Basel Committee releases climate risk principles
June 15, 2022|Written by Graham Caswell|Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, Bank of International Settlements
The 45 central banks and financial supervisors that make up the influential Basel Committee on Banking Supervision (BCBS) have published their finalised set of principles for managing and supervising climate-related financial risks. Approved last month, the principles are the first formal climate-related guidance issued by the global standard setter for the prudential regulation and supervision of banks.
Largely aligned with the recommendations of the Taskforce on Climate-related Financial Disclosures, the BCBS principles are based on analytical reports and draft principles released last year and were informed by an extensive public consultation process. They form part of an ongoing BCBS assessment of potential climate-related measures covering disclosure, supervision and regulation.
The first 12 principles are aimed at banks and cover corporate governance, internal controls, risk assessment, management and reporting, capital and liquidity adequacy and other elements of risk management, including scenario analysis. Banks should incorporate material climate-related financial risks into their internal capital and liquidity adequacy assessments (Principle 5), and should understand the impact of climate-related risk drivers on their liquidity risk profiles (Principle 10).
The remaining six principles focus on financial supervisors and regulators, outlining their duty to ensure that banks can "adequately identify, monitor and manage all material climate-related financial risks." Supervisors are expected to know the extent to which banks identify and assess their climate-related risks and, if needed, to "utilise an appropriate range of techniques and tools and adopt adequate follow-up measures in case of material misalignment with supervisory expectations."
Designed to accommodate a diverse range of banking systems, the principles attempt to find a balance between providing a common international baseline and the flexibility needed in this evolving area. They are aimed at large internationally active banks and financial authorities in Basel Committee member jurisdictions.
Initial civil society response to the BCBS principles was mixed. "On the positive side, the finalised version of the principles has a few clarifications, which add robustness to the supervisory approach," said Julia Symon, head of research and advocacy at Finance Watch. Symon also welcomed the distinction made between financially conclusive stress tests and more exploratory scenario analyses.
However she was clear that the current guidance was just a first step. "The Principles remain generic and mostly high level and recognise that supervisory and banks' own risk management practices will take time to mature," she said.
"As climate-related risks are of systemic nature and grow with time, more impactful and immediate measures are needed. We expect the Basel Committee to come out with further stronger measures on the results of its holistic review of the Basel framework."
Pierre Monnin, senior fellow with the Council on Economic Policies, also welcomed the BCBS principles but warned of the lack of an enforcement mechanism. "Experience from most advanced jurisdictions shows that financial institutions are far from meeting climate risk management supervisory expectations," he told Green Central Banking, pointing to an ECB assessment that no bank is close to meeting its climate-related supervisory expectations.
"BCBS recommendations should also guide supervisors on how to act when such gaps are acknowledged," he said, adding that this is missing in the current principles.
"The BCBS should highlight options for supervisors to complement supervisory expectations with regulatory measures – like Pillar 2 capital requirements – when supervised institutions do not fulfil expectations in terms of climate financial risk management," Monnin recommended.
"The BCBS principles are also mute on how supervisors should manage systemic risks posed by climate change and the transition. Macroprudential options should be suggested as climate is now widely recognised as a systemic risk for the financial system."
This page was last updated June 15, 2022
The Bank for International Settlements in Basel, Switzerland (c) Fred Romero
Banking regulation Banking supervision Prudential supervision Financial regulation Climate risk Disclosure
Banking on Climate Chaos: Fossil Fuel Finance Report 2022
This report offers comprehensive analysis on fossil fuel banking, showing how funding has increased over the six years since the Paris Agreemen
Written by Rainforest Action Network and others
Preventing a 'Climate Minsky Moment': Environmental Financial Risks and Prudential Exposure Limits
Central banks can avoid a 'climate Minsky moment' by placing soft limits on banks' exposures to transition-sensitive sectors, according to LSE's Grantham Institute.
Written by LSE Grantham Institute
BoE publishes first climate disclosure
The Bank of England (BoE) published its first climate-related financial disclosure, following the recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD). The bank has been a leading supporter of the TCFD since its inception, and its climate risk …
People's Bank of China sets priorities for green finance
Yi Gang, Governor of the People's Bank of China (PBoC), outlined four priorities for the bank in support of China's ambition to achieve carbon neutrality by 2060, announced in September. In a speech delivered by video to the Singapore FinTech …
People's Bank of China
Bank of Canada releases new climate scenarios model
The Bank of Canada (BoC) released an analysis of the global economy that combines climate scenarios with existing climate-economy models. The study is one of the first to show climate policy pathways, and assess their distribution of transition and physical risks …
US moves towards mandatory climate risk disclosure
The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is to "enhance its focus on climate-related disclosure in public company filings." The move is part of a process to update its 2010 climate disclosure requirements, acting SEC chair Allison Herren Lee said in …
UN report warns of climate risk 'blind spots'
A new and comprehensive report from the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) has warned that tools and methodologies used to analyse climate risk do not fully capture the full impacts of climate change. The report, from UNEP's Finance Initiative, found …
Climate change a key influence on monetary policy, says BoJ's Haruhiko Kuroda
The Governor of the Bank of Japan (BoJ), Haruhiko Kuroda, said that climate change is one of the key themes guiding monetary policy. Haruhiko Kuroda made the statement to the Japanese parliament's Financial Affairs Committee on Friday, saying that "climate change …
BoE launches climate stress tests for banks and insurers
The Bank of England (BoE) has announced it will launch the delayed climate stress tests for major UK banks and insurers in 2021. BoE Governor Andrew Bailey made the commitment in a speech on Monday, November 9 to the Green …
ECB stress test shows economic impact of climate change
A groundbreaking stress test shows a potential wave of defaults due to the effects of climate change without a "timely and effective" transition to a greener economy. The test, conducted by the European Central Bank (ECB), examined four million companies …
Climate change may force interest rates down, says Riksbank
Climate change may force central banks to keep interest rates low, Sweden's Riksbank warned in its annual account of monetary policy released on Wednesday. "If climate change increases the risk of catastrophe, makes economic developments more uncertain and worsens growth …