Kinderkuchen for the FBI
This is mostly an opera blog. I am generally looking for the full theatrical experience.
Operas Seen
Salome at the Deutsche Oper, Berlin
Conductor: Alain Altinoglu
Production: Claus Guth
Herodes: Thomas Blondelle (tenor)
Herodias: Jeanne-Michèle Charbonnet (mezzo-soprano)
Salome: Allison Oakes (soprano)
Jochanaan: Michael Volle (baritone)
Narraboth: Attilio Glaser (tenor)
In case you hadn't noticed before, Salome is an abused child. She is sexually obsessed because she has had sex since she was small. My feeling is that this is absolutely so. There are many things about this production that I could not explain, but one thing seemed clear--Herod is sexually obsessed with Salome. You knew that. His wife knows it. Perhaps it is as I have long suspected, perhaps Herodias has suggested to Salome that Jochanaan would be better off dead. Certainly she has told Salome that he is ranting about her.
Jochanaan arises from a pile of clothing on the floor wearing only underpants. Blond girls of various ages come out and dress him. I cannot explain the pile of clothing, but the young girls seem skilled at dressing an adult man. From years of practice, perhaps. Salome begins in a nightgown and changes to a dress. The other girls remain in their night gowns. Clearly the girls represent Salome at various stages of her life.
At the end we are in a men's clothing store. I have no idea why. Clearly this is a regie opera. For no reason that I could possibly explain I enjoyed this. Strauss' Salome is generally about dancing, which here is only symbolic. Be aware that there are virtually no opera singers who can both sing Salome and actually dance. Our Salome danced with Herodes. Perhaps that is why he liked it.
I have seen Alain Altinoglu before only with Jonas Kaufmann. He conducted the Munich Manon Lescaut and the Met Werther. He was excellent then and now. The music was varied and interesting, expressing the changing atmosphere of the scenes as they progressed.
Alison Oakes seems a young woman, who nevertheless performed this difficult role well. Of the others, I especially liked.Jeanne-Michèle Charbonnet. For some reason there was a lot of twitching which appeared and disappeared. Men from the ballet stood around and then twitched. Jeanne-Michele twitched rather better than the others. IMHO:
Salome normally builds to an overwhelming climax, one where you also feel that someone should kill Salome. But in this production the perversity is blunted. She does not actually kiss the head of Jochanaan, though she says she does. She sings and then sort of wanders off. They don't kill her. The effect is unmelodramatic and seems more a successfully executed revenge on Herodes than an obsession.
Footnote: Michael Volle was the Sachs in the wonderful Die Meistersinger I saw at Salzburg.
Posted by Dr.B at 2:37 AM
Labels: +300, Alain Altinoglu, All Travel, Claus Guth, Europe, German, Germany, Michael Volle, Opera Only, Reader Favorites, Regie, Review Performance, Strauss R
Fan Magazine (745)
FavOpera (157)
Northern California (384)
ONew2Me (188)
Opera Only (814)
OperaUS (414)
Reader Favorites (827)
YouTube Singers (412)
Popular Posts This Year
Summer Festivals 2019
Salzburg Festival 20 July – 31 August 2019 Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart Idomeneo, Peter Sellars production with Russell Thomas Francesco Cil...
Whitsun 2020
Pauline Viardot-Garcia Cecilia Bartoli's Whitsun Festival at Salzburg in 2020 will be an homage to Pauline Viardot-Garcia (1821 –...
L'Italiana in Algeri from Salzburg
Conductor: Jean-Christophe Spinosi Production: Moshe Leiser and Patrice Caurier Isabella: Cecilia Bartoli (mezzo) Mustafa: Ildar ...
Franco Zeffirelli (1923-2019)
The great opera director, Franco Zeffirelli, has died at 96. He created productions in many opera houses, many of which are still runnin...
Poppea from Salzburg
Conductor: William Christie, with his ensemble Les Arts Florissants Director: Jan Lauwers Poppea: Sonya Yoncheva (Soprano) Nero...
Roberto Devereux in San Francisco
We were discussing the current queen of opera Sondra Radvanovsky, and I suggested we sing "God Save the Queen" when she came ou...
Garrick Ohlsson in Sacramento
Last night at Sacramento State University we had a treat when the pianist Garrick Ohlsson performed an all Brahms program for us. This i...
Director: Andreas Kreigenburg Conductor : Michele Mariotti et Łukasz Borowicz Marguerite de Valois, catholic queen : Lisette Oropesa ...
American Bach Soloists Matthew Passion
And last night I drove to Davis in the rain to see Bach's Saint Matthew Passion sung in German. For the beautiful work of the America...
Samson et Dalila in HD
Conductor................Mark Elder Production...............Darko Tresnjak Samson..................Roberto Alagna Dalila...............
Singers Added
AandJ means Anja Harteros and Jonas Kaufmann. Recently I added Luciano Pavarotti, Dolora Zajick, Sondra Radvanovsky, Pretty Yende, Alessand...
