Estate Agency
Wills - Making a Will
Business Leases
General Private Client Topics
Family and Matrimonial
Tax and Financial Planning
Trust, Wills and Probate
General Commercial Topics
IP and IT
Landlord, Tenant and Property
Selby (Abbey Yard)
Selby (Finkle Street)
Sherburn-In-Elmet
EP Estate Agents
Call our offices
Sharing Principle - Court of Appeal Gives Guidance
The application of the 'sharing principle' to big money divorces is more than a matter of simple mathematics, and what family judges aim to achieve is a broadly fair outcome for both sides. That was certainly so in one case in which the Court of Appeal refused to increase an ex-wife's £73 million award.
The former couple had two children who had grown to adulthood during their 26-year marriage and, by the time of their divorce, their overall wealth was valued at £182 million. By far their largest asset was a lighting manufacturing company. There was no dispute that the sharing principle should be applied to the case.
In assessing the wife's entitlement, a family judge took account of the fact that the company had been founded by the husband eight years before the marriage. Taking a 'straight-line' approach to valuing the business at the date of the marriage, he found that the total marital wealth, net of taxes and costs of realisation, was £146 million. The wife's award came to roughly half that total, £72.8 million.
In challenging the judge's decision, the wife argued that her award was about £17 million lower than it should have been. Amongst other things, she pointed out that the husband owned half of the company on the date of the marriage, only later acquiring all of it. On that basis, it was said that the judge had underestimated the proportion of the company's value that had been built up during the marriage.
In rejecting her appeal, however, the Court found that her overall award resonated with fairness. The outcome reflected the judge's overarching view of the weight to be attributed to the husband's contributions to the company throughout its existence. It also represented a fair assessment of the true value of what the husband had brought into the marriage via the company.
Also ruling on the husband's cross-appeal, the Court found that the judge had erred in requiring him to pay the wife a £20 million lump sum within a year. In treating the value of the company as equivalent to cash, the judge had failed to consider whether the outcome achieved a fair division of copper-bottomed, non-risk assets. In order to achieve a broadly fair outcome, the Court ruled that the husband should have to pay the lump sum in four £5 million instalments over four years.
Simon Rounding
For assistance in dealing with the financial negotiations following relationship break-up, contact us.
For further information please call one of our experts on:
The contents of this article are intended for general information purposes only and shall not be deemed to be, or constitute legal advice. We cannot accept responsibility for any loss as a result of acts or omissions taken in respect of this article.
Channel Referrer Device
Telephone Please enter your telephone number
Morning Afternoon Evening ASAP
Please enter the best time for us to call you
Please select your preferred office
Preferred officeBarnsleySelby-Abbey-YardSelby-Finkle-StreetSherburn
Please let us know how you heard about us
We'll only use this information to handle your enquiry and we won't share it with any third parties. For more details see our Privacy Policy
Please select your preferred method of contact
Preferred contact methodTelephoneEmail
Please let us know your preferred contact method
Please enter the details of your enquiry
Moving house?
We understand the importance of communicating with everyone involved in the process, the importance of acting quickly so there are no delays and most importantly, in providing a value for money service.
Providing you have an up to date Energy Performance Certificate we can get your property up and running at no upfront cost within a few days.
No Sale No Fee
Our Estate Agent fee is only payable upon completion of a sale. If we don't sell, you don't pay.
If your circumstances change for whatever reason, and wish to remove your property you are free to do so, with no withdrawal fee.
S70 2HP
S71 4EW
royston@elmhirstparker.com
The Abbey Yard
YO8 4PX
13 Finkle Street
YO8 4DT
LS25 6BH
On - you agreed to accept cookies from this website - thank you.
On - you disabled cookies on this website - some functions will not operate as intended.
We use a range of cookies to improve your experience of our site. Find out more.