San Francisco: "Warren Buffett discusses 'disaster' contributing to Bay Area exodus in CNBC interview"
Mr. Buffett, through his insurance companies, guarantees a few of the country's municipal bonds. Muni holders are often in conflict with public employee unions and/or public employee pension overseers, especially in the event of a municipal bankruptcy.
These guarantees usually take the form of credit default swaps.
In addition Berkshire Hathaway carries a small amount of munis as an asset on the consolidated balance sheet.
Warren pays attention to this stuff. His 2008 Letter to Shareholders is a mini-masters course in moral hazard in the muni biz. Some copied out after the jump
And the headline story from the San Francisco Business Times:
Warren Buffett described unfunded public pensions as a "disaster" that companies and individuals must consider when deciding where to expand or move.
While corporate America's traditional, defined-benefit pension plans are no longer the problem they were 10 or 20 years ago, "in the public sector, you know, it's a disaster," Buffett told CNBC this week in discussing Amazon's (NASDAQ: AMZN) decision to ditch New York City for a major expansion.
California's unfunded public pensions are a hot topic, with taxpayers on the hook for making up any shortfalls in employee contributions or investment returns.
"If I were relocating into some state that had a huge unfunded pension plan, I'm walking into liabilities," Buffett said. "'Cause I mean, who knows whether they're gonna get it from the corporate income tax or my employees — you know, with personal income taxes or what. That liability isn't gonna — you can't ship it offshore or anything like that. And those are big numbers, really big numbers.
"The politicians are the ones that really haven't attacked it in a good many states. And when you see what they would have to do, I say to myself, 'Why do I wanna build a plant there that has to sit there for 30 or 40 years?'" he said. "They will come after corporations, they'll come after individuals. They're gonna have to raise a lotta money."...MORE
The class begins on page 13 of the 2008 letter. The following is from page 14:
...The rationale behind very low premium rates for insuring tax-exempts has been that defaults have historically been few. But that record largely reflects the experience of entities that issued uninsured bonds. Insurance of tax-exempt bonds didn't exist before 1971, and even after that most bonds remained uninsured.
A universe of tax-exempts fully covered by insurance would be certain to have a somewhat different loss experience from a group of uninsured, but otherwise similar bonds, the only question being how different.To understand why, let's go back to 1975 when New York City was on the edge of bankruptcy. At the time its bonds – virtually all uninsured – were heavily held by the city's wealthier residents as well as by New York banks and other institutions. These local bondholders deeply desired to solve the city's fiscal problems. So before long, concessions and cooperation from a host of involved constituencies produced a solution. Without one, it was apparent to all that New York's citizens and businesses would have experienced widespread and severe financial losses from their bond holdings.
Now, imagine that all of the city's bonds had instead been insured by Berkshire. Would similar belt-tightening, tax increases, labor concessions, etc. have been forthcoming? Of course not. At a minimum, Berkshire would have been asked to "share" in the required sacrifices. And, considering our deep pockets, the required contribution would most certainly have been substantial.
Local governments are going to face far tougher fiscal problems in the future than they have to date.The pension liabilities I talked about in last year's report will be a huge contributor to these woes. Many cities and states were surely horrified when they inspected the status of their funding at year end 2008.
The gap between assets and a realistic actuarial valuation of present liabilities is simply staggering.When faced with large revenue shortfalls, communities that have all of their bonds insured will be more prone to develop "solutions" less favorable to bondholders than those communities that have uninsured bonds held by local banks and residents. Losses in the tax-exempt arena, when they come, are also likely to be highly correlated among issuers.
If a few communities stiff their creditors and get away with it, the chance that others will follow in their footsteps will grow. What mayor or city council is going to choose pain to local citizens in the form of major tax increases over pain to a far-away bond insurer?
Insuring tax-exempts, therefore, has the look today of a dangerous business – one with similarities, in fact, to the insuring of natural catastrophes. In both cases, a string of loss-free years can be followed by a devastating experience that more than wipes out all earlier profits. We will try, therefore, to proceed carefully in this business, eschewing many classes of bonds that other monolines regularly embrace....MUCH MORE
Considering the apparent acceleration of muni bankruptcies in California, Vallejo in 2008 and then Stockton, Mammoth Lakes and San Bernardino, combined with talk of "strategic bankruptcy" Berkshire saw the problem and acted, fast.
IBD: "After Hours: These 7 Stocks Are Big Movers O...
Workday Beats, Stock up 1% After-Hours (WDAY)
Ahead of Today's Earnings: "How Innovative Is Work...
Rhyme Time at the San Francisco Federal Reserve Ba...
Startups That Want to Run Smart Cities
As Bank of America Drops the Merrill Lynch Name: "...
The Leap Baby Crime Loophole
Capital Markets: "Trump Walks Away from North Kore...
Shipping/LNG: "Novatek Wants Arctic Sea Route Open...
Plans Change for the Salvage of Norway's Sunken Fr...
