Jazz In Print - Periodicals, Books, Newspapers, etc...
DownBeat Reader's Poll - Vote For Hank Mobley
Started by bresna, 16 Jul 2018
170 posts in this topic
bresna
Location:Maine Seacoast
Posted 16 Jul 2018
The latest DownBeat reader's poll is up at their website: http://downbeat.com/?ACT=30&ad_id=428
If I could ask my fellow organissimo denizens for some help, could you please go there and simply click on Hank Mobley for the Hall Of Fame?
You don't need to vote for any of the other categories, just Hall Of Fame. Just click through the rest of them and submit the survey.
I'd really love to see Mobley get in. I believe that he is overdue.
Steve Reynolds
Funkateer
Location:Wayne, NJ
Incredible that Hank isn't in the Down Beat HOF
I don't think I want to see who is in whatever poor excuse it must be if the best hard bop tenor saxophonist who ever lived isn't in there
Scott Dolan
Yeah, that is pretty odd. I guess he's the Ray Guy of Jazz.
Justin V
Their polls jumped the shark for me when Wynton Marsalis made the Hall of Fame before the likes of Benny Golson, Jimmy Heath and literally dozens of others (like Mobley) who actually deserve it.
Just voted for Hank -- though I'm more surprised that Sam Rivers isn't already in their hall of fame.
Eh, I'm not. Sam Rivers is kind of a forgotten figure in Jazz, IMO.
Voted for Hank.
kh1958
Location:Dallas, Texas
I voted for Jaki Byard.
erwbol
Voted for Hank as well.
Team Green here, sorry, but thanks for the headsup!
GA Russell
Location:Raleigh, NC
Any suggestions for any other votes besides HOF?
Larry Kart
Location:Highland Park, Il.
Roscoe Mitchell, composer, soprano; Denny Zeitlin, pianist; Mary Halvorsen, guitarist; Wadada Leo Smith, trumpet; Jeb Bishop, trombone, were among my choices.
More amazing that Roscoe & Wadada are not in
or Sam Rivers
glad you think so highly of Jeb Bishop, Larry
I always search out recordings that feature him. On my rare opportunities to see him live, he's always been outstanding.
I posted this mainly for those who would normally not participate in this poll at all. I hope you can just click through a few screens to help get Hank Mobley into the Hall. I am not trying to twist any arms here. Feel free to vote for whoever you want. But if you weren't planning to vote at all...
What does Hank get if he wins?
14 minutes ago, JSngry said:
Hank gets overdue recognition.
We get Hank Mobley in the Jazz Hall Of Fame.
clifford_thornton
Location:Hudson Valley
I put Bill Dixon in, although his music goes beyond 'jazz.' But I do enjoy Hank Mobley and am surprised he hasn't been inducted already.
Location:Shawnee Mission, Kansas
Another vote for Hank. I didn't realize the poll was online.
Ed Swinnich
Location:Under extremely deep cover
I cast my vote for Hank. He deserves the recognition. One of my favorites.
Wanted to vote for Hank
had to vote for the *great* Fred Anderson
ejp626
Do they only take one from the readers? Or the top 5? It seems ludicrous that Grant Green isn't in there already...
Gheorghe
Location:Austria
Though I´m sure that most of my favourite musicians - and Mobley sure is one of them - have died (most of them still lived when I got my DB magazines monthly) , I think those halls of fame made sens when the musician who was voted was still alive and active. Like when Dexter Gordon made it into the hall of fame right after he had returned to the states. I remember that. Dexter was on the cover photo.
Don't know if I've told this story before, but when I was Down Beat's assistant editor in 1969 and Dan Morgenstern was the editor, with both of us having votes in the DB Hall of Fame critics poll version, we discovered that Pee Wee Russell, who had died that year, and Jack Teagarden, who had died in 1964, were just a few votes apart when all votes except our own (yet to be cast) votes had been tallied. At that time, maybe still today, each critic had three votes in each category of the poll, and the votes were weighted in some way, depending on whether one had assigned a musician to first, second, or third place on one's ballot. Don't know which of us came up with the idea, but it occurred to one of us that because the vote totals for Pee Wee and Teagarden were so close, because neither man might not make to the top for a good while (Pee Wee 's vote total having risen a good deal that year in large part because of his recent death), and finally because Pee Wee and Teagarden were such a natural pair to enter the HOP together, we decided to adjust our votes so that Pee Wee and Teagarden would tie for the HOF that year and enter together.
mikeweil
totally tjaderized
Location:Wiesbaden, Germany
Posted 17 Jul 2018 (edited)
5 hours ago, Larry Kart said:
...... we decided to adjust our votes so that Pee Wee and Teagarden would tie for the HOF that year and enter together.
There are so many jazz greats whose music I love on the list it is hard to make a choice for the HOF ...
Edited 17 Jul 2018 by mikeweil
sonnymax
Location:Waltham, MA
11 hours ago, Kevin Bresnahan said:
Meddling in an election? Are you sure your last name isn't Brezhnevhan?
Go To Topic Listing Jazz In Print - Periodicals, Books, Newspapers, etc...