Prev Page SYTYCD Top 16 Results Music
Janette And Jason Are Dating! Next Page
SYTYCD Top 16 Results Thoughts
I'm so excited that we have more control over the dancers' fates. That being said…I have NO idea how this vote's gonna go and it makes me so nervous. I particularly don't want to lose Peter.
My thoughts, as they happen –
-Cat looks super dramatic again tonight, but is being more her charming, appealing goofball self again. Yay!
-LOVED Dave Scott's Top 16 group routine. I particularly noticed Elleanore and Legacy and then, near the end, Ryan and Peter. And, of course, Noelle.
-Nigel's being a bit petulant about America's voting results and the judges not getting to eliminate who they want to eliminate. Hmmm…I wonder who they're talking about?
-Adam's pretty funny when he says, "I contemplated not showing up tonight." Now, I wonder what he's talking about. Stop being so coy, boys!
-Not surprised that it's Elleanor and Ryan in the Bottom 3, but I am worried. I don't want to lose Elleanor in particular.
-Dominic doing a K-Mart spot about dance moves – great! I suspect he learned a lot of his hosting skills from Cat, his favorite. ;")
-Crap, Peter and Pauline are in the Bottom 3. This can't be good.
-It's down to Karen/Kevin and Mollee/Nathan. Just as some of our readers predicted, Karen/Kevin are in the Bottom 3, due to Mollee/Nathan's enormous tween (and other) fan support. Karen is visibly pissed. I think both her and Kevin needed the wake up call to connect more with their audience, but it's gotta suck to be in the Bottom 3 when you obviously danced better than another couple. HOWEVER, I do not think that Nathan deserved Nigel's rant at all. I think Nathan made a light-hearted joke last night to diffuse an uncomfortable moment. I don't think he's going to ignore the feedback of the judges. Whether he and Mollee can grow in the short span of this t.v. show remains to be seen.
-The Alvin Ailey dancers were incredibly talented, but that was a kinda boring performance. I hated the song.
-The solos were all a'right, but not so hot. I enjoyed Peter's the best, but had a sinking feeling that the judges would continue to believe that Ryan and Kevin are more versatile. It'd be really nice to if we could see how Peter grows on the show.
-Nigel's going on yet another rant about how none of the solos were good enough. He's got a point about how Season 5 and their Top 4 are still strong in our minds, but why does he have to be so aggressively whiny? "Listen up and shut up!" ? Really, Nigel? Really?
-Awww, Pauline's cut. I would've been fine to lose Karen, but I'm glad we're keeping Elleanore.
-SO devastated that we lost Peter tonight! That was not the right decision. I actually think Kevin should've gone home. I was so excited to see what Peter was going to do on the show. I'm gonna go console myself with Glee!
November 11, 2009 I Written By Emilie
Filed Under: So You Think You Can Dance So You Think You Can Dance Discussion So You Think You Can Dance Season 6
Tags:Adam Shankman Alvin Ailey Ashleigh Di Lello Cat Deely Channing Cooke Dominic Sandoval Elleanore Scott Jakob Karr Karen Hauer Kathryn McCormick Kevin Hunte Legacy Perez Mollee Gray Nathan Trasoras Nigel Lythgoe Noelle Marsh Pauline Mata Peter Sabasino Russell Ferguson Ryan DiLello So You Think You Can Dance first performance So You Think You Can Dance top 20 Top 20 thoughts Victor Smalley
42 responses to "SYTYCD Top 16 Results Thoughts"
# Amanda commented on November 11, 2009:
Comcast sucks yet again I was having issues. I only had sound for the first half but cut out when Cat revealed Kathryn's fate….aahhh just my luck. Also I missed the opening number and the Ailey dancers which I really wanted to see it too.
I miss Dominic thing too and who could forget the crush he had on Cat. Cat had a bug in her hair of course it was her hair clip. Nigel was upset about Karen and Kevin, I have to say I agreed with him. I understand that people don't like when he gets tough but sometimes you have to be tough to get the best out of dancers.
