, -0.01977539, 0.030593872, -0.020111084, 0.0105896, 0.012718201, -0.006374359, 0.02798462, 0.0047416687, 0.05493164, -0.033477783, -0.016586304, 0.013259888, -0.076416016, -0.022781372, 0.0058021545, 0.041168213, -0.05697632, -0.04650879, -0.022720337, 0.0028686523, -0.049743652, -0.05947876, 0.06854248, -0.013183594, -0.009384155, 0.0026931763, -0.018798828, -0.042144775, 0.013069153, -0.021774292, 0.014053345, -0.040924072, 0.017074585, -0.04827881, -0.059814453, -0.039398193, 0.027801514, 0.00655365, 0.0016889572, -0.0073051453, -0.028518677, -0.004058838, -0.025894165, -0.07891846, -0.013175964, -0.028961182, 0.022964478, -0.068237305, -0.010902405, -0.01449585, -0.020095825, 0.019165039, 0.019577026, 0.023117065, 0.01235199, 0.017410278, 0.042419434, -0.028518677, -0.01576233, 0.043670654, 0.004146576, -0.015220642, 0.04449463, 0.044952393, 0.023269653, -0.03048706, -0.005947113, -0.0670166, 0.010032654, -0.032165527, -0.006389618, 0.0143585205, -0.020568848, 0.00017404556, -0.004547119, -0.015403748, -0.03692627, -0.0057029724, 0.048980713, -0.019607544, -0.04232788, 0.009880066, -0.029541016, -0.0005636215, 0.00982666, 0.023498535, 0.0541687, 0.0028495789, -0.0033283234, 0.014862061, 0.025024414, -0.015151978, 0.008033752, -0.001414299, -0.07110596, 0.0012769699, 0.01474762, 0.017913818, -0.012390137, -0.02394104, -0.06842041, -0.006866455, 0.06506348, -0.013885498, 0.017547607, 0.0058288574, -0.06896973, 0.06439209, -0.018859863, 0.0284729, 0.049957275, 0.021942139, 0.032562256, -0.014968872, 0.05996704, -0.057556152, -0.0060577393, -0.0003578663, -0.07348633, 0.011299133, -0.020736694, 0.03250122, -0.0069618225, 0.034606934, -0.045684814, -0.004043579, 0.01209259, 0.03277588, 0.045166016, -0.016448975, 0.040802002, -0.00034809113, 0.03286743, -0.021499634, -0.020706177, -0.03463745, -0.029006958, 0.019836426, 0.026687622, 0.028381348, 0.05871582, -0.011352539, -0.0045814514, -0.015205383, -0.03010559, 0.031280518, -0.004180908, -0.025222778, -0.027801514, -0.027236938, -0.0057258606, 0.03149414, -0.01109314, 0.017227173, -0.021072388, 0.00945282, -0.037139893, 0.018936157, 0.010757446, 0.05267334, -0.008575439, -0.04449463, -0.00497818, -0.030593872, -0.049987793, 0.0021686554, 0.015434265, -0.0043296814, 0.025970459, 0.016845703, -0.011390686, 0.0006670952, 0.006126404, -0.01576233, 0.024642944, 0.010307312, -0.039855957, -0.034820557, 0.028244019, 0.022003174, -0.009552002, -0.03665161, -0.019042969, 0.025604248, 0.0075950623, -0.020492554, -0.03189087, 0.032592773, -0.05441284, -0.045959473, 0.004360199, 0.016464233, -0.02168274, -0.009605408, 0.028701782, -0.024719238, -0.023086548, 0.013748169, -0.004096985, 0.026443481, 0.010894775, -0.055755615, -0.01373291, 0.0055274963, 0.0016613007, 0.020370483, 0.022262573, 0.0049438477, -0.051361084, 0.008392334, 0.004535675, 0.007911682, 0.007091522, -0.0006041527, -0.023803711, -0.02557373, -0.016296387, 0.004283905, 0.00497818, -0.06121826, 0.014465332, 0.035217285, 0.01626587, 0.043151855, -0.033233643, 0.02885437, -0.005256653, 0.031707764, -0.08880615, 0.02671814, -0.011169434, -0.033935547, -0.006801605, 0.023361206, 0.0037117004, 0.032348633, 0.020385742, -0.0038013458, -0.009025574, -0.009712219, 0.01259613, -0.006374359, -0.011795044, -0.025985718, -0.034606934, 0.008018494, -0.016555786, 0.042541504, 0.018554688, 0.083740234, -0.022598267, 0.017852783, -0.008514404, 0.011314392, -0.052520752, -0.024154663, -0.031799316, -0.051239014, -0.022781372, 0.030776978, -0.0050697327, 0.00032043457, 0.018203735, 0.040100098, -0.0129776, -0.039001465, 0.017150879, 0.039093018, -0.048461914, -0.06640625, 0.040130615, -0.062927246, -0.07183838, -0.08459473, 0.014640808, 0.033843994, 0.0007286072, 0.015350342, -0.043884277, 0.023590088, 0.023666382, 0.07757568, -0.0026607513, -0.0069007874, -0.05065918, 0.009887695, -0.037139893, -0.000012516975, -0.013504028, -0.012908936, -0.029525757, 0.001493454, 0.052093506, -0.0039787292, -0.023727417, -0.060058594, 0.033569336, 0.024246216, 0.042510986, -0.0045318604, -0.038726807, 0.014083862, 0.003873825, -0.0018777847, 0.0023345947, -0.018249512, -0.01121521, 0.014923096, 0.007736206, 0.029037476, 0.008979797, 0.05218506, 0.024353027, -0.016189575, 0.025772095, -0.016906738, 0.041412354, -0.016464233, 0.029006958, 0.038909912, 0.0029201508, -0.020004272, -0.01171875, 0.011993408, 0.015838623, -0.081604004, 0.007080078, -0.015068054, -0.014442444, -0.001291275, -0.033081055, 0.0074424744, -0.002067566, 0.0035076141, -0.020248413, -0.009391785, 0.03692627, 0.010314941, -0.010765076, 0.00730896, -0.01486969, 0.009979248, 0.017059326, 0.019195557, 0.04171753, -0.050628662, -0.009407043, -0.03060913, -0.028060913, 0.015350342, -0.037994385, -0.04751587, -0.024276733, 0.0049705505, -0.04006958, 0.047790527, 0.012031555, -0.023864746, -0.034423828, -0.014808655, 0.027252197, -0.033721924, -0.03164673, 0.037139893, -0.0062026978, 0.030532837, 0.06427002, -0.005054474, 0.01977539, 0.03314209, 0.0088272095, 0.004272461, -0.00566864, -0.041503906, 0.008422852, -0.0028133392, 0.008605957, 0.0010213852, 0.021362305, 0.010635376, 0.018051147, -0.03918457, -0.008636475, 0.012329102, 0.06390381, 0.024627686, -0.054260254, 0.04864502, -0.012939453, -0.053527832, 0.026046753, -0.050994873, -0.026016235, 0.021820068, -0.009841919, -0.012229919, 0.008575439, 0.010574341, -0.010627747, -0.016967773, 0.007221222, -0.009941101, 0.03479004, 0.0011320114, -0.011474609, -0.022140503, 0.010124207, -0.014884949, -0.04647827, 0.038726807, -0.000623703, 0.009544373, 0.020065308, 0.031433105, -0.05505371, -0.025436401, 0.0046691895, -0.02822876, -0.033996582, -0.0005245209, -0.012794495, 0.018112183, 0.0101623535, -0.0022525787, -0.014404297, -0.037384033, 0.02458191, -0.048675537, -0.010864258, 0.022979736, -0.014884949, 0.035614014, 0.049041748, 0.02923584, 0.048858643, 0.0016298294, -0.0004684925, -0.05239868, 0.035217285, -0.0067367554, 0.022659302, -0.059936523, -0.08947754, 0.0054740906, 0.027282715, 0.01638794, 0.017669678, 0.048309326, 0.03036499, 0.017654419, 0.015777588, 0.036010742, 0.06695557, -0.04751587, -0.046661377, 0.012077332, -0.0032234192, 0.0025405884, 0.05682373, 0.025100708, -0.031204224, -0.016189575, -0.02809143, -0.00063467026, -0.0028438568, 0.015670776, 0.0024204254, 0.03010559, -0.037353516, -0.018035889, -0.027709961, 0.0034828186, -0.0016069412, -0.008903503, -0.04888916, -0.08673096, 0.0625, 0.051879883, 0.0079193115, -0.023117065, 0.026641846, 0.031707764, -0.006641388, 0.018615723, -0.026168823, -0.022003174, -0.029464722, -0.017501831, 0.035186768, 0.027908325, -0.03503418, 0.036987305, 0.004085541, 0.046203613, 0.027053833, 0.0309906, 0.040618896, 0.029251099, 0.016937256, 0.015052795, 0.017288208, -0.013587952, 0.05923462, -0.04598999, 0.049346924, -0.01007843, -0.0066070557, -0.07745361, 0.021652222, 0.0413208, 0.060638428, 0.0061149597, 0.018615723, 0.007003784, -0.0335083, -0.00047898293, 0.0034618378, 0.078125, -0.004776001, -0.0022850037, 0.012130737, -0.038879395, 0.0047950745, 0.031463623, -0.014762878, 0.028396606, -0.016296387, 0.038879395, 0.030654907, -0.03805542, -0.015419006, -0.012634277, 0.04168701, -0.0035800934, -0.058410645, -0.042388916, -0.011741638, 0.058013916, -0.012908936, -0.011772156, 0.017044067, 0.0076789856, 0.0016527176, -0.016281128, 0.014137268, 0.05831909, -0.09460449, 0.02746582, -0.0019226074, -0.041412354, -0.06744385, 0.053741455, 0.008605957, 0.021896362, 0.018356323, 0.033081055, 0.0032176971, 0.038757324, -0.056793213, -0.044830322, 0.01713562, 0.07446289, -0.008872986, -0.004737854, -0.027664185, 0.001748085, 0.009490967, -0.005718231, -0.033966064, 0.0084991455, -0.018554688, 0.023620605, 0.028457642, 0.0035037994, 0.07672119, 0.011871338, -0.035949707, 0.044708252, 0.019760132, -0.04043579, 0.007507324, -0.0019989014, 0.0463562, 0.02798462, 0.08105469, 0.032440186, 0.00072431564, -0.011444092, 0.0019702911, 0.0073432922, 0.03967285, -0.009269714, 0.043762207, -0.0340271, -0.044769287, 0.04663086, -0.05923462, 0.056152344, -0.026321411, -0.0143585205, -0.042419434, 0.04736328, 0.001791954, -0.018798828, -0.08093262, -0.007873535, -0.0009460449, 0.0057029724, -0.014076233, -0.039855957, -0.021118164, 0.005443573, 0.055389404, 0.02722168, 0.006580353, 0.05731201, -0.03591919, -0.03564453, -0.00021541119, 0.007926941, 0.037841797, 0.008995056, 0.0024032593, -0.02935791, 0.021759033, 0.018936157, -0.02432251, -0.019241333, 0.028625488, -0.030075073, -0.032714844, -0.029800415, -0.058898926, -0.05206299, -0.064208984, -0.0062828064, 0.0050582886, -0.029891968, -0.009277344, 0.030212402, -0.019851685, -0.013336182, -0.0024490356, -0.026153564, 0.033081055, -0.002494812, 0.0030612946, -0.0101623535, 0.033843994, -0.0154953, -0.010025024, 0.013648987, 0.02909851, -0.015510559, -0.028747559, -0.025344849, 0.030136108, 0.06768799, -0.013633728, -0.051239014, 0.023513794, 0.008163452, 0.00070667267, -0.003025055, 0.00920105, 0.03640747, 0.015365601, 0.033599854, 0.0007596016, -0.06561279, 0.006336212, 0.033294678, 0.030578613, 0.03010559, -0.029678345, 0.036834717, 0.013786316, -0.042266846, 0.0052223206, 0.032165527, -0.013717651, 0.012634277, 0.00047969818, 0.039611816, -0.02229309, -0.019897461, -0.053100586, 0.042877197, -0.0154418945, 0.01789856, 0.0010671616, 0.060577393, 0.0039978027, 0.040771484, -0.010375977, -0.011566162, 0.044281006, 0.038024902, 0.008384705, -0.00957489, 0.032348633, 0.0143966675, 0.01991272, 0.026016235, -0.017501831, 0.03643799, 0.00097084045, 0.0060691833, -0.014945984, -0.026916504, -0.039093018, -0.012969971, -0.020599365, 0.011268616, -0.04714966, 0.03643799, 0.008529663, -0.008918762, 0.019042969, 0.028076172, -0.019714355, 0.004043579, -0.032165527, -0.010818481, -0.009483337, -0.01436615 ], "summary": [ -0.042297363, -0.06262207, -0.017303467, -0.016784668, -0.07489014, 0.0008330345, -0.06744385, 0.0107040405, 0.032440186, 0.021255493, -0.060333252, 0.005809784, -0.018096924, 0.0044403076, -0.0010290146, -0.039886475, -0.00868988, 0.034088135, -0.017456055, -0.026870728, 0.00484848, -0.03933716, -0.024520874, 0.015357971, 0.037750244, -0.0061569214, 0.0044403076, -0.0037498474, 0.037017822, 0.023529053, 0.01828003, -0.05303955, 0.0044059753, 0.04095459, -0.026565552, 0.013931274, -0.039855957, 0.037628174, 0.02104187, 0.0020484924, 0.014282227, -0.0043258667, 0.056488037, 0.022018433, 0.0104599, 0.045532227, -0.038269043, -0.07019043, 0.014831543, 0.023666382, 0.0056877136, 0.014419556, 0.0067253113, -0.029449463, -0.019607544, -0.01889038, -0.05810547, 0.016357422, -0.0063705444, 0.07421875, 0.029342651, 0.0031051636, -0.015235901, -0.027557373, 0.0037212372, -0.0017757416, -0.0395813, -0.0060157776, 0.066589355, 0.017990112, -0.012306213, 0.008110046, 0.009414673, -0.039489746, 0.04547119, 0.004371643, 0.030456543, 0.023147583, -0.018554688, 0.029190063, 0.02935791, 0.02659607, 0.019744873, -0.03527832, 0.018722534, -0.02772522, -0.00028157234, -0.009986877, -0.0076141357, -0.031707764, -0.0021266937, 0.006626129, -0.058502197, 0.0099105835, 0.023223877, -0.059692383, -0.044799805, -0.029815674, -0.021133423, -0.020553589, 0.017028809, -0.02053833, 0.0015602112, -0.009178162, 0.007575989, 0.04525757, 0.0026931763, -0.062072754, -0.007858276, -0.0009417534, -0.03189087, -0.01914978, 0.035308838, -0.0463562, 0.020629883, 0.014862061, 0.0046424866, 0.08734131, 0.023849487, 0.059143066, -0.008163452, 0.0035419464, -0.0032787323, 0.020812988, -0.013542175, -0.006839752, -0.015808105, 0.016540527, 0.061340332, 0.0044174194, -0.017303467, 0.03515625, -0.07183838, -0.062408447, -0.057739258, -0.0016727448, -0.025970459, 0.025863647, -0.0026626587, 0.015335083, -0.005332947, -0.046447754, 0.008308411, 0.02609253, -0.0084991455, 0.049194336, 0.027191162, -0.025054932, -0.006378174, -0.037872314, -0.017822266, -0.02949524, 0.020019531, -0.04559326, -0.028259277, -0.068847656, -0.079711914, -0.004005432, 0.037261963, -0.0059928894, 0.03567505, 0.018127441, 0.0031394958, 0.004776001, -0.012008667, -0.058654785, -0.011489868, -0.0028629303, 0.005531311, -0.0031814575, -0.012298584, 0.008285522, -0.003730774, -0.0059280396, 0.00217247, 0.014450073, -0.025039673, 0.109680176, 0.012763977, -0.07727051, 0.008018494, -0.04714966, 0.082458496, 0.015365601, -0.0135269165, -0.03579712, -0.0038070679, 0.014373779, 0.05847168, 0.00623703, -0.01007843, -0.05328369, 0.0044517517, -0.009849548, 0.0017652512, -0.030075073, 0.0045776367, -0.0045051575, -0.00843811, -0.007827759, 0.0077438354, -0.0077552795, -0.012779236, -0.04119873, -0.032165527, -0.04815674, 0.011146545, 0.018371582, 0.029632568, 0.023376465, 0.039764404, 0.05718994, -0.07183838, 0.007904053, -0.055236816, -0.035858154, -0.008483887, -0.0031986237, 0.001001358, -0.04876709, 0.020248413, 0.0068740845, 0.013969421, 0.057739258, -0.027420044, -0.014625549, -0.0044670105, 0.018676758, 0.0038146973, 0.020736694, 0.03277588, -0.02520752, 0.01222229, 0.023208618, -0.009117126, -0.022399902, 0.024978638, -0.0496521, 0.03942871, 0.03527832, 0.013542175, 0.020614624, -0.024673462, 0.001039505, 0.035064697, 0.003856659, 0.020690918, -0.012413025, -0.012718201, -0.0032367706, 0.002483368, 0.008560181, 0.02935791, -0.035491943, -0.008529663, 0.039916992, -0.02355957, -0.02078247, -0.016479492, 0.006652832, 0.006877899, -0.053741455, -0.010223389, -0.02545166, -0.035247803, -0.041107178, -0.017868042, -0.023132324, 0.030212402, -0.036376953, 0.003129959, -0.05871582, 0.0052871704, -0.03894043, -0.006576538, 0.022949219, -0.014587402, 0.025939941, 0.0149002075, -0.029846191, 0.01676941, 0.025512695, 0.015312195, -0.013092041, 0.025054932, -0.019607544, 0.0012569427, 0.010322571, -0.019302368, 0.02810669, 0.036956787, 0.030532837, 0.009796143, -0.017089844, 0.017089844, 0.0039100647, 0.09710693, 0.034576416, 0.0014133453, 0.0053520203, 0.017303467, 0.027679443, -0.014450073, -0.02268982, 0.0052452087, 0.010475159, -0.009750366, 0.007801056, -0.010627747, 0.0029201508, -0.04660034, 0.0018005371, -0.0031394958, 0.06286621, -0.068481445, -0.0519104, -0.022476196, -0.0014867783, -0.056488037, -0.008865356, 0.13122559, -0.0056991577, -0.0014019012, 0.05606079, -0.01914978, -0.07342529, 0.10168457, -0.041137695, 0.03414917, -0.04248047, -0.018692017, -0.06274414, -0.04083252, -0.008781433, 0.014793396, -0.011680603, -0.0047912598, 0.0065460205, -0.028671265, -0.0107421875, -0.016220093, -0.06536865, -0.0051651, -0.01852417, 0.012504578, -0.038269043, 0.013587952, -0.0015821457, 0.0061683655, 0.005531311, -0.002626419, -0.016921997, -0.009353638, 0.048583984, 0.01727295, -0.016586304, 0.0231781, 0.014190674, -0.03050232, -0.037597656, 0.015319824, 0.041625977, 0.004257202, -0.028030396, -0.021774292, -0.023971558, 0.033447266, -0.019683838, 0.033233643, 0.043182373, -0.008369446, 0.051452637, -0.058441162, -0.02267456, -0.016082764, -0.021835327, 0.09429932, 0.0053367615, -0.025878906, 0.041931152, 0.026489258, 0.05117798, -0.04623413, 0.019439697, 0.061828613, 0.013534546, -0.016647339, 0.027069092, 0.025817871, 0.009597778, 0.017593384, 0.011375427, -0.07928467, -0.01134491, 0.017318726, 0.019973755, 0.0023097992, 0.0020580292, -0.042419434, -0.024017334, 0.076416016, -0.020324707, 0.012962341, -0.004711151, -0.037200928, 0.061523438, 0.0181427, 0.02279663, 0.059295654, -0.042633057, 0.054504395, -0.04827881, 0.060913086, -0.08862305, -0.014961243, -0.017486572, -0.053375244, -0.0046424866, 0.0016012192, 0.045898438, 0.0012636185, 0.027252197, -0.039764404, 0.012893677, 0.025985718, 0.040283203, 0.03161621, -0.010726929, 0.052734375, -0.011375427, 0.034729004, -0.022033691, -0.019638062, 0.008087158, -0.043182373, 0.06756592, 0.042755127, 0.021118164, 0.08807373, -0.061706543, 0.026367188, 0.010253906, -0.07269287, 0.019134521, -0.015274048, -0.03994751, -0.0065994263, -0.022384644, -0.026489258, 0.041107178, -0.019485474, 0.017440796, -0.014907837, 0.023513794, -0.032073975, 0.03668213, -0.03213501, 0.03451538, 0.014701843, -0.0970459, -0.02104187, -0.03375244, -0.060394287, -0.02079773, 0.03488159, 0.038360596, -0.032989502, 0.03778076, -0.004306793, -0.010360718, 0.057128906, -0.046173096, 0.0128479, -0.008026123, -0.032318115, -0.051879883, 0.059051514, 0.0063705444, 0.040161133, -0.05606079, -0.07336426, 0.049591064, -0.029022217, -0.055877686, -0.03265381, 0.0119018555, -0.031021118, -0.054016113, 0.0067634583, 0.022750854, 0.006286621, -0.017852783, 0.008659363, 0.032318115, -0.012367249, -0.00605011, -0.030288696, 0.060638428, 0.007171631, -0.062683105, 0.0524292, -0.025314331, 0.017974854, 0.052734375, -0.00048422813, -0.008659363, -0.04067993, -0.0032634735, 0.007965088, -0.02470398, 0.0138168335, -0.008033752, -0.023971558, -0.037475586, 0.0040626526, 0.007911682, 0.0141067505, -0.048614502, 0.031280518, 0.01083374, 0.03314209, 0.021118164, -0.0138168335, 0.02255249, -0.012550354, 0.054016113, -0.055877686, 0.028961182, 0.00005120039, 0.027389526, 0.014785767, 0.012466431, 0.010467529, -0.009063721, 0.015289307, -0.036071777, -0.022445679, -0.015533447, 0.047973633, 0.023635864, -0.008995056, -0.014923096, -0.006664276, 0.044281006, -0.0015382767, 0.018234253, 0.0006842613, 0.025894165, -0.05105591, -0.0010967255, -0.014511108, 0.008552551, -0.013954163, -0.028640747, -0.019134521, -0.039978027, -0.005191803, 0.014732361, -0.002494812, 0.008583069, 0.016677856, 0.01914978, -0.020126343, -0.013656616, 0.034240723, 0.023544312, -0.031951904, -0.066467285, 0.00012671947, -0.016418457, -0.030853271, -0.03024292, 0.02381897, 0.011550903, -0.012397766, -0.018447876, -0.032318115, 0.015701294, 0.0037899017, 0.055908203, 0.007221222, -0.0060043335, -0.051086426, -0.013496399, -0.02532959, 0.0395813, -0.051727295, 0.011299133, -0.029968262, 0.033325195, 0.031433105, -0.018478394, -0.017242432, -0.06933594, -0.0013513565, 0.019973755, -0.02319336, 0.031402588, 0.010917664, 0.014823914, 0.00844574, 0.0037899017, 0.0064735413, 0.0054397583, -0.020965576, 0.0049324036, -0.0075798035, 0.023010254, -0.039611816, 0.060333252, 0.011734009, -0.014755249, 0.050842285, -0.043884277, 0.058410645, 0.017440796, -0.001742363, 0.008453369, 0.014472961, 0.015655518, 0.011726379, 0.0069618225, 0.026229858, -0.018096924, -0.02015686, -0.0063095093, 0.0045928955, 0.008781433, -0.022262573, 0.023925781, 0.025436401, 0.007965088, -0.0345459, -0.015350342, 0.0003194809, 0.004169464, -0.0078086853, -0.009216309, -0.0030937195, -0.028625488, -0.012207031, -0.0035190582, 0.009025574, -0.0068206787, 0.032440186, -0.041870117, -0.020889282, 0.035247803, -0.021530151, -0.017364502, -0.018081665, 0.011199951, -0.02748108, 0.024765015, 0.040985107, -0.024658203, 0.0040740967, -0.016921997, 0.0033130646, -0.07757568, -0.06237793, -0.037322998, -0.008460999, -0.013870239, 0.103027344, -0.014122009, 0.007347107, 0.046417236, -0.007144928, 0.036132812, -0.0071258545, -0.035614014, -0.03289795, -0.0079956055, 0.0005469322, 0.011886597, 0.025024414, 0.025650024, -0.009468079, -0.008674622, -0.016326904, -0.013656616, 0.050567627, 0.016189575, -0.038238525, 0.02079773, -0.006965637, -0.023254395, -0.010917664, 0.02281189, -0.024230957, -0.0020961761, 0.006340027, 0.0009551048, 0.007663727, -0.009887695, -0.00036668777, 0.009239197, -0.012306213, -0.023361206, 0.03656006, 0.022384644, -0.012756348, 0.009750366, -0.005874634, -0.015213013, -0.017303467, 0.008880615, -0.032806396, -0.0031852722, -0.032348633, 0.051116943, -0.054901123, -0.01083374, -0.03326416, -0.030914307, -0.070007324, -0.036743164, -0.01625061, 0.049041748, -0.0018377304, 0.00048971176, -0.00774765, -0.016494751, 0.023040771, -0.0473938, -0.024673462, 0.013442993, -0.0031833649, 0.0028438568, 0.019805908, 0.028656006, 0.015411377, -0.0018568039, -0.0004799366, -0.014152527, 0.045043945, -0.021255493, 0.018722534, -0.04425049, -0.041381836, 0.00819397, 0.028549194, 0.01374054, 0.003786087, 0.032989502, 0.014671326, 0.010818481, 0.028030396, 0.0060806274, 0.044403076, -0.018112183, -0.053344727, 0.035705566, 0.016738892, 0.022201538, 0.041259766, 0.005027771, -0.045684814, -0.011138916, -0.0039711, 0.020721436, 0.017242432, 0.015007019, 0.017425537, 0.05328369, 0.001452446, 0.015472412, 0.014221191, -0.035705566, -0.016601562, -0.009666443, -0.030456543, -0.101379395, 0.10723877, 0.018447876, 0.014411926, -0.013954163, -0.012275696, -0.0098724365, 0.011360168, -0.005836487, 0.003917694, 0.009918213, -0.0053253174, 0.003982544, 0.038360596, 0.011024475, -0.031341553, 0.02168274, 0.017868042, 0.030700684, 0.018234253, 0.011695862, 0.0069236755, -0.013870239, 0.0024433136, 0.002796173, 0.005504608, -0.027145386, 0.046844482, -0.02116394, -0.014945984, -0.055633545, -0.03756714, -0.04849243, 0.052886963, -0.01852417, 0.009307861, 0.016036987, 0.01512146, -0.010818481, -0.01789856, -0.028366089, 0.021759033, 0.026351929, 0.002632141, -0.0068206787, 0.03363037, -0.019241333, -0.012496948, 0.0345459, -0.03338623, 0.050933838, -0.010513306, 0.025924683, 0.045410156, -0.05114746, -0.027404785, -0.035369873, 0.030914307, -0.025634766, -0.02456665, 0.0015249252, 0.029174805, 0.020111084, -0.027175903, 0.030731201, 0.0017156601, -0.00881958, 0.0007634163, -0.008483887, 0.038635254, 0.009651184, -0.02947998, 0.026992798, 0.019332886, -0.033325195, 0.011604309, 0.05758667, 0.0088272095, 0.0035133362, 0.024673462, -0.021484375, 0.0053977966, 0.017501831, -0.01838684, -0.021270752, 0.020111084, 0.051757812, 0.00041389465, 0.01499939, -0.0029277802, 0.0006799698, 0.0046691895, 0.007598877, -0.013053894, -0.005092621, -0.0149002075, -0.003627777, 0.028411865, 0.013473511, 0.032684326, 0.028244019, -0.012390137, 0.0025367737, 0.052520752, -0.038238525, 0.0051879883, 0.025894165, 0.058746338, 0.06890869, 0.09033203, -0.013114929, 0.01537323, 0.05545044, -0.028640747, 0.026824951, -0.028579712, 0.0016050339, -0.014266968, -0.019134521, 0.0042648315, 0.0035247803, -0.0079193115, 0.03062439, -0.06378174, 0.017303467, -0.032165527, 0.049072266, -0.060913086, -0.011390686, -0.037475586, -0.004211426, 0.023071289, 0.016052246, 0.029312134, -0.032409668, -0.017044067, 0.009963989, 0.02935791, 0.009666443, 0.008514404, 0.055389404, -0.02746582, -0.025054932, -0.017089844, 0.030639648, 0.03878784, 0.009254456, -0.026382446, 0.012680054, 0.0049552917, 0.024765015, -0.048797607, -0.046905518, 0.017684937, 0.034698486, -0.01626587, -0.04336548, -0.04748535, -0.04660034, -0.07324219, -0.039031982, 0.023803711, -0.047088623, 0.006298065, 0.020126343, -0.025009155, -0.006099701, -0.0066947937, 0.017868042, 0.034301758, 0.012863159, 0.004558563, 0.043914795, 0.0345459, -0.022750854, -0.0073127747, -0.01838684, -0.025222778, 0.007736206, -0.032226562, -0.025604248, 0.03353882, 0.06222534, 0.014152527, -0.0579834, 0.045715332, -0.04296875, 0.037353516, -0.03112793, -0.048950195, -0.0119018555, 0.040802002, 0.038970947, 0.026000977, -0.03451538, 0.04272461, 0.021270752, 0.018676758, 0.026229858, -0.02293396, 0.044036865, 0.019226074, -0.050354004, -0.020980835, 0.021820068, 0.0063285828, -0.029266357, 0.008110046, 0.012283325, -0.027832031, -0.045684814, -0.032318115, 0.047088623, -0.017578125, 0.026550293, -0.004940033, 0.027130127, 0.013389587, 0.003627777, -0.059753418, 0.013328552, 0.0178833, 0.00315094, -0.0016269684, -0.018844604, 0.012779236, 0.052703857, 0.0105896, 0.018707275, -0.0101623535, 0.014175415, -0.003271103, 0.021148682, -0.002286911, 0.02532959, -0.013420105, -0.048797607, -0.018325806, 0.014923096, -0.025894165, 0.0058135986, 0.017028809, -0.007347107, 0.021194458, 0.022354126, -0.024871826, 0.013008118, -0.009361267, -0.0115356445, -0.025680542, 0.010673523 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07022v1
ViLMA: A Zero-Shot Benchmark for Linguistic and Temporal Grounding in Video-Language Models
Ilker Kesen, Andrea Pedrotti, Mustafa Dogan, Michele Cafagna, Emre Can Acikgoz, Letitia Parcalabescu, Iacer Calixto, Anette Frank, Albert Gatt, Aykut Erdem, Erkut Erdem
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
With the ever-increasing popularity of pretrained Video-Language Models (VidLMs), there is a pressing need to develop robust evaluation methodologies that delve deeper into their visio-linguistic capabilities. To address this challenge, we present ViLMA (Video Language Model Assessment), a task-agnostic benchmark that places the assessment of fine-grained capabilities of these models on a firm footing. Task-based evaluations, while valuable, fail to capture the complexities and specific temporal aspects of moving images that VidLMs need to process. Through carefully curated counterfactuals, ViLMA offers a controlled evaluation suite that sheds light on the true potential of these models, as well as their performance gaps compared to human-level understanding. ViLMA also includes proficiency tests, which assess basic capabilities deemed essential to solving the main counterfactual tests. We show that current VidLMs' grounding abilities are no better than those of vision-language models which use static images. This is especially striking once the performance on proficiency tests is factored in. Our benchmark serves as a catalyst for future research on VidLMs, helping to highlight areas that still need to be explored.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07022v1
2023-11-13T02:13:13
2023-11-13T02:13:13
{ "title": [ -0.014549255, -0.004825592, -0.043395996, -0.07849121, 0.0018520355, -0.00983429, -0.05517578, 0.009277344, 0.020690918, 0.037231445, -0.008300781, 0.0030174255, 0.009605408, -0.0073013306, -0.062072754, 0.014793396, -0.011581421, 0.05529785, -0.0056114197, -0.036712646, -0.007965088, -0.05807495, 0.04837036, 0.03387451, 0.052001953, -0.07067871, -0.056610107, 0.026382446, -0.017425537, -0.02432251, 0.0154418945, 0.0019273758, 0.033599854, 0.02015686, -0.008628845, -0.003376007, -0.039764404, 0.015655518, -0.0015602112, 0.013679504, 0.0259552, -0.006828308, -0.0073547363, 0.0005412102, -0.044189453, 0.032165527, -0.05255127, -0.013832092, -0.0043258667, 0.05355835, 0.008987427, 0.016860962, -0.018981934, 0.037506104, 0.0070381165, -0.05758667, -0.042785645, 0.0017347336, 0.026443481, 0.07763672, 0.03161621, -0.034820557, 0.0012321472, -0.020690918, -0.038726807, -0.0038108826, -0.027740479, 0.014526367, 0.06842041, 0.018310547, -0.022247314, 0.009033203, 0.0011234283, -0.032409668, -0.02319336, 0.04473877, 0.01499176, 0.002752304, 0.029220581, -0.02281189, 0.022506714, -0.014297485, 0.03793335, -0.033691406, 0.021087646, -0.05734253, -0.005970001, -0.0050849915, -0.04486084, -0.08148193, -0.023330688, -0.021972656, -0.044006348, -0.029190063, -0.018218994, -0.04827881, -0.020935059, 0.041168213, -0.0017137527, -0.02722168, -0.036712646, 0.04055786, -0.06713867, -0.004634857, 0.024261475, -0.0126953125, -0.01864624, -0.023529053, 0.014266968, 0.024795532, -0.04928589, 0.0713501, 0.019073486, -0.0090408325, -0.013710022, 0.0035896301, -0.005329132, -0.0010700226, 0.021835327, 0.01134491, -0.024398804, -0.027359009, 0.030654907, 0.009986877, 0.048706055, 0.01763916, -0.051727295, 0.016799927, -0.0006632805, 0.03414917, 0.009086609, 0.04824829, -0.0703125, -0.10412598, -0.079711914, 0.04220581, 0.00088739395, 0.010559082, -0.040222168, 0.036590576, -0.016983032, -0.02734375, 0.011161804, -0.03387451, -0.0013570786, -0.0035209656, 0.059417725, 0.012779236, -0.044952393, -0.0647583, 0.019836426, 0.0021591187, 0.021102905, -0.0015354156, -0.035125732, -0.016525269, -0.11138916, -0.01423645, 0.026885986, 0.006088257, 0.016220093, 0.0003914833, -0.0016469955, -0.019851685, -0.0070648193, -0.02017212, -0.014434814, -0.006465912, 0.012863159, 0.053741455, -0.043792725, 0.04852295, -0.0013990402, 0.015083313, 0.006580353, -0.0055885315, 0.012794495, -0.023910522, 0.046844482, -0.03161621, -0.013114929, -0.035736084, -0.008399963, 0.03781128, -0.04547119, -0.05279541, -0.007980347, -0.011070251, 0.050048828, 0.010238647, -0.02468872, 0.017028809, -0.047668457, -0.016799927, -0.041625977, -0.022994995, 0.0061416626, 0.019454956, -0.001707077, 0.0029335022, -0.0093307495, -0.014907837, -0.033966064, -0.012763977, -0.038726807, -0.039154053, -0.023406982, 0.014770508, -0.015106201, 0.04083252, 0.053466797, 0.032684326, -0.046844482, 0.019226074, -0.0041656494, -0.03555298, 0.015045166, -0.0023155212, 0.006790161, -0.0076789856, 0.0046806335, -0.005836487, 0.028747559, 0.057678223, 0.0039711, 0.0074653625, 0.008369446, -0.013870239, 0.04949951, 0.013389587, 0.07458496, -0.03265381, 0.033172607, -0.00019085407, -0.020080566, -0.012519836, -0.016555786, -0.01763916, 0.0046806335, 0.015487671, 0.0007414818, -0.005783081, -0.024902344, 0.011482239, 0.053466797, 0.0007214546, 0.009140015, 0.014633179, 0.032318115, 0.0236969, 0.047729492, 0.007789612, 0.053771973, -0.039733887, 0.01763916, 0.047027588, 0.015556335, -0.0077438354, -0.016571045, 0.015899658, 0.018630981, 0.011688232, -0.03010559, 0.006160736, -0.07043457, 0.022598267, -0.026000977, 0.011779785, 0.022445679, 0.0025920868, 0.014778137, -0.011985779, 0.011116028, -0.028137207, 0.018997192, -0.022369385, -0.0076408386, 0.014030457, 0.0039138794, -0.06286621, -0.020599365, 0.019866943, 0.04071045, -0.0019426346, 0.009300232, 0.01687622, 0.02418518, -0.028915405, -0.017929077, -0.018096924, 0.028945923, 0.014137268, -0.013076782, -0.0009303093, 0.005847931, -0.02810669, 0.10534668, 0.06298828, -0.014877319, 0.032287598, -0.04434204, 0.01876831, -0.004398346, -0.015808105, 0.023468018, 0.010429382, 0.03616333, 0.019683838, -0.027236938, 0.017349243, -0.05154419, -0.0026569366, -0.0052223206, -0.015167236, -0.037841797, -0.05831909, -0.008964539, -0.027282715, -0.05545044, -0.04019165, 0.07244873, -0.035949707, 0.0010166168, 0.019561768, -0.013549805, -0.0463562, 0.034698486, -0.027023315, -0.019805908, 0.03353882, 0.051116943, 0.019165039, -0.05203247, -0.031799316, -0.022033691, 0.0037670135, -0.012176514, 0.0051879883, -0.01537323, 0.006275177, 0.020721436, -0.0074806213, 0.023635864, -0.020721436, 0.012939453, -0.02709961, 0.037139893, 0.017822266, -0.061584473, 0.01461792, 0.019210815, -0.026947021, -0.013168335, 0.004638672, 0.062438965, -0.011566162, -0.03878784, 0.024597168, 0.03955078, -0.015823364, 0.03152466, 0.021957397, 0.011619568, -0.057128906, -0.021575928, -0.049072266, -0.016052246, -0.031280518, -0.03164673, 0.037384033, -0.052978516, -0.029251099, -0.021942139, -0.024673462, -0.02178955, 0.040985107, 0.0031642914, -0.03427124, -0.040618896, -0.02796936, -0.031402588, 0.01096344, -0.024963379, 0.02633667, 0.086364746, 0.000041425228, 0.005168915, 0.02217102, 0.029159546, 0.0025749207, -0.022872925, -0.023910522, -0.045318604, -0.0027256012, 0.016204834, 0.0057258606, -0.016311646, -0.02923584, -0.09088135, -0.0038375854, 0.02748108, 0.005630493, -0.01890564, 0.026947021, -0.07397461, 0.03543091, -0.018951416, -0.024459839, 0.028518677, 0.036071777, 0.011062622, 0.0034370422, -0.0007596016, -0.020233154, -0.0009455681, -0.027709961, -0.10546875, 0.01864624, 0.0021820068, -0.028396606, -0.018005371, -0.02897644, -0.05303955, -0.0031032562, 0.010620117, 0.044036865, 0.011993408, -0.0024795532, 0.0003900528, -0.015419006, 0.003107071, -0.03137207, -0.032348633, -0.02128601, -0.005039215, 0.03515625, -0.014831543, 0.047454834, 0.0073127747, -0.0037651062, -0.018173218, -0.003030777, -0.0013990402, 0.012565613, -0.0009365082, -0.011665344, 0.014297485, 0.021560669, -0.008117676, 0.013282776, -0.041900635, -0.010261536, -0.050079346, 0.023406982, -0.02861023, 0.02798462, 0.018218994, 0.020187378, -0.020645142, -0.034942627, 0.006374359, -0.040618896, -0.029327393, 0.0060195923, 0.054107666, 0.05303955, -0.053222656, -0.0044021606, -0.041931152, 0.025878906, 0.013114929, -0.051849365, 0.008239746, 0.00092697144, -0.017074585, -0.017074585, 0.0027370453, 0.0024337769, -0.013206482, 0.012619019, 0.01084137, -0.0024147034, -0.021514893, -0.039978027, 0.0017557144, -0.00075769424, -0.08508301, -0.009597778, -0.00015902519, -0.021270752, -0.037902832, -0.029144287, 0.02418518, -0.024047852, -0.03225708, 0.034088135, -0.016418457, -0.040283203, -0.02015686, -0.05407715, -0.04437256, 0.0826416, 0.01725769, 0.022842407, 0.039916992, -0.01322937, -0.023742676, -0.019363403, 0.03265381, 0.015357971, 0.03781128, 0.000042796135, 0.016143799, 0.03262329, -0.031799316, 0.02532959, 0.027801514, -0.029663086, 0.011894226, 0.01902771, 0.010131836, 0.036193848, 0.014945984, 0.046813965, -0.038116455, -0.007411957, -0.03302002, 0.016235352, -0.018692017, -0.006164551, 0.0022354126, -0.015182495, 0.020584106, 0.018936157, 0.037506104, 0.062316895, -0.021530151, -0.004627228, 0.05303955, 0.023422241, -0.022277832, -0.008453369, 0.026123047, 0.04748535, 0.00046801567, 0.025543213, -0.0008234978, 0.030227661, 0.010101318, -0.025894165, 0.012748718, 0.027999878, -0.0021877289, -0.03503418, -0.07141113, -0.038635254, 0.01977539, -0.010864258, -0.0046463013, 0.06088257, 0.04055786, 0.0024261475, -0.026367188, -0.0030708313, 0.033843994, 0.017913818, -0.044158936, -0.09460449, -0.00617218, -0.024291992, -0.046295166, -0.029312134, -0.03125, -0.026657104, 0.027511597, 0.0038661957, -0.03012085, 0.005722046, 0.03842163, 0.11090088, 0.051116943, 0.00053453445, -0.08050537, 0.0038909912, -0.014144897, -0.04425049, 0.0030555725, -0.0146102905, -0.016433716, -0.050964355, 0.00434494, -0.0061950684, -0.0048675537, -0.011009216, 0.027435303, -0.008995056, 0.043121338, -0.023971558, -0.002658844, 0.015777588, 0.011154175, 0.003921509, 0.0121536255, -0.031188965, -0.006916046, -0.007408142, 0.0335083, 0.01348114, -0.0050468445, 0.04019165, 0.0016994476, -0.010215759, 0.019882202, -0.0020446777, 0.027145386, 0.034576416, 0.026687622, -0.0042686462, -0.050567627, -0.042877197, 0.0036125183, 0.0066833496, 0.03427124, -0.029129028, 0.027801514, 0.010925293, -0.002609253, 0.03805542, -0.009887695, 0.017181396, 0.02973938, 0.0061569214, -0.041015625, -0.08062744, -0.013412476, 0.05532837, -0.0113220215, -0.0029525757, -0.02684021, -0.018325806, -0.0051002502, 0.07867432, 0.057403564, -0.00058078766, 0.021591187, -0.016586304, -0.00843811, -0.021026611, -0.06036377, -0.0206604, -0.0020179749, 0.009841919, -0.029281616, 0.027038574, -0.055908203, -0.01348114, -0.020019531, -0.011665344, 0.013504028, -0.049072266, 0.05419922, 0.09411621, -0.0025348663, 0.05291748, 0.012062073, 0.008003235, -0.000011026859, 0.06021118, 0.0025463104, 0.03149414, 0.027832031, -0.03262329, -0.011375427, -0.008659363, 0.005115509, 0.015556335, 0.040252686, 0.02243042, 0.017242432, -0.058563232, 0.028869629, -0.023773193, -0.039794922, 0.016616821, -0.037231445, -0.013702393, -0.011894226, 0.023834229, 0.028564453, -0.013916016, -0.043518066, -0.0362854, 0.0029296875, -0.06124878, 0.02861023, 0.0019435883, -0.042114258, -0.059295654, 0.007385254, -0.024459839, -0.0057525635, 0.007888794, -0.0030021667, -0.030410767, 0.023757935, 0.018676758, -0.023635864, 0.024673462, -0.010520935, 0.0011119843, 0.033447266, 0.0546875, -0.04156494, -0.012641907, 0.015914917, -0.023727417, 0.0032043457, 0.039642334, 0.022720337, -0.02330017, -0.008674622, -0.034484863, -0.016403198, 0.025756836, 0.033599854, -0.025115967, -0.029724121, 0.034240723, -0.013427734, -0.008483887, 0.0057792664, -0.024673462, 0.023391724, -0.010009766, -0.013206482, -0.06976318, 0.03250122, 0.014305115, 0.037322998, -0.011489868, -0.104003906, 0.015960693, 0.011001587, -0.0021629333, -0.030166626, 0.03274536, 0.031585693, -0.026412964, -0.02229309, -0.00573349, 0.029647827, -0.04336548, 0.004600525, -0.018081665, -0.003206253, -0.035369873, 0.05038452, -0.018981934, -0.0010757446, -0.04550171, -0.037078857, -0.015991211, 0.014076233, 0.00046730042, 0.004714966, -0.0064430237, -0.045837402, 0.008422852, -0.021499634, -0.013885498, -0.027770996, 0.0029907227, 0.001250267, 0.0062217712, 0.0053977966, 0.0019741058, -0.012176514, -0.033569336, 0.020263672, 0.045776367, -0.0021343231, 0.037750244, -0.026290894, -0.016815186, -0.00023531914, -0.026473999, 0.028915405, -0.03286743, -0.003616333, 0.019363403, -0.012580872, 0.048217773, 0.011199951, 0.058288574, 0.0579834, 0.0132369995, -0.010154724, 0.0039634705, 0.0022525787, -0.057495117, -0.0085372925, -0.043029785, -0.008346558, -0.05029297, -0.01550293, -0.044677734, 0.017364502, -0.015945435, 0.024520874, -0.010246277, 0.006374359, 0.0011034012, 0.020751953, 0.040161133, -0.0038890839, 0.043884277, 0.016677856, 0.0181427, 0.015083313, -0.030807495, -0.0011291504, 0.030517578, 0.014633179, -0.01260376, 0.006603241, -0.02482605, -0.0010137558, 0.029510498, 0.021697998, -0.035827637, -0.015525818, -0.039794922, 0.018585205, 0.000012457371, 0.03302002, 0.057281494, 0.0054397583, -0.017211914, -0.000073969364, 0.0018320084, -0.035339355, -0.05142212, 0.005443573, 0.013198853, -0.061767578, 0.029159546, -0.022598267, -0.025314331, -0.021560669, 0.044189453, 0.01474762, -0.04345703, -0.015029907, 0.014526367, 0.026535034, 0.004787445, -0.0070343018, -0.04724121, -0.026885986, 0.012748718, 0.05593872, -0.026062012, 0.017562866, -0.013381958, 0.033294678, -0.028030396, -0.027130127, 0.01739502, -0.0115737915, -0.014297485, 0.034057617, -0.016418457, 0.036010742, 0.020248413, -0.03967285, 0.015106201, 0.019470215, -0.04473877, -0.008682251, 0.012893677, 0.016067505, 0.02607727, 0.059631348, 0.0063171387, 0.0026950836, -0.011138916, -0.039276123, 0.010902405, 0.008483887, -0.028549194, -0.005214691, -0.03640747, -0.038391113, 0.0022945404, -0.036193848, 0.043395996, -0.06854248, -0.037017822, -0.030517578, 0.03842163, 0.0044174194, -0.014976501, -0.030273438, -0.04724121, 0.00015079975, -0.0064926147, 0.021438599, -0.056518555, -0.03829956, -0.015579224, 0.0124435425, -0.01625061, 0.007369995, 0.019485474, -0.01687622, -0.08477783, 0.020477295, -0.030303955, 0.050933838, -0.035369873, -0.011169434, -0.022354126, -0.0012283325, 0.019134521, 0.0007390976, -0.02671814, 0.024780273, -0.06945801, -0.022628784, -0.0026435852, -0.0061302185, -0.018585205, -0.012367249, -0.019592285, 0.0104599, -0.028045654, 0.016937256, 0.04522705, -0.048461914, -0.051483154, 0.00054216385, -0.019363403, 0.06109619, 0.0124053955, -0.0029468536, 0.017669678, 0.027908325, -0.03302002, -0.009483337, -0.0047798157, 0.023910522, 0.019439697, -0.05029297, 0.013725281, 0.0012102127, 0.027313232, -0.049682617, -0.050476074, 0.013832092, 0.026382446, -0.0211792, 0.0029335022, 0.036224365, -0.016845703, 0.027023315, -0.0155181885, -0.0046424866, -0.020950317, -0.03173828, -0.016571045, 0.025634766, 0.040039062, 0.0051994324, 0.00046873093, 0.037139893, -0.053894043, 0.018218994, -0.008293152, -0.013511658, 0.028717041, -0.012573242, 0.036956787, -0.025344849, 0.014472961, -0.065979004, 0.043640137, -0.008605957, 0.01777649, -0.007171631, 0.038482666, -0.001876831, 0.043273926, -0.009239197, -0.075683594, 0.054504395, 0.049835205, 0.013763428, 0.049346924, 0.0063934326, -0.045074463, -0.012954712, -0.008377075, -0.006385803, -0.0010566711, 0.03289795, -0.04547119, 0.016464233, -0.07745361, -0.046844482, -0.032836914, -0.030181885, 0.029663086, -0.0345459, 0.009132385, -0.008369446, -0.03933716, -0.012786865, 0.011749268, 0.0110321045, -0.043029785, -0.035858154, -0.07269287, 0.05368042, -0.0014696121 ], "summary": [ 0.021347046, -0.04269409, 0.0025138855, -0.027236938, -0.043762207, 0.006385803, -0.021057129, 0.002527237, 0.029144287, 0.068847656, 0.015144348, -0.004306793, -0.014984131, -0.0076179504, -0.08380127, -0.0131073, 0.0023040771, 0.031341553, 0.00009739399, -0.017532349, 0.01361084, -0.0236969, -0.0127334595, -0.028244019, 0.03086853, -0.06085205, -0.052093506, 0.00026082993, 0.00756073, 0.00522995, 0.024368286, 0.0048332214, -0.0057144165, -0.009651184, 0.056152344, -0.03100586, 0.009788513, -0.0008773804, 0.022277832, 0.0015821457, 0.028823853, -0.005748749, 0.064697266, 0.01979065, -0.011940002, 0.059539795, -0.025650024, -0.021835327, 0.04458618, 0.04071045, 0.02609253, 0.021942139, 0.0012273788, 0.015380859, -0.021820068, -0.02482605, -0.037719727, 0.012649536, 0.0017671585, 0.10925293, 0.019424438, 0.012672424, -0.043304443, -0.06744385, -0.023712158, 0.03640747, -0.047546387, -0.019622803, 0.06329346, 0.0051841736, -0.03265381, -0.006038666, 0.012954712, -0.09240723, 0.033416748, 0.07611084, -0.037719727, 0.011428833, 0.023544312, -0.021362305, 0.040405273, 0.0107421875, 0.07891846, -0.005115509, -0.015327454, -0.025680542, 0.0009756088, -0.020736694, -0.02583313, -0.029632568, -0.032989502, 0.0063591003, -0.059326172, -0.009635925, 0.0022907257, -0.028244019, -0.016204834, -0.0107421875, -0.00032615662, -0.0069274902, -0.010101318, -0.013580322, -0.0019426346, -0.004814148, 0.024307251, -0.010986328, -0.016204834, -0.005092621, 0.05581665, 0.0058670044, -0.0413208, 0.053863525, 0.015945435, -0.0010099411, -0.047424316, -0.014945984, -0.008277893, 0.008300781, 0.009025574, -0.003616333, -0.048919678, -0.0016498566, 0.028823853, 0.029144287, -0.018814087, 0.018737793, 0.046142578, -0.0446167, 0.026031494, 0.010177612, -0.016723633, 0.043151855, -0.02178955, -0.05834961, -0.06173706, -0.013389587, 0.025314331, 0.026290894, -0.0027046204, -0.0135650635, -0.011795044, 0.03189087, 0.062927246, -0.019805908, -0.0016937256, 0.025848389, 0.034210205, 0.0231781, -0.024551392, -0.083618164, 0.06149292, -0.03262329, 0.01826477, -0.04876709, 0.0211792, -0.03866577, -0.06781006, 0.0149383545, 0.010002136, 0.046295166, 0.025894165, 0.0015087128, 0.030731201, 0.032836914, 0.0064964294, -0.034301758, -0.015289307, -0.01725769, 0.008674622, 0.06665039, -0.030303955, 0.040893555, 0.0037574768, 0.017822266, 0.00057411194, -0.032989502, -0.01687622, 0.032409668, 0.056030273, -0.03152466, -0.025726318, -0.025878906, 0.08874512, -0.017059326, -0.009231567, -0.07446289, 0.004558563, 0.0068244934, 0.04269409, 0.02293396, -0.02961731, -0.03149414, -0.059265137, 0.024520874, -0.013038635, -0.012550354, -0.030166626, -0.008598328, -0.008666992, 0.013343811, 0.026947021, -0.011779785, -0.014640808, -0.05621338, -0.08648682, -0.043273926, -0.004878998, 0.026519775, -0.0036907196, 0.040893555, 0.029296875, 0.034942627, -0.057403564, 0.024093628, -0.008705139, -0.03591919, 0.023361206, 0.0012722015, 0.0038146973, -0.0060157776, 0.03086853, 0.00069761276, -0.00022220612, 0.0814209, -0.04675293, 0.019058228, -0.0010881424, 0.034698486, 0.060577393, 0.00029993057, 0.13256836, -0.06286621, -0.01889038, 0.043792725, 0.0093307495, -0.026733398, -0.017562866, -0.06964111, 0.034118652, 0.028152466, 0.01838684, 0.022705078, -0.029052734, -0.010002136, 0.028839111, 0.024658203, 0.04083252, -0.011116028, 0.00045228004, -0.025131226, 0.006298065, -0.014152527, 0.059417725, -0.037200928, 0.025772095, 0.02911377, 0.013648987, 0.0056114197, -0.00024867058, -0.013473511, 0.014663696, 0.022491455, -0.00075244904, 0.008758545, -0.022537231, -0.03933716, -0.007785797, -0.003200531, 0.03274536, -0.04937744, 0.012878418, -0.007575989, -0.02168274, -0.023895264, 0.011795044, -0.013549805, -0.015197754, 0.01486969, -0.031951904, -0.03189087, -0.0101623535, -0.009994507, 0.015136719, -0.013076782, 0.02633667, 0.015075684, 0.03567505, -0.015838623, -0.014434814, 0.017105103, 0.039489746, -0.0003569126, -0.013786316, -0.010139465, -0.014846802, -0.01876831, 0.06939697, 0.02357483, 0.021743774, -0.030044556, 0.0062675476, 0.021560669, -0.074035645, 0.0029125214, 0.01184082, 0.011039734, 0.013961792, 0.028427124, 0.015411377, -0.03060913, 0.013664246, 0.01449585, 0.029922485, 0.037200928, -0.03845215, -0.03717041, -0.00504303, 0.0345459, -0.024780273, 0.011398315, 0.06109619, -0.022964478, 0.048034668, 0.051116943, 0.0020313263, -0.06463623, 0.09240723, -0.014411926, -0.0057678223, 0.020217896, 0.0039024353, 0.015617371, -0.02709961, -0.04562378, -0.010520935, 0.01071167, 0.00036025047, -0.016616821, -0.019561768, -0.0075416565, 0.017105103, -0.045074463, 0.02279663, -0.007434845, -0.054840088, 0.009300232, 0.030349731, -0.0013723373, -0.037078857, -0.0053253174, 0.028198242, -0.016830444, 0.00010091066, 0.02973938, 0.04284668, -0.0050735474, -0.029663086, 0.0073127747, 0.025970459, -0.034606934, 0.059173584, 0.03414917, 0.02708435, -0.05065918, -0.051330566, -0.044799805, 0.0446167, -0.052124023, -0.004169464, 0.029296875, 0.0044174194, 0.020111084, -0.01171875, -0.01737976, -0.0140686035, 0.013870239, 0.08178711, 0.00945282, -0.012214661, 0.05596924, 0.032409668, 0.06304932, -0.016647339, 0.07696533, 0.08886719, 0.016342163, 0.0090408325, 0.026489258, 0.01234436, -0.012649536, -0.027664185, -0.0061416626, 0.00012755394, -0.023635864, 0.0069274902, 0.0071868896, -0.028884888, 0.026062012, -0.013404846, -0.009567261, -0.00010585785, 0.03982544, 0.037384033, 0.0002245903, -0.052093506, 0.06262207, -0.034301758, -0.0045928955, 0.030792236, 0.021636963, 0.025924683, -0.0256958, 0.019317627, -0.030700684, -0.020050049, 0.0028324127, -0.02204895, 0.009033203, -0.007633209, -0.0038223267, -0.0028057098, 0.013008118, -0.007888794, 0.0015239716, -0.01586914, 0.05999756, -0.030532837, 0.015823364, -0.038360596, -0.0013504028, 0.011550903, -0.030883789, -0.012054443, 0.0017795563, -0.02166748, 0.012756348, -0.022277832, -0.014389038, 0.0064468384, -0.051818848, -0.011329651, -0.016998291, 0.002948761, -0.009429932, -0.030319214, 0.030441284, 0.018920898, 0.021820068, -0.0032920837, 0.009002686, -0.032196045, 0.009468079, -0.004043579, 0.02645874, -0.03378296, 0.006565094, -0.016525269, 0.0446167, 0.05783081, -0.050994873, -0.017959595, -0.055999756, -0.0024337769, 0.02470398, 0.06585693, 0.059173584, -0.09161377, 0.026290894, -0.01007843, -0.019973755, 0.06896973, -0.050354004, 0.00041532516, -0.00026798248, -0.018478394, -0.011817932, 0.036224365, 0.011329651, 0.012001038, -0.014801025, -0.024719238, 0.013450623, -0.0010738373, -0.0078125, -0.0035076141, 0.017715454, -0.019683838, -0.0061416626, 0.028640747, 0.022705078, -0.007499695, -0.022994995, 0.062194824, -0.0010118484, 0.028900146, 0.03173828, -0.0053977966, 0.033081055, 0.00073480606, -0.042388916, -0.01222229, 0.015777588, -0.018814087, 0.03778076, 0.018707275, 0.0178833, 0.019561768, 0.0031909943, 0.017150879, 0.016601562, 0.0317688, -0.009506226, 0.0115356445, -0.009780884, -0.013137817, 0.025741577, -0.0072021484, -0.06945801, 0.02508545, 0.011909485, 0.019882202, 0.042663574, 0.022140503, 0.014022827, -0.033050537, 0.012611389, -0.013908386, 0.017105103, -0.012290955, -0.038085938, -0.008781433, 0.01423645, -0.01209259, 0.040496826, 0.028823853, 0.0015001297, -0.019317627, -0.00041222572, 0.037506104, 0.021438599, -0.0107803345, -0.03250122, 0.00007069111, 0.038146973, -0.01499939, 0.00157547, -0.01461792, -0.0101623535, 0.022506714, -0.06021118, 0.022018433, 0.039642334, 0.02268982, -0.03643799, 0.007396698, -0.049865723, 0.031921387, -0.030075073, 0.008888245, 0.019607544, 0.032409668, 0.017059326, -0.013267517, 0.0025959015, 0.02758789, 0.039093018, -0.08691406, -0.13708496, -0.024780273, -0.04550171, -0.04525757, -0.02128601, -0.027160645, -0.0098724365, -0.030014038, 0.028686523, -0.060699463, -0.036865234, 0.020309448, 0.09564209, 0.016403198, 0.06414795, -0.060394287, -0.047851562, -0.01838684, -0.03149414, -0.01651001, 0.0038547516, -0.049743652, -0.057159424, 0.010169983, -0.00026249886, -0.0040626526, 0.009796143, -0.012199402, -0.0044784546, 0.019683838, -0.023757935, 0.024002075, 0.0036716461, 0.0024604797, 0.013084412, 0.0034980774, -0.003572464, -0.010673523, 0.016647339, 0.0062713623, 0.04208374, -0.001282692, 0.044921875, -0.017318726, -0.007965088, 0.02267456, -0.021392822, 0.021011353, 0.018707275, 0.035827637, -0.023712158, -0.051361084, -0.027114868, -0.003692627, -0.012748718, 0.015716553, -0.0024795532, -0.036132812, 0.039031982, 0.030715942, 0.03173828, -0.011909485, 0.0076026917, 0.04296875, 0.0013551712, -0.030059814, -0.06378174, 0.009529114, 0.06970215, -0.014976501, -0.010429382, -0.046020508, -0.027297974, -0.013137817, 0.03161621, 0.0073509216, -0.009757996, 0.0011320114, -0.026168823, -0.020812988, -0.02935791, -0.036010742, -0.032562256, -0.015449524, 0.024658203, -0.03149414, 0.03543091, 0.045776367, -0.02130127, -0.04257202, -0.000500679, -0.015464783, -0.0061836243, -0.024612427, 0.042633057, -0.010047913, 0.047912598, 0.022903442, -0.031951904, -0.031829834, 0.055633545, -0.0579834, 0.016952515, 0.035095215, -0.05859375, -0.003080368, -0.026947021, 0.0011348724, 0.04260254, 0.055145264, 0.028198242, 0.04925537, -0.05126953, 0.022705078, -0.046966553, -0.020721436, 0.017105103, -0.030807495, 0.008964539, -0.05328369, 0.021591187, 0.018829346, 0.008277893, -0.03704834, -0.0519104, -0.0030651093, -0.078430176, -0.0013113022, -0.013618469, -0.038726807, -0.030334473, -0.0051231384, -0.0053596497, -0.0085372925, -0.0022411346, 0.03149414, -0.015449524, -0.018539429, 0.019088745, 0.036132812, 0.006511688, -0.0014781952, -0.02130127, -0.014060974, 0.053619385, -0.037506104, -0.004852295, 0.027694702, 0.015136719, 0.007965088, 0.011177063, 0.00459671, 0.01197052, -0.016448975, -0.0032863617, -0.049591064, -0.0435791, 0.0013246536, -0.06365967, -0.05517578, 0.022521973, -0.022079468, -0.053375244, 0.005203247, -0.026351929, -0.016983032, -0.012939453, -0.011245728, -0.030929565, 0.034057617, 0.009155273, 0.03878784, 0.011116028, -0.066467285, 0.023498535, 0.018112183, 0.008842468, 0.013305664, 0.07867432, 0.028823853, -0.012992859, -0.0001078248, 0.021377563, -0.008178711, -0.019744873, -0.008781433, -0.026321411, 0.010124207, -0.019821167, 0.04714966, -0.02923584, -0.016052246, -0.023956299, -0.027069092, 0.028930664, 0.022003174, -0.026611328, 0.01966858, -0.003396988, -0.036376953, 0.01864624, 0.027770996, -0.030517578, -0.04019165, 0.007293701, -0.015464783, -0.018310547, 0.07299805, 0.017684937, -0.022720337, -0.026855469, -0.00041747093, 0.048980713, 0.03060913, 0.045196533, -0.01473999, -0.031982422, -0.01876831, 0.03869629, -0.010658264, 0.026412964, -0.05343628, -0.07098389, -0.0033569336, 0.05718994, -0.002603531, 0.008956909, -0.034851074, -0.030303955, 0.016326904, 0.009048462, 0.017807007, -0.024307251, -0.028533936, -0.0039634705, -0.032470703, -0.007587433, -0.015930176, 0.0013561249, 0.03616333, -0.020126343, -0.031829834, 0.04800415, -0.0054130554, 0.011100769, 0.027313232, -0.030563354, 0.0028076172, -0.002401352, 0.016677856, 0.0052757263, 0.0049209595, -0.005001068, -0.019073486, 0.020599365, 0.0022068024, 0.024749756, 0.009254456, -0.0309906, 0.017227173, 0.0135650635, -0.028289795, -0.06878662, 0.017150879, -0.04232788, 0.03427124, 0.03390503, 0.05166626, 0.020263672, -0.034698486, 0.07159424, -0.04324341, -0.015960693, -0.0041122437, -0.027404785, 0.0009469986, 0.014221191, -0.015686035, 0.004173279, -0.009269714, -0.022064209, 0.0031757355, 0.016403198, 0.02897644, -0.00497818, 0.01235199, -0.0065574646, 0.012634277, -0.00069999695, -0.027664185, -0.040283203, -0.047302246, -0.008972168, 0.026504517, -0.011558533, 0.0046195984, -0.04208374, 0.016983032, -0.026245117, -0.029891968, 0.04650879, -0.042022705, 0.004070282, 0.0058784485, 0.014724731, 0.037841797, 0.04840088, -0.0096206665, 0.02468872, 0.039520264, -0.017822266, 0.044769287, -0.0014953613, 0.03250122, -0.009262085, 0.013633728, -0.050323486, 0.0076942444, 0.039154053, -0.004776001, 0.022491455, -0.018798828, 0.014427185, -0.017868042, -0.045166016, -0.00075006485, -0.036132812, -0.005859375, 0.027435303, -0.07885742, -0.007423401, -0.041748047, 0.03286743, -0.05770874, 0.016601562, -0.009109497, -0.04095459, 0.005695343, 0.018600464, 0.036865234, -0.05041504, -0.018722534, -0.01423645, -0.011268616, -0.017684937, 0.016723633, 0.02760315, -0.028549194, -0.03677368, 0.03829956, 0.03277588, 0.06738281, 0.005683899, -0.04650879, 0.0061035156, 0.0021247864, 0.040618896, 0.0115737915, -0.008483887, -0.0058059692, -0.013725281, 0.0003709793, 0.0059432983, 0.02128601, -0.02015686, -0.03933716, -0.035858154, 0.027313232, -0.04916382, 0.022628784, 0.043121338, -0.02659607, -0.046722412, 0.015533447, -0.017608643, 0.056365967, -0.002910614, 0.04159546, -0.015640259, 0.05166626, 0.002773285, -0.006362915, 0.031707764, 0.026412964, 0.04473877, -0.06262207, 0.0001693964, -0.008987427, 0.003698349, -0.017303467, -0.019195557, 0.03665161, 0.0446167, -0.009513855, -0.041534424, 0.0098724365, -0.012619019, 0.029586792, 0.007610321, 0.0011262894, -0.025436401, -0.0079574585, 0.035064697, 0.025177002, 0.0059814453, -0.0026683807, -0.006210327, -0.0036144257, -0.04373169, 0.014945984, -0.034210205, -0.016052246, 0.0005583763, -0.026748657, -0.017501831, -0.015434265, 0.014968872, -0.001414299, 0.009468079, -0.0038318634, 0.01889038, -0.032165527, 0.013671875, -0.008811951, -0.015838623, 0.015571594, -0.04953003, 0.027145386, 0.028549194, 0.027862549, 0.0069999695, 0.027252197, -0.05166626, -0.03741455, -0.0045700073, 0.014678955, 0.002193451, 0.00082731247, -0.029464722, 0.013160706, -0.06286621, -0.047790527, -0.0030879974, -0.0069999695, -0.013710022, -0.019836426, 0.03375244, 0.05328369, -0.04272461, 0.022979736, 0.009407043, -0.002357483, 0.00016272068, -0.0055618286, -0.039123535, -0.0005273819, 0.007896423 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07014v1
Teach me with a Whisper: Enhancing Large Language Models for Analyzing Spoken Transcripts using Speech Embeddings
Fatema Hasan, Yulong Li, James Foulds, Shimei Pan, Bishwaranjan Bhattacharjee
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
Speech data has rich acoustic and paralinguistic information with important cues for understanding a speaker's tone, emotion, and intent, yet traditional large language models such as BERT do not incorporate this information. There has been an increased interest in multi-modal language models leveraging audio and/or visual information and text. However, current multi-modal language models require both text and audio/visual data streams during inference/test time. In this work, we propose a methodology for training language models leveraging spoken language audio data but without requiring the audio stream during prediction time. This leads to an improved language model for analyzing spoken transcripts while avoiding an audio processing overhead at test time. We achieve this via an audio-language knowledge distillation framework, where we transfer acoustic and paralinguistic information from a pre-trained speech embedding (OpenAI Whisper) teacher model to help train a student language model on an audio-text dataset. In our experiments, the student model achieves consistent improvement over traditional language models on tasks analyzing spoken transcripts.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07014v1
2023-11-13T01:53:12
2023-11-13T01:53:12
{ "title": [ -0.016479492, -0.009307861, -0.04473877, -0.07574463, -0.0046806335, -0.00579834, -0.06854248, 0.020355225, 0.010917664, 0.026870728, -0.027008057, 0.010513306, 0.012138367, -0.003276825, -0.029663086, 0.0062026978, -0.013877869, 0.05596924, -0.01586914, -0.037750244, -0.004508972, -0.072753906, 0.03225708, 0.0045776367, 0.04522705, -0.04348755, -0.06347656, 0.01586914, -0.032836914, -0.028274536, 0.005554199, -0.00079107285, 0.03277588, 0.034942627, -0.03173828, 0.0025959015, -0.0592041, 0.03555298, -0.008850098, 0.0032291412, 0.026504517, -0.01789856, -0.005256653, -0.019134521, -0.018249512, 0.02355957, -0.044525146, -0.029510498, -0.014305115, 0.03729248, 0.01663208, 0.013710022, -0.016036987, 0.03375244, 0.022094727, -0.025299072, -0.032714844, 0.03616333, 0.03286743, 0.05770874, 0.019927979, -0.01965332, 0.0014371872, -0.016098022, -0.05886841, -0.017318726, -0.027374268, 0.011947632, 0.06524658, -0.027938843, -0.016815186, 0.025115967, 0.004306793, -0.028213501, -0.08679199, 0.040100098, 0.030426025, 0.014953613, 0.035614014, -0.060913086, -0.0056915283, -0.014205933, 0.046539307, -0.03805542, 0.021575928, -0.044067383, -0.023956299, -0.0032653809, -0.014266968, -0.06060791, 0.0038146973, -0.0049591064, -0.000374794, 0.010063171, -0.031463623, -0.024368286, -0.015167236, 0.029754639, -0.003080368, -0.032073975, -0.01713562, 0.029067993, -0.05227661, -0.009605408, 0.014381409, 0.00881958, -0.026733398, -0.026229858, 0.017211914, 0.038146973, -0.030044556, 0.046844482, -0.002166748, -0.02960205, 0.0071754456, 0.03869629, -0.008232117, 0.017807007, 0.025283813, 0.0158844, -0.0018825531, -0.017745972, 0.015457153, -0.009346008, 0.037994385, 0.002664566, -0.05319214, 0.012039185, 0.0037822723, 0.02267456, 0.022003174, 0.04486084, -0.13708496, -0.09124756, -0.07055664, 0.05303955, -0.0395813, 0.00037574768, -0.026428223, 0.028045654, -0.015411377, -0.036956787, 0.012939453, -0.00472641, 0.000034093857, -0.0005774498, 0.070617676, -0.006126404, -0.062408447, -0.018981934, -0.032958984, 0.0423584, 0.024139404, -0.025436401, -0.037078857, -0.039916992, -0.13098145, -0.021713257, 0.040374756, -0.0060195923, 0.010826111, 0.0039482117, 0.007949829, -0.005897522, 0.008178711, -0.0037326813, 0.0016336441, 0.004131317, 0.008956909, 0.023529053, -0.013900757, 0.020736694, 0.03829956, 0.012863159, -0.01828003, 0.010627747, 0.02268982, -0.011993408, 0.03729248, -0.024841309, -0.007572174, -0.030151367, 0.0060272217, 0.03845215, -0.03930664, -0.025375366, 0.01675415, 0.01638794, 0.034820557, 0.013198853, -0.044311523, 0.026382446, -0.031707764, -0.04559326, -0.056732178, -0.022369385, 0.039001465, 0.019836426, 0.0045814514, 0.013412476, 0.019210815, 0.009109497, -0.025238037, -0.008644104, -0.03012085, -0.02532959, -0.023284912, 0.010345459, -0.008651733, 0.049621582, 0.051849365, 0.024719238, -0.04559326, 0.008666992, -0.007980347, -0.020736694, 0.015319824, 0.008384705, 0.00080919266, -0.0026340485, -0.0072135925, -0.0057029724, 0.009422302, 0.03894043, 0.016830444, -0.00022387505, 0.019699097, -0.018829346, 0.037506104, 0.028823853, 0.048675537, -0.06628418, 0.047698975, 0.047698975, -0.0045394897, -0.02619934, 0.008766174, -0.024108887, 0.019332886, 0.006538391, 0.00083875656, -0.009819031, -0.017211914, 0.01687622, 0.050567627, -0.011924744, 0.003648758, -0.0008158684, 0.015220642, 0.029922485, 0.060791016, 0.0060157776, 0.035949707, -0.01625061, 0.009849548, 0.04522705, 0.007183075, -0.022827148, -0.0131073, 0.013389587, 0.01939392, 0.0067214966, -0.02406311, 0.0063591003, -0.058044434, 0.030639648, -0.037017822, 0.00068855286, -0.005809784, 0.025100708, 0.03717041, -0.014625549, 0.022460938, 0.017532349, 0.006412506, -0.010559082, -0.006702423, -0.004299164, 0.023620605, -0.03201294, 0.0027236938, 0.031051636, 0.03829956, 0.0062332153, 0.012962341, 0.0010089874, 0.013076782, -0.0051078796, -0.033935547, -0.009643555, 0.031829834, 0.060791016, 0.011657715, -0.008560181, 0.018981934, 0.023117065, 0.12335205, 0.06161499, -0.032562256, 0.043792725, -0.011505127, 0.033172607, 0.026168823, -0.011802673, 0.022750854, 0.016479492, 0.03060913, 0.005039215, -0.027359009, 0.015335083, -0.050109863, 0.015327454, -0.005794525, -0.005897522, -0.045959473, -0.049591064, 0.012756348, -0.029006958, -0.034118652, -0.012321472, 0.08508301, -0.047302246, -0.005634308, -0.014678955, -0.02999878, -0.025924683, 0.001074791, -0.025726318, 0.010536194, 0.027145386, 0.04824829, 0.016082764, -0.05508423, -0.04901123, -0.0047569275, 0.0034065247, -0.0132751465, -0.012306213, -0.015129089, 0.045898438, 0.030288696, -0.0025959015, 0.021438599, -0.036071777, -0.010284424, -0.04321289, 0.023132324, 0.00881958, 0.0062942505, -0.0009813309, 0.009483337, 0.0035572052, -0.02960205, 0.013931274, 0.06225586, -0.023712158, -0.014266968, 0.02507019, 0.02168274, -0.0236969, 0.035858154, 0.013938904, 0.005794525, -0.068603516, -0.030227661, -0.03692627, -0.030151367, -0.01473999, -0.0042037964, 0.044403076, -0.032714844, -0.025009155, -0.035827637, -0.013931274, 0.01259613, 0.0021820068, 0.0055351257, -0.02508545, -0.028305054, -0.01751709, -0.02381897, 0.0022449493, -0.010932922, 0.0138168335, 0.06329346, 0.011734009, -0.00083208084, 0.010299683, 0.028533936, 0.002910614, -0.0031909943, -0.0051345825, -0.072509766, 0.005218506, 0.019424438, 0.009094238, 0.014144897, -0.00579834, -0.092285156, -0.021942139, 0.08929443, 0.008804321, -0.021972656, 0.048980713, -0.0670166, 0.02331543, 0.019378662, -0.007106781, 0.0357666, 0.03213501, 0.033355713, -0.0044670105, 0.027801514, -0.03048706, -0.00074386597, -0.03741455, -0.11126709, 0.020858765, -0.016326904, -0.021057129, -0.012771606, -0.03466797, -0.05429077, 0.00046515465, 0.011787415, 0.04626465, 0.007419586, -0.0068893433, -0.013015747, -0.021911621, 0.014915466, -0.037384033, -0.02809143, -0.016311646, -0.013870239, 0.041381836, 0.010360718, 0.0657959, 0.023468018, -0.007293701, -0.033691406, -0.004764557, -0.0053215027, 0.011009216, 0.023910522, -0.045196533, -0.0034694672, -0.007637024, -0.031097412, 0.031097412, -0.02330017, -0.0007596016, -0.07043457, 0.022262573, -0.03237915, 0.018417358, 0.01448822, 0.016311646, -0.026794434, -0.022659302, 0.026870728, -0.02520752, -0.054748535, 0.0011262894, 0.063964844, 0.0025119781, -0.03050232, 0.0017108917, -0.019882202, 0.0284729, 0.024749756, -0.02696228, -0.012969971, -0.01828003, -0.012962341, -0.0105896, 0.0072364807, -0.013092041, 0.016403198, -0.00315094, -0.023391724, 0.018127441, -0.022155762, -0.08312988, -0.020690918, 0.002002716, -0.09753418, -0.03967285, 0.012741089, -0.07269287, -0.051605225, -0.047912598, 0.015792847, -0.03717041, -0.027526855, 0.0035991669, -0.026809692, -0.03829956, -0.0132751465, -0.09466553, 0.012763977, 0.08746338, 0.021896362, 0.036499023, 0.051940918, -0.020263672, -0.02331543, -0.017852783, 0.03173828, 0.0037212372, 0.055419922, 0.0028190613, -0.00491333, 0.026885986, -0.016067505, 0.021881104, 0.064941406, -0.03326416, 0.037322998, 0.0059547424, 0.00919342, 0.016830444, 0.0035514832, 0.03857422, -0.003566742, -0.0036754608, -0.052490234, 0.008903503, 0.0035305023, 0.03591919, 0.023788452, -0.013977051, 0.018676758, -0.019012451, 0.015533447, 0.012023926, -0.023361206, -0.0023841858, 0.050598145, 0.0035171509, -0.01977539, -0.0035648346, 0.019195557, 0.036376953, 0.0047073364, 0.025268555, -0.004295349, 0.030853271, -0.014389038, -0.014228821, -0.0041160583, 0.011680603, -0.01550293, 0.002067566, -0.0552063, -0.042022705, -0.031341553, 0.002357483, -0.007843018, 0.046142578, 0.05734253, -0.0011434555, -0.020553589, -0.015060425, 0.07019043, 0.0051612854, -0.016357422, -0.092163086, 0.014556885, -0.017700195, -0.045166016, -0.037719727, 0.0064811707, -0.024963379, 0.021835327, -0.016830444, -0.001127243, 0.009147644, 0.028640747, 0.055114746, 0.028762817, -0.006061554, -0.040222168, 0.010002136, -0.024047852, -0.020751953, 0.006855011, -0.00034189224, -0.0016078949, -0.027664185, 0.0071144104, -0.013183594, -0.0073776245, -0.014381409, 0.027557373, -0.014160156, 0.05847168, -0.026931763, 0.010749817, 0.020828247, 0.015960693, 0.009895325, 0.0025939941, -0.028030396, -0.009971619, 0.0066337585, 0.038024902, -0.0011873245, 0.0071487427, 0.04458618, 0.026870728, -0.0038223267, 0.03488159, -0.00021255016, 0.035614014, -0.00043559074, 0.011734009, -0.0020923615, -0.06213379, -0.034576416, -0.018188477, 0.008262634, 0.04827881, -0.05645752, 0.019927979, -0.018920898, 0.0054016113, 0.01751709, -0.012817383, 0.0155181885, 0.0039863586, 0.008872986, -0.04071045, -0.055908203, -0.007537842, 0.029876709, -0.014472961, -0.0024738312, -0.0023555756, 0.011077881, 0.011398315, 0.049804688, 0.029434204, 0.00075769424, -0.008399963, -0.009094238, -0.0047187805, -0.023513794, -0.04711914, 0.01197052, 0.002357483, 0.0066337585, -0.020629883, 0.0074882507, -0.07122803, -0.004211426, -0.026748657, -0.034851074, 0.042266846, -0.06726074, 0.0146484375, 0.07104492, -0.008293152, 0.052001953, -0.0107421875, 0.021835327, 0.01637268, 0.06414795, 0.010017395, 0.015419006, 0.033355713, -0.045654297, 0.017166138, -0.0060920715, 0.023071289, 0.03213501, 0.032714844, 0.014862061, 0.019210815, -0.0647583, 0.012626648, -0.00756073, -0.030151367, 0.015930176, -0.04888916, -0.003868103, 0.020645142, 0.0071372986, 0.018188477, -0.016174316, -0.028152466, -0.01234436, -0.0036811829, -0.05557251, 0.00409317, -0.006275177, -0.06512451, -0.013954163, 0.029464722, -0.024139404, -0.02748108, 0.027023315, -0.008956909, -0.02507019, 0.030517578, 0.012260437, -0.0287323, -0.009712219, -0.0021839142, 0.008354187, 0.03100586, 0.03366089, -0.031188965, -0.003692627, -0.0010204315, -0.047088623, -0.039855957, 0.02848816, 0.009056091, -0.0066871643, -0.0074501038, -0.019699097, 0.013534546, -0.013870239, 0.029815674, -0.012718201, -0.015701294, 0.027816772, -0.020233154, -0.025878906, 0.006427765, -0.010055542, 0.005279541, -0.0007801056, -0.0068206787, -0.06695557, 0.03237915, 0.014457703, 0.039001465, -0.008575439, -0.07751465, 0.010246277, 0.011276245, 0.009475708, -0.0016384125, 0.018844604, 0.02218628, 0.024841309, -0.007217407, 0.0146865845, 0.055999756, -0.055664062, -0.028503418, 0.0054473877, -0.00015473366, -0.0025424957, 0.08135986, -0.007030487, -0.027175903, -0.042510986, -0.048614502, -0.02027893, 0.019607544, 0.017868042, 0.0040283203, 0.019470215, -0.011177063, 0.046875, -0.039733887, -0.006855011, -0.03643799, 0.037261963, -0.0018119812, -0.02130127, 0.0006365776, -0.011314392, -0.0029067993, -0.029174805, 0.034423828, 0.020248413, -0.03302002, 0.0033683777, -0.038482666, 0.008758545, -0.014678955, -0.02508545, 0.042144775, -0.0019950867, -0.006690979, 0.03640747, -0.01398468, 0.047027588, 0.02494812, 0.062683105, 0.05722046, 0.0059051514, 0.0032348633, 0.01499939, 0.012329102, -0.046539307, 0.0028705597, -0.04675293, -0.0016508102, -0.05380249, -0.013145447, -0.047302246, -0.003929138, 0.012680054, 0.021194458, 0.022720337, 0.013320923, 0.018539429, -0.028396606, 0.021560669, -0.024017334, 0.03439331, -0.0072250366, 0.009468079, 0.007205963, -0.047027588, 0.021408081, 0.036193848, -0.0072631836, -0.0048713684, -0.01235199, 0.0017299652, -0.0044021606, 0.009223938, 0.017593384, -0.039398193, -0.015914917, -0.036895752, 0.015792847, -0.00642395, 0.012748718, 0.07183838, 0.012908936, -0.001540184, -0.02128601, 0.0096206665, -0.038238525, -0.034240723, -0.0033721924, 0.03933716, -0.105285645, 0.03842163, -0.00774765, -0.017700195, -0.047790527, 0.048095703, 0.013885498, -0.031219482, -0.016921997, -0.0033435822, 0.045959473, 0.0010709763, -0.023452759, -0.049041748, -0.021224976, 0.025268555, 0.053527832, -0.029815674, 0.021484375, 0.013008118, 0.028244019, 0.008911133, -0.0025730133, -0.0059394836, 0.028930664, -0.011222839, 0.03543091, -0.020019531, 0.016571045, -0.00066947937, -0.036834717, 0.0071754456, 0.010765076, -0.046661377, -0.011779785, 0.01574707, 0.0038166046, 0.024368286, 0.06903076, 0.03756714, 0.007549286, -0.035461426, -0.04147339, 0.01184082, 0.05029297, -0.026626587, 0.012924194, -0.031707764, -0.042999268, 0.031951904, -0.039215088, 0.061706543, -0.06512451, -0.021835327, -0.01928711, 0.032836914, 0.012260437, -0.020767212, -0.037261963, -0.016601562, -0.04043579, 0.0057373047, 0.023345947, -0.020050049, -0.02961731, -0.02053833, 0.006515503, -0.0014533997, 0.007865906, 0.011253357, -0.015556335, -0.0770874, 0.01914978, -0.030975342, 0.057678223, -0.033050537, -0.0023403168, -0.018234253, 0.006137848, 0.014579773, -0.008529663, -0.024490356, 0.018936157, -0.03074646, -0.02935791, 0.025009155, 0.025054932, -0.016418457, -0.04547119, -0.009887695, -0.007446289, -0.030258179, 0.010292053, 0.047912598, -0.04257202, -0.035980225, -0.00198555, -0.028503418, 0.042053223, 0.0004708767, -0.012634277, 0.0335083, 0.011940002, -0.027435303, 0.008140564, 0.032318115, 0.034179688, 0.012557983, -0.05041504, 0.008026123, 0.020126343, 0.041015625, -0.05114746, -0.06121826, 0.021942139, 0.0032958984, -0.0077438354, 0.040222168, 0.008087158, -0.00014269352, 0.02330017, 0.014656067, 0.007663727, -0.036468506, 0.01625061, -0.023971558, 0.027359009, 0.046905518, -0.008979797, 0.019012451, 0.026809692, -0.035980225, 0.0019836426, 0.0003979206, -0.015579224, 0.014190674, -0.004207611, 0.020767212, -0.024978638, -0.007381439, -0.059692383, 0.036834717, -0.020080566, 0.020462036, -0.016921997, 0.021194458, -0.0007266998, 0.033111572, -0.050048828, -0.09063721, 0.06390381, 0.0546875, -0.0051078796, 0.026977539, -0.017181396, -0.0011758804, -0.009529114, -0.02053833, -0.0040397644, 0.015609741, 0.025360107, -0.06365967, 0.0118637085, -0.076660156, -0.037902832, -0.052246094, -0.058746338, 0.05307007, -0.031204224, 0.0073661804, -0.020980835, 0.00061273575, -0.004234314, 0.028030396, -0.024246216, -0.008079529, -0.062408447, -0.03918457, 0.03967285, -0.031402588 ], "summary": [ 0.013137817, -0.020324707, 0.00020492077, -0.062683105, -0.056671143, 0.0056991577, -0.10656738, -0.000047385693, 0.039123535, 0.025360107, -0.055419922, -0.023406982, 0.03024292, -0.006385803, 0.00034856796, -0.024963379, -0.007419586, 0.014816284, -0.03086853, -0.019363403, -0.0026130676, -0.028411865, -0.022521973, -0.029525757, 0.025909424, -0.029708862, -0.036346436, 0.04284668, -0.0075531006, 0.03149414, 0.022003174, -0.026351929, 0.019638062, 0.037628174, -0.05203247, 0.010803223, -0.03955078, 0.028717041, -0.006958008, 0.0289917, 0.04119873, -0.012649536, 0.039398193, 0.0014867783, -0.016601562, 0.03289795, 0.0040512085, -0.017196655, 0.010238647, 0.022277832, 0.0098724365, 0.008674622, -0.0051345825, 0.021896362, -0.008148193, -0.0016908646, -0.030548096, 0.039031982, -0.0067481995, 0.064941406, 0.0085372925, 0.04776001, -0.025863647, -0.026489258, -0.030441284, 0.0061912537, -0.006111145, -0.030380249, 0.013969421, -0.04260254, 0.017868042, 0.002916336, 0.03012085, -0.06756592, -0.023590088, 0.06488037, -0.010223389, 0.03378296, 0.019226074, -0.058532715, -0.008979797, 0.01687622, 0.01876831, -0.048461914, -0.021072388, -0.07574463, -0.01071167, 0.018325806, -0.034820557, -0.009338379, -0.024551392, 0.011497498, -0.033599854, 0.04421997, 0.00013446808, 0.0044555664, -0.021087646, -0.012580872, 0.008399963, -0.006580353, 0.03149414, -0.033416748, 0.0066566467, -0.032104492, 0.026733398, 0.014450073, -0.02798462, -0.038330078, 0.02609253, 0.011695862, -0.020233154, 0.012207031, -0.035095215, -0.051727295, -0.0038700104, 0.050079346, -0.019439697, 0.0051193237, 0.0041923523, -0.0041236877, -0.01071167, 0.032684326, -0.013427734, -0.026504517, 0.011291504, -0.004714966, -0.0020751953, 0.0026073456, 0.017593384, -0.0033473969, 0.012763977, 0.028274536, -0.07421875, -0.034118652, -0.04901123, 0.021636963, -0.0005507469, 0.0075645447, -0.020217896, 0.0048828125, 0.03744507, -0.003917694, 0.028289795, 0.0209198, -0.021133423, 0.015975952, 0.034484863, -0.01638794, -0.028442383, -0.041503906, -0.014335632, -0.009559631, -0.00055122375, -0.025512695, 0.01979065, -0.055908203, -0.035247803, -0.008262634, 0.048797607, -0.006084442, 0.023666382, 0.0004169941, 0.007209778, 0.05593872, 0.0037670135, 0.010025024, 0.016784668, -0.009849548, 0.024856567, -0.030456543, -0.009292603, 0.011650085, 0.06677246, 0.027648926, -0.004055023, 0.021713257, -0.022644043, 0.013397217, 0.040740967, -0.03466797, 0.0032978058, -0.022659302, 0.05050659, 0.012687683, -0.014053345, -0.03250122, 0.017211914, 0.06732178, 0.031433105, 0.03250122, -0.03274536, -0.039886475, 0.020599365, -0.0181427, -0.022598267, -0.02609253, 0.013801575, 0.02027893, -0.0107040405, -0.0048980713, 0.07409668, 0.034484863, -0.030654907, -0.06378174, -0.10559082, -0.011428833, -0.017868042, 0.04574585, -0.03363037, 0.03137207, 0.0418396, 0.01386261, -0.044708252, 0.026367188, 0.022445679, -0.012649536, 0.008293152, -0.0112838745, 0.016937256, -0.007297516, 0.043762207, -0.016311646, 0.0021781921, 0.046295166, -0.056915283, 0.016418457, 0.004749298, 0.055145264, 0.016830444, 0.030639648, 0.09851074, -0.07940674, 0.020706177, 0.060302734, 0.014755249, -0.003873825, 0.03857422, -0.06652832, 0.04800415, 0.014175415, 0.002620697, 0.01701355, -0.045928955, 0.0135650635, -0.00919342, 0.00047445297, 0.018066406, -0.016204834, -0.009307861, 0.040161133, 0.046783447, -0.0058555603, -0.004699707, -0.050842285, 0.001698494, 0.026260376, 0.0074310303, -0.079956055, 0.003353119, -0.014282227, 0.05065918, -0.03060913, -0.07299805, 0.009567261, -0.049957275, 0.0059814453, -0.0340271, -0.02885437, 0.009422302, -0.0027542114, 0.009895325, -0.046569824, 0.012756348, 0.0011091232, -0.03479004, -0.029815674, -0.013641357, 0.03225708, 0.02671814, -0.024978638, 0.00006514788, 0.021331787, 0.019882202, -0.013809204, 0.025314331, 0.022964478, 0.017669678, -0.008087158, -0.0062561035, 0.04360962, 0.024475098, 0.065979004, 0.01424408, 0.016189575, 0.018478394, 0.030349731, 0.042175293, 0.013748169, -0.0042037964, 0.0037937164, 0.010398865, 0.04244995, -0.023727417, 0.022033691, 0.021896362, -0.046417236, -0.014297485, 0.0021591187, -0.004432678, -0.016281128, -0.02772522, 0.081726074, 0.020568848, 0.058898926, -0.04751587, -0.027770996, -0.003736496, 0.028381348, 0.016021729, 0.0552063, 0.09423828, -0.072753906, 0.03729248, 0.019515991, -0.048309326, -0.061187744, 0.078552246, -0.0181427, 0.03475952, 0.02305603, 0.030426025, 0.032592773, -0.030136108, 0.010429382, 0.005432129, 0.0036354065, 0.015182495, -0.07043457, 0.0034446716, 0.049468994, 0.064086914, 0.039794922, 0.012199402, -0.0015392303, -0.05255127, -0.052093506, 0.0524292, -0.032592773, 0.035827637, 0.023986816, 0.0124053955, 0.032104492, -0.0050582886, 0.03326416, 0.025390625, -0.05633545, -0.028045654, 0.034942627, -0.009017944, -0.016967773, 0.03048706, 0.008926392, 0.0009112358, -0.1038208, -0.011917114, -0.01158905, -0.03527832, -0.040802002, 0.002128601, 0.004486084, 0.0025081635, -0.004600525, -0.025039673, -0.018478394, -0.004673004, 0.00970459, 0.0814209, -0.007255554, -0.032287598, 0.031402588, 0.008346558, 0.01574707, -0.00014853477, 0.00049448013, 0.056427002, 0.015640259, 0.04373169, 0.033172607, 0.05203247, -0.009094238, 0.016403198, -0.003967285, -0.04928589, -0.010025024, 0.056915283, 0.028625488, -0.035827637, -0.011657715, -0.06555176, -0.030380249, 0.079711914, 0.017486572, 0.0066833496, 0.040039062, -0.037139893, 0.05343628, 0.03817749, 0.010147095, 0.031799316, -0.037353516, 0.029510498, -0.008399963, 0.03427124, -0.028823853, 0.0010709763, -0.044952393, -0.029891968, 0.01360321, -0.014038086, -0.011169434, -0.011756897, 0.024551392, -0.0085372925, 0.01071167, 0.013832092, 0.095214844, -0.02947998, 0.011276245, -0.02368164, -0.022720337, 0.011772156, -0.019454956, -0.023483276, -0.005783081, -0.00004416704, 0.08465576, 0.0051574707, 0.0057258606, 0.01361084, -0.040893555, -0.024795532, -0.013725281, 0.0062332153, 0.002368927, 0.018844604, -0.018005371, -0.014877319, 0.00083494186, 0.0031814575, 0.019226074, -0.032562256, 0.008857727, -0.013839722, 0.028335571, -0.029876709, 0.0018987656, -0.001581192, 0.04714966, 0.01940918, -0.062286377, 0.014511108, -0.04812622, -0.033050537, 0.016296387, 0.059265137, 0.02470398, -0.041900635, 0.025558472, -0.014259338, 0.017028809, 0.042266846, -0.07159424, -0.012687683, -0.020492554, -0.010620117, -0.03173828, 0.012329102, -0.0048599243, 0.05456543, -0.008102417, -0.0435791, 0.019058228, -0.051849365, -0.025177002, 0.010429382, 0.0021305084, -0.02255249, -0.0087890625, 0.009185791, -0.007949829, -0.032592773, -0.0027866364, 0.03955078, -0.037719727, 0.0068969727, -0.0042152405, -0.035491943, 0.047698975, -0.029907227, -0.08062744, 0.059051514, -0.0158844, 0.03543091, 0.043304443, -0.00015115738, 0.018447876, 0.040771484, 0.014854431, 0.021530151, -0.02355957, 0.051940918, -0.026123047, -0.030059814, -0.014129639, 0.0014543533, -0.010910034, 0.0748291, -0.04776001, 0.054229736, -0.00011610985, 0.00088119507, 0.021011353, 0.021224976, 0.01928711, -0.020309448, 0.0055618286, 0.0030994415, 0.017364502, 0.014755249, 0.031921387, 0.016052246, 0.029968262, 0.0078125, -0.0109939575, -0.0002849102, -0.070251465, -0.037841797, -0.010368347, 0.04486084, 0.050933838, -0.039154053, -0.008628845, 0.019546509, 0.090270996, -0.009284973, 0.018600464, -0.0052490234, 0.017166138, 0.028686523, 0.004814148, -0.0050239563, 0.0022773743, 0.016281128, -0.029144287, -0.019546509, -0.027786255, -0.013206482, -0.004787445, 0.0057907104, 0.03982544, 0.014411926, -0.008613586, -0.0054359436, 0.013214111, 0.029220581, 0.01966858, -0.046875, -0.09820557, -0.015129089, -0.008544922, -0.020217896, -0.02003479, -0.06298828, -0.05392456, -0.017654419, 0.0018835068, -0.015266418, 0.014656067, 0.016098022, 0.04748535, 0.021942139, 0.003364563, -0.05050659, -0.017318726, -0.030960083, 0.026290894, -0.008003235, 0.006198883, -0.007904053, 0.007675171, 0.0079422, -0.014373779, 0.0126571655, -0.024749756, -0.034332275, 0.002904892, -0.011756897, -0.02760315, 0.009117126, -0.012611389, 0.024032593, -0.010414124, 0.0016813278, -0.010681152, 0.026367188, -0.035247803, -0.015945435, 0.049316406, 0.012397766, 0.058654785, -0.024917603, -0.013267517, 0.0027046204, 0.0032749176, 0.023849487, 0.020187378, -0.008483887, 0.008834839, -0.014793396, -0.02053833, 0.0031337738, -0.019897461, -0.0076828003, -0.007835388, -0.011695862, 0.006877899, 0.016174316, 0.03744507, -0.0011196136, -0.01979065, 0.035003662, -0.021362305, -0.017410278, -0.04537964, -0.008140564, 0.05105591, -0.020401001, -0.046844482, -0.058380127, -0.028762817, 0.02166748, -0.008384705, -0.0014486313, -0.059417725, -0.020324707, -0.034332275, -0.03665161, 0.0066108704, -0.007888794, -0.015670776, -0.02619934, 0.020462036, -0.0048980713, -0.009666443, 0.035858154, 0.0062408447, -0.013549805, -0.011100769, 0.026977539, -0.022994995, -0.022140503, 0.022155762, -0.0335083, 0.0181427, 0.020980835, -0.016067505, -0.011276245, 0.017211914, -0.0064353943, -0.03189087, -0.008598328, -0.036193848, 0.0004556179, -0.0026512146, 0.03640747, 0.03817749, 0.014602661, 0.018310547, 0.004776001, -0.02670288, 0.0016098022, -0.00843811, -0.012886047, 0.0024337769, -0.011711121, 0.02053833, 0.020370483, 0.0016126633, -0.0073890686, -0.028427124, -0.0011224747, 0.0048980713, -0.028381348, -0.0362854, -0.015808105, -0.028244019, -0.06640625, 0.039611816, 0.036102295, -0.0055007935, -0.027542114, 0.04675293, -0.010047913, 0.013175964, 0.020019531, -0.035339355, -0.0013723373, -0.018798828, 0.026763916, 0.00017595291, -0.011352539, 0.033355713, -0.0032024384, -0.010848999, 0.02017212, -0.015289307, -0.0017280579, 0.021514893, 0.006160736, 0.0042686462, -0.007446289, 0.020202637, 0.021118164, -0.05657959, 0.009773254, -0.022415161, -0.0045280457, 0.011047363, -0.029586792, -0.0146102905, 0.024902344, -0.0062026978, -0.0044136047, 0.002298355, 0.012046814, -0.078430176, 0.016357422, 0.013473511, 0.04748535, -0.046142578, -0.013870239, -0.01398468, 0.036743164, 0.015029907, -0.011810303, 0.02545166, 0.003501892, 0.009498596, 0.0040016174, -0.008842468, 0.029174805, -0.012504578, -0.0051879883, 0.013267517, 0.01727295, 0.0033874512, 0.03994751, 0.026504517, 0.008918762, -0.027267456, -0.019470215, 0.010345459, 0.00094127655, 0.00623703, 0.003145218, 0.03665161, 0.061309814, 0.01940918, 0.011566162, -0.0057296753, -0.04043579, 0.03161621, -0.018417358, -0.04537964, 0.018707275, 0.015617371, -0.01687622, 0.026107788, 0.0031337738, 0.02104187, -0.045562744, 0.050201416, -0.013931274, 0.009552002, -0.0149383545, 0.0057640076, 0.037322998, 0.0013217926, -0.033172607, -0.0052337646, 0.043945312, 0.042114258, 0.028411865, -0.033813477, 0.0034046173, -0.026611328, -0.030029297, 0.0034599304, -0.042816162, -0.02722168, 0.01902771, -0.020233154, -0.029388428, -0.06903076, -0.038604736, -0.02079773, 0.04626465, -0.051086426, -0.049041748, 0.06323242, -0.014175415, 0.009513855, 0.015098572, -0.04525757, 0.019699097, -0.039215088, -0.0030403137, -0.006702423, 0.037322998, -0.052947998, 0.0062446594, 0.055145264, -0.004776001, -0.0068893433, -0.022018433, 0.03479004, 0.002986908, -0.040374756, -0.032928467, -0.09082031, 0.019180298, -0.059570312, 0.0046463013, 0.01007843, 0.037872314, 0.04425049, -0.023284912, -0.0071868896, -0.01197052, 0.02217102, 0.0076904297, 0.016281128, -0.011291504, 0.01259613, -0.033233643, 0.014511108, 0.03668213, -0.026382446, 0.005519867, 0.056854248, 0.020263672, 0.009933472, -0.008056641, 0.021469116, 0.011566162, 0.03353882, -0.026321411, -0.049743652, -0.02670288, 0.0020122528, 0.010871887, -0.011138916, 0.00044226646, 0.009140015, 0.035186768, 0.026428223, 0.0423584, 0.00944519, -0.00034499168, 0.0082473755, 0.035125732, -0.022003174, 0.008346558, -0.011947632, -0.016143799, 0.023452759, 0.017456055, -0.008705139, 0.018936157, 0.05230713, 0.06463623, 0.046051025, 0.051483154, -0.017105103, 0.012878418, 0.055786133, -0.0064926147, 0.0066490173, -0.0043640137, -0.008026123, -0.05682373, -0.009597778, 0.00868988, -0.03463745, -0.01473999, 0.031082153, -0.045806885, -0.016799927, -0.055358887, 0.01737976, -0.049682617, -0.003709793, -0.002746582, -0.05987549, -0.07299805, 0.016220093, 0.023330688, -0.017471313, 0.0057258606, -0.020950317, -0.03894043, -0.008155823, 0.014984131, 0.037963867, -0.017318726, -0.017318726, 0.04663086, 0.01777649, 0.09649658, 0.013473511, -0.032562256, 0.0022716522, 0.042510986, 0.015670776, -0.016738892, -0.04034424, 0.04977417, 0.06173706, -0.01965332, 0.0061531067, 0.019119263, -0.013595581, -0.07635498, 0.011604309, -0.017349243, -0.04498291, 0.041015625, 0.07141113, -0.0134887695, -0.07501221, 0.006061554, -0.036224365, 0.05722046, -0.043914795, -0.003932953, -0.006011963, 0.051116943, -0.032714844, 0.0025463104, -0.010795593, -0.0037975311, 0.00712204, -0.018753052, -0.011749268, 0.0024089813, 0.016052246, -0.03491211, -0.04385376, 0.01474762, 0.026290894, -0.004676819, -0.003440857, 0.013420105, 0.010414124, 0.009941101, 0.03466797, -0.002445221, -0.016784668, 0.05316162, 0.030395508, 0.03741455, 0.0023288727, -0.03778076, 0.04660034, -0.0140686035, -0.07574463, -0.027175903, 0.0071792603, -0.00091171265, -0.041992188, 0.026107788, -0.0049705505, -0.03149414, -0.041168213, -0.039031982, 0.053100586, -0.033081055, -0.029724121, 0.0033988953, 0.022506714, -0.003786087, 0.00029110909, -0.042633057, -0.057556152, 0.0143585205, 0.013206482, 0.0023498535, -0.0043525696, 0.02722168, -0.0015592575, 0.0027599335, -0.026550293, 0.005290985, 0.01574707, 0.019760132, -0.049224854, 0.0052719116, -0.11987305, -0.018859863, -0.07672119, -0.04827881, 0.015579224, -0.01637268, 0.020721436, 0.020950317, -0.01737976, 0.0126571655, -0.0036315918, -0.041534424, 0.011695862, -0.01828003, -0.02281189, -0.015716553, 0.010803223 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07006v1
Context-dependent Instruction Tuning for Dialogue Response Generation
Jin Myung Kwak, Minseon Kim, Sung Ju Hwang
cs.CL, cs.AI
Recent language models have achieved impressive performance in natural language tasks by incorporating instructions with task input during fine-tuning. Since all samples in the same natural language task can be explained with the same task instructions, many instruction datasets only provide a few instructions for the entire task, without considering the input of each example in the task. However, this approach becomes ineffective in complex multi-turn dialogue generation tasks, where the input varies highly with each turn as the dialogue context changes, so that simple task instructions cannot improve the generation performance. To address this limitation, we introduce a context-based instruction fine-tuning framework for each multi-turn dialogue which generates both responses and instructions based on the previous context as input. During the evaluation, the model generates instructions based on the previous context to self-guide the response. The proposed framework produces comparable or even outstanding results compared to the baselines by aligning instructions to the input during fine-tuning with the instructions in quantitative evaluations on dialogue benchmark datasets with reduced computation budget.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07006v1
2023-11-13T01:25:30
2023-11-13T01:25:30
{ "title": [ -0.03302002, -0.026397705, -0.027786255, -0.054534912, -0.020339966, 0.0036144257, -0.05014038, 0.016937256, -0.014099121, 0.025421143, -0.005874634, 0.011245728, -0.03692627, -0.018066406, -0.042022705, -0.015365601, -0.007507324, 0.03475952, -0.033111572, -0.04623413, 0.0014276505, -0.062164307, -0.01939392, 0.052215576, 0.022338867, -0.041900635, -0.0592041, 0.029251099, -0.022888184, -0.005378723, -0.015731812, -0.012123108, 0.050231934, 0.022857666, -0.03567505, 0.0028705597, -0.03515625, 0.010505676, -0.017028809, 0.035858154, 0.024978638, -0.01374054, -0.038269043, -0.03564453, -0.032470703, 0.014328003, -0.012046814, -0.012207031, -0.003993988, 0.014831543, 0.0033893585, 0.042633057, 0.002664566, -0.01335144, 0.009132385, -0.027160645, -0.039398193, -0.0049819946, 0.036071777, 0.054656982, 0.03338623, -0.04852295, 0.009651184, -0.013793945, -0.011756897, -0.025558472, -0.024475098, 0.01235199, 0.060791016, 0.02357483, -0.001127243, 0.005504608, 0.0022392273, -0.033416748, -0.030548096, 0.04748535, -0.0043525696, 0.009941101, 0.042266846, -0.04373169, 0.00036931038, 0.02041626, 0.025482178, -0.040496826, 0.015655518, -0.052642822, -0.011199951, -0.01525116, -0.059326172, -0.079711914, -0.020111084, -0.013221741, -0.028747559, -0.0345459, -0.05392456, -0.029876709, -0.020385742, -0.020309448, -0.0026950836, -0.019439697, 0.0059280396, 0.00894928, -0.004108429, -0.01977539, 0.023620605, 0.028396606, -0.011184692, -0.014144897, 0.012428284, 0.020980835, -0.026107788, 0.040893555, 0.014160156, 0.018951416, -0.022537231, -0.022888184, -0.031188965, 0.009262085, -0.002779007, 0.0126953125, -0.033569336, -0.037109375, 0.06567383, -0.008529663, 0.041381836, 0.037750244, -0.031234741, -0.030303955, 0.012039185, 0.028442383, 0.018600464, 0.028320312, -0.05770874, -0.057739258, -0.04989624, 0.045440674, 0.01020813, -0.02444458, -0.039245605, 0.029464722, 0.0068626404, -0.021438599, 0.007686615, -0.036621094, 0.011016846, 0.024658203, 0.055145264, -0.008232117, -0.045898438, -0.03829956, -0.018707275, 0.017166138, 0.0045051575, 0.008369446, -0.025848389, -0.0048446655, -0.097717285, -0.010955811, 0.040252686, 0.00969696, -0.0041122437, 0.010185242, 0.02331543, -0.0021572113, 0.036224365, -0.0074882507, -0.00554657, 0.014892578, 0.02583313, 0.06744385, -0.009849548, 0.046417236, -0.0052833557, 0.0105896, -0.0010089874, -0.008865356, 0.009994507, -0.02217102, 0.02255249, -0.0030517578, 0.016143799, -0.019989014, -0.018096924, 0.0440979, -0.06726074, 0.0038032532, 0.0061683655, 0.014434814, 0.022613525, 0.00868988, -0.009422302, 0.045684814, -0.048431396, -0.05609131, -0.044036865, 0.004535675, -0.0010347366, 0.019592285, -0.009300232, 0.04043579, -0.006855011, 0.0058059692, -0.02293396, -0.012161255, -0.037872314, -0.029678345, -0.017852783, 0.021636963, 0.011543274, 0.041046143, 0.034240723, 0.009407043, -0.032714844, 0.031921387, -0.029830933, -0.037963867, 0.033172607, 0.02319336, 0.023284912, 0.0043792725, 0.01763916, -0.015808105, 0.01977539, 0.034362793, 0.042541504, -0.006462097, 0.0032310486, -0.02949524, 0.0619812, 0.02268982, 0.029327393, -0.03869629, 0.03741455, 0.018630981, -0.0154953, 0.0020694733, -0.003124237, -0.007255554, -0.008079529, 0.0057868958, -0.0029067993, 0.00070238113, -0.02305603, 0.013908386, 0.034698486, -0.012817383, 0.0068893433, 0.002588272, 0.011833191, -0.0053100586, 0.052368164, -0.013549805, 0.061279297, 0.010025024, 0.014129639, 0.042419434, -0.012771606, 0.0030517578, 0.010635376, -0.023010254, 0.01235199, -0.0074386597, -0.0037784576, 0.0008072853, -0.062927246, 0.0032691956, -0.04647827, -0.009765625, 0.006023407, 0.0023822784, 0.030349731, -0.028701782, 0.010383606, -0.04309082, -0.012802124, -0.0110321045, -0.020843506, 0.04071045, 0.0289917, -0.07946777, -0.015914917, -0.0054397583, 0.024291992, -0.005836487, 0.031173706, 0.020263672, 0.02029419, -0.028930664, -0.0118255615, -0.018295288, 0.04309082, 0.014549255, -0.006351471, 0.010322571, -0.006008148, -0.017410278, 0.0904541, 0.043304443, -0.016738892, 0.033721924, -0.0051116943, 0.03338623, 0.026809692, -0.01158905, -0.00036406517, -0.008964539, 0.009933472, 0.017242432, -0.008026123, 0.004508972, 0.00116539, 0.064819336, 0.00028586388, -0.03729248, -0.027801514, -0.047851562, 0.013206482, -0.030670166, -0.06390381, -0.018707275, 0.11987305, -0.03353882, -0.019302368, -0.018463135, -0.013504028, -0.03479004, -0.007637024, -0.038238525, 0.010551453, 0.023529053, 0.027755737, 0.03869629, -0.053375244, -0.006034851, -0.003124237, 0.008560181, -0.004547119, 0.017089844, -0.009208679, -0.012687683, 0.006275177, -0.023452759, 0.0034618378, -0.009841919, -0.0079956055, -0.039276123, 0.013206482, -0.0030727386, 0.015472412, 0.02166748, -0.00097084045, -0.015434265, -0.023513794, 0.05505371, 0.061279297, 0.0028915405, -0.00831604, 0.076538086, 0.026229858, 0.0043678284, 0.057495117, 0.022720337, 0.021652222, -0.060028076, -0.02355957, -0.055664062, -0.027938843, -0.009422302, 0.0052757263, 0.046539307, 0.0031032562, -0.008392334, -0.03668213, -0.023040771, -0.0061302185, -0.019042969, 0.017974854, -0.02015686, -0.041503906, -0.015655518, -0.008872986, 0.02104187, -0.0440979, 0.015434265, 0.09259033, 0.006340027, -0.0036258698, 0.008735657, 0.032714844, 0.013534546, 0.00065374374, -0.033355713, -0.029083252, 0.0055274963, 0.047790527, 0.004295349, -0.026504517, -0.0140686035, -0.12164307, -0.009712219, 0.049468994, 0.010215759, -0.02458191, 0.02796936, -0.0625, 0.0151901245, 0.00077199936, -0.027114868, 0.03427124, 0.013908386, -0.0050735474, -0.007270813, -0.0059051514, -0.039093018, -0.003929138, -0.02848816, -0.10095215, 0.015037537, -0.016555786, -0.02406311, -0.005836487, -0.040222168, -0.04525757, 0.0014429092, 0.0077590942, 0.05441284, 0.03086853, 0.009681702, 0.021118164, -0.05105591, 0.00046753883, -0.042755127, -0.028778076, 0.018127441, 0.0146865845, 0.07446289, 0.002866745, 0.014572144, 0.03250122, -0.016143799, -0.05142212, -0.0037021637, -0.052581787, -0.015625, -0.008644104, -0.048736572, -0.0068206787, -0.033996582, -0.05117798, -0.041381836, -0.026321411, 0.005695343, -0.058410645, 0.022277832, 0.006210327, 0.111328125, -0.0064735413, 0.023254395, 0.011199951, -0.029052734, 0.027709961, -0.032562256, -0.065979004, 0.026992798, 0.04559326, -0.0013370514, 0.02053833, -0.019714355, -0.025009155, 0.026885986, -0.01499939, -0.016708374, 0.0024051666, -0.005493164, -0.0021476746, -0.02609253, 0.0026283264, 0.0053634644, -0.0037345886, -0.00932312, -0.004360199, 0.0035362244, 0.005088806, -0.060424805, -0.02279663, 0.00869751, -0.09118652, -0.0029029846, -0.0021591187, -0.007751465, -0.039855957, -0.016845703, 0.018295288, -0.01461792, -0.032928467, 0.024902344, -0.007133484, -0.050811768, -0.012191772, -0.06390381, -0.05368042, 0.0927124, 0.018188477, 0.0039596558, 0.04827881, -0.045135498, -0.039093018, -0.008880615, 0.048339844, 0.018981934, 0.033050537, 0.039001465, -0.002544403, 0.037628174, -0.025924683, 0.030227661, 0.046844482, -0.008422852, 0.02507019, 0.0009150505, 0.004398346, 0.01838684, -0.021209717, 0.04827881, 0.00484848, -0.003293991, -0.07147217, 0.03579712, 0.0068969727, -0.009529114, -0.0039482117, -0.034606934, -0.0072135925, 0.0027122498, 0.018707275, 0.049194336, -0.018188477, 0.02758789, 0.048797607, -0.01423645, -0.014419556, 0.01335907, 0.033569336, 0.018417358, -0.007484436, 0.01600647, -0.023849487, 0.03527832, 0.020523071, -0.026947021, 0.0146865845, 0.018661499, -0.06439209, -0.020767212, -0.053649902, -0.028076172, -0.013153076, 0.027420044, -0.030807495, 0.030776978, 0.043701172, -0.012748718, -0.020431519, 0.012893677, 0.062469482, -0.02583313, 0.017990112, -0.062805176, -0.028869629, 0.008354187, -0.06628418, -0.023330688, -0.06842041, -0.04522705, -0.0025310516, -0.00642395, -0.024124146, 0.018234253, 0.031951904, 0.0574646, 0.048614502, -0.008369446, -0.048095703, 0.033813477, -0.023529053, -0.04763794, 0.022781372, 0.0016803741, -0.011306763, -0.02368164, 0.029830933, -0.022644043, -0.0090789795, 0.004737854, 0.05795288, -0.029953003, 0.0713501, -0.05618286, 0.018081665, 0.01751709, 0.02708435, 0.03012085, 0.017227173, -0.03366089, -0.006137848, -0.008544922, 0.05908203, -0.019760132, -0.011810303, -0.0028800964, 0.02973938, 0.034973145, -0.012290955, -0.013076782, -0.01361084, 0.021713257, -0.0078125, 0.032287598, 0.009460449, -0.024658203, 0.018814087, 0.010681152, 0.02772522, -0.020874023, 0.051879883, -0.0070343018, 0.017303467, 0.03479004, 0.00027155876, 0.02053833, -0.01739502, 0.0008420944, -0.038360596, -0.012321472, 0.019699097, -0.010009766, -0.0256958, 0.001127243, -0.0066452026, 0.00037765503, 0.016799927, 0.062561035, 0.023223877, 0.013809204, 0.010856628, 0.020996094, 0.018554688, -0.031188965, -0.04949951, -0.011100769, 0.015464783, 0.016860962, -0.017929077, 0.057128906, -0.058654785, 0.007194519, 0.0023422241, -0.035308838, 0.018508911, -0.082458496, 0.03277588, 0.042022705, -0.02319336, 0.022277832, 0.0020885468, 0.021621704, 0.0065193176, 0.066101074, -0.010536194, 0.014381409, 0.043273926, -0.042175293, 0.008224487, -0.011978149, 0.014511108, 0.014320374, 0.029663086, 0.019729614, 0.043823242, -0.06036377, 0.009307861, 0.013343811, 0.002714157, -0.005306244, -0.038024902, 0.02822876, 0.034088135, -0.0059432983, 0.01789856, -0.030822754, -0.037475586, -0.04473877, -0.02709961, -0.085998535, 0.0007133484, -0.05050659, -0.031402588, -0.03778076, -0.009971619, -0.04135132, 0.009803772, 0.0022945404, -0.0010061264, -0.026138306, 0.021591187, 0.04937744, -0.02482605, 0.0262146, -0.007797241, -0.006690979, 0.05343628, 0.051605225, -0.046203613, -0.008010864, 0.011779785, -0.037139893, -0.027297974, 0.007534027, 0.0023860931, -0.0019721985, -0.011405945, -0.0064201355, -0.008300781, 0.009773254, 0.03363037, -0.008964539, -0.04977417, 0.01991272, -0.006717682, -0.0038890839, 0.01222229, 0.017959595, -0.008491516, 0.015052795, 0.0072250366, -0.012245178, 0.0067100525, 0.018997192, 0.03491211, -0.03555298, -0.091674805, 0.0037117004, 0.02293396, -0.002981186, -0.030639648, 0.031463623, 0.023864746, -0.009391785, -0.009643555, -0.005039215, 0.035003662, -0.026687622, -0.016601562, -0.008552551, -0.010894775, -0.026412964, 0.0513916, -0.0074272156, -0.018661499, -0.04647827, -0.034210205, -0.03164673, 0.012397766, 0.023956299, -0.010246277, 0.011024475, -0.016937256, 0.003709793, -0.0035800934, 0.0008034706, -0.04864502, 0.012069702, 0.0045280457, -0.018981934, 0.025985718, 0.01864624, 0.025161743, -0.010009766, 0.03253174, 0.010322571, -0.02885437, 0.034851074, -0.07366943, 0.008575439, -0.0135650635, -0.046295166, 0.01751709, 0.0070610046, -0.0059051514, 0.057373047, -0.032684326, 0.04244995, 0.006099701, 0.06890869, 0.05126953, 0.018310547, 0.015556335, 0.01436615, 0.02293396, -0.03213501, 0.025787354, -0.044769287, 0.015335083, -0.027877808, -0.006324768, -0.09753418, -0.003967285, 0.039489746, 0.042938232, -0.0060691833, 0.016723633, -0.004497528, -0.009651184, 0.0357666, -0.0006890297, 0.06414795, 0.012489319, 0.0014677048, 0.017715454, -0.04360962, 0.024734497, 0.040618896, -0.012718201, 0.0004775524, -0.040649414, -0.030654907, 0.017730713, 0.0082092285, 0.015403748, -0.012512207, -0.036499023, -0.04336548, 0.026519775, 0.009498596, 0.015090942, 0.03652954, 0.031951904, -0.008178711, 0.013061523, 0.01058197, -0.023391724, -0.0184021, -0.01902771, 0.026031494, -0.05166626, 0.022018433, -0.011199951, -0.018478394, -0.032562256, 0.07244873, 0.01473999, -0.014335632, 0.03878784, 0.014427185, 0.020462036, -0.014152527, 0.012954712, -0.041015625, -0.04586792, -0.009819031, 0.038909912, -0.013771057, 0.061309814, 0.037506104, 0.0046844482, 0.0071258545, 0.006412506, -0.0016450882, 0.046966553, 0.00024533272, 0.03515625, -0.039733887, 0.0025367737, -0.012207031, -0.0284729, -0.018096924, 0.021133423, -0.040130615, -0.014457703, 0.015960693, 0.052215576, 0.031036377, 0.07733154, 0.00005507469, 0.0073013306, -0.0028972626, -0.011955261, 0.059783936, 0.0236969, -0.025314331, 0.010307312, -0.0418396, -0.051696777, 0.018081665, -0.0345459, 0.08325195, -0.037475586, 0.008674622, -0.009925842, -0.021057129, 0.049438477, -0.026794434, -0.028915405, -0.002670288, -0.020202637, 0.00018572807, 0.013465881, -0.024337769, -0.0362854, -0.008125305, 0.038146973, 0.013435364, 0.013954163, 0.023513794, -0.020217896, -0.0869751, 0.04046631, -0.043640137, 0.07196045, -0.040100098, -0.0069465637, 0.012390137, 0.0027923584, -0.0035934448, -0.057861328, -0.042419434, 0.006149292, 0.00894928, -0.017959595, 0.007926941, 0.04397583, 0.0010519028, 0.007221222, -0.015556335, 0.011962891, -0.019119263, 0.016647339, 0.03656006, -0.016784668, -0.057647705, -0.023361206, -0.019058228, 0.03137207, -0.002998352, -0.02104187, 0.030639648, 0.022583008, -0.040802002, -0.0052948, -0.0025730133, 0.026916504, 0.012702942, -0.062683105, 0.028274536, -0.0021781921, 0.0107040405, -0.05319214, -0.064575195, 0.021240234, 0.063964844, -0.021606445, 0.032165527, 0.043945312, 0.009437561, 0.026672363, -0.0069236755, -0.011230469, -0.037261963, 0.0234375, 0.014518738, 0.043640137, 0.033416748, -0.011779785, -0.0031223297, -0.0053749084, -0.016403198, 0.0031528473, 0.0022335052, -0.016098022, -0.0016317368, -0.008384705, 0.010124207, -0.02748108, 0.02017212, -0.109436035, 0.012413025, 0.009841919, 0.046142578, -0.008354187, 0.047546387, 0.014884949, 0.08343506, -0.039276123, -0.01966858, -0.014595032, 0.019897461, -0.008926392, 0.06072998, -0.030532837, -0.015335083, -0.0040397644, -0.0028820038, -0.00043821335, 0.0047683716, 0.024810791, -0.039489746, -0.0062561035, -0.07098389, -0.041015625, -0.021484375, -0.022232056, 0.0107040405, 0.0030059814, 0.001663208, 0.029190063, -0.018753052, 0.0030612946, 0.02607727, 0.03640747, -0.009712219, -0.04083252, 0.008491516, 0.047576904, -0.028411865 ], "summary": [ 0.019088745, -0.04208374, -0.016784668, -0.05117798, -0.04928589, 0.0014619827, -0.065979004, 0.027130127, 0.009155273, 0.05718994, -0.036254883, 0.013046265, 0.009422302, 0.011161804, -0.03353882, -0.022277832, -0.013397217, 0.018447876, -0.03439331, -0.050689697, 0.033691406, -0.07861328, -0.036621094, 0.06866455, 0.006500244, -0.06530762, -0.010467529, 0.02482605, 0.01713562, 0.036590576, 0.0018119812, -0.018753052, 0.0099487305, 0.0126571655, -0.007217407, -0.018600464, -0.016021729, 0.00995636, 0.003692627, 0.032073975, 0.04449463, -0.01247406, 0.026657104, -0.029342651, -0.030532837, 0.025909424, 0.033813477, -0.008323669, 0.028137207, 0.015701294, -0.0038318634, -0.007194519, -0.013092041, -0.005092621, -0.038635254, -0.04058838, -0.059051514, -0.018051147, 0.005420685, 0.067871094, 0.03665161, -0.022750854, 0.00025868416, -0.035247803, 0.008934021, 0.015670776, 0.0006699562, -0.025680542, 0.034240723, 0.003129959, 0.0039405823, -0.007621765, 0.0026130676, -0.08508301, -0.0020179749, 0.07183838, -0.0037651062, -0.00014746189, 0.0052375793, -0.05596924, -0.04067993, 0.032592773, 0.02458191, -0.045074463, -0.034576416, -0.071777344, -0.029891968, 0.015197754, -0.058288574, -0.01637268, -0.03250122, -0.02583313, -0.051116943, -0.006866455, -0.00008511543, -0.021575928, 0.012702942, -0.039733887, -0.0015325546, -0.02494812, 0.05493164, -0.03982544, 0.032226562, -0.008575439, -0.0024967194, 0.019058228, 0.036621094, 0.03475952, 0.007129669, -0.005104065, -0.033172607, 0.03955078, -0.0050354004, -0.047302246, -0.012329102, -0.0013523102, -0.005428314, 0.004634857, 0.0068244934, -0.016021729, -0.044036865, -0.008430481, 0.062469482, 0.03427124, 0.0074768066, 0.066589355, 0.0058250427, -0.048217773, 0.05645752, 0.012878418, -0.017654419, 0.0154800415, 0.021499634, -0.01763916, -0.02670288, -0.0018539429, 0.028121948, 0.011146545, -0.035186768, 0.014190674, -0.0096206665, -0.0057373047, 0.0003657341, -0.023895264, -0.0018854141, 0.025817871, 0.02734375, -0.008636475, -0.038085938, -0.032470703, 0.0149002075, -0.0041389465, 0.01979065, -0.035125732, 0.011245728, -0.089782715, -0.06048584, -0.01423645, 0.06359863, 0.00034189224, -0.02130127, 0.014221191, 0.05822754, -0.008415222, -0.016540527, -0.013435364, -0.010505676, -0.02809143, 0.011375427, 0.016616821, -0.022460938, 0.03475952, -0.008399963, -0.010475159, -0.0061683655, -0.024612427, 0.000667572, -0.010635376, -0.0005426407, 0.024978638, 0.00982666, -0.027999878, 0.00045919418, 0.017166138, -0.014213562, 0.01991272, -0.022735596, 0.013420105, 0.041778564, -0.0010290146, -0.037719727, 0.005355835, -0.035125732, -0.023025513, -0.039916992, 0.019836426, -0.044647217, 0.03656006, -0.037353516, 0.032073975, 0.063964844, 0.01902771, -0.02961731, -0.01838684, -0.11291504, 0.016433716, -0.035095215, 0.034210205, 0.0146102905, 0.003124237, 0.028778076, 0.0143966675, -0.03390503, 0.026412964, -0.029556274, -0.01838684, 0.040496826, -0.018325806, 0.020507812, 0.009254456, 0.060913086, 0.015350342, 0.014419556, 0.09173584, -0.006298065, -0.009208679, -0.00390625, 0.021438599, 0.03552246, 0.017288208, 0.056152344, -0.04232788, 0.039642334, 0.06161499, -0.0066337585, 0.0030174255, 0.025390625, -0.011352539, -0.0020008087, -0.0073509216, 0.018722534, 0.016937256, -0.03366089, -0.011352539, 0.003522873, -0.017654419, 0.016677856, -0.014457703, -0.004119873, 0.019210815, 0.0068511963, -0.0025348663, 0.02507019, -0.020736694, -0.00072717667, 0.028549194, -0.02218628, -0.029067993, 0.010803223, -0.037597656, 0.027923584, -0.029464722, -0.019439697, 0.00063705444, -0.035308838, -0.043823242, -0.03729248, -0.038970947, 0.006187439, -0.03390503, 0.025802612, -0.032043457, -0.009796143, -0.07745361, -0.02331543, -0.019744873, -0.02519226, 0.04849243, 0.02998352, -0.05117798, 0.013748169, 0.011482239, 0.012893677, -0.012138367, 0.010673523, 0.027297974, 0.023376465, 0.003818512, -0.004398346, -0.0005836487, 0.023071289, 0.019592285, -0.0002937317, 0.010429382, -0.0006866455, -0.023544312, 0.07019043, -0.02268982, 0.027313232, -0.026855469, 0.005203247, 0.043701172, -0.0065345764, -0.012428284, 0.015007019, -0.025726318, 0.005886078, 0.007434845, 0.0054626465, -0.0030708313, -0.01612854, 0.059814453, 0.039276123, 0.06347656, -0.019607544, -0.048706055, 0.02848816, 0.038604736, -0.03427124, -0.014312744, 0.13903809, 0.012557983, 0.013336182, 0.000039577484, 0.009498596, -0.054992676, 0.02331543, -0.044555664, 0.0135269165, 0.015129089, -0.018844604, 0.005443573, -0.031982422, 0.025817871, -0.005256653, 0.0009255409, 0.010513306, 0.034210205, 0.022521973, 0.0007867813, 0.03375244, -0.025527954, -0.014404297, -0.017959595, -0.057434082, -0.011260986, 0.035736084, -0.014442444, 0.052825928, 0.025054932, 0.0027503967, 0.0036621094, -0.044158936, 0.016601562, 0.021575928, -0.023910522, 0.005584717, 0.038208008, 0.020385742, -0.004333496, 0.043701172, 0.012619019, 0.010467529, -0.06732178, -0.031677246, -0.008079529, -0.009017944, -0.010444641, 0.04562378, 0.030303955, 0.052612305, 0.047088623, -0.042938232, -0.028686523, -0.015823364, -0.05319214, 0.11431885, 0.012710571, -0.051086426, 0.049316406, 0.004306793, 0.03414917, -0.040130615, 0.0002527237, 0.07946777, -0.003227234, -0.0064315796, 0.02607727, 0.038085938, 0.014076233, -0.0079193115, -0.03829956, -0.016235352, -0.022842407, 0.048858643, 0.039276123, -0.04071045, -0.027404785, -0.042419434, -0.040222168, 0.04815674, 0.0042533875, -0.0013132095, 0.023651123, -0.029647827, 0.039154053, 0.02053833, -0.0104599, 0.05166626, -0.036132812, 0.028045654, -0.04937744, 0.022399902, -0.08648682, -0.0149383545, -0.013710022, 0.010307312, 0.012870789, -0.012512207, -0.0095825195, 0.0048980713, 0.01878357, 0.010025024, 0.009300232, 0.01977539, 0.08331299, -0.0035572052, 0.013313293, -0.00024151802, -0.027526855, 0.011108398, -0.035583496, -0.015701294, 0.059631348, 0.02180481, 0.10168457, 0.0045433044, -0.043151855, 0.048675537, -0.068847656, -0.024871826, -0.019226074, -0.07067871, -0.027160645, -0.015487671, -0.030761719, -0.015380859, -0.04547119, -0.020324707, -0.009681702, -0.043029785, -0.006706238, -0.015007019, 0.04675293, -0.01737976, 0.11462402, -0.036315918, 0.038330078, 0.048858643, -0.042022705, 0.029968262, -0.024597168, -0.052978516, 0.021026611, 0.04055786, 0.027297974, -0.01864624, 0.004562378, -0.03842163, 0.042541504, 0.016281128, -0.06311035, -0.029663086, -0.024093628, 0.011962891, -0.056671143, 0.043670654, 0.015319824, 0.040405273, -0.048583984, -0.0385437, -0.002105713, 0.006664276, -0.043640137, 0.0040359497, 0.01612854, -0.028839111, 0.019561768, 0.009437561, 0.03515625, -0.021942139, -0.012680054, 0.040222168, -0.010139465, -0.016403198, 0.033355713, -0.018066406, 0.056121826, -0.017791748, -0.06903076, -0.006954193, -0.0057144165, 0.04260254, 0.023773193, -0.013542175, -0.02520752, 0.016418457, 0.04031372, 0.04849243, -0.035247803, 0.05404663, 0.02658081, -0.00592041, -0.001917839, -0.003572464, 0.009590149, 0.014266968, -0.024856567, 0.00982666, 0.011108398, 0.029785156, 0.060699463, -0.015541077, -0.0035705566, 0.028244019, 0.0061950684, -0.041229248, 0.055908203, -0.0027866364, 0.0053482056, -0.0028438568, 0.0019359589, -0.007904053, 0.0069236755, 0.023895264, -0.024002075, -0.020126343, 0.0070152283, 0.05328369, 0.02281189, -0.00045013428, -0.009941101, -0.029266357, 0.028335571, -0.008880615, 0.042999268, -0.025161743, 0.043121338, -0.011077881, 0.041107178, -0.009117126, -0.017822266, -0.05807495, -0.019454956, -0.040161133, 0.045715332, -0.030380249, 0.030776978, -0.011978149, 0.029953003, 0.052978516, -0.005508423, -0.003353119, -0.004852295, 0.046875, -0.0035209656, -0.05001831, -0.111328125, -0.035980225, -0.016571045, -0.027633667, -0.012504578, -0.09680176, -0.0848999, -0.024917603, 0.017181396, -0.009277344, -0.00065374374, 0.018829346, -0.0047798157, 0.006793976, 0.007633209, -0.013504028, -0.02897644, -0.024734497, -0.017745972, -0.02519226, 0.0077934265, -0.032684326, 0.0013637543, 0.042114258, -0.031677246, -0.01146698, -0.016571045, 0.001871109, -0.011451721, 0.039733887, -0.014572144, 0.014854431, 0.015197754, 0.029266357, 0.025512695, -0.0057258606, -0.009437561, 0.014984131, 0.0022468567, 0.02746582, 0.031204224, -0.022109985, 0.008346558, 0.004688263, 0.04748535, -0.01638794, -0.033599854, -0.014320374, 0.010040283, -0.0058174133, 0.0154418945, 0.03414917, -0.024551392, 0.0095825195, -0.0035972595, -0.008613586, 0.026306152, -0.034851074, 0.03048706, 0.0368042, 0.036987305, -0.022644043, -0.011817932, 0.028030396, -0.013511658, -0.018356323, -0.004169464, 0.0018882751, -0.026382446, 0.002149582, -0.019119263, -0.017791748, -0.018554688, 0.013633728, 0.024337769, 0.0011119843, -0.007801056, 0.020050049, 0.0027999878, 0.014709473, -0.0052719116, -0.020095825, -0.048034668, -0.006023407, 0.005874634, -0.007858276, 0.030288696, 0.026016235, 0.024124146, -0.018844604, -0.04171753, 0.023788452, -0.044036865, -0.03579712, 0.0018548965, -0.06732178, 0.031219482, 0.015991211, -0.020141602, -0.028167725, 0.029907227, -0.02432251, -0.01373291, 0.009895325, -0.058654785, -0.021362305, -0.0051231384, -0.012573242, 0.049865723, 0.04901123, 0.02696228, 0.038604736, -0.02746582, 0.0054130554, 0.026931763, -0.0015125275, -0.042419434, 0.003446579, 0.05078125, 0.014503479, -0.010307312, 0.03010559, -0.0011053085, -0.03152466, -0.06707764, -0.008033752, -0.091918945, -0.0075569153, -0.03164673, -0.033203125, 0.03616333, 0.01838684, -0.035308838, -0.009231567, 0.035308838, -0.0029029846, 0.020812988, -0.005748749, 0.0044670105, -0.0077934265, 0.054260254, -0.010627747, -0.008995056, 0.017715454, 0.06237793, -0.046539307, -0.007575989, 0.0064582825, 0.010391235, 0.0056266785, -0.00092315674, 0.019073486, 0.0071983337, 0.0003402233, 0.015022278, 0.014724731, -0.0011548996, 0.02154541, -0.010429382, -0.03817749, 0.019241333, -0.016220093, -0.018203735, 0.03515625, -0.011619568, -0.0030708313, 0.010856628, 0.010467529, -0.04650879, 0.008049011, 0.03567505, 0.05709839, -0.055908203, -0.066345215, -0.00029325485, 0.03668213, 0.010574341, 0.013069153, 0.041870117, 0.02748108, 0.0015678406, 0.008331299, 0.017837524, 0.010574341, -0.02406311, -0.0030078888, -0.011672974, 0.014038086, -0.02507019, 0.0099105835, -0.018600464, -0.0039482117, -0.016159058, 0.010688782, 0.009147644, 0.022644043, -0.010940552, -0.006427765, 0.027618408, 0.021072388, 0.00819397, 0.042755127, -0.009552002, -0.043762207, 0.022460938, -0.016235352, -0.019760132, 0.03338623, -0.0068359375, -0.0070114136, 0.036224365, 0.024414062, 0.015701294, -0.055999756, 0.06097412, -0.03845215, 0.018173218, 0.0014019012, 0.018234253, 0.0044517517, 0.0033950806, -0.004108429, -0.0038833618, -0.003528595, 0.0385437, 0.03036499, 0.027130127, 0.0013303757, -0.015380859, 0.015945435, 0.02420044, 0.031021118, -0.015525818, 0.019622803, 0.00248909, -0.00894165, 0.001502037, -0.03842163, -0.05117798, 0.0098724365, 0.022964478, 0.009529114, 0.02168274, 0.011978149, -0.015457153, -0.0158844, -0.03250122, 0.043029785, 0.01739502, 0.011955261, 0.0044403076, 0.001619339, -0.076538086, 0.012763977, 0.07147217, -0.010787964, -0.0049324036, -0.03918457, 0.0020923615, 0.00007224083, -0.03942871, 0.00762558, -0.085998535, -0.018203735, -0.057739258, 0.016571045, 0.012886047, 0.048065186, 0.01687622, -0.0029640198, 0.030059814, -0.0061912537, 0.004711151, 0.010894775, -0.011459351, 0.021957397, 0.012237549, -0.022232056, -0.010650635, 0.009132385, -0.018875122, 0.00983429, 0.043701172, 0.04449463, -0.026153564, 0.026657104, 0.009841919, -0.000957489, -0.026947021, -0.011314392, -0.031555176, -0.037017822, 0.0025081635, 0.016326904, 0.00020897388, 0.05328369, 0.0093307495, 0.0028533936, 0.028778076, 0.039093018, 0.011550903, 0.030822754, 0.02545166, 0.04171753, -0.03717041, 0.011047363, 0.0069618225, -0.014633179, -0.008842468, 0.050689697, -0.03656006, 0.026901245, -0.012260437, 0.05871582, 0.03488159, 0.064941406, -0.021118164, 0.037872314, 0.027191162, 0.02645874, 0.028503418, -0.0024986267, -0.011985779, -0.011993408, -0.015403748, 0.0013589859, -0.0087509155, -0.020843506, 0.03756714, -0.042053223, 0.013549805, -0.04046631, 0.010696411, -0.055603027, -0.011505127, 0.0051460266, -0.044708252, -0.029403687, 0.029251099, 0.052642822, -0.01979065, 0.013336182, -0.0051994324, -0.03338623, 0.006252289, 0.012817383, 0.036834717, -0.029281616, -0.06323242, 0.04925537, 0.012664795, 0.08557129, 0.01789856, -0.005680084, 0.054656982, 0.021469116, -0.027511597, -0.08905029, -0.033691406, 0.023544312, 0.05911255, -0.03213501, 0.020217896, 0.037628174, 0.0049858093, -0.047546387, -0.041168213, -0.004058838, -0.036102295, 0.025878906, 0.03778076, -0.0032463074, -0.040618896, -0.0045318604, -0.016143799, 0.02696228, -0.030776978, -0.006072998, 0.010612488, 0.012336731, -0.022567749, -0.037994385, -0.013061523, -0.007385254, 0.019485474, -0.028244019, 0.0007162094, -0.020050049, 0.0067977905, -0.032989502, -0.05529785, 0.00472641, 0.027450562, 0.008178711, -0.008850098, 0.016998291, 0.0132369995, 0.015304565, 0.023925781, 0.0033111572, -0.030014038, 0.07775879, 0.04397583, 0.034729004, 0.018508911, -0.040649414, 0.058898926, 0.009094238, -0.05355835, -0.008628845, -0.0074691772, -0.0011816025, -0.028625488, 0.0059318542, -0.021316528, -0.035949707, -0.05822754, -0.07562256, 0.004421234, 0.0066184998, -0.0009899139, -0.004798889, 0.03741455, -0.01663208, 0.023849487, -0.044311523, 0.010986328, -0.03125, -0.011627197, -0.003824234, 0.0042037964, 0.008491516, 0.0068893433, 0.020843506, -0.00566864, 0.0055122375, 0.018463135, 0.021499634, -0.049102783, -0.025268555, -0.07507324, -0.009223938, 0.024673462, -0.0017633438, 0.011260986, 0.0135269165, -0.00004208088, 0.04449463, -0.019546509, 0.025299072, 0.02418518, 0.005027771, 0.017715454, 0.028579712, 0.035461426, 0.0093688965, 0.017929077 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06985v1
SELF-EXPLAIN: Teaching Large Language Models to Reason Complex Questions by Themselves
Jiachen Zhao, Zonghai Yao, Zhichao Yang, Hong Yu
cs.CL
Large language models (LLMs) can generate intermediate reasoning steps. To elicit the reliable reasoning, the common practice is to employ few-shot chain-of-thought prompting, where several in-context demonstrations for reasoning are prepended to the question. However, such chain-of-thought examples are expensive to craft, especially for professional domains, and can have high variance depending on human annotators. Therefore, this work investigates whether LLMs can teach themselves to reason without human-crafted demonstrations. We propose SELF-EXPLAIN to generate CoT examples by LLMs inspired by "encoding specificity" in human memory retrieval. We find using self-explanations makes LLMs more confident, more calibrated and less biased when answering complex questions. Moreover, we find prompting with self-explanations can even significantly outperform using human-crafted CoTs on several complex question answering dataset.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06985v1
2023-11-12T23:14:43
2023-11-12T23:14:43
{ "title": [ -0.028945923, -0.024139404, -0.01977539, -0.06695557, -0.017211914, 0.010597229, -0.04537964, 0.004470825, -0.0028247833, 0.00008517504, -0.0095825195, 0.006969452, -0.032104492, -0.022949219, -0.028625488, -0.0074005127, 0.0010967255, 0.019012451, -0.033325195, -0.023269653, -0.0029945374, -0.033721924, 0.012359619, 0.028915405, 0.04724121, -0.055511475, -0.06903076, 0.044281006, -0.037750244, -0.020950317, -0.0018911362, 0.0118637085, 0.03933716, 0.040893555, -0.047576904, 0.014518738, -0.04849243, 0.020736694, -0.012458801, 0.018127441, 0.025100708, -0.013801575, -0.0345459, -0.0036087036, -0.05130005, 0.0022125244, -0.038238525, -0.019378662, -0.005104065, 0.06311035, 0.0026283264, 0.051483154, -0.020401001, 0.022155762, 0.027114868, -0.023239136, 0.007457733, -0.028411865, 0.0335083, 0.03753662, 0.012573242, -0.054626465, 0.021942139, -0.016433716, -0.034973145, -0.017120361, -0.023544312, 0.0098724365, 0.07672119, -0.0014133453, -0.032958984, 0.025787354, 0.022201538, 0.015167236, -0.048858643, -0.026000977, 0.048217773, 0.0115737915, 0.046783447, -0.030303955, 0.018188477, -0.00242424, 0.022476196, -0.017562866, -0.00009268522, -0.042907715, -0.009239197, -0.007648468, -0.01940918, -0.09906006, -0.0058059692, -0.03704834, -0.040283203, -0.0035438538, -0.029190063, -0.047424316, -0.0124053955, 0.0062789917, -0.004180908, -0.03652954, -0.00141716, 0.020126343, -0.04788208, -0.009033203, 0.006587982, 0.03540039, -0.030838013, -0.009246826, 0.026138306, 0.04473877, -0.012168884, 0.022705078, 0.0132751465, -0.033172607, 0.010154724, 0.023895264, -0.003408432, 0.032470703, 0.037475586, 0.019317627, -0.015258789, -0.04006958, 0.05203247, 0.019744873, 0.04046631, 0.03353882, -0.041046143, -0.018249512, 0.04421997, 0.017578125, -0.012252808, 0.028884888, -0.08203125, -0.0836792, -0.04473877, 0.034576416, -0.013183594, -0.0149383545, -0.04208374, 0.035736084, 0.011436462, -0.01914978, 0.0206604, -0.013671875, -0.018859863, -0.0019407272, 0.06604004, 0.005428314, -0.06298828, -0.07183838, -0.01020813, 0.01928711, 0.033691406, -0.0023498535, -0.072753906, -0.0035877228, -0.13745117, 0.028381348, -0.010856628, 0.026443481, 0.0034637451, 0.013137817, 0.025314331, -0.0076141357, 0.0041122437, -0.027755737, -0.03366089, -0.004600525, 0.017501831, 0.015220642, -0.014381409, 0.026931763, 0.018035889, 0.001004219, -0.003129959, 0.0024909973, 0.020004272, 0.0024662018, 0.0141067505, 0.0131073, 0.012649536, -0.025360107, 0.006790161, 0.044281006, -0.038848877, -0.036468506, -0.021591187, -0.029968262, 0.06512451, 0.003030777, -0.04824829, 0.017852783, -0.043273926, -0.025375366, -0.034210205, -0.022399902, 0.007820129, 0.02178955, -0.004386902, 0.005279541, -0.040100098, 0.0056915283, -0.02230835, -0.008644104, -0.024291992, -0.005809784, -0.01499176, 0.04055786, -0.005710602, 0.060455322, 0.06524658, 0.043395996, -0.06072998, 0.04321289, -0.010726929, -0.077941895, 0.032714844, -0.014060974, -0.011390686, -0.03036499, 0.0014858246, -0.016586304, 0.013839722, 0.078186035, -0.015220642, 0.014450073, -0.010574341, -0.0013065338, 0.009185791, 0.045715332, 0.022720337, -0.054748535, 0.049346924, 0.030838013, -0.00554657, -0.017227173, -0.016418457, -0.017150879, -0.0021648407, 0.020477295, -0.0062789917, -0.016281128, -0.0070762634, 0.0035629272, 0.029571533, -0.004234314, 0.019073486, -0.016418457, 0.0103302, 0.0006246567, 0.043884277, 0.011985779, 0.05230713, 0.01977539, 0.008377075, 0.0524292, 0.019592285, 0.012527466, -0.022521973, 0.009231567, 0.010818481, -0.0070648193, -0.029510498, 0.010025024, -0.060668945, 0.0143585205, -0.032196045, 0.007160187, 0.015388489, -0.0069122314, 0.016937256, -0.031311035, 0.023040771, -0.016464233, -0.019714355, -0.001042366, -0.012145996, 0.028137207, 0.020080566, -0.060638428, 0.0034446716, 0.022659302, 0.026412964, -0.007041931, 0.0030403137, 0.02230835, 0.006778717, 0.004673004, -0.0003669262, 0.013114929, 0.05255127, 0.029647827, 0.015022278, 0.00020849705, 0.020233154, -0.014343262, 0.09362793, 0.06945801, -0.024856567, 0.020568848, -0.03353882, 0.024536133, 0.015975952, -0.018356323, 0.019851685, -0.013244629, 0.031021118, 0.018478394, -0.027633667, 0.03668213, -0.09210205, -0.0060272217, 0.0049362183, -0.0067214966, -0.033081055, -0.05227661, 0.00869751, -0.030899048, -0.032165527, -0.017547607, 0.074523926, 0.0018024445, -0.027267456, 0.011100769, 0.00080776215, -0.019958496, 0.010169983, -0.04473877, -0.004169464, 0.02394104, 0.0340271, -0.0028133392, -0.058410645, -0.05432129, -0.0059127808, 0.010238647, -0.005832672, -0.010246277, -0.025680542, 0.042663574, 0.022125244, -0.04550171, 0.03579712, -0.040527344, 0.00349617, -0.041107178, -0.0020809174, 0.025299072, -0.007911682, -0.024993896, 0.021514893, -0.02784729, -0.011276245, 0.032409668, 0.05935669, -0.029342651, -0.044128418, 0.03366089, 0.009552002, -0.034454346, 0.05596924, 0.00041341782, 0.014633179, -0.067871094, -0.01399231, -0.038238525, -0.056152344, -0.012466431, -0.01259613, 0.026046753, -0.045837402, -0.017684937, -0.044891357, -0.021438599, 0.008811951, 0.012245178, -0.0037059784, -0.04208374, -0.015716553, -0.012702942, -0.02053833, 0.027633667, -0.041931152, 0.041625977, 0.08666992, 0.022979736, 0.021972656, 0.008857727, 0.04840088, -0.0010232925, -0.0055236816, -0.027679443, -0.042938232, -0.002752304, 0.033996582, 0.012992859, -0.025161743, -0.018707275, -0.07873535, -0.011871338, 0.054138184, -0.0057029724, -0.034698486, 0.040527344, -0.08343506, 0.022369385, -0.017929077, -0.029342651, 0.018920898, -0.02330017, 0.0143585205, 0.0067100525, 0.019638062, -0.047790527, 0.015472412, -0.05331421, -0.13793945, 0.022918701, -0.028839111, -0.014442444, -0.00674057, -0.02142334, -0.03967285, 0.013679504, -0.0061798096, 0.050811768, 0.03173828, 0.015075684, 0.04638672, -0.038238525, -0.00806427, -0.020828247, 0.000685215, 0.0090408325, -0.03161621, 0.04840088, 0.0012378693, 0.031402588, 0.03552246, -0.022705078, -0.022491455, -0.02168274, -0.05987549, 0.021224976, -0.037231445, -0.018081665, -0.029251099, -0.018310547, -0.01876831, 0.014503479, -0.01461792, 0.008468628, -0.04849243, 0.00365448, -0.02494812, 0.016098022, 0.00055360794, 0.011177063, -0.022018433, -0.021133423, 0.008796692, -0.023117065, -0.046539307, 0.005504608, 0.05517578, -0.0018815994, 0.029006958, -0.016326904, -0.03265381, 0.040496826, -0.014091492, -0.030029297, -0.021835327, 0.013412476, -0.0040626526, 0.022766113, -0.031402588, 0.009933472, -0.00090551376, 0.041168213, 0.0014591217, -0.0028362274, -0.023498535, -0.07116699, -0.006591797, -0.011489868, -0.12017822, -0.022918701, -0.0029201508, -0.0036334991, 0.0128479, -0.05996704, 0.039733887, -0.01991272, -0.05050659, 0.0132751465, -0.015449524, -0.0043754578, -0.01638794, -0.07525635, -0.01727295, 0.073913574, -0.0096206665, 0.012939453, 0.043670654, -0.017669678, -0.010360718, -0.021774292, 0.026260376, 0.03050232, 0.016571045, 0.0035419464, -0.0496521, 0.038238525, -0.03387451, 0.017837524, 0.036865234, -0.017227173, 0.011566162, 0.020904541, -0.027709961, 0.010169983, -0.0065460205, 0.058258057, -0.0013856888, -0.021453857, -0.049560547, 0.040130615, 0.0023498535, 0.005016327, 0.023773193, -0.0007171631, 0.006259918, 0.016189575, -0.017730713, 0.03250122, -0.011856079, -0.012466431, 0.024551392, 0.011756897, -0.014854431, -0.013366699, 0.018341064, 0.042236328, 0.017410278, 0.025817871, 0.014373779, 0.049346924, -0.03314209, 0.0015392303, -0.018585205, 0.006500244, -0.025863647, 0.016082764, -0.06329346, -0.042236328, -0.04333496, 0.013412476, -0.007881165, 0.052886963, 0.045654297, -0.010810852, -0.010398865, -0.014701843, 0.035858154, -0.0037899017, -0.011161804, -0.08453369, -0.017669678, -0.007698059, -0.06768799, -0.033477783, -0.03149414, 0.007369995, 0.005092621, 0.0061416626, -0.013908386, 0.013053894, 0.030654907, 0.072265625, 0.045410156, -0.00006181002, -0.05517578, 0.036712646, -0.010238647, -0.027053833, 0.022354126, 0.013320923, 0.0028743744, -0.03286743, 0.015640259, -0.03086853, -0.01576233, -0.04977417, 0.028121948, -0.00069093704, 0.039093018, -0.0038280487, 0.0026817322, 0.028305054, 0.022094727, 0.018936157, 0.0008158684, -0.025772095, 0.0007662773, 0.007293701, 0.060394287, -0.019256592, -0.004219055, 0.009986877, 0.020477295, 0.041503906, -0.0015010834, 0.0021457672, -0.0020923615, -0.009597778, 0.0010509491, 0.023803711, -0.031677246, -0.027648926, -0.0072898865, 0.011772156, 0.03781128, -0.06390381, 0.05041504, -0.0055999756, 0.0018186569, 0.034088135, -0.011650085, 0.019515991, -0.0042686462, 0.0060653687, -0.05206299, -0.05355835, 0.0037174225, 0.03189087, -0.017501831, 0.007598877, 0.0093688965, 0.014862061, 0.027313232, 0.058502197, 0.07672119, -0.040405273, 0.012367249, -0.013305664, -0.0040016174, 0.0049591064, -0.0262146, 0.015022278, 0.0064926147, 0.007423401, -0.062347412, 0.020507812, -0.053741455, 0.014083862, -0.023864746, -0.028686523, 0.030014038, -0.06573486, 0.028640747, 0.09039307, -0.018035889, 0.05697632, 0.03869629, -0.00006645918, -0.009757996, 0.060150146, -0.012077332, 0.0440979, 0.029830933, -0.07122803, -0.010009766, -0.010818481, 0.039733887, -0.0069999695, 0.031143188, 0.018585205, 0.026351929, -0.074645996, 0.021911621, 0.012054443, -0.001950264, 0.019378662, -0.05987549, 0.0069465637, 0.022720337, 0.018508911, 0.0082473755, -0.040771484, -0.025314331, -0.009284973, -0.026611328, -0.037139893, 0.019897461, -0.028549194, -0.03753662, -0.028182983, 0.004951477, -0.023101807, -0.004142761, 0.033569336, -0.00806427, -0.01512146, 0.013153076, 0.047790527, -0.0021419525, 0.014808655, -0.042907715, -0.017120361, 0.040527344, 0.041748047, -0.011756897, -0.0063095093, -0.016555786, -0.02935791, 0.0007443428, 0.01713562, -0.008735657, 0.0011701584, -0.0003209114, 0.0028438568, -0.0009403229, -0.009757996, 0.016052246, -0.0008277893, -0.037139893, 0.02935791, -0.006816864, 0.00046682358, -0.009567261, 0.021011353, -0.03314209, 0.010635376, 0.028030396, -0.011810303, 0.012779236, 0.00843811, 0.016571045, -0.0047569275, -0.041290283, -0.016296387, 0.029067993, 0.0012149811, -0.00472641, 0.036132812, 0.0259552, 0.023513794, -0.018539429, 0.009796143, 0.037628174, -0.035827637, -0.030029297, -0.000436306, 0.008346558, -0.011795044, 0.05230713, -0.005580902, -0.02444458, -0.021057129, -0.041412354, -0.015304565, 0.0073127747, 0.008766174, 0.014625549, 0.0029010773, -0.0152282715, 0.032226562, -0.039978027, -0.011756897, -0.041656494, 0.024978638, -0.024291992, -0.04220581, 0.032440186, -0.002614975, -0.0021514893, -0.033813477, 0.024017334, 0.033172607, 0.019165039, 0.019119263, -0.03277588, -0.0005326271, -0.03918457, -0.03466797, 0.041229248, 0.023788452, -0.023086548, 0.049621582, -0.013145447, 0.05984497, 0.032409668, 0.051971436, 0.033447266, 0.016220093, 0.023483276, 0.014518738, 0.032928467, -0.028030396, 0.05166626, -0.056610107, 0.0158844, -0.074157715, -0.014038086, -0.103149414, -0.0031929016, 0.008880615, 0.027862549, 0.030090332, 0.004863739, 0.013763428, 0.010131836, 0.015472412, 0.0446167, 0.05606079, -0.010734558, 0.011375427, -0.00623703, -0.035888672, 0.041412354, 0.043701172, -0.013961792, -0.0019664764, -0.023910522, -0.011062622, 0.020111084, 0.00079631805, -0.0029277802, -0.050323486, -0.009727478, -0.038116455, 0.009117126, -0.018341064, 0.0034217834, 0.061584473, 0.030731201, -0.012046814, -0.0075416565, 0.02116394, -0.042999268, -0.011489868, -0.01713562, 0.01701355, -0.08337402, 0.018127441, 0.00056409836, -0.012550354, -0.017837524, 0.06536865, 0.034576416, -0.018737793, -0.007270813, 0.035461426, 0.019882202, 0.008430481, -0.0033626556, -0.034301758, -0.017562866, 0.014724731, 0.019195557, -0.0011224747, 0.042114258, 0.031341553, 0.022720337, -0.017410278, -0.04006958, 0.022720337, -0.018188477, -0.0042037964, 0.028717041, -0.0064201355, 0.029067993, -0.014503479, -0.026290894, -0.011367798, 0.03152466, -0.074523926, -0.003967285, 0.008239746, 0.044555664, 0.024551392, 0.07318115, -0.0033512115, -0.017837524, -0.0022029877, -0.03201294, 0.011184692, 0.014633179, -0.030075073, 0.016693115, -0.05392456, -0.046783447, 0.024475098, -0.053375244, 0.04397583, -0.037475586, 0.0038261414, -0.03942871, 0.04675293, 0.013412476, -0.044189453, -0.021209717, -0.0015125275, -0.026641846, -0.0023765564, 0.0004658699, 0.002008438, -0.0036697388, 0.0065231323, 0.008399963, 0.038116455, -0.0005517006, -0.0069885254, -0.032196045, -0.04156494, 0.028762817, -0.0009832382, 0.06317139, -0.0049743652, -0.021697998, -0.008796692, 0.0034427643, 0.015541077, -0.026916504, -0.040283203, 0.018615723, -0.012451172, -0.015068054, 0.021606445, 0.031341553, -0.0061073303, -0.02923584, -0.042663574, 0.013496399, -0.021026611, 0.01008606, 0.03503418, -0.040283203, -0.04196167, 0.0008234978, -0.026351929, 0.049072266, -0.002855301, -0.01108551, 0.038513184, -0.002210617, -0.010299683, -0.013702393, 0.029312134, 0.027664185, 0.0013828278, -0.027801514, 0.015823364, 0.016143799, 0.04333496, -0.05722046, -0.040222168, 0.0017337799, 0.0015830994, 0.005645752, 0.045318604, 0.018875122, -0.022033691, -0.014167786, 0.014778137, -0.014060974, -0.023635864, 0.006916046, 0.026763916, 0.042053223, 0.060760498, -0.009529114, 0.013671875, 0.024475098, -0.025115967, -0.007167816, 0.018035889, 0.01309967, 0.025924683, 0.01626587, 0.046844482, -0.050354004, 0.014411926, -0.04736328, -0.006565094, 0.0051002502, 0.013069153, -0.019577026, 0.022201538, -0.03277588, 0.047973633, -0.030044556, -0.0703125, 0.050598145, 0.058563232, 0.010116577, 0.02180481, -0.020736694, -0.011688232, 0.014839172, 0.011062622, 0.00048351288, 0.0060195923, -0.0005712509, -0.03173828, 0.0008468628, -0.058135986, -0.025848389, -0.015991211, -0.0357666, 0.05090332, -0.0317688, -0.008285522, -0.024276733, -0.01637268, 0.008255005, 0.020355225, 0.0046806335, -0.021118164, -0.0395813, 0.0104522705, 0.037109375, -0.0069007874 ], "summary": [ 0.011459351, -0.04385376, 0.028381348, -0.019485474, -0.087524414, 0.010627747, -0.06890869, -0.020187378, -0.012550354, -0.011260986, -0.022994995, -0.005054474, -0.016098022, -0.03970337, 0.025009155, -0.03543091, 0.013893127, -0.0040283203, -0.017715454, -0.011054993, 0.014144897, -0.0007915497, -0.02607727, 0.04006958, 0.015541077, -0.012741089, 0.009735107, -0.00009775162, 0.05178833, 0.03668213, 0.021575928, -0.07342529, 0.013847351, 0.016403198, -0.014801025, 0.016738892, -0.030975342, 0.015930176, -0.003932953, 0.00289917, 0.008529663, -0.011131287, 0.018310547, -0.022232056, -0.034057617, 0.042755127, -0.036315918, -0.023391724, 0.043426514, 0.020355225, -0.004550934, 0.02999878, -0.008720398, 0.016571045, -0.0259552, -0.013946533, -0.008483887, -0.054534912, 0.0029067993, 0.042633057, 0.023208618, -0.018722534, 0.00818634, -0.022415161, -0.03237915, 0.030166626, 0.015174866, -0.041931152, 0.06542969, 0.0052108765, -0.019882202, 0.017471313, 0.02545166, -0.03878784, -0.02027893, -0.013168335, 0.057403564, 0.0041770935, -0.002023697, -0.026733398, 0.02909851, 0.018005371, 0.029464722, -0.059295654, 0.02357483, -0.057739258, 0.004901886, 0.0029029846, -0.008682251, -0.09069824, -0.005783081, -0.04437256, -0.05822754, 0.0007624626, 0.00036144257, -0.072509766, -0.0015077591, -0.027175903, -0.01890564, -0.048461914, 0.03591919, -0.011009216, -0.033843994, 0.005832672, 0.0057640076, 0.058776855, -0.019927979, -0.0435791, 0.018249512, 0.010940552, 0.0066947937, 0.015655518, 0.021408081, -0.060943604, 0.024017334, 0.02670288, 0.008087158, 0.06817627, 0.043548584, 0.00440979, -0.032592773, -0.031921387, 0.036468506, 0.06762695, 0.03753662, 0.058929443, 0.0053710938, -0.021713257, 0.03933716, 0.021224976, -0.006652832, -0.001036644, 0.01374054, 0.00554657, -0.0032787323, -0.012535095, 0.011543274, -0.01537323, -0.0340271, 0.0038928986, 0.014511108, 0.0047569275, 0.024398804, -0.016647339, -0.0077667236, 0.055847168, 0.03353882, -0.028305054, -0.018188477, -0.031021118, -0.046173096, -0.01626587, 0.021621704, -0.018157959, -0.03515625, -0.04647827, -0.079711914, 0.0062675476, 0.05505371, -0.0005507469, -0.0066833496, 0.008003235, 0.02784729, 0.0031089783, -0.022262573, -0.015777588, -0.009796143, -0.015090942, 0.033599854, 0.045928955, 0.007713318, -0.015167236, 0.03048706, 0.021224976, -0.019561768, 0.0024223328, 0.034729004, 0.048461914, -0.0006504059, 0.016738892, 0.0052108765, -0.03555298, 0.06652832, -0.014289856, -0.008506775, -0.014411926, 0.0033092499, 0.055480957, 0.032318115, 0.03652954, -0.06756592, -0.03604126, -0.014785767, -0.019683838, 0.004261017, -0.04296875, 0.00089740753, -0.01374054, 0.003686905, 0.023803711, -0.0008149147, -0.0022144318, -0.015197754, -0.024978638, -0.05493164, -0.004245758, -0.014678955, 0.03466797, 0.02015686, 0.04751587, 0.02708435, 0.021881104, -0.04650879, 0.021881104, -0.0138168335, -0.04660034, 0.023269653, -0.01713562, 0.008979797, -0.060668945, 0.046905518, -0.006198883, 0.015670776, 0.07745361, -0.025802612, 0.018203735, -0.024902344, 0.022033691, -0.00699234, 0.036499023, -0.013160706, -0.035705566, 0.032836914, 0.025909424, -0.029129028, -0.020614624, -0.0036010742, -0.0670166, 0.023956299, 0.05316162, 0.020645142, 0.0045433044, -0.033935547, -0.020904541, 0.036468506, 0.041259766, 0.03552246, -0.04144287, -0.0034942627, 0.0141067505, -0.023391724, 0.00415802, 0.026046753, -0.0027332306, -0.003419876, 0.050354004, -0.0013523102, -0.0048179626, -0.01398468, -0.000035345554, 0.0029182434, -0.019332886, -0.027404785, -0.008590698, -0.010261536, -0.005558014, 0.009963989, 0.0061416626, 0.030960083, -0.025634766, -0.0019741058, -0.07952881, 0.011627197, -0.05999756, -0.04031372, -0.03326416, -0.00705719, 0.03918457, 0.04675293, -0.056762695, 0.014038086, 0.0065612793, 0.0029258728, -0.009674072, 0.011230469, 0.0060920715, 0.019958496, 0.043151855, 0.0015182495, 0.05230713, 0.061798096, -0.011383057, -0.014472961, -0.0067100525, 0.00017392635, -0.021652222, 0.03665161, 0.008079529, 0.026138306, -0.02319336, -0.017959595, 0.046936035, 0.0032081604, -0.007003784, 0.023620605, -0.0065841675, 0.031921387, 0.01902771, 0.000016629696, 0.02720642, -0.06939697, -0.0034236908, 0.01927185, 0.06774902, -0.036346436, -0.0357666, -0.00907135, 0.028320312, 0.012664795, 0.03137207, 0.113220215, 0.016281128, -0.00806427, 0.029266357, -0.0022773743, -0.0635376, 0.064941406, -0.033477783, 0.028869629, -0.019165039, -0.000045120716, -0.025939941, -0.031341553, -0.025421143, 0.021896362, -0.016082764, 0.01399231, -0.002729416, -0.000110030174, 0.020935059, 0.043701172, -0.03186035, 0.00031495094, 0.0035552979, -0.0003414154, 0.016784668, -0.04248047, 0.01889038, 0.01927185, -0.013381958, -0.018295288, -0.027038574, -0.018127441, 0.041870117, 0.0059661865, -0.0013198853, 0.013999939, 0.040405273, -0.014854431, -0.03768921, 0.032104492, 0.025558472, 0.011444092, -0.058746338, -0.03326416, -0.02494812, -0.027557373, 0.0066108704, -0.014419556, 0.0062065125, -0.043518066, 0.033721924, -0.06097412, -0.027038574, -0.017044067, 0.05758667, 0.107421875, -0.021270752, -0.022094727, 0.05114746, 0.0031471252, 0.033081055, -0.057922363, 0.009490967, 0.09094238, 0.008705139, -0.01184845, 0.0093307495, 0.037994385, 0.018981934, -0.0007958412, -0.0385437, -0.029418945, -0.024810791, 0.0234375, 0.019226074, -0.04763794, -0.021255493, -0.027389526, -0.009254456, 0.067871094, -0.020523071, -0.004638672, 0.014511108, -0.045288086, 0.018478394, -0.0070533752, 0.0011167526, 0.03616333, -0.089416504, 0.048034668, -0.07080078, 0.053894043, -0.1003418, 0.014099121, -0.05419922, -0.09576416, -0.005619049, -0.030151367, 0.058654785, -0.005645752, 0.013511658, -0.016403198, 0.035339355, 0.003829956, 0.014816284, -0.0038452148, 0.019317627, 0.013008118, -0.00085639954, -0.011207581, -0.01966858, -0.009605408, -0.011520386, -0.034362793, 0.033203125, 0.006336212, 0.010902405, 0.011482239, -0.029907227, -0.028701782, -0.05496216, -0.11975098, -0.02154541, -0.042419434, -0.037017822, -0.057373047, -0.05444336, -0.0413208, 0.033447266, -0.033111572, 0.018615723, -0.02268982, 0.025100708, -0.024002075, 0.015319824, -0.040374756, -0.004676819, 0.0050086975, -0.030044556, -0.016418457, 0.0155181885, -0.048309326, -0.04196167, 0.052337646, -0.0073509216, -0.006576538, 0.01171875, 0.0017004013, 0.008148193, 0.016464233, -0.032989502, -0.006565094, 0.008460999, -0.026245117, 0.012374878, 0.022201538, -0.003042221, 0.031158447, -0.0061073303, -0.037841797, 0.016952515, -0.047607422, -0.07281494, -0.040496826, 0.004283905, -0.0814209, -0.045837402, -0.013519287, 0.035003662, 0.005077362, -0.02357483, 0.031143188, -0.0024471283, -0.038146973, 0.029510498, -0.028793335, 0.0871582, -0.007709503, -0.041290283, 0.012413025, -0.02230835, 0.0093307495, 0.0030555725, 0.004211426, -0.0073776245, 0.013916016, 0.018554688, 0.025131226, 0.012260437, 0.022384644, -0.0050964355, -0.026855469, 0.006248474, -0.017166138, 0.02067566, 0.01838684, -0.08306885, 0.028411865, 0.03491211, 0.033599854, 0.016326904, 0.02178955, 0.0063819885, 0.013427734, 0.002614975, -0.007598877, 0.0151901245, 0.0028362274, -0.014678955, 0.026672363, 0.023422241, -0.025680542, 0.019256592, 0.0010461807, -0.0011091232, -0.05026245, -0.020690918, 0.011734009, 0.046783447, -0.046569824, -0.0619812, 0.020446777, 0.09576416, 0.016036987, 0.012283325, 0.042816162, 0.061950684, -0.061340332, 0.03744507, -0.0116119385, -0.0121154785, 0.0033607483, 0.0009651184, -0.03326416, 0.00504303, -0.033477783, 0.009796143, -0.0033130646, 0.043762207, 0.03375244, 0.010177612, -0.015716553, -0.010932922, 0.0027885437, 0.0036907196, -0.040740967, -0.09088135, -0.07836914, 0.0040512085, -0.030014038, -0.00006604195, -0.04248047, -0.020553589, -0.03768921, -0.0045280457, -0.007797241, 0.029571533, 0.010688782, 0.023925781, 0.0020599365, -0.009178162, -0.019699097, 0.02027893, 0.011878967, -0.030441284, 0.006576538, 0.00089740753, 0.011909485, -0.025299072, -0.00039482117, -0.0154418945, -0.03451538, -0.07672119, 0.017227173, 0.0335083, 0.022735596, 0.031951904, -0.007820129, 0.026473999, 0.023544312, -0.002796173, 0.0018405914, -0.007709503, 0.04989624, -0.0010566711, 0.03894043, 0.03378296, -0.032714844, -0.022033691, 0.008972168, 0.032440186, -0.01197052, -0.0076293945, -0.029541016, -0.002614975, -0.005306244, 0.025497437, 0.041168213, 0.021377563, 0.05303955, 0.018753052, 0.03390503, 0.008483887, 0.013641357, -0.01889038, -0.013542175, 0.044708252, 0.008506775, -0.020477295, 0.04864502, -0.022476196, -0.024887085, -0.0054855347, -0.0006799698, -0.025512695, 0.0007081032, -0.010231018, 0.012702942, 0.0035533905, 0.018096924, 0.0107040405, 0.01020813, -0.06100464, 0.06591797, -0.015594482, -0.016601562, 0.035461426, 0.003873825, -0.016983032, -0.017105103, -0.0074310303, -0.0027198792, -0.0340271, 0.014373779, -0.022872925, -0.0016307831, -0.012908936, -0.010406494, -0.028030396, 0.0158844, 0.017623901, -0.06384277, 0.034332275, 0.090026855, 0.0099487305, -0.03439331, 0.023513794, -0.028640747, 0.030441284, -0.0098724365, -0.05444336, -0.008308411, -0.0023384094, 0.009025574, 0.032073975, 0.026260376, 0.011924744, 0.0048103333, -0.011642456, 0.0014228821, 0.0064888, 0.0060157776, 0.005607605, -0.017974854, 0.026916504, 0.014343262, 0.007106781, -0.0023670197, 0.013496399, -0.015457153, -0.008270264, -0.0069122314, -0.022094727, -0.029129028, -0.025497437, -0.01448822, 0.021987915, -0.013328552, -0.021713257, 0.018325806, 0.035308838, -0.018966675, 0.0009188652, -0.011749268, 0.020248413, 0.014091492, 0.017623901, -0.024627686, -0.008987427, -0.0022621155, 0.028839111, -0.0020484924, 0.0034656525, -0.016540527, -0.009208679, -0.032196045, -0.013893127, -0.039276123, 0.03277588, -0.011009216, 0.050231934, 0.0395813, -0.021057129, 0.028015137, 0.0006685257, -0.060821533, 0.008018494, -0.024337769, -0.043395996, 0.012710571, -0.00008028746, -0.073913574, 0.024765015, 0.045318604, -0.015090942, -0.004032135, 0.041534424, 0.038238525, -0.041412354, -0.061462402, -0.015823364, 0.03543091, 0.0034770966, -0.009971619, 0.021408081, -0.005138397, 0.013305664, -0.0035762787, -0.0058898926, 0.012542725, -0.006881714, -0.030334473, -0.009529114, 0.011779785, -0.037994385, 0.010978699, 0.0020771027, -0.00969696, -0.009223938, -0.01727295, 0.013969421, -0.030334473, -0.012245178, -0.015174866, -0.018814087, -0.002998352, -0.004966736, 0.0010824203, -0.019943237, -0.03378296, -0.0013275146, -0.026794434, -0.052947998, 0.09844971, 0.01260376, -0.012489319, -0.032104492, 0.0062408447, 0.006626129, 0.016571045, 0.014457703, 0.02027893, -0.011047363, -0.01777649, -0.006515503, 0.03668213, 0.023284912, -0.0062026978, 0.04034424, 0.00970459, 0.030792236, 0.028381348, 0.013809204, -0.021453857, -0.015304565, 0.038513184, 0.0076026917, 0.037353516, 0.0003671646, 0.084472656, -0.050628662, 0.005935669, -0.066223145, -0.048065186, -0.03378296, -0.028656006, 0.027404785, -0.028533936, 0.042999268, -0.00819397, -0.004928589, 0.030685425, -0.03479004, 0.049560547, -0.012245178, -0.0115737915, -0.0060043335, 0.005268097, -0.011940002, 0.010124207, 0.032470703, -0.005027771, 0.0335083, -0.026184082, 0.021209717, 0.05505371, -0.04107666, -0.038391113, -0.070495605, 0.02432251, -0.05117798, -0.046173096, 0.0090789795, 0.010826111, -0.009735107, -0.020339966, 0.040802002, 0.018173218, -0.0134887695, -0.0047187805, 0.002735138, 0.0017557144, 0.0013380051, -0.018676758, -0.012519836, -0.003660202, -0.0031547546, -0.003868103, 0.06817627, 0.03302002, 0.0154953, 0.04058838, 0.0050621033, 0.002960205, -0.0027942657, 0.004447937, -0.031402588, -0.02684021, -0.014297485, -0.008857727, 0.008491516, 0.034606934, 0.019012451, 0.004634857, 0.02305603, -0.047058105, 0.021453857, -0.05657959, 0.0181427, 0.03289795, 0.06677246, 0.074401855, 0.012664795, -0.019454956, 0.052124023, 0.039886475, -0.066223145, 0.04437256, -0.004207611, 0.083862305, 0.038604736, 0.072387695, -0.03387451, -0.0019626617, 0.052856445, 0.009429932, 0.03125, -0.007549286, -0.011024475, -0.015563965, -0.0051574707, 0.016036987, 0.010917664, 0.027008057, 0.006904602, -0.07611084, 0.0178833, -0.028244019, 0.019958496, -0.028717041, -0.0075531006, -0.046173096, -0.02558899, -0.003824234, 0.0023765564, 0.006511688, -0.00793457, 0.004878998, -0.0020618439, 0.006702423, 0.03842163, -0.006023407, -0.00033831596, -0.023330688, 0.025680542, 0.035858154, 0.04916382, 0.085998535, 0.016021729, -0.036254883, 0.042053223, 0.010971069, 0.0154418945, -0.056549072, -0.05517578, 0.02456665, 0.07385254, 0.020202637, -0.0036354065, 0.02671814, -0.00084352493, -0.0023117065, -0.014427185, 0.028686523, -0.0256958, 0.031280518, 0.056732178, -0.024291992, -0.034606934, 0.010520935, -0.025619507, 0.060302734, -0.010765076, -0.0124053955, 0.052520752, 0.014953613, -0.0029563904, -0.023101807, -0.018951416, -0.051940918, 0.001499176, -0.011207581, -0.0054512024, -0.013839722, 0.028045654, -0.039367676, -0.04623413, -0.024414062, 0.0020103455, 0.011169434, -0.0140686035, 0.01234436, -0.015037537, 0.00094890594, -0.011955261, -0.012084961, 0.0025939941, 0.056365967, 0.08331299, 0.053253174, 0.024383545, -0.040985107, 0.058013916, -0.0132369995, -0.048431396, -0.0149002075, -0.014846802, 0.017913818, -0.03488159, 0.015464783, 0.0026302338, -0.03012085, -0.04031372, -0.019165039, -0.024520874, 0.008842468, -0.003396988, -0.026123047, 0.018249512, -0.02192688, -0.029174805, 0.004211426, -0.009384155, -0.008621216, 0.023162842, 0.014129639, 0.008979797, -0.023147583, -0.010360718, 0.019256592, 0.002298355, 0.008407593, 0.00026249886, -0.0033931732, -0.0025291443, -0.009208679, -0.058685303, -0.022216797, -0.023742676, -0.011756897, 0.0014619827, -0.02822876, 0.022476196, 0.018310547, -0.015930176, 0.029205322, 0.0075569153, 0.005344391, 0.004211426, 0.00655365, 0.05493164, -0.02168274, 0.023986816 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06899v1
