Questions? Comments? Contact the Embryo Parson
Make Baptists Anglican Again
The Old Jamestown Church
Orthodox Anglicanism for North America and Beyond
Celebrating 400 years of Anglicanism in America at the Old Jamestown Church
TRADITIONAL ANGLICANISM
Layman's Guide to the Thirty-Nine Articles, Fr. Robert Hart, Fr. Luke Wells and Bishop Peter Robinson (Tending to show that, as J.H. Newman put it, the Articles are "patient . . . of a Catholic interpretation.")
The Thirty-Nine Articles of Religion
Fr. Hart Essays on Classical Anglicanism
Class Notes and Videos for Inquierers - St. Matthew Anglican Catholic Church
Branch Theory or Branch Fact?: Catholic Ecumenism and the Elephant in the Room
On the Catholicity of Anglicanism
A Protestant Learns About Anglicanism
A Brief History of the English Church
Thomas Cranmer and the English Reformation
The Caroline Divines
What Was the Oxford Movement?
Dead Anglican Theologians Society
CENTER FOR PASTOR THEOLOGIANS
"What concord is there between the Academy and the Church?" - Tertullian
The Pastorate as the Proper Venue for the Church's Theology
CPT Blog
HIERATIC LITURGICAL ENGLISH
Peter Berger: The Vernacularist Illusion
Shawn Tribe: On the Use of a Hieratic Liturgical English
Why Use Archaic Language?
An Appeal for Cranmer's Prayers
ON BEING ANGLICAN
A Medieval "Sinner's Prayer"
"Marvel not that I said unto thee, Ye must be born again." (Some reflections on the conversion of C.S. Lewis)
How I Got There: An Evangelical Converts to Anglicanism
Journey to Anglicanism
"Kansas'" Bassist Dave Hope: From Rock Star and Druggie to Anglican Priest
An Atheist (C.S. Lewis) Converts, Rejoins the Anglican Church and Becomes One of Christianity's Most Notable Spokesmen
TRADITIONAL ANGLICAN CHURCHES
"Continuing Anglican" Churches - We would argue the most consistently traditional or "classical" Anglican churches.
Continuing Anglican Miscellany
"Anglican Realignment" Churches (ACNA, AMiA, and others) - Conservative but markedly less traditional than the Continuing Anglican Churches.
Reformed Episcopal Church - Currently part of the Anglican Realignment but these days much more like the traditional Continuing Anglican bodies.
ANGLICAN BLOGS AND WEB SITES
1662 Book of Common Prayer Online
A Living Text
Alastair's Adversaria
Akenside Press
American Anglican Council
American Anglican Council Videos on the 39 Articles
ἀναστόμωσις
Anglican Audio
Anglican Bible and Book Society
An Anglican Bookshelf (List of recommended Anglican books)
Anglican Catholic Church
Anglican Catholic Liturgy and Theology
Anglican Church in North America
Anglican Church Planting
Anglican Eucharistic Theology
Anglican Expositor
Anglican Internet Church
Anglican Mainstream
Anglican Mission in the Americas
Anglican Mom
An Anglican Priest
Anglican.net
Anglican Radio
Anglican Rose
Anglican Way Magazine
Anglicanly Speaking
The Anglophilic Anglican
A BCP Anglican
The Book of Common Prayer (Blog of Photos)
The Book of Common Prayer (Online Texts)
The Cathedral Close
The Catholic Anglican
Chinese Orthodoxy
The Church Calendar
Church Society
Classical Anglicanism: Essays by Fr. Robert Hart
Cogito, Credo, Petam
Colorado Anglican Society
CommonPrayer.org
(The Old) Continuing Anglican Churchman
(The New) Continuing Anglican Churchman
The Curate's Corner
The Cure of Souls
Drew's Views
The Evangelical Ascetic
Faith and Gender: Five Aspects of Man
Fellowship of Concerned Churchmen
Forward in Christ Magazine
Forward in Faith North America
Francis J. Hall's Theological Outlines
Free Range Anglican
Full Homely Divinity
Gavin Ashenden
The Hackney Hub
The Homely Hours
International Catholic Congress of Anglicans
Jesse Nigro's Thoughts
The Latimer Trust
Laudable Practice
Martin Thornton
Meditating on "Irvana"
New Goliards
New Scriptorium (Anglican Articles and Books Online)
The North American Anglican
O cuniculi! Ubi lexicon Latinum posui?
