id
stringlengths 9
15
| text
stringlengths 1.28k
134k
| reference-summary
stringlengths 244
1.81k
|
|---|---|---|
1512.03812 | for the hybrid monte carlo algorithm ( hmc)@xcite , often used to study quantum chromodynamics ( qcd ) on the lattice , one is interested in efficient numerical time integration schemes which are optimal in terms of computational costs per trajectory for a given acceptance rate . high order numerical methods allow the use of larger step sizes , but demand a larger computational effort per step ; low order schemes do not require such large computational costs per step , but need more steps per trajectory . so there is a need to balance these opposing effects . omelyan integration schemes @xcite of a force - gradient type have proved to be an efficient choice , since it is easy to obtain higher order schemes that demand a small additional computational effort . these schemes use higher - order information from force - gradient terms to both increase the convergence of the method and decrease the size of the leading error coefficient . other ideas to achieve better efficiency for numerical time integrators are given by multirate or nested approaches . these schemes do not increase the order but reduce the computational costs per path by recognizing the different dynamical time - scales generated by different parts of the action . slow forces , which are usually expensive to evaluate , need only to be sampled at low frequency while fast forces which are usually cheap to evaluate need to be sampled at a high frequency . a natural way to inherit the advantages from both force - gradient type schemes and multirate approaches would be to combine these two ideas . previously , we studied the behavior of the adapted nested force - gradient scheme for the example of the @xmath0-body problem @xcite and would like to learn more about their usefulness for lattice field theory calculations . due to the huge computational effort required for qcd simulations , it is natural to attempt an intermediate step first . we chose the model problem of quantum electrodynamics ( qed ) in two dimensions , the schwinger model @xcite , since it is well - suited as a test case for new concepts and ideas which can be subsequently applied to more computationally demanding problems @xcite . as a lattice quantum field theory , it has many of the properties of more sophisticated models such as qcd , for example the numerical cost is still dominated by the fermion part of the action . the fact that this model , with far fewer degrees of freedom , does not require such large computational effort makes it the perfect choice for testing purposes . we compare the behavior of numerical time integration schemes currently used for hmc @xcite with the nested force - gradient integrator @xcite and the adapted version introduced in @xcite . we investigate the computational costs needed to perform numerical calculations , as well as the effort required to achieve a satisfactory acceptance rate during the hmc evolution . our goal is to find a numerical scheme for the hmc algorithm which would provide a sufficiently high acceptance rate while not drastically increasing the simulation time . the paper is organized as follows . in section 2 we give a short overview of the hmc algorithm and numerical schemes for time integration , which are used in hmc . in section 3 we present the 2-dimensional schwinger model and introduce the idea of the force - gradient approach and the resulting novel class of numerical schemes . section 4 is devoted to the results of a comparison between widely used algorithms and the new approach and section 5 draws our conclusion . in this section we provide a general overview of the hmc algorithm @xcite to introduce our novel integrator . we also present some standard numerical time integrating methods used in hmc , as well state - of - the - art numerical schemes , which we later compare by applying them to the two - dimensional schwinger model . in the hybrid monte carlo algorithm , the quantum lattice field theory is embedded in a higher - dimensional classical system through the introduction of a fictitious ( simulation ) time @xcite . the gauge field @xmath1 is associated with its ( fictitious ) conjugate momenta @xmath2 , and the classical system is described by the hamiltonian , @xmath3 + { \mathcal{b}}[u],\ ] ] where @xmath4 $ ] and @xmath5 $ ] represent the kinetic and potential energy respectively . for a given configuration @xmath1 , a new configuration @xmath6 is generated by performing an hmc update @xmath7 , which consists of two steps : * * molecular dynamics trajectory : * evolve the gauge fields @xmath1 , elements of a lie group , and the momenta @xmath2 , elements of the corresponding lie algebra , in a fictitious computer time @xmath8 according to hamilton s equations of motions @xmath9 since analytical solutions are not available in general , numerical methods must be used to solve the system of eqn . . the discrete updates of @xmath1 and @xmath2 with an integration step @xmath10 are @xmath11 leading to a first - order approximation at time @xmath12 . since the momenta @xmath2 are elements of lie algebra , we have an additive update of @xmath2 . on the other hand , the links @xmath1 must be elements of the lie group , therefore an exponential update is used for @xmath1 to preserve the underlying group structure . * * metropolis step : * accept or reject the new configuration @xmath13 with probability @xmath14 where @xmath15 . in this paper we are concerned with numerical time integration schemes , which preserve the fundamental properties of geometric integration , time - reversibility and volume - preservation . all numerical schemes presented below possess these necessary properties . * basic schemes : * well - known , commonly used integration schemes in molecular dynamics are given by * the leap - frog method , a 3-stage composition scheme of the discrete updates defined above : @xmath16 * and a 5-stage extension widely used in qcd computations : @xmath17 * force gradient schemes : * force - gradient schemes increase accuracy by using additional information from the force gradient term @xmath18 , with @xmath19 defining lie brackets . the 5-stage force - gradient scheme proposed by omelyan et al @xcite is the simplest ; @xmath20 here we also test the modification of the force - gradient method proposed in @xcite , where the force - gradient term @xmath21 is approximated via a taylor expansion . an extension is given by the 11-stage decomposition @xcite , recently implemented as the integrator in the open source code openqcd as one of the standard options @xcite @xmath22where @xmath23 , @xmath24 , @xmath25 and @xmath26 are parameters from equation ( 71 ) in ref . @xcite . * nested schemes : * qed and qcd problems usually lead to hamiltonians with the following fine structure @xmath27 + { \mathcal{b}}_{1}[u]+ { \mathcal{b}}_{2}[u],\ ] ] where the action of the system can be split into two parts : a fast action @xmath28 such as the gauge action , and a slow part @xmath29 , for example , the fermion action . this allows us to apply the idea of multirate schemes ( an idea known as nested integration in physics literature)@xcite in order to reduce the computational effort . at first we consider the nested version of the leap - frog method @xmath30 where the inner cheaper system @xmath31+{\mathcal{b}}_{1}[u]$ ] is solved by @xmath32 with @xmath33 being a number of iterations for the fast part of the action . our main goal is to compare the above - mentioned methods with more elaborated nested schemes : in @xcite , a similar 5-stage decomposition scheme has been recently introduced : @xmath34 a nested version of , which has been used in @xcite reads @xmath35 where @xmath36 with @xmath37 and @xmath38 . in the limit @xmath39 we have @xmath40 . note that this approach uses force - gradient information at all levels , i.e. , the high computational cost of high order schemes appears at all levels . one may overcome this problem by using schemes of different order at the different levels without losing the effective high order of the overall multirate scheme . for the latter , we include appropriate force gradient information as we explain in the following for the case of two time levels , where the gauge action plays the role of the fast and cheap part , and the fermionic action plays the role of the slow and expensive part . the reasoning is as follows : if one uses the 5-stage sexton - weingarten integrator of second order for the slow action , and approximates the fast action by @xmath41 leap - frog steps of step size @xmath42 , the error of the overall multirate scheme will be of order @xmath43 . with the use of force gradient information only at the slowest level it is possible to cancel the leading error term of order @xmath44 . as @xmath45 usually holds in the multirate setting , the overall order is then given by the leading error term of order @xmath46 , i.e. , the scheme has an effective order of four . one example for such a scheme for problems of type is given by the 5-stage nested force - gradient scheme introduced in @xcite @xmath47 to summarize , the adapted scheme differs from the original one in two perspectives : * the force gradient scheme for the fast action is replaced by a leap - frog scheme . * only the part @xmath48 of the full force gradient @xmath49 is needed to gain the effective order of four . the numerical schemes - and - are second order convergent schemes . methods - and - have the fourth order of convergence . we do not consider integrators of higher order than four since the computational costs are too high . the schemes of the same convergence order differ from each other by the number of stages ( updates of momenta and links per time step ) . usually methods with more stages have smaller leading error coefficients and therefore have better accuracy , but higher computational costs . we would like to determine which integrator would represent the best compromise between high accuracy and computational efficiency . we will apply all these numerical integration schemes to the two - dimensional schwinger model . the most challenging task from the theoretical point of view is to derive the force - gradient term @xmath21 . in the next section we introduce the schwinger model and explain how to obtain the force - gradient term . the 2 dimensional schwinger model is defined by the following hamiltonian function @xmath50 = \frac{1}{2}\sum_{n=1,\mu=1}^{v,2 } p_{n,\mu}^2 + s_g[u ] + s_f[u].}\ ] ] with @xmath51 the volume of the lattice . unlike qcd , where @xmath52 and @xmath53 , for this qed problem , the links @xmath1 are the elements of the lie group @xmath54 and the momenta @xmath55 belong to @xmath56 , which represents the lie algebra of the group @xmath54 . this makes this test example very cheap in terms of the computational time . this together with the fact that the schwinger model also shares many of the features of qcd simulations , makes the schwinger model an excellent test example when considering numerical integrators : a fast dynamics given by the computationally cheap gauge part @xmath57 $ ] of the action demanding small step sizes , and a slow dynamics given by the computationally expensive fermion part @xmath58 $ ] allowing large step sizes . the pure gauge part of the action @xmath59 sums up over all plaquettes @xmath60 in the two - dimensional lattice with @xmath61 and is given by @xmath62 the links @xmath1 can be written in the form @xmath63 and connect the sites @xmath0 and @xmath64 on the lattice ; @xmath65 $ ] , @xmath66 , @xmath67 @xmath68 are respectively space and time directions and @xmath69 is a coupling constant . note that from now on we will set the lattice spacing @xmath70 . the fermion part of the action @xmath71 is given by @xmath72 where @xmath26 is a complex pseudofermion field . here , @xmath73 denotes the wilson dirac operator given by @xmath74 where @xmath75 are the pauli matrices @xmath76 @xmath77 is the mass parameter and the kronecker delta @xmath78 acts on the pseudofermion field by @xmath79 with @xmath80 the pseudofermion field , a vector in the two - dimensional spinor space taking values at each lattice point @xmath0 . in order to proceed with the numerical integration we need to obtain the force @xmath81 and the force gradient term @xmath21 . the force term @xmath82 with respect to the link @xmath83 is given by the first derivative of the action @xmath84 and can be written as @xmath85 since the numerical schemes use the multi - rate approach , the shifts in the momenta updates are split on @xmath86 and @xmath87 and we can consider them separately . the force terms @xmath86 and @xmath87 are obtained by differentiation over @xmath54 group elements , which for the schwinger model is the standard differentiation . the force associated with link @xmath88 from the gauge action is given by @xmath89 the force term of the fermion part is given by @xmath90 \,\ ] ] where vectors @xmath91 and @xmath92 are given @xmath93 for the numerical methods and we need to find the force gradient term @xmath94 with respect to the link @xmath83 . in case of the schwinger model this term reads @xmath95 for simplicity we decompose the force gradient term in four parts @xmath96 this decomposition is also useful since the numerical integrator only uses the term @xmath97 by construction . as shown in @xcite , to obtain the fourth order convergent scheme from the second order convergent method we must eliminate the leading error term , which is exactly represented by @xmath97 . for completeness we discuss all 4 parts below . the @xmath98 part of the force - gradient term is @xmath99 \end{aligned}\ ] ] with the set of plaquettes @xmath100 then by using the vectors @xmath101 defined in we obtain the @xmath102 piece of the force - gradient term given by @xmath103 . } \end{aligned}\ ] ] the second derivative of the fermion action is @xmath104 \xi + } \nonumber \\ & & { 2 \operatorname{re } \chi^\dagger \frac{\partial d}{\partial q_\mu(n ) } ( d^\dagger d)^{-1 } \frac{\partial d^\dagger}{\partial q_\nu(m ) } \chi \ , , } \nonumber \\ & & { = 2 \operatorname{re } \left [ z_{1,m,\nu}^\dagger \frac{\partial d}{\partial q_{\mu}(n ) } \xi + \chi^\dagger \frac{\partial d}{\partial q_{\mu}(n ) } d^{-1 } w_{2,m,\nu } - \chi^\dagger \frac{\partial^2 d}{\partial q_{\nu}(m ) \partial q_{\mu}(n ) } \xi + \chi^\dagger \frac{\partial d}{\partial q_{\mu}(n ) } d^{-1 } z_{1,m,\nu}\right ] } \nonumber \\ & & { = 2 \textrm{re } \left [ z_{1,m,\nu}^\dagger w_{2,n,\mu } + w_{1,n,\mu}^\dagger z_{2,m,\nu } - \chi^\dagger \frac{\partial^2 d}{\partial q_{\nu}(m ) \partial q_{\mu}(n ) } \xi \right ] } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in terms of the vectors @xmath105 and @xmath92 defined in . now the fields @xmath106 and @xmath107 are given by @xmath108 with @xmath109 in order to calculate @xmath110 and @xmath111 it is possible to perform the summation of @xmath112 before the inversions of @xmath73 and @xmath113 to get @xmath114 and @xmath115 which save @xmath116 additional inversions for the force gradient terms . it follows for the force gradient term @xmath111 @xmath117\ ] ] with @xmath118 + z_1 \right ) \ , . \end{aligned}\ ] ] the expression for @xmath110 can be obtained from the one for @xmath111 by replacing in and the vector @xmath119 with @xmath120 defined in . it is important to mention that the computationally most demanding part of the numerical integration of the schwinger model and quantum field theory in general is the inverse of the dirac operator @xmath121 . every momenta update , which includes fermion action requires 2 inversions of the dirac operator , the addition of the force - gradient term @xmath21 requires 4 more inversions . therefore leap - frog based methods and need 4 computations of @xmath121 per time step ; schemes and 6 times ; force - gradient based methods 8 for and , 10 for and the 11 stage method has 12 inversions of the dirac operator . since we use the multi - rate approach for schemes , and , which leads generally to fewer macro time steps needed than for the standard schemes we expect the integrator will be the most efficient choice among the methods considered . in the next section we present numerical tests of this prediction . in this section we apply the numerical integrators to compute the molecular dynamics step for the schwinger model when studied with the hmc algorithm . we consider a @xmath122 by @xmath122 lattice with a coupling constant @xmath123 and mass @xmath124 . the parameters were taken from @xcite and correspond to the scaling variable @xmath125 defined in @xcite.we have chosen them to simulate close to the scaling limit with light fermions and also to increase the impact of the fermion part of the action . we use one thermalised gauge configuration . for each integrator and value of the step - size we generate @xmath126 independent sets of momenta and integrate the equations of motion on a trajectory of length @xmath127 . we compute the absolute error @xmath128 and estimate its statistical error from the standard deviation . also the parameter @xmath33 is chosen in such a way to make micro step size to be @xmath129 times smaller than the macro step size @xmath10 . figure [ fig:1 ] presents the comparison between the numerical integrators . it shows the absolute error @xmath128 versus the step - size of the numerical scheme . here the multi - rate schemes , , and outperform their standard versions as expected . also it is easy to see that the scheme has the best accuracy and the nested force - gradient method just slightly edges the adapted nested force - gradient scheme . figure [ fig:2 ] presents the cpu time , required for the proposed integrators , versus the achieved accuracy . we can observe that the nested force - gradient method and adapted nested force- gradient method show much better results in terms of a computational efficiency than the integrators and ; and even compared to the 11 stage scheme . here we can see that the modification of proposed in @xcite also performs better than its original version . it shows almost similar computational costs as nested versions of the force - gradient approach - , since it has the same number of @xmath121 ( see table [ tab:1 ] ) . but it is less efficient because the proposed nested approach is more precise . .step - sizes and number of inversions of @xmath73 per step and per trajectory for acceptance rate of 90% [ cols="^,^,^,^,^",options="header " , ] table [ tab:1 ] shows the number of inversions of the dirac operator @xmath73 , which is needed to reach 90% acceptance rate of the hmc . since @xmath121 is the most computationally demanding part it is important to see how many of these inversions are required per each trajectory . from table [ tab:1 ] it easy to see that the adapted nested force - gradient method and nested force - gradient method need the least number of @xmath121 per trajectory to reach the chosen acceptance rate @xmath130 . we can also claim that methods and have a potential to perform even better with respect to the computational effort in the case of lattice qcd problems , since the impact of the fermion action and the computational time to obtain the inversion of the dirac operator @xmath73 is much more significant . we presented the nested force - gradient approach and its adapted version applied to a model problem in quantum field theory , the two - dimensional schwinger model . the derivation of the force - gradient terms was given and the schwinger model was introduced . nested force - gradient schemes seem to be an optimal choice with relatively high convergence order and low computational effort . also it would be possible to improve the algorithm by measuring the poisson brackets of the shadow hamiltonian of the proposed integrator and then tuning the set of optimal parameters , e. g. micro and macro step sizes . + in future work we will apply this approach to the hmc algorithm for numerical integration in lattice qcd . here we expect the adapted nested - force gradient scheme to outperform the original one , if we further partition the action into more than two parts , by using techniques to factorize the fermion determinant : less force - gradient information is needed for the most expensive action , and only leap - frog steps are needed for the high frequency parts of the action . this work is part of project b5 within the sfb / transregio 55 _ hadronenphysik mit gitter - qcd _ funded by dfg ( deutsche forschungsgemeinschaft ) . s. duane , a.d . kennedy , b.j . pendleton , d. roweth , hybrid monte carlo , phys . b195 ( 1987 ) , pp . e. hairer , c. lubich , g. wanner , geometric numerical integration : structure - preserving algorithms for ordinary differential equations , springer , berlin , 2002 . omelyan , i.m . mryglod , r. folk , symplectic analytically integrable decomposition algorithms : classification , derivation , and application to molecular dynamics , quantum and celestial mechanics , comput . 151 ( 2003 ) , pp . | we study a novel class of numerical integrators , the adapted nested force - gradient schemes , used within the molecular dynamics step of the hybrid monte carlo ( hmc ) algorithm . we test these methods in the schwinger model on the lattice , a well known benchmark problem . we derive the analytical basis of nested force - gradient type methods and demonstrate the advantage of the proposed approach , namely reduced computational costs compared with other numerical integration schemes in hmc . |