Flames: Benchmarking Value Alignment of Chinese Large Language Models
Kexin Huang, Xiangyang Liu, Qianyu Guo, Tianxiang Sun, Jiawei Sun, Yaru Wang, Zeyang Zhou, Yixu Wang, Yan Teng, Xipeng Qiu, Yingchun Wang, Dahua Lin
cs.CL, cs.AI
The widespread adoption of large language models (LLMs) across various regions underscores the urgent need to evaluate their alignment with human values. Current benchmarks, however, fall short of effectively uncovering safety vulnerabilities in LLMs. Despite numerous models achieving high scores and 'topping the chart' in these evaluations, there is still a significant gap in LLMs' deeper alignment with human values and achieving genuine harmlessness. To this end, this paper proposes the first highly adversarial benchmark named Flames, consisting of 2,251 manually crafted prompts, ~18.7K model responses with fine-grained annotations, and a specified scorer. Our framework encompasses both common harmlessness principles, such as fairness, safety, legality, and data protection, and a unique morality dimension that integrates specific Chinese values such as harmony. Based on the framework, we carefully design adversarial prompts that incorporate complex scenarios and jailbreaking methods, mostly with implicit malice. By prompting mainstream LLMs with such adversarially constructed prompts, we obtain model responses, which are then rigorously annotated for evaluation. Our findings indicate that all the evaluated LLMs demonstrate relatively poor performance on Flames, particularly in the safety and fairness dimensions. Claude emerges as the best-performing model overall, but with its harmless rate being only 63.08% while GPT-4 only scores 39.04%. The complexity of Flames has far exceeded existing benchmarks, setting a new challenge for contemporary LLMs and highlighting the need for further alignment of LLMs. To efficiently evaluate new models on the benchmark, we develop a specified scorer capable of scoring LLMs across multiple dimensions, achieving an accuracy of 77.4%. The Flames Benchmark is publicly available on https://github.com/AIFlames/Flames.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06899v1
2023-11-12T17:18:21
2023-11-12T17:18:21
{ "title": [ -0.04031372, -0.0050582886, -0.04321289, -0.04788208, -0.0049743652, -0.0029392242, -0.054748535, -0.0015878677, 0.010009766, 0.0368042, -0.0075683594, -0.0003798008, 0.013389587, -0.027740479, -0.048583984, 0.0077171326, -0.022033691, 0.030776978, -0.011184692, -0.039733887, 0.014389038, -0.070129395, 0.030654907, -0.002506256, 0.095825195, -0.12011719, -0.09509277, 0.028808594, -0.00031590462, -0.01676941, 0.022338867, 0.03463745, 0.033966064, 0.024597168, -0.014022827, 0.03677368, -0.047912598, 0.030914307, -0.0030822754, 0.0021591187, 0.03894043, -0.014205933, 0.0070724487, -0.00072288513, -0.03829956, 0.03378296, -0.03152466, -0.02381897, -0.0113220215, -0.013542175, 0.0074310303, 0.012611389, 0.01260376, -0.005996704, 0.0027198792, -0.013870239, -0.026229858, 0.03503418, 0.018203735, 0.07861328, 0.019302368, -0.0011672974, -0.012619019, -0.03488159, -0.032592773, 0.016693115, 0.04168701, -0.00037574768, 0.062469482, 0.008766174, -0.023361206, 0.022857666, 0.029342651, -0.016662598, -0.025039673, 0.008361816, 0.018554688, 0.010986328, 0.039794922, -0.031234741, -0.0025730133, -0.023803711, -0.0015926361, -0.010612488, 0.0014705658, -0.022903442, -0.01373291, -0.00046730042, -0.023727417, -0.093688965, -0.0068893433, 0.0032520294, -0.053771973, 0.0031776428, -0.030563354, -0.029891968, -0.034088135, 0.030471802, -0.0027656555, 0.00046372414, -0.041381836, 0.030212402, -0.049865723, -0.026260376, 0.010421753, 0.021850586, -0.018737793, -0.0037231445, 0.024108887, 0.03250122, -0.021209717, 0.03237915, 0.01184082, -0.0099487305, 0.015289307, 0.0049438477, -0.004760742, 0.019683838, -0.012245178, 0.028884888, -0.017303467, -0.0211792, 0.053344727, 0.0211792, 0.006576538, 0.0062675476, -0.025970459, -0.032287598, -0.033325195, 0.016647339, 0.008674622, 0.031219482, -0.06958008, -0.056884766, -0.052490234, 0.041168213, -0.025726318, -0.00053977966, -0.01612854, 0.009460449, 0.043701172, -0.047210693, -0.0015687943, 0.023513794, 0.022506714, 0.0067443848, 0.07183838, -0.0015277863, -0.033935547, -0.039123535, -0.024520874, 0.028045654, 0.031066895, -0.020751953, -0.07965088, -0.016983032, -0.14135742, 0.015464783, 0.009307861, 0.0037212372, -0.020629883, -0.002603531, 0.021072388, -0.03173828, -0.00010943413, -0.00017607212, -0.0079422, -0.0035476685, 0.026290894, 0.040130615, -0.0077438354, 0.026412964, 0.0085372925, -0.0016508102, -0.0038108826, -0.0038452148, 0.018417358, 0.0046691895, 0.012489319, -0.022201538, 0.014221191, -0.021499634, -0.00315094, 0.04815674, -0.05102539, -0.056274414, 0.0018310547, 0.0020446777, 0.058746338, 0.023727417, -0.006881714, -0.025680542, -0.06173706, -0.009414673, -0.046081543, -0.00030183792, 0.0152282715, 0.04827881, -0.004802704, -0.029144287, -0.010864258, 0.010627747, -0.058563232, 0.0019245148, -0.05819702, -0.030776978, -0.026260376, 0.015075684, -0.041259766, 0.052642822, 0.06750488, 0.015151978, -0.06768799, 0.06933594, 0.018310547, -0.057250977, 0.03250122, -0.000746727, -0.008872986, -0.016906738, -0.0074424744, -0.025772095, 0.0020484924, 0.040496826, -0.02659607, 0.02494812, -0.012023926, 0.016845703, 0.025497437, 0.033966064, 0.07702637, -0.044158936, 0.041107178, 0.022644043, -0.032928467, -0.037750244, -0.02859497, -0.005432129, 0.0028915405, 0.03161621, 0.00011771917, -0.008369446, -0.029724121, -0.012893677, 0.0035934448, -0.022476196, 0.009429932, -0.00014340878, 0.041809082, 0.07165527, 0.035003662, 0.029312134, 0.018508911, -0.056732178, 0.029800415, 0.05871582, -0.009803772, -0.016647339, -0.004924774, 0.00081300735, 0.01902771, -0.024414062, -0.027832031, 0.005180359, -0.06762695, -0.0038967133, -0.04055786, -0.018341064, -0.005428314, 0.0048065186, 0.04006958, -0.013702393, 0.020706177, -0.032806396, -0.02848816, -0.033996582, -0.0012292862, 0.03363037, 0.01222229, -0.07147217, -0.0107040405, -0.0095825195, 0.03427124, -0.000518322, 0.01133728, 0.013809204, 0.029541016, -0.00041103363, -0.060577393, -0.058013916, 0.0024108887, 0.0413208, -0.0007791519, 0.00198555, 0.014549255, -0.0036468506, 0.07659912, 0.04736328, -0.027328491, 0.026107788, -0.036956787, 0.012649536, 0.016906738, -0.027893066, 0.02331543, 0.045074463, 0.038726807, 0.00868988, -0.023345947, 0.022033691, -0.05340576, -0.019348145, 0.0138168335, -0.0017309189, -0.051818848, -0.06945801, -0.01209259, -0.026123047, -0.07116699, -0.03656006, 0.0770874, -0.0049362183, -0.03010559, 0.017791748, -0.007572174, -0.025222778, 0.019927979, -0.037597656, -0.009994507, -0.0118255615, 0.036346436, -0.015586853, -0.06298828, -0.047668457, 0.005859375, 0.009132385, -0.020401001, -0.0082092285, -0.02949524, 0.024154663, 0.011749268, -0.0005335808, 0.016113281, -0.045440674, 0.0017385483, -0.064819336, 0.006916046, 0.0032043457, 0.047576904, -0.00027608871, 0.004547119, 0.009788513, 0.009269714, 0.0026664734, 0.067993164, -0.042022705, -0.06677246, 0.033966064, 0.027114868, -0.008621216, 0.012641907, 0.026779175, 0.0017051697, -0.03881836, -0.024108887, -0.054718018, -0.028518677, -0.0033626556, -0.02204895, 0.017913818, -0.021728516, -0.038238525, -0.021011353, -0.027435303, -0.015563965, -0.009498596, 0.011199951, -0.028518677, -0.0135269165, 0.0046539307, -0.022354126, 0.025497437, -0.012321472, 0.051513672, 0.060760498, 0.011039734, 0.026687622, 0.0032730103, 0.038513184, 0.0038223267, 0.0074768066, -0.01727295, -0.022460938, -0.008003235, 0.045532227, 0.019973755, -0.027252197, -0.01600647, -0.088378906, 0.0013380051, 0.06829834, 0.006587982, -0.013153076, 0.0234375, -0.06781006, 0.040740967, -0.008956909, 0.0050201416, 0.043121338, 0.007835388, 0.012634277, 0.018936157, -0.0018930435, -0.014060974, -0.019866943, -0.028518677, -0.06542969, 0.045532227, -0.040618896, -0.061706543, 0.01725769, -0.025177002, -0.04498291, -0.030883789, -0.011413574, 0.050872803, 0.03036499, 0.04888916, -0.0039024353, -0.062683105, -0.0023784637, -0.05227661, -0.016784668, -0.018814087, -0.033447266, 0.011230469, 0.014083862, 0.04574585, 0.03640747, -0.009651184, -0.040039062, -0.0155181885, -0.0143966675, 0.019256592, 0.010475159, -0.028381348, -0.023925781, -0.019134521, -0.0003902912, 0.03451538, -0.04196167, 0.0054740906, -0.0259552, 0.021438599, -0.029937744, -0.0211792, 0.030044556, 0.014289856, -0.021026611, -0.017288208, 0.016998291, -0.020751953, -0.022384644, 0.011604309, 0.08868408, 0.02772522, -0.063964844, 0.013198853, -0.028198242, 0.0256958, 0.041137695, -0.040924072, 0.010231018, 0.009635925, -0.033843994, 0.00075769424, 0.026672363, 0.002149582, -0.0038223267, -0.017242432, 0.011253357, 0.0042762756, -0.01663208, -0.06335449, -0.0034065247, 0.006198883, -0.11065674, -0.025802612, 0.007949829, 0.008514404, -0.023223877, -0.014434814, 0.029022217, 0.012161255, -0.023727417, 0.022857666, -0.015274048, -0.028381348, 0.014175415, -0.06896973, 0.001074791, 0.08074951, 0.01171875, 0.012756348, 0.020965576, 0.029785156, 0.008560181, -0.038726807, 0.0004761219, -0.011260986, 0.041503906, -0.04837036, -0.06719971, 0.024291992, -0.038726807, 0.021453857, 0.02822876, -0.03677368, 0.020233154, 0.019165039, 0.026641846, 0.02949524, 0.0008044243, 0.035003662, -0.00749588, -0.025115967, -0.030685425, -0.0038280487, -0.026931763, 0.012626648, -0.014259338, -0.0005836487, 0.019699097, -0.004169464, 0.046295166, 0.019439697, -0.0128479, 0.0075531006, 0.021240234, -0.016983032, -0.02658081, -0.012245178, 0.022460938, 0.022506714, 0.015625, 0.017425537, -0.011222839, 0.03390503, -0.0061683655, 0.008659363, -0.04473877, -0.018875122, -0.046966553, 0.0077209473, -0.044128418, -0.042816162, -0.05178833, 0.019744873, -0.019561768, 0.05404663, 0.02458191, 0.0033817291, -0.0023403168, -0.01448822, 0.043670654, 0.003501892, -0.012962341, -0.059387207, 0.009788513, -0.008613586, -0.056152344, -0.023269653, -0.0138549805, 0.027359009, 0.03161621, 0.00084733963, -0.010467529, 0.003955841, 0.018295288, 0.0006580353, 0.03942871, -0.0076446533, -0.02116394, -0.011222839, -0.01777649, -0.00044989586, -0.003288269, 0.008728027, -0.0069084167, -0.012382507, 0.015716553, -0.007774353, -0.015068054, -0.015151978, 0.012756348, -0.009689331, 0.044311523, -0.0074882507, 0.02645874, 0.009857178, 0.0077781677, -0.0053482056, 0.0037021637, -0.03564453, -0.00078725815, -0.024459839, 0.000808239, 0.010192871, 0.02406311, 0.020843506, 0.0032577515, -0.018463135, 0.0024585724, 0.035308838, 0.003194809, -0.020141602, 0.0131073, -0.00038862228, -0.045013428, -0.023864746, -0.0059928894, -0.010673523, 0.024291992, -0.04510498, 0.036590576, -0.049072266, 0.031143188, 0.020935059, -0.016464233, 0.021484375, -0.012428284, 0.026062012, -0.04647827, -0.012794495, 0.0056419373, -0.0020503998, -0.035369873, -0.017166138, -0.030563354, -0.014961243, 0.016204834, 0.053894043, 0.05303955, -0.020568848, -0.011192322, -0.019165039, -0.020889282, -0.0054092407, -0.048614502, -0.0030078888, 0.0059814453, 0.0082473755, -0.03982544, 0.02166748, -0.037139893, -0.02078247, -0.019714355, -0.03466797, 0.031066895, -0.070251465, -0.0004708767, 0.05303955, -0.0045700073, 0.04156494, 0.024353027, 0.022521973, 0.028457642, 0.055389404, 0.016494751, 0.023132324, 0.016967773, -0.010040283, 0.016433716, 0.007537842, 0.014129639, -0.0124053955, 0.032226562, -0.0061073303, 0.021774292, -0.03656006, 0.020385742, 0.013084412, -0.020141602, 0.027862549, -0.05770874, 0.016281128, 0.0014925003, -0.011817932, 0.03656006, -0.019226074, -0.02494812, -0.041503906, -0.00019264221, -0.089538574, 0.0025348663, -0.006111145, -0.05557251, -0.02670288, 0.04425049, -0.03479004, -0.012649536, 0.032562256, -0.020248413, -0.030456543, 0.050079346, 0.01574707, -0.029708862, -0.008125305, 0.016937256, 0.00655365, 0.031219482, 0.046813965, -0.036590576, -0.011482239, -0.0038585663, -0.007396698, -0.0037403107, -0.009407043, 0.0032863617, 0.00995636, -0.0109939575, -0.010246277, 0.010063171, -0.017944336, 0.024459839, -0.016616821, -0.011390686, 0.014511108, -0.0025119781, 0.009147644, -0.0024471283, 0.0076828003, 0.012680054, -0.004180908, -0.002046585, -0.03829956, 0.048431396, -0.013938904, -0.0061569214, -0.0014657974, -0.07299805, 0.02381897, 0.006504059, -0.029296875, -0.018478394, 0.042541504, 0.033416748, 0.001045227, -0.0030384064, 0.0066490173, 0.047302246, -0.046295166, -0.024032593, 0.019363403, 0.014656067, 0.01876831, 0.059539795, -0.013687134, -0.0137786865, -0.028182983, -0.049865723, -0.01928711, 0.0090408325, 0.018676758, 0.008033752, 0.012580872, -0.028701782, 0.0345459, -0.040924072, -0.03567505, -0.03955078, 0.01600647, -0.003479004, -0.020751953, 0.023849487, -0.033233643, -0.010398865, -0.012519836, 0.02746582, 0.011207581, -0.026016235, 0.037628174, -0.014503479, -0.0069618225, -0.018859863, -0.030654907, 0.024154663, 0.001294136, -0.02633667, 0.014663696, -0.02305603, 0.057922363, -0.0006451607, 0.019454956, 0.030044556, 0.020263672, 0.0003643036, -0.004776001, 0.038879395, -0.022491455, 0.0050468445, -0.012664795, 0.016799927, -0.038482666, 0.0016307831, -0.077819824, 0.050964355, 0.019348145, 0.049835205, -0.0014505386, 0.015106201, 0.02116394, 0.019500732, 0.030227661, 0.0039634705, 0.06774902, 0.074157715, 0.0099105835, 0.016281128, -0.018829346, 0.010940552, 0.033203125, 0.010025024, -0.009033203, 0.006549835, -0.014877319, 0.00945282, -0.0043678284, 0.027496338, -0.008049011, -0.0048675537, -0.016189575, 0.019134521, 0.0054244995, 0.03768921, 0.0541687, -0.0010814667, -0.005958557, -0.017196655, -0.012145996, -0.04953003, -0.054595947, 0.026306152, 0.01828003, -0.08337402, 0.035461426, -0.018325806, -0.014663696, 0.02519226, 0.012512207, 0.03616333, -0.07940674, -0.08642578, 0.024963379, 0.05154419, 0.043304443, 0.0060539246, -0.03137207, -0.028717041, 0.015129089, 0.0440979, -0.013702393, 0.039154053, 0.012367249, 0.008476257, 0.016830444, -0.04272461, 0.006629944, -0.011833191, 0.012672424, 0.03262329, -0.00198555, 0.017105103, 0.0013208389, -0.026931763, 0.026245117, 0.0013427734, -0.041229248, 0.005657196, 0.012680054, 0.02708435, 0.020141602, 0.07067871, 0.023925781, 0.01007843, -0.026412964, -0.037109375, 0.035308838, 0.023635864, -0.012802124, 0.02923584, -0.031402588, -0.042144775, 0.03250122, -0.032989502, 0.04776001, -0.07800293, 0.0073013306, -0.037384033, 0.06137085, -0.02305603, -0.056610107, -0.055480957, 0.000084102154, -0.033477783, 0.013504028, 0.04333496, -0.022994995, -0.05795288, -0.014480591, 0.026031494, -0.024841309, 0.004875183, 0.010375977, -0.0126571655, -0.06298828, 0.026855469, -0.021499634, 0.058898926, -0.02748108, 0.017074585, 0.016647339, 0.0042800903, -0.017791748, -0.050933838, -0.03213501, -0.008476257, -0.008911133, -0.070373535, 0.03125, 0.015029907, -0.013656616, -0.03479004, -0.054351807, -0.010955811, -0.041137695, 0.0049438477, 0.04248047, -0.045318604, -0.043701172, 0.0042686462, -0.031707764, 0.06732178, 0.0209198, 0.0042877197, -0.016860962, 0.020980835, -0.006580353, -0.016220093, 0.04031372, 0.055358887, 0.006664276, -0.053985596, 0.02281189, 0.02230835, 0.059265137, -0.025268555, -0.035736084, 0.024459839, -0.0019416809, 0.0046806335, 0.048858643, 0.035186768, 0.013252258, -0.012107849, 0.001168251, -0.015113831, -0.021408081, -0.028900146, -0.016235352, 0.026794434, 0.050476074, -0.00041270256, 0.01940918, 0.062927246, -0.045043945, 0.00573349, -0.0016002655, 0.0059013367, 0.033416748, -0.0007882118, 0.06088257, -0.025039673, -0.0044059753, -0.02166748, 0.014595032, 0.0023593903, 0.021133423, -0.013877869, 0.014907837, -0.013404846, 0.047576904, -0.03387451, -0.03237915, 0.035461426, 0.03503418, 0.0034885406, 0.02368164, 0.010650635, 0.01222229, -0.019882202, -0.00006455183, 0.0045166016, 0.022476196, -0.0076179504, -0.014907837, 0.042877197, -0.06842041, -0.031982422, -0.014343262, -0.026062012, 0.046722412, -0.05545044, 0.014793396, -0.05343628, -0.025787354, -0.004714966, 0.03237915, 0.006290436, -0.0423584, -0.029693604, -0.022628784, 0.053955078, -0.012611389 ], "summary": [ -0.016021729, 0.011909485, -0.003271103, 0.0020275116, -0.02748108, 0.0259552, -0.061462402, -0.05429077, -0.023269653, 0.0154800415, -0.017837524, 0.05218506, -0.032287598, -0.018218994, 0.024749756, -0.032196045, -0.026870728, -0.0062789917, -0.023483276, -0.043151855, 0.026657104, -0.070129395, -0.009353638, -0.01939392, 0.054718018, -0.08428955, -0.010017395, 0.0074501038, 0.044128418, 0.021987915, 0.030715942, -0.014373779, 0.016601562, 0.048919678, -0.052337646, -0.0039024353, -0.055419922, 0.03366089, -0.00894165, 0.009689331, 0.027999878, -0.009292603, 0.040100098, 0.04458618, -0.025665283, 0.01890564, -0.010902405, -0.023513794, 0.041046143, 0.019470215, -0.0011997223, 0.01777649, -0.007904053, -0.0060768127, -0.028625488, -0.008636475, -0.02166748, -0.016784668, 0.02204895, 0.08795166, 0.015571594, -0.009361267, -0.014083862, -0.084472656, -0.02545166, 0.039520264, 0.031463623, -0.041229248, 0.08630371, 0.022979736, -0.018066406, 0.020523071, 0.062683105, -0.07861328, 0.00642395, 0.04031372, -0.031555176, -0.008468628, 0.0541687, -0.06311035, -0.0046195984, 0.012535095, -0.022567749, 0.006290436, -0.019821167, 0.016708374, -0.016799927, -0.019836426, -0.004764557, -0.03918457, -0.021240234, 0.013031006, -0.0140686035, -0.011260986, -0.020584106, -0.036621094, 0.008880615, -0.01612854, -0.008232117, -0.04446411, 0.02368164, -0.02357483, -0.025039673, 0.017044067, -0.017745972, 0.019378662, -0.010314941, -0.012542725, -0.021316528, 0.020736694, -0.023651123, -0.079589844, 0.026016235, -0.014518738, -0.023529053, 0.011230469, -0.0026512146, 0.04522705, 0.01473999, 0.061676025, -0.033325195, -0.005592346, 0.025161743, 0.07220459, -0.011634827, 0.05758667, 0.03817749, -0.045684814, 0.008605957, 0.008132935, 0.0038757324, 0.03604126, -0.038116455, -0.036895752, -0.05392456, -0.0001450777, -0.0039253235, -0.005317688, -0.0057525635, 0.0044898987, 0.022827148, -0.019195557, 0.017990112, 0.015296936, 0.0015687943, 0.04711914, 0.014343262, -0.009849548, 0.010177612, -0.055480957, 0.0078125, -0.020950317, 0.027572632, -0.037139893, -0.011856079, -0.034301758, -0.1182251, 0.043518066, 0.033050537, 0.03918457, 0.026184082, 0.00818634, 0.021469116, 0.023651123, -0.0099487305, -0.016433716, -0.039245605, -0.020523071, 0.024261475, 0.08062744, 0.0046844482, 0.0036087036, 0.00642395, 0.010017395, -0.019134521, -0.019378662, -0.009361267, 0.040222168, 0.01675415, -0.040863037, -0.01007843, -0.0317688, 0.04888916, -0.0040664673, 0.00020980835, -0.05355835, -0.0016365051, -0.0012664795, 0.029067993, 0.014480591, -0.015487671, -0.020950317, -0.0020637512, 0.00064373016, -0.02784729, -0.023468018, -0.023101807, 0.017532349, -0.04119873, -0.0023841858, 0.052978516, -0.007396698, -0.0076026917, -0.06109619, -0.09112549, -0.010124207, -0.017929077, 0.030380249, -0.004398346, 0.040039062, 0.03616333, 0.01449585, -0.06732178, 0.10632324, 0.015823364, -0.024719238, 0.021133423, -0.015396118, 0.0104522705, -0.02166748, 0.034210205, 0.027801514, -0.0029754639, 0.05102539, -0.02229309, -0.015182495, 0.0035190582, 0.020706177, 0.05758667, 0.012306213, 0.083740234, -0.050231934, 0.046844482, 0.04776001, -0.0018787384, -0.028640747, 0.0036621094, -0.103881836, 0.011146545, 0.06719971, 0.009185791, 0.06506348, -0.047027588, -0.023742676, 0.0093688965, -0.039154053, 0.0071525574, -0.0076446533, -0.011581421, 0.010665894, 0.0019273758, 0.0075035095, 0.020507812, -0.030410767, -0.017547607, 0.046447754, -0.0231781, -0.006462097, -0.0079574585, -0.00548172, 0.018707275, -0.011291504, -0.0051841736, -0.01739502, 0.008918762, -0.09234619, -0.02709961, -0.04220581, 0.016983032, -0.06222534, 0.030441284, -0.03668213, -0.0053634644, -0.046813965, 0.024505615, -0.044921875, -0.016433716, 0.02760315, 0.001244545, -0.0519104, -0.0077667236, -0.034576416, 0.0037002563, -0.00894165, 0.050323486, 0.03366089, 0.028533936, 0.010101318, -0.014328003, 0.007896423, -0.0023651123, 0.039916992, -0.004547119, 0.009414673, 0.031158447, -0.004753113, 0.039001465, 0.02659607, -0.0025291443, -0.0082473755, 0.0021095276, 0.025161743, -0.008796692, -0.017349243, 0.02609253, 0.037628174, 0.057891846, 0.023208618, 0.020126343, -0.018875122, 0.011222839, -0.01637268, 0.030685425, 0.06762695, -0.030517578, -0.031585693, -0.0009317398, 0.03378296, -0.0009112358, 0.0019721985, 0.10687256, 0.0055122375, 0.0121154785, 0.02633667, 0.0048599243, -0.06549072, 0.06750488, -0.039489746, 0.005672455, -0.016036987, -0.015945435, -0.036132812, -0.03463745, -0.017913818, 0.01713562, 0.007789612, 0.000017642975, 0.042816162, -0.02015686, -0.03491211, -0.009536743, -0.061309814, -0.017913818, 0.0042381287, -0.036071777, -0.019241333, 0.02154541, -0.023605347, 0.040252686, 0.010147095, -0.0007996559, 0.02192688, 0.018493652, 0.0044517517, 0.044403076, -0.030944824, -0.04321289, -0.0096588135, 0.0064888, -0.056365967, 0.011955261, 0.040252686, 0.028778076, 0.0060539246, -0.07556152, -0.03918457, 0.011726379, 0.06201172, 0.016296387, 0.027252197, 0.02859497, 0.031234741, -0.07659912, -0.032440186, -0.04940796, -0.010765076, 0.07678223, -0.008476257, 0.006801605, 0.050476074, 0.0034942627, 0.033294678, -0.0068092346, 0.04446411, 0.084472656, 0.007282257, 0.009246826, -0.0011758804, 0.043060303, 0.009033203, 0.0005469322, -0.040161133, -0.009681702, -0.0016517639, 0.021469116, 0.0004415512, -0.03112793, 0.00029158592, -0.07110596, -0.014701843, 0.014709473, -0.007129669, 0.017913818, -0.010299683, -0.01927185, 0.034088135, -0.020019531, 0.0014533997, 0.027664185, -0.060760498, 0.012542725, -0.025024414, -0.018096924, -0.035247803, -0.008491516, -0.05215454, -0.049743652, -0.0006427765, 0.0013837814, 0.025634766, -0.0019035339, 0.0030555725, -0.041046143, -0.0056419373, -0.033996582, 0.019973755, -0.00447464, 0.053955078, -0.031951904, 0.021270752, -0.0008196831, -0.015396118, -0.0015535355, 0.028945923, -0.066345215, 0.01802063, 0.019348145, -0.010940552, 0.08929443, -0.073913574, -0.01902771, -0.009971619, -0.041656494, -0.0048675537, -0.0075683594, -0.027938843, -0.013893127, -0.03375244, -0.008216858, 0.053375244, -0.023880005, 0.0032081604, -0.0031738281, 0.022735596, -0.036895752, 0.009384155, -0.008483887, 0.05166626, 0.038482666, -0.013038635, 0.013114929, -0.036743164, 0.014015198, 0.027694702, 0.044006348, 0.035247803, -0.056915283, 0.016738892, -0.010971069, -0.004863739, 0.049987793, -0.048858643, 0.016281128, 0.0008597374, -0.023788452, -0.046966553, 0.04876709, 0.027328491, 0.0018749237, -0.0435791, -0.057128906, 0.029464722, -0.013587952, -0.085632324, -0.058532715, 0.029129028, -0.07684326, -0.053619385, 0.0066452026, 0.029067993, -0.022949219, -0.00031113625, 0.0340271, 0.005016327, -0.004436493, 0.028198242, -0.018875122, 0.060272217, 0.003818512, -0.07745361, 0.026306152, -0.011230469, 0.016540527, 0.030731201, -0.0037822723, 0.017318726, 0.011741638, 0.008544922, -0.005760193, -0.030670166, 0.04248047, -0.038208008, -0.042785645, -0.018005371, -0.02255249, 0.021774292, 0.009353638, -0.028335571, 0.013801575, 0.008636475, 0.044006348, 0.06188965, 0.0062408447, 0.00705719, -0.01878357, 0.02192688, -0.05419922, 0.008644104, -0.011604309, -0.040527344, 0.006790161, 0.015853882, 0.004055023, 0.030700684, 0.01889038, 0.005847931, -0.04220581, -0.027709961, -0.0072746277, 0.023788452, -0.03591919, -0.014389038, 0.01473999, 0.059387207, -0.007675171, 0.014259338, -0.037719727, -0.004650116, 0.015182495, -0.016647339, -0.038116455, -0.025253296, -0.025939941, -0.0047187805, -0.028015137, 0.016464233, -0.051574707, 0.022567749, -0.0034217834, 0.033325195, 0.05697632, 0.007987976, 0.0072250366, -0.041381836, 0.02130127, 0.015380859, -0.03881836, -0.09753418, 0.029342651, -0.023544312, -0.030761719, -0.034973145, 0.05206299, 0.016784668, -0.012046814, -0.025009155, -0.009651184, 0.012840271, 0.0005578995, 0.006187439, 0.00061273575, 0.018035889, -0.01348114, -0.018997192, -0.020843506, -0.0044288635, 0.0131073, -0.02532959, -0.018829346, -0.01473999, 0.015419006, 0.012527466, -0.019897461, -0.01713562, 0.034576416, -0.005428314, 0.05456543, -0.029586792, 0.0101623535, 0.0149383545, 0.014122009, -0.014404297, 0.0017595291, 0.009780884, 0.009124756, -0.018539429, -0.05065918, 0.09423828, 0.003753662, 0.01890564, -0.010040283, -0.018966675, -0.0005893707, 0.010627747, -0.020996094, 0.0040626526, 0.020050049, -0.004924774, -0.030517578, -0.015396118, 0.002691269, -0.012321472, 0.012306213, -0.0018959045, -0.002166748, -0.041259766, 0.009246826, 0.0013446808, -0.011230469, 0.006298065, 0.0067253113, -0.002998352, -0.023010254, 0.006088257, 0.019317627, -0.04196167, -0.0023231506, -0.021255493, -0.0023384094, -0.0082473755, 0.0107040405, -0.011726379, 0.0051498413, -0.03326416, -0.0154418945, -0.03540039, -0.031799316, 0.007419586, -0.038330078, -0.06286621, -0.0019254684, 0.0154418945, 0.010505676, 0.038604736, 0.00008583069, -0.003982544, -0.014770508, -0.02848816, 0.010185242, -0.040252686, -0.06317139, -0.0054130554, -0.04348755, 0.021911621, 0.03479004, 0.029937744, -0.0057411194, 0.046905518, -0.012809753, -0.00869751, 0.008796692, -0.01512146, 0.001124382, -0.016616821, -0.015686035, 0.030319214, 0.014503479, 0.0075149536, 0.008987427, -0.00831604, -0.009742737, -0.013679504, 0.015106201, 0.03466797, -0.028701782, 0.031829834, -0.0011110306, -0.0008621216, -0.010116577, 0.009399414, -0.030654907, -0.01965332, 0.0035037994, -0.02017212, -0.02116394, -0.020843506, -0.008522034, -0.028656006, 0.023788452, -0.032928467, 0.021865845, 0.0039253235, -0.035888672, -0.028793335, 0.009399414, -0.011756897, -0.00055885315, -0.030151367, 0.004398346, 0.003944397, -0.03930664, 0.03616333, -0.066711426, -0.01953125, -0.018615723, -0.018051147, -0.04058838, -0.060424805, -0.0209198, 0.052459717, -0.009170532, -0.02267456, -0.014343262, -0.0011110306, 0.036621094, -0.058410645, -0.032806396, 0.003370285, -0.021026611, -0.018951416, 0.005466461, -0.008781433, -0.004901886, 0.00021767616, 0.0012464523, -0.041992188, 0.04437256, -0.00223732, -0.00016915798, 0.0007481575, -0.027679443, -0.000021755695, 0.027008057, -0.0070991516, -0.022491455, 0.023284912, 0.019943237, -0.034301758, -0.028915405, -0.008384705, 0.0051231384, -0.030654907, -0.057525635, -0.021835327, 0.031402588, 0.0012836456, 0.004787445, -0.017028809, -0.044403076, 0.008743286, -0.07147217, -0.0014047623, -0.019485474, 0.0134887695, 0.054840088, 0.029937744, -0.048919678, 0.0047187805, -0.013015747, -0.025375366, -0.023376465, -0.039093018, -0.037353516, -0.056274414, 0.12878418, 0.033447266, 0.006626129, -0.024993896, 0.0033817291, -0.003068924, -0.0011577606, 0.0036392212, -0.0023670197, 0.0028190613, -0.043029785, 0.027053833, 0.0073242188, 0.048095703, -0.02911377, 0.010734558, 0.0015144348, 0.039154053, 0.0064086914, 0.010505676, -0.015098572, 0.00041770935, 0.015716553, 0.0049362183, 0.014152527, -0.014175415, 0.008628845, -0.003288269, -0.016113281, -0.03579712, -0.036712646, -0.013313293, 0.061431885, -0.02909851, 0.010322571, 0.01687622, 0.009994507, 0.028900146, 0.015975952, -0.02784729, -0.035949707, 0.010063171, 0.07531738, 0.010185242, 0.060516357, -0.02079773, -0.03363037, 0.026290894, -0.028671265, 0.045166016, -0.01928711, -0.003768921, 0.051971436, -0.03262329, -0.017242432, -0.032592773, 0.0010728836, -0.04751587, -0.0070724487, 0.021499634, 0.017150879, 0.032440186, -0.02848816, 0.047332764, -0.022415161, -0.0035133362, 0.0011920929, -0.008071899, 0.0206604, -0.011505127, 0.0013589859, 0.011199951, -0.0020065308, -0.01889038, 0.012199402, 0.015731812, 0.027389526, -0.039123535, -0.024154663, 0.009773254, 0.017868042, 0.0135269165, 0.00831604, -0.034240723, -0.048675537, 0.000008583069, 0.03265381, -0.022979736, 0.023101807, -0.010879517, 0.023605347, 0.040405273, -0.008850098, 0.0031147003, -0.020965576, 0.029083252, 0.03024292, 0.028701782, 0.01361084, 0.007133484, -0.017807007, 0.030441284, 0.008911133, -0.0076828003, 0.028793335, 0.00035095215, 0.064086914, 0.078430176, 0.07324219, -0.022491455, 0.015640259, 0.054351807, -0.021499634, 0.033935547, 0.023117065, 0.03668213, 0.015792847, -0.035095215, -0.005493164, 0.012504578, 0.012321472, 0.054840088, -0.053497314, -0.005382538, -0.054779053, 0.036468506, -0.066223145, -0.01348114, 0.0070381165, -0.05215454, 0.038360596, -0.011566162, 0.025222778, -0.024429321, -0.021011353, -0.024765015, 0.05126953, -0.017837524, -0.024337769, 0.019561768, -0.0008664131, -0.05859375, -0.0038585663, -0.020263672, 0.033325195, -0.021972656, -0.035308838, 0.024124146, 0.020385742, -0.006702423, -0.062683105, -0.023788452, -0.03945923, 0.026535034, -0.01612854, 0.008728027, 0.027359009, -0.021209717, -0.058929443, -0.045043945, 0.014457703, -0.043395996, 0.08544922, 0.027374268, -0.018203735, -0.06011963, 0.02671814, -0.04196167, 0.04727173, -0.042022705, 0.000213027, 0.0029792786, -0.0036640167, -0.0010614395, -0.031173706, 0.020568848, 0.017471313, -0.004673004, -0.023910522, 0.005241394, -0.0016508102, 0.04751587, -0.02418518, -0.0039253235, 0.0041160583, 0.020187378, 0.0043182373, 0.0041236877, -0.0010251999, -0.010650635, 0.01525116, 0.008125305, 0.0029830933, -0.012870789, 0.04257202, 0.019256592, 0.018569946, 0.03479004, -0.028396606, 0.054718018, 0.030883789, -0.035308838, 0.0069732666, -0.0034656525, 0.019439697, -0.0044403076, -0.017150879, 0.009284973, -0.05441284, 0.0023269653, 0.043792725, 0.013572693, -0.022750854, -0.013145447, -0.028823853, -0.009841919, -0.007736206, -0.046875, 0.011459351, 0.016845703, -0.009498596, 0.00819397, 0.02885437, 0.006690979, -0.004676819, 0.001581192, -0.023117065, 0.008491516, 0.022232056, -0.0032863617, -0.0035934448, -0.015701294, 0.01739502, -0.0011739731, -0.039764404, -0.057128906, -0.03152466, 0.021835327, -0.01234436, 0.0126953125, 0.04107666, -0.03201294, 0.029220581, 0.05996704, 0.02885437, 0.023071289, 0.012290955, -0.036895752, 0.020507812, -0.0055389404 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06898v1
Retrieval and Generative Approaches for a Pregnancy Chatbot in Nepali with Stemmed and Non-Stemmed Data : A Comparative Study
Sujan Poudel, Nabin Ghimire, Bipesh Subedi, Saugat Singh
cs.CL, cs.LG
The field of Natural Language Processing which involves the use of artificial intelligence to support human languages has seen tremendous growth due to its high-quality features. Its applications such as language translation, chatbots, virtual assistants, search autocomplete, and autocorrect are widely used in various domains including healthcare, advertising, customer service, and target advertising. To provide pregnancy-related information a health domain chatbot has been proposed and this work explores two different NLP-based approaches for developing the chatbot. The first approach is a multiclass classification-based retrieval approach using BERTbased multilingual BERT and multilingual DistilBERT while the other approach employs a transformer-based generative chatbot for pregnancy-related information. The performance of both stemmed and non-stemmed datasets in Nepali language has been analyzed for each approach. The experimented results indicate that BERT-based pre-trained models perform well on non-stemmed data whereas scratch transformer models have better performance on stemmed data. Among the models tested the DistilBERT model achieved the highest training and validation accuracy and testing accuracy of 0.9165 on the retrieval-based model architecture implementation on the non-stemmed dataset. Similarly, in the generative approach architecture implementation with transformer 1 gram BLEU and 2 gram BLEU scores of 0.3570 and 0.1413 respectively were achieved.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06898v1
2023-11-12T17:16:46
2023-11-12T17:16:46
{ "title": [ -0.008476257, -0.02909851, 0.0017175674, -0.031921387, -0.03845215, 0.00793457, -0.045166016, -0.0025367737, 0.03149414, 0.062347412, -0.020584106, -0.011154175, 0.046661377, -0.020767212, -0.064697266, 0.0069732666, 0.009277344, 0.024795532, 0.013442993, -0.02130127, -0.013847351, -0.015563965, 0.008216858, 0.022842407, -0.026489258, 0.05419922, -0.07543945, 0.008796692, -0.027130127, 0.012588501, -0.0065727234, -0.02609253, 0.03302002, 0.010116577, -0.015899658, 0.007633209, 0.0019187927, 0.0065345764, 0.015045166, 0.007896423, 0.003332138, 0.0013475418, -0.025466919, -0.020446777, -0.06530762, 0.016098022, -0.06304932, -0.00030064583, -0.024169922, 0.025863647, -0.012702942, 0.025558472, -0.0030956268, 0.043182373, 0.018859863, 0.012161255, 0.0140686035, -0.039794922, 0.032714844, -0.0050468445, -0.011428833, -0.026626587, 0.03656006, -0.010612488, 0.005596161, -0.022155762, 0.0017213821, 0.020446777, 0.062347412, 0.013679504, 0.0007071495, 0.012023926, 0.009506226, -0.02583313, -0.024765015, 0.070495605, 0.0014381409, 0.034484863, 0.03390503, -0.027709961, -0.019424438, 0.010070801, 0.0395813, -0.027832031, 0.0087509155, -0.04220581, -0.018051147, 0.011108398, -0.030395508, -0.04171753, -0.0036201477, -0.015304565, -0.06652832, 0.021514893, 0.01966858, -0.07098389, -0.020126343, 0.009841919, -0.008773804, -0.02935791, -0.013000488, 0.043273926, -0.066589355, -0.0012130737, 0.021408081, 0.007587433, -0.019729614, -0.066467285, 0.031585693, 0.032714844, -0.038848877, 0.05883789, 0.026138306, -0.013572693, 0.009712219, 0.025161743, 0.006336212, 0.017974854, -0.001244545, 0.025238037, -0.0211792, -0.023040771, 0.026947021, -0.013763428, 0.021820068, -0.014060974, -0.05026245, 0.027618408, -0.01965332, 0.025817871, 0.012397766, 0.044281006, -0.040374756, -0.056121826, -0.056396484, 0.037719727, -0.026489258, -0.024612427, 0.007926941, -0.016311646, 0.044311523, -0.022766113, 0.0077934265, 0.017974854, -0.023773193, 0.008926392, 0.02796936, -0.006008148, -0.041625977, -0.006088257, -0.048919678, 0.030181885, 0.033599854, -0.024383545, -0.06335449, -0.036346436, -0.09112549, -0.009391785, 0.015403748, -0.019348145, 0.0018234253, 0.010765076, 0.0012216568, -0.015487671, -0.0072135925, -0.023788452, -0.020309448, 0.009521484, 0.034484863, -0.0099487305, 0.025344849, 0.053131104, 0.059326172, -0.0018997192, 0.012046814, -0.0050621033, -0.006149292, 0.012748718, -0.003665924, 0.012962341, 0.033050537, -0.01727295, -0.025741577, 0.056671143, -0.08557129, 0.042388916, -0.00894928, 0.03250122, 0.045837402, -0.01687622, 0.013587952, 0.04449463, -0.043914795, -0.0033855438, -0.01939392, -0.008117676, -0.00039100647, 0.007774353, -0.0003619194, -0.015197754, 0.016601562, -0.000916481, -0.00248909, -0.01499176, -0.07104492, -0.019973755, -0.045684814, 0.022979736, -0.0093688965, 0.05114746, 0.055236816, 0.038391113, -0.04006958, 0.04324341, 0.020721436, -0.056732178, 0.058776855, 0.008415222, 0.010681152, -0.036895752, 0.011543274, -0.033477783, -0.008636475, 0.05026245, -0.0018148422, -0.018066406, 0.0129470825, -0.024475098, 0.04724121, 0.022201538, 0.04147339, -0.023147583, 0.023376465, -0.004348755, -0.016616821, 0.012550354, 0.0079956055, -0.043670654, 0.008384705, 0.011695862, 0.0060653687, 0.023284912, -0.0018587112, 0.02949524, 0.046447754, -0.04119873, -0.0043792725, 0.01651001, 0.012016296, 0.017791748, 0.04598999, -0.0026474, 0.037200928, 0.03552246, -0.002368927, 0.047790527, -0.053527832, -0.037231445, 0.02104187, -0.00970459, 0.018066406, -0.01828003, 0.045043945, -0.012626648, -0.03616333, -0.018814087, -0.0077056885, -0.00091028214, -0.009269714, -0.03189087, 0.028747559, 0.030838013, 0.017288208, -0.023849487, -0.012207031, -0.005695343, -0.04019165, 0.022903442, 0.0546875, -0.04724121, -0.012260437, -0.009178162, 0.051452637, -0.0026416779, 0.042114258, 0.024673462, 0.03768921, -0.014808655, -0.009147644, 0.024505615, 0.024002075, 0.061706543, 0.027664185, 0.003566742, 0.0009012222, 0.031066895, 0.08294678, 0.0947876, -0.054595947, 0.04736328, -0.026168823, 0.002784729, 0.009361267, -0.016143799, 0.007987976, -0.00044107437, 0.009162903, 0.021606445, 0.0055389404, -0.022842407, 0.014480591, 0.068115234, 0.021713257, 0.030822754, -0.03866577, -0.058807373, 0.0021953583, -0.004802704, -0.03173828, -0.008224487, 0.05697632, -0.017700195, -0.011512756, -0.019805908, -0.005203247, -0.025665283, -0.0051727295, -0.01499939, 0.001411438, 0.009239197, 0.012268066, 0.047424316, -0.03970337, 0.056854248, 0.0068206787, 0.01852417, -0.017807007, 0.028503418, -0.0010099411, -0.03353882, 0.0034236908, 0.059173584, -0.031280518, -0.021011353, 0.0112838745, -0.05303955, 0.01751709, 0.003967285, -0.0015125275, 0.0067863464, 0.011955261, -0.019454956, 0.001206398, 0.010025024, 0.082214355, -0.06604004, -0.060302734, 0.04135132, 0.018569946, -0.014518738, 0.028869629, 0.025924683, 0.004940033, -0.048675537, -0.013519287, -0.045196533, -0.04397583, 0.0047798157, 0.03302002, 0.05206299, -0.006008148, 0.02911377, -0.058685303, -0.011375427, 0.014083862, -0.029205322, 0.008041382, -0.034454346, -0.026184082, -0.008766174, -0.01889038, 0.0019388199, -0.03189087, 0.044403076, 0.07745361, 0.018157959, 0.010719299, -0.025314331, 0.036010742, 0.008491516, -0.0012245178, -0.050567627, -0.03274536, -0.029876709, 0.05078125, 0.034851074, -0.05633545, -0.007965088, -0.047210693, 0.0035076141, 0.10522461, -0.009513855, -0.0029029846, 0.033050537, -0.049468994, 0.064697266, 0.03060913, 0.010292053, 0.04397583, 0.019714355, 0.0019369125, -0.038757324, 0.0066070557, -0.07623291, 0.0027427673, -0.021942139, -0.055511475, -0.0007867813, 0.019546509, -0.02079773, 0.005214691, -0.028015137, -0.042144775, -0.010688782, -0.015037537, 0.06665039, 0.014152527, 0.029266357, 0.004108429, -0.04031372, -0.009468079, -0.03918457, 0.008888245, -0.035491943, 0.0071792603, 0.017089844, -0.028015137, 0.061920166, -0.022323608, -0.00137043, 0.0047454834, -0.00705719, -0.013648987, 0.03173828, -0.028640747, -0.010299683, 0.0030155182, 0.009887695, -0.04196167, 0.037017822, -0.033569336, 0.02760315, -0.057769775, 0.025436401, -0.028457642, 0.022521973, 0.0064582825, 0.00869751, -0.026779175, 0.022598267, 0.028320312, 0.0034637451, 0.006385803, -0.005630493, 0.05456543, 0.041229248, -0.040740967, 0.02456665, -0.020324707, 0.018630981, 0.06390381, -0.058380127, 0.004043579, 0.0010261536, -0.027069092, -0.056732178, 0.0435791, 0.028030396, 0.026565552, -0.050354004, -0.025100708, 0.034851074, -0.037597656, -0.11047363, -0.06365967, -0.00051546097, -0.111450195, -0.06817627, 0.009727478, -0.04586792, -0.06384277, -0.010101318, 0.018493652, -0.021652222, 0.0018825531, 0.021316528, 0.013885498, -0.021652222, 0.0001026988, -0.06021118, -0.024520874, 0.07495117, -0.02609253, 0.019134521, 0.025558472, -0.024215698, 0.018676758, 0.015312195, 0.01373291, 0.024414062, 0.049835205, 0.030166626, -0.09881592, -0.0016555786, -0.024520874, 0.037506104, -0.0078048706, -0.03189087, 0.0034751892, 0.027297974, 0.014122009, 0.010131836, -0.0010414124, 0.035614014, 0.0014228821, 0.015449524, -0.062072754, 0.011108398, -0.032592773, -0.0038394928, 0.023239136, 0.01864624, -0.034729004, -0.035736084, 0.04876709, -0.012123108, 0.008453369, -0.020889282, 0.019836426, 0.027282715, -0.0032043457, 0.0010128021, 0.024978638, 0.052764893, 0.0038909912, 0.0016584396, -0.01940918, 0.05621338, -0.034301758, 0.010177612, -0.025604248, -0.0119018555, -0.022384644, -0.03543091, -0.06726074, 0.0038585663, -0.030181885, 0.018295288, 0.015129089, 0.018966675, 0.0046920776, 0.031463623, -0.046844482, 0.0053138733, 0.017852783, -0.017547607, 0.017028809, -0.040130615, 0.01586914, -0.04360962, -0.08520508, -0.053253174, -0.049041748, 0.028152466, 0.02230835, 0.01991272, -0.0016317368, 0.0496521, 0.018005371, -0.008384705, 0.02760315, -0.035003662, -0.02394104, 0.06298828, -0.034973145, -0.017044067, 0.015357971, -0.0011196136, -0.028244019, -0.02772522, 0.018844604, -0.009422302, -0.023498535, -0.026153564, 0.028396606, -0.008544922, 0.05392456, -0.02760315, -0.0065574646, 0.019851685, 0.031097412, 0.008399963, -0.0013380051, -0.021743774, -0.01184845, -0.030700684, 0.022232056, 0.018112183, -0.0008215904, -0.012329102, 0.026870728, 0.0035686493, 0.0047569275, 0.046325684, -0.000916481, -0.012771606, 0.0345459, -0.001613617, -0.033050537, -0.0317688, 0.024536133, -0.010368347, 0.024612427, -0.015090942, 0.062408447, -0.053009033, 0.0028038025, 0.039520264, 0.006713867, -0.025543213, -0.0033226013, -0.0047187805, -0.06842041, -0.04458618, -0.016113281, 0.05102539, -0.038482666, -0.023666382, -0.006916046, -0.00932312, 0.01965332, 0.025756836, -0.021011353, -0.005596161, -0.013961792, 0.008781433, -0.010169983, -0.026519775, -0.050567627, 0.0023460388, -0.015434265, 0.02319336, 0.056427002, -0.060058594, -0.064331055, -0.03451538, -0.017318726, -0.028152466, 0.0597229, -0.04067993, -0.038726807, 0.052947998, -0.040374756, 0.016433716, -0.03878784, 0.015357971, -0.0022335052, 0.05557251, -0.027557373, -0.011764526, 0.032470703, -0.008346558, 0.027801514, 0.019973755, 0.024032593, 0.017456055, -0.013504028, 0.010421753, 0.0109939575, -0.011070251, 0.021820068, 0.032562256, -0.0053215027, -0.000018060207, -0.036956787, 0.060058594, -0.01701355, -0.054718018, -0.009506226, -0.002904892, -0.019454956, 0.0037879944, -0.034301758, -0.027648926, 0.025726318, -0.020858765, -0.055603027, -0.004333496, 0.030944824, 0.0053901672, -0.034973145, 0.021652222, 0.032562256, -0.0044288635, 0.009613037, 0.03515625, -0.03982544, 0.0019321442, 0.033203125, 0.020050049, 0.025878906, 0.0011758804, -0.053466797, -0.027114868, -0.0071640015, 0.013893127, 0.043395996, 0.019378662, 0.027694702, 0.013687134, 0.009208679, -0.012321472, -0.040039062, -0.022567749, 0.0073394775, -0.042297363, -0.015586853, 0.030807495, -0.009963989, -0.002008438, 0.0184021, 0.038146973, 0.009643555, 0.006214142, -0.00050735474, 0.0036392212, 0.017150879, 0.03074646, 0.04849243, -0.06048584, -0.09094238, 0.0023059845, 0.020874023, 0.010894775, 0.026229858, 0.0635376, 0.038238525, 0.036468506, 0.0042762756, 0.029342651, 0.031555176, -0.036071777, -0.008560181, -0.020843506, -0.010650635, -0.052734375, 0.038513184, 0.005443573, 0.0048065186, -0.022323608, -0.04949951, -0.029418945, 0.016418457, 0.06173706, -0.013031006, 0.0413208, 0.008880615, 0.033813477, -0.0340271, -0.005332947, -0.04269409, 0.017623901, 0.006629944, 0.008140564, 0.010360718, -0.0028629303, -0.007484436, 0.009742737, 0.006629944, -0.023391724, -0.01828003, 0.059417725, 0.000056803226, 0.0027770996, -0.04473877, -0.007358551, 0.046142578, 0.025650024, 0.0056915283, 0.08685303, -0.018508911, 0.038085938, 0.011024475, 0.0309906, 0.01876831, 0.013031006, -0.0003426075, 0.019515991, -0.0062332153, -0.018951416, 0.030426025, -0.04437256, -0.0592041, -0.058502197, -0.028747559, -0.051757812, -0.009796143, 0.0054626465, -0.043273926, 0.016448975, -0.02748108, 0.0029945374, 0.054779053, -0.026000977, 0.012268066, -0.034729004, 0.0013809204, 0.0014181137, -0.030807495, -0.003791809, 0.03692627, 0.026870728, 0.0034484863, 0.008483887, -0.009674072, -0.024810791, 0.009391785, 0.021591187, 0.0023994446, -0.047088623, 0.01751709, -0.047668457, 0.016326904, 0.011131287, 0.050567627, 0.0071258545, 0.014160156, -0.008132935, 0.015640259, -0.025436401, -0.005622864, 0.04019165, -0.044677734, 0.022338867, -0.03164673, 0.016815186, -0.009895325, -0.031677246, -0.017868042, 0.03439331, 0.03805542, -0.03527832, 0.024749756, 0.011299133, 0.010101318, -0.018035889, -0.011474609, -0.050201416, -0.01727295, -0.010604858, -0.013923645, -0.0024986267, -0.0059661865, 0.032318115, 0.02218628, 0.034423828, -0.003692627, -0.0033855438, -0.005760193, 0.007537842, 0.03378296, -0.00091695786, 0.018218994, -0.03668213, -0.0385437, 0.0048980713, -0.0126571655, -0.016448975, -0.037750244, 0.013305664, 0.022583008, -0.00023365021, 0.02961731, -0.0039482117, -0.018310547, -0.009719849, -0.025848389, -0.004295349, 0.012107849, -0.018630981, -0.017562866, -0.025604248, -0.04815674, 0.008171082, -0.04232788, 0.048034668, -0.084106445, 0.015960693, -0.01965332, -0.0036945343, -0.0015821457, -0.020690918, -0.03378296, -0.020568848, -0.022750854, -0.0012083054, 0.012626648, -0.03729248, -0.0050735474, -0.027816772, -0.0038414001, -0.007572174, 0.0077171326, 0.03817749, -0.037719727, -0.015022278, 0.0287323, 0.03390503, 0.06677246, 0.001490593, 0.0025615692, 0.01727295, -0.0052986145, -0.013931274, -0.016067505, -0.014282227, 0.0018892288, -0.017944336, -0.045074463, 0.01789856, 0.030303955, -0.029708862, -0.074401855, 0.037200928, -0.043792725, -0.020309448, 0.03677368, -0.009590149, 0.011154175, -0.10144043, -0.026748657, -0.027862549, -0.026275635, -0.02961731, -0.022613525, 0.020996094, 0.005531311, -0.03564453, -0.00932312, -0.0062408447, 0.014457703, -0.0076675415, -0.027709961, -0.01197052, 0.024276733, 0.038757324, -0.012680054, -0.11364746, -0.003780365, 0.005092621, -0.0059547424, 0.02519226, -0.0025596619, 0.014205933, 0.07659912, 0.032287598, 0.018493652, -0.03918457, -0.033813477, 0.021881104, 0.026000977, -0.0012674332, 0.004787445, -0.02696228, 0.0032367706, -0.035308838, 0.007858276, 0.008987427, 0.0028820038, -0.0005879402, -0.0009236336, 0.030395508, -0.014526367, -0.05001831, -0.039367676, 0.009613037, 0.01625061, 0.0357666, 0.011947632, 0.010734558, 0.007873535, 0.08905029, 0.018814087, -0.016021729, 0.04248047, 0.017425537, 0.046966553, 0.013168335, 0.03378296, -0.02722168, -0.0057678223, 0.0013933182, -0.00006788969, -0.00043702126, 0.024032593, -0.024963379, 0.0036125183, -0.023864746, -0.0062675476, -0.010414124, -0.0067329407, 0.02407837, 0.014915466, -0.0075149536, 0.0032424927, -0.010887146, -0.002866745, -0.0181427, 0.005519867, -0.0440979, -0.007987976, 0.007499695, 0.011184692, 0.02003479 ], "summary": [ 0.010032654, -0.02456665, 0.0017929077, -0.026565552, -0.04208374, 0.0015802383, -0.057861328, -0.010215759, 0.033843994, 0.05718994, -0.0026626587, -0.023117065, 0.04916382, -0.025375366, -0.022903442, -0.0014276505, -0.0064811707, 0.0395813, 0.02355957, -0.036193848, 0.014762878, -0.037750244, -0.012771606, -0.015045166, -0.0073928833, -0.0009908676, -0.04434204, 0.026489258, -0.009819031, 0.039367676, 0.008171082, -0.034088135, 0.013847351, 0.004425049, -0.015449524, -0.011672974, 0.022735596, -0.017181396, -0.0011510849, 0.024765015, 0.03704834, -0.014404297, 0.04586792, 0.007785797, -0.022003174, 0.02456665, -0.01146698, -0.034423828, -0.014556885, -0.015960693, -0.0042304993, -0.0098724365, 0.0011491776, -0.025115967, -0.018341064, 0.006668091, 0.018234253, -0.020858765, 0.021087646, -0.0023670197, -0.020187378, 0.0017976761, 0.016235352, -0.006855011, -0.021697998, 0.0034275055, 0.007904053, -0.00970459, 0.044799805, -0.010917664, 0.02029419, 0.013954163, 0.028945923, -0.051849365, -0.013847351, 0.057434082, 0.0015192032, 0.015426636, 0.021453857, -0.04534912, -0.00504303, 0.024856567, 0.02558899, -0.036956787, 0.009117126, -0.040161133, -0.021331787, -0.007881165, -0.029281616, -0.018371582, -0.022979736, 0.0056915283, -0.06774902, 0.03704834, 0.0211792, -0.029373169, -0.008911133, -0.008872986, -0.017608643, -0.0040016174, 0.036315918, -0.0041885376, 0.0138168335, -0.009391785, 0.001832962, 0.034851074, -0.011314392, -0.032043457, 0.0317688, 0.010887146, -0.017715454, 0.01763916, 0.024154663, -0.055114746, -0.0009365082, 0.03765869, 0.021484375, 0.02015686, 0.019836426, -0.011245728, -0.019226074, -0.013038635, 0.018798828, -0.005874634, 0.01374054, 0.0034313202, -0.028808594, 0.001420021, -0.013374329, 0.025283813, 0.0030212402, 0.016845703, -0.030914307, -0.0010681152, -0.03692627, 0.013931274, 0.012916565, -0.02696228, 0.004131317, -0.03050232, 0.054504395, -0.005016327, -0.024551392, 0.04348755, -0.019515991, 0.0066947937, 0.0052719116, -0.0024051666, -0.0057144165, -0.008346558, -0.030639648, 0.016616821, 0.06677246, -0.048980713, -0.08166504, -0.060577393, -0.06665039, -0.01663208, -0.007873535, -0.042510986, -0.012504578, 0.007965088, 0.025558472, -0.016479492, -0.029144287, -0.00083065033, -0.0158844, 0.004547119, 0.027282715, -0.06414795, 0.016983032, 0.0574646, 0.078430176, 0.015655518, 0.013313293, 0.004585266, -0.009963989, 0.054626465, -0.0047836304, -0.014717102, 0.011802673, -0.035125732, 0.054382324, 0.017288208, -0.038879395, 0.019317627, -0.0002872944, 0.042755127, 0.04156494, 0.005706787, -0.010871887, 0.016418457, -0.00749588, 0.0046539307, -0.011566162, -0.019302368, -0.02357483, 0.013221741, -0.017654419, -0.011802673, 0.031677246, 0.015792847, -0.009361267, -0.037841797, -0.085754395, 0.0018005371, -0.022598267, 0.039916992, 0.004837036, 0.033355713, 0.02658081, 0.007183075, -0.018585205, 0.045959473, 0.020141602, -0.045959473, 0.060455322, 0.022277832, 0.01386261, -0.040893555, 0.018173218, -0.0056648254, -0.0063171387, 0.07873535, -0.011047363, -0.0033283234, -0.00894928, -0.0019330978, 0.030334473, -0.0005364418, 0.036712646, -0.013008118, 0.010414124, -0.01878357, -0.03955078, -0.0013360977, 0.0032844543, -0.08276367, 0.011985779, 0.039916992, -0.0027370453, 0.035858154, -0.03677368, 0.028701782, 0.0362854, -0.022994995, -0.008758545, 0.03366089, 0.008293152, 0.047454834, 0.026809692, 0.01158905, 0.018051147, 0.015075684, -0.0037727356, 0.037017822, -0.06500244, -0.08770752, 0.03842163, -0.040496826, 0.045074463, -0.042388916, -0.011268616, -0.015319824, -0.00522995, -0.04623413, -0.0036373138, -0.02243042, -0.027755737, -0.028945923, 0.035003662, 0.023971558, 0.008705139, -0.010864258, -0.049926758, -0.033111572, -0.031677246, 0.043762207, 0.02557373, -0.035858154, -0.011505127, -0.014778137, -0.0033607483, -0.0054244995, 0.035980225, 0.02708435, 0.028244019, 0.0013961792, 0.007282257, 0.02885437, 0.009361267, 0.06585693, 0.015586853, 0.021987915, 0.021057129, 0.010131836, 0.0736084, 0.027496338, -0.026412964, 0.0045547485, 0.02456665, 0.026687622, -0.034820557, 0.012184143, 0.010513306, -0.028518677, -0.017227173, 0.044952393, 0.023010254, -0.043182373, 0.019836426, 0.08526611, 0.0256958, 0.06323242, -0.05178833, -0.053131104, -0.0062828064, 0.01335907, -0.021606445, 0.006576538, 0.03994751, 0.010360718, 0.0079574585, 0.012107849, 0.029449463, -0.03137207, 0.032287598, 0.003982544, -0.005706787, 0.010757446, -0.010002136, 0.020965576, -0.0016269684, 0.057739258, -0.009750366, 0.003326416, -0.0009965897, 0.043701172, 0.02142334, -0.045288086, 0.012535095, 0.091308594, -0.031555176, -0.005367279, -0.031021118, -0.010894775, 0.028778076, -0.0112838745, 0.0041122437, 0.010810852, -0.0019550323, -0.008621216, -0.02583313, 0.034484863, 0.03768921, -0.05331421, -0.01209259, 0.04776001, 0.017852783, -0.010658264, 0.045013428, 0.016021729, 0.004776001, -0.05899048, 0.0018606186, -0.04119873, -0.015090942, -0.042663574, 0.033325195, 0.053131104, 0.016921997, 0.04425049, -0.03543091, -0.011878967, -0.011878967, -0.033843994, 0.09112549, 0.0010480881, -0.029953003, 0.046661377, 0.0055274963, 0.0039787292, -0.007598877, -0.0041656494, 0.059539795, -0.0029830933, 0.0069770813, -0.023422241, 0.07513428, 0.020706177, 0.031188965, -0.035858154, 0.013008118, -0.009170532, 0.040130615, 0.04663086, -0.0793457, -0.02230835, -0.03933716, -0.0008263588, 0.10272217, 0.00466156, 0.019134521, 0.04534912, -0.04031372, 0.0859375, 0.035827637, 0.012863159, 0.040985107, -0.0012931824, -0.008972168, -0.0016899109, 0.005580902, -0.032562256, -0.03164673, -0.0029621124, -0.005783081, -0.0022773743, 0.0234375, -0.027755737, -0.00422287, 0.0035495758, -0.0072669983, -0.0076065063, -0.015556335, 0.08013916, -0.014785767, 0.039215088, 0.00806427, -0.039855957, -0.022979736, -0.031982422, -0.0121536255, -0.015975952, 0.007587433, 0.042419434, -0.02885437, 0.02204895, -0.02748108, -0.016448975, -0.0005607605, 0.0010232925, 0.0152282715, 0.010429382, -0.0051841736, 0.0006914139, 0.036132812, 0.016937256, 0.0039863586, 0.020080566, -0.01322937, 0.0016746521, -0.0023765564, 0.02748108, -0.02810669, 0.019607544, -0.043762207, 0.020553589, 0.02168274, -0.0121154785, 0.021194458, -0.016937256, 0.0043411255, 0.0042915344, 0.04107666, 0.04925537, -0.018249512, 0.040924072, -0.008613586, 0.028167725, 0.08026123, -0.09466553, -0.0029354095, -0.01940918, -0.018127441, -0.04727173, 0.05581665, -0.005657196, 0.05331421, -0.053741455, -0.08135986, 0.04928589, -0.010353088, -0.13244629, -0.08392334, 0.016784668, -0.08746338, -0.07647705, -0.0074157715, -0.015541077, -0.07373047, 0.029815674, 0.03024292, -0.015113831, 0.010063171, 0.02281189, -0.011291504, 0.03314209, 0.010910034, -0.047576904, 0.007045746, 0.0062713623, 0.02519226, 0.008644104, -0.019073486, 0.00027179718, 0.040771484, 0.02796936, 0.030014038, -0.0050849915, 0.024612427, -0.000028789043, -0.09234619, -0.014411926, -0.038146973, -0.00068712234, 0.021530151, -0.026779175, 0.00541687, 0.0050735474, 0.064331055, 0.068359375, 0.000118136406, 0.0110321045, -0.0021953583, 0.0008587837, -0.026901245, -0.011749268, -0.011543274, -0.035308838, 0.0045204163, 0.022109985, -0.06585693, -0.0048217773, 0.04071045, -0.030700684, -0.0019874573, -0.037109375, 0.047607422, 0.042114258, 0.000016987324, 0.02281189, 0.0050468445, 0.07006836, -0.010635376, 0.021560669, -0.008178711, 0.040985107, -0.0049362183, 0.0023479462, -0.011299133, 0.0064353943, -0.031433105, -0.032043457, -0.03274536, 0.016784668, -0.023025513, 0.017181396, -0.0002863407, 0.012039185, -0.0075798035, -0.004283905, -0.014289856, 0.023651123, 0.040100098, 0.006855011, 0.0014209747, -0.051635742, 0.037994385, -0.06567383, -0.0496521, -0.043151855, -0.058654785, -0.020446777, 0.010940552, 0.035827637, -0.011543274, 0.03024292, -0.0043678284, 0.006008148, 0.0014286041, -0.024414062, -0.018066406, 0.010902405, -0.03201294, 0.0009946823, -0.012954712, -0.0064697266, -0.044708252, -0.015296936, 0.041229248, -0.012268066, -0.034118652, -0.045959473, 0.003921509, 0.03793335, 0.013023376, 0.016036987, 0.020355225, 0.015281677, 0.04031372, 0.02835083, 0.011184692, 0.010566711, -0.037994385, -0.024536133, 0.0048446655, 0.021591187, -0.008804321, -0.010131836, 0.020004272, 0.011413574, -0.0021514893, 0.01751709, -0.013496399, -0.029754639, 0.016723633, 0.028198242, -0.0073242188, -0.03503418, 0.020904541, 0.0103302, 0.007671356, -0.0025844574, 0.019165039, -0.016799927, 0.01725769, 0.050476074, -0.0069465637, -0.025360107, 0.0010728836, -0.014228821, -0.059814453, -0.00023937225, -0.017807007, 0.015914917, -0.027236938, -0.037872314, -0.03086853, -0.037719727, 0.006175995, 0.0023288727, -0.04321289, 0.023071289, 0.010169983, -0.001627922, -0.0008401871, -0.0066871643, -0.008720398, 0.006126404, -0.0069122314, 0.01826477, 0.042938232, -0.07928467, -0.008590698, -0.026031494, -0.031433105, -0.025405884, 0.047058105, -0.04336548, -0.07489014, 0.02607727, -0.046722412, 0.009712219, -0.024368286, -0.045562744, -0.026672363, 0.042816162, -0.06756592, 0.0031967163, 0.011688232, -0.04168701, -0.007041931, 0.0008368492, 0.020141602, 0.009712219, 0.0035591125, 0.012481689, -0.004928589, -0.013061523, 0.005958557, -0.00157547, 0.010429382, 0.014137268, -0.029937744, 0.04296875, -0.009208679, -0.024276733, -0.019622803, -0.024780273, -0.0036811829, 0.018371582, -0.034423828, -0.04171753, 0.019744873, -0.035339355, -0.039886475, -0.01802063, 0.03805542, -0.010734558, -0.035369873, 0.024505615, 0.009544373, 0.011871338, -0.0115356445, -0.008583069, -0.04321289, 0.03225708, 0.043060303, 0.020080566, 0.009963989, 0.0024681091, -0.06738281, -0.018005371, 0.01084137, -0.0021476746, -0.00071144104, 0.00868988, 0.010696411, 0.0121154785, -0.02418518, -0.018295288, -0.04989624, -0.014976501, 0.019485474, -0.06512451, -0.0579834, -0.004951477, -0.007320404, -0.012802124, 0.014572144, 0.05316162, -0.0014715195, -0.0098724365, 0.009590149, -0.03451538, 0.011077881, 0.03543091, 0.036376953, -0.05883789, -0.07019043, -0.010215759, 0.02218628, 0.018417358, 0.062927246, 0.062042236, 0.02583313, 0.05130005, 0.041381836, 0.061584473, 0.0340271, -0.022003174, -0.027893066, -0.022705078, 0.013015747, -0.026519775, 0.051818848, 0.0019321442, -0.010894775, -0.01448822, -0.05291748, 0.0032138824, 0.0007457733, 0.033325195, 0.018463135, 0.030792236, -0.006225586, 0.025344849, -0.01687622, -0.0009560585, -0.007911682, -0.009559631, -0.0057258606, 0.0018157959, 0.03390503, 0.048309326, -0.018173218, 0.013290405, -0.0064582825, 0.0027866364, 0.0055999756, 0.046142578, 0.0007648468, -0.010032654, -0.024887085, -0.03314209, 0.039398193, 0.019241333, 0.022338867, 0.08062744, 0.011329651, 0.0154800415, 0.013084412, 0.017791748, 0.009841919, 0.011978149, 0.024353027, 0.009414673, 0.0012836456, -0.015045166, 0.0236969, 0.0027751923, -0.05886841, -0.062347412, -0.049072266, 0.0026931763, 0.0524292, -0.03817749, -0.028564453, 0.017059326, -0.007850647, 0.009895325, 0.041900635, -0.044891357, 0.00040912628, -0.036102295, -0.018234253, -0.027770996, -0.0022773743, 0.010124207, 0.027374268, 0.041381836, -0.010246277, 0.034301758, 0.017349243, 0.012756348, 0.010734558, -0.013687134, -0.00894928, -0.06738281, 0.043884277, -0.0395813, 0.056640625, 0.026916504, 0.071777344, 0.014808655, 0.005344391, 0.0138168335, -0.016571045, -0.005306244, -0.025436401, 0.041412354, -0.03289795, -0.018234253, -0.0058174133, 0.034301758, 0.03491211, -0.027450562, -0.00868988, 0.017868042, 0.04071045, -0.022155762, 0.03152466, 0.008728027, 0.0057373047, -0.033721924, 0.0104599, -0.045288086, -0.026931763, -0.018341064, -0.023651123, 0.0054092407, -0.0052604675, 0.022445679, 0.032318115, 0.03668213, 0.02810669, 0.0067329407, 0.0012388229, 0.02746582, 0.018859863, -0.013427734, -0.0073928833, -0.022720337, -0.032958984, -0.013504028, -0.0017461777, 0.016067505, -0.025344849, 0.006511688, 0.022521973, 0.0041656494, 0.016799927, -0.039886475, 0.0005788803, 0.025634766, -0.0076789856, -0.013412476, -0.01096344, -0.0018692017, -0.03555298, -0.015792847, -0.0020694733, -0.008705139, 0.017501831, 0.05215454, -0.076538086, 0.0006494522, -0.034088135, 0.038360596, -0.09197998, -0.0028686523, 0.00028777122, -0.037017822, -0.03250122, 0.016586304, 0.04815674, -0.034942627, 0.030929565, -0.031402588, -0.05987549, 0.0012073517, 0.0042915344, 0.031707764, -0.021850586, -0.004398346, 0.034851074, 0.038482666, 0.06774902, 0.012641907, -0.0075416565, 0.02935791, -0.016830444, -0.043548584, -0.04537964, 0.0143966675, -0.035369873, -0.019058228, -0.017211914, 0.0011167526, 0.025894165, -0.03982544, -0.09844971, 0.062927246, -0.03262329, -0.02432251, 0.041168213, -0.004146576, 0.03277588, -0.08428955, -0.02734375, -0.009178162, -0.051452637, -0.028549194, -0.008415222, 0.046203613, 0.006793976, -0.022033691, 0.017578125, 0.027938843, 0.032196045, -0.001619339, -0.05871582, -0.0077171326, 0.0010490417, 0.028717041, -0.019104004, -0.105285645, 0.012046814, 0.032318115, -0.0019798279, -0.0035820007, -0.025878906, -0.010002136, 0.07141113, 0.03729248, 0.022644043, -0.029052734, -0.030960083, -0.008369446, 0.05307007, -0.02180481, -0.021102905, -0.027389526, -0.00340271, -0.03967285, -0.013633728, -0.018966675, 0.026885986, -0.015052795, -0.013381958, 0.007843018, -0.04626465, -0.049346924, -0.039733887, 0.03262329, -0.0007996559, 0.013755798, 0.024246216, 0.010124207, 0.010467529, 0.072387695, -0.00066661835, -0.003200531, 0.022903442, -0.010566711, 0.052337646, -0.018112183, 0.061767578, -0.011787415, 0.00730896, -0.01096344, 0.010925293, 0.007446289, 0.0074653625, -0.04949951, -0.019073486, -0.039398193, 0.021026611, -0.015792847, 0.0012197495, 0.029281616, 0.012718201, -0.032226562, 0.021759033, -0.043792725, 0.0047416687, -0.013969421, 0.018478394, -0.03491211, 0.04638672, -0.008682251, 0.0025424957, 0.038024902 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06858v1
Can Large Language Models Augment a Biomedical Ontology with missing Concepts and Relations?
Antonio Zaitoun, Tomer Sagi, Szymon Wilk, Mor Peleg
cs.CL, cs.AI
Ontologies play a crucial role in organizing and representing knowledge. However, even current ontologies do not encompass all relevant concepts and relationships. Here, we explore the potential of large language models (LLM) to expand an existing ontology in a semi-automated fashion. We demonstrate our approach on the biomedical ontology SNOMED-CT utilizing semantic relation types from the widely used UMLS semantic network. We propose a method that uses conversational interactions with an LLM to analyze clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) and detect the relationships among the new medical concepts that are not present in SNOMED-CT. Our initial experimentation with the conversational prompts yielded promising preliminary results given a manually generated gold standard, directing our future potential improvements.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06858v1
2023-11-12T14:20:55
2023-11-12T14:20:55
{ "title": [ -0.014175415, -0.009750366, -0.038269043, -0.061035156, -0.024536133, 0.011924744, -0.071777344, 0.0023422241, 0.020965576, 0.008926392, -0.03164673, -0.017974854, 0.016479492, -0.025619507, -0.015670776, -0.008460999, 0.0036029816, 0.043273926, 0.040222168, -0.01637268, 0.006626129, -0.021835327, 0.07006836, -0.022354126, 0.027954102, -0.025360107, -0.046417236, -0.00046682358, -0.032440186, -0.05014038, -0.00016713142, 0.019317627, 0.040130615, -0.009674072, -0.018554688, -0.058624268, -0.018218994, -0.014320374, -0.0152282715, -0.0009365082, 0.029556274, -0.026916504, 0.07702637, -0.00856781, 0.012245178, 0.048980713, -0.029434204, -0.042510986, -0.0062408447, 0.0075263977, 0.00019562244, 0.00046157837, 0.0014257431, 0.013000488, -0.0004863739, -0.008857727, -0.012641907, -0.019561768, 0.04562378, 0.01586914, -0.002325058, -0.045898438, 0.030960083, -0.031311035, -0.030090332, 0.020080566, -0.015548706, 0.00010937452, 0.03265381, 0.0046424866, -0.010231018, -0.016052246, -0.006652832, 0.0026340485, -0.04248047, 0.006034851, 0.017150879, 0.003206253, 0.034973145, -0.031311035, 0.02684021, 0.02885437, 0.030334473, -0.015975952, 0.012260437, -0.013153076, -0.004283905, -0.028717041, -0.033966064, -0.060943604, -0.01197052, -0.03463745, -0.067871094, 0.017074585, 0.0098724365, -0.049194336, -0.0032787323, -0.009391785, -0.005844116, -0.0074424744, 0.008163452, -0.01109314, 0.0022125244, -0.015640259, 0.01637268, 0.0357666, -0.021728516, -0.047698975, 0.019943237, 0.015335083, -0.025161743, 0.009422302, 0.022842407, -0.026901245, 0.0047950745, 0.007259369, -0.014785767, 0.041625977, 0.02746582, 0.037902832, -0.01713562, -0.011428833, -0.017822266, 0.016906738, 0.0116119385, -0.029266357, -0.019561768, 0.04486084, -0.02418518, 0.021453857, 0.017364502, 0.054260254, -0.067871094, -0.05117798, -0.06222534, 0.024993896, -0.0052337646, 0.017196655, -0.031173706, 0.01285553, 0.023712158, -0.009643555, 0.012825012, 0.012619019, -0.019973755, -0.009300232, 0.02571106, 0.02758789, -0.033813477, -0.05847168, 0.009269714, 0.001373291, 0.049621582, -0.021453857, -0.07354736, -0.03945923, -0.07891846, -0.025009155, 0.006454468, -0.049560547, 0.004032135, 0.018417358, 0.0026340485, -0.025848389, -0.01777649, -0.030944824, 0.016540527, 0.020828247, 0.021942139, 0.012710571, 0.019134521, 0.0073280334, 0.02583313, 0.0018825531, 0.0064582825, 0.013320923, 0.018844604, -0.007709503, -0.015335083, 0.00818634, 0.014480591, -0.024414062, -0.032043457, 0.032196045, -0.050628662, -0.027999878, -0.013473511, 0.023025513, 0.086120605, -0.0027866364, -0.045318604, -0.017242432, -0.03479004, -0.025939941, -0.05065918, 0.008308411, 0.02494812, 0.034698486, -0.008766174, 0.024398804, -0.03488159, 0.042541504, -0.056671143, 0.046936035, -0.010375977, -0.014762878, 0.00017404556, 0.006072998, -0.022460938, 0.05331421, 0.05053711, 0.050811768, -0.076538086, 0.020584106, 0.0032463074, -0.040771484, 0.018325806, -0.0043640137, -0.024459839, -0.053833008, -0.014221191, -0.009292603, 0.008422852, 0.076293945, -0.0043678284, 0.006137848, -0.007457733, -0.008171082, -0.014091492, 0.02671814, 0.015625, -0.012374878, 0.013763428, 0.0027885437, -0.01751709, -0.016220093, 0.025512695, -0.04006958, 0.013519287, 0.0077056885, -0.006248474, -0.0390625, -0.014289856, 0.02671814, 0.025436401, 0.027633667, 0.011764526, 0.014556885, 0.006046295, 0.030059814, 0.057556152, 0.029251099, 0.011390686, 0.03237915, 0.008369446, 0.03050232, 0.0038700104, -0.037902832, -0.021102905, 0.014221191, 0.049194336, 0.027114868, -0.04144287, 0.026000977, -0.07421875, -0.0026988983, -0.044525146, -0.010093689, -0.0051651, -0.0010938644, 0.037872314, -0.026046753, 0.015281677, 0.007080078, -0.03250122, -0.010536194, 0.0007677078, 0.003479004, 0.023223877, -0.035949707, -0.0024490356, 0.0056991577, 0.045410156, 0.00057029724, 0.011260986, 0.018707275, 0.04171753, -0.0090789795, -0.007949829, -0.013267517, 0.030181885, 0.021942139, 0.01927185, 0.00058698654, 0.033081055, -0.0118637085, 0.035461426, 0.030639648, -0.007858276, 0.0027484894, -0.04534912, 0.026229858, 0.0033245087, -0.0020503998, 0.02204895, -0.016998291, 0.015472412, 0.029312134, -0.007926941, -0.0051994324, -0.033325195, 0.033111572, 0.009132385, 0.0072021484, -0.049591064, -0.045898438, -0.025360107, -0.01007843, -0.05886841, -0.011123657, 0.034210205, 0.021102905, -0.007972717, -0.004714966, 0.027679443, -0.03289795, -0.034362793, -0.018920898, 0.029067993, -0.029678345, -0.035736084, -0.040222168, -0.09307861, -0.02458191, -0.0005354881, 0.0030441284, -0.006137848, 0.014213562, -0.016357422, -0.0057754517, -0.0041999817, 0.012145996, 0.006046295, -0.037628174, 0.044769287, -0.055480957, 0.02708435, 0.0036621094, 0.01953125, 0.030059814, -0.036468506, 0.006412506, -0.0038700104, 0.039794922, 0.054473877, -0.052978516, -0.0039596558, 0.05886841, -0.012756348, 0.003545761, 0.027770996, 0.030166626, 0.034362793, -0.0284729, -0.058380127, -0.05316162, 0.0037345886, 0.015396118, -0.0015058517, 0.01914978, -0.054138184, -0.011192322, -0.06463623, 0.004306793, 0.04849243, 0.028381348, 0.035705566, -0.0181427, -0.027511597, 0.02154541, 0.013130188, 0.026641846, -0.015792847, 0.040649414, 0.09729004, 0.020309448, 0.00844574, 0.025268555, 0.012458801, -0.012084961, -0.047668457, -0.04598999, 0.0418396, -0.029586792, -0.005657196, 0.02508545, -0.070373535, -0.032684326, -0.0062026978, 0.020553589, 0.0848999, -0.0012807846, -0.0070114136, 0.043701172, -0.07220459, 0.04168701, 0.009307861, 0.0039138794, 0.02015686, 0.00472641, -0.016082764, 0.02557373, -0.010772705, -0.0071754456, -0.007762909, -0.02986145, -0.09881592, 0.012161255, -0.003446579, -0.023529053, -0.025817871, 0.01285553, -0.0463562, -0.011383057, -0.0051498413, 0.044555664, 0.029815674, 0.008865356, 0.0055618286, -0.008544922, 0.012176514, -0.03137207, -0.013366699, -0.033325195, -0.007888794, 0.03643799, -0.020889282, 0.046539307, -0.03643799, 0.007286072, 0.002571106, -0.0016975403, -0.024139404, 0.019378662, -0.03036499, -0.034698486, -0.0063438416, 0.013328552, -0.015014648, -0.00027251244, -0.018005371, 0.01373291, -0.025619507, 0.010185242, -0.019119263, 0.026870728, -0.0064353943, 0.023101807, 0.008300781, -0.052459717, 0.0018596649, -0.028289795, -0.0552063, -0.00038075447, 0.015434265, 0.0050621033, -0.033966064, 0.008293152, -0.047027588, 0.013931274, 0.006641388, 0.027526855, -0.0035972595, -0.016845703, 0.014083862, 0.009254456, -0.018218994, -0.011299133, 0.0051078796, 0.008934021, -0.013702393, 0.023254395, -0.02192688, -0.11633301, -0.047851562, -0.00094366074, -0.15600586, -0.079589844, 0.018188477, -0.057861328, -0.06866455, -0.07299805, 0.0068244934, -0.07531738, -0.042053223, 0.033172607, -0.0082092285, 0.049987793, 0.020965576, -0.0748291, 0.017028809, 0.06097412, 0.012565613, 0.027175903, 0.055236816, -0.010070801, 0.00049352646, -0.001209259, 0.027282715, 0.04876709, 0.058807373, 0.02015686, -0.018936157, 0.021347046, -0.023452759, -0.005332947, 0.056152344, -0.010215759, 0.01802063, 0.0033931732, 0.011688232, 0.026245117, 0.010604858, 0.057556152, -0.029312134, -0.014595032, -0.007003784, 0.01386261, 0.001414299, -0.020858765, 0.0052604675, -0.016845703, -0.0030670166, 0.03274536, 0.025848389, 0.042297363, 0.009895325, -0.022491455, 0.010025024, -0.004875183, -0.010978699, -0.003929138, 0.024978638, 0.00015366077, -0.013282776, 0.059783936, -0.011138916, 0.068725586, -0.01158905, -0.01713562, 0.009651184, 0.027938843, -0.018661499, -0.018951416, -0.049468994, -0.021331787, -0.016296387, 0.010131836, 0.0038890839, 0.053527832, 0.04171753, 0.015617371, -0.038238525, -0.013717651, 0.061035156, -0.005432129, 0.0029201508, -0.056518555, 0.037597656, -0.034698486, -0.056396484, -0.0637207, -0.068725586, 0.024780273, -0.0020828247, 0.040496826, -0.023529053, 0.011230469, 0.0013074875, 0.012687683, 0.062286377, -0.027145386, -0.061584473, -0.014381409, -0.016860962, -0.009101868, 0.00831604, 0.0088272095, 0.0027809143, -0.029190063, -0.033813477, 0.0010547638, -0.04119873, -0.07897949, 0.05331421, -0.008430481, 0.041625977, 0.0446167, 0.026687622, 0.037139893, -0.011772156, -0.008644104, -0.012306213, -0.03387451, 0.049591064, -0.005973816, 0.012054443, -0.019378662, 0.00049734116, 0.022994995, 0.02859497, -0.0069618225, -0.0011348724, -0.011764526, 0.002248764, 0.011482239, 0.0021400452, -0.006263733, -0.04309082, -0.029449463, -0.0058631897, -0.012680054, 0.037872314, 0.0049972534, 0.03640747, -0.051971436, -0.024002075, -0.020523071, -0.010925293, 0.027191162, -0.0051612854, 0.028411865, -0.034820557, -0.057647705, 0.010559082, 0.0390625, -0.01474762, -0.0067367554, 0.0031585693, 0.037872314, 0.025024414, 0.008003235, 0.024291992, -0.02355957, -0.025024414, -0.023864746, -0.010757446, 0.013130188, -0.062805176, -0.021118164, -0.024963379, 0.018249512, 0.013542175, -0.0008802414, -0.049102783, -0.0124435425, -0.04373169, -0.022964478, 0.0446167, -0.050628662, 0.027359009, 0.10723877, 0.003376007, 0.04864502, -0.0078125, 0.015274048, -0.0016803741, 0.03237915, -0.026733398, 0.03466797, 0.019561768, -0.07757568, 0.03527832, -0.018615723, 0.0048980713, -0.018188477, 0.01235199, 0.003742218, 0.02659607, -0.04321289, 0.008972168, 0.016555786, 0.01424408, 0.0209198, -0.04650879, 0.043182373, 0.029205322, -0.02180481, 0.012680054, -0.060180664, -0.010864258, 0.021942139, -0.013465881, 0.0034980774, 0.036224365, 0.012825012, -0.04196167, -0.023529053, 0.007381439, -0.011184692, 0.011520386, 0.008476257, -0.014541626, -0.020019531, 0.029067993, 0.03366089, -0.07696533, 0.012802124, -0.01309967, 0.01751709, 0.026351929, 0.0061187744, -0.02116394, 0.0036315918, -0.01889038, -0.045074463, -0.0019397736, 0.020339966, 0.007575989, 0.013656616, -0.007133484, -0.020843506, -0.009033203, 0.0060768127, 0.02720642, -0.030853271, -0.019851685, 0.015281677, -0.012886047, -0.009666443, 0.036254883, 0.04171753, -0.0140686035, 0.017318726, 0.033721924, -0.08001709, 0.043914795, -0.009178162, 0.035888672, -0.005947113, -0.030288696, 0.00970459, 0.031402588, -0.010726929, 0.00034546852, 0.03753662, 0.03451538, 0.07574463, -0.06262207, 0.006038666, 0.016357422, -0.04345703, -0.016189575, -0.032165527, 0.005580902, -0.054626465, 0.03933716, 0.0078125, 0.012901306, -0.037841797, -0.049621582, -0.016204834, -0.0048561096, 0.0034179688, 0.0011196136, -0.012435913, 0.0027542114, 0.046966553, -0.054016113, 0.020904541, -0.03552246, 0.0050621033, -0.031921387, 0.0023269653, 0.016418457, 0.03363037, -0.0075950623, -0.020401001, 0.02293396, 0.025878906, 0.0069351196, 0.03060913, -0.024780273, -0.009925842, -0.025787354, -0.020645142, 0.020904541, 0.022247314, -0.02835083, 0.02394104, -0.013336182, 0.048675537, 0.022628784, 0.06536865, 0.03866577, 0.020065308, 0.04296875, 0.007789612, 0.0061683655, -0.020202637, -0.0024166107, -0.01991272, 0.029693604, 0.0099105835, 0.0018558502, -0.048187256, 0.018356323, 0.039855957, 0.033691406, 0.021224976, 0.0012168884, 0.020401001, 0.033050537, 0.03225708, 0.03756714, 0.07946777, -0.026763916, -0.021850586, 0.01222229, -0.027618408, 0.027755737, 0.046936035, -0.0076446533, 0.0023612976, -0.034240723, 0.0052490234, 0.027038574, -0.013633728, -0.0206604, -0.018737793, 0.033111572, -0.036895752, 0.032562256, 0.002840042, 0.026000977, 0.026535034, 0.012794495, -0.011909485, -0.00040769577, -0.004749298, -0.029769897, 0.0025901794, -0.043792725, 0.018844604, -0.12030029, 0.002500534, 0.023483276, 0.017410278, -0.022964478, 0.058441162, 0.0009493828, -0.030075073, 0.026321411, -0.0019836426, 0.013977051, 0.015296936, 0.012435913, -0.038757324, -0.036376953, -0.0181427, -0.013000488, -0.0027637482, 0.025161743, 0.026504517, -0.01600647, 0.0124435425, -0.08099365, 0.005596161, -0.0042266846, -0.0059814453, 0.02180481, 0.0692749, 0.0206604, -0.028030396, -0.031829834, -0.00522995, 0.02204895, -0.024414062, -0.010559082, 0.03933716, 0.017288208, -0.009048462, 0.058013916, 0.018981934, -0.00983429, -0.026809692, -0.017044067, -0.03515625, 0.035186768, -0.024871826, -0.011932373, -0.0418396, -0.04257202, -0.011833191, -0.081848145, 0.026123047, -0.0657959, -0.00919342, -0.029754639, 0.02078247, 0.02784729, -0.017211914, -0.076293945, -0.019104004, -0.08502197, 0.026931763, 0.009315491, -0.015266418, -0.00012767315, -0.036224365, -0.06878662, -0.01739502, 0.014404297, 0.030212402, -0.043762207, -0.06585693, 0.041229248, 0.016159058, 0.074401855, -0.013999939, 0.0028514862, -0.03250122, -0.008056641, 0.005580902, -0.004283905, 0.0066184998, -0.02394104, -0.05706787, -0.017410278, -0.005207062, -0.007698059, -0.0317688, -0.06011963, 0.030288696, -0.009674072, -0.028793335, -0.003648758, 0.024414062, -0.046051025, 0.0066375732, 0.015090942, -0.042999268, 0.04119873, 0.029312134, -0.008979797, 0.0008997917, 0.017044067, -0.024505615, -0.044158936, -0.0019721985, 0.01083374, 0.004055023, -0.038513184, 0.002729416, 0.0078048706, 0.056365967, -0.032318115, -0.097839355, 0.010688782, 0.019866943, -0.014762878, 0.021865845, 0.0028438568, -0.019104004, 0.016830444, -0.0010509491, -0.006641388, -0.007972717, -0.015914917, -0.0149383545, 0.018157959, 0.026489258, -0.01940918, 0.01197052, 0.033691406, -0.04257202, -0.008628845, 0.031188965, -0.0024929047, 0.0024757385, 0.011077881, 0.0058403015, -0.047729492, -0.019821167, 0.013221741, 0.023391724, -0.010948181, 0.015052795, -0.008781433, 0.0030822754, -0.0053634644, 0.019119263, -0.029510498, -0.044067383, 0.061950684, 0.04647827, 0.012390137, -0.025222778, 0.026275635, 0.004512787, -0.00064849854, 0.012191772, -0.006652832, 0.014595032, 0.0463562, -0.014030457, 0.014518738, -0.04660034, -0.020553589, -0.03717041, -0.035064697, 0.016113281, -0.037384033, 0.021697998, -0.026031494, -0.00044965744, 0.0017147064, 0.026763916, 0.03942871, -0.042053223, 0.007030487, -0.04473877, 0.030471802, -0.005050659 ], "summary": [ -0.004924774, -0.018539429, -0.03717041, -0.04058838, -0.034484863, -0.0050086975, -0.084472656, -0.011604309, 0.0005207062, 0.013832092, -0.00944519, -0.01171875, -0.005882263, -0.04147339, 0.011978149, -0.019592285, 0.013244629, 0.017654419, 0.034484863, -0.020401001, 0.018066406, -0.005821228, 0.02268982, -0.015129089, 0.002773285, -0.03112793, 0.0032920837, -0.021484375, 0.011795044, -0.005882263, 0.012931824, -0.021347046, 0.012435913, -0.0020637512, 0.010696411, -0.016113281, -0.030303955, -0.005592346, 0.0022945404, -0.008323669, 0.009857178, -0.0064048767, 0.12182617, -0.02406311, 0.050964355, 0.03250122, -0.0041656494, -0.07525635, 0.0071525574, -0.035186768, 0.023880005, -0.012283325, 0.023239136, 0.013267517, -0.044769287, -0.008659363, -0.018569946, -0.030044556, 0.01309967, 0.019073486, 0.013961792, -0.026809692, 0.02268982, -0.0017776489, -0.01374054, 0.0052223206, -0.033233643, -0.011566162, 0.035125732, 0.0031852722, 0.015487671, -0.0013170242, 0.01586914, -0.040130615, 0.02633667, -0.001613617, 0.010620117, 0.008018494, 0.01737976, 0.003616333, 0.028503418, 0.037261963, 0.03152466, -0.036102295, 0.020263672, -0.0149002075, -0.011138916, -0.029006958, 0.008995056, -0.014862061, -0.01235199, 0.006576538, -0.014884949, 0.02355957, 0.0066871643, -0.04360962, -0.0006747246, -0.011291504, -0.009651184, -0.024810791, 0.062164307, -0.050964355, 0.03149414, -0.028717041, 0.012359619, 0.07507324, -0.017547607, -0.06463623, 0.0044059753, 0.0006918907, 0.004966736, -0.03375244, 0.021560669, -0.045959473, -0.0016794205, 0.019592285, 0.0042800903, 0.033355713, 0.019012451, 0.015235901, -0.005405426, 0.0047836304, -0.012763977, 0.04916382, -0.00077676773, -0.005962372, 0.00031471252, 0.015151978, -0.05368042, 0.021865845, 0.027832031, 0.03765869, -0.07623291, -0.017120361, -0.06335449, 0.0068969727, -0.0155181885, -0.01058197, -0.007949829, 0.0060806274, 0.02746582, -0.020874023, 0.005203247, 0.019210815, -0.024124146, -0.00024354458, 0.019317627, 0.01876831, -0.015167236, -0.022994995, 0.0077781677, -0.01020813, 0.07446289, -0.019744873, -0.08465576, -0.06451416, -0.052825928, -0.027816772, 0.022628784, -0.0736084, -0.027877808, 0.004272461, 0.0423584, -0.031188965, -0.019683838, -0.010444641, -0.026824951, -0.005367279, 0.014160156, -0.030258179, 0.023254395, 0.046325684, 0.05114746, 0.0016717911, 0.0154418945, -0.0056877136, -0.005355835, 0.011238098, -0.0011949539, 0.031951904, 0.040985107, -0.0027580261, 0.040649414, 0.01940918, -0.005760193, -0.030914307, 0.011871338, 0.009552002, 0.034942627, 0.00819397, -0.005329132, -0.012176514, 0.0012712479, -0.0129776, -0.04598999, -0.023345947, 0.02116394, 0.030212402, -0.021697998, -0.00027632713, 0.028320312, 0.021102905, -0.018569946, 0.0068969727, -0.018325806, -0.0021591187, 0.017852783, 0.0022697449, 0.013214111, 0.042755127, 0.028701782, 0.058288574, -0.0769043, 0.019607544, -0.01751709, -0.030593872, 0.024551392, -0.02079773, 0.0015745163, -0.07055664, 0.009376526, 0.0034389496, -0.009010315, 0.07489014, -0.047088623, -0.0015306473, -0.02861023, 0.018569946, -0.057495117, 0.023925781, -0.020004272, 0.0022945404, 0.013946533, 0.030471802, 0.018295288, 0.015853882, 0.05770874, -0.07647705, 0.0121154785, 0.014228821, 0.013755798, 0.0008878708, -0.0062789917, 0.010757446, 0.027236938, 0.01675415, 0.034820557, -0.016799927, -0.013801575, 0.017105103, -0.0017499924, 0.022323608, 0.034698486, 0.06008911, -0.016174316, 0.046966553, -0.017181396, -0.046813965, -0.013092041, -0.0003902912, 0.03277588, -0.0473938, -0.061676025, 0.0052871704, -0.052612305, -0.030929565, -0.038970947, -0.024917603, 0.006504059, -0.024978638, 0.028381348, -0.022583008, 0.00749588, -0.016174316, -0.049194336, -0.006538391, -0.014625549, 0.019989014, 0.03439331, -0.027252197, -0.016235352, 0.0025081635, 0.04168701, 0.0012226105, 0.004573822, -0.016448975, 0.042175293, 0.005542755, 0.012428284, 0.030883789, 0.03643799, 0.015975952, 0.0011720657, 0.018310547, 0.0013790131, -0.0016088486, 0.040802002, -0.0010871887, 0.026412964, -0.02330017, 0.02053833, 0.04019165, -0.024414062, 0.025283813, 0.017044067, -0.03930664, -0.029937744, 0.042907715, 0.001449585, -0.02897644, -0.013755798, 0.06878662, 0.010627747, -0.0020999908, -0.029129028, -0.028396606, -0.016174316, 0.003194809, -0.008018494, 0.05279541, 0.055847168, 0.0209198, -0.0046310425, 0.024353027, 0.020019531, -0.04067993, 0.025848389, -0.0076522827, 0.062042236, -0.054656982, -0.06573486, -0.059631348, -0.07543945, 0.030715942, 0.01399231, -0.00730896, 0.006954193, -0.004108429, -0.018295288, -0.0006299019, 0.01424408, 0.013519287, -0.0070991516, -0.030151367, -0.0042304993, 0.016571045, 0.031921387, 0.006778717, 0.064331055, 0.02468872, -0.050872803, -0.013244629, 0.018707275, 0.05114746, 0.066345215, -0.060668945, -0.038116455, 0.066101074, -0.005458832, -0.012794495, 0.021011353, 0.05895996, 0.044921875, -0.02949524, -0.076171875, -0.04345703, 0.032714844, 0.002922058, 0.019592285, 0.047851562, -0.033843994, 0.042053223, -0.046813965, -0.021133423, 0.0015363693, 0.010116577, 0.07678223, -0.017822266, -0.024169922, 0.04864502, -0.0061912537, 0.01977539, -0.014945984, 0.017990112, 0.08691406, 0.004211426, -0.0019493103, 0.04486084, -0.005130768, 0.0059814453, -0.04522705, -0.041809082, 0.021133423, -0.033935547, -0.022384644, 0.006664276, -0.02658081, -0.00819397, 0.018371582, -0.013671875, 0.04586792, 0.02468872, 0.03274536, 0.02645874, -0.059417725, 0.07385254, -0.0064735413, 0.009017944, 0.035949707, -0.03527832, -0.012825012, 0.012619019, -0.029937744, -0.0129776, -0.033050537, -0.0074043274, -0.062805176, -0.018630981, 0.039520264, 0.039855957, -0.005393982, -0.023086548, -0.02178955, 0.033996582, 0.0048713684, 0.013534546, 0.014968872, 0.01146698, -0.00945282, 0.0143585205, 0.010047913, -0.022140503, -0.019348145, -0.035888672, -0.016296387, 0.044952393, -0.010017395, 0.015571594, -0.022064209, -0.018234253, -0.014411926, -0.0068855286, -0.052825928, -0.008865356, -0.026000977, -0.023117065, 0.010040283, -0.026062012, -0.02494812, -0.017593384, -0.013420105, 0.016815186, 0.004283905, 0.028823853, 0.0055122375, 0.030593872, -0.024368286, 0.01864624, 0.045562744, -0.043426514, -0.0026435852, -0.021636963, -0.03237915, -0.01473999, 0.032104492, 0.03643799, -0.07458496, 0.03765869, -0.041015625, 0.011543274, 0.049194336, -0.025909424, -0.02255249, -0.029678345, 0.010940552, 0.01637268, 0.009254456, -0.04437256, 0.037231445, 0.0023040771, -0.04901123, 0.035980225, -0.018676758, -0.13024902, -0.06088257, -0.0038108826, -0.13378906, -0.09051514, 0.00090551376, -0.016647339, -0.04815674, -0.025482178, 0.030181885, -0.036346436, -0.023590088, 0.039733887, -0.02645874, 0.09692383, 0.019927979, -0.064086914, 0.059814453, -0.021255493, 0.0022888184, 0.047210693, 0.042175293, 0.015586853, 0.015945435, 0.025405884, 0.020385742, 0.0067443848, 0.054595947, 0.010192871, 0.0041999817, 0.00844574, -0.005718231, 0.019241333, 0.06274414, -0.02267456, 0.04937744, -0.013420105, 0.044677734, 0.0725708, -0.0034179688, 0.0021133423, -0.002210617, 0.0063323975, -0.0067863464, 0.014297485, 0.010604858, -0.008705139, 0.021911621, -0.0062713623, -0.033294678, 0.002084732, 0.01965332, -0.006843567, -0.010749817, -0.08068848, -0.009788513, 0.06384277, 0.0010461807, -0.015777588, 0.0002682209, 0.05935669, -0.03414917, 0.06939697, -0.026779175, 0.046142578, -0.04574585, -0.012916565, 0.005645752, 0.02507019, -0.03515625, -0.025970459, -0.012397766, -0.011062622, -0.025009155, 0.013496399, 0.01525116, 0.028167725, 0.0440979, 0.021438599, -0.0035800934, -0.044677734, 0.07672119, -0.00020635128, -0.016799927, -0.08276367, 0.0010290146, -0.028900146, -0.026916504, -0.041259766, -0.053771973, -0.016952515, -0.026260376, 0.012924194, -0.035064697, 0.015289307, -0.024154663, -0.0075302124, 0.053527832, -0.025878906, -0.048736572, -0.047424316, -0.016647339, 0.049621582, -0.018249512, 0.018508911, -0.018585205, 0.0040626526, -0.057617188, 0.012939453, -0.03668213, -0.09283447, 0.0099487305, 0.020751953, 0.0033569336, 0.0680542, 0.011497498, 0.026626587, 0.012313843, -0.020202637, 0.00019907951, -0.00605011, 0.034332275, -0.038879395, -0.011985779, 0.02230835, -0.016845703, 0.007293701, -0.00095176697, 0.010238647, 0.0006804466, -0.016937256, -0.011184692, 0.006099701, 0.006980896, -0.02734375, -0.0040130615, 0.0018491745, 0.021911621, -0.011520386, 0.038757324, 0.05581665, -0.007232666, -0.022232056, 0.019241333, -0.054992676, -0.045074463, 0.04067993, -0.046691895, 0.029724121, 0.0029830933, -0.020431519, 0.011352539, -0.0009665489, 0.012771606, -0.0035057068, -0.00737381, 0.024002075, 0.0020523071, 0.006187439, -0.02154541, -0.036987305, 0.052856445, -0.013626099, -0.015731812, 0.024536133, -0.016281128, -0.0072517395, -0.012512207, 0.0071487427, 0.04598999, -0.06048584, -0.02027893, -0.028671265, -0.007789612, 0.014053345, -0.0042915344, -0.01348114, 0.018554688, 0.06994629, -0.022659302, 0.02607727, 0.038604736, -0.01927185, -0.040008545, 0.029800415, -0.04067993, 0.019454956, -0.0023841858, -0.066711426, -0.0010299683, -0.021820068, -0.012680054, -0.007537842, 0.016601562, 0.004219055, 0.00027108192, -0.012382507, -0.016296387, -0.0501709, 0.021820068, -0.019607544, 0.009124756, 0.027008057, 0.05053711, 0.001124382, 0.009742737, -0.02444458, -0.019119263, -0.016616821, -0.0029315948, -0.050201416, 0.015434265, 0.0073928833, -0.0031280518, -0.013664246, 0.00011026859, -0.03765869, -0.0054969788, 0.027420044, 0.020507812, 0.01727295, -0.0014343262, 0.00566864, -0.0362854, -0.012199402, -0.0027046204, 0.019958496, -0.019256592, 0.00064611435, -0.013946533, 0.0009326935, -0.008766174, -0.04547119, -0.04937744, -0.0038433075, -0.02180481, 0.021697998, 0.0038280487, -0.003786087, 0.009025574, -0.0028533936, 0.026641846, -0.03286743, -0.025466919, 0.01727295, -0.019195557, -0.021652222, 0.02229309, -0.0032444, -0.048828125, 0.010269165, 0.027832031, -0.03338623, 0.050811768, -0.019622803, 0.022964478, -0.026397705, 0.008460999, 0.007633209, 0.04296875, -0.0057258606, -0.0026435852, -0.0054130554, 0.0062065125, 0.09283447, -0.06970215, -0.027175903, 0.0064582825, -0.025360107, -0.0725708, -0.019424438, 0.025024414, -0.017410278, 0.02243042, 0.027862549, -0.03491211, 0.004966736, -0.038391113, -0.00009095669, -0.030670166, 0.002128601, -0.007255554, -0.008087158, 0.02255249, 0.030090332, -0.011352539, 0.03010559, -0.0048446655, -0.019760132, -0.024536133, -0.028198242, 0.03604126, 0.082092285, 0.008491516, 0.014549255, 0.00957489, 0.0036678314, -0.029296875, 0.02671814, -0.016418457, 0.008369446, -0.029693604, 0.013000488, 0.028289795, 0.041137695, -0.019760132, 0.0491333, -0.0010499954, 0.017120361, 0.022155762, 0.064331055, -0.006958008, 0.0023441315, 0.078430176, 0.020492554, 0.020217896, -0.010772705, 0.047851562, -0.0087509155, 0.013076782, -0.015342712, -0.01940918, -0.04888916, 0.024505615, 0.023361206, -0.010276794, 0.047576904, -0.0054893494, 0.022109985, 0.03225708, -0.022918701, 0.04168701, 0.018737793, -0.011703491, -0.0146102905, 0.029510498, 0.0031318665, -0.004047394, 0.028945923, -0.0010881424, 0.018157959, -0.02659607, 0.028320312, 0.034332275, -0.024719238, -0.05758667, -0.045654297, 0.04901123, -0.06689453, 0.024505615, 0.03253174, 0.030426025, -0.0021381378, 0.015686035, 0.016311646, 0.014160156, 0.0039901733, -0.0107803345, 0.015777588, -0.02784729, 0.0008573532, -0.025466919, -0.02432251, 0.01109314, 0.011146545, 0.026351929, 0.04953003, 0.032440186, 0.0021896362, 0.028518677, -0.017700195, 0.0074882507, -0.010345459, 0.004634857, -0.03100586, -0.0052223206, 0.0035476685, -0.03250122, 0.018753052, 0.035736084, 0.059143066, -0.0028381348, 0.03753662, -0.050201416, -0.0070877075, -0.0206604, 0.0018033981, 0.026657104, 0.093688965, -0.032684326, -0.03869629, -0.024459839, 0.005176544, -0.008857727, 0.03225708, -0.008163452, 0.011543274, -0.010063171, 0.0026245117, 0.029632568, -0.032409668, -0.002878189, 0.013343811, -0.0126571655, -0.03274536, 0.00756073, -0.016311646, -0.056549072, -0.01687622, 0.004787445, -0.044677734, -0.02178955, -0.017623901, -0.09875488, 0.011726379, -0.016036987, 0.017044067, -0.049835205, 0.026947021, -0.059661865, -0.016662598, -0.057037354, 0.024963379, 0.015960693, -0.026000977, 0.015335083, -0.02444458, -0.048675537, -0.02470398, -0.0023880005, -0.00020849705, -0.029541016, 0.0011482239, 0.048950195, 0.046417236, 0.08300781, 0.015945435, 0.006904602, 0.019073486, 0.0022296906, -0.029922485, -0.045074463, -0.002532959, 0.014663696, -0.019470215, 0.0077667236, -0.014160156, 0.010643005, -0.023910522, -0.066467285, 0.054107666, 0.0006227493, -0.025512695, 0.027862549, 0.0011291504, -0.04837036, 0.03555298, 0.016403198, -0.015296936, 0.03161621, 0.017852783, -0.013839722, 0.025848389, 0.046783447, -0.06237793, -0.027297974, -0.04510498, -0.02003479, 0.010116577, -0.031951904, 0.010391235, -0.0034046173, 0.044525146, -0.013336182, -0.07965088, 0.014381409, 0.009994507, 0.012588501, 0.0062789917, -0.024368286, -0.030807495, -0.007118225, 0.013885498, -0.006793976, 0.0034866333, 0.026367188, 0.0059661865, -0.023040771, -0.003124237, 0.0012741089, -0.0073928833, 0.0036334991, -0.029937744, -0.00299263, 0.030654907, -0.0032043457, 0.008163452, 0.0009737015, 0.003692627, -0.052001953, -0.013412476, 0.06323242, 0.025314331, -0.03579712, -0.0056648254, -0.020706177, -0.020065308, -0.0019931793, -0.039733887, -0.064941406, -0.007911682, 0.036193848, 0.013336182, -0.008476257, -0.044128418, 0.020767212, 0.051727295, -0.016326904, -0.014984131, 0.015617371, -0.027130127, 0.006340027, -0.03466797, -0.008049011, -0.0058288574, 0.017166138, -0.09039307, -0.030883789, 0.010299683, -0.008369446, -0.0184021, 0.011505127, -0.019851685, 0.0054512024, 0.029159546, -0.027297974, -0.040924072, 0.029800415, 0.023147583, -0.0038967133, 0.020965576 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06855v1
DialMAT: Dialogue-Enabled Transformer with Moment-Based Adversarial Training
Kanta Kaneda, Ryosuke Korekata, Yuiga Wada, Shunya Nagashima, Motonari Kambara, Yui Iioka, Haruka Matsuo, Yuto Imai, Takayuki Nishimura, Komei Sugiura
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.RO
This paper focuses on the DialFRED task, which is the task of embodied instruction following in a setting where an agent can actively ask questions about the task. To address this task, we propose DialMAT. DialMAT introduces Moment-based Adversarial Training, which incorporates adversarial perturbations into the latent space of language, image, and action. Additionally, it introduces a crossmodal parallel feature extraction mechanism that applies foundation models to both language and image. We evaluated our model using a dataset constructed from the DialFRED dataset and demonstrated superior performance compared to the baseline method in terms of success rate and path weighted success rate. The model secured the top position in the DialFRED Challenge, which took place at the CVPR 2023 Embodied AI workshop.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06855v1
2023-11-12T14:12:19
2023-11-12T14:12:19
{ "title": [ -0.0077056885, 0.00051784515, -0.042236328, -0.056884766, 0.027053833, -0.0022583008, -0.01940918, 0.0014314651, -0.030014038, 0.019500732, 0.010238647, 0.00831604, -0.0015382767, -0.03366089, -0.012374878, -0.0062294006, -0.021865845, 0.03878784, -0.037475586, -0.040283203, -0.017578125, -0.05987549, 0.003730774, 0.036590576, 0.028686523, -0.047821045, -0.070495605, 0.030456543, -0.020462036, -0.021652222, -0.0052986145, -0.0030899048, 0.040802002, 0.012893677, -0.012031555, -0.0140686035, -0.06365967, 0.03793335, 0.008140564, -0.010215759, 0.018157959, 0.0031528473, -0.04699707, 0.001581192, -0.07525635, -0.0057907104, -0.03652954, 0.0116119385, -0.0076179504, 0.06097412, 0.005760193, 0.022460938, -0.028671265, 0.045898438, 0.0066070557, -0.05441284, -0.047698975, -0.0045700073, 0.040649414, 0.09161377, 0.035186768, -0.08258057, 0.0019445419, -0.050720215, -0.032714844, -0.022445679, 0.020645142, 0.016693115, 0.058502197, 0.00001257658, -0.009132385, 0.03062439, 0.007949829, -0.024230957, -0.036254883, 0.049957275, 0.00390625, 0.01737976, 0.056518555, -0.049072266, 0.011245728, -0.014015198, 0.034118652, -0.024978638, 0.029922485, -0.029541016, -0.013633728, -0.007820129, -0.0418396, -0.05496216, -0.01727295, -0.032806396, -0.028045654, 0.00422287, -0.017730713, -0.02822876, -0.020950317, 0.0016117096, 0.02027893, 0.004951477, 0.020858765, -0.0018882751, -0.00015437603, -0.023635864, 0.025238037, 0.061187744, -0.023635864, -0.04837036, -0.0068092346, 0.006439209, -0.010261536, -0.00069236755, 0.007774353, 0.008361816, -0.010871887, 0.000702858, -0.017593384, 0.005302429, -0.0079422, 0.030395508, -0.020904541, -0.03866577, 0.04373169, -0.022994995, 0.046844482, 0.009162903, -0.056152344, 0.008056641, -0.00497818, 0.022567749, 0.003780365, 0.042114258, -0.08331299, -0.06896973, -0.04888916, 0.04171753, -0.019577026, 0.0017442703, 0.0042915344, -0.010276794, 0.01637268, -0.022598267, 0.002090454, 0.010284424, -0.009735107, 0.016143799, 0.058898926, -0.00944519, -0.056671143, -0.06506348, 0.013885498, -0.020050049, 0.006565094, 0.013931274, 0.003168106, 0.0018463135, -0.06335449, -0.019302368, 0.024398804, 0.006298065, 0.02911377, -0.0004734993, -0.006706238, 0.048583984, 0.074279785, -0.017669678, -0.004928589, 0.02798462, 0.008308411, 0.053985596, -0.042022705, 0.018569946, 0.021194458, 0.01374054, -0.011711121, 0.0109939575, 0.01058197, 0.0042495728, 0.036254883, -0.041534424, -0.0003862381, -0.019012451, 0.0034828186, 0.054016113, -0.031982422, 0.009902954, 0.0061836243, 0.005344391, 0.027618408, 0.008216858, -0.05532837, 0.047058105, -0.02381897, -0.036956787, -0.04876709, -0.018737793, 0.015434265, 0.045776367, -0.011741638, 0.00085163116, 0.0063323975, 0.013061523, -0.056884766, -0.009780884, -0.056427002, -0.018554688, -0.032409668, 0.022918701, -0.06439209, 0.047302246, 0.06854248, -0.005748749, -0.046691895, 0.04095459, 0.02268982, -0.07269287, 0.018981934, -0.016540527, 0.012420654, -0.003786087, 0.004310608, 0.014144897, -0.004512787, 0.01309967, 0.0039138794, 0.03149414, 0.000685215, -0.016723633, 0.072631836, 0.03378296, 0.097473145, -0.0619812, 0.05114746, 0.05154419, -0.011222839, -0.016998291, -0.006263733, -0.014053345, 0.001627922, 0.021255493, 0.0099105835, -0.0034732819, -0.043395996, -0.018737793, 0.0501709, -0.026031494, -0.004737854, 0.008041382, -0.0025138855, -0.035949707, 0.06890869, 0.008148193, 0.067993164, 0.014984131, 0.02218628, 0.04901123, 0.0005493164, 0.0023956299, -0.0062942505, -0.013259888, 0.016967773, -0.0023593903, -0.024475098, 0.01576233, -0.050872803, 0.014320374, -0.01876831, 0.013076782, 0.013122559, 0.013961792, 0.022323608, -0.031799316, 0.020126343, -0.0019044876, -0.010597229, -0.01625061, -0.023330688, 0.015075684, 0.0317688, -0.055389404, -0.003921509, -0.011665344, 0.024780273, -0.0068969727, 0.04751587, 0.006385803, 0.010391235, -0.020645142, -0.03414917, -0.028961182, 0.020324707, 0.024856567, -0.01184082, 0.005004883, 0.0259552, -0.014877319, 0.07055664, 0.03475952, -0.009025574, 0.0070991516, -0.021530151, 0.020507812, 0.015556335, -0.021331787, 0.01586914, -0.028762817, 0.039642334, 0.011695862, -0.014434814, 0.02670288, -0.06137085, 0.04071045, -0.0027332306, -0.01084137, -0.04989624, -0.06335449, -0.0035247803, -0.032318115, -0.064941406, -0.02204895, 0.12841797, -0.05947876, -0.038970947, -0.013374329, -0.045959473, -0.033111572, 0.028442383, -0.043273926, -0.038330078, 0.036834717, 0.0413208, 0.037261963, -0.02784729, 0.01864624, -0.0022182465, 0.020858765, -0.0014629364, 0.013053894, -0.0129852295, -0.008888245, 0.025100708, -0.005970001, -0.0032749176, -0.018737793, -0.0009098053, -0.02508545, 0.015472412, 0.017303467, -0.024414062, 0.019119263, -0.0046577454, -0.034973145, -0.025527954, 0.02180481, 0.049102783, -0.013496399, -0.0034999847, 0.026046753, 0.0134887695, -0.015899658, 0.051239014, 0.036346436, 0.03829956, -0.04458618, -0.031143188, -0.065979004, 0.030334473, -0.027755737, 0.022750854, 0.06518555, -0.0074501038, 0.012275696, -0.06555176, -0.0340271, -0.014785767, -0.013031006, 0.010879517, -0.019851685, -0.036743164, -0.014389038, -0.008872986, 0.0006093979, -0.007987976, 0.015808105, 0.0680542, 0.0059051514, -0.02760315, -0.023330688, 0.05343628, 0.011299133, 0.03753662, -0.029281616, -0.016326904, 0.009002686, 0.03427124, 0.00009191036, -0.022720337, 0.028121948, -0.119018555, 0.0024356842, 0.04055786, 0.017333984, -0.017303467, 0.023544312, -0.06298828, -0.004421234, -0.00072288513, -0.024673462, 0.013771057, 0.034240723, 0.014709473, -0.0038928986, 0.0022029877, -0.016723633, 0.024887085, -0.053527832, -0.12207031, 0.016586304, -0.0110321045, 0.0010690689, -0.02583313, -0.0066833496, -0.068115234, 0.00014209747, 0.00724411, 0.014228821, 0.024475098, -0.0079422, 0.026672363, -0.00642395, -0.008399963, -0.02128601, -0.023162842, -0.015930176, -0.0024147034, -0.013595581, -0.004512787, 0.0077781677, 0.027664185, -0.010215759, -0.02748108, -0.026855469, -0.029876709, 0.02381897, -0.0031166077, -0.02130127, -0.018051147, -0.030456543, -0.024490356, 0.006790161, -0.032958984, -0.005870819, -0.042419434, 0.025726318, -0.0074691772, 0.07458496, 0.007499695, 0.03866577, 0.006160736, -0.033935547, 0.03543091, -0.038848877, -0.047546387, 0.04928589, 0.061065674, -0.009284973, -0.005344391, -0.008087158, -0.01651001, 0.030838013, 0.004108429, -0.015571594, 0.007133484, 0.0033817291, -0.014701843, -0.013458252, -0.0022201538, -0.0053215027, -0.0026111603, 0.0049095154, -0.0087509155, -0.0075187683, 0.006210327, -0.050567627, -0.016143799, 0.015335083, -0.08557129, -0.01474762, 0.015808105, -0.043518066, -0.05657959, -0.03668213, 0.034179688, -0.024597168, -0.010124207, 0.020477295, -0.008033752, -0.019943237, -0.0013103485, -0.07513428, -0.017333984, 0.06665039, 0.015731812, -0.0018053055, 0.03414917, -0.028076172, -0.026855469, -0.0053367615, 0.016479492, 0.0066566467, 0.044036865, 0.019470215, -0.03111267, 0.041900635, -0.03314209, 0.01486969, 0.045196533, 0.025772095, 0.002439499, -0.0132751465, 0.034332275, 0.018295288, -0.01360321, 0.03894043, 0.01322937, 0.010925293, -0.07623291, 0.016220093, 0.021484375, -0.0052719116, 0.007965088, -0.037017822, 0.039215088, 0.044952393, -0.0051574707, 0.05731201, -0.0063552856, -0.0028953552, 0.043395996, -0.0022125244, -0.020996094, 0.0011806488, 0.02798462, 0.019226074, -0.00617218, 0.018295288, -0.017074585, 0.03289795, 0.004096985, -0.015136719, -0.0068740845, 0.011184692, -0.029525757, -0.0074005127, -0.054382324, 0.0031204224, -0.0206604, 0.006958008, -0.02079773, 0.038116455, 0.028045654, -0.032928467, -0.016143799, 0.009796143, 0.030670166, 0.0121536255, -0.015068054, -0.06817627, -0.0008382797, -0.011543274, -0.049346924, -0.03918457, 0.00283432, -0.0057792664, 0.021499634, -0.013442993, -0.021026611, 0.026901245, 0.01499939, 0.06173706, 0.060424805, -0.01902771, -0.059509277, 0.014831543, -0.021209717, -0.052459717, 0.038482666, -0.018188477, -0.016998291, -0.032196045, 0.057281494, -0.032684326, 0.0070724487, 0.012084961, 0.03173828, -0.007820129, 0.06149292, -0.066101074, -0.009628296, 0.006099701, 0.0077400208, 0.008468628, 0.00019228458, -0.039886475, -0.019973755, 0.0022907257, 0.036376953, -0.0154800415, 0.0007638931, 0.013031006, 0.027511597, 0.011184692, 0.0049972534, 0.021408081, -0.0105896, 0.0047454834, 0.023422241, 0.024841309, -0.032104492, -0.041046143, -0.0019741058, 0.01247406, 0.033325195, -0.04324341, 0.051940918, -0.0055122375, -0.0040740967, 0.039764404, -0.0031108856, 0.025543213, 0.023117065, 0.0131073, -0.045806885, -0.036621094, 0.01739502, 0.025283813, -0.0385437, -0.009269714, -0.01928711, -0.0096206665, 0.01309967, 0.06500244, 0.019744873, 0.0074501038, 0.029708862, -0.0002937317, -0.006099701, -0.028305054, -0.059692383, 0.010124207, -0.0060806274, 0.019699097, -0.03591919, 0.030319214, -0.052734375, -0.010040283, 0.00409317, -0.010971069, 0.0055732727, -0.06011963, 0.00806427, 0.048034668, -0.006664276, 0.03250122, -0.014450073, 0.030044556, 0.01524353, 0.066467285, -0.00084877014, 0.026382446, 0.03704834, -0.0021591187, 0.02507019, 0.016693115, 0.028900146, -0.0096206665, 0.05532837, 0.005962372, 0.012268066, -0.07489014, 0.025527954, 0.014434814, -0.04373169, 0.04067993, -0.04736328, 0.022125244, -0.00067567825, -0.0073280334, 0.0025501251, -0.014175415, -0.030029297, -0.014343262, -0.023803711, -0.0423584, 0.007888794, -0.033477783, -0.049560547, -0.027282715, 0.056121826, -0.009529114, 0.0026683807, 0.010368347, -0.011802673, -0.030273438, 0.014122009, 0.022705078, -0.044952393, -0.003929138, -0.012161255, 0.024749756, 0.025863647, 0.016738892, -0.061645508, -0.010322571, -0.018920898, -0.04336548, -0.037017822, 0.0029449463, 0.024673462, 0.013793945, -0.011802673, -0.0075302124, -0.012496948, -0.016296387, 0.016326904, -0.012260437, -0.033233643, 0.02128601, -0.010360718, 0.0041618347, 0.01146698, 0.008995056, 0.019958496, 0.0009498596, -0.009666443, -0.053222656, 0.025756836, -0.004337311, 0.011177063, -0.008071899, -0.035064697, 0.013160706, 0.022369385, -0.0016698837, -0.025131226, 0.00017285347, 0.029693604, -0.02168274, 0.005428314, -0.007381439, 0.059173584, -0.042114258, -0.014297485, -0.019561768, 0.00831604, -0.023239136, 0.064208984, -0.026382446, -0.020889282, -0.03466797, -0.08300781, -0.02633667, 0.0065078735, 0.023742676, 0.024154663, 0.0044174194, -0.04824829, 0.044769287, 0.020462036, -0.021224976, -0.048187256, -0.018722534, 0.022872925, 0.028060913, 0.046844482, 0.005153656, -0.012237549, -0.0032615662, 0.040802002, 0.0236969, -0.038726807, 0.042175293, -0.053497314, -0.0007610321, -0.016677856, -0.036743164, 0.04940796, -0.009529114, -0.0033016205, 0.05621338, -0.00793457, 0.057922363, 0.00818634, 0.061279297, 0.029327393, 0.01247406, 0.037017822, 0.012428284, 0.011543274, -0.028839111, 0.03945923, -0.04550171, 0.023132324, -0.0362854, -0.019821167, -0.08026123, 0.011306763, 0.026657104, 0.041107178, -0.0129852295, 0.017913818, 0.0152282715, 0.0075035095, 0.032348633, -0.041381836, 0.052368164, 0.004634857, 0.006500244, 0.0058555603, -0.008087158, 0.011062622, 0.028549194, -0.03186035, 0.029174805, -0.040130615, -0.010948181, 0.0030097961, 0.008407593, 0.007648468, -0.022399902, -0.009597778, -0.033294678, 0.022872925, -0.012504578, 0.037628174, 0.04220581, 0.044677734, -0.021743774, 0.013061523, 0.0052337646, -0.04144287, -0.028274536, -0.007205963, 0.011878967, -0.051239014, 0.013969421, -0.022521973, -0.016448975, -0.023406982, 0.02407837, 0.028030396, -0.05883789, -0.039733887, 0.030593872, 0.046142578, 0.011634827, 0.014717102, -0.0385437, -0.035705566, 0.0009226799, 0.04034424, -0.017730713, 0.041107178, 0.036102295, 0.0014657974, -0.01876831, 0.008491516, -0.01663208, 0.06542969, -0.032592773, 0.01965332, -0.062286377, 0.002998352, -0.013008118, -0.0287323, -0.011253357, 0.020126343, -0.050811768, -0.02168274, 0.046417236, 0.05935669, 0.047790527, 0.07385254, 0.01335907, -0.0042800903, 0.0014419556, -0.03970337, 0.02406311, 0.0076675415, -0.036224365, -0.009307861, -0.016021729, -0.032196045, 0.0068588257, -0.030853271, 0.033935547, -0.01474762, -0.004760742, -0.024841309, -0.01499939, 0.051696777, -0.050476074, 0.023971558, -0.03665161, -0.049743652, 0.0057411194, 0.01285553, -0.004776001, -0.02204895, -0.014984131, 0.026489258, 0.0044517517, 0.0034656525, 0.0005168915, -0.023742676, -0.039520264, 0.009422302, -0.046081543, 0.06124878, -0.031433105, -0.030136108, -0.03881836, 0.0005745888, 0.03111267, 0.003408432, -0.032562256, 0.028823853, -0.033233643, -0.041015625, 0.022262573, 0.027297974, -0.01411438, -0.016784668, -0.012649536, 0.0030956268, -0.01739502, 0.02658081, 0.011817932, -0.039031982, -0.04522705, 0.000831604, -0.021820068, 0.031036377, -0.001616478, -0.00982666, 0.008705139, 0.020690918, -0.020065308, 0.044677734, 0.034240723, 0.07244873, -0.008804321, -0.059570312, 0.026611328, 0.00856781, 0.021636963, -0.04550171, -0.03930664, 0.022445679, 0.05593872, -0.0075263977, 0.027908325, 0.03463745, -0.0096588135, 0.011817932, 0.014945984, -0.0075950623, -0.024414062, 0.0012645721, -0.008758545, 0.04714966, 0.05090332, -0.017501831, 0.016647339, 0.03463745, -0.013145447, -0.003255844, -0.0030059814, 0.0025615692, -0.0017404556, -0.0007071495, 0.032165527, -0.024047852, 0.011886597, -0.04522705, 0.042297363, -0.0055732727, 0.041503906, -0.01285553, 0.022598267, 0.0096206665, 0.028564453, -0.03491211, -0.06762695, 0.041870117, 0.030197144, 0.0034599304, 0.048553467, -0.029876709, -0.01448822, -0.012916565, 0.003692627, 0.011390686, 0.009086609, 0.019958496, -0.056274414, 0.016983032, -0.09210205, -0.054840088, -0.042266846, -0.030685425, 0.024932861, -0.024398804, 0.022872925, 0.007411957, -0.018554688, -0.004096985, 0.04638672, 0.0060043335, -0.009490967, -0.036499023, 0.017974854, 0.052886963, -0.023895264 ], "summary": [ -0.018920898, -0.017089844, -0.029800415, -0.010604858, -0.027694702, -0.0079422, -0.024810791, 0.00831604, -0.0046157837, 0.020843506, -0.0045433044, 0.0491333, 0.013725281, -0.018753052, 0.037628174, -0.000003516674, -0.021469116, 0.00349617, -0.02368164, -0.0065460205, 0.001364708, -0.01727295, -0.037719727, -0.03616333, 0.030715942, 0.018936157, -0.06982422, 0.01386261, -0.00046920776, 0.01725769, 0.0075531006, -0.017730713, 0.010307312, 0.015411377, -0.017578125, -0.095703125, -0.03543091, 0.02217102, -0.006980896, 0.0070610046, 0.01637268, -0.0033550262, -0.000086426735, 0.020401001, -0.035186768, 0.021057129, -0.032989502, -0.027679443, 0.03366089, 0.07122803, -0.028671265, 0.022232056, -0.060821533, 0.045776367, -0.011642456, -0.047576904, -0.023345947, -0.035491943, 0.034057617, 0.0524292, -0.00017356873, -0.039520264, -0.0020484924, -0.046722412, -0.03390503, -0.01701355, -0.021850586, 0.006641388, 0.059265137, -0.0032691956, -0.014007568, 0.02583313, 0.011405945, -0.046020508, 0.0023097992, 0.05303955, -0.011756897, 0.01965332, 0.019592285, -0.02696228, -0.019104004, 0.012535095, 0.038482666, -0.022583008, -0.009002686, -0.023727417, -0.013961792, -0.0046195984, -0.052581787, -0.029052734, -0.036865234, 0.029464722, -0.093322754, -0.006263733, 0.000112473965, -0.032440186, -0.0047836304, -0.020828247, 0.03942871, 0.04510498, 0.039611816, -0.050964355, 0.0635376, -0.021774292, 0.018249512, 0.026184082, 0.018554688, -0.047424316, -0.022216797, -0.0154418945, -0.043640137, -0.02748108, -0.007297516, -0.0016613007, -0.05493164, 0.007736206, -0.030410767, 0.012382507, -0.013938904, 0.057037354, -0.03125, -0.0107040405, 0.038330078, 0.0030574799, 0.037231445, 0.042114258, 0.0031356812, -0.031097412, 0.05419922, -0.014152527, -0.027770996, 0.027694702, -0.013282776, -0.021118164, -0.011428833, -0.001868248, -0.022384644, 0.013755798, 0.015022278, -0.023727417, 0.034729004, 0.007396698, 0.04647827, 0.030029297, -0.059387207, 0.04257202, 0.006198883, 0.0009832382, -0.030456543, -0.10266113, 0.003194809, -0.061279297, -0.01260376, 0.017211914, 0.05328369, 0.00032138824, -0.036132812, 0.015213013, 0.03918457, 0.036499023, 0.047058105, 0.022338867, 0.033721924, 0.10369873, 0.055358887, -0.020767212, 0.006549835, 0.0037631989, 0.01889038, 0.06274414, -0.016830444, 0.0418396, 0.0063934326, 0.01838684, 0.0071754456, -0.024734497, -0.013671875, -0.0138168335, 0.029373169, -0.08117676, -0.048828125, -0.038757324, 0.01108551, 0.0046539307, 0.02822876, -0.027313232, 0.008476257, 0.0018043518, 0.01550293, 0.026260376, -0.062316895, 0.0032901764, -0.046081543, -0.001335144, -0.033203125, 0.006259918, -0.0137786865, 0.018569946, -0.018951416, -0.0042304993, 0.040283203, 0.040130615, -0.026382446, -0.008575439, -0.09173584, 0.018936157, -0.025543213, 0.033599854, -0.07043457, 0.0032176971, 0.038269043, -0.029342651, -0.016586304, 0.013381958, 0.032684326, -0.02128601, 0.005718231, -0.041870117, -0.0074691772, -0.012290955, -0.003145218, 0.034118652, -0.036315918, 0.018981934, 0.014846802, -0.0032749176, -0.010391235, -0.01285553, 0.052612305, 0.013206482, 0.058654785, -0.012252808, -0.0018749237, 0.01777649, -0.013931274, -0.0010910034, 0.011184692, -0.042510986, -0.0035991669, 0.024047852, -0.0035552979, 0.02520752, -0.05419922, -0.00907135, 0.034606934, 0.044708252, 0.025756836, -0.010375977, -0.051727295, -0.03225708, 0.02935791, 0.017440796, 0.033203125, 0.026855469, -0.023895264, 0.046295166, 0.011222839, -0.03857422, -0.0035915375, 0.0036754608, 0.019882202, -0.038635254, -0.06262207, 0.011650085, -0.05731201, -0.04815674, -0.032714844, -0.024215698, 0.018478394, -0.045440674, 0.03161621, -0.013076782, 0.0079422, -0.036590576, -0.0020198822, -0.043548584, -0.041290283, 0.028366089, 0.03765869, -0.03186035, 0.011383057, -0.0071411133, 0.016464233, -0.0054092407, 0.06512451, 0.024124146, -0.00041890144, -0.0019226074, 0.0051841736, 0.0236969, 0.041107178, 0.023910522, 0.009300232, 0.0029621124, -0.012550354, -0.005973816, -0.0289917, 0.019866943, -0.0016422272, -0.019134521, -0.031829834, 0.02772522, 0.0050582886, -0.021896362, 0.017700195, -0.0670166, -0.00020861626, 0.036376953, 0.0076522827, -0.009414673, -0.012161255, 0.072387695, 0.023254395, 0.020187378, -0.0036678314, -0.020477295, -0.008834839, 0.021728516, -0.045562744, -0.021438599, 0.07519531, -0.068847656, -0.019302368, 0.036499023, -0.05041504, -0.038482666, 0.10473633, -0.017944336, 0.0059013367, 0.033569336, -0.011428833, 0.024658203, -0.044952393, 0.0121536255, 0.0064582825, 0.034362793, 0.00027108192, 0.026138306, 0.016845703, 0.016326904, 0.06488037, -0.008796692, 0.008804321, 0.048858643, -0.03829956, 0.003271103, -0.0004491806, -0.011817932, 0.013252258, 0.024993896, -0.0040664673, 0.009780884, -0.03250122, 0.028930664, 0.01637268, -0.010070801, 0.021347046, 0.027252197, 0.005039215, -0.013542175, 0.044952393, 0.017623901, 0.018661499, -0.031799316, -0.03149414, -0.050872803, 0.023422241, -0.013420105, 0.052703857, 0.03515625, 0.045440674, 0.046203613, -0.042755127, -0.021957397, -0.015686035, -0.060577393, 0.095581055, -0.0015220642, -0.036102295, 0.046539307, 0.006576538, -0.0015621185, 0.008468628, 0.013710022, 0.12133789, 0.012702942, 0.019927979, -0.0079422, 0.09942627, -0.0061302185, 0.04425049, -0.038513184, 0.017288208, -0.02078247, 0.021499634, 0.018737793, -0.088378906, -0.0017662048, -0.047454834, 0.014549255, 0.025924683, -0.0127334595, -0.0030078888, 0.0003373623, -0.0211792, 0.0007200241, 0.015380859, -0.027297974, 0.009529114, 0.0027103424, 0.028366089, -0.034576416, 0.01020813, -0.024139404, 0.0037994385, -0.039367676, -0.0803833, -0.007194519, -0.012672424, 0.023269653, 0.006904602, 0.007698059, -0.019332886, 0.028335571, 0.0017356873, 0.053955078, -0.016036987, -0.012199402, 0.00061511993, 0.024719238, -0.0031967163, 0.0063209534, -0.021148682, 0.022155762, -0.022567749, 0.004371643, 0.010185242, -0.071899414, 0.08178711, -0.058502197, -0.028701782, -0.014205933, -0.04119873, 0.016601562, -0.023605347, -0.004627228, -0.013549805, -0.05130005, -0.0084991455, -0.019439697, -0.019943237, -0.0078125, -0.00010895729, 0.03414917, -0.00217247, 0.09698486, 0.010047913, 0.058013916, 0.101257324, -0.07904053, 0.00030851364, -0.0390625, -0.07525635, 0.06945801, 0.037902832, 0.00021862984, -0.038726807, 0.019454956, -0.034118652, 0.023010254, 0.044036865, -0.027801514, 0.013999939, -0.026657104, 0.0030441284, -0.03677368, 0.014633179, -0.02684021, 0.05126953, -0.021835327, -0.030548096, 0.0155181885, -0.012710571, -0.01826477, -0.04309082, 0.014831543, -0.05496216, -0.024459839, 0.055786133, -0.007675171, -0.010749817, -0.033599854, 0.057861328, -0.016601562, 0.03024292, 0.039367676, -0.00390625, 0.064575195, -0.0030441284, -0.026443481, -0.008872986, -0.027389526, 0.026916504, 0.0077934265, 0.03390503, 0.012893677, 0.030212402, 0.03378296, 0.0035972595, 0.02607727, 0.048217773, 0.015808105, 0.011695862, 0.027618408, -0.018798828, 0.04156494, 0.0362854, 0.0141067505, 0.025115967, -0.020950317, 0.03152466, 0.035949707, 0.006072998, -0.00983429, 0.0013103485, 0.008964539, -0.010910034, 0.04257202, 0.0032444, 0.0093307495, 0.0231781, 0.032165527, 0.036224365, 0.0096588135, -0.035339355, -0.0501709, -0.0124053955, -0.035583496, -0.007736206, 0.011230469, -0.022567749, -0.03111267, -0.007106781, 0.027816772, -0.013206482, 0.025604248, -0.02330017, 0.032043457, 0.034057617, 0.018463135, -0.023925781, -0.022979736, -0.0033397675, 0.002401352, -0.039855957, -0.013755798, -0.066223145, 0.02444458, 0.035980225, 0.020904541, 0.025009155, -0.016815186, 0.008712769, -0.019073486, 0.062683105, 0.02784729, -0.050933838, -0.10455322, 0.026245117, -0.02973938, -0.025268555, -0.032104492, -0.0054016113, -0.021331787, -0.012290955, -0.025177002, -0.03842163, -0.0019874573, -0.005012512, 0.04559326, 0.029891968, 0.02330017, -0.051879883, -0.034332275, 0.0005259514, -0.017181396, 0.015350342, -0.0023231506, 0.009185791, 0.0049972534, 0.017288208, -0.03857422, 0.00819397, -0.031066895, -0.0038166046, 0.016433716, 0.01322937, -0.043029785, -0.018081665, -0.004623413, -0.015701294, 0.0035591125, -0.0016489029, -0.022521973, -0.023269653, -0.0051460266, 0.006942749, -0.03475952, -0.009803772, 0.014602661, -0.029846191, 0.0022602081, -0.00699234, -0.017456055, -0.029388428, 0.029251099, 0.05227661, 0.0146102905, 0.03643799, -0.03857422, 0.014503479, 0.04385376, 0.0020484924, 0.004398346, 0.023849487, 0.0317688, -0.043151855, 0.04348755, -0.00064611435, -0.008621216, 0.041625977, -0.031585693, -0.0395813, -0.032073975, 0.014442444, 0.062561035, -0.02267456, -0.014572144, -0.035705566, 0.015640259, 0.003414154, 0.03060913, -0.00459671, -0.0289917, 0.048553467, -0.009216309, -0.016159058, 0.014411926, -0.017227173, 0.00057935715, -0.027313232, -0.0045661926, -0.031097412, -0.0077209473, 0.028640747, -0.021438599, -0.030563354, -0.045654297, 0.052764893, -0.059753418, -0.033966064, 0.044830322, -0.0357666, 0.05105591, 0.005180359, 0.050811768, 0.032196045, 0.044799805, -0.0020179749, 0.0017719269, 0.020812988, -0.009010315, 0.020996094, -0.040802002, 0.007045746, -0.002998352, -0.01737976, 0.023925781, 0.009742737, -0.044189453, 0.00983429, 0.0009584427, -0.02961731, 0.022277832, -0.030975342, 0.025177002, -0.001332283, 0.013298035, -0.028045654, -0.0070610046, -0.06439209, -0.03970337, -0.008232117, -0.01977539, -0.019805908, -0.0625, 0.016601562, 0.0029830933, 0.035247803, -0.040100098, 0.03024292, 0.020950317, 0.012641907, 0.04046631, -0.016464233, 0.027389526, -0.02545166, -0.026153564, -0.00541687, 0.037353516, -0.020980835, -0.014411926, -0.057617188, 0.00006324053, -0.0050468445, -0.026901245, -0.031219482, 0.011451721, 0.017166138, 0.028808594, -0.010192871, 0.012145996, -0.025299072, -0.054229736, 0.012207031, -0.049346924, -0.031341553, 0.022857666, -0.020721436, -0.0021095276, 0.009361267, -0.049194336, 0.016677856, -0.00869751, -0.0032997131, -0.074279785, 0.07678223, -0.00015902519, 0.048950195, 0.00090551376, -0.017501831, 0.016021729, 0.036254883, -0.027755737, 0.030944824, 0.04458618, 0.026245117, 0.016601562, -0.0037441254, 0.03225708, 0.014633179, -0.024032593, -0.008453369, -0.026229858, 0.0075683594, -0.065979004, -0.008049011, 0.010055542, 0.010566711, -0.0132369995, -0.021652222, 0.022537231, 0.028701782, -0.0013856888, -0.002462387, 0.016113281, -0.055145264, -0.015403748, 0.043060303, -0.011131287, -0.005432129, -0.06915283, 0.010322571, 0.030715942, 0.089660645, 0.07507324, 0.020751953, 0.006198883, 0.0039405823, -0.012283325, -0.028869629, 0.05331421, -0.021865845, 0.011650085, -0.008781433, -0.018295288, 0.01386261, 0.014511108, -0.026062012, 0.018798828, 0.0022563934, 0.040496826, 0.012718201, 0.030899048, -0.006313324, -0.023788452, 0.025650024, 0.02607727, 0.025741577, -0.019683838, 0.039001465, -0.029556274, -0.005191803, -0.033294678, -0.027755737, -0.0141067505, 0.02230835, 0.017425537, -0.006175995, 0.008239746, 0.004386902, 0.019714355, 0.008895874, -0.025482178, -0.05218506, 0.00422287, -0.008888245, -0.0026359558, 0.009262085, -0.012489319, 0.012107849, 0.025772095, -0.030807495, 0.05496216, -0.0053520203, 0.005268097, 0.0184021, -0.022125244, -0.00762558, -0.012031555, 0.027679443, -0.0035915375, 0.012580872, 0.009849548, 0.018798828, 0.015319824, -0.003124237, 0.033996582, -0.021087646, 0.002817154, -0.006843567, 0.019851685, -0.026657104, -0.037017822, 0.026626587, -0.012054443, -0.007217407, -0.01033783, 0.0035896301, 0.0055618286, 0.045074463, -0.007987976, -0.018127441, 0.017364502, 0.030914307, 0.02027893, 0.024093628, -0.02909851, -0.07348633, -0.014091492, 0.03375244, -0.015197754, 0.03164673, 0.013191223, -0.033325195, 0.004558563, -0.03164673, -0.006011963, 0.044799805, 0.0020122528, 0.035339355, -0.010185242, 0.030654907, 0.025894165, -0.012672424, 0.016326904, 0.03616333, -0.01222229, 0.02734375, 0.03616333, 0.051757812, 0.029022217, 0.039093018, -0.033843994, 0.018112183, 0.035308838, -0.00856781, 0.03302002, -0.048583984, -0.010223389, -0.06439209, 0.024230957, 0.013404846, -0.018814087, -0.010559082, 0.019195557, -0.010696411, -0.009338379, -0.009277344, -0.015159607, 0.0044784546, 0.0023593903, -0.005393982, -0.025985718, -0.020980835, 0.044891357, 0.052001953, -0.013534546, 0.031234741, -0.004890442, -0.041290283, 0.011917114, -0.002462387, 0.026016235, -0.010368347, -0.016204834, -0.012458801, -0.013473511, 0.029846191, 0.009635925, -0.062042236, -0.0065956116, 0.0046081543, 0.05105591, 0.02861023, -0.025131226, 0.032226562, 0.008468628, -0.04043579, 0.023986816, 0.01739502, -0.025787354, -0.07141113, 0.022369385, -0.0284729, -0.02798462, 0.024627686, 0.04147339, 0.008308411, -0.0670166, -0.011047363, -0.007091522, 0.015838623, -0.03189087, 0.00044083595, 0.007080078, 0.03378296, -0.048553467, 0.00016093254, -0.0021381378, 0.03186035, 0.015571594, -0.04309082, 0.0038700104, -0.008903503, -0.009231567, -0.031066895, -0.032562256, 0.04107666, 0.07043457, -0.029403687, -0.039215088, 0.012954712, -0.026794434, 0.061279297, 0.0038642883, -0.0015172958, -0.022476196, 0.023025513, 0.009162903, 0.015655518, 0.015357971, -0.027236938, 0.038238525, 0.025787354, -0.037353516, -0.05014038, -0.0069389343, 0.020355225, -0.03994751, 0.0206604, -0.0069389343, -0.031707764, -0.025390625, -0.00894165, -0.0013237, 0.010368347, 0.046844482, -0.024902344, 0.015388489, 0.014984131, 0.026657104, -0.02520752, -0.0065078735, -0.0236969, -0.023620605, 0.008705139, 0.015823364, 0.0184021, -0.0008506775, -0.0047187805, -0.0072784424, 0.040924072, -0.0063705444, -0.028915405, -0.049468994, 0.0105896, -0.087524414, -0.038909912, -0.036712646, -0.020095825, 0.0053749084, -0.02154541, 0.024841309, 0.060333252, -0.0418396, 0.017791748, 0.04095459, 0.000045657158, 0.021575928, 0.006134033, 0.010818481, -0.0021476746, -0.004951477 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06851v2
