Liz Jarvis explains why she joined Lib Dems from Labour
By Caron Lindsay | Thu 3rd January 2019 - 4:19 pm
Follow @caronmlindsay
I've been talking to Liz Jarvis, who joined the Lib Dems from Labour in the Summer a bit on Twitter. Remarkably, out of 700,000 people, we found each other to have a brief conversation at the People's Vote march in October. She's written for the Independent Voices website about why she joined us.
She was pretty involved in the Labour Party as a student and voted Labour throughout her adult life. When the Liberal Democrats went into coalition with the Tories, any positive feelings she had towards our party evaporated and she continued to vote Labour. But along came Jeremy Corbyn:
I might have remained "soft" Labour but for the perfect storm of Jeremy Corbyn and Brexit. The latter is quite simply anathema to me, not just because I'm the granddaughter of immigrants, but because I believe so strongly in freedom of movement, and that the evidence backs up the overwhelming truth that we are better off in the EU than we can possibly be out of it.
The Momentum-propelled adulation of Jeremy Corbyn left me cold. I was also increasingly uneasy about the accusations of anti-Semitism in the Labour Party, and for the first time in my voting life I started to feel politically homeless.
Last summer I explained how I was feeling to a friend who had joined the Lib Dems, and he asked me why I was still supporting Labour. After a heated debate, the conclusion was tribalism. I had been clinging on to my political heritage and the promise of what might have been, had Blair not led Britain to war in Iraq, had Corbyn not become leader, had David Miliband stuck around or Ed not eaten that bacon sandwich.
The more I delved into Lib Dem policies, particularly on education, the NHS and crime, the more I realised that this was the party for me. I have always believed passionately in equality and internationalism, and politically, I am home.
Like any relationship it takes work. I was welcomed with open arms into my local party, which has a small but dedicated group of activists, and plunged headfirst into campaigning. Since joining I've canvassed, attended meetings and hustings, placed coloured stickers on a Brexometer (it's really a giant whiteboard, but useful for gauging opinion) and been selected as spokesperson for my local ward.
She's going to be coming to Conference in York in the Spring.
Liz is not alone. During the Christmas holidays, there has been a steady flow of people joining us from Labour, especially when Jeremy Corbyn cosies up further to the Tories on Brexit at a time when almost three quarters of his members want a People's Vote. Corbyn seems more interested in finding a way to deliver Brexit than giving the people of this country the chance to mark the Government's homework. Unless he changes his mind, the flow from Labour to Lib Dems will only intensify.
* Caron Lindsay is Editor of Liberal Democrat Voice and blogs at Caron's Musings
Read more by Caron Lindsay or more about brexit, independent, labour or liz jarvis.
This entry was posted in News.
Why be a Liberal Democrat and an 'Orange Booker'?
Looking beyond Brexit
Joseph Bourke 3rd Jan '19 - 4:58pm
Well written article in the Independent. Attracted a couple of apposite comments as well:
"Sure, the Lib Dems supported austerity. As did, let's not forget, the Labour party at the time (take a bow, Chancellor Alastair Darling). Far from 'enabling' the Tories' cuts, the LibDems moderated them (for proof, compare with the far more savage cuts since the end of the coalition). It's a convenient myth to blame austerity on the Lib Dems, but a myth nonetheless. It would have happened, regardless of which party was in power.
And the NHS reorganisation? Yes, the Lib Dems as the smaller party in the coalition were feeble, made mistakes and allowed themselves to be outsmarted by the Tories. But 'unprincipled' is not a word I use for that. I reserve it for those responsible for crimes against humanity, such as the invasion of Iraq, an illegal war with mass casualties – Labour's war, that the Lib Dems opposed.
In short, the Lib Dems may not be perfect, but they don't need lessons in morality from Labour of all parties.
And right now, which is the only major party principled enough to unequivocally support the people's right to have the final say on the terms of Brexit? I'll give you a hint: it's not Labour. "
"Governments can spend as much as they like. If they spend too much the money becomes worthless. It is easy to say what you would like to spend money on. It is much harder to say which of the things that you would like to spend money on but won't."
jayne Mansfield 3rd Jan '19 - 8:14pm
There are some that cannot get over the fact that David Miliband did not win the Labour leadership. Why would one want David Miliband to stick around if one was so opposed to the Iraq War?
I thought that the photograph of Ed Miliband struggling with a bacon sandwich and the commentary engendered in some sections of the press disgraceful. In my opinion it was a dog whistle and shaming.
Tom Harney 4th Jan '19 - 9:41am
To me the question for the party is whether we are really in a position to integrate new people into the party.
As far as Labour is concerned it is easy to trace the path of the party from Tony Blair's campaign to increase donations from business, to get support from the right wing press to the right wing government he presided over. However we have to balance the many good things his government did against the most probable other possibility that he would never have won in the first place.
expats 4th Jan '19 - 11:32am
Joseph Bourke 3rd Jan '19 – 4:58pm…………… I reserve it for those responsible for crimes against humanity, such as the invasion of Iraq, an illegal war with mass casualties – Labour's war, that the Lib Dems opposed…………..
Hardly Labour's war as far more Labour MPs opposed it than Tory/LibDem combined; it was Tony Blair's war.
You are rather selective in picking your wars. I seem to remember that we, as party, supported both the Libyan conflict (I suppose being in government changes one's perspective) and the two votes on bombing Syria…
BTW If it's 'consistency you are after then it's worth remembering that the current Labour leader voted against all those conflicts.
Lib Dem Voice welcomes comments from everyone but we ask you to be polite, to be on topic and to be who you say you are. You can read our comments policy in full here. Please respect it and all readers of the site.
If you are a member of the party, you can have the Lib Dem Logo appear next to your comments to show this. You must be registered for our forum and can then login on this public site with the same username and password.
To have your photo next to your comment please signup your email address with Gravatar.
Your email is never published. Required fields are marked *
Please complete the name of this site, Liberal Democrat ...?
Andy Hinton 18th Jan - 3:09pm
Seems like a pretty sensible move to me. A contest right now would be obscured by the Labour contest, this way we stand a chance...
Jeff 18th Jan - 3:03pm
Ian 18th Jan '20 - 1:29pm: ...the economic case for austerity is believed by no-one nowadays. The EU believed it and still do. 'Austerity has...
Peter Martin 18th Jan - 3:01pm
@ Joseph Bourke, "Socialism grounded in Marxist theory relies on the Labour theory of value holding that the value of goods or services are solely...