0807.5065 | one of the main goals of the search for periodic isolated sources of gravitational waves ( g.w . ) is to perform all sky surveys , based on `` blind searches '' , where the source parameters are unknown . in this case hierarchical procedures are applied , based on a sequence of increasing resolution steps . in this paper we study in details the problem of sensitivity loss due to discretization of parameters and to the needs to limit the computing cost , with hough procedures . in particular , we propose and study the characteristics of a frequency hough procedure , designed mainly to reduce the discretization problem , and we compare it with the sky hough procedure , which is actually used in the virgo collaboration . + the paper is organized as follows : in sect . 2 we present the basic scheme of the rome hierarchical procedure , based on the main idea of coincidences among subsets of data ; in sect . 3 we discuss the limits due to digitization of the sky hough procedure ; in sects . 4 , 5 we present the new frequency hough procedure , discussing details its implementation and its basic characteristics ; in sect . 6 we present the study of amplitude losses due to digitization , and thus efficiencies , for both the procedures . conclusions and comments are given in sect . hierarchical procedures , based on hough transform algorithms , are applied by various groups in the g.w . community . see , for example , references @xcite . there are various ways of implementing the hierarchical procedure and the hough transform . the hough transform is a linear transform that is used to recognize the parameters of the analytical description of a curve from the position of some points on it . it operates on an `` image '' of points , in our case the peakmap in the time - frequency plane . for each peak of this map we increase a set of bins of a multi - dimensional histogram ( in our case a two - dimensional histogram ) defined on the parameters space , called the hough map . in the old procedure , the parameter space was the position of the source , i.e. the celestial sphere , and we fixed the spin down value for each hough map . in the new one , the parameter space is the plane @xmath0 , and for each hough map , we fix the position of the source . the mapping ( i.e. which points of the hough map must be increased for a certain point in the peakmap ) can be done in different ways : we use always what we call the `` biunivocal mapping '' , i.e. a mapping in which every point in the hough map derive from a single point of the peakmap at a given time . it is easy to demonstrate that in this case the mapping is also uniform , i.e. in the case of uniformly distributed random dots in the peakmap , the expected value of the hough map @xmath1 is a constant ( for all parameter value ) . this value , depending on the number n of the spectra of the peakmap and on the mapping , defines the `` noise '' of the map . it is binomially distributed with parameters n and @xmath2 . we will refer here to the rome scheme , presently used in virgo data . [ fig : schema ] shows the basic scheme of the rome hierarchical procedure . details on the main aspects of the procedure are given in references @xcite . after data cleaning ( short time domain disturbances removal ) and `` short ffts data base '' ( sfdb ) creation , peakmaps are computed , using a very refined auto - regressive algorithm to equalize the spectral data by an appropriate follow - up of the noise . peakmaps are frequency vs time maps , obtained from equalized spectra by selecting all the local maxima above a chosen threshold . an accurate cleaning of peakmaps , by removing known noise lines and the more persistent lines , is needed and its implementation is critical for the next step analysis . on the cleaned peakmaps , methods of peaks detection are applied . that is , transformation from the input plane to the hough plane , thresholding and first order candidates selection . candidate parameters are defined by source frequency , celestial coordinates , first spin - down parameter . the need for coincidences among candidates obtained in different subsets of data ( two in the scheme of fig . [ fig : schema ] ) has been discussed in references @xcite . this method is very efficient to reduce the number of spurious candidates at a fixed threshold . thus , for a given false alarm probability , we can lower the threshold -with respect to the choice of not doing coincidences- gaining in detection efficiency . the method has a better efficiency when the data sets have similar sensitivities . after the coincidence , the survived candidates are analyzed coherently with longer ffts on corrected data . then the spectral filtering is used to take into account the spread of the power in five bands , as explained in reference @xcite . finally , second order candidates are produced . as stated before , the sky hough method shows amplitude losses , and thus loss of sensitivity , which are due to digitization of parameters . this effect shows up mainly for the complexity of the transform together with the need of reducing the computing cost : * the method is based on a transform between the time - frequency peakmap and the celestial sphere . it is not simple for the non linearity of the mapping ; * to reduce the computational effort , we need to use `` look - up tables '' which introduce further digitization errors ; * to reduce the computational effort , fast algorithms have been developed , which require the use of a rectangular grid to map the sky . compared to the `` optimal '' ( see later ) grid , the rectangular one has over - resolution in some regions of the sky . this leads also to a higher number of candidates . * the use of the celestial map as the space to spot the candidates is very prone to artifacts , see @xcite : some regions are always `` privileged '' , that is they have a higher candidates number with respect to the expectation . the problem arises because each hough map is constructed over the whole sky . hence , it seemed important the study of alternative procedures . given the observation that most of the problems are related to the complexity of the transformation , we exploit the possibility of the use of a different but simpler transformation . a part the simplicity of the transformation we obviously need to study a procedure which is less , or equivalently , computationally expensive . therefore we studied a procedure which has a better , or equivalent , sensitivity , at the same computational cost of the sky hough . the transformation we propose transforms the * time - observed frequency * plane into the * source frequency - spin down * plane . let s go into details . if @xmath3 is the frequency ( doppler corrected for a given sky direction ) , @xmath4 the source intrinsic frequency , @xmath5 the first spin - down parameter , @xmath6 the time at the detector and @xmath7 a reference time , we have that @xmath8 a straight line in the hough plane . we then get the following : @xmath9 each point in the input plane @xmath10 , that is a peak in the doppler shifted peakmap , is transformed into a straight line in the hough @xmath11 plane , with slope @xmath12 . the slope depends on the choice of the reference time . if we choose @xmath7 equal to the beginning time of the data we analyze , then the slope is always negative and inversely proportional to the time gap . + this is the choice we have done here . in addition , considering the width @xmath13 of the frequency bins in the input plane we notice that each peak is transformed into a stripe among two parallel straight lines @xmath14 it is a linear transformation . now the input plane is obtained from the original peakmap by correcting it for the doppler shift due to the earth revolution and rotation , for each point in the sky grid we need to analyze . thus `` time '' is the time at the detector and `` frequency '' the observed frequency , after the doppler correction . but , as each sfdb is short enough to not be affected by a time - varying doppler shift , then the doppler effect removal from the original peakmap , obtained from the collection of all the sfdb data , reduces to a very simple `` shifting '' procedure of the peakmap bins . in the analysis scheme , this bins shift is part of the hough procedure . + in the following , we give details on the construction of the map . the frequency hough map is constructed using the `` direct differential method '' , as is done with the sky hough . with this method , instead of building directly the hough map , one builds a map that , if `` integrated '' ( i.e. summed over bins from left to right ) , gives the hough map . this is important to minimize the number of floating point operations . as already explained , for each sky position , the input peakmap is got from the original one by shifting bins to correct for the doppler effect . the sky is sampled with a non uniform covering grid , which will be later discussed . here we explain in detail the technique , by giving the sequence of operations : * for each point in the sky grid , for each coordinate in the input plane @xmath10 and for each spin - down value @xmath15 , the map is incremented by 1 in the point @xmath16 and decremented by 1 in the point @xmath17 . hence , for each sky position , a differential map is constructed . the sum of the bins along the frequency direction is then performed to construct the final integral map . this two dimensional histogram is the frequency hough map . in the algorithm implementation we plan to divide the input peakmap into 10 hz bands , thus constructing , for each position in the sky , a different hough map every 10 hz . + in case there is the need to exploit higher order one spin down parameters , one ( or more ) loop(s ) has ( have ) to be added to the sequence of operations , to scan the discrete set of values of the new parameter(s ) . this clearly influences the computing cost , but does not change the basics of the method . let s first discuss two peculiar aspects of this new method , which are the basis of its appeal . from the given analysis scheme , it is easy to see that the frequency resolution for the estimation of the source frequency @xmath4 can be enhanced , with respect to the binning frequency @xmath13 , without relevantly affecting the computational effort . in fact , the use of a resolution @xmath18 with @xmath19 , affects only the size of the hough map . this has a computational cost only when summing over the bins to construct the integral map from the differential one . but we notice that the total cost of the construction of the hough map is due to the construction of the differential map , dominated by the number of peaks in the peakmap and to the construction of the integral map , dominated by the number of bins . the former , in all practical cases , is the one which dominates . + the possibility to enhance the frequency resolution results to be , as will be shown in the next sections , a very important peculiarity of the new method . it which enhances considerably the efficiency , by reducing the digitalization effect . the same in the sky hough procedure would have a relevant computational cost . regarding the increasing of the spin down resolution , it would cost for both the procedures : the better the resolution in the spin down estimation the higher is the number of loops of the procedures . here we describe how we construct the grid on the sky . suppose two sources , at the same frequency @xmath4 and same latitude @xmath20 . their angular delay @xmath21 with respect to the detector rotation produces a time delay @xmath22 . the two sources will then have the same frequency variation at the detector , which is the classical equation due to the doppler effect , @xmath23 but with time delay @xmath24 . the observed frequency difference has thus a maximum value which is given by @xmath25 thus the angular resolution is , in radians : @xmath26 where @xmath27 is the number of points in the doppler band for a signal of max frequency @xmath4 : @xmath28 and @xmath29 . + we now repeat the same reasoning , supposing the two sources , at the same frequency @xmath4 and same longitude @xmath30 . the two sources will have the same frequency variation at the detector , now given by @xmath31 , but with an angular delay @xmath32 . the observed frequency difference has a maximum value which is : @xmath33 we obtain for the angular resolution , in radians : @xmath34 using eqs . [ gammalong ] and [ gammalat ] we get : @xmath35 @xmath36 using these equations we construct the grid on the sky , which we call the `` optimal '' grid . the points of the grid are not uniformly distributed . with a simulation , we have estimated the the number of points in the grid @xmath37 , which is , in the high frequency limit : @xmath38 @xmath39 is an extra resolution factor , which can be greater than 1 , to enhance the efficiency , but even less than 1 , to save computing cost , obviously worsening the efficiency . fig.[fig : gridsim1 ] shows the optimal sky grid , for @xmath40 ( which corresponds to a source frequency @xmath41 hz ) . as already said , the grid used in the sky hough method , is not optimal , but rectangular , to use fastest computing algorithms . the number of points in this rectangular grid is : @xmath42 which is , asymptotically , a factor @xmath43 higher then the number of points of the optimal grid . in fact this grid has to be over resolved to maintain the same sensitivity of the corresponding optimal grid . further , we note that this over resolution produces a higher number of candidates from certain sky positions . , x - axis : ecliptical longitude , degrees , from 0 to 400 ; y - axis : ecliptical latitude , degrees , from -100 to 100 ; the number of points in the map is @xmath37=2902.,width=453 ] the sensitivity of the sky hough procedure is affected by artifacts , i.e. an excess of candidates in some places of the sky map , which are due to local spectral disturbances . the effect ca nt be eliminated because each map is constructed over the whole sky , and hence the threshold for candidate selection has to be the same for the whole sky . using the frequency hough procedure this effect disappears because each map is constructed for only one position in the sky . so , because of the adaptivity of the threshold , if a sky region gives an excess of candidates , the threshold is raised and then there is a loss in sensitivity only for that sky region . we are now ready to enter into details by studying the efficiency of both the methods , by the use of simulations . figure [ fig : gridsim2 ] is an example of how a frequency hough map looks like , having injected into white noise three signals , at different frequencies and spin - down . to study the efficiency of the methods , as a function of the frequency over resolution factor , we have simulated a signal in the absence of noise . the reason for this is that we were interested in studying only the losses due to the discretization errors . the parameters chosen for the simulation are similar to actual situations ( detector parameters , source expected parameters ) . the parameters of the simulation are shown in table [ tab : par ] . [ fig : freqloss ] shows the amplitude loss versus the frequency over resolution factor @xmath45 . the loss was calculated as the average value of all the peaks found in the 500 spectra ( it is important to remember that our procedure considers peaks only the maxima above threshold ) . the result is clear : using @xmath46 the amplitude loss is 3.6 @xmath47 ( the efficiency @xmath48 ) , while with @xmath49 , which is the only practically possible choice of the sky hough , the amplitude loss is 11.6 @xmath47 ( the efficiency @xmath50 ) . from the figure , we notice that there is no further gain of increasing the over resolution factor over 10 . thus , we fixed to 10 the over resolution factor for the frequency hough . in next simulations , results with @xmath46 are thus for the frequency hough , results with @xmath49 are for the sky hough . once we have fixed the frequency over resolution factor we wanted to quantify how the increasing of the spin down resolution from the nominal one would affect the sensitivity . the results are in fig . [ fig : freqloss1 ] , which shows the loss in amplitude vs the spin down over resolution factor , for both the cases @xmath49 , sky hough , and @xmath46,frequency hough . it can be noticed that , in the case of the frequency hough , even for the worst analyzed situation , which corresponds to the nominal spin down step @xmath51 the loss is quite small . is is 3.6 @xmath47 ( the efficiency @xmath48 ) . the situation is worst for the sky hough , where the loss in amplitude at the nominal spin down step is 11.6 @xmath47 ( the efficiency @xmath50 ) . the improvement obtained by a better spin down resolution is not so important , as can be seen from the figure . it seems reasonable , given the observation that increasing the spin down resolution has a computational cost for both the methods , to use the nominal @xmath52 resolution ( x - axis equal to 1 in the figure ) . to study the loss due to the sky grid resolution , we have simulated 50 signals , randomly distributed over the sky . we have then looked for results using the optimal grid , again registering the average value of all the detected peaks . in what follows , we suppose to use the optimal grid for both the procedures , sky and frequency hough . fig.[fig : loss_spinres ] shows the amplitude losses , as a function of the over resolution sky map factor @xmath39 , in the two cases of @xmath46 ( left ) , frequency hough , and @xmath49 ( right ) , sky hough . the amplitude loss , for @xmath44 , is @xmath53 for the frequency hough , and @xmath54 , for the sky hough . again , a better efficiency for the new procedure . we notice that the use of an over resolution for the sky map , would have an impact on the computing cost , with both the procedures . . the figures compare the loss when @xmath46 ( left ) , frequency hough , and when @xmath55 ( right ) , sky hough.,title="fig:",width=302 ] . the figures compare the loss when @xmath46 ( left ) , frequency hough , and when @xmath55 ( right ) , sky hough.,title="fig:",width=302 ] + we see that the ratio of the amplitude efficiencies is @xmath57 which in power is 1.317 . from this , we can compute the gain in computing cost for the same sensitivity . let us firstly recall that the @xmath58 sensitivity in the hierarchical search is proportional to @xmath59 , and the computing cost to @xmath60 . thus , the `` equivalent fft '' length factor is @xmath61=1.734 and the gain in computing cost is @xmath62=5.2 ( that is , the ratio of computing costs needed to have the same @xmath58 sensitivity ) . * the * adaptivity * , that is the weight of peaks to consider the noise level and the gain due to the antenna pattern toward a direction , is , with this approach , immediate and very simple , as each hough map is done for a single sky position . it has been shown , with the sky hough , that the adaptivity of the procedure is a very important task for the analysis ; * this new procedure is appropriate also for all those situations in which the * source position * is known and we should estimate only source frequency and spin down ; * with a proper choice of parameters , it is also possible to detect and hence remove * spurious signals * , with a constant or linearly varying frequency . on the latter point , we are now working to study the efficiency of this method in terms of rejection of spurious lines in the peakmap . we know that this is a very critical task for the analysis , since the presence of spurious lines highly affects the sensitivity of the search . we expect this new method to be much more insensitive to the presence of spurious lines , since in the chosen hough plane spurious lines and g.w . signals should have a very different and well separable behavior . b. krisnan , a. sintes , m. a. papa , b . f. schutz , s. frasca , c. palomba , _ phys.rev.d70:082001_ , 2004 . `` the hough transform search for continuous gravitational waves '' a. sintes , b. krisnan , _ phys.conf.ser.32:206-211_ , 2006 . `` improved hough search for gravitational wave pulsars '' p. astone , s. frasca , c. palomba,_cqg 22:s1197-s1210_,2005 `` the short fft database and the peakmap for the hierarchical search of periodic sources '' s. frasca , p. astone , c. palomba,_cqg 22:s1013-s1019 _ , 2005 `` evaluation of sensitivity and computing power for the virgo hierarchical search for periodic sources '' c. palomba , p. astone , s. frasca , _ cqg 22:s1255-s1264_,2005 `` adaptive hough transform for the search of periodic sources '' f. acernese et al ( virgo coll . ) _ cqg 24:s491-s499 _ , 2007 `` coincidence analysis between periodic source candidates in c6 and c7 virgo data '' f. acernese et al ( virgo coll . ) _ proceedings of the eleventh marcel grossmann meeting on general relativity ( berlin , 2006 ) edited by h. kleinert , r.t . jantzen and r. ruffini , world scientific , singapore _ , 2008 `` first coincidence search among periodic gravitational wave source candidates using virgo data '' p. astone , s. frasca , c. palomba_proceedings of the eleventh marcel grossmann meeting on general relativity ( berlin 2006 ) edited by h. kleinert , r.t . jantzen and r. ruffini , world scientific , singapore _ , 2008 `` incoherent strategies for the network detection of periodic gravitational waves '' c. palomba , s. frasca , _ cqg 21:s1645-s1654 _ , 2004 `` spectral filtering for hierarchical search of periodic sources '' | in the hierarchical search for periodic sources of gravitational waves , the candidate selection , in the incoherent step , can be performed with hough transform procedures . in this paper we analyze the problem of sensitivity loss due to discretization of the parameters space vs computing cost , comparing the properties of the sky hough procedure with those of a new frequency hough , which is based on a transformation from the _ time - observed frequency _ plane to the _ source frequency - spin down _ plane . results on simulated peakmaps suggest various advantages in favor of the use of the frequency hough . the ones which show up to really make the difference are 1 ) the possibility to enhance the frequency resolution without relevantly affecting the computing cost . this reduces the digitization effects ; 2 ) the excess of candidates due to local disturbances in some places of the sky map . they do not affect the new analysis because each map is constructed for only one position in the sky . + pacs . numbers : 04.80nn,07.05kf,97.60jd |
