Commentary Housing Housing Rights Stop All Government Evictions Campaign Stop Government Evictions from Safe Affordable Homes
Supervisors Face Historic Affordable Housing Vote to Permit Trailers & Tiny Homes Sept 27 meeting to consider policy recommendation extending temp housing designation to county's lowest cost housing
Posted on August 29, 2022 by Jonathan Greenberg and Tim Ryan
Tomorrow afternoon, September 27, Supervisors will, for the first time ever, consider a change in policy that would allow some of the more than 10,000 low income renters on private rural property to remain in their safe, affordable trailers and tiny homes without fear of eviction from county code enforcement.
The Sonoma Independent urges citizens who care about affordable housing, and our neighbors who live in trailers and tiny homes, to let Supervisors know that we need real reform. Housing advocates are asking anyone who is able to join the zoom meeting or attend in person. A full list of Sonoma County supervisors and their contact information is at the bottom of this article. The alternative housing item will be heard in the afternoon after the break for lunch, around 1:00 a.m. The meeting agenda can be downloaded here and the specific agenda item can be found here.
Join us in urging supervisors to make these historic changes to building code enforcement and policy:
1) Create a new class of temporary housing for trailers and tiny homes
2) Legalize waterless composting toilets
3) Permit a "hold and haul" option for wastewater disposal, allowing thousands of people living in trailers to remain there without being attached to septic systems for wastewater, which is un-permitable for many property owners.
Last year, Permit Sonoma issued 30-day orders forcing property owners to evict about 189 rent-paying tenants, many of them seniors, out of the only safe housing they could afford in the county, for lack of unobtainable or prohibitively expensive permits.
The supervisors now have an opportunity to stop many of these evictions. Legalizing waterless toilets, creating a new class of temporary housing, and allowing "hold and haul" wastewater disposal are some of the building code changes which will be put before the board on Tuesday. While these and other changes will not protect all of the people living in alternative housing, they are the most substantial policy shifts to be considered in the yearlong effort to keep people in their tiny homes and trailers.
Even though this opportunity is promising, it remains to be seen whether the Supervisors will take action, or whether they will preserve the current status quo. Lynda Hopkins has been a champion for alternative housing and will almost certainly vote for the changes. Susan Gorin and David Rabbitt have also expressed the desire for policy shifts to protect renters, but it is unclear how far this support will go. Vice Chair James Gore and Supervisor Coursey have been more cautious in stating their positions about the issue, and it appears from his previous statements that Coursey at least may not support safe alternative housing.
Tomorrows meeting is the culmination of a year long effort by local housing activists and the Sonoma Independent. The issue was brought to light when Copperwoman Saso, a Sebastopol area grandmother, was forced to move from her state of the art tiny home by order of Permit Sonoma. Copperwoman wrote this song about the situation, which was viewed by more than 50,000 people on YouTube.
Most recently, on April 6, five months ago, after receiving the largest affordable housing petition in county history (3,500 people have signed the Sonoma Independent's "SAGE" petition to Stop All Government Evictions from Safe, Affordable Trailers and Tiny Homes Campaign), Supervisors Lynda Hopkins, Susan Gorin and David Rabbitt ordered Permit Sonoma and County Counsel to craft a solution that would create an emergency housing ordinance to curb inhumane eviction that have removed thousands of residents from the most affordable housing in the region. Instead of a specific ordinance, permanent changes to the county building code are being considered as part of the 2022 model building code update.
Supervisor Lynda Hopkins, who has long championed the need to curb Permit Sonoma's relentless campaign against low income residents of safe trailers and tiny homes, observed, "When we have so many unhoused people it seems crazy to evict people."
Supervisor Susan Gorin concurred, stating, "I would like to consider a moratorium on evictions" until new policies could be developed.
Supervisor David Rabbitt, on April 6, summed up the supervisor majority opinion when he concluded, "I did hear support for a moratorium to make sure no one gets kicked out of a structure that fails to meet a standard but is safe."
Permit Sonoma has stated that it is up to Supervisors to determine policy. However, in the staff recommendations report for tomorrows meeting, the agency included provisions that if followed, would negate the directives made by Hopkins, Gorin, and Rabbitt. The most problematic of these staff recommendations, is the prescription that every modest dwelling unit be attached to a permanent septic system or municipal sewer system. Allowing waterless toilets is a major step forward, but this provision will make little difference if tiny homes and trailers are still required to connect to septic systems.
Septic tanks are notoriously expensive to improve or replace, which is generally necessary if a property owner wishes to connect additional units to one. Fortunately, there is a ready made solution to the issue of septic connections. Fire survivors who are rebuilding, but currently living in trailers on their property are given a "hold and haul" option for their waste water disposal. This option allows units to be connected to an above ground tank, which is then pumped regularly. While Permit Sonoma does not recommend "hold and haul" tanks for alternative housing, they are listed as an option in the report.
Leo Chyi, the District Director to Supervisor Hopkins, noted that the recommendations in the staff advisory, "doesn't appear to speak to curbing citations from Permit Sonoma that result in eviction. Following staff recommendations would be a small piece of progress but leave a long way to go still."
