Discover our other sites:
Norske og internasjonale forskningsnyheter
Forskningsnyheter for unge
Science news from Norway in English
Meninger, debatt og blogger skrevet av forskere
Forskning.nos stillingsmarked
You might be looking for...
School and education
Share your science
Learn to write
Oppdag våre andre nettsteder:
Removing a child from his or her home is one of the strongest public interventions in the relationship between parents and children. (Photo: Colourbox)
When the state takes your child
A child custody row between the Norwegian state and an Indian couple living in Norway has caused a big stir. A recently published study reveals when and why social workers split up families.
Isak Ladegaard
tuesday 24. April 2012 - 06:00
Last year, Anurup Bhattacharya and his wife Sagarika, an Indian couple living in Norway, lost custody of their children.
Their row with the Norwegian child welfare services has attracted a great deal of media attention and sparked diplomatic action from both India and Norway.
The two children, aged three years and five months at the time, were put in foster care by the local child welfare service. It said the parents failed to take proper care of them.
Families were helped for three years
In a study published last year, Øivin Christiansen and Norman Andersen at the University of Bergen surveyed and interviewed 87 social workers in the Norwegian child welfare service.
Researcher Øivin Christiansen from the University of Bergen surveyed and interviewed 87 social workers in the Norwegian child welfare service.
The two researchers examined 109 cases in which children were re moved from their parents.
Christiansen says that most of these families were well-known to the child welfare service before the crucial intervention was made, and that the families had received help and guidance for an average of three years.
"The children were taken away due to increasing concerns about their situation at home and because the intervening measures didn't seem to be working well enough," says Christiansen.
Not always against the parents' will
The Norwegian child welfare agency aims to teach parents how to take proper care of their children, while also assessing whether or not intervention is necessary.
Christiansen explains that parents often accept the child service's intervening measures, and that they sometimes willingly give up custody of their children. This applied to about half of the examined cases.
If parents want to keep the custody of their children they can appeal to the local authorities. In some cases where the children's situation is considered unsafe and critical, they are taken away from the home before the trial and kept until the trial is over.
Dirty homes and hungry children
In the interviews, social workers described homes in which parents failed to provide basic, practical care for their children.
Sometimes during their home visits they found that the children were hungry, had poor hygiene and needed clothes and appropriate food.
Some homes were deemed unfit for children as they were untidy and filled with cigarette smoke and bad smell. These houses were described as "chaotic in every sense of the word," as one social worker put it.
Social workers in the studied cases reported that the children's behaviour was sometimes different from what was expected for their age – they might be overly introverted or nearly apathetic, showing little curiosity and signs of happiness, and did a poor job with their homework.
In other cases children could act externalised; their disruptive, aggressive, boundless and sometimes scary behaviour caused problems at home and/or in school.
These behaviours were sometimes seen as a consequence of how parents failed to create a predictable framework around their children, and how they struggled to control interactions within the family.
Social workers often described parents' shortcomings in terms of cooperation, attention, monitoring, control, predictability, and contact.
"The nightmare in Norway"
Earlier this year, the Indian couple fighting the child welfare service were interviewed by India's largest English language TV station, New Delhi Television. The sequence was dubbed "The Nightmare in Norway."
The parents denied any wrongdoing and said the child services' misinterpretation of cultural differences led to the situation, including sleeping in the same bed as the children and feeding them by hand.
The child welfare agency denied this, but has not given an official explanation for their intervention as they are bound through confidentiality outside the courtroom.
Christiansen says that working with immigrant families can be a challenge.
"It's about what to accept, and what not to accept. What's culture, what isn't?"
He adds that there are often language problems, and some families have difficulties understanding how public agencies such as the child welfare service can intervene in people's lives in Norway.
Criticism of the child welfare service
The child welfare services have been criticised for how their social workers sometimes deal with families from foreign cultures. But the criticism is twofold.
"On the one hand the criticism is about how they don't consider cultural differences and are ignorant about other cultures," Christiansen says.
"But on the other hand they're also criticised for not noticing problems that children experience and for not realising how cultural differences can be used as an excuse."
Most of the employees at the child welfare service are educated social workers or child welfare pedagogues, and some have a background in psychology or general pedagogy.
Christiansen explains that the Norwegian child welfare agency differs from similar institutions in the US and the UK in that the Norwegian threshold for a family to receive help is significantly lower.
He adds that this, however, has not led to a greater number of intervening measures in Norway.
Back to India?
The Indian government told Norway that it's important that the children are allowed to return to India as soon as possible. But last month they put diplomatic efforts on hold as the family situation has become a "personal matter between husband and wife," as junior foreign minister Preneet Kaur told the BBC.
Also last month, the husband was quoted in the newspaper The Hindu as saying "My wife has a serious psychological problem," adding that he has "concealed the seriousness" within his family.
The child welfare service agency in Norway, meanwhile, was willing to hand over the children to their uncle, who lives in India.
