Family sues Facebook after murder of Robert Godwin Sr. recorded, posted on social network
Posted 9:15 pm, January 30, 2018, by AP Wire Service
CLEVELAND, Ohio — The family of a slain Cleveland man believes Facebook could have done more to prevent his murder, according to a lawsuit filed earlier this month.
The killing of Robert Godwin, Sr., 74, was recorded and made viewable on the social network last April.
The family alleges in its lawsuit that Facebook is responsible for the wrongful death of Godwin due to its negligence. The lawsuit, filed in Cuyahoga County Clerk of Courts on January 19, says Facebook acted with "intentional, willful, malicious, in bad faith and in reckless disregard for the rights of Mr. Godwin."
Steve Stephens, the man who killed Godwin, announced his intent to kill someone on the platform prior to Godwin's murder, the complaint states. Stephens recorded the shooting and uploaded it to Facebook.
Stephens later logged onto Facebook Live, its livestreaming tool, and described the attack. He eventually killed himself after a police chase.
Cleveland murder suspect Steve Stephens kills himself in Erie, PA after pursuit
Video of the murder stayed up for more than two hours before it was removed by Facebook. The company, which relies on algorithms and human moderators to flag inappropriate and illegal content, has been criticized for the time it takes to respond to such content. Critics have said it relies too heavily on its users to flag posts.
At the time, the company said two hours had lapsed before users reported the video. Facebook disabled Stephens' account 23 minutes after that, the company said.
The complaint, filed by Godwin's daughter Debbie on behalf of the Godwin estate, names other Facebook-owned companies as defendants, including ad serving platform Atlas Solutions and CrowdTangle, a content discovery tool.
The lawsuit says Facebook has the ability to "cull, mine, analyze, and synthesize information" collected by individuals in real-time." Facebook "possessed this knowledge, and the ability to alert law enforcement, with more than sufficient time to act and prevent Robert Godwin, Sr.'s death," it asserts.
Related: Heath experts urge Facebook to shut down Messenger Kids
The issue of how Facebook moderates misuse of its platform has been a fraught one for the company.
Godwin's murder is just one example of how activity in the physical world can lead to questions about the responsibilities of digital platforms, and how what happens online could have real-life consequences. When a man murdered two Virginia journalists in August 2015, he filmed the crime and uploaded the video to Facebook and Twitter. Facebook and Twitter each suspended his accounts on their sites within minutes. In December 2016, a man investigating a conspiracy theory known as "Pizzagate" that was floated on a number of different websites fired several shots in a pizza restaurant in Washington, D.C. that was a subject of the false story.
"We want people to feel safe using Facebook, which is why we have policies in place prohibiting direct threats, attacks, serious threats of harm to public and personal safety and other criminal activity," Facebook associate general counsel Natalie Naugle said in a statement regarding the lawsuit. "We give people tools to report content that violates our policies, and take swift action to remove violating content when it's reported to us. We sympathize with the victim's family, who suffered such a tragic and senseless loss."
Facebook killer's mother says he 'snapped:' "I'm sorry it ended the way it did"
Ex-girlfriend of Facebook murder suspect meets with victim's family
Topics: Steve Stephens
Family of 2 Wisconsin brothers killed in Missouri files wrongful death lawsuit
$2M bond for man charged with capital murder after girlfriend's daughter, stuffed in backpack, died in car
Krispy Kreme owners donate $5 million to Holocaust survivors over family's Nazi past
Mississippi judge grants bail for man imprisoned 23 years despite 6 mistrials or overturned convictions
George Zimmerman sues Trayvon Martin's parents and others for $100 million
Michael Bell Sr. speaks out on Chrystul Kizer, facing life in prison in shooting of alleged trafficker
Ikea to pay $46 million to family of toddler crushed by dresser
Family of Ty'Rese West files federal civil rights lawsuit against Eric Giese, Mount Pleasant
Domino's worker sentenced for fatally stabbing 21-year-old boss; victim's family sues pizza chain
'He was going to snitch on me:' Life in prison for Fond du Lac man who shot his friend 16 times
At trial, attorneys for man accused of plotting mass shooting in Milwaukee will argue FBI entrapped him
Federal indictment filed against Matthew Neumann, brother after conviction in employees' deaths