The Ohio Anglican Blog
The Old High Churchman
Philorthodox
Prayer Book Anglican
The Prayer Book Society, USA
Project Canterbury
Ritual Notes
Pusey House
Prydain
Rebel Priest (Jules Gomes)
Reformed Catholicism
Reformed Episcopal Church
The Ridley Institute
River Thames Beach Party
The Secker Society
Society of Archbishops Cranmer and Laud
The Southern High Churchman
Stand Firm
Texanglican
The Theologian
The World's Ruined
TitusOneNine
To All The World
Trinity House Blog
United Episcopal Church of North America
Virtue Online
We See Through A Mirror Darkly
When I Consider How My Light is Spent: The Crier in the Digital Wilderness Calls for a Second Catholic Revival
Wyclif
Bad Vestments
The Low Churchman's Guide to the Solemn High Mass
"WORSHIP WARS"
Ponder Anew: Discussions about Worship for Thinking People
RESISTING LEFTIST ANTICHRISTIANITY
Black-Robed Regiment
Cardinal Charles Chaput Reviews "For Greater Glory" (Cristero War)
Benedict Option
Jim Kalb: How Bad Will Things Get?
The Once and Future Christendom
RESISTING ISLAMIC ANTICHRISTIANITY
Christians in the Roman Army: Countering the Pacifist Narrative
Bernard of Clairvaux and the Knights Templar
Gates of Nineveh
Islamophobes (We're in good company)
Nineveh Plains Protection Units
Restore Nineveh Now - Nineveh Plains Protection Units
Sons of Liberty International (SOLI)
OTHER SITES AND BLOGS, MANLY, POLITICAL AND WHATNOT
Abbeville Institute Blog
Art of the Rifle
Chronicles: A Magazine of American Culture
Church For Men
The Church Impotent: The Feminization of Christianity, (Leon Podles' online book)
The Counter-Revolution
Joffre the Giant: Excursions in Christian Virility
Men of the West
Mercurius Pragmaticus Redivivus
Mere Comments
Mitre and Crown
Monomakhos (Eastern Orthodox; Paleocon)
The Orthosphere
Paterfamilias Daily
Tales of Chivalry
The Midland Agrarian
Those Catholic Men
Tim Holcombe: Anti-State; Pro-Kingdom
Pint, Pipe and Cross Club
The Pipe Smoker
Red River Orthodox
The Salisbury Review
Throne, Altar, Liberty
Project Appleseed (Basic Rifle Marksmanship)
What's Wrong With The World: Dispatches From The 10th Crusade
CHRISTIAN MUSIC FOR CHRISTIAN MEN
Numavox Records (Music of Kerry Livgen & Co.)
Wovenhand
Jerycho
WOMEN'S ORDINATION TO THE PRIESTHOOD
A Defense of the Doctrine of the Eternal Subordination of the Son (Yes, this is about women's ordination.)
An (Extended) Short History of the Diaconate
Essays on the Ordination of Women to the Priesthood from the Episcopal Diocese of Ft. Worth
Faith and Gender: Five Aspects of Man, blog of Fr. William Mouser, International Council for Gender Studies
Father is Head at the Table: Male Eucharistic Headship and Primary Spiritual Leadership, Ray Sutton
FIFNA Bishops Stand Firm Against Ordination of Women
God, Gender and the Pastoral Office, S.M. Hutchens
God, Sex and Gender, Gavin Ashenden
Homo Hierarchicus and Ecclesial Order, Brian Horne
How Ordaining Women Harms Ministry to Men, C.R. Wiley
Let's Stop Making Women Presbyters, J.I. Packer
Liturgy and Interchangeable Sexes, Peter J. Leithart
Male-Only Ordination is Natural: Why the Church is a Model of Reality, Steven Wedgeworth
Ordaining Women as Deacons: A Reappraisal of the Anglican Mission in America's Policy, John Rodgers
Priestesses in Plano, Robert Hart
Priestesses in the Church?, C.S. Lewis
Priesthood and Masculinity, Stephen DeYoung
Reasons for Questioning Women's Ordination in the Light of Scripture, Rodney Whitacre
Streams of the River: Articles Outlining the Arguments Against the Ordination of Women to the Priesthood ,
Traditional Anglican Resources
William Witt's Articles on Women's Ordination (Old Jamestown Church archive)
Women Priests?, Eric Mascall
Women and the Priesthood, Catholic Answers
Women Priests: History & Theology, Patrick Reardon
The Anglican Realignment's Formation Problem
What Must It Have Been Like. . .
Anglicanism: Protestant or Patristic?