0908.1812 | this review focuses specifically on what we have learned about the progenitors of core - collapse supernovae ( cc sne ) by examining images of the supernova ( sn ) sites taken prior to the explosion . by registering pre - sn and post - sn images , usually taken at high resolution using either space - based optical detectors , or ground - based infrared detectors equipped with laser guide star adaptive optics systems ( lgs - ao ) , about one dozen cc sn progenitors have now been directly detected ( i.e. , shown to be spatially coincident with the sn ) in pre - sn images , with roughly two dozen upper limits derived from non - detections @xcite . this field has come a long way in the last decade , and promises to advance rapidly as more and more nearby galaxies hosts of future cc sne have high - resolution images added to the archive . this review is organized as follows . following a brief summary of sn classification and stellar evolution theory ( 2 ) , one example from each of the following three categories of progenitor studies is provided ( 3 ; ordered from most - to - least common ) : ( 1 ) no progenitor star detected in pre - sn image(s ) ; ( 2 ) likely progenitor star identified via spatial coincidence in pre - sn and post - sn images ; ( 3 ) progenitor star detected in pre - sn image(s ) and subsequently confirmed by demonstrating its absence in images taken after the sn has faded beyond detection . a summary of overall results to date for each sn type is then given ( 4 ) , followed by a brief discussion of outstanding questions and areas in which future progress is likely ( 5 ) . note that discussion is limited to what the examination of images of sn sites taken prior to the explosion has taught us , and necessarily excludes ( or relegates to very brief comment ) such related investigations as sn environments ( e.g. , @xcite ; see also the article by elias rosa in this volume ) and sn progenitor `` forensics '' ( e.g. , @xcite ; see also the article by modjaz in this volume ) . for a comprehensive discussion of all such related areas , see the recent review by @xcite . it is typical to subdivide cc sne into at least five major categories ( see @xcite for a thorough review ) : ii - plateau ( ii - p ; hydrogen in spectrum and plateau in optical light curve ) , ii - linear ( ii - l ; hydrogen in spectrum , no plateau in optical light curve ) , iin ( hydrogen in spectrum and spectral and photometric evidence for interaction between sn ejecta and a dense circumstellar medium [ csm ] ) , iib ( hydrogen in spectrum initially , but transforms into a hydrogen - deficient spectrum at later times ) , and ib / c ( no evidence for hydrogen in spectrum at any time ) , where the ordering is a roughly increasing one in terms of inferred degree of envelope stripping prior to explosion ( i.e. , ii - p are the least stripped at the time of explosion , and ib / c are the most stripped ) . while most of this review focuses on the observational advances that have been made , theoretical input is critical to translate observed progenitor luminosity ( or limits ) into zero - age - main - sequence masses ( @xmath0 ) and stellar evolutionary states . among the most complete ( and accessiblestars . ] ) stellar evolution models at present are the metallicity - dependent models produced with the cambridge stellar evolution code , stars , the descendant of the code developed originally by @xcite and updated most recently by @xcite ( 2004 ; see also @xcite , and references therein ) , since they follow stellar evolution up to the initiation of core neon burning , which is likely to give an accurate indication of the pre - sn luminosity . the hertzsprung - russell diagram ( hrd ) of the stars evolutionary tracks are shown in figure 1 for stars ranging in initial mass from @xmath1 . comparison with other contemporary model grids ( e.g. , @xcite ; @xcite ) show that the endpoints for stars in the @xmath2 range differ by at most @xmath3 dex in luminosity among the codes @xcite , which gives some assurance that systematic uncertainties are not great , at least at the low - mass end for red supergiant ( rsg ) stars . two areas of uncertainty in need of better quantification ( or , at least , agreement within the community ) include the effects that stellar rotation and mass - loss might have on the observable characteristics of stars prior to core collapse . not surprisingly , when no progenitor star is actually detected at the sn location in pre - sn images , only an upper limit to the progenitor s luminosity and , hence , mass , can be derived . to illustrate the analysis process in such a situation , i consider sn 2006my , an sn ii - p that exploded in a galaxy @xmath4 mpc away ( nearly all sne with progenitor studies are within @xmath5 mpc , since source confusion becomes an increasing problem with distance ) . details for this particular event are provided by @xcite ; here i briefly outline the steps my colleagues and i took to derive an upper mass limit on its progenitor . the _ hubble space telescope _ ( _ hst _ ) imaged the site of sn 2006my using the wide - field and planetary camera 2 ( wfpc2 ) in 1994 ( pre - sn ) and again in 2007 ( shortly after explosion ) . we registered the two images and pinpointed the sn location to better than 30 milli - arcsec in the pre - sn frame ( figure 2a , b ) . such fine registration allowed us to rule out a nearby point source ( source ` 1 ' in figure 2a ) as the progenitor star with greater than @xmath6 confidence . ( note that this source had been previously identified by @xcite as the likely progenitor based on registration with lower - resolution ground - based optical post - sn images . ) we next set an @xmath7-band detection limit in the pre - sn frame by placing artificial stars of progressively fainter magnitude at the sn location and letting the photometry software ( in this case , hstphot , see @xcite ) attempt to detect them . the point at which the software no longer detected a point source then serves as the limiting upper magnitude for the progenitor star . to translate this single - filter detection limit into a luminosity , we assumed that the progenitor was a rsg ( given other sn ii - p progenitor detections this seems a reasonable assumption ; see 3.2 and 4 ) , and then determined the greatest bolometric magnitude it could have had while still remaining below our detection threshold . this is accomplished through : @xmath8 where @xmath9 is the distance modulus of the host galaxy ( ngc 4651 ) , @xmath10 the extinction to sn 2006my , @xmath7 the @xmath7-band detection threshold , @xmath11 the color range of rsg stars ( i.e. , spectral types @xmath12 ) , and @xmath13 the bolometric correction corresponding to each @xmath14 . upon adopting the most conservative values for each of the parameters ( i.e. , the ones that produce the least restrictive @xmath15 for the progenitor s upper luminosity limit ) , and allowing for a maximum systematic uncertainty of 0.2 dex in the theoretical stellar model endpoints ( see 2 ) , the limiting bolometric magnitude above which any rsg would have been detected in our pre - sn image , @xmath15 , is derived . we then compared this with the final luminosity of stars with @xmath16 predicted by the stars stellar evolution models ( figure 2c ) to derive an upper bound on the progenitor mass of @xmath17 . from this analysis , then , we conclude that any rsg progenitor with an initial mass greater than @xmath18 would have been detected using our analysis procedure . analyses similar to that described here for sn 2006my have been carried out on each of 22 non - detections in pre - sn images @xcite . as we shall see ( 4 ) , it is the sheer number of such progenitor non - detections that permits rather strong conclusions to be drawn about cc sn progenitors from this category of progenitor studies . next , we consider the individually more revealing situation where an object coincident with the transformed sn location is actually detected in the pre - sn image(s ) , a situation that exists now for 11 cc sne @xcite . as an outstanding example of the analytic power provided by having multi - filter pre - sn images available ( especially in the near infrared for rsg progenitors ) , we consider the recent work of @xcite on sn 2008bk , a very nearby ( @xmath19 mpc ) sn ii - p . in this case , pre - sn ground - based images in @xmath20 were registered with post - sn lgs - ao @xmath21-band images to yield solid progenitor star detections in @xmath22 , and upper luminosity limits in @xmath23 and @xmath24 . when compared with the known spectral energy distribution ( sed ) of rsg , a good match for the progenitor of sn 2008bk is found with a progenitor of spectral type m4i ( figure 3 ) . from comparison with the stars stellar evolutionary models an initial progenitor mass of @xmath25 is derived for this sn . similar studies on seven other detected sn ii - p progenitors have found stars consistent with rsg in all cases , providing nice agreement between theory and observation . as we shall see in 4 , however , the _ range _ of masses inferred for these rsg progenitors is somewhat unexpected . finally , we consider the most satisfying situation where images taken before , during , and long after the sn explosion exist that clearly show the progenitor star , the sn , and the absence of the progenitor star , respectively . such a sequence provides nearly conclusive proof of the progenitor star s identity . currently , such a time series exists for only two objects : sn 1987a ( e.g. , * ? ? ? * ) and sn 2005gl @xcite . because the case of sn 1987a is well - known , i present sn 2005gl as the example of this situation ; it also clearly demonstrates the investigative power provided by having a third observation , long after the sn has dropped below detection . as shown by @xcite , early spectra of sn 2005gl exhibited the classic features of a type iin event , showing narrow but resolved lines of hydrogen superposed on an intermediate - width component on an otherwise featureless continuum . analysis of the spectral features indicate ejecta interacting with a dense csm , whose properties suggest that the progenitor star exploded shortly after an lbv - like mass - loss episode . comparison of a pre - sn _ hst _ image with a post - sn image obtained from the ground using the lgs - ao at the keck ii telescope established a spatial coincidence between the sn and a very bright source possessing an estimated luminosity of over @xmath26 ( @xcite ; see figures 4a and 4b ) . the only single stars known to possess such an extraordinary luminosity are very massive ( @xmath27 ; see figure 1 ) , which conventional theory predicts should explode only after the lbv phase has ended @xcite . initially , strong claims for the unexpectedly luminous progenitor / sn 2005gl association had to be tempered by consideration of the distance of sn 2005gl s host galaxy . at over 60 mpc away , the @xmath28 resolution of the pre - sn _ hst _ image corresponds to @xmath5 pc , which raises suspicion that the object could be , e.g. , an unresolved stellar cluster or association of several massive stars , with only part of the light coming from the actual progenitor of sn 2005gl @xcite . additional observations , therefore , were clearly needed to settle the case , and two years later , an additional _ hst _ observation was made . this observation demonstrates that the luminous source in the pre - sn image has , indeed , disappeared ( figure 4c ) , which implies that the progenitor of sn 2005gl was a single , extremely luminous , star that exploded while in the lbv phase @xcite . such a luminosity is indicative of having had an initial mass of @xmath29 , which likely left behind a stellar mass black hole ( e.g. , * ? ? ? in addition to exploding during an unexpected evolutionary phase , the very fact _ that _ such a massive star is demonstrated to have exploded at all as opposed to directly collapsing to a black hole with no sn explosion is important , since the optical signature produced at the time of stellar collapse to a black hole is , at present , virtually unconstrained by either observation or theory ( see , e.g. , * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . the three examples discussed in 3 serve to illustrate how the science of seeking progenitors in pre - sn images is carried out , and what conclusions can typically be drawn . i now briefly summarize results to date arising from direct progenitor searches in pre - sn images ; for a more comprehensive review , see @xcite . * type ii - plateau : * sne ii - p are by far the most well - defined category of cc sne in terms of direct observational progenitor constraints , having had eight putative progenitor detections made and 12 upper luminosity limits established . all of the available evidence suggests that rsg are the immediate progenitors of sne ii - p . by employing a uniform reduction and analysis procedure , @xcite has produced the cumulative frequency distribution shown in figure 5 for sne ii - p , from which an intriguing result is immediately evident : all but one of the sne ii - p have initial masses constrained to be @xmath30 , with the most massive _ detected _ progenitor of an sn ii - p having a mass of only @xmath31 . this is surprising , since rsg up to @xmath32 are clearly observed in the local group ( * ? ? ? * and references therein ) , and would have easily been detected in the pre - sn images . this lack of massive rsg progenitors for sne ii - p lead @xcite to speculate that these massive rsg progenitors may be forming black holes heralded by faint , or non - existent , sn explosions ( see also * ? ? ? * type ii - linear : * a rare type of cc sn , it is perhaps not surprising that only one sn ii - l ( sn 1980k ) has a pre - sn image , the analysis of which rules out massive rsg greater than about @xmath33 @xcite . analysis of the stellar population of the type ii - l sn 1979c by @xcite determines a mass range of @xmath34 for its progenitor . at this point , firm conclusions about the progenitors of sne ii - l can not be made , although early indications are that at least some do not arise from extremely massive stars . * type iin : * sn 2005gl , described earlier in this review ( 3.3 ) as having a very massive ( @xmath27 ) progenitor that exploded while in the lbv phase , is the only example of an sn iin for which a progenitor has been detected in pre - sn images . whether such a massive progenitor is indicative of the class as a whole is not known . * type iib : * pre - sn images exist for two events . first , sn 1993j in m81 , where extensive analyses of pre - sn and post - sn images ( and spectra ) lead to the conclusion that a @xmath35 star exploded in a binary system , with a slightly less massive secondary surviving the explosion ( * ? ? ? * and references therein ) . very recently , the type iib sn 2008ax has provided a great opportunity to further investigate this rare class of cc sne since pre - sn _ hst_/wfpc2 images exist in @xmath36 . a study by @xcite finds a curiously flat sed for the progenitor star , which is impossible to reconcile with a single rsg , but may be consistent with an early - type w - r ( wn class ) progenitor , suggesting a progenitor star with a large ( @xmath37 ) initial mass . * type ib / c : * a well - studied class , with ten upper limits but no detections from analysis of pre - sn images . the lack of detections is surprising , since it is commonly thought that at least some of the progenitors of sne ib / c should be luminous , single w - r stars , in addition to others perhaps arising from lower mass stars in binary systems . while none of the non - detections definitively rule out a w - r progenitor , @xcite demonstrates that it is quite unlikely at this point that all sne ib / c come from them . a summary of the current state of affairs of cc sn progenitor research via studies of pre - sn images is provided by figure 6 . the science of seeking sn progenitors has made tremendous strides in just the last ten years . for the future , i look with particular interest at the extremes as areas ripe for breakthrough discoveries , since it is there that many of our most fundamental questions lie . on the low - mass end , how will the lack of massive rsg progenitors for sne ii - p be resolved ? are we seeing the first glimpse of the mass cutoff for direct collapse to black holes ? if so , then how will this be reconciled with the _ very _ massive stars ( i.e. , the other mass extreme ) that apparently do explode as sne iin or possibly iib ? and finally , how does binarity influence all of these conclusions ? clearly , we are just at the beginning stages of this exciting field of research , and great advances will no doubt be made in the coming decade . i thank the scientific organizing committee of the `` hot and cool : bridging gaps in massive star evolution '' conference for inviting me to provide this review . i thank seppo mattila for permitting reproduction of a figure from a recent paper , and stephen smartt for allowing the use of figures in advance of publication of his annual reviews article on the topic . | i summarize what we have learned about the nature of stars that ultimately explode as core - collapse supernovae from the examination of images taken prior to the explosion . by registering pre - supernova and post - supernova images , usually taken at high resolution using either space - based optical detectors , or ground - based infrared detectors equipped with laser guide star adaptive optics systems , nearly three dozen core - collapse supernovae have now had the properties of their progenitor stars either directly measured or ( more commonly ) constrained by establishing upper limits on their luminosities . these studies enable direct comparison with stellar evolution models that , in turn , permit estimates of the progenitor stars physical characteristics to be made . i review progenitor characteristics ( or constraints ) inferred from this work for each of the major core - collapse supernova types ( ii - plateau , ii - linear , iib , iin , ib / c ) , with a particular focus on the analytical techniques used and the processes through which conclusions have been drawn . brief discussion of a few individual events is also provided , including sn 2005gl , a type iin supernova that is shown to have had an extremely luminous and thus very massive progenitor that exploded shortly after a violent , luminous blue variable - like eruption phase , contrary to standard theoretical predictions . |
1311.0649 | kingman s coalescent is a random tree introduced by @xcite as the genealogy arising in large population genetic models . it has infinitely many leaves and is usually constructed from leaves to the root as follows : given that there are @xmath7 lines in the tree , after some exponential time with rate @xmath8 , two lines are chosen uniformly and merged to one line , leaving the tree with @xmath9 lines . due to the quadratic rate @xmath10 the tree immediately comes down from infinitely to finitely many leaves @xcite . since the seminal paper by @xcite this random tree has been generalized to other infinite trees arising in population genetics models . for the kingman coalescent some laws of large numbers and central limit theorems have been proved . they are nicely summarized in @xcite , chapter 4.2 ; see also proposition [ p:11 ] below . for @xmath11 let @xmath12 denote the number of lines time @xmath13 in the past . then , since the kingman coalescent immediately comes down from infinity , @xmath12 is finite . furthermore it is approximately @xmath14 . equivalently , the time @xmath0 it takes the coalescent to go from infinitely many lines to @xmath1 lines is approximately @xmath15 for large @xmath1 . going to the fine structure , at time @xmath0 the infinite population is decomposed in @xmath1 families ( whose joint distribution is exchangeable ) and every leaf in the tree belongs to exactly one of the @xmath1 families whose frequencies are denoted by @xmath16 . it is known that for large @xmath1 a randomly chosen @xmath3 is approximately exponentially distributed with mean @xmath17 . this translates into several laws of large numbers ; see e.g. ( 35 ) in @xcite . in particular the probability of picking ( from the initial infinite population ) two leaves that belong to the same family , given by @xmath18 , is approximately @xmath15 . the main goal of the present paper is to study the corresponding large deviations results . to the best of our knowledge , except for @xcite , cf . remark [ rem : angel ] , results in this direction are not present in the literature . we formulate our results in the next section . theorem [ t1 ] gives a full large deviation principle for the distributions of @xmath19 . the proof , given in section [ sec : proofs1 ] , is an application of the grtner - ellis theorem . as a byproduct , we derive a large deviation principle for the distributions of @xmath20 in corollary [ cor : tnt ] . large deviations of @xmath21 are considered in theorem [ t2 ] and exact rate functions for downwards and upwards deviations are given . the proof is given in section [ sec : proof - theorem - reft2 ] . for the upward deviations we use a variant of cramr s theorem for heavy - tailed random variables ; see e.g. @xcite . for the downward deviations we use a connection to self - normalized large deviations ; see @xcite . this connection was pointed out to us by alain rouault and nina gantert . since the rate function for downward deviations is hard to treat analytically we provide in theorem [ t3 ] a simple lower bound . the proof of that bound is given in section [ sec : proof - theorem3 ] . the kingman coalescent can be seen as a discrete graph , more precisely a discrete tree with infinitely many leaves . let @xmath22 be independent exponentially distributed variables with mean @xmath23 . then the kingman coalescent tree can be constructed from the root to the leaves as follows . 1 . start the tree with two lines from the root . 2 . for @xmath24 the tree stays with @xmath7 lines for the amount of time @xmath25 . after that time one of the @xmath7 lines is randomly chosen . this line splits in two so that the number of lines jumps from @xmath7 to @xmath26 . 3 . stop upon reaching infinitely many lines , which happens after ( the almost surely finite ) time @xmath27 . the random variable @xmath28 is the total tree height . alternatively , @xmath28 is the time to the most recent common ancestor ( mrca ) of the infinite population ( of leaves ) . counted from the top of the tree at time @xmath29 a random number @xmath12 of active lines in the kingman tree is present , i.e.