Is there a place for CPR and sustained physiological support in brain-dead non-donors?
Stephen D Brown
Correspondence to Dr Stephen D Brown, Department of Radiology, Boston Children's Hospital and Harvard Medical School, 300 Longwood Ave, Boston, MA 02115, USA; Stephen.brown{at}childrens.harvard.edu
This article addresses whether cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) and sustained physiological support should ever be permitted in individuals who are diagnosed as brain dead and who had held previously expressed moral or religious objections to the currently accepted criteria for such a determination. It contrasts how requests for care would normally be treated in cases involving a brain-dead individual with previously expressed wishes to donate and a similarly diagnosed individual with previously expressed beliefs that did not conform to a brain-based conception of death. The paper first focuses narrowly on requests for CPR and then expands its scope to address extended physiological support. It describes how refusing the brain-dead non-donor's requests for either CPR or extended support would represent enduring harm to the antemortem or previously autonomous individual by negating their beliefs and self-identity. The paper subsequently discusses potential implications of policy that would allow greater accommodations to those with conscientious objections to currently accepted brain-based death criteria, such as for cost, insurance, higher brain formulations and bedside communication. The conclusion is that granting wider latitude to personal conceptions around the definition of death, rather than forcing a contested definition on those with valid moral and religious objections, would benefit both individuals and society.
Patient perspective
Definition/Determination of Death
Moral and Religious Aspects
Attitudes Toward Death
A narrative review of the empirical evidence on public attitudes on brain death and vital organ transplantation: the need for better data to inform policy
Seema K Shah et al., Journal of Medical Ethics, 2014
Death and organ donation: back to the future
F G Miller, Journal of Medical Ethics, 2009
Individual choice in the definition of death
A Bagheri, Journal of Medical Ethics, 2007
Defining death in non-heart beating organ donors
N Zamperetti et al., Journal of Medical Ethics, 2003
Death, dying and donation: organ transplantation and the diagnosis of death
I H Kerridge et al., Journal of Medical Ethics, 2002
Organismal death, the dead - donor rule and the ethics of vital organ procurement
Xavier Symons et al., Journal of Medical Ethics, 2018
Should individuals choose their definition of death
A Molina et al., Journal of Medical Ethics, 2008
Does it matter that organ donors are not dead? Ethical and policy implications
M Potts et al., Journal of Medical Ethics, 2005
Waiting for a miracle or best medical practice? End - of - life medical ethical dilemmas in Bahrain
Sayed Alwadaei et al., Journal of Medical Ethics, 2019
Non-heart beating organ donation: old procurement strategy — new ethical problems
M D D Bell, Journal of Medical Ethics, 2003