The Eternal Liturgy vs. Contemporary Worship
Real Presence: The Eucharistic Primitivism of the Scottish Liturgy of 1764
E.J. Bicknell on the History of Subscription to the Thirty-Nine Articles
Becoming a Prayer Book Family
"We Are The Resistance"
Why Is It Your Business How Other People Worship
Trad Expressions™: Why High Church Is Contemporary
Chant For Men
It Came To This Once, And It Will Soon Come To It Again
This Guy For Pope
Militia Christi. Onward Christian Soldiers
Christianity's Masculinity Crisis
An Anglo-Catholic Responsio
"Gentlemen, Prepare to Defend Yourselves!"
Continuing Anglicanism Before Continuing Anglicanism Was Cool
S.M. Hutchens on the Dithering ACNA
ACNA
The ACNA and the Historic Priesthood
The ACNA, Still Dithering
Fr. Patrick Henry Reardon on Orthodoxy
The Neuroscience of Traditional Architecture
Why Ancient Liturgy Matters
Samuel Seabury's Miter
Fr. Jonathan Munn Responds to a Critic of the Anglican Catholic Church
A Letter to an Eastern Orthodox Convert from Evangelicalism
Categories and Monthly Archives
"Three Streams" Anglicanism (31)
39 Articles (31)
ACNA (102)
Anarcho-Monarchy (3)
Anglican Catholic Church (52)
Anglican Chants and Hymnody (60)
Anglican Church in America (4)
Anglican Churches (11)
Anglican Follies (65)
Anglican Orders (37)
Anglican Province in America (9)
Anglican Province of Christ the King (2)
Anglican Realignment (109)
Anglican Spiritual Life (151)
Anglicans, Alcohol and Smoke (11)
Anglo-Calvinism (23)
Anglo-Catholicism (115)
Apocalypse and Parousia (1)
Ascetical Theology (30)
Becoming A Christian (12)
Benedict Option (25)
Benedictine Spirituality (24)
Bernard of Clairvaux (26)
Bernard Option (24)
Best Anglican Theology Blogs (5)
Book of Common Prayer (53)
C.S. Lewis (23)
Caroline Divines (39)
Chants and Hymnody (47)
Chaplaincy (1)
Charismata (15)
Christian Culture (99)
Christian Pacifism (25)
Christian Resistance Theory and Praxis (85)
Church of England (63)
Church v. Academy (8)
Clash of Civilizations (29)
Contemporary Christian Worship (40)
Continuing Anglicanism (66)
Crusades (30)
Culture Wars (62)
Daily Offices (2)
Death of the Anglican Communion (37)
Demise of the Orthodox Western Rite (18)
Diocese of the Holy Cross (2)
Dogmatic Theology (25)
Eastern Orthodoxy (131)
English Reformation (104)
Episcopacy (5)
Episcopaganism (4)
Episcopal Church (42)
Ethno-theology (9)
Eucharist (28)
Evangelical and Catholic (92)
Evangelical Converts (12)
Future of Protestantism (29)
Hierarchy (4)
Historical Theology (95)
Holy Scripture (44)
Iconography (5)
John Calvin (23)
Just War Doctrine (13)
Justification By Faith (44)
Liberal-leftism (30)
Liturgical Calendar (14)
Liturgical Theology (28)
Liturgical Year (29)
Liturgy (53)
Man-glicanism (62)
Muscular Christianity (108)
Mysticism (17)
Neo-Anglicanism (66)
New Age Religion (4)
New Perspective on Paul (6)
Northern Alliance (38)
Orthodox Anglican Church (16)
Oxford Movement (28)
Patriarchy (19)
Political Theory and Praxis (67)
Predestination and Free Will (36)
Reformed Episcopal Church (12)
Richard Hooker (4)
Right to Keep and Bear Arms (14)
Roman Catholicism (94)
Spiritual Autobiography (2)
Spiritual Warfare (5)
The Gospel (54)
The Orthodox Anglican Communion (8)
The Problem of Anglican Identity (94)
Traditional Anglicanism (323)
Traditional Architecture (1)
United Episcopal Church North America (12)
Videos and Music (93)
Western Culture (77)
Why Anglicanism? (112)
William Witt's Articles on Women's Ordination (12)
Women's Ordination (65)
Blog Comments RSS
A Reply to Kerby Rials
Embryo Parson Posted on Friday, January 16, 2015 at 12:16AM
UPDATE 1/25.