Automatic Textual Normalization for Hate Speech Detection
Anh Thi-Hoang Nguyen, Dung Ha Nguyen, Nguyet Thi Nguyen, Khanh Thanh-Duy Ho, Kiet Van Nguyen
cs.CL
Social media data is a valuable resource for research, yet it contains a wide range of non-standard words (NSW). These irregularities hinder the effective operation of NLP tools. Current state-of-the-art methods for the Vietnamese language address this issue as a problem of lexical normalization, involving the creation of manual rules or the implementation of multi-staged deep learning frameworks, which necessitate extensive efforts to craft intricate rules. In contrast, our approach is straightforward, employing solely a sequence-to-sequence (Seq2Seq) model. In this research, we provide a dataset for textual normalization, comprising 2,181 human-annotated comments with an inter-annotator agreement of 0.9014. By leveraging the Seq2Seq model for textual normalization, our results reveal that the accuracy achieved falls slightly short of 70%. Nevertheless, textual normalization enhances the accuracy of the Hate Speech Detection (HSD) task by approximately 2%, demonstrating its potential to improve the performance of complex NLP tasks. Our dataset is accessible for research purposes.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06851v2
2023-11-15T17:33:39
2023-11-12T14:01:38
{ "title": [ 0.0008497238, 0.010894775, -0.034454346, -0.0473938, 0.0262146, -0.0076522827, -0.002878189, -0.01374054, -0.010902405, 0.042510986, -0.020401001, 0.023239136, 0.012908936, 0.0020198822, -0.05633545, 0.0053710938, -0.009140015, 0.053619385, -0.007835388, -0.033721924, 0.010978699, -0.044281006, 0.039276123, -0.0051841736, 0.0061454773, -0.068847656, -0.002216339, 0.006465912, -0.02619934, -0.038970947, -0.008804321, 0.014137268, 0.0287323, 0.04034424, -0.013000488, 0.030181885, -0.044525146, 0.046203613, 0.020751953, -0.004310608, 0.0061836243, -0.0032310486, -0.045562744, 0.024230957, -0.036712646, -0.0021381378, -0.041503906, -0.02116394, -0.029312134, 0.018218994, 0.0079956055, 0.018920898, 0.0012178421, 0.016357422, 0.015792847, -0.03729248, -0.040374756, 0.014274597, 0.034851074, 0.061645508, 0.036590576, -0.044433594, 0.0029239655, -0.011802673, -0.035247803, -0.0034446716, -0.0031108856, 0.02130127, 0.056549072, -0.03366089, -0.021072388, 0.022598267, 0.016937256, -0.0029201508, -0.028793335, -0.008934021, 0.026412964, 0.004119873, 0.041168213, -0.026473999, -0.029037476, -0.011062622, 0.024276733, -0.024887085, 0.0069503784, -0.037750244, -0.022750854, -0.0075569153, -0.055908203, -0.055358887, -0.010383606, -0.0015001297, -0.03289795, -0.0038414001, -0.02432251, -0.022583008, 0.0024700165, 0.07141113, -0.018951416, -0.022659302, -0.036621094, 0.04196167, -0.059020996, -0.018188477, 0.021484375, 0.023101807, -0.0345459, -0.02708435, 0.017929077, 0.03543091, -0.02772522, 0.0048446655, 0.016937256, -0.0067596436, -0.008583069, 0.01197052, 0.01210022, -0.0069847107, 0.016540527, 0.004085541, -0.009819031, -0.03982544, 0.03414917, -0.012649536, 0.033233643, 0.0016956329, -0.05493164, 0.00007849932, -0.0077323914, 0.02482605, 0.015808105, 0.039978027, -0.0949707, -0.07678223, -0.06591797, 0.043182373, -0.017471313, 0.0022716522, -0.013137817, 0.03060913, -0.019317627, -0.0385437, 0.014907837, -0.0044403076, 0.024398804, 0.018081665, 0.06713867, -0.012023926, -0.04269409, -0.04083252, -0.0020484924, 0.020874023, 0.039367676, -0.012130737, -0.0713501, -0.030258179, -0.101623535, -0.03955078, 0.023864746, -0.038146973, 0.040985107, -0.0042381287, -0.016479492, 0.012214661, 0.018844604, 0.0022068024, -0.01171875, 0.021774292, 0.005012512, -0.016983032, -0.017837524, 0.039886475, 0.02558899, 0.009048462, -0.0012674332, 0.0011329651, 0.0038795471, 0.020233154, 0.008232117, -0.008384705, 0.02128601, -0.025894165, 0.017410278, 0.05130005, -0.09576416, 0.0067214966, 0.032043457, 0.05606079, 0.033203125, 0.0011739731, 0.019454956, 0.034057617, -0.040740967, -0.051330566, -0.040222168, -0.014373779, 0.029434204, 0.023254395, 0.0072631836, 0.02067566, -0.012245178, -0.025360107, -0.018585205, -0.02758789, -0.046661377, -0.028152466, -0.029403687, 0.016586304, -0.037078857, 0.044433594, 0.06237793, 0.016311646, -0.054473877, 0.04119873, 0.0054779053, -0.04650879, 0.018218994, -0.01133728, 0.006752014, -0.028396606, -0.010383606, 0.013954163, 0.007045746, 0.033935547, 0.04724121, -0.006641388, 0.021469116, -0.040405273, 0.095947266, 0.016937256, 0.070007324, -0.047454834, 0.081726074, 0.04916382, 0.0073890686, -0.018814087, 0.00044965744, -0.048065186, 0.0014467239, 0.025314331, -0.0055274963, 0.01084137, -0.011558533, 0.009864807, 0.064208984, -0.031158447, 0.0031547546, 0.01184082, 0.028137207, 0.00036883354, 0.033050537, -0.018112183, 0.056793213, -0.028625488, 0.021697998, 0.04776001, 0.0046806335, 0.005470276, -0.03363037, 0.018676758, -0.00043177605, 0.02142334, 0.0023555756, 0.014968872, -0.018600464, -0.012458801, -0.025909424, -0.0018720627, 0.004463196, 0.019454956, 0.007411957, -0.05130005, 0.015655518, -0.013702393, -0.018692017, -0.04324341, -0.012138367, 0.021438599, 0.0073890686, -0.060424805, -0.017745972, 0.00831604, 0.024719238, -0.0036754608, 0.007835388, 0.011749268, 0.013008118, -0.019332886, -0.0234375, -0.036254883, 0.01966858, 0.05557251, 0.004714966, -0.0017824173, 0.03591919, 0.00017380714, 0.12731934, 0.06536865, -0.024307251, 0.03363037, -0.05090332, 0.015052795, 0.0015325546, -0.011421204, 0.011657715, 0.0056915283, 0.03237915, 0.012168884, -0.032073975, 0.014404297, -0.049468994, -0.000042319298, -0.015792847, -0.04510498, -0.059417725, -0.059020996, -0.009941101, -0.066711426, -0.060638428, 0.0041885376, 0.06958008, -0.023071289, -0.035583496, -0.010757446, -0.022964478, -0.007133484, -0.016738892, -0.034179688, -0.010681152, 0.031921387, 0.06750488, 0.04232788, -0.031234741, -0.024307251, 0.0015277863, 0.0024356842, -0.01499939, 0.018844604, -0.020019531, -0.00793457, -0.0024700165, 0.003047943, 0.009490967, -0.034851074, 0.01158905, -0.056152344, 0.016174316, 0.009155273, -0.015335083, 0.0053215027, 0.024337769, -0.0047073364, -0.011146545, 0.00062417984, 0.046813965, 0.019500732, -0.020568848, -0.011817932, 0.021133423, -0.034942627, 0.023391724, 0.022903442, 0.018661499, -0.030456543, -0.053253174, -0.03274536, -0.011390686, 0.025299072, -0.009857178, 0.046569824, 0.005874634, -0.016983032, -0.04534912, -0.02835083, -0.022323608, -0.0184021, -0.03652954, -0.0519104, 0.020904541, -0.030319214, -0.005027771, -0.016479492, -0.0009813309, -0.008300781, 0.070007324, 0.022781372, -0.0015010834, -0.010406494, 0.029754639, 0.0064430237, -0.016983032, -0.02861023, -0.054351807, -0.0041275024, 0.032562256, 0.009864807, 0.022537231, 0.0021743774, -0.08483887, -0.02508545, 0.027130127, 0.000497818, -0.023025513, 0.015007019, -0.06707764, 0.0068626404, -0.012275696, -0.025604248, 0.024215698, 0.046905518, 0.009292603, 0.04623413, 0.00031161308, 0.023651123, -0.011306763, -0.036834717, -0.12023926, 0.02355957, -0.0362854, -0.028930664, -0.0052757263, -0.038238525, -0.044830322, 0.0059509277, -0.040130615, 0.01852417, 0.008293152, 0.02192688, 0.0020179749, 0.0082092285, -0.006500244, -0.019317627, -0.0023670197, -0.0107803345, -0.05026245, 0.01727295, 0.004585266, 0.07409668, 0.044952393, -0.017501831, 0.0019369125, 0.0059661865, -0.016326904, 0.027572632, 0.00522995, -0.04019165, 0.0006184578, -0.008407593, -0.01663208, 0.04425049, -0.019165039, -0.0079574585, -0.04559326, 0.012542725, -0.032836914, 0.031311035, 0.0053634644, 0.025558472, -0.021972656, 0.007293701, 0.044891357, -0.03237915, -0.023010254, 0.041809082, 0.042907715, -0.004562378, 0.0028305054, 0.0009803772, -0.009811401, 0.019485474, 0.01209259, -0.018600464, -0.00045084953, -0.018157959, 0.030929565, -0.0012521744, -0.04550171, 0.0010623932, -0.035491943, 0.016677856, -0.0021705627, 0.008132935, -0.013252258, -0.087890625, -0.028305054, 0.005836487, -0.117614746, -0.041137695, 0.015510559, -0.028457642, -0.0284729, -0.042236328, 0.019302368, -0.013626099, -0.027999878, 0.023757935, -0.009414673, -0.0038585663, -0.0118637085, -0.0692749, -0.035186768, 0.08947754, 0.02142334, 0.020401001, 0.037384033, -0.017745972, -0.027893066, -0.033569336, 0.02671814, 0.021408081, 0.000008165836, -0.0025157928, -0.037384033, 0.028915405, -0.026428223, 0.017196655, 0.025848389, -0.0016098022, 0.00774765, -0.009292603, 0.018585205, 0.03656006, -0.018737793, 0.060455322, 0.0058288574, -0.032165527, -0.06719971, -0.00075244904, -0.018371582, -0.012825012, 0.01725769, -0.016036987, 0.040649414, 0.016967773, 0.010101318, 0.07110596, -0.022521973, 0.00522995, 0.048431396, -0.024841309, -0.009902954, -0.008018494, -0.00094890594, 0.022872925, 0.015640259, -0.017196655, -0.032592773, -0.018173218, -0.016845703, -0.049621582, -0.0055770874, -0.0025291443, -0.048980713, -0.00088500977, -0.06286621, -0.05230713, -0.037353516, 0.01512146, -0.014907837, 0.039764404, 0.04547119, 0.01399231, -0.035217285, -0.0036067963, 0.06768799, -0.007827759, 0.01373291, -0.06555176, -0.0075035095, -0.00409317, -0.052215576, -0.03173828, -0.016525269, -0.009857178, 0.021697998, -0.016693115, 0.0029964447, 0.011436462, 0.02494812, 0.0463562, 0.03866577, 0.0001399517, -0.0256958, 0.050933838, -0.033447266, -0.025253296, 0.021896362, -0.022033691, -0.022338867, -0.021743774, 0.035125732, -0.014671326, -0.009208679, -0.02029419, 0.035980225, -0.041900635, 0.072509766, -0.009033203, 0.022064209, 0.0209198, 0.0030708313, 0.017288208, 0.019821167, -0.036254883, 0.0051612854, 0.00068998337, 0.02885437, -0.021987915, 0.031921387, 0.047576904, 0.005672455, -0.026947021, -0.020507812, 0.025970459, -0.0019388199, -0.000086307526, -0.0143966675, 0.013793945, -0.0579834, -0.036956787, -0.0135650635, -0.013053894, 0.042633057, -0.051574707, 0.039764404, -0.012992859, -0.002521515, 0.042877197, -0.00046515465, 0.01499176, -0.0067863464, 0.012702942, -0.053344727, -0.047088623, 0.024261475, 0.048950195, -0.03744507, 0.020019531, -0.012550354, -0.0068130493, 0.031082153, 0.036102295, 0.0030460358, 0.023803711, -0.0095825195, 0.004558563, 0.014038086, -0.026412964, -0.03942871, 0.007537842, 0.044311523, 0.003894806, -0.0141067505, -0.020492554, -0.07727051, -0.038391113, -0.01360321, -0.005821228, -0.010314941, -0.05532837, 0.019729614, 0.05596924, -0.0042915344, 0.033477783, -0.048095703, 0.010932922, 0.030654907, 0.059509277, -0.004634857, 0.0020446777, 0.047424316, -0.030960083, 0.0014877319, -0.0018806458, 0.026473999, 0.016357422, 0.032409668, 0.023727417, 0.019042969, -0.060150146, 0.010025024, -0.014381409, -0.0059509277, 0.023513794, -0.043884277, -0.0010147095, 0.019195557, 0.007827759, -0.010192871, -0.0025806427, -0.005382538, 0.014213562, -0.026443481, -0.017333984, -0.009628296, -0.034606934, -0.06536865, -0.033691406, 0.029296875, 0.015716553, 0.007911682, -0.010505676, 0.004634857, -0.044036865, 0.030944824, 0.033843994, -0.07006836, 0.006401062, -0.011802673, 0.024169922, 0.04525757, 0.008361816, -0.028961182, 0.00006520748, -0.0048332214, -0.045135498, -0.05444336, 0.0048675537, -0.008598328, 0.0041618347, -0.0055503845, -0.0423584, 0.00944519, 0.008239746, 0.028213501, -0.0012130737, -0.019180298, 0.016357422, 0.004798889, 0.000729084, -0.00014710426, 0.005027771, 0.008026123, 0.003232956, -0.006793976, -0.019332886, 0.0024166107, 0.01247406, 0.032470703, -0.025299072, -0.04638672, -0.007583618, 0.022506714, 0.02218628, 0.0010766983, 0.01234436, 0.03643799, 0.011154175, -0.010940552, 0.016220093, 0.051574707, -0.052215576, -0.04321289, -0.00957489, 0.017120361, -0.023071289, 0.018844604, 0.009010315, -0.018753052, -0.026870728, -0.06854248, -0.033996582, 0.023361206, 0.022338867, 0.018341064, 0.011436462, -0.050689697, 0.04522705, -0.035980225, -0.024765015, -0.03982544, 0.037200928, -0.0058517456, -0.0066452026, 0.0013751984, -0.026473999, -0.007797241, -0.010566711, 0.010772705, 0.014755249, -0.013999939, 0.037750244, -0.01576233, 0.013679504, -0.006275177, -0.05050659, 0.025390625, -0.020629883, 0.0013513565, 0.039245605, -0.028671265, 0.044799805, 0.018569946, 0.06781006, 0.064575195, 0.019836426, 0.0061416626, 0.0027217865, 0.009536743, -0.03918457, -0.0141067505, -0.059417725, -0.021469116, -0.053955078, -0.00033664703, -0.057403564, 0.017303467, -0.010147095, 0.035003662, -0.018463135, 0.027191162, 0.009536743, 0.0042877197, 0.05630493, -0.026168823, 0.059326172, -0.015151978, -0.00011622906, -0.020828247, -0.027008057, 0.03616333, 0.03555298, 0.0076408386, 0.0002977848, -0.011962891, -0.007873535, -0.025878906, 0.022033691, 0.032409668, -0.024612427, -0.02218628, -0.022598267, 0.027252197, 0.0006008148, 0.029541016, 0.038513184, 0.034729004, 0.02078247, -0.028778076, -0.0022220612, -0.040374756, -0.009178162, -0.025497437, 0.021209717, -0.05239868, 0.02305603, -0.031585693, -0.015144348, -0.02017212, 0.01676941, 0.027526855, -0.07635498, -0.035186768, 0.03390503, 0.041992188, -0.016662598, 0.028793335, -0.052703857, -0.052734375, -0.06512451, 0.026519775, -0.018325806, -0.0017232895, -0.008964539, 0.047943115, -0.028060913, 0.0090789795, 0.011276245, -0.0018339157, -0.009063721, 0.027679443, -0.042236328, 0.0038433075, 0.010810852, -0.03555298, -0.002614975, 0.012306213, -0.02168274, -0.017578125, 0.029708862, 0.030639648, 0.026229858, 0.09118652, 0.052124023, -0.0020332336, -0.048034668, -0.015777588, 0.0098724365, 0.04135132, -0.027297974, 0.008033752, -0.038909912, -0.046936035, 0.0102005005, -0.053619385, 0.053833008, -0.036865234, 0.0068626404, -0.02684021, 0.009963989, 0.014205933, -0.047912598, 0.032043457, -0.035491943, 0.0073051453, -0.038635254, -0.04284668, -0.04248047, -0.04849243, -0.03591919, 0.05709839, -0.008354187, -0.0012722015, -0.009727478, -0.008094788, -0.055267334, 0.0013456345, -0.02859497, 0.039642334, -0.02331543, 0.0046043396, -0.004310608, -0.010185242, -0.0027275085, -0.009590149, -0.008880615, -0.0127334595, -0.038146973, -0.03704834, 0.008857727, 0.010818481, -0.032073975, -0.040527344, -0.0012617111, -0.0102005005, -0.033447266, 0.025299072, 0.04977417, -0.014854431, -0.1116333, -0.014213562, -0.026901245, 0.019714355, -0.009376526, -0.010917664, 0.024383545, 0.012252808, -0.010093689, -0.020904541, 0.029815674, 0.047546387, 0.00095129013, -0.028213501, 0.017196655, 0.019104004, 0.04623413, -0.06323242, -0.05053711, -0.014427185, 0.025268555, -0.0068206787, 0.044830322, 0.017120361, 0.0013008118, 0.002708435, 0.003583908, -0.0017547607, -0.036254883, -0.05230713, -0.048553467, 0.0385437, 0.032104492, -0.009422302, -0.024734497, 0.02859497, -0.0059509277, -0.0016698837, 0.0006570816, -0.017318726, -0.0001180172, -0.00024533272, 0.0051116943, -0.015335083, -0.008079529, -0.04925537, 0.036102295, 0.0038833618, 0.047027588, -0.03475952, 0.0236969, 0.019500732, 0.021347046, -0.022155762, -0.08190918, 0.030456543, 0.018676758, -0.002002716, 0.04928589, -0.016036987, -0.028381348, -0.009048462, -0.019363403, -0.012580872, -0.014442444, 0.037109375, -0.031799316, -0.0033226013, -0.044769287, -0.050598145, -0.028259277, -0.042755127, 0.03878784, -0.042938232, 0.018676758, -0.03475952, 0.014198303, -0.007663727, 0.035858154, -0.008201599, -0.026367188, -0.021621704, 0.011405945, 0.045074463, -0.015701294 ], "summary": [ 0.008796692, -0.0032520294, -0.019119263, 0.009407043, -0.022003174, -0.023422241, -0.023529053, -0.02798462, 0.011314392, 0.047851562, -0.072021484, 0.034698486, 0.018295288, 0.027435303, -0.023452759, -0.025161743, -0.008644104, 0.07141113, 0.024169922, -0.0053100586, -0.004928589, -0.020477295, -0.006679535, -0.02003479, -0.009155273, -0.039642334, 0.046081543, -0.0053482056, 0.02041626, 0.012367249, 0.022369385, -0.028381348, -0.021148682, 0.053527832, -0.025619507, -0.01361084, -0.01020813, 0.041412354, 0.013122559, 0.024780273, 0.02281189, -0.0101623535, 0.066345215, -0.0076408386, 0.014320374, 0.014579773, 0.020599365, -0.03515625, 0.009559631, -0.0026836395, -0.006210327, 0.009223938, -0.0023288727, -0.020309448, -0.012786865, -0.012519836, -0.03475952, 0.013137817, -0.0007491112, 0.07098389, 0.018112183, 0.038360596, -0.021820068, -0.037109375, -0.007701874, 0.007129669, 0.0048446655, 0.002418518, 0.018814087, -0.023620605, 0.006477356, -0.0049438477, 0.020812988, -0.017700195, 0.014579773, 0.0047912598, -0.020477295, 0.012710571, 0.03878784, 0.006877899, -0.028060913, 0.035705566, 0.015579224, -0.03414917, -0.027328491, -0.06903076, -0.01675415, 0.0071525574, -0.05053711, -0.008224487, -0.028793335, -0.03753662, -0.082336426, 0.08300781, 0.019866943, 0.008880615, 0.012886047, 0.026412964, 0.006629944, 0.030014038, -0.028778076, -0.010284424, 0.0158844, -0.033813477, 0.032287598, 0.0013418198, -0.025314331, -0.03475952, 0.04598999, 0.030456543, -0.025817871, 0.044799805, 0.026428223, -0.057495117, 0.02067566, 0.030670166, 0.050109863, 0.018341064, 0.018798828, -0.018997192, -0.026367188, -0.0011482239, 0.0011205673, -0.0034370422, 0.03982544, 0.022705078, -0.009635925, 0.021652222, 0.032226562, -0.010803223, -0.010665894, 0.02003479, 0.003921509, -0.020217896, -0.04159546, 0.014297485, 0.019744873, -0.028289795, -0.02911377, 0.017807007, 0.014434814, -0.046173096, -0.023529053, 0.0034866333, 0.026748657, 0.046722412, 0.020629883, -0.015449524, -0.0016651154, -0.042755127, 0.023376465, -0.00057935715, 0.055664062, -0.045196533, -0.050201416, -0.06329346, -0.05795288, -0.031799316, 0.018997192, -0.032165527, 0.06793213, 0.0039405823, -0.015991211, 0.036376953, -0.028289795, -0.012901306, -0.018707275, -0.008895874, 0.0009331703, -0.053833008, -0.02029419, 0.041259766, 0.04837036, -0.012626648, -0.00044584274, -0.0138549805, -0.032806396, 0.011657715, -0.010429382, 0.0074424744, 0.027862549, -0.016403198, 0.007801056, 0.054138184, -0.055389404, 0.027816772, 0.000467062, 0.07128906, 0.0552063, 0.0017356873, 0.015853882, -0.027511597, -0.0284729, -0.012184143, 0.0022907257, -0.034820557, 0.014030457, -0.03704834, 0.0066871643, 0.035949707, 0.06347656, -0.04525757, 0.032226562, -0.08331299, -0.10974121, -0.031555176, -0.030532837, 0.017745972, -0.0076446533, 0.00283432, 0.030334473, -0.01436615, -0.05596924, 0.085510254, 0.0037136078, -0.030883789, -0.0009279251, -0.050811768, -0.017501831, -0.024353027, -0.008735657, 0.015792847, -0.03564453, 0.054138184, 0.018829346, 0.00020730495, 0.02154541, 0.002319336, 0.08959961, 0.01499939, 0.07922363, -0.053253174, 0.07531738, 0.06121826, -0.02885437, -0.022201538, 0.023666382, -0.042053223, 0.021102905, 0.032409668, 0.020217896, 0.022720337, -0.047454834, -0.044952393, 0.070007324, -0.0045394897, -0.00894165, -0.030288696, 0.0019273758, 0.02456665, 0.019058228, -0.026245117, 0.028381348, -0.072021484, 0.013000488, 0.031311035, -0.014335632, -0.035980225, 0.0009021759, 0.019882202, 0.0032863617, -0.012428284, 0.004676819, -0.0070228577, 0.03591919, -0.05999756, -0.00058698654, -0.027191162, -0.0015058517, -0.026443481, 0.011375427, -0.027542114, 0.010467529, -0.023986816, -0.05126953, -0.05822754, -0.011741638, 0.053955078, -0.013961792, -0.045196533, 0.004951477, 0.019577026, 0.0011348724, -0.005290985, 0.008224487, 0.029891968, 0.00605011, 0.031097412, -0.03845215, -0.00061655045, -0.01109314, 0.082336426, 0.012901306, -0.0066337585, 0.062561035, 0.01965332, 0.10827637, 0.016174316, -0.004333496, -0.018035889, 0.0070343018, 0.021026611, -0.037902832, -0.0014286041, 0.03012085, 0.0021343231, 0.022155762, -0.00025057793, 0.0016698837, 0.012382507, -0.056243896, 0.005329132, -0.0005893707, 0.031951904, -0.07305908, -0.047302246, -0.039978027, 0.008148193, -0.032287598, 0.047302246, 0.06512451, 0.040008545, -0.0390625, -0.017501831, 0.0032138824, -0.007286072, -0.038879395, -0.05001831, -0.01876831, 0.018051147, 0.040496826, 0.017974854, 0.016830444, -0.013793945, 0.013557434, -0.022460938, -0.0018091202, -0.020706177, -0.01776123, 0.02859497, 0.019638062, 0.020019531, -0.00598526, -0.06506348, -0.024963379, 0.0012235641, 0.040283203, 0.002084732, -0.021240234, 0.0065574646, 0.013298035, -0.0317688, 0.011688232, 0.008544922, 0.0435791, 0.0065994263, -0.03866577, 0.024368286, 0.04397583, -0.01914978, 0.0011711121, 0.03189087, 0.013999939, -0.01512146, -0.07171631, -0.00073194504, -0.0054473877, 0.05419922, 0.009971619, 0.014045715, 0.04901123, 0.0104904175, -0.04763794, -0.029022217, -0.039520264, -0.02949524, 0.024169922, -0.034240723, 0.025650024, 0.02041626, -0.015579224, -0.0132751465, 0.01449585, 0.008758545, 0.053649902, -0.008453369, 0.0044517517, 0.04373169, 0.0034999847, -0.001739502, -0.020126343, -0.01259613, -0.02609253, -0.029937744, -0.003326416, 0.019302368, -0.0037708282, -0.0073432922, 0.011375427, -0.049224854, 0.03213501, -0.015556335, 0.008857727, -0.003129959, -0.013702393, 0.03186035, 0.015899658, 0.0063476562, 0.009490967, -0.0024795532, 0.026779175, -0.0010166168, 0.00497818, -0.002521515, 0.0090408325, -0.054107666, -0.0038108826, 0.006324768, -0.020217896, -0.018493652, -0.0017795563, 0.0044517517, 0.0036087036, 0.018661499, -0.052764893, 0.02128601, -0.011543274, 0.03111267, -0.0032291412, 0.06311035, 0.0049209595, 0.012176514, -0.019958496, 0.013664246, -0.024993896, 0.0680542, 0.015594482, 0.009902954, 0.048187256, -0.041809082, -0.009895325, 0.023925781, -0.03881836, 0.009384155, -0.0034046173, -0.026046753, 0.023513794, -0.04168701, 0.026443481, 0.07421875, -0.022766113, -0.02017212, 0.014099121, 0.026885986, -0.05429077, 0.015350342, -0.034301758, 0.043060303, 0.06878662, -0.019165039, 0.032287598, -0.04321289, -0.0053634644, 0.072265625, 0.033111572, 0.048614502, -0.077819824, 0.019332886, -0.03829956, 0.009338379, 0.04510498, -0.03375244, -0.017440796, -0.04348755, 0.03555298, -0.07293701, -0.015426636, 0.015403748, 0.014556885, -0.019561768, -0.052490234, 0.025909424, -0.08807373, -0.088134766, -0.024368286, -0.0030651093, -0.06652832, -0.055236816, 0.022872925, 0.010101318, -0.012489319, -0.014190674, 0.060150146, -0.037872314, 0.0072898865, 0.02633667, -0.015594482, 0.06317139, 0.0042648315, -0.06726074, -0.0026111603, 0.012939453, 0.05038452, 0.018356323, -0.004753113, 0.000364542, 0.011428833, 0.015037537, 0.022521973, 0.007873535, 0.006664276, -0.012390137, -0.015808105, -0.005126953, -0.0053977966, 0.0062446594, 0.046325684, -0.00459671, 0.024307251, -0.007972717, 0.04135132, 0.068481445, -0.0044784546, 0.020980835, -0.016799927, -0.0045776367, -0.03475952, -0.015365601, 0.009307861, -0.01637268, 0.016662598, -0.0022144318, -0.02532959, 0.031921387, 0.019836426, 0.006919861, -0.026123047, -0.037475586, 0.029678345, 0.01499176, 0.011001587, 0.005050659, -0.033203125, 0.01826477, 0.038085938, -0.034118652, 0.007987976, -0.005191803, -0.020553589, -0.0018863678, -0.03878784, -0.036376953, -0.07647705, -0.03375244, 0.0071144104, 0.007610321, -0.01776123, -0.0054893494, -0.035125732, 0.066711426, 0.022323608, 0.022521973, -0.010818481, -0.017745972, 0.028198242, 0.0026416779, -0.0423584, -0.08203125, -0.017562866, -0.04043579, -0.024475098, -0.017868042, 0.00070381165, -0.03616333, -0.014434814, 0.00042676926, 0.0069351196, 0.019042969, 0.019760132, 0.03857422, 0.011802673, 0.005832672, -0.032958984, 0.0446167, -0.05871582, 0.027618408, -0.002462387, -0.017410278, -0.04727173, -0.009681702, 0.009162903, 0.01335907, -0.023544312, -0.044036865, 0.008293152, -0.00642395, 0.021560669, 0.025054932, 0.026184082, 0.018356323, 0.0021686554, 0.009811401, 0.015602112, -0.008163452, 0.010055542, 0.00793457, -0.033294678, 0.048706055, 0.04486084, 0.060333252, -0.042144775, -0.05206299, 0.00011718273, 0.046539307, 0.007511139, -0.025360107, 0.006542206, 0.0028858185, -0.04928589, -0.059265137, -0.020324707, -0.026351929, -0.016983032, -0.033599854, 0.008674622, -0.026641846, 0.028060913, 0.03994751, -0.0010566711, -0.0029659271, 0.01335144, 0.0004963875, -0.029373169, -0.030303955, 0.018234253, 0.04714966, -0.017578125, -0.02709961, -0.039276123, -0.013206482, 0.010681152, 0.0014209747, -0.033294678, 0.0118637085, 0.0024700165, -0.009429932, -0.002998352, -0.010681152, -0.00022780895, -0.03527832, 0.047088623, 0.01701355, 0.03933716, -0.056243896, 0.0034294128, -0.04336548, -0.038635254, -0.0051498413, 0.01626587, -0.023071289, -0.038269043, 0.03475952, -0.00415802, 0.011749268, -0.0020217896, -0.030227661, 0.014099121, 0.034088135, -0.0390625, -0.0025806427, 0.017059326, 0.0031051636, -0.020355225, 0.008239746, 0.025405884, 0.03765869, 0.03253174, 0.033355713, 0.025939941, -0.029769897, -0.0017032623, -0.043273926, -0.004085541, -0.028289795, 0.013137817, 0.02281189, -0.02407837, 0.012260437, -0.001537323, 0.022979736, -0.009544373, -0.013938904, 0.008125305, -0.031036377, -0.038238525, -0.023971558, -0.024246216, 0.002002716, 0.037261963, 0.0010356903, 0.019866943, 0.007270813, -0.010948181, -0.0065956116, 0.018798828, -0.027801514, -0.044006348, 0.024291992, 0.050750732, 0.026229858, 0.023086548, 0.011489868, -0.0038928986, -0.0076942444, -0.005580902, 0.007926941, 0.01436615, -0.0046577454, -0.021133423, 0.032592773, -0.0010261536, -0.006427765, -0.0018138885, -0.044677734, 0.0038452148, -0.04031372, 0.0037593842, 0.019699097, -0.031204224, -0.051086426, 0.027435303, -0.004890442, -0.038635254, 0.009277344, 0.01171875, -0.00856781, 0.004825592, 0.052337646, 0.06555176, -0.04550171, -0.059570312, -0.01322937, 0.02746582, 0.0112838745, 0.020019531, -0.0076904297, 0.014518738, 0.05532837, -0.042816162, -0.006942749, 0.00894928, -0.01776123, -0.0064849854, -0.016525269, 0.02558899, -0.046417236, -0.035095215, 0.026062012, 0.015342712, 0.003868103, -0.020629883, 0.014801025, 0.024246216, -0.02279663, -0.024291992, -0.018463135, -0.018875122, 0.046783447, -0.02281189, -0.014831543, -0.009124756, 0.037139893, -0.0033245087, 0.0070991516, -0.02406311, -0.019897461, -0.017044067, 0.046447754, -0.012741089, -0.02078247, -0.019378662, 0.033569336, 0.031829834, 0.017532349, 0.011497498, -0.007675171, -0.010772705, -0.030212402, 0.02230835, -0.006931305, -0.0031394958, 0.03289795, 0.01096344, -0.014266968, 0.028503418, -0.0072135925, -0.051330566, -0.011291504, -0.014778137, -0.032165527, -0.019241333, -0.017028809, -0.048736572, -0.02709961, -0.01399231, 0.021240234, 0.05505371, -0.052093506, -0.005016327, 0.0340271, 0.007080078, 0.012359619, 0.03579712, -0.015136719, 0.03652954, 0.01751709, 0.044158936, 0.023925781, 0.023727417, -0.0748291, 0.0049743652, 0.050048828, -0.0131073, 0.015731812, 0.01184082, 0.013282776, -0.0037460327, 0.007167816, -0.015350342, -0.056915283, 0.044036865, -0.025619507, 0.013710022, -0.00043201447, 0.02003479, 0.015556335, -0.006526947, 0.055664062, -0.034729004, -0.001159668, -0.01586914, -0.00007903576, -0.008117676, 0.024047852, -0.042297363, 0.024368286, -0.009925842, -0.028076172, 0.0574646, 0.015579224, 0.042114258, -0.05831909, -0.009643555, 0.014411926, 0.009262085, -0.037841797, -0.0026874542, -0.0513916, -0.09472656, -0.07373047, 0.04296875, -0.03527832, -0.020050049, -0.05429077, 0.0413208, 0.0064201355, 0.015670776, 0.011817932, -0.012390137, 0.009109497, 0.04147339, -0.020050049, 0.019958496, 0.032165527, -0.025039673, 0.045654297, 0.013313293, -0.028167725, 0.037902832, -0.028564453, 0.043762207, 0.031707764, 0.076416016, 0.009597778, 0.00945282, -0.00598526, 0.017456055, 0.008178711, 0.0046463013, -0.010887146, -0.037261963, -0.019073486, 0.0054359436, -0.027114868, -0.013343811, 0.0423584, -0.06161499, 0.026245117, -0.032592773, 0.0011835098, -0.05731201, 0.0033473969, 0.034118652, -0.032440186, -0.0006303787, -0.009643555, 0.010803223, -0.050811768, -0.022155762, -0.050109863, 0.015556335, -0.037139893, -0.004348755, 0.04434204, 0.012161255, -0.059265137, -0.0012168884, -0.021759033, 0.043701172, -0.036956787, 0.0048599243, 0.033325195, 0.008705139, -0.01260376, -0.061767578, -0.015052795, -0.022247314, 0.022476196, -0.097839355, 0.0039596558, -0.022338867, -0.051818848, -0.0970459, 0.007019043, -0.038269043, -0.04043579, 0.07946777, 0.019729614, 0.028274536, -0.10290527, 0.009002686, -0.02029419, -0.040374756, -0.08770752, 0.012306213, 0.05419922, 0.020126343, 0.015563965, -0.0052719116, 0.013999939, 0.0066108704, 0.011154175, -0.0028209686, -0.006187439, 0.020599365, 0.04714966, -0.024368286, -0.033111572, 0.00566864, 0.003791809, -0.0033473969, -0.0042800903, 0.013298035, -0.007358551, -0.0049934387, 0.026733398, -0.01184845, -0.028671265, -0.042266846, -0.040924072, 0.055603027, -0.017440796, -0.032928467, -0.02659607, 0.017227173, -0.022567749, -0.019927979, -0.020111084, -0.014251709, -0.027740479, -0.0012102127, -0.003168106, -0.014709473, -0.003271103, -0.039245605, 0.015541077, 0.005607605, 0.031097412, -0.029800415, 0.032684326, 0.0137786865, 0.00756073, -0.033691406, -0.06365967, 0.03515625, -0.00995636, 0.015533447, 0.010276794, 0.06695557, -0.020462036, 0.0065689087, -0.021255493, -0.002023697, -0.02003479, 0.03439331, -0.028686523, -0.023544312, -0.030014038, -0.017059326, -0.018310547, -0.0335083, 0.03286743, -0.030303955, 0.012458801, -0.0012807846, 0.0068588257, 0.01965332, 0.0018501282, -0.011779785, -0.01902771, 0.013053894, 0.06573486, -0.0040283203, 0.01713562 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06838v1
GIELLM: Japanese General Information Extraction Large Language Model Utilizing Mutual Reinforcement Effect
Chengguang Gan, Qinghao Zhang, Tatsunori Mori
cs.CL
Information Extraction (IE) stands as a cornerstone in natural language processing, traditionally segmented into distinct sub-tasks. The advent of Large Language Models (LLMs) heralds a paradigm shift, suggesting the feasibility of a singular model addressing multiple IE subtasks. In this vein, we introduce the General Information Extraction Large Language Model (GIELLM), which integrates text Classification, Sentiment Analysis, Named Entity Recognition, Relation Extraction, and Event Extraction using a uniform input-output schema. This innovation marks the first instance of a model simultaneously handling such a diverse array of IE subtasks. Notably, the GIELLM leverages the Mutual Reinforcement Effect (MRE), enhancing performance in integrated tasks compared to their isolated counterparts. Our experiments demonstrate State-of-the-Art (SOTA) results in five out of six Japanese mixed datasets, significantly surpassing GPT-3.5-Turbo. Further, an independent evaluation using the novel Text Classification Relation and Event Extraction(TCREE) dataset corroborates the synergistic advantages of MRE in text and word classification. This breakthrough paves the way for most IE subtasks to be subsumed under a singular LLM framework. Specialized fine-tune task-specific models are no longer needed.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06838v1
2023-11-12T13:30:38
2023-11-12T13:30:38
{ "title": [ -0.039215088, -0.009635925, -0.044525146, -0.029251099, -0.013114929, -0.007007599, -0.03640747, -0.00093078613, -0.010650635, 0.031433105, -0.033599854, -0.009552002, 0.02545166, -0.015022278, -0.02746582, -0.016799927, -0.029754639, 0.043823242, -0.01979065, -0.036834717, -0.005859375, -0.068237305, 0.019134521, -0.039001465, 0.026397705, -0.016921997, -0.079833984, 0.012130737, -0.024551392, -0.017166138, 0.0034713745, 0.01096344, 0.03161621, 0.0256958, -0.04144287, 0.01890564, -0.038330078, 0.023117065, -0.012290955, 0.007507324, 0.013084412, 0.005634308, -0.020217896, -0.021102905, -0.040740967, 0.037841797, -0.09069824, -0.018798828, 0.0018825531, 0.024154663, 0.0024871826, 0.04333496, 0.018295288, 0.03604126, 0.014053345, -0.036193848, -0.03463745, 0.024414062, 0.030380249, 0.042388916, 0.013061523, -0.029464722, 0.015556335, -0.028274536, -0.04119873, -0.006626129, -0.022476196, 0.023254395, 0.019058228, -0.03302002, -0.011390686, -0.003162384, -0.017166138, 0.0021438599, -0.07141113, 0.013595581, 0.035095215, -0.019119263, 0.040283203, -0.029449463, -0.005290985, 0.004196167, -0.00017642975, -0.052124023, 0.048583984, -0.02571106, -0.020355225, -0.00038337708, -0.054779053, -0.07409668, -0.02130127, -0.02067566, -0.07159424, -0.012046814, -0.01676941, -0.04574585, -0.021408081, 0.011230469, 0.005241394, -0.010429382, -0.0501709, 0.043792725, -0.058441162, -0.008972168, 0.008621216, -0.0101623535, -0.0047302246, -0.0069465637, 0.025985718, 0.02494812, -0.048339844, 0.06732178, 0.017562866, 0.008583069, -0.015625, -0.0010108948, -0.018814087, 0.0045547485, 0.002565384, 0.018493652, 0.0118255615, -0.006286621, -0.008735657, 0.0055236816, 0.024673462, 0.01121521, -0.021743774, 0.013504028, -0.017974854, -0.006412506, 0.02960205, 0.053527832, -0.11663818, -0.066589355, -0.07055664, 0.059295654, -0.026306152, 0.03665161, 0.0076065063, -0.012626648, 0.03604126, -0.033111572, 0.009353638, 0.053497314, 0.03060913, -0.0073547363, 0.07086182, 0.00097608566, -0.038146973, -0.037109375, -0.015472412, 0.04559326, 0.034698486, -0.028533936, -0.058685303, -0.06390381, -0.117370605, -0.020812988, 0.03503418, -0.02331543, 0.0017566681, 0.0014228821, 0.0018491745, 0.015426636, 0.04638672, -0.0035915375, 0.009544373, 0.028717041, 0.023757935, 0.012756348, -0.008132935, -0.0019607544, 0.019744873, 0.0003888607, -0.0029907227, 0.030395508, -0.00970459, 0.033355713, -0.004573822, -0.0071105957, 0.014198303, -0.049346924, -0.030822754, 0.046722412, -0.029403687, -0.039855957, -0.010520935, 0.00002926588, 0.06890869, 0.02381897, -0.046691895, -0.029754639, -0.08123779, -0.014549255, -0.027236938, 0.02998352, 0.026062012, 0.038238525, 0.009811401, -0.009521484, -0.024124146, 0.030090332, -0.05529785, 0.024856567, 0.011505127, -0.035858154, 0.0012340546, 0.0042686462, -0.0423584, 0.045654297, 0.06365967, 0.0009832382, -0.04660034, 0.01210022, -0.00006312132, -0.07556152, 0.012062073, -0.0047302246, -0.0009255409, -0.000120818615, 0.011734009, -0.023910522, 0.0103302, 0.018692017, -0.0038700104, 0.014533997, -0.014701843, 0.0038833618, 0.01940918, 0.04840088, 0.035858154, -0.026931763, 0.038116455, 0.047698975, -0.02658081, -0.041870117, -0.026870728, -0.008369446, 0.019607544, 0.023635864, 0.0022563934, -0.027816772, -0.012802124, 0.012313843, 0.017044067, -0.0072898865, 0.009727478, -0.005542755, 0.028167725, 0.020370483, 0.03326416, 0.0050201416, 0.04473877, 0.04840088, 0.025634766, 0.033569336, 0.0015459061, 0.0019140244, -0.03186035, -0.009544373, 0.013549805, 0.009223938, -0.026763916, 0.018997192, -0.0680542, 0.01473999, -0.024810791, 0.013977051, 0.0051231384, -0.0012483597, 0.031143188, -0.0010852814, 0.014434814, -0.03277588, -0.018539429, -0.036193848, -0.0015945435, 0.042755127, 0.0066452026, -0.06958008, -0.0036830902, 0.011512756, 0.036834717, -0.0010108948, 0.019958496, 0.018417358, 0.025802612, -0.013786316, -0.06100464, 0.0005130768, 0.04147339, 0.04736328, 0.0019950867, -0.014022827, 0.024536133, 0.033477783, 0.1048584, 0.07550049, -0.009735107, 0.016525269, -0.06665039, 0.0070343018, -0.009010315, -0.009849548, 0.007724762, 0.0050964355, 0.009819031, -0.00945282, -0.051757812, 0.016708374, -0.07342529, 0.0065345764, 0.0024414062, -0.0049743652, -0.059265137, -0.058044434, -0.02154541, -0.033294678, -0.07055664, -0.015686035, 0.07171631, -0.027893066, -0.023849487, -0.0033569336, -0.020248413, -0.02809143, -0.012138367, -0.030090332, -0.005207062, 0.022323608, 0.00642395, 0.021026611, -0.06274414, 0.0011968613, -0.008079529, 0.018981934, -0.02482605, 0.022994995, -0.036499023, -0.0017356873, -0.028579712, -0.035614014, 0.015312195, -0.060913086, -0.0046958923, -0.04071045, -0.007045746, -0.0014514923, -0.010688782, -0.00073862076, 0.0030937195, 0.0032596588, 0.02368164, 0.056427002, 0.089416504, -0.014320374, -0.06021118, 0.048583984, 0.015419006, -0.012527466, 0.037841797, 0.037963867, 0.018463135, -0.068115234, -0.024749756, -0.068847656, -0.020309448, -0.026733398, 0.022598267, 0.05078125, -0.03677368, -0.006629944, -0.0647583, 0.0012817383, 0.02947998, -0.005241394, 0.04437256, -0.012001038, -0.046691895, 0.01625061, -0.0058517456, 0.025741577, -0.0362854, 0.021072388, 0.043640137, 0.01953125, -0.0002810955, 0.0023479462, 0.0033283234, -0.007736206, -0.026947021, -0.015991211, 0.010665894, -0.012207031, 0.032836914, 0.009475708, -0.022949219, -0.0047454834, -0.07006836, 0.009315491, 0.04434204, 0.018508911, -0.0017585754, 0.041015625, -0.07574463, 0.04550171, -0.010192871, -0.0037212372, 0.026489258, 0.03274536, 0.008842468, -0.0021362305, 0.0045776367, -0.024749756, 0.021118164, -0.036468506, -0.08404541, 0.025543213, -0.0014572144, -0.05041504, -0.019317627, -0.007911682, -0.057800293, -0.026901245, 0.0010194778, 0.07647705, 0.02003479, 0.006412506, 0.0076408386, 0.02279663, 0.031585693, -0.015960693, -0.033477783, -0.021575928, 0.0014266968, 0.02696228, 0.0079574585, 0.050933838, 0.03656006, -0.00035095215, -0.038391113, -0.012664795, -0.01259613, -0.0024490356, -0.009033203, -0.033325195, 0.0070381165, -0.023101807, -0.030532837, 0.03942871, -0.03466797, 0.020874023, -0.019622803, 0.01071167, -0.024230957, -0.047973633, 0.0073394775, 0.009162903, -0.012313843, -0.03491211, 0.006641388, -0.015007019, -0.024612427, -0.0079422, 0.04815674, -0.0018815994, 0.00038170815, -0.000120818615, -0.01625061, 0.02255249, 0.013504028, -0.009513855, -0.014953613, -0.025146484, -0.01448822, -0.033050537, 0.019180298, 0.00466156, 0.014770508, -0.034362793, 0.008399963, -0.000521183, -0.0345459, -0.061676025, -0.013694763, 0.006587982, -0.11206055, -0.03277588, 0.009361267, -0.02168274, -0.028320312, -0.03817749, 0.017364502, -0.03475952, -0.047912598, 0.014556885, -0.0008034706, -0.025894165, -0.0060424805, -0.07702637, -0.019897461, 0.08880615, -0.009231567, 0.03515625, 0.04006958, -0.024658203, -0.030685425, -0.009346008, 0.038635254, 0.03744507, 0.03274536, 0.020339966, -0.028701782, 0.019714355, -0.02218628, 0.006038666, 0.057159424, -0.011817932, 0.022201538, 0.0029697418, 0.0046806335, 0.0021247864, -0.005596161, 0.03955078, 0.013404846, -0.025482178, -0.036712646, 0.006137848, -0.027160645, -0.028579712, 0.0043525696, 0.0024738312, 0.007621765, 0.015388489, 0.012489319, 0.047729492, -0.024673462, -0.001663208, 0.03503418, 0.003376007, -0.026794434, -0.014984131, 0.018203735, 0.030197144, -0.0057678223, 0.023971558, -0.003932953, 0.044952393, 0.002729416, -0.026504517, 0.005695343, 0.025985718, -0.047698975, -0.0016822815, -0.034332275, -0.04711914, -0.035339355, 0.016342163, -0.0066108704, 0.03933716, 0.04043579, 0.02418518, -0.056854248, 0.003227234, 0.020202637, -0.011276245, -0.012817383, -0.059570312, -0.011367798, -0.026977539, -0.074157715, -0.048858643, -0.021347046, 0.020584106, 0.012664795, 0.021896362, -0.025466919, -0.006263733, 0.030212402, 0.061920166, 0.0149383545, 0.010032654, -0.032165527, 0.006542206, -0.040130615, -0.021606445, -0.0104599, -0.02281189, -0.039245605, -0.019989014, 0.042663574, -0.00056266785, -0.022094727, -0.0491333, 0.014961243, -0.006378174, 0.05328369, 0.006679535, 0.02658081, 0.023040771, 0.0026893616, 0.00075626373, -0.00081014633, -0.043304443, 0.017700195, -0.010421753, 0.02168274, -0.01713562, 0.009742737, 0.040649414, 0.027145386, 0.020736694, -0.0057144165, 0.000036418438, 0.017501831, 0.007671356, -0.033966064, 0.04815674, -0.00182724, 0.0039043427, 0.007637024, -0.010429382, 0.032989502, -0.060272217, 0.030197144, -0.036315918, 0.028839111, -0.002105713, -0.03149414, 0.009986877, -0.028823853, 0.019683838, -0.024169922, -0.002325058, 0.03463745, -0.005908966, -0.02178955, 0.023071289, -0.024353027, -0.021759033, 0.0022735596, 0.024459839, 0.019439697, -0.0069847107, -0.0028858185, -0.02671814, -0.0021629333, 0.007183075, -0.04458618, -0.009048462, -0.0072631836, 0.016998291, -0.030334473, 0.03302002, -0.037963867, -0.0031528473, -0.037139893, -0.011772156, 0.022460938, -0.063964844, 0.00022673607, 0.056732178, 0.012245178, 0.021133423, 0.012435913, 0.0047836304, 0.038360596, 0.02911377, 0.01914978, -0.005180359, 0.020080566, -0.043395996, 0.0021266937, -0.0049934387, 0.013648987, -0.02204895, 0.058685303, 0.0060653687, 0.03930664, -0.083984375, 0.023162842, 0.005630493, -0.012771606, 0.0236969, -0.039398193, 0.022216797, 0.0206604, -0.016479492, 0.0025959015, -0.07531738, -0.06561279, -0.007118225, -0.037078857, -0.036590576, 0.023239136, -0.0034255981, -0.07086182, -0.02923584, 0.021728516, -0.0016212463, -0.03353882, 0.010551453, 0.032928467, -0.013076782, 0.010887146, 0.038360596, -0.053771973, 0.029922485, 0.0088272095, 0.017593384, 0.0413208, 0.007820129, -0.03894043, 0.0017700195, 0.021438599, -0.04888916, -0.030548096, 0.0016765594, -0.022872925, -0.015823364, -0.002960205, 0.0008087158, -0.0050239563, -0.027709961, 0.009857178, -0.004825592, -0.0061950684, 0.048034668, -0.012825012, -0.00068569183, 0.025863647, 0.03543091, 0.0045166016, 0.006832123, 0.009773254, -0.030700684, -0.0034866333, 0.011550903, 0.027008057, -0.043792725, -0.091674805, -0.0071868896, 0.013885498, 0.009300232, 0.018096924, 0.040405273, 0.036834717, 0.034729004, 0.020553589, 0.028930664, 0.06390381, -0.053985596, -0.013511658, -0.019638062, -0.0034561157, -0.04309082, 0.032958984, 0.004295349, 0.018829346, -0.03265381, -0.05807495, -0.033721924, 0.011833191, 0.03366089, -0.0023880005, -0.000521183, 0.012298584, 0.0597229, -0.05014038, -0.0031433105, -0.04977417, 0.033203125, -0.018615723, -0.049926758, 0.006515503, -0.00818634, -0.006954193, -0.013053894, 0.007499695, 0.007926941, -0.014945984, 0.02432251, -0.015472412, 0.0020542145, -0.018447876, -0.04055786, 0.010986328, 0.00076436996, -0.020477295, 0.036499023, -0.037231445, 0.06549072, -0.004470825, 0.055847168, 0.054534912, 0.008781433, -0.010040283, 0.0031700134, -0.007385254, -0.041748047, 0.022979736, -0.025161743, 0.0013818741, -0.040863037, -0.012931824, -0.07751465, 0.023483276, 0.012672424, 0.034851074, -0.009880066, 0.0061569214, -0.008056641, -0.0017595291, 0.02619934, 0.012573242, 0.052459717, -0.032958984, -0.009086609, -0.011764526, -0.018951416, 0.052337646, 0.037994385, -0.012641907, -0.0011177063, -0.002878189, -0.025558472, 0.012229919, -0.008453369, 0.040740967, -0.033111572, -0.03201294, -0.02935791, 0.028305054, 0.010910034, 0.056854248, 0.025756836, 0.012023926, -0.049102783, 0.020355225, -0.013931274, -0.013290405, -0.039398193, 0.048309326, 0.048675537, -0.09729004, 0.062194824, 0.006980896, -0.044403076, -0.068603516, 0.03353882, 0.03161621, -0.025405884, -0.010406494, 0.011230469, 0.032348633, 0.0061950684, 0.021713257, -0.040405273, -0.018936157, -0.0033569336, 0.0013456345, 0.00374794, 0.018920898, 0.017532349, 0.0032787323, -0.011413574, -0.0070114136, -0.006614685, 0.034973145, -0.025161743, 0.023284912, -0.0028629303, 0.070007324, -0.020004272, -0.0491333, 0.024383545, -0.0012969971, -0.064941406, -0.022201538, 0.02960205, 0.009819031, 0.07098389, 0.06964111, 0.021743774, 0.006591797, 0.015296936, -0.045715332, 0.0072669983, 0.028945923, -0.044830322, -0.015960693, -0.021316528, -0.03164673, 0.014549255, -0.06488037, 0.026367188, -0.060272217, -0.011932373, -0.0385437, 0.030548096, 0.0155181885, -0.027511597, -0.05871582, -0.034423828, -0.052978516, 0.016983032, 0.02720642, 0.0047569275, -0.026382446, -0.0030727386, 0.025787354, 0.004283905, 0.000014305115, 0.01436615, -0.0146865845, -0.035705566, -0.0034236908, -0.017822266, 0.032104492, -0.032928467, 0.000729084, -0.0013465881, 0.00642395, 0.004169464, -0.05581665, -0.03060913, -0.024597168, -0.0005402565, -0.016525269, 0.0060920715, 0.013473511, -0.008125305, -0.02355957, -0.02116394, 0.0038051605, -0.03100586, 0.036315918, 0.028930664, -0.016021729, -0.07336426, -0.006122589, -0.02456665, 0.022537231, -0.01134491, -0.004886627, 0.01727295, 0.011222839, -0.027816772, -0.016860962, 0.018661499, 0.0395813, 0.013435364, -0.027542114, 0.0061912537, 0.020980835, 0.058929443, -0.052703857, -0.06677246, -0.01234436, 0.015342712, -0.021697998, 0.026931763, 0.017501831, -0.010681152, 0.02078247, 0.029205322, -0.007194519, -0.024139404, 0.0135650635, -0.00059747696, 0.03643799, 0.032470703, -0.01348114, 0.01776123, 0.011077881, -0.029205322, 0.00052928925, 0.0012130737, -0.021270752, 0.007587433, -0.008178711, 0.010215759, -0.024475098, 0.015289307, -0.036895752, 0.06817627, -0.030899048, -0.0009813309, 0.0014438629, 0.023513794, -0.00022506714, 0.024658203, -0.019638062, -0.043548584, 0.062072754, 0.036254883, 0.03652954, 0.027786255, 0.020935059, 0.000031471252, -0.0026893616, 0.006465912, 0.0064964294, 0.022659302, -0.024017334, -0.007537842, 0.029556274, -0.06506348, -0.038757324, -0.020095825, -0.023651123, 0.03378296, -0.04257202, 0.018539429, -0.015686035, -0.025115967, -0.004573822, 0.038757324, 0.00054979324, -0.032409668, -0.021499634, 0.014640808, 0.045074463, -0.008522034 ], "summary": [ 0.0032958984, -0.009353638, -0.039855957, -0.055267334, -0.034973145, 0.0004413128, -0.076416016, -0.0016708374, 0.024536133, 0.026062012, -0.05029297, -0.009307861, 0.031036377, -0.00995636, 0.0025959015, -0.030273438, -0.041656494, 0.04324341, -0.011962891, -0.03778076, 0.0053863525, -0.064941406, -0.01637268, -0.09301758, 0.004749298, -0.020141602, -0.017425537, 0.01663208, 0.013244629, 0.028549194, 0.0138168335, -0.020126343, 0.026809692, 0.025039673, -0.053833008, 0.01953125, -0.043029785, 0.0031108856, -0.0076675415, 0.010551453, 0.01739502, 0.012870789, 0.033599854, -0.038726807, -0.017715454, 0.052581787, -0.06866455, -0.03475952, 0.04284668, -0.017974854, -0.018814087, 0.009033203, -0.00015437603, -0.04888916, -0.024917603, -0.022232056, -0.059265137, -0.0005068779, -0.009010315, 0.09020996, 0.055419922, 0.008712769, -0.021118164, -0.029647827, -0.013572693, 0.012413025, 0.029342651, -0.0077323914, -0.034942627, -0.021453857, 0.031188965, -0.016036987, -0.005016327, -0.06008911, -0.03942871, 0.06713867, 0.03137207, 0.003698349, -0.0007715225, -0.03189087, -0.0008254051, 0.039367676, -0.035339355, -0.05657959, 0.030303955, -0.039154053, -0.015914917, -0.013175964, -0.0121536255, -0.022399902, -0.020751953, -0.047454834, -0.06201172, 0.050628662, 0.031982422, -0.034851074, -0.036254883, -0.01121521, -0.039276123, -0.0026493073, -0.014022827, -0.0045928955, -0.0011920929, -0.0079956055, -0.014030457, 0.0047340393, -0.006134033, -0.043426514, 0.010040283, 0.028930664, -0.024002075, 0.039245605, 0.013130188, -0.031433105, -0.014778137, 0.015960693, 0.004962921, 0.050445557, 0.015625, 0.044952393, -0.00844574, 0.02748108, -0.05126953, 0.032073975, 0.0056610107, 0.00026893616, 0.021026611, 0.029708862, 0.01889038, -0.035095215, 0.023803711, 0.042297363, -0.09234619, -0.04095459, -0.07495117, 0.033843994, 0.019058228, 0.042510986, 0.005001068, -0.028152466, 0.06304932, -0.02319336, -0.044525146, 0.057678223, 0.054504395, 0.021408081, 0.050476074, -0.0064811707, -0.016357422, -0.00869751, -0.013374329, 0.048217773, 0.060150146, -0.068359375, -0.06549072, -0.119262695, -0.077941895, -0.03378296, 0.04953003, -0.05419922, -0.006629944, -0.003944397, 0.026397705, 0.022827148, 0.006580353, 0.0035533905, -0.024658203, -0.0029792786, 0.018356323, -0.030914307, -0.004261017, 0.012825012, 0.014335632, -0.00415802, 0.010848999, 0.018630981, 0.004436493, 0.013000488, -0.028076172, 0.020111084, 0.001709938, -0.052886963, -0.042053223, 0.024230957, -0.024871826, 0.013160706, -0.016464233, 0.06689453, 0.074279785, 0.007534027, -0.014038086, -0.06982422, -0.09069824, 0.010055542, -0.012199402, 0.009346008, 0.012565613, 0.0027503967, 0.006652832, -0.0005092621, 0.018188477, 0.04055786, -0.039093018, -0.024673462, -0.029800415, -0.010391235, 0.012901306, 0.020751953, -0.024414062, 0.012771606, 0.028915405, -0.020217896, -0.047607422, 0.037109375, -0.009391785, -0.051696777, 0.0340271, -0.01826477, 0.016433716, -0.013069153, 0.02545166, 0.022277832, -0.015075684, 0.0418396, -0.006790161, -0.00737381, 0.007873535, 0.023803711, 0.060333252, 0.025466919, 0.05319214, -0.062469482, 0.050994873, 0.07739258, -0.031951904, -0.030288696, 0.007904053, -0.030838013, 0.023727417, 0.030883789, 0.014556885, 0.0078125, -0.052215576, -0.028152466, 0.0020256042, -0.0054130554, 0.0010080338, -0.016555786, 0.0009403229, 0.005344391, 0.016799927, -0.017974854, 0.011123657, 0.003929138, 0.032958984, 0.010131836, 0.0234375, -0.02217102, -0.031219482, 0.004425049, 0.022018433, -0.007827759, -0.06524658, 0.021438599, -0.014915466, -0.014434814, 0.028640747, 0.03390503, -0.00075626373, -0.026107788, 0.018630981, 0.020111084, -0.0024929047, -0.041229248, -0.018722534, -0.004020691, -0.023223877, 0.035858154, 0.007282257, -0.021072388, -0.030029297, -0.0063285828, -0.021057129, -0.00466156, 0.026062012, -0.015426636, 0.0061950684, -0.016601562, -0.005836487, 0.07574463, 0.046447754, 0.046783447, -0.002008438, 0.01335144, 0.0181427, 0.036193848, 0.06549072, -0.0042266846, 0.02494812, -0.03253174, -0.01285553, 0.012207031, -0.034454346, -0.019226074, 0.024368286, -0.028961182, -0.0154953, 0.025238037, 0.01751709, 0.0073928833, -0.041778564, 0.06640625, 0.031021118, 0.07116699, -0.050079346, -0.048583984, -0.022613525, 0.032928467, -0.05618286, 0.011520386, 0.074157715, -0.025115967, -0.021148682, 0.0050621033, -0.030838013, -0.019332886, 0.020965576, -0.02154541, -0.0010232925, 0.022705078, -0.027740479, 0.008308411, -0.04159546, 0.030654907, -0.017181396, 0.012413025, -0.0018100739, 0.03491211, -0.015136719, 0.006286621, 0.0074272156, -0.019592285, 0.005622864, -0.025558472, -0.04525757, -0.015945435, 0.019439697, -0.021575928, 0.001502037, -0.015426636, 0.012191772, 0.0015602112, 0.045288086, 0.072265625, 0.06222534, -0.009506226, -0.06488037, -0.006511688, -0.015602112, -0.059265137, 0.043304443, 0.036102295, 0.010719299, -0.107788086, -0.040527344, -0.035125732, -0.03744507, -0.012771606, 0.034606934, 0.02897644, 0.022766113, 0.027328491, -0.09094238, -0.006591797, -0.0019893646, -0.016036987, 0.10235596, 0.007133484, -0.048980713, 0.056762695, 0.0023231506, 0.04031372, -0.02444458, 0.02015686, 0.022003174, 0.041046143, -0.009361267, -0.03363037, 0.02268982, -0.006855011, 0.007461548, -0.010414124, 0.021209717, -0.0178833, 0.035186768, 0.016845703, -0.051086426, -0.0037250519, -0.031677246, -0.0067100525, 0.037902832, 0.056488037, 0.044921875, 0.039093018, -0.049957275, 0.088378906, 0.0044174194, 0.017807007, 0.023284912, -0.016601562, 0.0017719269, -0.014122009, 0.0012292862, -0.02709961, 0.0012359619, -0.014465332, -0.016204834, 0.0030593872, 0.0099105835, -0.031677246, -0.019317627, 0.02861023, -0.021057129, -0.011138916, 0.012512207, 0.045928955, -0.002494812, -0.009391785, -0.0007762909, 0.056671143, 0.028167725, 0.005844116, -0.016601562, 0.0010271072, -0.025772095, 0.042877197, 0.010612488, -0.0061950684, 0.023223877, -0.04940796, -0.013885498, -0.004211426, -0.0038433075, -0.030792236, -0.0109939575, -0.018508911, 0.028656006, -0.005973816, -0.00579834, 0.042633057, -0.04638672, 0.013908386, 0.04446411, 0.028915405, -0.01889038, -0.059020996, -0.036895752, 0.018722534, 0.056274414, -0.04888916, -0.0039405823, 0.001742363, -0.047088623, -0.0043411255, 0.08666992, -0.03765869, -0.030380249, 0.0064964294, 0.011642456, 0.00819397, 0.048187256, -0.02017212, -0.05392456, -0.03390503, -0.03515625, -0.05041504, 0.072753906, 0.009376526, 0.07873535, -0.05496216, -0.011856079, -0.003818512, -0.050689697, -0.031082153, -0.028503418, 0.012359619, -0.07720947, -0.03982544, 0.0075683594, 0.02986145, -0.014030457, -0.04159546, 0.042999268, -0.022781372, -0.030944824, 0.03378296, -0.009590149, 0.070373535, 0.007843018, -0.071899414, 0.029556274, 0.017807007, -0.009941101, 0.05722046, 0.0011129379, -0.0036144257, 0.027740479, 0.027832031, 0.025497437, -0.00097227097, 0.04611206, 0.0008997917, -0.046539307, 0.00065612793, -0.013648987, -0.0002758503, 0.038635254, -0.037017822, 0.030532837, 0.0053253174, 0.023117065, 0.03643799, 0.01713562, 0.010635376, 0.0036087036, -0.027023315, 0.020141602, 0.004699707, -0.052978516, -0.024353027, 0.04763794, 0.046813965, -0.006515503, -0.0082092285, 0.0022735596, -0.000078201294, -0.04849243, -0.0019664764, 0.035583496, 0.0008802414, -0.022994995, -0.01626587, 0.004840851, 0.048614502, -0.017593384, 0.0030021667, -0.001868248, 0.03387451, -0.015167236, -0.025680542, 0.027648926, 0.02935791, -0.034179688, -0.01890564, 0.022155762, -0.06335449, -0.02482605, 0.0110321045, -0.015686035, 0.037475586, 0.044067383, 0.024673462, -0.027557373, -0.02720642, 0.0110321045, -0.0078086853, -0.0048713684, -0.05999756, 0.010375977, -0.024978638, -0.023391724, -0.016708374, -0.021957397, -0.009300232, -0.009384155, -0.0039711, -0.04071045, 0.0025081635, 0.00522995, 0.060577393, 0.013710022, 0.020645142, -0.03012085, -0.034179688, -0.036895752, 0.028686523, -0.033355713, -0.01525116, -0.047607422, -0.004371643, 0.011444092, 0.008651733, -0.03643799, -0.07910156, 0.010925293, 0.01890564, 0.028747559, 0.029647827, -0.002149582, 0.014480591, 0.00819397, 0.0017414093, -0.011650085, -0.005405426, -0.0026760101, 0.0061302185, 0.0011310577, 0.033050537, -0.009178162, 0.012084961, 0.005142212, -0.003004074, 0.013923645, -0.003967285, 0.0049362183, 0.024017334, -0.015335083, 0.0362854, 0.019134521, 0.005680084, -0.00095415115, -0.013710022, 0.012687683, -0.028808594, -0.015449524, -0.008758545, 0.035003662, -0.024841309, -0.04574585, 0.0016965866, -0.05026245, 0.007785797, 0.00048613548, 0.0039749146, 0.034423828, -0.01158905, 0.0033855438, 0.011520386, -0.051361084, -0.035736084, 0.0066337585, -0.028015137, -0.046661377, -0.026504517, 0.0345459, -0.024139404, -0.016204834, 0.041534424, -0.02645874, -0.006462097, -0.027496338, 0.012252808, -0.0065956116, 0.0002092123, 0.022247314, -0.010887146, -0.036895752, 0.015617371, 0.0063667297, -0.039215088, -0.034332275, 0.0390625, 0.030960083, 0.001282692, 0.03390503, -0.01159668, -0.023605347, 0.023956299, -0.024093628, 0.0038776398, -0.0049705505, -0.035003662, -0.020690918, -0.024002075, 0.019439697, 0.0013341904, 0.064697266, 0.022735596, 0.03302002, -0.074645996, 0.0027236938, -0.04852295, -0.030517578, -0.013168335, 0.00497818, 0.01737976, -0.016708374, 0.009414673, 0.021728516, -0.0184021, -0.03378296, -0.024932861, 0.00028014183, -0.041381836, 0.0034332275, 0.022903442, -0.06512451, 0.04626465, 0.0046958923, 0.004463196, -0.027908325, 0.04434204, 0.020996094, 0.034179688, -0.015388489, 0.02003479, -0.013679504, 0.009788513, 0.016937256, 0.019989014, -0.008354187, -0.009674072, 0.03338623, 0.014190674, -0.027038574, -0.045196533, -0.034118652, 0.011703491, -0.019424438, 0.030776978, 0.012023926, 0.022827148, -0.008300781, -0.026565552, 0.014076233, -0.030441284, -0.016708374, 0.03857422, -0.029052734, -0.032440186, 0.028884888, 0.011260986, -0.005706787, -0.008651733, -0.012451172, -0.020446777, 0.0010623932, 0.007293701, 0.027114868, -0.06008911, -0.09259033, 0.007472992, 0.014762878, 0.016525269, 0.011550903, 0.030380249, 0.02255249, 0.012756348, 0.03289795, 0.027664185, 0.03765869, -0.013000488, -0.025299072, -0.024658203, 0.013511658, -0.043640137, -0.012290955, 0.011108398, -0.0015048981, 0.006477356, -0.028656006, 0.003742218, -0.016418457, -0.0035648346, 0.0024547577, -0.0014629364, 0.030349731, 0.051727295, 0.008605957, -0.038513184, -0.024658203, 0.018096924, -0.0017948151, -0.009414673, 0.03918457, -0.032928467, -0.042175293, 0.04156494, 0.01626587, 0.011749268, -0.029037476, 0.037475586, 0.039642334, 0.000094890594, -0.026351929, 0.007858276, 0.026672363, 0.035736084, -0.02947998, 0.009742737, 0.014877319, 0.042907715, 0.014152527, 0.028839111, 0.029937744, 0.0015678406, -0.013511658, 0.0031108856, -0.0107040405, -0.024810791, 0.020645142, -0.009819031, -0.019729614, -0.032928467, -0.020248413, -0.027359009, 0.042816162, -0.0058288574, 0.014595032, 0.0032691956, 0.011505127, -0.0030612946, -0.00894928, -0.02909851, 0.0046424866, 0.0234375, -0.027923584, -0.02142334, 0.016326904, -0.014450073, 0.022766113, 0.037200928, -0.005126953, 0.0034255981, 0.012969971, 0.015151978, 0.038146973, -0.04421997, 0.0026454926, -0.03363037, 0.027236938, -0.020599365, 0.041534424, 0.053955078, 0.09899902, -0.02684021, -0.03414917, -0.058898926, 0.02911377, -0.037261963, 0.030151367, -0.0071144104, 0.026367188, 0.014503479, -0.019302368, 0.012451172, 0.026489258, -0.027359009, 0.0049552917, -0.029953003, 0.0770874, -0.043182373, -0.04928589, -0.0029201508, 0.03668213, -0.014442444, -0.03189087, -0.033935547, 0.019943237, -0.012901306, -0.06124878, 0.05230713, -0.021728516, -0.007083893, -0.02192688, 0.039367676, 0.00016057491, 0.0018920898, 0.025848389, 0.006828308, 0.016998291, 0.025726318, 0.017364502, -0.00008785725, -0.03237915, 0.034301758, 0.007297516, -0.010368347, 0.012969971, 0.029510498, -0.0046157837, 0.062927246, 0.038269043, -0.023071289, 0.026763916, 0.0418396, -0.022598267, 0.0013065338, -0.04135132, -0.011520386, -0.040985107, -0.022109985, 0.014640808, -0.026489258, -0.034118652, 0.004234314, -0.08331299, -0.016723633, -0.038909912, 0.0051498413, -0.03036499, 0.027404785, -0.03375244, -0.058013916, -0.08984375, 0.033111572, 0.0062828064, -0.015853882, -0.04156494, -0.033843994, -0.0039787292, -0.028182983, -0.018569946, 0.014022827, -0.010002136, -0.017028809, -0.011306763, -0.0011978149, 0.027145386, -0.023910522, -0.02116394, 0.018310547, 0.019378662, 0.0064888, -0.06933594, -0.016906738, -0.0034809113, 0.029754639, -0.007965088, 0.0016508102, 0.019989014, 0.00046300888, -0.040374756, -0.010253906, -0.0025367737, -0.029205322, 0.049438477, 0.033935547, -0.0030384064, -0.03930664, 0.01763916, -0.006843567, 0.028778076, -0.035064697, -0.0085372925, 0.034973145, 0.018569946, -0.015403748, -0.016052246, -0.0053901672, 0.010002136, 0.013404846, -0.008636475, -0.0057296753, 0.0035762787, 0.036224365, -0.047943115, -0.019470215, -0.009300232, 0.022964478, 0.005558014, -0.028137207, -0.015548706, -0.017669678, 0.05303955, 0.012275696, 0.012031555, -0.026397705, 0.027557373, -0.023498535, 0.035614014, -0.0036296844, -0.029281616, 0.012420654, 0.021743774, -0.01486969, -0.009841919, 0.012969971, -0.026443481, -0.023101807, 0.0029697418, -0.017715454, -0.02130127, -0.008201599, 0.028060913, 0.04574585, -0.045196533, -0.058502197, -0.003206253, -0.0049324036, -0.05041504, -0.08203125, -0.023406982, -0.0013771057, 0.020309448, 0.0024967194, 0.03201294, 0.008171082, 0.03817749, 0.03237915, -0.00039339066, -0.0008111, 0.021148682, 0.027679443, -0.018951416, -0.034851074, 0.019195557, -0.089782715, -0.014442444, -0.017745972, -0.01739502, 0.010406494, -0.033569336, 0.017547607, 0.0072784424, -0.0050621033, 0.01838684, 0.035217285, -0.0066490173, 0.008979797, 0.033599854, 0.024810791, -0.008522034, 0.010223389 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06818v1
Cricket Player Profiling: Unraveling Strengths and Weaknesses Using Text Commentary Data
Swarup Ranjan Behera, Vijaya V. Saradhi
cs.LG, cs.CL, I.2.7
Devising player-specific strategies in cricket necessitates a meticulous understanding of each player's unique strengths and weaknesses. Nevertheless, the absence of a definitive computational approach to extract such insights from cricket players poses a significant challenge. This paper seeks to address this gap by establishing computational models designed to extract the rules governing player strengths and weaknesses, thereby facilitating the development of tailored strategies for individual players. The complexity of this endeavor lies in several key areas: the selection of a suitable dataset, the precise definition of strength and weakness rules, the identification of an appropriate learning algorithm, and the validation of the derived rules. To tackle these challenges, we propose the utilization of unstructured data, specifically cricket text commentary, as a valuable resource for constructing comprehensive strength and weakness rules for cricket players. We also introduce computationally feasible definitions for the construction of these rules, and present a dimensionality reduction technique for the rule-building process. In order to showcase the practicality of this approach, we conduct an in-depth analysis of cricket player strengths and weaknesses using a vast corpus of more than one million text commentaries. Furthermore, we validate the constructed rules through two distinct methodologies: intrinsic and extrinsic. The outcomes of this research are made openly accessible, including the collected data, source code, and results for over 250 cricket players, which can be accessed at https://bit.ly/2PKuzx8.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06818v1
2023-11-12T11:51:05
2023-11-12T11:51:05
{ "title": [ -0.01939392, -0.001953125, -0.040618896, -0.014724731, 0.0049858093, -0.019485474, -0.0017614365, -0.0138168335, -0.0067329407, 0.036834717, -0.036010742, 0.027893066, 0.004108429, 0.004562378, -0.04714966, -0.024627686, -0.005290985, 0.036346436, -0.0057868958, -0.031433105, 0.009986877, -0.03062439, 0.005355835, 0.014099121, 0.018600464, -0.023727417, -0.023117065, 0.01826477, 0.015319824, -0.012481689, 0.0030441284, -0.022720337, 0.038726807, 0.008163452, 0.012145996, 0.06536865, -0.039154053, 0.032165527, 0.017791748, -0.010391235, 0.0076560974, -0.0042915344, -0.059173584, -0.00018846989, -0.06274414, 0.013175964, -0.06225586, -0.008102417, -0.014533997, 0.019592285, -0.0039138794, 0.022155762, 0.015838623, 0.006881714, 0.012512207, -0.018478394, -0.04852295, 0.0146865845, 0.017486572, 0.038513184, 0.024536133, -0.028381348, 0.020767212, 0.0018472672, -0.035339355, -0.022247314, 0.004627228, 0.037322998, 0.04937744, -0.023040771, -0.010292053, 0.037628174, -0.014389038, -0.008560181, -0.047821045, 0.01852417, 0.03475952, 0.0211792, 0.013000488, -0.00869751, 0.0002169609, -0.0473938, 0.059020996, -0.002500534, -0.0023517609, 0.0013360977, 0.00039625168, -0.0009880066, -0.008743286, -0.017150879, -0.0054359436, 0.0007305145, 0.025619507, 0.014007568, -0.051116943, -0.0042648315, 0.0046806335, 0.031677246, -0.008010864, -0.02760315, -0.044311523, 0.020965576, -0.0552063, -0.0074539185, 0.0066986084, 0.059661865, -0.0059051514, -0.0018005371, 0.0061531067, 0.0093688965, -0.0044059753, 0.0009584427, 0.041625977, 0.024490356, -0.015151978, -0.025024414, -0.0024757385, 0.015945435, 0.003545761, 0.017242432, -0.011413574, -0.015106201, 0.00038576126, -0.0065460205, 0.012718201, -0.025131226, -0.034576416, 0.025482178, 0.02482605, 0.022491455, -0.00019693375, 0.051208496, -0.07714844, -0.09295654, -0.05557251, 0.03366089, -0.03173828, -0.023345947, -0.03289795, 0.047943115, -0.031311035, -0.03778076, 0.048461914, -0.033294678, 0.018173218, -0.0118637085, 0.043914795, 0.016494751, -0.016082764, 0.024368286, -0.0423584, 0.051727295, 0.010719299, 0.0046958923, -0.006111145, 0.003622055, -0.058441162, -0.020935059, 0.01626587, -0.011383057, 0.049316406, -0.00944519, -0.045928955, 0.021102905, 0.0154953, 0.007789612, 0.0017004013, 0.023666382, 0.0055274963, -0.0044937134, -0.010734558, -0.013046265, 0.010932922, -0.018325806, -0.010658264, 0.0129852295, -0.005622864, -0.001156807, 0.020004272, -0.018203735, 0.00081443787, -0.016296387, -0.006351471, 0.04107666, -0.05819702, -0.028625488, 0.01965332, 0.01360321, 0.029693604, 0.007572174, 0.017745972, 0.030670166, -0.06695557, -0.04574585, -0.035461426, 0.008506775, 0.028396606, 0.032958984, -0.0040779114, 0.01663208, 0.040985107, -0.007980347, 0.0033130646, -0.022827148, -0.026977539, -0.029525757, -0.0010166168, 0.016983032, -0.03289795, 0.045074463, 0.04336548, -0.009391785, -0.031951904, 0.025268555, 0.00969696, -0.055725098, 0.0069618225, -0.023117065, 0.011009216, 0.0027179718, -0.016098022, 0.0023345947, -0.013687134, 0.0077934265, -0.006198883, -0.0058517456, 0.025436401, -0.013916016, 0.04763794, 0.027709961, 0.088012695, -0.05606079, 0.058135986, 0.025650024, -0.012779236, -0.008033752, 0.009361267, -0.027175903, -0.0019664764, 0.02204895, 0.0042800903, -0.0045318604, -0.009284973, 0.0013008118, 0.021728516, -0.059692383, -0.0015573502, 0.010429382, 0.055358887, 0.03100586, -0.0042152405, -0.014389038, 0.068237305, -0.001786232, 0.020324707, 0.05758667, -0.028030396, 0.023117065, -0.030029297, 0.020004272, 0.011512756, 0.09893799, 0.054504395, 0.02130127, -0.013290405, 0.016220093, 0.009300232, 0.039886475, 0.016738892, 0.0064086914, 0.0039596558, -0.017150879, 0.017242432, 0.01360321, 0.04727173, -0.02053833, -0.010375977, -0.0069389343, 0.027069092, -0.016174316, 0.0030155182, 0.01838684, -0.008598328, -0.007499695, 0.030090332, 0.007972717, -0.004421234, 0.015731812, -0.056854248, -0.0043792725, 0.028533936, 0.057922363, -0.0143585205, 0.0010118484, 0.0033473969, 0.0256958, 0.08770752, 0.093688965, -0.050628662, 0.057647705, -0.05581665, 0.0007004738, 0.0446167, -0.048706055, 0.002166748, 0.03387451, -0.007171631, 0.012207031, -0.016647339, 0.001282692, -0.006111145, 0.02532959, 0.025726318, -0.026275635, 0.0119018555, -0.011291504, 0.025909424, 0.01638794, 0.0068588257, 0.019104004, 0.028015137, -0.03692627, -0.018630981, -0.02230835, -0.01979065, -0.0109939575, -0.04220581, -0.020095825, 0.008651733, 0.011497498, 0.011329651, 0.0019569397, -0.0793457, -0.015602112, 0.01033783, 0.038513184, -0.008865356, -0.01663208, -0.008003235, 0.0028533936, 0.00038218498, 0.015449524, 0.008705139, -0.03152466, 0.0017137527, -0.06021118, -0.012565613, 0.0154953, -0.032562256, -0.026306152, 0.037200928, -0.008796692, -0.010353088, 0.020492554, 0.04663086, -0.00844574, -0.007835388, 0.07324219, 0.04559326, 0.017807007, 0.023666382, 0.044403076, 0.009963989, -0.05215454, -0.031677246, -0.062561035, -0.012001038, -0.0011100769, 0.023956299, 0.042266846, -0.038208008, -0.018463135, -0.014137268, 0.017059326, 0.026809692, 0.0068473816, -0.046020508, -0.051757812, 0.0050621033, -0.045532227, -0.0047454834, -0.033569336, 0.033081055, -0.00041294098, 0.042022705, 0.028778076, -0.0051231384, -0.018157959, 0.013244629, -0.005207062, -0.008094788, -0.004589081, -0.04748535, -0.0079956055, 0.014953613, 0.0033950806, 0.006008148, 0.013496399, -0.07989502, -0.0027179718, 0.07043457, -0.007144928, -0.017578125, 0.045318604, -0.076049805, 0.070129395, 0.010505676, -0.0077667236, 0.02053833, 0.078430176, -0.0016870499, -0.00034570694, 0.004306793, 0.005176544, -0.0022945404, -0.000033140182, -0.068359375, 0.023773193, -0.013290405, -0.033813477, 0.027877808, -0.040039062, -0.009132385, 0.006324768, 0.003435135, 0.0670166, 0.007598877, -0.0016517639, 0.007949829, -0.026870728, 0.019424438, -0.02305603, 0.01474762, -0.030090332, -0.03074646, 0.02609253, -0.011726379, 0.09893799, 0.0015392303, -0.015655518, -0.052337646, -0.007980347, 0.006893158, 0.033172607, 0.018234253, -0.035003662, -0.027526855, -0.03842163, -0.009933472, 0.0009455681, -0.008865356, -0.0030555725, -0.00030970573, 0.018493652, -0.017105103, 0.036254883, -0.016799927, 0.018325806, -0.023834229, -0.011947632, 0.010688782, -0.010803223, -0.0034770966, -0.004016876, 0.026321411, -0.011756897, 0.011428833, -0.0028896332, -0.028564453, 0.02458191, 0.003698349, -0.003129959, -0.019470215, -0.02470398, 0.033935547, -0.022750854, -0.0043563843, 0.010627747, -0.016937256, -0.008987427, -0.0141067505, 0.0126953125, -0.009651184, -0.036987305, -0.016647339, 0.02104187, -0.062683105, -0.023834229, 0.01550293, -0.01939392, -0.0770874, -0.0016851425, 0.00843811, -0.01927185, -0.014442444, 0.036376953, -0.012062073, 0.029037476, -0.035186768, -0.10217285, -0.0073051453, 0.04864502, -0.024093628, 0.062042236, 0.04815674, -0.009269714, -0.029251099, -0.001830101, 0.025039673, 0.04006958, 0.011260986, 0.0048828125, -0.014450073, 0.0032367706, -0.01586914, 0.03012085, -0.013504028, -0.04159546, 0.016082764, 0.015380859, 0.03466797, 0.069885254, -0.00969696, 0.058807373, 0.012634277, -0.018432617, -0.06384277, -0.001458168, 0.009567261, -0.0050735474, 0.029968262, -0.0056991577, 0.026367188, 0.017105103, 0.002374649, 0.026000977, -0.019134521, -0.014205933, 0.064086914, 0.0066108704, -0.010787964, -0.013427734, -0.017791748, 0.04260254, -0.02305603, 0.012741089, -0.025985718, 0.037109375, -0.0340271, -0.031234741, 0.020446777, 0.031219482, -0.076171875, -0.025741577, -0.041412354, -0.044952393, -0.038909912, 0.022903442, -0.0059776306, -0.0035095215, 0.024154663, 0.0045204163, -0.030670166, -0.0076065063, 0.019744873, 0.001791954, -0.012687683, -0.06402588, 0.00756073, -0.014213562, -0.05407715, -0.008712769, 0.04574585, -0.018447876, 0.058502197, -0.053527832, -0.033325195, -0.0031547546, 0.008834839, 0.051696777, 0.043945312, 0.009063721, -0.04611206, 0.01928711, -0.024780273, -0.011489868, 0.04171753, 0.008415222, 0.01991272, 0.008575439, 0.017929077, -0.031341553, -0.004611969, 0.0062675476, 0.023223877, -0.04916382, 0.051696777, -0.020935059, 0.04714966, 0.022399902, 0.012557983, 0.009765625, -0.0113220215, -0.028549194, -0.0051193237, 0.00856781, 0.0625, -0.02557373, 0.010597229, 0.024368286, -0.0021972656, -0.02746582, 0.0022201538, 0.018203735, 0.022491455, -0.005970001, 0.0050621033, 0.01902771, -0.04916382, -0.02923584, -0.03225708, 0.0051956177, 0.02279663, -0.11480713, 0.022888184, -0.023040771, -0.0059280396, 0.045837402, 0.016204834, 0.018157959, 0.039764404, 0.024780273, -0.02947998, -0.03427124, 0.040618896, 0.03567505, -0.005393982, 0.0058174133, -0.0064315796, 0.027572632, 0.0015335083, 0.039031982, -0.022476196, 0.04916382, 0.023452759, 0.021896362, 0.013137817, -0.034301758, -0.021774292, -0.007499695, 0.045837402, 0.0073776245, -0.068847656, 0.0027484894, -0.0096206665, -0.026947021, 0.0042419434, -0.033599854, 0.01991272, -0.05895996, 0.00674057, 0.047180176, -0.039855957, 0.026412964, -0.025039673, 0.03744507, 0.07647705, 0.044708252, 0.01687622, -0.014442444, 0.026306152, 0.010658264, -0.06817627, -0.027069092, 0.0335083, 0.024368286, 0.03149414, 0.040283203, 0.012825012, -0.07965088, 0.020065308, 0.0043296814, -0.004638672, 0.017425537, -0.059783936, 0.020568848, -0.023483276, -0.018615723, 0.0035705566, -0.0055732727, 0.0121536255, 0.027526855, -0.024887085, 0.0016059875, -0.01637268, -0.029266357, -0.057800293, -0.066589355, 0.008728027, 0.022125244, 0.017822266, -0.040252686, 0.02810669, -0.051574707, 0.014572144, 0.0423584, -0.06677246, 0.026947021, -0.021530151, 0.010505676, 0.05392456, 0.02658081, -0.05496216, -0.0019397736, -0.0055503845, -0.013328552, -0.019454956, 0.02545166, 0.009376526, -0.014053345, -0.0042800903, -0.040008545, 0.0014362335, -0.008308411, 0.013168335, -0.00592041, -0.019989014, 0.008102417, -0.02116394, -0.015312195, 0.027252197, 0.023544312, 0.009750366, 0.012504578, -0.0019016266, -0.03869629, 0.044158936, 0.0010271072, 0.028579712, -0.011108398, -0.059509277, 0.01235199, 0.0132369995, -0.008087158, 0.024353027, 0.03930664, 0.031173706, 0.075683594, 0.01991272, 0.03363037, 0.054382324, -0.020629883, -0.062561035, -0.02658081, 0.000030755997, -0.027755737, 0.048095703, 0.002500534, -0.05307007, -0.014442444, -0.0440979, -0.019622803, 0.010421753, 0.014328003, 0.002166748, 0.02456665, -0.02949524, 0.02859497, -0.035949707, -0.014541626, -0.05230713, 0.041625977, -0.014083862, -0.0016260147, 0.012519836, -0.022537231, -0.008659363, -0.04397583, 0.020080566, 0.0067977905, 0.020187378, -0.019561768, 0.009429932, 0.0010566711, -0.018188477, -0.03555298, 0.055847168, 0.009864807, -0.006462097, 0.05923462, -0.010421753, 0.030639648, 0.022445679, 0.046051025, 0.04953003, 0.022338867, -0.001698494, -0.00038027763, 0.002811432, -0.026687622, -0.028167725, -0.043029785, -0.025512695, -0.020080566, -0.0029697418, -0.04824829, 0.015144348, 0.020492554, 0.048553467, -0.020248413, 0.014503479, 0.039520264, -0.007701874, 0.02558899, -0.0602417, 0.066711426, -0.016967773, -0.0019874573, -0.0317688, -0.07910156, 0.08062744, 0.05960083, -0.03479004, 0.005317688, -0.0077590942, -0.021469116, -0.021728516, 0.0119018555, 0.03842163, -0.005268097, -0.008201599, -0.008415222, 0.040283203, 0.008369446, 0.034179688, 0.051605225, 0.027862549, 0.0010681152, -0.026535034, 0.0022335052, -0.030822754, -0.012191772, -0.009246826, 0.046905518, -0.07318115, 0.04977417, -0.021896362, -0.03567505, -0.04562378, 0.04727173, 0.017074585, -0.006122589, -0.002948761, 0.039733887, 0.020187378, 0.017242432, -0.011428833, -0.041412354, -0.03378296, -0.013221741, 0.015045166, -0.016601562, -0.0063171387, 0.0060272217, 0.0184021, 0.030227661, -0.04296875, -0.0037574768, 0.0061302185, -0.002204895, 0.03479004, 0.030715942, 0.026916504, 0.0061454773, -0.029266357, -0.0063591003, 0.02696228, -0.037139893, -0.009933472, 0.017608643, 0.023803711, 0.04296875, 0.08062744, 0.042266846, 0.0063095093, -0.016220093, -0.043304443, 0.01965332, 0.051574707, -0.0110321045, 0.0063934326, -0.046875, -0.054382324, 0.016662598, -0.057250977, 0.067993164, -0.042785645, 0.0027656555, -0.034210205, 0.04043579, -0.0060653687, -0.03970337, -0.021820068, -0.017349243, -0.024642944, 0.010414124, 0.00085163116, -0.043945312, 0.014045715, 0.008666992, -0.020080566, 0.04168701, 0.014671326, 0.066711426, -0.015579224, -0.08648682, 0.021408081, -0.026519775, 0.04373169, -0.08728027, -0.0049476624, -0.0012187958, 0.0256958, 0.008735657, -0.026123047, -0.046936035, 0.06536865, 0.01789856, -0.05255127, 0.005344391, -0.0072288513, -0.044677734, -0.04534912, 0.03656006, -0.020584106, -0.028244019, -0.025054932, 0.015052795, -0.019744873, -0.054992676, -0.0287323, -0.04699707, 0.019104004, 0.034179688, -0.014137268, 0.045654297, 0.012260437, -0.010635376, -0.0090789795, -0.012176514, 0.0013942719, 0.008979797, -0.03842163, -0.009544373, 0.009941101, 0.028625488, -0.066711426, -0.06896973, -0.018707275, 0.08673096, -0.0010089874, 0.04397583, -0.0024166107, 0.022979736, 0.023239136, 0.029724121, 0.0009994507, -0.032684326, -0.04623413, -0.042999268, 0.04421997, 0.032958984, -0.016708374, -0.024215698, 0.028625488, 0.032318115, 0.028533936, -0.0020771027, -0.008651733, 0.012123108, -0.012275696, 0.041168213, 0.012779236, -0.033721924, -0.03970337, 0.030044556, -0.0004785061, 0.036590576, -0.013160706, 0.024871826, 0.0061950684, 0.043670654, -0.04119873, -0.059417725, 0.051330566, 0.049591064, 0.0104599, 0.057159424, 0.015258789, -0.0040893555, -0.011688232, -0.00066804886, 0.006362915, -0.0027751923, 0.00756073, -0.0103302, 0.00598526, -0.0519104, -0.04852295, 0.001080513, -0.040008545, 0.05670166, -0.021362305, 0.010414124, -0.006336212, 0.0154418945, -0.00374794, 0.035491943, -0.0014448166, -0.05355835, 0.013114929, 0.05230713, 0.06842041, 0.010986328 ], "summary": [ -0.016479492, -0.034576416, 0.006061554, 0.03463745, -0.04901123, -0.007789612, -0.02394104, -0.04373169, -0.009681702, 0.040924072, -0.032196045, 0.04071045, 0.01259613, 0.0030117035, -0.014694214, -0.013801575, 0.013809204, 0.0074386597, -0.011024475, -0.040924072, 0.030288696, -0.031158447, -0.025253296, 0.1027832, 0.018676758, 0.007675171, 0.005908966, -0.0027256012, 0.020446777, 0.018554688, 0.005378723, -0.04067993, 0.025115967, -0.0038814545, 0.010047913, 0.026382446, 0.0073394775, -0.00016868114, -0.0026855469, 0.035064697, 0.020126343, 0.0004286766, -0.017471313, 0.007633209, -0.05130005, 0.0050239563, -0.014663696, 0.0002411604, 0.019012451, 0.010292053, -0.00079774857, 0.011932373, 0.005847931, -0.0035953522, -0.0079956055, -0.027832031, -0.02684021, -0.029174805, 0.0042533875, 0.059661865, 0.011734009, -0.022338867, 0.010574341, -0.036193848, -0.022872925, -0.012786865, 0.049560547, 0.016296387, 0.037261963, -0.052246094, 0.0025100708, 0.05822754, -0.0037021637, 0.010810852, -0.011917114, 0.0012903214, 0.02468872, 0.03491211, -0.0032482147, 0.0006213188, 0.00907135, -0.015419006, 0.072631836, -0.028945923, -0.002916336, -0.029708862, 0.004043579, 0.0013513565, 0.0020370483, -0.0009088516, -0.017700195, 0.052856445, -0.0018701553, 0.015930176, -0.03253174, 0.0012397766, -0.023849487, -0.0418396, -0.0008163452, -0.0076828003, 0.0110321045, -0.033477783, 0.036376953, -0.012954712, -0.025680542, 0.04611206, 0.031036377, 0.011054993, -0.027694702, -0.007926941, -0.01473999, -0.06439209, 0.04498291, 0.03842163, -0.03878784, -0.031707764, 0.00289917, 0.019256592, -0.0048217773, 0.04272461, -0.01927185, 0.005420685, -0.028503418, 0.036468506, -0.030166626, -0.015701294, 0.003932953, 0.0027256012, 0.07409668, -0.00048708916, -0.022949219, 0.013580322, -0.016357422, -0.027877808, -0.00422287, -0.00762558, 0.00806427, -0.047729492, -0.027252197, 0.038085938, -0.024215698, -0.031204224, 0.00007522106, -0.018096924, 0.074401855, 0.0070610046, 0.034301758, -0.00044369698, 0.006385803, 0.0501709, -0.03942871, 0.060180664, 0.023788452, -0.016738892, -0.015930176, -0.010345459, -0.022888184, 0.0045814514, -0.0015306473, -0.014442444, 0.059570312, -0.0056114197, -0.047912598, 0.02947998, -0.0095825195, 0.015899658, -0.015335083, -0.002626419, 0.0075645447, -0.055145264, -0.00011116266, -0.0143966675, 0.016830444, -0.008125305, 0.00843811, 0.014854431, -0.042633057, -0.02796936, -0.010299683, 0.036376953, 0.035461426, -0.009002686, -0.07116699, 0.056396484, 0.014060974, -0.04034424, 0.013465881, -0.022247314, 0.029800415, 0.023361206, 0.0010242462, 0.019104004, -0.041931152, -0.010215759, -0.04208374, 0.022964478, 0.0073051453, 0.02947998, -0.027236938, 0.03125, 0.062194824, 0.001156807, 0.010566711, -0.03213501, -0.0052452087, -0.019699097, 0.013000488, 0.014022827, -0.08947754, 0.012626648, 0.05645752, -0.01058197, -0.057281494, 0.039916992, 0.06542969, -0.033111572, -0.0038909912, 0.0032463074, 0.019500732, -0.00982666, -0.00072336197, 0.011619568, -0.0143585205, -0.0053977966, -0.0496521, -0.013618469, 0.008621216, 0.013267517, -0.00793457, 0.027404785, 0.051239014, -0.027877808, 0.0335083, 0.025909424, -0.0010633469, 0.0026683807, 0.027450562, -0.058776855, 0.019500732, 0.030914307, 0.021835327, 0.0024719238, -0.014785767, -0.037475586, -0.046173096, -0.10888672, 0.0020122528, -0.020568848, -0.006664276, 0.029586792, -0.028671265, 0.017501831, 0.023986816, 0.018692017, -0.027923584, 0.04837036, -0.04019165, 0.011726379, 0.027908325, 0.0016889572, -0.025100708, 0.045440674, 0.07623291, -0.025405884, 0.020828247, -0.014167786, 0.024719238, 0.016952515, 0.03665161, -0.025619507, -0.016983032, -0.06738281, 0.011878967, -0.012107849, 0.0005803108, -0.043701172, 0.002817154, 0.0012168884, 0.005302429, -0.015602112, 0.01977539, 0.010414124, -0.042785645, 0.0005354881, 0.01902771, -0.0014886856, -0.013427734, 0.039001465, 0.0048446655, 0.08642578, 0.054626465, 0.0602417, -0.00086307526, 0.027999878, -0.0050354004, 0.03717041, 0.020584106, 0.06903076, -0.023635864, 0.0055351257, -0.055267334, 0.009170532, 0.021255493, -0.05645752, -0.019638062, 0.029571533, -0.052124023, 0.01966858, -0.0066223145, -0.04611206, 0.03186035, 0.047912598, 0.025482178, -0.011154175, 0.05316162, 0.02192688, 0.028686523, 0.046905518, 0.0546875, 0.07122803, 0.005329132, -0.0256958, 0.026168823, 0.008323669, -0.0045547485, -0.030822754, 0.027816772, 0.0011138916, 0.0033397675, -0.031921387, -0.03363037, -0.03427124, -0.059661865, 0.04815674, 0.00724411, 0.030792236, 0.0036010742, 0.03237915, 0.0035114288, -0.027252197, 0.007472992, 0.05859375, 0.0035514832, -0.013221741, -0.025222778, -0.0016584396, -0.029876709, 0.009063721, 0.004261017, -0.030914307, 0.020141602, -0.0038204193, -0.013137817, 0.041046143, 0.016281128, 0.009590149, 0.0061531067, 0.06555176, 0.034820557, 0.0014095306, 0.028182983, 0.033111572, 0.00566864, -0.027679443, -0.054382324, -0.02947998, 0.03894043, -0.0041618347, 0.036071777, 0.05581665, -0.05041504, 0.033355713, -0.018814087, 0.0022029877, 0.033416748, 0.024291992, 0.03086853, -0.013893127, -0.025680542, 0.017654419, 0.025360107, 0.009246826, -0.008850098, -0.0055999756, 0.027633667, 0.018447876, 0.018035889, -0.0034618378, 0.04650879, -0.011741638, 0.0007314682, -0.0181427, -0.0020751953, -0.041870117, -0.011993408, 0.020980835, -0.008010864, -0.013801575, 0.025115967, -0.028823853, 0.052947998, -0.0016593933, 0.011550903, 0.03491211, -0.024902344, 0.05355835, 0.033599854, 0.00017225742, 0.01033783, 0.082458496, 0.028457642, -0.05960083, 0.03164673, -0.025344849, 0.026779175, 0.005054474, -0.013977051, 0.010108948, -0.013259888, -0.00013792515, 0.021606445, -0.014862061, 0.0109939575, 0.026245117, 0.0040397644, 0.005306244, -0.008735657, 0.006713867, 0.003206253, 0.016784668, -0.007575989, -0.006969452, 0.011314392, -0.020019531, -0.024002075, 0.020248413, -0.015640259, 0.06524658, -0.013877869, -0.03829956, -0.05316162, -0.0064735413, -0.0134887695, 0.031311035, -0.002210617, -0.009887695, -0.019729614, -0.053222656, 0.05392456, 0.0067710876, -0.016204834, -0.020812988, 0.05505371, 0.015083313, -0.0362854, 0.008758545, -0.03463745, 0.017044067, 0.019302368, -0.017028809, -0.015640259, -0.014656067, -0.003583908, -0.012397766, 0.004180908, 0.028915405, -0.039520264, 0.016540527, 0.00077056885, -0.01361084, 0.013885498, 0.023956299, -0.031707764, -0.038482666, 0.00579834, -0.039886475, 0.0446167, -0.0066833496, 0.053955078, -0.028244019, -0.022369385, 0.015129089, -0.007003784, -0.044799805, -0.013061523, 0.0016870499, -0.04458618, -0.03387451, 0.0051841736, 0.022338867, -0.03050232, 0.0104904175, 0.033477783, -0.009666443, -0.008583069, 0.029342651, -0.036590576, 0.11657715, -0.000030100346, -0.09307861, 0.0501709, -0.025726318, 0.01436615, 0.026885986, -0.027877808, 0.011833191, 0.033691406, 0.019363403, 0.038848877, 0.023605347, -0.002231598, -0.009140015, -0.041412354, 0.002166748, -0.017608643, 0.044647217, -0.001619339, 0.015014648, 0.0068092346, -0.03086853, 0.034210205, 0.079956055, -0.005168915, 0.020935059, 0.014724731, -0.02432251, -0.030776978, 0.0043945312, 0.0018882751, -0.022705078, 0.037597656, 0.025970459, -0.020141602, 0.014427185, -0.0075645447, -0.016952515, -0.03414917, -0.041137695, 0.06970215, 0.05380249, -0.002002716, 0.0013952255, -0.025741577, 0.08105469, -0.027496338, 0.034362793, -0.044128418, 0.04260254, -0.051513672, -0.00019621849, 0.020050049, 0.034210205, -0.09033203, -0.033447266, 0.000767231, -0.000060915947, -0.026901245, 0.029067993, -0.005710602, -0.033203125, -0.0071144104, -0.007911682, 0.002336502, -0.0024280548, 0.050354004, 0.018508911, -0.029678345, -0.067871094, -0.016189575, -0.021575928, 0.006011963, 0.0135650635, 0.019729614, -0.03540039, 0.00894165, -0.04296875, -0.023788452, -0.005214691, 0.03656006, 0.07507324, 0.02229309, 0.041015625, -0.03741455, -0.0031471252, -0.020828247, 0.024307251, 0.010444641, 0.014137268, 0.012001038, 0.028305054, -0.009719849, 0.0006227493, -0.037994385, -0.03652954, 0.021087646, 0.0007658005, 0.02218628, 0.03338623, 0.04208374, 0.032196045, -0.024887085, -0.01902771, -0.017486572, -0.03781128, 0.08862305, 0.00116539, 0.048614502, -0.056121826, -0.010528564, 0.02557373, -0.0035991669, -0.020446777, 0.033203125, -0.021057129, 0.025512695, 0.00022757053, -0.016693115, 0.027938843, 0.0075263977, -0.024230957, -0.010307312, -0.0093688965, -0.017044067, -0.055511475, 0.00092840195, -0.038116455, -0.01436615, 0.028564453, 0.014137268, -0.009094238, 0.039642334, -0.0035133362, 0.0052833557, -0.00541687, 0.039978027, 0.02281189, -0.0008597374, -0.00073719025, -0.06677246, 0.00831604, 0.008735657, 0.028396606, -0.04031372, -0.012283325, 0.046173096, 0.019699097, -0.011940002, -0.02178955, -0.005519867, -0.020462036, 0.042297363, 0.008026123, -0.056640625, 0.013877869, 0.048034668, -0.02810669, 0.012840271, -0.030776978, -0.00029110909, -0.044952393, -0.026260376, 0.0007443428, -0.050811768, -0.0006155968, -0.043395996, 0.003036499, 0.042419434, 0.04220581, -0.018814087, -0.00025367737, 0.0126953125, 0.012626648, -0.094177246, -0.055023193, 0.011550903, 0.049591064, 0.025466919, 0.05291748, 0.009689331, -0.07110596, -0.0022697449, -0.058380127, 0.031143188, -0.011154175, -0.017623901, 0.02381897, -0.021316528, -0.012969971, -0.017868042, -0.021377563, 0.025436401, 0.036315918, -0.04144287, -0.0038166046, 0.02532959, -0.026321411, 0.0075683594, -0.037322998, -0.051208496, -0.0050468445, 0.06414795, -0.03125, 0.017913818, -0.018493652, -0.024597168, 0.02748108, -0.056274414, 0.067993164, -0.02116394, 0.020462036, 0.023406982, 0.0155181885, -0.025634766, -0.001868248, -0.005214691, 0.0049591064, 0.030197144, -0.010955811, -0.005306244, 0.024169922, -0.014289856, -0.038726807, 0.0024909973, -0.006713867, 0.021499634, -0.022491455, -0.026611328, 0.0046310425, -0.029342651, -0.048828125, 0.03265381, -0.039001465, -0.013175964, 0.013389587, -0.008178711, -0.0126571655, 0.029647827, -0.013381958, -0.011276245, -0.007865906, -0.03161621, 0.014007568, 0.015792847, -0.02960205, 0.05947876, 0.032562256, 0.010574341, 0.087524414, 0.032836914, 0.0395813, 0.03201294, -0.0030174255, -0.031204224, -0.03640747, -0.009841919, -0.032409668, 0.06878662, -0.00083875656, -0.035003662, -0.028381348, -0.0115737915, 0.0041999817, -0.023757935, -0.008605957, -0.013450623, 0.0042533875, 0.012001038, 0.018676758, -0.004180908, -0.028533936, -0.011123657, 0.025253296, -0.009979248, -0.010284424, 0.04788208, -0.011672974, -0.0072669983, -0.017150879, -0.011459351, 0.003786087, 0.033111572, -0.007827759, 0.022323608, -0.0015745163, 0.00046014786, 0.009338379, 0.03656006, -0.011039734, 0.041259766, 0.01171875, 0.024276733, -0.005859375, -0.009162903, -0.013549805, -0.011726379, -0.03274536, -0.017486572, -0.013755798, -0.03338623, -0.03930664, 0.017669678, 0.0052261353, -0.05255127, -0.03475952, -0.049743652, 0.0038547516, 0.025360107, -0.014884949, 0.025878906, 0.022628784, 0.018096924, 0.042785645, 0.0057029724, -0.035980225, -0.03375244, 0.045196533, -0.02243042, -0.0050735474, -0.0335083, -0.092041016, 0.043060303, 0.06695557, -0.0003631115, -0.009475708, -0.013717651, -0.0158844, -0.014442444, -0.0065345764, 0.027999878, -0.010063171, 0.0068740845, -0.0049324036, 0.06567383, 0.031951904, 0.031463623, 0.04852295, -0.023651123, 0.10321045, -0.07507324, -0.010902405, 0.0019874573, -0.017227173, 0.0115737915, 0.014503479, -0.020523071, 0.012268066, -0.0005645752, -0.028778076, -0.014205933, 0.01889038, 0.02204895, 0.016616821, -0.00047969818, -0.008926392, 0.017974854, 0.008781433, -0.026428223, -0.032043457, -0.02293396, -0.001373291, 0.004131317, -0.0014696121, 0.012542725, 0.00085926056, 0.008674622, 0.0011196136, -0.003730774, -0.0034103394, 0.0030441284, -0.022277832, 0.01184845, 0.032287598, 0.0031585693, 0.04196167, -0.017425537, -0.018173218, 0.025634766, -0.029205322, 0.024368286, -0.042877197, 0.07006836, 0.05783081, 0.07141113, -0.0395813, 0.0025806427, 0.07183838, -0.013923645, 0.006263733, 0.029800415, -0.00048422813, -0.007896423, -0.03591919, -0.012283325, -0.0055351257, -0.038726807, 0.032836914, -0.04196167, 0.004184723, -0.03161621, 0.030715942, -0.074401855, -0.005569458, 0.046051025, -0.04449463, 0.006416321, 0.017944336, 0.0071640015, -0.06188965, 0.055480957, -0.009246826, -0.055114746, 0.033813477, 0.00617218, 0.05001831, -0.0104599, -0.068115234, 0.03152466, -0.009109497, 0.07232666, -0.057373047, -0.019363403, 0.046936035, 0.018722534, -0.0042152405, -0.08673096, -0.050354004, 0.021911621, 0.08630371, -0.012390137, 0.015686035, 0.025634766, -0.016616821, -0.03363037, 0.046691895, -0.007472992, -0.025039673, -0.0019760132, 0.022644043, -0.0038986206, -0.026229858, -0.011070251, -0.029556274, 0.01159668, 0.013587952, 0.009460449, 0.0340271, 0.030654907, -0.004119873, -0.0065574646, 0.004463196, 0.0028038025, 0.006313324, -0.03250122, -0.007598877, 0.009506226, 0.01109314, -0.041290283, -0.04675293, 0.005886078, 0.05923462, 0.011451721, 0.032043457, -0.03778076, 0.0059814453, 0.035247803, 0.06335449, 0.015457153, -0.03427124, -0.062927246, -0.040740967, 0.039276123, -0.026138306, -0.022521973, -0.041778564, 0.012939453, -0.029907227, -0.01689148, 0.027679443, 0.0002065897, -0.011657715, 0.018692017, 0.039123535, -0.015014648, -0.05557251, 0.004753113, 0.0026893616, -0.00037384033, 0.014556885, -0.029083252, 0.002122879, 0.0014429092, -0.00065660477, -0.044708252, -0.012428284, -0.011444092, 0.03466797, -0.015174866, 0.0025749207, -0.018981934, 0.021972656, -0.002664566, 0.013908386, 0.014808655, -0.005508423, -0.0043182373, 0.051605225, 0.009857178, 0.0024261475, -0.04547119, 0.000053346157, -0.053833008, 0.046875, 0.01096344, -0.005821228, 0.044403076, 0.031982422, 0.012756348, 0.042663574, 0.04638672, -0.0236969, 0.06549072, 0.12030029, 0.056243896, 0.039031982 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06815v1
Evaluation of GPT-4 for chest X-ray impression generation: A reader study on performance and perception
Sebastian Ziegelmayer, Alexander W. Marka, Nicolas Lenhart, Nadja Nehls, Stefan Reischl, Felix Harder, Andreas Sauter, Marcus Makowski, Markus Graf, Joshua Gawlitza
cs.CL
The remarkable generative capabilities of multimodal foundation models are currently being explored for a variety of applications. Generating radiological impressions is a challenging task that could significantly reduce the workload of radiologists. In our study we explored and analyzed the generative abilities of GPT-4 for Chest X-ray impression generation. To generate and evaluate impressions of chest X-rays based on different input modalities (image, text, text and image), a blinded radiological report was written for 25-cases of the publicly available NIH-dataset. GPT-4 was given image, finding section or both sequentially to generate an input dependent impression. In a blind randomized reading, 4-radiologists rated the impressions and were asked to classify the impression origin (Human, AI), providing justification for their decision. Lastly text model evaluation metrics and their correlation with the radiological score (summation of the 4 dimensions) was assessed. According to the radiological score, the human-written impression was rated highest, although not significantly different to text-based impressions. The automated evaluation metrics showed moderate to substantial correlations to the radiological score for the image impressions, however individual scores were highly divergent among inputs, indicating insufficient representation of radiological quality. Detection of AI-generated impressions varied by input and was 61% for text-based impressions. Impressions classified as AI-generated had significantly worse radiological scores even when written by a radiologist, indicating potential bias. Our study revealed significant discrepancies between a radiological assessment and common automatic evaluation metrics depending on the model input. The detection of AI-generated findings is subject to bias that highly rated impressions are perceived as human-written.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06815v1
2023-11-12T11:40:57
2023-11-12T11:40:57
{ "title": [ -0.002614975, 0.015686035, -0.026290894, -0.01953125, 0.0005812645, -0.026550293, -0.008460999, -0.028701782, -0.012161255, 0.009468079, -0.018722534, -0.002035141, -0.03540039, -0.047210693, -0.044921875, -0.009475708, -0.007209778, -0.02520752, -0.039764404, -0.043945312, 0.029434204, -0.06262207, 0.006954193, 0.025146484, -0.024154663, 0.019744873, -0.059509277, -0.0090408325, -0.055847168, -0.060180664, -0.021850586, 0.06781006, 0.011749268, 0.028320312, 0.0047340393, 0.00459671, -0.038757324, 0.033447266, 0.014526367, 0.0058937073, -0.023635864, 0.025283813, 0.04034424, -0.046295166, -0.032409668, 0.053894043, -0.1083374, -0.024520874, 0.003921509, 0.052856445, -0.006313324, 0.022964478, 0.00052547455, 0.052734375, 0.0068893433, 0.0005583763, -0.06262207, 0.019927979, 0.0435791, 0.06524658, 0.022979736, -0.024169922, 0.0013456345, -0.021011353, -0.01234436, -0.023513794, -0.014442444, 0.0061035156, 0.074279785, 0.035583496, 0.004283905, 0.019088745, -0.0014343262, -0.034729004, -0.044067383, 0.09350586, 0.01096344, 0.05343628, 0.01701355, -0.0491333, 0.029785156, 0.023040771, -0.031921387, 0.011436462, 0.010772705, 0.013336182, 0.00031471252, -0.025939941, -0.021484375, -0.044311523, -0.004184723, -0.049438477, -0.0063056946, -0.0014295578, -0.0025539398, -0.072509766, -0.024932861, -0.03805542, 0.01272583, 0.0044403076, 0.010498047, -0.029281616, 0.031036377, -0.005809784, -0.010505676, 0.010124207, 0.0113220215, -0.027389526, -0.0057144165, 0.021377563, -0.027740479, 0.014305115, 0.006122589, -0.021697998, -0.01828003, 0.0546875, 0.048614502, -0.02130127, 0.0073280334, 0.010818481, 0.00497818, -0.014640808, 0.0703125, 0.017822266, 0.048797607, 0.049713135, -0.042510986, -0.044555664, -0.032562256, -0.0016908646, 0.033111572, 0.05871582, -0.055541992, -0.04446411, -0.053344727, 0.03265381, -0.0045204163, 0.015670776, -0.01586914, 0.0129470825, -0.0018033981, -0.03756714, 0.013580322, -0.03111267, -0.018936157, 0.03692627, 0.027938843, -0.0023517609, -0.037597656, -0.04611206, -0.018585205, -0.021911621, 0.023361206, -0.011253357, 0.001294136, -0.060333252, -0.052490234, -0.033447266, 0.06274414, -0.004989624, 0.053771973, 0.013893127, -0.015090942, 0.008163452, 0.030273438, -0.036102295, -0.009765625, 0.03463745, 0.01889038, 0.025848389, 0.007713318, -0.0012817383, 0.0473938, -0.01373291, -0.003074646, 0.014732361, 0.021224976, 0.022537231, 0.005203247, -0.034423828, 0.004501343, -0.011856079, 0.01638794, 0.018081665, -0.018035889, -0.052642822, -0.004020691, -0.006916046, 0.036743164, 0.016357422, -0.048309326, 0.003320694, -0.038757324, -0.015914917, -0.015945435, 0.012382507, 0.0007286072, 0.022537231, -0.005126953, -0.010292053, -0.030456543, -0.0074806213, 0.014770508, 0.01802063, -0.013671875, -0.012268066, -0.021209717, 0.0062713623, -0.027389526, -0.00945282, 0.039093018, -0.022323608, -0.037628174, 0.048736572, -0.013130188, -0.04019165, 0.021469116, 0.017593384, -0.0068130493, 0.020889282, -0.034057617, 0.009407043, -0.03010559, -0.019363403, 0.0009937286, 0.042053223, -0.017120361, -0.0053977966, -0.0036773682, 0.06652832, -0.015213013, -0.01574707, -0.027267456, 0.008758545, -0.029190063, -0.007019043, 0.013671875, 0.056518555, 0.009666443, -0.018096924, -0.0022201538, -0.026809692, -0.013717651, 0.035827637, 0.055755615, 0.05581665, 0.02986145, -0.00018012524, 0.027420044, 0.031021118, 0.021606445, -0.004108429, 0.057006836, 0.0021839142, -0.0018024445, 0.061798096, -0.014434814, 0.004421234, 0.04727173, -0.036010742, -0.0012216568, 0.036010742, 0.04815674, 0.019577026, -0.032440186, 0.021453857, -0.015487671, 0.008171082, -0.021102905, 0.03302002, 0.033721924, -0.004558563, 0.030471802, -0.023376465, -0.037353516, 0.030807495, -0.045562744, 0.029144287, 0.042022705, -0.02508545, 0.005519867, 0.010032654, 0.033721924, -0.004047394, 0.01977539, 0.023620605, 0.028564453, 0.02418518, -0.06323242, -0.03451538, 0.030899048, -0.013893127, -0.03842163, -0.022247314, -0.0010719299, -0.014572144, 0.010604858, 0.029693604, 0.015449524, -0.0010137558, -0.03463745, 0.026870728, -0.008155823, 0.0056381226, 0.0036582947, 0.050231934, -0.010116577, 0.031463623, 0.0071029663, -0.022537231, 0.015716553, 0.05267334, 0.026672363, 0.03173828, -0.05670166, -0.056854248, -0.016906738, 0.013076782, -0.050720215, -0.039031982, 0.0014476776, -0.032165527, -0.038116455, -0.0076560974, -0.011558533, 0.0061569214, -0.027557373, -0.012245178, -0.015060425, 0.011230469, 0.059753418, 0.008354187, -0.049316406, -0.0871582, 0.013298035, 0.010070801, -0.0055770874, -0.009437561, -0.039794922, 0.014701843, -0.0070533752, -0.019714355, 0.016647339, -0.06188965, -0.022720337, -0.0024299622, 0.000026226044, 0.006401062, -0.03012085, -0.0028915405, 0.029769897, -0.022415161, -0.010658264, -0.015090942, 0.014122009, 0.096191406, 0.029067993, -0.0049591064, 0.049438477, -0.026153564, 0.033111572, 0.041748047, 0.024520874, -0.026550293, -0.05227661, -0.06439209, -0.012825012, -0.002336502, 0.024093628, 0.05783081, -0.02633667, 0.0074272156, -0.039245605, -0.00014197826, -0.0049209595, -0.009773254, -0.013458252, -0.01701355, -0.008712769, -0.016616821, 0.040527344, 0.021850586, -0.014251709, 0.031066895, 0.058258057, 0.018341064, 0.042541504, -0.014724731, 0.048339844, -0.024658203, 0.008506775, -0.0032520294, 0.024047852, -0.015159607, 0.0055160522, -0.010856628, -0.012107849, 0.012817383, -0.06085205, 0.012886047, -0.039916992, 0.0012235641, 0.0016078949, -0.03552246, -0.00819397, -0.07293701, -0.035461426, -0.027435303, 0.030578613, 0.10333252, 0.021774292, -0.008834839, 0.03366089, -0.0006966591, -0.0071105957, 0.0016345978, -0.05606079, 0.02128601, -0.005317688, -0.0178833, -0.009269714, 0.0053596497, -0.0463562, -0.014312744, 0.014533997, 0.0569458, 0.05090332, -0.0059814453, 0.015426636, -0.00844574, 0.045776367, -0.035339355, -0.01322937, -0.063964844, -0.032958984, -0.002149582, -0.001707077, 0.09326172, -0.012413025, 0.022537231, 0.018981934, 0.019836426, 0.0033550262, 0.026382446, -0.0017461777, -0.0390625, 0.030731201, 0.023010254, -0.027893066, -0.017410278, 0.00554657, 0.030197144, -0.007484436, 0.011207581, -0.007820129, -0.010810852, 0.01121521, 0.035064697, -0.00064468384, -0.013221741, 0.009994507, -0.031036377, -0.037384033, 0.022003174, 0.010818481, -0.02720642, 0.055511475, -0.024505615, -0.021911621, 0.011810303, -0.022415161, 0.0049972534, 0.03366089, 0.027282715, -0.0025959015, 0.0026302338, -0.019836426, 0.041931152, -0.07574463, -0.017150879, -0.010482788, 0.0030975342, 0.02067566, -0.08270264, -0.046325684, 0.036254883, -0.08459473, -0.011856079, 0.013252258, -0.04260254, -0.07006836, -0.0104522705, 0.016601562, -0.018951416, 0.010757446, 0.017105103, 0.0046577454, 0.010063171, 0.017501831, -0.07385254, -0.032287598, 0.07489014, -0.01751709, -0.004760742, 0.009208679, -0.019882202, -0.009719849, 0.0039634705, 0.022369385, -0.0015087128, 0.038970947, 0.027069092, -0.019317627, 0.028701782, -0.023803711, 0.042175293, -0.004306793, -0.017333984, 0.0015869141, -0.0020523071, 0.030395508, 0.015022278, 0.013801575, 0.04208374, -0.012001038, 0.004501343, -0.042144775, 0.017242432, -0.014015198, -0.04724121, 0.013366699, 0.006916046, -0.038970947, 0.01914978, 0.042877197, 0.057037354, -0.030441284, -0.0012493134, 0.0027217865, -0.039733887, -0.02458191, -0.002872467, -0.008865356, 0.024490356, -0.01121521, 0.02355957, -0.021743774, 0.030944824, -0.012924194, -0.017471313, -0.0052986145, 0.018310547, -0.09472656, -0.017196655, -0.052734375, -0.021896362, -0.05203247, 0.028640747, -0.009628296, 0.0012140274, 0.04119873, -0.003686905, -0.041900635, -0.0007429123, 0.040863037, -0.010276794, -0.034454346, -0.09362793, 0.028808594, -0.033569336, -0.060028076, -0.034729004, -0.030792236, -0.0042877197, 0.041778564, 0.008369446, -0.056243896, -0.018661499, 0.013496399, 0.042114258, 0.029556274, 0.027374268, -0.041381836, -0.016906738, -0.025680542, -0.047424316, 0.038909912, -0.02708435, -0.017242432, -0.016845703, 0.060028076, -0.024642944, -0.016784668, -0.03805542, 0.024154663, -0.024475098, 0.037261963, 0.0033607483, 0.018249512, 0.010803223, 0.02609253, -0.007820129, 0.003118515, -0.03161621, 0.0064201355, -0.04034424, -0.00038814545, 0.03778076, 0.029907227, 0.07434082, 0.012367249, -0.036895752, 0.009376526, 0.032073975, 0.04071045, -0.003419876, -0.02368164, 0.020690918, -0.030258179, -0.03274536, -0.010032654, -0.034454346, 0.022155762, -0.054260254, -0.018981934, -0.0045280457, 0.059326172, -0.016601562, -0.038848877, 0.030822754, -0.021881104, 0.026657104, -0.06945801, -0.03237915, -0.0009522438, 0.043548584, -0.04425049, 0.011474609, 0.021865845, 0.0014152527, 0.008666992, 0.05859375, 0.038726807, 0.026306152, -0.03274536, -0.00075531006, 0.01739502, -0.056793213, -0.026855469, 0.028839111, 0.012641907, 0.014289856, -0.04559326, -0.017242432, -0.021606445, -0.036468506, -0.008041382, -0.027877808, -0.0013427734, -0.05041504, 0.017791748, 0.037872314, -0.028137207, 0.027893066, -0.017852783, 0.03591919, 0.03265381, 0.032836914, 0.014442444, 0.005748749, 0.010154724, 0.042022705, 0.011405945, -0.007980347, -0.0060424805, 0.029464722, 0.029876709, 0.005176544, 0.033203125, -0.028366089, 0.013748169, 0.012489319, -0.025299072, 0.041137695, -0.043060303, 0.034851074, 0.018936157, -0.025939941, 0.0016479492, -0.06121826, -0.01751709, 0.02142334, -0.039764404, -0.011184692, 0.085998535, -0.0010728836, -0.053222656, -0.041046143, -0.0016126633, 0.012565613, 0.0071983337, -0.027511597, 0.012756348, -0.07800293, 0.0149383545, 0.023742676, -0.10412598, 0.046173096, -0.012901306, 0.024490356, 0.051574707, 0.009719849, -0.061584473, -0.008033752, -0.020050049, -0.04119873, -0.062438965, 0.0030555725, 0.011039734, 0.020126343, 0.0047454834, -0.06713867, -0.031555176, 0.037719727, 0.03201294, -0.004020691, -0.028167725, 0.026916504, -0.018981934, -0.004688263, 0.0016746521, 0.035461426, 0.0046844482, -0.009086609, -0.000030219555, -0.02798462, 0.0019073486, 0.015052795, 0.0057144165, 0.019073486, -0.043182373, 0.0054779053, 0.008674622, -0.0049858093, -0.017913818, 0.03262329, 0.029327393, 0.0008687973, -0.0095825195, 0.0060043335, 0.04034424, -0.02229309, -0.070617676, -0.011741638, 0.015335083, -0.0012636185, 0.066833496, -0.020690918, -0.076660156, -0.010887146, -0.04425049, -0.021438599, 0.021362305, 0.03048706, -0.0011768341, 0.017486572, -0.089416504, -0.021102905, -0.033203125, -0.017730713, -0.064331055, 0.03363037, -0.021743774, -0.042053223, 0.049682617, -0.027770996, -0.015670776, -0.011207581, 0.035888672, -0.0042686462, -0.0070152283, 0.022857666, 0.02748108, -0.002796173, -0.043823242, 0.024673462, 0.021026611, 0.03643799, -0.029388428, 0.030761719, -0.0033435822, 0.04135132, 0.012817383, 0.02456665, 0.0015192032, 0.007911682, 0.012245178, 0.0079422, -0.05822754, -0.024673462, -0.009346008, -0.05923462, 0.0020580292, -0.019989014, 0.003358841, -0.03668213, 0.003967285, 0.027114868, 0.028900146, -0.014976501, 0.0011777878, 0.009033203, -0.008300781, 0.021865845, -0.014007568, 0.049957275, 0.07104492, 0.035339355, -0.027526855, -0.025726318, 0.029785156, 0.017730713, -0.031234741, 0.047332764, -0.030853271, -0.01121521, -0.012893677, -0.026321411, 0.020751953, -0.023010254, -0.015686035, -0.018692017, 0.051361084, 0.015975952, 0.011985779, 0.05883789, 0.024276733, 0.030548096, -0.044067383, -0.0073242188, 0.009979248, 0.0017051697, -0.018554688, 0.051879883, -0.028564453, 0.017547607, -0.0104522705, -0.035949707, -0.0013475418, 0.040008545, 0.009941101, -0.03250122, -0.0099105835, -0.0007753372, 0.024337769, 0.044433594, 0.023468018, -0.020751953, -0.024871826, -0.0058403015, 0.008911133, 0.0052757263, 0.03161621, 0.00970459, 0.037231445, 0.035125732, 0.0049972534, 0.0067329407, -0.010635376, 0.008460999, 0.03427124, -0.0031318665, 0.026763916, -0.031036377, -0.02935791, -0.005252838, 0.011192322, -0.052459717, -0.009277344, 0.009231567, 0.0021686554, -0.002702713, 0.03314209, 0.0033626556, -0.0059127808, -0.028701782, -0.015281677, -0.0044288635, -0.020950317, -0.0236969, -0.039642334, 0.006160736, -0.015525818, 0.01247406, -0.041534424, 0.036865234, -0.024291992, -0.007858276, -0.030426025, 0.00091171265, 0.042541504, -0.038482666, -0.04751587, -0.028503418, -0.0026302338, 0.0043640137, 0.0037441254, -0.059539795, -0.030151367, -0.022720337, 0.007598877, -0.00806427, 0.029678345, 0.009605408, -0.045013428, -0.0541687, 0.08178711, 0.040100098, 0.11022949, 0.01309967, -0.019699097, -0.035980225, 0.024734497, 0.034362793, 0.014274597, -0.029312134, 0.059539795, -0.0007133484, 0.015281677, -0.01727295, 0.012023926, -0.02079773, -0.06384277, 0.027389526, 0.009590149, -0.04562378, 0.0096206665, -0.0184021, -0.034576416, 0.009506226, -0.004306793, -0.021957397, -0.0016736984, 0.016998291, -0.027664185, 0.035339355, -0.007865906, -0.026000977, 0.04071045, 0.007751465, 0.024414062, -0.0440979, -0.01612854, -0.001745224, 0.013839722, -0.006828308, -0.081848145, -0.06451416, -0.0029659271, 0.097229004, 0.00459671, 0.001540184, -0.007911682, 0.0033512115, 0.028839111, 0.012168884, 0.023666382, -0.05178833, 0.04321289, 0.028381348, 0.009346008, 0.0074310303, -0.0040893555, 0.004508972, 0.0010461807, -0.051940918, 0.021850586, -0.008880615, -0.019165039, 0.018325806, -0.019866943, 0.030731201, -0.010818481, 0.022979736, -0.04144287, 0.015701294, -0.0020008087, -0.007797241, 0.008712769, 0.012512207, -0.02722168, 0.03668213, -0.014595032, -0.000623703, 0.029022217, 0.015350342, 0.021530151, 0.042510986, 0.016601562, 0.0056877136, 0.0024757385, -0.013961792, -0.010772705, -0.018554688, 0.060333252, -0.0395813, -0.013710022, 0.0014820099, -0.034698486, 0.02609253, -0.01626587, 0.033569336, -0.011749268, 0.0066223145, 0.003107071, -0.029571533, 0.010749817, -0.00056791306, 0.021240234, -0.025497437, -0.020248413, -0.04586792, 0.0078086853, -0.011375427 ], "summary": [ 0.004634857, 0.008995056, -0.004081726, -0.0043678284, -0.016998291, -0.011993408, -0.00046300888, -0.02911377, 0.029312134, -0.0056266785, -0.0028705597, -0.012489319, -0.05633545, -0.037475586, -0.029876709, -0.022277832, -0.022384644, 0.0068244934, -0.027709961, -0.046539307, 0.025436401, -0.07067871, -0.028060913, 0.017974854, -0.005126953, 0.018539429, -0.04248047, 0.009407043, -0.013160706, 0.008361816, -0.0010948181, 0.00315094, -0.008872986, 0.024398804, 0.022750854, 0.012084961, -0.010803223, 0.025878906, 0.038482666, -0.015357971, -0.014526367, 0.020996094, 0.12219238, -0.045654297, 0.00072431564, 0.075683594, -0.07678223, -0.046173096, 0.028915405, 0.026260376, -0.0067596436, 0.037719727, -0.012001038, 0.024734497, -0.0057640076, 0.0126953125, -0.07183838, -0.001540184, 0.04135132, 0.033203125, 0.01600647, -0.05819702, 0.017486572, -0.025527954, -0.0184021, -0.008110046, 0.014640808, -0.005569458, 0.042755127, 0.020385742, 0.00819397, 0.0206604, 0.021408081, -0.07287598, -0.046722412, 0.07647705, 0.0028076172, 0.013198853, 0.016357422, -0.07824707, 0.06726074, 0.035369873, -0.022033691, 0.011878967, 0.0072517395, 0.0045776367, 0.010650635, -0.045074463, -0.018295288, -0.017807007, -0.011207581, -0.048828125, -0.038146973, 0.03479004, 0.03152466, -0.061035156, -0.018936157, -0.043914795, 0.0087509155, 0.022857666, 0.054992676, -0.06616211, 0.08514404, -0.026062012, -0.016815186, 0.043395996, 0.031219482, -0.024261475, -0.016921997, 0.0035953522, -0.009346008, 0.009689331, -0.0104522705, -0.05065918, -0.022445679, 0.07550049, 0.042877197, -0.0042648315, 0.009506226, 0.033813477, -0.00057029724, -0.015296936, 0.06713867, 0.070373535, 0.021621704, 0.056365967, -0.026947021, -0.056732178, -0.012435913, -0.0001335144, 0.004081726, 0.039916992, 0.0073432922, -0.014556885, -0.040740967, 0.0021514893, 0.007007599, -0.004924774, -0.019165039, 0.0030002594, 0.015686035, -0.02394104, 0.0051879883, -0.0040626526, -0.053741455, 0.045898438, 0.027633667, -0.0039978027, -0.039916992, -0.07141113, 0.002866745, -0.05319214, 0.030456543, -0.026367188, 0.01914978, -0.06304932, 0.018371582, -0.039001465, 0.009483337, -0.03475952, 0.07714844, 0.01386261, 0.006980896, 0.03201294, 0.019958496, -0.030181885, -0.046325684, -0.011459351, 0.021133423, 0.03793335, 0.0020141602, -0.004886627, 0.0154418945, 0.024032593, 0.002462387, 0.005847931, 0.009315491, 0.018341064, 0.030014038, -0.0093688965, -0.022476196, -0.03225708, 0.05895996, -0.0034065247, -0.007659912, -0.03414917, -0.021713257, 0.027435303, 0.057006836, 0.018295288, -0.06085205, -0.0440979, -0.0025291443, -0.010604858, 0.011146545, 0.0289917, -0.029220581, 0.037628174, -0.0131073, -0.032806396, 0.029693604, -0.025878906, 0.030456543, -0.02406311, -0.0637207, -0.003206253, -0.020370483, 0.021728516, -0.048583984, 0.01108551, 0.05709839, -0.0018634796, -0.056762695, 0.07116699, 0.010917664, -0.03390503, 0.011528015, -0.007881165, -0.00806427, 0.0034275055, -0.02319336, 0.017425537, -0.040252686, -0.016555786, 0.0011072159, 0.014274597, -0.0024223328, 0.00075674057, 0.014274597, 0.041046143, 0.0128479, -0.03314209, -0.009529114, -0.02166748, -0.030578613, 0.005844116, 0.035095215, -0.003288269, -0.0057640076, 0.017990112, 0.009460449, 0.012908936, -0.00000834465, 0.05682373, 0.05517578, 0.043518066, 0.024871826, 0.010299683, 0.012084961, 0.058441162, -0.024932861, 0.020141602, 0.028579712, -0.009986877, -0.0103302, 0.057617188, -0.01461792, -0.06561279, 0.055847168, -0.022613525, 0.024780273, 0.024871826, -0.016571045, 0.032073975, -0.026733398, 0.021133423, -0.014831543, 0.002456665, -0.039764404, 0.010894775, 0.029022217, -0.00010752678, 0.004589081, -0.019363403, -0.033294678, 0.040924072, -0.052520752, 0.030776978, 0.04156494, -0.0031108856, -0.0030212402, -0.009056091, 0.022583008, -0.0069618225, 0.031921387, 0.01637268, 0.029144287, -0.007858276, -0.078552246, -0.0003991127, 0.03540039, 0.003993988, -0.018829346, -0.033111572, -0.0035972595, 0.0090789795, -0.0037555695, -0.011154175, 0.04333496, -0.02947998, -0.0054969788, 0.056915283, -0.029037476, 0.0463562, -0.022354126, 0.046020508, -0.035308838, 0.01637268, 0.008613586, -0.057556152, 0.040039062, 0.0513916, 0.026779175, 0.04800415, -0.028366089, -0.041381836, -0.03793335, 0.031585693, -0.07171631, -0.03366089, 0.043762207, -0.004047394, 0.007965088, 0.0023422241, -0.007522583, -0.03326416, 0.0096588135, -0.018112183, 0.000054001808, 0.00035429, -0.0027160645, -0.016113281, -0.036010742, -0.039978027, 0.0040283203, -0.0104522705, 0.004737854, -0.00049448013, -0.013160706, -0.002855301, 0.0057640076, 0.022781372, -0.006538391, -0.037078857, -0.060821533, 0.008010864, 0.031921387, -0.005592346, -0.017791748, -0.02229309, 0.043945312, -0.02709961, -0.03933716, 0.020721436, -0.02243042, 0.06976318, 0.07110596, 0.002910614, -0.00074005127, -0.036956787, 0.03390503, 0.01348114, 0.010696411, -0.02659607, -0.054718018, -0.02217102, -0.0102005005, 0.012550354, -0.0039367676, 0.025939941, 0.01939392, 0.021469116, -0.054901123, -0.02633667, -0.050476074, -0.016677856, 0.03289795, -0.02772522, 0.03265381, 0.028289795, 0.015068054, 0.040008545, -0.024902344, 0.038635254, 0.07836914, -0.0022830963, 0.025299072, 0.013877869, 0.071777344, -0.0025806427, 0.010635376, -0.023925781, 0.056030273, -0.029663086, 0.009902954, -0.0018253326, -0.040924072, 0.020690918, -0.013053894, -0.00027513504, -0.07312012, 0.039154053, 0.036193848, -0.029190063, -0.031341553, -0.048553467, -0.06524658, -0.026565552, 0.019927979, 0.084228516, 0.00048804283, -0.03451538, -0.008056641, -0.0067634583, -0.023620605, 0.023254395, -0.017868042, 0.0018510818, 0.014060974, 0.016845703, -0.011077881, 0.04119873, -0.028778076, 0.016174316, -0.007522583, 0.0647583, -0.005870819, 0.0070381165, 0.0031604767, 0.012939453, 0.020904541, -0.0126571655, -0.03933716, -0.042419434, -0.023071289, 0.03982544, 0.0074920654, 0.059295654, -0.0025558472, -0.003850937, 0.0029888153, -0.017593384, -0.030578613, -0.017868042, -0.017974854, -0.023727417, 0.01890564, 0.0011482239, -0.08465576, -0.007221222, 0.0023937225, 0.046844482, -0.002105713, 0.026504517, 0.013900757, -0.007965088, -0.030822754, 0.031707764, 0.039215088, -0.018447876, 0.020889282, -0.014312744, -0.04421997, 0.01852417, 0.024169922, -0.026306152, 0.014884949, -0.011489868, -0.03427124, 0.026428223, 0.015174866, -0.0023460388, 0.002708435, 0.0052108765, 0.010269165, -0.031158447, -0.0012750626, 0.05795288, -0.056915283, -0.029891968, -0.02822876, 0.022994995, -0.01789856, -0.06561279, -0.037841797, 0.012626648, -0.07159424, -0.05984497, -0.00044727325, -0.011192322, -0.06768799, -0.017211914, 0.0158844, -0.02960205, -0.002149582, 0.044006348, -0.015823364, 0.02633667, 0.00907135, -0.041137695, -0.016159058, 0.01360321, 0.009307861, -0.003818512, -0.0071258545, 0.0037460327, 0.02999878, 0.032928467, 0.024276733, -0.018005371, 0.034057617, 0.011924744, -0.01914978, -0.008590698, -0.012313843, 0.06311035, -0.035583496, -0.016113281, 0.0033245087, -0.006210327, 0.021270752, 0.042175293, 0.013557434, -0.001627922, 0.0027675629, 0.015136719, -0.034057617, 0.044006348, -0.025650024, -0.05126953, 0.027038574, 0.022277832, -0.029190063, 0.016159058, 0.022491455, 0.040924072, -0.030227661, -0.026748657, 0.0022201538, 0.009033203, -0.0049819946, 0.0011224747, -0.026931763, 0.030838013, -0.020965576, 0.0045166016, -0.016616821, 0.022781372, -0.029327393, -0.018325806, 0.009750366, 0.020004272, -0.07080078, -0.03970337, -0.025772095, -0.024093628, -0.03591919, 0.02180481, -0.0019702911, -0.01991272, 0.044036865, -0.027236938, -0.015052795, -0.009025574, 0.036071777, -0.012123108, -0.0022583008, -0.08532715, 0.062561035, -0.044891357, -0.028961182, -0.048614502, -0.013549805, 0.014595032, -0.0022468567, 0.024795532, -0.021209717, -0.0025577545, -0.011703491, 0.009689331, 0.033935547, 0.024032593, -0.036499023, -0.037902832, -0.009346008, -0.04348755, 0.013336182, -0.017242432, -0.014038086, -0.031219482, 0.024780273, -0.024749756, -0.011146545, -0.06097412, 0.024108887, -0.0012760162, 0.030181885, 0.011619568, 0.008781433, 0.019500732, 0.036132812, 0.007881165, 0.011306763, -0.008712769, -0.033294678, -0.020065308, 0.002407074, 0.019638062, 0.028961182, 0.058685303, -0.01739502, -0.013114929, -0.012756348, 0.02218628, 0.013557434, -0.016662598, -0.016021729, 0.035888672, 0.0025844574, -0.026931763, -0.006614685, -0.014877319, 0.00039100647, -0.03060913, -0.032043457, 0.009109497, 0.03692627, -0.0069236755, -0.03781128, -0.017456055, -0.022384644, -0.01638794, -0.0592041, -0.04272461, -0.031188965, 0.025253296, -0.018508911, -0.015792847, 0.014427185, -0.015007019, 0.0025100708, 0.0072669983, -0.005168915, 0.015838623, -0.02279663, -0.011947632, 0.008514404, -0.016082764, 0.0077934265, 0.007091522, -0.009033203, -0.01727295, -0.022903442, -0.061798096, 0.030731201, -0.059753418, -0.0018129349, -0.038391113, 0.0023498535, -0.057006836, -0.021850586, 0.021957397, -0.05722046, 0.01979065, -0.016693115, 0.03640747, -0.006111145, 0.007709503, -0.015838623, -0.0026607513, -0.024932861, 0.02659607, 0.0002746582, -0.022583008, -0.012542725, 0.072631836, 0.01737976, 0.036712646, 0.04336548, -0.011039734, -0.0014848709, -0.015960693, 0.0015392303, 0.02659607, -0.018981934, 0.046173096, 0.0006132126, -0.024978638, -0.025314331, -0.03677368, -0.022399902, -0.0035972595, -0.03189087, -0.00806427, 0.03845215, -0.023208618, -0.0637207, -0.020095825, -0.017196655, 0.02458191, -0.0043182373, -0.013748169, 0.014183044, -0.047424316, -0.01928711, 0.02822876, -0.08605957, 0.054351807, -0.028167725, 0.03024292, 0.020889282, -0.005771637, -0.05834961, -0.015701294, -0.020614624, -0.013336182, -0.028564453, -0.020629883, -0.009483337, 0.032836914, 0.012283325, -0.045959473, 0.0046920776, 0.03439331, 0.034332275, -0.014221191, -0.013465881, 0.032714844, -0.020080566, -0.003932953, -0.0030612946, -0.009994507, -0.01828003, -0.0049438477, 0.021102905, -0.023010254, -0.010803223, 0.0340271, 0.050689697, -0.033447266, -0.012290955, -0.015281677, 0.0546875, 0.033721924, 0.015357971, 0.015327454, 0.013793945, -0.020477295, 0.020217896, 0.023147583, 0.041229248, -0.028579712, -0.06518555, -0.008300781, 0.021942139, 0.015686035, 0.026321411, -0.03062439, -0.07556152, 0.014976501, -0.028869629, 0.009437561, 0.01689148, 0.017028809, 0.0126571655, 0.028625488, -0.06365967, -0.029724121, -0.018661499, -0.042510986, -0.048217773, 0.021728516, -0.02204895, -0.04852295, 0.08477783, -0.026565552, -0.040130615, 0.009674072, 0.010848999, 0.024002075, 0.0009036064, 0.033081055, 0.02607727, -0.0119018555, -0.06665039, 0.06677246, 0.015853882, 0.080444336, -0.055603027, -0.014846802, 0.016418457, 0.05255127, 0.03262329, -0.016860962, -0.01058197, -0.004924774, 0.033935547, 0.0022296906, -0.03164673, -0.0023937225, 0.00248909, -0.03164673, -0.0047950745, -0.011390686, -0.017791748, 0.02796936, -0.0071754456, 0.029525757, -0.0016078949, 0.0047073364, 0.0047073364, 0.005332947, 0.015655518, -0.010650635, -0.024642944, 0.007896423, 0.040222168, 0.033966064, 0.0039253235, -0.06921387, -0.014427185, 0.018508911, -0.027069092, 0.03375244, -0.0057792664, 0.0077667236, 0.01890564, -0.04055786, -0.0035533905, -0.05291748, 0.018127441, -0.036346436, 0.039367676, 0.0077285767, 0.031280518, 0.02909851, -0.015167236, 0.091796875, -0.06506348, -0.018096924, 0.034576416, 0.055267334, -0.04550171, 0.012680054, 0.016204834, -0.02418518, 0.009300232, -0.014038086, -0.0103302, 0.017868042, 0.04949951, -0.026473999, -0.002937317, 0.046325684, 0.014694214, -0.019866943, 0.017227173, -0.029678345, -0.036376953, -0.024093628, -0.014442444, 0.0105896, 0.031707764, 0.011169434, 0.022781372, 0.047729492, 0.015342712, -0.009056091, 0.0059432983, 0.016647339, 0.039611816, 0.017807007, 0.028884888, -0.032165527, -0.024307251, 0.02017212, 0.00033330917, -0.040618896, -0.0016355515, 0.023788452, 0.0024547577, -0.013977051, 0.014060974, -0.035095215, -0.0048561096, 0.0047912598, -0.005508423, -0.006526947, -0.022857666, 0.0087509155, -0.03390503, 0.002521515, 0.004096985, 0.010887146, 0.03552246, 0.08239746, -0.033294678, -0.0025730133, -0.020019531, 0.007282257, -0.0027160645, -0.009773254, -0.059906006, -0.03050232, 0.042663574, -0.027755737, -0.015167236, -0.06829834, -0.016921997, -0.02368164, 0.031021118, -0.020843506, 0.048553467, 0.026687622, -0.047210693, 0.0013084412, 0.064697266, 0.054595947, 0.12097168, 0.054351807, -0.01902771, 0.009590149, 0.031982422, 0.00071048737, 0.010948181, -0.024734497, 0.08520508, 0.006210327, 0.02557373, -0.004425049, 0.022537231, -0.02331543, -0.06365967, 0.001821518, 0.014015198, -0.050689697, 0.059143066, -0.012626648, -0.021118164, 0.021011353, 0.01159668, -0.023956299, 0.030960083, -0.003200531, -0.005168915, 0.013336182, 0.01524353, -0.011207581, 0.031463623, 0.026504517, 0.030639648, -0.03717041, -0.032043457, 0.0078048706, -0.014259338, -0.007873535, -0.055358887, -0.03765869, 0.0039901733, 0.0803833, 0.0034675598, -0.01902771, -0.01612854, -0.0026187897, 0.05618286, 0.013343811, 0.017868042, -0.036621094, 0.009994507, 0.007637024, 0.020950317, 0.00308609, -0.004333496, -0.012207031, -0.002002716, -0.043060303, -0.008796692, -0.0070610046, -0.028411865, -0.017730713, -0.005558014, 0.008468628, 0.0039367676, 0.0029907227, -0.015808105, -0.00067281723, -0.009963989, -0.019424438, 0.0072784424, -0.0025463104, -0.03338623, 0.05142212, -0.036468506, 0.014785767, -0.006000519, 0.00035524368, 0.006439209, 0.022338867, 0.0154800415, 0.028335571, 0.031402588, -0.012619019, -0.032043457, -0.010696411, 0.070373535, -0.062805176, -0.056610107, 0.0053901672, -0.03515625, -0.011222839, -0.016784668, -0.00010544062, -0.003118515, 0.022323608, 0.035949707, -0.012466431, 0.023895264, 0.0004892349, 0.021713257, -0.02407837, 0.014190674, -0.05026245, 0.0046157837, 0.020507812 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06807v1
On the Robustness of Question Rewriting Systems to Questions of Varying Hardness
Hai Ye, Hwee Tou Ng, Wenjuan Han
cs.CL
In conversational question answering (CQA), the task of question rewriting~(QR) in context aims to rewrite a context-dependent question into an equivalent self-contained question that gives the same answer. In this paper, we are interested in the robustness of a QR system to questions varying in rewriting hardness or difficulty. Since there is a lack of questions classified based on their rewriting hardness, we first propose a heuristic method to automatically classify questions into subsets of varying hardness, by measuring the discrepancy between a question and its rewrite. To find out what makes questions hard or easy for rewriting, we then conduct a human evaluation to annotate the rewriting hardness of questions. Finally, to enhance the robustness of QR systems to questions of varying hardness, we propose a novel learning framework for QR that first trains a QR model independently on each subset of questions of a certain level of hardness, then combines these QR models as one joint model for inference. Experimental results on two datasets show that our framework improves the overall performance compared to the baselines.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06807v1
2023-11-12T11:09:30
2023-11-12T11:09:30