@xmath30 at time @xmath0 every leaf belongs to one of @xmath1 disjoint families and all members of each such family stem from the same line at time @xmath0 . let us denote the frequencies of these families ( which exist due to exchangeability by definetti s theorem ) by @xmath16 . the following results are well known ( see @xcite for and and @xcite for ; proofs can also be found in @xcite . ) + let [ p:11 ] @xmath31 , @xmath32 and @xmath33 be as above . then @xmath34 we [ rem : interllnfe ] note that the left hand side of has the interpretation of a _ homozygosity by descent _ in the following sense : when picking two leaves from the tree at time @xmath35 , the probability that both share a common ancestor at time @xmath0 is @xmath36 . then , the law of large number states that the homozygosity by descent at time @xmath0 is approximately @xmath15 for large @xmath1 . in the present paper we are interested in large deviations results corresponding to the statements of proposition [ p:11 ] . we start with large deviations connected with . first we introduce some notation . for @xmath37 let @xmath38 denote the distribution of @xmath19 , i.e. @xmath39 . furthermore we denote by @xmath40 the borel @xmath41-algebra on @xmath42 and for @xmath43 we denote by @xmath44 the _ interior _ and by @xmath45 the _ closure _ of @xmath46 . for @xmath47 , let @xmath48 be the unique solution of the equation @xmath49 , where the continuous and increasing function @xmath50 is defined by ( see figure [ fig : t1 ] for a plot ) @xmath51 2 & : \ ; t=0 , \\[2ex ] \displaystyle\frac{2}{\sqrt{|t|}}\arctan\sqrt{|t| } & : \ ; t < 0 . \end{cases}\end{aligned}\ ] ] the proof of the following theorem is given in section [ sec : proof - theorem - reft1 ] . the sequence [ t1 ] @xmath52 satisfies a large deviation principle with scale @xmath1 and good rate function @xmath53 given by @xmath54 \infty & : \ ; x\leq 0 . \end{cases } \end{aligned}\ ] ] in other words , for any @xmath55 we have @xmath56 and @xmath53 from and , respectively.,title="fig:",width=226 ] and @xmath53 from and , respectively.,title="fig:",width=226 ] both , the function @xmath57 from and @xmath53 from are plotted in figure [ fig : t1 ] . the minimum of the rate function is attained at @xmath58 . this fact is clear from the law of large numbers , . in addition , @xmath59 for @xmath60 because @xmath61 almost surely . let us now have a closer look at the behaviour of @xmath62 for @xmath63 near @xmath35 and for large @xmath63 . since @xmath64 , we have that @xmath65 , and hence , @xmath66 . in this case , @xmath67 where the last equality follows from @xmath68 . to understand the behaviour for large @xmath63 , note that since @xmath69 for @xmath70 we have @xmath71 and in particular @xmath72 . it follows @xmath73 note that and are equivalent . indeed , @xmath74 ( this also holds with @xmath75 replaced by @xmath76 ) by construction , and @xmath77 as @xmath78 and @xmath79 as @xmath80 . hence , theorem [ t1 ] translates into a large deviation principle for @xmath20 . in the following we denote by @xmath81 the distribution of @xmath82 , i.e. @xmath83 . the proof of the next result is given in section [ sec : proof - coroll - refc ] ; see figure [ fig : cor1 ] for a plot of the rate function @xmath84 . for @xmath85 the family @xmath86 [ cor : tnt ] satisfies a large deviation principle with scale @xmath87 and good rate function @xmath84 given by @xmath88 \displaystyle \frac{\pi^2}{2 } & : \ , x=0 , \\[1.5ex ] \infty & : \ , x<0 , \end{cases } \end{aligned}\ ] ] with @xmath53 from . in particular , for @xmath89 we have @xmath90 from corollary [ cor : tnt ] . the figure on the right is a comparison of @xmath84 with the lower bound obtained from @xcite.,title="fig:",width=226 ] from corollary [ cor : tnt ] . the figure on the right is a comparison of @xmath84 with the lower bound obtained from @xcite.,title="fig:",width=226 ] the distributions @xmath91 ( as well as @xmath92 ) have been described explicitely in the literature . @xcite , section 6 , gives @xmath93 in principle , this formula must also give the large deviations for the measures @xmath81 , but this does not seem straight - forward . although [ rem : angel ] the main goal of @xcite was the analysis of spatial @xmath94-coalescents , they also provide some large deviations bounds on kingman s coalescent . these bounds are mainly based on markov inequality . precisely , in lemma 2.2 in @xcite it is shown that for @xmath95 @xmath96 and therefore @xmath97 in the neighbourhood of @xmath98 the last inequality translates easily into a bound for the rate function @xmath84 from ; see figure [ fig : cor1 ] . namely , for @xmath99 we have @xmath100 next , we state some large deviations results connected to . for @xmath101 we know from that @xmath102 holds almost surely . the proof of this result is based on the well - known fact ( see e.g. section 5 in @xcite ) that the distribution of @xmath103 can be derived using uniform order statistics : let @xmath104 be independent and uniformly distributed on @xmath105 $ ] , and @xmath106 be their order statistics . additionally , let @xmath107 be independent exponentially distributed random variables with mean @xmath23 . then , @xmath108 here the second equality in distribution is one of the well known representations of uniform spacings ; see e.g. section 4.1 in @xcite . it follows @xmath109 we will use this representation to obtain large deviations results for @xmath103 . in particular we show that upwards large deviations of @xmath103 are on the scale @xmath6 while downwards large deviations are on the scale @xmath1 . the proof is given in section [ sec : proof - theorem - reft2 ] . for [ t2 ] each @xmath110 , we have @xmath111 furthermore @xmath112 and for each @xmath113 , we have @xmath114 the function @xmath115 is positive for @xmath116 and is given by @xmath117 here @xmath118 is a function of the form @xmath119 with @xmath120 where @xmath121 denotes the distribution function of the one dimensional standard gaussian distribution . though the rate function in is exact it is hard to treat analytically . for this reason we provide in theorem [ t3 ] a much simpler lower bound for downwards large deviations of @xmath103 . for the proof we use the following lemma which provides another representation of @xmath103 in terms of exponential random variables ( see section [ sec : proofs2 ] for proofs ) . let [ l : wn ] @xmath122 be independent exponentially distributed random variables with mean @xmath23 . then , @xmath123 for [ t3 ] @xmath124 we have @xmath125 the main point in the proof of lemma [ l : wn ] is that @xmath103 does not depend on the order of the @xmath126 and hence we can as well order them according to their size . let us briefly explain how we will use in the proof of in . since @xmath103 is minimal if @xmath127 ( whence @xmath128 ) , we have to look for possibilities that all @xmath126 s are of about the same size in order to obtain a large deviations result for @xmath103 . let @xmath129 denote the above exponential random variables ordered in increasing order , i.e. @xmath130 is the @xmath4th smallest value . using `` competing exponential clocks '' arguments ( see also the proof of the lemma ) one can see that @xmath131 is exponentially distributed with mean @xmath132 . hence , one way of obtaining similar values for all @xmath126 s arises if @xmath133 is particularly large , which then leads to a large deviations result for @xmath103 . from in theorem [ t2 ] and the lower bound from in theorem [ t3].,width=226 ] \1 . let us give some heuristics about the rates arising in theorem [ t2 ] . for , we have to ask ourselves about the easiest way @xmath103 becomes too large . from , we see that this is the case if one of the @xmath126 s is too large , making this kind of deviations a local property in the sense that only a single of the @xmath126 s has to show some untypical behavior . this is different when looking at , i.e. too small values of @xmath103 . first , observe that @xmath103 is small only if all ( or many ) families have about equal sizes ( extreme case @xmath134 gives the minimal value @xmath128 ) . hence , such downward deviations require to study a global property of the random variable @xmath103 , which is significantly harder . for the proof of we will interpret @xmath103 as a self - normalised sum and use from @xcite a result on large deviations result for such sums . \2 . from , we see that in fact @xmath103 is a function of uniform order statistics , which , for instance , have been studied in detail ( although no large deviations results were given ) in @xcite . hence , theorem [ t2 ] may as well be interpreted as a large deviations result for uniform order statistics . \3 . as stated in remark [ rem : interllnfe ] , @xmath135 can be interpreted as homozygosity at time @xmath0 . using a poisson process along the tree with intensity @xmath136 , we can ask for the probability of picking two leaves from the tree which are not separated by a poisson mark , denoted by _ homozygosity in state _ , abbreviated by @xmath137 . this quantity is closely related to the poisson - dirichlet distribution and some large deviations ( in the limit of large @xmath138 ) were derived in @xcite . it is shown there in theorem 5.1 that @xmath139 and that @xmath140 for @xmath141 . however , a large deviation principle for the quantity @xmath142 ( noting that @xmath143 ) , which corresponds to the results from theorem [ t2 ] , could not be obtained by @xcite . at least , it was shown that its scale can not be larger than @xmath144 . the proof of theorem [ t1 ] is an application of the grtner - ellis theorem ; see for instance section 2.3 in @xcite . let @xmath145 $ ] and @xmath146 . to show that the sequence @xmath147 satisfies a large deviation principle with scale @xmath1 and a good rate function we need to check the following three conditions . 1 . @xmath148 exists for all @xmath149 as a limit in @xmath150 . furthermore @xmath151 is lower - semicontinuous , @xmath152 , where @xmath153 . @xmath94 is differentiable on @xmath154 . 3 . @xmath94 is _ steep _ , i.e. @xmath155 whenever @xmath156 and @xmath157 . then the good rate function is given by @xmath158 we proceed in three steps . first , we compute @xmath159 . second , we check the further assumptions of the grtner - ellis theorem and obtain @xmath53 as the fenchel - legendre transform of @xmath94 . in the third step , for the rate function @xmath53 from we obtain its simplified form given in theorem [ t1 ] . the limit of @xmath160 : * we will show that @xmath161 for this , recall from that @xmath162 where @xmath163 is exponentially distributed with rate @xmath164 as well as independent of @xmath165 for all @xmath166 . furthermore recall that the moment generating function of an exponentially distributed random variable @xmath167 with rate @xmath168 is given by @xmath169 = \begin{cases } \frac{\lambda}{\lambda - t } , & \text{if $ t<\lambda$},\\ \infty , & \text{if $ t\geq \lambda$. } \end{cases}\end{aligned}\ ] ] hence , for each @xmath170 and @xmath171 we obtain by the monotone convergence theorem @xmath172 = \mathbf{e}\left[e^{t n^2 \sum_{k = n+1}^\infty s_k/\binom k2}\right ] = \prod_{k = n+1}^\infty \mathbf{e}\left[e^{tn^2 s_k/\binom k 2}\right].\ ] ] we have to consider two cases @xmath173 and @xmath174 separately . first suppose that @xmath175 . then there exists @xmath176 so that for all @xmath177 we have @xmath178 consequently , using , we obtain @xmath179 = \infty$ ] for each @xmath177 . hence , @xmath180 and @xmath181 for @xmath1 large enough . thus , we have @xmath182 now suppose that @xmath183 . for @xmath184 and @xmath185 we have @xmath186 . furthermore using and we can write @xmath187 using this we can rewrite @xmath188 for @xmath189 as @xmath190 and by the dominated convergence theorem we obtain @xmath191 hence , ge1 is shown with @xmath94 as in . moreover , we have @xmath192 $ ] , @xmath193 and @xmath94 is lower - semi - continuous . * step 2 . further assumptions of the grtner - ellis theorem : * we proceed by checking the assumptions ge2 and ge3 . for differentiability of @xmath94 for @xmath194 consider for @xmath195 the function @xmath196 we have @xmath197 for @xmath198 and the derivative @xmath199 exists for each @xmath200 and is continuous in @xmath149 . hence , we can interchange differentiation and integration and obtain @xmath201 furthermore , for a sequence @xmath202 with @xmath203 we obtain @xmath204 i.e. condition ge3 is also satisfied . * step 3 . properties of @xmath205 : * applying the grtner - ellis theorem reveals that the sequence of distributions of @xmath206 satisfies a large deviation principle with good rate function @xmath207= \sup_{t \leq 1 } \left [ \frac t2 x + \int_1^\infty \log\left(1-\frac{t}{y^2}\right ) \,\emph dy \right].\end{aligned}\ ] ] in order to compute that supremum , we write for @xmath208 @xmath209 & = x - 2\int_1^\infty \frac{1}{y^2 - t}dy \\ & = x + \frac{1}{\sqrt{t}}\int_1^\infty \frac{1}{y+\sqrt{t } } - \frac{1}{y-\sqrt{t } } dy \\ & = x - \frac{1}{\sqrt{t } } \log \frac{1+\sqrt{t}}{1-\sqrt{t}}\end{aligned}\ ] ] while for @xmath210 @xmath209 & = x - 2\int_1^\infty \frac{1}{y^2 + |t|}dy \\ & = x - \frac{2}{\sqrt{|t|}}\arctan\sqrt{|t|}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] it is easy to see that the second derivative is negative throughout , such that the supremum is attained at @xmath211 given by the solution of @xmath212 for @xmath57 as in . finally we note that for @xmath213 the range of @xmath214 is @xmath215 and for @xmath216 $ ] the range of @xmath217 is @xmath218 $ ] . hence , the scale function @xmath53 is of the form given in . the proof is based on the fact that @xmath219 . thus , for @xmath220 we have @xmath221 and for @xmath222 @xmath223 the value @xmath224 follows from . since the rate function @xmath53 attains its minimum at @xmath58 , is decreasing below and increasing above @xmath98 , the result follows . when looking at , note that @xmath103 does not depend on the order of the @xmath126 s . therefore , it is possible to order them according to their size . precisely , let @xmath225 be their order statistics . then it is well - known that @xmath226 indeed , the smallest of @xmath1 independent exponentially distributed mean @xmath23 random variables is exponentially distributed with mean @xmath227 ( as does @xmath228 ) , and the second smallest then has the same distribution as @xmath229 etc . now , we obtain as follows @xmath230 we start by proving . let @xmath110 and let @xmath231 be independent exponential random variables with mean @xmath23 . in what follows we set @xmath232 according to , it suffices to show that @xmath233 to this end we will show that for all @xmath234 , @xmath235 as well as @xmath236 and obtain by letting @xmath237 . for we have @xmath238 we consider the two terms on the right hand side of the last display separately and start with the first one . observe that @xmath239 = \infty$ ] for @xmath168 , @xmath240 = 2 $ ] and @xmath241 for @xmath242 . we use a variant of cramr s theorem for heavy - tailed random variables from @xcite . in particular , we refer to the statement around equation ( 1.2 ) there ( the assumption there is fulfilled with @xmath243 replaced by @xmath244 and @xmath245 , @xmath246 and @xmath247 ) . we obtain @xmath248 for the second term on the right hand side of by the ( classical ) cramr theorem we obtain @xmath249 where @xmath250 is the fenchel - legendre transform of the function @xmath251 $ ] . now , using , and we obtain @xmath252 which shows . for the proof of we write @xmath253 again we consider both terms in the last line separately . for the first term , as in we obtain @xmath254 for the second term , we use the same argument as for and get @xmath255 combining and with now gives which proves . since the minimum of @xmath103 is @xmath23 ( when @xmath256 for all @xmath7 ) the assertion @xmath257 is clear . it remains to prove , show that the rate function is of the form and justify the positivity of @xmath115 for @xmath258 . for @xmath259 using we obtain @xmath260 furthermore , for @xmath258 we have @xmath261/\sqrt{\mathbf e[r_1 ^ 2]}$ ] . thus , we can use theorem 1.1 from @xcite and obtain @xmath262.\end{aligned}\ ] ] now we have @xmath263 & = \int_0^\infty \exp\bigl(-y + t(c y - \frac1{2\sqrt x}(y^2+c^2))\bigr ) \ , dy \\ \intertext{and elementary integration yields } & = \frac{\sqrt{2\pi}x^{1/4}}{\sqrt{t } } \exp\left(\frac{(tc-1)^2x - t^2c^2}{2t\sqrt{x}}\right ) \phi\left(\frac{(tc-1)x^{1/4}}{\sqrt t}\right),\end{aligned}\ ] ] where @xmath121 denotes the distribution function of the one dimensional standard gaussian distribution . taking @xmath264 of the last term we obtain . now we fix @xmath258 and show that @xmath115 is positive . in the sequel we write @xmath265 we have @xmath266 \\ & \ge \mathbf e\left [ \inf_{t \ge 0}\exp\bigl(t h(r_1,c ) \bigr)\right ] \\ & = \mathbf e\left[\mathbbm 1_{\{h(r_1,c ) < 0\ } } \inf_{t \ge 0}\exp\bigl(t h(r_1,c ) \bigr)\right ] + \mathbf e\left [ \mathbbm 1_{\{h(r_1,c ) \ge 0\ } } \inf_{t \ge 0}\exp\bigl(t h(r_1,c ) \bigr)\right ] \\ & = \mathbf p \bigl(h(r_1,c ) \ge 0\bigr).\end{aligned}\ ] ] the function @xmath267 is non - negative on the interval @xmath268 $ ] where @xmath269 are the zeros of the function . it follows @xmath270 = \mathbf p \left ( r_1 \le r_1 \le r_2 \right ) = e^{-c(\sqrt{x}-\sqrt{x-1 } ) } - e^{-c(\sqrt{x}+\sqrt{x-1})}.\end{aligned}\ ] ] finally , by elementary calculation we obtain @xmath271 this expression ( and therefore also @xmath115 ) is positive for @xmath258 . thus , the proof of theorem [ t2 ] is concluded . we prove the inequality using lemma [ l : wn ] . let @xmath272 and set @xmath273 . for @xmath11 we have @xmath274 now @xmath275 , and conditioning in the second factor in the curly braces can be removed by using the fact that conditioned on @xmath276 the exponential random variable @xmath277 has the same distribution as @xmath278 . after some elementary calculations we see that the last line of the above display equals @xmath279 from the strong law of large numbers and with lemma [ l : wn ] we know that @xmath280{n\to\infty } 2 \quad \text{almost surely.}\end{aligned}\ ] ] it follows that almost surely @xmath281{n\to\infty } \frac{2 + 2y+y^2}{1 + 2y+y^2 } = x.\end{aligned}\ ] ] thus , @xmath282 the rest follows by letting @xmath283 . we thank shui feng for pointing out connections to @xcite and nina gantert and alain rouault for pointing out the reference @xcite and fruitful email discussion that led to the exact rate function in . this research was supported by the dfg through grants pf-672/6 - 1 to ad and pp . evans , s. ( 2000 ) . kingman s coalescent as a random metric space . in _ stochastic models : proceedings of the international conference on stochastic models in honour of professor donald a. dawson , ottawa , canada , june 10 - 13 , 1998 ( l.g gorostiza and b.g . ivanoff eds . ) _ , canad . | kingman s coalescent is a random tree that arises from classical population genetic models such as the moran model . the individuals alive in these models correspond to the leaves in the tree and the following two laws of large numbers concerning the structure of the tree - top are well - known : ( i ) the ( shortest ) distance , denoted by @xmath0 , from the tree - top to the level when there are @xmath1 lines in the tree satisfies @xmath2 almost surely ; ( ii ) at time @xmath0 , the population is naturally partitioned in exactly @xmath1 families where individuals belong to the same family if they have a common ancestor at time @xmath0 in the past . if @xmath3 denotes the size of the @xmath4th family , then @xmath5 almost surely . for both laws of large numbers we prove corresponding large deviations results . for ( i ) , the rate of the large deviations is @xmath1 and we can give the rate function explicitly . for ( ii ) , the rate is @xmath1 for downwards deviations and @xmath6 for upwards deviations . for both cases we give the exact rate function . = = = = |