On December 21 of last year, Assemblies of God pastor and missionary Kerby Rials posted a critical response to the article How I Got There: An Evangelical Converts to Anglicanism, to which I will respond here. (The article was written by a certain "Fr. Doug", who was the vicar at All Saints Anglican Church in San Antonio at the time of the article's first publication. I have yet to find his last name.) Before responding to Pastor Rials, however, I want to extend the right hand of fellowship to him by thanking God for his mission to plant Evangelical churches in Belgium, and for the irenic tone of his response to the article. Pastor Rials and I have become Facebook friends, though we have as yet to interact there. I think he will find after reading my reply here that he has more in common with certain Anglicans than he thinks. In fact, a goodly number of charismatic Evangelicals from AOG and Vineyard ranks have become Anglicans. Many of them are church planters themselves and seek to perpetuate Three Streams Anglicanism in North America and beyond.
So, now that I've offered the rose of friendship to Pastor Rials, I would like to turn his attention to the thorns. His response begins:
I read your story with interest, and felt led to leave you a response. In looking over your account of your conversion, I could not find, what seemed to me, to be a strong justification of Anglican theology as opposed to evangelical protestant theology. As I see it, these are the principal concerns:
You noted, first of all, that "the priest is a father and the parishioners are his children. He is responsible for raising and nuturing (sic) them." This contradicts, it seems to me, the New Testament passages speaking of the priesthood of every believer, and the fact that there are no priests in the New Testament at all. The collegiality and the equality of the believers in the New Testament does not concur with the hierarchical system practiced in Anglicanism. It creates a barrier between the believer and Christ, inserting an hierarchical priesthood.
Classical Anglicanism in fact holds to the priesthood of all believers as one of the key Reformational distinctives that fueled the English Reformation. However, like so many in the baptistic and free church traditions, Pastor Rials illogically concludes from the few New Testament data which speak to the issue of the priesthood of believers that some form of democratic egalitarianism is implied. He sees no "hierarchical system" in the New Testament when in fact there is hierarchy to be seen just about anywhere you look. For example, it was the apostles and the elders who convened the Jerusalem Council, not the "priesthood of believers" at large. We see hierarchy set forth in the listing of spiritual gifts concerning church leadership seen in I Cor. 12:28 and Ephesians 4:11-16. Of these leaders, the writer of the Epistle to the Hebrews writes, "Obey . . . and submit to them, for they are keeping watch over your souls, as those who will have to give an account."
Though revisionist Anglo-Catholics would demur, we would agree with Pastor Rials that there is no sacerdotal priesthood in the New Testament. There is, however, a "presbyterate". The English word "priest" is etymologically related to the word "presbyter", so there it is perfectly acceptable to call an elder of the church a "priest", so long as we stipulate that the "priests" of the New Testament were not sacrificing priests. That being said, St. Paul was not averse to seeing a priestly aspect of his ministry, for, as he writes in Romans 15: 15-17, ". . . I have written very boldly to you on some points so as to remind you again, because of the grace that was given me from God, to be a minister of Christ Jesus to the Gentiles, ministering as a priest the gospel of God, so that my offering of the Gentiles may become acceptable, sanctified by the Holy Spirit." (NASB) The word there is hierourgounta, literally, "ministering as a priest", as the NASB literally translates it, and if it is possible for a church leader to do priestly service in one sense, why not more? I would recommend to Pastor Rials that he read the Conciliar Anglican blog article On the Eucharist: Why We Need a Presbyter at the Altar and that he also lay his hands on Brian Horne's article Homo Hierarchicus and Ecclesial Order. We move on:
Secondly, and in a related fashion, Anglicanism's reliance on apostolic succession is faulty, it seems to me, as Christ himself noted that those who were not apostles and had no apostolic succession had a valid ministry: (Luke 9:49) "John answered and said, "Master, we saw someone casting out demons in Your name; and we tried to prevent him because he does not follow along with us." But Jesus said to him, "Do not hinder him; for he who is not against you is for you." Paul had no apostolic succession, but it did not hinder him either: (Gal. 1:12ff) For I neither received it from man, nor was I taught it, but I received it through a revelation of Jesus Christ...But when God... was pleased to reveal His Son in me so that I might preach Him among the Gentiles, I did not immediately consult with flesh and blood, nor did I go up to Jerusalem to those who were apostles before me; but I went away to Arabia, and returned once more to Damascus."