# Amie commented on November 11, 2009:
Mollee and Nathan must grow up or be gone. I swear that this result makes me wonder if SYTYCD is a victim of that bad website, "Vote For the Worst" – arrrgh. At least Cat looked lovely tonight – not like some demented lizard woman. And Karen looked amazing – her hair was beautiful! I don't think that the dancing has been that great, so far and the stage plus some lackluster choreo = unhappy girl.
# Johnny Mar commented on November 11, 2009:
Okay, I realize that NIgel is executive producer and he's not going anywhere, but he needs to go. Obviously this won't happen, but I would at least like an attitude adjustment. Obviously season 5's solos were incredible and still fresh in our minds, but that was what 2, 3 months ago? I don't believe this top 20 is less talented, they just have it tougher than the other seasons. If Nigel is going to argue about talent and solos then why doesn't he ever make reference to season 3? Now, I didn't necessarily like season 3, but I cannot deny the fact that Danny, Neil, Sabra etc… were some of the most talented individuals the show has ever seen.
The comments to Nathan also bothered me. First, Nigel says "nathan isn't learning anything." Learning anything? This is the first week he hasn't been amazing so he hasn't had a situation where he's had to necessarily prove himself. Nigel also says that Nathan's comments were "juvenille." I thought Nathan and Mollee both knew that their routine was lacking so Nathan was just trying to shed some light on a crappy situation. They were just killed by the judges, so why not crack a joke. Nathan, I don't believe your comments were Juvenille or that you're not learning anything. I think he's fully aware that he isn't perfect.
On a positive note, the group routine was pretty good, and I thought the girls solos were good. The guys solos were a little 'ehh' with Ryan's backflip attempt and Kevin's very slow backflip. Peter surprised me, but it seemed that the judges weren't that impressed. Anyway, those are just my thoughts.
# kel commented on November 11, 2009:
What exactly did Nathan say last night? (Sorry for asking, I missed his performance last night). Did it really warrant Nigel's bad attitude? I was wondering what exactly was up his bum tonight…
# Emilie commented on November 11, 2009:
@Amanda: Yeah, he has to be tough on the dancers. But not on the audience! And no more whining from him. As an Executive Audience Member, I decree: No more whining, Nigel!
@Amie: I don't think SYTYCD is a victim of "Vote for the Worst." I think Mollee & Nathan have just found a strong, devote fan base who believe in them. I just hope they continue to learn and grow so that they'll deserve that fan base.
@Johnny Mar: Great points about the Season 3 dancers and tonight's solos.
@Kel: Oops! This clip actually cuts off right before Nigel's comments and Nathan's response, unfortunately. Can't find one that includes his comments. Basically, Nathan's said before the dance that he was gonna "be cool" in the dance. So when Nigel asked how he felt they'd done or something along those lines, Nathan hesitated and then joked, "I feel hot!" He meant the opposite of cool, as in he did a bad job. But I think Nigel just decided to feel disrespected and throw a tantrum. Nathan was being goofy and joking in an uncomfortable moment, in my opinion.
# Stephanie commented on November 11, 2009:
I am really disappointed with tonight's results. Peter was the one person I didn't want to loose, and I can't help but feel Nigel et. al. have some sort of tapper-hate. First, it took so long for Bianca to make it, and then she and her two fellow tappers are gone by week three? After performances that really weren't bad? I LIKED that quickstep, I really did! And why was the dance performance before the solos? The judges had no time at all to deliberate, which means that they'd made their minds before the show even began. Sigh. I'm starting to wish they'd kept SYTYCD in the summer. I don't like a lot of the changes I see.