{ "title": [ -0.005844116, -0.00970459, -0.008102417, -0.08685303, -0.0021018982, 0.023605347, -0.05996704, -0.010818481, 0.016571045, 0.014053345, -0.02029419, 0.014213562, -0.042785645, 0.0004427433, -0.062927246, -0.007881165, 0.00011372566, -0.009140015, -0.05758667, -0.05682373, -0.0021133423, -0.066711426, 0.019683838, 0.06964111, 0.046051025, -0.039642334, -0.043914795, 0.014770508, -0.005718231, -0.023880005, -0.007221222, -0.011383057, 0.057495117, 0.03048706, -0.019561768, 0.029876709, -0.008895874, 0.012168884, -0.00774765, 0.038024902, 0.024276733, -0.03591919, -0.03967285, -0.03274536, -0.034332275, 0.021438599, -0.030761719, -0.006477356, -0.00059604645, 0.049926758, 0.0007252693, 0.056121826, -0.03074646, 0.022506714, 0.02128601, -0.013687134, 0.017730713, -0.06488037, 0.020721436, 0.046203613, 0.024658203, -0.042633057, 0.026275635, -0.014587402, -0.0037956238, -0.015541077, 0.020401001, 0.027755737, 0.06970215, 0.009010315, -0.036956787, 0.02178955, 0.023864746, -0.0039787292, -0.020339966, -0.014297485, 0.03704834, 0.008644104, 0.03186035, -0.01864624, 0.007820129, -0.029891968, -0.0020561218, -0.02281189, 0.028381348, -0.0010871887, -0.014419556, -0.019744873, -0.012924194, -0.05871582, -0.0053977966, -0.010421753, -0.019851685, -0.009292603, -0.0181427, -0.028793335, -0.004348755, -0.011917114, 0.0070114136, -0.03842163, 0.036193848, -0.022994995, -0.012290955, 0.010940552, -0.0023612976, 0.013839722, -0.013870239, 0.0072631836, 0.014778137, 0.051361084, -0.003047943, 0.046051025, -0.017410278, -0.0236969, 0.006580353, 0.025985718, -0.015304565, 0.0063705444, 0.016433716, 0.028244019, -0.027145386, -0.040985107, 0.0357666, -0.024215698, 0.029785156, -0.004512787, -0.051696777, 0.012161255, -0.012283325, 0.020233154, 0.006965637, 0.035827637, -0.076171875, -0.061157227, -0.041870117, 0.038635254, -0.0042800903, -0.023254395, -0.009254456, 0.016601562, -0.001455307, -0.049468994, 0.0040512085, -0.0012626648, -0.014503479, 0.042663574, 0.07080078, -0.02180481, -0.07556152, -0.0690918, -0.017532349, -0.024429321, 0.018814087, -0.0146102905, -0.06707764, -0.024597168, -0.12524414, 0.009887695, 0.018127441, -0.00084114075, 0.014221191, 0.013336182, 0.031585693, 0.013916016, 0.044525146, -0.031433105, -0.06781006, 0.013000488, 0.011047363, 0.052642822, -0.0050086975, 0.023330688, -0.025009155, 0.009117126, -0.0010900497, 0.0018367767, 0.02293396, -0.023406982, 0.016860962, 0.028686523, 0.023895264, -0.010398865, -0.031585693, 0.055847168, -0.050109863, -0.019699097, -0.01802063, 0.0035514832, 0.053833008, 0.0009741783, -0.0418396, 0.0011262894, -0.0054893494, -0.028015137, -0.03491211, -0.03225708, 0.019943237, 0.022583008, -0.019042969, 0.023345947, -0.05105591, 0.0058403015, -0.015960693, 0.008872986, 0.019485474, -0.016693115, -0.0029029846, 0.017532349, -0.022781372, 0.06506348, 0.079956055, 0.040039062, -0.081604004, 0.07763672, 0.013069153, -0.035705566, 0.050842285, 0.007621765, 0.011260986, -0.033050537, 0.0044021606, -0.010345459, 0.024246216, 0.058502197, 0.002243042, -0.00015580654, -0.0019369125, -0.029510498, 0.02204895, 0.009147644, 0.05517578, -0.012069702, 0.047332764, 0.032440186, 0.0118637085, -0.012550354, -0.0037078857, -0.052978516, -0.012107849, 0.017547607, 0.0016374588, -0.028533936, -0.018539429, 0.02003479, 0.0033931732, -0.029525757, 0.00076007843, 0.015838623, 0.0048294067, 0.0012359619, 0.039245605, 0.007835388, 0.04626465, 0.035308838, 0.0016498566, 0.051086426, 0.039001465, 0.05731201, -0.0017337799, 0.025009155, -0.040618896, 0.0029411316, 0.005077362, 0.012145996, -0.01802063, -0.0054397583, -0.014808655, 0.005344391, 0.023376465, 0.005092621, -0.0012683868, -0.064086914, 0.005393982, -0.009468079, 0.023544312, -0.011291504, -0.026992798, 0.01651001, 0.029586792, -0.048431396, -0.013145447, 0.002166748, 0.07305908, 0.0109939575, -0.010124207, -0.00047135353, 0.055511475, 0.015792847, 0.030426025, 0.015060425, 0.04925537, 0.02684021, 0.0022468567, 0.02809143, 0.023544312, -0.028213501, 0.03555298, 0.046966553, -0.018051147, 0.026168823, -0.03866577, 0.026565552, 0.016220093, -0.015167236, 0.01134491, 0.02722168, 0.0064811707, 0.03414917, -0.0070495605, 0.009902954, -0.05935669, -0.0040359497, -0.005393982, -0.016448975, -0.029418945, -0.040863037, 0.012702942, -0.023834229, -0.021499634, -0.01776123, 0.048980713, -0.010749817, -0.020553589, -0.0019798279, 0.007888794, -0.018249512, 0.004043579, -0.020996094, -0.015159607, 0.020812988, -0.0019779205, -0.017852783, -0.06726074, -0.043273926, -0.014373779, 0.012260437, -0.0043144226, 0.026916504, -0.02420044, -0.034942627, 0.0023231506, -0.067871094, -0.009346008, -0.0020866394, -0.008712769, -0.02986145, 0.022277832, 0.0109939575, -0.032684326, 0.0146865845, 0.014839172, -0.04034424, -0.005554199, 0.023971558, 0.05429077, -0.018997192, -0.028671265, 0.0435791, 0.019515991, -0.018875122, 0.02734375, 0.017471313, 0.009231567, -0.05508423, -0.028762817, -0.05419922, -0.028808594, 0.003929138, 0.018539429, 0.040863037, -0.0289917, -0.02809143, -0.053375244, -0.004173279, 0.035369873, -0.007461548, -0.03527832, -0.044891357, -0.0045928955, -0.038146973, -0.023864746, -0.0057296753, -0.019302368, 0.0045166016, 0.056427002, 0.027740479, -0.0046424866, 0.0012798309, 0.011383057, -0.0085372925, -0.023986816, -0.01071167, -0.0067367554, -0.021820068, 0.0058135986, 0.01663208, -0.020874023, -0.055908203, 0.006164551, -0.011581421, 0.0440979, -0.03390503, -0.015457153, -0.009437561, -0.065979004, 0.032409668, -0.015304565, -0.010437012, 0.04257202, -0.021820068, 0.008125305, 0.028259277, -0.0033054352, -0.022277832, -0.0050811768, -0.042297363, -0.12512207, 0.016784668, 0.009025574, -0.025558472, -0.027740479, -0.06762695, -0.051818848, 0.01322937, -0.023254395, 0.03881836, 0.00724411, 0.0231781, 0.011772156, -0.061401367, -0.03463745, -0.029006958, -0.0041007996, 0.022766113, -0.0062065125, -0.0056533813, -0.009460449, -0.010032654, 0.044189453, -0.025939941, -0.022583008, -0.0074005127, -0.03253174, 0.00497818, -0.025726318, -0.011978149, 0.004901886, -0.008010864, -0.02835083, -0.008224487, -0.036224365, 0.014587402, -0.027618408, 0.0026988983, 0.003616333, 0.022842407, 0.021636963, 0.008430481, -0.015388489, -0.01096344, -0.00070905685, -0.014953613, -0.033843994, -0.008857727, 0.047424316, -0.015060425, -0.013664246, -0.019058228, -0.025680542, 0.00932312, -0.0284729, 0.01374054, 0.017059326, -0.0006737709, 0.011016846, 0.020126343, -0.027923584, 0.010131836, -0.052978516, 0.009056091, 0.030578613, -0.0011253357, 0.0073623657, -0.066467285, -0.010734558, 0.01449585, -0.13659668, -0.022918701, -0.0028057098, -0.0034770966, 0.007686615, -0.018417358, 0.03552246, -0.031036377, -0.03277588, -0.009712219, -0.01210022, -0.007217407, -0.019485474, -0.060638428, -0.0385437, 0.06335449, -0.029403687, 0.0077705383, 0.05505371, -0.014923096, -0.03048706, -0.011398315, 0.022766113, 0.0149383545, 0.008430481, 0.016952515, -0.027359009, 0.007457733, -0.020004272, 0.037139893, -0.023025513, -0.0010204315, -0.00982666, 0.013008118, 0.00090551376, 0.038970947, -0.052459717, 0.05996704, 0.048950195, -0.013366699, -0.10076904, 0.042877197, -0.006374359, -0.040222168, 0.022384644, -0.017990112, -0.0012216568, 0.031433105, -0.004432678, 0.062286377, -0.002084732, -0.010124207, 0.035583496, -0.009971619, -0.0030937195, 0.013305664, 0.028625488, 0.020889282, -0.006298065, 0.03237915, -0.055480957, 0.016494751, 0.0037841797, 0.0069732666, -0.037078857, -0.01940918, -0.021377563, 0.017044067, -0.03817749, -0.03753662, -0.042633057, 0.005710602, -0.018188477, 0.07720947, 0.04751587, 0.004611969, -0.046875, -0.0046157837, 0.061035156, -0.02885437, 0.05441284, -0.021270752, 0.008766174, -0.0046958923, -0.05053711, -0.040222168, -0.009719849, 0.022033691, 0.018997192, 0.009780884, 0.014633179, 0.02684021, 0.025924683, -0.02029419, 0.023391724, -0.025878906, 0.0059547424, 0.054992676, -0.017532349, -0.043518066, 0.037475586, -0.0046806335, 0.003030777, -0.02519226, 0.026870728, -0.017852783, -0.039733887, -0.07922363, 0.068725586, -0.00076436996, 0.08892822, 0.025741577, 0.0012340546, 0.04776001, 0.004432678, 0.017471313, 0.010368347, -0.03857422, -0.016113281, -0.0037231445, 0.045654297, -0.008071899, 0.008651733, 0.039855957, 0.00983429, 0.028762817, -0.03567505, 0.0010433197, -0.018829346, 0.0052337646, 0.0071105957, 0.01737976, -0.048919678, -0.039154053, -0.013404846, 0.0041236877, 0.03579712, -0.025817871, 0.045318604, -0.01876831, 0.028198242, 0.009147644, -0.030838013, 0.011398315, -0.04937744, 0.015701294, -0.04196167, -0.041870117, 0.032714844, 0.04333496, -0.01928711, 0.034454346, -0.002527237, 0.0049209595, 0.029373169, 0.060150146, 0.06768799, -0.034454346, -0.0025959015, -0.004600525, 0.0042152405, -0.005027771, -0.06402588, -0.006252289, 0.0076904297, 0.030960083, -0.025939941, 0.07824707, -0.07788086, 0.018371582, -0.033477783, -0.033325195, 0.020202637, -0.076049805, 0.0096206665, 0.048339844, -0.002483368, 0.04257202, -0.029586792, 0.041137695, 0.008308411, 0.058807373, -0.005531311, 0.014091492, 0.06414795, -0.058654785, 0.007259369, 0.000063061714, 0.052581787, 0.0059394836, 0.032287598, 0.024719238, 0.020874023, -0.06317139, 0.00032496452, -0.020767212, 0.030776978, 0.023803711, -0.0569458, 0.007610321, -0.009132385, -0.0015449524, 0.03640747, -0.042144775, 0.0016489029, -0.013076782, -0.017700195, -0.06347656, 0.013618469, -0.007106781, -0.056915283, -0.0058021545, 0.0006942749, -0.0018901825, 0.005126953, 0.02545166, -0.007648468, -0.04537964, 0.016036987, 0.05783081, 0.010528564, -0.0007944107, 0.000007867813, 0.0020122528, 0.05718994, 0.018920898, -0.044036865, -0.012283325, -0.012748718, -0.031204224, 0.026412964, 0.015426636, 0.016616821, 0.009231567, -0.016555786, -0.022705078, 0.037963867, -0.035980225, 0.021728516, 0.028457642, 0.01574707, 0.026733398, 0.0043945312, 0.009414673, -0.023162842, 0.011329651, 0.0039787292, -0.004825592, 0.004501343, -0.013710022, 0.0009975433, 0.0044555664, 0.011924744, -0.02909851, -0.02911377, -0.009353638, 0.026412964, -0.005584717, -0.0013046265, 0.019226074, 0.03665161, 0.035003662, -0.024276733, 0.010688782, 0.0345459, -0.031921387, -0.026794434, -0.02784729, 0.0063667297, -0.031433105, 0.076293945, -0.0044937134, -0.033172607, -0.03314209, -0.056152344, -0.02458191, 0.022964478, 0.012420654, 0.035003662, 0.0385437, -0.0018796921, 0.05343628, -0.0035972595, -0.006980896, -0.034210205, -0.0017385483, 0.0033988953, -0.013687134, 0.03277588, 0.020019531, 0.012687683, -0.045806885, -0.0008659363, 0.044067383, 0.03765869, -0.009544373, -0.051361084, -0.013153076, -0.010368347, -0.04800415, 0.035980225, -0.008842468, -0.016830444, 0.025421143, -0.00995636, 0.040985107, 0.03768921, 0.06304932, 0.04663086, 0.023406982, 0.03277588, 0.019882202, 0.019195557, -0.028030396, 0.019683838, -0.045410156, 0.012191772, -0.05432129, 0.005962372, -0.09967041, 0.029464722, 0.005306244, 0.04663086, -0.016860962, 0.025802612, 0.008415222, -0.008216858, 0.03326416, -0.010940552, 0.075683594, 0.009399414, -0.003320694, 0.0042152405, -0.015220642, 0.033355713, 0.038726807, 0.012161255, -0.0140686035, -0.02520752, -0.0501709, 0.014183044, 0.021133423, 0.011123657, -0.05328369, -0.040130615, -0.07116699, 0.0022411346, -0.013000488, 0.03186035, 0.04083252, -0.017684937, 0.042785645, -0.01789856, -0.012023926, -0.04486084, -0.030929565, -0.020339966, 0.0014429092, -0.049224854, -0.005268097, -0.039855957, 0.009773254, -0.007827759, 0.045196533, 0.026046753, -0.035247803, -0.021057129, 0.001282692, 0.025985718, 0.015602112, 0.002571106, -0.03479004, 0.0012931824, 0.030578613, 0.024246216, 0.008300781, 0.003824234, -0.009025574, 0.046905518, -0.023223877, -0.0019760132, 0.0154418945, -0.009254456, -0.008712769, 0.012580872, -0.020248413, 0.054260254, -0.011993408, -0.03173828, 0.003211975, 0.019851685, -0.08215332, -0.0020942688, -0.012062073, 0.009559631, 0.028289795, 0.059295654, 0.023788452, -0.010879517, -0.017333984, -0.052947998, 0.019836426, 0.06518555, -0.007347107, 0.057922363, -0.056915283, -0.06121826, 0.064208984, -0.031555176, 0.10443115, -0.033569336, 0.0057754517, -0.037139893, 0.021499634, 0.0073051453, -0.037628174, 0.018447876, -0.03967285, -0.010803223, -0.0072021484, -0.001745224, -0.07598877, -0.010147095, -0.026168823, -0.013313293, 0.0079422, 0.0052490234, -0.008712769, -0.03387451, -0.038604736, 0.011459351, -0.0033740997, 0.058410645, -0.021408081, -0.013145447, 0.005962372, 0.0090408325, -0.017700195, -0.055511475, -0.029190063, -0.028137207, -0.0019989014, -0.0022735596, -0.0037498474, 0.01285553, -0.01777649, -0.03253174, -0.023880005, 0.029678345, -0.036010742, 0.04058838, -0.02947998, -0.04095459, -0.021377563, 0.008399963, -0.003162384, 0.0071487427, -0.0039024353, -0.0033245087, 0.017211914, 0.021087646, -0.031829834, -0.041809082, 0.0054779053, 0.018341064, 0.019882202, -0.039642334, 0.021987915, 0.05215454, 0.053741455, -0.0209198, -0.0023269653, 0.03010559, -0.0340271, -0.02217102, 0.077819824, 0.0058059692, 0.005012512, 0.043060303, 0.037719727, -0.0016260147, -0.027893066, -0.008087158, -0.014465332, 0.010353088, 0.04928589, -0.0008239746, 0.016448975, 0.031982422, -0.02848816, -0.017807007, -0.007484436, -0.022521973, -0.024246216, 0.002418518, 0.0074882507, -0.011154175, 0.019744873, -0.06695557, 0.0013532639, 0.011856079, -0.0005364418, -0.0030784607, 0.026168823, -0.017944336, 0.051086426, -0.027374268, -0.018096924, 0.035186768, 0.025360107, 0.018920898, 0.008079529, -0.01689148, 0.0044403076, 0.0056495667, 0.0022735596, -0.01838684, -0.022781372, 0.03829956, -0.0015850067, -0.0030269623, -0.0063819885, -0.03967285, 0.036315918, -0.0022830963, 0.016296387, -0.01676941, 0.004501343, 0.0059394836, -0.022125244, 0.0040512085, 0.033203125, 0.023635864, -0.0105896, -0.020828247, 0.022064209, 0.04244995, -0.0075263977 ], "summary": [ 0.018951416, -0.0068740845, -0.027191162, -0.0023326874, -0.033325195, -0.024963379, -0.042755127, -0.034942627, 0.014266968, 0.027862549, -0.013847351, 0.024093628, -0.024520874, -0.011161804, -0.032196045, -0.0146484375, -0.00035881996, -0.0030174255, -0.044525146, -0.04360962, 0.018234253, -0.050628662, -0.048980713, 0.054504395, 0.0028705597, -0.042938232, 0.020263672, 0.020065308, 0.018707275, 0.022460938, 0.012634277, -0.037597656, 0.0056877136, 0.045043945, -0.022827148, -0.005130768, 0.00067710876, 0.0068244934, 0.0053710938, 0.04095459, 0.041656494, -0.036010742, 0.021408081, -0.03970337, -0.016220093, 0.048187256, 0.008331299, -0.013031006, 0.059631348, 0.043273926, -0.024658203, 0.03982544, -0.04446411, -0.0034446716, -0.008239746, -0.006500244, 0.015213013, -0.05645752, -0.0049209595, 0.04031372, 0.015457153, -0.007041931, 0.014915466, -0.039398193, -0.0007481575, -0.0024547577, 0.032470703, -0.0009841919, 0.033111572, -0.0423584, -0.023284912, 0.026855469, 0.02684021, -0.07110596, -0.01146698, 0.035339355, 0.010307312, 0.0121154785, 0.015853882, -0.042999268, 0.018753052, 0.009262085, 0.037078857, -0.039520264, 0.03414917, -0.0033836365, -0.007019043, -0.031829834, -0.012542725, -0.029281616, -0.0059928894, -0.039367676, -0.06112671, 0.053985596, 0.039733887, -0.050231934, 0.009880066, -0.05291748, 0.022247314, -0.02758789, 0.074035645, -0.053649902, 0.045288086, -0.00080394745, -0.0073623657, 0.020614624, 0.004776001, 0.009399414, 0.02017212, 0.027542114, 0.002216339, 0.032409668, -0.03564453, -0.04925537, 0.0020809174, 0.052368164, -0.024795532, 0.021911621, 0.010810852, 0.017944336, -0.038269043, -0.010055542, 0.04321289, 0.022415161, 0.020233154, 0.036346436, -0.011054993, -0.017471313, -0.0033798218, 0.007843018, -0.016189575, 0.026062012, 0.018112183, 0.010421753, -0.008277893, 0.0038814545, 0.031677246, -0.0054512024, -0.007987976, 0.019378662, 0.034454346, -0.047210693, -0.04537964, 0.030517578, -0.022018433, 0.064941406, 0.040985107, -0.03366089, -0.06237793, -0.041290283, -0.016143799, -0.02734375, 0.038604736, -0.03149414, -0.039916992, -0.077697754, -0.034088135, -0.024917603, 0.02633667, -0.046020508, 0.04446411, 0.009017944, 0.0289917, 0.01663208, 0.006340027, -0.04260254, -0.06359863, -0.010787964, 0.0066223145, 0.04269409, 0.018157959, 0.007068634, -0.030273438, -0.0056495667, -0.0046081543, -0.010848999, -0.013015747, -0.029968262, 0.0009608269, 0.038726807, 0.007331848, -0.028656006, -0.045776367, 0.022872925, -0.014152527, -0.014404297, -0.005958557, 0.029129028, 0.05670166, 0.006439209, -0.04421997, -0.03918457, 0.016586304, -0.0181427, -0.027114868, -0.0056037903, -0.021392822, 0.017730713, -0.03768921, 0.03503418, 0.03866577, 0.019348145, -0.018722534, -0.021697998, -0.105163574, 0.004508972, -0.028671265, 0.034179688, -0.009002686, 0.041625977, 0.059448242, 0.04135132, -0.08093262, 0.03640747, -0.0011634827, -0.030456543, 0.04220581, -0.04498291, 0.006679535, -0.061950684, 0.028656006, 0.02558899, -0.011360168, 0.07525635, -0.026885986, -0.01499176, -0.014045715, 0.009864807, -0.009231567, 0.012237549, 0.027191162, -0.008804321, 0.09161377, 0.07324219, -0.009925842, -0.016052246, 0.023498535, -0.06567383, -0.015022278, 0.027542114, 0.025802612, 0.009513855, -0.05126953, -0.032684326, 0.030456543, -0.036834717, -0.02796936, 0.0041160583, -0.032592773, 0.042877197, -0.0058937073, 0.013908386, -0.0031089783, 0.033111572, -0.023269653, 0.020690918, 0.002193451, 0.039978027, -0.030273438, -0.012268066, -0.034454346, -0.061157227, 0.009155273, -0.030715942, 0.020187378, -0.055236816, 0.011756897, -0.013053894, 0.0496521, -0.061279297, -0.018325806, -0.0625, 0.008888245, -0.019821167, 0.023880005, -0.020721436, -0.021575928, 0.004890442, 0.05166626, -0.010658264, 0.016784668, 0.011543274, 0.051452637, -0.0032978058, 0.018844604, -0.0009608269, 0.03451538, 0.0181427, 0.043060303, 0.04321289, 0.025665283, 0.05065918, 0.028366089, 0.04119873, 0.013717651, -0.014335632, -0.004257202, -0.00085926056, 0.016036987, -0.024276733, -0.00070238113, 0.047668457, 0.002374649, 0.011413574, 0.014373779, 0.0234375, -0.016067505, 0.042388916, 0.02645874, 0.025772095, -0.046325684, 0.019195557, 0.023162842, 0.056365967, -0.021514893, -0.031982422, -0.011749268, 0.047302246, -0.01763916, 0.013496399, 0.10406494, -0.024459839, 0.023727417, 0.023391724, -0.005622864, -0.05065918, 0.05166626, -0.014678955, 0.014152527, 0.022994995, -0.04788208, -0.026016235, -0.058441162, -0.017852783, -0.008987427, 0.0023422241, 0.017700195, -0.026931763, 0.019500732, 0.015792847, 0.068725586, -0.048339844, -0.031799316, 0.020889282, -0.044067383, 0.0054359436, 0.0041923523, 0.008682251, 0.014907837, 0.00011396408, 0.0056610107, -0.040740967, -0.006866455, 0.022628784, 0.020019531, -0.014625549, -0.017532349, 0.025222778, 0.016082764, -0.024230957, 0.03213501, 0.021850586, 0.013031006, -0.1217041, -0.02734375, -0.029678345, -0.038757324, -0.0057868958, 0.025482178, 0.024291992, 0.012168884, 0.014976501, -0.039398193, -0.015602112, 0.016342163, -0.029678345, 0.06384277, -0.026687622, 0.02456665, 0.03591919, -0.013183594, 0.01373291, -0.018920898, 0.03024292, 0.01574707, 0.035949707, -0.022003174, 0.03173828, -0.02609253, -0.018432617, -0.046295166, 0.024261475, 0.010864258, -0.02003479, -0.020889282, 0.0013637543, -0.018295288, -0.029190063, 0.02281189, -0.029251099, 0.041412354, -0.016906738, 0.02986145, -0.0072364807, -0.030838013, 0.04348755, -0.0005431175, 0.0058784485, 0.041137695, -0.061706543, 0.02557373, -0.012481689, 0.016326904, -0.05230713, 0.0057868958, -0.048034668, -0.036193848, -0.0017366409, 0.02104187, 0.010154724, -0.015777588, -0.036834717, -0.036743164, 0.010353088, -0.011985779, 0.021148682, -0.02041626, 0.013153076, -0.004016876, -0.019485474, -0.028137207, -0.024887085, 0.003944397, 0.033355713, -0.020812988, 0.0011482239, -0.005847931, -0.06335449, 0.056762695, -0.08380127, -0.030822754, -0.004119873, -0.05633545, -0.006790161, -0.028823853, -0.0082092285, -0.00090932846, -0.039916992, -0.04232788, -0.030288696, -0.04586792, 0.015701294, -0.009025574, 0.028869629, -0.0035686493, 0.04522705, -0.023498535, 0.045043945, 0.049835205, -0.029403687, -0.004234314, -0.036712646, 0.021026611, 0.013626099, 0.089904785, 0.014465332, -0.03186035, 0.0013246536, -0.034179688, 0.03463745, 0.032836914, -0.0947876, -0.037353516, -0.02861023, 0.026000977, 0.0154418945, -0.0017356873, -0.017196655, 0.02670288, 0.009384155, -0.018341064, 0.0076293945, -0.018005371, -0.048339844, -0.020233154, 0.009841919, -0.07244873, -0.0049552917, 0.016540527, 0.018875122, 0.04925537, 0.00024104118, 0.06506348, -0.010757446, 0.010681152, -0.024856567, -0.022109985, 0.034851074, -0.015838623, -0.06427002, 0.020004272, -0.032104492, -0.008918762, 0.004020691, -0.011154175, -0.0051651, 0.015533447, 0.028182983, 0.023956299, -0.03375244, 0.010475159, -0.0099105835, -0.01008606, -0.011619568, -0.009002686, 0.003929138, 0.010467529, -0.047332764, 0.0056037903, 0.016815186, 0.039489746, 0.079956055, -0.039886475, -0.000934124, 0.04345703, -0.015510559, -0.04147339, 0.041168213, 0.0007119179, -0.028961182, 0.042633057, 0.016021729, -0.016586304, 0.026062012, -0.03060913, -0.00592041, -0.018722534, -0.025939941, 0.032989502, 0.015731812, -0.016723633, -0.011123657, 0.0032482147, 0.045410156, -0.0070152283, 0.0036563873, -0.05606079, 0.0026226044, -0.03817749, 0.024597168, -0.022949219, -0.018539429, 0.01991272, -0.024124146, -0.011016846, 0.023971558, 0.006641388, -0.018493652, 0.009735107, 0.06390381, 0.00086832047, 0.035003662, -0.0016756058, -0.020889282, 0.05831909, 0.022003174, -0.031829834, -0.0446167, -0.0043563843, -0.04055786, -0.03475952, -0.03286743, -0.057922363, -0.04660034, 0.0075302124, 0.029296875, 0.019332886, 0.010314941, 0.019882202, -0.039031982, -0.0036811829, -0.003074646, 0.02519226, -0.012557983, -0.013198853, -0.028274536, 0.024169922, -0.020339966, 0.005744934, 0.0076065063, 0.026855469, -0.02519226, -0.043182373, -0.10241699, 0.034576416, 0.009979248, 0.031082153, 0.06878662, 0.035980225, 0.049743652, 0.038269043, 0.010360718, -0.0016479492, -0.0034122467, -0.01979065, -0.0129776, 0.052886963, -0.010749817, -0.026489258, 0.015304565, 0.012023926, 0.03778076, -0.01878357, -0.017547607, -0.013412476, 0.0036010742, -0.011985779, 0.02456665, 0.005252838, -0.030593872, -0.0013694763, -0.0211792, 0.0024642944, 0.018753052, -0.016021729, 0.005908966, 0.05493164, 0.032592773, -0.018493652, -0.01586914, -0.0063591003, -0.015487671, -0.020935059, 0.0013284683, 0.016189575, 0.0033550262, 0.003118515, -0.017562866, -0.007129669, 0.0008716583, 0.049835205, 0.0022296906, 0.037719727, -0.05682373, -0.024307251, 0.0008997917, 0.026489258, 0.01939392, -0.028411865, -0.046691895, 0.035095215, 0.026351929, 0.009376526, 0.02861023, 0.003955841, 0.0068588257, -0.019119263, -0.011459351, 0.013183594, -0.05117798, -0.014953613, 0.025543213, -0.03881836, 0.014663696, 0.0021190643, 0.007671356, -0.03768921, 0.032928467, -0.043548584, 0.00793457, 0.018630981, -0.04534912, 0.0154418945, -0.028549194, 0.019927979, 0.03149414, 0.019195557, 0.020446777, 0.01638794, -0.03488159, -0.0071792603, -0.014282227, 0.06976318, -0.025527954, -0.023086548, 0.030822754, 0.012619019, -0.016342163, 0.034606934, 0.014404297, 0.0068244934, -0.021499634, 0.008262634, -0.04055786, -0.023010254, -0.02079773, -0.06048584, 0.01600647, -0.0021076202, 0.013771057, 0.028625488, -0.005645752, -0.0014219284, -0.030090332, -0.030380249, 0.031433105, 0.018295288, 0.03173828, 0.007259369, 0.002067566, 0.017089844, 0.021621704, -0.052703857, -0.022399902, 0.0072517395, -0.012306213, -0.0055999756, 0.03552246, 0.033233643, -0.0004785061, 0.02558899, -0.000664711, 0.05142212, -0.031021118, 0.009536743, 0.014633179, 0.030029297, 0.049591064, -0.006778717, -0.018600464, -0.02330017, -0.006362915, -0.013626099, -0.0104599, 0.0034389496, -0.0006198883, 0.01890564, 0.013175964, 0.047790527, -0.053649902, 0.011528015, -0.031082153, 0.058166504, -0.004310608, 0.006187439, 0.054656982, 0.03286743, 0.04724121, 0.0013074875, 0.024734497, 0.016433716, -0.011665344, 0.015899658, -0.036071777, 0.017242432, -0.05606079, 0.047454834, -0.008483887, 0.009613037, -0.03567505, -0.028137207, 0.006084442, 0.010475159, 0.006969452, 0.015571594, 0.035583496, -0.01260376, 0.03540039, 0.025817871, 0.02772522, -0.023117065, -0.009895325, -0.009544373, 0.028305054, 0.02772522, 0.042266846, -0.0015888214, -0.04699707, -0.021469116, 0.027496338, 0.04522705, -0.0096588135, -0.007167816, -0.010055542, 0.016525269, 0.008171082, 0.043426514, -0.03933716, -0.020309448, -0.026824951, 0.017684937, 0.044403076, 0.04562378, -0.010360718, 0.01108551, -0.0021400452, -0.004535675, 0.012290955, -0.006290436, -0.0155181885, 0.06604004, 0.0018577576, 0.007507324, -0.050201416, -0.025909424, -0.088256836, 0.06048584, -0.023895264, 0.027526855, 0.04071045, 0.017318726, 0.042938232, 0.01876831, -0.057006836, -0.029266357, 0.015335083, 0.010635376, 0.011482239, 0.00045776367, -0.054351807, 0.007904053, 0.045959473, -0.009292603, 0.022720337, 0.01084137, 0.000010073185, -0.0006632805, -0.029556274, -0.01058197, -0.10070801, 0.0077934265, -0.054870605, 0.032104492, -0.0035362244, 0.060333252, 0.040374756, -0.023376465, 0.043060303, -0.023223877, -0.009262085, -0.0385437, -0.0146102905, -0.023895264, -0.034729004, 0.014038086, -0.011360168, -0.011940002, 0.006061554, 0.03555298, 0.06774902, 0.02532959, -0.020385742, 0.030685425, 0.023498535, -0.018051147, -0.0051574707, 0.001876831, -0.045135498, -0.0126571655, 0.03451538, -0.0033073425, -0.011978149, -0.04345703, 0.009101868, 0.026641846, 0.006752014, 0.03012085, 0.010192871, -0.0015544891, 0.015396118, 0.040649414, -0.04714966, 0.041992188, -0.0023670197, -0.02784729, 0.006149292, 0.03363037, -0.034851074, 0.026016235, -0.026519775, 0.04840088, 0.038116455, 0.055480957, -0.02734375, 0.017181396, 0.040008545, -0.00065755844, 0.00024795532, 0.0041542053, 0.025100708, 0.028579712, -0.041015625, -0.0068626404, 0.044891357, 0.01763916, 0.105651855, -0.05279541, 0.02458191, -0.023742676, -0.02331543, -0.046722412, 0.0063476562, 0.020721436, -0.05682373, -0.024261475, 0.03074646, 0.017440796, -0.06573486, 0.0211792, -0.03225708, -0.068603516, 0.006038666, 0.00422287, 0.029785156, -0.023635864, 0.0077171326, -0.0058059692, 0.030319214, 0.050598145, 0.0011720657, -0.038360596, 0.008415222, -0.0008544922, 0.006881714, -0.04916382, -0.026763916, -0.0046691895, 0.006877899, 0.0052719116, -0.0060157776, 0.0062675476, -0.020233154, -0.06390381, 0.023071289, 0.013175964, -0.030838013, 0.048034668, -0.02053833, -0.003370285, -0.06854248, -0.020126343, 0.011878967, -0.01576233, -0.010070801, 0.011512756, 0.022979736, 0.04156494, -0.018951416, -0.02368164, -0.005569458, -0.025299072, 0.041656494, -0.01499939, -0.018722534, 0.027038574, 0.015914917, -0.023849487, -0.012786865, 0.014480591, 0.053588867, -0.00674057, 0.043304443, -0.008644104, -0.005683899, 0.059906006, 0.024520874, 0.0014095306, 0.0035438538, 0.07476807, 0.045410156, 0.032836914, 0.0118255615, -0.04147339, 0.03717041, -0.011772156, -0.042633057, -0.033050537, -0.007095337, 0.0014047623, -0.03656006, 0.020385742, -0.027053833, -0.048736572, 0.008079529, -0.041107178, 0.004108429, 0.0034275055, 0.017028809, 0.009231567, -0.00007754564, 0.0070343018, 0.050079346, -0.025268555, 0.054840088, -0.005607605, -0.032043457, 0.030029297, -0.04525757, 0.040985107, 0.031036377, 0.0126571655, 0.0051345825, 0.016174316, 0.004135132, 0.028579712, -0.024536133, -0.0066490173, -0.07098389, 0.00856781, -0.020111084, 0.013633728, -0.012290955, -0.008140564, 0.0013780594, 0.029922485, -0.038635254, 0.023635864, 0.052337646, 0.024520874, -0.005054474, 0.053588867, 0.061584473, 0.023529053, 0.022918701 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06805v1
Tunable Soft Prompts are Messengers in Federated Learning
Chenhe Dong, Yuexiang Xie, Bolin Ding, Ying Shen, Yaliang Li
cs.CL
Federated learning (FL) enables multiple participants to collaboratively train machine learning models using decentralized data sources, alleviating privacy concerns that arise from directly sharing local data. However, the lack of model privacy protection in FL becomes an unneglectable challenge, especially when people want to federally finetune models based on a proprietary large language model. In this study, we propose a novel FL training approach that accomplishes information exchange among participants via tunable soft prompts. These soft prompts, updated and transmitted between the server and clients, assume the role of the global model parameters and serve as messengers to deliver useful knowledge from the local data and global model. As the global model itself is not required to be shared and the local training is conducted based on an auxiliary model with fewer parameters than the global model, the proposed approach provides protection for the global model while reducing communication and computation costs in FL. Extensive experiments show the effectiveness of the proposed approach compared to several baselines. We have released the source code at \url{https://github.com/alibaba/FederatedScope/tree/fedsp/federatedscope/nlp/fedsp}.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06805v1
2023-11-12T11:01:10
2023-11-12T11:01:10
{ "title": [ 0.01687622, 0.0068626404, -0.030517578, -0.03616333, -0.024108887, -0.028396606, -0.010566711, -0.0066871643, -0.054534912, 0.021728516, -0.045959473, 0.012931824, 0.0038909912, -0.023406982, 0.035583496, -0.03869629, 0.025360107, 0.0023384094, 0.002746582, -0.012924194, -0.03527832, -0.012893677, 0.03262329, 0.008041382, 0.02520752, 0.0041046143, -0.0970459, -0.023757935, 0.02003479, -0.004299164, 0.006526947, 0.006137848, 0.0060806274, 0.03552246, -0.018829346, -0.025909424, -0.026123047, 0.043823242, -0.002483368, 0.022079468, 0.020599365, -0.004043579, 0.02468872, -0.008377075, -0.013137817, 0.01184845, -0.026412964, -0.025650024, 0.027908325, 0.01574707, -0.029052734, -0.0154800415, -0.02809143, 0.025939941, -0.031280518, -0.044952393, -0.024932861, 0.023895264, 0.03970337, 0.01927185, -0.02319336, -0.028121948, 0.030044556, -0.06262207, 0.0023345947, -0.02281189, -0.059143066, 0.02859497, 0.055786133, 0.024368286, 0.0079193115, -0.008171082, 0.0062026978, -0.012863159, -0.028381348, -0.0026855469, 0.010795593, 0.0026664734, 0.022125244, -0.031219482, -0.00045752525, 0.019424438, 0.0023059845, -0.045410156, 0.013206482, -0.037872314, -0.016998291, 0.0070724487, -0.0042304993, -0.021713257, -0.01083374, 0.042541504, -0.03970337, 0.039001465, -0.018005371, -0.028793335, 0.011169434, 0.013755798, -0.008453369, -0.054718018, -0.0259552, 0.0011043549, -0.091430664, 0.016342163, -0.00440979, 0.03479004, 0.0037460327, 0.025482178, 0.016586304, 0.019363403, -0.0016098022, -0.0016822815, -0.005054474, 0.057922363, -0.017105103, -0.05206299, -0.064941406, 0.022445679, -0.039764404, 0.03326416, 0.014587402, 0.03488159, 0.028503418, -0.0056037903, -0.0018377304, 0.030899048, -0.016494751, -0.055358887, -0.0569458, 0.027008057, -0.01600647, 0.0803833, -0.042175293, -0.0647583, -0.068725586, 0.008422852, -0.02835083, -0.029663086, -0.015167236, -0.011489868, 0.04486084, -0.047912598, 0.00015234947, 0.037902832, -0.0064048767, 0.026748657, 0.058135986, 0.006351471, -0.037109375, -0.072509766, 0.000664711, 0.036499023, -0.017074585, 0.016952515, 0.019744873, -0.00050640106, -0.04208374, -0.0042762756, 0.06097412, 0.017318726, 0.0039100647, -0.0072898865, -0.00050735474, 0.02784729, 0.025741577, 0.013587952, -0.0031375885, 0.021942139, 0.004043579, 0.072387695, -0.02670288, 0.006385803, 0.013748169, -0.0284729, -0.024993896, -0.0053520203, 0.020263672, 0.016571045, 0.020462036, -0.027435303, 0.0054626465, -0.011993408, 0.027053833, -0.004146576, -0.014839172, -0.04434204, -0.017715454, 0.008964539, 0.054016113, 0.029846191, -0.06317139, 0.00793457, -0.033416748, -0.045654297, -0.022735596, 0.03262329, -0.00655365, 0.029418945, 0.0024757385, 0.0054130554, -0.0005502701, 0.043823242, -0.035217285, 0.03765869, -0.034820557, 0.009338379, -0.010215759, 0.0154800415, 0.026062012, -0.018081665, 0.0072402954, -0.026885986, 0.032592773, -0.09124756, -0.07006836, 0.007911682, 0.013427734, -0.0513916, -0.015556335, -0.028579712, -0.011550903, 0.032806396, -0.032226562, 0.029129028, 0.011329651, 0.008872986, 0.001865387, -0.00042247772, 0.06451416, 0.0098724365, 0.107788086, -0.028182983, 0.0015077591, -0.017410278, -0.042144775, -0.014915466, 0.008781433, -0.035827637, 0.02734375, 0.050476074, 0.003282547, -0.017303467, 0.0016231537, 0.02709961, 0.02243042, 0.015426636, 0.025421143, -0.009986877, 0.01651001, 0.010902405, 0.050079346, -0.0018367767, 0.031921387, 0.031677246, 0.006137848, 0.040893555, 0.01864624, -0.015296936, 0.010818481, 0.041229248, -0.010620117, 0.06707764, 0.015670776, 0.034118652, -0.08691406, -0.021362305, -0.062805176, -0.02798462, -0.0021190643, 0.003982544, 0.045196533, -0.025390625, 0.018615723, -0.034698486, -0.0087509155, -0.052520752, -0.052764893, 0.035888672, 0.024673462, -0.045532227, -0.019226074, 0.0016489029, 0.033966064, -0.000054836273, 0.0024433136, 0.049194336, 0.052001953, -0.0059547424, -0.0025558472, 0.014717102, 0.062927246, 0.025634766, 0.015525818, 0.002380371, 0.016983032, -0.009750366, 0.037231445, 0.07141113, -0.03579712, 0.018295288, -0.046539307, -0.0065307617, 0.023132324, -0.026016235, -0.0014095306, 0.018966675, 0.01953125, 0.0017843246, -0.018417358, -0.034851074, -0.02142334, 0.0012311935, 0.010948181, -0.023361206, -0.021362305, -0.021194458, -0.02482605, -0.013763428, -0.027145386, -0.00078964233, 0.11419678, 0.025924683, -0.0039901733, -0.032470703, 0.0031280518, -0.056427002, -0.03488159, -0.027542114, 0.013069153, 0.015525818, -0.019302368, -0.005470276, -0.07159424, 0.012573242, 0.0037612915, 0.021530151, 0.009635925, -0.042877197, 0.0077438354, 0.00073194504, 0.015960693, -0.02949524, 0.002248764, -0.042022705, 0.019989014, -0.062194824, -0.035980225, -0.012664795, 0.015197754, -0.00919342, 0.031280518, 0.0069084167, -0.02017212, -0.0009112358, 0.045135498, -0.07080078, -0.008781433, 0.032043457, 0.007030487, -0.019500732, 0.054840088, 0.005695343, 0.007850647, -0.040374756, 0.006286621, -0.042236328, -0.02204895, -0.016036987, -0.017623901, 0.02520752, -0.0035915375, -0.0037231445, -0.059295654, -0.018157959, -0.025115967, 0.0024318695, 0.04824829, -0.02168274, -0.041748047, 0.012390137, 0.006454468, -0.0051879883, 0.012252808, -0.009338379, 0.06713867, -0.013954163, -0.014518738, 0.007209778, 0.02029419, 0.008087158, -0.017822266, -0.038604736, -0.034179688, -0.021087646, -0.00058555603, 0.029693604, -0.032989502, -0.054901123, -0.024337769, -0.0030822754, 0.059539795, -0.039398193, -0.04598999, 0.040252686, -0.017181396, -0.009033203, 0.06689453, -0.03286743, 0.02949524, 0.024887085, -0.0023670197, -0.0236969, 0.031707764, -0.03805542, -0.00090932846, -0.026870728, -0.040863037, 0.00856781, -0.048950195, 0.028686523, 0.04837036, -0.024749756, -0.027954102, -0.009025574, 0.037994385, 0.034576416, 0.029571533, -0.025924683, -0.015716553, 0.005592346, 0.019897461, -0.02508545, -0.0043182373, -0.0004582405, -0.022628784, -0.008544922, -0.0032444, 0.01209259, 0.05517578, -0.029174805, -0.10998535, -0.037200928, -0.045776367, 0.0015878677, -0.028869629, -0.033050537, -0.03744507, -0.09857178, -0.020431519, 0.028289795, -0.01966858, 0.011749268, -0.03060913, 0.007461548, -0.022033691, 0.04534912, 0.001830101, 0.03237915, 0.019897461, 0.0055656433, 0.025543213, -0.0015583038, -0.08099365, 0.03050232, 0.0027809143, -0.014724731, 0.04095459, -0.005207062, -0.030471802, 0.026489258, -0.032714844, -0.007511139, -0.0049476624, -0.011016846, 0.0043792725, 0.0069999695, -0.006259918, -0.0071029663, 0.0030841827, 0.0021686554, 0.025375366, 0.0075798035, -0.021759033, -0.020446777, -0.014526367, 0.017425537, -0.08050537, -0.04675293, 0.027694702, -0.031921387, -0.05142212, -0.033355713, 0.029190063, -0.04937744, -0.019866943, 0.004009247, 0.0029754639, 0.020721436, 0.0143966675, -0.046783447, -0.02758789, 0.028762817, -0.015167236, -0.018203735, 0.013755798, -0.037963867, -0.053497314, -0.0015630722, 0.01852417, 0.0040893555, 0.008354187, 0.0066337585, 0.017837524, 0.017486572, -0.015930176, 0.031341553, 0.020126343, -0.018157959, 0.01689148, 0.016479492, 0.014251709, 0.058135986, -0.0619812, 0.029586792, 0.06994629, -0.015617371, -0.058898926, 0.039611816, -0.015014648, -0.046875, 0.032073975, 0.012687683, 0.035461426, 0.041137695, -0.018829346, 0.038848877, -0.010238647, 0.0026683807, 0.01638794, 0.0029315948, -0.029281616, -0.042907715, -0.004322052, 0.026062012, -0.019317627, -0.008522034, -0.0027503967, 0.062561035, -0.017745972, 0.012298584, 0.029769897, 0.022232056, -0.05517578, -0.002407074, 0.004852295, -0.10870361, -0.045135498, 0.019973755, -0.014945984, 0.026016235, 0.027175903, -0.0126571655, -0.04269409, 0.020614624, -0.018096924, 0.004940033, -0.015960693, -0.059051514, -0.059295654, -0.005908966, -0.09320068, -0.02418518, -0.061401367, -0.05215454, -0.00844574, 0.0059928894, -0.042175293, 0.025146484, 0.008087158, 0.049926758, 0.042907715, 0.020767212, -0.05505371, 0.03125, -0.007499695, 0.00030612946, -0.020996094, 0.043884277, -0.02722168, -0.05102539, -0.017120361, 0.0021762848, -0.009262085, -0.0647583, 0.024246216, 0.0038089752, 0.035308838, 0.008758545, -0.011512756, 0.033599854, -0.0018539429, 0.009712219, 0.01222229, -0.028289795, 0.0005578995, 0.009117126, -0.02357483, 0.030685425, -0.018493652, -0.0068473816, 0.038635254, -0.018341064, 0.0011301041, 0.0045318604, -0.0054893494, 0.03189087, -0.0074768066, 0.051696777, 0.0016994476, -0.016708374, 0.03086853, -0.02067566, 0.028060913, -0.00042915344, -0.014656067, -0.011497498, -0.018112183, -0.008132935, -0.022567749, 0.015602112, 0.019866943, 0.006515503, -0.01939392, -0.02949524, 0.023956299, 0.039520264, -0.0067710876, 0.001947403, -0.016464233, 0.0067253113, 0.029388428, 0.028320312, 0.012802124, -0.049102783, 0.009399414, -0.0035629272, -0.013870239, -0.00042510033, -0.041137695, -0.030685425, -0.012008667, 0.01675415, 0.018249512, -0.011199951, -0.002122879, -0.03479004, -0.03842163, 0.001247406, 0.003917694, -0.048065186, -0.028213501, 0.030426025, 0.027008057, 0.015808105, 0.033050537, 0.027267456, 0.024124146, 0.029403687, 0.012382507, 0.010421753, -0.011138916, 0.009315491, -0.029266357, -0.019897461, 0.014785767, 0.0038604736, 0.039245605, 0.019317627, 0.028747559, -0.07208252, 0.012741089, -0.0023002625, 0.010566711, -0.011291504, -0.034057617, 0.028808594, -0.0058898926, -0.0032844543, 0.010559082, -0.06536865, -0.07019043, -0.03100586, -0.032928467, -0.04147339, 0.030700684, -0.011550903, -0.034210205, -0.034973145, 0.09588623, -0.03048706, -0.02758789, -0.0034503937, 0.003753662, -0.017715454, -0.003982544, -0.0015096664, -0.025894165, 0.0048103333, 0.005142212, 0.027404785, 0.006034851, -0.01663208, -0.05105591, -0.022003174, 0.014602661, 0.005306244, 0.017929077, -0.023986816, -0.008560181, 0.013206482, -0.025177002, 0.0038776398, 0.025238037, -0.031463623, 0.014701843, 0.046417236, -0.041931152, -0.0023021698, -0.012275696, 0.013282776, 0.008651733, 0.03338623, 0.008224487, -0.003435135, 0.0181427, -0.046936035, 0.026763916, 0.0041656494, 0.008811951, 0.0007123947, -0.023025513, 0.0025634766, 0.028900146, 0.013824463, -0.030349731, -0.024246216, -0.0077781677, 0.060455322, -0.022628784, -0.024108887, 0.06945801, 0.0067710876, -0.023452759, -0.04534912, 0.000052809715, -0.07739258, 0.02053833, 0.0047912598, 0.00048089027, -0.02658081, -0.089782715, -0.027938843, -0.009162903, 0.057678223, 0.032043457, 0.05819702, -0.049835205, -0.025756836, 0.023483276, 0.018707275, -0.033111572, 0.010147095, -0.018081665, -0.022537231, 0.017593384, 0.036010742, 0.007041931, -0.013046265, 0.02330017, 0.016464233, 0.0082092285, 0.0019330978, -0.015792847, -0.014022827, -0.01361084, 0.024810791, 0.0368042, 0.03918457, -0.023513794, 0.046722412, -0.015335083, 0.03616333, 0.02406311, 0.05154419, 0.024841309, 0.016296387, 0.026672363, 0.022140503, 0.013153076, -0.022003174, 0.066711426, -0.077697754, 0.03439331, -0.03668213, -0.019134521, -0.1003418, -0.021057129, 0.038482666, 0.040771484, -0.0017986298, -0.0032444, 0.014015198, -0.028198242, -0.013671875, -0.010406494, 0.03881836, -0.08477783, -0.025619507, -0.007648468, -0.019210815, 0.030273438, 0.036987305, -0.012374878, 0.025405884, -0.015792847, -0.016235352, 0.041259766, -0.0069503784, -0.027038574, -0.03427124, 0.02067566, -0.051727295, -0.009971619, 0.010696411, 0.0045928955, -0.0032348633, 0.026870728, 0.0011434555, 0.026885986, -0.01626587, 0.03793335, -0.053955078, 0.022521973, 0.043640137, -0.019607544, -0.013465881, -0.04547119, -0.039489746, -0.013320923, 0.06262207, 0.024490356, -0.02029419, 0.020523071, 0.009773254, -0.0075149536, 0.022521973, 0.017196655, -0.018112183, -0.019714355, 0.021514893, 0.0027313232, 0.008850098, 0.03567505, -0.0075263977, 0.0035591125, -0.027816772, -0.018508911, -0.02142334, 0.013847351, -0.083984375, 0.004547119, 0.012336731, 0.095703125, -0.029678345, -0.03503418, 0.03540039, 0.03137207, -0.099975586, 0.019683838, 0.030212402, 0.091430664, 0.015655518, 0.049560547, -0.03378296, -0.019851685, 0.04083252, 0.015510559, 0.044311523, 0.054870605, -0.0053482056, 0.02645874, -0.028625488, -0.018371582, 0.00592041, -0.005542755, -0.007904053, -0.023910522, 0.070007324, -0.021438599, -0.03567505, -0.007572174, -0.043029785, 0.025787354, 0.013847351, -0.0546875, 0.015266418, -0.009300232, -0.03692627, 0.0012598038, -0.039520264, -0.005142212, 0.01953125, -0.006881714, 0.041656494, -0.025665283, -0.009635925, 0.0015182495, -0.01033783, 0.022659302, 0.009223938, -0.02053833, -0.0033226013, -0.0016098022, 0.034210205, 0.0074920654, -0.034240723, 0.024978638, -0.001572609, -0.024765015, -0.00041508675, 0.010009766, -0.025772095, -0.031341553, -0.017807007, 0.026885986, -0.015426636, 0.014801025, 0.009407043, -0.029266357, -0.032073975, 0.008895874, -0.03656006, 0.02418518, 0.014144897, -0.018463135, -0.011154175, 0.021453857, -0.046936035, -0.032592773, -0.01133728, 0.010192871, 0.0043754578, -0.025344849, -0.0124435425, 0.01663208, 0.027557373, -0.0385437, -0.030303955, 0.0041885376, 0.066467285, -0.0012588501, 0.033294678, 0.047210693, 0.023483276, -0.04135132, -0.00920105, -0.023712158, -0.009338379, 0.012397766, 0.021652222, 0.02671814, 0.03189087, -0.028121948, 0.025024414, 0.018432617, -0.016616821, 0.018478394, 0.011512756, -0.064086914, -0.007095337, -0.018966675, -0.0005207062, 0.0051879883, -0.010437012, -0.029373169, -0.011138916, 0.018295288, 0.032318115, -0.026733398, 0.02218628, -0.0058403015, 0.07897949, -0.0014257431, 0.03567505, -0.00818634, 0.021224976, 0.01838684, 0.022903442, 0.011306763, 0.012435913, 0.0051651, 0.010414124, 0.023010254, 0.014221191, 0.004047394, -0.008102417, 0.010017395, -0.059661865, -0.033813477, -0.021530151, -0.024612427, 0.005760193, -0.07788086, 0.056640625, -0.038635254, -0.011550903, 0.01878357, -0.025726318, 0.068481445, -0.016937256, -0.004383087, -0.03111267, 0.010047913, 0.017974854 ], "summary": [ -0.018005371, -0.0018615723, -0.0446167, -0.047180176, -0.009925842, -0.006336212, -0.03074646, 0.0101623535, -0.030899048, 0.005367279, -0.050628662, 0.023849487, -0.02545166, -0.011131287, 0.036743164, -0.05834961, -0.008628845, 0.004432678, 0.006881714, -0.028915405, 0.0042152405, -0.02029419, 0.009048462, -0.05557251, 0.04119873, -0.044799805, -0.08178711, 0.021469116, 0.022720337, 0.032440186, 0.023117065, -0.013801575, -0.008468628, 0.050720215, -0.04510498, -0.074157715, -0.0047721863, 0.01953125, -0.0073051453, 0.028961182, 0.039611816, -0.016845703, 0.016555786, 0.034698486, -0.019073486, 0.012184143, -0.014793396, -0.036834717, 0.009605408, 0.08306885, -0.013572693, -0.009811401, -0.038238525, 0.054382324, -0.014526367, -0.046661377, -0.01272583, -0.0073013306, 0.039123535, 0.012664795, -0.0034923553, -0.028701782, 0.0030059814, -0.039855957, -0.008605957, -0.0067977905, -0.029571533, 0.009651184, 0.0546875, -0.0046195984, -0.01058197, 0.01083374, 0.042907715, -0.042419434, -0.010139465, -0.025039673, 0.031204224, -0.0032672882, 0.0008177757, -0.01852417, 0.0011110306, 0.024520874, -0.02468872, -0.019104004, -0.0025615692, -0.0079193115, -0.016052246, -0.012130737, 0.0047340393, 0.0317688, -0.0036258698, -0.01940918, -0.011764526, 0.086120605, 0.016067505, 0.011062622, -0.015914917, -0.021133423, 0.008270264, -0.001625061, -0.0064468384, -0.014152527, -0.024734497, 0.004432678, -0.031341553, 0.059906006, 0.007419586, -0.01525116, -0.044128418, -0.0019083023, -0.009346008, -0.07940674, -0.023376465, -0.010688782, -0.036895752, 0.02720642, -0.0259552, -0.0009689331, -0.012001038, 0.027420044, 0.046325684, 0.06317139, -0.017807007, 0.026947021, -0.003698349, 0.024337769, 0.0015497208, -0.041625977, -0.014915466, 0.006778717, -0.015579224, 0.045318604, -0.015586853, -0.012680054, -0.03475952, 0.0046691895, -0.0022888184, 0.0118255615, 0.004009247, -0.006298065, 0.03488159, -0.020523071, -0.017166138, 0.043792725, -0.02822876, 0.033721924, 0.0345459, -0.015945435, -0.036224365, -0.047668457, -0.030319214, 0.026397705, 0.019851685, -0.00730896, 0.0009202957, -0.027572632, -0.01159668, -0.011024475, 0.0132369995, -0.027374268, 0.04901123, -0.0035171509, -0.017654419, 0.052764893, 0.003145218, 0.016723633, 0.0008187294, -0.01737976, -0.0031852722, 0.015449524, -0.02394104, 0.010475159, -0.012580872, -0.018936157, -0.004798889, -0.0052108765, 0.005962372, 0.06500244, 0.019058228, -0.0335083, 0.0013713837, -0.009017944, 0.10510254, -0.009857178, 0.0178833, -0.041931152, -0.0041122437, 0.0023002625, 0.043762207, 0.022979736, -0.05343628, -0.018203735, -0.026153564, -0.015838623, -0.023483276, 0.031707764, -0.017578125, 0.03366089, -0.008903503, -0.018188477, 0.03149414, 0.03970337, -0.032104492, 0.011383057, -0.04547119, 0.016067505, 0.0005760193, 0.027877808, -0.026687622, -0.014083862, 0.025238037, -0.03665161, 0.010169983, -0.024612427, -0.017669678, -0.0107803345, 0.0039405823, -0.048095703, 0.013793945, -0.027999878, 0.01838684, 0.044891357, -0.00642395, 0.019195557, -0.047790527, -0.005367279, -0.025344849, 0.025283813, 0.0063285828, -0.006374359, 0.11407471, -0.01914978, -0.028152466, 0.0029201508, -0.008705139, -0.009269714, 0.00983429, -0.04348755, 0.014778137, 0.03375244, -0.002532959, 0.000028848648, -0.04058838, 0.024307251, -0.0047073364, 0.047302246, 0.04977417, -0.0030994415, -0.0063056946, 0.015449524, 0.0418396, 0.0030555725, 0.007369995, 0.026031494, 0.014793396, 0.023666382, 0.008514404, -0.039367676, 0.01939392, -0.0016832352, 0.026168823, -0.023773193, -0.054901123, 0.016494751, -0.050476074, -0.061309814, -0.032806396, -0.044677734, 0.014305115, -0.042388916, 0.033050537, -0.061157227, 0.010017395, -0.020141602, -0.03918457, -0.051940918, -0.013305664, 0.030899048, 0.019165039, -0.04458618, -0.022003174, 0.00057029724, 0.0024662018, -0.013572693, 0.0011463165, -0.0006132126, 0.02420044, -0.022079468, 0.007217407, 0.028915405, 0.04550171, 0.0053634644, -0.0073661804, -0.010192871, 0.01838684, -0.017227173, 0.024673462, 0.052215576, -0.024291992, -0.0031280518, -0.032440186, 0.005420685, -0.00056409836, -0.038269043, -0.004837036, -0.0015153885, -0.00086545944, 0.014251709, -0.007965088, 0.0035209656, -0.04168701, 0.01979065, 0.009941101, 0.0070610046, -0.04321289, -0.03765869, -0.009231567, -0.013900757, -0.029800415, 0.03274536, 0.13745117, 0.015808105, -0.000351429, 0.0059661865, -0.0021591187, -0.052886963, 0.031097412, -0.037322998, 0.027267456, -0.00015628338, -0.090026855, -0.025894165, -0.075805664, 0.030899048, -0.019165039, 0.0065727234, 0.005268097, -0.028198242, 0.014602661, 0.010414124, 0.052947998, 0.015113831, 0.016342163, -0.009155273, -0.059570312, -0.033477783, -0.008483887, -0.013931274, -0.033111572, -0.043182373, 0.06616211, -0.0058555603, -0.01360321, 0.008338928, 0.027008057, -0.053497314, -0.006526947, -0.005443573, -0.024215698, -0.04159546, 0.045288086, 0.007030487, 0.0015487671, -0.095336914, 0.008735657, -0.01689148, -0.03656006, -0.015640259, 0.043914795, 0.0690918, 0.01361084, 0.043701172, -0.07928467, -0.005760193, 0.007972717, -0.01398468, 0.12634277, 0.024139404, -0.03842163, 0.07312012, 0.043151855, 0.019058228, -0.008155823, -0.027801514, 0.010856628, 0.019973755, 0.008743286, 0.022247314, 0.0158844, -0.013420105, -0.0046577454, 0.009002686, 0.009185791, -0.018325806, -0.0068511963, 0.0053977966, 0.014785767, -0.00920105, 0.014152527, -0.03805542, 0.02746582, 0.0024299622, -0.0073928833, 0.003370285, 0.008255005, -0.038848877, 0.05496216, -0.011146545, 0.0079956055, -0.015220642, 0.02557373, -0.03717041, 0.0033798218, -0.03378296, 0.003458023, -0.052490234, 0.018707275, 0.013679504, -0.027832031, -0.016403198, 0.030639648, 0.0022068024, -0.0039863586, -0.012313843, 0.026245117, 0.07232666, -0.020599365, -0.037017822, -0.0043678284, 0.032806396, 0.013328552, -0.0001835823, -0.0014448166, -0.011360168, -0.06402588, -0.020080566, -0.00074625015, 0.0043029785, 0.03475952, -0.048553467, -0.058654785, -0.014915466, -0.03564453, -0.006591797, 0.00007504225, -0.03643799, -0.0030097961, -0.057037354, 0.008285522, 0.07281494, -0.029373169, 0.0057258606, 0.0018758774, 0.017578125, -0.025421143, -0.0075035095, -0.006980896, 0.036376953, 0.047912598, -0.022979736, 0.014198303, -0.006916046, -0.0552063, 0.025619507, 0.057128906, 0.047698975, -0.016601562, 0.017150879, -0.027816772, 0.024917603, 0.055999756, -0.10296631, -0.037200928, -0.0010099411, -0.0022010803, 0.0063171387, 0.010726929, -0.00094366074, 0.025100708, -0.005874634, -0.052642822, 0.046173096, -0.07183838, -0.08483887, -0.087768555, 0.025787354, -0.10412598, -0.072387695, 0.007911682, -0.012809753, -0.035125732, -0.04083252, 0.018432617, -0.03491211, -0.01928711, 0.031951904, -0.014381409, 0.07080078, -0.0029907227, -0.07318115, 0.017471313, -0.009681702, 0.032348633, 0.023925781, 0.008781433, 0.026809692, -0.003982544, 0.0158844, 0.010818481, -0.034729004, 0.020233154, -0.03161621, 0.0015678406, 0.038208008, -0.03201294, 0.0023059845, 0.0029239655, 0.012512207, -0.021011353, 0.0033435822, 0.023834229, 0.08135986, -0.050354004, 0.019607544, 0.034210205, -0.040039062, -0.026229858, 0.034698486, 0.014457703, -0.0077934265, 0.014137268, 0.011856079, 0.02758789, 0.032470703, -0.030059814, -0.021636963, -0.017242432, -0.04660034, 0.01965332, 0.055755615, -0.013824463, -0.017059326, 0.007637024, 0.057769775, -0.01184082, 0.0073928833, -0.008911133, 0.0041999817, 0.0051345825, -0.028427124, 0.014816284, 0.010345459, -0.0053253174, -0.011184692, -0.0019273758, 0.009506226, 0.005393982, 0.0029182434, -0.022888184, 0.018630981, -0.00029540062, -0.018630981, -0.017913818, 0.020462036, -0.0152282715, 0.023773193, -0.02420044, -0.049865723, -0.029708862, 0.021240234, -0.060760498, -0.011627197, -0.03640747, -0.081848145, -0.017669678, -0.027267456, -0.005256653, 0.01852417, -0.0055999756, -0.018875122, 0.052490234, -0.018173218, -0.042144775, -0.0546875, -0.03173828, 0.019012451, -0.004447937, 0.03302002, -0.05178833, -0.048187256, -0.01878357, 0.027893066, -0.017349243, -0.056396484, 0.02281189, 0.0087509155, 0.0023441315, 0.029129028, 0.032165527, 0.029067993, -0.0023479462, 0.0040740967, 0.003118515, -0.0013008118, 0.00793457, 0.009979248, -0.033355713, 0.043548584, -0.0058288574, 0.016281128, -0.013977051, -0.005077362, 0.012290955, -0.0037670135, -0.0049209595, 0.013008118, 0.019348145, -0.009429932, 0.018753052, -0.00579834, 0.033416748, 0.010299683, 0.019058228, 0.023147583, 0.0051193237, -0.014541626, -0.01914978, 0.013618469, -0.009017944, 0.009422302, 0.018981934, 0.0026836395, -0.002527237, -0.005214691, 0.028762817, 0.019119263, -0.019683838, -0.020568848, -0.05050659, -0.012275696, 0.023498535, 0.006980896, -0.022583008, -0.058135986, 0.01876831, -0.016098022, -0.03744507, 0.0058670044, -0.02116394, -0.002292633, 0.02104187, 0.029922485, -0.009559631, 0.011528015, 0.021347046, 0.0031051636, -0.037322998, 0.0010309219, 0.00667572, -0.04284668, -0.078430176, 0.00027036667, 0.012084961, -0.015068054, 0.027877808, 0.000702858, 0.034454346, 0.023651123, 0.012710571, 0.0036907196, -0.027236938, 0.027450562, -0.043640137, -0.028747559, 0.014045715, 0.026885986, 0.015838623, 0.027389526, 0.002626419, -0.05102539, -0.0037212372, -0.019058228, -0.018951416, -0.038635254, 0.0132369995, 0.04849243, 0.032043457, 0.000243783, -0.0040016174, -0.04336548, -0.046813965, -0.03765869, -0.019683838, -0.055480957, 0.04852295, -0.007419586, -0.03036499, 0.008544922, 0.041870117, -0.027191162, -0.026550293, 0.027389526, 0.0020160675, 0.0052375793, -0.034576416, -0.021499634, -0.018981934, -0.004589081, -0.0042915344, 0.01828003, -0.034088135, -0.026794434, -0.014755249, 0.0014753342, -0.020401001, -0.026657104, -0.043182373, -0.047576904, -0.0309906, 0.05996704, -0.025634766, 0.017303467, 0.024093628, -0.0579834, -0.012260437, 0.048675537, -0.028442383, 0.014320374, -0.024353027, -0.03186035, -0.014793396, 0.020950317, -0.01939392, -0.02520752, 0.0068244934, -0.037841797, 0.047698975, 0.014312744, -0.0017156601, 0.038146973, 0.0116119385, -0.0008955002, 0.032440186, -0.0099487305, -0.04107666, -0.013504028, 0.0056610107, 0.010284424, -0.022125244, -0.040802002, 0.03982544, 0.012084961, -0.0024662018, -0.044921875, 0.014190674, -0.06951904, -0.020339966, 0.0047721863, 0.01991272, -0.012794495, -0.08544922, -0.009635925, -0.013046265, 0.041870117, 0.05380249, 0.07147217, 0.012145996, 0.031097412, 0.024597168, -0.008117676, -0.018478394, 0.012573242, -0.01361084, -0.01940918, 0.0262146, 0.014503479, -0.018203735, 0.008979797, 0.021087646, -0.0025596619, -0.0014514923, 0.024551392, 0.025161743, 0.01158905, -0.017105103, 0.030471802, 0.023651123, 0.032287598, -0.022033691, 0.014854431, 0.022750854, 0.021011353, 0.013282776, 0.00605011, 0.0008749962, 0.013832092, 0.02507019, 0.0017938614, -0.012069702, -0.016571045, 0.053833008, -0.0024986267, -0.029830933, -0.040008545, -0.05050659, -0.05303955, 0.020309448, 0.0016517639, -0.003835678, 0.037384033, 0.0037937164, 0.016967773, -0.000029087067, -0.034606934, 0.00094652176, 0.00076913834, -0.058563232, -0.029418945, 0.009887695, 0.014930725, 0.0066108704, 0.04776001, 0.009101868, 0.014198303, 0.025787354, -0.0026226044, 0.043823242, -0.035003662, -0.017089844, -0.08251953, 0.02116394, -0.048736572, 0.019546509, 0.012969971, 0.007129669, 0.024139404, 0.032562256, 0.04031372, -0.024810791, 0.020401001, 0.021011353, 0.00074243546, -0.0119018555, -0.007713318, 0.024917603, -0.049438477, -0.020812988, -0.016174316, 0.01902771, 0.023147583, 0.041778564, -0.08001709, 0.014816284, -0.0029029846, -0.011138916, -0.050598145, 0.015914917, -0.0071754456, -0.0025749207, 0.04296875, 0.027404785, 0.0013780594, 0.022445679, -0.018966675, 0.017425537, -0.01259613, 0.0005288124, 0.0021839142, -0.002981186, -0.012840271, 0.019119263, -0.03579712, 0.03677368, 0.034240723, -0.017730713, 0.00073957443, 0.053985596, -0.03378296, 0.02217102, 0.03564453, 0.09954834, 0.06524658, 0.059936523, -0.06414795, 0.014450073, 0.10479736, -0.00970459, 0.046447754, -0.0053520203, -0.015419006, -0.01448822, -0.008163452, 0.019851685, -0.0013160706, 0.011741638, -0.020019531, 0.000018000603, 0.05847168, -0.039276123, -0.005428314, -0.059570312, -0.041015625, 0.11584473, -0.0051612854, -0.04534912, 0.034240723, 0.074279785, 0.00097465515, 0.046142578, -0.035186768, -0.056396484, -0.0027542114, -0.016662598, -0.003314972, 0.02355957, 0.0050201416, 0.012550354, -0.03945923, 0.05105591, -0.026351929, -0.03225708, 0.03137207, -0.0060691833, 0.02268982, 0.013656616, -0.017074585, 0.0054244995, 0.015060425, -0.04660034, 0.022216797, 0.0362854, -0.0340271, -0.10760498, 0.004085541, -0.020126343, -0.051727295, 0.042938232, 0.018676758, -0.009941101, -0.03326416, 0.022613525, -0.030380249, 0.013954163, -0.027801514, 0.006385803, -0.017562866, 0.040802002, -0.022476196, -0.02986145, -0.0104522705, 0.0015144348, -0.018707275, -0.048095703, 0.019546509, -0.013038635, 0.039886475, -0.011421204, 0.016357422, 0.021743774, 0.029083252, 0.018157959, 0.024307251, -0.0056915283, -0.0028362274, -0.025146484, 0.024856567, -0.008926392, -0.0047950745, -0.013694763, 0.026535034, 0.02104187, 0.02708435, -0.00554657, -0.007713318, 0.027420044, -0.020553589, -0.0084991455, 0.028823853, -0.021881104, -0.027450562, -0.013648987, -0.03050232, -0.021697998, -0.0423584, -0.016052246, -0.0149002075, 0.008483887, 0.027282715, -0.03729248, 0.024108887, -0.014556885, -0.00605011, 0.0053596497, 0.0028800964, -0.02658081, -0.010871887, 0.010887146, 0.027175903, -0.017669678, -0.028259277, -0.0020523071, -0.0009274483, 0.027191162, 0.010215759, -0.006881714, -0.032684326, 0.008575439, -0.08392334, -0.021575928, -0.054504395, -0.039978027, 0.009056091, -0.07043457, 0.048217773, -0.020706177, 0.0013437271, 0.028564453, -0.015022278, 0.06347656, 0.03427124, -0.0099487305, -0.033843994, 0.0026016235, -0.0015258789 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06771v1
Learning Globally Optimized Language Structure via Adversarial Training
Xuwang Yin
cs.CL, cs.AI
Recent work has explored integrating autoregressive language models with energy-based models (EBMs) to enhance text generation capabilities. However, learning effective EBMs for text is challenged by the discrete nature of language. This work proposes an adversarial training strategy to address limitations in prior efforts. Specifically, an iterative adversarial attack algorithm is presented to generate negative samples for training the EBM by perturbing text from the autoregressive model. This aims to enable the EBM to suppress spurious modes outside the support of the data distribution. Experiments on an arithmetic sequence generation task demonstrate that the proposed adversarial training approach can substantially enhance the quality of generated sequences compared to prior methods. The results highlight the promise of adversarial techniques to improve discrete EBM training. Key contributions include: (1) an adversarial attack strategy tailored to text to generate negative samples, circumventing MCMC limitations; (2) an adversarial training algorithm for EBMs leveraging these attacks; (3) empirical validation of performance improvements on a sequence generation task.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06771v1
2023-11-12T08:21:43
2023-11-12T08:21:43
{ "title": [ -0.033294678, -0.013557434, -0.030700684, -0.06689453, -0.008872986, 0.019104004, -0.06365967, 0.01802063, -0.033477783, 0.022903442, 0.010620117, 0.019348145, -0.02192688, -0.026168823, -0.013763428, 0.00013697147, -0.001001358, 0.024551392, -0.041992188, -0.03604126, -0.017089844, -0.046844482, 0.021652222, 0.0104522705, 0.044769287, -0.08685303, -0.054870605, 0.022521973, -0.027862549, -0.032165527, 0.0023422241, 0.016799927, 0.04348755, 0.029083252, -0.02619934, -0.0043640137, -0.04168701, 0.017990112, 0.01210022, -0.0068359375, 0.019592285, 0.009147644, -0.022033691, 0.0061302185, -0.04675293, -0.00040912628, -0.049591064, -0.026672363, -0.00819397, 0.051696777, 0.023406982, 0.04244995, -0.0066604614, 0.017410278, 0.02458191, -0.03894043, -0.026611328, -0.006160736, 0.030914307, 0.09411621, 0.027893066, -0.05480957, 0.0008020401, -0.055541992, -0.018951416, -0.027130127, -0.03060913, 0.03652954, 0.03338623, 0.0049743652, -0.0025482178, -0.0056495667, 0.012519836, -0.02519226, -0.046691895, -0.007511139, 0.03152466, -0.0045547485, 0.043182373, -0.041229248, 0.01878357, 0.012306213, 0.018814087, -0.030059814, 0.032318115, -0.0340271, -0.027053833, -0.015457153, -0.036193848, -0.08166504, -0.0022735596, -0.011817932, -0.040374756, -0.014289856, -0.011894226, -0.0552063, -0.015975952, -0.010108948, 0.0029411316, -0.008766174, -0.002363205, 0.01889038, 0.0012636185, -0.007091522, 0.016082764, 0.005153656, -0.02798462, -0.028640747, 0.012481689, 0.028808594, -0.039642334, 0.028823853, 0.008232117, -0.0035114288, 0.0030403137, 0.023956299, -0.00894928, 0.03111267, 0.010818481, 0.060302734, -0.0046463013, -0.02482605, 0.0040893555, 0.0014667511, 0.038757324, 0.016403198, -0.04928589, 0.013267517, -0.00466156, 0.022979736, 0.0098724365, 0.048095703, -0.10217285, -0.091674805, -0.07122803, 0.04925537, -0.040405273, 0.0036239624, -0.029754639, 0.021469116, 0.0049819946, -0.018539429, 0.014732361, -0.0058631897, -0.0033435822, 0.0104522705, 0.07080078, -0.0087890625, -0.064086914, -0.05355835, -0.020950317, 0.010910034, 0.044006348, -0.0055389404, -0.074035645, -0.023529053, -0.109069824, -0.018707275, 0.00043058395, -0.01991272, 0.024993896, 0.004383087, 0.00041246414, 0.017654419, 0.026245117, -0.0073890686, -0.02709961, 0.0029449463, 0.0135269165, 0.019561768, -0.010421753, 0.027679443, 0.0107040405, 0.0013933182, -0.013839722, 0.0035934448, 0.029083252, -0.010231018, 0.01965332, 0.0013341904, 0.02180481, -0.022232056, -0.010475159, 0.052520752, -0.055633545, -0.023605347, 0.00044369698, -0.0038795471, 0.06652832, 0.0035572052, -0.012916565, 0.00592041, -0.033599854, -0.028411865, -0.03918457, 0.0033359528, 0.016357422, 0.049835205, -0.0053863525, -0.01209259, -0.014625549, 0.010673523, -0.044647217, -0.0082092285, -0.018615723, -0.029434204, -0.015533447, 0.020950317, -0.03189087, 0.021621704, 0.058624268, -0.0051879883, -0.041931152, 0.038970947, 0.0007429123, -0.030929565, 0.04421997, 0.007785797, 0.008728027, -0.018173218, -0.009277344, -0.009742737, 0.01651001, 0.048828125, 0.020385742, -0.0068855286, -0.0025939941, -0.02848816, 0.04916382, 0.017684937, 0.047668457, -0.017715454, 0.059173584, 0.04260254, -0.009552002, -0.025878906, -0.016677856, -0.018325806, 0.001004219, 0.01461792, -0.006916046, 0.009498596, -0.02355957, 0.013076782, 0.045654297, -0.032836914, -0.009651184, 0.013442993, 0.005760193, 0.0345459, 0.06536865, 0.03387451, 0.028411865, -0.024383545, 0.021331787, 0.057006836, 0.00844574, -0.011459351, -0.005065918, 0.018203735, 0.0035362244, 0.02168274, -0.0018720627, 0.021453857, -0.03173828, 0.0041503906, -0.027297974, -0.002981186, -0.0012025833, -0.0023403168, 0.032043457, -0.010360718, 0.021453857, -0.020339966, -0.0041122437, -0.0077590942, -0.012290955, 0.01739502, 0.019577026, -0.057647705, -0.001461029, 0.026351929, 0.04147339, 0.0031032562, 0.02381897, 0.023864746, 0.00019288063, -0.025619507, 0.0008201599, -0.005771637, 0.047180176, 0.042663574, 0.002105713, 0.019378662, 0.02255249, -0.0013532639, 0.10076904, 0.07757568, -0.041900635, 0.033172607, -0.0054626465, 0.022888184, 0.0020828247, -0.025299072, 0.0071105957, 0.03237915, 0.034454346, 0.0064849854, -0.036590576, 0.036010742, -0.07458496, -0.010185242, -0.012825012, -0.0028057098, -0.07409668, -0.078430176, -0.007659912, -0.05380249, -0.047302246, -0.008415222, 0.08441162, -0.011741638, -0.011810303, 0.008384705, -0.0011367798, -0.032684326, 0.022979736, -0.032104492, 0.030853271, 0.031097412, 0.030136108, 0.0362854, -0.07281494, -0.04650879, -0.009933472, 0.004875183, -0.0041503906, -0.006462097, -0.02104187, 0.015716553, 0.044158936, -0.0001872778, 0.026473999, -0.027053833, -0.0033283234, -0.04244995, 0.027069092, 0.011650085, -0.03955078, 0.0044403076, 0.027954102, -0.027633667, 0.0017318726, 0.0418396, 0.081848145, -0.0132751465, -0.03866577, 0.03250122, 0.03491211, -0.014793396, 0.028518677, 0.030029297, 0.019485474, -0.05331421, -0.029708862, -0.05783081, -0.005458832, -0.013122559, 0.0074424744, 0.05368042, -0.035736084, -0.008987427, -0.038757324, -0.01927185, 0.028060913, -0.0004580021, 0.026977539, -0.019958496, -0.019973755, -0.0006418228, -0.013015747, 0.019821167, -0.040985107, 0.010108948, 0.0758667, -0.005908966, -0.011398315, -0.0014276505, 0.036071777, 0.012588501, 0.008010864, -0.011192322, -0.017242432, 0.014961243, 0.024124146, 0.0065078735, -0.033355713, -0.03451538, -0.11212158, -0.006515503, 0.04748535, -0.0051460266, -0.028427124, 0.02468872, -0.061920166, 0.013755798, -0.00592041, -0.022003174, 0.019454956, 0.05090332, 0.012397766, 0.024551392, 0.013000488, -0.005794525, 0.013130188, -0.030319214, -0.08898926, 0.029205322, -0.0063667297, -0.048919678, -0.024658203, -0.010528564, -0.050964355, -0.009757996, 0.000079631805, 0.022506714, 0.03012085, 0.011444092, 0.023895264, -0.009933472, 0.0030784607, -0.027618408, -0.031951904, -0.012992859, -0.01689148, 0.037261963, 0.021560669, 0.043182373, 0.05355835, -0.015052795, -0.044830322, -0.0074501038, -0.005744934, 0.031051636, -0.0039978027, -0.02041626, -0.010826111, -0.039642334, 0.0027866364, 0.039093018, -0.024887085, -0.0077819824, -0.016326904, 0.013938904, -0.036987305, 0.006855011, 0.01802063, 0.0132751465, -0.016448975, -0.014816284, 0.024383545, -0.03125, -0.03555298, 0.020324707, 0.032318115, 0.01360321, -0.03353882, -0.0025730133, -0.035858154, 0.019454956, 0.00046610832, -0.00016129017, 0.004676819, 0.011207581, -0.0178833, -0.014694214, -0.012878418, 0.018432617, -0.02116394, 0.017913818, -0.013954163, 0.007675171, 0.0047073364, -0.06286621, -0.007865906, 0.0022964478, -0.1005249, -0.018447876, 0.00655365, -0.025863647, -0.018936157, -0.026733398, 0.043701172, -0.028549194, -0.010787964, -0.00017595291, -0.022155762, -0.02178955, -0.009925842, -0.07885742, -0.011192322, 0.095214844, 0.003036499, 0.009033203, 0.032714844, -0.033966064, -0.0395813, -0.0038452148, 0.032714844, 0.023895264, 0.026367188, 0.019897461, -0.02532959, 0.031463623, -0.030181885, 0.025375366, 0.050598145, 0.01889038, 0.010467529, 0.0028533936, -0.0013303757, 0.01108551, -0.022384644, 0.05142212, 0.0068092346, -0.0075950623, -0.081604004, 0.019515991, 0.0038814545, 0.0052986145, 0.021942139, -0.015045166, 0.026733398, 0.02142334, -0.021636963, 0.029830933, -0.011749268, 0.006210327, 0.050323486, -0.0042152405, -0.02015686, -0.012893677, 0.022903442, 0.022644043, -0.004573822, 0.022735596, -0.033691406, 0.014579773, 0.013458252, -0.046966553, 0.0022411346, 0.02494812, -0.060546875, -0.019195557, -0.053741455, -0.034179688, -0.013473511, 0.009742737, -0.023223877, 0.03274536, 0.03982544, -0.023162842, -0.007007599, -0.0049209595, 0.039794922, -0.0036754608, 0.005355835, -0.05581665, -0.0127334595, -0.008766174, -0.066833496, -0.032104492, -0.014724731, -0.002866745, 0.032226562, -0.008094788, -0.018218994, 0.0014772415, 0.033721924, 0.0848999, 0.035858154, 0.00957489, -0.040039062, 0.039520264, -0.033050537, -0.017715454, 0.020736694, 0.0002593994, -0.008033752, -0.0154418945, 0.030395508, -0.038269043, -0.019760132, -0.02470398, 0.027938843, -0.023452759, 0.04840088, -0.0053863525, 0.03729248, 0.01979065, -0.0059814453, 0.0317688, 0.02067566, -0.043151855, -0.019424438, 0.006866455, 0.025985718, -0.035095215, 0.03314209, 0.06463623, -0.0067214966, -0.022827148, 0.0053596497, 0.022460938, 0.029449463, -0.008346558, 0.013038635, 0.009338379, -0.07006836, -0.01914978, 0.0030994415, -0.0154800415, 0.054229736, -0.051086426, 0.040527344, -0.0027751923, -0.00932312, 0.065979004, -0.002483368, 0.0050964355, 0.02949524, 0.011314392, -0.059051514, -0.033477783, 0.0039634705, 0.021011353, -0.028808594, -0.0019302368, 0.008308411, 0.0021038055, 0.017303467, 0.03930664, 0.01461792, -0.008621216, -0.0075187683, -0.028427124, -0.0047340393, -0.011695862, -0.06213379, 0.0032749176, 0.0006942749, 0.025405884, -0.020843506, 0.03277588, -0.08227539, 0.010650635, -0.0076408386, -0.014282227, 0.021896362, -0.089904785, 0.014678955, 0.06762695, 0.013748169, 0.030227661, -0.024276733, 0.018981934, 0.009666443, 0.08459473, -0.010314941, 0.037719727, 0.054260254, -0.035705566, -0.01751709, 0.00015556812, 0.03375244, -0.0104904175, 0.032440186, 0.02243042, 0.013191223, -0.07409668, 0.01499939, 0.025360107, -0.017578125, 0.04034424, -0.056152344, 0.016174316, 0.01802063, -0.013328552, -0.00818634, -0.023880005, -0.02331543, 0.0010881424, -0.032592773, -0.03439331, 0.00083494186, -0.0546875, -0.047027588, -0.040893555, 0.03604126, -0.020217896, -0.0038585663, 0.005420685, -0.010688782, -0.042663574, 0.02053833, 0.013381958, -0.04699707, -0.0035953522, -0.0063056946, 0.014335632, 0.03024292, 0.015357971, -0.04534912, -0.0119018555, -0.018463135, -0.042114258, -0.03086853, 0.0061454773, 0.015686035, 0.00844574, -0.0061683655, 0.0042381287, 0.007144928, 0.0060691833, 0.030517578, 0.012145996, -0.038116455, 0.03768921, -0.00075387955, 0.01914978, 0.011917114, -0.0029773712, -0.022460938, 0.015991211, 0.016418457, -0.02658081, 0.021606445, -0.0060272217, 0.023788452, -0.02619934, -0.03741455, -0.005207062, 0.025848389, 0.010734558, -0.008544922, 0.017181396, 0.036254883, -0.016555786, 0.006126404, 0.012763977, 0.057556152, -0.062683105, -0.022903442, -0.0055732727, -0.0017681122, -0.030136108, 0.03778076, -0.018981934, -0.017715454, -0.040893555, -0.050872803, -0.024307251, 0.022155762, 0.022399902, 0.029846191, 0.029129028, 0.0025520325, 0.07122803, -0.025527954, -0.025390625, -0.03213501, 0.011131287, -0.0011262894, -0.015304565, 0.026794434, -0.024780273, 0.005935669, -0.019821167, 0.024414062, 0.0016479492, -0.022994995, 0.014961243, -0.02861023, 0.015594482, -0.014053345, -0.0473938, 0.029373169, -0.016143799, 0.0070762634, 0.04925537, -0.035949707, 0.05657959, 0.021270752, 0.055664062, 0.053253174, -0.0019102097, 0.0075416565, 0.006614685, -0.0020523071, -0.04257202, 0.016708374, -0.024337769, 0.0046577454, -0.059692383, -0.011489868, -0.093322754, 0.023376465, 0.008102417, 0.041778564, -0.00831604, 0.014228821, 0.013679504, 0.016525269, 0.036224365, -0.026794434, 0.058898926, 0.026901245, 0.030578613, -0.01902771, -0.059509277, 0.03552246, 0.047546387, -0.0038814545, -0.010437012, -0.002922058, -0.028793335, 0.003932953, 0.018814087, 0.017669678, -0.028686523, -0.011878967, -0.040130615, 0.01234436, -0.017669678, 0.036712646, 0.049926758, 0.018692017, -0.0211792, -0.0039482117, -0.0028820038, -0.0340271, -0.030883789, 0.00085401535, 0.011558533, -0.05505371, 0.02053833, -0.004962921, -0.012519836, -0.047454834, 0.01210022, 0.041168213, -0.049865723, -0.049072266, 0.041809082, 0.054504395, -0.000033318996, 0.007537842, -0.04421997, -0.01751709, 0.0069236755, 0.038482666, -0.022140503, 0.00579834, 0.0038909912, 0.017288208, -0.02305603, -0.024841309, 0.015411377, 0.00062561035, -0.00075912476, 0.022491455, -0.036865234, 0.018966675, 0.015106201, -0.022033691, 0.0020389557, 0.018417358, -0.05407715, -0.012336731, 0.036071777, 0.03289795, 0.058410645, 0.07269287, 0.026428223, -0.013877869, 0.012741089, -0.062347412, 0.038909912, 0.040924072, -0.020339966, 0.02709961, -0.030822754, -0.037902832, 0.049713135, -0.03668213, 0.06677246, -0.031341553, -0.010673523, -0.041748047, 0.052642822, 0.013847351, -0.062286377, -0.015975952, -0.026062012, -0.0009050369, -0.009414673, -0.0009584427, -0.024261475, -0.04058838, -0.011398315, 0.048583984, -0.0045433044, 0.0045814514, 0.001660347, -0.02368164, -0.041412354, 0.015792847, -0.041992188, 0.05734253, -0.041412354, 0.0014858246, -0.014274597, 0.020492554, -0.0073623657, -0.04650879, -0.037963867, 0.002729416, -0.00056552887, -0.034179688, 0.008850098, 0.022140503, -0.016357422, -0.016494751, -0.044067383, 0.0116119385, -0.030670166, 0.015686035, 0.04650879, -0.034576416, -0.055145264, 0.0011548996, -0.029464722, 0.05014038, 0.0008659363, -0.010520935, 0.016159058, 0.006767273, -0.020980835, 0.022399902, 0.045196533, 0.06365967, -0.011352539, -0.056640625, 0.024353027, 0.027832031, 0.060546875, -0.041534424, -0.024902344, 0.017822266, 0.019714355, -0.0056037903, 0.01146698, 0.01878357, -0.011383057, 0.008079529, 0.010231018, 0.000102460384, -0.033111572, -0.015220642, -0.003227234, 0.037963867, 0.041992188, 0.001958847, -0.027267456, 0.02420044, -0.022338867, 0.002691269, -0.009857178, 0.0031547546, -0.010261536, -0.008743286, 0.004825592, -0.027023315, -0.015205383, -0.054534912, 0.008216858, 0.010620117, 0.048431396, -0.01675415, 0.018981934, -0.007827759, 0.06677246, -0.054992676, -0.055511475, 0.04257202, 0.04437256, -0.0104599, 0.01977539, -0.03753662, 0.010040283, -0.0050964355, 0.014770508, 0.0036792755, 0.021408081, -0.010223389, 0.00044751167, 0.02835083, -0.050994873, -0.036315918, -0.027954102, -0.01966858, 0.03857422, -0.042816162, 0.009155273, -0.036254883, -0.0087890625, -0.011886597, 0.043060303, 0.025024414, -0.021530151, -0.052337646, -0.039794922, 0.07922363, -0.028320312 ], "summary": [ 0.028884888, 0.0042877197, -0.024368286, -0.022399902, -0.0152282715, -0.024993896, -0.028396606, -0.013244629, -0.018615723, 0.04660034, 0.0050315857, 0.01525116, 0.038238525, -0.023162842, 0.0011548996, -0.016799927, -0.017089844, 0.046844482, -0.010551453, -0.015823364, 0.01763916, -0.012771606, -0.056610107, -0.044128418, -0.0096588135, -0.04852295, 0.0692749, -0.020965576, 0.055633545, 0.026382446, 0.013320923, -0.044708252, -0.008888245, 0.024627686, -0.0001834631, -0.07861328, -0.039093018, 0.03744507, -0.00067329407, 0.0043640137, 0.03781128, -0.013061523, 0.016708374, 0.020080566, -0.013374329, 0.0059280396, 0.026153564, -0.022079468, 0.029556274, 0.052825928, -0.012382507, -0.0030899048, -0.023742676, 0.016738892, -0.010696411, -0.010498047, -0.11376953, 0.038726807, 0.02960205, 0.106933594, 0.035736084, -0.05105591, -0.019302368, -0.08532715, -0.0075912476, 0.0032978058, 0.01878357, -0.0013198853, 0.029266357, -0.006084442, 0.010406494, 0.0013465881, 0.012458801, -0.078430176, -0.03326416, 0.054138184, 0.023971558, 0.0018005371, 0.0023956299, -0.055511475, 0.0076141357, 0.06756592, 0.03842163, -0.058013916, -0.0040512085, -0.07147217, -0.02305603, -0.011650085, -0.005683899, -0.02507019, -0.013000488, 0.00349617, -0.031951904, 0.02999878, 0.006389618, -0.03918457, 0.002023697, 0.0017566681, -0.0035133362, 0.017440796, 0.025344849, -0.038269043, 0.06048584, -0.031311035, 0.006690979, 0.025558472, -0.026016235, -0.0035476685, 0.021835327, 0.026184082, -0.004650116, -0.017929077, 0.010177612, -0.050964355, -0.0062065125, 0.067993164, 0.019638062, 0.033233643, 0.006614685, 0.05810547, -0.00894928, 0.007381439, -0.0036697388, 0.035949707, 0.011985779, 0.026184082, 0.0033130646, -0.006286621, 0.010818481, -0.03857422, -0.003791809, 0.03652954, -0.00078725815, -0.014305115, -0.02986145, 0.009986877, -0.015335083, -0.014884949, -0.02758789, 0.008163452, 0.026000977, -0.021240234, -0.017333984, 0.0010223389, 0.013313293, 0.010925293, 0.025878906, -0.00069618225, -0.008239746, -0.0033607483, -0.014472961, -0.0016651154, 0.053375244, -0.01373291, -0.025909424, -0.054840088, -0.013969421, -0.022079468, -0.0023612976, -0.054840088, 0.044555664, 0.0038223267, -0.031463623, 0.04095459, 0.0027770996, -0.02810669, 0.026489258, 0.009353638, 0.018508911, -0.020523071, 0.020477295, 0.0005941391, 0.04348755, -0.005634308, -0.0033493042, -0.006111145, 0.013946533, 0.012786865, -0.0049438477, 0.010803223, 0.013839722, -0.021957397, 0.0022258759, 0.025299072, -0.03024292, -0.000097990036, -0.004638672, 0.026000977, 0.036468506, 0.0090789795, 0.011955261, 0.0032367706, -0.031555176, 0.0011692047, -0.019424438, 0.022506714, -0.055786133, 0.025863647, -0.031143188, -0.014533997, 0.057403564, 0.027740479, -0.0340271, -0.04095459, -0.081604004, -0.016235352, -0.013900757, 0.030776978, -0.024414062, 0.004360199, 0.022262573, -0.01638794, -0.020996094, 0.04385376, 0.012771606, -0.03237915, 0.04864502, -0.019256592, 0.011039734, 0.0072250366, 0.0028896332, 0.0463562, -0.041290283, 0.025817871, 0.0027980804, -0.023757935, -0.017364502, -0.023803711, 0.030227661, -0.016281128, 0.054016113, 0.019744873, 0.037109375, 0.04888916, -0.0044517517, -0.009086609, 0.000749588, -0.08337402, 0.006439209, 0.053131104, 0.008422852, 0.050445557, -0.06390381, -0.023635864, 0.0019779205, -0.02017212, -0.008224487, -0.004169464, -0.037353516, 0.00491333, 0.022888184, 0.023742676, 0.030822754, -0.024002075, -0.014595032, 0.05621338, -0.017105103, -0.012390137, 0.013305664, -0.03591919, 0.03201294, 0.0055351257, -0.009521484, 0.009735107, 0.0011205673, -0.0062065125, 0.008766174, 0.0022010803, -0.0128479, 0.0070266724, 0.005756378, -0.02973938, 0.012367249, -0.049835205, -0.020065308, -0.02178955, -0.030029297, 0.032989502, 0.041046143, -0.03970337, -0.016723633, 0.010917664, 0.024932861, -0.017669678, 0.02331543, 0.030975342, 0.009536743, -0.037475586, -0.016311646, 0.016433716, 0.03186035, 0.042785645, 0.003545761, 0.0066070557, -0.005382538, 0.005264282, 0.03213501, 0.02822876, -0.02368164, -0.016479492, 0.027679443, 0.024017334, -0.022018433, 0.00096797943, 0.0008625984, 0.020843506, -0.008049011, -0.0014438629, -0.020080566, 0.009376526, -0.054016113, 0.0028209686, 0.030456543, 0.06933594, -0.014434814, -0.03363037, 0.0014982224, 0.051940918, 0.008811951, 0.04208374, 0.09802246, 0.007843018, 0.040893555, 0.008300781, -0.012573242, -0.055236816, 0.054840088, -0.022888184, 0.06542969, -0.025482178, -0.008277893, -0.002840042, -0.044433594, 0.015853882, 0.014694214, -0.0206604, 0.0074501038, 0.005382538, 0.011405945, -0.0016241074, 0.054107666, 0.0064964294, -0.0043296814, 0.027832031, -0.048339844, 0.0095825195, 0.0027217865, -0.0018720627, -0.0028762817, 0.0003399849, 0.030212402, -0.010505676, -0.029663086, 0.05908203, 0.014968872, -0.031433105, 0.029067993, 0.055511475, 0.005180359, -0.0005607605, 0.020614624, 0.03262329, 0.0032482147, -0.03955078, -0.019866943, -0.038848877, -0.0071372986, -0.0049095154, 0.027420044, 0.045074463, 0.017944336, 0.037628174, -0.037109375, -0.03036499, -0.036590576, -0.017868042, 0.10192871, 0.014465332, 0.0040779114, 0.066223145, 0.02861023, 0.036346436, -0.00040531158, 0.017196655, 0.0592041, 0.012863159, 0.02456665, 0.008117676, 0.057617188, 0.00016379356, 0.020889282, -0.011634827, -0.0034675598, -0.011016846, 0.016967773, 0.020187378, -0.028121948, -0.041503906, -0.03604126, -0.018920898, 0.028518677, 0.020599365, -0.009391785, 0.028793335, -0.027664185, 0.022735596, 0.017471313, -0.015052795, 0.0076065063, 0.00016438961, 0.056854248, -0.02494812, 0.052459717, -0.03616333, 0.039367676, -0.04901123, -0.020309448, 0.009613037, -0.032562256, -0.0069847107, 0.003232956, -0.008514404, 0.0009698868, -0.0052223206, 0.01586914, -0.006816864, 0.03213501, -0.0071105957, -0.017715454, 0.032470703, 0.017593384, -0.029312134, -0.021697998, 0.029342651, -0.0069770813, 0.06137085, 0.01309967, -0.038146973, 0.060180664, -0.04699707, -0.02973938, -0.00051403046, -0.007221222, -0.02607727, 0.006046295, -0.020065308, 0.010574341, -0.016403198, 0.012863159, 0.033294678, -0.007675171, -0.020339966, 0.046020508, 0.024795532, -0.019042969, 0.054138184, -0.012802124, 0.02696228, 0.06311035, -0.04067993, -0.016067505, -0.022277832, -0.022994995, 0.019836426, 0.041015625, -0.028381348, 0.04324341, -0.017929077, -0.003686905, 0.0034599304, -0.027389526, -0.010520935, -0.023147583, -0.0026836395, -0.023956299, -0.041748047, 0.030014038, 0.032470703, 0.016952515, -0.037719727, -0.047729492, 0.00818634, -0.0018815994, -0.07293701, -0.04840088, 0.016311646, -0.0769043, -0.03314209, 0.018157959, -0.023071289, -0.027954102, -0.020217896, 0.038909912, -0.013252258, 0.0024147034, 0.01586914, -0.027877808, 0.061828613, 0.00756073, -0.068237305, 0.019592285, -0.00023329258, 0.022216797, 0.010131836, -0.020370483, 0.005332947, 0.007003784, 0.027709961, 0.026535034, -0.025390625, 0.006088257, 0.009895325, -0.0021820068, 0.01524353, -0.0047912598, 0.022567749, -0.0010671616, 0.008918762, -0.008796692, -0.016418457, 0.08050537, 0.06939697, 0.000233531, 0.0056152344, -0.0077285767, 0.024536133, -0.05722046, -0.02507019, 0.014091492, 0.0027770996, 0.008880615, 0.021377563, -0.0154800415, 0.013656616, 0.012252808, -0.039276123, -0.007820129, -0.044677734, 0.008071899, 0.04385376, -0.0135269165, -0.032562256, -0.020584106, 0.051574707, -0.0023784637, 0.035217285, -0.039916992, 0.04763794, -0.060333252, 0.053527832, -0.02923584, -0.028793335, -0.034362793, -0.022888184, -0.029891968, 0.043426514, -0.030349731, 0.013679504, -0.015365601, 0.029663086, 0.028457642, -0.03378296, -0.000310421, 0.0029621124, 0.021835327, 0.017608643, -0.037902832, -0.08947754, -0.012908936, -0.009605408, -0.05340576, -0.01977539, -0.037597656, -0.0345459, 0.008483887, -0.012298584, -0.015342712, 0.015419006, 0.0038967133, 0.02798462, 0.061431885, 0.004650116, -0.06866455, -0.00006967783, -0.023147583, -0.023986816, 0.030685425, -0.013542175, -0.000049173832, 0.011940002, 0.057861328, -0.05908203, -0.031555176, -0.018249512, 0.04940796, 0.018112183, 0.062805176, -0.0446167, -0.003293991, 0.013397217, 0.011489868, 0.017028809, 0.009986877, 0.0038909912, -0.010139465, 0.015007019, 0.009689331, 0.016616821, -0.008781433, 0.03186035, -0.010505676, -0.03060913, 0.035858154, -0.013847351, 0.035888672, 0.055023193, 0.026428223, 0.029953003, -0.0019931793, -0.05255127, 0.0129776, 0.00038647652, -0.00001424551, 0.0158844, -0.018127441, 0.025390625, -0.012359619, 0.08862305, 0.01486969, -0.015701294, 0.08728027, -0.03274536, -0.028015137, -0.00014853477, 0.0073661804, 0.021072388, -0.02432251, -0.036956787, -0.03918457, -0.00014710426, 0.009544373, -0.007293701, -0.051330566, 0.004310608, -0.0059051514, -0.012672424, -0.006549835, -0.00894165, -0.040618896, -0.012649536, -0.030822754, 0.000415802, -0.00642395, 0.016052246, 0.024047852, 0.0005698204, -0.02330017, -0.020889282, 0.0066566467, -0.043304443, -0.061828613, -0.012962341, -0.033233643, 0.0141067505, -0.042022705, 0.027557373, 0.004085541, 0.04333496, -0.004261017, -0.03338623, 0.026535034, 0.0018224716, 0.016998291, -0.02130127, 0.026351929, 0.031082153, 0.01348114, 0.016098022, 0.041656494, -0.055847168, -0.0074043274, -0.03869629, -0.04373169, 0.022262573, -0.0035877228, 0.04626465, 0.016036987, -0.01651001, -0.017303467, -0.0046195984, -0.005306244, 0.03010559, -0.036895752, 0.003993988, 0.011398315, -0.038238525, -0.0034446716, 0.0011615753, -0.0017127991, -0.023544312, 0.021606445, 0.0036621094, -0.002199173, -0.011482239, -0.02658081, 0.03265381, -0.0211792, -0.0065612793, -0.0018291473, 0.017440796, -0.01486969, -0.010772705, -0.055725098, -0.017181396, -0.014762878, -0.025970459, -0.025894165, -0.024795532, -0.004070282, 0.03414917, 0.027053833, 0.012619019, 0.034606934, -0.0018472672, 0.01776123, 0.024154663, -0.008026123, 0.04626465, -0.031707764, -0.052764893, 0.023330688, -0.06561279, -0.033325195, 0.018997192, 0.010520935, -0.024749756, -0.009132385, 0.047668457, 0.019729614, -0.041168213, -0.0103302, -0.015403748, 0.032043457, 0.009178162, -0.04547119, 0.038238525, 0.005996704, -0.021484375, 0.011886597, -0.02810669, 0.024017334, 0.023010254, -0.027252197, -0.039245605, 0.004383087, -0.038269043, 0.036865234, -0.0048294067, -0.027496338, -0.02482605, -0.03274536, 0.0049438477, 0.0038757324, 0.007282257, 0.022613525, 0.03125, 0.0047035217, 0.040039062, 0.011253357, -0.029418945, -0.032684326, 0.01272583, -0.0126571655, -0.03262329, 0.044830322, -0.016479492, -0.022277832, 0.035858154, 0.008003235, 0.0023326874, -0.029464722, 0.04171753, -0.009895325, -0.0043907166, -0.050872803, 0.0069465637, 0.023483276, 0.0625, -0.03112793, 0.047027588, 0.0068092346, 0.048950195, -0.004207611, -0.012138367, 0.020965576, 0.02758789, -0.0017080307, -0.014862061, -0.04159546, -0.014839172, 0.03274536, -0.034088135, -0.042907715, -0.06213379, -0.034240723, -0.017318726, 0.019424438, -0.02947998, 0.042022705, 0.0014762878, 0.026885986, 0.03137207, 0.00491333, -0.037017822, -0.048950195, 0.036865234, -0.0009121895, 0.007358551, 0.019165039, -0.053100586, 0.013847351, 0.019348145, -0.06286621, 0.064086914, 0.018737793, 0.037017822, 0.043640137, -0.076049805, -0.0038833618, -0.11279297, 0.01360321, -0.038513184, 0.0029087067, 0.0030593872, 0.034942627, 0.007297516, -0.03387451, 0.07739258, -0.022079468, -0.0074806213, -0.011367798, -0.0020313263, 0.013557434, 0.015274048, -0.048980713, 0.023391724, 0.030059814, -0.018951416, -0.027923584, 0.025726318, 0.012039185, -0.026977539, -0.004020691, 0.017227173, 0.015586853, 0.0074920654, -0.0118637085, -0.055389404, -0.053649902, -0.0070877075, 0.027938843, -0.048217773, 0.0025520325, 0.048706055, 0.00061941147, -0.00642395, 0.00970459, 0.018218994, 0.0082092285, 0.035736084, 0.024169922, -0.062561035, -0.010932922, 0.01222229, -0.010505676, 0.009025574, 0.011291504, -0.0059547424, 0.021087646, 0.011489868, 0.09063721, 0.099975586, 0.091430664, -0.014663696, 0.033569336, 0.064331055, 0.00075387955, 0.04324341, 0.014350891, 0.0036811829, -0.023468018, -0.023406982, -0.0017538071, 0.00869751, 0.011741638, 0.061157227, 0.021453857, -0.0021038055, -0.041625977, 0.0063056946, 0.02458191, -0.061035156, 0.0026054382, -0.032470703, -0.018493652, -0.006626129, 0.018829346, -0.010795593, -0.06451416, -0.050354004, 0.06384277, -0.053131104, -0.014167786, 0.030960083, 0.005870819, -0.0023517609, -0.023666382, -0.008476257, 0.028305054, -0.014724731, -0.01914978, 0.03793335, 0.009002686, 0.0010385513, -0.08917236, -0.024047852, -0.046539307, 0.059051514, -0.016052246, -0.016555786, 0.003768921, -0.027832031, -0.02861023, -0.023757935, 0.00655365, -0.038208008, 0.06201172, 0.032104492, -0.00008928776, -0.09802246, 0.000056684017, -0.033447266, 0.0335083, -0.03439331, -0.0064201355, 0.02859497, 0.017654419, -0.017089844, 0.016662598, 0.024475098, 0.032928467, -0.0023078918, -0.05029297, 0.014129639, -0.0006737709, 0.03414917, -0.008369446, -0.024276733, 0.027740479, 0.0362854, -0.024108887, -0.064941406, 0.0074157715, -0.007118225, 0.06604004, 0.00093746185, 0.009147644, -0.043151855, 0.032989502, 0.003074646, 0.061035156, 0.039886475, -0.041931152, 0.016494751, 0.015914917, 0.0061035156, -0.044433594, -0.01713562, -0.008430481, -0.07244873, 0.011177063, -0.018707275, -0.032073975, -0.022598267, -0.061676025, -0.01576233, 0.022644043, 0.021499634, -0.020812988, 0.055389404, -0.03665161, 0.014228821, -0.049560547, -0.04031372, 0.024627686, 0.013511658, -0.0034008026, -0.0059051514, 0.021881104, 0.013168335, 0.020812988, 0.017501831, -0.0010328293, 0.04522705, 0.007507324, 0.0027256012, -0.00030183792, -0.06604004, -0.040527344, -0.07342529, -0.026809692, 0.0069389343, -0.04724121, 0.033447266, 0.0061302185, 0.0059432983, 0.014167786, 0.027526855, -0.0015964508, 0.041259766, -0.030410767, -0.06994629, -0.007385254, -0.024169922 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07618v1
Large Language Models' Understanding of Math: Source Criticism and Extrapolation
Roozbeh Yousefzadeh, Xuenan Cao
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, math.HO
It has been suggested that large language models such as GPT-4 have acquired some form of understanding beyond the correlations among the words in text including some understanding of mathematics as well. Here, we perform a critical inquiry into this claim by evaluating the mathematical understanding of the GPT-4 model. Considering that GPT-4's training set is a secret, it is not straightforward to evaluate whether the model's correct answers are based on a mathematical understanding or based on replication of proofs that the model has seen before. We specifically craft mathematical questions which their formal proofs are not readily available on the web, proofs that are more likely not seen by the GPT-4. We see that GPT-4 is unable to solve those problems despite their simplicity. It is hard to find scientific evidence suggesting that GPT-4 has acquired an understanding of even basic mathematical concepts. A straightforward way to find failure modes of GPT-4 in theorem proving is to craft questions where their formal proofs are not available on the web. Our finding suggests that GPT-4's ability is to reproduce, rephrase, and polish the mathematical proofs that it has seen before, and not in grasping mathematical concepts. We also see that GPT-4's ability to prove mathematical theorems is continuously expanding over time despite the claim that it is a fixed model. We suggest that the task of proving mathematical theorems in formal language is comparable to the methods used in search engines such as Google while predicting the next word in a sentence may be a misguided approach, a recipe that often leads to excessive extrapolation and eventual failures. Prompting the GPT-4 over and over may benefit the GPT-4 and the OpenAI, but we question whether it is valuable for machine learning or for theorem proving.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07618v1
2023-11-12T07:52:32
2023-11-12T07:52:32
{ "title": [ -0.04434204, -0.013420105, -0.012954712, -0.024520874, -0.028137207, -0.009292603, -0.02848816, -0.00868988, -0.015335083, 0.019104004, -0.04284668, 0.0010480881, -0.0025939941, -0.01499176, -0.025680542, -0.015335083, -0.0146865845, 0.032043457, -0.011627197, -0.033813477, 0.0058403015, -0.035705566, 0.034179688, 0.011360168, 0.038024902, -0.050994873, -0.05117798, 0.0137786865, -0.031585693, -0.026519775, -0.0024051666, 0.008796692, 0.050201416, 0.016952515, -0.02709961, -0.012451172, -0.054351807, 0.01789856, -0.018081665, 0.009475708, 0.008346558, -0.01033783, 0.0051574707, 0.019424438, -0.050201416, 0.049591064, -0.08062744, -0.017471313, -0.013000488, 0.032592773, -0.00019001961, 0.047912598, -0.015022278, 0.029067993, 0.020599365, -0.02897644, -0.023117065, 0.02267456, 0.024536133, 0.046722412, 0.011161804, -0.001830101, -0.0012559891, -0.007091522, -0.037231445, -0.015213013, -0.033233643, 0.008682251, 0.06088257, -0.007843018, -0.019821167, 0.018798828, 0.015403748, -0.008865356, -0.035980225, -0.00041413307, 0.053741455, 0.008224487, 0.029266357, -0.028640747, 0.03201294, 0.013320923, 0.025054932, -0.012207031, 0.01663208, -0.01625061, -0.016143799, -0.024887085, -0.035125732, -0.08935547, -0.011383057, -0.00762558, -0.05029297, -0.019348145, -0.013473511, -0.054534912, -0.0073013306, 0.025131226, -0.0013618469, -0.040100098, -0.042541504, 0.030136108, -0.08673096, -0.005393982, 0.010467529, 0.020095825, -0.011375427, -0.018707275, 0.016479492, 0.029693604, -0.020370483, 0.022323608, 0.010116577, -0.022033691, 0.00085020065, 0.01058197, -0.016815186, 0.026321411, 0.030776978, 0.036621094, 0.0026512146, -0.025558472, 0.022262573, 0.04034424, 0.04916382, 0.033294678, -0.041168213, 0.0011825562, 0.005012512, 0.04067993, 0.019577026, 0.031341553, -0.12060547, -0.07965088, -0.07495117, 0.044891357, 0.0026435852, -0.0039138794, -0.031051636, 0.03967285, -0.00894928, -0.02607727, 0.03527832, -0.016906738, -0.024093628, 0.013320923, 0.055908203, -0.00667572, -0.057800293, -0.06756592, -0.0072517395, -0.0012044907, 0.021484375, -0.0067634583, -0.0637207, -0.004383087, -0.12817383, 0.022247314, -0.008277893, 0.025665283, -0.007194519, 0.001909256, -0.012893677, -0.024169922, -0.028427124, 0.004863739, 0.032043457, 0.004070282, 0.007133484, 0.008277893, -0.008468628, 0.0045776367, -0.013336182, 0.00242424, 0.011268616, 0.011497498, 0.0026512146, 0.008407593, -0.0004491806, 0.015960693, 0.022232056, -0.015258789, -0.018463135, 0.052581787, -0.032470703, -0.07086182, -0.0062942505, -0.028533936, 0.06011963, 0.009712219, -0.04006958, 0.007827759, -0.041748047, -0.024398804, -0.037597656, -0.015319824, 0.03250122, 0.016448975, 0.00021338463, 0.007820129, -0.039001465, 0.022033691, -0.025802612, 0.0048446655, -0.035888672, -0.016586304, -0.011688232, 0.03564453, -0.013412476, 0.066101074, 0.059661865, 0.048217773, -0.07733154, 0.062438965, 0.0035266876, -0.07122803, 0.02861023, -0.00091791153, -0.01828003, -0.027236938, -0.017944336, -0.01600647, 0.0076522827, 0.050842285, -0.029571533, 0.0099487305, -0.0034503937, -0.0088272095, -0.0033950806, 0.020324707, 0.06439209, -0.0357666, 0.03237915, 0.029876709, -0.0023651123, -0.03074646, -0.013938904, -0.033966064, 0.015991211, 0.016616821, -0.0008969307, -0.030899048, -0.00945282, 0.018569946, 0.012413025, -0.0024471283, 0.025314331, -0.0074272156, 0.02659607, 0.042297363, 0.05078125, 0.028045654, 0.028915405, -0.007259369, 0.011642456, 0.05706787, 0.007850647, -0.018218994, -0.0069847107, 0.0095825195, 0.035247803, 0.012420654, -0.044555664, 0.024551392, -0.0670166, 0.011741638, -0.039093018, -0.0074005127, 0.017333984, -0.012306213, 0.018737793, -0.030181885, 0.0021305084, -0.036468506, -0.02784729, -0.015319824, -0.021209717, 0.04562378, 0.01914978, -0.07476807, 0.010620117, 0.013679504, 0.04385376, -0.00070858, 0.02835083, -0.027786255, 0.0047035217, -0.0071640015, -0.015266418, -0.007583618, 0.045318604, 0.0287323, 0.02255249, -0.011352539, -0.0022602081, -0.013687134, 0.08959961, 0.054656982, -0.027023315, 0.012329102, -0.017196655, 0.030776978, 0.0044822693, -0.0063819885, 0.009101868, 0.013214111, 0.036254883, 0.0054626465, -0.045654297, 0.019958496, -0.07470703, -0.03010559, 0.0046577454, -0.00680542, -0.03552246, -0.036499023, -0.0011987686, -0.029769897, -0.056243896, -0.03010559, 0.0541687, -0.008651733, -0.008071899, -0.00869751, 0.0019550323, -0.020706177, -0.023025513, -0.035461426, 0.014526367, 0.0037784576, 0.014732361, -0.004486084, -0.06567383, -0.03604126, -0.00010025501, 0.0074806213, -0.0077171326, -0.032989502, -0.048797607, 0.01902771, -0.012084961, -0.011711121, 0.031143188, -0.06011963, -0.002166748, -0.054718018, -0.0057373047, 0.012969971, 0.0021877289, -0.017120361, 0.019226074, -0.00573349, -0.015609741, 0.019302368, 0.060943604, -0.023788452, -0.030395508, 0.026046753, 0.0017938614, -0.025405884, 0.019058228, 0.03173828, 0.0076828003, -0.017822266, -0.021896362, -0.05331421, -0.023803711, 0.0053138733, -0.0030994415, 0.016555786, -0.03918457, -0.029785156, -0.018661499, -0.010650635, 0.02986145, -0.002128601, 0.016281128, -0.03945923, -0.0047569275, 0.0034427643, -0.030075073, 0.021224976, -0.028045654, 0.06304932, 0.091918945, 0.011390686, 0.027633667, 0.017745972, 0.04901123, -0.0043907166, -0.014335632, -0.017654419, -0.0019760132, -0.013381958, 0.006538391, 0.0023498535, -0.040618896, -0.026062012, -0.04800415, 0.019378662, 0.087768555, -0.010513306, -0.029663086, 0.06384277, -0.091552734, 0.07977295, -0.0001667738, 0.0069084167, 0.028640747, 0.0059509277, 0.008132935, -0.004512787, -0.007083893, -0.041259766, 0.006565094, -0.02923584, -0.11364746, 0.028182983, -0.021820068, -0.011230469, -0.00017297268, -0.029205322, -0.03793335, -0.0033626556, -0.027175903, 0.03414917, 0.01940918, 0.02229309, 0.019500732, -0.014953613, -0.0134887695, -0.020629883, -0.018600464, 0.015510559, -0.0070381165, 0.080078125, 0.0046844482, 0.045013428, 0.02357483, -0.014411926, -0.009056091, -0.016204834, -0.047424316, 0.019088745, -0.023391724, -0.023666382, -0.0035762787, -0.0016489029, 0.0071525574, 0.02229309, -0.006591797, 0.0028572083, -0.03466797, 0.0023822784, -0.04055786, -0.016601562, 0.013145447, -0.0005469322, -0.045532227, 0.0021533966, 0.0068969727, -0.010765076, -0.03213501, -0.019210815, 0.042907715, -0.012748718, -0.00020325184, 0.0023899078, -0.028717041, 0.021972656, 0.019699097, -0.023971558, 0.006099701, -0.0070114136, 0.001783371, 0.024490356, -0.025360107, -0.015853882, -0.00042557716, 0.026748657, -0.022232056, 0.027450562, -0.014221191, -0.089416504, -0.043701172, 0.00077199936, -0.09875488, -0.026992798, 0.01197052, -0.01675415, -0.019714355, -0.04727173, 0.016204834, -0.010070801, -0.040527344, 0.031311035, -0.020309448, 0.022262573, 0.022720337, -0.08312988, 0.010513306, 0.068115234, -0.012321472, -0.005935669, 0.026550293, 0.001707077, 0.0012025833, -0.03753662, 0.038024902, 0.034210205, 0.0064315796, 0.0037822723, -0.044830322, 0.018341064, -0.031433105, 0.025024414, 0.020950317, -0.03704834, 0.015914917, 0.02810669, -0.016555786, 0.004573822, -0.024459839, 0.042785645, 0.03112793, -0.000992775, -0.07489014, 0.05355835, -0.010536194, -0.01789856, 0.01789856, -0.00894928, 0.03390503, 0.0284729, 0.0022773743, 0.052734375, -0.002046585, -0.019302368, 0.020355225, 0.02520752, -0.022445679, -0.013458252, 0.013633728, 0.034423828, 0.0034427643, 0.03640747, -0.0051345825, 0.049926758, -0.021942139, -0.006591797, 0.0046844482, 0.018203735, -0.014892578, 0.02180481, -0.05407715, -0.062805176, -0.05795288, 0.019363403, 0.011505127, 0.062683105, 0.046661377, 0.047088623, -0.03466797, -0.041503906, 0.02848816, 0.00027751923, -0.02470398, -0.076171875, 0.0053100586, -0.014808655, -0.06311035, -0.050109863, -0.01550293, 0.009536743, 0.026168823, 0.01335144, -0.015701294, 0.01763916, 0.010406494, 0.025680542, 0.04260254, -0.0024051666, -0.038208008, 0.0552063, -0.037994385, -0.014381409, 0.023284912, 0.0049209595, -0.02041626, -0.041046143, -0.011413574, 0.00079345703, 0.011482239, -0.030700684, 0.022705078, -0.015975952, 0.03062439, -0.053771973, -0.02305603, 0.008987427, -0.011932373, 0.018661499, 0.0030727386, -0.040740967, 0.008544922, 0.007095337, 0.041625977, -0.033966064, 0.017593384, 0.046905518, 0.029693604, 0.011329651, -0.0012025833, -0.00086402893, 0.02545166, -0.004940033, 0.01222229, 0.004940033, -0.04837036, -0.021057129, 0.013496399, 0.0069389343, 0.052642822, -0.02835083, 0.023162842, -0.025238037, 0.012779236, -0.011878967, -0.018417358, 0.039154053, -0.014663696, 0.034362793, -0.05026245, -0.044006348, 0.007205963, 0.038970947, -0.03717041, 0.011047363, -0.0016746521, 0.0069770813, 0.022354126, 0.05596924, 0.049926758, -0.02003479, 0.031585693, -0.008323669, 0.0037288666, 0.0024681091, -0.040222168, 0.007835388, -0.000030338764, 0.014442444, -0.042022705, 0.007659912, -0.047851562, -0.014427185, -0.05493164, -0.043518066, 0.05102539, -0.080444336, -0.0049552917, 0.09008789, -0.002735138, 0.052703857, 0.018203735, 0.0014514923, 0.017669678, 0.060028076, -0.011360168, 0.028656006, 0.044921875, -0.056671143, 0.025726318, 0.006980896, 0.024795532, 0.013793945, 0.030639648, 0.0055656433, 0.030517578, -0.04345703, 0.014213562, -0.0043144226, -0.040924072, 0.018463135, -0.03918457, 0.025894165, 0.0074005127, -0.0045204163, 0.0138549805, -0.042266846, 0.0058555603, 0.027252197, -0.016403198, 0.01361084, 0.030960083, -0.0024280548, -0.02229309, -0.053985596, 0.019256592, -0.034729004, 0.0041923523, 0.014160156, -0.0057411194, -0.03213501, 0.025039673, 0.033325195, -0.038238525, 0.005680084, -0.033203125, -0.009155273, 0.032348633, 0.050689697, -0.039794922, -0.009895325, -0.009284973, -0.04257202, -0.031463623, 0.026031494, 0.006664276, 0.006679535, -0.009262085, -0.017501831, 0.007419586, 0.016311646, 0.038269043, -0.013580322, -0.009963989, 0.0178833, 0.0016365051, 0.009590149, 0.023330688, -0.0028514862, 0.00793457, 0.020935059, 0.009963989, -0.049346924, 0.009979248, 0.0058937073, 0.009536743, -0.023269653, -0.04611206, 0.00001347065, 0.022628784, -0.005531311, -0.010597229, 0.023147583, 0.02633667, 0.04663086, -0.016799927, 0.0016851425, 0.04525757, -0.02508545, -0.019226074, -0.006958008, -0.0009469986, -0.012275696, 0.07067871, -0.010269165, -0.010314941, -0.04147339, -0.039154053, -0.03048706, 0.0039482117, 0.015159607, -0.0069236755, 0.0087890625, -0.007904053, 0.019638062, -0.07873535, -0.018936157, -0.04562378, 0.033447266, -0.031311035, -0.061950684, 0.024169922, -0.03201294, -0.028457642, -0.024459839, 0.033721924, 0.0637207, 0.017852783, 0.030593872, -0.03656006, -0.02911377, -0.034820557, -0.017868042, 0.017562866, 0.02268982, -0.031433105, 0.030380249, -0.022094727, 0.062408447, 0.023086548, 0.057922363, 0.022857666, 0.0021247864, 0.014007568, 0.008033752, 0.0050811768, -0.033996582, 0.011550903, -0.048339844, -0.011566162, -0.067993164, -0.012077332, -0.064453125, -0.014717102, 0.0014286041, 0.023651123, 0.029342651, 0.0037651062, 0.012275696, -0.00084877014, 0.03640747, 0.027130127, 0.05621338, 0.00019264221, 0.011657715, 0.001329422, -0.03704834, 0.011138916, 0.037353516, -0.0088272095, 0.0031108856, -0.029129028, -0.027511597, 0.011703491, -0.0013065338, 0.0062408447, -0.03152466, -0.020599365, -0.036193848, 0.04269409, -0.0057411194, 0.024902344, 0.07727051, 0.02180481, -0.013694763, -0.019577026, 0.006275177, -0.01878357, -0.017929077, -0.016525269, 0.019897461, -0.04800415, 0.0095825195, -0.005886078, -0.014381409, -0.0077667236, 0.05230713, 0.0231781, -0.03845215, -0.009498596, 0.0062179565, 0.030410767, 0.020828247, 0.032806396, -0.028884888, -0.030578613, 0.0003786087, 0.025314331, 0.0013008118, 0.05307007, 0.016342163, 0.02381897, -0.021835327, -0.02494812, 0.013168335, -0.0032081604, -0.012161255, 0.03656006, -0.02243042, 0.028198242, 0.014579773, -0.02607727, -0.007843018, 0.02178955, -0.04220581, 0.0015907288, 0.020050049, 0.043792725, 0.054382324, 0.08288574, 0.02293396, 0.00015640259, 0.01033783, -0.037139893, 0.02746582, 0.03918457, -0.0077400208, 0.03111267, -0.048980713, -0.057861328, 0.050598145, -0.033843994, 0.105651855, -0.0440979, 0.010650635, -0.049194336, 0.052215576, -0.00021874905, -0.06677246, -0.021713257, -0.00006490946, -0.044281006, 0.010948181, 0.00422287, -0.018829346, -0.019363403, -0.010604858, 0.0041160583, 0.0026855469, 0.032318115, 0.035308838, -0.047088623, -0.045440674, 0.031234741, 0.0006804466, 0.06945801, -0.028289795, -0.0044403076, -0.011459351, 0.019119263, -0.009712219, -0.016189575, -0.033050537, 0.029403687, -0.00548172, -0.028549194, -0.00014185905, -0.0056152344, -0.014160156, -0.020202637, -0.05340576, 0.001871109, -0.03375244, 0.00063467026, 0.028747559, -0.0368042, -0.015213013, 0.0012168884, -0.02520752, 0.037597656, 0.019226074, -0.008987427, 0.0047187805, 0.012428284, -0.057373047, -0.04043579, 0.0005226135, 0.033294678, 0.02281189, -0.0446167, -0.0023937225, 0.032104492, 0.049865723, -0.03994751, -0.027526855, 0.040893555, 0.008323669, 0.00046896935, 0.013221741, 0.0098724365, -0.02142334, -0.001039505, -0.014793396, -0.010124207, -0.008979797, 0.02670288, 0.017730713, 0.04373169, 0.059783936, -0.015701294, 0.029190063, 0.0076560974, -0.01537323, 0.00983429, 0.016555786, 0.0035438538, 0.020004272, -0.0118255615, 0.013023376, -0.040222168, -0.019821167, -0.03643799, -0.021820068, 0.009117126, 0.018478394, -0.00894165, 0.017791748, -0.031173706, 0.06878662, -0.02027893, -0.08135986, 0.060302734, 0.060180664, -0.0032310486, 0.023040771, -0.0146484375, -0.026367188, -0.0072631836, 0.005844116, 0.000113368034, -0.0019893646, 0.014442444, -0.015808105, 0.018737793, -0.02355957, -0.030670166, -0.02217102, -0.040893555, 0.054534912, -0.040863037, 0.00233078, -0.034606934, -0.030227661, 0.006378174, 0.03164673, -0.003545761, -0.009178162, -0.05987549, -0.013748169, 0.023422241, -0.023803711 ], "summary": [ 0.028549194, 0.0062408447, 0.03475952, 0.02545166, -0.03024292, -0.015731812, 0.021026611, -0.055114746, 0.008514404, -0.002603531, -0.040496826, -0.01737976, -0.00242424, -0.011421204, 0.0042648315, -0.047424316, 0.003856659, 0.039611816, 0.040985107, -0.023254395, 0.008003235, -0.011260986, 0.016098022, -0.023330688, -0.018463135, -0.009918213, 0.021102905, -0.000582695, 0.019973755, 0.00907135, 0.0026988983, -0.01878357, 0.021530151, 0.033203125, -0.027053833, -0.020217896, -0.013244629, 0.020095825, -0.007282257, 0.020492554, -0.003648758, 0.01247406, 0.023147583, -0.008369446, -0.035461426, 0.014984131, -0.032440186, -0.026626587, 0.019332886, 0.07977295, -0.0036125183, 0.012260437, -0.034484863, 0.058441162, -0.0008201599, -0.025100708, 0.01525116, -0.05718994, 0.0146484375, 0.032409668, 0.011070251, 0.010543823, 0.0098724365, -0.025344849, -0.028564453, -0.023162842, -0.019989014, -0.017150879, 0.021148682, -0.0057640076, 0.024597168, 0.009437561, 0.012588501, -0.007446289, -0.016433716, -0.027114868, 0.03994751, -0.020217896, -0.0104599, -0.005554199, 0.048431396, 0.05407715, -0.010627747, 0.0027694702, 0.0075950623, -0.00071430206, -0.015853882, -0.03540039, -0.0057792664, -0.05908203, -0.007648468, -0.03616333, -0.03111267, 0.002653122, 0.0025157928, -0.076049805, -0.016464233, -0.048614502, -0.01902771, -0.051116943, 0.044647217, -0.044769287, 0.009315491, 0.010215759, -0.029937744, -0.0029830933, 0.031707764, -0.033813477, -0.02027893, 0.01902771, -0.04043579, -0.023757935, 0.017913818, -0.06329346, -0.011451721, 0.054840088, 0.035247803, 0.011581421, 0.03262329, 0.029129028, -0.003484726, 0.02027893, -0.010253906, 0.016571045, 0.030166626, 0.028961182, -0.0018596649, 0.0007195473, 0.039031982, -0.006729126, 0.008399963, 0.05795288, -0.07702637, -0.08203125, -0.10253906, 0.019973755, 0.024551392, -0.01007843, -0.00004643202, -0.0067825317, 0.01083374, -0.03164673, 0.002729416, 0.009376526, -0.033172607, 0.043701172, 0.04397583, -0.0115356445, -0.055786133, -0.07128906, 0.0079422, -0.010772705, 0.0049705505, -0.012420654, -0.017456055, -0.02960205, -0.06573486, 0.011077881, 0.029144287, 0.025558472, 0.03173828, -0.006778717, -0.01576233, 0.0107421875, -0.033172607, 0.002817154, -0.023590088, -0.0064353943, 0.011703491, -0.031341553, 0.029037476, 0.04788208, -0.010131836, -0.018325806, 0.019744873, -0.035217285, -0.004524231, -0.018356323, -0.005683899, 0.032165527, 0.033233643, -0.00983429, -0.041168213, 0.051696777, 0.0054130554, -0.0078086853, -0.012390137, 0.0048294067, 0.042236328, -0.004676819, -0.06347656, -0.012023926, -0.03616333, 0.027740479, 0.035980225, 0.015686035, -0.016296387, 0.014976501, 0.013122559, -0.06518555, 0.038330078, 0.010673523, -0.011222839, -0.055236816, -0.10168457, 0.031951904, -0.025756836, 0.062286377, -0.048706055, 0.030136108, 0.045806885, -0.02760315, -0.058258057, 0.1038208, 0.03652954, -0.055725098, 0.025939941, 0.018981934, -0.008522034, 0.0018205643, -0.01335144, 0.033233643, -0.032165527, 0.00283432, -0.0602417, 0.015602112, -0.02067566, 0.020568848, -0.042907715, 0.037322998, 0.024047852, -0.03604126, 0.01927185, 0.05731201, 0.0056877136, -0.02507019, 0.014053345, -0.08081055, 0.034454346, 0.02885437, 0.022918701, -0.00085401535, -0.047546387, -0.051879883, 0.015686035, 0.0064048767, 0.029724121, -0.044158936, -0.010414124, 0.03387451, 0.04562378, 0.01838684, -0.005241394, 0.00022339821, -0.008239746, 0.03353882, 0.037200928, 0.026779175, -0.017654419, 0.020401001, -0.000040769577, 0.052246094, -0.011871338, 0.008956909, -0.004840851, -0.036590576, -0.016815186, -0.021881104, 0.0041046143, -0.029144287, 0.013366699, -0.043701172, -0.027038574, -0.05529785, -0.0026855469, -0.039001465, -0.04095459, 0.051208496, 0.016281128, -0.055725098, 0.012199402, 0.012680054, 0.0010242462, -0.0068244934, 0.021499634, 0.034118652, 0.009925842, 0.01675415, 0.0074272156, 0.0770874, 0.051513672, 0.047943115, 0.027069092, 0.01927185, -0.039276123, 0.024673462, -0.012046814, 0.025115967, 0.007888794, -0.019088745, -0.0030841827, 0.036315918, -0.02861023, 0.019607544, -0.001912117, 0.04562378, 0.022415161, -0.025100708, -0.02708435, 0.019866943, -0.091796875, -0.042510986, 0.030761719, 0.10736084, -0.036590576, -0.040802002, 0.010177612, 0.06738281, 0.0045547485, 0.0015916824, 0.055755615, 0.022613525, -0.0059127808, 0.03765869, 0.010009766, -0.02961731, 0.052001953, -0.016342163, -0.0029735565, -0.016494751, -0.049987793, -0.04156494, -0.08013916, -0.0056037903, 0.0031642914, 0.04336548, 0.004512787, 0.0046157837, -0.032684326, 0.003528595, -0.00033593178, -0.01524353, -0.0044136047, -0.03930664, -0.044708252, 0.004421234, 0.0019550323, -0.002538681, -0.004753113, -0.007457733, 0.0032749176, -0.015312195, 0.008049011, 0.022918701, 0.048461914, -0.00018668175, -0.026916504, 0.043762207, 0.025665283, -0.03552246, 0.025939941, 0.041809082, 0.022155762, -0.032104492, -0.03591919, -0.04824829, -0.0077209473, 0.014038086, 0.04373169, 0.027999878, -0.020355225, 0.026992798, -0.017745972, -0.00086069107, 0.042297363, -0.009552002, 0.093444824, -0.01322937, 0.005722046, 0.05078125, 0.020858765, 0.05102539, -0.050598145, 0.05480957, 0.040008545, 0.00806427, -0.023590088, 0.018112183, 0.0074424744, -0.005004883, -0.031082153, -0.0151901245, 0.038208008, -0.03314209, -0.0072898865, 0.0008087158, 0.0013055801, -0.009651184, 0.013206482, -0.021331787, 0.10308838, -0.00024294853, -0.0017852783, 0.055847168, -0.044128418, 0.0715332, 0.04385376, 0.016815186, 0.017745972, -0.05340576, 0.038085938, -0.017425537, 0.0056419373, -0.026824951, -0.0057525635, -0.060821533, 0.0052871704, -0.003112793, 0.035064697, -0.018630981, -0.039794922, 0.0340271, -0.017196655, 0.013114929, -0.017059326, -0.014915466, 0.014160156, 0.035888672, -0.017837524, 0.037200928, -0.007709503, -0.0067329407, -0.024246216, 0.046783447, -0.021850586, 0.09161377, 0.03302002, 0.0053634644, 0.074035645, -0.051361084, 0.022521973, -0.013511658, -0.072143555, 0.009933472, -0.016693115, -0.021392822, -0.003932953, -0.02406311, -0.004924774, 0.0044517517, -0.016174316, 0.012359619, -0.011161804, 0.026565552, -0.002040863, 0.013137817, -0.0062408447, 0.014274597, 0.028396606, -0.021469116, -0.011650085, -0.010765076, -0.029220581, -0.0037384033, 0.039276123, -0.0021247864, -0.042877197, 0.014076233, -0.021392822, 0.018432617, 0.035827637, -0.016937256, -0.000051379204, -0.0056495667, 0.00019156933, -0.019042969, 0.019104004, 0.009544373, 0.0020580292, -0.022476196, -0.053344727, 0.024429321, -0.021560669, -0.06384277, -0.05722046, 0.019485474, -0.05596924, -0.02482605, -0.016494751, -0.0031929016, 0.0061950684, -0.01852417, 0.028015137, -0.018859863, -0.021697998, -0.005050659, -0.022644043, 0.07421875, 0.00554657, -0.047088623, 0.010902405, -0.006958008, 0.016433716, 0.00592041, 0.013175964, 0.033966064, 0.01713562, 0.011856079, 0.0015554428, -0.0060157776, 0.021438599, -0.031021118, -0.02746582, 0.008674622, -0.026824951, 0.016937256, -0.004623413, -0.010246277, -0.0053596497, 0.0071144104, -0.0023498535, -0.002357483, -0.0048294067, 0.0014419556, 0.034973145, 0.03765869, -0.059387207, 0.07287598, 0.0021190643, -0.058013916, 0.009277344, -0.010353088, -0.037078857, 0.052703857, 0.036102295, 0.05871582, -0.02722168, -0.047546387, 0.018554688, 0.053222656, -0.033966064, -0.03213501, -0.0021457672, 0.09094238, -0.015136719, 0.037078857, 0.008956909, 0.06378174, -0.06347656, 0.010673523, 0.011917114, 0.03466797, -0.045837402, -0.028747559, -0.035583496, 0.033416748, -0.016220093, 0.021896362, -0.0134887695, -0.004535675, -0.0012369156, -0.024642944, 0.0037021637, 0.0059165955, 0.009544373, 0.028167725, -0.038726807, -0.07867432, 0.010292053, -0.017562866, -0.053771973, -0.029037476, -0.046020508, -0.014709473, -0.01361084, 0.0019168854, 0.0047035217, 0.035491943, -0.020370483, -0.0107040405, 0.007537842, 0.0041770935, -0.015853882, 0.06311035, -0.009101868, -0.006652832, 0.020141602, -0.023925781, -0.002243042, -0.007949829, 0.037750244, -0.0050201416, 0.016464233, -0.053497314, 0.00018548965, -0.01071167, 0.022201538, -0.02734375, -0.04547119, 0.0012197495, 0.007434845, 0.008773804, 0.008216858, 0.004386902, -0.026306152, 0.016464233, -0.014556885, 0.051818848, 0.0019359589, 0.05947876, -0.0024738312, 0.000092327595, -0.017929077, -0.004825592, -0.002439499, 0.014656067, 0.028305054, -0.023910522, -0.030563354, -0.00028538704, 0.035003662, 0.0012950897, 0.036743164, 0.04019165, -0.01159668, -0.031219482, -0.006690979, 0.004573822, -0.010002136, -0.00472641, 0.015167236, -0.010971069, -0.04840088, -0.056427002, -0.0109939575, 0.052124023, -0.011413574, -0.011940002, -0.026535034, -0.051818848, 0.02583313, 0.010627747, 0.03186035, -0.04446411, 0.015594482, -0.02229309, 0.018966675, 0.0038414001, -0.012893677, -0.00932312, -0.00079870224, 0.006542206, -0.040802002, -0.017044067, 0.03665161, -0.031951904, -0.037628174, -0.03149414, 0.047332764, -0.03930664, -0.032806396, 0.051239014, -0.021881104, 0.02432251, -0.0234375, -0.007987976, -0.028244019, 0.023040771, -0.047668457, 0.0065193176, 0.0018358231, -0.030151367, 0.021881104, 0.006767273, 0.039367676, 0.010513306, -0.0056037903, 0.015655518, 0.003276825, -0.016708374, -0.005908966, -0.052703857, -0.02696228, 0.036987305, -0.02659607, 0.007797241, 0.006313324, 0.025543213, -0.016342163, -0.011146545, -0.0002708435, 0.06756592, -0.019119263, 0.066833496, 0.022079468, -0.0020771027, 0.014549255, 0.016021729, 0.029266357, -0.06488037, 0.0012369156, 0.033813477, -0.008743286, 0.026504517, -0.004924774, -0.026428223, -0.05114746, 0.0028362274, 0.026504517, 0.022125244, -0.006046295, -0.007835388, 0.0056762695, 0.0031585693, -0.05783081, -0.033325195, -0.06185913, -0.007865906, -0.009025574, 0.07574463, 0.017974854, 0.0025920868, 0.015045166, -0.0053634644, 0.026473999, -0.02748108, -0.0027999878, 0.03253174, -0.02003479, -0.013877869, 0.010971069, -0.049957275, -0.013145447, -0.0032024384, 0.010246277, -0.07336426, -0.035308838, 0.029449463, -0.0007843971, -0.029251099, 0.024856567, -0.04260254, 0.03125, -0.0143585205, 0.012512207, -0.02532959, 0.0075683594, 0.041809082, -0.0107421875, 0.0026187897, 0.057128906, -0.013084412, 0.033599854, -0.03363037, -0.011314392, -0.04940796, 0.032989502, -0.013916016, 0.027145386, -0.03857422, -0.029586792, 0.005630493, -0.014251709, -0.016159058, 0.004058838, 0.002380371, 0.020217896, 0.014373779, -0.035125732, -0.015548706, -0.0070724487, -0.0010471344, -0.02708435, -0.072021484, 0.075927734, 0.008361816, -0.0769043, 0.033355713, -0.00009572506, 0.070739746, 0.03466797, 0.060546875, 0.0026016235, -0.03552246, -0.018341064, 0.035827637, 0.02999878, 0.018432617, -0.011253357, -0.008605957, 0.014556885, 0.032043457, 0.016845703, -0.0129470825, -0.042999268, -0.011192322, 0.04724121, 0.006351471, 0.023773193, 0.0065193176, 0.004070282, -0.0006723404, -0.029891968, -0.02357483, -0.03164673, -0.0015592575, 0.031219482, -0.025863647, -0.009170532, 0.07788086, 0.0006508827, 0.032104492, 0.029541016, -0.026626587, 0.020095825, 0.01322937, 0.0063819885, -0.010253906, -0.00024223328, -0.049804688, -0.000004172325, 0.043548584, 0.0006403923, 0.006137848, -0.009353638, 0.0057029724, 0.051361084, -0.07305908, -0.016174316, -0.085876465, 0.00023412704, -0.051513672, -0.0020484924, 0.002653122, 0.011238098, 0.013900757, 0.008514404, 0.04345703, -0.015701294, -0.0014820099, 0.008743286, 0.0073280334, -0.02407837, -0.013122559, 0.020568848, -0.027450562, -0.004020691, -0.007232666, -0.0042915344, 0.027709961, 0.033477783, -0.01461792, 0.0021038055, -0.0014104843, 0.020202637, 0.004928589, 0.017089844, -0.027938843, -0.024993896, 0.008354187, -0.0077209473, 0.01474762, 0.022125244, 0.025268555, 0.037750244, -0.024993896, 0.021057129, 0.013450623, -0.010185242, 0.012794495, 0.02355957, -0.05722046, 0.01965332, 0.015350342, -0.008682251, 0.021072388, 0.015037537, 0.011581421, 0.011856079, 0.027496338, 0.058898926, 0.043701172, 0.035705566, -0.045318604, 0.013694763, 0.065979004, 0.0075645447, 0.024993896, 0.0029659271, 0.011878967, -0.0101623535, -0.035308838, -0.0020198822, 0.013534546, 0.026687622, 0.069885254, -0.013587952, 0.03656006, -0.026367188, -0.042388916, -0.010467529, -0.010696411, 0.03161621, -0.0071372986, -0.018951416, 0.015838623, -0.001077652, -0.02607727, 0.044036865, -0.008522034, -0.03552246, 0.03869629, 0.035003662, 0.013893127, -0.05331421, -0.0033512115, 0.04650879, 0.05670166, 0.08276367, 0.044128418, -0.008888245, 0.0046463013, 0.053588867, -0.015670776, -0.042816162, -0.030532837, 0.066223145, 0.030258179, -0.024841309, 0.0052757263, 0.012619019, -0.0231781, -0.045318604, -0.027435303, 0.00762558, -0.033477783, 0.035186768, -0.027679443, -0.023330688, 0.044067383, 0.017471313, -0.016693115, -0.003829956, 0.009803772, -0.010276794, 0.04663086, -0.0061454773, 0.00022411346, -0.024383545, 0.010719299, -0.030975342, -0.0023498535, -0.013641357, -0.00037026405, -0.0045280457, 0.030441284, -0.031921387, -0.044799805, -0.0028057098, -0.0036334991, -0.006511688, -0.0030937195, -0.035736084, -0.024169922, 0.0524292, 0.041503906, 0.012863159, -0.00957489, 0.053466797, 0.07531738, 0.06652832, 0.020904541, -0.037139893, 0.06976318, -0.0206604, -0.083496094, 0.010299683, 0.01586914, -0.02519226, -0.004234314, -0.020721436, -0.028442383, -0.026901245, -0.0057678223, -0.016189575, -0.031051636, 0.008010864, -0.028579712, -0.0074157715, 0.00042891502, -0.04309082, 0.037994385, 0.0115737915, -0.0015211105, -0.05053711, 0.0037384033, -0.00019705296, 0.017700195, -0.011642456, -0.02178955, 0.0010786057, 0.012786865, -0.0025959015, -0.0074310303, 0.0041923523, -0.041046143, -0.013046265, -0.016357422, 0.014335632, -0.045715332, -0.02406311, 0.045410156, -0.009521484, -0.01739502, -0.014083862, -0.005935669, 0.037994385, 0.020629883, 0.08013916, 0.035461426, -0.0063095093, -0.035949707, 0.010314941, -0.0046463013 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07617v1
CLAMP: A Contrastive Language And Molecule Pre-training Network
Neel Redkar
cs.CL, cs.IR, 8.2.D.2.5
This paper highlights a shift in how to approach material generation. Instead of material-to-material, we propose a language-to-material generation architecture that utilizes millions of untapped data points. Using a web scraper to collect crystal text pairs from open-source research papers, a contrastive model can be trained using a convolutional graph neural network encoder and a language encoder. This would allow unsupervised zero-shot classification which can be trained by taking advantage of linguistic structure. Without any specific training data, an ~82\% accuracy was achieved and ~75\% accuracy for photocatalyst prediction with an extremely small dataset. This novel network could ideally be cross-applied to any reaction that can be described via text, opening completely new methods to think about 3D chemical framework generation. In the full experiment diffusion models would likely be incorporated to fully exploit the latent space.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07617v1
2023-11-12T07:45:35
2023-11-12T07:45:35
{ "title": [ -0.020584106, -0.02330017, -0.03491211, -0.04940796, -0.017227173, -0.0028209686, -0.03857422, -0.0019330978, 0.01675415, 0.015296936, -0.0021362305, 0.0045433044, -0.015914917, -0.03515625, -0.028289795, 0.016723633, -0.009651184, 0.056640625, -0.006626129, -0.03475952, -0.033050537, -0.038970947, 0.04660034, 0.0154418945, 0.02116394, -0.07611084, -0.052642822, 0.016845703, -0.022766113, -0.0256958, -0.0027923584, 0.014968872, 0.05026245, 0.051239014, -0.059753418, 0.002199173, -0.0803833, 0.0345459, -0.01701355, 0.010574341, 0.008888245, 0.0032463074, 0.002363205, -0.015022278, -0.04675293, 0.03488159, -0.068603516, -0.008224487, 0.0014762878, 0.015975952, -0.00982666, 0.030563354, -0.029663086, 0.032592773, 0.010055542, -0.013656616, -0.043548584, 0.003921509, 0.040924072, 0.085754395, 0.02809143, -0.05770874, 0.0043945312, -0.055541992, -0.032104492, -0.016784668, -0.03491211, 0.0390625, 0.055145264, 0.0017061234, -0.017730713, 0.015914917, -0.002691269, -0.023620605, -0.05178833, 0.042663574, 0.031951904, 0.01676941, 0.026321411, -0.038360596, 0.030075073, -0.0011730194, 0.014175415, -0.008132935, 0.010726929, -0.023910522, -0.023223877, -0.020187378, -0.014915466, -0.061462402, -0.014213562, 0.02607727, -0.007896423, -0.020385742, -0.036499023, -0.036376953, -0.0061454773, 0.0031490326, -0.012825012, 0.0049934387, 0.0036411285, -0.002670288, 0.019302368, -0.021240234, 0.014274597, 0.020965576, -0.029815674, -0.0107803345, 0.02784729, 0.04336548, -0.006362915, 0.02355957, 0.0030384064, 0.004196167, 0.0038986206, 0.013702393, -0.02444458, 0.027145386, -0.009880066, 0.0395813, 0.007472992, -0.012512207, 0.039916992, 0.009819031, 0.016342163, 0.01600647, -0.04248047, -0.009399414, -0.06463623, 0.029876709, 0.037322998, 0.06311035, -0.09484863, -0.048797607, -0.09063721, 0.055480957, 0.021026611, 0.0013875961, 0.0018510818, -0.007068634, 0.016021729, -0.03793335, -0.017593384, 0.0017642975, -0.0068206787, 0.026138306, 0.052520752, -0.008575439, -0.042877197, -0.07171631, 0.0017280579, -0.008773804, 0.04550171, 0.0007157326, -0.095581055, -0.00093889236, -0.14538574, 0.0064468384, -0.014587402, 0.0022888184, 0.021133423, 0.0014133453, -0.023071289, -0.006298065, 0.03125, -0.009979248, -0.026535034, 0.025009155, 0.02468872, 0.047058105, -0.0016307831, 0.022964478, 0.04168701, -0.011749268, -0.025924683, -0.013061523, 0.019760132, -0.020584106, 0.025375366, -0.01424408, -0.0025863647, -0.010765076, -0.011993408, 0.038909912, -0.04788208, -0.04385376, -0.01411438, -0.022125244, 0.06762695, 0.022445679, -0.019363403, 0.02961731, -0.026870728, -0.020126343, -0.06161499, -0.0031909943, 0.0209198, 0.046691895, -0.024154663, 0.0066490173, -0.05026245, -0.012680054, -0.013748169, 0.027175903, -0.013809204, -0.007183075, -0.014984131, 0.008361816, -0.0043296814, 0.033447266, 0.035339355, 0.00088357925, -0.017944336, 0.0015420914, -0.036102295, -0.06225586, 0.01953125, 0.020248413, 0.012138367, 0.015464783, 0.009017944, -0.03503418, 0.025283813, 0.046417236, -0.0030670166, -0.00009918213, -0.005744934, -0.027862549, -0.011398315, 0.04269409, 0.01864624, -0.025741577, 0.01940918, 0.015945435, -0.004207611, -0.001832962, 0.020629883, -0.0005941391, 0.0025367737, 0.0040397644, 0.011779785, 0.0042686462, -0.02053833, -0.0074501038, 0.07519531, 0.025680542, 0.02331543, -0.013412476, 0.022766113, 0.047729492, 0.03616333, 0.033447266, 0.045654297, 0.00091934204, 0.0008444786, 0.06762695, 0.021362305, 0.026855469, -0.013076782, 0.016082764, -0.0024299622, 0.04650879, -0.0057640076, 0.021194458, -0.04824829, -0.014762878, -0.028717041, -0.0015802383, 0.020019531, -0.010391235, 0.027145386, -0.039154053, 0.02166748, -0.02520752, -0.008140564, -0.046417236, -0.017089844, 0.007045746, 0.016433716, -0.079589844, -0.0121154785, 0.022064209, 0.028244019, 0.0017309189, 0.034362793, 0.022506714, -0.005756378, -0.020629883, -0.020935059, -0.033233643, 0.036132812, 0.0008587837, -0.0046195984, 0.0010986328, 0.024398804, -0.03164673, 0.08544922, 0.06149292, -0.019607544, 0.048065186, -0.024536133, 0.01928711, 0.017974854, -0.018218994, -0.0018205643, 0.033355713, 0.013175964, 0.0068626404, -0.047607422, -0.007247925, -0.06842041, -0.008155823, 0.00036787987, -0.001584053, -0.062316895, -0.057800293, -0.021652222, -0.045410156, -0.051574707, -0.029846191, 0.05178833, 0.0024356842, -0.0026779175, 0.0012140274, 0.01914978, -0.046081543, 0.0002822876, -0.013923645, 0.0077400208, 0.013145447, 0.009757996, 0.009353638, -0.06359863, -0.019241333, -0.0030517578, 0.0021686554, 0.0008573532, 0.01852417, -0.0181427, -0.0015201569, 0.033721924, 0.0062408447, 0.022521973, -0.030303955, 0.008216858, -0.041748047, 0.008872986, 0.009132385, -0.0129470825, 0.014694214, 0.006965637, -0.013381958, -0.013343811, 0.05307007, 0.07537842, -0.04345703, -0.034851074, 0.08148193, 0.04168701, 0.01789856, 0.024398804, 0.0077171326, 0.0016708374, -0.062316895, -0.021240234, -0.03540039, -0.02658081, -0.011474609, -0.016204834, 0.048950195, -0.04638672, -0.027572632, -0.02015686, -0.009841919, -0.013504028, 0.00472641, -0.029388428, -0.046905518, -0.0395813, -0.03152466, -0.03353882, 0.009979248, -0.01234436, 0.037628174, 0.08654785, -0.035858154, -0.029586792, 0.023239136, 0.031585693, 0.024963379, -0.032562256, -0.04724121, -0.040496826, -0.00033473969, 0.00598526, 0.014724731, 0.00043821335, -0.034088135, -0.09539795, -0.007820129, 0.02986145, -0.0031147003, -0.02053833, 0.010810852, -0.06341553, 0.00724411, -0.020111084, -0.016525269, 0.033599854, 0.059387207, -0.001291275, 0.018539429, 0.019760132, -0.004081726, 0.006008148, -0.020843506, -0.068481445, 0.024627686, -0.014778137, -0.04989624, -0.015419006, -0.009597778, -0.0597229, -0.009796143, 0.033691406, 0.041168213, 0.020080566, -0.022064209, 0.004722595, -0.024520874, -0.005138397, -0.025177002, -0.039031982, -0.0077171326, 0.014076233, 0.02720642, -0.017684937, 0.004962921, 0.010269165, 0.006614685, -0.014183044, -0.013534546, 0.003610611, 0.020889282, -0.008010864, -0.017990112, -0.0072250366, 0.021530151, -0.022094727, -0.025863647, -0.021148682, -0.005168915, -0.03729248, 0.014793396, -0.016662598, 0.060577393, 0.03378296, 0.026947021, 0.009819031, -0.03842163, -0.0052452087, -0.04046631, -0.048095703, 0.026672363, 0.017868042, 0.025436401, 0.0005431175, -0.027801514, -0.027648926, 0.01108551, -0.05343628, 0.020202637, -0.010536194, 0.010437012, -0.017333984, -0.0011739731, -0.010620117, 0.0035419464, 0.0012559891, 0.014785767, 0.02456665, -0.0008187294, -0.029571533, -0.059265137, -0.012077332, 0.0184021, -0.110961914, -0.030410767, 0.011352539, -0.017929077, -0.032928467, -0.046691895, 0.036621094, -0.045806885, -0.05291748, 0.024124146, -0.00944519, -0.019638062, -0.0010128021, -0.06384277, -0.022415161, 0.06903076, -0.0020599365, 0.01210022, 0.051330566, -0.031677246, -0.04650879, -0.03250122, 0.025985718, 0.035705566, 0.03326416, 0.013198853, -0.024536133, 0.018478394, -0.043640137, 0.02279663, 0.016326904, -0.02166748, 0.012374878, 0.022384644, 0.024765015, 0.03262329, 0.007461548, 0.039154053, -0.009094238, -0.0010547638, -0.055603027, -0.0008535385, 0.008201599, 0.0008029938, 0.0284729, -0.016601562, 0.030136108, 0.021987915, -0.01676941, 0.033111572, -0.0022277832, 0.01828003, 0.0680542, -0.008155823, 0.006401062, 0.028442383, 0.023666382, 0.0016727448, -0.011238098, 0.04473877, 0.0088272095, 0.07696533, -0.0236969, -0.014976501, 0.006904602, 0.02444458, -0.05218506, -0.0035915375, -0.043151855, -0.03793335, -0.02406311, 0.012435913, -0.017715454, 0.043884277, 0.025100708, -0.0090408325, -0.024963379, -0.0054473877, -0.004760742, 0.011779785, -0.030288696, -0.068237305, -0.015686035, -0.008888245, -0.092163086, -0.05355835, -0.05935669, -0.01725769, -0.012054443, 0.024398804, -0.032928467, 0.00067281723, 0.043670654, 0.09979248, 0.055511475, 0.007911682, -0.07897949, 0.0068092346, -0.006095886, -0.05633545, 0.0116119385, -0.016326904, -0.018951416, -0.041625977, 0.0025253296, -0.025405884, -0.017974854, -0.04724121, 0.010375977, 0.009788513, 0.023635864, 0.0050582886, 0.013076782, 0.030227661, 0.021499634, 0.020202637, 0.010177612, -0.027618408, -0.056274414, 0.018478394, 0.03289795, 0.009315491, 0.00390625, 0.042144775, 0.037322998, 0.0010576248, 0.010139465, 0.009239197, 0.038513184, -0.020095825, -0.016921997, 0.012611389, -0.053009033, -0.027572632, 0.010238647, -0.025405884, 0.052581787, -0.019958496, 0.03552246, -0.018081665, -0.024734497, 0.035064697, -0.009101868, 0.010406494, 0.04437256, 0.008262634, -0.06738281, -0.07019043, -0.014129639, 0.07342529, -0.037872314, -0.011047363, -0.010818481, 0.016662598, 0.0046081543, 0.055786133, 0.024414062, -0.008712769, 0.04067993, -0.00856781, -0.0050468445, -0.02444458, -0.050872803, 0.012619019, 0.010421753, 0.017868042, -0.03048706, 0.003648758, -0.06750488, -0.010879517, -0.03213501, -0.013008118, 0.01713562, -0.06567383, 0.0041885376, 0.0769043, 0.010017395, 0.043640137, 0.0052337646, 0.033813477, 0.011390686, 0.038879395, 0.006378174, -0.007221222, 0.027526855, -0.050231934, 0.007858276, 0.013023376, 0.019088745, -0.004966736, 0.010261536, -0.0022678375, -0.013725281, -0.03540039, 0.024276733, 0.016189575, 0.0028762817, 0.03656006, -0.06323242, 0.020233154, -0.024673462, -0.018859863, -0.004108429, -0.056915283, -0.029846191, 0.016738892, -0.058135986, -0.066101074, 0.034942627, -0.056549072, -0.02394104, -0.082458496, 0.027145386, -0.020874023, 0.0154800415, -0.01852417, 0.0018672943, -0.046539307, 0.01940918, 0.025756836, -0.03111267, 0.03161621, -0.019454956, -0.0026493073, 0.05718994, 0.051116943, -0.057281494, -0.017578125, 0.021835327, -0.025405884, 0.009506226, 0.010299683, 0.016082764, -0.026519775, 0.013298035, -0.024505615, 0.0010490417, 0.016921997, 0.037017822, -0.02809143, -0.012008667, 0.03982544, 0.008865356, 0.0030612946, 0.003921509, 0.006187439, -0.041778564, 0.030670166, 0.0368042, -0.03024292, 0.009414673, -0.017074585, 0.0033435822, -0.0050086975, -0.060791016, 0.0158844, 0.00818634, 0.0057296753, 0.028030396, 0.04159546, 0.035461426, 0.037597656, -0.039093018, 0.030029297, 0.04321289, -0.059906006, -0.029403687, -0.0110321045, -0.011398315, -0.049438477, 0.057495117, 0.018493652, -0.002614975, -0.033294678, -0.06378174, -0.029525757, 0.010032654, 0.036102295, 0.020950317, 0.010795593, -0.044891357, 0.01876831, -0.0031013489, -0.014038086, -0.043945312, 0.008972168, 0.0025691986, -0.010253906, 0.034240723, -0.010437012, -0.009315491, -0.014289856, 0.01965332, 0.025482178, 0.0025806427, 0.01713562, -0.041778564, -0.0077171326, -0.0211792, -0.018539429, 0.032226562, 0.0047035217, -0.027420044, 0.030288696, -0.022613525, 0.06512451, 0.01322937, 0.06335449, 0.029190063, -0.0061950684, 0.010757446, 0.010047913, 0.04550171, -0.032928467, 0.011024475, -0.02619934, 0.010177612, -0.041137695, -0.018585205, -0.08123779, 0.027908325, 0.016189575, 0.027877808, 0.0051574707, 0.002298355, 0.035858154, 0.008171082, 0.022262573, -0.021102905, 0.049224854, -0.020019531, 0.0029411316, -0.0063819885, -0.017990112, 0.03778076, 0.045898438, -0.0070991516, -0.0070877075, -0.02368164, -0.017120361, 0.024383545, 0.014953613, 0.004875183, -0.009056091, -0.0028190613, -0.02746582, 0.057861328, 0.015808105, 0.06506348, 0.040618896, 0.020095825, -0.016571045, -0.0115356445, -0.027069092, -0.02519226, 0.004020691, -0.00554657, 0.025253296, -0.046173096, 0.04095459, 0.003917694, -0.030212402, -0.030075073, 0.062805176, 0.02218628, -0.016677856, 0.0026416779, -0.0002052784, 0.036010742, 0.0132369995, 0.036254883, -0.038116455, -0.013282776, -0.0013532639, 0.008705139, 0.005706787, 0.025360107, 0.037750244, -0.0077667236, -0.005344391, -0.055236816, 0.008338928, 0.020614624, -0.00025892258, 0.038116455, 0.012207031, 0.0473938, 0.014945984, -0.031280518, 0.012809753, 0.047851562, -0.08642578, 0.022827148, 0.02583313, 0.022155762, 0.009613037, 0.06036377, 0.009437561, -0.011940002, -0.03479004, -0.03488159, 0.018951416, 0.0118637085, -0.028060913, 0.0039596558, -0.035186768, -0.023498535, -0.0043792725, -0.047943115, 0.02003479, -0.023330688, -0.003458023, -0.026626587, 0.01436615, 0.043029785, -0.050109863, -0.017440796, -0.028015137, -0.029327393, -0.006793976, -0.01109314, -0.030883789, -0.017074585, -0.013931274, 0.02545166, 0.008491516, -0.01108551, 0.0036773682, -0.014945984, -0.06109619, -0.011932373, -0.02394104, 0.019195557, -0.032287598, -0.026672363, -0.017913818, -0.0016384125, 0.000518322, -0.016479492, -0.010772705, -0.018035889, -0.03656006, -0.013786316, -0.0011987686, 0.0054740906, -0.020721436, -0.016159058, 0.013832092, 0.011131287, -0.0152282715, 0.009880066, -0.0057258606, -0.03994751, -0.025253296, -0.012954712, -0.0062942505, 0.018295288, 0.01158905, -0.025970459, 0.01687622, 0.007797241, -0.02645874, -0.015144348, -0.008506775, 0.026855469, -0.015670776, -0.031799316, 0.012825012, 0.02267456, 0.022750854, -0.05606079, -0.041412354, 0.0103302, 0.037017822, -0.008865356, 0.028396606, 0.054504395, -0.009399414, -0.012825012, -0.023880005, -0.025466919, -0.019943237, -0.012084961, -0.01737976, 0.018569946, 0.014160156, -0.01322937, -0.009780884, 0.03086853, -0.045074463, 0.010108948, 0.017501831, 0.02482605, 0.034179688, -0.0027103424, 0.07312012, -0.038146973, -0.0019454956, -0.050872803, 0.015060425, 0.010185242, 0.04940796, -0.047912598, 0.0395813, 0.0028858185, 0.03540039, -0.031234741, -0.037078857, 0.06262207, 0.038269043, 0.031158447, 0.015357971, 0.0124435425, 0.0071105957, -0.0053634644, -0.00894165, -0.0048065186, 0.006668091, 0.018569946, -0.023391724, 0.016159058, -0.0423584, -0.031051636, -0.049865723, -0.047210693, 0.044311523, -0.031433105, 0.0129852295, -0.041748047, -0.013542175, -0.005218506, 0.0043563843, 0.016601562, -0.032409668, -0.048095703, -0.007785797, 0.034820557, -0.009170532 ], "summary": [ -0.038757324, -0.040222168, -0.03656006, -0.034179688, -0.06591797, 0.0073165894, -0.08911133, 0.034729004, 0.049316406, 0.012435913, -0.013023376, 0.013893127, -0.006801605, -0.023620605, 0.00048208237, -0.00308609, -0.008155823, 0.053649902, 0.04272461, -0.014450073, 0.02130127, -0.013648987, 0.024795532, -0.053375244, -0.007858276, -0.025375366, -0.004875183, -0.0054779053, 0.0118255615, 0.021499634, 0.0140686035, -0.0045814514, 0.007598877, 0.007369995, 0.017959595, -0.027572632, -0.002506256, -0.0040626526, 0.010055542, 0.011184692, 0.017608643, -0.014007568, 0.028213501, -0.010498047, -0.031677246, 0.05429077, -0.023727417, -0.013069153, 0.024307251, -0.000082433224, -0.00472641, -0.037750244, -0.011917114, -0.026290894, -0.019973755, -0.004878998, -0.06072998, 0.0036621094, 0.0181427, 0.08416748, 0.02758789, -0.010627747, -0.016952515, -0.04638672, -0.05142212, 0.00029349327, 0.03665161, -0.021499634, 0.051971436, -0.028045654, 0.0024299622, 0.037475586, 0.021377563, -0.048950195, -0.038085938, 0.04360962, 0.0126571655, 0.03363037, 0.012390137, -0.053588867, -0.027420044, 0.03591919, -0.014831543, -0.061309814, 0.009918213, -0.057525635, -0.024414062, 0.0003798008, -0.0028305054, -0.020355225, -0.0007338524, 0.010246277, -0.049926758, 0.02999878, 0.019500732, -0.05630493, -0.021102905, -0.033813477, 0.0061073303, 0.050445557, 0.035247803, -0.044799805, 0.095214844, -0.04425049, 0.02558899, 0.056610107, -0.056915283, -0.04437256, 0.0335083, 0.028564453, 0.009277344, -0.013320923, 0.004837036, -0.03466797, -0.02809143, 0.042907715, 0.0025177002, 0.020080566, 0.0079422, 0.04486084, -0.0057296753, 0.018722534, 0.007896423, 0.034820557, -0.0022697449, 0.007949829, 0.008956909, -0.017715454, 0.012649536, -0.033416748, 0.013053894, 0.060150146, 0.02368164, -0.018127441, -0.054901123, 0.031036377, 0.047790527, 0.05432129, 0.010528564, -0.022247314, 0.053497314, -0.02067566, -0.046783447, 0.0859375, -0.028381348, 0.020401001, 0.015159607, -0.00655365, -0.0317688, -0.01889038, -0.021362305, -0.0022659302, 0.022201538, -0.012619019, -0.009223938, -0.06390381, -0.03414917, -0.027404785, 0.06616211, -0.028366089, 0.043548584, 0.024978638, -0.013061523, 0.06933594, 0.03918457, -0.0289917, 0.023803711, 0.023712158, 0.025009155, 0.04220581, -0.012916565, 0.010543823, 0.012619019, -0.012573242, -0.01524353, -0.012367249, 0.026824951, -0.03942871, -0.0019388199, 0.029022217, -0.012573242, -0.013618469, -0.023086548, 0.031555176, -0.01423645, -0.021438599, -0.017852783, -0.018035889, 0.053833008, -0.0040779114, 0.003232956, -0.005115509, -0.0035629272, -0.0066490173, -0.008911133, -0.005519867, -0.004547119, 0.01713562, -0.0005249977, 0.00088071823, 0.011436462, 0.039123535, -0.00982666, 0.012863159, -0.013671875, 0.023025513, 0.0042533875, 0.014213562, -0.03579712, 0.013343811, 0.04107666, -0.021636963, -0.037506104, 0.031051636, 0.0079422, -0.064575195, 0.027023315, -0.0012340546, 0.0066452026, -0.037628174, 0.024963379, 0.006336212, 0.0073623657, 0.072753906, 0.022644043, -0.013549805, 0.018432617, -0.0049972534, 0.07104492, -0.008399963, 0.08087158, -0.019943237, 0.019424438, 0.018615723, -0.008636475, 0.0061569214, 0.058166504, -0.03894043, 0.010871887, 0.016479492, 0.016723633, 0.029754639, -0.05065918, -0.004508972, 0.08642578, 0.07421875, 0.02885437, -0.01763916, 0.014984131, 0.11431885, -0.015129089, 0.051849365, -0.023895264, -0.02178955, -0.029724121, 0.05505371, 0.0012226105, 0.015380859, 0.012260437, -0.010765076, 0.030944824, 0.05831909, 0.01146698, 0.0138549805, -0.007675171, -0.03466797, 0.0038490295, -0.012168884, -0.023590088, -0.027801514, 0.02381897, 0.026000977, -0.0035953522, -0.067993164, -0.06427002, -0.027557373, -0.014015198, 0.064208984, -0.0005145073, -0.05795288, 0.006877899, 0.007194519, -0.017364502, -0.02154541, 0.05899048, 0.008125305, -0.028778076, -0.028915405, 0.03250122, 0.039916992, 0.038208008, 0.0007266998, -0.025512695, 0.030914307, 0.033050537, -0.019332886, 0.03704834, 0.05847168, -0.010925293, -0.022247314, -0.005771637, 0.006565094, -0.03982544, 0.0057754517, 0.015281677, 0.036224365, 0.02684021, -0.011428833, 0.008026123, 0.018539429, -0.057556152, -0.014640808, 0.008766174, 0.035583496, -0.030807495, -0.03540039, -0.015777588, -0.00021445751, -0.05532837, -0.019088745, 0.1295166, 0.008613586, 0.02468872, 0.020874023, 0.002532959, -0.079833984, 0.047851562, -0.019332886, 0.03186035, 0.021148682, -0.0126953125, 0.03677368, -0.015159607, 0.046844482, 0.005470276, -0.0040130615, 0.0131073, -0.00982666, -0.0076522827, -0.008956909, 0.01977539, 0.030914307, -0.0018291473, -0.020523071, 0.006603241, -0.027267456, 0.008415222, -0.007457733, 0.024093628, 0.007865906, -0.007083893, 0.006084442, 0.029678345, 0.0680542, 0.073791504, -0.011474609, -0.038482666, 0.096069336, 0.05606079, 0.018859863, -0.04623413, 0.04336548, -0.021057129, -0.026550293, -0.027328491, -0.004016876, 0.004837036, 0.031173706, 0.0024204254, 0.003955841, 0.032196045, 0.0050201416, -0.019866943, -0.024856567, -0.056610107, -0.032714844, 0.06036377, -0.022232056, -0.012504578, 0.03353882, -0.02178955, 0.016220093, -0.018417358, 0.02532959, 0.06384277, 0.0040664673, -0.008705139, 0.05316162, 0.020996094, 0.008773804, -0.031982422, -0.020843506, -0.0048675537, 0.002128601, -0.007881165, 0.012626648, -0.043395996, -0.047302246, -0.03262329, -0.020080566, -0.036590576, 0.04586792, 0.008598328, -0.0062942505, -0.018096924, -0.03375244, -0.02519226, -0.035308838, 0.017990112, 0.058441162, 0.024978638, -0.042144775, 0.0138168335, -0.0037899017, -0.009117126, 0.012039185, 0.0084991455, -0.010299683, 0.026031494, -0.025848389, -0.03515625, 0.032318115, -0.013267517, 0.006351471, 0.042877197, 0.056793213, 0.0041160583, -0.03314209, 0.011016846, 0.03866577, 0.028121948, -0.0025920868, -0.033050537, -0.0014314651, -0.0005583763, 0.08355713, 0.0061035156, -0.020187378, 0.033172607, -0.0357666, 0.0029640198, -0.003665924, 0.019042969, -0.0044136047, 0.015838623, -0.04208374, 0.015350342, 0.028259277, -0.024139404, 0.017044067, -0.025863647, -0.00089645386, 0.029312134, 0.04248047, -0.007835388, 0.042419434, -0.0006337166, 0.036987305, 0.056518555, -0.021591187, 0.0368042, -0.015686035, -0.02670288, 0.046539307, -0.012374878, 0.012214661, 0.008087158, -0.0032196045, -0.044952393, 0.018447876, -0.016525269, -0.0023059845, -0.007633209, -0.0036697388, 0.0020256042, -0.024124146, 0.031402588, 0.03640747, -0.057769775, -0.039367676, -0.0736084, 0.03729248, 0.012054443, -0.05508423, -0.023330688, 0.015197754, -0.029388428, -0.029846191, 0.03543091, 0.0044174194, -0.04574585, -0.0368042, 0.04937744, -0.039093018, -0.0034046173, 0.06524658, 0.015426636, 0.026290894, 0.027877808, -0.029510498, -0.007904053, 0.021392822, -0.0035591125, -0.0035476685, 0.017852783, -0.013366699, -0.023956299, 0.03463745, 0.03277588, 0.00504303, 0.021575928, 0.009536743, -0.03488159, -0.020553589, -0.01928711, -0.0035438538, 0.012374878, -0.020477295, 0.0025119781, 0.006816864, 0.006427765, 0.020095825, 0.0014419556, 0.021209717, 0.020996094, 0.021469116, -0.03744507, 0.039398193, -0.018936157, 0.014060974, 0.025405884, 0.058532715, 0.007972717, -0.0057868958, -0.021972656, -0.06335449, -0.015563965, -0.053222656, -0.0060157776, 0.027786255, 0.0004911423, 0.015899658, 0.0014734268, 0.040039062, -0.0138549805, 0.04949951, -0.003376007, 0.04425049, -0.041656494, -0.0018644333, 0.01512146, 0.040740967, -0.053344727, -0.03842163, -0.024673462, 0.019836426, -0.00017750263, 0.004070282, -0.03778076, 0.06088257, 0.036468506, 0.010368347, -0.012031555, -0.011222839, 0.014854431, 0.016921997, -0.035827637, -0.0927124, 0.016860962, -0.03918457, -0.020965576, -0.024093628, -0.03918457, -0.041656494, -0.0124053955, 0.012992859, 0.013374329, 0.006778717, 0.010047913, -0.011367798, 0.02468872, -0.008049011, -0.038391113, -0.030548096, 0.00995636, -0.026107788, 0.0010070801, -0.0018730164, -0.007457733, -0.04534912, -0.030212402, -0.01586914, -0.008384705, -0.06384277, 0.028060913, 0.019195557, -0.000040233135, -0.034698486, -0.017959595, 0.005332947, 0.041168213, 0.00687027, 0.021987915, -0.006919861, -0.021713257, -0.03378296, -0.010643005, 0.054840088, 0.03314209, 0.03829956, -0.05090332, -0.059265137, 0.016235352, 0.045074463, 0.020706177, -0.019683838, 0.0017786026, -0.0050354004, -0.06762695, -0.026153564, -0.023132324, -0.024368286, 0.016601562, -0.015052795, 0.013244629, 0.0010795593, -0.05303955, 0.043060303, -0.0035152435, -0.024658203, 0.044403076, -0.024414062, -0.030532837, -0.016479492, 0.018035889, 0.013641357, 0.003944397, -0.01953125, -0.016616821, -0.0031604767, 0.0115356445, 0.011001587, 0.011222839, 0.0012521744, -0.010787964, -0.014595032, -0.0027942657, -0.013374329, -0.023910522, 0.010665894, 0.04473877, 0.0039482117, 0.00491333, -0.05709839, -0.0066719055, -0.028808594, -0.051635742, 0.010803223, 0.018341064, -0.0001513958, 0.0036716461, 0.08251953, -0.02470398, 0.056274414, -0.030166626, 0.0132369995, -0.0085372925, 0.009559631, -0.034240723, -0.019607544, -0.018203735, -0.005596161, 0.016082764, 0.013061523, 0.0036373138, 0.017547607, 0.014846802, 0.013999939, -0.014892578, 0.0024051666, -0.0038471222, -0.004009247, -0.008644104, 0.0016269684, -0.012451172, 0.0473938, 0.013755798, -0.010688782, -0.031311035, -0.03643799, 0.0013914108, 0.047332764, -0.032958984, 0.01939392, 0.048339844, -0.031707764, -0.012893677, -0.047943115, 0.02508545, -0.040618896, 0.024978638, -0.013679504, -0.022079468, -0.03086853, -0.023391724, 0.016586304, -0.011177063, 0.019989014, -0.018234253, -0.008094788, 0.000936985, 0.032073975, -0.039886475, -0.0008878708, -0.02659607, -0.023086548, -0.054534912, -0.03540039, -0.028305054, 0.060516357, 0.030197144, 0.004447937, 0.036071777, 0.00007772446, 0.027420044, -0.016784668, -0.0058670044, 0.046417236, -0.010688782, -0.039093018, 0.052612305, -0.039794922, -0.058654785, 0.05105591, 0.025024414, -0.0049552917, 0.017974854, 0.011985779, 0.055480957, -0.02456665, -0.012023926, -0.015975952, 0.041290283, 0.034332275, 0.020645142, 0.010940552, 0.008560181, -0.01651001, -0.017227173, -0.00032114983, 0.016281128, -0.020263672, -0.01474762, -0.038330078, -0.0021648407, -0.059936523, 0.0024776459, 0.015930176, -0.0006213188, -0.00995636, -0.03665161, -0.003545761, -0.013137817, 0.021911621, 0.0017318726, 0.03744507, -0.015960693, 0.000068962574, -0.028778076, -0.02078247, -0.03213501, 0.025405884, -0.037994385, -0.054107666, 0.048553467, -0.021072388, -0.05331421, 0.029144287, 0.02508545, 0.053497314, 0.011917114, 0.05355835, -0.0011844635, -0.01777649, -0.0049743652, 0.02217102, 0.035186768, 0.006626129, -0.0034980774, 0.0044555664, 0.02116394, 0.019042969, 0.035858154, -0.001540184, 0.00067186356, 0.020599365, 0.057556152, -0.0010986328, 0.01361084, 0.0016670227, 0.0077285767, -0.013092041, -0.033966064, -0.038360596, -0.03152466, -0.02999878, 0.026397705, -0.007347107, -0.037841797, 0.09967041, -0.027557373, 0.019561768, 0.018936157, -0.016159058, 0.07684326, -0.006149292, -0.043426514, -0.018310547, 0.0075645447, -0.05935669, 0.037719727, 0.056243896, -0.03262329, 0.026855469, 0.02330017, 0.02243042, 0.033599854, -0.023147583, -0.038269043, -0.0234375, 0.043395996, -0.010124207, 0.049194336, 0.041809082, 0.08178711, 0.0032196045, -0.055419922, 0.03527832, -0.016601562, -0.033843994, 0.013717651, 0.023422241, -0.021133423, -0.015808105, 0.037139893, 0.00049448013, 0.005844116, -0.014251709, 0.008766174, -0.010498047, 0.044189453, -0.021392822, -0.017669678, -0.0018396378, 0.034301758, -0.004009247, -0.030792236, -0.06329346, -0.051086426, 0.0055656433, 0.005340576, -0.051208496, -0.04067993, 0.046417236, 0.039611816, -0.006126404, -0.010505676, 0.013435364, -0.04269409, 0.0096206665, 0.027297974, 0.025848389, 0.037231445, 0.051361084, -0.018234253, 0.03503418, 0.03265381, -0.012268066, 0.047790527, -0.00058221817, 0.031341553, 0.04119873, 0.032470703, 0.0023555756, 0.01776123, 0.035095215, -0.023864746, -0.017044067, -0.037139893, 0.003479004, -0.061187744, -0.016143799, 0.00079345703, -0.045562744, -0.014228821, 0.05496216, -0.016113281, -0.0071525574, -0.009864807, -0.028213501, 0.029220581, -0.030670166, -0.024658203, -0.024871826, 0.009979248, -0.011802673, -0.008216858, -0.033691406, -0.033294678, -0.033599854, 0.053253174, -0.010154724, 0.0064582825, 0.035980225, -0.019363403, -0.029693604, 0.008026123, 0.0046806335, 0.04168701, 0.020690918, 0.0039253235, 0.050628662, -0.0057754517, -0.012107849, -0.08178711, -0.0110321045, -0.04107666, 0.026779175, -0.026672363, -0.03074646, -0.024215698, -0.025375366, -0.054656982, 0.006336212, 0.020492554, -0.03933716, 0.04550171, 0.018203735, -0.04019165, 0.014823914, 0.015167236, 0.009300232, 0.055023193, -0.010429382, -0.012336731, 0.025268555, 0.039001465, -0.036224365, -0.028137207, -0.03277588, -0.021316528, 0.027908325, -0.024856567, -0.014976501, 0.030395508, 0.031051636, -0.03149414, -0.004890442, 0.035491943, 0.06451416, -0.005622864, -0.018371582, 0.026107788, -0.025177002, -0.018936157, 0.0005450249, -0.0209198, 0.00059080124, 0.068115234, 0.025650024, 0.004787445, 0.017196655, -0.034729004, 0.043060303, 0.01626587, -0.037139893, -0.021026611, 0.013389587, -0.010757446, -0.037597656, 0.0056877136, -0.0015096664, -0.021575928, -0.015419006, -0.06262207, -0.006454468, 0.016082764, 0.055114746, -0.0259552, 0.06008911, 0.012428284, 0.0040779114, -0.019561768, -0.028579712, 0.0137786865, 0.018493652, 0.004840851, 0.011734009, 0.017974854, -0.0077323914, 0.021514893, 0.011444092, -0.013687134, 0.027374268, 0.020706177, -0.02003479, -0.024749756, -0.03668213, -0.026412964, -0.10900879, -0.037078857, 0.0005221367, -0.06542969, 0.020309448, -0.0058555603, -0.022216797, 0.018508911, -0.008522034, 0.007381439, -0.009552002, 0.008773804, 0.021194458, -0.017120361, 0.013374329 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06761v1
