Home › CA15 › Palestinian Group Clashes With Swalwell Over His Support for Israel
Palestinian Group Clashes With Swalwell Over His Support for Israel
By Steven Tavares on August 16, 2014 • ( 125 )
Constituents show opposition to U.S. support for Israel at a town hall in San Lorenzo Thursday held by Rep. Eric Swalwell. PHOTO/Steven Tavares
CONGRESS | 15th DISTRICT | On July 11, Rep. Eric Swalwell riled Palestinian groups and constituents in the 15th Congressional District with a Facebook posting that expressed sympathy for Israel in its ongoing conflict with Palestinians in Gaza. "Innocent civilians in Israel have been under constant attack from rocket attacks from Hamas-controlled Gaza," Swalwell wrote. "These attacks have recently escalated, with over 500 rockets fired at Israel in just the past month. I stand with Israel as it seeks peace and security in the region."
It didn't help the a photo of the Israeli flag accompanied the post. Hundreds made forceful comments in opposition and the item was shared over 1,300 times. Later that day, Swalwell posted another, but more even-handed response. "As the situation in Middle East escalates I am praying for a shared peace between Israel and Palestinians."
A vast majority of the 90-minute town hall featured over a
dozen comments on Swalwell's support for Israel.
PHOTO/Steven Tavares
Swalwell used the latter opinion often at a town hall Thursday night in San Lorenzo while over a dozen pro-Palestinian speakers dominated the proceedings and criticized him for his support of Israel. Swalwell repeatedly called for peace in the region, but also labeled Hamas a terrorist organization. "I don't have a dog in this fight," he said. "I just want peace in this area."
When some speakers called him out for receiving campaign contributions from pro-Israeli organizations, Swalwell said, "You're right. I have vote for and supported aid to Israel. I have supported aid for the Palestinian people," and he added recently voting to send $47 million in aid to Palestinians. "We must give Palestinians economic opportunity and access to the rest of the world," he said.
But, similar to the controversial online posting, Swalwell maintained Israel has a right to defend itself. "I firmly believe it has a right and that it does so in a targeted way, only going after Hamas. It's unacceptable for any innocent people to die in this conflict. It is also unacceptable to use innocent people in this conflict as shields." Later, he said, separating Hamas from the Palestinian people is essential to solving the conflict. "It's not going to be easy," said Swalwell. A number of speakers expressed skepticism over Swalwell's neutral stance. Whenever someone raised the subject of Palestine, dozens flashed sheets printed with the words, "Congressman Swalwell. End the occupation now."
Saba Maher, a law student from Emeryville, and others, said the $47 million in humanitarian aid was a meager amount in contrast to $3 billion in support the U.S. gives Israel. "I know that may seem like a lot to you, but that translates to band-aids and cupcakes and maybe bricks to rebuild the infrastructure," said Maher. "You continue to say Hamas is a terrorist organization, but congressman, I'm here to tell you, it's Israel's policies and it's the U.S. blanket support for Israel that is creating Hamas aggression against Israel."
While the number of deaths on the Palestinian side greatly outnumbers those in Israel, Swalwell said, "Every rocket that is fired by Hamas is intended to kill innocent Israelis." To date, just three Israelis have perished, while nearly 2,000 Palestinians have died from rockets fired on Gaza. In addition, an estimated 9,000 more Palestinians have been injured. "In the face of these numbers, and in the face of this injustice, how can you continue to send support to Israel?" Maher asked. "How can you sit there and say it's not just body count? They have faces, they have names. They are people."
Another speaker named Layma Ahmadzai began her remarks with "I'm an American. I was born in Fremont," and also criticized Swalwell's Facebook posting for being one-sided and not taking into account the loss of life on the Palestinian side of the border. Swalwell responded, "Body counts is not a measurement for the harm."
Since his election nearly two years ago, Swalwell's public support for Israel has been consistent. Just weeks after winning the election in November 2012, the then-congressman-elect Swalwell made comments regarding Israel similar to rhetoric heard Thursday night. "No nation should face constant attacks on its civilians. I stand with hundreds in Congress who support Israel's security and right to defend itself. I hope we can see long-term peace in the region and immediate calm for those who are living in fear," he said, Nov. 16, 2012.
Swalwell's political campaigns have also benefited from pro-Israeli groups. Since arriving on the political scene in 2012, Swalwell has received over $50,000 in contributions from such lobbying groups. The amount ranks as his fourth largest group of contributors. After one constituent Thursday charged Swalwell with accepting donations from the most powerful Israeli organization in the U.S., the American Israeli Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), he denied ever receiving money from the group. But, the comment is not entirely true. While fundraising records show AIPAC has never directly contributed to Swalwell's campaign, his congressional trip last year to Israel, which he referenced Thursday, was paid for by a group called the American Israeli Education Foundation. This group is an offshoot of AIPAC.
