Syria and the Fundamentalist Islamic Uprising - By Robert Turner
Should the United States have prolonged the Syrian civil war by arming the rebels? Based on recent experience, one wonders if deposing ruling monarchies is in the best interest of either the peoples of the Middle East or of the world at large. Consider the following:
The failure of the Carter administration to support its ally Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, the Shah of Iran, led to establishment of the Islamic Republic of Iran, the region's greatest threat. The reward to the United States for its implicit support of the Iranian revolution was an attack on its embassy, the ensuing hostage crisis, throngs in the streets screaming "Death to America," and support of terrorism aimed at the U.S. and its' allies. The result to Israel is likely to be increasingly dire in months and years to come.
The failure of the Obama administration to support U.S. ally Hosni Mubarak, president of Egypt, and a key supporter of the peace with Israel negotiated by Anwar Sadat, led to a near takeover of Egypt by the Muslim Brotherhood, described as a terrorist organization by a number of allies in the region. Only intervention by the military saved Egypt from Islamic totalitarianism.
While hardly virtuous, Muammar Gaddafi, following a wakeup confrontation with President Reagan's military followed by the implicit threat of George W. Bush's anti-terrorism campaign after 9/11, had given up his nuclear ambitions and was actually providing significant assistance in world efforts to defeat Islamic terrorism. Hillary Clinton, Obama's first-term Secretary of State, decided that Colonel Gaddafi should not be allowed to put down a rebel insurrection within Libya and led an international effort to free Libya from his predilection to violence. Again, our interference resulted in tragedy for America and disaster for the people of Libya.
Saddam Hussein, the counterweight to Iran in the Middle East, was a cruel dictator with the propensity to involve himself in world politics and commit despicable acts. After 9/11, in addition to its war against the Taliban in Afghanistan, the Bush administration opted to invade Iraq due to concerns over Hussein's weapons of mass destruction. The ensuing government of Iraq was transformed from Sunni Muslim control that kept a firm hand on its Shiite Muslim majority population to Shiite Muslim control that abused its minority Sunni Muslim population. The result has been a continued reign of terror as car bombs and suicide bombers continue attacks on both branches of the Islamic tree.
Our involvement in Iraq was then followed by the disastrous and premature Obama decision to withdraw U.S. forces, thereby creating the opening for creation of a caliphate by the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria (ISIS) that has been on a murderous rampage throughout not only the Middle East but now extends into Europe, Africa, and even the United States.
That brings me back to the question of Syria: if the United States had not encouraged Syrians in their rebellion against the Assad government, if we had not surreptitiously armed Islamist rebels with weapons from Gaddafi's stockpiles in Libya, if we had not trained and equipped something we called the "Free Syrian Army," might not the civil war in Syria have ended by now with far fewer casualties than our prolonging of the war effort has allowed? I don't know the answer to this question, but it seems worthy of serious consideration.
Is it a curious coincidence that this revolutionary wave engulfing one Islamic nation after another from Tunisia in 2010, to Libya, Egypt, Yemen, Syria and Iraq occurred within mere months of one another? Is it a coincidence that demonstrations, protest and riots over this same period of time occurred in Morocco, Bahrain, Algeria, Lebanon, Jordan, Kuwait, Oman and Sudan with lesser protests in half a dozen other nations?
Is it a coincidence that where such demonstrations were immediately met with violent response and repression from governments, pro-government militias and counter-demonstrators such unrest largely passed but where the U.S. and its allies have intervened in support of regime change, battles still rage and horror rules the day creating a tidal wave of refugees threatening western civilization?
Do the United States and/or Western Europe really want to force regime change in Syria or should we instead support a ceasefire with the current government in place? There are steps we can take short of regime change that perhaps, based on our recent experience might lead to a better result.
http://www.americanthinker.com/articles/2017/04/syria_and_the_fundamentalist_islamic_uprising.html
Labels: Government, Politics
George Soros and German Media - By Mark Musser
Machiavelli's Advice for Mr. Trump – and Us - By J...
The Rise of the Generals - By Patrick J. Buchanan
The Place of Christianity in History: A View from ...
Why It's Impossible For Any Group To Be 'Inclusive...
Why Politicians Win (and Workers Lose) - By Hans-H...
Vox Popoli: An Alt-Right army
The Real "Anti-Science" - by Wesley J. Smith
Most "science" is fake science - by Vox Day
I Used To Be Blissfully Naive - By Richard Daughty...
The global elite are headed for a fall. And they d...
Of Two Minds - Housing's Echo Bubble Now Exceeds t...
The Clover Who Squealed - EPautos - Libertarian Ca...
Vox Popoli: The Media Bubble is real
The French Scuttle Their Own Ship - By Thierry Mey...
The Answer to American Troubles - By Kirkpatrick Sale
Crush's Comment on Today's article "Christian cens...