quant-ph0307206 | entanglement @xcite in a composite system refers to certain implicit correlation between the subsystems arising from their interaction . it is the key resource of quantum computation and quantum information processing @xcite . due to recent advances in this field , entanglement has generated renewed interest . there have been different approaches to understand and to quantify entanglement @xcite . but so far the entanglement , only in a bipartite pure state has been investigated very extensively . the von neumann entropy @xcite of either of the subsystems provides a good measure of entanglement in this case @xcite . this is the quantum partner of the shannon s entropy @xcite in classical information theory and is defined as @xcite @xmath1 where @xmath2 . here , @xmath3 is the reduced density operator of the subsystem @xmath4 and is given by @xmath5 where @xmath6 is the density operator of the composite system under consideration and @xmath7 , @xmath8 . in general , the quantities @xmath9 satisfy the following inequality ( due to araki and lieb ) @xcite : @xmath10 where @xmath11 is the joint entropy of the composite system comprising @xmath12 and @xmath13 . the second part of the above inequality is known as subadditivity inequality @xcite . for a pure state , @xmath14 and thus @xmath15 . the equality sign in the above relation holds good if and only if the composite density matrix @xmath6 can be written as a tensor product of its two reduced density matrices @xmath16 and @xmath17 , i.e. , for a disentangled state . one can define the index of correlation @xmath18 given by the expression @xmath19 @xcite , which can also be interpreted as information entropy in quantum information point of view . we note that kim _ et al . _ have calculated the entropies of different kinds of pure states including two - mode fock states and squeezed states @xcite . further , the above relation for entropy has been studied in the context of entangled gaussian states @xcite . so far we have discussed about the measurement of entanglement in a bipartite pure state . if the composite system is in a mixed state ( defined by the density operator @xmath20 ) , the entanglement of formation @xmath21 can be defined in terms of the average von neumann entropies of the pure states of the decompositions @xcite . wootters has shown the quantity @xmath21 to be an explicit function of @xmath20 @xcite . he has introduced the notion of concurrence in this context . we further notice that from the schmidt decomposition of a pure bipartite state , one can properly identify the entanglement present in the state @xcite . this is also very useful to study bipartite continuous systems @xcite . on the other hand , for a mixed state @xmath20 , the separability criterion has been proposed @xcite to study entanglement . this is based on positive partial transpose mapping of @xmath20 . thus the negativity ( entanglement monotone ) of the eigenvalues of the partial transpose of @xmath20 could be a measure of entanglement in a mixed bipartite system @xcite . the concept of negativity as an entanglement measure has been used in context of interaction of atoms with thermal field @xcite . the separability criterion has been extended to continuous systems @xcite also . despite many approaches to define entanglement for a bipartite system , there have been only a few approaches to quantify entanglement in the composite systems of three or more particles @xcite . we note that a generalization of schmidt decomposition in multipartite systems in pure states has been introduced @xcite . @xcite proposed a measurement of entanglement in a tripartite system in terms of concurrences of the pairs of subsystems . this measure is invariant under permutations of the subsystems . an average entanglement in a four - partite entangled state has been defined in terms of von neumann entropies of the pairs of subsystems @xcite . very recently , yukalov has addressed the question more generally and quantified multipartite entanglement @xcite in terms of the ratio of norms of an entangling operator and of a disentangling operator in the relevant disentangled hilbert space . in this paper , we put forward a possible measurement of entanglement of a four - particle system by studying the entropy of the reduced three - particle system . as mentioned above , the von neumann entropy is a good measure for entanglement in a bipartite system . for a tripartite composite state , this entropy satisfies a strong subadditivity inequality ( ssi ) @xcite , which has many important implications in the subject of quantum information theory . in this paper , we study the properties of a four - particle entangled state through the three - particle entropy and the ssi . the structure of the paper is as follows . in sec . ii , we provide a brief discussion on strong subadditivity inequality from the quantum information point of view . in sec . iii , we describe a physical model and show the preparation of a four - particle entangled state . in sec . iv , we study the validity of the ssi in the present context and provide a physical explanation of the results . we conclude this paper by proposing a measurement of the corresponding four - particle entanglement . we have already mentioned that for a bipartite composite system of two particles @xmath12 and @xmath13 , the joint entropy @xmath11 satisfies the subadditivity inequality ( [ ineq ] ) . for a composite system of three particles a , b , and c , this inequality can be extended to the following form @xcite : @xmath22 this inequality is known as strong subadditivity inequality . the most obvious situation that the equality sign holds in ( [ lieb ] ) is when the composite density matrix @xmath23 can be written as the tensor product of its three reduced density matrices as @xmath24 , i.e. , when the system is in a disentangled state . however , the more stringent condition for this reads as @xcite @xmath25 there have been numerous implications of the above inequality ( [ lieb ] ) in quantum information theory @xcite . firstly , it refers to the fact that the conditioning on the subsystem always reduces the entropy , i.e. , @xmath26 , where , @xmath27 is the entropy of a conditional on knowing the state of b. secondly , the above inequality implies that discarding a quantum system never increases mutual information , i.e. , @xmath28 , where , @xmath29 is the mutual information of the subsystems a and b. thirdly , quantum operations never increase mutual information of two subsystems . this means that if the mutual information of the two subsystems a and b becomes @xmath30 after trace - preserving operation on b , then @xmath31 . further , this inequality ( [ lieb ] ) implies that the conditional entropy of the subsystems a , b , and c is also subadditive , i.e. , @xmath32 . to verify ssi , one needs to calculate the entropies like @xmath33 which clearly requires a three - particle mixed state which we can produce using a pure four - particle entangled state @xcite . in the next section , we discuss how one can prepare a pure four - particle entangled state so that we can study ssi for the first time for a system realizable using cavity qed methods . we consider two three - level atoms ( a and b ) with relevant energy levels in @xmath0-configuration ( see fig . [ fig1 ] ) interacting with a two - mode high quality optical cavity . the specified annihilation operators for the cavity modes are @xmath34 and @xmath35 . the atoms are interacting with the cavity mode @xmath34 in @xmath36 transition and with the mode @xmath35 in @xmath37 transition . the hamiltonian for the system under rotating wave approximation can be written as @xmath38\;,\ ] ] where , @xmath39 is the atomic transition frequency between the levels @xmath40 and @xmath41 , @xmath42 @xmath43 is the respective frequency of the cavity modes @xmath34 and @xmath35 , @xmath44 @xmath43 provides the atom - cavity coupling . we assume @xmath44 s to be real and function of time . we start with the initial state @xmath45 , where @xmath46 and @xmath47 are the initial numbers of photons in the cavity modes @xmath34 and @xmath35 , respectively and the two atoms are in @xmath48 state . the state of the system can be expanded in terms of the relevant basis states in the following way : @xmath49 from the schrdinger equation we find the following equations of the corresponding probability amplitudes : @xmath50\;,\\ \dot{d}_6&=&-i(\sqrt{\mu + 2}g_{2a}d_4+\sqrt{\mu + 2}g_{2b}d_7)\;,\nonumber\\ \dot{d}_7&=&-i(\sqrt{\mu + 1}g_{2a}d_5+\sqrt{\mu + 2}g_{2b}d_6+\delta d_7+\sqrt{n-1}g_{1b}d _ 8)\;,\nonumber\\ \dot{d}_8&=&-i(\sqrt{n-1}g_{1b}d_7+\sqrt{\mu + 1}g_{2a}d_9)\;,\nonumber\\ \dot{d}_9&=&-i(\sqrt{n}g_{1a}d_1+\sqrt{n-1}g_{1b}d_5+\sqrt{\mu + 1}g_{2a}d_8+\delta d_9)\;,\nonumber\end{aligned}\ ] ] where , we have used the following transformations : @xmath51 where , @xmath52 , @xmath53 is the one - photon detuning of the cavity modes for the @xmath54-th atom . here we have assumed that the cavity modes are in two - photon resonance and @xmath55 . writing these equations ( [ doteq ] ) in the matrix form @xmath56=-i[m][d_i]$ ] , we find that one of the eigenvalues of the matrix @xmath57 $ ] is zero . the corresponding eigenstate is @xmath58\ ; , \label{dark}\ ] ] where @xmath59 clearly , this state is an entangled state of four particles , namely , the atoms a and b , and the two modes @xmath34 and @xmath35 . using appropriate time - dependence of the pulses , the four - particle system can be prepared in this state , as discussed in the next section . recently , there have a few experimental demonstrations of preparation of four - particle entangled state @xcite and performance of a c - not gate @xcite . interestingly , the state @xmath60 is a two - atom two - mode multipartite coherent population trapping ( cpt ) state which is a counterpart of the well - known cpt state for a single atom interacting with two coherent fields @xcite . we next discuss how the state @xmath60 can be prepared by using raman adiabatic passage technique . we assume that both the atoms are initially in @xmath48 state . we further assume the time - dependence of the rabi frequencies @xmath44 of the two modes as @xmath61 here , @xmath62 ( @xmath63 ) is the amplitude of the respective pulse , @xmath64 and @xmath65 are the width and time - separation respectively , of the two pulses . note that the pulses are applied in counterintuitive sequence . under this condition , the atom - cavity system follows the evolution of the state @xmath60 adiabatically . this state is a zero eigenvalue eigenstate ( adiabatic state ) of the hamiltonian ( [ hamil1 ] ) . during this process , known as stimulated raman adiabatic technique ( stirap ) @xcite , the atom - cavity system remains in this state for all times . in the present case , at the end of the evolution , the population of both the atoms are simultaneously transferred to the state @xmath66 . however , if the atoms are not in one - photon resonance , i.e. , if @xmath67 , then this transfer process is not complete . this happens because the system does not remain confined in the null adiabatic state @xmath60 for @xmath67 @xcite . we now investigate the validity of ssi for any trio of quantum systems in the present process . we can express this inequality for any three particles , namely , atom a , atom b , and cavity mode @xmath34 with number @xmath46 of photons out of the four - particle system under consideration as @xmath68 here , @xmath69 defines the joint von neumann entropy of the relevant subsystems [ see eq . ( [ entropy ] ) ] . this can be calculated from the state ( [ wavefunc ] ) by tracing over the other subsystems , e.g. , @xmath70 where , @xmath6 is the reduced density matrix of the atoms a and b and is given by @xmath71 we show the time variation of @xmath72 in fig . clearly , @xmath73 never becomes negative during the evolution and thus the ssi ( [ ssi ] ) holds for all times . from fig . [ fig2 ] , one clearly sees that for @xmath74 , in long time limit , @xmath72 becomes zero . this means that the subsystems ( a , b , and the mode @xmath34 with photon number @xmath46 ) become disentangled . this happens because of complete adiabatic transfer of population to the level @xmath66 of both the atoms at long time limit . the entire process can be written as @xmath75 we have shown the time - variation of the coefficients @xmath76 , @xmath77 , @xmath78 , and @xmath79 [ see eq . ( [ norm ] ) ] in fig . [ fig3 ] . this figure reveals the above evolution according to the state @xmath60 under the action of the pulses ( [ pulse ] ) . but for @xmath80 , since complete population transfer does not occur , the system remains entangled in the state @xmath81 at long time limit . this is clear from the dashed curve of fig . [ fig2 ] , as the equality @xmath82 no longer holds at this time limit . thus we can recognize the expression @xmath72 [ see eq . ( [ ssi ] ) ] as a measure of four - particle entanglement in the present process . precisely , @xmath83 , where the equality sign holds good for the disentangled states . an increase in value of @xmath72 refers to increase in entanglement . thus , during the evolution , the system gets more entangled for @xmath74 than for @xmath80 . however , at the end of the evolution , the entanglement persists for nonzero @xmath84 . we must emphasize here that , the present definition of entanglement measurement satisfies all the relevant criteria , namely , ( a ) it is semipositive , i.e. , @xmath83 , ( b ) @xmath82 for an disentangled state , and ( c ) the function @xmath73 is continuous in time domain . using our four - particle entanglement , we can also study the inequality ( [ ineq ] ) involving the entropies of two particles , say , atoms a and b. they remain strongly correlated during the evolution , as @xmath18 remains much larger than zero . at the end of the evolution , @xmath18 becomes zero for @xmath85 which means that the subsystems become uncorrelated . in other words , the entanglement between them vanishes . we note in passing that for a four - particle ghz state defined by @xmath86 of four qubits a , b , c , and d , one is led to a three - particle mixed state @xmath23 defined by @xmath87 in this case , @xmath88 . therefore , the parameter @xmath72 in this case becomes zero , as from eq . ( [ ssi ] ) . so we have a counter - example , in which the equality sign in ( [ lieb ] ) holds for an entangled state , too . however , we note that the above state ( [ mix ] ) satisfies the condition ( [ must ] ) and thus the said equality . in conclusion , we have shown for the first time the role of strong subadditivity inequality for entropies in a four - particle composite system . the stimulated raman adiabatic technique has been used to prepare the four - particle entangled state using two three - level atoms initially in their ground states in a two - mode cavity . we further show that the parameter @xmath72 could serve as a possible measurement of entanglement in the four - particle entangled state under consideration . c. h. bennett , g. brassard , s. popescu , b. schumacher , j. a. smolin , and w. k. wootters , phys . lett . * 76 * , 722 ( 1996 ) ; c. h. bennett , d. p. divincenzo , j. smolin , and w. k. wootters , phys . rev . a * 54 * , 3824 ( 1996 ) . a. peres , phys . lett . * 77 * , 1413 ( 1996 ) ; m. horodecki , p. horodecki , and r. horodecki , phys . a * 223 * , 1 ( 1996 ) ; p. horodecki , _ ibid . _ * 232 * , 333 ( 1997 ) ; v. giovannetti , s. mancini , d. vitali , and p. tombesi , phys . rev . a * 67 * , 022320 - 1 ( 2003 ) . c. a. sackett , d. kielpinski , b. e. king , c. langer , v. meyer , c. j. myatt , m. rowe , q. a. turchette , w. m. itano , d. j. wineland , and c. monroe , nature ( london ) * 404 * , 256 ( 2000 ) ; m. eibl , s. gaertner , m. bourennane , c. kurtsiefer , m. ukowski , and h. weinfurter , phys . lett . * 90 * , 200403 ( 2003 ) . | strong subadditivity inequality for a three - particle composite system is an important inequality in quantum information theory which can be studied via a four - particle entangled state . we use two three - level atoms in @xmath0 configuration interacting with a two - mode cavity and the raman adiabatic passage technique for the production of the four - particle entangled state . using this four - particle entanglement , we study for the first time various aspects of the strong subadditivity inequality . |
1412.2508 | slowly pulsating b - type supergiants ( spbsg ) have emerged as a new class of pulsating variables after saio et al . ( 2006 ) have detected pulsational frequencies in the most satellite data of the blue supergiant hd 163899 ( b2 ib / ii , klare & neckel 1977 , schmidt & carruthers 1996 ) . saio et al . ( 2006 ) identified 48 frequency peaks in the most light curve and attributed them to g- and p - mode pulsations . because so far only one object of this type is found , the spbsg class is not yet well defined as for the range of effective temperature and luminosity . also the evolutionary status of these pulsators remains unrevealed ; they may be either in the shell hydrogen burning phase as well as after core helium ignition . the finding of saio et al . ( 2006 ) has prompted a few groups ( godart et al . 2009 , daszyska - daszkiewicz , ostrowski , pamyatnykh . 2013 ; hereafter d2013 ) to reanalyse pulsation stability in models of b - type stars after the terminal age main sequence ( tams ) and to further studies of spbsg variables . the presence of g - mode pulsations in b - type post - main sequence stars has been explained by a partial reflection of some modes at an intermediate convective zone ( icz ) related to the hydrogen - burning shell or at a chemical gradient zone surrounding the radiative core . however , all studies of these objects published so far are based on the assumption that hd 163899 has not reached the phase of core helium ignition , i.e. , it is in the phase of shell hydrogen burning . this assumption might not necessary be fulfilled , because the blue loop can reach temperatures of early b spectral types . in this paper we calculate models which undergo core helium burning on the blue loop and compare them with models in the hydrogen shell burning phase . the structure of the paper is as follows . in section [ domains ] , we present the new instability domains which include pulsational instability on the blue loops . the effects of opacity , metallicity , overshooting , element diffusion and mass loss on the pulsational instability areas are studied . propagation diagrams and properties of instability parameter and kinetic energy of modes for representative models are described in section [ models ] . in section [ identification ] we construct photometric diagnostic diagrams for the b - type supergiant models and discuss a prospect for mode identification . an attempt to interpret the oscillation spectrum of hd 163899 is presented in section [ hd163899 ] . the last section contains conclusions . the evolutionary models were calculated with mesa evolution code ( modules for experiments in stellar astrophysics , paxton et al . 2011 , paxton et al . 2013 ) . mesa allows to follow the evolution of massive stars to the pre - supernova phase . our previous calculations ( d2013 ) were limited to the phase before core helium ignition due to the lack of helium burning in warsaw - new jersey evolution code we used . we considered the mass range of 13@xmath318 @xmath0 . all computed models have an initial hydrogen abundance of @xmath4 and agss09 metal mixture ( asplund et al . the initial metal abundance varies from @xmath5 to @xmath6 . opal ( iglesias & rogers 1996 ) and op opacity tables ( seaton 2005 ) were used . all effects of rotation were neglected . non - adiabatic pulsation analysis was performed using the code of dziembowski ( 1977 ) . in fig.[fig1 ] we present evolutionary tracks including various effects : opacity , metallicity , overshooting , mass loss and element diffusion . they will be discussed in detail in the following subsections . the convective zones are determined by the ledoux criterion . it seems to be more justified than the schwarzschild criterion because of a direct sensitivity of the chemical gradient to evolution . lebreton et al . ( 2009 ) argued that the use of the ledoux criterion leads to a narrower icz and hence to the smaller number of unstable modes . in case of our models , mesa produces the wide icz with both criterions and this effect is not significant . for the envelope , we adopted the parameter of the mixing length theory ( mlt ) of @xmath7 which is the higher value than usually used for massive stars . during the main sequence ( ms ) and hydrogen - shell burning phases , the value of @xmath8 has a negligible effect on structure of massive stars but on the red giant branch ( rgb ) a higher efficiency of convection is needed and hence we opted for the higher value of @xmath8 . we took into account convective overshooting from the hydrogen and helium core and inward overshooting from non - burning convective zones , using the exponential formula ( herwig 2000 ) : @xmath9 where @xmath10 is the diffusion coefficient derived from mlt at a user - defined location near the boundary of a convective zone , @xmath11 is the pressure scale height at that location , @xmath12 is the distance in the radiative layer away from that location , and @xmath13 is an adjustable parameter , which we set to @xmath14 for most of calculated models . this value of @xmath13 mimics the behaviour of step overshooting with @xmath15 . in our models the core helium ignition commences on the way towards the rgb but at this stage the energy produced from the helium burning is much lower than the energy produced from the hydrogen shell burning . the shell dominates the evolution up to the tip of rgb . at this point the energy produced in a helium core becomes comparable to the energy from the shell and the luminosity of a star drops . a star might eventually move towards higher effective temperatures and form a blue loop . the behaviour of the blue loops is still very poorly known and it is difficult to predict the effect of different parameters on their properties . we found that the convective overshooting has the most visible effect on their emergence , especially the inward overshooting from the non - burning zone . without that overshooting it is impossible to obtain blue loops in our models independently of metallicity , opacity , diffusion , etc . this effect is shown in fig.[fig2 ] , where we depicted two evolutionary tracks for the mass of 15 @xmath0 calculated with and without inward overshooting from the non - burning zone . the blue loop emerges if the @xmath16-gradient left by the evolution during ms is erased by the outer convective zone on the rgb . the range of this convective zone is increased by the inward overshooting . on the other hand , the overshooting from the hydrogen core generally acts against emerging of the blue loops . we show the effect of different values of the overshooting parameter on the evolutionary tracks in the central - left panel ( @xmath17 ) and in the bottom - left panel ( @xmath18 ) of fig.[fig1 ] . in both cases the blue loops are present but for the lower value of @xmath13 they have a larger extension . if we increase the overshooting only from the hydrogen core to @xmath18 and we leave @xmath17 for the helium core overshooting and the inward overshooting from non - burning zone , the blue loops still emerge but their extension is lower . this is caused mainly by the reduced overshooting from the helium core which decreases the amount of helium available to burn and hence leads to smaller extension of the blue loop . with ( solid line ) and without ( dashed line ) inward overshooting from the non - burning convective zone . opal opacity tables and metallicity @xmath19 were used.,width=325 ] the presented examples show that properties of mixing , especially the convective overshooting , have a huge impact on the behaviour of the blue loops . it is difficult to discriminate between different effects but generally it seems that the inward overshooting from the outer convective zone on the rgb is indispensable to obtain blue loops for the models in the studied range of masses . the overshooting from the hydrogen core suspends the emerging of the blue loops and the overshooting from the helium core has a slight effect on their extension . for the models considered in section2.1 , we computed pulsational instability for modes with the degrees @xmath20 . they are shown as thick lines in in fig.