Learning Knowledge-Enhanced Contextual Language Representations for Domain Natural Language Understanding
Ruyao Xu, Taolin Zhang, Chengyu Wang, Zhongjie Duan, Cen Chen, Minghui Qiu, Dawei Cheng, Xiaofeng He, Weining Qian
cs.CL
Knowledge-Enhanced Pre-trained Language Models (KEPLMs) improve the performance of various downstream NLP tasks by injecting knowledge facts from large-scale Knowledge Graphs (KGs). However, existing methods for pre-training KEPLMs with relational triples are difficult to be adapted to close domains due to the lack of sufficient domain graph semantics. In this paper, we propose a Knowledge-enhanced lANGuAge Representation learning framework for various clOsed dOmains (KANGAROO) via capturing the implicit graph structure among the entities. Specifically, since the entity coverage rates of closed-domain KGs can be relatively low and may exhibit the global sparsity phenomenon for knowledge injection, we consider not only the shallow relational representations of triples but also the hyperbolic embeddings of deep hierarchical entity-class structures for effective knowledge fusion.Moreover, as two closed-domain entities under the same entity-class often have locally dense neighbor subgraphs counted by max point biconnected component, we further propose a data augmentation strategy based on contrastive learning over subgraphs to construct hard negative samples of higher quality. It makes the underlying KELPMs better distinguish the semantics of these neighboring entities to further complement the global semantic sparsity. In the experiments, we evaluate KANGAROO over various knowledge-aware and general NLP tasks in both full and few-shot learning settings, outperforming various KEPLM training paradigms performance in closed-domains significantly.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06761v1
2023-11-12T07:37:24
2023-11-12T07:37:24
{ "title": [ -0.008346558, -0.0073280334, -0.03756714, -0.08239746, 0.0098724365, 0.0000641942, -0.052093506, 0.011642456, 0.011962891, 0.023422241, -0.02407837, -0.003929138, 0.0040512085, -0.008888245, -0.044799805, 0.0022945404, -0.008598328, 0.031173706, -0.039245605, -0.0446167, -0.016479492, -0.054473877, 0.026748657, 0.007286072, 0.04824829, -0.073791504, -0.03302002, 0.031402588, -0.013839722, -0.021392822, 0.004550934, -0.023483276, 0.0357666, 0.013793945, 0.0027828217, -0.015609741, -0.04336548, 0.0028495789, 0.0036087036, 0.002401352, 0.025604248, -0.0057907104, -0.017944336, -0.028182983, -0.0357666, 0.035980225, -0.06414795, -0.026321411, -0.0070228577, 0.04925537, 0.03186035, 0.020385742, 0.0033130646, 0.030639648, 0.024505615, -0.05166626, -0.052124023, 0.0017681122, 0.0395813, 0.052581787, 0.033111572, -0.06347656, 0.011505127, -0.022125244, -0.039093018, -0.0211792, -0.0010595322, 0.010154724, 0.05001831, -0.021133423, -0.009269714, 0.029083252, 0.01725769, -0.021911621, -0.04284668, 0.0040664673, 0.044647217, 0.0036125183, 0.03125, -0.0440979, -0.0031280518, 0.008857727, 0.012825012, -0.023040771, 0.009498596, -0.0368042, -0.020965576, -0.0048713684, -0.035095215, -0.07946777, -0.007888794, -0.015556335, -0.050933838, 0.0038700104, -0.02180481, -0.03878784, 0.010871887, 0.012176514, 0.016906738, -0.036193848, 0.0075416565, 0.02218628, -0.040893555, -0.012336731, 0.017303467, 0.041992188, -0.0033740997, -0.0064811707, 0.012992859, 0.0052223206, -0.027008057, 0.028686523, -0.0043525696, -0.02709961, 0.0068626404, 0.045959473, -0.016464233, 0.024658203, 0.019638062, 0.036071777, -0.014518738, -0.031341553, 0.015281677, 0.02029419, 0.049468994, 0.03918457, -0.04824829, 0.02003479, 0.011558533, 0.034973145, 0.006664276, 0.0345459, -0.1060791, -0.0635376, -0.051971436, 0.040039062, -0.00032663345, 0.0132751465, -0.01940918, -0.0009422302, 0.02142334, 0.013336182, 0.006061554, -0.0019311905, -0.00086069107, 0.0115737915, 0.058502197, -0.01121521, -0.043304443, -0.0423584, -0.03363037, 0.011566162, 0.04336548, -0.033843994, -0.05319214, -0.055786133, -0.12432861, -0.027313232, 0.03262329, -0.026443481, -0.005191803, 0.0010614395, 0.026184082, -0.008468628, 0.013023376, -0.0010290146, -0.033996582, 0.000047683716, 0.009902954, 0.009887695, 0.014099121, 0.015625, 0.0030136108, -0.0035476685, -0.01096344, 0.002161026, 0.015777588, 0.016311646, 0.014694214, 0.02230835, 0.026000977, -0.02796936, 0.024505615, 0.046203613, -0.037322998, -0.025421143, -0.0012350082, -0.015350342, 0.044769287, 0.005584717, -0.01876831, 0.028381348, -0.024169922, -0.04019165, -0.037384033, -0.016784668, 0.019927979, 0.025344849, 0.0060424805, 0.009239197, -0.050445557, 0.0016088486, -0.027313232, 0.0024490356, -0.014663696, -0.034240723, -0.012145996, 0.015106201, -0.010475159, 0.051239014, 0.05770874, 0.023330688, -0.036621094, -0.004550934, -0.014472961, -0.04663086, 0.04107666, -0.011962891, -0.00056552887, -0.030273438, 0.015129089, 0.0039024353, 0.020248413, 0.06124878, 0.0071792603, -0.00056409836, 0.0043945312, -0.016082764, 0.01940918, 0.017150879, 0.04348755, -0.03366089, 0.033843994, 0.02722168, -0.014266968, -0.033416748, -0.01235199, -0.015472412, 0.013999939, 0.009674072, -0.010749817, -0.020370483, -0.024108887, 0.017181396, 0.03878784, 0.0031204224, -0.0072784424, 0.006996155, 0.002204895, 0.052856445, 0.074645996, 0.03729248, 0.0155181885, 0.021133423, -0.0074043274, 0.039001465, 0.010879517, 0.004257202, -0.02507019, -0.0128479, 0.012428284, -0.019317627, -0.021484375, 0.0038051605, -0.045318604, 0.004989624, -0.032714844, -0.013519287, -0.014213562, -0.0017900467, 0.039520264, 0.0036144257, 0.011123657, -0.022399902, -0.016296387, -0.0025024414, -0.024414062, 0.03677368, 0.03326416, -0.06640625, -0.0003836155, 0.0011672974, 0.033569336, 0.0014486313, 0.04067993, 0.0072402954, 0.00983429, -0.024551392, -0.014015198, -0.0006389618, 0.046051025, 0.048034668, 0.01525116, 0.0058937073, 0.014190674, 0.008415222, 0.092285156, 0.05657959, -0.038482666, 0.04446411, -0.03149414, 0.0309906, 0.032440186, -0.02798462, 0.014053345, 0.008430481, 0.033691406, 0.01876831, -0.03074646, 0.019104004, -0.05593872, 0.013793945, -0.0065460205, -0.019226074, -0.06137085, -0.060546875, 0.0021305084, -0.053253174, -0.06958008, -0.01109314, 0.10296631, -0.008270264, -0.010887146, -0.00013709068, 0.0006480217, -0.028839111, -0.009780884, -0.029052734, -0.025161743, 0.02003479, 0.026046753, 0.013587952, -0.05102539, -0.027236938, -0.019973755, 0.00031471252, -0.01398468, -0.03692627, -0.024917603, 0.046813965, 0.03277588, 0.004924774, 0.03475952, -0.05050659, -0.012008667, -0.03201294, 0.02633667, 0.019348145, -0.00831604, -0.010047913, 0.015068054, -0.03149414, -0.015457153, 0.025177002, 0.064331055, -0.02670288, -0.027313232, 0.037994385, 0.013656616, -0.0037117004, 0.048858643, 0.024353027, 0.02861023, -0.09411621, -0.041992188, -0.041900635, -0.010017395, -0.022583008, -0.021560669, 0.031585693, -0.036010742, -0.007843018, -0.05810547, -0.026473999, 0.010566711, 0.014465332, 0.025024414, -0.0070343018, -0.043884277, -0.0051841736, -0.0021457672, 0.021957397, -0.038208008, -0.014816284, 0.058380127, 0.014297485, -0.015792847, 0.03463745, 0.019546509, -0.004272461, -0.0071640015, 0.010787964, -0.008644104, -0.0042266846, 0.035491943, 0.023040771, -0.03378296, -0.0012731552, -0.08337402, -0.011207581, 0.05758667, 0.0030136108, -0.022491455, 0.04574585, -0.08300781, 0.041809082, -0.013511658, -0.015083313, 0.027648926, 0.033599854, 0.00806427, 0.024932861, 0.02268982, -0.016464233, 0.0025463104, -0.03527832, -0.13220215, 0.023956299, -0.0012550354, -0.012107849, -0.010795593, -0.046875, -0.06665039, -0.0018072128, -0.0052871704, 0.019607544, 0.034698486, 0.022277832, 0.0060157776, -0.016403198, -0.00043320656, -0.040100098, -0.007801056, -0.008911133, -0.03213501, 0.023223877, -0.01084137, 0.028045654, 0.021362305, -0.025680542, -0.022903442, 0.012687683, -0.009117126, 0.020080566, -0.011238098, -0.02659607, 0.011276245, -0.011650085, 0.0028419495, 0.007762909, -0.0053520203, 0.0027427673, -0.02394104, 0.0047569275, -0.035186768, 0.035095215, -0.005001068, 0.015975952, -0.011329651, -0.058410645, 0.013168335, -0.04486084, -0.051818848, 0.0020275116, 0.060699463, -0.003440857, 0.01675415, -0.011734009, -0.026153564, 0.045013428, -0.0050849915, -0.055145264, -0.03074646, -0.021621704, 0.013427734, -0.0006108284, -0.0103302, 0.0028972626, 0.0084991455, 0.012413025, 0.0056533813, -0.006084442, -0.022201538, -0.08026123, -0.0064353943, -0.0018892288, -0.13464355, -0.029159546, 0.0031337738, -0.008262634, -0.0026760101, -0.05606079, 0.028167725, -0.018981934, -0.050323486, 0.013763428, -0.019088745, 0.0032539368, -0.019485474, -0.07977295, -0.012229919, 0.06793213, 0.0074806213, 0.025222778, 0.04937744, -0.022125244, -0.04675293, -0.01928711, 0.049591064, 0.017166138, 0.0034160614, 0.025939941, -0.035736084, 0.033111572, -0.02418518, 0.01776123, 0.049865723, 0.008956909, 0.010498047, -0.0058517456, -0.0008506775, 0.028656006, -0.026733398, 0.032470703, 0.020339966, -0.026641846, -0.04498291, 0.039916992, 0.0017557144, 0.0073242188, 0.010620117, -0.025268555, 0.002796173, 0.0061073303, -0.0006685257, 0.029052734, 0.0024986267, -0.006362915, 0.03793335, 0.010101318, -0.0070495605, -0.008018494, 0.007007599, 0.020263672, 0.01676941, 0.044555664, 0.0053100586, 0.04156494, -0.027282715, -0.008377075, -0.0149383545, 0.008850098, -0.055389404, -0.007843018, -0.03857422, -0.018615723, -0.019012451, 0.018981934, -0.035858154, 0.033233643, 0.06677246, 0.002319336, -0.019515991, -0.011558533, 0.04776001, -0.009536743, -0.01725769, -0.083984375, 0.010360718, -0.016723633, -0.04574585, -0.031402588, -0.025131226, -0.004650116, 0.03933716, 0.0031604767, -0.018417358, 0.028533936, 0.026138306, 0.07269287, 0.06347656, -0.0020561218, -0.061767578, 0.08129883, -0.027618408, -0.02104187, 0.026321411, -0.016952515, 0.0032539368, -0.0127334595, 0.029052734, -0.022094727, -0.014770508, -0.06323242, 0.023040771, -0.022659302, 0.028808594, 0.008834839, 0.037139893, 0.025558472, 0.0043792725, 0.037750244, 0.011474609, -0.026809692, -0.00023365021, 0.013694763, 0.04837036, -0.009094238, 0.011184692, 0.05117798, 0.012512207, 0.008338928, -0.005874634, -0.009437561, 0.02067566, 0.013259888, -0.019241333, 0.03414917, -0.047576904, -0.01411438, -0.0084991455, 0.007183075, 0.054626465, -0.053497314, 0.02545166, -0.0116119385, 0.023254395, 0.030075073, -0.023239136, 0.008666992, -0.0033779144, 0.024597168, -0.054901123, -0.042114258, -0.007980347, 0.033691406, -0.023925781, 0.0053634644, 0.0075798035, 0.0035629272, 0.021957397, 0.06088257, 0.073791504, -0.049743652, -0.012107849, -0.02696228, -0.009109497, -0.007827759, -0.044921875, 0.011932373, 0.019851685, 0.013397217, -0.037017822, 0.012168884, -0.06738281, -0.01247406, -0.009651184, -0.030548096, 0.029052734, -0.08062744, 0.018081665, 0.08123779, 0.002588272, 0.02848816, 0.0021514893, 0.021408081, 0.0138168335, 0.06323242, 0.007358551, 0.024765015, 0.04421997, -0.06616211, 0.011474609, -0.002122879, 0.028396606, -0.0021190643, 0.022155762, 0.014770508, 0.00843811, -0.060516357, 0.017456055, 0.005168915, -0.020401001, 0.023971558, -0.040283203, 0.021408081, 0.03062439, -0.0027103424, 0.010375977, -0.04486084, -0.025939941, -0.0178833, -0.014808655, -0.0546875, 0.00019049644, -0.012832642, -0.04852295, -0.06109619, 0.022506714, -0.02456665, 0.015182495, 0.0030784607, -0.016433716, -0.05630493, 0.03479004, 0.024002075, -0.031555176, 0.0013093948, -0.0071372986, 0.0039749146, 0.03253174, 0.021408081, 0.0027713776, 0.0019016266, 0.005683899, -0.05102539, -0.039093018, 0.027542114, -0.0075302124, -0.007965088, 0.0051078796, -0.033111572, -0.002418518, 0.012123108, 0.018508911, -0.0024814606, -0.0074691772, 0.0395813, 0.0023860931, -0.0015697479, 0.0020046234, 0.008804321, -0.018722534, 0.0087509155, 0.023651123, -0.017700195, 0.023086548, -0.009475708, 0.030273438, -0.01210022, -0.06237793, 0.0013046265, 0.027267456, 0.017623901, 0.007217407, 0.017028809, 0.037231445, 0.043182373, 0.00055503845, 0.02330017, 0.05718994, -0.051239014, 0.010902405, -0.023208618, -0.0014400482, -0.039367676, 0.077819824, -0.017501831, 0.008491516, -0.054351807, -0.03427124, -0.01576233, 0.03010559, 0.0064430237, 0.0057868958, 0.0011892319, -0.04345703, 0.025024414, -0.022521973, -0.0020160675, -0.031311035, 0.01914978, -0.014968872, -0.038970947, 0.024307251, 0.007068634, 0.0077667236, -0.033111572, 0.012062073, 0.026443481, 0.0061531067, 0.016326904, -0.05239868, 0.004699707, -0.02861023, -0.042785645, 0.038757324, -0.011726379, 0.0033950806, 0.047943115, -0.025756836, 0.06188965, 0.035736084, 0.030014038, 0.044647217, 0.0043563843, 0.023132324, -0.0048942566, -0.008407593, -0.024002075, 0.033599854, -0.046569824, 0.014526367, -0.049987793, -0.0061035156, -0.09442139, -0.024917603, 0.040222168, 0.009979248, 0.024765015, 0.0023479462, 0.020477295, 0.011062622, 0.01625061, 0.012451172, 0.028686523, -0.008529663, 0.010559082, -0.030593872, -0.036315918, 0.044647217, 0.057525635, 0.010818481, -0.013343811, -0.017608643, -0.022903442, 0.0046424866, 0.027236938, 0.008285522, -0.05050659, -0.017623901, -0.05392456, 0.040618896, 0.00006908178, 0.033172607, 0.046081543, 0.05404663, -0.059173584, 0.01096344, 0.021469116, -0.035217285, -0.0101623535, -0.031555176, 0.0069084167, -0.07147217, 0.026977539, 0.014015198, -0.009391785, -0.034820557, 0.04147339, 0.031433105, -0.04067993, -0.017089844, 0.0418396, 0.028930664, -0.015052795, 0.02178955, -0.041137695, -0.007972717, -0.0025043488, 0.0012569427, -0.0045280457, 0.007598877, 0.03186035, 0.030303955, 0.0015134811, -0.020568848, -0.0027008057, 0.023422241, -0.01512146, 0.029022217, -0.017990112, 0.029296875, -0.012565613, -0.04260254, 0.0079193115, 0.0055389404, -0.04977417, -0.032348633, 0.011131287, 0.017974854, 0.023422241, 0.067993164, 0.025741577, -0.0010433197, -0.038604736, -0.03161621, 0.0024280548, 0.042510986, -0.04019165, 0.023284912, -0.040405273, -0.04940796, 0.030349731, -0.062805176, 0.057922363, -0.04949951, -0.014602661, -0.025650024, 0.036132812, -0.005680084, -0.016021729, -0.028869629, -0.023468018, -0.043121338, -0.0008969307, 0.015434265, -0.00944519, -0.006340027, -0.00083875656, -0.002904892, 0.010749817, 0.017486572, -0.008804321, -0.035339355, -0.026321411, 0.035308838, -0.018859863, 0.06311035, -0.023727417, 0.0036506653, -0.005748749, -0.007873535, 0.00084638596, -0.024902344, -0.030273438, -0.018310547, -0.008460999, -0.007827759, 0.011604309, 0.037200928, -0.0052490234, -0.05480957, -0.020965576, -0.002817154, -0.04537964, 0.030212402, 0.017745972, -0.044769287, -0.00983429, 0.0018434525, -0.020217896, 0.035186768, 0.020126343, -0.016067505, 0.02822876, 0.017669678, -0.03286743, 0.0077781677, 0.011947632, 0.03086853, -0.0049743652, -0.010856628, 0.00031757355, 0.017028809, 0.043304443, -0.07611084, -0.074401855, -0.013931274, 0.024902344, -0.002412796, 0.049926758, 0.05279541, -0.0096206665, -0.015090942, -0.014457703, -0.015296936, -0.02394104, -0.0053482056, -0.0051078796, 0.0473938, 0.06378174, -0.010192871, 0.0046081543, 0.037353516, -0.0065078735, -0.007411957, 0.0078048706, -0.007293701, 0.004196167, 0.005344391, 0.008583069, -0.028640747, -0.026855469, -0.07409668, 0.033843994, -0.010231018, 0.043914795, -0.016143799, 0.03366089, 0.013191223, 0.05517578, -0.024108887, -0.063964844, 0.04901123, 0.028289795, 0.011016846, 0.024520874, 0.001991272, -0.019470215, -0.011054993, -0.0041007996, 0.0075416565, 0.010612488, 0.031829834, -0.033203125, 0.017074585, -0.06439209, -0.023147583, -0.024871826, -0.024520874, 0.053741455, -0.047088623, -0.0074386597, -0.028930664, -0.030029297, -0.005683899, 0.042907715, 0.009376526, -0.03366089, -0.01424408, 0.033966064, 0.05432129, -0.007423401 ], "summary": [ -0.0011205673, -0.0345459, -0.042907715, -0.056884766, -0.064575195, -0.015731812, -0.09234619, 0.016921997, 0.061431885, 0.012771606, -0.04647827, -0.0038642883, 0.02772522, -0.012184143, 0.005706787, -0.008636475, -0.004310608, 0.02508545, 0.008155823, -0.017105103, -0.015037537, -0.033111572, 0.015060425, -0.048736572, 0.015083313, -0.059753418, 0.0055732727, 0.012039185, 0.02835083, 0.03012085, 0.017059326, -0.03036499, 0.020690918, 0.03704834, -0.039611816, -0.0016498566, -0.026123047, 0.013069153, -0.0016412735, 0.03933716, 0.008483887, 0.007106781, 0.057434082, -0.022918701, -0.012641907, 0.037017822, -0.022018433, -0.031982422, 0.024627686, 0.011222839, 0.011619568, 0.008102417, 0.0102005005, -0.0036468506, -0.016448975, -0.00995636, -0.10272217, 0.0047912598, 0.017807007, 0.07080078, 0.03652954, -0.064697266, -0.010978699, -0.030929565, -0.025115967, -0.024597168, 0.037109375, -0.00957489, 0.04269409, -0.044036865, 0.011428833, 0.068237305, 0.044311523, -0.068115234, -0.015899658, 0.047912598, 0.009552002, 0.047088623, 0.02027893, -0.06341553, 0.01940918, 0.038085938, 0.013587952, -0.041992188, -0.015579224, -0.070739746, -0.0046806335, 0.012969971, -0.0149383545, -0.014335632, -0.011810303, -0.027893066, -0.049224854, 0.0569458, 0.035369873, -0.044036865, -0.025543213, -0.061035156, 0.00522995, -0.011352539, 0.03543091, -0.024215698, 0.015090942, 0.0001757145, 0.012611389, 0.025100708, -0.034057617, -0.00223732, 0.056427002, 0.031677246, 0.010498047, 0.0005145073, 0.012573242, -0.030303955, 0.016708374, 0.02520752, 0.000538826, 0.06964111, 0.008125305, 0.050048828, 0.0023536682, 0.02432251, -0.031066895, 0.031341553, 0.006919861, 0.0023097992, 0.006385803, 0.03111267, 0.027160645, -0.0051498413, -0.028381348, 0.040130615, -0.02394104, -0.03451538, -0.046020508, 0.002626419, 0.015701294, 0.019638062, 0.007572174, -0.02407837, 0.0077171326, 0.0007662773, -0.009002686, 0.011047363, 0.006225586, 0.05041504, 0.01878357, -0.019073486, -0.011016846, -0.0463562, 0.012428284, -0.058166504, 0.05911255, -0.025909424, -0.031021118, -0.06866455, -0.05682373, -0.02722168, 0.0096588135, -0.028701782, 0.00642395, -0.02305603, 0.026855469, 0.013458252, -0.015991211, 0.023422241, -0.03062439, -0.013763428, 0.020858765, 0.019012451, 0.0029525757, 0.025100708, -0.0042533875, -0.02268982, -0.009208679, -0.021453857, 0.02204895, 0.036224365, 0.0043907166, 0.01727295, 0.038146973, -0.008995056, 0.06933594, 0.0039405823, -0.02671814, -0.011482239, -0.006839752, 0.014015198, 0.05307007, 0.0056152344, 0.009613037, -0.038208008, -0.025222778, 0.024368286, 0.0032901764, -0.0043525696, 0.012619019, 0.016616821, 0.016433716, -0.03665161, -0.014511108, 0.026168823, -0.017227173, -0.0068626404, -0.027938843, 0.0074920654, 0.00012910366, 0.024139404, -0.028182983, 0.032226562, 0.035888672, 0.013076782, -0.032318115, -0.03390503, -0.009094238, -0.045837402, 0.004337311, -0.010131836, 0.025939941, -0.0030326843, 0.04864502, 0.025924683, 0.010948181, 0.027572632, -0.0256958, 0.022659302, -0.037231445, 0.016967773, -0.023620605, 0.011779785, 0.01725769, 0.017990112, 0.028015137, 0.049957275, -0.006931305, -0.015388489, 0.0049591064, -0.05581665, 0.034057617, 0.027633667, 0.010215759, -0.013412476, -0.043273926, -0.013336182, 0.028182983, 0.017410278, 0.012268066, -0.02218628, -0.02468872, 0.023132324, -0.016098022, 0.041137695, 0.014671326, 0.009414673, -0.0047416687, 0.03817749, 0.0047035217, -0.041290283, -0.014503479, -0.0039253235, 0.021957397, -0.049926758, -0.06524658, -0.0040283203, -0.052124023, -0.041229248, -0.021713257, -0.011512756, 0.03414917, -0.057006836, 0.011047363, -0.03729248, -0.00009012222, -0.060913086, -0.07458496, -0.028015137, -0.030685425, 0.079711914, 0.0011882782, -0.060180664, -0.0037155151, 0.010955811, 0.02583313, -0.018005371, 0.0041770935, 0.01739502, 0.017623901, -0.029953003, -0.017166138, 0.030227661, 0.028274536, 0.027496338, -0.012283325, -0.0004146099, 0.014419556, 0.0138168335, 0.011108398, -0.002281189, 0.0073127747, -0.0006723404, 0.024459839, 0.058532715, 0.0066184998, -0.003047943, 0.026321411, -0.02532959, 0.0038719177, 0.041625977, 0.019012451, -0.02015686, -0.024856567, 0.044555664, 0.022201538, 0.051757812, -0.022232056, -0.01864624, 0.0057029724, 0.036254883, 0.0025558472, 0.015670776, 0.09387207, 0.044189453, 0.001332283, 0.01184845, 0.014762878, -0.0513916, 0.021087646, -0.022964478, 0.018341064, -0.0011348724, -0.034362793, -0.037902832, -0.04788208, -0.037109375, -0.019348145, -0.026153564, 0.009963989, -0.04977417, -0.011047363, 0.051971436, 0.055603027, 0.009613037, 0.007255554, -0.024536133, -0.010101318, -0.019424438, 0.03265381, -0.012832642, 0.0073509216, 0.019821167, -0.012283325, -0.021865845, 0.006088257, 0.048858643, 0.045288086, -0.043945312, -0.027999878, 0.051574707, 0.0001462698, -0.012825012, 0.023590088, 0.038085938, 0.0022258759, -0.10827637, -0.023544312, -0.03353882, -0.0065612793, -0.033813477, 0.021713257, 0.03668213, -0.0015306473, 0.06124878, -0.09918213, -0.01576233, -0.014862061, 0.007217407, 0.08459473, 0.0007081032, -0.0284729, 0.04598999, 0.0041885376, 0.017211914, -0.017242432, -0.016693115, 0.07745361, 0.006450653, -0.0670166, 0.041381836, -0.034057617, 0.013298035, -0.04034424, -0.0028209686, 0.02168274, -0.030319214, 0.027954102, 0.018066406, -0.03326416, 0.015014648, -0.02330017, -0.027618408, 0.06903076, 0.036376953, 0.031280518, 0.03353882, -0.046691895, 0.05029297, -0.00054883957, 0.006828308, 0.021697998, -0.003660202, 0.014785767, -0.03314209, 0.00970459, -0.021102905, -0.03137207, -0.01550293, -0.006011963, 0.03060913, -0.027297974, -0.032592773, -0.013801575, 0.039276123, -0.058654785, -0.040985107, 0.0006542206, 0.02507019, 0.007118225, 0.046173096, -0.02670288, -0.003698349, 0.019592285, -0.050109863, -0.0038890839, 0.012954712, -0.008758545, 0.029418945, -0.027526855, -0.031921387, 0.011665344, -0.06072998, -0.0013036728, -0.040405273, -0.008132935, 0.008987427, -0.0206604, -0.008155823, -0.025863647, -0.0004606247, 0.021347046, 0.05206299, -0.009765625, -0.023468018, -0.006187439, 0.019439697, -0.04699707, 0.046661377, -0.035369873, 0.009552002, -0.005783081, -0.03970337, 0.017410278, 0.0056495667, -0.06652832, -0.018997192, 0.066223145, 0.00082302094, -0.029190063, 0.0012273788, -0.013969421, 0.030715942, 0.03643799, -0.058502197, -0.019729614, 0.0006198883, -0.03253174, -0.036193848, 0.041870117, 0.028045654, 0.024414062, -0.033111572, -0.06097412, 0.025634766, -0.016113281, -0.051361084, -0.059661865, 0.03253174, -0.05807495, -0.034210205, 0.0073013306, 0.018234253, 0.023376465, -0.030975342, 0.043670654, -0.0075302124, -0.026672363, 0.0035190582, -0.031311035, 0.08453369, -0.00289917, -0.05831909, 0.045043945, -0.034973145, 0.027832031, 0.03881836, -0.03265381, 0.010093689, 0.037322998, 0.028839111, 0.015655518, -0.02671814, 0.04269409, -0.010261536, -0.022369385, -0.0015487671, -0.0053596497, 0.008834839, 0.026031494, -0.020324707, 0.014137268, 0.004119873, 0.03527832, 0.072265625, -0.008605957, 0.0051078796, 0.034362793, -0.006790161, -0.00944519, 0.012786865, 0.023101807, 0.006626129, -0.005065918, -0.020584106, -0.009925842, 0.022659302, 0.03036499, 0.006175995, -0.0045280457, -0.057769775, 0.05618286, 0.059661865, 0.02519226, -0.009849548, -0.03729248, 0.06112671, 0.0032367706, 0.012557983, 0.0060920715, 0.022628784, -0.038238525, -0.009933472, -0.003774643, 0.023025513, -0.049804688, -0.05444336, 0.0039787292, 0.0021305084, 0.007789612, -0.0015678406, -0.005001068, 0.020095825, -0.00045013428, -0.0049476624, -0.00440979, 0.009269714, 0.017227173, 0.03149414, -0.06970215, -0.09661865, 0.004524231, -0.010429382, -0.04348755, -0.01890564, -0.073791504, -0.058410645, -0.020599365, 0.004798889, -0.020248413, 0.01979065, 0.0096206665, 0.04055786, 0.023132324, 0.017303467, -0.03564453, 0.02696228, -0.022521973, 0.002111435, 0.0027999878, -0.03164673, -0.005706787, 0.0012655258, 0.026824951, -0.010948181, -0.042114258, -0.10522461, -0.0020866394, 0.024536133, -0.026489258, 0.06829834, 0.019470215, 0.021530151, 0.0053634644, 0.03213501, 0.013771057, 0.009132385, -0.032073975, 0.030960083, -0.014404297, 0.043273926, 0.0021476746, 0.053588867, -0.014160156, 0.0016546249, -0.0042915344, -0.018630981, 0.008377075, 0.026733398, 0.008331299, 0.010177612, -0.033477783, -0.026184082, -0.007019043, -0.015655518, -0.0059661865, -0.012832642, -0.045928955, 0.014533997, 0.011138916, 0.03729248, -0.009361267, 0.016296387, 0.06591797, 0.0034160614, -0.0011548996, -0.022781372, 0.006038666, 0.012031555, 0.011024475, -0.023910522, -0.044281006, 0.0075149536, 0.026031494, -0.013420105, 0.018188477, -0.0680542, -0.03945923, -0.039916992, -0.016952515, 0.022247314, -0.032165527, -0.030578613, -0.008872986, -0.0014123917, 0.018676758, -0.00957489, -0.019073486, -0.0009236336, -0.05496216, 0.016983032, 0.01876831, -0.015281677, -0.06323242, 0.025405884, -0.01071167, 0.010345459, 0.0362854, -0.02116394, -0.06329346, 0.04434204, -0.03955078, 0.01486969, 0.041625977, -0.11773682, 0.0044898987, -0.00674057, 0.0072784424, 0.012573242, 0.011230469, 0.0116119385, 0.0034770966, -0.029830933, -0.0058135986, -0.01084137, 0.024047852, -0.027038574, -0.0023708344, 0.04046631, 0.007411957, -0.01777649, -0.0051498413, 0.00187397, -0.017959595, -0.017059326, 0.00007933378, -0.025360107, -0.016220093, -0.014579773, -0.01576233, -0.025817871, -0.012863159, -0.009674072, 0.03665161, 0.0053901672, -0.009994507, -0.0385437, -0.019302368, 0.0124053955, 0.012046814, 0.007820129, 0.020599365, 0.0154953, 0.0060195923, -0.0059127808, 0.012893677, 0.006198883, 0.009895325, -0.031707764, -0.051757812, -0.011245728, -0.037506104, 0.02482605, 0.032073975, 0.049957275, -0.0008506775, -0.04498291, 0.020370483, -0.06500244, -0.0181427, 0.038360596, -0.035064697, -0.049926758, 0.021347046, -0.019454956, -0.0121154785, 0.0048675537, 0.011741638, -0.07208252, 0.05117798, 0.0155181885, 0.02671814, -0.00054740906, -0.040740967, 0.018356323, 0.01625061, -0.025405884, 0.05206299, 0.0881958, 0.04953003, 0.022415161, 0.048797607, 0.054901123, 0.03137207, -0.019805908, 0.04232788, -0.00970459, 0.028579712, -0.045776367, 0.005958557, -0.00049066544, 0.068115234, -0.047729492, -0.030822754, 0.025787354, 0.03302002, -0.0074539185, 0.0209198, 0.019012451, -0.00095558167, 0.07232666, -0.011421204, -0.030136108, -0.023651123, -0.000767231, -0.031097412, -0.021057129, 0.07763672, -0.012504578, -0.024993896, -0.014144897, -0.015266418, 0.028335571, 0.022140503, 0.025268555, -0.0018854141, -0.016830444, -0.0039138794, 0.014228821, -0.0051956177, 0.020736694, -0.01322937, -0.0019836426, -0.012756348, 0.045562744, 0.06573486, -0.012992859, 0.01979065, -0.033813477, -0.03086853, 0.0126571655, -0.011772156, -0.01184082, 0.054351807, -0.000039339066, 0.011207581, -0.03729248, -0.025314331, -0.07458496, 0.08483887, -0.008453369, -0.003627777, 0.04006958, -0.005996704, 0.014305115, 0.050567627, -0.07611084, 0.029785156, -0.0073280334, -0.013130188, -0.0010519028, -0.019714355, -0.02772522, 0.024627686, 0.04144287, -0.009742737, 0.021881104, 0.020462036, 0.0015821457, 0.040283203, -0.011245728, -0.021148682, -0.083862305, 0.039764404, -0.053253174, 0.03439331, 0.030029297, 0.06970215, -0.0013837814, -0.0014867783, -0.033935547, 0.03010559, -0.018676758, 0.01651001, 0.03125, -0.03164673, 0.015380859, -0.028198242, -0.019561768, 0.027435303, -0.00011050701, 0.031585693, 0.026245117, 0.044189453, -0.03314209, 0.00730896, 0.019424438, 0.005001068, -0.0077171326, 0.013885498, -0.05718994, -0.011505127, -0.055725098, -0.046173096, 0.0011606216, -0.06628418, 0.010276794, 0.022003174, 0.00907135, -0.0021247864, 0.008483887, -0.014190674, 0.0008955002, 0.036956787, 0.0017290115, 0.030838013, -0.01309967, -0.024765015, 0.02909851, 0.004890442, 0.00037693977, 0.009681702, 0.022491455, 0.05609131, 0.035980225, 0.038085938, -0.02204895, 0.012886047, 0.029968262, -0.013549805, 0.01574707, -0.02319336, -0.022216797, -0.04071045, -0.007820129, 0.0046844482, -0.010475159, -0.030197144, -0.0058059692, -0.03277588, -0.0025978088, -0.018035889, -0.0013523102, -0.021621704, 0.0018844604, -0.0015583038, -0.03302002, -0.05935669, 0.05392456, 0.047698975, -0.040222168, -0.0071411133, 0.0074539185, -0.04763794, -0.000068843365, 0.0050086975, 0.0073623657, -0.02532959, -0.015113831, 0.026626587, 0.023086548, 0.07366943, 0.037506104, -0.027832031, 0.04953003, -0.031204224, 0.04562378, -0.052124023, -0.040618896, -0.028411865, 0.03869629, -0.023895264, 0.0024490356, 0.0052948, -0.014640808, -0.042144775, 0.034729004, -0.013694763, -0.023849487, 0.027618408, 0.0284729, -0.033355713, 0.015388489, 0.018295288, -0.021942139, 0.037231445, -0.005180359, -0.01979065, 0.009864807, 0.0309906, -0.050628662, 0.01676941, -0.013442993, 0.013336182, -0.024993896, -0.013793945, -0.015335083, 0.00016498566, 0.026626587, -0.04147339, -0.007457733, 0.0071258545, 0.03945923, 0.0025634766, -0.0126953125, 0.016052246, -0.011817932, 0.007598877, -0.0017776489, -0.008857727, -0.0062026978, 0.003200531, -0.023254395, 0.01033783, 0.008766174, -0.02331543, 0.012809753, 0.03829956, -0.03186035, -0.013122559, -0.010498047, -0.015777588, -0.026855469, 0.009567261, 0.003929138, -0.0107421875, -0.023284912, -0.009681702, -0.020339966, -0.0045661926, -0.030410767, -0.028213501, 0.030899048, -0.07147217, -0.04385376, -0.042022705, 0.010932922, 0.0047721863, -0.018356323, 0.024932861, -0.044891357, 0.037994385, 0.030670166, -0.012687683, 0.020996094, 0.022598267, 0.04598999, -0.018447876, -0.006286621, 0.019226074, -0.03010559, 0.0003964901, -0.055389404, -0.020217896, 0.02468872, -0.041259766, 0.003578186, -0.019256592, -0.007587433, 0.009674072, -0.003458023, -0.014518738, -0.0112838745, 0.038848877, 0.028961182, -0.007987976, 0.032714844 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06758v1
Sharing, Teaching and Aligning: Knowledgeable Transfer Learning for Cross-Lingual Machine Reading Comprehension
Tingfeng Cao, Chengyu Wang, Chuanqi Tan, Jun Huang, Jinhui Zhu
cs.CL
In cross-lingual language understanding, machine translation is often utilized to enhance the transferability of models across languages, either by translating the training data from the source language to the target, or from the target to the source to aid inference. However, in cross-lingual machine reading comprehension (MRC), it is difficult to perform a deep level of assistance to enhance cross-lingual transfer because of the variation of answer span positions in different languages. In this paper, we propose X-STA, a new approach for cross-lingual MRC. Specifically, we leverage an attentive teacher to subtly transfer the answer spans of the source language to the answer output space of the target. A Gradient-Disentangled Knowledge Sharing technique is proposed as an improved cross-attention block. In addition, we force the model to learn semantic alignments from multiple granularities and calibrate the model outputs with teacher guidance to enhance cross-lingual transferability. Experiments on three multi-lingual MRC datasets show the effectiveness of our method, outperforming state-of-the-art approaches.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06758v1
2023-11-12T07:20:37
2023-11-12T07:20:37
{ "title": [ -0.051452637, -0.014503479, -0.019989014, -0.03955078, -0.027648926, 0.011985779, -0.048736572, -0.012168884, 0.0037117004, 0.045806885, -0.030303955, 0.016357422, 0.017242432, 0.0077781677, -0.04864502, 0.0047416687, -0.016189575, 0.046936035, -0.014572144, -0.030044556, -0.013877869, -0.038909912, 0.039398193, 0.010192871, 0.025177002, -0.04437256, -0.06768799, 0.0107421875, -0.030288696, -0.03024292, -0.009399414, 0.012893677, 0.039367676, 0.01638794, -0.031097412, -0.012458801, -0.024215698, 0.00076150894, -0.011947632, 0.011512756, 0.021743774, -0.0005273819, -0.03729248, -0.012313843, -0.048736572, 0.019348145, -0.062561035, -0.026870728, -0.01878357, 0.043823242, 0.015525818, 0.016357422, -0.0074768066, 0.050689697, 0.032104492, -0.018005371, -0.020339966, 0.010055542, 0.036071777, 0.06317139, 0.031051636, -0.018600464, -0.000104904175, -0.038391113, -0.03756714, -0.02230835, 0.023422241, 0.005882263, 0.068481445, -0.01991272, -0.026947021, 0.044403076, 0.018051147, -0.025177002, -0.03466797, 0.014221191, 0.036987305, 0.011260986, 0.03564453, -0.050811768, -0.03945923, -0.0151901245, -0.005760193, -0.031097412, 0.009635925, -0.025299072, -0.027008057, 0.0009765625, -0.04699707, -0.090148926, -0.016723633, -0.026107788, -0.07324219, -0.011566162, -0.0075187683, -0.058776855, -0.02204895, 0.03717041, -0.0038452148, -0.024810791, -0.045074463, 0.04916382, -0.07543945, -0.014259338, 0.037017822, 0.013824463, -0.038482666, -0.038391113, 0.023773193, 0.039978027, -0.023925781, 0.029190063, -0.0041046143, -0.027069092, 0.008056641, 0.03491211, -0.014144897, 0.052124023, 0.03189087, 0.031402588, -0.02029419, -0.025482178, 0.0026512146, 0.037628174, 0.030807495, 0.00774765, -0.022247314, 0.016998291, 0.013435364, 0.028457642, 0.0035133362, 0.037475586, -0.086364746, -0.06689453, -0.051696777, 0.02961731, -0.014205933, 0.00504303, -0.018249512, 0.005584717, 0.026977539, -0.012321472, -0.0068130493, 0.014099121, 0.0038986206, 0.0046920776, 0.06921387, -0.00028157234, -0.040130615, -0.057373047, -0.0026664734, 0.017303467, 0.026916504, -0.0028362274, -0.09320068, -0.037139893, -0.13806152, -0.032806396, 0.036956787, -0.012542725, 0.015533447, 0.015914917, 0.011795044, 0.015419006, 0.029388428, -0.021942139, -0.00014209747, 0.015457153, 0.0032138824, -0.015510559, -0.024719238, -0.0000564456, 0.017547607, -0.0055656433, -0.0070266724, 0.03829956, 0.041809082, 0.0025424957, 0.0061950684, 0.0021781921, 0.0008354187, -0.039916992, 0.00085544586, 0.03366089, -0.034942627, -0.06512451, 0.016525269, 0.012916565, 0.05670166, 0.033233643, -0.031951904, -0.013244629, -0.037597656, -0.036712646, -0.035125732, 0.0010099411, 0.01651001, 0.026229858, 0.009361267, 0.002275467, -0.016342163, -0.01525116, -0.0107803345, 0.0012245178, -0.018539429, -0.028152466, -0.022125244, 0.007522583, -0.027679443, 0.053863525, 0.055786133, 0.01612854, -0.053344727, 0.021865845, 0.0066490173, -0.04425049, 0.027542114, 0.00756073, 0.011505127, -0.042053223, 0.02444458, -0.012046814, 0.030059814, 0.052124023, -0.007820129, -0.03869629, 0.016708374, -0.027450562, 0.02218628, 0.0019207001, 0.08666992, -0.026916504, 0.053863525, 0.0138168335, -0.0011281967, 0.0021781921, 0.024368286, -0.041625977, 0.007255554, 0.008033752, -0.005706787, -0.021011353, -0.020965576, 0.01914978, 0.03225708, -0.0032596588, 0.007358551, 0.010131836, 0.00315094, 0.021774292, 0.047851562, 0.011207581, 0.02923584, -0.010726929, 0.010688782, 0.0362854, 0.002040863, -0.008583069, -0.023666382, 0.0054893494, 0.010215759, 0.015899658, 0.0008802414, 0.021713257, -0.053710938, 0.0036201477, -0.016921997, -0.0060768127, 0.0046806335, -0.0090408325, 0.027542114, 0.0010194778, 0.014266968, 0.0069351196, -0.021347046, -0.020095825, -0.022262573, 0.01197052, 0.046447754, -0.042297363, 0.0059432983, 0.023269653, 0.014335632, -0.012588501, 0.03237915, 0.016784668, -0.008773804, -0.030654907, 0.0043792725, -0.020843506, 0.029266357, 0.02659607, 0.00983429, -0.0077056885, 0.028182983, -0.013801575, 0.105529785, 0.036895752, -0.014205933, 0.019500732, -0.032684326, 0.029708862, 0.0077400208, -0.01751709, 0.009361267, 0.017807007, 0.04071045, 0.005897522, -0.024169922, 0.01197052, -0.04562378, -0.0073661804, -0.021255493, -0.0065612793, -0.07952881, -0.072143555, -0.017166138, -0.052459717, -0.06402588, -0.0028152466, 0.12719727, -0.01689148, -0.0259552, 0.008720398, -0.031097412, -0.02142334, 0.004020691, -0.042785645, -0.007572174, 0.025894165, 0.033050537, 0.0071411133, -0.03881836, -0.017990112, -0.017028809, 0.00064611435, -0.014411926, -0.053344727, -0.03390503, 0.039978027, 0.017318726, 0.03503418, 0.039978027, -0.055633545, -0.009719849, -0.045135498, 0.021011353, 0.007610321, -0.03967285, -0.0034542084, 0.03463745, -0.02885437, 0.007396698, 0.041107178, 0.0836792, -0.046569824, -0.058624268, 0.05899048, 0.01550293, -0.0020446777, 0.011779785, 0.014892578, -0.0040245056, -0.042388916, -0.008895874, -0.027999878, -0.017150879, -0.021362305, -0.0003566742, 0.032592773, -0.036590576, -0.0037631989, -0.054534912, -0.0027580261, 0.027526855, 0.0031261444, -0.00289917, -0.02029419, -0.022613525, -0.007194519, 0.006465912, 0.012138367, -0.012039185, -0.016586304, 0.022872925, 0.033050537, -0.00819397, 0.005027771, 0.0076942444, -0.0118637085, -0.0035419464, 0.017364502, -0.011741638, 0.0007200241, 0.03567505, -0.0065574646, -0.015625, 0.015563965, -0.11199951, 0.002128601, 0.09832764, -0.002620697, -0.02557373, 0.049072266, -0.08538818, 0.051971436, 0.019500732, 0.0016584396, 0.0138168335, 0.035064697, 0.0039253235, 0.00415802, 0.007701874, -0.013420105, 0.009666443, -0.03466797, -0.12524414, 0.021560669, -0.035949707, -0.00730896, -0.0025234222, -0.010299683, -0.05496216, -0.008369446, 0.011184692, 0.079589844, 0.02178955, -0.0045204163, 0.025756836, -0.031829834, 0.019943237, -0.035827637, -0.03652954, -0.016525269, 0.00008952618, 0.04751587, 0.014266968, 0.037078857, 0.012580872, -0.0047035217, -0.048614502, -0.003917694, 0.006313324, 0.023452759, 0.00024414062, -0.024124146, -0.008110046, -0.022521973, -0.016983032, 0.005016327, -0.009971619, -0.0027580261, -0.035369873, 0.0067977905, -0.03060913, 0.017440796, 0.019622803, 0.023376465, -0.0066108704, -0.031097412, 0.02670288, -0.026779175, -0.036254883, 0.029800415, 0.02609253, 0.0069351196, -0.0011472702, -0.010002136, -0.057037354, 0.03955078, -0.00061035156, -0.021438599, -0.0017776489, -0.010139465, 0.0018997192, -0.0033664703, -0.021087646, -0.0019130707, 0.004421234, 0.024398804, -0.013084412, 0.010894775, -0.04019165, -0.06744385, -0.006855011, -0.0074424744, -0.08770752, -0.019821167, 0.012466431, -0.018722534, -0.008552551, -0.04736328, 0.02746582, -0.006969452, -0.019699097, 0.0088272095, -0.015083313, -0.0010185242, -0.013336182, -0.08685303, -0.013000488, 0.075805664, 0.0013446808, 0.031433105, 0.04849243, -0.01499176, -0.023406982, -0.0309906, 0.032196045, 0.021743774, 0.027877808, 0.000035881996, -0.024780273, 0.031799316, -0.03050232, -0.0065994263, 0.043304443, -0.036895752, 0.0064926147, 0.021408081, -0.025848389, 0.039398193, -0.03857422, 0.07244873, -0.019683838, -0.024154663, -0.07745361, 0.033111572, -0.010147095, 0.0024166107, 0.02748108, -0.024902344, 0.0335083, 0.017425537, -0.0073547363, 0.06933594, -0.0056610107, 0.011108398, 0.023132324, -0.013671875, -0.036834717, -0.013473511, 0.04977417, 0.016448975, -0.006916046, 0.021972656, -0.018005371, 0.027450562, 0.011497498, -0.026657104, -0.00090408325, 0.0151901245, -0.0317688, -0.022888184, -0.052490234, -0.024917603, -0.008659363, 0.010444641, -0.020080566, 0.038330078, 0.026138306, -0.02772522, -0.019561768, 0.03543091, 0.020584106, -0.0037403107, 0.004837036, -0.052642822, -0.0036144257, -0.007205963, -0.07183838, -0.02406311, -0.061279297, -0.008743286, 0.02319336, 0.007648468, -0.0070228577, 0.02305603, 0.011711121, 0.04336548, 0.056488037, -0.012962341, -0.040802002, 0.050872803, -0.04574585, -0.008522034, 0.034851074, 0.0030822754, -0.0033607483, -0.016998291, 0.03845215, -0.023712158, -0.03427124, -0.049072266, 0.028747559, 0.015975952, 0.011550903, 0.015098572, 0.027008057, 0.028823853, 0.0056381226, 0.029769897, 0.003917694, -0.038024902, 0.001625061, 0.028701782, 0.031280518, -0.010047913, 0.021118164, 0.03060913, 0.028060913, 0.031677246, -0.012901306, 0.024459839, 0.0152282715, -0.017501831, -0.015808105, 0.03152466, -0.028381348, -0.023529053, 0.006729126, 0.012214661, 0.033477783, -0.037139893, 0.0395813, 0.03366089, -0.017105103, 0.0070610046, -0.02571106, 0.034820557, -0.028213501, 0.010536194, -0.0491333, -0.07269287, -0.019851685, 0.0446167, -0.032958984, -0.0037403107, -0.01890564, -0.026031494, 0.036743164, 0.050079346, 0.032165527, -0.008712769, -0.033416748, -0.0026054382, 0.0034713745, -0.043395996, -0.02822876, 0.0063323975, -0.010971069, -0.0033245087, -0.020248413, -0.021224976, -0.04812622, -0.011726379, -0.03378296, -0.004585266, 0.027648926, -0.049194336, 0.018600464, 0.08319092, 0.003835678, 0.03665161, -0.011398315, 0.028137207, 0.015174866, 0.05834961, 0.0049057007, 0.01525116, 0.04547119, -0.030029297, -0.0051994324, 0.008972168, 0.044189453, -0.0016736984, 0.019119263, -0.0049819946, -0.007820129, -0.04940796, 0.030578613, 0.0127334595, -0.043548584, 0.021530151, -0.03729248, 0.031066895, 0.022567749, -0.0009202957, 0.013374329, -0.047668457, -0.0025424957, -0.0019836426, -0.019241333, -0.03164673, 0.024017334, -0.0063934326, -0.056854248, -0.027908325, 0.032989502, -0.0050315857, 0.0010490417, 0.009613037, -0.0030612946, -0.045043945, 0.018844604, 0.023635864, -0.0049324036, -0.023757935, 0.017242432, 0.017532349, 0.024810791, 0.006137848, -0.074035645, -0.019943237, 0.0047302246, -0.02760315, -0.013504028, 0.021347046, 0.019561768, -0.017120361, -0.0053710938, -0.002855301, -0.012863159, -0.027954102, 0.0024490356, 0.0008177757, -0.024536133, 0.03237915, 0.0012283325, 0.016998291, 0.0023822784, 0.01612854, -0.027404785, 0.0024547577, 0.029663086, -0.020324707, 0.025741577, -0.016571045, 0.0031547546, -0.008605957, -0.03668213, 0.004131317, 0.018615723, -0.00982666, 0.016601562, 0.03567505, 0.03930664, 0.043060303, 0.019760132, 0.020401001, 0.06347656, -0.04397583, -0.009269714, -0.026153564, -0.0002567768, -0.024246216, 0.05218506, -0.02986145, -0.010795593, -0.043914795, -0.045074463, -0.017654419, 0.009811401, 0.005176544, 0.0011501312, -0.019546509, -0.06591797, 0.0115737915, -0.025360107, -0.031402588, -0.060821533, 0.03842163, -0.0024795532, -0.008514404, 0.036865234, -0.040985107, -0.02659607, 0.0012540817, 0.017242432, 0.013877869, -0.0005993843, 0.041229248, -0.007507324, 0.009757996, -0.007297516, -0.022521973, 0.016662598, 0.0031738281, -0.023956299, 0.006111145, -0.006427765, 0.06707764, 0.0046653748, 0.0035820007, 0.033935547, -0.017715454, -0.030273438, -0.0070648193, -0.017807007, -0.045135498, 0.01802063, -0.06298828, -0.0001335144, -0.05255127, -0.0049858093, -0.07965088, -0.009506226, 0.02230835, 0.023666382, 0.025924683, -0.0004811287, 0.023330688, 0.031341553, 0.026275635, 0.032714844, 0.04498291, -0.023040771, 0.015586853, -0.048431396, -0.022521973, 0.036834717, 0.0317688, -0.0005197525, 0.025177002, -0.0018377304, -0.02658081, 0.015838623, -0.0015830994, 0.021881104, -0.020858765, -0.019577026, -0.03540039, 0.0056877136, -0.01499176, 0.015083313, 0.057159424, 0.036376953, -0.060577393, 0.011291504, 0.02520752, -0.044128418, -0.0018930435, -0.039031982, 0.011756897, -0.05532837, 0.0395813, -0.011207581, -0.02330017, -0.007858276, 0.034179688, 0.029327393, -0.06439209, -0.05505371, 0.042785645, 0.04776001, 0.017547607, 0.013435364, -0.030380249, -0.0035381317, 0.01638794, 0.01651001, -0.00089502335, 0.0077209473, 0.0068511963, 0.051086426, 0.007194519, 0.016845703, -0.010795593, 0.024856567, -0.0345459, 0.03704834, -0.03302002, 0.022018433, 0.0077705383, -0.029693604, -0.0047073364, 0.025619507, -0.04937744, -0.014549255, 0.033111572, 0.029388428, 0.0287323, 0.068115234, 0.021942139, -0.006401062, -0.006088257, -0.052124023, 0.025436401, 0.038635254, -0.029663086, 0.019119263, -0.048950195, -0.046813965, 0.0036716461, -0.048797607, 0.033172607, -0.033935547, -0.015731812, -0.03955078, 0.019866943, 0.015029907, -0.04034424, -0.015670776, -0.034088135, -0.04425049, -0.001745224, 0.02381897, -0.012321472, -0.03994751, -0.020950317, 0.026443481, -0.02319336, 0.014419556, 0.013946533, -0.03149414, -0.02482605, 0.041778564, -0.00013923645, 0.08178711, -0.03967285, -0.0011281967, 0.0037612915, -0.0033950806, 0.002319336, -0.034057617, -0.019104004, -0.02961731, -0.0044784546, -0.06707764, 0.028015137, 0.008377075, -0.030227661, -0.046051025, -0.051971436, -0.0029449463, -0.046936035, -0.012817383, 0.039520264, -0.041381836, -0.0037994385, 0.002817154, -0.042785645, 0.040740967, 0.0335083, -0.022399902, 0.00043845177, 0.016571045, -0.02859497, -0.003376007, 0.013969421, 0.055023193, -0.008834839, -0.050231934, -0.0029258728, 0.013175964, 0.039398193, -0.050720215, -0.07458496, 0.008514404, 0.035491943, -0.0051078796, 0.03353882, 0.016143799, 0.0025806427, -0.005065918, 0.014213562, -0.0021381378, -0.031311035, 0.013336182, -0.006011963, 0.032592773, 0.053253174, -0.022018433, 0.034698486, 0.03213501, -0.03390503, -0.002855301, 0.00039601326, -0.0058135986, -0.0069465637, 0.001786232, 0.02633667, -0.009284973, -0.05142212, -0.052368164, 0.054016113, -0.021347046, 0.017562866, -0.0039043427, 0.015403748, 0.0044784546, 0.049743652, -0.041259766, -0.062927246, 0.0463562, 0.014434814, -0.0025291443, 0.0105896, 0.01537323, -0.0013113022, 0.001660347, 0.009689331, -0.0018634796, 0.024230957, 0.023483276, -0.021072388, 0.014709473, -0.07159424, -0.031021118, 0.015266418, -0.042633057, 0.050750732, -0.050323486, 0.009475708, -0.032226562, 0.000538826, 0.008369446, 0.031951904, 0.040496826, -0.014678955, -0.031585693, -0.02180481, 0.041870117, -0.015960693 ], "summary": [ -0.033935547, -0.019805908, 0.00041937828, 0.00039744377, -0.06323242, 0.010986328, -0.08123779, -0.03286743, 0.042999268, 0.026153564, -0.060668945, -0.0007224083, 0.058929443, 0.0031547546, 0.007511139, 0.006839752, 0.008201599, 0.040039062, 0.026473999, -0.012886047, -0.0032749176, -0.01751709, 0.012542725, -0.005302429, -0.0016651154, -0.016937256, -0.018798828, -0.010559082, 0.007789612, 0.019195557, -0.0018911362, -0.014808655, 0.036621094, 0.0056495667, -0.049865723, -0.037322998, -0.04324341, -0.016159058, -0.047729492, 0.036590576, 0.013404846, -0.0009918213, 0.02659607, 0.013534546, -0.01374054, -0.01411438, -0.004776001, -0.0446167, 0.0068626404, 0.04611206, -0.009208679, 0.006351471, -0.024871826, 0.042175293, 0.018081665, 0.021392822, -0.048583984, 0.040008545, -0.009605408, 0.06567383, 0.04473877, 0.06161499, -0.037750244, -0.02293396, 0.026992798, -0.0020103455, 0.07312012, 0.020736694, 0.0053100586, 0.01360321, 0.017211914, 0.018844604, 0.020141602, -0.05230713, -0.010978699, 0.049835205, 0.01637268, 0.044067383, -0.0054016113, -0.023345947, -0.048187256, -0.0056991577, -0.030014038, -0.031143188, 0.0004901886, -0.0027065277, -0.027069092, 0.00015223026, -0.018630981, -0.07141113, -0.017303467, 0.0012845993, -0.08068848, 0.00009250641, 0.007144928, -0.07067871, -0.017791748, 0.0056915283, 0.007701874, -0.0032405853, -0.019882202, 0.00048804283, -0.026046753, -0.020462036, -0.00844574, -0.027175903, 0.00036168098, -0.017715454, 0.013092041, 0.03265381, -0.041015625, 0.039733887, -0.0104599, -0.028030396, -0.00089883804, 0.049713135, -0.0008535385, 0.021728516, 0.0036525726, 0.015007019, -0.028518677, -0.006385803, 0.0023841858, 0.058288574, 0.0036411285, 0.0154800415, 0.014839172, 0.003414154, 0.0146865845, -0.010284424, -0.011886597, 0.01473999, -0.014923096, 0.020217896, -0.003736496, 0.0033817291, 0.03112793, -0.0038585663, -0.027191162, -0.023544312, 0.06793213, 0.025238037, -0.00806427, 0.009674072, -0.011268616, -0.012390137, 0.02558899, 0.025177002, 0.00021493435, -0.047821045, 0.043273926, -0.025512695, 0.045532227, -0.024795532, -0.07977295, -0.070007324, -0.06866455, -0.021087646, 0.03717041, -0.023834229, 0.023101807, 0.007598877, 0.012557983, 0.038085938, -0.005584717, 0.000050485134, -0.008216858, -0.004573822, 0.010681152, -0.068115234, 0.0067634583, -0.0072898865, 0.019363403, -0.0065307617, 0.008895874, 0.018127441, 0.0031719208, 0.007972717, -0.0050811768, -0.0026054382, 0.006549835, -0.03765869, -0.0158844, 0.020324707, -0.011619568, -0.04840088, 0.02017212, 0.057006836, 0.03427124, 0.033843994, -0.014846802, -0.04345703, -0.023834229, -0.013519287, -0.030914307, 0.024475098, 0.014823914, 0.047210693, -0.012931824, -0.030426025, 0.050933838, -0.018951416, 0.023406982, -0.02204895, -0.04537964, -0.007835388, -0.01687622, 0.009986877, -0.012779236, 0.0574646, 0.020385742, 0.02986145, -0.043273926, 0.018417358, 0.018447876, -0.0077285767, 0.025253296, -0.008483887, 0.039398193, -0.035705566, 0.05154419, 0.025177002, 0.006954193, 0.030807495, -0.031204224, -0.019989014, -0.012397766, 0.0023422241, -0.0054969788, -0.008102417, 0.045562744, 0.021224976, 0.032196045, -0.00085163116, -0.037994385, 0.017684937, 0.04397583, -0.010520935, -0.0019512177, 0.014297485, 0.018630981, -0.009529114, -0.045776367, -0.019882202, -0.015701294, -0.03289795, 0.0058898926, -0.00071048737, -0.014419556, 0.008590698, -0.0063934326, -0.0020313263, 0.03286743, -0.015808105, 0.0045776367, 0.035247803, -0.02027893, -0.028793335, -0.035888672, -0.0075950623, 0.03668213, -0.06021118, -0.057495117, -0.015106201, -0.015258789, -0.045013428, -0.013381958, -0.036590576, 0.008598328, -0.030075073, 0.028457642, -0.023391724, 0.010772705, 0.0028514862, -0.06903076, 0.0064888, -0.028900146, 0.011520386, 0.03152466, -0.0009174347, 0.012321472, 0.048980713, -0.0079956055, -0.023864746, 0.029205322, 0.011779785, -0.022415161, -0.023757935, 0.029586792, 0.040649414, 0.047332764, 0.01953125, 0.009681702, 0.018218994, 0.01751709, -0.021347046, 0.04324341, -0.0231781, 0.011054993, -0.0028362274, 0.030288696, 0.06982422, -0.005519867, 0.023834229, 0.0061187744, 0.007820129, -0.015991211, 0.0231781, 0.014221191, 0.005760193, -0.055145264, 0.002571106, -0.0006389618, 0.025924683, -0.070495605, -0.05822754, -0.019226074, -0.013381958, -0.046447754, 0.03010559, 0.14575195, 0.033447266, 0.026275635, 0.051757812, -0.0093307495, -0.07092285, 0.08117676, -0.03656006, -0.019638062, -0.013839722, -0.015075684, -0.036590576, -0.021514893, 0.012466431, 0.0037345886, -0.010032654, 0.002067566, -0.12512207, -0.03579712, 0.045043945, 0.039978027, 0.03463745, 0.03692627, -0.052612305, -0.01133728, -0.022262573, 0.042419434, -0.0018396378, -0.005191803, 0.013969421, 0.01499939, -0.015609741, 0.025726318, 0.06311035, 0.055847168, -0.06262207, -0.050048828, 0.09240723, 0.0049743652, 0.0023593903, 0.011207581, 0.032806396, 0.0035743713, -0.059509277, -0.0069999695, -0.009475708, 0.0016384125, -0.03189087, 0.027679443, 0.025268555, 0.044128418, 0.026382446, -0.10015869, -0.021713257, -0.024551392, -0.014724731, 0.029052734, -0.016464233, 0.0052108765, 0.03111267, 0.03277588, 0.033233643, 0.032958984, 0.0064926147, 0.03237915, 0.019851685, 0.022140503, 0.031799316, 0.022232056, -0.010917664, -0.013893127, 0.008529663, 0.026794434, -0.0143966675, 0.007133484, -0.0037269592, -0.001958847, -0.0003554821, -0.018356323, -0.013671875, 0.08691406, 0.064086914, 0.03338623, 0.03668213, -0.05227661, 0.059173584, 0.014381409, 0.027267456, 0.0040779114, 0.021697998, 0.031234741, -0.027160645, 0.022583008, -0.025146484, 0.009033203, -0.031173706, -0.039031982, 0.009292603, -0.02468872, 0.019714355, -0.000626564, 0.014770508, -0.038391113, -0.0028076172, 0.020385742, 0.12243652, -0.049072266, -0.018218994, 0.003622055, 0.0030765533, 0.022018433, -0.0063056946, -0.013931274, 0.044555664, 0.00831604, 0.078308105, 0.011436462, -0.022018433, 0.04196167, -0.055755615, -0.05908203, -0.024261475, -0.005886078, 0.006290436, -0.011955261, 0.0049362183, -0.01625061, -0.041015625, -0.011871338, 0.011016846, -0.026992798, 0.023040771, -0.023223877, 0.016494751, -0.029876709, -0.04006958, 0.022872925, 0.031982422, 0.04837036, -0.04537964, -0.0070991516, -0.013656616, -0.041381836, 0.013832092, 0.03753662, 0.041259766, -0.033843994, 0.0087890625, -0.025222778, 0.004714966, 0.017700195, -0.06555176, -0.022994995, -0.0041542053, -0.024963379, -0.017318726, 0.02394104, -0.0008111, 0.044036865, -0.0068588257, -0.03302002, 0.030075073, -0.03164673, -0.050323486, -0.0024166107, -0.00024747849, -0.04071045, -0.0473938, -0.001168251, 0.019165039, -0.012298584, -0.006629944, 0.027359009, -0.018157959, -0.022415161, 0.012519836, -0.01398468, 0.015731812, -0.030532837, -0.083862305, 0.0001231432, -0.004421234, 0.0026397705, 0.03768921, -0.034606934, -0.0048294067, 0.020507812, 0.011390686, 0.020385742, -0.0028820038, 0.01991272, -0.012390137, 0.03314209, -0.005290985, 0.012626648, 0.009063721, 0.06738281, -0.05355835, 0.049621582, -0.004711151, -0.034973145, 0.037078857, -0.025482178, 0.04135132, -0.01360321, 0.006088257, -0.048828125, 0.061431885, -0.013168335, -0.0049934387, 0.026123047, 0.024032593, 0.0020961761, 0.0010585785, 0.0035858154, -0.005153656, -0.0076026917, -0.007637024, 0.02670288, 0.041534424, -0.03491211, -0.028457642, 0.02558899, 0.060150146, -0.0149002075, 0.020065308, -0.050598145, 0.01486969, 0.031799316, -0.0010557175, -0.011795044, -0.023483276, -0.024856567, -0.042297363, 0.006954193, 0.028060913, 0.00016784668, 0.0011463165, -0.011650085, 0.010276794, 0.010643005, -0.0019159317, -0.016021729, 0.0112838745, -0.0014381409, 0.016082764, -0.041992188, -0.088256836, 0.020629883, -0.030776978, -0.044311523, -0.018188477, -0.06774902, -0.046722412, 0.022537231, 0.021331787, -0.02406311, 0.0032539368, -0.008979797, 0.024597168, 0.021636963, 0.04498291, -0.0017433167, 0.035949707, -0.050567627, 0.048065186, 0.008117676, 0.026107788, -0.011222839, 0.008529663, 0.044921875, -0.010719299, -0.03982544, -0.06304932, 0.013465881, 0.04220581, -0.019439697, 0.045684814, 0.026535034, 0.02444458, 0.00819397, 0.04800415, 0.005302429, -0.015281677, -0.012207031, 0.042266846, 0.02507019, 0.013938904, 0.006511688, 0.014953613, 0.008338928, -0.012420654, -0.0034980774, 0.024810791, 0.021270752, -0.03213501, -0.012466431, 0.033050537, 0.023025513, 0.0021247864, 0.037750244, -0.00055885315, 0.016830444, 0.0019264221, -0.025512695, 0.049713135, 0.009788513, -0.020614624, -0.041931152, 0.01348114, -0.044952393, -0.0013809204, -0.013336182, -0.053131104, 0.011512756, 0.06378174, -0.021942139, -0.006538391, -0.07525635, -0.051605225, 0.025436401, 0.00014960766, -0.019317627, -0.000790596, -0.029159546, -0.009063721, 0.0005402565, -0.032958984, -0.009490967, 0.012825012, -0.04525757, 0.0013628006, 0.012908936, -0.028411865, 0.008842468, 0.012214661, -0.032714844, 0.001871109, -0.0028476715, -0.009674072, -0.035858154, 0.025253296, -0.03186035, 0.025558472, -0.0066337585, -0.004386902, 0.006214142, 0.057281494, -0.019042969, 0.0011005402, 0.024658203, -0.0046043396, 0.020721436, 0.005256653, 0.026672363, 0.006298065, 0.028213501, -0.005794525, 0.010292053, -0.03048706, 0.0060310364, 0.017715454, -0.004760742, 0.007724762, -0.020568848, 0.048187256, 0.011711121, -0.018188477, 0.022964478, -0.010643005, -0.012741089, -0.01939392, 0.017303467, -0.039886475, 0.023712158, 0.03744507, -0.056396484, -0.00522995, 0.009132385, 0.025665283, 0.0112838745, 0.0058135986, -0.00048542023, -0.04421997, -0.018875122, -0.00724411, 0.05596924, 0.002784729, 0.05255127, 0.0033073425, 0.006954193, 0.002128601, -0.064086914, -0.010055542, -0.0063934326, 0.0073127747, -0.0010528564, -0.010169983, -0.0021533966, 0.026412964, 0.004802704, 0.018127441, 0.0069503784, -0.056121826, -0.013900757, -0.0090408325, 0.008613586, 0.03125, 0.0016527176, 0.0149383545, 0.007129669, 0.0181427, -0.0925293, 0.011444092, 0.06311035, -0.016952515, 0.010574341, 0.005218506, -0.0028743744, 0.0048103333, 0.00447464, -0.017196655, 0.025939941, -0.019195557, 0.06591797, 0.060943604, 0.020080566, 0.07739258, 0.013702393, 0.036621094, 0.004333496, -0.0044784546, -0.002620697, -0.013946533, 0.03515625, -0.0051879883, 0.038482666, -0.036346436, -0.009674072, -0.013191223, -0.0017337799, 0.016464233, -0.006385803, -0.0132369995, -0.020401001, -0.014633179, -0.020126343, 0.000007212162, 0.022476196, -0.014404297, -0.05203247, 0.04260254, -0.020217896, -0.019943237, 0.029754639, -0.021759033, -0.064697266, 0.044830322, 0.00010108948, 0.02166748, 0.015342712, 0.051971436, 0.033355713, -0.004623413, 0.0062217712, 0.013160706, 0.026824951, 0.000024735928, -0.03491211, -0.03237915, 0.051971436, 0.053527832, 0.004081726, -0.06890869, -0.0022830963, -0.01083374, -0.040893555, -0.01979065, -0.044189453, -0.018829346, 0.06793213, 0.0008649826, -0.02217102, -0.04663086, -0.048828125, -0.0715332, 0.045837402, -0.013954163, -0.028564453, 0.05505371, -0.012939453, 0.01058197, 0.020050049, -0.053955078, 0.035003662, -0.030181885, -0.008087158, 0.0021018982, -0.023010254, -0.022903442, 0.02998352, 0.038269043, -0.019821167, 0.04547119, -0.025543213, -0.0033664703, 0.023986816, -0.016693115, -0.009307861, -0.046447754, 0.015808105, -0.04348755, 0.0011663437, 0.007133484, 0.027282715, 0.036956787, 0.020645142, -0.05444336, 0.024536133, 0.040161133, -0.035736084, -0.014709473, -0.023544312, -0.008453369, -0.02142334, 0.011909485, -0.015716553, -0.014038086, 0.014526367, 0.02911377, 0.024261475, -0.057434082, -0.019714355, 0.016143799, 0.011520386, 0.023086548, 0.0061569214, -0.030349731, -0.024291992, -0.006591797, -0.009292603, 0.0059127808, 0.0181427, 0.013221741, 0.028289795, 0.028579712, 0.019577026, 0.0059013367, 0.0070152283, -0.01159668, 0.037261963, 0.003074646, 0.023895264, 0.0056152344, -0.027313232, 0.04244995, -0.009719849, -0.020492554, 0.021865845, -0.02458191, 0.024215698, 0.07232666, 0.045806885, -0.034057617, 0.04058838, 0.061065674, -0.025497437, 0.054107666, 0.0027389526, -0.010353088, -0.017669678, -0.025558472, 0.0032596588, -0.026641846, -0.035217285, -0.002243042, -0.037231445, -0.01878357, -0.05114746, 0.03543091, -0.05429077, -0.020385742, -0.008430481, -0.06347656, -0.10534668, 0.033416748, 0.05596924, -0.026870728, -0.029510498, -0.021621704, -0.02796936, -0.034210205, 0.0033073425, 0.020202637, -0.009109497, 0.022140503, 0.0496521, 0.022598267, 0.09967041, -0.022613525, -0.04019165, -0.0126953125, -0.0030651093, 0.037017822, -0.012329102, -0.008255005, -0.02796936, 0.00071525574, -0.028930664, 0.009262085, 0.0018482208, -0.016708374, -0.043121338, -0.031555176, 0.008987427, -0.044036865, -0.013763428, 0.01576233, -0.028427124, 0.037017822, 0.000025391579, -0.027359009, 0.012687683, 0.013572693, 0.0057144165, -0.006580353, 0.03942871, -0.018157959, 0.010749817, 0.007381439, 0.028182983, -0.0068893433, -0.057373047, -0.0012197495, -0.011100769, 0.017974854, -0.022659302, -0.05984497, 0.03778076, 0.051483154, -0.0099105835, -0.009780884, -0.013465881, -0.010551453, 0.018005371, 0.04751587, 0.008621216, -0.023071289, 0.08123779, 0.0440979, 0.059265137, 0.038909912, -0.05886841, 0.07757568, 0.011962891, -0.040863037, -0.002407074, -0.004962921, 0.04284668, -0.017456055, -0.0038032532, 0.0046195984, -0.033935547, -0.07501221, -0.023773193, 0.027420044, -0.0077552795, -0.0056915283, -0.0030727386, 0.011108398, 0.0017261505, 0.0030651093, -0.050872803, 0.028671265, 0.00070524216, -0.010345459, 0.007537842, -0.011077881, 0.034454346, 0.040985107, 0.027740479, 0.031707764, -0.015205383, 0.04724121, 0.04345703, 0.01802063, -0.0025253296, -0.046936035, -0.023101807, 0.0011110306, -0.0309906, 0.011398315, -0.0524292, 0.023590088, -0.00016260147, -0.0124435425, 0.030349731, 0.021530151, 0.050689697, 0.017333984, 0.028274536, -0.019348145, -0.009498596, 0.019973755 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06754v1
From Complex to Simple: Unraveling the Cognitive Tree for Reasoning with Small Language Models
Junbing Yan, Chengyu Wang, Taolin Zhang, Xiaofeng He, Jun Huang, Wei Zhang
cs.CL
Reasoning is a distinctive human capacity, enabling us to address complex problems by breaking them down into a series of manageable cognitive steps. Yet, complex logical reasoning is still cumbersome for language models. Based on the dual process theory in cognitive science, we are the first to unravel the cognitive reasoning abilities of language models. Our framework employs an iterative methodology to construct a Cognitive Tree (CogTree). The root node of this tree represents the initial query, while the leaf nodes consist of straightforward questions that can be answered directly. This construction involves two main components: the implicit extraction module (referred to as the intuitive system) and the explicit reasoning module (referred to as the reflective system). The intuitive system rapidly generates multiple responses by utilizing in-context examples, while the reflective system scores these responses using comparative learning. The scores guide the intuitive system in its subsequent generation step. Our experimental results on two popular and challenging reasoning tasks indicate that it is possible to achieve a performance level comparable to that of GPT-3.5 (with 175B parameters), using a significantly smaller language model that contains fewer parameters (<=7B) than 5% of GPT-3.5.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06754v1
2023-11-12T06:56:21
2023-11-12T06:56:21
{ "title": [ -0.046813965, -0.030899048, -0.03189087, -0.06567383, -0.015090942, 0.025970459, -0.075927734, 0.002981186, 0.004512787, 0.01939392, -0.010368347, -0.014854431, -0.0146484375, -0.032989502, -0.053131104, -0.009567261, -0.0027275085, 0.01991272, -0.037231445, -0.035705566, -0.0048561096, -0.05126953, 0.03302002, 0.043395996, 0.056121826, -0.065979004, -0.046813965, 0.015975952, -0.029663086, -0.02633667, -0.00070667267, 0.010940552, 0.050689697, 0.003768921, 0.0010881424, 0.014297485, -0.053253174, 0.0062561035, 0.0020618439, -0.0012207031, 0.03048706, -0.021118164, -0.014030457, -0.023834229, -0.037872314, 0.014694214, -0.039154053, -0.011779785, -0.010108948, 0.018371582, 0.0007882118, 0.010818481, -0.03390503, 0.034210205, 0.021438599, -0.01033783, -0.0309906, -0.03579712, 0.030944824, 0.06970215, 0.04147339, -0.04611206, 0.006893158, -0.005531311, -0.034118652, -0.011566162, -0.004196167, 0.015281677, 0.09289551, 0.011657715, -0.031341553, 0.03567505, 0.018112183, 0.009902954, -0.046661377, 0.0033626556, 0.037719727, 0.009155273, 0.0340271, -0.035369873, -0.00095176697, 0.0040626526, -0.012962341, -0.011070251, 0.012794495, -0.022521973, -0.026062012, -0.011917114, -0.02243042, -0.07952881, -0.01424408, -0.014091492, -0.019989014, -0.023208618, -0.040527344, -0.030456543, -0.021362305, 0.00440979, 0.018707275, -0.023071289, -0.02406311, 0.030441284, -0.059570312, 0.0035686493, 0.01663208, 0.036895752, -0.03677368, -0.033843994, 0.025756836, 0.033111572, -0.0025672913, 0.02029419, -0.0013656616, -0.009376526, 0.0309906, 0.017196655, -0.034484863, 0.049987793, 0.013244629, 0.04675293, -0.050231934, -0.062042236, 0.021224976, 0.03201294, 0.036132812, 0.016815186, -0.030273438, 0.016540527, 0.011894226, 0.04498291, 0.004081726, 0.02784729, -0.087402344, -0.08831787, -0.061523438, 0.032470703, 0.004852295, -0.00019490719, -0.03112793, 0.006160736, 0.015701294, -0.014823914, -0.0009737015, -0.015296936, -0.024520874, 0.00831604, 0.053588867, -0.0002861023, -0.06335449, -0.06329346, -0.010726929, -0.0035953522, 0.042541504, -0.00053310394, -0.092285156, -0.01876831, -0.15759277, -0.0018873215, 0.014083862, -0.0033073425, 0.0019140244, 0.018569946, 0.014503479, -0.015571594, 0.017227173, -0.03439331, -0.02470398, 0.006427765, 0.009346008, 0.0035495758, -0.0070991516, 0.037963867, -0.029907227, -0.018676758, 0.011947632, -0.015113831, 0.030288696, 0.013511658, 0.014533997, -0.003967285, 0.016555786, -0.022003174, 0.01612854, 0.053344727, -0.056640625, -0.022659302, -0.005882263, 0.008216858, 0.046295166, 0.015930176, -0.04147339, 0.014328003, -0.033813477, -0.03540039, -0.04837036, -0.02381897, 0.038238525, 0.027069092, -0.008163452, -0.008628845, -0.03024292, -0.0015830994, -0.020965576, -0.02368164, -0.019989014, -0.023330688, -0.017028809, 0.028518677, -0.009353638, 0.060546875, 0.05508423, 0.041748047, -0.050231934, 0.010314941, -0.007293701, -0.06304932, 0.021026611, -0.0058403015, -0.0146102905, -0.01625061, -0.013046265, -0.028762817, -0.0052719116, 0.078552246, -0.010902405, 0.009239197, 0.00014722347, -0.0037460327, 0.0287323, 0.029785156, 0.03967285, -0.052459717, 0.042144775, 0.041534424, -0.0058517456, -0.023712158, -0.029190063, -0.0055656433, -0.005027771, 0.009399414, -0.0049972534, -0.02708435, -0.021850586, 0.0047836304, 0.024139404, -0.008354187, 0.014160156, -0.016662598, 0.021057129, 0.017974854, 0.074645996, 0.022109985, 0.048309326, 0.028945923, 0.0024642944, 0.04550171, 0.010681152, -0.020248413, -0.00491333, 0.026641846, 0.013328552, -0.011024475, -0.035003662, 0.004009247, -0.0335083, -0.0008530617, -0.020767212, 0.020706177, 0.022155762, -0.022979736, 0.01121521, -0.0178833, 0.018920898, -0.018066406, -0.020507812, -0.003829956, -0.018051147, 0.015640259, 0.014183044, -0.06414795, -0.011833191, 0.01537323, 0.03741455, -0.0008664131, -0.0009813309, 0.012237549, 0.023330688, -0.0098724365, 0.0065345764, 0.0009832382, 0.044921875, 0.019729614, -0.0016527176, 0.009208679, -0.0016021729, -0.015838623, 0.06719971, 0.07281494, -0.025009155, 0.023376465, -0.04244995, 0.014579773, 0.01838684, -0.029953003, 0.0025939941, 0.017608643, 0.0035972595, 0.04296875, -0.019927979, 0.011016846, -0.058258057, 0.011299133, 0.010131836, -0.029266357, -0.019058228, -0.035614014, 0.017929077, -0.012008667, -0.004749298, -0.007217407, 0.05001831, -0.016723633, -0.036010742, 0.011154175, 0.004333496, -0.017959595, 0.011199951, -0.033355713, -0.01399231, 0.017715454, 0.057678223, 0.025848389, -0.04534912, -0.025634766, -0.0075035095, 0.003917694, -0.0035152435, -0.0065345764, -0.027297974, 0.033599854, 0.019638062, -0.038208008, 0.020309448, -0.04196167, 0.0024909973, -0.048095703, 0.020523071, 0.02659607, -0.012939453, -0.013504028, 0.019485474, -0.024353027, -0.027359009, 0.050842285, 0.080444336, -0.061645508, -0.03302002, 0.070495605, 0.009651184, -0.018630981, 0.028518677, 0.0178833, 0.02418518, -0.04232788, -0.041534424, -0.027908325, -0.02218628, 0.010147095, -0.006149292, 0.026168823, -0.05807495, -0.011123657, -0.041870117, -0.014373779, 0.011245728, 0.01159668, 0.010658264, -0.020248413, -0.05368042, -0.0042533875, -0.03186035, 0.0070152283, -0.040863037, 0.03768921, 0.10266113, 0.0033111572, 0.006023407, 0.021209717, 0.05886841, 0.0064048767, -0.010040283, -0.026809692, -0.036987305, -0.0032787323, 0.012069702, 0.024856567, -0.021499634, -0.0259552, -0.07543945, -0.008140564, 0.0625, -0.0026454926, -0.031402588, 0.036346436, -0.061340332, 0.012214661, -0.008155823, -0.019760132, 0.028839111, 0.027542114, 0.0023765564, 0.010047913, 0.0024814606, -0.03677368, 0.008964539, -0.03869629, -0.1451416, 0.021774292, -0.004146576, -0.023773193, -0.009307861, -0.058258057, -0.047668457, 0.0075683594, -0.04623413, 0.025650024, 0.0016794205, 0.049316406, 0.0047721863, -0.02357483, -0.03692627, -0.013999939, -0.009475708, -0.006958008, -0.019348145, 0.005039215, -0.011299133, 0.016281128, 0.0071029663, -0.015159607, -0.010345459, -0.0178833, -0.039855957, 0.0024032593, 0.0026664734, -0.039886475, -0.009376526, 0.004562378, -0.030899048, -0.021911621, -0.03161621, 0.015335083, -0.023498535, 0.023803711, -0.0021839142, 0.042175293, 0.0012407303, 0.003780365, -0.029800415, 0.00018966198, 0.038909912, -0.010070801, -0.07385254, 0.003944397, 0.05911255, -0.009147644, 0.009475708, -0.006465912, -0.006969452, 0.018157959, 0.0038719177, -0.022888184, -0.0012741089, 0.0119018555, -0.011734009, 0.00079107285, -0.013381958, -0.00655365, 0.0040245056, 0.034362793, -0.015007019, 0.013839722, -0.021270752, -0.0552063, -0.031921387, 0.015823364, -0.101501465, -0.015686035, 0.0026931763, -0.006046295, -0.002588272, -0.03970337, 0.023620605, -0.0028686523, -0.050476074, 0.009613037, -0.022872925, -0.023483276, 0.008758545, -0.068603516, 0.008018494, 0.08929443, 0.0004925728, -0.005695343, 0.030670166, -0.021331787, -0.03439331, -0.053253174, 0.021011353, -0.021896362, 0.02142334, -0.013374329, -0.019546509, 0.038635254, -0.024230957, 0.033233643, 0.02204895, 0.006839752, -0.004142761, 0.0126953125, -0.011978149, 0.008659363, 0.014595032, 0.03189087, 0.004611969, 0.00049352646, -0.04510498, 0.031219482, -0.008239746, -0.022979736, 0.024337769, -0.012573242, -0.011405945, -0.0007314682, 0.01725769, 0.06323242, -0.01146698, -0.012199402, 0.028121948, 0.011253357, -0.009811401, 0.0074539185, 0.018432617, 0.0491333, 0.014282227, 0.025177002, 0.011123657, 0.04711914, -0.024398804, -0.019073486, -0.015106201, 0.019195557, -0.03881836, 0.010116577, -0.046966553, -0.022155762, -0.029693604, 0.0024166107, -0.014915466, 0.061767578, 0.043151855, 0.005176544, -0.019683838, -0.023162842, 0.05126953, -0.001367569, 0.004047394, -0.061065674, -0.013046265, -0.016052246, -0.06561279, -0.024124146, -0.06616211, -0.024536133, 0.015464783, 0.020584106, -0.03451538, 0.017608643, 0.012878418, 0.09484863, 0.06604004, -0.008232117, -0.08441162, 0.049102783, -0.012306213, -0.010650635, 0.0069236755, 0.00705719, 0.0068511963, -0.022125244, -0.009346008, -0.013336182, -0.0032291412, -0.043792725, 0.019134521, -0.019378662, 0.050048828, -0.004878998, 0.0011777878, 0.019058228, 0.009643555, 0.014457703, -0.0026187897, -0.03488159, -0.009811401, 0.00017523766, 0.07196045, -0.0079956055, -0.0049972534, 0.00274086, 0.031402588, 0.028747559, -0.0016822815, -0.0018625259, -0.0034370422, -0.003255844, 0.021316528, 0.020370483, -0.019485474, -0.044403076, -0.0005249977, 0.021118164, 0.03302002, -0.050109863, 0.046691895, -0.04675293, 0.004386902, 0.030166626, -0.010612488, 0.00088214874, 0.01109314, 0.014755249, -0.051361084, -0.041503906, 0.0062789917, 0.041137695, -0.027709961, 0.020965576, -0.0017576218, -0.005908966, 0.002916336, 0.041809082, 0.013786316, -0.044830322, 0.025054932, -0.033966064, -0.048828125, -0.00039291382, -0.046325684, 0.020355225, -0.0017271042, 0.018127441, -0.03829956, 0.016464233, -0.07318115, 0.00008672476, -0.010070801, -0.022399902, 0.02116394, -0.071777344, 0.024276733, 0.08227539, 0.0011711121, 0.04269409, 0.005065918, -0.0019426346, -0.00056409836, 0.076416016, -0.0116119385, 0.041137695, 0.04525757, -0.050720215, 0.010696411, 0.011459351, 0.048339844, -0.02835083, 0.009925842, -0.00207901, -0.009521484, -0.054595947, 0.014526367, -0.006954193, -0.015129089, 0.013916016, -0.045043945, 0.008918762, 0.023086548, -0.0018310547, 0.039123535, -0.01965332, -0.027862549, -0.012283325, 0.0075531006, -0.022460938, 0.024795532, 0.01852417, -0.041046143, -0.052093506, -0.004432678, 0.0033626556, 0.011917114, 0.00598526, 0.00894165, -0.041625977, 0.0051612854, 0.03918457, 0.00415802, 0.023117065, -0.0335083, -0.015098572, 0.05810547, 0.041900635, 0.006591797, 0.008384705, -0.013542175, -0.029449463, -0.01889038, 0.014404297, -0.012519836, 0.0069007874, -0.0063591003, -0.031341553, -0.0008611679, 0.01612854, 0.02947998, -0.0031929016, -0.023254395, 0.014122009, -0.0014953613, -0.0052375793, 0.0018749237, 0.019683838, -0.037750244, 0.015029907, 0.030532837, -0.055755615, 0.019592285, 0.003583908, 0.0037345886, 0.00598526, -0.07696533, 0.014282227, 0.008857727, -0.006526947, 0.0023498535, -0.012046814, 0.029754639, 0.037384033, -0.03414917, 0.0030441284, 0.05657959, -0.051513672, -0.00957489, -0.00491333, -0.010253906, -0.028793335, 0.0793457, -0.005821228, -0.0078048706, -0.049865723, -0.049468994, -0.023223877, 0.0017414093, 0.010536194, 0.002483368, 0.010002136, -0.01953125, 0.02986145, -0.01802063, -0.019012451, -0.039276123, 0.011756897, -0.009239197, -0.008232117, 0.030197144, -0.006931305, -0.0060424805, -0.02835083, 0.028823853, 0.034057617, 0.0004143715, 0.034942627, -0.030761719, -0.0008907318, -0.022445679, -0.033691406, 0.076293945, -0.014305115, -0.0006990433, 0.05178833, -0.000076532364, 0.045562744, 0.041870117, 0.053253174, 0.044158936, 0.012687683, 0.037384033, 0.006099701, 0.0234375, -0.024017334, 0.038879395, -0.05105591, 0.014961243, -0.056396484, 0.0004374981, -0.089660645, 0.01586914, 0.0072898865, 0.010955811, 0.02116394, -0.005378723, 0.010475159, 0.0029563904, 0.03543091, 0.03677368, 0.053741455, 0.013061523, 0.027786255, -0.017425537, -0.036743164, 0.018341064, 0.0440979, -0.0008816719, -0.0027980804, -0.04083252, -0.011894226, 0.0036754608, 0.02748108, -0.008224487, -0.029937744, -0.0049858093, -0.04196167, 0.012748718, -0.008140564, 0.020751953, 0.050323486, 0.038360596, -0.022277832, 0.012908936, 0.0019779205, -0.06756592, -0.021209717, -0.030197144, -0.00894165, -0.043151855, 0.030563354, -0.038391113, -0.015914917, -0.027328491, 0.050079346, 0.03390503, -0.046051025, -0.027801514, 0.007575989, 0.042236328, 0.008155823, 0.024658203, -0.036102295, -0.01939392, -0.010391235, 0.013160706, 0.011711121, 0.050445557, 0.04043579, 0.030792236, -0.007835388, -0.05883789, 0.014678955, -0.03375244, -0.023910522, 0.015213013, 0.047180176, 0.024414062, -0.005859375, -0.035339355, 0.015388489, -0.00014913082, -0.05142212, 0.0020198822, 0.002828598, 0.063964844, 0.036499023, 0.066589355, 0.013298035, -0.02355957, 0.022140503, -0.053527832, 0.021118164, 0.057678223, -0.02230835, 0.013214111, -0.042541504, -0.058624268, 0.031433105, -0.05718994, 0.07287598, -0.06060791, -0.0072631836, -0.028167725, 0.031799316, 0.024932861, -0.043914795, -0.039642334, -0.014480591, -0.030532837, -0.0019521713, 0.00033950806, -0.045043945, -0.01838684, -0.0027580261, 0.008544922, 0.0012559891, 0.021591187, -0.0040626526, -0.047088623, -0.05758667, 0.0463562, 0.0019798279, 0.075927734, 0.0011014938, -0.005542755, -0.004211426, 0.0129852295, 0.0013456345, -0.040374756, -0.033050537, 0.0052490234, -0.009277344, -0.042541504, 0.018173218, 0.013191223, -0.011222839, 0.00045871735, -0.04321289, 0.014671326, -0.016220093, 0.029556274, 0.02709961, -0.05480957, -0.0052833557, 0.01687622, -0.029953003, 0.060760498, -0.0017194748, -0.009239197, 0.036743164, 0.02444458, -0.021133423, -0.01802063, -0.009094238, 0.012786865, 0.001578331, -0.01713562, -0.0052719116, 0.032104492, 0.040771484, -0.0569458, -0.031021118, 0.006477356, -0.002948761, 0.0064315796, 0.011703491, 0.020843506, -0.01335907, 0.0068969727, -0.0014371872, -0.0074424744, -0.045318604, -0.023284912, 0.0020542145, 0.045135498, 0.029769897, -0.0034294128, -0.008544922, 0.014389038, -0.053131104, 0.016921997, 0.014503479, 0.009666443, 0.039154053, -0.01260376, 0.05545044, -0.020080566, -0.013641357, -0.023544312, -0.0105896, 0.009513855, 0.029052734, -0.025405884, 0.0071983337, -0.024337769, 0.038085938, -0.009475708, -0.04650879, 0.040649414, 0.05859375, 0.0075302124, 0.03265381, -0.016906738, -0.0262146, -0.0041885376, -0.0024795532, -0.0011844635, -0.019485474, -0.009300232, -0.023406982, 0.005256653, -0.037200928, -0.010559082, -0.018707275, -0.042816162, 0.052093506, -0.024047852, 0.004634857, -0.039733887, -0.016677856, 0.0037059784, 0.042144775, 0.0050086975, -0.0010089874, -0.049835205, 0.022994995, 0.03604126, -0.017990112 ], "summary": [ 0.006275177, -0.01537323, 0.0013065338, -0.041046143, -0.054870605, 0.022232056, -0.08868408, -0.0029659271, 0.0041275024, 0.030303955, -0.038116455, -0.019195557, 0.016174316, -0.0082473755, -0.033325195, -0.04586792, -0.004234314, 0.03161621, -0.006225586, -0.026672363, 0.023468018, -0.032806396, -0.023635864, 0.039764404, 0.020858765, -0.016677856, -0.049072266, 0.019058228, 0.013206482, 0.015350342, 0.013969421, -0.0049362183, 0.025527954, 0.003484726, -0.027282715, -0.0073280334, -0.013626099, -0.0014753342, 0.0019407272, 0.005279541, -0.009674072, 0.007091522, -0.013580322, -0.02456665, -0.03970337, 0.0149383545, -0.03866577, -0.021911621, 0.05142212, -0.021728516, -0.030639648, 0.042053223, -0.035125732, -0.017700195, -0.008041382, 0.02015686, -0.054992676, -0.057403564, -0.013214111, 0.07635498, 0.048950195, -0.015213013, -0.0039634705, -0.040100098, -0.0262146, 0.0052833557, 0.05923462, -0.023635864, 0.027923584, -0.022338867, 0.01084137, 0.04751587, 0.024124146, -0.021514893, -0.04067993, 0.018173218, 0.009162903, -0.0004081726, 0.02357483, -0.02810669, -0.014198303, 0.020996094, -0.017807007, 0.010406494, -0.023529053, -0.0019397736, -0.021102905, -0.0149383545, -0.027816772, -0.046569824, -0.02279663, 0.0058555603, -0.0619812, -0.029022217, -0.011474609, -0.053863525, -0.03930664, -0.0670166, 0.008361816, -0.04324341, 0.020874023, -0.029663086, -0.030441284, 0.014427185, 0.009811401, 0.029373169, -0.03668213, -0.026931763, 0.042877197, 0.029891968, 0.0030441284, -0.03010559, 0.025726318, -0.06298828, 0.012893677, 0.033294678, 0.008918762, 0.04373169, 0.042907715, 0.0048942566, -0.05618286, -0.035339355, 0.00093889236, 0.07989502, 0.047576904, 0.048431396, 0.017654419, 0.019302368, 0.03543091, 0.009460449, -0.010360718, 0.01940918, -0.04827881, -0.0491333, -0.051971436, 0.0024108887, 0.042877197, 0.019821167, -0.004627228, -0.005432129, 0.02508545, -0.020492554, -0.018966675, 0.009918213, -0.024551392, 0.020843506, 0.03805542, 0.024856567, -0.057891846, -0.06225586, 0.01687622, -0.030181885, 0.029159546, -0.0146102905, -0.08843994, -0.042236328, -0.117004395, 0.022583008, 0.03656006, -0.020874023, -0.01689148, -0.002527237, 0.02142334, 0.008583069, -0.024871826, 0.002588272, -0.007297516, -0.017105103, 0.010536194, -0.014305115, -0.016906738, 0.058898926, -0.008979797, -0.0015382767, 0.008338928, -0.023834229, 0.015434265, 0.009239197, -0.020904541, 0.033599854, 0.024536133, -0.026916504, -0.010505676, 0.010803223, -0.03930664, 0.030303955, -0.007217407, 0.083618164, 0.035858154, 0.0039787292, -0.015670776, -0.024642944, 0.022369385, 0.0019874573, 0.012535095, -0.05709839, 0.006881714, -0.019195557, -0.0043907166, -0.018478394, 0.024230957, -0.0031547546, -0.018035889, -0.03137207, -0.12585449, 0.01676941, -0.046325684, 0.04083252, 0.018463135, 0.0074157715, 0.030136108, 0.022598267, -0.051605225, 0.039764404, -0.039855957, -0.02557373, 0.030288696, -0.0058021545, 0.012863159, -0.006099701, 0.012245178, 0.0030136108, -0.031311035, 0.039001465, -0.004676819, 0.03933716, -0.023864746, 0.029647827, 0.022003174, 0.03161621, 0.006416321, -0.034332275, 0.053863525, 0.070251465, -0.020309448, -0.017303467, 0.0088272095, -0.0037555695, 0.0035381317, 0.02130127, 0.034484863, -0.0037727356, -0.042236328, -0.06500244, 0.0077781677, -0.0024986267, 0.027130127, -0.051330566, -0.00020062923, 0.035888672, 0.045776367, 0.019332886, 0.0053749084, -0.011024475, 0.000541687, 0.023544312, -0.035461426, -0.037506104, 0.031402588, -0.024490356, 0.01890564, 0.009742737, 0.006828308, 0.004463196, -0.0051612854, -0.016952515, 0.036834717, 0.02810669, 0.010772705, -0.048583984, -0.0017242432, 0.0015764236, -0.008407593, -0.05810547, -0.021392822, -0.070373535, -0.009712219, 0.056915283, -0.031555176, -0.069885254, -0.01146698, 0.046051025, 0.01965332, -0.016418457, -0.016967773, 0.05065918, 0.017715454, -0.01689148, 0.011421204, 0.08502197, 0.077941895, 0.020950317, -0.01235199, 0.034179688, 0.010520935, 0.002916336, 0.010070801, 0.012168884, 0.0077056885, -0.02406311, -0.008613586, 0.052581787, -0.012489319, -0.013015747, 0.010681152, -0.018600464, -0.0105896, 0.019638062, 0.0030879974, -0.018249512, -0.030685425, 0.042785645, 0.056365967, 0.03111267, 0.02078247, 0.014732361, -0.008155823, 0.06750488, -0.0050239563, -0.013763428, 0.026123047, 0.027313232, 0.0060424805, 0.03466797, 0.024673462, -0.040802002, 0.058898926, -0.008575439, -0.02078247, -0.0032138824, 0.010597229, -0.025146484, -0.014312744, -0.0005335808, 0.0049057007, -0.0065727234, 0.011161804, -0.020965576, 0.0043144226, 0.05984497, 0.04309082, -0.06317139, -0.007648468, -0.028030396, -0.042755127, -0.004585266, 0.03152466, 0.007083893, 0.0066184998, -0.022018433, 0.036132812, -0.038909912, 0.0119018555, 0.030700684, 0.036315918, -0.029052734, -0.025253296, 0.038604736, -0.012466431, -0.035247803, 0.02281189, 0.018997192, 0.005432129, -0.06359863, -0.043029785, -0.01550293, -0.022338867, 0.010948181, 0.026260376, -0.0017147064, -0.0034008026, 0.03817749, -0.061828613, -0.009155273, 0.015380859, -0.006965637, 0.09350586, -0.0064697266, -0.003835678, 0.044311523, 0.009735107, 0.04324341, -0.044311523, 0.035736084, 0.08917236, 0.0049858093, -0.005088806, 0.00365448, 0.058135986, 0.016921997, -0.004711151, -0.048736572, -0.046905518, -0.015586853, 0.021774292, 0.02909851, -0.027069092, -0.016937256, -0.044891357, -0.023345947, 0.066101074, 0.013870239, 0.0064048767, 0.026245117, -0.046569824, 0.013908386, 0.025558472, -0.0054244995, 0.023406982, -0.058746338, 0.018096924, 0.003189087, 0.0024642944, -0.018859863, -0.010681152, -0.043762207, -0.055023193, 0.0044174194, -0.00969696, 0.018737793, -0.0033893585, -0.02897644, -0.0032787323, 0.032470703, -0.03845215, 0.036468506, -0.0078125, 0.046905518, 0.018539429, -0.026016235, -0.021469116, -0.0184021, -0.016433716, -0.010009766, 0.0060195923, 0.031188965, -0.022232056, -0.01991272, 0.005607605, -0.030151367, 0.012199402, -0.011756897, -0.059020996, -0.011528015, -0.03277588, -0.024353027, 0.010421753, -0.0061531067, -0.01133728, -0.010154724, -0.036071777, 0.013031006, 0.060638428, 0.03640747, 0.004989624, 0.005718231, -0.04748535, 0.0074539185, 0.039215088, 0.0046539307, 0.024154663, -0.0027427673, -0.045440674, 0.009529114, 0.033233643, 0.023620605, -0.026184082, 0.038757324, 0.0023345947, 0.0076065063, 0.046447754, -0.05834961, -0.03262329, -0.0077934265, -0.02545166, -0.0029392242, 0.056121826, 0.0027542114, 0.037841797, -0.028411865, -0.07836914, 0.030303955, -0.022720337, -0.08062744, -0.044036865, 0.013137817, -0.034362793, -0.012313843, -0.02619934, 0.033294678, 0.045043945, 0.011657715, 0.023895264, 0.015197754, -0.028549194, -0.042510986, -0.027404785, 0.041656494, 0.0049819946, -0.06768799, 0.046661377, -0.010772705, 0.023269653, 0.0053367615, -0.058898926, -0.0027122498, 0.03503418, 0.015792847, 0.01574707, -0.064086914, 0.029418945, -0.013679504, -0.034057617, -0.002986908, -0.016586304, 0.020950317, -0.029373169, -0.03994751, -0.015899658, 0.022109985, -0.0028800964, 0.059753418, -0.0023784637, 0.017715454, -0.027954102, 0.0129776, -0.043884277, 0.04208374, -0.014259338, -0.0552063, 0.020080566, 0.013710022, -0.057434082, 0.025299072, 0.03164673, 0.0104904175, -0.014419556, -0.03387451, 0.006454468, 0.028564453, -0.025268555, -0.014305115, 0.013717651, 0.04034424, -0.00063323975, 0.061676025, 0.018630981, 0.060180664, -0.027038574, -0.0012083054, 0.00073194504, 0.014167786, -0.031234741, -0.005718231, -0.008255005, 0.014884949, -0.01725769, 0.0048942566, -0.028945923, 0.05026245, 0.059326172, 0.023208618, -0.008834839, -0.061035156, 0.05984497, 0.0016450882, -0.035186768, -0.09307861, -0.010536194, -0.021240234, -0.029144287, -0.019729614, -0.10662842, -0.0569458, -0.019805908, 0.030441284, -0.08050537, -0.0014028549, -0.005897522, 0.11212158, 0.04949951, 0.041503906, -0.09350586, 0.0033397675, 0.01398468, -0.00031638145, 0.013336182, 0.0036697388, 0.026107788, 0.01838684, -0.0067100525, -0.03475952, -0.012069702, -0.078308105, 0.0062408447, -0.021820068, 0.018951416, 0.03768921, 0.0149383545, 0.018249512, 0.007286072, 0.01461792, -0.0034313202, -0.0024433136, 0.011581421, 0.016418457, 0.023086548, 0.02998352, 0.0016908646, 0.025115967, -0.012741089, 0.0055732727, -0.008262634, -0.004245758, 0.0049743652, -0.000038325787, 0.049957275, 0.014923096, -0.027023315, -0.040252686, 0.005004883, 0.020858765, 0.0066184998, -0.0030498505, -0.02911377, -0.03262329, 0.0071754456, 0.009780884, -0.0236969, 0.0013084412, 0.015716553, 0.01171875, -0.032562256, 0.0013628006, 0.024719238, 0.00004029274, -0.0067329407, 0.0025253296, -0.027114868, -0.04071045, -0.0009570122, 0.011001587, 0.013305664, -0.080322266, 0.044036865, -0.049743652, -0.04827881, 0.030441284, -0.0040359497, -0.014953613, -0.018966675, 0.009490967, -0.014572144, 0.0135269165, 0.017486572, 0.029769897, -0.010002136, -0.051849365, 0.013923645, -0.06695557, -0.026611328, 0.018585205, -0.06976318, 0.05496216, 0.01979065, 0.00016117096, -0.03842163, 0.037628174, -0.04650879, 0.028915405, 0.0026054382, -0.033477783, -0.0020656586, 0.007293701, 0.0625, -0.03756714, -0.0009794235, 0.007068634, -0.027145386, -0.044067383, -0.0178833, -0.02607727, -0.007270813, -0.004463196, 0.0040779114, 0.055908203, 0.051696777, -0.027938843, 0.029541016, 0.028015137, -0.02607727, -0.007335663, 0.022705078, -0.0051574707, -0.0104522705, 0.029083252, -0.02748108, -0.0066986084, -0.030548096, 0.007843018, 0.034820557, 0.0013895035, 0.005218506, -0.024093628, -0.020202637, 0.062347412, 0.014060974, 0.019744873, -0.018417358, 0.008605957, 0.0043258667, -0.004299164, 0.007369995, -0.011413574, -0.029296875, 0.0028953552, 0.024658203, 0.0038909912, 0.00491333, 0.049987793, 0.034332275, 0.025161743, 0.048065186, -0.019042969, 0.029037476, -0.029830933, 0.006801605, 0.021484375, -0.027038574, -0.03552246, 0.024795532, 0.030593872, -0.07183838, 0.011070251, 0.04837036, -0.0496521, -0.005180359, 0.036254883, 0.00623703, 0.004463196, -0.034057617, -0.006038666, 0.023223877, 0.0007009506, 0.024795532, -0.009140015, -0.0023612976, 0.0087509155, 0.020935059, 0.005420685, 0.041107178, -0.019561768, 0.008712769, -0.014083862, -0.010673523, -0.018798828, 0.06518555, -0.0077705383, 0.018249512, -0.034301758, -0.05319214, 0.0126953125, -0.027069092, 0.0044403076, 0.010871887, 0.015029907, 0.020645142, 0.030883789, -0.0027618408, -0.018035889, -0.033477783, 0.00049734116, -0.040893555, -0.0491333, 0.08068848, 0.0127334595, -0.020706177, 0.012992859, 0.020431519, 0.015342712, -0.0131073, 0.03717041, 0.007762909, 0.004966736, 0.009750366, 0.006664276, 0.027450562, -0.015533447, -0.005783081, -0.020751953, 0.014350891, 0.037597656, 0.033325195, 0.028839111, 0.017440796, -0.012832642, 0.0149002075, 0.008087158, -0.0016336441, -0.019485474, 0.059051514, -0.013313293, 0.00075912476, -0.04525757, -0.026763916, -0.039398193, 0.063964844, -0.009170532, -0.013343811, 0.030563354, -0.0077438354, -0.02078247, 0.028335571, -0.036834717, 0.057769775, 0.010063171, -0.011238098, 0.00014281273, 0.008056641, -0.057434082, 0.02720642, 0.057617188, -0.023880005, 0.005584717, -0.03515625, 0.012687683, 0.029266357, -0.014259338, -0.040893555, -0.042755127, 0.034332275, -0.037841797, -0.009346008, 0.008163452, 0.023468018, 0.012954712, 0.022750854, 0.010482788, 0.02305603, 0.0037078857, -0.033203125, -0.010444641, -0.019821167, -0.04647827, 0.022766113, 0.00016844273, -0.028076172, -0.007987976, 0.020339966, 0.042053223, 0.013954163, -0.013038635, -0.0035324097, 0.020126343, 0.0037231445, 0.034301758, -0.0032367706, -0.042755127, -0.051635742, -0.0063438416, 0.014862061, -0.012252808, 0.02658081, 0.016998291, -0.00024533272, 0.0076560974, -0.026916504, 0.007472992, -0.01096344, 0.021591187, 0.031951904, 0.018615723, 0.01524353, 0.014266968, -0.024414062, 0.025604248, 0.011581421, 0.007293701, 0.036895752, -0.01953125, 0.072387695, 0.037750244, 0.03643799, -0.050964355, -0.0041923523, 0.04736328, 0.0056877136, 0.056762695, 0.015838623, 0.013343811, -0.035583496, -0.019058228, -0.007041931, -0.014564514, 0.023452759, 0.07501221, -0.027786255, 0.012771606, -0.0463562, 0.018539429, -0.0053482056, -0.040496826, -0.04360962, -0.016540527, -0.024795532, 0.02003479, 0.00919342, -0.03338623, 0.011512756, -0.030303955, -0.028579712, 0.010627747, 0.035888672, 0.021347046, -0.056152344, 0.005176544, 0.062683105, 0.054748535, 0.093566895, 0.053955078, -0.025802612, 0.012748718, 0.034698486, -0.0041236877, -0.029815674, -0.021102905, 0.037231445, 0.02331543, -0.01637268, 0.010391235, 0.018676758, -0.015464783, -0.051513672, -0.04006958, 0.003616333, -0.025497437, 0.0803833, 0.014450073, -0.022979736, 0.006511688, 0.04031372, -0.050933838, 0.029708862, -0.0635376, -0.016998291, 0.04751587, 0.004131317, 0.003112793, -0.032562256, -0.018310547, -0.032043457, -0.009544373, -0.0004775524, -0.010902405, -0.00762558, 0.020645142, -0.05432129, 0.0035381317, -0.011940002, 0.033813477, 0.02330017, -0.048858643, 0.011451721, -0.009605408, -0.014709473, -0.000082433224, -0.026031494, -0.0077819824, -0.022277832, 0.023269653, 0.031143188, -0.011726379, -0.0005373955, -0.011253357, 0.0079574585, -0.05429077, -0.018600464, 0.018600464, 0.006416321, 0.0047035217, 0.009109497, 0.017089844, -0.0385437, -0.011886597, 0.04309082, -0.030441284, 0.0035476685, -0.025802612, -0.017105103, -0.02458191, -0.05911255, -0.034454346, 0.008232117, 0.00223732, -0.010009766, 0.016662598, 0.020126343, -0.04434204, 0.019943237, -0.0025672913, 0.026275635, -0.01461792, -0.0058517456, -0.040222168, -0.007774353, -0.018249512, -0.024505615, -0.012023926, 0.009262085, 0.0077934265, -0.0015106201, 0.012756348, -0.030426025, 0.009918213, -0.040771484, 0.008987427, 0.026794434, 0.010528564, 0.015945435, -0.0010585785, 0.032806396, 0.038848877, 0.0020256042, 0.014762878 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06753v1
Towards General-Purpose Speech Abilities for Large Language Models Using Unpaired Data
Yassir Fathullah, Chunyang Wu, Egor Lakomkin, Junteng Jia, Yuan Shangguan, Jay Mahadeokar, Ozlem Kalinli, Christian Fuegen, Mike Seltzer
cs.CL, cs.AI
In this work, we extend the instruction-tuned Llama-2 model with end-to-end general-purpose speech processing and reasoning abilities while maintaining the wide range of LLM capabilities, without using any carefully curated paired data. The proposed model can utilize audio prompts as a replacement for text and sustain a conversation. Such a model also has extended cross-modal capabilities such as being able to perform speech question answering, speech translation, and audio summarization amongst many other closed and open-domain tasks. This is unlike prior approaches in speech, in which LLMs are extended to handle audio for a limited number of pre-designated tasks. Experiments show that our end-to-end approach is on par with or outperforms a cascaded system (speech recognizer + LLM) in terms of modeling the response to a prompt. Furthermore, unlike a cascade, our approach shows the ability to interchange text and audio modalities and utilize the prior context in a conversation to provide better results.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06753v1
2023-11-12T06:56:14
2023-11-12T06:56:14
{ "title": [ -0.021270752, 0.0022602081, -0.06414795, -0.07720947, -0.00340271, -0.013183594, -0.058624268, 0.031143188, 0.020462036, 0.03414917, -0.018676758, -0.02003479, 0.01777649, -0.020904541, -0.056121826, 0.016677856, -0.017852783, 0.053955078, -0.0317688, -0.039398193, 0.013282776, -0.07104492, -0.004802704, 0.035308838, 0.0418396, -0.06762695, -0.10235596, 0.028778076, -0.037353516, -0.021972656, -0.0016841888, 0.030761719, 0.03970337, 0.0149383545, -0.015640259, -0.019104004, -0.059753418, 0.024917603, -0.0012588501, -0.010002136, 0.033050537, -0.01159668, -0.0140686035, 0.0053710938, -0.029205322, 0.021011353, -0.023086548, -0.013313293, 0.0035305023, 0.026519775, 0.0003194809, 0.05682373, -0.017166138, -0.0036125183, 0.023269653, -0.018188477, -0.013061523, 0.017837524, 0.025024414, 0.05255127, 0.019302368, 0.00042152405, -0.003982544, -0.019546509, -0.027282715, -0.017852783, -0.023284912, 0.02180481, 0.033721924, -0.020812988, -0.013183594, -0.0050964355, 0.013679504, -0.01524353, -0.05102539, 0.015579224, 0.023208618, 0.016098022, 0.050567627, -0.05029297, 0.00983429, 0.0044174194, 0.043060303, -0.024978638, 0.029144287, -0.034332275, -0.0158844, -0.007980347, -0.03363037, -0.055389404, -0.002275467, -0.007896423, -0.02267456, 0.015670776, -0.016494751, -0.04006958, -0.004497528, 0.029907227, -0.00080633163, -0.04336548, -0.0042762756, 0.016235352, -0.040008545, -0.016036987, 0.015197754, 0.020568848, -0.055389404, -0.03250122, 0.038604736, 0.04269409, -0.021575928, 0.029754639, 0.017837524, -0.0016345978, 0.0008215904, 0.014465332, -0.000036478043, 0.029388428, 0.023605347, 0.04638672, -0.008178711, -0.021316528, 0.00919342, -0.009017944, 0.04336548, 0.0070648193, -0.039764404, -0.0015058517, -0.010520935, 0.028762817, 0.036315918, 0.047332764, -0.14343262, -0.074645996, -0.07977295, 0.05834961, -0.0119018555, 0.003036499, -0.03186035, 0.03540039, -0.027191162, -0.025161743, 0.031341553, -0.013336182, 0.01612854, 0.0065460205, 0.06323242, -0.0055122375, -0.05810547, -0.032928467, -0.00472641, 0.023071289, 0.021972656, -0.0074272156, -0.050628662, -0.022399902, -0.11621094, -0.016418457, 0.01889038, -0.011276245, 0.027038574, 0.010894775, -0.008811951, 0.007797241, 0.014465332, -0.0099105835, -0.012771606, 0.004348755, 0.013641357, 0.013412476, -0.02330017, 0.0056991577, 0.035949707, 0.02519226, -0.015419006, 0.014595032, 0.007537842, 0.0009174347, 0.035888672, -0.015052795, 0.0028038025, -0.023422241, 0.024978638, 0.026916504, -0.064331055, -0.02734375, -0.003358841, -0.0129852295, 0.05102539, 0.007873535, -0.012512207, 0.019195557, -0.026535034, -0.016494751, -0.056640625, -0.049072266, 0.03665161, 0.008232117, -0.012054443, 0.022277832, 0.018157959, -0.013961792, -0.013076782, -0.033172607, -0.044891357, -0.037475586, -0.026275635, 0.02015686, -0.014480591, 0.03286743, 0.053375244, 0.00003528595, -0.03656006, 0.029937744, -0.013832092, -0.059417725, 0.025405884, 0.022720337, 0.0107040405, -0.005619049, -0.0012607574, -0.020843506, 0.027526855, 0.061187744, -0.00045609474, 0.0036792755, 0.0068206787, -0.009063721, 0.035247803, 0.01625061, 0.06311035, -0.037597656, 0.034820557, 0.02961731, 0.009002686, -0.023849487, 0.0041275024, -0.024642944, 0.02986145, 0.0006303787, -0.0040664673, -0.0317688, -0.009483337, 0.028121948, 0.041625977, 0.019882202, 0.021377563, 0.0073013306, -0.0025539398, 0.022018433, 0.044006348, 0.026031494, 0.03933716, 0.01737976, -0.0062217712, 0.05355835, -0.005886078, -0.0025959015, -0.0126953125, -0.022018433, 0.025619507, -0.009925842, -0.0109939575, 0.005508423, -0.041107178, 0.014732361, -0.03933716, -0.015098572, -0.0060806274, 0.024368286, 0.014053345, -0.042419434, 0.015899658, -0.016326904, -0.00036740303, -0.01876831, -0.011329651, 0.023544312, 0.022613525, -0.05441284, 0.0011301041, 0.025283813, 0.04425049, 0.0018129349, 0.0059280396, -0.009643555, 0.018157959, -0.011703491, -0.023513794, -0.004623413, 0.05178833, 0.037353516, 0.00023663044, 0.0019292831, 0.0032653809, 0.0018615723, 0.07879639, 0.040527344, -0.02281189, 0.01953125, -0.026000977, 0.03164673, 0.0102005005, -0.003850937, 0.01499939, 0.0012350082, 0.015541077, 0.03164673, -0.011924744, 0.010948181, -0.04550171, 0.03213501, 0.0124053955, -0.026016235, -0.038208008, -0.039520264, -0.008262634, -0.03439331, -0.044921875, 0.005088806, 0.085632324, -0.039855957, -0.013710022, -0.019180298, -0.022781372, -0.026153564, -0.007820129, -0.034606934, 0.027542114, 0.04248047, 0.03692627, 0.045776367, -0.074523926, -0.07141113, -0.013549805, 0.005104065, -0.020233154, 0.0048294067, -0.025253296, 0.029449463, -0.0045280457, 0.0030021667, 0.018417358, -0.047058105, -0.00504303, -0.041412354, 0.024673462, 0.008399963, -0.02368164, -0.011268616, 0.022506714, -0.01676941, -0.014221191, 0.036315918, 0.060943604, -0.0053710938, -0.039215088, 0.032928467, 0.0038757324, -0.016723633, 0.039367676, 0.032104492, 0.023422241, -0.062561035, -0.031555176, -0.05670166, -0.031234741, -0.012573242, -0.01626587, 0.020187378, -0.041748047, -0.02368164, -0.07324219, -0.014778137, 0.016555786, 0.034454346, -0.002670288, -0.029006958, -0.0073394775, -0.01701355, -0.0077705383, 0.022583008, -0.03616333, 0.032226562, 0.0647583, 0.01852417, 0.009399414, -0.000057697296, 0.032196045, 0.0031261444, -0.005958557, 0.0016355515, -0.038513184, 0.00060272217, 0.020629883, 0.012321472, -0.019897461, -0.033172607, -0.093933105, 0.0036964417, 0.07574463, 0.0013809204, -0.03366089, 0.04949951, -0.059448242, 0.029083252, 0.02255249, -0.008956909, 0.031311035, 0.031677246, 0.013977051, -0.007587433, 0.019241333, -0.04611206, 0.0073928833, -0.04159546, -0.093444824, 0.036132812, -0.0118255615, -0.067871094, -0.028961182, -0.008163452, -0.036102295, -0.0015773773, 0.0042762756, 0.044433594, 0.028900146, 0.004016876, 0.013465881, -0.019058228, 0.011421204, -0.026245117, -0.022659302, -0.016189575, 0.00041866302, 0.062408447, -0.0056991577, 0.033721924, 0.012619019, -0.010574341, -0.00459671, -0.007133484, -0.038391113, 0.026229858, -0.013214111, -0.027572632, -0.0154800415, 0.012519836, -0.012054443, 0.008338928, -0.008354187, 0.0015830994, -0.040405273, 0.0068206787, -0.020507812, 0.03591919, 0.0065078735, 0.013015747, -0.020645142, -0.04067993, 0.0103302, -0.026321411, -0.05709839, -0.0058670044, 0.052703857, 0.02859497, -0.062561035, 0.009605408, -0.03491211, 0.015975952, 0.034606934, -0.01411438, -0.0059509277, -0.004547119, -0.017105103, -0.021514893, 0.008529663, 0.015281677, -0.009269714, -0.00774765, -0.0317688, 0.016052246, -0.041137695, -0.08337402, -0.017852783, -0.009231567, -0.0904541, -0.022994995, 0.013771057, -0.01612854, -0.0031871796, -0.02949524, 0.022766113, -0.0077705383, -0.034057617, 0.012054443, -0.018829346, -0.027618408, -0.029083252, -0.09277344, 0.006252289, 0.080200195, 0.015686035, 0.047943115, 0.030456543, 0.0021629333, 0.006290436, -0.020080566, 0.04727173, 0.014167786, 0.0435791, 0.008491516, -0.0140686035, 0.041503906, -0.028411865, 0.013916016, 0.049835205, -0.004749298, 0.006828308, 0.0035896301, 0.003604889, 0.035827637, -0.012710571, 0.062347412, -0.0047035217, -0.017074585, -0.05279541, 0.01171875, -0.0060272217, -0.004562378, 0.014511108, -0.015586853, 0.015670776, 0.02671814, 0.007419586, 0.06149292, -0.010787964, 0.010345459, 0.047088623, -0.012687683, -0.024795532, 0.017211914, 0.036224365, 0.016616821, 0.0033988953, 0.049591064, 0.0038890839, 0.042510986, 0.006565094, -0.029922485, 0.0006132126, 0.028198242, -0.04360962, -0.020401001, -0.052337646, -0.07946777, -0.026367188, 0.009132385, -0.006916046, 0.03857422, 0.033843994, 0.017562866, -0.043304443, 0.002286911, 0.03945923, -0.0004620552, 0.009635925, -0.060455322, 0.012916565, -0.007621765, -0.049621582, -0.039520264, 0.006374359, -0.011062622, 0.038024902, -0.025650024, -0.023361206, -0.0077323914, 0.021011353, 0.04888916, 0.040863037, -0.011192322, -0.04849243, -0.035339355, -0.03074646, -0.042907715, 0.03652954, -0.012886047, -0.0065994263, -0.018493652, 0.046203613, -0.033172607, 0.011146545, 0.005519867, 0.007396698, -0.0524292, 0.05630493, -0.04168701, 0.020843506, 0.015167236, -0.00094366074, 0.010871887, 0.001666069, -0.03768921, 0.030548096, 0.006591797, 0.035369873, -0.007549286, 0.016479492, 0.041900635, 0.013298035, 0.015640259, 0.00095415115, 0.004573822, 0.022399902, 0.0075263977, 0.0074653625, 0.019332886, -0.052886963, -0.05331421, -0.015174866, 0.011833191, 0.035186768, -0.045166016, 0.027420044, 0.008583069, 0.01826477, 0.017669678, -0.017715454, 0.02279663, -0.008270264, 0.012145996, -0.05697632, -0.036193848, 0.013267517, 0.022109985, -0.042755127, 0.00592041, -0.009735107, -0.029510498, 0.020889282, 0.049621582, 0.028808594, 0.0027580261, -0.011779785, -0.013572693, -0.0064353943, -0.02204895, -0.044281006, 0.0020961761, 0.003528595, 0.0017766953, -0.023345947, 0.01600647, -0.06738281, -0.0009918213, -0.028701782, -0.020050049, 0.03112793, -0.06616211, 0.019317627, 0.06585693, 0.00447464, 0.039093018, -0.011039734, 0.00023078918, 0.030761719, 0.059814453, -0.0025157928, 0.036834717, 0.030578613, -0.026382446, 0.0035820007, -0.018844604, 0.01687622, -0.001584053, 0.03765869, 0.012161255, 0.03564453, -0.09411621, 0.017333984, 0.0121536255, -0.009460449, 0.0014896393, -0.046051025, 0.010437012, 0.02381897, -0.01411438, 0.02029419, -0.03149414, -0.036834717, -0.015197754, -0.00025749207, -0.03729248, 0.022521973, -0.004386902, -0.06161499, -0.0032787323, 0.022872925, -0.031051636, 0.0016126633, 0.030975342, -0.017791748, -0.015808105, 0.028411865, 0.03765869, -0.048095703, 0.02017212, -0.00970459, 0.004512787, 0.041931152, 0.03250122, -0.028259277, -0.007598877, 0.011436462, -0.049682617, -0.021728516, 0.008705139, -0.007820129, -0.0037994385, 0.009597778, -0.028793335, -0.009033203, 0.0048103333, 0.023040771, -0.013183594, -0.01146698, 0.048797607, -0.0060920715, -0.0012025833, -0.0021362305, -0.015098572, 0.017227173, -0.0010232925, -0.009140015, -0.054901123, 0.018676758, 0.01965332, 0.043029785, -0.036499023, -0.07318115, -0.0026111603, 0.015335083, 0.0061683655, -0.011436462, 0.03866577, 0.032440186, -0.01852417, 0.011306763, 0.015602112, 0.055541992, -0.054473877, -0.0002219677, -0.01977539, -0.010154724, -0.025039673, 0.0904541, -0.018615723, -0.0066566467, -0.06274414, -0.05886841, -0.03302002, 0.026260376, 0.034820557, 0.007904053, 0.02331543, -0.009376526, 0.04006958, -0.05014038, -0.018218994, -0.017364502, 0.03463745, -0.0064048767, -0.041992188, -0.01966858, -0.0055618286, -0.0063934326, -0.018005371, 0.017684937, 0.021453857, -0.0027561188, 0.004005432, -0.020019531, 0.0038414001, -0.004306793, -0.034301758, 0.034484863, -0.014701843, -0.011405945, 0.038360596, -0.031799316, 0.046966553, -0.012062073, 0.019973755, 0.009559631, -0.0059318542, -0.011238098, -0.010269165, 0.005748749, -0.045654297, -0.003479004, -0.039001465, -0.0135650635, -0.05105591, -0.0103302, -0.07104492, 0.0107040405, 0.011650085, 0.005340576, 0.021072388, -0.0020065308, 0.0121154785, -0.022125244, 0.02192688, -0.003862381, 0.032592773, -0.019317627, -0.0031280518, -0.013259888, -0.024246216, 0.03164673, 0.034606934, -0.008270264, -0.0007958412, -0.021743774, -0.024047852, 0.020492554, 0.0018701553, 0.008766174, -0.015556335, -0.008621216, -0.040374756, 0.04147339, -0.0050201416, 0.037841797, 0.07141113, 0.0037612915, 0.026657104, -0.039367676, 0.0020561218, -0.015083313, -0.009780884, 0.012748718, 0.033691406, -0.07861328, 0.04019165, 0.01524353, -0.025634766, -0.04043579, 0.046966553, 0.008705139, -0.0463562, -0.013053894, 0.009017944, 0.026641846, -0.0044059753, 0.0046424866, -0.044311523, -0.036346436, 0.0056762695, 0.052246094, -0.03930664, 0.014213562, 0.002325058, 0.015426636, -0.029037476, -0.043670654, 0.013549805, -0.0026569366, -0.032440186, 0.026428223, 0.013305664, 0.043060303, -0.009757996, -0.036224365, -0.014289856, 0.011070251, -0.062927246, -0.026367188, 0.013069153, 0.04269409, 0.022033691, 0.07989502, 0.015541077, -0.01663208, 0.0011577606, -0.03201294, 0.010124207, 0.040374756, -0.028778076, 0.008529663, -0.048980713, -0.0390625, 0.017990112, -0.046142578, 0.053527832, -0.055419922, -0.004398346, -0.02708435, 0.0423584, 0.0044403076, -0.05996704, -0.018829346, -0.009681702, -0.01751709, 0.0076408386, 0.024505615, -0.01424408, -0.027404785, -0.008277893, 0.011726379, 0.024047852, 0.017364502, 0.010383606, -0.020309448, -0.05532837, 0.045898438, -0.0149383545, 0.09222412, -0.04550171, -0.008041382, -0.013542175, 0.0020103455, -0.0035514832, -0.016906738, -0.015960693, -0.0011615753, -0.02949524, -0.057495117, 0.03010559, 0.028945923, -0.0023021698, -0.01550293, -0.03277588, -0.012886047, -0.035186768, 0.03503418, 0.050445557, -0.046203613, -0.082336426, 0.0027942657, -0.041748047, 0.059753418, -0.019195557, -0.005596161, 0.0045700073, 0.019836426, -0.0418396, 0.0066184998, 0.044677734, 0.06628418, -0.002292633, -0.047943115, 0.008666992, 0.033843994, 0.049468994, -0.047424316, -0.027938843, 0.016815186, 0.005050659, -0.0060577393, 0.01676941, 0.028686523, 0.0041923523, 0.0003683567, 0.0038852692, -0.00025582314, -0.027664185, 0.003042221, 0.004787445, 0.0390625, 0.038879395, -0.0140686035, 0.026107788, 0.012321472, -0.053863525, -0.0047683716, 0.009719849, 0.002199173, 0.02104187, -0.009941101, 0.029876709, -0.03656006, -0.01789856, -0.064941406, -0.008842468, -0.002325058, 0.003068924, -0.025619507, 0.032562256, -0.05215454, 0.024398804, -0.033996582, -0.06317139, 0.05899048, 0.031173706, 0.014770508, -0.007534027, 0.010467529, 0.005290985, -0.0026283264, -0.018981934, 0.01763916, 0.017120361, 0.019042969, -0.06500244, 0.015182495, -0.10534668, -0.021026611, -0.03186035, -0.04559326, 0.042907715, -0.012626648, -0.0007662773, -0.028213501, 0.013282776, -0.0054016113, 0.01878357, 0.0060691833, -0.01008606, -0.060058594, -0.02684021, 0.040252686, -0.024490356 ], "summary": [ -0.015388489, -0.014564514, -0.009010315, -0.046722412, -0.03692627, 0.016204834, -0.105407715, -0.010375977, 0.009628296, 0.0042152405, -0.0020866394, -0.0085372925, 0.008056641, -0.05392456, 0.029800415, -0.005996704, -0.016815186, 0.032928467, -0.03314209, -0.045288086, 0.012954712, -0.061157227, -0.06161499, 0.06689453, 0.014274597, 0.008758545, -0.009788513, -0.0015277863, 0.01348114, 0.030853271, 0.014389038, -0.051330566, 0.020141602, 0.03527832, -0.047027588, -0.032989502, -0.054229736, 0.02319336, -0.0077667236, 0.012283325, 0.05529785, -0.026306152, 0.047332764, 0.01386261, -0.00057029724, 0.03933716, 0.019088745, -0.041259766, 0.037719727, 0.006427765, 0.0034732819, 0.076171875, -0.008056641, -0.008590698, -0.013130188, 0.011520386, -0.040496826, -0.004173279, 0.008659363, 0.05807495, 0.01727295, 0.001660347, -0.01335144, -0.02658081, -0.0021533966, -0.00944519, -0.040222168, 0.0041007996, 0.025970459, -0.018707275, -0.0015573502, -0.008148193, 0.017730713, -0.076416016, 0.0096206665, 0.05999756, -0.04837036, 0.009391785, 0.04168701, -0.040252686, -0.0018129349, 0.031280518, 0.06427002, -0.08441162, 0.0413208, -0.06652832, -0.004753113, -0.0008530617, 0.014465332, -0.021820068, 0.004016876, 0.012825012, -0.017807007, 0.05307007, 0.02154541, -0.05291748, -0.0028896332, -0.023986816, -0.022491455, -0.010627747, 0.04058838, -0.022277832, 0.035858154, -0.022109985, 0.0054016113, 0.021102905, 0.01398468, -0.05722046, -0.009552002, 0.0054473877, -0.039794922, 0.01928711, -0.0017871857, -0.043426514, 0.01108551, 0.027908325, -0.00522995, 0.05014038, 0.015716553, 0.004383087, -0.033172607, -0.013847351, 0.026031494, 0.06173706, 0.0012798309, 0.03111267, 0.0138168335, -0.012527466, 0.049346924, 0.028686523, 0.02722168, 0.03643799, -0.07165527, -0.076293945, -0.09387207, 0.02168274, 0.046936035, 0.016296387, 0.00774765, -0.007293701, 0.047302246, 0.004196167, -0.0018777847, 0.021972656, 0.022247314, 0.03503418, 0.052978516, -0.008712769, -0.03125, -0.01953125, 0.016189575, 0.030471802, 0.0006432533, -0.018066406, 0.03137207, -0.045013428, -0.034179688, -0.021087646, 0.080444336, -0.014503479, -0.024719238, -0.003320694, 0.05999756, -0.005180359, -0.028793335, 0.007446289, -0.026428223, -0.010360718, 0.019638062, 0.018325806, -0.000034570694, 0.015258789, 0.028839111, 0.013908386, -0.01461792, -0.018615723, -0.016036987, 0.024047852, 0.04284668, -0.012802124, 0.0059394836, -0.01234436, 0.06939697, 0.0058555603, -0.037841797, 0.0035476685, 0.01574707, 0.07122803, 0.019424438, 0.010292053, -0.005241394, -0.009902954, 0.019851685, 0.005504608, -0.028137207, -0.049072266, -0.010231018, -0.0016517639, -0.03778076, 0.00945282, 0.051361084, -0.007118225, -0.02041626, -0.060760498, -0.11621094, -0.01574707, -0.009605408, 0.028701782, 0.013053894, 0.011756897, 0.023376465, 0.0043258667, -0.032836914, 0.0074424744, -0.057037354, -0.04837036, 0.0040130615, 0.025558472, 0.009590149, 0.013725281, 0.0057296753, -0.02078247, -0.007881165, 0.034576416, -0.0011434555, -0.027496338, 0.02255249, -0.0008034706, 0.049224854, -0.0045051575, 0.04336548, -0.07080078, 0.061401367, 0.034088135, 0.014915466, 0.0007548332, 0.05923462, -0.10430908, 0.023925781, 0.03894043, 0.004676819, 0.0030708313, -0.041412354, 0.009162903, 0.0029182434, 0.047058105, 0.034118652, 0.0030975342, -0.014320374, -0.029510498, 0.031097412, -0.025146484, 0.052947998, 0.019622803, 0.008079529, 0.008911133, 0.0013828278, 0.016448975, -0.03149414, -0.01449585, 0.016174316, -0.06378174, -0.030014038, -0.013656616, -0.02684021, -0.059631348, -0.015174866, -0.034057617, 0.010772705, -0.042816162, 0.029815674, -0.016586304, -0.009033203, -0.035095215, -0.03555298, -0.035461426, -0.032409668, 0.04324341, 0.027023315, -0.046020508, 0.005744934, -0.029067993, -0.017974854, -0.0023078918, 0.056152344, -0.022384644, 0.013534546, 0.03479004, 0.0017175674, 0.068237305, 0.059387207, 0.03741455, 0.016235352, 0.0013504028, -0.019699097, 0.013832092, 0.030654907, 0.024780273, -0.016174316, -0.00053167343, -0.0014734268, 0.030654907, 0.026351929, -0.03982544, 0.023117065, -0.02142334, 0.019256592, 0.011489868, 0.020874023, 0.012672424, -0.024429321, 0.05368042, 0.03387451, 0.04562378, -0.047821045, -0.051361084, -0.0017900467, 0.023834229, -0.021575928, 0.034088135, 0.1060791, -0.037078857, -0.0072402954, 0.028305054, -0.027938843, -0.036071777, 0.05368042, -0.03527832, 0.023147583, -0.007041931, -0.009094238, -0.028335571, -0.048339844, -0.034118652, 0.012611389, -0.002981186, 0.014549255, -0.031982422, 0.021652222, 0.018600464, 0.07531738, 0.0070228577, -0.005344391, 0.027389526, -0.03552246, -0.019378662, 0.026138306, -0.012687683, 0.007499695, 0.0041999817, 0.020492554, -0.014434814, 0.03314209, 0.06463623, 0.04827881, -0.05142212, -0.05114746, 0.026535034, -0.045654297, -0.048736572, 0.038848877, 0.004016876, -0.009376526, -0.09851074, -0.0014133453, -0.01727295, -0.050079346, -0.024627686, -0.015464783, -0.012260437, 0.016998291, 0.025405884, -0.066345215, -0.042755127, -0.04397583, 0.010025024, 0.05810547, 0.000054955482, -0.032165527, 0.025787354, 0.024139404, 0.023956299, 0.014572144, 0.0262146, 0.061828613, 0.05206299, 0.046936035, 0.010398865, 0.020355225, -0.035614014, -0.019012451, 0.0013332367, 0.005268097, -0.020553589, 0.021621704, 0.00793457, -0.039764404, 0.014884949, -0.049957275, -0.0064048767, 0.11352539, 0.010063171, 0.0039787292, 0.0395813, -0.01612854, 0.028915405, 0.0826416, 0.020767212, 0.0284729, -0.03704834, 0.023117065, -0.056488037, 0.01234436, -0.06964111, 0.0002837181, -0.029312134, -0.054534912, -0.016311646, 0.023605347, 0.010536194, -0.0236969, 0.0077438354, -0.012077332, 0.04196167, 0.0030937195, 0.05770874, -0.021606445, 0.012031555, -0.023361206, -0.01600647, -0.008125305, -0.0259552, -0.042144775, -0.011131287, 0.04043579, 0.04336548, -0.0068244934, -0.039123535, 0.00819397, -0.022583008, -0.027160645, -0.02470398, -0.070007324, -0.026397705, -0.021148682, -0.032684326, -0.012245178, -0.030822754, -0.03842163, 0.016159058, -0.023468018, -0.005947113, -0.024795532, 0.037902832, -0.007850647, 0.095703125, -0.030700684, 0.033691406, 0.03866577, -0.05154419, -0.008575439, -0.02279663, -0.05230713, -0.011634827, 0.03604126, 0.061462402, -0.066345215, 0.027069092, -0.00856781, -0.01197052, 0.042938232, -0.047698975, -0.013961792, -0.024230957, 0.00983429, -0.049072266, 0.022064209, 0.019332886, 0.012779236, -0.043304443, -0.064453125, 0.026412964, -0.062683105, -0.030456543, -0.023986816, 0.015098572, -0.014305115, -0.015151978, -0.01928711, -0.00541687, -0.015670776, 0.0011882782, 0.025024414, -0.021118164, -0.011360168, -0.002954483, -0.0045394897, 0.014572144, -0.010719299, -0.047027588, -0.0211792, 0.009170532, 0.00011181831, -0.0046920776, 0.004398346, -0.044067383, -0.0027370453, 0.03829956, 0.040618896, -0.03427124, 0.05911255, 0.021774292, -0.0010690689, 0.0016069412, -0.0076942444, -0.0418396, 0.077819824, -0.0546875, 0.026489258, 0.011711121, 0.045074463, 0.020889282, 0.0151901245, 0.0069351196, -0.019226074, 0.024734497, -0.02029419, 0.0035438538, 0.008155823, -0.005290985, 0.02960205, 0.008842468, 0.007911682, 0.013259888, -0.009681702, -0.0027065277, -0.027404785, -0.015548706, 0.016281128, 0.04144287, -0.028060913, -0.008979797, 0.037200928, 0.057678223, -0.006427765, 0.0335083, -0.01473999, 0.040252686, -0.0082473755, 0.019699097, -0.009094238, -0.015304565, 0.022857666, -0.024230957, -0.039031982, -0.014854431, -0.0076026917, -0.0041236877, 0.0029697418, 0.04434204, 0.031829834, 0.015701294, -0.026565552, -0.00806427, 0.006603241, -0.0037727356, -0.024230957, -0.07836914, -0.057250977, -0.023422241, -0.025848389, 0.0016212463, -0.075805664, -0.060913086, -0.018661499, 0.021499634, 0.02017212, 0.039398193, 0.00793457, -0.018539429, 0.047210693, -0.013557434, -0.04437256, 0.009101868, -0.017288208, 0.0038394928, 0.010719299, 0.01852417, -0.008804321, -0.011253357, 0.013183594, -0.009437561, 0.0067214966, -0.030258179, 0.0087509155, -0.023773193, 0.004501343, -0.026367188, 0.015655518, 0.011192322, 0.0061798096, 0.0034866333, -0.009750366, -0.015419006, 0.017364502, -0.0023708344, 0.013641357, 0.014457703, -0.028839111, -0.014572144, 0.01776123, -0.019805908, 0.018737793, 0.0054512024, -0.015266418, 0.03656006, -0.007598877, 0.036102295, 0.029251099, -0.023834229, 0.0078125, 0.001909256, -0.00995636, 0.002828598, -0.0010643005, 0.051086426, 0.0085372925, 0.027496338, -0.008460999, 0.009773254, 0.010513306, -0.012512207, -0.025894165, -0.041992188, 0.007537842, 0.039031982, -0.002544403, -0.0047035217, -0.035827637, -0.040924072, -0.0076942444, 0.0022659302, -0.0031719208, -0.010513306, 0.031799316, -0.022994995, -0.020507812, 0.0062942505, -0.0020618439, -0.060577393, 0.0011768341, 0.009162903, -0.0053710938, 0.01309967, 0.0036334991, -0.0019350052, 0.0028514862, -0.017501831, -0.0030708313, -0.047790527, -0.029083252, -0.0104522705, -0.040618896, -0.0052337646, 0.07287598, -0.024261475, -0.043151855, 0.039642334, -0.04534912, 0.05960083, -0.01108551, -0.057647705, -0.013725281, -0.032684326, -0.010269165, 0.05807495, 0.017288208, 0.028839111, 0.017318726, -0.013130188, -0.0058250427, 0.0071525574, 0.054901123, -0.040100098, -0.009681702, 0.021133423, -0.00541687, -0.0017127991, 0.00050735474, 0.016662598, -0.056121826, -0.03363037, 0.0016803741, -0.03366089, -0.0014238358, 0.002506256, -0.019515991, 0.03881836, 0.023498535, -0.03189087, 0.018539429, 0.027313232, -0.020462036, 0.0074386597, 0.030075073, -0.02746582, 0.007133484, -0.023635864, 0.02796936, -0.017974854, -0.0072135925, 0.068237305, -0.03527832, -0.010971069, -0.0009765625, -0.024475098, -0.019241333, 0.019470215, 0.014274597, 0.008682251, 0.01852417, 0.023712158, 0.0050621033, -0.03717041, 0.012062073, -0.04953003, -0.018417358, 0.027877808, -0.029418945, -0.020629883, -0.0024814606, 0.020095825, -0.005126953, -0.021820068, 0.02407837, -0.11682129, 0.022598267, -0.0154953, 0.023498535, -0.043914795, -0.027130127, -0.0038433075, 0.03137207, 0.009010315, -0.016647339, -0.0072364807, 0.00077962875, -0.006061554, -0.0440979, -0.036254883, -0.0039405823, -0.02168274, -0.054870605, -0.012626648, -0.000446558, -0.00945282, 0.036590576, 0.016708374, -0.05014038, -0.0028972626, -0.0079956055, 0.00028705597, 0.022842407, 0.03265381, -0.00630188, 0.070495605, 0.01499939, -0.0036563873, 0.01928711, 0.018157959, -0.022521973, -0.018081665, -0.009544373, 0.020721436, 0.01448822, 0.07684326, -0.012001038, 0.029373169, -0.0017690659, 0.006942749, -0.033233643, 0.04916382, -0.013153076, 0.0053138733, -0.030914307, -0.0017061234, 0.0024051666, 0.04272461, -0.04437256, -0.008529663, 0.0010375977, 0.054107666, 0.023040771, 0.00003248453, 0.0049819946, -0.008644104, 0.007785797, 0.013885498, -0.00014030933, -0.02418518, 0.030853271, -0.030334473, -0.025146484, -0.015510559, -0.025253296, -0.01878357, -0.0030517578, 0.027420044, 0.013458252, 0.010185242, 0.017974854, -0.0031337738, 0.030075073, -0.010665894, 0.030899048, 0.027832031, -0.0236969, -0.021636963, 0.019515991, -0.010482788, -0.0025043488, 0.048614502, 0.023544312, -0.005756378, -0.03439331, 0.0040359497, 0.005947113, -0.018875122, -0.018966675, -0.04534912, 0.0022296906, -0.04812622, -0.010795593, 0.006122589, 0.029830933, 0.024291992, -0.009941101, 0.029830933, -0.00096321106, 0.0039367676, -0.0043296814, 0.016036987, -0.02456665, 0.0010681152, -0.0031147003, 0.0061302185, 0.016342163, -0.01474762, 0.029388428, 0.03048706, 0.01876831, -0.04837036, 0.025970459, -0.020339966, 0.0031757355, -0.045959473, 0.001244545, -0.035949707, -0.042175293, -0.028274536, 0.010673523, -0.0031528473, 0.017700195, 0.005554199, 0.00043606758, 0.049560547, 0.020523071, 0.01386261, 0.03125, 0.015464783, 0.040924072, -0.0109939575, 0.017288208, 0.01687622, -0.027526855, 0.016418457, 0.017684937, -0.01210022, 0.021865845, -0.002500534, 0.06414795, 0.050231934, 0.054901123, -0.027023315, 0.02015686, 0.05239868, 0.0014228821, 0.02041626, -0.016235352, 0.0000680089, -0.04083252, -0.027236938, 0.010070801, -0.035461426, 0.020233154, 0.039764404, -0.05895996, 0.002922058, -0.045562744, 0.018661499, -0.050933838, 0.0006971359, -0.0061569214, -0.041412354, -0.09289551, 0.017959595, 0.012367249, -0.0132751465, -0.0069885254, -0.07348633, -0.016571045, -0.042114258, 0.004573822, 0.041778564, -0.01966858, -0.011856079, 0.027130127, -0.0010976791, 0.07501221, -0.025039673, -0.043518066, -0.005065918, 0.025772095, 0.046539307, -0.017242432, -0.041992188, 0.0357666, 0.036102295, 0.02986145, -0.017562866, 0.010131836, -0.0043792725, -0.009422302, -0.021270752, 0.0368042, -0.03326416, 0.0059814453, 0.06982422, -0.009277344, -0.034118652, 0.010467529, -0.029129028, 0.040008545, -0.04547119, -0.018310547, 0.0592041, 0.0141067505, -0.051696777, 0.006839752, -0.008155823, -0.007129669, 0.013977051, -0.0095825195, -0.003194809, -0.024902344, 0.01689148, -0.05038452, -0.084106445, -0.04135132, 0.031234741, -0.006034851, -0.01802063, 0.0006480217, 0.007583618, 0.012420654, 0.033599854, -0.0019330978, -0.046539307, 0.053649902, 0.055023193, 0.06060791, 0.0073928833, -0.02999878, 0.031707764, -0.023391724, -0.0418396, -0.00258255, -0.0047073364, -0.00806427, -0.026519775, -0.0035591125, -0.00096035004, -0.013511658, -0.05126953, -0.017959595, -0.020721436, 0.011238098, 0.0034255981, -0.0289917, 0.014923096, -0.015319824, -0.025253296, -0.009552002, -0.0057296753, -0.008560181, -0.01159668, 0.010467529, -0.030700684, 0.0022621155, -0.002325058, -0.016830444, 0.014816284, 0.015655518, 0.031982422, -0.023101807, 0.016113281, 0.024627686, -0.033355713, -0.006126404, -0.06427002, -0.0047302246, -0.02848816, -0.012802124, 0.012001038, 0.039764404, -0.051940918, 0.011520386, 0.008377075, -0.022567749, 0.0019073486, 0.0038852692, 0.044311523, -0.011978149, 0.0054130554 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06752v1