Christian censorship won't sanctify - by Trevaris ...
Bulk Cash Pays for the Wall - By John A. Cassara
The GOP Fraud - By Laurence M. Vance
The Latest 18th Century Fake News - By Brion McCla...
This Lawsuit Could Shatter ALL Federal Gun Control...
The real culprits behind the human waves of migran...
Will the FBI Spy on the Ron Paul Institute for Pea...
Vox Popoli: The end of "religious freedom"
We Must Never Forget That Genocide Begins With Gro...
A Deep Dive Into the Founding | Power Line
Vox Popoli: Sean Hannity is next
Vox Popoli: Audaciously correcting fake history
Islam in the Heart of England and France - by Deni...
Churches of the Gov't - By Paul Green
Big Red Flag for Cognitive Dissonance | Scott Adam...
This Vote, She Is Very Serious - By Eric Margolis
It's not just the French coming apart - by Vox Day
The French, Coming Apart | City Journal - Christop...
Why The H-1B Visa Racket Should Be Abolished, Not ...
Turkey Could Start a Global Meltdown - By Nick Gia...
Is Democracy in a Death Spiral? | Patrick J. Bucha...
The State Is Run by Megalomaniacs - By Hans-Herman...
What if We Don't Govern Ourselves? -By Andrew P. N...
Christianity and History - By Joseph Sobran
Hans-Hermann Hoppe On Migrant Crisis, USA, Germany...
UPDATE - The Nerve Agent Attack that Did Not Occur...
Trump's Incomprehensible Strategy in Syria - By Ti...
K-12: Quacks Rule - By Bruce Deitrick Price
There Will Be Blood: Left Prepares For War After B...
oftwominds-Charles Hugh Smith: What's Your Plan B?
How Two Stubborn Men Averted Nuclear War, Twice, i...
Vox Popoli: Restoring the deconstructed West
Imperial Obsession and the War on Terror - By Clyd...
Vox Popoli: Where is the God-Emperor?
Since when did people start going to college to ge...
Matthew's Gospel Offers An Amazing Case For Christ...
Why The Donald Should Cool It On N. Korea----The F...
Congress devoured by dark, 'corrupting influence' ...
Coal's Colossal Comeback | The American Spectator ...
Remember the Housing Bubble of 2008? Meet the Car ...
Dateline South Korea: What's Trump's Endgame Here?...
The Last Country America "Liberated" From An "Evil...
Video Shows Tampering with "Evidence" of Syrian Ch...
The US & China: Why The Sudden Convergence On Nort...
Vox Popoli: Christ is risen
(Germany) FAMILY TARGETED BY SWAT TEAM WITH BATTER...
Blessed Are the Peacemakers - By Yvonne Lorenzo
Is That Armageddon Over The Horizon? - By Paul Cra...
The Specter of Nuclear Destruction - By Thierry Me...
Don't Move to These States; They're in Serious Fin...
If You're Wondering Why Trump Can Just Bomb Countr...
A Tale of Violence in Two Cities: Augusta and Bilo...
Political 'Partisanship' And 'Divisiveness' Will N...
Lust For War | Zero Hedge - by Tyler Durden
The Sobering Reality of Trump – Reformed Libertarian
Swedish Doctors Call on "White Helmets" in Syria t...
It Wasn't 3D Chess - By Dan Phillips, MD.
Earth's Magnetic Poles - By Alanna Ketler
The Fog of War - By Chris Sullivan
The Deep State and Gramscian/Alinskyite Institutio...
Syria and the Fundamentalist Islamic Uprising - By...
Vox Popoli: Convergence and the Presbyterian Churc...
Of Two Minds - Who's Playing The Long Game--and Wh...
Trump's Bombing of Syria: Continuation of a Policy...
1983 CIA Document Reveals Plan To Destroy Syria, F...
Purge the Generals - By Michael Scheuer
Iran the Destabilizer - The Unz Review - PHILIP GI...
A comment on today's posts by daCrush
Desperate Solutions to Made-up Problems - By Eric ...
They Took Your Clothes and Gave You a Barrel - By ...
oftwominds-Charles Hugh Smith: The Media's Missing...
D.C.'s war madness - by Damon Linker
Is Trump Enlisting in the War Party? | Patrick J. ...
Vox Popoli: Mailvox: but what about [fill-in-the-b...
Many Very Bad Things Are About to Happen - By Doug...
Teaching doctors to give hormones to 'transgendere...
Not Prepared: Will Most Americans Be Absolutely Bl...
Vox Popoli: The Alt-Lite's fatal flaw
Into the Abyss - By Steven LaTulippe
US Nuclear Target Map - By M.D. Creekmore
Report: 40,000 Pro-Assad Christians in Aleppo Fear...
A War With Syria Has Begun - by Gary North
Hedge Fund CIO: "Expect Enormous Losses In The Nex...