AandJ (13) Ailyn Pérez (21) Alessandro Corbelli (11) Alice Coote (11) Ana Maria Martinez (5) Angela Gheorghiu (44) Anita Rachvelishvili (9) Anja Harteros (39) Anna Caterina Antonacci (5) Anna Netrebko (229) Barbara Hannigan (10) Brandon Jovanovich (11) Bryan Hymel (5) Bryn Terfel (11) Cecilia Bartoli (237) Christine Goerke (4) Countertenors (34) Diana Damrau (15) Dolora Zajick (8) Elīna Garanča (38) Eric Owens (14) Eva-Maria Westbroek (16) Gerald Finley (12) Golda Schultz (4) Heidi Stober (12) Isabel Leonard (25) J'Nai Bridges (7) Jamie Barton (12) Javier Camarena (21) Jonas Kaufmann (214) Joyce DiDonato (97) Juan Diego Florez (43) Karita Mattila (11) Kristine Opolais (18) Lawrence Brownlee (19) Leah Crocetto (8) Lisette Oropesa (17) Luca Pisaroni (22) Ludovic Tézier (10) Maria Guleghina (12) Mariusz Kwiecien (10) Matthew Polenzani (24) Mezzo-sopranos (188) Michael Fabiano (21) Michael Volle (4) Nadine Sierra (23) Nina Stemme (22) Patricia Racette (14) Philippe Jaroussky (19) Piotr Beczala (24) Placido Domingo (56) Pretty Yende (8) René Pape (17) Roberto Alagna (24) Rolando Villazon (39) Russell Thomas (4) Sondra Radvanovsky (17) Sonya Yoncheva (7) Stéphanie d'Oustrac (4) Susan Graham (27) Tomasz Konieczny (5) Vesselina Kasarova (19) Vittorio Grigolo (11) Vivica Genaux (21) Željko Lučić (8)
Retired Singers
Christine Schaefer (11) Dawn Upshaw (21) Deborah Voigt (10) Dmitri Hvorostovsky (37) Ewa Podleś (7) Johann Botha (6) László Polgár (6) Leontyne Price (20) Lorraine Hunt (24) Luciano Pavarotti (10) Maria Callas (18) Memoriam (40) Natalie Dessay (61) Renée Fleming (80) Willard White (9)
Alain Altinoglu (3) Antonio Pappano (19) Christian Thielemann (7) Christoph Eschenbach (5) Daniel Barenboim (10) Daniele Gatti (5) Donald Runnicles (19) Fabio Luisi (14) Franz Welser-Möst (10) Giovanni Antonini (4) James Levine (35) Kirill Petrenko (8) Marc Minkowski (10) Marco Armiliato (15) Maurizio Benini (9) Nicholas McGegan (9) Nicola Luisotti (30) Nicole Paiement (11) Nikolaus Harnoncourt (8) Patrick Summers (13) Philippe Jordan (5) Riccardo Chailly (6) Riccardo Muti (17) Simon Rattle (6) Valery Gergiev (13) William Christie (7) Yannick Nézet-Séguin (10) Zubin Mehta (4)
Directors / Producers
Alexander Pereira (6) Bartlett Sher (10) Brian Staufenbiel (10) Claus Guth (11) David Alden (5) David Gockley (5) David McVicar (18) Francesca Zambello (10) Franco Zeffirelli (9) Laurent Pelly (14) Leiser & Caurier (7) Lotfi Mansouri (6) Michael Mayer (3) Otto Schenk (4) Peter Sellars (24) Richard Eyre (5) Robert Carsen (11) Stefan Herheim (3) Willy Decker (4)
Locations and Venues
All Travel (245) American Bach Soloists (14) Austria (76) France (38) Germany (61) Great Britain (97) Italy (43) Los Angeles Opera (7) Metropolitan Opera (231) New Mexico (53) New York (24) Opera Parallèle (10) Sacramento (153) San Francisco Opera (146) SF Bay Area (222) Washington (11) West Edge Opera (19) Zurich Opera (38)
Single Operas
Aida (8) Arabella (5) Barbiere (5) Carmen (10) Cav/Pag (5) Chénier (10) Clemenza (5) Cosi (8) DonCarl (9) DonG (8) Elixir (6) FaustAll (13) Flute (5) Girl (5) Giulio (7) IlTrova (10) LaBo (13) Lohengrin (6) Lucia (9) Lulu (7) Mac (5) ManLes (15) Manon (4) Norma (11) Nozze (14) Onegin (8) Pique (3) Porgy (6) Rigo (11) Rosenk (19) Schicchi (4) Tosca (13) Traviata (19) Tristan (7) Troyens (4) Turan (10) Walküre (9)
Vocal Topics
About Phrasing (99)
About Singing (84)
Advice to Composers (17)
Advice to Singers (40)
Music and the Brain (18)
Theater Topics
About Staging (43)
Blackface (5)
Opera is about Love (11)
Peter Sellars (24)
Regie (161)
Styles and Genres