And this week the two children returned to India, after a Norwegian court ruled that their custody should be handed over to their uncle.
Øyvin Christiansen's profile at Uni Research
No longer a private matter to slap your child
How much should Government intervene in domestic matters? In Norway they go all the way when it comes to domestic violence.
Little known about domestic violence against immigrant children
Child welfare authorities lack knowledge on domestic violence against children in immigrant families and this makes them slower to react.
society and culture social relations norway forskning.no culture children welfare state society & culture
New study on the difficulties facing children of diplomats:"The hardest thing about being a diplomat's kid was, without comparison, returning home"
What old graffiti can tell us about medieval people
Calves not allowed to stay with their mother are more stressed and grow less well
From the Nobel Peace Prize to the front lines: Ethiopia's Abiy Ahmed named worst head of state in the world
Hunting moorings in the dark
University of South-Eastern Norway
We become less polite when we are shopping
BI Norwegian Business School
How artificial is artificial intelligence, really?
Many veterinarians struggle with suicidal thoughts
NTNU Norwegian University of Science and Technology
Hunting for dead stars
New study on Long Covid: Brain fog, poor memory and shortness of breath one year after infection
Vaccinated people seldom end up in intensive care due to Covid
Maternal behaviour may transmit mental health problems to children
Tinnitus affects women more severely than men
A bone and a stick inscribed with Norse runic text found in Oslo
First patient injected with Norwegian T-cell vaccine against Covid
Most read 2021: the AstraZeneca Covid vaccine, celiac disease and alpha wolves
What's happening with Russia's climate policy?
Our lung capacity has gotten a lot better
Patients who lost their sense of smell after Covid-19 are queuing up for help
Deadly heat and extreme rainfall: This is what the world will be like if the temperature rises by 3 degrees, according to researchers
He knows where the voices in your head are from — and maybe he can stop them
About Sciencenorway.no
Sciencenorway.no brings you science news from Norway.
This is the English version of forskning.no, Norway's independent, online newspaper on science.
ScienceNorway.no follows the Norwegian Editor's Code and the Code of Ethics of the Norwegian Press.
Editor-in-chief: Nina Kristiansen
+47 414 55 513 / [email protected]
Assistant editor: Ida Irene Bergstrøm
Ads and market: Preben Forberg
Address: Sandakerveien 24 C / D3, Oslo, Norway
/Sciencenorway.no
@Sciencenorwayno
/forskning.no
Owners of Sciencenorway.no and forskning.no
Akvaplan-niva
Department of Mental Health Research and Development, Division of Mental Health and Addiction | Vestre Viken Health Trust
Directorate for Higher Education and Skills
FHF – Norwegian Seafood Research Fund
Geological Survey of Norway
Inland Norway University of Applied Sciences
Innlandet Hospital trust
Institute for Rural and Regional Research
Institute for Social Research
Institute of Marine Research (IMR)
Kristiania University College
KS Research and development
Molde University College
NIKU - Norwegian Institute for Cultural Heritage Research
NILU – Norwegian Institute for Air Research
NLA University College
NOKUT Norwegian Agency for Quality Assurance in Education
Nord University
Nordland Research Institute
Norwegian Biodiversity Information Centre (NBIC)
Norwegian Cancer Society
Norwegian Centre for E-health Research
Norwegian Centre for Organic Agriculture
Norwegian Centre for Violence and Traumatic Stress Studies (NKVTS)
Norwegian Computing Center
Norwegian Defence Research Establishment (FFI)
Norwegian Institute for Water Research (NIVA)
Norwegian Institute of International Affairs (NUPI)
Norwegian National Advisory Unit on Ageing and Health
Norwegian National Advisory Unit on Women's Health
Norwegian National Association for Public Health
Norwegian Polar Institute
Norwegian School of Sports Sciences
Norwegian Space Agency
NSD - Norwegian centre for research data
Oral Health Centres of Expertise
R&D management, Norwegian Public Roads Administration
Regional Center for Child and Adolescent Mental Health, Eastern and Southern Norway (RBUP)
Telemark Research Institute (TRI)
The Centre for Advanced Study (CAS)
The Fafo Institute for Labour and Social Research
The Fram Centre
The Narvik War and Peace Centre
The Norwegian Center for Child Behavioral Development (NUBU)
The Norwegian Center for Holocaust and Minority Studies
The Norwegian Geotechnical Institute
The Norwegian Meteorological Institute
The Norwegian National Research Ethics Committees
The Norwegian Scientific Committee for Food and Environment
The Norwegian Water Resources and Energy Directorate
The Regional Research Funds in Norway
The University Centre in Svalbard
UiT The Arctic University of Norway
University College of Norwegian Correctional Service
University of Agder
University of Stavanger
VID Specialized University
Volda University College
Western Norway Research Institute
Western Norway University of Applied Sciences (HVL)
Østfold University College