Kel, I can't remember the exact wording, but essentially Nathan and Mollee were blasted for their crappy salsa performance, as they should've been. Towards the end of the judges comments, Nigel said that it was clear they were uncomfortable out there, or something to that effect. Cat turns to them and says, "well, how do you think you looked out there?" Nathan and Mollee paused, and after a short but awkward moment, Nathan said, "I think…I looked…HOT!" And everyone applauded and off they went. But, seriously, who expects an honest answer at that point?! He had thirty seconds to leave an impression on the voters' minds; an admission of incompetence isn't going to garner votes! Apparrantly Nigel wanted a soul-baring sob fest, though. Jackass.
Lol. Kel, Stephanie's right. That's *exactly* what went down. That was as good as video, Stephanie. ;") Especially the jackass part.
# Chelsea Rae commented on November 11, 2009:
I liked Peter too but I liked all three of the bottom guys and I had a feeling he and Pauline would be leaving. Certainly Nathan and Mollee should have been in the bottom, but what was with Nigel? I thought he was rude and it was uncalled for. Pitching a temper because you don't like the results is not fair and those solos were not amazing but they were not THAT bad!
What really irritated me for some reason (and yes this does show my bias)? Yes Kayla, Jeanine, and Brandon were fabulous dancers and soloists, but what was with the singleing out of Ade? I liked the guy and he made a good partner but he wasn't Travis or Danny.
@Chelsea Rae: I think it was mostly because Ryan's move kinda resembled Ade's, but wasn't as good.
# Rachel commented on November 11, 2009:
I was a little frustrated with Nigel's harsh words for Nathan tonight as well. Yes, N&M danced horribly last night, and you could tell when they were on stage tonight that they were both worried and very surprised to hear they made it through. Nigel basically told Nathan the only reason he was still there was that he was cute, just completely disregarding his first 2 weeks and the other group dances, which he's performed well in. Well Nigel, you've cast him in the top 20 knowing full well that he was going to appeal to teenage girls, and then you have the nerve to criticize him for it? Really? He knows he danced terribly, and i'm sure they'll dance better next week, but Nigel was acting like he was the downfall of the whole pairing. No criticism of Mollee whatsoever. I guess Nigel was still upset about the "I'm hot" comment. Whatever… i'm not surprised about the outcome tonight, although i would have preferred to see Karen & Kevin go.
And whats with all the Ade love? I wasn't a fan of his and i didn't think he was anywhere near Brandon's level of talent last year. And he certainly wasn't a Travis or Will, or even Danny
# Kenna commented on November 11, 2009:
I just want to say that I was completely disgusted with Nigel tonight. Like everyone said, Nathan was just trying to cut the tension last night, but attacking him on stage, live, in front of millions of people tonight was wrong and IMMATURE on Nigel's part. If you paid close attention, Nathan almost started crying on stage. His eyes were full.
And then when Nigel yelled at the audience to "shut up" and he wasn't kidding, he was practically saying his opinion is right and ours is wrong.
Nigel has become, in my opinion, way too big for his britches.
@Rachel I get the Ade love, then again it helps to see him in person.
@Emilie When was Nigel harsh on the audience? Oh if you are talking about the comment about voting for Nathan based on looks alone…then again I side with Nigel. Don't get me wrong I love Nathan but both him and Mollee were the worst of the night for me.
I said it before I have no problems with the judges. If you don't want to listen to them then hit the mute button.
@Rachel: I'm with you on the disregard for Nathan doing some amazing dancing to get to where he's at and Nigel kinda disregarding that cause he was disappointed in Nathan's comment. Though, doesn't he know by now that being "mean" to a dancer is only guaranteeing them votes? I get the Ade love, though. He really grew on me and I felt like he tended to disappear much more completely into his character and dance, whereas I think that often hurt Brandon.
@Kenna: I'd say someone should spank him, but he'd probably like that too much. 🙂
@Amanda: You're totally right about Ade in person. ::fans herself:: He was so sweet and funny and cute. I was talking more about Nigel telling the audience to shut up and that they were wrong if they disagreed with the judges…ahem…him…
@ Emilie you are probably 100% right. he is a creepy old man. haha
i love how Adam, at the beginning of the show after Nigel's rant about America should vote because of dancing yada yada, and was like. "this is america's FAVORITE dancer, so will mistakes be made based on the best dancing being voted? yes. but at the end of the day. its america's choice."
loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee adam.