While the recommendations put forward by staff do not go nearly far enough to protect people living in alternative housing, the Supervisors do not need to follow them.
With a majority vote, Supervisors could do more to permit affordable market rate housing than has ever been accomplished in Sonoma County history-and end what amounts to an inhumane code enforcement's eviction war on the poor.
Contact your Supervisor
The most important thing that each Sonoma County citizen can do is to directly contact those elected and paid to represent us. Ask that they place this issue on the agenda and vote for a moratorium or major policy change on Permit Sonoma's vacate orders that result in evictions of low income renters from trailers, tiny homes and other safe affordable dwellings.
The Board of Supervisors office phone number for all districts is (707) 565-2241 Ask to speak with your supervisor and leave a message or speak to a staffer. Or you can send an email.
Listing of supervisors:
Susan Gorin, 1st District (East Santa Rosa, Kenwood, Sonoma)
Email: Susan.Gorin@sonoma-county.org
David Rabbitt, 2nd District (Cotati, Penngrove, Petaluma)
Email: David.Rabbitt@sonoma-county.org
Chris Coursey, 3rd District (Santa Rosa / Rohnert Park)
Email: district3@sonoma-county.org
James Gore, 4th District (Windsor to Cloverdale)
Email: district4@sonoma-county.or
Lynda Hopkins, 5th District (Santa Rosa, Sebastopol, Annapolis)
Chris Coursey
David Rabbitt
James Gore
Lynda Hopkins
Sonoma County Supervisors
Stop All Government Evictions
Susan Gorin
Supervisors Face Historic Affordable Housing Vote to Permit Trailers & Tiny Homes Sept 27 meeting to consider policy recommendation extending temp housing designation to county's lowest cost housing https%3A%2F%2Fwww.sonomaindependent.org%2Fpermit-sonoma-wants-to-continue-eviction-war-on-poor-supervisors-must-end-it%2F">
Supervisors Face Historic Affordable Housing Vote to Permit Trailers & Tiny Homes Sept 27 meeting to consider policy recommendation extending temp housing designation to county's lowest cost housing">
Jonathan Greenberg
Jonathan Greenberg is editor and owner of the award winning Sonoma Independent website, which serves the public interest with insight, solutions and advocacy. Jonathan is an investigative financial journalist with 40 years of experience with national publications, including Forbes, The Washington Post, The New York Times, New York, Town & Country. Mother Jones and The New Republic. During the past few years, Jonathan wrote four of the most widely-read exposes about Donald Trump's career published in the Washington Post. Jonathan was the notorious Forbes 400 reporter who taped two long calls in 1984 in which Trump pretended to be John Barron. Jonathan's Washington Post expose about this was the subject of monologues on Colbert, the Daily Show and Seth Meyers. Jonathan has appeared live on a dozen major news shows, including on CNN with Chris Cuomo, Erin Burnett and Don Lemon, on MSNBC with Ari Berber and Ali Velshi, and NPR's On the Media. A fuller bio and links to Jonathan's work can be found at JonathanGreenberg.com. Jonathan is a new media entrepreneur and was the founder of Gist.com, an acclaimed Web 1.0 company that won the first annual Webby Awards in 1997. In 2006, Jonathan founded Progressive Source Communications, the parent company of The Sonoma Independent. Progressive Source is a public interest communications company that creates multimedia websites, videos and digital advocacy campaigns that build public awareness of solutions that serve the common good.
Posted by Tim Ryan - February 4, 2022 0
122 Shares Facebook 122 Twitter LinkedIn Email On January 25, during a Sonoma County's Board of Supervisors meeting to set…
Five 2016 Election Results that Prove Sonoma County is ALREADY Great! Historic Local Victories for Women, Library, Hospital & Organic Ag as Voters Reject the New Normal
Posted by Jonathan Greenberg - November 12, 2016 0
67 Shares Facebook 67 Twitter LinkedIn Email During these bewildering post-election days, a number of friends have told me that…
The Kind of County We Don't Want The problem wasn't that THEY came, but rather that WE were essentially evicted
Posted by Lynda McDaniel - May 9, 2016 0
25 Shares Facebook 25 Twitter LinkedIn Email It used to be such a nice place to live—a working-class town in…
County Plan to Build Administrative Campus at Sears Site Falls Apart Under Public Pressure Costly project stopped by Supervisors Hopkins and Rabbitt after outcry on Social media, coverage in independent news
Posted by Sonoma Independent Editorial Board - April 19, 2022 0
131 Shares Facebook 131 Twitter LinkedIn Email After months of pushing the project forward with little input from the public,…
Uplifting Schwarzenegger Video Speaks from the Heart to the Heartland Compares Capitol riot to Nazi violence & wishes Biden success in uniting America
Posted by Jonathan Greenberg - January 10, 2021 0
Far from preaching to the choir, the historic videos message carries a compelling question to Republicans, Independents and Trump supporters.
Trump's Attack on Biden's Faith Echoes Norman Peale's Anti-Catholic Campaign Against Kennedy