Careers at Tanners
General Private Client
Divorce is Often Bitter, But Maintaining a Sense of Proportion is Crucial
Amidst the emotional and financial destruction that can arise from divorce, keeping a sense of proportion is crucial. The Court of Appeal made that point in lamenting a former couple's expenditure of more than £500,000 in legal costs fighting over an asset worth less than £300,000.
At the start of the couple's 12-year marriage, during which they had two children, they both had highly paid jobs. However, by the time of their separation, their circumstances were greatly reduced and the only asset that was potentially available for division between them was an overseas flat.
The flat was owned by a company, the sole shareholder of which was the husband's mother. However, following a hearing, a judge found that the husband was the flat's beneficial owner. He was ordered to pay the wife £150,000, that sum representing roughly half of the flat's value. After the mother appealed, the judge's orders were upheld.
In upholding the mother's further appeal, the Court noted that the case was yet another sad example of a highly educated former couple engaging in emotionally bruising, destructive and disproportionately expensive litigation in relation to money and the young children of the marriage.
The Court found that the initial trial of the action had been infected by serious procedural irregularities and that the mother had been denied a fair hearing. There was no basis for that part of the judge's order which set aside any transactions that had led to the flat's title being vested in the company and ultimately the mother. She thus continued, via her shares in the company, to be the flat's legal owner.
The Court, however, went on to uphold the judge's conclusion that the flat was and remained in the husband's beneficial ownership. That finding was almost inevitable on the evidence. The lump sum order made against the husband was therefore justified. The Court noted that it was a matter for the husband whether to require his mother to sell the flat in order to raise the necessary funds.
Please fill in the form below and we'll get back to you as soon as possible
We'll only use this information to handle your enquiry and we won't share it with any third parties. For more details see our Privacy Policy.
Tanners Solicitors
Thomas Street
39409 Cirencester
Tanners Diversity Presentation
Copyright © 2018 Tanners Solicitors LLP. All rights reserved.
Tanners Solicitors LLP is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority (462152).