@Kenna: Adam rocks. Yes. Period. End of sentence. He's a breath of fresh air and my favorite of all the decisions that the SYTYCD producers have made this season. Well….I'm kinda partial to their Top 20. Except, I think the judges have been sending some of the wrong dancers home.
# Mel commented on November 11, 2009:
I'm surprised at the results, and tonight was quite a tense night!
As much as I'm bitter over Nathan/Mollee being safe due in no part to their lackluster performance the other night, it was Ameriker who voted that way.
I'm sad to see Pauline and Peter go. I though Kevin should have gone, and I personally would have wanted to see Mollee go, but out of the three bottom girls, I'm just glad that Ellenore is safe!
Thanks for the info guys, I am visiting the 'rents and they don't have dvr! 🙁 I don't know how I ever lived without it. I wish a video of the incident would come out sometime… I seriously think Nigel needs to get off of his high horse because a lot of people seem disappointed in his extremely immature statements. I felt so embarrassed for poor Nathan! He wasn't great, but he did not deserve that live verbal beatdown.
# Lauren commented on November 11, 2009:
Nigel has neverrr bothered me in the last 5 seasons, until this one. He is SO immature and SO arrogant. HOW COULD HE BASH NATHAN LIKE THAT?! I'm not Nathan's biggest fan, but I don't dislike him. And his comment the other night WAS harmless. He was making a silly joke because he knew his performance wasn't great.. EVERYONE has SOME bad performance, and they've never bashed anyone that hard before. Nathan IS an amazing dancer or he wouldn't have made it to top 20… NIGEL PUT HIM THERE!!! DON'T COMPLAIN ABOUT IT IF YOU'RE THE ONE WHO PUT HIM THERE!!! SO RIDICULOUS….. and Karen? REALLY? with the attitude like "i'm too good, i shouldn't be here." like yea you're good, but you don't need to be NASTY. when pauline got sent home karen barely hugged her and was making a face and pauline was soooo sweet. so annoying. i hate nigel. he's a fool.
# Shannon commented on November 11, 2009:
@ Kenna: EXACTLY.
Wasn't it NIGEL himself saying all last season how it's all about "America's FAVORITE dancer"?! Um… hello! Of course Nathan and Mollee weren't going to be in the bottom 3. Anyone could've told him that.
Now, I'm not saying they SHOULDN"T have been in the bottom. N&M's was certainly the worst of the night. But, again… it's up to the votes who is in the bottom and who isn't. And if we're supposed to vote for our FAVORITE dancer, I don't understand how the judges can say that America voted WRONG.
I also think it should've been Kevin to go home tonight, NOT Peter.
@Emilie lol. Nigel does have to tell them to be quiet but I would to so the contestants can actually hear what he has to say. Until we hit the top 10 they still decide who goes home. I think he gets upset when the solo's are up to par. Solo's can make or break you in the competition…so the judges that you want to stay and leave some blood on the dance floor.
show*
# James G. commented on November 11, 2009:
I agree with the general consensus of the comments. Nigel was way off base tonight, and I wonder what has gotten into him to take a Nathan's tension-diffusing joke and blow it way out of proportion. He humiliated Nathan on national television. It doesn't matter that Nathan and Mollee should have been in the bottom 3. Just as bad, he acted like Nathan was the sole reason the Mollee/Nathan salsa dance was poor, when Mollee shared just as much of the blame. Nathan has proven himself capable so far, and he just didn't deserve that. I really hope Nigel has the decency to apologize for his comments next week.
I still believe Nigel is getting like this because of Evan from last season (who I admit shouldn't have gone as far as he did, but I digress). It's very clear he was not happy that Evan made it to the top 4. He seems dead-set on trying to avoid that situation from happening again. That's the theory I'm working with for now.
