In 1962 Oscar loved her in "West Side Story" (& isn't she the first one you think of for the category?)
[DOC] [TLE] The Nighthawk Awards: 1961 | News from the Boston Becks [PAR] Mar 22, 2015 ... First there are the categories, followed by all the films with their nominations, ... 
West Side Story **; The Hustler *; La Dolce Vita; One, Two, Three ..... A Best 
Foreign Film nominee at the 1960 Oscars, you should see it if you can.