In 1962 Oscar loved her in "West Side Story" (& isn't she the first one you think of for the category?)
[DOC] [TLE] Conversations With Sondheim - The New York Times [PAR] Mar 12, 2000 ... Ice Cream, from She Loves Me (1963), lyrics by Sheldon Harnick; Tell ... men 
who created "West Side Story" look as cool as the Jets and Sharks.