Karen needs to get over herself, and the judges need to stop inflating her ego with overdone praise. She's good, but hasn't been stellar.
I can understand Pauline leaving, although I think Peter left too soon. Peter showed potential in the Wade Robson routine, and I really think a tapper should have been allowed to go deeper. I think Kevin should have left, since his growth has been marginal. Additionally, just about everything he does, someone else in recent memory has done better. Russell does better krump/hard-hitting hip-hop, Legacy does better tricks, Phillip (season 5) did better pop and locking, etc. He's a jack-of-all-trades, master-of-none. I don't find that exciting to watch on a show like this.
I'm glad the Ryan/Ellenore partnership will last another week. I hope they can regain some ground.
# Ryan S commented on November 11, 2009:
It's pretty obvious to me that Nigel is just disappointed with the level of performance so far from the top 20. And it's starting to bubble over in his critique.
As a teacher / instructor myself I find I get in the same mood when I see the talented individuals I work with not living up to their potential.
I do think though that Nigel is very close to crossing the line from "motivating" through some rather harsh critique to being disrespectful to the remaining dancers.
I've got a feeling he'll do some self-reflecting as he IS a professional and we'll see the warmer / kinder Nigel back in form next week. Or at least I hope so.
Even Adam who's usually bright and sunny seemed a bit underwhelmed tonight…and to be honest so am I. Season 6 was looking to be quite amazing but so far not a single routine has had the "wow" factor for me that we've usually seen by now. (Although the frog / princess routine came VERY close for me)
# ahs commented on November 11, 2009:
I had to miss the show tonight, and it seems like maybe it was a good thing? I'm really kind of glad I wasn't subjected to all the Nigel ranting. I want to like Nigel!
I'm surprised Peter was sent home 🙁 Did the judges say if it was unanimous or not? I know Nigel wanted to keep Bianca last week but Mary and Adam outvoted him. Wonder if that happened again. (Did he do all the ranting at the end of the show or was it throughout?? If it was at the end I'd guess it was because he was outvoted and losing the last tapper, but if not, I can make no excuses for him, lol.)
@ahs: It was unanimous. :'(
# Margaret commented on November 12, 2009:
wow, I go to a meeting for an hour and this thread gets huge! It's been interesting to read everyone's comments. Nigel did seem to be quite tense tonight, probably because of how up and down the season has been so far. I don't mind when he tells the audience to be quiet so the dancers can hear him, but I didn't like how forceful he was when he told them to shut up. It just felt like overkill. I know he blew up at nathan last night, slightly warranted, but it felt like he forgot he was talking to an 18 year old kid (the youngest of the top 10 guys). this is a family show!
my quick thoughts on the night:
what a fantastic group routine! dave scott rocks, and it was definitely one of the most original group routines i've seen, with the music, the costumes, and the choreography. i would put it right up there with some of the best group routines ever done on the show. ramalama from s2 still takes the cake for me though, but i digress.
glad to see the strong partnerships getting rewarded (jakob/ashleigh, kathryn/legacy, and i'd even put noelle/russell in there) and for ryan/ellenore and kevin/karen to get another week together)
nathan/mollee just confuse me, i think they're both very talented, and everyone knows that it was their fans that got them through last night. i'm interested to see how they bounce back next week.
i really like the karen/kevin partnership, though i prefer him over her. i'd love to see them pull contemporary or broadway, something way out of both of their comfort zones next week.
it was definitely a rough night, but hopefully all the dancers learned from it and can come back strong next week.
@Margaret – I agree! Nothing can touch Ramalama! Definitely the best (well, my favorite) group routine ever! Though my close runner-up is S4's The Dance! 🙂
I just watched the Dave group piece and it was tremendous!
# Christine commented on November 12, 2009:
lol Emilie I'm sad too, but that comment about consoling yourself with Glee made me laugh. Soooo true!
