Cruise ships could be put into storage for months due to coronavirus
Gene Sloan
Some of the world's biggest cruise lines are weighing plans to lay up portions of their fleets for an extended period due to the coronavirus outbreak.
Cruise giant Carnival Corp., the parent company of nine of the world's best-known cruise brands, said in a regulatory filing last week that some of its vessels could face a "prolonged" withdrawal from service consistent with what is known in the industry as a cold layup.
In such a layup, machinery on the ship is prepared for an extended period of nonuse and the majority of crew is sent home.
For more TPG U.K. news delivered each morning to your inbox, sign up for our daily newsletter.
"During the pause in our global fleet cruise operations, certain of our ships will be in warm ship layup where the ship will be manned by a full crew, and certain of our ships will be in a prolonged ship layup where the ship will be manned by a limited crew," Carnival Corp. said in the filing with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). "We currently estimate the substantial majority of our fleet will be in prolonged ship layup."
Based in Miami, Carnival Corp. is the parent company of its namesake Carnival Cruise Line brand, as well as three more North America-based lines: Princess Cruises, Holland America and Seabourn. It also owns U.K.-based Cunard Line and P&O Cruises; Germany's Aida Cruises; Italy's Costa Cruises; and Australia's P&O Cruises Australia.
All nine of the brands began temporarily shutting down operations in March as the number of coronavirus cases began soaring around the globe. But, for now, most of the brands only have cancelled sailings scheduled to depart in the next six weeks.
Carnival Corp.'s filing this week suggests the shutdowns will last far longer.
In the filing, Carnival Corp. said it expected the length of time that its ships will be out of service could be "extended and may be prolonged."
The regulatory filing came in conjunction with an effort by Carnival Corp. to shore up its finances by selling $6 billion worth of common stock and debt instruments.
Related: Here's how to cancel or postpone a cruise due to coronavirus
With its ships no longer sailing, Carnival Corp. is burning through about $1 billion a month, according to the filing.
Carnival Corp. said a move to prolonged lay ups for its ships would save the company about $1 million to $2 million per month, per ship.
"We estimate the cost per warm ship layup is approximately $2 to 3 million per month and the cost per prolonged ship layup is approximately $1 million per month," the company said in the filing.
Together, Carnival Corp.'s nine brands operate 105 vessels. They account for about 45% of all cruises taken worldwide.
Companies often map out worse-case scenarios in SEC filings, in an effort to be as transparent as possible with investors. But Carnival Corp.'s statements about laying up ships for a prolonged period weren't presented as a worse-case scenario. A spokesperson for Carnival Corp. could not comment due to a "quiet period" surrounding the company's stock sale.
Carnival Corp. did not use the term cold layup in its filing, but its description of the layups as prolonged is consistent with what the industry refers to as a cold layup.
Related: Cruise ship 'draws' 16-mile-wide smile at sea as departing gift for passengers
In a cold layup, vessels are staffed with just enough crew to perform routine maintenance and monitor ship systems including safety equipment, according to Lloyd's Register, one of several "classification societies" worldwide that set technical standards and issue certifications for cruise ships. Lloyd's Register certifies the vessels for several Carnival Corp. brands, including Carnival and Princess.
In a guide to layups, Lloyd's Register lists a long checklist of actions that should be performed in advance of and during a cold layup. For starters, ballast tanks are either emptied completely or filled completely with water plus corrosion inhibitors. In machinery areas such as engine rooms, dehumidifiers are deployed to prevent corrosion. Steam generating plants would be emptied and opened for natural ventilation.
Dehumidifiers also would be deployed in cabin areas and public rooms; cabin linens and towels would be stored in one dry location; and cabin mattresses would be stored on edge. Refrigerated provision chambers would be emptied and left with doors open.
It can take three weeks to reactivate a ship after a cold layup, according to Lloyd's Register.
Lloyd's Register lists several other levels of layups, each with its own requirements. They include a "hot ship" layup where a vessel can be back in service in 24 hours and a "warm ship" layup where a vessel can return to service in a week.
There's also a more extreme "long-term" layup designed for ships that will be mothballed for five years or more. A long-term layup can take three months to reverse.
Multimonth layups are not unusual in the cruise world. River lines such as Avalon Waterways and AmaWaterways typically lay up their vessels in Europe every winter during the coldest months. Avalon's voyages on the Seine River in France, for instance, only take place between April and October. For the rest of the year, the line's ship on the Seine, Tapestry II, doesn't operate.
Two U.S.-focused small-ship lines — American Cruise Lines and American Queen Steamboat Company — also lay up ships during the coldest winter months.
While most Carnival Corp. brands only have cancelled sailings through mid-May for now, a few already have announced longer shutdowns for a handful of ships — in some cases, far longer. On Wednesday, the Carnival brand said it had cancelled all sailings on two of its 27 vessels, Carnival Legend and Carnival Radiance, through 30 October and 1 November, respectively. It also cancelled Alaska sailings on the Carnival Spirit through June 30.
In the case of the Carnival Radiance, an overhaul of the ship that had been scheduled to take place this spring in Spain can't be done because the shipyard is shutdown due to the severe coronavirus outbreak in the country. Carnival Legend also had been scheduled to be in Europe this year.
In the case of Carnival Spirit, the ship no longer can operate itineraries to Alaska through 1 July due to a coronavirus-related ban on ships imposed by Canada. Carnival relies on Canadian ports to make its Alaska itineraries viable. Carnival began sending crew from Carnival Spirit home in March.
Other cruise companies that already have announced extended shutdowns include Viking. The line has cancelled all sailings on its 73 river ships and six ocean ships through 1 July. Small expedition cruise marketer Adventure Canada has cancelled all sailings for the rest of the year.
On Wednesday, the parent company of British cruise operator Saga said in a financial disclosure that it was building a contingency plan around an assumption that its cruise business could be suspended for a period of six months, from mid-March to mid-September.
For now, the company only has cancelled voyages through 1 May.
"It is likely that the period of travel suspension will continue beyond May," Saga said.
Saga said it also had considered a further, more severe scenario that assumes cruising wouldn't resume until January of 2021.
Featured image courtesy of Carnival.
Gene Sloan has written about cruising for more than 25 years and for many years oversaw USA TODAY's award-winning cruise site, USA TODAY Cruises. He's sailed on nearly 150 ships.