Shipping: "Electric Container Ships Are Stuck on t...
Elon Musk's Boring Co. Chicago Tunnel Project Is Dead
San Francisco: "Warren Buffett discusses 'disaster...
"Amazon backs out of massive Seattle office tower ...
UPDATED "Sharing economy as an anti-concept"
China's Plan For Global Media Dominance
NY Fed EVP: "Models Only Get You So Far" (now with...
Elon Musk Apologises for Calling Man Who Criticise...
Elaine: What We Need Is Communism That Scales
"First (standalone 144A) terrorism risk cat bond o...
Shipping: China's Iron Ore Inventory Is Getting La...
"16 Tankers Are Stuck With 8.36 Million Barrels Of...
"Top-Rated Chipmaker Xilinx Gets Big Price-Target ...
"The Anticompetitive Effects of Low Interest Rates"
Summon the Demon: How AI Will Go Out Of Control A...
Remember Just Mayo? They Rebranded to Just and Rai...
"How an AI 'Motherbrain' helps venture capitalists...
Pray for FT Alphaville's Bryce Elder
Capital Markets Generally Mournful and Reflective,...
S&P 500 Chartology: Well Here We Are Again
Société Générale's Albert Edwards Is Worried
Guess Who's No Longer In a Drought?
Chartology: Canola Oil
The World's Largest Battery To Power The Permian
Creighton U's Rural Mainstreet Index Falls for Feb...
Shipping: "Container Spot Rates Decline Sharply"
"Norway has full supremacy over Svalbard snow crab...
"Moscow Bans the Barents Observer from Russian Int...
The Hidden History of Holocaust Money
Harvard Is Going Bigger In Tech Than Other Endowments
"How Hitler Nearly Destroyed the Great American No...
"A new paper suggests that Amazon's negative cash ...
"Vexed in Vittel: French Town Becomes a Focal Poin...
"Russian port data show huge increases in Arctic s...
Dreamtime Finance (and the Kelly Criterion)
The Smart, the Stupid, and the Catastrophically Sc...
Electricity: Here Come The Big Batteries
Baltic Battle: Estonia vs Denmark as The Blame Gam...
The panic of 1825, the Sovereign Debt of a Made Up...
How William Crockford Built a Fortune And Nearly D...
When You Really Gotta Build a Train Staion Fast, C...
UPDATED—Inflation, Taxes and Gin, Also Known as Mo...
"Teaching people to trade stocks is like starting ...
How Stupid Are You If You Can't Sell Pot In Califo...
"Mexico introduces all-you-can-drink tequila train...
Free Dan McCrum
"The future has become a financial fetish, sliced ...
Shipping: Maersk Warns 2019 Global Economic Outloo...
Earnings: First Solar Don't Got the Beat (FSLR)
Siberia As Breadbasket For China
"What Trucking & Freight Just Said About the Goods...
"Stuff Elon says, (inevitable) bitcoin edition" (T...
Glencore Plans new Buyback, Says Cobalt Close to a...
The FT's Colby Smith Is Doing Actual Financial Jou...
Finance: "Hedge Funds Hunt for Shipping Debt in Ne...
Shipping: The Baltic and International Maritime Co...
"Once hailed as unhackable, blockchains are now ge...
IRI/Columbia El Niño Forecast
Trucking Freight Futures: Former JP Morgan Markete...
Pope Francis: "Don't Be Afraid of Looking Like 'C...
What Happened To Germany's Military?
Capital Markets: "US-China Trade and Brexit Domina...
"First Solar to Report Q4 Earnings: What's in Stor...
Gold Hits A 10-Month High
Creeped out by Facebook's algorithms? Just wait un...
"AQR Quants Gaze Into Crystal Ball, See 'Soberingl...
"What do Disney, Skype, GlaxoSmithKline and Koch I...
This Is a First: I Have Never Before Seen The Roma...
China: "...Banks open floodgates in January to hel...
Freight Futures For the Trucking Industry
Oh Lord, What's McCrum Done Now?
Emanual Derman Answers Edge.org's Annual Question ...
More Presidential Humor: Reagan in West Berlin
Shipping/Logistics: Softbank Is Reportedly Leading...
ICYMI: "China ride-hailing giant Didi to lay off 1...
Working the Room Presidential humor from Lincoln ...
The Orkney Energy Miracle
British family detained in Syria claim they joined...
Capital Markets: "Dollar Drifts Lower"
"...Russian Hostile Meddling Backfires in Northern...
"Sicily's mafia sprang from the growing global mar...
Oligarchia: "The digital revolution isn't over but...
"How to Leave the Euro"
"The Success of the American Lockpicker,"
Bruno Ganz, star of 'Downfall' and 'Wings of Desir...
TIL: Finding Point Nemo
Meanwhile in Harbin
In the Last Week Pakistani Terrorists Have Killed ...
"The Treasure Behind the Wall: Something in the ne...
Online Advertising: "The Art of Eyeball Harvesting"