‹ A Summer of Discontent in Oakland
Ro Khanna: 'Chuck Reed is an American Hero' ›
Categories: CA15, campaign finance, congress, Eric Swalwell, Facebook, Gaza, israel, Palestinians, pro-israel, San Lorenzo, townhall
As this article is about the great representative our district NOW has, we return you to regular programming–anti-Semite free!
Thanks for being a great friend to Israel and representing our district well, Congressman Swalwell!
Keep up the good work and forget the anti-Semites in the district, who were permanently marginalized with your election two years ago. They can go cry their terrorist tears for Barbie Lee.
Remember I've said BOTH Israel and Hamas is wrong. They need to go back to the boundaries the United Nations set up. Instead Israel keeps taken more Palestinian land and building settlements that prevent peace from happening. I guess when you are losing an argument you resort to name calling.
We have utterly NO interest in anything that you have to say.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's policy of settlement expansion on land the Palestinians claim for a future state is deemed illegal by the European Union and an "obstacle to peace" by the United States.
The United States urges Israel to reverse its latest plan to seize Palestinian land in the Bethlehem …
UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon was "alarmed" by Israel's plans, his spokesman said.
"The seizure of such a large swathe of land risks paving the way for further settlement activity, which -– as the United Nations has reiterated on many occasions -– is illegal under international law and runs totally counter to the pursuit of a two-state solution," the spokesman said.
"The secretary-general calls on Israel to heed the calls of the international community to refrain from settlement activity and abide by its commitments under international law…"
Egypt — which last week mediated a permanent truce between Israel and the Hamas rulers of the Gaza Strip to end a 50-day war — denounced Israel's move.
"This is not a positive step — it contradicts international law and will have negative consequences on the peace process," a foreign ministry statement in Cairo said.
The foreign ministry did not mention the Gaza truce talks, but insisted that Israel's planned West Bank land grab would be "an obstacle" to a two-state solution between Israel and the Palestinians.
Rights watchdog Amnesty International similarly denounced the Israeli plans, saying that it "appears to be the largest land grab in the occupied Palestinian territories since 1980."
"Israel's strategy of illegally confiscating land for settlements in the West Bank must stop once and for all," said Amnesty's Philip Luther.
The Palestinians have called for diplomatic action against Israel, while Israeli peace campaigners said the land expropriation is the biggest of its kind in three decades.
It's the American taxpayer that's paying for this war through our over generous 3.5 billion gift to the war Machine of Israel. Not only that we are paying for that Iron Dome that Israel hides behind so that it can steal land from the Palestinians and build new settlements. They need to go back to the 1967 borders and sit down and negotiate with Abbas not Hamas for a Palestinian state. I'm tired of our taxpayer money being wasted on Israel who has NO desire to sit down with us and Abbas to negotiate a peace settlement.
We can care less what you have to say 8:54 because you have presented NO facts and are on the wrong side of world opinion. FACTS:
We have utterly NO interest in anything that you have to say. Your FICTION is of no interest to anyone. Go play ball on 880.
I've got Congressman Swalwell. What have you got?
Lots of hate, and anti-Semitic losers!
We can care less what you have to say because you have presented NO facts and are on the wrong side of world opinion. FACTS:
Yeah, ask that question of every other country that is our ally, you blatant anti-Semite. Too bad you don't have such a problem with other countries in Europe, Asia, South America, etc.
Take your vitriol some place else. We don't tolerate that shit in the district or America.
Congressman Swalwell has Eretz Y'srael's back, and we have his–for many, many more years to come.
Swalwell should be trying to bring peace to this area. Both Israel and Hamas doesn't want peace. Israel steals from us,spies on us, and in a manner of speaking spits in our face by refusing to agree to peace negotiations. In return we give them almost four billion a year. With allies like this we don't need enemies.
Each country needs to go back to the United Nation borders that were set up years ago. That means Israel needs to stop building more settlements on Palestinian land and remove the ones that are on Palestinian land. These settlements are what enabled Hamas to come to power. Neither Hamas or Netanyahu want peace. The conservatives in Israel just want to take more land for settlements that they aren't entitled to and Hamas just wants to destroy Israel. Stop the settlements or peace will be impossible.
Israel has one of the biggest groups of lobbyists in Washington D.C. Swalwell is just one of the politicians they have bought.
So odd that the Israeli killers of women and children take no responsibility for world outrage at their occupation, murders and senseless blockade. Unfortunately Swallwell takes money from these people. He will not get my vote or that of many other lifelong Democrats who live in his district because he supports these killers.
September 7, 2014 • 11:09 PM
Yes, we will make our voices heard at the polls. Looking forward not just to November but to future elections with Swallwell as the poster child for the murder of innocents. To bad Swallwell and his supporters equates these atrocities to being an anti Semite.