[fig1 ] . the top panels show models calculated with @xmath21 and opal ( the top - left panel ) and op opacity tables ( the top - right panel ) . the central panels depicts models calculated for @xmath22 and opal tables without and with mass loss ( the central - left and central - right panels , respectively ) . the bottom - left panel shows the models calculated with @xmath22 , opal tables and convective overshooting parameter @xmath18 . the bottom - right panel depicts models calculated with element diffusion . details of the used mass - loss models and implementation of diffusion are described later in this section . similarly to our previous results ( d2013 ) there is the p- and g - mode instability beyond tams for the models that undergo hydrogen shell burning . most of the unstable modes are non - radial , but the radial fundamental mode is also unstable in hotter models beyond main sequence . the main difference between our current and all previous calculations is the presence of unstable non - radial modes on the blue loops for more massive models ( @xmath23 and @xmath24 ) . the radial modes are stable in this evolutionary stage in all calculated models . the existence of pulsation instability on the blue loop , as well as the blue loops themselves , depend critically on the metallicity , @xmath25 . with lowering the metallicity the blue loops reach the higher effective temperatures which has a huge impact on pulsation instability . in models with the lower value of @xmath26 the driving layer related to the metal opacity bump is located too deep in the star to be effective . on the other hand , the lower value of metallicity the lower the @xmath25 opacity bump . this crucially weakens instability for the ms and h - shell burning models but it seems to have a negligible effect on the instability on the blue loops , especially when compared to the effect of the effective temperature . in models with @xmath27 the instability in the phase before core helium ignition is entirely quenched whereas there are still a lot of unstable modes in the models with very well developed blue loop . the pulsational instability on the blue loops vanishes at @xmath28 . the reason for that is a difference in the internal structure resulting from a presence of an inward overshooting from the nonburning zone in the blue - loop models . the main effect of this overshooting is visible during the evolution on the rgb , but there is also a thin zone of overshooting below the icz . that leads to enrichment of hydrogen in layers just below the icz , which causes a steep increase of the @xmath16-gradient in a thin zone . as a consequence the brunt - visl frequency , @xmath29 , increases as well , what makes trapping of pulsation modes more effective and some of them can be driven by the @xmath1-mechanism operating in the z - bump despite low metallicity . the opposite situation occurs for models with higher metallicities . for example with @xmath6 there is a large instability area beyond ms but there are no unstable modes in the blue loop models , because of too low temperature the blue loops reach . the exceptions are the highest considered masses - @xmath30 for opal opacities and @xmath31 for op opacity tables . for those masses there are a few models on the hottest part of the blue loops that have unstable modes . for every calculated mass and independently of metallicity or opacity tables we obtained unstable radial modes in the cooler models on the red giant branch or its vicinity . this result is similar to the one from saio et al . ( 2013 ) and it was expected because in this area of hr diagram a classical instability strip is located . those models are high - mass classical cepheids , in which the pulsations are driven in a region of the second ionization of helium . it is important to note that there are two effects that make the pulsational code we use unsuitable for such stars : the linear approximation and the lack of convection - pulsation interaction . we use the convective flux freezing approximation which is not adequate in large outer convective zones . we do not study properties of these stars to any further extent in this paper . ( solid lines ) and and the lamb frequencies , @xmath32 , for @xmath33 ( dashed lines ) and @xmath34 ( dotted lines ) , as a function of @xmath35 , for model1 ( top panel ) and model2 ( bottom panel ) . the scales of @xmath26 are different to represent the actual temperature profiles of the models.,title="fig:",width=332 ] ( solid lines ) and and the lamb frequencies , @xmath32 , for @xmath33 ( dashed lines ) and @xmath34 ( dotted lines ) , as a function of @xmath35 , for model1 ( top panel ) and model2 ( bottom panel ) . the scales of @xmath26 are different to represent the actual temperature profiles of the models.,title="fig:",width=332 ] as depicted in fig.[fig1 ] , for @xmath21 and @xmath36 there is a large instability strip that covers models both before and after core helium ignition . a comparison of the top- and central - left panels gives the effect of metallicity . for @xmath21 ( top - left panel ) , the range of effective temperatures that covers unstable models on the blue loop is a little wider than for @xmath22 ( central - left panel ) . this is a consequence of a larger extension of the loops towards the higher effective temperatures for lower metallicieties . as expected , an increase in @xmath25 results in wider instability area on ms and beyond tams . the upper panels show an effect of opacity tables on instability domains for @xmath21 , but the main conclusions are the same for every tested metallicity . there are significant differences on the ms phase , due to a long - known fact that for op tables instability starts earlier than for opal tables . during the hydrogen shell burning phase and on the blue loop the differences are very subtle . the loops and instability areas have slightly different shapes but generally they are similar for both sources of the opacity data . in the central panels we compare instability domains for models with @xmath22 calculated without ( the central - left panel ) and with mass loss ( the central - right panel ) . for @xmath37 we used the wind s scheme of vink et al . ( 2001 ) whereas for @xmath38 a recipe of de jager et al . ( 1988 ) was adopted . we do not study very massive models and hence the amount of mass which is lost during the evolution is rather modest . for instance , a star with initial mass of @xmath39 loses only about @xmath40 during the evolution from zams to the point when helium is depleted in its core . the maximum value of the mass - loss rate is reached on the tip of the red giant branch and for the @xmath39 star it has the value of @xmath41 . mass loss seems to have a negligible effect on instability of models immediately beyond tams , whereas this effect on the instability on the blue loops is much more pronounced . with the reduced mass a star reaches lower luminosity during helium burning phase and also a blue loop reaches lower effective temperature than for models calculated without mass loss . both of these effects lead to smaller instability range during this phase of evolution . the description of wind which we used for lower effective temperatures ( de jager et al . ( 1988 ) ) gives relatively low values of mass loss when compared to other models we checked ( nieuwenhuijzen & de jager 1990 , van loon et al . 2005 , reimers 1975 ) . it means that the instability areas on the blue loops calculated with other mass - loss models would be even smaller or entirely vanished . also with sufficiently high mass loss the blue loops do not emerge at all . we will not discuss effects of mass loss anymore in this paper because they do not change any qualitative results presented here . despite this it has to be remembered that it is a common phenomenon and it should be enabled during construction of detailed asteroseismic models . the bottom - left panel depicts the instability areas calculated for higher value of convective overshooting , @xmath18 . the most important difference when compared to models with @xmath17 ( central - left panel ) is smaller extension of the blue loops and hence there are no unstable models present during this evolutionary phase . in the bottom - right panel of fig.[fig1 ] we present models calculated with @xmath22 , opal opacity tables and element diffusion . mesa calculates element diffusion by solving burgler s equations using the method and diffusion coefficients of thoul et al . the effect of diffusion on the shape of evolution tracks and instability areas is negligible , both for models before and after core helium ignition . the small changes of abundances of chemical elements in the central regions of the star do not modify significantly a behaviour of pulsation modes . the minor differences of frequencies might be important during a comparison to the observations but they do not influence the qualitative results presented here . here , we compare pulsation properties of two representative models with similar positions in the h - r diagram but in two different evolutionary stages , one during the shell hydrogen burning phase ( @xmath39 , @xmath42 , @xmath43 , hereafter model1 ) and the second during core helium burning ( @xmath44 , @xmath45 , @xmath46 , hereafter model2 ) . they are calculated with opal opacity tables , agss09 metal mixture and @xmath19 . propagation of pulsational modes in the radial direction is confined to the regions determined by the two characteristic frequencies ( e.g. , unno et al . 1989 ) , i.e. , the lamb ( acoustic ) frequency ( @xmath47 ) and brunt - visl ( buoyancy ) frequency ( @xmath48 ) . the values of @xmath47 depend mostly on the mode degree , @xmath49 , whereas the brunt - visl frequency is very sensitive to the structure of a star ( e.g. , a presence of convective zones or chemical gradients ) . in fig.[fig3 ] , we present propagation diagrams , i.e. , @xmath50 , @xmath51 , for models 1 and 2 ( the top and bottom panels , respectively ) . the main difference between these models is the presence of a convective core ( @xmath52 ) in the model on the blue loop , whereas the model that undergoes shell hydrogen burning has a radiative core . beyond the core , the propagation diagrams of these two models are qualitatively similar ; in particular , both have a fully developed intermediate convective zone . the two spikes in the run of brunt - visl frequency that occur in the vicinity of convective zones in model2 have different origin . the one at the border of the convective core is both a consequence of the very steep @xmath16-gradient in this region of star ( the main reason ) and also a numerical effect related to the extreme difficulties with precise determination of the border of helium core by evolution codes . due to a very high sensitivity of triple - alpha process to a change of temperature , the location of border changes slightly with every step of evolution . that results in an artificial increase of the @xmath16-gradient , which is clearly visible in behaviour of @xmath29 . the second spike , at the innermost border of icz is related to the presence of inward overshooting from this convective zone . that leads to a steep change of @xmath16 and a peak in the propagation diagram . in fig.[fig4 ] , we present the instability parameter , @xmath53 , for modes with the harmonic spherical degrees @xmath54 , as a function of frequency for models 1 and 2 ( the top and bottom panels respectively ) . instability parameter measures the net energy gained by a mode during one pulsational cycle and is defined as ( stellingwerf 1978 ) : @xmath55 where @xmath56 is the global work integral . this definition gives normalization @xmath57 $ ] . if @xmath58 a pulsation mode is unstable and if @xmath59 it is stable . there are two global maxima of @xmath53 in model1 , which is similar to the behaviour during the ms evolution ( d2013 ) . the first one , at low frequencies , is related to the very high - order g - modes , while the second one , at higher frequencies , is related to the low - order p- and g - modes . all non - radial modes in the second group are mixed modes and they behave like p - modes only in the outer envelope of the star . in the frequency range presented in fig.[fig4 ] , i.e. , from 0.04 to 3.5 d@xmath60 , the values of the radial order , @xmath61 , are in ranges of about @xmath62 for the @xmath33 modes and @xmath63 for the @xmath34 modes . in model1 the fundamental radial mode and the first overtone are unstable with the ratio of periods @xmath64 . the most interesting behaviour of @xmath53 is visible in the vicinity of the first maximum . there is a clearly visible pattern of consecutive local minima and maxima , which does not occur in ms models . this phenomenon is related to the partial trapping of pulsation modes in the radiative core and the envelope . the detailed description of this phenomenon can be found in our previous paper ( d2013 ) . in model2 , which burns helium in its core , a situation is different . there are only a few very high - order low - frequency g - modes which are unstable . these maximum values of @xmath53 are shifted towards lower frequencies when compared to model1 . there is no pattern of local minima and maxima and the calculated frequency spectrum is much sparser than for model1 . this is typical for every blue - loop that a number of unstable modes is very low . model2 has one unstable dipole mode with frequencies of @xmath65 c / d and two unstable quadruple modes with frequencies @xmath66 c / d . radial modes are always stable in models during core helium burning phase , regardless of metallicity , opacity tables , etc . however , the ratio of periods between the first overtone and the fundamental mode is visibly lower than in model1 and has a value @xmath67 . in model2 , the radial orders of pulsation modes are much larger , in particular for the quadruple mode . for the considered range of @xmath68 , cf . fig.[fig4 ] , the values of @xmath61 are : @xmath69 for @xmath33 and @xmath70 for @xmath34 . in fig.[fig5 ] , we compare the kinetic energy densities , @xmath71 ( top panels ) , and differential work integrals , @xmath72 ( bottom panels ) , for unstable and stable modes of the degree @xmath34 with very close frequencies . the left group of panels is for model1 ( before core helium ignition ) and the left group of panels for model2 ( after core helium ignition ) . the behaviour of presented modes is typical and representative for all unstable and stable modes during shell hydrogen burning and on the blue loops . the properties of pulsational modes in the shell hydrogen burning model have been already presented in d2013 but for comparative purposes we repeat them here . in model1 , both unstable ( @xmath73 c / d , @xmath74 ) and stable ( @xmath75 , @xmath76 ) modes exhibit a very strong damping in the radiative helium core , which is visible in the behaviour of @xmath72 in the bottom panels of the left group . as shown in the upper panels of this group , most of the kinetic energy of the modes is confined in the central region . the most notable difference between the presented modes is that the unstable one has some energy deposited also in the radiative envelope , whereas the stable one has almost no energy in this region . this is due to the fact that the unstable mode has been partially reflected at the icz and is trapped in two cavities : the core and the outer layers . that energy , although its amount is small when compared to the amount trapped in the core , is sufficient for the @xmath1 mechanism , operating in the @xmath2bump , to efficiently drive the pulsations . this is visible in the behaviour of differential work integral - there is a maximum around @xmath77 and it dominates over the damping in the core . on the contrary , the stable mode has not been reflected at icz because it does not have a node of eigenfunction there . that means that it penetrates the core with high amplitude and is effectively damped there . the above behaviour of @xmath71 explains the pattern of local maxima and minima of @xmath53 described earlier on . for model2 we also compare two very close modes : the unstable one with @xmath78 c / d and @xmath79 and the stable one with @xmath80 c / d and @xmath81 . their kinetic energy densities and differential work integrals are shown in the right group of panels in fig.[fig5 ] . the behavior of @xmath71 is different for these modes than for the modes from the model1 . the entire energy of the stable mode is confined to the radiative zone in - between the convective core and the icz ( there is strong damping in this region of the star ) , whereas the unstable mode has almost all of its energy trapped in the outer radiative zone . that means that the unstable modes of the blue loop models have to be almost entirely reflected at the icz . this fact might be the explanation why we do have far fewer unstable modes from models burning helium in its core than from models before core helium ignition and also the lack of the structure of @xmath53 observed in model1 . the behaviour of kinetic energy density depicted in fig.[fig5 ] is typical for all unstable and stable modes both during hydrogen shell burning and on the blue loops . in our previous paper ( d2013 ) , we have shown that one should not expect regular patterns in the oscillation spectra of blue supergiants which the asymptotic theory predicts for g - mode pulsations . however , it turned out that there is a prospect for identification of the degree , @xmath49 , for modes excited in the blue supergiant models before core helium ignition from photometric diagnostic diagrams ( d2013 ) . here , we will check whether the photometric amplitudes and phases of pulsations in models after core helium ignition have similar properties . the expression for the complex amplitudes of the light variations in a given passband within the linear and zero - rotation approximation can be found , e.g. , in daszyska - daszkiewicz et al . ( 2002 ) , and need not be repeated here . to compute the values of these observables , we used the nonadiabatic pulsational code of dziembowski ( 1977 ) and tables of the fluxes in photometric passbands and nonlinear limb - darkening coefficients computed by daszyska - daszkiewicz & szewczuk ( 2011 ) on the basis of the nlte atmosphere models of lanz & hubeny ( 2007 ) . in fig.[fig6 ] , we show positions of unstable modes with the degree @xmath82 excited in the supergiant models in the photometric diagnostic diagrams employing the @xmath83 and @xmath84 johnson filters . these passbands are similar to those used on the bright - star target explorer constellation ( brite ) which is already operating . we used the opal data for the agss09 mixture and @xmath22 . in the left panel we marked positions of all unstable modes in models with masses @xmath85 whereas in the right panel we chose modes excited in models with @xmath86 and @xmath87 . these temperature range is a typical maximum error and larger than the error for hd 163899 ( saio et al . 2006 ) . with different symbols we discriminate between different values of @xmath49 and evolutionary stages . their meanings are described in the legend of the plots . in the diagram for all studied masses , there is a perfect separation between radial and non - radial modes and fairly good separation between dipoles and quadruples . a discrimination between models undergoing shell hydrogen burning and models on the blue loops is not obvious . modes excited in models on these evolution stages tend to group in slightly different locations but in a plot including such a range of masses their distinction would be uncertain given observational errors in the photometric amplitudes and phases . the situation improves slightly when we are able to constrain the mass and effective temperature . after fixing the range of @xmath26 in the right panel of fig.[fig6 ] , the separation between phases before and after core helium ignition can be noticeable . fig.[fig7 ] presents how the photometric observables depend on the mode frequency considering again the br johnson passbands and the same models as in the right panel of fig.[fig6 ] . from this plot we can conclude that much better separation between modes of different values of @xmath49 , from both the amplitude ratios and phase differences , occurs for higher frequency modes which are unstable only in model1 . and @xmath88 , respectively . the models have been calculated with @xmath21 and opal opacity tables . the grey area depicts the error of @xmath26 for hd 163899 ( saio et al . 2006).,width=332 ] the greatest uncertainty concerning spbsg stars is their evolutionary status . although the basic parameters ( @xmath26 , @xmath89 , @xmath25 , @xmath90 , etc . ) of hd 163899 are very poorly determined or unknown , our calculations still can give some insights about the star . in fig.[fig8 ] , we present a comparison of evolution times in the pulsational unstable region of hr diagram during shell hydrogen burning phase and on the blue loop , for models with masses @xmath91 and @xmath92 , respectively , and @xmath21 . the star spends only a very short time ( about 8 000 years ) in the instability strip during the shell - hydrogen burning phase compared to the time spent on the unstable region of the blue loop ( about 800 000 years ) . there should be much more stars in the region of hr diagram occupied by blue supergiants that undergo core helium burning than stars that moves towards red giant branch ( rgb ) . on the one hand , this is the main and only argument why spbsg stars should be on the blue loop . on the other hand , hd 163899 is the only know star of this type and we might be very lucky to catch it during the very short phase of pulsational instability before core helium ignition . other arguments also prefer this evolutionary stage . the instability area during a crossing towards rgb is wider in @xmath93 than on the blue loop . this is especially important when we take into account the effect of mass loss which is ubiquitous effect for massive stars . in such a case the instability area on the blue loops become very small . the most important argument is a number of excited modes ; there is much more unstable modes in models during the shell - hydrogen burning phase than in models on the blue loop . the last argument against the evolution on the blue loop is a complete lack of unstable high - frequency modes in this phase . such modes are present in the spectrum of hd 163899 and they are present in our models before core helium ignition . in fig.