I was hoping Pauline would be in the top 10. I think if Billy Bell was her partner she would have been. You could tell during the Wade Robson performance judging, Nigel tried to go against his peers and say "well I certainly hope they stick around" i think more for Peter the tapper. But ARRRRGH!!! I was hoping Kevin would go. If it was between Karen or Pauline I'd want to keep Pauline. It's really …an unfortunate situation. I was thinking Victor and Channing to be cut since I don't really think they add anything to the show.
I think all three girls were top 10 material, but out of the 3 dancers (once there are top 5 girls hypothetically), Pauline could be considered a victim of the unlucky draw. It's like cutting Jesus in S3 because he was up against Neil and Danny. Jesus was a wonderful dancer but put him next to those two (top 2 males), you could tell he was the one to go. Sadly his kind spirit wasn't enough for America to vote and personality was not enough for the judges.
I never thought either Peter or Pauline would win, but I thought they'd make it to the top 10 🙁
Can they just take the top 20 on tour lol?
I don't know what it is about Nigel this season too. It's like they see something viewers at home can't see. I love Adam as a judge. He gives the most honest and constructive criticism without being mean. I understand that not everyone is going to be nice about giving criticism, but Nigel just gives his opinion on what he liked/hated, what needed work (but not specifically HOW to improve, and is it me or do you think he's jealous of Ryan's upper body? lols…just a thought.
Why do you think he asked Dmitry to cover it up so much?
man… i haven't even watched the results show but reading the blogs and spoilers just makes me sad….
*watches Glee too*
# Kevin commented on November 12, 2009:
I wasn't bothered by Nigel's comments. I know everyone fixates on the "favorite" not "best" dancer. But I think the goal o fthe show/voting audience shoudl be "best". That used to be the tag line, bu tthey changed it becasue America often get's it wrong. But I still think that should be the goal and that the judges should stress that.
I also enjoyed the group number. But Tyce's "Send in the Clowns" and Travis' "Let it Rock" last season are probably my last two.
I think Nigel owes Nathan an apology next week, i hope he cools down and can think rationally next week. Do you guys think his comments at the beginning of the show "about someone being cut if they were in the bottom" were directed toward Nathan/Mollee or Victor/Channing? Even if N&M were in the bottom i have a hard time believing he would cut them.
And how about Dave Scott back with a vengeance this season! Last nights dance was amazing, and the caveman dance from ep 1 was the best hip hop in a while!
# Hakim commented on November 12, 2009:
i agree with mel. i wish mollee had gone. she's too immature. she's a good dancer but she doesn't have what it takes to sell the dance. seriously lacking character.
im really not liking where SYTYCD is going. its failing across the board. music editing and mixing is bad. they need to bring back guest judges. adam's great but a difference of opinion is better. don't get me started with the camera angles. can hardly watch the dance properly.
im gonna get knocked down because of this.. but i think ade dosnt get the credit he deserves. he's so much more innovative and creative a dancer compared to brandon + he has the technique to boot. brandon is really good but he's sooo jazz 101.
# Mayor commented on November 12, 2009:
I think that Nigel was trying to imply that Nathan has the potential and he expects more from him…..pushing him. He seemed to be hinting that if Nathan and Mollee were in the bottom, they would have saved Nathan. Mollee needs to go. Poor Pauline – she has had one situation after another, first Billy left because he was ill, then she had to perform with Brandon with 1 1/2 days of rehearsal, then she gets Phillip, and finally Peter. She didn't have any chance to develop a connection with any partner!!!
Nigel has apologized via Twitter for his comments both on the performance show and last night, and I'm glad, he let his emotions get the best of him at the performance show, Nathan is an 18 year old kid!
@Hakim, I'm not Mollee's biggest fan either, but I'm willing to give her a week or two more, if she doesn't start to live up to the potential I know she has, then I'll be thinking it's her time to go.