BeautifulPrompt: Towards Automatic Prompt Engineering for Text-to-Image Synthesis
Tingfeng Cao, Chengyu Wang, Bingyan Liu, Ziheng Wu, Jinhui Zhu, Jun Huang
cs.CL
Recently, diffusion-based deep generative models (e.g., Stable Diffusion) have shown impressive results in text-to-image synthesis. However, current text-to-image models often require multiple passes of prompt engineering by humans in order to produce satisfactory results for real-world applications. We propose BeautifulPrompt, a deep generative model to produce high-quality prompts from very simple raw descriptions, which enables diffusion-based models to generate more beautiful images. In our work, we first fine-tuned the BeautifulPrompt model over low-quality and high-quality collecting prompt pairs. Then, to ensure that our generated prompts can generate more beautiful images, we further propose a Reinforcement Learning with Visual AI Feedback technique to fine-tune our model to maximize the reward values of the generated prompts, where the reward values are calculated based on the PickScore and the Aesthetic Scores. Our results demonstrate that learning from visual AI feedback promises the potential to improve the quality of generated prompts and images significantly. We further showcase the integration of BeautifulPrompt to a cloud-native AI platform to provide better text-to-image generation service in the cloud.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06752v1
2023-11-12T06:39:00
2023-11-12T06:39:00
{ "title": [ -0.032714844, -0.011154175, -0.01763916, -0.03567505, -0.012390137, 0.0124435425, -0.03567505, -0.019958496, 0.026046753, 0.036376953, -0.050689697, 0.030578613, 0.0030517578, -0.0076446533, -0.039367676, 0.0004799366, -0.0071983337, 0.010238647, -0.045074463, -0.03111267, -0.007865906, -0.059753418, 0.00036096573, 0.03237915, 0.019195557, -0.008758545, -0.03326416, 0.008987427, -0.037841797, -0.024612427, 0.00014150143, 0.008354187, 0.038970947, 0.03817749, -0.020019531, 0.04953003, -0.05178833, 0.036346436, 0.017868042, -0.009460449, 0.013549805, -0.015701294, -0.026611328, -0.026885986, -0.048095703, 0.03564453, -0.05117798, -0.008422852, -0.0056877136, 0.049713135, 0.0018434525, 0.019485474, -0.011520386, 0.032440186, -0.0024642944, -0.052001953, -0.05996704, 0.033233643, 0.042633057, 0.05606079, 0.026611328, -0.048583984, -0.0020637512, -0.034454346, -0.006248474, -0.021636963, -0.04522705, 0.02760315, 0.07397461, 0.01423645, -0.031463623, 0.01309967, 0.0009813309, -0.06329346, -0.03555298, 0.07940674, -0.020233154, 0.0031967163, 0.051849365, -0.050323486, 0.00088596344, 0.006713867, -0.0011606216, -0.03616333, 0.031555176, -0.042022705, -0.011665344, -0.015075684, -0.050048828, -0.06124878, -0.014533997, -0.005130768, -0.037628174, -0.017837524, -0.032714844, -0.028564453, -0.011459351, 0.018371582, 0.015129089, 0.0076942444, 0.030334473, -0.011329651, 0.028808594, -0.039520264, 0.015945435, 0.053253174, -0.021255493, 0.023925781, 0.019699097, 0.040252686, 0.0014600754, 0.007003784, 0.025741577, 0.008155823, -0.0048179626, 0.005847931, -0.0055770874, 0.027877808, 0.00920105, 0.045318604, -0.012336731, -0.02746582, 0.038146973, 0.026870728, 0.03982544, 0.02407837, -0.03475952, -0.017028809, 0.012290955, -0.007637024, -0.0026454926, 0.058624268, -0.055236816, -0.06958008, -0.046783447, 0.056274414, -0.005630493, 0.0063591003, -0.02456665, 0.020721436, 0.01260376, -0.012413025, 0.0036182404, -0.019134521, -0.0049324036, 0.016082764, 0.04727173, -0.005340576, -0.044708252, -0.04748535, -0.0006184578, -0.0067977905, 0.0017023087, -0.0046157837, 0.004432678, -0.023544312, -0.10620117, -0.025756836, 0.059295654, 0.015472412, 0.014961243, 0.037506104, 0.049926758, 0.028442383, 0.074401855, -0.053131104, -0.032928467, 0.011878967, 0.023956299, 0.035858154, -0.018295288, 0.016448975, 0.050079346, 0.009124756, -0.006877899, 0.008232117, 0.05834961, -0.03111267, 0.011329651, 0.048309326, 0.03111267, -0.0069885254, 0.0152282715, 0.029144287, -0.0758667, -0.0289917, 0.009819031, 0.03591919, 0.058410645, 0.023361206, -0.041503906, -0.0028038025, -0.041992188, -0.044403076, -0.025268555, -0.017929077, 0.008079529, -0.0042533875, 0.0082473755, 0.04446411, -0.029678345, -0.020812988, -0.015586853, 0.0059051514, -0.0317688, -0.034118652, -0.022613525, 0.022827148, 0.008163452, 0.036895752, 0.03515625, 0.007881165, -0.03100586, 0.0055122375, -0.030960083, -0.05871582, 0.033966064, 0.024307251, 0.01675415, -0.020858765, -0.010475159, -0.00793457, 0.011199951, 0.030899048, 0.01033783, -0.017059326, 0.012016296, -0.028366089, 0.031082153, -0.0036468506, 0.054748535, 0.0053520203, 0.021881104, 0.052459717, 0.0046463013, -0.011741638, -0.0001847744, -0.031707764, 0.022659302, 0.0017566681, 0.0016450882, 0.010070801, -0.022598267, -0.009475708, 0.09643555, 0.025466919, 0.01574707, -0.0026378632, 0.022094727, 0.023132324, 0.03314209, -0.017654419, 0.048431396, -0.031951904, 0.004589081, 0.031585693, 0.005203247, -0.012130737, -0.006996155, -0.0016307831, 0.02368164, 0.0059394836, -0.01701355, 0.013450623, -0.043884277, 0.008369446, -0.03503418, -0.005710602, -0.010261536, 0.015365601, 0.035980225, -0.01663208, 0.012207031, -0.04071045, 0.015472412, -0.023071289, -0.026855469, 0.03491211, 0.044799805, -0.06933594, -0.008293152, -0.023452759, 0.032318115, -0.01272583, 0.05038452, -0.010345459, 0.018432617, -0.03741455, -0.01234436, 0.020889282, 0.061340332, 0.03439331, 0.016052246, -0.008308411, -0.00957489, 0.012084961, 0.09454346, 0.038604736, 0.0067329407, 0.014289856, 0.0020503998, 0.024917603, 0.0050849915, 0.008682251, -0.009162903, 0.044403076, 0.017715454, 0.0027866364, -0.0231781, -0.011131287, -0.017059326, -0.00459671, -0.0065956116, -0.01184082, -0.0692749, -0.05886841, -0.01235199, -0.04321289, -0.050109863, -0.014915466, 0.10290527, -0.0385437, -0.030395508, -0.021011353, -0.03805542, -0.013336182, -0.008346558, -0.042419434, -0.05895996, 0.022994995, 0.03463745, -0.0038909912, -0.038208008, -0.0033111572, -0.00045204163, 0.016235352, -0.012077332, 0.01133728, -0.012283325, 0.017440796, 0.0056495667, 0.0060272217, 0.0010948181, -0.036071777, 0.014022827, -0.06842041, 0.017425537, 0.010017395, -0.0075531006, 0.0041122437, 0.015052795, -0.02204895, -0.02796936, -0.013618469, 0.022872925, 0.03656006, 0.02116394, 0.0013866425, 0.029296875, -0.032684326, 0.007320404, 0.0154800415, -0.009727478, 0.015411377, -0.028167725, -0.02619934, -0.014968872, 0.024673462, -0.00029587746, 0.04260254, -0.015960693, -0.035095215, -0.017105103, -0.016479492, -0.0008325577, -0.010299683, -0.024490356, -0.029434204, -0.0011396408, -0.017562866, 0.01361084, 0.023040771, -0.0357666, 0.009666443, 0.07562256, 0.019927979, -0.009628296, 0.007369995, 0.03765869, 0.00025701523, 0.013343811, 0.0027580261, -0.030303955, -0.0075302124, 0.012077332, -0.0016307831, -0.010345459, 0.023132324, -0.09484863, 0.008682251, 0.007457733, 0.012283325, -0.011489868, 0.00415802, -0.043548584, -0.05090332, -0.012870789, -0.044067383, 0.036499023, 0.03363037, 0.004589081, 0.018966675, -0.0115356445, -0.007751465, -0.016723633, -0.03137207, -0.10345459, 0.014419556, -0.030883789, -0.020996094, -0.01914978, -0.007610321, -0.0569458, 0.002588272, 0.011886597, 0.07110596, 0.013374329, -0.017578125, 0.017318726, -0.03945923, 0.0033988953, -0.028411865, -0.020645142, -0.017608643, -0.020431519, 0.019317627, 0.015808105, 0.028503418, 0.03955078, -0.019989014, -0.00818634, 0.0067634583, -0.011985779, 0.016235352, 0.00039839745, -0.038482666, 0.0051651, 0.01991272, -0.041992188, -0.0016613007, -0.006916046, 0.014785767, -0.029022217, -0.003227234, -0.003522873, 0.026947021, 0.013084412, 0.029556274, 0.0019874573, -0.049865723, 0.029281616, -0.034820557, -0.06713867, 0.04119873, 0.020187378, -0.013153076, 0.032073975, -0.03567505, -0.04812622, 0.03479004, -0.03881836, 0.010437012, 0.025497437, 0.0079193115, -0.0005979538, -0.0009317398, -0.016906738, 0.010681152, -0.039031982, 0.006942749, 0.019485474, -0.019851685, 0.092285156, -0.06793213, -0.0025405884, 0.0040397644, -0.10595703, -0.021469116, 0.008834839, -0.027893066, -0.060455322, -0.022415161, 0.01108551, -0.017166138, -0.012580872, 0.03933716, 0.003019333, -0.04171753, -0.014190674, -0.045013428, -0.07611084, 0.08544922, 0.025772095, -0.0087890625, 0.0692749, -0.030014038, -0.027191162, -0.0057907104, 0.02482605, 0.039276123, 0.03933716, 0.03866577, -0.05545044, 0.026229858, -0.0385437, 0.020019531, 0.014595032, -0.006587982, -0.01096344, -0.0016031265, -0.0023212433, 0.03604126, -0.036315918, 0.06311035, 0.019958496, -0.0032691956, -0.089538574, 0.013420105, -0.020858765, -0.005016327, 0.031951904, -0.0054893494, 0.00010949373, -0.02418518, 0.015403748, 0.042388916, -0.017028809, 0.011512756, 0.042266846, -0.010536194, -0.01927185, -0.010353088, 0.017227173, 0.048034668, 0.0006084442, 0.041290283, -0.0061950684, 0.051452637, -0.009239197, -0.008415222, -0.0051078796, 0.004497528, -0.031158447, -0.016403198, -0.072387695, -0.0044403076, -0.020233154, 0.015182495, 0.00037050247, 0.043823242, 0.048095703, -0.019638062, -0.016693115, 0.0053977966, 0.021316528, -0.009346008, 0.00086021423, -0.066711426, -0.0014152527, -0.0014419556, -0.046905518, -0.018463135, -0.029342651, -0.041259766, 0.02998352, -0.019424438, -0.008338928, 0.017410278, 0.012145996, 0.03793335, 0.05038452, 0.004096985, -0.037597656, 0.06976318, 0.0049858093, -0.060913086, 0.011123657, 0.00365448, 0.0063934326, -0.03137207, 0.014099121, -0.030059814, -0.027923584, 0.0088272095, 0.04949951, -0.018051147, 0.08538818, -0.0317688, 0.020339966, 0.019851685, 0.024291992, 0.00062179565, 0.01826477, -0.028884888, 0.0074806213, -0.018005371, 0.011985779, 0.050872803, -0.008148193, 0.021118164, 0.026107788, 0.0049209595, 0.010276794, -0.018615723, -0.0046081543, 0.03768921, 0.003660202, -0.00022614002, -0.043029785, -0.030227661, -0.003698349, -0.002527237, 0.044311523, -0.012367249, 0.04067993, -0.020217896, 0.00017488003, -0.0015525818, -0.022598267, 0.010643005, -0.027938843, 0.014556885, -0.031036377, -0.057434082, 0.003168106, 0.04260254, -0.01991272, 0.00655365, -0.01953125, 0.0061149597, -0.012611389, 0.07519531, 0.037139893, 0.03930664, 0.010116577, -0.0058250427, 0.007659912, -0.052520752, -0.048797607, 0.0140686035, 0.0011749268, 0.001865387, -0.040924072, 0.017852783, -0.043701172, -0.022994995, -0.021636963, -0.024810791, 0.0016927719, -0.05166626, 0.045440674, 0.071899414, -0.025787354, 0.05697632, -0.011428833, 0.0317688, 0.022750854, 0.07141113, -0.009170532, 0.021011353, 0.040771484, -0.010444641, 0.060943604, 0.017822266, 0.012229919, 0.029647827, 0.009513855, -0.0065574646, 0.014213562, 0.012199402, 0.012077332, 0.013542175, -0.013183594, 0.0390625, -0.0446167, 0.02230835, 0.030517578, -0.010185242, -0.009017944, -0.00970459, -0.04748535, -0.038757324, -0.019470215, -0.059661865, 0.026245117, -0.03704834, -0.05130005, -0.035461426, 0.0069236755, -0.011398315, -0.026123047, 0.0068206787, 0.022872925, -0.028427124, 0.026519775, 0.03302002, -0.02935791, -0.010688782, 0.009002686, 0.000497818, 0.042114258, 0.021118164, -0.0385437, -0.0129470825, 0.00026774406, -0.033813477, -0.033355713, 0.007801056, 0.0027236938, -0.0068206787, -0.0140686035, -0.052459717, -0.013641357, 0.014923096, 0.038970947, -0.038238525, -0.0026569366, 0.012710571, -0.008666992, 0.004459381, 0.022201538, -0.003545761, -0.01386261, 0.010063171, 0.01928711, -0.028503418, 0.036010742, -0.02130127, 0.015792847, -0.008094788, -0.033447266, 0.004245758, 0.018676758, 0.0066871643, -0.00023031235, -0.0002053976, 0.019348145, -0.004989624, 0.015396118, 0.01600647, 0.0690918, -0.0395813, -0.045288086, -0.027496338, 0.0034503937, -0.036956787, 0.06628418, 0.010269165, -0.022659302, -0.038269043, -0.06744385, -0.032409668, 0.01033783, 0.038269043, 0.018356323, 0.025115967, -0.04534912, 0.011497498, -0.030639648, -0.024917603, -0.039245605, 0.010597229, -0.009750366, -0.014778137, 0.059448242, 0.0051574707, -0.0026073456, -0.003982544, 0.025741577, 0.013710022, -0.01689148, 0.04824829, -0.06060791, 0.00032901764, -0.025650024, -0.039489746, 0.03277588, 0.0061035156, -0.007896423, 0.07232666, -0.019958496, 0.05456543, 0.01109314, 0.03677368, 0.06274414, 0.025772095, -0.010665894, -0.0050964355, -0.014289856, -0.03652954, -0.0022010803, -0.057373047, 0.008071899, -0.032440186, -0.015670776, -0.033233643, -0.012870789, 0.015655518, 0.02154541, 0.022659302, -0.0031089783, 0.006134033, -0.0033740997, -0.011436462, -0.0014925003, 0.0211792, -0.048034668, -0.0060043335, -0.0077819824, -0.031066895, 0.05633545, 0.042175293, -0.029312134, 0.01977539, -0.032226562, -0.020721436, 0.016326904, 0.0044021606, 0.014350891, -0.033233643, -0.0256958, -0.046966553, 0.011940002, -0.004878998, -0.008560181, 0.07043457, 0.033355713, 0.036834717, -0.02519226, 0.026351929, 0.00047564507, -0.008552551, 0.0032653809, 0.02619934, 0.0068511963, 0.009300232, -0.033172607, -0.035980225, -0.045074463, 0.034576416, 0.015579224, -0.03225708, -0.0099487305, 0.030960083, 0.036224365, 0.007217407, -0.023666382, -0.05355835, -0.027893066, 0.00630188, 0.049621582, -0.012397766, 0.018218994, 0.0129470825, 0.017593384, 0.012046814, -0.034118652, 0.021987915, -0.0004413128, 0.011253357, 0.029769897, 0.025177002, 0.047424316, 0.00945282, -0.026748657, 0.000063955784, 0.020965576, -0.0519104, -0.015586853, 0.01776123, 0.059295654, 0.019897461, 0.0748291, 0.0058059692, -0.013450623, -0.012519836, -0.030166626, 0.029922485, 0.030349731, -0.03149414, 0.0018777847, -0.029129028, -0.027664185, 0.00969696, -0.028701782, 0.0259552, -0.031921387, 0.0008034706, -0.017959595, 0.00819397, 0.06298828, -0.042999268, -0.042816162, 0.0006775856, -0.027832031, -0.019073486, -0.0048217773, -0.0154800415, -0.06072998, -0.023376465, 0.056549072, -0.026046753, 0.011222839, 0.01725769, -0.028747559, -0.050811768, 0.016906738, -0.0078086853, 0.054382324, -0.0395813, -0.007583618, -0.0032405853, 0.0065193176, 0.006855011, -0.03326416, -0.035339355, -0.0057640076, -0.020401001, -0.036132812, 0.010139465, 0.015930176, -0.016311646, -0.008262634, -0.064208984, 0.026748657, -0.038146973, 0.045043945, 0.007835388, -0.0692749, -0.0006952286, 0.008956909, -0.03488159, 0.06726074, 0.029281616, -0.010620117, 0.027572632, 0.020507812, -0.03338623, -0.0074272156, 0.0022468567, 0.026260376, 0.019897461, -0.02909851, 0.009780884, -0.00223732, 0.02822876, -0.064208984, -0.11053467, -0.029815674, 0.029525757, -0.035491943, 0.021881104, 0.05682373, 0.03137207, 0.0423584, 0.0022792816, -0.015304565, -0.059417725, -0.007820129, -0.027770996, 0.057617188, 0.041412354, -0.011108398, -0.010688782, 0.016296387, -0.010253906, 0.004283905, -0.00356102, -0.02128601, -0.0054244995, -0.0040016174, 0.0024852753, -0.025283813, -0.0014734268, -0.09106445, 0.041931152, 0.003293991, 0.028244019, -0.020385742, 0.04977417, 0.0026302338, 0.020126343, -0.023513794, -0.04046631, 0.02848816, 0.037475586, -0.0014657974, 0.044769287, -0.024230957, -0.011245728, -0.015548706, -0.00944519, -0.012588501, -0.013397217, 0.01374054, -0.015106201, -0.008460999, -0.030548096, -0.072021484, -0.0256958, -0.051818848, 0.012336731, -0.030685425, 0.03842163, 0.020431519, 0.0032634735, -0.0012435913, 0.032287598, 0.025131226, 0.0149002075, -0.072143555, -0.022125244, 0.03463745, -0.047454834 ], "summary": [ 0.0017595291, -0.019638062, -0.011062622, -0.022613525, -0.014335632, -0.013031006, -0.022033691, -0.00774765, 0.047912598, 0.028701782, -0.068847656, 0.020706177, 0.037750244, -0.012664795, 0.0046195984, -0.0032691956, 0.009925842, 0.0039100647, -0.011184692, -0.03225708, 0.015266418, -0.03768921, -0.039031982, 0.038909912, -0.008453369, 0.019683838, 0.017700195, 0.013206482, -0.015350342, 0.008781433, 0.0040740967, -0.029434204, 0.014190674, -0.0014724731, 0.022506714, 0.036834717, -0.0026836395, 0.0059547424, 0.021362305, -0.011245728, 0.007987976, -0.010940552, 0.021362305, -0.04675293, -0.021224976, 0.032684326, -0.008888245, -0.030548096, 0.01725769, 0.05529785, -0.0054779053, 0.02508545, -0.021316528, 0.03225708, -0.0002425909, -0.0040397644, -0.07196045, 0.009864807, 0.023803711, 0.05105591, 0.02267456, -0.042022705, -0.0037326813, -0.037200928, -0.002248764, -0.026260376, -0.051879883, 0.027740479, 0.047821045, 0.008590698, -0.01777649, -0.0011854172, 0.004627228, -0.07824707, -0.041381836, 0.0579834, -0.027709961, -0.031311035, 0.03048706, -0.058380127, 0.007007599, 0.033233643, 0.003452301, -0.026535034, -0.0067749023, -0.033996582, -0.015541077, -0.016601562, -0.031311035, -0.0057907104, -0.023727417, -0.017684937, -0.05670166, 0.034332275, 0.019470215, -0.025299072, -0.022201538, -0.021392822, 0.005748749, 0.05731201, 0.03555298, -0.04763794, 0.111816406, -0.06237793, -0.014518738, 0.009819031, -0.004234314, 0.06365967, 0.04107666, 0.04168701, -0.001083374, -0.024017334, -0.0044288635, -0.012756348, 0.0034255981, 0.007911682, -0.037384033, 0.035888672, -0.0129776, 0.039733887, 0.0011577606, 0.00014269352, 0.034698486, 0.06524658, 0.020568848, 0.04849243, -0.0052986145, -0.04046631, 0.0027046204, -0.012054443, 0.0014228821, 0.054473877, -0.0033073425, -0.028762817, -0.046295166, 0.020874023, 0.031066895, 0.008659363, -0.0028266907, -0.040039062, 0.0680542, 0.0038528442, -0.007587433, 0.020736694, 0.029464722, 0.003862381, 0.020889282, 0.012184143, 0.000119805336, -0.016326904, 0.017440796, 0.0054397583, -0.018234253, 0.009391785, 0.012313843, -0.02368164, -0.048614502, -0.008880615, 0.059539795, 0.010093689, 0.03353882, 0.035125732, 0.07495117, 0.046447754, 0.03213501, -0.05819702, -0.044189453, -0.01889038, 0.018463135, 0.026687622, -0.0033016205, 0.027236938, 0.013626099, 0.0031204224, 0.0063552856, -0.02128601, 0.026550293, -0.027297974, 0.033416748, 0.014556885, -0.012290955, -0.012779236, 0.070251465, -0.021850586, -0.0062065125, -0.028686523, 0.0019521713, 0.049957275, 0.046539307, 0.03744507, -0.07720947, -0.044830322, -0.036224365, -0.034851074, -0.0034103394, 0.029052734, -0.025970459, 0.0014925003, -0.0064582825, 0.00856781, 0.012016296, -0.01247406, 0.0022850037, -0.05810547, -0.0814209, -0.01209259, -0.021987915, 0.039215088, -0.012702942, 0.019851685, 0.025939941, -0.019180298, -0.028671265, 0.06100464, 0.003501892, -0.046081543, 0.010276794, -0.010177612, 0.006893158, -0.036254883, 0.0075035095, 0.026382446, -0.002571106, 0.036071777, 0.0044174194, 0.0021972656, -0.0008172989, 0.016082764, 0.010406494, 0.015701294, 0.021865845, -0.0006904602, 0.014228821, 0.029708862, -0.0028247833, 0.0015964508, 0.012825012, -0.073791504, 0.009025574, 0.035705566, 0.016052246, 0.06390381, -0.021697998, -0.0072784424, 0.104003906, 0.028152466, -0.004589081, -0.0010175705, 0.008605957, 0.017166138, -0.010978699, -0.02029419, 0.014762878, -0.06750488, 0.0046310425, 0.036621094, -0.0049591064, -0.017837524, 0.011634827, -0.0009045601, 0.012237549, 0.023422241, -0.000105679035, 0.006340027, -0.06774902, -0.025894165, -0.06011963, -0.04940796, -0.0055236816, -0.029434204, 0.052612305, -0.011993408, -0.007835388, -0.035125732, 0.030303955, -0.03225708, -0.03326416, 0.017974854, 0.05154419, -0.028381348, 0.003293991, -0.007598877, 0.011581421, -0.025344849, 0.056610107, 0.024154663, 0.00006699562, -0.018447876, 0.002275467, 0.061553955, 0.05822754, 0.037506104, 0.024963379, -0.011878967, 0.0067863464, 0.03086853, -0.0073661804, -0.005138397, 0.020141602, -0.036315918, 0.024276733, 0.050689697, -0.018737793, 0.0184021, -0.016189575, 0.07714844, 0.018417358, -0.031799316, -0.02432251, -0.010971069, -0.032196045, -0.03265381, 0.013839722, 0.083984375, -0.029830933, -0.0524292, 0.0021686554, 0.039276123, -0.012138367, -0.004802704, 0.118774414, 0.021621704, -0.030532837, 0.01285553, -0.021591187, -0.032684326, 0.042816162, -0.051361084, -0.051818848, -0.009803772, -0.0093688965, -0.032318115, -0.001748085, 0.048309326, -0.0074653625, 0.0017995834, 0.017913818, 0.028915405, 0.02218628, 0.0023708344, 0.051239014, 0.03930664, -0.0155181885, -0.00017666817, -0.027557373, -0.04815674, 0.012763977, -0.012298584, 0.034851074, -0.0022773743, 0.021011353, 0.01033783, -0.037628174, 0.036743164, -0.011817932, 0.012626648, 0.049438477, 0.03253174, 0.0068206787, -0.021102905, -0.009361267, 0.015602112, -0.025497437, -0.012207031, 0.002943039, -0.010566711, -0.0030212402, 0.0029640198, -0.017944336, -0.0008649826, 0.030303955, -0.000016212463, 0.0072250366, -0.04071045, -0.064086914, -0.013458252, 0.06781006, -0.0052986145, -0.032684326, 0.032043457, 0.007347107, 0.035461426, -0.040374756, 0.046295166, 0.07141113, 0.0009331703, -0.01272583, 0.007713318, 0.047027588, 0.016143799, 0.0053100586, -0.0064582825, -0.0096206665, -0.020217896, 0.025817871, 0.019714355, -0.00039172173, 0.030136108, -0.028244019, -0.044555664, -0.008476257, 0.011047363, 0.016860962, -0.009796143, -0.008201599, -0.033691406, -0.0013933182, -0.0134887695, 0.014961243, -0.008552551, 0.014694214, -0.02999878, -0.013000488, -0.025375366, -0.00409317, -0.030563354, -0.011993408, 0.008636475, -0.01966858, -0.008979797, -0.015586853, 0.04559326, -0.011116028, 0.0082092285, 0.030883789, 0.06878662, -0.036743164, -0.0037212372, -0.028503418, -0.040161133, -0.009735107, -0.04434204, -0.029022217, 0.0058250427, 0.004234314, 0.04849243, 0.01600647, -0.0015993118, 0.04144287, -0.028808594, -0.045440674, -0.012458801, -0.03543091, -0.009796143, 0.022003174, -0.05593872, -0.015205383, -0.045135498, -0.043518066, 0.019363403, -0.012084961, 0.012466431, 0.0033073425, 0.036224365, -0.009750366, 0.048706055, 0.0011806488, 0.04837036, 0.07281494, -0.022888184, 0.037506104, -0.035949707, -0.02709961, 0.06518555, 0.038146973, -0.020370483, -0.006576538, -0.03668213, -0.055755615, 0.044281006, -0.012573242, 0.011390686, 0.016235352, -0.01600647, -0.00027751923, -0.06414795, 0.027664185, 0.0423584, -0.017974854, -0.053466797, -0.040130615, 0.0124053955, 0.052520752, -0.044036865, -0.038024902, 0.019134521, -0.048828125, -0.039489746, 0.02029419, 0.00016129017, -0.021270752, -0.011245728, 0.049926758, -0.03793335, 0.008674622, 0.02180481, -0.0061569214, 0.011924744, -0.0030708313, -0.018218994, -0.050048828, -0.011352539, 0.060302734, -0.028518677, 0.01272583, 0.016067505, -0.004512787, 0.026992798, 0.020523071, -0.040496826, 0.039154053, 0.0011386871, -0.014373779, 0.0053596497, -0.008621216, -0.000289917, 0.010505676, -0.010467529, -0.019348145, 0.012001038, 0.0035076141, 0.03765869, -0.021697998, 0.022567749, 0.032958984, -0.018035889, -0.030288696, 0.015686035, -0.025787354, -0.035339355, 0.026748657, 0.031677246, -0.018341064, 0.009315491, 0.013648987, -0.0003733635, -0.016067505, -0.031188965, 0.05206299, 0.058380127, -0.0040779114, -0.01058197, -0.007549286, 0.06555176, -0.0141067505, -0.0012540817, -0.025405884, 0.03640747, -0.052001953, 0.043029785, -0.003545761, -0.020446777, -0.05038452, -0.0552063, -0.025024414, -0.00037884712, 0.0050468445, 0.0021743774, 0.00052547455, 0.020996094, 0.012481689, -0.02104187, -0.01675415, 0.017471313, -0.012908936, 0.019821167, -0.07940674, -0.10308838, -0.005542755, -0.03778076, -0.0053863525, 0.0032100677, -0.0033130646, -0.07751465, 0.013473511, -0.020629883, -0.018295288, 0.0038318634, -0.019134521, 0.008926392, 0.02053833, 0.035705566, -0.028747559, 0.022750854, 0.012809753, -0.07897949, 0.0134887695, -0.0015449524, 0.00025367737, -0.09436035, -0.033935547, -0.014251709, -0.027069092, -0.023895264, 0.023925781, -0.013519287, 0.072509766, 0.013397217, 0.03677368, 0.017425537, 0.052886963, -0.0068244934, 0.018829346, 0.021194458, -0.033172607, -0.025848389, -0.0018186569, 0.09716797, -0.04360962, 0.0044937134, 0.025680542, -0.029403687, 0.046325684, -0.01184082, 0.021377563, 0.054779053, 0.011459351, -0.0008339882, -0.027648926, -0.011077881, 0.016036987, -0.025985718, 0.01928711, 0.024246216, 0.010917664, -0.008384705, -0.00019681454, 0.044952393, 0.014221191, -0.010879517, 0.047302246, -0.017654419, -0.014572144, -0.06591797, -0.0026550293, 0.06756592, -0.012054443, -0.015731812, -0.043670654, -0.00491333, -0.025894165, 0.02154541, -0.011184692, 0.024124146, 0.024612427, -0.029464722, -0.011001587, -0.020401001, -0.016159058, -0.033935547, -0.022079468, -0.0071907043, -0.053710938, 0.006225586, 0.068603516, -0.039794922, -0.009681702, 0.0044059753, -0.029800415, -0.0022392273, -0.018432617, 0.006664276, -0.064208984, 0.015640259, 0.051483154, 0.010513306, -0.022720337, 0.047912598, -0.02923584, 0.024414062, 0.005973816, -0.032165527, 0.09399414, 0.013145447, 0.00894165, 0.049560547, -0.01927185, -0.00053834915, 0.0118255615, 0.044769287, -0.020904541, -0.027572632, -0.007926941, 0.047576904, -0.029220581, 0.019470215, 0.026977539, -0.00006276369, -0.014343262, -0.0053138733, -0.04888916, -0.045562744, -0.011009216, -0.047058105, 0.010887146, -0.034576416, -0.06335449, -0.033843994, 0.02859497, 0.0065193176, -0.027999878, -0.021270752, 0.0067214966, -0.052978516, 0.0008468628, -0.0052757263, -0.022491455, -0.019546509, 0.040161133, 0.03186035, -0.019882202, -0.019851685, -0.049346924, -0.0131073, 0.0064926147, -0.001996994, -0.046020508, -0.04953003, -0.04473877, 0.025985718, 0.009536743, -0.011619568, 0.03866577, -0.018081665, 0.032592773, -0.062683105, 0.025344849, -0.00028681755, -0.008598328, -0.016311646, 0.057037354, -0.051940918, -0.034729004, 0.031402588, 0.022994995, -0.028701782, 0.02330017, 0.0093307495, 0.04269409, -0.037872314, -0.04360962, 0.011756897, 0.033050537, 0.024978638, 0.0071907043, 0.025314331, 0.017196655, -0.038116455, 0.05859375, 0.03125, 0.053222656, -0.018859863, -0.0016117096, -0.025970459, 0.0047912598, -0.05496216, -0.0040016174, 0.020111084, 0.016494751, -0.018203735, -0.050079346, 0.021072388, 0.016403198, 0.027328491, 0.015777588, 0.03161621, -0.05645752, 0.008308411, -0.046783447, -0.018295288, -0.002357483, 0.017303467, -0.035949707, -0.024368286, 0.050231934, -0.013053894, 0.0050315857, 0.016281128, 0.0129776, 0.013114929, -0.050231934, 0.06933594, -0.040161133, 0.0039253235, -0.023162842, -0.0041618347, 0.032562256, 0.024246216, 0.023284912, 0.05303955, 0.014076233, 0.023254395, -0.0079956055, -0.03741455, 0.010795593, -0.0017824173, -0.0284729, -0.031280518, 0.004676819, -0.021560669, 0.025314331, -0.011512756, -0.061157227, -0.0256958, -0.06173706, 0.0044059753, -0.057556152, 0.021591187, -0.024261475, 0.062927246, -0.01134491, -0.006965637, 0.008651733, -0.040771484, 0.0095825195, -0.024398804, -0.019989014, -0.016464233, -0.014671326, -0.034088135, 0.03262329, 0.042816162, -0.007408142, 0.0069847107, 0.000021576881, 0.0016336441, 0.057159424, -0.029083252, -0.022232056, -0.061645508, 0.0063552856, -0.05239868, -0.019714355, -0.009735107, -0.0011224747, 0.028686523, -0.018798828, 0.08782959, -0.041229248, 0.008041382, 0.016830444, 0.02218628, -0.014526367, -0.0037460327, 0.062042236, -0.0053100586, -0.012161255, -0.023468018, 0.0067329407, 0.0143585205, 0.010421753, -0.04067993, -0.011924744, -0.012954712, 0.013397217, 0.00970459, -0.0004696846, -0.059661865, -0.044006348, -0.0011177063, 0.0014810562, -0.025756836, -0.008735657, 0.045654297, -0.007007599, 0.032836914, -0.0040779114, 0.020401001, -0.0152282715, 0.04916382, 0.03527832, 0.019851685, 0.0151901245, -0.0042762756, -0.02659607, 0.029159546, -0.003293991, -0.010887146, 0.021911621, -0.027694702, 0.048797607, -0.004673004, 0.015731812, -0.05230713, -0.020141602, 0.034484863, 0.0048179626, 0.018035889, 0.017089844, 0.0023918152, -0.019729614, -0.00806427, 0.010932922, 0.000113129616, 0.0038223267, 0.025924683, -0.0024776459, 0.0011577606, 0.002811432, -0.032348633, 0.038116455, -0.01586914, -0.03552246, -0.017456055, 0.009986877, -0.0024490356, -0.0076293945, -0.027420044, -0.030532837, -0.012496948, 0.054351807, 0.000046670437, -0.005428314, 0.01638794, -0.0059547424, 0.0116119385, -0.009742737, 0.009635925, 0.0390625, -0.035186768, -0.025390625, 0.028045654, 0.019042969, 0.0042266846, -0.041625977, -0.018920898, 0.0030136108, 0.053375244, -0.046173096, 0.029510498, 0.024124146, -0.014007568, -0.04534912, -0.017150879, -0.0014324188, -0.034301758, 0.07128906, 0.022262573, -0.035827637, 0.018371582, 0.03982544, -0.03326416, 0.06719971, -0.024276733, -0.0056381226, 0.018356323, 0.024475098, -0.021072388, -0.0075531006, 0.0031528473, 0.011749268, 0.013534546, -0.013671875, -0.017089844, 0.004776001, 0.039276123, -0.02607727, -0.07354736, -0.011497498, 0.00440979, 0.00032234192, -0.01637268, 0.010772705, 0.035827637, 0.025344849, 0.025939941, 0.0013475418, -0.049316406, 0.025863647, -0.0036201477, 0.06304932, 0.012207031, -0.046661377, 0.017288208, -0.0059928894, -0.034301758, -0.008201599, -0.011482239, -0.01574707, -0.018035889, -0.008201599, -0.00957489, -0.036010742, 0.025802612, -0.07977295, 0.010307312, 0.009689331, 0.03866577, -0.0340271, 0.051727295, 0.012496948, 0.044036865, -0.05758667, 0.035614014, 0.019882202, -0.003194809, 0.021499634, -0.03555298, 0.027801514, 0.05633545, 0.032714844, 0.008811951, -0.023284912, 0.023834229, 0.030715942, -0.024139404, -0.041870117, -0.027069092, -0.061767578, -0.064575195, -0.047027588, -0.008850098, -0.022338867, 0.030090332, 0.049591064, -0.009536743, 0.018859863, -0.0017671585, 0.023849487, 0.019073486, -0.0017700195, -0.02557373, -0.007675171, 0.0012140274 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06737v1
Detecting and Correcting Hate Speech in Multimodal Memes with Large Visual Language Model
Minh-Hao Van, Xintao Wu
cs.CL, cs.AI
Recently, large language models (LLMs) have taken the spotlight in natural language processing. Further, integrating LLMs with vision enables the users to explore more emergent abilities in multimodality. Visual language models (VLMs), such as LLaVA, Flamingo, or GPT-4, have demonstrated impressive performance on various visio-linguistic tasks. Consequently, there are enormous applications of large models that could be potentially used on social media platforms. Despite that, there is a lack of related work on detecting or correcting hateful memes with VLMs. In this work, we study the ability of VLMs on hateful meme detection and hateful meme correction tasks with zero-shot prompting. From our empirical experiments, we show the effectiveness of the pretrained LLaVA model and discuss its strengths and weaknesses in these tasks.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06737v1
2023-11-12T05:20:20
2023-11-12T05:20:20
{ "title": [ 0.028305054, 0.019165039, -0.03189087, -0.024993896, 0.008407593, -0.029891968, -0.018127441, -0.032043457, 0.017089844, 0.0395813, -0.011367798, 0.008171082, 0.019348145, -0.016357422, -0.04638672, 0.012741089, -0.02458191, 0.055419922, -0.0072898865, -0.022857666, 0.001326561, -0.06274414, 0.036834717, -0.022018433, -0.00024020672, -0.038391113, -0.018234253, -0.0066947937, -0.026473999, -0.04333496, -0.0040359497, 0.025146484, 0.06518555, 0.005458832, -0.04940796, 0.041015625, -0.073791504, 0.035888672, -0.004585266, -0.0018701553, 0.0050239563, -0.014945984, -0.0041160583, 0.018814087, -0.034973145, 0.032714844, -0.05847168, -0.019866943, -0.005455017, 0.0184021, 0.016189575, 0.015655518, 0.013793945, 0.025299072, -0.00084257126, -0.042114258, -0.043518066, 0.0010538101, 0.031234741, 0.06124878, 0.0385437, -0.041992188, -0.0009851456, -0.0234375, -0.04397583, 0.013877869, -0.0051002502, -0.0044555664, 0.05368042, -0.027954102, -0.023223877, 0.012771606, 0.020446777, -0.0317688, -0.03253174, 0.015625, 0.024932861, 0.010894775, 0.01965332, -0.035949707, -0.03439331, -0.008293152, 0.017700195, -0.017547607, 0.0090408325, -0.016464233, -0.014160156, -0.01374054, -0.052886963, -0.047607422, -0.007774353, -0.04019165, -0.059936523, 0.025527954, 0.0006322861, -0.01928711, -0.0044517517, 0.077697754, -0.01991272, -0.024719238, -0.031066895, 0.030731201, -0.05142212, -0.029754639, 0.024291992, -0.0023784637, -0.037200928, -0.031021118, 0.042877197, 0.04473877, -0.030792236, 0.034606934, 0.014083862, -0.0039978027, -0.008270264, 0.022857666, 0.017288208, -0.00060129166, -0.007534027, 0.030517578, 0.0019836426, -0.02911377, 0.041625977, -0.008201599, 0.02999878, -0.0063552856, -0.048614502, 0.0011663437, -0.015701294, 0.02798462, 0.005378723, 0.056884766, -0.05581665, -0.08276367, -0.075805664, 0.02758789, -0.03564453, 0.013420105, -0.00065898895, 0.031143188, -0.028121948, -0.04248047, 0.039001465, -0.009902954, 0.0023040771, 0.01637268, 0.05545044, 0.0034942627, -0.06573486, -0.0579834, 0.030410767, -0.0052223206, 0.019348145, -0.01108551, -0.026748657, 0.0018281937, -0.07183838, -0.033691406, 0.011398315, -0.00806427, 0.032958984, 0.0076522827, 0.02017212, 0.0018930435, 0.005153656, -0.011932373, -0.03656006, 0.0049438477, 0.015281677, -0.0032844543, -0.0056037903, 0.015731812, 0.0044898987, 0.0022735596, 0.004463196, -0.006454468, 0.009689331, -0.012992859, 0.01096344, -0.0045204163, 0.0013494492, -0.017990112, -0.0020885468, 0.044891357, -0.07525635, -0.04800415, 0.028335571, 0.033416748, 0.03994751, 0.016815186, 0.021591187, 0.012931824, -0.022354126, -0.05480957, -0.06072998, -0.008232117, 0.02067566, 0.03668213, -0.009429932, 0.0390625, -0.00055122375, -0.0101623535, -0.023742676, -0.02796936, -0.074035645, -0.036468506, -0.030426025, 0.019348145, -0.027297974, 0.042297363, 0.05117798, 0.013298035, -0.06100464, 0.07397461, 0.01537323, -0.0635376, -0.0020103455, -0.008163452, -0.015182495, -0.015174866, -0.020690918, 0.0050315857, -0.0068244934, 0.036743164, 0.034210205, 0.004535675, 0.026763916, -0.026138306, 0.058898926, 0.028701782, 0.037200928, -0.05810547, 0.047912598, 0.02835083, -0.0075416565, -0.026367188, -0.009597778, -0.07928467, 0.021072388, 0.03555298, 0.000910759, 0.015205383, -0.006511688, 0.0104599, 0.049560547, -0.0026664734, 0.017654419, 0.0129470825, 0.010055542, 0.0038414001, 0.04534912, 0.0071258545, 0.045532227, -0.024795532, 0.019226074, 0.03967285, -0.015022278, -0.013221741, -0.04562378, 0.02255249, 0.020706177, 0.01651001, 0.0022239685, 0.011253357, -0.021316528, -0.022888184, -0.03967285, -0.0141067505, 0.0034618378, 0.008148193, 0.015686035, -0.07397461, 0.01600647, -0.03253174, -0.0015525818, 0.012969971, -0.006500244, 0.014816284, 0.024932861, -0.047576904, -0.021438599, -0.021118164, 0.023895264, -0.007129669, 0.024124146, -0.006549835, 0.028549194, -0.017623901, -0.003768921, -0.013305664, 0.030654907, 0.028320312, 0.016311646, -0.012382507, 0.03503418, -0.008369446, 0.1161499, 0.06109619, -0.0063438416, 0.021316528, -0.026657104, 0.01474762, -0.016738892, 0.013961792, -0.0033912659, 0.025039673, 0.009841919, -0.0040664673, -0.035064697, -0.0025959015, -0.02796936, 0.0340271, -0.007209778, -0.03805542, -0.061309814, -0.05480957, -0.03161621, -0.03665161, -0.07208252, 0.0051841736, 0.05697632, -0.033935547, -0.03186035, 0.0042800903, -0.029556274, -0.005859375, 0.014656067, -0.030899048, -0.017059326, 0.020568848, 0.086364746, 0.041534424, -0.023284912, -0.018661499, 0.02180481, -0.004501343, -0.0069274902, 0.013938904, -0.014205933, -0.0011053085, 0.0030784607, -0.028869629, 0.0015449524, -0.0103302, 0.0035419464, -0.054840088, 0.026290894, -0.0032520294, -0.013145447, 0.015914917, 0.008087158, 0.00630188, -0.009475708, -0.0027275085, 0.041992188, 0.013923645, -0.022491455, -0.011329651, 0.018325806, -0.019165039, -0.0048599243, 0.019348145, 0.00023782253, -0.024642944, -0.025375366, -0.028076172, -0.040252686, 0.054504395, 0.029006958, 0.05923462, -0.001420021, -0.014465332, -0.014907837, -0.004634857, 0.017837524, -0.03186035, -0.037902832, -0.054534912, 0.026504517, -0.026931763, -0.037963867, -0.03543091, 0.019897461, 0.020767212, 0.10424805, 0.011672974, -0.00034165382, 0.0129470825, 0.013442993, 0.008728027, -0.044067383, -0.048309326, -0.03375244, 0.0066833496, 0.023712158, -0.014205933, 0.015731812, 0.011734009, -0.10443115, -0.014373779, 0.00057172775, 0.010101318, -0.004890442, 0.025146484, -0.08831787, 0.036346436, -0.044769287, -0.025756836, 0.0209198, 0.067871094, 0.019836426, 0.028152466, 0.0051460266, 0.033691406, -0.000895977, -0.034606934, -0.14855957, 0.017593384, -0.049438477, -0.0033302307, 0.004348755, -0.033172607, -0.04928589, 0.009117126, -0.004043579, 0.037994385, -0.001950264, -0.008224487, 0.011695862, -0.011711121, -0.004901886, -0.012641907, -0.00818634, -0.0068244934, -0.043945312, 0.015029907, 0.0051460266, 0.058410645, 0.03488159, -0.026229858, -0.008781433, -0.018203735, -0.037231445, 0.018554688, 0.004863739, -0.04586792, -0.024093628, -0.011100769, -0.022918701, 0.03390503, -0.039093018, 0.0077934265, -0.017623901, 0.027954102, -0.018234253, 0.0060691833, -0.029342651, 0.042053223, -0.017715454, -0.02243042, 0.060638428, -0.03414917, -0.029449463, 0.049713135, 0.027114868, -0.02104187, 0.00030350685, 0.0036239624, -0.022003174, 0.019104004, 0.026916504, 0.0060920715, 0.019836426, -0.016555786, 0.036193848, -0.045562744, -0.03201294, 0.020858765, -0.049713135, -0.011276245, -0.02458191, 0.024887085, -0.051818848, -0.072021484, -0.009475708, -0.004802704, -0.08544922, -0.050628662, 0.035461426, -0.02909851, -0.03717041, -0.035369873, 0.048187256, -0.04510498, 0.004009247, 0.03466797, 0.0023021698, -0.022033691, -0.0016012192, -0.051849365, -0.039215088, 0.073791504, 0.0036792755, 0.0012130737, 0.04147339, -0.012008667, 0.0031261444, -0.03237915, 0.03778076, 0.04815674, 0.018051147, 0.0041389465, -0.033355713, 0.043029785, -0.025909424, -0.00017857552, 0.038879395, -0.021240234, 0.0040130615, 0.024597168, 0.022720337, 0.008911133, -0.0035362244, 0.05819702, 0.010108948, -0.028381348, -0.034484863, -0.027435303, -0.015975952, -0.011436462, 0.021484375, -0.021560669, 0.028945923, 0.018661499, -0.0007214546, 0.06628418, -0.02267456, 0.0017986298, 0.03640747, -0.010314941, -0.017120361, -0.0016899109, 0.007247925, 0.027297974, 0.017425537, -0.010025024, -0.026992798, -0.0077705383, -0.013092041, -0.032165527, -0.018753052, -0.004219055, -0.052215576, -0.023254395, -0.055480957, -0.06304932, -0.025161743, 0.014122009, -0.01134491, 0.03591919, 0.038513184, 0.011177063, -0.020309448, -0.00982666, 0.07745361, -0.0043792725, 0.010253906, -0.06365967, -0.023910522, 0.008087158, -0.07495117, -0.021896362, -0.018249512, -0.022125244, 0.009223938, -0.019439697, -0.0062026978, 0.01084137, 0.007270813, 0.050201416, 0.08251953, 0.0124053955, -0.046813965, 0.054748535, -0.03564453, -0.025680542, 0.016586304, -0.002735138, -0.0236969, -0.015960693, 0.01828003, -0.019042969, -0.022781372, -0.02835083, 0.054656982, -0.023971558, 0.0814209, -0.01474762, 0.006500244, 0.025817871, 0.0011301041, 0.02507019, 0.020263672, -0.027999878, -0.014953613, 0.0118255615, 0.018707275, -0.015014648, 0.022491455, 0.043640137, 0.01247406, 0.0002361536, -0.008361816, 0.013305664, 0.00026345253, 0.0010910034, 0.023635864, 0.0004940033, -0.057891846, -0.033050537, -0.026245117, -0.016464233, 0.018630981, -0.047546387, 0.047698975, -0.004638672, -0.036712646, 0.025802612, 0.0063209534, 0.009490967, 0.012878418, 0.0064811707, -0.03363037, -0.05722046, 0.025177002, 0.05508423, -0.016815186, 0.022445679, -0.021881104, -0.0079422, 0.047912598, 0.031036377, -0.017700195, -0.0023860931, -0.023788452, 0.011054993, -0.0007958412, -0.038116455, -0.039367676, 0.014205933, 0.043182373, 0.015327454, -0.042633057, -0.00044584274, -0.030197144, -0.038085938, -0.017105103, -0.0053482056, 0.008514404, -0.039215088, 0.032928467, 0.08581543, -0.017913818, 0.03753662, 0.026107788, 0.027359009, -0.0084991455, 0.0546875, -0.0043182373, 0.015426636, 0.04724121, -0.07788086, 0.028625488, 0.004310608, 0.00957489, 0.0121536255, 0.022277832, 0.008071899, 0.014671326, -0.038909912, 0.015167236, -0.02633667, -0.017486572, 0.032073975, -0.041656494, -0.0070610046, 0.00059366226, 0.009010315, -0.0024642944, -0.018356323, 0.008308411, 0.019363403, -0.037750244, -0.016082764, -0.0008664131, -0.049468994, -0.08734131, -0.024414062, 0.009666443, 0.02067566, -0.002828598, -0.011184692, -0.008407593, -0.058563232, 0.029006958, 0.032958984, -0.049041748, 0.002002716, -0.0035095215, 0.0044174194, 0.036102295, 0.016448975, -0.01789856, -0.0073165894, -0.019897461, -0.024429321, -0.013496399, 0.026275635, 0.023223877, 0.014282227, -0.013442993, -0.034942627, -0.009468079, 0.010826111, 0.034332275, -0.027786255, -0.0104522705, 0.021621704, -0.01448822, -0.017303467, 0.019012451, -0.019989014, -0.00415802, 0.011940002, 0.0099105835, -0.062805176, 0.013931274, 0.002746582, 0.03555298, 0.0057296753, -0.042144775, 0.007835388, 0.023239136, 0.020980835, -0.0048217773, 0.022338867, 0.031311035, 0.015487671, -0.0041999817, 0.012016296, 0.054504395, -0.028182983, -0.013938904, -0.0004043579, 0.0095825195, -0.040283203, 0.002626419, 0.016662598, 0.015899658, -0.038391113, -0.05810547, -0.017105103, 0.023269653, -0.003534317, 0.013336182, -0.0024871826, -0.030075073, 0.04321289, -0.064453125, 0.013641357, -0.03378296, 0.021148682, -0.017593384, -0.0004556179, -0.010154724, -0.0008430481, -0.025619507, 0.010902405, 0.009498596, 0.012916565, -0.02709961, 0.04269409, -0.021911621, 0.0121536255, -0.013511658, -0.03250122, 0.03616333, -0.017471313, 0.0077400208, 0.03668213, -0.004585266, 0.044830322, 0.03302002, 0.06149292, 0.061462402, 0.022415161, 0.0010519028, 0.014724731, 0.0063438416, -0.032348633, 0.011016846, -0.064208984, -0.024749756, -0.07495117, -0.020629883, -0.07086182, 0.024520874, -0.03237915, 0.036193848, 0.015594482, 0.005432129, 0.0058670044, -0.010650635, 0.03164673, -0.01927185, 0.042175293, -0.015731812, -0.018112183, 0.03353882, -0.031433105, 0.03338623, 0.044067383, 0.010139465, -0.014053345, -0.020385742, -0.010032654, -0.013290405, 0.017822266, 0.017181396, -0.03375244, -0.01763916, -0.03353882, 0.023117065, 0.00022923946, 0.021499634, 0.048980713, 0.01096344, -0.006919861, -0.024108887, 0.011428833, -0.032684326, -0.019927979, -0.017349243, 0.02571106, -0.02923584, 0.037872314, -0.031402588, -0.030593872, -0.005256653, 0.03881836, 0.032714844, -0.06933594, -0.012649536, 0.03173828, 0.024414062, -0.011413574, 0.029830933, -0.051086426, -0.03829956, -0.06097412, 0.018859863, 0.0020771027, -0.019210815, -0.023391724, 0.037384033, -0.010131836, -0.001206398, 0.019119263, -0.008010864, 0.008766174, 0.030548096, -0.030639648, 0.012306213, 0.016647339, -0.03213501, 0.003622055, 0.006855011, -0.021759033, -0.014373779, -0.011192322, 0.056793213, 0.0000461936, 0.064086914, 0.0021858215, -0.016662598, -0.01348114, 0.003540039, 0.00687027, 0.05432129, -0.015136719, -0.010429382, -0.03741455, -0.05368042, 0.010040283, -0.04373169, 0.07318115, -0.05328369, 0.024551392, -0.024841309, -0.0068359375, 0.031555176, -0.05657959, 0.016677856, -0.02029419, -0.036895752, -0.022613525, -0.046295166, -0.041168213, -0.04611206, -0.036010742, 0.033172607, -0.025680542, 0.0061302185, -0.01322937, -0.01991272, -0.048309326, 0.0028762817, -0.011116028, 0.045135498, 0.013626099, -0.008926392, -0.03363037, 0.010643005, 0.014587402, -0.012580872, -0.014419556, -0.0016841888, -0.046661377, -0.02508545, 0.0011529922, 0.00096035004, -0.020767212, -0.059051514, -0.01939392, -0.0024528503, -0.045166016, 0.015022278, 0.048614502, -0.019882202, -0.1149292, -0.028060913, -0.021530151, 0.04107666, 0.013015747, 0.0021953583, 0.018798828, 0.025039673, -0.017913818, -0.022903442, 0.01802063, 0.02458191, 0.0138168335, -0.02078247, -0.00036239624, 0.019561768, 0.030014038, -0.03842163, -0.076660156, -0.0007238388, 0.011672974, -0.012794495, 0.004863739, 0.02381897, -0.017196655, 0.02229309, -0.0098724365, -0.0047073364, -0.017654419, -0.006996155, -0.014556885, 0.019744873, 0.051208496, -0.0051078796, 0.0026397705, 0.032592773, -0.025238037, 0.00046610832, -0.015792847, -0.02607727, -0.0020275116, -0.00060892105, 0.021102905, -0.006866455, 0.01638794, -0.010574341, 0.056152344, -0.0110321045, 0.047973633, -0.009162903, 0.0003566742, 0.037139893, 0.027252197, -0.0065231323, -0.09033203, 0.03829956, 0.031799316, 0.0028915405, 0.043060303, -0.011932373, -0.0418396, -0.023620605, -0.0143966675, 0.0005378723, -0.008033752, 0.014259338, -0.022720337, 0.010215759, -0.06427002, -0.045013428, -0.030288696, -0.04800415, 0.033843994, -0.04473877, 0.014373779, -0.035095215, 0.0064201355, -0.009674072, 0.05505371, 0.0019350052, -0.028656006, -0.0042419434, -0.015113831, 0.056243896, -0.015899658 ], "summary": [ 0.025100708, -0.016662598, -0.0038452148, 0.0023994446, -0.048461914, -0.024856567, -0.017501831, -0.027328491, 0.042755127, 0.042266846, -0.0061302185, -0.024291992, 0.048553467, -0.028076172, -0.019348145, 0.005428314, -0.012664795, 0.05303955, 0.015258789, -0.008293152, -0.003698349, -0.0395813, 0.0044136047, -0.068603516, -0.0023536682, -0.011398315, 0.0064735413, -0.030273438, -0.009643555, -0.011627197, 0.007106781, 0.013000488, 0.022460938, -0.0007472038, -0.008964539, 0.05432129, -0.06439209, 0.039215088, 0.012504578, -0.005592346, 0.0062828064, -0.0054359436, 0.061767578, 0.010681152, -0.0052948, 0.040863037, -0.04446411, -0.06085205, 0.011520386, -0.017593384, -0.0058403015, 0.03375244, 0.0073051453, 0.01776123, -0.029174805, -0.029052734, -0.053375244, 0.029205322, 0.0027618408, 0.08728027, 0.02545166, -0.0008788109, -0.022033691, -0.049743652, -0.032318115, 0.029769897, -0.024154663, -0.02394104, 0.047607422, -0.020080566, -0.009117126, -0.014945984, 0.01084137, -0.064941406, 0.024276733, 0.031677246, 0.005558014, 0.0034999847, -0.0036830902, -0.004550934, -0.0038051605, 0.04257202, 0.027633667, -0.007045746, -0.02255249, -0.012565613, -0.013092041, -0.020339966, -0.02330017, -0.0435791, -0.018798828, -0.04949951, -0.07104492, 0.057373047, 0.026687622, -0.03086853, 0.01550293, 0.034118652, -0.025924683, -0.012649536, 0.008888245, -0.020248413, 0.01234436, -0.028564453, 0.020828247, 0.025146484, -0.033477783, -0.016464233, 0.042633057, 0.020706177, -0.0032653809, -0.016693115, 0.024215698, 0.004299164, -0.031982422, -0.014289856, 0.0060195923, 0.023544312, -0.0024280548, 0.022064209, -0.029251099, -0.0262146, 0.039916992, 0.039642334, 0.021484375, 0.019180298, -0.009231567, -0.0057792664, 0.023651123, 0.012229919, -0.0030918121, 0.03314209, -0.02760315, -0.0446167, -0.056274414, -0.004878998, 0.01159668, 0.0021762848, 0.011131287, -0.00028276443, -0.00015473366, -0.012481689, 0.03161621, 0.011817932, 0.00541687, 0.022583008, 0.033081055, 0.0051002502, -0.0390625, -0.06732178, 0.04272461, -0.009544373, 0.008369446, -0.024353027, 0.013908386, -0.030899048, -0.0345459, -0.020339966, 0.045410156, 0.007247925, 0.00983429, -0.0013360977, 0.04321289, 0.017044067, -0.014785767, 0.0026683807, -0.012809753, -0.013458252, 0.01977539, -0.011985779, 0.007461548, 0.031677246, 0.033691406, 0.014785767, 0.016082764, -0.010978699, -0.00844574, 0.04119873, 0.022155762, -0.06903076, -0.016067505, -0.033111572, 0.056274414, 0.004585266, -0.025817871, -0.043029785, 0.026672363, 0.06384277, 0.019607544, 0.04006958, 0.0007534027, -0.019302368, -0.010932922, 0.0005707741, -0.01828003, -0.023406982, 0.007911682, 0.01184845, -0.012054443, 0.0076065063, 0.038085938, -0.020889282, 0.0020771027, -0.07751465, -0.12109375, -0.011070251, -0.034576416, 0.042633057, 0.0041236877, 0.024307251, 0.016082764, -0.0131073, -0.04815674, 0.08660889, -0.005695343, -0.04925537, 0.01159668, -0.0077285767, -0.01209259, -0.03933716, 0.013824463, 0.018798828, -0.0043258667, 0.07727051, -0.038269043, -0.0017137527, 0.01309967, 0.021118164, 0.023635864, 0.03326416, 0.06335449, -0.06933594, 0.011306763, 0.014793396, -0.00969696, -0.0362854, 0.0009112358, -0.12310791, 0.04449463, 0.07525635, 0.024871826, 0.02078247, -0.032989502, -0.019760132, 0.029846191, 0.01133728, 0.028457642, -0.023666382, -0.0024261475, 0.011856079, 0.007282257, -0.017959595, 0.026290894, -0.05895996, 0.015350342, 0.036621094, -0.025634766, -0.043792725, -0.031951904, 0.021560669, 0.015167236, -0.002046585, 0.0032730103, 0.005470276, -0.0005464554, -0.06591797, -0.029769897, -0.03894043, 0.012252808, -0.031677246, 0.02494812, -0.08013916, 0.013847351, -0.06488037, -0.048217773, 0.010902405, 0.0030918121, 0.032562256, 0.025009155, -0.05343628, -0.017059326, -0.02897644, -0.046691895, -0.015731812, 0.037231445, -0.004611969, -0.0002090931, -0.0029392242, 0.036499023, 0.050048828, 0.039794922, 0.029830933, 0.029174805, 0.003835678, 0.034820557, -0.011421204, 0.09698486, -0.0105896, 0.041259766, -0.028823853, 0.030456543, 0.036865234, -0.04812622, 0.023284912, -0.0027999878, 0.029205322, -0.0065078735, 0.0088272095, 0.0077323914, 0.0027065277, -0.023925781, 0.047973633, 0.0206604, 0.039123535, -0.05569458, -0.043182373, -0.027420044, 0.02670288, -0.0259552, 0.030319214, 0.088256836, -0.007160187, -0.033599854, 0.03189087, -0.018295288, -0.02935791, 0.055755615, -0.043945312, -0.002412796, 0.0031776428, 0.04257202, 0.014183044, 0.009765625, -0.014205933, 0.022125244, -0.029296875, 0.0017776489, 0.010803223, -0.005405426, -0.0012273788, 0.022888184, -0.042999268, -0.0047836304, -0.0008454323, -0.03475952, -0.02053833, -0.001906395, -0.0234375, 0.00063562393, 0.015068054, 0.005405426, 0.031051636, 0.0038909912, 0.032318115, 0.025802612, 0.004386902, -0.021865845, -0.006038666, -0.0023536682, -0.034332275, -0.020614624, 0.034851074, -0.002696991, -0.02784729, -0.0256958, -0.011512756, -0.03201294, 0.049804688, 0.06506348, 0.053466797, 0.022994995, 0.04864502, -0.024490356, -0.0079574585, 0.00283432, -0.04034424, 0.03765869, -0.01713562, 0.05807495, 0.045898438, 0.009880066, 0.011222839, 0.048553467, 0.024230957, 0.08898926, 0.007335663, 0.017349243, 0.019439697, 0.019989014, 0.008270264, -0.03366089, -0.057647705, -0.022567749, -0.004638672, 0.0050849915, -0.022338867, 0.019317627, 0.015159607, -0.066589355, -0.025970459, -0.019058228, 0.016357422, 0.057739258, -0.02998352, -0.06585693, 0.08746338, -0.07104492, 0.0131073, 0.044433594, 0.004180908, 0.03451538, -0.011001587, 0.03503418, -0.01486969, -0.024734497, -0.0082092285, -0.085510254, -0.0066986084, -0.023422241, 0.050476074, -0.001832962, -0.008834839, -0.0033454895, 0.040130615, -0.009147644, 0.015823364, -0.031173706, -0.000024795532, -0.017364502, 0.042541504, -0.020812988, 0.008476257, -0.008972168, -0.013504028, -0.050811768, 0.010925293, 0.014823914, 0.025466919, 0.044311523, -0.058776855, 0.004371643, -0.022399902, -0.060394287, -0.005569458, -0.0014648438, -0.0423584, -0.017471313, -0.005760193, 0.014465332, 0.04067993, -0.038757324, -0.004337311, -0.0027275085, 0.026657104, -0.049072266, 0.006088257, -0.041229248, 0.05239868, 0.05697632, -0.027374268, 0.027633667, -0.042053223, -0.0032997131, 0.046539307, 0.022949219, 0.020568848, -0.020553589, 0.036193848, 0.016693115, -0.036956787, 0.06347656, -0.034484863, 0.011077881, -0.023117065, 0.015449524, -0.059509277, 0.0067100525, 0.017410278, -0.0112838745, -0.040283203, -0.044281006, 0.02720642, -0.0713501, -0.04876709, -0.030776978, 0.0044021606, -0.058288574, -0.041015625, 0.0033721924, 0.024734497, -0.015808105, 0.010574341, 0.07208252, -0.039978027, 0.024810791, 0.02154541, -0.010032654, 0.022918701, 0.0032176971, -0.045806885, 0.014213562, -0.004787445, 0.019851685, 0.01612854, 0.0063209534, -0.009552002, 0.023544312, -0.0076141357, 0.027389526, 0.03527832, -0.005428314, -0.003955841, -0.011177063, 0.0098724365, -0.013465881, -0.0031604767, 0.045135498, -0.05038452, 0.027374268, 0.020141602, 0.0473938, 0.026000977, 0.030090332, 0.0005130768, -0.0027275085, 0.016464233, 0.0065460205, -0.0057029724, -0.0016584396, -0.030761719, 0.03729248, 0.0033721924, 0.0019664764, 0.0418396, -0.015007019, 0.02168274, -0.035949707, -0.019195557, 0.016784668, 0.006340027, -0.02027893, -0.015304565, 0.0052833557, 0.036132812, -0.014457703, 0.015144348, -0.014297485, 0.0071029663, 0.01436615, -0.026260376, -0.015838623, 0.0020523071, -0.016021729, -0.039093018, -0.039245605, -0.0440979, -0.00080776215, 0.0093307495, -0.0018320084, 0.02130127, 0.03414917, 0.012313843, 0.021453857, -0.045532227, 0.0592041, 0.018615723, -0.025543213, -0.09814453, -0.031951904, -0.0048332214, -0.047607422, -0.025238037, -0.0017309189, -0.034729004, -0.029312134, -0.017410278, -0.021453857, 0.00007426739, 0.012428284, 0.05847168, 0.061401367, 0.04296875, -0.060791016, 0.012939453, -0.021194458, -0.0009121895, -0.026687622, 0.00982666, -0.041992188, -0.011360168, 0.012283325, 0.000008404255, -0.027420044, -0.0635376, 0.016601562, -0.012237549, 0.043945312, 0.048339844, 0.016052246, 0.021331787, 0.018981934, -0.008872986, 0.003643036, 0.010787964, 0.010604858, -0.009346008, -0.017730713, 0.0625, 0.020095825, 0.04537964, 0.0062179565, -0.00945282, -0.025161743, 0.025878906, -0.0067367554, 0.000069737434, 0.027511597, -0.017227173, -0.024429321, -0.014541626, 0.008232117, -0.020477295, 0.007205963, 0.023712158, 0.015266418, 0.010734558, -0.004924774, 0.04837036, -0.0005326271, -0.013832092, 0.0357666, -0.013832092, -0.011100769, -0.07543945, 0.0039978027, 0.06726074, 0.005718231, -0.00020599365, -0.046447754, -0.043945312, 0.014976501, 0.0039405823, -0.04385376, 0.009941101, 0.013214111, 0.008621216, -0.0027313232, -0.0231781, -0.009254456, -0.0154418945, 0.050720215, 0.026046753, -0.012802124, -0.027786255, 0.024765015, -0.06390381, -0.032073975, 0.00052404404, 0.0025520325, -0.023101807, -0.035308838, 0.037231445, -0.015792847, 0.022842407, 0.07989502, -0.012039185, -0.053619385, 0.028762817, -0.0357666, 0.0071754456, 0.005584717, -0.08758545, 0.031311035, -0.013931274, 0.0053596497, 0.042541504, 0.025634766, 0.010643005, 0.043151855, -0.02470398, -0.0025959015, -0.06585693, -0.02720642, 0.040130615, -0.023330688, 0.0061569214, -0.029052734, 0.008583069, -0.010536194, 0.0038318634, -0.021743774, -0.0069999695, -0.009216309, -0.021743774, -0.016021729, -0.03781128, -0.0859375, -0.0110321045, 0.023330688, 0.02558899, -0.023986816, -0.0018835068, -0.0024089813, -0.048461914, 0.016784668, -0.0051956177, -0.01424408, -0.0121154785, 0.027999878, 0.014419556, -0.013389587, 0.013793945, -0.018112183, -0.0045318604, -0.026901245, -0.009803772, 0.0012245178, 0.03817749, 0.03164673, 0.020507812, -0.010810852, 0.015655518, 0.013420105, -0.014663696, 0.02961731, -0.06213379, -0.011695862, 0.0068855286, -0.049713135, -0.07299805, 0.052642822, -0.023330688, -0.026794434, 0.014465332, 0.0009536743, -0.031555176, 0.027038574, -0.007911682, 0.03152466, -0.03805542, -0.0546875, 0.014839172, 0.021606445, 0.026733398, -0.023040771, 0.05239868, 0.010566711, -0.027038574, -0.010986328, -0.001830101, 0.0017747879, -0.0037059784, -0.009239197, 0.017623901, 0.025222778, -0.026626587, -0.03778076, 0.026306152, 0.018432617, -0.014724731, -0.043701172, 0.017211914, 0.016403198, 0.0010585785, 0.00137043, 0.00198555, -0.03427124, 0.012519836, -0.032440186, -0.0006580353, 0.002708435, -0.014099121, -0.021438599, -0.015556335, 0.04425049, 0.022598267, -0.02029419, 0.037322998, 0.008857727, 0.008903503, -0.04675293, 0.0418396, -0.009498596, 0.007850647, -0.0104599, -0.013175964, 0.012207031, 0.015090942, -0.015159607, 0.011756897, 0.009376526, 0.044433594, 0.051818848, 0.011909485, 0.041503906, 0.009223938, 0.014030457, 0.013366699, -0.013153076, -0.011383057, 0.042419434, -0.007701874, -0.042053223, -0.07165527, -0.043395996, -0.04385376, 0.072021484, -0.05999756, -0.017791748, 0.048950195, -0.0079956055, 0.0024547577, 0.025238037, -0.030838013, 0.031402588, -0.0075035095, -0.0006670952, -0.02178955, 0.04446411, -0.025177002, 0.003648758, 0.044708252, -0.014877319, 0.007030487, -0.024307251, 0.00983429, -0.0014848709, -0.0068473816, -0.030883789, -0.060821533, 0.018844604, -0.046569824, 0.011230469, 0.011260986, 0.030853271, 0.026626587, -0.028640747, 0.032684326, -0.03579712, -0.013397217, -0.009178162, -0.012641907, -0.0062332153, -0.0028572083, 0.018798828, -0.006313324, -0.025436401, -0.020309448, 0.057403564, 0.025772095, 0.035461426, -0.049346924, -0.011390686, 0.0016717911, 0.018661499, -0.010955811, 0.012969971, -0.057891846, -0.050567627, -0.076538086, -0.014472961, 0.0063667297, -0.033843994, -0.04748535, 0.03744507, 0.017456055, -0.018325806, 0.03137207, -0.05630493, 0.049743652, 0.034179688, 0.01991272, 0.009521484, 0.019821167, -0.017715454, 0.0051498413, 0.02859497, -0.03152466, 0.009628296, -0.035247803, 0.0635376, -0.011772156, 0.039764404, -0.04849243, -0.0044555664, 0.024215698, 0.026947021, 0.0035247803, 0.020095825, 0.007335663, -0.034179688, -0.04336548, -0.019714355, -0.024795532, -0.053344727, 0.02734375, -0.055908203, 0.064208984, -0.023162842, -0.021118164, -0.03253174, -0.022857666, 0.025787354, 0.0009088516, -0.011009216, -0.0014896393, 0.0026683807, -0.030960083, -0.01689148, -0.029510498, 0.00010186434, -0.016448975, -0.0023078918, 0.0044288635, 0.0033340454, -0.024780273, -0.008407593, 0.013397217, 0.04397583, 0.034179688, -0.038116455, 0.0059814453, 0.0009784698, 0.033325195, -0.021087646, -0.030395508, 0.0019702911, 0.01423645, 0.021743774, -0.027526855, -0.002790451, -0.032043457, -0.1270752, -0.002708435, 0.009033203, -0.06414795, 0.05267334, 0.016708374, -0.013206482, -0.10180664, -0.009109497, -0.019058228, 0.016998291, -0.015014648, -0.0140686035, 0.040405273, 0.016204834, -0.0109939575, 0.012260437, 0.01550293, 0.018966675, -0.00055503845, -0.0029029846, -0.004547119, 0.001294136, 0.023025513, -0.013397217, -0.05899048, 0.0012264252, 0.005004883, -0.0055999756, -0.04852295, -0.01802063, -0.03543091, 0.070495605, -0.014320374, 0.009162903, 0.0020217896, 0.029205322, 0.025390625, 0.03152466, 0.024490356, -0.03274536, 0.012023926, 0.0079193115, -0.03677368, -0.009147644, -0.012664795, -0.029129028, -0.016403198, -0.00010514259, -0.000177145, -0.023773193, 0.019866943, 0.056732178, 0.04067993, -0.026443481, 0.036376953, -0.020080566, -0.017684937, 0.037628174, -0.035064697, -0.024276733, -0.08111572, 0.040222168, 0.022415161, 0.0005903244, 0.0067977905, 0.036102295, -0.025115967, 0.00006347895, -0.0035171509, -0.012969971, -0.0036411285, 0.0037708282, -0.028045654, -0.005596161, -0.03186035, -0.016998291, -0.060516357, -0.027633667, 0.015167236, -0.048919678, 0.018112183, -0.005378723, -0.007537842, 0.0007686615, 0.045196533, 0.0017986298, -0.006477356, 0.019683838, -0.007270813, 0.0151901245, 0.011833191 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06736v1
Are LLMs Rigorous Logical Reasoner? Empowering Natural Language Proof Generation with Contrastive Stepwise Decoding
Ying Su, Xiaojin Fu, Mingwen Liu, Zhijiang Guo
cs.CL
Logical reasoning remains a pivotal component within the realm of artificial intelligence. The recent evolution of large language models (LLMs) has marked significant progress in this domain. The adoption of strategies like chain-of-thought (CoT) has enhanced the performance of LLMs across diverse reasoning tasks. Nonetheless, logical reasoning that involves proof planning, specifically those that necessitate the validation of explanation accuracy, continues to present stumbling blocks. In this study, we first evaluate the efficacy of LLMs with advanced CoT strategies concerning such tasks. Our analysis reveals that LLMs still struggle to navigate complex reasoning chains, which demand the meticulous linkage of premises to derive a cogent conclusion. To address this issue, we finetune a smaller-scale language model, equipping it to decompose proof objectives into more manageable subgoals. We also introduce contrastive decoding to stepwise proof generation, making use of negative reasoning paths to strengthen the model's capacity for logical deduction. Experiments on EntailmentBank underscore the success of our method in augmenting the proof planning abilities of language models.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06736v1
2023-11-12T05:12:49
2023-11-12T05:12:49
{ "title": [ -0.039611816, -0.02053833, -0.052703857, -0.06427002, -0.029846191, -0.008560181, -0.0803833, 0.0067863464, -0.018341064, 0.01675415, -0.038848877, 0.02583313, -0.013198853, -0.016815186, -0.013504028, -0.019851685, -0.02809143, 0.05041504, -0.034698486, -0.0385437, 0.00005853176, -0.072509766, -0.009124756, 0.06286621, 0.0076446533, -0.0096206665, 0.008850098, -0.009849548, 0.014984131, 0.00044751167, 0.007888794, -0.057769775, 0.021224976, 0.0072669983, 0.011734009, 0.035095215, -0.04083252, 0.0309906, 0.008613586, 0.002714157, 0.0053253174, -0.012001038, -0.0463562, -0.037384033, -0.04522705, 0.0055389404, -0.04751587, -0.009986877, -0.007118225, 0.042236328, 0.00067043304, -0.0045814514, -0.01386261, 0.055908203, 0.009719849, -0.021835327, -0.02078247, -0.043884277, 0.026870728, 0.049316406, 0.03164673, -0.035736084, 0.014465332, -0.027069092, -0.009979248, -0.012771606, -0.042938232, 0.0076942444, 0.06173706, 0.017837524, -0.008422852, 0.0042877197, 0.0036296844, -0.015296936, -0.037597656, 0.022384644, 0.026245117, 0.0051651, 0.034423828, -0.036743164, 0.034820557, 0.03100586, 0.041809082, -0.04989624, 0.056427002, -0.02015686, -0.0046463013, -0.0259552, -0.04071045, -0.09637451, -0.025009155, -0.009155273, -0.021850586, -0.051574707, -0.060699463, -0.052246094, 0.0025253296, 0.02897644, -0.00541687, -0.028335571, -0.01586914, 0.0184021, -0.041412354, -0.022277832, 0.0028629303, 0.03237915, -0.005039215, -0.014183044, 0.0014429092, 0.02142334, -0.025726318, 0.019500732, 0.014808655, -0.08392334, 0.040405273, 0.051879883, 0.014724731, 0.03543091, 0.04147339, 0.0087890625, -0.038879395, -0.04940796, 0.025283813, 0.07055664, 0.02973938, 0.038024902, -0.003944397, 0.005897522, 0.017745972, 0.048706055, 0.013389587, 0.009292603, -0.09844971, -0.08312988, -0.06903076, 0.023040771, 0.011978149, -0.013801575, -0.024795532, 0.0011749268, 0.02218628, -0.007156372, 0.030151367, 0.007511139, -0.016326904, 0.011604309, 0.035217285, -0.009880066, -0.029251099, -0.034179688, -0.061065674, 0.015686035, 0.020706177, -0.030029297, -0.07336426, -0.039154053, -0.14526367, 0.022323608, 0.054779053, 0.01096344, 0.009742737, 0.018005371, 0.0362854, 0.015419006, 0.030914307, -0.02796936, -0.02760315, 0.006500244, 0.03060913, 0.059051514, 0.00630188, 0.0027618408, 0.023742676, 0.00141716, -0.015327454, 0.0032577515, 0.031677246, 0.00289917, -0.010734558, 0.002773285, 0.0026168823, -0.025741577, -0.01121521, 0.03475952, -0.061309814, 0.003850937, -0.004863739, 0.03213501, 0.04119873, -0.003835678, -0.0078048706, 0.011077881, 0.0016145706, -0.026855469, -0.0206604, -0.057373047, -0.016021729, -0.016418457, -0.005050659, 0.03149414, -0.03062439, 0.010292053, -0.051757812, 0.012130737, -0.037750244, -0.025283813, -0.014717102, 0.013954163, -0.030029297, 0.05596924, 0.045166016, 0.003967285, -0.030975342, 0.032348633, 0.010398865, -0.09649658, 0.013008118, -0.0073280334, -0.007095337, -0.047424316, 0.02482605, -0.026901245, 0.030593872, 0.0670166, 0.007030487, 0.040252686, -0.018417358, 0.00484848, 0.027069092, 0.03857422, 0.04135132, -0.03479004, 0.020187378, 0.020126343, -0.002199173, -0.010734558, -0.015701294, -0.0637207, -0.005870819, 0.020385742, 0.0146102905, 0.001909256, -0.016601562, -0.039764404, 0.053619385, -0.011444092, 0.017059326, -0.039489746, 0.0018854141, 0.04385376, 0.06072998, 0.030075073, 0.026123047, 0.014663696, -0.015617371, 0.05682373, 0.016799927, 0.0076179504, -0.0044670105, 0.0047416687, 0.004020691, -0.0058021545, -0.022018433, 0.0012149811, -0.045532227, -0.039794922, -0.03326416, -0.003534317, 0.014945984, -0.047058105, 0.027786255, 0.00009030104, 0.012290955, -0.0006890297, -0.045166016, -0.015823364, -0.019683838, 0.032928467, 0.032470703, -0.040008545, 0.0026683807, 0.0024662018, 0.06829834, -0.013435364, 0.023834229, 0.019882202, 0.03857422, -0.027313232, -0.03189087, -0.0077590942, 0.031677246, 0.034118652, -0.008872986, 0.0126953125, 0.017105103, -0.017944336, 0.06958008, 0.040527344, -0.010055542, 0.011878967, -0.039489746, 0.012252808, 0.034118652, -0.024642944, 0.00010496378, 0.015594482, 0.012794495, 0.021408081, -0.023910522, -0.0002206564, -0.05316162, -0.00894165, -0.0010318756, -0.0018825531, -0.03302002, -0.04522705, 0.0014543533, -0.02078247, -0.026412964, 0.005493164, 0.047027588, 0.000043570995, 0.0041122437, 0.008804321, 0.005458832, -0.048065186, 0.028335571, -0.023010254, 0.020248413, 0.012138367, 0.038482666, 0.01512146, -0.04272461, -0.001086235, 0.013313293, 0.0090789795, -0.0049819946, -0.016571045, -0.03378296, -0.03881836, -0.026245117, -0.026412964, 0.017623901, -0.022338867, -0.037353516, 0.021133423, 0.0050849915, 0.015022278, -0.03503418, -0.009788513, 0.021118164, -0.04019165, -0.00308609, 0.03945923, 0.052581787, -0.031677246, -0.011566162, 0.050109863, 0.0064888, -0.007873535, 0.038330078, 0.007835388, 0.030410767, -0.034942627, -0.035339355, -0.036895752, -0.0068092346, -0.0046310425, -0.0121536255, 0.021438599, -0.035003662, -0.031082153, -0.051330566, -0.006904602, 0.005256653, 0.031707764, 0.030166626, -0.015106201, -0.03741455, 0.005645752, -0.011451721, 0.023956299, -0.052459717, 0.03967285, 0.06402588, 0.019927979, -0.004764557, -0.014678955, 0.028549194, 0.0012216568, -0.0032863617, -0.016189575, -0.068237305, -0.039886475, 0.0134887695, 0.014083862, -0.028076172, 0.01928711, -0.019515991, -0.0023002625, 0.07098389, -0.0024662018, -0.01991272, 0.032714844, -0.06756592, -0.025756836, -0.0041046143, -0.01020813, 0.01739502, -0.029815674, 0.008041382, -0.029632568, -0.018554688, -0.03604126, 0.017913818, -0.06750488, -0.09790039, 0.023040771, -0.028366089, -0.002954483, -0.0002450943, -0.009262085, -0.039978027, -0.0077781677, -0.021835327, 0.035980225, 0.04348755, 0.019882202, 0.021560669, 0.024154663, 0.024841309, -0.013999939, -0.0042648315, 0.014816284, -0.022064209, 0.056732178, 0.003627777, 0.020706177, 0.023468018, -0.021713257, -0.002828598, 0.007949829, -0.019256592, 0.026138306, 0.007881165, -0.03970337, -0.009361267, -0.01084137, -0.016326904, 0.018463135, -0.014556885, -0.0020809174, -0.04626465, 0.01876831, -0.02947998, 0.070373535, 0.0076408386, 0.015823364, -0.027069092, -0.010627747, 0.002653122, -0.0073776245, -0.024291992, -0.010482788, 0.043792725, -0.009094238, -0.014602661, 0.006965637, -0.047851562, 0.04135132, 0.009185791, 0.00017786026, -0.0062713623, 0.004070282, 0.03112793, -0.005302429, -0.035125732, 0.04623413, -0.07513428, -0.018615723, -0.01272583, 0.007457733, -0.007827759, -0.068481445, -0.024307251, 0.0104904175, -0.08709717, -0.016983032, 0.010322571, -0.015144348, -0.04269409, -0.012207031, 0.020309448, -0.02130127, -0.027038574, 0.019378662, -0.01625061, 0.034576416, 0.027069092, -0.045074463, 0.0023765564, 0.060028076, -0.004917145, -0.006790161, 0.051239014, -0.007671356, -0.0637207, -0.007472992, 0.012924194, -0.019134521, 0.00995636, 0.006477356, -0.014762878, 0.028808594, -0.026107788, 0.017684937, 0.021148682, -0.033569336, 0.011726379, 0.029541016, -0.00969696, 0.028152466, -0.029342651, 0.05935669, 0.021072388, -0.018814087, -0.068847656, 0.04260254, 0.0066986084, -0.029525757, 0.01687622, -0.051879883, 0.022735596, 0.055664062, 0.0038471222, 0.07385254, -0.010475159, -0.03387451, 0.020614624, 0.03225708, -0.029052734, -0.012489319, 0.025894165, 0.064086914, 0.0042686462, 0.044311523, -0.00932312, 0.06750488, -0.040039062, 0.041778564, -0.02368164, -0.006008148, -0.051696777, -0.003545761, -0.054626465, -0.015777588, -0.016342163, 0.027160645, -0.045166016, 0.016464233, 0.05923462, 0.0014047623, -0.050231934, 0.0047340393, 0.033203125, -0.00749588, -0.030532837, -0.0925293, -0.024154663, 0.0055732727, -0.054229736, -0.0357666, -0.03100586, 0.025878906, -0.017868042, 0.0055160522, -0.00047564507, 0.031158447, 0.020248413, 0.027160645, 0.050354004, -0.009712219, -0.026321411, 0.04574585, -0.004764557, -0.01889038, -0.028198242, 0.034484863, -0.023498535, -0.048431396, -0.020217896, 0.00027751923, -0.017959595, -0.078186035, 0.03741455, 0.007896423, 0.040252686, 0.020492554, 0.003648758, 0.025314331, -0.0006952286, 0.0045394897, 0.0005364418, -0.037841797, 0.040008545, 0.0022411346, 0.056732178, -0.034088135, -0.029006958, -0.008033752, 0.0385437, 0.024932861, 0.0051002502, -0.0077819824, 0.011199951, 0.015464783, 0.02658081, 0.011161804, -0.025619507, -0.016983032, 0.025390625, 0.01737976, 0.058532715, -0.015151978, -0.008834839, -0.022140503, 0.021408081, 0.053985596, -0.003824234, 0.0284729, 0.07434082, 0.008300781, -0.04208374, 0.008934021, 0.022979736, -0.02583313, -0.028640747, 0.0015506744, 0.011260986, 0.0082473755, 0.02796936, 0.032989502, 0.05255127, -0.025497437, 0.03012085, -0.005836487, 0.019012451, 0.016342163, -0.035308838, -0.0007176399, -0.012504578, 0.015701294, -0.0067367554, 0.0079193115, -0.035369873, -0.00066900253, -0.004951477, -0.021469116, -0.03353882, -0.054779053, 0.03237915, 0.023483276, -0.017745972, 0.044799805, 0.022232056, 0.014312744, -0.020263672, 0.05529785, -0.019973755, 0.023666382, 0.041503906, -0.06829834, -0.032440186, 0.01083374, 0.037963867, 0.013427734, 0.046142578, 0.02067566, 0.011146545, -0.05899048, 0.00054597855, -0.0022296906, 0.0012588501, 0.012550354, -0.03567505, 0.009666443, 0.017089844, 0.011726379, 0.0034255981, -0.010368347, -0.047424316, -0.0028419495, -0.020339966, 0.015022278, -0.008544922, -0.0070228577, -0.041290283, -0.036071777, 0.054260254, -0.025558472, -0.01991272, 0.016494751, -0.003545761, -0.019088745, 0.031311035, 0.03274536, -0.017333984, 0.00919342, 0.0101623535, -0.008399963, 0.050689697, 0.051361084, -0.044830322, -0.016845703, 0.028457642, -0.03515625, -0.017623901, 0.009857178, -0.0074501038, -0.013145447, 0.005504608, 0.008171082, -0.00008279085, -0.0026435852, 0.038726807, -0.024429321, -0.03074646, 0.026947021, -0.015716553, 0.0017642975, 0.044158936, 0.028778076, -0.022979736, 0.02947998, 0.036743164, -0.04147339, 0.020553589, 0.016998291, 0.009963989, -0.0041885376, -0.06994629, -0.008018494, 0.02394104, -0.0009355545, 0.0034675598, 0.0049819946, 0.018341064, 0.08770752, -0.0149383545, 0.0031547546, 0.060150146, -0.03286743, -0.015533447, -0.017974854, 0.024093628, -0.03970337, 0.025314331, -0.0057792664, -0.0044670105, -0.021591187, -0.046173096, -0.028381348, -0.005519867, 0.019454956, -0.011390686, -0.0072402954, -0.016235352, 0.0099105835, -0.05090332, -0.012245178, -0.057373047, 0.022903442, -0.043426514, -0.0625, 0.070007324, -0.0028705597, -0.0053596497, -0.025650024, 0.031311035, 0.04638672, 0.005203247, 0.047027588, -0.046081543, -0.026153564, -0.033325195, 0.0023994446, 0.04660034, 0.017059326, -0.006587982, 0.056610107, -0.030044556, 0.04486084, -0.004272461, 0.053253174, -0.009765625, 0.019210815, 0.046447754, 0.004798889, 0.015731812, -0.023651123, 0.023422241, -0.03933716, -0.009803772, -0.045410156, -0.020721436, -0.08062744, -0.025299072, 0.023620605, 0.045959473, 0.009811401, 0.009239197, 0.043518066, 0.016845703, 0.0073509216, -0.015960693, 0.06213379, -0.035888672, -0.015945435, 0.0057029724, -0.0096206665, 0.020309448, 0.035003662, -0.03237915, 0.04043579, -0.010437012, -0.018417358, 0.036621094, 0.0068893433, -0.0077171326, -0.06567383, 0.0030593872, -0.065979004, 0.027832031, -0.012527466, 0.021438599, 0.059295654, 0.016143799, 0.013504028, -0.029129028, 0.012786865, -0.028778076, 0.021759033, -0.019683838, 0.00049352646, -0.02935791, 0.03363037, -0.012275696, -0.028503418, -0.017684937, 0.064331055, 0.009681702, -0.013175964, 0.01600647, 0.0065345764, 0.014961243, 0.031585693, 0.03363037, -0.015335083, -0.025421143, -0.005264282, -0.008705139, 0.018295288, 0.0715332, 0.052856445, 0.032562256, 0.007633209, -0.030578613, 0.009742737, -0.023849487, -0.011497498, 0.022460938, 0.03741455, 0.0748291, 0.0021743774, -0.0357666, 0.017807007, 0.02809143, -0.08306885, 0.0054969788, 0.0008802414, 0.035308838, 0.023880005, 0.05493164, 0.017227173, -0.021713257, 0.0012931824, -0.03277588, -0.009605408, 0.032196045, -0.025100708, 0.015304565, -0.02558899, -0.03768921, 0.042999268, -0.013504028, 0.058441162, -0.028579712, -0.017440796, -0.050109863, 0.055603027, -0.0060768127, -0.02255249, -0.032196045, -0.036499023, 0.0066184998, -0.009895325, 0.019363403, -0.025253296, -0.022140503, -0.013450623, 0.040893555, -0.0062561035, 0.016296387, 0.012535095, -0.05709839, -0.027236938, 0.027526855, 0.03463745, 0.055023193, 0.03933716, -0.009376526, 0.0014514923, 0.013931274, -0.011726379, -0.031982422, -0.022750854, 0.0071144104, -0.0009832382, -0.0024585724, 0.021850586, 0.030029297, 0.016921997, 0.02772522, -0.011100769, 0.02633667, -0.012420654, 0.008163452, 0.016586304, -0.035583496, -0.02116394, 0.0073127747, -0.034240723, 0.040802002, 0.026763916, -0.012680054, 0.05255127, 0.020965576, -0.0024375916, -0.02420044, -0.00920105, -0.014099121, -0.0006504059, -0.024032593, 0.006542206, -0.0046157837, 0.02178955, -0.05114746, -0.09881592, -0.004573822, 0.023727417, -0.02909851, 0.00630188, 0.04727173, -0.00034809113, -0.023422241, 0.011993408, -0.034851074, -0.027755737, 0.040924072, 0.009963989, 0.010528564, 0.054138184, -0.02609253, 0.037719727, 0.008674622, -0.0143966675, 0.025863647, -0.017562866, -0.038116455, -0.005241394, -0.014678955, 0.018325806, 0.0118255615, -0.019577026, -0.03878784, 0.032348633, -0.010551453, 0.020996094, -0.016525269, 0.03475952, 0.00390625, 0.01689148, -0.0011510849, -0.02684021, 0.03765869, 0.04272461, 0.021224976, 0.03643799, -0.0032215118, -0.017730713, -0.019332886, 0.02519226, -0.0018415451, 0.026016235, 0.005645752, 0.029144287, 0.037322998, -0.008621216, -0.017349243, -0.020721436, -0.01096344, 0.033081055, -0.009307861, 0.0015230179, -0.01928711, -0.0078125, 0.010040283, 0.053649902, -0.00497818, -0.023757935, -0.03918457, 0.028045654, 0.039642334, -0.025283813 ], "summary": [ -0.013710022, -0.044128418, -0.006175995, -0.04373169, -0.06756592, 0.011749268, -0.07946777, 0.004776001, 0.0075950623, 0.02319336, -0.039154053, 0.016113281, 0.024917603, -0.01701355, 0.009529114, -0.012268066, -0.014923096, 0.034942627, -0.0036144257, -0.032989502, 0.022827148, -0.05065918, -0.018798828, 0.06573486, -0.013038635, -0.0024356842, 0.02545166, -0.011550903, 0.034301758, 0.02230835, 0.015174866, -0.044128418, 0.019470215, -0.004562378, -0.0009822845, 0.03201294, 0.0009121895, -0.0049095154, -0.015029907, 0.03955078, 0.02128601, -0.013008118, 0.051086426, -0.0127334595, -0.0056266785, 0.049926758, -0.02406311, -0.016296387, 0.013000488, 0.03378296, -0.0009803772, 0.0050621033, -0.016067505, 0.043029785, -0.030776978, -0.025802612, -0.03579712, -0.020645142, -0.0008020401, 0.084228516, 0.041503906, 0.0028533936, -0.024093628, -0.041625977, -0.014556885, 0.012428284, 0.010276794, -0.018554688, 0.0637207, 0.014541626, -0.010604858, 0.02557373, 0.021987915, -0.0046577454, 0.0036468506, -0.023132324, 0.038604736, -0.016601562, 0.010009766, 0.00011229515, -0.009361267, 0.020233154, 0.0072288513, -0.030578613, -0.0026741028, -0.024414062, -0.024902344, 0.000050783157, -0.0141067505, -0.06225586, -0.020523071, -0.004261017, -0.047424316, 0.0005540848, -0.03475952, -0.031021118, 0.0028305054, -0.015586853, -0.0020065308, -0.048980713, 0.048919678, -0.047302246, -0.010650635, -0.009887695, -0.0024356842, 0.0390625, -0.0070724487, -0.004562378, 0.024124146, 0.01928711, 0.010437012, -0.00017142296, 0.003583908, -0.07885742, 0.04815674, 0.06048584, 0.017807007, 0.084106445, 0.047027588, 0.04486084, -0.047027588, -0.041412354, -0.023330688, 0.07720947, 0.023956299, 0.031951904, 0.022109985, 0.02029419, 0.03161621, 0.0231781, -0.0055999756, 0.007270813, -0.05783081, -0.03338623, -0.045654297, -0.018615723, 0.021484375, -0.0093307495, -0.02708435, -0.028656006, 0.05065918, 0.011207581, -0.004245758, 0.00091552734, -0.02532959, 0.049072266, 0.025131226, -0.0013122559, -0.025726318, -0.048034668, -0.023010254, -0.034332275, 0.03152466, -0.022384644, -0.05795288, -0.055023193, -0.113342285, 0.03717041, 0.04660034, 0.01247406, -0.0076446533, 0.025527954, 0.021347046, -0.016677856, -0.012176514, -0.047668457, -0.016220093, -0.0037765503, 0.01689148, 0.02961731, -0.01184082, 0.015159607, -0.014297485, 0.0077705383, 0.002084732, -0.013549805, 0.035583496, 0.028182983, -0.02670288, 0.033691406, 0.028961182, -0.022888184, 0.01876831, 0.00036907196, -0.026611328, 0.0059928894, 0.00006580353, 0.0345459, 0.037719727, 0.010154724, 0.004875183, -0.01965332, -0.02078247, -0.011489868, 0.0018558502, -0.035583496, 0.002111435, -0.015197754, -0.005252838, 0.015434265, 0.011703491, 0.003850937, -0.02607727, -0.026992798, -0.06854248, -0.008865356, -0.015213013, 0.035491943, 0.011192322, 0.037139893, 0.025527954, 0.014633179, -0.044921875, 0.043914795, -0.0060653687, -0.050872803, 0.0072364807, -0.02368164, 0.01802063, -0.036315918, 0.039276123, 0.029968262, 0.00932312, 0.033813477, -0.03677368, 0.014793396, -0.029174805, 0.03012085, -0.011924744, 0.044525146, 0.005264282, -0.046142578, 0.0362854, 0.027023315, -0.0262146, -0.017028809, -0.019470215, -0.0657959, 0.0046844482, 0.044067383, 0.022460938, 0.018936157, -0.047027588, -0.037231445, 0.023071289, -0.0032234192, 0.015411377, -0.021469116, -0.03451538, 0.0078125, 0.034484863, 0.021331787, 0.012878418, 0.038604736, -0.023147583, 0.033599854, -0.005924225, -0.02835083, 0.010536194, 0.026382446, -0.0003888607, -0.011993408, -0.015823364, -0.0016241074, 0.008171082, -0.049621582, -0.0034542084, -0.0056114197, 0.009086609, -0.056732178, 0.009269714, -0.032562256, 0.017974854, -0.05029297, -0.08734131, 0.012779236, -0.023513794, 0.04812622, 0.053222656, -0.046325684, 0.003036499, 0.018539429, 0.07348633, -0.005836487, 0.015541077, 0.03152466, 0.036376953, -0.018325806, 0.003118515, 0.053619385, 0.05355835, 0.009880066, 0.0024909973, -0.012687683, 0.0010404587, -0.005092621, 0.03201294, 0.029968262, 0.014579773, -0.014633179, 0.002855301, 0.039031982, -0.023208618, 0.011199951, 0.016937256, 0.004623413, 0.02041626, 0.009902954, -0.002462387, 0.016906738, -0.05847168, -0.0026283264, 0.020690918, 0.061706543, -0.030807495, -0.029129028, -0.0048828125, 0.04446411, 0.030914307, 0.062805176, 0.024810791, 0.008361816, 0.009918213, 0.040222168, 0.01612854, -0.036865234, 0.07543945, -0.0158844, 0.032104492, -0.003288269, -0.00016248226, -0.010978699, -0.032287598, -0.006008148, 0.006904602, -0.015487671, 0.00042009354, 0.03945923, -0.0064697266, -0.0107803345, 0.014167786, -0.07623291, 0.0038223267, 0.004470825, -0.02760315, 0.0076065063, -0.011413574, -0.0011463165, 0.0005674362, -0.006576538, -0.0049095154, -0.014434814, -0.012619019, 0.06414795, 0.018127441, 0.01335144, 0.017578125, 0.037994385, 0.0013198853, -0.034606934, 0.00843811, 0.030975342, 0.015640259, -0.036224365, -0.050323486, -0.015731812, -0.006385803, 0.028656006, 0.033721924, 0.01474762, -0.05731201, 0.05581665, -0.056915283, -0.005455017, 0.033233643, 0.04196167, 0.12902832, 0.012214661, -0.055725098, 0.062042236, 0.005393982, 0.044525146, -0.06524658, 0.052612305, 0.06750488, 0.011772156, -0.0027332306, 0.034240723, 0.0118637085, 0.0026454926, -0.021469116, -0.016616821, -0.006580353, -0.03869629, 0.0050849915, 0.025238037, -0.031280518, -0.019256592, 0.019119263, -0.022109985, 0.082092285, 0.0021953583, 0.011878967, 0.012275696, -0.03918457, 0.026519775, -0.003435135, 0.01739502, 0.055358887, -0.07678223, 0.027359009, -0.0184021, 0.017044067, -0.061584473, -0.03768921, -0.02230835, -0.036254883, 0.014030457, -0.02015686, -0.009292603, -0.020462036, 0.0496521, -0.021896362, -0.0077438354, -0.01838684, 0.014656067, 0.010116577, 0.04095459, -0.011756897, 0.024108887, 0.022567749, -0.026824951, -0.023117065, 0.02709961, -0.023529053, 0.05218506, 0.008071899, -0.023620605, 0.030731201, -0.040008545, 0.010520935, -0.003818512, -0.07519531, -0.041412354, -0.01889038, -0.036987305, 0.02067566, -0.0056915283, -0.008636475, -0.013557434, -0.044891357, 0.005153656, 0.039978027, 0.04208374, 0.0036258698, 0.03527832, -0.025863647, 0.0015640259, 0.005218506, -0.029815674, -0.017913818, 0.0119018555, -0.06237793, -0.04434204, 0.06311035, 0.024795532, -0.07019043, 0.014457703, -0.0035171509, -0.0053634644, 0.043548584, -0.034301758, -0.012573242, 0.0015630722, -0.019058228, -0.02458191, 0.025848389, 0.033081055, 0.009674072, -0.03074646, -0.061920166, 0.03338623, -0.031921387, -0.053863525, -0.042755127, 0.0067443848, -0.04800415, -0.019561768, -0.0039043427, 0.0287323, 0.0063667297, -0.029449463, 0.039489746, -0.002412796, -0.020736694, 0.023254395, -0.038726807, 0.07910156, 0.05114746, -0.041259766, 0.053497314, 0.0049819946, 0.010887146, -0.011817932, 0.009468079, 0.0357666, -0.030914307, -0.013809204, -0.03137207, -0.048980713, -0.023712158, -0.04776001, -0.011314392, -0.0025691986, -0.025268555, 0.03866577, -0.0026550293, -0.04232788, 0.012809753, 0.016479492, 0.025924683, 0.03564453, -0.009544373, 0.0039100647, 0.011566162, 0.018188477, -0.046966553, 0.03375244, -0.0022506714, -0.026428223, 0.025939941, -0.014587402, 0.0015506744, 0.026870728, 0.012756348, 0.027389526, -0.027008057, -0.022735596, 0.024307251, 0.021499634, -0.012962341, -0.011810303, -0.0031013489, 0.055786133, 0.0032157898, 0.051818848, -0.017593384, 0.05859375, -0.021270752, 0.039001465, -0.012573242, -0.034057617, -0.02456665, -0.007572174, -0.022994995, 0.043273926, -0.026062012, 0.025253296, -0.012802124, -0.01285553, 0.04373169, 0.048431396, -0.018859863, -0.051361084, 0.078552246, -0.0077056885, -0.015197754, -0.08807373, -0.064208984, 0.0017967224, -0.029876709, -0.016342163, -0.053741455, -0.020446777, -0.040527344, 0.010871887, -0.01537323, 0.022506714, 0.0037994385, 0.021743774, 0.03062439, 0.025741577, -0.0154953, 0.060424805, -0.0074157715, 0.018981934, -0.0076789856, 0.022949219, -0.021316528, -0.03326416, -0.03692627, 0.011978149, -0.03012085, -0.06958008, 0.004436493, 0.025253296, 0.0102005005, 0.04006958, -0.002040863, 0.01776123, 0.05255127, -0.024520874, -0.00856781, -0.02267456, 0.024047852, -0.05050659, 0.06188965, 0.020080566, -0.04647827, -0.008331299, 0.021881104, 0.02305603, -0.006942749, -0.02104187, -0.018051147, 0.018585205, 0.046905518, -0.0019741058, 0.028289795, 0.019470215, 0.049468994, 0.02394104, 0.034942627, 0.017166138, 0.00095415115, -0.049346924, -0.005393982, 0.041992188, 0.0024356842, -0.0079422, 0.058044434, -0.011154175, -0.03414917, -0.02166748, -0.0068893433, 0.0236969, -0.011749268, -0.0036373138, -0.0041275024, -0.027755737, -0.0016212463, 0.039367676, 0.07092285, -0.03326416, 0.056427002, -0.015182495, 0.014419556, 0.045013428, -0.00066137314, -0.039093018, -0.02772522, 0.01033783, -0.029403687, 0.019805908, 0.028762817, -0.00031089783, -0.016799927, -0.010650635, 0.0051574707, -0.037384033, -0.012893677, 0.04260254, -0.03201294, 0.014083862, 0.054473877, -0.033294678, -0.07543945, 0.01977539, -0.057617188, 0.037994385, -0.008460999, -0.07434082, -0.034210205, 0.0072631836, 0.030380249, 0.024917603, -0.0027618408, 0.022109985, -0.010345459, -0.018112183, -0.010345459, -0.03753662, -0.015029907, -0.020996094, 0.011459351, 0.02798462, 0.017990112, 0.014274597, 0.013374329, 0.031433105, -0.021987915, -0.002708435, 0.026138306, 0.009506226, -0.04031372, 0.010414124, -0.0074920654, -0.008026123, -0.004825592, -0.036956787, -0.009246826, 0.03366089, -0.011909485, 0.0002272129, 0.0063285828, 0.018936157, 0.012817383, 0.0135650635, -0.0069999695, 0.002614975, 0.010009766, 0.05303955, 0.0105896, -0.0011873245, -0.009513855, -0.010986328, -0.008720398, 0.031173706, -0.010925293, -0.00011628866, -0.019363403, -0.00041604042, -0.005153656, 0.0064888, 0.032043457, -0.04244995, -0.06048584, -0.020828247, -0.033569336, -0.050628662, 0.060028076, 0.027938843, -0.058135986, 0.030075073, 0.03842163, -0.07611084, 0.0065956116, 0.014701843, 0.0015411377, -0.004211426, -0.058288574, 0.0041618347, 0.01802063, -0.0022640228, 0.006160736, -0.007663727, -0.0061912537, 0.062316895, -0.03503418, -0.009101868, 0.0141067505, -0.003534317, -0.012191772, -0.010971069, 0.005355835, -0.024154663, 0.02885437, -0.007751465, -0.0018339157, -0.017654419, -0.011558533, -0.012992859, -0.031341553, 0.011695862, -0.030075073, 0.019683838, 0.018600464, -0.002538681, 0.01625061, -0.030227661, -0.048950195, 0.004600525, -0.027679443, -0.07067871, 0.08111572, 0.00806427, -0.040527344, 0.0056877136, 0.006706238, 0.038146973, 0.020996094, 0.03286743, 0.00034213066, -0.02609253, -0.0015983582, 0.0018577576, 0.044403076, -0.008674622, 0.0057792664, 0.010658264, 0.05596924, 0.016220093, 0.011802673, -0.01651001, -0.010444641, -0.003929138, 0.004108429, -0.004749298, 0.021377563, -0.01411438, 0.10803223, -0.0033817291, -0.020355225, -0.07800293, -0.07141113, -0.057128906, 0.018875122, -0.006340027, -0.008224487, 0.01008606, 0.0024528503, -0.010391235, -0.0099487305, -0.014205933, -0.0048332214, 0.016342163, 0.012619019, -0.026443481, 0.01876831, 0.0051460266, -0.011436462, 0.04611206, 0.038146973, -0.009269714, -0.019332886, 0.017150879, 0.057922363, -0.028915405, -0.04763794, -0.048431396, 0.028442383, -0.052459717, 0.00881958, 0.020233154, 0.018676758, 0.001282692, -0.022567749, 0.038848877, -0.011810303, -0.0023670197, -0.015136719, 0.02406311, -0.02784729, -0.024368286, 0.011383057, -0.006591797, 0.005634308, -0.013946533, -0.036468506, 0.020355225, 0.030273438, -0.022338867, 0.01651001, -0.013328552, -0.002632141, -0.01071167, 0.020736694, -0.030899048, -0.03010559, -0.0023841858, 0.00095176697, 0.013664246, 0.045898438, 0.020080566, 0.00737381, 0.011749268, -0.027236938, 0.010391235, -0.031463623, -0.008346558, 0.021377563, 0.07849121, 0.051818848, 0.01979065, -0.013557434, 0.05456543, 0.027374268, -0.02268982, 0.04675293, 0.016036987, 0.054229736, 0.062469482, 0.07519531, -0.0036697388, 0.0035572052, 0.060577393, -0.013084412, -0.018493652, 0.022277832, 0.016113281, -0.017547607, -0.016235352, -0.008102417, 0.020904541, 0.051605225, 0.10095215, -0.05581665, 0.009017944, -0.04663086, 0.04144287, -0.06384277, -0.009941101, -0.016983032, -0.0262146, -0.0011510849, -0.0011310577, -0.0032043457, -0.039978027, -0.009437561, -0.02330017, 0.0067596436, -0.008255005, 0.015930176, 0.0068359375, -0.050476074, -0.016082764, 0.025054932, 0.07098389, 0.05960083, 0.09124756, -0.030014038, 0.029266357, 0.021072388, 0.0050582886, -0.058441162, -0.053466797, 0.030822754, 0.05041504, 0.019760132, 0.013542175, 0.0435791, 0.0132369995, 0.009117126, -0.028640747, 0.028564453, -0.02178955, 0.012138367, 0.027664185, -0.031143188, 0.0024776459, 0.019134521, -0.039123535, 0.035125732, 0.0069007874, 0.008804321, 0.06677246, 0.028762817, -0.016113281, 0.012420654, -0.021408081, -0.04626465, 0.02330017, -0.055603027, -0.028533936, 0.0070648193, 0.046844482, -0.021881104, -0.065979004, 0.041778564, 0.025268555, -0.0037117004, -0.01626587, 0.021118164, 0.011734009, 0.006542206, -0.002904892, -0.012245178, -0.017074585, 0.029296875, 0.028533936, 0.038513184, 0.0058059692, -0.036254883, 0.05432129, 0.004962921, -0.06689453, 0.01234436, -0.042541504, 0.032073975, -0.002735138, -0.02558899, 0.017501831, -0.028060913, -0.008735657, 0.007534027, 0.007095337, -0.0009584427, 0.016540527, -0.019607544, 0.0057754517, 0.00054979324, 0.0011930466, 0.0051727295, -0.0042533875, -0.0026874542, 0.038269043, 0.0067443848, 0.0004887581, -0.021240234, -0.016555786, 0.013374329, 0.019332886, -0.006340027, -0.0031833649, -0.0115356445, 0.036132812, -0.00541687, 0.005622864, -0.016326904, -0.010826111, -0.009407043, 0.00073480606, -0.032073975, 0.026550293, 0.008834839, -0.011894226, 0.035339355, 0.029830933, -0.0021152496, 0.017608643, 0.012054443, 0.034698486, -0.01939392, 0.011627197 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06729v1
Comprehending Lexical and Affective Ontologies in the Demographically Diverse Spatial Social Media Discourse
Salim Sazzed
cs.CL
This study aims to comprehend linguistic and socio-demographic features, encompassing English language styles, conveyed sentiments, and lexical diversity within spatial online social media review data. To this end, we undertake a case study that scrutinizes reviews composed by two distinct and demographically diverse groups. Our analysis entails the extraction and examination of various statistical, grammatical, and sentimental features from these two groups. Subsequently, we leverage these features with machine learning (ML) classifiers to discern their potential in effectively differentiating between the groups. Our investigation unveils substantial disparities in certain linguistic attributes between the two groups. When integrated into ML classifiers, these attributes exhibit a marked efficacy in distinguishing the groups, yielding a macro F1 score of approximately 0.85. Furthermore, we conduct a comparative evaluation of these linguistic features with word n-gram-based lexical features in discerning demographically diverse review data. As expected, the n-gram lexical features, coupled with fine-tuned transformer-based models, show superior performance, attaining accuracies surpassing 95\% and macro F1 scores exceeding 0.96. Our meticulous analysis and comprehensive evaluations substantiate the efficacy of linguistic and sentimental features in effectively discerning demographically diverse review data. The findings of this study provide valuable guidelines for future research endeavors concerning the analysis of demographic patterns in textual content across various social media platforms.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06729v1
2023-11-12T04:23:33
2023-11-12T04:23:33
{ "title": [ 0.016342163, -0.0012359619, -0.014228821, -0.057006836, 0.0020427704, -0.0031738281, -0.013824463, -0.011993408, 0.018722534, 0.02520752, -0.036346436, 0.0022277832, 0.007801056, 0.0017299652, -0.043884277, -0.0129470825, -0.0068244934, 0.027008057, -0.005039215, -0.016143799, -0.034057617, -0.017944336, 0.025268555, -0.026245117, 0.0236969, -0.064208984, -0.058898926, 0.0055351257, -0.019973755, -0.018936157, -0.002161026, 0.02368164, 0.03488159, 0.01991272, -0.042236328, -0.042419434, -0.034820557, 0.003818512, -0.022598267, 0.026992798, 0.0038337708, -0.01121521, -0.0345459, -0.008216858, -0.03555298, 0.020065308, -0.050231934, -0.00894165, -0.016418457, 0.012664795, -0.0018043518, 0.00466156, 0.0025405884, 0.008728027, -0.0036258698, -0.051574707, -0.008377075, -0.042877197, 0.021148682, 0.0038909912, 0.020645142, -0.04336548, 0.023498535, 0.007896423, -0.01878357, -0.017578125, 0.006500244, 0.013847351, 0.025238037, -0.02053833, 0.00083589554, 0.013633728, 0.022018433, -0.045074463, -0.003894806, 0.050201416, -0.00077438354, 0.016555786, 0.014144897, -0.02255249, -0.014564514, 0.029312134, 0.01777649, -0.050964355, 0.022537231, -0.03527832, -0.026733398, -0.011810303, -0.03781128, -0.05819702, -0.00894928, -0.024169922, -0.03668213, 0.00063467026, -0.015419006, -0.042999268, 0.00051116943, 0.048431396, -0.0020389557, -0.02772522, -0.024154663, 0.0051727295, -0.051849365, -0.018005371, 0.021835327, 0.011550903, -0.022842407, -0.016342163, 0.03793335, 0.041748047, -0.022201538, 0.039733887, 0.01625061, -0.008781433, 0.008987427, -0.012634277, -0.026519775, 0.040161133, 0.012969971, 0.018035889, -0.026565552, -0.06173706, 0.012161255, 0.07397461, 0.03378296, 0.0008749962, -0.03665161, 0.04714966, 0.0101623535, 0.014595032, 0.019012451, 0.06500244, -0.101135254, -0.10095215, -0.09564209, 0.042907715, -0.009559631, -0.019546509, -0.020584106, 0.02961731, -0.0007710457, -0.029953003, 0.0082473755, -0.0021686554, 0.020889282, 0.00004953146, 0.03967285, 0.019180298, -0.023529053, -0.033355713, 0.006210327, 0.011741638, 0.038757324, -0.020080566, -0.06738281, -0.024795532, -0.062316895, -0.04019165, 0.0044441223, -0.052764893, 0.040527344, 0.0038814545, -0.005908966, 0.044769287, 0.03262329, -0.017929077, -0.0028934479, 0.01512146, 0.0062561035, -0.0011377335, -0.024398804, 0.029037476, -0.009552002, -0.023345947, -0.011749268, -0.0020771027, 0.019439697, -0.04067993, 0.002368927, 0.017745972, -0.0066452026, -0.01386261, -0.022781372, 0.0524292, -0.05114746, -0.013557434, 0.01007843, 0.013496399, 0.022979736, 0.004333496, 0.015533447, 0.030822754, -0.055633545, -0.038024902, -0.010437012, 0.0059318542, 0.033203125, -0.00969696, 0.027282715, 0.0022792816, -0.01979065, -0.024276733, -0.025253296, -0.012184143, -0.057800293, -0.04840088, -0.01360321, 0.028747559, 0.013076782, 0.06274414, 0.027877808, 0.009140015, -0.041412354, 0.025909424, -0.026184082, -0.06976318, 0.015930176, -0.02494812, -0.015151978, -0.034606934, -0.019104004, 0.004261017, -0.030349731, 0.042388916, 0.031463623, -0.02230835, 0.01826477, -0.04397583, 0.056121826, 0.010055542, 0.043273926, -0.02104187, 0.021942139, -0.020065308, -0.022781372, 0.005630493, -0.009773254, -0.031188965, -0.0011119843, 0.01600647, -0.0012550354, 0.018096924, 0.021652222, 0.044311523, 0.06726074, -0.0284729, 0.0073547363, 0.013847351, 0.015991211, 0.049804688, 0.009506226, 0.0065078735, 0.047973633, -0.002735138, -0.048461914, 0.07519531, -0.0064353943, -0.062316895, 0.005584717, 0.010391235, 0.026657104, -0.0027256012, -0.027938843, 0.028945923, -0.06903076, -0.012039185, -0.020736694, -0.010520935, 0.011817932, -0.030639648, 0.026016235, 0.027175903, 0.017211914, -0.014724731, -0.038208008, 0.03668213, -0.013114929, 0.030838013, -0.0055274963, -0.049682617, -0.0037498474, 0.004623413, 0.012145996, -0.008132935, 0.02909851, -0.0006198883, 0.010978699, -0.012802124, 0.03463745, -0.017288208, 0.026016235, 0.028442383, 0.019256592, 0.027786255, 0.02368164, -0.03237915, 0.082214355, 0.06365967, -0.019042969, 0.03842163, -0.020202637, 0.034484863, 0.0055007935, 0.0055122375, 0.017562866, -0.024810791, 0.013542175, 0.025604248, -0.013214111, -0.021514893, -0.029754639, 0.04647827, 0.003791809, -0.056274414, -0.0024776459, -0.0040893555, 0.008834839, -0.00084733963, -0.019760132, 0.034606934, 0.078125, -0.023544312, -0.009727478, -0.010345459, -0.022964478, -0.0357666, 0.005508423, -0.031707764, 0.01486969, 0.01411438, 0.016021729, -0.007911682, -0.045776367, -0.039215088, -0.011528015, -0.0069007874, -0.010269165, -0.039733887, -0.04043579, 0.008522034, -0.013175964, -0.021972656, 0.026870728, -0.054779053, 0.008613586, -0.034332275, 0.015151978, 0.021194458, 0.012840271, 0.01058197, -0.014770508, -0.023544312, 0.010719299, 0.028015137, 0.09259033, -0.0345459, -0.07055664, 0.05593872, 0.037200928, -0.0028057098, 0.0055999756, 0.010910034, -0.0051078796, -0.028503418, -0.0021324158, -0.021881104, -0.027633667, 0.016738892, 0.00283432, 0.031173706, -0.022018433, -0.01576233, -0.044433594, -0.020309448, 0.01537323, -0.011009216, -0.058563232, -0.05444336, 0.0019874573, -0.04840088, -0.051574707, -0.04748535, 0.03338623, 0.0020656586, 0.06829834, -0.0025844574, -0.03543091, -0.01966858, 0.020355225, 0.020477295, -0.009162903, -0.038879395, -0.040252686, -0.005569458, 0.027923584, -0.00409317, -0.0017032623, 0.042663574, -0.091430664, -0.011192322, 0.051971436, 0.007865906, -0.0043792725, 0.039367676, -0.086120605, 0.054351807, -0.025909424, 0.0038909912, 0.027008057, 0.016708374, -0.021224976, 0.017227173, -0.0181427, -0.0016527176, -0.009727478, -0.027648926, -0.08013916, 0.017318726, 0.021728516, -0.044403076, -0.028045654, -0.03074646, -0.053344727, -0.015617371, -0.0058937073, 0.047027588, 0.03881836, 0.006225586, -0.0063591003, 0.007129669, 0.020935059, -0.022735596, 0.0020370483, -0.016082764, -0.051513672, -0.0019493103, -0.0015592575, 0.050964355, 0.038391113, -0.023956299, -0.030654907, 0.006790161, -0.026046753, 0.0065689087, -0.020446777, -0.02394104, 0.019088745, -0.019332886, -0.011077881, 0.037384033, -0.0020637512, 0.015525818, -0.008293152, 0.0113220215, -0.022827148, -0.034973145, -0.01966858, 0.030593872, 0.011894226, -0.03186035, 0.023498535, -0.02079773, -0.049438477, 0.0418396, 0.021514893, -0.010276794, 0.02798462, 0.0042037964, -0.040374756, 0.04071045, 0.024475098, -0.038726807, -0.007896423, -0.0071868896, 0.011703491, -0.022613525, -0.02078247, 0.023666382, -0.020584106, 0.008491516, -0.012107849, 0.022521973, -0.07098389, -0.0791626, -0.028579712, -0.0075912476, -0.09881592, -0.03753662, 0.0029697418, -0.043029785, -0.04043579, -0.020233154, 0.017456055, -0.005115509, -0.026306152, 0.0121536255, -0.0014705658, 0.019454956, -0.011650085, -0.06695557, -0.019363403, 0.061187744, -0.035736084, 0.019638062, 0.051574707, -0.024093628, 0.025802612, -0.02444458, 0.029541016, 0.05722046, 0.04248047, 0.016845703, -0.020965576, 0.02609253, -0.024124146, 0.012992859, 0.029876709, -0.029907227, 0.008705139, 0.012763977, 0.010818481, 0.03756714, -0.013999939, 0.060058594, 0.0065231323, -0.019363403, -0.03152466, 0.017318726, 0.0064353943, 0.008728027, -0.0043296814, -0.026229858, -0.0018720627, 0.01360321, 0.033111572, 0.032165527, 0.005443573, 0.0009484291, 0.029083252, -0.011116028, 0.011444092, 0.0052948, 0.010368347, -0.0017881393, 0.0151901245, 0.025146484, 0.009887695, 0.05218506, -0.024124146, -0.0071372986, -0.016647339, -0.0010185242, -0.080566406, 0.00021338463, -0.02041626, -0.061584473, -0.055419922, 0.04034424, -0.01033783, 0.03515625, 0.041778564, -0.012863159, -0.025146484, -0.0070266724, 0.03479004, 0.0075950623, -0.031219482, -0.08074951, 0.015029907, -0.031173706, -0.09387207, -0.04348755, -0.009399414, 0.005176544, 0.040252686, 0.01512146, -0.0075035095, 0.0513916, 0.0033226013, 0.025375366, 0.059753418, -0.033111572, -0.05630493, 0.081604004, -0.039276123, -0.019042969, 0.043548584, -0.009124756, 0.009223938, -0.013374329, 0.004486084, -0.005619049, -0.03491211, -0.07696533, 0.02444458, -0.011436462, 0.03164673, 0.056396484, 0.02722168, 0.025390625, 0.01071167, 0.0037994385, 0.017715454, -0.033813477, -0.017318726, -0.022323608, 0.0135269165, -0.008087158, -0.008552551, 0.036834717, 0.024383545, -0.011909485, 0.040740967, -0.00049495697, 0.043426514, 0.019866943, 0.0051841736, -0.025939941, -0.02116394, -0.035186768, 0.0070228577, 0.009284973, 0.050476074, 0.0071792603, 0.0385437, -0.0670166, -0.013809204, -0.020401001, -0.0149383545, 0.0129852295, -0.020065308, 0.027786255, -0.04095459, -0.044555664, -0.003932953, 0.027679443, -0.010185242, -0.013130188, 0.009056091, 0.011489868, 0.028717041, 0.050994873, 0.049591064, -0.025741577, 0.01701355, -0.010215759, -0.0015983582, -0.009559631, -0.036712646, 0.031707764, -0.019454956, 0.0063438416, -0.045928955, -0.003955841, -0.00504303, -0.024795532, -0.035491943, -0.026916504, 0.0060577393, -0.036895752, 0.057128906, 0.09863281, -0.026641846, 0.07598877, -0.015975952, 0.017684937, 0.029907227, 0.057006836, -0.0037651062, 0.005710602, 0.03982544, -0.051452637, -0.0004618168, 0.0109939575, 0.03515625, 0.0390625, 0.0028820038, 0.014732361, 0.0008034706, -0.013252258, 0.0031490326, -0.041992188, -0.03753662, 0.011924744, -0.035217285, 0.009521484, 0.0025691986, 0.00894165, 0.008125305, -0.011199951, -0.0023765564, -0.010154724, -0.010131836, -0.019104004, -0.003917694, -0.014083862, -0.04107666, -0.058532715, -0.005382538, -0.0046920776, 0.042236328, -0.01687622, -0.027252197, -0.052612305, 0.034088135, 0.034332275, -0.050476074, -0.024932861, -0.026870728, 0.010253906, -0.00459671, 0.024261475, -0.020019531, -0.003042221, -0.044281006, -0.045318604, -0.03100586, 0.01902771, 0.025390625, 0.0413208, -0.0034732819, -0.02835083, -0.009628296, -0.0181427, 0.013137817, -0.014381409, 0.0074539185, 0.03729248, -0.0016469955, 0.026229858, 0.037750244, -0.016983032, -0.028640747, 0.035247803, 0.03756714, -0.030532837, 0.010665894, -0.008178711, 0.021774292, -0.032043457, -0.038116455, 0.0012464523, 0.0029468536, 0.0026855469, -0.0018596649, 0.00983429, 0.025344849, 0.04525757, -0.054138184, -0.018936157, 0.016098022, -0.0491333, 0.0440979, -0.022842407, -0.006374359, -0.08831787, 0.029907227, 0.010421753, 0.055267334, -0.06793213, -0.0317688, -0.006385803, 0.029464722, 0.011756897, 0.013763428, 0.023162842, -0.016342163, 0.05621338, -0.068481445, 0.012268066, -0.004486084, 0.042388916, 0.003868103, -0.011940002, -0.045654297, -0.026229858, 0.01373291, -0.01776123, 0.018737793, 0.015014648, -0.012779236, 0.040771484, -0.042053223, 0.01171875, 0.0032672882, -0.039794922, 0.022903442, -0.026626587, 0.011734009, 0.012359619, 0.006729126, 0.03161621, 0.0039749146, 0.040771484, 0.013435364, 0.024627686, 0.04876709, -0.0024032593, 0.00712204, -0.016220093, -0.03265381, -0.0635376, -0.02720642, -0.036621094, -0.00006580353, -0.04751587, -0.026229858, 0.013389587, -0.011634827, 0.04763794, -0.0040779114, 0.030853271, 0.004207611, 0.010673523, -0.008415222, 0.018569946, -0.05960083, -0.0013189316, -0.04083252, 0.0039596558, 0.047180176, 0.040100098, -0.007858276, 0.015960693, -0.012786865, -0.024032593, 0.016708374, 0.045135498, -0.01689148, -0.020141602, 0.027938843, -0.03930664, 0.055480957, 0.0061836243, 0.042266846, 0.042236328, 0.02281189, -0.026412964, -0.00856781, -0.00044322014, 0.011985779, -0.0077400208, -0.0061531067, 0.02507019, -0.0132369995, -0.0022716522, -0.011711121, -0.025421143, 0.017456055, 0.05117798, 0.04107666, -0.03475952, -0.011947632, 0.02960205, 0.020004272, -0.0059432983, 0.033325195, -0.056732178, -0.057769775, -0.049346924, 0.012542725, -0.013320923, -0.016036987, 0.014762878, 0.04925537, 0.000702858, -0.03756714, 0.0027275085, -0.046875, 0.0023918152, 0.04244995, 0.015731812, 0.014022827, -0.003850937, -0.028869629, -0.01727295, 0.019210815, -0.054992676, -0.014533997, 0.004886627, 0.017288208, -0.013908386, 0.04949951, 0.038208008, -0.016662598, -0.054779053, -0.029968262, -0.0041122437, 0.03717041, -0.03050232, -0.018371582, -0.025466919, -0.03692627, -0.00018393993, -0.027328491, 0.05441284, -0.0635376, 0.021881104, -0.035491943, 0.050445557, 0.0037021637, -0.04714966, -0.07336426, 0.0076408386, -0.04232788, -0.007080078, -0.022460938, -0.029907227, 0.0035037994, -0.015914917, -0.0109939575, 0.000682354, 0.020446777, 0.026321411, -0.03237915, -0.0713501, 0.024139404, -0.010482788, 0.0635376, 0.0013532639, -0.014282227, -0.033691406, 0.017501831, 0.00032830238, 0.018554688, -0.00032758713, 0.019638062, -0.041290283, -0.011123657, -0.015029907, -0.0038585663, -0.013870239, -0.015914917, 0.0413208, -0.0034217834, -0.024978638, 0.0046958923, 0.0022964478, -0.029785156, -0.051757812, -0.008384705, -0.044830322, 0.009590149, 0.035308838, 0.014022827, -0.005176544, 0.020187378, -0.017028809, -0.050689697, 0.021484375, 0.028335571, 0.02760315, -0.0056495667, -0.024108887, 0.023971558, 0.01058197, -0.06903076, -0.08258057, -0.0005044937, 0.06011963, 0.0017662048, 0.048187256, 0.016235352, -0.001917839, 0.021316528, -0.0011949539, -0.0066184998, -0.019760132, -0.048034668, -0.028930664, 0.029846191, 0.027038574, -0.002090454, -0.0234375, 0.040252686, 0.009147644, 0.015853882, 0.043823242, -0.0602417, 0.020751953, 0.0056152344, -0.0008635521, -0.01789856, 0.003774643, -0.04321289, 0.01158905, 0.006164551, 0.053588867, -0.031021118, 0.03555298, 0.017333984, 0.010528564, -0.047332764, -0.090270996, 0.061584473, 0.06451416, -0.012840271, 0.044158936, 0.0054092407, -0.01576233, -0.021362305, -0.0039634705, -0.009490967, -0.003194809, 0.057403564, -0.0423584, 0.020996094, -0.05996704, -0.033691406, 0.0088272095, -0.048431396, 0.045013428, -0.03439331, -0.0024814606, -0.022109985, 0.01777649, -0.012168884, 0.027450562, -0.014312744, -0.018981934, -0.0340271, -0.018035889, 0.023071289, -0.020950317 ], "summary": [ 0.007434845, -0.007118225, 0.00033187866, 0.033355713, -0.017318726, -0.012802124, 0.0017986298, -0.042266846, 0.018936157, 0.030517578, -0.04208374, 0.011222839, 0.0043563843, 0.0033397675, -0.007499695, -0.022277832, -0.005256653, 0.064819336, 0.04574585, -0.0211792, 0.008399963, -0.028701782, 0.01058197, -0.030822754, 0.04031372, -0.07122803, -0.004135132, 0.03048706, 0.031433105, 0.028778076, 0.028900146, -0.01361084, 0.021774292, 0.015670776, -0.024429321, -0.005973816, 0.005218506, 0.0030593872, -0.019561768, 0.055511475, 0.020339966, 0.0018100739, 0.028076172, -0.011199951, -0.041046143, 0.025177002, -0.010192871, -0.0025081635, 0.0073013306, -0.04031372, -0.0028686523, -0.026779175, 0.02168274, -0.048461914, -0.037353516, -0.034484863, -0.020477295, 0.024810791, -0.00030255318, 0.040039062, 0.012901306, 0.014144897, -0.003917694, -0.03353882, -0.0357666, 0.026290894, 0.020050049, -0.0037460327, -0.0065460205, -0.03829956, 0.0016527176, -0.0062065125, 0.002588272, -0.072509766, 0.014404297, 0.07861328, -0.029174805, 0.009628296, 0.010429382, -0.016464233, -0.06518555, 0.034179688, -0.04510498, -0.07922363, 0.013145447, -0.03765869, -0.03793335, 0.012359619, -0.032806396, -0.07043457, -0.019500732, -0.050933838, -0.13232422, 0.051513672, 0.04510498, -0.049224854, 0.029937744, 0.04724121, -0.003829956, -0.01864624, -0.011268616, -0.019638062, -0.012786865, -0.013847351, 0.026168823, 0.010475159, -0.007881165, -0.035949707, 0.02557373, 0.01828003, -0.00969696, 0.030517578, 0.027786255, -0.018676758, -0.0053367615, 0.0054740906, -0.0063705444, 0.0501709, 0.02128601, 0.0005097389, -0.015914917, 0.014259338, -0.028808594, 0.03704834, 0.01600647, 0.034118652, 0.013687134, 0.003742218, -0.00038218498, 0.08483887, 0.000207901, 0.0076942444, -0.10107422, -0.08093262, -0.09240723, -0.02696228, 0.0066490173, -0.00069856644, 0.012931824, -0.02394104, 0.0079956055, 0.010543823, 0.041656494, 0.0036888123, -0.0019817352, -0.0038070679, 0.0006108284, 0.03616333, -0.0006070137, -0.010673523, 0.029937744, -0.0076293945, 0.060638428, -0.035583496, -0.051605225, -0.044921875, -0.051849365, -0.02670288, 0.0038223267, -0.054138184, 0.048339844, -0.016799927, -0.009483337, 0.031951904, -0.003660202, 0.009033203, -0.024642944, 0.0041618347, 0.013198853, -0.050567627, 0.028259277, 0.02658081, 0.036315918, -0.03741455, 0.0015068054, -0.014808655, -0.005382538, 0.019363403, 0.009635925, 0.0013580322, 0.0018138885, -0.038238525, 0.020599365, 0.022033691, -0.033233643, 0.005016327, 0.04525757, 0.0758667, -0.01676941, 0.030563354, 0.036102295, -0.001162529, -0.030563354, 0.004043579, 0.015792847, -0.021591187, 0.0061683655, -0.022750854, 0.02142334, -0.01322937, 0.075683594, -0.0064353943, -0.0077781677, -0.044403076, -0.07098389, -0.038604736, -0.0013284683, 0.018081665, 0.010757446, 0.040283203, 0.009208679, -0.0049819946, -0.025146484, 0.04458618, 0.008094788, -0.025787354, 0.025726318, -0.029647827, 0.017120361, -0.05456543, 0.023895264, 0.046936035, -0.030044556, 0.04888916, -0.021148682, -0.0335083, 0.016464233, -0.010437012, 0.07885742, -0.019561768, 0.14501953, -0.034301758, 0.03189087, -0.0042381287, -0.039276123, 0.0075569153, 0.028778076, -0.032440186, 0.0034942627, 0.032562256, 0.015129089, 0.048797607, 0.000033676624, 0.024673462, 0.033935547, -0.035125732, 0.01638794, 0.008575439, 0.015350342, 0.10083008, -0.03591919, 0.019241333, 0.009407043, -0.08013916, -0.056854248, 0.075683594, -0.03845215, -0.048950195, 0.0008249283, -0.0031604767, 0.007797241, 0.0076942444, 0.0070381165, 0.012390137, -0.005001068, -0.050048828, 0.0059890747, 0.0124435425, 0.017913818, -0.059265137, 0.011520386, 0.016998291, 0.015670776, -0.0031318665, -0.06298828, -0.0018949509, -0.0052604675, 0.026153564, -0.0027503967, -0.010551453, 0.011642456, 0.07647705, 0.0146484375, -0.015686035, -0.016693115, -0.014198303, -0.01751709, -0.007835388, 0.017593384, 0.042877197, 0.031036377, 0.05380249, 0.012145996, 0.020401001, 0.016937256, 0.021438599, 0.08050537, 0.025360107, -0.010391235, 0.01701355, 0.04711914, 0.042022705, -0.0006303787, 0.009025574, 0.010520935, 0.006462097, 0.0129776, 0.033721924, 0.014793396, -0.019714355, -0.02015686, 0.032562256, 0.03262329, 0.008399963, 0.018707275, -0.01133728, 0.0055770874, 0.046691895, 0.0043640137, -0.0014457703, 0.091552734, -0.009361267, 0.009498596, 0.002111435, -0.020111084, -0.04547119, 0.024627686, -0.017089844, 0.014831543, 0.0024204254, -0.02986145, -0.023925781, -0.049926758, -0.0101623535, -0.011909485, 0.0022392273, 0.0054740906, -0.043792725, -0.032226562, 0.0072021484, -0.008430481, 0.0061569214, 0.018600464, -0.030532837, -0.04269409, -0.003622055, 0.03994751, -0.0032234192, -0.04864502, 0.0011434555, 0.02961731, -0.021896362, -0.006023407, 0.031829834, 0.057403564, -0.05230713, -0.032958984, 0.060394287, 0.030975342, -0.0024909973, -0.055877686, 0.03942871, -0.025619507, -0.024429321, -0.02532959, -0.016326904, -0.0037460327, 0.049987793, 0.008918762, 0.008583069, 0.017196655, 0.0051078796, -0.02331543, -0.0009431839, -0.004146576, -0.008773804, 0.0029888153, -0.035614014, 0.040527344, 0.0021591187, -0.012992859, -0.03100586, 0.026657104, -0.029953003, 0.06518555, -0.003736496, -0.027313232, -0.009254456, 0.038909912, 0.022918701, 0.0059127808, -0.02230835, -0.028167725, 0.006340027, 0.028762817, -0.018798828, 0.022506714, 0.07489014, -0.097473145, -0.020843506, 0.02418518, 0.030685425, 0.029312134, 0.0021438599, -0.059814453, 0.064575195, -0.031585693, 0.0073242188, 0.010574341, 0.018569946, -0.0072746277, -0.013633728, -0.030776978, 0.020446777, -0.008705139, -0.029525757, 0.070617676, 0.0115737915, 0.0047073364, -0.053466797, -0.0011377335, 0.04864502, -0.021270752, -0.01751709, -0.010803223, 0.029708862, -0.011772156, 0.011627197, -0.035888672, 0.03982544, 0.008911133, 0.004760742, -0.010681152, 0.0064849854, -0.046569824, 0.062438965, 0.013160706, 0.07507324, 0.051971436, -0.05709839, -0.017471313, 0.008743286, 0.011810303, 0.013618469, 0.008483887, -0.014656067, 0.024307251, -0.036132812, 0.039093018, 0.032348633, -0.024932861, 0.0030899048, 0.020584106, 0.014663696, -0.04360962, -0.05960083, -0.0045394897, 0.05618286, 0.059020996, -0.035308838, 0.029724121, -0.014778137, -0.054626465, 0.060577393, 0.023651123, 0.0113220215, 0.011375427, 0.031982422, 0.004055023, 0.0016336441, 0.06689453, -0.05456543, -0.03491211, -0.010948181, -0.0041007996, -0.03817749, 0.03793335, 0.035064697, -0.0022964478, -0.044799805, -0.058441162, 0.04345703, -0.04623413, -0.08453369, -0.03552246, -0.001033783, -0.03338623, -0.041656494, -0.02166748, 0.009498596, -0.023025513, 0.031097412, 0.017547607, -0.010040283, -0.009811401, 0.018707275, -0.00080394745, 0.025024414, -0.007259369, -0.051635742, -0.057617188, 0.009780884, 0.026184082, 0.0236969, 0.02180481, 0.010009766, 0.03942871, -0.006351471, 0.009780884, 0.036346436, 0.045684814, -0.02772522, -0.048736572, -0.033111572, -0.012794495, 0.009590149, -0.0041656494, -0.01889038, 0.00058984756, -0.006286621, 0.03817749, 0.066101074, -0.009681702, 0.005054474, 0.024139404, 0.0003080368, -0.021957397, 0.022567749, 0.010246277, -0.004863739, 0.0009303093, -0.0049858093, -0.03491211, 0.012779236, 0.042510986, -0.016571045, -0.025009155, -0.01838684, 0.022994995, -0.009498596, 0.0090789795, 0.028686523, -0.0068740845, 0.023208618, 0.003107071, -0.013137817, -0.015197754, -0.014793396, -0.0027160645, -0.035308838, -0.015701294, 0.0075035095, -0.058776855, -0.017425537, 0.019348145, -0.07348633, -0.0513916, 0.022537231, 0.013122559, 0.013931274, 0.011650085, -0.031311035, -0.017150879, 0.019973755, 0.028045654, 0.01058197, 0.009254456, -0.0597229, -0.004623413, -0.041870117, -0.03152466, -0.023986816, 0.020492554, -0.037109375, -0.0039138794, -0.013206482, -0.012748718, 0.025360107, -0.019851685, 0.027664185, 0.040893555, 0.0019721985, -0.05303955, 0.01727295, -0.055145264, 0.0061035156, 0.037353516, 0.015129089, -0.025115967, -0.018173218, 0.014053345, -0.0014867783, -0.027526855, -0.032196045, -0.00042653084, 0.005783081, -0.003408432, 0.017028809, 0.030883789, 0.0018806458, -0.0055618286, -0.004459381, 0.010406494, -0.022903442, -0.00233078, -0.025527954, 0.00051784515, -0.024780273, 0.011459351, 0.03857422, -0.010749817, -0.035064697, 0.03161621, 0.009155273, 0.04043579, -0.01864624, 0.047424316, -0.010772705, -0.013397217, -0.005558014, 0.019836426, 0.014480591, 0.029083252, -0.018341064, 0.0023117065, 0.019104004, 0.010597229, 0.042419434, 0.00017344952, -0.0051841736, 0.01977539, -0.010391235, -0.004219055, -0.009292603, 0.010879517, 0.004714966, -0.0038414001, -0.019836426, -0.03805542, 0.003967285, -0.002998352, 0.030014038, -0.017593384, 0.009056091, 0.03475952, 0.012481689, 0.0045318604, -0.020187378, -0.02532959, -0.0035972595, -0.057403564, -0.008872986, 0.02998352, -0.03805542, 0.012207031, -0.035949707, -0.041412354, -0.034606934, -0.0030765533, -0.060516357, -0.06384277, -0.0014705658, -0.032836914, 0.035125732, -0.039794922, 0.01979065, 0.0004723072, 0.0362854, -0.02394104, -0.033294678, 0.00844574, 0.0047187805, -0.039886475, -0.052459717, 0.015403748, 0.04953003, 0.011360168, 0.038604736, 0.017166138, -0.039215088, 0.000110805035, -0.040771484, -0.010154724, -0.007949829, -0.025543213, -0.010772705, -0.038208008, 0.03552246, 0.0013885498, 0.042114258, -0.021484375, -0.0158844, 0.018875122, -0.017196655, -0.032562256, -0.003829956, -0.060058594, -0.051971436, -0.0030536652, 0.036743164, -0.006996155, -0.04550171, 0.039794922, -0.03451538, 0.021316528, 0.014076233, -0.04296875, -0.03479004, -0.016555786, 0.017654419, -0.034576416, 0.018325806, -0.045288086, -0.006668091, -0.044311523, -0.0050201416, 0.010307312, 0.013313293, 0.032104492, 0.03781128, -0.023330688, -0.012863159, 0.0024547577, -0.06137085, 0.0006623268, -0.0073051453, -0.02243042, -0.0016736984, 0.0005803108, -0.0022182465, 0.024642944, -0.036621094, -0.031829834, 0.016189575, 0.013298035, -0.038726807, 0.0013084412, 0.025436401, 0.013725281, -0.08959961, -0.052001953, -0.015487671, 0.023284912, -0.01158905, 0.01600647, -0.013175964, 0.0015983582, 0.035369873, -0.0090789795, -0.00061416626, 0.051208496, -0.033081055, 0.010887146, -0.03466797, 0.020599365, -0.05368042, 0.0065078735, -0.022613525, 0.020248413, -0.037200928, -0.029006958, 0.014442444, -0.008468628, -0.015144348, -0.0107803345, 0.0011320114, -0.027954102, 0.005455017, -0.034851074, -0.03086853, 0.0018367767, 0.057800293, -0.0020046234, -0.018920898, -0.012786865, -0.09100342, -0.036071777, 0.053222656, -0.007293701, 0.004989624, -0.035064697, 0.062164307, 0.003479004, 0.007797241, -0.0073928833, 0.015174866, 0.019714355, -0.0028457642, 0.012809753, 0.00844574, 0.027420044, 0.019699097, -0.016418457, -0.03062439, -0.009315491, 0.011405945, -0.01777649, -0.017410278, -0.023635864, -0.01348114, -0.04525757, -0.03375244, -0.07336426, -0.03845215, -0.029953003, 0.027008057, 0.022232056, -0.050445557, -0.0041275024, 0.06585693, -0.0035266876, 0.037841797, 0.0040130615, -0.026626587, 0.01675415, 0.013435364, -0.054656982, -0.02746582, -0.00017797947, 0.022094727, 0.013038635, 0.033111572, -0.0050239563, 0.028076172, -0.0018625259, -0.027359009, 0.039978027, 0.005455017, -0.031158447, -0.026809692, 0.026107788, -0.044921875, 0.03390503, 0.011756897, 0.042297363, 0.02960205, -0.0017194748, 0.05606079, -0.047210693, -0.012237549, -0.00623703, 0.007904053, -0.026168823, -0.036254883, 0.07507324, -0.0037155151, -0.018737793, -0.026657104, 0.028579712, -0.01838684, 0.07824707, -0.043060303, -0.026870728, 0.017120361, 0.019439697, -0.03942871, 0.0028972626, -0.049682617, -0.028244019, -0.047180176, -0.03302002, 0.0079422, -0.008903503, 0.029129028, 0.036590576, -0.008377075, -0.025299072, 0.028930664, -0.06427002, 0.043060303, 0.03338623, -0.012664795, 0.03414917, 0.017120361, -0.02897644, 0.038208008, 0.018829346, -0.006790161, 0.012580872, 0.03817749, 0.02709961, 0.06616211, 0.053863525, -0.008483887, 0.012428284, 0.04043579, -0.024551392, -0.008850098, 0.018035889, 0.00051116943, -0.029418945, 0.0016365051, 0.0011358261, -0.0061416626, 0.03387451, 0.046417236, -0.05154419, -0.02508545, -0.03048706, 0.031921387, -0.042907715, -0.0012397766, -0.03152466, -0.047027588, 0.011413574, -0.026351929, -0.008926392, -0.056365967, -0.005191803, -0.046417236, -0.01675415, -0.025741577, -0.007987976, 0.015701294, -0.0039405823, -0.02281189, 0.0023880005, -0.00020074844, 0.05508423, -0.0052757263, 0.0052604675, 0.045806885, 0.004261017, -0.03475952, -0.024230957, 0.0008878708, 0.02897644, -0.007835388, -0.046691895, -0.005268097, -0.009796143, -0.033935547, -0.036834717, 0.02583313, -0.008514404, -0.025405884, 0.016571045, 0.016662598, 0.012893677, -0.097595215, -0.022750854, -0.025405884, -0.0047187805, -0.008323669, 0.030838013, -0.031311035, 0.032958984, 0.013053894, -0.04324341, 0.034362793, 0.033966064, 0.028411865, -0.0128479, -0.006713867, -0.019210815, -0.014099121, -0.057250977, -0.04534912, 0.00037169456, 0.06341553, -0.0012397766, 0.009033203, -0.0026931763, -0.0026283264, 0.011619568, 0.029312134, -0.00021219254, -0.011291504, -0.027404785, -0.0010719299, 0.054382324, -0.0062026978, -0.010574341, -0.029022217, 0.013053894, -0.01651001, 0.020080566, 0.045928955, -0.054260254, 0.001086235, -0.01109314, -0.012229919, -0.008804321, -0.037872314, -0.0012397766, 0.012329102, -0.0030822754, 0.04663086, -0.01448822, -0.0053100586, 0.026992798, 0.010635376, -0.028762817, -0.016098022, 0.0028514862, 0.013557434, 0.0039863586, 0.015670776, 0.019958496, 0.024597168, -0.0033416748, -0.012130737, -0.0041885376, -0.008178711, 0.052764893, -0.0418396, -0.007637024, -0.036834717, 0.012199402, 0.0050735474, -0.034454346, 0.062683105, -0.031921387, -0.027053833, -0.016601562, -0.005153656, 0.0062446594, -0.001253128, -0.016555786, -0.04458618, 0.037506104, 0.04446411, -0.0029087067, 0.03439331 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06724v1
Controllable Topic-Focused Abstractive Summarization
Seyed Ali Bahrainian, Martin Jaggi, Carsten Eickhoff
cs.CL, cs.LG
Controlled abstractive summarization focuses on producing condensed versions of a source article to cover specific aspects by shifting the distribution of generated text towards a desired style, e.g., a set of topics. Subsequently, the resulting summaries may be tailored to user-defined requirements. This paper presents a new Transformer-based architecture capable of producing topic-focused summaries. The architecture modifies the cross-attention mechanism of the Transformer to bring topic-focus control to the generation process while not adding any further parameters to the model. We show that our model sets a new state of the art on the NEWTS dataset in terms of topic-focused abstractive summarization as well as a topic-prevalence score. Moreover, we show via extensive experiments that our proposed topical cross-attention mechanism can be plugged into various Transformer models, such as BART and T5, improving their performance on the CNN/Dailymail and XSum benchmark datasets for abstractive summarization. This is achieved via fine-tuning, without requiring training from scratch. Finally, we show through human evaluation that our model generates more faithful summaries outperforming the state-of-the-art Frost model.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06724v1
2023-11-12T03:51:38
2023-11-12T03:51:38