American Music (140) Baroque Music (133) Bel canto (129) British Music (36) Choral (23) Classic (74) Czech Music (17) French Music (148) Modern Music (204) Play (5) Pop Music (36) Recital (36) Russian Music (38) Seria (44) Song (91) Verismo (80)
Passing Interests
All Interviews (79)
Fav (14)
Gertrude Stein (12)
MyFavorites (59)
Sexiest (72)
Review Books (79)
Review CD (126)
Review DVD / Video (198)
Review HD (159)
Review Movies (37)
Review Performance (416)
Review Streaming (110)
Review Television (35)
Adamo (3) Adams (17) Adès (7) Alfano (7) Bach (36) Balfe (3) Barab (2) Barber (15) Bartók (4) Beethoven (30) Bellini (34) Benjamin (2) Berg (10) Berio (3) Berlioz (22) Bernstein (7) Biber (1) Birtwistle (1) Bizet (23) Boito (5) Bolcom (1) Borodin (2) Brahms (19) Britten (10) Caccini (5) Cage (4) Catán (1) Cavalli (5) Charpentier (3) Chopin (6) Cilea (3) Corigliano (3) Couperin (1) Dallapiccola (1) de Falla (5) Debussy (9) Delibes (1) Donizetti (42) Dowland (4) Dun (2) Duparc (4) Dvorák (7) Fauré (7) Fine (1) Floyd (2) Gabrieli (1) Gasser (2) Gershwin (16) Getty (1) Giacomelli (1) Giordano (14) Glass (17) Glinka (2) Gluck (13) Golijov (12) Gorb (1) Gordon (3) Górecki (1) Gounod (19) Gubaidulina (2) Hahn (8) Halévy (4) Handel (49) Harbison (2) Haydn (6) Haydn M (1) Heggie (13) Henze (1) Hindemith (1) Humperdinck (3) Ives (2) Janáček (9) Kern (1) Korngold (7) Krása (1) Larson (1) Lehar (3) Leoncavallo (4) Lieberson (3) Ligeti (5) Liszt (8) López (2) Machover (1) Mahler (22) Marschner (2) Martini (3) Mascagni (6) Massenet (23) Maw (2) Mendelssohn (7) Menotti (4) Messiaen (2) Meyerbeer (4) Monteverdi (11) Montsalvatge (2) Moravec (2) Mozart (71) Muhly (2) Mussorgsky (5) Obradors (3) Offenbach (13) Orff (2) Ortiz (1) Paisiello (1) Pärt (3) Paulus (1) Penderecki (1) Picker (2) Ponchielli (1) Porpora (4) Poulenc (8) Previn (3) Prokofiev (7) Puccini (83) Purcell (9) Rachmaninov (13) Rameau (6) Ravel (4) Reich (3) Respighi (2) Rimsky-Korsakov (2) Rossini (65) Roussel (1) Saariaho (5) Saint-Saëns (8) Schoenberg (6) Schubert (20) Schumann (14) Shostakovich (2) Sibelius (2) Smetana (3) Sondheim (8) Spontini (2) Steffani (8) Stockhausen (3) Strauss J (6) Strauss R (73) Stravinsky (4) Sullivan (2) Susa (1) Szymanowski (2) Tchaikovsky (22) Telemann (6) Theofanidis (1) Thomas (4) Thomson (1) Turnage (1) Tutino (2) Verdi (146) Vinci (1) Vivaldi (16) Wagner (60) Wallace (2) Weber (2) Webern (1) Weill (18) Weir (1) Williams (4) Wolf (3) Wuorinen (3) Zandonai (2)
Elektra in HD
Roberto Devereux in HD
James Levine to Retire
Der Rosenkavalier at Deutsche Oper, Berlin
Die Liebe der Danae at Deutsche Oper, Berlin
Die ägyptische Helena at the Deutsche Oper, Berlin...
Elektra at the Deutsche Oper, Berlin
Lieder in Berlin
Opera Wire
Obituary: William Benjamin Ray Passes Away At 94
Taminophile
Wie eiskalt ist dein Händchen.....
operaramblings
reGENERATION week 1
Fanáticos da Ópera / Opera Fanatics
LE NOZZE DI FIGARO, Royal Opera House, Londres, Julho / London, July 2019
Schwabacher Summer Concert 2019
Operavore
The Opera Life in Vienna
Barihunks
Jonathan Beyer to appear on "Worst Cooks in America"
JDCMB
One woman, three harps and a very long journey
Regie, or Not Regie?
Operas Online (Arte Concert Edition) – Some Last Chance Opportunities
The Wagnerian
Sponsor Your Own Meistersinger?
I HEAR VOICES
Mozart's La Clemenza di Tito, Theatro São Pedro, São Paulo, 05.05.2019
BlakesBlog - Reflections on Theater, Opera and Music
My Review of my Opera and Theater experiences for 2018
Aria PDF Database
Musical America
My history book
Opera Musica
Operabase
Sacramento 365