Classical Anglicans would agree with Pastor Rials that the ministry of the Holy Spirit can't be confined to the church hierarchy, but to make that acknowledgment is not in any way to gainsay the proposition that Christ, and the apostles after him, DID establish a church order that was not only hierarchical in nature but would need a means of perpetuating itself. Read any book worth its salt on apostolic succession, and it is certainly evident that church order underwent a process of evolution during the first century. However, it became clear by the second and third centuries that a mechanism for episcopal succession was in place. We see it coming into shape as early as the end of the first century, as evidenced in Clement of Rome:
Through countryside and city [the apostles] preached, and they appointed their earliest converts, testing them by the Spirit, to be the bishops and deacons of future believers. Nor was this a novelty, for bishops and deacons had been written about a long time earlier. . . . Our apostles knew through our Lord Jesus Christ that there would be strife for the office of bishop. For this reason, therefore, having received perfect foreknowledge, they appointed those who have already been mentioned and afterwards added the further provision that, if they should die, other approved men should succeed to their ministry.
As the decades and the next few centuries unfolded, patristic testimony to apostolic succession became multiplied. However, it is not in any way necessary to hold the view, as some high church Anglicans and Anglo-Catholics do, that without an apostolic succession there are no valid sacraments or no valid church. That certainly was not the view of Anglican divinity from Cranmer through Hooker. It was only later that this view began to assert itself. Classical Anglicans do not view the bishop as being necessary to the esse of the church, but they tend rather to sort themselves into plene esse and bene esse camps, all of which is to say that the activity of the Holy Spirit can in no way be bound to the canonical boundaries of the church.
Anglicanism's reliance upon the liturgy is also not found in the New Testament, nor is its reliance upon tradition as superior to scripture or its belief in transubstantiation (sic) nor its reliance upon infant baptism, which did not come into the church until 400 years after the apostles. Anglicanism seems to be drifting doctrinally toward Catholicism and LIberalism at the same time. It is a church without a strong sense of purpose, unable to deal with heretical beliefs like homosexuality in the bishopric. I used to consider it a protestant church but I am not sure anymore!
In this paragraph we find a string of wholly false and misinformed assertions. If Pastor Rials would simply read some scholarly works on this history of the Christian liturgy, he will be shown all the indications to be found in the New Testament that the apostolic (which is to say Jewish) church most likely inherited a liturgical form of worship based on the Hebraic form of worship. Classical Anglicanism does not believe in transubstantiation, and nor does Anglo-Catholicism (which tends to gravitate to a more Eastern view of the sacrament). Infant baptism did not appear 400 years after the apostles. We have copious evidence from the 2nd century as to its practice, and as the penetrating exegetical and historical work of Joachim Jeremias demonstrates, there is every reason that Christian paedobaptism is related to Jewish proselyte baptism as a child is related to a parent. Segments of Anglicanism have indeed been drifting toward Catholicism and liberalism ever since the 19th century, but Pastor Rials illogically concludes that what is true of the part must be true of the whole. It makes me wonder if he's ever examined Anglicanism's Formularies or read J.I. Packer or John Stott, who are noted representatives of a huge Evangelical Protestant stream in the Anglican Communion and Realignment Anglicanism.
The sum of the matter here, if I may be blunt, is that Pastor Rials really doesn't have much of an understanding of what it is he rejects in his response to Fr. Doug, but if he's game, we would be pleased to disabuse him of any other false notions he has of the Anglican Way, as we have done here with respect to the notions expressed in said response. I think if he would simply read the 39 Articles, he'd find a document that is thoroughly Protestant and Evangelical, but he would also find there a document that reflects a catholicity that the AOG simply doesn't have, and which is why historically-minded Pentecostals have left churches like the AOG and the Vineyard for "Three Stream" Anglican churches, which are aplenty around the world. I would direct his attention to one Pentecostal theologian in particular, Simon Chan, who in his book Liturgical Theology: The Church as Worshiping Community in essence forces the question of why Pentecostals shouldn't become Anglicans.
1 Comment → Share Article →
in "Three Streams" Anglicanism, 39 Articles, ACNA, AMiA, Anglican Orders, Anglican Realignment, Anglican Spiritual Life, Anglo-Catholicism, Baptism, Charismata, English Reformation, Eucharist, Evangelical Converts, Evangelical and Catholic, Historical Theology, Holy Scripture, Liturgical Theology, Liturgy, Roman Catholicism, Traditional Anglicanism, Why Anglicanism?
Reader Comments (1)
"If Pastor Rials would simply read some scholarly works on this history of the Christian liturgy, he will be shown all the indications to be found in the New Testament that the apostolic (which is to say Jewish) church most likely inherited a liturgical form of worship based on the Hebraic form of worship."
Could you please provide any source material on this or do an article. I'd be super curious to know more.
May 16, 2016 | Mark
« C.S. Lewis on Mere Liberty and the Evils of Statism | Main | From an Anglican Bishop in Nigeria »
Copyright © 2012 - 2016, Embryo Parson. All rights reserved.