{ "title": [ 0.0005302429, 0.010429382, -0.0335083, -0.07965088, -0.008110046, 0.0005145073, -0.058898926, -0.018463135, 0.018829346, 0.046142578, -0.02268982, 0.035247803, -0.01121521, -0.00071287155, -0.03955078, 0.015235901, -0.0017251968, 0.016204834, -0.0340271, -0.03970337, -0.0024299622, -0.047607422, 0.020645142, 0.0022068024, -0.009963989, -0.033416748, -0.043823242, 0.011268616, -0.042663574, -0.029632568, -0.018920898, 0.017120361, 0.046905518, 0.028671265, -0.033935547, 0.03387451, -0.044006348, 0.017318726, 0.0068092346, -0.0035152435, 0.0069618225, 0.01939392, -0.016952515, 0.004623413, -0.048706055, 0.025619507, -0.07714844, -0.01448822, -0.009559631, -0.02482605, 0.002954483, 0.029769897, -0.007965088, -0.014884949, 0.013664246, -0.00894165, 0.01423645, -0.03363037, 0.0473938, 0.011451721, 0.00015091896, -0.050964355, 0.030838013, -0.008422852, -0.021652222, -0.025436401, -0.01713562, 0.017089844, 0.064819336, 0.0050849915, -0.024765015, 0.013511658, 0.00907135, 0.009162903, -0.03591919, -0.017486572, 0.018920898, -0.004852295, 0.04147339, 0.0014162064, -0.03756714, -0.04083252, 0.017333984, -0.068725586, 0.04776001, -0.03753662, -0.019424438, -0.00026369095, -0.012649536, -0.10101318, 0.0044784546, -0.0051727295, -0.038879395, 0.020980835, -0.016845703, -0.038513184, 0.0016126633, 0.035369873, -0.01928711, -0.029067993, -0.03161621, 0.028640747, -0.02809143, -0.01486969, 0.018966675, 0.0019292831, -0.021820068, 0.023391724, 0.05166626, 0.049194336, -0.02130127, 0.040039062, 0.027694702, 0.011421204, -0.0069847107, -0.011047363, -0.019515991, 0.02696228, -0.0029754639, 0.030380249, 0.007129669, -0.018112183, 0.020248413, 0.033721924, -0.00623703, -0.0038967133, -0.045043945, -0.0020313263, 0.03717041, 0.03778076, -0.0002965927, 0.04284668, -0.10266113, -0.10772705, -0.05734253, 0.032562256, -0.011123657, 0.0017843246, -0.03375244, -0.002084732, 0.015525818, -0.011878967, 0.015594482, 0.005672455, 0.013053894, -0.000043332577, 0.060638428, 0.009605408, -0.046417236, -0.020187378, -0.030136108, 0.028549194, 0.042419434, -0.02381897, -0.101501465, -0.0619812, -0.1274414, -0.035980225, 0.049316406, -0.03253174, 0.028289795, 0.0003182888, -0.018966675, -0.014595032, 0.013755798, -0.010673523, -0.0038337708, 0.024978638, 0.015609741, 0.026550293, -0.020004272, -0.003458023, 0.009902954, -0.0015335083, -0.010643005, 0.020019531, 0.00869751, -0.0067443848, 0.030914307, -0.0027656555, 0.0058937073, -0.028289795, -0.0056114197, 0.061431885, -0.070739746, -0.022903442, -0.004886627, 0.021484375, 0.04611206, 0.016906738, -0.03842163, 0.014770508, -0.047668457, -0.041748047, -0.035339355, -0.01725769, 0.019195557, 0.020523071, 0.00969696, 0.011062622, -0.020812988, 0.005619049, -0.033111572, 0.009094238, 0.003856659, -0.020324707, -0.0093307495, 0.012016296, -0.047546387, 0.03643799, 0.07513428, 0.012710571, -0.041381836, 0.006713867, -0.004962921, -0.051879883, 0.029876709, -0.003112793, -0.0005264282, -0.029464722, 0.0073509216, 0.0056152344, 0.010238647, 0.05014038, 0.058532715, -0.015449524, 0.017654419, -0.03765869, 0.08190918, 0.019241333, 0.055725098, -0.036712646, 0.041870117, -0.012306213, -0.033172607, -0.025466919, -0.0010786057, 0.0054359436, 0.0118637085, 0.028686523, 0.005207062, 0.011131287, -0.0006456375, 0.027114868, 0.08831787, -0.004589081, 0.006225586, 0.018310547, 0.0041389465, -0.0010242462, 0.0541687, 0.00434494, 0.050354004, 0.0068969727, 0.0007162094, 0.06591797, 0.029296875, 0.029144287, -0.057128906, 0.038116455, -0.015525818, 0.032043457, 0.01826477, 0.004180908, -0.03375244, 0.012649536, 0.0096588135, 0.03353882, -0.01398468, -0.001241684, 0.015396118, 0.030761719, 0.011451721, 0.028671265, -0.0044937134, -0.01864624, -0.012748718, 0.0039978027, 0.0025291443, -0.034942627, -0.012512207, 0.017578125, 0.043914795, 0.0022964478, 0.008529663, -0.017074585, 0.02041626, -0.017822266, -0.017425537, -0.033477783, 0.041900635, 0.04309082, 0.030654907, -0.013069153, 0.013420105, 0.000038683414, 0.084228516, 0.04156494, 0.0044555664, 0.011764526, -0.024047852, 0.028717041, -0.015808105, 0.015571594, -0.00081920624, 0.034698486, 0.045166016, -0.015640259, -0.044677734, -0.00242424, -0.04034424, -0.022659302, -0.004169464, -0.004623413, -0.07122803, -0.05935669, -0.011459351, -0.0574646, -0.06549072, -0.045013428, 0.08453369, -0.041259766, -0.011428833, -0.0012350082, -0.027282715, -0.034179688, 0.021377563, -0.023391724, -0.011054993, 0.018112183, 0.03111267, 0.016342163, -0.046722412, 0.00033473969, -0.008117676, 0.01411438, -0.019180298, 0.020217896, -0.026992798, 0.006465912, -0.0048103333, -0.016738892, 0.010955811, -0.037261963, 0.036315918, -0.043304443, -0.0011444092, 0.019958496, -0.014289856, 0.010040283, -0.008842468, -0.012763977, -0.019592285, 0.013511658, 0.04067993, -0.004306793, -0.0059776306, 0.034576416, 0.021942139, -0.015899658, 0.036071777, -0.011756897, -0.015434265, -0.090270996, 0.034942627, -0.034851074, -0.048858643, -0.038879395, 0.012283325, 0.046142578, -0.033599854, -0.012245178, -0.024398804, 0.008605957, 0.02279663, 0.0005583763, -0.01247406, -0.046875, 0.014137268, -0.009605408, 0.0079574585, 0.012954712, -0.0012693405, 0.0057296753, 0.064697266, 0.00050354004, -0.01802063, -0.0137786865, 0.034606934, 0.019226074, -0.020233154, -0.05709839, -0.048431396, 0.0008430481, 0.01687622, 0.01210022, -0.01096344, -0.027053833, -0.08886719, -0.011138916, 0.0345459, 0.020065308, -0.011413574, 0.022125244, -0.0848999, 0.05419922, -0.040496826, -0.015731812, 0.027175903, 0.030731201, -0.0057029724, 0.019897461, -0.0030612946, 0.010017395, -0.013427734, -0.035491943, -0.107177734, 0.01675415, 0.016357422, -0.03289795, -0.016143799, -0.072143555, -0.030044556, 0.016159058, -0.017471313, 0.055419922, 0.020095825, 0.023208618, 0.0053482056, -0.025939941, -0.0037078857, -0.04208374, -0.014785767, -0.024353027, -0.009666443, 0.01285553, -0.011177063, 0.039611816, 0.00831604, -0.0021533966, -0.056671143, 0.0051345825, -0.0056877136, 0.034210205, -0.008201599, -0.029205322, -0.006088257, -0.033325195, -0.018692017, 0.01083374, -0.0059890747, -0.002450943, -0.04220581, 0.0041923523, -0.016098022, 0.03729248, 0.0003771782, 0.018096924, -0.032226562, 0.0025634766, 0.016311646, -0.03994751, 0.021499634, 0.00086164474, 0.02519226, 0.0015869141, -0.019622803, -0.027786255, -0.06762695, 0.035125732, -0.023162842, 0.01878357, 0.021713257, 0.006706238, 0.010292053, 0.00091409683, -0.026824951, 0.0184021, -0.050689697, -0.011070251, 0.019073486, -0.0065574646, 0.01828003, -0.07092285, 0.008049011, -0.005722046, -0.11468506, -0.04260254, 0.011917114, -0.02230835, -0.036834717, -0.03274536, 0.015541077, -0.011978149, -0.028335571, 0.002954483, -0.010917664, 0.008972168, -0.0076942444, -0.0826416, -0.03933716, 0.095336914, 0.006511688, 0.038116455, 0.08465576, 0.007347107, -0.015701294, 0.014801025, 0.025436401, 0.028808594, 0.050445557, 0.011001587, -0.021560669, 0.009918213, -0.019317627, 0.00048446655, 0.045928955, -0.009376526, 0.014694214, -0.00023663044, -0.025512695, 0.034179688, -0.04876709, 0.070251465, 0.0054016113, -0.032592773, -0.06286621, 0.033355713, -0.0110321045, 0.007873535, 0.020431519, -0.035736084, 0.04598999, 0.008476257, -0.0047454834, 0.05117798, -0.005722046, -0.024002075, 0.04559326, 0.0015354156, 0.012756348, 0.00007456541, 0.008918762, 0.021224976, 0.008285522, 0.0043144226, -0.014007568, 0.054016113, -0.045196533, -0.010887146, -0.007129669, -0.002986908, -0.03152466, 0.003293991, -0.039886475, -0.051208496, -0.05126953, 0.022583008, -0.0022964478, 0.046691895, 0.03161621, 0.020584106, -0.041412354, 0.017425537, -0.00047779083, 0.004737854, 0.00045251846, -0.042175293, -0.015342712, 0.017364502, -0.04196167, -0.029296875, -0.02267456, 0.0077781677, -0.01638794, -0.013130188, 0.00006532669, 0.02758789, 0.0135650635, 0.038513184, 0.048065186, -0.01663208, -0.038238525, 0.04611206, -0.01802063, -0.0017948151, 0.0063438416, 0.025283813, -0.008720398, -0.02947998, -0.0050354004, -0.0099487305, -0.01600647, -0.058441162, 0.024993896, 0.007583618, 0.024856567, 0.01864624, 0.01977539, 0.029190063, 0.0037651062, 0.019042969, 0.022613525, -0.029296875, -0.02230835, 0.005153656, 0.039276123, -0.03717041, 0.0038490295, 0.03781128, 0.0003902912, -0.0011281967, 0.0075302124, 0.013648987, 0.021316528, 0.025848389, 0.013801575, 0.02229309, -0.04220581, -0.021850586, -0.006111145, -0.0028896332, 0.043670654, -0.06939697, 0.03781128, 0.009933472, 0.00548172, 0.044830322, -0.0026416779, 0.025848389, 0.0013399124, 0.007282257, -0.057556152, -0.050842285, -0.0052490234, 0.0440979, -0.022399902, -0.0112838745, 0.0020885468, 0.030319214, -0.0022468567, 0.074157715, 0.056732178, 0.02861023, -0.007297516, -0.026519775, 0.003540039, -0.042297363, -0.031707764, 0.008300781, -0.025299072, 0.0014228821, -0.0748291, 0.015777588, 0.0059928894, -0.049468994, -0.042114258, -0.0021762848, 0.0028076172, -0.050445557, 0.04083252, 0.08306885, 0.030441284, 0.0519104, -0.018508911, 0.027008057, 0.006439209, 0.07446289, -0.011962891, 0.04626465, 0.06149292, -0.062469482, -0.01386261, 0.0043258667, 0.013656616, 0.011405945, 0.050231934, 0.016937256, 0.031982422, -0.066833496, 0.021072388, 0.037017822, 0.007663727, -0.0026664734, -0.04171753, 0.012184143, 0.012619019, 0.014122009, 0.018585205, -0.026885986, -0.04159546, -0.010482788, -0.013328552, -0.04156494, 0.015319824, 0.024017334, -0.050354004, -0.028121948, 0.035888672, 0.005672455, -0.0029125214, 0.009284973, 0.030395508, -0.01689148, 0.020599365, 0.06542969, -0.03274536, 0.021606445, -0.028549194, 0.009292603, 0.060791016, 0.03353882, -0.007293701, -0.0076675415, -0.0129776, -0.038482666, -0.0016126633, -0.007751465, 0.00096035004, 0.0049209595, -0.010635376, 0.00046992302, -0.004627228, -0.02949524, 0.016555786, -0.017456055, -0.024017334, 0.032928467, 0.00051021576, 0.012481689, 0.0052108765, 0.00969696, -0.023513794, 0.0019321442, 0.029907227, -0.042541504, 0.0008840561, 0.03918457, 0.047851562, -0.031585693, -0.033447266, -0.018661499, 0.03753662, 0.01121521, 0.021362305, 0.02128601, 0.018630981, 0.038330078, 0.0049858093, 0.028640747, 0.06817627, -0.039978027, -0.023803711, -0.02267456, 0.0022296906, -0.03086853, 0.030532837, -0.0039978027, -0.014251709, -0.025283813, -0.038024902, -0.020629883, 0.03286743, 0.02935791, 0.01259613, 0.023849487, -0.012718201, 0.022857666, -0.01777649, -0.01524353, -0.025894165, 0.055358887, 0.0027580261, -0.024963379, -0.012413025, -0.026504517, -0.009178162, -0.0079193115, 0.021499634, 0.0037631989, -0.007736206, 0.0032691956, -0.011566162, 0.02154541, -0.026626587, -0.026107788, 0.04525757, 0.027374268, -0.018035889, 0.062438965, -0.038482666, 0.06329346, 0.017501831, 0.05441284, 0.058288574, 0.0015182495, -0.022094727, 0.009185791, -0.010536194, -0.055389404, -0.008430481, -0.054138184, -0.031829834, -0.04748535, -0.012268066, -0.068847656, -0.017181396, 0.025512695, 0.025512695, -0.016830444, 0.023010254, -0.0011348724, -0.032806396, 0.04638672, -0.055847168, 0.04574585, -0.020263672, -0.00048422813, -0.012786865, -0.024215698, 0.02835083, 0.035186768, 0.00982666, -0.0019330978, -0.046875, -0.013702393, 0.017822266, -0.0033664703, 0.018356323, 0.005558014, -0.02432251, -0.03265381, 0.01272583, -0.010795593, 0.02357483, 0.044128418, 0.016601562, -0.022369385, -0.008003235, 0.0107421875, -0.012062073, -0.010620117, -0.011306763, 0.033111572, -0.07763672, 0.03768921, 0.007129669, -0.029159546, -0.016647339, 0.03302002, 0.039886475, -0.054138184, -0.02281189, 0.031341553, 0.03253174, -0.015197754, 0.021728516, -0.033050537, -0.004219055, 0.0032577515, 0.012870789, -0.0029010773, -0.001698494, 0.027160645, 0.01348114, 0.013435364, -0.0184021, 0.013404846, 0.015853882, -0.0020008087, 0.02746582, 0.008163452, 0.018478394, -0.011695862, -0.03778076, 0.018127441, 0.0045700073, -0.03515625, -0.007369995, 0.020202637, 0.020950317, 0.05532837, 0.0592041, 0.027557373, -0.0011978149, -0.009376526, -0.05731201, 0.02998352, 0.044158936, -0.048736572, -0.025619507, -0.016906738, -0.019515991, -0.0112838745, -0.045654297, 0.00074386597, -0.05291748, -0.004878998, -0.038970947, 0.056152344, 0.0014915466, -0.025802612, -0.050048828, -0.003320694, -0.059936523, 0.009269714, 0.0309906, 0.001663208, -0.058135986, -0.03100586, 0.044433594, -0.035186768, -0.024337769, -0.00042366982, -0.018692017, -0.066467285, 0.0027942657, -0.016708374, 0.034301758, -0.035705566, -0.0112838745, -0.0019273758, 0.009941101, 0.0076446533, -0.0124053955, -0.023071289, 0.024627686, -0.033813477, -0.011627197, -0.017105103, -0.005580902, -0.016540527, -0.006214142, -0.029556274, 0.013961792, -0.020996094, 0.005592346, 0.018737793, -0.042816162, -0.035827637, -0.004737854, -0.038909912, 0.024383545, 0.014839172, -0.02684021, 0.02558899, -0.0029678345, -0.013870239, -0.030212402, 0.015029907, 0.037994385, 0.008682251, -0.047973633, 0.0016832352, 0.020126343, 0.04840088, -0.0569458, -0.035614014, 0.012573242, 0.036193848, -0.03353882, 0.062469482, -0.002281189, -0.005027771, 0.016983032, 0.04196167, -0.00079250336, -0.036132812, -0.0011539459, -0.029296875, -0.007701874, 0.034362793, 0.0039482117, -0.017227173, 0.031051636, 0.0018100739, -0.0032958984, 0.00025320053, -0.0042037964, -0.012306213, 0.0052490234, 0.013175964, -0.004650116, -0.05065918, -0.0690918, 0.015701294, 0.022338867, 0.0368042, -0.018615723, 0.03314209, -0.0044822693, 0.08239746, -0.04397583, -0.06329346, 0.027648926, 0.03213501, -0.014640808, 0.0496521, -0.0069236755, -0.0079574585, -0.016571045, 0.005065918, -0.0037231445, 0.005645752, 0.026153564, -0.010147095, 0.015167236, -0.027862549, -0.03652954, -0.006954193, -0.022766113, 0.044830322, -0.0073928833, -0.01373291, 0.023666382, -0.030776978, -0.0051727295, 0.018798828, 0.0029621124, -0.027435303, -0.052947998, -0.006008148, 0.043304443, -0.0021305084 ], "summary": [ 0.028640747, -0.00058555603, 0.0070533752, -0.05593872, -0.033935547, 0.020965576, -0.08270264, -0.041046143, 0.02909851, 0.05883789, -0.05126953, 0.03640747, 0.0368042, 0.008644104, -0.014595032, 0.0005965233, 0.0082092285, 0.01272583, 0.0047073364, -0.030426025, 0.028564453, -0.0317688, 0.0001937151, 0.035949707, -0.012817383, -0.03289795, 0.011428833, 0.017288208, 0.009521484, 0.01940918, 0.0076293945, -0.017974854, 0.022842407, 0.026809692, -0.040283203, 0.015327454, 0.002714157, -0.004436493, -0.010017395, 0.035461426, 0.028793335, 0.0000833869, 0.018081665, 0.0051116943, -0.021072388, 0.013015747, 0.0074882507, -0.018218994, 0.030166626, -0.033843994, -0.010299683, 0.010658264, -0.0029735565, -0.076049805, -0.019332886, 0.011062622, 0.00010496378, 0.0027580261, 0.01461792, 0.012748718, 0.002483368, 0.012489319, 0.004219055, -0.0044555664, -0.0076179504, 0.022720337, 0.09588623, -0.007911682, 0.03161621, -0.0019035339, 0.004146576, 0.025497437, 0.014122009, -0.0064353943, -0.036102295, 0.014625549, 0.0032157898, 0.0087509155, 0.03390503, -0.02293396, -0.039764404, -0.009490967, 0.036224365, -0.08496094, 0.049591064, -0.026733398, -0.023864746, 0.012054443, -0.0149002075, -0.0541687, -0.02330017, 0.027572632, -0.06768799, 0.019180298, 0.0023612976, -0.012252808, -0.0129470825, -0.014541626, -0.016311646, -0.0063056946, 0.012023926, -0.025543213, 0.041107178, -0.027175903, 0.0013494492, 0.010284424, -0.0026779175, 0.047027588, 0.062805176, 0.03869629, 0.006137848, 0.011009216, -0.0022258759, -0.022064209, -0.010070801, 0.00881958, -0.018707275, 0.016967773, 0.0052223206, -0.010627747, -0.007041931, 0.0059547424, 0.035980225, 0.061645508, -0.008026123, 0.031921387, 0.013313293, -0.045959473, 0.049560547, 0.0018959045, -0.024429321, 0.014709473, 0.029327393, -0.020523071, -0.016845703, -0.013542175, 0.028015137, -0.0025157928, -0.013397217, -0.031463623, 0.0395813, 0.0060424805, -0.010467529, 0.0034332275, 0.0058631897, 0.015930176, 0.05557251, 0.0038261414, -0.04486084, -0.019363403, -0.005054474, 0.03640747, 0.057769775, -0.03918457, -0.056884766, -0.12609863, -0.028060913, -0.07788086, 0.06262207, -0.0836792, 0.020828247, -0.013000488, -0.04727173, 0.001748085, -0.01878357, -0.0017004013, 0.03491211, 0.009811401, 0.023849487, -0.01008606, -0.010932922, -0.0060272217, 0.036071777, -0.007160187, -0.0054244995, 0.018569946, -0.03439331, -0.0048103333, 0.03048706, -0.024780273, 0.0072021484, -0.018859863, 0.0028934479, 0.05078125, -0.039642334, 0.010871887, -0.0070495605, 0.078186035, 0.045532227, 0.030151367, -0.044128418, -0.025497437, -0.025939941, 0.01184845, 0.02456665, -0.014198303, -0.03918457, -0.016845703, 0.0016269684, -0.045715332, 0.027740479, 0.013717651, -0.016311646, -0.010063171, -0.038024902, 0.01737976, -0.015403748, 0.019760132, -0.037597656, 0.023895264, 0.041381836, -0.019454956, -0.022415161, 0.021743774, 0.0007209778, -0.061523438, 0.06185913, -0.015266418, 0.024230957, -0.0657959, 0.043029785, 0.045654297, 0.003545761, 0.059753418, 0.055358887, -0.053985596, 0.030838013, -0.048950195, 0.09100342, -0.016204834, 0.032989502, -0.027664185, 0.017578125, 0.018539429, -0.013641357, -0.013320923, 0.018814087, -0.045196533, 0.017059326, 0.04360962, 0.02458191, 0.07635498, -0.040771484, -0.015274048, 0.06439209, -0.012428284, 0.004875183, -0.015434265, -0.021896362, -0.042785645, 0.0029907227, -0.032989502, 0.04284668, -0.048095703, -0.0090789795, 0.051116943, 0.014022827, 0.0041770935, -0.033569336, 0.013542175, 0.0037460327, 0.042022705, 0.003129959, 0.018630981, 0.026565552, -0.0061531067, 0.042877197, 0.036376953, -0.0015172958, -0.017410278, 0.0027179718, 0.015556335, 0.0065956116, 0.040893555, -0.03366089, -0.026428223, -0.01977539, 0.0014677048, -0.012702942, 0.006095886, 0.003982544, 0.030059814, -0.007545471, -0.004219055, 0.020141602, -0.010971069, -0.009803772, 0.019241333, -0.0010375977, 0.03930664, 0.029937744, 0.0637207, 0.033172607, -0.00088214874, 0.028900146, 0.027450562, 0.043029785, -0.04977417, 0.0574646, -0.043792725, 0.039367676, 0.06689453, -0.031951904, 0.04748535, 0.0029258728, 0.04473877, 0.015174866, -0.027359009, -0.014793396, 0.002691269, -0.057617188, -0.02267456, 0.017593384, 0.08947754, -0.06933594, -0.048706055, -0.023986816, 0.015716553, -0.026977539, -0.01979065, 0.11114502, -0.0010061264, 0.013763428, 0.026794434, -0.023529053, -0.06536865, 0.06756592, -0.029296875, -0.046783447, 0.0029392242, 0.007713318, -0.015182495, -0.0002156496, 0.06781006, 0.003479004, -0.0022907257, 0.0028476715, 0.04135132, 0.002916336, -0.021240234, 0.00756073, -0.029571533, -0.011909485, 0.0034732819, 0.030776978, -0.0015077591, -0.015777588, 0.013519287, 0.013374329, 0.045654297, -0.059509277, -0.0063209534, -0.03515625, 0.018600464, -0.005317688, -0.00025820732, 0.047576904, -0.0025844574, -0.0067977905, -0.048828125, 0.047424316, -0.02204895, -0.02407837, -0.089660645, 0.023223877, -0.009178162, -0.031341553, -0.06048584, 0.03274536, 0.0121536255, 0.06738281, 0.01285553, -0.050567627, -0.02243042, -0.025146484, -0.04748535, 0.057037354, -0.012535095, -0.009292603, 0.04156494, 0.016448975, 0.033294678, 0.010009766, 0.043701172, 0.044952393, 0.0009880066, 0.014823914, -0.024902344, 0.03744507, 0.006137848, 0.0029964447, -0.04852295, -0.044799805, -0.0116119385, -0.017227173, 0.0016965866, -0.015220642, -0.008422852, -0.024230957, -0.018737793, 0.047973633, 0.016830444, 0.023635864, 0.0129470825, -0.04486084, 0.04309082, -0.005252838, 0.0024700165, 0.014221191, 0.0065460205, 0.0023059845, -0.03189087, -0.016448975, -0.0181427, -0.0030078888, -0.030975342, -0.047332764, -0.0005683899, 0.012237549, 0.0045661926, -0.0025787354, -0.033477783, 0.00028300285, 0.027450562, -0.012191772, 0.049682617, -0.004627228, 0.028427124, -0.013771057, 0.01727295, 0.0064086914, -0.02017212, -0.017730713, 0.0022239685, 0.0071258545, 0.05911255, 0.009742737, -0.010002136, 0.019119263, -0.017715454, -0.045562744, -0.015289307, 0.013206482, 0.023117065, -0.01612854, -0.0037498474, -0.012130737, -0.0135650635, -0.0129852295, 0.030685425, -0.018325806, -0.0066070557, 0.007987976, 0.03717041, -0.021636963, 0.051971436, 0.0046577454, 0.034240723, 0.010055542, 0.02027893, 0.028015137, -0.024047852, 0.023391724, 0.021240234, 0.023239136, 0.0368042, -0.080566406, -0.0017948151, -0.072021484, 0.026611328, 0.027236938, -0.013626099, 0.004928589, -0.017852783, 0.013114929, -0.06222534, 0.016571045, 0.013580322, 0.0024852753, -0.038024902, -0.016555786, 0.008026123, 0.07556152, -0.070129395, -0.018936157, 0.015182495, -0.07513428, -0.042388916, 0.017944336, 0.007827759, -0.023742676, -0.031341553, 0.02583313, 0.0038146973, -0.0019264221, 0.034362793, 0.0050697327, 0.039733887, -0.0051651, -0.06439209, -0.005180359, 0.015159607, 0.018936157, 0.023483276, 0.014030457, 0.052215576, 0.011047363, 0.03665161, 0.010223389, -0.040130615, 0.036712646, -0.019760132, -0.018554688, 0.010116577, -0.01777649, -0.019485474, 0.012580872, -0.00088214874, -0.0011339188, 0.0008482933, -0.015045166, 0.040008545, -0.026184082, 0.016586304, 0.007873535, -0.009185791, -0.04083252, 0.052337646, -0.0030460358, -0.0066070557, 0.037017822, 0.0016183853, 0.018661499, 0.02796936, -0.009780884, 0.0068740845, -0.007904053, -0.040771484, 0.0236969, 0.053894043, 0.014038086, 0.018447876, 0.014228821, 0.064453125, 0.011672974, -0.029556274, -0.0073280334, 0.006778717, -0.0635376, 0.004142761, -0.002620697, -0.003200531, -0.037872314, -0.023071289, 0.021820068, -0.011421204, -0.027191162, -0.014381409, -0.0121536255, 0.05456543, -0.003824234, 0.03050232, -0.009994507, 0.0008382797, -0.04296875, 0.050750732, -0.07141113, -0.059143066, -0.038330078, 0.012832642, -0.03262329, -0.03112793, -0.052215576, -0.027832031, -0.072753906, -0.0073623657, -0.027069092, 0.030273438, -0.014968872, 0.0287323, 0.046081543, 0.010070801, -0.057647705, 0.035064697, -0.01197052, 0.031799316, -0.021270752, 0.04220581, -0.02230835, -0.0037555695, -0.00007134676, 0.008300781, 0.00019109249, -0.097839355, -0.019058228, 0.011268616, -0.027420044, 0.021636963, -0.017410278, 0.0071983337, -0.0099105835, 0.007598877, 0.012466431, -0.0032405853, -0.020050049, -0.004901886, -0.013160706, -0.01033783, -0.028335571, -0.0030269623, -0.0025730133, -0.018554688, 0.041168213, -0.013809204, 0.017837524, 0.03942871, 0.030563354, 0.019042969, 0.011894226, -0.033447266, 0.0014333725, 0.021469116, -0.0071258545, -0.039093018, -0.0090408325, 0.03250122, -0.0038833618, 0.050201416, 0.0036506653, 0.0154800415, 0.05178833, -0.021118164, -0.062683105, -0.07598877, -0.05267334, 0.06149292, -0.006603241, -0.044128418, 0.0041007996, -0.002368927, -0.01928711, 0.034118652, 0.009780884, 0.029388428, 0.054107666, -0.0045547485, 0.01537323, -0.020507812, -0.013122559, -0.015045166, -0.05496216, -0.00019145012, 0.0062789917, -0.027114868, 0.022506714, -0.0362854, -0.05105591, -0.007171631, -0.015838623, -0.02104187, -0.028793335, 0.024261475, -0.015777588, 0.034240723, -0.00258255, 0.007789612, -0.008544922, 0.047210693, -0.028503418, 0.011810303, 0.030441284, -0.010147095, -0.01763916, -0.016677856, 0.041656494, 0.05883789, 0.017929077, 0.03277588, 0.040252686, -0.05960083, -0.0067329407, 0.011978149, 0.046569824, -0.021621704, -0.010368347, 0.036010742, -0.008659363, -0.005302429, -0.011947632, 0.005138397, -0.056640625, -0.03475952, -0.0054626465, -0.041503906, 0.006580353, -0.00077342987, -0.04675293, 0.0060920715, 0.026535034, 0.028533936, -0.003566742, -0.0025787354, 0.0004310608, -0.027420044, -0.040771484, 0.050994873, -0.0009188652, 0.04031372, -0.010040283, 0.0236969, 0.02027893, -0.0031909943, -0.0152282715, -0.009544373, -0.030288696, 0.0035476685, -0.0005364418, -0.047912598, -0.017852783, 0.07525635, 0.0067710876, 0.07543945, 0.050476074, -0.07775879, 0.012245178, -0.006198883, -0.0039596558, 0.038330078, -0.013374329, 0.0004453659, 0.049438477, 0.012298584, -0.024124146, 0.011619568, 0.022781372, -0.058502197, -0.0152282715, 0.058776855, 0.076416016, -0.064331055, -0.008636475, -0.03152466, 0.05834961, 0.026321411, 0.04916382, 0.010848999, -0.0055236816, 0.037139893, 0.042175293, 0.020080566, 0.051086426, -0.0090789795, -0.02406311, -0.013473511, 0.027999878, -0.0023841858, -0.000521183, -0.0065956116, -0.0146484375, 0.0023422241, -0.029418945, 0.009178162, -0.0012378693, 0.018661499, 0.019607544, 0.03692627, 0.010536194, 0.0077171326, -0.039855957, -0.026626587, 0.0090408325, 0.066345215, -0.01008606, -0.046905518, -0.0027389526, -0.047180176, -0.038330078, 0.048065186, 0.033050537, 0.008850098, -0.03189087, 0.044708252, -0.003627777, -0.0013780594, -0.010406494, 0.0113220215, 0.018066406, 0.024032593, -0.026229858, 0.00983429, 0.021530151, 0.04638672, 0.012260437, 0.009529114, 0.009986877, -0.022842407, -0.026672363, 0.0043945312, -0.052856445, -0.042114258, 0.020431519, -0.019348145, -0.035888672, -0.03201294, -0.038238525, -0.026489258, 0.011695862, 0.01146698, -0.012527466, 0.0073051453, 0.0076141357, -0.016479492, -0.019485474, -0.03451538, -0.020401001, -0.015457153, -0.039154053, -0.014137268, -0.012687683, -0.03845215, 0.031402588, 0.05126953, 0.017196655, -0.014549255, -0.07733154, 0.024093628, 0.030136108, -0.029937744, -0.037109375, -0.0134887695, 0.022979736, -0.039489746, 0.010925293, 0.01737976, 0.04840088, 0.016983032, -0.01889038, 0.0010414124, 0.00831604, -0.012939453, 0.046905518, 0.0019836426, 0.020690918, 0.019515991, -0.0006017685, 0.012641907, 0.025741577, -0.04156494, -0.0021018982, 0.016296387, 0.04522705, -0.060668945, 0.018676758, 0.019729614, 0.006378174, -0.050933838, 0.03152466, -0.042938232, -0.0071029663, -0.0262146, -0.03640747, 0.016983032, -0.013214111, 0.034118652, -0.018707275, 0.039642334, -0.007007599, 0.018539429, 0.017791748, 0.016464233, 0.022476196, 0.01600647, 0.010978699, 0.020385742, -0.030380249, 0.042663574, 0.010421753, 0.010299683, 0.032073975, 0.01637268, 0.0073776245, 0.043518066, 0.04940796, -0.0047187805, 0.03152466, -0.0022907257, 0.0040359497, 0.013870239, -0.018630981, -0.017913818, -0.09423828, -0.015235901, 0.023803711, -0.07531738, -0.019989014, -0.037109375, -0.030731201, 0.0042495728, -0.03302002, 0.017227173, -0.022903442, -0.01689148, -0.01348114, -0.025985718, -0.092285156, 0.022384644, 0.042816162, 0.007724762, -0.042816162, -0.05621338, 0.008293152, -0.051605225, -0.006038666, 0.03692627, 0.007797241, -0.025497437, 0.0033035278, -0.01626587, 0.043029785, -0.043548584, -0.027069092, 0.012245178, 0.012184143, 0.035247803, -0.026184082, -0.029571533, 0.037139893, -0.010635376, 0.01763916, -0.06323242, -0.039764404, -0.026519775, -0.021499634, -0.03933716, 0.0357666, -0.034301758, 0.012992859, 0.015960693, 0.00894928, -0.06738281, -0.004184723, -0.019515991, -0.0047569275, -0.01637268, -0.0077705383, 0.052124023, 0.0031833649, -0.0113220215, -0.010864258, 0.008224487, 0.0041236877, 0.0101623535, -0.06262207, 0.0010967255, 0.011299133, 0.042388916, -0.02520752, 0.011932373, 0.030227661, 0.08459473, -0.011749268, 0.001461029, -0.009513855, 0.0029754639, 0.004524231, 0.06585693, 0.0030612946, -0.050567627, 0.042297363, -0.0017147064, -0.0011911392, 0.0047340393, -0.0101623535, -0.0047950745, 0.015556335, -0.004337311, -0.018981934, -0.016967773, 0.026260376, -0.042816162, 0.0030822754, -0.029769897, -0.028030396, -0.060943604, -0.0496521, -0.029037476, 0.009407043, -0.01777649, -0.019165039, 0.035736084, -0.053222656, 0.0035037994, -0.03591919, -0.034118652, 0.00289917, 0.010513306, -0.002002716, -0.0008864403, 0.018051147, 0.0023002625, -0.006374359, 0.0079193115, 0.005722046, 0.0015277863, 0.013305664, -0.01586914, -0.0053596497, -0.04324341, -0.008216858, -0.004032135, -0.022918701, 0.03265381, -0.021835327, -0.020065308, 0.025894165, -0.027679443, 0.028244019, 0.0048942566, 0.026519775, 0.017700195, -0.010665894, -0.06323242, 0.0060424805, 0.0020866394 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06720v1
Cappy: Outperforming and Boosting Large Multi-Task LMs with a Small Scorer
Bowen Tan, Yun Zhu, Lijuan Liu, Eric Xing, Zhiting Hu, Jindong Chen
cs.LG, cs.CL
Large language models (LLMs) such as T0, FLAN, and OPT-IML, excel in multi-tasking under a unified instruction-following paradigm, where they also exhibit remarkable generalization abilities to unseen tasks. Despite their impressive performance, these LLMs, with sizes ranging from several billion to hundreds of billions of parameters, demand substantial computational resources, making their training and inference expensive and inefficient. Furthermore, adapting these models to downstream applications, particularly complex tasks, is often unfeasible due to the extensive hardware requirements for finetuning, even when utilizing parameter-efficient approaches such as prompt tuning. Additionally, the most powerful multi-task LLMs, such as OPT-IML-175B and FLAN-PaLM-540B, are not publicly accessible, severely limiting their customization potential. To address these challenges, we introduce a pretrained small scorer, Cappy, designed to enhance the performance and efficiency of multi-task LLMs. With merely 360 million parameters, Cappy functions either independently on classification tasks or serve as an auxiliary component for LLMs, boosting their performance. Moreover, Cappy enables efficiently integrating downstream supervision without requiring LLM finetuning nor the access to their parameters. Our experiments demonstrate that, when working independently on 11 language understanding tasks from PromptSource, Cappy outperforms LLMs that are several orders of magnitude larger. Besides, on 45 complex tasks from BIG-Bench, Cappy boosts the performance of the advanced multi-task LLM, FLAN-T5, by a large margin. Furthermore, Cappy is flexible to cooperate with other LLM adaptations, including finetuning and in-context learning, offering additional performance enhancement.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06720v1
2023-11-12T03:25:34
2023-11-12T03:25:34
{ "title": [ -0.021392822, -0.0025234222, -0.051757812, -0.028060913, 0.012191772, -0.025939941, -0.0074005127, -0.0119018555, -0.014572144, 0.032714844, -0.021881104, 0.011398315, -0.008232117, -0.0025691986, -0.03817749, -0.0012540817, -0.010627747, 0.023529053, -0.038085938, -0.044311523, -0.013053894, -0.07122803, 0.020095825, 0.066101074, 0.03338623, -0.036346436, -0.113464355, 0.026763916, -0.060455322, -0.041656494, -0.017166138, 0.059661865, 0.04083252, 0.02746582, -0.01247406, 0.034606934, -0.021987915, 0.026382446, 0.015075684, -0.0027923584, 0.03466797, -0.006591797, -0.02204895, -0.00052022934, -0.047668457, 0.023971558, -0.0435791, -0.0023117065, -0.011108398, 0.024993896, 0.021713257, 0.04940796, 0.0074043274, -0.0010843277, 0.012367249, -0.03857422, -0.0060157776, 0.010353088, 0.019226074, 0.057525635, 0.014549255, -0.019805908, 0.01574707, -0.019622803, -0.037994385, 0.009361267, -0.020004272, 0.017364502, 0.06842041, 0.0050354004, -0.0524292, 0.01637268, 0.014968872, 0.015144348, -0.05621338, -0.03439331, 0.058166504, -0.008628845, 0.03277588, -0.014984131, 0.019561768, -0.040527344, -0.0047302246, -0.03274536, 0.034301758, -0.013648987, -0.0075187683, -0.013244629, -0.032928467, -0.05255127, -0.016448975, -0.027908325, -0.015174866, 0.017868042, -0.01197052, -0.02935791, -0.0146102905, 0.04473877, -0.0018386841, -0.040039062, -0.021224976, 0.0065612793, -0.0703125, -0.0073547363, 0.00844574, 0.03375244, -0.03652954, -0.039520264, 0.0007414818, 0.032043457, -0.021728516, 0.0016555786, 0.031555176, 0.01020813, 0.010803223, -0.012550354, -0.002046585, 0.0368042, 0.0053367615, 0.030731201, -0.0066871643, -0.024490356, 0.010643005, 0.014137268, 0.040740967, 0.027053833, -0.045013428, -0.0030002594, -0.038726807, 0.014671326, 0.0077667236, 0.0635376, -0.10333252, -0.08850098, -0.07702637, 0.045562744, -0.018234253, -0.025512695, -0.009307861, 0.01965332, 0.018173218, -0.024734497, 0.00217247, 0.0021877289, 0.0013694763, 0.007751465, 0.057250977, 0.006263733, -0.026824951, -0.04135132, -0.0012321472, 0.0007214546, -0.0018444061, -0.0018053055, -0.016647339, 0.0127334595, -0.13574219, 0.023117065, 0.024032593, 0.056488037, 0.013656616, 0.014213562, 0.00013875961, 0.009414673, 0.0317688, -0.030456543, 0.0018234253, 0.03164673, 0.0073776245, 0.0037727356, -0.014602661, 0.020996094, 0.039916992, -0.002729416, -0.0034179688, 0.009681702, 0.041290283, 0.017822266, 0.035247803, -0.053741455, -0.020812988, -0.023666382, 0.048858643, 0.004180908, -0.045959473, -0.04840088, -0.011070251, -0.017532349, 0.048217773, 0.016052246, -0.020584106, 0.0055122375, -0.029922485, -0.058410645, -0.040161133, -0.016174316, 0.01739502, 0.019256592, -0.0060043335, 0.02835083, 0.000060081482, 0.008674622, -0.050811768, 0.008796692, -0.04034424, -0.027770996, -0.014526367, 0.020446777, 0.0132369995, 0.05065918, 0.032562256, 0.01398468, -0.021759033, -0.007980347, -0.030151367, -0.051513672, 0.010757446, -0.004764557, 0.0008921623, -0.024749756, 0.008636475, -0.004184723, 0.014511108, 0.027374268, -0.0006117821, 0.006351471, 0.005630493, -0.0059394836, 0.024459839, 0.032684326, 0.062347412, -0.06524658, 0.03414917, 0.045928955, 0.012168884, -0.041809082, -0.0066947937, -0.052368164, 0.033721924, 0.02494812, -0.005882263, -0.039031982, -0.020019531, 0.040008545, 0.026062012, 0.004600525, 0.006969452, 0.038482666, 0.032989502, 0.03253174, 0.020019531, 0.005558014, 0.05432129, -0.048675537, 0.017120361, 0.059387207, 0.027313232, 0.046905518, -0.039154053, 0.02218628, -0.011650085, 0.025009155, 0.0021266937, 0.020645142, -0.058410645, 0.037078857, -0.012550354, 0.03302002, 0.012298584, 0.016311646, 0.025848389, -0.01197052, 0.020080566, -0.005973816, -0.023468018, -0.014595032, -0.014831543, 0.022766113, 0.025253296, -0.058380127, -0.023620605, -0.0063819885, 0.023956299, 0.0020103455, 0.028060913, -0.01927185, 0.017242432, -0.022109985, -0.003189087, -0.02128601, 0.03881836, 0.040405273, 0.019088745, -0.0027179718, 0.02758789, 7.748604e-7, 0.08306885, 0.06945801, -0.016296387, 0.028366089, -0.036499023, 0.016601562, -0.0005226135, -0.013954163, 0.010169983, 0.028259277, 0.053771973, 0.0019197464, -0.03161621, 0.03289795, -0.0814209, -0.011222839, 0.017745972, 0.05407715, -0.07147217, -0.07373047, 0.017852783, -0.022262573, -0.028442383, -0.049560547, 0.070251465, -0.028396606, -0.0070114136, -0.005138397, -0.014434814, -0.016143799, -0.00026154518, -0.03768921, -0.00472641, 0.030792236, 0.036865234, 0.028564453, -0.05722046, -0.022720337, 0.0028762817, 0.010887146, -0.0017080307, -0.006515503, -0.023513794, 0.012664795, 0.021774292, -0.0069732666, 0.017166138, -0.031677246, -0.0077934265, -0.032470703, -0.015579224, 0.031555176, -0.029464722, -0.0024490356, 0.01638794, -0.026123047, -0.015068054, 0.01826477, 0.051574707, -0.018188477, -0.031341553, 0.030258179, 0.012557983, -0.028625488, 0.044708252, 0.016311646, 0.001326561, -0.042785645, -0.006351471, -0.049713135, -0.0042686462, -0.039123535, 0.0011520386, 0.048461914, -0.04852295, -0.0018692017, -0.049743652, -0.01979065, -0.0073776245, 0.02017212, -0.020614624, -0.041381836, -0.007167816, -0.025299072, -0.01260376, 0.009773254, 0.00023257732, 0.01713562, 0.08709717, 0.0019836426, -0.011657715, 0.0077705383, 0.031707764, -0.0006427765, -0.013534546, -0.026184082, -0.044311523, -0.0017671585, 0.0025234222, 0.016235352, -0.0044517517, -0.026123047, -0.0657959, -0.0103302, 0.060424805, 0.0013151169, -0.0115737915, 0.03289795, -0.066101074, 0.035064697, 0.01159668, -0.009735107, 0.031234741, 0.008460999, 0.006454468, -0.008010864, 0.007850647, -0.049224854, 0.016967773, -0.042175293, -0.10675049, 0.040130615, -0.028015137, -0.031677246, -0.004573822, -0.023101807, -0.048706055, -0.010650635, 0.0072021484, 0.049224854, 0.030929565, 0.0077705383, 0.02357483, -0.012809753, 0.011276245, -0.029449463, 0.01109314, -0.010719299, -0.027740479, 0.0026798248, -0.029510498, 0.026992798, 0.013832092, -0.01889038, -0.028900146, -0.019210815, -0.02166748, 0.040924072, 0.00008612871, -0.029769897, -0.026687622, -0.03164673, -0.005859375, 0.025650024, -0.010009766, -0.016174316, -0.027786255, 0.009048462, -0.023468018, 0.04550171, -0.00907135, 0.013465881, -0.021057129, -0.059448242, 0.0015964508, -0.029083252, -0.06890869, -0.0016918182, 0.029769897, 0.010864258, -0.015716553, 0.0039978027, -0.021072388, 0.014823914, -0.0143585205, 0.02003479, 0.027999878, -0.003047943, -0.0129852295, -0.011192322, -0.008621216, 0.009750366, -0.029769897, -0.020233154, -0.031280518, 0.015571594, -0.05960083, -0.053710938, 0.000562191, -0.0043182373, -0.08251953, -0.045837402, 0.008735657, -0.005138397, -0.022537231, -0.049926758, 0.027313232, 0.00054740906, -0.02607727, 0.013175964, -0.02243042, -0.019302368, -0.0019168854, -0.061462402, -0.000582695, 0.06890869, -0.012207031, 0.028747559, 0.044830322, 0.0015859604, -0.024261475, -0.016677856, 0.009864807, -0.010307312, 0.05053711, -0.008125305, -0.023239136, 0.034851074, -0.038909912, 0.011047363, 0.020309448, -0.008468628, -0.007774353, 0.012680054, 0.022766113, 0.019378662, -0.05432129, 0.048980713, 0.015991211, 0.013404846, -0.11010742, 0.007129669, 0.022766113, -0.0044670105, 0.008171082, -0.038024902, 0.033569336, 0.03994751, -0.0035762787, 0.057647705, -0.035949707, -0.0045318604, 0.05718994, 0.007369995, -0.023345947, -0.017929077, 0.018157959, 0.04171753, -0.013702393, 0.042297363, 0.011505127, 0.069885254, -0.036010742, -0.013092041, 0.016738892, 0.038848877, -0.053253174, -0.005645752, -0.06188965, -0.032684326, -0.02760315, 0.008140564, -0.017211914, 0.015899658, 0.036743164, -0.024490356, -0.034606934, 0.019729614, 0.03677368, 0.008987427, -0.0066947937, -0.05303955, -0.000034749508, 0.0076560974, -0.04876709, -0.027633667, 0.008430481, -0.024551392, 0.028961182, -0.017929077, -0.007270813, 0.021713257, 0.023010254, 0.044952393, 0.030273438, -0.026611328, -0.05404663, -0.025756836, -0.02017212, -0.02558899, 0.046966553, -0.013038635, -0.005947113, -0.015640259, 0.02104187, -0.015167236, -0.004951477, -0.06842041, 0.020904541, -0.00415802, 0.04724121, 0.013145447, 0.007713318, 0.025238037, -0.0011720657, 0.008659363, -0.014221191, -0.037963867, -0.017456055, 0.03125, 0.052856445, -0.009109497, 0.0021190643, 0.03781128, 0.03540039, 0.0070991516, 0.013809204, 0.01663208, 0.022872925, -0.007209778, 0.0011377335, 0.03024292, -0.05267334, -0.03375244, -0.003566742, -0.005622864, 0.028915405, -0.06561279, 0.052947998, 0.026153564, -0.019683838, 0.008743286, -0.023834229, 0.019897461, -0.011741638, 0.011505127, -0.08862305, -0.064331055, -0.03881836, 0.05102539, -0.038360596, -0.015159607, 0.017837524, -0.001250267, 0.026138306, 0.050476074, 0.03765869, -0.011810303, 0.007003784, -0.022323608, -0.017410278, -0.02658081, -0.03363037, -0.010902405, 0.0052108765, 0.013771057, -0.046295166, 0.02130127, -0.04083252, -0.017288208, 0.0020980835, -0.029876709, 0.020996094, -0.0869751, 0.002746582, 0.04711914, 0.015838623, 0.008377075, -0.0024929047, 0.03262329, -0.021987915, 0.06384277, -0.01146698, 0.036499023, 0.04623413, -0.042510986, 0.022354126, 0.009971619, 0.033111572, -0.013114929, 0.049743652, 0.0015201569, 0.015731812, -0.06549072, 0.0309906, 0.023010254, -0.018493652, 0.02355957, -0.058013916, 0.0057411194, 0.022445679, 0.0075912476, 0.013328552, -0.0127334595, -0.046325684, -0.03479004, -0.0128479, -0.06506348, 0.021759033, -0.005672455, -0.03201294, -0.020095825, 0.028884888, -0.018966675, -0.00039052963, 0.016342163, 0.0060424805, -0.014816284, 0.011833191, 0.027633667, -0.027038574, 0.0041885376, -0.006126404, 0.00932312, 0.03869629, 0.02192688, -0.032043457, 0.0018959045, -0.0335083, -0.039794922, -0.01423645, 0.019897461, 0.023788452, 0.004070282, -0.005844116, -0.005138397, 0.008285522, -0.02545166, 0.029312134, -0.011268616, -0.02494812, 0.0236969, -0.0020484924, 0.007598877, 0.023223877, 0.012687683, -0.005630493, 0.019165039, 0.0059547424, -0.042633057, 0.025665283, -0.018127441, 0.0009946823, -0.02420044, -0.039154053, 0.014389038, 0.03765869, -0.0030078888, 0.018005371, 0.024719238, 0.03086853, 0.027404785, 0.0041542053, 0.026260376, 0.06555176, -0.05050659, -0.025268555, -0.008651733, 0.004611969, -0.008735657, 0.088378906, -0.0074272156, -0.02218628, -0.05078125, -0.042053223, -0.023651123, 0.002073288, 0.02166748, 0.009269714, 0.014228821, -0.014556885, 0.022598267, -0.029556274, -0.026855469, -0.03933716, 0.009101868, -0.013595581, -0.034942627, 0.038482666, -0.012199402, -0.019699097, -0.006526947, 0.019515991, 0.01210022, -0.016799927, 0.03253174, -0.014411926, 0.007133484, -0.042175293, 0.00033473969, 0.05166626, 0.03564453, -0.024795532, 0.039764404, -0.039916992, 0.058135986, 0.026977539, 0.044677734, 0.032836914, -0.0012378693, 0.005466461, 0.01663208, 0.019577026, -0.04675293, 0.00031161308, -0.033172607, -0.007217407, -0.0524292, -0.016082764, -0.05795288, 0.034484863, -0.011230469, 0.036010742, -0.020431519, 0.020324707, -0.002532959, -0.0140686035, 0.024108887, -0.02670288, 0.050628662, -0.029434204, -0.004989624, -0.0107040405, 0.016860962, 0.03277588, 0.03643799, 0.0016994476, 0.0052223206, -0.02796936, -0.012573242, -0.0041770935, 0.009239197, 0.02319336, -0.025100708, -0.023620605, -0.025024414, 0.028579712, -0.0033302307, 0.048461914, 0.04840088, 0.021743774, -0.014892578, -0.0024871826, -0.0046806335, 0.0018472672, -0.03817749, 0.03857422, 0.06591797, -0.08392334, 0.03491211, -0.010551453, -0.037109375, 0.020401001, 0.03378296, 0.029266357, -0.06994629, -0.050598145, 0.023162842, 0.037109375, 0.009162903, 0.018035889, -0.023742676, 0.009529114, 0.024780273, 0.019683838, 0.0063934326, 0.02305603, 0.006969452, 0.037872314, -0.019607544, 0.0042648315, 0.007881165, 0.019500732, -0.031921387, 0.01979065, -0.035705566, 0.0635376, 0.0069465637, -0.033813477, 0.02633667, 0.008934021, -0.06732178, -0.004875183, 0.050628662, 0.07287598, 0.06137085, 0.06149292, -0.007106781, -0.014373779, 0.044189453, -0.06756592, 0.01727295, 0.04309082, -0.037231445, 0.019744873, -0.04055786, -0.043273926, 0.025054932, -0.06274414, 0.02760315, -0.062072754, 0.023269653, -0.031921387, 0.03894043, 0.008682251, -0.053253174, -0.04034424, -0.0005912781, -0.024353027, -0.0009212494, 0.0025043488, -0.010414124, -0.02456665, -0.0070266724, 0.039794922, 0.017303467, -0.014671326, -0.0012874603, -0.008674622, -0.05718994, -0.024658203, -0.053466797, 0.015853882, -0.037963867, -0.022979736, -0.035888672, -0.0017690659, 0.008331299, -0.013702393, -0.022628784, -0.004085541, -0.038330078, -0.014808655, 0.0031738281, 0.006477356, -0.0132369995, -0.006126404, -0.057373047, 0.035125732, -0.03427124, -0.0010471344, 0.053253174, -0.05026245, -0.044036865, 0.0038757324, -0.038726807, 0.08050537, 0.025268555, -0.0035419464, -0.023483276, 0.038604736, -0.028884888, -0.03186035, -0.0011472702, 0.04208374, -0.019683838, -0.0473938, 0.0090408325, 0.024261475, 0.049560547, -0.041900635, -0.00642395, 0.011550903, 0.030441284, 0.01361084, 0.06008911, 0.0009713173, -0.004673004, 0.004371643, 0.031402588, 0.021148682, -0.05419922, -0.002981186, -0.010025024, 0.0118255615, 0.051330566, -0.008605957, 0.0014505386, 0.035369873, -0.021484375, -0.01626587, 0.02508545, 0.015380859, -0.010932922, 0.004184723, 0.016098022, -0.026611328, -0.04888916, -0.007820129, 0.002073288, -0.0042304993, 0.020202637, -0.035949707, 0.017654419, -0.028884888, 0.015106201, -0.026382446, -0.028930664, 0.043121338, 0.02835083, 0.018310547, 0.014633179, -0.018737793, 0.0019407272, -0.0031356812, 0.008415222, -0.011054993, 0.022888184, 0.010620117, -0.014305115, 0.016708374, -0.039031982, -0.028396606, -0.0046653748, -0.031555176, 0.02571106, -0.021850586, 0.0039787292, -0.0046463013, -0.04159546, 0.00009047985, 0.03262329, 0.007537842, -0.0017776489, -0.050598145, -0.026870728, 0.05105591, -0.024520874 ], "summary": [ -0.06573486, -0.050079346, -0.04827881, -0.035003662, -0.06317139, 0.0025863647, -0.10064697, 0.035736084, 0.023025513, 0.010734558, -0.03640747, 0.0020580292, -0.010643005, -0.018569946, 0.0017213821, -0.022445679, -0.016464233, 0.024734497, -0.030838013, -0.049316406, 0.011550903, -0.07739258, -0.005207062, 0.04284668, 0.04736328, -0.06793213, -0.07104492, -0.0072631836, 0.0141067505, -0.0037288666, 0.01927185, 0.032958984, 0.0032806396, 0.035583496, -0.004020691, 0.03488159, -0.007369995, 0.020523071, 0.013626099, 0.022918701, 0.027709961, -0.015792847, 0.0770874, 0.018112183, -0.0049819946, 0.05718994, -0.015838623, -0.01474762, 0.029800415, -0.02357483, -0.015029907, 0.044036865, -0.0048561096, -0.04168701, -0.027160645, -0.03314209, -0.025222778, 0.0035552979, -0.010383606, 0.070251465, 0.02053833, 0.01675415, -0.015090942, -0.026611328, 0.019836426, 0.05508423, 0.00004196167, -0.0074691772, 0.054504395, 0.044525146, -0.0473938, -0.026290894, 0.016418457, -0.028244019, -0.008636475, 0.012313843, 0.01612854, 0.0035514832, 0.024642944, -0.009239197, 0.022949219, 0.0033798218, -0.020385742, -0.011978149, 0.029556274, 0.010002136, 0.003353119, -0.023223877, -0.012786865, -0.0017232895, -0.0146484375, -0.0021915436, -0.03677368, 0.04562378, 0.0066986084, -0.010063171, -0.044677734, -0.04019165, -0.03112793, -0.022720337, 0.035827637, -0.033935547, 0.017715454, -0.002149582, 0.004146576, 0.024871826, -0.031082153, -0.03225708, 0.0032215118, 0.031143188, -0.024215698, -0.045410156, 0.00598526, -0.023452759, 0.016189575, 0.0035476685, -0.02041626, 0.06939697, 0.012878418, 0.043945312, -0.01966858, 0.0023975372, -0.01914978, 0.011291504, 0.033355713, 0.013946533, -0.009422302, 0.0135650635, 0.00042510033, 0.003168106, -0.009559631, 0.0435791, -0.018753052, -0.024398804, -0.053985596, -0.00472641, -0.0124435425, 0.0036258698, -0.023849487, 0.009651184, 0.0057792664, -0.029129028, -0.002817154, 0.011238098, -0.011421204, 0.018127441, 0.03845215, 0.01940918, -0.027557373, -0.03805542, 0.011886597, -0.004650116, 0.0050315857, -0.025772095, -0.01625061, -0.056365967, -0.11260986, 0.018493652, 0.07220459, 0.018432617, 0.0052948, -0.010223389, -0.008003235, 0.0018129349, 0.007171631, -0.011711121, -0.001958847, 0.005252838, 0.014511108, -0.0010375977, -0.004802704, 0.05166626, 0.023773193, 0.0234375, 0.024383545, 0.008644104, 0.007106781, 0.061645508, 0.031234741, -0.10101318, -0.03945923, -0.054870605, 0.078125, -0.020767212, -0.0107421875, -0.089782715, 0.006259918, 0.013702393, 0.05340576, 0.036987305, -0.008590698, -0.06188965, -0.0013065338, -0.005378723, 0.010063171, -0.019546509, -0.008613586, 0.0059661865, -0.008201599, -0.009246826, 0.057769775, 0.01663208, -0.011421204, -0.044311523, -0.050079346, -0.017623901, 0.0010118484, 0.022979736, 0.026245117, 0.025558472, 0.0020980835, -0.01626587, -0.0029830933, -0.0056495667, -0.052703857, -0.053710938, -0.007789612, 0.017303467, 0.016326904, -0.023452759, 0.05517578, -0.016571045, 0.04815674, 0.052246094, -0.047058105, 0.004962921, 0.0016822815, 0.042816162, 0.011238098, 0.035186768, 0.0513916, -0.06616211, 0.011619568, 0.037139893, -0.0010318756, -0.035491943, 0.017074585, -0.08734131, 0.044311523, 0.045410156, 0.0129470825, 0.0060157776, -0.008239746, 0.017791748, -0.005016327, 0.009346008, 0.034973145, -0.016067505, -0.00365448, -0.005191803, -0.013267517, -0.048919678, 0.03375244, -0.06817627, -0.0077438354, 0.03265381, -0.028274536, 0.0040245056, -0.01600647, 0.0181427, -0.0062942505, -0.014442444, 0.007724762, -0.0041618347, -0.056915283, -0.03286743, -0.020614624, -0.016113281, 0.0140686035, -0.054229736, 0.015266418, -0.007797241, 0.011985779, -0.03652954, -0.035705566, -0.055023193, -0.02607727, 0.05456543, 0.011680603, -0.05090332, -0.009986877, 0.036010742, -0.012840271, -0.01876831, 0.018447876, 0.013900757, -0.025894165, -0.026901245, 0.010375977, 0.033935547, 0.039611816, 0.043029785, 0.025146484, -0.021087646, 0.048858643, 0.009941101, 0.06896973, 0.05834961, 0.00063085556, 0.0063285828, 0.007843018, 0.020309448, -0.053710938, 0.01612854, 0.024749756, -0.019577026, 0.04623413, 0.0090408325, -0.003932953, 0.005672455, -0.062194824, -0.007980347, 0.010696411, 0.0993042, -0.07116699, -0.053375244, -0.012260437, 0.03933716, -0.02381897, 0.012504578, 0.0513916, -0.027740479, -0.0016727448, 0.020721436, -0.015914917, -0.028198242, 0.058380127, -0.026824951, 0.044555664, -0.016738892, 0.017120361, -0.014122009, -0.053863525, -0.064331055, 0.011878967, -0.0050468445, 0.0028705597, 0.024993896, -0.012771606, 0.018096924, 0.021896362, -0.06173706, 0.019577026, 0.001335144, -0.016799927, 0.017578125, -0.0037975311, 0.0129776, 0.057739258, 0.015716553, -0.019851685, -0.018630981, 0.006969452, 0.047546387, 0.021987915, 0.0057754517, -0.004886627, 0.011428833, -0.013420105, -0.04559326, 0.048583984, 0.038146973, 0.013648987, -0.051940918, -0.01007843, -0.0501709, 0.0062217712, -0.04473877, 0.031036377, 0.008163452, 0.012779236, 0.015838623, -0.031585693, -0.0124053955, -0.0030021667, -0.01939392, 0.048950195, -0.018417358, -0.033416748, 0.027511597, -0.0121154785, 0.028442383, -0.011497498, 0.03692627, 0.054595947, 0.024978638, -0.0031089783, -0.0029945374, 0.0059547424, -0.0018100739, -0.0056419373, 0.0013008118, -0.0053367615, 0.00023412704, -0.010879517, 0.0051002502, 0.0026569366, -0.034606934, -0.01965332, -0.02154541, 0.04650879, -0.0016670227, 0.012367249, 0.01461792, -0.025924683, 0.047088623, 0.009902954, -0.002878189, 0.029846191, -0.024810791, 0.011772156, -0.05078125, 0.014808655, -0.05758667, -0.0050849915, -0.024917603, -0.05126953, 0.008331299, -0.01348114, -0.0024166107, -0.00093460083, 0.028167725, -0.012336731, 0.01474762, 0.012840271, 0.018356323, 0.01335907, 0.015113831, 0.01864624, 0.00074243546, 0.019622803, -0.022140503, 0.014511108, 0.03704834, -0.05871582, 0.035827637, -0.023773193, -0.02557373, 0.015579224, -0.079711914, -0.010665894, 0.008239746, -0.06585693, 0.0154953, -0.03466797, -0.022964478, -0.016036987, -0.05392456, 0.013298035, 0.04031372, -0.01675415, -0.011543274, 0.0049591064, 0.025161743, -0.029647827, 0.040802002, -0.058502197, 0.021362305, 0.04360962, -0.0637207, -0.00028705597, -0.029510498, -0.043914795, 0.006160736, 0.0087509155, 0.04473877, -0.09063721, 0.064453125, -0.0018472672, -0.032073975, 0.064331055, 0.0065345764, 0.036010742, -0.009140015, -0.0040664673, -0.03363037, 0.036132812, -0.0064964294, -0.005344391, -0.055267334, -0.058746338, 0.042755127, -0.029006958, -0.06329346, -0.044189453, 0.021835327, -0.0579834, -0.057006836, -0.0026054382, 0.05557251, 0.00029993057, 0.006011963, 0.04055786, 0.0066108704, -0.011001587, 0.0262146, -0.011245728, 0.04019165, -0.01007843, -0.052490234, 0.021575928, -0.015899658, -0.004421234, 0.047729492, -0.024597168, 0.029006958, 0.018722534, 0.0040893555, 0.011703491, -0.051727295, 0.012924194, -0.04333496, -0.0014953613, 0.0032444, -0.0262146, 0.023269653, -0.0011587143, -0.03149414, 0.007347107, 0.018707275, 0.018249512, 0.041015625, -0.015213013, 0.0335083, -0.012176514, 0.025283813, -0.049072266, 0.010345459, 0.0113220215, 0.013450623, 0.02418518, -0.009986877, 0.011482239, 0.005794525, -0.0036697388, -0.014373779, -0.06225586, -0.008796692, 0.05053711, 0.02848816, -0.030639648, -0.00466156, 0.019866943, 0.09490967, -0.027755737, -0.006996155, -0.01586914, 0.03491211, -0.046142578, -0.013931274, 0.026062012, 0.03643799, -0.006340027, -0.037017822, -0.043426514, -0.009674072, 0.008796692, 0.005634308, 0.0020313263, 0.018737793, 0.013504028, 0.038024902, -0.0037155151, -0.0129852295, 0.038146973, 0.025787354, -0.048828125, -0.048309326, 0.0024776459, 0.00031661987, -0.037841797, -0.027008057, -0.03439331, -0.05783081, -0.020507812, -0.011627197, -0.02619934, 0.017028809, 0.007987976, 0.034088135, 0.040374756, -0.0118255615, -0.056152344, -0.032684326, -0.04119873, 0.030212402, -0.004764557, 0.0047187805, -0.027328491, 0.015625, 0.03353882, 0.0053901672, -0.0088272095, -0.08734131, -0.0058059692, -0.018997192, 0.034301758, 0.053375244, 0.013206482, 0.008712769, -0.001247406, 0.00052928925, -0.011932373, -0.01979065, -0.014274597, 0.005306244, 0.0046424866, 0.017410278, 0.009757996, 0.05340576, 0.011512756, -0.024337769, 0.00818634, 0.005607605, 0.033355713, -0.032989502, -0.014213562, 0.056427002, -0.010887146, -0.053497314, -0.0047302246, -0.043792725, -0.016830444, 0.0019683838, -0.00010538101, -0.0018939972, 0.039916992, 0.0060577393, -0.036132812, 0.00005185604, -0.022399902, -0.007209778, -0.047821045, -0.042510986, -0.030303955, 0.02218628, 0.012420654, -0.0184021, -0.007972717, -0.034729004, 0.02218628, 0.015113831, -0.025466919, -0.04925537, 0.05239868, -0.010978699, -0.022109985, 0.012939453, 0.00356102, -0.04272461, 0.0395813, 0.020309448, -0.0031261444, 0.015319824, -0.0060577393, -0.0015535355, -0.0063591003, -0.01838684, 0.0345459, -0.077819824, -0.07171631, 0.008384705, -0.009391785, -0.02507019, 0.07019043, 0.0023059845, -0.05819702, 0.051879883, -0.041625977, 0.05026245, 0.005176544, -0.06768799, -0.016342163, -0.010429382, 0.008544922, 0.016723633, 0.037750244, 0.01423645, 0.017349243, -0.034423828, -0.009529114, 0.0059814453, 0.042938232, 0.014457703, -0.035064697, 0.02720642, 0.016525269, -0.015083313, 0.0038280487, 0.040222168, -0.0725708, -0.063964844, 0.013946533, -0.05029297, -0.02659607, -0.02468872, -0.006965637, 0.021896362, 0.0055999756, -0.062286377, 0.004837036, 0.039886475, -0.03286743, -0.0049819946, -0.031158447, 0.0011816025, 0.012046814, -0.0032653809, -0.009208679, 0.020477295, -0.021270752, -0.014968872, -0.038330078, -0.0018892288, -0.015090942, -0.038269043, -0.06530762, 0.015235901, -0.005126953, -0.0026416779, -0.021697998, 0.011474609, -0.016174316, -0.026824951, 0.046173096, -0.055511475, -0.066589355, -0.025878906, -0.015487671, 0.002439499, 0.03363037, 0.011482239, -0.03475952, 0.019241333, 0.023849487, -0.04611206, 0.024536133, -0.008216858, 0.0016298294, -0.041931152, -0.029693604, 0.003200531, 0.035461426, -0.008407593, 0.008880615, 0.015197754, 0.0095825195, -0.00043272972, -0.011436462, 0.012573242, 0.00623703, -0.026016235, -0.037200928, 0.008758545, 0.011260986, 0.0047187805, 0.053588867, -0.0040626526, -0.03439331, -0.03048706, -0.013435364, 0.0116119385, -0.01751709, -0.00730896, 0.0030956268, 0.018234253, 0.0048599243, -0.0077934265, -0.0030269623, -0.0287323, -0.013053894, -0.01600647, -0.029541016, -0.07727051, 0.09667969, 0.017074585, -0.01146698, 0.035858154, -0.025527954, 0.0010061264, -0.020523071, 0.030731201, -0.028396606, 0.009552002, -0.05432129, 0.02482605, 0.025527954, 0.06011963, -0.04525757, 0.01852417, 0.010124207, 0.046325684, 0.048797607, -0.014633179, -0.0010433197, 0.0004184246, 0.032684326, 0.013908386, 0.022415161, -0.00063180923, 0.038208008, -0.017074585, -0.034179688, -0.061584473, -0.04788208, -0.02696228, 0.026901245, -0.0345459, 0.027923584, 0.013069153, 0.010978699, -0.027328491, -0.010177612, -0.04876709, 0.04208374, 0.02458191, -0.030349731, -0.02658081, 0.009185791, -0.007129669, 0.02468872, 0.045959473, 0.0007638931, 0.01574707, -0.009902954, 0.012939453, 0.030929565, -0.046173096, -0.015510559, -0.06640625, 0.0031547546, -0.0491333, 0.0013990402, 0.018035889, 0.04714966, 0.0007381439, -0.011367798, 0.029693604, -0.0020961761, -0.01159668, 0.033294678, -0.017028809, 0.0463562, 0.02180481, -0.016662598, 0.015899658, 0.025527954, -0.030426025, 0.056243896, 0.044555664, 0.012145996, -0.044036865, -0.012832642, 0.000073730946, 0.011108398, 0.0056915283, 0.026992798, -0.011131287, 0.015731812, 0.018249512, -0.014434814, 0.04309082, 0.043151855, 0.013214111, 0.01878357, 0.04208374, 0.0043945312, 0.0072631836, -0.004924774, -0.00037622452, 0.016220093, 0.050750732, 0.050231934, -0.023880005, -0.031829834, 0.017227173, 0.01600647, -0.052001953, -0.0012569427, 0.036315918, 0.054718018, 0.06707764, 0.06561279, -0.017166138, 0.018173218, 0.051849365, -0.029006958, 0.0067214966, -0.011077881, 0.0004401207, 0.018081665, -0.037139893, -0.0011997223, 0.012969971, -0.029678345, 0.01184845, -0.06762695, 0.039245605, -0.028442383, 0.024887085, -0.03378296, -0.025131226, -0.061706543, 0.022323608, -0.0032463074, 0.0012559891, -0.005290985, -0.019210815, 0.022216797, -0.011329651, 0.0016479492, 0.025360107, -0.009399414, 0.029403687, -0.0030155182, -0.043792725, -0.0060539246, -0.009719849, 0.04260254, -0.035369873, -0.007972717, 0.05255127, 0.0011281967, 0.0011768341, -0.061553955, -0.04019165, 0.02003479, 0.037017822, -0.0287323, 0.010414124, 0.007888794, -0.014846802, -0.030212402, -0.025894165, -0.000054180622, -0.03878784, 0.018096924, 0.043304443, -0.03817749, -0.01033783, 0.025604248, -0.013450623, 0.06915283, 0.008651733, -0.0052833557, 0.007095337, 0.012123108, -0.021270752, -0.042541504, -0.000705719, -0.0044517517, -0.01966858, -0.02709961, -0.008552551, 0.0104599, 0.05569458, -0.0032176971, -0.01876831, 0.0236969, -0.024459839, 0.0010223389, -0.025909424, 0.010734558, -0.020370483, 0.019454956, 0.0011453629, -0.0048561096, -0.027053833, 0.054870605, 0.01335144, -0.02949524, 0.025177002, -0.001405716, 0.040283203, 0.015068054, -0.025924683, -0.0209198, 0.055786133, 0.017471313, -0.009819031, 0.01222229, 0.0011711121, -0.043762207, -0.08886719, 0.024368286, 0.0050582886, -0.016204834, -0.004558563, -0.032165527, 0.008888245, -0.026504517, -0.031402588, -0.058776855, 0.022216797, 0.020858765, 0.0018529892, 0.0071029663, -0.03567505, 0.008888245, 0.07019043, -0.0098724365, 0.024353027, 0.0065689087, 0.048583984, -0.008743286, -0.027786255, 0.0028953552, -0.050048828, -0.013877869, -0.031341553, -0.030715942, 0.0043182373, -0.023651123, 0.01713562, 0.031311035, -0.030349731, 0.027923584, 0.04449463, -0.008239746, 0.022888184, -0.0066604614, 0.009338379, -0.0020046234, -0.007183075 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06714v1
What factors influence the popularity of user-generated text in the creative domain? A case study of book reviews
Salim Sazzed
cs.CL, cs.IR
This study investigates a range of psychological, lexical, semantic, and readability features of book reviews to elucidate the factors underlying their perceived popularity. To this end, we conduct statistical analyses of various features, including the types and frequency of opinion and emotion-conveying terms, connectives, character mentions, word uniqueness, commonness, and sentence structure, among others. Additionally, we utilize two readability tests to explore whether reading ease is positively associated with review popularity. Finally, we employ traditional machine learning classifiers and transformer-based fine-tuned language models with n-gram features to automatically determine review popularity. Our findings indicate that, with the exception of a few features (e.g., review length, emotions, and word uniqueness), most attributes do not exhibit significant differences between popular and non-popular review groups. Furthermore, the poor performance of machine learning classifiers using the word n-gram feature highlights the challenges associated with determining popularity in creative domains. Overall, our study provides insights into the factors underlying review popularity and highlights the need for further research in this area, particularly in the creative realm.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06714v1
2023-11-12T02:54:11
2023-11-12T02:54:11
{ "title": [ -0.0027198792, 0.008811951, -0.018493652, 0.017105103, 0.0015869141, -0.039367676, 0.024276733, -0.043121338, -0.05029297, 0.0473938, -0.008796692, 0.0423584, -0.012924194, -0.0051841736, -0.047424316, -0.011154175, -0.035614014, 0.044952393, -0.022537231, -0.037017822, 0.005718231, -0.07110596, -0.007347107, -0.030136108, 0.016937256, -0.036712646, 0.0129776, -0.021560669, 0.011779785, -0.016647339, 0.0031280518, -0.016983032, 0.021865845, 0.02015686, 0.014030457, 0.016983032, -0.015342712, 0.021697998, 0.010688782, -0.006717682, 0.018447876, -0.008255005, -0.028060913, -0.015563965, -0.031097412, 0.0034999847, -0.021636963, -0.017471313, -0.0026340485, -0.00440979, -0.0056533813, 0.03781128, 0.0152282715, 0.005138397, 0.0048980713, -0.0116119385, -0.017410278, -0.0390625, 0.055511475, -0.004699707, -0.00058078766, -0.09075928, 0.040802002, -0.004837036, -0.0068473816, -0.013542175, -0.014167786, 0.023101807, 0.06311035, 0.026855469, -0.019866943, 0.017868042, 0.0061798096, -0.028747559, -0.0063285828, 0.03265381, -0.008987427, 0.012931824, 0.053894043, -0.018722534, -0.06530762, 0.0046653748, -0.0357666, -0.049743652, 0.013786316, -0.023971558, -0.031311035, 0.017059326, -0.01826477, -0.05987549, 0.006942749, -0.039764404, -0.045654297, 0.030014038, 0.0076026917, -0.04260254, 0.02279663, 0.09387207, 0.009895325, -0.027664185, -0.031021118, 0.02104187, -0.07489014, -0.010597229, 0.01083374, 0.028182983, -0.015014648, -0.007701874, 0.027862549, 0.033966064, -0.025054932, 0.024536133, 0.026885986, 0.019546509, -0.022644043, -0.02986145, -0.013519287, 0.0256958, 0.0034751892, 0.043701172, 0.0031757355, -0.0028076172, 0.04498291, -0.009506226, 0.03326416, 0.018966675, -0.03564453, -0.022781372, -0.015159607, 0.059265137, 0.01838684, 0.026229858, -0.11029053, -0.074279785, -0.05834961, 0.020309448, -0.026473999, -0.004627228, -0.016174316, 0.012397766, 0.003168106, -0.017425537, 0.029830933, -0.00497818, 0.0063323975, -0.02381897, 0.041015625, 0.023910522, -0.0141067505, -0.012809753, -0.014556885, 0.026992798, 0.026809692, -0.03488159, -0.041290283, -0.07019043, -0.093811035, -0.047302246, 0.07458496, -0.03918457, 0.031341553, 0.024139404, -0.0048980713, 0.036254883, 0.049621582, -0.036468506, 0.0016794205, 0.029586792, 0.027404785, 0.06329346, 0.0035705566, -0.021408081, 0.0063171387, -0.0024337769, -0.026870728, 0.013671875, 0.07067871, 0.030334473, -0.017654419, 0.016235352, -0.0014133453, -0.030548096, 0.047607422, -0.0017442703, -0.061645508, -0.012649536, 0.010040283, 0.021469116, 0.03918457, 0.015350342, -0.02810669, 0.03265381, -0.03225708, -0.064453125, -0.023406982, 0.026062012, -0.007583618, 0.01940918, 0.0015869141, 0.018005371, -0.029159546, -0.015342712, -0.014656067, 0.015411377, 0.01008606, -0.026992798, 0.0075531006, 0.016708374, 0.007686615, 0.08532715, 0.019119263, 0.0031604767, -0.024261475, 0.030334473, 0.013626099, -0.06896973, 0.04925537, -0.007472992, 0.015716553, -0.0368042, 0.008720398, -0.001253128, -0.0061836243, 0.026168823, 0.008712769, -0.03111267, 0.0063934326, -0.044769287, 0.028366089, 0.014427185, 0.05340576, -0.01096344, 0.07727051, 0.035736084, -0.033111572, -0.033050537, -0.006843567, -0.039154053, 0.006565094, 0.052581787, 0.004688263, -0.01184845, 0.010269165, 0.048431396, -0.002210617, -0.027496338, 0.023803711, 0.014762878, 0.057647705, 0.06976318, 0.030731201, 0.011047363, 0.026947021, -0.027496338, 0.020645142, 0.06933594, -0.0019760132, 0.02368164, -0.018325806, 0.007873535, 0.008544922, 0.059814453, 0.019805908, 0.021026611, -0.05328369, 0.014572144, -0.031066895, 0.0064697266, -0.009048462, 0.0018854141, 0.030670166, 0.016098022, 0.011909485, 0.003753662, 0.019866943, 0.008956909, -0.035339355, 0.0077056885, 0.04159546, -0.020462036, -0.026443481, -0.0056533813, 0.02268982, -0.010391235, -0.009941101, -0.0022888184, 0.034942627, -0.003232956, -0.0029354095, -0.006122589, 0.037750244, 0.064575195, 0.033111572, 0.0035629272, 0.018936157, 0.011734009, 0.08477783, 0.01737976, -0.0014543533, 0.016235352, 0.020828247, 0.047698975, 0.016540527, 0.011398315, 0.009277344, 0.03314209, 0.023605347, 0.017333984, -0.017654419, -0.007949829, -0.027511597, -0.0000269413, 0.0045814514, -0.012023926, -0.020080566, -0.034423828, -0.0036144257, -0.0070648193, -0.043670654, -0.023010254, 0.056610107, -0.0016965866, -0.008651733, -0.022628784, 0.0003504753, -0.022827148, -0.022827148, -0.030517578, 0.00730896, -0.013198853, 0.016784668, -0.007461548, -0.06137085, -0.026763916, 0.014015198, 0.010505676, -0.021606445, -0.0019159317, -0.036590576, 0.008598328, -0.035217285, -0.012359619, 0.017074585, -0.04348755, 0.032989502, -0.051361084, 0.010818481, 0.009414673, 0.00730896, 0.019836426, -0.009788513, 0.0028533936, 0.01260376, -0.0134887695, 0.06561279, -0.006412506, -0.03869629, 0.027511597, 0.040405273, -0.01612854, 0.01675415, 0.026916504, 0.0011577606, -0.010604858, -0.009643555, -0.045166016, -0.03378296, 0.02279663, -0.021820068, 0.021102905, -0.018630981, -0.037078857, -0.0127334595, 0.0018014908, 0.0121536255, -0.0051002502, 0.011779785, -0.027740479, -0.029754639, -0.019210815, -0.018600464, -0.011436462, -0.030090332, 0.0044403076, 0.06384277, 0.00084495544, -0.016464233, 0.013183594, 0.010757446, -0.0056114197, 0.0045928955, 0.0015821457, -0.04437256, -0.0028705597, 0.031829834, -0.012710571, -0.014289856, 0.039276123, -0.114868164, 0.01285553, 0.037963867, -0.00111866, -0.015686035, 0.033172607, -0.06463623, 0.062438965, 0.006374359, -0.012992859, 0.027282715, 0.02935791, 0.0052108765, 0.010353088, 0.029922485, -0.021514893, -0.0045280457, -0.045043945, -0.07006836, 0.02835083, -0.037261963, -0.048858643, -0.0010261536, -0.009155273, -0.01751709, -0.008888245, 0.006713867, 0.08105469, 0.0030670166, -0.021743774, -0.01802063, -0.026519775, 0.014274597, -0.023712158, -0.0006685257, -0.023010254, -0.049804688, 0.009559631, -0.0039253235, 0.046661377, 0.009292603, 0.000102460384, -0.027008057, -0.015975952, -0.020690918, -0.00042366982, -0.018920898, -0.025009155, -0.010604858, -0.011932373, 0.0042915344, 0.0037117004, 0.026000977, 0.012748718, 0.006187439, -0.0037822723, -0.016662598, -0.0004518032, -0.009750366, 0.051818848, -0.0134887695, -0.029907227, 0.031234741, -0.04360962, -0.04397583, 0.039916992, 0.019332886, -0.038757324, 0.039215088, -0.028335571, -0.037628174, 0.042510986, -0.034820557, 0.02684021, -0.0077209473, 0.0025196075, 0.019851685, -0.003967285, -0.01574707, 0.022766113, -0.024612427, -0.000107347965, 0.018585205, 0.01687622, 0.032714844, -0.060638428, -0.019226074, 0.008781433, -0.10803223, -0.057922363, -0.011001587, -0.035095215, -0.055511475, 0.010147095, 0.012336731, -0.016036987, -0.014884949, 0.012702942, -0.007247925, 0.033325195, -0.00041127205, -0.06323242, -0.052642822, 0.06677246, -0.017547607, -0.0038642883, 0.07739258, -0.0090408325, -0.03253174, 0.0010242462, 0.02796936, 0.028381348, 0.034973145, 0.018630981, -0.016281128, 0.036590576, -0.02229309, 0.049438477, 0.007926941, -0.017120361, 0.01612854, -0.00466156, 0.02897644, 0.052612305, -0.03265381, 0.06323242, 0.027832031, -0.014266968, -0.064331055, -0.004878998, -0.00063705444, -0.017242432, 0.00022995472, -0.021713257, -0.0070724487, 0.016708374, 0.038085938, 0.042541504, -0.0030765533, -0.042175293, -0.002407074, -0.004825592, 0.009727478, -0.00356102, -0.023590088, 0.014221191, 0.021469116, -0.018661499, -0.020874023, 0.0032482147, -0.050598145, -0.019821167, -0.0129852295, -0.004043579, -0.06500244, -0.0019483566, -0.03201294, -0.08984375, -0.06744385, 0.029373169, 0.011192322, 0.035064697, 0.039215088, -0.011444092, -0.045166016, 0.011711121, 0.03201294, -0.0056495667, 0.013717651, -0.05508423, -0.016967773, -0.02368164, -0.050720215, -0.015159607, 0.0005221367, -0.010017395, 0.051116943, -0.013809204, -0.033416748, 0.039733887, -0.0014743805, -0.007171631, 0.04748535, -0.033416748, -0.039123535, 0.015380859, -0.019424438, -0.027328491, 0.027130127, 0.020141602, -0.013153076, -0.051971436, 0.0048675537, -0.014602661, -0.02658081, -0.013748169, 0.068481445, -0.020858765, 0.061401367, -0.03314209, 0.025177002, 0.03353882, 0.029571533, -0.011650085, 0.002149582, -0.03567505, 0.013504028, -0.014122009, 0.053253174, -0.014976501, -0.014808655, 0.021865845, 0.033172607, 0.023361206, -0.013206482, -0.0029449463, -0.0040130615, 0.022033691, 0.018814087, -0.0074424744, -0.02696228, -0.040618896, -0.016998291, 0.010414124, 0.024963379, -0.06384277, 0.033081055, -0.015640259, -0.011184692, 0.017440796, -0.015609741, 0.005947113, -0.0058555603, 0.008636475, -0.056274414, -0.0158844, -0.011940002, -0.0141067505, -0.032196045, -0.012718201, 0.017745972, 0.005748749, 0.016677856, 0.049346924, 0.008216858, 0.039367676, -0.032562256, 0.02154541, 0.0028514862, -0.06896973, -0.016311646, 0.012184143, 0.028808594, 0.012886047, -0.021850586, -0.004306793, -0.061828613, -0.0135269165, -0.030776978, -0.041229248, 0.05041504, -0.04067993, 0.0670166, 0.124938965, -0.028930664, 0.07141113, -0.032348633, -0.0022773743, 0.04397583, 0.050445557, -0.024841309, 0.00705719, 0.041778564, -0.0129470825, -0.0024318695, -0.017532349, 0.007167816, 0.03225708, 0.030975342, 0.007904053, 0.014389038, -0.053466797, 0.016342163, -0.00970459, -0.009223938, 0.0115737915, -0.038330078, 0.018615723, 0.0059814453, -0.008552551, 0.00058460236, -0.04611206, -0.024017334, -0.010719299, -0.03451538, -0.046539307, -0.0033779144, -0.024108887, -0.077819824, -0.062683105, 0.028747559, 0.023422241, -0.006668091, -0.03314209, 0.023788452, -0.053588867, 0.013725281, 0.04724121, -0.05493164, 0.046936035, -0.033081055, -0.009506226, 0.05368042, 0.054382324, -0.01512146, -0.008308411, -0.033447266, -0.029907227, 0.014228821, 0.00642395, 0.004135132, 0.029083252, 0.0007920265, -0.0657959, -0.005466461, -0.0035572052, 0.0064430237, 0.007774353, -0.00497818, 0.019332886, -0.014709473, -0.01109314, 0.040374756, 0.0062713623, -0.03567505, 0.030776978, 0.031280518, 0.007762909, -0.008483887, 0.017959595, 0.020004272, -0.06640625, -0.07330322, -0.005332947, 0.008613586, -0.013015747, 0.004180908, 0.013282776, 0.00844574, 0.019485474, -0.010879517, 0.0073432922, 0.05911255, -0.03677368, -0.015357971, -0.017227173, 0.008857727, -0.05126953, 0.031311035, 0.030273438, 0.012870789, -0.030227661, -0.027633667, -0.025772095, 0.02708435, 0.024520874, -0.024551392, 0.024612427, -0.06323242, -0.008598328, -0.07159424, 0.0036067963, -0.017532349, 0.0072250366, -0.021255493, -0.02166748, 0.0368042, 0.007167816, -0.040863037, -0.020736694, 0.009674072, 0.06286621, 0.023849487, 0.05178833, -0.06982422, -0.019821167, -0.025924683, -0.03741455, 0.013717651, 0.020111084, -0.052734375, 0.017959595, -0.013160706, 0.06945801, 0.017944336, 0.043823242, 0.040222168, 0.030960083, 0.019699097, -0.0028362274, 0.0078048706, -0.0071372986, -0.027053833, -0.06713867, -0.02015686, -0.035491943, 0.0017194748, -0.055786133, -0.0050621033, 0.018508911, 0.03314209, 0.023666382, 0.009361267, -0.016204834, -0.008728027, 0.02720642, 0.08258057, 0.074279785, -0.05316162, 0.005706787, -0.026809692, -0.047790527, 0.045928955, 0.03564453, -0.05078125, 0.03955078, -0.039611816, -0.011161804, -0.0025939941, -0.001408577, 0.00026106834, 0.027297974, -0.0012493134, -0.007896423, 0.015777588, -0.004825592, 0.013465881, 0.047729492, 0.02748108, 0.013999939, -0.0262146, 0.0032444, 0.010765076, -0.032836914, -0.002822876, 0.032714844, -0.04159546, 0.013008118, -0.028396606, -0.028808594, -0.04107666, 0.051116943, 0.018676758, -0.013389587, -0.01802063, 0.036834717, 0.028961182, 0.005836487, 0.021224976, -0.04626465, -0.025970459, -0.006641388, -0.0031394958, -0.004814148, -0.012420654, 0.010673523, 0.06317139, -0.009796143, 0.0015621185, 0.0051574707, -0.026809692, -0.0073051453, 0.02709961, -0.023483276, 0.021209717, -0.0033931732, -0.030090332, 0.011505127, 0.0005040169, -0.004673004, -0.022262573, 0.011520386, 0.019088745, 0.004310608, 0.06335449, 0.030914307, 0.0031700134, -0.061401367, -0.023773193, 0.035858154, 0.05441284, -0.038970947, 0.010002136, -0.012107849, -0.04949951, 0.03894043, -0.05114746, 0.03579712, -0.02407837, -0.013053894, -0.0017251968, -0.020233154, 0.06958008, -0.020889282, -0.03967285, -0.0045318604, -0.019378662, -0.0040245056, -0.0101623535, -0.02279663, -0.03845215, -0.021972656, 0.047424316, -0.02458191, 0.0059509277, 0.023712158, -0.012321472, -0.049438477, 0.009780884, -0.020706177, 0.05734253, -0.04650879, 0.004573822, 0.035858154, -0.011016846, -0.009376526, -0.0362854, -0.039764404, 0.013343811, 0.016998291, -0.030471802, 0.028381348, 0.015174866, -0.0129852295, 0.0046463013, -0.02305603, 0.0040359497, -0.02015686, 0.008796692, -0.0030956268, -0.05038452, 0.0017328262, 0.009979248, -0.047698975, 0.03451538, 0.029922485, -0.018753052, 0.05807495, 0.003370285, -0.032928467, -0.004032135, -0.0003066063, 0.01586914, -0.0037975311, -0.00995636, -0.0016546249, 0.024383545, 0.015045166, -0.068847656, -0.055755615, -0.012008667, 0.057250977, 0.002231598, 0.03149414, 0.025650024, 0.033111572, 0.013130188, 0.0009794235, -0.002155304, -0.053375244, -0.0473938, -0.019165039, 0.026351929, 0.035980225, 0.010810852, -0.03616333, 0.007511139, 0.026306152, -0.004840851, -0.0051841736, -0.049102783, -0.00945282, 0.010467529, 0.0049476624, 0.019180298, -0.010398865, -0.08679199, 0.007522583, 0.0032539368, 0.017730713, -0.0013990402, 0.048553467, -0.009162903, 0.066101074, -0.016357422, -0.01713562, 0.021118164, 0.039001465, 0.013923645, 0.066467285, -0.026168823, -0.010856628, 0.016189575, -0.0028476715, -0.016815186, 0.0019836426, 0.00034093857, 0.020080566, -0.017700195, -0.005760193, -0.05130005, -0.0154418945, -0.035583496, 0.02911377, -0.031921387, 0.0069732666, -0.0075149536, -0.017501831, 0.014076233, 0.0069122314, 0.015609741, -0.01927185, -0.049438477, -0.012809753, 0.028152466, -0.016860962 ], "summary": [ -0.010856628, -0.009933472, 0.013549805, 0.089904785, -0.03152466, -0.01927185, 0.022201538, -0.071777344, 0.0099487305, 0.023147583, -0.026229858, 0.0099487305, 0.0063171387, -0.009346008, -0.016647339, -0.029953003, -0.008735657, 0.047302246, 0.04385376, -0.019165039, 0.036895752, -0.02734375, -0.004425049, -0.03744507, 0.034484863, -0.047576904, 0.07745361, -0.016983032, 0.06402588, 0.03189087, 0.0289917, -0.07556152, -0.0011968613, 0.013198853, 0.017990112, -0.041534424, 0.028045654, -0.008216858, -0.0019521713, 0.03314209, 0.03717041, -0.015022278, 0.023376465, -0.034179688, -0.026855469, 0.019363403, 0.0105896, -0.007095337, 0.03201294, -0.07006836, -0.008460999, 0.046020508, 0.009887695, -0.056121826, -0.027008057, 0.0052337646, 0.01436615, -0.03289795, 0.026062012, -0.019714355, -0.017410278, -0.026306152, 0.04019165, -0.017715454, 0.011734009, 0.016113281, 0.014671326, 0.0035133362, 0.045837402, 0.015045166, -0.016235352, 0.0028057098, 0.0045700073, -0.07324219, 0.015777588, 0.070007324, -0.020080566, 0.03515625, 0.01776123, -0.026824951, -0.08099365, -0.0018167496, -0.04724121, -0.062286377, -0.011482239, -0.02482605, -0.035583496, 0.03640747, -0.034301758, -0.0289917, -0.010658264, -0.08258057, -0.088012695, 0.06842041, 0.06359863, -0.034606934, 0.016281128, 0.028839111, 0.018127441, -0.024154663, 0.00070381165, -0.016189575, -0.033203125, -0.0021972656, 0.026382446, 0.031799316, -0.0047416687, 0.0060539246, 0.04244995, 0.0033817291, -0.009056091, 0.002456665, 0.016159058, 0.0031356812, 0.0003736019, -0.007820129, -0.029891968, 0.05807495, -0.0065956116, 0.028396606, -0.0017757416, 0.008842468, -0.0015974045, 0.013458252, 0.011039734, 0.025024414, -0.008079529, -0.012580872, -0.014442444, 0.10205078, 0.0042304993, -0.01651001, -0.067993164, -0.043670654, -0.061523438, -0.04272461, -0.008132935, -0.0317688, 0.0033359528, -0.021575928, 0.015563965, 0.026153564, 0.058502197, -0.011520386, 0.049682617, -0.02406311, -0.0028057098, 0.040161133, 0.027160645, -0.009429932, 0.07696533, -0.01586914, 0.058776855, -0.039367676, -0.064575195, -0.067993164, -0.07067871, -0.0128479, 0.039276123, -0.022109985, 0.03982544, -0.0004892349, 0.004421234, 0.055664062, 0.028671265, 0.0057029724, -0.031555176, 0.00068855286, 0.0178833, 0.0070991516, 0.0057258606, -0.034729004, -0.0335083, -0.005607605, -0.012924194, 0.016540527, 0.04147339, 0.05130005, -0.032470703, 0.013397217, 0.011688232, -0.038208008, 0.070495605, -0.025650024, -0.0059776306, 0.0009293556, 0.050354004, 0.088134766, -0.0028915405, 0.046844482, -0.0010728836, -0.027236938, -0.015899658, 0.0018615723, -0.0050239563, 0.001698494, -0.0026874542, 0.0206604, -0.000049948692, -0.041778564, 0.08660889, -0.012542725, -0.0033111572, -0.025543213, -0.018737793, -0.048583984, 0.0262146, -0.018157959, -0.019256592, 0.048217773, 0.025650024, -0.00868988, -0.019851685, 0.046173096, 0.020004272, -0.04257202, 0.03805542, 0.003074646, 0.021881104, -0.05029297, 0.03152466, 0.021209717, -0.004863739, 0.048461914, -0.007457733, -0.017456055, -0.015930176, -0.009986877, 0.02670288, -0.009277344, 0.062561035, -0.0045280457, 0.06939697, 0.046813965, -0.024230957, -0.029296875, 0.01777649, -0.06317139, 0.023849487, 0.05831909, 0.0019416809, 0.003194809, -0.021224976, 0.015701294, -0.038085938, -0.007247925, 0.038146973, -0.004764557, 0.04119873, 0.09918213, -0.022064209, 0.007663727, 0.0008773804, -0.063964844, -0.030258179, 0.064331055, -0.004749298, 0.0065612793, -0.005092621, 0.028152466, -0.02330017, 0.07910156, 0.040039062, 0.020889282, -0.028259277, -0.010055542, -0.006801605, 0.0077209473, 0.0015821457, -0.028427124, 0.026504517, 0.0070266724, 0.003665924, 0.012191772, -0.033172607, -0.04876709, -0.010185242, 0.0061569214, 0.024719238, -0.017318726, 0.004295349, 0.051757812, 0.010612488, -0.008773804, -0.045959473, -0.012123108, 0.013244629, 0.032043457, 0.007144928, 0.031555176, 0.030227661, 0.082458496, 0.02519226, 0.027709961, 0.031158447, 0.03189087, 0.06365967, -0.03125, 0.032958984, -0.021865845, 0.08154297, 0.06665039, -0.023620605, 0.043426514, 0.013694763, 0.017562866, 0.018814087, 0.018096924, 0.0061912537, -0.018081665, -0.021392822, 0.00051164627, 0.026657104, 0.06750488, -0.0038700104, -0.027191162, 0.007873535, 0.05230713, 0.010940552, -0.01725769, 0.09295654, -0.008560181, 0.011383057, 0.01108551, -0.0096206665, -0.042999268, 0.044555664, -0.0236969, -0.03753662, -0.026306152, -0.0008277893, -0.060333252, -0.0473938, -0.0138168335, 0.012435913, 0.014556885, -0.001964569, -0.026351929, -0.03930664, 0.018707275, -0.020614624, -0.015167236, 0.02470398, -0.06951904, -0.021331787, 0.003873825, 0.0041923523, -0.0052490234, -0.011116028, 0.02748108, -0.0073051453, 0.0058250427, -0.007881165, 0.0071983337, 0.039886475, -0.0076675415, -0.0023155212, 0.024307251, 0.052520752, -0.019348145, -0.019546509, 0.0047302246, -0.020996094, -0.06414795, -0.029846191, -0.0048675537, -0.010818481, 0.0023784637, 0.014259338, -0.0055999756, 0.024520874, -0.025543213, -0.03652954, 0.008026123, 0.024856567, -0.0023975372, 0.062042236, -0.004508972, 0.0060310364, 0.035461426, -0.006225586, -0.01763916, 0.0079956055, -0.040039062, 0.022537231, -0.006362915, -0.021087646, 0.013534546, 0.017822266, 0.012519836, 0.006137848, -0.0011129379, -0.020050049, -0.015701294, 0.013916016, -0.008552551, 0.023513794, 0.022705078, -0.043518066, -0.03250122, 0.03439331, 0.024276733, 0.028320312, 0.006866455, -0.057891846, 0.103881836, -0.019607544, 0.010093689, 0.026977539, -0.00062799454, 0.02923584, 0.000364542, 0.023880005, 0.0030021667, -0.017120361, -0.024673462, 0.034484863, 0.011528015, -0.02180481, -0.03579712, -0.018447876, 0.058013916, -0.029891968, -0.018371582, -0.0070343018, 0.054656982, -0.034423828, -0.010978699, -0.04095459, 0.017364502, 0.011779785, -0.00793457, -0.00944519, 0.032562256, -0.05645752, 0.029846191, 0.012397766, -0.027359009, 0.05834961, -0.0524292, -0.0028743744, -0.019454956, 0.029815674, 0.011734009, -0.015731812, 0.031463623, 0.0074157715, 0.01676941, 0.021911621, -0.00919342, 0.012512207, 0.005077362, 0.05038452, 0.016845703, -0.019180298, -0.053619385, -0.009712219, 0.056152344, 0.047790527, -0.03353882, 0.014549255, -0.033081055, -0.045196533, 0.046661377, 0.028533936, -0.0070762634, 0.0074272156, 0.0014333725, -0.0020141602, 0.00957489, 0.000992775, -0.027008057, -0.04864502, -0.011955261, -0.0018396378, -0.013702393, 0.036346436, 0.01285553, 0.043426514, -0.014167786, -0.017547607, 0.044891357, 0.0023651123, -0.049102783, -0.01033783, 0.008415222, -0.066589355, -0.0703125, -0.029129028, 0.0059394836, -0.030288696, 0.040527344, 0.010551453, -0.0037403107, -0.00667572, 0.00844574, -0.021652222, 0.07885742, -0.018325806, -0.0993042, 0.005874634, -0.021270752, 0.017807007, 0.03643799, -0.011543274, -0.0005402565, 0.015670776, 0.015853882, 0.0038146973, -0.026184082, 0.050842285, -0.016906738, -0.020721436, -0.011451721, -0.0047569275, 0.059692383, 0.005138397, -0.048431396, 0.042175293, -0.003709793, 0.020339966, 0.06488037, -0.020385742, 0.011734009, 0.022613525, 0.03543091, -0.051513672, 0.05960083, -0.0072288513, -0.045043945, -0.01928711, -0.01474762, -0.070617676, 0.0009613037, 0.072631836, 0.022399902, -0.029449463, -0.048950195, 0.004901886, 0.014389038, 0.01763916, 0.0023117065, -0.027908325, 0.028076172, 0.013961792, -0.064331055, -0.021133423, -0.053466797, -0.023010254, -0.047027588, 0.0024108887, 0.012077332, -0.04638672, 0.023529053, 0.021942139, -0.10632324, -0.08856201, 0.012001038, 0.016952515, 0.041748047, -0.009353638, -0.0073661804, 0.0000053048134, 0.02218628, 0.055877686, 0.01725769, -0.02406311, -0.071899414, 0.0042762756, -0.03213501, -0.038146973, -0.033355713, -0.024337769, -0.03439331, 0.0023994446, 0.0104904175, -0.02709961, 0.026901245, -0.009765625, -0.0016393661, 0.03817749, -0.019729614, -0.049468994, -0.026184082, -0.021774292, -0.0048713684, 0.023986816, 0.0051841736, -0.012306213, -0.0385437, -0.012374878, 0.00969696, -0.025253296, -0.02722168, 0.023925781, 0.006576538, 0.00036668777, -0.014312744, 0.033050537, 0.011260986, -0.0013875961, -0.013008118, -0.001159668, -0.03729248, 0.029541016, -0.011177063, 0.028656006, -0.055023193, -0.012840271, -0.011184692, 0.046081543, -0.017105103, 0.0024719238, 0.030715942, -0.00045371056, -0.015380859, 0.018447876, 0.019851685, 0.008262634, -0.0071372986, 0.02772522, -0.0027656555, 0.021499634, -0.018798828, -0.026321411, 0.045318604, -0.029632568, 0.017913818, -0.01637268, -0.0006155968, 0.023757935, -0.023361206, -0.04953003, -0.024505615, -0.04156494, 0.0031719208, -0.019622803, -0.029037476, -0.0033493042, -0.017913818, 0.023803711, 0.011009216, -0.026260376, 0.02658081, -0.019195557, 0.032806396, 0.030944824, -0.028564453, -0.002664566, -0.029693604, -0.020812988, -0.006996155, -0.0019359589, -0.010437012, 0.012008667, -0.033935547, -0.02418518, -0.00856781, 0.008010864, -0.042510986, -0.019210815, 0.032348633, -0.014480591, 0.030929565, -0.012466431, -0.018936157, -0.020492554, 0.018600464, -0.047821045, 0.0034046173, -0.010871887, -0.028244019, -0.015991211, -0.027542114, 0.014259338, 0.02720642, 0.035736084, 0.023101807, 0.003255844, -0.049102783, -0.02116394, -0.043273926, 0.040252686, -0.0028266907, -0.030960083, -0.0024929047, 0.021621704, 0.014526367, -0.0041503906, 0.040527344, 0.011367798, 0.017944336, 0.016296387, -0.013114929, -0.025177002, -0.008201599, -0.04598999, -0.09185791, -0.0013799667, 0.03237915, 0.013664246, -0.07067871, 0.04559326, -0.062805176, -0.017074585, 0.02708435, -0.004348755, 0.0045318604, -0.0047912598, 0.01197052, 0.000834465, 0.010879517, -0.017852783, -0.021514893, -0.035217285, 0.027770996, 0.10522461, 0.038238525, 0.04638672, 0.025482178, -0.02645874, -0.014671326, -0.006641388, -0.053588867, -0.021957397, 0.0015382767, -0.028884888, -0.0013484955, 0.011314392, 0.0051460266, 0.022155762, -0.0004441738, -0.02267456, 0.005130768, 0.015586853, 0.00289917, 0.0005736351, -0.005619049, 0.002817154, -0.10290527, -0.061065674, -0.0056991577, 0.014785767, -0.0064926147, 0.0065193176, -0.05545044, -0.003730774, -0.016082764, -0.028625488, -0.024658203, 0.069885254, -0.0519104, -0.002292633, -0.034973145, 0.013137817, -0.047058105, 0.0019874573, -0.0057296753, 0.015914917, -0.018035889, -0.03616333, 0.02003479, 0.0021362305, -0.00027537346, -0.018112183, -0.011894226, -0.085754395, -0.027313232, -0.029708862, -0.035583496, 0.018371582, 0.020523071, -0.009490967, -0.02696228, 0.049316406, -0.044281006, -0.029418945, 0.016967773, -0.015701294, 0.0236969, 0.017440796, 0.03677368, -0.021362305, 0.0012540817, 0.0072288513, 0.012969971, -0.026260376, 0.006061554, -0.012718201, -0.017532349, -0.0013237, 0.03668213, 0.02267456, -0.0033798218, 0.019348145, -0.0044937134, -0.011474609, -0.007408142, -0.020812988, -0.021148682, -0.05783081, -0.031829834, -0.05029297, -0.029846191, -0.017715454, 0.030975342, 0.038909912, -0.04937744, -0.00093507767, 0.028076172, 0.008018494, -0.021911621, 0.012298584, 0.011039734, 0.07647705, 0.035736084, -0.066711426, -0.006526947, -0.03945923, -0.008903503, 0.015586853, 0.03375244, -0.034240723, 0.056365967, -0.068603516, 0.017822266, 0.008300781, -0.026290894, -0.027618408, 0.04220581, 0.02772522, -0.014602661, -0.00095653534, 0.011566162, 0.030593872, 0.004032135, 0.0044517517, 0.026306152, 0.0011882782, -0.005630493, -0.017700195, -0.005218506, -0.037261963, -0.016204834, 0.01889038, -0.018341064, -0.0024814606, -0.006526947, -0.01838684, 0.031204224, 0.02810669, 0.0033988953, 0.010055542, 0.029388428, 0.007545471, -0.0078125, -0.0031814575, -0.05822754, -0.03793335, -0.035247803, -0.04437256, 0.0036029816, -0.050994873, 0.0113220215, 0.030548096, 0.015838623, 0.016601562, -0.0012044907, 0.0027332306, 0.0041618347, 0.019760132, -0.005176544, -0.02142334, 0.026901245, -0.010185242, 0.007358551, 0.011352539, 0.028015137, 0.011627197, 0.020965576, 0.010574341, 0.037994385, 0.044921875, -0.03152466, 0.013053894, 0.023101807, -0.009315491, 0.016601562, 0.02355957, 0.0042304993, -0.02204895, -0.010848999, -0.010551453, -0.003353119, -0.0154800415, 0.01007843, -0.026824951, -0.025222778, -0.014854431, 0.013946533, -0.019989014, 0.005054474, -0.0262146, -0.029388428, 0.0062179565, 0.0060577393, 0.01210022, -0.043945312, -0.012756348, -0.03125, -0.0005903244, -0.025344849, 0.013092041, 0.03213501, -0.031188965, -0.0011444092, -0.010467529, 0.024246216, 0.04034424, -0.011260986, 0.004711151, 0.070129395, 0.00072193146, -0.035827637, -0.051330566, -0.041107178, 0.05883789, 0.051879883, -0.07891846, 0.03955078, 0.0048332214, -0.03375244, -0.007865906, -0.039276123, 0.0036449432, -0.008575439, -0.0034427643, -0.030090332, -0.033355713, 0.01914978, 0.001074791, -0.029846191, -0.016235352, 0.036712646, -0.0026397705, 0.05697632, 0.0020122528, -0.010192871, -0.0020313263, 0.0064086914, 0.008033752, -0.0018663406, 0.0052757263, -0.0035972595, -0.0071258545, -0.008522034, -0.07562256, -0.036621094, -0.016357422, 0.06347656, 0.0009469986, 0.023635864, 0.022872925, 0.043640137, -0.0072746277, 0.0036678314, -0.011779785, -0.036376953, -0.015220642, -0.009643555, 0.023956299, -0.0010566711, -0.012336731, -0.025344849, -0.00055265427, -0.0022468567, 0.018341064, -0.0021076202, -0.058532715, -0.021774292, -0.023468018, -0.022735596, 0.0056495667, -0.01878357, -0.022338867, -0.0287323, 0.00655365, -0.0050086975, 0.0021038055, -0.004459381, -0.017501831, 0.059326172, -0.04257202, 0.03237915, -0.013412476, -0.015563965, 0.009635925, 0.009780884, 0.008972168, 0.03829956, 0.026367188, 0.00970459, -0.020690918, 0.00178051, 0.020812988, 0.040771484, -0.02709961, -0.015403748, -0.010314941, 0.0045547485, -0.018112183, 0.044311523, 0.003353119, -0.029205322, 0.023239136, 0.00083589554, 0.01979065, 0.0005760193, 0.001739502, 0.0049057007, -0.0090408325, 0.0073013306, 0.00053310394, 0.010414124 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06697v1
Trusted Source Alignment in Large Language Models
Vasilisa Bashlovkina, Zhaobin Kuang, Riley Matthews, Edward Clifford, Yennie Jun, William W. Cohen, Simon Baumgartner
cs.CL
Large language models (LLMs) are trained on web-scale corpora that inevitably include contradictory factual information from sources of varying reliability. In this paper, we propose measuring an LLM property called trusted source alignment (TSA): the model's propensity to align with content produced by trusted publishers in the face of uncertainty or controversy. We present FactCheckQA, a TSA evaluation dataset based on a corpus of fact checking articles. We describe a simple protocol for evaluating TSA and offer a detailed analysis of design considerations including response extraction, claim contextualization, and bias in prompt formulation. Applying the protocol to PaLM-2, we find that as we scale up the model size, the model performance on FactCheckQA improves from near-random to up to 80% balanced accuracy in aligning with trusted sources.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06697v1
2023-11-12T00:25:25
2023-11-12T00:25:25
{ "title": [ -0.04083252, -0.0057296753, -0.068359375, -0.08050537, 0.0149002075, 0.0035171509, -0.0713501, 0.021575928, -0.0073165894, 0.038269043, -0.002105713, -0.0022411346, 0.020629883, -0.023468018, -0.03012085, 0.01448822, -0.015357971, 0.018737793, -0.036468506, -0.050231934, 0.0048980713, -0.068359375, 0.035217285, -0.028869629, 0.07458496, -0.08679199, -0.049041748, 0.01927185, 0.011177063, -0.007068634, 0.0054016113, -0.0028076172, 0.045410156, 0.019638062, -0.03842163, -0.0134887695, -0.03274536, 0.011383057, -0.025543213, 0.025527954, 0.025650024, -0.0006942749, 0.01499176, 0.010726929, -0.030410767, 0.027679443, -0.049224854, -0.030303955, -0.013191223, 0.034973145, 0.00894928, 0.026748657, -0.005886078, 0.015312195, 0.022827148, -0.022918701, -0.017593384, 0.024642944, 0.00016725063, 0.089904785, 0.045196533, 0.010017395, -0.013374329, -0.013137817, -0.032165527, -0.00831604, 0.0039749146, 0.012756348, 0.026321411, -0.006427765, -0.0035533905, 0.0013790131, 0.030715942, -0.012428284, -0.03387451, 0.022750854, 0.012535095, 0.026443481, 0.054656982, -0.050933838, 0.0015602112, -0.0093688965, 0.008323669, -0.017562866, 0.020523071, -0.029800415, -0.014259338, -0.016433716, -0.018951416, -0.06817627, -0.004699707, 0.0184021, -0.022628784, 0.007972717, -0.02029419, -0.026168823, -0.005760193, 0.082336426, -0.018310547, -0.018569946, -0.038604736, 0.034240723, -0.0690918, -0.038482666, 0.0022201538, 0.026763916, -0.018234253, -0.038909912, 0.005214691, 0.032226562, -0.022476196, 0.02229309, 0.0045166016, -0.011299133, -0.0019626617, 0.021209717, 0.0041923523, -0.0022888184, 0.022949219, 0.021972656, -0.018493652, -0.028121948, 0.03366089, -0.009712219, 0.01876831, -0.0023937225, -0.034606934, -0.0118637085, -0.029510498, 0.0418396, -0.0015659332, 0.023391724, -0.08453369, -0.06274414, -0.052703857, 0.025253296, -0.037353516, 0.0031700134, -0.024841309, 0.011650085, 0.004436493, -0.02494812, 0.03326416, 0.0016345978, 0.034576416, -0.00831604, 0.07244873, 0.0047187805, -0.04663086, -0.011489868, -0.019897461, 0.031036377, 0.035583496, -0.018310547, -0.062042236, -0.05090332, -0.107299805, -0.027313232, 0.03451538, -0.024276733, -0.031707764, -0.006374359, 0.007217407, -0.040130615, -0.01197052, 0.01687622, 0.010643005, 0.0020198822, 0.012313843, 0.0262146, -0.02154541, 0.016448975, 0.009048462, 0.008529663, -0.002790451, 0.009902954, -0.012573242, 0.026306152, 0.028182983, -0.019119263, 0.016998291, -0.027786255, 0.019592285, 0.05355835, -0.06518555, -0.028671265, 0.010406494, 0.010749817, 0.05126953, 0.011978149, -0.003019333, 0.02128601, -0.04373169, -0.03503418, -0.024734497, -0.022521973, 0.02217102, 0.03793335, 0.0031433105, 0.0009250641, -0.015388489, 0.010772705, -0.039245605, -0.015945435, -0.023788452, -0.031051636, -0.013412476, 0.017837524, -0.013771057, 0.04498291, 0.07092285, 0.024291992, -0.06286621, 0.046447754, -0.0024585724, -0.05215454, 0.028686523, -0.0004813671, -0.0024051666, -0.013999939, -0.02154541, 0.006389618, -0.002632141, 0.03250122, -0.02458191, 0.019378662, -0.018692017, 0.000049889088, 0.009513855, 0.020202637, 0.08215332, -0.035217285, 0.032409668, 0.013412476, -0.0087509155, -0.02935791, -0.04611206, -0.050994873, 0.001080513, 0.0340271, 0.006729126, -0.027740479, -0.022033691, -0.016616821, 0.030670166, -0.020721436, 0.009391785, -0.008216858, 0.03805542, 0.054534912, 0.029632568, 0.008239746, 0.047424316, -0.04510498, 0.020568848, 0.05697632, -0.0038318634, 0.0074043274, 0.0053863525, -0.010238647, 0.034698486, -0.019805908, -0.042907715, 0.011367798, -0.06414795, 0.006668091, -0.034088135, 0.0009584427, 0.0047454834, 0.014221191, 0.03125, -0.024841309, 0.009590149, 0.00024724007, -0.0048599243, -0.02079773, -0.010688782, 0.020523071, 0.0021076202, -0.049743652, -0.01423645, -0.009315491, 0.018432617, -0.0016069412, 0.009544373, 0.021820068, 0.0155181885, -0.0134887695, -0.030151367, -0.010604858, 0.042877197, 0.0473938, 0.009506226, 0.022994995, 0.014030457, 0.006336212, 0.105895996, 0.04937744, -0.027053833, 0.040100098, -0.0059509277, 0.030807495, 0.017913818, -0.0069618225, 0.022949219, 0.04071045, 0.056121826, 0.016952515, -0.036346436, 0.0126571655, -0.050231934, -0.030700684, -0.0012664795, -0.045776367, -0.053100586, -0.06488037, -0.013175964, -0.051696777, -0.05706787, -0.0047569275, 0.06524658, -0.0060195923, -0.026992798, 0.03326416, 0.000117480755, -0.025482178, 0.024154663, -0.03881836, -0.00003105402, 0.010437012, 0.049438477, 0.016067505, -0.04498291, -0.05105591, -0.0015468597, -0.0069999695, -0.0068359375, -0.013206482, -0.022979736, 0.02746582, 0.030517578, -0.011184692, 0.024459839, -0.033050537, -0.015686035, -0.074157715, 0.018997192, 0.0027332306, 0.011642456, -0.013916016, 0.030822754, 0.0061569214, 0.0013751984, 0.021438599, 0.08062744, -0.04638672, -0.06768799, 0.039276123, 0.02418518, -0.018600464, 0.02217102, 0.033355713, 0.0017652512, -0.026855469, -0.047332764, -0.049621582, -0.005077362, -0.00080251694, 0.018920898, 0.06384277, -0.037384033, 0.00005310774, -0.015388489, -0.0036067963, 0.012039185, -0.028930664, 0.0154953, -0.031311035, -0.026763916, 0.0004284382, -0.018035889, 0.02720642, -0.025482178, 0.054260254, 0.08331299, 0.023544312, 0.052886963, 0.03942871, 0.036621094, -0.02067566, -0.009460449, 0.0017280579, -0.0033073425, -0.0047302246, 0.03552246, 0.010040283, -0.016189575, -0.004940033, -0.080566406, -0.004261017, 0.046081543, -0.0018892288, -0.023803711, 0.017333984, -0.050354004, -0.010948181, -0.0036411285, -0.022842407, 0.029434204, 0.0066184998, 0.021133423, 0.017990112, 0.021911621, -0.03491211, 0.008018494, -0.056884766, -0.14892578, 0.028121948, -0.0413208, 0.0016040802, -0.003019333, -0.033813477, -0.074035645, -0.0037517548, -0.0070762634, 0.047210693, 0.018356323, 0.01939392, 0.024414062, -0.02217102, -0.0071792603, -0.012428284, -0.008705139, 0.0028209686, -0.033996582, 0.016967773, 0.002588272, 0.02571106, 0.04547119, -0.022705078, -0.025039673, -0.013587952, -0.007785797, 0.018478394, 0.020584106, -0.03643799, -0.02470398, -0.013397217, 0.0041122437, 0.009887695, -0.030319214, 0.00035500526, 0.0031661987, 0.012138367, -0.013183594, 0.001906395, 0.028198242, 0.0013017654, -0.029891968, -0.009048462, 0.026672363, -0.005508423, -0.059906006, -0.0019702911, 0.049835205, 0.02557373, -0.05142212, 0.00995636, -0.016036987, 0.0025463104, 0.030548096, 0.0002925396, 0.00982666, 0.023834229, -0.014808655, 0.01574707, -0.031982422, 0.011413574, -0.018295288, 0.03186035, 0.005783081, 0.009284973, -0.020736694, -0.07513428, -0.0143585205, -0.011680603, -0.115356445, -0.03164673, 0.010040283, -0.026657104, -0.025253296, -0.031951904, 0.03366089, -0.03387451, -0.029281616, 0.011772156, -0.023025513, -0.015205383, -0.003900528, -0.09094238, 0.009010315, 0.083862305, -0.009231567, 0.024124146, 0.01234436, 0.011741638, -0.028823853, -0.03869629, 0.01953125, -0.03817749, 0.009117126, -0.032928467, -0.04296875, 0.018112183, -0.030776978, 0.01361084, 0.025787354, -0.030288696, 0.003862381, 0.01184082, 0.010421753, 0.042388916, -0.025314331, 0.038238525, 0.018661499, -0.033477783, -0.06451416, 0.020477295, -0.021469116, 0.0084991455, 0.0031833649, -0.0064811707, 0.0059509277, -0.002609253, 0.024810791, 0.0368042, -0.019317627, 0.029922485, 0.03881836, -0.0178833, -0.04208374, -0.04989624, 0.01235199, 0.025756836, 0.015533447, 0.004688263, -0.012077332, 0.02079773, 0.016494751, -0.0154800415, -0.021881104, -0.00089788437, -0.027633667, 0.0068893433, -0.061187744, -0.049621582, -0.027496338, 0.016036987, -0.021347046, 0.044311523, 0.042144775, 0.0076828003, -0.009262085, -0.013938904, 0.043548584, -0.005180359, 0.012374878, -0.05166626, -0.00818634, 0.0053863525, -0.038757324, -0.02960205, -0.00920105, 0.0034122467, 0.01626587, -0.008346558, -0.014533997, 0.021499634, 0.018630981, 0.03930664, 0.055633545, -0.011299133, -0.0541687, 0.04321289, -0.026626587, -0.00141716, 0.024902344, 0.022003174, 0.010871887, -0.016036987, 0.010986328, -0.02645874, -0.035858154, -0.023590088, 0.05105591, -0.018630981, 0.06323242, 0.0008506775, 0.04269409, 0.026794434, -0.021652222, 0.0004963875, 0.014968872, -0.03643799, 0.02192688, 0.0051727295, 0.00028681755, -0.0057907104, 0.029556274, 0.053375244, 0.013336182, -0.0055351257, -0.010772705, 0.016418457, 0.005947113, -0.002954483, 0.03463745, -0.0041275024, -0.05029297, -0.019042969, 0.021759033, 0.00705719, 0.06341553, -0.017318726, 0.029205322, -0.041748047, 0.021865845, 0.005218506, -0.022125244, 0.033721924, -0.037628174, 0.039886475, -0.04547119, -0.03503418, 0.0071868896, 0.0284729, -0.02859497, 0.0059509277, -0.021591187, 0.0067329407, 0.025024414, 0.03466797, 0.02128601, -0.012138367, -0.023880005, -0.024154663, -0.013710022, -0.02168274, -0.056274414, -0.010070801, -0.011405945, 0.01574707, -0.013893127, 0.046966553, -0.078125, 0.010848999, -0.009544373, -0.01676941, 0.0006117821, -0.07006836, 0.029708862, 0.06286621, 0.011695862, 0.03768921, 0.0021076202, 0.025634766, 0.03881836, 0.06695557, 0.008857727, 0.021636963, 0.029708862, -0.026275635, -0.0023269653, 0.0017499924, 0.0016498566, -0.013786316, 0.06317139, 0.008659363, 0.028900146, -0.05935669, 0.015586853, 0.044769287, 0.007583618, 0.02571106, -0.05606079, 0.016174316, 0.024932861, 0.004924774, 0.02532959, -0.01424408, -0.041137695, -0.05340576, -0.00014078617, -0.07159424, 0.008666992, 0.004863739, -0.041809082, -0.006702423, 0.010406494, -0.022964478, -0.005207062, 0.039916992, -0.007572174, -0.021011353, 0.05316162, 0.04031372, -0.03527832, 0.00730896, -0.017318726, 0.0049591064, 0.043121338, 0.038330078, -0.013061523, 0.00035572052, -0.023880005, -0.047454834, -0.045074463, -0.0068206787, -0.0018177032, 0.02015686, -0.011421204, -0.02015686, 0.0028076172, 0.017745972, 0.040252686, -0.028823853, -0.029907227, 0.023330688, -0.006164551, -0.011711121, -0.0042419434, 0.036346436, -0.012542725, -0.000053703785, 0.020736694, -0.047058105, 0.04031372, -0.038909912, -0.00013542175, -0.023864746, -0.055358887, 0.021713257, 0.020858765, 0.0021514893, -0.0061149597, 0.03729248, 0.032928467, 0.009346008, 0.012031555, 0.01096344, 0.030654907, -0.030273438, -0.019165039, 0.009147644, 0.011230469, 0.008880615, 0.037750244, 0.00062322617, -0.007549286, -0.029373169, -0.048217773, -0.031051636, 0.012054443, 0.027786255, 0.0017662048, 0.018203735, -0.004310608, 0.029006958, -0.035339355, -0.03048706, -0.046539307, 0.037384033, -0.0015945435, -0.03741455, 0.015548706, -0.02848816, -0.026275635, -0.006374359, 0.018936157, 0.03491211, -0.004573822, 0.025405884, -0.02507019, -0.01436615, -0.03945923, -0.038970947, 0.027923584, 0.02166748, -0.021331787, 0.03326416, -0.012786865, 0.05569458, -0.0066986084, 0.0473938, 0.04727173, 0.013916016, 0.011024475, -0.006324768, 0.0017385483, -0.039123535, 0.008728027, -0.02772522, 0.009536743, -0.032470703, 0.0040397644, -0.07751465, 0.013023376, 0.037506104, 0.034851074, -0.01600647, 0.017608643, 0.018203735, -0.019485474, 0.03353882, -0.037902832, 0.054504395, 0.04748535, 0.007247925, 0.00079393387, -0.011016846, 0.014846802, 0.034179688, 0.01449585, -0.0070228577, 0.007572174, -0.021835327, 0.013038635, 0.008842468, 0.010299683, -0.03881836, -0.0023612976, -0.038360596, 0.027282715, 0.0020561218, 0.049041748, 0.05368042, 0.013427734, 0.0011930466, -0.020553589, -0.0009665489, -0.07470703, -0.030441284, -0.0096206665, 0.0052719116, -0.05947876, 0.038085938, -0.029083252, -0.0058898926, -0.012901306, 0.0036945343, 0.042755127, -0.071777344, -0.060028076, 0.021530151, 0.050689697, 0.01512146, 0.00027036667, -0.04168701, -0.03010559, -0.0006489754, 0.045013428, -0.012954712, 0.01663208, -0.015022278, 0.035583496, -0.010520935, -0.032287598, 0.01789856, -0.029403687, 0.014930725, 0.02444458, -0.007835388, 0.010848999, -0.023788452, -0.033843994, 0.009185791, -0.004261017, -0.04574585, -0.02961731, 0.037963867, 0.02355957, 0.05215454, 0.07696533, 0.050811768, 0.0011396408, -0.015449524, -0.058929443, 0.027770996, 0.015289307, -0.017120361, 0.037628174, -0.043426514, -0.038757324, 0.05078125, -0.05041504, 0.055480957, -0.05130005, 0.0068969727, -0.041900635, 0.07293701, -0.010978699, -0.0670166, -0.02230835, -0.0004453659, -0.013092041, -0.0052261353, 0.005203247, -0.032043457, -0.052734375, 0.00033330917, 0.0440979, -0.012565613, -0.0015001297, 0.006038666, -0.0112838745, -0.0692749, 0.0019350052, -0.034606934, 0.04321289, -0.04776001, 0.004863739, 0.011619568, -0.0041160583, -0.01977539, -0.048828125, -0.021362305, -0.033966064, -0.028457642, -0.045928955, 0.0068969727, 0.006389618, -0.028823853, -0.042785645, -0.024353027, -0.005317688, -0.034118652, 0.029174805, 0.035705566, -0.045043945, -0.02545166, 0.011817932, -0.029006958, 0.049041748, 0.0049591064, -0.018798828, 0.037994385, -0.0012788773, -0.02168274, 0.001783371, 0.030456543, 0.055847168, 0.000934124, -0.07434082, 0.029830933, 0.02861023, 0.05053711, -0.033416748, 0.00027656555, 0.04248047, 0.008720398, -0.011062622, 0.028930664, 0.026229858, 0.0034103394, 0.004211426, 0.017227173, -0.004016876, -0.044830322, -0.014892578, -0.024108887, 0.008346558, 0.04763794, 0.0063438416, 0.006099701, 0.05496216, -0.030960083, 0.0032539368, 0.0037441254, -0.022567749, 0.0041923523, -0.008377075, 0.009864807, -0.02407837, 0.0053901672, -0.041290283, 0.02218628, -0.0034008026, 0.016098022, -0.00793457, 0.016555786, -0.007896423, 0.061462402, -0.015823364, -0.052124023, 0.025543213, 0.025283813, 0.0077590942, 0.022262573, -0.009239197, -0.01637268, -0.032928467, 0.00013291836, 0.010009766, 0.02029419, -0.004623413, -0.02633667, 0.031097412, -0.0317688, -0.032348633, -0.020965576, -0.032165527, 0.041046143, -0.030380249, -0.003326416, -0.030273438, -0.015571594, -0.009346008, 0.034088135, -0.005706787, -0.019683838, -0.056396484, -0.041900635, 0.046539307, -0.02520752 ], "summary": [ -0.04208374, 0.0019836426, -0.072387695, -0.0012245178, -0.029510498, -0.024551392, -0.06842041, -0.02746582, -0.015975952, 0.022918701, -0.017410278, -0.021896362, -0.008979797, -0.037872314, -0.014076233, -0.049194336, -0.025024414, 0.0027103424, -0.033813477, -0.030960083, 0.017166138, -0.051330566, -0.026626587, -0.05645752, 0.034118652, -0.037109375, 0.04840088, 0.024459839, 0.041137695, 0.02015686, 0.021728516, -0.046966553, 0.037139893, 0.013023376, -0.059173584, -0.035980225, -0.023040771, -0.0007996559, -0.055480957, 0.057891846, 0.03491211, -0.022506714, 0.07739258, 0.019714355, -0.008476257, 0.02720642, -0.006450653, -0.04095459, 0.018829346, 0.00090026855, -0.0052223206, 0.019561768, -0.016693115, 0.011566162, -0.008583069, 0.022918701, -0.028579712, -0.0289917, -0.015419006, 0.07757568, 0.06439209, 0.033813477, -0.012496948, 0.009788513, -0.010498047, 0.0065345764, -0.002155304, -0.002483368, 0.02960205, 0.0052337646, 0.0012321472, -0.008338928, 0.04586792, -0.031280518, 0.015930176, 0.015808105, 0.0074768066, 0.037841797, 0.02796936, -0.027770996, 0.016906738, 0.027328491, 0.015045166, -0.05178833, 0.022842407, -0.01876831, -0.009925842, -0.019119263, 0.01335144, -0.037994385, -0.004623413, -0.002090454, -0.040863037, 0.04244995, 0.02331543, -0.064453125, 0.019256592, 0.05178833, -0.028182983, -0.033599854, -0.028701782, 0.022842407, -0.08312988, 0.0011701584, 0.0069351196, 0.045684814, -0.029724121, -0.043060303, 0.0041389465, 0.020233154, -0.0014781952, -0.010040283, 0.017410278, -0.025100708, -0.017044067, 0.003944397, 0.0034828186, 0.039764404, 0.020874023, 0.053527832, -0.009239197, 0.018829346, 0.021240234, 0.041992188, -0.01184082, 0.027114868, -0.0026111603, -0.04776001, -0.051727295, 0.038360596, 0.013084412, 0.03250122, -0.049743652, -0.03692627, -0.072509766, -0.0030574799, -0.04067993, -0.002910614, -0.034606934, -0.000077188015, -0.009780884, 0.0040664673, 0.06738281, -0.021194458, 0.008728027, 0.043670654, 0.05065918, 0.0019397736, -0.04711914, -0.07598877, 0.00071430206, 0.03479004, 0.05331421, -0.06463623, -0.042297363, -0.123046875, -0.068725586, -0.022155762, 0.051849365, -0.045410156, -0.013267517, -0.01109314, -0.013504028, -0.03427124, -0.06439209, 0.002735138, 0.010482788, -0.007484436, 0.006198883, -0.000869751, -0.020980835, 0.00014722347, -0.012458801, 0.019927979, 0.013336182, 0.02748108, -0.04156494, 0.064697266, 0.024993896, -0.05239868, 0.0035324097, -0.03427124, 0.056427002, 0.02154541, 0.0026454926, -0.052764893, 0.024307251, 0.02381897, 0.01763916, 0.032226562, -0.025360107, -0.010437012, -0.002008438, -0.012199402, -0.015541077, 0.01739502, -0.025436401, 0.037017822, -0.027526855, -0.04425049, 0.07904053, 0.0075302124, 0.006427765, -0.054595947, -0.07531738, -0.013076782, 0.0001538992, 0.014312744, -0.013542175, 0.04953003, 0.04333496, 0.029891968, -0.08770752, 0.11993408, 0.019119263, -0.054534912, 0.03805542, -0.058044434, -0.011459351, -0.07946777, -0.008125305, 0.062683105, -0.034606934, 0.07287598, -0.052368164, -0.015571594, -0.011512756, 0.0030117035, -0.0012893677, -0.006416321, 0.06976318, -0.004322052, 0.055145264, 0.08258057, -0.01751709, -0.041778564, -0.033721924, -0.09698486, 0.015022278, 0.06677246, 0.028045654, 0.010467529, -0.023071289, -0.0025081635, 0.008003235, -0.007183075, 0.03289795, -0.025100708, 0.032043457, 0.08117676, -0.02508545, -0.016952515, 0.011329651, -0.04034424, 0.0042762756, 0.04135132, 0.0034236908, -0.0005068779, -0.017333984, -0.001991272, 0.020843506, -0.02848816, -0.047058105, -0.0020427704, 0.007095337, -0.053100586, -0.017532349, -0.031677246, 0.011688232, -0.030029297, 0.017288208, -0.07922363, 0.018630981, -0.01651001, -0.019363403, -0.022354126, -0.017242432, 0.0137786865, 0.021636963, -0.016403198, -0.007270813, -0.019897461, 0.0062789917, 0.0022830963, 0.02798462, -0.008834839, 0.029769897, 0.023147583, -0.025009155, 0.01411438, 0.026809692, -0.021118164, -0.03237915, 0.008934021, 0.014846802, -0.037719727, 0.064086914, 0.00969696, 0.008277893, 0.0025157928, 0.030960083, 0.032196045, -0.022155762, 0.023391724, 0.030029297, 0.03845215, 0.043151855, 0.026916504, 0.019683838, 0.0025615692, -0.02418518, 0.009559631, 0.02281189, -0.010795593, -0.032196045, -0.020004272, -0.04284668, -0.0028705597, -0.06933594, 0.018981934, 0.1026001, -0.00831604, 0.003501892, 0.022155762, -0.017562866, -0.05178833, 0.06628418, -0.024093628, 0.026550293, -0.021316528, -0.0069389343, -0.036376953, -0.051849365, -0.012649536, 0.018218994, 0.0060043335, 0.006641388, -0.0062065125, -0.011154175, -0.024810791, 0.024337769, -0.028762817, -0.00093364716, -0.0016002655, -0.03250122, -0.0048980713, 0.030975342, -0.004688263, 0.023422241, 0.007701874, 0.005264282, -0.0126953125, 0.02859497, 0.039764404, 0.042022705, -0.0541687, -0.055267334, 0.013084412, -0.021453857, -0.040100098, -0.01335907, 0.04168701, -0.012893677, -0.037261963, -0.030395508, -0.027923584, -0.0075683594, 0.0056495667, 0.017471313, 0.005268097, 0.06439209, 0.013587952, -0.033966064, -0.029800415, -0.038085938, -0.049804688, 0.06878662, -0.0067634583, 0.010566711, 0.04107666, 0.027404785, 0.038604736, 0.002817154, 0.014801025, 0.04336548, 0.045440674, 0.038391113, 0.045135498, 0.002166748, -0.033477783, -0.019989014, 0.033721924, 0.002231598, -0.0141067505, 0.003616333, -0.00207901, -0.013450623, 0.011138916, -0.027832031, -0.000044047832, 0.014961243, 0.017578125, 0.042022705, -0.018554688, -0.026184082, 0.0063476562, -0.026245117, -0.0014629364, 0.013221741, -0.048034668, 0.02420044, -0.0030136108, 0.011299133, -0.016098022, 0.004627228, -0.06274414, -0.021438599, 0.0017108917, -0.01461792, -0.0047912598, 0.004470825, 0.0099105835, -0.0021896362, 0.0017843246, 0.0014925003, 0.027130127, 0.007820129, 0.0033893585, 0.008583069, 0.0036296844, 0.014724731, -0.028900146, 0.009529114, 0.01247406, -0.042297363, 0.0072631836, -0.014564514, 0.0061187744, 0.022338867, -0.050231934, -0.022705078, -0.008361816, -0.028701782, -0.009239197, -0.0003464222, -0.016952515, -0.004825592, -0.018066406, 0.029510498, 0.023742676, -0.020004272, -0.004016876, 0.0345459, 0.02168274, -0.030181885, 0.003774643, -0.040893555, 0.026367188, 0.022766113, -0.008407593, 0.018722534, -0.0046958923, -0.016464233, 0.009635925, 0.054107666, 0.03955078, -0.06060791, 0.06286621, 0.03591919, -0.037597656, 0.09265137, -0.046325684, 0.0010175705, -0.0029830933, 0.025665283, -0.00907135, -0.023254395, 0.0065193176, 0.007675171, 0.016860962, -0.009407043, 0.008743286, -0.014968872, -0.053466797, -0.009819031, -0.009468079, -0.06463623, -0.034240723, 0.01197052, -0.0027503967, -0.04800415, -0.01436615, 0.037231445, -0.021133423, -0.0061531067, 0.041412354, -0.04486084, 0.059295654, 0.008956909, -0.0993042, 0.064819336, -0.008216858, -0.0077819824, 0.04510498, -0.0076789856, 0.03173828, 0.015975952, -0.027862549, 0.013938904, -0.021408081, 0.007247925, -0.045135498, -0.05795288, -0.010864258, -0.016143799, 0.015380859, 0.053497314, -0.045654297, 0.04348755, -0.0046081543, 0.045684814, 0.059417725, -0.036010742, 0.007408142, 0.048034668, -0.027755737, -0.037628174, 0.018844604, -0.029891968, -0.004886627, 0.024658203, 0.008476257, -0.018585205, 0.0034885406, 0.039367676, 0.012802124, -0.035491943, -0.00012421608, 0.011787415, -0.0021152496, -0.055114746, -0.04647827, 0.011375427, 0.036102295, 0.0079193115, -0.019485474, -0.027191162, 0.007686615, -0.0011510849, 0.012397766, -0.0418396, -0.04397583, -0.01651001, -0.01348114, -0.025863647, -0.036590576, -0.044769287, 0.025512695, 0.0053710938, 0.026657104, 0.029037476, -0.012046814, 0.004627228, -0.009399414, -0.007194519, 0.019866943, -0.048461914, -0.097351074, 0.010322571, -0.025665283, -0.021484375, -0.04360962, -0.027450562, 0.006340027, -0.028625488, 0.01838684, 0.0115737915, 0.007171631, -0.007534027, -0.026351929, -0.032165527, 0.03564453, 0.0463562, 0.03173828, -0.026519775, 0.04373169, -0.007896423, 0.027618408, -0.014762878, 0.020599365, 0.014251709, -0.020736694, -0.03970337, -0.038146973, 0.008636475, 0.036499023, -0.0031871796, 0.03375244, 0.047210693, 0.021102905, -0.031311035, 0.000374794, 0.014518738, -0.0023822784, 0.028839111, 0.02255249, -0.05508423, 0.046447754, 0.014038086, 0.016708374, -0.013046265, -0.016860962, -0.015510559, 0.01524353, -0.02986145, 0.0050201416, 0.013633728, -0.0028247833, 0.013694763, 0.013183594, 0.039276123, -0.017333984, 0.034240723, 0.034179688, -0.029785156, -0.04446411, 0.019088745, -0.0009174347, -0.0112838745, 0.016830444, 0.010131836, 0.00920105, -0.020111084, -0.041137695, 0.0006380081, 0.031555176, 0.0018024445, -0.019927979, -0.025436401, -0.0020198822, 0.021743774, 0.017852783, -0.01991272, -0.055786133, 0.03543091, -0.024490356, -0.026138306, 0.0056152344, -0.026184082, -0.0079956055, 0.02015686, 0.0129852295, 0.0038700104, -0.026168823, 0.01033783, -0.03189087, -0.019622803, 0.013191223, -0.003063202, -0.009635925, 0.00022506714, 0.042633057, -0.013908386, 0.02279663, 0.05935669, 0.0020217896, -0.0057373047, 0.024627686, -0.021331787, 0.019332886, -0.030593872, 0.018005371, 0.008094788, -0.017547607, -0.0024051666, 0.031219482, 0.066833496, 0.011299133, 0.05239868, -0.04824829, -0.008132935, -0.017944336, 0.011672974, 0.014328003, -0.027877808, 0.03970337, -0.017028809, -0.001991272, 0.00067329407, 0.04623413, -0.07080078, -0.06750488, 0.021392822, -0.04852295, -0.023391724, -0.018463135, -0.016235352, 0.012756348, -0.0023841858, -0.04208374, 0.0010986328, 0.04611206, -0.019760132, 0.008605957, 0.023468018, 0.016494751, 0.0017337799, -0.011489868, 0.011001587, -0.0059280396, -0.013954163, 0.033599854, -0.009605408, -0.014198303, -0.0073547363, -0.020736694, -0.00023281574, -0.014625549, -0.014816284, 0.042541504, 0.0024852753, 0.0021095276, 0.016616821, 0.012741089, 0.038208008, -0.016342163, -0.02670288, 0.019607544, -0.02973938, -0.031585693, 0.031021118, 0.03366089, -0.028961182, -0.00598526, 0.021560669, -0.062042236, 0.026733398, 0.00042510033, 0.008987427, -0.04119873, -0.0357666, -0.007610321, 0.036834717, -0.0052452087, -0.000081181526, 0.0546875, 0.020019531, -0.0058250427, 0.02067566, 0.021102905, 0.018844604, -0.023376465, -0.05117798, -0.014907837, 0.028656006, -0.016983032, -0.0009531975, 0.007209778, -0.031951904, 0.011375427, -0.03173828, -0.008102417, -0.020599365, 0.023757935, -0.029647827, -0.00022315979, 0.0073242188, 0.033203125, 0.022232056, -0.019424438, -0.03100586, 0.0015058517, -0.010635376, 0.0010156631, 0.041656494, 0.012901306, -0.04296875, 0.024017334, -0.004447937, 0.044647217, 0.0046157837, 0.047851562, 0.013999939, -0.018814087, -0.02027893, -0.0044555664, 0.037017822, 0.026885986, -0.031677246, 0.021087646, 0.019851685, 0.045166016, 0.012245178, 0.015945435, 0.0059127808, 0.015563965, 0.02293396, -0.0021629333, 0.010284424, -0.0031223297, 0.052246094, 0.0025863647, 0.002670288, -0.0023994446, -0.016448975, -0.030151367, 0.04309082, 0.033447266, 0.004535675, 0.023284912, 0.013420105, 0.03643799, -0.022949219, -0.016937256, -0.048461914, 0.02420044, 0.025650024, -0.0063056946, 0.04510498, -0.027526855, -0.0033092499, 0.038146973, -0.00712204, 0.014419556, 0.019699097, 0.021987915, 0.013320923, -0.028656006, -0.021820068, -0.059051514, 0.042419434, -0.027893066, 0.060913086, 0.040222168, 0.07897949, 0.011856079, -0.02355957, 0.039916992, -0.031204224, -0.023452759, -0.020233154, -0.008148193, 0.0011196136, 0.0066452026, -0.03387451, 0.009178162, -0.0054397583, -0.018447876, 0.037475586, -0.004070282, 0.04449463, -0.05996704, -0.06188965, -0.003742218, 0.036315918, 0.017196655, -0.013259888, -0.045074463, -0.019332886, -0.031402588, -0.012672424, 0.014923096, -0.021636963, -0.024627686, 0.04196167, 0.04272461, -0.02947998, 0.029083252, -0.062438965, 0.048858643, 0.048583984, 0.04208374, -0.0054130554, -0.008277893, -0.020996094, 0.017288208, 0.018707275, -0.011924744, 0.0077171326, 0.018600464, 0.025238037, 0.058898926, 0.04727173, 0.007648468, 0.02494812, 0.029220581, -0.027450562, -0.015304565, -0.005832672, 0.021026611, 0.029647827, -0.029373169, 0.0035762787, 0.021133423, 0.01335907, 0.074157715, -0.061279297, 0.02949524, -0.0473938, 0.048339844, -0.09918213, -0.023162842, 0.03289795, -0.032165527, -0.005973816, 0.00907135, 0.031234741, -0.023086548, -0.008766174, -0.011581421, 0.013442993, -0.006641388, -0.018356323, 0.012557983, 0.0184021, -0.030853271, -0.014266968, -0.0064582825, 0.029907227, -0.030166626, -0.029678345, 0.060058594, -0.012954712, 0.0178833, -0.03286743, -0.054626465, -0.00021529198, 0.03488159, -0.013847351, 0.0058250427, 0.0095825195, -0.020812988, -0.07086182, 0.02746582, -0.00592041, -0.037200928, 0.041259766, 0.04449463, -0.008010864, -0.0552063, 0.005996704, -0.017089844, 0.031463623, -0.014083862, -0.021514893, 0.09576416, -0.014389038, -0.02607727, 0.017196655, -0.008003235, -0.0017433167, 0.021881104, -0.022918701, -0.016326904, 0.009002686, 0.026855469, -0.017608643, -0.0178833, 0.022720337, 0.015205383, -0.026443481, -0.025360107, 0.0065727234, -0.014022827, 0.053527832, 0.0031490326, 0.0034675598, -0.018356323, 0.037017822, 0.028701782, 0.033996582, 0.008552551, -0.04837036, 0.048431396, 0.020889282, -0.06149292, -0.0102005005, 0.0027675629, -0.014915466, -0.015701294, -0.0008125305, 0.015068054, -0.028518677, 0.03463745, -0.001335144, 0.018676758, -0.022262573, -0.018112183, -0.0135650635, 0.0034008026, -0.029708862, -0.0151901245, -0.033172607, 0.014801025, -0.0030975342, -0.024215698, 0.016845703, -0.019897461, 0.03604126, 0.033416748, -0.010498047, -0.017913818, 0.0035114288, -0.0071029663, 0.024551392, -0.032928467, 0.0014467239, -0.031677246, -0.005290985, -0.021972656, -0.038604736, 0.037200928, 0.0137786865, -0.009155273, 0.05340576, -0.008346558, 0.022842407, 0.022384644, 0.013694763, 0.008888245, 0.0037136078, -0.0024547577, -0.004814148, 0.00340271 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06696v1
Simple and Effective Input Reformulations for Translation
Brian Yu, Hansen Lillemark, Kurt Keutzer
cs.CL, cs.LG
Foundation language models learn from their finetuning input context in different ways. In this paper, we reformulate inputs during finetuning for challenging translation tasks, leveraging model strengths from pretraining in novel ways to improve downstream performance. These reformulations are simple data level modifications, require no additional collection of training data or modification of data at inference time. They can be applied either on single language pair translation tasks or massively multilingual translation tasks. Experiments with these techniques demonstrate significant performance improvements up to $\textbf{3.5 chrF++ on the Flores200 translation benchmark}$. We hope our research accessibly improves finetuning data efficiency, enabling more effective training to scalably improve state-of-the-art performance. Our code is released $\href{https://github.com/bri25yu/LanguageModelExperimentation}{here}.$
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06696v1
2023-11-12T00:23:37
2023-11-12T00:23:37
{ "title": [ -0.012191772, -0.0024547577, 0.006729126, -0.05392456, -0.031982422, 0.004306793, -0.06793213, -0.022476196, -0.011657715, 0.05529785, 0.017547607, -0.006477356, 0.0138168335, -0.044555664, -0.031311035, 0.023452759, 0.017044067, -0.016189575, -0.061950684, -0.050994873, -0.010940552, -0.05407715, 0.0074806213, 0.008850098, 0.011054993, -0.046295166, -0.068481445, -0.008583069, -0.045532227, -0.048461914, -0.007537842, 0.07232666, 0.04171753, -0.014183044, -0.009803772, 0.001493454, -0.05456543, 0.007610321, -0.024093628, -0.018096924, 0.032470703, -0.019622803, -0.02267456, -0.055236816, -0.031036377, 0.015007019, 0.013374329, 0.028503418, -0.008018494, -0.002632141, -0.003993988, -0.005794525, 0.010192871, 0.038604736, -0.011146545, -0.04748535, -0.050231934, -0.027450562, 0.020141602, 0.06762695, 0.027282715, -0.015838623, 0.024017334, -0.03161621, 0.028152466, -0.016586304, -0.03744507, 0.040405273, 0.03579712, 0.026000977, -0.029769897, -0.019836426, -0.006778717, -0.024337769, 0.010223389, 0.025009155, -0.029052734, 0.016998291, 0.035888672, -0.0022087097, 0.0007982254, 0.012001038, 0.012687683, -0.06726074, 0.022384644, -0.06878662, -0.0060424805, -0.00065898895, -0.045288086, -0.08935547, -0.026443481, 0.0018672943, -0.054504395, -0.0038452148, -0.038146973, -0.04031372, 0.0020885468, -0.025665283, 0.024032593, -0.0128479, -0.040863037, 0.0025844574, -0.0073242188, -0.012428284, 0.030807495, 0.022216797, 0.0020008087, 0.017578125, 0.036987305, 0.03491211, -0.013420105, 0.06488037, 0.018829346, 0.010520935, 0.008178711, -0.008460999, -0.011131287, 0.02848816, -0.007789612, 0.033203125, -0.019821167, -0.027038574, 0.042053223, 0.0016822815, 0.014823914, 0.0034332275, -0.044769287, -0.0024299622, 0.025131226, 0.010818481, -0.014022827, 0.036193848, -0.045837402, -0.060394287, -0.019256592, 0.0031833649, -0.024749756, -0.018707275, -0.029525757, 0.009521484, 0.0124053955, -0.033081055, 0.011062622, -0.0079422, 0.004798889, 0.015213013, 0.044403076, -0.01234436, -0.026657104, -0.050598145, -0.019882202, -0.0017957687, 0.009300232, 0.01676941, -0.03753662, -0.0018053055, -0.087524414, -0.010559082, 0.030853271, 0.01146698, 0.0034828186, 0.004501343, 0.0060539246, -0.031158447, 0.0014181137, 0.0053215027, 0.0029182434, 0.015899658, -0.0015039444, 0.052734375, -0.005718231, 0.018447876, -0.0006303787, -0.025100708, -0.0146865845, -0.02420044, -0.009597778, 0.0018806458, 0.008483887, 0.037506104, 0.05935669, -0.009483337, -0.02947998, 0.068481445, -0.04647827, -0.044921875, -0.0053710938, -0.01940918, 0.06921387, 0.018585205, -0.042877197, 0.025054932, -0.04147339, -0.021697998, -0.026687622, 0.020263672, 0.0069351196, 0.049224854, 0.0007624626, -0.012466431, -0.0385437, 0.032287598, -0.02116394, 0.011528015, 0.022247314, -0.015388489, 0.0022335052, 0.005214691, 0.0018968582, 0.031707764, 0.05001831, 0.00092983246, -0.017715454, -0.009361267, -0.03552246, -0.025344849, 0.011108398, -0.0099105835, -0.012359619, -0.034576416, 0.031143188, -0.0390625, 0.00868988, 0.08068848, 0.018295288, 0.027938843, -0.020050049, -0.0015926361, 0.052093506, 0.01939392, 0.09313965, 0.0073890686, 0.052856445, 0.012908936, -0.058441162, -0.027709961, -0.007095337, 0.0028934479, -0.009231567, 0.04006958, 0.0135269165, -0.037353516, -0.004798889, 0.010360718, 0.016098022, -0.015594482, 0.0141067505, 0.0019607544, 0.026184082, 0.028549194, 0.051330566, -0.040008545, 0.038482666, -0.049957275, 0.012969971, 0.058685303, -0.009277344, -0.0040245056, -0.015777588, 0.016693115, 0.0003402233, -0.015701294, 0.008422852, -0.0017633438, -0.015838623, 0.0098724365, -0.0034713745, 0.035308838, -0.020736694, 0.013763428, 0.011726379, 0.0019836426, 0.011268616, -0.012451172, -0.072509766, -0.018859863, -0.009132385, 0.04006958, 0.001663208, -0.05633545, -0.02027893, 0.034576416, 0.0635376, 0.0019989014, -0.0107421875, 0.0619812, 0.037109375, -0.013664246, -0.00024366379, -0.0024929047, 0.053375244, 0.023925781, 0.016021729, 0.009399414, 0.05014038, 0.002483368, 0.08959961, 0.029891968, -0.03741455, 0.029907227, -0.024795532, 0.013580322, 0.05090332, -0.035827637, -0.003643036, 0.032714844, 0.007068634, 0.0064582825, -0.004207611, -0.010429382, -0.040802002, 0.017227173, -0.020141602, -0.012123108, -0.07196045, -0.070739746, -0.026351929, -0.056549072, -0.07128906, 0.006351471, 0.011505127, -0.011169434, -0.066833496, 0.005908966, -0.0054473877, 0.009529114, -0.002708435, -0.014862061, 0.025115967, 0.0042381287, 0.032073975, 0.0021209717, -0.068603516, -0.07684326, 0.018295288, 0.011146545, 0.006767273, -0.030288696, -0.012908936, 0.026779175, 0.037139893, -0.029129028, 0.012207031, -0.03439331, 0.039978027, -0.036254883, -0.004798889, 0.0076560974, 0.004634857, 0.010688782, -0.0032749176, -0.002521515, 0.0104904175, 0.008094788, 0.07116699, -0.041534424, -0.03616333, 0.028549194, 0.035614014, -0.016555786, 0.043029785, 0.040618896, 0.03302002, -0.050811768, -0.021209717, -0.07086182, -0.027267456, 0.0006761551, -0.00068473816, 0.03842163, -0.01727295, -0.0018978119, -0.023757935, 0.0025081635, -0.020309448, -0.017196655, 0.032989502, -0.023269653, -0.054534912, -0.014450073, 0.026290894, 0.01576233, -0.008216858, -0.0058288574, 0.025115967, 0.025894165, 0.013374329, 0.017486572, 0.0046195984, -0.0024261475, -0.0076560974, 0.015548706, -0.0095825195, -0.018676758, 0.014701843, 0.019622803, -0.019226074, -0.014732361, -0.051086426, 0.004962921, 0.0791626, -0.02758789, -0.034576416, 0.007045746, -0.04296875, -0.018051147, -0.00020134449, -0.0032978058, 0.01828003, 0.060668945, 0.009963989, 0.014450073, 0.036987305, -0.02180481, 0.008804321, -0.015434265, -0.08911133, 0.034729004, -0.023666382, -0.018508911, 0.026916504, -0.054718018, -0.0035762787, 0.009864807, -0.040283203, 0.05569458, 0.025375366, 0.039031982, 0.03173828, -0.05441284, 0.0012645721, -0.024978638, -0.01210022, 0.010276794, 0.007255554, 0.040222168, -0.007419586, 0.038116455, 0.05239868, -0.016540527, -0.05444336, -0.012886047, -0.022644043, -0.008598328, -0.0069084167, -0.024002075, -0.015930176, -0.022216797, 0.012184143, 0.035186768, -0.0007324219, 0.011253357, -0.038085938, 0.000080525875, -0.045684814, 0.025161743, -0.013496399, 0.016586304, 0.006259918, 0.0014533997, 0.0064849854, -0.030014038, -0.012199402, 0.006614685, -0.01335144, 0.02267456, 0.009895325, 0.004737854, -0.008102417, -0.021347046, -0.029159546, 0.031341553, 0.0054893494, 0.00655365, 0.007648468, -0.0064811707, -0.04244995, 0.008354187, -0.032440186, 0.0011167526, -0.02268982, 0.020050049, 0.04522705, -0.06878662, -0.029418945, 0.02796936, -0.072387695, -0.01826477, 0.03086853, 0.017181396, -0.029556274, -0.013931274, 0.040802002, -0.04333496, -0.034454346, 0.019561768, -0.0060272217, -0.0138549805, -0.0082473755, -0.07904053, -0.068237305, 0.061920166, -0.011329651, 0.016693115, 0.0625, -0.062927246, -0.039367676, 0.009780884, 0.040252686, 0.04525757, 0.057250977, 0.017974854, -0.02305603, -0.0073432922, -0.030944824, 0.02015686, -0.009178162, -0.034973145, -0.011619568, 0.031051636, 0.0149002075, 0.04788208, -0.011688232, 0.052856445, 0.026824951, -0.053955078, -0.031951904, 0.0071983337, -0.03753662, -0.03302002, 0.013542175, -0.021347046, 0.011833191, 0.0066108704, 0.011306763, 0.064331055, -0.009231567, -0.005935669, 0.0072250366, -0.03363037, 0.0061531067, -0.007888794, -0.029724121, -0.00012528896, 0.022888184, -0.05697632, -0.005367279, 0.03338623, 0.017410278, 0.011795044, -0.008293152, -0.007331848, -0.01838684, -0.0131073, -0.048614502, -0.020355225, -0.029571533, 0.020202637, -0.030044556, 0.027130127, 0.033477783, -0.024536133, -0.039855957, 0.03338623, -0.016662598, -0.009849548, 0.023529053, -0.037628174, -0.02720642, -0.020263672, -0.05758667, -0.033843994, -0.03665161, -0.010322571, -0.0047569275, 0.017028809, -0.049621582, 0.017440796, 0.018295288, 0.046813965, 0.0395813, 0.017929077, -0.042541504, 0.05819702, -0.02986145, -0.018447876, 0.021408081, -0.017944336, -0.026168823, -0.02809143, 0.013130188, -0.01084137, -0.020111084, -0.019866943, 0.02558899, -0.026473999, 0.08123779, 0.0000061392784, 0.010765076, 0.0076179504, -0.022155762, -0.009101868, -0.009002686, -0.041259766, 0.07647705, 0.028335571, 0.026824951, -0.022583008, -0.001420021, 0.04019165, 0.04522705, 0.008010864, -0.037261963, 0.020446777, 0.0027008057, 0.0039100647, -0.0009794235, 0.036468506, -0.007659912, -0.03967285, 0.0071640015, -0.0009264946, 0.03137207, -0.03567505, -0.00566864, -0.006542206, 0.06097412, 0.004398346, -0.038909912, 0.040893555, -0.019714355, 0.04095459, -0.037872314, 0.032409668, 0.028289795, -0.016357422, -0.039093018, -0.011566162, -0.026687622, 0.017074585, 0.015022278, 0.04107666, 0.023040771, -0.035736084, 0.0023880005, -0.03604126, -0.01826477, -0.009498596, -0.028671265, -0.0011482239, 0.016571045, 0.022644043, 0.00459671, 0.0012655258, -0.030929565, 0.002735138, -0.0025959015, 0.0149002075, 0.0015268326, -0.046142578, 0.042755127, 0.076171875, 0.022415161, 0.020935059, -0.017623901, -0.004180908, 0.010726929, 0.057769775, -0.017486572, 0.00075769424, 0.045410156, -0.03704834, 0.0012159348, -0.03024292, 0.004333496, -0.03845215, 0.053894043, -0.014709473, 0.037231445, -0.07165527, -0.020248413, 0.012924194, 0.053619385, 0.01576233, -0.06903076, -0.0022888184, -0.0010032654, 0.009124756, 0.010971069, -0.06793213, -0.068115234, -0.018615723, -0.038909912, -0.06488037, 0.023513794, -0.009605408, -0.053588867, 0.020233154, 0.07727051, 0.022781372, -0.004261017, 0.010467529, -0.0017356873, -0.034606934, 0.020767212, 0.008354187, -0.049835205, 0.008506775, 0.000521183, 0.027770996, 0.034851074, 0.0140686035, -0.023086548, 0.0021800995, -0.008476257, -0.005821228, 0.02381897, 0.022369385, 0.013786316, -0.008850098, -0.01222229, -0.011291504, -0.008522034, -0.025527954, 0.01361084, 0.0016241074, -0.035247803, 0.0131073, -0.016220093, -0.003572464, -0.017166138, -0.012359619, -0.026611328, 0.00579834, 0.02645874, -0.023452759, 0.028182983, -0.0034503937, -0.014389038, 0.00017380714, -0.05404663, 0.016815186, -0.0031089783, -0.013458252, 0.01600647, 0.05026245, 0.023864746, 0.066711426, -0.015380859, 0.024032593, 0.059509277, -0.011917114, -0.041931152, -0.020233154, -0.023361206, -0.026855469, 0.06274414, 0.03100586, -0.018630981, -0.0181427, -0.06011963, -0.033111572, -0.0013246536, 0.046295166, -0.015258789, 0.0146865845, -0.07751465, -0.030319214, 0.02494812, -0.0009417534, -0.039245605, 0.042999268, -0.010665894, -0.02230835, 0.017623901, 0.0054512024, -0.022628784, -0.0027809143, 0.05078125, 0.04824829, -0.01360321, 0.033599854, 0.0104522705, -0.034454346, -0.025558472, -0.032043457, 0.045959473, 0.030593872, -0.027374268, 0.044281006, -0.0054893494, 0.055847168, 0.00894928, 0.02017212, 0.029846191, -0.0021648407, -0.027648926, 0.011444092, 0.008392334, -0.018249512, -0.003124237, -0.05819702, -0.0099487305, -0.033691406, 0.0046920776, -0.09625244, -0.01638794, 0.025405884, 0.032440186, -0.011222839, 0.0030612946, -0.015930176, -0.032043457, -0.0029525757, 0.021606445, 0.04574585, -0.00020003319, -0.0066986084, -0.014717102, -0.0362854, 0.028442383, 0.033599854, -0.002664566, 0.0048828125, -0.029968262, -0.029907227, 0.016860962, -0.026947021, 0.03314209, -0.0158844, -0.021835327, -0.02671814, -0.0000243783, 0.002714157, 0.03173828, 0.02154541, -0.011039734, 0.009208679, -0.000052273273, -0.022659302, -0.023925781, -0.05142212, 0.010620117, 0.032409668, -0.0892334, 0.040252686, -0.036132812, -0.033416748, -0.018966675, 0.015136719, 0.028198242, -0.014320374, -0.00843811, 0.011367798, 0.024978638, 0.011749268, 0.046783447, -0.015586853, -0.040893555, 0.008995056, 0.034454346, -0.017410278, 0.015945435, -0.008300781, 0.04321289, -0.009216309, -0.010520935, 0.010368347, -0.027709961, -0.0099105835, 0.020339966, -0.008094788, 0.04888916, -0.0009331703, -0.036010742, 0.020507812, 0.012229919, -0.029083252, 0.0024471283, 0.014976501, 0.008224487, 0.004371643, 0.02229309, 0.03250122, -0.032104492, -0.018096924, -0.042266846, 0.014411926, 0.03491211, -0.034729004, 0.016052246, -0.049987793, -0.045654297, 0.01965332, -0.103759766, 0.020370483, -0.0035991669, -0.030090332, -0.06842041, 0.07312012, -0.014381409, -0.043945312, -0.06536865, -0.044189453, -0.040222168, -0.007335663, 0.00025057793, -0.022201538, -0.032684326, -0.028213501, 0.04348755, -0.018585205, 0.019180298, 0.055023193, -0.04031372, -0.06945801, 0.08135986, 0.014533997, 0.07720947, -0.023666382, -0.0029067993, 0.0051078796, -0.019989014, 0.0048446655, -0.038879395, -0.021133423, -0.053009033, -0.028442383, -0.053649902, -0.0027713776, -0.031143188, -0.0317688, -0.019378662, -0.017684937, 0.010131836, -0.023071289, -0.0048446655, 0.0037326813, -0.028289795, -0.008392334, -0.005264282, -0.028427124, 0.027130127, 0.022445679, -0.033599854, 0.054229736, -0.010055542, -0.04095459, 0.009178162, 0.005378723, 0.03704834, 0.0068473816, -0.022033691, 0.027770996, 0.005836487, 0.055480957, -0.05822754, -0.03543091, -0.011161804, 0.046539307, -0.023010254, 0.066223145, 0.0178833, 0.014556885, -0.026611328, 0.030380249, -0.02709961, -0.015945435, 0.031829834, 0.024917603, 0.010765076, 0.0256958, -0.021972656, 0.0082473755, -0.00042414665, -0.00737381, 0.005844116, -0.013893127, -0.03213501, 0.023727417, -0.010032654, 0.01776123, 0.0016946793, 0.023361206, -0.061157227, 0.06048584, -0.018295288, 0.0063819885, -0.019363403, 0.04034424, 0.0020618439, 0.028213501, -0.04257202, -0.0035514832, 0.018432617, 0.034301758, -0.013191223, 0.023208618, 0.013839722, 0.018829346, -0.011947632, 0.011833191, 0.046142578, 0.015777588, -0.020263672, 0.024246216, 0.037384033, -0.06304932, -0.031188965, -0.06021118, -0.057403564, 0.042297363, -0.018981934, -0.012229919, 0.016830444, -0.03286743, 0.014831543, -0.007926941, 0.019714355, -0.002544403, -0.05065918, -0.0473938, 0.0038833618, -0.021835327 ], "summary": [ -0.022766113, -0.025512695, -0.022491455, -0.0546875, -0.04901123, 0.017944336, -0.0925293, 0.0068206787, 0.010643005, 0.05633545, -0.003698349, 0.01374054, 0.021514893, -0.009025574, -0.032928467, 0.004840851, -0.005329132, 0.0043258667, -0.024627686, -0.029067993, 0.019958496, -0.049194336, -0.026229858, -0.00459671, 0.01361084, -0.020828247, -0.083618164, 0.022445679, -0.024398804, 0.005596161, -0.0023231506, 0.021865845, 0.037109375, 0.0030937195, -0.044708252, -0.042755127, -0.022979736, -0.0051231384, -0.025314331, 0.02507019, 0.036193848, -0.021560669, 0.020812988, 0.0065994263, -0.016036987, 0.013473511, 0.018737793, -0.028259277, 0.0143966675, 0.032836914, 0.00096702576, -0.008964539, -0.00089883804, 0.0061073303, -0.034698486, -0.05380249, -0.060577393, 0.017074585, 0.01991272, 0.100097656, 0.024490356, 0.001168251, -0.027740479, -0.074035645, -0.0077590942, 0.0062446594, -0.033813477, 0.013793945, 0.050750732, 0.00023722649, -0.01626587, -0.0019130707, 0.022506714, -0.027191162, -0.03213501, -0.017425537, 0.009857178, -0.009628296, 0.024780273, -0.03213501, 0.04876709, 0.011314392, 0.03125, -0.0027618408, -0.024734497, -0.05834961, 0.012504578, 0.006427765, -0.028335571, -0.040252686, -0.01826477, -0.052642822, -0.030776978, 0.02557373, -0.0101623535, -0.023727417, -0.01939392, -0.06756592, 0.03048706, 0.0030403137, 0.021026611, -0.02885437, 0.01701355, 0.017593384, 0.015426636, -0.009262085, 0.0146102905, 0.018066406, 0.030731201, 0.015792847, -0.023422241, 0.09399414, -0.009422302, -0.058807373, -0.0143966675, 0.037017822, 0.012428284, 0.015586853, 0.030929565, 0.012046814, -0.012565613, -0.005760193, 0.015342712, 0.057250977, 0.01637268, 0.033355713, -0.0040016174, -0.00063991547, 0.03488159, 0.0496521, -0.02508545, -0.0062789917, 0.0014915466, -0.027130127, -0.017089844, -0.033294678, 0.028747559, 0.005683899, -0.02772522, 0.017669678, 0.011100769, -0.0073547363, -0.023513794, -0.018844604, 0.009117126, 0.025848389, 0.031341553, -0.01939392, -0.026794434, -0.032684326, 0.000119924545, -0.030212402, 0.020629883, -0.0047569275, -0.017349243, -0.031585693, -0.051574707, -0.00365448, 0.009559631, 0.0033798218, 0.02897644, 0.00043320656, 0.0015115738, -0.0023403168, -0.046691895, 0.0019550323, -0.010307312, -0.022735596, 0.0025405884, -0.00037264824, -0.012741089, 0.0020503998, -0.016647339, -0.0024051666, -0.008979797, -0.015571594, -0.0004389286, 0.03125, -0.009544373, 0.03741455, 0.033203125, -0.025756836, 0.021820068, 0.03173828, -0.00015735626, -0.052947998, -0.021591187, -0.04611206, 0.09020996, -0.0015859604, -0.05496216, -0.04421997, -0.04159546, 0.020568848, -0.011444092, 0.031982422, -0.0033779144, 0.07147217, -0.017074585, -0.07159424, 0.049621582, 0.022216797, -0.026947021, -0.026824951, -0.0970459, 0.009742737, -0.02180481, 0.037475586, -0.0054779053, -0.0033893585, 0.027542114, 0.0065841675, -0.022369385, -0.0048980713, -0.02659607, 0.004638672, 0.038757324, -0.013763428, 0.02104187, -0.04434204, 0.054992676, 0.010032654, 0.024368286, 0.09472656, -0.04928589, 0.02418518, 0.0026779175, 0.043823242, 0.013954163, 0.0076675415, 0.09063721, -0.027832031, 0.053985596, 0.023101807, -0.040100098, -0.011657715, 0.015029907, -0.010002136, 0.004600525, 0.033081055, 0.01889038, -0.0070495605, -0.037902832, -0.005088806, -0.00013613701, 0.012878418, 0.019836426, -0.009178162, 0.02468872, 0.05517578, -0.016174316, -0.0118637085, 0.008766174, -0.07147217, 0.011291504, 0.029525757, -0.012489319, -0.059753418, -0.0003838539, -0.024505615, 0.03555298, -0.032989502, -0.06500244, 0.019989014, 0.017349243, -0.012634277, 0.0032253265, 0.0018558502, -0.044158936, 0.007511139, 0.024459839, -0.0079574585, -0.0060920715, -0.044647217, -0.09625244, 0.007293701, -0.018066406, 0.056488037, 0.012039185, -0.044128418, 0.023376465, 0.08105469, 0.042236328, -0.018859863, 0.00032877922, 0.050598145, -0.0026874542, -0.014518738, 0.010055542, 0.046936035, 0.048736572, 0.009780884, -0.0029907227, -0.009284973, 0.051116943, -0.013916016, 0.05441284, 0.0007214546, -0.0038261414, -0.008964539, 0.00983429, 0.045288086, 0.024017334, -0.034057617, 0.010299683, -0.0025501251, 0.006275177, 0.0138168335, 0.009819031, 0.0033054352, -0.053100586, 0.0049591064, 0.016845703, 0.11047363, -0.079711914, -0.06896973, -0.0141067505, 0.022857666, -0.017089844, 0.0141067505, 0.0074539185, 0.009086609, 0.015174866, 0.029708862, 0.017227173, -0.021057129, 0.0519104, 0.0031833649, 0.061920166, 0.022628784, -0.013832092, 0.009544373, -0.04940796, -0.059387207, -0.007587433, -0.012390137, 0.028381348, -0.028717041, -0.0072517395, 0.042144775, 0.059570312, -0.018829346, 0.007598877, -0.03479004, -0.027633667, -0.04067993, -0.0044403076, -0.002943039, 0.061065674, 0.00756073, -0.0020809174, 0.014762878, 0.0028457642, 0.032562256, 0.01852417, -0.030273438, -0.013290405, 0.012542725, -0.03164673, -0.048065186, 0.014953613, 0.037109375, -0.0017366409, -0.07299805, -0.0129776, -0.032318115, -0.032318115, -0.02128601, 0.03161621, 0.014831543, 0.022567749, 0.019424438, -0.029205322, -0.016296387, -0.006767273, -0.05316162, 0.0970459, 0.0126571655, -0.0703125, 0.035705566, 0.032043457, 0.042510986, -0.072021484, -0.009567261, 0.06384277, -0.0005221367, -0.037872314, 0.023162842, 0.024353027, 0.03479004, 0.011833191, -0.014633179, -0.006690979, -0.019683838, -0.011405945, 0.036102295, -0.072021484, -0.047698975, -0.01939392, 0.010826111, 0.062927246, -0.0039100647, 0.0058403015, -0.0003566742, -0.00041246414, 0.030731201, 0.04550171, -0.011405945, 0.026153564, 0.029174805, 0.023956299, -0.07128906, 0.017181396, -0.05343628, 0.0024299622, -0.0028705597, 0.014320374, 0.0063934326, -0.01727295, -0.007980347, 0.015113831, -0.0131073, 0.019729614, 0.022613525, 0.025436401, 0.042877197, -0.008903503, 0.0010290146, -0.011260986, -0.024398804, 0.0005531311, -0.031921387, -0.0063934326, 0.0446167, -0.0031414032, 0.092041016, 0.013725281, 0.006038666, 0.048919678, -0.054351807, -0.038970947, -0.040100098, -0.06463623, -0.04574585, -0.04232788, -0.004676819, -0.023895264, -0.03842163, 0.025802612, 0.048919678, -0.0035572052, 0.0049858093, 0.012687683, 0.023254395, -0.041290283, 0.027801514, -0.030059814, 0.020080566, 0.03768921, -0.011871338, 0.0018548965, -0.024810791, 0.010177612, 0.0019445419, 0.0050468445, 0.05215454, -0.06048584, 0.049713135, 0.014320374, -0.053710938, 0.024215698, -0.00078201294, -0.005207062, 0.020339966, 0.005012512, -0.01600647, -0.015052795, 0.020004272, 0.018600464, 0.007850647, -0.048828125, 0.0054512024, 0.02229309, -0.051239014, -0.011787415, 0.016220093, -0.04107666, -0.011260986, 0.009544373, 0.036376953, 0.010215759, -0.029968262, 0.042510986, -0.021636963, -0.023376465, 0.026855469, -0.02482605, 0.06518555, -0.0031089783, -0.07122803, 0.002855301, -0.0005187988, 0.034301758, 0.018844604, 0.012512207, 0.0050086975, 0.0146484375, 0.03768921, 0.017456055, -0.029800415, 0.051849365, 0.0023899078, -0.011062622, 0.0007739067, -0.021606445, 0.024368286, 0.0041275024, -0.03503418, -0.004245758, 0.010803223, 0.023132324, 0.036254883, -0.015563965, 0.012512207, 0.037353516, 0.00022137165, -0.024490356, 0.040008545, 0.0096588135, 0.010948181, 0.00724411, -0.018005371, 0.0027427673, 0.022384644, 0.021240234, 0.007751465, -0.0067214966, -0.00051927567, 0.04333496, 0.022232056, 0.0051841736, -0.028869629, -0.02444458, 0.029891968, 0.005016327, -0.037963867, -0.0128479, 0.005142212, -0.039093018, 0.0032691956, 0.0054626465, 0.00894165, -0.011878967, -0.039489746, -0.06298828, 0.009292603, -0.032226562, 0.038848877, 0.026687622, 0.012992859, -0.012084961, -0.027008057, -0.017410278, 0.06555176, 0.015792847, 0.04031372, -0.07977295, -0.09246826, 0.020996094, -0.028656006, -0.043640137, -0.072143555, -0.06506348, -0.02935791, -0.049316406, 0.028808594, -0.018356323, 0.024932861, 0.006958008, 0.014289856, 0.040100098, 0.0033168793, -0.050750732, 0.004360199, -0.0112838745, -0.019607544, -0.03237915, -0.0019702911, -0.031585693, -0.032958984, 0.007972717, 0.0040016174, -0.017654419, -0.05319214, 0.0022621155, 0.010353088, 0.024719238, 0.0031356812, -0.016525269, 0.009841919, -0.0003232956, -0.014762878, -0.0024662018, -0.01776123, 0.05319214, -0.0309906, 0.01133728, -0.019424438, 0.01637268, 0.0418396, 0.0004169941, 0.013832092, -0.026062012, -0.0042686462, -0.0064353943, -0.02885437, 0.018585205, -0.008125305, 0.007293701, -0.013069153, -0.0070610046, -0.0030879974, -0.0059013367, -0.03543091, -0.08148193, 0.01689148, 0.080322266, 0.019622803, -0.04196167, 0.018539429, 0.031204224, 0.0051345825, -0.02998352, 0.013031006, 0.011512756, -0.028884888, -0.004585266, -0.008483887, -0.009689331, -0.01713562, 0.028274536, 0.018630981, -0.01007843, -0.047973633, 0.004837036, -0.018157959, -0.018157959, 0.0064888, -0.0071983337, -0.060058594, -0.012664795, 0.0027580261, 0.03677368, 0.0026741028, -0.008338928, 0.0013465881, -0.0099105835, -0.006252289, -0.0019741058, -0.057556152, -0.037109375, -0.009941101, -0.004005432, -0.0036678314, 0.008888245, 0.0041618347, -0.0071868896, 0.044952393, -0.022125244, 0.00078487396, 0.019226074, 0.01008606, -0.05480957, -0.03262329, 0.021057129, 0.031829834, 0.024139404, 0.024429321, 0.012496948, -0.04714966, -0.009811401, -0.026473999, 0.010238647, 0.0012865067, -0.018676758, 0.01737976, -0.00034475327, -0.008384705, -0.023269653, -0.03744507, -0.03201294, -0.036132812, -0.029083252, -0.06262207, 0.050048828, -0.036254883, -0.07128906, 0.014572144, 0.059143066, 0.00856781, -0.018218994, -0.0012464523, -0.018173218, -0.03186035, -0.018585205, -0.00014555454, 0.009635925, 0.018798828, 0.011856079, 0.009246826, -0.0037059784, -0.0045204163, 0.0028381348, -0.0023288727, -0.0064468384, -0.00869751, 0.0017843246, 0.037872314, 0.013923645, 0.000869751, -0.000957489, 0.01914978, 0.023651123, -0.019485474, 0.017089844, 0.008583069, -0.037994385, 0.017364502, -0.0178833, -0.010177612, 0.0036449432, -0.0079956055, -0.0104599, -0.0041999817, 0.011138916, -0.03225708, 0.033966064, 0.016143799, 0.031280518, 0.0069618225, -0.04345703, 0.014122009, 0.03010559, 0.0012130737, 0.047546387, 0.068359375, 0.028152466, 0.034240723, 0.035583496, 0.034454346, 0.032440186, -0.02746582, -0.0056915283, 0.0019512177, 0.034942627, -0.008003235, 0.038024902, 0.0047721863, 0.01725769, -0.01751709, -0.017974854, -0.0014362335, -0.014694214, 0.015548706, -0.0024776459, 0.028656006, -0.014221191, -0.015045166, 0.064819336, -0.05041504, -0.03967285, 0.010528564, -0.0016021729, -0.043304443, 0.08227539, -0.01914978, -0.041625977, 0.030807495, 0.018539429, 0.027313232, -0.016677856, 0.03793335, 0.042022705, -0.015823364, 0.0043525696, 0.0016651154, 0.003835678, 0.0017061234, -0.019851685, -0.013084412, -0.0071144104, 0.033233643, 0.034210205, -0.018936157, 0.009468079, -0.030929565, -0.044006348, 0.020095825, 0.050720215, -0.012702942, 0.00674057, -0.031433105, -0.033050537, -0.046813965, -0.019378662, -0.02078247, 0.019760132, -0.029876709, 0.012626648, 0.043029785, 0.0062217712, 0.0084991455, 0.011314392, -0.05947876, 0.049682617, 0.014518738, -0.0014438629, -0.0016736984, 0.04107666, -0.0826416, 0.010803223, 0.052581787, -0.033721924, 0.0070648193, 0.013542175, -0.030807495, 0.051940918, -0.03933716, 0.0031738281, -0.06500244, -0.016143799, -0.054718018, 0.003967285, 0.014854431, 0.0463562, 0.005680084, -0.021759033, 0.050720215, 0.002002716, -0.011116028, -0.014389038, -0.030761719, 0.011940002, -0.0030841827, -0.038360596, -0.006298065, -0.0105896, -0.010391235, -0.011749268, 0.03656006, 0.028656006, -0.03817749, 0.025680542, 0.024749756, -0.013839722, -0.038360596, 0.000017285347, -0.0017671585, -0.03201294, 0.040802002, 0.072143555, 0.015579224, 0.048095703, -0.06616211, 0.012420654, 0.0062675476, 0.012306213, 0.0065994263, -0.012252808, 0.025802612, 0.040161133, -0.026763916, 0.039886475, 0.031799316, -0.018600464, 0.031921387, 0.034973145, -0.03894043, 0.045776367, -0.02142334, 0.044647217, 0.037261963, 0.032470703, -0.026809692, 0.004020691, 0.050872803, -0.017974854, -0.009391785, -0.032073975, -0.009773254, -0.002412796, -0.040130615, -0.0052719116, -0.012390137, -0.08569336, -0.006515503, -0.039367676, 0.00052690506, -0.03817749, 0.032348633, -0.06958008, -0.0052871704, 0.011779785, -0.049468994, -0.069885254, 0.018310547, 0.04623413, -0.025375366, -0.016601562, -0.039794922, -0.003692627, -0.03488159, 0.0063476562, 0.048217773, -0.0062828064, -0.046539307, 0.030548096, -0.008422852, 0.067993164, -0.016906738, -0.03503418, 0.04458618, -0.013877869, 0.031677246, -0.07281494, -0.060821533, -0.020324707, 0.047851562, -0.07342529, 0.012832642, -0.008117676, -0.029525757, -0.043945312, -0.0062408447, -0.016174316, -0.038116455, -0.012512207, 0.043304443, -0.031463623, 0.021514893, 0.004421234, -0.008911133, 0.050354004, 0.009239197, 0.0019521713, 0.013893127, 0.027816772, -0.0340271, 0.020904541, 0.038208008, 0.051727295, -0.014793396, -0.04083252, 0.027954102, -0.038238525, 0.019805908, -0.03149414, -0.023269653, 0.015411377, 0.030853271, 0.013442993, -0.018692017, -0.009857178, -0.035064697, 0.010375977, 0.0018978119, -0.0032863617, 0.0056648254, 0.046661377, 0.07458496, 0.031219482, 0.031829834, -0.021957397, 0.037017822, 0.00020694733, -0.051361084, -0.018218994, -0.0067100525, -0.012550354, -0.016952515, -0.0013122559, -0.028396606, -0.03488159, 0.0036354065, -0.04574585, 0.018875122, -0.011795044, -0.016708374, 0.0042304993, 0.029922485, -0.037750244, 0.021942139, -0.04989624, 0.0231781, -0.011520386, 0.009353638, 0.000869751, -0.044891357, 0.020507812, 0.046417236, 0.014625549, -0.0082092285, 0.02192688, 0.019424438, -0.0013227463, -0.016693115, -0.013031006, -0.059509277, -0.017501831, -0.011253357, -0.011001587, 0.022872925, -0.054840088, 0.014907837, -0.010688782, -0.028717041, 0.015686035, 0.014533997, 0.015945435, 0.008552551, 0.015304565, -0.02571106, 0.0008339882, 0.006099701 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06694v1
