Q:

How can I become better at formulating my feedback when critiquing a writer's work as beta reader?

As a beta reader, I sometimes find myself frustrated at trying to find the right words and how to properly structure my sentences when I give a critique or just simple feedback. How can I work on becoming a better critiquer and formulating my words appropriately?

A:

Give specific feedback, not general feedback, make sure you mention anything that you do find especially good, and focus on constructive/productive criticism.  For example:

I thought the section with the dog was strong.  The imagery really came alive there and drew me in.  The next section didn't grab me in the same way, you might want to think about either editing it out, or putting in the same level of detail so it isn't such a contrast.

You're not going to be judged on how well written your response is --what the writer is looking for is an honest reaction, with useful, actionable criticisms.