I hope that the solos improve from last night. I agree that Ade had some awesome solos last year, but what about Travis and Danny and Benji and Nick and Blake?! I mean, Blake did a backflip and physically changed direction in his top 6 solo! A post from me should be coming up today that has that clip, it's incredible.
@Christine: Hey, maybe they'll bring Peter on Glee! He can be the football player we haven't seen much of yet… Can he sing, too? I hate to stereotype, but Italian? With those blues eyes? He *has* to sing! Lol. I think Top 20 would be a morass of dancers and we wouldn't get to see much of our favorites. BUT, I appreciate the sentiment. I want Peter back, anyway, anyhow.
@Kevin: But *how* can America find the "best" dancer when we'll never agree on who that is? John and I think alike a lot, but even we were in disagreement last night. He felt more saddened by Pauline, I felt more saddened by Peter. What does "best" mean? To me, it means someone who makes me want to watch them dance. Or dance with them. 🙂
@Rachel: I think he will apologize. Beneath it all, Nigel is a classy guy. He Twittered that he got carried on. Ditto on Dave Scott!!
@Hakim: Man, I love Mollee, but I'm starting to really agree with you there about her maturity. She's the same age as Jeanine was on the show! Jeanine can really smolder. Mollee doesn't know how to be anything but cute. And maybe it's wrong to be mad at a young girl for being cute instead of sexy, but I don't think that's an inappropriate expectation of a dancer. Hear ya on Ade/Brandon.
@Mayor: You're so right about Pauline. It sucks she never got a chance to form a strong partnership.
# Rant about "Favorite" and "Best," Peter and Evan | Pure So You Think You Can Dance pingbacked on November 12, 2009:
[…] And you want to watch him dance, which I just used as my definition of the "best," in the comments here. I think we'd be lying to ourselves if we tried to find America's "Best" […]
wow, I totally forgot that Jeanine and Mollee are the same age! You would never guess when you watch them dance, plus Jakob is 19!
I did feel for Pauline, she kind of got shafted, having to change partners every time.
@Emilie, I'm with you, I was sad to see Peter go. He had a quality about it, where he just made me smile whenever I saw him dance. Yes, he wasn't the most technically gifted, but he worked so hard. He did so well in the Wade Robson piece, I wish we could have seen him for a couple more weeks. But I think he got stuck in a Jesus from S3-type situation. Jesus left simply because the other 2 guys in the bottom were Neil and Danny, and it was week 3 (wow that's ironic) and it was pretty obvious Neil and Danny weren't going anywhere.
# Kayla commented on November 12, 2009:
I thought Ellenore's solo was great! I loved it! I was so surprised to hear Nigel bashing all the solos. I thought it was clever and unique. I feel like they go back and forth on what they are looking for in solos. Maybe i just don't have that eye that sees what they see. Because I can love a solo and they will hate it and vise versa. I thought Peter's was a lot better than Ryan's. Ryan seemed so frantic and desperate with that cheesy smile across his face.
# Ms. D commented on November 12, 2009:
Did anybody consider that Nigel's frustration with Nathan might not have begun with this week's performance?
This is the kid who tried out a season early, fully knowing the rules, hoping they wouldn't apply to him… so it's not a stretch that he may not be the most humble person off the set this season.
I thought Nigel's delivery was wrong, but his content was right. I'm glad he apologized, but I hope his message isn't lost. I like Nathan, and fully expect him to make the Top 10… but I would like to see him grow as well.
@Ms. D – That's possible. Although that didn't seem to turn Nigel off Brandon last season. He was… what? I want to say 15 the first time he auditioned (S1)?
@Margaret, i love them too!! especially love danny, Allison and blake!! they are ahh-mazing. 😀 havnt seen Blake clips for awhile now… gonna check them out again.
Top - Home
SYTYCD Top 14 Results Thoughts ...
Top 20 Performance Thoughts ...
SYTYCD Top 18 Performance Thoughts ...