Comparative Multi-View Language Grounding
Chancharik Mitra, Abrar Anwar, Rodolfo Corona, Dan Klein, Jesse Thomason
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.RO
In this work, we consider the task of resolving object referents when given a comparative language description. We present a Multi-view Approach to Grounding in Context (MAGiC) that leverages transformers to pragmatically reason over both objects given multiple image views and a language description. In contrast to past efforts that attempt to connect vision and language for this task without fully considering the resulting referential context, MAGiC makes use of the comparative information by jointly reasoning over multiple views of both object referent candidates and the referring language expression. We present an analysis demonstrating that comparative reasoning contributes to SOTA performance on the SNARE object reference task.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06694v1
2023-11-12T00:21:58
2023-11-12T00:21:58
{ "title": [ -0.0072288513, -0.0023269653, -0.03555298, -0.08166504, -0.016235352, -0.0032367706, -0.067993164, 0.015899658, -0.0038280487, 0.045776367, -0.028121948, 0.0102005005, 0.014884949, -0.025497437, -0.026794434, 0.0028915405, 0.0050735474, 0.05050659, -0.0074882507, -0.028564453, -0.05618286, -0.01084137, 0.022537231, -0.009681702, 0.03692627, -0.0692749, -0.05545044, -0.0041770935, 0.00021541119, -0.03479004, 0.0023078918, 0.017822266, 0.038391113, -0.0052986145, -0.0063171387, 0.0062446594, -0.026855469, 0.00039362907, -0.025405884, 0.027709961, 0.003435135, 0.007881165, 0.0013999939, -0.016448975, -0.053466797, -0.000120699406, -0.03237915, 0.015365601, -0.010643005, 0.016525269, -0.0015010834, 0.00037240982, 0.0055236816, 0.053588867, 0.0003118515, -0.026412964, -0.0029697418, -0.021148682, 0.00011140108, 0.07476807, 0.033813477, 0.0045166016, -0.00036358833, -0.044403076, -0.012359619, -0.0073509216, -0.025527954, 0.021774292, 0.05404663, 0.010124207, -0.037719727, -0.007534027, 0.017578125, -0.01826477, 0.011291504, 0.023483276, -0.018157959, 0.02456665, 0.029830933, -0.017471313, -0.0104599, 0.0140686035, -0.046936035, -0.027328491, 0.01007843, -0.03866577, -0.014129639, -0.013244629, -0.036865234, -0.08929443, -0.0074424744, 0.007762909, -0.07940674, 0.008453369, -0.009857178, -0.05319214, -0.013923645, 0.026535034, -0.012802124, -0.042266846, -0.04989624, 0.023498535, -0.0625, -0.021270752, 0.013320923, -0.012069702, 0.02507019, 0.032836914, 0.031143188, 0.030181885, -0.042816162, 0.06945801, -0.0071411133, 0.0151901245, -0.0071525574, -0.0035419464, -0.01576233, -0.018249512, -0.02293396, 0.014862061, -0.020355225, -0.021743774, 0.015182495, 0.010246277, 0.027877808, 0.021438599, -0.040222168, 0.0011711121, -0.017440796, 0.06286621, -0.0022258759, 0.029342651, -0.10272217, -0.07373047, -0.046051025, -0.003479004, -0.033294678, -0.043518066, -0.036712646, -0.0076026917, 0.011047363, -0.021377563, 0.015571594, -0.0047683716, -0.012062073, 0.0065689087, 0.055267334, 0.020706177, -0.03640747, -0.06939697, 0.000030100346, -0.007335663, 0.02772522, -0.018432617, -0.040130615, -0.04333496, -0.11633301, -0.006389618, 0.029388428, 0.011550903, -0.047912598, -0.015052795, 0.024215698, -0.062286377, -0.0011739731, 0.01008606, -0.020492554, 0.01637268, 0.013954163, 0.0541687, -0.022460938, 0.059783936, 0.006210327, 0.0082473755, 0.010856628, -0.0037174225, -0.023727417, 0.000333786, 0.013008118, 0.0031528473, 0.026977539, -0.026229858, -0.04748535, 0.07659912, -0.060394287, -0.010643005, -0.01737976, 0.0061836243, 0.03189087, 0.016494751, 0.0134887695, 0.032196045, -0.030181885, 0.026046753, -0.05618286, -0.026123047, 0.02192688, 0.055023193, -0.02772522, 0.00013744831, 0.009162903, 0.032470703, -0.03805542, -0.00374794, -0.016281128, -0.028198242, -0.0045204163, 0.0061912537, -0.02293396, 0.0413208, 0.06604004, 0.026107788, -0.06262207, 0.021759033, -0.01826477, -0.05493164, 0.024993896, -0.024246216, 0.009811401, -0.032409668, 0.037902832, -0.015327454, 0.004283905, 0.05529785, -0.013328552, 0.019226074, -0.0034942627, -0.0026111603, 0.020126343, 0.047546387, 0.056243896, -0.044281006, 0.03656006, 0.012336731, -0.018859863, -0.0042915344, -0.012924194, -0.014755249, -0.007881165, 0.019088745, -0.001666069, -0.010513306, 0.0029239655, 0.02116394, 0.02128601, -0.02848816, 0.005771637, 0.0025959015, 0.023757935, 0.060394287, 0.06768799, 0.009635925, 0.041778564, 0.015464783, -0.015853882, 0.06738281, 0.022201538, -0.024917603, -0.023513794, 0.03579712, 0.016815186, 0.017105103, -0.04208374, 0.03933716, -0.06903076, -0.008491516, -0.049621582, 0.01033783, 0.00064754486, -0.03375244, 0.016448975, -0.011550903, 0.005710602, -0.011985779, -0.006877899, -0.028686523, -0.014228821, 0.0317688, -0.0010261536, -0.03717041, -0.027694702, 0.03930664, 0.020126343, -0.013053894, 0.0023937225, -0.003025055, 0.004283905, -0.031799316, -0.005344391, -0.01524353, 0.04550171, 0.0012903214, -0.015701294, 0.020629883, 0.03164673, -0.027526855, 0.06414795, 0.049072266, -0.030151367, 0.012245178, -0.045806885, 0.011444092, 0.020080566, -0.016479492, 0.0041770935, 0.020645142, 0.02986145, -0.018798828, -0.035247803, 0.019683838, -0.06762695, 0.01486969, -0.016921997, -0.046569824, -0.025375366, -0.026229858, 0.0053253174, -0.06414795, -0.015342712, -0.015304565, 0.029449463, -0.03692627, -0.015319824, 0.02658081, -0.019500732, -0.037384033, 0.040283203, -0.021560669, -0.010948181, 0.012367249, 0.016418457, -0.008636475, -0.08294678, -0.056884766, -0.0070610046, 0.013755798, -0.005203247, -0.015960693, -0.0046691895, 0.04031372, 0.037902832, 0.04647827, 0.019241333, -0.0541687, 0.011428833, -0.059570312, 0.026153564, 0.004058838, -0.018737793, 0.009925842, 0.017715454, -0.012504578, -0.0007286072, 0.022445679, 0.062194824, -0.049194336, -0.036010742, 0.039886475, 0.023391724, -0.0073928833, 0.018554688, 0.008003235, 0.0069732666, -0.03387451, 0.0019216537, -0.055664062, -0.008918762, -0.02192688, 0.0026016235, 0.032836914, -0.021118164, -0.016174316, -0.030822754, 0.011680603, -0.0039901733, -0.018066406, -0.024368286, -0.04660034, -0.046661377, -0.04144287, -0.008895874, 0.00737381, -0.00522995, 0.0284729, 0.06341553, 0.01260376, 0.0077667236, 0.010612488, 0.03164673, 0.008468628, -0.026565552, -0.03552246, -0.043304443, -0.015571594, 0.047332764, 0.021575928, 0.0013589859, -0.012664795, -0.06713867, -0.009719849, 0.011993408, -0.018356323, -0.04611206, 0.02041626, -0.081604004, -0.0015506744, -0.035461426, -0.03866577, 0.028503418, 0.046875, -0.011711121, 0.024459839, -0.000023007393, -0.0016393661, 0.003955841, -0.044647217, -0.08203125, 0.009475708, 0.008796692, -0.0058135986, -0.010116577, -0.026947021, -0.06774902, -0.0071525574, -0.007534027, 0.09802246, 0.007896423, 0.016448975, 0.034332275, -0.029312134, -0.0034942627, -0.01007843, -0.006729126, -0.008743286, -0.004043579, 0.002998352, -0.025543213, 0.015113831, 0.032409668, -0.027496338, -0.013916016, -0.0010070801, 0.00422287, -0.00007939339, 0.027801514, -0.047943115, 0.005580902, 0.004890442, -0.004245758, 0.029037476, -0.05130005, 0.018188477, -0.043884277, 0.009216309, -0.03677368, -0.015777588, 0.00025582314, 0.016052246, -0.003414154, -0.010437012, 0.008003235, -0.015167236, -0.018798828, 0.00016593933, 0.020446777, 0.064086914, -0.023742676, -0.004184723, -0.059020996, 0.017303467, -0.0042533875, -0.049438477, 0.009635925, 0.014389038, -0.011138916, -0.0005340576, -0.019683838, 0.0127334595, -0.031311035, 0.019454956, 0.014801025, 0.0018529892, -0.022003174, -0.05718994, 0.015266418, -0.0022335052, -0.080444336, -0.009025574, 0.016052246, 0.029724121, -0.015052795, -0.015808105, 0.03781128, -0.013511658, -0.03778076, 0.014907837, -0.010299683, -0.012893677, 0.0072364807, -0.07678223, -0.032348633, 0.07885742, -0.006023407, 0.008430481, 0.012397766, -0.02960205, -0.06335449, -0.020568848, 0.06262207, 0.023712158, -0.0209198, 0.01184082, -0.009475708, -0.02949524, -0.0138168335, 0.0029945374, 0.009719849, -0.06652832, 0.02659607, 0.048095703, -0.01763916, 0.01991272, -0.00466156, 0.04486084, -0.014083862, 0.0178833, -0.04321289, 0.049041748, -0.0135269165, -0.028030396, 0.018508911, -0.029876709, 0.029434204, 0.0390625, -0.008552551, 0.06109619, -0.015991211, 0.010345459, 0.053497314, -0.0037174225, -0.03378296, -0.0149002075, 0.0041999817, 0.026824951, 0.010726929, -0.0032997131, -0.0049705505, 0.033050537, -0.0007266998, -0.028656006, 0.0110321045, 0.022521973, -0.018920898, 0.008163452, -0.022262573, -0.055145264, -0.016494751, 0.0067481995, -0.018508911, 0.03274536, 0.04220581, 0.012542725, -0.02696228, -0.00945282, 0.055236816, -0.0049705505, -0.0087509155, -0.06378174, 0.02748108, -0.0146484375, -0.07336426, -0.07006836, -0.07867432, 0.019226074, -0.017456055, 0.030883789, -0.039001465, 0.0069274902, 0.028182983, 0.072509766, 0.046905518, 0.007408142, -0.031982422, 0.053466797, -0.019546509, 0.033172607, -0.0124435425, 0.0036239624, 0.0079574585, 0.012763977, 0.012382507, -0.014228821, -0.0137786865, -0.075927734, 0.016326904, -0.022628784, 0.0023612976, 0.0362854, 0.017944336, 0.02482605, 0.024337769, -0.008110046, 0.018508911, -0.045837402, 0.014053345, -0.039001465, 0.045837402, -0.012145996, 0.020462036, 0.041412354, 0.021957397, -0.018997192, -0.012664795, 0.027557373, 0.0289917, 0.011932373, 0.018066406, -0.0015039444, -0.020492554, -0.013542175, 0.022613525, -0.008422852, 0.047943115, -0.035095215, -0.00818634, -0.00680542, 0.014755249, 0.025604248, -0.01953125, 0.02960205, 0.036987305, 0.019439697, -0.054656982, -0.018707275, -0.00819397, 0.020950317, -0.03591919, -0.008216858, -0.008049011, -0.034118652, 0.025894165, 0.039611816, 0.032714844, -0.030776978, 0.015579224, -0.021392822, 0.0061416626, -0.007987976, -0.0635376, 0.022567749, -0.013893127, 0.02444458, 0.0056381226, 0.016052246, -0.04586792, 0.01184845, -0.0021324158, -0.018936157, 0.027679443, -0.06161499, 0.026290894, 0.07312012, -0.01574707, 0.04208374, -0.015457153, -0.022109985, 0.045715332, 0.06762695, -0.021835327, 0.028244019, 0.04244995, -0.04864502, -0.040039062, 0.007144928, 0.0011911392, 0.0017881393, 0.060791016, 0.013343811, 0.020202637, -0.04147339, 0.011962891, 0.023544312, -0.010818481, 0.02420044, -0.051635742, 0.022323608, -0.0018157959, 0.017074585, 0.05911255, -0.03857422, -0.06036377, -0.0692749, 0.00484848, -0.11273193, 0.017089844, 0.038757324, -0.056610107, -0.057281494, 0.05142212, 0.019439697, 0.009490967, -0.024459839, 0.017044067, -0.059417725, 0.05670166, 0.023406982, -0.048828125, 0.02079773, -0.03753662, -0.014328003, 0.036071777, 0.08312988, -0.048583984, -0.015029907, -0.004764557, -0.042877197, 0.0143966675, 0.01146698, 0.0206604, -0.01335907, 0.007850647, -0.024276733, -0.017623901, 0.0038585663, 0.031280518, -0.024597168, -0.029006958, 0.03439331, -0.027175903, -0.033691406, -0.015159607, -0.006832123, -0.0054244995, -0.01071167, 0.008636475, -0.009857178, 0.046142578, -0.017501831, 0.010620117, -0.028656006, -0.04888916, 0.020690918, 0.021316528, -0.0061149597, -0.02217102, 0.037475586, 0.022018433, 0.0129470825, 0.00680542, 0.008796692, 0.044281006, -0.010009766, -0.031188965, -0.0262146, -0.002866745, -0.007499695, 0.030517578, -0.0006980896, -0.026260376, -0.01701355, -0.02822876, -0.02104187, 0.010246277, -0.007797241, -0.0015544891, -0.020248413, 0.0124435425, 0.042297363, 0.0044021606, -0.012252808, -0.04638672, 0.044433594, -0.027160645, -0.069885254, 0.04849243, -0.013549805, 0.0056266785, -0.0019626617, -0.006954193, 0.032287598, 0.002319336, 0.033294678, -0.039001465, 0.00035476685, -0.029205322, -0.010391235, 0.022583008, 0.015045166, -0.03048706, 0.006652832, -0.027374268, 0.08068848, -0.008575439, 0.018417358, 0.022491455, -0.0016403198, 0.0022468567, 0.0046195984, 0.04006958, -0.02268982, -0.0030384064, -0.04147339, -0.00957489, -0.04611206, -0.010276794, -0.10522461, -0.0025730133, 0.026290894, 0.011314392, -0.002336502, -0.00217247, 0.010597229, 0.014808655, 0.0075569153, -0.00749588, 0.02935791, -0.0007266998, 0.010101318, 0.002357483, -0.046447754, -0.0020065308, 0.039916992, 0.0013093948, -0.0140686035, -0.011352539, -0.010063171, 0.014656067, -0.00623703, 0.03842163, 0.000087440014, -0.036956787, -0.019851685, 0.0068626404, -0.010635376, 0.036132812, 0.05999756, -0.0036830902, -0.028411865, -0.009719849, 0.01209259, -0.014190674, -0.0053100586, -0.008201599, -0.0007791519, -0.0423584, 0.017440796, 0.008728027, -0.018218994, -0.0034599304, 0.0135269165, 0.05895996, -0.043029785, 0.0020446777, 0.015281677, 0.023071289, -0.0107421875, 0.019851685, -0.047912598, -0.018325806, -0.036621094, -0.0018262863, 0.0119018555, -0.0036315918, -0.011024475, 0.009841919, 0.02458191, -0.013031006, 0.0037231445, 0.015434265, 0.009017944, 0.014717102, 0.007270813, 0.034118652, 0.0034561157, -0.034942627, 0.013298035, 0.009216309, -0.04248047, 0.008338928, -0.0027599335, 0.0035533905, 0.016738892, 0.03967285, 0.018966675, -0.013694763, -0.023620605, -0.026153564, 0.024612427, -0.002752304, -0.030212402, 0.03817749, -0.031066895, -0.024749756, 0.03668213, -0.034240723, 0.03970337, -0.029800415, 0.0025691986, -0.04421997, 0.047943115, 0.015823364, -0.044921875, -0.07385254, 0.0018939972, 0.0008201599, -0.004016876, -0.0026798248, -0.059326172, 0.00026249886, -0.018600464, -0.01576233, -0.010940552, 0.011703491, 0.024917603, -0.04232788, -0.055236816, 0.03857422, 0.0076942444, 0.083862305, -0.0014867783, -0.0181427, -0.010803223, -0.005306244, -0.00831604, 0.007835388, -0.0019226074, -0.0038776398, -0.054595947, -0.010025024, 0.014923096, 0.0309906, -0.0031394958, -0.02204895, -0.0009889603, -0.01374054, -0.029663086, -0.011505127, -0.002401352, -0.015098572, -0.0051498413, -0.00970459, -0.018554688, 0.018951416, 0.011352539, -0.010887146, 0.023269653, -0.01399231, 0.0064888, -0.020431519, 0.025543213, 0.046325684, 0.0021381378, -0.050109863, -0.014656067, 0.012619019, 0.02218628, -0.044128418, -0.080200195, 0.04711914, 0.057556152, -0.021606445, 0.06359863, 0.027038574, -0.035858154, -0.021942139, -0.011802673, -0.03942871, 0.02532959, 0.01259613, -0.009422302, -0.008934021, 0.020248413, -0.008483887, 0.0029182434, 0.033203125, -0.01637268, -0.007736206, 0.018920898, 0.034606934, 0.0087890625, 0.011566162, 0.05239868, -0.043151855, -0.033996582, -0.0440979, 0.074157715, -0.03010559, 0.006378174, 0.017288208, 0.013183594, 0.013656616, 0.06994629, -0.03173828, -0.07183838, 0.061187744, 0.040740967, 0.0028095245, 0.011138916, 0.032165527, -0.008560181, -0.03543091, 0.021469116, 0.032958984, 0.036865234, 0.010154724, -0.015106201, 0.032928467, -0.070251465, -0.047668457, -0.024719238, -0.026565552, 0.04458618, -0.03918457, 0.019042969, -0.013763428, -0.025741577, -0.00022017956, 0.031188965, -0.01461792, -0.04107666, -0.022033691, 0.064697266, 0.049194336, 0.003479004 ], "summary": [ 0.05029297, 0.009407043, -0.012306213, -0.057769775, -0.0019626617, -0.009033203, -0.03768921, -0.024993896, 0.011276245, 0.0309906, -0.025238037, -0.013420105, 0.04660034, -0.028244019, 0.014671326, -0.011268616, 0.008544922, 0.036834717, 0.040008545, -0.0031929016, -0.0009570122, 0.015655518, 0.010421753, -0.01386261, 0.033966064, -0.05026245, 0.00013315678, -0.020523071, 0.02784729, -0.016937256, 0.03527832, 0.008384705, 0.022888184, -0.015701294, 0.01335907, 0.0046691895, -0.004776001, -0.01676941, -0.017150879, 0.04598999, 0.014320374, -0.0066490173, 0.008453369, -0.016479492, -0.042388916, -0.006893158, -0.015449524, 0.008003235, 0.04852295, 0.012748718, -0.004901886, -0.009643555, -0.015686035, 0.044677734, -0.032714844, -0.019424438, -0.019851685, -0.019561768, 0.015930176, 0.08728027, 0.033081055, 0.0059814453, -0.03189087, -0.047851562, 0.016098022, 0.014434814, 0.02015686, 0.024749756, 0.045898438, 0.0064430237, -0.025756836, 0.0038146973, 0.023208618, -0.012268066, 0.02178955, 0.033996582, -0.022476196, 0.041137695, 0.04083252, -0.004383087, 0.0037002563, -0.0028076172, -0.001906395, -0.014221191, -0.016403198, -0.020217896, -0.0059890747, -0.0071144104, -0.040100098, -0.029174805, -0.032043457, 0.03878784, -0.09008789, -0.023590088, -0.0033054352, -0.034332275, 0.012458801, 0.026885986, 0.017166138, -0.030059814, 0.015007019, -0.03479004, -0.010002136, -0.02960205, -0.0044403076, -0.0012454987, 0.016906738, -0.037200928, -0.004333496, 0.001285553, -0.048736572, 0.0440979, 0.0013713837, -0.029708862, -0.028335571, 0.026519775, 0.0031356812, -0.007873535, 0.0030765533, -0.00724411, -0.03152466, -0.03677368, 0.035705566, 0.105895996, 0.06304932, 0.09069824, -0.021759033, -0.009666443, -0.029708862, 0.05090332, -0.007648468, 0.027511597, -0.00064373016, -0.03189087, -0.04510498, -0.017684937, -0.007091522, 0.012084961, -0.020141602, -0.0109939575, 0.027648926, 0.00075769424, 0.016784668, 0.012191772, -0.03982544, 0.015525818, 0.01600647, 0.023498535, -0.03942871, -0.05505371, 0.017654419, -0.042907715, 0.016113281, -0.018829346, 0.0077819824, -0.04385376, -0.02267456, -0.00957489, 0.017807007, -0.0026359558, -0.023086548, 0.00030899048, 0.031707764, 0.0037937164, 0.010848999, -0.018173218, 0.006580353, -0.0028972626, 0.018463135, 0.02418518, -0.03265381, 0.047454834, 0.012687683, -0.0046157837, 0.0017251968, -0.010147095, -0.04473877, 0.039916992, 0.012283325, -0.011260986, 0.016830444, -0.03717041, 0.010292053, 0.03829956, -0.031951904, 0.005836487, -0.024002075, 0.027359009, 0.032073975, 0.00068950653, -0.0146102905, 0.005718231, -0.028900146, 0.046569824, -0.03994751, 0.00009512901, -0.0068206787, 0.054992676, -0.04034424, -0.021087646, 0.05355835, 0.004081726, -0.023529053, -0.008003235, -0.038391113, -0.025146484, -0.011428833, -0.0059280396, -0.022583008, 0.024673462, 0.041870117, 0.03451538, -0.057617188, 0.04257202, -0.008262634, -0.050811768, 0.028640747, -0.046173096, 0.04940796, -0.034210205, 0.06021118, 0.04248047, -0.009002686, 0.018325806, -0.023773193, 0.05065918, -0.019577026, 0.039489746, -0.021087646, 0.07873535, -0.03805542, -0.05609131, -0.005657196, 0.017227173, 0.0059928894, 0.0005865097, 0.039794922, -0.049835205, 0.018981934, 0.009422302, 0.02557373, -0.007511139, -0.009353638, -0.018447876, -0.012062073, -0.06652832, 0.0026073456, -0.01423645, 0.002210617, 0.021133423, 0.03765869, -0.00016283989, 0.03994751, 0.019958496, 0.0055503845, 0.024505615, -0.032318115, -0.06365967, 0.014778137, -0.015411377, 0.042175293, -0.017745972, -0.028640747, 0.013092041, -0.024719238, -0.042633057, -0.008460999, -0.010055542, 0.036071777, -0.05819702, 0.0048294067, -0.04397583, 0.0061950684, -0.023742676, -0.040008545, -0.04083252, -0.03640747, 0.030639648, 0.035186768, -0.031982422, -0.0012493134, 0.031188965, -0.033447266, -0.015670776, 0.03982544, 0.04916382, -0.022766113, -0.022903442, 0.03894043, 0.038513184, 0.042388916, 0.02368164, 0.008773804, 0.01890564, -0.011505127, -0.0104522705, -0.026550293, -0.014785767, 0.019302368, -0.027664185, -0.013389587, 0.03881836, 0.0031700134, -0.017288208, 0.027572632, -0.040863037, -0.0077781677, 0.03488159, 0.02418518, 0.013305664, -0.06439209, 0.034210205, 0.012229919, 0.032440186, -0.042175293, -0.031829834, -0.03012085, 0.014549255, -0.037841797, 0.0010299683, 0.06951904, 0.009613037, 0.03152466, 0.06573486, 0.018676758, -0.059020996, 0.09350586, -0.012435913, -0.021560669, 0.030822754, -0.00046610832, -0.0087509155, -0.03652954, -0.009300232, -0.01209259, 0.025939941, 0.014923096, -0.041992188, 0.01876831, 0.04977417, 0.06817627, 0.0035514832, 0.0054397583, -0.018051147, -0.031036377, 0.0028648376, 0.020996094, 0.015151978, -0.03894043, 0.0016431808, 0.008453369, -0.022705078, -0.0030765533, 0.029693604, 0.010368347, -0.034851074, -0.006801605, 0.035186768, -0.012901306, -0.011062622, 0.010398865, 0.015609741, -0.004878998, -0.047851562, -0.011749268, -0.014968872, 0.0063819885, -0.009811401, 0.024230957, 0.015258789, -0.008270264, 0.03656006, -0.061767578, -0.014297485, 0.009780884, -0.01020813, 0.030807495, -0.024963379, -0.02444458, 0.011024475, -0.020370483, 0.009246826, -0.0066337585, 0.031433105, 0.10522461, -0.0029830933, 0.004753113, 0.038116455, 0.051849365, 0.014602661, -0.000341177, -0.047088623, 0.010238647, -0.053344727, 0.01701355, 0.021728516, -0.01966858, -0.007259369, 0.0017528534, -0.029724121, -0.027709961, 0.029846191, -0.0018892288, 0.014579773, -0.051696777, 0.0014772415, -0.0146484375, -0.03086853, 0.025360107, 0.015792847, 0.01586914, -0.037109375, -0.0057296753, -0.0033283234, -0.00026273727, -0.031555176, -0.02583313, -0.016204834, 0.013114929, 0.021697998, 0.0018157959, 0.0034427643, -0.039367676, 0.012634277, 0.012481689, 0.080078125, -0.025390625, 0.002620697, 0.018554688, -0.04257202, -0.005126953, -0.018218994, 0.014137268, 0.0017700195, -0.023422241, -0.0054359436, -0.028762817, -0.04437256, -0.0021018982, -0.06561279, 0.00036668777, 0.02104187, -0.0071792603, -0.013328552, 0.0022525787, -0.028366089, 0.04876709, 0.006515503, -0.026550293, 0.021896362, -0.05340576, 0.016830444, -0.006626129, 0.027435303, -0.015808105, 0.008964539, -0.03186035, 0.01335144, 0.044952393, -0.036346436, 0.0072021484, 0.016723633, -0.08544922, -0.0063438416, 0.021026611, 0.03744507, 0.011680603, 0.018203735, -0.034179688, 0.011451721, 0.047210693, -0.06542969, 0.012374878, -0.0023059845, 0.037750244, 0.0037250519, -0.026290894, -0.0030670166, -0.022216797, 0.03164673, -0.024871826, 0.006263733, 0.008224487, -0.02935791, -0.0090789795, 0.0181427, -0.050750732, -0.0076904297, 0.03237915, 0.08496094, 0.060638428, -0.01864624, 0.06707764, 0.014305115, -0.0024414062, 0.028518677, -0.013877869, 0.032958984, -0.0052261353, -0.02468872, -0.014694214, -0.011795044, 0.00034689903, 0.009902954, 0.008758545, 0.0009293556, -0.019577026, 0.014823914, 0.0368042, 0.018814087, -0.040771484, 0.010421753, 0.011878967, -0.004840851, -0.023284912, 0.0014438629, 0.0077323914, -0.06915283, 0.012367249, 0.05105591, 0.01084137, 0.028747559, 0.014312744, 0.0033569336, -0.010543823, 0.034362793, -0.0044670105, 0.07043457, -0.022216797, -0.018707275, 0.017364502, 0.0072288513, -0.04425049, -0.011688232, 0.03479004, 0.015411377, -0.0362854, 0.039398193, 0.056274414, -0.02331543, -0.019256592, -0.0045280457, 0.0034160614, 0.025177002, 0.03149414, -0.0034046173, 0.028244019, 0.040252686, -0.06689453, 0.032592773, -0.0152282715, 0.0032215118, -0.05218506, -0.042053223, 0.00008958578, -0.00019299984, -0.0019798279, -0.010559082, -0.012275696, 0.021942139, 0.016052246, 0.020019531, -0.015640259, 0.0046920776, 0.023101807, 0.031433105, -0.0715332, -0.079589844, -0.00831604, -0.022735596, -0.070373535, -0.03213501, -0.09350586, -0.035247803, -0.013938904, 0.015274048, -0.027709961, 0.034484863, -0.0025081635, 0.07293701, 0.06536865, -0.0019683838, -0.085510254, 0.04284668, -0.02204895, 0.026107788, 0.008338928, -0.00198555, 0.0018262863, 0.0104522705, -0.0060691833, -0.007369995, -0.0124435425, -0.14050293, -0.021102905, -0.008796692, -0.047729492, 0.08843994, 0.018112183, 0.016174316, 0.027023315, -0.0101623535, -0.008888245, -0.029174805, 0.070495605, -0.04849243, 0.06762695, -0.019195557, -0.008651733, 0.0395813, 0.013664246, -0.026626587, 0.013961792, 0.0070610046, 0.022735596, 0.01499176, 0.02607727, -0.03866577, -0.042510986, -0.008087158, 0.019363403, -0.010231018, 0.024353027, -0.010482788, -0.004634857, 0.02192688, 0.03756714, 0.023071289, -0.025177002, -0.01576233, -0.020462036, -0.012168884, -0.05117798, -0.04989624, -0.04019165, 0.06707764, -0.02734375, -0.012832642, -0.034942627, -0.07299805, 0.018203735, 0.04083252, 0.027999878, -0.06854248, 0.054138184, -0.012580872, -0.019927979, 0.016143799, -0.039093018, 0.00944519, -0.06311035, 0.0064888, 0.025756836, -0.034210205, -0.006477356, -0.025634766, 0.014152527, -0.02571106, 0.008377075, -0.076416016, -0.0034275055, -0.0038471222, -0.03692627, -0.008651733, 0.008377075, 0.012664795, 0.034851074, 0.036590576, 0.013267517, -0.020828247, -0.0034217834, 0.036132812, -0.025177002, 0.019836426, 0.007675171, -0.014282227, 0.05154419, 0.0062713623, -0.025436401, -0.012649536, 0.018600464, -0.020935059, -0.017211914, -0.029144287, 0.0012340546, 0.03540039, -0.015579224, -0.0012197495, 0.04067993, 0.020721436, -0.027069092, -0.062438965, 0.019836426, -0.08685303, 0.0043525696, 0.015167236, -0.055603027, -0.07293701, 0.009742737, 0.029708862, 0.00026011467, -0.053649902, 0.032226562, -0.058410645, 0.018432617, 0.042510986, -0.037078857, 0.027160645, -0.020050049, -0.0030384064, 0.010009766, 0.046325684, -0.022659302, -0.011154175, -0.041809082, -0.0104599, 0.0069007874, 0.0051841736, 0.009010315, 0.05633545, 0.0065841675, -0.037109375, -0.016677856, 0.04525757, 0.0345459, -0.045654297, -0.023590088, 0.02357483, -0.024749756, -0.040039062, 0.030303955, 0.011550903, -0.054016113, 0.0051498413, 0.025283813, -0.027877808, 0.037872314, -0.041412354, 0.010566711, -0.03515625, -0.04815674, 0.023605347, 0.0158844, 0.014419556, -0.014518738, 0.0002822876, 0.00705719, 0.033599854, 0.0025348663, -0.01309967, 0.03286743, 0.018554688, -0.0028381348, -0.023742676, 0.015960693, -0.027297974, 0.0071983337, -0.013442993, -0.010429382, 0.002357483, 0.013061523, -0.0009794235, -0.03427124, -0.017700195, -0.044006348, -0.028915405, 0.011459351, -0.03677368, -0.0037574768, 0.0057411194, -0.039855957, 0.024749756, -0.019638062, -0.032928467, 0.041290283, 0.012542725, -0.017730713, -0.00013554096, -0.0031166077, 0.044891357, 0.010658264, 0.05810547, -0.04763794, -0.015945435, -0.028015137, 0.015792847, 0.011054993, 0.000034987926, -0.019104004, 0.0067214966, -0.007534027, 0.044433594, 0.029418945, -0.0029850006, 0.017791748, 0.027954102, 0.015396118, 0.0017738342, 0.028884888, 0.0021076202, 0.052001953, -0.021087646, -0.014266968, -0.036865234, -0.055358887, -0.018661499, 0.0018291473, 0.008369446, 0.015151978, 0.045074463, -0.0020694733, 0.015640259, 0.05050659, -0.014282227, 0.060668945, 0.021209717, 0.013847351, -0.0010910034, -0.0033073425, -0.035369873, 0.041015625, 0.04763794, -0.004055023, 0.011795044, -0.05480957, -0.0038795471, 0.002035141, -0.0048713684, 0.0045433044, -0.008117676, -0.0058403015, -0.021026611, 0.03387451, 0.018478394, 0.055145264, 0.028381348, 0.01739502, -0.060516357, 0.01751709, 0.024398804, -0.0041122437, 0.014190674, -0.03363037, -0.025421143, 0.00730896, -0.02293396, 0.0016307831, 0.007358551, 0.021881104, 0.032562256, 0.045166016, -0.04083252, -0.017623901, 0.074035645, 0.0026836395, -0.0048675537, -0.0074882507, -0.037750244, 0.01940918, -0.018188477, -0.06311035, 0.045898438, 0.01121521, 0.02444458, -0.010002136, 0.060913086, -0.0066184998, 0.0022354126, 0.02444458, 0.01802063, 0.029129028, 0.0028266907, 0.023605347, 0.024032593, -0.020355225, 0.030151367, 0.017333984, 0.0143966675, 0.009994507, 0.012176514, 0.02748108, -0.0154418945, 0.014602661, -0.051361084, -0.028045654, 0.04437256, 0.019683838, -0.013900757, -0.012542725, 0.015197754, 0.015090942, -0.04727173, 0.001414299, -0.010665894, -0.02607727, -0.004928589, -0.05493164, -0.019882202, -0.0079956055, -0.006793976, -0.013313293, 0.01889038, -0.055603027, -0.009880066, -0.020446777, 0.017974854, 0.032318115, -0.015319824, 0.008087158, 0.0020198822, -0.01713562, 0.022033691, 0.033111572, 0.0154418945, -0.031051636, -0.024002075, 0.06530762, 0.023040771, 0.12298584, 0.072631836, -0.046325684, -0.013694763, 0.0076141357, 0.026565552, 0.068359375, -0.0064048767, 0.089782715, -0.041168213, -0.03656006, 0.024124146, 0.02758789, -0.011016846, -0.011154175, -0.0008158684, 0.0076828003, -0.0154418945, 0.03857422, -0.041656494, -0.015151978, 0.029968262, 0.015930176, -0.027893066, -0.023834229, 0.0020999908, 0.0054969788, 0.025054932, 0.011001587, 0.010643005, -0.01423645, 0.018432617, 0.014015198, 0.028198242, -0.046142578, -0.016311646, -0.018737793, -0.018981934, -0.03817749, -0.06100464, 0.03878784, 0.10089111, 0.011451721, 0.024124146, -0.014221191, -0.018493652, 0.011329651, 0.034851074, 0.002620697, -0.012619019, 0.06951904, 0.010498047, -0.009384155, -0.011390686, -0.017791748, 0.018218994, 0.0022087097, -0.03878784, -0.020217896, -0.021865845, 0.05041504, -0.01687622, 0.0110321045, 0.030090332, -0.048736572, -0.01626587, -0.017593384, 0.035064697, -0.010322571, -0.004043579, 0.0005283356, 0.010971069, -0.0044784546, 0.013900757, -0.0071983337, -0.06500244, 0.03366089, 0.016464233, 0.01247406, -0.028060913, 0.04925537, -0.019515991, -0.016738892, -0.0033817291, 0.03475952, 0.004043579, 0.010932922, -0.074157715, -0.006046295, -0.07122803, -0.062347412, 0.046447754, -0.017303467, -0.013710022, -0.044128418, 0.05126953, 0.03237915, -0.018966675, 0.012107849, 0.04977417, -0.0055274963, -0.0022010803, 0.017166138, 0.038848877, 0.018005371, 0.0076179504 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06668v1
In-context Vectors: Making In Context Learning More Effective and Controllable Through Latent Space Steering
Sheng Liu, Lei Xing, James Zou
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
Large language models (LLMs) demonstrate emergent in-context learning capabilities, where they adapt to new tasks based on example demonstrations. However, in-context learning has seen limited effectiveness in many settings, is difficult to quantitatively control and takes up context window space. To overcome these limitations, we propose an alternative approach that recasts in-context learning as in-context vectors (ICV). Using ICV has two steps. We first use a forward pass on demonstration examples to create the in-context vector from the latent embedding of the LLM. This vector captures essential information about the intended task. On a new query, instead of adding demonstrations to the prompt, we shift the latent states of the LLM using the ICV. The ICV approach has several benefits: 1) it enables the LLM to more effectively follow the demonstration examples; 2) it's easy to control by adjusting the magnitude of the ICV; 3) it reduces the length of the prompt by removing the in-context demonstrations; 4) ICV is computationally much more efficient than fine-tuning. We demonstrate that ICV achieves better performance compared to standard in-context learning and fine-tuning on diverse tasks including safety, style transfer, role-playing and formatting. Moreover, we show that we can flexibly teach LLM to simultaneously follow different types of instructions by simple vector arithmetics on the corresponding ICVs.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06668v1
2023-11-11T21:19:44
2023-11-11T21:19:44
{ "title": [ 0.021865845, -0.0038452148, -0.027374268, -0.018127441, 0.011878967, -0.03488159, 0.033050537, -0.038604736, -0.027435303, 0.03427124, -0.042877197, 0.04751587, -0.012184143, -0.013252258, -0.005065918, -0.013412476, 0.006954193, 0.012550354, -0.033996582, -0.043182373, -0.0423584, -0.04055786, 0.033325195, 0.06427002, 0.020126343, -0.031951904, -0.093444824, 0.023529053, -0.038360596, -0.033935547, -0.01360321, 0.026870728, 0.026779175, 0.02722168, 0.0006299019, -0.004917145, -0.06524658, 0.03640747, 0.022445679, -0.018035889, 0.028945923, 0.0007677078, -0.037261963, -0.025848389, -0.048034668, 0.0068626404, -0.045074463, -0.015045166, -0.018218994, 0.032043457, 0.016296387, 0.045043945, -0.009635925, 0.04449463, 0.014595032, -0.024780273, -0.0715332, -0.022872925, 0.032409668, 0.087768555, 0.050933838, -0.072143555, 0.0104599, -0.035949707, -0.024536133, -0.035827637, -0.0491333, 0.047027588, 0.0670166, 0.018859863, -0.011184692, 0.0115356445, -0.0048980713, 0.010223389, -0.061584473, 0.014633179, 0.07525635, 0.026153564, 0.014640808, -0.038116455, -0.008369446, -0.018249512, -0.03186035, -0.04525757, 0.02796936, -0.020858765, -0.02482605, -0.013679504, 0.0063438416, -0.05392456, 0.004878998, -0.001247406, 0.012283325, 0.008323669, -0.035308838, -0.04385376, 0.01737976, 0.023849487, 0.018753052, -0.019378662, -0.0284729, 0.010322571, -0.061035156, -0.012908936, 0.013954163, -0.0022907257, -0.008583069, 0.0022239685, 0.025344849, 0.032714844, -0.03289795, 0.040252686, -0.014053345, -0.00029921532, -0.025894165, 0.004776001, -0.0065956116, -0.015914917, -0.001326561, -0.021499634, 0.0063819885, -0.010368347, 0.030715942, 0.040100098, 0.025238037, 0.04135132, -0.037231445, -0.027023315, -0.0385437, 0.045715332, -0.0051193237, 0.06201172, -0.0496521, -0.090270996, -0.08062744, 0.023010254, 0.02420044, 0.0036907196, -0.017974854, 0.00053071976, -0.0018529892, 0.0036735535, 0.006668091, -0.04107666, 0.0041275024, 0.017364502, 0.03717041, 0.010398865, -0.02609253, -0.056243896, -0.0019893646, 0.0025043488, 0.030090332, -0.021850586, -0.026306152, -0.018234253, -0.118652344, -0.00034809113, 0.00579834, 0.019119263, 0.031402588, 0.005458832, -0.011062622, 0.013259888, 0.02218628, -0.021438599, -0.009628296, 0.0057258606, 0.013458252, 0.068725586, -0.016479492, -0.0010032654, -0.017654419, -0.007701874, -0.002565384, 0.008270264, 0.009941101, 0.012046814, 0.016906738, 0.013641357, 0.021087646, -0.021118164, -0.020584106, 0.04748535, -0.012489319, -0.049316406, -0.0050849915, -0.026550293, 0.03466797, 0.019180298, -0.03793335, 0.041412354, -0.053894043, -0.080444336, -0.064331055, 0.033172607, 0.052734375, 0.0597229, -0.010246277, 0.027664185, 0.041015625, -0.0034484863, -0.0126571655, -0.012489319, -0.023956299, -0.028808594, -0.006427765, 0.018753052, -0.0025024414, 0.048309326, 0.026382446, 0.013717651, -0.016143799, -0.032440186, -0.027709961, -0.039215088, 0.045928955, -0.0368042, 0.0036411285, -0.016479492, 0.0014123917, 0.0005784035, -0.0052375793, 0.050720215, 0.014503479, -0.012229919, -0.0014925003, -0.027618408, 0.03579712, 0.019973755, 0.058563232, -0.023880005, 0.028137207, 0.006542206, -0.028533936, -0.018417358, -0.02947998, -0.02255249, -0.00013184547, 0.03137207, -0.0020103455, 0.00042247772, -0.024520874, 0.03543091, 0.032043457, -0.0040779114, -0.016418457, 0.039764404, -0.01828003, 0.007858276, 0.055023193, 0.02684021, 0.03967285, 0.01499176, -0.018463135, 0.05618286, -0.019348145, 0.0053100586, -0.004840851, 0.01020813, -0.009162903, 0.038391113, 0.029129028, 0.009391785, -0.008628845, -0.047058105, -0.010787964, 0.007873535, 0.012680054, -0.039733887, 0.039978027, -0.0016584396, 0.015235901, -0.025848389, -0.018753052, -0.021850586, -0.039123535, 0.034576416, 0.02758789, -0.06866455, -0.019134521, -0.026901245, -0.00381279, 0.0056495667, 0.030807495, 0.020401001, 0.02658081, -0.005264282, 0.003736496, -0.017318726, 0.020904541, 0.045166016, 0.0052604675, 0.021636963, 0.018356323, -0.0019197464, 0.05102539, 0.072143555, -0.05218506, 0.048339844, -0.029418945, 0.023345947, 0.016937256, -0.012229919, 0.011230469, 0.01020813, 0.040649414, 0.018051147, -0.005794525, 0.0033397675, -0.026809692, 0.035461426, -0.006275177, -0.01374054, -0.06311035, -0.058624268, -0.0032958984, -0.04168701, -0.044036865, -0.024993896, 0.11151123, -0.041137695, -0.018356323, -0.010971069, -0.007827759, -0.039245605, -0.0040740967, -0.039520264, 0.008201599, 0.03366089, 0.028717041, 0.050323486, -0.046875, -0.009002686, -0.0072364807, 0.0059165955, 0.0063972473, -0.04437256, -0.020553589, 0.019805908, 0.022781372, -0.039031982, 0.024520874, -0.023223877, -0.029754639, -0.0395813, 0.02607727, 0.012702942, -0.010314941, 0.009757996, 0.03086853, -0.012413025, -0.011680603, 0.033233643, 0.051696777, -0.03729248, -0.020202637, 0.039367676, 0.021011353, -0.0053253174, 0.04498291, 0.017044067, 0.012268066, -0.05609131, -0.016540527, -0.056610107, -0.005973816, -0.027191162, 0.0027713776, 0.044311523, -0.05923462, 0.0096588135, -0.03149414, -0.004966736, 0.01322937, 0.029708862, -0.013381958, -0.045837402, -0.030151367, -0.024902344, -0.00957489, 0.0038928986, -0.015205383, 0.020980835, 0.074279785, -0.008964539, 0.0118637085, 0.018539429, 0.071777344, 0.006088257, 0.023788452, -0.030761719, -0.050598145, 0.006790161, 0.021850586, 0.019622803, 0.004169464, -0.047668457, -0.101257324, -0.030914307, 0.033477783, -0.010871887, -0.023757935, 0.014633179, -0.055145264, 0.025665283, 0.002023697, -0.025497437, 0.030075073, 0.068115234, -0.011146545, -0.011314392, 0.02609253, -0.03062439, 0.024139404, -0.0071525574, -0.08770752, 0.022262573, -0.03717041, 0.00012981892, 0.013580322, -0.019470215, -0.045928955, -0.0042037964, -0.013427734, 0.029327393, 0.055480957, 0.035949707, 0.012573242, -0.022216797, 0.015731812, -0.051879883, -0.0006480217, -0.013267517, -0.039031982, -0.020980835, -0.00957489, 0.013412476, 0.034851074, -0.031158447, -0.025268555, -0.010528564, -0.03010559, 0.0016546249, -0.027297974, -0.020721436, -0.0010328293, -0.009605408, 0.0037231445, -0.0060424805, -0.03100586, -0.0116119385, -0.03274536, 0.014434814, -0.03390503, 0.079833984, -0.009727478, 0.031036377, -0.00026512146, -0.012504578, 0.037384033, -0.016998291, -0.051086426, 0.031280518, 0.0072898865, -0.010879517, 0.06137085, -0.018569946, 0.0035648346, -0.00793457, -0.03579712, 0.019210815, 0.012313843, -0.016235352, 0.025527954, 0.021453857, 0.0010585785, -0.01878357, -0.0129470825, -0.01586914, 0.021133423, -0.0034313202, -0.02128601, -0.046417236, 0.012573242, 0.007259369, -0.09643555, -0.031707764, 0.02128601, -0.02520752, -0.031921387, -0.04510498, 0.025436401, -0.019134521, -0.015068054, 0.002336502, -0.01386261, -0.025558472, 0.008712769, -0.084350586, -0.004589081, 0.06213379, 0.018554688, 0.008094788, 0.024414062, -0.047821045, -0.024780273, -0.045013428, 0.03152466, 0.012626648, 0.044189453, -0.002412796, 0.010261536, 0.037384033, -0.018096924, 0.004623413, 0.0637207, 0.040008545, 0.00504303, -0.004749298, 0.011665344, 0.02003479, -0.03414917, 0.024887085, 0.033843994, 0.017547607, -0.07824707, 0.045654297, 0.010879517, 0.0029411316, -0.0027503967, -0.00116539, -0.0038032532, 0.018737793, 0.012145996, 0.020080566, -0.0002515316, 0.01687622, 0.038757324, -0.0017414093, -0.009811401, 0.01802063, 0.019363403, -0.0013580322, 0.012580872, -0.006134033, 0.0017375946, 0.0079574585, -0.04107666, -0.028396606, -0.01600647, 0.021575928, -0.0146865845, -0.012916565, -0.05130005, -0.03149414, -0.041931152, 0.017990112, 0.007381439, 0.018234253, 0.034057617, -0.018493652, -0.011940002, -0.003189087, -0.029083252, 0.014595032, -0.038848877, -0.07147217, -0.04714966, -0.008903503, -0.07537842, -0.02229309, -0.029190063, -0.038238525, 0.029815674, -0.0012207031, -0.047607422, 0.015609741, 0.018463135, 0.083984375, 0.023086548, 0.01235199, -0.06866455, 0.035827637, -0.012870789, -0.00655365, 0.01235199, 0.0075416565, 0.0017108917, 0.006477356, 0.00605011, -0.020904541, -0.009819031, -0.05895996, -0.009307861, -0.022964478, 0.03930664, 0.035888672, 0.05734253, 0.030044556, 0.019744873, -0.0033245087, -0.0065193176, -0.022659302, -0.003200531, 0.016098022, 0.037506104, 0.03338623, 0.0154800415, 0.023635864, -0.0053977966, -0.008529663, 0.020736694, -0.0021190643, 0.029891968, -0.023452759, -0.018203735, 0.020568848, -0.022445679, -0.009208679, 0.011871338, -0.012771606, 0.039916992, -0.04309082, 0.037200928, 0.01625061, 0.014793396, 0.05279541, -0.016586304, 0.0030117035, 0.018356323, 0.0045394897, -0.09887695, -0.0725708, -0.05923462, 0.06304932, -0.034454346, -0.017562866, 0.033996582, 0.007850647, 0.043304443, 0.034088135, 0.058624268, -0.03881836, -0.025863647, 0.0005054474, 0.008865356, 0.0010900497, -0.046966553, -0.012832642, 0.031234741, 0.028518677, -0.04473877, 0.010398865, -0.029586792, -0.003944397, -0.015640259, -0.019226074, 0.007259369, -0.06695557, 0.017532349, 0.05456543, 0.016342163, 0.03390503, 0.0059776306, 0.035217285, 0.02229309, 0.031311035, 0.026916504, -0.016204834, 0.017959595, -0.039978027, 0.002696991, -0.0005326271, 0.011405945, 0.0015392303, 0.04473877, 0.0104599, 0.012054443, -0.05831909, 0.037963867, 0.0077934265, -0.028778076, 0.0036888123, -0.04486084, 0.014854431, -0.02583313, 0.010131836, 0.026031494, -0.037841797, -0.011077881, 0.00060606, -0.027908325, -0.045318604, 0.03173828, -0.018249512, -0.039001465, -0.06842041, 0.029174805, -0.005466461, 0.02204895, -0.026153564, 0.01675415, -0.039886475, 0.009468079, 0.016540527, -0.03439331, 0.009780884, -0.023208618, 0.014717102, 0.010185242, 0.019424438, -0.031555176, -0.0056991577, -0.0061836243, -0.040863037, 0.008842468, 0.06304932, 0.029830933, -0.028442383, 0.008911133, 0.025466919, 0.039520264, 0.0010557175, 0.0440979, 0.014976501, -0.031433105, 0.034301758, -0.011177063, -0.027755737, 0.025894165, -0.008636475, -0.037200928, 0.02255249, 0.016311646, -0.0022850037, 0.02368164, 0.016220093, 0.0131073, -0.014953613, -0.07299805, 0.0047683716, 0.026062012, -0.023468018, 0.023040771, 0.049804688, 0.033477783, 0.051727295, 0.009925842, 0.02607727, 0.055389404, -0.018157959, -0.025985718, 0.0008792877, -0.011482239, -0.029846191, 0.05355835, 0.010261536, -0.016296387, -0.031280518, -0.019241333, -0.02859497, 0.023651123, 0.01852417, -0.011062622, 0.01374054, -0.008346558, 0.01966858, -0.02949524, -0.014038086, -0.031982422, 0.026123047, -0.01033783, -0.007865906, 0.009346008, -0.033111572, -0.012992859, -0.014183044, 0.018096924, -0.0063056946, 0.0129776, -0.020050049, -0.00881958, 0.007423401, -0.038146973, 0.018829346, 0.05657959, 0.012786865, -0.049713135, 0.033050537, -0.014892578, 0.07147217, -0.017440796, 0.03881836, 0.019515991, 0.006652832, 0.0047340393, -0.006980896, 0.006401062, -0.038269043, 0.033416748, -0.03616333, 0.012916565, -0.053588867, -0.029205322, -0.091308594, 0.0063819885, 0.01927185, 0.021453857, 0.0022678375, 0.0018177032, 0.0044403076, -0.014541626, 0.0211792, 0.0007390976, 0.041503906, -0.0024604797, -0.0032176971, -0.014656067, -0.024368286, 0.024902344, 0.04034424, -0.0010385513, 0.017318726, -0.0033817291, -0.019226074, -0.016189575, 0.030151367, 0.024658203, -0.015281677, -0.0053710938, -0.014427185, 0.050628662, 0.004169464, 0.050323486, 0.05026245, 0.036010742, -0.01966858, -0.0121536255, -0.012260437, 0.027770996, -0.012367249, 0.01398468, 0.062805176, -0.08087158, 0.018371582, 0.0022277832, -0.047851562, -0.0033836365, 0.040008545, 0.029571533, -0.061553955, -0.031280518, 0.021987915, 0.030761719, -0.0019702911, 0.014457703, -0.014762878, -0.027709961, 0.00005465746, 0.024291992, 0.012809753, 0.035980225, -0.0030174255, 0.003206253, 0.01928711, -0.0184021, -0.0045814514, 0.028762817, -0.004386902, 0.03842163, -0.014549255, 0.019943237, 0.014022827, -0.02923584, 0.0079193115, 0.028945923, -0.04534912, 0.006591797, -0.014915466, 0.05532837, 0.031433105, 0.09741211, 0.016418457, 0.0058250427, -0.0018777847, -0.012664795, 0.018035889, 0.022140503, -0.027664185, 0.00995636, -0.036102295, -0.028060913, -0.010848999, -0.058807373, 0.012107849, -0.026809692, 0.018692017, -0.0050697327, -0.031051636, 0.046203613, -0.039794922, -0.012130737, 0.011398315, -0.051452637, 0.015472412, 0.027740479, -0.016082764, 0.011001587, 0.010734558, 0.001958847, 0.041503906, 0.0073890686, 0.021972656, -0.03265381, -0.049224854, 0.031204224, -0.028640747, 0.06329346, -0.023605347, -0.051635742, -0.021026611, -0.0050315857, 0.043548584, 0.006385803, -0.04559326, 0.03994751, -0.021316528, 0.014282227, -0.007736206, 0.020690918, -0.00434494, -0.037139893, -0.013450623, 0.023452759, -0.038146973, 0.0110321045, 0.0435791, -0.02482605, -0.06304932, -0.014312744, 0.0070533752, 0.05505371, 0.005607605, -0.011940002, 0.037353516, 0.0013427734, -0.051483154, -0.019714355, -0.0041770935, 0.03378296, 0.02053833, -0.009101868, -0.014602661, 0.025497437, 0.039367676, -0.06964111, -0.032989502, -0.0141067505, 0.060577393, -0.019088745, 0.054870605, 0.034088135, -0.010986328, 0.02229309, 0.009490967, -0.0023727417, -0.031463623, -0.0026817322, -0.01146698, 0.025909424, 0.046142578, -0.00969696, 0.00041985512, 0.035980225, -0.0026607513, -0.0105896, 0.00856781, 0.0017299652, 0.010948181, 0.0115737915, 0.05508423, 0.0023479462, -0.023910522, -0.020050049, -0.0054016113, 0.020706177, 0.06329346, -0.029174805, 0.015197754, -0.0027313232, 0.089660645, -0.021759033, -0.031463623, 0.013977051, 0.006462097, 0.007156372, 0.057739258, 0.0048294067, -0.016708374, 0.010360718, -0.0023670197, -0.010307312, 0.021255493, 0.034942627, -0.027313232, 0.0052757263, -0.045837402, -0.021987915, -0.04724121, -0.03366089, 0.032989502, -0.028884888, -0.0041122437, -0.00440979, -0.046844482, -0.008255005, 0.022705078, 0.017471313, -0.052368164, -0.040283203, -0.022323608, 0.06567383, 0.0028743744 ], "summary": [ 0.03869629, -0.047546387, 0.010940552, -0.026138306, -0.05722046, -0.0055732727, -0.022918701, 0.0069503784, 0.0127334595, 0.009422302, -0.07556152, 0.030456543, -0.024749756, -0.002603531, 0.019760132, -0.04034424, 0.0035419464, 0.016036987, -0.008071899, -0.042175293, 0.025390625, -0.047943115, 0.0027179718, 0.05419922, 0.008155823, -0.04220581, -0.017501831, -0.02180481, 0.019226074, 0.0027656555, -0.002588272, -0.0050354004, -0.0027198792, 0.02557373, -0.015823364, -0.03363037, -0.05960083, 0.02482605, 0.010292053, 0.0025730133, 0.012924194, 0.007701874, 0.05911255, -0.040802002, -0.017807007, 0.032196045, -0.015777588, -0.017913818, 0.02482605, -0.010757446, -0.011947632, 0.041809082, -0.013336182, -0.0053100586, -0.028656006, -0.028366089, -0.06604004, -0.010414124, 0.012084961, 0.07122803, 0.035705566, -0.024047852, -0.0018320084, -0.046569824, 0.004638672, 0.011619568, -0.019363403, -0.004421234, 0.023986816, 0.015220642, 0.0037345886, -0.00819397, 0.002067566, -0.047302246, -0.02772522, 0.03829956, 0.03930664, -0.0047683716, -0.007820129, -0.026794434, -0.014007568, 0.05996704, -0.0043525696, -0.079589844, 0.022140503, -0.044311523, -0.017333984, -0.014633179, 0.021621704, -0.04711914, 0.0073928833, -0.0008854866, -0.029342651, 0.010574341, 0.006828308, -0.0725708, -0.013328552, 0.008377075, -0.0010614395, 0.009597778, 0.030258179, -0.029388428, 0.044403076, -0.037139893, 0.0121154785, 0.0035934448, -0.008743286, -0.0071258545, 0.04827881, 0.00920105, -0.014945984, 0.04421997, -0.009849548, -0.03933716, 0.005355835, 0.027282715, -0.001449585, 0.03527832, 0.01020813, 0.014312744, 0.025177002, 0.039489746, 0.01638794, 0.042816162, 0.0036506653, 0.049438477, -0.0015573502, -0.054870605, 0.0003387928, 0.0019140244, -0.006832123, 0.044921875, -0.013626099, -0.022216797, -0.03781128, 0.0019426346, -0.00944519, 0.03768921, -0.01158905, -0.017227173, 0.025405884, -0.024734497, -0.0053749084, 0.002779007, 0.008010864, 0.039215088, 0.025466919, -0.0002939701, -0.0211792, -0.04916382, 0.016784668, -0.027770996, 0.04248047, -0.06695557, -0.03277588, -0.078552246, -0.101135254, 0.009674072, 0.027770996, 0.020614624, 0.0052757263, -0.006198883, 0.009880066, -0.017654419, -0.03643799, -0.014076233, -0.0046653748, -0.027862549, 0.024429321, 0.046844482, 0.0068130493, -0.0063476562, -0.024017334, 0.018707275, 0.008720398, 0.005367279, -0.017150879, 0.048339844, -0.008613586, 0.01914978, 0.024307251, -0.03353882, 0.017669678, 0.003868103, 0.0011367798, -0.041870117, -0.023880005, -0.025054932, 0.06604004, 0.008430481, -0.005542755, -0.016235352, -0.037719727, 0.0056915283, -0.0129776, 0.02268982, 0.017211914, 0.03945923, -0.005355835, -0.039001465, 0.084350586, 0.026153564, -0.0075569153, -0.051849365, -0.067871094, -0.0028457642, -0.012336731, 0.034729004, 0.051818848, 0.032470703, -0.010108948, 0.020812988, -0.015960693, -0.0026607513, -0.044647217, -0.011306763, 0.02619934, -0.021484375, 0.0051116943, -0.027633667, 0.04699707, 0.0024299622, 0.016296387, 0.0914917, -0.038909912, -0.027160645, 0.008903503, 0.02128601, 0.0050582886, 0.025772095, 0.033721924, -0.05593872, 0.012565613, 0.021850586, -0.022705078, -0.023101807, -0.038848877, -0.08569336, 0.03616333, 0.070739746, 0.011619568, 0.015327454, -0.01777649, 0.030136108, 0.020431519, 0.01436615, 0.0055885315, 0.018203735, -0.05065918, -0.019332886, 0.021331787, 0.018737793, 0.02545166, -0.0007624626, 0.0024738312, 0.030059814, -0.00038528442, -0.012039185, -0.01638794, 0.001294136, -0.0044784546, -0.03930664, -0.01777649, -0.013473511, -0.043304443, -0.066467285, -0.014694214, -0.022216797, 0.03543091, -0.07385254, 0.013435364, -0.031921387, 0.0023403168, -0.059814453, -0.033935547, -0.047851562, -0.018218994, 0.04925537, 0.035491943, -0.056365967, -0.011795044, -0.032989502, -0.0128479, -0.018600464, 0.014007568, 0.0138168335, 0.017913818, 0.0012693405, -0.004360199, 0.044067383, 0.02178955, 0.05999756, 0.017822266, 0.0085372925, -0.00116539, 0.026733398, 0.055236816, 0.040771484, -0.016433716, -0.0044403076, 0.03112793, 0.022415161, -0.040740967, 0.00894928, 0.029327393, -0.008773804, 0.035888672, 0.016296387, 0.02507019, 0.021347046, -0.02772522, 0.018539429, 0.01586914, 0.08111572, -0.061035156, -0.045410156, 0.01448822, 0.02545166, -0.006023407, 0.015777588, 0.11022949, -0.029403687, 0.011489868, 0.02935791, -0.01574707, -0.049957275, 0.0748291, -0.030792236, 0.035583496, 0.010810852, -0.017669678, 0.020523071, -0.037139893, -0.0072402954, -0.007133484, -0.015365601, 0.0070533752, -0.059539795, -0.008201599, 0.04486084, 0.06161499, -0.03945923, 0.03466797, -0.000808239, -0.037139893, -0.015579224, 0.001663208, 0.0057411194, -0.0044288635, -0.011802673, 0.03829956, -0.018203735, -0.0071792603, 0.03768921, 0.037384033, -0.025161743, -0.026306152, 0.03543091, 0.0048599243, -0.023910522, 0.052734375, 0.038024902, 0.039489746, -0.062438965, -0.030349731, -0.039611816, 0.0005283356, -0.027526855, -0.0050964355, 0.0055122375, -0.00014805794, 0.013221741, -0.03253174, -0.027770996, -0.028915405, -0.0011358261, 0.08728027, -0.0000044107437, -0.040374756, 0.045715332, 0.013648987, 0.045684814, -0.035736084, 0.040649414, 0.072021484, 0.009849548, 0.024642944, 0.026870728, 0.058685303, -0.003932953, 0.029724121, 0.003929138, -0.017730713, -0.010894775, 0.0057907104, 0.0028800964, -0.02571106, -0.021835327, -0.024215698, -0.010971069, 0.063964844, -0.00080919266, 0.0032997131, 0.024627686, -0.025772095, 0.075805664, 0.027191162, 0.00003683567, 0.027435303, -0.0211792, 0.028549194, -0.06185913, 0.0181427, -0.07495117, 0.012779236, -0.027557373, -0.047943115, 0.013679504, -0.054840088, 0.035461426, 0.01108551, 0.016433716, -0.0087890625, 0.0032634735, 0.0015602112, 0.044189453, 0.021240234, 0.026489258, 0.012504578, 0.0019445419, 0.012924194, -0.03704834, -0.015617371, 0.025238037, -0.05593872, 0.01991272, 0.024139404, -0.026229858, 0.06616211, -0.072509766, -0.005718231, -0.025772095, -0.080444336, -0.012001038, -0.03729248, -0.016616821, -0.015625, -0.030471802, 0.02154541, 0.0423584, -0.035339355, -0.022354126, -0.029556274, 0.03515625, -0.051574707, 0.07556152, -0.035614014, 0.04269409, 0.0524292, -0.031204224, 0.016098022, -0.039398193, -0.0016546249, 0.032318115, 0.000101685524, 0.035217285, 0.018478394, 0.03125, 0.009292603, -0.034423828, 0.023605347, -0.035736084, -0.030349731, -0.028945923, -0.0018491745, 0.0077438354, 0.054901123, -0.01864624, 0.034454346, -0.06896973, -0.033813477, 0.020401001, -0.07305908, -0.037475586, -0.002910614, 0.00038957596, -0.055114746, -0.03579712, 0.011817932, 0.025558472, -0.0072135925, -0.0031528473, 0.03543091, -0.020187378, -0.0020942688, 0.011039734, -0.020843506, 0.05999756, -0.018112183, -0.06677246, -0.0078048706, -0.03390503, 0.03555298, 0.044006348, -0.022369385, -0.040374756, -0.030334473, 0.017349243, 0.050048828, -0.006587982, 0.007675171, 0.029510498, -0.009414673, 0.0016727448, -0.0010375977, 0.0062789917, 0.06768799, -0.0043029785, 0.037872314, -0.011482239, 0.01612854, 0.04486084, -0.0234375, 0.0072746277, 0.011550903, 0.0037345886, -0.025924683, 0.039398193, -0.0013246536, 0.0017366409, 0.026794434, 0.013267517, -0.040924072, -0.0033493042, 0.025161743, 0.004257202, -0.015380859, -0.0035762787, 0.028396606, 0.021270752, -0.022094727, -0.008560181, 0.01776123, 0.03173828, 0.019729614, 0.010498047, -0.0007162094, 0.0008535385, -0.09881592, -0.0065307617, -0.011779785, 0.013870239, -0.0059394836, -0.009902954, -0.006378174, -0.0069999695, -0.014770508, 0.002609253, -0.0035419464, 0.04434204, 0.02519226, 0.011329651, -0.0026378632, -0.024368286, 0.004901886, 0.021881104, -0.050628662, -0.07977295, -0.046295166, 0.0020713806, -0.036315918, 0.0015497208, -0.027328491, -0.08270264, 0.0017910004, -0.01777649, -0.04724121, 0.02255249, 0.007156372, 0.049194336, -0.0056610107, 0.017120361, -0.036346436, 0.019088745, -0.0088272095, -0.003982544, 0.022064209, 0.015541077, 0.01776123, 0.03189087, 0.021438599, -0.038879395, -0.016159058, -0.078063965, -0.0011291504, -0.0039863586, 0.010124207, 0.045532227, 0.029312134, 0.025741577, -0.0020809174, -0.01133728, -0.008926392, -0.008102417, 0.046081543, 0.014572144, 0.009162903, 0.009033203, -0.013458252, -0.022567749, 0.007434845, 0.0287323, -0.02142334, -0.0054512024, -0.028808594, -0.021652222, 0.010925293, -0.008239746, -0.015380859, 0.020950317, 0.021148682, -0.006843567, 0.028869629, -0.031829834, 0.010391235, -0.0063095093, 0.029006958, 0.064575195, 0.0035877228, -0.027664185, 0.030426025, -0.0259552, -0.054016113, -0.04626465, -0.040374756, 0.020492554, -0.0057525635, -0.03152466, 0.017807007, 0.0061302185, 0.05834961, -0.017349243, 0.023757935, -0.09075928, -0.025863647, -0.01361084, -0.0099487305, 0.033813477, -0.012275696, -0.07513428, -0.0028972626, 0.024169922, -0.030181885, 0.050750732, 0.028686523, -0.00504303, -0.025390625, -0.01864624, -0.008354187, -0.0395813, -0.042541504, -0.010917664, -0.029266357, 0.016693115, 0.078125, -0.00019288063, -0.030349731, 0.039733887, -0.018753052, 0.014579773, 0.00818634, -0.06384277, -0.029388428, -0.013519287, 0.0027923584, 0.010215759, 0.011077881, 0.014953613, -0.0066184998, -0.027145386, -0.005039215, -0.014915466, 0.014930725, -0.03036499, -0.008682251, 0.009002686, -0.01838684, 0.017700195, 0.0061416626, 0.044036865, -0.008018494, -0.025024414, 0.0006709099, -0.035064697, -0.012863159, -0.04257202, -0.027954102, 0.033172607, 0.002588272, -0.024871826, 0.0058937073, 0.03149414, -0.027450562, 0.0014772415, -0.024475098, -0.021240234, -0.019851685, 0.018035889, 0.0004439354, 0.021255493, -0.024902344, -0.011878967, -0.023452759, -0.017120361, -0.026565552, -0.00642395, 0.0085372925, 0.017730713, 0.02003479, 0.013130188, 0.0037460327, 0.026382446, 0.030578613, -0.008369446, 0.030349731, 0.017593384, -0.04269409, 0.016830444, -0.035217285, -0.064453125, 0.013031006, -0.02557373, -0.060943604, 0.010215759, 0.014526367, -0.011253357, 0.042907715, -0.0033988953, 0.005748749, 0.0066452026, -0.056884766, 0.018539429, 0.016235352, 0.0013113022, -0.013442993, 0.035247803, 0.003692627, 0.022705078, 0.013771057, 0.0030517578, 0.031311035, 0.013427734, 0.001991272, -0.027236938, 0.0032024384, -0.02960205, 0.07006836, 0.0010137558, -0.0035991669, -0.035003662, 0.015449524, 0.007736206, -0.0064964294, 0.0052719116, -0.03591919, -0.0030651093, 0.00035429, -0.010597229, 0.0070877075, -0.012550354, -0.049041748, 0.03201294, -0.027908325, -0.03201294, 0.034820557, -0.02053833, -0.04296875, 0.021026611, 0.015159607, 0.0015163422, 0.0036144257, 0.0010595322, 0.0413208, 0.008399963, -0.030151367, 0.0178833, 0.0501709, 0.026473999, -0.05834961, 0.026412964, 0.0104904175, 0.06298828, -0.012565613, -0.020996094, -0.026443481, -0.012527466, -0.0006508827, -0.010261536, 0.032836914, -0.012199402, 0.081848145, -0.0236969, -0.0152282715, -0.065979004, -0.047424316, -0.045898438, -0.014701843, 0.0007328987, -0.015945435, 0.023956299, -0.006576538, -0.011802673, 0.017105103, -0.07122803, 0.026565552, -0.02659607, 0.016860962, 0.004852295, -0.013793945, -0.04071045, 0.017120361, 0.042785645, 0.00022757053, 0.007068634, 0.027908325, 0.01550293, -0.001074791, -0.030944824, 0.009902954, -0.10131836, 0.01486969, -0.02180481, -0.0004582405, 0.013931274, 0.029922485, 0.008651733, 0.012313843, 0.04421997, -0.0050315857, -0.003955841, 0.0317688, 0.00045347214, 0.024978638, 0.014953613, -0.023605347, -0.02192688, 0.0140686035, -0.025787354, 0.040985107, 0.052886963, 0.026550293, -0.037231445, 0.009605408, -0.0005931854, 0.003358841, -0.006866455, 0.023620605, -0.003414154, -0.0016031265, -0.0040893555, -0.017700195, 0.049560547, 0.055633545, -0.011398315, -0.039215088, 0.04574585, -0.037384033, 0.00818634, 0.039154053, 0.006790161, 0.029891968, 0.03945923, 0.020706177, 0.02619934, -0.014694214, 0.012176514, 0.047210693, -0.011795044, 0.042175293, -0.02180481, 0.046173096, 0.042510986, 0.05368042, -0.04437256, 0.017501831, 0.0602417, 0.0034809113, 0.008178711, 0.010986328, -0.012252808, -0.020080566, -0.01889038, 0.016815186, -0.033294678, -0.0043525696, -0.060577393, -0.055267334, 0.06365967, -0.017684937, -0.0058059692, -0.021514893, -0.021270752, 0.0000012516975, 0.0158844, -0.037475586, 0.031951904, 0.04824829, -0.010238647, 0.028427124, 0.0015821457, -0.042633057, 0.019683838, 0.0026016235, 0.028961182, -0.00982666, -0.0024681091, 0.020599365, 0.0027427673, 0.07196045, -0.024490356, -0.03086853, 0.03982544, -0.00592041, 0.016906738, -0.027114868, -0.029754639, 0.0040664673, 0.02079773, 0.034088135, -0.01966858, 0.030563354, 0.009735107, -0.06994629, -0.04119873, 0.013313293, -0.052612305, 0.050872803, 0.05456543, -0.01739502, -0.0657959, 0.01890564, -0.014175415, 0.04171753, -0.030899048, -0.013069153, 0.046966553, 0.0027599335, -0.08685303, -0.03100586, -0.018127441, -0.004486084, 0.04248047, -0.009284973, -0.010749817, -0.0057525635, 0.02947998, -0.03262329, -0.037261963, -0.009017944, 0.02545166, 0.012817383, -0.008453369, 0.01638794, -0.026107788, 0.013160706, -0.029830933, -0.007896423, 0.000518322, 0.08898926, 0.053009033, 0.0126571655, 0.06085205, -0.03543091, 0.06317139, 0.03161621, -0.024032593, -0.021194458, -0.018707275, 0.0009880066, -0.024536133, 0.014137268, 0.00969696, -0.011306763, -0.01890564, -0.046020508, 0.009407043, 0.0042648315, -0.00793457, -0.010108948, 0.025390625, -0.038146973, 0.034606934, -0.011047363, -0.017333984, -0.00617218, 0.00969696, -0.0020542145, 0.014945984, 0.007648468, -0.008560181, 0.024978638, 0.0124435425, 0.0040130615, 0.041870117, 0.026809692, -0.03933716, -0.011116028, -0.097473145, 0.0013055801, -0.07775879, -0.023773193, 0.00793457, -0.026748657, -0.002254486, 0.016418457, -0.03036499, 0.010131836, 0.023971558, 0.016052246, -0.015068054, 0.021911621, -0.0025367737, 0.03302002, 0.024810791 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.07611v1
Intentional Biases in LLM Responses
Nicklaus Badyal, Derek Jacoby, Yvonne Coady
cs.CL
In this study we intentionally introduce biases into large language model responses in an attempt to create specific personas for interactive media purposes. We explore the differences between open source models such as Falcon-7b and the GPT-4 model from Open AI, and we quantify some differences in responses afforded by the two systems. We find that the guardrails in the GPT-4 mixture of experts models with a supervisor, while useful in assuring AI alignment in general, are detrimental in trying to construct personas with a variety of uncommon viewpoints. This study aims to set the groundwork for future exploration in intentional biases of large language models such that these practices can be applied in the creative field, and new forms of media.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.07611v1
2023-11-11T19:59:24
2023-11-11T19:59:24
{ "title": [ -0.018081665, 0.0028572083, -0.03463745, 0.0007529259, -0.05014038, -0.018081665, -0.034118652, -0.029922485, -0.015380859, 0.014350891, -0.02734375, -0.009796143, -0.004917145, -0.056793213, 0.0107040405, -0.019210815, -0.015594482, 0.04953003, -0.019821167, -0.03717041, -0.03555298, -0.06365967, -0.01537323, -0.023284912, 0.04763794, -0.034973145, -0.023117065, -0.016357422, 0.032836914, -0.0061416626, 0.022445679, -0.033935547, 0.05319214, -0.014984131, 0.022155762, 0.026794434, -0.010131836, 0.00040626526, -0.002506256, 0.027420044, 0.014984131, -0.013496399, -0.052490234, -0.018371582, -0.064208984, -0.0076828003, -0.017211914, 0.021881104, -0.006134033, -0.0000056624413, -0.017318726, -0.002254486, -0.003019333, 0.04736328, 0.0074005127, 0.021026611, -0.016677856, -0.021728516, 0.011436462, 0.044006348, 0.01939392, 0.0073394775, 0.022155762, -0.018585205, -0.0059051514, -0.014503479, -0.020187378, 0.01247406, 0.056762695, 0.027160645, -0.0070648193, -0.011352539, -0.003736496, -0.011947632, -0.018615723, 0.004360199, 0.024780273, -0.004470825, 0.028762817, -0.012802124, 0.033081055, 0.020706177, -0.04815674, -0.014587402, 0.00957489, -0.013824463, -0.00061416626, -0.030151367, 0.0022506714, -0.055389404, 0.0007748604, 0.027526855, 0.014678955, -0.0075416565, -0.056610107, -0.04522705, -0.0129470825, 0.052978516, -0.013954163, -0.08276367, -0.04864502, 0.0287323, -0.14770508, -0.00020265579, 0.011169434, -0.013694763, -0.0035247803, -0.023376465, 0.0034713745, 0.043121338, -0.03805542, 0.036346436, -0.0057525635, -0.008094788, 0.032989502, 0.0022563934, -0.0345459, 0.03527832, -0.020248413, 0.00390625, -0.043029785, -0.035339355, 0.026260376, 0.0209198, 0.03427124, 0.02583313, -0.025512695, -0.00024080276, -0.004169464, 0.02557373, -0.0063591003, 0.03543091, -0.05581665, -0.056671143, -0.041107178, -0.01108551, -0.0023384094, -0.034851074, -0.020645142, -0.014480591, 0.009178162, 0.013656616, 0.02973938, -0.050598145, -0.003314972, 0.06323242, 0.037109375, -0.022994995, -0.007789612, -0.068725586, -0.019363403, -0.020477295, -0.008995056, 0.011787415, -0.026977539, 0.012039185, -0.090270996, 0.023132324, 0.03616333, 0.026641846, 0.017868042, -0.02861023, -0.040283203, 0.0041046143, 0.013496399, 0.027862549, 0.0070648193, 0.047698975, 0.013221741, 0.07470703, -0.013145447, 0.0071754456, -0.032073975, -0.01423645, -0.020599365, -0.016357422, 0.028030396, 0.017227173, 0.020751953, -0.027755737, 0.03994751, 0.003288269, 0.0039100647, 0.034942627, -0.06329346, -0.035095215, 0.030975342, 0.04360962, -0.009017944, 0.030700684, 0.033477783, 0.054534912, -0.015068054, -0.035583496, -0.025146484, -0.029586792, 0.025650024, -0.0005059242, 0.0033817291, 0.01977539, 0.025024414, 0.0033912659, 0.022125244, -0.035583496, -0.024505615, -0.004512787, -0.007385254, 0.025283813, -0.017486572, 0.045288086, 0.036712646, -0.009422302, -0.028411865, 0.03173828, -0.017074585, -0.07702637, 0.019882202, -0.029571533, 0.0010738373, -0.06842041, 0.026321411, -0.018447876, 0.01158905, 0.066467285, -0.006198883, -0.003917694, 0.020080566, -0.019119263, 0.042510986, 0.029678345, 0.07342529, -0.037872314, -0.0028495789, -0.0012655258, -0.022415161, 0.0032215118, -0.013153076, -0.037353516, -0.004306793, 0.044006348, -0.0013332367, -0.0023880005, 0.032073975, 0.091308594, 0.03375244, 0.05404663, 0.05203247, 0.013122559, 0.03540039, -0.01953125, 0.04156494, -0.020462036, 0.08441162, -0.038513184, 0.032592773, 0.079589844, -0.009971619, -0.023422241, 0.0060577393, 0.01966858, -0.005870819, -0.015083313, -0.001748085, -0.012390137, -0.008171082, -0.061309814, -0.030578613, -0.005168915, 0.016586304, -0.03869629, 0.030761719, -0.031188965, 0.018234253, -0.04031372, -0.024612427, -0.0052490234, -0.032836914, 0.052001953, 0.0016479492, -0.05328369, -0.02357483, 0.0034885406, 0.030883789, -0.004306793, 0.016555786, -0.0040283203, 0.03237915, -0.015296936, -0.025741577, -0.05038452, 0.022521973, -0.010635376, -0.023468018, 0.009864807, -0.017623901, -0.032318115, 0.016708374, 0.050628662, -0.03451538, 0.01675415, -0.023712158, 0.0023555756, 0.0074157715, 0.01361084, 0.015205383, 0.022201538, 0.017303467, 0.023956299, 0.017227173, 0.0001937151, -0.008346558, 0.03768921, 0.000910759, -0.04647827, 0.0073051453, -0.0050964355, 0.02848816, -0.021469116, -0.00071668625, 0.028381348, 0.08972168, 0.010894775, -0.011924744, -0.020324707, 0.005329132, -0.05908203, -0.011703491, -0.032562256, -0.0017671585, -0.036010742, 0.022445679, -0.064453125, -0.07623291, -0.08557129, 0.03677368, -0.016082764, 0.011116028, 0.025939941, 0.006713867, -0.005104065, 0.009117126, -0.018997192, -0.012779236, -0.044158936, 0.024139404, -0.015457153, -0.012054443, 0.013969421, -0.05316162, 0.0038585663, 0.022201538, -0.04837036, -0.015419006, 0.03189087, 0.029693604, -0.0385437, -0.00024700165, 0.038879395, 0.011398315, -0.026321411, 0.03375244, 0.031677246, 0.018051147, -0.030776978, -0.024002075, -0.07348633, -0.015838623, 0.016067505, -0.00039601326, 0.030792236, -0.032073975, -0.013679504, -0.022125244, 0.0076065063, -0.014053345, 0.01272583, -0.016983032, -0.046081543, 0.008781433, -0.023117065, 0.016677856, -0.00093126297, 0.006626129, 0.024383545, 0.04550171, 0.009880066, -0.04562378, -0.021835327, 0.020858765, 0.030059814, -0.008964539, -0.024810791, -0.02998352, -0.032440186, -0.017959595, 0.002822876, 0.020706177, -0.007904053, -0.005580902, -0.008850098, 0.020462036, -0.006008148, -0.008773804, 0.0002670288, -0.06463623, 0.001742363, -0.027420044, -0.022064209, 0.033599854, 0.0070266724, -0.020401001, 0.032836914, 0.018005371, -0.01789856, -0.0035247803, -0.027496338, -0.09063721, 0.003698349, 0.009757996, 0.021530151, -0.0073394775, -0.0335083, -0.017608643, 0.004951477, 0.01625061, 0.025634766, 0.016738892, -0.012901306, 0.030044556, -0.000041246414, -0.0043411255, -0.010398865, -0.005771637, -0.00051927567, -0.028274536, -0.018371582, -0.025375366, 0.031707764, 0.04135132, -0.033325195, -0.016540527, -0.028533936, -0.041381836, -0.0071144104, -0.03048706, -0.00920105, 0.009788513, -0.017807007, -0.04046631, 0.0126571655, -0.04788208, 0.010292053, -0.03817749, 0.029190063, -0.019088745, 0.054138184, 0.032714844, 0.009269714, -0.02078247, 0.046203613, 0.027389526, 0.0035762787, -0.0075950623, -0.016357422, 0.019989014, 0.010818481, 0.0031337738, -0.005756378, 0.002626419, -0.0069618225, -0.009140015, -0.011497498, 0.011421204, 0.0152282715, -0.0068740845, 0.007858276, -0.027450562, 0.02041626, -0.04660034, 0.00023555756, -0.0056762695, 0.010498047, 0.005771637, -0.085754395, -0.017944336, 0.02357483, -0.0793457, -0.016830444, 0.0030136108, -0.026473999, -0.042022705, -0.028701782, 0.01524353, -0.048858643, -0.03857422, -0.003080368, -0.013961792, -0.0093688965, 0.02999878, -0.09436035, -0.002948761, 0.054595947, -0.019241333, 0.0033473969, 0.003458023, -0.046173096, -0.0154800415, -0.006061554, 0.016784668, 0.012771606, 0.05886841, 0.010627747, 0.01864624, -0.021728516, 0.009399414, 0.06896973, 0.03024292, 0.013153076, 0.05709839, 0.0026054382, 0.04537964, -0.0019054413, 0.018569946, 0.030914307, 0.028808594, 0.008865356, -0.023239136, 0.0050239563, -0.025405884, -0.011520386, -0.0012073517, 0.009468079, 0.03656006, 0.004585266, 0.022628784, 0.0146484375, -0.0178833, 0.008476257, 0.019042969, -0.008758545, -0.038024902, -0.01713562, 0.007587433, 0.024734497, -0.014823914, -0.026489258, -0.029510498, 0.057861328, 0.025039673, 0.022460938, 0.0066719055, -0.011329651, -0.023803711, 0.0034732819, -0.020950317, -0.10888672, -0.059631348, 0.0011997223, -0.0069770813, 0.03213501, 0.038482666, 0.0121536255, -0.05441284, 0.0014123917, -0.022323608, -0.013633728, 0.016220093, -0.045806885, -0.006511688, -0.0006866455, -0.066101074, -0.019729614, -0.009117126, -0.017684937, 0.008880615, -0.022079468, 0.008354187, 0.028152466, 0.024505615, -0.03112793, 0.034942627, -0.027282715, 0.011688232, 0.023254395, 0.006881714, 0.0021362305, 0.013458252, -0.012489319, 0.0020885468, 0.0146865845, -0.003320694, 0.0045661926, -0.024383545, -0.06488037, 0.02078247, 0.020721436, 0.01626587, 0.029251099, -0.0037345886, 0.029968262, 0.021270752, -0.0132369995, -0.00083875656, -0.034423828, 0.021484375, -0.01423645, 0.03164673, 0.029632568, 0.015090942, 0.010948181, 0.026931763, -0.028182983, -0.044311523, 0.04763794, -0.009750366, 0.014053345, 0.03112793, 0.004135132, 0.011253357, -0.005279541, 0.04559326, -0.005466461, 0.039520264, 0.0047035217, -0.0044174194, -0.018218994, 0.024856567, 0.017349243, -0.0043678284, 0.032714844, 0.025238037, 0.014411926, -0.022094727, 0.03237915, 0.0569458, -0.038482666, -0.03829956, 0.0023460388, 0.0062561035, 0.015296936, -0.00021147728, 0.04547119, 0.00072288513, -0.0023212433, 0.045410156, -0.00579834, 0.0046195984, -0.015617371, -0.07299805, 0.017181396, 0.00049352646, 0.025756836, 0.01574707, 0.0023517609, -0.050964355, -0.039733887, 0.011650085, -0.04837036, -0.015640259, -0.0814209, -0.0011863708, -0.018997192, -0.019042969, 0.020523071, 0.0357666, 0.0035305023, 0.013671875, 0.08093262, -0.04208374, 0.03036499, 0.04925537, -0.048919678, -0.03778076, -0.014808655, 0.05404663, 0.031463623, -0.0034103394, 0.030410767, 0.03062439, -0.066467285, 0.006046295, -0.011734009, -0.004047394, 0.0062713623, -0.038146973, 0.018341064, -0.008232117, 0.002910614, -0.003129959, 0.0014209747, -0.0004351139, 0.040893555, -0.022445679, 0.0071792603, 0.007583618, -0.020111084, -0.011802673, -0.030471802, 0.033172607, 0.0052604675, 0.036132812, -0.004623413, 0.01890564, -0.020629883, 0.015075684, 0.015434265, -0.050567627, -0.0065231323, -0.0062828064, 0.025924683, 0.023651123, 0.022781372, -0.003320694, 0.011222839, -0.044128418, -0.0546875, -0.0047683716, 0.024963379, 0.033843994, 0.020767212, -0.013664246, -0.03152466, 0.008621216, -0.005443573, 0.018554688, 0.050079346, -0.054107666, 0.034820557, -0.01739502, -0.013023376, 0.011764526, 0.05886841, -0.0059509277, 0.0029277802, 0.011062622, -0.016586304, -0.012817383, 0.009963989, 0.016830444, -0.080078125, -0.06774902, -0.011932373, 0.02909851, 0.015945435, -0.007408142, 0.038238525, 0.024871826, 0.04147339, -0.034423828, -0.001964569, 0.028564453, -0.015327454, -0.1182251, -0.017288208, -0.035583496, -0.015151978, 0.07043457, 0.037750244, -0.097717285, -0.00982666, -0.04019165, -0.01713562, 0.0014705658, 0.03503418, -0.055114746, -0.02053833, -0.042541504, -0.0023231506, -0.011253357, -0.026779175, -0.026763916, 0.009056091, -0.0368042, -0.10571289, 0.111816406, 0.015945435, 0.06011963, -0.041900635, 0.01689148, -0.011306763, -0.014213562, 0.007598877, -0.048797607, 0.005832672, -0.031829834, -0.0021686554, 0.021057129, 0.01914978, -0.026565552, 0.027236938, -0.04144287, 0.051849365, 0.02798462, 0.025390625, 0.016723633, 0.027008057, 0.029663086, 0.017303467, 0.012428284, -0.0069274902, -0.0149002075, -0.04434204, 0.006904602, 0.010604858, 0.028137207, -0.107177734, 0.016616821, 0.06378174, 0.03149414, -0.058654785, 0.00919342, -0.0054473877, 0.01184845, 0.007282257, -0.03555298, 0.035247803, 0.022979736, -0.014801025, 0.03933716, -0.038970947, -0.012634277, 0.02456665, -0.013137817, -0.0035133362, -0.03753662, -0.0037975311, -0.006729126, 0.0006995201, 0.006641388, 0.015945435, 0.007068634, -0.020477295, 0.04031372, 0.032470703, 0.06616211, 0.029434204, -0.020019531, 0.004787445, -0.016113281, -0.03125, 0.03640747, -0.020202637, 0.023147583, 0.039245605, -0.012298584, 0.044311523, -0.00390625, -0.060333252, -0.013053894, 0.05255127, 0.011146545, 0.02758789, -0.005569458, 0.002872467, 0.013381958, 0.06109619, 0.054656982, -0.03161621, -0.018356323, -0.017562866, 0.0056381226, 0.01373291, 0.017288208, 0.00881958, 0.068115234, 0.0049438477, -0.0051193237, 0.008628845, -0.0463562, -0.026168823, 0.018203735, 0.058166504, 0.067871094, -0.0096206665, -0.022216797, 0.024536133, 0.024536133, -0.09033203, 0.033416748, -0.0017709732, 0.008514404, -0.00014519691, 0.033416748, 0.023803711, -0.0368042, -0.054718018, -0.022476196, 0.029785156, 0.009796143, 0.005054474, 0.020523071, -0.028656006, -0.022781372, 0.06323242, 0.027374268, 0.10205078, -0.038391113, -0.00016975403, -0.030334473, -0.015960693, 0.017974854, -0.016815186, -0.03982544, -0.020507812, 0.047973633, 0.009628296, -0.022109985, -0.09448242, -0.022491455, 0.010154724, 0.049316406, 0.03829956, -0.009651184, 0.016662598, -0.021972656, -0.048828125, 0.028579712, -0.0028839111, 0.042541504, -0.024108887, -0.026443481, -0.009017944, 0.019317627, 0.022094727, -0.013160706, -0.034088135, -0.002735138, 0.008766174, 0.05960083, -0.037963867, 0.005508423, -0.0115737915, -0.0031414032, -0.0059013367, 0.051452637, -0.043029785, -0.013153076, 0.032409668, -0.012573242, -0.04626465, -0.020019531, -0.0062942505, 0.041778564, 0.021957397, -0.032562256, 0.044067383, 0.000072956085, -0.041900635, -0.032196045, -0.018676758, 0.021560669, -0.0050582886, -0.0012960434, -0.012145996, 0.0154953, 0.03173828, -0.0574646, -0.060791016, -0.011390686, 0.04421997, -0.0051651, 0.04815674, 0.021652222, 0.007671356, 0.0015954971, -0.018463135, -0.023376465, -0.018844604, 0.044952393, 0.03125, -0.0015525818, 0.052490234, -0.019607544, 0.044281006, 0.017074585, 0.0031909943, -0.015991211, 0.030319214, -0.0075531006, -0.02229309, 0.009803772, -0.0073890686, -0.023971558, -0.07299805, -0.019851685, 0.0058784485, -0.019088745, -0.018218994, 0.011627197, 0.0020503998, -0.045410156, 0.024887085, -0.018173218, 0.0032787323, 0.004047394, 0.0345459, 0.0026435852, 0.012245178, -0.022842407, 0.012199402, 0.0034923553, -0.016021729, -0.0021209717, -0.036254883, 0.047027588, -0.005672455, -0.018493652, 0.0016489029, -0.024520874, 0.010322571, -0.014320374, 0.028305054, -0.032287598, 0.014717102, -0.023803711, -0.031402588, 0.0034275055, 0.029663086, 0.0020313263, -0.047821045, -0.0129470825, 0.0070533752, 0.03817749, -0.0022144318 ], "summary": [ -0.010795593, 0.0053863525, -0.0115356445, 0.04638672, -0.023651123, -0.021514893, 0.006793976, -0.054901123, 0.002588272, 0.02229309, -0.024276733, 0.014953613, 0.018310547, -0.028427124, 0.034088135, -0.029388428, -0.028671265, 0.041748047, 0.007167816, -0.029708862, 0.030960083, -0.06121826, -0.044433594, -0.05392456, 0.047607422, -0.08972168, -0.051849365, 0.030960083, 0.0054016113, 0.02708435, 0.0146102905, 0.02293396, 0.032043457, 0.035095215, -0.06555176, 0.01322937, -0.009025574, 0.0075569153, -0.016647339, 0.03427124, 0.01776123, 0.006099701, 0.00497818, 0.0009551048, -0.016479492, -0.007507324, 0.00023674965, -0.040771484, 0.02494812, 0.03353882, -0.010139465, 0.004245758, -0.012557983, -0.00029921532, -0.009307861, -0.0028438568, 0.023529053, 0.012908936, 0.011940002, 0.022018433, 0.0006146431, 0.036376953, -0.0038108826, -0.02027893, -0.0028076172, 0.012954712, -0.0025367737, -0.021728516, 0.018569946, 0.021728516, 0.031280518, -0.027511597, 0.034362793, -0.07019043, -0.02822876, 0.07354736, -0.0077667236, 0.026672363, 0.041778564, -0.07525635, 0.0149383545, 0.06149292, -0.026672363, -0.048095703, -0.0059394836, -0.058044434, -0.009735107, -0.012702942, -0.011512756, 0.0033073425, -0.013755798, -0.035583496, -0.011756897, 0.052978516, 0.032348633, -0.0395813, -0.011627197, -0.0395813, 0.0055007935, -0.016159058, 0.016799927, -0.017974854, -0.019332886, 0.000058472157, 0.022613525, 0.0069351196, -0.03527832, -0.024993896, 0.03869629, 0.03387451, -0.0032787323, -0.00015974045, -0.0051231384, -0.00217247, -0.036071777, 0.0042686462, -0.019927979, 0.0059013367, -0.015434265, 0.014785767, -0.009002686, -0.0026397705, 0.03842163, 0.015533447, 0.00793457, 0.023147583, 0.0018835068, -0.03942871, -0.020339966, 0.018508911, 0.0036315918, 0.027542114, -0.012252808, -0.005897522, -0.0473938, -0.00017774105, 0.00029158592, -0.009712219, -0.013969421, 0.012931824, -0.017059326, -0.03753662, 0.030776978, -0.007926941, 0.008735657, 0.059143066, 0.038085938, -0.024459839, -0.03894043, -0.053771973, 0.007511139, -0.039123535, 0.00077438354, -0.012893677, 0.048614502, -0.032348633, -0.015411377, -0.004463196, 0.050048828, 0.0027198792, -0.019714355, -0.0026283264, 0.041809082, 0.024673462, -0.0075569153, 0.020492554, -0.014221191, -0.012054443, 0.00793457, 0.026641846, -0.0335083, 0.027236938, -0.0017747879, -0.009284973, -0.017150879, -0.0126571655, -0.013641357, -0.014640808, 0.012359619, -0.007411957, 0.021087646, -0.0087509155, -0.015365601, 0.038024902, -0.06359863, 0.0007662773, 0.003446579, 0.07495117, 0.05279541, 0.010559082, 0.035614014, -0.028778076, 0.002073288, 0.016830444, 0.034454346, -0.020492554, -0.016967773, -0.005882263, 0.011558533, -0.0473938, 0.06439209, 0.0066604614, 0.009529114, -0.06976318, -0.12249756, 0.029968262, -0.04837036, 0.05633545, -0.062194824, -0.0026550293, 0.041625977, -0.032989502, -0.04232788, 0.10876465, 0.04360962, -0.033691406, 0.01939392, 0.01398468, 0.012481689, -0.030654907, 0.015716553, 0.0036029816, -0.0017814636, 0.047210693, -0.0040397644, -0.004917145, 0.008079529, 0.011650085, 0.051849365, 0.022399902, 0.056518555, -0.044158936, 0.008743286, 0.04397583, -0.00705719, -0.011413574, -0.0033054352, -0.04736328, 0.018066406, 0.027191162, 0.03225708, 0.0015916824, -0.03326416, -0.02330017, -0.004447937, 0.007621765, 0.049194336, -0.038726807, 0.0069465637, -0.00020945072, 0.0155181885, -0.013938904, 0.047576904, -0.066589355, 0.006416321, 0.043701172, -0.044769287, -0.06222534, 0.05633545, -0.051574707, 0.041748047, -0.028335571, -0.026763916, 0.0057296753, -0.021270752, -0.037963867, -0.036743164, -0.034301758, -0.0096206665, -0.020584106, 0.03366089, -0.03491211, 0.0040626526, -0.04788208, 0.025482178, -0.018295288, -0.05734253, 0.036499023, 0.028625488, -0.03805542, -0.0010938644, 0.0037174225, -0.03201294, -0.017425537, 0.038482666, 0.02218628, -0.0046653748, -0.010131836, -0.011001587, 0.017120361, 0.018463135, 0.04534912, 0.0011873245, 0.024124146, -0.017471313, -0.004878998, 0.037902832, 0.023712158, 0.013206482, -0.032470703, 0.049743652, 0.032043457, -0.066345215, 0.042938232, 0.010665894, -0.020431519, 0.003835678, 0.0335083, 0.021713257, 0.010231018, -0.03302002, 0.033325195, 0.0317688, 0.009025574, 0.0036888123, 0.0040512085, 0.0003244877, 0.05407715, 0.024459839, 0.06262207, 0.14379883, -0.014701843, 0.0309906, 0.0041542053, -0.013465881, -0.07531738, 0.035247803, -0.029693604, 0.033996582, -0.010765076, -0.020874023, -0.043121338, -0.056121826, -0.044189453, 0.008255005, -0.0005545616, 0.0043258667, 0.040649414, 0.024780273, 0.0018625259, 0.057006836, -0.0063209534, -0.006351471, 0.01374054, 0.0079422, -0.032836914, 0.012413025, 0.0058135986, -0.0041236877, 0.0079193115, -0.0043563843, -0.012123108, -0.007484436, 0.008796692, 0.022262573, 0.012794495, 0.000895977, 0.012710571, 0.036132812, -0.031585693, 0.020019531, 0.028259277, 0.0009965897, -0.017089844, -0.032836914, -0.040740967, -0.016693115, 0.011108398, 0.04827881, 0.03753662, 0.009483337, 0.07281494, -0.047546387, -0.01751709, -0.020187378, -0.05078125, 0.028015137, -0.013046265, 0.0048828125, 0.01889038, 0.027709961, 0.03503418, 0.009376526, 0.05923462, 0.0569458, 0.008346558, -0.020431519, 0.002986908, 0.016921997, 0.011245728, -0.009483337, -0.017547607, -0.00806427, 0.005016327, 0.01902771, -0.011978149, -0.037078857, 0.003227234, -0.08807373, -0.0015916824, 0.042297363, -0.008613586, 0.023620605, -0.003944397, -0.05795288, 0.046661377, -0.030807495, 0.002855301, 0.03466797, -0.033813477, 0.041809082, -0.05279541, 0.026000977, -0.04272461, -0.013336182, -0.038360596, -0.052246094, -0.015296936, 0.03741455, 0.024383545, -0.047790527, 0.048706055, -0.0390625, 0.016967773, -0.014343262, 0.032958984, -0.018829346, 0.0012464523, -0.010391235, 0.027557373, -0.0010480881, 0.0045547485, -0.020401001, -0.0335083, -0.05987549, 0.03173828, 0.023483276, 0.06896973, 0.047180176, -0.043701172, -0.015533447, -0.030715942, -0.03765869, -0.003604889, -0.014892578, -0.01473999, -0.036834717, -0.0053138733, 0.014854431, -0.007423401, -0.024551392, 0.0014600754, 0.030441284, 0.03024292, -0.013641357, 0.038330078, -0.03692627, 0.015792847, -0.009613037, 0.024978638, 0.048309326, -0.00028967857, -0.013893127, -0.017913818, 0.051483154, -0.0071105957, -0.02381897, -0.0032043457, -0.025650024, 0.019515991, 0.019882202, -0.025878906, -0.021240234, 0.005168915, -0.010673523, -0.018005371, 0.02027893, 0.044006348, -0.021499634, -0.020858765, -0.07336426, 0.04232788, -0.04156494, -0.0871582, -0.049865723, 0.009925842, -0.08660889, -0.059387207, -0.00033521652, 0.025299072, -0.0112838745, -0.008201599, 0.028274536, 0.011917114, -0.0056381226, 0.022598267, -0.020385742, 0.011520386, -0.0024108887, -0.06854248, 0.039031982, 0.0023345947, -0.011116028, 0.016326904, 0.014595032, 0.034057617, 0.015838623, 0.01586914, 0.020553589, -0.024978638, 0.040100098, -0.02281189, -0.041107178, 0.005241394, -0.014030457, 0.060058594, 0.0060539246, -0.014503479, 0.023269653, -0.015487671, 0.008117676, 0.032928467, -0.004886627, -0.0075035095, 0.006164551, 0.03086853, -0.024887085, 0.05267334, 0.0022659302, -0.02482605, 0.016189575, -0.015670776, -0.026824951, 0.022460938, 0.035888672, 0.04446411, -0.024536133, 0.0021266937, 0.025787354, 0.017974854, -0.041809082, -0.014884949, 0.015296936, 0.0597229, -0.03656006, -0.019226074, -0.050201416, 0.0053138733, 0.002532959, -0.046936035, 0.03375244, 0.047027588, -0.03451538, -0.027526855, -0.021408081, -0.049591064, -0.039886475, 0.030899048, 0.016082764, 0.020401001, 0.0209198, 0.0012073517, 0.0037784576, -0.007106781, 0.057617188, 0.03125, -0.04232788, -0.09564209, 0.01096344, 0.0025482178, -0.046722412, -0.04309082, -0.046081543, -0.0390625, -0.030578613, -0.0143585205, -0.050628662, 0.015159607, -0.025497437, 0.04473877, 0.04446411, 0.02835083, -0.064331055, 0.006629944, 0.0010251999, -0.012260437, -0.0048332214, -0.028076172, -0.0003592968, 0.016082764, 0.04647827, -0.022216797, -0.0287323, -0.0871582, 0.02355957, 0.020050049, 0.0010757446, 0.001537323, -0.04046631, 0.02067566, 0.037902832, -0.038116455, -0.00058174133, 0.0020923615, 0.0042762756, -0.060791016, -0.032165527, 0.08453369, 0.03164673, 0.061523438, -0.0064201355, 0.004837036, -0.036193848, 0.022247314, -0.0037136078, -0.018081665, -0.00068855286, 0.023925781, 0.022613525, -0.018035889, 0.018188477, 0.008651733, 0.0005326271, 0.024169922, -0.011985779, -0.021759033, -0.020599365, -0.025527954, -0.023910522, 0.02407837, -0.0035381317, 0.0209198, -0.014846802, -0.028289795, 0.017181396, 0.02482605, 0.001824379, -0.0044174194, -0.021621704, 0.00005978346, 0.004562378, 0.013458252, 0.008033752, -0.023513794, 0.009681702, -0.038360596, -0.017486572, 0.004840851, -0.023513794, -0.007904053, 0.017822266, 0.023483276, -0.0071372986, 0.033203125, -0.008972168, 0.015235901, -0.0027179718, -0.056884766, 0.01574707, -0.064575195, -0.02835083, -0.008148193, -0.080566406, 0.02760315, 0.042785645, -0.008659363, 0.009780884, 0.025009155, -0.030059814, 0.0036506653, -0.03579712, 0.015197754, -0.0019989014, -0.028793335, 0.004322052, 0.048614502, 0.022644043, 0.03253174, 0.04989624, -0.049743652, 0.0022602081, -0.023330688, 0.009292603, 0.012802124, -0.014083862, 0.038269043, -0.0057029724, -0.015060425, -0.005958557, 0.004081726, -0.052459717, -0.06048584, 0.012237549, -0.060791016, -0.00623703, -0.014434814, -0.013519287, -0.04699707, 0.0033569336, -0.018249512, 0.005908966, -0.01525116, -0.00079631805, -0.031829834, 0.007003784, -0.0090789795, -0.056610107, 0.007045746, 0.008407593, 0.017440796, -0.008468628, 0.016326904, 0.054382324, 0.01689148, -0.06262207, -0.051696777, -0.05633545, -0.020141602, -0.023406982, 0.09063721, -0.00030136108, -0.01876831, -0.019943237, -0.011878967, 0.02607727, -0.055114746, -0.017059326, 0.017059326, -0.016921997, -0.010879517, -0.009254456, 0.015487671, -0.0032958984, -0.010864258, 0.0012950897, -0.016601562, 0.024765015, 0.011077881, 0.045074463, -0.028793335, -0.05105591, 0.010063171, 0.023086548, 0.019424438, -0.030792236, 0.045410156, 0.009353638, -0.07727051, 0.023162842, 0.0031394958, 0.025924683, -0.008605957, -0.005367279, -0.008140564, 0.015571594, -0.013450623, 0.024978638, 0.031311035, 0.012298584, -0.019714355, -0.022094727, -0.009338379, -0.0063209534, 0.032928467, -0.010475159, 0.03137207, -0.001832962, -0.011474609, -0.053955078, 0.011497498, -0.0027446747, 0.0053482056, -0.03463745, -0.04360962, 0.03439331, 0.036254883, -0.0109939575, 0.02394104, 0.010299683, 0.01889038, -0.01374054, 0.031463623, -0.02519226, -0.0007138252, -0.011054993, 0.025985718, 0.036956787, -0.005344391, -0.030593872, -0.029541016, 0.06604004, 0.028839111, 0.014060974, -0.008987427, -0.025405884, 0.02746582, 0.06744385, 0.0046691895, 0.03652954, 0.02406311, -0.017211914, 0.005317688, -0.034942627, -0.0046691895, -0.030227661, -0.0043144226, 0.05255127, 0.00074005127, 0.0154800415, 0.005039215, 0.005176544, -0.0015983582, 0.038970947, -0.03112793, 0.032836914, 0.023483276, 0.026657104, 0.021377563, 0.03262329, -0.0993042, 0.0054359436, 0.05718994, -0.041046143, 0.000073969364, -0.013130188, 0.02961731, 0.01727295, -0.053100586, -0.017166138, -0.061279297, 0.024978638, -0.037261963, 0.008773804, 0.0071983337, -0.0007777214, 0.047821045, 0.016860962, 0.051452637, -0.032592773, 0.018295288, 0.007701874, -0.0026168823, 0.014953613, 0.000998497, 0.0014514923, 0.013557434, 0.025924683, -0.027999878, 0.002450943, 0.025772095, 0.03414917, 0.002155304, 0.0052490234, 0.006465912, 0.0043907166, -0.0026416779, -0.019760132, -0.052215576, -0.06274414, -0.03543091, 0.030136108, -0.032165527, -0.018310547, -0.030044556, 0.01474762, 0.020843506, -0.012290955, -0.0073242188, -0.0012731552, -0.018585205, 0.023590088, 0.028884888, 0.02267456, -0.017837524, -0.023605347, -0.0019493103, 0.019622803, -0.06878662, 0.021224976, -0.016662598, 0.05770874, 0.050811768, 0.06536865, -0.03286743, 0.023452759, 0.057250977, -0.002773285, 0.049835205, -0.008018494, 0.019989014, 0.0019874573, -0.02609253, 0.0061950684, 0.028900146, 0.0015935898, 0.050964355, -0.01838684, 0.009178162, -0.015960693, -0.024780273, 0.0041923523, -0.010276794, 0.009811401, -0.021331787, 0.014984131, 0.0052108765, 0.012145996, -0.043029785, 0.026992798, -0.008613586, -0.02267456, 0.032684326, 0.01121521, 0.056793213, -0.0023059845, -0.057861328, 0.03250122, -0.011459351, 0.07702637, -0.043060303, -0.013381958, 0.0023403168, 0.018707275, 0.00491333, -0.01890564, -0.014045715, 0.026504517, -0.0024051666, 0.032562256, -0.026168823, 0.0059394836, -0.011314392, -0.022384644, -0.004016876, 0.024932861, -0.0418396, 0.03955078, 0.047302246, -0.013710022, -0.05419922, 0.017044067, -0.031982422, 0.032806396, -0.044799805, -0.01424408, 0.041229248, 0.013084412, -0.0357666, 0.049316406, 0.025436401, 0.042663574, -0.015579224, -0.047546387, -0.011222839, -0.02267456, 0.0065460205, -0.03994751, -0.08630371, 0.01826477, 0.047912598, 0.00819397, -0.048034668, -0.0025844574, -0.013198853, 0.0032081604, 0.010398865, -0.007835388, -0.022033691, 0.01537323, 0.04598999, 0.040863037, -0.01927185, -0.028457642, -0.006038666, -0.015014648, -0.07348633, -0.009590149, 0.06060791, -0.043395996, 0.011512756, 0.010932922, 0.012580872, -0.029296875, 0.015670776, -0.036010742, -0.056396484, 0.0151901245, -0.017059326, -0.017074585, 0.021270752, -0.05496216, 0.04827881, -0.0126953125, -0.03137207, 0.030563354, 0.02255249, 0.018188477, -0.0021038055, 0.01940918, -0.0030136108, -0.02255249, 0.017868042, 0.021575928, 0.017318726, -0.01184845, -0.037322998, 0.015129089, -0.025009155, -0.033569336, -0.08703613, -0.031799316, -0.00002682209, -0.050476074, 0.035369873, -0.0027446747, -0.023376465, 0.02722168, 0.007774353, 0.0066871643, 0.0096588135, -0.0063591003, 0.018753052, -0.010192871, 0.00029230118 ] }
http://arxiv.org/abs/2311.06649v1
A Template Is All You Meme
Luke Bates, Peter Ebert Christensen, Preslav Nakov, Iryna Gurevych
cs.CL
Memes are a modern form of communication and meme templates possess a base semantics that is customizable by whomever posts it on social media. Machine learning systems struggle with memes, which is likely due to such systems having insufficient context to understand memes, as there is more to memes than the obvious image and text. Here, to aid understanding of memes, we release a knowledge base of memes and information found on www.knowyourmeme.com, which we call the Know Your Meme Knowledge Base (KYMKB), composed of more than 54,000 images. The KYMKB includes popular meme templates, examples of each template, and detailed information about the template. We hypothesize that meme templates can be used to inject models with the context missing from previous approaches. To test our hypothesis, we create a non-parametric majority-based classifier, which we call Template-Label Counter (TLC). We find TLC more effective than or competitive with fine-tuned baselines. To demonstrate the power of meme templates and the value of both our knowledge base and method, we conduct thorough classification experiments and exploratory data analysis in the context of five meme analysis tasks.
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2311.06649v1
2023-11-11T19:38:14
2023-11-11T19:38:14
{ "title": [ 0.047729492, -0.00034308434, 0.011756897, -0.03866577, -0.040374756, -0.01651001, -0.018310547, -0.0030765533, 0.006881714, 0.090148926, 0.0016794205, 0.020858765, 0.019821167, -0.0126571655, -0.026367188, 0.03918457, 0.026245117, -0.012016296, -0.031463623, -0.02368164, -0.0011434555, -0.03010559, -0.04727173, 0.032592773, 0.0057792664, -0.0071258545, -0.016738892, -0.02267456, 0.005531311, -0.040527344, -0.0009794235, 0.037841797, 0.02986145, 0.0046577454, -0.017211914, 0.058532715, -0.03451538, 0.016189575, -0.001657486, -0.027389526, 0.0034770966, -0.0066604614, -0.02029419, -0.029724121, -0.040161133, 0.027038574, -0.032684326, -0.014183044, 0.05709839, -0.015335083, 0.010368347, -0.081726074, -0.0021572113, 0.028533936, -0.03677368, 0.028656006, -0.056518555, -0.0154800415, 0.012062073, 0.019805908, 0.0015478134, -0.030822754, 0.06542969, -0.029693604, 0.0048294067, -0.01348114, -0.03439331, 0.009788513, 0.04421997, 0.0146484375, 0.0037822723, -0.027511597, 0.029251099, -0.07574463, 0.043426514, -0.017623901, 0.010986328, 0.02027893, -0.019104004, -0.031021118, -0.023727417, -0.017623901, -0.032196045, -0.015083313, -0.010894775, -0.021560669, -0.005104065, 0.00034165382, 0.005065918, -0.07507324, -0.010360718, 0.017028809, -0.016525269, 0.02583313, -0.026641846, -0.01638794, 0.0041770935, 0.01966858, -0.050994873, -0.0007491112, -0.08325195, 0.01272583, -0.015342712, -0.027053833, -0.010345459, 0.015113831, 0.014274597, 0.021499634, 0.047668457, 0.03781128, 0.009147644, 0.03262329, -0.029434204, 0.034057617, -0.015556335, 0.026626587, -0.03857422, -0.016906738, -0.071899414, 0.014816284, -0.008796692, -0.013626099, 0.08251953, 0.0060424805, -0.023895264, 0.012565613, -0.0075149536, -0.07208252, 0.009681702, -0.0020141602, -0.023208618, 0.060943604, -0.11022949, -0.074035645, -0.051757812, -0.014518738, -0.045654297, -0.03591919, -0.0056152344, 0.021957397, -0.019134521, -0.056427002, 0.028701782, 0.035461426, -0.03933716, 0.008583069, 0.033172607, 0.007965088, -0.020690918, -0.032409668, -0.024551392, 0.018569946, -0.031097412, 0.060150146, 0.01939392, 0.0625, -0.054229736, 0.018417358, 0.048858643, 0.076293945, 0.0067443848, 0.0061454773, 0.028671265, 0.023910522, 0.040405273, -0.012641907, -0.017532349, 0.023773193, 0.013717651, 0.0703125, -0.04119873, -0.00067949295, -0.00504303, -0.0020198822, -0.023147583, 0.01411438, 0.009094238, -0.025238037, 0.0131073, -0.009666443, 0.016098022, -0.018722534, -0.041259766, 0.054748535, -0.045898438, -0.058807373, 0.012397766, 0.011451721, 0.032348633, 0.014694214, 0.025024414, 0.0014390945, 0.0029907227, -0.0025901794, -0.020339966, 0.014808655, -0.03765869, 0.04144287, -0.023040771, -0.002981186, 0.005744934, 0.011207581, 0.0013837814, 0.008598328, -0.0043563843, 0.001411438, 0.000025629997, -0.006072998, 0.02558899, 0.06359863, 0.009132385, 0.0042915344, -0.011520386, -0.023605347, -0.020309448, -0.025741577, -0.013755798, -0.046783447, -0.023223877, 0.010055542, 0.0032196045, 0.013870239, -0.013534546, 0.07891846, 0.023452759, -0.010108948, -0.018844604, -0.014411926, -0.025268555, 0.04156494, -0.037994385, -0.00026082993, -0.029632568, -0.03543091, -0.082336426, -0.028182983, -0.03970337, 0.034698486, 0.00038647652, 0.034179688, -0.0035247803, 0.0002424717, -0.0073394775, 0.042053223, 0.02708435, -0.00340271, 0.016647339, 0.043151855, -0.011688232, -0.0062294006, 0.0030841827, -0.010971069, 0.013671875, -0.04058838, 0.0034389496, 0.033721924, 0.012779236, -0.002035141, -0.01966858, 0.0619812, -0.028793335, 0.07287598, 0.045135498, 0.0044670105, -0.01625061, -0.009178162, -0.008712769, 0.017608643, -0.05392456, 0.019973755, 0.043640137, -0.0019321442, 0.013801575, 0.028839111, -0.01449585, 0.046142578, -0.004714966, -0.032287598, 0.0028190613, 0.03579712, -0.006416321, -0.04473877, 0.02130127, 0.031921387, 0.04046631, -0.0033016205, 0.05319214, 0.04473877, -0.00299263, -0.0066833496, 0.037475586, 0.013641357, -0.011436462, 0.022918701, 0.04626465, 0.00028944016, 0.044403076, 0.01725769, -0.008056641, 0.0053520203, -0.0073013306, 0.037597656, 0.0049972534, 0.012168884, -0.022415161, 0.02482605, 0.009437561, -0.055480957, -0.034820557, -0.053253174, 0.033355713, 0.038360596, 0.0061569214, 0.011070251, -0.008377075, -0.048431396, 0.0071907043, -0.020187378, -0.046325684, -0.025604248, 0.06890869, -0.022521973, -0.02041626, -0.08270264, -0.00497818, -0.017929077, -0.08685303, -0.021911621, -0.03048706, 0.01927185, 0.045898438, -0.040924072, 0.0028514862, -0.11444092, 0.015533447, -0.03010559, 0.014945984, 0.051757812, 0.047790527, 0.026443481, 0.037597656, -0.009124756, -0.017868042, -0.023330688, 0.02658081, -0.015045166, -0.021530151, -0.009727478, -0.038269043, 0.029449463, 0.011894226, 0.013809204, -0.000541687, -0.041656494, 0.038330078, -0.0013694763, -0.019012451, -0.025436401, 0.051696777, -0.06640625, -0.024551392, 0.010276794, -0.02658081, 0.09698486, 0.06982422, -0.08416748, 0.0028018951, 0.0059547424, -0.024734497, 0.0017356873, -0.029403687, -0.019622803, 0.023132324, 0.019683838, -0.007091522, 0.01638794, -0.033416748, -0.06100464, -0.0029907227, -0.030715942, -0.009284973, 0.022384644, 0.017196655, 0.05609131, -0.008872986, 0.0058250427, -0.0057144165, 0.025436401, 0.014961243, 0.00605011, 0.004219055, 0.01625061, -0.032928467, 0.007282257, 0.021118164, -0.018432617, 0.04071045, -0.016693115, -0.080566406, -0.017410278, 0.05319214, -0.01222229, -0.019577026, 0.0007815361, -0.028396606, -0.04348755, 0.016799927, -0.015144348, -0.007297516, 0.034118652, 0.0067977905, 0.043426514, 0.02293396, 0.020431519, 0.018997192, -0.026367188, -0.041992188, 0.0107421875, -0.016448975, 0.010551453, 0.036743164, -0.037353516, -0.0067863464, 0.008415222, -0.04244995, 0.027923584, 0.007858276, 0.02923584, -0.0090789795, -0.040100098, -0.032043457, -0.028137207, -0.007736206, -0.023162842, -0.0060310364, -0.023269653, -0.034332275, 0.0116119385, -0.010902405, -0.008476257, -0.018493652, -0.026138306, -0.0050239563, 0.015670776, -0.034301758, 0.0047416687, -0.009666443, -0.04348755, 0.0039711, -0.01158905, -0.053009033, 0.015052795, -0.027282715, -0.0026130676, -0.019592285, -0.039733887, 0.00844574, 0.03265381, -0.021133423, 0.07562256, 0.07891846, 0.0063591003, -0.035064697, 0.0070610046, -0.0013113022, -0.03604126, 0.06677246, -0.03286743, -0.023864746, 0.021072388, -0.03842163, 0.015388489, 0.008392334, -0.0034713745, -0.013595581, -0.025787354, 0.011428833, 0.04208374, -0.0574646, -0.042510986, 0.020401001, -0.007282257, 0.028381348, -0.0020122528, 0.009140015, 0.021636963, -0.05206299, -0.008110046, 0.008613586, -0.005584717, -0.048675537, 0.030227661, 0.0030708313, -0.032318115, -0.0060577393, -0.012283325, 0.00011700392, 0.0019836426, 0.034698486, -0.016296387, -0.078430176, 0.021102905, -0.0033607483, -0.059051514, 0.021514893, -0.06347656, 0.00333786, 0.013763428, 0.040252686, 0.03668213, 0.040527344, 0.015640259, 0.02456665, 0.006450653, -0.022338867, 0.050323486, -0.025268555, 0.01309967, -0.021072388, -0.00907135, 0.036621094, 0.018035889, 0.014518738, 0.03265381, 0.03677368, -0.032989502, -0.0071907043, -0.014251709, -0.044799805, 0.0047569275, 0.030181885, 0.042297363, 0.06695557, -0.01512146, -0.034973145, -0.03302002, -0.013420105, -0.0010976791, -0.0056381226, -0.051727295, -0.0016317368, -0.0068473816, -0.06304932, 0.0014209747, 0.004764557, -0.011154175, 0.05279541, 0.09277344, -0.0076293945, 0.035980225, 0.04324341, 0.02067566, -0.03579712, -0.00349617, -0.011207581, -0.072021484, -0.025512695, -0.007987976, -0.050567627, 0.01739502, 0.0061531067, 0.012138367, -0.032714844, 0.017028809, 0.029037476, -0.0020046234, 0.01927185, -0.01235199, -0.011291504, -0.02458191, -0.028747559, -0.0069732666, -0.011123657, -0.036376953, 0.011062622, 0.01335144, -0.019882202, 0.010978699, -0.00166893, 0.033294678, 0.049072266, 0.060577393, -0.016311646, 0.060424805, 0.0020542145, 0.03668213, -0.04107666, -0.0064964294, -0.018371582, 0.008956909, 0.0051879883, -0.0066108704, -0.014656067, -0.025650024, 0.023071289, 0.005203247, 0.032043457, -0.017166138, 0.007587433, 0.014556885, -0.002040863, 0.0014953613, 0.01864624, 0.0051994324, 0.03366089, 0.03137207, 0.045684814, 0.026275635, -0.009033203, 0.026550293, -0.008369446, 0.018554688, -0.0050201416, -0.009529114, -0.015670776, 0.0065345764, -0.0029258728, 0.056640625, -0.044525146, -0.051361084, -0.03579712, -0.037261963, -0.008033752, -0.06561279, 0.019042969, 0.018936157, -0.045166016, -0.0006084442, 0.002275467, -0.026107788, -0.00013267994, -0.021530151, -0.0059890747, 0.012123108, 0.032470703, -0.018539429, 0.013313293, -0.023880005, -0.013046265, 0.066833496, 0.00097465515, 0.008659363, -0.040649414, -0.0067100525, 0.02078247, -0.026473999, -0.013557434, -0.006362915, -0.033996582, 0.0009088516, 0.06060791, 0.036621094, 0.020019531, 0.019134521, 0.01398468, 0.029449463, -0.029907227, 0.045654297, -0.028579712, 0.015052795, 0.07122803, 0.09338379, -0.041107178, 0.054504395, 0.013671875, 0.015304565, -0.023086548, 0.04309082, -0.025878906, 0.004524231, 0.02330017, -0.0357666, -0.018463135, -0.0463562, -0.030532837, -0.0017108917, 0.057617188, 0.019241333, 0.043823242, -0.020874023, -0.011802673, -0.0068626404, 0.08026123, -0.035736084, -0.03933716, -0.00459671, -0.014137268, 0.021377563, -0.006187439, -0.0592041, -0.051452637, 0.01737976, -0.028274536, 0.01902771, -0.008628845, 0.012207031, -0.047546387, 0.045440674, 0.049102783, 0.007133484, -0.010749817, 0.016296387, -0.010383606, 0.0036182404, 0.03414917, 0.033691406, 0.012237549, 0.012901306, 0.023513794, -0.0009813309, 0.029724121, 0.029632568, 0.009422302, 0.0012798309, 0.018859863, 0.010055542, 0.056732178, -0.0006971359, -0.007232666, 0.0134887695, -0.022338867, -0.048339844, -0.04925537, 0.0010261536, 0.033569336, -0.04397583, -0.05871582, -0.0073661804, 0.00086307526, -0.008666992, 0.0007853508, -0.011428833, -0.0024433136, -0.019454956, 0.015808105, -0.065979004, -0.014854431, 0.0022201538, -0.048614502, -0.006752014, -0.006099701, -0.0049552917, 0.01499176, 0.007949829, 0.017822266, 0.01940918, -0.014945984, 0.10797119, -0.0016956329, 0.018188477, 0.037994385, 0.02809143, -0.03338623, -0.005683899, -0.00030374527, -0.045135498, -0.043884277, 0.0024871826, 0.004627228, 0.010108948, -0.0904541, -0.019561768, -0.014427185, 0.037353516, 0.01828003, -0.012565613, -0.06414795, 0.024658203, 0.04473877, 0.034301758, -0.009468079, 0.04043579, -0.04119873, -0.047027588, -0.018432617, 0.05895996, -0.024398804, 0.030929565, 0.019134521, 0.027236938, -0.021575928, 0.047821045, 0.004085541, -0.015457153, -0.028442383, -0.011070251, 0.0104904175, 0.055236816, -0.009979248, 0.067993164, 0.001701355, 0.02229309, 0.018249512, 0.007183075, 0.039276123, 0.000099778175, -0.018173218, 0.0077438354, -0.017211914, -0.00894928, 0.053497314, -0.05432129, -0.0010490417, -0.025527954, -0.025726318, -0.10723877, -0.03036499, 0.052337646, 0.017608643, -0.020248413, -0.0037784576, -0.021972656, -0.027664185, 0.00054740906, -0.0075531006, 0.02545166, -0.038848877, 0.000047564507, -0.037872314, -0.038909912, 0.010124207, 0.02760315, 0.00049209595, 0.013809204, -0.0017194748, 0.01889038, 0.018447876, -0.03149414, -0.004196167, 0.003047943, 0.021591187, -0.015357971, 0.050598145, 0.047424316, 0.04550171, 0.026763916, -0.023391724, -0.03353882, 0.013374329, -0.003168106, 0.051727295, -0.027297974, 0.02722168, 0.03173828, -0.016815186, -0.0070152283, -0.0034179688, -0.02407837, 0.025375366, 0.0082473755, 0.064331055, 0.013252258, -0.006095886, 0.017349243, 0.026916504, 0.014251709, 0.037628174, -0.031173706, -0.011428833, -0.009971619, -0.024978638, 0.0049743652, -0.014602661, 0.02027893, 0.06567383, -0.0340271, -0.010688782, 0.004310608, -0.056640625, -0.035980225, 0.009529114, 0.0158844, -0.00035119057, -0.012268066, -0.0107421875, 0.013687134, 0.021743774, -0.02708435, 0.03363037, -0.016525269, 0.04168701, 0.0135650635, 0.041229248, 0.0102005005, -0.021087646, 0.0075263977, 0.0053901672, 0.041229248, 0.026260376, -0.023406982, -0.0076560974, -0.03414917, -0.0022716522, -0.021347046, -0.036468506, -0.01991272, 0.018188477, 0.036895752, -0.031799316, 0.0069465637, -0.012008667, -0.01751709, -0.019134521, 0.02407837, -0.058013916, -0.0037784576, -0.019226074, 0.018722534, -0.027359009, -0.038238525, 0.057037354, 0.026229858, -0.008918762, 0.015319824, -0.015670776, -0.023132324, 0.035858154, 0.019882202, 0.06524658, 0.0026798248, -0.020050049, -0.021560669, 0.016967773, 0.037322998, -0.022750854, -0.02218628, -0.00856781, -0.019302368, -0.013961792, -0.009246826, -0.006504059, -0.015914917, -0.044891357, 0.010673523, 0.017822266, -0.019165039, -0.01763916, 0.0022392273, -0.0072250366, -0.043426514, -0.02293396, 0.0075035095, -0.0005016327, 0.038726807, -0.008125305, -0.009971619, 0.036102295, -0.0076446533, -0.04989624, -0.010223389, 0.0041770935, -0.0127334595, 0.03060913, -0.02015686, 0.02708435, 0.032287598, -0.029006958, -0.046569824, 0.007965088, 0.0011787415, -0.073913574, 0.07904053, 0.0637207, 0.027191162, -0.0012350082, 0.03314209, -0.04031372, -0.017211914, 0.004470825, 0.0018968582, -0.0061683655, -0.00003796816, -0.0035648346, -0.006996155, 0.0043182373, -0.0019350052, -0.021331787, -0.026245117, -0.0446167, -0.036224365, 0.008895874, 0.00087594986, 0.001203537, 0.03475952, -0.014442444, 0.059814453, -0.017745972, 0.034942627, -0.022735596, 0.007030487, 0.051116943, 0.023010254, 0.01473999, -0.008773804, -0.021820068, 0.013809204, -0.015686035, -0.000223279, -0.002029419, -0.019134521, -0.030471802, 0.043762207, 0.04736328, 0.036834717, -0.040863037, 0.050933838, 0.027069092, -0.029846191, -0.03729248, -0.028671265, -0.035736084, 0.053710938, -0.04284668, 0.005760193, 0.0043754578, -0.02835083, -0.0028133392, -0.020217896, -0.00818634, -0.004650116, -0.018753052, -0.038757324, -0.014595032, -0.0069465637 ], "summary": [ 0.027557373, 0.0011749268, 0.041625977, 0.032562256, -0.032348633, -0.0031166077, -0.0071144104, -0.07366943, 0.047424316, 0.021224976, -0.037231445, 0.020217896, 0.00082063675, -0.009887695, -0.014793396, 0.0031166077, 0.0154800415, 0.00699234, -0.0020332336, -0.024597168, -0.010292053, -0.020767212, 0.009643555, -0.010543823, -0.0072784424, -0.034423828, 0.050872803, -0.008125305, 0.010887146, -0.0012922287, 0.008377075, 0.0040740967, 0.052856445, 0.026657104, -0.05432129, 0.07373047, -0.026901245, 0.015182495, 0.0065612793, 0.007835388, -0.011688232, 0.0034542084, 0.08459473, -0.06536865, 0.016143799, 0.06756592, -0.05142212, -0.0602417, 0.024963379, -0.013511658, 0.0046539307, -0.028717041, -0.0031528473, 0.03149414, -0.039367676, 0.00415802, -0.0725708, -0.01966858, 0.022277832, 0.061065674, 0.0289917, -0.026382446, -0.0039749146, -0.03564453, -0.014060974, 0.004295349, 0.024475098, 0.0129776, 0.045074463, -0.010292053, -0.005130768, 0.012382507, 0.0058403015, -0.09844971, -0.005428314, 0.06744385, -0.007472992, -0.00063562393, -0.015541077, -0.046783447, 0.00058221817, -0.010070801, 0.036193848, -0.00012087822, -0.03741455, 0.0059814453, -0.014694214, 0.0028247833, -0.018356323, -0.016677856, -0.023544312, -0.042938232, -0.025177002, 0.062805176, -0.007965088, 0.019683838, 0.021636963, 0.023956299, -0.04699707, -0.052703857, -0.043273926, 0.003955841, -0.06915283, 0.0075531006, 0.006011963, 0.051940918, -0.0073394775, 0.003993988, 0.054656982, 0.019348145, 0.010650635, 0.011138916, -0.025650024, -0.04147339, -0.0055236816, 0.038116455, -0.03302002, 0.01007843, -0.00088357925, 0.007980347, -0.012283325, -0.0026512146, 0.06378174, 0.035339355, 0.017730713, 0.044525146, -0.01953125, -0.04574585, -0.0014543533, 0.068847656, 0.0059280396, 0.015640259, -0.045532227, -0.06439209, -0.076416016, -0.028213501, -0.0140686035, -0.020904541, 0.012252808, 0.0035705566, -0.004108429, -0.021865845, 0.027389526, -0.020202637, -0.0149002075, 0.021621704, 0.021133423, 0.005290985, -0.015716553, -0.019989014, 0.009651184, -0.024627686, 0.032318115, -0.014694214, -0.058807373, -0.022872925, -0.07507324, 0.008331299, 0.003501892, 0.0077590942, 0.029006958, -0.014205933, -0.0010261536, 0.011497498, 0.015731812, 0.020446777, -0.03982544, -0.005344391, 0.007980347, -0.030944824, 0.01210022, -0.017349243, 0.009811401, -0.028335571, -0.0124053955, -0.017089844, 0.020614624, 0.024414062, -0.022399902, 0.018341064, 0.02420044, -0.021530151, -0.006866455, 0.024383545, -0.012687683, -0.022262573, 0.008323669, 0.012702942, 0.036895752, 0.014404297, 0.011665344, -0.015914917, -0.0077705383, 0.021148682, 0.0016269684, -0.0010204315, -0.05178833, 0.02508545, -0.034118652, -0.015899658, 0.04727173, 0.037628174, -0.03237915, -0.025314331, -0.06021118, -0.0028133392, -0.009674072, 0.018447876, -0.0357666, 0.023590088, 0.022064209, -0.019592285, -0.04888916, 0.056121826, 0.022613525, -0.037078857, 0.066833496, 0.0012512207, -0.025741577, -0.020462036, -0.034057617, -0.021026611, -0.062316895, 0.093933105, -0.01889038, 0.017684937, -0.030456543, 0.035217285, -0.06048584, 0.054351807, -0.04147339, -0.009284973, -0.03555298, -0.012748718, -0.013839722, -0.012908936, -0.0030651093, -0.08477783, 0.016830444, 0.04800415, 0.0075798035, 0.01625061, -0.040802002, -0.011627197, 0.04034424, 0.032409668, 0.018295288, 0.013298035, -0.03616333, 0.020690918, 0.026504517, 0.031204224, 0.0061950684, -0.02394104, -0.021392822, 0.017608643, -0.015991211, 0.012962341, -0.017196655, 0.03265381, -0.0138168335, 0.051208496, 0.043121338, 0.003156662, 0.042114258, -0.04373169, 0.018554688, -0.013076782, -0.01449585, -0.0045394897, 0.021896362, -0.062042236, -0.00756073, -0.039367676, -0.019958496, 0.022216797, -0.03878784, 0.03668213, 0.041046143, -0.035858154, 0.0009236336, 0.013702393, -0.05606079, -0.006755829, -0.00033044815, -0.035369873, -0.0060920715, 0.046905518, -0.0038928986, -0.0033912659, -0.007194519, 0.080078125, 0.03289795, -0.00066137314, 0.06060791, 0.0126571655, 0.055755615, 0.00011301041, 0.028747559, -0.03778076, 0.020355225, 0.043151855, -0.059936523, 0.04095459, -0.0035705566, 0.034576416, 0.03555298, -0.018600464, 0.0005054474, -0.01537323, -0.0063591003, 0.008666992, -0.0006828308, 0.050567627, -0.07287598, -0.066101074, -0.024307251, 0.00025510788, -0.055633545, 0.007835388, 0.099243164, 0.012832642, 0.01083374, -0.021774292, 0.003211975, -0.037841797, -0.007926941, -0.016723633, -0.088256836, 0.010269165, -0.003753662, -0.07318115, -0.021377563, -0.036987305, -0.005886078, -0.0053596497, 0.013809204, 0.033203125, 0.004146576, -0.035980225, 0.030166626, -0.022262573, -0.0155181885, 0.014091492, -0.028045654, 0.007118225, 0.00022089481, -0.0040397644, -0.017684937, -0.002067566, 0.004852295, -0.011016846, -0.037231445, 0.022994995, 0.004924774, 0.007118225, 0.03842163, -0.027252197, -0.01651001, -0.049865723, -0.026519775, 0.01424408, -0.01524353, 0.05529785, 0.00749588, -0.027832031, -0.0044937134, 0.030654907, 0.020065308, 0.06896973, -0.027755737, 0.01890564, 0.017120361, 0.0138168335, 0.014282227, 0.010505676, 0.0004017353, -0.037200928, 0.023239136, 0.0012044907, -0.0067481995, -0.003364563, 0.020202637, -0.007545471, -0.016479492, 0.038482666, -0.016616821, 0.013572693, -0.029403687, -0.004787445, -0.03225708, 0.021484375, 0.010620117, 0.0019760132, -0.035064697, -0.03579712, 0.059631348, 0.018341064, -0.02267456, -0.03805542, -0.027999878, 0.020950317, 0.024429321, -0.0084991455, -0.032989502, 0.041534424, -0.034973145, -0.011871338, 0.009521484, 0.058166504, 0.028213501, -0.027923584, 0.041656494, -0.010894775, 0.026138306, -0.02154541, 0.019424438, 0.0012159348, -0.008728027, -0.0057525635, 0.028671265, 0.0141067505, 0.01600647, 0.013824463, -0.015037537, 0.01259613, -0.0072898865, 0.05026245, -0.04071045, -0.031188965, -0.014038086, -0.04916382, 0.01586914, -0.0015497208, -0.0513916, 0.0037441254, 0.006614685, 0.030014038, 0.03591919, -0.060791016, -0.0019874573, -0.016052246, 0.020843506, 0.009559631, 0.005180359, 0.01486969, 0.006942749, 0.002817154, 0.05130005, 0.03930664, -0.011009216, -0.005153656, 0.025604248, -0.001452446, -0.049560547, -0.05819702, -0.018798828, 0.022415161, 0.032836914, -0.026794434, 0.0013151169, -0.0013456345, -0.054656982, -0.007133484, 0.0029277802, -0.01739502, 0.055419922, -0.0011548996, -0.0362854, 0.029037476, -0.00031638145, -0.031982422, -0.009490967, -0.031677246, 0.023101807, -0.0015010834, 0.021911621, -0.002878189, -0.0030994415, -0.028656006, -0.054718018, 0.027145386, -0.033203125, -0.10687256, -0.04458618, 0.019592285, -0.08807373, -0.0847168, -0.015274048, 0.0101623535, -0.041168213, 0.021987915, 0.010696411, 0.016403198, 0.015396118, 0.009780884, -0.011627197, 0.09490967, 0.016952515, -0.050933838, -0.027648926, -0.016693115, 0.03640747, -0.023071289, -0.015090942, 0.002773285, 0.056427002, -0.004009247, 0.024124146, 0.039794922, 0.042175293, -0.016906738, -0.020233154, 0.008033752, -0.010231018, 0.03527832, 0.00019824505, 0.009765625, -0.01134491, -0.009567261, 0.04336548, 0.0690918, 0.007511139, -0.010238647, 0.010040283, 0.0030651093, -0.012840271, 0.022247314, -0.015281677, -0.012435913, 0.024215698, 0.04333496, -0.008560181, -0.01272583, 0.022232056, -0.04046631, -0.019363403, -0.0362854, -0.043121338, 0.020324707, -0.028823853, 0.032806396, 0.054779053, 0.027008057, 0.019607544, 0.026885986, 0.009773254, -0.01285553, -0.02243042, -0.021026611, -0.04348755, -0.010910034, -0.043792725, -0.022094727, 0.014472961, -0.057495117, -0.018234253, 0.018035889, 0.0006122589, -0.0096588135, 0.033477783, -0.00021409988, -0.00141716, -0.006504059, 0.017807007, -0.002105713, -0.056732178, -0.078430176, -0.0016307831, -0.027328491, -0.045532227, -0.03677368, -0.035583496, -0.09210205, 0.009254456, 0.0209198, -0.033294678, -0.00060367584, 0.011108398, 0.06695557, 0.065979004, 0.04486084, -0.071899414, 0.054718018, -0.008262634, 0.034301758, -0.024154663, 0.011947632, 0.0012674332, -0.00047516823, -0.018676758, 0.00024938583, -0.03656006, -0.038085938, 0.026977539, 0.026351929, 0.032440186, 0.0016326904, 0.015701294, 0.022598267, 0.0065231323, 0.01689148, -0.004432678, 0.0041389465, 0.0022945404, 0.021820068, 0.030349731, 0.036102295, 0.0040740967, 0.058410645, 0.018966675, -0.019470215, -0.009757996, -0.0026893616, 0.009414673, 0.0066833496, -0.00020122528, 0.059448242, 0.010070801, -0.0065193176, -0.018630981, -0.008232117, -0.019439697, -0.043640137, 0.034118652, 0.044433594, -0.031188965, 0.031280518, 0.008377075, -0.020721436, 0.0126953125, -0.02494812, -0.008804321, -0.04647827, -0.0056533813, 0.064331055, -0.009887695, -0.033355713, -0.07696533, -0.016555786, 0.048553467, 0.013763428, -0.0423584, -0.03012085, -0.016983032, 0.015396118, -0.011543274, -0.032958984, -0.021148682, 0.0045661926, 0.08532715, 0.01689148, 0.009925842, -0.03753662, 0.0131073, -0.0067214966, -0.027191162, 0.012130737, -0.048828125, 0.022628784, 0.009597778, 0.0440979, -0.051971436, 0.05581665, 0.021148682, 0.027648926, -0.032806396, 0.03225708, -0.03201294, 0.006362915, 0.0038642883, -0.036071777, -0.005680084, -0.030395508, -0.024932861, 0.031951904, 0.035461426, 0.011062622, 0.012794495, -0.019241333, -0.025421143, -0.06323242, 0.037231445, -0.039520264, 0.00806427, 0.0047035217, 0.042236328, 0.026611328, -0.02897644, 0.0032138824, -0.037597656, 0.017105103, -0.008026123, 0.031234741, -0.0052375793, -0.01914978, -0.055664062, 0.015029907, 0.029190063, 0.021072388, 0.0021705627, -0.0043678284, -0.017044067, -0.025466919, -0.0044136047, 0.0031757355, -0.011665344, -0.0046310425, 0.016021729, 0.010398865, -0.011787415, 0.013420105, -0.002735138, -0.034576416, 0.017578125, -0.0047569275, 0.021621704, -0.022109985, -0.009597778, 0.021743774, -0.0020599365, 0.017471313, -0.021759033, -0.040161133, 0.0012340546, -0.04751587, -0.04647827, 0.017730713, -0.014877319, -0.01876831, 0.019943237, -0.039489746, -0.006526947, -0.015930176, 0.0036830902, -0.09008789, -0.014854431, 0.015457153, -0.016540527, -0.0047569275, -0.045776367, -0.010032654, 0.022506714, 0.0037631989, 0.056274414, 0.022140503, 0.020874023, 0.08496094, -0.017852783, 0.041381836, 0.04034424, -0.05734253, 0.02267456, -0.037139893, 0.015571594, -0.07336426, -0.02859497, 0.0044174194, 0.041259766, -0.03125, -0.031982422, 0.01210022, -0.017822266, -0.01751709, 0.006828308, -0.01473999, 0.008163452, 0.029876709, -0.03225708, -0.022399902, 0.0138168335, -0.0067977905, -0.021102905, -0.018310547, 0.0579834, -0.0013217926, -0.03894043, 0.053100586, 0.0126571655, 0.031341553, -0.019088745, 0.061157227, -0.024398804, -0.011360168, -0.0026054382, 0.013717651, 0.034606934, -0.012008667, 0.0093307495, 0.022232056, -0.0008382797, 0.016204834, -0.017593384, -0.020965576, -0.040496826, 0.0036563873, 0.05883789, -0.01586914, 0.0017595291, -0.0107040405, 0.05996704, -0.029266357, -0.020965576, -0.07421875, -0.061767578, 0.001578331, 0.011779785, -0.04421997, -0.058929443, 0.06530762, -0.017959595, -0.008117676, 0.038879395, -0.05090332, 0.03778076, -0.039367676, -0.046325684, -0.036865234, 0.021484375, -0.03213501, 0.015159607, 0.0541687, -0.03930664, 0.031311035, -0.018615723, 0.02041626, -0.014801025, -0.019577026, 0.0011119843, -0.08081055, 0.0027980804, -0.04498291, 0.04196167, 0.025405884, 0.0496521, 0.026550293, -0.003227234, -0.023330688, -0.011634827, 0.006401062, -0.010093689, 0.008224487, -0.02456665, -0.005104065, 0.00088739395, 0.0025405884, -0.0024719238, -0.013656616, 0.054504395, 0.04647827, 0.037261963, -0.05517578, 0.006629944, 0.008621216, -0.015731812, -0.027420044, 0.008895874, -0.027297974, -0.012435913, -0.009559631, -0.014312744, 0.009414673, -0.021759033, 0.008964539, 0.04309082, 0.012969971, 0.035736084, 0.001917839, 0.010292053, 0.0028572083, 0.021697998, -0.010047913, -0.012908936, 0.01953125, -0.010269165, -0.001250267, 0.017959595, 0.0029087067, 0.009880066, -0.023498535, 0.07299805, 0.044708252, 0.067871094, -0.047302246, 0.008926392, 0.05899048, 0.012191772, 0.035064697, 0.058563232, -0.0054359436, -0.06591797, -0.0042533875, -0.015037537, -0.025482178, 0.014724731, 0.046203613, -0.027130127, 0.0211792, 0.0031032562, -0.02708435, -0.021255493, 0.006164551, 0.0020256042, 0.029891968, -0.03149414, 0.010765076, 0.01184845, -0.029281616, -0.020828247, -0.035186768, -0.0107803345, -0.027328491, 0.030822754, 0.0362854, -0.011184692, -0.00434494, 0.008178711, 0.0005021095, 0.07836914, -0.015670776, -0.009437561, 0.030212402, -0.01109314, 0.0064888, -0.035217285, -0.012779236, 0.0014791489, 0.017684937, -0.03817749, 0.011665344, 0.022476196, -0.030151367, -0.08508301, -0.034820557, -0.002275467, -0.048919678, -0.026000977, 0.017974854, -0.0016679764, -0.022506714, -0.029251099, -0.0016241074, 0.007091522, 0.0335083, 0.005126953, -0.03945923, 0.049224854, -0.026748657, -0.07922363, -0.043640137, -0.06329346, 0.0010728836, 0.025619507, -0.0317688, 0.014549255, 0.02218628, -0.054504395, -0.0118637085, 0.0018720627, 0.02859497, 0.010055542, 0.014854431, -0.00969696, -0.004966736, 0.0017929077, 0.044677734, 0.008728027, -0.023757935, 0.009483337, 0.029434204, -0.022262573, 0.010513306, 0.022628784, -0.01626587, 0.025985718, -0.03778076, -0.020706177, -0.05657959, 0.000726223, -0.054382324, 0.015731812, -0.0017709732, 0.00080156326, 0.0043029785, 0.013504028, 0.021896362, -0.010421753, 0.020736694, -0.008392334, -0.0013771057, 0.0103302, 0.022613525, 0.025222778, -0.026397705, -0.039642334, 0.013198853, 0.010314941, 0.017669678, -0.0090789795, -0.045043945, -0.013679504, 0.0018577576, 0.013763428, -0.0013618469, -0.04849243, 0.032196045, 0.0069885254, -0.01260376, -0.0006380081, -0.093444824, -0.037353516, 0.039611816, -0.0045547485, -0.01940918, 0.015167236, -0.013145447, 0.02067566, 0.017074585, 0.046417236, 0.01146698, 0.01600647, 0.008026123, 0.011260986, -0.0018424988 ] }