[fig9 ] , we compare the oscillation spectrum of hd 163899 ( top panel ) and the theoretical one computed for a model in the shell - hydrogen burning phase ( @xmath53 vs. @xmath68 , bottom panel ) . pulsational modes with the degree up to @xmath94 were considered . this is one of models in which the larger number of pulsation modes are excited . the observed spectrum consists of 48 frequencies between @xmath95 to @xmath96 c / d ( c.f . table 1 in saio et al . this range covers both g - modes ( high - order ) and p - modes in post - ms models . there are also frequencies between those two groups which do not occur in pulsation calculations . we do not know @xmath90 for the star and hence we do not include rotation in our calculations . this is left for the future work . the estimated critical velocity for model1 , which has the stellar radius @xmath97 , is @xmath98 km / s which corresponds to the critical rotation frequency of about @xmath99 c / d . it is very unlikely that a supergiant would rotate at such a high rate , but even with lower rotation rate the very low dominant frequency , @xmath100 c / d , could be explained by retrograde modes . the rotational splitting could also solve the biggest problem of our pulsation models which is too low number of unstable g - modes . as for the observed range of frequencies which occur between the theoretical g- and p - mode maxima , it could be filled in with the high @xmath49 modes of various azimuthal orders , @xmath101 . our goal was to study pulsational properties of b - type supergiants with masses @xmath102 , especially to check the possibility whether spbsg stars can undergo core helium burning . in addition to previously known spbsg instability strip ( saio et al . 2006 , d2013 ) which covers the stars that move towards rgb after departure from ms , we found the instability strip for the blue - loop models for the temperatures of b spectral types . its width depends on the extension and shape of the blue loops and hence it varies with many parameters , especially with metallicity , overshooting and mass loss . one of the most important results of our paper is the fact that an inward overshooting from the outer convective zone on the rgb phase is indispensable for the emergence of blue loops at all . the lower values of metallicity in the main sequence and shell hydrogen burning models acts towards decreasing pulsational instability whereas in the case of the blue loops models the most important factor is the effective temperature . for lower values of @xmath25 the blue loops have larger extension and the driving layer is located at the proper place for pulsation to be excited . we found unstable modes in the blue loop models with metallicity as low as @xmath103 . there is a difference in behaviour of instability parameter , @xmath53 , between models before and after core helium ignition . as we previously shown ( d2013 ) , in models during shell - hydrogen burning phase there are two groups of unstable mods ; one related to the very high - order g - modes and the second related to the p - mode behaviour . on the contrary , in models on the blue loops only the very high - order g - modes are unstable and the number of unstable modes is much lower than in models that departed from tams and move towards rgb . that might be explained by the difference in the kinetic energy density distribution between those two evolutionary phases . in models that undergo shell hydrogen burning , only a partial reflection of pulsation mode at the icz is sufficient to efficiently drive the mode , whereas on the blue loop the mode has to be almost entirely reflected in order to be unstable . comparing the properties of models before and after core helium ignition and frequencies detected in the light curve of hd 163899 , we drew a conclusion that spbsg stars should rather undergo shell hydrogen burning and not core helium burning on the blue loop . however , to fully support this statement a better determination of basic parameters of hd 163899 is needed and , in the next step , seismic model of the stars should be constructed taking into account the effects of rotation . we found also that mode identification from multicolour photometry is applicable to spbsg stars and hence multi - colour photometry for hd 163899 would be desirable . the analysis of such data could finally lead to constraining the evolutionary status of the star and help to understand pulsations of spbsg stars . this work was financially supported by the polish ncn grants 2013/09/n / st9/00611 , 2011/01/m / st9/05914 and 2011/01/b / st9/05448 . 99 asplund , m. , grevesse , n. , sauval , a. j. , scott , p. : 2009 , ara&a 47 , 481 daszyska - daszkiewicz j. , dziembowski w. a. , pamyatnykh a. a. , goupil m - j . , 2002 , a&a , 392 , 151 daszyska - daszkiewicz , j. , ostrowski , j. , pamyatnykh a.a . : 2013 , mnras 432 , 3153 ( d2013 ) daszyska - daszkiewicz j. , szewczuk w. , 2011 , apj , 728 , 17 dziembowski , w. : 1977 , aca 27 , 95 godart , m. , noels , a. , dupret , m .- a . , lebreton , y. , 2009 , mnras 396 , 1833 herwig , f. : 2000 , a&a , 360 , 952 iglesias , c. a. , rogers , f. j. : 1996 , apj 464 , 943 de jager , c. , nieuwenhuijzen , h. , van der hucht , k. a. : 1988 , a&as 72 , 259 klare , g. , neckel , t. : 1977 , a&as 27 , 215 lanz t. , hubeny i. 2007 , apjs , 169 , 83 lebreton , y. , montalbn , j. , godart , m. , et al . : 2009 , coast 158 , 277 van loon , j. th . , cioni , m .- l. , zijlstra , a. a. , loup , c. : 2005 , a&a 438 , 273 nieuwenhuijzen , h. , de jager , c. : 1990 , a&a 231 , 134 pamyatnykh , a. a. : 1999 , aca 49 , 119 pamyatnykh , a. a. , ziomek , w. : 2007 , coast 150 , 207 paxton , b. , bildsten , l. , dotter , a. , et al . : 2011 , apjs 192 , 3 paxton , b. , cantiello , m. , arras , p. , et al . : 2013 , apjs 208 , 4 reimers , d. : 1975 , mem . liege 8 , 369 saio , h. , kuschnig , r. , gautschy , a. , et al . : 2006 , apj 650 , 1111 saio , h. , georgy , c. , meynet , g. : 2013 , mnras 433 , 1246 schmidt , e. g. , carruthers , g. r. : 1996 , apjs 104 , 101 seaton , m. j. : 2005 , mnras 362 , l1 stellingwerf r. f. : 1978 , aj 83 , 1184 thoul , a. a. , bahcall , j. n. , loeb , a. : 1994 , apj 421 , 828 unno , w. , osaki , y. , ando , h. , saio , h. , shibahashi , h. : 1989 , nonradial oscillations of stars , tokyo , university of tokyo press vink , j. s. , de koter , a. , lamers , h. j. g. l. m. : 2001 , a&a 369 , 574 | evolutionary tracks and pulsational analysis of models with masses of 13 - 18 @xmath0 are presented . we address two important questions . the first one deals with one of the most unresolved problems in astrophysics , i.e. , the existence of a blue loop after core helium ignition ; the so called `` to loop or not to loop '' problem . we show that inward overshooting from the outer convective zone in the red giant phase is prerequisite for the development of the blue loop . our second question concerns pulsational instability of models in the core helium burning phase . we present for the first time that models on the blue loop can have unstable modes driven by the @xmath1 mechanism operating in the @xmath2bump . contrary to post - main sequence models in the shell hydrogen burning phases , pulsational instability of the blue loop models depends mainly on effective temperature and metallicity is of secondary importance . finally , we try to interpret the oscillation spectrum of the blue supergiant hd 163899 , the only member of the spbsg class , and to get some clue on the evolutionary status of the star . [ firstpage ] stars : early - type stars : supergiants stars : oscillations |
1001.0199 | the flight management infrastructure ( fmi ) product is intended to keep the aircraft from interfering with preplanned observations on the sky . it predicts the ground tracks necessary to execute its mission , and corrects the plan for actual conditions while airborne . to support this , it contains both a planning component that can run on the ground and in the air , and an execution component that runs in the air . the planning component manages a set of ordered observations and optional aircraft repositioning requests . the execution component compares the plan to actual conditions in flight and requests headings ( indirectly ) from the autopilot . sofia mission planning differs from satellite or ground based observatory planning in a few key areas . most importantly , the observatory position is a function of observation target history , which prevents observations from being considered as time - slots alone . assignment of flight dates is also nontrivial targets can not be localized on the sky or the observatory will always fly in about the same direction ( requiring nearly equivalent dead time to return ) ; this suggests entire flight series should be considered at once , for greater target variety . flight planning and execution differs from conventional as well . all conventional aircraft fly from point to point along specified paths on the ground , and `` drift '' the aircraft to compensate for winds . typical drift angles ( course - heading ) exceed 3@xmath0 , and the worst possible case approaches 30@xmath0 , so sofia can not necessarily observe in this manner . expected winds can be planned for using a weather forecast . correcting course for _ unexpected _ winds can be accomplished by adjusting observation durations , by relocating the aircraft between observations , or by `` observation triage '' as a last resort . this requires an astronomically - aware airborne monitoring function to compare current conditions to plan . aircraft capabilities are a strong function of fuel weight , which argues against simple parametrizing by time , in favor of fuel . in addition to the geometrical and practical constraints described above , the sofia flight planning problem also has a number of external constraints , all of which prevent a truly automated , or even rigorously sequential , flight planning process . for instance , special use airspace ( sua ) incursions may require external approval , and it can not be known ahead of time whether such approval will be forthcoming in all cases . national airspace boundaries require international agreements . over - ocean operations are prohibited for safety reasons for the first flights ; for later flights , fairly complex fuel reserve constraints are required . gross takeoff weight has a hard limit of 700,000 pounds , which limits the duration of sofia missions . some science - driven constraints require interaction with scientists or detailed knowledge of the observations ; especially , trading off water vapor overburden estimates with altitude and duration , and for trading off observations against each other . prior to any particular mission , several iterations of flight planning are performed . this is expected to include fully integrated automated flight planning ( frank , gross , & krkl 2004 ) , routinely . manual choice of observation ( including order ) will occur subsequently . upon execution , replanning might occur if conditions are sufficiently different from assumptions . figure [ fig : sampleflight ] shows a color - processed screenshot of a simulated flight intended for april , 2008 , from palmdale , ca . actual conditions for the simulation shown differ from planned only by small timing errors of the order of several seconds between segments and at takeoff . as mentioned earlier , it is advantageous to consider entire flight series at once , in order to trade observations between flights . the data structure supporting this is shown in fig . [ fig : flightseries ] . fmi requires substantial input data in order to accurately predict a flight track and its constraints . weather forecast time - series are taken from the national center for environmental prediction global forecasting system , quadrilinearly interpolated . an alternative is required for dates more than several days in the future , since accurate forecasts are not available then ; we use a set of stacked monthly means for 19972001 ( the last years available ) from the european center for medium ranger weather forcasting 40 year reanalysis ( uppala et . al . 2005 ) also quadrilinearly interpolated . aircraft performance is interpolated from tables generated by boeing inflt runs , for cruising , thrust - limited climbs , and descents . planned flight track intersections with special use airspace ( sua ) boundaries ( including non - us zones , from the us national imagery and mapping agency ) are evaluated using a quadtree - based search on the 8000 + sua boundaries for each flight segment . observation segments are treated as initial value problems in cartesian coordinates , others may be boundary or initial problems , as appropriate . desired headings are calculated during execution from planned ( not actual ) sky coordinates and actual position ; direct steering by the telescope can not be allowed for safety reasons . in order to test fmi components and integrate other systems , as well as for training purposes , we use a simulation environment . this includes a medium - fidelity aircraft simulator , an automated pilot simulator , a method to set the time arbitrarily , and a telescope simulator ( brggenwirth , gross , nelbach , & shuping 2008 ) . while airborne , the fmi software components interact with the airborne data acquisition software to acquire the aircraft s position and attitude . while on the ground , the planner portion of fmi interacts with observers planning software and must support multiple simultaneous planning sessions . the airborne configuration is shown in fig . [ fig : dataflow ] ; the ground configuration is similar , except there is no flight executor nor mccs data ( except in testing configurations ) , and there is a connection to the observation planning database . sofia presents a unique flight planning problem due to the nature of astronomical observation . fmi provides a connection between scientific needs of an observatory with the practical constraints of operating an aircraft , without introducing excessive safety considerations or pilot workload , or planner effort . brggenwirth , s. , gross , m. a. k. , nelbach , f. j. , & shuping , r. y. 2009 , , 485 frank , j. , gross , m. a. k. , & krkl , e. 2004 , in proc . 16th conf . on innovative applications of artificial intelligence , ed . d. l. mcguinness & g. ferguson ( boston : mit press ) , 828 uppala , s. m. et al . 2005 , quart . j. r. meterol . soc.,131 , 2961 | sofia is a 2.5 meter airborne infrared telescope , mounted in a boeing 747sp aircraft . due to the large size of the telescope , only a few degrees of azimuth are available at the telescope bearing . this means the heading of the aircraft is fundamentally associated with the telescope s observation targets , and the ground track necessary to enable a given mission is highly complex and dependent on the coordinates , duration , and order of observations to be performed . we have designed and implemented a flight management infrastructure ( fmi ) product in order to plan and execute such missions in the presence of a large number of external constraints ( e.g. restricted airspace , international boundaries , elevation limits of the telescope , aircraft performance , winds at altitude , and ambient temperatures ) . we present an overview of the fmi , including the process , constraints and basic algorithms used to plan and execute sofia missions . |
hep-lat0105026 | qcd at finite quark / baryon - number density at zero and at finite temperature describes nuclear matter . nuclear matter at high temperatures ( and possibly densities ) was certainly present in the early universe . neutron stars consist of dense cold nuclear matter . rhic and the cern heavy - ion program promise to produce hot nuclear matter in the laboratory . calculating the properties of high density nuclear matter could predict if and where strange matter could be produced . any method which can be used to determine the properties of nuclear matter could be adapted to nuclear physics calculations . finite quark - number density is best achieved by introducing a chemical potential @xmath0 for quark - number , and using the grand - canonical partition function . unfortunately , this renders the euclidean - time fermion determinant complex , with a real part which can change sign . standard lattice simulations , which rely on importance sampling , fail in this case . attempting to circumvent these problems by using canonical ( fixed quark number ) ensembles fail except at high temperatures @xcite because of sign problems . until a simulation method is found which avoids these difficulties , it is useful to study models which exhibit _ some _ of the properties of qcd at high @xmath0 . now it is expected that , at zero temperature , nuclear matter undergoes a phase transition at @xmath0 of order one third the mass of the nucleon . it has been proposed that at still higher @xmath0 the ground state is characterised by a diquark condensate @xcite . such a condensate would not only cause spontaneous breaking of baryon number , but would also spontaneously break colour . since colour is a gauge symmetry , such breaking is realized in the higgs mode . thus nuclear matter would become a colour superconductor at high @xmath0 . for this reason we have simulated 2-colour qcd , i.e. su(2 ) yang - mills theory with fermion matter fields ( ` quarks ' ) in the fundamental representation of @xmath4 , and finite @xmath0 . as well as having colour confinement this theory does exhibit diquark condensation as we shall demonstrate in this paper , but for @xmath5 , since the diquark ` baryons ' in the same multiplet as the pions , also have mass @xmath6 . for @xmath7 the phenomenon is describable as a rotation of the condensate from the chiral to the diquark direction as predicted by effective lagrangian analyses @xcite . unlike in true ( 3-colour ) qcd , the diquark condensates are colourless , and the broken symmetry is realized in the goldstone mode , and there is no colour superconductivity , but rather superfluidity , as in liquid @xmath8he . despite this , we shall later argue that this theory is more similar to 2-flavour qcd than one might think ( see section 4 ) . since 2-colour qcd has a non - negative determinant and pfaffian , even at non - zero @xmath0 , standard simulation methods can be used . we use the hybrid molelcular - dynamics method and simulate the theory with 4 flavours of staggered quarks @xcite . pfaffian simulations of a 4-fermion model including a diquark source term have been reported in @xcite . we have run simulations at a moderately large quark mass and an intermediate gauge coupling on @xmath1 and @xmath9 lattices , i.e. at zero temperature . we measured order parameters including the chiral and diquark condensates , the quark - number and energy densities , and the wilson line ( polyakov loop ) . the larger lattice allowed us to observe finite size effects and , more importantly to measure the scalar and pseudoscalar meson and diquark masses , which include all the potential goldstone bosons in the theory . preliminary results from these simulations were reported at lattice2000 , bangalore @xcite . the extension of these calculations to finite temperature was reported in a recent letter @xcite . this work builds on early work with 8 quark flavours which presented far less conclusive results @xcite . previous studies of diquark condensation in this model with various numbers of flavours have either used the approximation where @xmath10 in the updating algorithm @xcite ( as does @xcite ) , or been in the strong gauge - coupling regime @xcite . section 2 introduces the staggered - fermion lattice port of 2-colour qcd . the results of our simulation are presented in section 3 . section 4 gives our conclusions and indicates future avenues of research . because in 2-colour qcd fundamental quarks and antiquarks lie in the same representation of @xmath4 the flavour symmetry group for @xmath11 flavours is enlarged from @xmath12 to @xmath13 . the pattern of chiral symmetry breaking is @xmath14 rather than the usual @xmath15 @xcite . 3-colour qcd with 1 staggered quark ( 4 continuum flavours ) has a @xmath16 flavour symmetry . for 2 colours this is enhanced to @xmath17 @xcite . chiral or quark - number symmetry breaking ( the chiral and diquark condensates lie in the same u(2 ) multiplet ) occurs according to the pattern @xmath18 . the quark action for 2-colour qcd with one staggered quark is @xmath19\chi + \frac{1}{2}\lambda[\chi^t\tau_2\chi + \bar{\chi}\tau_2\bar{\chi}^t]\right\ } \label{eqn : lagrangian}\ ] ] where @xmath20 is the normal staggered covariant finite difference operator with @xmath0 introduced by multiplying the links in the @xmath21 direction by @xmath22 and those in the @xmath23 direction by @xmath24 . the superscript @xmath25 stands for transposition . note that we have introduced a gauge - invariant majorana mass @xmath26 which explicitly breaks quark - number symmetry . such an explicit symmetry breaking term is needed to observe spontaneous symmetry breaking on a finite lattice . we shall be interested in the limit @xmath27 . integrating out these fermion fields yields @xmath28 = \sqrt{{\rm det}({\cal a}^\dagger { \cal a } + \lambda^2 ) } \label{eqn : pfaffian}\ ] ] where @xmath29 we note that @xmath30 is positive definite for finite @xmath26 . hence the pfaffian never vanishes and thus , by continuity arguments never changes sign and can be chosen to be positive . note that @xmath31 has been shown to be positive in @xcite . denoting the @xmath32 matrix in equation [ eqn : pfaffian ] by @xmath33 we have seen that its determinant is the determinant of a positive definite matrix and thus can be used directly in our simulations . to do this we define @xmath34 by @xmath35 { \cal m } \left[\begin{array}{cc } \tau_2 & 0 \\ 0 & 1 \end{array}\right]\ ] ] so that @xmath36\ ] ] and @xmath37.