Judge plans to dismiss case on wages of immigrant detainees
Gene Johnson, The Associated Press September 24, 2019
In this photo taken Sept. 10, 2019, a guard with the GEO Group sits at a desk in a housing area at the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) detention facility in Tacoma, Wash. during a media tour. On Tuesday, Sept. 24, 2019, U.S. District Judge Robert Bryan notified attorneys for Washington state and the GEO Group -- which operates the detention center -- that he plans to dismiss a case in which Washington state was pursuing a claim that immigration detainees must be paid minimum wage for work they perform in custody. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
SEATTLE — A U.S. judge who previously ruled that Washington state could pursue its claim that immigration detainees must be paid minimum wage for work at a privately run, for-profit immigration jail said Tuesday he intends to reverse himself at the urging of the Trump administration.
U.S. District Judge Robert Bryan issued a proposed order notifying lawyers for the state and for the GEO Group, which operates the large immigration detention centre in Tacoma, that he plans to dismiss the case. He gave them until Oct. 4 to respond.
"Judges don't like to reverse themselves," Bryan wrote. "Sometimes, however, it is necessary — when the law changes or becomes more clear, or when additional facts come to light, or old facts have new impact as the law becomes more clear. So it is here."
Washington Attorney General Bob Ferguson, a Democrat, sued GEO in 2017, saying the company had relied on detainee labour for work that should have earned them the state minimum wage — currently $12 an hour.
The lawsuit sought to force GEO to give up profits it made by underpaying the detainees, and it has been seen as a test of how well Democratic state officials could resist President Donald Trump's immigration agenda.
Bryan had repeatedly refused to dismiss the case. He ruled in December that Washington state could pursue its claim that the GEO Group was required to pay minimum wage, instead of $1 a day, for janitorial, kitchen and other duty done by detainees.
While he said it was too early to determine whether the Minimum Wage Act applied to the detainees, he noted that there was nothing in the law that would exempt civil detainees at a privately run jail from being paid minimum wage.
He reconsidered his analysis after the U.S. Justice Department filed a "statement of interest" in the case last month, calling the lawsuit "an aggressive and legally unjustified effort by the state of Washington to interfere with federal immigration enforcement."
The agency insisted that because Washington does not pay minimum wage for work by its own detainees at state-run facilities, such as the Special Commitment Center for sex offenders on McNeil Island, it discriminated against the U.S. government to require a federal contractor to pay its detainees minimum wage.
In his proposed order Tuesday, Bryan said he especially took note of two rulings, one from the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and one from the U.S. Supreme Court, issued in the spring, after his initial ruling in the GEO case.
The new opinions clarified how the constitutional principle of "intergovernmental immunity" applies, he said: Federal contractors must be treated just as the federal government itself would be treated, and because the state cannot discriminate against the federal government under the Constitution's Supremacy Clause, it cannot discriminate against GEO.
"If the state is permitted to enforce the Minimum Wage Act against GEO, the cost of civil detention under federal law would be higher than the cost of civil detention under the laws of the state of Washington," Bryan wrote. "This the state cannot do."
The attorney general's office did not immediately respond to an email seeking comment.
In a written statement, GEO said it abides by national detention standards set out by the federal government, which govern the Voluntary Work Program used at its immigrant detention centres.
"The wage rates associated with this federally mandated program are stipulated under long-established guidelines set by the United States Congress," the statement said.
GEO's 1,575-bed facility, previously called the Northwest Detention Center, has recently been renamed the Northwest Processing Center as part of a nationwide rebranding of such facilities.
During a news media tour of the detention centre this month, Nathalie Asher, who heads ICE's enforcement and removal operations in the region, said the name change more accurately reflects the facility's mission.
Gene Johnson, The Associated Press