Too bad Hamas Palestinians believe that murdering Israeli teens, starting another intifada, using their own as human shields, and firing rockets non-stop and indiscriminately into Israel is A.O.K.
Yes, we will make our voices heard at the polls when we overwhelmingly re-elect our great congressman who actually gives a damn about the only democracy in that part of the world and doesn't condone murdering terrorists.
Remember many have said BOTH Israel and Hamas are wrong. They need to go back to the boundaries the United Nations set up. Instead Israel keeps taken more Palestinian land and building settlements that prevent peace from happening.
It's the American taxpayer that's paying for this war through our over generous 3.5 billion gift to the war Machine of Israel. Not only that we are paying for that Iron Dome that Israel hides behind so that it can steal land from the Palestinians and build new settlements. They need to go back to the 1967 borders and sit down and negotiate with Abbas not Hamas for a Palestinian state. I'm tired of our taxpayer money being wasted on Israel who has NO desire to sit down with us and Abbas ( not Hamas) to negotiate a peace settlement.
Anonymous above you posted the same post multiple times now. We definitely have NO interest in what YOU have to say!
The United Nations needs to set a deadline for Israel to end it's occupation of lands captured in the 1967 war and make way for an independent Palestinian state. Israel also needs to stop taking land from the Palestinians through settlements.
Swalwell needs stop listening to one of the most powerful lobby in Washington D.C. and work for peace. He's supposed to represent ALL the people, not just the ones who give him money.
nonymous above you posted the same post multiple times now. We definitely have NO interest in what YOU have to say!
EBCitizen on Twitter
Recent Posts: EAST BAY CITIZEN
Alameda fire chief, out on leave since last spring, is retiring
Covid-19: 'I think we might be through the worst,' says Alameda County health official
Two progressive Black women launch campaigns to unseat Alameda County Sheriff Ahern, DA O'Malley
Appointed San Leandro planning commissioner asked to step down after anti-cop tweets
Reynoso doesn't have Hayward USD to kick around anymore; school board begins search for replacement
Archives Select Month January 2021 (13) December 2020 (33) November 2020 (17) October 2020 (23) September 2020 (18) August 2020 (18) July 2020 (27) June 2020 (26) May 2020 (34) April 2020 (47) March 2020 (41) February 2020 (35) January 2020 (49) December 2019 (33) November 2019 (33) October 2019 (40) September 2019 (28) August 2019 (19) July 2019 (36) June 2019 (38) May 2019 (39) April 2019 (45) March 2019 (37) February 2019 (44) January 2019 (51) December 2018 (39) November 2018 (43) October 2018 (48) September 2018 (33) August 2018 (43) July 2018 (51) June 2018 (62) May 2018 (49) April 2018 (32) March 2018 (38) February 2018 (25) January 2018 (33) December 2017 (31) November 2017 (33) October 2017 (32) September 2017 (34) August 2017 (20) July 2017 (28) June 2017 (42) May 2017 (30) April 2017 (33) March 2017 (29) February 2017 (29) January 2017 (38) December 2016 (16) November 2016 (36) October 2016 (41) September 2016 (34) August 2016 (30) July 2016 (31) June 2016 (41) May 2016 (29) April 2016 (34) March 2016 (30) February 2016 (30) January 2016 (28) December 2015 (25) November 2015 (30) October 2015 (27) September 2015 (37) August 2015 (22) July 2015 (28) June 2015 (23) May 2015 (56) April 2015 (33) March 2015 (36) February 2015 (38) January 2015 (44) December 2014 (22) November 2014 (41) October 2014 (43) September 2014 (31) August 2014 (23) July 2014 (32) June 2014 (42) May 2014 (52) April 2014 (42) March 2014 (43) February 2014 (39) January 2014 (44) December 2013 (33) November 2013 (27) October 2013 (38) September 2013 (33) August 2013 (30) July 2013 (40) June 2013 (49) May 2013 (47) April 2013 (33) March 2013 (49) February 2013 (35) January 2013 (38) December 2012 (28) November 2012 (46) October 2012 (49) September 2012 (38) August 2012 (35) July 2012 (34) June 2012 (41) May 2012 (45) April 2012 (34) March 2012 (32) February 2012 (36) January 2012 (40) December 2011 (29) November 2011 (40) October 2011 (28) September 2011 (41) August 2011 (12) July 2011 (9) June 2011 (45) May 2011 (30) April 2011 (47) March 2011 (30) February 2011 (33) January 2011 (35) December 2010 (37) November 2010 (41) October 2010 (41) September 2010 (43) August 2010 (28) July 2010 (33) June 2010 (37) May 2010 (32) April 2010 (30) March 2010 (31) February 2010 (25) January 2010 (31) December 2009 (28) November 2009 (23) October 2009 (22) September 2009 (27) August 2009 (30) July 2009 (23) June 2009 (27) May 2009 (14)