\ ] ] we note that @xmath38 = \det[{\cal a}^\dagger { \cal a } + \lambda^2]$ ] . because we are now dealing with the matrix @xmath39 we can use the hybrid molecular dynamics method with ` noisy ' fermions @xcite to simulate this theory . here , although we generate gaussian noise with both upper and lower components , we keep only the upper components of the pseudo - fermion field to calculate @xmath40 $ ] , which means that we only need to invert @xmath30 at each update . keeping only half the components of the pseudo - fermion field is entirely analogous to keeping only the fermion fields on even sites in normal qcd simulations . the square root of equation [ eqn : pfaffian ] is obtained by inserting a factor of @xmath41 in front of the fermion term in the stochastic action in the standard manner . we now give a brief discussion of symmetry breaking in this model . this is covered in more detail in @xcite . at @xmath42 , the @xmath17 symmetry will break spontaneously . two directions in which it will choose to break are of particular interest . the first is where it breaks to give a non - zero chiral condensate @xmath43 . there will be 3 goldstone bosons corresponding to the 3 broken generators of @xmath17 . these states and their corresponding @xmath17 generators are @xmath44 @xmath45 remains unbroken . the second is where @xmath17 breaks to give a non - zero diquark condensate @xmath46 . this time the 3 goldstone bosons and corresponding generators are @xmath47 @xmath48 remains unbroken . when @xmath49 only 2 goldstone bosons remain , @xmath50 and @xmath51 . when in addition @xmath52 , only the latter state remains a goldstone boson . a more detailed study of the patterns of symmetry breaking can be performed in terms of an effective lagrangian for the goldstone modes as in @xcite . the only difference is that the effective field , denoted @xmath53 in that work , here belongs to a symmetric @xmath32 tensor representation of @xmath17 rather than to the antisymmetric @xmath54 representation of @xmath13 of the continuum case . one can see the remnant @xmath55 symmetry when @xmath27 by allowing @xmath26 to become complex . the majorana mass term in equation [ eqn : lagrangian ] then becomes @xmath56 $ ] . @xmath57 is replaced by @xmath58 in the pfaffian . although the 2-flavour theory would be of more interest in the continuum , we have chosen to simulate the 4-flavour theory because this represents a single staggered quark species and thus has well defined symmetries and a well defined spectrum at all lattice spacings . unlike the 8-flavour case simulated in @xcite it probably does have a sensible continuum limit . we have simulated 2-colour qcd with 1 staggered quark species ( 4 continuum flavours ) on @xmath1 and @xmath9 lattices . the simulations reported here are all at @xmath59 which is roughly the @xmath60 for the finite temperature transition on an @xmath61 lattice @xcite . this first set of simulations has been performed with quark mass @xmath62 in lattice units . these simulations are currently being repeated at @xmath63 , where the smaller pion mass will give a richer spectrum of goldstone and pseudo - goldstone bosons and where a larger portion of the relevant phase diagram should be described by effective lagrangians . ( we have also performed some zero temperature simulations at @xmath64 and @xmath65 . this has been reported in our finite temperature / finite @xmath0 letter @xcite . ) since we wished to take the limit @xmath27 , we needed @xmath66 . the values we chose were @xmath67 and @xmath68 for @xmath62 . ( at low @xmath0 s we also ran at @xmath10 . ) the smaller lattice was used to map out the interesting range of @xmath0 values , measuring order parameters including the diquark condensate @xmath69 , the chiral condensate @xmath70 , and the number density @xmath71 . in addition to measuring these quantities on the larger lattice , we also calculated the spectrum of potential goldstone bosons . the length of each ` run ' was 2000 molecular dynamics time units . @xmath72 had to be chosen as low as @xmath73 for @xmath67 and @xmath74 . in figure [ fig : pt2p ] we have plotted the diquark condensate as a function of @xmath0 at each @xmath26 for both lattice sizes . since we are interested in the limit where the symmetry breaking parameter @xmath27 , we have performed a linear extrapolation of the diquark condensate to @xmath10 . note that the effective lagrangian calculations @xcite suggest that linear extrapolations are the correct approach for @xmath26 sufficiently small , except at @xmath75 . the results of these extrapolations are plotted in figure [ fig : pt2p_0 ] . what we first notice is that for @xmath76 , the extrapolated diquark condensate is small enough that we can believe that it should be zero . for @xmath77 it is clearly non - zero . the points at @xmath78 would appear to show finite size rounding were it not for the fact that the @xmath1 and @xmath9 points are so close together . we think it more likely that @xmath78 is so close to the transition that the linear extrapolation has broken down . we therfore conclude that the system undergoes a phase transition at @xmath79 . if this holds true , the fact that @xmath75 is less than @xmath80 would indicate that the diquark ` baryons ' do not exist as free particles but bind into ` nuclear ' matter . over the range @xmath81 , the condensate increases with a curvature consistent with a critical index @xmath82 ( the tree level effective lagrangian analysis predicts the mean field result @xmath83 ) . since the condensate starts to decrease soon after @xmath84 , the scaling region is narrow and it would require more points to even try to extract this critical index . for @xmath85 , the condensate starts to decrease , approaching zero for large @xmath0 , which would appear to be a saturation effect . in fact figure [ fig : pt2p_0 ] suggests that the condensate vanishes for @xmath86 , indicating a saturation phase transition . we shall have more to say about this later . note that this decrease in the condensate with @xmath0 is not predicted by the effective lagrangian analysis , which is only expected to be valid for small @xmath0 and @xmath6 . this is not surprising if it is indeed a saturation effect . saturation is a result of the fermi statistics of the quarks , and should not be seen in a model which only considers the system s bosonic excitations . we now turn to a consideration of the chiral condensate , @xmath70 . this is plotted in figure [ fig : pbp ] for our 2 different lattice sizes . in the @xmath27 limit , this is expected to be constant at its @xmath87 value for @xmath88 . these plots are consistent with this expectation . above @xmath75 , effective lagrangian studies predict that the condensate merely rotates from the chiral direction to the diquark direction , so that the magnitude of the condensate , i.e. @xmath89 , should remain constant and independent of @xmath26 . since the diquark condensate increases up to @xmath90 , this means that the chiral condensate should fall , as it does . it , however , continues to fall past this point , because of saturation effects , appearing to vanish for @xmath91 . to test the prediction that the principal effect for @xmath92 is merely a rotation , we have tabulated @xmath89 in table [ tab : condensate ] . .magnitude of the condensate @xmath89 as functions of @xmath0 and @xmath26 on a @xmath9 lattice . errors are not quoted but they are in the next or a subsequent digit after the least significant quoted digit . [ cols="^,^,^ " , ] we see that , for @xmath93 , the magnitude of the condensate is approximately constant and independent of @xmath26 , so that the main effect is a rotation of the condensate from the direction of chiral symmetry breaking to that of quark - number breaking . for @xmath94 , it decreases with increasing @xmath0 approaching zero for large @xmath0 . in figure [ fig : j0 ] we plot the quark - number density @xmath71 as a function of @xmath0 for our 2 lattices . @xmath95 is consistent with zero as @xmath27 , for @xmath88 . ( note effective lagrangians predict that it vanishes quadratically with @xmath26 in this region . ) above @xmath75 it increases with increasing @xmath0 approaching the saturation value of 2 ( 1 staggered quark field of each colour / site , the maximum value allowed by fermi statistics ) for large @xmath0 . note that figure [ fig : j0 ] suggests that @xmath96 for @xmath91 with @xmath97 consistent with that predicted from the condensates . this indicates that it is this saturation which causes the condensates to vanish for @xmath91 . it also tells us that this transition is an artifact of the finite lattice spacing and would recede to infinite @xmath0 in the continuum limit . on the @xmath9 lattice we have measured the propagators for all the potential goldstone bosons , both scalar and pseudoscalar using a single noisy point source for the connected propagators and multiple ( 5 ) noisy point sources for the disconnected propagators . we have measured both diagonal and off - diagonal zero momentum propagators . in figure [ fig : goldstone ] we show the masses from fitting the propagator for the diquark state produced by applying the operator @xmath51 to the vacuum , to the form @xmath98 + \exp[-m_g(n_t - t ) ] \right\},\ ] ] valid for large temporal separations @xmath25 . as argued in section 2 , this is the expected goldstone boson for @xmath99 and @xmath10 . the effective lagrangian approach indicates that , in the low @xmath0 phase , this mass should be quadratic in @xmath26 , while in the high @xmath0 phase , it should vanish as @xmath100 . we have performed extrapolations based on this and plotted them in the figure . for the 3 points closest to the transition @xmath101 , we have performed both extrapolations . for @xmath102 and @xmath10 , we expect @xmath103 with @xmath104 . we see that for @xmath105 , the points obtained from quadratic extrapolation lie on this straight line , the point at @xmath106 is close to the line and that for @xmath107 lies above this line . all points for @xmath108 obtained by square root extrapolation are negative . the points at @xmath109 show the most significant negative values ( although both are greater than @xmath110 ) , and should be considered as transitional . the other points are so close to zero that one can easily attribute the difference as being due to a combination of the systematic errors in extracting masses from point source propagators and higher order terms in the extrapolation . thus our results are consistent with a transition to a phase with a massless ( goldstone ) scalar diquark at @xmath111 , as expected . finally the large value of this diquark mass at @xmath112 is further indication that the system has passed through the saturation phase transition . we now turn to consideration of the other potential goldstone bosons of the theory . since at this quark mass , @xmath113 is relatively large , we concentrate on those states which are expected to have masses of order @xmath6 or less over the range of interest . for this reason , we consider the pion itself . for @xmath88 , its mass should remain constant at @xmath6 , and it is created by the operator @xmath114 . for @xmath99 , it is expected to mix with the pseudoscalar diquark state created from the vacuum by the operator @xmath50 . rather than trying to diagonalize the propagator over these 2 states , we have instead calculated the diagonal propagators for each of these states separately . these we fit to the form @xmath115 + \exp[-m_\pi(n_t - t ) ] \right\ } + b ( -1)^t \left\ { \exp[-m_{b1 } t ] + \exp[-m_{b1}(n_t - t ) ] \right\}\ ] ] or the form with @xmath116 , and a similar form for the diquark state . these masses are plotted in figure [ fig : pseudo ] . note that these 2 graphs are almost identical . for @xmath99 , this is expected , since the 2 states mix . for @xmath88 this is not , a priori , expected since the diquark state should exhibit a linear decrease with @xmath0 for @xmath10 . however , since @xmath117 this gives a small mixing with the pion state , which is then the lowest mass particle contributing to this pseudoscalar diquark propagator in this region . it is precisely because this mixing is so small that the errors are so large . the final indicator that this is the correct interpretation was that the @xmath87 , @xmath10 propagator yielded no sensible mass fit , a sure indicator that the mass was large where there can be no mixing . the pion mass fits in this low @xmath0 domain are consistent with the expectation that the @xmath10 pion mass is independent of @xmath0 in this region . for @xmath99 these masses fall faster than the expected @xmath118 . at least part of the reason for this more rapid falloff is the saturation effect . note that the reason that this mass tends to zero at large @xmath0 ( before the saturation transition ) is because the pseudoscalar diquark would be a goldstone boson if @xmath119 , and as @xmath0 increases the relative importance of @xmath120 diminishes . the fact that the @xmath121 mass becomes more poorly determined for large @xmath0 is because here , the lowest mass state in this channel is predominantly the pseudoscalar diquark . it is interesting to contrast our findings with those of a study of adjoint quarks in 2-colour qcd @xcite with @xmath26 set to zero , implying strictly no mixing ; in this case @xmath6 was found to rise as @xmath122 for @xmath123 , with the signal becoming appreciably noisier in the high density phase . both behaviours are in accord with the predictions of chiral perturbation theory for a meson formed from quarks with a symmetric combination of quantum numbers under the residual global symmetry , the difference arising due to the distinct dyson indices of each model @xcite . two - colour lattice qcd with one staggered quark species ( 4 continuum flavours ) has been studied at finite chemical potential @xmath0 for quark number . we have shown conclusive evidence that this theory undergoes a phase transition to a phase characterized by a diquark condensate which spontaneously breaks quark - number , at @xmath124 . this transition appears to be second order . the simulations were performed at an intermediate value of the coupling ( close to @xmath60 for the finite temperature transition at @xmath87 on a lattice with @xmath61 ) . because of this , the relevant symmetry was the lattice flavour symmetry @xmath17 rather than the @xmath125 of the continuum 4-flavour theory . we have presented convincing evidence that the scalar diquark is the goldstone boson associated with the spontaneous breaking of quark number for @xmath99 . in addition we have measured the lightest mass in the pion channel as a function of @xmath0 . for @xmath7 the chiral condensate and diquark condensate are well described as a single condensate of constant magnitude which rotates from the chiral direction for @xmath88 towards the diquark direction as @xmath0 is increased above @xmath75 . despite the fact that the quark mass @xmath62 was large enough that @xmath6 was not small relative to the 2-colour qcd scale , we saw good qualitative agreement with previous calculations in terms of effective lagrangians ( of the chiral perturbation theory form ) for @xmath7 . this includes the fact that the quark number density increases from zero at @xmath126 . as @xmath0 becomes large , this relationship with effective lagrangians is no longer valid . both chiral and diquark condensates decrease towards zero as @xmath0 becomes large . however , because at least part of this is due to the fact that @xmath95 saturates at 2 fermions / site , a finite lattice spacing artifact , and because we see large finite size effects in the condensates for these @xmath0 values , studies at smaller lattice spacings as well as on larger lattices would be needed to determine how much of this observed high @xmath0 behaviour is real . we are currently extending these calculations to lower quark mass ( @xmath63 ) where we should be able to measure the complete spectrum of goldstone and pseudo - goldstone bosons . for this @xmath120 , the pion mass should be half that at @xmath62 and the assumptions of the effective lagrangian approach should have more validity , allowing a more quantitative analysis . in addition , there is a larger range of @xmath127 between @xmath75 and the turnover point . this means we can hope to measure the critical index @xmath128 for this transition . ( preliminary attempts to extract this index from short runs at relatively strong coupling were reported in our letter on finite @xmath25 and @xmath0 . ) let us now compare 2-colour qcd with 3-colour qcd , at finite @xmath0 . most of this discussion is condensed from the published literature @xcite . since for 2-colour qcd , the diquark condensate is a colour singlet , the spontaneous breaking of quark number is realized in the goldstone mode . this contrasts with true ( 3-colour ) qcd where the condensate is , of necessity , coloured and the symmetry breaking is realized in the higgs mode . to see similarities , we consider the mode of symmetry - breaking for normal qcd with 2 light quark flavours . here the expected condensate is a flavour singlet and a colour anti - triplet , i.e. antisymmetric in both flavour and colour . the pattern of colour breaking is @xmath129 where @xmath130 and @xmath131 refer to quark number before and after the breaking . the 5 gluons corresponding to symmetries broken by the condensate , gain masses via the higgs mechanism by combining with the 5 would - be goldstone bosons associated with colour / quark - number breaking . with respect to the remnant @xmath132 colour symmetry , the condensate is a flavour _ and _ colour singlet . this is precisely the condensate that would be formed from the 2 quarks which are in a colour doublet with respect to this unbroken @xmath132 ( the third quark is a singlet with respect to this group ) if we ignored the interactions of the gluons which gain masses due to the higgs mechanism . since the gluon masses produced from the goldstone bosons produced in this manner are of order @xmath133 , ignoring such light particle interactions is presumably a rather drastic approximation . however , one might hope that it has at least qualitative validity . ( note that @xmath134 is of the order of @xmath135 mev , @xmath136 , giving gluon masses of the same order of magnitude as previous estimates . ) since this remnant @xmath132 theory is also at finite @xmath0 this condensate spontaneously breaks only 1 symmetry , quark number . as seen above , the goldstone boson associated with this breaking gives mass to one of the gluons via the higgs mechanism . finally , we note that with an appropriate reinterpretation of the fields , 2-colour qcd with a finite chemical potential for quark number can be reinterpreted as 2-colour qcd with a finite chemical potential for isospin . it is clear that one can simulate true 3-colour qcd for 2 flavours with a finite chemical potential for isospin . such a program is underway . the 2-colour theory can be used as a guide to the pattern of symmetry breaking and what to expect . this work was partially supported by the nsf under grant nsf - phy96 - 05199 and by the u. s. department of energy under contract w-31 - 109-eng-38 . sjh and sem were supported by eu - tmr contract no . erbfmrx - ct97 - 0122 . these simulations were performed on the ibm sp and cray sv1 s at nersc and on the ibm sp and cray t90 at npaci . dks would line to thank c. k. zachos for useful discussions . 9999 j. engels , o. kaczmarek , f. karsch and e. laermann , nucl . suppl.)83 369 ( 2000 ) . b. c. barrois , nucl . b129 , 390 ( 1977 ) d. bailin and a. love , phys . 107 , 325 ( 1984 ) . m. alford , k. rajagopal and f. wilczek , phys . b222 , 247 ( 1998 ) ; m. alford , k. rajagopal and f. wilczek , nucl . b537 , 443 ( 1999 ) ; t. schfer and f. wilczek , phys . d60 , 074014 ( 1999 ) ; t. schfer and f. wilczek , phys . rev . d60 , 114033 ( 1999 ) . r. rapp , t. schafer , e. v. shuryak and m. velkovsky , phys . 81 , 53 ( 1998 ) good recent reviews include : m. alford , nucl . b(proc . suppl . ) 73 , 161 ( 1999 ) ; e. shuryak , nucl . b(proc . suppl . ) 83 - 84 , 103 ( 2000 ) ; k. rajagopal and f. wilczek , e - print hep - ph/0011333 ( 2000 ) . j. b. kogut , m. a. stephanov , d. toublan , j. j. m. verbaschot and a. zhitnitsky , nucl . b 582 , 477 ( 2000 ) ; j. b. kogut , m. a. stephanov and d. toublan , phys . 464 , 183 ( 1999 ) . s. duane and j. b. kogut , phys . 55 , 2774 ( 1985 ) ; s. gottlieb , w. liu , d. toussaint , r. l. renken and r. l. sugar , phys . d35 , 2531 ( 1987 ) . s. j. hands , b. lucini and s .e . morrison , phys . lett 86 , 753 ( 2001 ) . s. j. hands , j. b. kogut , s. e. morrison and d. k. sinclair , nucl . b(proc . suppl . ) 94 , 457 ( 2001 ) . j. b. kogut , d. toublan and d. k. sinclair , e - print hep - lat/0104010 ( 2001 ) . s. hands , j. b. kogut , m .- lombardo and s. e. morrison , nucl . b 558 , 327 ( 1999 ) . s. e. morrison and s. j. hands , in ` strong and electroweak matter ' 98 ( eds . j. ambjrn et al ) p. 364 hep - lat/9902012 ( 1999 ) ; e. bittner , m .- lombardo , h. markum and r. pullirsch , nucl . proc . suppl . 94 , 445 ( 2001 ) . r. aloisio , v . azcoiti , g. di carlo , a. galante and a. f. grillo , phys . b493 , 189 ( 2000 ) . w. pauli , nuovo cimento 6 , 205 ( 1957 ) ; f. grsey , nuovo cimento 7 , 411 ( 1958 ) ; m. e. peskin , nucl . b175 , 197 ( 1980 ) . s. j. hands , i. montvay , s. e. morrison , m. oevers , l. scorzato and j. skullerud , eur . j. c17 , 285 ( 2000 ) . j. b. kogut , nucl . b290 , 1 ( 1987 ) . | we have simulated two - colour four - flavour qcd at non - zero chemical potential @xmath0 for quark number . simulations were performed on @xmath1 and @xmath2 lattices . clear evidence was seen for the formation of a colourless diquark condensate which breaks quark number spontaneously , for @xmath3 . the transition appears to be second order . we have measured the spectrum of scalar and pseudoscalar bosons which shows clear evidence for the expected goldstone boson . our results are in qualitative agreement with those from effective lagrangians for the potential goldstone excitations of this theory . |
0809.0691 | "a cluster category is a certain 2-calabi - yau orbit category of the derived category of a heredita(...TRUNCATED) | "we define mutation on coloured quivers associated to tilting objects in higher cluster categories .(...TRUNCATED) |
hep-ph9602267 | "this paper explores the phenomenology of the standard model s minimal supersymmetric @xcite extensi(...TRUNCATED) | "we compute the one - loop corrections to the @xmath0 vertex in the @xmath1 symmetric minimal supers(...TRUNCATED) |
End of preview. Expand
in Dataset Viewer.
Original data from: https://github.com/armancohan/long-summarization
The first n (with n ~ 3000) rows of the test split of the original dataset were processed and filtered as follows. This resulted in 978 filtered rows.
- In the original dataset, some sentences appear several times in the same article, even if they're only contained once in the original research paper. For this reason, all dataset rows where the same sentence appeared more than once where removed.
- In the original dataset, every sentence is a separate string, and these strings are contained in arrays. Therefore, all these strings were merged in order to create one single string for each article body and one other for each article abstract.
- All line breaks were removed.
- Downloads last month
- 41